Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Happy Hour #37: Podcast Noir - ‘City of Angels’

Discuss on Reddit ➤ Support the Show ➤ Crack out your smoky sax and don your best femme fatale dress, as we’re going to LA in the 1940s for ‘City of Angels.’ Jimi and Tommy try and work out why we don’t see too much of this show, have a tennis match about the lyrics of the show and discuss the many opportunities for creative teams that the show offers... Read More

From the show: Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour

1 h 13 mins
4/20/17

About

Discuss on Reddit ➤

Support the Show ➤

Crack out your smoky sax and don your best femme fatale dress, as we’re going to LA in the 1940s for ‘City of Angels.’ Jimi and Tommy try and work out why we don’t see too much of this show, have a tennis match about the lyrics of the show and discuss the many opportunities for creative teams that the show offers.

City of Angels (Original Broadway Cast Recording)

Amazon / iTunes / Spotify

SHOW NOTES

Interested in finding out more about Film Noir? Start with the quintessential Maltese Falcon! You can check out the trailer here.

Visiting London anytime soon? Why not check out the West End premiere of ‘The Life’ starring Sharon D. Clarke written by ‘City of Angels’ Cy Coleman?

Thoughts on City of Angels success rate Why do you think City of Angels has never kicked up a storm? Or even just never revived on Broadway? Let us know on Reddit!

We often wonder what goes into the creative team’s decision to showcase what they do at the Tony’s! Have a look at what City of Angels brought to the table.

Want to give yourself a challenge? License ‘City of Angels’ with your local theatre group!

The recent West End revival met some good success. Donmar Artistic Director Josie Rourke weighs in on why she chose City of Angels as her first musical.

A CINEMATIC QUIZ QUESTION

Did you know, John Williams worked arranging the score for the 1971 film version of Fiddler on the Roof. To our knowledge, he’s only ever arranged one other song from musical theatre. This song is the title song of next week’s musical.

P.S. It's not 'Thomas and the King'

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Jimi: Okay, so well let's get jiggy with it.

[0:01] Tommy: Alright.

[0:03] Jimi: Do you remember that song, Will Smith?

[0:05] Tommy: Getting jiggy with it.

[0:06] Jimi: No, I don't.

[0:08] Tommy: I'm singing it.

[0:10] Jimi: With something else.

[0:11] Tommy: But I don't know what.

[0:13] Jimi: Yes, I do remember that song with Will Smith.

[0:15] Tommy: Moral of the story.

[0:16] Jimi: Why isn't Will Smith written a musical?

[0:19] Tommy: Well, somebody get us another drink!

[0:21] Jimi: Welcome to Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour.

[0:25] Tommy: Your weekly podcast with soda and showboating.

[0:28] Jimi: Oh, I like that one.

[0:29] Tommy: Is that from the internet?

[0:31] Jimi: No, that's as an original.

[0:32] Tommy: It's an original Derby Mitchell.

[0:33] Jimi: I'm literally gonna do it until I've squeezed my brain out.

[0:36] Tommy: And then we can peel from the internet.

[0:37] Jimi: But thank you to the people who gave us suggestions.

[0:40] Tommy: We're keeping a list.

[0:41] Jimi: They will be used.

[0:42] Tommy: We're checking it twice.

[0:44] Jimi: Gonna find out who's podcasting nice.

[0:47] Tommy: Ah, because none of y'all are naughty.

[0:51] Jimi: Um what you're drinking today, Mr. T?

[0:53] Tommy: Today I am drinking a gin and tonic with just the gin.

[1:00] Jimi: Did I do that in a good voice?

[1:01] Tommy: That was that was that's close.

[1:03] Jimi: Was that supposed to be like your film?

[1:06] Tommy: Yeah, did you not hear the like saxophone in the background?

[1:11] Jimi: Yeah, exactly.

[1:12] Tommy: She had legs that kept on going, and the only thing that stopped them was the floor.

[1:17] Jimi: Um I'm drinking uh Pinot Noir.

[1:22] Tommy: I wish I thought you would I thought you would get that.

[1:22] Jimi: I thought you would get that.

[1:26] Tommy: No, that's good.

[1:26] Jimi: That's clever.

[1:27] Tommy: I like that more than mine.

[1:28] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:29] Tommy: Thank you.

[1:29] Jimi: Shout out to Titus Burgess.

[1:32] Tommy: Right.

[1:32] Jimi: Why what are we going on about?

[1:34] Tommy: Well, what's this?

[1:35] Jimi: Well, I'll tell you.

[1:37] Tommy: In the song Beautiful City from Godspell lies the title of this, the musical we're gonna talk about this week.

[1:43] Jimi: What music And it's not pale.

[1:45] Tommy: It's not pale.

[1:46] Jimi: I did enjoy someone someone commented and said, Are they just trolling us?

[1:49] Tommy: Are they just gonna do beautiful, the Carol King musical?

[1:51] Jimi: And I was like, Ooh, that would have been good.

[1:53] Tommy: But no, we're not.

[1:55] Jimi: We're doing City of Angels.

[2:12] Tommy: Three million people in the City of Angels, according to the last census.

[2:16] Jimi: Easily half of them up to something they don't want the other half to know.

[2:21] Tommy: We all get sucked in by the lobby.

[2:24] Jimi: Palm trees finger the sky, and there's enough sunshine to lay some off on Pittsburgh.

[2:29] Tommy: But that's all on top.

[2:31] Jimi: LA, truth to tell, is not much different than a pretty girl with the clap.

[3:04] Tommy: Yes, we are.

[3:05] Jimi: The City of Angels, not the city, just City of Los Angeles.

[3:11] Tommy: LA LA.

[3:12] Jimi: LA in the 40s.

[3:13] Tommy: Do you have any other names?

[3:14] Jimi: Uh Hollywood Land.

[3:16] Tommy: Um because you know it's like the big the big smoke.

[3:19] Jimi: Yeah, yeah.

[3:20] Tommy: And I'm gonna try and say this without vomiting.

[3:23] Jimi: La La Land.

[3:24] Tommy: I did it.

[3:25] Jimi: La La La.

[3:26] Tommy: Well done.

[3:26] Jimi: Congratulations.

[3:27] Tommy: No, it's how nobody cares about that anymore.

[3:29] Jimi: Right?

[3:30] Tommy: Um City of Angels.

[3:34] Jimi: Uh huh.

[3:34] Tommy: Uh music by the wonderful Cy Coleman.

[3:37] Jimi: Welcome to our first Cy Coleman musical.

[3:39] Tommy: Who knew it would take us this long?

[3:41] Jimi: Right?

[3:41] Tommy: Cy Coleman feels like he's like second string musical theater.

[3:44] Jimi: I love Cy Coleman.

[3:45] Tommy: Not to put him down.

[3:46] Jimi: But there's you know, Andrew, you got your Weber's, your Sondheimes, your Schwartz's, um, you know, like your Kaufman and Hearts.

[3:53] Tommy: And then like Coleman is further down on the list.

[3:57] Jimi: He's written things you know about, but you don't know that he wrote them.

[4:00] Tommy: Yeah, he's like dancing around with like lesser and um other people.

[4:07] Jimi: Yeah, exactly.

[4:09] Tommy: Um but you so fab uh wrote hits as such as Sweet Charity, uh Barnum, Barnabies and Barnum.

[4:19] Jimi: The Life, currently enjoying its first uh West End premiere.

[4:24] Tommy: Really?

[4:25] Jimi: Despite the fact it was written in the 80s, yeah.

[4:27] Tommy: Well, who knew?

[4:29] Jimi: Um did you you said Sweet Charity?

[4:31] Tommy: Will Rogers Follies that's a big one?

[4:35] Jimi: Yes, indeed, oh won that Tony Award.

[4:38] Tommy: Um so yeah, he's he's good.

[4:40] Jimi: He's he's legit, guys.

[4:41] Tommy: Legit good we also discovered that you he wrote he wrote what song was that uh what is it?

[4:46] Jimi: The song Witchcraft.

[4:48] Tommy: It's Witchcraft, and uh the best is yet to come, uh Frank Sinatra standard.

[4:53] Jimi: There you go.

[4:54] Tommy: He's good, guys.

[4:56] Jimi: He's good.

[4:57] Tommy: Um we also have lyrics by Mr. David Zippel.

[5:00] Jimi: Gonna say Zippel.

[5:02] Tommy: Let's go with that.

[5:04] Jimi: Um, and he uh wrote the lyrics for Hercules and get this, Mulan.

[5:13] Tommy: Really?

[5:14] Jimi: Yeah, man.

[5:15] Tommy: David Zippel made a man out of us.

[5:17] Jimi: He did.

[5:18] Tommy: Like, that's great.

[5:19] Jimi: Who knew that?

[5:20] Tommy: I mean, probably a lot of people, but I think that's so cool.

[5:24] Jimi: Because they're good.

[5:25] Tommy: They're good.

[5:26] Jimi: I mean, Hercules, yeah, that's got some great lyrics.

[5:29] Tommy: It's an it's an interesting crawl.

[5:31] Jimi: Because like Cy Coleman comes from old musical theater, you know, golden agey kind of feeling sort of stuff.

[5:38] Tommy: His stuff is more edgy than some of the more traditional Golden Age stuff.

[5:41] Jimi: But then with Zippel with the more contemporary lyrical twist of like Pop Disney movies.

[5:48] Tommy: It's an interesting combo.

[5:50] Jimi: Yeah, definitely.

[5:51] Tommy: Well, he's I think it's weird.

[5:53] Jimi: Like Zippel kind of pulls from the contemporary in terms of obviously content.

[5:58] Tommy: Yeah.

[5:59] Jimi: And but he has that really strong tongue-in-cheek style of someone like Irving Berlin.

[6:07] Tommy: Yeah, yeah.

[6:08] Jimi: Do you know what I mean?

[6:09] Tommy: With that really high comedy factor.

[6:12] Jimi: Very witty.

[6:13] Tommy: Yeah, very witty, very witty lyrics, very clever lyrics.

[6:13] Jimi: Very clever lyrics.

[6:18] Tommy: And I I do think this is interesting because you don't get many.

[6:22] Jimi: Um also the book's by Larry Gelbart, who wrote one of my all-time favorite movies.

[6:26] Tommy: Do you know what that is, Tommy?

[6:28] Tommy: Uh no.

[6:31] Jimi: Go Tootsie Go.

[6:35] Tommy: You're doing a thing that's supposed to make me figure out what you're talking about.

[6:41] Jimi: You've not seen Tootsie? You call yourself a show queen and you've not seen Tootsie.

[6:46] Tommy: Number one, I've not seen Tootsie.

[6:48] Tommy: Number one, I do not call myself a show queen.

[6:53] Jimi: Oh my god.

[6:54] Tommy: I like that I like that you call it Toot.

[6:59] Jimi: As opposed to what?

[7:02] Tommy: Tootsie.

[7:03] Jimi: Tootsie.

[7:04] Tommy: Tootsie.

[7:04] Jimi: Tootsie.

[7:05] Tommy: No, Tootsie.

[7:07] Jimi: Um, because it's an ooh sound.

[7:08] Tommy: Uh the.

[7:10] Jimi: Yeah, Dustin Hoffman.

[7:12] Tommy: No, I know of the movie.

[7:13] Tommy: I have just not seen the movie.

[7:15] Jimi: Just collab.

[7:16] Tommy: Great.

[7:17] Jimi: We what I'm gonna do, I'm gonna fly over there and just bring a selection of like gay movies.

[7:23] Tommy: I'm really I'm excited.

[7:24] Jimi: And I'm gonna re-gay you.

[7:27] Tommy: You're gonna I have to retest to get my gay card recertified.

[7:31] Jimi: Yeah, yeah.

[7:32] Tommy: You need to take the test anyway, so you may as well really up the game because I know it's getting harder.

[7:38] Jimi: We've got high standards.

[7:39] Tommy: It's really competitive these days.

[7:40] Jimi: Really competitive.

[7:41] Tommy: That's what I hear.

[7:43] Jimi: Um, so yeah, but um anyway, talking about people, um it's interesting because you very rarely get someone on each.

[7:52] Tommy: Right.

[7:52] Jimi: Yeah, right.

[7:54] Tommy: Normally it's like, oh, I'll do music and lyrics, you do boot, or I've got all three.

[7:59] Jimi: Yeah.

[8:00] Tommy: Very rarely, I think do you get well, not very rarely, but it's it's less common, I think.

[8:06] Jimi: I think even three of all the combinations is less common because you get a lot of duos, you get a lot of singletons, or you get a lot of like music and lyrics and book with additional music and lyrics by so and so.

[8:17] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.

[8:18] Jimi: Like people having a hand, yeah.

[8:20] Tommy: Or then you end up with these like Disney amalgamations that have 16 authors because someone wrote the movie and someone wrote the plot of the movie, and someone wrote the original novel that Mary Poppins is based on, and then they brought in a new team to co-write, and all of a sudden the poster is filled with people's names.

[8:36] Jimi: Exactly.

[8:37] Tommy: But what these three chaps have done are create a completely original musical.

[8:44] Jimi: Yeah.

[8:44] Tommy: And that's that's I think that's really impressive.

[8:46] Jimi: Like each of them are kind of masters of their own craft, and they really are.

[8:50] Tommy: Like they have lots of, you know, their CV is strong.

[8:53] Jimi: Um, and here they have come together to create a complete original work.

[8:57] Tommy: Yeah.

[8:58] Jimi: Um, so let's talk about it.

[8:59] Tommy: Let's let's see what what its history is.

[9:02] Jimi: Yeah.

[9:02] Tommy: Where did it all begin, Tommy?

[9:03] Tommy: So this musical started, uh, it opened on Broadway in 1989, ran for a couple years.

[9:09] Jimi: Um, did uh did okay, mildly popular.

[9:12] Tommy: Um, and then it won one Tony for Tony Best Musical.

[9:16] Jimi: It won, I think it won book and score as well.

[9:18] Tommy: Book and score as well.

[9:19] Jimi: So there you go.

[9:19] Tommy: If you could if you needed more testament to the fact that um yeah, that it was it was good.

[9:26] Tommy: And so then it had uh a couple West End productions, one in '93 that didn't that I guess didn't do too well.

[9:33] Jimi: It it didn't really change.

[9:35] Tommy: So but not um not cr critically, like critically, it was really warmly received.

[9:40] Jimi: Um was a hit at the Olivier Awards, won Olivier for Best Musical, Best Actor, um, amongst other I think best director as well.

[9:48] Tommy: Like it really, really did well.

[9:50] Jimi: Um but for reasons which we probably will discuss in a little moment, um, it didn't explode.

[9:59] Tommy: Yeah.

[10:00] Jimi: Um, which is very disappointing.

[10:02] Tommy: But yeah, so they've just they just revived it recently in 2014.

[10:06] Jimi: Um again, quite successfully, but it was only a limited run at the Donmar.

[10:10] Tommy: So there you go.

[10:11] Jimi: Yeah, never never revived on Broadway, of all things.

[10:14] Tommy: Never revived on Broadway.

[10:16] Jimi: Yeah, for for a best musical, I mean that's basically it.

[10:21] Tommy: The Broadway production, the two West End productions, and then you know, a couple regional and local productions here and there, but never a tour, never a revival, nothing off Broadway, nothing off West End.

[10:31] Jimi: Which is strange for a contemporary best musical winner, you know.

[10:36] Tommy: These these shows get second lives all over the place.

[10:39] Jimi: Absolutely.

[10:41] Tommy: So we're gonna try and peel apart why that's why that's happening in a little bit.

[10:44] Jimi: Um, but let's tell you what it's all about.

[10:48] Tommy: So really it's it's a proper homage, a proper love letter to um the classic film noir genre of the 1940s.

[10:56] Jimi: Um it's you know, it is from the get-go from the first stinky saxophone that you've got, um, it you you get transported to that black and white, long-shaded, um, sexy, sultry era.

[11:12] Tommy: And we're we're following the story of Stone, who's a private investigator, and it's it's every stereotype to the nines, you know.

[11:22] Jimi: Absolutely.

[11:23] Tommy: Sexy girls.

[11:25] Jimi: Yep, he's got his his Girl Friday, his secretary.

[11:29] Tommy: Um, and then he's a PI, he's doing a voiceover, and then the action freezes, and you hear the backspace button on a typewriter, and the actors go back in time, and is revealed Stein, the author who is writing this film noir book as we are watching it.

[11:47] Jimi: Exactly.

[11:48] Tommy: So, yeah, he's been commissioned to turn one of his uh he's a novelist, and he's commissioned to turn one of his novels into a film.

[11:56] Jimi: Um, and he's very excited about this prospect because as we all know from our Merrill Lee, we roll a long days, um, that LA is the place to go if you want to make money.

[12:07] Tommy: Um, unless you're in Sunset Boulevard, in which case you will probably fail.

[12:11] Jimi: Um if you're a Melly Laura Long, you're you're gonna do really well.

[12:15] Tommy: Um, so he's very excited about make a lot of money, he's kind of sacrificed his relationship with his wife, she's way back in New York.

[12:22] Jimi: Um, and it's kind of all about how he gets shafted by LA.

[12:28] Tommy: Yeah, it's also on the on the LA story side, I would also say it's pretty stereotypical, like a producer who wants to make all the changes, you know, and doesn't have quite the respect for the art, um, but is super popular, so how dare you cross him?

[12:42] Jimi: Um exactly, exactly.

[12:44] Tommy: And if it feels like there's a real there's some real beef there.

[12:48] Jimi: Yes.

[12:48] Tommy: I don't know whether it's from um Larry Gelbart or maybe a kind of a mix of all three of them may have experienced this along the way, but of this like the producers and the directors meddling in my story, right?

[12:59] Jimi: How dare they kind of idea.

[13:01] Tommy: Yeah, um, which is uh you know it happens all the time.

[13:04] Jimi: And then of course, the the shtick of the whole show, which is really what it's known for, um, is we're seeing both of these stories kind of develop at the same time, and all of the film noir stone stories are presented quote unquote in black and white, and so all the cast members are in like very monochromatic outfits, and like the set pieces are black and white, and then the LA scriptwriting story is in color, and the interplay between those two is where the cleverness and the comedy and the intelligence of this musical comes from.

[13:38] Tommy: Yeah, completely.

[13:39] Jimi: And the end of act one, it all kind of gets thrown in its head as um magic happens and uh Stone interacts with his author, um Stein, and uh that kind of leads the way for the rest of the rest of the show.

[13:56] Tommy: Um yeah, so really in like that's an interesting concept.

[14:01] Jimi: It's really clever.

[14:02] Tommy: It is, it is baffling to me that it's uner that it is original that like they came up with this, it's so layered to start out with.

[14:10] Jimi: In you know, my musical theater assumption world, I assume.

[14:13] Tommy: Well, of course, you started with a story and then added this clever twist onto it, but no, they everything's written from the ground up.

[14:22] Jimi: Um like the cleverness, you know, I think the the shtick of watching the thing that someone's writing is done every once in a while.

[14:36] Jimi: But to really, really dive into it and have duets between characters in the story and out of the story, and you know, every actor save for Stone and Stein plays pretty much a character and a representation of themselves inside the film noir story.

[14:53] Tommy: Um, that's super clever.

[14:56] Jimi: Super clever.

[14:58] Tommy: Um, so why does it never get performed?

[15:01] Jimi: Let's find out after this.

[15:44] Tommy: You've earned your salary.

[15:47] Jimi: Searching for Mallory.

[15:50] Tommy: One up the last heat.

[15:54] Jimi: Well then I am the You've been assigned to find out.

[16:11] Tommy: Okay, so what's going on?

[16:13] Jimi: Yeah, it's a good question. I mean, I enjoy listening to this show. Um, I imagine watching this show is actually probably more enjoyable than listening to this show because it has the visual gags and it is, I think I would say a true on comedy. Um, but I don't think why it didn't do too well is because it's not particularly stunning in any of its individual execution things. It's very like once explored, it's quaint. You know. Dig further.

[16:48] Tommy: Um, okay. Let's so like, what'd you mean by what do you mean by quaint? Sorry. What's the moral of this musical?

[16:57] Jimi: Well, that's I think an interesting thing in its own right. Um, because by the end of the show, it flips the whole film noir idea on its head. Right. Because one of the key features of film noir is that they often don't have happy endings, they're often really melancholic, right? Dark, yeah, towards the end. The private eye gets shot. Um, normally someone, yeah, someone's dead. Um, you know, in the case of something like Sunset Boulevard, he's already dead from the get-go. Um, very rarely do you end with a lovely big happy ending, which is exactly what City of Angels is about. And I think that that plays into the hands of kind of what was happening to Stain. Right. And that his producer was being like, let's make it a lovely happy change, let's do it. And then this is what people want. Right. And it's got almost like a self-fulfilling prophecy.

[17:52] Tommy: Yeah.

[17:53] Jimi: That ends up being a happy ending. That's kind of what I feel, because that doesn't feel intentional. Um, I don't think they're trying to say something there. I think they're trying to end their musical. Um, yeah, I don't, I wouldn't go to the show to be like ready to get my life changed. Do you know? I mean, uh, it's a really just enjoyable conceit with lots of enjoyable little bits and bobs in it, you know. I think that's why it's not terribly successful. Um, you know, musical like people don't go out humming the scenery. Um, and this is a show based around the scenery. There's catchy tunes in this, but there aren't tunes you play on the radio. Um, there's catchy tunes in this, but they're not tunes that stand outside of the show. Um, the plot is kind of quaint and I wouldn't say meandering, but like we're not taken on an epic journey here to there. There's even not a really specific like this is the conflict, you know.

[18:56] Tommy: Um, like that makes I mean, yeah, I would agree. I would agree that definitely it's there's lots it's it's quite convoluted, it's a very intricate story, you know. There's about like 40 different scene changes, which in its own right is mental. Um, I would say, yeah, definitely very intricate, but you can't well, I don't know. I feel it you it's a shame to say that for City of Angels, you know, you don't deserve to do well because your book is a bit complicated when if you think about all of the other musicals that don't have a polished book, which is, you know, I would say more than half of the musical theater genre doesn't have a polished book and yet can still maintain levels of success.

[19:43] Jimi: Um, because I think you only need to look at, um, you know, someone like Andrew Lloyd Webber, right?

[19:51] Tommy: Right.

[19:51] Jimi: Who is, you know, uh, something like Cats, okay? Yeah, I know I'm cat's trash, but it's, you know, show me the good plot, do you know what I mean that you have there?

[20:05] Tommy: I would challenge the Cats comparison because Cats is so out there, but take something like Phantom, which has a million different characters and a bunch of different subplots, but yeah, Phantom you can plug your ears and look at and be like, ah, yes, bad guy, good guy, lady, like, you know, you can walk through the simplest explanation of the plot on it. Whereas like City of Angels has a really interesting plot, and it took us several minutes to kind of get through. Um, and you know, we still haven't talked about anything that happens to Stone the Private Investigator, mostly because it's like not really important or pivotal to the plot. Um, and then the stuff that happens to Stein is to me at least as boring and uninteresting as some of the plot in La La Land.

Um, where it's like, I get it, life is hard, artists struggle, blah blah blah, oh you poor thing. Um, and like don't get me wrong, I still enjoy this show, but I think that's why like there's nothing, you know, what do you put on the poster of City of Angels, not knowing the branding of it? There's not a good thing to point at that this show is about or represented by.

[21:14] Tommy: And like, so you think you think it's just not marketable? You think that's why it's never been picked up again?

[21:20] Jimi: I think so. Maybe that's the point I'm trying to make. Um, like not marketable comes down to a couple things. Like not marketable because there's nothing to market. Um, not marketable because it not because it's complicated. Because like the plot of Into the Woods is complicated, but you know, sometimes hold your hand through it. Um, the plot of this is complicated, is almost unnecessarily complicated at points, maybe. I don't know. I think definitely towards the end of the second act, yeah, but I think that is just a kind of fault of the show.

[21:58] Tommy: Yeah.

[21:58] Jimi: Um, but again, I would say that it's got many friends in the musical theater oeuvre.

[22:05] Tommy: Yeah.

[22:05] Jimi: Um that share that exact same trait of that tricky second act. We've talked about it before, you know.

[22:14] Tommy: Yeah, second act.

[22:15] Jimi: That they're very, very tough. And yet, you know, you see a lot of them over and over and over again.

[22:19] Tommy: Right.

[22:20] Jimi: Um, I d I have a couple of theories as to why it didn't land. Um, one of them is timing.

[22:25] Tommy: Okay.

[22:28] Jimi: So if we look at Broadway in this time, this time period, so um obviously it was 1989 that it opened. Um, what are we just about to get? We're about to get the unveiling of Andrew Lloyd Webber to the world and the takeover um of AL Dubs.

[22:50] Tommy: So again, we've talked about this to the death about kind of why Andrew Lloyd Webber is so successful and da da la da.

[22:57] Jimi: Um, yeah. And you know, there were always these kind of, uh, what’s the word I'm thinking for? Casualties that kind of sit here because of the timing.

[23:11] Tommy: Yeah.

[23:11] Jimi: Do you know what I mean? Um, and I think it is a feeling because one of the main reasons we always said about Andrew Lloyd Webber taking over is because of the dearth um that the 80s AIDS crisis created in the gay community. Um, a lot of the gay community were writers for the theatre. Um, but yet here we have, you know, three stalwarts of the theatre um creating a completely original piece of work um that is really great and really solid.

[23:41] Tommy: Um, and even, you know, I would say beats Cats down to the ground like, um, and yet I it just doesn't get a look in.

[23:51] Jimi: So I can imagine by its second year um on Broadway, people were just getting ready for this mega musical. Do you know what I mean? The birth of the mega musical was happening, and so this more kind of, it's not a concept musical, but it's fun. Do you know what I mean? And it's very old school golden agey um, yeah, that it's really got that vibe, doesn't it?

[24:16] Tommy: Like it's got, yeah, yeah.

[24:18] Jimi: Um, and so they kind of weren't here for that anymore. Um, and so it faded into dust.

[24:25] Tommy: Um, and I would think that's exactly what happened in the West End.

[24:29] Jimi: Um, I know a fair amount of critics kind of believed that, and that this was the kind of birth of the idea that the West End audience um is a little bit dumber than the Broadway audience, and uh, you know, just wants to go see a nice simple lark as opposed to what he's a character and he's a book, uh, yeah, a book and I don't what are you you're the same person you're different right have to think do you know what I mean?

[24:56] Tommy: Um, and you know at the time maybe the West End audience wasn't here for that because they wanted their Miss Saigon's and their Evitas and their blah blah blah as Les Mis's and blah blah blah.

[26:32] Jimi: Um, so I think it was a casualty of time.

[26:32] Tommy: Yeah.

[26:32] Jimi: Um, now when it comes to tours, it's never really had many successful tours, if any, yeah, um it's a very complex musical to stage.

[26:32] Tommy: It is, yes, it very much is because the they're two worlds that have nothing in common and needs they have some very specific requirements.

[26:32] Jimi: Yeah.

[26:32] Tommy: To like very, very specific.

[26:32] Jimi: And like otherwise the shtick doesn't convey.

[26:32] Tommy: Exactly.

[26:32] Jimi: And it is a shtick. I would a hundred percent submit to that that it is, uh, oh, come and see this cool thing that we do.

[26:32] Tommy: Yeah, in the same way, you know, come watch us crash a chandelier on the stage. Like I don't I don't think we're in an art form that's above that. I ain't penalizing it because it's a cool shtick, it's very, very cool, and I love it.

[26:32] Jimi: Um, so that would make it very difficult to just pack up in a box and travel around the country with.

[26:32] Tommy: Um, is well orchestra wise you'd have to be an extremely talented orchestrator to dumb this down and still get that vibe.

[26:59] Jimi: Yeah. Do you know what I mean? That big strong nineteen forties Schmaltzy vibe? Um, and obviously you ain't having an orchestra when you're touring.

[26:59] Tommy: Right.

[26:59] Jimi: So what are you gonna do?

[28:05] Tommy: Um, so I think there's lots of these different reasons. I don't know, there may be something else, people might just secretly hate Cy Coleman because it's the same, it's almost the same with The Life as well.

[28:05] Jimi: Like we've only just got The Life on the West End, and it's been out since 1990.

[28:05] Tommy: He never breaks free of something.

[28:05] Jimi: Yeah, there is something, there is a little something, yeah, and I don't know, because I almost I again almost kind of feel the same with Barnum.

[28:05] Tommy: Yeah, yeah.

[28:05] Jimi: Do you know? Like, there's a little something where I'm just like, oh what is that?

[28:05] Tommy: Yeah, why is it, is it marketing, or you know, maybe it's the sort of thing, who knows?

[28:05] Jimi: We're not biographers, but maybe they're, you know, maybe Cy is very stuck in the decisions he makes, and like there is that room for that little improvement during production that never happens.

[28:05] Tommy: Yeah, maybe that's it.

[28:05] Jimi: Maybe, you know, or you know, we're putting a lot of the weight on Cy. Maybe it was the, um, maybe it was Gilbert who, you know, was playing into his Stein role and was like, I ain't touching this book, yeah girl, this is perfect.

[28:05] Tommy: Perhaps.

[28:05] Jimi: Um, I don't know. I just find it really, really interesting because you know, we talk a lot about oh, there's no original musicals, there's no original musicals. Here's an original musical that's very good, yeah. Do you know what I mean?

[28:05] Tommy: Right.

[28:05] Jimi: Um, never made anywhere.

[28:05] Tommy: Yeah, and everyone's like, what is it?

[28:05] Jimi: Yeah, the, yeah, Angel LA.

[28:05] Tommy: But I feel like I really do, you know, maybe maybe this is one of our hashtag patented disagreements.

[28:05] Jimi: Um, I like this musical, I think it's very good.

[28:09] Tommy: I think there's lots of room for improvement.

[28:11] Jimi: Um, I think it's despite how much we've gone on and on about it being complex, the characters are pretty simplistic.

[28:19] Tommy: Um, they're pretty one-dimensional.

[28:22] Jimi: I don't feel like any of the characters in either of the story happened before the show or continue to happen after the show, obviously.

[28:32] Tommy: Right.

[28:32] Jimi: Um that, you know, whereas like the baker from Into the Woods goes on living his life completely changed and like has a whole and like had a whole past that brought him into this show.

[28:46] Jimi: Um and some of that I think comes from the basis of non-original musicals.

[28:51] Jimi: Um is like you have a whole story and a back, you know, we saw it with all um our great comet interviews about like when you have all of war and peace to set up your character, you have so many things you can develop and pull on and like it creates these deep, deep, multifaceted characters.

[29:11] Jimi: Whereas with something like this, where all you have is the text of the libretto, there's some shallowness there that I'm, you know, maybe not, maybe doesn't end up written down in a New York Times review, but I think is felt by Joe Tourist when he comes in to see this kind of show. It's like, oh, what a fun night.

[29:27] Tommy: Yeah.

[29:30] Jimi: But I again, you know, it's I don't think it ever calls out to being a big hitter in that respect. I don't think it's ever trying to say I'm gonna be in Into the Woods.

[29:38] Tommy: Right.

[29:42] Jimi: I think it's trying to say I'm Dirty Rotten Scoundrels or I'm something similar. I'm Catch Me If You Can. I'm, yeah, Drowsy Chaperone, even. But you know, I mean, but even those, so like maybe Drowsy Chaperone aside, but Dirty Rotten Scoundrels, those characters have passed and are interesting and like, yeah, but it's because based on the...

[29:54] Tommy: Right, but like I think that's the problem. Uh maybe, I don't know, is that it doesn't have a basis, and so like it almost feels like if I, when I'm writing my book How to Write an Original Musical, the first step is to go not write a musical and then turn that into a musical, like figure out a really fleshed out, deep down, well thought out story before you ever pull out, you know, your blank score sheet. Um make sure these characters are real, are three-dimensional, have, you know, families and grudges and gripes, and then pull the, you know, find the three days that make up your musical and just pull those pieces.

[30:45] Jimi: Okay, yeah, I do definitely see what you mean.

[30:48] Tommy: I would say as too many characters.

[30:50] Jimi: Yes.

[30:50] Tommy: There's lots and lots of characters here, but then it all fits into the film noir genre. Do you know what I mean?

[30:57] Jimi: Because if you think of something like The Maltese Falcon, which is like, well, one of the only film noirs I've seen.

[31:08] Tommy: It's a good one to choose.

[31:09] Jimi: Like classic ones, yeah. That you again, you don't at the end of that film, you're not like, gosh, what would, you know, their lives after that? You're just like, and there was that yarn, and it's done.

[31:20] Tommy: Right.

[31:21] Jimi: Do you know what I mean? And I feel like it fits into its own box really well.

[31:27] Tommy: Yeah, you know, I mean, I think it does, and it is a really enjoyable night. Um, and again, we, this is the two sides of the coin that we sit on. I don't mind going for a nice enjoyable night at the theater.

[31:36] Jimi: Right.

[31:38] Tommy: I'd often more want to be challenged, yeah.

[31:42] Jimi: Yeah, exactly. Um, so but, and again, like I don't think, you know, I would say that you, as Mr. Challenge, are in the, would say more in the minority. Do you know what I mean? Like most audience goers do just want to go and have a nice night.

[31:58] Tommy: Yeah.

[31:58] Jimi: Do you know what I mean? A nice enjoyable night? So why wouldn't you like City of Angels?

[32:04] Tommy: Yeah.

[32:04] Jimi: I mean, like, I feel like, you know, I think of people like my mom, um, who would want to, who are probably in the nice enjoyable night kind of camp, but I still think they have a more enjoyable night when they can still leave the theater and be like, oh yeah, we can talk about this thing. Or like how interesting, uh, you know, like very plot point sort of stuff. Um even if it's the, you know, even if it's Beauty and the Beast or something really simplistic, like they're still, I don't know.

[32:35] Tommy: I don't know, you're not gonna leave Beauty and the Beast being like, right, so let's have the chat and about the debate about bestiality.

[32:40] Jimi: Right, but you're also, you're also not gonna leave Beauty and the Beast being like, oh, golly gee, what a nice fluffy night of fun. Like Beauty and the Beast is a story about love and romance and, you know, the challenges of exterior ugliness and like whether you can fall in love with someone's heart or someone's face. Like that's the whole Gaston-Beast sort of thing.

[33:00] Tommy: Like that's deep down inside of Beauty and the Beast. And I do, but then would you not, well, would you not leave this being like, you know, the Hollywood machine, are you gonna fall into that, you know, I mean, greed pattern? Are you gonna try and fight against that? The more, the moral of City of Angels pretty much seems to be like, gosh, Hollywood sucks. The only way to get out of it is to pretend. Um, you know, there's not like a, and here's how Stein saved his book. Like not believably. It's funny. It's a big ol', it's literally a punchline. Um, but it's not, you know, it's a cop-out. It's a Deus Ex Machina. Um, and I guess I have problems with that, I think.

[33:47] Jimi: It's still, it's still very much developing in my mind. This is a musical where like I like it and I shouldn't. You know? Through analysis, through talking about it, this doesn't check the boxes that I normally like to check with a musical.

[34:02] Tommy: Yeah.

[34:03] Jimi: But it's still, I think the sum of its parts make it really great.

[34:09] Tommy: Okay.

[34:09] Jimi: Do you know what I mean? I really do because I think the music, and we'll go on to talk about this in a bit, actually. In fact, let's talk about it right now.

[34:15] Tommy: All right.

[34:15] Jimi: Let's talk music.

[34:16] Tommy: Here we go.

[34:24] Jimi: You could weave in some deceit to weave an upper score. You'd have us all on the floor. That would be roaringly fighting. Set up my life, the joke that suffers in the telling. Just another horrid chestnut from the buttons to roll. I've heard so often before that I can't laugh.

[35:10] Tommy: I think the music of this show is really fantastic.

[35:14] Jimi: And some of Cy Coleman's best work.

[35:17] Tommy: Yes.

[35:18] Jimi: He's on such an odd one. I know we've already kind of teased this already, but I remember like the first time I ever saw Sweet Charity, and I was just like, what is this? And yeah, it was one of those, it like planted a little earworm in my head. And I was like, mm-hmm. Okay, I need to listen to that again, please. And then suddenly I find myself listening to it on repeat and repeat and repeat and picking out bits because it just, it sits there.

[35:45] Tommy: Exact same thing happened with Barnum.

[35:48] Jimi: Yeah.

[35:48] Tommy: Um, I mean, and I kind of grew mentally obsessed with Barnum. Um and City of Angels again, this the same kind of thing. Um not across the board. Some of it, Barn, like you know, I could listen to Barnum forever. Um, I think this has ebbs and flows, but I love its ebbs.

[36:08] Jimi: Yes.

[36:08] Tommy: Or the flows. I don't know what the good one would be out of those.

[36:11] Jimi: Probably the flows.

[36:12] Tommy: Yes.

[36:12] Jimi: I really love the flows. Um, do you know what I mean? So, and yeah, I don't know. I just think it's fab. But let's talk, let's talk a little bit about the lyrics.

[36:23] Tommy: Okay.

[36:24] Jimi: I mean, this is where that's an interesting. I go back and forth like within specific songs. So let's, I don't know, how about the tennis song? Um, which is a great duet and is like the sort of duet that if it showed up at a 54 Below cabaret, I'd be like, oh yes, awesome. You've picked something that people don't know a lot about, but is like really cleverly written. Um and so, you know, it's they're talking about tennis, but they're not talking about tennis, they're talking about sex, but it's about tennis.

[36:52] Tommy: And so it's an innuendo duet. Um akin to, you know, You're the Top or Friendship from Anything Goes, um, which is great, but then it has some lazy rhyming in it, which rubs me the wrong way. Um, you see him at home on the court, let's say that I've played around, great, we're setting up the innuendo. Well, you don't look like the sort. You're just, that is a forced rhyme to me.

[37:17] Jimi: Like, will you, do you think?

[37:19] Tommy: A little bit.

[37:20] Jimi: Like this song has these kind of side, like, uh, what's another similar one? Um, I would say lazy rhyming in that song would be the repetition of courts.

[37:26] Tommy: Right.

[37:33] Jimi: They should have picked a song you can or a word you can rhyme more with because like, um, I'm good at for more than one set, uh for more than one set, but I promise I'll show no regret if you beat me. My backhand is really my fort.

[37:50] Tommy: Shall we say though it's in your court, right?

[37:54] Jimi: It's funny, it's a funny joke, and but the ball being in your court is not specifically a tennis metaphor about sex in this particular moment, as good as my backhand is clearly my fort. Like they've hidden their best jokes not in the last line of the stanza.

[38:14] Tommy: Um, I think you're being really picky here.

[38:18] Jimi: You yes. I want it to be better because the other parts are better.

[38:29] Tommy: Like there are interior parts of this song that are better than the repeated chorus parts, or then like the punchline similar rhyme at the end of stanzas. And flip that. Put your good work where it matters. Um, it bugs me.

[38:48] Tommy: It's not something that I'm like, ah, City of Angels, the worst.

[38:53] Jimi: But it's the sort of thing where like I listen to the tennis song, like, oh, I like this. I wish it was a little better.

[38:58] Tommy: Okay.

[38:58] Jimi: Um, that's so interesting because it's the tennis song is probably one of the bigger songs from the show.

[39:03] Tommy: Right.

[39:03] Jimi: So like, um, uh I think I understand your racket. I'm not in your league, but you can hack it. Fine. Um, this game commences with love, very funny, very punny, great. Um, well, I think love is a bore, still great. Let's give the tempo a shove and raise the stakes a bit more, throwaway lines. Unnecessary. Let's give the tempo a shove. Are we making a musical reference? I don't think tempo is a tennis term unless it's a really deep tennis term.

[39:32] Tommy: Um, and even if it is, it's not a common enough one that me, layperson musical theater listener can understand your reference, and then and raise the stakes a bit more. This is just a throw line throwaway line, so you can get the rhyme. One thing I'm positive of, it's time for someone to score. You're setting up your punchline. Pick a better rhyme than more. Like these sorts of things bug me.

[39:57] Jimi: Yeah.

[39:59] Tommy: But I'm, it's a sort of, I can't come on to because I think, uh, I think I understand your racket, not your league, but you can hack it. Like, that's good. That's good. That's a good rhyme.

[40:08] Jimi: But that's like a really good rhyme.

[40:10] Tommy: Right.

[40:12] Jimi: And so then when they get to let's give the tempo a shove and raise the stakes a bit more, I want it to be good as racket and hack it.

[40:21] Tommy: Like, yeah, but that's, that's, uh, that's less lyrical and more still because obviously they're being like, hey, fourth wall break, uh, let's come towards the end of the song. Do you know what I mean? Because we've been repeating ourselves for a long time in this melody.

[40:37] Jimi: Yeah, we're driving towards the end.

[40:39] Tommy: Yeah, I mean, but like skip it, you know. Um this game commences with love. Well, I think love is a bore. One thing I'm positive of, it's time for someone to score. Like, you don't need it. You can totally cut it. And the song is just as funny. Um, it feels like a rough draft. Um, I feel, I don't know.

[40:59] Jimi: I think you're being over, I think you're being over.

[41:01] Tommy: I don't think it's a rough draft at all. I think there's too much good in it.

[41:04] Jimi: Yeah.

[41:05] Tommy: Do you know what I mean? Like, Sondheim also has throwaway lines.

[41:08] Jimi: Yes.

[41:08] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?

[41:09] Jimi: I think fewer so.

[41:09] Tommy: The best writers always have throwaway lines.

[41:13] Jimi: I think fewer so.

[41:14] Tommy: I would, I think, I think you can go through Into the Woods pretty with a pretty fine-toothed comb, and it would be hard to come across something that doesn't at least serve two or three purposes. Whereas like, let's give the tempo a shove and raise the stakes a bit more. There are little internal rhymes in there. We're not telling you anything about the character, we're not telling you anything about the plot. We're like repeating a musical phrase to build up tension in the song, maybe.

[41:44] Jimi: Um, but that's about it.

[41:49] Tommy: Mm-hmm.

[41:51] Jimi: Aww. I know it's, I feel bad that I don't like it. Um, I just want it, I yeah, I think, I think that's being, I don't know. I worry that that's looking for problems. Do you know what I mean?

[42:05] Tommy: Maybe.

[42:05] Jimi: But that's what we're sure, like, but that's what we do.

[42:10] Tommy: Yeah.

[42:10] Jimi: But then I don't know, I feel like there's shows that we've done where we would sing their praises and it's not look at the faults because we just love them so much. Do you know what I mean?

[42:19] Tommy: Maybe for me then, maybe this is what I'm feeling, and maybe at the beginning too. It's tiny things like this that happen over and over throughout this musical that make it, you know, B minus, B plus, and why it's not as, why it doesn't come across as stunning as it should be. Because for every stunning, interesting rhyme, there's a throwaway line in the same song. Um like with one more look through with a little tune up that, you know, it tightens the ship.

[42:53] Tommy: And like, but wouldn't that make the lift it from great to perfect?

[42:58] Jimi: Yes.

[42:59] Tommy: I mean, bad musicals are made up of tiny bad moments. Bad musicals, bad musicals that are this successful. I'm not saying this is a bad musical, musicals that have like unsuccessful moments. Generally, it's not because one big thing is wrong with them, it's because a bunch of tiny little things are wrong with them.

[43:15] Jimi: Um and like the tiny little things in this one are fixable. The tiny little things in this one, like are the things you work out during previews. Um, you know, based on production research history, it doesn't seem like this was particularly rushed or particular, like this is the thing they lay with, they were like, this is the one. Not at all, but I think it's obvious that work's gone into it because there are so many really smart rhymes and lyrics throughout the whole show.

[43:42] Tommy: Do you know what I mean? It's not just oh here's here's my good lyric song, here's my Patsy song. Like, there's so much innuendo, the comedy is really on point.

[43:52] Jimi: Yeah, um, their internal rhymes are insane. Like, like so so good. Um, and again, throughout across the board. I think that's so commendable.

[44:02] Tommy: Yeah, okay. So let's say uh another one I wrote down, Lost and Found. Um short little song, actually, um, sung slow, because it's a ballad.

[44:12] Jimi: Uh teasing lips, pleasing thighs, easy on private eyes is a really funny joke. Right?

[44:20] Tommy: And it's definitely and it's not a it's not a haha joke, it's like a clever joke. Um because it's like easy on the eyes is a saying, you know, I'm gonna take all the humor out by walking through the comedy of it, right?

[44:33] Jimi: But easy on the eyes is a saying, he is a private eye, he's a private investigator, easy on private eyes, like that's great. When sung, because it's such an extended ballad, you miss some of the comedy in that joke because of the musical phrasing of easy on private eyes or whatever the heck it is.

[44:55] Tommy: It takes a long time to make it.

[44:57] Jimi: I thought it I don't know, I didn't miss it.

[44:59] Tommy: I got it. Alright, maybe I'm stupid.

[45:01] Jimi: No, I don't think you're stu I don't think you're stupid. I think you're just looking for the buttons.

[45:05] Tommy: It's like you're you're fine tooth combing it and finding those knits.

[45:09] Jimi: Yeah, but I mean like it's like nibbling on the scallop. But it feels like something about this show doesn't quite fit.

[45:16] Tommy: Maybe maybe to me, maybe just to me. But like maybe that's it.

[45:20] Jimi: Something about No, I'm sure I'm sure there will be people that do agree with you because it doesn't get performed.

[45:25] Tommy: Right. Do you know what I mean? But like and so the it it it feels doubly sad because you know, um what is it like the ending of what you don't know about women?

[45:35] Jimi: Like it's wonderful, it's great, and like put that energy the body system, so funny.

[45:46] Tommy: Yeah, put those energy those that energy into the everything, you know.

[45:51] Jimi: Don't let I think I don't know, I think it's there.

[45:53] Tommy: That's so funny. I think it's there.

[45:55] Jimi: Um do you know what I mean? Fascinating.

[45:57] Tommy: Like, I forgo a lot of the I guess what you would regard as throwaway lyrics, um, but even then I don't think there's vast amounts of them in human.

[45:57] Jimi: I don't think there's vast amounts of them, especially compared to other shows.

[46:13] Tommy: Yes.

[46:14] Jimi: Um maybe that's why they stick out to me more, is because everything else seems seems very meticulously placed.

[46:22] Tommy: Um and so you end up with some of these tiny throwaway moments.

[46:26] Jimi: Like, just like even the whole conceit of something like it needs work.

[46:30] Tommy: Yeah, I mean, the whole song is double on Tondre.

[46:33] Jimi: Yeah, like that's so that's so smart. It's so smart, do you know what I mean?

[46:39] Tommy: Like, I don't know, I just feel there's too it's you know, I mean, to say that you think I mean this are too harsh, yeah.

[46:47] Jimi: I do, I do.

[46:48] Tommy: Yeah, I mean, obviously, that's it is your opinion, and and there will a hundred percent be people that agree with you.

[46:55] Jimi: Um, but I don't know, I think to to think, uh well, I'm not gonna listen to that one because the lyrics aren't that great, you're gonna miss out on so many amazing lyrical moments.

[47:09] Tommy: Yeah, do you know what I mean? To just kind of to say there's a bad point, so I'm gonna ignore.

[47:15] Jimi: I think do you know I mean I wonder, huh?

[47:17] Tommy: And this I mean, you know this, but it's worth saying. These are this is like an opinion I'm still figuring out in my mind, yeah.

[47:24] Jimi: So like it's still in progress.

[47:25] Tommy: So, like another one I thought about, and this one I don't have an explicit opinion about, but is somewhere near these things I've been talking about.

[47:32] Jimi: Um, it needs work.

[47:34] Tommy: Um your fiction has always had a little grit in it, a little heart in it, a little wit in it.

[47:41] Jimi: It used to be so clear that there was art in it.

[47:44] Tommy: If you had written it, uh, so you must go and spit in it and come to think of it.

[47:50] Jimi: Your writing always mirrors our relationship.

[47:52] Tommy: We're rhyming in it over and over and over again.

[47:55] Jimi: It's an identity rhyme.

[47:56] Tommy: And identity rhymes like this are often the sorts of things that I would call lazy rhyming.

[48:01] Jimi: I like this one because it keeps happening and happens more than just once or twice.

[48:08] Tommy: Um filled with this these kind of identity rhymes.

[48:13] Jimi: Like this this song has my favorite rhyme and probably up there in one of my favorite lines in musical theater of all time forever is your fertilized don't fertilize and these work.

[48:23] Tommy: Like, come on.

[48:24] Jimi: Well, and what what makes your fertilized don't fertilize work, it's literally the next thing.

[48:29] Tommy: But with dangers cropping up and sweet young strangers popping up like weeds.

[48:35] Jimi: So if you if you wish official pardoning, you better do a little gardening.

[48:39] Tommy: We're already setting up this gardening metaphor.

[48:43] Jimi: Um you needn't be so generous with your seeds, double meaning there, and then with the punchline, your fertile lies won't fertilize.

[48:52] Tommy: It's great.

[48:52] Jimi: It's and like has the setup to the rhyme.

[48:56] Tommy: Right.

[48:57] Jimi: So like in a musical with that, when you have this game commences with love, I think love's a boar.

[49:05] Tommy: Let's give the tempo a shove and raise the stakes a bit more.

[49:07] Jimi: It makes me a little that's two rhymes.

[49:10] Tommy: And if they they serve an artistic purpose as opposed to as opposed to uh uh lyrical wit purpose.

[49:17] Jimi: Do you know what I mean?

[49:18] Tommy: Yeah.

[49:18] Jimi: Like as in we're gunning towards the end here.

[49:21] Tommy: It's that wink to the audience, like I realize we've been going on a bit in this song of this back and forth.

[49:26] Jimi: We're gonna increase the speed.

[49:28] Tommy: But in it, you know, you could kind of put it into a match because the tempo of the back and forth of a racket.

[49:34] Jimi: Do you know what I mean?

[49:34] Tommy: See, and like you're going as much as I've gone very far to find this little nitpicky thing.

[49:39] Jimi: I feel like now you're going even further to find a way to justify it, you know?

[49:42] Tommy: It should be well, yeah, but I but I don't have anything wrong with it, so I'm trying to bring you to the to the point of being like, ah, okay, that do you know that'll be it.

[49:52] Jimi: It's a it's a part in the show where those two lines could have been anything, and this is what they picked, and it's uh you know, a simple, unthought-out choice.

[50:00] Tommy: Okay.

[50:00] Jimi: That's what bothers me.

[50:01] Tommy: Okay, I guess.

[50:02] Jimi: Well, we'll get in touch with that.

[50:06] Tommy: With the artistic David Zippel, and he will let him know, uh, let us know what the hell he was thinking, right?

[50:12] Jimi: When he did those atrocious two lines.

[50:15] Tommy: Goodness gracious.

[50:16] Jimi: I bet you like to play rough.

[50:18] Tommy: I like to work off a sweat.

[50:23] Jimi: And you just can't get enough.

[50:25] Tommy: I'm good for more than one set.

[50:29] Jimi: But I promise I'll show no regret if you beat me.

[50:34] Tommy: My backhand is clearly my fortune.

[50:38] Jimi: Shall we say the ball is in your court?

[50:45] Tommy: No one ever plays with me.

[50:48] Jimi: I've got your next of kin.

[50:52] Tommy: My husband never plays with me.

[50:56] Jimi: He's too easily winded.

[51:00] Tommy: You leave me breathless too.

[51:03] Jimi: Wait till our match is through.

[51:07] Tommy: I may lack form and finesse, but I warm up in a gif.

[51:14] Jimi: It's not exciting unless the competition is still.

[51:21] Tommy: I think I understand your racket.

[51:24] Jimi: I'm not in your league.

[51:26] Tommy: But you can hack it.

[51:28] Jimi: This game commences with love.

[51:30] Tommy: Well, I think love is a ball.

[51:32] Jimi: Let's give the tempo a shove.

[51:34] Tommy: And raise the stakes a bit more.

[51:36] Jimi: One thing I'm positive of.

[51:37] Tommy: It's time for someone to scroll.

[51:42] Jimi: Tell me how you like to play.

[51:46] Tommy: On grass or clay and every day.

[51:49] Jimi: They're both okay.

[51:51] Tommy: But time is running short.

[51:57] Jimi: Darling, let's don't del it.

[52:01] Tommy: Ready for a rousing rally.

[52:04] Jimi: Shall we say the ball is in your court?

[52:10] Tommy: I think with this show, so the awful abysmal lyrics aside.

[52:15] Jimi: Um again, another reason.

[52:20] Tommy: Excuse me. But another reason why I think it's a shame that it doesn't get performed more is the many millions of opportunities for creatives out there.

[52:30] Jimi: Yes.

[52:31] Tommy: Right.

[52:32] Jimi: Um a really good example, because obviously, you know, technology is a wonderful thing, and it grows at an exponential rate.

[52:41] Tommy: So productions in their original day, even if it was something like the 90s, um, are gonna look very very different nowadays.

[52:49] Jimi: So a really nice example is looking at the um Donmar revival and seeing if you can uh see some pictures and that because they do some amazing stylistic things um there and really kind of utilizing modern technology, um it's very it's so from it's very projection-y and kind of uh uh video screen-y, or am I thinking of a different yeah?

[53:14] Tommy: There's they use they use a lot of projection work, um, which is a great a great way to kind of show off the the movie aspect of it, you know what I mean.

[53:23] Jimi: Um but just you know, there the way that lighting is developed, you know.

[53:29] Tommy: If you if you think about something like Ghost, which you know, if you can tour ghost and have a blue guy on the stage walking around, right?

[53:37] Jimi: Like we're in a good place where you can do something interesting with a black and white movie.

[53:42] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?

[53:43] Jimi: Um so from a design perspective, uh you've got a feast, yes, a feast right there.

[53:51] Tommy: Um, and also you know, the 1940s isn't an era that gets touched on too much in musical theatre.

[54:03] Jimi: I guess that's pretty too.

[54:04] Tommy: I've never thought about it.

[54:05] Jimi: You know, I mean, yeah, yeah, exactly.

[54:07] Tommy: It's a strange one because we have the 30s in all of its decadence, and then we jump to the 50s in the forties, that kind of I guess because it is war tight.

[54:18] Jimi: Right.

[54:18] Tommy: So there's not a lot of unless it's a war musical, unless it's about war, yeah, exactly.

[54:24] Jimi: So um, but to you know, dip into this really kind of sexy film noir aesthetic, which is extremely typical of the 40s.

[54:36] Tommy: Um I think is really cool.

[54:38] Jimi: So you've got a lot of chance to play with with that, yeah.

[54:41] Tommy: Um with your set design, which is great.

[54:44] Jimi: Um on an acting front, oh it's it's how much fun can this be.

[54:50] Tommy: Yeah.

[54:50] Jimi: Like everyone plays two characters except for Stein and Stone.

[54:54] Tommy: Um and to bounce back and forth, and how you're gonna make them just similar enough but different enough.

[55:01] Jimi: Exactly.

[55:01] Tommy: Yeah.

[55:02] Jimi: Because everyone, everyone wants to, you know, if you're an actor, you want to play as cool things as you possibly can and as many things as you possibly can.

[55:09] Tommy: So, you know, if you can get two uh three-dimensional characters given to you, yeah, that you can kind of have a lot of fun with, um that are similar but very contrasting.

[55:21] Jimi: That's so much fun. Do you know?

[55:23] Tommy: I mean, that's such a feast.

[55:25] Jimi: Um so that's great.

[55:28] Tommy: Um choreographically, yes, especially with the kind of jazz Coleman underneath sort of stuff.

[55:36] Jimi: Yeah.

[55:37] Tommy: Um, and very kind of very interesting music in a in a kind of complex way.

[55:45] Jimi: Um so if you were a choreographer, it's not just your typical rhythm.

[55:51] Tommy: Yeah.

[55:51] Jimi: Well, and it's do you know I mean it's the kind of show that calls for choreography but never a dance break.

[55:56] Tommy: Um, yeah, and so it's so you're happy.

[55:59] Jimi: Well, that wasn't gonna be my point.

[56:04] Tommy: Um, like you it's that to me makes it a challenge.

[56:08] Jimi: Whereas like a dance break a dance break is a feast.

[56:10] Tommy: Like you, you know, do you have this many measures, it needs to be vaguely related to what's happening, but that's about it.

[56:16] Jimi: Um make it more related if you can, but who cares?

[56:19] Tommy: Um whereas like this sort of thing where all the chore there are moments where we should be dancing, but it needs to be about very explicitly about the story that's happening right now.

[56:29] Jimi: Um it's a challenge.

[56:31] Tommy: Yeah, and but there's I think there's also moments where it can be super stylistic.

[56:35] Jimi: Yeah.

[56:36] Tommy: Because obviously, you know, we're looking at a movie in real life, so you know, you've been given the stylistic card straight away from the get-go.

[56:44] Jimi: It's like go have fun.

[56:45] Tommy: Right.

[56:46] Jimi: Um, I think that's really great and an exciting thing.

[56:50] Tommy: Um and then finally with the music, I mean, holy moly.

[56:56] Jimi: I th I don't know.

[56:56] Tommy: I just imagine this would be an MD's dream.

[56:59] Jimi: I mean, it might be their nightmare because it's really bloody hard.

[57:03] Tommy: But it I don't know.

[57:04] Jimi: I to it for me, I would just want to sink my teeth into it and just really play around because obviously one of the most iconic things about film noir is the music.

[57:18] Tommy: Do you know what I mean? That's that's really what you think about um when you think that you think about that dirty size.

[57:26] Jimi: That's kind of like underscoring, yeah.

[57:27] Tommy: That is it makes the genre uh exactly, and it's very um very dramatic and it really it tells its own story.

[57:36] Jimi: Um and if you're an MD, you can get to play with that so much.

[57:41] Tommy: Do you know what I mean? To work out well, what story am I gonna tell with the music?

[57:46] Jimi: Um then the final final the the um what are they called?

[57:54] Tommy: The angel four, yeah, the four angels.

[57:56] Jimi: The do-op group, the the right they're like the the school board of this show from music man right yeah angel city four that's what they're called so like what what a great uh concept and idea to like put the sound in your musical in an in world kind of way absolutely like I don't know enough about history to know how that fits into the time period it feels a I mean I mean because it's like it's like barbershop plus yeah it's it's like do oppie scat jazz um it is yeah it is that's it exactly but like did they ever do that in the 40s in four like four part close harmony the weird I don't think it would ever have been quite as complex I think what it what strikes me as weird about it it feels somewhat 40s but not very film noir um yeah I guess it's it's kind of Andrew's sisters yeah exactly but you'd never have the Andrew sister seeing in the background of the film noir movie no exactly um exactly but this does it well like it it something about it fits like everybody's gotta be somewhere and those like you know uh four part dissonant harmonies they hit at the end of those notes or like when they all slide off about an earworm do you know I mean I that stays in my head catchy um and just the over the I can kind of overture I guess the scat overture um it sets you up right from the get go and that's the thing and again to to defend it again like um if I was sat in a theater and out popped four cats and they started scatting an overture, I'd be like, I'm here yeah I'm ready.

[59:40] Jimi: Do you know what I mean? Like that would blow my face off. I feel like it's done well. It's a double-edged sword, the music of this show. Um, because it is so complex. It is complex and catchy and difficult to hum. Um, and I think that is for better or for worse, uh, one of the death knells of a musical. Um, but uh, like it does have a couple of moments like it because like you're nothing without music.

[1:00:08] Tommy: Yeah, that's the thing you can hum is the tennis song is the finale that um, Catch Me If You Can wishes it had.

[1:00:15] Jimi: Right, exactly. Um, I just think it's a complete copycat. Sorry, but that's a different story.

[1:00:21] Tommy: Yeah, but then you get, you know, parts of You Don't Know About Women are very, very catchy and hummable, and then the ending bit, the lyrics of which I'll never know, you know.

[1:00:28] Jimi: No one will, no, no idea.

[1:00:32] Tommy: Exactly.

[1:00:33] Jimi: It's wonderful, can't hum it.

[1:00:35] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:00:36] Jimi: Yeah, exactly. That I can only imagine, like, see if you're performing that, and it'd be interesting. Do you know it'd be interesting to know actually if any of our listeners have ever done an amateur show? Because like I've never seen anyone.

[1:00:45] Tommy: I haven't either.

[1:00:49] Jimi: It feels very college appropriate. Um, big cast, lots of female roles, not very well done, not very often done, rather. Um, like stuff to research you could talk about film noir till your eyes are blue. Um, with this sort of thing. But no, I've never s I'd very rarely I guess there's not a big chorus.

[1:01:12] Tommy: Yeah, maybe that's not a big chorus.

[1:01:14] Jimi: Yeah, it's a show of leads.

[1:01:18] Tommy: Right.

[1:01:19] Jimi: You know, and I think that's fine. Um, but it's I do find it very interesting. But no, I'd be I would love to know if any of our listeners um did do this show, and if any of our listeners played Gabby and Uli and just to know how the hell you managed to do that.

[1:01:37] Tommy: Maybe that's maybe there aren't words at that ending bit and they've just been baffling us for years.

[1:01:41] Jimi: It just sounds like sounds.

[1:01:43] Tommy: It's just sounds that make that make a word a word like noise.

[1:01:45] Jimi: Get it out of that out, yeah.

[1:01:48] Tommy: Yeah, potentially, because like the fact that as well it's like close harmony, right? With extremely intricate close harmony with difficult lyrics, like that must just be one of those moments in theatre where you just ride on it. You're just like, I'm just gonna dive in and did I do it? Doesn't matter, it's the air close enough.

[1:02:07] Jimi: It is I did find it really interesting. Uh, What You Don't Know About Women was both the Tony Award song and it looked like the 2014 Olivier's, maybe. Um, like the I always this is a thing I always find so fascinating. It's like what from this show are you going to present as the one song that you're going to convince your biggest audience to like come see your thing? Like what what are you gonna showcase from this?

[1:02:33] Tommy: Um, that What You Don't Know About Women is what they picked is interesting because it's not about Stone or Stein. Um, and like in each one they have to like end cap it with tiny little scenes about the actual main characters so that we can pretend this is a musical about these people. Um, it's always fascinating to me.

[1:02:54] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:02:54] Tommy: Well, do you know it's it's an interesting thing um about the the mu the women in this show. We we love our women, yes, we love our feminist shows. I'm not gonna say that City of Angels is the heightened of feminist literature, I don't think so. But um, it does have some nice yeah interesting moments, and to be honest, film noir as a genre really plays an interesting card into the feminism debate.

[1:03:19] Jimi: Yeah, because it kind of gave birth to the femme fatale.

[1:03:23] Tommy: Yes.

[1:03:24] Jimi: It gave birth to I'm a woman in the driving seat and I'm using my sexuality. And there's I mean it's right ripe for debate and problems. The idea of like, you know, a woman using her sex appeal as power. Um, is can is either fabulous or awful depending upon how you look at it.

[1:03:43] Tommy: Um, exactly, exactly. Um, and you know, often she's using her sex appeal to cover up the fact that she's committed murder, right? You know, I guess you could there's the there's the imbalance of like you'd never see uh like a guy walking into a PI's office and be like, mmm, so what do you think? And like slowly unbuttoning his shirt, like that's not I mean I would I would be into that. I think that would be a fabulous film noir that someone should make, but I don't know if it exists.

[1:04:09] Jimi: Um, it probably does, isn't it? City of what would you call that?

[1:04:14] Tommy: Uh, City of Hangels.

[1:04:20] Jimi: Oh god, done, I'm dead.

[1:04:22] Tommy: That's it.

[1:04:23] Jimi: That was gay.

[1:04:25] Tommy: Um interesting, I'll put it in the show notes. The um director of the Donmar production uh wrote a really good article um as like a pr a preview for for the show. Um she kind of talks about her motivations for doing it, um and uh why you know why she because it's the first musical she'd ever directed and why she picked City of Angels um to do because you wouldn't pick you know I mean you wouldn't look at the cards. No one picks City of Angels, right? Here we go. So she she gives her own justifications as to why she goes about it. It's quite interesting.

[1:04:57] Jimi: So yeah, I implore y'all to to have a read there.

[1:05:01] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:05:01] Jimi: Um, but yeah, I I mean I would say do it. Like if you've got if you've got a little theatre community, if you can fill the parts, yeah, go for it.

[1:05:05] Tommy: Go for it.

[1:05:11] Jimi: It'll be fun.

[1:05:11] Tommy: Because it would be so fun, and people it just is a way to add things to your portfolio to add your repertoire as a learning curve. Like these there's so much for you to do here.

[1:05:25] Jimi: And also, I don't I don't know if you ever feel this. I don't know if I've ever talked about this, but it's a thing I feel it's it's like a librarian feeling sad for the books that don't get checked out very often, and then like checking them out just for fun, so that like they get off the shelf for a little bit. Um, there's definitely some personification of inanimate objects going on in here. But when you put on a piece of art that people don't put on very much, I think there's worth in that too, because like it keeps it alive, and then that many more people have heard about the thing to bring it forward in their lives and like keeps it awake.

[1:06:03] Tommy: Um, it's easy for art to die if no one does it, especially in this kind of world where our art exists in doing.

[1:06:11] Jimi: Um absolutely, absolutely. Um, I mean, we re yeah, you really do need you need you need to champion the things you love.

[1:06:22] Tommy: Yeah, well, and like even you know, you know, uh philosophical posturing aside, like just as far as the musical theater business works, MTI or Sam French or whoever licenses this show. If people don't do it enough, eventually the license will languish and they won't put the effort into keeping it, you know, keeping a box somewhere with the City of Angels scripts in them. Um, we're certainly far off from that happening, but it's worth it for people to perform these things.

[1:06:51] Jimi: Totally.

[1:06:52] Tommy: Totally. So if you like it, do it.

[1:06:53] Jimi: Do it.

[1:06:57] Tommy: If you like it.

[1:07:00] Jimi: Do it.

[1:07:03] Tommy: I'm nothing without you.

[1:07:07] Jimi: No hero, my zero, that's me.

[1:07:13] Tommy: There's no better guide.

[1:07:15] Jimi: I have to be all I can be.

[1:07:18] Tommy: I'm nowhere.

[1:07:22] Jimi: To doubt you is where I went wrong.

[1:07:26] Tommy: The script cost for using our smarts.

[1:07:31] Jimi: And greatness can come on the sum of all parts.

[1:07:56] Tommy: So Jimi, that was City of Angels.

[1:07:59] Jimi: Your least favorite music.

[1:08:01] Tommy: Untrue.

[1:08:03] Jimi: Cats is worse.

[1:08:05] Tommy: So much.

[1:08:06] Jimi: Cats is worse.

[1:08:08] Tommy: Even I would agree with that.

[1:08:09] Jimi: See?

[1:08:10] Tommy: See.

[1:08:13] Jimi: Ha ha ha.

[1:08:14] Tommy: I don't know how we made friends.

[1:08:17] Jimi: Exactly.

[1:08:17] Tommy: I know.

[1:08:17] Jimi: Nobody knows.

[1:08:19] Tommy: It's like um.

[1:08:21] Jimi: Did you you didn't watch Lost, did you?

[1:08:23] Tommy: No.

[1:08:23] Jimi: I got lost after the first season.

[1:08:25] Tommy: Ha.

[1:08:26] Jimi: Hey.

[1:08:27] Tommy: Cool.

[1:08:27] Jimi: Well, I won't finish that statement. Would you like to know what we're doing next week's?

[1:08:32] Tommy: Absolutely.

[1:08:33] Jimi: Hey Tommy, next week's really special.

[1:08:35] Tommy: Yes.

[1:08:35] Jimi: Why?

[1:08:36] Tommy: Do you know do you know why?

[1:08:37] Jimi: I do.

[1:08:40] Tommy: Okay.

[1:08:41] Jimi: Fine. Read my mind.

[1:08:43] Tommy: No, why is next week special, Jimi?

[1:08:46] Jimi: Ladies and gentlemen, we're gonna have a special guest.

[1:08:49] Tommy: What?

[1:08:50] Jimi: Right? How exciting is that? We're gonna get some actual an actual person with knowledge.

[1:08:55] Tommy: Right, not just us.

[1:08:57] Jimi: Right.

[1:08:58] Tommy: An expert in the field is gonna be joining us.

[1:09:01] Jimi: You make it sound like they're an expert in the field, like they're gonna be like a biologist or something.

[1:09:07] Tommy: Hey, that's me. I'm the one with the biology degree.

[1:09:09] Jimi: No, they have a degree in music. So that's you know, you can't get more expert than that.

[1:09:15] Tommy: That's true. That's true. But what would we be talking about?

[1:09:18] Jimi: Well, let's find out. You've got a quiz question for us, don't you?

[1:09:21] Tommy: I do. Starts off with a fact.

[1:09:22] Jimi: What?

[1:09:23] Tommy: Fact quiz question, all in one.

[1:09:26] Jimi: A quiz.

[1:09:27] Tommy: Um, Jimi, did you know that um famous composer John Williams, the man, um, worked uh on arranging the score for the 1971 film version of Fiddler on the Roof?

[1:09:38] Jimi: Ooh, how interesting.

[1:09:39] Tommy: Did you know that?

[1:09:40] Jimi: I didn't I know that now.

[1:09:42] Tommy: You do. Um, we've talked about Fiddler on the Roof, though, so we ain't gonna be gonna be doing that. Um, go listen to the Fiddler on the Roof podcast, everyone. Um, now, to our knowledge, he's only ever arranged one other song from musical theater to appear in a film.

[1:10:04] Jimi: The song is the title song of next week's musical.

[1:10:10] Tommy: What a question.

[1:10:13] Jimi: What a question, and what a song.

[1:10:15] Tommy: That's true.

[1:10:16] Jimi: What a song.

[1:10:17] Tommy: What could it be?

[1:10:18] Jimi: Who knows?

[1:10:20] Tommy: I don't know. If you would like to get in contact with either of us, I'm Musical MASH on Twitter and Musical Theatre Mash on YouTube.

[1:10:30] Jimi: And I am Asan Hendrix on Twitter and YouTube. And you can get in touch with us both over on Twitter at Jim and Tomic.

[1:10:39] Tommy: Or you can go to our website, jimandtomic.com, which has a link to the Reddit discussion, which is a thing you should check out.

[1:10:46] Jimi: Absolutely. I think we're recruit we're starting to recruit more and more people to Reddit. So we should uh work something out there.

[1:10:52] Tommy: Probably Dear Reddit. Send money.

[1:10:56] Jimi: I think that's how it works, right?

[1:10:59] Tommy: I think that's how it works. Um, we would love you to go and tell your friends and hey. By the way, people who've left us reviews. You're so nice.

[1:11:09] Jimi: You're so nice.

[1:11:12] Tommy: We were cheesing last week.

[1:11:15] Jimi: Absolutely cheesing.

[1:11:16] Tommy: Cheesing.

[1:11:17] Jimi: Very nice.

[1:11:17] Tommy: That's a word you made up.

[1:11:18] Jimi: Season.

[1:11:19] Tommy: Yeah, like cheese and like ah!

[1:11:21] Jimi: It's not like it sounds like you're making cheese.

[1:11:24] Tommy: Um cheesin.

[1:11:25] Jimi: Just turn in this.

[1:11:26] Tommy: I did I did make cheese as an aside. I just did pasteurizing milk and so forth.

[1:11:30] Jimi: Did you do it while you were reading iTunes reviews?

[1:11:33] Tommy: While I was cheesing reading iTunes.

[1:11:35] Jimi: Yeah, exactly. You're such a you're such a double cheeser.

[1:11:38] Tommy: Thank you.

[1:11:39] Jimi: Uh, and if you would like to leave us a review, uh, if you feel compelled to, that would be really nice too. And then we can cheese all over you too.

[1:11:47] Tommy: Gross.

[1:11:48] Jimi: I know.

[1:11:51] Tommy: I think that's it.

[1:11:53] Jimi: That's it.

[1:11:53] Tommy: So we shall see you next Wednesday.

[1:11:56] Jimi: Ta-da!

[1:11:58] Tommy: Ciao.

[1:12:11] Jimi: And then when the heron landed, uh, they wanted me to um leap away and then swim. And to do that, I had to put myself into a like headstand or like a neck stand, really. Uh huh. Um, and then kick my legs like that. Uh-huh. So it looks like I was swimming down. Um, and I couldn't do that.

[1:12:35] Tommy: Well.

[1:12:36] Jimi: So there you go. And I tried very hard, and I almost broke my neck. And that was when they were like, you can just hop away. And I was like, Thank you. Thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you for letting me not injure myself.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred