Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Happy Hour #54: How to Podcast  - ‘How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying’

Discuss on Reddit ➤ Support the Show ➤ The boys are back in town and they're diving straight into the self-help musical ‘How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying!’ This time around Jimi and Tommy try and fit ‘How to Succeed’ in a contemporary setting in spite of its blatant misogyny, Jimi muses on whether Bob Fosse is the real reason this show is so successful with the critics and together they work out how to get a Pulitzer prize... Read More

From the show: Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour

1 h 23 mins
4/18/18

About

Discuss on Reddit ➤

Support the Show ➤

The boys are back in town and they're diving straight into the self-help musical ‘How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying!’ This time around Jimi and Tommy try and fit ‘How to Succeed’ in a contemporary setting in spite of its blatant misogyny, Jimi muses on whether Bob Fosse is the real reason this show is so successful with the critics and together they work out how to get a Pulitzer prize.

How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying (Original Broadway Cast Recording)

Amazon / iTunes / Spotify

SHOW NOTES

We’ve missed you all so much! Come and let us know what you’ve been up to for the past 6 months over on Twitter!

Our 21st century ‘How To Succeed’ is easily the TV show ‘Mad Men’ which takes the extant misogyny of the 1960s and puts it in the driving seat. Here’s the show’s creator sitting down with Larry King to talk all about it.

For all you law aficionados out there, check out employment law Professor Miriam Cherry’s paper comparing the content of ‘How to Succeed’ with the Civil Rights Act of 1964 - who said musical theatre wasn’t relevant in the real world?

When you think ‘How to Succeed’ the last thing you think about is Bob Fosse - but he was there! However, if you watch ‘A Secretary is Not a Toy’ you can he his flexed-footed stamp is well and truly there!

Why do you think ‘How to Succeed’ won the Pulitzer prize for drama? Come over to Reddit and tell us!

A BROOKLYNITE QUIZ QUESTION

The folk-singer-author of our next musical has shared studio space with friend-of-the-podcast Dave Malloy. And her artistic connections clearly reflect this. What show?

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Jimi: I'm ex I'm gonna be accompanied by the ghost of Jacob Marelli this entire time.

[0:04] Tommy: Yeah, very topical again.

[0:06] Jimi: Thank you.

[0:06] Tommy: Thank you.

[0:07] Jimi: It's Christmas.

[0:08] Tommy: I think.

[0:09] Jimi: I think like if we're we're doing this in time, it probably is like Christmas is coming.

[0:13] Tommy: Based on our time scale, yeah.

[0:15] Jimi: Exactly.

[0:16] Tommy: Absolutely.

[0:16] Jimi: I'm excited to see what happens.

[0:20] Tommy: Um yeah.

[0:22] Jimi: So right, what do we do again?

[0:24] Tommy: Okay.

[0:28] Jimi: Welcome back to Jim and Tomic's musical theater happy hour, your weekly podcast with cocktails and comebacks.

[0:34] Tommy: Comebacks as in us coming back, not like witty retorts.

[0:38] Jimi: But also witty retorts.

[0:40] Tommy: Because we're witty and I retort every chance I get.

[0:45] Jimi: Absolutely, as you should.

[0:47] Tommy: As you should.

[0:49] Jimi: Um hey, what were you drinking today, Tommy?

[0:52] Tommy: Today I'm drinking a martini with two olives.

[0:56] Jimi: A double.

[0:59] Tommy: That is apparently how you're supposed to do it.

[1:01] Jimi: Um while I'm drinking coffee.

[1:04] Tommy: Oh no, wait, there's none left.

[1:07] Jimi: I've gone insane.

[1:09] Tommy: It's jokes.

[1:10] Jimi: Jokes, we got plenty.

[1:12] Tommy: We got hunters.

[1:14] Jimi: Um, so last week uh You can't even say that with a straight face last week.

[1:22] Tommy: Uh so six months ago.

[1:24] Jimi: We thought we'd give you uh a wee bit longer on this uh quiz question.

[1:27] Tommy: It was such a request.

[1:28] Jimi: It was quite a tricky one.

[1:29] Tommy: Um we thought we'd give you a give you a little extra extra pause.

[1:35] Jimi: Um so yeah, well, our quiz question from last time, uh from the You're a Good Man Charlie Brown podcast.

[1:42] Tommy: Was that what it was?

[1:43] Jimi: Um I know exactly.

[1:44] Tommy: It was like it was recorded.

[1:46] Jimi: I think it was recorded around the time the original You're a good man Charlie Brown was was was created, I think.

[1:53] Tommy: So it feels like.

[1:54] Jimi: Um but no, so the quiz question was um our next show, the show we're talking about today, um, is Anderson Cooper's only Broadway credit.

[2:02] Tommy: What show could that thank goodness he didn't do anything between when we recorded that show in this show?

[2:10] Jimi: Yeah, exactly.

[2:11] Tommy: Thank you, Anderson Cooper.

[2:13] Jimi: We're eternally grateful.

[2:14] Tommy: What show could it possibly be, Jimmy?

[2:17] Jimi: It could possibly be how to succeed in business without really trying.

[2:23] Tommy: Name's gonna get tiresome real fast.

[2:25] Jimi: Yes.

[2:26] Tommy: How to apply for a job.

[2:29] Jimi: How to advance from the mail room.

[2:31] Tommy: How to sit down at a desk.

[2:34] Jimi: How to dictate memorandums.

[2:37] Tommy: How to develop executive style.

[2:41] Jimi: How to commute in a three-button suit with that weary executive smile.

[2:49] Tommy: This book is all that I need.

[2:52] Jimi: How to how to succeed.

[2:57] Tommy: How to observe personnel.

[3:00] Jimi: How to select tune to lunch with.

[3:03] Tommy: How to avoid petty friends.

[3:06] Jimi: How to in general.

[3:08] Tommy: Hooray.

[3:09] Jimi: Okay, so How to Succeed opened all the way back in 1961 on Broadway.

[3:15] Tommy: Seminal classic.

[3:16] Jimi: It has music and lyrics by Frank Lesser, who you know from Guys and Dolls and a bunch of other things.

[3:22] Tommy: And book by a whole big committee, Abe Burroughs, Jack Weinstock, and Willie Gilbert, which is a great name.

[3:30] Jimi: I mean, what a name.

[3:33] Tommy: Um and it was based on the book of the same title, How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying, uh, by Mr. Shepard Mead.

[3:39] Jimi: Mm-hmm.

[3:41] Tommy: It played for a long time, several years.

[3:43] Jimi: Hundred 1,417 performance.

[3:46] Tommy: Um it won seven Tony Awards and was difficult to compete with for a while because it won um best conductor, which is not a category anymore.

[3:56] Jimi: So it should be.

[3:57] Tommy: It should be.

[3:58] Jimi: I never thought about that, but why isn't that a you know conductors do stuff?

[4:02] Tommy: I think it's because they swap out conductors a lot.

[4:05] Jimi: Um but this is so it this show won a pulser, Jimmy.

[4:08] Tommy: I know.

[4:09] Jimi: And actually, who knew?

[4:11] Tommy: Right.

[4:12] Jimi: You read it today and you wonder about it.

[4:14] Tommy: Yeah, we'll be getting into that a little bit later.

[4:17] Jimi: Um they made the film, which was really, really big um in 1967 while it was still going on, I think.

[4:25] Tommy: Maybe close enough.

[4:26] Jimi: Um with a lot of the same cast, though.

[4:28] Tommy: Um then there have been two revivals since the 1995 revival with Matthew Broderick and Megan Malale, both of their big theatrical breakout roles of all things.

[4:38] Jimi: Um then a 50th anniversary revival in 2011, um, with Danny Radcliffe and Broadw or and Tony nominee John Larriquette, which is how they introduce him on every talk show that they perform on.

[4:50] Tommy: It drives me bombs.

[4:51] Jimi: Brilliant.

[4:52] Tommy: That's hilarious.

[4:53] Jimi: But well known for his Tonies.

[4:55] Tommy: Uh who who actually is is he a big American guy?

[4:58] Jimi: He's I mean, he's Tony nominated.

[5:01] Tommy: He's Tony he is nominated for that Tony.

[5:04] Jimi: He's he's an he's an oh that guy.

[5:06] Tommy: Um he was he was big on a sitcom called Night Court, um, which is like a comedy parody, which I I wonder, like I don't even know how I know what Night Court is.

[5:17] Jimi: No one watches Night Court anymore.

[5:18] Tommy: I don't think it's in citation anywhere.

[5:21] Jimi: Um but like Night Court would have been it maybe comparable to something like Parks and Wreck, not in style but in concept, like a comedy about the inner workings of, you know, a court.

[5:35] Tommy: Okay.

[5:36] Jimi: Great.

[5:38] Tommy: Comedian and actor.

[5:39] Jimi: Still working.

[5:39] Tommy: Doing so.

[5:40] Jimi: Is it the the preface of Judge Diddy?

[5:42] Tommy: Is that where she came from?

[5:45] Jimi: Yeah.

[5:46] Tommy: Maybe sparked from the same fascination.

[5:50] Jimi: Cool.

[5:51] Tommy: Excellent.

[5:52] Jimi: Um yeah, and little tiny dad Harry Potter.

[5:55] Tommy: I know, he's so short.

[5:57] Jimi: He's so short.

[5:58] Tommy: He's so short.

[5:59] Jimi: Love him.

[6:00] Tommy: Um okay, so well, how to succeed.

[6:03] Jimi: Um, where's it we get?

[6:04] Basically, like the the self-help book.

[6:07] Tommy: Um, it's found by uh little chap called Jay Pierpont Finch.

[6:12] Jimi: Um and he basically decides I'm gonna use this book to uh climb I was about to say climb the charts, climb the the rungs of the corporate ladder, um and uh succeed.

[6:25] Tommy: Yeah.

[6:25] Jimi: Literally without really trying.

[6:28] Tommy: It is it's all right there in the title, if anything.

[6:31] Jimi: It's no wonder they abbreviate it H2S all the time.

[6:34] Tommy: Or H2 dollar sign.

[6:35] Jimi: H2 dollar sign.

[6:36] Tommy: They were putting the dollar sign in long before Cash How was.

[6:39] Jimi: Um How to Succeed is the original Casha, if any we just made a shesha reference.

[6:45] Tommy: I only got one that's a whip.

[6:51] Jimi: Yeah.

[6:51] Tommy: Yeah, so he climbs the corporate ladder by being by being a little shit.

[6:57] Jimi: Uh basically.

[6:58] Tommy: Yeah.

[6:59] Jimi: And along, you know, uh yeah, along the way, uh there's obviously some subplots in there.

[7:06] Tommy: Um there's the kind of villainous uh nepotism uh nephew of the the boss of the company.

[7:14] Jimi: Um the company which we should say is called was it world worldwide wicks?

[7:18] Tommy: Worldwide wickets.

[7:20] Jimi: Wickets.

[7:21] Tommy: What's a wicket?

[7:22] Jimi: Nobody knows.

[7:23] Tommy: It doesn't matter.

[7:25] Jimi: Exactly.

[7:26] Tommy: Exactly.

[7:27] Jimi: Um and who knows what the company does, but he does really well in it, and everyone wants to be at the top of this company.

[7:32] Tommy: I don't know about you, T, but I really do.

[7:36] Jimi: Um and there's a very, very um kind of uh loose love story in there.

[7:42] Tommy: Uh you know you need one.

[7:47] Jimi: Um it's a it's a sat it's a satire.

[7:52] Tommy: If you haven't seen it before, it's a send-up of like corporate working culture.

[7:57] Jimi: It's intended to be a parody, maybe right on the edge of parody and satire about you know office life in the 60s.

[8:06] Tommy: Very w what would become um the you know madmen style smoking and advertising agency and business executive sort of thing.

[8:18] Jimi: Which I you know, I think that kind of style has come full circle with it, because then with the popularity of madman that infused the 2011 revival and brought it back around, which is fascinating.

[8:29] Tommy: Yeah, and it's it's quite interesting to see them kind of work hand in hand.

[8:32] Jimi: Yeah.

[8:33] Tommy: Um, and how one maybe doesn't help the other.

[8:36] Jimi: Yeah.

[8:37] Tommy: Um so yeah, well, should we dive straight in?

[8:41] Jimi: Let's go for it.

[8:42] Tommy: Should we get in for some gender politics?

[8:44] Jimi: You know you've been wanting it, ladies and gentlemen.

[8:48] Tommy: Woo!

[8:48] Jimi: Oh man.

[8:49] Tommy: Alright.

[8:50] Jimi: Let's go.

[8:51] Tommy: No coffee.

[8:52] Jimi: No coffee.

[8:54] Tommy: That office light doesn't have to be Florasan!

[8:58] Jimi: I'll get no pains in the head.

[9:02] Tommy: That office chair doesn't have to be foam rubber.

[9:07] Jimi: And so if I spread, so I spread.

[9:11] Tommy: But only one chemical substance gets out the lid.

[9:18] Jimi: Like she said.

[9:20] Tommy: If I can take my coffee break.

[9:20] Jimi: My coffee break.

[9:26] Tommy: My coffee break.

[9:28] Jimi: If I can take my coffee break.

[9:33] Tommy: God is the sense of enterprise.

[9:38] Jimi: Something within me.

[9:42] Tommy: No coffee.

[9:43] Jimi: No coffee.

[9:44] Tommy: So I mean, like, first it doesn't, it doesn't take you know, a genius.

[9:48] Jimi: It doesn't take uh uh a genius to really see how I would say, you know, extremely misogynistic.

[10:01] Tommy: Oh man, I mean, analyzing this show has made me not like this show.

[10:05] Jimi: I used to like this show, and I really think I don't anymore.

[10:09] Tommy: Yeah, same.

[10:10] Jimi: Exact same.

[10:11] Tommy: Like it's one of those ones you hear it, you listen to it once, you're like, oh, that was jolly.

[10:15] Jimi: How funny?

[10:16] Tommy: And it's it's well constructed.

[10:18] Jimi: The jokes land really well.

[10:20] Tommy: The book is fantastic for like its construction, but it is sexist AF.

[10:27] Jimi: Yes.

[10:28] Tommy: And so this is this is the kind of thing.

[10:30] Jimi: So like when we talk about it being a satire, I mean we talk about it being a parody, um, that kind of implies that the the tongue is in the cheek, and that you know, the joke's on them, not you.

[10:40] Tommy: Yeah.

[10:41] Jimi: Um, but I don't I don't know how much that's the case in this show.

[10:45] Tommy: It's hard to say, and I wonder if that is well, so I did some digging into some like reviews.

[10:52] Jimi: It's hard to dig up old, old reviews of the original production.

[10:57] Tommy: Um they do there are references to the fact that like we they know that it is sexist in the time.

[11:05] Jimi: Um they knew it was sexist in 1961, but that's not a it's not a like, oh how awful of them, ha ha ha ha ha kind of sexist joke.

[11:17] Tommy: It's like, oh yes, sexism, a thing we regularly practice.

[11:23] Jimi: You're right.

[11:23] Tommy: That is what it's like.

[11:25] Jimi: Exactly.

[11:26] Tommy: Yeah.

[11:27] Jimi: Yeah, I completely agree.

[11:29] Tommy: It is unabashedly uh misogynistic and sexist, and like in a way, like that's where it's hard to judge.

[11:37] Jimi: It is unabashedly misogynistic and sexist in the same way that this whole you know corporate setup of the 1960s is also unabashedly sexist and misogynistic.

[11:49] Tommy: And so, you know, it's it's difficult to discredit the authors on that point because it is very much a reflection of its time.

[11:59] Jimi: Factual.

[12:00] Tommy: Yeah.

[12:01] Jimi: Um, but you know, you're right.

[12:04] Tommy: Can you can you do how to succeed anymore?

[12:07] Jimi: Well, that's that's the thing.

[12:09] Tommy: And it it's quite I don't know, I find it I find that mad men is actually I'm really glad that they existed at the exact same time.

[12:18] Jimi: Yeah.

[12:18] Tommy: Um because it it does kind of allow us to go, huh.

[12:24] Jimi: You know, I mean, the the arms fold and you sit back in your chair as you watch Daniel Radcliffe dance about you're like, yeah.

[12:29] Tommy: Alright, Dan.

[12:30] Jimi: Yeah.

[12:30] Tommy: Exactly.

[12:31] Jimi: See what you got there.

[12:32] Tommy: Um because there's so many things.

[12:34] Jimi: It's like, you know, Mad Men has seen how to succeed.

[12:38] Tommy: Um and has just been like, okay, so that's what's wrong with that, that's what's wrong with that.

[12:42] Jimi: That's these are the things that we need to highlight in our show.

[12:45] Tommy: Right.

[12:45] Jimi: Boom.

[12:46] Tommy: Um because obviously, you know, with someone like Don Draper and Mad Men, he he's not he's not a nice guy.

[12:52] Jimi: Right.

[12:52] Tommy: Um, but that's very much the point.

[12:56] Jimi: Yes.

[12:56] Tommy: Whereas in How to Succeed, and this is what I think it was fascinating reading reviews about Robert Morse, um the original Finch, uh superimposed with reviews about Matthew Broderick.

[13:09] Jimi: Um and the discussion because Finch is an anti-hero.

[13:13] Tommy: Finch is, you know, a conniving little shit.

[13:17] Jimi: Um but where m they describe Morris as being kind of like a lovable maniac.

[13:23] Tommy: Um and you watch him in the movie and clips of him and that reads like he I he's still, even for the camera, playing to the back of the house and has this kind of like wide-eyed I might kill you in the middle of the night look about him.

[13:36] Jimi: Yeah.

[13:37] Tommy: Looks slightly drug addled.

[13:38] Jimi: Yeah.

[13:39] Tommy: Do you get that vibe?

[13:40] Jimi: I do, and there, and it's weird watching him then compared to now, because he also I didn't know this because I didn't watch Mad Men.

[13:45] Tommy: Um, but he's in Mad Men.

[13:48] Jimi: He's in Mad Men.

[13:49] Tommy: Which is all comes full circle.

[13:51] Jimi: Talk about type casting, I mean right.

[13:54] Jimi: It's the only thing he's ever done. Um, but then you compare that to Matthew Broderick, who will forever be, you know, the somewhere between Ferris Bueller and um uh Bloom from how um what's the name of that musical? The Producers. Um and they d they describe him as being a little more I don't know, slick and coy and you know, which somehow seems more suited to Finch for me. But it is it is an interesting discussion of like do we want him to succeed?

[14:29] Tommy: Yeah.

[14:29] Jimi: And you kind of need to, but I don't know. Well that's it. So it's interesting 'cause I read I think I've read one review uh of the re most recent the twenty eleven revival um where like one of their opening lines was you know you know from the start it's gonna be a happy ending he's gonna get what he wants.

[14:48] Tommy: Right.

[14:48] Jimi: And I'm like why why should that necessarily be the case? Like wouldn't that almost just be the better show if it was like Yeah you know, these self help books are actually a load of shit. Uh you know I mean conniving won't get you to the top neither will nepot I mean but just just maybe something in there instead of you know here's the moon on a stick. Well done. I I think it's one of the more I don't know insightful parts of the show is when you know near near the end when Finch you know is says to Rosemary like he's gonna tell the truth because she wants him to and you know he's done with all of this and like it and he's actually in trouble and actually gonna get fired and there's some drama there and there's some tension there and then it immediately goes out the window and we start dancing again.

[15:36] Tommy: Um which I guess hey you know snap your fingers that's musical theater.

[15:40] Jimi: But exactly maybe what maybe what they're doing what Lesser is doing there is he's just shining a light on literally what is happening in that, you know, this corporate world is all a big old sham.

[15:52] Tommy: Yeah.

[15:52] Jimi: And it is just nepotism and it is just people faking their way to the top.

[15:56] Tommy: Yeah.

[15:56] Jimi: I mean, we know that.

[15:57] Tommy: Yeah.

[15:57] Jimi: That's that definitely does exist. Um, so maybe the fact that he gets his way is just again, it's just fact. It's just factual.

[16:04] Tommy: Well, and especially, you know, I'm I do not doubt that a lot of how to succeed's popularity has to do with the fact that Broadway is in New York and there's a you know, a working class audience who can go see this thing, and like it is your after work escape is a parody of your after work, you know, it's it's why Roseanne is popular, it's why like the it when it is a a satire or a reflection of real life for a particular audience, that's why it's popular, you know.

[16:39] Jimi: Yeah, for sure. How to succeed is a send-up of New York corporate culture, like the worldwide wicked corporation is next to the Richard Rogers, like leave one and go see the other. Um but I think you know, maybe that's that is the question. Can you do it today? Has corporate culture changed? Is this now period piece?

[17:01] Tommy: Exactly, exactly.

[17:04] Jimi: Because you know, we've talked about this on the show before. Like, first I'm trying to think of something like Oklahoma, yeah. Do you know where we sit on very different camps and I'm like, it's so archaic and it's so set in its time that you realize you can, you know, I mean you can distinguish yourself. I feel like because you know, the world is still run by corporations, um, maybe more so now, uh, is you know, is this as much of a like you say a period piece as something like Oklahoma, which is definitely set, you know what I mean, in the past, and you know you are looking at history there.

[17:35] Tommy: For this, unless you know, you need to be really careful in terms of your styling and your set dressing. Because I mean, you know, you put people in like, you know, Hugo Boss suits and suddenly you're in the 2010s.

[17:47] Jimi: Exactly.

[17:48] Tommy: Well, and it it because it is where something like Oklahoma is doesn't have the problematic the big problematic umbrella that I think how to succeed does. You know.

[18:01] Jimi: Yep.

[18:02] Tommy: There's certainly bits and pieces there, but you can fondly look back at the time in Oklahoma with rose colored glasses and not feel that, you know, tinge of guilt in the back of your mind that you absolutely feel with how to succeed. You know, like when Hetty's like, I, you know, I left being at the Copa, and at least when I was there, you know, I got pinched and got tipped for it.

[18:27] Jimi: Um we're we are not hiding this in any way.

[18:33] Tommy: Exactly.

[18:34] Jimi: And but that's the thing, is like with that line, like the end of it obviously saying around here a girl can't be nine to pick up a pencil with confidence. It's like she's literally saying, like, hey, sexual harassment's a problem.

[18:44] Tommy: Yeah.

[18:44] Jimi: And then what do they do? They turn around and laugh and sing a little song about it. Like it's well, and what's I want to find Well, where was it? Because I was looking through the libretto BG Vubs, the MTI libretto for this. They must have used some um like character recognition. Um no. And it is it is really bad. Um they call Mr. Gatch Mr. Catch on and off, because it gets yeah, there was it's really bad. Um but there's one they make a huge joke out of it, and it's a background joke too, which I think is perhaps the most telling part.

[19:24] Jimi: Um it's like an introduction to a scene, they're on the elevator set. Um that's like midway through act one, isn't it? And everyone's getting off the elevator, and a girl gets off the elevator, so I said, just keep your hands where they belong. A man gets off the elevator. So he said, I'm next in line for promotion. A different girl gets off the elevator. So I said, just keep your hands where they belong. A second man gets off the elevator. So he said, I'll be head of sales in a year with a raise in a third girl gets off the elevator. So I said, just keep your hands where they belong. Another man gets off the elevator. I'm dying to see that new production chart. And then Miss Crumholtz gets off the elevator and says, So what the hell? I'm having dinner with him.

[20:04] Tommy: Um if you can put your, you know, the identification of sexism and misogyny in a box for a second, it's a very funny joke. It's well delivered, it is like comedy perfection.

[20:19] Jimi: Yes.

[20:20] Tommy: It's really bad.

[20:21] Jimi: It's really bad.

[20:22] Tommy: I know. And that's but that's the thing is it's like, you know, oh, I'm trying to give it a good comparison. Maybe something like Millie? Yeah. Right? Where it's like you're looking at a I guess a kind of similar environment, obviously a different time. But um, you know, the all this stuff was still happening.

[20:36] Tommy: Right.

[20:40] Jimi: Um, and where Millie Millie treads a fine line too, I think, but like we're not pretending that Mrs. Mears is a is a person that she's a character. Kind of ignoring ignoring that storyline. We're gonna just push that one off. No, just in terms of like how women are treated and how the men work with the women. Like it's very much like, yeah, we know this is an issue, this is ridiculous.

[21:04] Tommy: Right.

[21:05] Jimi: Uh you know, the tongue is in the whereas this is just so on the nose. Let me put it to you this way, though, counter-argument to say that because we talked about this with guys and dolls, which is you know, apples for apples comparison to this show.

[21:19] Tommy: Yeah.

[21:20] Jimi: Um there is something to be said about some girl power in this show. Between Hetty, like very clearly, at least by the end of the show, understands the use of her sex appeal. All the times, or I guess in the movie he does it a bunch of times, but in the show he only does it once when Finch sends Hetty to, you know, go sabotage some businessman's life by delivering these letters personally. Um or something like Rosemary's through line, um, whether it's Cinderella Darling or the reprise of how to succeed in or what is it? Huh, The Secretary's Guide, How to Hook a Tycoon.

[21:59] Tommy: Yeah.

[21:59] Jimi: Um, the reprise at the beginning of Act Two, and like is you know, certainly a product of its time, but these are women who like have a very keen understanding of, you know, the the hand they're dealt right now and are trying desperately to capitalize it in the ways they can.

[22:25] Tommy: Yeah.

[22:25] Jimi: I'm I'm not entirely convinced on my own argument there. I know, I d I I do know what you mean. I t I totally see what you're getting at, in the sense that it's like we can't do anything about it, let's make the most of what we got. That kind of vibe.

[22:38] Tommy: Right.

[22:38] Jimi: Like work in the secretary pool until you can get married to a big tycoon, and then you're set.

[22:44] Tommy: Right.

[22:45] Jimi: But I think the only thing the only issue that I have there is none of them are like, this is awful.

[22:50] Tommy: Right, exactly.

[22:52] Jimi: They're all like, This is this is the Cinderella story. That's what do you know? I mean, that's what they're saying. Like, this is the thing we've been dreaming of.

[22:59] Tommy: Yeah.

[22:59] Jimi: This is our fable. Yeah. Do you know what I mean? And it's manky. Well, and so what do you think? Because that this show has remained, you know, this show is like a museum piece. They dust it off and they don't do much. But the big change was the ninety-five revival, which did cut Cinderella story and do a reprise of how to succeed in business from the secretary's perspective.

[23:22] Tommy: Yes.

[23:22] Jimi: How do you feel about that change? And then they put Cinderella story back for twenty eleven. You know, it's the fifty thing ever, so let's just celebrate the misogyny again.

[23:31] Tommy: Um yeah, I mean, like, sure it's a step. It's definitely a step in the right direction. And I think the ninety-five production overall is the one that sees the issues.

[23:41] Jimi: Yes.

[23:47] Tommy: It tries to dance around them.

[23:49] Jimi: Yeah.

[23:50] Tommy: Literally. It doesn't it doesn't tackle them, you know, there's no break style like Matthew Broderick's popping out the front and be like, guys, this is awful. Watch what I'm about to do. And then, you know, right there's there's none of that. Yeah. Um, but with things like the Secretary's Guides, um, at the opening of Act Two, it's it's certainly a step, but is it enough?

[24:13] Jimi: Yeah, I don't know.

[24:14] Tommy: I don't know.

[24:15] Jimi: I don't know either. Because the thing is is they do that and then the rest of the story just plays out.

[24:20] Tommy: Yeah.

[24:20] Jimi: When I think the um the ninety-five uh a secretary is not a toy is like it makes me uncomfortable.

[24:30] Tommy: It does make No and I would give you that. I think that is almost the tone that the whole show should try and take.

[24:37] Jimi: Right.

[24:38] Tommy: Like that one, you know, th in in that particular recording, um, the is that Gansh Gatch who sings that is like it is very clear that he does not heed this overt rule.

[24:58] Jimi: Like he is a lecherous, no good, and that doesn't come through in either the 61 or the 11 as much.

[25:05] Tommy: In the 61 or the 11, and with the right listening, it's like, hey, you know, HR sent up not that they had HR, but HR sent up these guidelines about sexual harassment, and you should follow them. A secretary is not a toy.

[25:17] Jimi: Whereas, like in 95, it's like, I am such a you know, awful human being, I don't follow this, like, look at how bad this is. And it goes full tilt into the satire. Um which I think that's the only way to guard this show. I think as well, see if you listen to the recording of it, um, and it comes it comes really, really clear through in the cast recording. Um, but it's a lot angrier, it's a lot darker.

[25:44] Tommy: They shout the end.

[25:45] Jimi: They don't sing the end, they just shout it.

[25:47] Tommy: Right.

[25:48] Jimi: Um, and just these little t tweaks, I think, I'm like smart thinking.

[25:53] Tommy: Yeah.

[25:54] Jimi: It makes it the the satire that it's supposed to be, as opposed to being like it an instruction manual.

[26:03] Tommy: Exactly.

[26:04] Jimi: Or like, you know, a secretary is not a toy, as if. Do you know what I mean?

[26:09] Tommy: Exactly.

[26:10] Jimi: Which is what I would say the original definitely does, and I guess the 2011 can't help but doing because you know, right.

[26:16] Tommy: But it's it's hard.

[26:19] Jimi: It is hard to backpedal.

[26:20] Tommy: It is hard to like take the sexism out of this show because it's a plot point.

[26:26] Jimi: For sure.

[26:27] Tommy: And I do know because I was thinking about this, I was like, I feel like we must have come across another show like this where it still gets played, it's still quite beloved, but is so errantly kind of awful in terms of its thing.

[26:39] Jimi: But I actually don't think we have because even like when we talk to guys and dolls, like there's ways to swing that to, you know, bulk up the girl power aspect of it.

[26:48] Tommy: For sure.

[26:48] Jimi: And make it very someone like Adelaide is actually she's got some good points and she's got a lot of strength.

[26:54] Tommy: Right.

[26:55] Jimi: Um someone like Laurie in Oklahoma, even of all the shows. Like it even has a little bit of something in there.

[26:59] Tommy: A little bit of something.

[27:04] Jimi: But you look at Hetty and Rosemary.

[27:10] Tommy: Oh my god.

[27:11] Jimi: She's such a such a painful. I I just want her to punch Finch in the face, you know.

[27:16] Tommy: Exactly.

[27:17] Jimi: Or like Mary Bug just to get back at him or something.

[27:20] Tommy: Right.

[27:21] Jimi: Or just leave like she said she was going to do and not be persuaded by this secretarial pool telling her you're our only hope.

[27:29] Tommy: Right.

[27:29] Jimi: And she never gets there. Oh, you know, that it's the last line. Oh, honey, I don't care if you're a window washer or you know, the chairman of the board, a president of the United States. I love you.

[27:38] Tommy: What was that thing you said?

[27:40] Jimi: I love you. Know the other thing. You know, it's the it's the final joke.

[27:43] Tommy: It's the laughter.

[27:44] Jimi: Exactly. Exactly. And that but that isn't the joke.

[27:47] Jimi: The joke is, oh, he wants to be president.

[27:50] Tommy: Right.

[27:50] Jimi: The joke isn't, oh, he just walked all over his, you know, fiancée.

[27:54] Tommy: Yeah.

[27:54] Jimi: Uh, it is really painful.

[27:56] Tommy: It's really painful.

[27:57] Jimi: Like this, just this whole idea of, um, in that time that, you know, being a secretary in an office was like the female equivalent of Tinder in those days.

[28:10] Tommy: They were literally there because they were single, yeah, and they needed to take care of their mother, and they just had to wait till they could get a husband and then go into glorious unemployment.

[28:20] Jimi: Is the fact they call it glory and unemployment.

[28:22] Tommy: I know.

[28:23] Jimi: I hate that so much.

[28:24] Tommy: No, it's so bad.

[28:25] Jimi: There, and like I was thinking through, I was running the mind experiment of like if you're given carte blanche to fix this show, how would you?

[28:32] Tommy: And I don't know if you can.

[28:34] Jimi: Like I thought about, you know, do you make Wally a woman?

[28:38] Tommy: Like the chairman of the board is a lady.

[28:41] Jimi: Um, I think the only thing that you could do, and again, there are probably ways that it wouldn't work, is you just completely gender flip it and you make a statement.

[28:51] Tommy: Yeah, and it just becomes a, you know, or you go like super dark with it, but then it's not entertaining anymore.

[28:58] Jimi: Well, exactly.

[28:59] Tommy: Because I was thinking about, I was thinking of like, um, you know, I was like, all right, if I ever had to direct this show, what how the hell would I take it?

[29:06] Jimi: Um, thinking about, uh, Assassins, yeah, right, where at the end of the show you kind of go through this whole journey with these guys where you kind of end up sympathizing with them, right?

[29:18] Tommy: Or at least empathizing with them and kind of seeing their point of view, yeah.

[29:22] Jimi: Um, and then you get something just broke, and then you get the finale, and suddenly you ru you hate them.

[29:29] Tommy: Like they're repugnant to the city.

[29:31] Jimi: It's the, that's the, I think it's an apocryphal story, but the story goes there was a production of Annie that was shut down because at the very, very end, and I, I had, you know, can't stand Annie, so I don't remember the particulars of how Annie ends, but you know, oh, I'm with Daddy Warbucks, and you know, I've, you know, an a Stanny, I am an Annie stan.

[29:51] Tommy: I just, I just coined that.

[29:52] Jimi: Okay.

[29:52] Tommy: I wondered if they're welcome.

[29:54] Jimi: Oh, is Tumblr still a thing?

[29:55] Tommy: Look what you've done.

[29:56] Jimi: Um, but apparently at the end of this, maybe imaginary production, you know, Annie's like so happy she's with Daddy Warbucks, and then the lights shift and go dark, and the orphanage set comes back on, and Annie ends up back in bed and wakes up from a dream, and then the blackest.

[30:15] Tommy: But like you'd have to do that.

[30:17] Jimi: You'd have to like totally, you know, figure out a way to bookend the performance with a like and this is bad.

[30:28] Tommy: Yeah, you know, big blinking sign or something.

[30:30] Jimi: Yeah.

[30:31] Tommy: Like you need, you need at that endpoint, like the Brotherhood of Man needs to turn into this, like the, you know, the chant of the patriarchy.

[30:36] Jimi: I mean, which already the thing is that, all right.

[30:38] Tommy: It is the chant of the patriarchy.

[30:40] Jimi: The name of the song is called The Brotherhood of Man.

[30:43] Tommy: There's one girl in the whole song, and she doesn't sing anything of substance.

[30:47] Jimi: I know.

[30:48] Tommy: Like it is, do you know, do you know what this show needs?

[30:51] Jimi: It needs to be directed by a woman.

[30:53] Tommy: I wonder, but who's gonna, you know?

[30:56] Jimi: Yeah, well, why the hell would you?

[30:57] Tommy: But like I would love to see, but I just, I not actually, I just don't know what you can do.

[31:04] Jimi: I know it is, it is really like I, I think I can work around a lot of problems in a show, and I don't think there's a thing that would fix this for me nowadays.

[31:14] Tommy: I think it's a, it's a period piece with some great tuners that are great out of context, and some great dance numbers, and you know, really funny comedy if you take it for what it is, but has no place in contemporary discourse.

[31:28] Jimi: No.

[31:29] Tommy: Just like sexual harassment has no place in the workplace.

[31:31] Jimi: I succeeded.

[31:33] Tommy: Did you not?

[31:33] Jimi: So I did a bunch of research on this because I had no idea.

[31:37] Tommy: Um, I wonder if we read the same paper because you're setting a lot of things that I had.

[31:41] Jimi: Oh, did you by that lawyer lady?

[31:42] Tommy: Yes.

[31:43] Jimi: Well, I learned a lot about law.

[31:45] Tommy: We'll find a link for it and put it in the show notes.

[31:48] Jimi: I hate reading lawyer papers because they're APA style and they cite everything.

[31:53] Tommy: Everything was cited, like everything.

[31:54] Jimi: Like every time they talk about the plot in the show, they cite the authors again.

[31:59] Tommy: And it's like, I get it, we know.

[32:00] Jimi: But this, so this lawyer presents went and saw a production of How to Succeed.

[32:05] Tommy: Um, she's an employment lawyer, um, and law professor, I think.

[32:09] Jimi: Um, let me here, hold on.

[32:11] Tommy: Let me look up her name so I can say her name.

[32:13] Jimi: Um, Mary something.

[32:15] Tommy: Cherry.

[32:16] Jimi: That's where I got Mary from.

[32:18] Tommy: Excellent, good.

[32:19] Jimi: Yeah.

[32:19] Tommy: Yeah.

[32:19] Jimi: So Miriam Cherry, she's a law professor at Cumberland School of Law, Stanford University.

[32:27] Tommy: Um, it's a wonderful paper.

[32:29] Jimi: So she went to see How to Succeed, um, you know, expecting a nice night out at the theater, and was deeply disturbed by all the things we've talked about, and so then analyzed the show from using her law experience, which is wonderful and fascinating, um, and talks about how employment law and sexual harassment law has changed since the 1960s.

[32:51] Tommy: Um, talks about how, and this is fascinating.

[32:54] Jimi: So the Civil Rights Act, Title VII, which I have heard of before, um, was penned in 1964.

[33:01] Tommy: Um, and it bars discrimination based on race, gender, um, and a couple other things.

[33:08] Jimi: Um, race, color, religion, sex, or national origin are the way it's phrased.

[33:14] Tommy: Um, and was the first thing that said, like you, you know, you can't pay a woman less for doing the same job as a man and all these things.

[33:21] Jimi: But there's a whole bunch of case law surrounding this, and the first successful case about sexual harassment um went to the United States Supreme Court in nineteen eighty-six.

[33:34] Tommy: Literally twenty-four years.

[33:36] Jimi: Yeah.

[33:36] Tommy: So sexual harassment was like just legal.

[33:40] Jimi: And that's even the wrong way to put it because it's not that like it was just not even identified as a thing until nineteen eighty-six.

[33:49] Tommy: Um, and it's a beautiful analysis of like how far we've come and how far we have to go.

[33:54] Jimi: Um, but it is, it's cool because How to Succeed is a contemporaneous time capsule of a primary source about sexual harassment in the workplace.

[34:05] Tommy: Yeah.

[34:06] Jimi: Like, you know, when, when whoever grabs what's her face, see, I don't know the names.

[34:11] Tommy: Um, and like, oh, it's su brings such a shine to my day when I see you around the office and grabs her butt and then she pushes them away, and then it's like I should stop reading Playboy.

[34:22] Jimi: Ha ha, what a funny joke.

[34:25] Tommy: You know?

[34:25] Jimi: Yeah, it's, it's manky.

[34:27] Tommy: Yeah.

[34:28] Jimi: It is manky.

[34:29] Tommy: Yeah, there was 'cause there was an article I read as well, um, that it was kind of matching it up with Mad Men and um talk, you know, brought in a lot of this as well.

[34:38] Jimi: And, and again it was just in response to, to seeing it.

[34:41] Tommy: And I think what a lot, and what's actually quite nice to note is that both of these writers were female.

[34:47] Jimi: Um, and what their kind of arguments are is that you can now look at this show, you can go see it, and it's a good talking point to be like, This isn't good, is it?

[34:57] Tommy: Right.

[34:57] Jimi: Um, and it's kind of creating that conversation.

[35:00] Tommy: Uh, so that to bring that into the argument of, you know, do we just go nope, uh, way with you had succeeded, or do you put it on a stage to be like, This is a pale of non do you know what I mean?

[35:11] Jimi: Right, exactly.

[35:11] Tommy: Do you showcase the, you know, the bullshit of the past?

[35:14] Jimi: I do think it does speak volumes that neither of the revivals were nearly as popular as the original production.

[35:20] Tommy: Um, they were still plenty popular, still played from, you know, 500 shows more than a year, um, but not the 1400 run that the original had.

[35:30] Jimi: And I imagine a lot of that has to do with the like unintentional uncomfortableness of it.

[35:39] Tommy: For sure.

[35:40] Jimi: Like it just, it's just there.

[35:42] Tommy: Um, of interest, is it done quite a lot in high schools over there?

[35:46] Jimi: I, I, it is a, I would peg it as a popular high school show.

[35:50] Tommy: I think the thing that holds it back is just it's a very male-heavy show, and that's just not how high school casts are.

[35:56] Jimi: Yes.

[35:57] Tommy: Um, it's, it's a hard show to cast for that reason.

[36:00] Jimi: Um, but there are, I mean, you know, I did my YouTube trolling, there are some fantastic um, you know, illicit recordings of high school productions on the internet.

[36:12] Tommy: Um, people do a really good job with this show.

[36:14] Jimi: Because it's, it's a hard show to mess up, barring which maybe in a second we will, you know, put our sexism in a box and just talk about it as a show.

[36:22] Tommy: Um, but like barring some of the overarching problems, it's a really good show.

[36:27] Jimi: I know that's, that's what's so frustrating.

[36:30] Tommy: It's really well made.

[36:31] Jimi: Um, yeah.

[36:33] Tommy: Well, okay, let's, let's talk about it.

[36:35] Jimi: Let's talk about that.

[36:45] Tommy: No matter what.

[36:46] Jimi: No drop take trouble, you're not.

[37:21] Tommy: A secretary is not a toy.

[37:21] Jimi: She's a highly specialized component of operational unity.

[37:21] Tommy: A fine and sensitive mechanism to serve the office community.

[37:21] Jimi: With the mother of all, she supports the and you'll find nothing like her at FAO Schwartz.

[37:21] Tommy: A secretary is not a pet, nor an erect.

[37:28] Jimi: It happened to Johnny McCoy.

[37:29] Tommy: Boy, they fired him like a shot.

[37:32] Jimi: The day the fella forgot a secretary.

[37:39] Tommy: Yep.

[37:41] Jimi: I'll open it later, but yeah, it's currently.

[37:44] Tommy: Let's talk about the show.

[37:45] Jimi: It's a funny, it's a well-constructed show.

[37:47] Tommy: I would like, I think Guys and Dolls and especially How to Succeed are good examples of what has become the cookie cutter musical.

[37:58] Jimi: I think they pioneered the form.

[38:01] Tommy: Um, but from like exposition of place to exposition of character to how the conflict progresses.

[38:09] Jimi: Um, it's just like that's the lesser of all people has discovered what makes a two-act big Broadway musical theater plot happen.

[38:23] Tommy: I, it is, and it's, it's quite smart because this is, you know, you need to remember this is very early days.

[38:28] Jimi: You know, I mean, we're just, uh, at the back of, you know, the golden age in a verte commas.

[38:33] Tommy: Right.

[38:33] Jimi: Um, so to, to have something that is as well constructed as this and it's kind of coherent.

[38:39] Tommy: Yeah, I mean, although this, all the early reviews express a lot of surprise about how good the book is, uh-huh, which I think is really telling that they're like yes, it's, uh, you know, it is as funny and witty and intelligent as a play of the era.

[38:56] Jimi: And there was one review that was like it foregoes some of the, you know, gags and slapstick for running commentary and, you know, more like quote unquote highbrow humor.

[39:10] Tommy: Exactly, exactly.

[39:11] Jimi: Um, and I wonder as well if like, you know, nowadays you've got the kind of like play with music vibe that's kind of coming to the fore.

[39:19] Tommy: Yeah.

[39:19] Jimi: Um, I wonder if that's what they thought this was in a way.

[39:22] Tommy: Yeah.

[39:22] Jimi: Which, you know, obviously it's an out and out musical, but I wonder if like, oh hey, there's some suspense.

[39:26] Tommy: Right, there's, there's drama, there's, I understand who these characters are.

[39:30] Jimi: And they have dimension and depth to a point.

[39:33] Tommy: Yeah.

[39:34] Jimi: So I wonder if that's, they were like, this is so hybrid.

[39:36] Tommy: Yeah.

[39:37] Jimi: I love the idea.

[39:38] Tommy: Well, and so the thing I'm thinking, because it's a thing I can never quite articulate, like from far away while squinting, I can look at this and say, like the well-made musical, but like picking out the individual pieces, sometimes I struggle with that.

[39:51] Jimi: You know, like what something like just stuff the, in my mind it's, it's the murder she wrote strategy, but I know it's been around forever.

[40:02] Tommy: The like, you know, he mentions briefly, um, uh, JB Bigley mentions that he's gonna be going golfing, and so he's gonna be in on Saturday, and it's like one, it's like a line, but then Finch takes advantage of that and then it becomes a plot point.

[40:19] Jimi: Or like the whole how the television scavenger hunt scheme was Bud's idea, and that comes back to bite him in the butt.

[40:28] Tommy: Like is a really intelligent plot construction device that I think you don't, you know, Oklahoma doesn't have that.

[40:36] Jimi: Um, even Guys and Dolls doesn't have that.

[40:41] Tommy: Oh, certainly not to that extent, no.

[40:43] Jimi: Like maybe, uh, I would say it might have like one strand with, um, Adelaide and Nathan, but oh no, with them, sorry, uh, l the other, oh my god, Sky and Sky and, uh, Sarah, there we go, Sky and Server.

[40:57] Tommy: Uh, with them and that, you know, there's the whole, uh, what's the religious passage the, um, man, it's been so long, it's like we haven't made a podcast in this.

[41:07] Jimi: Exactly.

[41:08] Tommy: They, I don't know, but there's something and it kind of gets called on through, and then that's the punchline at the end when he walks on and he's.

[41:14] Jimi: Right.

[41:14] Tommy: And that's, you know, nowadays that is, is that is sitcom standard, that is, you know, musical theater standard, like don't you dare, Deus Ex machina us.

[41:24] Jimi: Like if, if it's gonna come in in act two, the gun better damn well have been on the wall in act one.

[41:28] Tommy: Exactly, exactly.

[41:29] Jimi: That gun has to be there.

[41:31] Tommy: Um, yeah, so it's, I guess it must just be things like that.

[41:34] Jimi: I would say as well, um, in terms of the actual songs, it's not hitting like very like cliched yes, uh pockets, you know what I mean?

[41:44] Jimi: It's not got your, uh, like your I want song is there, but it's not the second song of the nut. I mean, it it's it's playing a little bit with the conventions that have just been set up.

[41:56] Tommy: Yeah, exactly. And it is still, uh, you know what I think part of it is too? They're not pop songs. Maybe that's part of the transition. They're not written to be songs that exist and are popular outside of the media. Certainly some of them are. I believe in you, which is clearly lesser was like, Well, I had I did great with Luck be a lady tonight, so let's write the same song again. Um, but like a lot of the songs like Coffee Break, they're not gonna play that on the radio. Um, it's a great song, you know, Paris original. Frank Sinatra's not gonna cover that. Like these are not going to be I'd like to see him try, I guess. I want to see him do it in the same dress. Um, but we're like exiting the concept of Tin Pan Alley and starting to kind of redefine what musical theater is.

It's no longer a marketing ploy for popular music. It's becoming like an artistic art form, which you know it's probably why I won the Pulitzer. Um, which we'll talk about later, I'm sure. More necessary later. Uh, but no, I I totally agree with you there. I totally agree. And and and most of the reviews, and even nowadays as well, really kind of laud the book because it's it's it's strong and it's kind of the glue that that holds the whole thing together because kind of you know, without it it's a little bit yeah uppy down y'all shall we see so let's can we talk about act two?

[43:28] Jimi: Yes, and like I think this is I think this musical was the first musical to encounter this problem because it was breaking ground in this area. Um this is I don't know. Have we talked about this on the podcast? It's a concept I have in my mind all the time, but that like the the second quarter of act two is the most difficult writing challenge in a piece of musical theater.

[44:01] Tommy: Do you know when we talked about it?

[44:02] Jimi: Hmm.

[44:03] Tommy: Hashtag callback, our first podcast.

[44:07] Jimi: No way. I have an amazing memory for these things. Thank you very much. So the idea is in a two-act musical, before intermission, you have to, you know, heighten the stakes. Something, you know, we need to be on a cliffhanger. Something needs to like make you come back from intermission. But whatever that is needs to be immediately resolved when you get back, so that you it's not like hanging over you the whole act. But it can't be so resolved that then there's nothing to do in act two.

[44:38] Tommy: Exactly.

[44:40] Jimi: And this show does not do that well.

[44:43] Tommy: No, it's it's like they sneeze. Do you know that's an jail? It just feels like a sneeze. And then they're like, oh, I just sneezed out all of this the plot. Um they're like, put it back, put it back, put it back in. Advertising. What could you pirates? What are we gonna do with pirates?

[45:06] Jimi: Yeah, exactly. I feel like you could have a piratical flair. That's what the corporate world needs. You end act one and you've got such great drama. Like Bud Frump is out to get Finch and it's very clear about it. I will return. And like Rosemary is like angry at Finch because he's ignoring her and he has this great future set up for him, but will he as have his wife? Wife, who knows? And you get back, and within like three pages, all that's gone. Like Bud Frump literally sings, I have returned. Like that's what I just can't believe. Like, I can't I can't, I can't. Because it's not even funny. It's so stupid. Because that his last line. Do you know I mean it's not even a theme in the show.

[45:49] Tommy: Right.

[45:49] Jimi: He's like, I will be back. Right. And he just comes back.

[45:54] Tommy: Yeah.

[45:54] Jimi: It is, you know, I I I think there's a, uh, a spectrum of like how to do your act two or your act one ending, and you want to end up in the middle, and on one end is I will return from Bud Frump. And on the other end is ever after in Into the Woods, like the end the song. Like we're done, we're done. The show's over, we're done, you know. And I think exactly this show's the other end of the spectrum.

[46:22] Tommy: It really is. Oh, bless it. Um, but yeah, okay. So let's talk about the pirates, because I read a bit more about this in my Fosse book. Of all things, I didn't even know until this time through that this was and not officially, but a Fosse show.

[46:40] Jimi: Well, so this is it. So this is actually quite interesting. It's a little kind of weird piece of like behind the scenes musical Broadway trivia, I guess. Um so yeah, so obviously I think it's if you if you're aware of Fosse stuff, particularly around this time, um, you'd kind of be able to clock it and be like, this seems very good and interestingly stylized. I wonder who did this. Um so basically Fosse um was there and he was credited as um, uh I think it was like, uh like musical staging by Bob Fosse, but he was not the choreographer, yeah.

[47:18] Tommy: Yeah, officially.

[47:19] Jimi: Um the exactly. So the choreographer was uh given to um Hugh Lambert, who was brought on right at the start because um I think it was Frank Lesser or might have been Nate Burroughs, uh was a huge huge fan of his stuff, and he'd he'd done stuff for like TV specials and um these kind of things. He was like, he's great. Uh we'll we'll get him involved. Um obviously when they started like when they did the read through for the show, everyone was like, This show's hysterical, it's the best. Uh and then they started rehearsing it and seeing how Hugh was working, and all the laughs, all the laughter stopped. Yeah, um, because basically there was just no cohesion, there was no through thought, and all Hugh Lambert was really doing was creating kind of sketch after sketch after sketch.

Um basically I think Abe Burroughs or again, frankly, or maybe the producers, I don't know. Uh one of them were actually quite good friends with uh Bob Fosse Gwen Verdon. Um basically wanted to bring him in, bring him on board as the choreographer.

[48:27] Jimi: As a choreographer doctor, yes.

[48:29] Tommy: Um but Bob Fosse was like, listen, um, I've just recently been fired uh as choreographer. I don't want someone else to go through that. Um so keep him on, uh he has to be there every rehearsal. Um give him the credit of choreographer and give me just something else. Um and I'm like, hey, anyone who says Bob Fosse's not a good guy, fair enough, there's many points, but that's a nice one. That's a good cold star for him. That's a really nice moment. Um and so he came in and then started working through um everything. Uh and then there's some really we'll just get let me just give some some choreographic tidbits, why not?

[49:09] Jimi: Yes, absolutely.

[49:11] Tommy: So interesting stuff, like he uh was really obsessed with the idea of keeping it realistic, because everything he'd done before was very musical theatre, it was very performative. Um whereas for this he couldn't really get away with that because it was a very domestic setting. Um and it wasn't the actual the original production wasn't heightened, it wasn't uh you know, an office, but it's an office, oh exactly, it's a dream office, exactly. It's a real office with elevators and coffee and typewriters and uh yeah, um, but so one of the big reasons uh there's no like dancing on desks, an office staple uh is because it's totally not realistic, like you wouldn't want run around and start dancing on a desk or push everything off, start dancing on a desk, take note 95.

[50:02] Jimi: 95.

[50:07] Tommy: Oh, 925, not 95. Got it. Not 95, no. 95 is fine. Keep going, 95.

[50:15] Jimi: And uh yeah, so and he was really, really into that, and he started to spawn his whole thing, which would kind of carry him through his career of uh, uh making it a chorus of individuals um and not just course all the people, yeah.

[50:33] Tommy: Exactly. Um, and so he everyone that was in, I think it was Coffee Break when he was doing it, because he found that one of the trickiest. Um he was basically made them write a character sheet about their life and where they've been from. So they could bring it all out. Progressive. How how new age much for 1960s? Shockingly enough, came from Bob Fosse, he's the best.

[50:55] Jimi: Um, and then it's what I find what I really love is that a lot of the reviews that they then got um were really praising the fact that the ensemble seemed so like intelligent and you know it felt very immersive. And so could one of the reasons why it being so successful, purely because of Bob Fosse? I'm gonna say yes.

[51:15] Tommy: I mean, probably.

[51:18] Jimi: But so the story goes that the what is it, Yoho Ho or the Pirate Ballet or whatever it is.

[51:25] Tommy: Yes, the Pirate Ballet, so original choreography, not Bob Fosse choreography.

[51:31] Jimi: Yes, so that was the kind of like, okay, Hugh, you're here. Um, we'll let you have this one.

[51:38] Tommy: Right.

[51:38] Jimi: Um, and so kind of shoehorned this thing at like where does this fit it here? Majorly shoehorned, like I mean. To the point where like that is that is what gets me so much. It is such and this happens with a lot of musicals of this time, whether it's a show with a character written specifically for a particular performer who has like a thing, and so the show incorporates their thing, like pajama game is this way with Eddie Foy and his knife throwing.

[52:09] Tommy: Um my god, I was really I compare this a lot to Pajama Game.

[52:13] Jimi: Yeah, like there's a lot of like, so we know this person can do this thing, so we're gonna write this show so they can do this thing. Of course, but then when you do it again, do you keep the thing? But you have to in this one because it is so intrinsically tied to the plot, but it could be anything. Like Finch just needs a a problem to go wrong in Act Two. It doesn't matter what it is.

[52:36] Tommy: Right.

[52:38] Jimi: It is not particular that it is a you know television scavenger hunt. Like literally, Bud Frump's idea could be anything as long as Bigley doesn't like it and then Finch convinces them to do it and then it goes wrong. It goes wrong. It doesn't matter what it is. It's just so left field. It is so left field.

[52:58] Tommy: Um cool. But I guess so this is this is what I always kind of come back to. Like, if it was a kind of stupid show or like a show with a tongue in the cheek, self-referential, whatever.

[53:12] Jimi: Yeah.

[53:12] Tommy: Then it would actually almost become fame because it would be like, what the hell is going on? Whereas of this, it's like, oh no, this is a choice.

[53:19] Jimi: Yeah, this is a choice.

[53:20] Tommy: Right. And where instead, why don't we spend more of it, like, why can't the drama be something about office life or relationships? Or, you know, does Hetty somehow get accidentally involved with Finch or some kind of three's company misunderstanding that then turns Bigley against him, but then you know, Rosemary, like how Act One ends, but in a bigger way in Act Two.

[53:43] Jimi: And then it's more about the people and the concept and the place, but you know, no, it's a whole new set. It's a television studio, it's a weird parody of a thing that like maybe existed, but doesn't feel like it's sustained. I don't know.

[53:57] Tommy: Not at all. Like and but I think the reason why they didn't do the heady thing, like you said, which I think seems really interesting, a lot of scope for comedy, um, is because it would give the the women far too much power.

[54:10] Jimi: That's probably the problem. Do you know what I mean?

[54:12] Tommy: Yeah, they would become the linchpin, and we can't have the have the secretary's revolt, maybe that's how to do it's saying no.

[54:18] Jimi: Oh, the dream. They're gonna take over and then Finch solves it somehow, and you know, placates Rosemary and like that's how to rewrite this show.

[54:27] Tommy: Yep. I mean, that is almost 95.

[54:30] Jimi: I guess that's true. Maybe that's what they did. Great. Um but yeah, so it's it's it's a problem that I I don't feel they tackle well.

[54:42] Tommy: No.

[54:42] Jimi: And is it is a I a thing you can't fix in revivals either. Like you'd have to well, and clearly they haven't, with you know, full if they're gonna make big changes, it's gonna be in a Broadway revival. And the the pirate section stays in to this day.

[55:00] Tommy: Yes.

[55:01] Jimi: And the thing is, is like surely it's not beloved.

[55:04] Tommy: No.

[55:05] Jimi: I mean, surely people aren't like Oh, I mean, you can't cut that. It's not like steam heat.

[55:09] Tommy: Right? No, I'm sorry to whoever you out there who you know the pirate ballet. This is the variety member you're gonna do out of context. And I'm sorry, you know, you got a poster on your wall in your bedroom.

[55:25] Tommy: Is that just like most viewed video on YouTube is just the one from the movie of the Pirate Valley. We're very sorry to you. No, I'm sure it's like Dream Ballets.

[55:34] Jimi: I'm sure it's what gets cut in high schools.

[55:36] Tommy: I'm, you know, no one is like looking up the original choreography to recreate it.

[55:41] Jimi: Right.

[55:41] Tommy: So surely not.

[55:42] Jimi: Like no, and it's such a sideways plot point.

[55:46] Tommy: It is so expository, like every line is like, you didn't tell anyone.

[55:53] Jimi: Oh, maybe I did.

[55:54] Tommy: Like, God.

[55:56] Jimi: The show's doing so well.

[55:58] Tommy: That actually made me cringe.

[55:59] Jimi: Right? That's what I'm saying.

[56:00] Tommy: But that's that's like almost basically the line.

[56:02] Jimi: Yep.

[56:03] Tommy: You know?

[56:04] Jimi: If they had a real Bible, uh, ugh.

[56:06] Tommy: I hate it.

[56:08] Jimi: Um which I think this all leads us really nicely on to our next point.

[56:14] Tommy: I think it does too.

[56:16] Jimi: Okay, we've still got segues.

[56:18] Tommy: We're still knocking them out of the fuck.

[56:21] Jimi: Now she's thinking.

[56:23] Tommy: I wish that he were more of a flirt.

[56:28] Jimi: And he's thinking.

[56:30] Tommy: I guess a little flirting won't hurt.

[56:35] Jimi: Now she's thinking.

[56:37] Tommy: One dinner we could meet.

[56:39] Jimi: And he's thinking.

[56:41] Tommy: We both have gotta eat.

[56:43] Jimi: And she says, and he says sometimes.

[56:47] Tommy: Well, it's been a long day.

[56:50] Jimi: Well, it's been a long been, a long been a long day.

[56:57] Tommy: Hey, okay, so like we've mentioned a couple of times, uh this is one of the nine musicals uh to have won the Pulitzer Prize in drama.

[57:08] Jimi: Yes, and I think I have mentioned this before in I don't know where, but have gotten flack about like why is that important that only nine musicals have won the Pulitzer Prize for drama.

[57:19] Tommy: And I think it is an important distinction to talk about because it is the discussion of whether or not musical theater can count as art.

[57:26] Jimi: Um is emblematic of how it's not counted as art in a lot of places.

[57:36] Tommy: Yeah.

[57:37] Jimi: You know, it feels lowbrow and you know, pedestrian.

[57:42] Tommy: Um that's one.

[57:45] Jimi: I think what we should do is go through these and kind of talk about their merits and what they because I feel like for the for the most part, I'm I'm happy with this list.

[57:55] Tommy: Yeah.

[57:55] Jimi: Well, what I found fascinating, and I didn't know this until I was doing research.

[57:58] Tommy: Um this is the contemporary um the Pulitzers don't have really explicit uh criteria.

[58:08] Jimi: You don't even have to you can submit to win a Pulitzer, but you don't have to.

[58:11] Tommy: They can just give it to you.

[58:12] Jimi: Um and so there's not a lot about it, but the contemporary one for the Pulitzer Prize and drama says that it must be a distinguished play by an American author, preferably original in its source and dealing with American life.

[58:26] Tommy: And that last part, dealing with American life, that part is new to me and is interesting, I think, when you look at this list of nine.

[58:35] Jimi: Yep.

[58:36] Tommy: Yes.

[58:37] Jimi: Right?

[58:39] Tommy: Oh.

[58:39] Jimi: It adds an interesting twist to it.

[58:41] Tommy: Two and two together there.

[58:42] Jimi: Yeah.

[58:43] Tommy: And they are kind of decidedly American in discussion.

[58:51] Jimi: Maybe with a couple choice examples.

[58:55] Tommy: I'm looking at 1985, yeah.

[58:56] Jimi: Yeah, you wonder about that.

[58:58] Tommy: But s the rest of them have a really distinguished like this is about America.

[59:02] Jimi: Um yeah.

[59:04] Tommy: No, in fact, everything everything else bar 1985, but then even 1985, you could maybe kind of you know goodness for act too.

[59:13] Jimi: Right.

[59:13] Tommy: Uh so 1932 of the icing.

[59:16] Jimi: I had to look this one up.

[59:17] Tommy: Do you know anything about this?

[59:19] Jimi: Yeah, so well just I've listened to it once.

[59:22] Tommy: Um it's uh uh a pr was it a real president?

[59:26] Jimi: No, I think it's a it's a political uh satire.

[59:30] Tommy: Oh, okay.

[59:31] Jimi: About well done nineteen thirty-two.

[59:33] Tommy: Right.

[59:34] Jimi: Yeah.

[59:35] Tommy: Um and yeah, it's uh a president who wins but then falls in love with the wrong person.

[59:44] Jimi: Something like that.

[59:45] Tommy: It's a it's by the Gershwins, you know, it's got okay songs.

[59:49] Jimi: Um it's you know, it's also nineteen thirty-two, so there's not really a high bar to plot.

[59:55] Tommy: Yes.

[59:57] Jimi: Um but uh the book was just stellar.

[1:00:00] Tommy: I've I know it so well.

[1:00:03] Jimi: Uh I don't I don't at all.

[1:00:05] Tommy: But so then we get real American.

[1:00:09] Jimi: Yes.

[1:00:09] Tommy: So that's why it's about America.

[1:00:12] Jimi: Um 1950, we get South Pacific.

[1:00:15] Tommy: Yes.

[1:00:15] Jimi: Makes a lot of sense.

[1:00:16] Tommy: Absolutely, absolutely.

[1:00:18] Jimi: Although to be honest, of all of the RHs, it wouldn't have been my pick, but that's fine.

[1:00:22] Tommy: But it is of of the RHs, I think one of the I don't know, one of the heftier ones.

[1:00:28] Jimi: I don't know if that's quite the right word.

[1:00:31] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:00:33] Jimi: For sometimes how kind of like light and fluffy their subject matter is.

[1:00:38] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[1:00:39] Jimi: I think South Pacific treads very much in whatever the opposite of light and fluffy is heavy and dense.

[1:00:46] Tommy: Yes, yeah, exactly.

[1:00:48] Jimi: Heavy and dense.

[1:00:49] Tommy: Um yeah, that's yeah, I would give you that.

[1:00:51] Jimi: I well to be honest, it could it could be any.

[1:00:53] Tommy: Well, not any, a few of yours.

[1:00:55] Jimi: But um decidedly American.

[1:00:58] Tommy: Decided to be American, very much so.

[1:01:00] Jimi: Different settings, still American.

[1:01:02] Tommy: Yes.

[1:01:03] Jimi: Um then we get 1960, Fiorello.

[1:01:07] Tommy: Yes, indeed.

[1:01:08] Jimi: Everyone's favorite tiny mirror.

[1:01:13] Tommy: Anyway.

[1:01:14] Jimi: Um but you know, decidedly American, biographical, semi-biographical, um, you know, popular with the New York audience, which I'm sure has a lot to do with it.

[1:01:25] Tommy: Absolutely.

[1:01:26] Jimi: Then 1962, How to Succeed in Business Without Really Trying.

[1:01:29] Tommy: We all know in love.

[1:01:30] Jimi: Maybe maybe one of the lighter ones on this list of all things.

[1:01:34] Tommy: Definitely the first comedy.

[1:01:35] Jimi: Yeah, that's for sure.

[1:01:37] Tommy: Um or like out and out comedy.

[1:01:40] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:01:40] Tommy: Uh happy ending.

[1:01:42] Jimi: A lot of these don't really have like decidedly happy endings.

[1:01:46] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:01:46] Jimi: You know, the rest of them have kind of melancholy endings.

[1:01:49] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:01:51] Jimi: It's like the Oscars though, do you know what I mean?

[1:01:53] Tommy: You know how to if you want to win your Pulitzer, you know what to do.

[1:01:57] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:01:57] Tommy: Um yeah, that's a good point.

[1:01:59] Jimi: Um yeah, we'll we'll get into it in a second, we'll keep going through the list.

[1:02:02] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:02:03] Jimi: Um 1976, a chorus line?

[1:02:05] Tommy: Make sense.

[1:02:05] Jimi: 100%.

[1:02:06] Tommy: Yes, absolutely deserves it.

[1:02:07] Jimi: 1985, Sunday in the Park with George.

[1:02:11] Tommy: Maybe the the least American show on this list.

[1:02:14] Jimi: Exactly.

[1:02:15] Tommy: I wonder if they like someone had like leaned on the bottom part of the the um criteria.

[1:02:21] Jimi: Right.

[1:02:22] Tommy: And they were deciding, so they just didn't read that.

[1:02:24] Jimi: Um admittedly it does say preferably original source and dealing with a few.

[1:02:30] Tommy: So maybe the preferably is attached to the floor.

[1:02:31] Jimi: And if you look at because we're this is nine out of maybe eighty some awards for Pulitzers and Drama, the rest have just gone to plays.

[1:02:38] Tommy: And if you look at some of the plays, they're not all decidedly American.

[1:02:41] Jimi: 100% true.

[1:02:42] Tommy: Yeah, very true.

[1:02:43] Jimi: Um 96, Rent, makes sense.

[1:02:47] Tommy: The American.

[1:02:48] Jimi: 2010, next to normal.

[1:02:49] Tommy: Absolutely.

[1:02:50] Jimi: Of course, 2016, Hamilton.

[1:02:53] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:02:54] Jimi: Chuck Rennie.

[1:02:55] Tommy: Um so yeah.

[1:02:57] Jimi: They all they all make sense.

[1:03:00] Tommy: Does How to Succeed belong on this list?

[1:03:03] Jimi: Exactly.

[1:03:04] Tommy: And I think that's the thing is when we when you picked it out there, like it is the it is a comedy.

[1:03:09] Jimi: Now, what I'm wondering, right?

[1:03:11] Tommy: Did these guys think it was some kind of commentary?

[1:03:14] Jimi: I don't know.

[1:03:15] Tommy: And it is the the Pulitzer is filled with the same kind of politics that you can expect from something like the Oscars nowadays.

[1:03:21] Jimi: Because there's like committees and you know how they nominate things is shrouded in mystery and is a bit on who you know.

[1:03:27] Tommy: And I think that the committee is like they describe it as one academic and four critics, so there's plenty of politicizing to go on there.

[1:03:36] Jimi: So who knows about the specifics of how How to Succeed made it on this list?

[1:03:40] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:03:41] Jimi: Um it's interesting to think about.

[1:03:43] Tommy: It really, really is just because I I think see if it was an out and out satire.

[1:03:49] Jimi: If this was like, you know, like you say, Matthew Brodrick come to the front of the stage kind of thing.

[1:03:54] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:03:54] Jimi: I'd g I'd give you it a hundred percent because it's it's a great satire, the things that it brings up and the topics that it raises, but I think that's it wasn't originally written as a satire.

[1:04:07] Tommy: It was kind of written as a celebration.

[1:04:09] Jimi: Right, yeah.

[1:04:10] Tommy: And a comedy, and maybe heightened in the way that musical theater is, but not, you know, there weren't a lot of things in the show that I think were exaggerations.

[1:04:19] Jimi: No.

[1:04:20] Tommy: Um, so whether this was just a sign of the times, like it was the 60s.

[1:04:25] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:04:26] Tommy: Do you know I mean things weren't going well?

[1:04:28] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:04:29] Tommy: Uh so whether that was their reasoning or whether maybe it was just a slow year.

[1:04:33] Jimi: Yeah, or maybe it's a discussion of like well, it doesn't it it can't be that it's a slow year because they don't have to award the Pulitzer.

[1:04:39] Tommy: Some years they don't know.

[1:04:40] Jimi: They don't need to.

[1:04:41] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:04:42] Jimi: And so they had to make the decision to award this.

[1:04:45] Tommy: And it's not like there's a list of five and then they pick one, they just pick one.

[1:04:49] Jimi: So this was a choice.

[1:04:50] Tommy: Um but I think it does it was a choice.

[1:04:53] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:04:53] Tommy: It says something about how integrated the book is.

[1:04:56] Jimi: It says something about I don't know, the the changing tastes in comedy.

[1:05:03] Tommy: It's kind of a victory for comedy in that way too.

[1:05:06] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:05:07] Tommy: In the same way that these these nine are victories for musical theater.

[1:05:11] Jimi: But the fact that we can award comedy with a recognition.

[1:05:17] Tommy: Um, you know, there's a great um I forget what award he won, uh, but Jerry Seinfeld won some like lifetime achievement award, um and gives his speech, and it is all about how he hates awards and awards are stupid, and comedians don't need awards because comedians are funny.

[1:05:37] Jimi: Um, and you see that reflected in the Oscars and reflected in contemporary discourse.

[1:05:42] Tommy: Comedies don't win, you know, dramas win, things that make you think win, and comedies, oh, they're light and fluffy, and then they you know seep their way into the cracks of your being to like actually make you think things.

[1:05:53] Jimi: Um and it is interesting to see how how to succeed in business kind of seeped into the cracks a little bit, um, and you know, kind of found its wedge into I don't know, academia, contemporary intelligence discourse of the 1960s.

[1:06:11] Tommy: For sure.

[1:06:13] Jimi: Yeah, I guess.

[1:06:15] Tommy: I mean it's just like I look at I look at the latter five, right?

[1:06:21] Jimi: Um and among them are some of my most beloved musicals, and a lot of it is down to the book.

[1:06:28] Tommy: Yes, absolutely.

[1:06:29] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:06:30] Tommy: Um maybe Rent, give or taste as much as I love Rent, but I think the thing that I don't love about Rent is necessarily the the story.

[1:06:39] Jimi: Yeah, but I don't think any any of these won for their songs, you know?

[1:06:43] Tommy: Right, exactly.

[1:06:44] Jimi: Um whereas how to succeed.

[1:06:46] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:06:47] Jimi: Um I don't know.

[1:06:48] Tommy: I'm just like no.

[1:06:51] Jimi: I can't I can't I'm not sure.

[1:06:54] Tommy: I find it so fascinating that it is in this company, you know.

[1:06:59] Jimi: Because like these are all the rest of these are not high school standard, you know.

[1:06:59] Tommy: The rest of these are difficult and dramatic and a sign of the times, and like aren't revived, maybe with the exception of a chorus line, um, because they've like made it into popular culture.

[1:07:20] Jimi: I think um more contemporary company excluded Rent Next to Normal and Hamilton because the game has changed since the nineties.

[1:07:27] Tommy: Right.

[1:07:28] Jimi: Um, but like, you know, people don't when they revive Sunday in the park with George, they don't do it because it has big name recognition.

[1:07:36] Tommy: They do it because it's art.

[1:07:37] Jimi: Um when they revive a you know when they revive Fiorello, yeah, like whenever that's never gonna happen.

[1:07:45] Tommy: Um you know, South Pacific, like they're not opera companies do South Pacific.

[1:07:51] Jimi: Um opera companies don't do how to succeed in business without really trying.

[1:07:56] Tommy: No, they don't.

[1:07:57] Jimi: Yeah, but even like you know, uh comedy troops.

[1:08:00] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:08:01] Jimi: I d I don't I don't know what comedy troops do.

[1:08:04] Tommy: But if they ever decided to do a musical, I don't think they'd leaf through and be like, oh well, we're obviously gonna just pick how to succeed.

[1:08:11] Jimi: Right.

[1:08:13] Tommy: No, it's not even if it's time, it's I wouldn't say it's still the funny.

[1:08:16] Jimi: You know, my my mother isn't gonna be like, oh, how to succeed that show I love.

[1:08:20] Tommy: I'm gonna go see it, you know?

[1:08:22] Jimi: Right.

[1:08:22] Tommy: Like, people aren't gonna fly to New York because, like, oh, my favorite show, How to Succeed in Business without Really Trying is getting revived.

[1:08:28] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:08:29] Tommy: Except for you with the you know, pirate dance poster on your wall, whoever you are.

[1:08:33] Jimi: Exactly.

[1:08:34] Tommy: We know you're no exception.

[1:08:36] Jimi: We're really grateful that for your existence.

[1:08:38] Tommy: Um yeah, it's so tricky, it's so odd.

[1:08:42] Jimi: Well, and it's what happened.

[1:08:44] Tommy: And like the the thing that I find fascinating about it is certainly you look at this progression of nine musicals and you see that the musicals have changed with the times, but I if you pick out the criteria that makes them Pulitzer winners, I don't think that criteria has changed much since 1932.

[1:09:03] Jimi: Absolutely, which makes how to succeed stick out even more.

[1:09:08] Tommy: Yeah, what the hell?

[1:09:10] Jimi: Like South Pacific was as revolutionary for its time as Hamilton is nowadays.

[1:09:15] Tommy: Absolutely.

[1:09:16] Jimi: How does it read more on this?

[1:09:18] Tommy: I want to read more on this because there has to be something going on there.

[1:09:21] Jimi: And and I looked at, let me see if I can find it again.

[1:09:25] Tommy: Um 1962 Tony Awards.

[1:09:28] Jimi: I looked at the um The Year. The year. What else was contemporary? It was the sixth. The forum was that season, wasn't it? No, it was the 16th Tony Awards. Um so the nominees for Best Musical were How to Succeed, Carnival, Milk and Honey, and No Strings. I mean, Milk and Honey was robbed. Hashtag Justice for Milk and Honey. Yeah. And because so the Pulitzer can go to any drama. The plays were A Man for All Seasons, Gideon, which I don't know, The Caretaker by Harold Pinter, and Night of the Iguana by Tennessee Williams. So like wow, wow. It's not it's not a bad year. Um, and how to succeed beat those two for something that is intelligent and insightful and filled with smarts or whatever a Pulitzer is supposed to represent.

Mm-hmm. This is why it is so fascinating. And maybe it is a weird political quirk of nineteen sixty-two, um, because they award him the year after, but it is fascinating. It really is, and it's a really underexplored corner of you know, Broadway history and idiosyncrasy. I think that about the show in total though, because it's one of those ones everyone everyone knows it.

[1:10:45] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:10:45] Jimi: Whether it's just the fact it's got a really long title, so people just remember it for that reason. Uh-huh. But everyone really kind of knows it.

[1:10:53] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:10:53] Jimi: Um, and yet you know, you'd be like, ah, sing it, sing me a song.

[1:10:58] Tommy: Right.

[1:10:59] Jimi: Yeah, that's what I was gonna say. Like, name tell me the name of one of the tunes.

[1:11:03] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:11:04] Jimi: What's the name of the main character?

[1:11:05] Tommy: Right.

[1:11:06] Jimi: You'd have to think about it for a second.

[1:11:09] Tommy: Right.

[1:11:09] Jimi: You know, as I s they're not they're not pop songs, they're not covered on the radio. So how how did this one I and I do I do wonder, I do hearken back to I wonder if it was just a New York show, and that was what like that gave it its oomph. It was so explicitly tied to like the commonality average experience of the New York working man of the time.

[1:11:33] Tommy: And that was something that made it popular and interesting above the rest.

[1:11:39] Jimi: I mean, that's it, like it it was contemporary.

[1:11:42] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:11:42] Jimi: Yeah. You know?

[1:11:44] Tommy: We yeah, so maybe people were just like, Oh, oh finally.

[1:11:47] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:11:51] Tommy: I wonder if it's popular because it was contemporary and non-challenging. Like if it's, you know, the big bang theory of yeah, the of musical theater. Like is not not a whole like it can feel a little intelligent at times, is certainly well constructed, but you're not gonna leave in nineteen sixty-one thinking like with your life changed, with a new, you know, philosophical outlook on life.

[1:12:15] Jimi: And that's because musical theater is a popular culture, you know, sometimes lowest common denominator kind of entertainer.

[1:12:23] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:12:23] Jimi: If that's part of its success.

[1:12:25] Tommy: I wonder.

[1:12:27] Jimi: It's quite interesting. It's like it's um taken a leaf out of its own book.

[1:12:34] Tommy: I mean, it's claimed its way to the top.

[1:12:36] Jimi: That's true, without really trying.

[1:12:39] Tommy: Really?

[1:12:39] Jimi: And nobody you know, you're kinda like thinking like, wait, what have you done?

[1:12:43] Tommy: Yeah, how to succeed in musical theater without really trying. Where are your credentials?

[1:12:47] Jimi: When when we write our thesis on this musical, that might be its title.

[1:12:52] Tommy: Right?

[1:12:52] Jimi: Yeah. There's something fishy going on.

[1:12:55] Tommy: You know, but that's not mm because they did try.

[1:12:59] Jimi: The I don't know, the deluxe recording, they're all on Spotify now, so it's hard to get them confused.

[1:13:04] Tommy: Can I tell you? Sidebar. Because it's been six months.

[1:13:08] Jimi: Um these shows have been sitting in my Spotify for so long.

[1:13:13] Tommy: Right. You know, Spotify generates daily mixes for you.

[1:13:16] Jimi: Yeah, yeah.

[1:13:17] Tommy: My daily mix six is just how to succeed songs.

[1:13:21] Jimi: Excellent.

[1:13:22] Tommy: Spotify has just decided I need a radio station of all the various how to succeed cast albums.

[1:13:27] Jimi: It's literally your favorite.

[1:13:29] Tommy: Don't don't try. Don't even try. You saw I put that note about feminism, you were like, Oh crap, yeah, he's gonna talk about that?

[1:13:36] Jimi: Yeah, gosh.

[1:13:37] Tommy: Awful. That's I think it's the deluxe album or something, it has some of Lesser's demos on it.

[1:13:44] Jimi: Oh, okay, interesting.

[1:13:45] Tommy: And they're they're fascinating. Um it's like has that got the uh Secretary is not a toy in three-four time.

[1:13:51] Jimi: It's got Secretary's Not a Toy in 3-4, and it's got what became Company Way, but was called Company Man.

[1:13:58] Tommy: Um and you can clearly see that they were the songs that they're gonna become, but especially Company Man, it's different.

[1:14:04] Jimi: They made changes.

[1:14:06] Tommy: They they re-he really adapted it and made it fit for theatre. And if this was it, you know, who knows how these demos continued to exist and who he was trying to convince with these things, because I think he was brought on board early in the writing process because it was adapted from a play.

[1:14:21] Jimi: Um, so it's not like he was shopping out this show to someone, he didn't record this demo to sell the show, um, but it exists, and you can hear the changes, and so they made dramatical, important changes to these things.

[1:14:37] Tommy: For sure.

[1:14:37] Jimi: Well, that was it's quite like again. I've got some more tidbits.

[1:14:41] Tommy: Uh so from uh The Secretary is not a toy, that was almost cut.

[1:14:46] Jimi: Huh.

[1:14:47] Tommy: Uh, because they couldn't stage it. They just they were trying everything.

[1:14:50] Jimi: Um, and just nothing was working.

[1:14:57] Tommy: Um when they turned it into a solo, it was um Rudy Valley who was singing it. I can't remember who he played.

[1:15:03] Jimi: Um, and he refused to sing it in three four time.

[1:15:07] Tommy: Weird.

[1:15:07] Jimi: Uh and so um Lesser ended up quitting.

[1:15:10] Tommy: Wow.

[1:15:11] Jimi: Uh so he left for three days and came back.

[1:15:14] Tommy: Um, and then Bob Fosse basically got to work on it, and it was him who turned it into what it is now.

[1:15:20] Jimi: Right.

[1:15:20] Tommy: Um, and that in many ways is his most iconic number from.

[1:15:25] Jimi: The recreation on um the movie, and it is iconic and it it is as interesting as like the rich man's frug is, but pedestrian, not you know, you still believe that these business people could be doing this dance.

[1:15:39] Jimi: Exactly.

[1:15:40] Tommy: Exactly.

[1:15:40] Jimi: They keep that the the character is is still there.

[1:15:43] Tommy: Um so he saved it.

[1:15:45] Jimi: But I find it quite interesting because to me, like that is the most problematic, well, one of the most problematic songs.

[1:15:49] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:15:50] Jimi: Uh in the show, and it was so close to being out, and I'm like, uh, oh well.

[1:15:56] Tommy: Um I don't know.

[1:15:57] Jimi: No, you're right.

[1:15:58] Tommy: Well, I I I do find it interesting that this that song might have been cut, because I don't know if the show would be the same without it.

[1:16:04] Jimi: Um I mean clearly it wouldn't, but uh like it it's it makes sexism a centerpiece of the show in a way that I think that's the thing that m makes it baffling for us.

[1:16:17] Tommy: If a secretary is not a toy wasn't in the show, this would be a cut-and-dry sexist piece because everything else would seem like accidental extra lines that are products of their time.

[1:16:29] Jimi: Whereas the secretary is not a toy mmm pushes it a little more into satire parody commentary land.

[1:16:35] Tommy: Exactly.

[1:16:35] Jimi: That's where the tonal shift changes, and you're like, I don't know what you mean by this.

[1:16:39] Tommy: Right.

[1:16:40] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:16:41] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:16:41] Jimi: And I wonder if and we still don't.

[1:16:43] Tommy: We still don't.

[1:16:44] Jimi: Do you think the bullets are people new, or do you think they just like oh do you think they were just like, ah, yeah.

[1:16:54] Tommy: Take a bow lesser.

[1:16:56] Jimi: You said what we're all thinking.

[1:16:58] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?

[1:17:00] Jimi: Yeah, I it's hard to say.

[1:17:02] Tommy: It's really hard to say.

[1:17:04] Jimi: And there's no, you know, that that paper um from Lawyer Cherry is maybe one of the only academic discussions of this show.

[1:17:13] Tommy: People don't talk about this show in that way.

[1:17:16] Jimi: Because it's you know, it's lowbrow, it's comedy.

[1:17:19] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:17:20] Jimi: But there's a lot of meat in there.

[1:17:24] Tommy: Literally.

[1:17:26] Jimi: Sorry, I've written that whole point.

[1:17:30] Tommy: You always gotta end it with a penis joke.

[1:17:32] Jimi: I know, I know.

[1:17:34] Tommy: But hey, we're a brotherhood of man, so oh wait.

[1:17:36] Jimi: Uh speaking of penis jokes, um isn't it funny that two of the main characters are called Frump and Bigley?

[1:17:49] Tommy: I mean, that's this the not specifically as as a phallic reference, but all their names are supposed to be references to what is what is our dear dear dear president?

[1:18:04] Jimi: What's his favorite catchphrase?

[1:18:07] Tommy: Ah, yes, I understand.

[1:18:09] Jimi: Isn't that isn't that creepy?

[1:18:11] Tommy: And you know, Frump Frump and Bigley.

[1:18:14] Jimi: Do you think this is his favorite musical?

[1:18:16] Tommy: How to succeed in business without really listen but listen to the But he's literally written that book.

[1:18:23] Jimi: He's written that book called How to Succeed.

[1:18:25] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?

[1:18:27] Jimi: It's quite creep.

[1:18:28] Tommy: And also, you know, like these two play the villains through the face of like capitalism.

[1:18:33] Jimi: I can see it is I can see the Saturday night live sketch now.

[1:18:38] Tommy: Like everyone leaves, uh Alec Baldwin alone in his office, and the music bump bump bum bum bump bump starts playing, and he reaches in his drawer and he pulls out a large print copy of how to succeed as a president without really trying.

[1:18:54] Jimi: Yeah, and some Fox News anchor voice comes from the heavens and starts.

[1:19:00] Tommy: So you finally made it to the White House. A great first step. There's one thing you must do.

[1:19:05] Jimi: Get out of the White House.

[1:19:07] Tommy: Yes.

[1:19:08] Jimi: How does the musical end?

[1:19:10] Tommy: He's like, Oh, I could be president.

[1:19:12] Jimi: It's terrifying.

[1:19:14] Tommy: Like listen.

[1:19:14] Jimi: See, right, now you know that.

[1:19:16] Tommy: Listen to Company Man again.

[1:19:18] Jimi: Or it was called Company Way.

[1:19:20] Tommy: Listen to that again.

[1:19:21] Jimi: Because or like the reprise of it.

[1:19:23] Tommy: Uh huh.

[1:19:23] Jimi: Because the list should just end by chanting Frump, Fromp, Fromp.

[1:19:28] Tommy: And it's really, really something else.

[1:19:31] Jimi: Terrifying.

[1:19:32] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:19:32] Jimi: So just wanted to leave you on that.

[1:19:37] Tommy: Just when you think.

[1:19:41] Jimi: Sorry if you used to like how to succeed in business.

[1:19:43] Tommy: Yeah, this is what we're doing now.

[1:19:45] Jimi: Next week we're gonna ruin the sign of music.

[1:19:48] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:20:34] Jimi: Oh, I'm proud to be present.

[1:20:47] Tommy: That was how to succeed in business without really trying.

[1:20:52] Jimi: And we only said the full title like three times.

[1:20:53] Tommy: So that was absolutely great.

[1:20:55] Jimi: Although H2S.

[1:20:58] Tommy: I mean.

[1:21:00] Jimi: Does it feel good to be back, Jimmy?

[1:21:02] Tommy: Oh, it just it really feels great.

[1:21:04] Jimi: I'm not gonna lie.

[1:21:06] Tommy: I'm like buzzed.

[1:21:07] Jimi: What has my life been for six months?

[1:21:10] Tommy: Been living in a hole, clawing your way out.

[1:21:14] Jimi: Literally.

[1:21:15] Tommy: I mean, there's the stories I could tell.

[1:21:17] Jimi: The stories.

[1:21:17] Tommy: I got a quiz question for you, Jimmy.

[1:21:19] Jimi: Oh, I'm excited.

[1:21:21] Tommy: You ready?

[1:21:22] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:21:23] Tommy: The folk singer author of our next musical has shared studio space with friend of the podcast, Dave Malloy. And her artistic connections clearly reflect this. What show?

[1:21:37] Jimi: What could it be?

[1:21:39] Tommy: And I promise you, and this is a promise, it won't be six months.

[1:21:43] Jimi: It'll be seven.

[1:21:44] Tommy: It will be seven.

[1:21:45] Jimi: Exactly.

[1:21:46] Tommy: Exactly.

[1:21:46] Jimi: So we'll see you in seven months.

[1:21:48] Tommy: You should be able to get it by then.

[1:21:49] Jimi: Um if you would like to get in touch with us, you can, whether you want to scorn us for being away so long, or tell us that you're so excited to hear us again, we don't mind.

[1:21:58] Tommy: Um you can find me over on Twitter at Asm Hendrix and YouTube at the same handle.

[1:22:02] Jimi: And I'm MusicalMash on Twitter and Musical Theatre Mash on YouTube, or you can check out our show Twitter, Jim and Tomic, or our website, Jim and Tomic.com.

[1:22:09] Tommy: There's a Reddit discussion.

[1:22:10] Jimi: I guess that's a thing we do.

[1:22:12] Tommy: That is something that is there.

[1:22:15] Jimi: That exists.

[1:22:16] Tommy: That's what people are gonna realize.

[1:22:17] Jimi: They're gonna be like, I was I was dying.

[1:22:19] Tommy: I was dying without a gym and Tomic.

[1:22:22] Jimi: I know.

[1:22:22] Tommy: And we m I must say it, like uh it's been breaking our hearts every time, you know, we see a tweet and and stuff, and uh we we were always gonna come back, but you know, we just people just need a little yeah little rest.

[1:22:35] Jimi: We adore all of you, and thank you for your and thank you for hanging about.

[1:22:39] Tommy: Yeah, I mean not not hitting unsubscribe in your little podcast app.

[1:22:43] Jimi: Exactly, exactly.

[1:22:45] Tommy: Um so if you enjoyed this once more, then tell your friends all about it.

[1:22:50] Jimi: That would be lush.

[1:22:52] Tommy: Exactly.

[1:22:52] Jimi: They can catch up on years of past material, and we're back, baby.

[1:22:57] Tommy: Yay!

[1:22:59] Jimi: So we'll see you next week.

[1:23:01] Tommy: Or in seven months.

[1:23:14] Jimi: Yay, fabulous.

[1:23:16] Tommy: Oh, how great.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred