Discuss on Reddit ➤ Support the Show ➤ This week Jimi and Tommy go on a trip with Sondheim to Italy and explore the life and love of Fosca and Giorgio in his ‘Passion.’ They ponder over why the show was a critical success but not as popular with audiences, laud the importance of orchestrators on Broadway and make conjecture on Sondheim’s meta-musical... Read More
From the show: Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour
Featured Shows
About
This week Jimi and Tommy go on a trip with Sondheim to Italy and explore the life and love of Fosca and Giorgio in his ‘Passion.’ They ponder over why the show was a critical success but not as popular with audiences, laud the importance of orchestrators on Broadway and make conjecture on Sondheim’s meta-musical.
Passion (Original Broadway Cast Recording)
SHOW NOTES
Did you know Donna Murphy also had a star turn as the Witch in Into the Woods? Watch Tommy proclaim his love for her in his Miscast Witches video!
If Sondheim is God then does that mean Finishing The… and Look I Made A… are the Old and New Testaments? Either way, gettem!
If you don’t know who Maria Friedman is then the perfect place to start is this this performance of ‘How Many Tears’ from Martin Guerre from ‘Hey, Mr Producer!’
We’re extremely grateful that Sondheim is an advocate for filmed staged versions of his show. Why not treat yourself and have a listen to the creator’s commentary on ‘Passion’?
Here’s a fascinating interview with Sondheim around the time of the release of ‘Passion’ on Broadway.
If you’ve never dipped into the ‘Show People with Paul Wontorek’ Broadway.com segments, you really should! No better place to start than with Judy Kuhn getting passionate.
Hear the man himself talking about the importance of orchestrators, particularly Jonathan Tunick!
If you don’t want to take our word for it, just look at Jonathan Tunick’s repertoire. We owe him so much!
A HIGHLY ANTICIPATED QUIZ QUESTION
This show has seen substantial rewrites for it’s licensable school version including the entire re-writing of one of its songs. The creators have said they actually like the new song better than the original and may just include it in all future versions. What show?
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Jimi: We need like a clapper board or something.
[0:03] Tommy: We do.
[0:03] Jimi: I think that's what we're missing.
[0:05] Tommy: That's the thing that will make it perfect.
[0:08] Jimi: Bring us to the next level.
[0:11] Tommy: Somebody get us another drink!
[0:12] Jimi: Welcome to Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour, your weekly podcast with Carols and Carafs.
[0:19] Tommy: Carol Channing, Carol Burnett, Carol Lawrence.
[0:25] Jimi: Who's that?
[0:26] Tommy: Carol Lawrence.
[0:27] Jimi: Carol Lawrence was the original Maria in West Side Story.
[0:30] Tommy: What was she now?
[0:31] Jimi: Yeah.
[0:32] Tommy: There was someone other than the famous Natalie Wood.
[0:34] Jimi: Carol Lawrence is also of Italian descent, I believe.
[0:37] Tommy: Um, they're getting there.
[0:44] Jimi: Um hey, speaking of Italy.
[0:48] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[0:50] Jimi: What are you drinking today?
[0:53] Tommy: A nice cup of Italian coffee.
[0:56] Jimi: Oh, delicious.
[0:59] Tommy: What are you drinking?
[1:01] Jimi: I'm drinking medicine.
[1:02] Tommy: Ah, medicine.
[1:04] Jimi: I'm sick.
[1:05] Tommy: I'm sorry to hear that.
[1:07] Jimi: It's okay.
[1:08] Tommy: I've accepted it.
[1:11] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:11] Tommy: Yes.
[1:12] Jimi: Well.
[1:17] Tommy: You'd think after what, 40 episodes we'd be good at this?
[1:20] Jimi: No, not at all.
[1:21] Tommy: Absolutely not.
[1:23] Jimi: Um.
[1:24] Tommy: Why?
[1:25] Jimi: I think do you know what? Do you know what I think is funny?
[1:27] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[1:28] Jimi: Is it's because this is this opening bit has become like a skit.
[1:32] Tommy: It really has.
[1:34] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:34] Tommy: An unproped, an unscripted improv skit.
[1:38] Jimi: With like really strict parameters in its structure.
[1:42] Tommy: Exactly.
[1:43] Jimi: Um.
[1:44] Tommy: And that's what people really listen for.
[1:47] Jimi: Most people turn it off.
[1:48] Tommy: Hey, Jimmy. What's the quiz question this week, sir?
[1:54] Jimi: Our quiz question was the following. The actor who auditioned for the lead role in the musical in this musical knocked her audition so far out of the park that Sondheim remarked, "Let's open tomorrow." What show was she auditioning for?
[2:05] Tommy: Right.
[2:08] Jimi: I think it was Passion.
[2:11] Tommy: It was most people would say Passion.
[2:14] Jimi: Passion.
[2:17] Tommy: Merely from a glance in the park.
[2:21] Jimi: So much happiness.
[2:25] Tommy: So much love.
[2:28] Jimi: I thought I knew what love was.
[2:32] Tommy: I wish we might have met so much sooner.
[2:34] Jimi: I could have thought I knew what love was.
[2:39] Tommy: I thought I knew how much I could feel it.
[2:42] Jimi: I didn't know what love was now.
[2:50] Tommy: It's what I feel with you.
[2:54] Jimi: The happiness I feel with you.
[2:58] Tommy: So much happy day.
[3:01] Jimi: You are so beautiful.
[3:02] Tommy: Happening by chance in a pond.
[3:04] Jimi: Not by chance by necessity.
[3:09] Tommy: No one else has ever felt before.
[3:13] Jimi: Just another love story.
[3:16] Tommy: That's what they would claim.
[3:20] Jimi: Another simple love story.
[3:23] Tommy: All in tall of them the same.
[3:27] Jimi: No, but this is more.
[3:29] Tommy: We feel more.
[3:30] Jimi: This is so much more by Gabriel Story.
[3:42] Tommy: Some say happiness comes and goes.
[3:50] Jimi: Then this happiness is a kind of happiness.
[3:53] Tommy: No one reading of I thought I knew what love.
[4:00] Jimi: I thought it was no more than a name for yearning.
[4:04] Tommy: I thought it was with kindness became.
[4:08] Jimi: I thought where there was love, there was shame.
[4:12] Tommy: Let with you.
[4:14] Jimi: There's just happiness.
[4:18] Tommy: And less happy.
[4:20] Jimi: Yes, Miss Donna Murphy.
[4:21] Tommy: The one the wonderful Donna Murphy.
[4:24] Jimi: Yeah, man.
[4:25] Tommy: She knocks out of the park.
[4:27] Jimi: Yeah.
[4:27] Tommy: This I mean.
[4:29] Jimi: Do you think it's safe to call this one of her big breaks?
[4:33] Tommy: Uh yeah.
[4:35] Jimi: I don't know her for anything else.
[4:37] Tommy: Yeah, I wouldn't have known her for and like maybe that makes me a bad Donna Murphy fan, but I wouldn't have known her for anything as big before Passion.
[4:45] Jimi: Yeah.
[4:46] Tommy: Yeah, certainly before.
[4:47] Jimi: Ooh.
[4:48] Tommy: Yeah.
[4:48] Jimi: Because obviously.
[4:49] Tommy: Um Mother Gothel.
[4:53] Jimi: Right, of course.
[4:54] Tommy: Afterwards, Donna Murphy all over the place.
[4:56] Jimi: Um, which is the name of the city.
[4:57] Tommy: But then also all over the place, but also, is it I know, I know.
[5:02] Jimi: It's really.
[5:03] Tommy: I love Donna Murphy.
[5:05] Jimi: She Fosca is one of her most wonderful roles because all the other stuff are these kind of character parts.
[5:12] Tommy: Like comical character parts.
[5:13] Jimi: Yeah.
[5:14] Tommy: Character in the proper sense.
[5:15] Jimi: Um, which I love her in, and she does a great job with.
[5:18] Tommy: But man, her is Fosca.
[5:21] Jimi: Right.
[5:21] Tommy: And that's what that is.
[5:22] Jimi: It's like, well, here's this fantastic actress.
[5:25] Tommy: Yeah.
[5:25] Jimi: Do you know what I mean?
[5:26] Tommy: Who can act her nuts off.
[5:28] Jimi: And yet.
[5:29] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[5:30] Jimi: You know, she does I don't I feel like I've I've never seen that again.
[5:33] Tommy: Yeah.
[5:34] Jimi: Yeah.
[5:34] Tommy: And I think it's I think it's why she does, you know, Mother Gothel and uh the witch and some of those roles so well, is because they do have a big comic turn, but are the dramatic evil villain to an extent.
[5:48] Jimi: Um so there's like a connection with the character, but also an understanding of comedic timing.
[5:54] Tommy: Okay.
[5:55] Jimi: Um that makes sense.
[5:56] Tommy: I know it's no, it's no Wonderful Town, that's for sure.
[5:59] Jimi: But did you um did you feature her in your Into the Woods Witches video?
[6:08] Tommy: Uh I believe she wins.
[6:12] Jimi: Well, there's a spoiler kid.
[6:16] Tommy: Um, well, hey, if you want to find out why.
[6:20] Jimi: Watch the video.
[6:20] Tommy: And there's like nine other that come before her, so you know.
[6:23] Jimi: Exactly.
[6:24] Tommy: But hey, this isn't the Donna Murphy fan appreciation podcast, Tommy.
[6:28] Jimi: It is a little bit.
[6:29] Tommy: It is a little just a little in the smallest menu shape.
[6:32] Jimi: Um no, but we're talking about Passion today.
[6:34] Tommy: Passion.
[6:35] Jimi: Stephen Sondheim's Passion.
[6:36] Tommy: Hey, we're doing a song time again.
[6:37] Jimi: We're doing a Sondheim musical.
[6:39] Tommy: I love it every time we do a song time.
[7:33] Jimi: Do you know what? I love it every time we do a Sondheim.
[7:33] Tommy: I do too.
[7:33] Jimi: This is you know, we'll talk about it later, but this was this is my last Sondheim uh in a lot of ways.
[7:33] Tommy: You've graduated.
[7:33] Jimi: This was the one that like I hadn't done anything about or listened to that much or watched, and I did it for this podcast, and that's it.
[7:33] Tommy: I've seen it all, Jimmy.
[7:33] Jimi: You've done it.
[7:33] Tommy: Until he comes out with a new one.
[7:33] Jimi: I love the frogs.
[7:33] Tommy: I don't love the frogs.
[7:33] Jimi: I don't forget the frogs.
[7:33] Tommy: You'll never live that day.
[7:33] Jimi: I also forgot about Assassins too.
[7:33] Tommy: Which you forgot that I forgot about.
[7:33] Jimi: Um I've just forgotten you've forgotten about it because I hate you so much for forgetting.
[7:33] Tommy: Passion is music and lyrics by Stephen Sondheim and the book by James Lapine at the long end of a Lapine Sondheim kind of collaborative journey.
[7:33] Jimi: Yeah, we're kind of at the end of the Sondheim journey here.
[7:32] Tommy: Yeah.
[7:32] Jimi: Yeah.
[9:30] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?
[9:30] Jimi: We're relatively present day.
[9:30] Tommy: Yeah, say for maybe the Bounce Road show.
[9:30] Jimi: The Bouncy Road show, yeah.
[9:30] Tommy: Yeah.
[9:30] Jimi: Um and this mysterious in the works, whatever it may be.
[9:30] Tommy: Yeah.
[9:30] Jimi: Um, which I really hope we get.
[9:30] Tommy: We will.
[9:30] Jimi: I really hope we get it.
[9:30] Tommy: Caddy, you hope you we get it.
[9:30] Jimi: We hope we get it.
[9:30] Tommy: How many musicals?
[9:30] Jimi: No, it doesn't fit.
[9:30] Tommy: Um it opened on Broadway in 1994.
[9:30] Jimi: So yeah, we're really this is contemporary.
[9:30] Tommy: We're pretty contemporary.
[9:30] Jimi: And then it moved to the West End in 96.
[9:30] Tommy: Um Donna Murphy was in the 94 production, and Maria Friedman was in the 96 production.
[9:30] Jimi: So I take it you will have no idea who Maria Friedman is.
[9:30] Tommy: Never heard of her.
[9:30] Jimi: Well, let me tell you.
[9:30] Tommy: So Maria Friedman was the first person who made me uh no axel lie, one of the first people that made me think, hey, musical theatre, that's cool.
[9:30] Jimi: That's a legitimate art form, that is.
[9:30] Tommy: Really?
[9:30] Jimi: And it wasn't in The Simpsons, it was in the other thing that I got on my musical theatre kick from Hey Mr. Producer, which I talk about all the time.
[9:30] Tommy: Yeah.
[9:30] Jimi: Um so she plays a couple of roles in it.
[9:30] Tommy: Okay.
[9:30] Jimi: Um, weirdly not Passion, despite the fact it was at that time.
[9:30] Tommy: Um, but I don't think Cameron Mackintosh produced Passion.
[9:30] Jimi: I doubt he did.
[9:30] Tommy: I don't think Mackintosh has ever produced a Sondheim.
[9:30] Jimi: He has.
[9:30] Tommy: He has a Sondheim section.
[9:30] Jimi: Yeah, well, that's that's where Julian Pianos comes from.
[9:30] Tommy: Oh, you're totally right.
[9:30] Jimi: Huh.
[9:30] Tommy: Yeah.
[9:30] Jimi: Um, but anyway, Maria Friedman sang um How Many Tears from Martin Guerre.
[9:30] Tommy: Okay.
[9:30] Jimi: Uh which is is weird.
[9:30] Tommy: Martin Guerre comes up a lot in this podcast.
[9:30] Jimi: Well, it doesn't comes up twice.
[9:30] Tommy: Um, this is the first time.
[9:30] Jimi: Uh, but that song was just so breathtaking, and her acting was perfect.
[9:30] Tommy: And you'd watch like it's one of those.
[9:30] Jimi: If you watched her sing that song, you'd be like, oh, okay, so you're gonna play Fosca one day.
[9:30] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?
[9:31] Jimi: Because she's very she's not your typical like lady.
[9:39] Tommy: Okay.
[9:39] Jimi: Jimmy put his hand under his chin when he did that in a cutesy kind of way for you not watching this audio podcast.
[9:46] Tommy: She's not your kind of sexy Laura Osnes lady.
[9:52] Jimi: Um she's sexy in her own way, like Fosca.
[9:57] Tommy: Like Fosca, exactly.
[9:59] Jimi: Um, and she sings with like her acting through song was like oh gives me shivers every time I think about it.
[10:03] Tommy: So that'll be in the show notes.
[10:04] Jimi: Let's show just brought her up so I could put it in the show notes.
[10:07] Tommy: I'm excited to watch it.
[10:08] Jimi: Thank you.
[10:09] Tommy: Um the Passion won best musical book and score and best actress.
[10:14] Jimi: I do think this show holds the record as the shortest running show ever to win best musical.
[10:21] Tommy: Wow, there you go.
[10:22] Jimi: It only ran for a couple hundred performances.
[10:25] Tommy: Um, but it lost out on the Olivier.
[10:28] Jimi: It did, it did indeed.
[10:29] Tommy: Despite, I mean, again, critical success.
[10:31] Jimi: Yeah.
[10:32] Tommy: Um, but it was a big year.
[10:34] Jimi: That was a big, big year.
[10:35] Tommy: So it was 97 in the Oliviers, and we had um Martin Guerre, that's the second time.
[10:41] Jimi: Um Passion and Nine ultimately that year.
[10:46] Tommy: I don't know quite how to put it into words, but there's a there's a particular flavor to the sauce that year, don't you think?
[10:52] Jimi: Between those three.
[10:53] Tommy: Like completely like Martin Guerre, France, Passion, Italy, Nine, Italy, very romantic, very centrist, like very seeped in these like deep imagery, metaphorical, like smoky kind of and all very just like legitimate musical theater, like which is so strange for the 90s, because that was the year of those are the dark ages.
[11:17] Jimi: Yeah, exactly.
[11:18] Tommy: So very, very strange that we had this, and uh quite unfortunate, I guess, because they all could all these great shows came at the same time, right?
[11:26] Jimi: Like very specifically at exactly the same time, exactly.
[11:30] Tommy: Um, and so Passion didn't win, but that's okay because Maria Friedman won the Olivier for best actress, so it's all fine.
[11:38] Jimi: Um and you can watch the original production of Passion, it was filmed.
[11:43] Tommy: You can't, it's one of the like I feel like Sondheim is the master of doing this.
[11:46] Jimi: He loves to televise his uh his shows.
[11:50] Tommy: And if you if you've purchased the Sondheim DVD set like I have, it's been sitting in your DVD set for years and you didn't even know.
[11:57] Jimi: Um Jimmy, did you know Sondheim calls this film adaptation, the filming of the stage version of Passion, the most successful filming adaptation he's ever seen of a musical?
[12:07] Tommy: Well, there you go.
[12:08] Jimi: High person.
[12:09] Tommy: When did he say that?
[12:10] Jimi: Uh on the DVD commentary, maybe a decade later.
[12:13] Tommy: Interesting.
[12:14] Jimi: Because I know he said good things about all of his other ones.
[12:18] Tommy: Yeah.
[12:20] Jimi: I wonder how it falls in.
[12:21] Tommy: I do he did seem to be very specifically talking about the filming of the stage.
[12:27] Jimi: The stage show.
[12:28] Tommy: As opposed to something like the Johnny Depp Sweeney Todd or the Meryl Streep Into the Woods, where it's like adapted for the film.
[12:35] Jimi: Yes.
[12:35] Tommy: Okay, good.
[12:36] Jimi: And like effectively translating the stage language to the screen.
[12:41] Tommy: So um what's out of interest? What's your favorite stage to film adaptation?
[12:49] Jimi: You know, after seeing Passion, Passion does a really good job.
[12:52] Tommy: Um I do I do think favorite is a different question than accuracy.
[12:57] Jimi: Um what's the one that you just enjoy the most?
[13:00] Tommy: That's what I want to know.
[13:01] Jimi: Um it's probably Into the Woods, but you know, because of all sorts of reasons.
[13:06] Tommy: Yeah.
[13:08] Jimi: What about you?
[13:09] Tommy: Um mine would be like The Light in the Piazza.
[13:11] Jimi: Oh, okay.
[13:12] Tommy: Yeah.
[13:12] Jimi: Yeah, that's a good one.
[13:13] Tommy: I didn't think about that, but that seems very faithful too.
[13:16] Jimi: Yeah, definitely.
[13:17] Tommy: I would I would really you you know it's on a stage.
[13:19] Jimi: I feel like that's the that's the bit when I really like it.
[13:21] Tommy: Yeah.
[13:21] Jimi: Um I also really like Rent's film by Ron Broadway, the fame.
[13:25] Tommy: That's a good one.
[13:26] Jimi: I will say it, you know, this gets blurry because I also think high on the list, um, the actual film version of The Producers, the musical, right?
[13:37] Tommy: Matthew Broderick, Nathan Lane, no, no, no, the film adaptation.
[13:42] Jimi: Oh, yes, yes, yes, yes.
[13:43] Tommy: But the film adaptation might as well be the musical.
[13:47] Jimi: Yeah.
[13:47] Tommy: Um, it's all like fourth wall removed, one angle on basically the sets.
[13:52] Jimi: Um I would like if we're, you know, if I have a bazillion in filion dollars, that would be the style I want all of my musicals adapted to on screen.
[14:03] Tommy: Yeah, just a little bit more.
[14:07] Jimi: Um, and it's weird because that movie got kind of panned.
[14:10] Tommy: Um did it, but yeah, it didn't do very well.
[14:13] Jimi: Um let's talk about that later.
[14:15] Tommy: Yeah, another day.
[14:19] Jimi: It was revived on the West End and off Broadway.
[14:22] Tommy: Mm-hmm.
[14:23] Jimi: Um, Patty LuPone was in it.
[14:25] Tommy: They did a Lincoln Center concert in 2005.
[14:27] Jimi: Yeah, so Patty was pegged to be Fosca right at the start, like pre-Donna Murphy.
[14:34] Tommy: Um, I don't think it was like written for her, right?
[14:37] Jimi: But I can completely appreciate why you would have her in mind.
[14:40] Tommy: Um, because she would have obviously just come out of Evita, and she would, I think by this time as well, she'd have played Fantine.
[14:48] Jimi: So she's, you know, I mean, tragic females.
[14:51] Tommy: Yeah.
[14:52] Jimi: She's got like, she's got one in the back.
[14:54] Tommy: Definitely the pipes, you know, and by that point a name too, which is kind of useful.
[15:00] Jimi: Exactly.
[15:00] Tommy: And guess what she did instead?
[15:03] Jimi: What did she do instead?
[15:04] Tommy: Sunset.
[15:06] Jimi: Well, it was the right choice at the time.
[15:10] Tommy: I know, but I bet you she kicked her boots.
[15:13] Jimi: Yeah.
[15:13] Tommy: Do you know?
[15:14] Jimi: She did.
[15:15] Tommy: Well, I don't know.
[15:17] Jimi: But it's okay because in the 2005 they did a Lincoln Center concert.
[15:21] Tommy: She got to play it.
[15:22] Jimi: Because I think to be honest, I think that's fantastic casting.
[15:24] Tommy: Yeah, I think that's really good.
[15:26] Jimi: You know, it's the over-under of like, would we have Donna Murphy if we had Patty LuPone?
[15:30] Tommy: Very true.
[15:30] Jimi: Yeah, that's it. It's like, it's not like, uh, if only, but like interesting to contemplate the alternate universe.
[15:37] Tommy: But that's, yeah, because she wouldn't have had to have the ordeal with ALDE.
[15:41] Jimi: Yeah, who knows where we'd be now.
[15:45] Jimi: Oh, I don't want to think about that world.
[15:48] Tommy: So, what is this show that we're talking about, Tommy?
[15:50] Tommy: Passion.
[15:51] Jimi: That we've made it this deep into the podcast, not even Donovan's summary.
[15:54] Tommy: I mean, I think of, I would really say of Sondheim's shows, this one has the most straightforward story.
[16:03] Jimi: Presented linearly, like maybe three or four main characters, one or two settings.
[16:11] Tommy: Um, climactic in its entirety.
[16:15] Jimi: There's not a lot of like weirdness going on.
[16:18] Tommy: Um, Passion is the, it's a story of love.
[16:24] Jimi: Completely love and sex and all in that's in between.
[16:28] Tommy: It's a story of passion.
[16:29] Jimi: Um, so, oh God.
[16:34] Tommy: Gi Giorgio.
[16:36] Jimi: Giorgio.
[16:37] Tommy: That was cute.
[16:39] Jimi: Thanks.
[16:39] Tommy: Giorgio.
[16:41] Jimi: Um, they never say his name throughout most of the show.
[16:44] Tommy: That's not true. They say it a million times.
[16:46] Jimi: Completely a lie, but that's okay.
[16:48] Tommy: It's okay. I know how you are.
[16:49] Jimi: Um, Giorgio is a military man.
[16:52] Tommy: Um, we open the show. He and, uh, his lover, Clara, are, uh, in flagrante delicto.
[17:02] Jimi: I don't know if that's right. Did I do that?
[17:03] Tommy: You can say in flagrante delicto, but you can't say Giorgio.
[17:07] Jimi: Jeez.
[17:09] Tommy: Um, yes, they are. Shh, don't tell anyone, they're having an affair.
[17:13] Jimi: Yeah.
[17:14] Tommy: Um, very, and like very much, you know, it's about the sex and the love, I would say.
[17:19] Jimi: Um, at least at the beginning.
[17:22] Tommy: And it's like the love that they've, they've kind of made together. One of the big things that this show talks about is the many different shades and sides of love.
[17:30] Jimi: Yes, yes.
[17:31] Tommy: And so we start with one shade of love.
[17:34] Jimi: Yes.
[17:34] Tommy: Um, and Giorgio being a military man gets called away to another battalion.
[17:39] Jimi: I don't understand the terminology.
[17:41] Tommy: I think it's an outpost is the term.
[17:43] Jimi: Yeah. Like tiny little town, tiny little battalion, has to leave.
[17:47] Tommy: Yep.
[17:48] Jimi: Then what happens?
[17:50] Tommy: Yep.
[17:50] Jimi: So there he meets Fosca.
[17:55] Tommy: Who is an extremely ailing?
[17:59] Jimi: And they always use the word homely to describe her, which I find hilarious.
[18:04] Tommy: It's a, it's an easy way to say not too attractive.
[18:07] Jimi: Exactly.
[18:08] Tommy: She's very, very sick and ailing and homely.
[18:12] Jimi: Yeah.
[18:13] Tommy: And also pale and has bad hair.
[18:15] Jimi: Yeah, she's, she's sick in the same way that she's homely, that it's like she's sick, she's decrepit.
[18:22] Tommy: With what?
[18:22] Jimi: Who cares?
[18:23] Tommy: Um, exactly. Well, I think it's like, I quite like the ambiguity of the never, you never find out what's wrong with her in the closest.
[18:33] Jimi: The closest we get is the doctor, I think at one point says something like, it's as if her nerves are more exposed to the world.
[18:40] Tommy: Exactly.
[18:41] Jimi: Her nerves are on the surface while we have skin to cover them.
[18:44] Tommy: Which is really interesting and I think important as we go through the plot.
[18:48] Jimi: Yes, definitely.
[18:49] Tommy: Um, so she's very close to death, even as it's not just like, oh, I've got this ongoing cold.
[18:54] Jimi: She's, she's to what, she's at the end, basically.
[18:57] Tommy: And is prone to, uh, loud screams, outbursts.
[19:01] Jimi: These big convulsions, these nervous convulsions that she has that most of the army men at this outpost, um, including her cousin, who is the general who is the boss of Giorgio, um, kind of pass off as like, oh yep, there she goes again, crazy old Fosca.
[19:17] Tommy: Yes, they're so used to it now.
[19:18] Jimi: Yeah.
[19:19] Tommy: Um, Giorgio is like, ah, so they, they meet and they have this connection because they're kind of a bit more into, well, but it basically all starts with Giorgio giving her some books because she loves reading.
[19:32] Jimi: Um, they kind of find that connection through there, and Fosca very, very quickly falls in love with Giorgio.
[19:39] Tommy: Yeah.
[19:39] Jimi: Um, and obviously Giorgio has Clara, and obviously she is not, I don't want to say repulsive, but in many ways repulsive.
[19:51] Tommy: Um, she expresses her love, um, in uncomfortable ways.
[20:02] Jimi: Yeah, no uncertain terms.
[20:03] Tommy: She's very much no holes barred.
[20:05] Jimi: Yeah.
[20:05] Tommy: And she understands that it's not returned, right?
[20:09] Jimi: But yet she won't be polite about that and it will very much kind of force it in his face and be very explicit about it.
[20:17] Tommy: And most of the show is them grappling with that, I would say.
[20:20] Jimi: It is, it very much so, very, very much so.
[20:23] Tommy: And how that feeds into Clara and his relationship with her, um, and their dynamics, and there's the, it's, you know, we couldn't, we would spend a whole podcast kind of explaining the intricacies of how it develops.
[20:35] Jimi: Yeah.
[20:36] Tommy: Um, but it's, it's a talk about love and like how it plays into Fosca's health. Uh, and like what is appropriate love, an appropriate expression of love.
[20:47] Jimi: Yes.
[20:48] Tommy: Um, completely.
[20:51] Jimi: Um, and it's, it's just very smart.
[20:54] Tommy: Yeah.
[20:57] Jimi: It's very dramatic, I would say.
[21:00] Tommy: It is, I think it is a romantic story, but I wouldn't call it a romance.
[21:04] Jimi: No, no, definitely not as we know it.
[21:07] Tommy: Yeah.
[21:07] Jimi: If that makes sense.
[21:09] Tommy: It, it reminds, it weirdly reminds me a lot of Piazza.
[21:12] Jimi: Yeah, I would say the same thing.
[21:14] Tommy: In style, um, in, you know, they're both Italian too.
[21:20] Jimi: Yeah, exactly.
[21:21] Tommy: That's it. It's just, I just, you know, I can totally see Adam Guettel listening to this a lot whilst writing Light in the Piazza because it's a very unconventional love story set in Italy with this romantic score that's very deep and dark and sumptuous and it's, it's about the stakes of love being the highest stakes in the world.
[21:39] Jimi: Exactly.
[21:40] Tommy: Relationship is the end all.
[21:42] Jimi: Um, very much so.
[21:46] Tommy: Um, so shall we get in, get on into it?
[21:49] Jimi: Let's, let's get on with it.
[21:51] Tommy: So enjoy the novel by Rousseau.
[21:54] Jimi: Oh, it's wonderful.
[21:56] Tommy: My favorite, really.
[22:02] Jimi: You should have kept the book longer to meditate over.
[22:06] Tommy: I do not read to think.
[22:11] Jimi: I do not read to learn.
[22:15] Tommy: I do not read to search for truth.
[22:19] Jimi: I know the truth.
[22:21] Tommy: The truth is hardly what I need.
[22:26] Jimi: I read.
[22:53] Tommy: Hi, read truly to get away from love.
[23:05] Jimi: No, Captain, I have no illusions.
[23:10] Tommy: I recognize the limits of my dreams.
[23:13] Jimi: I know how painful dreams can be, unless you know them merely to reams a flow, which offers nectar at the top, delicious nectar at the top, and bitter poison underneath.
[23:35] Tommy: The butterfly that stays too long and drinks too deep is doomed to die.
[23:43] Jimi: I read to fly to skill.
[23:51] Tommy: I do not read to swim.
[23:57] Jimi: I do not dwell on dreams.
[24:01] Tommy: I know how soon a dream becomes an expectation.
[24:08] Jimi: How can I have expectations?
[24:11] Tommy: How can we know Captain Reaver can be?
[24:16] Jimi: I do not hope for what I cannot have.
[24:21] Tommy: I do not cling to things I cannot keep.
[24:25] Jimi: The more you cling to things, the more you love them.
[24:30] Tommy: So I want to speak a little bit about love.
[24:32] Jimi: This is, this is a theory I'm developing.
[24:34] Tommy: Okay.
[24:35] Jimi: I'm excited to hear it.
[24:36] Tommy: Um, and I don't know how you found it, it is. It's just a theory I'm developing, you know, as of this week, whilst I've been researching.
[24:44] Tommy: And maybe one day I'll write an essay on it.
[24:46] Jimi: Maybe it'll be published.
[24:47] Tommy: Maybe.
[24:48] Jimi: And maybe I'll become famous.
[24:51] Tommy: Dr.
[24:52] Jimi: So I, I love thinking about patterns.
[24:54] Tommy: Okay.
[24:55] Jimi: That's a human thing, right? We, as humans, we find the patterns of things.
[25:01] Tommy: Um, and I feel like Passion is the kind of last in the sequence of a part of Stephen Sondheim's life.
[25:14] Tommy: Um, no, no.
[25:16] Jimi: Retorno.
[25:16] Tommy: I agree with you.
[25:17] Jimi: I agree with you 100%.
[25:19] Tommy: I want you to explain it, and then I have something to add.
[25:21] Jimi: Excellent.
[25:22] Tommy: Okay, cool.
[25:23] Jimi: Um, if you, if you know a little bit about Sondheim, you'll know he loves to talk about love in many different ways and never the ways that you think.
[25:32] Tommy: Um, we kind of tease this in one of the other Sondheims, maybe A Little Night Music.
[25:41] Jimi: Maybe that sounds right.
[25:43] Tommy: I can't remember.
[25:44] Jimi: But we kind of talked about the fact, maybe it was Sweeney even, but we kind of talked about the fact that Sondheim's a gay man.
[25:51] Tommy: Yes.
[25:52] Jimi: And was a gay man in times when being a gay man wasn't the easiest of things.
[26:00] Tommy: Um, he's a very private man, um, and he's a very complex man.
[26:08] Jimi: He's like, he's an artist, you know what I mean?
[26:10] Tommy: Yeah.
[26:11] Jimi: Um, as an artist, what he would, in my head, in my imagination, what he would do to process these difficulties and challenges would be to write about them.
[26:24] Tommy: But he isn't the type of man to write an explicit gay love story.
[26:29] Jimi: Right.
[26:29] Tommy: He's not William Finn.
[26:31] Jimi: Exactly.
[26:32] Tommy: Very, very, very key point.
[26:34] Jimi: He really isn't.
[26:35] Tommy: Yeah.
[26:35] Jimi: And so he uses art and he uses this kind of symbol of love and translates it through different musicals.
[26:45] Tommy: So if you look at kind of the journey between the following shows.
[26:49] Jimi: So if you look at the journey between Company, um, A Little Night Music, Sweeney, where we're seeing many different shades of love already.
[27:00] Tommy: Um, Company is this man who rejects love completely and doesn't understand it.
[27:08] Jimi: And you know, originally Company was supposed to end with him being like marriage is stupid.
[27:14] Tommy: Right.
[27:15] Jimi: And then it, they were like, that doesn't work.
[27:17] Tommy: Hang on, yeah.
[27:18] Jimi: Let's change this, right?
[27:19] Tommy: Being Alive.
[27:20] Jimi: Thanks, like that.
[27:20] Tommy: But you know, but his intention was to write this thing that was like, no marriage.
[27:25] Jimi: Um, then we've got like A Little Night Music where, you know, if you look at someone, um, like, uh, Desire, um, it's this, it's like love can be heartbreaking, love's dangerous, it's all very dark-sided.
[27:25] Tommy: Sweeney, very dark-sided, very dark-sided, yeah.
[27:45] Jimi: Um, then we get into something like Sunday.
[27:48] Jimi: It feels like a bit of a breakthrough there, doesn't it?
[27:50] Tommy: Yeah.
[27:50] Tommy: Yeah, it's, uh-huh, it's a news on time, and he's really mixing the two together.
[27:55] Jimi: Sunday to me is a big commentary on love and art, yeah, and how the, there's a struggle and a power play between the two.
[28:03] Tommy: Um, and then we get to Passion, and I feel like here Sondheim's like, I've kind of got it.
[28:13] Tommy: Like to me, this is his Being Alive moment.
[28:16] Jimi: This is when he's saying, okay, I understand that you need to be honest, you need to be at this kind of brink, yeah, almost.
[28:28] Tommy: I mean, what, doesn't Giorgio say at one point, love isn't something you get, it's something you give?
[28:37] Jimi: If I'm simplifying, but like there's that discussion of that. He has a conversation with Fosca about like it's not like why can't you love me? It's like when they're on the bed. Uh no, it's earlier. It's at the oh, I think Oh, when they're out walking. When they're out walking, she's like, How dare you? Yeah, um, I think who knows. Yes, um, yes, uh-huh. And he's he's yeah, singing with Clara and talking about what he's grappling with this too, because like if love isn't something you get it, something you give. Clearly, she's giving a whole bunch, so then what is his appropriate response to that? Um exactly, and so like I'm not saying that Passion is the perfect picture of love, but what Passion is is I think it's the most honest portrayal, yeah, and it's the most human portrayal that he's ever written.
[29:19] Tommy: Yeah, um, and it's it's so what we were saying about Fosca having her nerves exposed. This is what I think he's realized is that in order to find love and to be loved, you need to expose your nerves, yeah, and you need to let yourself out there, and it's a very introverted man and as a very private man. I can imagine how difficult that must be. Um so he talks about in an article, put in the show notes, it's I think it's with the New York Times. Um, and it's just kind of an interview about his life, but it's around the time of Passion. Um, and um, he talks about whilst writing it, he had an epiphany. Uh-huh. And I don't I read into that as he met someone. Uh-huh. Um, because before it he he said that he'd never been in love. Yes. Um before. Uh, and then he goes on to say he had an epiphany. And I'm like, well, so I imagine I can understand what that means.
[30:18] Jimi: Yeah. Um and to me, and me and being an artist and being lovely and romantic, I love the idea that this show was a part of almost therapy for him to be able to come through something and kind of be able to expose himself to that world.
[30:37] Tommy: I think I like, you know, it is hard to psychoanalyze someone from far away. And right, that you've never met and you've never spoken to it. And as much as we do it, like whether Sondheim is this, you know, has puts all these words into his art or not, like art's great anyway. But I do there seems something very valid about this and very it feels right.
[30:57] Jimi: Yeah, I do. I would say you so your list goes Company, Night Music, Sweeney, Sunday, Passion. I think you need to put one more at the end there. Um, I think you need to put Bounce, Roadshow. Um very specifically, so I don't know Bounce, Roadshow very well as as far as the differences are concerned, because that's kind of hidden. Um they don't talk about the revisions that happened between them because it seems like it's been quite the difficult thing.
[31:22] Tommy: But in Sondheim on Sondheim, um he very specific like it's an interview. He talks about the song The Best Thing That Ever Has Happened, which is a love song that was originally written in Bounce for a heterosexual couple that he rewrote for Road Show to be about a homosexual couple.
[31:42] Jimi: Well, there you go. And I think if we're counting like the saga of Sondheim's love and like how he explores that in his musicals, it fits right into the narrative. If he has this epiphany and Passion about discovering how love actually works, and then his discussion of love goes from being like an implicit metaphor through characters and feelings in Company, Night Music, Sweeney, and Sunday to this kind of overt discussion in a heterosexual relationship in Passion to then the discussion of it in a homosexual relationship in Roadshow.
[32:17] Tommy: Yeah. That's I mean, that feels, you know, there is the prototypical gay man's journey that I think we see that I've have felt in my life that I think we see in a lot of fiction that comes from that world. It fits that.
[32:31] Jimi: And and yeah, in a completely generational thing, we know that me and you we've lived in it, we're the lucky ones because we went through this in a microcosm of maybe a year or two.
[32:41] Tommy: Exactly, exactly. We feel like we've seen the darkness when we really, really haven't. Whereas, you know, he was there in the 60s.
[32:49] Jimi: Yeah.
[32:50] Tommy: And one too good. Um, and you know, uh obviously being in a community where there's lots of gay men, um, and kind of seeing how I'm sure that they can't be themselves in this industry. You know what I mean?
[33:06] Jimi: Yeah.
[33:06] Tommy: The commentary that he makes and and Merrill about LA and kind of the importance of image and things in LA, um, he's very wise to this. He understands that image is a big, big thing.
[33:21] Jimi: Yeah.
[33:22] Tommy: And and certainly I don't think even Sunday, but like of all of these, he's explicitly stated these aren't autobiographical, and I don't think we're we're saying that.
[33:33] Jimi: Absolutely not, but you write what you know.
[33:35] Tommy: You write what you know, and he knows this.
[33:38] Jimi: Yeah, um yeah, your experience has to come from some you have to write from somewhere. Do you know what I mean? You can't you can't manifest a part, right?
[33:49] Tommy: You can't just create something from nothing, especially. Um and I just feel it makes me just feel really happy in a way because I just feel like it's any anyone accepting, like for example, recently with Barry Manilow, for example, is a great, great example. I am so happy that at this time in his life he's been able to accept it and be able to be so open and about it, and that you know, got so much love from the community.
[34:16] Jimi: Yeah, um, I can only imagine how pleasing that must be. And I'm not saying sometimes obviously not in the closet, right?
[34:22] Tommy: Um but he did come out in his career, like yeah, you know, there's it's I mean, not to bring up on Sondheim again, but it's the I think the easiest way to experience Sondheim's life. But it's very a very touching moment when he finally talks about being in a relationship and finding someone, and you know, it's heart, it's heartwarming.
[34:42] Jimi: It's very heartwarming, and we obviously care a lot about him because he's the king, deeply and we want this new musical to come. So please uh like take your time, you'll do it right. And if you need any if you want anyone to like read a draft, you know, Jim and Tomic at gmail.com.
[34:59] Tommy: Well, we won't tell anyone.
[35:00] Jimi: Yeah, we're very caring about you. We know stuff, so just let us. Um, but I don't I don't know. I think there's something so beautiful and artistic, and I d I trust I trust him in art a lot, yeah.
[35:11] Tommy: Um and so I feel like this weird meta journey, yeah, this meta musical that we're going through.
[35:18] Jimi: Right.
[35:18] Tommy: Um is just so beautiful and poignant.
[35:21] Jimi: And how interesting that you derive so much happiness out of what I would peg is kind of a tragedy in this story.
[35:28] Tommy: There's moments of happiness, but for the most part, this is a sad story.
[35:33] Jimi: It's full it's full of sadness, that's for sure. But I feel like because Fosca before she dies, yeah, it has the love that she's always been waiting for.
[35:43] Tommy: Yeah, it it ends on an upswing, but you know, this is not a feel good kind of show.
[35:48] Jimi: No, it's yeah, it's an upswing, but it's kind of off to the side.
[35:51] Tommy: Yeah, a little bit um and just yeah, it's it's uh this show is a beautiful commentary on love. I feel like this is the one where he's like, okay, we'll talk about it. Fine, and he creates Fosca.
[36:06] Jimi: No, obviously, this isn't an original work, it's based on based on a film.
[36:10] Tommy: Yeah, well, maybe we should do a transition because I think that has to do with our next point.
[36:20] Jimi: 40 days he got on the luck.
[36:22] Tommy: 40 days.
[36:23] Jimi: A man is sick, but 40 days.
[36:34] Tommy: That's not an easy trick with a signora.
[36:36] Jimi: Gentlemen, you know what I think.
[36:38] Tommy: We need another drink.
[36:39] Jimi: I'll say, I'll say, I'll say.
[36:47] Tommy: Um, so Passion is based on an Italian film.
[36:50] Jimi: You're ready for me to butcher this.
[36:52] Tommy: I am so ready.
[36:53] Jimi: I'm so ready. Wait, let me get it up so I can see what you're doing.
[36:56] Tommy: Yeah, go.
[36:57] Jimi: Passione d'amore.
[36:59] Tommy: Passione d'amore.
[37:01] Jimi: Passione d'amore.
[37:03] Tommy: It's pretty damn good, Tommy.
[37:03] Jimi: Alright.
[37:04] Tommy: Passion of Love.
[37:05] Jimi: Um in Italian.
[37:06] Tommy: It's a it's an 80s movie.
[37:08] Jimi: Um very so I didn't watch it, but I like skipped through it.
[37:13] Tommy: Um it's uh if you've watched Passion and you skip through the movie, you'll be like, oh, oh yeah, oh this is great.
[37:21] Jimi: Um the reason I wanted to skip through the movie, so this is this is a new musical for me.
[37:27] Tommy: Um and so I watched the film, the DVD version, um, and then was paging through it because it's one of the few one few musicals I've watched on like DVD as opposed to Netflix or you know, elsewhere.
[37:41] Jimi: Um and there's a special features button.
[37:44] Tommy: And I was like, oh, this is interesting.
[37:45] Jimi: And one of the options, it just said commentary, and I hit play because my thought was like, who on earth did they find like seven years later to sit down and watch this thing to like talk over it for an hour?
[38:00] Tommy: Um and it's Steven Sondheim, James Lapine, Donna Murphy, Marion Mazzy, um, and the guy, Giorgio.
[38:12] Jimi: Um, is Jerry something.
[38:15] Tommy: Jerry something.
[38:16] Jimi: Jerry Shane.
[38:18] Tommy: Doing the commentary on it. And let me tell you, if you've been sitting on a DVD of Passion and haven't watched this commentary, highly recommended.
[38:25] Jimi: Amazing.
[38:26] Tommy: It's really good. It's like um, do you know those videos I make where I watch a movie and talk over it?
[38:31] Jimi: Uh-huh.
[38:31] Tommy: It's exactly like that, but it's Steven Sondheim and James Lapine.
[38:35] Jimi: I was trying to think of what that would be like at all.
[38:37] Tommy: It's one of those because I've done DVD um commentary before.
[38:40] Jimi: Uh huh.
[38:41] Tommy: Like, so if I for example, the Lord of the Rings one, I've listened to all of them.
[38:44] Jimi: Uh huh.
[38:44] Tommy: Um, and it's like you can listen to the one where it's like The Hobbits.
[38:48] Jimi: Uh-huh.
[38:49] Tommy: Or you can list the one where it's like um Sean Astin and Elijah Wood.
[38:54] Jimi: Uh-huh.
[38:54] Tommy: Or you can listen to one that's like Orlando and Viggo and it's it's like all what, five of them at once.
[39:01] Jimi: All together.
[39:02] Tommy: Just talking over each other, and it's like insider production stuff and like talking about audiences, and to your point here, a lot about the staging of it.
[39:12] Jimi: So a lot of the staging in this show, um, a lot of what drew Sondheim to the show, I learned from this commentary, is some of the staging in the imagery of the original movie.
[39:24] Tommy: Um, he talks about the moment when Fosca descends the staircase, which looks a lot like it does on stage.
[39:30] Jimi: Um, except in the movie, she's behind these kind of like distorted glass windows slowly descending the staircase.
[39:39] Tommy: Okay, and like she walks up to it in silhouette and you don't see what she looks like. It's beautiful, it's wonderfully staged.
[39:46] Jimi: Um, and like they did exactly the same thing on stage.
[39:50] Tommy: Um you you walk through this movie, you know, and then they're sitting at the table and they all look exactly the same, and like Fosca's sitting next to him and the doctor's sitting over there, and like it's you know, and then they have the scene where like Fosca's sitting in the big chair, and like he's sitting in the little chair, all the same straight through interesting.
[40:06] Jimi: It is like and it's weird because we talk about adaptations all the time.
[40:11] Tommy: Uh huh.
[40:12] Jimi: This is, I think, one of the most honest adaptations I've ever seen of a movie.
[40:18] Tommy: There you go.
[40:19] Jimi: But no one what makes this one different is no one's going to see Passion because they loved the original movie.
[40:25] Tommy: Right.
[40:25] Jimi: Exactly. You know, it's kind of exists in its own.
[40:28] Tommy: Whereas like everyone who goes to see Charlie in the Chocolate Factory is going because they've seen the movie.
[40:33] Jimi: Yeah, of course.
[40:35] Tommy: Which is so fascinating.
[40:37] Jimi: But it really affected it really seemed to affect Lapine's staging.
[40:42] Tommy: Um because they wanted to be a faithful representation of the movie.
[40:47] Jimi: I love that.
[40:48] Tommy: Yeah. Well I guess that's because I know when he watched it it was like an instant yeah I need this needs to be a musical right away.
[40:56] Jimi: I don't know how it's going to work but it needs to be a musical.
[40:58] Tommy: Sondheim he says when she descended the staircase um and the way Giorgio looked at Fosca you could tell the in Sondheim's words it's something like you could tell that it wasn't that Fosca was going to fall in love with him but this was going to be a story of Giorgio falling in love with her.
[41:15] Jimi: Yeah.
[41:16] Tommy: And like he got it he picked it up right away he was right and like then it became his journey to recreate that on stage with music.
[41:24] Jimi: Amazing that's so fab.
[41:26] Tommy: Isn't that cool is it the exact same story?
[41:28] Jimi: Pretty much so this is so we talk about one of their big problems with the staging of the show and they talk about it all the time in the commentary is people would laugh.
[41:40] Tommy: Yes people would find things funny.
[41:44] Jimi: Or um Donna Murphy talks about it.
[41:46] Tommy: She's just devastated about it.
[41:48] Jimi: When they meet oh on the hill or the shore or the rocks and her hands are bloody um yes before he carries her.
[41:48] Tommy: Before he carries her.
[41:56] Jimi: So you know that moment when like she walks away and then falls down and collapses.
[42:02] Tommy: She said it was one of her worst moments on stage.
[42:05] Jimi: One night she did that, and the audience cheered, and they were so thankful that this annoying, awful character was dead.
[42:14] Tommy: Okay, we need to pause and talk.
[42:16] Jimi: Well, don't pause, keep going, but talk about that and break it apart.
[42:20] Tommy: What's going on there?
[42:21] Jimi: So audiences didn't respond like they wanted them to.
[42:26] Tommy: They would laugh at inappropriate moments.
[42:29] Jimi: They would um Murphy talks about how like ladies would find her and tell her she was one of the most hateful, atrocious people ever, um, for like playing this character on stage.
[42:38] Tommy: Something about Fosca didn't play as sympathetic, and they couldn't tease out why.
[42:46] Jimi: And I think this has this absolutely translates into its short run and its polarizing ideal.
[42:52] Jimi: Because if Fosca doesn't translate as sympathetic at all, this is an awful story about a mean lady who deceives a guy who had a fine life into this awful, awful dark corner of the world, which is not the point, but it becomes the point very quickly.
[43:09] Tommy: Um, they talked about when Fosca finds him on the train, setting up her entrance right there was monumentally difficult because you think, oh thank God he's gotten rid of her, wait, yeah.
[43:26] Jimi: And like she shows up, and you're like, ah, shit, she's back.
[43:31] Tommy: Um, but that's not the point of the scene. The point of the scene is it's Giorgio's moment to be like, no, you stop, and like to see his reaction, but it didn't play that way.
[43:42] Jimi: Um, and you know, who knows why. They were at like a really big theater, it was like a thousand seat house, which this is a more intimate show than that.
[43:49] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[43:50] Jimi: Um, you know, is it the makeup? Is it what is it? And like they fixed it, but Sondheim talks about red flagging moments when people laughed every night.
[44:00] Tommy: Um, like there's one moment where Clara sends Giorgio a lock of her hair in a letter. It's not in the final show because people laughed at it, but it was in the show because it was in the movie.
[44:12] Jimi: Um, there's like a character whose name, oh, I'm gonna get it wrong, but it's like, uh, it might as well be General Uglio or something, or like something so ridiculous, but like that's his name.
[44:27] Tommy: It's like, you know, we're very clearly in the same way that I think Clara is light and Fosca is darkness, like yeah, yeah, yeah. We're saying that with names, but that other name got a laugh, so they cut it.
[44:39] Jimi: Um, a lot of like managing and rewriting the show was like figuring out how to get people to not laugh at it.
[44:46] Tommy: I do right, so I find this really fascinating. Isn't that crazy?
[44:52] Jimi: So because I've been there before, I've been, you know, watching my show and watching the audience, and you're sitting on a knife edge because you're like A, you don't want anything to go wrong, right?
[45:02] Tommy: Um, and B, you're just, you're gazing at them to see what do you think? Are you wrapped? Are you bored?
[45:07] Jimi: Yeah, are you laughing inappropriately?
[45:11] Tommy: And it does happen a lot, yeah. Um, and it's a complete, to me, it's a complete psychological thing.
[45:18] Jimi: Because people laugh as a response to catharsis, right? Um, and it's like you reach that point where you can go two ways, yeah.
[45:29] Tommy: And you can laugh or you can cry.
[45:31] Jimi: Yep.
[45:33] Tommy: And I feel like this show is exactly that.
[45:37] Jimi: Yeah.
[45:38] Tommy: And people because it's not a simple choice.
[45:44] Jimi: Yeah.
[45:45] Tommy: Right. It's not, uh, the ridiculousness of the end of Romeo and Juliet, where oh my god, you've killed yourself, she's alive, you idiot. It's not that, it's not that, yeah, outpouring.
[46:00] Jimi: Um, it's much more subtle and it's much more complex. Do you know what I mean? Because Fosca isn't, you don't instantly sympathize with her, right?
[46:04] Tommy: Do you know what I mean? And it takes you a long, long time to come around to Fosca. And you might not, and like that's okay, exactly.
[46:17] Jimi: Exactly. You know, that's the challenge of the show, I think.
[46:21] Tommy: Very much so, because you have to understand that Fosca is a real person, right? Not in Earth, but as in, you know, the idea of who Fosca represents, yeah.
[46:35] Jimi: Yeah, is, you know, we all have that within us, yeah. Um, and I find it very, I find it really interesting because to me what that says about these audiences are that they weren't willing to let themselves cry.
[46:53] Tommy: Yeah, I mean that's definitely laugh. I do think you are very spot on with the catharsis because you, you know, it's an hour forty minute one act with no applause breaks, yeah, none of the music is written in this with a button or to end it all flows into the next thing.
[47:09] Jimi: You don't have a break to acknowledge that this is a performance, exactly, and so you are like forced to acknowledge these characters as real people the whole time.
[47:19] Tommy: Um, that's rough, this is very, it's extremely challenging as an audience member. Um, and I wonder as well, so we're the 90s here.
[47:30] Jimi: Yeah.
[47:31] Tommy: And like we said earlier, it's a different time. Now obviously the Tonys were like, hey, we're gonna throw a bone here, musical theater.
[47:38] Jimi: Right.
[47:38] Tommy: Um, here you go. Um, but it's, you know, that if you looked out onto Broadway at this time, you'd be seeing lots of different things, and you'd be allowed to laugh, and you'd be allowed to applaud, and you know, you were getting to that stage where musical theater was getting its starting to develop, right?
[47:57] Jimi: Yeah, and here you come into this expecting a musical, right? You've, you know, it's Sondheim, right?
[48:06] Tommy: And you feel, oh, he's that good guy, he did that Woods one, right? Oh, that's so fun. That is so fun. Let's go for another fun night at the theater.
[48:14] Jimi: Exactly.
[48:15] Tommy: This is not a fun night.
[48:17] Jimi: He was in Funny Thing.
[48:18] Tommy: Yeah, he's so funny. I love it. Let's go. What is this? Why has she got a mole?
[48:24] Jimi: Like, do you know what I mean?
[48:25] Tommy: And I can, I can get it, I can see why they would be like the other thing they talk about, and I think this is true too, and who knows? You know, it's straight out of the movie, so you can't, and they're trying to stick to that, so you can only do so much rewriting, but you think how this show starts, which I think is appropriate, but it's very salacious, it's nudity.
[48:43] Jimi: Um, they mention on the audio recording, other than Hair and, oh, I don't remember the other one, they, the other musical they mention, but they're pretty sure they're just the third musical to do nudity on stage.
[48:57] Tommy: Wow, um, right? 1994, who knew?
[49:00] Jimi: Um, is interesting.
[49:02] Tommy: Yeah, but then again, I'm like, yeah, I couldn't tell you off the top, but they've done it like in the original, right?
[49:09] Jimi: Um, but you start out with this like lush, very serial, romantic, salacious bedroom scene. You know, lit very like it's filled with ambers and pinks and like, you know, like, ooh, what kind of saucy tale is this gonna be?
[49:29] Tommy: It's not.
[49:30] Jimi: It's not like that's as that's as sexy as this show is going to get, probably.
[49:35] Tommy: Yeah.
[49:36] Jimi: Um, and so like that, and it, you know, it's important. You're, we're setting up our baseline here.
[49:43] Tommy: Um, but as an audience member, that's really disarming.
[49:48] Jimi: Definitely.
[49:49] Tommy: Um, especially because Mara Maisie, and you're like, that's mother.
[49:52] Jimi: Yeah, yeah. That's mother from Ragtime. I can see a move.
[49:56] Tommy: Um, they have a long conversation on the DVD commentary about where everyone's microphone is.
[50:02] Jimi: Right.
[50:03] Tommy: It's fascinating.
[50:04] Jimi: Yeah.
[50:04] Tommy: Hers is in her wig.
[50:06] Jimi: Oh, good, good. I'm glad.
[50:09] Tommy: Um, but I, yeah, I find it very interesting. So I think it's important to note that, um, critically, the critics, the people with the big scrutinous eye, yeah.
[50:21] Jimi: Loved this.
[50:22] Tommy: Yeah.
[50:22] Jimi: And were head over heels with it because it was so refreshing and so different in many ways.
[50:30] Tommy: Um, and I think, I don't know. I, I've never seen a stage production of it myself. I've only ever seen the filmed version.
[50:38] Jimi: Um, but I imagine going into it and feeling like I've just watched a play.
[50:42] Tommy: Yeah, it does feel straight play.
[50:44] Jimi: It does feel like a play with music.
[50:47] Tommy: Um, because it's not even where, you know, when we talked about Piazza, um, that's very operatic in its tones, and it's talking about love and these very grand things.
[50:58] Jimi: I feel like Passion's almost the yin to the yang, or vice versa, um, of that, where it's so much more diluted and distilled that you've got this little concentrated pellet of love that you need to try and pick apart.
[51:14] Tommy: Um, so the recent off-Broadway revival, um, with the glorious Judy Kuhn, um, kind of I think gets it better, it gets it more right because it's a bit more, it's a bit, this will sound stupid, but it's a bit more wanky in its staging.
[51:38] Jimi: Okay, right?
[51:39] Tommy: It's a bit, it treats it more like a stage play. I'm not saying stage plays are wanky, like, but as in it's more abstract and a bit more intellectual about it and, um, it, you know, isn't aiming for realism at any point here.
[51:53] Jimi: Um, it uses a lot of political theatre techniques and epic theatre techniques, um, where, uh, you know, it's, there's only some chairs that they use and they dress the set accordingly.
[52:06] Tommy: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[52:08] Jimi: So I, to me, I think that if I was going in to watch that, I would almost get it more as an audience member because I feel like I would, I would know I'm like, oh, it's one of these shows.
[52:20] Tommy: Do you know what I mean? If I was expecting a big fun Into the Woods romp, then I would be like, you know, seeing Passion the way it's done with its grand moving sets and lovely set pieces, blah blah blah blah.
[52:35] Jimi: I can imagine being tricked into that fourth wall illusion.
[52:39] Tommy: Right.
[52:39] Jimi: Whereas this, um, Judy Kuhn revival, I think it was directed by John Doyle, um, much more intimate, um, and much more focused through the eyes of Giorgio.
[52:51] Tommy: And I think that's the key too.
[52:53] Jimi: Definitely, um, because then it kind of plays with the fourth wall a little bit more, and, uh, it kind of brings you in.
[53:01] Tommy: Yeah.
[53:01] Jimi: Um, so I can't imagine you'd have an excuse to laugh.
[53:06] Tommy: Right, yeah.
[53:07] Jimi: Because you'd be too close to the audience, um, yeah, or the actors.
[53:11] Tommy: Um, I think that's definitely true. They, I'm trying, I can't pin the timeline down, but they had all in the DVD commentary come from seeing a production, they say Washington, I assume Washington DC, and not Washington State, but I don't know.
[53:26] Jimi: Um, that they talk about a lot of those same things that something about that production seemed to Lepine says it's like seeing, you know, I've, I wrote the show and it's like seeing it all new again.
[53:37] Tommy: Um, that's really interesting, and like moments I didn't remember happen.
[53:41] Jimi: Um, and something about it seemed to hit a little more specifically like what they were going for.
[53:49] Tommy: Um, and they do talk a lot about the venue and the setup of like a Broadway show and a thousand seat proscenium theater might not be where Passion belongs.
[53:57] Jimi: Yeah, exactly.
[53:58] Tommy: And I a hundred percent don't think it should, and it is an off-Broadway show. Um, obviously Sondheim's name would propel it onto a Broadway stage, exactly, and producers would be like, yes, but it's not necessarily the most appropriate thing for it.
[54:13] Jimi: I bet you, I bet you 2017 it would do just fine.
[54:18] Tommy: Do you think?
[54:20] Jimi: I really do.
[54:22] Tommy: Um, because I wonder though, because I do not feel that producers and, um, designers would feel compelled to give it its gimmick.
[54:31] Jimi: I mean, what's its gimmick?
[54:33] Tommy: The staircase.
[54:34] Jimi: Um, but this is what I mean. As in like, I feel like nowadays to get onto the Broadway stage, you've got to have that thing people talk about.
[54:45] Tommy: Oh, I think they, I think they would, but I think it would be done with care.
[54:48] Jimi: Um, I mean, we were talking about this in the pre-show, but the comparisons between Passion and Comet, I think are intrinsic.
[54:55] Tommy: Um, deep love story based on a book, but only kind of, um, like I think there's something about a contemporary Broadway audience that would latch on to this.
[55:08] Jimi: Yeah, oh no, I think they definitely enjoy it, but I don't think it's populist.
[55:08] Tommy: I don't think it's for everyone.
[55:14] Jimi: I really don't, and it's not the show that I would be like, there's a lot of shows where I'd be like, you'd love this, go listen to it.
[55:20] Tommy: Comet being one of them, actually.
[55:22] Jimi: Yeah.
[55:22] Tommy: Um, and sometimes people are like, yeah, it's fine, or like, oh, I love it. I don't think I've ever really had him where it's like, oh my god, I hate that.
[55:30] Jimi: Whereas I can imagine some people still not getting it.
[55:35] Tommy: You know, that's because it's, I, it's so, it's just so intricate.
[55:39] Jimi: Like I've, I've, what I've been watching this for a long time, and I still am feeling things apart.
[55:46] Tommy: And you know, you, you may well, I think you have convinced me there.
[55:50] Jimi: I do, I, I forgot.
[55:51] Tommy: Um, the first time I watched this, I fell asleep.
[55:54] Jimi: Um, right.
[55:55] Tommy: No, and I, I totally get that.
[55:57] Jimi: Yeah.
[55:58] Tommy: The first, because I listened to it casually in the background.
[56:01] Jimi: Yeah.
[56:01] Tommy: And I was like, and I latched onto like Soldier's Gossip.
[56:05] Jimi: Yeah, exactly.
[56:06] Tommy: Which is probably because it's the most songy song in the whole show.
[56:10] Jimi: Um, the rest of it is like, here's another ballad and another ballad.
[56:14] Tommy: And like this is, you know, I think we're really, it's interesting that Sondheim did this, you know, so late in his career because he got, he understands all the nuances of the form and like the musical machine.
[56:26] Jimi: Um, like he's not just making pieces of art that exist out in the ether, he understands that he's making pieces of art that like have producers and stages and stage managers and audiences and tickets and merchandise.
[56:38] Tommy: Um, still, um, Alfred Hitchcock said the length of a contemporary movie should be directly related to the bladder capacity of an average American, um, and shouldn't be longer.
[56:53] Jimi: And like this show, you know, apart from being affronting to the audience on an ideological kind of standpoint, is affronting to the audience on kind of a physical standpoint.
[57:02] Tommy: Um, it's the same ballad, the same ballad again, sung by a bunch of different other people, and then again and the same tempo, and we're not gonna give you a break, and we're not gonna give you a comedic number, and we're not gonna start tap dancing, and there's not gonna be an 11 o'clock number where you like you applaud, you know, before the leading lady goes into her second reprise with a kickline of chorus boys.
[57:21] Jimi: Um, you know, we're like this show does the audience no favors. Um certainly a choice, um, it's just an interesting one.
[57:32] Tommy: Like completely, and I think that's what brings it so close to being a straight play.
[57:38] Jimi: Yeah, is that in you know, if you think of something like Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf, for example, yeah, um, where you're tightening this coil and tightening it tight, and you just by the end of it, you are ready, you're ready to go as an audience member, yeah, and then you get your payoff.
[57:53] Tommy: Um, I feel the same with this.
[57:56] Jimi: Yeah. It's you aren't given that moment to breathe, and not in the sense, because there obviously there are a lot of musicals out there that don't necessarily have those moments.
[58:04] Tommy: Yeah.
[58:05] Jimi: But you do have moments to be like, I'm thinking something like Les Mis.
[58:09] Tommy: Yeah.
[58:09] Jimi: Do you know what I mean?
[58:10] Tommy: Yeah.
[58:10] Jimi: Very sung through. And then the Tenardiers will show up and you can laugh for a second.
[58:15] Tommy: And you're allowed to relax and it's all good.
[58:16] Jimi: You're not allowed to relax in the show.
[58:18] Tommy: To the point where because obviously with things like um Soldier's Gossip, um I would take it, I would take it out.
[58:27] Jimi: Do you know what I mean?
[58:28] Tommy: Yeah.
[58:28] Jimi: Like particularly the um right in the pocket one, the billiards one.
[58:33] Tommy: Yeah.
[58:34] Jimi: Um it's very funny. I think it's a great song, but I agree.
[58:37] Tommy: It's not it breaks, it's important.
[58:40] Jimi: It's really it's kind of important to give the two of them a break to be off stage for like 30 seconds.
[58:45] Tommy: Um I now skip it.
[58:48] Jimi: Yeah, yeah. It's so weird that the one that the first one I ever honed in on, yeah, I now can't be bothered with because I'm like, take me to Fosca.
[58:56] Tommy: You know I will say, I wonder if this has something to do with it too. So you're to your point of Virginia Woolf, um, and they do this in a lot of straight plays where it's like we're gonna make you feel tense and awful and tense and like winding up that coil to you get that release moment.
[59:11] Jimi: Yeah.
[59:11] Tommy: Um so the second time I watched this with the commentary on, Sondheim and Lapine point out something that I never would have noticed, and I wonder if you've noticed.
[59:22] Jimi: After the duel, Giorgio shoots the captain, yep.
[59:27] Tommy: And then falls down and screams.
[59:30] Jimi: Yes.
[59:31] Tommy: You've noticed this moment?
[59:32] Jimi: Yes.
[59:33] Tommy: Does it stick out to you as anything special?
[59:35] Jimi: So I've read um what it's supposed to represent.
[59:40] Tommy: Okay.
[59:41] Jimi: It but I don't think in that production it does.
[59:44] Tommy: It doesn't.
[59:44] Jimi: Um and they talk about how they could never get it to land.
[59:47] Tommy: But the idea is we've spent the whole show watching Fosca have these emotional outbursts whenever the world, you know, it starts with when she sees the coffin in the distance, and like the impending idea that death is a thing affects her so emotionally that she collapses to the floor with a scream.
[1:00:08] Jimi: And that is Fosca's disease, is that she feels um and it doesn't matter how.
[1:00:15] Tommy: We see the duel.
[1:00:17] Jimi: Giorgio and Fosca had, you know, been intimate previously. Do I have that timeline right?
[1:00:23] Tommy: Um but that time, yeah.
[1:00:25] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:00:26] Tommy: Giorgio has caught the disease from Fosca of feeling.
[1:00:34] Jimi: Um that's a really powerful metaphor.
[1:00:38] Tommy: Because if you're tying Fosca's physical frailty to her disease of loving too much, um, and like all of the subtlety that that entails, and Giorgio's inability to understand that um until later in the show, and then he shoots this person and feels so awful about the world in this way, and like then, you know, that's what like that plays out the rest of the show.
[1:01:03] Jimi: He's got a fever and has these nervous breakdowns.
[1:01:05] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:01:06] Jimi: Um he caught the ability to love and to feel that pain in that really specific scream moment.
[1:01:15] Tommy: But as you said, it doesn't land.
[1:01:16] Jimi: As Sondheim and Lapine say, it never landed.
[1:01:19] Tommy: They never got it to translate the way they wanted it to.
[1:01:22] Jimi: And maybe if it had, that would be the, you know, when the coil suddenly explodes.
[1:01:29] Tommy: Like, that's when you're supposed to feel it.
[1:01:31] Jimi: That's supposed to be the catharsis of the whole show, is right there.
[1:01:35] Tommy: But it doesn't work.
[1:01:38] Jimi: Something about it doesn't work.
[1:01:39] Tommy: And it's not that it can't work.
[1:01:41] Jimi: Um, I don't think, but it's like in the original production, they hadn't figured it out.
[1:01:46] Tommy: I wonder if they had figured it out if it would still be playing.
[1:01:49] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:01:51] Tommy: It's yeah, I find it really interesting.
[1:01:52] Jimi: I think that's actually one of the it comes to where one of the issues I have with the show is that is that ending in in this idea that he catches whatever it is.
[1:02:04] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:02:05] Jimi: And that's a bit odd to me from a scientific standpoint.
[1:02:10] Tommy: Right, yes.
[1:02:11] Jimi: Because I'm looking at it and I'm like, yes, but give me a diagnosis, please, doctor.
[1:02:15] Tommy: Like do you know what I mean?
[1:02:17] Jimi: And it's to me it I I think I agree.
[1:02:22] Tommy: And I think that's you know, when I go into my like script doctor mind, like that line the doctor has early on about um, you know, she doesn't have that layer of skin covering her nerves.
[1:02:34] Jimi: Like, we gotta drive that home a couple more times.
[1:02:38] Tommy: We gotta say, like, Fosca loves, Fosca loves differently than us.
[1:02:42] Jimi: Uh huh.
[1:02:42] Tommy: Fosca feels things differently than us.
[1:02:45] Jimi: And that is the root of you know her misfortune.
[1:02:47] Tommy: Like, if we're gonna put it in their own phrasing.
[1:02:50] Jimi: Um to, you know, like in big blinky lights, be like, metaphor, not a you know, the doctor needs to say something like.
[1:02:50] Tommy: Yeah, oh no, completely, completely.
[1:03:01] Jimi: But I feel it's alluded to as an actual pathological thing.
[1:03:06] Tommy: Yeah, too much almost.
[1:03:07] Jimi: Yeah, exactly.
[1:03:11] Tommy: Because I think to kind of work out and peel apart what it is, you obviously have to go back into the flashback.
[1:03:16] Jimi: Um and uh you know, look at when it all started and it started after she was um you know deceived and um kind of destroyed emotionally by um a count who was only in it to basically get her dowry, yeah.
[1:03:34] Tommy: Um and it was after he deceived her and left her with however much rent it was the funny line, right?
[1:03:40] Jimi: Um that she started to be sick and started to be ill.
[1:03:45] Tommy: Um so it comes from that moment of being you know deceived and in this kind of it does shred the skin off you in those moments.
[1:03:52] Jimi: Yeah, and so what I then get confused about is at the end where Giorgio gets this, what's the deception, what's the right, you know, it's a different thing, yeah.
[1:03:52] Tommy: It's a different thing, yeah.
[1:04:08] Jimi: Um because in many ways it's all going right for them.
[1:04:13] Tommy: Yeah, I mean it's to have loved and then lost.
[1:04:16] Jimi: Um but I agree hasn't lost yet.
[1:04:18] Tommy: That's the thing, is she and uh i i i I find this again, I find this absolutely fascinating and and kind of beautiful in a way.
[1:04:26] Jimi: Um so before um uh the end of Act One, um where they sing I Wish I Could Forget You, that when she's dictating the letter, it we have the beautiful moment in the bed.
[1:04:39] Tommy: Um and he you know he's gone to her because she's dying because he's rejected her, yeah, and it's just it's affected her.
[1:04:47] Jimi: This rejection again has affected her so much that she's going to die.
[1:04:51] Tommy: And he comes in um and tells her what she needs to hear at that moment, yeah.
[1:04:59] Jimi: And she's healed again and she's she's kind of brought back from the brink.
[1:05:03] Tommy: And what I love about that is I'm just like, how much of it is real?
[1:05:03] Jimi: How much of it is her concoction?
[1:05:08] Tommy: How much of it is just psychological.
[1:05:13] Jimi: I mean, what we what we need is like a line from Tom Aldridge early on where he says, like, uh yeah, her I may be a doctor, but it seems I can't help her.
[1:05:23] Tommy: Her disease seems to be much less of the body and much more of the mind.
[1:05:27] Jimi: And that's exactly something like that will like fix a whole bunch of things.
[1:05:32] Tommy: And I wonder if that's a product of its time, you know.
[1:05:34] Jimi: Obviously, we only really understanding mental illness as a world in the past like 10 years.
[1:05:41] Tommy: Um back in the 90s, you know, there weren't they recently thought that AIDS was a ridiculous, you know, stupid thing that only happened to certain individuals.
[1:05:53] Jimi: Um they weren't ready to kind of fix that this world of mental health.
[1:06:00] Tommy: So I feel like it's it's kind of in that it's on its way.
[1:06:03] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:06:04] Tommy: I mean, um, not but the thing is it's not an issue I have with it.
[1:06:07] Jimi: I I still feel that you can look at the art of it and look at the metaphor.
[1:06:11] Tommy: Absolutely and accept that completely.
[1:06:14] Jimi: Um but it is, I mean, the stuff they talk about in this commentary, the stuff we talk about, the stuff I see in the show, it's why I love musical theater, and it's why I forget who commented, I've been going through a bunch of old comments, but like musicals are built out of these tiny choices.
[1:06:28] Tommy: Um these like they make or break it.
[1:06:32] Jimi: And if you can wrap your mind around that, um, like they the the staircase, um, they moved, it was in a bunch of different positions every night.
[1:06:41] Tommy: It was like closer to the little entrance or further away from the little entrance, or like how many stairs and like the they can make or break your show, just these tiny moments.
[1:06:53] Jimi: I I I mean, obviously, I've only really really worked in the Amdrum sector, but and you never really get previews, right?
[1:07:01] Tommy: You know, to play around things, go just change it and then hope that on your last night you're yeah, it's good, yeah.
[1:07:06] Jimi: Exactly.
[1:07:07] Tommy: There's the show, okay.
[1:07:07] Jimi: Let's tear the tetan guys.
[1:07:09] Tommy: Um but it's it is it's so true that these little tiny choices you make of just like move in this week, cut that move, like just these tiny little things can change the dynamic of the entire show, the whole show, yeah.
[1:07:25] Jimi: You know, yep.
[1:07:26] Tommy: Um so very fascinating.
[1:07:29] Jimi: Yeah, I will say, I wonder, I don't think this is a change that should be made.
[1:07:35] Tommy: Um but I wonder if so, like picture that dueling section, yeah, do something to make Fosca's relationship with um her cousin a little more meaningful, maybe a little bit.
[1:07:47] Jimi: Um and you know, they're going out for the duel, and like maybe we're diving into too uh cliche kind of here, but I think there is some cliche in this whole show, and like Fosca runs out or whatever and accidentally gets.
[1:08:02] Tommy: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[1:08:02] Jimi: That's like so I when the first the very first time I listened to it, that's what I thought was going to happen.
[1:08:06] Tommy: I was like, oh, she's gonna get shot, isn't she?
[1:08:08] Jimi: Yeah, and she doesn't, and she doesn't.
[1:08:11] Tommy: No, she never knows that it happened, and I'm very glad about that because if it did happen, it would be like called it and it would have ruined the whole show for me.
[1:08:19] Jimi: Whereas I'm like, Oh, you beat me.
[1:08:21] Tommy: Interesting, okay, cool.
[1:08:23] Jimi: Yeah, and so I love that.
[1:08:25] Tommy: Yeah, no, it's interesting.
[1:08:28] Jimi: There's a lot of interesting choices in the show, and they all come straight from the movie too.
[1:08:31] Tommy: So you know.
[1:08:32] Jimi: Yeah, well, that's it.
[1:08:32] Tommy: So don't I?
[1:08:34] Jimi: How dare you?
[1:08:36] Tommy: I'm not talking to you, I'm talking I was looking at my microphone for just talking to the the populist.
[1:08:41] Jimi: Um our Sondheim blamers out there.
[1:08:44] Tommy: Oh they're everywhere.
[1:08:48] Jimi: You race you from my mind.
[1:08:53] Tommy: But ever since I met you, I find I cannot leave the thought of you behind.
[1:09:05] Jimi: That doesn't mean I love you.
[1:09:07] Tommy: That doesn't mean I love you.
[1:09:10] Jimi: I wish that I could love you.
[1:09:17] Tommy: I know that I've upset you.
[1:09:32] Jimi: From sight, but now I see you in a different light.
[1:09:39] Tommy: And though I cannot love you, I wish that I could love you.
[1:09:50] Jimi: Fauna I'm seeing love like none I've ever known.
[1:10:02] Tommy: As permanent as death, implacable stone.
[1:10:10] Jimi: I love it like a knife, has cut into a life.
[1:10:16] Tommy: I want it left alone.
[1:10:21] Jimi: I love I may regret one I can't forget.
[1:10:30] Tommy: Okay, Tommy, I just want to make a little brief shout out, because it's been going on a while.
[1:10:35] Jimi: Um this podcast represents passion.
[1:10:38] Tommy: There's no time to relax here, just relentless conversation.
[1:10:43] Jimi: Um but I want to give a shout out to Mr.
[1:10:46] Tommy: Jonathan Tunick.
[1:10:47] Jimi: Jonathan Tunick.
[1:10:48] Tommy: Orchestrator Extraordinaire.
[1:10:50] Jimi: Orchestrator Extraordinaire.
[1:10:53] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:10:54] Jimi: So you might, you know, you might not know who he is, and you might think, hey, that's Stephen Sondheim.
[1:11:00] Tommy: Oh my god, he's so good, he's perfect.
[1:11:03] Jimi: Um we owe him everything.
[1:11:05] Tommy: What are you doing?
[1:11:06] Jimi: You owe him about 50%.
[1:11:07] Tommy: Yep.
[1:11:08] Jimi: Maybe, you know, 33.3 repeated percent.
[1:11:13] Tommy: Because the book writer is sometimes very um.
[1:11:17] Jimi: To me, Jonathan Tunick is the genius behind the genius.
[1:11:22] Tommy: Yep.
[1:11:23] Jimi: He's God behind God.
[1:11:25] Tommy: So he has orchestrated every Sondheim show since Company.
[1:11:30] Tommy: I think so, yeah. There may have been like maybe one or two here and there, but by and large, including the movies.
[1:11:38] Jimi: Um the revivals.
[1:11:41] Tommy: Every revival. So every time you like listen to a revival and you're like, oh, that orchestration sounds entirely different.
[1:11:46] Jimi: Jonathan Tunick did both.
[1:11:48] Tommy: Exactly. Exactly. So when you're Jimmy Mitchell and you complain that the um actor musical revival of Sweeney Todd just isn't as good.
[1:11:58] Jimi: You don'd rather like to stand on Jimmy Mitchell.
[1:12:01] Tommy: Because it was the same guy. But I still do because it's not as good. But we owe him a lot. And he's also, I mean, he's also done things like Titanic, one of the best scores in existence. Phantom, not of the opera, just Phantom by Morgan Weston.
[1:12:19] Jimi: Um, which is much better and beautifully orchestrated other things as well.
[1:12:24] Tommy: The chorus line revival.
[1:12:25] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:12:26] Tommy: Oh my god. Like he's sensational, this man. Because and the reason I the reason I I think passion is a good one to talk about is instrumentally, there are so many beautiful little moments that are just so illustrative.
[1:12:47] Jimi: Now I'm not a musician, so I can't talk about this with any sort of authority or knowledge, but I can use I can put on my like standard grade music hat and analyze away. Um but like for example, just as a nice easy one, right?
[1:13:03] Tommy: Um when Fosca enters and she speaks to him for the first time and thanks him for the books, um, and she says her first thing about um how she lives in melancholy, and then you get this oboe, this descending oboe, and it goes as low as an oboe can go, yeah, right to the bottom of the scale, and you're just introduced, and you're like, you're you're just sitting in your boots here, yeah.
[1:13:28] Jimi: And you're like, God, who is this woman? And then you've been exactly you've been taken right down, and then very gently in comes the uh but you know what I'm talking about.
[1:13:42] Tommy: I don't agree to think and comes that moment, and you're set and you're hooked, and you're like, Well, who is this mysterious woman? And it's not time has done that, yeah, but it's Jonathan Tunick that has made you feel that.
[1:13:56] Jimi: Yeah. Or in many, many ways. Let's say another thing I learned from Steve's own mouth. Um, when he was composing this show, I don't know if you know this, Jimmy. He wanted the show to both begin and end with an orgasm.
[1:14:10] Tommy: Um as in literally, as in like the direct quote. I wanted the show to begin and end with an orgasm, but you know, there are some problems with that, because like uh yeah, we like would there's a whole bunch of plot needs to happen at the end after Fosca has sex, so we can't really end with an art, and like we've got complicated, but we did begin with an orgasm.
[1:14:30] Jimi: If you listen to the very first music you hear, knowing that yeah, it sounds like an orgasm.
[1:14:39] Tommy: Interesting, because it is drums, it's the drums at the start. It's it's there's drums and some other stuff going on, you just gotta listen to it.
[1:14:45] Jimi: It's okay, interesting. Like, once you know that, oh, oh yes.
[1:14:49] Tommy: Amazing, yeah, and that's that's Jonathan Tunick. There you go. And that's it, you know, it really in Sondheim talks about it as well. I put in there's a Masterworks Broadway little clip. Um, and I want to hear him speak about it more because to me it's so integral, yeah.
[1:15:04] Jimi: And this is something that I you know, we we kind of started to talk about with Dan, um, and then goes, but it's I find it really fascinating, like the role that an orchestrator plays in musical theater.
[1:15:16] Tommy: Yeah. Because to me, in some ways, they end up being more important than the composer, yeah. It's like the composer says it's it's kind of like the director-writer relationship, yeah.
[1:15:28] Jimi: I would think that's an apt comparison because the writer's words are in stone. But the director is this is the path you're gonna travel, and your director colours in that path.
[1:15:38] Tommy: Yeah. And the composer does the exact same thing. It's like this is how we're gonna tell the story.
[1:15:44] Jimi: Yeah. Um, and the orchestrator colours it in, it gives it shade. Um, and Sondheim talks about um his relationship with his orchestrators, who principally are Jonathan Tunick. Um, and he's like, What I'm really pleased that I can do to give someone like Jonathan Tunick, who has such a theatrical awareness, is give them basically the meat that they can devour and that they can really sink their teeth into.
[1:16:13] Tommy: This isn't uh this isn't an anything goes, this isn't uh make it sound fun, yeah. Do you know what I mean? He's like evoke the feeling of melancholy, right? Do you know what I mean? In this woman who's at the end of her life, but not so explicitly that like your audience gets pulled out of the moment, exactly, exactly.
[1:16:31] Jimi: Um, and it's it is completely masterful, yeah. Um so just have to you have to check them out because they're complete unsung heroes, you know.
[1:16:40] Tommy: Yeah, it's especially this man, but like you know, you look through his repertoire and you're like, Oh my god, I love that, oh my god, I love it. Like the score to Sweeney Todd is one of my favorites, and it's all in the orchestration choices, and that's why I get really offended by the the Patti LuPone one because I'm just like I've missed so much, but it's not the same show.
[1:17:01] Jimi: Um I'm in it for the violins, the same orchestrator, it is the same action, but he's doing different things with it.
[1:17:08] Tommy: That's true, he is. You you did not mention my favorite of Jonathan Tunick's work, he was serious composer on season eight and season nine of Murder She Wrote.
[1:17:18] Jimi: Well.
[1:17:20] Tommy: Well, there you so can you cast your mind? You're an expert. Cast your mind to season eight, season nine.
[1:17:25] Jimi: I mean is it different?
[1:17:28] Tommy: So, like, not that. And like, you joke, but actually, the underscoring in season eight and season nine, because Murder She Wrote has a full orchestral score. Um is wonderful.
[1:17:40] Jimi: It actually does stand out as being very, very good.
[1:17:45] Tommy: I love it.
[1:17:46] Jimi: Yeah. I absolutely love it.
[1:17:48] Tommy: There you go. Like you just like literally just hop on to like well, show note is um is rep. And you scroll down, you're like, oh, I love it. Like, oh that? Oh, that oh no way. He's done 50,000 things.
[1:18:01] Jimi: Yeah, exactly. He's always and he's still working.
[1:18:04] Tommy: Very interestingly. Did you know he's he's an EGOT winner? Jonathan Tunick is an EGOT.
[1:18:12] Jimi: There's only so many people.
[1:18:15] Tommy: Right. Sondheim's not even an EGOT.
[1:18:18] Jimi: No.
[1:18:18] Tommy: Not yet.
[1:18:19] Jimi: Not yet. That's why we need that new show. Come on, Sondheim.
[1:18:22] Tommy: Actually, not really playing at. He doesn't need to win a Tony. That's not that wouldn't actually help things.
[1:18:30] Jimi: What?
[1:18:31] Tommy: Yeah, exactly. Yeah, what could he do? Uh, what's what's he probably missing?
[1:18:37] Jimi: What is he missing?
[1:18:38] Tommy: Uh I bet you when he's a man. He's got an Academy Award. He's got a Tony Award.
[1:18:41] Jimi: Does he have I bet you he's missing?
[1:18:43] Tommy: He's got a Grammy.
[1:18:44] Jimi: Oh, he's got it. Obviously.
[1:18:45] Tommy: Yeah. So he needs an Emmy.
[1:18:47] Jimi: Yeah, television. I don't think that's gonna happen.
[1:18:50] Tommy: Well, see if um because like Evening Primrose was made for TV.
[1:18:56] Jimi: Yeah, and it didn't do very well.
[1:18:59] Tommy: No, but if that did win, would that have been eligible for an Emmy? Or because it's a made for TV movie, would that be?
[1:19:09] Jimi: If it's not on stage, I don't understand the rules.
[1:19:11] Tommy: Okay, yeah, same. Sorry. But someone will know, will they?
[1:19:15] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:19:17] Tommy: Um interesting. So how can he win an Emmy? What can we do? Um we'll stage an elaborate George Clooney inspired heist where we sneak in to the Emmy vault, um, wearing all black, of course.
[1:19:34] Jimi: I'll descend from the skylight.
[1:19:36] Tommy: Um, you'll spray the powder so I can see where the laser beams are.
[1:19:40] Jimi: Yep.
[1:19:41] Tommy: And then we steal the Emmy, and then we hide it under Steven Sondheim's pillow.
[1:19:47] Jimi: But that won't mean he will have won it.
[1:19:50] Tommy: That means he will have obtained it. This is a flawless plan.
[1:19:53] Jimi: Okay, we'll go with that. We'll start with that anyway. And then eventually he'll get there. Um so there you go. EGOT winning, Jonathan Tunick, he's the master of musical theater.
[1:20:06] Tommy: He's the reason why you love music theater.
[1:20:08] Jimi: It's true. So well done, Em. Shout out. We need to honor these unsung heroes.
[1:20:15] Tommy: Yeah, yeah, absolutely. I mean, that's you know, that's why we that's why we do this thing, Jimmy. That's why we have a musical theater podcast.
[1:20:22] Jimi: It is indeed.
[1:20:27] Tommy: I'm someone to be love.
[1:20:30] Jimi: I'm someone to be love.
[1:20:33] Tommy: And that I learned from you.
[1:20:44] Jimi: So far inside my mind. But there you are, and there you will stay up when I have you.
[1:20:59] Tommy: I see how I will. And should you die tomorrow?
[1:21:09] Jimi: Another thing I see. Your love will live in me.
[1:21:16] Tommy: Your love will live in me. Your love will live in me. Your love will live in me. Your love will live in me. Your love will live with me. Your love will live in me. Your love will live with me. Your love will live in me. Your love will live in me. Your love will live in me.
[1:21:57] Tommy: That was Passion.
[1:21:59] Jimi: That was Passion. Jimmy, if you listen to the DVD commentary for this, um someone informs Sondheim.
[1:22:08] Tommy: Wait, you're talking about how the original Broadway production is the only one to do full nudity.
[1:22:20] Jimi: Um no one else seemed to have done that. Um on the West End. I forget who uses the phrase, but they use the phrase screwing doggy style.
[1:22:29] Tommy: Um Sondheim's immediate reaction is like, oh well, we should have changed the orchestrations to be lower.
[1:22:35] Jimi: That orgasm should have been in the bases. Gives you gives you flavor of what this commentary's like.
[1:22:43] Tommy: Absolutely beautiful. So I love it when Sondheim gets sassy.
[1:22:48] Jimi: Oh, it's the best. I really hope also that it was Maria Friedman that said screwing doggy style.
[1:22:53] Tommy: Uh that's a good question. I don't know. That would make me really happy if it was, just because just the idea of her saying it.
[1:22:59] Jimi: She doesn't look like the kind of person that should we say that much.
[1:23:03] Tommy: Oh, but so Maria Friedman's um sister is Sonia Friedman, who produces all of the good theater in the West End. Just a fun fact.
[1:23:10] Jimi: Oh, there you go. There are Keenan Bolgers.
[1:23:14] Tommy: There are there are that sounds like a an avant-garde movie.
[1:23:19] Jimi: Um Bolgers.
[1:23:22] Tommy: There are Keenan Bolgers. So, Tommy, you excited for what we're gonna be doing next week.
[1:23:29] Jimi: I'm really excited, actually. Give you a clue, it's not gonna be another Sondheim.
[1:23:34] Tommy: Dang, I'm less excited. In one month, dude, you can't have too much of a good thing.
[1:23:38] Jimi: Yeah, no, how dare someone talk about Sondheim an entire month?
[1:23:42] Tommy: That would be ridiculous. That's the disgusting concept. People are weird.
[1:23:47] Jimi: Unless they did like a flawless impression of it.
[1:23:49] Tommy: Right, yes. 100 spot on, you're like, that must be Steven Sondheim.
[1:23:54] Jimi: Yeah, to the nail. Um so I've got a quiz question. You ready?
[1:23:58] Tommy: I'm excited. I'm really excited.
[1:24:00] Jimi: Excellent. This show has seen substantial rewrites for its school's version, including the entire rewriting of one of its songs. The creators have said that they actually like the new song better than the original and might just include it in all licensable future versions. What show?
[1:24:22] Tommy: What a choice.
[1:24:27] Jimi: I know idiots. If you want to get in contact with us, I'm Musical MASH on Twitter and Musical Theatre Mash on YouTube.
[1:24:35] Tommy: And I am Asin Hendrix on Twitter and YouTube. And our show Twitter is Jim and Tomic, or you can go to our website Jim and Tomic.com, which has a link to the Reddit thread. Talk with us, discuss the show. It'll be great.
[1:24:46] Jimi: Exactly. We're on fire over there, Reddit. It's just great. People are creating Reddit accounts all over the place.
[1:24:51] Tommy: We gotta stop drop and roll. We're on fire that much.
[1:24:53] Jimi: Exactly. Um let it be you. Make your Reddit account today. Um and please tell go and tell your friends all about us.
[1:25:02] Tommy: Yeah. Most of most of our listeners hear about us through friends. I'm really starting to notice that.
[1:25:08] Jimi: So, you know.
[1:25:09] Tommy: Absolutely. That's a great way to help us out. It'd be V nice. And we shall see you next week.
[1:25:15] Jimi: Tataloo.
[1:25:16] Tommy: Toddaloo.
[1:25:18] Jimi: Tudaly.
[1:25:33] Tommy: You're a Marvel.
[1:25:34] Jimi: Oh god.
[1:25:35] Tommy: Um toddl.
[1:25:37] Jimi: Maybe that's the origin of Tiddaloo.
[1:25:39] Tommy: Uh probably.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
