Discuss on Reddit ➤ Support the Show ➤ Jimi and Tommy talk about Rodgers and Hammerstein’s record-breaking debut, ‘Oklahoma!’ The gang discuss where the show fits in a contemporary setting, the importance of narrative choreography and the birth of the two most important names in musical theatre history!.. Read More
From the show: Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour
Featured Shows
About
Jimi and Tommy talk about Rodgers and Hammerstein’s record-breaking debut, ‘Oklahoma!’ The gang discuss where the show fits in a contemporary setting, the importance of narrative choreography and the birth of the two most important names in musical theatre history!
Oklahoma! (1998 London Cast Recording)
SHOW NOTES
If musical theatre history is your thing, then look no further than Broadway: The American Musical beautifully narrated by Julie Andrews!
Also if you are interested in race representation in musical The Great White Way by Warren Hoffman is a good starting point.
Check out the glorious Agnes DeMille, one of the true founders of narrative choreography.
Oklahoma was the first musical to contain a dream ballet - have a look at the 1955 movie’s attempt at it!
What are you opinions and experiences with narrative choreography and dance on Broadway? Let us know on Reddit!
Stephen Sondheim owes a lot of his career to Mr Oscar Hammerstein II. Have a look at this great interview where he talks a little bit about his influence.
As it’s the holidays we’ve got an exciting giveaway in next week’s podcast so be sure to tune in and find out the details!
A LEGGY QUIZ QUESTION
Which musical contains Broadway’s premiere prosthetic kickline?
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Jimi: Uh, Rogers and Hammerstein.
[0:02] Tommy: Stein?
[0:03] Jimi: Steinstein. Now here's the thing.
[0:04] Tommy: What one?
[0:06] Jimi: I say Stein. I've always said Stein. I looked this up. It's in whatever way I say it in Sondheim: A Brief Chronology, that's the right way to say it. Because I actually did a lot of research to figure out the right way to say it. Wonder if we can now can't remember.
[0:24] Tommy: Hammerstein pronunciation.
[0:26] Jimi: I like looked him up saying it.
[0:28] Tommy: Oh, interesting.
[0:29] Jimi: Yeah, because I figure he says it right.
[0:32] Tommy: Yeah, Stein.
[0:33] Jimi: I thought so. I think it's probably supposed to be Stein as well, if we're being really, you know, correct.
[0:39] Tommy: Yeah.
[0:39] Jimi: Um, of course it's Stein.
[0:42] Tommy: Of course it's Stein.
[0:42] Jimi: Of course it sometimes says Stein. I thought, I mean, people get up in my business all the time about saying names wrong. I think Hammerstein, Hammerstein is the bottom of the barrel least offensive offenses.
[0:53] Tommy: Yeah.
[0:55] Jimi: Well, Paul Hammerstein out there is gonna tell you something else about that. Sorry, Paul. Well, somebody get us another drink. Welcome to Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour, late night edition.
[1:07] Tommy: Uh, your weekly podcast with champagne and shoff shoe. I can't really think of another sh because I think we've done shuffling.
[1:15] Jimi: That's still fun though, because it's alliteration, it's all how it sounds, not how it looks.
[1:20] Tommy: Exactly.
[1:21] Jimi: Exactly. Um, what are you drinking this evening, Thomas?
[1:24] Tommy: Uh, I've got me a nice cold glass of sarsaparilla.
[1:31] Jimi: Uh, yeah, I just said bourbon.
[1:34] Tommy: That's, do you have sarsaparilla in, uh, we don't.
[1:37] Jimi: I mean, I know what it is because of, um, Annie Get Your Gun.
[1:42] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:43] Jimi: Uh, as I know most of my American beverages from Annie Oakley.
[1:48] Tommy: Well, you know, they have the beverage song right in the middle of that musical.
[1:50] Jimi: Exactly, exactly. Um, so what is it?
[1:56] Tommy: What is it like, root beer?
[1:58] Jimi: It's, um, it's a bubbly drink, it has a little bit of a savory tinge to it. Um, it was a predecessor to Coca-Cola, I would say.
[2:08] Tommy: Okay.
[2:08] Jimi: Okay. Um, but yeah, it's non-alcoholic.
[2:14] Tommy: Thanks.
[2:15] Jimi: Most like this musical.
[2:17] Tommy: Exactly.
[2:18] Jimi: How sweet. Well, it does feature an alcoholic or, you know, a probable alcoholic.
[2:23] Tommy: So probably, yeah. Say what you will. Um, okay. We had a conversation last week. What was it, Tommy?
[2:28] Tommy: Our quiz question last week. There is a certain romantic duet which has the royal seal of approval. What musical is this from?
[2:38] Jimi: It is from the legendary Oklahoma.
[2:42] Tommy: Dun dun dun dun dun dun dun dun dun dun dun dun dun dun dun.
[2:48] Jimi: Right? That'll be it should be like that. Uh, no, I was just gonna do it. What a beautiful morning.
[2:52] Tommy: So jokes on it. Jokes on you.
[3:03] Jimi: The corn is as high as elephant's eye.
[3:09] Tommy: And it looks like it's climbing clear up to the sky.
[3:18] Jimi: Oh, what a beautiful morning. Oh, what a beautiful day. I got a beautiful feeling. Everything's going my way.
[3:36] Tommy: This musical is by, um, Mr. Richard Rogers and Mr. Oscar Hammerstein II. This is our first Rogers and Hammerstein. Isn't that crazy? Like, it's hard for me to picture them not together.
[3:48] Jimi: Uh-huh.
[3:48] Tommy: Yeah, I think it's one word. Rogers and Hammerstein.
[3:51] Jimi: Rogers and Hammerstein. No spaces. Rogers and Hammerstein. But yeah, how have we managed to go a year without doing an RH?
[3:57] Tommy: That's, I mean, I think it's not really our cup of tea.
[4:01] Jimi: Oh, it's my, I love them, but we'll talk about that later.
[4:04] Tommy: Yeah, yeah, exactly. Um, so yeah, this was their first show that they ever wrote together.
[4:09] Jimi: First collab.
[4:11] Tommy: Yep. It opened way back in 1943.
[4:14] Jimi: At the St. James Theatre on Broadway, and then premiered over in London in the Theatre Royal in 1947. And had unprecedented success in both places.
[4:24] Tommy: In a time where shows ran for 200, 300 performances, the first Broadway production ran for more than 2,000 performances.
[4:32] Jimi: Exactly.
[4:33] Tommy: Over five years.
[4:34] Jimi: Yeah, that's crazy.
[4:35] Tommy: That's nuts, isn't it? Um, it was revived a couple of times quite successfully in 1998 in the West End, weirdly enough.
[4:44] Jimi: Um, starring Mr. Hugh Jackman.
[4:45] Tommy: Of all people.
[4:47] Jimi: Of all people, um, that one transferred across the pond. And then, uh, there's a movie of 1955, and it's a very faithful reproduction. Rogers and Hammerstein themselves were big players in the creation of it.
[5:02] Tommy: So if you watch the movie, you get a pretty good sense of what the original was like.
[5:08] Jimi: Exactly.
[5:09] Tommy: And, and as I feel like all of their, um, all of their movies, all of their movie adaptations are really, really, you know, they stick, they stick to the source material.
[5:20] Jimi: Yeah.
[5:20] Tommy: Well, and they were, maybe we'll talk about this a bit more later, but they were, um, roadhouse movies. So they were toured around to different theaters and presented with the same kind of pomp and circumstance that you would a normal musical.
[5:33] Jimi: Yeah.
[5:34] Tommy: So they would like have an intermission and show it three times throughout the day, and like people would dress up to go see 'em. It was a big deal.
[5:41] Jimi: Exactly.
[5:42] Tommy: Exactly. So very good. Um, so what is Oklahoma with an exclamation point?
[5:47] Jimi: Oklahoma starting the long tradition of ending musical titles with an exclamation point.
[5:52] Tommy: Absolutely. Fiorello, Hello Dolly.
[5:55] Jimi: Not Fame.
[5:57] Tommy: Not Fame. No exclamation point there. Oklahoma is, I mean, in its broadest sense, is a, uh, take on, um, territorial Oklahoma and its journey into becoming a state, and the story of maybe two sets of love interests that are in that era.
[6:20] Jimi: That's a nice way of fitting it.
[6:23] Tommy: Yeah.
[6:24] Jimi: Yeah.
[6:25] Tommy: Yeah, it's about the territories.
[6:27] Jimi: Yeah, it's about Oklahoma territory. It's about, um, the differences between cowboys and farmers and kind of a good old-fashioned love story.
[6:38] Tommy: Mm-hmm.
[6:38] Jimi: With a little bit of murder thrown in for good measure.
[6:41] Tommy: With, uh, I forgot how dark some parts of this story are.
[6:45] Jimi: It's so dark.
[6:48] Tommy: It's crazy.
[6:48] Jimi: It's crazy, and like very, I mean, that this obvious again, we'll probably get into this, uh, in a smidge, but this has never been seen before.
[6:57] Tommy: Yeah, and it turns on a dime a little bit too, um, sometimes between its happiness and its darkness. So we've got who our dynamic duo, Curly and Lori.
[7:11] Jimi: Lori, yes.
[7:12] Tommy: Lori.
[7:13] Jimi: Which is, I know males called Lori, and it always confused me.
[7:17] Tommy: Yeah, no, Lori's a girl, Curly's a guy.
[7:19] Jimi: Yep.
[7:19] Tommy: Um, Curly's in love with Lori for sure.
[7:22] Jimi: Lori can't make up her mind, oddly.
[7:24] Tommy: But she's, she's pretty like she's, she's there. You know, I mean she, she wants to.
[7:27] Jimi: She wants to.
[7:30] Tommy: He's a cowboy. So he's, and the farmers in the cowboy, they, well, can they be friends?
[7:35] Jimi: We'll find out.
[7:36] Tommy: Um, to be discussed. Uh, but also is the like evil with a capital E, Judd Fry.
[7:43] Jimi: Yeah.
[7:44] Tommy: The farmhand on Aunt Eller's farm. Aunt Eller is Lori's aunt, but also everyone else's custodial, uh, semi matriarch.
[7:54] Jimi: Yes.
[7:54] Tommy: Um, she's the mother to the town.
[7:57] Jimi: Um, but Judd Fry is a dirty old farmhand who's got his eyes on Lori.
[8:03] Tommy: And, and also is out to get Curly.
[8:07] Jimi: Yep, for getting his eyes on Lori.
[8:10] Tommy: Yeah. And kind of her B plot is, uh, Miss Ado Annie, the delightful Ado Annie.
[8:19] Jimi: It's, uh, really more than anything. I think Ado Annie and Will Parker have entered the common parlance as just references towards a type, even more than Curly and Lori.
[8:29] Tommy: Exactly, exactly.
[8:30] Jimi: They were the pioneers.
[8:32] Tommy: Yeah, so to use the term. Ado Annie famously can't say no. Uh, you know, she, uh, um, when, uh, when a guy starts to kiss her, sometimes she just can't say no.
[8:44] Jimi: And so she's got that.
[8:47] Tommy: What is it? Sometimes when I lose a wrestling match, it kind of feels like I won.
[8:53] Jimi: She's got great, great messages for the girls out there.
[8:56] Tommy: Absolutely. Slash sarcasm.
[8:58] Jimi: Yeah, absolutely. Well, um, Will has been away in Kansas and big modern fancy Kansas with its, um, you know, gas buggies going by themselves.
[9:08] Tommy: It's like the technological future.
[9:11] Jimi: Exactly.
[9:11] Tommy: Um, she's been having it off with Mr. Ali Hakeem, who is, uh, a peddler from Persia from, from non-specific slightly racist, more than slightly racist depiction of India.
[9:25] Jimi: Um, so all and chaos and hilarity ensues.
[9:30] Tommy: Exactly. Hooray, hooray. They auction off lunchboxes, we dance, there's a marriage, someone gets murdered.
[9:39] Jimi: In the movie, we light a haystack on fire, and lots of talk about selling things and buying things.
[9:45] Tommy: Exactly. Exactly. What more do you want? Really, I think Monopoly: The Musical is just a spin-off of Oklahoma.
[9:52] Jimi: Well, I'll be, I'll wait and see. Maybe it won't be set in Oklahoma, maybe it will be set in like Maine.
[10:00] Tommy: I don't know. Everything's like a dream in Kansas City.
[10:05] Jimi: It's better than a Magic Ryan show.
[10:08] Tommy: You can turn the radiator on whenever you want some heat.
[10:12] Jimi: With every kind of comfort, every house is all complete.
[10:15] Tommy: You can walk to Primies in the rain and never wet your feet.
[10:19] Jimi: They've gone about as far as they can go.
[10:22] Tommy: Yes!
[10:25] Jimi: Come here. Everything's up to date in Kansas City.
[10:30] Tommy: They've gone about as far as they can go. Let's talk a bit about, uh, you know, Oklahoma is well known to be one of the main, it's the cornerstone almost of musical theater.
[10:44] Jimi: Absolutely.
[10:44] Tommy: And this, I mean, this is why we're talking about it. This is in some ways arguably the genesis of this art form we now know and love.
[10:52] Jimi: Exactly, exactly. Um, so it is really, it's been heralded as the first proper book musical, um, which is, you know, the kind of, uh, landscape that we see on Broadway in the West End and everywhere else where musical theatre is being created.
[11:11] Tommy: That's what we see now. We see book musicals for the most part.
[11:12] Jimi: It is the art form, the art form that came before the things that would have been musical-esque before Oklahoma and Showboat to an extent, are not recognizable by today's standards.
[11:25] Tommy: People don't perform things like that anymore.
[11:29] Jimi: Well, yeah, I mean, it's like there were kind of hints towards it. Obviously, we had, um, things like, you know, Pal Joey, um, they were, but they were really just a collection of songs.
[11:43] Tommy: Yeah, the, so the tradition of like musical performance on stage, briefly and unspecifically, was kind of these vaudeville music hall performances where it was a variety show.
[11:55] Jimi: There were a bunch of different acts, there were, you know, comedic vaudeville shtick acts, there were songs, there'd be dance, there'd be ballet sometimes, just kind of woven together, but not really one piece of show per se.
[12:09] Tommy: No, yeah. No.
[12:10] Jimi: And it was, well, it was Mr. Hammerstein when he teamed up with, um, Jerome Kern and they made Showboat. I guess that was the first time kind of on stage where people were like, huh, I'm not laughing. This is weird.
[12:23] Tommy: Um, and it, it kind of laid the, or opened the gate so that Oklahoma and musical theater could walk through it effectively.
[12:33] Jimi: And where Showboat certainly had a book, had a plot, had a bunch of songs and dance numbers tied together for the first time, Oklahoma did that and was wildly successful.
[12:44] Tommy: Yeah.
[12:44] Jimi: And I think, I think where Oklahoma is different is that, you know, the songs interweave, you know, it all interweaves together. It's, it's a proper harmony of, um, music, book, and dance, yeah, all together.
[12:57] Tommy: It seems so ridiculous and pedestrian to talk about today because it's such the standard. But the fact that like you had a scene, and then the scene turned into a song, and then at the end of the song was another scene still related to the song, like that was brand new.
[13:10] Jimi: That was a creative and revolutionary idea around this time. And here were characters, you know, going on this really distinct arc, you know.
[13:19] Tommy: People were making choices and going on journeys.
[13:22] Jimi: Um, and not just one or two, we're talking, you know, all of the characters for the most part.
[13:22] Tommy: For the most part would have that.
[13:31] Jimi: Um, so yeah, I think one of the first, I guess, revolutionary points of it, um, comes in the opening number, you know?
[13:41] Tommy: Yeah.
[13:41] Jimi: With "Oh, What a Beautiful Morning," you know, the stage opens, and there's a woman turning butter, uh, and in walks Curly, uh, and he sings a really lovely, um, just a nice happy song about, uh, walking in the morning.
[13:58] Tommy: Yep.
[13:58] Jimi: Um, that had never been seen before.
[14:01] Tommy: Nope.
[14:02] Jimi: And it totally still like it sets up so many things. We, I don't remember which podcast we talked about it upon, but like the first couple lines determine the rest of your show.
[14:10] Tommy: "Oh, what a beautiful morning, oh what a beautiful day. I've got a wonderful feeling, everything's going my way."
[14:15] Jimi: That's Oklahoma. That's the whole show. Everything ends up going Curly's way. Like that's kind of one of the big thesis of the show.
[14:23] Tommy: Yeah, definitely. Um, normally what would have happened in the opening of the show, you'd have big brassy colors, lots of lovely women running on stage and singing a big opening grab you by the balls chorus number.
[14:38] Jimi: Um, and here we were, you know, in rural Oklahoma.
[14:43] Jimi: Um like we're setting a setting. We're not just in a music hall anymore. Although I will say I do find it wonderfully interesting. The because this is such an early musical, the play up between the um diegetic and non-diegetic nature of some of the songs. Like even Oh, what a beautiful morning, um, Curly says a bunch of times, like, Oh, Aunt Eller, I'm just singing to you. Here I go, I'm gonna sing again. And like exactly it is interesting that um when when Will comes back as well in Kansas City, is like, well, I'm gonna sing about it, guys. Exactly. It's like here, let's do this dance. Like, and this is still a step towards non-diegetic music. Like, this is still in the realm of non diagesis for the time period. Exactly. Exactly. Um, they were really trying something out there, yeah. Um, which is is absolutely fine. So um uh basically Oklahoma was kind of born in uh a very interesting time, I think. And I think this is one of the main reasons why it was very successful.
[15:51] Tommy: Yeah. So it was kind of penned or or hoped to be created by the Theatre Guild, which is basically like the uh uh kind of again cornerstone of theatre in America. They wanted to make um a musical out of the play um that wasn't very successful, um, called Green Grow the Lilacs. Green Grow the Lilacs. The Territories. Um they yeah, they wanted this play. They kind of knew who they wanted to get. They wanted um Rogers and Hart, who were known to be, you know, the writers of musicals, that's what they did. Um, and they were they were the best you could get. But um Lawrence Hart uh was coming kind of to the end of his time, um was suffering through alcoholism and and not having a good time, so they kind of kept on uh Richard Rogers and um Hart kind of left him to go find uh um another collaborator.
[16:50] Jimi: Yeah. Um and you know and they found Oscar Hammerstein. So the the two they'd never worked together before. I think they'd met like once before back in the past. Um but this was you know, this was a a huge risk. Yeah. It was a huge risk, putting these two unknowns who were great in their fields, irrespective. Um but not never together before. Never exactly. So there was no on paper this wasn't gonna work, you know. Absolutely and and turning, you know, a uh kind of a non-comic piece into musical comic theatre. Yeah, exactly. That again, this was they were doing some some risky things, but yeah, um, you know, they were they were really financially struggling at that point. So I think they were they were hoping for a miracle, I guess.
[17:42] Tommy: Yeah. We're we're also so 1943 America we are in the middle near the end of World War II and so there's a that has a whole big effect on the psyche which definitely trickled down into theater world, you know. We we need this escape, we need this kind of idealism, but music hall fluffy vaudeville isn't quite gonna cut it anymore. I think that's it, and it was something I can I guess I only really realized it while I was researching this, but it you know, I think Pearl Harbor was something like 16 months or something before um Oklahoma was premiered, yeah. Um so it's still extremely fresh in everyone's minds.
[18:22] Jimi: Yeah. Um and I think people it was almost like America was just ready to grow up. Yeah. Do you know what I mean? It's enough of this fun time nonsense. Let's actually, you know, make a point. Yeah, and it's it's an interesting melding because musical theater itself is still escapism, right? At this time we're not like super super in-depth shining a magnifying glass on what's going on right now. We're still hearkening back to, you know, when Oklahoma's becoming a state. Um but there's there's definitely a tinge of something more serious there.
[19:01] Tommy: Yeah. You know, we're we're still not in a completely idyllic 1890s, you know, turn of the last century, Oklahoma. Exactly. And I think that it just yeah, in that in that way that the world was just ready for something just a bit more grown up. And it's weird thinking of Oklahoma as grown up because it's still extremely idealistic and yeah, and a lot of fun. But by today's standards' standards. Yeah. Yeah, exactly. By today's standards, it's it's Piff. But um, there's a lot of darkness, like we said before, in Oklahoma. Um the show, and I think you know, it's it's that way like people wanted to kind of lift the veil on this now. They didn't want to necessarily just go and say everyone either falling in love or comedians falling over and hit in their face and things like that. They wanted to see almost a bit more of reality.
[19:50] Jimi: Yeah, and it's I mean it's it's a musical of two love stories, and they're they're dirty, messy love stories. They're not, you know, Prince Charming. They're we're we're closer to Romeo and Juliet. Like there's it points it like doesn't pretend there aren't problems in the world, which is a new thing for this kind of musical vaudeville comedy entertainment. Totally. And I think it I find it really interesting that on its opening night, um it it didn't sell well. You know, I mean it wasn't sold out by any stretch. Um but through reviews and word of mouth, I think it was the next night they had cues around the block. Yeah, and and very very soon after it was completely sold out. Yeah, um and that just goes to show how how much people were needing this and how much people were wanting this. I find it so interesting that it it was literally like a spark that you know ign ignited something really special.
[20:48] Tommy: Yeah, absolutely. What happens now? Just keep your hand in mind feel so branding, mom say we're in all. So obviously Oklahoma in the in the forties makes a lot of sense. It was huge and revolutionary. If you go see Oklahoma now, it don't feel the first bit revolutionary. Right, exactly. It feels like now it feels nostalgic and fluffy and feel good and almost like a piece of operetta, and much less like, you know, Dear Evan Hansen or next to normal. Like we've come a long way more than like more than half a century. Yeah. So like it's it's it's very much it's become the escapism that it was running away from.
[22:26] Jimi: Right. Exactly. You know what I mean? Yeah, which is interesting. Absolutely. Um so like what's I mean, what's your experiences of Oklahoma? I mean, I it's like Oklahoma to me is important, but not it's not a musical I listen to in my spare time, you know. It's important to know where you came from. It's important to understand the history, and that's why I think it's important that everyone listen to Oklahoma, but I don't recommend Oklahoma as like a shining star on the hill example of musical theater. Like it's fluffy and presentational and bland and by today's standards, um, by you know, where we are now, and I do like it is interesting to me that even the 90s set of revivals were as successful as they were in the 90s.
[23:18] Tommy: I suspect they're more with the older crowds, with the kind of nostalgic theater going crowds, you know. The the spring awakening teenage crowd, I don't think you could ever convince to go to Oklahoma without some serious concept or rewrites. Or you know, you cast Hugh Jackman, right? Exactly. Like there's the the star appeal there too. But even then, I mean Curly Yeah, he's uh he wasn't Wolverine man. No, he wasn't Wolverine, and Curly doesn't do a lot in this musical. Yeah, but he's still there, he's still a little bit pretty. Um but no, I because I I don't know. I I really love it. I really love it. It's it's my favorite, is it my favorite? Yeah, it's my favorite Rogers and Hammerstein.
[23:59] Jimi: I could say I it's probably my uh it'd be a toss up between this and Cinderella. Um right, okay. Yeah, for me, it'd be toss up between this and Cinderella. Okay, yeah. Um, but I really enjoy going to watch Oklahoma. I really, really enjoy going to watch it. I it's one of those shows that if I see it in my local theater, yeah, I'd go, kind of regardless of who's doing it. Uh huh. Um because it's difficult to get wrong. Yeah, it is very hard to do wrong. It's I mean, this is one of those shows that's like super popular with Amdram and high school productions.
[24:36] Tommy: Absolutely. Because it is I mean, big asterisk next to this, but it is inoffensive, it is like super like it's Oklahoma. We're doing Oklahoma. Who could possibly have a problem with us doing Oklahoma? Asterisk me, but we'll get to that. Yeah, exactly. I think that's the thing. Is it's like it has uh it's almost become a good mus a strong museum piece. Yeah, exactly. I guess it it is it is a period piece of two periods. This is the interesting thing about all pieces of dramatic work, but we see it in our world too, is every performance piece, every book, every piece of art that's created has two eras. The era it set and the era it was created in.
[25:23] Jimi: And Oklahoma is a representation of both of those. So of like 1890s, 1900s Oklahoma, and of you know, m early 1940s New York America urban life, um, which is super interesting. Like it is certainly also kind of a dumbed-down depiction of country life, and we're doing some mocking here from the urban New York Rogers and Hammerstein perspective. Um, which I think is really fascinating, and it's not something like that. That is a meta story. That is a story outside of the play, and is not something that is represented just on stage itself.
[26:08] Tommy: I mean, is it I mean uh dumbing dumb because if you think of I mean, I obviously I'm not from America, so my ex you know, I am the kind of person that buys into the stereotype because is what I see. Right. If if I think of, you know, if I think of Westerns, and if I think of uh all of the fiction that I've taken in of you know the territories in and in that era, then it feels very relevant. It feels it feels correct. So the the song you have to look at most is Kansas City. Um this is a mockery of how behind the times territorial Oklahomans were, and is a pseudo-mockery of how behind the times western states are considered by urban areas, both in the 1940s and I would say now.
[26:58] Jimi: Um like everything's up to date in Kansas City, you know, they have all the modern conveniences, and the joke is us 1940s know that, like, oh yeah, radiators, of course. Oh yeah, telephones, of course. This is not, it's like, you know, everything's if we were like everything's up to date in Denver, Colorado, they've got rotary telephones, like as we sit here laughing with edibles. Exactly. Like as we, you know, sit here with our iPhones, like yeah, um it's but is but I I don't I still don't see that as a mockery though, because I I'm sure you know, in those days when people weren't traveling as much and we're just staying where they're I don't think it it is I don't assert that it is a all in all in out intentional mockery.
[27:49] Jimi: I mean, it's definitely supposed to be a comedy, it's not supposed to be sincere, right? And it is supposed to have that point of view of, oh, I'm looking at the past and oh look how much we've come on. But I would say for them, and that, you know, and when I say them, I mean like Will and Anne Eller, like it would be exciting and it would be dramatic because it was a different time, you know? And when, so then my assertion is when that's the story you pick to tell in nineteen forty-three New York, you're pointing out, you're, you know, whether intentionally or not, you're saying, look at how simple these people were. Simple, dumb, simple, insulting. But that's the thing is I don't think it is dumb. Huh. I don't, I don't think. I just think it's, I mean, they didn't have as much technology, yeah. Sure. Um, but I don't see it as stupid. I don't, I don't. I just find it exciting.
[28:47] Tommy: Okay. I guess, you know, I join in with the excitement, like the whole town joins in together in excitement of being up to date in Kansas City that they all start dancing. Like, I don't know, I think that's, I mean, I would, I would qualify this as 1940s shade where we're trying really hard to read these people and make sure it's very covert and that they don't understand the insult while we snicker in the background. Like, I think you, I think you got duped, but who knows? Maybe I'd like to do that.
[29:16] Jimi: But do you not think there is a truth to it? I realize we're laboring the point here, but do you not think there is a truth to it that, you know, I'm an elderly woman, uh-huh, living who, and I've lived my whole life in the territories?
[29:28] Jimi: I don't really know what technology they've got.
[29:30] Tommy: Yeah, I mean I right, but it's still because it's a mockery, like I get so the sticking point is you don't think we're calling them stupid and I do.
[29:41] Jimi: Um and the thing I don't know if this is an Amerocentric thing or something I've picked up on just recently because of lots of current events, but there is a I would say a dangerous stereotype of the dumb southerner of the dumb westerner in America that this perpetuates started that creates for a lot of separatism in the States.
[30:09] Tommy: Um we're very far away from Oklahoma the new stuff.
[30:13] Jimi: Sorry, we are.
[30:14] Tommy: But um yeah, it may be uh huh.
[30:16] Jimi: Yeah, we'll discuss it on Reddit.
[30:19] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.
[30:21] Jimi: But um it's an interesting one.
[30:23] Tommy: It's a it is interesting.
[30:24] Jimi: I do um I do think there's a lot of exterior commentary from the time period this was made in.
[30:32] Tommy: Yeah, I guess I'm a I'm a um I'm a Brit, so it's a different experience for me.
[30:39] Jimi: Umbody gonna slug out anything.
[30:46] Tommy: This here's a party.
[30:49] Jimi: Sing it, Andrew.
[30:51] Tommy: Dumb diddy um dumb dumb.
[30:55] Jimi: The farmer and the cowlands should be friends.
[30:59] Tommy: Oh, the farmer and the cowards should be friends.
[31:11] Jimi: Well's territory is a state joins the union just like all the others.
[31:17] Tommy: The farmer and the cow and my chunt must all behave themselves and act like brothers.
[31:25] Jimi: I'd like to teach you all a little saying and learn these words by heart the way you should.
[31:36] Tommy: I don't say I'm no better than anybody else.
[31:42] Jimi: But I'll be damned if I ain't just as good.
[31:46] Tommy: I can say I'm no better than anybody else.
[31:50] Jimi: I'll be damned if I ain't just as good.
[32:07] Tommy: But basically, so one of the things that I think's interesting about Oklahoma is you know, you can't really, like I was saying before, you can't really go wrong.
[32:16] Jimi: You also can't really do that much to it.
[32:19] Tommy: Um but not that people haven't tried, which I think is very interesting, and I think a lot of people really, especially nowadays, uh-huh in in certain amateur productions I've seen and other ones that I've read about, um, they really try and dig to to make a strong statement here.
[32:38] Jimi: Yeah.
[32:38] Tommy: Um really what it is is the statement, it's not there, it's not to be found.
[32:42] Jimi: We weren't we weren't ready in musical theater for that yet.
[32:45] Tommy: For that, and so it's just not in the text.
[32:47] Jimi: I mean it's oh what a beautiful morning, oh what a beautiful day, I've got a wonderful feeling everything's going my way.
[32:51] Tommy: That's as deep as it gets.
[32:53] Jimi: Exactly.
[32:53] Tommy: Yeah, completely.
[32:54] Jimi: I mean, obviously it, you know, it does deal with some dark themes and everything, but it's not, you know, we're not looking at race and race relations in the territory.
[33:07] Tommy: You know, relationship like marriage relationships.
[33:11] Jimi: We're not really taking a deep dive into those things.
[33:14] Tommy: Yeah, we're really, really not.
[33:15] Jimi: But um, so I I read on Wikipedia about the 2012 Siasta production.
[33:20] Tommy: Uh did you read about that one yet?
[33:21] Jimi: I did not.
[33:22] Tommy: So basically, I will tell. So remember, I can't remember what epit was, but one of the ones we were talking about race or fave top.
[33:30] Jimi: Um but it was the one I was telling about the ragtime production of the cast A Black Man Is Is the Grandfather.
[33:38] Tommy: Yeah.
[33:38] Jimi: And how inappropriate that was.
[33:40] Tommy: Well, the 2012 Seattle production of Oklahoma cared to take that a step further by casting a black man as Judd Fry.
[33:49] Jimi: Oh, oh boy.
[33:51] Tommy: Yeah.
[33:51] Jimi: And that opens up a whole can of worms.
[33:54] Tommy: So this uh I mean, so this is I think this ties with another subject further down, which I'd like to talk about, is some of the dated representations in this.
[34:03] Jimi: Um but you're right, that does open a whole interesting can of worms of having the hired labor on a farm.
[34:03] Tommy: The hired labor on a farm who's hated by everyone who you know is drunken and evil and goes to assault the the lovely daughter of the farm, and who is you know cajoled into hanging himself by the you know resident cowboy, right?
[34:34] Jimi: Um and at the end dies and nobody there's no justice for it.
[34:38] Tommy: Right, you know what I mean?
[34:39] Jimi: It's literally the opposite of what you would want to see, like and and so I think the implied question is is that okay, right?
[34:48] Tommy: Are they allowed to it not are they allowed, but is that an appropriate thing to do, right?
[34:53] Jimi: Right, exactly.
[34:54] Tommy: So I think to answer that question, we have to talk about Ali Hakim, right?
[35:00] Jimi: Um the Persian peddler, the Persian traveling salesman.
[35:04] Tommy: Okay, yeah, Persian up until like maybe nineteen ninety-five, played by a white white man.
[35:12] Jimi: Yep, a white non-Persian man and is Persian just for the comedy of it.
[35:19] Tommy: Is Persian just so you know he can get kicked around and pooped on a bunch.
[35:24] Jimi: Um like it is And be devious.
[35:28] Tommy: Yeah, it is subtle institutionalized racism.
[35:32] Jimi: This is I mean, I don't think it's subtle.
[35:34] Tommy: Well, so like I don't I don't think it's subtle either, but it's not like r this is the kind of insidious racism that has done awful things for our country and our and the world.
[35:48] Jimi: Um like they're not making him Persian to make a point about how Persians are something, right?
[35:56] Tommy: They're making him Persian because it's just an easy stereotype.
[35:59] Jimi: And they didn't even think about it.
[36:01] Tommy: It was just oh, of course, of course that's how it is.
[36:04] Jimi: And so I think the question of casting Judd Fry as a black man in more contemporary in 2012 is somewhat tied to how you view Ali Hakim as portrayed as a racist white man.
[36:23] Tommy: Well, what I would say to that is one is in the text, yeah.
[36:28] Jimi: And one isn't.
[36:29] Tommy: That's true.
[36:30] Jimi: Uh yes.
[36:32] Tommy: And so then I wonder, like, was that one I think you could find an argument.
[36:38] Jimi: I'm still not taking a side on this, but I think you could find an argument that there is some implication of Judd being a marginalized, you know, uh African American, uh a black person in territorial Oklahoma.
[36:58] Tommy: Um I think there's a bunch of weird muddled connotations with that.
[37:04] Jimi: Um I don't think like Oscar and uh uh uh oh my god I don't think Rogers and Hammerstein sat down and had that conversation.
[37:13] Tommy: I don't think they sat down and were like, this guy's a black guy, but we're gonna have him be a white guy so that it's we don't get in trouble.
[37:18] Jimi: Like I that's not what I'm trying to do.
[37:20] Tommy: I'm pretty sure in the source material he's not black either.
[37:25] Jimi: Yeah.
[37:25] Tommy: And we're we're kind of you know, we're in the West, not in the south.
[37:29] Jimi: We're in a different time period, like this is not you know, but it was you know, like you said, this it was an insidious uh thing in America, I mean absolutely.
[37:42] Tommy: And so I do I think it is an interesting choice and certainly sends a message.
[37:47] Jimi: It makes Judd less of a bad guy if that's the choice you made.
[37:53] Tommy: It it does, but it makes everyone else look demonic.
[37:56] Jimi: Um and that isn't what the sh you know, I mean, I wouldn't leave that show being like, oh Klahoma, like I would be a little bit more than a lot of things.
[38:06] Tommy: You're sending really weird mixed message there, like exactly that's no longer oh what a beautiful morning, oh what a beautiful day.
[38:12] Jimi: Exactly.
[38:13] Tommy: And if that's the kind of story that you want to tell, I wouldn't choose Oklahoma to tell that story.
[38:19] Jimi: Exactly.
[38:20] Tommy: You know what I mean?
[38:21] Jimi: Um But right, let's go back to Ali Hakeem.
[38:24] Tommy: Um so yeah, like I think where you know it's almost like uh um Shylock and the Merchant of Venice kind of thing.
[38:33] Jimi: Yes.
[38:33] Tommy: Only, you know, Ali Hakeem doesn't have his moment of being able to justify himself.
[38:37] Jimi: Right.
[38:38] Tommy: Uh you know, that I guess that's where it differs from the Shakespeare.
[38:43] Jimi: Yeah.
[38:44] Tommy: But it's it is again, it's at that time there'd be no issue with it.
[38:51] Jimi: Right.
[38:51] Tommy: It wouldn't be, I mean, it's it's weird to say, but it's kind of before like racism was invented.
[38:57] Jimi: Um certainly racism in America, you know, America.
[39:01] Tommy: Like not that it didn't exist, but before there were large swaths of people who would be not okay with this.
[39:07] Jimi: Exactly.
[39:08] Tommy: Exactly.
[39:09] Jimi: Which doesn't excuse it, right?
[39:12] Tommy: Um and makes doing revivals of Oklahoma tricky.
[39:16] Jimi: Definitely, definitely.
[39:18] Tommy: Because certain certainly it's not outside the realm of possibility that there was a Persian trader around the Oklahoma territory at this time who kind of just, you know, got in trouble with a bunch of fathers all the time and was accidentally betrothed to a couple different women.
[39:34] Jimi: Like that's not outside of the realm of possibility.
[39:37] Tommy: But it's the insidious institutional racism that's behind the whole thing.
[39:42] Jimi: Exactly.
[39:42] Tommy: That like you you want like a 16-paragraph program note to explain away the whole thing, and at that point we're not off for a nice night of musical comedy anymore.
[39:53] Jimi: Exactly, exactly.
[39:54] Tommy: Um and it's especially because well, the way that it would have been, I guess.
[40:01] Jimi: Um it's one race in a sea of white people.
[40:06] Tommy: Yes, exactly.
[40:07] Jimi: He is he is the outsider and they use his race to that end.
[40:11] Tommy: Exactly, exactly.
[40:12] Jimi: And it is a race thing.
[40:13] Tommy: Yeah.
[40:14] Jimi: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[40:15] Tommy: Um so I guess in in that respect, it's extremely dated and uh definitely controversial.
[40:23] Jimi: Yeah.
[40:24] Tommy: Nowadays.
[40:25] Jimi: Does so does that mean that you can't do it?
[40:28] Tommy: I mean, I if if Hugh Jackman in nineteen ninety five prove anything, no.
[40:32] Jimi: Um I think there are ways if if you appropriately racially cast, if you you know, and then I think you can like we do in a lot of revivals of classics, you know, we it's the beauty of theater.
[40:48] Tommy: We are more flexible with our pre-established texts.
[40:51] Jimi: We can fix some of these things.
[40:54] Tommy: And I think that's the right choice.
[40:56] Jimi: I think it is better to write them to be more culturally and racially respectful nowadays than the argument of like, well, that's what the authors intended.
[41:07] Tommy: Like that's what those authors intended, but we are new authors recreating this piece.
[41:12] Jimi: And I think especially in these cases, we should be allowed to pick and choose and mold and craft and you know, make it fit more contemporary conceptions of these sort of things.
[41:25] Tommy: Yeah.
[41:26] Jimi: I mean, I I certainly wouldn't want to take it on.
[41:28] Tommy: Yeah, absolutely.
[41:30] Jimi: It's it's a difficult conversation to have, especially because it's such a a fluffy piece.
[41:34] Tommy: Like this is the problem.
[41:35] Jimi: This was the big asterisk by you know, no one's gonna say no to Oklahoma.
[41:39] Tommy: Like the Persian.
[41:41] Jimi: Persian people at your school should like Yeah.
[41:44] Tommy: But that's is like you can you don't need to make Ali Hakeem as dark as he necessarily comes across.
[41:50] Jimi: Do you know?
[41:50] Tommy: I mean, he is very much the comic relief.
[41:52] Jimi: Yeah, absolutely.
[41:53] Tommy: In in the show alongside Will.
[41:55] Jimi: He's not he's not the villain.
[41:57] Tommy: No.
[41:57] Jimi: Um so there's not it's not marginalization in that respect, but it's just some little Yeah, just tiny little ones.
[42:06] Tommy: And like those are absolutely the ones, just fix them.
[42:08] Jimi: No one will know.
[42:09] Tommy: Like, just fix it.
[42:10] Jimi: No one will care.
[42:11] Tommy: Like we can you can do this.
[42:15] Jimi: Exactly.
[42:15] Tommy: Yeah.
[42:16] Jimi: Like exactly.
[42:17] Tommy: I mean, the thing is, it's one of the saddest things about it is it's one of the very few representations of Middle Eastern people in musical theater, which is really sad.
[42:28] Jimi: Yeah.
[42:28] Tommy: And like to then try and rite it out is even worse.
[42:34] Jimi: Ahus with shotguns.
[42:37] Tommy: Ah!
[42:39] Jimi: Ah!
[42:39] Tommy: Ah!
[42:40] Jimi: Ah!
[42:42] Tommy: Ah!
[42:45] Jimi: Revolution!
[42:46] Tommy: Revolution!
[42:48] Jimi: It's a problem we must hold in the Star Revolution!
[42:54] Tommy: Alright, boys!
[42:56] Jimi: Remo!
[42:57] Tommy: It's a sandwich, you got it!
[42:59] Jimi: It's a lucky!
[43:00] Tommy: That's right!
[43:00] Jimi: It's a problem!
[43:02] Tommy: We must write!
[43:05] Jimi: I got the answer!
[43:06] Tommy: I go away and don't come back!
[43:11] Jimi: I can't talk right now!
[43:12] Tommy: I got a lot of fun!
[43:14] Jimi: I'm a little bit shy, you know what I'm saying?
[43:16] Tommy: Okay, thanks.
[43:19] Jimi: I gotta go!
[43:21] Tommy: Well, what other messages and things, Tommy, do you think are included in your asterisk?
[43:26] Jimi: So I would the next one I really want to talk about, because it was in that um your favorite book, slash maybe your least favorite book, The Great White Way.
[43:34] Tommy: Um they talk about the lack of American Indian representation in Oklahoma, the musical.
[43:42] Jimi: And this is like a big historical thing.
[43:59] Jimi: Like that is a big part of the moving West of American history. And none of it is in this musical. There is not a single American Indian character. And like it's easy to say, like, well, you know, that's not the story they wanted to tell. But we're in historical fiction land. Like there's representation to be had here. And like the reason the West was dangerous to the white man was because of these native people. And that's, you know, there are sideways and outside references. The reason like cowboys exist and carry guns is because of American Indians. And since that all is present in this musical, it's a big slight not to include it. But 1940s, of course, of course they didn't include it.
[44:56] Tommy: Exactly. That's the caveat to all of this. It's it's not me saying, like, well, we need to write in an American Indian chorus into Oklahoma. Um it's but it is important to acknowledge that these are the pieces that are missing.
[45:12] Jimi: Oh, definitely. Um it's one of the again, being being a Brit. Yeah. It's not necessarily the first thing that springs to my mind because we never get, you know, we don't get taught about the territories, right? And you know, the advancement of the United States in our history class.
[45:25] Tommy: You've um you've lived on your land since time immemorial, literally.
[45:30] Jimi: Exactly. I think literally since zero days. I mean there it it's there are there are clauses in like all of the the UK text that says like we live here because we've just lived here since before we can remember.
[45:42] Tommy: Exactly. Exactly. And like that's not the American experience.
[45:46] Jimi: Not at all. Um so it I guess that isn't, you know, again, if I'm watching Oklahoma, I'm not thinking, hey, where are all the Native Americans gone?
[45:55] Tommy: Right, exactly. I'm thinking, hey, this is fun. Uh yeah, right. And you know, you the the the it's a really sordid history that probably you don't want in your nice comical night out at the theater.
[46:06] Jimi: Right. Yeah, it's almost like there's a time and a place.
[46:07] Tommy: Right. It's it's almost like there's a time and a place. Because I think to be honest, in that day, if you know, Rogers and Hammerstein decided to go out and make this hugely moralistic musical about the territories and how that was affecting Native American culture, A it would probably wouldn't have done as well. Um B musical theater would not have been the time to do that.
[46:30] Jimi: Right. Do you know what I mean?
[46:31] Tommy: Absolutely. Because musical theater was the home of kick lines.
[46:34] Jimi: Yeah. And even if they had done it with the best of intentions, it still would have ended up completely racist by today's standards.
[46:41] Tommy: Yeah. Um if Ali Hakeem is anything to go by.
[46:44] Jimi: Exactly. Um I guess that's the thing is you can't can you can you really say you know, Oklahoma bad for for doing that because I I don't think so, especially in this one.
[46:58] Tommy: I don't think Oklahoma bad for doing this. This is more of like, hey listener, Oklahoma is marked as a big standard of what we consider like the traditional American story, American history. And you know, there are other stories there that we need to remember.
[47:13] Jimi: Yeah, that's the thing. Like, and and if I think I'd if I think about Oklahoma, I don't think of it as, you know, oh, you want to learn about American history, go see Oklahoma, because it is literally like a minutiae.
[47:24] Tommy: But of course, but but that's the thing. This like, yes, and that's the problem. This is one of the things I feel so strongly about musical theater. Because it is so fluffy, because it is so innocuous, that makes its representation all the more important. Like if you did go to Oklahoma to learn about history and this was missing, then people would acknowledge it more. Then people would be like, aha, but here's the thing that you don't notice. But because oh ho hum, it's just this quaint night at the theater, it just becomes a part of the narrative. It just slips in super easy without anyone questioning it.
[48:00] Jimi: Definitely, but it took us a long time to get there on a musical theater stage. I mean it took it took us to to well, I guess to fiddler. It took us about 28 years before we started discussing, you know, hey, there's some problems in the world.
[48:12] Tommy: Yeah.
[48:13] Jimi: Let's look at it through a musical lens.
[48:15] Tommy: Yeah, that's true. I would say, yeah, I mean, there are there are Nazis in the sound of music.
[48:20] Jimi: Yeah, but you know, Nazis bad. That's that's much an easier just like Nazi's bad, done.
[48:27] Tommy: Exactly, exactly. Um that there's not really much gray area needed there. Um whereas you know, uh Fiddler starts to talk about other things and you know yes, and more culturally nuanced items.
[48:41] Jimi: Exactly.
[48:42] Tommy: Nazis bad.
[48:43] Jimi: Exactly. Um Yeah, so uh you've also brought up mental health. Now what I am intrigued to see what you mean by this.
[48:52] Tommy: So this I think I I find depictions in Oklahoma fascinating from a meta-analysis standpoint. Um Judd Frye, to me, is one of the very few bad guy with a capital B, evil with a capital E characters in literature, in musical theater. Um, you know, most other villains, save perhaps Snidley whiplash and like super melodramatic mustache twirling top hat top hat wearing like caped guys.
[49:25] Jimi: Yeah, and it's it's sort of like there's there's no one like him in in like natural fiction and like real fiction. For how nuanced and like um what's the word representational realistic this show is Judd Fry has no reason to be the way he is. Like, or at least not as represented on stage. Judd Fry is just kind of mean and evil and lecherous, and we just say yes to that. And we don't be like, but how did he get there? And as we know from being humans on this earth, no one wakes up in the morning wanting to be the bad guy.
[50:06] Tommy: Um and so I think it is an inter like this is this would be my way into Oklahoma. Um, at least as a case study, maybe not as a as a as a full-fledged production. But the mental health of Judd Fry. How did he get to be the way he is? How does he not see that the whole town disagrees with the way he treats women, the way he exists, like I think there's something to s it's an interesting, you know, I don't I am by no means qualified to psychoanalyze a musical theater character.
[50:44] Jimi: Uh-huh.
[50:45] Tommy: Nevertheless, I think it's interesting to talk about or explore, or even just ponder Judd Fry's mental health.
[50:51] Jimi: Yeah. Well, I mean, it's you know, that that character of the kind of resentful Luner.
[50:59] Tommy: Yeah.
[50:59] Jimi: Um with violent tendencies is really prominent in fiction.
[51:03] Tommy: I guess that's true. Do you know what I mean?
[51:05] Jimi: Yeah.
[51:06] Tommy: There's many, many examples.
[51:08] Jimi: Yeah. Um, and I think in Oklahoma, this has turned into cats.
[51:14] Tommy: How did this happen?
[51:16] Jimi: Like Jimmy B. Tell me part two.
[51:18] Tommy: Yeah.
[51:19] Jimi: But in Oklahoma, uh huh, you know, there's there's a lot to be dealing with, and they just don't have the time to focus on what Jeffrey is.
[51:28] Tommy: I actually it's one of those because uh because one of the things that RH are extremely good at doing is writing and crafting complex characters um with shades.
[51:39] Jimi: Yeah, because if you think of someone like Captain Von Trapp, okay, yeah, um, or even um the the King of Siam, like these are these are sterned hardened men who kind of become warm um and and go on that journey.
[51:56] Tommy: But they start off as these very cold and yeah, yeah, very c cold and uninviting.
[52:01] Jimi: And it's almost just like, well, Judd Fry could be them, but just doesn't get the opportunity to steady on his knife and a poorly delivered metaphor.
[52:11] Tommy: Um Right, because the thing I do know it was weird because I was listening to when I was listening to the Cash Cording, uh huh, and I was listening to Jud Fry is Dead.
[52:11] Jimi: Uh huh.
[52:19] Tommy: And it was like Curly's a dick.
[52:22] Jimi: Yeah, Curly's a dick.
[52:25] Tommy: Well I was gonna say, like, because um, you know, obviously Judd does awful awful thing and is very mean to Laurie, correct?
[52:32] Jimi: Right, um, and I'm sure there's reasons somewhere in in the meta.
[52:37] Tommy: Um, but at the end of the day, you know, telling someone to go kill themselves, yeah, isn't necessarily the nicest thing to do.
[52:45] Jimi: Right.
[52:45] Tommy: And whoever they are. In the so all we have is the story on stage, right? And for the most part, in the story on stage, by the time Curly, you know, is telling Judd to kill himself.
[52:58] Jimi: We actually haven't seen Judd be that bad.
[53:02] Tommy: Yes, that is very true.
[53:04] Jimi: You're just kind of told, oh, Judd Fry is an a nasty man.
[53:09] Tommy: Right. Um and like we're told most of that in uh what is it?
[53:14] Jimi: Poor Judd is dead, old Judd is dead.
[53:15] Tommy: I never remember the names of Judah.
[53:17] Jimi: Poor Judd Fry is dead. Like, we hear most of how Judd is a bad guy from the song where Curly's telling him to go kill himself.
[53:25] Tommy: Yeah.
[53:26] Jimi: And in an ironic sense, like, oh, people are gonna be so sad when you die.
[53:30] Tommy: Right.
[53:31] Jimi: Like, that's horrible.
[53:34] Tommy: It's horrible.
[53:34] Jimi: I mean, like again, we he we are throwing shade.
[53:38] Tommy: Um, like it's really what's happening there.
[53:42] Jimi: Um, but but then it's it's like you know, when he goes and then sings lonely room.
[53:48] Tommy: It to me it makes sense.
[53:49] Jimi: To me, it's like um, you know, it could be the it's the phantom of the opera, yeah.
[53:53] Tommy: It's um the beast from Beauty and the Beast.
[53:56] Jimi: Like it's that character going into his dark place, yeah.
[54:00] Tommy: Um, and you know, backed up by a very dark premonition in a dream ballet.
[54:06] Jimi: Yeah.
[54:07] Tommy: It's he's got he's got no hope.
[54:09] Jimi: Like right, exactly.
[54:12] Tommy: Like it, you know.
[54:13] Jimi: I so want Judd Fry's backstory.
[54:16] Tommy: So I so want to know.
[54:17] Jimi: Like someone will do it one day.
[54:19] Tommy: Yeah, I mean, it will be it will be a musical.
[54:21] Jimi: It'll be the the Rosencranz and Gildenstern are dead of Oklahoma.
[54:25] Tommy: Exactly, exactly.
[54:26] Jimi: We'll do that.
[54:27] Tommy: That can be our debut production, don't we?
[54:29] Jimi: We've been talking about it and teasing it.
[54:30] Tommy: It's it's not a half bad concept for like a one man 20 minute musical.
[54:35] Jimi: Definitely.
[54:36] Tommy: And we can get it right.
[54:37] Jimi: We can include the Native Americans.
[54:40] Tommy: That's really I guess really all these things, the all my asterisks are like, if I were to fix Oklahoma for 2012, these are the things.
[54:50] Jimi: Which I would never do because it's a period piece.
[54:53] Tommy: Like, exactly.
[54:54] Jimi: And you can't, you know, laws say that you can't.
[54:56] Tommy: Right.
[54:57] Jimi: Well, yeah, that's too.
[54:57] Tommy: That's the way.
[54:58] Jimi: Now, the one I will agree with you on is our is our final one.
[55:01] Tommy: Um, but that is the role of women in the show.
[55:04] Jimi: And I will agree with you on that.
[55:06] Tommy: Now, to some extent, um, because I think Lori's an interesting female character.
[55:13] Jimi: Because, you know, in the opening, right at the opening, uh, she sticks up for herself.
[55:18] Tommy: Yeah.
[55:19] Jimi: I I think um this now has a dated opinion of women, but for 1940s, and certainly for 1890s, has a very progressive forward thinking opinion of women's role in society.
[55:36] Tommy: Yeah, but I would say in Laurie's role.
[55:38] Jimi: I wouldn't necessarily say an Idawaney's role.
[55:41] Tommy: I mean, so the the person I think of most as exemplifying a lot of this is actually Aunt Eller.
[55:46] Jimi: Um, because almost every single one of her lines is this like double edged comment.
[55:54] Tommy: And of course, I can't like when she's looking through the the naked woman little wonder thing, right?
[56:00] Jimi: And she's like, Don't look at that. Let me see it.
[56:03] Tommy: Um, and all of her lines are like, stop doing that. Now let me do it. Like, stop breaking the rules. Here's how I'm gonna break the rules.
[56:12] Jimi: And I do think I see in her, in Lori, in Edo Annie, I see that kind of duality a little bit.
[56:20] Tommy: Of like, here are the here are the rules, here's how things should be, and here's how I'm bending them my way.
[56:27] Jimi: Like, even Edo Annie, certainly I can't say no.
[56:30] Tommy: Certainly, that kind of surface level message of like I'm gonna say yes to every man that comes my way, even if I don't want to say yes, um, is not a good message to begin with.
[56:41] Jimi: But she uses it to her power in a lot of ways.
[56:45] Tommy: Like, she's got those two boys under control.
[56:49] Jimi: Um, I mean d yeah, kind of.
[56:53] Tommy: Does she have Ali Hakim under control?
[56:55] Jimi: Yeah, I mean, I would say that's more uh whatever her father's name is.
[57:00] Tommy: Um I can't remember either.
[57:03] Jimi: The one with the gun.
[57:04] Tommy: And uh Andrew, Andrew Carnes.
[57:06] Jimi: Um like yes, I mean she she has them more under control than just the pure lyrics of I can't say no would lead you to believe.
[57:19] Tommy: Yeah.
[57:20] Jimi: Whether she knows it or not.
[57:21] Tommy: Right, okay.
[57:22] Jimi: Yeah, I don't know.
[57:23] Tommy: Just I think like it's that like I can't say no feels very much like the American, you know, I mean, that's right, American standard stick on vaudeville, and it would work absolutely fine.
[57:35] Jimi: Exactly.
[57:35] Tommy: In a number.
[57:36] Jimi: Yeah.
[57:36] Tommy: Um that you know, until we get to guys and dolls almost.
[57:42] Jimi: We don't really see Edoani's character get to a point of strength.
[57:48] Tommy: Right, and like turned on its head.
[57:49] Jimi: Yeah, absolutely.
[57:50] Tommy: Like I it's not, I don't can condone it by any means.
[57:55] Jimi: It's you know, it's like the first tiptoe in that direction.
[57:59] Tommy: I like I feel it.
[58:01] Jimi: It's hard to point to their overt parts where I see it.
[58:06] Tommy: Yeah, I know I do know what you mean.
[58:08] Jimi: But I do think like I'd say Laurie, and again, quite a lot of the characters in um Virgin Hamburstein's shows, the female characters anyway, have that like you see that kind of duality almost of you know the ability to love but isn't ready to just give it up.
[58:36] Jimi: It's not like I'm a hardened woman and I'm incapable of love. It's, you know, I've got it in me. You just need to exactly the right stage. Which, you know, is very one sided and it's very one track, but it was a much nicer way of portraying women than had been done before.
[58:54] Tommy: Yes. You know what I mean? As a lucky lovely, you know, here was a woman who women could look up to.
[59:01] Jimi: Yeah, absolutely. And there's still plenty of that in this show. Um, there's still plenty of just overt poor treatment of women.
[59:06] Tommy: The whole um Oklahoma hello.
[59:09] Jimi: Yeah, uh the Oklahoma hello, most of the dream ballet, um, whatever, whatever that verse is in everything's up to date in Kansas City, yeah. Um, where what is it? She goes all the way uh she took it about as far as she could go.
[59:23] Tommy: Yes, exactly. Like, there's a lot of just awful chauvinism going on here.
[59:28] Jimi: Oh damn right. But you know, it's the time.
[59:31] Tommy: It's the time.
[59:29] Jimi: It's the time, it's the asterisk.
[59:34] Tommy: Yeah, isn't it?
[59:35] Jimi: Yeah. It's the time. It doesn't make it okay, but that's why it happened.
[59:35] Tommy: It doesn't make it what?
[59:39] Jimi: Okay.
[59:40] Tommy: L E H O L.
[59:41] Jimi: It's a pun.
[59:43] Tommy: It is a pun.
[59:47] Jimi: A candle at his head. He's laying in a coffin made of wood.
[59:56] Tommy: What?
[59:57] Jimi: And hoaxer feel insane. Cause they used to dream bad. And now they know their friend has come for kids.
[1:00:20] Tommy: He's looking all so pretty. And so nice. He looks like he's asleep. It's a shame that he won't keep. But it's summer, and we're running out of us.
[1:01:03] Jimi: So we mentioned the dream ballet just there.
[1:01:06] Tommy: Yes.
[1:01:07] Jimi: The dream ballet. Like capital T, capital D, Capital B. The Dream Ballet. This is your there's no, you know, this isn't your entire. We're not talking meta musical here. This is actually what it was called.
[1:01:17] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:01:17] Jimi: Um because it was really, it was the first. It was the first. This was the first time this happened.
[1:01:23] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:01:23] Jimi: Uh-huh. Um and you know, it's kind of like Broadway be prepared to see this for the next God knows how many years.
[1:01:30] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:01:30] Jimi: In the same way that Oklahoma created the form in every other way, it also had a dream ballet. And then you can you it takes more than two hands to count how many dream ballets are in musicals now.
[1:01:43] Tommy: Or had been in musicals now, certainly it's fallen out of favor, thank God.
[1:01:47] Jimi: Yeah. Um do you know what my favorite dream ballet is?
[1:01:51] Tommy: Which one?
[1:01:52] Jimi: The pajama game.
[1:01:54] Tommy: Yes! Yes!
[1:01:55] Jimi: Because it's so ridiculous. This is the pre so okay. There are what what there's a dream ballet in Oklahoma, there's a dream ballet in West Side Story, there's a dream ballet in Bye Bye Birdie, there's a Dream Ballet in the Pajama Games.
[1:02:08] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:02:09] Jimi: And most of them save perhaps the Dream Ballet in Oklahoma, you may not have seen if you go see these shows. Because nowadays they're just cut.
[1:02:17] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:02:20] Jimi: They're just like, oh my god, this is 15 minutes long. Nope. Big X through Dream Ballet. But so you have to understand the Dream Ballet, it's important to understand where we came from. And that the previous musical theater form was a variety show vaudeville act, which may include a more legit dance piece, just separate from everything else.
[1:02:44] Tommy: And so of course it stands to reason that when you put a book on top of it, you keep the ballet. It's not like they added the ballet because they thought this was the best way to represent this moment. It's that the ballet was ex it pre existent and was folded into the form.
[1:03:00] Jimi: Exactly, exactly. So it was Balanchine who kind of brought um ballet onto Broadway um to use beautiful um alliteration there. Uh but he yeah, so it was he kind of showed that, hey, this is this is fun to see. You can do this on um bro, it doesn't all need to be soft she and tat dance. You can also do this kind of lovely artistic thing.
[1:03:22] Tommy: Um so I think it makes really logical sense for Agnes DeMille to then bring this in.
[1:03:28] Jimi: Yes.
[1:03:29] Tommy: To tell, you know, to because she was she was extremely artistic. Um so it m I to me it just makes a lot of sense for her to bring the kind of highest art dance form um into this to tell a story. And and that, you know, ballet is narrative.
[1:03:44] Jimi: Yes.
[1:03:45] Tommy: Um but you know, I think Agnes de Mille really I mean she created this kind of subgenre of ballet. Of this kind of narrative like a really like a specific storytelling.
[1:04:00] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:04:01] Tommy: Um it's not it's not just like um the nutcracker, where like, yes, there is a story, but sometimes you reach that point where why are we still dancing? Like in, you know, the dream ballet, there's a story the whole way through.
[1:04:14] Jimi: Yeah, and it's and it's a proper stor, you know, I mean it's like yeah, you represent a wedding and then you represent um the uh crashing of the wedding, and then you represent a rape. Like it's there's there's a lot packed into that.
[1:04:27] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:04:28] Jimi: Um and it's not that long. Do you know what I mean? So you really need to be specific with what you're doing. And this is why the Dream Ballet in Oklahoma is not cut anymore. Uh or it is not cut while others are, is because it is pivotal to the story.
[1:04:43] Tommy: Exactly. Exactly. It may not progress the overt plot, but it certainly informs Laurie's character in a really important way.
[1:04:51] Jimi: Yeah. That's I mean, that's her her decision, you know. I mean, where now you would get um uh a solo, uh, that's where she basically decided to change her mind.
[1:05:02] Tommy: Yeah, exactly make the right choice. Um, which is yeah, I just think it's it's a really again a really interesting thing. Um how it's kind of fallen out of favor.
[1:05:14] Jimi: Yeah, oh, I think it's fascinating because so I used to, I think I used to misrepresent this, and I don't know if I've said it on the podcast or we've just talked about it separately. But I used to say things like um ballet, dream ballet is included in musical theater because it is, as you said, that higher art form, that kind of legitimizing art form, and musical theater doesn't take itself seriously enough, and so feels like it needs this, you know, this like flag to wave to be like, oh no, no, no, but we are art. Like we're we're legit, we can do it. Like we got we got the fart jokes, we got the sex jokes, we got the body vaudeville nature, but also hi look, it's it's a painting, like, ooh, the fancy.
[1:06:01] Tommy: Um and I used to use that justification. I think less so now. I think what really happened was I think that was true in a non-incendiary way, and we see the dream ballet fall out of favor because the high art was just represented in the other parts of musical theater.
[1:06:21] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:06:22] Tommy: Yeah, I think there's definitely an extent of that. I mean, I feel like the only reason it was brought back in other shows was because Agnes DeMille just hit the nail on the head, and people are like, Oh, oh wait, that's good.
[1:06:33] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:06:33] Tommy: Oh, wait, wait, wait, wait. Let's let's do that. That makes a lot of sense.
[1:06:37] Jimi: Yeah, and that's why it kind of perpetrated.
[1:06:39] Tommy: Yeah. Do you know what I mean?
[1:06:40] Jimi: Yeah. But then you end up with the the dream ballet in the pajama game. Would you like to describe the dream ballet and the pajama game?
[1:06:47] Tommy: I was so I've I was in the dream ballet and the pajama game.
[1:06:50] Jimi: Oh, you guys didn't cut it?
[1:06:52] Tommy: Absolutely not. Why would you cut it?
[1:06:54] Jimi: Oh wait. Oh my god, if you're a director. You cut it?
[1:06:56] Tommy: Yeah, we cut it.
[1:07:03] Jimi: Yeah, I know. We cut it because I'm not a dance. That's a thing there. Like, it doesn't need to be ballet. We were a ballet dancer. Like, we just popped out of a cupboard and I was dressed like Rambo. Like. Do you know what I mean? And it's that I'm not even gonna say anymore, guys. Not even gonna say anymore.
[1:07:18] Tommy: It's ridiculous.
[1:07:19] Jimi: It's ridiculous. And like you, so as fun as it is, it's not necessary to the story.
[1:07:24] Tommy: No.
[1:07:25] Jimi: No, it's not necessary. But it's really good fun.
[1:07:27] Tommy: It's really good fun.
[1:07:28] Jimi: But you can literally like take the pages out of the script, and no one will even know that you cut it.
[1:07:35] Tommy: No. Well, MTI would.
[1:07:38] Jimi: M T I would. They'd slap a bell on your table and be like, oh, we see that.
[1:07:42] Tommy: MTI would cancel his lunch plans with Samuel French and fly to your high school just to reprimand you.
[1:07:42] Jimi: Just to.
[1:07:51] Tommy: But no, I know I do know what you mean. It is it is very superfluous. Um but uh yeah, no, I I do I do want to talk about why it's fallen out of favor. And why like narrative choreography as a whole, I feel is kind of fallen out of favor.
[1:08:06] Jimi: Oh, okay.
[1:08:07] Tommy: Um that's interesting. Because me, me being a big old fan of Bobby, big Bob Foss. We've not done any Fossies.
[1:08:12] Jimi: Oh no, we did cabaret.
[1:08:15] Tommy: We did cabaret. Um you know, I to me he he was my first instance of being like, oh wow, you can use dance to tell a story. That's great. And then, you know, I learned more and realized oh, quite a lot of people are doing that. Cool. Right.
[1:08:29] Jimi: Um, but I feel like nowadays we're almost just getting back into like spectacle land.
[1:08:36] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:08:37] Jimi: Do you know what I mean? Where it's less you're less using physicality and the body to show a story.
[1:08:49] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:08:49] Jimi: It's just like there's a story being told and there's some good music, so let's dance.
[1:08:53] Tommy: Yeah. I mean, that's you know, uh uh we can easily point to something like newsies, where we don't really need to jump up in the air and do synchronized Russian splits, like
[1:09:04] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:09:04] Tommy: I mean, exactly. Like the point is there, it's like we're happy, so we'll dance. Is that completely classic?
[1:09:09] Jimi: Yeah, exactly. And that you get to the point where you're three quarters of the way through the dance break and you're like, why how did we get here?
[1:09:14] Tommy: Yeah, completely.
[1:09:15] Jimi: And I feel like I'm gonna use an example from from my um book, but uh, you know, from something like In the Heights, because I wrote In the Heights, I don't know if you know how to do it.
[1:09:25] Tommy: Yes, I uh you are you are a little manoiranda.
[1:09:28] Jimi: Yeah, of course. Um sorry we talk about him so much. Uh but no, so kind of directing that and and researching the original production about a bit of a there's so much amazing choreography in that, right? And Black and Bealer is fantastic, and it's the same kind of issue that I had with the Hamilton choreography.
[1:09:44] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:09:45] Jimi: Um it's well, maybe not maybe less so with Hamilton. It kind of seems more appropriate in In the Heights than Hamilton.
[1:09:53] Tommy: Yeah, yeah, but like so the the the dancing, you know, it makes sense, it's it's almost it's diegetic dancing. I don't know if that's the term that you apply to it.
[1:10:00] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:10:01] Jimi: But then there, I think there are moments in in the heights where they're kind of missing out. And so one of the things that you know we did in in my production, and again, I'm Chip Harn, I don't care if we don't care about what I do. Two You're Born White Out Loud. I'm chitting. Um was you know, I love I love narrative choreography, and I like being able to tell a story through dance. Um so me and the other choreographers, for like a number like Breathe, for example, uh-huh. We're like, we want to tell the story of Nina's journey and how Nina feels oppressed by her community through some lyrical contemporary dance.
[1:10:37] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:10:37] Jimi: Um and it worked in my opinion and audience's opinion, it worked really, really well. Um I don't know why we don't see more of that.
[1:10:47] Tommy: I mean, it's it's important. I think I'm not saying I'm a pioneer in that I'm groundbreaking, but it does intrigue me why we don't see as much things like that on the stage.
[1:10:56] Jimi: I do think some of it is, and we're overlooking this, some of it is logistical. Like in the Oklahoma Dream Ballet, it's important to even just recognize that the people playing the characters are different actors. There's a dream lorry, there's a dream curly, there's a dream jud sometimes, um, who aren't just the actual physical people who play those people through the rest of the show.
[1:11:20] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:11:21] Jimi: Um, because you can't expect that, right? I mean, maybe you can if Billy Elliott has shown us anything.
[1:11:28] Tommy: I but that's the thing is I think I think you can like if you look at anything goes or you know, any any of the big dance shows that have been done recently, like the the actors can dance for the most part.
[1:11:40] Jimi: Um the talent you can't say that the talent isn't there on Broadway to do both, like
[1:11:46] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:11:47] Jimi: I don't know. I wonder I don't know.
[1:11:48] Tommy: I yeah, I don't know where it comes from. I don't know whether it's just again, like it's fallen out of favor. People think it's archaic.
[1:11:53] Jimi: Yeah, and and certainly all narrative choreography does not have to be ballet either. Because like it would be easy to fall into the trap of like ballet's not as popular anymore because it feels old and stodgy, which is untrue, but it feels old and stodgy. Um but you can do narrative choreography all sorts of ways. I don't know. I don't know, I wonder if it is this move towards more realistic seeming musicals in some way.
[1:12:16] Tommy: I think it is easier to accept that someone breaks out into song into non-diagetic song than someone breaks out into non-diegetic dance.
[1:12:26] Jimi: Um I don't know.
[1:12:29] Tommy: I don't know, because I feel I feel like the last time it was done well, or you know, certainly to my knowledge anyway, it was in a chorus line.
[1:12:37] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:12:38] Tommy: And that's just about dance, so that's still all kind of diegetic anyway.
[1:12:42] Jimi: Yeah, but then you know, I think they you know, I'm a big big fan of chorus line, so but I think they took it to an extra level. They go with like, yeah, it's dance, and then here's dancing about dance.
[1:12:52] Tommy: Right, exactly. You know what I mean? Uh but I can't think of anything of anything that really like has an extended storytelling that's new. That's not just a revival.
[1:13:01] Jimi: Because like certainly the revivals of West Side Story will have the dream ballet.
[1:13:05] Tommy: Uh huh, completely, completely. It's like you yeah, you don't even really get a big dance break.
[1:13:17] Jimi: When okay, so that's still kind of chorus line era.
[1:13:19] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.
[1:13:20] Jimi: Because of course Fox Pipps about it.
[1:13:23] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:13:23] Jimi: Um I don't know.
[1:13:27] Tommy: Cats.
[1:13:28] Jimi: Sorry to throw out, but cats it has it.
[1:13:30] Tommy: It is story.
[1:13:31] Jimi: There are long, long dance numbers where we're trying really hard to tell a story.
[1:13:36] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:13:36] Jimi: There's dream sequences in Evita.
[1:13:38] Tommy: Maybe Andrew Lloyd Webber's cracked it.
[1:13:40] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:13:41] Tommy: That would be disappointing to see.
[1:13:43] Jimi: He is the founding father of narrative dance in the 21st century.
[1:13:48] Tommy: And then, of course, there's the 20-minute dream ballet sequence at the end of School of Rock.
[1:13:53] Jimi: Um it's so good.
[1:13:54] Tommy: It's so good.
[1:13:55] Jimi: Joey Finn celebrating with all the kids.
[1:14:01] Tommy: Um so yeah, why not? I want to know from everyone else. Where has all the narrative dance gone?
[1:14:05] Jimi: Exactly.
[1:14:07] Tommy: And then people are gonna be like, well, actually, there's a huge dance segment in King Booch, and there's a huge dance section on Buddha Rap.
[1:14:13] Jimi: Recently, I think the only thing that I was like, oh, that's similar. It was Once. That'd be the only time.
[1:14:16] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:14:18] Jimi: I mean, like, I wonder if it's just evolved into other things. Like, certainly, there aren't like I wouldn't peg Lion King as having big extended narrative dance breaks, but I feel there is an essence of narrative choreography in the existence of Lion King.
[1:14:36] Tommy: Yeah, but yeah, yeah, I would agree.
[1:14:38] Jimi: I feel it's rooted in the fact that it's portraying African culture.
[1:14:43] Tommy: Yeah, I guess that's true.
[1:14:44] Jimi: African culture has narrative choreography.
[1:14:47] Tommy: It wasn't like Julie Taymor was like, oh, clearly. I know it's a great choreography. Let's put yeah, no, she came at it from another angle.
[1:14:54] Jimi: That's true.
[1:14:54] Tommy: Gosh, Lion King’s good. I've not thought about that in a while, but yeah, it's good.
[1:14:58] Jimi: I'm happy to bring it to you.
[1:15:00] Tommy: Thanks very much, D.
[1:15:17] Jimi: Hey, cookables, make cookables. Rogers and Hammerstein, Richard Rogers, Oscar Hammerstein the second, the legends, the icons.
[1:15:34] Tommy: Um where would we be without them? Like peanut butter and jelly.
[1:15:38] Jimi: Literally, where would we be without them? We would not have Stephen Sondheim.
[1:15:40] Tommy: We would not have contemporary musical theater in so many different things.
[1:15:47] Jimi: We wouldn't have musical theater.
[1:15:49] Tommy: Yeah, no, we wouldn't. Let it just I mean maybe something else, but like we owe our podcast to them in a lot of ways.
[1:15:57] Jimi: I mean I owe my life to them.
[1:15:58] Tommy: Like there you go.
[1:16:00] Jimi: Easy that it's worth it. It's worth it to just say the list. Oklahoma, Carousel, State Fair, South Pacific, The King and I, Cinderella, Flower Drum Song, and The Sound of Music. Like you heard of any of those? Recognize any?
[1:16:13] Tommy: I mean, pick the one you don't know.
[1:16:15] Jimi: Is it Flower Drum Song?
[1:16:17] Tommy: Good job.
[1:16:18] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:16:19] Tommy: Yeah, fair.
[1:16:20] Jimi: Fair.
[1:16:21] Tommy: We all make mistakes, right?
[1:16:22] Jimi: Um, but every single one of those is like ingrained in the popular culture. Like, there's a Sims, there are a dozen Simpsons jokes about each one of those musicals.
[1:16:34] Tommy: There's a dozen jokes. It features in all popular just literally all popular culture will at some point reference an RH musical.
[1:16:42] Jimi: Yep.
[1:16:42] Tommy: In somewhere or forum.
[1:16:43] Jimi: I'm sure that's the thing. It's like rule 34.
[1:16:45] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.
[1:16:46] Jimi: But this is rule 35.
[1:16:48] Tommy: Rule 35, the RH rule.
[1:16:51] Jimi: Exactly. Um so the guys, let's talk about them. Let's talk about them a little bit.
[1:16:55] Tommy: So interestingly enough, they met. I think it's fated, I believe, in divine intervention.
[1:17:03] Jimi: Uh-huh.
[1:17:03] Tommy: And I believe the powers that be were like, we need musical theatre in the world. Uh there's a guy called Jimmy Mitchell and Tommy Bleep out there who, you know, are gonna owe their lives to this one day. So we need to make sure that it works.
[1:17:18] Jimi: To make this happen.
[1:17:20] Tommy: Exactly. And just little things like um, you know, they both married someone called Dorothy.
[1:17:27] Jimi: Um they both went to Columbia.
[1:17:31] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[1:17:31] Jimi: Um other things I can't remember off the top of my head. I'm gonna look up just now so I can put them out because it's interesting. Hang on. I made a lot of notes on this, did they? Look.
[1:17:41] Tommy: That's fabulous.
[1:17:42] Jimi: Oh yeah, so right. Um, yeah, they both married not even just women named Dorothy, both interior decorators named Dorothy. What is that about?
[1:17:54] Tommy: Um both their fathers are called William.
[1:17:56] Jimi: Uh-huh. Right? Is that I mean, is that how you most meet most people as you ask what their father's name is, and if they if your friends are not?
[1:18:03] Tommy: I mean, I don't, but I think I will now. What's your father's name?
[1:18:09] Jimi: I think more than these coincidences, their writing styles melded the best together.
[1:18:17] Tommy: Exactly. They didn't and they had discovered their writing styles before they met each other, which is totally the thing.
[1:18:25] Jimi: So what is it? They do lyrics, then music. That's their job.
[1:18:28] Tommy: Yeah, so that's the way that they work. So um Richard Rogers famously worked with um Lorenz Hart on a myriad of amazing shows, including Pal Joey, which is a big favorite of mine, but which bothered and bewildered, we owe you know Rogers and Hart.
[1:18:47] Jimi: Yep.
[1:18:47] Tommy: Um and it's weird actually, though, because it only until I started becoming a proper nerd did I realize that it was the same Rogers.
[1:18:57] Jimi: Do you know what I mean?
[1:18:58] Tommy: Because you were the crazy thing. Because Rogers and Hammerstein is one word, yeah.
[1:19:03] Jimi: You never think that exists.
[1:19:06] Tommy: Exactly. And it's the same, like you know, Kern and Hammerstein, that was never a duo name, but they did a show together, or a couple of shows together.
[1:19:13] Jimi: So yeah, that's fine. Um but anyway, so uh yeah, Rogers worked with uh Lorenz Hart, developed his own style, but they always did it where um Richie would write the music, send it over to uh Lorenz Hart, and we would then attach his words to the music.
[1:19:34] Tommy: So in a restricted way, almost um what they then did when Rogers and Hammerstein came together, um because they both believe so so much in the fact that what should come first is the story.
[1:19:47] Jimi: Yeah, it's not the number, it's the story.
[1:19:49] Tommy: It's the story.
[1:19:50] Jimi: Um and they both really really believe that, both advocates of characters and creating rounded characters. Um so already you've got a bit of magic happening there.
[1:19:59] Tommy: Yes.
[1:20:00] Jimi: Um and they felt the best solution to do that would be to start with the lyrics first and then attach the music.
[1:20:06] Tommy: Yep.
[1:20:07] Jimi: Um and I'd be interested to know, and just in terms of people's or writing duos of today, whether that's what they do.
[1:20:16] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?
[1:20:17] Jimi: Yeah, I mean, as much as it's a joke, I think generally the contract comes first anyway.
[1:20:22] Tommy: Um yeah, but do you know what I mean? I mean like when it comes to the actual creative process, um yeah, I'd just be I'd be intrigued. Like what the how the how songs come to be.
[1:20:36] Tommy: It's all that's always the question. When you're which comes first, music or lyrics.
[1:20:40] Jimi: But anyway, yeah, so that's what they did, and it worked, it just worked very well. There's the kind of famous anecdote of um so Oscar had written the lyrics to Oh, What a Beautiful Morning, gave them over to Richard Rogers, and apparently wrote it in about 10 minutes.
[1:20:56] Tommy: Yeah because he was just like this makes perfect sense, of course, that that it did it.
[1:21:00] Jimi: Um so as long as the song takes to sing, he had written the music.
[1:21:05] Tommy: And that's amazing.
[1:21:05] Jimi: That's fabulous. And like it's when it when art is effortless like that, you know it's good.
[1:21:11] Tommy: Um interestingly enough, they didn't. Do you know? I mean, they were very humble and very cagey, and I can I can totally see why, because they were doing something new and risky.
[1:21:22] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:21:22] Tommy: Um just even trying to comprehend that is crazy to me. Like, can you imagine inventing an art form? What that must feel like while it's happening? Like you you have just no idea.
[1:21:33] Jimi: Yeah, can you even do that nowadays? Like, and this I mean this is this is why I'm I'm gonna bring it up again, but um, like this is why I said Oklahoma here comet.
[1:21:44] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:21:44] Jimi: Because I feel like and especially now having seen it, yeah, not in the the kind of holistic way that um Oklahoma had and and created something new, but I just feel like it's it's the next swerve in what you can do with musical theater.
[1:22:02] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?
[1:22:02] Jimi: Yeah, absolutely.
[1:22:03] Tommy: Um I I think that's 100%.
[1:22:06] Jimi: Yeah, I think nowadays it's just really difficult. It's really difficult to do.
[1:22:10] Tommy: That's our that's our that's post postmodernism. This is you know, art studies and history studies. Like there is not only is the everything a remix, but everything is now a remix of a remix.
[1:22:20] Jimi: Yeah, exactly.
[1:22:21] Tommy: And you know also there's a good chance Rogers and Hammerstein felt that way too. Like you don't know the thing that doesn't exist because it doesn't exist yet.
[1:22:33] Jimi: Um it does make me very much understand why they would be cagey, why they would be, you know, humble and not kind of toot their own horn, because this is all new.
[1:22:44] Tommy: They're like they're, you know, pushing their way into the unknown world of book musical theater, which is crazy to think about now because it is not we don't have to specify book musical theater anymore.
[1:22:57] Jimi: We mean musical theater.
[1:22:59] Tommy: Yeah, or you do like the new thing where you know you're a Jason Robert Brown and you're presenting a song cycle to end this narrative.
[1:23:05] Jimi: Yeah, which is like a take on, a take on, a take on a different kind of art form.
[1:23:09] Tommy: Yeah, it's it's just it's so interesting to kind of look at how far we've come since those days.
[1:23:15] Jimi: So yeah, we really we all that we all the boys.
[1:23:17] Tommy: Yeah, yeah.
[1:23:15] Jimi: We all the boys a lot. This is this is why we're talking about Oklahoma. It's really important.
[1:23:24] Tommy: Exactly, exactly.
[1:23:26] Jimi: Um and I think it is it's that it's kind of um brush up your Shakespeare to put to borrow a different thing.
[1:23:32] Tommy: Exactly.
[1:23:33] Jimi: Like you don't you don't have to like Oklahoma. Most people, Jimmy excluded, don't like Oklahoma.
[1:23:39] Tommy: Yeah, and you know what? I do have I do take issue with it because so it was interesting, you know, when we in my theater company that I have was with at uni, um we would every year when it came to like deciding the show, uh-huh, every year, um, I would be pushing Oklahoma.
[1:23:55] Tommy: Uh-huh and if we get into the final four and instantly be poo-pooed, and because they were like, well, listen, you know.
[1:24:01] Jimi: Um and I just find I think it's a big shame.
[1:24:04] Tommy: Yeah, because I like some of the most fun I've had at a theater has been seeing Oklahoma.
[1:24:10] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:24:10] Tommy: I I I yeah, I see that. I wonder, I wonder even like I even think Oklahoma is an important enough piece that that alone is is enough reason to produce it nowadays.
[1:24:24] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:24:25] Tommy: I guess it's it's like a museum piece. It's like taking your granddad out for a walk. Like do you know I mean it's important.
[1:24:32] Jimi: Oklahoma is a lot like taking your granddad out for a walk.
[1:24:35] Tommy: I think that's a really accurate description of how Oklahoma feels.
[1:24:39] Jimi: There's nothing wrong with it. It's important today.
[1:24:44] Tommy: And on that note, I don't think.
[1:25:42] Jimi: Absolutely. Which musical contains Broadway's premier prosthetic kick line?
[1:25:49] Tommy: Hmm.
[1:25:50] Jimi: Hmm.
[1:25:51] Tommy: If you want the answer to that before the podcast comes out, you should check our Twitter on Tuesday night. We're trying a new thing where we're gonna tweet the answer before we release the podcast, so it gives you a chance to listen to the musical beforehand.
[1:26:05] Jimi: Exactly. Thank you, Sharon, for giving us that idea. That wonderful suggestion.
[1:26:10] Tommy: And thank you all again to our uh the people we chatted with. It was fun.
[1:26:13] Jimi: Oh yeah, yeah.
[1:26:14] Tommy: Um Tommy, what is our show Twitter? Where will they find this answer?
[1:26:16] Jimi: If you'd like to find this answer, you can find it on Twitter, the show Twitter.
[1:26:22] Tommy: Twit twit Twitter, the show Twitter.
[1:26:25] Jimi: The show Twitter is Jim and Tomic on Twitter. Uh I am Tommy. I'm at MusicalMash on Twitter or Musical Theatre Mash on YouTube.
[1:26:32] Jimi: And I am Jimmy, and I am Asinhendrix on Twitter and YouTube. And all of this information is on our website, that's Jim and Tomic.com, and there's a link to the Reddit discussion.
[1:26:42] Tommy: And I'm trying really hard to be there. I promise I will be there.
[1:26:44] Jimi: Exactly. The people are wanting you, Mr. T.
[1:26:47] Tommy: And please, uh, if you are listening on iTunes, um, it would be lovely if you could pop on over and give us a little rating, even if you want to write a review. That would be fantastic.
[1:27:00] Jimi: Just lovely.
[1:27:01] Tommy: Hmm. That's all we got. We'll see you next week.
[1:27:03] Jimi: Indeed. We will see you next week.
[1:27:05] Tommy: Ciao.
[1:27:05] Jimi: Bye bye.
[1:27:17] Tommy: We need more state themed musicals, maybe.
[1:27:20] Jimi: I'm really excited. What would you do for South Dakota exclamation point?
[1:27:26] Tommy: What would be involved in that?
[1:27:29] Jimi: Uh I want you to name one fact about South Dakota.
[1:27:35] Tommy: Um, it's Is it above North Dakota?
[1:27:39] Jimi: Is that a thing?
[1:27:41] Tommy: No, it's below North Dakota.
[1:27:42] Jimi: It's below.
[1:27:43] Tommy: I thought that might have been a weird thing.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
