Happy Hour #80: Podcast and Be Gay - 'Candide' Support the Show ➤ Hold onto your optimism as this time around the riverbend Jimi and Tommy are talking all about Leonard Bernstein’s ‘Candide'.’ With a history full of as many twists and turns as the show itself, ‘Candide’ offers a wealth of fascinating discussion... Read More
From the show: Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour
About
Happy Hour #80: Podcast and Be Gay - 'Candide'
Hold onto your optimism as this time around the riverbend Jimi and Tommy are talking all about Leonard Bernstein’s ‘Candide'.’ With a history full of as many twists and turns as the show itself, ‘Candide’ offers a wealth of fascinating discussion. The boys try and piece together why this show has had some many wildly different incarnations, debate the existence of philosophy in the show and try to answer the unaswerable question: what is the difference between opera and musical theatre?
Candide (Original Broadway Cast Recording)
SHOW NOTES
If you’ve never experienced ‘Candide’ before, the best place to start is the 1974 ‘Chelsea’ recording as it includes clips from scenes as well as Bernstein’s beautiful music!
We also want to send out a massive thank you to Colden for sharing his bountiful knowledge of the show with us and helping us traverse the behemoth that is ‘Candide.’
If you’re ready to start learning all about the different productions and versions of the show then the best place to look is the Sondheim Guide online! It’s so extremely comprehensive you’d think Tommy had made it.
We didn’t get the opportunity to talk much about it in the episode, but it’s safe to say ‘Glitter and Be Gay’ is as iconic a musical theatre song as any other. Check out the delightful Kirsten Chenoweth singing it here in the Lincoln Centre production!
Who among us can answer the eternal question - where is the line between opera and musical theatre? Tell us on Twitter!
If you’re ready for some perplexity of a different sense to ‘Candide’ then have a look at ‘The Adding Machine.’
A Crooner’s Quiz Question
Sammy Davis Jr. was originally slated to originate this role in it’s pre-musical incarnation. Who knows if the show have been such a runaway success were it more rat-pack in style?
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Jimi: Go ham on those eggs.
[0:02] Tommy: Away we go.
[0:04] Jimi: Keish, did you just say quiche?
[0:06] Tommy: No, I said yeesh, but I should say quiche.
[0:08] Jimi: That would have been so good if you said quiche.
[0:12] Tommy: I'm not that funny.
[0:14] Jimi: You will be.
[0:17] Tommy: Let's get started.
[0:18] Jimi: Who's gone?
[0:19] Tommy: It's me.
[0:19] Jimi: Right.
[0:21] Tommy: Well, somebody get us another drink.
[0:23] Jimi: Welcome to Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour.
[0:27] Tommy: I'm Tommy.
[0:28] Jimi: And I'm Jimi, and this is the only musical theater podcast with barroom brawls and orchestra stalls.
[0:35] Tommy: Here we take apart your favorite shows, muddle them together with a shot of buffoonery, and pour you a refreshing glass of musical theater conversation.
[0:45] Jimi: Hey Tommy, what are you drinking today?
[0:48] Tommy: Uh, it's variations on a cup of coffee.
[0:54] Tommy: Sometimes I put the sugar in first and then add the coffee over top. Sometimes it's drip coffee. Sometimes I'd go for tea instead if I'm like screw coffee. Um, Columbia and Roast Ecuador. Sometimes I just invite Steven Sondheim over to, you know, grind some coffee beans for me.
[1:14] Tommy: I did that the other week, actually. It was such good chat.
[1:15] Jimi: It was so nice.
[1:18] Tommy: So, so good.
[1:19] Jimi: Excellent. That sounds delicious.
[1:21] Tommy: Um, I've diffused Tommy.
[1:24] Jimi: Enlighten me.
[1:25] Tommy: I will together. A quiz question in our archaic and difficult manner in which we disclose the title of the music.
[1:34] Tommy: Um, seamless. The quote definitive version of this infinitely revised operetta premiered in Glasgow in 1988.
[1:44] Jimi: It has since been revised multiple times. What show could it possibly be, Jimmy?
[1:50] Jimi: It is Candide.
[2:56] Tommy: Can Con Kin? Who knows?
[2:59] Jimi: Who knows?
[3:01] Tommy: Um, yes. Hey, Glasgow, thank you for saying Glasgow and not Glasgow.
[3:05] Jimi: It's entirely by accident every time I do it right.
[3:09] Tommy: It is, it's the eternal Moscow Moscow, Glasgow, Glasgow.
[3:14] Jimi: It's not a Glas Cow.
[3:16] Tommy: It is a Glasgow.
[3:19] Jimi: Um, yeah. Candide, I mean, where do you start?
[3:24] Tommy: Literally.
[3:26] Jimi: So intimidated.
[3:27] Tommy: So, it's so intimidated by this. It's taken us three months.
[3:31] Jimi: People, I mean, so many people have written entire, like, you know, a hundred-page dissertations about this show.
[3:37] Tommy: Yeah, exactly. Here we are saying that we're even gonna be able to scratch the surface.
[3:42] Jimi: Absolutely. Um, I think I want to say just off the bat, um, we want to give a shout out to Mr. Colden Lamb.
[3:48] Tommy: Oh, thank you, who basically wrote a PhD in our email inbox about Candide. It was very helpful.
[3:57] Jimi: He gave us a meta-analysis, which is something I've learned about in the medical world where you like gather up the hundred papers about a thing and do an analysis on the papers.
[4:06] Tommy: Yeah, it's like a lit review.
[4:07] Jimi: It's like a lit review. Um, that's probably in Candide for us, which was lovely. Um, yeah, it was very comprehensive. We're very, very grateful for that.
[4:16] Tommy: Sorry, it's taken us three months, but there was a lot to get through to be honest.
[4:19] Jimi: There was a hundred-page essay.
[4:22] Tommy: So the work, guys. The book itself is so long, dude. It took me so long to get through.
[4:27] Jimi: I know, literally. There's a lot of, there's like what, 20 words? I feel like the list of songs that are in the musical is actually slightly longer than the original novella.
[4:39] Tommy: So isn't that, well, we'll get to it, but that's how they introduced the 2001 Lincoln Centre. The narrator says, like, uh, Voltaire's Candide is a short little pamphlet where there's absolutely no singing. Bernstein's Candide is a long operetta where everyone practically insists upon it.
[4:58] Jimi: Yes, that is a beautiful, beautiful way of fitting it. Um, okay, let's stop beating around the bush. Let's talk about it.
[5:05] Tommy: Yeah. Where did it all begin? Candide premiered on Broadway in 1956.
[5:11] Jimi: Uh, it didn't have, it had pretty bad reviews.
[5:13] Tommy: Um, only played for 73 performances. That version was by Leonard Bernstein and Lillian Hellman.
[5:20] Jimi: Um, and Richard Wilbur.
[5:22] Tommy: Um, mostly. All said and done. The show has music by Leonard Bernstein, lyrics by Richard Wilbur, John Latouche, Dorothy Parker, Lillian Hellman, Stephen Sondheim, and Leonard Bernstein, and then has a book by Lillian Hellman and or Hugh Wheeler, depending upon.
[5:40] Jimi: I love that.
[5:44] Tommy: I mean, so this, there are so many versions of this. We can't just be like, this was the Broadway opening, and then this was the revival, and there you go.
[5:52] Jimi: Um, like we said, the original Hellman version now no longer exists.
[5:58] Tommy: Yeah.
[5:59] Jimi: Um, lost to time.
[6:01] Tommy: Yeah, the most, the next kind of notable one, which is actually a good place to start if you're completely new to Candide, is called the Chelsea version from 1973, and it has a red cover on Spotify.
[6:15] Jimi: Um, and it's quite good because it gives you, it gives you the book in between the songs to help you kind of make sense of what the hell is going on.
[6:24] Tommy: Um, that's the one with the new book by Hugh Wheeler.
[6:27] Jimi: Yes, indeed.
[6:28] Tommy: Oh.
[7:01] Jimi: Um, and then we had the what's called the opera house version, which was directed by Hal Prince as well, um, which features some more songs, because why not?
[7:01] Tommy: An opera company. Then we move on to what is called, per our quiz question, the definitive version in 1988.
[7:01] Jimi: Uh, it's the reason it exists is because Lillian Hellman died, and the parts of her script that she didn't want back in the show could be put back in the show.
[7:01] Tommy: Exactly.
[12:37] Jimi: Um, and I think Leonard Bernstein was really inspired by it. It was a Scottish opera production. He was really inspired by that, and he was like, I'm gonna do it, I'm gonna write the final version.
[12:37] Tommy: And then we had another one.
[12:37] Jimi: And then we revise it again. There's a revised opera house version that came out in '94 that adds the Sondheim and Latouche lyrics.
[12:37] Tommy: That version was built upon for a 1997 Broadway version.
[12:37] Jimi: Then it was revised again for the Royal National Theater in '99.
[12:37] Tommy: And then it all starts to, then it starts to fall apart.
[12:37] Jimi: Exactly. You know, you can expect that we're saying the Geminomic version, which will be launching shortly after this podcast is released.
[12:37] Tommy: Exactly.
[12:37] Jimi: It's exclusively on Zoom.
[12:37] Tommy: And it will be really good, I think. Really groundbreaking.
[12:37] Jimi: I think it's really, and it is very representative of the time we're in today.
[12:37] Tommy: Well, I mean, there's things to be said that I'm sure we will say.
[12:37] Jimi: Can you give us a brief summary about what happens?
[12:37] Tommy: Oh man. How brief can you be? Um, Candide lives in a fictional Austrian town, Westphalia.
[12:37] Jimi: Um, a bastard son taken in by a royal family, um, under the tutelage of Dr. Pangloss, whose thesis is that everything is for the best in this best of all possible worlds.
[12:37] Tommy: Candide is the optimist; things must be for the best.
[12:37] Jimi: Um, and then of course, is beset upon by untold horrors.
[12:37] Tommy: Um, you know, it is the town is pillaged, he's, you know, Pangloss is beset upon by the plague.
[12:37] Jimi: Uh, Cunegonde, his not quite betrothed, um, is, you know, raped repeatedly across the course of the show, all very tongue-in-cheek.
[12:37] Tommy: Everyone dies about six times throughout the course of the show.
[12:37] Jimi: Um, and it is based on Voltaire's novel, a discussion of, is a satire of unwavering optimism.
[12:37] Tommy: Saying that, you know, it is such a ridiculous thing to believe that everything happens for a reason.
[12:37] Jimi: And then exploring some of the philosophical implications of that in song.
[12:37] Tommy: Yeah.
[12:37] Jimi: And it is deeply rooted in philosophy.
[12:37] Tommy: Yeah.
[12:37] Jimi: Um, and again, more on that story later. But should we dive on into the world of Candide?
[12:37] Tommy: Of how did we get here?
[12:37] Jimi: Exactly.
[12:37] Tommy: I reminded life is really tired of being endlessly and go on with Holly.
[12:37] Jimi: That's not his name.
[12:37] Tommy: No, it is a heavy two change. Protect my awesome.
[12:37] Jimi: I have almost no everything I see I was happy in danger.
[12:37] Tommy: I mean, it is so strange because I'm like, where do we actually begin?
[12:37] Jimi: Right?
[12:37] Tommy: Well, because this show, what? Is, uh, this show is fifty-four years old and has had maybe as many revisions across the course of history.
[12:37] Jimi: Um, as years.
[12:37] Tommy: Right? Um, you know, this is a show that everyone agrees could be good and agrees hasn't been good when they've seen it.
[12:37] Jimi: Yeah, that's a again a really beautiful way of putting it.
[12:37] Tommy: I feel like all discussions about it, whether it's an essay, whether it's a full-length thesis, yeah, that's the kind of crux of it.
[12:37] Tommy: It's always a discussion of like what Candide could be.
[12:37] Jimi: Yeah, it's always like it was almost there, but um, and I find that utterly fascinating because what's stopping it?
[12:37] Tommy: Right.
[12:37] Jimi: Well, and you go back to so the explicit history, you know, in 1956 it premiered the Hellman and Bernstein version.
[12:37] Tommy: He started, Bernstein started working on it before West Side Story.
[12:37] Jimi: Um, this is right around that time.
[12:37] Tommy: Um, if you read the, it's hard to unpack, but Lillian Hellman was blamed for the poor reception of the initial production.
[12:37] Jimi: Her book seems to be what most people had the problem with.
[12:37] Tommy: Um, so then it becomes a question of, you know, how do you, you know.
[12:37] Jimi: I was trying to think about this. Are there other shows where a book writer has been so publicly cut where like the full production has existed, and then basically post the premiere, the book writer is fired, and then they bring on a new book writer?
[12:37] Tommy: I can think of plenty of examples where that happens before the show premieres, but to have this like post-premiere revision be the groundwork for this show, I think has done a lot of things to set it up for what it has become today.
[12:37] Jimi: Absolutely.
[12:37] Tommy: Um, because it's just, it just shows you that there wasn't that cohesion right at the start between Bernstein and Wheeler.
[12:37] Jimi: Yeah.
[12:37] Tommy: Um, no, not Wheeler, Hellman.
[12:37] Jimi: Hellman. God, it's gonna slab a lot.
[12:37] Tommy: Uh, between Bernstein and Hellman. Um, and that when you have that rocky foundation you're never gonna be able to produce something solid.
[12:37] Jimi: Um, and I think a lot of people say that it seems like they were writing in that original production they were just writing two different shows.
[12:37] Tommy: Yeah.
[12:37] Jimi: Um, but Bernstein was the one that people cared about.
[12:37] Tommy: Yeah.
[12:37] Jimi: Uh, so his kind of was the, well, we're not gonna obviously change the music, right? So what are you gonna do about your book?
[12:37] Tommy: Well, I do wonder about that in a more, like in a broader musical theater context because I can't imagine it going the other way, you know?
[12:37] Jimi: No, no show has ever persisted because of its book. Even shows with the best book, right? You know, book writers are notoriously undervalued.
[12:37] Tommy: Um, not saying that Hellman's version is great, like, but by all remarks, you know, the critics aren't wrong.
[12:37] Jimi: Um, yeah, but of course the music is what people want to keep because musicals are built around music.
[12:37] Jimi: Yeah, completely. You know, and it was Bernstein's idea, right? At the end of the day, um, so it really does make sense that it would be his thing. But, um, I think it shows you that you really can't have one without the other.
[14:02] Jimi: Right.
[14:03] Tommy: Yeah.
[14:04] Jimi: And I, you know, I do think a lot of then, you know, because you this hole just keeps getting dug deeper and deeper, like, uh, the Candide we have now is a result of that initial, uh, willingness to, you know, hack and slash at this thing.
[14:22] Jimi: Um, which already, like, I've had this thought before about, like, uh, divergent and convergent art making. Um, you know, whether it is people coming together to create a collaborative piece, or as often happens in musical theater, people diverging away from each other.
[14:39] Jimi: And like you can draw, you know, almost like a genetic tree of this show of the different parts that have been woven in and out, um, and rearranged. And so then, like, immediately after the Hellman version, or maybe not immediately, but a couple decades later, Hal Prince got the bright idea to redo this thing, brought on, uh, Hugh Wheeler, um, and the Chelsea version was created mostly without Bernstein's input.
[15:05] Jimi: Um, which is also pretty wild. Um, had a, you know, cool staging by the sounds of it, was, you know, very, very hippie.
[15:15] Tommy: Um, is the sense I get from reading descriptions.
[15:19] Jimi: Yeah, it seems very Hal Princey.
[15:21] Tommy: Yes.
[15:21] Jimi: I mean, very like, uh, of its time, shall we say?
[15:26] Tommy: That sounds about right.
[15:27] Jimi: And they cut the thing down, it was like a hundred minutes long. Um, apparently it was very successful, but it had a brand new book.
[15:34] Jimi: And so then already you've got this book that's, you know, one trying to fix the problems of the past, but also you have the new book because Lillian Hellman, you know, explicitly said, "Don't you dare use my book," um, if you're gonna change this thing.
[15:48] Tommy: Um, which I also find that quite funny.
[15:51] Jimi: Yeah.
[15:51] Tommy: Because it's like, well, your work won't exist.
[15:54] Jimi: Right.
[15:55] Jimi: So, and I appreciate it. Like, I do like, I think if I wrote something and someone's like, "We don't like it, we're gonna change it," um, I would obviously take that really personally, but it depends how invested you are because could you, like, how, I guess how proud do you need to be to say, "No, mine is definitive, right? Like, mine is perfect here, yeah, there's no need to change it when everyone is telling you it's not working," right?
[15:57] Jimi: So how are we gonna make this? And I think you'd be like, "Okay, well, let's try." I feel like that you, I feel like at least you would try, and it begs the question, you know, you said without this, like, your work doesn't exist. Like, it begs the question of what is the work, right? Because the book isn't, is the book the text on the page? Is the book the ideas? Is the book those thoughts being performed in the context of the musical?
[15:57] Jimi: Yeah, you know, because I think, like, I think for, um, for Hellman specifically that she really, really wanted to bring the novella onto the stage, um, and keep that same, uh, quite cynical, yeah, ideal. Um, and I think it's really telling that Hal Prince moved right away from that, yeah, um, and wanted to make it more theatrical and more, it's satirical, but on the other side of the coin, yes, not as acerbic, much more, um, slapstick.
[17:21] Tommy: Right, exactly. So, you know, these are unbelievable characters and you're watching them, and it's interesting because I would say recent revisions, like the, uh, 2009-2010, uh, Mary Zimmerman production, um, reincorporated a bunch of, like, direct adaptations from the novella and so almost as if we're swinging back towards that, you know, cynicism. It is this pendulum of art that we, you know, so often happen upon across decades.
[17:50] Jimi: Absolutely.
[17:51] Jimi: But what I find quite interesting, and this is a sort of nerdy tangent, but we've talked about it before with things like The Fantasticks and other shows set around late 60s, um, early 70s, about how they were really trying to push the boundaries in terms of art and in terms of, um, uh, just testing what an audience is capable of watching.
[18:14] Tommy: Yeah.
[18:14] Jimi: Um, and I find it really interesting that, uh, Hal Prince went down the more accessible route as opposed to the, "Okay, well, let's, you know, let's challenge you a bit here."
[18:27] Tommy: Right.
[18:27] Jimi: Um, but then I wonder if that's just because Candide already isn't hugely accessible to kind of get the kids into the house, you need to try and be like, "Hey, want to try something?"
[18:40] Tommy: Yeah, you need big arrows and like, "Over here, over here, you get it."
[18:43] Jimi: Like, for sure. Um, so yeah, after, uh, this version, 1973, the Chelsea version.
[18:52] Tommy: Yep.
[18:53] Jimi: Um, we then had a few others, and then the kind of next notable one was the opera house version, um, which was moving, uh, back into the operetta ideal of Candide and away from the musical theater.
[19:11] Tommy: Yeah.
[19:11] Jimi: And this is where Bernstein kind of comes back into the picture more so, I would say. Um, he brings in some of the songs he had written that were, you know, either cut from the Chelsea version or weren't even included in the Hellman version.
[19:25] Jimi: Um, you know, and this starts to become, if you've seen Candide at all and are listening to this, you've probably seen something most based on this opera house version, I would say.
[19:39] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[19:39] Jimi: In terms of like order.
[19:41] Tommy: Yeah.
[19:41] Jimi: And content.
[19:43] Jimi: Structure, existence, who knows.
[19:46] Tommy: It's so funny we would be like, "Yeah, this content is most similar to what you might know."
[19:51] Jimi: That's just nonsense.
[19:52] Tommy: It's so funny.
[19:53] Jimi: You say that about anything.
[19:54] Tommy: Right.
[19:54] Jimi: But like, that's the thing. No one has seen the Hellman version.
[19:57] Tommy: No one who's listening to this, likely has seen.
[20:00] Jimi: If you are, thank you for being alive to see the Hellman version and also being capable of listening to a podcast. I appreciate you deeply.
[20:07] Jimi: And I mean that, non-ironically. Um, but like the, you know, it is, we talk about this in fits and starts with other shows where you see these, you know, what, where we like break apart the minor, minor differences between this revival of a Sondheim show and that revival of the Sondheim show.
[20:24] Jimi: And Candide is like, "Wait, hold my beer." You know, we're gonna, "I've got my sledgehammer."
[20:29] Tommy: So delete, like, yeah, exactly, exactly.
[20:35] Jimi: That's exactly what happened.
[20:37] Tommy: Um, and then it happened again.
[20:40] Jimi: Yeah.
[20:43] Jimi: I think the sense I get is sometime in 1982, this started to become a pet project of Bernstein again.
[20:49] Tommy: Um, yeah, I think he was probably just like, "Oh look, people care about this."
[20:55] Jimi: Right.
[20:55] Jimi: This is still existing. You know, I mean, this is still my word.
[20:58] Jimi: And probably, you know, the popularity of West Side Story might have been dying out a little bit, and he was like, "Hang on."
[21:05] Jimi: Well, also by then it starts to stand on its own as, uh, or like the separate pieces start to stand on their own.
[21:11] Jimi: Like the overture is, you know, getting a whole bunch of traction being performed as a common, you know, Philharmonic orchestras and stuff like that.
[21:18] Tommy: For sure.
[21:32] Jimi: Um, and so that's how we ended up with the definitive version.
[21:38] Tommy: Um, definitive.
[21:40] Jimi: I posit that to you, Thomas.
[21:42] Tommy: It's a wild, I mean, you know, the art is never done, only abandoned.
[21:47] Jimi: I mean, I think it takes, uh, a Bernsteinian amount of hubris to describe a piece of art as a definitive version.
[21:59] Tommy: Definitive, yeah.
[22:00] Jimi: Now, is it only called that because he died shortly after?
[22:00] Tommy: I think it's called that because he said it was going to be the definitive version.
[22:08] Jimi: Um, like that, you know, that's what it takes.
[22:10] Jimi: Okay.
[22:10] Tommy: And that's, yeah, that's the problem and the delight with art is like you, you only have control over it until you're gone.
[22:17] Jimi: Um, and if it's, if it's good enough, people are gonna keep trying to improve upon it beyond your death.
[22:23] Tommy: Um, you know, I think is, and I guess that's, that's one of the interesting things about theater is that's, that's a thing you can do.
[22:30] Jimi: Right.
[22:30] Jimi: Well, and it's, it's that can still change after you've gone and it's mu, it's much more common and I think much more, I th, I'm gonna get this wrong because I, you know, failed out of my English minor.
[22:39] Jimi: Um, I believe F. Scott Fitzgerald was like notoriously resistant to any of his, um, books being adapted into anything television, plays, movies, or whatever.
[22:55] Tommy: Um, and then of course, shortly after his death, um, they started churning the wheels to create the Great Gatsby movie.
[23:04] Jimi: Um, right, like, and that's if you know that, and assuming I'm remembering that correctly, um, it seems much dirtier.
[23:11] Tommy: Whereas current revisions of Candide are celebrated in the theatrical community.
[23:17] Jimi: You know, people are like, you know, if only, if only he could see this, if only he was around to see what people have done with his work.
[23:24] Tommy: Um, and like who knows, it might be rolling over in his grave.
[23:28] Jimi: Potentially, potentially.
[23:30] Jimi: Maybe he had the same kind of Hellman vibe of like, "No, this is my thing, right? I don't want anyone else touching it, only I can do," but who knows.
[23:38] Jimi: I do, I do certainly think post the definitive version is why people have stopped calling them revisions.
[23:46] Tommy: Uh, yeah, fair, you know.
[23:48] Jimi: Because it's kind of, you're not, there's no new music.
[23:51] Tommy: I guess it comes back to that point of like, is it the book, is it the music, is it a combo?
[23:55] Jimi: Right.
[23:56] Jimi: I think for Candide it is the music because we're not gonna get any new songs for Candide.
[24:00] Tommy: Well, it's, we may get a new book.
[24:03] Jimi: In, you know, even in researching this, and anyone who's, you know, done this sort of stuff, you'll sympathize.
[24:08] Jimi: But like you type in Candide, you get the novella. The only way you get what you're looking for is to type in Leonard Bernstein's Candide into Google.
[24:16] Tommy: Um, you don't type in Candide musical because that's already fraught, you know, and no one else's name is so strongly associated with this thing more than Bernstein's.
[24:26] Jimi: Completely.
[24:27] Jimi: Um, so yeah, I think it's really telling that it's him who stood the test of time.
[24:33] Tommy: Yeah.
[24:33] Jimi: Uh, and I do wonder, maybe even down the line, uh, if we'll get, uh, a book that is equally as definitive.
[24:43] Tommy: Oh, it's, do you know what I mean? Where someone would be like, "Wow, this works."
[24:47] Jimi: Well, this marries well with this music.
[24:49] Jimi: It's so, the, when you look at the Wheeler version that, which, you know, was directly adapted to try and puzzle piece into the missing pieces from Hellman's book, like one of the craziest things to me is that they had to reinvent new names for the locations because those were all basically Hellman's intellectual property.
[25:09] Tommy: Um, that's wild and stupid.
[25:12] Jimi: Like totally, you know, they're, they're all made up places for the most part.
[25:17] Tommy: Like, you know, or close enough.
[25:20] Jimi: Um, so to, to be able to craft a book, like this is that, you know, divergent and convergent writing thing.
[25:28] Jimi: Like any book that would do these songs well has to be a good enough puzzle piece fit to the things that the songs are asking for.
[25:38] Jimi: But because the original book was already kind of, you know, cited as not even fitting into those pieces, it's like, you know, it's like there's the receptacle is broken.
[25:48] Jimi: There's not a great receiver for a good book because the songs are beautiful and lack a through line.
[25:59] Jimi: Exactly. You know? And I think I think that's really crucial. Yeah. Like that there's not a good hook for a book writer left anymore. Not at all. I mean, it's it's funny because there are so many songs. Like it is it is kind of like looking at the pot of crayons and being like, wow, I could really make anything here. Well, do um shall we do you wanna talk about the music?
[26:21] Tommy: Yeah, let's talk about the music.
[27:35] Jimi: So which crayon do you want? Oh man, there's a great There's over 100. Yeah, we'll we'll link the definitive Candide write-up. Um it's on Sondheim Guide, of course. Thank you, Sondheim Guide. Um, and by our count, there are a hundred and one songs that at one point were considered to be in this thing. Now, some of them were like, in this one biography, someone said that the original music written for Dear Officer Krupke was actually intended to be in Candide. And w imagine what that would have been. And like, that's you know, not really a cut song per se. You're not gonna adapt G Officer Krupke back into Candide.
[28:16] Tommy: No.
[28:17] Jimi: But they should and it probably will happen at some point. I know now that now that we've said it.
[28:22] Tommy: Exactly. But yeah, there's like th this is n this doesn't happen. This has never happened.
[28:28] Jimi: Right. This is ridiculous. This is absolute nonsense. I remember when we did the Music Man and we found out that Meredith Wilson wrote over 40 songs for the Music Man. I was like mind blown. I was like that is amazing. Look at all this content like wow what a story you could tell.
[28:45] Tommy: Right. I look at this over a hundred and I'm like that's just nonsense. It's just nuts. When I I started having I started like ex you know watching a bunch of different versions of this um and like I you know saw it in Chicago twice. We did it in college um and particularly I had the conflict over um uh easily assimilated um and I think it was when I was watching it and I was like I swear this was like the act one closer this it was great it was like we're gonna go off it's a great rousing dance number right but then I was watching the you know 2004 Lincoln Centre one and it's this weird quartet of like that's sale um and I'm like this is not as interesting as easily assimilated.
[29:32] Jimi: I thought this and it just doesn't matter you put the songs wherever you want.
[29:39] Tommy: Exactly well I think um we are women is really testament to that as well um um they're used in completely different places for different productions. I think in the um the definitive, the Scottish opera version, um, they're put at uh like quite near the end. Um I can't remember the context for them.
[30:03] Jimi: Can you uh uh Patty Lapone and Kristin Chenoweth come out on stage and sing to each other? Like what is the what is the greater context you need.
[30:11] Tommy: I'm just trying to think I'm just trying to think where they are at that point.
[30:14] Jimi: Yeah.
[30:14] Tommy: I think they might be in Montevideo.
[30:16] Jimi: Yeah, they're rich at that point anyway. I remember that much. Um but then previously it's been used when uh Cunegonda wanted to marry um the Archduke, yeah, or whatever he was. Um and uh d uh just even that of like here's let's just tear apart the context that really doesn't matter.
[30:37] Tommy: It does it does feel like there's you do there's plenty of room for flexibility somewhere in the intro. Do you have a narrator? Is it Voltaire? Does Pangloss come out? Whatever, right?
[30:49] Jimi: Yep.
[30:50] Tommy: Then you do the introduction set in stone, um, still with revisions to the lyrics, but yes, best of all possible worlds, and um the you know, Candide's sad song.
[31:02] Jimi: Um which is also wild. In the twenty in the 2004 Lincoln Centre version, he like packs his paddle ball away in a suitcase. In the Mary Zimmerman version, um in Chicago, there's this huge drop of like this wonderful palace that he lives in, and like his world falls apart and the drop falls on him and like the lights go blue and he uses the thing as a blanket to be like, you know, my world is dust now.
[31:28] Tommy: And it is so sad.
[31:30] Jimi: And I'm like, it's the same fucking song.
[31:33] Tommy: Like exactly. It is it's mad.
[31:36] Jimi: It's really, really mad. But like you have that, then you have, you know, into auto defe and glitter and be gay, and then you can just do whatever you want all the way until Make Our Garden Grow.
[31:48] Tommy: Genuinely. It's really funny. I just like but to me, right? I'm a bit like is that a good thing?
[31:54] Jimi: Right.
[31:59] Tommy: Or is that a bad thing?
[32:02] Jimi: Like, and I guess separately into good and bad is really stupid to not the name. But like to me, something that you can do that, you can have that much flexibility with.
[32:12] Tommy: Right.
[32:13] Jimi: Means that there really can't be any substance.
[32:15] Tommy: Right. Yes.
[32:16] Jimi: Well, and I think I think that's that's carton horse. There is no substance, so you can do that with it.
[32:22] Tommy: Okay, yeah.
[32:24] Jimi: Right? Like, these these characters' motivations are so poorly defined. The plot itself is lampshaded at the beginning of every scene.
[32:34] Tommy: Oh, I thought you were dead.
[32:35] Jimi: Well, I was. Let me Oh, we'll explain it later. Like that joke is leaned into so heavily, like, because it doesn't matter.
[32:48] Tommy: You know, and we're bouncing back and forth to different places, but the place you're in doesn't really matter unless you have like a vast understanding of you know Yeah.
[32:57] Jimi: Like generally the only thing that seems to really matter is that certain characters are on stage.
[33:04] Tommy: But even then, right.
[33:06] Jimi: It doesn't it doesn't. I was when I was rewatching for l like last night, I was watching with my boyfriend, and you know, you can kind of track like, alright, we've got basically five main characters, and across them five main voice parts.
[33:23] Tommy: And so we just want to do the different permutations of those voice parts singing with each other in interesting ways.
[33:30] Jimi: And you know, who cares what order they happen in. Genuinely. And then there's kind of a song for every eventuality. So it's like, oh do you not want to go there next? Okay, well we've got a song that will take you there.
[33:40] Tommy: Yeah.
[33:40] Jimi: Or a s you know I mean it's really it's nuts. I found our adaptation. I found it. Candide, Mystery of Edwin Drood style.
[33:50] Tommy: Yeah, exactly. Absolutely.
[33:51] Jimi: Do an audience poll in the middle wanna hear next.
[33:54] Tommy: In the middle of auto defeat, you decide on the order of the show.
[33:58] Jimi: Absolutely. I love that.
[34:00] Tommy: Yeah. Everyone comes around, you're given a list of literally a hundred songs that you have to pick from.
[34:06] Jimi: It takes five hours.
[34:07] Tommy: No no one audience member must come on stage.
[34:12] Jimi: And there's big cards with the different songs and they put them in an order and that's what we're stuck with.
[34:17] Tommy: And then that's what you do.
[34:19] Jimi: It's funny but though, because like obviously I'm sure you've seen um like improvised musical theater.
[34:24] Tommy: Yeah.
[34:24] Jimi: Right? Kind of based on that premise almost.
[34:27] Tommy: Um it's it's not like it it feels it feels like it and that's the thing that's the thing that I really struggle with because I'm like, how can I grow attached to these songs?
[34:36] Jimi: Right.
[34:36] Tommy: If they have no context.
[34:37] Jimi: But so here's the Because then they're just songs.
[34:41] Tommy: But I where's the musical theater.
[34:41] Jimi: Here's the problem. I do, right? Like you know, we we shit talk this but by the i it at the end like I balled at the end of the Mary Zimmerman production.
[34:52] Tommy: Like so deeply moved.
[34:55] Jimi: Um you know more than I had been for a long time at some you know live theatrical pieces.
[35:01] Tommy: Right.
[35:01] Jimi: It's awesome. It's very, you know, if if if you've seen any of Mary Zimmerman's work or know like um Arabian Nights or something like that. It's very storyteller centric.
[35:11] Tommy: You know, the narrator idea is divided amongst the cast.
[35:15] Jimi: The set is this very cool like forced perspective wood clad room with like panels that open up in and out.
[35:24] Tommy: Yeah.
[35:24] Jimi: You know, very simple staging but very effective. I think it's really beautiful actually her production.
[35:29] Tommy: Yeah.
[35:30] Jimi: And like at the very end during Make Our Garden Grow, the whole set starts to sprout flowers from every direction just you know simply and slowly.
[35:38] Tommy: The whole thing is gorgeous.
[35:40] Jimi: And so something had to get me there.
[35:43] Tommy: Yeah but is that like who's doing the work?
[35:46] Jimi: True.
[35:47] Tommy: That's a that's a good that is that is the question of the night.
[35:50] Jimi: And this is but this is what I thought when I was watching it.
[35:52] Tommy: I was like so the one that I've watched is the um the definitive version.
[35:59] Jimi: And listen I didn't enjoy it.
[36:01] Tommy: Yeah.
[36:02] Jimi: I didn't enjoy I've listened to Candide a lot before and I I really like some of the songs.
[36:07] Tommy: Right.
[36:07] Jimi: But again it's that thing of the first time you listen to a cast recording they're just songs.
[36:11] Tommy: They're not you're not getting the story.
[36:13] Jimi: Right.
[36:14] Tommy: And Candide always feels like that to me.
[36:16] Jimi: Yeah.
[36:16] Tommy: I don't I I find it really hard to pinpoint you know oh yeah that one that's then because there isn't a then.
[36:23] Jimi: Right.
[36:24] Tommy: And so with you at the Mary Zimmerman production, what's happened is someone's kind of interpreted and thrown things into a pot in your brain yeah because of whether it's aesthetics or whether it's acting or whether it's like you know whatever.
[36:37] Jimi: Right.
[36:38] Tommy: Your brain has put them together and told your own story.
[36:41] Jimi: Right.
[36:43] Tommy: And I think that is where I I I kind of take issue, I guess.
[36:48] Jimi: Yeah, no, that's fair.
[36:50] Tommy: Um, you know, we said it already, like Hal Prince, you know, was like, we need big arrows to walk people through this story.
[36:57] Jimi: And it's true.
[36:59] Tommy: You know, and I think it's why Candide has this weird relationship with musical theater, theater and opera, because that is the push and pull between musical theater and opera.
[37:07] Jimi: Opera, the audience does the work, musical theater, the cast does the work.
[37:11] Tommy: Exactly.
[37:12] Jimi: And I I think that's kind of where it comes down to.
[37:16] Tommy: Yeah.
[37:16] Jimi: Um, so yeah, I I d I don't know.
[37:20] Tommy: It to me it it frustrates me.
[37:23] Jimi: I guess because I'm I'm a musical theater boy.
[37:26] Tommy: Sure.
[37:27] Jimi: And I I'm story first, yeah. Everything else second.
[37:30] Tommy: Yeah.
[37:31] Jimi: Um and when you don't really have a story, yeah.
[37:35] Tommy: It's really tricky.
[37:36] Jimi: Let's talk about that, Tommy, because this is like one of the crazy things about this show is full-fledged, you know, opera groups have done it, and and you know and Hal Prince has directed 16 versions of it.
[37:49] Tommy: Like, except yeah, whether it be opera, musical, operetta, musicetta, wherever that is.
[37:54] Jimi: Right, yeah, you know, in concert, like so let's talk about, you know, how adaptable and like the the thousands of different versions of this thing that have been created.
[38:03] Tommy: I agree.
[38:26] Jimi: Oh my god!
[38:39] Tommy: Dearest, how can this be so? You were dead, you know, you were shot.
[38:47] Jimi: That is very true. Much love will find all we Then what did you do?
[38:54] Tommy: We're going to another Nother Day.
[38:57] Jimi: Now this talk of you.
[39:00] Tommy: Okay.
[39:01] Jimi: What is it?
[39:04] Tommy: The show?
[39:06] Jimi: Yeah.
[39:06] Tommy: No one can agree.
[39:07] Jimi: Um I can agree. I used to, uh it's been a long time, but I used to be pretty involved in um Wiki Project Musical Theater, which is now very much defunct.
[39:17] Tommy: Um I remember when you told me this for the first time, by the way. I was I was like, I felt like I was in the presence of like greatness. It was nothing to do with your whatever many thousand subscribers on YouTube. This guy is like changed my life for this much wiki.
[39:29] Jimi: This was long before um uh musical theater mash even, but there are still large sections of Synopsis' synopsis, synopsi, um, and other portions of musical theater articles on Wikipedia that like I wrote. Um we have so much to be grateful for for you.
[39:47] Tommy: I you know, I I do what I can. Um uh uh uh Wikipedia editors are notorious about um uh turf, you know, who's who's in charge of what article. Um and I remember getting in a minor beef with Wiki Project Opera over Candide, over whose style guide was going to apply to the thing.
[40:11] Jimi: And at the time I didn't know much about Candide, so I was like, fine, whatever, you know, you guys tackle it. Um, and now as a grown-ass adult, my thought is like, who cares? It's all you know, debate we're gonna, you know, give away the same information.
[40:25] Tommy: Uh-huh. But it is this is one of those shows that it it begs the question does the content create the medium, or does the medium define the content? Are operas that way because they're written to be operas, or is the piece performed that way because it's in an opera house?
[40:53] Jimi: Yeah. So I this this I feel like is the ultimate question. Like this is the you know that th that really horrible plot line in Doctor Who where it was like the The ultimate question, the last question we spoken at the end of the question or whatever the stupid phrase.
[41:11] Tommy: Doctor.
[41:12] Jimi: Yes, I do remember that.
[41:14] Tommy: Nonsense.
[41:15] Jimi: Uh I feel like this is ours of that.
[41:17] Tommy: Yeah.
[41:18] Jimi: Because I so many people have asked me this, and I like stumble through and answer it, and just throw loads of words at them, and I think they leave kind of satisfied, but I have no idea what I just said. Because it it's so uh there's just this eternal push-pool. Like, if you if you try and map out, I can't remember when we have talked about opera before because we've talked about Wagner before.
[41:39] Tommy: Yeah.
[41:39] Jimi: I mean, we talked about Sweeney, way back when?
[41:44] Tommy: That is way back when we're talking four years there, T.
[41:46] Jimi: Yeah. Maybe we talked about it in Thrupany Opera as well.
[41:48] Tommy: That's what I'm saying. That's why that was written as a response to the Wagnerian operas. Um but like it if you look at the journey and then you know, throw G and S in the mix there as well.
[42:00] Jimi: Right, it's the there's just so much crossover and overlap.
[42:04] Tommy: Yeah.
[42:04] Jimi: One changes into the other without anyone kind of realizing what's happened.
[42:08] Tommy: Right. And obviously, since then we've had operas that look more like musicals, and we've had musicals that look like I think nowadays, in in maybe even in the 2010s, I don't even know if we were quite there when I was in college. Um but like nowadays I think we've all come around to a postmodern understanding of performance art. That like all of this is the same and all of this is different, and you can call upon bits and pieces of whatever in whatever, and that's fine.
[42:40] Jimi: Well, what I would say I'm gonna get shot. But what I would say is I think musical theater people, well, not all musical theater people, I think a handful of musical theatre people would agree with that.
[42:49] Tommy: Yeah.
[42:49] Jimi: And probably a handful of opera people who agree with that, but I think a lot of opera people would be like, no.
[42:53] Tommy: That's fair.
[42:53] Jimi: Opera is opera.
[42:54] Tommy: Yeah.
[42:55] Jimi: Because there is, there's something about but I guess because it's so long standing.
[42:58] Tommy: Right.
[42:59] Jimi: You know what I mean? Like it it opera has etched, that's not as what that's not the word. Etched.
[43:04] Tommy: Yes.
[43:04] Jimi: Um it's word uh it's is marked into the stone of history. There's a there's a there's a a piece of pride that comes with going to the opera or you know going to a concert or going to the ballet, like, yes, I am an intellectual and I understand, and you know, I have the mental facilities, right?
[43:22] Tommy: And I don't I I say that in a in a teasing voice. I didn't know, but it's true.
[43:25] Jimi: It's true, it's absolutely true. That's why kind of the birth of musical theater was created. That's why you know Brecht wrote Thrupany Opera was because he was like, I need to give stuff that people can actually watch that people like the not the punters can go to.
[43:40] Tommy: Right.
[43:40] Jimi: Um as opposed to the Hoy Paloi. I also think if a contemporary, you know, opera feel went to a you know 1800s opera, they'd be bored out of their mind.
[43:53] Tommy: Oh, so I really agree.
[43:55] Jimi: Right. Because like I I think, like, see if we look at some other contenders for this, you know, the the people who live on the the divide. Um Jerry Springer, mm-hmm.
[44:09] Tommy: Very much a musical.
[44:10] Jimi: Right. As in terms of like what people call it, right? But just it it's really just a modern opera.
[44:16] Tommy: Yeah.
[44:17] Jimi: Yeah.
[44:17] Tommy: It resembles so many other modern operas.
[44:19] Jimi: Right. Well, and what is it that's made that I mean, and this is, you know, where we're two tangents in, but that's the whole plot of uh Mr. Burns, a post-electric play.
[44:29] Tommy: Like that did you just say Mr. Burns, a post-electric play.
[44:34] Jimi: Have you heard about this?
[44:36] Tommy: I have not heard about this. What's that?
[44:38] Jimi: What you would love Mr. Burns as in The Simpsons?
[44:41] Tommy: Yes, I don't know if this will make the cut. I'm amazed we've never talked about this.
[44:44] Jimi: You will love it. You will love this play, Jimmy. Um, you should read it because you can't see it anywhere. It's three acts. The first act starts after the apocalypse. Whatever it is, doesn't matter. It has happened um recently. And the the remnants of humanity or whoever is gathered around the campfire, and they're like, Oh, you remember that episode of The Simpsons? And they're like, Oh yeah, that one, and then Mr. Burns is like blah blah blah, you know, and they're basically, and they basically retell the plot of one episode of The Simpsons, best they can around the campfire, because humanity is gone, right? It doesn't exist anymore. It's kind of talking about storytelling. It only exists in their brain.
[45:26] Tommy: Act two, humanity is starting to rebuild, and a troop of traveling players performs this episode of The Simpsons in like, you know, trash bags and on abandoned cars, and like, you know, to the best they can, and some pieces get lost in the middle, and some pieces of remembered culture start to come back into the thing. Things that aren't related to The Simpsons but that we remember as part of our culture.
[45:50] Jimi: Act three, humanity has entirely rebuilt, and there's now this opera that is this episode of The Simpsons, but also has like Britney Spears songs in it. Um a very stylized Homer mask and a Marge headpiece, and like it's it is so clever and so funny.
[46:13] Tommy: Mr. Burns, a post electric play.
[46:16] Jimi: Post electric play.
[46:17] Tommy: I think it's what it's like.
[46:18] Jimi: That's amazing.
[46:19] Tommy: Yeah.
[46:20] Jimi: You would love it. You should look up some photos of it.
[46:22] Tommy: What an amazing idea.
[46:23] Jimi: Yeah. I really, really I'm totally into that.
[46:25] Tommy: Yeah, I'm amazed. You absolutely would love it.
[46:29] Jimi: But that's it, you know what? It it sits in an interesting place because it it it idea of uh heightening and you know uh what is this what is the kind of story that you're telling and what does everything look like? Uh it it it's just a po it's impossible to answer because the other one, it was interesting what you said earlier about um is it the content, is it the house?
[46:53] Tommy: Yeah.
[46:54] Jimi: Uh because I saw the ENO version, English national opera version of Sweeney.
[47:00] Tommy: Interesting.
[47:01] Jimi: With Bryn Turfle, who's a opera singer, yeah. Um, and Emma Thompson, who is not um and yeah, so it was in the Coliseum, um, which is uh a massive, very important, significant opera house. Um obviously ENO did it because they wanted to be kind of like expanding their repertoire and realizing that we want to make sure the opera stays and or that it grows.
[47:26] Tommy: They did it because they needed a a a seller that month.
[47:28] Jimi: A cellar, exactly. Um, and it when I watched it I couldn't tell what it what it was.
[47:38] Tommy: Yeah.
[47:38] Jimi: Do you know what I mean?
[47:39] Tommy: Because it it was weird the way that they started it, I think I might have spoken about this before, but the way they started it was very traditional. They had the plants at either side of the stage was the grand piano on the stage, and um everyone was in formal dress and they came out with their their scores as if it was gonna be like a concert performance.
[47:56] Jimi: Yeah.
[47:57] Tommy: Um and then halfway through the overture, uh they all start shutting their books and throwing them around. Um and then at one point they pick up the grand piano and throw it.
[48:08] Jimi: Um I've seen I've seen that, yeah.
[48:11] Tommy: Right. And it was really it was really effective. It was really, really effective because it was very much like this isn't your average opera.
[48:17] Jimi: Right, right.
[48:18] Tommy: But see, then we're we're subverting the style, but are we? Like I exactly, because also it kind of had nothing to do with Sweeney Todd.
[48:26] Jimi: Well, I do the the I guess the third question of like, is it so is it the content is it the house? If you flip that, like if it's the content, I would say the content of Sweeney Todd feels more operatic to me than the content of Candide.
[48:43] Tommy: Yeah, compli I um Yeah, Candide has this. This idea of the kind of Greek chorus, the the backing singers and the main players. And song uh uh Sweeney Todd is important, you know, t attend to the tale, it's about murder. Candide is like oh, raped again, like you know, nothing is important in Candide.
[49:05] Tommy: Yeah, that's that's a good point, actually, because the the um the kind of alienating effect um that Sweeney Todd has uh is really intrinsic and always taken quite seriously, whereas the alienating effects in Candide is on the more frivolous side of things, so like what Brecht would have done in his comedies as opposed to his like serious yeah moral plays.
[49:30] Jimi: Um but you get to decide because there are different versions of this show. There are ones where Voltaire or a narrator comes out and goes, the story of Candide, and there are ones where that doesn't happen.
[49:34] Tommy: Yep.
[49:34] Jimi: And there are ones where it's literally set in America with American history characters.
[49:47] Tommy: Yeah, the I'm gonna butcher the name the sh the Chateau des Bleu.
[49:52] Jimi: The Theatre Chatelet.
[49:54] Tommy: That's what I said. Um the French version. Um there's a couple clips you can see of this thing um that you that we'll put in the links and you should watch, but maybe watch in private. Um like there it's a it's a send-up of McCarthyism and a bunch of other American things. It's yeah, just like kind of American political history. There during Auto de Fay, there's a whole chorus of Klu Klux clan members that come out and start dancing around a bunch of business people.
[50:22] Jimi: Um there are indeed.
[50:23] Tommy: Yeah, like it is, and the the finale, Make Our Garden Grow is the whole set is this huge television, and they drop a projection screen, and as they sing Make Our Garden Grow projected on the screen are all these scenes of like you know, desolate forests and garbage heaps and like you know, fallout from bombings and fires, and like about how we're destroying the earth, juxtaposed with like make our garden grow.
[50:49] Jimi: Exactly.
[50:50] Tommy: It's moving, it's something for sure.
[50:54] Jimi: Yeah, um but it I it's that kind of thing. You get it quite a lot where it's like, are you doing that for shotgun? What's the what is the story that you're telling with this?
[51:03] Tommy: I saw I saw a clip of uh I think it's a Berlin version. The whole page was in German, so I couldn't understand a lot of it.
[51:11] Jimi: Um the clip was um glitter and be gay.
[51:16] Tommy: Um and Kunagonda is like standing on a bar with a stripper pole.
[51:21] Jimi: Um that's how she sings a song, which is story appropriate.
[51:26] Tommy: That is what she's doing, but it felt it's so different than you know uh uh her in a bathtub or you know her dancing around a lounge with uh pearls like in a pink tutu, you know, wildly different interpretations of the same piece.
[51:43] Jimi: So I get like your initial question someone comes up to you and says, Is Candide an opera or a musical? And I think the answer is like, well, it depends on what you do with it.
[51:52] Tommy: Exact it, kind of, but then it's it's weird because I think with Candide, I would say there are lots more opera versions than there are musical theater versions.
[52:03] Jimi: In fact, I find it really difficult to pick out the ones where I'm like, I identify this as a musical theater.
[52:11] Tommy: The I'd say the biggest one would be the Daniel Evans version, which I think is the 1990.
[52:20] Jimi: Okay.
[52:21] Tommy: Um it's a British one.
[52:23] Jimi: Okay.
[52:24] Tommy: Um it's the one on Spotify that has like the moon or something on it.
[52:28] Jimi: Yes, okay.
[52:29] Tommy: Yeah, it there's like a yellow, is it like a man with a yellow back and is blue and yellow and oh potentially, I don't know.
[52:36] Jimi: This is Daniel Evans what it's like riveting podcast materials.
[52:39] Tommy: Yeah, it kind of looks like that.
[52:41] Jimi: Um we're just letting it you have the opportunity to look for yourself.
[52:46] Tommy: Um anyway, it's really little key. The orchestrations are V small.
[52:49] Jimi: Yeah.
[52:50] Tommy: Um it's not it's not very good.
[52:56] Jimi: Right?
[52:57] Tommy: Yeah, yeah.
[52:59] Jimi: And to me, I'm like, is that telling?
[53:03] Tommy: Right.
[53:04] Jimi: Yeah. Is that the is that the thing is like when you try and musical theaterize this and um I've read a couple of reviews and things, and apparently it is a lot more low-key, and they are really hitting into the storytelling aspect of it and the musical theater of it as opposed to listen to this music and perhaps feel something.
[53:25] Tommy: Right.
[53:25] Jimi: Um I'm so sorry, people who like opera.
[53:29] Tommy: Well, it's there are better operas.
[53:32] Jimi: Yeah.
[53:32] Tommy: No one has no, I will say, even the biggest opera peddence, I would I would be struck if someone who says Candide is the best opera, right?
[53:40] Jimi: Yeah, okay.
[53:41] Tommy: Or the pinnacle of what opera should be.
[53:44] Jimi: Yeah.
[53:45] Tommy: That's a good but probably because it's bastardized, because it's this it treads this line.
[53:50] Jimi: Right.
[53:51] Tommy: But then Sweeney Todd isn't I don't know.
[53:53] Jimi: Yeah.
[53:54] Tommy: We don't have the you know, the the world of performed musical theater and you performed music performance, encompassing opera, I will say, is so it's such a small sample size. Like this is a problem we encounter all the time, that trying to draw patterns between these things is often fruitless because Candide is the only Candide, right?
[54:15] Jimi: It's not like Candide is representative of sixteen well, maybe it is the sixteen other Candides.
[54:21] Tommy: Um but like the the vast chasm between Candide and Sweeney Todd is huge, and they're still so very close to each other because Steven Sondheim studied under Leonard Bernstein.
[54:34] Jimi: Like there's only a couple people who make these things.
[54:38] Tommy: Yeah.
[54:39] Jimi: And so whenever you start to Oh that's sorry, I just had a like a little epiphany there because like an argument that I often get into with Light in the Piazza is that it's too much like an operetta.
[54:50] Tommy: Yeah.
[54:50] Jimi: And obviously Sandy was a big mentor to Adam Gettel.
[54:55] Tommy: Right.
[54:55] Jimi: Interesting.
[54:56] Tommy: Yeah.
[54:56] Jimi: It's just drooping down.
[54:57] Tommy: And it's that's that's an interesting point. Like we we talk about musical theater like it is this huge genre, and it is, but compared to other things like like there's no comparing. You know, walk through the fiction section in the library. Walk through the mystery section of the fiction section in the library. You know, walk through the vampire romance mystery section in the library, and you will find a more diverse group of books than the whole canon of musical theater, right?
[55:24] Jimi: Yeah.
[55:25] Tommy: And so once you start to, you know, w it it's it's why this is fun. It's why it's fun to unpack these things and draw the parallels because there are so few and we can keep them all in our head. Um you know, whereas like I try not to keep Twilight in my head.
[55:39] Jimi: Uh-huh.
[55:40] Tommy: I th yeah, I think I think I find it difficult just because like it music theater wouldn't exist without opera.
[55:47] Jimi: For sure.
[55:47] Tommy: Do you know what I mean? And i i it feels like just a little clay of it, but because it's got such deep popularity because it's so bloody good, um, I think that's why it it's tricky and that's that's why we find it really, I don't know, really difficult.
[56:03] Jimi: Um is Great Comet an opera?
[56:08] Tommy: No.
[56:09] Jimi: Why?
[56:11] Tommy: Because it doesn't feel because I like it.
[56:15] Jimi: Because it doesn't feel like that.
[56:16] Tommy: That's the power.
[56:18] Jimi: I don't know.
[56:20] Tommy: It's an unfair question because I will say Great Comet was conceived in the, you know, a postmodern acceptance.
[56:26] Jimi: Exactly.
[56:26] Tommy: Because like people it's great comic musical theater. Right. You know, I mean, is it transcendent? Yes, of course it is, because it's the best. Right.
[56:32] Jimi: Um but yeah, if there's someone who is is kind of taking it to the next thing, it's probably someone like Dave Malloy who's like, well, listen, let's look at this.
[56:33] Tommy: Right.
[56:33] Jimi: Let's look at this theme that's a good one. But it's still drawing upon the you know, the trickle down of both musical theater and opera a thousand other things, as all of these, you know, pieces of the thing is the thing is, Tommy, I would argue that it's still too early to look for the next thing.
[56:56] Tommy: Yeah.
[56:57] Jimi: Because opera was around for hundreds of years before, you know, Oscar Hammerstein and Richard Rogers were like, Right. Let's see what we can do. Musical theater, we're just about to crack a century.
[57:11] Tommy: Just about like just like really just.
[57:16] Jimi: Yeah. Um, and uh I think in that s in that case, it probably is truly to be like, okay, we're we've got this. You know, I mean, we know what this is now.
[57:25] Tommy: What's next?
[57:26] Jimi: Yeah.
[57:26] Tommy: Um because I think anything that attempts to go next will always just fall back to being, okay, well, yeah, it's just a nice, interesting piece of musical theater.
[57:34] Jimi: Right.
[57:34] Tommy: You know.
[57:34] Jimi: Well, you're just, you know, you're you're expanding the circle of the Venn diagram until your little bloop has gotten so big that it's so far away from the center that like you know, you mitosis into another category.
[57:45] Tommy: Exactly.
[57:46] Jimi: Love this biology of some lanes.
[57:48] Tommy: Mythosis is great.
[57:50] Jimi: Um how is your bloop, by the way? I was I was meant to ask you.
[57:52] Tommy: My bloop?
[57:53] Jimi: Yeah, your little bloop.
[57:55] Tommy: My bloop.
[57:56] Jimi: Well, you just said it. It sounded like a yeah, you said that. You said those words, not four seconds ago.
[58:02] Tommy: Oh, my bloop. How is my bloop? My bloop's good. Thanks.
[58:06] Jimi: Good.
[58:07] Tommy: Great comedy from Jim and Tomic.
[58:11] Jimi: Uh we were we were we were talking with one of our uh our bosses. Um, and he kept talking about how this show was funny, and I was like, I don't think this show's that funny.
[58:21] Tommy: Exactly.
[58:21] Jimi: I had one of my friends was like, I don't know if people have heard it, but they ad that we ran on the other BPN shows.
[58:28] Tommy: Yeah.
[58:28] Jimi: Um, and one of our parents was like, it was so good. I just loved it. I was like, what did you listen to? It was abysmal.
[58:38] Tommy: Abominable embarrassment.
[58:39] Jimi: I'm glad about frogs.
[58:41] Tommy: I'm glad people like us.
[58:44] Jimi: How sad is that?
[58:47] Tommy: I am also glad.
[58:48] Jimi: Anyway.
[58:49] Tommy: Candy.
[58:52] Jimi: Who knows?
[58:53] Tommy: Genuinely, who knows?
[59:22] Jimi: Well, now that we're super clear about what Candide is, right? And now that we've talked about how uh how shitty the story is. Do you want to talk about the story?
[59:30] Tommy: Yeah, let's do that.
[59:32] Jimi: Yeah, let's do it.
[59:34] Tommy: Um I mean, right.
[59:38] Jimi: It's got heart.
[59:41] Tommy: You gotta have heart.
[59:45] Jimi: Get out of here.
[59:46] Tommy: Um that's we talk about that instead.
[59:52] Jimi: Uh that's the diagram I want about like how much time we spend talking about other shows on episodes that are supposed to be about a particular show.
[1:00:00] Tommy: Exactly.
[1:00:00] Jimi: I think do you know what though? I think with Candide, I think one of the reasons why in this one in particular we're diverging is because it's so um philosophical.
[1:00:08] Tommy: Yes.
[1:00:09] Jimi: As in the the core piece, the original text um is philosophical in nature.
[1:00:14] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:00:15] Jimi: Uh and obviously if you're talking about something that is literally an idea, yeah, uh you then interpret it through other means because it's easier.
[1:00:24] Tommy: Right.
[1:00:24] Jimi: Um it it's it's hard to give that sort of thing a concrete physicality, you know, to root it in a a world or a person or a place or a story.
[1:00:36] Tommy: Absolutely.
[1:00:37] Jimi: And a a story, that's exactly it, because uh testament to what we've just spoken about for an hour. Um it's really hard to say to talk about the story of Candide the opera musical.
[1:00:50] Tommy: Yeah, because there's lots of different stories, you know.
[1:00:54] Jimi: There's one, there's like a a plot, but there's many different stories.
[1:00:59] Tommy: Right.
[1:01:00] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:01:01] Tommy: And they're all all towards the goal, like what would you say because if this if this is philosophical, right? Then at the end, at the third midnight, Voltaire's gonna come out and you know, say his moral for the story.
[1:01:15] Jimi: Right.
[1:01:15] Tommy: Like, what is the moral of Candide?
[1:01:20] Jimi: Well, it's funny because I've seen so many different interpretations.
[1:01:23] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:01:23] Jimi: But that's really interesting. Like, so what I'm gonna say just now, I don't really like philosophy.
[1:01:30] Tommy: Right.
[1:01:31] Jimi: I don't like it. I the the reason why, and I I don't know much about it. Well, no, I don't I don't know much about it. I've never studied it.
[1:01:40] Tommy: You've paired the two worst sentences together you possibly can for the thing.
[1:01:46] Jimi: Absolutely.
[1:01:47] Tommy: But I have still kind of opinions on it, right?
[1:01:50] Jimi: Of course.
[1:01:50] Tommy: Um that's all we do.
[1:01:52] Jimi: Yeah, exactly. I appreciate that I'm ignorant, right? And I've had many discussions with people who are really passionate about philosophy. Um, and I I fully appreciate their passion. Um, but it's not for me because I find it really inhibiting.
[1:02:04] Tommy: I think you know, I've I've spoken to people and met people in my life who really really buy into, you know, Nietzsche or Marxism, and they really live their life by this very strict code, yeah, and this set of rules, this philosophy, which is really an I it's an ideology.
[1:02:24] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:02:24] Tommy: Um when you say things to them, it's like, well, no, because Nietzsche said this.
[1:02:30] Jimi: Right.
[1:02:30] Tommy: And I'm like, but I'm sure I could find you somewhere in the Rolodex. Well, this person said this, and that's different. Who's correct? You like Nietzsche, so you're gonna say Nietzsche, but I'm gonna say Rousseau was correct, or I'm gonna say Voltaire was correct, you know. It's it's too silly.
[1:02:50] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:02:51] Tommy: Um do you is it the the finality of it? The like this is the world view, draw a circle around it, we're done.
[1:02:58] Jimi: Totally, because I've had people be like, oh, so you're uh ex because I've said something. Right. And I'm like, no, I don't have any idea what you're talking about because I've never read this.
[1:03:07] Tommy: Yeah, I'm sure someone else have had the same thoughts as I have, yeah.
[1:03:10] Jimi: But I've had those thoughts, those are my thoughts.
[1:03:13] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:03:13] Jimi: I wasn't influenced by Nietzsche or whoever, like nihilism or I don't I don't know. Like I came up with that myself, and I'm proud of that because that was uh a little moment of like oh, light bulb.
[1:03:27] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:03:27] Jimi: I'm not then gonna be like, okay, who's found this light bulb before me? Oh, okay, so this is what my next six light bulbs should look like.
[1:03:34] Tommy: Right.
[1:03:34] Jimi: You know, I want to have I like the melting pot. I like going on journeys, and I like thinking about different things in interpreting and making opinions up on them.
[1:03:44] Tommy: Well, wouldn't you so in like a way, sorry? In in some versions of Candide, um, the the musical, uh, we have Panglos, and then we have oh god, the old man in the cave. He's got a name, Nega Panglass.
[1:04:00] Jimi: Um the Spanish one.
[1:04:02] Tommy: Is he there's there is uh uh a foil to Panglas, who in some versions they meet. Um he sings words, words, words.
[1:04:10] Jimi: Uh Martin.
[1:04:12] Tommy: Oh, on the boat.
[1:04:14] Jimi: On the boat, sometimes on the boat, but in other versions, um, you know, he sings like the worst of all possible wor world worlds. Um there is this character who is, you know, we get I it's chicken and egg, and I'm not sure, and I'm sure I could look it up, but I'm not, but like the idea of a Panglossian view of life that everything will be good, and then there is this foil to that that everything is terrible, right? And if you start expanding and looking on Candide, there are they expand upon, you know, ten or eleven different philosophical views of life. You know, is it this religion or that religion?
[1:04:52] Tommy: Is it a view and everything's for the best? Is it a view and everything's for the worst? Is it a view and so many things are happening that it's too busy? Is it a view that so few things are happening that I am so bored with life? Yep. And the conclusion they end up on is like, whatever, we'll build a house, we'll tend our garden and do what we can. Um, and so like I would say Candide is almost a rejection of your view or what like I think you and Candide at the end of the show would agree.
[1:05:26] Jimi: I would agree with your agreement.
[1:05:29] Tommy: Um, because I mean like so Voltaire wrote it in response to um the, um, I think it was Leibniz, um, who had this idea of like optimism full stop. Yeah, best of all possible worlds, everything's for the best, great. Um, and you know, that was quite deeply steeped in religion that there was a greater power and everything had meaning because of that. And that is Pangloss, you know, that is exactly who that is.
[1:05:56] Jimi: Right.
[1:05:57] Tommy: Um, yeah, Candide goes on this journey and learns that well, actually maybe that isn't the right thing, right? And gets to this stage at the end where he's like, okay, it's this.
[1:06:07] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:06:07] Tommy: But then I don't know, even then, people just can't accept that.
[1:06:10] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:06:11] Tommy: Because I've seen like pages upon pages of debate so people have been like, well, the ending is very this person, or the ending is very this philosopher.
[1:06:19] Jimi: Well, and even the differences between how the ending is interpreted, whether you it's it is this hopeful, great where flowers sprout out of the stage, or this terrible backed by, you know, the nuclear wasteland that humanity has brought upon the earth.
[1:06:31] Tommy: Right, exactly. And I think like for me, right, my interpretation of it, because that's all I have. I don't have my books and philosophy to look through and relate things to.
[1:06:40] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:06:40] Tommy: Um, my interpretation of it is that it's like it all comes down to that line of like we do the best we know.
[1:06:47] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:06:48] Tommy: Right. Um that's literally all we can do ever.
[1:06:54] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:06:55] Tommy: Genuinely. That's that's that is the baseline. Um, and I think when you accept that, it's all good, mate. You know, like genuinely, because it's like, okay, are you doing the best you can?
[1:07:06] Jimi: Right.
[1:07:06] Tommy: Good.
[1:07:07] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:07:07] Tommy: Well, and that I mean, that is what if you as two dimensional as these characters are, that is, you know, Candide's modus operandi throughout the whole thing. You know, every time he accidentally murders someone or makes a choice, as if you can even call them choices when he makes them, it's always like, well, this seems like the best choice we could make in this situation.
[1:07:25] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:07:25] Tommy: And oftentimes it bites him in the ass. Um, but like that is, and then he learns from that. It's like still you want to, and like that is different from optimism. Like that is, you know, that to me is the rub of the thing. It's not just kind of like accept it. I don't know, like, yeah, but then people would say, Oh, that's nihilistic. And I'm like, it's not.
[1:07:47] Jimi: Right.
[1:07:48] Tommy: Because I don't understand what that is. So it's not that. Do you know what I mean? Because actually there is like 20 other influences going on that have got me to that decision. It is not one worldview.
[1:08:00] Jimi: Right.
[1:08:00] Tommy: Um it frustrates me. It really, it really frustrates me.
[1:08:04] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:08:06] Tommy: Um, that's I mean, I think that's one of the poisons of pieces like this of musical theater. On the page, Candide seems very simplistic, right? And you can leave it with a very simplistic view of the moral that you learned.
[1:08:24] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:08:24] Tommy: You know, happy ending. Happy well, it but happy ending, but because we accept the middle ground. Things aren't for the best, but they're also not for the worst.
[1:08:34] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:08:36] Tommy: Would you and like that that interpretation isn't wrong?
[1:08:39] Jimi: But well, no interpretation is wrong.
[1:08:42] Tommy: Right, because there's a thousand of them.
[1:08:44] Jimi: Exactly.
[1:08:45] Tommy: But like that's that is the question of like, does this story tell itself in the best way? And is that Bernstein's problem or Voltaire's problem?
[1:08:54] Jimi: Like well, I think at the time Voltaire wrote the best story he could, absolutely.
[1:08:59] Tommy: And I think it worked. He wrote the Candide version of the story.
[1:09:02] Jimi: He did a Candide.
[1:09:03] Tommy: Yeah, he Candide the heck out of that. Um but interestingly enough, I don't uh I think in this day and age, yeah, Candide isn't the right story to tell.
[1:09:13] Jimi: Yeah, to tell that to illustrate that point.
[1:09:17] Tommy: Because it's I think it's really I'm gonna get hit in the face. That's fine. It's a bit up its own arse.
[1:09:23] Jimi: That I agree with.
[1:09:24] Tommy: Yes. And I think people uh I think people really buy into that. I'm not saying that it it isn't steeped in intellectualism and it isn't steeped in interpretation. Like there is it is the pamphlet that was written, however many hundred years ago, yeah, was very good because look at you know, look at the years that have passed and look at us still now trying to interpret it, right? Still trying to work out what it's saying.
[1:09:48] Jimi: Right.
[1:09:50] Tommy: And I think I'm not saying I don't think it's frivolous, I think it does have meaning. Um I think for theatre for musical theater, I I don't have any interest in learning anything from it. I I think I I get the ending, and I like the ending, and I like that point of being like, here's an idea.
[1:10:12] Jimi: Right.
[1:10:12] Tommy: I didn't need the past two hours. Do you think it's because it sets itself up as a morality tale?
[1:10:22] Jimi: No.
[1:10:22] Tommy: Okay. And because I'm gonna cite two things here.
[1:10:25] Jimi: Excellent.
[1:10:26] Tommy: Uh two pieces of musical theatre.
[1:10:28] Jimi: Bever that.
[1:10:31] Tommy: Uh I'm gonna cite Pippin and I'm gonna cite Godspell.
[1:10:34] Jimi: Sorry, we're talking about Pippin again.
[1:10:36] Tommy: Um but uh weirdly, both by Schwartz.
[1:10:40] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:10:40] Tommy: Funny. Um I after after watching Candide, all I wanted to do was listen to Godspell.
[1:10:48] Jimi: Interesting.
[1:10:50] Tommy: Because I wasn't angered by it to me, right? Godspell and Pippin are both equally as interpretable pieces of theatre as Candide.
[1:11:04] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:11:05] Tommy: Um and again, there'll be people out there that will think I am trash talking this because this is you know, it's just Voltaire, like this is a historical piece of fiction, absolutely. But to be honest, I get more from watching Pippin, and I get more from watching Godspell um than I do from watching Candide because it's more relatable.
[1:11:24] Jimi: Uh-huh.
[1:11:25] Tommy: To me, again, this is all just opinion. It's more relatable.
[1:11:28] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:11:28] Tommy: Um, it's done in a more cohesive fashion.
[1:11:33] Jimi: Sure.
[1:11:34] Tommy: Like, no one's been like, how the hell do we tell Pippin? Pippin is a story that has been revived very successfully.
[1:11:41] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:11:41] Tommy: Not much changed other than its interpretation. It's a good Pippin, especially is a good parallel to a lot of um Candide stuff because it is, you know, episodic story, yeah you know, it takes place long in the long, long ago. Um with some absolutely distinct ties to its history that they tell you enough about, but also don't burden you with trying to understand. You don't need to know who Charlemagne was to understand Pippin.
[1:12:05] Jimi: Right.
[1:12:05] Tommy: I mean, and this this is like a literary thing here of I think it's like Picaresque or Bildungsroman. I've seen both these words thrown around. Um of like a coming of age, a learning, often by like a male uh archetype. Um and you know, for Pippin, and actually kind of Godspell because it's just a different it's just a different person. And I I kinda almost want to talk about that in a bit as well. But um like I don't know, you can go along in the right with him, and you're not throwing all of this opulence and all of this grandeur that comes with Bernstein's Candide.
[1:12:39] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:12:40] Tommy: You're not confused, really.
[1:12:42] Jimi: Right.
[1:12:43] Tommy: You might be a bit like this is weird, yeah.
[1:12:45] Jimi: Absolutely.
[1:12:46] Tommy: But I still wonder because like Pippin is less set up to be a morality tale in its existence than Candide is.
[1:13:40] Jimi: No, it's you know, it's clownish how uh uh vapid their relationship is, right? Even through to the end when they decide they're gonna settle down together and you know get married, right? You don't really still mean nothing. You don't really care about the romance between them, right?
[1:13:56] Tommy: Right.
[1:13:56] Jimi: Um which is not true of Pippin, right? You care about Pippin.
[1:14:01] Tommy: Um like I I I don't know what I'm doing. Well what I would say is like surely that's better when you're watching theater.
[1:14:10] Jimi: Right.
[1:14:10] Tommy: I I I like Because I'm not reading a pamphlet on philosophy. I'm not reading a pamphleted response to a philosopher's ideals.
[1:14:19] Jimi: Right.
[1:14:20] Tommy: Yeah. Do you know what I mean? I'm going into a house and I'm watching theater.
[1:14:24] Jimi: Right.
[1:14:25] Tommy: Um and I'm not saying theater can't have moral. Obviously not. If you know anything about me, that is literally my thing. Um but it does You are there to experience a story.
[1:14:36] Jimi: Right.
[1:14:36] Tommy: And kind of what I've been saying with Candide is like, I don't know if the story is there.
[1:14:41] Jimi: Right.
[1:14:41] Tommy: It does, I this is this is an oversimplification, but because of the way Voltaire has written Candide, the musical adaptation of Candide is kind of more comparable if there was like, you know, the communist manifesto, the musical.
[1:14:58] Jimi: Oh my god.
[1:14:59] Tommy: Marks.
[1:14:59] Jimi: Right, yeah, Marx.
[1:15:00] Tommy: Exclamation point. Exactly. Um, but you know what I mean? Like, because its source material is so seeped in some underlying you know, political mode morality.
[1:15:14] Jimi: Yeah, yeah.
[1:15:14] Tommy: Um, it is then harder to make the story worthwhile or interesting.
[1:15:25] Jimi: Right.
[1:15:26] Tommy: So there you go. Do you know I mean like that's the thing is like that's that's my that's my issue.
[1:15:31] Jimi: Right.
[1:15:32] Tommy: Like a the problem is Bernstein wrote such great songs for it. Like I think that's the problem with Candide.
[1:15:35] Jimi: Absolutely.
[1:15:40] Tommy: But Bernstein's songs outside of Make Our Garden Grow.
[1:15:45] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:15:45] Tommy: Don't hugely tell the story that Voltaire is talking about. Do you know what I mean? For the most part, like the they talk about other things.
[1:15:55] Jimi: Yeah, the ones that do are those ones that are that I said earlier that are set in stone in the order, right? Best of all possible worlds, auto-da-fé, glitter and be gay, and then make our garden grow.
[1:16:08] Tommy: And I thought, I don't know what I'm just like. Well, and that's I'd I'd I'd rather watch Pippin.
[1:16:18] Jimi: About like musical or operetta or like the problems with adaptation that like in musical theater, the idea is the songs further the story and the character development.
[1:16:33] Tommy: For sure.
[1:16:55] Jimi: Um but then I don't know to because I'm thinking like I was like, okay, I need to think of like give me a like concept of the musical.
[1:17:03] Tommy: Right.
[1:17:04] Jimi: And there's obviously there's so many because like you know, company. You know what a fair one is, and you might not have listened to this one because it's not great, but there is have you heard of The Adding Machine?
[1:17:15] Tommy: Yeah, I love The Adding Machine.
[1:17:17] Jimi: You okay, all right.
[1:17:18] Tommy: Um okay, I love The Adding Machine because it's wackadoo.
[1:17:23] Jimi: Sure, right.
[1:17:24] Tommy: I think if I saw a production of it, I would be bored.
[1:17:27] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:17:27] Tommy: Well, and it the you know, it was a play first that was equally as wackadoo. Um that is a philosophical commentary on what 1920s Americana.
[1:17:41] Jimi: Um yeah, kind of.
[1:17:42] Tommy: Uh-huh. Zeitgeist.
[1:17:44] Jimi: Yeah, you know, like a weird expressionistic piece. If you know nothing about The Adding Machine, you should look it up, the play or the musical.
[1:17:50] Jimi: It's a weird one. You'll love the opening. It's a weird workplace murder drama potentially.
[1:17:59] Tommy: Yeah. Um, but it's super expressionist. Um but has a philosophical edge to it, right?
[1:18:06] Jimi: But I think it absolutely does, yeah. And I think leans into that more so in a way that lets you know that like these characters are not people, they're characters, right?
[1:18:17] Tommy: Whereas Candide treads that line in the other direction, like, you know, Candide is a boy. He is a human boy, right?
[1:18:23] Jimi: Yeah. With human feelings. Except as you watch more of him, he's got like three motivational words, and the you know, slot machine spins in his head and it lands on one of them each scene.
[1:18:34] Tommy: I think maybe that is it. Maybe it's the character maybe it is the characters. Maybe I'm like, who are you? Why have you been twelve people already? Why have you died three times? Like, I have no investment in you.
[1:18:43] Jimi: Right. Um, and it kind of goes beyond Verfremdung's effect. It goes beyond that alienation idea.
[1:18:49] Tommy: Yeah, because they are trying to be characters.
[1:18:53] Jimi: Right. Well, and I think that is the like one of the things that the Zimmerman production did do that I very much enjoyed was that Candide they tried very hard not to make him two dimensional. He wasn't that chipper like oh ho, I am a you know 40-year-old tenor playing a tiny boy.
[1:19:10] Tommy: Like he was cast younger, which I was like more appropriately aged.
[1:19:16] Jimi: Yeah. You know, they'd cast someone who is a better actor than I think a lot of the opera singers who they cast in this role. But then you could see him you know run into these struggles every time he met someone with a new philosophy.
[1:19:29] Tommy: Like, oh that's that's the way the world should be oh okay but is that and you know there's not a lot of time to watch him have those moments so you know perhaps I am adding my own feeling on top of it a little more but then when he does finally make the decision at the end like well I guess we we'll just build a house you know as opposed like we'll just build a house I guess right yeah as so many of these other productions do.
[1:19:54] Jimi: Like I think that's that's what I want in my Candide.
[1:19:57] Tommy: I would agree because to me I'm like sounds like Pippin.
[1:19:59] Jimi: Yeah. Do you know I mean here's like here's a kid who struggles struggle struggle struggle struggle.
[1:20:03] Tommy: Yeah and then makes a decision and it's all taken away from it. I mean like but he's still happy with his decision.
[1:20:07] Jimi: Like that to me is that sounds like that but also you're still having to sit through a lot of guff.
[1:20:18] Tommy: Right to get there.
[1:20:19] Jimi: To get there.
[1:20:20] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:20:20] Jimi: In a way that doesn't really pay off.
[1:20:23] Tommy: No.
[1:20:24] Jimi: Like you could cut you don't need to encounter this one particular philosophy for Candide to have you know, reach his conclusion at the very very end.
[1:20:32] Tommy: Yeah, it's it's funny because like I I kind of appreciate it.
[1:20:36] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:20:36] Tommy: But I I don't really I don't really have this feeling with a lot of musicals.
[1:20:39] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:20:40] Tommy: Which is a good thing, I think.
[1:20:41] Jimi: Yeah, sure. Especially because we do a musical theater podcast.
[1:20:44] Tommy: Right, exactly. But as in like I'm often like, do you know what here's its merit. Here's I love it.
[1:20:48] Jimi: That's true.
[1:20:49] Tommy: But I I'm reluctant with Candide.
[1:20:51] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:20:52] Tommy: Because of its pedigree, I think.
[1:20:54] Jimi: Yeah. I'm like, this should be better by now.
[1:20:57] Tommy: Yeah. I did the I I read this line in one of the many theses. Um so I can't and I didn't cite it so I'm doing a bad job here. But I thought this was very apt. Um someone wrote the dramatic irony is that Candide, the musical, is a journey and not a destination, much like the show itself.
[1:21:15] Jimi: Yep.
[1:21:16] Tommy: And I think that is speaks volumes.
[1:21:19] Jimi: Exactly. No, but you're you're it's totally right because there are people that would have read Voltaire's pamphlet and disagreed with it wholeheartedly.
[1:21:27] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:21:28] Jimi: And there are people that will go and see Candide and they will disagree with it wholeheartedly.
[1:21:33] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:21:33] Jimi: Yeah, that's fair.
[1:21:35] Tommy: That's fine.
[1:21:36] Jimi: That's theatre. If if that's you know that means it is, you know, perhaps for its faults still doing its job.
[1:21:43] Tommy: Absolutely.
[1:21:44] Jimi: And the music is gorgeous.
[1:21:46] Tommy: The music's really good.
[1:21:48] Jimi: I've not said that once.
[1:21:50] Tommy: The music's amazing. There's a I it's I disappointed a lot of people. I don't think you've seen it yet in a in a in a moment of insomnia um I published Oh I know exactly what you're talking about. I published a video on musical theater mash long awaited that people got very excited about and it's really just a cut up of um the finale of Candide and Animal Crossing.
[1:22:12] Jimi: And it's yeah I still find it very funny.
[1:22:15] Tommy: Do you know what's do you know what's interesting though?
[1:22:17] Jimi: Deeply emotional Tommy.
[1:22:19] Tommy: I surprisingly so.
[1:22:20] Jimi: Like I started it as a joke, and I was getting into it and I was like, this is really moving.
[1:22:25] Tommy: Exactly. I because I don't know whether Tommy, whether it's just because of all of the shenanigans going on at the moment. But I watched that and I was just really like, you know, watching your little guy make his garden. I was like, that's beautiful.
[1:22:39] Jimi: Yeah. And you know what? It's just so interesting because obviously at the moment there are a lot of people.
[1:22:44] Tommy: Right, hold on. I can hear an ice cream truck.
[1:22:46] Jimi: Is that yeah, I know that's gonna happen a lot. So we'll just we'll just brush through it.
[1:22:50] Tommy: Um optimism.
[1:22:53] Jimi: Ice cream. But no, uh I think it yeah, all over the world right now, people are playing Animal Crossing and making these little gardens and kind of taken a step back and uh looked at what they've got and at the moment are doing the best they know.
[1:23:11] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:23:12] Jimi: Um and I think that weirdly links up really nicely with Candide.
[1:23:19] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:23:19] Jimi: Um the finale of Candide.
[1:23:21] Tommy: Absolutely.
[1:23:22] Jimi: Uh because it you know, that that's that idea of like it's it's taking the time to simplify.
[1:23:29] Tommy: Yeah, I don't know about you, but I've had lots of conversations with people where they're saying that do you know what I've realized a lot more so than I ever have because I've stopped.
[1:23:40] Jimi: Yeah, yeah.
[1:23:41] Tommy: When there I I was on a on a socially distanced walk around the block the other day, um, and someone had written on the sidewalk um adversity makes a man confront himself.
[1:23:53] Jimi: And there is, you know, whether it's in Candide or in you know this life-changing world we're living in right now, but there is something about like insurmountable obstacle and confrontation with like the constructed human world that we live in, and once pieces of it start getting slashed away, it really, really makes you confront what you have control over and what brings you joy.
[1:24:22] Tommy: Um exact there it is.
[1:24:24] Jimi: There there it is. It's what brings you joy.
[1:24:26] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:24:27] Jimi: It's what are you gonna do today that's just gonna make you happy.
[1:24:30] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:24:31] Jimi: You're now given permission to do that.
[1:24:33] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:24:34] Jimi: Um I've been taking a lot of solace in that idea and it's really like I feel I feel good.
[1:24:43] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:24:43] Jimi: Yeah. You know what I mean? Which is a funny thing to say at the moment.
[1:24:47] Tommy: But I feel really good because I've thought about this a lot.
[1:24:50] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:24:51] Tommy: And I have really taken the time to look at myself and be like, hang on.
[1:24:59] Jimi: Yeah. Why was I stressed?
[1:25:00] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:25:01] Jimi: Well and it's I think one of the crazy things is people have introspective life changing moments all the time, right?
[1:25:09] Tommy: But individually and exactly.
[1:25:12] Jimi: Right. That now we're all doing it. You know, now we're about one.
[1:25:15] Tommy: Uh we're all playing Animal Crossing at once.
[1:25:18] Jimi: Um Exactly. We're all playing Animal Crossing at once and we can talk to people about Animal Crossing.
[1:25:23] Tommy: Right.
[1:25:23] Jimi: You know, metaphorically and actually.
[1:25:25] Tommy: Um Exactly. And people will get it.
[1:25:27] Jimi: Yeah, and I'm you know, mean that not as a joke.
[1:25:30] Tommy: Um yeah it is it is interesting.
[1:25:33] Jimi: It is interesting that, you know, accidentally Candide has kind of landed on our predictions our predictions really does as I've jokingly together.
[1:25:45] Tommy: Right, exactly. During these challenging times.
[1:25:47] Jimi: And I don't mean to, you know, I'm sure neither of us mean to be flippant about the not at all the current conversation because I do take it I do take it very seriously.
[1:25:55] Tommy: Oh, yeah.
[1:25:55] Jimi: And I think I think you know, at the end of the day, um we've still got that garden to tend to.
[1:26:02] Tommy: Right.
[1:26:03] Jimi: So let's just get in about it.
[1:26:05] Tommy: Let's do it.
[1:26:05] Jimi: Yeah. And I think that's the thing is you're like, well, okay, how are you gonna do that? Well, we'll do the best we know. You know, it is the best we know.
[1:26:14] Tommy: It is very apt for all of its craziness.
[1:26:18] Jimi: Thank you, Leonard Bernstein.
[1:27:34] Tommy: And make our wrong Well, Tommy, we made it through our journey.
[1:28:04] Jimi: Fifty fifty four years later or whatever. I'm exhausted. It feels like we've traversed an ocean and our boat has sunk.
[1:28:14] Tommy: I think I got syphilis.
[1:28:16] Jimi: But then I got cured of it, and then I was stabbed, and then I came back to the house.
[1:28:19] Tommy: And then a statue fell on me.
[1:28:21] Jimi: Yeah, that was a shame.
[1:28:22] Tommy: Yeah, well, you know there's a sheep just beside me, so I'm happy.
[1:28:25] Jimi: We didn't even talk about the animals.
[1:28:27] Tommy: We didn't talk about the sheep.
[1:28:28] Jimi: These damn sheep. They don't make any sense. I always forget I always forget that they're there, and then the sheep show up again. I'm like, oh yeah, that's damn part.
[1:28:35] Tommy: But weirdly again, do you know another show where there's weird sheep?
[1:28:39] Jimi: Godspell. Just saying.
[1:28:40] Tommy: Anyway. What's next? I got a quiz question for you.
[1:28:43] Jimi: It's not a question, but I'm gonna say it with an upward inflection, so it sounds like one.
[1:28:50] Tommy: Sammy Davis Jr. was originally slated to originate this role in its pre-musical incarnation.
[1:28:57] Jimi: Who knows if this show would have been such a runaway success if it were more rat pack in style.
[1:29:06] Tommy: Who knows? Um, if you want to get in touch with us, the show Twitter is Jim and Tomic, uh, or join us in the Reddit discussion. Links are in the show notes right now on your podcatcher or at gym and tomic.com.
[1:29:16] Jimi: Yes, and while you are there, you can check out our Patreon page if you would like to financially support the show. Um, we want to give a big, big love to all of our current patrons, um, who even in these times are still supporting us and we love you for that.
[1:29:32] Tommy: Um but if you want, you can just go over to Apple Podcasts and leave us a review there because they're great.
[1:29:38] Jimi: And most of all it just helps that you listen. Um, you know, tell your friends everyone's looking for something to do right now. If you need a good backlog of stuff, we got a huge one.
[1:29:47] Tommy: It's a great time to jump in.
[1:29:49] Jimi: We've got almost 80 episodes for you, my friend. Look at us.
[1:29:52] Tommy: You know, and thanks for listening. Be safe out there.
[1:29:54] Jimi: Um I hear the ice cream van.
[1:29:57] Tommy: Yeah, Jimmy's gonna have to.
[1:29:59] Jimi: Jimmy's got new neighbors. He's gonna go, do they throw how does that even work? Do they throw the ice cream at you?
[1:30:02] Tommy: How can you socially distance ice cream?
[1:30:05] Jimi: I know, exactly. I think it's a whole illegal affair. I don't approve.
[1:30:09] Tommy: I don't approve, but hey.
[1:30:11] Jimi: Um so yeah, that's all for today. Thank you so much for listening.
[1:30:14] Tommy: And cheers.
[1:30:15] Jimi: Cheers.
[1:30:29] Tommy: Thank you, Leonard Bernstein.
[1:30:33] Jimi: You're welcome.
[1:30:35] Tommy: He's right behind you, Jimmy.
[1:30:37] Jimi: Quick! He's not six feet away.
[1:30:40] Tommy: Run!
[1:30:41] Jimi: Excuse me.
[1:30:43] Tommy: Take you this seriously.
[1:30:44] Jimi: Thank you.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
