Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Happy Hour #64: Another Podcast in Another Feed - ‘Evita’

Discuss on Reddit ➤ Support the Show ➤ What’s new Happy Hour fans? We’re flying back to the B.A., Buenos Aires, Big Apple to talk all about the controversial first lady, ‘Evita’ by Andrew Lloyd Webber and Tim Rice... Read More

From the show: Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour

1 h 57 mins
7/12/18

Featured Shows

About

Discuss on Reddit ➤

Support the Show ➤

What’s new Happy Hour fans? We’re flying back to the B.A., Buenos Aires, Big Apple to talk all about the controversial first lady, ‘Evita’ by Andrew Lloyd Webber and Tim Rice. Come for the deep discussion, stay for Jimi and Tommy fighting over whether this is a good show or not! This week the guys discuss some of Argentina’s troubled history, including the truth about what happened to Eva Peron’s body, work out the potential merits of the movie and debate whether or not this Andrew Lloyd Webber’s greatest score.

Evita (Original Cast Recording/1979)

Amazon / iTunes / Spotify

SPONSOR

This week’s episode is sponsored by Goldstar. Goldstar has a great selection of affordable tickets to all sorts of live events, including Broadway theater, national tours, concerts, comedy, dance, and more. Our first 200 listeners who head to goldstar.com/happyhour or use the promo code HAPPYHOUR at purchase will get $10 off their order.

SHOW NOTES

To be honest, I’d always have thought Patti was taller. Here is the diva herself giving her true opinions on what she thinks of Madonna in the movie.

If you’re interested in more background to Andrew Lloyd Webber’s process then have a look at this brilliantly detailed book with lots of exclusives and great photographs. (You can tell Tommy doesn’t write the show notes, right?)

Jimi is heartbroken more people won’t experience this amazing show, ‘These Trees Are Made of Blood’ - go check them out and give them some love!

If you’ve yet to see the movie, it’s definitely worth a watch. Once you’ve seen come and tell us what you thought over on Twitter!

We’d be surprised if you’re aware of Evita and have never seen this video. All jokes aside, no one can deny this wonderful woman is a POWERHOUSE!

And if you want to work out exactly how she does it (and some of the intelligence behind the composition of this number in particular) check out Seth Rudetsky’s brilliant deconstruction!

And if you want to hear in her own words what she thinks about Andrew Lloyd Webber then this interview is amazing with Broadway.com’s Paul Wontorek!

This is a fantastic article which goes into a lot of detail around the difficulties of casting a show like Evita.

SMELLS LIKE TEEN QUATEMENTS

This musical shares its poster title font with Nirvana’s album covers.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Jimi: This episode of Happy Hour is sponsored by Goldstar.

[0:02] Tommy: Goldstar has a great selection of affordable tickets to all sorts of live events, including theater, with Broadway and Broadway National Tours, concerts, comedy, dance, and more.

[0:11] Jimi: The first 200 listeners who use the promo code Happy Hour, one word all caps, will get ten dollars off their purchase at Goldstar.com backslash happy hour or using the Goldstar app.

[0:23] Jimi: I'm sweating.

[0:24] Tommy: That's because you just worked out and you ate three bananas.

[0:27] Jimi: I know it's also quite warm again.

[0:29] Tommy: It was cooler earlier, but now for some reason that the sun has gone.

[0:33] Jimi: Oh yeah, and you're in the world of no air conditioning, so yeah.

[0:38] Tommy: I don't know how you survive.

[0:43] Jimi: Anyway.

[0:44] Tommy: Right.

[0:45] Jimi: It's gonna be like I'm in Argentina.

[0:50] Tommy: Well, somebody get us another drink.

[0:53] Jimi: Welcome to Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour, your weekly podcast with Divas and Dacqueries.

[0:58] Tommy: Jimmy is trying so hard not to laugh into his microphone right now.

[1:03] Jimi: It was just we were like Welcome to the Right in there.

[1:11] Tommy: It's like 5 a.m. in Scotland right now.

[1:12] Jimi: Jimmy has been up to sweating like a thousand hours.

[1:18] Tommy: I have done a full day's work.

[1:19] Jimi: A full day's work.

[1:21] Tommy: That's like 16 million potatoes in Scottish time, right?

[1:25] Jimi: Was that offensive?

[1:26] Tommy: Was that a mildly racist joke?

[1:29] Jimi: I don't think so.

[1:30] Tommy: I just don't think it was applicable.

[1:32] Jimi: Oh, sorry.

[1:33] Tommy: Sometimes I get bad jokes confused with racist jokes because there's not a lot of difference.

[1:37] Jimi: Um hey, speaking of racist jokes, what are you drinking today?

[1:44] Tommy: We're never gonna make it through this.

[1:46] Jimi: Um What am I drinking today?

[1:50] Tommy: Uh God, I don't know.

[1:52] Jimi: The sweat of union workers?

[1:57] Tommy: How's that for a start?

[1:59] Jimi: Delicious.

[2:02] Tommy: How about you?

[2:05] Jimi: Um, I think I think you can get like Argentinian wine.

[2:10] Tommy: Sure.

[2:10] Jimi: I think you can get any kind of wine.

[2:12] Tommy: Like you can get like Chile and Chardonnay.

[2:14] Jimi: Yeah.

[2:15] Tommy: You can probably get Argentinian wine.

[2:17] Jimi: I don't know enough about wine.

[2:18] Tommy: Like, well.

[2:21] Jimi: Chile and Argentina are different countries.

[2:25] Tommy: Yeah, but they're not that far away.

[2:27] Jimi: They probably both grow grapes and drink.

[2:29] Tommy: I want to find out if you can get Argentinian wine.

[2:31] Jimi: Come to say.

[2:32] Tommy: Argentinian wine.

[2:33] Jimi: Yeah.

[2:33] Tommy: Easy.

[2:34] Jimi: Done.

[2:34] Tommy: Jimmy's gonna wake up tomorrow morning with like an obscure package at his front door with like 12 bottles of Argentinian wine that he accidentally ordered off of Amazon right now.

[2:45] Jimi: Yep.

[2:45] Tommy: They apparently do a really nice Malbec.

[2:47] Jimi: Ah love a Malbec.

[2:50] Tommy: I don't know.

[2:50] Jimi: I'm still sticking with my union worker sweat.

[2:54] Tommy: Okay, you enjoy that.

[2:56] Jimi: That's actually quite nice though.

[2:57] Tommy: Like the social class.

[2:59] Jimi: Yeah.

[2:59] Tommy: I'm sipping my wine from the balcony, looking down upon you.

[3:04] Jimi: I drink your sweat.

[3:05] Tommy: As you're chanting my name.

[3:08] Jimi: I gotta tell you about what they cheer at the gay bar when they play this song, but maybe that's for later.

[3:14] Tommy: Interesting.

[3:15] Jimi: They don't play for my me Argentina.

[3:18] Tommy: Well, guess what the musical's gonna be in a second after we hit the quiz question?

[3:22] Jimi: Uh but there's one point where they like zoom in and everyone's.

[3:26] Tommy: By the way, can I also just pause?

[3:28] Jimi: Uh-huh.

[3:28] Tommy: You realize to get to this episode, they've already read what the show is.

[3:32] Jimi: Don't break the illusion for me.

[3:35] Tommy: I've been living in the dark.

[3:38] Jimi: Fair enough.

[3:38] Tommy: I've always wondered.

[3:41] Jimi: There's one.

[3:43] Tommy: There's one point where they do like a crowd shout and everyone's holding up banners and they say Perone, and everyone in the bar goes, Peron, Per.

[3:51] Jimi: Oh no, it's backwards.

[3:53] Tommy: First, they show them from behind, so they're all mirrored, and so everyone goes, no rep, no rep, no rep, and then they reverse it and it goes perone.

[4:03] Jimi: Because if you look at Perone backwards, it says no rep.

[4:05] Tommy: It's much funnier in person.

[4:07] Jimi: And then there's one point where they do a crowd reaction shot and they zoom in in my favorite character in all of the Evita movie.

[4:13] Tommy: Um, who's this really angry looking Argentinian man in the middle of the crowd during Don't Cry for Me Argentina?

[4:19] Jimi: And they cut to him for like half a second, and the whole gay bar yells, I hate you, Evita.

[4:26] Tommy: And then they cut to the guy who plays Perone, and everyone yells, I'll never work again.

[4:31] Jimi: It's very funny.

[4:33] Tommy: Wow.

[4:34] Jimi: Great.

[4:35] Tommy: Sidetrack Mondays.

[4:37] Jimi: We'll see you there.

[4:39] Tommy: Oh man.

[4:41] Jimi: So Quaitman.

[4:47] Tommy: Okay, I can't even imagine what it could possibly be.

[4:49] Jimi: I think we've probably even said the title already.

[4:51] Tommy: Um, two of the actresses who have played the title role in this musical have only ever had one conversation with each other.

[4:58] Jimi: It went as follows.

[5:00] Tommy: One actress said to the other, I'm taller than you.

[5:04] Jimi: That was my famous Madonna impression because the musical we're doing is Evita.

[5:15] Tommy: I knew I wanna stand back with a fuck on you.

[5:18] Jimi: You'll be on me too.

[5:21] Tommy: I got up here!

[5:23] Jimi: When a side is back!

[5:27] Tommy: You wanna know what you're gonna get in me?

[5:29] Jimi: Just a little touch of quality.

[5:33] Tommy: Fill me up with your heat with your nine in the dead of a dummy.

[5:37] Jimi: Let me dance to your feet, make a lemon that I run it through me.

[5:41] Tommy: Don't hold back.

[5:42] Jimi: You are certain to impress.

[5:44] Tommy: Tell the driver that says where I'm staying.

[5:48] Jimi: Hello!

[5:50] Tommy: When the saddle is Don't look at me, I'm not somewhere to go.

[5:55] Jimi: We'll put on the show.

[5:58] Tommy: I thought Patty Lapone said it to Madonna.

[6:01] Jimi: No, Madonna said it to Patty.

[6:03] Tommy: What?

[6:05] Jimi: That's obviously.

[6:08] Tommy: No, it would be great if Patty said that on Tony.

[6:13] Jimi: I mean, that's why I picture it.

[6:14] Tommy: And also I was de I was sad, because I know you do a better Patty Lapone impression.

[6:19] Jimi: I do.

[6:20] Tommy: I do.

[6:21] Jimi: I wonder if that was a muted Evita, but that's fine.

[6:21] Tommy: Muted Evita.

[6:27] Jimi: A muted Evita.

[6:28] Tommy: Um, so Evita.

[6:30] Jimi: Uh music by Andrew Lloyd Webber and the lyrics, of course, by Mr.

[6:35] Tommy: Deep Lai.

[6:36] Jimi: Sorry, something got caught in my throat in there for a second there.

[6:38] Tommy: Um it started off as a concept album in 1976, and then it had its debut in the West End in 1978 with Elaine Page and David Essex.

[6:47] Jimi: You know who David Essex is?

[6:49] Tommy: Yes, he uh was the original Che in Evita in 1978 on the West End.

[6:54] Jimi: Do you know anything else he's done?

[6:56] Tommy: Uh he No, no, don't you be looking it up?

[6:59] Jimi: He poops at Jimmy sees me typing.

[7:01] Tommy: Well, he has he been in Doctor Who?

[7:03] Jimi: He looks familiar.

[7:04] Tommy: Uh I don't think so.

[7:06] Jimi: Well, then I don't know.

[7:07] Tommy: He's not a doctor.

[7:09] Jimi: Um he uh have you ever heard The War of the Worlds uh like uh musical, I guess, kind of?

[7:17] Tommy: No.

[7:19] Jimi: So well, basically he sings in that, but there's like the story of War of the Worlds has been like scored and orchestrated, it's incredible.

[7:26] Tommy: It's in the show notes already.

[7:28] Jimi: Uh-huh.

[7:29] Tommy: Um and he sings in it.

[7:32] Jimi: He's like a British rock singer.

[7:34] Tommy: Okay.

[7:34] Jimi: But has done a lot of theatre.

[7:35] Tommy: He did Tommy, I think.

[7:36] Jimi: Okay.

[7:37] Tommy: That's a good choice.

[7:39] Jimi: Oh, he was in Godspell as well.

[7:41] Tommy: You're looking it up now too, and you critiqued me.

[7:44] Jimi: No, I just know my fat the shade of it all.

[7:49] Tommy: It's West End.

[7:50] Jimi: I know West End.

[7:51] Tommy: I don't know any of these other people that are coming out for example.

[7:53] Jimi: Natty LePone or Mandy Patinkin from the Broadway Review in 1979.

[7:57] Tommy: Yes, indeed.

[7:58] Jimi: No idea who they are.

[7:59] Tommy: Um, and Evita kind of swept at the Tony Awards did really, really well.

[8:04] Jimi: Um got 11 noms, seven wins, including Best Musical.

[8:08] Tommy: Patty, of course, won Best Actress, Brava.

[8:14] Jimi: And then it was just very successful.

[8:19] Tommy: And got a film made.

[8:22] Jimi: I'm glad you put the very successful before the film.

[8:25] Tommy: Um and then it's, you know, it's been a it's been a stalwart in regional theaters, plenty of tours, and like I feel like Evita has entered, like exited the musical theater circle and entered popular culture.

[8:38] Jimi: Like people, you mentioned musical theater and people know Evita in the same way that people know Phantom or Cats or any of the other Andrew Lloyd Webber stuff.

[8:45] Tommy: Exactly.

[8:46] Jimi: No, that's it.

[8:46] Tommy: Like, you know, and it's not only do they know Evita, but they know Don't Cry from the Argentina, and they will sing you that hook.

[8:52] Jimi: Yeah.

[8:53] Tommy: Like Family Guy can make an Evita joke and people will understand it.

[8:57] Jimi: Totally.

[8:58] Tommy: Um but it's interesting though, because I think now what I would say is people know that Madonna was Evita.

[9:06] Jimi: Yeah, which, you know, we can have mixed feelings about.

[9:10] Tommy: Yeah.

[9:11] Jimi: Um, but I find that I just found that quite interesting because obviously that was so late on in the game of Evita.

[9:16] Tommy: Yeah.

[9:16] Jimi: Uh like it was already established and successful.

[9:19] Tommy: Super popular.

[9:21] Jimi: And you know, people would say Oh, I yeah, Madonna.

[9:25] Tommy: Right.

[9:26] Jimi: Which is interesting.

[9:27] Tommy: Yeah.

[9:27] Jimi: Ugh.

[9:28] Tommy: The what these people, they don't know what they're missing.

[9:30] Jimi: They don't.

[9:31] Tommy: Um so Evita.

[9:34] Jimi: Yeah.

[9:34] Tommy: Thomas, I'm handing the reins over to you.

[9:37] Jimi: Um, Evita is the um moderately biographical story about Ava Perone, First Lady of Argentina in the whatever's uh the forties.

[9:50] Tommy: Um, and kind of her like a story of her rise to fame/slash power, and it plays with some of how those things either do or don't go hand in hand, um, amidst a very divided and uprising-filled Argentina during that time.

[10:09] Jimi: Um, kind of commented on by this Greek chorus character named Che, Che Guevara or not, depending upon who you ask.

[10:19] Tommy: Yeah.

[10:20] Jimi: Like some interesting interpretations there.

[10:22] Tommy: Um, but a big discussion about like how does fame and politics interplay with each other?

[10:29] Jimi: Is it okay if you sleep your way to the top or not?

[10:32] Tommy: Um, and and also just like I don't know if honest's the right word, but like an attempt at an honest discussion of the actual person, Ava Perone, and her existence.

[10:48] Jimi: And also kind of like uh Lloyd Webber and Rice really got into this because they wanted to bring this story to a British slash American audience who might not have engaged with or experienced this story as distinctly as the Argentinian people have.

[11:05] Tommy: Um and so it's also kind of a discussion of that as well, too.

[11:09] Jimi: Yeah.

[11:10] Tommy: That was very good.

[11:11] Jimi: Thank you.

[11:12] Tommy: Thank you.

[11:13] Jimi: It's great.

[11:14] Tommy: Um yeah, well done.

[11:17] Jimi: Shall we get into it?

[11:21] Tommy: Yes.

[11:22] Jimi: Yes, we shall.

[11:22] Tommy: What if he said no?

[11:25] Jimi: No, and then just hug up.

[11:30] Tommy: Boop, funny outro joke, and yeah, yeah, exactly.

[11:34] Jimi: That's it.

[11:35] Tommy: But when you let the things you do affect us all.

[11:41] Jimi: But when you uh you take us away from the squalor of the real world.

[11:49] Tommy: Are you here on your own?

[11:51] Jimi: Yes.

[11:55] Tommy: So am I what a fortune that coincident may be you're my reward for my efforts in or not.

[12:07] Jimi: It seems crazy, but you must believe there's nothing calculated, nothing planned.

[12:15] Tommy: Please forgive me if I seem naive.

[12:19] Jimi: I would never want to force your hand, but please understand I'd be good for you.

[12:28] Tommy: I don't always rush in like this.

[12:32] Jimi: Twenty seconds after saying hello.

[12:36] Tommy: Telling strangers, I'm too good to miss.

[12:40] Jimi: If I'm wrong, I hope you'll tell me so.

[12:43] Tommy: But you really should know I'd be good for you.

[12:48] Jimi: I'd be surprisingly good for you.

[12:52] Tommy: I won't go on if I'm boring you.

[12:55] Jimi: But do you understand my point of view?

[12:58] Tommy: Do you like what you hear, what you see, and would you be good for me too?

[13:05] Jimi: Weird thing, weird first thing that kind of popped to mind there that I wonder if you can have any sort of a uh any sort of uh resonance with.

[13:16] Tommy: Um it may seem really off-tart, but hopefully we'll be able to steer it kind of back.

[13:21] Jimi: Okay.

[13:21] Tommy: Um Princess Diana.

[13:23] Jimi: Okay.

[13:25] Tommy: Uh I feel like um is uh in terms of like understanding the reverence that Argentinians had for Ava Perone.

[13:36] Jimi: Um I feel like it's something that the Brits would completely resonate with with uh Princess Diana.

[13:46] Tommy: Princess Die.

[13:47] Jimi: I feel that corollary.

[13:48] Tommy: My my first introduction to uh Princess Die uh Princess Die.

[13:52] Jimi: I almost says Princess Diaries, which would be wrong.

[13:55] Tommy: Um was my grandmother got the commemorative Princess Die Beanie Baby when I was very young.

[14:01] Jimi: Uh-huh, yes, I know it well.

[14:03] Tommy: Um, which was my foray into that world.

[14:05] Jimi: But this kind of the association between like fame and you know, royalty as maybe an umbrella term for like politics, um and how they do or don't intersect in the 20th century.

[14:23] Tommy: Um is a huge conceptual discussion in this show.

[14:28] Jimi: Um Princess I died definitely away in.

[14:32] Tommy: And, you know, based on what I read, and we did, I worked um Evita in college.

[14:37] Tommy: I was on, I was a master electrician, and I ran the board, so I saw this show like fifty times. Um, but like a huge discussion about the show is that people in, you know, the more Euro Western crowd don't feel this way about Eva Perón or didn't know who she was until really until this musical, maybe not as acutely. Um, I'm probably assuming some things from my Eurocentrist perspective there. But I mean, I don't know. What were we, what were you gonna say?

[15:14] Jimi: Well, I was just gonna say, obviously, and I'm just taking this straight from the musical, but in "Rainbow Tour," yeah. When she does the European tour, she doesn't make it to the UK, but I know that Argentina and the UK had a lot of relations. Um, I imagine we would be aware.

[15:33] Tommy: Yeah, and because we do have our own royal family, I know that um obviously Perón wasn't in the royal family, but it's almost that kind of reverence. Where it's like you're kind of beyond politics.

[15:46] Jimi: Yeah.

[15:46] Tommy: Do you know what I mean? You're just this other kind of thing.

[15:49] Jimi: You are, you're an icon in kind of the purest sense.

[15:52] Tommy: Yeah.

[15:53] Jimi: So I can imagine there being some resonance there, and also obviously just uh for us, yeah, it was directly post-war. Um, so kind of coming out of that and looking, you know, I mean, looking to this kind of positive beacon.

[16:09] Tommy: Yeah, I can see being some resonance here. Um, but obviously I imagine, you know, in uh like we say in "Rainbow Tour" in Spain, she was really revered.

[16:21] Jimi: Yeah.

[16:21] Tommy: Italy, not so much. Um, but uh yeah, I think it might just be an American thing.

[16:29] Jimi: Yeah, but it is like the if you haven't seen "Evita" or haven't, you know, only listened to it but haven't dove into it too much. One of the big huge discussions of it is kind of this like I say political revolution, but not in the way that it comes off, but like revolution in politics that we've kind of seen post-World War II, um, and the kind of like cult of personality, and these are vast assumptions across all sorts of world political venues, but like at least in Argentina, this musical showcases a big shift from like a series of dictatorships that were kind of in charge of Argentina and kind of this like war-driven, violence-driven politics, right? Like one person takes control from another person, takes control from another person, always through force, always with guns.

And then in comes Eva Perón, and at least as painted in this narrative, she kind of is a woman of the people, and like you know, it's it's flowers, not guns, and she wins people over with kindness and understanding, at least overtly.

[17:39] Tommy: Um and it really lots of money.

[17:41] Jimi: Yeah, and lots of money, and plenty of corruption. Like, don't get me wrong. This is not all sunshine and rainbows on the inside. Um, but it is I would say an interesting discussion we've like an interesting conversion that happened in the twentieth century, kind of like post-World War II across the world, even in countries that like to peg themselves as more democratic. Um, but that we kind of move into this like social eye politics. Like I'm not just in charge of running the country and you know, knowing the right people to be friends with and knowing the right people to kill to get who to get what I want, but like I'm in charge of looking nice and saying the right things and being at the right photo ops and looking pretty and like image starts to matter in politics a little more. Um huge, gigantic theme in this musical.

[18:35] Tommy: Um definitely and like I can never because I, you know, scoff whenever we talk about Andrew Lloyd Webber, I can never tell if it's intentional. Um because it doesn't seem I wish it was explored more. Um it doesn't seem you know, there's there's not as much commentary about it as I want in the show. But maybe maybe that's my own Lloyd Webber cynicism coming out.

[19:02] Jimi: Well, no, I think a lot of the t a lot of things they say, um just for reference as well, one of the um places I've got most of my information about "Evita" was uh it's a book called I think it's called like "The Life and Times of Andrew Lloyd Webber," um, something like that. It's it's in the show notes. But it it it tells you a lot about the conception of this.

[19:22] Tommy: Yeah.

[19:22] Jimi: Um and I don't think they ever really wanted it to be political.

[19:28] Tommy: Yeah, particularly Tim Rice. Um Tim Rice wanted to write it was his initial idea, and he wanted to write it because he was just obsessed with her, yeah. Um was kind of in love with her because she was this icon figure, yeah. Um and then Andrew Lloyd Webber came in and was like, no, she's like a horrible character, like she I can't get on board with this love, yeah. You know what I mean? We need to show this this darker side, yeah. Um and so I think their focus is showing that character and kind of the world that revolves around it.

[20:03] Jimi: Yeah.

[20:03] Tommy: Um I find I find that conflict really interesting because I do think, like, if you ask me if I were directing the show, or if you ask me to find like the core conflict to bring out of this musical, it's like I want to give an audience poll at the end asking, is Eva Perón a good person, and get 50-50 responses back. Like the the huge question throughout the thing is like, is what she's doing right and wholesome.

[20:35] Jimi: Yeah, well, it's that's interesting because I don't think I would want 50-50. I think I would want 100% of people saying no.

[20:43] Tommy: Really?

[20:43] Jimi: But yeah, totally, because it it's kind of the point.

[20:50] Tommy: Yeah, I mean okay. Okay, here's here's my argument the the show starts with her funeral, um, and like we're given no specific reason, like everyone loves her and mourns her deeply, and then the first like overt um addressing we get is from Che, who's yeah, like, she's awful, you know. She the things she did were terrible, you know, uh uh a movie actress died today, and why is everyone making such a hubbub? And so we start off with like this given assumption like look at this awful person, um, and like kind of are wound through this super problematic, don't get me wrong, like woman finds her power and sleeps her way to the top and uses it to both affect her own situation and maybe the situation of people similar to who where she came from, um, but at what cost through what corruption, through what you know, frivolities she um diverts to herself are is this good or bad? Um like that's at least where where my conflict comes from. I find it interesting that your you your reaction is like I want people to think like no Evita's not a good person.

[22:11] Jimi: Yeah, well she's not. Um, like I think the one of one of the biggest ones that always comes out for me is um "Don't Cry for Me, Argentina."

[22:20] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[22:21] Jimi: Uh specifically in the lyric of that. Um because if you really like it's one of those things, like I've been saying "Don't Cry for Me, Argentina" for so long, but only since becoming an intelligent human being to really uh think about what I'm saying.

[22:40] Tommy: Right.

[22:40] Jimi: And she's basically being like I used to be pure, but I really wasn't into that. So I'm really rich and fabulous now, and I'm not really gonna apologize for that. That's what the song is.

[22:55] Tommy: Yeah.

[22:55] Jimi: Like it's it do you know, I mean? So it and yet they're lapping it up because it's like, oh my god, yes, you're so glad like so. The alternate reading is like, don't cry for me, Argentina, like I never left you. Like I I look as opulent as and fantastic as I am right now, and then it becomes the democratic ideal, like, and so can you like that's in a new Argentina, like who who could lead the people but Perón if he like he how could he love me if he's not that kind of person. So I think this is an interesting plot point, and I actually I personally think this is intentional.

[23:37] Tommy: Yeah.

[23:37] Jimi: So she sings "Don't Cry for Me, Argentina." All you have to do is look at me, see how gorgeous I am to know that this has worked. Right um the song ends. Um then she comes back out after getting lauded, and then she delivers the speech.

[23:59] Tommy: Yeah, yeah.

[24:00] Jimi: And the speech is is very much being like, I've got this and you can have this too. And it she doesn't do it initially, that isn't her initial intention.

[24:08] Tommy: Yeah.

[24:08] Jimi: She gets pulled back out and kind of does this adulation thing because it's like a reactionary thing.

[24:16] Tommy: Yeah.

[24:16] Jimi: But in no point, not until um push comes to shove uh does she actually offer that to the people with the money comes roll the money keeps rolling in.

[24:28] Tommy: True, true. Like So I I really think there's I think it's I think uh she is crafty.

[24:37] Jimi: I think it's like it's one of the definitely crafty.

[24:40] Tommy: Yeah.

[24:40] Jimi: It's I'm not saying um she's evil, I'm not saying that, but I think she knows what she wants and she will do anything to get it. And she sa I mean she says it herself.

[24:51] Tommy: Yeah.

[24:51] Jimi: Um in the finale. Uh where she basically says that like I chose to live fast and die young.

[24:59] Tommy: Yeah.

[24:59] Jimi: As opposed to having time.

[25:01] Tommy: True.

[25:02] Jimi: Yeah.

[25:03] Tommy: Um and she's she's always that's I mean that's kind of where you have to give her applaudes. She she never really hides away from that fact. She's always very upfront about the fact that yeah, I know what I did.

[25:14] Jimi: Yeah.

[25:16] Tommy: I'm not gonna apologize about that.

[25:18] Jimi: Yeah.

[25:20] Tommy: It's interesting. I think this is why this musical has this is the the core of it that's become so successful is that it is this conflict that exists. Even more so than the music. Um I need a fan.

[25:38] Jimi: Um why do you need a fan? What are you fanning yourself?

[25:40] Tommy: Because I'm throwing shade.

[25:42] Jimi: Oh, I see. The proper response to throwing shade is to clack that fan.

[25:48] Tommy: I think you thwarp a fan now.

[25:49] Jimi: We thwarp a fan.

[25:51] Tommy: I'm behind the times. I just downloaded Fallout the other day and I'm like so old now I don't understand.

[25:57] Jimi: What's that got to do with anything?

[25:59] Tommy: How'd you fall out?

[26:00] Jimi: Yeah, we're talking about like not understanding the youth of the nation, whether they're gay or they play Fallout, because these are mutually exclusive groups.

[26:06] Tommy: Did the youth even play Fallout?

[26:08] Jimi: I think we need Fortnite.

[26:09] Tommy: I do mean Fortnite.

[26:11] Jimi: Oh no, I'm old.

[26:13] Tommy: I'm keeping that in.

[26:14] Jimi: I'm keeping that in.

[26:19] Tommy: Oh my gosh.

[26:23] Jimi: I was like, Fallout.

[26:26] Tommy: I mean like the way it released a new expansion like last year, but that's so bad.

[26:33] Jimi: You're an old bear.

[28:00] ♪ Musical number: "Don't Cry for Me Argentina" ♪

[28:16] Tommy: One of the things I think would improve the story or would certainly um uh make it less ambiguous as to who she was.

[29:38] Jimi: Is um I don't think they go in hard enough on uh the dark side of her character.

[29:49] Tommy: Yeah. It's there. If you really look for it.

[29:53] Jimi: Um, but you can kinda get swept up in the rainbow alongside all of the Peron.

[29:59] Tommy: In the fur in the yeah. Um we kind of almost missed a trick on, but these they start to get there is to do with her death.

[30:10] Jimi: Yeah. Her death is fat. So um the show ends with um thinking I just say I mean it's basically Mandy Patinkin.

[30:21] Tommy: Yeah.

[30:21] Jimi: Uh you're thinking, or Ricky Martin.

[30:24] Tommy: Yeah, yeah.

[30:24] Jimi: Or David Essex. I guess could be lots of people.

[30:27] Tommy: All three of them.

[30:28] Jimi: No, probably not all three of them.

[30:29] Tommy: Come Wilkinson.

[30:30] Jimi: I don't know about that.

[30:31] Tommy: Right. Um, anyway, Shay, uh saying like they um managed to build the pedestal, but then her body went missing for 17 years, and you don't really find out anything that happens about it.

[30:43] Jimi: Now, it would I can understand that as a writing point of view, kind of going into what happened post-death isn't useful or anything.

[30:57] Tommy: Kind of done, yeah.

[30:58] Jimi: But what it does kind of give you if you find out the story is it shows you this the like fallacy of it all, and that it all kind of meant nothing. Um which would add this kind of darker tinge.

[31:11] Tommy: So basically, um so she was embalmed uh and basically uh when I think it was like really shortly after um Peron got like overthrown uh or something, I'm not 100% sure.

[31:33] Jimi: Uh but basically, oh, it was in nineteen fifty-five.

[31:36] Tommy: Yes, yes, that is exactly it. It was embalmed, it lay there for two and a half years.

[31:42] Jimi: Then in 1955, Peron was ousted um after a coup, and uh the corpse was excommunicated.

[31:52] Tommy: Uh nobody knew what to do with it.

[31:55] Jimi: Yeah. Because they didn't want to bury it.

[31:57] Tommy: Right.

[31:58] Jimi: Um, so a guy called Antonio Aranda, who I think was a like high up person in Peron's world.

[32:08] Tommy: I'm not 100% sure who he was.

[32:10] Jimi: Uh, he kept it in his bedroom with his wife.

[32:13] Tommy: Oh.

[32:13] Jimi: Uh, and he basically slept with a loaded pistol.

[32:18] Tommy: Wow.

[32:18] Jimi: Um, to protect it because it it obviously was an icon.

[32:23] Tommy: Right. You know what I mean? Now that she was a corpse, this was like a tool.

[32:27] Jimi: Yeah. To be used. Hu hugely important in a bunch of different ways from a bunch of different perspectives.

[32:33] Tommy: Yeah. Totally.

[32:34] Jimi: Um, and so he awful. Like, I can't this this isn't this is real.

[32:40] Tommy: Um, he shot and killed his pregnant wife when she was heading to the bathroom because he thought she was an intruder.

[32:48] Jimi: Wow.

[32:49] Tommy: Um gosh.

[32:50] Jimi: Yeah. Uh then the corpse got moved again.

[32:55] Tommy: Um, it was kept in a storeroom in a box that was marked like radio sets.

[33:01] Jimi: Wow or something.

[33:02] Tommy: Yeah.

[33:03] Jimi: Um, then uh she it got given to I think it was like an Italian widow.

[33:10] Tommy: Uh huh.

[33:10] Jimi: Um, and they gave her like another name.

[33:13] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[33:14] Jimi: Um, and then she eventually got buried with Peron once he died.

[33:19] Tommy: Yeah.

[33:19] Jimi: But it's just this this idea of like this thing, you know, th the thousands of people who came to leap over her body, yeah.

[33:28] Tommy: She gets reduced to being in a storeroom somewhere.

[33:31] Jimi: Right. How your how your story changes once you're no longer a part of it.

[33:35] Tommy: Exactly.

[33:36] Jimi: Um, I'm I'm no dramaturg, but I'd find that quite tricky to work in.

[33:42] Tommy: But it it adds that quite moralistic aspect to it.

[33:46] Jimi: Yeah. Of and it's just it is quite just interesting in in the real world, I guess.

[33:50] Tommy: Yeah.

[33:51] Jimi: Um that this happened and that she led this life of such hedonism and glory for it just to be reduced to radio sets.

[34:04] Tommy: Yeah.

[34:05] Jimi: Well, and it does like put in, you know.

[34:09] Tommy: The musical doesn't quite play up its the capability it has in the unreliable narrator battle.

[34:18] Jimi: Who do you believe? Do you believe Shay? Do you believe Ava?

[34:21] Tommy: Yep.

[34:22] Jimi: Throughout the whole thing.

[34:22] Tommy: And like that's why Waltz Between Ava and Shay is, I think, a fabulous piece of musical theater.

[34:27] Jimi: Yeah, definitely.

[34:28] Tommy: You know, it's a wonderful thing to build to.

[34:30] Jimi: They haven't acknowledged each other, basically, the entire show until this moment where they have a dance with each other.

[34:35] Tommy: Um, and like to see, you know, how who who wins the what story we're telling battle.

[34:43] Jimi: Yeah.

[34:44] Tommy: No.

[34:44] Jimi: I'm excited for you to direct this show in the future.

[34:47] Tommy: Thanks.

[34:48] Jimi: It's it's a hundred percent going to happen.

[34:50] Tommy: I direct so much nowadays.

[34:52] Jimi: The Scottish premiere of Evita is currently on tour with Marty Pello.

[35:00] Tommy: That sounds like a cleaning product.

[35:03] Jimi: Uh he was it weirdly, coincidentally, in a band called Wet Wet Wet.

[35:08] Tommy: Hey, maybe he is a cleaning.

[35:11] Jimi: He probably is.

[35:12] Tommy: I wish he was.

[35:13] Jimi: He's awful.

[35:14] Tommy: Um that's yeah, Bill Ken.

[35:17] Jimi: Oh talk about Bill Kenray at some point.

[35:20] Tommy: I'm excited.

[35:21] Jimi: No is not the time.

[35:22] Tommy: Anyway.

[35:23] Jimi: Let's keep sitting on controversy.

[35:26] Tommy: Yes.

[35:26] Jimi: Or controversy.

[35:28] Tommy: I think that's the one you say.

[35:29] Jimi: That is what we say.

[35:30] Tommy: Cause you Brits like to add extra letters, but that's fine.

[35:34] Jimi: Yeah, that's what we like to do.

[35:36] Tommy: Say the English language is supposed to be said.

[35:39] Jimi: Um Yeah.

[35:41] Tommy: So you've got some points here.

[35:44] Jimi: Mm-hmm.

[35:46] Tommy: That Jimatomic Staples let's discuss.

[35:50] Jimi: So this musical is written by Andrew Lloyd Webber and Tim Rice.

[35:57] Tommy: Jimmy, I don't know if you know this.

[35:59] Jimi: Yeah.

[36:00] Tommy: But neither of them are from Argentina.

[36:02] Jimi: Yes.

[36:04] Tommy: And there's like Ava Perone is a as like a person is already kind of controversial in Argentinian history.

[36:14] Jimi: Like, without the musical.

[36:16] Tommy: Um for some of the reasons we've talked about already.

[36:19] Jimi: But I I wonder about there's a lot of writing that like this is a uh uh colonized reconstruction of Argentinian history by two European white men.

[36:33] Tommy: Um I wondered how you felt about this, and I wonder like where we draw the line, because plenty of people write musicals about things they don't know.

[36:43] Jimi: And like when does that become not okay?

[36:48] Tommy: Um because like certainly uh you know, I don't have maybe the specs the specific evidence to back it up, but I would wager Andrew Lloyd Webber and Tim Rice did their research in this show.

[37:00] Jimi: Um like they didn't just have been researching it for about five years.

[37:05] Tommy: Yeah.

[37:05] Jimi: So like it's not like this is a careless representation.

[37:11] Tommy: Um but still there is this is I mean, I felt when I wrote this in the show notes, I felt like I was playing the Jim and Tomic's devil's advocate because all the time we fall into the like, well, it's not their story, how dare they, right?

[37:23] Jimi: How dare they appropriate this topic?

[37:25] Tommy: Um and I don't know how I feel about this one.

[37:27] Jimi: I I legitimately don't.

[37:29] Tommy: I'm right on the fence.

[37:30] Jimi: And like w I don't know, worried that I might be wrong, or worried that like on the one hand, I do think it's kind of offensive, and see the kind of like white, chauvinistic, Eurocentric lens that Rice and Lloyd Weber have painted this musical in and can see the problems that already has created the like I don't know if it's a TV tropes term, but the kind of like feminine Latino whore hero, pardon all my terminology, but like the like use your body to get what you want, and like while I do think there's power in that, I think there's less power in that when it's written by two white men.

[38:08] Tommy: Um but on the other hand, there's a big bent towards this, like they're, you know, bringing we talked about this in Heights, like bringing a story that m certainly wouldn't have reached the audiences that it currently has had it not existed in this musical.

[38:25] Jimi: And so I wonder, like, where, you know, tell me the answers. Where is that line?

[38:29] Tommy: So I'm gonna jump in uh with two gentlemen that we know and love called Kandra and Ebb.

[38:36] Jimi: Mm-hmm.

[38:37] Tommy: Um we've talked about this before in the Scotchbird Boys.

[38:40] Jimi: Kandra and Ebb, two white men.

[38:42] Tommy: Yep.

[38:43] Jimi: Scotspur Boys an extremely important part of the black civil rights movement.

[38:49] Tommy: Yeah.

[38:50] Jimi: Uh should they have told that story?

[38:54] Tommy: Absolutely, because I would never have known about it.

[38:57] Jimi: Right.

[38:57] Tommy: Had they not.

[38:58] Jimi: Yeah.

[39:01] Tommy: As would a lot of theatre goers.

[39:03] Jimi: Do you know what I mean?

[39:03] Tommy: Like like we said then, it's not even something that gets talked about in American curriculum.

[39:08] Jimi: Yeah, exactly.

[39:09] Tommy: This is very, very important.

[39:11] Jimi: Um and I feel like with Argentina, uh it's a very difficult country.

[39:21] Tommy: Yeah.

[39:21] Jimi: And it's very super nuanced.

[39:24] Tommy: It's super new.

[39:25] Jimi: It's um it's it's its history is fascinating.

[39:29] Tommy: Yeah.

[39:29] Jimi: Um and so deep and difficult.

[39:35] Tommy: Uh you know, I mean it it's been war torn for so long.

[39:41] Jimi: Um the stability in those stable periods are still kind of uh like deep and there's a you know I mean the reason that it's stable isn't necessarily a stable reason is that like their their stability might not have come out of the best of reasons, but because of how like their average level is unstable, there's a lot of uh joy is the wrong word, but like importance placed on the moments of stability.

[40:16] Tommy: Yeah, exactly, exactly.

[40:18] Jimi: Um excuse me, and you know, for a lot of people, uh Peronism was a positive thing.

[40:28] Tommy: Yeah, um, and their lives at that time were made better because of it.

[40:32] Jimi: Yeah.

[40:33] Tommy: Um, and then you know, the next movement um in Argentina was the Dirty War, and that was one of the most horrific things that's happened on the earth.

[40:45] Jimi: Um, but yeah, I'd wager you don't know much about it.

[40:48] Tommy: Nope.

[40:49] Jimi: So uh the only reason I know anything about it is because of white people writing musical theatre.

[40:55] Tommy: Um so I'm gonna hit out with two musicals.

[40:58] Jimi: Um first of which Candor and Ebb, Kiss of the Spider Woman, fabulous show.

[41:03] Tommy: Yeah, takes place during the Dirty War from inside a prison cell.

[41:07] Jimi: And it's it's not really telling you much about the war, but you get a glimpse of the country at the time.

[41:12] Tommy: Yeah, like a slight glimpse of the country.

[41:15] Jimi: In the same way, if you like Kev Bray, and that that's like a pre-World War II view of Germany, yeah.

[41:22] Tommy: Kiss of the Spider Woman has this has a similar vibe.

[41:25] Jimi: Does that seem fair?

[41:26] Tommy: Kind of, yeah, yeah.

[41:28] Jimi: But I'd say this other musical, which is called These Trees Are Made of Blood.

[41:32] Tommy: Yeah, I've not heard of this one, so you you absolutely won't have.

[41:35] Jimi: Um it was like an off-west end uh piece that one of my friends was in.

[41:40] Tommy: Uh huh.

[41:40] Jimi: Um, and it's it's generally one of the best pieces of theatre I've ever seen.

[41:44] Tommy: Uh huh.

[41:45] Jimi: Like, I was so blown away by it for so many reasons.

[41:48] Tommy: Um so and I'm so I'm actually really happy I get a chance to mention it on the podcast because I've been like working out for so long how to do it.

[41:57] Jimi: Uh-huh.

[41:58] Tommy: Um but this is this is absolutely perfect.

[42:01] Jimi: So um it's basically it uses the kind of Candor and Ebb framing device of uh we're gonna take uh a method of performance and we're gonna tell a story through that.

[42:14] Tommy: So they pick uh um quite similar to Cabaret, they pick a uh it's sort of nightclub setting.

[42:21] Jimi: Okay, yeah, um, and there's a host and he takes you through uh everything, and you know it's like you're in Argentina and everything's fun, isn't it?

[42:32] Tommy: You're having a great time and it's all festive, um, and then the sl the story just slowly but surely just starts to break down, yeah, and you realize that this is a dark place to be.

[42:43] Jimi: Yeah.

[42:43] Tommy: Um you basically just start to learn about uh this group of people called um the disappeared, and it basically anyone kind of trying to protest against uh the regime or who people who know people who protest against the regime would just be removed from society, yeah, no questions asked, uh, and killed, and um these trees of made of blood, the musical ends uh with uh basically the the kind of back curtain drops, and the whole of the backstage is just filled with these the faces of these people, and there are so many, and it's such an overwhelming moment because it's it's a story I knew nothing about, right?

[43:26] Jimi: This is a genocide, yeah, and I knew nothing about it, yeah.

[43:30] Tommy: And I was I was more just shocked at myself for being like I can't believe that I've got you know I mean gotten this far and not even been aware um of the extent of it.

[43:42] Jimi: Yeah, uh so to come back to your question, yeah.

[43:48] Jimi: Should people be telling the story if they're not from there?

[43:52] Tommy: Yeah, I want to say absolutely, yeah. Um I don't think that counts for every story.

[43:59] Jimi: Right.

[43:59] Tommy: But I feel for this, when it's something that is it's it's analytical.

[44:06] Jimi: Yeah.

[44:06] Tommy: Do you know it's it's it's very it's it's it's taking a story or taking um an idea and really looking at it with a lens.

[44:20] Jimi: Yeah.

[44:21] Tommy: Rather than just telling a story outright.

[44:24] Jimi: Well, and it does, like, we're that you know, I'm preaching to the choir when I'm talking to you, but this is the thing we love about musical theater is it puts that layer in between that lets you look at this kind of piece of history with a lens. It becomes just a little more than factual. Like we're not it's not just a documentary about Eva Peron, but it instead becomes this like emotional lens through which you are guided, like this tour of Argentinian history.

[44:57] Tommy: Um I do think so. Then I think this is where I'm I'm thinking this up in my brain right now, so who knows how accurate it is, but these trees are made of blood. Your description of it made me think about this. I wonder if maybe this is why I'm a little more unsure about Evita. And I think one of the things that actually I like a little bit more about the movie than it as a stage play, that the movie dives in a little bit more with some of the like absolutely gruesome and awful imagery of this portion of Argentine history.

[45:32] Jimi: Um where it's a musical on stage, like you're not gonna spend a lot of time showing a bunch of dead kids out in the street or a bunch of explosions at union rallies or things like that um and like for all of the movies faults it certainly showcased some of the violence a little more accurately um which I do think the stage musical is maybe missing a little bit like I if like we need to see I don't know both sides of the story it sounds wanky to say but like to for it to have the right emotional impact for what I want that 50/50 audience reaction you need to see more of the bad stuff that's happening while Evita's throwing money up in the air on her balcony you know.

[45:32] Tommy: Yeah, I would totally agree with that. Um and I think I think that's just a production point of view. To be honest I've never actually watched the the recent Broadway one with Alina um but I'm so I don't know if they they bring in an element of that.

[46:37] Jimi: Yeah.

[46:38] Tommy: But I think that would just take a smart director to bring an else because the thing is I would argue that it's in the music. It's certainly in the music. I do think it takes a director. Because that's the problem with this show is since it is an opera and the I've seen the script there's not a lot of specific stage directions.

[46:55] Jimi: Yeah yeah it takes a smart director. Like our production in college was fine but certainly not this. And I saw it on tour maybe in high school um I don't know what production birthed that tour for it was just a choice. And like it was certainly moving but doesn't at least neither production, at least to my memory, has that kind of like, you know, like there needs to be in the show, I think, a couple of moments of like absolutely awful bloody death terribleness, um, that isn't quite explicitly written in.

[47:31] Tommy: It's certainly not written out, but it takes it takes a strong director, it takes some intelligent and important choices to make that as impactful as it needs to be.

[47:42] Jimi: Uh-huh. It's interesting because it's um like Hal Prince, we don't need to question that he's a good director. Um he the the kind of slant he took with with Evita originally, um was almost quite a Brechtan concept, like really minimal lighting, yeah, extremely minimal set, um, and played a lot of it out just out straight out front.

[48:08] Tommy: Um and I think obviously to kind of give this kind, you know, the stark political theater concept. Yeah, there's something there. But but what I would say is theater, musical theater specifically, um in the late 70s is a different beast as to what it can be now.

[48:25] Jimi: Yeah.

[48:26] Tommy: Um I do think and it's one of those things as well, now that Evita is so beloved, it's kind of now obviously is the time to take that story and and to really dig into the meat of it because we all know it.

[48:41] Jimi: Yeah.

[48:42] Tommy: We don't want to just go see another Evita. We want we want something new from it. And I think that's something uh a smart director could could do.

[48:50] Jimi: I do, I do wonder if Evita is entering this realm of like um Le Miz problemisticity, um, which is a word I just invented. Um where like I don't think have you seen there's a YouTube video. Maybe we'll find it for the show notes. I don't know if I can find it again, where it's like a daughter recording her mom and dad coming back from seeing Le Miz in theaters, and they're just bawling. And they're not crying because it's a sad story. Because it is a sad story, but they're crying because they've been waiting so long to see Le Miz in theaters, and they're like, oh, and then they started singing the s and then the flag, and oh my god, like just losing it with kind of the culturalness associated to it.

[49:33] Jimi: And you know, I don't think average white suburban Midwestern person who goes to see Le Miz in theaters is like, yeah, the minor French revolution of whenever. Wow, they certainly fought for their freedoms. I feel so sad for the political things that we're fighting for. They're like, oh no, Anne Hathaway. Um I think Evita, like this is this is the the tightrope to walk. Like, how many people see Evita and are like, oh, Madonna or Patty LuPone or whatever, and not like diving into this story.

[50:10] Tommy: But that's what I mean. That's what it needs a director then to tell that story properly.

[50:14] Jimi: Yeah, do you know what I mean? And to take it away from this is a star vehicle, this is uh I'm just showcasing that's the thing as well, is like um going from that that opera album to putting that on a stage. I don't know how you do that because it's relentless, yeah.

[50:32] Tommy: It's all over the place.

[50:33] Jimi: Yeah, um, and so first of all, kind of hats off to Hal Prince for doing that the first way, but then um now that we know it, and now that we've had the time to really digest the material and digest it as a musical, yeah.

[50:49] Tommy: I think there's like I just I like say is that you can get a bit deeper into it and you can fruit around a little bit more, yeah.

[50:58] Jimi: Yeah, no, I'd be interested to see it.

[51:00] Tommy: Yeah. I mean, I really, really and I wouldn't be it's one of those things I wouldn't go away being like, well, they've they've just put a way, like some productions they'll really want to hit into an issue that isn't really there.

[51:12] Jimi: Not quite there, yeah.

[51:14] Tommy: This would make total sense.

[51:15] Jimi: Yeah, no, absolutely. It it's I mean, it's amazing that Candor and Ebb and Cabaret keep coming up, but it feels like it needs that kind of cabaret revival um Alan Cumming treatment.

[51:26] Tommy: Exactly.

[51:26] Jimi: What a great yeah, exactly. Go in on it.

[51:30] Tommy: Totally. Um you can do you know, I mean a really good reviver can can do that with a show, yeah.

[51:39] Jimi: Um and and paint a new spin on it without really touching the material that much, just really just thinking.

[51:45] Tommy: I do I do feel I do feel like that takes a bunch of artistic strength though. Um to like, you know, to like to do Les Miz Without a Turntable, to like go in and and like kind of because it's iconic, like so much of this show has just become its own piece of lore and history. Um, and to like just not even open that book on rehearsal day and just be like, nope, we're starting again is like that takes a lot of strength as an artist and power and is important, like I think that's a really important quality to have.

[52:22] Jimi: Um but not not one that we see in our industry a lot. I think a lot of times it's easier to fall into like, yeah, we're gonna drop the chandelier on the stage again because that's what everyone's done.

[52:31] Tommy: Exactly.

[52:31] Jimi: Yeah.

[52:33] Tommy: Um, so who knows? Is it you?

[52:35] Jimi: Director?

[52:36] Tommy: I hope so.

[52:37] Jimi: I hope it's him.

[52:38] Tommy: Let us know.

[52:39] Jimi: Or her.

[52:39] Tommy: Yeah.

[52:40] Jimi: And and send us tickets and we'll show up.

[52:43] Tommy: Yes, and we'll give you a good report.

[52:45] Jimi: Or I will.

[52:45] Tommy: I probably won't.

[52:46] Jimi: No, because I'm mean.

[52:50] Tommy: Exactly. Shall we talk about Andrew Lloyd Webber?

[52:53] Jimi: Ah, again.

[53:00] Tommy: How can you be so short-sided? To look never further than this week or next week to have no impossible dream. Allow me to help you slink off to the sidelines. I'll pay off a gift free chills. But first only would be delighted to witness me tackle the world's greatest problems from war to pollution.

[53:28] Jimi: No hope of solution. Even if I live for 100 years. There is a hill.

[53:44] Tommy: So come if you're able to somewhere unstable and stay there. With what we all hate in some tottering state, but not here, dear.

[53:55] Jimi: Okay, so this episode is of course sponsored by Gold Star.

[53:58] Tommy: Tell me tell us all about Goldstar.

[54:00] Jimi: Well, so I'm looking up right here. Um as you know, Gold Star has a bunch of tickets to live events, affordable tickets. Um most of their tickets are uh markdown from the original ones, and they have a bunch of regional tickets right here in Denver. Jimmy, I could go see Crybaby the musical. Did you know that was a thing?

[54:16] Tommy: Absolutely. You're talking to a big John Waters fan right here.

[54:19] Jimi: Or if if I wanted to put my sports hat on, they've got some Rockies tickets too, and I could go to a baseball game.

[54:27] Tommy: That I could tell you nothing.

[54:30] Jimi: Um yeah, if you uh go over and check out goldstar.com um or check out the absolutely free gold star app. Um and if you are one of our first 200 listeners who use our our promo code happy hour, uh then you'll get ten dollars off your purchase, and that's on the already marked down tickets.

[54:50] Tommy: Yeah, absolutely. Uh a lot of tickets on Goldstar are about 50% off, and I see that here, and it just looks great. Look at this. I could go see Annie.

[54:58] Jimi: I would go see Annie.

[54:59] Tommy: Yeah, would you?

[55:00] Jimi: We'd like to thank you, so great.

[55:04] Tommy: Yep, so if you use the promo code Happy Hour, that's happy hour all caps one word at goldstar.com backslash happy hour, you can get ten dollars off your first order. That only goes out to our first two hundred listeners, so use it quick, use it now.

[55:19] Jimi: Run use it now, run to your computer.

[55:34] Tommy: What I give for a hundredies at the physical empty every day mod on my creator.

[55:54] Jimi: In a body that's falling up on serious flaw.

[56:01] Tommy: I hope you know that.

[56:20] Jimi: I will say of Andrew Lloyd Webber's scores, this is the one I can listen to. Um even before before I started going into it for specifically for this podcast, I I would have unabashedly said I like Evita.

[56:36] Tommy: I since have going into it since in my old my old age, um have found more things to like find problems with it that kind of swings the pendulum more towards meh territory.

[56:48] Jimi: Um but I well I don't know if I'd call it his best score. I I do think it is his most I okay.

[56:56] Tommy: I don't say that as saying I think something else is his best score more than still fine.

[57:02] Jimi: Yeah, I still find problems with this, and the problems with this I still think are like hugely problematic on a musical theater scale.

[57:08] Tommy: I think this is most his most listenable score.

[57:11] Jimi: Um I find fewer problems with this than I do his other musicals.

[57:16] Tommy: Does that make it his best?

[57:17] Jimi: I don't know.

[57:18] Tommy: Um technically, yes.

[57:21] Jimi: Technically, yes, yeah.

[57:22] Tommy: I find you say that yeah.

[57:25] Jimi: I just want to jump on that straight away in the fact that you say it's his most listenable.

[57:29] Tommy: Yeah.

[57:30] Jimi: Because it's like atonal to F, and not all of it.

[57:36] Tommy: I don't I don't think it's so eternal.

[57:43] Jimi: There's nothing atonal about what's not.

[57:51] Tommy: This is when the podcast just devolves into Jimmy and I mean Yes, it is less atonal than Jesus Christ Superstar.

[58:03] Jimi: That's not even true.

[58:06] Tommy: That's not true.

[58:07] Jimi: Like it's the and this is but this is I'm not saying this is a bad thing. I think this is what makes it his best best score because it's so impressive.

[58:18] Tommy: I do think it's impressive.

[58:19] Jimi: I do think I do think it it borders on Sondheim-esque in some of its, so maybe that makes it atonal.

[58:25] Tommy: Um the problems I have with it on a score level, melodically and longitudinally, is that like there are like six melodies.

[58:36] Jimi: Um and not in an Into the Woods kind of way where there's six melodies but they're different every time you listen to them, but in a way where it's like there's six melodies, and who knows which one might pop up, and it doesn't really matter which one popped up.

[58:47] Tommy: Like I they're not they're not themes.

[58:49] Jimi: They're not they are themes.

[58:52] Tommy: But they're not.

[58:53] Jimi: But they are.

[58:54] Tommy: Let's take the ending.

[58:56] Jimi: Um the very very ending.

[58:58] Tommy: Okay.

[58:59] Jimi: The last thing we hear is almost a reprise of Rainbow High.

[59:04] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[59:05] Jimi: This and it leaves you with this idea that it's just all about the glamour, and even in death, she's just sit bathing in this glamour.

[59:14] Tommy: That's one tiny example.

[59:15] Jimi: Um like they pick up no, it's it's so smart.

[59:15] Tommy: It's so smart.

[59:21] Jimi: The theme that's the thing though, he uses the themes really well.

[59:24] Tommy: I wonder introduces them at the right time to it's almost like to remind you.

[59:30] Jimi: I wonder if the difference is you have listened to it and I have seen it.

[59:34] Tommy: Um because there are plenty of underscoring themes, and not even my college production, but like the touring production, or even the movie.

[59:42] Jimi: There are like some undercoring underscoring themes where they don't like they'll do the um the uh the what is it, the board things have reached a pretty pass one like that theme.

[59:57] Tommy: Pretty low class, dot dot like there's one point in the movie they do it they did it really early, and I remember thinking like, why is this happening?

[1:00:04] Jimi: I know what this theme is because I know when it's gonna come back later, but we're not talking about rich people.

[1:00:04] Tommy: We're not talking about this like classist assumption, and this theme's like really one-dimensional.

[1:00:13] Jimi: Like we don't we don't this song doesn't come back, like we don't reuse this.

[1:00:17] Tommy: So why are you putting this underscoring in?

[1:00:20] Jimi: I think it does come back in in Buenos Aires, by the way.

[1:00:23] Tommy: But um Yeah, I don't I d I don't know.

[1:00:27] Jimi: I if I if I knew the bit you were referring to And I and of course I'm doing a bad job of describing it.

[1:00:33] Tommy: Um But I would I just think like you need you need to give him his plaudits for this one because this is good.

[1:00:42] Jimi: Do I like and is his use of um like uh what were they called?

[1:00:48] Tommy: Meter.

[1:00:49] Jimi: Um is so impressive.

[1:00:52] Tommy: It's it's like it's not Wagnerian, but it's getting there.

[1:00:58] Jimi: No, it's because he didn't plagiarize this one.

[1:00:59] Tommy: Um this is it though.

[1:01:01] Jimi: Like it is I think this I do find this quite fascinating because he this is effectively his most original work.

[1:01:10] Tommy: That's true.

[1:01:12] Jimi: And it's in my opinion, it's it is his best.

[1:01:14] Tommy: Yeah, do you know what I mean?

[1:01:15] Jimi: And he's just allowed to kind of go with it.

[1:01:17] Tommy: So his dad helped him out with uh the orchestrations, yeah.

[1:01:21] Jimi: Um his dad comes from much uh uh more classical background, more um more background background.

[1:01:30] Tommy: And um he was confused and then he was ashamed of me.

[1:01:35] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:01:37] Tommy: Uh and then uh you know, was like here's some instruments uh from Latin America that you could use to bring in the live there.

[1:01:46] Jimi: Yeah, but beyond that, it's it's it is fully original.

[1:01:50] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:01:51] Jimi: I've have I've already done have I ever told you my two Andrew Lloyd Webber conspiracy theories.

[1:01:56] Tommy: Uh potentially, and I've probably gone and rolled my eyes, but yes, go.

[1:02:00] Jimi: Well, so the first is about the cat's VHS that Andrew Lloyd Webber hid in every teenager's drawer or gave to every teenager's grandma to give them for Christmas.

[1:02:09] Tommy: Right, yes.

[1:02:09] Jimi: I had good information.

[1:02:11] Tommy: That has brought cats into the popular culture because Andrew Lloyd Webber was like, hmm, ha ha ha, this was or just because it's really really good.

[1:02:18] Jimi: Um my other theory is that like Andrew Lloyd Webber, the person is perpetually stuck in like a ratatouille style relationship with a cat who is like a musical theater writing savant.

[1:02:34] Tommy: Um this is why a cat walked over his keyboard and deleted all of Love Never Dies.

[1:02:39] Jimi: Um, and why he wrote the musical Cats, but like, and why really Andrew Lloyd Webber's cat wrote the musical Cats and like the adult the cat had in its life was Andrew Lloyd Webber and was like, yes, we will make this relationship work.

[1:02:53] Tommy: A la ratatouille.

[1:02:54] Jimi: Um catatouille.

[1:02:56] Tommy: Catatouie.

[1:02:58] Jimi: This is my theory of like why this one's the most original.

[1:03:01] Tommy: This is the one the cat, like, you know, maybe it's an Argentinian cat, who knows?

[1:03:05] Jimi: Like, really dove in and was gonna write this one.

[1:03:08] Tommy: And this is why Andrew Lloyd Webber plagiarizes sometimes, because when the cat can't get it done, Andrew Lloyd Webber, who knows nothing about music, needs to be like, well, we gotta figure this out somehow, and then you know, resorts to plagiarism.

[1:03:21] Jimi: 100% fact.

[1:03:23] Tommy: You heard it here first.

[1:03:24] Jimi: I think you're totally right.

[1:03:26] Tommy: No, I'm refusing to hear it.

[1:03:28] Jimi: Um, I just think it's it's just so well done.

[1:03:32] Tommy: Um, a couple of other bits I want to kind of highlight just for how smart they are.

[1:03:36] Jimi: And this kind of brings in Tim Rice too, to be honest.

[1:03:38] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:03:39] Jimi: Um, with Another Suitcase and Another Hall.

[1:03:43] Tommy: I find this song fascinating.

[1:03:46] Jimi: Oh, it's great.

[1:03:46] Tommy: Don't count on the movie representation either, because

[1:03:46] Jimi: No, absolutely don't, because it was ruined.

[1:03:52] Tommy: Yes, 100%.

[1:03:53] Jimi: Never watch it.

[1:03:55] Tommy: Fast forward.

[1:03:55] Jimi: Fun thing.

[1:03:56] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[1:03:56] Jimi: Um, do you know who plays Peron's Mistress?

[1:04:00] Tommy: Who?

[1:04:02] Jimi: It is Andrea Corr.

[1:04:02] Tommy: You don't know who that is.

[1:04:04] Jimi: Nope.

[1:04:05] Tommy: But British people will.

[1:04:07] Jimi: Um, from the band The Corrs.

[1:04:09] Tommy: Oh.

[1:04:10] Jimi: Nope.

[1:04:11] Tommy: You don't know The Corrs.

[1:04:12] Jimi: Nope, but I made a sound like I did.

[1:04:13] Tommy: That was good.

[1:04:14] Jimi: Yeah, kind of like an Irish pop folk band.

[1:04:17] Tommy: Why did they have her sing it?

[1:04:18] Jimi: Because Madonna was in the 90s.

[1:04:21] Tommy: 100%.

[1:04:22] Jimi: That was exactly it.

[1:04:23] Tommy: But also, I'm just like, well done, Andrea Corr.

[1:04:25] Jimi: I thought she did very well.

[1:04:26] Tommy: I thought she in that brief moment of not talking.

[1:04:29] Jimi: Have you ever seen The Black Cauldron?

[1:04:32] Tommy: Yes.

[1:04:32] Jimi: A long time ago.

[1:04:34] Tommy: Right.

[1:04:34] Jimi: Um, do you remember the song On My Father's Wings?

[1:04:39] Tommy: No.

[1:04:39] Jimi: And I will fly on my father's wings.

[1:04:43] Tommy: Okay.

[1:04:43] Jimi: Is that Andrea Corr?

[1:04:45] Tommy: That's Andrea Corr.

[1:04:46] Jimi: Alright.

[1:04:47] Tommy: The Corrs, everyone.

[1:04:49] Jimi: Of course.

[1:04:49] Tommy: They're very good.

[1:04:51] Jimi: I'll stick some stuff in the show notes.

[1:04:53] Tommy: Um, anyways.

[1:04:54] Jimi: Another Suitcase, I think, is one of the most important songs in the show.

[1:04:58] Tommy: Yes!

[1:04:58] Jimi: And I think Madonna ruined it by singing it.

[1:05:01] Tommy: Because the point is that other women are doing this.

[1:05:04] Jimi: Well.

[1:05:06] Tommy: Kind of, yes.

[1:05:08] Jimi: Which like, caveat, this is um a man writing a woman's world.

[1:05:12] Tommy: Like, I see a lot of problems here.

[1:05:13] Jimi: But uh for me at least, I think, as written, the fact that like this nameless other lady is singing, like, well, you know, Evita Perón has surpassed me in this ladder of female hierarchy in Argentina in this time.

[1:05:31] Tommy: And now I'm just another suitcase in another hall, but you know, where am I going to?

[1:05:36] Jimi: Don't ask anymore.

[1:05:37] Tommy: Like, it that to me, like, that's that's a tip on the pendulum towards like sympathizing with Evita.

[1:05:45] Jimi: Like, it is not sympathizing with Evita.

[1:05:48] Tommy: Oh, do you feel differently?

[1:05:50] Jimi: Interesting.

[1:05:50] Tommy: 100%.

[1:05:51] Jimi: Really?

[1:05:52] Tommy: Okay, tell me.

[1:05:52] Jimi: Tell me why you're sympathizing.

[1:05:54] Tommy: No, you first.

[1:05:54] Jimi: Okay.

[1:05:55] Tommy: Because it makes her not the only like certainly it is a bad thing she's doing maybe not bad, but not the best thing she's doing in that moment.

[1:06:04] Jimi: Like, hey, you know, um, what is it like?

[1:06:06] Tommy: Go back to school, you you play the part well, I forget the specific lines, but she kicks her out with some like real shady kind of, you know, poo-poo.

[1:06:15] Jimi: Um, but then on a story level, it shows that like this is how this world works.

[1:06:23] Tommy: For better or for worse, for right or for wrong, whether it's true or not, but this world is filled with a bunch of these kind of women who are trying to get ahead in the world in their panties, like in the bedrooms of famous or influential or important rich men.

[1:06:43] Jimi: And to me, that legitimizes Ava's Ava Perón's journey a little more.

[1:06:50] Tommy: She's not just the like, well, fuck it, I'm gonna throw all of this under the bus and do with it.

[1:06:57] Jimi: Like this is this is the life, this is the world.

[1:07:00] Tommy: Whether that's true or not, whether that's legitimate or not, whether that's accurately portrayed or not, I have lots of problems with.

[1:07:05] Jimi: I really want to maintain that caveat.

[1:07:07] Tommy: I think a lot of that comes from the chauvinistic, Eurocentric, white-centered person that wrote this musical, but at least from a story perspective, it's why I think having Another Suitcase in Another Hall really being the only other female-led song, it's like probably the second listed actress on the playbill for this show, right?

[1:07:32] Jimi: Whoever sings Another Suitcase in Another Hall, which is crazy for a two-hour show for one person who only sings one song.

[1:07:38] Tommy: Um and why it's so important that someone else sings that song.

[1:07:43] Jimi: But why do you think the opposite?

[1:07:44] Tommy: Why do you think it makes her worse?

[1:07:47] Jimi: Because it shows you Evita's character.

[1:07:49] Tommy: Um, so up until then, uh you've seen her be like kind of like devious, uh-huh, but it's with all of these men who you don't connect to um you don't uh you don't care about their exactly um maybe Augustine you get a slight bit of sympathy for him, yeah, and he does kind of give her the warning, like your ambition.

[1:08:21] Jimi: Um but this is the first time you see her step on someone.

[1:08:27] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:08:27] Jimi: And in that moment, it's like, oh, you have the ability to step on someone.

[1:08:33] Tommy: And she doesn't do it in a nice way.

[1:08:35] Jimi: She doesn't do it in a I'm sorry, I need to do this.

[1:08:38] Tommy: It's done in a no, you get out now.

[1:08:40] Jimi: This is my world.

[1:08:41] Tommy: And it's horribly cutting.

[1:08:43] Jimi: And you see that the real Ava Perón, because Perón's mistress, who he kicks out, was or could have easily been an Ava.

[1:08:54] Tommy: Yeah, she could have been equal.

[1:08:57] Jimi: Right.

[1:08:57] Tommy: Yeah, she could have been Ava Perón, basically.

[1:08:59] Jimi: Absolutely.

[1:09:00] Tommy: And all she does is she just tosses her out and she's completely forgotten about.

[1:09:04] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:09:05] Tommy: And that's that's the thing.

[1:09:06] Jimi: So in that moment, you get the whole story of Ava Perón's mistress.

[1:09:12] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:09:13] Jimi: Um, and that's all you need, and it gives you this you get this like light just like almost shining on Eva because you're like, you're someone to watch now.

[1:09:23] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:09:24] Jimi: And it's like anything she does after that, you always kind of remember how you got there.

[1:09:30] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:09:31] Jimi: I do huh.

[1:09:33] Tommy: The question I have is like this is maybe the one moment where we see Ava Perón step on someone else.

[1:09:42] Jimi: There are assumptions throughout, right?

[1:09:44] Tommy: But explicitly, we don't really see Ava pushing anyone else aside.

[1:09:50] Jimi: We see plenty of the male dominated world pushing other people aside.

[1:09:56] Tommy: Like there's whole musical numbers centered around it, right?

[1:10:01] Jimi: And so I wonder if that's to me that reads as like this is the world.

[1:10:08] Tommy: Pete like we live in a world where everyone's shitty to each other.

[1:10:11] Jimi: And I don't know.

[1:10:13] Tommy: Somehow that lessens it for me in this world specifically.

[1:10:17] Jimi: For me, I'm like, this is the thing that makes you realize that she's a bad person because she doesn't push one person aside.

[1:10:26] Tommy: She pushes a whole nation aside.

[1:10:29] Jimi: Do you know what I mean?

[1:10:31] Tommy: Like she stands there on that balcony and laps it up.

[1:10:35] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:10:36] Tommy: But while she's enjoying the fruits of everything.

[1:10:40] Jimi: She's not, do you know what I mean?

[1:10:41] Tommy: She's doing it, she's only doing it for her own selfish gain.

[1:10:46] Jimi: The actress hasn't learned the lines you like to hear.

[1:10:48] Tommy: She's sad for a country, sad to be defeated by her own weak body.

[1:10:51] Jimi: I want to tell the people of Argentina I've decided I should decline all of the honors and titles you've pressed me to take.

[1:10:58] Tommy: For I'm contented to let me simply go on as the woman who brings her people to the heart of Perón.

[1:11:05] Jimi: Yeah, that's when she's about to die, and she's been forced to make that statement.

[1:11:11] Tommy: But that's the whole point.

[1:11:13] Jimi: Like that is the story.

[1:11:14] Tommy: She has been forced to make that statement.

[1:11:16] Jimi: She doesn't want to make that statement.

[1:11:17] Tommy: If she could have her way, she would keep going, but she knows she's burnt out, and that's that, and then she goes on to make the apology and lament.

[1:11:26] Jimi: Um no, sorry, the lack of apology in lament.

[1:11:29] Tommy: Um everything she does, she does for pure pure selfish gain.

[1:11:32] Jimi: And it's that it's that kind of idea that it's like it looks wonderful on the outside, and it's like, look at all of these people that you're throwing money at whilst the country is dissolving into a little sinkhole.

[1:11:44] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?

[1:11:45] Jimi: It's the um let them eat cake.

[1:11:49] Tommy: You know?

[1:11:49] Jimi: Yeah, yeah that vibe.

[1:11:51] Tommy: Um, and she is loving because she is exactly where she wants to be.

[1:11:58] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:11:58] Tommy: I don't know.

[1:11:59] Jimi: I've I you know we'll never agree on this, but I do think it is a fascinating conflict.

[1:12:06] Tommy: It speaks uh I hate I hate it also, by the way.

[1:12:13] Jimi: But yeah, it's really really well written music theatre.

[1:12:16] Tommy: I know.

[1:12:17] Jimi: But that's why you hate it.

[1:12:19] Tommy: It's not really well written.

[1:12:20] Jimi: Some of it's so bad.

[1:12:22] Tommy: But a lot of things are bad.

[1:12:24] Jimi: Um but a lot of this is really bad.

[1:12:26] Tommy: No, I c I actually just disagree, and I think you've lost this battle.

[1:12:30] Jimi: Away with you.

[1:12:31] Tommy: That's that's fine.

[1:12:33] Jimi: Before before we leave the music though, yes.

[1:12:36] Tommy: Um do you know the origins of Don't Cry for Me Argentina?

[1:12:40] Jimi: I do not.

[1:12:42] Tommy: So let me find out where he was exactly.

[1:12:45] Tommy: Give me a wee second, I've got up my phone.

[1:12:47] Tommy: So basically, um when Andrew Lloyd Webber came back to Tim Rice being like, No, you can't uh you can't just make this a love story for Ava Perón, she's a horrible person.

[1:13:02] Jimi: Yeah. Um he uh they basically got to work on right, okay. Well, what do we need? And they felt that they needed uh like hook for the show to get that idea and drive it in.

[1:13:08] Tommy: Yeah. Um Andrew Lloyd Webber was actually inspired uh from when he went to see Judy Garland in one of her last things. It was uh she was doing a show called Talk of the Town in what is now the Hippodrome.

[1:13:30] Jimi: Uh-huh. Um, and so yeah, she was near the end, like drug addled, um, like pathetic and very like you know like hashtag Judy Garland. So pitiful. Um and it got to uh so yeah, she showed up nearly an hour late, um, and then when she sang uh Over the Rainbow, the crowd were like screaming at her in like derision, um, throwing stuff at her, uh what she couldn't continue.

[1:14:04] Tommy: Yeah, and she just went into her dressing room. Um and this was the thing that kind of rang true for him. He was like, This is what we need for Eva Perón, this woman who is just put out so much, and yet this uh this song about happiness and that is this that can be used as this moment of triumph.

[1:14:27] Jimi: Right, um, then comes back to bite her in the ass. And so that's what's so nice about the triumph through pity, yeah.

[1:14:34] Tommy: Yeah, and so the last broadcast um that's what makes it so damn tragic because she had this moment in the sun and now she's just been forced to take all that away and decline everything.

[1:14:46] Jimi: And uh great segue.

[1:14:49] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[1:14:50] Jimi: Madonna does it beautifully.

[1:14:52] Tommy: Oh, but it's sad when a lover fed dies, but when we were hot, we were hot.

[1:14:58] Jimi: I know you're not back on the good times we've said.

[1:15:02] Tommy: But they will not die.

[1:15:05] Jimi: There is no one, no one and Tom.

[1:15:08] Tommy: Never has it, never will be a lover.

[1:15:32] Jimi: Okay, we're gonna talk about the movies. Are you in Camp Madonna?

[1:15:36] Tommy: No, no, no, not at all.

[1:15:38] Jimi: Okay, thank god. I was afraid we weren't gonna be friends anymore.

[1:15:40] Tommy: Yeah, exactly. The end.

[1:15:42] Jimi: Um.

[1:15:47] Tommy: No, no, no. Absolutely. The movie sucks. I watched it for the first time for this podcast. Have you seen it before?

[1:15:53] Jimi: No, no, no. This is my first time too. I've been avoiding it.

[1:15:56] Tommy: Um Yeah, like well, as a as like a musical adaptation. It's not bad.

[1:16:03] Jimi: It's not bad.

[1:16:04] Tommy: It's not bad.

[1:16:06] Jimi: As a musical adaptation and as a movie.

[1:16:09] Tommy: Like, if you there are a bunch of like still frames you could take out of this thing that are beauteuuuh. Like, I preferred it to Nine.

[1:16:16] Jimi: Yeah, oh, for sure. Absolutely.

[1:16:18] Tommy: So it's um Madonna and Antonio Banderas.

[1:16:22] Jimi: Uh and whoever played Perón.

[1:16:24] Tommy: Jonathan Price.

[1:16:25] Jimi: Jonathan Price, Nat Mafes, and there's only three characters in the show, so.

[1:16:30] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.

[1:16:31] Jimi: Um, actually, I thought Jonathan Price did quite well.

[1:16:35] Tommy: Um of the three, he did the best.

[1:16:39] Jimi: He's definitely got the best vocal.

[1:16:41] Tommy: Yes.

[1:16:41] Jimi: Uh it just drove me nuts through the whole thing. Everything is like too dubbed.

[1:16:49] Tommy: Like, they'd like similar dubs. Not just Madonna and Banderas, but like random old people.

[1:16:56] Jimi: And you're like, why do you have the voice of a 28-year-old?

[1:16:59] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:16:59] Jimi: Like, this camp.

[1:17:02] Tommy: I think that's a proper sign of the times, though. Because it was night, it was, you know, the 90s.

[1:17:06] Jimi: The night like that and Lloyd Webber's inability to resist putting electronic instruments into his musicals.

[1:17:16] Tommy: Like they like the reorchestrations in the film.

[1:17:20] Jimi: We might not be able to be friends anymore.

[1:17:23] Tommy: Yeah, but I love electro shit.

[1:17:25] Jimi: Like Yeah, it doesn't work for the show.

[1:17:29] Tommy: The reason I love it is just because I'm like, yeah, 80s. Like, do you know what I mean? That's just like I get that it's it's not necessarily.

[1:17:37] Jimi: And that's a stupid reason, and we can get past it.

[1:17:39] Tommy: That's fine. I just like that sound, so I'm like, cool.

[1:17:43] Jimi: Um it was refreshing, it was new.

[1:17:46] Tommy: Um yeah, like you have to again take your hat off to Antonio because he doesn't he does a fine job.

[1:17:57] Jimi: Yeah, this is stuff that is written that Colm Wilkinson, like Javert said.

[1:18:05] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:18:05] Jimi: Like this is hard. Intense stuff.

[1:18:07] Tommy: Well, and too, like, there's all sorts of Hollywood scuttlebutt about this, but the gossip is also that a lot of this musical was also out of Madonna's range.

[1:18:18] Jimi: Um it was taken down.

[1:18:20] Tommy: Yeah, which like the whole thing was shaken down. Just cast singers who can sing your music.

[1:18:28] Jimi: Yep.

[1:18:29] Tommy: Um write it in the sky.

[1:18:31] Jimi: The casting for this show though was a farce.

[1:18:35] Tommy: Like the kind of journey to get this movie made is crazy.

[1:18:38] Jimi: Like, I feel like every director in Hollywood was on it at one point.

[1:18:42] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:18:42] Jimi: Um the the closest person who was kind of like second, I guess, uh, was Meryl Streep.

[1:18:49] Tommy: And apparently she knocked it out of the park.

[1:18:52] Jimi: I'm sure she did.

[1:18:53] Tommy: That's but the thing is, well, initially, um initially, I think Tim Rice, the producer and the original director, wanted Elaine Paige, which makes total sense.

[1:19:06] Jimi: Would have been a more accurate decision.

[1:19:07] Tommy: Because she can sing it.

[1:19:09] Jimi: Um I think just time got away from them, and she would just wasn't involved anymore.

[1:19:16] Tommy: And then once Madonna kind of came into the conversation.

[1:19:20] Jimi: And Madonna was really passionate about herself being a part of it, right?

[1:19:23] Tommy: Yeah, absolutely.

[1:19:25] Jimi: Um, she showed up in costume to her first audition.

[1:19:29] Tommy: Uh uh.

[1:19:32] Jimi: Which is like fair, but I'm having I'm having smash flashbacks.

[1:19:35] Tommy: Can you call those smashbacks?

[1:19:37] Jimi: Um absolutely can.

[1:19:40] Tommy: We have quite a term here.

[1:19:42] Jimi: Fabulous.

[1:19:42] Tommy: Um by the way, a lot of people do that.

[1:19:44] Jimi: That's that's quite a common thing.

[1:19:46] Tommy: Don't do that.

[1:19:47] Jimi: Um a lot of these people get jobs though, so I hate the industry.

[1:19:53] Tommy: Um so yeah, so no, she can she she isn't singing the score, in my opinion.

[1:20:00] Jimi: No, because uh actually one of the things, and just to talk about how great the music is again, um, one of the things uh I love about it.

[1:20:09] Tommy: So Patti LuPone, for example, fabulous.

[1:20:12] Jimi: She's no unstoppable.

[1:20:14] Tommy: She is.

[1:20:15] Jimi: Um, but she's no stranger to saying how she thinks Andrew Lloyd Webber's uh absolute bastard who hates women because he wrote Evita like this, um, and how it can't she can't sing it, no one can sing it.

[1:20:28] Tommy: No one can't sing it.

[1:20:30] Jimi: Uh it's damaging and dangerous, etc. etc.

[1:20:34] Tommy: Um, I mean, I think a lot of that's Patti being Patti.

[1:20:38] Jimi: Also, like, love Patti LuPone. Have you seen the subtitled version of her singing Love Cornosy?

[1:20:44] Tommy: Of course, great.

[1:20:44] Jimi: It'll be in the show notes because it's required viewing.

[1:20:47] Tommy: Absolutely.

[1:20:47] Jimi: It's great.

[1:20:48] Tommy: Um, but yeah, that that's like prime Patti as well.

[1:20:53] Jimi: Oh yeah, it's like cry Patti.

[1:20:55] Tommy: Um I think she's incredible.

[1:20:56] Jimi: She's the that's the cast recording I listen to the most.

[1:20:58] Tommy: Of course, followed closely behind by Eleanor.

[1:21:01] Jimi: Sorry, Elaine. I'm just not that into you.

[1:21:04] Tommy: Um but what was I saying?

[1:21:07] Jimi: Yeah, I think writing so he writes it right in the tessitura of the female voice, um, and it's uh it is diff it is difficult, and it he and I don't know whether this was Patti or whether this was him, it's him or the musical director, but someone uh has made her sing it as a belt.

[1:21:32] Tommy: I think it's Patti because it's Patti.

[1:21:35] Jimi: Um but ba ba but I think it works so well because what it does is creates this atmosphere, this vibe of like desperation and intensity, yeah, and it's like this relentless sound, yeah, um, which drives this plot forward, like it really, really does.

[1:21:57] Tommy: A lot of the time it's not nice, it's not like a nice listen.

[1:22:00] Jimi: No, if you think of something it's not a pure tone, yeah.

[1:22:03] Tommy: Yeah, if you think of something like uh good Nine and thank you, whoever, um, when they get into their clashy harmony, yeah, it's sensational because it is it's that like these two forces, yeah, like fighting, and she is right there on a it is incredible.

[1:22:24] Jimi: Yeah, but I do I don't I don't want to get too far past this because it does as much as we joke about me not liking Andrew Lloyd Webber, it is one of the things that burns me to the core about him is that he does not take his singers into account, and like that's a thing to do to take your singers into account.

[1:22:42] Tommy: Like Sondheim jokes all the time about how Send in the Clowns is his bizarre, somehow most popular piece of music, and he wrote it for Judi Dench specifically because she had problems singing, and that's why it is structured the way it is.

[1:23:00] Jimi: Like you can find interviews where Stephen Sondheim goes, Isn't it rich? Breathe, breathe, aren't we a pair? Breathe, yeah, breathe.

[1:23:11] Tommy: Like it's a song written so that you can sing it.

[1:23:16] Jimi: And I I find it such a douchey artistic move to be like, well, this is the music, and the only way to express the art is through the music.

[1:23:26] Tommy: And if you can't do the music, then you can't do the art.

[1:23:29] Jimi: Like you fundamentally disagree.

[1:23:33] Tommy: Because without that, you don't get any creativity.

[1:23:38] Jimi: Everything is just safely within the realms of a person's voice.

[1:23:42] Tommy: And then how do you stretch people?

[1:23:43] Jimi: Because the thing is, you can stretch people, yeah.

[1:23:46] Tommy: At the end of the day, she still sang it.

[1:23:48] Jimi: Elena Rogers sings the fuck out of it.

[1:23:50] Tommy: Like people can sing it, but like traditionally, so much so that it's entered into Urban Legend, people don't play Evita eight times a week.

[1:23:59] Jimi: Like, it's one of the only lead roles with a built-in second where like your your understudy is assumed to go on part of the time because singing it all week is impossible.

[1:24:10] Tommy: But if we look at something like opera, you have a complete but you have a completely similar vibe there.

[1:24:19] Jimi: And he wrote this as an as an opera.

[1:24:21] Tommy: And I think like it it gets close to being in that world.

[1:24:26] Jimi: You also just need to look at something like Elphaba.

[1:24:29] Tommy: Like Yeah.

[1:24:30] Jimi: Which also, like Stephen Schwartz has similar not bringing the key down.

[1:24:37] Tommy: Yeah, but we're looking at two of the most uh iconic and important men in musical theater.

[1:24:42] Jimi: Yes, like but but I but would defying gravity be any less impactful if the first time you heard it it was a whole step lower?

[1:24:51] Tommy: Um potentially.

[1:24:52] Jimi: I don't know.

[1:24:52] Tommy: I've never heard it a whole step lower.

[1:24:54] Jimi: Right, but if you had never heard the whole step higher, no one would know.

[1:24:59] Tommy: But what I would say.

[1:25:01] Jimi: No, you would because someone would cover it a whole step higher and be like, and it'd be fine.

[1:25:07] Tommy: But what I would say is with Evita, uh huh, it's been taken down however many steps from Madonna, and it's not as impressive.

[1:25:15] Jimi: That's true.

[1:25:15] Tommy: I guess I am speaking outside both ends of my ass.

[1:25:18] Jimi: Like it's it's I it I just think it's needed, it is totally necessary.

[1:25:23] Tommy: It's hard, it is extremely hard, and like the character doesn't stop singing.

[1:25:28] Jimi: Um ever.

[1:25:29] Tommy: The whole shop that's really really challenging.

[1:25:32] Jimi: Um if if it takes that you know the actor has to take a couple of nights off in order to give this performance, so kind of so be it.

[1:25:41] Tommy: Like what you get is this really interesting piece of art and vocal Olympics.

[1:25:45] Jimi: Yeah, I just I'm into I do think this is a different in our assumptions, but I'm not in true into vocal Olympics at the you know, as a trade-off for good storytelling.

[1:25:58] Tommy: And I think I don't think it quite because they have taken steps to avoid that, but I think it it peters on that edge, at least in its writing.

[1:26:06] Jimi: Like this would be I th I think it might just be Patti being Patti and being very vocal because uh certainly I've not read anything.

[1:26:14] Tommy: Please listeners send me something.

[1:26:17] Jimi: Um I've not necessarily gone out and looked for this, but I've not seen Elaine Page be like this is the hardest, you know.

[1:26:22] Tommy: I mean, this ruined my life.

[1:26:24] Jimi: I was depressed after doing like, and I'm not taking away from Patti's experience here, like it was really tougher, that's absolutely fine.

[1:26:33] Tommy: And um and also she has plenty of reason now to shit talk Andrew Lloyd Webber every second she gets.

[1:26:39] Jimi: So you 100% exact exactly.

[1:26:42] Tommy: Um like I don't know, it's still like is she's true, she still did it.

[1:26:51] Jimi: And it's I would uh I mean I don't think you'd disagree, but it I think Patti's performance is still the definitive performance of this.

[1:26:57] Tommy: That's the one I always will listen to because of that, because it is there on our voice, because it has that break.

[1:27:03] Jimi: Um fact to pull out uh a story that we have both experienced when we chatted to Brittany Ashford, yeah, um uh during Comet, and she said that Dave who writes a lot of music for her specifically, always writes in that part of her voice that he she hates singing in because it creates this vulnerable sound.

[1:27:29] Jimi: Like that's just that the like uh ballet choreographers won't panic about their uh prima ballerina having to exert themselves because they know they can.

[1:27:46] Tommy: Yeah um and they know that when they do they'll give the performance of a lifetime.

[1:27:51] Jimi: Yeah, I don't know. I find this such a touchy subject. Like all these things, like pushing your physical boundaries for a performance. Like there's plenty of stories of like Ben Platt like pushing himself too far during T-Raven Hansen, yeah. Um, you know, there's all sorts of stories which always like drive me nuts and really hit me hard, like um of like crappy fight choreographers or like bad intimacy choreography that happens in shows that like pushes these boundaries, and I get super nervous and prickly about these things because I think like there's definitely times when I particularly with the intimacy stuff, yeah, it doesn't get handled well at all.

[1:28:30] Tommy: But I feel like this is a diff this is a different thing.

[1:28:32] Jimi: Yeah, I d I I wanna like where do you draw the line? Because we're just talking about using our bodies to perform a thing. And certainly you should push yourself and challenge yourself, but like i if you're needing to get throat shots every night to complete your performance.

[1:28:48] Tommy: She wasn't.

[1:28:49] Jimi: Are you sure?

[1:28:50] Tommy: I'm pretty sure, yeah. I don't think especially I don't think that was a a big thing there because nothing had been written like this.

[1:28:57] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:28:58] Tommy: You know.

[1:28:59] Jimi: I don't know. It makes it make a maximum. I I do, I I do understand it, but I just feel like uh and it is Controv, but good art takes risks.

[1:29:11] Tommy: Yeah, true. Good art takes risks.

[1:29:12] Jimi: Um I d I d I haven't heard her say it, but I've never heard her say that she regrets doing it.

[1:29:20] Tommy: True.

[1:29:21] Jimi: What's her most popular role?

[1:29:23] Tommy: She won her Tony.

[1:29:25] Jimi: Do you think she regrets it.

[1:29:26] Tommy: I don't think she regrets her most popular role. I I just really hope I'd hope that she didn't.

[1:29:30] Jimi: I can understand why she would hate it.

[1:29:32] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:29:33] Jimi: So why she really wouldn't enjoy it. But um I'd be sad if she like feels feels damaged by it emotionally or physically.

[1:29:44] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:29:45] Jimi: Yeah. Um I guess just because it her performance means a lot to me, so I'd be like, oh yeah.

[1:29:50] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:29:51] Jimi: Uh no, that's so that's that's my thoughts there.

[1:29:55] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:29:55] Jimi: Um but Elena Rogers nails it.

[1:29:58] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:29:59] Jimi: I think she said, I'll need to try and find this interview because I read it a while ago. Um I think she said that uh the reason why Patty struggled so much is because she's American.

[1:30:14] Tommy: Um and it's to do with like where she speaks.

[1:30:17] Jimi: Oh, yeah.

[1:30:18] Tommy: It's kind of it's kind of nonsense.

[1:30:20] Jimi: Uh no, I'll believe that. We'll bring up the subtitled version again of Patty Lapone singing.

[1:30:26] Tommy: No, but then like you know, she doesn't speak up here, she's not speaking up in her high voice. She speaks down here, and she is Yeah, one I'm sure she makes it very forward. It's Patty Lapone, and she drives all of her fouls real wide and like hammers it home like a sledgehammer.

[1:30:39] Tommy: No, yeah. Totally.

[1:30:40] Jimi: And so uh what Elena Rogers was basically saying, like, it's much easier if you're speaking up here, but like Elaine Page does not speak up here as well, but she was fine.

[1:30:49] Tommy: So I I do think this is the opportune moment to transition into talking about casting this show, Jeremy.

[1:30:57] Jimi: Yes.

[1:31:00] Tommy: And magic race live on face time. Excitement.

[1:31:05] Jimi: I came from the people. They need to adorn me. The Christian beyond me. From my head to my toes. I need to be dazzling. I want to be rained. I must have excitement. And some aside. I'm left profty. It's Michael, you sell me. Some lucky about me. And I shall be rained. I need that respect.

[1:31:41] Tommy: And so do I. How do you cast this show?

[1:31:46] Jimi: Well, I think it's really tricky. Um yeah. And the thing is as well, I'm almost quite hesitant to go on about it because I feel like we talked about it two podcasts ago.

[1:31:56] Tommy: That's true.

[1:31:56] Jimi: This exact same conversation. And I think some of the exact same incidents as well.

[1:32:01] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:32:02] Jimi: Uh so I d I I it's one of those things. We didn't get any answers then.

[1:32:08] Tommy: No.

[1:32:09] Jimi: I can't see as getting any answers now. So the thing that like colors it for me is this is a a Euro musical bit written by white Europeans casting basically white Europeans as Argentinian roles in its initial production. Um and like does kind of lean into some of that like West Side story discussion we talked about.

[1:32:26] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:32:31] Jimi: Like, can you ever do a racially appropriate casting of this? Um and I've seen articles, and we'll put one in the show notes, that say things like, any production of a Vita will always be whitewashed, no matter how hard you try. Um, part like the social justice person person in me is like, yeah, and the person in me who likes a Vita is like, but I like Avita and I want to hear it again.

[1:33:00] Tommy: Um, this this controversy hit Chicago while I was there super hard. There was we talked about it, um North Shore Music Theater. Um did a like pretty much completely non Latinx production of Evita and people raised hell over it, rightly so. Um and there is there's this quote here, which I don't think I'll read the entire thing about. Um, but Bill Haney, the artistic director, said this thing that I wanna I'm I'm reserving my opinion about it because I want to know what you think. Um but he said when approached with this controversy of casting a very white woman as a Vita, saying that there's no part in the story uh that speaks to events happening to her, Avita, or not happening to her because of her race, nor are her actions motivated motivated by her race.

[1:33:48] Jimi: Um and he brings up Maria Von Trapp and a couple other people in musicals who are like they're from musicals where nationality and race aren't a thing, so if the race isn't part of a narrative, the race doesn't need to be part of the casting.

[1:34:08] Tommy: Yeah, not hugely.

[1:34:09] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:34:09] Jimi: Uh but I think it's um it's uh solution that a lot of people offer.

[1:34:10] Jimi: This seemed like an this is something we haven't talked about.

[1:34:15] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:34:16] Jimi: For a lot of shows. The the time that I've heard it the most actually was when what was the instance of it? It was a Billy Elliott.

[1:34:27] Tommy: Mm hmm.

[1:34:27] Jimi: One of the bellies was black.

[1:34:30] Tommy: Okay.

[1:34:30] Jimi: Um his mum was white. Uh and there was naturally his Britain, there was outcry.

[1:34:34] Tommy: Right.

[1:34:38] Jimi: Um, because that doesn't make any sense.

[1:34:41] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:34:41] Jimi: Um, and they were like, no, we're just casting completely colorblind like. Like I mean, that's how the uh Andy Miantis Tommy in Denver, um, mom and dad to Tommy were black and white, of course. Young Tommy was white, middle Tommy was black, and then Andy Meantis was white.

[1:34:57] Tommy: Yeah, which certainly drew gasps from the Denver audience. I was like, God, uh everyone get over it.

[1:35:04] Jimi: Um I've heard so I've heard it from that respect of like uh it it it doesn't it doesn't matter what race that we're talking about, this part of the story.

[1:35:14] Tommy: Yeah um so what I think com kinda comes just in here though is just uh the classic white privilege thing. Like it's not our none of these are stories to tell. Like um uh you know when Yeah, it's it's the the thing is is like we're gonna end up not being able to do anything.

[1:35:40] Tommy: Right.

[1:35:40] Jimi: Um and and that's tricky too. But I d I don't know, I just feel like um So for example that take the the recent Broadway. You've got Elena, you've got Ricky Martin, yeah.

[1:35:57] Tommy: Certainly Latinx in their own way, yeah.

[1:35:59] Jimi: Yep, and then you've got Michael Severis.

[1:36:02] Tommy: Not uh

[1:36:02] Jimi: So like this is the question then. you hit Michael Severus and you're like, oh, is Michael you suddenly ask the question Is Michael Severus Latino? Does he identify as Latino? And this is where these things become like super multifaceted super quickly. A lot of the very important and correct responses to Bill Haney, the um the artistic director of North Strown Music Theatre, first off started by saying, Well, hold on, Latinx is not a race, it is a culture because people identify that way and come from all sorts of different countries, and like already the idea of race is kind of problematic to begin with.

[1:36:44] Tommy: Um and so already we're in problematic territory here.

[1:36:49] Jimi: And so then a lot of the other discussions from Latino and Latina actors started talking about like even if Evita is this white person's dish discussion of being Latin, whatever. Um, you know, how however you want to phrase that, um then it is important that someone with that background who are or who identifies as having that background can portray that story, especially in an industry where those people are underrepresented.

[1:37:24] Tommy: Um and common in all these stories, and why we're struggling to look up Michael Severus, um fabulous. Um, is like there is a self-identification there of like, is this your culture? Um, is this something that you consider a part of who you are, which also is a whole nother can of worms. Um you know, and I do I do think there is an important and difficult to talk about worm of truth in your statement that like we're never gonna be able to do anything if we go too far down this path.

[1:38:04] Tommy: But on the other hand, we can't completely ignore this.

[1:38:07] Jimi: Um Yeah, not at all. Um, and but it's it it I mean like why should it why should it be different for Latin American people?

[1:38:21] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:38:22] Jimi: Like why should that be the one that you ignore what makes right, yeah. But like, you know, the are you gonna start protesting productions of Brigadoon?

[1:38:35] Tommy: Um, but I g again I'm not my race isn't Scottish.

[1:38:41] Jimi: Okay.

[1:38:42] Tommy: But your culture is like this this is the and like this is this is a whataboutism argument, so like it already is losing its validity. But it is an interesting thought experiment to be like where, you know, is it just maybe that's it. Maybe it's in the underrepresented, and like as long as you are doing things to bring up the underrepresented, like casting the black kid as medium Tommy and Tommy, or you know, uh what's is it Kristoff in Frozen? Um who you know, like I pardon my ignorance, but I don't think there are too many black people in Scanda Switzer Norway in Frozen Time.

[1:39:24] Jimi: Um, and just kind of diving past that and that being fine and okay because the place is called Arendale, by the way. Thank you.

[1:39:31] Tommy: Skanda Switzer Norway.

[1:39:33] Jimi: Um the like airing on the side of inclusivity versus exclusivity. Um being aware of our biases, being open to like confronting our biases, like maybe that's the solution. Living in the mess. It like acknowledging the mess as opposed to just hand waving it, which I think a lot m too many artistic directors and directors, especially with a Vita.

[1:39:59] Tommy: Um, like this year this year uh it hit North Shore Musical Theater um there were like four or five regional productions that all had the same specific problem with a Vita like casting a bunch of white actors yeah um and like read online once or twice you know stay up with this sort of stuff if you're trying if you're doing the research you should be doing to be accurate in your direction historically you should also be doing the research you should be doing to be accurate in your direction contemporarily.

[1:40:29] Jimi: Yep and sensitively yeah um I guess like the the solution we kind of came to with heights wasn't a solution the closest thing to anything that we could get sense of um was be as diverse as possible like if you can't go whole hog be as diverse as possible and promote that yeah um yeah yeah that's probably about it but it's still hard you know it's I think it'll be a I'm interested to watch the industry continue to grapple with it for like the next decade at least good luck in seeing anything changing.

[1:41:09] Tommy: Yeah especially in the moment yeah especially at the moment um the other tricky one is what what I'd worry about is so we have uh we have a race problem obviously to do with writers yeah um and a huge dearth of writers of color yeah.

[1:41:33] Jimi: What I would worry about is that people for fear of getting backlash stop writing your Candra Nebs, for example, your Android Webbers, your Tim Rice, for example, stop using their position of power to tell these underrepresented stories.

[1:41:52] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:42:05] Jimi: And then we lose sight of the world.

[1:42:08] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:42:08] Jimi: Because fighting that fight, fighting the writing side of things, yeah, that isn't visible.

[1:42:17] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:42:17] Jimi: Right.

[1:42:18] Tommy: You don't see that side of things, you don't see composers.

[1:42:21] Jimi: Right.

[1:42:22] Tommy: But I do think this is a contemporary problem.

[1:42:26] Jimi: Like, I don't I can't think of times in the past where we called out authors for like, you know, writing about histories that they don't know, but we are entering that world.

[1:42:35] Tommy: Um, no, you know, for better or for worse.

[1:42:37] Jimi: I don't know if it's for better or for worse.

[1:42:39] Tommy: Um, but I agree.

[1:42:43] Jimi: I see that as a huge future problem.

[1:42:44] Tommy: Like, yeah, if you only write what you know, we live in a boring world.

[1:42:48] Jimi: Um, and obviously the solution there is well, pave the way for writers of colour, yeah.

[1:42:55] Tommy: But at the moment, the kind of world that's fostered for musical theatre, yeah, is a white world.

[1:43:04] Jimi: Do you know what I mean? Like that is from a very early age.

[1:43:07] Tommy: Your responsibility becomes like bring someone up the ladder with you.

[1:43:10] Jimi: Like let Lynn Manuel Miranda write the Spanish lyrics for the revival of West Side Story.

[1:43:18] Tommy: Like do your research, bring the people into the world that are going to inform the story, make it authentic, make it a part of whatever you're not.

[1:43:27] Jimi: And if you reach the point where you're out of your bailiwick, like throw up your pen and give it to someone else.

[1:43:32] Tommy: Um co-list them, whatever.

[1:43:35] Jimi: Do that.

[1:43:36] Tommy: Um which that I like that's powerful.

[1:43:41] Jimi: And then shine a spotlight on it.

[1:43:43] Tommy: Like make don't let that sort of thing hide in the shadows.

[1:43:47] Jimi: Um, even like if we're talking about the revival of Once on This Island and all the work the artistic team did to like go to you know places they're not from and do the research that they need to do.

[1:44:01] Tommy: Yeah, um, that's important.

[1:44:03] Jimi: Even if it's not their specific story, they're bringing someone else's authentic story to the stage.

[1:44:09] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:44:10] Jimi: As best they can.

[1:44:11] Tommy: Yeah, totally.

[1:44:12] Jimi: And I think that's all we really can do at the moment.

[1:44:15] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:44:16] Jimi: Until I don't know, a whole world's attitude changes.

[1:44:20] Tommy: Yeah, sunshine and rainbows, and you know, when musical theater saves the world.

[1:44:24] Jimi: Rainbows.

[1:44:25] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:44:26] Jimi: Evita.

[1:44:27] Tommy: We could do a tour of one.

[1:44:30] Jimi: Brought it back around.

[1:44:31] Tommy: Totally intentional to.

[1:44:33] Jimi: Don't rub it in.

[1:44:34] Tommy: I just feel like to conclude to conclude on Evita.

[1:44:38] Jimi: Um, you know, we're not finished in the Adrian Weber shows.

[1:44:42] Tommy: Um unfortunately.

[1:44:44] Jimi: Uh-huh.

[1:44:45] Tommy: But I think you need to you need to um you need to try.

[1:44:45] Jimi: You need to try here to be an objective musical theater fan.

[1:44:58] Tommy: Because I feel like you hate cats so much that it's targe your view on everything else.

[1:45:08] Jimi: I like how at the beginning I assumed you were talking to like you, the audience, and then halfway through I realized you were talking to you, me.

[1:45:16] Tommy: I was directly talking to you.

[1:45:18] Jimi: Because it's really tricky.

[1:45:20] Tommy: It's tricky because um I feel like it's a shame because you're then missing out on some really great artistry.

[1:45:27] Jimi: I do up the wall.

[1:45:29] Tommy: I do I do very much enjoy Evita.

[1:45:32] Jimi: Can I tell you?

[1:45:33] Tommy: We so we did Evita in college.

[1:45:36] Jimi: I was my sophomore year, so it was part of the, you know, everyone had their own jokes, because we all had seen it.

[1:45:41] Tommy: Um I had this friend who had a proclivity to like get mildly or majorly intoxicated in places where he didn't know where he was, and then panickedly call one in our friend group to be like, I don't know where I am. Will you help me get home?

[1:46:00] Jimi: There was one day he called us and he said, I'm at the beach.

[1:46:03] Tommy: My college was in central Illinois. There's no water for hundreds of miles.

[1:46:08] Jimi: How could you be at the beach?

[1:46:09] Tommy: Turns out he was in a sandbox outside of a scuba dive store.

[1:46:13] Jimi: Um we walked him home.

[1:46:16] Tommy: It was fine.

[1:46:17] Jimi: And the way to get to his apartment, you climb up this staircase at the outside of his apartment, which has like a door and a little balcony, and like we're finally there.

[1:46:25] Tommy: We like stumbled all the way home, we got him there.

[1:46:27] Jimi: He walks up the staircase, he turns with his house key in his hand and goes, I'm Evita, and throws the key somewhere into the darkness of the bushes of the lawn.

[1:46:42] Tommy: And we had to spend like another hour and a half finding his key because he was Evita.

[1:46:47] Jimi: That's my experience with Evita.

[1:46:50] Tommy: Oh my gosh.

[1:46:51] Jimi: I ca that would make me hate it.

[1:46:54] Tommy: I get it now.

[1:46:55] Jimi: This is actually the root of all of your hate for Andrew Lloyd Webber.

[1:46:58] Tommy: That's where it started.

[1:46:59] Jimi: That was the seed.

[1:47:01] Tommy: Interactive.

[1:47:02] Jimi: Searching for keys.

[1:47:04] Tommy: 2 a.m.

[1:47:05] Jimi: Um fun story speaking about uh the balcony.

[1:47:10] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[1:47:11] Jimi: Uh to end in a Patti LuPone triumph moment.

[1:47:14] Tommy: Yes.

[1:47:15] Jimi: Um so obviously Elaine Paige had originated it.

[1:47:18] Tommy: And they were really trying to recreate Elaine Paige's performance within Patti LuPone.

[1:47:24] Jimi: Don't do that.

[1:47:25] Tommy: Um so the arms, the iconic arms.

[1:47:30] Jimi: Iconic arms, yeah.

[1:47:36] Tommy: Um the hands pass her forward.

[1:47:40] Jimi: Uh that's what Elaine did.

[1:47:40] Tommy: That's what Eva Perón did quite a lot.

[1:47:46] Jimi: Um they're doing some photo shoots for the promo.

[1:47:52] Tommy: And they're like, uh Patti, you just do the arms the way that Elaine did them was just like this.

[1:47:58] Jimi: She was like, that's not how I do my arms. I do my arms like this, and she's she stretches them straight out.

[1:48:05] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[1:48:06] Jimi: Um they obviously have a big back and forth about their naturally.

[1:48:12] Tommy: Um Patti returns to them with a photo of Eva Perón arms fully stretched out.

[1:48:22] Jimi: And that's the image that they used.

[1:48:25] Tommy: And I think, well done, Pat.

[1:48:27] Jimi: It's what they call getting Patti LuPone.

[1:48:31] Tommy: You just got Patti LuPone.

[1:48:35] Jimi: Was that you?

[1:48:36] Tommy: Did you make that video?

[1:48:37] Jimi: We don't need to talk about it, it's fine.

[1:48:39] Tommy: Was it you?

[1:48:41] Jimi: Yes.

[1:48:42] Tommy: Oh.

[1:48:47] Jimi: That thing got suppressive though.

[1:48:48] Tommy: That was just uh head.

[1:48:51] Jimi: Juilliard graduate Patti LuPone, one of my musical videos.

[1:48:56] Tommy: People still quote that.

[1:49:00] Jimi: That's not something you're gonna live down.

[1:49:02] Tommy: I live a weird existence.

[1:49:03] Jimi: You do.

[1:49:04] Tommy: Very well shot though.

[1:49:05] Jimi: Very impressive.

[1:49:06] Tommy: Thank you.

[1:49:06] Jimi: Thank you.

[1:49:07] Tommy: I don't think you get enough plotters for it.

[1:49:08] Jimi: It took me a long time alone in my apartment.

[1:49:11] Tommy: Yep.

[1:49:12] Jimi: More so than any other of your videos, I imagine.

[1:49:15] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:49:16] Jimi: I don't know.

[1:49:16] Tommy: I don't know if I want to.

[1:49:19] Jimi: Yeah, a little bit.

[1:49:20] Tommy: If we're talking about like filming time, most of the time I'd just be like, ah, this doesn't need to film. I'll just put an animated graphic over it. It's fine.

[1:49:20] Jimi: Most of the time I just don't make videos now, so that's fine, me neither.

[1:49:36] Tommy: Hey, look at us.

[1:49:37] Jimi: YouTube's crap now.

[1:49:38] Tommy: YouTube's our fault.

[1:49:40] Jimi: It was a little crap now.

[1:49:41] Tommy: Yeah, it's good.

[1:49:42] Jimi: After we left, the whole platform went down the door.

[1:49:47] Tommy: She had her moments.

[1:49:50] Jimi: She had some spa.

[1:49:53] Tommy: Best show in town was the crowd.

[1:49:57] Jimi: Outside the Casa Rosada.

[1:50:09] Tommy: About beware your ambition.

[1:50:14] Jimi: Screw the middle classes.

[1:50:16] Tommy: I will never accept them.

[1:50:17] Jimi: And they will never deny me anything again.

[1:50:20] Tommy: My father's other family were middle class, and we were kept out of sight, hidden from view.

[1:50:34] Jimi: It seems crazy, but you must believe.

[1:50:42] Tommy: Please forgive me if I seem naive.

[1:50:46] Jimi: I would never want to force your hand, but please understand.

[1:51:30] Tommy: So young the instant queen, a rich, beautiful thing, of all the talents crossed between a fantasy of the bedroom and the same.

[1:52:04] Jimi: She's not coming back to you.

[1:52:17] Tommy: Quinn is there, you're taking it brewer.

[1:52:19] Jimi: She's not coming back to you.

[1:52:22] Tommy: That Jimmy was Evita.

[1:52:26] Jimi: I had a great time.

[1:52:28] Tommy: The chorus when they sing Don't Cry for Me, Argentina at the gay bar in Chicago is Don't Cry for Me, I'm a Diva.

[1:52:37] Jimi: The truth is I have no talent.

[1:52:41] Tommy: All through the eighties, you bought my LPs.

[1:52:44] Jimi: What were you sink thinking?

[1:52:47] Tommy: You silly.

[1:52:48] Jimi: And then they say a derogatory word meaning gay men.

[1:52:52] Tommy: It's very funny.

[1:52:53] Jimi: Brilliant.

[1:52:54] Tommy: That's funny.

[1:52:55] Jimi: And like the ending.

[1:52:56] Tommy: And then she she says, Have I said too much?

[1:52:58] Jimi: And everyone goes, Yes!

[1:53:02] Tommy: No, like, actually, she has some moments where I'm like, that was quite impressive, Madonna.

[1:53:08] Jimi: Well, I'm glad you feel that way.

[1:53:09] Tommy: But they're not singing moments.

[1:53:12] Jimi: No.

[1:53:12] Tommy: They're not moments.

[1:53:13] Jimi: I thought her speech was really good.

[1:53:15] Tommy: Okay.

[1:53:17] Jimi: I might have been I might have been asleep by then.

[1:53:20] Tommy: It was quite good as well.

[1:53:21] Jimi: But that's fair.

[1:53:23] Tommy: Anyway.

[1:53:24] Jimi: Um hey.

[1:53:26] Tommy: Hey, I got equipment for you.

[1:53:28] Jimi: I'm ready.

[1:53:29] Tommy: This musical shares its poster title font with Nirvana's album covers.

[1:53:36] Jimi: Did I say that right? Nirvana?

[1:53:38] Tommy: Nirvana.

[1:53:39] Jimi: Can you sing me a Nirvana song?

[1:53:42] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:53:43] Jimi: Um we are Nirvana.

[1:53:47] Tommy: This is our Nirvana song.

[1:53:49] Jimi: Which is actually, we're not gonna take it, which is by the who, but you know, I was I was getting close ish in pop mu never mind.

[1:53:57] Tommy: Digging my hole deeper.

[1:54:00] Jimi: I'm just not gonna see anything anymore.

[1:54:04] Tommy: If you would like to get in touch with us, you absolutely can, and please do.

[1:54:08] Jimi: Come and find me over on Twitter. I'm at Asin Hendrix.

[1:54:10] Tommy: And I'm Musical Mash on Twitter, Musical Theatre Mash on YouTube, or check out our show Twitter at Jim and Tomic or our website, Jim and Tomic.com.

[1:54:20] Jimi: It has a link to our Reddit discussion where we'll be chatting up a storm about Evita.

[1:54:24] Tommy: Um, and it also has a link to our Patreon where you can support us if you would like.

[1:54:30] Jimi: And we thank all our current Patreons, patrons, by the way.

[1:54:35] Tommy: We absolutely do.

[1:54:36] Jimi: Yeah, thank you guys so much.

[1:54:37] Tommy: You guys rock.

[1:54:38] Jimi: We're and and in general, we're super every time we start the show before Jimmy and I start recording, we just talk about how excited we are about hearing new people who are listening to this and like you know, be like, oh, I just discovered this thing, or oh, I've been listening to this forever.

[1:54:52] Tommy: Like, it really does bring us a lot of joy that people out there who listen to this.

[1:54:58] Jimi: Like, I genuinely like I can't describe how often I refresh the Reddit page.

[1:55:03] Tommy: Like, has anyone new out of the comment?

[1:55:05] Jimi: No.

[1:55:06] Tommy: I imagine you do a similar thing.

[1:55:08] Jimi: I do.

[1:55:09] Tommy: I don't reply, but I do but you're always watching.

[1:55:13] Jimi: We're always watching just like Evita Perón.

[1:55:18] Tommy: Right.

[1:55:19] Jimi: I do reply though. So come and say things.

[1:55:22] Tommy: I wish you to picture my face painted poorly in like a 1980s style in a giant poster on the side of a building, like smiling a little bit with really red lipstick and like bleach blonde hair.

[1:55:35] Jimi: Always watching.

[1:55:37] Tommy: Like Evita Perón.

[1:55:41] Jimi: Jimmy doesn't understand.

[1:55:42] Tommy: That's fine.

[1:55:43] Jimi: What was that interaction that we just had there?

[1:55:45] Tommy: It's just it's just, you know, I'm always watching.

[1:55:45] Jimi: Like Evita Perón as a giant poster.

[1:55:50] Tommy: It's fine.

[1:55:51] Jimi: Someone else will understand.

[1:55:53] Tommy: We'll see you next week.

[1:55:56] Jimi: Bye bye.

[1:56:09] Tommy: What do you mean?

[1:56:10] Jimi: Do you mean like as an Ava?

[1:56:13] Tommy: Oh, the posters of Evita that are painted on the walls with like her big face.

[1:56:17] Jimi: She's like staring down at everyone.

[1:56:19] Tommy: Why did you say the 80s?

[1:56:21] Jimi: Because that's when.

[1:56:23] Tommy: I don't know.

[1:56:24] Jimi: The 40s?

[1:56:26] Tommy: Yeah, and it came out in the late 70s, which is basically the 80s.

[1:56:31] Jimi: Yeah, but the posters weren't.

[1:56:36] Tommy: Don't dive into my metaphors too deep.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred