Discuss on Reddit ➤ Support the Show ➤ Good morning! Unpack your raincoats and dust off your tap shoes as it’s time to celebrate the greatest movie musical of all time - Singin’ in the Rain!.. Read More
From the show: Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour
About
Good morning! Unpack your raincoats and dust off your tap shoes as it’s time to celebrate the greatest movie musical of all time - Singin’ in the Rain! We chat all about directorial tyranny, metatheatrical dubbing and Hollywood’s biggest drag queen of all time - Gene Kelly!
Singin' In The Rain (Original Film Soundtrack)
SHOW NOTES
She battled through the tyranny of Gene Kelly’s directorial reign and gave birth to the exquisite Carrie Fisher. Check out this amazing interview from Debbie Reynold’s daughter!
Check out Hollywood’s most beautiful Drag Queen of all time - Gene Kelly, beat for the gods!
This movie contains some of the greatest tap dancing routines ever! Check out ‘Fit as a Fiddle’ at the movie’s opening for a little taste. Oh, and movie producers - bring tap back!
Which Beautiful Girl are you? Jimi is naturally number 2 as his cloak is ALWAYS trimmed with monkey fur to lend a dash of drama, Tommy is number 4; always dripping with fringe.
Shout to our dearly departed Queen of Dubbing - Marni Nixon! Check out this great interview on NPR. Then have a listen to the magic she can do in this clip of My Fair Lady. Compare Audrey Hepburn’s singing voice with Marni Nixon’s - thank goodness for you, Ms. Nixon!
Have a listen to Cole Porter’s ‘Be a Clown’ from The Pirate. Sound familiar?
Check out an amazing documentary series on homosexuality in musical theatre by “some guy”. What do you think, is Cosmo Brown a coded gay character?
Have a look at the incredible design from Théâtre du Châtelet’s production coming to Broadway…at some point!
A POLITICAL QUIZ QUESTION…
The source material for this musical was quite controversial and talks of censorship made it into the American political discourse. In one censorship hearing, a politician criticized the censorship attempt saying: “Are we going to start attacking ABC for Scandal? I mean where does this stop?”
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Tommy: Speaking of minor movie roles, did you know Rita Moreno's in Singin' in the Rain?
[0:07] Jimi: Where's she in Singin' in the Rain?
[0:09] Tommy: She plays Zelda, who I think has like two lines.
[0:13] Jimi: Oh, yeah, Evil Zelda.
[0:14] Tommy: Evil Zelda.
[0:15] Jimi: Evil Zelda.
[0:17] Tommy: That's Rita Moreno.
[0:18] Jimi: There you go.
[0:19] Tommy: Everyone, were you in it?
[0:21] Jimi: I was.
[0:21] Jimi: I was in Singin' in the Rain. I played the plant that Lena Lamont can't make love to.
[0:26] Tommy: Ah.
[0:27] Jimi: I played the dummy that Donald O'Connor dances with and makes him laugh.
[0:31] Tommy: Well, somebody get us another drink.
[0:34] Tommy: Welcome to Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour.
[0:37] Tommy: I am Tommy.
[0:38] Jimi: I am Jimi.
[0:40] Tommy: And we are your weekly podcast with show tunes and spirits.
[0:49] Jimi: And I don't know if anyone knows that yet, so I am drinking Iron Brew.
[0:53] Tommy: Ooh.
[0:54] Jimi: I've got a, I've got, uh, what is this?
[0:57] Jimi: An extrovert American IPA.
[1:00] Tommy: Because I'm American.
[1:02] Jimi: You are.
[1:04] Tommy: But you're drinking an India Pale Ale.
[1:07] Jimi: Mixed signals, Tommy.
[1:09] Tommy: From America.
[1:10] Jimi: That's true.
[1:11] Jimi: It's an American India Pale Ale.
[1:15] Tommy: But nothing to do with American Indians.
[1:17] Jimi: Exactly.
[1:18] Jimi: Our quiz question from last time was very well thought out.
[1:23] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:24] Jimi: It's probably our best.
[1:26] Tommy: I think so.
[1:27] Jimi: I think so.
[1:28] Jimi: It definitely took us the longest, but for maybe different reasons.
[1:32] Tommy: In case you missed it, it was what musical's title song's first lyric goes like this when poorly translated.
[1:39] Jimi: Quote, condone violence in the cloud from any location monitoring.
[1:45] Tommy: Surely that's the Steven Sondheim's something.
[1:48] Jimi: No, Jimmy, with that caliber of rain.
[1:51] Tommy: No, it's Singin' in the Rain.
[3:40] Jimi: Singin' in the Rain.
[3:40] Tommy: Just Singin' in the Rain.
[3:40] Jimi: What a glorious view, and we're happy again.
[3:40] Tommy: We're walkin' down the lane.
[3:40] Jimi: Oh, Singin' in the Rain. I love that show.
[3:40] Tommy: When did you first see this show?
[3:40] Jimi: This movie, I guess.
[3:40] Jimi: Probably later than I should. It was two of my best friends, Casey and Martin, who, and I wed, though it's Martin's favorite of all time.
[3:40] Tommy: Yeah.
[3:40] Jimi: And they showed me it in what, let's say like 2009, 2008.
[3:40] Tommy: Holy crap.
[3:40] Jimi: I know, that's late, isn't it?
[3:40] Tommy: I mean, I think I saw this movie when I was five.
[3:40] Jimi: Wow.
[3:40] Jimi: Yeah, this might be one of my earliest musicals I ever witnessed and took part of.
[3:40] Tommy: Oh, well, there you go.
[3:40] Tommy: And were you like instantly hooked?
[3:40] Jimi: I mean, yes and no. I have a love-hate relationship with Singin' in the Rain.
[3:40] Jimi: Mostly love.
[3:40] Tommy: Okay.
[3:40] Tommy: Mostly love.
[3:40] Tommy: I mean, so what? Would you call this the greatest movie musical?
[3:40] Jimi: I'd say it's up there. I really, really would.
[3:40] Jimi: I mean, it literally tops the lists like AFI's 100 greatest musicals and things like that.
[3:40] Tommy: Yeah.
[3:40] Jimi: It's number one. I think of its time, and by that I don't mean like, oh, it was only good then.
[3:40] Tommy: Right.
[3:40] Jimi: But I mean of that era of movie musicals, the MGM musicals, I think it is the best.
[3:40] Tommy: It's certainly the most iconic.
[3:40] Jimi: Easily.
[3:40] Jimi: And everyone knows Singin' in the Rain.
[3:40] Tommy: Yeah, I literally know Singin' in the Rain. Every single person knows that.
[3:40] Jimi: For the two people out there who feel really lonely and who haven't seen Singin' in the Rain, what is this show about? The basic premise is it takes place in a time when silent movies were going out and the talkies, as they're called, are this new revolutionary picture idea. They're taking the movie industry by storm. This is a demonstration of a talking picture. Notice it is a picture of me and I am talking. We have kind of a massive famous actor called Don Lockwood, played by Gene Kelly, who basically discovers this beautiful kind of ingenue, wonderful dancer called Kathy Selden, who's been kind of doing the vaudeville circuit but wants to be a proper actress. So he kind of takes her under his wing and nurtures her whilst trying to combat with all of these new talking pictures alongside his fellow leading lady, Lena Lamont, who has the unfortunate affliction of an awful voice, which an actress in the early talkie movie age is not a good thing.
[4:55] Tommy: It's not good, exactly. And then alongside them, we've got Donald O'Connor just making us all happy.
[4:55] Jimi: And Donald O'Connor is there too, yeah, pretty much second banana best friend, and maybe we'll talk more about him later. I have some theories about Cosmo Brown.
[4:55] Tommy: What could they be? Dun dun dun!
[4:55] Jimi: So this movie musical is based on reality in a lot of ways, I would say.
[5:23] Tommy: Which is interesting for musical comedy.
[5:24] Jimi: Yeah, definitely, because especially of that era, it was all kind of not fantasy. Like, we're not talking in space, but it was like hyper romantic or, you know, it's happening over out in the cornfields or the sea or whatever.
[5:39] Tommy: Right.
[5:39] Jimi: Whereas this is just, you know, LA.
[5:41] Tommy: Yeah, it's LA, it's Hollywood in the twenties. They talk about The Jazz Singer and other, you know, talkies of the time.
[5:48] Tommy: Yep.
[5:48] Jimi: There's a whole montage with like actual references to actual early twenties and thirties and forties movies. Watching it, I actually learned a lot, which I never expect to do from early musical comedy.
[6:01] Jimi: Yeah, because I don't really know, you know, the transition and or just how, I guess, what it took to be a silent film actor as opposed to a non-silent talking film actor.
[6:13] Tommy: Yeah.
[6:14] Jimi: And you never really think like, oh, there is a huge distinct difference there.
[6:18] Tommy: Yeah.
[6:18] Jimi: And it's a shame because, you know, people like Lena Lamont, she'd be out of a job.
[6:23] Tommy: It's very inside Hollywood in a lot of ways. You know, it's definitely elevated, and I don't—there is certainly some suspension of disbelief in the same way that like, you know, who can sit down at a piano and just write out a song. But I think one of the things that attracted me a lot to it at a very young age and like why it fits in in my canon very well is it's about a lot of—it's about technical theater too.
[6:44] Tommy: Yeah.
[6:45] Jimi: Like figuring out the technology of the talkie and like how the whole hiding the microphone scene and like—
[6:45] Tommy: That is an amazing scene.
[6:53] Jimi: So funny.
[6:53] Jimi: You're right. It makes you realize that, hey, there's all of this backstage work going on.
[6:58] Tommy: Yeah.
[6:58] Jimi: Man, Condon and Green's screenplay for this thing is really funny.
[7:05] Jimi: It's genuinely funny. It's not like, oh, again, funny for the time.
[7:09] Tommy: Right.
[7:10] Jimi: But it is like nowadays it's still really funny. Their characters are great.
[7:15] Tommy: And just the number of one-liners. Like, there's one point where when Cosmo and Don find Kathy again, and she previously, you know, last time they met her, she burst out of a cake, and Cosmo says, "I'm glad you turned up. We've been looking inside every cake in town."
[7:30] Tommy: Yeah.
[7:31] Jimi: That's great. Well done, Condon and Green.
[7:48] Tommy: We should talk about the Freed Unit.
[7:50] Jimi: So this is a classic movie from Arthur Freed's studio unit at MGM?
[7:57] Tommy: Yeah, it kind of—he, I think he came on, he started off as like, well, not from the bottom, but like middling, and then just ended up just taking over.
[8:06] Jimi: And I think he was just—it became the chief studio exec. It was still MGM, but the Freed Unit was his posse.
[8:16] Tommy: They produced a bunch of movie musicals you heard about. Like he was an associate producer on The Wizard of Oz. Out of his unit came Gigi and On the Town, and An American in Paris, and Meet Me in St. Louis, like all sorts of those classic movie musicals, and then Singin' in the Rain, the classic movie musical.
[8:32] Jimi: Yeah, and they're all like—I think from that list as well, they're such high quality. I think that's what's really noticeable. Like I could still watch each of those today and love them.
[8:43] Tommy: And that's very impressive.
[8:45] Jimi: Did you know, Jimmy? It is all of Arthur Freed's music in Singin' in the Rain.
[8:51] Jimi: I did know that.
[8:53] Tommy: Shocker.
[8:55] Jimi: But yeah, these songs weren't written for Singin' in the Rain. It wasn't like, "Oh, I've got this great idea about the transition between silent films into talking films. I'm gonna go write all this music." All the music was there.
[9:09] Tommy: Who was the other guy?
[9:10] Jimi: Um, Nasio or Nassio? Herb Brown.
[9:14] Tommy: I think—I assume it's a household name.
[9:15] Jimi: Household name.
[9:16] Tommy: Yeah.
[9:16] Jimi: One of my faves. Good old NHB.
[9:19] Jimi: I assume it's like Ignacio.
[9:21] Tommy: Okay, well, apologies out there.
[9:24] Jimi: Yeah.
[9:25] Jimi: But so it's all their songs, and they threw them together. They asked Condon and Green to like write a show around those songs.
[9:33] Tommy: Which I think if you think of the songs, you know, well done, Condon and Green.
[9:39] Jimi: Yeah, they did a fabulous job. There's nothing linking them.
[9:43] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?
[9:44] Jimi: Would you qualify this as a jukebox musical?
[9:47] Tommy: I refer to this as a jukebox musical from time to time.
[9:50] Jimi: Yeah. I mean, I'd say in a sense, yes, because it's obviously come from a collection of songs by one artist that haven't been written for the show. But I would say that it's not in the form of jukebox musical that we know at the moment, where it's like taking popular songs, do you know what I mean? Like popularized songs and sticking them in. So I would be reluctant to call it a jukebox.
[10:13] Jimi: I think it's—and I think as well, because at that period of time, you know, I mean, you had people like Cole Porter, you had people like the Gershwins, who were doing the exact same thing. And I don't think you'd ever call them a jukebox musical.
[10:25] Tommy: So that's true.
[10:26] Jimi: Maybe it's even—I wonder comparatively, perhaps, because like a lot of the songs are very well incorporated in the plot, like "Good Morning."
[10:33] Tommy: Yeah.
[10:33] Jimi: I would say almost every song except like "Beautiful Girl" and the songs in the montages have some kind of plot serving.
[10:43] Tommy: Oh, and the Broadway rhythm, which we'll get to.
[10:49] Jimi: But most of the rest of them are well incorporated into the text and seem useful.
[10:56] Tommy: And they do, they all make sense.
[10:57] Jimi: They absolutely all make sense.
[10:59] Tommy: As the title of the show, um, say, a shout out to Condon and Green.
[10:59] Jimi: Shout out to Condon and Green. They've written so, so many wonderful things.
[11:07] Tommy: They've just written all of the best things.
[11:09] Jimi: Peter Pan, On the 20th Century, Bells Are Ringing, uh, you have to give a master check because again, the book for On the Town is so good.
[11:20] Tommy: So good. I love On the Town.
[11:22] Jimi: Anyway, we're not talking about On the Town.
[11:24] Tommy: And Applause, which is getting applause nowadays, and it's revived.
[11:29] Jimi: It's fabulous.
[11:30] Jimi: Yeah, they're a talented pair.
[11:32] Tommy: And what isn't it just nice that they're just two friends, two platonic friends?
[11:36] Jimi: Yes, yeah.
[11:37] Jimi: The story goes that I've been wading through the IMDb trivia for Singin' in the Rain and a bunch of other locations. And I think more than any other movie, I have found like, you know, you find those facts where you're like, "I don't think that's real. I think someone made that up at some point, and now we've decided that's trivia."
[11:55] Tommy: Okay.
[11:55] Jimi: I have found more of those facts for Singin' in the Rain than I think I have for any other thing I've ever researched.
[12:02] Tommy: I wonder why that is. Do you think it's just because it is so notorious?
[12:05] Jimi: It's so popular, it's so notorious, people like to talk about it a lot. I mean, one of the ones that I read that I believe was that Comden and Green moved into a almost foreclosed silent movie star's mansion to write the screenplay, and that like the old silent movie star had lost their job because they didn't have a good voice, and it helped them get in the mood of the era.
[12:30] Tommy: So did they like discover secret diaries by the silent movie star about how they speak in a very, very broad Jersey accent or whatever?
[12:39] Jimi: I don't know.
[12:40] Tommy: Well, you—I can imagine Comden and Green sitting around their dining room table eating their milk and sandwiches at one in the morning and thinking like, "How are we gonna get 'Good Morning' into this picture?"
[12:50] Jimi: Wait, I got it.
[12:51] Jimi: And then you know, and then they check the time.
[12:54] Tommy: Yeah, that makes perfect sense.
[12:55] Jimi: And they were great tap dancers.
[12:59] Tommy: That may or may not be true.
[13:01] Jimi: Good morning, good morning.
[13:04] Tommy: We've talked the whole night through.
[13:06] Jimi: Good morning, good morning to you.
[13:10] Tommy: Good morning, good morning.
[13:13] Jimi: It's great to stay up late.
[13:15] Tommy: Good morning.
[13:16] Jimi: Good morning to you.
[13:19] Tommy: When the man began to play, the stars were shining bright.
[13:24] Jimi: Now the milkman's on his way.
[13:26] Tommy: It's too late to say goodnight.
[13:28] Jimi: So good morning.
[13:29] Tommy: One trivia fact that I have seen confirmed on several occasions, and that very much colors my opinion of this movie is Gene Kelly's treatment of Debbie Reynolds throughout the.
[13:44] Jimi: So I'm like, I'm like, I'm kinda in it.
[13:47] Tommy: I'm I don't mind.
[13:49] Jimi: Really?
[13:50] Tommy: Uh I think he's such a sleep.
[13:52] Jimi: Well, no, he wasn't like sexual with her.
[13:55] Tommy: Is that what you're talking about?
[13:56] Jimi: No, he was just mean.
[13:58] Tommy: Yeah, he was mean, but he was mean to anyone who wasn't good.
[14:03] Jimi: And I think his feelings I liked, well, the way I like to think about it.
[14:07] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[14:07] Jimi: Is that he was mean because he knew how good she was. Like he wouldn't have let her in the show in the film.
[14:14] Tommy: He was a co-director, right?
[14:16] Jimi: Yeah, exactly. And he I maybe even like an exec, I don't know.
[14:20] Tommy: Yeah.
[14:20] Jimi: But he wouldn't he wouldn't have let her in if she couldn't pull up the goods. Do you know what I mean?
[14:26] Tommy: But you just hate it.
[14:28] Jimi: I really struggle with directoral abuse of actors.
[14:34] Tommy: I really, really struggle with that.
[14:36] Jimi: And even I struggle with it when like directors will justify it by saying, Well, you're supposed to feel hurt in this scene, or you're supposed to be sad.
[14:45] Tommy: But this is Evan singing in the rain. Like you know, happy tap dance, smile, they're supposed to be in love, and the director is out there telling you that your tap dance isn't good enough, and you know, you're crying under a piano.
[15:00] Jimi: So the story goes.
[15:01] Tommy: Well, yeah, I mean, uh when I direct, I'm not like that. I'm lovely. I'm really, really lovely.
[15:05] Jimi: But it it g it got the goods.
[15:10] Tommy: That's true. Although I did hear that she had to have a meeting with Fred Astaire.
[15:14] Jimi: That is the other trivia, is that Fred Astaire found her crying under a piano.
[15:17] Tommy: Under a table.
[15:18] Jimi: I heard table, but yeah, piano, we'll go with that.
[15:20] Tommy: See, these are yeah. Who knows? But apparently he was equally drilling and he was just like, no, this is just the way it is.
[15:26] Jimi: And admittedly, that is kind of true. When you're when you're tap dancing, it's not easy.
[15:30] Tommy: Well, and that's even just how the studio culture was in the 40s and 50s. Very rigorous. You have to churn out these movies so fast.
[15:40] Jimi: Um, and you know, you have to do it right.
[15:40] Tommy: And I don't I mean, I don't doubt that there's some element of misogyny in there.
[15:48] Jimi: Oh, I'm sure.
[15:49] Tommy: Oh, I'm sure there's a large element of misogyny in there.
[15:52] Jimi: It is the 50s, Hollywood or not.
[15:55] Tommy: Like, yeah, exactly. So that's I don't agree with that.
[16:00] Jimi: But I don't care. I just I'm in love with Gene Kelly.
[16:03] Tommy: So Debbie Reynolds called this one of the two most difficult things she's ever done.
[16:08] Jimi: Yeah. You know what the other was?
[16:11] Tommy: Childbirth.
[16:12] Jimi: Childbirth. Well, tap dancing and childbirth. What more do you want in life, right?
[16:17] Tommy: And you know, for what it's worth, the child was Carrie Fisher.
[16:23] Jimi: So have you seen like things of Carrie Fisher now?
[16:27] Tommy: Have I seen things of Carrie Fisher now?
[16:29] Jimi: Yeah, like as in like interviews or things like that.
[16:32] Tommy: Like her in Star Wars?
[16:34] Jimi: I saw her in Star Wars.
[16:35] Tommy: Yeah, but did you see like interviews with her?
[16:38] Jimi: No, why?
[16:39] Tommy: She's crazy.
[16:40] Jimi: She's gone.
[16:41] Tommy: She is crazy.
[16:41] Jimi: She's she's still crazy.
[16:43] Tommy: She's come back down though.
[16:44] Jimi: She's always the dog she always carries with her is her therapy dog.
[16:47] Tommy: Well, that's it. Like it's it, but she's crazy and agree. I'm not saying like, oh my god, I'm terrified by Carrie Fisher.
[16:53] Jimi: Like her interviews are golden because of how I don't know, she's just living in another world.
[16:59] Tommy: It's hilarious. It's really good fun.
[17:01] Jimi: I gotta watch some Carrie Fisher interviews.
[17:03] Tommy: Yeah, exactly. There's I'll send you some good ones.
[17:06] Jimi: Send you some good ones in particular in Faith.
[17:09] Tommy: But they're always always a treat.
[17:10] Jimi: Life was a song. You came along.
[17:16] Tommy: I've laid away so whole life so if I did thank you, Kid.
[17:29] Jimi: This is what I say to you.
[17:39] Tommy: You meant for me.
[17:53] Jimi: So yeah, he wasn't the nicest. And I think that's something that you hear about him all the time.
[17:58] Tommy: Because even with you know his relationship with Fred Astaire, you know, obviously they had literally virtually the same career and were direct rivals, I guess.
[18:07] Jimi: And and they just didn't get on.
[18:09] Tommy: But you know, it takes all types.
[18:11] Jimi: Exactly. And he's still still really beautiful.
[18:14] Tommy: That's why I like Fred Astaire more.
[18:16] Jimi: And we will agree to disagree.
[18:18] Tommy: Do you think Fred Astaire is beautiful?
[18:20] Jimi: Uh I think Fred Astaire is classy.
[18:24] Tommy: Okay.
[18:24] Jimi: I don't think I don't know. I think Gene Kelly is sexy.
[18:28] Tommy: I don't think Gene Kelly's sexy.
[18:30] Jimi: No, he is.
[18:34] Tommy: Have you been reconvinced about his sex appeal after seeing the HD?
[18:38] Jimi: Oh my god, right. Okay revisions to singing in the rain. Let me break this down.
[18:43] Tommy: Okay.
[18:43] Jimi: So I have I have like an old DVD of it. Um which is all so it didn't look good. And I was like, okay, I'm gonna.
[18:50] Tommy: So I went on iTunes and I downloaded it all very legally, which is good. I've got the receipts.
[18:55] Jimi: Good for you, claps for you.
[18:56] Tommy: And it was an HD, and I couldn't really believe it. I was like, oh my god, they've remastered singing in the rain. How great.
[19:03] Jimi: And it starts off so well, and then like the first thing you see is this massive close-up of Gene Kelly.
[19:09] Tommy: Um, and the eyeliner, an eyeshadow is just it's on fleek, I think the kids say.
[19:18] Jimi: He is ready to hit the runway on the next season of RuPaul's Drag Race.
[19:23] Tommy: Uh season nine, starring Gene Kelly.
[19:26] Jimi: Like, it's it's very well done. But I was like, that I've never noticed that before.
[19:31] Tommy: And you wouldn't ever notice that before. You know, on like your potato filter cameras, but now we're in the land of HD, and I'm like, God.
[19:39] Jimi: Man. And I did I I'm not gonna lie, it did halt my sexiness feeling of Gene Kelly. But it's fine, because I just went on YouTube and everything was blurry again and all was well.
[19:50] Tommy: You just squint when you watch movies now.
[19:52] Jimi: That's that's that key.
[19:54] Tommy: Exactly. But tell Debbie Reynolds looked great.
[19:57] Jimi: Oh she isn't she like 18 when this movie happened.
[20:00] Tommy: I think she's very young.
[20:02] Jimi: Something like that. She's so beautiful.
[20:04] Tommy: Beautiful girl.
[20:06] Jimi: You're a lovely picture, beautiful girl.
[20:10] Tommy: You're a gorgeous mixture of all and lies under the big blue sky.
[20:17] Jimi: My heart cries, beautiful girl.
[20:21] Tommy: You're a dazzling eye for beautiful girl.
[20:25] Jimi: I could never trifle if I had you. You would be my dream come true.
[20:32] Tommy: Do you wanna let's talk about the choreography?
[20:34] Jimi: Let's do it. I think more than anything, this movie shines for its choreography.
[20:39] Tommy: Do you mean in particular to this movie, or do you mean this movie shines this movie's choreography shines brighter than I think the element in this movie that shines the most, maybe above the screenplay, is its choreography.
[20:53] Jimi: Yeah, okay. It is definitely the most the most iconic parts of this movie are related to its choreography.
[20:59] Tommy: To dance.
[21:00] Jimi: Yeah, I would agree. I would agree.
[21:01] Tommy: First of all, let's just get this out.
[21:03] Jimi: Uh huh.
[21:04] Tommy: I need another tap movie.
[21:07] Jimi: Yeah. Like, I miss it. I miss tap so much.
[21:11] Tommy: Oh man. I i I I I don't even know. It just it fills me with glee and joy and excitement.
[21:17] Jimi: It's so incredible. And like I I only have a casual passing knowledge with tap, but I was watching it more particularly this last watch through, and I noticed like in good morning, there's a part where they're about to walk up the stairs, and they do like a quick little side time step before they start walking.
[21:37] Tommy: It takes like a half of a second, but it's like seven or eight taps, and it's so fast and so unnecessary. Their backs are turned to you, like it doesn't it it is not the focus of the moment, but like just those little flourishes in this movie, yeah, it makes the whole thing.
[21:54] Jimi: Yeah, like the that is it, like the tiniest little flap will just add that extra beat of joy into your brain.
[22:00] Tommy: It's so good. It's so good.
[22:01] Jimi: And I think what I love as well is um obviously one of the first ones that you see, uh Fit as a Fiddle.
[22:07] Tommy: Yeah.
[22:07] Jimi: That uh blows my mind. When they do like the little, I don't know, crossfit.
[22:12] Tommy: Yeah, the like the like square thing.
[22:16] Jimi: Yeah, yeah, yeah. Whilst whilst playing a fiddle, you're like, how are you moving? How are you not tripping over yourself? Like holy cow just so impressive.
[22:26] Tommy: Moses supposes, like I can't hear Moses without hearing the tap rhythm in my head.
[22:32] Jimi: And remind me to get into that later about cast recordings.
[22:37] Tommy: It's that's one of the things I notice with these cast recordings. I enjoy the there are like the movie one will dub in the taps back in, but some of the Broadway one of the other um uh like West End performances have no tap sound in it, and it just sounds empty.
[22:50] Jimi: It's like music written. Infuriating.
[22:53] Tommy: Yeah. Exactly. It infuriates me.
[22:54] Jimi: I'm like, it's not it's not hard to do.
[22:57] Tommy: No, you literally like just stick a mic near the floor.
[23:00] Jimi: Exactly. Like it sounds great. It it absolutely infuriates me because the these songs are kind of nothing without the tap.
[23:09] Tommy: The um dance break has been scored with tap in mind.
[23:14] Jimi: And you're right, it sounds so empty because you've lost this huge vital percussive element.
[23:20] Tommy: And I don't know why. I think what is it, the Broadway?
[23:24] Jimi: The original Broadway.
[23:26] Tommy: There's a bunch of the the cast recording landscape of this show is difficult to untangle. There's a bunch of studio recordings, there's a bunch of overseas productions that like don't qualify themselves well.
[23:40] Jimi: It's don't I mean, I would my recommendation to people would be don't listen to anything but the movie version.
[23:46] Tommy: Except for maybe a couple key songs that were added to the stage productions.
[23:50] Jimi: Yeah, exactly. But they're not just different. It's not worth listening to in their entirety.
[23:54] Tommy: Not at all.
[23:55] Jimi: The movie is it it made it.
[23:56] Tommy: It's iconic.
[23:57] Jimi: Roses are roses, the roses, the roses, the roses, when roses and hose and poses.
[24:03] Tommy: Couldn't be a lily or a tappy tapping delay.
[24:06] Jimi: It's gotta be a rose, cause it rhymes with most.
[24:29] Tommy: I guess we should probably say that, that we're gonna refer a lot to the movie this time as opposed to the Broadway show, because I mean it was a it's better.
[24:37] Jimi: It was a it was a movie musical long before it was ever a stage musical.
[24:41] Tommy: Yeah, exactly. It's one of those weird backwards interpretations of I don't think a lot of musicals take this journey.
[24:48] Jimi: And I think that speaks to how popular this movie musical was. I don't think a lot of other movie musicals have such at least as successful stage adaptations.
[24:59] Tommy: Well, I mean, the only one that I can think of is like American in Paris really recently.
[25:04] Jimi: Yeah, American in Paris and Wizard of the kind of but even then it's not.
[25:09] Tommy: Even then, yeah.
[25:10] Jimi: No, and like the stage versions of Singing in the Rain do their very best to just try and recreate the movie on stage.
[25:16] Tommy: I mean, literally scene per scene.
[25:18] Jimi: Yeah, exactly. A couple songs here and there to cover transitions, but that's it.
[25:23] Tommy: The the songs to listen to, by the way, to wrap that tie up, there's a they give Lena a couple songs in the stage versions.
[25:31] Jimi: Yeah.
[25:31] Tommy: That are, you know, it's weird to hear her sing.
[25:35] Jimi: I think it's interesting to listen to him. She has one that's called What's Wrong with Me, which is certainly very funny.
[25:40] Tommy: But also just really difficult to listen to, and I mean that in a physical way.
[25:44] Tommy: Yeah. Like it's n it goes beyond Adelaide. Like it is it's Lena Lamont. You know what I mean? She does not let up and it's painful. But I suppose that's what it should be, you know. It's not when you're gonna stick on in the background to chill out and listen to Gash Gording. But I'm sure it in the moment of the show, it's kind of funny. I don't understand. What's wrong with me? Why doesn't he kiss me? He has a chance for a romance. What's wrong with me? What's wrong with me? Hal, um, I don't thrill. He doesn't feel my sex appeal. What's wrong with me? Shall we talk about uh broad wait, where the you gotta just tell me tell me straight out. Do you like this number?
[26:45] Jimi: No!
[26:46] Tommy: Okay, good. No, no, no. The first time I saw the movie, uh I like I don't know whether I like went to the toilet or something. I came back and we're in the middle of this. I was like, No. So I because I knew it was coming. I timed like the introductory scene to get into this. Cause they're watching they're watching Rushes of the Dubs. They're like watching uh Debbie Reynolds' voice under Lena, and then Don is like, we're gonna we're gonna put a new we gotta throw a modern number into the picture. So he's a hoofer going to Broadway, and it's like a 45 second scene to like introduce Oh hey, by the way, this thing's about to happen, and then all of a sudden it's Gene Kelly singing at the camera in like a technicolor vomit of dance. And uh for about like it feels like half an hour. I mean it's not. I mean it must well it must be about 10 minutes though, at least 15 minutes. It bothers me so much, Jimmy.
[27:46] Jimi: Yeah, completely. Like it doesn't have anything to do with the movie.
[27:51] Tommy: No, doesn't that anything to do with the in-movie movie? No is literally just a chance for Gene Kelly and that one sexy lady to show off.
[28:03] Jimi: Sid Sharice, you she is the best part of that number, and don't call her that one sexy lady.
[28:10] Tommy: Wait, it's not Sicharice, is it?
[28:12] Jimi: It's Sid Sharice.
[28:13] Tommy: That's Sid Charisse.
[28:15] Jimi: Is that actually?
[28:16] Tommy: Yeah.
[28:20] Jimi: I hadn't realized that.
[28:24] Tommy: That one sexy lady. I just thought it was like token brunette.
[28:30] Jimi: Sid Charisse. That no. That's good. That makes me a bit happier. She's the best part of that number. Like, if it's I mean, she really is. If it's an excuse to get Sid Sharice involved in the show.
[28:42] Tommy: Yeah. Fine. Wow. Yep, that's her.
[28:46] Jimi: Am I blowing your mind now?
[28:48] Tommy: Yeah, I'll need to rewatch it with closer watching, as opposed to just to be like, what's happening?
[28:54] Jimi: Yeah. And just every now and then just singing, gotta dad. And then this weird way with the version of what is that? The the like chorus choreography with like the shoulders and the jazz hands.
[29:10] Tommy: Yeah. Like, if you look at them, they all know how stupid it is.
[29:14] Jimi: Yeah. It's so, but I'm just, yeah, Gene Kelly must just have been like, listen, you guys, everyone else is doing really well in this movie. I need a moment where it's just me.
[29:24] Tommy: Yeah. Okay. It's like, you know, I know I just had a solo dance number, like a couple songs ago, and it was the title number, but I think we could give me another one.
[29:35] Jimi: Yeah, exactly. And so they did that. And I just. And it's not even like it's fine dancing, it's Gene Kelly, of course he does it well, but it's not it's nothing spectacular.
[29:47] Tommy: Yeah, it's very high quality, and it's good. And I think like all it does is it just dates the movie.
[29:53] Jimi: Yeah. Because that, I mean, there was loads of that, like nonsense tacked on guff. That and the the beautiful girl fashion show are very like.
[30:02] Tommy: I I love that though, because that's camp as.
[30:05] Jimi: That is so calm.
[30:06] Tommy: It's camp and fun and not necessary.
[30:09] Jimi: Oh, it's completely unnecessary.
[30:12] Tommy: Completely. That is so that is oh my god. Those women. I want to be one of those women. I don't know which one I would choose to be.
[30:21] Jimi: Monkey's fur and some bit of drama. Uh it's it is that is high drag right there. We'll we'll do look for it in your mailboxes soon. The gym and Tomic calendar, where uh Jimmy and I pose as each of the girls in the beautiful girl segment and sing it in the rain.
[30:41] Tommy: I mean, if we ever get desperate for merch, we know what's coming.
[30:44] Jimi: We know what's happening. And the song's it's sweet. The song's sweet, it's catchy, it's chopping a stick. It's it's it's a little creepy. You have the lips that were meant to be kissed, and you're over sweet 16. That's still a little young.
[31:00] Tommy: That's makes makes me uncomfortable.
[31:03] Jimi: Rightway, rhythm, it's got me, everybody death. Broadway, rhythm, it's got me, everybody death. Hold on and gay wide way in each very cafe or casters play. Take it your breath away.
[31:30] Tommy: Can we talk about voice dubbing? That's the plot of the show, isn't it? It's just my favorite thing in the world is like the actual voice dubbing that happened in this movie about voice dubbing. Do you know about this?
[31:40] Jimi: No, I didn't.
[31:41] Tommy: All or at least most of Debbie Reynolds' singing voice was dubbed. Which is funny, because she is the actress who supposedly is brought in to dub Lena Lamont in everything else. But so when you hear her singing in like Good Morning and a couple other numbers, it's what's her name? Betty Noyes' voice. But in some parts where Debbie Reynolds is quote-unquote dubbing Gene Hagen, Lena Lamont, it's actually Gene Hagen's real, not Lena Lamont voice. And then Debbie Reynolds is just lip syncing syncing.
[32:19] Jimi: Yeah. Like this that blows our mind. Because now you have to sit and you have to think, okay. What were the execs thinking?
[32:27] Tommy: Yeah.
[32:27] Jimi: Like, I know what we'll do. We'll cast her. She can't sing, but that's okay. But she needs to sing for this person. We'll get someone else who can sing for her. She can sing, but she's not allowed to sing, so we need to make sure that she can't sing. Uh but sh we'll get her to sing it more. Like, what the hell? Imagine that bored me thing.
[32:41] Tommy: It's it's no more ridiculous than autotune.
[32:44] Jimi: It's like a 50s version of autotune.
[32:46] Tommy: I guess. I mean, no, it's not. Wait, what? It's like in contemporary movie musicals, every actor has some digital enhancement. Even in a lot of live shows, they have, you know, backstage auto-tuning or dubbing voices.
[33:03] Jimi: Well, the difference for this is that these women were never credited.
[33:07] Tommy: That's true. You don't know any of this.
[33:09] Jimi: That's true. And it's a lot of it's still hearsay too.
[33:12] Tommy: Exactly, yeah, completely. Um, because I like you say, I had never heard about Miss What's her name?
[33:16] Jimi: Betty Noyes.
[33:17] Tommy: Betty Noyes, who makes a lot of noise. I guess like the most famous one, and let's tip her hats to the now dearly departed Marni Nixon. Basically the queen of dubbing. What is what did she do?
[33:34] Jimi: So most famously she dubbed, and I would say these are no secrets anymore. I think everyone knows this. She's written a book. Anytime you get like the hundred greatest musicals, you find this fact out. But yeah, so she dubbed Audrey Hepburn in My Fair Lady. So Audrey Hepburn was obviously cast in My Fair Lady because she was a big name, she's a fantastic actress, cute as a button, perfect. That's what you want. Obviously, not taking into account the fact that she's not the strongest singer. Now let's give her some credit. She can sing a little bit. And there's a recording that we will put in the show notes of you can hear her singing, I could have danced all night. And I mean she does a great job, but it's not it's not an easy song. That that role was written for Mary Martin. Mary Martin went into Peter Pan, so they gave it to Julie. Julie, who did fabulously.
[34:23] Tommy: Yeah, exactly. She changed the game. That was just but then in the long history of stage to movie snubs, they went with Miss Audrey Hepburn. It's been happening since days of your Julie Andrews gets snubbed every once in a while. But I think the joke is, it's like um Audrey Hepburn like called for them to cast Julie Andrews. She was like, Surely this woman should be playing this role. Which I think you know makes me like respect Audrey Hepburn a lot. Because I'm like, that's a good gag that you're wanting to give up there, because you're so scared about your voice. So to solve all of that, they decided to not tell Audrey Hepburn and then just get someone else to sing in their place, which is ridiculous. And completely uncredited. I think there's an interview that I've been trying to find. I can't find it anywhere. But I think Marni Nixon says she got like $500.
[35:11] Jimi: Holy cow.
[35:12] Tommy: And that was it. And not like royal, no royalties, just here's your fee. Thank you. Hollywood.
[35:19] Jimi: Yeah.
[35:20] Tommy: Yeah, exactly. And apparently, yeah, Audrey Hepburn was a gem about it. You know what I mean? The person who was not a gem was Natalie Wood.
[35:30] Jimi: Who can't sing.
[35:32] Tommy: No, no she cannot. There's not even there's not even any semblance of her being able to sing like Audrey Hepburn can. So yeah, in West Side Story, it kind of blows your mind. The same voice in West Side Story is the exact same voice. And my fair lady. But yeah, Natalie Wood, but she kicked up a storm. Like she was she was really mean and horrible to Marni Nixon. I hear that about Natalie Wood in general. Just another reason why she shouldn't have been in that film.
[35:56] Jimi: Exactly.
[35:57] Tommy: I want a series of all of these movies where Marni Nixon dubs the voice until three-quarters of the way through, and then Donald O'Connor shoves her to the side, and then he dubs the rest of the movie.
[36:12] Jimi: Exactly. Exactly.
[36:13] Tommy: That should happen to all of them.
[36:16] Jimi: I'm singing in the rain.
[36:18] Tommy: Just singing in the rain. What a glorious feeling. I'm happy again. I laughing at the card.
[36:34] Jimi: And I'm very good. So my favorite part of this show is make 'em laugh and is Donald O'Connor.
[36:42] Tommy: Barnaby.
[36:42] Jimi: Yeah, I mean, it it is the best bit. There. Said it. So good. Historical musical theatre moment. Right. Musical, musical, movie, comedy, like spot on, fabulous. Should we talk about that song? Would you call this plagiarism?
[37:01] Tommy: Completely.
[37:03] Jimi: So out with the weird London cast recording that features this song.
[37:08] Tommy: Yeah.
[37:09] Jimi: I've never heard the original. I've never been able to find it.
[37:13] Tommy: Be a clown?
[37:14] Jimi: Yeah, like in like with from the 30s.
[37:17] Tommy: Oh, you got I'll I'll st we'll put I'll put some links in the show notes. It's all over the place. Judy Garland used to sing it in duet in a tramp costume all the time. I'm sure I can find it in a video song.
[37:27] Jimi: Okay, great. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Hit me up. It is not only the same. So the songs Be a Clown and Make Em Laugh share very similar melodies, and really share very similar content. Um this I guess when you say similar, you mean the same thing.
[37:41] Tommy: Basically the same.
[37:42] Jimi: Yeah. And they're by different authors. It's important to point out. Be a clown is by Cole Porter. Uh and Make Em Laugh is a new song by Arthur Freed for this movie. Quote unquote.
[37:50] Tommy: Yes. Brand new.
[37:51] Jimi: Yeah, but again, like singing in her in trivia, the story goes that you know there wasn't a fuss kicked up because Freed, using all of his magical production powers, helped Cole Porter out by giving him the gig for writing the music for a movie called The Pirate, which we all know.
[38:11] Tommy: I never heard of it.
[38:13] Jimi: And so by doing him that favor, Cole Porter was like, yeah, have my song and please make it historically amazing and take all of the credit, please. Um, I'm sure that's how it went down.
[38:25] Tommy: I mean, it's worth it. It's a great number.
[38:28] Jimi: I know. I'm not gonna complain. Sorry. It's a wonderful number.
[38:31] Jimi: It's so if you've never, if you're gonna watch one number from Singin' in the Rain, watch "Make 'Em Laugh."
[38:36] Tommy: Oh, 100%, and watch it again and again and again and again and again.
[38:39] Jimi: Don't watch Matthew Morrison trying to do it.
[38:41] Tommy: Don't watch anyone else but Donald O'Connor.
[38:43] Jimi: Again, it's that kind of thing of even though it is it's very old timey.
[38:47] Tommy: Yeah, it's very it's very vaudeville.
[38:49] Jimi: Yeah, but it when you watch it now, I still split sides laugh.
[38:55] Tommy: Like, yeah, it's amazing.
[38:56] Jimi: It's the first time we had that little like circle run.
[38:59] Tommy: Yeah.
[38:59] Jimi: That Homer Simpson made famous.
[39:02] Tommy: And like what I find so impressive about it, if we saw that number in a movie that came out in 2016, it would be impressive, but maybe not as impressive, because you would assume there's CGI or they're using wires, or they did it in 15 different takes, or there's stunt doubles.
[39:21] Jimi: But this is Donald O'Connor running around on a sound stage, you know, no help.
[39:21] Tommy: No help.
[39:28] Jimi: And making these feats of acrobatics happen.
[39:31] Tommy: One take.
[39:33] Jimi: Yeah.
[39:33] Tommy: So the story goes.
[39:35] Jimi: Well, uh no, no, I don't I think there were multiple takes, but like the end is all one shot, is what I mean, one shot.
[39:41] Tommy: That is so impressive.
[39:42] Jimi: To remember all your cues, yeah, timing, spot like marks.
[39:46] Tommy: Holy moly.
[39:48] Jimi: Holy moly.
[39:49] Tommy: It's crazy.
[39:49] Jimi: What a man.
[39:50] Tommy: Yeah.
[39:50] Jimi: What a man.
[39:51] Tommy: Gift a gift to mankind.
[39:53] Jimi: Make 'em laugh, make 'em laugh.
[39:56] Tommy: Don't you know everyone wants to laugh?
[40:00] Jimi: My dad said be an actor, my son.
[40:03] Tommy: But be a comic common one.
[40:05] Jimi: They'll be standing in lines for those old hunky tonkey shines.
[40:12] Tommy: Now you could study Shakespeare and be quite elite.
[40:15] Jimi: And you could charm the critics and have nothing to eat.
[40:18] Tommy: Just on a banana veal, the world's a gifty.
[40:21] Jimi: Make 'em laugh, make 'em laugh, make 'em laugh.
[40:23] Tommy: They don't make them like they used to.
[40:25] Jimi: No, they're.
[40:26] Tommy: Let's talk about that.
[40:26] Jimi: Who do we have nowadays that you could be like, yeah, you could do that.
[40:30] Tommy: Like legitimately a triple threat dancer, singer, actor.
[40:34] Jimi: Completely.
[40:35] Tommy: Not like this.
[40:35] Jimi: I mean, we don't have our tap numbers anymore.
[40:37] Tommy: This is it.
[40:38] Jimi: And even like in revivals and stuff, you'll get moments where people will jump in and they'll be alright, but the choreography's been reduced.
[40:46] Tommy: It's been kind of dumbed down.
[40:47] Jimi: Like if we think about someone like I say someone like Sutton, right?
[40:51] Tommy: Who I think is probably one of the closest we've got.
[40:53] Jimi: For sure.
[40:54] Tommy: Even in Anything Goes, I know she dances for the whole dance break, but the choreography she's doing, it's not too difficult.
[41:02] Jimi: Yeah.
[41:02] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?
[41:03] Jimi: I do think to Broadway stage actors' credit, they're singing and dancing at the same time.
[41:09] Tommy: And it's, you know, let's not pretend for a second that these that they were actually singing while they were dancing "Good Morning" or "Make 'Em Laugh."
[41:16] Jimi: Very good point.
[41:17] Tommy: Very good point.
[41:18] Jimi: I don't care.
[41:21] Tommy: No, that's no, that's true.
[41:22] Jimi: I never really thought that.
[41:24] Tommy: Just I even, but even if we look into the world of movie musicals, yeah, we get none of this.
[41:29] Jimi: No, it's anymore.
[41:31] Tommy: Like bleeding with talent, this whole movie.
[41:34] Jimi: Like legitimate, actual, visceral performing talent.
[41:39] Tommy: And I'm trying to think, like, when did that stop?
[41:42] Jimi: Was it the 70s?
[41:43] Tommy: That's the 60s and the 70s.
[41:45] Jimi: It's you know, whenever tap fell out of favor.
[41:47] Tommy: But that just makes no cause even like it just makes no sense.
[41:51] Jimi: Yeah.
[41:51] Tommy: Because if you think like, because obviously the 70s we still had Fosse.
[41:55] Jimi: Yeah.
[41:55] Tommy: And I guess it was kinda after him.
[41:57] Jimi: Yeah.
[41:57] Tommy: But even there was nothing in the age.
[41:59] Jimi: You know, Fosse changed the choreography bent from being big and bold and brash to being tiny and reserved and intentional and quiet.
[42:08] Tommy: But then it was still it was still also I would say still athletic.
[42:11] Jimi: Because that's the thing is that we call these guys athletes.
[42:13] Tommy: And I would say that Fosse and Gwen and Anne Ranking and Ben Vereen, like these guys were all athletes because it was so perfect.
[42:22] Jimi: But again, you never you never really see that.
[42:26] Tommy: Like the thing the one that I guess comes to mind is like Hairspray.
[42:29] Jimi: I feel like that's been the Hairspray is is very athletic.
[42:32] Tommy: It's very dance extravaganza.
[42:34] Jimi: But then it's I don't know, even then it's it doesn't feel the same.
[42:39] Tommy: Things don't feel like they have the same technical skill that Singin' in the Rain does.
[42:44] Jimi: You know, Hairspray is very good and certainly to the trained eye is very technical and important, but it doesn't, you know, it looks like dancehall dance.
[42:53] Tommy: It looks like you know you're dancing for fun, where like tap dance is like you are dancing on a dime.
[43:01] Jimi: Literally, if you're in 42nd Street, the fun for you.
[43:05] Tommy: It makes me sad because it's what I love.
[43:08] Jimi: Like one of my favorite shows that I've ever done was Anything Goes, and it was when I learned tap.
[43:14] Tommy: Yeah.
[43:14] Jimi: And it is just you feel so proud because of what you're achieving.
[43:18] Tommy: It feels amazing to perform those numbers.
[43:20] Jimi: Yeah.
[43:21] Tommy: And it's great fun to watch.
[43:22] Jimi: And I was like, I want it back.
[43:25] Tommy: Choreographers of the world, if you're listening, we need a tap dance renaissance.
[43:28] Jimi: Make it happen.
[43:52] Tommy: Can I put this hypothetical story option in your hat?
[44:00] Jimi: Yeah, please do.
[44:01] Tommy: You've told me briefly about this before, but I wanna I want to hear you spell it out.
[44:05] Jimi: Cosmo Brown, Donald O'Connor's character, is a gay character.
[44:11] Tommy: Bum bum.
[44:14] Jimi: And I think I've thought this long before I had gay and musical theater on my mind, but I like if you want, and I was looking for it this time, the way Cosmo treats Lena when Lena is trying to muscle in on what is his turf with Don Lockwood, and like they've been friends for the longest time, and the number of like even when Don says like Cosmo, you're my best friend, and he has these moments, which I'm sure I'm reading in, like I'm sure this wasn't scripted specifically, but like you're my closest friend, and he's like, Oh, yes, friend, I am your closest friend. We are friends. We are two male friends who are just friends, and all we are are friends.
[44:59] Tommy: And like that's an exact quote from the film as well.
[45:04] Jimi: It's a Camden and Green original.
[45:06] Tommy: It's you know, and you you couldn't, it's as close as you could get to writing a gay character without writing it in the 50s, you couldn't have a gay character, an out gay character, and an overt gay character at all.
[45:16] Jimi: Cosmo Brown is a gay character.
[45:19] Tommy: I thought a really good a really good YouTube series recently, all about this.
[45:23] Jimi: I can't remember who did it.
[45:25] Tommy: Yeah, I um you should go someone should Google it probably.
[45:29] Jimi: It's probably called something like musical theater is so um gay.
[45:35] Tommy: Uh that's what it was.
[45:36] Jimi: Musical theater is so gay.
[45:38] Tommy: Or if you'd like, hashtag humble brag, at least right now, if you type just the words musical theater into YouTube, it's like the third result.
[45:48] Jimi: Um well hey I know moving up in the world.
[45:52] Tommy: Um but yeah, coded gay characters in musical theater. Once you start looking out for them, they're all over the place.
[45:58] Jimi: Completely.
[45:58] Tommy: Well, I mean, we've talked about before Natasha Bierre, great comment of 1912. I'm still I swear Dolikoff is a gay man, and he is really in love with that um there they are.
[46:08] Jimi: You're right though, they are everywhere, and yeah, I think you make the really good point in your video when you talk about composers like Cole Porter who are writing these lyrics that literally are saying gay, gay, gay, gay, gay, gay, gay, gay, gay, gay.
[46:21] Tommy: Right.
[46:22] Jimi: And it's that way for them to be like, I exist, and you wouldn't have this form without me.
[46:27] Tommy: But then what I wonder about this is there's no gay production team, lesbian production. You know, I mean, there's no everyone involved is straight.
[46:37] Jimi: Well so well, yeah, as far as we as far as we know.
[46:42] Tommy: I think both Donald and um Gene Kelly have sorted histories.
[46:48] Jimi: Really?
[46:49] Tommy: I think there have at least been rumors.
[46:51] Jimi: Hollywood in the 50s, everyone was gay in Hollywood in the fifties, or everyone was at least flexible in Hollywood in the 50s.
[47:00] Jimi: Okay.
[47:02] Tommy: Interesting.
[47:02] Jimi: I would never have thought that from Gene Kelly, though.
[47:05] Tommy: Because he emits this masculinity.
[47:07] Jimi: Yeah, exactly.
[47:09] Tommy: Fred is there, I'll give you.
[47:11] Jimi: See, then he's so.
[47:13] Tommy: I would totally go the other way.
[47:14] Jimi: I would call Fred Astaire straighter than Gene Kelly.
[47:17] Tommy: I don't know.
[47:17] Jimi: He's so straight, Gene Kelly.
[47:20] Tommy: But Donald O'Connor, I can give you.
[47:22] Jimi: But then is that just because of Cosmo?
[47:24] Tommy: Uh it could be.
[47:25] Jimi: Maybe you know, he's doing the great actor.
[47:27] Tommy: I know he's I think he's been married a couple times to women.
[47:31] Jimi: I should specify.
[47:32] Tommy: I mean, I look, I always look at character well, I look at like Cosmo in that film, and I just I'm like, I feel you, buddy.
[47:37] Jimi: I feel ya.
[47:38] Tommy: I've been there, I've had those straight friends, and I've been like, yeah, I'll do anything for you.
[47:42] Jimi: Yeah, of course.
[47:43] Tommy: I don't mind saying up till 3 a.m. Follow you to the end of the world.
[47:46] Jimi: Yeah, completely.
[47:48] Tommy: Like your heart bleeds for Donald O'Connor in that film.
[47:51] Jimi: Because he also, you know, it gets a happy-ish ending.
[47:57] Tommy: That's what you want.
[48:01] Jimi: Yay.
[48:01] Tommy: Even RF gets his money, but poor little Cosmo just sits there.
[48:05] Jimi: And I think you're right. Like the relationship that he has with Lena Lamont is again.
[48:09] Tommy: I've had that relationship with overpowering demons.
[48:13] Jimi: Of people in the movie, Cosmo Brown hates Lena Lamont more than anyone else.
[48:18] Tommy: He has more lines against her, more sarcastic quips about her than anyone else in this whole show.
[48:24] Jimi: Completely.
[48:25] Tommy: And also the relationship that he has with Debbie Reynolds.
[48:29] Jimi: Yeah.
[48:29] Tommy: Is really platonic.
[48:31] Jimi: Yeah.
[48:32] Tommy: Not in a sense of, oh, I know you're you're interested in my best friends, but I'm not gonna go there.
[48:37] Jimi: It's literally like a buddy relationship.
[48:39] Tommy: Yep, but with a female.
[48:41] Jimi: And that doesn't happen in those days.
[48:43] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?
[48:44] Jimi: Nope.
[48:44] Tommy: In our chauvinistic hat wearing time.
[48:47] Jimi: Yeah, exactly.
[48:48] Tommy: I think that makes it very, very apparent.
[48:50] Jimi: And also Gene Kelly's wearing fabulous eyeshadow, so who could resist, you know?
[48:56] Tommy: He's getting the mixed signals.
[48:57] Jimi: That's what it is.
[49:00] Tommy: All I do is dream of you the whole night through.
[49:04] Jimi: With the dawn is still go on.
[49:06] Tommy: Dreaming of you.
[49:08] Jimi: You're every song, you're everything, you're every song I give her sing.
[49:12] Tommy: Summer, winter, autumn, and spring.
[49:16] Jimi: And we're there for the 24 hours a day.
[49:20] Tommy: Baby spin, sweet content, dreaming away.
[49:24] Jimi: Guys like we're blue morning, night night nine too.
[49:28] Tommy: All I do is the whole range who is dream of you.
[49:32] Jimi: So this is coming to Broadway soon.
[49:34] Tommy: This was news to me.
[49:35] Jimi: I didn't know this at all.
[49:36] Tommy: So the production is come from France.
[49:40] Jimi: Okay.
[49:40] Tommy: I can't pronounce the name of the company that did it.
[49:45] Tommy: I don't know what that's right.
[49:47] Jimi: Thank you.
[49:47] Tommy: Um Paris.
[49:49] Jimi: France.
[49:50] Tommy: They're doing are they do you think they're trying to do the same thing they did with An American in Paris?
[49:55] Jimi: Yeah, it's the exact same company.
[49:56] Tommy: Exact same thing.
[49:57] Jimi: I bet you they're trying to do the exact same thing they did with An American in Paris.
[50:01] Tommy: You could it get more similar?
[50:02] Jimi: A big old big old dance show.
[50:04] Tommy: Yeah, I mean like written by the freed the freed unit that was turned into a musical, you know what I mean?
[50:09] Jimi: It's just almost as a revival, I guess.
[50:11] Tommy: Yeah, so it's it's coming.
[50:12] Jimi: It looks it looks really good.
[50:14] Tommy: It looks a lot better than the kind of recent Chichester one that we had in London.
[50:19] Jimi: They did quite well and it was alright.
[50:21] Tommy: Yeah, is that the one that was on that royal variety performance that I've seen on YouTube?
[50:25] Jimi: Uh huh.
[50:25] Tommy: I have seen it.
[50:26] Jimi: It was fine.
[50:28] Tommy: Yeah.
[50:28] Jimi: The Chichester is known for churning out fantastic productions.
[50:31] Tommy: Yeah.
[50:32] Jimi: In terms of design.
[50:34] Tommy: Like, so they did the recent Gypsy.
[50:36] Jimi: Okay, yes, which is fabulous.
[50:39] Tommy: Yeah, the design is exemplary.
[50:41] Jimi: They did the recent Sweeney Todd with MLD and Michael Ball.
[50:44] Tommy: Um, they've just done an amazing production of Barnum.
[50:47] Jimi: Okay.
[50:47] Tommy: And they're gonna do half a six pins, which I know is your favorite musical.
[50:52] Jimi: So there's lots of things.
[50:54] Tommy: There's lots of really, really great things that they're turning out.
[50:58] Jimi: I don't think Singin' in the Rain was our best.
[51:00] Tommy: Yeah.
[51:00] Jimi: But it had a run on the West End for a good while, like a really good while.
[51:05] Tommy: Really successful tour.
[51:06] Jimi: But the looks of it, this production from Théâtre du Châtelet.
[51:11] Tommy: Uh huh.
[51:11] Jimi: Who knows?
[51:12] Tommy: Looks better.
[51:13] Jimi: It look I mean, the stuff they did with An American in Paris was just stunning.
[51:17] Tommy: It was so beautiful and like it was just a joy to watch.
[51:22] Jimi: Completely. I mean, the choreography. In fact, I know I've just talked about how they don't make like CS2. But to be honest, in that show, the choreography was sensational. Like it's true. The performance that they did on the Tonies was moving. So have you ever have you looked up any pictures of anything from it? So I'm watching a compilation video right now, and it looks it looks really cool. It's all in this like black and white casting.
[51:47] Tommy: Black and white.
[51:48] Jimi: Yeah, the whole thing. The whole thing, apart from um Broadway, of course would be just vomiting technicolor.
[51:56] Tommy: Exactly. I think as a design, it looks really, really cool. Some nice moments, but it I think it totally covers what we said earlier.
[52:05] Jimi: Yeah.
[52:06] Tommy: It looks exactly like the movie on stage. And that's what I think that's what you do with this character. Frame by frame, scene by scene. And I guess I suppose my change it.
[52:31] Jimi: I think it flows really well.
[52:33] Tommy: Yeah. And again, it's the name Singin' in the Rain. Everyone, everyone wants to see it. And be like, oh, I know, I know that movie. Well, that's we're from Oklahoma. Let's go see Singin' in the Rain, honey.
[52:42] Jimi: Here. Whoa.
[52:45] Tommy: Yeah. Um sorry, that was really offensive to Midwestern America. The thing that annoys me about the musical is it's like, come and see how we do rain on stage.
[52:56] Jimi: Yeah.
[52:56] Tommy: And that's the only thing that they're ever focusing on. Or getting people in. No, I'm like, it's literally the 21st century. It's really it's theater. You can like have 3D holograms on stage now. I've I know of high schools that have done rain on stage.
[53:15] Jimi: Like it's not yeah. My my uni amateur company did a production of Island Theatre and they had a frickin' waterfall running for the whole show. Like, we we get it.
[53:24] Tommy: Yeah, you could do it. Now that isn't to say that I don't love rain on stage and water on stage, but I think trying to use that excuse me as your selling point as a marketing game nowadays, uh silly.
[53:36] Jimi: I think silly. Water, I don't know, water on stage has this like weird does this weird thing to me. It it makes you feel amazing. I don't know that it's because it's like it's not supposed to be there, uh-huh, but it's really really great. I remember I saw this amazing production of Midsummer Night's Dream, uh-huh, where basically they had the whole Athenian scene at the start, and then Phyllis straight started stripping, and we're like, hey, what's going on here? And then he just like falls to the side and falls into the stage with this massive splash, and there was just this hidden pool.
[54:08] Tommy: Ooh, right?
[54:09] Jimi: And then it all starts the whole stage, just starts raining.
[54:12] Tommy: That's very cool.
[54:13] Jimi: And then that was the fair world. It was really, really good. And it's always been my ambition to have a show where it rains on stage.
[54:19] Tommy: With rain in it.
[54:31] Jimi: Um singing in the rain.
[54:35] Tommy: Yes, singing in the rain.
[54:38] Jimi: What a glorious feel.
[54:42] Tommy: And I'm happy again.
[54:46] Jimi: I'm laughing at clouds.
[54:49] Tommy: So dark upon.
[54:53] Jimi: And the sun's in my heart.
[54:55] Tommy: Hammer.
[54:57] Jimi: You hate him.
[54:58] Tommy: You hate him so much.
[54:59] Jimi: I really don't like Gene Kelly.
[55:00] Tommy: That's so interesting. I enjoy some like I I appreciate his talent and his technical prowess. I think some of his directoral stuff is great. I love what he did with Hello Dolly. I think as a person he was a part of and set a precedent for directoral behavior that has been detrimental and that Hollywood is still feeling the repercussions of today.
[55:21] Jimi: Do you think do you think he started it? Do you think he started bad directing?
[55:25] Tommy: I don't think he started that kind of like overwhelming chauvinistic, like oppressive directing. Um certainly Alfred Hitchcock was much worse than Gene Kelly just to pluck an example out of the air.
[55:38] Jimi: Yeah, but I'm thinking like Jerome Robbins, like he was mean, like he he like persecuted the cast of Wednesday stories.
[55:44] Tommy: I have I have I have no I I will not suffer directors like that. I will call them out on that bullshit because I don't think that's necessary. I don't think it was necessary then, and it's certainly not necessary now.
[55:56] Jimi: And the fact that it became the norm in the 30s, 40s, 50s, 60s, 70s is a destructive presence that we are still trying to break down as a culture.
[56:06] Tommy: You know, I don't know that's true. It is true that we are like trying, like you say, trying to break it down. Because I've I mean I've been reading a few books and things about directing, and particularly directing in musical theater, and the like literally every single book has a paragraph being like, Yes, we know Jerome Robbins was really good and he got good results, but please don't do it like that.
[56:25] Jimi: But every single book I read, even if it's completely unrelated. And like it's I think it's it is important to continue to call those things out to never hand wave them away because we've been hand waving them away for decades, and you know, it's 2016.
[56:42] Tommy: It's time to And as do you know what, like it doesn't work because as a director, it does annoy me when people think that you have to be a dick to get the job done.
[56:53] Jimi: No.
[56:53] Tommy: And so like new directors come in and they kind of put on this persona, and I'm like, just please stop. Like, please stop because you're it's gonna take you twice as long to get something out of your actor, it's gonna take you twice as long to get your actors trust you. Sure, you may gain the respect quite quickly, but just because they're scared of you, like that's not how it should be.
[57:15] Jimi: I see so many new directors trying to put on this mean persona.
[57:19] Tommy: I say, stop new directors. It's just unnecessary, it's just unnecessary. We're we're all professionals trying to get the same thing done. There's no reason to play games.
[57:28] Jimi: Yeah. Have you ever in your land of tech, have you ever had to work with any evil demon directors?
[57:35] Tommy: All the time. College. Um, this is my apologies to theatrical college professors out there, and some of some college professors I've had have been fabulous. But one of the things I've noticed about a lot of theatrical education professionals, both in at the college level and the high school level, is that education is their plan B.
[57:55] Jimi: They wanted to do whatever it is they do professionally, and this is their backup plan.
[58:00] Tommy: And because it's their backup plan, they go into it with like a repressed sense of hatred towards these, you know, young uh aspiring professionals that comes out in their direction. You know, of course, directing professors have a proclivity for the egomaniacal, for the controlling. It is a no-brainer, and then that's all the more reason to be self-aware about it.
[58:30] Jimi: Completely. I had an acting professor in college, because I also I acted a little bit in college, and it was like acting too, I think, and I had completed some it was the Glass of Menagerie. Do you know how many times I've had to do scenes from the Glass of Menagerie? Stop using scenes from the Glass of Menagerie.
[58:44] Tommy: Um a scene I had done in high school in acting classes, doing it again in college, and finish the scene, and the the acting teacher who is a directing professor is sitting in the front of the class and turns to one of my classmates to the left and goes, Did you believe it? And then turns to a classmate on the other side and goes, Did you believe it? And then looks at me and goes, I didn't believe it.
[59:09] Jimi: And I'm like, Okay, that's fine, but there are more constructive ways to communicate that piece of feedback.
[59:19] Tommy: There are ways that aren't gonna be so so mean, just so mean. There's just mean it's it's just mean.
[59:28] Jimi: Like you're never going to get anything from that. There is no actor who could take that note and be like, Ah, okay, I'm inspired by that. Let's see that mulking that you just did about it.
[59:38] Tommy: We're in a cool thing. I'm ready to go do it, knife.
[59:41] Jimi: Yeah. Can you can you imagine a math teacher writing on top of like a kid who got a C on the quizzes test being like, you suck at math?
[59:50] Tommy: Like, no!
[59:51] Jimi: Exactly. You write try better next time or come see me so we can figure this out.
[59:56] Tommy: Like completely bothers me. Bothers me so much. So it is why I will not suffer some of Gene Kelly's antics.
[1:00:04] Jimi: Fair enough.
[1:00:05] Tommy: I still still fancy him, but that's like Have you ever suffered that horrible thing of having your hostess ask you to sing?
[1:00:14] Jimi: And just because you're so polite, you mumble through your teeth.
[1:00:20] Tommy: Alright. And suddenly a deathly gloom descends upon the entire room.
[1:00:28] Jimi: And the whispering gallery starts to ring with hold your hats.
[1:00:34] Tommy: She's gonna sing.
[1:00:36] Jimi: Well, here I am with great regret.
[1:00:40] Tommy: An innocent victim of etiquette.
[1:00:44] Jimi: I'm gonna sing, but not for long.
[1:00:51] Tommy: And though it's old, it's a love song.
[1:01:02] Jimi: Just singing in the rain.
[1:01:04] Tommy: What a glorious feeling.
[1:01:07] Jimi: I'm happy again.
[1:01:09] Tommy: That was singing in the rain.
[1:01:10] Jimi: It was.
[1:01:11] Tommy: I feel all dry now.
[1:01:13] Jimi: Yeah, I'm soaked.
[1:01:14] Tommy: Soaked to the core.
[1:01:16] Jimi: Probably gonna be worth it for the rest of my life.
[1:01:19] Tommy: Uh Jimmy, we have a quiz question for the topic of next week's show.
[1:01:24] Jimi: Okay.
[1:01:25] Tommy: You ready? Can you tell me what it is?
[1:01:26] Jimi: I can't ready.
[1:01:27] Tommy: The source material for this musical was quite controversial, and talks of censorship made it into the American political discourse. In one censorship hearing, a politician criticized the censorship attempt, saying, quote, are we going to start attacking ABC for scandal?
[1:01:44] Jimi: I mean, where does this stop?
[1:01:46] Tommy: End quote. Sassy politician.
[1:01:48] Jimi: Yeah, I know.
[1:01:49] Tommy: What show could that be?
[1:01:50] Jimi: I love it.
[1:01:51] Tommy: I have no idea. That's all very political and exciting.
[1:01:54] Jimi: It's almost as good as our trivia question for this week.
[1:01:58] Tommy: I think it's better than our trivia question for this week.
[1:02:01] Jimi: Ever so slightly.
[1:02:02] Tommy: Um, because it's actually trivia. Anyway, anyway, if you could pop along to our iTunes, it would help us out so so much if you could give us a little review.
[1:02:12] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:02:12] Tommy: Say some happy things about the podcast.
[1:02:15] Jimi: Or some sad things.
[1:02:16] Tommy: I mean, guess in time. Thank you as well to the people who have already left a review. You're lovely people.
[1:02:21] Jimi: I know everyone always says this, but it would actually help us.
[1:02:24] Tommy: Yeah, it actually does help us a whole lot.
[1:02:25] Jimi: Yeah. If you want to get in contact with us, I'm Tommy.
[1:02:29] Tommy: I'm on at musical mash on Twitter, or you can find me at Musical TheatreMash on YouTube.
[1:02:33] Jimi: And I am also on Twitter at AsinHendricks.
[1:02:38] Tommy: The spelling of my name. People get very confused by that.
[1:02:41] Jimi: I'm also on YouTube.
[1:02:42] Tommy: I don't make that much, but I will.
[1:02:45] Jimi: Uh or we have a show Twitter that's at Jim and Tomic on Twitter.
[1:02:49] Tommy: Or you can go onto our website, Jim and Tomic.com.
[1:02:52] Jimi: And also you'll be able to get a link to our Reddit discussion.
[1:02:55] Tommy: Yeah, we want to talk with you.
[1:02:56] Jimi: Yeah, exactly. We have some great chats over there.
[1:02:58] Tommy: Every every week, every podcast, there's some really exciting discussions.
[1:03:01] Jimi: And it's so interesting hearing your opinions and your experiences of the show in greater than 140 characters.
[1:03:07] Tommy: So yeah, come and come and speak to us over there.
[1:03:10] Jimi: Absolutely.
[1:03:10] Tommy: And tell your friends. You know this great musical theater podcast.
[1:03:13] Jimi: They should listen to.
[1:03:14] Tommy: We want this basically to be playing at Musical Mondays.
[1:03:18] Jimi: Every Monday.
[1:03:19] Tommy: Your bars across the world.
[1:03:24] Jimi: Global domination is a goal.
[1:03:26] Tommy: That's the aim, you know?
[1:03:27] Jimi: It's fine.
[1:03:29] Tommy: It's gonna happen.
[1:03:30] Jimi: And I guess we'll see you next Wednesday.
[1:03:33] Tommy: See you then.
[1:03:46] Jimi: Do you believe the whole thing about the milk?
[1:03:49] Tommy: Putting milk in the water?
[1:03:50] Jimi: No, I think that's one of those made-up trivia things.
[1:03:52] Tommy: Yeah, exactly. What about the whole thing about him being ill?
[1:03:54] Jimi: I also think that's one of those made-up trivia things.
[1:03:57] Tommy: That's the one though that I'm not sure if it is because everyone says that.
[1:04:01] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:04:01] Tommy: A lot of people everywhere.
[1:04:03] Jimi: Do you know how many people believe in Bigfoot?
[1:04:05] Tommy: Like me.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
