Discuss on Reddit ➤ Support the Show ➤ Open the windows! Travel the highways! Toast the vintages and fizz the fizz! This week the Bosom Buddies are dishing on Jerry Herman’s second female tour de force: Mame. Get ready for plenty of whinging about the film, prasing of Ms... Read More
From the show: Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour
About
Open the windows! Travel the highways! Toast the vintages and fizz the fizz! This week the Bosom Buddies are dishing on Jerry Herman’s second female tour de force: Mame. Get ready for plenty of whinging about the film, prasing of Ms. Lansbury, contemplation of powerful female roles, and perhaps a hint of Nietzsche! Oh, and some gay stuff. Always some gay stuff.
Mame (Original Broadway Cast)
SPONSOR
This week’s episode is sponsored by Goldstar – the online ticket vendor that has a great selection of affordable tickets to all sorts of live events. Our first 200 listeners who head to goldstar.com/happyhour or use the promo code HAPPYHOUR at purchase will get $10 off their order.
SHOW NOTES
You’ve heard the musical, now get the book! Patrick Dennis’s novel (and Mame’s escapades) took the world by storm in the 1950s. It’s no wonder the book exploded so quickly into so many stage and film adaptations.
For a more direct discussion of southern racist problems of a bygone era, check out Happy Hour #39 about Kander and Ebb’s The Scottsboro Boys.
Is Kimmy Schmidt a modern day Auntie Mame? Well…HAS VERA CHARLES ALWAYS BEEN A LEADING LADY?!?!?
Want to get all intellectual like Jimi and read up on your Apollonian epic and Dionysian lyric verse? Then crack open a copy of Nietzsche’s The Birth of Tragedy. (And then you can explain it to Tommy).
For a fascinatingly fabulous trip town a YouTube black hole, why not check out this all-male performance of Mame from San Franciscio in 1980.
Interested in more discussion about gay men and their relationships with musical theatre, check out Tommy’s series “Musical Theatre is SO gay!”
Haven’t watched Lucy in the Mame movie yet? Don’t. Just satisfy your curiosity with this trailer for the original film.
Oh you HAVE watched the Mame movie? Then maybe you can sympathize with Tommy (or add to the vitriolic comments) on his Miscast Mame video.
Still got thoughts about the movie? Hit us up on the reddit to vent your woes.
Jimi has insisted that Tommy include the Angela Lansbury massage video. Tommy is writing these notes (in the third person) and…sigh…will include a link to the video.
Just kidding. This is the video.
A FITNESS QUIZ STATEMENT
This musical was (partially) inspired by a New York Pilates Studio on 181st street.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:01] Tommy: This episode of Happy Hour is sponsored by Gold Star.
[0:04] Jimi: Gold Star has a great selection of affordable tickets to all sorts of live events, including theater, with Broadway and Broadway national tours, concerts, comedy, dance, and more.
[0:12] Tommy: The first 200 listeners who use the promo code Happy Hour, one word all caps, will get $10 off their purchase at Goldstar.com backslash happy hour or using the Gold Star app.
[0:25] Jimi: Jimmy, didn't you fall asleep during the Tony?
[0:27] Tommy: I did.
[0:29] Jimi: I absolutely did.
[0:30] Tommy: Well, not during, they were happening somewhere else.
[0:33] Jimi: I was asleep.
[0:33] Tommy: And you were asleep.
[0:34] Jimi: You didn't I've caught up, never fear.
[0:36] Tommy: You didn't miss much.
[0:38] Jimi: I I didn't.
[0:39] Tommy: I have seen that now.
[0:41] Jimi: What I my experience of the Tonies has been watching uh the Once on This Island performance about 40 times.
[0:48] Tommy: And over and over again.
[0:50] Jimi: That's it.
[0:51] Tommy: I watched the Band's Visit one like twice.
[0:53] Jimi: Yeah.
[0:53] Tommy: It's beautiful.
[0:54] Jimi: It's just fantastic.
[0:55] Tommy: I was surprised with the Band's Visit one, how great a job they do in filming it to make it feel super intimate.
[1:02] Jimi: Um on the Radio City stage.
[1:05] Tommy: Um I guess the same with Once on This Island.
[1:07] Jimi: They did a I mean they built the Circle in the Square.
[1:10] Tommy: The whole thing.
[1:11] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:11] Tommy: A theater in a theater.
[1:13] Jimi: Circle in the Square in Radio City Music Hall.
[1:16] Tommy: Somebody get us another drink!
[1:18] Jimi: Welcome to Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour, your weekly podcast with wigs and whiskey.
[1:47] Tommy: That's a good one.
[1:47] Jimi: We've already had the whiskey last week.
[1:47] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:47] Jimi: Alright.
[1:47] Tommy: Scotland now.
[1:47] Jimi: Well, you know, we've got there's just plenty of whiskey to go around.
[1:47] Tommy: There is so much.
[1:47] Jimi: It's all good.
[1:47] Tommy: Speaking of, what are you drinking today, Jimmy?
[1:47] Jimi: Um, let's go for um.
[1:45] Tommy: I don't know, like a sidecar?
[2:15] Jimi: Ooh, that's a good one.
[2:15] Tommy: I had two.
[2:15] Jimi: Does that make sense?
[2:15] Tommy: I had that does make sense.
[2:15] Jimi: I was either gonna be drinking um just a small triple.
[2:15] Tommy: Or a daiquiri with honey.
[2:15] Jimi: Yes, that would be appropriate.
[2:15] Tommy: Mine was just of the era.
[2:16] Jimi: Or some gin from a bathtub.
[2:16] Tommy: There's just lots of alcohol in there.
[2:16] Jimi: Yeah, there is very true.
[2:27] Tommy: Yeah, gin from a bathtub.
[2:27] Jimi: That's that's a good one.
[2:27] Tommy: Gin from a bathtub.
[2:27] Jimi: Ten cents.
[2:27] Tommy: Um wow.
[2:27] Jimi: We say two bits.
[2:27] Tommy: That's funny.
[2:27] Jimi: Oh, yeah, we we wouldn't say two bits.
[2:27] Tommy: It doesn't make sense.
[2:25] Jimi: No.
[2:27] Tommy: Well, we also don't see gin from a bathtub.
[2:30] Jimi: Savages!
[2:32] Tommy: Anyway.
[2:33] Jimi: Um, you have a quiz question, I believe.
[2:35] Tommy: I do.
[2:36] A laundry list of actresses were considered to play the title role in this musical, including Mary Martin, Ethel Merman, Gwen Verdon, B. Arthur, Doris Day, Elaine Stritch, Lena Horne, and Judy Garland.
[2:46] Jimi: It's my own version of the D.Va poker rap.
[2:48] Tommy: But instead, the role went to a relative newcomer on the Broadway scene.
[2:55] Jimi: What show, Jimmy?
[2:56] Tommy: By the way, that's a new video idea, just so let you know.
[2:59] Jimi: You put that one in a pen.
[3:00] Tommy: Um, that show could only be Mame.
[3:06] Jimi: The candles.
[3:09] Tommy: Get the eyes out.
[3:12] Jimi: Roll the rug up.
[3:15] Tommy: It's today.
[3:19] Jimi: Though it may not be anyone's birthday.
[3:22] Tommy: I'm always off on the first of the year.
[3:26] Jimi: I know that this very minute has her story.
[3:29] Tommy: And that we're here.
[3:36] Jimi: Make a merry.
[3:39] Tommy: And so I'm told.
[3:45] Jimi: Tune the ground up.
[3:48] Tommy: Dance your shoes up.
[3:52] Jimi: Strike the band up.
[3:55] Tommy: It's today.
[3:58] Jimi: And we're in the world.
[4:05] Tommy: I don't know how you're not gonna put the title song right here.
[4:09] Jimi: I was gonna put it's today.
[4:11] Tommy: Like, why would like you said Mame and then it'd be maim.
[4:15] Jimi: Whatever.
[4:16] Tommy: I guess that's not how it works.
[4:17] Jimi: That'll be the closing one, Thomas.
[4:22] Tommy: Don't.
[4:23] Jimi: But my seamless editing of you singing into that song.
[4:27] Tommy: Oh, was spotless.
[4:29] Jimi: To die for.
[4:30] Tommy: I spent far too long making that good.
[4:32] Jimi: Um yes, we are doing Mame hooray.
[4:36] Tommy: Um music and lyrics by of course Mr.
[4:39] Jimi: Jerry Herman, and the book by Jerome Lawrence and Robert Edwin Lee.
[4:43] Tommy: Who goes by Robert E.
[4:45] Jimi: Lee?
[4:45] Tommy: Um, strangely.
[4:47] Jimi: Bertie Lee.
[4:48] Tommy: Bird Bertie Lee.
[4:49] Jimi: Um it's based on Auntie Mame by Patrick Dennis, the book.
[4:54] Tommy: Also the play, also the film of the play.
[4:58] Jimi: Um they all just kind of happened around the same time in the 50s.
[5:03] Tommy: Yeah, absolutely.
[5:04] Jimi: Um, and it opened up on Broadway in 1966 with, of course, Miss Angela Lansbury, who is the woman from our quiz question.
[5:12] Tommy: Um, and it ran for a whopping uh 1500 performances, which is incredible.
[5:17] Jimi: And it opened in the West End in 1969.
[5:20] Tommy: Yeah, great year.
[5:22] Jimi: Um and at the Tonys the 66 Tonys, uh, Angela Lansbury won, B. Arthur won, Frankie Michaels won for Best Supporting Actor.
[5:36] Tommy: They all did very well.
[5:37] Jimi: And there's a film, but you know, we'll get to that.
[5:40] Tommy: We will get to that.
[5:42] Jimi: Ha ha ha.
[5:44] Tommy: Okie dokie.
[5:45] Jimi: So, well, the story of Mame, it's a it's a windy one.
[5:48] Tommy: Yes.
[5:48] Jimi: It's sprawling.
[5:50] Tommy: Super episodic.
[5:51] Jimi: Yes.
[5:52] Tommy: Takes place over decades?
[5:55] Jimi: Absolutely.
[5:55] Tommy: Yeah, about 20 years.
[5:57] Jimi: Yeah.
[5:58] Tommy: Mame Dennis is a Manhattan socialite who is, you know, living in the roaring twenties and throwing her gin-filled like socialite parties when who should knock at the door but her only living relative Patrick, her nephew, who has been bequeathed to Mame by Patrick's late father.
[6:26] Jimi: And Mame takes Patrick on a wild life through his upbringing.
[6:31] Tommy: Um everywhere from Manhattan to the South to Shangri-La.
[6:38] Jimi: Um, it's their misadventures kind of through Patrick's upbringing.
[6:44] Tommy: That seemed pretty good.
[6:45] Jimi: Yeah, definitely.
[6:46] Tommy: Definitely.
[6:46] Jimi: Um, and it sort of uh comes to a sort of a close uh when Patrick's all grown up and he he meets Mame again, and she finds that he's uh kind of become the person she never wanted him to be.
[7:02] Tommy: Yes.
[7:03] Jimi: Uh and it's all about how she kind of finally shows him the way.
[7:07] Tommy: Yes, exactly.
[7:09] Jimi: There is um, you know, Mame is uh exotic and artistic and bohemian, and uh Patrick and really Patrick's father was decidedly not, and so Patrick is kind of um, you know, put under Mame's care with a huge set of caveats enforced by Mr.
[7:31] Tommy: Babcock, who is in charge of his trust, um Patrick's trust.
[7:36] Jimi: And so we kind of see the the tension there between Mame's Bohemian lifestyle and Patrick's back and forth between wanting to become his anti-Mame and not wanting to become his anti-Mame.
[7:49] Tommy: Exactly.
[7:50] Jimi: And I've got some definitions for later for that.
[7:52] Tommy: Ooh.
[7:53] Jimi: Some literary definition.
[7:57] Tommy: How intellectual.
[8:00] Jimi: Way, that's what we are.
[8:02] Tommy: Um but here, shall we shall we dive on into the Roaring Twenties?
[8:08] Jimi: Let's do it.
[8:08] Tommy: I'm Charles Stinning in my seat.
[8:10] Jimi: Charles Stinning, can you verb that?
[8:13] Tommy: Yeah.
[8:13] Jimi: Excellent.
[8:14] Tommy: I'm Charles Stinning in my seat.
[8:16] Jimi: Excellent.
[8:19] Tommy: Oh, Vera, I can't wait to hear that overture.
[8:22] Jimi: Tell me about the show.
[8:24] Tommy: Well, well, it's this terribly modern operetta about a lady astronomer who makes a universe shaking discovery.
[8:56] Jimi: I have a little secret I'd like to impart that I hope doesn't give you too much of a start.
[9:02] Tommy: Though it's shocking, it's completely true.
[9:10] Jimi: I know it isn't gossip or rumor, of course, for I've had it from quite a reliable source, and I'd like to pass it on to you in the moon is a lady.
[9:38] Tommy: A lady with lipstick and curls the cow that jumped over, cried would jump in Jehovah.
[9:54] Jimi: I think it's just one of the girls.
[10:01] Tommy: She winks at the end of the day.
[10:05] Jimi: You know, I actually it is a long-running joke in my family that we will break into the Charleston at random moments.
[10:13] Tommy: You think I'm making that up, but that's actually a thing that me and my brothers do all the time.
[10:18] Jimi: And you actually break into it.
[10:19] Tommy: Yeah, when in doubt, Charleston.
[10:21] Jimi: Okay, right now, just for my own benefit, can you get up and why not?
[10:31] Tommy: Because I'm very comfy right now.
[10:33] Jimi: Ugh.
[10:34] Tommy: I was even kidding.
[10:35] Jimi: Well, tomorrow at Pride.
[10:36] Tommy: I want videos.
[10:37] Jimi: Plenty of Charlestoning.
[10:38] Tommy: Charlestoning and pride.
[10:40] Jimi: I love it.
[10:40] Tommy: It's one of my favorite uh styles of dance to do.
[10:44] Jimi: Yes.
[10:44] Tommy: Yeah.
[10:45] Jimi: No, it's it's just so invigorating.
[10:47] Tommy: That whole this whole era, the 1920s, this, you know, flapper Charleston style dance.
[10:53] Jimi: Oh, yes, please.
[10:54] Tommy: Yeah, absolutely.
[10:56] Jimi: Um, none of the other stuff that was going on, but just uh just that.
[10:59] Tommy: That's so all the paid closed door stuff is the best.
[11:02] Jimi: Yes.
[11:03] Tommy: Jimmy, can I Jimmy, can I read to you a stage direction from this musical?
[11:08] Jimi: Yes.
[11:09] Tommy: This is from the very beginning.
[11:11] They're describing the partygoers at Mame's first big party.
[11:15] Um right at she like this is, you know, our meeting of Auntie Mame and the context in which she lives kind of before Patrick enters her life, or like right as he enters.
[11:25] Jimi: Um this is a stage direction straight out of the libretto.
[11:28] Now Mame is down the stairs greeting and kissing guests who include the half drunken but chic operetta star Vera Charles, a bearded Orthodox bishop, the athletic Ralph Devine, the suave publisher M. Lindsay Woolsey, and people who might be Floyd Gibbons, Marian Anderson, Radcliffe Hall, Paul Robertson, Lady Mendel, Fatty Arbuckle, Bob Benchley, Texas Guinan, I don't know who these people are.
[11:49] Tommy: Plus assorted flappers, gangsters, and even an Arab.
[11:55] Jimi: Yeah.
[11:58] Tommy: And I think there is a very interesting tone that this musical sets of like an anti-racism progressiveness of a bygone era.
[12:10] Jimi: Yeah.
[12:11] Tommy: It's weird, because like when I so when I read that stage direction, it was that I was like, oh, because it wasn't it wasn't um oh I can't believe that.
[12:22] Jimi: Because I get what I get what they're meaning by that.
[12:25] Tommy: Right.
[12:25] Jimi: They're saying you know, Mame invites everyone to her parties.
[12:29] Tommy: Exactly.
[12:30] Jimi: And like the part, you know, we've got anyone mixing with people like Fatty Arbuckle, who's a big director, he's the only one of them I know, but I thought I'd pull that out.
[12:39] Tommy: Um, like the Hoy Polloi.
[12:42] Jimi: Right, exactly.
[12:43] Tommy: Like the the elite of Manhattan, but also but the the exotic elite.
[12:48] Jimi: Um there is certainly, you know, a uh an interesting undercurrent through this show that it is I find it difficult to tease out about you know Mame is a contemporary icon and tries to stay up to date.
[13:06] Tommy: She's always updating the paintings in her house and is like fills, you know, surrounds herself with um the outcasts of society sometimes like the but it is interesting to see that written in the 1960s, where like there's that dichotomy of they want this to be progressive and new, of course, but it is still the 60s, so there's still like you know, we looking back on it now, it seems almost naive.
[13:41] Tommy: Yeah.
[13:43] Jimi: Uh wait, what do you mean like on their part?
[13:48] Tommy: Yeah, like the I think the thing that stands out to me the most is um so Mame falls in love with Beauregard. You know, a fine southern gentleman. Um, and it is quite the to-do that Mame goes to visit Beauregard and his gigantic family on their southern plantation.
[14:10] Jimi: Yes.
[14:11] Tommy: And while it is interesting because there are moments where characters in this show are portrayed as explicitly racist.
[14:20] Jimi: Yeah.
[14:20] Tommy: No one on the plantation is portrayed as explicitly racist. But they're like you, with all the trappings of this kind of Southern feel that always, you know, makes me nervous, rubs me the wrong way a little bit.
[14:39] Jimi: And the whole conceit is that Beauregard's family isn't going to appreciate or accept Mame because she's a Yankee. She's uh, you know, an uppity society girl, and that's not how we do things down here. Um then, through, you know, hilarious happenstance and being able to ride a horse accidentally, Mame proves herself to this giant family, and suddenly the entire South accepts this Yankee Manhattan girl as one of their own.
[15:12] Tommy: Um that is like, you know, it's it's like the authors were like, and then that's how Mame solved southern racism or you know, southern lack of acceptance by just being funny and nice and a go getter. Um and like clearly that's not the intent. Jerry Herman just wants to write a song where you can cakewalk and kick line. Um but there's something about it that like seems naive.
[15:45] Jimi: Do you think it's just too idealistic? Is that what you mean?
[15:47] Tommy: I think it is, you know, I think it is something that hold would hold the musical back today. Um like, and why we don't see a lot of contemporary revivals. Uh I also think it's the sort of thing that in 1966 the New York audience was like, yeah. Um because also for a New York Manhattan audience, it is easier to portray Southern people as slow and stupid.
[16:13] Jimi: Um because they're far away. We talked about this in maybe Space Force. Um like there is that, you know, it's almost like a uh a Yankee savior story.
[16:31] Tommy: Yeah, it has it's uh I feel like it kind of comes out of nowhere. That whole section.
[16:35] Jimi: Yeah.
[16:36] Tommy: Because Beauregard could be anyone.
[16:38] Jimi: Right, exactly. He doesn't need to be a plantation owner in the South.
[16:43] Tommy: Um is quite peculiar that he is. So uh yeah, I always I remember the first the very first time I listened to it. No, it's actually quite uh weird. So the first time I listened to this was in about 2009.
[16:57] Jimi: Okay.
[16:57] Tommy: Um, and then I didn't pick it up again until a month ago.
[17:01] Jimi: So fascinating.
[17:03] Tommy: Yeah. Uh in back in 2009, that was when I was like becoming a nerd. Uh and so now being a nerd, right? Um, at first I was a bit like, oh, I did not pick up on that the first time. I mean, just it's so left left of you because it also never gets brought back again.
[17:22] Jimi: No.
[17:23] Tommy: In Act Two, yeah. That whole story stopped.
[17:25] Jimi: No, it's gone. I mean, like, Beauregard's dead at the end of intermission.
[17:29] Tommy: Like, yeah. It's um it's such a I think that's one of the, you know, maybe separate from some of the more social issues for this thing. I do think that is an interesting um kind of piece of fallout of this being such an episodic musical, is that so many things happen and then never come back again and are like only barely related to the story, like the man in the moon is a lady, like hilarious, wonderful, and could also be totally cut and none of the plot would be lost.
[18:03] Jimi: Totally, none of it. Absolutely.
[18:05] Tommy: Um of these things I think just kind of build up to show you who Mame is, and like these are Mame's ideals, yeah. Like these are the this is the Mame way, yeah.
[18:17] Jimi: Um it's quite interesting because like it almost feels like you could collect you could go out and collect the Mame comics.
[18:24] Tommy: Yeah, exactly. Do you know what I mean? And like, oh, and this one, this is the one where Mame saves the South.
[18:28] Jimi: Right.
[18:28] Tommy: Oh, this is the one where Mame stars in a vaudeville show.
[18:31] Jimi: Right.
[18:31] Tommy: Like Yeah, exactly. Like if that's what it feels like. It feels like a serial.
[18:34] Jimi: Yeah, and that they've just kind of brought these all together. Um I think it was supposed to be a TV show at one point.
[18:42] Jimi: Interesting.
[18:42] Tommy: I would I think I would very much enjoy that.
[18:45] Jimi: Yeah.
[18:46] Tommy: Um but I don't I mean, I don't know the history of it, but I have 100% read that somewhere. Um it does have that episodic, like, because she is this very strong character who has it's almost she's almost like Kimmy Bloody Schmidt.
[19:03] Jimi: Yeah.
[19:03] Tommy: Like, do you know what I mean? And and huge differences, but uh just in that sense, it's like, well, what does Kimmy get up to today?
[19:10] Jimi: Yeah, exactly.
[19:10] Tommy: You know, I think it's put Kimmy in this situation. Let's put Mame in this situation and see what she does. I don't know where I was reading it, reading it, but it was a quote from Jerry Herman, and he said, um uh Mame may not always know where she's going, but she damn well is gonna get there.
[19:26] Jimi: Um Exactly, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
[19:28] Tommy: I read that. It's such a great descriptor. Um but it then it is interesting that like some of these, you know, quote unquote progressive issues come out, but because it's so episodic, it's like boop, that's it, done, move on.
[19:41] Jimi: Absolutely.
[19:41] Tommy: It's just like, yeah, it's just like she waves her magic main wand and then trots off to the next one.
[19:47] Jimi: Exactly.
[19:47] Tommy: Um yeah, it's quite it is quite interesting. And I guess like as a sort of a storytelling point of view, um, obviously she goes on these, like we say, misadventures. Um it's quite interesting that the kind of the main story, this her main project, the main magic wand throw of her and Patrick is the only thing that could ever be in jeopardy.
[20:10] Jimi: Yeah.
[20:10] Tommy: But yeah, that's like the strongest relationship that runs through the whole show.
[20:15] Jimi: Yeah.
[20:16] Tommy: Um so that's quite smart. I quite like that.
[20:18] Jimi: Yeah, it is it is interesting. I find it interesting because episodic musicals stereotypically don't do well. Episodic plays don't do well. Um, you know, it's the the Greek unity of time. Um the fact that this was as popular as it was and still kind of weaves this, you know, what's the comic book of the week meme story into two hours of theater.
[20:44] Jimi: Um is fascinating. Like I wanna it is like why, you know?
[20:51] Tommy: Yeah.
[20:51] Jimi: It's gotta be something more than just catchy thong songs or catchy thongs.
[20:56] Tommy: Um catchy thongs. Woo!
[20:59] Jimi: I do I do think it speaks a lot to just how wonderfully clever the character of Mame is.
[21:07] Tommy: Absolutely.
[21:09] Jimi: Um, it's just is such an iconic character. Um, and I feel like there will be eyes rolling out there because like, oh look, it's two gay guys talking about Mame again. But that's fine.
[21:23] Tommy: Um, and we'll talk more on that story later. But uh yeah, so uh on my readings, my readings of Mame, uh um, I stumbled into uh Greek literature.
[21:36] Jimi: Fascinating.
[21:37] Tommy: Um in the concept uh of Apollonian and Dionysian uh uh stories or like a dichotomy.
[21:48] Jimi: Okay.
[21:50] Tommy: Uh and I think it was Nietzsche, and I'm not even kidding, uh, who kind of propagated this idea.
[22:00] Jimi: Yes, we're talking about philosophy of Jimotography's because he's happy.
[22:04] Tommy: Yes, we are um but just in the sense, and I think this is just uh what I mean is that it's a really good uh example of this, because it's uh this kind of concept of um Apollonian Dionysian dichotomy, uh-huh, um in the sense that so um Apollo and Dionysus, two Greek gods, uh had a sort of a rivalry because Apollo represented sort of a stoic and rigid way of life, whereas uh Dionysus, who's the god of wine and merriment, uh very much you know, lived in the world of freedom and wildness and you know, cathonic craziness.
[22:48] Jimi: Um, and these two had this kind of you know, this battle.
[22:53] Tommy: Um, and I think it it gets talked about a lot in gay culture, yeah.
[22:59] Jimi: Uh b because of our own kind of dichotomy, or his certainly a more historical dichotomy that we've had of you know, living in the closet and having this other life that we have, you know, in an underground leather bar, yeah.
[23:15] Tommy: Um then coming out in anything.
[23:17] Jimi: Stereotyped as raucous and you know exactly, yeah.
[23:22] Tommy: Absolutely. Um, and so I think it comes into play in Mame, yeah.
[23:28] Jimi: Uh, because Mame is a hundred percent a Dionysian character, like a hundred percent. She has no there's nothing stopping Mame.
[23:38] Tommy: Right.
[23:38] Jimi: Do you know what I mean? She is a barrel that is rolling, yeah, and it will just keep keep on going.
[23:43] Tommy: Yeah.
[23:43] Jimi: Um she openly says this and she openly celebrates this.
[23:49] Tommy: Yeah.
[23:49] Jimi: Um, but then you have these other kind of characters in her life which present this more Apollonian uh vibe.
[23:58] Tommy: Yeah.
[23:59] Jimi: Uh so you've got Mr. Babat, I can never remember his actual name.
[24:02] Tommy: Uh I was about to say Mr. Babaduke.
[24:08] Jimi: It is pride.
[24:10] Tommy: Babcock. Speaking of speaking of gay icons, the Babadic.
[24:16] Jimi: Um, but yeah, so Mystick, you know, who is this idea of like staunch conservatism, bully for you, etc.
[24:23] Tommy: Right.
[24:23] Jimi: Um but like portrayed as this, you know, he is the antagonist.
[24:28] Tommy: Yes, yes, absolutely.
[24:30] Jimi: Um, but presents doesn't present an ideal a ne an idea that is antagonistic, it's just different.
[24:38] Tommy: Yeah, I mean, it it's different to the one that we're celebrating in this story, yeah.
[24:43] Jimi: Um, because there's nothing wrong with sending your child to a normal school.
[24:47] Tommy: Right.
[24:48] Jimi: I mean, he does he does have lines like, I'm gonna turn this boy into a god fearing Catholic if it has if I have to break every bone in his body.
[24:55] Tommy: Like he's not the brightest shining light of No, but then the thing is is that is it's that's still a it's quite a fa a paternal thing to say, you know.
[25:06] Jimi: I mean, and there are families where I'm sure that quote has been heard.
[25:09] Tommy: Yeah, yeah.
[25:10] Jimi: Unironically.
[25:11] Tommy: Yeah.
[25:11] Jimi: Um so it's not it's not like it's so uh he's not like I'm gonna lock you up in a patr horrible nasty school for evil boys or something like that.
[25:20] Tommy: Right.
[25:21] Jimi: It's just your father wants you to have a conventional education and we're gonna do that, and Mame's like, absolutely not, to the nudist colony with you.
[25:29] Tommy: Right, yeah, exactly. The other end of the spectrum.
[25:32] Jimi: It is it does very much create, I think a story of characters who don't make a lot of decisions. Um like this is a very observational story, you know.
[25:45] Tommy: Like certainly you're engaging with Mame and you're like empathizing with her and like feeling all the things she feels, but I don't know if like maybe um if he walked into my life, is that the name of that song?
[25:59] Jimi: Um yeah, if he walked into my life, she has some like interior conflict, maybe.
[26:08] Tommy: That's about it, you know.
[26:11] Jimi: Mame is not indecisive in this show.
[26:15] Tommy: Yeah.
[26:15] Jimi: Like and yeah, there's very little inter like that is really the only point.
[26:20] Tommy: Yeah.
[26:20] Jimi: Um, which I think makes it super powerful. Um, you know, it makes her super powerful.
[26:26] Tommy: Yeah.
[26:27] Jimi: Like the She's Mary Poppins.
[26:29] Tommy: Like she is.
[26:30] Jimi: She is Mary Poppins. She is otherworldly mystical, um, you know.
[26:36] Tommy: And unstoppable.
[26:37] Jimi: Yeah. Like. You never you at no point in the show do you think, oh god, Mame's gonna change, or oh god, Mame's gonna lose her flair.
[26:45] Jimi: Yeah.
[26:46] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?
[26:46] Jimi: Yeah.
[26:47] Tommy: You do think, oh god, Mame's gonna lose Patrick.
[26:50] Jimi: Um, and like that that I think is the fear of the show.
[26:54] Tommy: That's the mystery, that's the suspense, that's what you know keeps you engaged, and what makes the whole dinner party scene hilarious and tense at the very end.
[27:05] Jimi: Um, is she gonna make this last hurrah?
[27:09] Tommy: Exactly. The we haven't quite explained.
[27:11] Jimi: Uh Patrick um falls in love with a boring girl.
[27:16] Tommy: Does that seem like a good description?
[27:17] Jimi: Literally, that's it.
[27:18] Tommy: Yeah.
[27:19] Jimi: Um the a rich, boring girl.
[27:21] Tommy: A rich boring girl and invites her whole family, the Uptons, over to Mame's apartment for a dinner party.
[27:28] Jimi: Um well first called Upton Downs, which I think is funny.
[27:31] Tommy: Oh man.
[27:32] Jimi: Um, but the Uptons uh besides from being kind of boring suburbanites, are also racist.
[27:39] Tommy: Um the like Mame invites them over, you know, and and is Mame serves them, you know, baked monkey and boiled python or whatever it is.
[27:53] Jimi: And bees this one's bees.
[27:56] Tommy: Um it's so funny.
[27:58] Jimi: Um but then uh, you know, intro like accidentally, quote unquote introduces them to Mrs. Gooch, the unmarried pregnant nanny of Patrick.
[28:09] Tommy: Um, you know, and then uh in her big old FU tells the Uptons that she's bought the land right next to their estate and is going to turn it into uh a home for unmarried pregnant women, which totally disturbs them.
[28:27] Jimi: And there is a brief moment where you think you know, Mame might have totally lost her connection with Patrick right there.
[28:34] Tommy: Like this may be a step too far towards indoctrinating him in her Bohemian lifestyle.
[28:42] Jimi: Yeah.
[28:42] Tommy: Um of course it's a music it's a Jerry Herman musical, so that doesn't happen, but I think that is the drama that's worth playing up in this.
[28:50] Jimi: Yeah, for sure.
[28:52] Tommy: Um but yeah, she's just it's a f an amazing character, a proper celebratory, joyous being.
[29:02] Jimi: Yeah, absolutely.
[29:03] Tommy: A force.
[29:04] Jimi: A proper force.
[29:06] Tommy: Um and I don't think there are many uh characters as forceful yeah as this one.
[29:16] Jimi: I I think so too.
[29:17] Tommy: Well, you this might be a good transition point.
[29:20] Jimi: That's what I was building to.
[29:21] Tommy: Yes, well done for Piccadill.
[29:24] Jimi: I'll make this bow, my little love.
[29:26] Tommy: That on the last day of your life, you'll be smiling the same young smile.
[29:35] Jimi: You're smiling now, my little love.
[29:38] Tommy: If you wake up every morning and you pull aside the shutter, and you promise me that these will be the first words that you uh open a new window, open a new door, travel a new highway that's never been tried before.
[30:03] Jimi: Before you find your adult fellow, punching the same clock, walking the same tight rope as everyone on the block.
[30:12] Tommy: The fella you ought to be three-dimensional, soaking up light down to your toes.
[30:20] Jimi: Whenever they say it's rightly unconventional, just put your thumb up to your nose and show them how to dance to a new rhythm.
[30:31] Tommy: This is a new song.
[30:37] Jimi: There's only one way to make the bowl stay.
[30:41] Tommy: Simply travel a new highway, dance to a new rhythm.
[30:45] Jimi: Open a new window every day.
[30:51] Tommy: Open a new window.
[30:53] Jimi: Open a new door.
[30:55] Tommy: Travel a new highway.
[30:57] Jimi: There's never been tried before.
[30:59] Tommy: Before you find a whole fellow, touching the same part, walking the same tight rope as everyone on the board.
[31:07] Jimi: The fella you ought to be a three-dimensional.
[31:11] Tommy: Soaking apart.
[31:15] Jimi: Whenever they say the slightly unconventional, just with your door, up to your nose.
[31:55] Tommy: One of the things that makes Mame so powerful is she is a she's a non-traditional female role in musical theater.
[32:04] Jimi: Do you think that's fair to say?
[32:05] Tommy: Absolutely.
[32:06] Jimi: Especially in 1960s musical theater.
[32:08] Tommy: Yeah.
[32:08] Jimi: I mean, coming right off of, you know, Jerry Herman wrote Hello Dolly and then wanted to write Hello Dolly again and wrote Mame.
[32:15] Tommy: And right?
[32:17] Jimi: And there's plenty of comparison you can do between Mame and Dolly.
[32:20] Tommy: And Dolly is, of course, also a powerful female character.
[32:24] Jimi: Um but her entire modus operandi is um to marry Horace Vandergelder.
[32:32] Tommy: Like her entire existence on this in this musical is to get married.
[32:37] Jimi: For Mame, her love story is a tiny portion of this show.
[32:43] Tommy: Yep.
[32:44] Jimi: It's just one.
[32:45] Tommy: And also she says very early on that marriage isn't on her radar.
[32:50] Jimi: Like it's not something she's seeking out.
[32:53] Tommy: Yeah.
[32:53] Jimi: She's just seeking out the ability to live.
[32:56] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.
[32:57] Jimi: You know?
[32:57] Tommy: And that's her priority.
[32:59] Jimi: To that, there I think there is an argument to be made that she marries Beauregard for that.
[33:05] Tommy: I wouldn't go so far to say that she marries Beauregard for his money, but she definitely marries him to live in the misadventure.
[33:12] Jimi: Right, exactly.
[33:13] Tommy: Yeah.
[33:14] Jimi: Up I completely, completely believe that.
[33:16] Tommy: I don't really see their relationship as being anything too solid, anything too exciting.
[33:22] Jimi: Just in the sense that she's a lovely person who probably has a lot of love to give.
[33:26] Tommy: Yeah.
[33:27] Jimi: Uh and is able to give that freely.
[33:29] Tommy: Yeah.
[33:29] Jimi: You know.
[33:30] Tommy: I don't think she's like, you're the man for me, I'm ready to settle down for the rest of my life.
[33:35] Jimi: Yeah.
[33:36] Tommy: I mean do whatever you want.
[33:37] Jimi: Yeah.
[33:38] Tommy: And it and it's just such a tiny part of the show.
[33:41] Jimi: Like between um uh Bosom Buddies and Gooch's song, like we we pass the Bechtel test fully and completely in this like most of the conversation most of the songs in the show are sung by women and aren't about men.
[33:59] Tommy: Yeah, yeah.
[34:01] Jimi: Which is super progressive for 1966.
[34:05] Tommy: Absolutely.
[34:05] Jimi: And it again, it just doesn't really happen.
[34:08] Tommy: Yeah.
[34:09] Jimi: Nowadays.
[34:10] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.
[34:12] Jimi: Like we haven't I th that I think is perhaps one of the more baffling things is like that this, you know, maybe because we are talking it as an adaptation and um, you know Jerome Robert and Jerry all got very lucky that this story was so beloved and that they were able to adapt it in the time they wrote it in.
[34:30] Tommy: Like, you know, they we can't give them all the credit for inventing Mame.
[34:35] Jimi: Um But it is surprising that there aren't more you know, we don't we don't hit strong independent women in musical theater again in this way.
[34:49] Tommy: I would say applause.
[34:51] Jimi: Yeah, applause is a good example.
[34:53] Tommy: Um, you know, wicked, um, like yeah, which still has plenty of, you know, uh heterosexual love in it um yeah but like the Mame is unique in that way.
[35:08] Jimi: Like super I think so, super feminist.
[35:11] Tommy: Sticking it literally sticking it to the man throughout the entire show um like who cares it's just like sisters doing it for the like do you know I mean they're just everyone wants to be Mame and Vera.
[35:22] Jimi: Oh god yes uh um yeah well and so that is you joked earlier but two more gays talking about Mame um like they at musical Mondays in the gay bar in Chicago they play Bosom Buddies the good version between B. Arthur and Angela Lansbury from whatever Tony's or show it is yeah and like everyone loses it and everyone tears the house down be because something about it is so gay.
[35:53] Tommy: Yeah you know it's it's literally just two old queens throwing shades.
[35:59] Jimi: Right.
[36:00] Tommy: Yeah that's that's a fabulous way to put it like that's exactly what it is the the cattiness the you know we hate each other because we love each other kind of like we would be nowhere without each other right and I know you inside out.
[36:15] Jimi: Right.
[36:16] Tommy: Do you know I mean it's and I insult you deeply every moment we meet.
[36:21] Jimi: Because I love you.
[36:22] Tommy: Yeah exactly um is great which is hugely you know a part of gay culture.
[36:29] Jimi: And like who knows how intentional all of this was but like gay audiences adore Mame.
[36:39] Tommy: Well I think I think it is intentional.
[36:41] Jimi: I absolutely think it is and I think it's just all because of Jerry Herman.
[36:44] Tommy: Like so obviously we said, yeah, this isn't Jerry Herman's story.
[36:47] Jimi: This is a pure adaptation.
[36:48] Tommy: But what attracted Jerry Herman to it, right?
[36:51] Jimi: Um, you know, is is this it is it's a hundred percent a gay story.
[36:57] Tommy: Yeah.
[36:58] Jimi: Um, and I feel like Jerry Herman's own narrative.
[37:01] Tommy: We've talked this uh weirdly we've talked to this about Sondheim.
[37:03] Jimi: There's a hundred percent an essay in this.
[37:05] Tommy: Yeah.
[37:05] Jimi: Um as he progresses, he peeks more and more out of the closet.
[37:09] Tommy: Oh yeah.
[37:10] Jimi: Do you know what I mean?
[37:11] Tommy: Until we hit Lakage and then we're and then more fully out, yeah.
[37:13] Jimi: The wings are on the floor, right?
[37:15] Tommy: Um but you know, this is a really important moment for him because this, you know, it's weird that it takes a gay man to write this feminist show.
[37:26] Jimi: Yeah.
[37:26] Tommy: Yeah.
[37:27] Jimi: You know, it would it couldn't have been written by Rogers and Hammerstein, like yeah, lesser.
[37:35] Tommy: You know, I mean, it couldn't because they don't they wouldn't get this.
[37:39] Jimi: Yeah, they wouldn't get the need for this.
[37:41] Tommy: Yeah.
[37:41] Jimi: And yeah.
[37:44] Tommy: It just means because that's what I see that's what I see Mame as.
[37:47] Jimi: Yeah.
[37:48] Tommy: And I guess we're in a way as well, she's just a beacon.
[37:50] Jimi: Right.
[37:51] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?
[37:52] Jimi: Exactly.
[37:52] Tommy: She's well, and not to, you know, I I think there is a dangerous type rope to walk because I never want to minimize Mame as a feminist icon and bogard it into Mame being a metaphorical representation of the gay man's journey, right?
[38:09] Jimi: Oh, absolutely, absolutely.
[38:10] Tommy: And like I I think she's certainly both.
[38:14] Jimi: Um see, I don't I don't look at it as like the gay man's journey.
[38:19] Tommy: I don't like because I I know there are all the parallels between Patrick and her, and like, you know, I've read essays about Mame being the drag mother to Patrick's drag daughter and all that.
[38:29] Jimi: Um I think at its heart it it is it is purely feminist and it's for women because the stories aren't there for women.
[38:37] Tommy: Mm-hmm.
[38:37] Jimi: Yeah.
[38:38] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?
[38:39] Jimi: And the the way it works in a versatic commas with with gay culture is we look to these wonderful sisterly relationships because uh that is the kind of inner femininity that we want to explore.
[38:55] Tommy: You know what I mean?
[38:56] Jimi: Yeah.
[38:56] Tommy: The inner feminine that we as gay men choose to embrace as opposed to block.
[39:03] Jimi: Right.
[39:04] Tommy: Because we all have it.
[39:05] Jimi: Exactly.
[39:06] Tommy: And there aren't explicit representations of it as much or then what you know, pick your poison.
[39:12] Jimi: And so what you have is Mame.
[39:15] Tommy: Yeah.
[39:16] Jimi: Absolutely.
[39:17] Tommy: Absolutely.
[39:17] Jimi: So it's, uh, you know, I don't see Jerry Herman writing this as, uh, gay, you know, gay homosexual propaganda. Do you know what I mean? I'm like, I'm gonna tell my story.
[39:28] Tommy: Yeah.
[39:28] Jimi: It's just like, this is the woman I want to be friends with.
[39:32] Tommy: Right.
[39:32] Jimi: Exactly. Yeah. This is, you know, it's escapism.
[39:36] Tommy: Yeah.
[39:36] Jimi: Absolutely. Because it's so idealistic.
[39:39] Tommy: Yes.
[39:40] Jimi: Abs, yes. And especially, you know, we're talking 1960s. This is a time where, like, writing escapist literature for the theater is a bit of an act of protest.
[39:50] Tommy: Um, 100.
[39:53] Jimi: 100.
[39:54] Tommy: Um, so it is, it's just beautiful. I mean, the thing is, it's like we could talk till the cows come home about Mame of the Gays.
[40:01] Tommy: Yes. And I think the gays have for decades. Really, really have. Um. And it's just, yeah, I don't know, I just think it's great in that respect. It is just fabulous in that respect. Yep. Um there's a great uh YouTube video series. The all-male Mame production. No, not that one. No, I was talking about musical theaters. Oh, I make YouTube videos sometimes in the past. Um I was giving you a beautiful blog and you didn't even pick it up. Yeah, maybe we'll maybe we'll put in the show notes if you haven't watched it. I talk a long time about how musical theater is gay. I talk a lot about Jerry Herman. Um yeah, but there's I mean there's loads like we'll kind of load up the uh show notes with books and essays and things like that. Because there's loads out there, and it is very interesting.
[40:52] Jimi: Yeah. Um I feel like this is a big, you know, cornerstone in this world of moving musicals away from the Rogers and Hammersteins and into the uh Lawrences and the Sondheims and the Yeah, letting musical theater I don't know, feel a little more.
[41:18] Tommy: Yeah, exactly. Just kind of be, you know, it's almost like it's allowing musical theater to write the stories for the people that are watching them.
[41:30] Jimi: Yeah, yeah. No, that's exactly it. I mean like I, you know, I love Mame and I listened and watched this show and just the concepts behind like open a new window and it's today and like I find so infinitely empowering. Um for whatever reason.
[41:51] Tommy: Oh totally. It just, it that's the thing, it's like on the sock, whether you're gay or whether you're straight, whatever.
[41:57] Jimi: Yeah. It's just an exciting, powerful story.
[42:03] Tommy: Yeah. We'll always be somebody's friends, sisters, and palms.
[42:13] Jimi: We'll always be for somebody.
[42:18] Tommy: If life should reject you, there's me to protect you.
[42:22] Jimi: If I say that your tongue is vicious, if I call you uncooped, it's simply that.
[42:32] Tommy: Who else but up for somebody will sit down and tell ya the truth.
[42:40] Jimi: Though now and again I'm aware that my can be.
[42:43] Tommy: Okay, so this episode is of course sponsored by Gold Star. Tommy, tell us all about Gold Star.
[42:48] Jimi: Well, so I'm looking up right here. Um as you know, Gold Star has a bunch of tickets to live events, affordable tickets. Uh most of their tickets are marked down from the original ones, and they have a bunch of regional tickets right here in Denver. Jimmy, I could go see Crybaby the Musical. Did you know that was a thing?
[43:04] Tommy: Absolutely. You're talking to a big John Waters fan right here. Or if I wanted to put my sports hat on, they've got some Rockies tickets too, and I could go to a baseball game.
[43:15] Jimi: That I could tell you nothing about. Yeah, if you uh go over and check out goldstar.com um or check out the absolutely free Gold Star app. Um, and if you are one of our first 200 listeners who use our promo code Happy Hour, uh then you'll get $10 off your purchase.
[43:35] Tommy: And that's on the already marked down tickets.
[43:38] Jimi: Yeah, absolutely. Uh a lot of tickets on Gold Star about 50% off, and I see that here, and it just looks great. Look at this.
[43:43] Tommy: I could go see Annie.
[43:46] Jimi: I would go see Annie.
[43:47] Tommy: Yeah. Would you?
[43:48] Jimi: We'd like to thank you, bigger hoover.
[43:51] Tommy: So great. Yep, so if you use the promo code Happy Hour, that's Happy Hour all caps one word at goldstar.com backslash happy hour.
[44:00] Jimi: You can get ten dollars off your first order.
[44:03] Tommy: That only goes out to our first 200 listeners. So use it quick.
[44:05] Jimi: Use it now.
[44:06] Tommy: Run, use it now.
[44:09] Jimi: Run to your computer.
[44:16] Tommy: I'll always be Alistokeless if you'll be Gertrude Stein.
[44:25] Jimi: And though I'll admit I dish you, I've gossiped and gloated, but I'm so devoted.
[44:33] Tommy: And if I say that sex and guts made you into a star, it's simply that.
[44:42] Jimi: Who else but up for somebody will tell you how rotten you are?
[44:51] Tommy: Just turn to your brother somebody for a faction for health and affection for loyalty, love and more soon.
[45:02] Jimi: Remember that.
[45:03] Tommy: Who else got up for somebody?
[45:12] Jimi: Sit down and sell.
[45:20] Tommy: Speaking of gay men.
[45:22] Jimi: Lucille Ball.
[45:25] Tommy: Well, I was gonna say, this I think is perhaps one of the biggest gay men conflicts in the history of homosexuality.
[45:39] Jimi: Wow.
[45:40] Tommy: I'm ready.
[45:44] Jimi: Jimmy, did you know they made a movie of this musical?
[45:47] Tommy: I did.
[45:50] Jimi: And do you know who starred as Mame in the movie of this musical?
[45:56] Tommy: That was I Love Lucy herself.
[46:00] Jimi: 62-year-old Lucille Ball.
[46:03] Tommy: Yep. Yep.
[46:06] Jimi: And no one has forgiven anyone for this movie in years.
[46:11] Tommy: No, they have not. It's I find it reasonably fascinating and kind of funny.
[46:18] Jimi: Yeah. Um, because so like I'm actually not that attached to Mame. I'm just gonna throw that out there.
[46:22] Tommy: It's fascinating.
[46:24] Jimi: Okay.
[46:24] Tommy: Yeah. Uh it like I say, it came onto my radar in 2009. You know, it's not like, oh, the big part of my life.
[46:30] Jimi: It's not a daily listen for you.
[46:32] Tommy: Yeah, like the actual musical, the all the kind of stuff lying around it, the socio-political world of Mame.
[46:38] Jimi: Yeah.
[46:38] Tommy: Um, I'm well loving and involved in.
[46:41] Jimi: Yeah.
[46:41] Tommy: But the actual show itself, yeah.
[46:43] Jimi: Uh I you know, it's not it's not anywhere near my top ten.
[46:48] Tommy: Um much for Hello Dolly.
[46:51] Jimi: Okay.
[46:52] Tommy: You know, talking Herman and much for Hello Dolly.
[46:55] Jimi: Um, uh, so the movie I I hadn't watched till we were getting ready to do this.
[47:05] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[47:06] Jimi: Um, and I wouldn't mind if you could post me the two hours and thirty minutes or whatever uh that I took to watch it.
[47:17] Tommy: It's so bad.
[47:19] Jimi: It's really bad.
[47:21] Tommy: It's really bad.
[47:22] Jimi: And okay, so because I've made a video about this.
[47:25] Tommy: I made a video a long time ago, and I don't know.
[47:27] Jimi: This is your viral sensation talking about it.
[47:33] Tommy: And Lucille Ball did an awful job in this movie.
[47:36] Jimi: And to this day, that YouTube video still receives some of the most angry comments.
[47:45] Tommy: Yeah.
[47:45] Jimi: Like vitriol.
[47:46] Tommy: Like, I went through them today. It was quite fun.
[47:48] Jimi: It is fascinating.
[47:50] Tommy: How dare you insult Lucille Ball in this way? She's a comedic genius. I love her and Mame.
[47:55] Jimi: And like, okay.
[47:57] Tommy: I think first it bears saying.
[48:00] Jimi: I think Lucille Ball is a genius.
[48:03] Tommy: Absolutely. Unequivocally.
[48:04] Jimi: I think she has defined television and a whole bunch of American culture as we know it.
[48:11] Tommy: Um, you know, but like, even just talking about the Lucy show and or I Love Lucy and Star Trek.
[48:20] Jimi: Like, just take those two as paragons of entertainment, and already you've encompassed like 80% of contemporary film and television entertainment is based on or takes things from these two things that she created, basically.
[48:36] Tommy: Um she's not good in this movie.
[48:39] Jimi: She was a poor choice, and everyone knows it.
[48:43] Tommy: Critics knew it at the time, Angela Lansbury knew it, Jerry Herman knew it and was super insistent that it not be made.
[48:51] Jimi: Jerry Herman, like, then refused to make any movies of his musicals again unless he had direct producing influence.
[48:59] Tommy: Um Lucy herself refused to make a film ever again after this one because it went so poorly.
[49:06] Jimi: Yeah, I think that's huge.
[49:08] Tommy: B. Arthur knew it was a mistake.
[49:09] Jimi: Um B. Arthur, like, there's a random little interview I found where she like slates it.
[49:16] Tommy: She's like, it's the worst movie ever made.
[49:17] Jimi: Oh yeah.
[49:18] Tommy: Like, wow.
[49:18] Jimi: And I think there's a quote.
[49:20] Tommy: Oh, I forget, I forget the metaphor she uses, but um when asked about what filming it was like, Lucille Ball says it's like watching your house burn down.
[49:29] Jimi: Um, or something like that.
[49:31] Tommy: Like people involved in this movie and who saw this movie hated it.
[49:36] Jimi: And so I find it so fascinating that there is this subset of people who feel so passionately that they enjoy this.
[49:47] Tommy: Like I'm I But do not do not just think it's just that thing.
[49:51] Jimi: I think it's I think like I really do have difficulty unpacking this because I understand Diva worship from a gay perspective.
[49:58] Tommy: Like that's how I am about Angela Lansbury, which is perhaps why I'm a little blinded.
[50:03] Jimi: Um but like, and you know, there are plenty of people out there who are just gigantic Lucille Ball fans and so adore everything she does.
[50:14] Tommy: Like objectively, the movie is boring and long and poorly filmed and poorly sung, and like just some of it, and it what makes it such a tragedy is the fact that the musical was so well received, was such a great thing, and this was a perfect chance to bring that to film.
[50:38] Jimi: Kind of like I, you know, Jerry Herman was disappointed with um Gene Kelly's movie of Hello Dolly.
[50:44] Tommy: Um, but I think that's a pretty faithful, honest representation of the stage musical.
[50:51] Jimi: Yeah, it's great.
[50:52] Tommy: I love it.
[50:52] Jimi: It's wonderful.
[50:53] Tommy: I get the Barbara Streisand controversy, but I think the rest of it's perfect.
[50:56] Jimi: Exactly.
[50:57] Tommy: The Mame film is not a good representation of the musical.
[51:04] Jimi: No, it's not.
[51:05] Tommy: I think um so obviously in your video, you know, you talk about you're kind of discussing why did it fail.
[51:15] Jimi: Um I think there was a number of reasons.
[51:18] Tommy: I really do.
[51:19] Jimi: Um for me, the thing that I hated most about it, uh was Gene Sachs's direction.
[51:27] Tommy: Yes.
[51:27] Jimi: Yeah.
[51:29] Tommy: Because it doesn't exist.
[51:30] Jimi: No.
[51:31] Tommy: It's odd, it's very, very odd.
[51:33] Jimi: It almost feels at times like it's bordering on like Lynchian.
[51:38] Tommy: Yeah.
[51:38] Jimi: Like for some of the choices that I'm just like intentionally obscure, like yeah.
[51:43] Tommy: Yeah.
[51:43] Jimi: That for example, first scene, it's today. Why the hell does Patrick go up that banister, slide down it, and do it again?
[51:53] Tommy: They literally repeat the exact same thing twice, don't even change the shot.
[51:57] Jimi: And I'm just like that to me, yeah, instantly I was like, this is bad.
[52:03] Tommy: Yeah.
[52:04] Jimi: And then I couldn't get past it from there.
[52:06] Tommy: Um, I know like with Lucille Ball, like we know that she's not a good as good a singer as Angela Lansbury.
[52:17] Jimi: All good.
[52:18] Tommy: Right.
[52:19] Jimi: Um, and to be honest, I actually don't I don't hate her voice.
[52:19] Tommy: I don't hate her I don't hate her voice.
[52:24] Jimi: I wish I because I rewatched it again maybe two days ago.
[52:30] Tommy: Um it's just painful every time.
[52:33] Jimi: Um but like there are plenty of Lady Broadway singers with weird voices who are absolutely successful, you know, B. Arthur.
[52:45] Tommy: Um B. Arthur, exactly.
[52:47] Jimi: Carol Channing, like who has a Rosalind Russell?
[52:51] Tommy: Right?
[52:52] Jimi: Who has weirder voices than these people?
[52:54] Tommy: And they can find ways and find vocal coaches to get through this sort of stuff.
[53:00] Jimi: Yeah.
[53:00] Tommy: Um Lucy just couldn't, just couldn't.
[53:05] Jimi: And half of you thinks like she's not an idiot.
[53:09] Tommy: She must have known, right?
[53:12] Jimi: And so much of the production of this movie is shrouded in Hollywood gossip.
[53:18] Tommy: Um who quite knows what's real and what's rumor.
[53:21] Tommy: Um, but absolutely at some point, someone raised the idea of dubbing Lucy's voice.
[53:27] Jimi: And who knows why that didn't happen, but it doesn't seem like an unfair bet that Lucy put the kibosh on that.
[53:34] Tommy: Um she put the kibosh on a few things.
[53:37] Jimi: Right.
[53:38] Tommy: Madeline Kahn.
[53:39] Jimi: Yeah.
[53:39] Tommy: Oh, that's not even who was gonna play Mrs.
[53:42] Jimi: Gooch.
[53:43] Tommy: Yeah.
[53:44] Jimi: Yeah.
[53:45] Tommy: That would have been great.
[53:46] Jimi: Oh, it would be I really like, I really like Gooch in the film.
[53:49] Tommy: Yeah, I think she's one of the best parts.
[53:51] Jimi: Um she's lovely.
[53:52] Tommy: Yeah.
[53:52] Jimi: Um but yeah, it's I don't know.
[53:58] Tommy: Like, I don't I don't fully put the blame on Lucy Lucy O'Ball.
[54:02] Jimi: No.
[54:02] Tommy: I don't because apparently, you know, she wanted to do it after seeing Rosalind Russell in the film.
[54:08] Jimi: You know, she didn't get it for Broadway good, because that wouldn't that would have been good.
[54:13] Tommy: No.
[54:14] Jimi: Um and so she got a chance to do it in the film, but I just feel like she was given the wrong director, and also the world had had enough of Mame.
[54:24] Tommy: Yeah.
[54:24] Jimi: Maybe we were just done with it by the way.
[54:26] Tommy: You know, it had like five different iterations.
[54:29] Jimi: Yeah.
[54:30] Tommy: Yeah.
[54:30] Jimi: It has quite the journey that way.
[54:33] Tommy: And which is a shame.
[54:36] Jimi: Like maybe it's worth it.
[54:38] Tommy: Well, Lucy should have just made a straight movie that was like the continued adventures of Auntie Mame.
[54:44] Jimi: Yeah.
[54:45] Tommy: Like that would have been great.
[54:48] Jimi: I know.
[54:49] Tommy: Do you know what? There were some scenes in it where I was watching.
[54:52] Jimi: Um, in particular.
[54:57] Tommy: Uh in particular, Need a Little Christmas.
[55:03] Jimi: And I guess in a bit in It's Today.
[55:05] Tommy: Yeah.
[55:05] Jimi: Where I got Russell Crowe vibes.
[55:10] Tommy: We weren't expecting that, were you?
[55:12] Jimi: What do you mean?
[55:13] Tommy: I have this thing, right? Obviously, we all know Russell Crowe should not have been in Les Misérables.
[55:19] Jimi: We all adore Russell Crowe in Les Mis and think he was the perfect choice.
[55:23] Tommy: And anyway.
[55:24] Jimi: Um I'm sorry, did I I didn't put my sarcasm filter on heavy enough?
[55:28] Tommy: I did not.
[55:29] Jimi: I I've just had a small cornery incident.
[55:34] Tommy: Um so we all know that that should never have happened.
[55:37] Jimi: Um but my heart breaks for Russell Crowe because you watch stars and you see fear in that man's eyes.
[55:45] Tommy: Yes.
[55:46] Jimi: And that is not acting.
[55:47] Tommy: Yeah.
[55:47] Jimi: That isn't.
[55:48] Tommy: I'm doing this weird thing where I know that I'm doomed to die, so I'm gonna play stars as if I'm scared.
[55:53] Jimi: Yeah.
[55:54] Tommy: Um he's just scared because he doesn't know how to sing.
[55:57] Jimi: Yeah.
[55:57] Tommy: And I absolutely see that in It's Today.
[56:01] Jimi: Um Right.
[56:03] Tommy: It's just like, I don't know what I'm doing.
[56:05] Jimi: And now we dance, and now we dance, and everyone's a better dancer than me.
[56:08] Tommy: Yeah.
[56:08] Jimi: No one's giving me direction.
[56:10] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.
[56:11] Jimi: And I wave my hand like this.
[56:13] Tommy: Yeah.
[56:13] Jimi: Yeah, she has this painted on face and it's properly painted on.
[56:17] Tommy: Yes.
[56:18] Jimi: Um it and again, I find I just find it a little bit heartbreaking.
[56:23] Tommy: I'm like, this is a shame.
[56:25] Jimi: I mean, she's not she's not been set up properly to do this.
[56:28] Tommy: She's been dealt a really bad card.
[56:30] Jimi: Yeah.
[56:31] Tommy: Um, and obviously, if you know she's got B. Arthur there who obviously doesn't like her, right?
[56:37] Jimi: She's not got this kind of camaraderie or sisterhood where someone that you shouldn't go to and be like, uh help die in here.
[56:45] Tommy: Yeah.
[56:45] Jimi: Um because as well, it's bloody Lucille Ball.
[56:50] Tommy: Yeah, she should be good at this.
[56:52] Jimi: She should be good at anything she does.
[56:55] Tommy: Because Exactly she generally is.
[56:58] Jimi: But she is good.
[56:59] Tommy: She's absolutely great.
[57:01] Jimi: Um, but in this I just feel the odds were totally stacked against her.
[57:06] Tommy: Um and it comes across and it's it's just a bit heartbreaking.
[57:09] Jimi: I feel really bad.
[57:10] Tommy: It's really sad for her.
[57:12] Jimi: I get low key sad every time I watch the Mame film.
[57:17] Tommy: Um, just because of what could have been.
[57:19] Jimi: There've been a lot of even since I made my Mame video, there've been a lot of other bootlegs of the original Lansbury production that have come out.
[57:27] Tommy: And man, it is like this is my time travel show.
[57:30] Jimi: This is if I could go back and see one original production on Broadway, yeah, it would be Mame.
[57:36] Tommy: Um, because it just seems infectious and exuberant and like such a feel good time.
[57:42] Jimi: Um, and there is no good recreation of it, you know.
[57:48] Tommy: No.
[57:48] Jimi: There hasn't been even they made a uh Lansbury came back for a revival, um, I think in the 70s, um, the eighties, eighty three.
[57:59] Tommy: Um and uh it was not well received.
[58:02] Jimi: Um it just kind of lost some of its shine and some of its vigor, and probably the eighties we were beyond that.
[58:08] Tommy: Um that's it.
[58:10] Jimi: And so just feel like idealism.
[58:13] Tommy: Yeah.
[58:14] Jimi: Really?
[58:14] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.
[58:15] Jimi: Oh over that.
[58:16] Tommy: It's gonna be fine, you're gonna survive the stock market crash.
[58:20] Jimi: Please.
[58:21] Tommy: Yeah.
[58:22] Jimi: We're just kind of over that in our cynical adulthood.
[58:25] Tommy: As soon as the 80s hit, it was like, no.
[58:27] Jimi: No.
[58:28] Tommy: No thank you.
[58:29] Jimi: Exactly.
[58:29] Tommy: Uh but to know to go back and sit there in a 1960s audience and watch this, uh, what I wouldn't give.
[58:37] Jimi: I know.
[58:38] Tommy: I just love what it did for Angela Lansbury.
[58:41] Jimi: Like, oh my god, she made it.
[58:43] Tommy: Um, like that's what she says in her interview.
[58:45] Jimi: She knew she made it.
[58:46] Tommy: It's a beautiful interview.
[58:48] Jimi: Oh man, yeah.
[58:49] Tommy: Angela Lansbury is my spirit animal, deeply and truly.
[58:52] Jimi: She is.
[58:53] Tommy: You love her so much.
[58:54] Jimi: I really adore her.
[58:55] Tommy: I adore her in this.
[58:56] Jimi: I mean, not to gush too much, but like watch okay, I gush a lot.
[59:04] Tommy: Watch the Manchurian Candidate, watch Sweeney Todd, watch a bootleg of her in Mame, and then watch Murder She Wrote.
[59:11] Jimi: And like, that's the same gosh darn actress.
[59:15] Tommy: Um it's insane.
[59:17] Jimi: And like, not in the way that like, ooh, Johnny Depp always plays a stupid bizarre character and is different every time.
[59:25] Tommy: Like Angela Lansbury is very clearly herself, but has broken like is versatile and like like Patrick Stewart.
[59:35] Jimi: Like, like you know, Meryl Streep.
[59:38] Tommy: Meryl Streep, yeah.
[59:39] Jimi: Versatile, able to take on anything so poised, and then just so sweet and kind.
[59:45] Tommy: Um, yeah, no.
[59:47] Jimi: Yeah.
[59:47] Tommy: Deeply and truly, I care for Angela Lansbury.
[59:50] Jimi: And after you've watched all those, watch her massage video.
[59:53] Tommy: Yeah, put that away.
[59:55] Jimi: We don't talk about that.
[59:56] Tommy: Yes, we do.
[59:57] Jimi: I'm sorry.
[59:58] Tommy: If I didn't have that, I would not be able to jiff.
[1:00:02] Jimi: Oh.
[1:00:03] Tommy: Uh, I have no response.
[1:00:04] Jimi: I have no response.
[1:00:06] Tommy: It's so good.
[1:00:07] Jimi: I actually kinda like it.
[1:00:08] Tommy: I will never watch it.
[1:00:10] Jimi: It's sexy.
[1:00:11] Tommy: I will never watch it.
[1:00:12] Jimi: You've never seen it?
[1:00:13] Tommy: I've I am aware of it and have seen bits and pieces, and I will never watch it.
[1:00:18] Jimi: Oh my Christ.
[1:00:20] Tommy: No way, you've never seen it.
[1:00:22] Jimi: I'm gonna that is gonna be like my clockwork orange moment for you.
[1:00:27] Tommy: It's probably one of the few pieces of Angela Lansbury literature that I haven't experienced.
[1:00:34] Jimi: It is pure literature.
[1:00:37] Tommy: It's so good.
[1:00:39] Jimi: It's really good.
[1:00:40] Tommy: And like and I think it was probably quite effective.
[1:00:43] Jimi: I believe it.
[1:00:45] Tommy: It's just like I didn't know.
[1:00:47] Jimi: You know this year in a bath.
[1:00:48] Tommy: I didn't know it existed for a very long time and had experienced her as like mild-mannered Jessica Fletcher on Murder She Wrote.
[1:00:56] Jimi: And like, it's just you know it's a step too far for my childhood brain, and I feel like I'm gonna have some Freudian break if I watch it.
[1:01:06] Tommy: She's a sexy woman.
[1:01:08] Jimi: She is.
[1:01:10] Tommy: Nobody can deny.
[1:01:14] Jimi: Angela Lansbury is a sexy woman, no one can deny.
[1:01:17] Tommy: Get me the t-shirt right now.
[1:01:19] Jimi: Absolutely.
[1:01:21] Tommy: Um I'm gonna well it's definitely going to have shown up.
[1:01:25] Jimi: Everyone else can watch it.
[1:01:27] Tommy: You can.
[1:01:28] Jimi: Oh, I'm so sad you're missing it.
[1:01:30] Tommy: Open a new window.
[1:01:33] Jimi: Open a new door.
[1:01:36] Tommy: Travel a new highway that's never been tried before.
[1:01:49] Jimi: There's only one way to make the bottom slame.
[1:02:11] Tommy: You can give you live on the high of the way all the time.
[1:02:30] Jimi: It's the day.
[1:02:54] Tommy: And was in the window.
[1:02:56] Jimi: And what was that minute?
[1:02:57] Tommy: Yes, we need a live Christmas.
[1:02:59] Jimi: Write this very minute.
[1:03:56] Tommy: So Tommy, that was Mame.
[1:03:57] Jimi: That you can die happy.
[1:04:03] Tommy: Jimi.
[1:04:10] Jimi: You know they only named it Mame because Angela Lansbury told them to.
[1:04:14] Tommy: Here's my hat.
[1:04:16] Jimi: Fellowship.
[1:04:17] Tommy: I know it's the same song.
[1:04:18] Jimi: Not to mention.
[1:04:19] Tommy: We've talked about it all the time, but Need a Little Christmas and It Takes a Woman.
[1:04:23] Jimi: It's literally the same.
[1:04:24] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:04:25] Jimi: And I forgot.
[1:04:26] Tommy: I can never remember the name of the song, but they cut a song from Mame that is the new song.
[1:04:30] Jimi: Could end to the movie.
[1:04:32] Tommy: No, and put it into Hello Dolly.
[1:04:34] Jimi: Um, that's what I mean into the whole Jolly movie.
[1:04:36] Tommy: Yes.
[1:04:36] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:04:37] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:04:37] Jimi: They're just the same show.
[1:04:38] Tommy: Mame and Dolly.
[1:04:41] Jimi: No, they're not there.
[1:04:42] Tommy: They're very different despite having very many structural similarities.
[1:04:46] Jimi: And musical similarities.
[1:04:48] Tommy: Anyway.
[1:04:49] Jimi: Enough about that.
[1:04:51] Tommy: You've had your dreams.
[1:04:53] Jimi: It is time for mine.
[1:04:56] Tommy: That was intense.
[1:04:57] Jimi: Oh, that's great in there.
[1:04:58] Tommy: I thought that was good.
[1:05:00] Jimi: Ummy, have a quiz question.
[1:05:02] Tommy: We should act.
[1:05:04] Jimi: What's your quiz question?
[1:05:06] Tommy: Okay.
[1:05:07] Jimi: So hey.
[1:05:07] Tommy: Uh this music again.
[1:05:11] Jimi: Did we ever do questions over the always been statement?
[1:05:13] Tommy: You wanna just call them quiz statements from now on?
[1:05:15] Jimi: We got a quiz statement for you.
[1:05:16] Tommy: The Quaitman.
[1:05:18] Jimi: The Quaken.
[1:05:19] Tommy: I hate it.
[1:05:20] Jimi: Um this musical was partially inspired by a New York Pilates studio on 181st Street.
[1:05:28] Tommy: Dun dun dun.
[1:05:30] Jimi: It's Pilates the musical.
[1:05:32] Tommy: What is it?
[1:05:32] Jimi: Uh Bonchance.
[1:05:34] Tommy: If you want to get in contact with us, I'm MusicalMash on Twitter and Musical Theatre Mash on YouTube.
[1:05:39] Jimi: And I am as in Hendrix over on Twitter.
[1:05:43] Tommy: I don't do YouTube anymore, so I'm not gonna keep twisting that.
[1:05:46] Jimi: You can see if you want.
[1:05:47] Tommy: Or you can check out our show Twitter at Jim and Tomic, or you can go to the website Jim and Tomic.com, which has a link to the Reddit discussion where you can talk about Mame.
[1:05:56] Jimi: Yeah, much to Tommy's like, maybe Tommy will come to Reddit for this one.
[1:05:59] Tommy: Maybe he promises nothing.
[1:06:02] Jimi: Um yes, if you would like to support the podcast, you can also find the link to our Patreon um on the website as well.
[1:06:10] Tommy: And we'll see you next time.
[1:06:14] Jimi: Yes, indeed.
[1:06:15] Tommy: Goodbye now.
[1:06:16] Jimi: Tootaloo, Buckaroo.
[1:06:31] Tommy: In a while took a while.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
