Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Happy Hour #60: Waitin’ For My Podcast - ‘Brigadoon’

Discuss on Reddit ➤ Support the Show ➤ Hoots mon! There’s a moose loose aboot this podcast. Time to travel through the mist and into the mythical Scottish town of ‘Brigadoon.’ Expect many references, bad accents and groans from Jimi, as the boys explore Lerner and Loewe’s famous musical... Read More

From the show: Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour

1 h 39 mins
6/14/18

About

Discuss on Reddit ➤

Support the Show ➤

Hoots mon! There’s a moose loose aboot this podcast. Time to travel through the mist and into the mythical Scottish town of ‘Brigadoon.’ Expect many references, bad accents and groans from Jimi, as the boys explore Lerner and Loewe’s famous musical. This time around they discuss how accurate a portrayal it actually is, Jimi gives us a brief history of Scotland and Tommy learns all about Buckfast. Braw!

Brigadoon (1988 London Cast Recording)

Amazon / iTunes / Spotify

SHOW NOTES

There’ll be plenty of ‘authentic’ Scottish references in the show notes for you all to sample this week. Let’s start with Ned culture and The Wee Man who enjoys a Buckfast every once in a while. Gene Kelly, eat your heart out.

One of the potential origins for the story of Brigadoon is the piece of Celtic classic folklore of Tir Na n’Og which you can read more about here!

If you fancy reading more about the history of ‘Brigadoon’ and its impact on Scottish culture you can check out this great book, which also brings ‘Braveheart’ into the mix...

Sir Harry Lauder is one of the biggest names in exporting Scottish ‘culture’ to the world. As kitsch as it is, you can’t deny that it had an effect! Here he is singing his most famous song, “Roamin’ in the Gloamin’.”

Harry Lauder’s impact can be seen in examples such as this: our favourites Fred and Ginger trying their hand (one more successfully than the other) at Scottish culture. Maybe just stick to what you’re best at guys…

A fine example of what Jimi was talking about of these Scottish ditties he learned in school is the Jeely Piece Song. Yes, a song about throwing sandwiches out of a high-rise. Get into it!

If you think bagpipes are just a lot of noise, you would be wrong! Here’s Clanadonia giving us something a bit more traditional and for a bit of difference, here’s The Red Hot Chilli Pipers with one of their famous covers.

If you fancy celebrating Hogmanay wherever you are and feel the need to first foot, here’s a fine recipe for Black Bun. It’s honestly so delicious!

A QUIZ QUESTION FOR DIVAS

A laundry list of actresses were considered to play the title role in this musical including: Mary Martin, Ethel Merman, Gwen Verdon, Bea Arthur, Doris Day, Elaine Stritch, Lena Horne and Judy Garland. But instead the role went to a relative newcomer on the Broadway scene. What show?

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Jimi: Is actually or the history that we know.

[0:02] Tommy: Sorry, Siri.

[0:03] Jimi: I'm listening.

[0:09] Tommy: That's so weird.

[0:10] Jimi: It's because you said history and it heard Hey Siri.

[0:15] Tommy: Grrrr.

[0:17] Jimi: Well somebody get us another drink!

[0:19] Tommy: Welcome to Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour.

[0:22] Jimi: Your weekly podcast with reels and Ribina.

[0:26] Tommy: You made a both of these words.

[0:29] Jimi: I know. So this is something I hadn't really twigged if I didn't bring you in my little like pack of Scottish thing.

[0:36] Tommy: No.

[0:36] Jimi: It was Ribina.

[0:38] Tommy: What is Ribina?

[0:40] Jimi: It's not even to be honest, it's not even Scottish. I think it's just UK-wide.

[0:44] Tommy: Um, but it's lovely. It's like a blackcurrant uh children's soft drink.

[0:50] Jimi: But not like carbonated, just uh Why is that ew?

[0:54] Tommy: That sounds disgusting.

[0:57] Jimi: Aw.

[0:58] Tommy: Oh no, it's delightful. Everyone was raised on Ribina.

[1:01] Jimi: And then it that was Ribina was one of the ones that got it was the first things to get hit by like we need to stop children eating sugar.

[1:08] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[1:09] Jimi: So it instantly got you know reduced and it was just never as good.

[1:12] Tommy: It looks like it looks like black currant?

[1:15] Jimi: It looks like floor cleaner.

[1:20] Tommy: Oh, you've reached into my heart.

[1:23] Jimi: It's like a deep purple and it's got like I like black currant.

[1:28] Tommy: I would picture this like next to the next to the pine salt in the in the washer floor aisle.

[1:35] Jimi: Wow.

[1:37] Tommy: No, it's delightful. It's really nice.

[1:40] Jimi: Um they also do strawberry flavor, which is like the best.

[1:43] Tommy: And everyone knows that.

[1:45] Jimi: I would I would be much more on board with strawberry flavor.

[1:47] Tommy: Yeah, blackcurrant's like the OG, but you know, we all know strawberry so we're at.

[1:52] Jimi: Uh so wait, okay. What's this beef that you have with blackcurrant?

[1:55] Tommy: Well, that's not blackcurrant in general is not a very popular flavor in the US.

[2:01] Jimi: Really?

[2:02] Tommy: Yeah, I I would be hard pressed to think of something I could just walk down to the supermarket and get that just black currant?

[2:10] Jimi: That flavor that is blackcurrant flavored or has blackcurrant in it.

[2:13] Tommy: Yeah now.

[2:14] Jimi: Interesting.

[2:15] Tommy: Well, there we go, the discrepancies are beginning already.

[2:18] Jimi: I don't even know. I mean, it seems gross.

[2:19] Tommy: What does it does it taste like blueberries?

[2:22] Jimi: What does it taste like?

[2:24] Tommy: Tastes like blackcurrants.

[2:28] Jimi: Yeah. Out of here with that.

[2:29] Tommy: It tastes it tastes sweet, kinda bitter.

[2:32] Jimi: Okay.

[2:33] Tommy: Um it's like uh so you're a child, your mom and dad are drinking wine.

[2:39] Jimi: Right.

[2:39] Tommy: You would drink blackcurrant because it would make you feel like you're drinking wine.

[2:43] Jimi: Oh in America we just drink wine.

[2:45] Tommy: No. Ugh.

[2:46] Jimi: Disgusting.

[2:47] Tommy: Um Yeah, it's it's nice. It's it's um a little bit bitter.

[2:52] Jimi: It's got a a slight bitterness.

[2:54] Tommy: Okay.

[2:55] Jimi: Uh but Ribina itself obviously plied with sugar.

[2:59] Tommy: Right.

[3:00] Jimi: It's just a soft drink.

[3:02] Tommy: Yeah.

[3:02] Jimi: Yeah, we and blackcurrants I would say are mostly used as a f uh flavoring. You know, you wouldn't just like go and like and pick up a ton of blackcurrant.

[3:11] Tommy: Do you make do you make like blackcurrant pie?

[3:14] Jimi: Or like no, that would they're too bitter.

[3:17] Tommy: They're too bitter for that.

[3:19] Jimi: Um but we would probably make either blueberries, which I know you have.

[3:23] Tommy: Yes.

[3:24] Jimi: Uh or black um blackberries.

[3:27] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[3:28] Jimi: It's different from blackberry.

[3:29] Tommy: Which is different.

[3:29] Jimi: Yes.

[3:30] Tommy: Did you have blackberries?

[3:31] Jimi: We do have blackberries.

[3:32] Tommy: Did you know most at least in America, most I think it's blueberry flavoring.

[3:37] Jimi: Um doesn't come from real blueberries.

[3:41] Tommy: It it comes from a very specific secretion from beaver anuses.

[3:48] Jimi: You're kidding.

[3:49] Tommy: That's not even true.

[3:50] Jimi: 100% true.

[3:53] Tommy: What?

[3:53] Jimi: Yep. Absolutely true.

[3:55] Tommy: I'm I believe it if it's not blueberries, it's strawberries or something.

[3:58] Jimi: But what they farm beavers?

[4:01] Tommy: I well, I just wonder who was the first person.

[4:04] Jimi: Right.

[4:05] Tommy: It's like that tastes a little bit like blueberries. Let's stick it in a muffin.

[4:12] Jimi: Wow.

[4:13] Tommy: Yeah. So if you have like blueberry flavoured candy or something.

[4:18] Jimi: You're just eating the anus of a beaver.

[4:21] Tommy: Which is not gay slang for something, despite how it sounds.

[4:25] Jimi: Exactly.

[4:27] Tommy: Wow. I'm gonna need to muse on that one for a little bit.

[4:32] Jimi: Anyway. Uh speaking What are you drinking?

[4:35] Tommy: Right. speaking of black currant drinks. What are you drinking today?

[4:39] Jimi: What am I drinking? That's alright.

[4:41] Tommy: I'm drinking this is my ballpark. I got it.

[4:44] Jimi: I think I'll go with we've talked about iron brewery quite a lot, so that's gonna be the obvious answer now.

[4:50] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[4:51] Jimi: So we're just gonna go with buckfast.

[4:53] Tommy: Buckfast?

[4:54] Jimi: Yeah, a lovely refreshing glass of buckfast.

[4:59] Tommy: What is buckfast?

[5:01] Jimi: Uh buckfast is a uh fortified wine.

[5:05] Tommy: Oh that is popular amongst uh what we call the Ned population.

[5:12] Jimi: Um that you have no equivalent for.

[5:15] Tommy: Nope.

[5:15] Jimi: I suspect much of this particular podcast is going to be you saying something very Scottish and me saying what the hell does that mean?

[5:24] Tommy: Exactly, exactly. And I think that's fine.

[5:27] Jimi: Yes. I feel like, yeah, I have a duty here to represent.

[5:33] Tommy: We do have a couple of Scottish listeners, so hopefully they'll be loving this.

[5:37] Jimi: Yes, feeling right at home.

[5:39] Tommy: Yep.

[5:40] Jimi: But no, nobody. Well, no, people do drink buckfast.

[5:43] Tommy: It kind of gets drunk now by hipsters, ironically.

[5:46] Jimi: Got it.

[5:46] Tommy: But it's like an old timey grog sort of ale wine.

[5:49] Jimi: Well, so it's it's made by monks. It's made made in a place called Buckfast Abbey.

[5:52] Tommy: Um the only people that drink it are uh monks and hipsters.

[6:00] Jimi: Well, Ned's and that's the thing is because Mankey it's it's really, really brought in.

[6:03] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[6:03] Jimi: Um it looks like Lord of the Rings reference. How are you with your Lord of the Rings references?

[6:08] Tommy: If it's from the movie, you've got a fighting chance, but that's about it.

[6:12] Jimi: I mean, it's a really, really niche run in the movie. But like what they like try and force feed Mary in the second film.

[6:20] Tommy: Nope.

[6:21] Jimi: It looks a bit like that.

[6:23] Tommy: Got it.

[6:23] Jimi: Perfect. It's basically thick and brown.

[6:27] Tommy: That's what you need to know.

[6:28] Jimi: I feel I'm gonna learn so many things.

[6:30] Tommy: Um You are you're right, it's gonna be great.

[6:32] Jimi: And what are you drinking? I'm intrigued.

[6:34] Tommy: Oh, uh, I'm drinking I'm gonna try this one out, but it might be wrong.

[6:40] Jimi: Water from the Lee.

[6:44] Tommy: Is the Lee a body of water?

[6:47] Jimi: And the Lee would just be like a river.

[6:49] Tommy: Great!

[6:49] Jimi: So I was right.

[6:51] Tommy: Yes.

[6:52] Jimi: Yes, you would. And actually, guess what in Scotland? You can probably do this in the States as well, but you can drink her water.

[6:59] Tommy: Oh, you can't do that in the States. You'll either get radiation poisoning or um oh, I forget what it's called. Um, but it makes you poop a lot.

[7:07] Jimi: Um really?

[7:08] Tommy: Even like in the mountains?

[7:10] Jimi: No, no, no, no.

[7:12] Tommy: Do you know why?

[7:13] Jimi: Do you know why?

[7:13] Tommy: No, I don't.

[7:14] Jimi: Because it's because the rivers are filled with beaver poop.

[7:19] Tommy: Is that actually why?

[7:20] Jimi: Yes.

[7:21] Tommy: Get out of town.

[7:23] Jimi: That's incredible.

[7:24] Tommy: I mean ours are filled with like dead sheep and stuff, but doesn't matter.

[7:28] Jimi: We still drink it anyway.

[7:29] Tommy: Maybe you just have stronger immune systems.

[7:31] Jimi: I think that might be it.

[7:32] Tommy: No, it's love.

[7:33] Jimi: Oh my gosh, the best, the best water I've ever had.

[7:36] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[7:36] Jimi: I was out hiking.

[7:37] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[7:38] Jimi: Um straight from the lee. Straight from this beautiful little brook, pop in the bottle, clear as day.

[7:44] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[7:45] Jimi: Have a sip, and it was just because it was so c it's quite early in the morning, so it was lovely and chill.

[7:49] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[7:50] Jimi: And it was just, I was just like, you know, I was like, energized.

[7:53] Tommy: That just sounds like super refreshing.

[7:55] Jimi: But what Jimmy, why why are we talking so much about Scotland?

[7:59] Tommy: Because we're changing the podcast, guys.

[8:02] Jimi: They're just gonna be Jimmy Till and Tommy stuff about Scotland.

[8:06] Tommy: Um, that is because we're broaching into Scottish musical theatre territory, said in full inverted commas.

[8:15] Jimi: Uh well, hey, we've got a quiz question, I'll see if we can guess what it might be.

[8:20] Tommy: If you haven't guessed already, my goodness.

[8:22] Jimi: Um so the film version of this musical proved that Gene Kelly was afraid of cows.

[8:30] Tommy: So many options.

[8:31] Jimi: So many options.

[8:32] Tommy: So many.

[8:33] Jimi: So many.

[8:34] Tommy: All of those Gene Kelly cow crossovers that we've experienced.

[8:38] Jimi: Um so Thomas, what what could that possibly be?

[9:45] Tommy: Maybe we're gonna put in music.

[9:49] Jimi: Just gonna put that there.

[9:51] Tommy: Um I like as well now that you're doing the singing beforehand.

[9:54] Jimi: Right, yes.

[9:55] Tommy: So as to avoid like 'cause that stumped me, I don't know what's going on.

[9:57] Jimi: Exactly.

[9:58] Tommy: No, I'm I'm I'm Matthew. I do I wish this musical makes me wish every musical began with a chorus of people singing the title of the musical.

[10:08] Jimi: Every single one.

[10:10] Tommy: That would be great.

[10:12] Jimi: What would well I'm trying to I'm looking at the wall now and I'm like, what would be fantastic for that?

[10:16] Tommy: I was about to be like in the heights.

[10:19] Jimi: Oh wait. Yeah.

[10:19] Tommy: You're good by Charlie Brown.

[10:21] Jimi: Oh wait. Yeah, it does create some problems for um a funny thing happened on the way to the forum and how to succeed in business without well, I guess.

[10:32] Tommy: Oh, maybe Brigadoon just doesn't do it well and is why I find it so.

[10:36] Jimi: Maybe that's it.

[10:37] Tommy: Maybe that is it.

[10:38] Jimi: It comes out of yeah, most of the in fact most of these shows that I'm looking at into the woods.

[10:43] Tommy: Yeah.

[10:44] Jimi: Yep, they're all They all tell you maybe it's just so shoehorned into Brigadoon.

[10:49] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.

[10:51] Jimi: It's like we're coming.

[10:52] Tommy: Yeah we come.

[10:53] Jimi: Exactly.

[10:53] Tommy: Anyway, is Brigadoon.

[10:55] Jimi: Well, before we get too far from our quiz question.

[10:58] Tommy: Yes.

[10:58] Jimi: Oh Gene Kelly was uh terrified of a long-horned cow that was used in the film version of Brigadoon, and so he insisted that the cow was blindfolded and chained to the floor, and they put plastic eyes on top of the blindfold so that you couldn't tell that the cow was blindfolded.

[11:15] Tommy: But you can totally tell because that cow is just like what the hell is going on?

[11:19] Jimi: Just like this face that just doesn't move.

[11:21] Tommy: You can't see the chains though.

[11:23] Jimi: They've covered them up with some lovely fake grass.

[11:25] Tommy: Oh man, any anything to rub Gene Kelly in the dirt.

[11:29] Jimi: I'm all about I will say, right? And Highland Cow's defense here.

[11:34] Tommy: Um so we like these are really these are a common beast in the Highlands.

[11:40] Jimi: Like you do see them.

[11:42] Tommy: Um they're probably quite they're probably more docile than like normal cattle.

[11:49] Jimi: I'm saying.

[11:50] Tommy: I bet you they're more than wild American cattle.

[11:53] Jimi: Like I wouldn't get close to a bison or a buffalo.

[11:56] Tommy: Oh no.

[11:57] Jimi: And because that's the thing, so um I th I have a feeling I might even talk about this before in the podcast. If not, it doesn't matter.

[12:02] Tommy: Uh had an ex who um lived on a cow farm.

[12:06] Jimi: Um and so to get to his house, we had to walk through this field of cows, and they would just approach you.

[12:13] Tommy: And they are big, like they are big beasts.

[12:15] Jimi: Uh-huh.

[12:16] Tommy: And the only way that we could like keep them back was by grabbing a massive stick and screaming at them.

[12:23] Jimi: You live in a bizarre weird place.

[12:26] Tommy: I do, I do.

[12:27] Jimi: And that was it, that was all we had to do. I was constantly shitting myself.

[12:33] Tommy: And we're talking like 20 of them.

[12:35] Jimi: Oh, yeah.

[12:35] Tommy: So Gene Kelly, I get it.

[12:38] Jimi: I get it, man. I really get it.

[12:41] Tommy: Uh yeah, so Brigadoon.

[12:43] Jimi: Brigadoon.

[12:45] Tommy: Last week it was our first uh Irons of Flarity this week.

[12:49] Jimi: Our first learner and low.

[12:50] Tommy: Learner and Low.

[12:51] Jimi: Uh music by Frederick Lerner, Book and Lyrics by Alan or sorry, music by Frederick Lowe, book by book and lyrics by Alan J. Lerner.

[12:57] Tommy: Yes, indeed.

[12:59] Jimi: Their first names don't matter. It's like Rogers and Hammerstein.

[13:02] Tommy: Um exactly. Well, I think it's Fritz anyway. I've never seen them actually be called Frederick.

[13:06] Jimi: Yeah, no, that's weird.

[13:07] Tommy: Um Broadway 1947.

[13:11] Jimi: Yep, we're back in the early days once again.

[13:14] Tommy: Um opened over in my neck of the woods a wee bit after uh 1949.

[13:19] Jimi: I think after it had just closed on Broadway.

[13:21] Tommy: It it it lasted well in both uh both areas.

[13:26] Jimi: Nearly, I think for their context.

[13:28] Tommy: Right.

[13:28] Jimi: Yeah, nearly 600 performances, which is huge for that era.

[13:33] Tommy: Um then the Gene Kelly movie, which came out of the uh much lauded Freed Unit in 1954.

[13:40] Jimi: Any movie musical you can think of probably came out of the Freed Unit.

[13:44] Tommy: Probably starring Gene Kelly.

[13:45] Jimi: Probably starring Gene Kelly, exactly.

[13:47] Tommy: Um very excitingly, didn't didn't realize this.

[13:50] Jimi: Um it was represented at the very first Tony Awards.

[13:54] Tommy: Yeah.

[13:55] Jimi: How nice is that?

[13:57] Tommy: Um this is before they even had a best musical category.

[14:01] Jimi: Um, so it wasn't eligible for best musical because that didn't exist yet.

[14:05] Tommy: Right.

[14:06] Jimi: Um, but Agnes DeMille won for uh choreography.

[14:11] Tommy: So there you go, isn't that nice?

[14:13] Jimi: That is nice.

[14:14] Tommy: Um it's been revived a bazillion times. I saw Brigadoon Um maybe in sixth grade at a regional professional theater.

[14:24] Jimi: In the round.

[14:25] Tommy: It's fascinating.

[14:27] Jimi: Was this in Chicago?

[14:28] Tommy: It was North Chicago, yeah.

[14:30] Jimi: It's uh uh called the Marriott Theater. They're a pretty famous uh Was that the one that did the rewrite?

[14:36] Tommy: I don't not that I know of.

[14:38] Jimi: What really was one I'm pretty sure it was in Chicago.

[14:42] Tommy: Yeah.

[14:42] Jimi: Uh wait, is this getting are we too soon?

[14:45] Tommy: We're never too soon.

[14:46] Jimi: What did they change?

[14:47] Tommy: We're never too soon.

[14:48] Jimi: So um they changed the they updated the book.

[14:51] Tommy: Oh.

[14:52] Jimi: Uh but I think this was early 2000s.

[14:54] Tommy: No, that would be too late.

[14:56] Jimi: Well maybe.

[14:58] Tommy: I don't know.

[14:59] Jimi: It's been so long, I don't quite remember.

[15:01] Tommy: Yeah.

[15:02] Jimi: Um 2014.

[15:10] Tommy: 2014 at the Goodman?

[15:11] Jimi: 2014.

[15:12] Tommy: Uh uh, it was it just says Chicago.

[15:16] Jimi: Huh.

[15:17] Tommy: Um so they did they like bring it up to 2014 state.

[15:22] Jimi: Right.

[15:22] Tommy: It was the good man, it was the good goodness gracious.

[15:24] Jimi: Huh.

[15:25] Tommy: Yes. So um yeah, so a guy basically just took the book, totally revived it, um, kind of brought it uh more into well not it wasn't like set in the modern era, but I think they had links with um Jeff and uh uh Tommy, her name.

[15:48] Jimi: Uh they were like World War II vets.

[15:52] Tommy: Oh, okay, interesting.

[15:53] Jimi: Um, and so they kind of brought in this idea of uh yeah, like PTSD and how that kind of it fed into the whole Harry storyline, like Harry, Harry.

[16:08] Tommy: I don't know.

[16:10] Jimi: Their names are impossible to remember.

[16:12] Tommy: I think it's Harry, it was Harry.

[16:14] Jimi: Um yeah, so it you know, interesting.

[16:17] Tommy: Yeah.

[16:18] Jimi: Um apparently it was very good.

[16:20] Tommy: Yeah, I mean I believe it. Goodman does great work.

[16:22] Jimi: Well, before we get too deep into it, what's the what's this show about, Jimmy?

[16:26] Jimi: Well, well, let me tell you, this classic classic Scottish piece of mythology. Uh so uh basically for one day every hundred years, the quaint town of Brigadoon appears through the mist.

[16:45] Jimi: Uh and uh they get to live live a day uh before disappearing again, and uh two hunters American hunters, I must be.

[16:45] Tommy: American hunters.

[16:56] Jimi: Uh Tommy and Jeff stumble upon this this town uh on its day, and they get to go and interact with all of the the villagers.

[17:05] Jimi: Um uh Tommy obviously falls in love.

[17:10] Tommy: Right, because it's a piece of musical theater from the forties, so exactly.

[17:13] Jimi: So he falls in love, but I mean it's only there for a day.

[17:17] Tommy: Right.

[17:17] Jimi: So he has to fall in love pretty quickly here. Um well I won't spoil the ending, you know.

[17:25] Tommy: I won't spoil it.

[17:27] Jimi: There's also a wedding, there's also a chase, um there's lots of catchy songs.

[17:35] Tommy: Yeah.

[17:35] Jimi: I don't know, Brigadou. There's a bat there's lots of dancing.

[17:39] Tommy: Uh um, yeah, no, it it is a it's a funeral, a very iconic funeral.

[17:44] Jimi: Very iconic funeral. It is a manufactured piece of Scottish folklore from an American perspective.

[17:51] Tommy: Does that seem fair?

[17:53] Jimi: Yes.

[17:53] Tommy: Yes, it does.

[17:56] Jimi: I do right, so right, we're just gonna dive straight in.

[17:59] Tommy: I'm so excited.

[18:00] Jimi: Segway.

[18:08] ♪ Musical number ♪

[18:31] ♪ Musical number ♪

[18:40] ♪ Musical number ♪

[19:08] Tommy: So you're you're American.

[19:11] Jimi: I am I'm Scottish.

[19:13] Tommy: Yes. Did you do Americans think that this is a thing?

[19:17] Jimi: That this is what Scotland looks like.

[19:19] Tommy: No, no, no.

[19:20] Jimi: Not we're not there yet.

[19:21] Tommy: Oh.

[19:22] Jimi: Um, do they think that Brigadoon is like a a piece of Scottish mythology? Do they think, oh yes, you know the tale of Brigadoon?

[19:29] Tommy: I bet you your your lay person who has seen Brigadoon could you if you said like, yeah, that's you know, a real piece of mythology, they'd be like, okay.

[19:39] Jimi: You know, I don't think it's the sort of thing. No, I bet you I bet you a large portion of the of like an American's conception of ye oldy Scotland comes from the creation and existence of Brigadoon.

[19:58] Tommy: Well, I'll tell you something. I don't even think it's just Americans.

[20:01] Jimi: Yeah, you think it's bigger than that?

[20:03] Tommy: Oh yeah.

[20:04] Jimi: Um, so yeah, let's have a look at where it all where it all began.

[20:09] Tommy: Um so Scotland's really interesting.

[20:14] Jimi: Uh because our our own history is a little bit odd.

[20:20] Tommy: Obviously we've we've existed for a long, long time.

[20:23] Jimi: Right.

[20:23] Tommy: Um slight bit longer than you guys.

[20:26] Jimi: Uh yes, absolutely.

[20:27] Tommy: I believe you invented the long long time word.

[20:29] Jimi: Haven't you existed since time immemorial? Isn't that part of UK and Scottish and like that corner of the world's founding?

[20:38] Tommy: We've existed for so long that we don't know how long we've existed, and so we're just gonna.

[20:43] Jimi: Pretty much.

[20:43] Tommy: Yeah.

[20:44] Jimi: Pretty much. And that's actually quite key to all of this, Mullarky, because um there's a lot of there's a lot of our history that we don't really know.

[20:54] Jimi: Um particularly it's all of the things that people love about Scotland, all of these different ideas that are relatively manufactured.

[21:07] Tommy: Um and it all happened around the Victorian era.

[21:10] Jimi: Okay.

[21:10] Tommy: Um we all well we owe it all to a guy, um, well not all of it, but a lot of it to uh a guy called Sir Walter Scott.

[21:18] Jimi: Okay.

[21:19] Tommy: That means you might know that name rings a bell.

[21:22] Jimi: So he he wrote his biggest one was uh a book uh called Waverly.

[21:27] Tommy: Okay.

[21:28] Jimi: That was a big big sc Scottish romantic love story.

[21:32] Jimi: Um but he uh was an I think he's a gets included in one of these uh groups of authors called uh the Caleyard or Kailyard fiction.

[21:43] Tommy: Okay.

[21:43] Jimi: Um which uh Calyard I think it it literally translates as something like uh like Cabbage Farm or something.

[21:53] Tommy: Um but it's to do with that beautiful picturesque image of you know Scotland we work in the land uh very earthy and you know Hobbiton and uh all of that malarkey um and very very popular to Americans in particular.

[22:14] Tommy: So also JM Barry, for example, yes, uh who obviously wrote Peter Pan, but is a Scottish man wrote many other pieces of Scottish fiction um actually set in Scotland um and kind of perpetrated this image of like the bucolic Scottish Highlands peacefulness and country and very romantic, you know, all of these were big deep romances of swarthy men and um beautiful red-headed maidens and um it all just fed into itself.

[22:51] Jimi: Um but the big thing was uh so Sir Walter Scott so um after the do you know I don't know how deep to go into Scottish history here, but do you know much about like the Highland clearances?

[23:05] Tommy: Um is that when they have to clear out all the Sunday the the spring um inventory to make way for the summer inventory and so everything gets marked down like 50% at Walmart?

[23:18] Jimi: No, but that would be nice if that actually happened.

[23:21] Tommy: No.

[23:21] Jimi: Um no, so the Highland clearances, um it's actually a horribly devastating thing in our history.

[23:28] Tommy: Um that's it.

[23:29] Jimi: Uh so yeah, basically um after the Jacobite Rebellion, which we spoke about in The Unsung Heroes.

[23:36] Tommy: Oh yes, our other foray into Scottish musical theatre.

[23:40] Jimi: And that's about it anyway. Um so yeah, we spoke about so that was basically um the the kind of last hurrah of Scotland trying to become its own nation uh against England.

[23:53] Tommy: Um England won um at the Battle of Culloden, and uh kind of ever since then it's always been been that way.

[24:02] Jimi: Um but a big part of it uh was getting rid of all these Scottishisms basically to try and strip Scotland of its national identity.

[24:12] Tommy: Um so things like tartan was banned, okay.

[24:16] Jimi: Um you know, showing uh allegiance to your clan was banned.

[24:20] Tommy: Okay.

[24:21] Jimi: Um as well as many other things. So the Highland clearances basically what that um became about was uh uh the I guess like proliferation of um sheep farming um as opposed to like potato farming.

[24:39] Tommy: Right, okay.

[24:40] Jimi: Because Scotland as well got affected by the Irish Potato Famine, uh and so I'm gonna make sure I get back to my point successfully here um but it meant a lot of families were kind of driven out of their crofts uh driven out of their farms um forced to kind of go inward into the city um and kind of this idea of being Scottish it g it was some we had to very much cling to because it was being stripped away from it all over all of this heritage was being stripped away um until uh Sir Walter Scott came along basically and um obviously was a very popular and international author um and we had a visit from I think it was King George I wanna say the fourth maybe the fifth uh one of them a George um around the Victoria's times uh he basically came uh to Scotland uh and um Sir Walter Scott was in charge of uh basically just like celebrating it and like is in charge of like everything almost like the master ceremonies for this visit.

[25:51] Tommy: Okay.

[25:52] Jimi: Um and what he did was basically put on this big show of tartanry and this big show of um bagpipes and all of these like essential Scottish things to make it seem very like oh quaint and kitsch and all of this.

[26:08] Tommy: Yeah.

[26:09] Jimi: And really that's where this all started.

[26:12] Tommy: Got it.

[26:12] Jimi: So there is certainly a feeling that a lot of this is almost it's like early tourism advertising.

[26:21] Tommy: Yeah.

[26:22] Jimi: Absolutely. And so um, for example, you you'll know these things about Scotland that like every family has a tartan.

[26:30] Tommy: Right.

[26:30] Jimi: What clan do you belong to, etc., etc., etc.

[26:33] Tommy: Yeah.

[26:33] Jimi: All of that's actually kind of bullshit, to be honest.

[26:36] Tommy: Yeah, uh-huh, it's complete nonsense because um and actually, weirdly enough, Outlander. Do you get Outlander?

[26:43] Tommy: I have nothing to do with it.

[26:46] Jimi: But I know it exists.

[26:47] Tommy: I think it does I think it is over there.

[26:49] Jimi: Uh-huh. I'm pretty sure.

[26:51] Jimi: Um basically it is a reasonably good representation of this kind of Jacobite time um with the Battle of Claudin and things like that.

[27:01] Tommy: Um because basically you you're you to show allegiance to your clan, you would wear a pin.

[27:05] Jimi: Uh you know, I mean you would have an emblem or a flower, you know what I mean?

[27:09] Jimi: That was how you showed allegiance to Bonnie Prince Charlie was you wore this white flower.

[27:12] Tommy: Um it was nothing to do with tartans.

[27:15] Jimi: Yeah.

[27:15] Tommy: Uh Tartan was just it existed, absolutely.

[27:18] Jimi: Uh-huh.

[27:19] Tommy: But it would just be what can you afford.

[27:22] Jimi: Right.

[27:22] Tommy: Um, and it would be used to show that.

[27:24] Jimi: Yeah, you know what I mean.

[27:25] Tommy: So people What that's the the thing I have always wondered in seeing, you know, how many kilts and how much tartans flying around in the time periods when they say that it should exist, like in contemporary representation of that.

[27:41] Jimi: And like, just from a technology and weaving and dyeing standpoint, that's a lot of time to spend on a lot of really fancy fabric that you're gonna wear all the time.

[27:53] Tommy: Um, so that was the thing, so they would they wouldn't necessarily wear it all the time.

[27:57] Jimi: It would it would be a ceremonial thing.

[27:59] Tommy: Yeah.

[28:00] Jimi: Um but obviously the richer you are, the richer you'd want to look.

[28:04] Tommy: Right.

[28:05] Jimi: Um, and so colours like red and blue uh would be the most expensive dyes uh to to bring in.

[28:13] Tommy: And so that's what they would be wearing.

[28:14] Jimi: It would have nothing to do with the fact that oh you're a Stuart or you're a McGregor or you're a McDonald's.

[28:20] Jimi: You wear this pattern. It was just, yeah, exactly. It was just a case of like I want to have lots of red and blue because I'm really rich and I want to show people that. Fascinating. That's all it would be. Um, but yet there are hundreds of Scottish people that won't know this.

[28:37] Tommy: Right.

[28:38] Jimi: And they'll think, oh yeah, I'm wearing my family tartan.

[28:40] Tommy: Yeah.

[28:41] Jimi: All that all that is is around the nineteenth century. Someone was like, we'll take that one.

[28:46] Tommy: Yeah, and then it became the family tart.

[28:48] Jimi: And since then it's pro it's propagated that way. That's that's really all it is. How do how do Scottish people feel about on a greater sense this, but also just like Brigadoon.

[29:01] Tommy: Um is you know, we've talked about um inaccurate cultural representations for other cultures before, and like there's not a from my perspective at least, there's not a huge Scottish public outcry every time they perform Brigadoon.

[29:18] Jimi: No.

[29:19] Tommy: Um, and I think that that's that's because of a number of reasons.

[29:23] Jimi: Uh huh.

[29:24] Tommy: Um I think is because Scottish people were intensely proud.

[29:29] Jimi: Yes.

[29:30] Tommy: Intensely proud of our heritage, whether it's was created in the nineteenth century or not, we're still very proud of it.

[29:36] Jimi: Yeah.

[29:37] Tommy: Um and we love to celebrate it. We're very traditional.

[29:40] Jimi: Uh huh.

[29:41] Tommy: Uh but I think it's just because we're just a bit low-key.

[29:47] Jimi: Like we know it's pish. Do you know what I mean?

[29:49] Tommy: We know it's trite and we know it's full of all of these stereotypes.

[29:53] Jimi: Yeah.

[29:53] Tommy: But I think all we do is just meet it with a bit of a huh and a roll of the eyes.

[29:57] Jimi: Uh-huh.

[29:57] Tommy: Okay.

[29:58] Jimi: That's how I certainly meet it.

[29:59] Tommy: Yeah.

[30:00] Jimi: And that's how a lot of you know my contemporaries meet it. I'm sure there probably are people out there who are I would say are staunchly against it.

[30:09] Tommy: Um and to be honest, I would imagine there would be people who are like, we get it.

[30:14] Jimi: Yeah.

[30:15] Tommy: Because actually what Brigadoon has done is it's just put up a big ol' signpost in Scotland of being like, give us money.

[30:24] Jimi: Yeah.

[30:26] Tommy: I mean, it it is on a on a on a a certain reading. It is a tourism advertisement for Scotland.

[30:34] Jimi: Absolutely.

[30:35] Tommy: It's about two guys who go on a trip to Scotland and love it so much they need to go back.

[30:41] Jimi: That is hard, that's exactly it.

[30:43] Tommy: Yeah.

[30:44] Jimi: Um it's funny.

[30:47] Tommy: Yeah.

[30:48] Jimi: I do I find it quite interesting. So I have this weird kind of relationship with it. I must say, I'm not as big as fan as a show.

[30:55] Tommy: Just as a show.

[30:56] Jimi: Yeah. Um, I think for as an example of early integrated musical theatre, yeah, uh, it's it's quite poor, I would say, to be honest.

[31:06] Tommy: Um fascinating.

[31:07] Jimi: But I think a lot of that comes from the fact that I just find it hard to listen to.

[31:12] Tommy: Yes.

[31:13] Jimi: Okay. Well, can we maybe this is a good spot for a transition, but can we talk about it as a piece of integrated musical theatre?

[31:20] Tommy: Yeah, let's do it.

[31:37] Jimi: Oh me from here.

[32:13] Tommy: I I'm gonna make a bold statement. That was a bad role.

[32:17] Jimi: It doesn't really matter.

[32:18] Tommy: That was a good it was a good drum roll.

[32:19] Jimi: Um can you do like a uh bagpipe roll?

[32:22] Tommy: A drum roll but with bagpipes.

[32:24] Jimi: What like a like a a pipe band?

[32:26] Tommy: Like yes, but just with the bagpipe.

[32:31] Jimi: Alright.

[32:31] Tommy: No, I'm gonna be able to do that.

[32:33] Jimi: I think the success of Brigadoon is um like proof of the w if Brigadoon was not as as successful as it was, we would have lost the integrated musical.

[32:46] Tommy: Wow.

[32:47] Jimi: I think that and I'd wager that's a bold statement.

[32:50] Tommy: Um reasonably, but I see what you mean.

[32:53] Jimi: Like Brigadoon is probably number three in a line of popular integrated musicals as they exist in American musical theater.

[33:03] Tommy: We went Oklahoma, Carousel, Brigadoon.

[33:06] Jimi: Um Oklahoma and Carousel were both by Rogers and Hammerstein.

[33:13] Tommy: Um and so they were, you know, the pattern was just limited to those two authors, right?

[33:20] Jimi: Yeah.

[33:20] Tommy: And that the integrated musical was a thing that these two kooky guys did.

[33:25] Jimi: And either there wasn't much success with other ones or other people weren't trying it.

[33:29] Tommy: Um, but Learner and Lowe very decidedly wanted to imitate Rogers and Hammerstein's success with Oklahoma and Carousel and went out to write Brigadoon, which I would wager is also more integrated than Oklahoma and Carousel are.

[33:45] Jimi: Yeah, you can see the the upswing.

[33:47] Tommy: Yeah.

[33:47] Jimi: If that makes sense.

[33:48] Tommy: Yeah, like there were all all of the songs are integrated fully.

[33:54] Jimi: Um, and there's only a couple that seem like we're just gonna stop and sing about a thing right now.

[34:00] Tommy: You know, you don't you don't have an everything's up to date in Kansas City dance break that like never comes back and is unimportant.

[34:07] Jimi: Um for the for the most part.

[34:11] Tommy: But for the most part, yeah.

[34:12] Jimi: Like some of the It's so hard it's it's hard to think because we need to remember this is a different time.

[34:17] Tommy: Right.

[34:17] Jimi: We're comparing it to two other shows.

[34:19] Tommy: Right.

[34:19] Jimi: You know, I mean like that's all we really have to compare it to exactly two other shows.

[34:23] Tommy: Yeah.

[34:23] Jimi: Um so yes, no, I I I would agree with you.

[34:26] Tommy: And like even things like my mother's wedding day and like some of the which still kind of stand out as these novelty songs, are still explicitly woven into the plot.

[34:38] Jimi: Yes.

[34:39] Tommy: And so I think, you know, there's I don't know the exact saying, but like do it once and it's an accident, do it twice and it's a pattern.

[34:47] Jimi: And Brigadoon is the twice because we're coming off of Rogers and Hammerstein.

[34:53] Tommy: Um and I think that is why that's why we're talking about the show, I think, because it is important in the transition to the integrated musical.

[35:03] Jimi: And I think even more than Oklahoma and Carousel defines some of those tenets of the integrated musical.

[35:10] Tommy: Like an exposition song sung by the community to tell you where we're at.

[35:14] Jimi: Um you can tell they worked really hard to play with the order we're going to introduce uh salient plot elements at the beginning.

[35:23] Tommy: Like it starts out with Brigadoon and we talk about the two weary hunters who don't say much of anything before we immediately go learn about the town.

[35:34] Jimi: And like come to the fair which is you know, who cares, right?

[35:39] Tommy: It's just to introduce that these are the people who live in this town and then we go back to the hunters.

[35:45] Jimi: Um and like that sort of pattern and that sort of attention to plot an exposition through music is something we see all the time now in contemporary musical theater.

[35:54] Tommy: Yeah.

[35:54] Jimi: Um but is new around now.

[35:57] Tommy: Absolutely.

[35:58] Jimi: I I think I must to give to give Brigadoon its plot is I think McConaughey Square is like way ahead of its time.

[36:05] Tommy: And that's so silly.

[36:06] Jimi: But like it really really is because it is your proper scene setting song.

[36:10] Tommy: Oh yeah.

[36:11] Jimi: That you know by the time the six does rolled around became a standard.

[36:15] Tommy: Oh yeah everyone I mean just look at Beauty and the Beast like the you know Bonjour.

[36:20] Jimi: Like this is an explicit pattern that has been copied over and over in pieces of musical theater that Brigadoon just kinda stumbled upon.

[36:29] Tommy: Totally because it you know it wasn't there it wasn't there in Oklahoma.

[36:32] Jimi: No it's not really there in Carousel it's this was the first time where it was like here we are, we are the people here's examples of the people.

[36:40] Tommy: Right.

[36:40] Jimi: This is what we do.

[36:42] Tommy: I'm I'm not an important character but I'm gonna sing a little diddy about can't put the milk back in the cow to let you know that this is a funny piece and here's how the people act in this world.

[36:51] Jimi: Absolutely.

[36:52] Tommy: Absolutely.

[36:53] Jimi: And it it really is a great way to set up the show because it shows you all of the locations that you'll be seeing for the rest of the day of the day.

[36:59] Tommy: Yep.

[37:00] Jimi: Um it introduces you to all the characters, the dynamics, you see it.

[37:03] Tommy: Oh everyone, this is a lovely place to be.

[37:05] Jimi: Yep.

[37:06] Tommy: Not much bad is going on here.

[37:07] Jimi: Like it's and it's great.

[37:09] Tommy: And it sets you up well because it puts you in uh Jeff and Tommy's shoes because you're introduced to this place from a time forgotten, and then you, the audience member, presumably modern American, are coming into it the same way Jeff and Tommy are, with maybe just a little more information, maybe not.

[37:27] Jimi: Um but then it sets up a mystery, like it does so many good like plot development things that musicals hadn't seen before.

[37:37] Tommy: You know, even just even just that concept of a mystery in a show.

[37:41] Jimi: You know, there's no mystery in Oklahoma, there's no mystery in Carousel.

[37:44] Tommy: Um but I think good musicals thrive on some form of mystery, some form of unknown.

[37:53] Jimi: Yeah, for sure.

[37:54] Tommy: So anyway.

[37:56] Jimi: No, I I'd I would 100% give it as plaudits for that.

[37:59] Tommy: Yeah.

[38:00] Jimi: Brigadoon, the second and more important integrated musical.

[38:05] Tommy: Yeah.

[38:06] Jimi: Um and that's the thing.

[38:07] Tommy: I think, you know, listening to it, especially if you listen to like the original recording, you'll think this must have been created in like the 1910s.

[38:17] Jimi: Yes.

[38:17] Tommy: It sounds like you know what I mean.

[38:18] Jimi: It was written by Alexander Hamilton himself.

[38:21] Tommy: Like it's just it um it feels really, really dated.

[38:26] Jimi: Um I think that's probably one of the reasons why I find it difficult because it's one of those things, Oklahoma has like 40 cast recordings, and a lot of them are great.

[38:37] Tommy: Right.

[38:37] Jimi: Um, same with Carousel.

[38:40] Tommy: Uh whereas Brigatoon, it's got like one or two.

[38:43] Jimi: And they're not great.

[38:44] Tommy: And they're really they're not that great.

[38:46] Jimi: And I think that's a shame.

[38:47] Tommy: Yeah.

[38:48] Jimi: Because obviously this is the main way that I see shows.

[38:53] Tommy: It's how you know it's through the cast recording.

[38:55] Jimi: Yes.

[38:55] Tommy: Uh and so it's a shame that that's the you know, my kind of initial exposure to it.

[39:01] Jimi: If it's nice in a like nostalgic way, and I'm like, oh, very pretty, but I can't connect it.

[39:07] Tommy: I can't like musically analyze it as well.

[39:09] Jimi: Um I find interesting that there aren't because I think Brigadoon is easier to sell to a contemporary audience than something like Carousel or Oklahoma.

[39:20] Tommy: Um I I think Brigadoon, because it you know it's a half sci-fi time traveling piece, uh it will always feel out of time.

[39:30] Jimi: Whereas Oklahoma and Carousel feel dated.

[39:35] Tommy: Yeah, because they're very much fixed in their time.

[39:38] Jimi: Yeah, that's that is a tricky thing, isn't it?

[39:39] Tommy: Because obviously you know, you could you could effectively try to set Brigadoon today.

[39:44] Jimi: Yeah, I mean, as we discussed, the Goodman did, um, or attempted to, yeah.

[39:48] Tommy: Uh huh.

[39:49] Jimi: Um like you only have to update two characters for it to be set today.

[39:53] Tommy: Yeah, I never thought about that.

[39:55] Jimi: That's quite interesting.

[39:56] Tommy: Yeah.

[39:56] Jimi: That's smart.

[39:57] Tommy: It's really it's a really clever way to write a show, and I think will prevent it from ever feeling like a period piece in its core plot.

[40:05] Jimi: Um it also I think kind of avoids a lot not all, but a lot of the pitfalls that make that you know contemporary audiences would find offensive or less politically correct that some other musicals of the time fall into.

[40:20] Tommy: Um there's an argument to be made about uh weddings and betrothments and you know, some portrayal of women.

[40:29] Jimi: But even there, there's not, you know, there's strong female characters in this.

[40:34] Tommy: Simplistic, certainly.

[40:35] Jimi: Um but they're not, you know.

[40:39] Tommy: Well, so it it kind of feeds into is this like can we segue already?

[40:42] Jimi: Let's segue already.

[40:47] Tommy: And 'tis a lovely time to wander.

[40:57] Jimi: Maybe I'll a day as a ritual then maybe I'll be this one.

[41:07] Tommy: But they won't be the same.

[41:10] Jimi: They'll come along this when the mist is in the globe.

[41:31] Tommy: You're not there, I want the wrong way.

[41:58] Jimi: You really don't like the music in this show.

[42:00] Tommy: Ugh, no, it's fine, but it's just some of it's very pretty.

[42:04] Jimi: Yeah, you would.

[42:05] Tommy: I don't think it's it's because you live in Brigadoon and you have to listen to this music every day, right?

[42:11] Jimi: I have to listen to the accents.

[42:13] Tommy: Yeah, that's what I have to do.

[42:14] Jimi: It's really what it is.

[42:15] Tommy: Ah, yes.

[42:16] Jimi: Dinah, you know.

[42:18] Tommy: Oh, don't.

[42:19] Jimi: I just can't.

[42:21] Tommy: Exactly the thing.

[42:22] Jimi: Like, that's very very accurate bigotune work you're doing there.

[42:25] Tommy: Anyway, let's segue.

[42:27] Jimi: I forgot where it was.

[42:28] Tommy: Oh yeah, okay.

[42:31] Jimi: I'm not this isn't gonna turn into one of our huge feminist rants. This was the 1940s. Right. They really didn't know any better. Yeah. Um the women, you know, are pretty damn awful. Yes. But um if you you know you've got someone like Meg, um, who you could kind of think, oh, she's, you know, in control of herself sexually. Right. Um But to be honest, she's almost more of a like one of these tartanry uh style characters of like, ah, this the Scottish wild woman. Right. Do you know what I mean? She lives like the the Serena from Nine. Yeah, she lives out in the wilds and oh, she'll take your virginity vegan as a exactly. No, but that and her my mother's wedding day, you know, like I should know because I was there, like there's lots of that characterization painted into it.

Yes. Um I mean, all she really wants for the whole show is a shag. Right. Yeah. And it is funny because you see the trope of this song um in a lot of musicals of the era. Like, what is it in Anna Get Your Gun? Um, I can't say no. Um No, that's Oklahoma, but yes. Oklahoma. Yeah. There's one in Anna Get Your Gun too that I can't remember the name of right now. Um, but you see this kind of like, oh yep, I'm I'm a loose woman. Isn't that funny? Um Exactly. And it is, it's the May West character that you laugh at. Exactly. Um is definitely no I I'm making assumptions, but I don't think any female author would write a female character like that. No. I think they'd have a little bit more depth than just desperately want to shag in the woods.

These are characters created by men. Um that's the thing, you know, you the the whole scope you have is you've got one woman who's desperately searching for a husband, one woman who's getting married, and one who's just desperately looking for sex. Right. But she's the silly one. Like that's it. That's your women. Yeah, exactly. And they're all, you know, falling in love very quickly. As is every other character in the show. To equality's credit, Tommy also falls stupid quickly in love. Like, he is your little romantic boy kind of thing. Um but right, so I want to talk about um well, actually, you I want you to make your point here about um coded gay characters.

[45:03] Tommy: Yes. Yes. Jeff Douglas. I this I remember having this thought watching Brigadoon in sixth or seventh grade when I went to go see it. Jeff Douglas is a coded gay character in musical theater, and because we're so early in contemporary American musical theater, this might be the first example of a a truly out and out coded gay character. Um Jeff, you can read this entire story with Jeff being um having an unrequited crush on Tommy, being having a drinking problem because he can't deal with it, being upset that Tommy has a fiance and is straight, traveling on a boys' trip out to go hunting in Scotland with like some, you know, perhaps deeply seated fantasy that something might happen or spark between them.

And his whole world gets thrown upside down because even here in the most remote reaches of Scotland where there shouldn't be anything on the map, Tommy still finds a girl to fall in love with, and he becomes so distraught over this and you know, spurns all of Meg's advances that he turns back to drinking and accidentally shoots what's his face in the tree. Um like it is a coded gay story. There's one line he has when uh Meg brings him up to the the sh the the Shag Shack or whatever it is. Um call it that um uh Meg says, all you men are alike, and he says in that joking way, I should certainly hope so. Um right? Like, there's a way to craft so many things he says as the you know the foppish wisecracking gay character. Um I I would be it would you it would be difficult to convince me that this was not intentional.

[47:00] Jimi: Yeah, exactly. Um yeah, the only one I would say, the only reason I would say is because I don't think either Fritz Low or Alan Lerner were gay. No. To my knowledge, I'm not an expert on them. As far as I don't think they were. I have done just m s more than the normal person's amount of reading on these things. As far as I know, they weren't gay in that kind of, you know, closeted way that people were in the 40s. Yeah, uh-huh. But certainly they existed in those circles. Um definitely. Um yeah, I do find it really because, like you say, this is so early. Like, you know, when you've got your like Donald O'Connors and singing in the rain, by the time that comes along, you almost expect it. Right.

Uh but the the one thing I would say that makes me think otherwise is just because he like Jeff is in no way a villain. Okay. And a lot of the time these characters are written like uh the devil in um uh Dan Yankees. Dam Yankees. Yeah. Just that is often often the way it is. Like they are the they have a bad or there's something bad in them. Well, I mean, Jeff is certainly not someone to be idolized in this show. You know, he's he's a vice-filled atheist. Um you're certainly supposed to like you're not supposed to sympathize with Jeff in uh surface reading. Um, you know, he's yeah, he's he also he it's almost like the uh Jeff. Right. Like he's deeply flawed for no good reason.

[48:41] Tommy: Yeah, that's a good point, actually.

[48:43] Jimi: Yeah, he's constantly kind of bitter and sassy.

[48:46] Tommy: Yeah.

[48:47] Jimi: And doesn't ever really seem happy at any point in the show.

[48:51] Tommy: Yeah, okay, I'll give you that actually.

[48:53] Jimi: Yeah, I'm gonna give you that. It it is, you know, and who knows how much authorial intent there is behind these things. There's a good chance that Lerner and Lowe were modeling this character over someone they knew who, you know, may or may not have been gay, and the intent wasn't to, you know, make the character gay, but was just a copy of these same things, right?

[49:17] Tommy: Yeah.

[49:17] Jimi: Um, but uh the coincidences keep mounting.

[49:23] Tommy: Yeah, definitely.

[49:24] Jimi: So, well, this is this is where I want to I've teased us for it on other podcasts, and this is where I kind of want to get into it. So I actually think this musical has a lot more external influence to it, um, than I think you would maybe first realize. Um and I think that the kind of goal the coded gay character, it it opens up this kind of tunnel, I guess, of ideas.

[49:50] Tommy: Okay.

[49:50] Jimi: Um now this was written post-war.

[49:55] Tommy: Yes.

[49:56] Jimi: Very early post-war.

[49:58] Tommy: Um, and you know, drums were starting to begin about the Cold War and communism and the McCarthy era, which obviously didn't really start kicking in until it's probably it's probably right around there.

[50:18] Tommy: Um let me just have a look.

[50:21] Jimi: Like there you go, lasting roughly from 1947 to 1956.

[50:25] Tommy: So we're right about there.

[50:27] Jimi: We're the the the beginnings of it.

[50:30] Tommy: Definitely, and the thing is, is so um the the the rumblings will be happening.

[50:35] Jimi: Um now it just so happens that uh Lerner and Lowe, um, the producer and the producers of uh Brigadoon and the director Agnes de Mill um were in a kind of group, you know, a little cohort that they had, um, one of which I can't remember his name, which is crap. One that basically one of their friends ended up becoming uh whistleblower and gave a lot of names, just like we talked about with Jerome Robbins, right?

[51:07] Tommy: Um to in the McCarthy hearings and that and I said a lot of the group.

[51:12] Jimi: So it's interesting that that was there in their friendship group. Now I am not saying that Lerner and Lowe and all of them because they were they were very liberal. This was the thing they were, they were probably suspected themselves at points of of being communists.

[51:28] Tommy: Um but if I just feel like if it was there, the conversations would be being had, and just the general feeling, yeah.

[51:35] Jimi: Um basically, I do think Brigadoon, this is a bold and wild statement, but there's stuff there. I think Brigadoon is like mild um McCarthyist propaganda.

[51:49] Tommy: Yeah, I could see that.

[51:50] Jimi: I mean, what the the school teacher's story, like our our town, we knew the witches were coming to bring their ill upon Brigadoon, and so the preacher went out in order to protect us from this is it, yeah. The whole story is about protection and keeping what's true and what's wonderful in glorious because the thing is there's not really right.

[52:14] Tommy: So in this whole show, there's not really an antagonist.

[52:17] Jimi: Right, there's not like a visible antagonist.

[52:19] Tommy: Yeah.

[52:19] Jimi: And I'll get to the the kind of only example of that in a second.

[52:23] Tommy: Right.

[52:23] Jimi: Um, the only major threat is the outside world.

[52:27] Tommy: Right.

[52:28] Jimi: Yeah.

[52:28] Tommy: Right?

[52:29] Jimi: Um, with these witches that they've made up.

[52:31] Tommy: That's a pile of pish, by the way.

[52:32] Jimi: We don't really but like the witch trials happened way before Scotland.

[52:35] Tommy: No, what actually did happen uh at this time was what I was talking about with the Highland Clearances.

[52:40] Jimi: Right.

[52:41] Tommy: In the stripping away.

[52:42] Jimi: That that if they just said that.

[52:43] Tommy: We're gonna pretend protect us from the British.

[52:46] Jimi: Um but instead it was oh the witches.

[52:49] Tommy: Oh yeah.

[52:51] Jimi: Um, anyway, so that's like the big threat.

[52:53] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[52:54] Jimi: Um, and the main theme is stay in Brigadoon.

[52:58] Tommy: Right.

[52:59] Jimi: It's good to be in Brigadoon, love being in Brigadoon.

[53:02] Tommy: And B embrace the community.

[53:05] Jimi: If one person exits the community, we're all done for.

[53:10] Tommy: Exactly.

[53:11] Jimi: Um, and so you just have to look to that one person who tries, right, um, Harry Beaton, who isn't really an antagonist because he doesn't do that much.

[53:21] Tommy: Yeah.

[53:22] Jimi: It A doesn't do that much.

[53:23] Tommy: Um but B, so he is there, he is in love with the woman who is getting married on this day, yeah.

[53:29] Jimi: that they're they're celebrating.

[53:30] Tommy: Yeah, and but one of the big things about him, and this is what really makes me think it's propaganda, is that Harry's uh during the the fete the fate, um he is at the side reading, yes, he's and he's pouring over his books because he's an intellectual learning, he's gaining knowledge and it's exactly yeah, he is an intellectual, and that very much so was uh suspicious thing, right?

[53:58] Jimi: And when the McCarthy hearing started coming in, yeah, they looked to the intellectuals because they thought they were homosexuals and commies, right?

[54:07] Tommy: Um, these people who were very much booksmarked that weren't getting involved in the celebrations, who were trying to pour and find out you know, stuff about the other world.

[54:16] Jimi: Right.

[54:17] Tommy: The rest of the world, sorry.

[54:18] Jimi: Um and so here he was this character who's sticks completely out from everyone else.

[54:24] Tommy: Right.

[54:24] Jimi: Because he's just likes sitting in his books.

[54:26] Tommy: Right.

[54:26] Jimi: Um, he's the only one that's made out to be this antagonist, and eventually he's the one that's like, well, screw you's all I'm getting out of here.

[54:34] Tommy: Yeah.

[54:35] Jimi: And he he dies.

[54:37] Tommy: Now, this is another what I think key point.

[54:40] Jimi: Uh-huh.

[54:40] Tommy: Um, and I'm gonna bring in Oklahoma here.

[54:43] Jimi: Uh-huh.

[54:43] Tommy: Now, I don't think Oklahoma is McCarthy's propaganda.

[54:47] Jimi: That is that being said.

[54:48] Tommy: Okay.

[54:49] Jimi: Um, but one of the things, so one of the kind of key factors of musicals at this era are um people didn't people weren't murdered.

[54:57] Tommy: Right.

[54:57] Jimi: It's an accident.

[54:58] Tommy: It's an accident.

[54:59] Jimi: Because you can't have that.

[55:00] Tommy: It's a musical.

[55:01] Jimi: It's a musical.

[55:02] Tommy: Right.

[55:02] Jimi: Right.

[55:02] Tommy: We can't have murder.

[55:04] Jimi: Yeah.

[55:04] Tommy: Right.

[55:04] Jimi: Right.

[55:04] Tommy: Right.

[55:18] Jimi: And dies.

[55:19] Tommy: Yes.

[55:19] Jimi: Um in Oklahoma, uh, there was a struggle between um Curly and Judd.

[55:25] Tommy: But Judd fell on his own knife.

[55:27] Jimi: Right.

[55:28] Tommy: Yes.

[55:28] Jimi: Very important that Curly did not kill Judd.

[55:31] Tommy: Right.

[55:32] Jimi: No.

[55:32] Tommy: Uh that would be too malicious.

[55:34] Jimi: Jeff.

[55:34] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.

[55:35] Jimi: And Jeff did not kill Harry because they would be, then they would be villains.

[55:39] Tommy: Right.

[55:39] Jimi: Because we can't be doing with murder.

[55:42] Jimi: But they stopped the bad guy.

[55:45] Tommy: Yeah.

[55:45] Jimi: They stopped the bad guy and saved it is saved everyone.

[55:50] Tommy: And so let's rejoice.

[55:52] Jimi: Let's sing about my mother's wedding day.

[55:55] Tommy: Yeah.

[55:55] Jimi: Well, so here's here's the thing.

[55:57] Tommy: I saw this, it was uh an uncited review in an article about Brigadoon.

[56:03] Jimi: Yep.

[56:03] Tommy: But some reviewer described parts of Brigadoon as being a closet horror story.

[56:10] Jimi: Uh huh.

[56:11] Tommy: Which I thought was a fascinating lens through which to view Brigadoon.

[56:16] Jimi: Like you're trapped in this town that you can never leave.

[56:22] Tommy: That is like stuck in the old ways and everyone in the town is gonna try and murder you if you try to leave.

[56:30] Jimi: Yeah.

[56:30] Tommy: It's a horror story.

[56:32] Jimi: It's terrifying.

[56:33] Tommy: Absolutely.

[56:34] Jimi: But we're we're set up to kind of praise and celebrate that.

[56:37] Tommy: And you know to be like, oh I hope he I hope he doesn't get out.

[56:40] Jimi: We've we'll feel so bad if everyone else disappears um in this very loosely defined mythos of this world anyway.

[56:47] Tommy: Yeah I know.

[56:48] Jimi: Well that's the thing it's like how do they know that they're getting married that they've been asleep for a hundred years or whatever that's all yeah we we should talk about that too.

[56:56] Tommy: Yeah but so that I just think fascinating that in this intensely Scottish and inverted commas tale uh lies this huge piece.

[57:06] Jimi: And I think that's it.

[57:07] Tommy: It's that Trojan horse kind of vibe.

[57:09] Jimi: Right.

[57:10] Tommy: You're wheeling this out to people as is this like look at this beautiful mythical fantasy world.

[57:16] Jimi: Right.

[57:17] Tommy: And we all know that all the best fantasies have this layer of pure propaganda underneath them.

[57:23] Jimi: Yeah.

[57:23] Tommy: That's how you feed it.

[57:24] Jimi: That's how you get the message out.

[57:26] Tommy: Yeah.

[57:26] Jimi: You tell a fairy tale.

[57:28] Tommy: Exactly and I don't doubt it.

[57:30] Jimi: And when the movie was made oh yes because we know for a fact the Free Junit was heavily involved in this.

[57:36] Tommy: They were trying so hard to demonstrate that that they were patriots right?

[57:41] Jimi: Exactly and so when this movie gets made like the oh the marketing that went alongside this movie.

[57:48] Tommy: They changed the name of a town.

[57:50] Jimi: Really?

[57:51] Tommy: To Brigadoon.

[57:52] Jimi: Yeah.

[57:52] Tommy: I think it was a Maryland.

[57:53] Jimi: It's the name of a town.

[57:55] Tommy: Um, you know, it was like rolled out they had very intensely prescribed marketing.

[58:01] Jimi: Yeah.

[58:01] Tommy: Um making bagp because they really wanted to propagate this all the way through.

[58:07] Jimi: Um and make it kind of ingrained in America, and people lapped it up.

[58:10] Tommy: Yeah.

[58:11] Jimi: People absolutely lapped it up.

[58:13] Tommy: Um and I do not doubt for a single jot of a second that that's what this is.

[58:20] Jimi: I really, really believe it.

[58:21] Tommy: Yeah.

[58:22] Jimi: I'd love to write an essay on it one day.

[58:23] Tommy: I think I think it's fascinating.

[58:25] Jimi: And I think it it also speaks to I would I would be interested to see then the portrayal of in quotes America in this musical in that whole thing.

[58:38] Tommy: Um because I think it's they portray at least Jeff and Tommy's America as a not so great place.

[58:46] Jimi: Um especially in the movie, right?

[58:49] Tommy: In contrast to Brigadoon, you know, so much so that they want to go back.

[58:53] Jimi: Like it's an awful fast-moving talking, lying and cheating, smoking and drinking kind of you know, it's a bar in New York.

[59:02] Tommy: Um not that I think that derails the McCarthyism, um uh the undertone.

[59:10] Jimi: Right, but it is interesting to to you know to slot that in and think about like are are we trying to embrace a more colonial America, a more you know, uh a past tense of America.

[59:24] Tommy: Yeah, well uh it is, it's it's the make America great again.

[59:28] Jimi: Absolutely.

[59:29] Tommy: Like, I think there is an interesting, like, while I enjoy Brigadoon, I think some of its uh moral underpinnings, if there are any, um, are scary.

[59:39] Jimi: Um I just think it's a very intense story.

[59:44] Tommy: Yeah, they never give a reason of like why we should embrace the old days, right?

[59:51] Jimi: Yep.

[59:51] Tommy: The witches might be coming, that's about it.

[59:54] Jimi: Um that's it.

[59:55] Tommy: There's no reason, you know, and clearly everyone's getting along just fine.

[1:00:01] Jimi: Um, but so is everyone in New York.

[1:00:05] Tommy: They're but they're painted in a negative light.

[1:00:08] Jimi: Um, you know, it is it all just kinda happens.

[1:00:14] Tommy: There's no good reason for Tommy to fall in love with Brigadoon.

[1:00:18] Jimi: Um, you know, for him to like he's he's in love with Brigadoon and the idea of it, but he's not in love with Scotland.

[1:00:27] Tommy: Um he's you know exactly doesn't have that feeling when they're wandering in the highlands outside of Brigadoon.

[1:00:32] Jimi: I completely agree.

[1:00:33] Tommy: That's it, you know, he doesn't talk about the fact that oh it's just the hills though, like they're so lovely, I can totally see me living here.

[1:00:40] Jimi: Right is just Fiona.

[1:00:42] Tommy: Right.

[1:00:42] Jimi: That's the only thing that he's fussed about is being with Fiona.

[1:00:46] Tommy: And why why?

[1:00:47] Jimi: Like they fall in love wordlessly.

[1:00:48] Tommy: It's and like this is a very musical theater trope, especially for the time, you know, love at first sight, blah blah blah, who cares?

[1:00:54] Jimi: And Fiona's not given a really good chance to demonstrate why you should fall in love with her because it's an awful female character written by a man.

[1:01:00] Tommy: Um but still, nothing and then they dance, and they pick flowers, they dance, it's almost like being in love.

[1:01:08] Jimi: He falls head over heels for her, so much so that like he's ready to, you know, chase down and defend the town and then needs to come back, and like he's got a fiance back home.

[1:01:17] Tommy: Um exactly.

[1:01:18] Jimi: There's yeah.

[1:01:20] Tommy: I found the problematic parts of this show.

[1:01:24] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:01:24] Tommy: Oh yeah.

[1:01:25] Jimi: I mean, that's the thing, they're they're there, they're really, really there.

[1:01:28] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:01:28] Jimi: Um it's yeah, it's just something it's just interesting because it's so bloody popular.

[1:01:36] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:01:36] Jimi: And has had a serious impact.

[1:01:39] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:01:39] Jimi: Um and that's a segue.

[1:03:11] Tommy: Um so I do quickly I want to talk weird, but I again we didn't think there'd be much, but I feel like we've still got another error in it.

[1:03:20] Jimi: Um I do quickly quickly want to talk about um a bit of the impact that it's had um worldwide because uh so do you know who um Sir Harry Lauder is?

[1:03:33] Tommy: I do not.

[1:03:35] Jimi: He you've seen Havester Producer.

[1:03:38] Tommy: I have.

[1:03:38] Jimi: Yep.

[1:03:39] Tommy: He has a his musical Lauder exclamation mark.

[1:03:43] Jimi: Okay.

[1:03:43] Tommy: Uh has a a slight feature at the start, the one with all the bagpipes.

[1:03:46] Jimi: Oh, okay.

[1:03:47] Tommy: Yes, yes, yes, yes, right?

[1:03:48] Jimi: Um so Harry Lauder was uh a Scottish vaudevillion.

[1:03:54] Tommy: Okay.

[1:03:55] Jimi: Basically, um international again, internationally acclaimed, internationally loud renowned, and brought this lovely kitsch uh uh Twee version of Scotland that we had been building up for for about a hundred years to America into the vaudeville circuit.

[1:04:12] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[1:04:12] Jimi: Um, with these lovely Twee songs.

[1:04:14] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[1:04:15] Jimi: Um that paved the way for the music in Brigadier.

[1:04:18] Tommy: And this so this is one of the reasons why I find it very hard to listen to, and why I think a lot of the songs don't feel integrated.

[1:04:26] Jimi: Yes, okay.

[1:04:27] Tommy: Because I've heard all of these songs sung by Harry Lauder, by Tommy Scott, but a lot of these Scottish uh they're not even they're not folk artists, they're they're almost I don't know.

[1:04:39] Jimi: It's like a manufactured folk art.

[1:04:41] Tommy: It's like yeah, but it's there's no folk element to it.

[1:04:44] Jimi: That's uh it's it's just tweet.

[1:04:46] Tommy: Yeah, that's it's it's uh it's kitsch.

[1:04:49] Jimi: It's not it's very yeah, it's tartanry.

[1:04:51] Tommy: Right.

[1:04:52] Jimi: It's the songs they're singing aren't the songs that were passed down to them from their grandmothers.

[1:04:57] Tommy: Exactly.

[1:04:58] Jimi: Like I could sing you four or five songs now that are just in the Scottish vernacular um that you could probably think were from Brigadoon.

[1:05:08] Tommy: Mm-hmm.

[1:05:09] Jimi: Okay.

[1:05:09] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?

[1:05:10] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:05:10] Tommy: Just in terms of the way that they lelt, um and just i in terms of what they're talking about.

[1:05:17] Jimi: So songs like um My Mother's Wedding Day or Go Home to Bonnie Jean Um are to me just pure unadulterated copies of people like Harry Lauder.

[1:05:31] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[1:05:32] Jimi: Um but it that's what that's that's that is what we are exporting.

[1:05:40] Tommy: Right.

[1:05:40] Jimi: Harry Lauder is Scottish.

[1:05:42] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:05:42] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:05:42] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?

[1:05:43] Jimi: Right.

[1:05:43] Tommy: So it is our representation out there.

[1:05:45] Jimi: It becomes genuine just because of its existence, but there is a tinge of like ungenuineness to it.

[1:05:51] Tommy: Or it's like it starts to feel like a photocopy of a photocopy.

[1:05:54] Jimi: Um Yeah.

[1:05:55] Tommy: Because we sing these songs in school.

[1:05:58] Jimi: Not these not from Brigadoon.

[1:05:59] Tommy: Right.

[1:06:00] Jimi: But uh, you know, these other little like, you know, oh you can shove your granny af a bus.

[1:06:05] Tommy: You know, I mean, the Julie Peace song.

[1:06:07] Jimi: Uh-huh.

[1:06:07] Tommy: I'm just gonna quote all these so I could put them all the show notes basically.

[1:06:10] Jimi: Um yeah, all of these songs that we just know and we just sing.

[1:06:15] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:06:16] Jimi: Just because they're part of your your culture, quote unquote.

[1:06:19] Tommy: But exactly.

[1:06:20] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:06:21] Tommy: Exactly.

[1:06:22] Jimi: Um so Brigadoon has had like quite an immense impact in that response.

[1:06:29] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:06:29] Jimi: Um which I find interesting because I uh how you like how?

[1:06:38] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:06:39] Jimi: How is this one show?

[1:06:41] Tommy: Even um uh something like Brave.

[1:06:43] Jimi: Yeah, yeah.

[1:06:44] Tommy: It's like the the It's like it's got a Scottish patina.

[1:06:50] Jimi: But it is manufactured.

[1:06:52] Tommy: Patina Miller.

[1:06:55] Jimi: No, a patina.

[1:06:56] Tommy: Do you not know what like when I've never heard of that before?

[1:06:58] Jimi: Really?

[1:06:58] Tommy: Like when brass gets kinda like gross and muddy as it ages, or like how the Statue of Liberty used to be uh copper, but now has like a uh uh green patina over all of it.

[1:07:10] Jimi: We call that oxidization, actually, over here, because that's what it is.

[1:07:15] Tommy: No, okay, yeah, I get I get it.

[1:07:17] Jimi: Grime.

[1:07:18] Tommy: Grime, a veneer.

[1:07:19] Jimi: Uh a thin layer of Scottish over really just a manufactured Western existence.

[1:07:26] Tommy: Yeah, totally.

[1:07:27] Jimi: Because that's the thing is like again, Brave, there's a few more authentic elements in there.

[1:07:32] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:07:33] Jimi: Um, but it's just it's just got all the traits of Brigadoon, but they're just taking a lot of the red out of the tartan.

[1:07:40] Tommy: Like this is this is something I find fascinating though, because as described, we are also t talking about the basic structure of something like the King and I, which I will be be first to say is like explicitly racist and insensitive towards you know, a generic kind of pestiche of eastern culture.

[1:08:03] Jimi: Um and is like uh an awful western interpretation of that.

[1:08:07] Tommy: Yep.

[1:08:07] Jimi: Brigadoon somehow kinda like, and maybe just because it's Scottish and Western, I don't know, but like snuck under that distaste.

[1:08:17] Tommy: Um and maybe it's because it is also embraced by Scottish culture in a weird way.

[1:08:23] Jimi: Yep.

[1:08:24] Tommy: Um, but there, you know, we're only a couple steps from Brigadoon being a really offensive depiction, inaccurate depiction of Scottish culture.

[1:08:33] Jimi: Absolutely, absolutely.

[1:08:34] Tommy: Um and I think it I think it does just come from the fact that a lot of our history Yeah, a lot of our history is relatively manufactured for the touristry.

[1:08:46] Jimi: Right.

[1:08:46] Tommy: I mean, so they almost it's it's that kind of thing, it's like, oh, we can't really say anything against it because this exotica that is presenting is making us a lot of money.

[1:08:58] Jimi: Right.

[1:08:58] Tommy: I I think that must be it.

[1:09:00] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:09:00] Tommy: I feel I feel like that's it.

[1:09:01] Jimi: I also think it do well, I don't know.

[1:09:04] Tommy: Um you tell me Because the thing is is like, you know, there's no one in Thailand that will be like, oh, without the king and I we'd have no one.

[1:09:12] Jimi: Right.

[1:09:13] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.

[1:09:14] Jimi: Um I do think perhaps this manufactured Scottish tourism culture does kind of evade some of the like looking down upon its people traps that in other places that's not evaded.

[1:09:31] Tommy: Like, in if you took the Brigadoon depiction of Scotland, save for, you know, Meg, the the the wee Scottish last.

[1:09:40] Jimi: That's why they made it.

[1:09:41] Tommy: Right.

[1:09:41] Jimi: Um, and even then, like offensive certainly, but n we're not Oh, she's still fabulous.

[1:09:48] Tommy: Right, she's still great and in control and like we're not calling her simple-minded or dumb person.

[1:09:54] Jimi: Whereas in some of these others, it's like, oh yes, look, you know, look at the simplistic native people of this land in whatever land that is.

[1:10:02] Tommy: This man can't speak English.

[1:10:04] Jimi: Ha ha ha.

[1:10:05] Tommy: Um whereas in Scotland, in in that kind of depiction of Scotland, there's not uh like these people have a culture and a society, and uh, you know, uh civility as depicted, um, which I think sidesteps the potential for it to be offensive, but only just.

[1:10:26] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:10:27] Tommy: It's interesting, because that's that's the thing, it's like if you said to me, is it offensive?

[1:10:30] Jimi: I'd be like, yeah.

[1:10:33] Tommy: And I'd I'd find it hard to say yes.

[1:10:36] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:10:36] Tommy: Because there are there are some things that are quite accurate.

[1:10:39] Jimi: For example, and this something that never really gets talked about in Brigade.

[1:10:49] Jimi: Yeah. Not that that isn't how we have our funerals, that's not what I mean. But um the music, yeah, the music written for the funeral with the bagpipe, yeah, uh is very accurate. And like that is to me, is like that's authentic Scottish folk right there.

[1:11:07] Tommy: Right.

[1:11:08] Jimi: Okay. I mean, that's what uh to me, I would be like, is our heritage. You know, you can hear that ringing through the Glen.

[1:11:15] Tommy: Uh huh.

[1:11:16] Jimi: I need to talk about the word Glen as well, because I love that. Um Yeah, you could you know, I mean, that's that's the kind of thing that makes you makes me feel I guess Scotland proud.

[1:11:26] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:11:26] Jimi: Um, not go home to Bonnie Jean.

[1:11:28] Tommy: Right.

[1:11:29] Jimi: Um, but it's quite funny because it that never really gets talked no about I mean in kind of any of the the discussion that I've read uh across the years, yeah. No one really acknowledges that bit. And I'm like, well to me, that's it. That's the that's the one bit that they've got. Seems authentic.

[1:11:47] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[1:11:48] Jimi: Um, and apparently quite interesting. Um uh um Fritz Lowe uh was really frustrated that he had to write it. Um because originally there I don't think there was gonna be any death um in the whole show. But uh I think it was the director and Agnes DeMill uh basically came together and were like, someone needs to die.

[1:12:13] Tommy: Uh basically they were just like it's too yeah, it's too it's too lovey dovey, it's just too romantic.

[1:12:19] Jimi: Yeah, that there needs to be a darker shade to it. Um because that's the way musicals were headed nowadays.

[1:12:25] Tommy: Right.

[1:12:25] Jimi: Um so when they came to Fritz Lowe and being like, listen, yeah, yeah. Um he was really frustrated because he had to write this kind of like melancholic funereal thing.

[1:12:40] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:12:41] Jimi: Um but I'm really glad they did because it's it's lovely.

[1:12:43] Tommy: Yeah, it's really really lovely.

[1:12:46] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:12:47] Tommy: Uh what's your view of bagpipes?

[1:12:50] Jimi: Um, I mean, I'm very Irish, so bagpipes have been a big part of my life too.

[1:12:55] Tommy: Um You think I'm joking.

[1:13:01] Jimi: Okay. Pause, rewind. I'm very Irish.

[1:13:06] Tommy: Obviously, I know you have an Irish name.

[1:13:08] Jimi: Uh-huh. O'Malley, everyone.

[1:13:10] Tommy: Thomas O'Malley.

[1:13:11] Jimi: Thomas O'Malley, exactly.

[1:13:12] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:13:13] Jimi: Um.

[1:13:15] Tommy: But what how how have you interacted with that heritage?

[1:13:18] Jimi: So there is a gigantic um Iri Chicago Irish contingent. Huge.

[1:13:28] Tommy: Um, that who know who knows culturally why?

[1:13:31] Jimi: I'm sure it has I'm sure it has to do with the potato famine.

[1:13:34] Tommy: Um and Oh yeah, that was uh, that was why everybody left. Immigrants to America and a bunch of them set up camp basically on the south side of Chicago.

[1:13:42] Jimi: Um not the kind of Chirac south side of Chicago, but there's another part there like there's a parade called the South Side Irish Parade, um that happens on St. Patrick's Day.

[1:13:57] Tommy: Yes, of course they do.

[1:13:58] Jimi: And it is but it is certainly a manufactured American ideal of being Irish.

[1:14:04] Tommy: Um but it's still there's still plenty of like attached culture there.

[1:14:09] Jimi: Um that's interesting.

[1:14:11] Tommy: So you do actually connect with that's authentic Irish culture in some way. Do you feel a part of that?

[1:14:17] Jimi: Uh d I mean I feel like it has been a part of my existence. Um, I wouldn't like I don't describe myself as Irish.

[1:14:27] Tommy: Um out of this kind of context.

[1:14:30] Jimi: Um but like I have plenty of relatives and grandparents who have like gone back to Ireland and like you know, found old relatives and went to old gravesites and like there's a big you know, I I I think it is a manufactured Irish Catholic thing, um about like your heritage and where you come from and you know similar to having uh the tartan of your clan.

[1:14:51] Tommy: Um right?

[1:14:53] Jimi: Um but yeah, you like w I can track back my family tree all the way through people who came over from Ireland on both sides of my family.

[1:15:01] Tommy: Uh my dad's side.

[1:15:03] Jimi: Okay so bagpipes have been a big part of my life.

[1:15:06] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:15:07] Jimi: Oh well that's nice.

[1:15:09] Tommy: That's nice.

[1:15:10] Jimi: Um I love them.

[1:15:12] Tommy: I think I think they can be very nice.

[1:15:14] Jimi: I think they are more visceral in person.

[1:15:17] Tommy: Um you know?

[1:15:19] Jimi: I wouldn't I I think something about the loudness of a bagpipe in person or like a marching bagpipe band is very different than say listening to recorded bagpipe music.

[1:15:29] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:15:31] Jimi: I don't know, I think for me it's just so stirring.

[1:15:34] Tommy: But so are you listening to bagpipes?

[1:15:37] Jimi: This is such a strange topic of conversation. Are you listening to bagpipes in so when you're doing it in person, are these Scottish or Irish people that are playing them?

[1:15:47] Tommy: Uh yes, probably.

[1:15:49] Jimi: I didn't ask them because they have bagpipes in their mouths.

[1:15:52] Tommy: Um because no the thing is a bagpipe can be played badly.

[1:15:56] Jimi: Oh yes.

[1:15:57] Tommy: A bag a bagpipe can be played badly and I do so the other way I encounter bagpipes, um both my uh Chicago school that I worked for and my current school that I work for bagpipes are a surprisingly big part of some ceremony in America.

[1:16:14] Jimi: Like our graduation was led by a bagpiper.

[1:16:18] Tommy: I've been to a couple funerals where the casket is led by a bagpiper.

[1:16:23] Jimi: Like that's a it's a thing. Not because of any particular heritage but just because it makes it feel more ceremonial.

[1:16:30] Tommy: I don't know why that's fascinating.

[1:16:31] Jimi: Isn't that fascinating?

[1:16:33] Tommy: That is really weird to me.

[1:16:34] Jimi: And one of the things I was thinking when I was watching Brigadoon, there is like a a bagpiper set list that's like six different songs. Didlly didn't right that one whatever that is and I think there is so much more variety available in bagpiping and would love to hear something other than I'll slap you some great stuff in the show notes.

[1:16:58] Tommy: Yeah no like I think bag which is fun about Brigadoon because they are incorporating bagpipes into a larger orchestral sound.

[1:17:07] Jimi: Which doesn't happen as often.

[1:17:08] Tommy: Um, you know, it's a bunch of it's a bunch of pipers and drums or just one piper.

[1:17:12] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:17:13] Tommy: Um and I really enjoy it integrated and it really I I think it classes up the instrument a little more.

[1:17:19] Jimi: Um but there's something fun about a bagpipe in in that there's something fun about a bugle, um, that like uh you can play it on a hill and hear it for miles and it's yeah built that way.

[1:17:31] Tommy: Um which I think is cool.

[1:17:34] Jimi: You know, it is it it does make it seem old timey and visceral, and plenty of that's manufactured.

[1:17:42] Tommy: Um but you know, bagpipes were made to be heard from miles away.

[1:17:46] Jimi: Well it's like they're a war cry.

[1:17:48] Tommy: I think it was dates back to like the 1600s.

[1:17:50] Jimi: That is something that's that's a part of our history.

[1:17:52] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:17:53] Jimi: You know.

[1:17:53] Tommy: Um when we were fighting uh the Battle of Culloden, we would have had pipes there, do you know what I mean?

[1:17:59] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:18:00] Tommy: To to be intimidating.

[1:18:02] Jimi: Right.

[1:18:02] Tommy: That's just in the same way that we'd have the bugles in uh the Civil War.

[1:18:08] Jimi: Exactly.

[1:18:08] Tommy: You know, I mean it's it's just it was just a big part of it.

[1:18:12] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:18:12] Tommy: Um yeah, I really, really love them.

[1:18:15] Jimi: I think uh I I I it's weird. I want to like go through a list of things and be like, what are your opinions on these? What are your opinions on these?

[1:18:24] Tommy: Um I think this will probably I would like this to be one of our big discussions on Reddit this this time around.

[1:18:30] Jimi: Okay.

[1:18:31] Tommy: It's just like uh US obviously we have listeners outside the US and I realize we've got listeners in Scotland England, everything like that.

[1:18:39] Jimi: Um but asking mostly like the US listeners, like what is your perception of Scotland?

[1:18:46] Tommy: Well, it is because I mean, you know this. We encounter this all the time, but like the bizarre cultural differences that we don't know about between the United States and Scotland until we start talking about them.

[1:18:56] Jimi: Um you know, thing things like what were we talking about the other day where you didn't know how far north Colorado was.

[1:19:03] Tommy: Um like how it affects the weather and the time of day.

[1:19:06] Jimi: Um that like w when we looked up you can fit three Scotlands inside of my entire state.

[1:19:12] Tommy: Um just some interesting perception differences um that I find fascinating.

[1:19:22] Jimi: Uh-huh.

[1:19:23] Tommy: Well, I mean, so uh it's it might be difficult because you know me and I I've spoken a lot.

[1:19:28] Jimi: But like what are what would you say are your perceptions of Scotland?

[1:19:33] Tommy: Hmm.

[1:19:34] Jimi: Interesting.

[1:19:35] Tommy: I and the Scottish people.

[1:19:37] Jimi: And the Scottish people.

[1:19:38] Tommy: I Yeah, and I don't mind you being like you won't offend me.

[1:19:41] Jimi: Well, I think we've talked about a bunch of them because and like this is where I don't know if they are through talking with you or through, you know, Brigadoon.

[1:19:48] Tommy: Um but like I do get the sense of Scotland as like a a proud people in a different way than like America is patriotic, right?

[1:19:58] Jimi: Um like I think America is patriotic just because um, you know, because you must be in the flag and eagles and whatever.

[1:20:07] Tommy: Um whereas like there there is an identity associated with American proudness, whereas I think the Scottish identity is proudness, um, and like a a non braggarty kind of proudness.

[1:20:21] Jimi: Um I so what I would almost relate it to, and I don't know if it's a bit close to the bone.

[1:20:25] Tommy: Uh huh.

[1:20:26] Jimi: But I would compare Scottish pride to Native American pride.

[1:20:30] Tommy: Yeah, I th I s I see that.

[1:20:32] Jimi: It's like a pride of the land.

[1:20:34] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:20:34] Jimi: It's a pride of the world that we live in.

[1:20:36] Tommy: It's not a pride.

[1:20:37] Jimi: That's why that's why it's not called patriotism.

[1:20:39] Tommy: Right.

[1:20:40] Jimi: Yeah because we're not there's no father there.

[1:20:42] Tommy: Exactly.

[1:20:42] Jimi: You know what I mean?

[1:20:43] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:20:43] Jimi: It's it would be a mother if anything, because Scotland does have used it.

[1:20:48] Tommy: Right.

[1:20:48] Jimi: The like from the mother earth.

[1:20:50] Tommy: From the mother land from like all those imagery notations.

[1:20:56] Jimi: Exactly.

[1:20:56] Tommy: And I I think that rings very true, especially if we're talking in the differences between the two, because you know, Americans have no leg to stand on when talking about our land and our country, because it's not.

[1:21:10] Jimi: Is it?

[1:21:11] Tommy: Nope.

[1:21:11] Jimi: We stole it.

[1:21:13] Tommy: We stole every bit of it.

[1:21:15] Jimi: Um literally every bit of it.

[1:21:17] Tommy: And so there's no you can't have that kind of pride that you have in Scotland where like literally you were born out of the woods.

[1:21:24] Jimi: Um, you were there as long as anyone can remember, and even before that, and so there is no then your origin story becomes a myth, right?

[1:21:35] Tommy: Um which I think is the popularity of something like Brigadoon, true or not, is that it it paints this picture, you know.

[1:21:44] Jimi: I think I'm I'm more versed in this in Ireland, but if you don't mind me drawing too close of a comparison.

[1:21:50] Tommy: No, we're we're very similar.

[1:21:51] Jimi: Like we're all Celts.

[1:21:53] Tommy: Yes.

[1:21:54] Jimi: The like the we people and the leprechauns and the myth, you know, like and the fairies in the woods and whatever.

[1:22:01] Tommy: But there is that sense of like this is a mystical and important land that has sustained us that we've lived on forever.

[1:22:10] Jimi: Um you know, we're proud of it, we take care of it, um, and it's all we've got.

[1:22:17] Tommy: Um which I think from my perspective would inform a lot of Scottish culture.

[1:22:23] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:22:24] Tommy: I would give you that.

[1:22:25] Jimi: Totally.

[1:22:26] Tommy: And that's the thing is like we are we are very proud.

[1:22:28] Jimi: We we are um we're very we take a lot of things very seriously.

[1:22:36] Tommy: Relaxed as we are, and that is a big thing as well, we're very laid back.

[1:22:40] Jimi: Um it is I feel like it is a stereotype that oh everyone in Scotland's lovely and welcoming.

[1:22:44] Tommy: Yes.

[1:22:45] Jimi: That's actually just I would say very tr true.

[1:22:48] Tommy: Um in that's why you know with things like uh Brexit happening, um, it it's not a represent like it's it's created a big conversation in Scotland because Scotland, right technically, and this will get me a lot of beef, but that's fine.

[1:23:03] Jimi: Um Scotland technically didn't vote for Brexit.

[1:23:07] Tommy: Um, you know, if you look at Scotland.

[1:23:09] Jimi: If you look at the demographics of how the vote turned out, yeah.

[1:23:12] Tommy: Pretty much everyone said no.

[1:23:13] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:23:14] Tommy: And but just because of our the way the votes are weighted and everything like that, yeah, it went through.

[1:23:19] Jimi: Um because we are like, you know, we are very staunchly pro-immigrant and proper that was the thing I was gonna say of like even of just Western quote unquote countries, whether we're talking Europe or America or Canada, um, I do think Scotland reads as decidedly non-xenophobic in a way that's different from even like England.

[1:23:45] Tommy: Um completely, completely.

[1:23:48] Jimi: And um and that speaks to that welcomingness and friendliness.

[1:23:52] Tommy: Totally, and I couldn't tell you where that's come from.

[1:23:54] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:23:55] Tommy: No idea.

[1:23:55] Jimi: But that is defin it's definitely a thing.

[1:23:58] Tommy: Um but we're also, you know, like, we are quite big drinkers.

[1:24:04] Jimi: You know, and it that's again like going to America, that was something I found because I was like we d we just kidding, we do kind of just drink all the time.

[1:24:12] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:24:13] Jimi: Um that isn't really the same elsewhere.

[1:24:16] Tommy: No, it's not.

[1:24:17] Jimi: You know what I mean?

[1:24:18] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:24:18] Jimi: Um and but it's a very social thing, and uh there's a lot of like ritual to it as well.

[1:24:24] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:24:24] Jimi: Um if you think of for example, so for uh Hogmana, do you know what Hogmana is?

[1:24:29] Tommy: Nope.

[1:24:29] Jimi: So Hogmoney is what we call um like New Year's.

[1:24:32] Tommy: Oh okay.

[1:24:33] Jimi: It's not the town next to Hogwarts.

[1:24:35] Tommy: It's not, it's not.

[1:24:36] Jimi: But I can't tell you where that is.

[1:24:38] Tommy: I do know obviously being Scottish, I know exactly where Hoggers is.

[1:24:40] Jimi: Obviously.

[1:24:41] Tommy: But unfortunately, you'll understand.

[1:24:43] Jimi: It only appears once every hundred years.

[1:24:44] Tommy: Uh 300 years, yeah.

[1:24:46] Jimi: Gene Kelly goes and falls in love.

[1:24:48] Tommy: Um so yeah, Hogman A.

[1:24:52] Jimi: Um, we've got loads of traditions around this.

[1:24:55] Tommy: Uh huh.

[1:24:55] Jimi: Um, and there's still traditions that we buy into.

[1:24:57] Tommy: I buy into them every year.

[1:25:00] Jimi: Uh, where we have this thing called uh first footing.

[1:25:04] Tommy: Okay.

[1:25:05] Jimi: Um, so first footing is uh after midnight, uh huh. Um you go to a neighbor's house or friend's house, um, and you would bring them uh three things.

[1:25:05] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[1:25:18] Jimi: Well, uh first of all, you would need a tall, dark and handsome man.

[1:25:22] Tommy: Of course.

[1:25:23] Jimi: To bring them. That's he has which often me. Um you would need to bring coal. You would need to bring whiskey.

[1:25:34] Tommy: Okay.

[1:25:36] Jimi: And you would need to bring a thing called black bun.

[1:25:36] Tommy: Black bun.

[1:25:40] Jimi: Black bun, which is uh a sort of uh treacle uh fruit cake encased in a short crust pastry.

[1:25:48] Tommy: Okay.

[1:25:49] Jimi: Really, really nice. Very rich.

[1:25:51] Tommy: Yeah, it sounds super rich.

[1:25:52] Jimi: And it's just to represent having a year of sustenance and warmth and merriment, um and it's still still do it.

[1:26:00] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:26:01] Jimi: I mean, how archaic is that.

[1:26:02] Tommy: Right.

[1:26:03] Jimi: But it's and it's fun that's just what you do. It is interesting to me also that you describe that as a tradition. Um because like I think there are American cultural traditions that we describe more as celebrations.

[1:26:19] Tommy: Um like Fourth of July. We're gonna go have a barbecue and set off some fireworks.

[1:26:24] Jimi: Um right, but we would describe that as a party. Um not as I mean hogmanay, hogmanay's are far.

[1:26:32] Tommy: Oh, I'm sure.

[1:26:32] Jimi: I'm sure they're I'm sure they're very similar in like actuality, right? But it is interesting that yours is a tradition, and it's not a solemn tradition, it's a jokey tradition, right?

[1:26:44] Tommy: It's not well, yeah, uh it's it's done with it's it's decorous, you know. I mean, it's done with reverence.

[1:26:49] Jimi: Yes.

[1:26:51] Tommy: But it's not it's not like we don't like walk through inside.

[1:26:53] Jimi: Right, but there's like I bring you all the black buttons.

[1:26:56] Tommy: Right, there's not like a parade while wearing cloaks and kilts down.

[1:27:00] Jimi: No, although I do wear my kilt every year.

[1:27:02] Tommy: Good, excellent. As it should be.

[1:27:05] Jimi: It is it is interesting and fun, and I do think that's why, you know, I I I think it speaks to Brigadoon's success, is that it that and this is awful commentary on America, but I think it's true, because Scotland is kind of an accessible exoticism, um right? That because it still feels Western at its core, because they they speak English if a little different there.

[1:27:33] Tommy: Um that like you, as you know, xenophobic, fearful American, you still go to Scotland and feel fine. Um whereas like you might not have the same experience even in like Spain, much less in India. Um, which speaks to Americans' internalized racism. Um but I think that's a you know, they Lerner and Loewe lucked out setting this musical in Scotland.

[1:28:01] Jimi: I really think so. I really think so.

[1:28:03] Tommy: Because I mean it was only a couple of minutes until they were writing My Fair Lady.

[1:28:07] Jimi: Yeah, yeah. You know what I mean? Uh which is a slightly more authentic picture of England.

[1:28:15] Tommy: England.

[1:28:15] Jimi: Yes. You know what I mean? But it doesn't get, you know, it doesn't get the same treatment.

[1:28:19] Tommy: Right.

[1:28:19] Jimi: As Scotland does, you know. And this story at its core could have been anywhere, you know. It's a lost town in upstate New York.

[1:28:30] Tommy: Like that's the thing, is it could, you know, I mean they could be out in Ohio and it's uh, you know, an old gold rush to I don't know if they had gold rush now.

[1:28:38] Jimi: Yeah, but whatever. But uh I mean like that kind of thing that comes, you know, billowing out of the sand. Yeah, like the basics, you know, were just fine, but setting it in Scotland gave them a musical genre, a you know fake or not culture to bathe it in that was so rich that adds such a great connotation to it.

[1:28:57] Tommy: Um and then it is interesting that the interplay between the two, how totally Brigadoon's portrayal of Scottish culture has become Scottish culture through its existence.

[1:29:12] Jimi: Yeah, totally. Crazy.

[1:29:14] Tommy: Brighton.

[1:29:19] Jimi: But hey. Do you know what's upsetting?

[1:29:22] Tommy: Come to me.

[1:29:24] Jimi: Bend to me.

[1:29:27] Tommy: Music I was listening.

[1:29:30] Jimi: I was listening to it, and my boyfriend entered from the other room and he said, which came first? Brigadoon or Phantom of the Opera? And I was like, ah, you've noticed.

[1:29:39] Tommy: Brigadoon by a long mile.

[1:29:41] Jimi: Yeah, exactly. Exactly. There's no there's no questions.

[1:29:45] Tommy: But isn't it also like a Beethoven thing? Is that not music of the night not a Beethoven one as well?

[1:29:51] Jimi: I don't Jimmy. It is hard to keep track of all of Andrew Lloyd Webber's plagiarisms. You can't expect me to just have an encyclopedia knowledge of them.

[1:30:00] Tommy: There's no there's no book binding big enough.

[1:30:02] Jimi: No, no, it's hard they just keep happening.

[1:30:04] Tommy: Really? Keep them coming, AL dubs. Keep them coming.

[1:30:10] Jimi: Um one thing before we close off, I would just like to say this is a plea. If you're Scottish, can you please write a musical about Scotland?

[1:30:23] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:30:25] Jimi: Because Brigadoon is our representation in the musical theatre over. Like that's it. That's it. That's it.

[1:30:32] Tommy: Um it's just it it's upsetting.

[1:30:37] Jimi: Yeah. You know, that we do so we do have a show called Sunshine on Leith, uh, which is a jukebox musical uh based on a band called The Proclaimers. You probably have heard the 1000 miles.

[1:30:47] Tommy: Yes, I meant to look up and play 1000 miles at a school assembly the other day, but I forgot the specific name and accidentally played 500 miles, which is a different song.

[1:30:59] Jimi: Brilliant.

[1:31:01] Tommy: Very different.

[1:31:02] Jimi: Yeah, I made up for it by playing 500 miles twice.

[1:31:05] Tommy: So good. Excellent.

[1:31:07] Jimi: Um so good. Uh but yeah, so there's a jukebox musical with them. It's alright, it's alright, it's not it's not great at all. Um but it's just a shame because Scotland has the richest history.

[1:31:21] Tommy: I mean, we've only barely touched it.

[1:31:22] Jimi: Yeah, I'm sure. We've really barely touched it here. And I get we d we talked about this in the Rob Roy Unsung Heroes, but not everyone listens to them.

[1:31:30] Tommy: No.

[1:31:31] Jimi: So this will be the calling. This will be where it all changes on the Brigadoon podcast. Um but you know, we have such a rich history. Our actual mythology is fascinating. The stories and our folklore are stunningly beautiful.

[1:31:46] Tommy: Um our social politics today are fascinating.

[1:31:50] Jimi: Yeah, no, I would love a contemporary any kind of art. Like I wish there, you know, one of the Harry Potter movies was set more squarely in Scotland or something.

[1:31:59] Tommy: Right? Like it's just a shape. Like we had a whole bloody Scottish Enlightenment. We changed philosophy in Scotland.

[1:32:06] Jimi: That's awesome. We invented the bloody telephone and the television and penicillin. Like we're good.

[1:32:13] Tommy: I'm excited to hear that song in the musical.

[1:32:20] Jimi: Um, I do actually know of a um penicillin musical coming to the fringe this year.

[1:32:26] Tommy: Really?

[1:32:27] Jimi: Yep.

[1:32:27] Tommy: Huh.

[1:32:28] Jimi: I'll let you know how it is. It is uh the I think you could force television and penicillin. There's a good it's not quite a it's a it's a close ride. It's almost there.

[1:32:36] Tommy: Or like in a in a patter song, television penicillin, like that's beautiful.

[1:32:42] Jimi: Oh that love that's lovely. Right, isn't that funny?

[1:32:44] Tommy: There you go.

[1:32:44] Jimi: Yep. There you go, but it's giving you your stars.

[1:32:47] Tommy: Yes, you're bloody welcome.

[1:32:49] Jimi: You don't even need to credit us with that one.

[1:32:51] Tommy: No, for free. Go do it for free.

[1:32:53] Jimi: Yep. Um I just I don't know, I just feel so I want it. Yeah, it's our mus even just our music is beautiful. Like, it's so nice.

[1:33:01] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:33:04] Jimi: Can someone just bloody do it?

[1:33:05] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:33:07] Jimi: Thanks. Maybe we'll talk about it on this podcast. But then the thing is is remember when we talk about things, they happen.

[1:33:16] Tommy: I know.

[1:33:17] Jimi: It's gonna happen. It's gonna happen. Next season.

[1:33:20] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:33:20] Jimi: After share. God, I man, I'm working on my Tony's video now and I'm just like ready to kill myself.

[1:33:27] Tommy: Um so yeah, it will happen. So there's there's the plea. That's perfect. That's all I wanted to say.

[1:33:33] Tommy: Wonderful.

[1:33:54] Jimi: Oh man, man, you must really love her.

[1:33:59] Tommy: You woke me up.

[1:34:02] Jimi: Come light.

[1:34:05] Tommy: Oh should you be doing some guys lad. I told you when you love someone deeply.

[1:34:14] Jimi: Anything is possible.

[1:34:17] Tommy: Even let it come.

[1:34:40] Jimi: Jimmy.

[1:34:42] Tommy: That was Brigadoon.

[1:34:43] Jimi: Aye, it was Laddie. We're gonna have to wait another hundred years to talk about it again.

[1:34:49] Tommy: Aye, we will, Ken.

[1:34:53] Jimi: They just all pirates in Scout?

[1:34:54] Tommy: I just need Yeah, that's all we talk. Um I just need to say. In um Go Home with Bonnie Jean, uh one of the uh one of the lyrics is in Edinburgh I used to know a lass with an air and her name was Joe, and every night at ten I would meet her in the Glen.

[1:35:20] Jimi: There's no Glen in Edinburgh.

[1:35:25] Tommy: Was there in 1767?

[1:35:29] Jimi: I'm gonna say no. It's because that was the lowlands. Also, you wouldn't be going from Brigadoon and the Bloody Islands down to the Lowlands.

[1:35:39] Tommy: It just wouldn't happen.

[1:35:41] Jimi: Shocking inaccuracy. Uh that is the most stunning one. Not to mention that they figured all this out in two days.

[1:35:49] Tommy: They just, I mean, they just say Glen so much.

[1:35:54] Jimi: These so much. Jimmy, these people are in shock. Like they've lost their heartfelt minister only two days ago, and then fell asleep and woke up and it was suddenly the 1800s, and then spent all that day putting together what had happened, and then we're fine with it and decided to move on with the wedding and just normal life on the third day.

[1:36:16] Tommy: Hopefully one day I'll see Brigadoon.

[1:36:18] Jimi: Hopefully.

[1:36:18] Tommy: That'd be nice.

[1:36:19] Jimi: Yeah. We must be doing it.

[1:36:21] Tommy: Right?

[1:36:22] Jimi: At some point.

[1:36:24] Tommy: I mean, yeah.

[1:36:25] Jimi: 100 years. Do you think it'll be a big tourist attraction by that point?

[1:36:29] Tommy: Everyone will be standing at the end of the day.

[1:36:30] Jimi: Yeah, it'll be like sage people just waiting with selfies.

[1:36:33] Tommy: Oh, those poor Brigadoonians. They'll wake up and stretch and they have a paparazzi just sitting outside their door.

[1:36:40] Jimi: Exactly. It will happen. Anyway, uh, so that was Brigadoon. Let's leave that for another hundred years. Um, and what let's think about what we're gonna do next. I've got a quiz question for you.

[1:36:51] Tommy: Ooh.

[1:36:54] Jimi: Great. You turned into a ghost for a second.

[1:36:58] Tommy: That may or may not be a clue.

[1:37:02] Jimi: Can you imagine? Um a laundry list of actresses were considered to play the title role in this musical, including Mary Martin, Ethel Merman, Gwen Verdon, B. Arthur, Doris Day, Elaine Stritch, Lena Horne, and Judy Garland. But instead, the role went to a relative newcomer to the Broadway scene. What show could I possibly be talking about?

[1:37:25] Tommy: I've no idea.

[1:37:26] Jimi: That's not good.

[1:37:29] Tommy: Oh, that would be great. It'd be like the female version of the boys in the band on Broadway right now.

[1:37:33] Jimi: So every gay actor you've ever seen.

[1:37:36] Tommy: Absolutely. And it would be great because I think the boys in the band would love that.

[1:37:39] Jimi: Yeah. I just want to see all of these girls in the boys in the band.

[1:37:44] Tommy: It'd be so good. Love it.

[1:37:47] Jimi: Oh man. Um well hey, if you'd like to get in touch with us and chat all about Scotland and the like, you can. Uh come and say hey in my very Scottish Twitter at Asin Hendrix.

[1:37:59] Tommy: Or come and say hello in my American Twitter musical mash or musical theatre mash on YouTube.

[1:38:05] Jimi: Or you can check out the show Twitter, and Jim and Tomic or Jim and Tomic.com.

[1:38:09] Tommy: Yes, which is linked to our lovely Reddit discussion. We'll be chatting up a storm sun.

[1:38:18] Jimi: That was very Irish.

[1:38:20] Tommy: Uh well, you know, it's as close as I get.

[1:38:20] Jimi: It's as close as you can possibly get. Um yes, and tell if we can tell your friends all about what we get up to over here.

[1:38:29] Tommy: Totes my goats, and we'll see you next time.

[1:38:33] Jimi: Yes indeed.

[1:38:54] Tommy: Awful.

[1:38:56] Jimi: How about that?

[1:38:56] Tommy: Wind sounds.

[1:38:57] Jimi: I disappear into the mist.

[1:39:02] Tommy: Wow.

[1:39:04] Jimi: For a hundred years.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred