Discuss on Reddit ➤ Support the Show ➤ Come with us to 19th century Russia where we attend the stunning musicopera, “Natasha, Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812” based on a chapter of Tolsty’s epic ‘War and Peace’... Read More
From the show: Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour
About
Come with us to 19th century Russia where we attend the stunning musicopera, “Natasha, Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812” based on a chapter of Tolsty’s epic ‘War and Peace’. Seeing as it’s regarded as one of the longest novels, we thought we’d make this one of the longest podcasts - so here’s part 1! We muse about how Comet will leave its mark on the future of musical theatre, whether it’s Mosc-OH or Mosc-OW, and generally bask in the brilliance of Mr Dave Malloy!
Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet of 1812 (Original Cast)
SHOW NOTES
Shout out to superfan, Brad, who supplied us with an amazing relic from the American Rep production of the show – an actual, honest to goodness programme!
Come join us on our obsession with Dave Malloy - check out his blog for some magic musings from the maestro himself!
Get a glimpse of the stunning production values and interviews from the creative team.
Is it Mosc-OH or Mosc-OW? Linguists of the Happy Hour, let us know!
Bored of reading the Hamilton genius pages for the millionth time? We’ve got you covered.
Join us for a shot of your finest Russian standard and tasty pierogi and stay tuned for Part 2 coming soon!
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:04] Tommy: Well, somebody get us another drink.
[0:07] Jimi: We're on.
[0:08] Tommy: We're back.
[0:09] Jimi: Hey, we're back.
[0:12] Tommy: It's only been, well, it's only been, I don't know what you're talking about.
[0:14] Jimi: It's only been like a week.
[0:15] Tommy: Right.
[0:16] Jimi: I was, man, I was listening to that thing like, and next week's question, and I realize we've said that every time.
[0:22] Tommy: This is like, and last week's question and this week's question, and I don't know if that's ever been right.
[0:27] Jimi: Well, no, it's a bi-weekly podcast. I don't know why we just say that.
[0:33] Tommy: But hey, it's tradition now.
[0:35] Jimi: It is tradition.
[0:36] Tommy: The kids will miss it.
[0:37] Jimi: I'm so excited.
[0:38] Tommy: Yeah.
[0:39] Jimi: Why are you excited?
[0:40] Tommy: Well, A, just to be back.
[0:41] Jimi: Well, that too, yes.
[0:42] Tommy: And B for the content of what we're... Oh man.
[0:46] Tommy: I feel like I've been on like a pilgrimage in the little break that we've had.
[0:52] Jimi: You know, if there's any show I think that deserves this much time, kind of sitting with it and marinating on it, it's definitely this one.
[1:00] Tommy: This one.
[1:03] Jimi: Uh-huh. Should we just fire straight in?
[1:06] Tommy: We probably should.
[1:07] Jimi: So if you were gonna talk for a while...
[1:09] Tommy: I mean, there's a lot to talk about.
[1:12] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:12] Tommy: So, uh, people, like, we've a whole bunch of people got our trivia question right.
[1:18] Jimi: I know.
[1:19] Tommy: Which is awesome.
[1:20] Jimi: Yeah, I'm really proud of them.
[1:21] Tommy: Because especially after we annoyed people.
[1:28] Tommy: Um, so for those of you who just tuned in to the podcast, maybe welcome.
[1:33] Jimi: Um, our trivia question last week, huh?
[1:36] Tommy: Um, was this musical is one that we've never listened to before based on a book that neither of us have read.
[1:43] Jimi: The person who famously never sang as Eliza Doolittle in My Fair Lady played the title character of this show in a 1956 film adaptation of this book that we've never read.
[1:53] Tommy: What musical are we talking about?
[1:55] Jimi: That was a long question.
[1:56] Tommy: I didn't realize that.
[1:57] Jimi: For a long title of a musical.
[1:59] Tommy: Right?
[2:00] Jimi: That musical is...
[2:02] Tommy: Are you ready?
[2:04] Jimi: That was my drum roll.
[2:05] Tommy: Oh, okay.
[2:06] Jimi: Sorry.
[2:06] Tommy: I heard that.
[2:07] Jimi: Do it again.
[2:08] Tommy: We'll do it again.
[2:10] Jimi: So that musical is...
[2:11] Tommy: I'll put, I'll just put it in and here, here's the sound effect of a drum roll.
[2:17] Jimi: Excellent.
[2:19] Tommy: It is Natasha, Pierre and, oh, I get this part...
[2:24] Jimi: The Great Comet of 1812.
[2:26] Tommy: Indeed.
[2:27] Jimi: Which I can, I get, I've been in describing this show to people, I have gotten that you're wrong, I think, every time.
[2:35] Tommy: Excellent.
[2:35] Jimi: Great.
[2:38] Tommy: Well, because did we talk about long titles?
[2:41] Jimi: I feel like that's a thing we talked about.
[2:42] Tommy: I feel like we've talked about that as well.
[2:44] Jimi: It's a mark.
[2:44] Tommy: We did. I know.
[2:45] Jimi: It was, we talked about it in Spelling Bee.
[2:46] Tommy: Um, because you were saying Spelling Bee has a long title.
[2:49] Jimi: The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee.
[2:51] Tommy: There's that Shakespeare company for old people.
[2:53] Jimi: Is that, am I right in thinking that something, well, it was just a Shakespeare company that wasn't specifically for old people, but...
[2:53] Tommy: Oh no, uh-huh.
[3:00] Jimi: But the audiences were potentially old and didn't like, like Rosencrantz and Guildenstern are Dead.
[3:05] Tommy: Exactly.
[3:06] Jimi: And so they, but you can see they've branded the thing The Great Comet.
[3:10] Tommy: Yes.
[3:11] Jimi: And while the full title is Natasha, Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812, you can just call it The Great Comet.
[3:15] Tommy: TGC.
[3:16] Jimi: And I, yeah, I've been, I've just gone straight to Comet.
[3:20] Tommy: I've just been, just Comet?
[3:22] Jimi: Yeah, just Comet.
[3:24] Tommy: Why not?
[3:30] Jimi: There's a war going on out there somewhere.
[3:36] Tommy: And Andre is into... There's a war going on.
[3:44] Jimi: It's a beautiful show.
[3:45] Tommy: Where'd you begin?
[3:46] Jimi: It's a beautiful show.
[3:48] Tommy: So, Jimmy, have I, I've told you the full story of how I came across this show?
[3:53] Jimi: Of like how this show entered my life?
[3:56] Tommy: Have you?
[3:56] Jimi: Have I?
[3:57] Tommy: Maybe I haven't.
[3:58] Jimi: Um, so the, it was mentioned briefly in that playoff of, I think it was our Christmas episode we were talking about...
[4:06] Tommy: Shag again, the game.
[4:08] Jimi: The game where you find two numbers from different shows with the same title, and one of them was The Great Comet, which I had never heard about.
[4:14] Tommy: Um, so this is a fact that's just bounced around in my mind.
[4:17] Jimi: Yeah.
[4:18] Tommy: And then one Monday night, I'm out at this bar that I like that plays musical theater on Monday.
[4:22] Jimi: Of course, Mecca.
[4:24] Tommy: And this very friendly chap comes up to me and goes, "Hey, you're Tommy."
[4:29] Jimi: And I, I was like playing back through in my mind, like, do I, I don't know, I don't know who this is.
[4:35] Tommy: And he goes, "You don't know me, but I love your podcast."
[4:40] Jimi: Like in real life, actual person.
[4:43] Tommy: Um, so shout out to Brad.
[4:45] Jimi: Hi, Brad.
[4:45] Tommy: I'm sure you're listening.
[4:46] Jimi: Hey, Brad.
[4:47] Tommy: Um, because it gets even better.
[4:49] Tommy: Brad had heard this episode and was surprised that I hadn't heard about Natasha, Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812 because it is one of his favorite musicals.
[4:58] Jimi: And I was like, no, I know nothing about it.
[4:59] Tommy: And he's like, "Oh, you have to listen to it."
[5:01] Jimi: Oh, you have to listen to it.
[5:02] Tommy: Yep.
[5:02] Tommy: Um, and so I told him and I went and I listened to it, and I told him, "Yeah, and for one of our podcasts from now, Jimmy and I are gonna talk about it."
[5:09] Tommy: And he said, "Oh, next week I'm gonna have something for you."
[5:13] Jimi: And I'm like, what?
[5:15] Tommy: Okay.
[5:15] Tommy: Um, and then at the bar next week, Brad very, very kindly gave me this original program, which you can hear in the microphone for the show.
[5:25] Jimi: And I'm seeing it.
[5:27] Tommy: And a little shaker egg.
[5:31] Jimi: Also, that he stole from the show.
[5:33] Tommy: My super shout outs to Super Fan Brad.
[5:37] Jimi: The show wouldn't be happening without you.
[5:39] Tommy: Our official sponsor, Brad.
[5:43] Tommy: And let me say, this program is super helpful in understanding this show.
[5:50] Jimi: Well, that's exactly what they say in that first number.
[5:53] Tommy: Right?
[5:54] Jimi: Can you talk us through it?
[5:55] Tommy: Give us the layout of the program.
[5:57] Jimi: Well, the layout of the program or the layout of the show, because I think we'll just go to the program.
[6:02] Tommy: I mean, is the program as long as War and Peace?
[6:05] Jimi: Or it does a good job of summarizing what I think is a very complicated show.
[6:11] Tommy: So Natasha, Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812 is based on War and Peace, but only like 70 pages of it.
[6:19] Jimi: It's, yeah, volume two, chapter five.
[6:22] Tommy: Yeah.
[6:22] Jimi: And so it's not, and you don't need to know a damn thing about War and Peace to understand this show.
[6:29] Tommy: But it, I mean, what, how would you, what would you say is the crux, is the plot of this show?
[6:35] Jimi: Because it's, it's a tough one, right?
[6:36] Tommy: It is a tough one.
[6:37] Jimi: It is a tough one.
[6:38] Tommy: Um, very sort of classic Russian in it.
[6:41] Jimi: There's like 90 stories.
[6:42] Tommy: It's sort of like Les Mis in that way.
[6:44] Jimi: I mean, it's very like Les Mis that it is.
[6:47] Tommy: And that's, I guess, from the whole War and Peace.
[6:49] Jimi: Um, well, apparently the main character of War and Peace is Pierre.
[6:53] Tommy: Yep.
[6:53] Jimi: So obviously he has his own kind of little story.
[6:56] Tommy: I'd say kind of running as an undercurrent throughout the whole thing.
[7:00] Jimi: I'm sure we'll get into that, whether who's the protagonist of this show is.
[7:05] Tommy: Yeah.
[7:06] Tommy: But kind of the main action revolves around Natasha slash Natalia.
[7:12] Jimi: Everyone, everyone has, I mean, they say it in the opening number, which you should listen to.
[7:17] Tommy: Uh, but everyone in this show has nine different names.
[7:19] Jimi: And that, that's just how Russian names are.
[7:23] Tommy: And it gets a little confusing.
[7:25] Jimi: Yeah, I've got no idea why that is.
[7:28] Tommy: Uh, I remember hearing about the, and I, you know, I did all my research and didn't look it up at all.
[7:32] Jimi: Uh-huh.
[7:33] Tommy: Um, but it's something like, you know, you have your name and your father's name and your mother's name and your nickname, and then it's all been translated from Russian into English, and so there's a lot of subtlety that's lost there.
[7:44] Jimi: Okay.
[7:45] Tommy: But I mean, from everything I've read, they stick really, really close to a lot of the text of War and Peace.
[7:50] Jimi: A lot of it is quoted directly in the show.
[7:54] Tommy: Well, pretty much the whole of the finale is directly from the novel.
[7:59] Jimi: Yeah.
[7:59] Tommy: The main crux of it revolves around Natasha and her sort of betrothment to a kind of rich, good-prospected man named Andre.
[8:10] Jimi: Andre.
[8:11] Tommy: Uh, who is away fighting in, don't even know which war, how bad is that?
[8:16] Jimi: Just the war, the war of War and Peace.
[8:18] Tommy: We'll call it that.
[8:22] Tommy: So he's off, he's off fighting, and she's, she's sort of waiting eagerly for him to return so they can get married.
[8:30] Tommy: But in true classic style, in walks a sexy man.
[8:35] Jimi: Sexy man Anatole.
[8:37] Tommy: Anatole, who is hot.
[8:38] Jimi: And he, uh, kind of enchants her.
[8:41] Tommy: Enchants?
[8:42] Jimi: I don't know if, in, I mean...
[8:42] Tommy: Well, I think at start very much so.
[8:46] Jimi: Very like, who is this mysterious fiery being?
[8:51] Tommy: I think it's a little more insidious than that.
[8:55] Tommy: We're just diving straight in.
[8:55] Jimi: Sorry, call up everyone.
[8:59] Tommy: Listen to it.
[9:01] Tommy: Um, because in the opera, obviously, it is that kind of sense of, I'm trying to think of an illusion, like, uh, that kind of, it's that Disney moment, do you know what I mean?
[9:09] Jimi: That like, I see you, you see me.
[9:11] Tommy: Yeah, love it, love at first sight in the most cliché yet realistic way.
[9:15] Jimi: Exactly.
[9:16] Tommy: And I think because Natasha's so young and so innocent and unknowing, she's just kind of like, "Oh wow, this man, he's a lot smarter and is like, yes."
[9:27] Tommy: Here's the, here is the woman I will be in love with, but...
[9:27] Jimi: Exactly, but Anatole is married.
[9:37] Tommy: And Natasha is betrothed, and then, you know, I don't know if I'd call it hilarity, but drama ensues.
[9:44] Jimi: Massive drama, and actually quite really powerful.
[9:47] Tommy: Really powerful, really, really powerful.
[9:49] Tommy: Because, so I don't really know why Andre, no, not Andre, Anatole.
[9:57] Jimi: We're gonna get everyone's name wrong like 80 times.
[9:59] Tommy: Why do you both begin with AN? Like, why?
[10:02] Jimi: Um, why Anatole wants Natasha?
[10:05] Tommy: Because I don't think he's in love with her, right?
[10:07] Jimi: Like to the point where it's like, oh, uh, I want to be, do you know what I mean?
[10:11] Tommy: I do think it's a sort of a like, um, Mr. Wickham kind of thing from Pride and Prejudice.
[10:16] Jimi: Do you know what I mean?
[10:17] Tommy: That idea of, uh, almost like trophy wife or to, I don't know, to have someone, I don't know.
[10:23] Jimi: I mean, I think we are set up in this world of 19th century Russia where like you have your spouse and you have your, you know, side partners.
[10:35] Tommy: Yeah.
[10:35] Tommy: Like there's, like Pierre is married to Helene, but Helene is like openly and consistently cheating on him with Dolikov, who's a minor character.
[10:46] Jimi: And also her brother.
[10:47] Tommy: And also...
[10:47] Jimi: Oh, really?
[10:51] Tommy: Yeah.
[10:51] Jimi: There's some fun.
[10:52] Tommy: I know, right? Incestuous scandal.
[10:55] Jimi: Messed up Moscow.
[10:56] Tommy: Right, exactly.
[10:57] Jimi: Which is also a new drink I'm creating.
[10:59] Tommy: Um, you just like take a Moscow mule and then like put some like dirt and gray in it.
[11:06] Jimi: Yeah, and then you throw it on the floor, and then you drink it with a straw.
[11:09] Tommy: A messed up Moscow.
[11:10] Jimi: Enjoy.
[11:11] Tommy: I love it.
[11:11] Tommy: Uh, oh, actually, just a quick point as you say Moscow.
[11:16] Jimi: Is that like a weird American thing that you guys say?
[11:19] Tommy: Because it's, we say Moscow.
[11:21] Jimi: Oh, Moscow.
[11:22] Tommy: I mean, that's probably a Midwestern thing I do too.
[11:25] Jimi: Right.
[11:26] Tommy: Because it's weird because in, obviously in the show they say Moscow.
[11:30] Jimi: Do you know what I mean?
[11:31] Tommy: Um, you know, like that's fun and idiosyncratic.
[11:34] Jimi: I would have never even noticed.
[11:38] Tommy: You are at the opera.
[11:40] Jimi: You wanna have study up a little bit if you want to be fine.
[11:44] Tommy: This is a complicated Russian novel. Everyone's had nine different names.
[11:48] Jimi: So look it up in your program.
[11:56] Tommy: The intentional anachronism in this show.
[11:59] Jimi: Oh my god, you're really jumping, right?
[12:00] Tommy: Is amazing.
[12:01] Jimi: Beautiful and fantastic.
[12:03] Tommy: It starts from the very beginning.
[12:04] Tommy: Um, like Pierre has this one line, uh, spending hours at his screen.
[12:10] Jimi: Mm-hmm.
[12:11] Tommy: And he's in 19th century Russia.
[12:13] Jimi: And I was on genius, genius.com, search for, uh, Natasha, Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812.
[12:19] Tommy: Um, and the author, David Malloy, has commented on genius, and he goes, "Yes, this is an anachronism."
[12:27] Tommy: He's talking about being at a computer screen.
[12:30] Tommy: We are unabashedly, you know, mixing our timelines and all at once embracing this like, uh, very dated world and the way it interfaces with our contemporary world.
[12:44] Jimi: The thing is, he does it completely unabashedly.
[12:46] Tommy: It's not like, "Here's a gimmick," do you know, "here's I'm gonna squeeze us in."
[12:50] Tommy: It actually does it, I think it just does it so, it just kind of makes sense.
[12:54] Jimi: I don't know.
[12:55] Tommy: It's so interesting.
[12:57] Tommy: Um, to again to jump to a completely other point already.
[13:01] Jimi: I'll go back to that point.
[13:03] Tommy: And we'll maybe we'll get back to the plot at the end of the podcast.
[13:08] Tommy: But to just jump onto Dave Malloy.
[13:10] Jimi: Um, so I now, uh, subscribe to the church of Dave Malloy.
[13:14] Tommy: Oh, isn't he fabulous?
[13:15] Jimi: I wanna go be his friend.
[13:17] Tommy: Exactly.
[13:17] Tommy: Like I, uh, he's now just, I, I don't know.
[13:20] Tommy: I find it hard and difficult to say words.
[13:24] Tommy: He is musical theater nerd to, uh, like as we are, exactly, but he, he is so much more well spoken.
[13:33] Jimi: Have you found his blog?
[13:34] Tommy: Oh, it's wonderful and weird and arcane, but also like, it's like, um, a con, there's a controlled eclecticism about everything he writes.
[13:46] Jimi: I can't wait for it to be novelized. Like, oh man. It's what like because I remember when I had my live journal when I was like 14 and 15 and writing all sorts of absolute nonsense. Um, this is like like that, but beautiful. Do you know what I mean? It's like curated nonsense. I was thinking this when I was reading through his blog and a bunch of the other things he's written. Like when we talk about spelling B or when we talk about a song time, we have a couple like primary source sort of stuff from William Finn or Stephen Sondheim that we can go to, like things they've written about the show. I there's still more things to read that Malloy has written about this show that I haven't been able to get to.
Like it's there's so much depth and like and it's great because it is a little bit. I I don't wouldn't say the show is difficult to understand, but it's dense. Yeah, there's a lot in there, and there's stuff you'll miss if you don't have someone pointing out pointing it out to you, and who better than the guy who wrote the whole thing. But I'm still listening to it, and still, you know, I mean, I'm like, well, listen to this song a little bit more today, and then you get it, and you're like, it's amazing, and then you find out how that song links in with this, and this is, it's just it's it's huge. It's wonderful. It really, really is right. So sorry, to jump back to anachronisms, I'm sure we'll get back to DMO.
But um, one of the ones I love, right? So this one I think it was Danny B, I think posted on I think it might have been Reddit. He was wondering like what was the first thing that we listened to. Remember, he said that oh, we listened to something and we think it's the best thing ever already.
[15:14] Tommy: Yeah. Um, so we listened to the jewel for those of you listening along at home. If you go to the jewel. Did we?
[15:19] Jimi: I don't even remember. Do you know I remember that?
[15:22] Tommy: Yeah, so that was that was well, that was the first thing I listened to, and then it was like God Tommy, listen to this now, listen to it. And we just clicked right into the middle, and it was just before the house music.
[15:34] Jimi: Right, exactly. Right before the house music dropped into this Russian classic 1800s Russian classic musical. And I was just like, What is this? And then it was amazing, but I didn't realize so. So at that moment in the show, in the actual show, the conductor sticks on a pair of headphones and jumps on onto some decks and just starts it makes it like I'm like, what the yes, correct? Like to jump, maybe as we are, between like classical chamber music to hardcore dance floor electronica.
[16:09] Tommy: Yeah.
[16:09] Jimi: And like, and then mix the two.
[16:11] Tommy: Yeah.
[16:12] Jimi: Back and forth and back and forth. And there's, you know, I I my brain isn't big enough to understand the way that is weaving in and out of what characters are around and that sort of stuff. Like, I only recently realized reading Malloy's stuff that all the electronica stuff is all tied to Anatole. And then no bait no beat drops until he shows up, and once he leaves, the beat never drops again.
[16:35] Tommy: Because he's slick and cool.
[16:36] Jimi: Right. And, you know, it comes straight out of a 2009 disco.
[16:42] Tommy: Yeah.
[16:46] Jimi: Yeah, it's and it's it's fun. Like you look at clips of of the guy playing Anatole, and he just looks like he's having the best time.
[16:53] Tommy: Yeah.
[16:53] Jimi: Because he just gets to be cool. We we should also say, because if you're listening to this and picturing like a traditional stage musical in your mind, oh god. We gotta we have to paint a bigger picture of this for you. The the most popular incarnation of this show uh happened in a vacant lot in like in New York on the Broadway strip.
[17:18] Tommy: They erected a tent and built what is basically a bar restaurant performance space that the whole thing happened in.
[17:26] Jimi: Like it is environmental theater like nobody's business. The the actors are above you and around you and next to you, and meanwhile you're getting drunk right along with them at this mashup between an 1800s vodka bar and you know the nightclub down the street.
[17:47] Tommy: Right, exactly. It's like the set design is one of the most beautiful things I've ever look at.
[17:55] Jimi: Um shout out to Mimi Leen who is done it because it's just incredible.
[18:00] Tommy: Yeah.
[18:00] Jimi: In terms of you you kind of go ahead and you know you it feels Russian, it feels rich, it feels you know, I mean, so I don't know what the word I'm trying to say is. Some affluent for that.
[18:13] Tommy: Very decadent and Yeah, exactly.
[18:15] Jimi: Because you've got the portraits all lining the wall, and there's red, and then the kind of crowning glory for everything are the these beautiful massive starburst lights.
[18:27] Tommy: Like huge chandeliers, which get used to great effect um in the finale, and it's it it is completely unlike anything else.
[18:35] Jimi: I mean, that's what you know. You you watch there's a bunch of super clips of famous people you recognize talking about this show, and the things people say is it is like nothing they've ever seen.
[18:46] Tommy: Exactly.
[18:46] Jimi: Um but also like it's not like it's not uncomfortable like some other environmental theater can be.
[18:53] Tommy: It doesn't seem that way.
[18:54] Jimi: You know, it's not like Cirque du Soleil where the annoying clown is gonna like walk into the audience and be like, you audience member, come here, we're going to pull you on stage and you'll be the butt of the joke.
[19:04] Tommy: Like it's they've done they've gone to really great lengths to make the audience feel comfortable and a part of their performance, yeah, and not like imposed upon by actors being, you know, inches away from them singing.
[19:19] Jimi: Exactly. It's funny, because I I don't mind that. I quite enjoy actors being everything.
[19:23] Tommy: Right.
[19:23] Jimi: Because you are an actor.
[19:26] Tommy: Well, I don't even know. I just think it's it's just so I don't know. I just like, yeah, maybe that is it.
[19:31] Jimi: Maybe it's like I'm at the show now, it's me.
[19:31] Tommy: It's me.
[19:34] Jimi: Um I don't know. I just think it's really exciting in that respect because in terms of uh musical theater, yeah. That doesn't hugely get done in terms of sort of American staging.
[19:48] Tommy: Because it seems well, and it doesn't seem like a gimmick.
[19:50] Jimi: It doesn't seem like something that was added on top of an already written show or piece of art.
[19:56] Tommy: Right.
[19:56] Jimi: Like it is very much a part of the story they're telling and how they want to tell it. And they do it so so well.
[20:02] Tommy: Like Rachel Travkin, the director.
[20:05] Jimi: Again, I'm just like, you how have you done this? How lucky we are that all these people are on Earth right now.
[20:13] Tommy: Like this is there, there are parts of this that are new in very difficult to describe ways.
[20:22] Jimi: Yeah.
[20:22] Tommy: That are like not just revolutionary.
[20:28] Jimi: Like I, you know, we we because we have can are contractually obligated to mention Hamilton.
[20:33] Tommy: Um which was certainly a game changer in a lot of the Broadway scene in like what a musical can be about and how you go about doing what I think is like they they are revolutionizing the art form from within the art form.
[20:47] Jimi: Right. Natasha is coming at it from this whole sideways angle.
[20:53] Tommy: Like we don't need a theater, we're just gonna build a tent.
[20:56] Jimi: You know, we're we don't like we're we're not gonna simplify our script for you.
[21:01] Tommy: In fact, we're gonna take it straight out of the novel and do nothing to make it easy for you.
[21:06] Jimi: Better keep up.
[21:07] Tommy: Exactly.
[21:07] Jimi: It's intelligent theatre, and it doesn't ever want to try and patronize it for this audience who might not get it, so it's okay, so we'll just let them have their moment.
[21:16] Tommy: It's no you you if you really want to get it, if you really want to love it, then pay pay attention.
[21:22] Jimi: Um and it will be amazing for you.
[21:24] Tommy: Exactly.
[21:25] Jimi: My kind of my kind of feelings of it are, and you might feel this is dramatic, but there was Oklahoma, right? There was Hare, and then there's gonna be Natasha Pierre and a great comet of 1812.
[21:35] Tommy: You really think so?
[21:36] Jimi: A hundred percent. There's never been anything like this on Broadway.
[21:40] Tommy: That's true.
[21:41] Jimi: And it's that it's that way that I was saying, it's completely new in like literally nearly all aspects.
[21:49] Tommy: Like from the simplest aspects to the most complicated ones.
[21:52] Jimi: In terms of in terms of the music, it's it's not in the same way that Hamilton's like, oh, you know, it's using the genre of hip hop. I feel that comet is kind of just a transcended musical genre, and it's just it's it's created its own sound.
[22:09] Tommy: It's very experimental and uh specific in so many ways.
[22:16] Jimi: Yeah, that's a great way of putting it.
[22:17] Tommy: Like it is comp there there's so many choices that we made, whether it's like this particular sample or this particular vocal effect that we're gonna put on it.
[22:26] Jimi: Yeah, but only right here, and you're never gonna hear it again.
[22:29] Tommy: And it's so well thought through that it it's it's hugely exciting and hugely inspirational.
[22:37] Jimi: Me and you of being like musical theatre boys, we talk about this a lot, like the future of music, like what's gonna be happening.
[22:46] Tommy: What's next?
[22:47] Jimi: And I don't know for me, I've just I've not been this excited, yeah, and like I say, inspired in a while. So like I'm with me and my friend Jay, we're writing our own musical at the moment.
[22:58] Tommy: Uh huh.
[22:58] Jimi: It's gonna be on at the fringe. And I remember when we listened to this and uh also Preludes, um, which another Dave Malloy musical, go check it out, please. We were just like, we can do this, like you're allowed to do what I mean.
[23:13] Tommy: It's like you're allowed to do this in a musical.
[23:16] Jimi: Well, and like you can people you do this and people come see it. You're not relegated to some like awful collegiate corner of the musical theater world, but like Natasha Pierre in the Great Comet of 1812 is opening on Broadway in fall of this year.
[23:32] Tommy: Exactly.
[23:33] Jimi: This is this is pop culture now.
[23:35] Tommy: Exact and everyone is going to love it.
[23:37] Jimi: Like that is I'm so excited about is I I don't worry at all that this isn't gonna explode and get people excited about musical theatre again because uh it's in the way that like Hamilton I feel is like paved a really a really nice way for to kind of say to people, hey musical theatre's here, it's really good, right?
[24:00] Tommy: Um ignore Spongebob and come in, come and we'll get to that and come and watch it.
[24:06] Jimi: Um because Hamilton like Hamilton's taking over the world, absolutely no denying that, right?
[24:11] Tommy: But what I feel with Comet is gonna do is gonna be like, right, thank you so much for coming to Broadway. This is what we can do.
[24:18] Jimi: Yeah.
[24:18] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?
[24:19] Jimi: And then it's just gonna change the game.
[24:22] Tommy: I am so excited.
[24:23] Jimi: Do you think this is a question I had do you think it's gonna be too weird?
[24:30] Tommy: No, I don't I don't think so.
[24:32] Jimi: Like, remember Spring Awakening, right?
[24:34] Tommy: Mm-hmm.
[24:35] Jimi: Mm-hmm. That in its own little way was quite revolutionary.
[24:39] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?
[24:39] Jimi: It was here's some rock and pop and kids and um the teams fell in love and it was really great for kind of Broadway.
[24:49] Tommy: But Spring Awakening's weird.
[24:51] Jimi: Like Yeah, that's true.
[24:52] Tommy: It's really, really weird.
[24:53] Jimi: It's especially if you it's new if no one ever heard it before.
[24:57] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.
[24:57] Jimi: And it's you know, wacky staging that doesn't really make sense.
[25:00] Tommy: There's masturbation.
[25:01] Jimi: Like, what's going on? And I feel in that same way with this that people are gonna like the fact that it's it's weird.
[25:09] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?
[25:10] Jimi: Yeah.
[25:10] Tommy: Because it's it's so intelligent, it's not gimmicky, it's just interesting.
[25:15] Jimi: I I agree that people won't find it weird, but I could see, you know, the this is this is our jam.
[25:21] Tommy: That like we love musical theater.
[25:23] Jimi: Right.
[25:23] Tommy: Musical theater on Broadway still to a very large extent thrives on the pop culture tourist machine.
[25:32] Jimi: Like you you have to be able to take your cousins from out of town to see the show for it to be successful.
[25:37] Tommy: Yeah.
[25:38] Jimi: Um and I could see, you know, you know, I could see bringing my mother to the show and hear her being like, What have you gotten me into?
[25:45] Tommy: Really?
[25:46] Jimi: Yeah.
[25:46] Tommy: I I don't know.
[25:47] Jimi: I think when I see I don't know, I think if you're there and watching it because it's so because so good at what it does.
[25:54] Tommy: That's true.
[25:55] Jimi: Like in this it's in the same way that you know, people who don't like hip hop still get into Hamilton.
[26:02] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?
[26:02] Jimi: And they're like, well, actually it's not that bad. Because it it's so good at its own thing.
[26:08] Tommy: Well and it's good, it's good at like this is the the thing, like without the opening number, Natasha wouldn't succeed.
[26:17] Jimi: Oh, completely.
[26:18] Tommy: Like they went, and it's very clear that they went back and wrote this opening number.
[26:21] Jimi: So if you if you haven't listened, the prologue of Great Comet is one of the most straightforward expositional musical theater songs I've ever heard.
[26:31] Tommy: Yeah.
[26:32] Jimi: Everyone comes out and there it's like um Natasha is young and loves Andre with all her heart and Andre isn't here. And then they introduce the next character.
[26:41] Tommy: And it's like every character introduces themselves, has a one-sentence description about who they are, and then they go backwards through everyone else you heard about, and Andre isn't here.
[26:57] Jimi: And it's all fun. Mario's also young and Andre is good.
[27:04] Tommy: Better learn it.
[27:05] Jimi: It's gonna be complicated from here on.
[27:06] Tommy: This is as simple as it gets.
[27:08] Jimi: Catch up.
[27:09] Tommy: That's that's new to me in musical theater.
[27:12] Jimi: No musical theater has been as outright expositional in its beginning.
[27:17] Tommy: You know, you try and hide exposition.
[27:19] Jimi: You're you're trying to be like, you know, oh Jimmy, you're the podcaster. You've gotta be thinking about what we're gonna do to save the theater, right?
[27:28] Jimi: You're trying to like hide what the conflict is and introduce the characters while still making it seem like a sentence that people are gonna say in real life.
[27:35] Tommy: Yep.
[27:35] Jimi: You know, or you have the maid answer the phone and be like, oh no, the master's away. No, he doesn't know that she's cheating on him.
[27:43] Tommy: Oh, sure, yes, they're coming tonight, and I'm sure something will happen. Like, but this show is like, hey, listen, you're at the opera, better get with it.
[27:53] Jimi: Like, no exaggeration.
[27:55] Tommy: Yeah, I was talking about this in my friend Jay last night. Is it's it's like a it's like for chips for children almost, you know. I mean, it's like it's using that um really typical childhood playground song, uh, it's the 12 days of Christmas, rolling back and forth, so you'll all remember, but it's not patronizing, it's not belittling, it's not saying you're too stupid to get this, it's just useful, and that's just what I love about it.
[28:17] Jimi: That in this hugely artistic and interesting show, they've got such a like simple construct to just help propel it, which is absolutely amazing.
[28:27] Tommy: And I think as well, if you know there are people out there who are huge fans of the novel or classics and things like that. I don't think they'd get annoyed at the like reductions. Do you know what I mean?
[28:39] Jimi: Because the the words that they choose to describe them, they're like singular words, are perfect.
[28:47] Tommy: Yeah, they are the the perfect definition, yeah, that have many different meanings and and things like that, but it they just describe them perfectly, and you're right, it's so useful um in terms of setting up, and you'll hear that person's name down the line.
[29:04] Jimi: Oh, I remember you, okay, right? You are young, you are hot, you were a meme.
[29:09] Tommy: And even like, you know, you are not an important character, like they say that about it's like you know, these people are this and they're not important.
[29:19] Jimi: And Balaga, well, he's just for fun. Like, please don't don't invest your time in remembering him.
[29:25] Tommy: And then when his song comes out, it's amazing.
[29:27] Jimi: Yes, it's very fun, and then you don't need to worry about him. You're like, I know that he is an inconsequential character, and I'm just gonna enjoy this song.
[29:36] Tommy: Completely, just bravo. It's it's so it's a good musical, Jimmy.
[29:42] Jimi: I think what we should do is we should go through the the numbers and just talk briefly about them.
[29:49] Tommy: Did you know it's divided into five parts, which I found very useful?
[29:53] Jimi: Yes, it is like like Hamilton. This is a show where you know, please listen to it and look up a synopsis. It will help you understand the show.
[30:02] Tommy: And I don't know, I think there's lots of people out there that would completely discredit it for that and be like, oh well, you should be able to understand it in its first time. It's like absolute nonsense.
[30:12] Jimi: Right. I I don't know what you fully unlike. I don't think there's any show I've been to that I've been like, I've followed this perfectly to a T.
[30:19] Tommy: There's what's the point in it then? I d I don't know if this happens in Scotland, but this is a thing I absolutely despise about um American high school literature.
[30:29] Jimi: Um particularly Shakespeare, but with a lot of other plays that they teach as literature, that you know, you sit down and read it and you go home and you read two pages and you read five pages and then you come back and you talk about it.
[30:43] Tommy: Yeah.
[30:43] Jimi: And then it's like, but you have to understand what's going on, kid in school who is reading this play, and like that's not no, that's not the point.
[30:52] Tommy: Exactly.
[30:53] Jimi: Shakespeare didn't write these things to be read. He barely even wrote them. Like they're pieces to be performed, and you shouldn't feel bad for not fully grasping it when you read it.
[31:06] Tommy: Just like you shouldn't feel bad for not fully grasping this musical if you're just listening to the cast album. It's there's there's so there's too much there, do you know what I mean?
[31:14] Jimi: Yeah. And it you just get to enjoy it that first time. You get to have that amazing carnal experience.
[31:20] Tommy: Yeah.
[31:20] Jimi: And then you go back and you get to learn about it and discover it more. That's just the joy of bloody theatre.
[31:27] Tommy: But right, so let's should we go through section by part by part?
[31:31] Jimi: Sure. So first there's the prologue, which we talked about.
[31:34] Tommy: We introduced literally every character in the show.
[31:36] Jimi: Yep.
[31:37] Tommy: And the most important thing is that Andre, Natasha's betrothed, isn't here.
[31:43] Jimi: Yes.
[31:44] Tommy: That is the end of every sentence. Natasha's young and Andre isn't here.
[31:48] Jimi: Yes, exactly. And this is all in your program, you're at the app.
[31:51] Tommy: Which we just sing the show.
[31:53] Jimi: Exactly. Like that this it's we're just gonna sing the whole thing for you right now.
[31:57] Tommy: Which should be great.
[31:58] Jimi: But then a lot of the songs are very naming songs, I think is a whole it's worth a whole scholarly discussion.
[32:10] Tommy: Yeah.
[32:10] Jimi: Because I think there a lot of people look put a lot of effort into it, a lot of people put a little effort into it, and then a lot of people just find the right balance.
[32:19] Tommy: Yeah.
[32:19] Jimi: Most of these songs are are either named there's there's no creativity in how they're named, and it's perfect.
[32:27] Tommy: Right.
[32:27] Jimi: They're simple and to the point. It just tells you what happens.
[32:33] Tommy: Here's what we're talking about.
[32:34] Jimi: This is describing this person, this is how this person feels. Like it's very straightforward.
[32:39] Tommy: And again, perfect, thank you.
[32:41] Jimi: Exactly. It seems it seems, and I say this with no academic backing, but it seems very Russian.
[32:47] Tommy: Yeah, right.
[32:48] Jimi: Well the whole the whole thing does, because like even breaking it down into parts, this is the same as the book.
[32:52] Tommy: Like the book is broken down into volumes and chapters and sections.
[32:55] Jimi: Like it that's perfectly fine.
[32:57] Tommy: And it's a gr when you've got something that's so substantial, you need it.
[33:01] Jimi: Yeah. Do you know what I mean? You need to have those chunks.
[33:03] Tommy: Yeah.
[33:04] Jimi: Right. So we've spoken about the prologue, then we have Pierre.
[33:07] Tommy: Um, so at the end of the prologue, they say what about Pierre?
[33:11] Jimi: Because obviously he's in the title, you know he's about somewhere.
[33:14] Tommy: You're like, right. Well, what about Pierre?
[33:15] Jimi: What about him? Great question?
[33:16] Tommy: Right.
[33:17] Jimi: Um, and what I think's actually quite interesting is with all the other characters, they get their like one word, they get their one sentence, and then we get Pierre, and I think actually, obviously Pierre being the main character of the whole the whole book, out of all of the characters on the stage, he at the moment, at this part of the novel, is probably the most complex.
[33:39] Tommy: Yeah.
[33:39] Jimi: Because he's going through it. Do you know? I mean, he's he's really in this weird place where basic kind of little history lesson, like what's happening in Russia at the moment, um, is there enjoying war by the way.
[33:51] Tommy: That's probably the part that is the part of the prologue we didn't mention.
[33:54] Jimi: There's a war going on somewhere.
[33:56] Tommy: Oh, yeah, and Andre isn't here.
[33:58] Jimi: Exactly. Um, but in Moscow, they were just happy to forget about all that, enjoy the fact that they've got some money and it was very indulgent, the upper class were swinging about and not really caring, and it was your it was that it was like Weimar Germany.
[34:18] Tommy: It's about war and richness, but that's exactly what was going on.
[34:23] Jimi: Right, exactly. It's a wonderful content.
[34:26] Tommy: Um, and that's that's what was happening.
[34:28] Jimi: And Pierre was fully indulging in all of that.
[34:31] Tommy: Um, but it's starting to be like, what is this all for?
[34:36] Jimi: Like, why am I doing this?
[34:39] Tommy: He's having a little bit of a big existential crisis.
[34:42] Jimi: Exactly, exactly. The poor guy.
[34:44] Tommy: Um, and because of that, we then get a whole song to talk about his crisis because when you're having that existential crisis, you can't be summed up in one word because you think this and you feel this and this as well.
[34:57] Jimi: Um I think it's so great that while setting up, you know, one of the main characters, uh, they also get to show how confused and uh he is.
[35:10] Tommy: Yeah, and they and it's they set up him and his relationship to everyone else.
[35:16] Jimi: Like they call, you know, it's oh Pierre, our merry feasting crank.
[35:20] Tommy: Yeah.
[35:20] Jimi: He's smart and eccentric and warm-hearted and old school, and his purse is always empty because he lends it out to everyone, like and dying, and kind of trying to figure it out.
[35:33] Tommy: Yeah, and it is it's it's a song, it's like there's lots of like pity in it.
[35:37] Jimi: Yeah.
[35:37] Tommy: Um, but you know he's a goodie because everyone is kind of like, ah, just not like evil Pierre, it's just like, oh Pierre.
[35:47] Jimi: Yeah, exactly. And I get it, and instantly you're like, okay, cool, we like him.
[35:51] Tommy: We like this guy.
[35:52] Jimi: But it doesn't really set up like Pierre Pierre is an enigma in this show, I think for me.
[35:57] Tommy: A great, like an intentional and important enigma.
[36:01] Jimi: Um, and it sets it up very well.
[36:04] Tommy: The zest of life has vanished, only the skeleton remains unexpectedly vile.
[36:12] Jimi: I used to be better, I used to be better, I used to be better.
[36:12] Tommy: I used to be better, I used to be better, I used to be better.
[36:29] Jimi: Oh Pierre, our merry feasting crank, our most dear, most kind, most smart and centric.
[36:37] Tommy: A war on a rush on the ocean.
[36:40] Jimi: His purse is always empty, curse is open to all Pierre.
[36:48] Tommy: Just one of a hundred saddle men letting out their final days in Australia.
[36:54] Jimi: Um author's author's note in a couple of the productions, Pierre was played by uh Dave Dave Milly.
[37:04] Tommy: Yeah.
[37:04] Jimi: The author. I think in literally all the all the productions until Broadway, um it's been debate.
[37:11] Tommy: So I tried to look this up. There's a couple, like he's not listed as Pierre in the program I have.
[37:18] Jimi: Oh, interesting.
[37:19] Tommy: What where is that from?
[37:22] Jimi: Hard to say.
[37:23] Tommy: It doesn't say what theater it's in.
[37:25] Jimi: Because they weren't in theaters.
[37:28] Tommy: I know, but it's still a company. Do you know what I mean?
[37:30] Jimi: Like the American rep.
[37:31] Tommy: It doesn't say casino.
[37:33] Jimi: This is the Arsnova production.
[37:35] Tommy: Right.
[37:36] Jimi: That that was both of the tented ones which were spread out.
[37:40] Tommy: So who does it credit for playing?
[37:42] Jimi: Pierre.
[37:43] Tommy: Uh David Abelis.
[37:45] Jimi: Oh, interesting.
[37:46] Tommy: I never even come across his name.
[37:47] Jimi: Oh, wait, I've just found it on So apparently David Abelis came in when they were in Times Square as opposed to meat packing.
[37:55] Tommy: Oh, okay.
[37:58] Jimi: Man, what a new day and age we live in where musicals and theater can exist anywhere.
[38:05] Tommy: Exactly.
[38:05] Jimi: In the meat packing district.
[38:07] Tommy: Who would think to go to the meat packing district in New York to go see a show?
[38:11] Jimi: See, this is why my mother would be like, What have you gotten me into?
[38:14] Tommy: Like, Mom, we gotta go to the meat packing district. We're gonna watch a musical. Also, you're gonna get very drunk.
[38:19] Jimi: And then we're gonna go to a gay club and we're gonna have a great time.
[38:21] Tommy: I mean, we do that anyway.
[38:23] Jimi: Exactly.
[38:25] Tommy: Uh yeah.
[38:26] Jimi: So right, Moscow.
[38:28] Tommy: Moscow.
[38:28] Jimi: To Moscow.
[38:29] Tommy: So I love Moscow.
[38:31] Jimi: Right, Moscow.
[38:32] Tommy: So it's right, basically it's a Glasgow.
[38:34] Jimi: Well, not a glass winner thing, it's a precious thing.
[38:35] Tommy: We have the sound O that you don't have.
[38:38] Jimi: Moscow.
[38:39] Tommy: Yeah.
[38:40] Jimi: Because say why would you say Glasgow?
[38:43] Tommy: I would I would say Glasgow, because I know that's right, but Glasgow is what the Glasgow, the famous glass cow.
[38:50] Jimi: Where's the problem?
[38:51] Tommy: No.
[38:52] Jimi: It's the exact it's the exact same thing.
[38:53] Tommy: But do you know what really interesting?
[38:55] Jimi: And I'm I want to ask Dave Malloy this question.
[38:58] Tommy: Um if you're listening, Dave Malloy. Uh why in Natasha Bier the Great Comic of 1812, is it Moscow?
[39:05] Jimi: Uh-huh.
[39:06] Tommy: And then in preludes, it's Moscow.
[39:09] Jimi: Ooh, interesting question.
[39:10] Tommy: He will tell you have you read through all of his genius annotations?
[39:14] Jimi: I've not.
[39:14] Tommy: They're fabulous.
[39:15] Jimi: Um what's great is a bunch of them, he'd be like, you know where who sings and bursts into tears.
[39:22] Tommy: Does Natasha sing that at some point?
[39:24] Jimi: Uh it's Mario Dimitri.
[39:27] Tommy: Oh no, I think it's Natasha sing it about yourself.
[39:29] Jimi: Yeah.
[39:30] Tommy: Um he says in the genius annotation, sometimes during rehearsal, the actress would replace this line with and burst into flames.
[39:36] Jimi: Amazing.
[39:37] Tommy: Which and like there's a bunch of those about like just for fun.
[39:40] Jimi: Sometimes this line was this.
[39:42] Tommy: But he also talks about how um he uh pronounces things wrong all the time, which I sympathize with.
[39:48] Jimi: Ah, there you go.
[39:49] Tommy: As someone who lives on the internet and gets called out every single gosh darn time I say word wrong.
[39:55] Jimi: Exactly.
[39:55] Tommy: How dare you?
[39:56] Jimi: So, Dave, I sympathize, whether it's Moscow or Moscow.
[40:00] Tommy: Moscow and Moscow.
[40:01] Jimi: Well, I mean, it doesn't really matter because well, is it accent?
[40:05] Tommy: Linguistic students of the musical theatre world, let us know.
[40:09] Jimi: Jimmy, I think we've we've gone in too deep.
[40:11] Tommy: I know this isn't deep musical, but I think we've gone in a little too deep.
[40:15] Jimi: Um right.
[40:16] Tommy: So anyway, Moscow.
[40:18] Jimi: Moscow.
[40:18] Tommy: Song number three. Like any good musical, after you introduce the characters, you have to introduce the little cow.
[40:24] Jimi: Exactly.
[40:24] Tommy: It's what you do. Unabashedly.
[40:26] Jimi: And the first thing that happens is Natasha says Maria's full name, and Maria says Natasha's full name.
[40:33] Tommy: Maria Dmitrievna.
[40:34] Jimi: What an amazing name. I want to call my child that. Just fill fill both names.
[40:39] Tommy: Maria Dmitrievna.
[40:41] Jimi: That is so Russian. It's amazing.
[40:43] Tommy: Maria Dmitrievka Akrosimova.
[40:48] Jimi: Akrosimova, yep. Something like that.
[40:50] Tommy: I'm cheating. I have the text in front of me.
[40:53] Jimi: Yeah.
[40:53] Tommy: Maria Dmitry. And so like her name is Maria, and they call her Maria.
[40:58] Jimi: Natasha's full name is Natalia Icht something Rostova.
[41:03] Tommy: Yep.
[41:04] Jimi: And so she can be Princess Rostova, Natalia or Natasha.
[41:08] Tommy: Yeah.
[41:09] Jimi: And then they so Sonia is Sofia Alexandrova Rostova, who's Natasha's cousin.
[41:16] Jimi: Yeah. Um, and she's Sophia or Sonia or Princess Rostova. And this is why the names become really confusing really quickly. And apparently in the book, that is equally confusing.
[41:27] Tommy: Yeah. Like I've got to be able to do that. So I basically, yeah, this is it is pretty much just setting up this is the setting. This is what's happening culturally.
[41:34] Jimi: Well, and Natasha has gone back to Moscow from where it doesn't really matter.
[41:38] Tommy: Yeah. To stay with her godmother, Maria.
[41:41] Jimi: Yeah. With her cousin. And they're here because they can't be taken care of by their husbands or betrothed because they're in a war.
[41:49] Tommy: And yeah, in nice old-fashioned style, they have their chaperone, Maria, who is what is she? She's mean but fair.
[41:55] Jimi: Uh strict, kind.
[41:59] Tommy: Strict kind. And in the wonderfully drawn family tree that comes in the program.
[42:05] Jimi: Oh wow, how exciting.
[42:07] Tommy: Oh, it's wonderful. She has this wonderful high-necked dress, which I'm sure is also her costume. But like, doesn't that define her real right away?
[42:16] Jimi: And it's so easy, and this is what when this goes to Broadway, a lot of people will poo-poo, but it's easy to be like, but that's cheating.
[42:24] Tommy: But that's and like exactly. Jimi made a face that was like, then you know that little like smiley that gets put on like Reddit and stuff all the time.
[42:33] Jimi: The like shruggy shoulder guy, the little shrug- I'll find them up under the show notes. The shrugging shoulder guy. Because, and something I think Natasha, Pierre in the Great Comet of 1812 embraces, is the moment you think about going to see a show, that's when the performance starts.
[42:51] Tommy: Right. That's a great way of putting it.
[42:52] Jimi: Which is why, you know, it goes back to like the big title thing, um, all the advertisements for the show, like all of these things, whether you like it or not, affect how you perceive the show.
[43:03] Tommy: Yeah.
[43:04] Jimi: Um, and the taken to its logical extreme is Natasha, Pierre in the Great Comet of 1812, where you're going to see a show that is in something that's kind of like a restaurant or a bar in the meat packing district that you know is based on War and Peace, which is this novel you didn't read in your education, but you have vague Russian knowledge of and so have a sense about it, and then all of a sudden they're just you know blurting these things out, and there's a family tree in the program.
[43:32] Tommy: Yeah, and all of these things are the show. It is not just the text in the script or the performance on stage.
[43:39] Jimi: Exactly.
[43:41] Tommy: Write it on my flag and read it off a soapbox on the corner.
[43:44] Jimi: Completely.
[43:45] Tommy: And yeah, it's not cheating.
[44:01] Jimi: Countess Natalia Rosovast.
[44:06] Tommy: Call me Natasha.
[44:10] Jimi: Maria Dimitria Nakroshimova.
[44:13] Tommy: So we are Zandrovna Rostova much call me so.
[44:22] Jimi: Welcome to Moscow where Freden and Princesses live.
[44:29] Tommy: I'll take you where you must go.
[44:37] Jimi: My goddaughter, my favorite Natasha.
[44:40] Tommy: I will touch you on the tree.
[44:44] Jimi: So that's Moscow.
[44:45] Tommy: Moscow.
[44:46] Jimi: Yep.
[44:47] Tommy: The mosque.
[44:48] Jimi: So you've got the glass coat and you've got the moss cow.
[44:51] Tommy: Is there a Glasgow mule? Like a drink you can order?
[44:53] Jimi: That should be maker.
[44:56] Tommy: It should be, shouldn't it?
[44:57] Jimi: Yeah, it's filled with haggis.
[45:00] Tommy: Yeah.
[45:05] Jimi: So Natasha gets sent by her godmother to go meet her in-laws.
[45:11] Tommy: Yes.
[45:11] Jimi: Because that's the nice thing to do.
[45:13] Tommy: Exactly. It's just like you should go do that.
[45:15] Jimi: I know he's not there, but make them like you, and then everything will be fine.
[45:18] Tommy: And there's some vagaries about money involved, and like if you want to inherit well, you should be nice to the other people in the family.
[45:26] Jimi: It all seems very Russian and very nonspecific, and not that important quite why.
[45:32] Tommy: Yeah.
[45:32] Jimi: Um, because it well, um, Natasha isn't as rich as um Andre, Andre.
[45:39] Tommy: Um, and so it's not she isn't the best person to marry in that respect.
[45:44] Jimi: So she does have to kind of go and butter them up a little bit uh to be like I'm I'm a really great person.
[45:50] Tommy: And it also means this decadent world of Moscow is a little new to her.
[45:56] Jimi: Um so she goes in the song The Private and Intimate Lives to pay a visit on old Prince Bolkonski, who is Andre's father and Andre's sister, Mary.
[46:07] Tommy: Yes.
[46:07] Jimi: Um so these are the two supporting roles.
[46:12] Tommy: Yeah, might they're minor characters, so we don't need to care about them too much.
[46:15] Jimi: But they're hilarious.
[46:17] Tommy: Andre's family totally messed up.
[46:19] Jimi: Exactly.
[46:20] Tommy: And boy are they.
[46:21] Jimi: Yep. I'm the first so the first time I think this is the first moment where you're like, what the hell is Dave Malloy?
[46:30] Tommy: Like what crazy weird up to it's so weird.
[46:36] Jimi: Yeah. He is old and senile and angry.
[46:42] Tommy: Um, and then his poor doting daughter who has to take care of him all the time.
[46:49] Jimi: Yep.
[46:50] Tommy: And doesn't seem to like it.
[46:52] Jimi: And so needless to say, Natasha's meeting with them does not go well.
[46:55] Tommy: Bolkonski does not seem to take to her, and Mary doesn't either.
[47:01] Jimi: So poor Natasha, um she leaves and proceeds to sing one of the most beautiful songs ever.
[47:10] Tommy: Do you agree? What do you think?
[47:11] Jimi: No one else?
[47:12] Tommy: Yeah.
[47:12] Jimi: I don't think it's the most beautiful song in the show, but I think it's a beautiful song.
[47:16] Tommy: I I I agree.
[47:17] Jimi: Uh I think one of the other most beautiful songs in the world ever is also in this show.
[47:23] Tommy: I think so I and Molloy talks about it in one of the many things I read about, but where classically you have sympathetic and unsympathetic protagonists.
[47:33] Jimi: Yeah.
[47:34] Tommy: Protagonists that you are you get behind and are the everyman, and you're like, yeah, you want him to win.
[47:39] Jimi: And unsympathetic protagonists where you're like, what?
[47:41] Tommy: Oh, what an awful person.
[47:43] Jimi: And you just like, you know, angry throughout the whole thing.
[47:46] Tommy: Yeah.
[47:47] Jimi: It is a roller coaster with Natasha.
[47:49] Tommy: Completely.
[47:50] Jimi: She is one minute precocious and difficult to stand, and the next minute totally sincere and like just the most you like cry internally for the pain that she's going through.
[48:07] Tommy: Which is wonderful.
[48:08] Jimi: It's just all the way, all the way through the show, she's constantly asking questions.
[48:12] Tommy: She's constantly saying, I don't know what's happening.
[48:15] Jimi: I don't really get this.
[48:17] Tommy: Because, and they say it right at the start, Natasha is young.
[48:20] Jimi: She can't cope with life yet.
[48:22] Tommy: I I didn't look this up specifically, but I get the sense, at least at the beginning of the show and this part of War and Peace.
[48:29] Jimi: She's like 15.
[48:32] Tommy: I imagine she's about 15, 16.
[48:35] Jimi: Yeah. Like young and betrothed to a man who's off at war.
[48:41] Tommy: Like that, you know, there's a lot to I can't imagine that happening, or what that's like.
[48:47] Jimi: It's a very archaic, you know, structure that we've done away with in the Western world.
[48:53] Tommy: But to be honest, still exist it still exists.
[48:56] Jimi: I think it's it is so fascinating to kind of see it from the and I don't want to say victim, but the victim's perspective.
[49:07] Tommy: Yeah.
[49:08] Jimi: Um well, and from from a contemporary's perspective.
[49:11] Tommy: Like you're you're you're in it with them.
[49:13] Jimi: Yeah, you're not sitting and reading War and Peace, this archaic novel.
[49:16] Tommy: Yeah.
[49:16] Jimi: You're right in the middle of it, and you get it.
[49:19] Tommy: And I mean, even if you don't get it, you feel it.
[49:22] Jimi: Completely.
[49:23] Tommy: Um and you sympathize it.
[49:25] Jimi: And no one else sets you up for that.
[49:27] Tommy: I mean, she's singing about how much she misses Andre.
[49:30] Jimi: This has my favorite lines in the show that I think are straight from War and Peace, where she sings, like she's missing her Andre.
[49:39] Tommy: You know, you and I, I'll never be this happy again.
[49:41] Jimi: Yeah.
[49:41] Tommy: You and I, you and I, no one else.
[49:43] Jimi: Maybe he'll come today.
[49:45] Tommy: Maybe he came already, and he's sitting in the drawing room, and I simply forgot.
[49:50] Jimi: Yeah.
[49:51] Tommy: It is so succinct.
[49:53] Jimi: Like it's it's four lines.
[49:54] Tommy: It's really easy, but that is exactly where Natasha's at, and it is complex and interesting and difficult to describe in other words.
[50:04] Jimi: Mm-hmm.
[50:05] Tommy: And it's, you know, what starts making this a beautiful musical.
[50:08] Jimi: Like that is where to start with this very childlike kindergarten song that's like, here's who I am, here's who I am, and then end up only four songs later, you know, maybe he's sitting in the drawing room and I simply forgot.
[50:21] Tommy: Yeah.
[50:21] Jimi: Like, what a whoa.
[50:23] Tommy: We're in for a night.
[50:24] Jimi: It's like I th I think no one else is the first time it's like it's musical theater as we know it.
[50:30] Tommy: And it it provides you with this kind of like nice still time to like reflect on part one and everything that's happened and uh, you know, realize that yeah, that she is young.
[50:44] Jimi: Do you know what I mean? It's being confirmed.
[50:46] Tommy: She's young and trying so and trying.
[50:49] Jimi: She's she's not just floating through this world.
[50:51] Tommy: She's trying really hard with everything she knows how to do to like process and understand and like exact get through these really strong romanticized feelings she's having.
[51:02] Jimi: Completely.
[51:03] Tommy: And I feel as well, I feel a lot of it.
[51:06] Jimi: Um, and I wonder if you agree, is probably part of her love for Andre has come from her being told she needs to love Andre in that very young way where it's like you know what we mean when you're you're in your first relationship and you feel that right, I'll probably say I love you in like a couple of weeks.
[51:26] Tommy: Um I mean, it's like you're not gonna be.
[51:30] Jimi: Uh-huh.
[51:30] Tommy: You don't process the feelings necessarily, but you know you've got these, but you just kind of do what should be done.
[51:36] Jimi: Yeah.
[51:36] Tommy: Um it's really heartbreaking, and I absolutely absolutely adore it.
[51:40] Jimi: One thing I forgot to mention in terms of form, in the song before, with Attach and Belkonzies, um, uh, I love what they do all the way throughout the musical, uh, with their kind of like fourth wall breaking narrative reading um moments.
[51:57] Tommy: Um, and I love the one between Mary and um Mary and Natasha.
[52:03] Jimi: Uh-huh.
[52:04] Tommy: So because it's like when they have that first meeting and it's like they don't say anything, um, and then they break down and there's this amazing like bass riff.
[52:12] Jimi: Um, and then she the like Mary becomes this really sassy like rock chick from being this completely timid and afraid little girl into this like and it's like yes, and I love that, and they do that all the way throughout.
[52:30] Tommy: You're not just watching a story about 19th century Russia, you're watching the novel War and Peace.
[52:40] Jimi: Yeah, yeah.
[52:41] Tommy: Those those narrative parts about like, here's my inner monologue.
[52:45] Jimi: I'm just gonna tell you.
[52:46] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.
[52:47] Jimi: Exactly.
[52:48] Tommy: And that's it.
[52:48] Jimi: It's unabashed.
[52:49] Tommy: It's just like, well, yeah, this was great.
[52:51] Jimi: So this is what I'm just gonna say.
[52:53] Tommy: Did you buy it?
[52:54] Jimi: And it's absolutely fab.
[52:55] Tommy: So it's wonderful.
[52:57] Jimi: The buy-in for what is a really high concept sort of piece of performance is great.
[53:02] Tommy: Completely.
[53:03] Jimi: You don't you don't question it, you never think.
[53:06] Tommy: And your childlike eyes, and your distant smile.
[53:12] Jimi: I'll never be this happy again.
[53:17] Tommy: You and die.
[53:35] Jimi: And no one maybe he'll come today.
[53:50] Tommy: Maybe he came already, and he's sitting in the drawing room.
[53:58] Jimi: And I simply forgot.
[54:08] Tommy: Um right, part two.
[54:09] Jimi: Part two.
[54:10] Tommy: We uh so such a good part.
[54:14] Jimi: Maria takes Sonia and Natasha to the opera.
[54:14] Tommy: The opera, the opera.
[54:22] Jimi: Hold up your dresses and jump out quickly.
[54:24] Tommy: Oh, it's just great.
[54:25] Jimi: I want to know what the staging is at that point.
[54:27] Tommy: I really, really do.
[54:28] Jimi: They're getting out of the sleigh.
[54:30] Tommy: I know, but I I don't I want to I want to know if they're like in a sleigh.
[54:34] Jimi: I'm sure they're not.
[54:35] Tommy: Like, that's the thing. Is like the staging of this is so simple.
[54:39] Jimi: Yeah.
[54:40] Tommy: It's just so simple and elegant.
[54:43] Jimi: Because everything is expositional, but in a in a really uh smart way.
[54:48] Tommy: It's not like it's not hold up your dresses and jump out of the sleigh.
[54:53] Jimi: It's hold up your dresses and jump out quickly.
[54:55] Tommy: And we haven't even talked about modes of transport in 19th century Russia yet.
[55:01] Jimi: Exactly.
[55:02] Tommy: And it's great.
[55:03] Jimi: And it's like we've already implied like we have we it hold up your dresses and jump out quickly.
[55:07] Tommy: We're at the opera.
[55:08] Jimi: Like we're implying so many things.
[55:09] Tommy: I've taken you out to the opera. You're wearing a dress because we know what you know, we're going to the opera, we have traveled to get here.
[55:15] Jimi: Like simple.
[55:16] Tommy: So simple.
[55:17] Jimi: One line.
[55:18] Tommy: And this is the first moment where you get to really understand what Russia is like at the moment.
[55:24] Jimi: Where everyone is looking at each other up and down and saying, Are you beautiful? What are you wearing? Have you got pearls? What are you showing in your body? Are you looking for something? And it's everything is status.
[55:36] Tommy: Yes.
[55:37] Jimi: I love that. It's absolutely amazing.
[55:39] Tommy: Who is that? What are they wearing? Who and like everyone they they say everyone vaguely knew of Natasha's engagement.
[55:45] Jimi: One of the finest matches in all of Russia.
[55:47] Tommy: Yep.
[55:49] Jimi: It's just a line, just exposition.
[55:51] Tommy: Exactly.
[55:52] Jimi: And it's so interesting because you you you can completely picture it. You can completely see what that would have been like.
[55:59] Tommy: Um just everyone just looking at each other and being like, I'm at the opera. You're seeing me at the opera. That's good, isn't it?
[56:06] Jimi: And it just using it is this complete status.
[56:10] Tommy: And it makes Natasha uncomfortable.
[56:13] Jimi: Exactly, because this is new to her.
[56:15] Tommy: This is all so strange.
[56:16] Jimi: And she's she's doing it well, like without trying. People are jealous of her.
[56:21] Tommy: She is pretty, she is young, she has made it to the opera.
[56:24] Jimi: She's got nice shoulders.
[56:25] Tommy: She she has nice shoulders.
[56:27] Jimi: Man, uh uh Anatole on a couple occasions mentions Natasha's feet.
[56:34] Tommy: More than once.
[56:35] Jimi: He talks about how nice her feet are.
[56:39] Tommy: It's just a thing.
[56:41] Jimi: It's a thing that happens like several times about the show, and it's always like she's so lovely, she's so beautiful, what lovely feet, and she's beautiful, and I love her, and that's the song.
[56:50] Tommy: And then he sings another song, and he's like, Oh, her eyes, she's just oh, I must have her and her feet, and we must and great shoulders.
[56:58] Jimi: And like maybe it's just because that's one of the parts that's on show. It's just something I noticed in my listening to today that I hadn't noticed before.
[57:06] Tommy: And I mean, perhaps, and it's Anatol just has a really distinct foot fetish, and maybe absolutely fine.
[57:12] Jimi: Let's honor that. We're not here to kink shame.
[57:15] Tommy: That's not what we're about.
[57:17] Jimi: It's I I just I hope that's also straight from like there's a passage.
[57:22] Tommy: There's a whole chapter about Anatole's foot fetish completely.
[57:26] Jimi: Um you know, I know it's a long book.
[57:26] Tommy: It's a long book.
[57:31] Jimi: And there's probably like six pages in War and Peace that just like no one has ever read.
[57:36] Tommy: Just like they've always everyone's just been like, nah, skip this part.
[57:40] Jimi: No, yeah, exactly. I'm I'm sure the missing the missing chapter of Warren Peace.
[57:44] Tommy: Um it's probably the one about the foot fetish.
[57:47] Jimi: Probably speaking of tangents, uh no they go to the opera, we we meet a bunch of other people again, like this is the actual in world exposition.
[57:56] Tommy: Dolokov shows up, he's an assassin, but a non important Helene is there with Dolikov, but married to Pierre.
[58:04] Jimi: Secretly in love with her brother.
[58:05] Tommy: Yep.
[58:06] Jimi: And Pierre is enjoying himself at home this evening despite his wife's absence.
[58:11] Tommy: I just love that line.
[58:12] Jimi: So I'm fine, it's okay.
[58:14] Tommy: Yeah.
[58:15] Jimi: Ah, it's great.
[58:17] Tommy: Really, really good.
[58:17] Jimi: Um, and yeah, and you get to know that Helena's a bitch.
[58:22] Tommy: Yep.
[58:23] Jimi: Yeah.
[58:23] Tommy: It's great.
[58:24] Jimi: She meets Natasha, and then the opera starts.
[58:27] Tommy: Exactly.
[58:28] Jimi: And it starts.
[58:31] Tommy: You gotta listen to it.
[58:33] Jimi: It's and it this is you know, every every time an author writes about the performance work that they're doing, yeah.
[58:39] Tommy: You know they're making some commentary on it.
[58:41] Jimi: And I know half of this is stolen from Tolstoy about his opinion of this avant-garde opera.
[58:48] Tommy: He hated it.
[58:49] Jimi: And like the uh the little snippet of quote unquote opera that they perform is weird.
[58:58] Tommy: It's like it's it's like um the crucifixion from Jesus Christ Superstar.
[59:02] Jimi: Yeah.
[59:03] Tommy: It's so you're just like, what the hell is going on?
[59:06] Jimi: Yeah, why why are you screaming?
[59:08] Tommy: Like what?
[59:10] Jimi: Um, but it's very like opera.
[59:12] Tommy: Yeah, you can do what I mean.
[59:13] Jimi: I'm like, well, I could imagine it doesn't seem like a caricature.
[59:16] Tommy: Like it is probably very real.
[59:19] Jimi: Yeah, I I love I'm a big big fan of opera.
[59:22] Tommy: Um, well, some operas.
[59:24] Jimi: Uh and it's really, really interesting because you it's like Natasha has a line where she's like, I don't know what's going on, but this is all really cool.
[59:34] Tommy: And that's what I was like first for the first opera I saw. I was like, I'm not following anything, but it's really dramatic, and that's fun.
[59:40] Jimi: Um, and yeah, the music is certainly dramatic.
[59:43] Tommy: And so that's why this number is so interesting because five songs ago, they said point blank to the audience, you're at the opera.
[59:50] Jimi: Uh-huh.
[59:50] Tommy: And now a character in the show is saying about the opera, I do not understand this.
[59:56] Jimi: But I love it.
[59:57] Tommy: Exactly.
[59:58] Jimi: And they don't I mean they don't actually say any words in this opera, they just scream and you gotta do it.
[1:00:04] Tommy: Which is pretty much like this anyway.
[1:00:07] Jimi: It's so weird.
[1:00:08] Tommy: It's so weird.
[1:00:42] Jimi: And then mid-opera, enter Anatol.
[1:00:46] Tommy: Dum dumatol is hot.
[1:00:50] Jimi: And what what is the line?
[1:00:52] Tommy: Um which one?
[1:00:53] Jimi: Sorry, just giving you a bass because that's Anatol's coming.
[1:00:56] Tommy: So it's something like he he he walks in so handsome and ridiculous, or like it would have seemed so ridiculous were it not for his swagger.
[1:01:10] Jimi: Exactly.
[1:01:10] Tommy: And he, I mean, if you I think there are video clips of him entering, and he literally just struts down the whole theater, like and swinging his coat about with his lovely haircut.
[1:01:20] Jimi: Um and you're just like, you are at war.
[1:01:23] Tommy: Yep.
[1:01:24] Jimi: What what uh what are you about?
[1:01:26] Tommy: I wanna know more.
[1:01:27] Jimi: And he's got this I just love the dum.
[1:01:30] Tommy: It's so good.
[1:01:31] Jimi: You're just like, you are yeah, this is he feels powerful, uh electric.
[1:01:36] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:01:36] Jimi: This is when the club music starts.
[1:01:38] Tommy: Yeah, this is when this becomes more than just like a chamber music retelling of War and Peace.
[1:01:46] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:01:46] Tommy: And so Natasha stops caring about the opera.
[1:01:51] Jimi: And while the opera happens in the background, like she has this great line that's like, every time I'm looking at him, he's looking at me.
[1:01:51] Tommy: Every time I'm looking at him, he's looking at me.
[1:01:59] Jimi: Looking at me, yeah.
[1:02:00] Tommy: Oh, oh boy.
[1:02:02] Jimi: There's troubles afoot.
[1:02:03] Tommy: Troubles a foot.
[1:02:04] Jimi: Exactly, exactly.
[1:02:05] Tommy: But do you know so we were talking about this earlier, but do you not just think you can feel that electricity between them?
[1:02:11] Jimi: Oh, yeah.
[1:02:11] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?
[1:02:12] Jimi: That she's like, it is it's that like stirring in your underwear when you don't quite understand what's going on there.
[1:02:18] Tommy: Right.
[1:02:18] Jimi: But feels kind of good, but also like what?
[1:02:21] Tommy: It's that it's that feeling.
[1:02:22] Jimi: And we have no idea, like, she has talked so much about how she thinks she loves Andre, but uh we haven't met him, we know nothing about their relationship, and then like sex in a bottle walks in and Natasha can't handle it.
[1:02:39] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:02:40] Jimi: And we know we're in this world where everyone is judging everyone for everything they're doing and who they're looking at.
[1:02:48] Tommy: Exactly.
[1:02:49] Jimi: And in this very public place, Natasha is having is you know, getting the vapors a little bit.
[1:02:59] Tommy: And looking looking into his eyes.
[1:03:07] Jimi: I am bright.
[1:03:11] Tommy: So they interact and they look at each other and he looks at her body and she understands that he's looking at her body and he speaks a little bit of French and he's exotic and he invites her out.
[1:03:26] Jimi: To uh wait, can I use this phrase?
[1:03:28] Tommy: He invites her to a fancy dress party.
[1:03:30] Jimi: Uh what do you mean a costume term?
[1:03:33] Tommy: Oh, do you not this is a phrase that Americans don't use, but I find it funny that is popular in the UK.
[1:03:39] Jimi: No, do you not have fancy dress parties?
[1:03:41] Tommy: Yeah, but do you not have fancy dress parties?
[1:03:43] Jimi: We don't if you if you invite if you sent out an invitation to all of my friends and invited them to a fancy dress party, they would show up in like suits and ties.
[1:03:53] Tommy: Wow.
[1:03:53] Jimi: Really?
[1:03:54] Tommy: Right?
[1:03:54] Jimi: This is a cultural thing I just recently learned about.
[1:03:58] Tommy: I suppose yeah.
[1:03:59] Jimi: You call it a costume party.
[1:04:00] Tommy: I'd call it a costume party.
[1:04:02] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:04:03] Tommy: Well.
[1:04:03] Jimi: Because and there I can't even remember what it was. There was some piece of like text-based literature I was reading where they were talking about a fancy dress party.
[1:04:11] Tommy: I was like, whoa, and then they were talking about who they were dressed up as.
[1:04:15] Jimi: I was like, what is going on?
[1:04:18] Tommy: That's so interesting.
[1:04:19] Jimi: I don't know what my suit looks like.
[1:04:22] Tommy: Uh Anatole invites Natasha to a costume tournament.
[1:04:26] Jimi: Yep.
[1:04:27] Tommy: Um, and she is starting to feel very confused.
[1:04:32] Jimi: She is being like, Well, he's speaking to me, and this is like nice, uh, and he's close.
[1:04:39] Tommy: Um, and she's obsessed with his eyes.
[1:04:42] Jimi: Oh my god.
[1:04:43] Tommy: And she's starting to feel, well, here's a man who's showing interest in me.
[1:04:47] Jimi: And I imagine probably the first.
[1:04:49] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:04:49] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:04:50] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?
[1:04:51] Jimi: Because the first time she's been exposed to people.
[1:04:54] Tommy: Um, so she's got no idea what's going on, but she likes it because he's hot.
[1:05:00] Jimi: And then and she has no idea what to do.
[1:05:03] Tommy: She has no idea what to do.
[1:05:04] Jimi: Like, and she sings a whole song about it.
[1:05:06] Tommy: Exactly.
[1:05:06] Jimi: Natasha Lost.
[1:05:07] Tommy: It's literally called Natasha Lost.
[1:05:10] Jimi: Again, heart another heartbreaking one.
[1:05:13] Tommy: Like at right at the end of the part is like this is how we end things.
[1:05:18] Jimi: She she feels so bad about it too.
[1:05:21] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:05:22] Jimi: Like about what is basically, you know, all subtext removed, a very normal casual conversation with another human being.
[1:05:33] Tommy: Exactly.
[1:05:33] Jimi: There's no like they I don't think they touch like it's oh you're at the opera. I'm at the opera. We're talking.
[1:05:40] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:05:40] Jimi: But is this is those feelings that she has that she's you know, she's like, oh my god, I'm not allowed to feel this.
[1:05:47] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:05:47] Jimi: Um and do you know what that's reasonably topical?
[1:05:50] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:05:51] Jimi: Do you know what I mean? Because well, yeah, just I think even nowadays people still have a weird thing about that.
[1:05:55] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:05:56] Jimi: Where it's like if you're in a long-term relationship, and you know, your partner looks at someone they're attracted to and understands that they're attracted, but then depending on the relationship, can feel very guilty for feeling.
[1:06:12] Tommy: But it's like, no, it's just complet it's completely different.
[1:06:14] Jimi: It's natural and human.
[1:06:16] Tommy: I did I did take a note one of the very first notes I took about this show, Natasha Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812, or hookup culture in 19th century Russia.
[1:06:25] Jimi: Right, exactly.
[1:06:27] Tommy: And the problems they're in.
[1:06:28] Jimi: You're just like, oh Natasha, calm down.
[1:06:31] Tommy: Yep.
[1:06:31] Jimi: But she doesn't know any better.
[1:06:34] Tommy: Oh.
[1:06:34] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:06:35] Tommy: You gotta love her.
[1:06:37] Jimi: And yeah, it wasn't like there was nothing between us.
[1:06:42] Tommy: No offense, no modesty, just his face and strong hands, his glittering eyes and his tender smile.
[1:06:51] Jimi: That gold handsome rest my arm.
[1:07:05] Tommy: So then this is what I love about this show.
[1:07:08] Jimi: Uh-huh.
[1:07:09] Tommy: We're at the opera, which, you know, my first time listening to her, I was like, oh, the opera. That's where young people go to have fun.
[1:07:14] Jimi: Like this is their, this is what they do to like go, you know, this is where you would meet someone you would flirt with.
[1:07:21] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[1:07:21] Jimi: And then the very next thing that happens is they all go out to drink at the club.
[1:07:27] Tommy: And it's it's like a club from 2016.
[1:07:30] Jimi: I mean, like literally, I want to go there.
[1:07:32] Tommy: Absolutely literally.
[1:07:34] Jimi: The you know, we Dolikov isn't uh so who goes out?
[1:07:37] Tommy: Anatole Pierre and Dolikov.
[1:07:39] Jimi: And I think Helen's there's uh Helena or whatever she's called.
[1:07:42] Tommy: Everyone's everyone's going to the club and it's a club.
[1:07:45] Jimi: And there's there's like, you know, it's like gonna drink tonight, uh it's you know, it sounds like a pop song.
[1:07:51] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:07:51] Jimi: And so this is this is this is the first song that's gonna be.
[1:07:56] Tommy: Um and it it explodes into this like hip-hop meets you know, old-fashioned rushing Russian drinking song.
[1:08:06] Jimi: Drink with me, my love!
[1:08:12] Tommy: And the side is song the song!
[1:08:32] Jimi: And then, oh my god, when it goes there, bow bad out, but players are mad.
[1:08:39] Jimi: Like, this is the best musical.
[1:08:41] Tommy: Wait, honestly, this is the moment where I was just I was like, I'm so sold. It's like I wanna go there. I wanna I wanna live that life. I wanna be at this club.
[1:08:52] Jimi: Exactly. I want to give me a single stick. You are there. Like everyone's around, like it's it's you you're there. It's not even a show. The conductor is playing decks. This is the best thing ever. Um you also get to find out a little bit more about the characters. This is where you find out that Anatole is married.
[1:09:12] Tommy: Shh. Yeah. Don't tell anyone. Only only Pierre and Dolokov.
[1:09:17] Jimi: Pierre and Dolokov. Yeah, the close. Dolokov's brother Pierre, his good friend. And you get to find out a wee bit more about Dolokov and his relationship to Anatole, that he's very kind of subservient under Anatole's thumb, and you you suddenly quickly realize that Anatole's the the top here. Um he's kind of got everyone wrapped around his finger in some way.
[1:09:37] Tommy: And everyone's drinking.
[1:09:39] Jimi: Yes.
[1:09:39] Tommy: And drinking and drinking and drinking.
[1:09:41] Jimi: That's not good.
[1:09:41] Tommy: That's not good.
[1:09:42] Jimi: Yeah. Um, because Pierre Bloody gets drunk, doesn't he?
[1:09:46] Tommy: Pierre gets drunk and Helene, his wife, is flirting with Dolokov.
[1:09:51] Jimi: Yeah, that bitch. Which you know, Pierre. Pierre, I think has a sense that his wife is a slut, mostly because she sang it at the beginning of the show.
[1:10:01] Tommy: Yeah, exactly. Like it's it's her, it's her what's the word demonym? Um it's just what she is. Um, but challenges Dolokov to a duel.
[1:10:11] Jimi: Yep.
[1:10:12] Tommy: Which is stupid because Pierre is an old man who is drunk, and Dolokov's descriptor is a very good shot.
[1:10:20] Jimi: Yep.
[1:10:20] Tommy: He's an assassin and he's good at hitting people with a gun. Um and Dave Malloy says he wrote a duel into a musical long before Lin-Manuel Miranda did.
[1:10:31] Jimi: Exactly. Completely. This is how you do it, Jill. No, I'm joking. Um, but I feel like I know more about duels now. Um I'm ready to take it to the comet level. I also wonder, I wonder about if there was any like regional difference in duels. Because they do mention paces later on, and but I think they say 13. And I was like, well, that's not 10. Maybe maybe they have a different number system in Russia.
[1:11:00] Tommy: Yeah. Um yeah, so who knows?
[1:11:04] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:11:04] Tommy: Again, if you know, listeners. Let us know, please. We want to learn all about Russian history.
[1:11:10] Jimi: Absolutely. There is, I do want to point out a great line that Dolokov says, they're all they're um uh toasting to the health of married women.
[1:11:20] Tommy: Yes.
[1:11:20] Jimi: And Dolokov says, here's to the health of married women, and the smile lurks at the corner of my mouth. Here's to the health of married women and their lovers.
[1:11:28] Tommy: Exactly.
[1:11:31] Jimi: Exactly.
[1:11:31] Tommy: And it yeah, exactly. It's perfect. No, and it's taunting, and no wonder he gets driven over the edge, because I would say that so that's annoying. So they duel in the bar, presumably. Surprisingly, no one gets hurt.
[1:11:45] Jimi: They both miss.
[1:11:46] Tommy: They both miss, but it is it is dramatic. It it is surprising that Dolokov misses, it is unsurprising that Pierre misses.
[1:11:53] Jimi: Right.
[1:11:53] Tommy: Um, but it's all very scary, and you know, you're not sure.
[1:11:57] Jimi: Exactly.
[1:11:57] Tommy: Because you're an audience member and you haven't read War and Peace. Um meanwhile, Natasha is still distraught.
[1:12:07] Jimi: Yep.
[1:12:08] Tommy: And classic.
[1:12:10] Jimi: Right. Exactly. Um Sonya things that really like I love the bit. Um I just love the music in it. I mean, I love the music, but there's just little bits in this. I don't know any technical terms, but like goes down a little bit. I don't know what that means. But do you know I mean? Where it's like um travels to Troy, Kabucha, and it just feels lovely.
[1:12:32] Tommy: I I have been critical of pieces of more operatic leaning pieces of musical theater that are sung through things like Rent, things like Les Mis, um, because it often very much sounds like the authors decided it was going to be sung through, and then just made everything a lyric. And when you sing something, it is more important. You know, you you talk until you can't talk anymore, and then you sing, and you sing until you can't sing anymore, and then you dance, and that's how musical theater escalates.
[1:13:02] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:13:03] Tommy: Um, and so if you sing, everything must be more important. And a lot of musicals, in my professional opinion, don't do that well. Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet of 1812 does that very well.
[1:13:14] Jimi: 100%.
[1:13:14] Tommy: Everything is everything is sung. There is there are all there is only one paragraph of lines in this entire show that is not sung, and it is the most moving paragraph of lines. And that's it, it's used effectively, it's used as an actual tool. It's wonderful. Everything that is sung, everything that is repeated is important, and it's great. And this song is no exception. Um, Sunday morning. And it is, it's just it's it's a little kind of odd put in there song, but really beautiful, and it does a lot. It drives the story along. You get to find again more about the characters. Natasha's still trying to figure herself out. Sonya's trying to be as nice as possible to her cousin and like be friendly and help us through, you know, Maria's still being old school. And that's I think you get to see a lot more of Natasha and Sonya's relationship, which is extremely crucial.
[1:14:04] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:14:04] Tommy: Extremely crucial. How close they are and the and the you know, so Sonya, I think is a little more down-to-earth than Natasha.
[1:14:12] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:14:12] Tommy: Um, like I would say that almost physically, like Natasha seems to float in this weird ethereal space in how she thinks about the world, where Sonya is kind and practical.
[1:14:24] Jimi: Yeah, she's just more pragmatic. She's she just kind of gets it. But I think in it's it's it's interesting because it is that idea of like if you took some bits of Natasha, like the passion and the interest, uh-huh, and then you took the you know, pragmatism of Sonya, and you smash them together, you get this wonderful person.
[1:14:40] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:14:40] Jimi: So they compliment each other so well in that way.
[1:14:42] Tommy: Absolutely.
[1:14:44] Jimi: Like all like all cousins should.
[1:14:45] Tommy: Exactly.
[1:14:48] Jimi: After church, Mario left for Prince Bokanski. The rudeness of that man on straight mouth. That terrible old prince. You kiss me. I can't bear to think of it. I'll shut myself in my room and try on new dresses. And just after Mario left, there was a knock at the door. Natasha had just turned her head to the glass when she heard a voice that made her flush.
[1:15:29] Tommy: And then there's a knock at the door. Ba ba ba. Oh my god. And then Helene goes. Sings an amazing song. Um the when when the beat drops, oh how she blushes blushes, how she blushes my pretty.
[1:15:44] Jimi: Yes.
[1:15:44] Tommy: It's I I think this is probably the song at the show that I sing the most.
[1:15:50] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:15:51] Tommy: Just because it feels so good to say. It feels like a pop song. Like a good you know, not in a derogatory way, like a a good contemporary pop song that like you're so excited when it comes on the radio.
[1:16:05] Jimi: Uh-huh.
[1:16:05] Tommy: And it's a few. Like this amazing, like catchy hook.
[1:16:09] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:16:10] Tommy: And this is I you can get to hear Helene's voice, which is amazing and very unlike everyone else.
[1:16:15] Jimi: She's wonderful.
[1:16:16] Tommy: So good. Um, sadly, like one of the very like few moments where you get to really hear it, but thankfully we man, does it shine? Um, and she's come over with not the best of intentions.
[1:16:27] Jimi: No, she has not. She, you know, she this is the world she lives in, and she wants to invite Natasha to the ball to the costume tournament with not the express intention of like setting her up um with Anatole. Like, it's yeah, you can imagine that Anatole has been like, I like her, go get her for me. Do you know what I mean?
[1:16:46] Tommy: Yeah, and she's like, oh, this'll be fun.
[1:16:49] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:16:50] Tommy: Because that's the world she lives in. If you want it, you take it.
[1:16:53] Jimi: Completely.
[1:16:54] Tommy: She also fantastically mispronounces a bunch of French words.
[1:16:59] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:17:01] Tommy: I mean, I've got I I can't talk, but yeah.
[1:17:05] Jimi: Absolutely. I I thought it was correct until this moment.
[1:17:08] Tommy: I only knew it wasn't correct because the internet told me.
[1:17:11] Jimi: Oh, okay.
[1:17:11] Tommy: Um, but it very much adds to her character. She can't speak French. She's Russian. Um I do think it's it and I want to know, again, people out there let us know. Uh I want to know why uh like her and uh Anatole speak French. I mean, Anatole is from France. Not like not like raised in France, but has traveled the world and has been to France. I imagine Helene has too.
[1:17:38] Jimi: I don't know, that's a good question.
[1:17:39] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:17:39] Jimi: I'm sure I'm sure there's a chapter in War and Peace all about it.
[1:17:42] Tommy: Uh huh.
[1:17:43] Jimi: Cause to me it like it gives them this air of like, we know stuff, we speak in a different language.
[1:17:48] Tommy: Exactly.
[1:17:49] Jimi: It gives them a power.
[1:17:50] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.
[1:17:51] Jimi: It's like we're exotic.
[1:17:53] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:17:53] Jimi: I love that they both do it.
[1:17:54] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:17:55] Jimi: Kind of no one else, which gives.
[1:17:56] Tommy: And Helene very much convinces Natasha, like, oh, okay, I can go to this.
[1:18:02] Jimi: Yeah, yeah.
[1:18:03] Tommy: Which way of course I can go out. I can go out. Let's go out. I can go to the costume party. It'll be fine.
[1:18:09] Jimi: Completely. Um, and that's a mistake, isn't it?
[1:18:12] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[1:18:14] ♪ Musical number ♪
[1:18:38] Jimi: Because we close with the ball where Anatole and Natasha dance at the ball and do a little more than dancing, I would say. They get down to it and kiss. And and you know, like, of course. Like, of course. But you then you're like, this is the point where earlier you were like, Oh Natasha, I understand your sadness. And now you're like, no.
[1:19:00] Tommy: You're like, clearly, this is the wrong choice.
[1:19:03] Jimi: I know.
[1:19:04] Tommy: But she she sees his eyes.
[1:19:06] Jimi: Yep.
[1:19:07] Tommy: She sees his lovely hair. And you know, he's saying that thing is as well is he's saying these nice things. Alright, he's saying, I'm in love with you. And she's like, oh, but if you're in love with me, then well, maybe I have to be with you because that's what you do, isn't it? When you're and someone's in love with you, you you be with them.
[1:19:23] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:19:25] Tommy: She's like, well, can I have two people? I don't think I like it. Can I can I love more than one person?
[1:19:29] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:19:30] Tommy: Um, and so she's like, she literally she ends well just about just literally being like, I've I've I've got nothing to say. Like, I have no idea.
[1:19:41] Jimi: Yep.
[1:19:41] Tommy: Well, and after she has nothing to say, they kiss. And as and you can tell it's it's not like a nice thing because A, the music is like, burda, and um she's like saying, You're hurting me. But it it is still, you know, she still has a lot of like I I can't love you. If I kissed you, I must have loved you.
[1:20:02] Jimi: Exactly.
[1:20:03] Tommy: She's she's real really torn about Anatole and Andre. Enough so that like you're gonna come back after intermission to hear what happens.
[1:20:11] Jimi: Exactly. Natasha.
[1:20:15] Tommy: Oh, poor Natasha.
[1:20:16] Jimi: Poor Natasha.
[1:20:19] ♪ Musical number ♪
[1:22:08] Jimi: So here we're at the interval. I feel we should digress because we're at the interval. I mean, I imagine most people uh during intermission at the show do shots of vodka because that seems to be the thing to do.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
