Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Happy Hour #69 (Side 1): StarPodcast - ‘Ghost Quartet’

Discuss on Reddit ➤ Support the Show ➤ We don’t even know how to begin, but we certainly know that we are here and discussing Dave Malloy’s spookily exquisite song-cycle, ‘Ghost Quartet.’ Spanning two full episodes where they dissect the show track-by-track, the boys get existential and talk about the other side, universal consciousness theory, the complex human relationship with alcohol, artist idolatry, how simple can often be best and the nature of protagonist and antagonist... Read More

From the show: Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour

1 h 47 mins
7/22/19

About

Discuss on Reddit ➤

Support the Show ➤

We don’t even know how to begin, but we certainly know that we are here and discussing Dave Malloy’s spookily exquisite song-cycle, ‘Ghost Quartet.’ Spanning two full episodes where they dissect the show track-by-track, the boys get existential and talk about the other side, universal consciousness theory, the complex human relationship with alcohol, artist idolatry, how simple can often be best and the nature of protagonist and antagonist.

Studio Recording:

Amazon / iTunes / Spotify

Live at the McKittrick:

Amazon / iTunes / Spotify

SHOW NOTES:

The question we’re all asking is, WILL a Fosse neck do it? I guess we’ll never know.

In true Prayer style, Jimi will try his hardest to not quote the Rainbow Sponge Lady video in future podcasts.

If you’re batting about London this winter then check out London’s premiere of Ghost Quartet!

So Jimi’s opinion on digesting Ghost Quartet is to see it first (if possible), listen to the McKittrick Live Recording, then listen to the studio recording to pull it all apart and start to change your whole viewpoint on life, the universe and everything.

As usual, Dave has provided us with some fascinating insights on his music and many wonderful effusions on his fellow cast members via his Genius annotations.

If you’re into Arabian Nights and are board game oriented look no further than one of Jimi’s all time favourites: Tales of the Arabian Nights!

Can we start a Twitter campaign to see if Dave actually intended it to be Roxie Usher a la Anything Goes? The people need to know!

In one of her standout moments, Elaine Stritch’s one woman show paints a fascinating picture about her relationship with alcohol.

If you want to join Jimi’s cult of Jeff Buckley then why not start with one of the best studio albums of all time, Grace?

Then while you’re feeling musical why not have a gander at one of Thelonius Monk’s greatest albums too? A staple for every record player to be quite honest.

Check out Wind Cave and/or Cheddar Gorge depending on your locale for some Lights Out action!

Is this podcast really just a way for Jimi to garner like-minded people who share his eclectic tase in fiction? I think so. Feel free to PM him about anything related to Twin Peaks, Lost, The OA, Rusty Lake or House of Leaves.

How can it be that we spoke for around 3 hours about a show, yet there still be so much more to say? Let's move this talk over to Reddit. We're dying to hear your thoughts!

A HAZARDOUS QUIZ QUESTION:

During the filming of the movie that this musical is based on, a jilted lighting operator intentionally attempted to drop a lighting instrument on one of the young actresses in an attempt at revenge for his own daughter not being cast in the role. What show?

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:04] Jimi: We interrupt our program to bring you this important message.

[0:07] Jimi: Hey podcast fans, it's your pal Jimmy here. Uh spoiler alert, today we are talking about Dave Malloy's whiskey-infused song cycle extravaganza Ghost Quartet, which if you've ever listened to before, you'll know has more twists and turns than the Minotaur's Labyrinth. And while Tommy and I uh search for the center of the maze, uh we get pretty deep. And as such, this podcast is split into two parts. Um this is side one, and if you hadn't guessed already, this is the one to listen to first. If you did guess that, ten points to you. Um also I say this in the episode, but uh of all the shows we've talked about, uh you really want to listen to the cast recording of this one before diving into the podcast. Uh or you could listen along. That could also be fun. You do you, you know? Uh either way, grab a whiskey, and let's get spooky.

[1:17] Tommy: Yes.

[1:21] Jimi: Boom. It's like magic. I did some sort of like Liza arms there. I was doing the Liza arm shake. Liza Manelli elbows. That was a joke that I have put on Twitter in some YouTube descriptions for a thousand years that I don't that like one of my friends said at one point, and I don't actually remember why it was originally funny. Do you have jokes like that in your life?

[1:44] Tommy: Probably.

[1:46] Jimi: No, the height of comedy it will always be Liza Minelli turns off a lamp. Oh no, false neck new. I don't know. There must be a polio switch or something. Pow! Remember that? So good. Absolutely brilliant. Like genius. Oh, so funny. And I feel only applicable to musical theater gays. Only like there, you know, are like 30 people in the world who appreciate it as much as we do.

[2:16] Tommy: Exactly.

[2:17] Jimi: And they all listen to this podcast. Literally, they all do. Um yeah, my friend Marnie has on the back of a hoodie with a Fossy neck to it, and I support that. I support that. That's good. Add it to the merch store.

[2:31] Tommy: Yes.

[2:32] Jimi: Sorry, Marnie. I'm stealing that. I am stealing that. Somebody get us another drink! Welcome to Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour, the only musical theater podcast with grace notes and grape notes.

[2:47] Tommy: Ooh.

[2:49] Jimi: Nice. Do we taste like grape?

[2:52] Tommy: You're damn right we do.

[2:53] Jimi: Have you tasted yourself recently?

[2:55] Tommy: Don't ask me that question. That's a personal question.

[2:57] Jimi: That's a personal question. But probably tastes like grape.

[3:02] Tommy: Probably. I'd be okay with that. Just like notes of grape, those notes.

[3:07] Jimi: Notes of grape. There's there. It's in the background. The mouthfeel. Mmm, grapes. Grape. Do it all the time. Anyway. Speaking of, what are you drinking today?

[3:19] Tommy: Oh.

[3:19] Jimi: Sir? I mean, there's only like four choices.

[3:23] Tommy: Literally four. I wonder which one you'll pick.

[3:25] Jimi: Uh, probably Jameson.

[3:28] Tommy: Interesting.

[3:29] Jimi: Yeah. Interesting choice. Which would you pick?

[3:31] Tommy: Like a villain.

[3:32] Jimi: Please, please. I'm a Scott. Uh, I guess that makes sense. I just don't I don't like whiskey or brandy enough.

[3:38] Tommy: No, I hate it.

[3:39] Jimi: Then don't buy the expensive stuff.

[3:41] Tommy: That's the thing. Have you had Jameson?

[3:44] Jimi: This is just a thought I had. I don't maybe. I don't know, maybe. Have you?

[3:48] Tommy: Yeah, cuz I mean it's a Tennessee whiskey. Um, but I don't think it has made I I bet you it would be more difficult for you to come across. Um, I don't know though. It's we're this is Scotland.

[4:00] Jimi: That's true. This is the land.

[4:03] Tommy: This is the land of whiskey.

[4:07] Jimi: Um yeah, no, like I mean lag of it. Like, I I don't know. Whiskey's fine. I love smelling it. I would smell it forever.

[4:16] Tommy: Yeah.

[4:16] Jimi: But it dare pass my lips. No.

[4:19] Tommy: It's that burn.

[4:21] Jimi: Yeah, I will if someone if someone pours it for me, I will drink it. Um and don't get me wrong, I can appreciate the difference between like better whiskies and worse whiskies, and like, you know, taste the notes and all that. Like, I can. I just don't enjoy it.

[4:37] Tommy: Yeah, exactly. I can do like I know when it's Petey.

[4:41] Jimi: Yeah.

[4:43] Tommy: And that's about it. Okay. Um, hey, what the hell are we on about?

[4:49] Jimi: Uh, well, I can tell you in the form of a quiz question. Are you ready?

[4:52] Tommy: Ah, please do.

[4:53] Jimi: Yeah, I'm so ready. Which musical features metallophone, accordion, auto harp, air who, and ukulele in its orchestration.

[5:02] Tommy: Gotta love an air who.

[5:04] Jimi: It could only be. This is Ghost Quartet. Side one. Track one. I don't know. Now I don't know. I don't know. But I've been told. I've been told that's true of everything. I think I know. Everything I think I know. I don't know. I don't know, but I've been told. But I've been told. Yes, I've been told. You asked for it. The army arts and crafts of army. Sorry, that's the that's that Sponge Lady. Remember I told you about that sponge lady. I have since watched The Sponge Lady since we talked about the sponge lady, and I understand. Well, at one point she says, you asked for it. And I feel that's applicable. No, Ghost Quartet, widely widely requested, probably due in no small part to our relationship with Natash Pier and the Great Comet of 1812.

[6:04] Tommy: Yes, indeed.

[6:05] Jimi: Yes, indeed oh. Jimmy, I think we should let people in on uh because it will become apparent as we progress through the podcast. Do you know the first time I listened to this musical?

[6:15] Tommy: When was it, Tommy?

[6:17] Jimi: It was three days ago.

[6:19] Tommy: Gasp.

[6:20] Jimi: But I think that's fun. I think that's really fun. Well because we're working from both sides of the coin here. How long have you been listening to Ghost Quartet?

[6:31] Tommy: For about three years.

[6:35] Jimi: When did we listen to Comet?

[6:36] Tommy: Three years ago.

[6:37] Jimi: Yeah. Yeah. Wow. Okay. For about three years. Yeah. So that's nice, isn't it? It'll get hopefully a balanced perspective.

[6:45] Tommy: Absolutely.

[6:46] Jimi: Absolutely. Um, so hey. Uh Ghost Quartet. It premiered in 2014 at the Bushwick Star. We're talking off Broadway again. We're we're in the backwoods. Um, and then it moved over uh to the McKittrick Hotel for a bit of a revamp. And the McKittrick Hotel is home of the long-standing Sleep No More experiential Macbeth retelling.

[7:11] Tommy: Exactly. It's a perfect, it's haunting.

[7:13] Jimi: It is a chilling place. A haunting, haunted venue, perfect for Ghost Quartet.

[7:18] Tommy: Absolutely is. And then it toured, including to the Enborough Fringe, where Jimmy, you saw this show.

[7:24] Jimi: I did. I did. My dreams came true and I saw it with the original cast, kind of the only cast. But yeah, wasn't expecting it and was very pleased that it happened. It was in um Pain's Plough, which is a beautiful sort of in-the-round theatre in a proper circle person.

[7:49] Tommy: Yeah.

[7:49] Jimi: Um and it was really magical. Yeah. Um and the UK were being spoiled with the Ghost Quartet because it's coming back to us again in October, but not with the original cast. New cast, which is an interesting because this is such a I think maybe even more than any other show we've talked about, such a cast-dependent show. Um like a cast developed show and was written for and by everyone who was in the original production. Um we've done now here this and we've talked about title of show, we've not done it. Um but you know, the it's uh a similar vein, and that it's very much grown from these people and the people are playing in some ways themselves.

[8:32] Tommy: Yes.

[8:32] Jimi: Um when you take it out of that context, it's different. It's different for sure. And even more so than the title of show uh uh duilogy. What do you call two pieces in a like a trilogy but with two?

[8:48] Tommy: Um I don't know.

[8:51] Jimi: That's a good question.

[8:52] Tommy: Duology?

[8:53] Jimi: Duology, even more than the title of show duology. This show is also written for like the instrumental talents of the cast which are wide and varied um and super specific exactly when your cast orchestrates your show yeah um that obviously puts you into quite a niche right yeah it's quite tricky to find someone casting for bearded male who plays cello and air who not to mention everything else you can do extended vocal technique plus metallophone right you know auto harp and ukulele or I don't know what the combos are but um yeah it's tricky it'll be interesting I will be fascinated to hear how the new cast does I'm sure it'll be fantastic because yeah I think um when we round things off I'd like to speak a bit about other productions of it because they do exist it's in the amateur world um and it's different.

[9:53] Tommy: Yeah.

[9:54] Jimi: Yeah. So how can people hear this Tommy?

[9:56] Tommy: Well there are two recordings the studio recording and uh recording recorded live at the McKittrick Hotel. Per Jimmy's recommendation I listen to the McKittrick recording first. Um and I recommend that to people who haven't listened to this show. I think that's the experience to go with it captures a little bit more of what is a both a simple and complicated show.

[10:19] Jimi: Yeah yeah it can be simple it can also be complicated.

[10:23] Tommy: Yeah um yeah I think so like the then the live recording nothing's cut right in the studio recording quite a lot of the scenes are cuts.

[10:32] Jimi: Yes.

[10:32] Tommy: Or things are, you know, kind of snipped down a little bit. Um, but yeah, I think the live recording's a really good one just to be like, okay, this is what it is.

[10:40] Jimi: Yeah.

[10:40] Tommy: And then the studio recording, you can just hear it all a bit more.

[10:42] Jimi: You can hear it all a bit more. And you know, it's it's a dense and like this is if you this is a recording you'll want to listen to more than once anyway.

[10:50] Tommy: Oh, good grade, yes.

[10:51] Jimi: But is well, I'm sure we'll talk about it.

[10:55] Tommy: Exactly. Um because we're do I don't even know where to begin. Uh when describing uh what this is all about.

[11:04] Jimi: Wait, because it is it's really difficult. I can do this. I can describe this show. I don't like you've put it here in our show notes, and this is like the publicity summary for the show. Um a song cycle about love, death, and whiskey, a camera breaks, and four friends drink and four interwoven narratives spanning seven centuries. I don't like this summary. Um I I it because I don't think it adequately describes the show, but this is also a show where you know you get so deep into the plot that you reach a point where you say just go watch it, and maybe you'll understand it better. But even if you do watch it, you might not understand it any better.

[11:42] Tommy: Yeah.

[11:43] Jimi: Yeah. Um so wait, how would you describe it?

[11:47] Tommy: You said you could do this.

[11:48] Jimi: Um is that your description?

[11:49] Tommy: No, my description.

[11:51] Jimi: Yeah, go watch it.

[11:52] Tommy: No, uh Ghost Quartet is a dreamlike song cycle ghost story. Um with one solidifying plot line that pans out into four or five plot lines, depending upon you on how you count it, all told by ghosts of the same character.

[12:15] Jimi: You could use some proofreading, but interesting. Because this is a th I have so I felt like because I knew this was gonna be a bear, no pun intended, going in trying to sort out the plot of this thing. Um and actually, by like listen two or three, I was pretty confident that I had most of it.

[12:37] Tommy: Right.

[12:37] Jimi: Um and then you you like go online and you're like, what am I missing? And there are all these. Have you ever seen you don't watch It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia, do you?

[12:47] Tommy: No.

[12:48] Jimi: There is a a memeable clip from that, uh where one of the characters is working in a mail room and is like, I've unearthed this conspiracy, Pepe Sylvia, and has one of those like crazy board ones.

[12:58] Tommy: Yeah, that's the guy doing this.

[12:59] Jimi: With like all of the all of the uh yarn things. Every explanation of the show online looks like that crazy person board, and I don't think it needs to be that complicated.

[13:11] Tommy: Uh yeah, I agree.

[13:13] Jimi: There's a there's a main storyline um that exists somewhere between uh that is basically these actors telling their story. It is it is these four friends storyline.

[13:24] Jimi: Um and that is that is the the limbo that we kind of live in. The hub of it all is what the genius annotated lyrics call the two sisters storyline, where uh a spurn sister wants to get revenge on her other sister and goes to a bear uh who sends her on a quest to get four things.

[13:44] Jimi: Um those four things are Jimmy. Um one pot of honey, uh huh, one piece of stardust, uh one secret baptism, and a photo of a ghost. And this girl ends up kind of uh traveling through time and space, both forward and backward, to retrieve these things through three other timelines. One loosely based on Edgar Allan Poe's The House of Usher, one a contemporary story of a uh murder that takes place on a subway, um, and one uh an ancient uh re-contexture or a recontextualization of the ancient story of Arabian Nights or you know the tale of a thousand and one stories.

[14:25] Tommy: Yes, and that's it.

[14:27] Jimi: It's not that hard.

[14:29] Tommy: Easy as that, right?

[14:31] Jimi: Um, I think in terms of in terms of what's happening, you're totally right. Um I think uh the only thing I would counter with is I don't think there's a plot like I don't think there's a plot.

[14:44] Tommy: Yes.

[14:46] Jimi: Well, and also I I mean they say in the beginning that you know, this this is a circular story.

[14:46] Tommy: This is a circular story, exactly.

[14:53] Jimi: I I also think and I don't know, this is something I feel more and more about art the more I delve into it.

[15:00] Tommy: Yes.

[15:01] Jimi: And I think my opinion has changed on this even since we started this podcast. I think you can enjoy a piece of art with have without having fully completely understood the intricacies of its plot.

[15:14] Tommy: 100% with you.

[15:15] Jimi: And I think that's so important.

[15:17] Tommy: Yeah.

[15:17] Jimi: I mean, like and this is this is why people struggle going to like art museums and looking at paintings. Like you can look at a painting and enjoy it and not have the full contextualization of it.

[15:30] Tommy: And that's a totally.

[15:32] Jimi: Totally.

[15:33] Tommy: Um, yeah.

[15:35] Jimi: Uh I wanna cut I want to come back to that point about a sort of appreciating art and uh getting deeper.

[15:44] Tommy: Yeah, for sure.

[15:44] Jimi: As as time goes on, because you've been listening to us for three days.

[15:48] Tommy: Yeah.

[15:48] Jimi: I've been listening to us for three years.

[15:50] Tommy: Yeah.

[15:51] Jimi: Um we will have completely different relationships with the show.

[15:56] Tommy: Exactly.

[15:57] Jimi: Um, but certainly as your starting point going in. Uh that's that's your that's your bread and butter.

[16:04] Tommy: Yeah.

[16:04] Jimi: And and worth it, like if you've listened to if you haven't listened to it yet, of course, worth listening to it before you continue with this podcast.

[16:11] Tommy: I complet I completely agree.

[16:13] Jimi: I think this is it's almost like here's your how-to for this podcast. Um listen to it once, listen to the life once, start to finish, um, come back and then listen along.

[16:23] Tommy: Yeah.

[16:24] Jimi: And we'll tell you all about it.

[16:25] Tommy: Which exactly we should start right now with side one track one.

[16:29] Jimi: I don't know.

[16:30] Tommy: I've got a thousand one story.

[16:38] Jimi: Every single one of them.

[16:47] Jimi: Let me read you a story, let me read you a romance.

[16:52] Jimi: I will re you will listen, and this terrible night will pass.

[17:01] Jimi: I used to play.

[17:14] Jimi: Now somewhere every night started at the game on the phone.

[17:23] Jimi: Keep my head down alone.

[17:29] Jimi: I don't know if this is me at all, or just some ghost of me that I dreamed of.

[17:36] Jimi: Just to save myself to sleep.

[17:40] Jimi: Or someone that I used to be, or someone that I will be, or someone that I am right now.

[18:01] Jimi: Or someone that used to be, or someone that I will be, or someone that I am right now.

[18:01] Jimi: Or someone that used to be, or someone that I will be, or someone I am right now.

[18:13] Jimi: I don't even know how to begin.

[18:19] Jimi: Stop.

[18:19] Tommy: And it's true.

[18:20] Jimi: It's true.

[18:21] Tommy: And I'm worried of everything I know.

[18:24] Jimi: I'm worried that this is just be gonna become us, like just reading all the lyrics out loud.

[18:29] Tommy: I mean, in many ways, that'd be entertaining for.

[18:34] Jimi: How do you feel about I don't know as a introduction song to a musical?

[18:39] Tommy: Um, I think uh it for me it kind of goes in two halves.

[18:43] Jimi: Okay.

[18:43] Tommy: The song itself.

[18:44] Tommy: Um I think you've got the first half, which is is bit you know, it has been like there's lots of I don't know uh I've been told it it kind of winds around itself.

[18:56] Jimi: Yes.

[18:56] Tommy: Right.

[18:57] Tommy: There's lots of just I don't know, so there's there's confusion, it's outlaying that I think at the start.

[19:02] Jimi: This is gonna be there's like questions.

[19:05] Tommy: Yeah, yeah.

[19:06] Tommy: Right?

[19:06] Jimi: And it's very, very simple.

[19:08] Tommy: Um then I think as the song goes on, it very quickly starts to introduce the themes.

[19:15] Jimi: Yes, and it and it throws themes.

[19:17] Tommy: This show does a really good job of tossing in themes before like explicitly throwing in a theme before it becomes relevant or even contextualized.

[19:28] Jimi: Yes.

[19:29] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[19:29] Jimi: Yeah, yes.

[19:30] Tommy: Um because as the song ends and it starts to talk about um when I was a child, I used to play long ago that's not me anymore.

[19:41] Jimi: Um I read the subway, I keep my head down.

[19:47] Jimi: Um this idea of there's definitely uh a transition going on somewhere.

[19:54] Tommy: There is a past and there is a present.

[19:57] Jimi: Yes.

[19:58] Tommy: And it's the future.

[20:00] Jimi: Yeah.

[20:00] Jimi: That is in question.

[20:02] Tommy: Yeah.

[20:05] Jimi: I I mean I would even call that in the because this the because it's a circular story.

[20:10] Tommy: But yes, yeah, we are we're acknowledging the fact that like time is both important and unimportant.

[20:15] Jimi: Time is a theme in this show.

[20:17] Tommy: It's important or not.

[20:18] Jimi: Um for sure.

[20:19] Jimi: I think um, yeah, uh as as we go through it, because I've got I've got ideas and feelings about the show that I'd like to present to you kind of as we go through it.

[20:30] Tommy: Sure.

[20:30] Jimi: Um and for me just I d I I don't know, sets it up as a very nice big old question mark. There's no, you know, here's your character, here's your exposition.

[20:43] Tommy: Right.

[20:44] Jimi: Where you know, one-to-one comparison, um, uh the opening number of Great Comet is much more didactic and explanatory, um, and sets up the characters.

[20:55] Tommy: This this song very much sets up that like this is gonna be a confusing story, come along for the ride.

[21:02] Jimi: Yes.

[21:03] Jimi: Don't feel like you need to understand it all.

[21:05] Jimi: I don't I don't know, but I've been told, you know, I've here's a thousand stories, every single one of them's a lie.

[21:10] Jimi: Let me tell you one.

[21:11] Tommy: Um.

[21:13] Jimi: And that this is just gonna be a night of storytelling.

[21:17] Tommy: It is interesting to me, and I think when we get at the end of side one, uh any kind of dead person, that although the like perhaps the one thematic titular concept through this whole thing is the idea of ghosts and existing through other beings and like transferring that spirit, that is one theme that seems to be pretty absent.

[21:42] Jimi: I guess there's where's my ghost in the mirror, um, but it it it is certainly minimized in this opening number for how prevalent it is in the rest of the show.

[21:52] Tommy: Um let me go back to the lyrics.

[21:56] Jimi: Um yes.

[21:59] Tommy: Because see to it's it's interesting you say it's about ghosts.

[22:04] Jimi: I I wouldn't say it's about ghosts.

[22:06] Tommy: I would say not about like, ooh, spooky.

[22:10] Jimi: Well, but it is kind of about that too.

[22:12] Tommy: Um but I think um it it kind of uses ghosts or this kind of word ghost or the idea of ghost spirits um as a uh like in Pokemon, like you play substitution and the little doll comes out.

[22:29] Jimi: There's literally a word for that that isn't coming into my head, but that's what I'm picturing right now.

[22:33] Tommy: It's the kind of the smokescreen almost for what ghosts mean.

[22:39] Jimi: Um because uh as we get into it, uh, you know, Dave Malloy doesn't believe in ghosts.

[22:45] Tommy: Right.

[22:46] Jimi: I I mean I think this entire concept, this entire c album is an exploration of what a ghost would be if you are Dave Molloy.

[22:57] Tommy: Of a concept that the English language does not have a word for, but the closest we can come to is ghost.

[23:05] Jimi: Yeah, that's nice.

[23:06] Tommy: That's very nice.

[23:07] Jimi: Um but I think uh what I don't know talks about is it is a human thing.

[23:12] Jimi: Like it's talking about these very human things that we can all relate to regrets, uh being stagnant and not having a clue.

[23:25] Tommy: Yeah.

[23:25] Jimi: Sure.

[23:26] Tommy: Yeah, I mean, so it's just I think it just is like, here you go.

[23:29] Jimi: Yeah.

[23:30] Tommy: Welcome.

[23:31] Jimi: Um and then also just from a a sort of musical perspective, um everyone's singing and everyone's playing instruments.

[23:38] Jimi: Yeah.

[23:39] Tommy: So you're you're in the world very quickly.

[23:41] Jimi: Yeah, and it sets up the spirit of the show.

[23:42] Jimi: Like in the same way um you know Monsters Inc., um the Pixar movie.

[23:47] Tommy: I do.

[23:47] Jimi: Famously did not start with the opening jazzy credits scene with all the doors, b-da-ba-da-ba-ba-ba-da-ba-da-bum.

[23:55] Jimi: Instead started with the like, you know, uh uh monster coming into the kid's room and it's really spooky.

[24:04] Jimi: And then oh he screwed it up, oh right, and you realize that this there's this world of monsters.

[24:08] Tommy: But because it's it started with this weird tone of spookiness, the entire film from then on didn't land well.

[24:14] Jimi: Um, you hear the story time and time again, and a funny thing happened on the way to the forum, even in great comment.

[24:20] Jimi: Like, if you don't have the right opening number to set the spirit of the thing, the rest of it dies.

[24:25] Tommy: And this show needs a bouncy inviting, somewhat tongue-in-cheek number to set up the spirit of it.

[24:35] Jimi: Otherwise, you're gonna get mired in some of the gothic grim uh uh content that it talks about, but not be able to make wrap your mind around the spirit through which it wants to talk about some of that content.

[24:49] Tommy: Yep.

[24:50] Jimi: And it to me, this is this might be a metaphor too far.

[24:53] Tommy: Have you you've never done Sleep No More, have you?

[24:56] Jimi: No.

[24:56] Tommy: I have met plenty of people who have.

[24:59] Jimi: I know plenty about it, but not something I've experienced personally myself.

[25:03] Tommy: Yeah.

[25:03] Jimi: Well, I think it's quite auspicious that it was in the McKittrick because uh for sure.

[25:09] Jimi: The there's a part of that experience where you can get out where you can have a rest.

[25:15] Tommy: Because it's intense.

[25:16] Jimi: Yeah.

[25:16] Jimi: Um and you can take off your mask and you can you know, chill.

[25:20] Jimi: Um for me, I don't know is that taking off your mask point because yeah, while you're in amongst it, yeah, you can go straight back to I don't know and kind of recuperate, yeah, check in.

[25:35] Tommy: Well, and that's that's the lovely thing I think about the structure of this whole show.

[25:38] Jimi: I would say that happens three or four times in this show.

[25:41] Tommy: Where where we take a trip to the break room where you can catch your bre your breath, where we can acknowledge that this is a show.

[25:48] Jimi: And like the, you know, in the live uh recording, they intro every single track they call it, which is so ridiculous that they set up this whole conceit that there are sides and tracks on what exists mostly as a digital album for most people.

[26:04] Tommy: The metaphor is so many layers deep already, but then to bring it into the real world and perform it, but say those things out loud, and uh uh Dave Mulloy talks about these in his genius annotations that they are hearkening back to the idea of a concept album.

[26:19] Jimi: Exactly.

[26:20] Tommy: But that we do want to be at least mildly Brechttian in nature, and like you're watching a story, you're watching people tell you the story, and that's the point.

[26:20] Jimi: You're watching people tell you a story about people telling stories, about people telling stories, and it's stories all the way down.

[26:35] Tommy: Totally.

[26:36] Jimi: And that's the thing with any story, whatever you take away from it, thumbs up.

[26:41] Tommy: Great.

[26:41] Jimi: Yep.

[26:41] Tommy: Have a good night.

[26:43] Jimi: And that's that's it.

[26:44] Jimi: Um so speaking of stories, shall we delve into the next track?

[26:48] Tommy: Shall we go to the camera shop?

[26:49] Jimi: Let's go.

[26:56] Tommy: Rose and Pearl lived by the sea, gathering salt in the moonlight, and Rose loved a man who lived in the trees.

[27:09] Jimi: Rose cried to Paul on me side on me side.

[27:13] Tommy: Rose into his tree house and looked up the stars through his telescope.

[27:21] Jimi: She wanted to hold his hand.

[27:24] Tommy: So she wrote him a poem, signed it and sealed it in a rice paper umboat with a lily forestale.

[27:33] Jimi: But the man stole her work.

[27:37] Tommy: He was the editor of a prestigious astronomy journal.

[27:43] Jimi: He rolled down all she saw.

[27:47] Tommy: And published it in his mind.

[27:54] Jimi: And then ward is dusty in here, isn't it?

[28:02] Tommy: Don't know how much I'm probable to throughout this, but hey, I've started it.

[28:06] Jimi: Um yes, and it is I need a Swiffer.

[28:11] Tommy: Sorry, I have it's been a while since I've improved.

[28:13] Jimi: Uh that's fair.

[28:14] Tommy: Um that was a good one.

[28:15] Jimi: Thank you.

[28:16] Tommy: Well done.

[28:16] Jimi: Thank you.

[28:17] Tommy: Um the camera shop, we're now the the story begins.

[28:22] Jimi: Yes.

[28:23] Tommy: Um or ends.

[28:24] Jimi: Who knows?

[28:26] Tommy: Well, yes, almost, almost.

[28:27] Jimi: This is the kind of the beginning of the end of the Yeah.

[28:33] Tommy: Maybe maybe a penultimate kind of song if we were just looking at the central plot of the show and not wrapping it in some commentary.

[28:43] Jimi: Um so we meet uh two of the Inverticomas characters.

[28:55] Tommy: I know, and it's it's so hard because they're gonna have a thousand different names throughout the whole thing.

[29:00] Jimi: Yes.

[29:01] Tommy: They really, really will.

[29:02] Jimi: Um and yeah, we'll get lost during this description.

[29:06] Tommy: Yeah.

[29:07] Jimi: You'll get lost during this description.

[29:08] Tommy: It's fine.

[29:09] Jimi: But we'll have a great time.

[29:10] Tommy: It's Gelsey in Britain.

[29:12] Jimi: Exactly.

[29:13] Tommy: Um and I think for the most part, that's what we'll use.

[29:16] Jimi: Yeah.

[29:16] Tommy: Um but uh you know, well, maybe we should say what each who each of the characters are.

[29:22] Jimi: I would vaguely say that Gelsie generally is Pearl, and that's a useful name to give her the entire time, and Britain generally is Rose.

[29:32] Tommy: Rose.

[29:33] Jimi: Those are good characters to center them around.

[29:36] Tommy: Yes.

[29:37] Jimi: Um Yes.

[29:40] Tommy: But that does change.

[29:41] Jimi: Yes.

[29:42] Tommy: But it does change, and it's difficult.

[29:43] Jimi: It does change.

[29:44] Tommy: And there are different roses throughout the story.

[29:46] Jimi: Like the you know.

[29:47] Tommy: Exactly.

[29:48] Jimi: Even that becomes problematic.

[29:49] Tommy: And the whole point is that you don't even like the the difficulty we're having in determining the character is the point of the show.

[29:57] Jimi: Um because it's all happening.

[30:01] Tommy: Anyway, Britton goes to Gelsie's camera store to get her camera fixed.

[30:06] Jimi: It yes, because it got smashed and lost.

[30:09] Tommy: And it's spooky.

[30:11] Jimi: Oh it is.

[30:13] Tommy: It it you do you kind of begin this sense of eeriness because Gelsie is fantastic and eerie as a human, right?

[30:21] Jimi: Yes.

[30:22] Tommy: Um and that's the biggest compliment I could ever get.

[30:25] Jimi: Yeah, absolutely.

[30:26] Tommy: Do you know I mean she is f she is just so interesting.

[30:30] Jimi: Yeah.

[30:31] Tommy: Um and uh the way she presents herself in this as uh she does have this kind of all knowing you know uh vendor and it's it's it's a trope almost I feel like it happens quite a lot.

[30:45] Jimi: Like the all-knowing shop vendor.

[30:47] Tommy: The ethereal shopkeeper who knows more than you, and like you know, like everything from the um, you know, like fortune tellers in The Legend of Zelda to like Christopher Walken and Click, like that kind of like I'll sell you your future, but make a joke about vacuums.

[31:05] Jimi: Um I think so that's the kind of thing that's presented very quickly.

[31:10] Tommy: Yes.

[31:10] Jimi: Um, and she uh begins to tell the story.

[31:16] Tommy: Yes, one one of the maybe the biggest framing stories.

[31:21] Jimi: Yes, kind of.

[31:23] Tommy: Yeah.

[31:24] Jimi: I mean this so she she tells the story of Rose and Pearl, which I think is useful to call the two sisters story.

[31:34] Tommy: Yes.

[31:35] Jimi: And also, I think before we go on, um, it's important that this is the first time that this incarnation of Rose, Britain, um hears about other incarnations of Rose.

[31:49] Tommy: Yes.

[31:50] Jimi: Like we the idea is presented that there's more than one.

[31:53] Tommy: I would say, I mean I think, and you know, tell me I'm wrong, but I would say of the two, Rose leans more protagonist than Pearl in this story.

[32:05] Jimi: If we're talking about audience identification as an earmark towards protagonists.

[32:10] Tommy: You're along yeah, you're along for the raid with Rose.

[32:13] Jimi: And so you, like Rose, don't quite understand this concept at this moment.

[32:21] Tommy: Um that Rose, oh, what a familiar name. Let me tell you about a different Rose, who might be the same Rose.

[32:28] Jimi: Exactly.

[32:29] Tommy: Because when she says it's a beautiful name, you it's almost like she's saying, I'm talking about you.

[32:36] Jimi: Right.

[32:36] Tommy: Like you you get that vibe.

[32:38] Jimi: Yeah.

[32:38] Tommy: It's like You know what I mean?

[32:40] Jimi: Of course your name is Rose.

[32:41] Tommy: I get it.

[32:42] Jimi: Yes, I know who you are.

[32:44] Tommy: With that presented, then you do start to put Britain into the story.

[32:48] Jimi: Right.

[32:48] Tommy: And and you start to you you start making assumptions about both these characters.

[32:53] Jimi: Because at least in the maybe side one and through about half of side two, this is a mystery story, right?

[32:59] Tommy: You're trying to sort it out.

[33:01] Jimi: I think throughout most of the thing is you're trying to sort it out in your brain, which is half the fun of it.

[33:06] Tommy: Well, three years later.

[33:07] Jimi: Yeah, right, still sorting it out.

[33:08] Tommy: You know what I mean?

[33:09] Jimi: Yeah.

[33:10] Tommy: Um, we kind of begin the two sisters storyline.

[33:16] Jimi: Yes.

[33:16] Tommy: Which I would say is the one it is uh like almost overtly the one that tores it ta ties it together in the same way that the Baker's story in Into the Woods ties these stories together.

[33:28] Jimi: Like not that's not even a big jump.

[33:31] Tommy: Like it is a musical call out in the show itself.

[33:35] Jimi: Exactly, yeah.

[33:36] Tommy: I mean, there's literally a very, very, very blatant into the woods reference.

[33:40] Jimi: Yeah.

[33:40] Tommy: Um, you know.

[33:41] Jimi: But so ancient or old old Rose, mythical Rose and Pearl, um what?

[33:50] Tommy: Are are at odds.

[33:52] Jimi: They loved the same, or they both loved the same man, but the man loved Pearl, and Rose wants to get revenge.

[33:58] Tommy: And the way she wants to get revenge is by having a bear kill the old man and turn Pearl into a bird and trap them together so that Pearl the bird has to eat the dead man.

[34:11] Jimi: Yes.

[34:11] Tommy: This is basically this is the conceit.

[34:14] Jimi: Yes.

[34:15] Tommy: Um so obviously, like it's an instantly it's a fairy tale.

[34:22] Jimi: Right, yes.

[34:23] Tommy: Um, but you get brought into this more uh kind of electric realm when Gelsey says, Don't you remember?

[34:35] Jimi: To me, that's an extremely crucial line.

[34:38] Tommy: Well, yeah, I mean that theme comes back over and over again is that Pearl is trying to get Rose to remember all of her history.

[34:46] Jimi: Exactly.

[34:47] Tommy: Exactly.

[34:48] Jimi: And this in Jimmy's thesis of Ghost Quartet, uh, this is a very crucial, crucial thing.

[34:54] Tommy: Yeah.

[34:54] Jimi: The idea of remembering.

[34:56] Tommy: Yes.

[34:57] Jimi: Um, and how important that is.

[34:59] Tommy: Yeah.

[35:00] Jimi: And and um.

[35:03] Tommy: Yeah, I'll be fun to explore that with you as we go through.

[35:06] Jimi: Um yeah, totally.

[35:08] Tommy: Um but yes, so we're now we're on the road, we've got uh a mission collecting.

[35:14] Jimi: We got a laundry list, we need a pot of honey, a piece of stardust, a secret baptism, and a photo of a ghost.

[35:19] Tommy: Easy.

[35:20] Jimi: Away we go.

[35:20] Tommy: Easy easy peasy.

[35:23] Jimi: And uh we get to work pretty quickly because we're getting everything.

[35:34] Tommy: The whole story is spoiled.

[35:36] Jimi: Yeah.

[35:36] Tommy: I mean track two, the whole thing.

[35:39] Jimi: Track two star child.

[35:40] Tommy: Or track two, uh no, at the end of even the camera shop, they say.

[35:45] Jimi: Um Yep.

[35:47] Tommy: Rose stole the honey from a soldier.

[35:50] Jimi: Uh she stole the stardust from an ancient uh but we get into it for the baby.

[35:56] Tommy: Um she stole the baby from its mother uh and took it into the sea in the trials blessed, which leads us nicely into Star Child.

[36:05] Jimi: A billion lies away should think in the shape thing, but he's already turned to dust and the stars a million language.

[36:23] Tommy: A ghost beside the rest of nothing I see more.

[36:39] Jimi: But I will transcend and fall with this old fame.

[36:54] Tommy: I will myself.

[37:17] Jimi: So, in many ways, uh-huh, this is the song.

[37:22] Tommy: What do you mean?

[37:24] Jimi: Um, so this is the first song that I went back to.

[37:28] Tommy: Okay.

[37:30] Jimi: Right?

[37:30] Tommy: You know, there's always anytime you listen to a cash recording, there's always that first one where you're like, I liked that one.

[37:37] Jimi: Yeah.

[37:37] Tommy: Okay.

[37:38] Jimi: And you go back there, and then that's how you start to start peeling.

[37:41] Tommy: Like unpacking it, yeah.

[37:43] Jimi: Yeah.

[37:43] Tommy: Um First of all, this is a stunning song.

[37:47] Jimi: It's a beautiful song.

[37:48] Tommy: Full stop.

[37:49] Jimi: This is very much Dave Malloy magic.

[37:51] Tommy: Yeah.

[37:52] Jimi: Right?

[37:53] Tommy: Um, very simple in terms of music.

[37:57] Jimi: Yeah.

[37:58] Tommy: Very, very simple.

[37:59] Jimi: Um, think Sonya alone.

[38:01] Tommy: Yes.

[38:01] Jimi: You know, I mean extremely simple, but very poignant and very artistic.

[38:05] Tommy: And I think it it starts to introduce one of the things that absolutely differentiates the show from Great Comet is in l and many other musicals, but certainly Great Comet has a linear narrative structure.

[38:22] Jimi: And like, Sony Alone is an important character development song in Great Comet and helps us progress the story along.

[38:29] Tommy: Star Child, we don't we never really meet Star Child again.

[38:34] Jimi: Exactly.

[38:35] Tommy: We don't need to know anything about her.

[38:38] Jimi: And actually, the I was trying to put it together because I was like going through, you know, trying to piece the plot together in my head and checking off, you know, where does Rose get the four things?

[38:48] Tommy: We never actually hear about the baptism.

[38:54] Jimi: Except she took the child in the sea and the child was blessed.

[38:58] Tommy: It happens, you know, off stage, off-camera, right?

[39:01] Jimi: This is the only time we hear about it, and then we just assume that it has happened.

[39:05] Tommy: But this is setting up, you know, like this is the beauty of the show, that like how it lets you delve into these layers, even beyond just the uh on the surface level, like story within a story within a story, but it lets you get into the structure of it all.

[39:22] Jimi: Like immediately, you know, Britain's been on stage as you know uh uh uh Rose.

[39:28] Tommy: She's been three people so far.

[39:30] Jimi: Exactly, right?

[39:31] Tommy: Um, and and now she's this ridiculous thing that a story was just told about how she needs to go get herself, basically.

[39:40] Jimi: Yeah, yeah, she she robs herself.

[39:42] Tommy: Yeah.

[39:42] Jimi: Um so I loved that you just said we don't meet Star Child ever again.

[39:48] Tommy: Well, okay.

[39:49] Jimi: Okay.

[39:51] Tommy: Um you felt right into my trap.

[39:54] Jimi: I feel the bear trap clutching around my leg.

[39:57] Tommy: Yeah.

[39:58] Jimi: No, I agree with you.

[40:00] Tommy: Right.

[40:00] Jimi: Okay.

[40:00] Tommy: And I think that is so crucial.

[40:03] Jimi: Yes.

[40:04] Jimi: To me, "Star Child" is like the kind of point of the whole show.

[40:14] Tommy: Okay.

[40:14] Jimi: Tell me more.

[40:15] Tommy: Right.

[40:16] Jimi: So, well, uh, okay, I'm gonna ask a few questions and things first.

[40:20] Tommy: Okay.

[40:21] Jimi: Um, what—and if you're listening at home, answer these in your head and let us know. Um, how does "Star Child" as a song, as a full song, differ from every single other song in "Ghost Quartet"?

[40:39] Tommy: And just, you know, I mean, just—do you know what my first thought was?

[40:43] Jimi: It's unabashedly hopeful. Um, every other song in this show is, you know, from mildly to extremely depressive. Um, or has some kind of tinges of that in its content, in its lyrics. "Star Child" is like, uh, you know, it's time to get out of bed and be the Star Child I can be. Um, like that deserves to be on a sampler above everyone's bed.

[41:13] Tommy: Um, absolutely it does.

[41:15] Jimi: And like the concept, you know, clearly Dave Malloy also has a—among his many obsessions—one with space and stars and the cosmos and how that relates to humanity, and that we are all, you know, we are all Stardust or whatever that Carl Sagan's quote is. Um, and like we are all children of the stars, we are all star children. Um, but there's a—so we gotta live up to that, right?

[41:41] Tommy: Yep.

[41:42] Jimi: Um, and to package all of that thought into "it's time to get out of bed and be the Star Child I can be." What a simple phrase.

[41:50] Tommy: Yep.

[41:53] Jimi: Uh, yeah, yeah.

[41:54] Tommy: Yeah.

[41:55] Jimi: I mean, that's, um, how I would qualify it as being different.

[41:58] Tommy: Uh, yeah, I completely agree with you. And, uh, yeah, unabashedly hopeful, I think, is exactly the kind of dart that we want to take with us as we walk through the story.

[42:10] Jimi: Yeah, um, because everything that "Star Child" talks about never really crops up anywhere else apart from like one or two situations, which we'll obviously get to. Um, but it is—it's hopeful because it's talking about potential.

[42:27] Tommy: Yes, it's talking about, I will, yeah, um, I will repeat it again and again and again, I will.

[42:34] Jimi: Is it—is it a vow?

[42:35] Tommy: Yeah, it is a vow to, you know, I will become the next best thing, I will light myself on fire.

[42:41] Jimi: What a—what powerful shit.

[42:44] Tommy: Like exactly, absolutely self-fucking immolation, yeah, right?

[42:49] Jimi: Um, you can't do any better, but it doesn't—it's not like I will light myself on fire and commit suicide. You don't get that feeling.

[42:57] Tommy: Yeah, it's very much I will be a fucking blaze, I will be the Phoenix Force.

[43:02] Jimi: Absolutely. I love—and we're, you know, this is—we're probably five hours out knowing how long this podcast is gonna be. Um, contrasting the song with "Prayer" at the end of the show and embracing both of them is like—is honestly very deeply moving to me.

[43:09] Tommy: Um, so "Star Child" sticks out like a sort of thumb, and I think that's—that's to me, yeah, in complete hindsight. I think that's why I went back to it, because it's the nice one.

[43:35] Jimi: Yeah, okay.

[43:36] Tommy: It's lovely, it makes you feel happy and empowered.

[43:41] Jimi: Yeah.

[43:42] Tommy: There's not anything else in the show that makes you feel like that.

[43:48] Jimi: Yeah, that's—that's fair. I mean, it's, you know, it's the—no one else of this show. Like it is the—we are—it is okay, we're musical theater scholars. This is Rose's "I Want" song.

[44:01] Tommy: If we're gonna put this into a more traditional musical theater structure.

[44:06] Jimi: I think I'm reluctant to make it as, uh, black and white as that.

[44:13] Tommy: Certainly.

[44:14] Jimi: I give you—I give you that gray area because I don't think this sits into—well, I don't know. I hedge that bet. I think lots of—right.

[44:22] Tommy: I think lots of this show is successful because it does leverage that traditional two-act musical theater structure.

[44:29] Jimi: Um, while being wildly not that.

[44:33] Tommy: And I think while this is wildly not an "I Want" song, it serves much of the purpose of an "I Want" song in a way that the audience doesn't quite know it yet.

[44:45] Jimi: Well, yeah, I just feel like it's—it's like the hold on to this coin.

[44:53] Tommy: Yes.

[44:53] Jimi: I'll come back to that in a minute.

[44:55] Tommy: Yes, yes.

[44:55] Jimi: It's that and you're holding it.

[44:57] Tommy: Yeah.

[44:57] Jimi: Because you know it's there. Because as we said, "Star Child," the character never, never, ever, ever, ever comes back.

[45:03] Tommy: But if "Star Child"—

[45:03] Jimi: Right, yes. Um, but if "Star Child" is part of Britain's character line, and we are assuming that these people are vaguely related in their existence and wants and hopes and dreams and actions, yeah, then her hope to be everything she can be and more is something we—is why we don't see Rose in like the "Two Sisters" timeline as quite a villain.

[45:38] Tommy: Because there's a potential.

[45:40] Jimi: Because there's that potential. Because you—you have a sense that she wants to be and do good.

[45:45] Tommy: Vaguely.

[45:51] Jimi: But there's an opportunity.

[45:52] Tommy: Yeah.

[45:53] Jimi: That exists.

[45:54] Tommy: And we've seen that in "Star Tales."

[45:56] Jimi: And that's—that I think is what I mean when I say it like holds that place of an "I Want" song. It points—a big arrow and says, like, hey, hey, hey, this is the good guy. Not that there are bad guys. Not that it's black and white, but like, hey, hey, hey, hey, hey, this one. Watch this one.

[46:12] Tommy: Yes, kind of.

[46:16] Jimi: Kind of. I think there's more to "Star Child," the character, than just that.

[46:20] Tommy: Sure.

[46:21] Jimi: But yes.

[46:25] Tommy: It's definitely, uh, it has the same feeling that an "I Want" song gives you.

[46:29] Jimi: It has—it's the—oh, okay.

[46:31] Tommy: Yeah.

[46:32] Jimi: It's the stakes.

[46:33] Tommy: Yeah.

[46:34] Jimi: It has the same, you know, it feels like something's coming. It feels like purpose. It feels like part of your world. Like it may not save, you know, it doesn't serve the same explicit narrative purpose because this is not an explicitly narrative show.

[46:52] Tommy: But on like a gut feeling kind of way.

[46:55] Jimi: Yep.

[46:56] Jimi: And it's the third song in the show, and most "I Want" songs are the third or fourth song in the show.

[47:01] Tommy: Exactly.

[47:01] Jimi: And I think that's very important.

[47:02] Tommy: It's very important that we meet "Star Child" right now.

[47:06] Jimi: Right at the start.

[47:07] Tommy: Yeah.

[47:07] Jimi: It's the start of the story.

[47:09] Tommy: Yeah.

[47:09] Jimi: Um.

[47:10] Tommy: Absolutely.

[47:11] Jimi: Okay. Uh, "Subway."

[47:14] Tommy: Track four.

[47:16] Jimi: And the time of Canada dies, can of the top and the driver cash dives and back the camp and the pusher can't stop and the driver has a drink and the victim has a drink and the pusher has a drink and the photographer has a drink.

[47:42] Tommy: There's a man on the platform screaming about the apocalypse.

[47:46] Jimi: Screaming about the damn revelation in that hand.

[47:50] Tommy: Ruby to me.

[47:52] Jimi: Remove me everything.

[47:59] Tommy: Reveal it to me, please right now.

[48:03] Jimi: Remember to me, please right now.

[48:08] Tommy: Man, this—uh, who n w can we place bets now? I say no, I'm guessing two forty-two.

[48:22] Jimi: Well, "Comet" was—"Comet" was in two parts.

[48:26] Tommy: Yeah, "Comet" was in two parts.

[48:28] Jimi: And we recorded a Tony's show in the middle of it.

[48:32] Tommy: Did you? We recorded for like six hours that day?

[48:35] Jimi: Yeah, we absolutely did.

[48:37] Tommy: That's funny. I forgot that.

[48:39] Jimi: Um, yeah, I'm guessing at least two and a half.

[48:44] Tommy: I mean, I mean, the listeners will know by now. This is fun. Placing bets against the future.

[48:49] Jimi: If only future me could tell you.

[48:53] Tommy: Very fitting.

[48:54] Jimi: Side one, track four.

[48:56] Tommy: This is a four.

[48:58] Jimi: Yes.

[48:58] Tommy: Okay, so here's a news story. Here's something new.

[49:01] Jimi: And it's fresh.

[49:03] Tommy: It—it like, I mean, slams in like a subway train.

[49:07] Jimi: Yeah.

[49:08] Tommy: It is the—I think the first song in the show that does that. Everything else leads up to this point, leads into itself.

[49:15] Jimi: And it is interesting to see those moments in the show where one song does very well segue into another, and where one song just doesn't.

[49:22] Tommy: Um, and "Subway" comes out of nowhere.

[49:25] Jimi: Exactly.

[49:26] Tommy: So here in the subway, um, we have all four characters existing in this one instance—the driver, the photographer, Pearl, and the pusher.

[49:39] Jimi: And um, I would say not in this moment, uh-huh, because this story is presented nonlinearly, but the subway, the concept of this story in this particular moment serves as the climax of this show.

[50:04] Tommy: Emotionally.

[50:06] Jimi: Yeah.

[50:07] Tommy: Yeah.

[50:08] Jimi: Like when we get—when we get there.

[50:10] Tommy: Yeah, totally.

[50:11] Jimi: I know exactly what you mean.

[50:12] Tommy: And so what is to me.

[50:13] Jimi: Okay, yeah.

[50:15] Tommy: To me, it reminds me of "Inception."

[50:18] Jimi: Sure.

[50:18] Tommy: And this is why I think this is fascinating. Because if the subway, which, spoiler alert, will come back pretty near the end of side three, um, as kind of this—if we're talking a traditional story arc structure, as kind of this climax, the first time we're introduced to the subway in that same stereotypical story arc climax holds the point of the inciting incident.

[50:43] Jimi: But because we're in this cyclical, nonlinear "Inception"-like structure, they're just the same moment.

[50:51] Tommy: Exactly.

[50:52] Jimi: It's all happening at once.

[50:53] Tommy: Yeah.

[50:54] Jimi: This has all happened before. You just—the only thing that changes between experiencing this on track four, side one, and then experiencing it later as like side three, track four, um, is that you, the audience member, don't know who any of these people are yet.

[51:10] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.

[51:11] Jimi: You just—you just get told over and over again there's a driver, there's a victim, there's a pusher, and there's a photographer.

[51:17] Tommy: Well, and I would also say that the subway of any of the storylines is the one where they are most um explicitly didactic about what actually happens.

[51:29] Jimi: Yes.

[51:29] Tommy: Everything else is kind of seeped in metaphor or has this kind of poetry about it. This one is like the driver can't stop, the victim can't climb, the pusher can't stop, and the photographer doesn't help.

[51:39] Jimi: Um, we'll sing it again.

[51:41] Tommy: Yeah, it completely—like you need to—it just gets drummed into your head.

[51:46] Jimi: Um, and this is why I think "Inception," right? Because if we start to look—it's weird because he's never cited "Inception" as any sort of inspiration.

[51:56] Tommy: Of all things.

[51:57] Jimi: And I do think—because I think there's an element of that.

[51:59] Tommy: Yeah.

[52:00] Jimi: I think I do want to take a brief side note because I think this is something that a lot of, um, descriptions and analysis of this musical get sidelined in, and I think it's so important. Um, there's Dave Malloy, who's wonderful, and has a lot of like deep and beautiful commentary about his own work, much of which exists on Genius, which uncertainly have already been linked in the show notes 50 times. Um, talks a lot about how his life inspirations for certain pieces.

[52:30] Tommy: Yes.

[52:31] Jimi: I do think it is important to not confuse the inspiration of certain pieces of a musical with the actual plot of the musical.

[52:42] Tommy: Yep.

[52:42] Jimi: And I think some people put too much weight in the former.

[52:49] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[52:49] Jimi: Like in the—in the Wikipedia article summary for this thing, um, of the many—the laundry list of things that it lists that it references, one of the things it says is it takes inspiration from the video game "Zelda."

[53:04] Tommy: Now I read that before listening to this.

[53:10] Jimi: And as an avid video game music listener, I was like, oh, I'm so excited for this like "Zelda" uh song to come in or whatever.

[53:19] Tommy: But really what they mean is in a Genius annotation, Dave Malloy said the game on the phone that the victim might be playing could kind of be like a boss battle fight from "The Legend of Zelda 2" on the NES.

[53:34] Jimi: Yes. That's not great, awesome, sure, but it is not an intentional artistic, you know, inspiration that is worth reading into, right? Beyond like the fact that video games exist. In the same way that like um, you know, in the last five years, handful after handful of Doritos, right? Oh, well, a Dorito is vaguely triangular, and could the three points of a Dorito actually mean like no There's a third person in the relationship. Oh my god. No, no. Um, stop it. Stop it, everyone. I don't like it. I don't want it. Like, just because Dave Malloy said it, like, of course it inspired him. It's a part of his life. Of course he drew a podcast. Exactly. It's a part of his life. You know, he talks about all sorts of Twilight Zone references, which certainly you can feel the spirit of the Twilight Zone.

You can hear it in the camera shop, but it might be an homage, and you don't need to know anything about it to completely and fully understand the show. And I think people conflate those two different things of importance. Take on the other hand, which we'll get to in a second, but um the House of Usher, the Edgar Allan Poe short story, clearly referenced and homaged to in the show.

[54:57] Tommy: Yeah.

[54:58] Jimi: Is different from The Legend of Zelda. Sorry, I got off on a tangent and you were talking about something.

[55:04] Tommy: That's all right. No, I think it's a very important thing because also, so uh I mean I've read The Fall of the House of Usher.

[55:11] Jimi: Yeah.

[55:11] Tommy: It doesn't crack the code for Ghost Quartet. It's not a cipher.

[55:15] Jimi: No. Do you know what I mean?

[55:16] Tommy: Right.

[55:16] Jimi: It sure it'll help you understand a couple of the jokes.

[55:19] Tommy: Yeah.

[55:19] Jimi: Same with Arabian Nights. Yeah. When I mean when the um, you know, the cow is white as milk, the cape is red as blood, underscore comes in when the bear is listing off his requirements. Yeah, uh-huh. It's it's a reference, but you don't need to know a lick of Into the Woods at all. That's all. And Dave Malloy wouldn't be a good writer if that's what he was doing.

[55:39] Tommy: Well, and I mean if he was like, this is for the Poe fans. Everyone else.

[55:44] Jimi: Right. Bye.

[55:45] Tommy: Right.

[55:45] Jimi: I I think the difference between like until Dave Malloy, and I think I do I do really mean this, and it's a big sentence to say, but until Dave Malloy, people were people hid their artistic history. They hid their life experience, the things they drew inspiration from, all of this. Um, because we want to live in a world of originality, and I think Dave Malloy's existence alongside his work and his ease of commenting on it and talking about his inspiration and like where how these things have come out of his brain.

[56:22] Tommy: Yeah.

[56:23] Jimi: Ushers in a new era of musical theater artistry.

[56:28] Tommy: Yep.

[56:29] Jimi: You know, in a in a way that, like, even in Into the Woods, you know, Sondheim is never like, oh, yes. And here's the deep, deep study we did of different histories of fairy tales to talk about like, no, because that's not that era of playwriting and songwriting and musical thinkership. Um but people, because they're used to that old school, they think, oh, well, if the author must have said it, then it must be a word from God.

[57:01] Tommy: Um and like certainly sometimes it is, but the word from God is the text. Nothing more, nothing less.

[57:10] Jimi: Yep. Anyway, the subway.

[57:14] Tommy: Yes, okay. Throw that soapbox away under the tracks.

[57:17] Jimi: Um I was talking about Inception.

[57:20] Tommy: Yes.

[57:21] Jimi: Yeah. So, and this is just brief, but it will kind of come back. Um, as we're gonna start deep diving now, do you know I mean, and we're gonna be traveling through time.

[57:31] Tommy: Yes.

[57:31] Jimi: Um, all these the thing to remember is that everything is happening at once.

[57:38] Tommy: Right.

[57:38] Jimi: It's all it's all happening at once. And not I think Inception is a good starting point.

[57:45] Tommy: But I think unlike Inception, or even unlike um Arabian Nights, which is explicitly referenced in this show, where one of the keys in Arabian Nights is that it like in the middle of a story, someone else will start telling a story, and now we're gonna experience that story.

[58:00] Jimi: And like it just keeps going linearly deeply.

[58:04] Tommy: Yeah.

[58:04] Jimi: The connections between this are not exactly linear in that way.

[58:10] Tommy: No, exactly. It's not like subway's connected to Usher, which is connected to all just happening at once.

[58:20] Jimi: But with Subway, the reason the reason why I think Inception came in is because Subway is one incident. There's one thing happening. Literally, there's the pushing and there's a death.

[58:30] Tommy: Pushing and a death, and that's all that's going on.

[58:30] Jimi: When you go into the next level, um, wherever that may be, whether it's two sisters, whether it's Usher, yeah.

[58:39] Tommy: Um, you are entering of more of a world.

[58:43] Jimi: Yes.

[58:45] Tommy: There are other things going on, there's history to understand.

[58:48] Jimi: When you're in Subway land, you need to know nothing other than there's a driver, there's a victim, there's a pusher, and there's a photographer. One one one point, one peak, one moment.

[58:59] Tommy: That's it.

[58:59] Jimi: Yeah. That's it.

[59:01] Tommy: Um so there you go, subway.

[59:03] Jimi: Cool dark and soundless day.

[59:10] Jimi: In the autumn of eighteen seventy-three, my wife then died, sat at the bed of our only daughter.

[59:25] Tommy: Roxy.

[1:00:35] Jimi: Side one track five Usher part one hour good Have anyone thought of like let's try side one in an hour?

[1:00:42] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:00:43] Jimi: Sure.

[1:00:44] Tommy: Oh gosh.

[1:00:45] Jimi: Anyway. Side one track five, Usher Part One.

[1:00:49] Tommy: Hooray.

[1:00:50] Jimi: Um Okay, so here we meet the Usher family.

[1:00:53] Tommy: Of Edgar Allan Poe fame.

[1:00:55] Jimi: Mostly. Exactly. I think of of the references, this is the one that is the most uh is closest to story.

[1:01:04] Tommy: It's certainly not the same as it's but Arabian Nights I would say on beyond the level pegging.

[1:01:11] Jimi: Yeah, that's um Yeah, the c I mean the the characters and their kind of relationship and the uh spiral.

[1:01:19] Tommy: Yes.

[1:01:21] Jimi: The they go on and they go through.

[1:01:22] Tommy: Yes.

[1:01:23] Jimi: Very, you know, and very poignant. Certainly uh Dave is calling back to this, you know, Poenzian feeling of Gothic American literature.

[1:01:35] Tommy: Um can't let go of the motif of the thing.

[1:01:40] Jimi: Um useful to like once you start throwing these things in, it it starts flipping all these switches in audience's mind.

[1:01:47] Tommy: In the same way that Camera Shop did um to be like, oh yes, yes, yes, ghost story. Ah, yes, yes, yes, yes.

[1:01:53] Jimi: Horror. Yes. Yes, yes, I understand. Okay.

[1:01:57] Tommy: Eerie, spooky, creepy, exactly.

[1:01:59] Jimi: Ominous um and yeah, I think what Usher just adds is a sort of Victorian feel to it all, which is you know, if you're talking about ghost stories, if you're talking about um uh the spiritual world, anything like that, Victorian has to come into it.

[1:02:15] Tommy: Absolutely.

[1:02:16] Jimi: Um practically invented what we know it as today. You know, Fall of the House of Usher, Sparknotes version, the house is vaguely dying with the people who live in it, and it's spooky because of that.

[1:02:31] Tommy: Yes.

[1:02:32] Jimi: Good summary.

[1:02:34] Tommy: Yeah, classic po of the world is reflecting what's going on inside, just classic.

[1:02:39] Jimi: Yes, and no one quite knows what's going on, and certainly, you know, sets up a lot of tropes of you know what we might consider like a haunted house trope.

[1:02:49] Tommy: Yes.

[1:02:50] Jimi: A haunted hops.

[1:02:52] Tommy: Creaky floors, spooky things, inhabited house.

[1:02:56] Jimi: Yes. Ooh.

[1:02:57] Tommy: Hearts in the basement and everything like that.

[1:03:00] Jimi: Um yeah, uh in terms of linking it to the story, um, we find out that uh the child that was stolen gets referred to here, um is Star Child.

[1:03:15] Tommy: It's Star Child.

[1:03:16] Jimi: Britain in this in the Usher timeline plays a girl called Roxy.

[1:03:21] Tommy: Um also do you think I thought about this today, Roxy Usher?

[1:03:21] Jimi: Roxy Usher?

[1:03:28] Tommy: I don't know.

[1:03:29] Jimi: You're the pants on the Roxy Usher.

[1:03:37] Tommy: Honestly.

[1:03:39] Jimi: Uh it'll be it'll be on Genius before this podcast is over, I'm sure.

[1:03:44] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.

[1:03:45] Jimi: This has been said. In fact, yeah, I'm gonna go put it up there just so nobody conceals this shit.

[1:03:50] Tommy: But yeah, Dave, if you're listening, surely to God, Roxy Usher.

[1:03:54] Jimi: Can you uh man the pants?

[1:03:56] Tommy: Ah, the Roxy Usher.

[1:03:58] Jimi: It's so it is so good, and like, you know, we refer to him by first name. I've had maybe like three conversations with Dave Malloy, fantastic guy, loved hanging out with him in the occasions we have.

[1:04:10] Tommy: Roxy Usher is one of those things where like you can't imagine that it was unintentional, but also having met Dave Malloy, it might have been.

[1:04:19] Jimi: Yeah, exactly. Who that who knows?

[1:04:24] Tommy: Who the f knows?

[1:04:25] Jimi: Doesn't matter. It is there and it works.

[1:04:29] Tommy: Oh man.

[1:04:30] Jimi: It does work. Isn't that funny? Roxy Usher.

[1:04:32] Tommy: Um I'm now trying to think if she ever says the word pants in the entire show.

[1:04:36] Jimi: No, I don't think she does.

[1:04:38] Tommy: That's just there's no other anything goes references in the rest of the show.

[1:04:43] Jimi: Sadly.

[1:04:44] Tommy: Um maybe that's what it's all about.

[1:04:46] Jimi: This is the intro to the Usher line.

[1:04:49] Tommy: Uh it's a a spooky family lost their child a long time ago, and they have some familial struggles.

[1:04:58] Jimi: Exactly. Um and Gelsey has an incredible opening speech that just brings it's again a classic Gelsey. I'm deeply in love with her.

[1:05:06] Tommy: Wonderful.

[1:05:07] Jimi: Because she she's the only person that can do it, and it's so great. My I love I love this bit in the live recording because it like it is it is spooky and creepy.

[1:05:19] Tommy: Yeah, and like intentionally so, and you can hear a couple chuckles from the audience.

[1:05:25] Jimi: I imagine because of how uncomfortable it is.

[1:05:28] Tommy: Yeah, it is.

[1:05:30] Jimi: It really, really is because it's very it's so very intimate.

[1:05:33] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:05:33] Jimi: That's the thing about Ghost Quartet, it's very intimate.

[1:05:35] Tommy: Well, and the the House of Usher, I think gives us some of the more pure horror bits, if we're talking about like specifically horror in the totally, because yeah, it's it's that gothic horror vibe.

[1:05:48] Jimi: Camera shop is spooky.

[1:05:50] Tommy: Um kind, you know, kind of spooky in the same way that like Charlie Brown in a ghost outfit is spooky, right?

[1:05:58] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:05:59] Tommy: Whereas it's just it's it's the hairs stand on end, whereas the horror.

[1:06:03] Jimi: This is like deeply, deeply evil and creepy.

[1:06:06] Tommy: Yeah, yeah.

[1:06:08] Jimi: Um so yes, that is the Usher family. We've met them, we'll come back to them quite shortly.

[1:06:13] Tommy: Several times.

[1:06:14] Jimi: Yes.

[1:06:15] Tommy: Um track six Soldier and Rose.

[1:06:25] Jimi: Do I do believe so true?

[1:06:42] Tommy: I don't believe in anything.

[1:06:47] Jimi: But if you wanna steal my hug, please wait up.

[1:06:54] Jimi: I'm drunk. Then take me on to the dance. And let me cry against your cheek. Then take me out back and shoot me in the alley. I won't speak.

[1:07:42] Tommy: So Jimi. This is Hi. This is my least favorite track on the album.

[1:07:45] Jimi: I get that. I get it. I get it. Um it you'll come back to it.

[1:07:55] Tommy: I don't though. It's been three days.

[1:07:58] Jimi: Yeah, sure. Fair. Absolutely. Because I I was I don't want to be the patronizing knob who's like, I know I was there too. Everyone has different artistic experiences. But yeah, I used to just be a bit like I love the tremble, love that. It's a pretty song. Um you know. But it never I never it took me a long time to get it. And there's some metaphorical discussion about like a a a soldier's um, you know, appreciation of death and embracing of death and how that relates to being a ghost and whatever the afterlife is in this discussion, which comes back in like the tango later on, like don't get me wrong, I see connections here. I the thing that bothers me, and maybe it's because I'm clinging to the narrative too much, but like one of the things we need to get is honey.

And we're getting honey for a bear, but in this one we're kind of playing fast and loose about like are we getting honey, the you know, d sweet liquid that bees make, or are we getting honey, the metaphor for sex? Um and it's it's never really explicitly defined either in either direction, which bothers me.

[1:09:08] Tommy: Yeah, and it we get it so early and kind of of nothing, and it doesn't come back in like big meaningful ways. I don't know.

[1:09:18] Jimi: Yes. Yeah, no, I I think um of all the objects, um this one and I guess the stardust, but the stardust uh is so much more of a through line. It kind of means something. It kind of means something more. We talk about stars so much more as the show goes on.

[1:09:35] Tommy: Yes, uh-huh. Um but I think the the pot of honey idea, I just feel like you could hardly expect it to just be a pot of honey.

[1:09:46] Jimi: Of course. It's not that it's not that simple of a show, of course.

[1:09:51] Tommy: Exactly. Um Yeah, no ca I I think I think you're totally right. Like it's it's uh you know, if they had an extra twenty minutes, they could probably delve into the soldier's background a bit more. Or where does he come from? Where does where like where does Rose meet him in her what universe?

[1:10:13] Jimi: Sure. You know?

[1:10:13] Tommy: Yeah. And for you know, we are there's lots of discussion of what the relationship between Rose and uh Pearl are as like meta characters throughout the show, and the answer is that they are each other's everything. Mother and daughter both directions, sisters in both directions, lovers in both directions, like they are each other's everything.

[1:10:37] Jimi: And this is the beginning of seeing a moment where they are lovers, which we don't see a lot of throughout the show. We see a lot of other relationships. Um narratively, I get why that's important. Um I think um just to highlight to so you can put um thingies in my for my uh thesis.

[1:11:00] Tommy: Yes like little sticky notes.

[1:11:01] Jimi: Of course. The sticky notes that we'll put here. Um we'll take we'll go right to the end of the song.

[1:11:07] Tommy: Yes. After post wooing, um uh Gelsey's been wooed, the soldier has been wooed.

[1:11:13] Jimi: Yes. Fine with it, she gets what's going on. Um she says, I'm a soldier, I don't believe in anything, but if you're gonna steal my honey, please wait until I'm drunk. Here's kind of our first I think our first talk of being drunk.

[1:11:30] Tommy: Yeah, we do the the camera shop owner offers her whiskey, um but that's pretty brief.

[1:11:37] Jimi: Yes. But the the like of alcohol.

[1:11:41] Tommy: Yeah, for sure.

[1:11:43] Jimi: Yep. Um and it's a very it it is prevalent throughout the whole show.

[1:11:49] Tommy: Yes.

[1:11:49] Jimi: Um it keeps coming back to uh uh negative relationship with alcohol.

[1:11:54] Tommy: Yes. It's always it's a very underpinning thing.

[1:11:57] Jimi: Well it's this what I'm gonna say is Ghost Quartet isn't an allegory about alcoholism.

[1:12:03] Tommy: Sure.

[1:12:04] Jimi: I don't think that it talks about the fallback, the indulgence, the sloth. I would I would counter that I think Ghost Quartet talks about the duality of drinking. Because there's a song later on called uh My Four Friends. Um like that and you know the discussion of like being empty in both ways, being empty, ready to receive something, but also being empty, totally depleted. Um like I get the sense that we're seeing this is the first time we're seeing I no, I think in this moment we're seeing both sides of that drunkenness. Both sides of what being drunk could mean.

[1:12:11] Tommy: I would I would contend in my annotations on your thesis that the soldier, you know, you could read this in both ways. If you're gonna steal my honey, the thing that I'm guarding or whatever, um please wait until I'm drunk. Either please wait until I am so stupefied that I don't even care anymore.

[1:13:09] Jimi: Or please wait until I have reached this point of euphoria where I at least have something better than this non-feeling that I'm having right now.

[1:13:19] Tommy: Um fascinating. That's fascinating way to think about that.

[1:13:24] Jimi: Um as we go because there's lots of there's lots of word choice that you said there that fits completely into what I think is the core theme of uh Ghost Quartet. And I've never thought about the alcohol going the other way. That's really interesting.

[1:13:39] Tommy: Well, I think um and I, you know, he's he's kind of open about it, but as we see, like this in many ways, the show is a delve into Dave Malloy's head. But lots of lots of authors talk about this about how you know, wanting to or needing to or trying to feel a little drunk before they do their work. Um, we'd start this podcast by asking each other what we drank at the beginning of it.

[1:14:02] Jimi: And that is for sure a double edged sword, right?

[1:14:07] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:14:08] Jimi: Like the idea of is it gonna stupefy you or make you dumber and all these terrible things that are absolutely real about alcoholism and drunkenness and all these things. But also, so many artists and wonderful things throughout the ages have felt this need to be drunk or intoxicated to create their art, often to the detriment of those around them and like in terrible ways, but sometimes not.

[1:14:32] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:14:33] Jimi: I we should every time drunk comes up, look at it a little bit.

[1:14:38] Tommy: I I agree. Um I would say though, with soldier, I think it's the negative.

[1:14:44] Jimi: Sure.

[1:14:44] Tommy: I think I just because it prefaces it with I don't believe in anything.

[1:14:49] Jimi: Right.

[1:14:50] Tommy: This is someone who is at the end of it all.

[1:14:51] Jimi: Right.

[1:14:52] Tommy: And I think that's why it's a soldier.

[1:14:53] Jimi: Yes.

[1:14:53] Tommy: Yeah, at the absolute end of everything, and the one thing that's gonna make it a little better is a drink.

[1:15:01] Jimi: Yep.

[1:15:02] Tommy: Yep, yep, yep. Um, this idea of kind of uh wastedness, um, the cynicism uh very much is uh a big privilege set the character.

[1:15:17] Jimi: Um you don't watch Twin Peaks, do you?

[1:15:19] Tommy: I do not watch Twin Peaks.

[1:15:20] Jimi: Okay. There's a thing, any of our Twin Peaks fans out there, um, they'll know what I mean when I say Garmambosia.

[1:15:27] Tommy: Okay.

[1:15:28] Jimi: You'll obviously know what I mean by that. Garmimbose is creamed corn.

[1:15:32] Tommy: Gross.

[1:15:34] Jimi: Yep. And it is um consumed by the people from the Black Lodge.

[1:15:38] Tommy: Okay.

[1:15:39] Jimi: Um, and what Garmambosia is, i in our world it is represented by creamed corn.

[1:15:45] Tommy: Okay.

[1:15:45] Jimi: Um for them, it is uh a manifestation of hate and fear and negativity.

[1:15:53] Tommy: Okay.

[1:15:54] Jimi: Um so it I why did I bring that up?

[1:16:00] Tommy: Drink.

[1:16:00] Jimi: It it flashed into me.

[1:16:02] Tommy: Yeah, it is.

[1:16:02] Jimi: It's it's the idea of like this thing that you indulge in. That is this embodiment of the evil's not the right word. Uh but evil evil works. Like negativity, badness.

[1:16:17] Tommy: The low.

[1:16:18] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:16:18] Tommy: Yes, the low.

[1:16:19] Jimi: That's a good way to put it. Exactly. Exactly.

[1:16:22] Tommy: Um and so this battle between choosing the low, choosing the euphoria.

[1:16:29] Jimi: Yeah, it will we'll meet.

[1:16:31] Tommy: Yes.

[1:16:31] Jimi: Yeah. I mean, I absolutely we will. I think that's half the battle of this show. As we move into the end of side one, track seven.

[1:16:40] Tommy: My god, track seven. Any kind of dead person. And if you could be a dead guy, what kind of dead guy would you be?

[1:17:02] Jimi: Don't wanna be a zombie, because zombies are just good fun. Don't want to be a vampire because they can't feel the sun. Don't want to be a medical corpses, ghost would cut me wrong. No, I just want to be a ghost and go. What fun. One of my favorite songs in the show. It's so It's a break. It's perfect and easy and like shows that like if Dave Malloy wanted to go out and write a new anything goes. Like I think he would hate it the whole time. But could do it in a hardcore. It's a catchy musical theater song.

[1:17:50] Tommy: Any kind of dead person. Um if you could be any kind of dead person, what would you be?

[1:17:55] Jimi: I'd be a ghost. Dun dun dun dun dun dun dun, right? Um who knew there were so many different types of dead people.

[1:18:02] Tommy: Oh, it's so it's a nice it's a nice little patter laundry list song, ain't it? Good old-fashioned musical theater patter song.

[1:18:08] Jimi: A classic.

[1:18:09] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:18:10] Jimi: Um, and it nicely relaxes us from the literally one hour of talk that we've done. As I said early on, like this is this is one of the breaks that you get. This is one of the you know, you get to take off your mask for a second and embrace and have this little song. They in the live performance, they hand out rhythm instruments and everyone gets to play along.

[1:18:32] Tommy: Yes, that's something that we should talk about. So what did you get to play?

[1:18:34] Jimi: That is an amazing thing. I didn't get anything the first time.

[1:18:40] Tommy: Okay.

[1:18:40] Jimi: Um, for this one. I got a shaker because I pretty much asked for it in the finale.

[1:18:48] Tommy: Okay. Come to that. But yes, it it is such a lovely thing, and it's just, you know, they're pr they're instantly breaking the fourth wall because until this moment, yes, Dave talks to us, but it's very much in the I'm a performer talking to you.

[1:19:01] Jimi: Right.

[1:19:01] Tommy: But when they come out and they're giving instruments, they're they're not in character at all. Well, they are Dave Gelsey Britain and they're letting you break your character as invisible audience member, too.

[1:19:13] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:19:14] Tommy: Which is important.

[1:19:15] Jimi: Exactly. And you know, a Dave Malloy staple, like Great Comet does this to great success as well. Um in appropriately narrative moments where we need to acknowledge that we are a group of people experiencing this story together for a second.

[1:19:30] Tommy: Exactly.

[1:19:31] Jimi: It's community. It's in in many ways that is what theatre should be. Oklahoma's doing it right now in Circle in the Square.

[1:19:37] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:19:38] Jimi: You're sharing experience together.

[1:19:40] Tommy: Yeah, absolutely. And like don't forget it. You know, good good to have it this early on.

[1:19:45] Jimi: Hey, don't forget it.

[1:19:46] Tommy: We're all here.

[1:19:47] Jimi: Stanislavski is rolling in his grave.

[1:19:50] Tommy: I do have, and I think this is the eternal mystery. On the live recording, they have at the end of the thing, Dave goes, and that is the end of side one. And has some like little spiel about like we need to pick up all the percussion instruments so they don't make any noise. And then he has one line where it sounds like one has gotten lost, or like catches up to like hand them, and Dave goes, Oh, especially that one, that's the worst one.

[1:20:15] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:20:15] Tommy: Which one's the worst one?

[1:20:18] Jimi: I would imagine it's a shaker.

[1:20:20] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:20:21] Jimi: Because shakers are the worst.

[1:20:23] Tommy: Do you not think about it?

[1:20:28] Jimi: We're about to we're about to have some some podcast prop comedy here.

[1:20:32] Tommy: Right.

[1:20:33] Jimi: Right? Whatever they do.

[1:20:36] Tommy: It's making even if even if they're just sitting, yeah, right?

[1:20:39] Jimi: I'm gonna cross my legs.

[1:20:41] Tommy: We can hear everyone adjusting myself in the seat.

[1:20:46] Jimi: Like it's in my hands, it's gonna make sound.

[1:20:49] Tommy: Also, this is the great comet shaker.

[1:20:51] Jimi: Just for brings back good memories.

[1:20:55] Tommy: This is the avant garde theater piece I'm gonna make where everyone has to hold shakers the entire time, but you're told not to make noise, and it's all about boring people and seeing how fidgety they get.

[1:21:05] Jimi: Exactly.

[1:21:05] Tommy: We'll do it'll be the sequel to my uh communal lighting design number where everyone in the audience gets a flashlight and you get to decide what you want to look at.

[1:21:13] Jimi: Um I love that.

[1:21:14] Tommy: Oh my Christ! Wouldn't that be fun?

[1:21:16] Jimi: Freak for that idea built up develop it.

[1:21:18] Tommy: Tommy picked that idea, nobody else steal that.

[1:21:21] Jimi: I'll work on that with you.

[1:21:23] Tommy: Um anyway, any kind of dead person, hugely important.

[1:21:26] Jimi: Don't get me wrong. We are like the thesis of the song, if you could be any kind of dead person, what would you be?

[1:21:32] Tommy: I'd be a ghost.

[1:21:34] Jimi: Um like if we are exploding the library of sci-fi oogie boogie characters that could exist, which one do you think is best?

[1:21:45] Tommy: Oh, I think it's a ghost, and go woo-woo-woo all night long, right?

[1:21:49] Jimi: Not hugely in like they're not uh putting a spotlight on it and saying, hey, hey, hey, this is important.

[1:21:56] Tommy: But again, it's called ghost quartet.

[1:21:58] Jimi: The punchline of this song is I'd be a ghost. There has to be something important about it.

[1:22:03] Tommy: Um disagree.

[1:22:07] Jimi: Okay.

[1:22:08] Tommy: I think this is the one where it's like I have no idea what's going on.

[1:22:14] Jimi: You think this is just a big thing.

[1:22:15] Tommy: Then they start talking about ghosts.

[1:22:16] Jimi: This is this is the thing.

[1:22:17] Tommy: They start talking about ghosts, so it's like, oh, it's ghosts, ghost for that.

[1:22:20] Jimi: This is the ghost.

[1:22:20] Tommy: I've got it, I've got it.

[1:22:21] Jimi: You think this is like the third movement of Balaga where we're just running around and smashing pictures on each other?

[1:22:27] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:22:27] Jimi: I think this is the like because I do know do you not agree?

[1:22:30] Tommy: Like if you are so confused, which you could easily be.

[1:22:33] Jimi: Sure.

[1:22:34] Tommy: Right?

[1:22:34] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:22:34] Tommy: You're not following.

[1:22:35] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:22:35] Tommy: Here they're talking about ghosts.

[1:22:37] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:22:38] Tommy: That's the thing that is on the poster.

[1:22:40] Jimi: Yeah, but that's the thing that's on the poster because this is this concept that Dave Malloy has that there is no English word for, but we're using the word ghost for.

[1:22:49] Tommy: Yeah, totally.

[1:22:49] Jimi: But I mean, as in like I am lost at sea.

[1:22:52] Tommy: You know, I mean, I'm not getting this.

[1:22:54] Jimi: This is the thing that stops me from leaving the theater because I'm not getting it.

[1:22:58] Tommy: Sure.

[1:22:58] Jimi: This is the one it's like, oh, it's about ghosts.

[1:23:00] Tommy: Right.

[1:23:00] Jimi: And I can't leave yet because I'm still holding a shaker.

[1:23:02] Tommy: But Yeah, that's it.

[1:23:04] Jimi: But yes.

[1:23:05] Tommy: I I would wager, and we're only on side one, so we're not quite at thesis forming time yet.

[1:23:11] Jimi: No.

[1:23:11] Tommy: But if a conceit of the show is something like we all exist through the this communal transference of memory and character, which is certainly a theme of this show.

[1:23:27] Jimi: And one of the human ways to explain that ethereal transference is the existence of ghosts.

[1:23:36] Tommy: Or is the concept of ghosts or the idea of ghosts or the human fascination with ghosts it's important that we say ghost sixteen times in this song.

[1:23:49] Jimi: Yeah, but I think that's as important as it is.

[1:23:52] Tommy: Oh, for sure.

[1:23:52] Jimi: I mean, we rhyme it with toast.

[1:23:54] Tommy: Like, don't this is I think it's just it's a flagpole.

[1:23:58] Jimi: It's a flagpole, but it uh but some of these songs in shows, as I think we'll get to when we talk about our next podcast uh podcast show, sometimes you reach these charm songs and shows, and it's just because we needed a tap dance number right now.

[1:23:58] Tommy: And it's just because we needed a toe tapper right now.

[1:24:17] Jimi: And I I want to put my flag in the sand and say, like, no, no, no, this is still a little more important than that.

[1:24:24] Tommy: If I could be anything, I could be a ghost.

[1:24:27] Jimi: I'm confounded with music and babies and laughter, stories and goodness, infinity and luck.

[1:24:35] Tommy: I'm confused by the notion that somebody loves me and drugs make me crazy.

[1:24:41] Jimi: And a Clara Boyne told me once I'm not an old soul.

[1:24:45] Tommy: Oh Lord, I wish I could sing like that.

[1:24:51] Jimi: But I don't practice enough.

[1:24:54] Tommy: Practice, practice- No, I don't practice no.

[1:24:58] Jimi: Practice, practice.

[1:25:01] Tommy: Side two.

[1:25:02] Jimi: Track one.

[1:25:03] Tommy: The Astronomer.

[1:25:04] Jimi: Yes.

[1:25:05] Tommy: Okay.

[1:25:06] Jimi: And it it works so well.

[1:25:09] Tommy: Like, in terms of story structuring, they know what they're doing.

[1:25:13] Jimi: This works very well.

[1:25:14] Tommy: We're meeting a new character.

[1:25:15] Jimi: We're meeting a new character.

[1:25:16] Tommy: And it's been this long.

[1:25:17] Jimi: We've heard about the astronomer before, although his mission might have gone past you because it does go by pretty quickly.

[1:25:24] Tommy: Exactly.

[1:25:24] Jimi: But the astronomer, in the two sisters story, is that was lovely.

[1:25:29] Tommy: Thank you.

[1:25:30] Jimi: Is the antagonist.

[1:25:34] Tommy: Right, with wobbles, another person in the soup.

[1:25:37] Jimi: He's not a good guy.

[1:25:40] Tommy: Is anyone?

[1:25:41] Jimi: Right.

[1:25:41] Tommy: Sure.

[1:25:42] Jimi: He's not a good guy in the uh single-dimensional telling of this storyline.

[1:25:48] Tommy: Is that fair?

[1:25:51] Jimi: Jimmy Show.

[1:25:52] Tommy: He's made choices.

[1:25:53] Jimi: He's made choices.

[1:25:54] Tommy: Sure.

[1:25:54] Jimi: That's fair.

[1:25:55] Tommy: As is everyone else.

[1:25:56] Jimi: In well.

[1:26:00] Tommy: Yeah, I get I I get you.

[1:26:03] Jimi: I get you like kill you.

[1:26:05] Tommy: I'm just, I'm that wanker who's loath to think of anyone as one dimensional.

[1:26:09] Jimi: Right.

[1:26:09] Tommy: Well, and I mean that's part of the stuff.

[1:26:11] Jimi: Especially something like this.

[1:26:12] Tommy: What's that line where it says Rose is everyone or Rose is just like everyone.

[1:26:16] Jimi: Um Rose is the same as everybody else.

[1:26:18] Tommy: So is the astronomer.

[1:26:20] Jimi: Um absolutely, we're all the same.

[1:26:24] Tommy: We'll have choices.

[1:26:25] Jimi: Sh sure.

[1:26:26] Tommy: Our previous introduction to the astronomer would have characterized him as a protagonist.

[1:26:31] Jimi: Or as an antagonist.

[1:26:33] Tommy: Yes.

[1:26:33] Jimi: And this is when we meet him.

[1:26:35] Tommy: If you're wanting one, pick him.

[1:26:39] Jimi: Right? It's that kind of thing.

[1:26:41] Tommy: If you really, really want an antagonist, you'll do.

[1:26:44] Jimi: More I mean up to this point, prior to the astronomer.

[1:26:47] Tommy: Not that I think he's gonna have some big redeeming song at the end.

[1:26:51] Jimi: Like, but up until this point, until we've met him, he fit the role of the antagonist.

[1:26:57] Tommy: He was the one that started the problem.

[1:27:01] Jimi: From Rose's from Rose's telling of the story.

[1:27:03] Tommy: We don't know that yet, but that's what I mean.

[1:27:06] Jimi: Like, did he?

[1:27:07] Tommy: These are questions you're asking and smirking at me because of things we learn later in the Not necessarily.

[1:27:07] Jimi: Not necessarily.

[1:27:16] Tommy: Because I yeah, I don't want to, I don't want to get into the the meat of it now, but all we know so far about the astronomer is that he loved Gelsey and not Rose.

[1:27:29] Jimi: And as an audience, like I'm not saying, like, no moral judgment on the on the character of the non-timeline characters in the story.

[1:27:39] Tommy: No judgment based on like whether or not you agree with these people.

[1:27:43] Jimi: In the progression of Ghost Quartet, the show that we've been watching so far.

[1:27:48] Tommy: Where it has been telegraphed to us, as you agreed, that Rose, the ethereal character, is kind of a good guy.

[1:27:56] Jimi: That we're told.

[1:27:57] Tommy: I didn't say good guy, I said protagonist.

[1:28:00] Jimi: Ah, you frustrate me.

[1:28:02] Tommy: I choose my words very well, Thomas.

[1:28:05] Jimi: Because there's no good guys.

[1:28:07] Tommy: Fair.

[1:28:08] Jimi: But that's not a thing we've learned yet.

[1:28:10] Tommy: Right?

[1:28:11] Jimi: You're coming at this, and this is what I mean, and this is why I think our opinions are important diff importantly difference in this.

[1:28:16] Tommy: In the same way that you agree with Mrs. Lovett and Sweeney Todd at the end of Act One, right?

[1:28:21] Jimi: They're bad guys by the end of the show.

[1:28:25] Tommy: Um of all the things.

[1:28:27] Jimi: But uh Yes.

[1:28:30] Tommy: We I totally know what you mean.

[1:28:32] Jimi: If you are watching the show for the first time, as intended at this point, as intended, as all as I always say, all musical should at their core be created for.

[1:28:44] Tommy: For a first-time viewer, someone going into the show, not knowing anything.

[1:28:48] Jimi: At this point, Rose fits the archetypal characterization of a protagonist.

[1:28:55] Tommy: And the astronomer, until we've met him, fits the archetype archetypal characterization of an antagonist.

[1:29:02] Jimi: And this is important because of the reversal that you're embodying that we experience later, right?

[1:29:08] Tommy: I think it's important to the story that you're convinced one way, at least a little bit, before you start going the other way.

[1:29:15] Jimi: It's why this story's told out of order.

[1:29:19] Tommy: It's why we haven't met the astronomer yet.

[1:29:22] Jimi: I just find it really difficult to agree with that.

[1:29:28] Tommy: Okay.

[1:29:29] Jimi: Because when you watch it, there's nothing archetypal about a him being an antagonist.

[1:29:38] Tommy: And like you say, if you've missed it, you just see him right now.

[1:29:41] Jimi: Sure.

[1:29:42] Tommy: You accept him, you accept him for face value.

[1:29:45] Jimi: Sure.

[1:29:45] Tommy: Fair.

[1:29:45] Jimi: And it's Dave Malloy.

[1:29:47] Tommy: Right.

[1:29:47] Jimi: You know, I mean, he's already had two other roles.

[1:29:49] Tommy: Right.

[1:29:49] Jimi: And has been the guy.

[1:29:50] Tommy: And he's the maestro of the whole thing.

[1:29:52] Jimi: The guy telling you to tell yourself turn your cell phone off, which is still a part of the performance, whether you want it to be or not.

[1:29:57] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:29:58] Jimi: So you know, I don't think you I don't think you do think of him as the antagonist.

[1:30:05] Tommy: Okay.

[1:30:06] Jimi: If you went into this blind, I don't think you would.

[1:30:08] Tommy: Okay.

[1:30:08] Jimi: And that was the end of the podcast.

[1:30:10] Tommy: And that was the end of the podcast part two.

[1:30:13] Jimi: If only.

[1:30:14] Tommy: If only.

[1:30:15] Jimi: No, we've got six more hours to go, folks.

[1:30:18] Tommy: Yep.

[1:30:19] Jimi: Um, okay, anyway, whoever he may be, this is who he is.

[1:30:26] Tommy: Um he basically because this is basically him just it's a song about him.

[1:30:30] Jimi: Yes.

[1:30:30] Tommy: It it it is a character introduction song at its core, right?

[1:30:34] Jimi: Yep.

[1:30:34] Tommy: I'm the astronomer.

[1:30:36] Jimi: Yep.

[1:30:38] Tommy: Um, and again, we start to see some of the themes that we're noticing and sticking as as we go through.

[1:30:48] Jimi: Um because he is talking about these wondrous things.

[1:30:55] Tommy: He's an astronomer, he's a man who deals in the cosmos.

[1:30:59] Jimi: Right.

[1:31:00] Tommy: That is his bailiwick, as Tommy would say.

[1:31:03] Jimi: Yes.

[1:31:05] Tommy: Um and he compares himself by he uh through uh negatives, basically, that he's not a priest and he's not a monk, but still is saying that like in relation to those things, he is an astronomer.

[1:31:21] Jimi: And so we are putting astronomy and the observation of the stars on this kind of ethereal level, I would wait.

[1:31:29] Tommy: Yes.

[1:31:30] Jimi: Man of science.

[1:31:31] Tommy: Yes.

[1:31:31] Jimi: Man of faith.

[1:31:32] Tommy: Man of science and well, but like our first loss reference of the evening.

[1:31:36] Jimi: God.

[1:31:36] Tommy: Um like a Oh, take note, there's lots coming.

[1:31:39] Jimi: I oh, I'm so excited.

[1:31:41] Tommy: Um, like akin to priestliness, he is an astronomer.

[1:31:45] Jimi: Yes, exactly.

[1:31:47] Tommy: And as it's and it brings it up at the end of the song as well.

[1:31:50] Jimi: Um, that you know, he talks about faith, he has a relationship with faith.

[1:31:56] Tommy: Yes.

[1:31:57] Jimi: But he's looking at it through a lens.

[1:32:00] Tommy: He is an astronomer looking at things through his telescope.

[1:32:05] Jimi: Um he is, like, through that, and through having that lack of faith, um resigns himself.

[1:32:21] Tommy: Yes.

[1:32:22] Jimi: To like only knowing so much.

[1:32:25] Tommy: There is discussion later on, as you're right, man of science, man of faith, um, about like can you only be sure of the things you've seen?

[1:32:35] Jimi: Yes.

[1:32:36] Tommy: And an astronomer is it's a it's a perfect metaphor for that.

[1:32:40] Jimi: Is like we're not really sure about all of this until we look at it, and even when we do, we're only kind of sure of it, and we get more and more sure about it, but then we discover new and bizarre things that we become more sure about.

[1:32:52] Tommy: Exactly.

[1:32:53] Jimi: Because you would think that a man who deals in stars can accept something bigger than himself.

[1:32:59] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:33:00] Jimi: I mean, I I think it is uh no small coincidence that humanly depictions and ideals of God or otherworldly beings always exist in the sky and above us.

[1:33:15] Tommy: The sky, exactly.

[1:33:16] Jimi: You know, from from Roman and Greek mythology through to you know contemporary depictions of the uh Catholic god.

[1:33:23] Tommy: Um like it's up there because that's the beyond, that's what we don't know about.

[1:33:29] Jimi: Um but astronomy is the thing that seeks to make sense of all that.

[1:33:33] Jimi: Exactly. Which is it's a really interesting and important, I think, characterization and parallel. So I think what we find is that by the end of this song, we go along with him for the ride, and then we find out that actually the astronomer is just another person, like I say, in the soup.

[1:33:52] Tommy: Yes.

[1:33:53] Jimi: He's just another one who's swilling around, yes is aware of this.

[1:33:58] Tommy: Yeah, cool, yeah, that's fantastic over there.

[1:34:01] Jimi: CBA. But it is not priestly or godly or otherworldly or has any clairvoyance.

[1:34:09] Tommy: Nope.

[1:34:10] Jimi: Not at all. Um there's lots of the thing that I think is quite important is that there's lots of I wish.

[1:34:20] Tommy: Yeah, sure.

[1:34:21] Jimi: There's lots of well, he says I wish I could sing like that a lot. Um that's quite important because it's that's a passive thing. Compare that to Star Child, I will. Whereas I will, it's a vow.

[1:34:36] Tommy: Yeah, I wish is completely different.

[1:34:40] Jimi: Yeah. Completely different. Um, and I think that's very crucial. In why the astronomer is the antagonist and Star Child is the protagonist.

[1:34:51] Tommy: Absolutely. He's the I'll totally give you that Star Child's the protagonist, but we'll come back to that.

[1:34:52] Jimi: We'll come back to that. Um, that's that is the astronomer. Great song. Beautiful song. Love it.

[1:35:01] Tommy: Dave Loy's so cute when he sings it.

[1:35:06] Jimi: So cute. He always cute. He writes the same characters for himself. Have you noticed this?

[1:35:10] Tommy: Um hold the astronomer up next to Pierre. Hold the astronomer up next to King Hrothgar and Beowulf, yeah.

[1:35:20] Jimi: Yeah. It's yeah. Yeah. He knows he knows where he's doing wrong.

[1:35:25] Tommy: Well, uh, sure. Uh I think more, you know, you write what you know the best.

[1:35:34] Jimi: And exactly. And he does that, like this kind of existential quandary mixed with dead dread uh dread about the world beyond and what we may or may not know yet. Ghost Quartet. Right, a musical by Dave Malloy. Um they don't have computers or any of that shit, and everyone's mind is just fine. They just hang out in nature all the time.

[1:35:59] Tommy: Only it's better because it's perfect nature with no bugs or humidity and no bread.

[1:36:04] Jimi: It's not so perfect, it's boring. They figure that out too. So there's like gray days and rain and stuff, which is fine, because everyone likes to be a little sad some of the time and watch the rain on the windowsills. Because they're all soul.

[1:36:20] Tommy: I mean, they are all soul. Did you know that Rose is a star child?

[1:36:25] Jimi: That's right. She's a freaking star child! So I'm sorry if this is like sad for you, but you're gonna be dead in like 30 years. And even less if you two keep drinking, like wood, and when you meet me over there, you'll see, and you'll think, gosh, that 30 years of being sad was just stupid. Who cares anymore? Because now it's just an eternity of soul and swimming.

[1:36:43] Tommy: And fruit.

[1:36:54] Jimi: So why don't you just shut up? Why don't you just have another fucking drink and shut the fuck up?

[1:37:00] Tommy: Skip side two, track two.

[1:37:02] Jimi: Not skip it.

[1:37:03] Tommy: No.

[1:37:04] Jimi: Talk about it. It's it's mostly it's mostly a scene.

[1:37:08] Tommy: It's a scoray!

[1:37:12] Jimi: So yeah, this is the one. If you're listening to the studio recording, you won't get this.

[1:37:17] Tommy: No, it's gone.

[1:37:17] Jimi: You should this and it's worth listening to on the live recording. Um it is. It's a meeting between the Usher family about Roxy's imaginary friend Rose.

[1:37:31] Tommy: Names get confusing here.

[1:37:34] Jimi: Yes. Um Roxy's imaginary friend Rose.

[1:37:37] Tommy: Yes.

[1:37:38] Jimi: Um to me. Family meeting. Uh-huh. So crucial. So important. To the whole sheback.

[1:37:48] Tommy: Oh, yes.

[1:37:48] Jimi: Um. Because uh who is Rose? Right? That is the question that this this number calls calls up, right?

[1:37:59] Tommy: It is.

[1:38:00] Jimi: Well, from the facts, who is Rose? Right. And is it and uh is Roxy different than Rose? Rose wanted to answer. You want to get to answer that? You can't answer this.

[1:38:09] Tommy: Yes, that's the point of the whole show.

[1:38:11] Jimi: Well, you can, because Roxy is it's Roxy's imagin is Roxy's imaginary friend. Right. Called Rose, who's told her that she is a Star Child. Right, yes, because she's Star Child, but also Roxy then ends up embodying Star Child. Like they're all the same person.

[1:38:28] Tommy: No, Roxy's daughter is Star Child.

[1:38:34] Jimi: See now you're d you're pointing at the wall with all the yarns on it.

[1:38:39] Tommy: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.

[1:38:41] Jimi: Um the Yes. So yeah, Starchild, this is this is where this is into the Star Child world. Um basically Roxy's experience with Rose, this Star Child, um, is that she wants her to cross over to this perfect world of joy and joyness and uh everything's fab, but it's not too fab.

[1:39:11] Tommy: It's not too fabulous.

[1:39:14] Jimi: A little bit sad, because that's important. Um but it's all soul.

[1:39:19] Tommy: Yes.

[1:39:20] Jimi: Right? Um this to me is like this is the thing.

[1:39:29] Tommy: Yeah, okay.

[1:39:30] Jimi: What do you This is the world? What do you what do you mean? Because I have ideas too, but

[1:39:38] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:39:38] Jimi: This is the this is the I want. This is the option, this is the choice. Okay. Right. What Ro um what Rose, what this star child, this person talking to Roxy from the beyond, um can be whatever you make of it, but to me it's like it's the childhood, it's the imagination, it's the spirit, it's the hope, it's it's the last thing in Pandora's box.

[1:40:09] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:40:10] Jimi: You know what I mean? Yeah. It's the it's the magic of it all that you don't want to lose, and that every single person in this show regrets losing.

[1:40:20] Tommy: Fair.

[1:40:21] Jimi: I think because what's what's the other half of it as portrayed in this is your mortality. Right? That's that's the choice that like Roxy is is portraying to her parents. Is like you could go to this world where everything's beautiful, um, and it's all wonderful and we all exist as soul, or you can continue to live on this earth as your singular person, where all you know is who you are. And do you believe that there is this great beyond for lack of a better terminology around it?

[1:41:05] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[1:41:07] Jimi: Um, you know, like everyone else in this scene, their motivation is like, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. That's that's just death. That's that's terrible. It's silly.

[1:41:20] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:41:21] Jimi: Everything she's talking about, you know, I mean, they say it's silly.

[1:41:24] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:41:25] Jimi: Um, and like that is, and when we get to hero, I think that becomes the question, right? Um, you know, it is like without without saying it from a surface level reading, like uh uh Roxy is advocating suicide here, right? Through the perspective of her parents.

[1:41:44] Tommy: Yeah, yes.

[1:41:49] Jimi: Okay. And like she certainly in her brain, she's thinking it of it as something much greater than that, crossing over, um, you know, joining the eternal consciousness of the beyond, right? And all these terms that we can't quite talk around it. And we've just sat here for a side and a half of music seeing the crossovers between these beyonds, so we're somewhat inclined to believe her. But also we have our own human experience, and these are called into conflict in the existence of this scene.

[1:42:22] Tommy: Exactly.

[1:42:23] Jimi: I think um the fact that that Roxy is young and is looking at it through a young lens, um that's kind of why it feels like the death, or you know, I mean, that's the discrepancy that we're seeing. I think as you get older, it becomes a different thing. It's you know, I mean, g it gets talked about so much in the real world, in fiction. I we've talked we've talked about it in the podcast before.

[1:42:53] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:42:54] Jimi: Um with historic materials, for example, um, the idea that you give up your innocence, you lose your innocence, and with that goes a whole lot of other stuff. Yeah. And you gain something different, but you've lost something, and you can't have both.

[1:43:07] Tommy: And you can't have both.

[1:43:16] Jimi: Yeah. Um what and that to me that this is what Ghost Quartet is. Right.

[1:43:22] Tommy: Well, and harkens back to if, say, you know, Star Child is setting us up for this, right? I will be everything that I can. And so being everything that you can be is crossing over, is joining this eternal consciousness. And you know, not too many spoilers yet, although hopefully you listen to it all together. The question then becomes did the mega character of Rose do like one, get what she wanted, and two, do what she needed to to get what she wanted.

[1:43:55] Jimi: Yep.

[1:43:56] Tommy: Um and the idea being that there's always another chance.

[1:43:56] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:43:56] Tommy: There's always another chance to get into this world. To me, like what I'm what I picture when I think about it is that there's a swirling sphere.

[1:44:13] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:44:13] Tommy: And around it is this other world of the Star Child.

[1:44:18] Jimi: Yeah. Well, this is I mean.

[1:44:20] Tommy: And if you can part the veil.

[1:44:23] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:44:24] Tommy: You can jump through.

[1:44:25] Jimi: This is this is the fascinating and wonderful part of the show. And you know, I I stumbled upon the verbiage for it earlier, but I do think it is appropriate that like ghost is just a word we're using to describe something that we don't have a word for. But this entire show is a contemplation about the beyond of human existence. Calling into all sorts of cultural touchstones of how people have approached that before. From religion, from exploration of the literal cosmos, from the exploration of horror and the dead and what happens to the dead, and what are the living do around the dead, and how do our souls continue? Um, like this is the beautiful thing about this show, and we are encountering it only about halfway through.

[1:45:15] Jimi: Um, but that like Dave Malloy is engaging in this conversation that I think humanity has been having since we've been able to have conscious thought.

[1:45:31] Tommy: Yeah, yeah, completely.

[1:45:32] Jimi: It's the beyond.

[1:45:34] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:45:35] Jimi: It's the beyond, and it's how is it I just think the question that it's posing is it possible to have that?

[1:45:43] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:45:45] Jimi: In the real world.

[1:45:46] Tommy: Right.

[1:45:47] Jimi: Yeah. And the whole scene ends with, why don't you just have another fucking drink and shut the fuck up?

[1:45:55] Tommy: Exactly.

[1:45:59] Jimi: Well, it's more important because it leads us into four friends. And we will find out all about four friends on site two of this podcast. So how are we doing? Are we are we following along? Well, we're about an hour and a half in, and I don't know about you all, but uh that whiskey has made me need a toilet break. So uh go have a little rest, maybe refill, uh, and then nestle back down uh for site two for even more ghostly movements. Waha, etc.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred