Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Happy Hour #51: 48kHz: A Musical Podcast - ‘35mm: A Musical Exhibition’

Discuss on Reddit ➤ Support the Show ➤ Hold still, and focus as we’re talking all about Ryan Scott Oliver and Matthew Murphy’s beautiful “35mm: A Musical Exhibition.” As this is a fusion of photography and music the boys get arty this week... Read More

From the show: Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour

2 h 5 mins
9/17/17

About

Discuss on Reddit ➤

Support the Show ➤

Hold still, and focus as we’re talking all about Ryan Scott Oliver and Matthew Murphy’s beautiful “35mm: A Musical Exhibition.” As this is a fusion of photography and music the boys get arty this week. They talk about what makes a musical ‘exhibition,’ ponder over the terrifying potential of Twilight the Musical and muse over how artists really want their work to be viewed and appreciated.

35MM: A Musical Exhibition (Original Cast Recording)

Amazon / iTunes / Spotify

SHOW NOTES

If you’re intrigued as to what the hell we were talking about with that quiz question, check out some of Matthew Murphy’s beautiful work!

In London from 09/18 to 09/30? Then go on a fact finding mission for Jimi and Tommy and go see ‘35mm’ at The Other Palace and let us know all about it!

To find out more about Ryan Scott Oliver and Lindsay Mendez’s Actor Therapy Group then have a look at their website here.

Have a look at Katie Thompson singing ‘Leave, Luanne’ - what do you think about a female singing it? Do you think it changes the message?

If you’re at all interested in the sculptor that moved Jimi so GD much then you can watch this great documentary on him here.

A CLASSICAL QUIZ QUESTION

Some people argue that this next musical features the music of Felix Mendelssohn and his Violin Concerto in E Minor? Mendelssohn remains uncredited to this day. What show?

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Jimi: I want you to tell the people what you were doing when I called you.

[0:03] Tommy: When you called me. Um doing what I normally do at 11:30 p.m. on the nights that we record and I set up my mic.

[0:11] Jimi: Right.

[0:15] Tommy: Um, I was uh singing along. Uh or should I say duetting with a random—

[0:18] Jimi: No, you should say singing along.

[0:24] Tommy: I usually sing along. Uh no, I'm gonna say duetting, Thomas. Uh with a random person who had, you know, sung one half of the karaoke part to "17" from Heathers, and I was singing JD.

[0:40] Jimi: So there.

[0:42] Tommy: So I see no, I see nothing wrong with that.

[0:44] Jimi: Tweet @asinhendrix your half of a duet videos, and maybe he'll sing along with you.

[0:51] Tommy: No do that. That'd be well fun.

[0:53] Jimi: I loved it, guys. Do you ever did you never do that? Just record like one half of the song and then you sing the other harmony part?

[1:04] Jimi: Well, you have no fun.

[1:05] Tommy: Most of like I literally have folders of me just singing like it's like uh Les Mis finale Fantine. And then I'll just let that and then I'll just like sing the Epiphany part over the top.

[1:17] Jimi: Do you have like bookmarks in the top of your web browser for different duets that you like click on for the other thing?

[1:23] Tommy: Well, I mean I do make some myself, um, and just like duet with myself. @asinhendrix2 on YouTube.

[1:30] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:31] Tommy: Yeah, maybe that's the thing that I could start. Sing with me, sing with Jim.

[1:36] Jimi: Do it.

[1:37] Tommy: Do it. Somebody get us another drink!

[1:41] Jimi: Welcome to Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour, your weekly podcast with Mojitos and mixtapes.

[1:47] Tommy: I see you've typed here mixed tapes.

[1:50] Jimi: Was that intentional or is that a Scottish thing?

[1:53] Tommy: Because it's a mixed tape.

[1:55] Jimi: Ah, this might be a Scottish thing. In America, we would call that a mix tape.

[1:58] Tommy: A mixed tape.

[1:59] Jimi: Maybe I've just got that wrong.

[2:01] Tommy: But I wondered if you were going for kind of some kind of cocktail illusion there, because it's a mixed tape.

[2:08] Jimi: It'd be good if you had like a 90s bar.

[2:11] Tommy: That's exactly what I meant.

[2:12] Jimi: Let's pretend that that's what I meant.

[2:13] Tommy: No, I think I just got it wrong.

[2:15] Jimi: I think I just got it wrong.

[2:17] Tommy: Guys, Jimmy did something wrong.

[2:19] Jimi: Uh-oh.

[2:20] Tommy: A mixed tape.

[2:23] Jimi: He made a mixed tape.

[2:27] Tommy: That works then. Speaking of mixed tapes, what are you drinking today?

[2:32] Jimi: You caught me just taking a mouthful. Um, well, oh, thank you. Thank you. Uh a waiter there just handed me a free glass of uh I think this is oh what? I think it's just sparkling wine.

[2:43] Tommy: That's fine. It's what you get at an exhibition like this.

[2:47] Jimi: Look, look, look, look, look. I didn't know we were bringing the improvisational moments into this part of the podcast.

[2:53] Tommy: We are.

[2:53] Jimi: We absolutely everywhere.

[2:56] Tommy: We're just gonna start creating our own shows, just making them up straight away.

[3:00] Jimi: Yep.

[3:01] Tommy: That's well, you know, that's much better than what I've got.

[3:04] Jimi: What have you got?

[3:06] Tommy: I've just got uh a coffee cup full of d uh photographic development fluid. Um that was another option that I thought of.

[3:13] Jimi: Yeah.

[3:14] Tommy: But and I was gonna do act out again and like do me like dying because I'd just drink in like lots of chemicals.

[3:21] Jimi: That might have been more confusing than uh your initially already confusing improv moment.

[3:27] Tommy: Potentially. But if you saw if you saw the physical actions that's the same thing.

[3:30] Jimi: That's true. Snapped on and everything.

[3:32] Tommy: I see. I do think you should incorporate more physical actions into silent physical actions into our audio only format show.

[3:41] Jimi: I think that'll be right now. Right now, Jimmy is doing so many things. Anyway, what were you talking about today? What are we getting on about?

[3:50] Tommy: I don't think anyone got this, but that's fair because I mean difficult.

[3:54] Jimi: Yeah. One of the co-collaborators of this musical, don't know what I'm talking about, has worked with a laundry list of famous musical theater names. Lynn Manuel Miranda, do you know him?

[4:06] Tommy: Who's I mmm rings a bell? He's alright.

[4:09] Jimi: Um Jeremy Jordan, Ramin Karimloo, Betsy Wolfe, Annaleigh Ashford, and Miss Sierra Boggess.

[4:19] Tommy: Ariel herself.

[4:21] Jimi: Um, but not in the way that you would think. What show, Thomas? What show could it possibly be?

[5:38] Tommy: We're talking about "35mm: A Musical Exhibition."

[5:38] Jimi: Stop time. Captured lights, gathered imaging on photoside. A sensor. Small magatus. Records and stages, pixel pages of truth. Oh a life. Stopped in post in a world that never goes.

[5:38] Tommy: No one apparently.

[5:36] Jimi: That's fair. So what we were meaning by that, not in the way you think, um, is because uh "35mm: A Musical Exhibition," uh-huh um is actually based on uh a series of photographs or inspired by a series of photographs uh by Mr. Matthew Murphy, who is a big New York photographer who's taken many headshots, many very famous headshots of all these famous people he's worked with, but exactly trick trick question. We haven't had quite a trick question in a while.

[6:14] Tommy: Exactly. And I'm sure if you googled all those names together, you would maybe just get Broadway.com being like, these people have won awards. Um anyways, uh so yeah, this is a musical, uh kind of well, a musical exhibition. I'm gonna say a song cycle, but we'll talk about that later.

[6:30] Jimi: We'll talk about that for sure. But a musical exhibition uh by Mr. Ryan Scott Oliver.

[6:39] Tommy: Yeah, what else has he done?

[6:41] Jimi: He has done um, well, probably his other biggest thing um would be "Jasper in Deadland," which is pretty big. The gorgeous and hunky hunky hunky Matt Doyle. Um other than that, he's got not done vast amounts. Um he's got a couple of things in development that working. He's working on like a dark Peter Pan adaptation kind of thing. And he's done a couple smaller things that I've not heard of. Mr. Sharp, Darling, um, "We Foxes," but these are not things that have "35mm," I think is certainly one of his more well-known works.

[7:20] Tommy: Well, it was it was fully produced. Though the other ones I think were done either regionally or you know, in development, like rehearsed readings, whereas um "35mm" actually got put on in um an art space uh off Broadway.

[7:39] Jimi: Yeah. So there you go. Uh it played off Broadway in 2012 and then had uh an off West End production in 2013. Um and it's gonna be revived again this year on the West End.

[7:49] Tommy: Yeah, in like a matter of minutes.

[7:51] Jimi: Yeah. Uh so that's quite cool. Um and uh literally this will sound this will isn't I gonna get spelled with like oh yeah, they don't dare. I had no idea when we because we decide what we're gonna be doing like weeks and weeks and weeks in advance. And no idea that this was gonna go inside with this, but hey, it has so what do you know?

[8:11] Tommy: It was in it was in the air, it was in the zeitgeist.

[8:13] Jimi: It was indeed. Um so it's I mean it's difficult to say what this is about because it's not really about anything.

[8:22] Tommy: Yeah. I think I think the place to start is this is a song cycle. At its most base level, this is a song cycle. It's a series of songs loosely related to each other, where we're trying to say something by putting them all together.

[8:37] Jimi: Um but I want to almost challenge that again.

[8:40] Tommy: Not right now. We're gonna challenge that at the end. That's gonna be a concluding thing.

[8:45] Jimi: Um but I'm doing it up to be really big.

[8:48] Tommy: Oh, it's gonna be huge.

[8:49] Jimi: Um but no, I do want to challenge that because you know obviously we've done a song cycle before we did when we did "Songs for a New World." Um, and that is definitely a song cycle. Um but I feel like this is something kinda different, similar in many ways, but something kinda different.

[9:09] Tommy: Um maybe these apart why I think that.

[9:14] Jimi: Yeah, on its most base level, each song in this show is inspired by one or a couple photos, and the photos are featured heavily in that song. You can see them, and there's you know, they never explicitly say why, and then maybe there's a question why even, but it's a big there photos are important. "35mm: A Musical Exhibition." It's in there too.

[9:39] Tommy: Also, it's a I mean, would you say there's a double entendre going on here in the title? A musical exhibition.

[9:45] Jimi: What do you mean?

[9:49] Tommy: Well a musical exhibition, as in we are at a photo showing an art gallery where you're getting your glass of wine, but a musical exhibition where we are exhibiting ourselves, where there is kind of this exposure of something.

[10:07] Jimi: I well, I just think it's it that and this is what what I'm talking about with a song cycle. I think it is more of an exhibition as opposed to a song cycle, um, in its in its most literal sense.

[10:19] Tommy: Interesting.

[10:20] Jimi: And I'm leaning the other way, but who knows?

[10:23] Tommy: Strong opinions loosely held.

[10:25] Jimi: Yeah.

[10:26] Tommy: Um, so what how we're gonna work this, um, we're gonna treat it like we're I've still got my sparkling mm-hmm, sparkling wine in a hand, glug glug glug. Uh, and Tommy and I are gonna walk around the each of these photos as we look at them.

[10:42] Tommy: Yes.

[10:51] Jimi: It's an anthemster.

[11:02] Tommy: I am running middle road as I'm chasing with tell side.

[11:12] Jimi: Okay, so I I guess it's important to say as well, and the framing of the if you've never listened to this before, um the framing of this show uh is it's got a kind of um all-encompassing beginning and end.

[11:26] Tommy: Yes.

[11:26] Jimi: Uh and interspersed or these um and I read as well that um Ryan Scott Oliver, he said that those transitions are really just a time for the audience to just kind of like chill out.

[11:41] Tommy: They don't really mean take a breath.

[11:43] Jimi: Yeah, uh-huh.

[11:44] Tommy: That's just like have a relax.

[11:47] Jimi: Yeah. You know, the the kind of like comedy moments in the Shakespeare plays. It's it's that kind of thing.

[11:54] Tommy: Yeah.

[11:54] Jimi: Um and they're all they're very much themed around the concept of photography. The first one is called "Stop Time." Um and there's there's something there about F-stops in there, like we're we're playing with photographic imagery, not in the photo kind of way, but in the metaphor kind of way.

[12:11] Tommy: Yeah.

[12:12] Jimi: Um, and it's all about, you know, you freeze a moment, but what happens after this moment? What happens around this moment? Is this moment bigger than this one particular snapshot you've taken?

[12:24] Tommy: Exactly.

[12:25] Jimi: Exactly. And it is, it's it's thinking about how much does the bit before matter, how much does the bit after matter? Is it all just about what you've managed to capture in that little square?

[12:37] Tommy: This is uh this is a high level conceptual kind of show.

[12:42] Jimi: Well, we're an art gallery, Tommy.

[12:44] Tommy: So art gall uh I have so many opinions about art galleries. Maybe they'll come up. But we should move on to the first song, "Crazy Town."

[12:52] Jimi: Yeah.

[12:53] Tommy: So I want to talk about why it opens with this.

[12:59] Jimi: What's a good idea?

[13:01] Tommy: Uh uh I don't know. The same reason most shows open with a song like this. I mean, "Crazy Town" without the explicit exposition that happens in a normal piece of musical theater, feels like an intro song.

[13:19] Tommy: It's upbeat, all the characters are in it. Um it also, I mean, between "Stop Time," the transitionary kind of prelude song, and "Crazy Town," we're setting up our audience for what kind of musical this is gonna be.

[13:34] Jimi: Oh, we should help help remind me. "Stop Time," the exposure that goes with it is a beautiful picture of two hands kind of looking through a lens detached from a camera.

[13:45] Tommy: And then in "Crazy Town," it's a whole bunch of different exposures that are kind of different body parts. Um close ups. They one looks like one looks like it's from a migraine commercial.

[13:58] Jimi: Um but they're you know, there's a lot of gesture to them, and they're all set against uh primary or primary ish colored backgrounds. Um, usually two photographs. There's like there must be 40 of them. Um and they kind of go throughout. So I don't know. I don't know if I have a good reason for why we open with Crazy Town. What do what do you think? Do you have any solutions?

[14:20] Tommy: Um I think I think it does a couple of things. I think it it sets you up for Ryan Scott Oliver's style of music because one thing I would definitely say is that he has a really interesting and uh distinctive sound.

[14:37] Jimi: Yeah.

[14:37] Tommy: Um that isn't really anything you've heard much before. Um it's and uh again, sorry to always say this, but we'll talk about the end, because I do have a lot of thoughts on him. Um I think it sets you up for that 'cause it's a bit wacky. It starts with a sort of a fugue of noises.

[14:54] Jimi: Yeah.

[14:57] Tommy: Um then it it it I don't know, it's uh it's I think it's because it it feels like it's at the start of a journey or it's talking about the start of a journey.

[15:10] Jimi: Yeah, I think I I think there's commentary about that in the song. The part that reads to me the most is this ain't no never land, this ain't no wonderland, this ain't no Narnia, this ain't no Oz, this isn't your magical land far away. This is Crazy Town, which is you know, a contemporary way of talking about Wonderland.

[15:30] Tommy: Um I don't know. To me, I think the whole song is kind of just about uh like that moment in your life where you kind of just have to get on the get on the horse.

[15:44] Jimi: Yeah do you know I mean it's that like really difficult period of like where you have to uh you know, kind of your pup your pubescent days have gone and you're now okay uh just a a full-on person um and you have to face up to all of those different things and there's a couple of bits that that make me think that okay like what uh just so he talks about um I can't remember which world he's in uh but uh when he finds the money and it's that idea of um you know it's your first kind of interaction with money um and there's lots of it and you don't really know what to do with it um then you've got the idea of obviously the sex part of it yeah um which is very very blatant um and then this kind of idea of like there's a the again the kind of fugue part of um where he's talking about his eight inch copper key which I have a feeling is very phallic um and it might just be solely phallic but you can't and I can't find the door that it goes to and it's bothering me.

[15:44] Tommy: Yeah yeah exactly and it is just that idea of there yeah and then just when he says like it's a Christ like allegory yeah um like you know it's that idea of it's the responsibility Christ at the end of his life and the passion um was very much facing you know the the re the reality of of things um and yeah it's I think it's that's where that's where he's at so to me it's kind of like because all of the songs in this I would say are aimed at adults.

[17:32] Jimi: Yes.

[17:32] Tommy: There's not really any like oh, you know, when you're a kid, it's like this you know I mean, there's there's nothing like that. They're all songs for adults, and I feel like this is the one that's kind of like the earliest, if you know, I mean if you're chronological life.

[17:47] Jimi: It is, I mean, and this was my follow-up question was do you see Crazy Town? Because a lot of these songs are I don't know, for later, but leaning on the standalone song cycle-ish like I exist as a story unto myself. Um my follow-up question was going to be do you see Crazy Town as standalone I exist or expositionally motivated towards the rest of the evening.

[18:16] Tommy: Um I just see it as standalone I exist.

[18:20] Jimi: Really, I see it as kind of a like not exposition in its purest sense, but we're here for Crazy Town and Crazy Town, like all these stories happen in Crazy Town, not explicitly, not like, oh, these are characters that live in this mythical town that we call Crazy Town. But we're we're getting used to the language and the brain and the type of story we're about to experience. Abstract, metaphorical, filled with imagery, not gonna make a lot of sense sometimes, but still intentionally put together in the same bucket, so you view it as one.

[18:56] Tommy: And don't confuse this with your childhood concepts of Wonderland Narnia, Oz or Neverland. This is you know, New York, and not New York in Wonderland Alice's New Adventure kind of way, but like in new contemporary adult quarter life crisis kind of way.

[19:17] Jimi: Um, but through a deeply artistic lens.

[19:22] Tommy: Yeah, definitely. No, I would I completely I completely agree with that. Um, but I don't think it's it's tied in to any of the uh you know I mean I don't think it's like you don't ever oh I hark back to crazy time when I think of that.

[19:35] Jimi: Yeah, like you say, it sets you it sets you up completely, and it it you know it does the classic musical theater trope of welcome to the world, right?

[19:44] Tommy: Exactly, you know, and that's why I say expositional in the same way that like you know no other song in the music man goes like aha yes, thank you for reminding me of Iowa Stubborn from the beginning of this show.

[19:56] Jimi: Exactly like we don't actually bring that back, but it tells you what town we're in. This time we're not in River City, we're in Crazy Town.

[20:03] Tommy: Yeah, but I I just feel like because Crazy Town to me is adulthood.

[20:09] Jimi: Yeah, then it's like obviously.

[20:12] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?

[20:13] Jimi: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

[20:14] Tommy: No, absolutely. Like it's it's yes.

[20:17] Jimi: I don't know, it's hard, man.

[20:19] Tommy: It's hard to talk about art.

[20:21] Jimi: Yeah, exactly. I know.

[20:22] Tommy: But it it is a it's a welcome. This is the song the white rabbit would sing if we were entering Wonderland.

[20:28] Jimi: I know, but this isn't Wonderland, you know.

[20:31] Tommy: How much does Frank Wildhorn wish that he wrote this?

[20:33] Jimi: Yeah, this would have been a much better intro to it. When call me Frank Wildhorn, we'll we'll we'll figure it out.

[20:39] Tommy: Um yeah.

[20:41] Jimi: I'm I know we're still waiting on that call.

[20:43] Tommy: That's I've time the time is ticking.

[20:46] Jimi: No, it's not well that that I mean that's its own Alpha Wonderland allegory right there.

[20:52] Tommy: It absolutely is good for us, good for us, even let me kiss you, and let me kiss you and let me kiss you.

[21:02] Jimi: And that is why kind of guy.

[21:07] Tommy: Thank you're gonna be able to do that.

[21:08] Jimi: You want to talk about the next one?

[21:09] Tommy: Let's talk about the next one.

[21:11] Jimi: So we we have another transition, but that's fine. Um then we have On Monday, which uh it's exposure.

[21:20] Tommy: Um it's photograph is uh a lady's hand uh reaching for a gent's hand, which is pocketed. Um that I mean I feel like that's very clear as to what the song itself is about, um, where it's about uh a girl is basically singing um to her lover, uh or and is basically trying to come to terms with the fact that they're on completely different pages as to how they view love and how they uh approach it.

[21:57] Jimi: Um so she is very much of the ilk of let's seize the moment, let's do things now, moves very quickly through things, whereas he is much more about taking things slow and you know letting things build and letting things develop.

[22:16] Tommy: Um I think that is quite cool because both both are are equally viable.

[22:24] Jimi: Yeah.

[22:24] Tommy: Do you know I mean, and both I think people can relate to one or the other.

[22:28] Jimi: Jimmy, I don't like this song.

[22:30] Tommy: Do you not?

[22:31] Jimi: No.

[22:32] Tommy: Um, can I tell you a secret that you're not allowed to tell any high schooler ever?

[22:40] Jimi: Right, okay.

[22:41] Tommy: So no high schoolers listening to this bit.

[22:44] Jimi: Ever.

[22:44] Tommy: Jimmy, have you ever gone to see I guess I don't know if this is uh an American thing or not, but like a talent show. Like an amateur talent show.

[22:51] Jimi: One that's been pre-rehearsed and arranged.

[22:53] Tommy: Not one where like not like an open mic night, but like we're gonna showcase everyone's talents today, and they all auditioned with them. Or a variety show, or you know, we're all gonna do different acts.

[23:07] Jimi: Mm-hmm.

[23:07] Tommy: Yeah.

[23:08] Jimi: I've been in many.

[23:09] Tommy: There you go. Have you ever been the second act?

[23:13] Jimi: The ver not like act two, but the second thing to happen in a show.

[23:17] Tommy: I I can't remember, but probably not, no.

[23:20] Jimi: The second thing to happen in a show like this, in a variety show, in a student vocal concert, in things that are arranged from different people, the second act is always the worst.

[23:30] Tommy: Um intentionally so.

[23:33] Jimi: You want to open on something strong.

[23:36] Tommy: You put your strongest number there.

[23:38] Jimi: Then you figure contextually you want something pretty good to start the second half after the interval.

[23:38] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[23:38] Jimi: You want something pretty good to end it.

[23:45] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[23:48] Jimi: After you've figured those things out, you put your worst thing right after the very first number of the show.

[23:56] Tommy: Because then you've gotten it out of the way.

[23:58] Jimi: Uh-huh.

[23:59] Tommy: It can't be the first thing of the show, because then people will leave.

[24:03] Jimi: Yeah, I understand.

[24:04] Tommy: But if it's the second thing of the show, they're not like following up on something that was better than them or more exciting than them, or seems more interesting than them.

[24:13] Jimi: Yeah, I understand.

[24:15] Tommy: This happens all the time. On Monday is this second act.

[24:19] Jimi: Because Stop Time and Crazy Town are prologue and exposition, and then we're getting into the meat of it, and on Monday's a second one.

[24:26] Tommy: On Monday is not bizarre, is not strange, is not terribly the photograph is not terribly interesting.

[24:33] Jimi: Um, it's a good photograph, but there's nothing, you know, I can tell what it all is.

[24:39] Tommy: I don't think the song is terribly inspired by the photograph.

[24:43] Jimi: It this feels like soap opera standard, this feels like sitcom standard.

[24:47] Tommy: This could be the plot of another musical.

[24:49] Jimi: I don't want it in this show.

[24:51] Tommy: Interesting.

[24:52] Jimi: Very interesting.

[24:53] Tommy: It's the only song in this show I have that reaction to.

[24:56] Jimi: Yeah, I know.

[24:56] Tommy: I mean, I know I'd say it's out of all of them, it's the most generic and it's the most kind of ordinary days, no offense, uh style.

[25:06] Jimi: Yeah um Do you know I mean of here's a situation and we're talking through it.

[25:12] Tommy: But I don't know. I I I don't think that would be a universal reaction.

[25:17] Jimi: Um because I think there are people who would relate to it.

[25:23] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?

[25:25] Jimi: Um I think they need more interesting lives.

[25:28] Tommy: Well, why?

[25:29] Jimi: Why'd you say that?

[25:30] Tommy: It's I on Tuesday I called you, you ignored me, straight voicemail, blah blah blah blah blah.

[25:36] Jimi: Oh your problems.

[25:38] Tommy: Um maybe I sound I don't know.

[25:40] Jimi: I've now that I say that.

[25:41] Tommy: I wonder if it sounds interesting.

[25:42] Jimi: I wonder if you're the guy.

[25:44] Tommy: Do you know I mean I wonder if you're the guy.

[25:45] Jimi: I wonder if you're the guy.

[25:47] Tommy: I maybe I'm I'm sick of like uninteresting, non-nuanced love stories.

[25:54] Jimi: Um you know, please don't show me Snow White again.

[25:58] Tommy: Um not that this not that this is Snow White, but this just feels so like out of contextly pedestrian and bare when compared to the rest of this show.

[26:14] Jimi: Yeah, I don't I mean Yeah, I'm no I would agree with you.

[26:18] Tommy: It's it's not it's not my favorite, and I didn't expect to speak about it for more than five minutes.

[26:22] Jimi: But I do find it I do find it really interesting uh the the reasons why you don't like it.

[26:30] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?

[26:31] Jimi: Uh because I I think it's totally if you you know if you really go into the meat of what what the song's talking about, yeah.

[26:37] Tommy: Um this idea that oh just because you want love to happen quickly, it means it means you're young, means you're juvenile, means you don't really understand life.

[26:45] Jimi: Yeah.

[26:46] Tommy: Um that's not necessarily true.

[26:49] Jimi: I I think I think it's a m it's a more specific thing that I'm reacting negatively to.

[26:53] Tommy: Um you can entirely unpack this song.

[26:57] Jimi: You can pull it all out of the box and look at every side of it and look at the picture and be like, yep, that's a song about this picture.

[27:04] Tommy: Yeah.

[27:04] Jimi: And I understand the whole thing.

[27:06] Jimi: And every other song in this show is not like that.

[27:09] Tommy: Yeah.

[27:10] Jimi: There are parts that are mysterious, there are parts that are open to interpretation, there are parts that are surprising, there are parts that like contrast the photo or something.

[27:18] Tommy: Yeah.

[27:19] Jimi: And this song doesn't do that.

[27:21] Tommy: I don't know. I think you I think you could get a discussion out of it because you could you know, I mean, you can argue both parts.

[27:27] Jimi: Yeah.

[27:27] Tommy: Maybe.

[27:28] Jimi: Maybe I just find that discussion uninteresting because I'm a cynical hag.

[27:32] Tommy: And you're also deeply in love.

[27:35] Jimi: Yes.

[27:36] Tommy: With musical theater.

[27:38] Jimi: Exactly.

[27:38] Tommy: Is that his name?

[27:39] Jimi: Yes.

[27:40] Tommy: It's a weird name.

[27:40] Jimi: Musical theater.

[27:41] Tommy: Yeah.

[27:42] Jimi: Well, you know, I try to keep my interests narrow.

[27:45] Tommy: That's gonna be awkward.

[27:46] Jimi: Then he will literally become musical theatre mash.

[27:49] Tommy: Yes, absolutely.

[27:50] Jimi: In the wedding.

[27:51] Tommy: Well, that's good.

[27:51] Jimi: You plan that way.

[27:52] Tommy: I'm all about the future planning.

[27:55] Jimi: Absolutely.

[27:59] Tommy: Make small cuts.

[28:01] Jimi: Now you don't try to take them.

[28:03] Tommy: Try to borrow or break them.

[28:05] Jimi: And Carol Lee.

[28:07] Tommy: God damn it.

[28:08] Jimi: Stabs you nuts.

[28:09] Tommy: Oh, gently.

[28:11] Jimi: But repeatedly.

[28:13] Tommy: Caroly, Caroly, Carolie threw up in food.

[28:17] Jimi: On my MacBook.

[28:20] Tommy: Well, let's move on to number three.

[28:25] Jimi: I was like, what number are we on that?

[28:26] Tommy: Maybe four.

[28:27] Jimi: It doesn't matter.

[28:28] Tommy: We're talking Carolie.

[28:31] Jimi: Before we get too far into it, the picture is it's a it's two, it's two different exposures of two pictures this one.

[28:39] Tommy: Yeah.

[28:39] Jimi: Of um a doll, a girl doll with blonde hair. One of them looks as you would expect a doll to, and the next one is close, but one of the eyes has gone a little cross-eyed, and about half of the hair is missing.

[28:51] Tommy: Yeah, she's been punched.

[28:54] Jimi: Yes.

[28:54] Tommy: Yes.

[28:55] Jimi: It's been mauled. Um yeah, and so basically this is J. Armstrong Johnson uh singing uh all about being uh male nanny to a logo called Kala Carolie, who uh is like every other annoying child that you have to be.

[29:13] Tommy: The lyric is she is Satan.

[29:15] Jimi: Yes, um, which is one of my favorite repeated rhymes in musical theater that I've run into recently.

[29:23] Tommy: Yeah, I would agree.

[29:25] Jimi: Yeah, very, very good. So basically, yeah, and it's it's it is very much like situation comedy. Um it's funny. One of my one of my big bugbears about these kind of songs. Uh I can't remember if we talked about it software. Probably not, because it's really much of an opportunity. Um but it's um contemporary references.

[29:49] Tommy: Mmm.

[29:49] Jimi: Which one bugs you in this one?

[29:51] Tommy: MacBook.

[29:52] Jimi: Mmm.

[29:53] Tommy: Yep.

[29:53] Jimi: That's a bad one.

[29:54] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?

[29:54] Jimi: Like those.

[29:55] Tommy: Those bugging too, yeah.

[29:56] Jimi: Uh-huh. It's they're they're everywhere in this kind of oeuvre of musical. Um it just it's just like, oh, yeah. It's not because it's product placement, it's not because that. It's just because it pulls you out. The uh the one that always gets me is handful after handful of Doritos.

[30:16] Tommy: Oh, interesting.

[30:17] Jimi: That doesn't get me.

[30:18] Tommy: Really?

[30:18] Jimi: Okay.

[30:19] Tommy: Yeah.

[30:19] Jimi: Yeah, that one gets me. Those sorts of things. Brand names, contemporary references.

[30:23] Tommy: The Facebook song.

[30:24] Jimi: Yeah, the face of the song. You know, I mean it's full of them.

[30:26] Tommy: It's full of things.

[30:27] Jimi: Exactly. And it's I'm sure it's very funny when you perform it right now when you wrote the musical because you're not thinking of us five years later listening to it. They don't make MacBooks anymore, do they?

[30:39] Tommy: Or do they call them MacBooks?

[30:41] Jimi: It would be a MacBook Pro is what you would get.

[30:43] Tommy: And you can't rhyme that.

[30:44] Jimi: Pro doesn't rhyme with anything.

[30:46] Tommy: MacBook Pro.

[30:48] Jimi: It does work. Well done. You should write musicals.

[30:51] Tommy: I should. Um but yeah, I think it's just it's that kind of thing. It like it hates it instantly. It's not old enough to become vintage. You you initially reacted to this kind of punchline song. Um tell me more about that.

[31:04] Jimi: Because I think I think this one is darker than a traditional punchline song.

[31:09] Tommy: Oh, I don't know. I don't think it I don't think so. I think it's funny. I think it's just really good fun. I mean in the plot in the plot of the song, he sells Carolie to a crack dealer.

[31:20] Jimi: Interesting.

[31:21] Tommy: I didn't hear that because I was thinking it when he said Mr. Carolie.

[31:27] Jimi: Uh-huh.

[31:29] Tommy: I thought he was addressing her father.

[31:31] Jimi: Oh.

[31:33] Tommy: That's funnier. That's that makes it even funnier.

[31:36] Jimi: You might enjoy this song next more next time you listen to it. And I do think the idea is he's like running through the audience. I don't think he sells her to a crack dealer. I think he's like walking through the audience. He's like, take her, she can help you sell your crack. Or if you need to barter, she's an easy sale. But uh don't throw her in the trash or send her in the mail. She'll come back to haunt you. Here she is. Ha ha ha! I'm free of Caroly! Going crazy because he left this lady behind this girl behind. Hilarious.

[32:01] Tommy: That's funny. Selling a baby for crack. That's great. I love that.

[32:04] Jimi: I absolutely love that. I mean, not as explicitly, but I I think that to me puts it one, only one very tiny notch of the musical theater punchline song.

[32:16] Tommy: Oh, no, definitely. And I mean, I think it's an extremely great example of a musical theater punchline song. Um yeah, but no, it's it's really good fun. It's a really good laugh. And a nice vocal.

[32:27] Jimi: Yeah.

[32:28] Tommy: Well done. J-E-J.

[32:36] Jimi: Why should we?

[32:39] Tommy: We don't speak of husbands or homes, or work or wives unhappy lives.

[32:49] Jimi: All we've got our lips on faces moving flawlessly.

[32:59] Tommy: Holding secrets in our clock.

[33:14] Jimi: Tommy, let's continue our browser, right?

[33:17] Tommy: Oh, look at this one over here. It's called The Party Goes With You.

[33:22] Jimi: Interesting. And here it is, is uh potentially a male um walking in the streets of New York with many balloons. And you can't see him and he's walking away.

[33:33] Tommy: I do think so. Do you experience this musical as I imagine most people long before seeing these photos, right?

[33:39] Jimi: Yeah. And I do think many people experience the show having never looked at these photos.

[33:44] Tommy: Yeah.

[33:44] Jimi: This one's a good one to look at.

[33:47] Tommy: Yeah, it's lovely.

[33:48] Jimi: I would have that on my wall.

[33:49] Tommy: Yeah. Well, and it's fun with the song called The Party Goes With You.

[33:53] Jimi: Yeah.

[33:53] Tommy: It's a man walking around with you know 50 balloons all around him.

[33:57] Jimi: That's funny. Like if this was just a photo on the wall titled The Party Goes With You, I would already have opinions and feelings about that sort of thing.

[34:06] Tommy: Yeah.

[34:08] Jimi: Um, but I think it's a really lovely song, and I think it's a fascinating song.

[34:12] Tommy: Yeah.

[34:12] Jimi: Um, and I just mean fascinating, like musically in particular.

[34:16] Tommy: Oh.

[34:16] Jimi: Um, it's sort of sung as if it I don't know, it kind of evokes a sort of a smoky jazz style.

[34:24] Tommy: Um just with perfect vocal.

[34:30] Jimi: Of course.

[34:32] Tommy: Ugh, that woman, that woman can do no wrong.

[34:35] Jimi: And it's just, it's really, it's really dusky and uh kind of poignant and slightly sad. Um, and very very unlindsay Mendez.

[34:47] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?

[34:48] Jimi: It doesn't go to the you know, top E belt that she can nail.

[34:53] Tommy: Yeah, it's it stays very, very low.

[34:57] Jimi: Um I think that's so nice. It's really refreshing to hear uh her sing like that. Um and I know that they're they're really really close. Um, like they formed uh um an actor's therapy group together, actually, which is amazing.

[35:13] Tommy: Yeah, uh huh.

[35:14] Jimi: So it's for young ac young actors who you know, obviously just getting into the biz and it is the most psychologically draining job in the whole bloody world, especially New York. Yeah, um and yeah, that it's uh a therapy group for for them and absolutely amazing. Um and he writes a lot of the mu her their music specifically for her because he he knows her voice.

[35:36] Tommy: Yeah.

[35:36] Jimi: Um and I think this has been totally written with her in mind, and just because of a really subtle riffing ability, yeah, um that is is infused all the way throughout this, and um so gentle and yeah.

[35:51] Tommy: So I mean in terms of what it's about, again it's just quite poignant and quite yeah.

[35:57] Jimi: But it's not there's nothing there's nothing explicit there. It's really especially especially with this image. This is a confusing song, you know?

[36:06] Tommy: Yeah.

[36:06] Jimi: If you didn't see this image you'd think this was about a a party, a you know, like maybe more of an explicit talk of like how one person feels about another person when they're at this kind of you know, smoky low-key house party and how they feel about when they leave, but then put this man with his balloons walking through the streets of New York, and I don't know what to think anymore.

[36:32] Tommy: Yeah, I know. I think it it's weird when I look at the image and then think of the the song, I think it's just it it kind of heaps on the irony of it.

[36:42] Jimi: Yeah.

[36:43] Tommy: Um that kind of like huh, oh well, that goes with irony, you know what we and that it's the Alanis Morissette effect.

[36:53] Jimi: Um and I think that kind of adds adds in the the pathos of it. Uh and because it that's the thing is like they're not separating. Do you know what I mean? It's not like it's not goodbye forever.

[37:06] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.

[37:07] Jimi: It's as if he's literally just leaving the room.

[37:08] Tommy: Yeah, it's it's like good goodbye to this moment.

[37:12] Jimi: Yeah, yeah, exactly. And it's and it is it's that it's almost like you know, she loves him so much that even just like literally leaving the room is enough to kind of break her heart and make her muse on on all of this.

[37:24] Tommy: Yeah.

[37:24] Jimi: Um and that's just a beautiful uh sentiment, I guess.

[37:30] Tommy: Yeah, it's a it's a it's an interesting capturing of a very ephemeral thought and feeling.

[37:36] Jimi: Yeah, definitely. Um it's really beautiful, it's a really beautiful song. Um, but what do you think about the fact so um a really interesting part of this show is the the character names um so uh each actor in it is like um I think they're like man one, man two, right?

[37:57] Tommy: Very simple or voice one, voice two, yeah.

[38:00] Jimi: Uh huh. Yeah. Um but within each song they're given a character name.

[38:06] Tommy: Which I imagine would have been in the program too.

[38:08] Jimi: So this is like you can assume this is part of the show. This is not just like stuff we've picked up later lead reading the libretto. Um so for the party goes with you, um, Lindsay Mendes character is called the broad.

[38:22] Tommy: Yeah.

[38:23] Jimi: I find that kind of interesting because that's a very, you know, misogynistic name for a I wonder if we have ocean confusion.

[38:32] Tommy: I do think the broad I think the word broad is misogynistic, but I think maybe less so in America.

[38:38] Jimi: Okay.

[38:39] Tommy: The it's maybe, especially contemporarily, I would never call a woman abroad, but listen to all a whole bunch of Golden Oldie Frank Sinatra songs.

[38:48] Jimi: But so that that's I think that's the reason why she's called it is because it this song evokes that time. That smoky jazz age sort of.

[38:56] Tommy: Yeah, yeah.

[38:57] Jimi: Uh uh and I see her is that almost like that femme fatale style, you know, cigarette in hand watching um Humphrey Bogart leave the leave the room. Do you know what I mean? It's it's that that kind of thing that evokes.

[39:06] Tommy: It's cool.

[39:09] Jimi: Yeah, it is cool.

[39:10] Tommy: What makes so my lady okay?

[39:14] Jimi: My maid with hair like jet and skin like pearl and potion spray.

[39:18] Tommy: I'm in you hear my call good lady on the burn my model.

[39:30] Jimi: Wow, look at this one. This is dramatic.

[39:31] Tommy: So we move on to good lady.

[39:35] Jimi: Um which the uh the CD insert tells me is exposure 52. It's a man who is standing in a fountain, or maybe the chamber of secrets.

[39:48] Tommy: It looks it looks very like the Chamber of Secrets.

[39:51] Jimi: Yeah, if the Chamber of Secrets was white um on the walls, and he is has an angry yelling face on and angry hand claws, and is there's a b like a very stunning uh fountain splash that uh he has created behind him.

[40:06] Tommy: Like it looks like he has torn the water into the air out of rage and anger.

[40:12] Jimi: Yeah. Um and that's again is kinda what the song. Do you know what I mean?

[40:18] Tommy: Yeah.

[40:18] Jimi: Um, so it's basically about a man who again is is very much in love with a woman who has left him for another man, um, and he uh kind of goes on this rage bender to uh try and get her back, basically.

[40:42] Tommy: Um but you know, maybe not in the most sensible ways.

[40:45] Jimi: Yeah, yeah, exactly.

[40:47] Tommy: Also, because he's in the middle of a fountain.

[40:49] Jimi: Yes.

[40:50] Tommy: But strangely enough, we're like in the middle ages. Blondel's back, ladies and gentlemen.

[40:53] Jimi: Blondel's back.

[40:58] Tommy: Uh but I quite like that. I quite like the the middle again, the mint the kind of switch up of setting. And we should mention that all throughout this song, the rest of the singers are are it's like this interesting Italian chant.

[41:14] Jimi: Um that is from Carmina Barana.

[41:18] Tommy: Yeah.

[41:20] Jimi: Who knew?

[41:21] Tommy: Who knew?

[41:22] Jimi: Who knew? Um but yeah, and it's uh I guess it it creates that kind of old timey feel, you know, it's got this that Latin vibe.

[41:31] Tommy: Yeah, uh and it is lyrically appropriate. I bemoan the wounds of fortune with weeping eyes for the gifts she made me, she uh what perverishly takes away, something like that. Um, you know, so uh it's also the song, it's not just watermelon, watermelon, and watermelon and Latin or Italian.

[41:51] Jimi: Yes, exact exactly.

[41:53] Tommy: Um but yeah, it's a it's a good it's a good tune. I don't know, it's it's not again, it's not one of the ones that I'm like, oh god, I'll listen to that for the rest of the time. It's a really good bop. It's a good bop.

[42:05] Jimi: That works, yeah. Good bop.

[42:07] Tommy: Yeah. Do you view this as so we're in Crazy Town, which I've said is contemporary New York-ish. This song, and maybe the last song, a little a little maybe the party goes with you a little bit, but definitely Good Lady is not a song that plays in contemporary New York.

[42:28] Jimi: No, and but I I d I I never said that Crazy Time was contemporary New York.

[42:33] Tommy: Okay.

[42:34] Jimi: You said Crazy Time was contemporary New York, because I don't think it is.

[42:37] Tommy: Okay.

[42:38] Jimi: I think like say I think Crazy Town is adulthood.

[42:43] Tommy: The real world.

[42:45] Jimi: Interesting. Because I don't, and again, we're to we're teasing this big finish, but this isn't, and I'm very passionate about this, that this isn't another song cycle saying contemporary New York.

[42:56] Tommy: Right.

[42:56] Jimi: Because we've got five gazillion of them. Like there's too many.

[43:02] Tommy: Yeah.

[43:02] Jimi: Um and I don't think this is. And in the sense that, you know, Ryan Ryan Scott Oliver is from New York, or lives in New York. Uh so that's my underlying question is is this a song sung by a medieval knight?

[43:17] Tommy: Or okay.

[43:19] Jimi: There you go.

[43:21] Tommy: I think so. I think so. And I think um yeah, completely. And I think that's a really good uh skill, I guess, of Ryan Scott Oliver's is that uh he does that, he writes about things that are interesting and different.

[43:38] Jimi: Um I would I don't I don't know how I feel about this. I would offer as the counterpoint, which I'm still unsure about, that it if if in my world Crazy Town is Contemporary New York, we're pulling a we're pulling a metaphor here. That's like especially and maybe I'm too stuck on the pictures that go with these things. Um but that this is you know we are we are using the terms of chivalry and the terms of um you know knights and ladies in white and these sorts of things um but talking about it through a contemporary lens beyond just we realize that the audience exists in the 2010s um but that there's some tinge there but I don't know I don't have good evidence for that I don't have a good reason to back that up and I'm on the fence about it.

[44:32] Tommy: Yeah I d I just don't think I think it like it's just purely like in in the right production of this someone walking out in medieval knights armor wouldn't be the worst choice is what I hear you're saying.

[44:45] Jimi: That is exactly how I would direct it yeah I wouldn't just say no but no like even just like you know bathed in blood is black as pitch you wouldn't get away with that in contemporary New York you know maybe in the 80s but not not in post Giuliani New York.

[45:02] Tommy: Yeah I just think I think and there's not I don't think there's anything wrong with that. I think there's no nothing wrong in calling a spade in a spade and just being like why why not write a song from the knight's perspective. It's it's just interesting that it comes two songs later after a song talking about a MacBook you know um ex uh and again right we'll just get to it we should we should move on because we're we're never gonna get to it in this I'm just gonna make me happy all the time.

[45:45] Jimi: And I know I don't deserve you, but please have faith in me. I'm working to be worthy, and so you are gonna see me happy.

[46:04] Tommy: Fascinating. Um I love this photo. I love this photo. It's uh a guy and a girl. Um we're assuming a lot of things, of course, but a guy and a girl standing in front of a yellow picket fence with Walmart style inflatable smiley face balloons held in front of their face, and they're kind of backlit in the shadows.

[46:24] Jimi: Pre-emoji days.

[46:25] Tommy: Exactly. Remember those?

[46:26] Jimi: That is uh that's a watchman smiley face.

[46:28] Tommy: That is a watch face.

[46:30] Jimi: Yeah, with a uh a blue and white sky behind them.

[46:34] Tommy: Yep.

[46:36] Jimi: Um I just love the shadows that they create. I think it's cool. It's really into them, but it's it's an it's an edgy happiness.

[46:44] Tommy: This is not joy.

[46:46] Jimi: Yeah, exactly. It is painted very much painted on. It's that like we are happy. Here is my mask.

[46:52] Tommy: Yeah. Um again, that's kind of what the the song is, but it's another bop, I would say.

[47:01] Jimi: Yeah, it's I mean, it the they're dark lyrics. You make me happy all the time, and you know that I'm a total dick. Um, you know, you make me happy all the time, and that's really fucking tough. Like, it this is you know the the image doesn't imply drug use. There's more something about a relationship here, but it is that kind of like we're getting our happy fix. This is not like you fill my heart with laughter.

[47:27] Tommy: Um it's you make me happy. Well, I I I think as well. I think it's the idea that you need to be happy that is that, you know, yeah, if you're in a good strong relationship, then you're happy.

[47:39] Jimi: Yeah. Do you know what I mean?

[47:40] Tommy: Are you guys happy? Are you happy together?

[47:42] Jimi: Right. Um, I mean, what is that? It kind of gets into the meat of like, what does that mean? Like, sure, maybe.

[47:48] Tommy: Yeah.

[47:49] Jimi: Yeah, you make you make me happy. Great. Yeah. Um, here's all of the the bad things that I do.

[47:55] Tommy: Right.

[47:55] Jimi: Yeah. Do you know is that like it's not dark to the point of being unsettling, but there is like a a tinge to it, you know?

[48:03] Tommy: Yeah. Uh-huh.

[48:03] Jimi: It's definitely a little bit jaded, a little bit bitter. Um yeah, I think again, it's it's it's an interesting point to make about uh yeah, just the the state of relationships, I mean it.

[48:20] Tommy: Yeah.

[48:20] Jimi: Um and that they kind of need especially in this kind of Instagram age, um, where you know, everything you're taking is like, look how happy we are, we're just so happy together.

[48:30] Tommy: Yeah, and then two minutes later you're getting a divorce.

[48:32] Jimi: Yeah. Yeah.

[48:33] Tommy: Do you know what I mean? It's that pressure to be happy.

[48:35] Jimi: Yeah, I it's I think it's definitely a discussion of pressure to be happy. Um is a you know, that's a new age topic for sure.

[48:45] Tommy: Yeah. Uh-huh.

[48:46] Jimi: And I think I I don't know, I I feel like again, I think this couple probably is quite strong.

[48:51] Tommy: Yeah.

[48:52] Jimi: Because they realize all their faults.

[48:54] Tommy: Yeah.

[48:54] Jimi: Do you know what I mean? Um, but it's almost like the the happy chat is for someone else.

[49:00] Tommy: Right.

[49:00] Jimi: Yeah, it's like we are we are playing, you know, we are holding these smiley faces balloons in front of our face to demonstrate for everyone else that we are happy, yeah.

[49:09] Tommy: Even though we know we are really difficult to live with.

[49:12] Jimi: Yeah, but I'm to acknowledge that.

[49:15] Tommy: Yeah, it's like that's what you that's what you want to see. You want to see us happy because why would you want to see us miserable? Because then you'd be like, oh no.

[49:22] Jimi: Right.

[49:22] Tommy: Oh gosh. Oh, that must be so odd. You know, I mean, they're just like, this is easier. I'm gonna put a blue in front of their face.

[49:28] Jimi: It's clear.

[49:29] Tommy: It's human in disguise.

[49:41] Jimi: The angel leads me onward, he watches as I sleep.

[49:48] Tommy: The angel thinks I've got some kind of soul to key.

[49:56] Jimi: I feel him rest his seraph arm against my chest.

[50:03] Tommy: Don't know why it should be bought by the angel.

[50:11] Jimi: I am wow, look at this one.

[50:18] Tommy: Yeah, it's a great photo.

[50:19] Jimi: The serif.

[50:20] Tommy: The serif, am I saying that right?

[50:22] Jimi: You are saying that correct.

[50:24] Tommy: Exposure fifty-four. Um I would have this on my wall, by the way, just is just to say this probably one of the ones I would really, really have in my wall.

[50:32] Jimi: It's 'cause there's an attractive man in it.

[50:34] Tommy: Um, it's the color. I love that tealy that tealy blue.

[50:38] Jimi: Tealy blue. I've got I've got flux on at the moment, so it may be orange.

[50:44] Tommy: I mean, who knows? Everything else is. We're looking at a man's back, he's wearing jeans and a white shirt, and he's holding a jacket, um, either coat or suit coat in his left hand.

[50:53] Jimi: Uh the whole frame, it's a Dutch angle, so it's tilted a little to the side.

[51:00] Tommy: Dutch angle, Jimmy's learnt something new.

[51:01] Jimi: There you go. That's called a Dutch angle. I'm 90% sure about.

[51:03] Tommy: Um and he's standing on a bridge or walkway of some sort, which is like green wrought iron with chain link fence around it.

[51:11] Jimi: It's a very perspective-y shot, like the bridge goes into the distance, and there's some graffiti and a light at the very end of this bridgey.

[51:19] Tommy: Yeah, big glowing, like glowing light, it's very urban.

[51:23] Jimi: Um, and the song itself is great.

[51:30] Tommy: Yeah.

[51:30] Jimi: I think it's amazing. Um, so I think this is probably one of the most autobiographical the whole thing. Um because important to note uh that Matthew Murphy um and Ryan Scott Oliver are um lovers.

[51:50] Tommy: Yes.

[51:51] Jimi: Uh and where are our still love it and where at the time of writing this as well. Um, and there's an interview, it's quite a cool interview, um, about the seraph. Um, and the question was posed like, so what came first? Was it the photo or was it the song?

[52:08] Tommy: Um and Ryan Scott Oliver offered that well, actually it was you know, we came first.

[52:16] Jimi: And then the song came. And I love that because it's like, yeah, you can you totally get that's a beautiful, beautiful love song.

[52:24] Tommy: Yes.

[52:25] Jimi: Um yeah. And there's it, you know, there is it's f it is a religious imagery song. Um the whole thing is talking about the devil and the angel and God and um, but coming from you know, this this gay love perspective and how that affects all these things.

[52:48] Tommy: I'm not doing a good job of explaining it.

[52:50] Jimi: But you get Well, yeah, uh-huh. And it's um the kind of the punchline of it is uh I don't believe in God.

[52:58] Tommy: Um I think Jesus was just a man.

[53:00] Jimi: Um but you know there's there's something about us being together that is more than just hey, this is all happened. Um again, I I quite like that because as someone who, you know, I'm not religious, but I care about faith and I care about yeah, you know, that that side of things that I do think there's higher power, blah blah blah blah.

[53:21] Tommy: Um I totally get I totally get this.

[53:24] Jimi: Yes. Um where it's like I'm not using the terms correctly, I'm not uh you know, I'm not making a sermon here.

[53:31] Tommy: Yeah.

[53:32] Jimi: But the there's still an appreciation of the idea of like the concept of l looking for these characters in your life. Not that they're the Judeo-Christian ideal of a god or a Jesus or an angel or a devil or whatever, but that there is some concept of those things that exists in your life.

[53:54] Tommy: Yeah.

[53:54] Jimi: And there's an interesting juxtaposition there.

[53:57] Tommy: Yeah.

[53:58] Jimi: Um it's just a really beautiful love song.

[54:02] Tommy: Good old gay love song.

[54:04] Jimi: And one of the few times we have a reprise of a previous song in a new song. There's a little ending of m uh make me happy that comes back in the seraph.

[54:14] Tommy: Mm-hmm.

[54:15] Jimi: Um which is nice, yeah, it's nice to link them together, I guess.

[54:20] Tommy: Yeah, maybe. It it makes me, you know, this this whole musical is a question. Um there's just just question marks all over the place, but it makes me wonder about make me happy putting it in what I view as a a pretty ending on a positive note, yeah to simplify it kind of love song with something that strikes me with a a song with a darker tinge at the end, but maybe I'm then reinterpreting or misinterpreting, or maybe that's the point, maybe that isn't the point, you know.

[54:51] Jimi: That's this whole show for me.

[54:53] Tommy: Yeah, well, I think you know, I think it having them at the at the end of it kind of makes the make me happy. You see that it is a you know, it is a loving relationship. It's just not necessary, you know.

[55:04] Jimi: I mean the phases are up.

[55:06] Tommy: Yeah, it's not necessarily outwardly gonna be the best thing, but there's still love there, you know what I mean?

[55:13] Jimi: Yeah, um, yeah.

[55:14] Tommy: But definitely gonna get that on my wall.

[55:16] Jimi: It's gorgeous.

[55:17] Tommy: You should. And there's amazing things. That's not the reason. I find that's really interesting. This is a total total sidebar. Um, but I'm interested to hear what you think.

[55:27] Jimi: Uh-huh.

[55:27] Tommy: What do you think about like uh provocative uh gay art? Like I'm talking like, would you have like a painting of like like a Tom of Finland painting? Like you're talking like the set decoration from queer as folk.

[55:44] Jimi: Um but do you know I mean like just like yeah.

[55:50] Tommy: It strikes me, it strikes me as very early 2000s, just from like a set designer set decoration kind of perspective.

[55:57] Jimi: Right.

[55:57] Tommy: Yeah.

[55:58] Jimi: But I do think, and I'd be interested, you know, to hear from the gay studies majors out there. Um I think it comes from a different era of coded coming out. Um, to put it in musical theater terms, picture Roger Debree's apartment. Um, pink curving staircase, lavender everywhere, and you walk into his apartment and he doesn't need to tell you who he is because you already know. Um there's like, you know, w the gay culture has these things because the utilitarian, um, you know, from whichever pierced ear you have to whatever handkerchief you have, you know, hanging in your pocket. Like we use these things because we don't show sometimes, and having the coded language to out yourself to people in the know is useful.

[56:50] Tommy: Yeah.

[56:51] Jimi: One of the ways to do that is to hang pictures of naked men in your apartment. Um, and I I think it's part of that. Aesthetically, it's not my cup of tea. Um, you know. Because I love I love a lot of the art, but I I wouldn't put it and I don't know. I'd feel a bit weird like having dinner and then be like penis. How would you feel? How would you feel about seeing it at an art gallery?

[57:14] Tommy: I'd be totally fine. Like that's the kind of art I love. Like I love Thomas M. I think you know, some of the art that's come out of that is beautiful. Uh-huh. Um, I I really love it, but yeah, I guess that's that is the time and the place for it.

[57:28] Jimi: I would say well I mean my corner. That's interesting, I don't know. I've never I never really thought about that.

[57:37] Tommy: I mean it's a good one.

[57:38] Jimi: Well, that's that's part of it too. And like you're doing something with it when you put it in your home. Um yeah, I don't know. Caveat, uh, don't Google Tom of Fin Finland with your grandma standing behind you.

[57:47] Tommy: Yes.

[57:48] Jimi: Um, or should we say if you're under 18? I don't know. I don't know, probably worth it.

[57:53] Tommy: Yeah.

[57:54] Jimi: I mean, I would say. Discover it on your own. Hallelujah.

[58:00] Tommy: Hallelujah.

[58:02] Jimi: Hallelujah.

[58:14] Tommy: Yeah, I'll call it Jesus.

[58:16] Jimi: And she'll sell for a lot. Very meta. Very David Lachapel.

[58:23] Tommy: Yeah, it's just a caption.

[58:26] Jimi: On the capture eye caught. One's the whore. How much more? Here. Wow. Look at this one. This is kind of spooky.

[58:37] Tommy: This song and this picture baffle me.

[58:39] Jimi: So this is Immaculate Deception.

[58:41] Tommy: Yeah.

[58:42] Jimi: So I'm interested. Why does it baffle you?

[58:44] Tommy: Because I think it's Blade's obvious is the word.

[58:47] Jimi: Wow.

[58:48] Tommy: Okay. Tell people about this picture first.

[58:51] Jimi: Okay, well, so the picture is um like a reflection picture in a puddle. Um it looks a bit like the Babadook.

[58:58] Tommy: I don't know. Look.

[58:59] Jimi: It does kinda. It does kind of look like the upside down Bab Babadook, but like viewed through the sliver of a puddle on a dirt or asphalt street.

[59:07] Tommy: Yeah.

[59:08] Jimi: Um it looks like it's very much like your um I've just got my camera. Oh my god, I can see the world through different perspectives.

[59:16] Tommy: Yeah.

[59:17] Jimi: Somewhere between that or like the the picture you accidentally took while you got your camera out to take another picture.

[59:23] Tommy: Also that, yeah.

[59:25] Jimi: And it's but it must be it's like the side of a building or something viewed through a puddle with some.

[59:29] Tommy: Yeah, it looks like uh like a big mural or something like that.

[59:32] Jimi: This particular sliver is kind of spooky. And some some indecipherable text and maybe an eyeball and a tiny little like quadrilateral of you know sinister red. Um so that combined with a song called Immaculate Deception, which is a really clever play on words without any context. Um but the I don't I I never want to put meaning on a piece of art because sometimes that's not the thing. I struggle and I like this song.

[1:00:04] Tommy: It makes me feel things, but I don't know what's trying to happen.

[1:00:09] Jimi: I think it's just about photography. I think it's just about uh, you know, being a photographer, uh or being an artist in many ways and having to capture things that aren't necessarily you know, m maybe morally the right thing, but you're doing it for your art.

[1:00:27] Tommy: Um then kind of profiting from that.

[1:00:31] Jimi: You know, I guess I just think that's exactly what it is. If you'll if you'll pardon the unintentional metaphor, but I hadn't zoomed out far enough to just think of it as a as a photography song.

[1:00:42] Tommy: Get your telephoto on.

[1:00:45] Jimi: Um yeah, no, I think it's I think it's just purely a photographer song. But what yeah, because like well, a shutter is a flutter of clicks.

[1:00:53] Tommy: Yeah, but what about all the all the religious metaphor in it?

[1:00:56] Jimi: Bless the Lord. Because that's the thing is it's like by by saying a hallelujah.

[1:01:00] Tommy: Yeah, by sla you know, you've got the fo a photo of a prostitute sitting in a gutter and calling it God, yeah.

[1:01:05] Jimi: Is makes it like, oh wow, yeah, go oh, I get it.

[1:01:09] Tommy: Yeah, I guess that's true. I'll give you money.

[1:01:10] Jimi: Whereas if you call it like prostitute and gutter, yeah. You're not gonna pay nearly as much money for that.

[1:01:15] Tommy: And you've and you've you've won me over, especially with the title Immaculate Deception. If we're talking about Immaculate Conception, like this thing just came out of nowhere, and ooh, uh, you know, we we didn't think we didn't put, you know, our pieces together to make this exist, but it's also a deception.

[1:01:29] Jimi: Yeah, yeah. You convince me. I know it's a good thing. You know, something is like zooming in on a dead rat.

[1:01:33] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:01:34] Jimi: Because it looks like Jesus. Do you know what I mean?

[1:01:36] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:01:36] Jimi: Like it is like, here is Jesus. With with this photography concept song, it is interesting when we hit the much teased, much lauded in part four of 35 millimeter uh later part of this episode where we talk about that thing.

[1:01:50] Tommy: Um yeah, this is this is definitely one of the uh like songs about this a song about photography, whereas no, you know what I mean. The rest aren't about this is like it brings you, and we're you know, if we're talking structure wise, um it brings you back out a little bit at the right moment in the show. We've been delving into some stories and some concepts and some ideas and some things, and then this is zooming back out.

[1:02:17] Jimi: We're back at stop focus level zoom a little bit, you know? And then we're about to get V heavy, because here's a picture of a stag's head.

[1:02:30] Tommy: Some ones howling screams like sighing with battered breathing, crowling, never dying in a fame, death, she cross her visible, so the bastards will never sleep again.

[1:02:59] Jimi: No, no, not free flue and she brings their souls down to hell. Caution to the policeman to the purpose!

[1:03:11] Tommy: Praise before those of you in America, it's a deer with antlers.

[1:03:22] Jimi: Yeah, a stag.

[1:03:24] Tommy: You have a stag.

[1:03:25] Jimi: We do, but it's also like slang for a man, which is important in this show.

[1:03:31] Tommy: Slide for a man in terms of like a stag do.

[1:03:34] Jimi: Right.

[1:03:34] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:03:35] Jimi: It's a I don't think you've got that. Do you have you ever been to a place with a mounted deer head on a wall? These things exist.

[1:03:41] Tommy: I'm from Scotland! We like made the red deer.

[1:03:47] Jimi: I don't actually think that's a red deer. The picture's uh it's very sepia, it's you know, yellowy, black and whitey. Um it's a it's um it's a man holding a deer's a mounted deer's head in front of his face and with his left arm and his right arm is outstretched, reaching backwards a little bit.

[1:04:06] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:04:06] Jimi: And he's definitely wearing a wife beater, and that's very important.

[1:04:09] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:04:10] Jimi: Um the song is called Leave Luan. And this, I think, is one of the songs, like people, if you want to listen to one song for 35mm, this would be one of the songs to listen to.

[1:04:18] Tommy: Definitely. This is a massive highlight. This is so good.

[1:04:20] Jimi: Oh my god, it's so good. Um, so we're we're in the deep south. Uh we're in Luzanna, and uh so yeah, so we've got uh the character of the Cajun, uh James Tom Johnson is back.

[1:04:36] Tommy: Um, and he's accompanied later on by uh Le Voix Homme des Sot or whoever, or de Sous, uh, and which we've found out means the voices below.

[1:04:51] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:04:51] Tommy: And there's a a long folk song tradition in America of this kind of song.

[1:04:58] Jimi: Yeah, all the way back to like, you know, uh oh Carolina. Like there are lots of songs about like poor old women who died. They're not all of them are as dark as appropriately dark sounding as this one is.

[1:05:13] Tommy: Um, but this is definitely a play on that kind of song.

[1:05:19] Jimi: Yeah, and it's got a really like nice southern kind of bluegrass vibe to it. Um it really it sticks out.

[1:05:27] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:05:27] Jimi: Um it's a narrative song. It's about uh this poor lady Luann who is escaping her um her wife beating husband.

[1:05:38] Tommy: Yep.

[1:05:39] Jimi: Uh and when she does escape, uh he sadly catches her um and kills her.

[1:05:49] Tommy: Uh but then she comes back to haunt him as this like uh a little bit like this kind of deity of the south who uh basically haunts wife beating men, which I love.

[1:06:03] Jimi: Yeah, no, it's it's it's a one I mean it's a a scary, sad song taken literally, but it is a beautifully structured and composed song.

[1:06:11] Tommy: Oh, completely.

[1:06:11] Jimi: It's a proper story, yeah.

[1:06:13] Tommy: Um yeah, a proper, proper story.

[1:06:17] Jimi: Uh and it's quite good because G Arm Stock Johnson, that's this is his background, is is his country. Um because my first exposure to him was uh hands in a hard body.

[1:06:29] Tommy: Um and obviously that's in the deep south.

[1:06:33] Jimi: And I was like, who's this gorgeous little country singer?

[1:06:35] Tommy: Um and this is him really getting to the yeah, yeah, bringing out his his country chops.

[1:06:40] Jimi: What it is I mean, I I think it's a lesson in songwriting conceptualization too, because the song is Leave Luan. The narrative is about how Luan wants to get out of there.

[1:06:50] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:06:50] Jimi: And if you follow the story, the the you know, punchline's the wrong word, but the ending is Luan never Luan remains and remains and remains and remains and remains to haunt you forever. That's what you get. You didn't want her to leave. Okay, she'll be here forever.

[1:07:05] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:07:06] Jimi: Maha ha ha.

[1:07:07] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:07:07] Jimi: Which is like that's that's the way to structure a story. That's absolutely that's invigorating without the song, and then put the song on top of it.

[1:07:15] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:07:17] Jimi: So an interesting point I want to make here. So on on your YouTubes, um, it will probably link you to as much of these as we possibly can, um, because it's been performed many times, as these songs often do.

[1:07:29] Tommy: But um, there's uh a female who sings a song, Katie Thompson um is her name.

[1:07:37] Jimi: And uh it was interesting because one of the comments on on one of the YouTube videos of of Jay singing it, um was like, I much prefer with a woman singing it, I think it makes a lot more sense with a woman singing it.

[1:07:51] Tommy: Um and I just wanted to posit that to you.

[1:07:54] Jimi: Huh, interesting and see what you think about that.

[1:07:56] Tommy: I think as far as I think it it it's two different contexts we're talking about. I from a me context, please let's give more songs to women.

[1:08:06] Jimi: Um from viewing this as a traditional southern country ballad, uh those are you know, in a canyon in a cav or an excavate, like there is something about a male singer there because of our you know, chauvinistic past, and that was the quote unquote normal.

[1:08:26] Tommy: Um and I think it would add an extra level of intrigue and interest having a female singer with this song.

[1:08:36] Jimi: Um if given the choice, if I were directing, absolutely I would make that choice, make it a lady.

[1:08:42] Tommy: Um, it gives it power.

[1:08:45] Jimi: Um, you know, having a man sing it, this is a tragedy that we're reminiscing about. Having a lady sing it, you know, it makes you question is this Luan singing this? Is this the song she sings to haunt her lover to like remind him of the story that happened, and now I will haunt you by telling it to you again and again and again over and over again.

[1:09:06] Tommy: Um that's fun, that's good, you know.

[1:09:10] Jimi: Yeah, because I I quite like I like that it's a guy because it's almost like uh you know, a guy singing it to his singing to his buddy in a bar. Do you know what I mean? To be like, stop beating up your wife, because you wouldn't listen to it. If it was a woman singing it, you wouldn't listen to her.

[1:09:26] Tommy: But if it's a guy singing it, it's got that kind of like yeah, you know, it's it's a bit I feel like it's uh it's a bit more chilling if it comes from a male.

[1:09:36] Jimi: Yeah, uh it's a cautionary tale at that point, yeah, exactly.

[1:09:41] Jimi: Exactly. But with a female, I think with a female, it's definitely a lot more hearty and a lot more, uh, strong. But I think with a guy, it's chilling; it's got a different tone.

[1:09:49] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:09:49] Jimi: Um, that's very interesting.

[1:09:51] Tommy: Yeah, yeah.

[1:09:52] Jimi: But I think that's, I think, I think that's a really cool thing about this song is that, yeah, it can be taken in different ways because it's definitely not, you know, there's no autobiographical element to it. At no point is Jamstrong Johnson singing from his own perspective, right?

[1:10:10] Tommy: Uh, but if it was a female, then obviously that could totally be implied.

[1:10:10] Jimi: Yeah, um, yeah, it's a great song. It's one of the most standalone songs in the show. You know, it's the most self-contained, one of the most song cycle-ish songs in the show, I would say. Don't shut me out, shut me out. Don't you hear my bang and shout? My bang shot be the baby who cries in the baby who as black bars call to five. Look at this, this is interesting. Is this religion? Have you not seen this picture? Mama, let me in is the next.

[1:10:10] Tommy: No, I have. I was acting.

[1:10:10] Jimi: Oh, oh yeah, I forgot. We're in this gallery. Sorry, I thought we were recording a podcast. What a silly thing to do. Sorry, um, get in the moment. Come on, you've done improv, Jesus. Yes, and um, yeah, so this is a statue of what looks like the Virgin Mary, um, kind of inlaid into a rock, uh, in a little arch, uh, and but it's blocked off by a fence post.

[1:13:02] Jimi: Um, mama, let me in.

[1:13:02] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:13:02] Jimi: So first of all, if you're in a choir, this is a great song because it's totally a cappella, um, and it's beautifully arranged. It's beautifully arranged.

[1:13:02] Tommy: Yeah, there's like a, uh, a caged fence in front of the statue of Mary, and she's inset in a, in a red rock or stucco wall or something.

[1:13:02] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:13:02] Jimi: Um, I would totally do it. Like, this is a great one.

[1:13:02] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:13:02] Jimi: There's such a, and it's because it's a cappella, it's kind of pick up and play. Um, so you know, yeah, for the Amdram lots out there, you don't need no violins for this.

[1:13:02] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:13:02] Jimi: Uh, go for it because it's really good. I mean, it sounds like a very traditional, when I went to Catholic school, this would be the kind of song I would hear in church, um, sound-wise, which is interesting based on its content.

[1:13:02] Tommy: Um, because you could, I could sing this song in a traditional Catholic church and it would have lots of meaning.

[1:14:50] Jimi: Mama, let me in, while you hate me, call me sin.

[1:14:50] Tommy: But knowing the autobiographical parts of this kind of, I mean, for me, this song is about being gay.

[1:14:50] Jimi: Interesting.

[1:14:50] Tommy: Never got that.

[1:14:50] Jimi: Really?

[1:14:50] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:14:50] Jimi: What's the song about for you?

[1:14:50] Tommy: Um, I just thought it was, uh, kind of not understanding parenthood, but also I think there is a religious element to it as well. I mean, and yeah, just taking it quite literally of, uh, religion, yeah, let me be a part of you kind of thing.

[1:14:50] Jimi: But I, I know, I mean, I can see what you mean. I can totally see what you mean.

[1:14:50] Tommy: Yeah, it reads, and I, you know, I don't know, it's, it's where I have the question and the struggle of like, am I doing this right? Which of course is the wrong question to ask, but you know, there's two gay collaborators working on this.

[1:14:50] Jimi: Yeah, we've already had songs that are about that to an extent.

[1:14:50] Tommy: Um, is this inspired from there or not?

[1:14:50] Jimi: Because it could be about all sorts of things.

[1:14:50] Tommy: Yeah, definitely, definitely.

[1:14:50] Jimi: Um, yeah, I guess, uh, yeah, that's, that's quite nice. I think it does have a really nice subtext to it.

[1:14:50] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:14:50] Jimi: Uh, a gay subtext.

[1:14:50] Tommy: Yeah, whatever.

[1:14:50] Jimi: Yeah, that's quite cool. It's really whatever, whatever your sin is, I think is what this song is about.

[1:14:50] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[1:14:50] Jimi: That's true. That, uh, yeah, and it is, it's just kind of accept me. Take me for whatever.

[1:14:50] Tommy: There's also, I think the double-edged sword of this one is there's the religious end of like why you call me sin, you know, let me in.

[1:14:50] Jimi: But then the, for me, what rings true is like the literal mama let me in, and like why you let me out, why you're calling me sin, please let me back into the house.

[1:15:00] Tommy: Like, there's don't shut me out. You know, makes it sad for me.

[1:15:06] Jimi: Yeah, yeah.

[1:15:07] Tommy: Yeah, no, it's definitely sad.

[1:15:10] Jimi: Definitely sad.

[1:15:11] Tommy: And I guess, yeah, that last line, love the sinner, love the sin, is that case of, uh, yeah, just embrace this part of me. Not, you know, not that, that just like it's not, um, even though it's right, I love you because it's, it's, they're playing on Love the Sinner, Hate the Sin.

[1:15:30] Jimi: And it's like Love the Sinner, love the Sin.

[1:15:32] Tommy: Yeah, because they're all the same.

[1:15:34] Jimi: Um, the next song.

[1:15:51] Tommy: Yeah, why must we tell them why?

[1:15:54] Jimi: Absolutely.

[1:15:55] Tommy: So on the surface, again, what an amazing bop.

[1:16:01] Jimi: Like, yeah, this might be my fave.

[1:16:03] Tommy: Uh, for many reasons.

[1:16:05] Jimi: Um, but basically, I think this is the most important song in the whole show.

[1:16:11] Tommy: I agree.

[1:16:12] Jimi: Yeah, that's good.

[1:16:13] Tommy: Um, because this is, I think this is your kind of, uh, crib sheet, is that what you guys call them?

[1:16:21] Jimi: Like your, your, like your G for the, yeah, yeah.

[1:16:24] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[1:16:25] Jimi: This is your what I did for love moment. This is your here's what the show is.

[1:16:29] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[1:16:30] Jimi: You know, I mean, go away and enjoy the rest of it.

[1:16:32] Tommy: Um, because basically, what it's talking about, oh, we should talk about the photo.

[1:16:32] Tommy: What's tell us?

[1:16:32] Jimi: Oh, we should talk about the photo.

[1:16:38] Tommy: So there's a bunch of different exposures, but they're all somewhat obscured or blurry photos of modern dancers made dance.

[1:16:47] Jimi: Yeah, is that a good descriptor?

[1:16:48] Tommy: Yeah, that's perfect.

[1:16:50] Jimi: Um, and basically, Alex Brightman is rocking out.

[1:16:55] Tommy: Um, and I guess to me, it's like playing the part of an artist.

[1:17:01] Jimi: And interestingly enough, all the characters in this are their first names, um, which makes me think again, it sticks out. This song kind of sticks out because they're just being themselves.

[1:17:11] Tommy: Um, and it's this thing of, um, just enjoy it, enjoy it for what it is.

[1:17:20] Jimi: Stop trying to question things, stop trying to, um, get out the, you know, the specific meaning, you know what I mean?

[1:17:29] Tommy: Yeah, just appreciate it.

[1:17:31] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:17:32] Tommy: In what context do you say those declaratives?

[1:17:37] Jimi: Appreciate what?

[1:17:39] Tommy: Art.

[1:17:40] Jimi: Okay.

[1:17:41] Tommy: That was my question.

[1:17:43] Jimi: Because this, we talked early about you not enjoying art museums.

[1:17:49] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[1:17:50] Jimi: Um, and I, I, that intrigues me, and this is the song to talk about it.

[1:17:57] Tommy: Um, because I love not knowing or not even thinking about why in art museums.

[1:18:05] Jimi: Um, we, I just finished a lesson in one of my classes where we did a crash course in, um, art and different art styles, and it's like here's one emblematic painting or piece from an artist and what you should know about their, you know, ism or whatever their, and here's another one, and here's another one, and here's another one.

[1:18:25] Tommy: Um, and near the end, we ran through, um, Andy Warhol, who everyone knows.

[1:18:29] Jimi: The picture I used was one of his Marilyns.

[1:18:31] Tommy: Um, pop art, the wrong color portrait of Marilyn Monroe.

[1:18:37] Jimi: Um, and then I talked about only briefly, uh, Cy Twombly, who you might not know.

[1:18:46] Tommy: I recognize the name to be on that.

[1:18:47] Jimi: He, you would, you probably wouldn't recognize his paintings, but he's, you know, he's an artist people talk about.

[1:18:54] Tommy: Um, I, I am by no means an expert, but if I were to describe his drawings, they look like children's scribbles on walls.

[1:19:03] Jimi: Yeah, I'm just, I'm just having a, they look like crayon scribbles on walls.

[1:19:07] Tommy: And one of my kids said, that's not art.

[1:19:11] Jimi: Um, that's, you know, and there's that default reaction.

[1:19:14] Tommy: That's not art, I could do that. Why are they doing that? What does that mean?

[1:19:16] Jimi: You know, that's a path that kids go down, all that.

[1:19:19] Tommy: But he went, that's not art.

[1:19:21] Jimi: And I went, okay, tell me why.

[1:19:23] Tommy: And, you know, that's a hard thing to articulate why you have that reaction.

[1:19:28] Jimi: Um, and I was like, okay, maybe this will make it easier.

[1:19:30] Tommy: And I went back to the Andy Warhol photo and I was like, what does this have that this other one doesn't have?

[1:19:37] Jimi: And initially, looking at Marilyn, you think like, well, there's intent there, or it's an image, or I can tell what it is, or there's a purpose, but none of those are conclusive when compared to a Twombly.

[1:19:51] Tommy: Um, this goes into the why must we tell them why.

[1:19:54] Jimi: It was a great moment.

[1:19:55] Tommy: Oh, teachers, I yearn for these teachable moments.

[1:19:59] Jimi: Um, about like art is complicated and complex.

[1:20:03] Tommy: And I'm not telling you you need to be a Cy Twombly fan.

[1:20:06] Jimi: Like, I'm not saying you need to appreciate this.

[1:20:09] Tommy: But there's, it doesn't always have a meaning.

[1:20:14] Jimi: It doesn't always look like something.

[1:20:17] Tommy: There isn't a why.

[1:20:18] Jimi: And it is, you know, why must we tell them why, parentheses, the artist's lament, um, is an interesting expression of some, something in that nugget of thought for me.

[1:20:32] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:20:34] Jimi: But I don't know.

[1:20:35] Tommy: It is weird to me that you also think this is a very important song and don't like art museums.

[1:20:41] Jimi: I, right, okay.

[1:20:42] Tommy: I think what you're doing is you're focusing, you're focusing on that.

[1:20:45] Jimi: What I'm saying is, like, I can appreciate, you know, I'm not gonna go in and look at, you know, Monet's water lilies and be like some crap.

[1:20:58] Tommy: I can, you know, I mean, it's not, it's not through lack of appreciation, yeah, it's just I've been to a lot of art museums where I've just not felt anything.

[1:21:06] Jimi: Okay, do you know what I mean?

[1:21:07] Tommy: Um, but that isn't to say I've never felt anything, like there's a, um, sculptor called Ron Mueck who, um, does some of the greatest things I've ever seen.

[1:21:18] Jimi: So he uses silicone, um, to create like hyper-realistic, um, sculptures.

[1:21:24] Tommy: Oh yeah, he does the really big people.

[1:21:26] Jimi: Yeah, exactly.

[1:21:28] Tommy: Um, so I saw one of his exhibitions, yeah, and I was obsessed and deeply, deeply moved, um, in a lot of, a lot of ways.

[1:21:37] Jimi: Um, I remember as well I went when I was in London one time with my dad, and I was, I was like nine or ten or something, and we went to a Caravaggio exhibition, yeah, and I was deeply moved.

[1:21:49] Tommy: Like I've still got a postcard that we got from the gift shop because the, like the chiaroscuro that he uses, yeah, it just, it just did something to me.

[1:21:57] Jimi: Do you know what I mean?

[1:21:58] Tommy: But like at the same time, I've been to an Henri Matisse exhibition and just kind of wandered through it as if it was IKEA.

[1:22:05] Jimi: Yeah, exactly.

[1:22:06] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?

[1:22:07] Jimi: That makes, okay, that clarifies things for me.

[1:22:09] Tommy: Because I've, I went to a, there was a Gauguin, uh, traveling exhibit at the Art Institute, um, extensive, so many pieces of his work, and you know, he's Gauguin, you recognize his name.

[1:22:22] Jimi: Um, and it, that didn't do it for me.

[1:22:25] Tommy: I, and I think we both, well, I would say, I wonder if you agree, that like that's okay.

[1:22:32] Jimi: Maybe I don't mind going to an art museum and leaving unchanged for those moments when you might find the thing that gets you.

[1:22:41] Tommy: Um, but I think the difference is, um, to, to bring us back to the ground a little bit, um, that's on us.

[1:22:53] Jimi: You know, it is not on the artist to tell us why.

[1:22:57] Tommy: They can, they can give us hints or explicit descriptions or nothing, and then it's up to us to do the work.

[1:23:07] Jimi: You know, you're looking at quote unquote another one of those totally white paintings, and you have to do a little more work.

[1:23:16] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:23:17] Jimi: Um, and you might do the work you're comfortable with and still end up the same person, and that's okay.

[1:23:23] Tommy: But, you know, some art, especially art that we qualify more as capital A art, requires less work because the artists tell us why more.

[1:23:35] Jimi: And it is interesting, especially in you know, the musical theater form, to hear this discussion of why must we tell them why?

[1:23:45] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:23:45] Jimi: Why must we prove each part, you know?

[1:23:47] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:23:48] Jimi: And I think it's just it's a really I guess I've ended every single segment.

[1:23:54] Tommy: A really cool song.

[1:23:55] Jimi: A really cool song.

[1:23:57] Tommy: Because it's something I I've never heard anyone have this discussion before.

[1:24:01] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:24:02] Tommy: Well, and they simplify it. Like the background reprise, think and you'll miss it.

[1:24:08] Jimi: Exactly.

[1:24:09] Tommy: Is beautiful.

[1:24:10] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:24:11] Tommy: Because they're playing on blink and you'll miss it, but thinking you'll miss it.

[1:24:14] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:24:15] Tommy: You know, it's about experiencing it. Don't think.

[1:24:20] Jimi: And it's so contradictory when an artist tells you to stop thinking about their art.

[1:24:27] Tommy: You know?

[1:24:28] Jimi: We're breaking the rule right now.

[1:24:30] Tommy: I know.

[1:24:30] Jimi: And there's been so many moments as well, I'm like, oh, we're really we're trying to dig it. But what it's come from is it's come from a feeling. It's come from a this is why this has resonated with me.

[1:24:39] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:24:40] Jimi: And I will say, like, you know, musical theater, shockingly enough, resonates with me a lot more than fine art does. Um I still like I say, I still have the same resonance.

[1:24:53] Tommy: I can't I realize that's so wanky, I sound like fucking.

[1:24:56] Jimi: It's hard.

[1:24:57] Tommy: I you should give yourself permission. It is hard to talk about high-level art without sounding like a douchey liberal arts college kid.

[1:25:06] Jimi: Because that's where the vocabulary comes from.

[1:25:09] Tommy: Um, and you know, we make fun of it too all the time. The I think that's that's also part of this too. It's why we start with Crazy Town. Like some art is stupid, and you can't tell me why it's stupid, but it feels stupid.

[1:25:27] Jimi: Um you know, it is the reason we have art, whether it's musical theater or a Joni Mitchell album or a photo or a painting, is because we are trying to express something we can't do through words.

[1:25:44] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:25:44] Jimi: And so when we try to do that backwards, it's difficult.

[1:25:48] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.

[1:25:50] Jimi: Exactly.

[1:25:51] Tommy: Um, but it's fun to get there.

[1:25:55] Jimi: Um he plunged them inside it as my world split escape.

[1:26:09] Tommy: We made love and sign now on the other.

[1:26:13] Jimi: And speaking of Justin Positions, it's a lot of fun.

[1:26:16] Tommy: Yeah, but surprisingly, there's still like seven more songs in the show.

[1:26:18] Jimi: Yeah, exactly. Um what I think is so great is so we've just had this huge deep metaphysical chat about being like, you know, just feel it, just feel it on the surface, and then we get a song about a vampire.

[1:26:31] Tommy: Yeah, which is basically about a vampire.

[1:26:34] Jimi: Well done, my because that is smart. You know, he's not then I know I've just said this about art, but here's this really deep concept that you're probably gonna find that you're having to muse over. No, this is just literally a song about a vampire.

[1:26:45] Tommy: It's called Twisted Teeth.

[1:26:46] Jimi: Um the photo is like a it's a it's a quad trick as opposed to a triptych. I don't know.

[1:26:52] Tommy: Is it is it uh quad trick is affirming that up if it's the same thing mirrored?

[1:26:59] Jimi: Yeah, I don't know.

[1:27:00] Tommy: So it's it's the same image four times, mirrored back and forth.

[1:27:05] Jimi: Yeah, um, and it's a a really I can't make out any describable forms in this. Um looks like bats.

[1:27:13] Tommy: Yeah, it's it's an ambery, orangey kind of what is it, buke buke, like that might be the term.

[1:27:23] Jimi: Yeah, is that how you say that?

[1:27:25] Tommy: Uh yeah, or a booky, yeah, uh-huh.

[1:27:27] Jimi: That sort of thing. Like light shine at light shined at the camera, refracting through the lens, creating floating orbs of light.

[1:27:36] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:27:37] Jimi: You know, in a weird, scratchy, orangey, ambery kind of world.

[1:27:41] Tommy: So I've looked at the I've looked at the high qual quality version and it's trees, it's tree branches.

[1:27:46] Jimi: Trees?

[1:27:46] Tommy: I can't see that at the end of the day. Tree branches, but together as a foursome. It does look like bats or spiders or you know, something dark, and it's dark and red. It's quite abstract for sure.

[1:27:56] Jimi: Yep.

[1:27:59] Tommy: Um and the song's about a vampire.

[1:28:03] Jimi: And a love song about a vampire.

[1:28:05] Tommy: Really?

[1:28:05] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:28:06] Tommy: Yeah, it's like um Twilight, the musical.

[1:28:10] Jimi: Don't say those words.

[1:28:11] Tommy: It'll happen.

[1:28:12] Jimi: Um it will have happened at some point. But yeah, no, I mean it is this is the maybe this was the paving step to Fifty Shades of Grey. Um from a from a lady to her mister, her vampire, and about how they go on their love-shaped vampire killing spree.

[1:28:32] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:28:32] Jimi: It's like uh yeah, it's like the opening scene in American Horror Story Hotel.

[1:28:37] Tommy: With Lady Gaga and Matt Bowmer.

[1:28:42] Jimi: You know, when you put these words together in that order, the world we live in sounds so strange.

[1:28:48] Tommy: It does, isn't it?

[1:28:49] Jimi: And oh you're so not perfect.

[1:28:55] Tommy: Yeah, oh Let me count the wings.

[1:29:01] Jimi: But oh Hemming and Hawing.

[1:29:06] Tommy: Hemming and hawing.

[1:29:08] Jimi: Sung by Radio and Lonely.

[1:29:11] Tommy: Yeah, very strange.

[1:29:12] Jimi: And the photo is we're on a children's playground on a swing. In winter, uh, there's a man and a woman in appropriate winter clothing. The woman is sitting on the right hand swing facing away from us, um, and the man is cl a little closer to us on the left facing away from her, so towards us a little off.

[1:29:32] Tommy: Um and it's all very orange. The sky is orange, the world is orange.

[1:29:37] Jimi: And he looks sad.

[1:29:39] Tommy: And he looks sad.

[1:29:40] Jimi: Um it doesn't look it is nighttime, but it doesn't look it.

[1:29:45] Tommy: Mm-hmm.

[1:29:46] Jimi: Yeah, I know what you mean by that.

[1:29:48] Tommy: Light pollution.

[1:29:49] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:29:50] Tommy: Um and really yeah, this is a this is a tricky song. If this was the one that came after, um, why must we tell them why?

[1:29:59] Jimi: Yeah, you'd be like, oh, I understand.

[1:30:01] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:30:01] Jimi: Um afraid to ask.

[1:30:04] Tommy: Uh uh.

[1:30:04] Jimi: This is a tricky one, and and it i maybe the one that I relate to the most.

[1:30:09] Tommy: Okay, tell me more.

[1:30:11] Jimi: Um, just again, just kind of personal let's get let's get some personal chat on the go. Um, but no, I've I've I've totally been there. I've stayed in relationships when I really shouldn't. Um because I go back and forth and back and forth, and at the time it feels great, and it's like you know, particularly with long distance relationships, um, where when you're together, it's great and it's fab and it's awesome, and you can kind of idealize everything, but then two days after they've left again, yeah you're just back to being depressed.

[1:30:47] Tommy: Um and it it's that i it takes a lot to make that decision to end something.

[1:30:56] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:30:57] Tommy: Um yeah, I think that's why I think this song really I'm like, God, I I get it.

[1:31:04] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:31:05] Tommy: I mean, I really, really get it.

[1:31:06] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:31:07] Tommy: Uh yeah.

[1:31:08] Jimi: I mean, I think this is a more nuanced kind of song than on Monday in that same kind of world for me.

[1:31:20] Tommy: Mm-hmm.

[1:31:20] Jimi: A more nuanced, interesting take on the exploration of relationships.

[1:31:28] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[1:31:29] Jimi: Um.

[1:31:30] Tommy: So it it doesn't surprise me that you relate to it that much because of that.

[1:31:35] Jimi: Because it has, you know, that nugget to hang on to.

[1:31:40] Tommy: Um you know.

[1:31:43] Jimi: And and I it I what's the right one? I empathize.

[1:31:51] Tommy: Um I haven't been there, but I can see it as a thing that exists, which is I I like that in a song.

[1:32:01] Jimi: I don't want a love song. I don't want my world filled with love songs that all apply to me. Not that this is a love song, but say relationship songs.

[1:32:09] Tommy: Um because I l I it I find the world more interesting assuming that we all live different lives and have different relationships and have different nuances to them.

[1:32:23] Jimi: Um and certainly there are threads that go through and you can experience different things, but we're all individuals.

[1:32:29] Tommy: And so having hemming and hawing, having this kind of discussion of like, are you, you know, will you leave, do you leave, are you getting bored? What what is up with this relationship?

[1:32:42] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:32:42] Tommy: Um thinking about it. It belongs in the show at the very end.

[1:32:50] Jimi: Yeah, definitely.

[1:32:51] Tommy: Yeah, it's it's j it's just really cool. Um it's yeah, it's it's full of ambiguities, it's full of questions, you know, cyclical arguments with yourself.

[1:33:05] Jimi: Um it's it's just so it's just very real.

[1:33:09] Tommy: Like it is very real.

[1:33:11] Jimi: I you know, I mean, most of these things have gone through my head at one point or other.

[1:33:16] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:33:17] Jimi: Um it just particularly the end, like I think it's again, it's it's very raw, but just the goddamn I hate you heart.

[1:33:24] Tommy: Yeah, is that if if everything was just controlled by your head, yeah, things would be so much easier.

[1:33:30] Jimi: Oh yeah.

[1:33:31] Tommy: It'd be so much easier.

[1:33:33] Jimi: Um but there's that part that will always change.

[1:33:38] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:33:39] Jimi: God damn you, dopamine.

[1:33:40] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:33:41] Jimi: Well, and it's the big struggle is that you're you are still in your head enough to know that.

[1:33:48] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.

[1:33:49] Jimi: To like metacognetize it enough to be like, mmm, I hate that I can't do this.

[1:33:55] Tommy: Yep.

[1:33:56] Jimi: Yep.

[1:33:56] Tommy: And it is, it's those, you know, that eternal battle that your head and your heart always has throughout your whole life. Just one time one of them will be winning, and that's the time when it really matters.

[1:34:06] Jimi: Right.

[1:34:07] Tommy: Um it's tricky.

[1:34:09] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:34:09] Tommy: And it's in a song.

[1:34:12] Jimi: Yeah, it's totally.

[1:34:14] Tommy: It's a good one.

[1:34:15] Jimi: But radio in Lonely, I find that interesting.

[1:34:18] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:34:18] Jimi: I mean, I did I would have not known that not having read, you know, this libretto. Um there is something I think that totally plays into your imagined situation of this. Like you hear that song on the radio while you are lonely that puts all these thoughts in your head as you, you know, overthink it on the drive home, or like the all of a sudden all the parts of your world suddenly become about the existential crisis you're having even though they're not.

[1:34:51] Tommy: And there is something even super meta about this these two characters ostensibly being a person thinking about this while listening to a song on the radio, as you, Jimmy, have that reaction to this song that you're listening to.

[1:35:08] Jimi: Yeah, you know.

[1:35:09] Tommy: That's there's that's interesting.

[1:35:12] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:35:13] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:35:14] Jimi: It's funky.

[1:35:16] Tommy: Funky.

[1:35:18] Jimi: Jesse let Jules know what was wrong with him.

[1:35:22] Tommy: And jewels stopped using and binging and kissing his whole life away.

[1:35:31] Jimi: Jules told Jesse he'd die for her.

[1:35:35] Tommy: Which looking back was the right thing to say.

[1:35:44] Jimi: Cut you a piece.

[1:35:47] Tommy: Of this cake?

[1:35:48] Jimi: Why thank you, Tommy.

[1:35:50] Tommy: Now let's look at this photo on the wall.

[1:35:53] Jimi: Am I doing the improv well?

[1:35:55] Tommy: Um You're doing it so well, actually.

[1:35:57] Jimi: You should do you should do it.

[1:35:59] Tommy: You should teach an improv class.

[1:36:00] Jimi: Yes, and um podcast.

[1:36:04] Tommy: Uh correct.

[1:36:06] Jimi: Um so this picture is um well, it's Jay Armstrong Johnson and a female that isn't Betsy Wolf.

[1:36:14] Tommy: I actually don't know who that is.

[1:36:15] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:36:15] Tommy: Um basically are well, it looks like it looks like a couple of things. It definitely feels like it's a road.

[1:36:22] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:36:25] Tommy: Um because you've got uh, well, what would be white line if it hadn't been color corrected.

[1:36:32] Jimi: Yeah um it looks maybe like there are yellow lines in America too.

[1:36:36] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:36:37] Jimi: Oh yeah.

[1:36:38] Tommy: Um and it looks like they might be like listening to the earth or they've just fallen down or something like that.

[1:36:47] Jimi: Jay Armstrong there are two photos next to each other. J Armstrong Johnson's photo appears to be right side up and he's listening to the ground and the ladies' photo is exactly the same mostly but upside down.

[1:37:00] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:37:00] Jimi: So there is this barrier between them.

[1:37:02] Tommy: It's you know what this is this is Rose Tyler and David Tennant.

[1:37:05] Jimi: Um I talk to me but don't talk to me about Doomsday.

[1:37:09] Tommy: Don't do that to me.

[1:37:13] Jimi: This is the best oh my god that will always make me cry that piece of music.

[1:37:17] Tommy: Let's just stop for a second talk about Doctor Who's it.

[1:37:20] Jimi: This is like the the angsty Jimmy podcast today.

[1:37:23] Tommy: Oh absolutely by the way that uh the oh my god thinking back to the reaction that I had to that oh I I opened up a can of worms.

[1:37:33] Jimi: Dark like there's not many times that I've reacted that much to anything. Um it was it was hefty. Cut You a Piece is sung by a friend of Jules and Jesse who are ostensibly these characters in this photo.

[1:37:49] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:37:50] Jimi: Um and you know it starts by sort of describing their relationship as you know a little bit dysfunctional but it works and uh at one point Jules told Jesse that he'd die for her, um, which looking back was the right thing to say. Um, and that comes into play uh later. Um so basically um this friend describes uh how basically Jules ended up killing Jesse by accident in a car crash. Um and then kind of reflects on it in his in his own life, I guess.

[1:38:28] Tommy: Um, it is it is interest it is a narrative story, but where it it is like a third person omniscient narrative story, but where then we hear about hear from the narrator singing it and how he reacts to this story.

[1:38:56] Jimi: Um it's like one of the last stanzas of the song um where he sings about thinking about this awful awful story of a husband losing his wife in a car crash while he was driving makes him so scared that he might lose his lover. Um which is that is touching and sad and adult and you know hard to talk about a little bit.

[1:39:26] Tommy: Yeah, it is because that's the thing if you know if it is his friend and he's he's musing on their relationship, then that in its own right is is difficult, but kind of using that to talk about or talk to the person that he loves and kind of use that as an example is is it's dark.

[1:39:46] Jimi: It's dark.

[1:39:47] Tommy: And it it is what are you gonna say?

[1:39:50] Jimi: Well, I was just gonna say, what do you think about the cut cut you a piece of me?

[1:39:55] Tommy: Yeah, I mean it's it's you know it's a it's a it's a harsh metaphor for the feelings we feel about the people we love and the people we care about. Like I'm going to literally give you a piece of me, and so if you were to leave me, that piece will be gone. Um that's you know, and like and that makes you precious to me, and that's okay, and that's and I care about you enough to do that.

[1:40:29] Jimi: Um there's also something very visceral about I cut you a piece of me.

[1:40:34] Tommy: Um Yeah, it is.

[1:40:35] Jimi: It's very, very visceral.

[1:40:37] Tommy: And to the point where I'm like, I don't I don't know, I've not worked, I've not worked this one out.

[1:40:43] Jimi: Well, especially juxtapose, like they're playing on a lot of, you know, their their relationship started and ended with broken glass, which is you know, it's a it's a sad ha ha joke because they got married at a temple and you crush a glass when you get married, and then yeah, the car crash.

[1:40:56] Tommy: Um, which there's something playing on that there, and also just the imagery of a car crash, which is you know, the the most appropriate use of the word brutal.

[1:41:08] Jimi: Um this is a also a love song.

[1:41:15] Tommy: No, it definitely is, but it's it's it feels very it just feels very intense.

[1:41:19] Jimi: I don't know it it's not as as beautiful as something is like the seraph.

[1:41:24] Tommy: Yeah you know, I mean it's there's yeah it comes from a darker place.

[1:41:29] Jimi: And it gets what what gets me, what makes me sad about this, this isn't the ballad of Jules and Jesse, right? This isn't let me tell you this tragic tale.

[1:41:39] Tommy: This is I know this tragic tale, and it makes me so preemptively sad about what might happen to us.

[1:41:49] Jimi: Um that's different than like, oh, I'll tell you a tale of a bad thing that happened, you know?

[1:41:56] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:41:57] Jimi: No, definitely, but I just feel it's like cutting cutting you a piece of me and then asking, cut me a piece of you.

[1:42:04] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:42:05] Jimi: Is is quite a lot. If someone said that to me, I wouldn't be like, gosh, that's a beautiful sentiment. I'd be like, please don't self-harm.

[1:42:12] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:42:13] Jimi: Like that's at first what I thought it was gonna be about.

[1:42:16] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:42:16] Jimi: I mean But then it never got there.

[1:42:18] Tommy: And I was like, This is why I'm interested.

[1:42:20] Jimi: And when when we hit our our well-teased Is This a Song cycle, um putting Cut You a Piece next to make me happy in like not physically, but in the same show.

[1:42:32] Tommy: Mm-hmm.

[1:42:33] Jimi: It were the exploration of relationships and what they mean in this, and in between those two songs in a couple other places.

[1:42:42] Tommy: Is I've said interesting a lot. It's interesting.

[1:42:45] Jimi: It fascinates me.

[1:42:46] Tommy: Yeah, it's cool.

[1:42:48] Jimi: Yours is interesting.

[1:42:49] Tommy: There we go, we got our words.

[1:42:50] Jimi: There we go.

[1:42:51] Tommy: You taste the silver spara, you taste the crown, you first of the roses in here.

[1:42:59] Jimi: You swallow the scepter music crown, you queen of my school!

[1:43:10] Tommy: Down on your knees, me for the queen!

[1:43:18] Jimi: Down on your knees, me for the queen.

[1:43:23] Tommy: And here we are.

[1:43:24] Jimi: Hey Luke!

[1:43:25] Tommy: It's the last picture.

[1:43:26] Jimi: It's the last exposure.

[1:43:31] Tommy: That's a it's an appropriate song for this song, the ballad of Sarah Barry.

[1:43:35] Jimi: I I really like this song, Jimmy.

[1:43:38] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:43:39] Jimi: I mean, even you would say this is a Bob.

[1:43:41] Tommy: Oh yeah.

[1:43:42] Jimi: Oh yeah, this is a Bob.

[1:43:43] Tommy: It's an appropriate Bob.

[1:43:44] Jimi: This is totally this is this is Heather's the musical, the song.

[1:43:49] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.

[1:43:49] Jimi: That's like I'm very excited for the sort of Rosencratz and Gilderstone are dead version of you know Sarah Berry.

[1:43:55] Tommy: I'm I'm excited for someone to turn this whole thing into a show.

[1:43:59] Jimi: Um so basically it's about uh oh well the picture um is cool.

[1:44:04] Tommy: It's uh eight girls.

[1:44:06] Jimi: Um the first one is uh sort of Wednesday Adams style uh girl with her face circled with a red marker, yeah um, and then six of the girls have their faces all scribbled out, um, and the last one has her leg scribbled off.

[1:44:23] Tommy: Yeah, and they're they're like high school girls in a high school hallway, all photographed in like Xerox black and white.

[1:44:30] Jimi: Yeah, with this red sharpie marker highlighter over them in various places.

[1:44:36] Tommy: Um and the song is basically about uh a girl called Sarah Berry, who is a popular bitch, um, and was all ready to become the uh homecoming queen.

[1:44:48] Jimi: Is that prom queen?

[1:44:50] Tommy: Um are they different things by the way? Or is it just different you just get different queens?

[1:44:54] Jimi: They're you could you could conceptualize them as the same dance for you.

[1:44:58] Tommy: Um homecoming generally is uh big football game of the year, which is in the fall.

[1:45:05] Jimi: And prom is generally not related to a sporting event and happens in the spring near the end of the year, and is big senior celebration.

[1:45:15] Tommy: It's a bit it's like the beginning of senior send-off kind of.

[1:45:18] Jimi: Okay.

[1:45:23] Tommy: So this is prom.

[1:45:25] Jimi: This is prom.

[1:45:27] Tommy: Yeah, so she is the popular girl.

[1:45:29] Jimi: She's the one that you know is gonna get it.

[1:45:31] Tommy: She's the Regina George, blah blah blah blah.

[1:45:34] Jimi: But then Julie Jenkins lost her leg in a wreck.

[1:45:37] Tommy: Yep.

[1:45:38] Jimi: And so, you know, it's kind of got the sympathy vote.

[1:45:41] Tommy: Um, and basically Sarah's uh, you know, through kind of parental pressure, uh, is campaigning to do whatever she can to get this queendom because it's it's the thing that means the most.

[1:45:56] Tommy: Yeah, um, and it's you know, that uh that in itself is a trope that we see quite a lot in many high school dramas.

[1:46:02] Jimi: What we don't often see though is um uh serial killer style onslaught, yeah, um where she goes around murdering all of this is like if Carrie didn't have special powers.

[1:46:14] Tommy: Um, in some ways, yeah.

[1:46:20] Jimi: Uh so yeah, basically she goes around and and kills all of the other potentials, um and uh but it is then gets carted off to the madhouse.

[1:46:33] Tommy: Yeah, in a in a true minor key bop fashion.

[1:46:36] Jimi: I mean, you know, there's the balladier begin like it's almost a rap.

[1:46:40] Tommy: Julie Jenkins lost her leg in a wreck, and the chorus goes, emp you did like this is it is it is uncomfortably funny.

[1:46:50] Jimi: Yeah, exactly.

[1:46:50] Tommy: Uh it's it's and is Heather's dark comedy funny.

[1:46:53] Jimi: Like it's oh yeah, like it's it's a lot of it's fun, and it's a good like kind of like tongue-in-cheek, cheesy end.

[1:47:01] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:47:02] Jimi: Do you know what I mean?

[1:47:02] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.

[1:47:04] Jimi: Which again I really like because it's it it almost like it mirrors back to crazy time, you know what I mean, where that's like the adolescent becoming an adult.

[1:47:13] Tommy: Here we have just pure adolescence.

[1:47:17] Jimi: Right.

[1:47:17] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:47:18] Jimi: Do you know what I mean?

[1:47:19] Tommy: Like uncontrolled adolescence.

[1:47:21] Jimi: Yeah, exactly.

[1:47:23] Tommy: Uh and it's good.

[1:47:26] Jimi: I think it's like it's probably it's probably one of the most popular songs, I think, from 35mm.

[1:47:31] Tommy: I feel like it's a catchy song.

[1:47:32] Jimi: It it is less deep than a lot of the other songs in the show.

[1:47:37] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[1:47:38] Jimi: Yeah, there's no there's no metaphor.

[1:47:39] Tommy: It's it's a story, but there's no yeah.

[1:47:42] Jimi: Well, no, I guess I guess there is there's the element of the parental pressure.

[1:47:45] Tommy: Uh yeah, I guess that's true.

[1:47:46] Jimi: Um you can reflect on the fact that uh that's something that you know happens quite a lot in high schools and um yeah, you know, parents do put a lot of pressure on their kids, and that's where it comes from in these the what the you know the warning tale, but it's to the point of ridiculous that hopefully it won't happen.

[1:48:09] Tommy: Hopefully.

[1:48:15] Jimi: A flower plugged from its bed.

[1:48:18] Tommy: Used in just paper dead on paper red But yeah, for some things for us and what's trapped inside.

[1:48:39] Jimi: And in the world I see on Does something try to respond.

[1:48:42] Tommy: It's still an honor Fleet Once.

[1:48:54] Jimi: Okay, let's talk about it.

[1:48:57] Tommy: One, do we come to any conclusions?

[1:49:00] Jimi: And two, is this a song cycle?

[1:49:03] Tommy: If not, what is this?

[1:49:05] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:49:06] Tommy: So I think this is a musical exhibition.

[1:49:11] Jimi: Um I don't think it's a song cycle.

[1:49:13] Tommy: I don't think there's any uh through thought, I don't think there's any deep meaning that links the whole thing together.

[1:49:19] Jimi: I think it's just um a series of what, 17 vignettes uh that each mean their own thing, and you can sit and you can look at them and you can muse on them and you don't think there's anything that ties these all together?

[1:49:36] Tommy: Um, other than their human stories.

[1:49:39] Jimi: Okay.

[1:49:40] Tommy: Huh.

[1:49:41] Jimi: Okay, so I'm I'm being mean, but you've said that Songs for a New World is a song cycle.

[1:49:48] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:49:49] Jimi: What's maybe it's easier, what's the difference?

[1:49:52] Tommy: So for me, Songs for a New World was written um specifically to link these things together.

[1:50:00] Jimi: Um so you've got this idea in Songs for a New World, it's all about starting something new, it's all about going forward.

[1:50:08] Tommy: Right.

[1:50:09] Jimi: Do you know what I mean?

[1:50:09] Tommy: And that's a that is a vagary.

[1:50:11] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:50:12] Tommy: Absolutely.

[1:50:13] Jimi: And there is definitely a songbook element to Songs for New World.

[1:50:15] Tommy: But I think for this, it's unabashedly just different things.

[1:50:21] Jimi: But how how is Songs for a New World being songs about starting something or adventure or whatever that vagueness is different from 35mm being songs about adulthood, maybe, or um relationships.

[1:50:37] Tommy: Um that kind of thing.

[1:50:41] Jimi: Yeah, I mean, no, sure, absolutely.

[1:50:44] Tommy: But what I think with Songs for a New World, yeah, the there are they are linked together.

[1:50:51] Jimi: Do you know what I mean?

[1:50:52] Tommy: Like that's they have been written that way.

[1:50:54] Jimi: Um whereas I don't I just don't think these are.

[1:50:57] Tommy: And so I think the fact that these are more standalone and are linked with these standalone pictures make it stand out on its own thing, you know?

[1:51:07] Jimi: I think I think we will just flat disagree on this.

[1:51:10] Tommy: I also think there's, you know, we could we could write several books on like what really is a song cycle, because I think the answer is it's like it's whatever you want it to be.

[1:51:21] Jimi: Uh-huh.

[1:51:22] Tommy: You know, I do I do a cabaret in my local pub. That's a song cycle because I've chosen to put songs together.

[1:51:28] Jimi: Do you know exactly? In many so yeah, okay, in that respect, it's a song cycle, but yeah, I don't want to just it's not it's not an ordinary days, it's not a song for New World. To me, it's something cooler.

[1:51:39] Tommy: Right, well, I don't I wouldn't qualify ordinary days as a song cycle. Um but this, like, as opposed to being a cabaret, you know, as opposed to being the songs of Ryan Scott Oliver.

[1:51:56] Jimi: Um to me a song cycle has just a scintillomore of effort behind the arranging of the songs and the putting them all together in one night than a cabaret. Um, even the fact that we hear every once in a while a reprise between one or two things, or that we have transitions between stuff pushes me more into the world of these songs are next to each other in an intentional order at the same time in the same night as a part of the same performance to make them one cohesive work of art. You know, I feel like if you start poking at the Jenga bricks and pulling one song here or there out of this show, it is a different show. It is less of a show.

[1:52:55] Tommy: Completely, but in the same way I'm a photographer and I'm curating an exhibition. Yeah, I'm gonna pick the photos that I want to put into that exhibition to you know for for that for that exact reason. Do you know what I mean?

[1:53:12] Jimi: Yeah. So I mean that just I think to me that just reads a song cycle. I think that's where our disagreement comes from about what a song cycle is.

[1:53:19] Tommy: Which let's be honest, no one knows. I would say, yeah, well, what I would just say is I think um when you think of a song cycle, you do think of something trying to link them all together. Do you know what I mean? Whether it's a musical theme, whether it's something like that. I just feel with this it's you're totally allowed to just take them bit by bit.

[1:53:37] Jimi: Yeah. Do you know what I mean? And that's not something that's been done that much. Do you know, yeah.

[1:53:43] Tommy: Yeah, I mean, I would, you know, what I'd throw back to you in my main way is I think you could do that with songs for a new world. You could, you could, but I feel like there is Jason Robert Brown would be disappointed in you.

[1:53:56] Jimi: Yeah. I do know what I mean. Uh well, I guess what I'm saying is Ryan Scott Oliver is disappointed in you. That's all I'm doing. That's I'm just saying that's a good thing.

[1:54:04] Tommy: No, just from what he said about the show, yeah, I I don't think so because he he said that it's you know these are these it's a collection of photographs.

[1:54:17] Jimi: Yeah, but it's a collection. Do you know what I mean?

[1:54:19] Tommy: Yeah, but there's no do you know what I mean? It's not like the theme is this, and this Carolee is linked to Twisted Teeth because do you know what I mean?

[1:54:29] Jimi: Okay, yes. That yeah. Alright.

[1:54:33] Tommy: Do you like just like Leave Luanne and Hemming and Hawing Right? Do you know like there's these independent moments.

[1:54:42] Jimi: But hemming and hawing and make me happy, or the seraph and Mama Let Me In. Um Right, okay. But maybe I'm implying that. But maybe I think I'd I think that's it. I I mean I what I like the thing it what attracts me so much to 35mm is the fact that you can just look at them as their own individual things and have different feelings. You don't need to be like, and at the end of this, it's all summed up neatly in this little bow. Whereas Songs for New World, you're supposed to leave thinking, I'm thinking hope. I'm thinking about it. All those adventurers.

[1:55:18] Tommy: Yeah, I'll give you that for sure. Do you know what I mean? That's what I like about this is it's just like moments in time.

[1:55:23] Jimi: Yeah. And that to me that's Casco.

[1:55:25] Tommy: Yeah. Again. Um what I do want to say is a kind of coda. Uh huh. Um, I do want to talk about Ryan Scott Oliver because um he's someone that more people should talk about.

[1:55:40] Jimi: For for sure. Um he like extr extremely excites me. In in everything that he writes. Like I'm very much the first thing I ever listened to is with Jasper in Deadland. Because I fancied Matt Doyle. And I was like, I wonder what he sounds like. And then I was just extremely surprised because I was like, this is freaky. This is odd. This is so odd. And if you've listened to this podcast, you would know that I love odd shit. Whether it's odd for the sake of being odd and just trying something, or whether it's doing it beautifully and artistically to make sense, then that's what I love.

[1:56:20] Tommy: I would say 35mm is actually only kind of scratching the surface of what Ryan Scott Oliver can do. You definitely see lots of glimpses of it. But he on Spotify there's a uh I mean, what does he call it? He calls it a um a short or brief musical allegory. Other body, a brief musical allegory.

[1:56:45] Jimi: Oh, I don't I don't know that. Um yeah, so it's basically uh I mean it's six songs all kind of run into each other. It's one sort of it's like an epic poem. I mean, it's it's that kind of thing. Um and it's kind of talking about the importance of telling stories and the importance of passing things on and learning from mistakes and you know, environmentalism, like it's a proper allegory, like it's a proper artistic thing, and I think this is something that he is extremely good at, and uh there's in the kind of musical theatre sphere at the moment, there's not many people I feel who are as good at telling stories like this.

[1:57:32] Tommy: Like I'd be inclined to say someone like um yeah, like Duncan Sheik, yeah, again is very good at writing in metaphor and painting these really pictures.

[1:57:42] Jimi: If you took the names out, you could have been describing Dave Malloy too.

[1:57:46] Tommy: Um yeah, I d yeah, I think I see that I see the differences you're talking about, but yeah, there's something I could totally I could totally pinch my especially when it comes to like experimental music, yeah.

[1:57:58] Jimi: Um but he writes in in like deep like poetic allegory, yeah. Do you know what I mean? Um, and but what I think is is so good, and you can tell it in here, you know, there's only really like two songs in this whole show that are solos, yeah. Um, and he uses vocals, yeah, so interestingly to really create an atmosphere to create a feeling, um, and no one else is doing it, and I find it very exciting.

[1:58:31] Tommy: Yeah, it's not like the chorus people trot themselves out whenever they you know the town's folk need to come singing the song, like there are voices that exist sometimes.

[1:58:40] Jimi: Yeah, he's he's kind of unashamed, like and I uh you know the art he's not he's not creating a new thing, like I would say like someone like Andrew Lippa does it or Steven Schwartz does it, yeah, but I feel like he where they go, he will go that little step further to be a bit like well I'm gonna just see what this sounds like. It sounds pretty cool. We're gonna go with that. Do you know what I mean? Um so yeah, I I've I implore people to listen to Otherbot A and kind of let me know what you think because it's just it's it's cool. I'm saying it again, it's cool. He's a cool guy.

[1:59:16] Tommy: Um, and I'm very so Darling is the the kind of dark Peter Pan uh rehash, and that's kind of I think that's currently in development.

[1:59:26] Jimi: Okay. Yeah, he's yeah, a good a good a good hit. He's exciting, yeah.

[1:59:36] Tommy: Uh-huh. It's exciting. Um, and he works with good people. Like, well, for sure. I mean look at 35mm.

[1:59:45] Jimi: I know. And it's so, I mean, like, you just have to look at this roster. So, you know, you've got Betsy Wolf who is kind of she's starting to really pick up speed. Um, you know, she was in Falsettos, she's gonna be in Carousel, she's gonna be great. Um, Alex Brightman, School of Rock, School of Right, uh G. Armstrong Johnson again is picking up speed, um, you know, he's in on the town, hands on a hard body, and uh and Jimmy's Dreams, um, and then um I get I get I but yeah, there you go with Lindsay Mendes. It's like why is she still not had a leading role? Like it's really frustrating.

[2:00:21] Jimi: She need like we were we were talking about this when we were prepping for this podcast. Like I've had requests forever about 35mm for like show of the weekend for the podcast, like they come in all the time. But for how popular this musical seems in our world, it does not have a fan following that some of the other cult favorites do.

[2:00:48] Tommy: There's not a lot of, you know, 35mm tumblers out there in the same way as there are Heather's tumblers out there.

[2:00:54] Jimi: Yeah, exactly. But I mean, Be More Chill was out for like a year and a half before it caught the wave.

[2:01:00] Tommy: That's true. So, you know, maybe I guess five years is quite a long time, but maybe it's just needs, you know, one person. Ben Platt needs to be like, this is cool, and then suddenly the world will explode over 35mm.

[2:01:13] Jimi: Don't sell yourself short. Maybe a mildly popular musical theater podcast needs to talk about 35mm.

[2:01:20] Tommy: I think we do have the same weight as Ben Platt.

[2:01:23] Jimi: Yeah. I mean, if we he stood on one side of a scale and we stood on the other side of a scale.

[2:01:28] Tommy: No, that's not true at all.

[2:01:32] Jimi: No.

[2:01:32] Tommy: But yeah, so if you're in London, go and see the production. Um that's on, it's on at the other palace.

[2:01:40] Jimi: Yeah. Um and tell us all about it.

[2:01:42] Tommy: Yeah, please do, because I'm not gonna make it down in time.

[2:01:45] Jimi: Um I'm certainly not gonna make it down in time.

[2:01:49] Tommy: We certainly are not. Uh yeah, it's I don't know. I just he's an exciting man, is Ransco Oliver. He excites me. And he always wears a baseball cap, and I really appreciate that.

[2:02:01] Jimi: I hope I hope your your future husband is taking notes out there. You have quite quite the interesting laundry list.

[2:02:11] Tommy: This isn't the podcast. There's been too many home tours.

[2:02:13] Jimi: I'll punch you in the face when I wake up.

[2:03:14] Tommy: That was 35mm a musical exhibition.

[2:03:15] Tommy: You should wear it, yeah.

[2:03:17] Jimi: Yeah. Only listens to songs about vampires on the train.

[2:03:18] Jimi: I am so drunk on free sparkling wine.

[2:03:21] Tommy: Absolutely. You know.

[2:03:21] Tommy: And I'm just dead because I've been drinking development fluid this whole night.

[2:03:24] Jimi: Yeah, exactly. That was so silly.

[2:03:25] Jimi: Hi, um.

[2:03:27] Tommy: You weren't even offering that. You just brought that yourself.

[2:03:29] Jimi: Well, yeah. I thought it would said BYO DF on the invitation.

[2:03:34] Tommy: Bring your once again. A B is a DF. Classic Tommy.

[2:03:39] Jimi: Classic Tommy. Hey, what are we doing next week?

[2:03:42] Tommy: I got the quits question. You ready?

[2:03:45] Jimi: Yeah.

[2:03:46] Tommy: Some people argue that this next musical features the music of Felix Mendelssohn and his violin concerto, an E minor. Mendelssohn remains uncredited in this musical to this day. What show, Jimmy?

[2:04:00] Jimi: I feel like you may be one of those people, Tommy.

[2:04:03] Tommy: Don't argue that.

[2:04:04] Jimi: I'm always one of those people. When in doubt, I'm one of those people.

[2:04:09] Tommy: You are.

[2:04:10] Jimi: If you would like to get in touch with us, you can. Come over and find me on Twitter at As in Hendricks and YouTube at the same handle.

[2:04:20] Tommy: And I'm MusicalMash on Twitter and Musical TheatreMash on YouTube, or you can check out our show Twitter, Jim and Tomic, or the website, Jim and Tomic.com.

[2:04:28] Jimi: Which has a link to our fabulous Reddit discussion where we'll be chatting up a storm.

[2:04:33] Tommy: I feel like there'd be lots of chat this time because there's lots of things to talk about.

[2:04:36] Jimi: Yeah, we talked about lots of things, that's for sure.

[2:04:39] Tommy: We absolutely did. That's what happens when you go to an art gallery, you know?

[2:04:43] Jimi: You talk about all things.

[2:04:46] Tommy: Yeah, exactly. And you get drunk on free wine.

[2:04:50] Jimi: Um sparkling wine, sorry. Um, and hey, we shall see you next week.

[2:04:58] Tommy: Correct. Sand sandwiches.

[2:05:00] Jimi: Did I do that right?

[2:05:02] Tommy: You did. Absolutely.

[2:05:04] Jimi: Bye bye.

[2:05:05] Tommy: Bye.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred