Discuss on Reddit ➤ Support the Show ➤ Jimi and Tommy are going back in history to look at a case that is not talked about enough - the story of the ‘The Scottsboro Boys.’ They examine the controversy surrounding Kander and Ebb’s use of a minstrel show as a framing device, discuss the importance of educating yourself about issues that might be foreign to you and why not enough people know about this musical... Read More
From the show: Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour
About
Jimi and Tommy are going back in history to look at a case that is not talked about enough - the story of the ‘The Scottsboro Boys.’ They examine the controversy surrounding Kander and Ebb’s use of a minstrel show as a framing device, discuss the importance of educating yourself about issues that might be foreign to you and why not enough people know about this musical.
The Scottsboro Boys (Original London Cast)
SHOW NOTES
If you want to find out more about The Scottsboro Boys’ story there is so much out there for you to have a look at, but why not watch this documentary to start you off?
It’s so important to look at all sides of the dice when it comes to any issue, particularly if it’s a side you might not agree with. Have a look at the article that inspired our quiz question this week.
In the same vein, have a look at this video from one of the Freedom Party protests surrounding The Scottsboro Boys’ Broadway run.
There’s an amazing interview with John Thompson, the book writer of this show that gives great insights into the controversy surrounding this piece.
Jane Elliott has done wonderful things for race relations and understanding all through her career. Check out this documentary from when she created her famous ‘Blue Eyes, Brown Eyes Experiment’ after the assassination of Martin Luther King Jr.
Once you’ve got the hang of what it’s about, go see what happened when Jane brought the experiment to the UK.
A SONDHEIMTASTIC QUIZ QUESTION
The actor who auditioned for the lead role in this musical knocked her audition so far out of the park that Sondheim remarked, “let’s open tomorrow!” What show?
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Jimi: Yeah, no. I wouldn't like maybe if you'd named Shania Twain, I'd been like, oh yeah, that's a person.
[0:08] Tommy: You would know Shania Twain. Come on over.
[0:12] Jimi: Come on over was my second album that I ever bought. First was Spice Girls, second was Shania Twain.
[0:17] Tommy: Oh, who was questioning?
[0:19] Jimi: Mine was the soundtrack to Sister Act.
[0:23] Tommy: Well, somebody get us another drink. Welcome to Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour, your weekly podcast with Scotch and Scrim.
[0:34] Jimi: Yes, sorry about that. I don't know if I've ever had Scotch.
[0:39] Tommy: Um, I hate it.
[0:42] Jimi: We call it whiskey. We don't call this Scotch because we are—wait, dumb question. Are Scotch and whiskey the same thing?
[0:48] Tommy: Yeah.
[0:49] Jimi: Alright, then I have had Scotch.
[0:51] Tommy: Oh, okay. Yeah, I think like would you call like Jack Daniels? Would you say that Scotch?
[0:56] Jimi: I would call that whiskey.
[0:58] Tommy: Yeah, I'd call that whiskey. But maybe it's different.
[1:02] Jimi: I don't think it's different. Scotch whiskey, yeah.
[1:06] Tommy: Often something called the Scotch is a malt.
[1:08] Jimi: Yeah, so it's like malt whiskey.
[1:10] Tommy: Huh, yeah. No, it's just whiskey.
[1:12] Jimi: Is it? Why have two words?
[1:16] Tommy: This is why we're a musical—two words. This is why we're a musical theatre podcast and not an alcohol podcast.
[1:21] Jimi: Exactly, because we don't get it.
[1:23] Tommy: No. Anyway, that's my drink, because I'm Scottish anyway.
[1:29] Jimi: We also invented Scrim in Scotland.
[1:31] Tommy: Really?
[1:32] Jimi: We didn't.
[1:32] Tommy: No, we didn't.
[1:33] Jimi: I would have believed.
[1:34] Tommy: It's fun to say in a Scottish accent. Scrim.
[1:36] Jimi: That's a good one.
[1:37] Tommy: It sounds like Scotch.
[1:38] Jimi: That sounds like—uh, you want me to say Scrim in a Scottish accent?
[1:41] Tommy: Please, yes.
[1:43] Jimi: Mmm Scrim.
[1:45] Tommy: That'll do, yeah. That sounds pretty good.
[1:47] Jimi: That was alright.
[1:48] Tommy: That's right. That was a good one.
[1:51] Jimi: Uh-huh.
[1:52] Tommy: As long as you like grunt a lot.
[1:54] Jimi: Yeah, that's what we do. And it was very—it was like a good brave. You know the movie Brave?
[1:59] Tommy: Oh, if you had the chance to change your life, scrub you.
[2:04] Jimi: Yeah.
[2:04] Tommy: Very Pixar Scott.
[2:05] Jimi: Yeah. So you're drinking Scotch because you're Scottish.
[2:07] Tommy: Uh, yes. What are you drinking today?
[2:13] Jimi: I'm drinking Alabama whiskey.
[2:15] Tommy: Which is not Alabama Scotch.
[2:18] Jimi: It's different. It doesn't have the same twang if you call it Alabama Scotch.
[2:18] Tommy: Okay.
[2:18] Jimi: Alabama Scotch.
[2:24] Tommy: Yeah, it doesn't, does it? Right? That sounds like something they'd advertise in a Skittles commercial.
[2:27] Jimi: It's like this is ridiculous.
[2:29] Tommy: Yeah, that's very true. Well, I'm drinking an Alabama slammer.
[2:33] Jimi: Ooh.
[2:34] Tommy: We're definitely in Alabama.
[2:35] Jimi: We're definitely in Alabama.
[2:37] Tommy: We are. Um, hey Tommy.
[2:40] Jimi: Hey Jimmy.
[2:41] Tommy: So the musical that we're talking with—the musical that we're gonna be talking about today sort of stirred something of a controversy in Broadway.
[2:47] Jimi: Ooh, I like how you say controversy.
[2:50] Tommy: Controversy?
[2:51] Jimi: That's not how that—controversy.
[2:54] Tommy: What do you—yeah, I suppose I think controversy might be right because you say controversial.
[2:59] Jimi: Yeah, you just say controversial.
[3:01] Tommy: What's the metal material you make cans out of?
[3:05] Jimi: Aluminium.
[3:08] Tommy: Oh, I'm sorry. I'm saying all the letters anyway. Read the rest of the quiz question.
[3:14] Tommy: Controversy on Broadway, though, even though it had lots of posed reviews, um, one critic did not speak so highly of it and said the only reason that this musical has made it to the Great White Way is the Great White Guilt. And what show would that be, Tommy?
[3:31] Jimi: What show indeed? It's The Scottsboro Boys.
[3:33] Tommy: Every member of society celebrates our notoriety. Step right up and meet the Scottsboro Robo.
[3:44] Jimi: Every communist throughout the land wants the part of to lend a hand. They all want to kiss the Scottsboro Robo.
[3:56] Tommy: Since they heard we're such a wow. And GM is calling now. Sand of Salso on the phone. And the many wonder brothers won't leave us alone. And little boy can't be a star.
[4:14] Jimi: Tommy Barry Morris Venny's prize.
[4:24] Tommy: So it's one of the two posthumous Candor Ebbs. Which one?
[4:28] Jimi: I was getting confused. Which one died?
[4:31] Tommy: Um, Fred Ebb died.
[4:33] Jimi: Fred Ebb died, and then they finished—versus Fred Ebb.
[4:36] Tommy: They finished Scottsboro Boys. And thankfully, John Cander can also write lyrics.
[4:41] Jimi: Thank goodness.
[4:42] Tommy: Yeah. After working together for years and years.
[4:45] Jimi: Yeah, exactly. Well, very excited for us to do a curtain, so we can talk about that one song.
[4:49] Tommy: Yeah.
[4:50] Jimi: Oh, um, but show people.
[4:52] Tommy: Yeah.
[4:52] Jimi: Um, and thinking of him.
[4:54] Tommy: Um, thinking of them, that's it.
[4:55] Jimi: Thank you. Um, and also didn't know they were gay. Found that out recently.
[5:00] Tommy: Really?
[5:01] Jimi: Yeah.
[5:02] Tommy: That's just the assumption. You have to go in with that assumption.
[5:04] Jimi: Like people are still weird, I always assume people are straight.
[5:08] Tommy: That's cause it's like creators. I always think.
[5:09] Jimi: You are blinded by Andrew Lloyd Webber.
[5:12] Tommy: Um, his masculinity. Uh, yeah, so um, this is a team that is tried and tested.
[5:21] Jimi: Yes.
[5:21] Tommy: Um, and they also had the wonderful Susan Stroman at the helm, um, who I guess most people know for Producers.
[5:30] Jimi: That's probably our like biggest—biggest.
[5:31] Tommy: That's pretty good. I love her for Contact, which is a hard one.
[5:35] Jimi: Not for Young Frankenstein, not high on your list.
[5:38] Tommy: Yeah, no, it's great. It's getting a revival on the West End, but uh, Contact's dancey.
[5:42] Jimi: Contact is dancey, and so are you.
[5:44] Tommy: Um, thank you. I am. Um, so when did it open up Broadway, Tommy?
[5:49] Tommy: It started uh off Broadway in 2010 at the Vineyard, um, and had a out of town run in Minneapolis and it opened on Broadway in October of 2010.
[5:57] Jimi: Um, and then it moved to the West End, right?
[5:59] Tommy: Yeah, it popped over in 2014 and had a really successful run at The Young Vic, which was nominated for everything and won nothing.
[6:13] Jimi: Nothing.
[6:14] Tommy: The classic Candor and Ebb play unless you're kissing the spider-woman. Although I will say I'm sure that had in no small part due to The Book of Mormon, which was also the same year, but we'll talk more about that later.
[6:26] Jimi: We'll definitely talk more about that.
[6:27] Tommy: Um, but poor guys have the Steel Pier as well. Um, so yeah, and it was the same over in the Oliviers as well. Slew of nominations, nay wins, something fishy.
[6:38] Jimi: Yeah.
[6:39] Tommy: To be discussed. Um, but right, so let's talk about what this is because I wonder um for our UK fish how much they would know about this part of history.
[6:52] Jimi: Well, and even um for it being a very American musical, both in content and in um context, I—the Scottsboro Boys before working on this podcast had been very much on the outside of my periphery. I knew it existed, I knew it was Candor and Ebb, but I had never listened to it all the way through until maybe a couple weeks ago.
[7:11] Tommy: Um, did you know the story of the Scottsboro Boys?
[7:16] Jimi: Absolutely not, which is a damn shame.
[7:18] Tommy: Um, here you go, right? So the story of the Scottsboro Boys, um, we're talking what, pre-Civil Rights Movement America. Um, something like nine black teenagers get on a train leaving uh Chattanooga.
[7:35] Jimi: Chattanooga—no, no, no, no. Aren't they leaving Georgia?
[7:39] Tommy: Um, commencing Chattanooga.
[7:45] Jimi: Oh, you're right. Okay. Nine black teenage boys get on a train, you know, they're looking for work, um, heading across the south, and get very falsely accused of raping two white teenagers.
[8:04] Tommy: Um, and then a series of heavily publicized and politicized trials happen um that are, you know, embroiled in racist undertones and really, you know, overt racist happenings um that very much led to some uh big changes in—big big changes.
[8:28] Jimi: The judicial system in America and really is kind of the Kickstarter of a lot of the civil rights movement, which is some of the framing of this music.
[8:38] Tommy: Which—and that's I think the thing that surprises me is that I didn't know about this. Because this, in my opinion, this is one of the—especially because this was the thing that overturned the courts.
[8:47] Jimi: Yeah.
[8:48] Tommy: This is the thing where law was starting to change.
[8:51] Jimi: Yeah.
[8:51] Tommy: Um, well, and I don't know if even if public opinion wasn't changing, but like there was—people were like, ah, hang on, that didn't go well. Do you know what I mean? There was lots—lots—lots of wrong things happened there.
[9:03] Jimi: Um, and I don't know how much of this makes it across the pond, but I'm—as in educator land, I am—this is something I'm keenly aware of. Um, in America, a lot of like a lot of the history textbooks, literally the history textbooks, but then metaphorically the history textbooks are written in a very—in an almost revisionist kind of way.
[9:26] Tommy: I know exactly what you're saying, yes.
[9:28] Jimi: Um, and so like this is the sort of story that would be in a first draft and then, you know, be disapproved by the white board in the South that's like we can't teach kids about this, and so doesn't become a story in our history books and have some, you know, is so important. You know, we hear about Rosa Parks and we hear about uh Martin Luther King Jr.
[9:47] Tommy: Um, but we don't hear about the Scottsboro Boys.
[9:50] Jimi: Yeah, and this, you know, these guys were at the forefront. So this is in the 30s, yeah.
[9:55] Tommy: Um, it was of the Candor and Ebb's like main era.
[9:58] Jimi: That's pretty much everything they do is written in Russian series.
[10:01] Tommy: I never thought about that before.
[10:02] Jimi: Umless it's like—it's—it's well, isn't it?
[10:04] Tommy: Yeah, except for maybe The Visit, which is I've read, yeah, but I've read from uh John that they love it just because this is when so much was happening. Like we've talked about before in Cabaret, for example, yeah, where the world is on the edge.
[10:20] Jimi: Do you know what I mean? It's on the knife edge.
[10:22] Tommy: Yeah.
[10:22] Jimi: Um, and it creates a lot of tumultuous things.
[10:27] Tommy: So that's exactly, you know, like you're looking for drama, yeah.
[10:30] Jimi: That's where you go. Um, so that's what they've kind of done. So the musical um looks at the story of these boys um through the form of a minstrel show.
[10:43] Tommy: Oh, it's a very Candor and Ebb trait.
[10:51] Jimi: Yeah. Most of their shows are framed in a user device.
[10:56] Tommy: Yeah.
[10:56] Jimi: They usually—a lot of their shows are very performative in nature.
[11:00] Tommy: Yeah. So for example, Cabaret is set a cabaret in Germany, an underground cabaret. Chicago is set in like a vaudeville setting.
[11:11] Jimi: Yeah.
[11:14] Tommy: Because of the Spider-Woman, there's got lots of theatricality in the prison, you know, when she comes—when the Spider-Woman comes in, blah blah blah. So this time around, they're using the uh minstrel show as their kind of vehicle to tell the story.
[11:31] Jimi: Yeah.
[11:31] Tommy: Um, but not as we know it.
[11:34] Jimi: Like, thank goodness. You know what I mean?
[11:36] Tommy: Um, oh yeah, of course.
[11:39] Jimi: Right. So for um, in case you haven't heard, because this is another thing I don't think makes it into the t—the history textbooks. The—I don't—tradition's the wrong word—habit performing style, racist performance we should never continue again, maybe of the minstrel show was a—a tradition of blackface performance from maybe the mid-1800s in America.
[12:06] Tommy: Um, seeped in the racism and the stereotype of that era.
[12:12] Jimi: Um, white performers putting on, you know, blackface and performing what were considered caricatures of black people in America at the time.
[12:24] Tommy: Yeah, you know, totally untrue, totally offensive, totally racist, and a very popular entertainment form through the city.
[12:32] Jimi: It was the main entertainment form through the 1800s all the way through. I mean, even at the 30s, yeah, it wasn't still as big because people, you know, vaudeville was beginning to creep out now.
[12:44] Tommy: Yep.
[12:45] Jimi: Um, but it was—it was still rife. Like I say, it's ingrained.
[12:48] Tommy: Yeah.
[12:49] Jimi: It was seated. And you—you see the history of it all, and there's all sorts of interesting, I think, controversial arguments around this, but yeah, America's popular live entertainment form shifted from the minstrel show to vaudeville to musical theater.
[13:05] Tommy: Um, so mm, better or worse, like when I talk about my down tempo showstopper, that kind of feel where like the music drops out. There's something—the seed of that comes from the cakewalk tradition in the minstrel show.
[13:23] Jimi: Um, like the—the music behind all that, the fact that vaudeville was very based in jazz and like these sort of things, they're all uh intricately tied together um in some really interesting ways.
[13:35] Tommy: Yeah, exactly. I mean, like the thing is is you know people, uh, c I guess kind of unfortunately would recognize so much from it. Early Tom and Jerry cartoons, for example.
[13:46] Jimi: Yeah.
[13:46] Tommy: Um, the—the woman who owns Tom is just, you know, massively stereotypical uh black women harking completely to all of the stereotypes that they portray in the minstrel show.
[13:59] Jimi: Do you know early Disney? You know how Mickey Mouse—
[14:01] Tommy: Mickey Mouse, yeah.
[14:02] Jimi: Mickey Mouse wearing gloves owes his glove wearing to minstrel shows in some ways.
[14:10] Tommy: It comes from the blackface tradition as they would wear gloves. And somehow this kind of performative nature got transferred to cartoons, maybe not explicitly racist. It's not like Mickey Mouse is wearing blackface, but there's—there's some kind of tangential relationship there that definitely, you know, you don't think about every time you look at Mickey Mouse.
[14:34] Tommy: Exactly. And then you know, you get the—the crows in Dumbo.
[14:37] Jimi: Yep.
[14:37] Tommy: Like these are—these are the stereotypes that were being completely rattled out.
[14:42] Jimi: Yeah. Do you know what I mean? And so worth it to say, in The Scottsboro Boys, and maybe this will transition into our next point. Um I think the big important change of this minstrel show tradition is all of the actors are actually black, not wearing blackface.
[14:59] Tommy: Yes. Um where the can of worms is opened, I would say, in some ways for the show. And it kind of made the way that they do it, you know, it's they're not this this isn't a stereotypical minstrel show. That isn't what Kander and Ebb have written. Um they're like I say, they're using that as the vehicle to create this very uncomfortable environment.
[15:24] Jimi: Oh, yeah. Um, that we'll yeah, we'll talk about in a little bit. But I think the the main line that makes you realize that this isn't this isn't the typical thing is um the line right at the start in um uh hey hey hey hey um when I think it's Haywood, um, or it might be Mr. Bones and Mr. Tambourine and he says when they're saying Mr. Lo interlocutor, what story are we gonna tell tonight? Um he's like, Oh, we're gonna tell the story of the Scottsboro boys. Um, and yeah, so it's Haywood that says, Mr. Interlocutor, this time can we tell it like it really happened? This time can we tell the truth? Um, and they do go on to tell the truth. You know, I mean they're they're bashing away all the stereotypes to tell a story.
[16:10] Tommy: Well, and they're using the stereotypes, they're really subverting the stereotype. Like my my favorite line in Hey Hey Hey is I forget um which which two of them it is. Um, but so the whole point, the the first song, Hey Hey, and the is like describing the fact that this is a minstrel show, everyone's a minstrel tonight. We're telling you a story, we're like, you know, they're really they're really laying it out. There's one moment where they like they point out a lady in the front row and she's like, you know, she seems scared to see you, and like we're acknowledging like this is uh gonna be uncomfortable, buckle up. Um but the whoever whichever two characters say our specialty is white people. Um and it is a a wonderful, magical, very uncomfortable subverting of the stereotype. Um which like you're you're in for a ride tonight.
[17:03] Jimi: Yeah, definitely. Um so it set that up right from the very beginning. Um so let's dive in, shall we? Here we go. Buckle up your BNO, and you can take your Santa Fe, and you can take your old rock island line and throw them all away. And if the Pennsylvania calls to say you want your money back, and if the New York Central's on the phone. Tell them their way off the track, commencing a chat and singing each other news. We're commensing each other new on the Southern Railroad Line.
[17:46] Tommy: Now I do want to preface this as we always do when we uh talk about musicals that deal with race. It's the we are two white men preface.
[17:56] Jimi: We are two yes, we are two white men speech. We are two white men. Um we are learning about this.
[18:06] Tommy: Yep. Uh and you know, we don't speak from experience. I we just it's like it's uh it's awful because it feels like a preemptive apology, but it's it feels always like we're gonna get some stuff wrong. We don't know. This is just what we see.
[18:22] Jimi: But I think there's also added in like we we need to talk about this.
[18:27] Tommy: Yeah, oh a hundred percent. And that that's that's a big crucial part about this show.
[18:32] Jimi: Yeah, I feel exactly. Um, and we'll talk about that.
[18:34] Tommy: Yeah. Uh and like we need to talk about this, and we are certainly not the forefront on this experience at all.
[18:41] Jimi: No, exactly, exactly. But you know, it's something that we care deeply about.
[18:46] Tommy: Yeah.
[18:46] Jimi: Which is why we're doing the show.
[18:48] Tommy: Yeah, exactly. Um, so yeah, the first thing I want to kind of address is this article that we use in the quiz question.
[18:56] Jimi: Okay, so it was an article in The New Republic, um, by uh an African American journalist called John McQuarter. And basically he is talking about the fact that this show isn't right.
[19:15] Tommy: Yeah.
[19:16] Jimi: I do I guess. So from from the onset. I would feel more comfortable with this show. Uh-huh. If either John Cander or Fred Ebb or Susan Stroman were black. I would feel more comfortable with the show that way.
[19:34] Tommy: And this is not a show about feeling comfortable. Um but it it's, you know. We live in a world where white people have been quote unquote telling black people's story forever and ever and ever.
[19:48] Jimi: Yeah.
[19:48] Tommy: And that's wrong. Um, and so then it it puts this show under heightened scrutiny, I think.
[19:56] Jimi: Yes.
[19:57] Tommy: Yes. Um, you know, and I there's a whole it's nuanced. I think there's a whole history to it. There aren't I can't name any off the top of my head. Uh black musical theater artists. Composers, composers.
[20:16] Jimi: Which makes me feel awful.
[20:18] Tommy: No, so that this is it. It's a huge it's a huge problem. Right. Um and it's it's systemic and yeah, it's it is. It's it's absolutely awful, and no one is arguing about that fact.
[20:31] Jimi: So what I feel what ha what should happen then is it's up to people like Kander and Ebb, and it's up to the people who have the privilege of being in a position where they can get a show onto Broadway pretty easily.
[20:44] Tommy: Right.
[20:45] Jimi: Just on their name alone, to tell the stories that other people because of this disgusting endemic thing.
[20:53] Tommy: Right.
[20:54] Jimi: Can't tell.
[20:54] Tommy: Yeah.
[20:54] Jimi: And it is, you know, there is a better alternate universe where this musical is written by black authors and created by black creators.
[21:03] Tommy: And of course this is not the best solution.
[21:06] Jimi: Yeah, and it's important to note as well, this isn't the only piece of fiction that um, you know, looks at the Scottsboro boys. There, you know, I mean, there are plays, um, I think there's movies, there's definitely plenty of documentaries on it. Like it was a huge part of American history.
[21:20] Tommy: Yeah.
[21:21] Jimi: So it gets talked about a lot, and this is just one example of it.
[21:25] Tommy: Yeah.
[21:25] Jimi: Um, but so um, yeah, John McQuarter, he obviously very isn't against the the main controversy about it, which we'll talk about in a minute.
[21:37] Tommy: Um, of the fact that it's set in a minstrel show, which is what most of the protests around the show were about.
[21:45] Jimi: Um he's actually more against the fact that it's not necessarily honest.
[21:51] Tommy: Yeah.
[21:52] Jimi: Um, which I find that's an interesting one.
[21:54] Tommy: That is an interesting one because obviously when you write a show, you choose what story you're going to tell.
[22:03] Jimi: Yeah.
[22:03] Tommy: Especially if it's if it's based on something, you can't cover every fact. You're not doing a documentary here.
[22:07] Jimi: Well, and you know, not even that you're not doing a documentary, but you're not, you know, we're not gonna sit through the three years that this took to become a thing. Like the intricacies and the the layers and layers and layers of this the story are are shocking.
[22:24] Tommy: Yeah.
[22:24] Jimi: Um, and you can obviously only tell so much. Um so he, you know, he talks about the fact that the kind of boys are painted in a very, very positive light, um, which might not necessarily have been the case.
[22:39] Tommy: Right.
[22:40] Jimi: Um, he was talking about the fact that um the character based on Haywood Patterson, um, in real life, I think apparently falsely implicated some of the other boys.
[22:51] Tommy: Okay.
[22:52] Jimi: Um, and they don't they never address that, and he's kind of Haywood in the musical is kind of like the hero, he's the kind of central one of the bodies.
[23:00] Tommy: Yeah.
[23:02] Jimi: And it basically also makes the argument, you know, like we say about great white guilt, that if this was about he says if it was about Tiananmen Square, or if it was about the Haymarket riots, it wouldn't be on Broadway.
[23:19] Tommy: Yeah.
[23:19] Jimi: So and I think this is where it's it's tricky.
[23:25] Tommy: Yeah.
[23:25] Jimi: And it is. And like, you know, this is a black person who went to see this show. We are white people talking about this show much later.
[23:33] Tommy: Yep.
[23:34] Jimi: And so we're wrong. We're just wrong, always. Not our opinion.
[23:39] Tommy: Or you know, not our place.
[23:40] Jimi: Like the our opinion doesn't matter.
[23:43] Tommy: Um then again, it does it.
[23:46] Jimi: I think it does.
[23:47] Tommy: It's not it's everyone's you know, it's that kind of thing is like it's it's the opinion fact debate that we have in their day and age.
[23:54] Jimi: Like opinions don't equal fact, opinions equal opinions, and it's important to have the conversation.
[24:00] Tommy: Yeah, that's that's the thing that it all comes down to. It's important to have this conversation. This is a question I had thinking about this, um, and I wanted to ask you, because you're on the other side of an ocean.
[24:10] Jimi: Yeah.
[24:11] Tommy: Is the concept of white guilt a thing in the United Kingdom?
[24:17] Jimi: Well, it's interesting you say that. Um I think we'll talk about it in a little bit. I realize that's what we've said all the way through this podcast. In a little bit, we'll talk about what are you gonna talk about now?
[24:25] Tommy: Um, but I would say no, not as much.
[24:29] Jimi: Okay.
[24:29] Tommy: I mean, when it comes to the slave trade, we because of our relationship with the states is always really interesting, and that you know, a lot of the time we like to lord ourselves over you, and vice versa.
[24:39] Jimi: Yeah.
[24:40] Tommy: Um, and it's this weird power play that we have. One of the ones that I think we always use, and I say we, again, not meaning me, I just mean like the zeitgeist.
[24:49] Jimi: Exactly.
[24:50] Tommy: Um, is the slave trade and the fact that you know we had the abolitionists and we were very much at the forefront of that.
[24:56] Jimi: Yeah.
[24:56] Tommy: And so like I will like, have you heard of say the concept of affirmative action?
[25:02] Jimi: Yes, yes.
[25:03] Tommy: But I mean that's our educ that's our education. Because so we um in our like high school education, certainly in Scotland, although admittedly I don't know if they still do not. But um, for example, you take modern studies, uh, which is our like it's like politics, I guess. You're studying politics.
[25:18] Jimi: Okay.
[25:19] Tommy: Um one of the things that we look at is um apartheid and civil rights in the states. And you know, not nearly as in detail as I would assume you guys would.
[25:33] Jimi: Yeah.
[25:33] Tommy: Because we're looking at we look at at South Africa and we also look at America and we kind of look at them in tandem.
[25:39] Jimi: Okay.
[25:39] Tommy: Um but so yeah, I do know what affirmative action means, and I know, you know, I like I know the stories about Rosa Parks and Martin Luther King, yeah, and um yeah, these these things that we're all very aware of.
[25:54] Jimi: The NAACP, you know, the work that people are doing.
[25:57] Tommy: Right.
[25:57] Jimi: Speaking of Rosa Parks, she's in this musical too.
[26:00] Tommy: Yeah, she is.
[26:01] Jimi: And if you listen to the cast, if you listen to the cast album, you'd never know.
[26:06] Tommy: Um the whole musical is framed with Rosa Parks because it's like the Scottsboro Boys is the seed that starts the civil rights movement that really, yeah, and then like Rosa Parks happens.
[26:17] Tommy: Um, and so it it the whole musical starts, you see this lady, unknown lady, sitting at a bus stop, and then the whole musical happens, and then at the end she gets on a bus and she happens to be Rosa Parks.
[26:29] Jimi: Um, you know, then civil rights happens in America. Um it's this huge wonderful framing device that is like Kander and Ebb's wonderful way of like you know cascading down into the story.
[26:43] Tommy: But at least open to interpretation, but at least the actress who plays Rosa Parks is present throughout most of the show.
[26:51] Jimi: Um she has a wonderful like shadow tap dance number with one of the characters, um, just in the background.
[27:00] Tommy: She watches a bunch of the stuff take place, and it's a beautiful like it's such a wonderful metaphorical commentary that you can't do another context.
[27:11] Jimi: Because to have an actress who you will later learn is Rosa Parks watching the the plight of the Scottsboro boys on stage, and then to see her take that action at the end and be like no today enough is enough. Today's the day we fix this. Um it's uh it gets me all flustered.
[27:31] Tommy: It's really good.
[27:33] Jimi: I totally get that.
[27:34] Tommy: I totally get that.
[27:35] Jimi: It is what a wonderful, wonderful thing.
[27:37] Tommy: Yeah, and like not something you would know if you only listen to it.
[27:40] Jimi: Yeah.
[27:41] Tommy: And I think speaks to the care with which this musical was constructed.
[27:46] Jimi: Completely.
[27:47] Tommy: Yeah, that's it.
[27:48] Jimi: The construction is masterful.
[27:51] Tommy: Yeah, like they it gives it and like the you know, the way we've said, like, I know Rosa Parks. Rosa Parks is a jumping off point for me as like casually educated American.
[28:02] Jimi: And so to put it in that context for me as white audience member, oh, I get it.
[28:02] Tommy: Yep.
[28:02] Jimi: Oh, I get it.
[28:09] Tommy: And then to use that, oh, she's watching these things happen, oh, she's having these moments with members of the cast. Unspoken in a shadow behind, and we know this is performative, so like we're, you know, is she there? Is she assuming things? Whoo, it gives me shivers.
[28:28] Jimi: It's it's good.
[28:29] Tommy: Yeah, it really, really is.
[28:31] Jimi: Um, but going back to uh we don't come at it from a point of view of like guilt, it's very much like it's happening over here.
[28:40] Tommy: Yeah, yeah.
[28:41] Jimi: You know, and I mean it's not to say there isn't racism in the UK. I mean, I'm sure there is.
[28:49] Tommy: I think America being such a young country and being in a really particular like I think a lot of man, we're gonna get real geopolitical in here in our discussion of this musical, but like America is a young country and happens to be a young country in a very specific day and age where other countries were young countries when you know, like oh thank goodness you have a bow and arrow and that's our technology.
[29:17] Tommy: Um like you know, we had guns.
[29:20] Jimi: Um it puts America in an interesting place. All this to say white guilt's a big American thing. We don't talk about it enough. It's a big I think it was a big problem in the 50s, 60s, 70s. I think it's a big problem. Problem's the wrong word. I think it's an interesting concept in the 50s, 60s, 70s. I think it's an interesting concept in 2017, yeah. Because if you know, if recent months haven't been enough evidence racism is alive and well and living in America, exactly. And like, and the concept and the idea of white guilt is intertwined with that, and it is a less than talked about one because it comes from the side of what would be considered quote unquote the good guys. You know. It's easy to talk about people who are racist and assholes because they're away and they're far and it's like a hard line.
But it's more difficult to talk about like the embarrassment you feel for your white ancestors who enslaved people. Exactly. And and all the, you know, nuanced and difficult history that followed. Um I think it is interesting to put the we talked about this in um her in Hello Dolly, however long ago. Um to talk about the concept of white guilt as it relates to Broadway, because musical theater is, you know, for worse, not for better or for worse, just for worse, a very white art form up until maybe very recently. Um and even then it's like here we're starting to see a change. Right. And it's like and and like we point at the change because it sparkles and shines. It's not like, oh yeah, great.
It's not like casual. It's like, look at this! Oh my god, Hamilton, you know. Um it's something to talk about. I think like to this quote, uh, the only reason this musical has made it on the Great White Way is the Great White Guilt. It's played off as a bad thing. I don't like if that's true, which I think is worth discussion, I think this musical's on Broadway because it's a good musical. I also think this musical's on Broadway because of the Great White Guilt. And I think that's okay. Yes.
[31:45] Tommy: And I do agree with you. Because I I would never, like I've said before, I would never have known who these Scottsboro boys were. Right. Unless John Kander and Fred Ebb and David Thompson told this story. Yeah. I would never have known. I would never have known. Um and this is a story I need to know. It's a story that everyone needs to know. Yeah. And like I think I think we've said it in sideways ways before, but the thing the thing I think musical theater can do is it can tell a story and make you feel the everything of it all. Um I can tell you that the Scottsboro boys were a couple of teenagers who were wrongly accused of rape in, you know, the pre-Civil Rights Movement Southern America. But to tell it with music, with these characters, with the subtle nuance that you can include, you know, in a tap dance about an electric chair, like that helps you get at the the pathos of it all, the feeling of it all, in a way that like a textbook definition can't.
[32:48] Jimi: Yeah, definitely. A hundred percent. You're feeling you get to feel something at the theater.
[32:54] Tommy: Yeah. Um, and it's it's important that these stories are told in a theatrical way. Um, and again, we will get on to more of that in a little bit.
[33:06] Jimi: Yep. And like super super unfortunate that there aren't black musical theater artists that existed in, you know, 2010 who could bring this to the stage. This is not the best solution, but better this than you know, than nothing.
[33:24] Tommy: Yeah. Than nothing. And I think that that's kind of one of the points that um John McQuarter's trying to make in that article is that he is saying that not today, like not now. We don't like you shouldn't be telling the story now. But I'm like, no, they should. And the thing is, is like this show this show is extremely polarizing.
[33:45] Jimi: Yes.
[33:47] Tommy: Absolutely. It's extremely polarizing, and it it does make you feel uncomfortable, and it's very much supposed to make you feel uncomfortable. And make you angry.
[33:55] Jimi: It's supposed to make you angry.
[33:56] Tommy: Yeah. Um where your anger gets directed is the thing.
[34:00] Jimi: Yeah.
[34:01] Tommy: Um, and that is what political theatre is.
[34:04] Jimi: Yes.
[34:05] Tommy: And what it should be. And so to me, this is a great example of political theatre.
[34:13] Jimi: Yes. To to that end. To that end, we should do a transition because I want to talk about why it makes people angry.
[34:19] Tommy: Well, talk about the things that the Bruces say that we're gonna talk about in a little minutes. Get ready.
[34:24] Jimi: Okay.
[34:27] Tommy: It worked nothing.
[34:32] Jimi: When you came here nothing.
[34:43] Tommy: It's surreal.
[34:47] Jimi: How do you know?
[34:55] Tommy: That's the truth, and nothing but.
[34:58] Jimi: Okay. Talk about it.
[35:01] Tommy: So the people. The other half, the part that the part that John McQuarter wasn't quite angry about were all the protests that surrounded this show. Um and a lot of the protests were centered around its vehicle of telling the story through a minstrel show. A like, you know, hardline racist kind of art form. Um that's one of the things that made people angry. And uh Whoopi Goldberg, of all people, um, came out saying, like, that's that's that's not true. That's like people are protesting this and they haven't seen it. Go see it and then decide whether you want to protest it, which is counterintuitive, certainly. Um, but I think what were you gonna say?
[35:45] Jimi: No, no, no, keep going, sorry.
[35:47] Tommy: Okay. I I like the question I have, and this is the question this is the question anyone who would protest this show needs to ask, and I think one of the deep-seated questions of the discussion of the vehicle of the show is a black minstrel show racist. Is the concept of black people putting on these stereotypes of a minstrel show a racist portrayal?
[36:18] Jimi: And well, so in sorry, no, no, you say I'm sorry, I always did.
[36:22] Tommy: Um instantly you need to go to history there because black people performed in minstrel shows.
[36:30] Jimi: Right.
[36:30] Tommy: Way back in the day. Yeah. Change started to begin as you moved in towards vaudeville, um, change started to begin when more and more black people performed in minstrel shows because what they were able to do was start to temper it.
[36:48] Jimi: Yeah.
[36:48] Tommy: Um and start to move away from the stereotypes and show a little bit more reality.
[36:56] Jimi: Well and so I think the answer to the question is a black minstrel show racist? I think the answer is yes.
[37:07] Tommy: Because they are so if you watch these black actors putting on these stereotypes of this form that was a minstrel show, and you're sitting in the audience, you're like, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. That's not okay. They can't, that's not what black people are like.
[37:25] Jimi: Exactly.
[37:25] Tommy: Then you've immediately flipped that switch in your head that says this is not okay when white people did it.
[37:35] Jimi: Yeah.
[37:36] Tommy: And like, not that it would have been okay if white people put on blackface and did very accurate representation of what black life was like in the mid eight mid to late 1800s.
[37:49] Jimi: Exactly.
[37:50] Tommy: Yeah. But the stuff they were doing was not accurate, was exaggerated, was stereotyped stereotypes, because of course, but so that's that's the point.
[38:04] Jimi: That's the our specialty as white people.
[38:07] Tommy: That's the like, of course this is wrong, and look at it, stare at it.
[38:15] Jimi: Yeah.
[38:15] Tommy: It's the it's the thing that is like I said before, it's the thing that Kander and Ebb are very good at doing. Um not just Kander and Ebb, uh Matt and Parker and Stone, I can't remember their trait on that from yeah, and Book of Mormon.
[38:32] Jimi: Yeah.
[38:33] Tommy: Um very much dubs we'll get to. But these guys are masters at making you laugh, and then instantly being like, oh my god, I shouldn't have done that.
[38:44] Jimi: And that's we've talked about this a million times. That's the beautiful part of musical theater. It disarms you and then punches you in the gut.
[38:50] Tommy: Exactly.
[38:51] Jimi: Exactly. You go along and you have that good time and then you feel awful about it, and it makes you think.
[38:56] Tommy: Yeah.
[38:56] Jimi: And it it stirs up this emotion in you. You're not you're not just being numb, and you're not just sitting back and having a lovely time.
[39:04] Tommy: Right.
[39:05] Jimi: You're thinking.
[39:05] Tommy: Yeah.
[39:05] Jimi: You're feeling something, and that is so important.
[39:09] Tommy: But the powerful part about it is there are brief moments, there are, you know, a couple seconds where you are just having a lovely time. Where you're like, what an entertaining little number. What oh oh how sweet. Oh how cute. But then in a very Brechtian way, you know, you're snapped back into reality, and you're like, and you get that gut punch.
[39:28] Jimi: Oh no, oh I enjoyed that.
[39:29] Tommy: Oh no, I enjoyed that.
[39:31] Jimi: That's awful.
[39:32] Tommy: What is going on in my mind?
[39:34] Jimi: Yeah.
[39:35] Tommy: And so in it it's one of those well that it's important to say that in the show, it's not all like that.
[39:40] Jimi: It's not all very subversive.
[39:42] Tommy: Yeah. There are moments of very out and out honesty, and very much like this is we're telling the story straight.
[39:51] Jimi: Yeah.
[39:51] Tommy: Um, which again I think is also important because if it was all the other way, you might worryingly you might get people who would miss it.
[39:59] Jimi: Yeah, absolutely.
[40:00] Tommy: You know what I mean? I mean it does that wonderful thing that musical theater can do where it like is like 16 framing stories in by the time you get to the honesty of the story, and then it zooms back out again, and each step you take m you know makes you analyze the different assumptions you're making about the story you just watched.
[40:19] Jimi: Yeah, definitely.
[40:21] Tommy: Um it it's really well done. Um and you're right, that is such a good point. Is it racist? Yes, but in many ways a lot of theatre is, but it's not racist in the sense of it's going out to make a racist statement.
[40:36] Jimi: Right.
[40:36] Tommy: It's highlighting racism.
[40:38] Jimi: Yeah, yes, exactly.
[40:40] Tommy: Like it is it is very knowingly racist.
[40:44] Jimi: Yeah.
[40:44] Tommy: In a lot of ways. I would I would give you that.
[40:46] Jimi: I would totally give you that.
[40:47] Tommy: In a way to point it out.
[40:48] Jimi: And it has, you know, what a what what a wonderfully convenient vehicle to do it in, a very racist vehicle.
[40:55] Tommy: Um and like they, you know, the the two characters who play the white women who accuse these men of rape, um and they're very caricatured, and they're, you know, they're not nuanced, they're you know, completely in stereotype.
[41:09] Jimi: And if you're sitting in the audience and you're like, no, no, no, that's wrong. That's not what this should be, then immediately your next thought is like, oh, but wait, wait, we were doing that.
[41:20] Tommy: We've been doing that for years.
[41:22] Jimi: Yeah, you know, which like in in the worst way, the argument is that, you know, is that an eye for an eye? Is that like you were racist, now we're gonna be mean and racist.
[41:35] Tommy: Um but some something about the the subtle and like very particular way this musical is constructed m makes it okay, I think.
[41:48] Jimi: Yeah, definitely, definitely.
[41:50] Tommy: Because it all creates that feeling, it stirs something um without being stupid.
[41:55] Jimi: Yeah, without being stupid, without being flippant.
[41:58] Tommy: Yeah. I do want to talk a little bit about the protest a little bit more um and kind of talk about why that was happening.
[42:05] Jimi: Yeah.
[42:06] Tommy: Um, so I think the crucial thing to know is I think like nine about 90% of the people hadn't seen the show.
[42:15] Jimi: They arrived 10 minutes before the show and 10 minutes after.
[42:18] Tommy: They didn't even hang around during the show to make this very public protest. Um so it was a group um called the Freedom Party, who are kind of like an extension of the Freedom Party.
[42:33] Jimi: Um now the Freedom Party uh back in the 60s were a huge part of the civil rights movement and did wonderful things, and so the Freedom Party is kind of like an off cut of that and uh kind of mixed up in some controversy.
[42:54] Tommy: They said that again.
[42:56] Jimi: Um they're uh you know it's their intentions are sometimes a little bit questionable.
[43:05] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[43:06] Jimi: Um what I'm not saying here is I'm not saying you know, the the opinion thing, I'm not saying they're wrong.
[43:11] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[43:12] Jimi: Of course they're entitled to me, and of course you can see exactly what they mean, and you can see exactly what why they're protesting, you know.
[43:19] Tommy: Um, but what one of the main things the creators of the show wanted them to do was come and see it so they could have a conversation about it.
[43:26] Jimi: Right.
[43:26] Tommy: Do you know what I mean? And that's the crucial part is that they weren't willing to have this conversation.
[43:31] Jimi: Yeah.
[43:31] Tommy: Um, but so interestingly enough, I watched a video of putting in the show notes um about well, it was a video of them protesting basically, and kind of hearing their side of the story um and what they what they were protesting about.
[43:48] Jimi: And very interestingly, there was a point where I was like, I'm with you, I'm actually with you on this because um one of their comments is about one of the posters, and on the posters it says 1,000 laughs guaranteed.
[44:01] Jimi: Um, I get why they're saying that's awful because they're saying this isn't, it's not a laughing story, it's not a laughing matter. This story isn't a comedy, right?
[44:12] Tommy: Yeah.
[44:15] Jimi: And so looking at that poster, I would be like, oh, that's a comedy. Who are these Scottsboro Boys? Cool, let's go. Do you know what I mean? Um, now on the flip side of that, uh-huh.
[44:28] Tommy: Well, what they would do for those people who would look at that, oh, that's a comedy, great. They've got them hook, line, and sinker.
[44:33] Jimi: Right. Because they're going in. And they're gonna go see it. A thousand laughs.
[44:36] Tommy: And they may laugh and then feel bad about it.
[44:40] Jimi: Exactly. And like I think, I think this show is a comedy in moments.
[44:49] Tommy: Well, in the sense that minstrel shows were there to entertain you.
[44:53] Jimi: Yeah, like in the sense that it's absolutely a farce in every definition of the term, and then it's a farce that also happened, and then you, it's beautiful when you hit these shows where like the show continues after you left the theatre, which I think the show absolutely is, like you're like, oh my god, oh my god, oh my god, that happened and that made me feel these things.
[45:14] Tommy: Yeah, completely. But to these protests, the American Freedom Party, I don't know how much of this hits you in the UK, the American Freedom Party is bullshit.
[45:25] Jimi: Right, okay. Total, total, like big money manufacturing, at least by the time 2010 hits.
[45:34] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[45:34] Jimi: These are racists.
[45:35] Tommy: So that's because that's what I'd read, and I didn't know how much truth was in it, so I didn't really want to comment on it.
[45:39] Jimi: But you know that they're doing a lot of it for publicity and publicity's sake.
[45:45] Tommy: Yeah.
[45:45] Jimi: And actually, interestingly enough, the writer of the show comments on this, and he says that what these protesters are doing are exactly what people did to the boys back in the day.
[46:01] Tommy: Yep.
[46:02] Jimi: They used them as like a political stepping stone.
[46:06] Tommy: And I never, you know, what the most horrible things. So the Communist Party, and they do make a brief comment on it in the finale of the show, um, that the Communist Party basically tried to keep them in jail because they were such a great, it was such a great voice and such a great martyrdom.
[46:24] Jimi: Do you know what I mean? They were trying to make martyrs out of these boys instead of trying to get them free.
[46:29] Tommy: Yeah, exactly. Because the longer they could spin it, the more cause that they would have.
[46:34] Jimi: And it's such a tricky thing because it's, and like it's twofold here. So I think very much, you know, the American Freedom Party in 2010, the thing they're protesting deep down inside, is like, how dare you point out that we were racist?
[46:52] Tommy: Um, right, okay.
[46:54] Jimi: Like I re, like if you boil it down to the dregs, I think that's what you end up with. How dare you acknowledge this piece of human history? Obviously, we're past that. Why must we keep talking about it?
[47:06] Tommy: Which is, that's the dark side to white guilt.
[47:09] Jimi: Um, but the other part, which to your point and in our notes here, I think is the song that's not the way we do things.
[47:18] Tommy: Yes.
[47:18] Jimi: Um, lots to say about this. So in, um, in this, is it wait, is it worth starting a new segment?
[47:26] Tommy: It's always worth starting a new segment.
[47:28] Jimi: Let's start a new segment.
[47:31] Tommy: Back in Manhattan, ask anyone. There's no bigger voice for equal rights than me.
[47:37] Jimi: I find for it.
[47:39] Tommy: I live for it. Just ask my cook, Jamaica.
[47:47] Jimi: What a mess!
[47:48] Tommy: Just ask our colored laundress, and I'm sure they'll agree.
[47:52] Jimi: That's right. Give a rail, Mr. M.
[47:54] Tommy: I said the folks up north all wanna see a go free.
[48:04] Jimi: So they sent you down the very best.
[48:04] Tommy: That's why they sent me. Although the wall may be disgusting hearing.
[48:10] Jimi: Alabama, but it's not the way we see things.
[48:13] Tommy: That's not the way we deal things. That's not the way we do things in New York.
[48:15] Jimi: That's not the way we do things.
[48:26] Tommy: I think this is one of the most important songs in the show.
[48:29] Jimi: And this is a song that makes it, makes the show.
[48:34] Tommy: So that's not the way we do things. In the real life Scottsboro Boys, um, a lawyer named Samuel Liebowitz is, I don't know, assigned, given the case of these boys. Um, he's not from the South. He's, he's a Yank.
[48:48] Jimi: Um, he's from the North. Um, and like the, this is why it has, why it becomes a civil rights movement, you know, firecracker. Um, is this southern case has been making waves up in the north.
[49:03] Tommy: Which, like, why would it? Who cares?
[49:06] Jimi: But because there's this, because it is based in racism and it's making the news and all these things are happening. And so this lawyer comes and is like gonna represent these boys and is like, he's, you know, he's taken the case on pro bono, he's gonna make it work. He's, you know, taken, he's like, there's some article about how he, you know, paid for his wife to come there, and like the all, you know, this is out of the kindness of his heart, and in the musical, it manifests itself in this song, "That's Not the Way We Do Things," which is sung by Samuel Liebowitz, um, who is the whole point is he, you know, he sees these drinking fountains in Alabama. One is for whites and one is for colored only.
[49:51] Tommy: Um, and that's not, that's not the way we do things in New York. That's not how New York is. New York is progressive. New York, we argue for equality. Just ask my maid, she'll tell you. Just ask my chauffeur, you know.
[50:06] Jimi: Um, just ask my cook Jemima, like how that's not how we do things. We don't do things that way in New York. Everyone's equal. Just ask all the black people who wait on me hand in foot. We don't do stuff like that.
[50:21] Tommy: Exactly. And I think this song is so important in the show because it undermines the white guilt argument, it undermines the, um, you know, apologist revisionist kind of argument. Like this guy who came, I'm sure, in his own mind with the best of intentions trying to save these people, like, is called out in a very blunt kind of way, where like the North might not be as backwater, might not be killing black people left and right, but still has plenty of racism built into the society.
[51:05] Jimi: Um, which makes it so important.
[51:08] Tommy: Definitely. Um, yeah, that the first time I heard it, that was when I heard that song, I was like, this is a good show.
[51:15] Jimi: Yeah.
[51:15] Tommy: Because I was like, they're saying something here. They're really, really saying something.
[51:19] Jimi: Yeah. Um, I have a lot of, I have a lot of thoughts about this issue.
[51:24] Tommy: Yeah.
[51:24] Jimi: Um, particularly as someone from the UK. So do you know who Jane Elliott is?
[51:31] Tommy: The name rings a bell.
[51:33] Jimi: You will know, you will know her, you'll know what she does. So basically, Jane Elliott is the pioneer of the blue eyes brown eyes experiment.
[51:36] Tommy: Blue eyes brown eyes, yes, I knew I recognized her.
[51:44] Jimi: We study her in um education studies in America.
[51:47] Tommy: Cool.
[51:48] Jimi: Yeah, totally understandable why. Um, so she, I think we've talked about this in the podcast as well before, but it's really, this is the time to talk about it. Um, she after um Martin Luther King was assassinated, she went into her class, um, which is all white.
[52:08] Tommy: Um, her kindergarten class, I believe.
[52:11] Jimi: Her kindergarten class, yeah, exactly. Very important to know. Young kids, yeah, very young kids. Um, and obviously she was so affronted by what had just happened, she wanted to teach her kids about it and teach them properly.
[52:25] Tommy: So she created this activity, I guess, um, where she segregated her children according to something as trivial as their eye color, something as random and as trivial as the eye color.
[52:37] Jimi: You um, you have to look up their documentaries on this and their own.
[52:40] Tommy: Yeah, so that's, yeah, that's what I'm gonna get to in a little bit. So the basic idea is that the blue-eyed children are great, perfect, uh, they own the class, they can get extra uh recess, um, they get to sit at the front, they have all of these privileges.
[53:00] Jimi: Um, the people with brown eyes, the kids with brown eyes have to wear a collar, and they're stupid, and they don't really understand things.
[53:06] Tommy: Yes, and they're setting us in the playground. Because don't you know brown eyes people, brown-eyed people are just, they're just indifferent.
[53:12] Jimi: Yeah, they're just, yeah, they're stupid, and that's just the way it is. Um, and the kids very quickly caught on to this, and yeah, it was a such an interesting social experiment.
[53:25] Tommy: So I'm not gonna spit like tell the results, but go watch it. Like, go watch the initial documentary.
[53:31] Jimi: Um, then I want you to fall into a Jane Elliott hole and blaze all of the people. Everything she's ever done. And so I will say, Jimmy, the we study this in Ed Psych in college in theater school, in uh teacher school in my world.
[53:46] Tommy: And as part of my um college education, we taught sample classes to other college kids.
[53:53] Jimi: And one of the classes we decided to teach was a hidden blue eyes brown eyes experiment.
[54:01] Tommy: Okay, cool.
[54:02] Jimi: Was kids showed up in the door and they got either pamphlet one or pamphlet two, which was about like folding origami or something.
[54:09] Tommy: And pamphlet one had like really specific instructions and was like, you know, here's how you do this, and pamphlet two was impossible to follow.
[54:16] Jimi: And all the kids who got pamphlet two, they had to sit in a corner of the room, they didn't get chairs, they had to sit on the floor. Um, and like we, you know, we yelled at them, and like pamphlet one was like, Oh, here, we'll help you um and like this was a 40 minute sample lesson and it was really a 20 minute sample lesson because in the next 20 minutes we were like pause and then we came back in we're like all right let's tell you what we did and let's see how you reacted.
[54:20] Tommy: Yeah, and in twenty minutes my, I think pretty much entirely white class the kids who you know were told they were bad and were sat in the corner had started acting up had started throwing things yeah like college kids in a sample made up kind of lesson yeah this is amazingly effective and true.
[55:02] Jimi: Yep, it really, really is and so she does it, I mean she does it sometimes with high school kids, she does it with um college kids, does it with adults, yeah, um the one that got me, the one that I'm leading to here is the time she did it in the UK.
[55:15] Tommy: Okay.
[55:17] Jimi: And I've never felt more ashamed of being British than I did after watching that and it made me sick to my stomach.
[55:25] Tommy: Yeah.
[55:25] Jimi: Um, because what you had there, so one of the main things about these documentaries and you'll see it anyone you watch, she's successful.
[55:33] Tommy: Yeah.
[55:33] Jimi: At the end of it, people get it and they understand and they accept it. The point she tries to make is that we're all racist.
[55:42] Tommy: Yeah.
[55:42] Jimi: Right? We have this amazing privilege. I says that you'll have seen her in that I think the point I would disagree with that characterization only subtly I think the point she makes is we're all, we all succumb to the downfalls of prejudice.
[56:01] Tommy: And often those are based around race.
[56:06] Jimi: Yeah. But in it just in a sense that she's like, and she, she does it. There's a viral video that goes around and it's her, and you might not know it's her, but it's her. Um, and she says um to everyone, it's a lecture hall, and she's like, which of you here would be black?
[56:24] Tommy: Or I'm totally paraphrasing here.
[56:26] Jimi: Right. But she's like, who would change your race to be black? Yeah, right now. The fact that don't nobody said she's like, that's your privilege, that's your privilege right there.
[56:36] Tommy: Yeah.
[56:36] Jimi: Realize it. Um, and I am so grateful that I have found her because it made me realize it. And I was like, yes, okay, this is what I need to do now.
[56:44] Tommy: And now you need to put in the work to change, to make a change.
[56:49] Jimi: And every day you should be learning, and every day you should be making a change. Um, so going back to this UK one, please watch it, it'll be in the show notes. Um, and if you're especially if you're from the UK, because you might not realize it, um, but it's so important that you realize it.
[57:04] Tommy: We have such, such a race issue in the UK, and it's very different from the way it is in the States.
[57:11] Jimi: Um, we to the point where we are, we're deniers, we are the not the way we do things.
[57:21] Tommy: We don't do race over here, we don't have a race issue in the UK, yeah, says so many people in the UK.
[57:28] Jimi: Yeah, quote, quote unquote, I don't see color.
[57:31] Tommy: Exactly.
[57:32] Jimi: I don't see, oh no, that's, we, we don't have, that's an American thing.
[57:36] Tommy: Yeah, that's an African thing.
[57:37] Jimi: We don't have race issues in the UK. And despite the fact that there were women who were, there was one woman who's African American, or Afgharibbean, sorry, and there was one woman who was uh Muslim, I think.
[57:55] Tommy: Um, and they were both saying, We have encountered racism, people are racist towards us on a daily basis.
[58:03] Jimi: They are telling this to this woman, and she is saying back, no, you're wrong, we're not racist in this country, right?
[58:10] Tommy: And I've felt so sick, and she, Jane Elliott loses control. And I've never seen her not succeed.
[58:16] Jimi: I've never seen her not succeed. It comes into the presenter of the show, who's actually a very news broadcaster, um, wages in, and it's also a bit like, yes, it's obviously not as bad here, and she's like, No, yeah, you've got it worse. Do you know what I mean?
[58:37] Jimi: And it's what people don't realize, and it's this denial that sickens me to my stomach because it's so rife.
[58:44] Tommy: It is so rife in the UK.
[58:46] Jimi: This weird, oh, we're British, it's fine. We don't have these issues.
[58:51] Tommy: Yeah, no, we seriously do.
[58:53] Jimi: We seriously, seriously do, and it's coming more to light now with immigration, with um obviously the whole Brexit campaign.
[59:01] Tommy: Like, we have our bloody issues, like we really, really do.
[59:05] Jimi: It's a hot button issue in 2017. I mean, it's you know, the Scottsboro Boys exist right now in America in the UK, and there are cases that have happened, and there are cases that are about to happen, and like so there of the prison population of 2,424,000, 279 inmates, 44% of them, that's more than a million, are black.
[59:38] Tommy: Yep.
[59:40] Jimi: Sixty-five percent of black boys grow up in fatherless homes.
[59:44] Tommy: There are 919,000 black men enrolled in college in the whole of the United States of America.
[59:52] Jimi: My um my boyfriend the doctor was talking about how there are studies coming out that black women die earlier because higher level of the whatever chemical is created by stress in their life.
[1:00:09] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:00:11] Jimi: It's endemic.
[1:00:13] Tommy: Right.
[1:00:13] Jimi: It's such an issue. All this to say to, you know, people protesting the show in 2010 under the line of like, why must we talk about this now? We're past this.
[1:00:24] Tommy: Obviously not.
[1:00:28] Jimi: Obviously not. And so, like, doom and gloom and awful and all this stuff, but the only solution is to talk about it.
[1:00:29] Tommy: The only solution is to talk about it.
[1:00:40] Jimi: Like we make no progress otherwise.
[1:00:45] Tommy: We spin in the same goddamn circles, otherwise.
[1:00:49] Jimi: Have conversations. Educate yourself.
[1:00:52] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:00:52] Jimi: Learn about the Scottsboro Boys, learn about Rosa Parks, learn about any of these moments in history.
[1:01:01] Tommy: No and try and understand.
[1:01:03] Jimi: No, yeah.
[1:01:03] Tommy: Yeah, no, not Mobis contemporaries.
[1:01:06] Jimi: Right. Well, and no, be okay with the fact that you're gonna make mistakes.
[1:01:11] Tommy: Exactly.
[1:01:11] Jimi: Like, we're this is none of this is easy, and that's the point.
[1:01:17] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:01:17] Jimi: Check that privilege that you have. Accept it. I think it's even I I struggle with the I've struggled with this for years, and I've only recently been able to articulate it. I struggle with the um uh imperative to check your privilege.
[1:01:31] Tommy: The point of this kind of privilege, the point of white privilege, the point of cis privilege, the point of street privilege, the point of male privilege, is that there is a part of it that you will never be able to fully understand. That's why you're privileged.
[1:01:47] Jimi: And so I I would never tell someone to check their privilege. I say acknowledge that you are privileged. That's why I'm sorry, that's what I mean by it. When I say check, I don't mean change. I mean you have it.
[1:01:58] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:01:59] Jimi: You've got it. You've got it. I'm the luckiest person in the world because I'm a white man and I can pretend that I'm straight.
[1:02:05] Tommy: Right, exactly.
[1:02:07] Jimi: Yeah. That's shit. That's real shit. But that's the that's the way it is. So I need to educate myself.
[1:02:14] Tommy: Right.
[1:02:15] Jimi: And it's not, maybe to go back to our very first point, it's not white guilt. I didn't I didn't do this. I don't feel guilty about this. I didn't do any of this. I don't feel bad about this.
[1:02:26] Tommy: You know, this is a hundred years ago.
[1:02:31] Jimi: I feel bad about the shit my peers are doing today.
[1:02:33] Tommy: Right.
[1:02:34] Jimi: That's something I feel guilty about. But it's not this historic white guilt that people hearkening back to. It's I don't want to be that chapter in the history book.
[1:02:39] Tommy: I don't want to be that in a hundred years.
[1:02:48] Jimi: And so the only way I know how to change that is to talk about it and then listen as much as possible.
[1:02:55] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:02:56] Jimi: Um, but it's not, you know, to qualify it as white guilt simplifies it too much.
[1:03:02] Tommy: Definitely.
[1:03:03] Jimi: Definitely. Um, yeah. I realize this all sounds really preachy.
[1:03:08] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:03:08] Jimi: And that's not that's not that's not what we're doing.
[1:03:11] Tommy: That isn't what this is, but we're just as you can probably tell, we're extremely passionate about this.
[1:03:16] Jimi: Um and it's something that I think more people need to get passionate about.
[1:03:21] Tommy: Well, and it's I mean, we we joke about it in sarcastic ways about this show always ending in you know this kind of place or ending up in this kind of place. But it's so, you know, if not if not here, then where?
[1:03:34] Jimi: Yeah, we've talked about musical theater being one of the whitest art forms in the world, and that's ridiculous.
[1:03:39] Tommy: Um art form is for me.
[1:03:39] Jimi: Yeah, I know. Well, for me, it always comes back to the fact that I know musical theater. This is my this is my area of expertise.
[1:03:48] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:03:48] Jimi: So if there's something that's gonna help me understand, it's gonna be a musical.
[1:03:52] Tommy: Right.
[1:03:52] Jimi: Do you know what I mean? And that's why that's why I think we focus on it.
[1:03:57] Tommy: Yeah, that's why I focus on it. It's why the show is so important.
[1:04:01] Jimi: The show is so important. This show came out in 2010.
[1:04:05] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:04:05] Jimi: You remember those moments where you think like, oh yeah, 2001, that's not too long ago, and it's like 20 years ago almost.
[1:04:11] Tommy: This kid, the show came out 2010. The show came out seven years ago.
[1:04:15] Jimi: This is a contemporary show.
[1:04:17] Tommy: Yep.
[1:04:17] Jimi: This is contemporary musical theater like Dear Evan Hansen is. Like this isn't contemporary musical theater like Rent is. This is like now, and people are upset about it, and people have all these issues with it.
[1:04:31] Tommy: Yep.
[1:04:32] Jimi: Um, I'm gonna use that as a lovely segue. Here we go. Because I want to talk about the fact that why does nobody know about this show?
[1:04:43] Tommy: Things happen right before you.
[1:04:49] Jimi: Things happen soon enough y're lost and thank you when I'm gonna go back home my goat maybe time for turn a prison maybe someday I get lucky someone's gonna say take the train and go back home Hop afraid and go back home.
[1:05:56] Tommy: Why does nobody quite get at least why does nobody know about this show?
[1:06:01] Jimi: I think so. I think it's it's summarized. And I'm not I'm doing broad strokes here, obviously.
[1:06:05] Tommy: Right, exactly.
[1:06:06] Jimi: But I I really think no one knows about the show can be summarized in three words, and they are a Book of Mormon.
[1:06:11] Tommy: Um this show premiered in 2010, the same year that Book of Mormon swept the Tony Awards.
[1:06:17] Jimi: Swept, yeah.
[1:06:18] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:06:19] Jimi: Um and so no one heard of the no one, you know, the Scottsboro Boys barely made a dent. It became one of those shows that gets swept to the side and you never hear about yet.
[1:06:28] Tommy: And there's a brilliant interview with um uh Strowman online. Post post Tony's um, where she's like, Man, we didn't expect to be nominated, and we were nominated like twelve times, and that's amazing.
[1:06:33] Jimi: We didn't expect to get to Broadway, yeah.
[1:06:46] Tommy: Because obviously the you know it's not a big budget show, their set is planks and chairs, and chairs and a couple tambourines, um that's that's their set, yeah.
[1:06:56] Jimi: Um but I think so. I think there's something so nuanced and insidious in this comparison, too. I think it's so much more than just the Book of Mormon is a fabulous musical.
[1:07:05] Tommy: The Book of Mormon. Have you ever noticed this?
[1:07:13] Jimi: This is one of my fascinating contemporary realizations. Think in your mind of all of the advertisements you've ever seen for Book of Mormon.
[1:07:20] Tommy: Yep, every single one.
[1:07:24] Jimi: It's all white guys, right?
[1:07:28] Tommy: It's all it's all the Mormon kids jumping on trampolines flying in the air.
[1:07:32] Jimi: The Book of Mormon's and this is official policy too. They're they're real strict on this. You can't publish photos of certain parts of Book of Mormon.
[1:07:43] Tommy: Their publicity department has a stranglehold on this.
[1:07:46] Jimi: But 90% of the Book of Mormon takes place in Africa.
[1:07:52] Tommy: Literally 90%, yeah.
[1:07:53] Jimi: Yeah. 90% of the Book of Mormon, like, this is a show about the discussion between right white relations and black relations.
[1:08:01] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:08:01] Jimi: Um 50, yeah, the other half of their leads are black.
[1:08:01] Tommy: Are black.
[1:08:06] Jimi: Have you ever seen a publicity photo of them?
[1:08:09] Tommy: Right.
[1:08:09] Jimi: Ever. And like, that's the point. And it's brilliant, it's so clever from their part because the fact that you don't think about it, the fact that you don't even know that Book of Mormon is hiding a secret about itself in this publicity, it's not like mousetrap, it's not like sheer madness, it's not like Mystery of Edwin Food. Where it's like, ooh, and there's a secret, and I'm not going to tell you, you know.
[1:08:37] Tommy: It's like you don't even know that there's a secret going in.
[1:08:41] Jimi: Yeah. It's a wonderful marketing strategy. Um, but it's insidious too.
[1:08:46] Tommy: Because exactly.
[1:08:47] Jimi: As much as the Book of Mormon is a show making fun of Mormons, you know, like satirizing and parroting the Mormon experience. The Book of Mormon is also very much a show about the different experience between the white American and the, you know, it seems redundant to say the black African, but that is what we're doing.
[1:09:09] Tommy: You know, we're in Uganda, everyone's black.
[1:09:11] Jimi: Um and like where the way the Book of Mormon does it's true, it's real, and it's a little racist.
[1:09:23] Tommy: Um a lot of the comedy in the Book of Mormon comes from laughing at, oh, those people in Uganda, how hilarious.
[1:09:35] Jimi: They don't know it's called Salt Lake City, they say Saltaleka City. Like that's a little racist. And it's funny, and it's South Park, so like they don't care.
[1:09:46] Tommy: You know, we're talking about like really extreme, you know, middle fingers in the air.
[1:09:51] Jimi: Um, but is it it is interesting that both these shows were popular in the same season because Book of Mormon allows you to put this black experience very much in the other bucket.
[1:10:05] Tommy: They live in Uganda.
[1:10:06] Jimi: They were born into, you know, poverty doesn't even begin to describe it like everyone has AIDS. Oh, what a funny joke. Fuck you, God! Like, that's the experience they described.
[1:10:20] Tommy: Which may very well be true, but that separation allows you, as the you know, privileged Broadway theater goer to like put that awfulness at a distance in your mind.
[1:10:34] Jimi: They become the other. They're not you, they're not Americans, they're not people who are trying to have the same experience you are. They're not people who are trying to, you know, get a job in Atlanta. They're people in Africa who are trying to survive and like not get shot in the head.
[1:10:50] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:10:51] Jimi: Um it's why Book of Mormon won the Tony and Scottsboro Boys didn't.
[1:10:56] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:10:56] Jimi: And you just have to look at that. And people protest the Scottsboro Boys.
[1:11:01] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:11:02] Jimi: Do you know? I mean, they protest the one that makes you cringe for the right reasons.
[1:11:07] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:11:08] Jimi: And like, I don't think Book of Mormon does it wrong. I think one of the most beautiful things that happens in the Book of Mormon is when they're like at the airport on their way to Africa, and it's it's a hilarious joke.
[1:11:19] Tommy: And they're like, and we will send you to Africa.
[1:11:22] Jimi: And the back curtain rises, and it's a a one-for-one Lion King parody, and you know, they sing the beginning song, and then the joke is like, oh yeah, that's Mrs. Smith. She lives down the block. We hired her to make this Lion King joke for you in this airport. Now have fun in Africa.
[1:11:39] Tommy: Um, and like it's it's a really nuanced joke that that is white people's conception of what Africa is like.
[1:11:50] Jimi: And then you they land in Uganda, and that's not the point. Pushes it into that distant world, which lets you feel you know, p people don't leave the Book of Mormon feeling white guilt the same way they leave the Scottsboro Boys feeling white guilt.
[1:12:06] Tommy: Exactly, yeah, yeah, yeah.
[1:12:08] Jimi: It's I it's really interesting. I haven't thought at length about it.
[1:12:11] Tommy: I still not seen Mormon.
[1:12:12] Jimi: Really?
[1:12:12] Tommy: Um, yeah, I know. I'm one of those people.
[1:12:15] Jimi: Uh I've still not seen it.
[1:12:17] Tommy: And um I'm definitely gonna need to see it before we do it.
[1:12:22] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:12:22] Tommy: It's really interesting.
[1:12:24] Jimi: It's a great I don't know enough about I don't know enough about comedy.
[1:12:26] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:12:26] Jimi: Do you know what I mean? And that's why I think we focus on it.
[1:12:27] Tommy: Don't get me wrong, it's a great show. It's a really good show.
[1:12:31] Jimi: There is Susan Blackwell's favorite musical. It's it's very funny. It's very well written.
[1:12:35] Tommy: Of course, you know, Matt Stone and Trey Parker are gonna write a great musical with the creators they're having a cue.
[1:12:42] Jimi: Um but the creators of South Park, the movie, which has one of the best musical theater songs of the whole time in it. And remember, remember they're white people writing part of a black story. Like there's something disingenuous there.
[1:13:01] Tommy: And they hide it in their satiric way in the same way that Strowman and Candor and Ebb hide it in their minstrel show.
[1:13:13] Jimi: Um, but one is you know, perhaps more convincing and more accepted, or allows you to feel happier when you leave the theater and not examine your life and cry yourself to sleep.
[1:13:23] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:13:25] Tommy: Like, as fortuitous as it is, I think it is fascinating that both these shows hit the Tonies the same year.
[1:13:32] Jimi: Very much so.
[1:13:33] Tommy: Very much so. And I mean, certainly not in articles I've seen. No one talked about that.
[1:13:37] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:13:39] Tommy: Right? I've yet to find someone making that comparison. And that's very interesting.
[1:13:43] Jimi: Why are we only doing this now?
[1:13:46] Tommy: Yeah. Um, and the thing is the crappy, crappy thing is the Book of Mormon opened in 2014 in the UK and was up against Scottsboro Boys once more.
[1:13:57] Jimi: The Olivier's.
[1:13:58] Tommy: Yeah. And the exact same thing happened. Um and it's happened a lot. I went back through just like the most recent years. Um in the year of The Color Purple, Jersey Boys won. New Year of Carolina Change, Arne Q won, Parade, Fossey won. Um, and I'm not gonna include Nixon Arval because Billy Elliott also deals with good issues. But um, you know, these shows in particular talk about race in a very frank way.
[1:14:29] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:14:30] Tommy: A very make you feel uncomfortable way.
[1:14:33] Jimi: Well, and from not in a I would say Hairspray or Ragtime kind of way, which I think are important stories to tell, and perhaps feel a little more legitimate coming from white authorship. Um because they're about they're about the conflict.
[1:14:55] Tommy: Yeah, not about the experience.
[1:14:59] Jimi: Yep.
[1:14:59] Tommy: Um, and obviously, you know, Parade is written by Jason Robert Brown, who's Jewish, and a huge part of Parade is you know how Judaism and Leo Frank's Judaism and how that all comes into it. Um you know, Carolina Change is about a maid who's black and the white family and how that all works together. Um, you know, they're come from there's evidence of you know understanding in those shows, but basically my point is you know I can count you a million people who know Jersey Boys, who know Avenue Q. Okay, maybe they don't know Fossey, okay. I'll give you that. Uh but Jerry's Avenue Q but they should the biggest sure as hell don't know Parade, like they definitely don't know Carolina Change, yeah. They might know The Color Purple recently that we had that great revival, um but before that revival, would they have known The Color Purple?
[1:15:57] Jimi: Yeah, that's a good question.
[1:15:59] Tommy: And it's yeah, and these are the stories in my opinion, these are the stories that should be being told. These are the stories that you should remember.
[1:16:05] Jimi: These are the paragons of musical theatre, right? These are why we do theatre, as far as we you know, that's our thesis on musical theatre.
[1:16:15] Tommy: Exactly. These are the theatre moments in musical theatre, it's not the happy clappy have a great time, right? Which I've known and I appreciate, and that that is a huge part of musical theatre, but the ones that when I'm having conversations with people who are throwing musical theatre down the pan, I need to bring up my Carolina Changes and my Color Purples and my Parades.
[1:16:36] Jimi: Yeah, because they're my argument.
[1:16:38] Tommy: Yep. And they're my argument. They're not the ones that win Tony Awards.
[1:16:43] Jimi: Exactly. And so as we enter the Tony Awards this year, what are the stories that aren't or that are gonna get forgotten about?
[1:16:52] Tommy: Oh, it's you know it's such a tough question. And it's such a tough question. And it will happen. There will be shows. There's so much this year. This year is huge.
[1:17:02] Jimi: Yes.
[1:17:02] Tommy: Um, and what are the ones that we're gonna forget about? Who remembers Phila? I'm sorry, right.
[1:17:07] Jimi: Do you know what I mean?
[1:17:09] Tommy: And I'm I'm not even I'm not even kidding. Who remembers Phila?
[1:17:12] Jimi: Yeah, no.
[1:17:13] Tommy: At the time, that was big.
[1:17:15] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:17:15] Tommy: And then it didn't win. And so we forget about it.
[1:17:18] Jimi: Yep.
[1:17:19] Tommy: Yep.
[1:17:19] Jimi: And like the question is, and you know, maybe bonus episode coming up, get excited. Maybe we'll discuss it more. Um I think the big question of now is are we in, you know, are we are we pH? Are we post Hamilton? Or is that just gonna be a blip on the radar?
[1:17:38] Tommy: Um and there's I also don't think in our very diverse in different ways and like filled with within breadth season, I don't think there's a good trial case for it this season quite yet. We're we're seeing like the the stutters and hints of it all, but there's not another there's not another Hamilton yet in the same way that Hamilton was revolutionary.
[1:18:04] Jimi: And that's do you know what? I'm I'm I'm picking I've picked out the examples here of fake news, dude, because there are moments where the flip side has happened and the right show has won.
[1:18:16] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:18:16] Jimi: Do you know what I mean?
[1:18:17] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:18:17] Jimi: But it's all too rare.
[1:18:18] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:18:19] Jimi: It's all too rare. And and you know, last year, I think, oh, I think this is right. All the featured actresses and actors and best actors and actresses, categories were won by people of color. Um are we post-Hamilton? Or does it, you know, are we post Hamilton in the way that in the same way that postmodern is postmodern? Where like Well, I mean, the thing is is like you just have to look at our leads from this year. Right.
[1:18:43] Tommy: And we're back into Whitewash though.
[1:18:47] Jimi: They're all just kind of white.
[1:18:48] Tommy: Yeah. And like not intentionally. All you have to look at is, you know, the recasting of Josh Groban to know that it's not the point. But we're we're definitely very white again. And we're telling loads of white stories again.
[1:19:06] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:19:07] Tommy: But this is it. And it, you know, it comes back to it comes back to what we said earlier. Um you know about Kander and Ebb. It's it all comes together. You've crafted this very well. Kander and Ebb and knowing your privilege and accepting your privilege and using that. And using it. I feel that Kander and Ebb and David Thompson have used their privilege well and have told the right story.
[1:19:33] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:19:33] Tommy: Like Scottsboro Boys. That should never be forgotten. Should never if you know, we say this all the time, and I I think it would we, you know, back on Fiddler we talked about this. Do you think anyone has made it all the way through this podcast not having listened to this?
[1:19:50] Jimi: Scottsboro Boys is a musical you need to listen to.
[1:19:53] Tommy: Exactly. Now I know it's not very available. Um my god, it was such a struggle.
[1:19:59] Jimi: Exactly.
[1:20:00] Tommy: I had to pay for it.
[1:20:01] Jimi: I know pay for it.
[1:20:03] Tommy: And I don't begrudge it because I paid for both cast albums. I had the struggle, I had to struggle through the stupidness that is Apple Music and iTunes in my iPhone again to buy this stuff.
[1:20:12] Jimi: Is it on Apple Music?
[1:20:13] Tommy: It was on iTunes.
[1:20:17] Jimi: Is that wait?
[1:20:19] Tommy: So Apple Music.
[1:20:20] Jimi: It took I don't have Apple Music. Moral of the story. Pay for the show and listen to it.
[1:20:27] Tommy: Right.
[1:20:28] Jimi: Oh, a hundred percent. Yeah. Like, don't, you know, I mean, pay for cast albums in general. If you pay for Spotify Premium, then okay, cool. Then great. Um, but this was worth saying that because that's worth it. But um yeah, but buy cast albums. Like don't like okay. I understand people might be in economic hardships, but you know, it's eight, it's it was eight pounds. I don't know what it is for you. Ten dollars? Something like that.
[1:20:52] Tommy: I think it's about eleven bucks.
[1:20:53] Jimi: Yeah, yeah. Like it is just do it. But now interestingly, what one would you pick? Have you listened to them both yet?
[1:20:57] Tommy: No, I've only listened to what is the off-Broadway cast recording, I guess.
[1:21:02] Jimi: Off property, okay. Um I I love the way I really love the West End recording. The first one I listened to as well, so that always makes me a little bit biased. But um I I prefer it. That's the one I go to. So that's the one I would recommend. If you're thinking I don't want to spend 16 pounds, however 20 dollars. Uh-huh. That's perfectly understandable. Uh buy one.
[1:21:29] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:21:29] Jimi: And I would maybe go for the money. Because that's the most up-to-date.
[1:21:32] Tommy: Okay.
[1:21:33] Jimi: That sounds legit. It's worth this is a show where it's worth it for the content.
[1:21:37] Tommy: 100%.
[1:21:38] Jimi: Yeah. I also think educate yourself. It's the big it's the big travesty with with this, with Hairspray, with Ragtime, with these sorts of shows. The you know, I feel this is a musical theater educator, and it's something we I think kind of tiptoed around when I was learning to be a teacher in theater school, but it's something I feel very much. Um, at least in America. Theater, musical theater, high school musical theater is a very white kid kind of thing. Um for a bunch of systemic reasons that are awful in every way. From school district funding to, you know, if you like it it comes to the systematic disenfranchisement of black people in America and how there's poverty rampant, and you can't afford to go see a show if you're like big problems.
[1:22:34] Tommy: Um endemic, yeah.
[1:22:35] Jimi: Yeah, endemic, very much so. And it means the Scottsboro Boys doesn't get performed because there aren't as many theater troops that you know have nine, ten, eleven, twelve black actors that they can just count on showing up to cast, and you certainly can't race bend this show.
[1:22:54] Tommy: A hundred percent.
[1:22:55] Jimi: This isn't a Hairspray where there's some blurred lines, and you know, or like a Once on This Island where you yeah, right, exactly. Nope. Please never ever do this show unless you have the cast for it. Not that I can think anyone ever would you'd have to be a special kind of idiot to do that, but it does mean it's a story that like you know, whereas isn't gonna get told that much. Whereas Sound of Music, you know, you probably don't have to drive 20 miles to see a production of The Sound of Music right now.
[1:23:25] Tommy: Exactly, exactly.
[1:23:26] Jimi: Yeah. Um so that's why you buy the cast album.
[1:23:29] Tommy: Yep.
[1:23:30] Jimi: That keeps it alive, it keeps the thought alive. It's really important in our art world, is like recirculating these stories. That's the capital we have. How long do we talk about these things until they disappear? And so you can talk about it, and like that's that's your contribution. Hey, I heard about this musical The Scottsboro Boys.
[1:23:50] Tommy: Yep.
[1:23:50] Jimi: If you've got a group of friends, club in together, do it.
[1:23:54] Tommy: You could do that, yeah.
[1:23:55] Jimi: Right? Save money, listen to it together, talk about it as a group of friends. Most learn. Most headphones are in stereo pairs.
[1:24:03] Tommy: Share them.
[1:24:04] Jimi: Yeah, get a nice set of speakers. We've all got 'em. Have a speaker.
[1:24:10] Tommy: And uh um toilet roll holder, uh toilet roll rank.
[1:24:14] Jimi: You've been watching BuzzFeed lights life hack videos.
[1:24:17] Tommy: Absolutely.
[1:24:18] Jimi: But that one works. I will give you that. And you know, the uh we're getting into weird tandem, but yes. Just get it. Listen to it. Listen to the show.
[1:24:26] Tommy: I can't imagine someone who made it an hour into this podcast and hasn't yet. But if you're that person, go listen to it.
[1:24:35] Jimi: I remember sitting on the porch here in a twilight, drifting up from the cotton leaves.
[1:24:42] Tommy: And you boys, you sing it so beautifully. Just the way I like it.
[1:24:48] Jimi: Wouldn't hurt if you smiled a bit. And in the kitchen, Mammy's bullet pork.
[1:24:56] Tommy: Cooking grits.
[1:24:58] Jimi: Scrubby. Tell the truth now. Don't you miss those honeysuckle days in hello.
[1:25:15] Tommy: How the sights and sounds come back to me.
[1:25:21] Jimi: Like my daddy hanging from a tree.
[1:25:26] Tommy: Hey, now wait a minute.
[1:25:28] Jimi: Or the fire that made those crosses work.
[1:25:32] Tommy: I don't remember that part of the song.
[1:25:34] Jimi: Don't you wish that we could just read to those like me and win me and listen and intolent Love Summer.
[1:25:58] Tommy: So Tommy, that was the Scottsboro Boys.
[1:26:01] Jimi: That was the Scottsboro Boys. I feel like we didn't talk about the world around the show.
[1:26:08] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:26:09] Jimi: Listen to it for yourself. Listen to the thing. Listen to it for yourself. It's a great show.
[1:26:13] Tommy: It's really good. You didn't need us. We hope we just we've sold you that it's worth listening to.
[1:26:19] Jimi: Yes.
[1:26:21] Tommy: And that's all well and good, but what are we doing next week?
[1:26:24] Jimi: That's a great question. Can I answer it with another question?
[1:26:28] Tommy: Please do.
[1:26:29] Jimi: Here we go.
[1:26:30] Tommy: No, please do.
[1:26:32] Jimi: The actor who auditioned for the lead role in this musical, not the actor who auditioned for the lead role in this musical knocked her audition so far out of the park that Sondheim remarked, "let's open tomorrow." What show?
[1:26:47] Tommy: I was about to say, I was about to say too if you didn't do it, it was like, no, don't we have to do it? You're so never pretty. But you just went and did it anyway.
[1:26:56] Jimi: Of course.
[1:26:57] Tommy: Well done.
[1:26:57] Jimi: Of course I did the show. What show was that?
[1:26:59] Tommy: My 100%.
[1:27:01] Jimi: Yeah. If you think you know, come and tell us. Um over on Twitter. I'm asinhendrix, and on YouTube, I am the exact same.
[1:27:08] Tommy: And I'm MusicalMash on Twitter and Musical Theatre Mash on YouTube, or our show Twitter is Jim and Tomic, or our website is Jim and Tomic.com, where there's a link to the subreddit where you can discuss our episode.
[1:27:19] Jimi: This episode.
[1:27:20] Tommy: Yep, we're still continuing with the great discussions, guys. They're ablaze. It's a great place. And come on, if you're gonna be discussing a show, come and talk about Scottsboro Boys with us. We want to hear your thoughts. Um tell your friends all about this podcast please, and we'll see you next week.
[1:27:36] Jimi: Bye-bye.
[1:27:50] Tommy: Have you seen the tickle miel mo without the fur?
[1:27:53] Jimi: Terrifying.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
