Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Happy Hour #56: We’re Still Podcasting  - ‘The Last Five Years’

Discuss on Reddit ➤ Support the Show ➤ Get out the tissues to mop those eyes (or ball up and throw!) as the boys get deep with Jason Robert Brown’s classic ‘The Last Five Years.’ This week Jimi and Tommy weigh up who ‘wins’ in this show, if anyone, whether this piece is autobiographical or not - and whether autobiographical shows are appropriate, and debate the nature of creative jealousy, infidelity and Russell Crowe... Read More

From the show: Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour

1 h 34 mins
5/2/18

Featured Shows

About

Discuss on Reddit ➤

Support the Show ➤

Get out the tissues to mop those eyes (or ball up and throw!) as the boys get deep with Jason Robert Brown’s classic ‘The Last Five Years.’ This week Jimi and Tommy weigh up who ‘wins’ in this show, if anyone, whether this piece is autobiographical or not - and whether autobiographical shows are appropriate, and debate the nature of creative jealousy, infidelity and Russell Crowe.

The Last Five Years (Original Broadway Cast)

Amazon / iTunes / Spotify

SHOW NOTES

We got quite deep this week and we imagine there will be some hefty discussion on this one. So, Jamie or Cathy? Or neither? Or both? What do you think? Get on over to Reddit and tell us your thoughts!

The origins of this show were shaky to say the least. This Playbill article shines a light on how it all started.

Here’s a great interview with the man himself talking about the origins of the show and the musical theatre business in general.

If you’ve not seen the trailer, it’s definitely worth watching. Here’s the trailer for your perusal, and here’s the link to the movie!

Jimi gets down and dirty with his thoughts about critics constantly citing a lack of ‘hummable melodies’ and he wants to know your thoughts! Let him know over on Twitter!

AN AWARD WINNING QUIZ QUESTION

Every actor who opened as the leading role from our next musical has won the Tony Award for Best Acting - even when the role wasn’t in this musical. What is it?

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Jimi: Okay, we've talked about this before, haven't we?

[0:02] Tommy: Jimmy's thinking songs.

[0:03] Jimi: I don't think we have, or I don't remember at least.

[0:07] Tommy: So for example, just there, I just said which is Peter Pan.

[0:14] Jimi: Yes, that I know.

[0:16] Tommy: So I have I don't know, I just and I feel like everyone must do this.

[0:19] Jimi: Like little songs that come out whilst you're doing something.

[0:25] Tommy: You might know?

[0:26] Jimi: Because I've got I've got a few.

[0:28] Tommy: Like I'll have like the entertainer.

[0:31] Jimi: Are they I'll have that?

[0:33] Tommy: Or are the songs themed to different tasks?

[0:36] Jimi: No, it's it well that maybe like in some if if someone did some study potentially of you.

[0:44] Tommy: But no, it you know, the other ones like Ride of the Valkyrie, that'll come out.

[0:49] Jimi: Um Indiana Jones theme.

[0:52] Tommy: Interesting.

[0:54] Jimi: Yeah, quite quite an array of songs too.

[0:58] Tommy: They are.

[0:59] Jimi: Um, but if they just pop up.

[1:02] Tommy: So I wait, I thought that was something everyone had.

[1:03] Jimi: There you go.

[1:04] Tommy: I mean, maybe.

[1:05] Jimi: I I don't.

[1:07] Tommy: Okay.

[1:07] Jimi: I bet you do.

[1:08] Tommy: Do you know do you what do you do?

[1:10] Jimi: Like, so you're doing something and you you want to fill that, you know, intensely awkward space.

[1:15] Tommy: Right.

[1:16] Jimi: Of silence whilst you're actually just physically doing something that isn't awkward at all.

[1:20] Tommy: Uh but do you not have like a da da da da?

[1:26] Jimi: No, I don't.

[1:26] Tommy: I'll listen to music, like real music, not music that's like.

[1:29] Jimi: But it's it's not that, it's it's just like a little like, oh, I'm doing a two-second task, and then those two seconds, it's like hold music.

[1:36] Tommy: In in real life.

[1:39] Jimi: No.

[1:40] Tommy: I mean, maybe maybe I'm the odd one out.

[1:42] Jimi: Um I'm sure everyone will let us know.

[1:44] Tommy: But I want people to let us know what is your what is your hold music.

[1:44] Jimi: What is your hold music?

[1:49] Tommy: It's uh it's like, what is your damage?

[1:51] Jimi: What is your hold music?

[1:52] Tommy: What's your time?

[1:53] Jimi: Yes.

[1:54] Tommy: That's what Heather's is missing.

[1:55] Jimi: Maybe that's a mean girls.

[1:58] Tommy: Somebody get us another drink!

[1:59] Jimi: Welcome to Jim and Tomic's musical theater.

[2:01] Tommy: Happy hour.

[2:02] Jimi: Your weekly podcast with sodas and serenades.

[2:06] Tommy: I can't remember.

[2:07] Jimi: I think we've had both of them for different times.

[2:09] Tommy: Stuff it.

[2:10] Jimi: Uh yay!

[2:12] Tommy: We're gonna uh uh uh no wait, no that sounded interesting.

[2:15] Jimi: What are we gonna do?

[2:16] Tommy: We're gonna have to repeat them all eventually, because you know, we're gonna turn into old men doing this.

[2:21] Jimi: Well, exactly.

[2:21] Tommy: There's only so many fruits.

[2:23] Jimi: Yeah, like I fruits.

[2:25] Tommy: There's only so many fruits.

[2:26] Jimi: That's my maybe that's what we can move on to.

[2:28] Tommy: That sounds like uh like a lust-based dating app for gay men.

[2:33] Jimi: Too many fruits.

[2:34] Tommy: God, I've been there.

[2:36] Jimi: Um so hey, speaking of fruits, what are you drinking?

[2:39] Tommy: Um that looks tasty actually today.

[2:40] Jimi: What is that?

[2:41] Tommy: It's very yummy.

[2:42] Jimi: Um, it's called a uh uh backwards cocktail.

[2:46] Tommy: It tastes different whether you drink it from the top or from the bottom.

[2:49] Jimi: It's one of those layered deilies.

[2:51] Tommy: Um it's really clever.

[2:53] Jimi: I love it.

[2:54] Tommy: Did you like that?

[2:55] Jimi: That was great.

[2:56] Tommy: That was really good.

[2:59] Jimi: That was fantastic.

[3:00] Tommy: Um well, I got mine.

[3:01] Jimi: I don't I don't know about it.

[3:02] Tommy: It tastes kind of like uh kind of bitter.

[3:06] Jimi: It's uh I got it from a Borders in Kentucky, but

[3:06] Tommy: Are you sure you didn't get it from a Target in Kentucky?

[3:11] Jimi: Or did that depend on which year you're drinking it?

[3:15] Tommy: It would indeed.

[3:15] Jimi: Maybe that's it.

[3:17] Tommy: Maybe it's just really out of date.

[3:17] Jimi: Oh topical.

[3:22] Jimi: Uh so oh goodness, what does that mean?

[3:24] Tommy: Um so yeah.

[3:24] Tommy: What could we possibly be talking about?

[3:25] Jimi: You have a quiz question for us.

[3:26] Tommy: Don't you dream?

[3:27] Jimi: I do indeed.

[3:28] Tommy: Okay, so this musical is perhaps one of the only musicals with key lyrical changes driven by a post-divorce legal agreement.

[3:38] Jimi: Dun dun dun.

[3:39] Tommy: What could it be?

[3:41] Jimi: It's cats!

[3:42] Tommy: It's not cats.

[3:43] Jimi: It is cat.

[3:46] Tommy: I wonder, maybe, maybe.

[3:49] Jimi: No, what is it?

[3:50] Tommy: What is it?

[3:51] Jimi: It is the last five years.

[4:05] ♪ Musical number: "Goodbye Until Tomorrow" — performed by Anna Kendrick ♪

[5:02] Jimi: Goodbye till tomorrow.

[5:06] Tommy: Goodbye till I recall how to breathe and I have been waiting.

[5:17] Jimi: Ah, playing two thousand and one.

[5:19] Tommy: Two thousand and one screaming out.

[5:20] Jimi: It was a simpler time.

[5:22] Tommy: All those all those tweens.

[5:24] Jimi: Wait, this was our this was our We were tweens.

[5:26] Tommy: We were twins.

[5:27] Jimi: Yeah, this was kind of our be more chill before Tumblr let us get really excited about it, don't you think?

[5:32] Tommy: Exactly.

[5:33] Jimi: Absolutely.

[5:33] Tommy: This was 100%.

[5:35] Jimi: This was like it speaks to me.

[5:38] Tommy: It was popular with musical theater nerds before like we were musical theater nerds in public.

[5:45] Jimi: Exactly.

[5:46] Tommy: I would totally give you that.

[5:47] Jimi: I would totally give you that.

[5:48] Tommy: Yeah.

[5:48] Jimi: Like if you if you if you knew what the last five years was, you could nerd out with the theater nerds across town by having a mutual love.

[5:58] Tommy: Yep.

[5:59] Jimi: Yep.

[5:59] Tommy: You just mentioned, like, do you know, have you heard about this uh snake called Wayne?

[6:04] Jimi: See what the reaction is, and then suddenly you'd be like, ah hey.

[6:07] Tommy: Hey.

[6:08] Jimi: Um so last five years, music book and lyrics by Mr.

[6:13] Tommy: Jason Robert Brown.

[6:15] Jimi: Premiered out of town uh in Chicago in 2001.

[6:17] Tommy: Uh technically just outside of Chicago in a town called Skokie.

[6:21] Jimi: Um Skoky, great name though.

[6:23] Tommy: Which may that's r uh my hood, um, which I think might, and maybe we'll talk about this later.

[6:28] Jimi: I don't know, but may have contributed to why I think this was especially popular in my little neck of the woods because when you say your hood, how how hoodlike for you is that?

[6:38] Tommy: You're not from Skokie.

[6:39] Jimi: I'm not from Skokie, but I had high school friends who saw the premiere of the last five years.

[6:43] Tommy: Cool.

[6:43] Jimi: Just as like a night on the town.

[6:45] Tommy: Not because it was something great, not because it was something that s seemed like it was gonna be fantastic, but just because it was the show in town.

[6:51] Jimi: Um excellent, cool.

[6:53] Tommy: Yeah.

[6:53] Jimi: So um and then it made it off Broadway uh in 2002.

[6:58] Tommy: Eventually.

[6:59] Jimi: Um didn't play for too long, just a couple months, I think.

[7:01] Tommy: Yeah, well, I think it was in kind of the post 911 fallout where things weren't really lasting.

[7:08] Jimi: Yeah, it wasn't.

[7:08] Tommy: Because nobody was going downtown.

[7:09] Jimi: So you know, I mean it wasn't it wasn't a thing.

[7:12] Tommy: Yeah.

[7:12] Jimi: Um so I think it kind of suffered from that.

[7:15] Tommy: Uh and also it was off Broadway.

[7:16] Jimi: Right.

[7:17] Tommy: You know, yeah.

[7:18] Jimi: Uh and then it kind of exploded out at a slew of international productions.

[7:23] Tommy: Japan, Korea, Poland.

[7:26] Jimi: I don't know why I picked those three everywhere.

[7:31] Tommy: Yeah, and also it's not Korea.

[7:32] Jimi: I don't know why I said Korea, or Japan.

[7:34] Tommy: I'm not gonna say that again.

[7:36] Jimi: I don't know why that's so strange.

[7:39] Tommy: Uh Poland, Ireland, Melbourne, Barcelona.

[7:44] Jimi: Barcelona has had a revival.

[7:46] Tommy: Barcelona's done it twice.

[7:47] Jimi: Yeah.

[7:48] Tommy: That's weird.

[7:49] Jimi: Barcelona?

[7:50] Tommy: Like where are you going?

[7:51] Jimi: Last five years revival in Barcelona.

[7:53] Tommy: Oh yeah.

[7:55] Jimi: Um, and of course, it had its West End opening, like actual on West End, uh in 2016 at the St.

[8:03] Tommy: James.

[8:04] Jimi: I'm surprised it took that long.

[8:06] Tommy: But no, but to get on West End.

[8:09] Jimi: Still, this show is but it's never been on Broadway.

[8:13] Tommy: I guess that's true.

[8:13] Jimi: I guess that's true.

[8:14] Tommy: Do you know?

[8:14] Jimi: Yeah.

[8:15] Tommy: That uh that I find that quite interesting that it even went there because it's a two-hander.

[8:19] Jimi: Yeah, because it's so tiny.

[8:20] Tommy: It's it's teensy, yeah.

[8:22] Jimi: Um, but hey, and then of course, in 2014, we had the movie with Jeremy Jordan and Anna Kendrick, which I just watched for the first time.

[8:33] Tommy: Is that you're just watching it now?

[8:34] Jimi: Yeah.

[8:35] Tommy: Oh it was fascinating.

[8:37] Jimi: Yeah, I'm very intrigued to hear your thoughts.

[8:39] Tommy: You're getting the live reactions, it's basically a YouTube react.

[8:43] Jimi: YouTube musical theater nerds react to musicals.

[8:48] Tommy: By the way, why isn't that a thing?

[8:50] Jimi: Fine brothers, are you listening?

[8:52] Tommy: Call us up.

[8:53] Jimi: We look good on camera too.

[8:55] Tommy: We really do.

[8:56] Jimi: We got experiments.

[8:58] Tommy: Um but I feel like that should be one of the things that they jump on.

[9:01] Jimi: Yeah.

[9:01] Tommy: Think about how big music theater is on YouTube.

[9:04] Jimi: I mean d yes.

[9:06] Tommy: Yeah.

[9:07] Jimi: Right?

[9:08] Tommy: I mean it's an undercapitalized market, that's for sure.

[9:11] Jimi: Absolutely.

[9:12] Tommy: And they love money.

[9:14] Jimi: Capitalizing on undercapitalized markets.

[9:16] Tommy: Absolutely.

[9:17] Jimi: That's what we like.

[9:18] Tommy: Um so yeah, so Tommy, yes.

[9:21] Jimi: What is last five years?

[9:22] Tommy: I don't think anyone will have heard of it.

[9:24] Jimi: No one.

[9:24] Tommy: No one.

[9:25] Jimi: Boy meets girl, girls going backwards in time.

[9:29] Tommy: Exactly.

[9:29] Jimi: It's just like the Doctor Who music.

[9:31] Tommy: Right, exactly.

[9:32] Jimi: That's pretty much what it is.

[9:33] Tommy: No, uh, last five years is I mean, pretty pretty standard love story fair at its core, I think.

[9:41] Jimi: It's just a really quaint love story, but the catch is in the structure.

[9:44] Tommy: Um, and the guy's story is traveling forward in time, while the girl's story is traveling backwards in time.

[9:52] Jimi: Either from first meeting through to marriage through to divorce, or the other way around.

[9:57] Tommy: Divorce, backwards to marriage, backwards to first meeting.

[10:01] Jimi: Yes.

[10:01] Tommy: Um without any sort of explicit explanation as well.

[10:04] Jimi: You don't see you you work that out for yourself.

[10:06] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.

[10:07] Jimi: Um there's no lame as style, it's 18, whatever.

[10:11] Tommy: Right.

[10:11] Jimi: You're in.

[10:13] Tommy: Whatever.

[10:14] Jimi: Yeah, no, you gotta you have to figure it out.

[10:15] Tommy: And you it's it's structured so that you can slowly figure it out as it goes.

[10:19] Jimi: The totally and it is what makes the story interesting and successful.

[10:23] Tommy: Without this structure, the story's boring.

[10:25] Jimi: Um because love stories, generally speaking, are kind of boring without something interesting added on top of them.

[10:31] Tommy: Um I think.

[10:33] Jimi: But the it's very specifically structured that the time the two stories cross is on their on their wedding day.

[10:40] Tommy: Um in the original staging, they had two wonderful turntables and they would slowly cross each other in different directions.

[10:47] Jimi: So perfect and simple.

[10:49] Tommy: There you go, nice and easy.

[10:50] Jimi: That's the thing is it is actually that's hard very simple.

[10:53] Tommy: I think shall we just delve straight in.

[10:55] Jimi: Let's do it flying.

[10:56] Tommy: Yes.

[10:56] Jimi: Oh my goodness, keep up with us.

[10:58] Tommy: Um let's talk about structuring.

[11:00] Jimi: Let's do it.

[11:02] Tommy: I'm breaking my mother's heart.

[11:05] Jimi: The JCC of Spring Valley is shaking and crumbling to the ground.

[11:11] Tommy: And my grandfather's rolling rolling in the score.

[11:19] Jimi: If you had a tattoo, that wouldn't matter.

[11:23] Tommy: If you had a shaved head, that'd be cool.

[11:26] Jimi: If you came from Spain or Japan or the back of a van, just as long as you're not from Hebrew school.

[11:32] Tommy: I say now I'm getting somewhere.

[11:35] Jimi: I'm finally breaking.

[11:39] Tommy: I say, hey, hey, shit goddess.

[11:43] Jimi: I've been waiting for someone like you.

[11:50] Tommy: So yeah, I think that's one of the really kind of key and beautiful things about this show is it is so simple.

[11:57] Jimi: It's not it's not doing anything that's complicated.

[12:00] Tommy: No.

[12:01] Jimi: They're not have it, you know.

[12:03] Tommy: They're not trying to do any sort of Chekhov's gun style things really that much either.

[12:08] Jimi: No.

[12:08] Tommy: It's just two it's one story told in two different directions, two different perspectives.

[12:16] Jimi: I don't think it's a a caricature.

[12:18] Tommy: It's not terribly exaggerated, but like, you know, they fall in and out of love.

[12:23] Jimi: It really approaches, I think, a lot of the simple love story stereotypes.

[12:29] Tommy: The minute you get married, every other woman in the world finds you attractive, the guy cheats on the girl, no one needs to know.

[12:35] Jimi: Like, oh d like this is simple bread and butter stuff, but told in a beautiful way, which is a thing that Jason Robert Brown does very well.

[12:44] Tommy: He does indeed.

[12:46] Jimi: In fact, shall we jump on that just now?

[12:47] Tommy: Let's just jump on that just now.

[12:48] Jimi: So, like you're saying about the kind of simple bread and butter.

[12:51] Tommy: I think if we're looking at the musical theatre oeuvre and our kind of timeline, as we've kind of already said um with Songs for a New World, when this kind of started to happen, I feel like this is Jason Robert Byrne kind of cashing in on his the thing that he started.

[13:08] Tommy: Yes.

[13:08] Jimi: Um it is almost a kind of song cycly vibe here where they're using these simple sit relatable situations to extend into metaphor.

[13:22] Jimi: Which actually we've been given a literary term by one of our listeners as to what this is called.

[13:27] Tommy: Um so let's get literal.

[13:29] Jimi: Uh it's called metaphysical wit.

[13:32] Tommy: Metaphysical wit.

[13:34] Jimi: Metaphysical wit.

[13:35] Tommy: And it is that sense of like you, you know, you stand on a piece of gum, um, and it is a metaphor for how as you go through life, things bounce off you and some things stick, and you know, I mean, like something's right.

[13:48] Jimi: Like it's that kind of idea.

[13:50] Tommy: Expanding the pedestrian into something bigger, maybe.

[13:55] Jimi: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

[13:56] Tommy: Um, and you know, very much this this contemporary musical theater song uh an inverted commas.

[14:03] Jimi: Right.

[14:03] Tommy: Um really that is that is almost the the defining factor um of a lot of it.

[14:10] Jimi: And it's you you you do get it quite a lot here.

[14:13] Tommy: Right.

[14:13] Jimi: And I and it is intentional.

[14:15] Tommy: I forget which uh Jason Robert Brown interview I was reading, but he talks about one of the he want he went into this wanting to write a simple, elegant love story with good music, but the problem he found was it was very easy for the audience to get ahead of the characters, um which then negates and simplifies the story, which I totally agree with.

[14:33] Jimi: And the way to create that mystery without it feeling artificial, is this exact structure is to turn it on its head so you know the ending.

[14:44] Tommy: It's impossible to get ahead of the characters because they already gave it to you, and then you must focus on the story in the middle, how we got there.

[14:53] Jimi: Yeah, for sure.

[14:54] Tommy: Um absolutely.

[14:56] Jimi: So I guess one of the key things that we want to talk about here is how many characters are in this show, Tommy.

[15:03] Tommy: There are two.

[15:03] Jimi: They're rarely on stage together at all.

[15:07] Tommy: Yeah.

[15:08] Jimi: Um but is this the only musical that has that?

[15:12] Tommy: Hmm, maybe.

[15:14] Jimi: It's certainly a structure borrowed from plays for sure.

[15:19] Tommy: There is something very like corely theatrical about this.

[15:22] Jimi: I mean, you know, you wrote it right here.

[15:24] Tommy: There we have a whole term for it, the two-hander.

[15:26] Jimi: Um there are hundreds of thousands of two-person plays that are written with this similar structure.

[15:33] Tommy: There are very few, if any, other two-person musicals.

[15:38] Jimi: Musicals just feel bigger.

[15:40] Tommy: Um I can't think.

[15:45] Jimi: I can think of a handful of like one-person shows.

[15:48] Tommy: Um, but not two-person shows.

[15:51] Jimi: And that's the thing, is like there's even, you know, even if you've got two extremely core characters, right?

[15:56] Tommy: Something like once, for example, you've still got a chorus behind it backing it up.

[16:01] Jimi: And I think that's that's where you've always got that chorus there.

[16:03] Tommy: It's a it's a structure logistical thing that is um eminently comparable to the contemporary cinematic trend of the A B plot, which it might even be inspired by traditional musical theater.

[16:13] Jimi: Um the you know, you think the golden age pieces of musical theater, you would have the A plot and the B plot, and the A plot happens on the full stage, and then they close the curtain and the B plot happens in front of the stage.

[16:23] Tommy: Drowsy Chaperon parodies this to fantastic extent.

[16:27] Jimi: But even something like Hello Dolly, if you follow that structure along with the scenic design in mind, um it goes A B A B A B A B all the way through.

[16:35] Tommy: And in movies, that's the that's termed uh meanwhile back at the ranch, um, and it lets you tell your story the right way, so you can tell enough of your story and then meanwhile back at the ranch and jump to the other plot, while something that we don't have to be too specific about happens off stage in the other plot, and then when what's happening on stage gets too boring or Rita reaches a climax or a moment of mystery, you jump back to the first plot.

[17:00] Jimi: Um and the structure of the show allows this two hander to do an A B plot.

[17:08] Tommy: We can jump back and forth between them.

[17:10] Jimi: Where if it was told forward, it would have to be two characters on stage the whole time, which is a little tiring, I imagine.

[17:17] Tommy: It would be relentless, it would be yeah hellish.

[17:21] Jimi: Yeah, exactly.

[17:22] Tommy: Everyone would get tired.

[17:23] Jimi: The singers, the audience.

[17:25] Tommy: Well, that's it.

[17:27] Jimi: But there you go.

[17:28] Tommy: That kinda hits on its own point.

[17:30] Jimi: Um because obviously having only one person on stage uh pretty much the whole time um the whole show feels very isolated and very bigger.

[17:40] Tommy: Yes.

[17:41] Jimi: Um and it does get very repetitive.

[17:45] Tommy: Um could argue Jason Robert Brown is like, I know that's the point.

[17:53] Jimi: Yeah.

[17:53] Tommy: Um because you know, the whole the whole point is is that you have these two people who have come into this relationship and have never really been cohesive together.

[18:06] Jimi: They've never really had that moment of extreme togetherness.

[18:10] Tommy: Yeah, he I believe Except maybe at their wedding.

[18:12] Jimi: He uses the phrase they're never really in the same place at the same time, both literally and metaphorically.

[18:18] Tommy: Exactly.

[18:18] Jimi: Um so I think that could be an artistic thing, and that's maybe why he didn't do more duetti stuff.

[18:25] Tommy: Yeah.

[18:25] Jimi: Uh because especially someone like Jason Robert Brown, who's very musical, very good at harmony, um, and likes writing interesting harmony, yeah.

[18:35] Tommy: I imagine the temptation would be there to write, you know, just a little bit more.

[18:40] Jimi: Yeah, you could be like, ah, but it'd be so good just to get this cool crunch.

[18:43] Tommy: Right.

[18:43] Jimi: Um, but we just we just don't see it.

[18:46] Tommy: So um I I like to think that it is actually intentional, and you're supposed to just get this sense of this guy doesn't have any sense of what's going on with her, she doesn't have any sense of what's going on with him, and it allows you to believe that the relationship is never gonna work.

[19:02] Tommy: Yeah.

[19:03] Jimi: I mean, I well, I think that is one of the questions of the show.

[19:10] Tommy: And like maybe I I jumped the gun too much, but like don't you kind of want it to work out?

[19:18] Jimi: And it's sad when it doesn't, even though you know that it won't, you know?

[19:23] Tommy: Nah.

[19:24] Jimi: Really?

[19:25] Tommy: Nah, not not in any way.

[19:26] Jimi: And this is actually it, this is the the big discussion that I have with everyone about last five years.

[19:31] Tommy: I think this is gonna be our coup de grade though, so let's not talk about it now.

[19:34] Jimi: We'll we'll dance around it for another 45 minutes.

[19:39] Tommy: Woohoo!

[19:41] Jimi: Uh yeah.

[19:42] Tommy: Okay.

[19:43] Jimi: But I think that is that's a discussion that needs to be had.

[19:47] Tommy: Well then let's let's talk about this.

[19:50] Jimi: Um this this musical has had quite the journey, don't you think?

[19:55] Tommy: For sure.

[19:57] Jimi: And there as our quiz question referenced, um is steeped in a lot of Broadway gossip um and rumors and like exterior show changing forces.

[20:11] Tommy: So shall we shall we talk about that a little bit?

[20:14] Jimi: Yeah, let's do it.

[20:21] Tommy: I'm climbing uphill, Daddy.

[20:24] Jimi: Climbing uphill.

[20:27] Tommy: I'm up every morning at six, and standing in line with two hundred girls who are younger and thinner than me, who have already been to the gym.

[20:43] Jimi: I'm waiting five hours in line, and watching the girls just coming and going in dresses that look just like this, till my number is finally called when I walk into room, there's a lot of men.

[21:02] Tommy: This is an autobiographical musical?

[21:04] Jimi: I know.

[21:05] Tommy: I mean it does just kind of boil down to that like art thing, like, oh, there will always be a piece of me in this.

[21:12] Jimi: Right.

[21:13] Tommy: But I mean, you know, he had a difficult divorce.

[21:16] Jimi: Yeah.

[21:17] Tommy: And what apparently was a tumultuous relationship.

[21:23] Jimi: So the story is uh, you know, a New Yorker who's shot up very quickly.

[21:28] Tommy: Right.

[21:28] Jimi: Um I don't know much about his ex-wife or her life.

[21:31] Tommy: That's intentional.

[21:33] Jimi: Um so who knows how much is there, but certainly for him, like you know.

[21:41] Tommy: So the story goes that Jason Robert Brown began writing this musical when he was married to um New York actress Teresa O'Neill, and they went through a very contentious divorce um with some, you know, divorce agreements that Jason Robert Brown very specifically about this musical um would be allowed to continue to write it as long as it was not directly connected to their life, and specifically that O'Neill was not you know alluded to or referenced in the musical.

[22:14] Tommy: And it's hard to tease out these particular details because they live in lawsuits that ended in settlements and the lawsuits are centered around keeping these details private.

[22:23] Jimi: Um so you know, a lot of this is hearsay and gossipy sort of stuff, which I don't like treading in a lot, but I think informs the story a whole bunch.

[22:32] Tommy: Um but between so from uh performing in Skokie, Illinois, the show was supposed to transfer to um the Kennedy Center, I believe.

[22:45] Jimi: Lincoln Center?

[22:46] Tommy: The Lincoln Center, I believe.

[22:48] Jimi: Um but and was actually initially commissioned by the Lincoln Center and then like given an out-of-town tryout in Skokie.

[22:56] Tommy: Well, something something something lawyers got involved, and the Lincoln Center and as original producers dropped the show and it shopped around for new producers and then eventually and then ended up premiering off Broadway maybe a year or two years later.

[23:10] Jimi: Um very much because Teresa O'Neill alleged, or Therese O'Neill's lawyers alleged that the show was too close to their life, and Jason Robert Brown rewrote some songs and changed the character of Kathy a whole bunch to kind of fit that in.

[23:26] Tommy: Yep.

[23:28] Jimi: And that affects how I feel about this show in some big ways.

[23:32] Tommy: Yeah.

[23:33] Jimi: But it's like obviously the big one is the one that we've already talked about in the quiz question.

[23:39] Tommy: Um that I could be in love with someone like you was about an Irish a Jewish man falling in love with an Irish woman.

[23:47] Jimi: Right.

[23:47] Tommy: And was rewritten to be Shik's a goddess.

[23:51] Jimi: And sources vary that like maybe there was initial protest to that song, and then he rewrote it, but then um O'Neal, you know, kind of backed down a little bit, but then it was too late, and Chicks the Goddess was in the show instead.

[24:04] Jimi: Who knows?

[24:05] Tommy: It's hard, it's really hard to tease some of this stuff up.

[24:08] Jimi: And you know, for structure's sake is the the reason why I care.

[24:12] Tommy: Um Yeah, precisely.

[24:14] Jimi: But so and I would I would love to know what what else was was different because to me, I mean, she's an actress, yeah, uh living in New York.

[24:24] Tommy: Yep.

[24:25] Jimi: Um she isn't, you know, she has jobs, she isn't like Tony Award winning.

[24:31] Tommy: Right.

[24:32] Jimi: Um you know, he is a writer, skyrocketing in fame, skyrocketing in fame in New York.

[24:39] Tommy: Yeah.

[24:40] Jimi: Um you know.

[24:42] Tommy: Like it is interest.

[24:44] Jimi: There's one there's one interview where they dance around whether he's going to call this show autobiographical or personal.

[24:52] Tommy: And that he definitely lands on personal as opposed to autobiographical.

[24:56] Jimi: And he has, because it's become more public knowledge, people have pressed Jason Robert Brown more specifically about this sort of thing.

[25:03] Tommy: And he comes out saying, like, I've got a quote here, um, about asking whether he was trying to demonstrate that someone was right and someone was wrong.

[25:11] Jimi: And Jason says, honestly, I wasn't trying to settle any scores.

[25:15] Tommy: I was just working through the very painful wreckage of a relationship that meant a lot to me.

[25:19] Jimi: Um and so it's definitely walking that tightrope there.

[25:26] Tommy: Yeah.

[25:26] Jimi: But the thing is, uh huh.

[25:28] Tommy: As it at the end of the day, if it's autobiographical, I don't mind.

[25:33] Jimi: Like it's one of those things.

[25:36] Tommy: I think he's done a good job of keeping it as balanced as possible.

[25:42] Jimi: When we get into the big discussion.

[25:45] Tommy: Yeah.

[25:45] Jimi: We'll talk a bit more about this.

[25:47] Tommy: But I think uh, like you say, you write art from a certain place.

[25:53] Jimi: Yeah.

[25:53] Tommy: Um, and you can tie we've talked about this with Sandy before.

[25:56] Jimi: You know, you can tie allusions to your life a lot of the time.

[26:01] Tommy: Yeah.

[26:02] Jimi: Um this one, you know, might be a little bit close to the bone.

[26:07] Tommy: Yeah.

[26:07] Jimi: Uh but I don't know.

[26:10] Tommy: I feel it doesn't make it any worse art.

[26:12] Jimi: In fact, almost it makes it more honest.

[26:14] Tommy: I I think I think I get the feeling you're disagreeing.

[26:18] Jimi: I agree with you on most points.

[26:19] Tommy: I think the thing I disagree with you about is that it's balanced.

[26:22] Jimi: I I feel like this show gives a little more credit to Jamie than he deserves.

[26:30] Tommy: And I only land on this conclusion through the autobiographical lens.

[26:35] Jimi: Um which I think is why I struggle with it a little bit.

[26:38] Tommy: Um Kathy's role reads very much to me as a female character written by a man in a bunch of moments.

[26:46] Jimi: Yes.

[26:47] Tommy: Which simplifies it a lot. You know, if you see more of it, I was astonished by how much more of a character you see just in the movie, um, and like how much more backstory she gets, but like just listening to the album, just seeing the show on stage, Kathy's an actress and a lover, and that's about it. Um, and it is whiny and complainy. Um, and that because it is a maybe autobiographical story where Jason Robert Brown is writing himself and someone else, the fact that the someone else feels a little less complex, a little less fleshed out, a little more one-dimensional feels kind of sexist. Um, I see this in interestingly, like because there are so many, you know, Amdram and semi-professional productions of this everywhere.

I see this in reviews, right? Every review I or a whole bunch of reviews that I've read about these things, especially more contemporary ones, hint at or allude to like veiled sexism and some of the sexist nature of the plot. Um, and like if we're analyzing this relationship linearly, like, like let's say we're trying to lay blame into a relationship and or a breakup. And I know that's not how it works, and like things are much more complex than that, and this is overly simplifying things. Jamie's the one who messed up. Jamie's the one who let his ego go to his head so that he couldn't hang out with Kathy. Jamie's the one who cheated on Kathy. Jamie's the one who like didn't wasn't quite there for Kathy as she was struggling in this difficult time in her life.

But it still reads in a bunch of ways as kind of balanced. You know, I wish Kathy were more flawed. I wish Kathy had also, you know, like I don't see the parts where Kathy isn't trying to connect in this story. Uh-huh. And that to me, because of the authorship, because of the autobiographical nature of it, smacks of sexism.

[27:57] Jimi: Yeah.

[28:58] Tommy: So I just find it really interesting because we seem to be sitting on total opposing camps, which is great. Fascinating. This is what makes for good podcasting. Uh-huh. Um, I would agree, I think it is sexist. It is written through the eyes of Jason Robert Brown, who is I would say quite a no-holds-barred kind of guy. Yeah. Um, not the most here, not the most sensitive. Yeah. Um, what you hear, it's some of his work, um, you know, people he's worked with, you know, things like that. You get the feeling he's very headstrong. Nothing wrong with that. Cool. Um, but I think in this work, I would I would agree that um the joy moments of Kathy aren't hugely joyous. They always feel a little bit hmm.

[28:58] Jimi: Right.

[29:51] Tommy: Um what I would say though, uh huh, is if you flipped the storylines, okay, it might feel slightly different because the first thing you do is you see Kathy in bits, you see a broken woman. Right. And it's hard to build that back up because all you have is you're like, oh, but it's all gonna end crappily for you, isn't it? Yeah. Whereas the first time you see Jamie, yeah, is this like, yes, I'm the best, right? Woohoo! Yeah. Um he does go downhill, but your first impression, the first impression you have is wow, he's charismatic. Right, you know, so um I think where they flit, I mean I don't know, I've never seen it, don't know. You know, no one's ever done that. That would be very illegal. Right. Um, and I haven't listened to it in that way. Yeah. But I do wonder if that would maybe affect it.

[30:51] Jimi: Well, so let me I want to explode those two songs explicitly then. If we go from still hurting to let's say "Shiksa Goddess," um although both "Shiksa Goddess" and "I Could Be in Love with Someone Like You" kind of serve the same purpose anyway. Yes. Um so we start with "Still Hurting," which is a song Kathy sings almost entirely about Jamie. About half of the lines in that song begin with the word Jamie. She says, you know, Jamie's over, Jamie is gone, Jamie has decided, like, is about like I feel so bad for this thing that you have done to me. Um and this thing we had that has gone away, go run, like all this sort of stuff, right? That's our introduction to Kathy, if we're just looking at the story linearly.

Then we meet Jamie, and his initial meet cute song with Kathy is basically a love song that might as well be subtitled "You'll Do." I love that. Yes, it's like you're not all these other people. I guess you're fine. Like that's, you know, I've been waiting through Demica Schwartz and Erica Weiss and the Handleman twins. I've been waiting through Heather Green Blatten, Annie Lincoln, Karen Pinkus and Lisa Katz. Like, thank God you're not these women. Um, and as my boyfriend said as we watched the movie this morning, uh, something like, wow, that's really awkward pillow talk. Like, you're breaking my mother's heart. Thank God you're not all these women. Let's do it. Um that's a that's a shisty thing to do.

That's a shisty thing to do. And even if it's not in the context of the movie where it's just him singing to himself about like how excited he is to have met this girl who is not all the other girls who's different this time. He doesn't say he doesn't say Kathy at all in that song.

[32:36] Jimi: No.

[32:36] Tommy: Um no, he doesn't. Um so two things. Mm-hmm. Two things. Number one, um, if you look at like by the minute I first met you, I could barely catch my breath. I've been standing for years with the phone in my hand like an idiot scared to death. You've got this kind of like puppy dog, oh my god, I'm really, really, really like you. Yeah. Um, like your argument about uh, you know, all the you the all the other girls don't matter now I've met you. That's the same for any relationship. Yeah. Do you know what I mean? But then all the other guys for us didn't matter until we met the one I've met. But then he's like But then he goes through an increasingly list an increasingly offensive list of qualities that wouldn't matter with a negative connotation to them.

Uh-huh. It they it really turns me off. Like, um, some of them, you know, if you had a tattoo, if you had a pierced tongue, it doesn't matter, right? Like, these bad things. If you had these bad things, it doesn't matter. If you came from Spain or Japan or the back of the van, and there's an implicit characterization and comparison between those three things, right? It doesn't matter if you were from Spain or Japan, or you know, popped out of the back of a van. Those things are all the same to me, right? Um if you once were in jail, or if you once were a man, let's not even talk about the transphobia there. Um like, and on and on and on. What's the good quality of Kathy that makes you excited to be with her?

[34:00] Jimi: Yeah.

[34:00] Tommy: Oh no, like, totally. But this is point number two. Okay. This makes Jamie look like an ass. Right. So my point is, if this is autobiographical, if this is personal, he's writing himself as a selfish ass. And I think the majority of reviews um say Jamie is a selfish ass. Um, particularly with the film. Yes. Maybe just because there are more reviews in the film. And maybe because you'd see more explicit stuff there. And certain things have changed, which I completely disagree with, but we'll talk about in a minute. Um there there is that sense of, you know, Jamie. And I think from the get-go, what you have are these two hugely flawed characters being presented to you from stage one. Yeah. You have Kathy who is whiny and um uh like grow up backbone, Kathy, uh, and you have Jamie who is a selfish ass.

And so what you want to see is, well, how the hell did this work? And then you realize, oh, it it never worked. Right. And I think that's the story. I suspect this is why my tinges of sexism are related to it being an autobiographical piece. Because Jason Robert Brown wrote it this way. Um and I I can't I can't quite draw the connection there, which is frustrating. Um, but something about you know, Jamie's an ass, but doesn't quite get his comeuppance at the end. He still breaks up with her. Um, you know, he doesn't fall into a cake like Cruella DeVille in 102 Dalmatians. Um that while he's not exonerated, certainly, he also d isn't doesn't get his comeuppance, doesn't, you know like he's still the controller in the relationship, he's still the manipulator in the relationship, and Jason Robert Brown wrote himself that way.

[36:06] Jimi: That's really interesting that you just said the manipulate thing, because I think again, I think it's a balance.

[36:12] Tommy: I think they both have their moments.

[36:13] Jimi: When do you 100% when do you think Kathy is a manipulator?

[36:18] Tommy: If I didn't believe in you.

[36:23] Jimi: How?

[36:24] Tommy: Jason. Because in that moment, yeah, he is basically saying, This is I am so excited for this part of my career. Um I understand that you are hurting and that you're in a really bad place in yours, and that's fine, it will get there. But for the moment, can you not just be happy for me right now? Yeah. Um, and she relentlessly, you know, keeps hitting him back in the face. Now, that is a couple's argument, right? Right. But I think so. The if we if we relinearalize the story, the counterpoint to if I didn't believe in you is um what's the name of that song? CM Smiling, right? Uh-huh. Maybe not explicitly the same specific time, but that's they're at the same point in the relationship, right?

[37:11] Jimi: Yeah, okay.

[37:11] Jimi: They couldn't, I would say it's more the one before "CM Smiling," which is the one that I never remember, uh, a part of that.

[37:21] Tommy: Hmm.

[37:22] Jimi: Okay. Interesting.

[37:23] Tommy: Because "CM Smiling" is the mirror of, uh, "Nobody Needs to Know."

[37:32] Jimi: Interesting. Okay. I would say the connection I was drawing between "CM Smiling" and "If I Didn't Believe in You" is that they are both very explicitly discussing the moment in their relationship when he starts going to all the parties and she doesn't.

[37:49] Tommy: And they're differing opinions to those sorts of things. He he is of the of the idea that like I need to go to these, it's a job thing. And she's the idea that like it's my fucking birthday, and you don't need to hang out with these jerks again because I know, because they always know, which is a thing she says, that you're gonna be hanging out with these girls in your life who aren't me. And that's a problem, and clearly it is because then he does.

[38:16] Jimi: Yeah, but I think he already has at that point.

[38:20] Tommy: So that's why I always put CM Smiling with Like post um post cheating.

[38:25] Jimi: Interesting.

[38:28] Tommy: You know what I mean? And I think it's because I would say like the um uh if I didn't believe in you party.

[38:38] Jimi: Uh-huh.

[38:38] Tommy: Um because this is the this is the publishing of his book party. This is the first thing. This is the the this is his big moment basically. Yeah um that you know I mean if she got a Broadway show um she he would be wanting you know they she would be wanting she would be wanting him to go to that party.

[38:58] Jimi: Yeah right um so that is this is his big moment and she just can't see that and whether it is just because she's disappointed that she's only just got Summerstock again or uh whether there's this creative jealousy side of things, I think she is being manipulative in that song. I'm not saying he never is, but I'm saying in that moment she is, and that's what I mean about the balance. I think there are these moments that they kind of just compliment each other all the way through. I mean, I do think our disagreement speaks to the success of this show. The fact and like I think the differences in how you would perceive these things do come down to specific directing choices and specific momentary choices. I think you could swing the show in both directions. Yeah, and I've seen I've seen it done.

[39:45] Jimi: Yeah.

[39:45] Tommy: Um and I think what it all boils down to is your I think it depends on your life.

[39:52] Jimi: Yeah.

[39:52] Tommy: It depends what you've experienced. Right. Um as to who you either relate to or who you can see yourself in in different moments, yeah. Um and you kind of you're almost like mentally tallying it up.

[40:04] Jimi: Yeah, that's that's very true. I mean, this one one of the wonderful things of the simplicity of this show is you are meant to read yourself into both halves of this relationship.

[40:13] Jimi: Absolutely, and like picture the arguments you've had or the problems you've had, or the successes and joys in a relationship you've had in these individual moments.

[40:22] Tommy: Yep.

[40:22] Jimi: Um and it's like because I've had like shouting matches about this show, you know, with people because of my opinions and um you know a lot of the musical theatre fans that I know are female for example um and I found certainly tend to side with Kathy.

[40:45] Jimi: Um and I'm not saying all females like with Kathy, whatever. Um but the certain ones that I have and so obviously me and I'm not saying I side with Jamie but I really see Jamie's point um and uh yeah we we just end up really butting heads.

[41:01] Tommy: All kind of comes down to if I didn't believe in you.

[41:04] Jimi: Yeah yeah for sure like for sure because I've been there I you know that's saying is I've been there.

[41:09] Tommy: Yeah.

[41:10] Jimi: I mean yeah I think this will be a disagreement of ours.

[41:14] Tommy: I think if I didn't believe in you she would have been just fine or at least exactly where she is what do you mean sorry?

[41:21] Jimi: So his thesis in that song if you will is if I didn't believe in you we'd never have gotten this far, right? If I didn't believe in you then the implication is like if I didn't believe in you you wouldn't have the modicum of success that you have right now or you wouldn't be pushing and trying.

[41:42] Tommy: I don't believe that that's that at all.

[41:44] Jimi: Okay.

[41:45] Tommy: No I think it's this if he's what he's saying is um if you didn't believe in her and her success and that she was a good actress what she's having these doubts about um what it would mean is that there would be no substance to their relationship. It wouldn't be if I didn't believe in you, you would be shit. He it's not saying I'm the one that's helped you through all of this.

[42:07] Jimi: Uh-huh.

[42:08] Tommy: I think what he's saying is this respect and belief, this like two-way street right we have here.

[42:14] Jimi: Yeah.

[42:15] Tommy: Um, is what keeps us going. Now, what this is the thing that you will always have in creative couples because creative jealousy is one of the the biggest bitches of all.

[42:26] Jimi: Yeah.

[42:27] Tommy: There's there's nothing quite like that feeling because you don't have a leg to stand on.

[42:32] Jimi: Right.

[42:32] Tommy: And a lot of the time, particularly with acting, you can't explain why you didn't get that part.

[42:38] Jimi: Right.

[42:38] Tommy: And there's nothing really more that you can do. It's just that you're not an inch taller, you know? And these things really, really build up inside you.

[42:48] Jimi: Yeah.

[42:48] Tommy: Um it just it feels like to me, it feels like such a selfish statement. If I didn't believe in you, we'd never have gotten this far.

[42:59] Jimi: Mm-hmm.

[43:00] Tommy: Exactly, as in We the Relationship.

[43:02] Jimi: Right.

[43:02] Tommy: Like the Because what he's saying, what he's saying is, I I believe in you. Can you not just believe in me even just this one moment?

[43:11] Jimi: Because what she's doing is like, we can't go to this party because I'm really upset right now.

[43:19] Tommy: Yeah.

[43:19] Jimi: And this is a big big deal for him. This is a big party. This is a very important event. It's like saying, you know, we can't go to your debut night because I'm not feeling it.

[43:32] Tommy: Right.

[43:32] Jimi: And is that why he says, I'm going.

[43:36] Tommy: Yeah.

[43:37] Jimi: That's that. She would be going if it was her show, if it was her Broadway show, she would obviously be going. And that's that. But what's it really about? You know?

[43:46] Tommy: Right.

[43:47] Jimi: And that's what that's what it goes into. And it's this the sense of creative jealousy. Um, because the thing is, I've been I've been on both sides in this song. I've been the manipulative person who's like, I can't get over my own neuroses here.

[44:02] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[44:03] Jimi: And I I don't want you to be happy at this point. Because I'm not.

[44:07] Tommy: Right.

[44:07] Jimi: Um, and I've been on the other side where it's like it's finally going right. You know the struggles that I've gone through and it's going right. Please just be on my side here.

[44:18] Tommy: Yeah.

[44:19] Jimi: Because you're the you're you're actually the only one that whose opinion I care about.

[44:23] Tommy: Right.

[44:24] Jimi: And the fact that I don't have that upsets me.

[44:28] Tommy: Yeah.

[44:29] Jimi: Yeah. I don't know if you've convinced me to like Jamie more, but it's definitely a more complex song, I think, than I gave it credit for.

[44:36] Tommy: So would you say, would you say to kind of close this off?

[44:40] Jimi: Well, no, because that's we've still got to have this discussion. I've already like made half of my points.

[44:47] Tommy: Um I'm excited to hear more about it later.

[44:49] Jimi: Yeah.

[44:50] Tommy: Um yeah.

[44:51] Jimi: But uh ask ask me anyway.

[44:54] Tommy: Would you say to close off this discussion? Then we'll move on to the next thing.

[44:57] Jimi: Well, I was gonna say, would you say that you side with one more than the other? Can you not see it as a balance at all?

[45:09] Tommy: I still I still think Kathy got the short end of the stick.

[45:15] Jimi: I really do. Because Jamie still cheats on her, and that's a problem, clearly in their relationship.

[45:23] Tommy: Um is a problem that was established earlier. The minute you get married, every other woman in the world finds you attractive.

[45:32] Jimi: Yes.

[45:33] Tommy: Like he he's predisposed for this. Um with some really stereotypical sexist undertones. I shouldn't care what she thinks because I can't fuck her anyway.

[45:43] Jimi: Like the Kathy doesn't say things like that.

[45:47] Tommy: No.

[45:48] Jimi: Um she does say manipulators.

[45:55] Tommy: Anyway, no, I think it's it's just it's just interesting. It's just so true because it's it's you know it's two sides of the coin. I 100% didn't expect this. This is fantastic.

[46:05] Tommy: This is great, it's really really good.

[46:08] Jimi: Um let's talk about the movie.

[46:10] Tommy: Let's do it.

[46:11] Jimi: Pause for break.

[46:12] Tommy: I am not always on time.

[46:16] Jimi: Please don't expect that from me.

[46:19] Tommy: I will be late, but if you can just wait, I will make it eventually.

[46:27] Jimi: Not like it's in my control, not like I'm proud of the fact, but anything other than being exactly on time.

[46:39] Tommy: I can do.

[46:42] Jimi: I don't know why people run.

[46:46] Tommy: I don't know why things fall through.

[46:50] Jimi: I don't know how anybody survives in this life without someone like you.

[46:57] Tommy: I could protect and preserve.

[47:01] Jimi: I could say no and goodbye.

[47:06] Tommy: But I want to bear your child I want to die knowing I had a long full life in your count forever share your life with me for the next ten lifetimes no one left who has ever known.

[48:21] Jimi: There are so many dreams I need to see with you.

[48:25] Tommy: So many years I need to be with you.

[49:35] Jimi: So a lot of opinions about the movie.

[49:39] Tommy: Yeah.

[49:40] Jimi: Glad it exists.

[49:41] Tommy: Yes.

[49:42] Jimi: Think it was reasonably well made, to be honest.

[49:45] Tommy: Yeah.

[49:46] Jimi: Um great casting.

[49:48] Tommy: Yes.

[49:48] Jimi: Oh yes.

[49:49] Tommy: Anakin Kendrick and Jeremy Jordan knock it out of the park.

[49:52] Jimi: Absolutely. The first time you see Jeremy Jordan is in his boxer shorts.

[49:56] Tommy: And I mean that's called me that's another big pig, but I'm gay.

[50:00] Jimi: Yeah, we're not. He was sold in that one moment.

[50:02] Tommy: Uh he's very sexy in that song.

[50:04] Jimi: Yes.

[50:05] Tommy: He wins.

[50:05] Jimi: He wins you over.

[50:06] Tommy: Um, yeah.

[50:08] Jimi: Uh but I think what the movie does highlights a lot of the problems with the show.

[50:16] Tommy: It fundamentally changes the story because they're both in every scene.

[50:21] Jimi: Um, which on a surface level is just kind of confusing.

[50:26] Tommy: Yeah, and looks so weird.

[50:29] Jimi: Yeah.

[50:29] Tommy: And they don't do a good job of telegraphing the time travel bit of it all.

[50:36] Jimi: Um yeah, I read uh an article with an interview from the director, um, Richard Le Gravanese. Don't know if that's the correct pronunciation. Sorry, Italy.

[50:44] Tommy: Um, where he was talking about this, and apparently they did a lot of um audience feedback about that, where as soon as it ended, he would like run up on the stage and be like, Do you need signposts?

[50:58] Jimi: And the audience were pretty much like, No, don't spoon feed us.

[51:02] Tommy: Right.

[51:03] Jimi: Um, and they were like, But did you know what was happening? Like, well, no, not at first, but we got there.

[51:07] Tommy: Yeah.

[51:07] Jimi: And I I guess it kind of recasts it as opposed to being two oppositely linear stories, more of a like conglomeration of nonlinear anecdotes.

[51:20] Tommy: It becomes less important, like one like Jeremy Jordan's story is generally traveling forward, and Anna Kendrick's story is generally travelling backwards, but we jump around in interesting ways.

[51:33] Jimi: And you don't quite it doesn't matter, you know, specifically, like whether this was this far back or this far back or that far back or which party it is.

[51:33] Tommy: Yeah.

[51:33] Jimi: You know.

[51:46] Tommy: I would I would agree with that actually.

[51:48] Jimi: I think particularly for the later years.

[51:51] Tommy: Yes.

[51:51] Jimi: Because they don't a post wedding it gets very and if if you don't know the musical, the non-movie musical per se, it gets a little more difficult to tell whether this is a Jamie moment or a Kathy moment, you know.

[52:06] Tommy: Exactly, yeah.

[52:07] Jimi: Um other than the fact that the other person just sat there looking Glaak at the whole thing.

[52:12] Tommy: Like this is the thing that I just didn't get as I was like, Yeah, this is why when you're directing the show, yeah, you never direct it with two people on stage because you never have a conversation where it's like, I'm talking and I'm monologuing and you are smiling sometimes, so maybe like in between Larry's like, uh-huh.

[52:29] Jimi: I don't really get what you're doing.

[52:31] Tommy: Why does this have to be what do you like?

[52:36] Jimi: It's just it's so bad because it's not natural.

[52:38] Tommy: It's really still at all.

[52:40] Jimi: Yeah.

[52:40] Tommy: Um now, could they have ever filmed another way?

[52:43] Jimi: I don't think so.

[52:44] Tommy: Yeah.

[52:45] Jimi: But it what that just does is it highlights a fundamental issue with the material.

[52:51] Tommy: But on the stage, you get away with it because you can get away with stuff on stage.

[52:57] Jimi: So maybe that means you know it didn't make sense in terms of the thing. On the slew of like stage to film adaptations of musicals, I still would rank this one very high.

[53:08] Tommy: I 100% I would agree, to be honest, yeah.

[53:11] Jimi: It captures the, you know, the feeling and the essence of the stage musical while capitalizing on some of the movie tools you get that you don't get on stage, but not overly relying on them and not totally rewriting the story to fit into a movie.

[53:27] Tommy: Yep.

[53:28] Jimi: Um yeah, and I think they do well.

[53:30] Jimi: Like speaking of rewrites, um, you got it there, like the little updates that they make to bring it into 2014. Some of them are pretty necessary. I absolutely laughed this morning. Do you know about so I saw your book at a board was in Kentucky? Do you know the store Borders Books and Music?

[53:46] Tommy: Yeah, we had Borders.

[53:48] Jimi: Yeah, uh, do you have them anymore?

[53:49] Tommy: No.

[53:50] Jimi: Right.

[53:51] Tommy: Liquidation, mate.

[53:52] Jimi: That's so funny. Yeah. And so they change it to Target, which I totally wasn't expecting, and like wasn't intended to be a laugh line, but I'd, you know, miss the next 10 seconds.

[54:01] Tommy: Exactly. It was so hilariously funny.

[54:03] Jimi: It's cute. And I think that's fair. That's the thing, is like a lot of younger people, you know, they're kind of appealing to that somebody generation who might not have found it. I mean, I wonder if that speaks to a bigger question I have about this musical, because I do this musical sits in one of those in a in a contemporary musical theater pocket of hyper contemporary references that sometimes bother me.

[54:23] Tommy: And those are the things they changed. The other one I wrote down here, um, these are the people that cast Russell Crowe in a musical, which is a much better joke than Linda Blair as well.

[54:31] Jimi: Oh my god, absolutely. Because the thing is Linda Blair when she went into Grease was actually okay.

[54:36] Tommy: Right.

[54:36] Jimi: Russell Crowe when he was in the movie of Les Mis was not.

[54:40] Tommy: Like this is Oh my god, wait, I spoke to someone recently who loved Russell Crowe, and they were like, Yeah, I thought he was just amazing.

[54:48] Jimi: Uh and I was like, Did you immediately unfriend them?

[54:51] Tommy: Well, that was they go actually I fundamentally will never get along with you now.

[54:55] Jimi: If you um what's the uh at the beginning of One Day More, it is very easy to use all of the actors' names and slot them into the parts uh they're singing. Russell Crowe, Russell Crowe, Russell Crowe, Russell Crowe, Russell Crowe, Russell, and then when Helena Bonham Carter, Helena Bonham Carter, Hellnab, it's lots of fun to meet.

[55:20] Tommy: Right?

[55:20] Jimi: Yeah. That's how I sing the song for that.

[55:22] Tommy: Okay, I'm into that. Anyway, contemporary updates in musical theater, or like handful after handful of Doritos, which I particularly enjoy, um, but is the sort of thing that will date a musical very quickly.

[55:35] Jimi: Um, email usage.

[55:39] Tommy: Yeah, I feel I'm sure we've talked about this before. I can't remember which one it was in.

[55:42] Jimi: Yeah. I feel like it must have been a contempt.

[55:44] Tommy: Yeah.

[55:44] Jimi: Um, but that's the is when you're doing it's it's like, for example, in Edges. Right. Um, the Facebook song is the most outdated number in all of musical theater now.

[55:54] Tommy: Yeah.

[55:54] Jimi: You know, I mean, like Oklahoma feels more current than the Facebook song.

[55:59] Tommy: Right.

[55:59] Jimi: And so what I wonder, like, is this I feel like this is a a publishing thing that authors should start doing. Um, I've seen it in other places where, like, you know, if you do a show like Spamalot, um, there are a couple directors' notes or you know, stage directions that allow you some changing of some records. You know, like shows playing down the street or shows, even um, I can't think of them now. But there are a bunch of musicals where it's like Well, Avenue Q, for example, um, for only for now.

[56:31] Tommy: Right.

[56:31] Jimi: They'll change they'll let you update it. Um and like give you notes that way. Um because that's important, because it was funny then, and if you don't update it, it doesn't become funny anymore.

[56:44] Tommy: Yeah.

[56:45] Jimi: Um, but it's important, like when you I think when you prep your manuscript to like send off to MTI or whoever, it would it is really important that you highlight these lines and explicitly allow these changes, because otherwise your show is gonna be immediately dated. Especially if your show exists, you know, anytime 1990 or later.

[57:08] Tommy: Um because then it it isn't quite a period piece yet.

[57:14] Jimi: Exactly. Well, I would say anything post-2000.

[57:16] Tommy: Yeah, for sure.

[57:17] Jimi: It's not a period piece at all. And the things that you're talking about are still completely relevant.

[57:23] Tommy: Right.

[57:24] Jimi: Um without it being set in a in a particular time. But what you do is by mentioning these things, you're setting it in a particular time.

[57:32] Tommy: Right.

[57:32] Jimi: And a time that will go over your future audiences' heads if you want the show to have a life beyond here.

[57:38] Tommy: Yeah.

[57:38] Jimi: Which, you know, Last Five Years will live and thrive forever and ever in amateur productions. But like, what happens when we don't have Doritos anymore?

[57:44] Tommy: Exactly.

[57:48] Jimi: You say handful after handful of Tostitos.

[57:52] Tommy: Ooh.

[57:53] Jimi: Is that a rhyme line?

[57:56] Tommy: Yeah.

[57:56] Jimi: Nope. Doritos doesn't rhyme with anything.

[57:58] Tommy: Well, there you go.

[57:59] Jimi: Tostitos is perfect.

[58:00] Tommy: It's Tostito's pizza rolls.

[58:02] Jimi: Yeah. I've I'm really sad that in all my times in the States I've never had a pizza roll.

[58:08] Tommy: You're not missing much.

[58:09] Jimi: Are you sure though?

[58:11] Tommy: Well, I mean, I had a bunch of Scottish candy that one time, so maybe you're missing some things. But like on the spectrum of good American food, Tostitos are pretty low.

[58:21] Jimi: Really?

[58:22] Tommy: Yeah.

[58:24] Jimi: It's quite sad actually. I thought they'd be the best thing that I've just never had.

[58:28] Tommy: Since microwave them.

[58:29] Jimi: Yeah, you can microwave most American foods. We're big on our microwaves.

[58:34] Tommy: Do you have microwaves?

[58:37] Jimi: Yeah.

[58:38] Tommy: You guys don't have kettles though. I still can't go with it.

[58:40] Jimi: We have a kettle?

[58:41] Tommy: We have a kettle. It takes forever because our electricity is lower voltage. But we have an electric kettle that will boil for coffee.

[58:47] Jimi: We don't drink tea. Thank you.

[58:49] Tommy: We poured it all in the hardware.

[58:50] Jimi: Thank you so much for that.

[58:52] Tommy: Uh yeah, you did. There's no we're not going back. Don't mention the tea.

[58:56] Jimi: Um before we move away from the movie though, uh-huh. I want to talk about something that uh almost offends me.

[59:04] Tommy: Okay.

[59:05] Jimi: Uh-huh. Um, and that is in the number called Nobody Needs to Know. Uh-huh. So here's the thing about uh relationships, infidelity, etc. Um now, if you haven't seen the movie, spoiler alert. Uh in Nobody Needs to Know, he Jamie, is it Jamie's song?

[59:34] Tommy: Um well, in fact, if you this from the stage show, uh, is Jamie waking up with Elise, his secretary, um, and you realize that they've been having a relationship whilst he is still with Kathy, he has been unfaithful with Elise.

[59:53] Jimi: Um at the end of the musical, Jamie and Elise are still together. Uh you don't know what happens next. You don't, you know, he's not like I'm marrying Elise, Elise is the one for me.

[1:00:07] Tommy: Right.

[1:00:07] Jimi: Um, but he does kind of say that in uh Nobody Needs to Know. Um in the movie, you have this what I just call I don't know, cinematic jerk off moment where it's like uh Jamie sitting still looking forward with all these women kind of speedily, you know, uh to become one Spice Girls video style run and like drape themselves on him and like sexual positiony stuff.

[1:00:39] Tommy: Um you know, in just including different characters you've seen throughout the whole movie um implying that he has been this mad shagger, um and this is where I have a really big problem because in that moment, yeah, Jamie is undoubtedly a dick. Yes, Jamie is undoubtedly the baddie, yes, Jamie is undoubtedly uh uh uh you can't he kind of doesn't have a leg to stand on, if he's just this mad shagger, right? Being like that's all I really care about is just having the sex, um then yeah, fair, he's a he's a total ass, and Kathy deserves much better.

[1:01:17] Tommy: Um whereas in the musical, he has gotten to a stage where his relationship is so difficult, and he has fallen for Elise. He has fallen out of love with Kathy, and he has since fallen in love with Elise, and they are starting a relationship. Whilst obviously he's still married to Kathy.

[1:01:42] Jimi: But that is completely different to being a mad shagger.

[1:01:47] Tommy: Yes.

[1:01:47] Jimi: Um and why Jason Robert Brown gave that a seal of approval, I'll never know. Um I think it's in that that actual moment kind of made me just not like the film a little bit because it was like, well, it's a different story now.

[1:02:00] Tommy: Right.

[1:02:00] Jimi: You've picked a side and it's just not it's not right. It's it's changing it's changing the story fundamentally.

[1:02:08] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:02:09] Jimi: Um that's that's my thoughts about it. I'm very passionate about it because I think there is I can I can understand Jamie if he just has Elise.

[1:02:25] Tommy: Right.

[1:02:25] Jimi: If it's just Madagascar.

[1:02:26] Tommy: I can't understand Jamie if he's a mad shagger, yeah.

[1:02:30] Jimi: I must have looked down at my notes during that moment, because I don't remember that at all.

[1:02:35] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:02:35] Jimi: I was just I was like, my jaw just like it was one of those like, you know, in um The Mummy?

[1:02:39] Tommy: Yes.

[1:02:40] Jimi: You know the guys, the big mummies with a big mouths.

[1:02:42] Tommy: Yeah, that launched like the spiders out of their mouths or whatever they are, or beetles or something.

[1:02:46] Jimi: Yeah. I was one of them in that moment.

[1:02:48] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:02:48] Jimi: I was just really upset. I was just really upset by it because it's it's also making a statement. It's awful by sexist and chauvinistic that like that's you know? It not not that it like paints it in the biggest of lights, but it there's still some endorsement and condoning of it by demonstrating the promiscuous male in the relationship, you know?

[1:03:15] Tommy: Like that like you can still get out of this and be fine in a couple months.

[1:03:21] Jimi: Um that that's that's that's an expected thing. I'm having emotional struggles. I think this speaks to why I struggle with Jamie's character in general, even if it's just a one even if it's just with Elise.

[1:03:33] Tommy: Um and on the fence, like you're starting a relationship, and then it is hard to end your current relationship while you're being drawn into this relationship you're starting for sure.

[1:03:42] Jimi: Um but that there is this kind of stereotypical expectation that like men are men.

[1:03:47] Tommy: Um Yeah, I think is I don't c I don't I don't think it comes from that. I think it comes from humans or humans, um, and we make connections and connections fade.

[1:03:56] Jimi: Right.

[1:03:57] Tommy: Like I don't know about you, but I have been in relationships that I have been in for far too long.

[1:04:02] Jimi: Uh-huh.

[1:04:02] Tommy: Um and their time was fully up.

[1:04:05] Jimi: Right.

[1:04:05] Tommy: Um, and all I was doing was making myself unhappy by shutting myself off to making connections with other people.

[1:04:11] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:04:12] Tommy: Um because for one reason or another it wasn't right to break up at that time.

[1:04:17] Jimi: Right.

[1:04:18] Tommy: Um I think I think the thing I struggle with is the parts of Jamie and Kathy's relationship that we see failing are their kind of like socio-emotional parts, right? Jamie wants Kathy to come to the party so that they can because they're in love and because they're dating and be or married or wherever they are at that point, um, and they spend time with each other because that's what people in relationships do.

[1:04:41] Jimi: And that's the problem that Jamie has. He's not getting that.

[1:04:43] Tommy: And then the fulfillment we see isn't like Jamie having a good time socially with a girl, it's them having sex, you know?

[1:04:55] Jimi: And there's yeah, but that's the but there's an assumption that other things are going on behind the scenes, but like are we assuming that because of this Jamie and Kathy aren't having sex?

[1:05:04] Tommy: I mean maybe probably, but then like show us that.

[1:05:07] Jimi: But how do you how do you show that in a one-hander in a monologue?

[1:05:12] Tommy: Right, exactly.

[1:05:12] Jimi: Like that's uh certainly a problem with the structure. You know, um but I think what I what I would say is see I'm smiling completely hints towards that they have not had any sort of physical connection, right? Because what she's saying is um we're laughing, yeah, everything's fine.

[1:05:28] Tommy: Right.

[1:05:28] Jimi: That's just you know I mean that's her shining light. Yeah, like, oh, it's okay because we're smiling together. But then he has to go with to be with other people, presumably Elise.

[1:05:37] Tommy: Um yeah, probably is Elise.

[1:05:39] Jimi: And but that's that's the thing. Now, the birthday thing is asshole, like very asshole, and again, keeps it balanced, right?

[1:05:46] Tommy: Absolutely.

[1:05:47] Jimi: Um the birthday thing, like, you know, you could stay with your wife on her birthday. I think that's fair.

[1:05:53] Tommy: Right.

[1:05:53] Jimi: Um but what again, I'm getting very personal, and I don't know if I should.

[1:06:05] Tommy: But like I've you know, I've been I've been at the end of that relationship where it's awful and all you feel is misery.

[1:06:16] Jimi: Like I like very personal.

[1:06:19] Tommy: Okay, but I whilst I was breaking up with uh one of my boyfriends I've had in the past of a long term relationship, um he he just could didn't accept it um and I I had moved on, like I I wasn't in love with him anymore.

[1:06:38] Jimi: Um he I mean, yeah, in so many words it was like no I can't accept this uh I still love you we can work this out and in my head I I was like I d I just I just don't think we can um and he wouldn't get it and it was a long distance relationship and he was staying at mine so he couldn't leave um and obviously we weren't just gonna block each other out and not speak to each other so we were just hanging out right and you know, having good times and laughing and stuff and he was like look we're laughing everything's like why can't we just have this and I'm like it's it's not about that like it's absolutely we can laugh yeah but it that isn't the patch right that it needs right do you know I mean it's so much deeper than that and it's it's we've gone so far.

[1:07:30] Jimi: Yeah, and so when I have a song like "See I'm Smiling," my heart breaks. Yeah, because I get it.

[1:07:38] Tommy: Yeah, I mean, I totally get it. Yeah, but the other side is still there.

[1:07:42] Jimi: Right.

[1:07:42] Tommy: Um, yeah, and yeah, I don't think that maybe why I don't—maybe this is why I get Jamie a little bit more and can see that it was just a relationship that was never gonna work because she couldn't see how much the cracks had opened, just to borrow lines from the show. Um, he had kind of tried as hard as he could, but it just wasn't working.

[1:08:08] Jimi: Yeah, I get that. Yeah, you know, I see that. I do. I think the thing that speaks to me very much is like, because I'm totally conflicted too. I may be on Kathy's side, but only just a bit. But that like how, you know, in the human experience, in you know, this context of the quote unquote breakup, which is like a pretty common human experience on the greater scale. But that it is still nuanced and conflicted and emotional and like no one wins. No one wins this show. No one wins this breakup. They're both worse off than they were.

[1:08:56] Tommy: Um, you know, and it makes it like heart-wrenching and sad. And then like you start questioning, like, but no one, you know, it's just a bullshitty human thing. Like, no one was physically hurt during this. No one, you know, has any lasting physical or emotional or, or sorry, physical or monetary or personal scars, but there's huge emotional scars on both sides and how that develops slowly and surreptitiously, and like, you know, just riding underneath all this guise of happiness. Um, it's a super depressing show from that lens.

[1:09:38] Jimi: I 100% would see it as, and you know, you can't leave being like, uh, yeah.

[1:09:45] Tommy: Right.

[1:09:45] Jimi: Because there isn't—I don't think there is joy in it.

[1:09:48] Tommy: No.

[1:09:48] Jimi: At all.

[1:09:49] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:09:49] Jimi: Even if you think, uh, Kathy will be okay, right?

[1:09:53] Tommy: She's much better off that.

[1:09:55] Jimi: Absolutely. That is a hundred percent probably the case.

[1:09:57] Tommy: And vice versa, they're not meant to be together.

[1:09:59] Jimi: Right.

[1:10:00] Tommy: But you do get the sense of ugh.

[1:10:05] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:10:06] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:10:06] Jimi: You know, I mean, this outpouring of, uh, I think, and I wonder if this is a philosophical difference, but I—the concept I think I struggle with is the like they were or weren't meant to be together, that like that is a thing. From my perspective, I think a relationship exists in the moments and in the specific parts, and certainly you may be specifically predisposed to have a more successful or less successful relationship based on a whole slew of factors, you know, personal interests and commonalities and, you know, rapport and things like that. But like the relationship doesn't exist in stasis.

[1:10:45] Tommy: Relationships exist in moments of interaction, in moments of being together, um, in those songs, in those reactions to each other. Um, if you accept that as a truth, which I think there are arguments against it, but like if you just, you know, move past that, um, it is then I think difficult to make an argument that like, oh, they're doomed from the start. Beyond the structure of the musical, beyond the—well, of course, because it ends with a breakup letter.

[1:11:16] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:11:16] Tommy: But like, you know, they'll never work out, I think is a—having seen plenty of relationships where my initial reaction was they'll never work out, and then 15 years later they're married. Um, like I don't know. It's something that affects my view of this show, I guess.

[1:11:37] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:11:38] Tommy: Yeah, I get that. I do. I think that they're doomed from the start.

[1:11:44] Jimi: No.

[1:11:45] Tommy: But I do think things happen that drive huge cleaves in between them.

[1:11:51] Jimi: Yeah. Do you think—I guess then this is the question. Are there moments in the show where either of them made the wrong choice if the end goal is to stay together? Do I think there could have been like a turning point? Do you think there were points where either Kathy or Jamie could have done a thing that would have more positively affected their relationship?

[1:12:15] Tommy: Like if Kathy was like, fine, I'll go to the party. Like it would work for a point, it maybe would have added, you know, a sixth year to the relationship.

[1:12:31] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:12:31] Tommy: But I think at its heart is this creative jealousy thing. Um, what we never do see is the moments where, you know, Jamie's career actually starts to go down a little bit.

[1:12:42] Jimi: Right.

[1:12:43] Tommy: Um, because he is just on this upswell.

[1:12:46] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:12:47] Tommy: That's just riding and riding and riding.

[1:12:49] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:12:49] Tommy: Um, as we see Kathy kind of go the opposite way.

[1:12:52] Jimi: Right.

[1:12:53] Tommy: Um, we never see that other moment where it's like Kathy's on an up. Um, you have that moment in Schmuel's song where it's like where he's basically saying how much he believes in her and wants her to do well and think she can do well, and that does give you that kind of like hope moment, and then she ends up in Ohio.

[1:13:14] Jimi: Right.

[1:13:15] Tommy: Um, and it's just a really tricky one.

[1:13:19] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:13:20] Tommy: Um, because I think as well with Kathy, you never really know what she wants.

[1:13:27] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:13:28] Tommy: You know?

[1:13:29] Jimi: Right.

[1:13:29] Tommy: She never says I want to be a Broadway superstar.

[1:13:34] Jimi: You know what she doesn't want. I will not be the girl, you know, back at home in the burbs with the baby, the garden of herbs.

[1:13:40] Tommy: Absolutely. Absolutely. You know, she wants that big city moment.

[1:13:45] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:13:46] Tommy: But you don't know, like, is she happy with Ohio? You know, or what is this bigger thing that she wants? Is that a fundamental thing as an actress? I'm getting more on board with your professional or artistic jealousy theory because, yeah, he has the line I will not fail so you can be comfortable, and she has the line about like I'm not gonna be a trophy wife, and those are both in like those are both in congruence with each other.

[1:14:14] Jimi: They agree on that, right? Um, but then he just happens to be more talented in the thing he's doing or have more luck or whatever than she does.

[1:14:24] Tommy: Um, yeah, and that's the thing is I think if he asked her that question and she could reply, and if she was being fully honest, she would say, yeah, do you know what? I want you to fail because this is unfair, right? And that is totally fair. That is the most human reaction that you can have. Yeah, um, you don't want—you know, I mean, that isn't what you want, but that would make you feel better.

[1:14:47] Jimi: Yeah, yeah, because you can—it's all these things with creativity in the industry that you just can't explain, right?

[1:14:47] Tommy: Yeah, well, because there's no reason to it. It's so much luck and, you know, subjectivity and things.

[1:15:01] Jimi: Yeah, yeah, but then it feels unfair when you both—like Jamie doesn't put in any work to get his success other than writing his stories.

[1:15:12] Tommy: Writing the story, yeah, exactly. She puts in three or four songs' worth of work. I'm climbing a hill, you know, all these things. Um, and gets very little out of it.

[1:15:22] Jimi: And that's frustrating.

[1:15:23] Tommy: It is so frustrating. So when your work is incongruent with your results.

[1:15:28] Jimi: Exactly, exactly.

[1:15:29] Tommy: So I'm—this is it. Like I'm not saying, oh Kathy, come on, buck up your ideas. I get it. Like I couldn't—I couldn't cope.

[1:15:37] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:15:37] Tommy: And I think the best solution for them is for her not to date a creative.

[1:15:43] Jimi: Yeah. Do you think people should only date people as successful as them?

[1:15:49] Tommy: But it's not success. It's your industry.

[1:15:52] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:15:54] Tommy: Absolutely. You need to be an extremely strong actor, a strong person who is an actor if you want to date another actor. Because you will always have those moments where one person is doing better than the other.

[1:16:09] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:16:09] Tommy: Do you know what I mean? I don't know if it works in other industries, you know, like someone maybe climbs the career ladder faster than the other one.

[1:16:20] Jimi: Yeah, but there's nothing—there's nothing in acting where you—there's no linear—there isn't a ladder.

[1:16:26] Tommy: Right.

[1:16:27] Jimi: Yeah, it's luck.

[1:16:28] Tommy: Do you know what I mean? So it's all luck. Um, and so it would take a very, very strong person, I think, to hold a relationship with another actor. Um, so no, I'm not saying it's a success thing. I think you can both be successful and you can both be appreciative of each other because one man's success is another man's—I mean, I don't give a shit.

[1:16:47] Jimi: Right.

[1:16:47] Tommy: Like, but it's—I would never—like I would never date another director.

[1:16:54] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:16:55] Tommy: I could—I physically couldn't. I can barely be friends with other directors. Like I find it—I find it so hard.

[1:17:01] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:17:01] Tommy: I find it really, really hard.

[1:17:02] Jimi: That's—and that's my issue.

[1:17:04] Tommy: Right.

[1:17:05] Jimi: That's a hundred percent my thing that I need to go over, but I find it so hard.

[1:17:09] Tommy: That's fascinating.

[1:17:10] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:17:10] Tommy: I mean, what do you think?

[1:17:12] Jimi: I think I agree. Um, you know, I have been, maybe in a lesser extent, but I have been of the opinion that like everyone, specifically everyone in either theater or education or both should have friends or compatriots both inside and outside their industries.

[1:17:34] Tommy: Um, it's important to have people who don't understand what you do, who are a part of your life.

[1:17:42] Jimi: So much because it lets you bounce things off, because it lets you get like an outside opinion, because it lets you vent to someone who is not going to try to provide you a solution.

[1:17:52] Tommy: Um, exactly, and that is so important, especially in a relationship.

[1:17:56] Jimi: Right.

[1:17:57] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:17:57] Jimi: Um, you know, maybe like if we're hypothesizing here, but maybe that's Jamie and Kathy's downfall is Jamie is like, here, here's a headshot guy in a new backstage. I'm gonna help you. I'm gonna do what I can to help you, which of course is the relationshipy thing to do, but it's also not terribly helpful.

[1:18:15] Tommy: Um, because in an industry of luck.

[1:18:18] Jimi: Right.

[1:18:19] Tommy: He can't do anything.

[1:18:20] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:18:23] Tommy: It's really—it's really, really tough.

[1:18:25] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:18:26] Tommy: Jimmy and Tommy solve relationship issues.

[1:18:29] Jimi: We do it all, mate.

[1:18:31] Tommy: We did it all.

[1:18:32] Jimi: Do it. Do you ask Judy or whatever the column was?

[1:18:36] Tommy: Send us your questions.

[1:18:38] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:18:39] Tommy: God.

[1:18:40] Jimi: We'll give you poor life advice in return.

[1:18:42] Tommy: We build a tree house.

[1:18:45] Jimi: I keep it from shaking.

[1:18:49] Tommy: Little more glue every time that it breaks.

[1:18:56] Jimi: Perfectly balanced, and then I start making conscious deliberate mistakes.

[1:19:15] Tommy: All that I ask for is one little corner, one private room at the back of my heart, tell her I found one.

[1:19:33] Tommy: She sends out battalions to claim it and blow it up.

[1:19:47] Tommy: Strips, and faster we're sliding, sliding and spilling, and what can I do?

[1:20:00] Tommy: Come back to bed, kid, take me inside you.

[1:20:08] Tommy: I promise I won't lie to you.

[1:20:44] Jimi: Everyone please. Oh, what I need, nobody needs to know. Nobody to know.

[1:20:44] Tommy: Jimmy, you've written here in our notes document jarring music, hummable melodies, and memorable songs. A rant by Jimmy Mitchell.

[1:21:34] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:21:34] Tommy: What do you mean by that?

[1:21:36] Jimi: So it's not clear from the title. I'll buckle up.

[1:21:40] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:21:41] Jimi: So it's not gonna be a huge rant.

[1:21:43] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[1:21:44] Jimi: But like ninety percent of the reviews, particularly of the movie that I read, were saying like, "the song is pretty crap." Uh, you know, I left, I couldn't remember any of them.

[1:21:59] Tommy: Right, right.

[1:21:59] Jimi: I'm sick of this. I'm sick to death of this. Um, we talked about it in Merrily very briefly. We didn't hit home, I didn't rant. I'm ready to rant. Um, what movie that isn't a musical do you leave from where you're quoting paragraphs of dialogue?

[1:22:17] Tommy: Right.

[1:22:18] Jimi: Which one is that? Sorry.

[1:22:19] Tommy: Oh, wait, none of them, because that's not the done thing.

[1:22:22] Jimi: What? Where did it ever become the thing where you have to leave a musical singing the songs?

[1:22:27] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[1:22:28] Jimi: What, 1950?

[1:22:29] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:22:30] Jimi: Oh, great. Oh, look, we're s 60 years. You know.

[1:22:35] Tommy: 60, almost 70 years.

[1:22:39] Jimi: Is that right?

[1:22:40] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:22:40] Jimi: Jimmy does math, the podcast.

[1:22:42] Tommy: Thank you. Thank you very much. Um, what the hell? Why is—and also these reviewers weren't reviewing things in the 1950s. Why are they saying this?

[1:22:49] Jimi: Well, like, please understand the art form. Please respect the art form because you would respect theatre in that way. You know, if we had a theatre to film adaptation, you wouldn't be saying, "Ah, you know, the monologues weren't memorable." Like, you would not say that. You would be saying, "Oh, it affected me emotionally."

[1:23:06] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:23:10] Jimi: But what you get for this is, "Yeah, do you know what? Like the story was actually pretty good. But as a musical, meh."

[1:23:16] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:23:17] Jimi: What? Are you kidding? You don't understand anything. It is—I definitely saw in a lot of reviews of the movie that like this poked the edges of people who understand musical theatre. Like people came to see this movie who hadn't seen a musical before. And you know, the audience member who's surprised that they're singing. Um, the same way you have in something like Les Mis or Sweeney Todd. Um, I do think that begs the question of does this story have to be a musical?

[1:23:45] Tommy: Absolutely.

[1:23:46] Jimi: But actually, I would a hundred percent say it does because look at the conversation that we've had.

[1:23:50] Tommy: Right.

[1:23:50] Jimi: If this was a play, I don't think we would have been as stimulated.

[1:23:55] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:23:56] Jimi: And if it was just a series of monologues, there wouldn't be as much of a resale value.

[1:24:04] Tommy: I agree.

[1:24:05] Jimi: I think it makes it more interesting.

[1:24:06] Tommy: Yeah, totally.

[1:24:08] Jimi: And that's why—that's one of the reasons why I love the musical data art form.

[1:24:11] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:24:11] Jimi: You know, sometimes more than plays. Because you do connect with it in a different way because the music taps into this part of your soul and you hear it differently than you would if it was just someone speaking it.

[1:24:22] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:24:23] Jimi: Um, sure, okay, you might not leave the bloody theatre after one watching singing it all.

[1:24:29] Tommy: Absolutely.

[1:24:30] Jimi: But that isn't the point. The point is, as with any good book, as with any good play text, you go back to it and you listen and you're like, "Ah, great." Things do not need a hummable melody.

[1:24:44] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[1:24:45] Jimi: They really, really don't. I also like, I hug these songs to myself all the time.

[1:24:50] Tommy: Well, exactly.

[1:24:52] Jimi: I'm sorry they're catchy as hell. Like sure they don't have a hook, sure they don't have a, you know, verse chorus, verse chorus, bridge chorus. Like, uh, fine, thank God they don't have that because that would be generic and boring.

[1:25:04] Tommy: No, the thing is, right, I'm not saying all musicals therefore need to be narrative and discourse, you know, um, discordant and things like that.

[1:25:11] Jimi: No, absolutely not. There's a great time and a place for a bop. I love a bop.

[1:25:15] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:25:16] Jimi: But I'm not saying you can only have one or the other.

[1:25:20] Tommy: Right.

[1:25:21] Jimi: One is much better than the other.

[1:25:23] Tommy: No, the proof is in the pudding.

[1:25:25] Jimi: The pudding is in the content.

[1:25:28] Tommy: The content is in the refrigerator.

[1:25:30] Jimi: The refrigerator is in the kitchen.

[1:25:32] Tommy: Yes.

[1:25:34] Jimi: And that's just my two cents. I hate—I hate that opinion. It's—it pisses me off. And this is why we'll never get respect.

[1:25:43] Tommy: Yes.

[1:25:45] Jimi: Because people are saying this isn't good because X and pretty well because of the song. "Oh, that Last Five Years one, yeah, that's not good."

[1:25:50] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:25:51] Jimi: "Because there's not—there's not—there's no good songs in it."

[1:25:54] Tommy: Right.

[1:25:54] Jimi: What? This is why I will never be a critic, despite how much time I spend critiquing these the things I love, but like that I despise that label. Um, is because the explicit purpose of a critic is to like tell you whether you should go see the thing, right?

[1:26:11] Tommy: Yep.

[1:26:11] Jimi: Um, but somehow that has ballooned into like they're supposed to be the expert, they're supposed to be the person who like knows enough to tell you why you might or might not enjoy it, or you know, why it is well structured or not structured, but somehow the job of critic has instead ballooned into this weird, bizarre, like uninformed commentary place.

[1:26:33] Tommy: Yep.

[1:26:34] Jimi: Um, I hate it. I hate it so much. And I read reviews all the time and hate myself when it happens. Um, but it's just so unnecessary. It's the only way into a show.

[1:26:46] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:26:46] Jimi: And I will read reviews, and those moments where they say X is really bad. I hate those moments. I'm just like, I don't care. I actually don't care about what's bad. Can you tell me what's good? Why should I see it?

[1:26:55] Tommy: Right.

[1:26:56] Jimi: Tell me why I shouldn't see it, please.

[1:26:58] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:26:58] Jimi: I would like to make that decision.

[1:27:00] Tommy: Right.

[1:27:00] Jimi: For myself.

[1:27:01] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:27:01] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:27:01] Jimi: It's really frustrating.

[1:27:05] Jimi: It's really frustrating. And it is a hundred percent affecting people's perception of our art form.

[1:27:10] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:27:11] Jimi: Oh yeah. Because that I would say is the main beef. People don't like musicals. Legit actors, for example, don't like musicals because they're just camp and unnecessary.

[1:27:20] Tommy: Right.

[1:27:20] Jimi: Uh, I'm sorry. You know, we've just spoken for an hour about one. Like, stop it.

[1:27:27] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:27:29] Jimi: I'm good at rants. That was stupid. But like it just—it just pisses—it really pisses me off. And it was just because it was review after review after review, and I'm like, I'm sorry, this is some of the most interesting and intricate music that we've actually ever had.

[1:27:44] Tommy: Right.

[1:27:44] Jimi: Yeah. I mean, Jason Robert Brown does things that other people just don't.

[1:27:48] Tommy: Right.

[1:27:49] Jimi: And like, have you done your research before you've seen this movie? Probably not. And I know you're not expecting your audience to do their research before this movie beyond your review. But that's why you should be doing the research. You're writing the review. You're the shortcut for everyone else. You're not allowed to take the shortcut.

[1:28:07] Tommy: Yep.

[1:28:07] Jimi: So why not just say instead of "the music's crap, didn't remember anything once I left," why not say, "the music sometimes at the start you can't actually quite tap into what it's really about, but when you go home and listen to it on any of the free streaming devices that you can, right? Um, you'll find that there's actually a lot more depth in there, and that's really cool because it's got re-listenable music." Like, come on. Or better yet, "I'm not a music reviewer, so don't feel qualified to talk about the music here. Let's talk about the story," you know?

[1:28:36] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:28:37] Jimi: Yeah. Pisses me off. Take that, movie critics.

[1:28:41] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:28:44] Jimi: And some musical theatre critics as well, though.

[1:28:48] Tommy: A lot of musical theatre critics, I think.

[1:28:50] Jimi: Also, they don't matter anymore, so you know.

[1:28:54] Tommy: Wait, why not?

[1:28:55] Jimi: Because everyone's gonna go see Frozen.

[1:28:58] Tommy: Oh, I see.

[1:29:00] Jimi: Yeah, well, they have to review something.

[1:29:01] Tommy: Yeah, that's true.

[1:29:02] Jimi: Otherwise, they're out of a job.

[1:29:03] Tommy: Well, newspapers are good.

[1:29:04] Jimi: It's a whole dying industry on like 16.

[1:29:07] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:29:17] Jimi: Oh no!

[1:29:20] Jimi: Try, all I could do was love you.

[1:29:27] Jimi: God, I loved you.

[1:29:35] Jimi: So we could find or we could win tomorrow until I crawl to your door and I will be waiting.

[1:30:06] Tommy: You never noticed how the wind had changed.

[1:31:03] Jimi: Just close the kind.

[1:31:50] Jimi: That was The Last Five Years, Jimmy.

[1:31:53] Tommy: That took about five years.

[1:31:54] Jimi: It did.

[1:31:55] Tommy: Do you think the podcast will sound the same or different if you listen to it backwards?

[1:32:00] Jimi: Um, actually what you'll find is if you listen to it backwards, you get a secret recipe for a nice sweet potato pie.

[1:32:10] Tommy: I'm excited to make that sweet potato pie.

[1:32:13] Jimi: Yeah. I got a quiz question for you. You ready?

[1:32:16] Tommy: I'm so—I'm stoked.

[1:32:18] Jimi: Okay. Every actor who opened as the leading role from our next musical has won the Tony Award for Best Acting, even when the role was not actually in the musical.

[1:32:30] Tommy: What could that even mean?

[1:32:32] Jimi: So confusing.

[1:32:34] Tommy: Yes. Um, hey, if you would like to get in touch with us, please do. Um, come find me on Twitter at asinhendrix or on YouTube at the same handle.

[1:32:43] Tommy: And I'm MusicalMash on Twitter and Musical Theatre Mash on YouTube, or our show Twitter is Jim and Tomic, or our website is Jim and Tomic.com, which has a link to the Reddit discussion.

[1:32:51] Jimi: Yes, where you can chat up Storm and tell us who do you side with? Do you side with Kathy? Do you side with Jimmy? Are you in the middle? Do you want to overshare about your personal relationships? Come and do it. Why the hell not? Um, everyone's doing it these days.

[1:33:04] Tommy: Um, and hey, tell your friends all about this podcast. Lyside yours a popular one. Maybe they really love that show. Maybe you're like, "Hey, I know these two guys that talk about this. You should listen to them talk about it."

[1:33:15] Jimi: Yes, you can. And we shall see you next week.

[1:33:19] Tommy: Toodaloo.

[1:33:31] Jimi: Toddaloo.

[1:33:32] Tommy: Remember that one? Throwback.

[1:33:35] Jimi: Bye.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred