Discuss on Reddit ➤ Support the Show ➤ Welcome to our podcast on Maple Avenue! This week, we're talking about the fabulously important (and recently closed) musical Fun Home... Read More
From the show: Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour
Featured Shows
About
Welcome to our podcast on Maple Avenue! This week, we're talking about the fabulously important (and recently closed) musical Fun Home. We chat about the importance of representation, non-linearity, vagaries in the LGBTQ alphabet soup of terminology, and Jimi gets caught up on a particular V-word.
Fun Home (Original Cast Recording)
SHOW NOTES
If you haven't read the graphic novel that the musical Fun Home is based on, we highly recommend it!
Alison Bechdel's early comic strip, Dykes to Watch Out For is archived online. Check it out!
After seeing her life on stage, Alison Bechdel responded in the best way possible: with another autobiographical comic strip.
Sydney Lucas. Ring of Keys. Tony Performance. 'Nuff said.
No matter how you describe it, Ellen's coming out on television was revolutionary in the 90s. Here's a retrospective.
Want to hear more about the political drama surrounding the graphic novel in South Carolina? Here's a quick NPR story about it.
It never made it to television (SHAME) but, thanks to the power of the internet, you can experience the entire Jeanine Tesori & Lisa Kron Tony acceptance speech.
A SCANDALOUS QUIZ QUESTION…
What musical revival caused an audience member to strip completely naked because she loved it that much?
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:31] Jimi: Hello, listeners, and welcome to Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour.
[0:38] Tommy: Um this is your weekly podcast with lyrics and libations.
[0:42] Jimi: Ooh, it sounds so sensual.
[0:47] Tommy: That turned into a carbon guillo impression there.
[0:50] Jimi: It was beautiful. What are you drinking today, Jimmy?
[0:54] Jimi: Um today I'm drinking it's a Spanish drink. It's called Agua Mineral.
[1:00] Tommy: Ooh.
[1:02] Tommy: I am also drinking a Spanish drink. It's called Java.
[1:08] Jimi: I don't know if that's Java.
[1:11] Tommy: I don't know if that's actually right.
[1:16] Jimi: Well that sounds like isn't that one of the extra sisters in Fiddler on the Roof?
[1:23] Tommy: I think it is. I think she was named after Coffee.
[1:27] Jimi: I think so. You know, listeners, correct me on that one.
[1:32] Tommy: Correct us if we're wrong, but isn't Tevia's sixth daughter named after Coffee?
[1:37] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:39] Tommy: Last week we had a quiz question. The source material for this musical was quite controversial, and talks of censorship made it into the American political discourse.
[1:48] Jimi: In one censorship hearing, a politician criticized the censorship attempt, saying, "Are we going to start attacking ABC for scandal?"
[1:56] Tommy: I mean, where does this stop?
[1:59] Jimi: Crazy.
[2:01] Tommy: It is quite crazy, isn't it?
[2:02] Jimi: Yeah. What uh when they use TV references. Um, so yeah, what what is that source material?
[2:07] Tommy: That is Fun Home.
[2:09] Jimi: Wow! Come to the home.
[2:13] Tommy: That's the best old funeral home, baby.
[2:16] Jimi: The door fun home.
[2:26] Tommy: So you've got no reason to roam.
[2:29] Jimi: Use a backdoor funeral home in this.
[2:34] Tommy: The things you learn.
[2:35] Jimi: The things you learn. We are not just a musical theater podcast, we are also a politics podcast.
[2:39] Tommy: In brief shining, glimmering moment.
[2:43] Jimi: Definitely. Um before we get into why it's just so evil and the worst. Um, should we give a brief summary of it is?
[2:52] Tommy: Yeah. Uh Fun Home premiered on Broadway in oh what, 2000 and well, on Broadway, I think it was 14.
[3:02] Jimi: On Broadway in 2014, 1415 season and off Broadway in 2013. It's based on a graphic novel by lesbian cartoonist Alison Bechdel.
[3:13] Tommy: Um and it's about her interesting relationship with her family and her father.
[3:20] Jimi: It is, it is. I think that's a lovely succinct way of putting it. Um, but it was uh very, very important at its time, wasn't it?
[3:28] Tommy: Because at its time, as I thought was like 20 years ago.
[3:31] Jimi: Exactly. It's still very much. Uh important. Um but because it looks a lot at um issues that hadn't really ever been talked about on uh a Broadway musical stage before, um, particularly the issue of lesbianism.
[3:47] Tommy: Exactly. So uh in the show, Alison is a is bifurcated, I guess trifurcated, into three different characters.
[3:56] Jimi: Yes. Uh big Allison, medium Allison, and little Allison.
[3:59] Tommy: And we kind of see little flashes of her life as she is remembering them while creating the graphic novel Fun Home that the musical is based on.
[4:09] Jimi: Um and she she's sorting through her own coming out as a lesbian and her father's interesting journey through life as a closeted queer person and perhaps resulting suicide.
[4:24] Tommy: And it's that makes it sound maybe a little darker than this musicalist.
[4:29] Jimi: Yeah.
[4:30] Tommy: But there is there's a lot of I mean, I mean there are some funnies in there. It's called Fun Home, after all.
[4:34] Jimi: Uh but I think it at its heart it is just it's a it's a beautiful story um of kind of accepting yourself and your family.
[4:47] Tommy: Um and there's some yeah, they tackle some really really good themes in there. Um I think that's one of the ones that I find most interesting is this idea of like you never really know your family, you never really know what their life is.
[5:05] Jimi: Um and so you almost have that epiphany moment where you kind of see them as a person.
[5:09] Tommy: Yeah. Um and that's it comes into play particularly with uh Alison and her mother uh for when she tells uh her mother, which comes out to her mother as lesbian, her mother actually makes this admission to Allison that well, actually, your dad has been sleeping with high school guys for most of most of our life, which is obviously a huge shock to Alison.
[5:35] Jimi: Yeah. Um that's the kind of moment where she realizes that her parents are just people, yeah.
[5:42] Tommy: I mean, they've got their own lives.
[5:43] Jimi: Yeah. And it's I something I just find really, really interesting, is just as a topic because it's something everyone has to go through. You know, that moment where your parents stop being they become people, just parents, yeah, exactly.
[5:57] Tommy: Yeah. It's really hmm. There's something special about it.
[6:00] Jimi: It's really the the exploration of familial relationships in both this musical and this book are they seem very new.
[6:12] Tommy: You know what I mean?
[6:13] Jimi: Yeah, yeah, totally. It's like it's you know, it is a there it's a legitimate seeming kind of dysfunctionality for the the Bechtel family because you see all of these dysfunctional families, quote unquote dysfunctional representations of familial life on television and stuff like that.
[6:31] Tommy: And there's they never seem like people you know, they seem like ridiculous caricatures of like that's not you know, you might see glimmers of your own insecurities or you know, you the actual relationship of your family members, but it it is always heightened to an extent where it seems very separate.
[6:48] Jimi: Whereas like I believe I could, you know, these could be my neighbors in Fun Home.
[6:53] Tommy: Yeah, 100%. Well, I think that's the thing is like at the end of the video, the source material is literally Alison Bechdel's life.
[6:59] Jimi: Yeah. Um it's based on her memoirs.
[7:01] Tommy: Yeah. Um and it it's it's fascinating.
[7:05] Jimi: Like I think there's so many elements of it that I find really fascinating that they did happen.
[7:11] Tommy: Um, particularly just the the kind of contrast between her and her dad.
[7:16] Jimi: Yeah.
[7:16] Tommy: Um so obviously the fact they're both queer, but uh what it is is the almost their struggle with their own identities and their gender identities.
[7:26] Jimi: Yeah.
[7:26] Tommy: So obviously if you've got, you know, uh a potentially gay bisexual man um and uh a lesbian woman who are literally they're sitting at opposite ends of of the spectrum there, um, and how they kind of uh present that.
[7:41] Jimi: There's a really good quote from the the graphic novel that I'd love to I'd love to read for you if you if you would.
[7:46] Tommy: Um and she says, "So not only were we inverts, we were inversions of each other. While I was trying to compensate for something unmanly in him, he was attempting to express something feminine through me. It was a war of cross purposes and so doomed to perpetual escalation."
[8:04] Jimi: Um and escalate.
[8:05] Tommy: It does.
[8:06] Jimi: How sadly. How beautifully put.
[8:08] Tommy: So beautifully put. Like, and I think, yeah, we should make a point here that if you haven't read the graphic novel, yeah, go get it right now.
[8:17] Jimi: Absolutely. Neither neither Jimmy nor I had read the novel before preparing for this podcast.
[8:22] Tommy: And even like if you like this musical, you'll absolutely like the novel. Even if you don't like this musical, grab the graphic novel.
[8:28] Jimi: If you're looking for a way into graphic novels or not, it's very accessible.
[8:33] Tommy: It's it's a quick read. I read it in like 40 minutes, maybe.
[8:36] Jimi: Yeah, exactly. Exactly. Like it's it's one of those that it i if you're n if you are new to graphic novels, it it does read like a normal novel.
[8:44] Tommy: There's captions to every picture, um that are are effectively written in prose.
[8:50] Jimi: Um so it it's not it doesn't feel weird. There's just some lovely illustrations that go alongside and alongside this amazing story.
[8:58] Tommy: And uh and I would say while while they certainly have the same core of a storyline and and you know they come from the same place, there are parts of the novel that I'm happy I know about now that are not that didn't make it through to the musical.
[9:12] Jimi: I mean, just uh all of Allison's literary references throughout the whole thing.
[9:18] Tommy: Uh huh.
[9:19] Jimi: It alludes to everything from you know Greek myths like Icarus to like the Adams family comic books, like all sorts of Gatsby, yeah, Proust, like she's she's a smart gal.
[9:35] Tommy: She's really smart.
[9:36] Jimi: Alison Bechdel lets you be smart with her too. It's not like they're these obscure sideways references that you can't get.
[9:43] Tommy: Yeah, exactly. Every time she kind of brings one up, she explains, she kind of analyzes it for you.
[9:49] Jimi: She's like, "This is how this relates to my family," um, and you need not understand it further.
[9:54] Tommy: But what it's also great is it's like, but go and find out what it is.
[9:57] Jimi: I think you feel compelled to actually read more.
[10:00] Tommy: Yeah.
[10:00] Jimi: Because yeah, she she literally takes passages from other books and things and quotes like this is the part that relates to my life.
[10:08] Tommy: It's um and like if she'll take passages from books that not only relate to her life, but that she is reading in the context of the story or that her dad's reading.
[10:19] Jimi: I mean, one of the things that reading the graphic novel very much put me in the mindset of that I hadn't be a mindset I hadn't been in before when listening to this musical, is Alison's uh big Allison's journey to find her own truth.
[10:37] Tommy: There's a couple sideways lines about it in the musical, like uh at the very beginning, she says something like, "I need real things because I don't trust memory."
[10:47] Jimi: And I think that shines even brighter in the graphic novel, but that you know, just the times when she has to rewrite her own captions or consider how to weave this non-linear constructed story together.
[11:02] Tommy: Exactly about like finding and almost creating her own truth, which is you know, as I would say freshman year of college, deep.
[11:11] Jimi: Yeah, exactly. Well, I I think like that what I think that stems from that lane is the fact that um for all of her all of the pictures in the the graphic novel, she took actual Polaroids of herself and drew from that reference.
[11:25] Tommy: Yeah.
[11:25] Jimi: Um because you want she wants that innate truth to it all.
[11:28] Tommy: And I love that that is is literally mirrored between the text and the graphic part of journey that's it's not just one or the other, it's it's a proper harmony.
[11:38] Jimi: Yeah.
[11:39] Tommy: Um and it really comes across like it really does.
[11:42] Jimi: It's like I'm no I'm no art critic, but the drawings are fantastic.
[11:46] Tommy: Yeah, they're absolutely amazing.
[11:48] Jimi: The whole thing is brilliant craftsmanship.
[11:52] Tommy: Um and I'd one critic put it, it's it's all just so very generous.
[11:56] Jimi: Like this is it's such a a deep you know, you're talking about your family's skeletons in the closet and your own insecurities about them.
[12:07] Tommy: Completely and putting that in, you know, into a very public forum.
[12:12] Jimi: Yeah, and I was I was thinking that today, like it must feel must feel so rewarding for Alison Bechdel to be able to have someone have two women who are unco unrelated to her in any way who are able to kind of interpret her life and present it for her in a different way.
[12:28] Tommy: I can only I can only imagine what that would feel like.
[12:33] Jimi: There's a brilliant, I'll put a link to it in the show notes. Um Alison Bechdel, not the ones in the play represented in the musical, um did a comic representation of her journey going to see Fun Home for the first time and it's wonderful.
[12:50] Tommy: She talks about how like she gave full creative control over to um the creators and like going to see it on stage.
[12:58] Jimi: It's just it's a she talks about it being a weird and interesting and wonderful experience.
[13:03] Tommy: Yeah.
[13:03] Jimi: And like very honest to the thing she created, but also seemingly very separate, even though it's three representations of her life on stage happening at the same time.
[13:15] Tommy: Exactly. Because it is, it's almost like a tertiary uh source because obviously you've got Alison Bechdel's life, then you've got Alison Bechdel's life in a graphic novel, then you've got Kronin and Tesori's interpretation of the graphic novel.
[13:26] Jimi: Exactly.
[13:27] Tommy: So I can understand where that kind of detachment comes from.
[13:29] Jimi: Yeah.
[13:30] Tommy: Um, but it must just be so I don't know, just fascinating to watch someone else interpret your life. Because it's one thing and to, you know, if you write a show and another director takes it on, but you know what I mean, and interprets it that way, but it's actually your life. Like that is you, you it's you on stage. It's your yeah. It's very it's amazing.
[13:50] Jimi: I was surprised actually at how little Alison Bechdel was involved.
[13:54] Tommy: Yeah.
[13:54] Jimi: I don't even think she was like an exec producer. I think she literally just handed it off.
[13:58] Tommy: Yeah.
[13:59] Jimi: Um, which is incredible. It's like it's so generous, it's so wonderfully generous.
[14:05] Tommy: Yeah, exactly. What's true? Dig deep into who and what and why and when. Until the gives way today.
[14:41] Jimi: Caption. My dad and I were exactly alike. I see everything.
[14:47] Tommy: Caption. My dad and I were nothing alike. I'm Superman.
[14:52] Jimi: My dad and my dad and I'm not sure. Um, should we talk a little bit about the story and how it's put together?
[14:58] Tommy: Yeah.
[15:00] Jimi: Yeah. Um so well, what do how would you see it? It's it's constructed. So this you know, this uh both the graphic novel and the musical, I think the mu it's more interesting the musical, frankly. But uh both both of them are presented nonlinearly, and that is why there are the three Allisons. So instead of starting at the beginning and ending at the end, you see the bits and pieces when they're important to weaving this story. Um and so you flash between small Allison, medium Alice and Big Allison, and sometimes they have duets with each other, which is fabulous. Um and it lets you you know, there there is no it makes it a story about a journey instead of about a destination.
[15:43] Tommy: Like you learn in the first song of the show. Alison is gonna be a lesbian, she's gonna struggle coming out to her family, and her dad is gonna come out kind of and commit suicide. Like exactly. Boom. Song one and two, done. No big no revelation, nothing to worry about there. And so it's not about where you got, but how you get there.
[16:04] Jimi: Yeah, completely. Um, and I think what that does is it then puts all the numbers, like the kind of introspective numbers in a different it's almost like a a Brechtdian light where you're you are looking at it from a an analytical point of view, as opposed to you're just feeling the emotion for the first time.
[16:22] Tommy: Um so for example, at like Edges of the World at the end of the show, um, which is the song where um Michael Servers is kind of move uh musing on his life uh and then gets hit by a truck. Um you're you know he's going to get hit by a truck. You know that you're not you're not like oh my god, is he gonna like what is this song about? Is he gonna die? It's not like Javert's suicide or something like that. It's literally just this man reflecting his life, and it means that you really tap into the lyrics a lot more. It's not like that moment when you're in a book and you're waiting to see what happens and you barely read a word, you just get to the moment.
[16:56] Jimi: Yeah.
[16:56] Tommy: Um for this, you don't, you take that time with him and you really get to listen. It's the same for days and days as well. Um, all of the all of the solo songs, I think that's something that is they've done really, really well, is that each of the characters, um, and that includes all of the Allisons, yeah, have their own solo song, um, or partial solo song, uh, that they get to explain the important part of their life.
[17:22] Jimi: Yep.
[17:23] Tommy: Um, which is so great. What a great It's so beautiful. And they're so they're so honest, seemingly. I mean, Ring of Keys. If keys, if you hadn't seen the Tony Awards performance, what are you doing with your life? Go watch it right now.
[17:37] Jimi: Like no one I ever saw before.
[17:41] Tommy: I feel I feel I don't know where you came from.
[17:51] Jimi: I wish I did.
[17:53] Tommy: I feel so dumb. I feel your swagger and your bearing.
[18:02] Jimi: And just right clothes, you're wearing your short hair and your dungarees and your lace-up boots.
[18:11] Tommy: And your keys.
[18:13] Jimi: Oh your ring of keys. Young Alison's like first realization of you know her own sexual orientation, her own, like that, you know, there are butch women out there and she wants that somehow in her life.
[18:37] Tommy: Yeah, exactly. And it's the you know, so many lyrics, everyone I think we'd have to blame Sondheim for this, but the like striving for the really really thought-out complete sentences, rhymes at the end of the line, yeah, kind of stuff. Um Ring of Keys, little Allison barely finishes a sentence like 16 times in a row. And there's something so beautiful and honest about that. And is still wonderfully filled with emotion, and you know exactly how she's feeling. I think it just evokes some sort of attachment.
[19:15] Jimi: Yeah, oh, complete I think we've all like each of us has experienced a first crush. Yeah, and uh that moment is is it's it is it's so innocent, it's not overplayed, it's purely just her trying to understand what what is this I'm feeling like why am I resonating so much with this woman in a pair of jeans? Like um it's it's really really well well done and like all of my hats, every single hat that I own thrown off my head for Sydney Lucas because that was one of my favorite moments that's ever happened in like history.
[19:49] Tommy: She kicked up, it's beautiful.
[19:52] Jimi: It's so beautiful. Like that Tony performance, I will link the hell out of it in the show notes. We'll put like 12 links to it just so you don't miss it. But um it it really like it just it I it changed my life, but in a way that I was just like, I'm so glad this is going to change a lot of other people's lives. Like um up until that moment, there'd literally be no musical theater representation of a lesbian girl on national television.
[20:20] Tommy: Absolutely, and that is ridiculous.
[20:23] Jimi: And um and certainly no representation of a lesbian girl that young.
[20:28] Tommy: Completely, completely. The pop culture reference for lesbian coming out, at least in America, is Ellen, and that's that's not when kids realize their sexual orientation. You know, it's we've we've lived in a pop culture media world that has set up this expectation that you're supposed to figure out your sexual orientation in your 20s, maybe.
[20:51] Jimi: Yeah, exactly.
[20:52] Tommy: Maybe after your first marriage.
[20:53] Jimi: Exactly. And like not that you not that you can't figure it out then, but some so many people struggle with these things so much earlier in life, and they're until Fun Home was little if any representation of that anywhere.
[21:08] Tommy: Exactly. Cause you'd look you look to these things, you'd look to media um when you're young. Especially now, especially in this day and age where you live on media. And that's what you want to see. You want to see that person that feels the same way as you.
[21:25] Jimi: When I was younger, there was none of that. Like I had lots of like really camp, really like flamboyant stereotypes.
[21:33] Tommy: You were you were either a you were either a Will or you were a Jack from Will and Grace.
[21:39] Jimi: Exactly. That was about it. There was no happy medium.
[21:42] Tommy: No.
[21:44] Jimi: And I I don't know I find that really really tricky because it would mean that you know all your friends who'd be watching the same thing had this preconceived notion of well that's what a gay person is. And you're sitting there thinking like yeah but I'm not like that.
[21:57] Tommy: Yeah.
[21:57] Jimi: So maybe I'm not maybe I shouldn't be or you don't want you know I mean you don't want to be because they're ridiculous and you're like well I can't be bothered to spend about like be exhausting to be Jack for the rest of my life.
[22:09] Tommy: Oh my gosh can you imagine um so like you want those grey icons to look up to. And I can't think of a more tasteful and realistic presentation of a queer character at that age in the world other than Sydney Lucas thinking he's at the 20s I mean that's one of I think that is one of the things that made that moment so moving is you're watching this young girl nine or ten sing a song about recognizing some spark of something in this fictional delivery person that she sees in this coffee shop. Meanwhile, in all of our minds, you imagine real nine-year-old almost lesbian sitting at home watching the television, having the exact same thoughts, seeing Sydney Lucas on television thinking, I understand that, I know that, and being equally unable to articulate it.
[23:05] Jimi: Yeah, exactly.
[23:06] Tommy: And I think it's something that I don't know, I I don't want to speak for you, but for me certainly. I actually I I can put myself in in that mind of I a young lesbian girl wanting to present themselves more as a you know like um what's Alison Bay like what did she call it she called it like um she was like classic something butch I mean an old school butch.
[23:27] Jimi: Old school butch exactly and I just think that's so good. But it's something that I I don't never wanted to be old school butch been trying to get the away from that. And I mean I think at least for me I don't want to speak for you on this but one of the things I've struggled with in talk you know figuring out the notes for this musical and going through it is that you know we we are or at least I am a gay man and this I'm also a gay man and this is a story about lesbians. And while we have our solidarity in you know our our quilt bag of acronisms and and names there's something different to those experiences.
[24:07] Tommy: Yeah definitely and which I I hadn't really realized until this musical came along I mean like I was just like yeah we're all gay.
[24:15] Jimi: Yeah in our in our so much more to it in our homo chauvinistic kind of way and exactly uh we can't get away from being men I think that's you know there's a lot of language difficulties around the whole queer tapestry of people. Um in the in, you know, I just did those um musical theater so gay videos.
[24:37] Tommy: Um and one of the books I read uh called Something for the Boys, which is an interesting book. I recommend it, um, but I disagree with it in a bunch of places.
[24:46] Jimi: But one of the things the author talks about is ever since Ellen came out as gay on television as opposed to coming out as a lesbian on television, there's been some you know inaccuracy, not inaccuracy, but like ambiguity around language surrounding these things. You know, can a homosexual woman call herself gay? Absolutely. She can also call herself lesbian, but a homosexual man isn't gonna call himself a lesbian and suddenly our language is muddled.
[25:16] Tommy: Um exactly.
[25:18] Jimi: And you know, language is important, but it it's especially when you know you're trying to separate these different experiences, which is also just kind of core to this show, too. The difference between Alison's experience and her father's experience.
[25:32] Tommy: Yeah.
[25:32] Jimi: I think that's it. It's just like for for us as as gay men, we we know where the differences lie.
[25:38] Tommy: Yeah.
[25:39] Jimi: But for people who can't get on our level at all as LGBT individuals, they they almost they need those separations, yeah, and distinctions and bookmarks, which I think does it throws in a lot of yeah of difficulty.
[25:53] Tommy: Um so it is it's a really interesting point now.
[25:55] Jimi: Joan, Joan, Joan, Joan.
[25:59] Tommy: Hi, Joan!
[26:00] Jimi: Don't wake up, Joan.
[26:02] Tommy: Oh my god, last night.
[26:04] Jimi: Oh my god, oh my god, oh my god, oh my god, last night.
[26:09] Tommy: I got so excited, I was too enthusiastic.
[26:13] Jimi: Thank you for not laughing.
[26:14] Tommy: Well, you laughed a little bit at one point when I was touching you and said I might lose consciousness, which you said was adorable, and I just have to trust that you don't think I'm an idiot or some kind of an animal.
[26:26] Jimi: I never lost control due to overwhelming lust, but I must say that I'm changing my major to Joan.
[26:40] Tommy: I'm changing my major to sex with Joan.
[26:45] Jimi: I'm changing my major to sex with Joan with a minor in Kissing Joel.
[26:52] Tommy: So Tommy.
[26:53] Jimi: So Jimi.
[26:55] Tommy: Tell me all about this controversy nonsense that you talked about.
[26:59] Jimi: So why was this source material so damn bad? It's the so Fun Home is has made it to the has the right honorable um distinction of being on numerous banned books list.
[27:16] Tommy: If you're ever looking for a uh a good set of reads, start at a banned books list. Um and in um right?
[27:26] Jimi: Uh 20 maybe 12, 13, um, South Carolina had planned for some of its colleges to use this book as a freshman reading material, which is a great choice.
[27:38] Tommy: This is a great literature.
[27:41] Jimi: Yeah. I can't think of better modern queer literature. Like an easy read, tons to talk about, tons to relate to, and also some discussion of issues that conservative politicians don't like.
[27:54] Tommy: And so the South Carolina uh legislator threatened to pull funding from two colleges, I believe, if they were going to use this book. And it stirred a great uproar. The cast of the then off-Broadway musical uh came to one of the colleges to do a benefit concert, um, which they all talk very lovingly of. Like I, you know, I think we had a little bit of the Streisand effect, and even more people heard about this musical and this book because of the attempts to ban it.
[28:23] Jimi: And you know, that's how it always happens. Um in the end, in the end, so the story goes, uh they so it was like they wanted to take away a certain amount of money that was the exact amount of money that this program in the college would get funded. Like, you know, it wasn't an explicit thing, but it was definitely a a silent middle finger to the college. Um as a compromise in the end, the legislature uh repurposed those funds to be spent on literature about the Constitution.
[28:57] Tommy: Which that's so nice of them.
[28:59] Jimi: It's it's really it's ironic.
[29:04] Tommy: Yeah, because it's you know, freedom to read whatever you want is written in the constitution.
[29:11] Jimi: Literally, oh god, honestly, legislators sometimes.
[29:15] Tommy: I know, I know more. Yeah, they could go Fun Home banned in a bunch of educational institutions, all the more reason to read it.
[29:24] Jimi: Exactly, exactly. And yeah, I wonder I wonder if it is on like the syllabus for a lot of things. Because over here, yeah, it's not that big.
[29:33] Tommy: Really?
[29:34] Jimi: Yeah. I I mean, beyond the musical, I'd never heard of I didn't, you know, without researching, I wouldn't have known it was a graphic novel.
[29:41] Tommy: Yeah.
[29:41] Jimi: Um there was only one copy when I went to buy it.
[29:46] Tommy: Wow, because it is it is huge. It is on top of a bunch of bestseller lists in America. Very popular. Um it was on the it never quite made any of the classes I was in in college. Um I think it was just becoming popular when it would have been on some of the lists, but it certainly is now.
[30:07] Tommy: Yeah.
[30:13] Jimi: All these issues are something only things American. Like the I just talked briefly about Stonewall, but that's it's very brief. Um you know, we kind of mirrored each other in terms of certainly in terms of the sixties and seventies, yeah.
[30:28] Tommy: Um kind of gay liberation.
[30:31] Jimi: Yeah. We were walking the same line. So I I don't I don't know why it's not I wonder I wonder if I mean gay rights has been a hot button issue for maybe the past decade and finally it's transitioning to, you know, now we're talking about trans rights and a bunch of other topics. But this was this got popular around all the gay marriage debates and all the things like that. I wonder if that gave it a big bump in the States.
[30:33] Tommy: I don't know.
[30:55] Jimi: That's an interesting thought. If you if you out there are a statistical analyzer of um book sales and trends, let us know.
[31:05] Tommy: Please let I'm sure there's at least three listening.
[31:09] Jimi: Probably that listen to our podcast.
[31:11] Tommy: Exactly. Um I don't know. I mean it might be used in like universities or something like that in like queer literature studies or something. But certainly in terms of like a populist book.
[31:22] Jimi: Yeah.
[31:23] Tommy: No. Not so much.
[31:24] Jimi: Huh.
[31:24] Tommy: No, not at all. That's classic Britain though, classic art is just being like, oh no, we don't need to speak about that.
[31:32] Jimi: Oh gosh.
[31:33] Tommy: No. There are naked people in this book.
[31:36] Jimi: Yes, no, there's a picture of a vagina.
[31:38] Tommy: I can't be showing that to my class.
[31:40] Jimi: Oh my god.
[31:42] Tommy: A British accent saying the word vagina is something I didn't think I was gonna find as funny as I did.
[31:48] Jimi: Very good.
[31:51] Tommy: And that's how literally everyone speaks in the UK.
[31:54] Jimi: I don't know if you because I know you've never been to the UK.
[31:56] Tommy: I've never been to I've never heard a British person before.
[31:59] Jimi: Yeah, so that's when you get here, that's everyone's just gonna be rocking around like vagina.
[32:04] Tommy: Vagina.
[32:06] Jimi: Everyone's wearing top hats and monocles.
[32:08] Tommy: This is how I imagine it.
[32:10] Jimi: Eating crumpets, drinking tea.
[32:12] Tommy: And just saying vagina over and over again.
[32:15] Jimi: Exactly. What a fun life we lead over here. It's like when you go when you go to America and everyone's on horseback, uh, you know, drinking a 62 ounce Coca-Cola.
[32:25] Tommy: Yeah, and shooting guns everywhere. Bang, bang, bang, bang, bang.
[32:27] Jimi: Boom-boo, boom-boo.
[32:29] Tommy: Yeah. And what what do you say over and over again?
[32:32] Jimi: Uh also vagina, actually.
[32:34] Tommy: Vagina.
[32:35] Jimi: Vagina.
[32:38] Tommy: I quite like that. Uh vagina.
[32:41] Jimi: Yeah, okay. Why not?
[32:45] Tommy: He wants the real heather duster used on the bookcase. Find all the books we've read and carefully restore.
[32:53] Jimi: He wants them alphabetized by classification. A volume out of place could start a third world war.
[33:02] Tommy: That's an each out of position. Watch it, that's a first edition. What are we missing? What have we left out when he comes down here? What's in snow?
[33:14] Jimi: He wants, he wants, he wants.
[33:18] Tommy: Welcome to our house on Maple.
[33:26] Jimi: Shall.
[33:26] Tommy: See, shiny ring.
[33:30] Jimi: And we are a typical family.
[33:43] Tommy: On that point, one of the things that I think is really kind of interesting, slash unique to this show. Certainly something in my experiences is actually like them how it was marketed. Um basically um the show isn't marketed as what the producers called it uh the lesbian suicide musical.
[34:05] Jimi: Um because who would who would call it that? Who would go to see that? Um but it's actually it's marketed as this beautiful universal family story of self-identification, reflection, and ultimately hope. Um, you know, there's no mention of LGBT there.
[34:22] Tommy: No, there's no mention of suicide because of LGBT issues.
[34:25] Jimi: Um it's literally just feels like, oh I can probably try, yeah, I've got a family.
[34:28] Tommy: Yeah. I'd love to feel hopeful.
[34:30] Jimi: Um and that's how all of the marketing is on any publicity you'll see. It's uh it's very light and happy in that way.
[34:38] Tommy: Yeah.
[34:38] Jimi: Um, even down to like the coloration and the images that they use. Like on the main one, I think it's like uh in the O of home. I think there's just like a little picture of like little Alison and her dad, like looking quirky.
[34:50] Tommy: Um it feels like something like the Adams family. Because I remember when I first came across this show, that was what I thought was gonna be like a fun comedy. I mean, it's called Fun Home.
[35:00] Jimi: Yeah.
[35:01] Tommy: So like you, you know, that's what you expect. You expect to have some fun. Um, and then suddenly you're thrown into this world, and you're like, hang on, what's happening? Like, who's dying now? Like, uh, and it it takes you by surprise, but you you're hooked, yeah, and you believe it because of how great it is, how great the source material is.
[35:20] Jimi: Um, and there's this really really interesting thing that uh I think it was the US ambassador to the UN, uh Miss Samantha Power.
[35:28] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[35:29] Jimi: Um, great name as well, by the way. Sam Power.
[35:32] Tommy: Sam Power, good name.
[35:33] Jimi: Yeah. Um, so she took uh 17 of her fellow ambassadors to the UN to see Fun Home. Um, and that is including people like Russia or Namibia, where it's illegal to be gay or to come out as gay.
[35:49] Tommy: Um and basically they didn't know anything about the show going into it. I'm sure they probably wouldn't have gone if they knew it was anything to do with LGBT issues.
[35:58] Jimi: Um apparently later, um Samantha was interviewed and she was like they were just blown away with it. Um, and her quote, I'll do another quote, um, basically said sometimes when you come uh at your fellow ambassadors frontally on the importance of LGBT rights, they can end up in a defensive posture.
[36:21] Tommy: But if you bring them into a show where you watch a young girl grappling with her first crush and seeing life played out forward rather than as a matter of politics or ideology, it can be easier to create more of a sense of empathy and community.
[36:37] Jimi: Yeah, because if that's the thing, if like if they can change literally change the minds of politicians, yeah, oh my grave, like that's like we we s we call shows important all the time, but I think in a very literal sense, it makes this show important.
[36:54] Tommy: Completely.
[36:55] Jimi: Like and I d I don't doubt that it's changed people's viewpoints. I mean, literally, we've already said here that it changed a you know, changed our viewpoints on the case.
[37:03] Tommy: Yeah, but you know, it peeled back peeled back the curtain to a a queer experience we didn't know about.
[37:09] Jimi: But that I is the you know, so often queer representation in the media is is so focused on the queer aspect, yeah.
[37:21] Tommy: In something like a chorus line or something like you know, the producers, all the stereotypical kind of stuff. Even even the ones that are progressive, even the ones that paint them in a positive light often paint them in a tragic light because of the like something like La Cage, which was you know revolutionary time, but still it's not necessarily the happiest couple, but it's like it's drenched in shame and you know and like certainly they come out the other end, like I am what I am, but it is a it is a that that kind of story of triumph has been the at least the gay representation in a lot of media now, and this isn't I mean it's a story of a different kind of triumph, but it it's not triumph over queer issues.
[38:08] Jimi: It's yeah just the triumph of a queer person which is real.
[38:15] Tommy: Yeah.
[38:15] Jimi: Yeah, totally. And I think like 'cause obviously there is there's shame in Fun Home completely reflected in Bruce.
[38:22] Tommy: Um but what I love is that it's you see Alison on the other side of it being like No, I've gotten through this and I've been great with it.
[38:33] Jimi: Yeah.
[38:34] Tommy: Um and I I love I love that. I love that you're able to see this hopeful uh without you know, I'm using inverted commas here, but normal life um that that she's allowed to live and is able to live um in spite of her father.
[38:52] Jimi: And even I mean like Alison says a lot of things about her father and certainly demonstrates that she feels a lot of ways about her father, but I don't think once does she ever feel ashamed about her father.
[39:05] Tommy: Yeah, not at all.
[39:06] Jimi: Which is and like even beyond, you know, like on the list of things to be ashamed about, beyond just being gay, but having relationships with underage kids and like uh, you know, kind of yeah, like there is probably high up there.
[39:24] Tommy: It's it's kinda high up on my list.
[39:26] Jimi: He did some dirty stuff. He you know, he just abandoned his children to go cruising in New York.
[39:32] Tommy: Yep, like there are things there to be ashamed about, and that but that's the easy route, you know.
[39:40] Jimi: Yeah, she's she is exploring it, I think deeper feelings and more nuanced opinions of her upbringing.
[39:49] Tommy: Completely.
[39:50] Jimi: And I think it's so important. I mean it's weird speaking about it because it is just her life. So it's not character creation, right? It's like you can't be like, why didn't you do it this way? Well, because that's not how it happened. But I think what is really crucial to it all is the fact that it is her father. You know, you have that kind of unspoken unquestioning respect for your parents in some way, no matter how awful they are. Because like her dad was abusive, he was violent, you know, he wasn't a good father in many respects. But at no point did she ever like I hate him or anything like that. It's just we didn't understand each other, and she sees it from such a mature point of view.
Like Alison Bechdel's a good gal. It's just presented in this really interesting way. And that's really, you know, as much as you can't say like, well, why didn't you tell it this way because that's not how it happened? She does, and then Jeanine Tesori and Lisa Kron very intentionally do mess with the timeline as a way of telling their story. If you can't mess with the content, you still have so much control over how you craft this story and what story you're trying to tell.
[41:08] Tommy: Yeah, and when things are presented, yeah. And you're able to paint the characters in that light, yeah, totally. Is that your wife playing the piano?
[41:18] Jimi: Don't worry about her. La la la la la la la la la la la la la la la la la la la la la la maybe not right now.
[41:20] Tommy: Maybe not right now.
[41:53] Jimi: La la la la la la la la la la la la la la la la la la la la la la.
[42:05] Tommy: Um well let's talk about the ladies. They're fabulous human beings. Yes, thank you, Jeanine Tesori, Lisa Kron, and Jane Tesori for making this important in the musical theatre world. Yep, this is a ding ding ding ding ding moment here. So the first entirely female authorship team to win a Tony Award. In what year is it? So what after 70 Tony Awards?
[42:30] Jimi: Yep. Awful.
[42:36] Tommy: Yeah. Well, and so certainly I think, you know, author-director authorship representation, creative representation across gender lines is a difficult thing to pin down in history. There is no very specific why has there been no female authorship team other than institutional and prolonged chauvinism in all corners of the world.
[43:06] Jimi: Completely and utterly. Because there's no lack of female songwriters.
[43:25] Tommy: Right. Do you know what I mean? There's lots of them. But writing for the theatre, it's like it's just a male world. Like it's awful. There's everywhere you look, everyone's a bloody man.
[43:36] Jimi: And I would wager that's not even, you know, is everyone a bloody man or are people just producing male-authored plays?
[43:44] Tommy: Yeah, well, exactly, exactly. Everyone you're seeing is a man.
[43:48] Jimi: Yeah. Which is so wrong. So I'm so glad that we're able to see them win. Oh no, wait, we weren't able to see them win. Why weren't we able to see them win?
[43:57] Tommy: Because there was a commercial break.
[43:59] Jimi: A commercial break. We were busy learning about cars or something or some prescription drug.
[44:05] Tommy: Yeah, I was so glad I read more about, I don't know, Vicodin, is that a drug? The history of Tony Award producing is sorted and filled with awful, awful scuffs like this one, not very this historic, historic Tony Award.
[44:23] Jimi: Completely. Like you saw literally 20 seconds of Jeanine Tesori saying a few words. But what we will do for you now, alongside Sydney Lucas, we'll post an equal 12 show notes of this speech. Because everyone's so it's just besides anything, it's just really inspirational. It's just great.
[44:40] Tommy: Yeah.
[44:41] Jimi: Of course it's great. They wrote this thing. Of course they're gonna be inspirational.
[44:46] Tommy: Exactly. I think that's, you know, in the same way we talked about like the lesbian experience is not the gay experience, and so there are things we don't know about it. This would and some certainly tinged by some stereotypes of gender expression, but this wouldn't be the same show if it was written by guys. It just wouldn't. I mean I can't I literally can't imagine what it would be like.
[45:11] Jimi: Other than probably quite poor.
[45:14] Tommy: Yeah, I bet you it wouldn't have done as well.
[45:16] Jimi: And all about Bruce.
[45:19] Tommy: Yeah, and all about Bruce. Um I can't I can't work out what it would be like at all.
[45:25] Jimi: Yeah.
[45:26] Tommy: Yeah.
[45:28] Jimi: So thank goodness that it was done when it was done. I think the origin story of it was that Lisa Kron had read Fun Home and went to Jeanine Tesori being like, this will be a great musical. She'd never, Lisa Kron had never written a musical before.
[45:44] Tommy: She's the first one.
[45:46] Jimi: Um, but this is their first ever musical, which actually blows my mind because not only did she just write the book, she wrote the lyrics as well.
[45:55] Tommy: Yeah.
[45:56] Jimi: And it doesn't sound like someone's first time at lyric writing.
[45:59] Tommy: No, it sounds stunning at all. Absolutely amazing. Like, please write more musicals, Lisa Kron. Please.
[46:06] Jimi: And yeah, it just came from that, and like we said, like Alison Bechdel barely had anything to do with it, and they were able to conjure this amazing story, the pair of them. So I'm very pleased that they won because it's so deserved. Because they deserved it.
[46:24] Tommy: Well, and they're, you know, the rumor always was that Hamilton was holding off their Broadway transfer until the Tonys for Fun Home, very specifically so that Fun Home could take the awards that Hamilton would have taken away from it.
[46:40] Jimi: Yeah. Um which who knows how true that was, but uh Hamilton would have been, I don't know if we would be talking about Fun Home had Hamilton.
[46:40] Tommy: Yeah, maybe not, maybe not with this much urgency.
[46:55] Jimi: Yeah, very true, which is quite sad to think, isn't it? That's something I always think about quite a lot is the luck of the draw when it comes to Tony seasons. Well, the luck of the draw when it comes to musicals, 90% of staged Broadway musicals fail.
[47:06] Tommy: Ninety percent.
[47:08] Jimi: Yeah. And you're running up against insane odds if you're trying to stage a Broadway musical. Don't let this deter you. You should absolutely do it.
[47:16] Tommy: Yeah, but make loads.
[47:19] Jimi: Um you know, put your mind in that headspace.
[47:23] Tommy: Yeah, and that's it, it doesn't even if you win the best Tony, it doesn't, I mean who remembers A Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder?
[47:29] Jimi: I saw it on tour recently. It was great.
[47:32] Tommy: Alright, okay. Who in the UK remembers it?
[47:35] Jimi: And by it was great, I say it was okay.
[47:38] Tommy: Yeah, exactly. But just because you win the Tony for best musical doesn't guarantee you a legacy, but if there was ever gonna be a musical, you should have a legacy.
[47:47] Jimi: Exactly. All of that to say Fun Home is a very special and important and deserves all of the success it has gotten and more.
[47:56] Tommy: Completely, completely.
[48:31] Jimi: I'm up so far. Teddy, there's a school. There's grandma's house. There's Uncle Pete's farm. I can see all the Pennsylvania. I can do Pennsylvania.
[48:53] Tommy: A picture of my father.
[48:56] Jimi: And I don't even care.
[49:01] Tommy: Made of little muffles.
[49:12] Jimi: So Tommy, that was Fun Home.
[49:14] Tommy: That was Fun Home.
[49:15] Jimi: Are you Thomas by the way?
[49:17] Tommy: Legally, yes.
[49:19] Jimi: Yeah, in the same way I'm legally James.
[49:21] Tommy: You're legally James?
[49:22] Jimi: Yeah, I know, right? Come on.
[49:26] Tommy: I don't know if this is a bad idea, but my middle name is James.
[49:26] Jimi: My middle name is Thomas.
[49:31] Tommy: What?
[49:32] Jimi: Separated at birth.
[49:34] Tommy: To be honest, it could be my granddad was called Thomas. So that would be.
[49:37] Jimi: Separated at birth. My granddad was called Thomas.
[49:41] Tommy: Oh my god, we have the same granddad.
[49:43] Jimi: Probably that seems likely. Literally the same. Um when I was younger, I actually gave myself a name of Thompson. I don't have a middle name, sorry. Um so I called Thompson because it was the name of my dentist. And I used to tell people, yeah, my parents named it after my dentist. I was a weird, I was one of those weird kids that lied.
[50:04] Tommy: We should get to this quiz question.
[50:06] Jimi: Yes, we should. Okay, so our quiz question for next week. For the next musical we're gonna talk about. Yep. Okay, so this musical was revived, okay? And this revival was so good that it caused an audience member to strip completely naked because they loved it that much.
[50:26] Tommy: What?
[50:27] Jimi: What? Scandalous.
[50:30] Tommy: And it wasn't scandalous, just to let you know.
[50:35] Jimi: Does this mean people saw her vagina?
[50:38] Tommy: Vagina.
[50:39] Jimi: I think so. Thanks, Charlie.
[50:42] Tommy: Um if you like this episode or if you didn't like this episode, you should review us on iTunes. It helps us out a whole lot.
[50:47] Jimi: It very much does. It really does. We ain't just saying that.
[50:52] Tommy: Um and if you'd like to get in touch with us to speak about anything specific or just to critique our accents respectively. Um Twitter, excuse me, on Twitter, I am Jimi at Asin Hendrix.
[51:10] Jimi: Um and the same on YouTube. Um I'm at Musical Mash on Twitter and Musical Theatre Mash on YouTube.
[51:17] Tommy: Yes, indeed. With the British spelling of theatre, which I really appreciate.
[51:20] Jimi: That's true. Well, because there's so this is the thing, and people will argue with me about this. This is a distinction that American English has that British English does not. At least as far as I was taught in American English, theatre R E is the art form or the concept, and theatre E R is the building.
[51:37] Tommy: Oh well, there you go.
[51:39] Jimi: And it lets you tell them apart, but it does make it difficult sometimes in my URLs to know which one you can do.
[51:44] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.
[51:45] Jimi: Exactly. Um and if you want to speak to us as a collective, then you can and tweet us at Jim and Tomic or get in touch on our website, which is also Jim and Tomic.com. And there'll be a link on the website to Reddit discussion where you can also talk about this. So many options to talk to us. We're so available, so available crazy.
[52:06] Tommy: So available.
[52:07] Jimi: Swipe right on Jim and Tonic.
[52:09] Tommy: Exactly. And because we're so nice, swipe, yeah, to make to accept us.
[52:14] Jimi: Yes.
[52:15] Tommy: Yeah. Um so yeah, swipe right to us, please. Uh and if you do like us, please tell your mates, your pals.
[52:24] Jimi: Your pals, your buddies.
[52:26] Tommy: Um, all about us because we want to share the love. We want to speak to them.
[52:29] Jimi: Yeah, we want them to swipe right on us too.
[52:33] Tommy: Damn right. We'll see you next Wednesday.
[52:35] Jimi: I think we will.
[52:39] Tommy: Goodbye.
[52:41] Jimi: Goodbye.
[52:42] Tommy: What's your do up to do a British goodbye?
[52:45] Jimi: Chip chip cheerio.
[52:47] Tommy: Top tall.
[52:50] Jimi: Goodbye.
[53:04] Jimi: Vagina.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
