Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Happy Hour #84: Mobius Podcast - 'A Strange Loop'

Happy Hour #84: Mobius Podcast - 'A Strange Loop' Let’s get metaphysical! It’s about darn time we discussed Michael R. Jackson’s Pulitzer winning ‘A Strange Loop.’ Potentially one of the most challenging musicals we have ever listened to, we are so excited delve into this extremely unique piece of musical theatre... Read More

From the show: Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour

1 h 52 mins
7/30/20

Featured Shows

About

Happy Hour #84: Mobius Podcast - 'A Strange Loop'

Let’s get metaphysical! It’s about darn time we discussed Michael R. Jackson’s Pulitzer winning ‘A Strange Loop.’ Potentially one of the most challenging musicals we have ever listened to, we are so excited delve into this extremely unique piece of musical theatre. Join in the conversation as we chat about what this show winning the Pulitzer means for musical theatre, how Michael R. Jackson’s raw honesty is refreshing and important, and muse on the future of Broadway once it has reopened.

Support the Show ➤

A Strange Loop (Original Cast Recording)

Amazon / iTunes / Spotify

SHOW NOTES

Black lives matter. As well as listening and hearing ‘A Strange Loop’ here’s a list of ways in which you can support the ongoing movement, and if you’re in the UK you can go here.

The article posted by Vogue is interesting as it was released when it won the Pulitzer, but before the George Floyd protests began. Definitely worth a read!

Frustratingly we don’t get the full story from the cast recording this time around, but you can preorder the libretto now for when it’s released on September 22nd this year!

There’s a fantastically comprehensive interview with Michael R. Jackson with Playwrights Horizon about his life and his journey to writing ‘A Strange Loop.’

Here’s the track that originally framed the show by Liz Phair who Michael R. Jackson is a massive fan of. Enjoy that delicious 90s sound!

If you want to delve into more of the deeply intellectual basis for this show then check our Hofstadter’s “I Am A Strange Loop” or DuBois’s commentary on double consciousness.

Jimi thoroughly recommends you get down and dirty with a copy of ‘Life of Pi’ by Yann Martel.

Here is a list of all of the ‘upcoming’ shows from black writers and black stories on Broadway. What do you think? Will Broadway listen and change?

Here’s an interesting article discussing Avenue Q and Book of Mormon in a 2020 lens.

Remember you can come chat to us about the episode on Twitter and Instagram @jimandtomic! Or if you wanna pop OFF then jump into our email inbox at jimandtomic@gmail.com!

A Dating Quiz Question

The author of this musical (allegedly) likes piña coladas and getting caught in the rain. What show?

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Jimmy: Do they say action?

[0:01] Tommy: I always had like—let me just think about all of the movies, the feature films I've been in.

[0:06] Jimmy: Um, my recollection, they do, yeah.

[0:11] Tommy: Certainly in the last seven I've done, they've done that.

[0:14] Jimmy: I guess the broader question I have is I'm always interested in like the different theatrical and movie vernacular between the UK and America.

[0:26] Tommy: I feel like I don't know the answer to that.

[0:32] Jimmy: I think, yeah, from any like movie extra I've seen, yeah, it's just—it's that's a universal thing.

[0:37] Tommy: Everyone says action.

[0:38] Jimmy: Action.

[0:39] Tommy: It's so—like there's one I encountered, like marker.

[0:42] Jimmy: What's marker?

[0:43] Tommy: I don't know.

[0:45] Jimmy: Somebody get us another drink.

[0:47] Tommy: Welcome to Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour.

[0:50] Jimmy: I'm Jimmy.

[0:51] Tommy: And I'm Tommy, and this is the only musical theater podcast with tequila shotting.

[0:56] Jimmy: And song spotting.

[0:58] Tommy: Here we take apart your favorite shows, muddle them together with a shot of buffoonery, and pour you a refreshing glass of musical theatre conversation.

[1:08] Jimmy: Hey Tommy, what you drinking today?

[1:11] Tommy: Uh, it's a glass of water I can see my reflection in.

[1:22] Jimmy: Nice.

[1:22] Tommy: I thought you were gonna say something with like a bendy straw.

[1:22] Jimmy: A bendy straw?

[1:27] Tommy: Yeah, like a bendy straw?

[1:28] Jimmy: Like, oh, got loops in it?

[1:30] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:33] Jimmy: Right?

[1:34] Tommy: Or like fruit milk.

[1:36] Jimmy: We would call that a crazy straw and not a bendy straw.

[1:40] Tommy: A bendy straw would be like a normal straw.

[1:43] Jimmy: With like a normal straw one bendy.

[1:45] Tommy: Yeah, that's true.

[1:45] Jimmy: That's fair.

[1:46] Tommy: Maybe we wouldn't call it a bendy straw.

[1:48] Jimmy: Although I think if I asked for a bendy straw, that's what I would get.

[1:51] Tommy: Not one with a bunch of loops in it?

[1:53] Jimmy: No, as in I would get it.

[1:55] Tommy: You wouldn't get that.

[1:55] Jimmy: I wish you—I wish like Starbucks and stuff just had like crazy straws.

[2:00] Tommy: Normal straws and crazy straws.

[2:02] Jimmy: I'm sure in our world of renewable straws that you could get a renewable crazy straw.

[2:07] Tommy: A metal.

[2:08] Jimmy: Here's my aluminum crazy straw.

[2:10] Tommy: Yeah, my hipster crazy straw.

[2:12] Jimmy: But I feel like if it's opaque, it takes out the fun of a crazy straw.

[2:17] Tommy: Yeah, because then you don't get to see the joy happening.

[2:19] Jimmy: Sorry.

[2:20] Tommy: This show was the first musical to receive the Pulitzer without a production on Broadway.

[2:26] Jimmy: What show, Jimmy?

[2:27] Tommy: Well, Tommy, it is a crazy loop.

[2:31] Jimmy: No, a crazy bandit.

[2:32] Tommy: No, I'm joking. It's a strange loop.

[2:35] Jimmy: Usher, usher, usher, usher, usher, usher, usher, usher, usher, usher, usher, usher, usher, usher, usher, usher, usher, usher, usher, usher, usher, usher, usher.

[3:12] Tommy: Can I really write this?

[3:15] Jimmy: How many minutes till the end of intermission?

[3:18] Tommy: Is that how the show should open?

[3:19] Jimmy: Should there even be a show?

[3:20] Tommy: It should start with what he's thinking, which is just a cursor blinking.

[3:23] Jimmy: Because of all of the directions that the narrative can tell.

[3:27] Tommy: Show what it's like to live up here and travel our world in a fat black queer body.

[3:38] Jimmy: How many minutes till the end of intermission?

[3:40] Tommy: A strange loop.

[3:41] Jimmy: Book, music, and lyrics by Mr. Michael R. Jackson.

[3:44] Tommy: Yes, and it has had its off-Broadway premiere.

[3:47] Jimmy: It was at Playwright's Horizons recently, May 24th through July 28th of 2019.

[3:52] Tommy: And it won the Pulitzer, number 10 for musicals for drama.

[3:57] Jimmy: It won in 2020.

[3:59] Tommy: Yeah.

[4:00] Jimmy: That was funny. You said musicals for drama, which I thought is like a lovely cause.

[4:08] Tommy: I would join the musicals for drama.

[4:10] Jimmy: Yeah.

[4:11] Tommy: They're my favorite kind.

[4:12] Jimmy: Um, but yes, exactly.

[4:14] Tommy: And that was only earlier this year, mid—like post-Pulitzer shutdown.

[4:20] Jimmy: Yeah.

[4:20] Tommy: We got some good news.

[4:22] Jimmy: Yeah.

[4:23] Tommy: And exciting news.

[4:25] Jimmy: And, uh, did you know there was—of all the three things that were up for the Pulitzer, two of them were musicals?

[4:32] Tommy: That's awesome.

[4:32] Jimmy: It's always—whenever I dive back into some of the history of both the Pulitzer Prize in general, but especially the Pulitzer Prize for drama as it relates to musicals, it's just such a fascinating—I think it's cool, and I enjoy watching, you know, art forms that we enjoy receiving these high honors.

[4:52] Tommy: And I always continually get the sense that a lot of awards are bullshit and arbitrary and, you know, a kind of prestige game.

[5:04] Jimmy: I would say maybe that has changed in recent years, maybe, I don't know.

[5:09] Tommy: But also I agree with the musicals that have won Pulitzers that are deserving of it.

[5:14] Jimmy: I don't know.

[5:14] Tommy: I have a conflicted sense about it because it is a bunch of smart people deciding what the smart people thing is.

[5:21] Jimmy: Yeah, exactly.

[5:21] Tommy: You know, I think the thing that I f—because it's such a—it's obviously it's an American right institution, so I like reflecting on it as a non-American.

[5:21] Jimmy: Sure.

[5:21] Tommy: And I just think it—you know, to look at the list because I think we talked about this before when we did—it's probably Next to Normal that would have been something.

[5:21] Jimmy: Yeah, uh-huh.

[5:21] Tommy: But we talked about because like these shows in their own right, there's something very American about them.

[5:21] Jimmy: Like, yeah, at their heart they are an American story in some way, whether it's like a moment in history or whether it's a feeling at the time.

[5:21] Tommy: Yeah, I would say that seems especially so in re—it—in case you don't have working knowledge of Pulitzer, although how many quizzes or you call them trivias have you done in lockdown where this has been the question?

[5:21] Jimmy: Oh man, I don't know.

[5:21] Tommy: It's been some kind of question to do with musicals in the Pulitzer.

[5:21] Jimmy: I would say I feel like I could rock it, but I always forget of the Icing and Fiorello.

[6:21] Tommy: I always forget South Pacific.

[6:23] Jimmy: Really?

[6:23] Tommy: South Pacific, I wouldn't decide of the—I think South Pacific, Fiorello, How to Succeed in Business, A Chorus Line, Sunday in the Park with George, Rent, Next to Normal, Hamilton, and A Strange Loop are the ten now.

[6:33] Jimmy: And I will say like maybe How to Succeed in on and maybe even Fiorello, South Pacific, and of the—I saying I'm just not as well versed in Americana in those times because they are so far away, but do seem to be—I think you're right, very emblematic of the time when they were written, you know, and like really capturing some very zeitgeisty, appropriately zeitgeisty thing.

[6:58] Tommy: Exactly, exactly.

[6:59] Jimmy: And I think like, yeah, the fact that it's A Strange Loop now is really good and quite telling and, um, yeah, an important thing.

[7:11] Tommy: I mean, obviously like there's been plays in between all of these, it's not just the still attack.

[7:17] Jimmy: Um, but I could not tell you a single one.

[7:19] Tommy: Nope.

[7:19] Jimmy: Um, so for us in the way that we view theatre through our musicals lens, this is a big—to me, it's a big moment.

[7:27] Tommy: Like Hamilton kind of paved the way for this to happen.

[7:30] Jimmy: Yeah.

[7:31] Tommy: Um, but I think as we go on and we talk about the show a lot more, I think it's safe to say that, um, like, um, things like Rent, and even I guess maybe Next to Normal, of these like very original stories, um, there's not really anything like this show.

[7:53] Jimmy: Yes, yeah, I would agree with that.

[7:55] Tommy: I think it does trade on a lot of tropes of its form, but very effectively and in a new, fascinating, new and interesting way.

[8:06] Jimmy: Absolutely.

[8:07] Tommy: And, but I just think like in terms of at its heart and its content, yeah, to the basic point of content.

[8:14] Jimmy: Oh yeah, this doesn't exist.

[8:15] Tommy: I mean, I haven't felt challenged in this particular way by a musical in any other way that I contextualize.

[8:26] Jimmy: This is a challenging show.

[8:29] Tommy: Agreed, agreed, and in a way I'm like, good.

[8:33] Jimmy: Yeah.

[8:33] Tommy: I love it, and I'm excited to talk about it.

[8:36] Jimmy: Um, for sure, for a ton of reasons.

[8:38] Tommy: Did you—I slept on this show, honestly.

[8:41] Jimmy: Um, yeah, I didn't realize it—it was last year.

[8:43] Tommy: I thought it was like—because when obviously the Pulitzer got announced, yeah.

[8:47] Jimmy: I thought it had like maybe just opened off-Broadway at the start of this year, and I was like, oh no.

[8:47] Tommy: Yeah, actually.

[8:54] Jimmy: I have a good friend who—we both used to live in Chicago, and he moved to New York when I moved to Denver.

[9:00] Tommy: Um, and maybe mid, you know, 2019, he did send me a text kind of out of the blue that was like, hey, do you know anything about A Strange Loop?

[9:09] Jimmy: I think it's really good.

[9:10] Tommy: Um, my response was like, huh, no, I don't.

[9:13] Jimmy: And that was my exposure to it.

[9:15] Tommy: And then I didn't revisit it till it won the Pulitzer.

[9:18] Jimmy: Didn't cross my radar, and you know, I don't know.

[9:21] Tommy: I feel a sense of shame about that that might be worth unpacking later.

[9:27] Jimmy: I mean, potentially, but probably only in hindsight.

[9:30] Tommy: Sure, yeah.

[9:31] Jimmy: You know, I mean, like, not like hearing the title and knowing that, yeah.

[9:34] Tommy: I don't think you would think, oh, you know, if your friend was like, this is like our usual, like quite revolutionary, right?

[9:43] Jimmy: You probably would have listened.

[9:44] Tommy: Probably would have listened.

[9:44] Jimmy: But him just being like this kind of cool musical, really like it.

[9:47] Tommy: Yeah, but I know—I mean, I do think there's something, and we're gonna get to the big hedging and apologizing in a second, but I do think there is something to, you know, we live in a world of musical theater news all the time, right?

[10:00] Jimmy: You know, we are often on the cutting edge of shows that pop up and first to listen to and stuff to get excited about, or like right when the bubbling about a show starts to bubble, yeah, it hits our world.

[10:12] Tommy: And this show didn't bubble for us in ways, with—you know, because we were allowed to sleep on it.

[10:18] Jimmy: And is it an accident or is it a sign of the institutionalized racism?

[10:25] Tommy: Is a really interesting question to explore, like the lifespan of a musical, the life of a musical outside of the show itself and how it reaches the popular consciousness.

[10:36] Jimmy: Like I think it's telling that I knew more about on the other one that was up for the Pulitzer than I did about this.

[10:42] Tommy: Yeah, yeah, I think that is.

[10:43] Jimmy: I mean, and I was like, oh, there's this huge new groundbreaker, and it's um, David Henry Wang.

[10:48] Tommy: Yep.

[10:48] Jimmy: Like, this is so cool.

[10:50] Tommy: And in the meantime, A Strange Loop was doing its thing.

[10:52] Jimmy: Right.

[10:52] Tommy: And it didn't hit your radar at all.

[10:55] Jimmy: And it is—it is a question of like, you know, whose responsibility is that to tell Jimmy and Tommy about shows?

[11:02] Tommy: Or is it our responsibility to seek it out?

[11:05] Jimmy: You know.

[11:06] Tommy: It's exactly a fascinating question.

[11:08] Jimmy: But hey, we're talking about it now, so that's good.

[11:11] Tommy: Yeah.

[11:11] Jimmy: You want to get to the big hedging?

[11:14] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.

[11:15] Jimmy: You're really good at it, so I'm like—we do this all the time.

[11:19] Tommy: Um, you know, we talk about stuff that's outside of our lane.

[11:22] Jimmy: This is a show about, uh, you know, a lot of black issues, about a lot of what it's like to be black in America.

[11:28] Tommy: Jimmy and I are two white people.

[11:29] Jimmy: Um, and it is, you know, always important to acknowledge that stuff that like we're probably gonna step in it.

[11:35] Tommy: You know, we're like, I think we're conscious about this stuff and we wanna, you know, be conscientious, but this is a tricky stuff to talk around.

[11:46] Jimmy: Um, it's important for us to talk around it as, you know, white theater critics, white theater commentators, whatever the hell we are.

[11:55] Tommy: Um, but if—you know, the same way when we talk about straight relationships, we're stepping outside our lane.

[12:02] Jimmy: But this one, I guess it is diminutive to compare those two, but they're similar.

[12:07] Tommy: It's a very different lane, yeah.

[12:08] Jimmy: Right.

[12:09] Tommy: Um, so you know, we're gonna be talking about and assuming things about experiences that we don't have.

[12:16] Jimmy: Um.

[12:17] Tommy: But it's also—that's the reason to do it.

[12:19] Jimmy: And I think it's one of the reasons we like theater and we like, you know, musical theater because they are representative of life experiences outside your own in a way that attempts to allow you to sympathize with them.

[12:32] Tommy: Exactly, exactly.

[12:33] Jimmy: And I think that is a beautiful segue to start talking about what this is.

[12:37] Tommy: Here we go.

[12:38] Jimmy: We want to know what's going on in New York.

[12:45] Tommy: We wanna know what's going on in your life.

[12:51] Jimmy: With people they're living in it, which are way.

[12:54] Tommy: And to everyone the B L E say.

[12:58] Jimmy: We wanna know what's going on in New York.

[13:03] Tommy: Yeah, I think you just hit on the point directly there.

[13:05] Jimmy: Like, um, it was interesting.

[13:09] Tommy: I can't remember, um, what publication it was.

[13:12] Jimmy: Let me look that up.

[13:15] Tommy: No.

[13:15] Jimmy: It was Vogue.

[13:17] Tommy: Of all things.

[13:18] Jimmy: Okay.

[13:19] Tommy: Come on, Vogue.

[13:20] Jimmy: Um, but yeah, basically they said that what makes it so powerful that it's not an attempt to find our common humanity amongst its diverse audience.

[13:35] Tommy: Yeah, but actually it's talking about its own thing.

[13:39] Jimmy: Um, the lyric in the song in the opening number puts it so beautifully—to show what it's like to live up here and travel through the world in a fat, black, queer body.

[13:49] Tommy: Yeah.

[13:50] Jimmy: It's not—it's not for us to be like, here's how you can tell your story through this.

[13:55] Tommy: Right.

[13:56] Jimmy: It is, here's how to tell my story.

[13:58] Tommy: Exactly.

[13:59] Jimmy: And you can see that.

[14:00] Tommy: Like that's—that's a crucial thing, I think.

[14:02] Tommy: And like I think I've already done a disservice by like couching the apology in about just being black, because they even uh, you know, that is lampshaded even in uh what is it today? Um you know, I forget which thought is calling Usher, um, but it's like, you know, we're gonna get you into something unapologetically black. Um and that like this is a discussion of like what you know, what it is to be black in a black world and what it is to be black in a white world, and the kind of intersectionality of that. Um and also like to delve even deeper, like what it's like to be black and gay.

[14:39] Jimmy: Yeah. Just because you know, the main character is gay doesn't mean that and we shouldn't really relate to his experience, and that is something I really want to talk about.

[14:46] Tommy: Absolutely. Um later is the the kind of differences and things that sort of eye-opened me when I was listening to this. So if if you two have slept on a strange loop, um absolutely listen to it.

[14:58] Jimmy: This Good morning.

[14:59] Tommy: Yeah, right. Welcome.

[15:00] Jimmy: It's great. You should listen.

[15:02] Tommy: This might be if we're depending upon what songs we're including in this, this might be one episode labeled explicit. Um you know, content warning on some on the whole damn thing. Um but it is this kind of uh uh thought exercise of the main character whose name is Usher, uh, you know, a uh big fat and queer American black man, um uh uh uh discovering, exploring his place in uh himself and how he relates to the heteronormative world around him and kind of the white world of Broadway and the religious world of his parents.

[15:41] Jimmy: Um and it is this, you know, self-referential looking at itself. It in in the same way I said it like kind of capitalizes on some tried and true musical theater tropes or things that have become tried and true musical theater tropes.

[15:54] Tommy: It is a musical about a guy writing a musical about a guy writing a musical, um, and you know, young talent in New York and all of these things, but it the whole thing's kind of flipped on its head as a uh an extreme act of self-introspection.

[16:10] Jimmy: Yeah.

[16:11] Tommy: Yeah, that that was well done. Actually, I did not want to take on that challenge, but I think you did it very well.

[16:17] Jimmy: Um completely.

[16:19] Tommy: Like it's uh like involved and folded in on itself, yeah, in the way that it is just naturally structured. But I think even just in its its general presentation, like you just kind of sit on different thoughts at different times.

[16:35] Jimmy: Like there's no like there's not even really a a journey.

[16:41] Tommy: Like there's no I I I for as abstract as the whole thing is, it is also remarkably narrative. Um we follow Usher, who's this main character, he gets his name because he's an Usher at the Lion King.

[16:55] Jimmy: Um, and one of the motifs is that this all might be happening in his head during intermission of the Lion King.

[17:02] Tommy: Um, but we watch him kind of explore, you know, he's a uh a budding musical theater playwright. Certainly it is a cipher for Michael R. Jackson.

[17:09] Jimmy: Um, I think unapologetically so.

[17:13] Tommy: Um, but is uh Usher is kind of contemplating, you know, his relationship with his parents, who have a uh I would say a more traditional upbringing, they're not very pleased with his homosexuality or his kind of artsy fartsy lifestyle.

[17:28] Jimmy: The one thing they really want him to do with his newfound MFA is to write a gospel play in the style of Tyler Perry, whom Usher despises, um, which he you know kind of does and kind of doesn't, and the whole then play itself kind of becomes a representation of this gospel play that he could write.

[17:46] Tommy: We also watched Usher um wade into the world of gay online dating and being a a black man in that space, um, in I think some of the most difficult to listen to songs on the album.

[18:00] Jimmy: Um kind of you know, full circle coming to terms with who he is.

[18:09] Tommy: But see, do you think so? Do you think he does come to terms at the end? Do you think do you think there is a full stop on it?

[18:16] Jimmy: That's a good question.

[18:19] Tommy: And like, do you find is the ending of this musical satisfying?

[18:23] Jimmy: Um, and it does, you know, if we're gonna talk form a little bit, it it plays on a lot of musical theater tropes there.

[18:30] Tommy: Um I was um I was joking with my boyfriend earlier. What's the lyric that was stuck in my head?

[18:38] Jimmy: Um is it dick sucking or big dick daddy sucking cock all Saturday morning, something like that.

[18:45] Tommy: Yes, uh-huh.

[18:46] Jimmy: I wrote that I vaguely recall.

[18:47] Tommy: Yeah.

[18:48] Jimmy: Um and like the tune is is infectious and stuck in my head, and like I can't sing that out loud walking down the street.

[18:54] Tommy: Um right.

[18:56] Jimmy: And I think like the the finale of this song, when we do come full circle, you know, the it a strange loop, it is a reprise of the initial song, and capitalizes on that musical theater, like, hey, it's the song you recognize from before, so clearly we must have come back where we started, but then the whole thing does kind of end uh like it doesn't button very well intentionally so.

[19:16] Tommy: Yeah.

[19:17] Jimmy: So it's it I think it is very well structured to leave you with that question.

[19:21] Tommy: Does it be a good thing?

[19:22] Jimmy: Well, I think I think, yeah, just because the even in the in the last song, like he ends it with maybes, like it they're not definite statements are like I have changed I have gone through the fire and I've come through the other side and realize that actually you know change starts from within like that kind of idea like or you don't need to change or whatever the the moral is I mean if any if if any moral he lands on it's that the sense of self is just an illusion maybe exactly and that and that's it but it's it's that maybe right is it just kind of leads you back because the the the idea that uh after this he'll have this awakening and will never reflect on himself again is is so silly because that's that's the whole discussion of the whole thing is that this is an ongoing never ending exactly strange loop.

[20:14] Tommy: And that that is the you know super that is the double meta of the whole thing is that you're watching the show that was written about this thought process.

[20:26] Jimmy: Yeah.

[20:27] Tommy: You know so so it the whole thing looks in on itself.

[20:32] Jimmy: Massively and I just think like I think that's that is one of the things that that draws me to it so much is that I like I love like weird shit.

[20:43] Tommy: Like I really love weird shit and I love abstract things that like I I you know I mean the presentation of an idea is about that's my job.

[20:52] Jimmy: Sure.

[20:53] Tommy: I really really love that you don't need you know I mean you don't need to just hand me a really like pinpointed story.

[21:00] Jimmy: I love good storytelling, but I think like this is good storytelling.

[21:04] Tommy: Yeah.

[21:05] Jimmy: Because it reaches into a concept right and tells a story.

[21:08] Tommy: Yeah.

[21:09] Jimmy: Like that is yeah incredible.

[21:10] Tommy: In in a way, you know, musical theatre is pop culture.

[21:14] Jimmy: And like in a way that is accessible to the you know, quote unquote lay person.

[21:20] Tommy: And I don't mean that diminutively. Um, musical theatre is meant to be understood and enjoyed as a loaded term, but enjoyed um by whoever walks in the door.

[21:32] Jimmy: And you know, honestly, the daringness to present such a complex and nuanced self-study through this form in a way that you know would be accessible to my mother.

[21:46] Tommy: Um would still be challenging to my mother, don't get me wrong.

[21:50] Jimmy: Um is cool, is new, is not it's very new, you know.

[21:55] Tommy: Um like obviously reading quite a lot about it, a lot of people um obviously compare it to company.

[22:03] Jimmy: Sure.

[22:03] Tommy: Um, and I think actually Michael uh Michael R. Jackson puts I think at the start of the playbill, he says that um it's like a blend of company and passing strange, yeah.

[22:14] Jimmy: Um, which is kind of fair, yeah.

[22:16] Tommy: Um but you can't like you can see um you can see a lot of those ideas of just like because I remember when I first listened to company where I was obviously kind of too young to really listen to it.

[22:29] Jimmy: Sure, I thought there was a story I mean I thought there was a plot, and as I grew up and and watched it more, and I sort of like realized like actually wait, nothing has happening, like nothing's happening here.

[22:41] Tommy: Yeah, this is just a discussion on an idea, right?

[22:44] Jimmy: Um and I just got really hooked on that as a concept, yeah.

[22:50] Tommy: Um but it's interesting, like alongside company, um one of the experiences I've obviously had with this and the fact that the script hasn't been released yet is I've only seen half the story.

[23:03] Jimmy: Oh yeah, we're missing, I mean, we often go in we're it's the struggle we have of not being New York based musical theater critics.

[23:10] Tommy: Um musical theater I hate using that word, sorry.

[23:13] Jimmy: Yeah, no, we're not critics.

[23:14] Tommy: Musical theater twice. Musical theater analyzers, fans, podcasters, whatever the heck we are, um is you know, we kind of have to hobble together bits and pieces of our understanding of some shows.

[23:25] Jimmy: Um and we make a lot of effort to do so, you know.

[23:28] Tommy: I mean, we absolutely do. Um But a strange loop is is really challenging right now because you know it it kind of lost its life too soon, it's stuck in the quagmire of quarantine closings.

[23:40] Jimmy: Um absolutely, you know, I have no doubt the show would be on Broadway now in normal times or on its way.

[23:47] Tommy: Um or or headed to bigger release somehow.

[23:50] Jimmy: But because we're because the world is on pause, we all you're right, we only have half the story of this thing.

[23:50] Tommy: Half the story.

[23:58] Jimmy: And so I I find that really interesting because like so the actual runtime is uh an hour and 45 minutes.

[24:03] Tommy: Yeah, and the album is just underwater.

[24:06] Jimmy: Yeah.

[24:06] Tommy: So there's 45 minutes of juicy great content there that we're not getting.

[24:10] Jimmy: And I find like for a show like this, yeah, um, that's really interesting because obviously when you take in a pi a piece of musical theatre um you really want to get a sense of the full thing, and I think one of the things that's really unique about our art form is that we uh have a kind of way in of doing that without just picking up a play script and reading it.

[24:38] Tommy: Um there's a really easy digestible way.

[24:40] Jimmy: Right um and yeah, I I don't know, I would really have loved for there to be to for there to have been some of the dialogue in the cast album.

[24:52] Tommy: Yeah.

[24:52] Jimmy: Um just to give it more of that shape because again, on first listening, if you if you weren't aware of this concept of looping and always returns back to this intermission theme, like that that that is something that runs all the way through it.

[25:07] Tommy: You have no concept of that, and actually almost would just feel like a linear like plot narrative story, yeah.

[25:15] Jimmy: Um and I think that's really interesting.

[25:17] Tommy: So I I do really wonder that um if it does get a bigger shot on Broadway and hopefully we can talk about that later as well.

[25:26] Jimmy: Um if they redo the cast album and kind of frame it in that way just because it I think like that is a probably be a better presentation of this story.

[25:38] Tommy: Yeah.

[25:39] Jimmy: Um in the same sort of way that like uh with company a lot of those scenes are still.

[25:48] Tommy: It certainly wasn't on the original, but in the where the spars are recording, they had more of this.

[25:55] Jimmy: They start including more of the scenes and the monologue stuff, yeah.

[25:59] Tommy: And you get that actually this is a a broader discussion.

[26:03] Jimmy: Yeah.

[26:04] Tommy: I do think though, even I'm having this realization now, like even with the original company cast recording, I feel like, and I'm you know, informing my past self, so it's hard to know exactly, but I feel like that still gives a more comprehensive sense of what company is that like I miss the book of a strange loop more than I think I miss the book of any other musical I've listened to.

[26:29] Jimmy: Yeah.

[26:30] Tommy: And uh now the thing about that though, I wonder if that's just because it's so well written you want to hear more.

[26:35] Jimmy: Sure, sure, that's fair.

[26:36] Tommy: Do you know I mean because I actually don't think I'm I'm missing out.

[26:39] Jimmy: Like, I'm not like I don't get that.

[26:41] Tommy: Like I'm not yeah, yeah.

[26:42] Jimmy: I don't feel like I'm not getting the story.

[26:43] Tommy: I actually do get and for something as complex as this, right?

[26:46] Jimmy: That's an impressive feat.

[26:48] Tommy: But the kind of dialogue that I've had in my head is I want to hear what he can write because he's a he's a playwright, like that's what he trained doing.

[26:56] Jimmy: Yeah.

[26:56] Tommy: Um so it's gonna be good.

[26:59] Jimmy: Yeah, and like some of the clips and things you see in the trailers are really funny.

[27:03] Tommy: Yeah.

[27:04] Jimmy: Um so yeah, I don't I don't know whether that's that's it more of just like you just want more.

[27:04] Tommy: You just want more because it's you want I mean it's the same logging we feel all the time.

[27:14] Jimmy: I want to have seen this show.

[27:16] Tommy: Absolutely, absolutely.

[27:18] Jimmy: Um yeah, and uh maybe this is the place to talk about it.

[27:24] Tommy: Like, I I'll be I'm intrigued to see what will happen with it.

[27:31] Jimmy: Yes.

[27:31] Tommy: Um at the moment there's no plans for it to go anywhere.

[27:35] Jimmy: Yeah.

[27:35] Tommy: Um I think it's got getting another showing in Washington.

[27:38] Jimmy: Okay.

[27:39] Tommy: Maybe next year.

[27:40] Jimmy: Yeah, and who knows these days.

[27:43] Tommy: Uh so that's its only kind of plan.

[27:46] Jimmy: Yeah.

[27:47] Tommy: Um, and this is this is probably far too big a question.

[27:53] Jimmy: Yeah.

[27:54] Tommy: How does this work on Broadway?

[27:56] Jimmy: It's a good question.

[27:57] Tommy: Well, and I do think, you know, there's I have a lot of questions about all of this. There there is this thought of like, what does Broadway look like when we open?

[28:06] Tommy: You know, exactly. Fascinatingly and intriguingly, like, not that the struggle of black folk in America hasn't been a problem for centuries. Um this show became popular and hit the popular consciousness before George Floyd, before all of the current unrest and the kind of like you know, great awakening of uh a lot of Americans right now. And so re-contextualizing it after that uh is is an interesting uh uh mental exercise, um, along with you know the combination of the George Floyd protests and the the awakening of uh Broadway to its uh uh ingrained racism um and kind of like the outward commitment that a bunch of places are making towards producing more work by black folk and people of color, you know. Here's one. Um but also part of that feels tokenizing, not that we shouldn't do it, like exactly. It's it's fair, it is all very challenging.

[29:25] Jimmy: Right. You know, I mean, and not being ignored because they're challenging.

[29:29] Tommy: Yeah, yeah. Well, and it is the question of the the marketability of Broadway. You know, can a strange loop open next door to uh the music that's a music man, right? And who's who's gonna make enough money to be profitable? And and that, you know, there's terrible connotations associated with all of that, with the implicit biases of Broadway audiences and how white Broadway audiences are, like, there's big problems in there that that shows. But I do wonder, I do wonder that will there be an appetite, like a new, fresh appetite for obviously the predominantly white audiences to want to consume black stories.

[30:09] Jimmy: Right.

[30:10] Tommy: Like, will there be an appetite for that?

[30:13] Jimmy: Yeah.

[30:14] Tommy: And it is I hope so. This is a good way in because it also discusses that the intersection of like, you know, how blackness lives in a in a in a white world. Um especially on Broadway, and like this one, you know, names it in some very real ways. Um so it's a good one for that.

[30:34] Jimmy: But I know that the question for all these things, and it's always the awful question, but like if it's not selling tickets, then it can't exist.

[30:41] Tommy: Exactly. And obviously, Broadway's a a big old beast to do that.

[30:45] Jimmy: And we've seen some very good stuff fall on it, that sword.

[30:49] Tommy: Right. Do you know what I mean? So yeah.

[30:53] Jimmy: It's a good tricky, interesting challenge.

[30:56] Tommy: It's a huge quest huge question. And I will also acknowledge, you know, we talked about it, we've talked about it over and over again even a minute ago, but like we live in such a fucked up world that being on Broadway is considered the pinnacle of American theater, right? And that's bullshit, even though it's true, um, and creates a huge slew of problems.

[31:17] Jimmy: Yeah.

[31:18] Tommy: And that but that's the thing, is like actually, I don't know, would I want to see this on Broadway or would I want to see it in the Playwrights Horizon?

[31:25] Jimmy: Right, exactly.

[31:26] Tommy: Like, I think I would want to see it in Playwrights Horizon, but I want it to be on Broadway for a variety of other reasons.

[31:33] Jimmy: Yeah, exactly. You want it to have the scale and success and the longevity that comes with a broad being a Broadway show. Frankly, in the same way that I felt uh about Tylo Show's journey, that it was absolutely I'm sure it was better in a smaller house, and I'm so pleased that it got its time.

[31:48] Tommy: Yeah.

[31:49] Jimmy: Um but you know, maybe that maybe I'm part of the problem in that thought process. You know what I mean?

[31:53] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[31:55] Jimmy: Yeah. Who knows?

[31:57] Tommy: Yeah. It's a it's interesting to grapple with that.

[32:02] Jimmy: Exactly. I have a feeling we've got a lot more grappling to do in this episode.

[32:07] Tommy: Um wait, shall we grapple some more?

[32:10] Jimmy: Let's go.

[32:11] Tommy: Let's grapple.

[32:18] Tommy: It was to show that I was tough enough, big enough and strong enough to slow down a speeding train.

[32:25] Tommy: I'll run the bulls in Spain.

[32:27] Tommy: I'll swerve down San Marine.

[32:30] Tommy: My brakes wear down, and now I'm broken.

[32:33] Tommy: Still I beat myself up, still I knock myself down, and still I flip myself off in the mirror.

[32:41] Tommy: Which makes me feel really bad, which makes me feel really good, which makes me feel like the stew biddest asshole.

[32:50] Tommy: Robert wants to hit the open road, but I keep dwelling on the past.

[32:55] Tommy: I pray that someday I will change.

[32:57] Tommy: Stranger things have happened.

[32:59] Tommy: Each time I try to chart my course, wild horses throw me off my fourth.

[32:41] Jimmy: So, Tommy, Broadway's racist.

[33:08] Tommy: It is, yes. Um, and it it it like a lot of things in America, it's ingrained in a lot of institutionalized racism. Um, and it's also like a sick joke. Um because so much of this like vaudevillean musical theater style, as a lot of musical styles in America, their you know, its origin is in black history, and you know, whether it's like you know, whether it's jazz and ragtime or you know, the what whatever it is we're imitating with minstrel shows, like it's all that history is all there, and so it is such a uh a sick joke that there is this whiteness to Broadway.

[33:49] Jimmy: Um and it is really interesting, and like it's interesting reading reviews of this show, especially from like stalwart white reviewers who are part of the institutionalized problem.

[34:01] Tommy: Um it's you know, in the start of the show, um Usher says something along the lines of like uh critics are gonna uh accuse you of navel gazing.

[34:13] Jimmy: Um, and Ben Brantley's review starts navel gazing becomes a highly invasive procedure.

[34:18] Tommy: Like, you know, read read the fucking room, Ben Brantley.

[34:22] Jimmy: Um but then it's a it's interesting, like that instantly is interesting because you hit that crossroads of if if if Ben Brantley really firmly believes that this is navel gazing, right?

[34:36] Tommy: Does it, you know, impinge on his own critical integrity or whatever?

[34:41] Jimmy: Exactly. You know what I mean?

[34:43] Tommy: Like by not mentioning it, or just by you know, being like, this is the best show ever.

[34:47] Jimmy: Right.

[34:48] Tommy: Without looking at it, without acknowledging it that way, like reading their spot in the thing is a fascinating question.

[34:55] Jimmy: And there is so what is interesting is to all these critics kind of talk around how like Brantley says something like, um, let me see if I can find the quote.

[35:06] Tommy: Um, and it's all set to a bouncy Broadway beat with an assortment of the kind of infectious, richly harmonic melodies that would have your grandparents leaving the theater humming.

[35:17] Jimmy: That is, if they hadn't walked out before.

[35:19] Tommy: And he's right, but what he's talking about is, and it this is what uh the Great White Wade talks a lot about, is this thing that has become categorized as like the white sound of musical theater.

[35:32] Jimmy: Yeah, exactly.

[35:33] Tommy: And this is the sick joke about it is the white sound of musical theater is so much informed by work of black artists that goes underrepresented and blah, blah, blah, blah, blah.

[35:41] Jimmy: Um because that's what Ben Brantley's saying there.

[35:43] Tommy: He's he's he's not saying it's the bouncy side of Broadway, he's saying it's the bouncy side of white.

[35:47] Jimmy: Of white Broadway.

[35:49] Tommy: And this is, you know, the I I have been coming back to because Hamilton discourse is back in the Twitterverse nowadays, and like people talking about La Memo Miranda, um, and that like, you know, uh I'm so pleased that Lumel Miranda now has this opportunity to write things like Moana Um and like stuff outside of quote unquote what he's expected to do, right?

[36:14] Jimmy: In the heights has an urban feel, and Hamilton has rap in it, and that's what we allow, you know, non-white people to bring to Broadway, that kind of exotic sound, right?

[36:26] Tommy: I say this with huge sarcasm quotes around it.

[36:29] Jimmy: And one of the wonderful divisive things about The Strange Loop is it absolutely capitalizes on that, you know, big bouncy Broadway sound, and is and makes you question what happens when a black man does it, right?

[36:44] Tommy: And do you feel weird about that? Watching that happen on stage, is that, you know, tugging on your implicit biases in a way that makes you uncomfortable or that you have to sit with, you know, and uh Usher calls it out of himself, embracing his inner white girl and you know, all of these things throughout the whole show.

[37:05] Jimmy: And so, like, that is one of the powers of this thing, is if you just like if you pulled the words out and just played the instrumentals and like asked someone who didn't know any better who wrote this, they'd probably name or compare it to a slew of white musical theater authors.

[37:25] Tommy: Um, and so, and like that is a lot what Usher is, you know, contemplating in this world is like there Broadway is a world of whiteness, unfortunately, or has been, and I'd like to think we're trying to change that, but it certainly hasn't changed in monumental ways.

[37:44] Jimmy: Yeah, yeah, for sure.

[37:45] Tommy: It's quite interesting. So there's a really good interview um with Michael R. Jackson where he he kind of talks about his beginnings and um his origins and in musical theater writing.

[37:56] Jimmy: So he um he started off he was a big p piano player when he was younger, um, and then he went to uh I think it was NYU um to study playwriting, even though he'd never written a play before.

[38:14] Tommy: Um got through that and then after that uh did his MFA in musical theater writing um and composing.

[38:27] Jimmy: Uh but it was quite interesting because he said that he had a really um like uh quite uh a good uh Broadway influence or a good musical theatre influence.

[38:42] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[38:43] Jimmy: Um so like the first show that he saw um was Showboat that you saw with his mum.

[38:50] Tommy: Yeah.

[38:50] Jimmy: Um was really what a first show to see.

[38:55] Tommy: Right, exactly, exactly.

[38:56] Jimmy: Um but it was he was really taken uh with obviously this kind of really interesting portrayal of racism, this really sweeping score, um, and you know, did the classic thing of your first musical burnt the castle up about like of course, yeah.

[39:12] Tommy: Um then he saw Raisin, okay, um, which is obviously the the musical adaptation of Raising the Sun.

[39:19] Jimmy: Yep.

[39:19] Tommy: Um then he saw West Side's story.

[39:23] Jimmy: Okay.

[39:23] Tommy: Um so like his really good themes of uh then he said the one that kind of changed it for him and that he became obsessed with was um was with uh William Finn in the 70s.

[39:40] Jimmy: Um and he says like in trousers, in his opinion, is one of the best things that's ever been written.

[39:45] Tommy: Uh despite the fact that Bill Finn hates it.

[39:48] Jimmy: Sure.

[39:48] Tommy: Uh but he just think just in terms of its like musical complexity, how challenging it is in terms of its themes.

[39:55] Jimmy: Yeah.

[39:56] Tommy: Um he's he is completely right.

[39:59] Jimmy: Um and then he also cites a chorus line.

[40:01] Tommy: So like as a as a a musical theatre.

[40:04] Jimmy: Yeah, that's a good thing.

[40:05] Tommy: Like that's as good a package as you could get.

[40:07] Jimmy: Yeah, that's awesome. I mean, that's that's the sort of like where should I start in musical theatre listical I wish I could write, you know.

[40:15] Tommy: Right, exactly. And I think I think like that is actually quite apparent.

[40:19] Jimmy: Yes.

[40:20] Tommy: In that you can see that in a strange look, not in terms of like, oh, you can hear William Finn or you can hear Gersh Gershwin.

[40:27] Jimmy: Right.

[40:28] Tommy: Yeah, but I hadn't even thought about kind of the, you know, in Trousers Falsetto Land kind of like issue musical.

[40:35] Jimmy: Right, exactly.

[40:36] Tommy: Like really challenging and very honest, frank stuff.

[40:39] Jimmy: Like in Trousers in the whole of the Falseto trilogy, like it it's very no holds bars in terms of what it was talking about, especially at that time.

[40:50] Tommy: Um yeah, I think it just taught him to live dangerously when it came to writing that it wasn't like you need to write XYZ.

[40:59] Jimmy: Yeah.

[40:59] Tommy: It was you can write your truth.

[41:02] Jimmy: Yeah.

[41:02] Tommy: Um and he had lots of really good mentors um as he as he sort of went through.

[41:09] Jimmy: Um and also he speaks quite a lot about how inspired he was by uh like female pop rock artists.

[41:18] Tommy: Um so Tori Amos he cites is uh is a really really big one.

[41:23] Jimmy: And yeah, an artist called Liz Fair, who he seems to be very obsessed with.

[41:28] Tommy: Uh and actually like in the original framing of the show, uh he wanted to write because she so this is spiraling as a a topic um he she has a song called Strange Loop.

[41:40] Jimmy: Oh, okay, which is based on Douglas Hofflader's term of a strange loop.

[41:44] Tommy: Right.

[41:44] Jimmy: Um he wanted hi his character to be writing a musical uh like based on that her.

[41:53] Tommy: Yeah, okay.

[41:54] Jimmy: And that um and that's why it was called a strange loop.

[41:56] Tommy: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

[41:57] Jimmy: Um but then couldn't get the rights to her music um and was told that he should just write his own thing.

[42:04] Tommy: Yeah.

[42:04] Jimmy: Uh and then that in turn led it to become this like self-referential thing.

[42:09] Tommy: Right. Um, of a strange loop, you know what I mean, which is again a strange loop in its own right.

[42:13] Jimi: Yeah.

[42:14] Tommy: Very interesting.

[42:14] Jimi: Yeah, uh but yeah just like again though these ideas of like because obviously Tori Amos is very again has a lot of candor in her writing like she's quite no holds part and I think if you're a young gay guy I think a lot of young gay guys really empathize with Tori Amos's music yeah um especially at that kind of uh formative years you know I mean so I think just all of these really incredible influences yeah have taught him to be fearless yeah um and that's really good.

[42:49] Tommy: Yeah it is really good rather than rather than to go that path of like yeah how can you be successful and make a mint right he's looked into okay how can I create something that is honest and important significant.

[43:05] Jimi: It is such an interesting I I I agree with you that he is fearless but I think it is a different it's like a fearlessness through vulnerability. Because like I would say you know Lin-Manuel Miranda casting you know a bunch of people as color uh people of color as the founding fathers that's fearless you know it is yeah and whereas a strange loop is fearless but also has this you know it the whole thing starts with like can I really write this and there is still a a a contemplation of appropriateness is the wrong word um it like it's honest it's just pure out and out honesty yeah um and like and I think I think that the honesty and the vulnerability yeah is what stops it from being wanky.

[43:50] Tommy: Yes.

[43:51] Jimi: Yeah.

[43:52] Tommy: It's what stops it from being the way Ben Brantley means navel gazing.

[43:58] Jimi: Yeah.

[43:58] Tommy: Absolutely because at no point did I think it was.

[44:01] Jimi: Right.

[44:01] Tommy: Do you know I mean in no point did I think it w like it felt like that.

[44:05] Jimi: Yeah.

[44:05] Tommy: In a way that it's like, okay, have a great time, Michael Jack. And like a lot of in a way. A lot of reviews kind of talk around that. And I I I find it very frustrating. Um you know, and everyone's entitled to their opinion, but I think the the prevalence of white critics is part of the problem.

[44:22] Jimi: Um Yeah, exactly. I mean, like I absolutely it's semi-autobiographical.

[44:27] Tommy: Right.

[44:28] Jimi: But not to me, not in a way that feels like I'm, you know, sitting in someone's living room.

[44:35] Tommy: Right.

[44:36] Jimi: Looking at my watch, wondering when I can go.

[44:38] Tommy: Right.

[44:38] Jimi: When like are you done yet? No, it's it's interesting, it's fascinating.

[44:41] Tommy: And is more, you know, title of show is navel gazing.

[44:45] Jimi: And I I dare anyone to show me a dis uh uh a review that uses that word.

[44:50] Tommy: Right, yeah, you know, like there's and whether they mean to or not, there's the difference here.

[44:56] Jimi: Yeah, exactly. Exactly.

[44:59] Tommy: Um so yeah, I th I that's uh I think one of the again, one of the things that makes me really appreciate it is that like stark honesty, yeah, um with how he handles the various themes that he talks about.

[45:15] Jimi: When I I love and perhaps they acknowledge it in the forty minutes we don't have in the book, but like he's an usher during intermission at Lion King, and that's all we say, but Lion King is such a fantastic exploration of blackness in the a musical theater space from a different era.

[45:37] Tommy: Absolutely.

[45:37] Jimi: You know, and representation with a question mark, um, and like, you know, a lot of white people for a predominantly white company getting together to create a piece inspired by an animated cartoon with animals.

[45:54] Tommy: And then like giving it a distinctly an important African flavor with certainly some appropriate African influence.

[46:03] Jimi: But like, you know, I've watched plenty of interviews with Julie Taymor and she does have a a bizarre exoticism around African theater and Asian theater.

[46:14] Tommy: That is, you know, somewhere between like are we letting a white person into this space or is this appropriation?

[46:21] Jimi: Um and Lion King absolutely treads that line. Plus then add on the commercialization of Disney.

[46:27] Tommy: Um and we'd start to enter problematic territory pretty quickly.

[46:31] Jimi: Um but also really important, you know, a a show cast with a ton of black actors on Broadway in 1997.

[46:40] Tommy: Seven, yeah.

[46:40] Jimi: That's important.

[46:42] Tommy: Um and like all he says is it's intermission for the Lion King.

[46:47] Jimi: Like that's the great stuff about this show.

[46:49] Tommy: And I'm sure like I am not culturally worldwide worldwise to uh understand and fully comprehend a ton of stuff in the show.

[46:58] Jimi: And I know it. And like what I love about it then is I can still see the points where like I have stuff to learn.

[47:09] Tommy: Um you know and the points where like oh I get it now.

[47:12] Jimi: Um that's a it's a I that's I think that's what I mean when I say challenging. Is it's you know, I know there's a lot I get, and I know there's a lot that is not registering with me.

[47:22] Tommy: Uh huh.

[47:22] Jimi: Or flying over my head. But I think like do don't you think it it makes you want to get more information?

[47:32] Tommy: It's not to the point where you're like, I don't get it.

[47:34] Jimi: Right.

[47:34] Tommy: And it's and it's not where a world it's not also where I want like musical explain it to me, you know.

[47:40] Jimi: I'm not like you know not at all. Like I don't think there is an I don't think there is an explanation at the end of it, like I don't think that exists within it.

[47:48] Tommy: Um but there's you're right, there's so much room to be explored.

[47:53] Jimi: Yeah.

[47:54] Tommy: And it's it's cool.

[47:57] Jimi: I hate when I end up on the box.

[48:04] Tommy: Michael R. Jackson is like, yeah, this has totally changed his whole thing.

[48:08] Jimi: Like Pulitzer, sure.

[48:11] Tommy: Yeah, it's important.

[48:12] Jimi: It's it's it's I'm so glad this is a part of the uh uh uh the canon, the paradigm, the the corpus.

[48:22] Tommy: Exactly.

[48:23] Jimi: Um, you know, it is a voice certainly that has been lacking in popular musical theater.

[48:29] Tommy: Um it's a shame that you know it has to come out so unabashedly this way.

[48:35] Jimi: Um, you know, it is it's also a thought I've had about some of the racism of of Broadway.

[48:40] Tommy: Um and what I mean when I say it's so great that Lin-Manuel Miranda can write songs for Moana is like we don't we still kind of expect you know non-white authors to write non-white stories.

[48:56] Jimi: Like there isn't you know there isn't a uh uh an analogy to the music man coming to Broadway by black authors, you know something that's just a a musical theater story, right?

[49:13] Tommy: There is this expectation that like if you are out of the in group coming to Broadway, you have to write about your experience um in order for it to be important.

[49:23] Jimi: Um, you know, it's it's a it's a grand shame that like there aren't more black authors on Broadway and people, you know, person of color authors on Broadway.

[49:34] Tommy: Yeah.

[49:35] Jimi: Well, you're approaching one of the big themes of the show there.

[49:39] Tommy: So I think now is a great time to pause and talk about themes.

[49:44] Jimi: Let's go there.

[49:45] Jimi: I am lying on the couch, I came out and flying, flapping both my wings so hard to keep me from dying with the crown of God forsaken thorns on my head.

[49:57] Tommy: Like all those black gay boys I knew will chose to go on back to the law.

[50:12] Jimi: All those black gay boys I knew will shows are going back to the law.

[50:12] Tommy: All those black gay boys I know who chose to go on back to the law.

[50:19] Jimi: And one more black gay boy I know to turn his back on the show.

[50:53] Tommy: Yeah, so like on on that point there, like I think that is really interesting because that's one of the biggest things that um Usher struggles with throughout the whole thing is like what kind of story do I want to write?

[51:09] Jimi: And then layered beneath that is well, what kind of black story do I want to write?

[51:13] Tommy: Yep.

[51:14] Jimi: Um and this is where the the kind of Tyler Perry world and combat comes comes in.

[51:21] Tommy: Yep.

[51:21] Jimi: That uh the the show that he he would thinks that his parents would want um is this kind of Tyler Perry style uh very broad and uh stereotypical, yeah.

[51:40] Tommy: Um but comes from a place of like honestly, I mean there is a an honesty and a reality to it in its own right, yeah.

[51:49] Jimi: Um but that isn't necessarily his reality, and that's not necessarily what he like wants to put on stage.

[51:58] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.

[51:59] Jimi: Yeah.

[51:59] Tommy: Um then kind of what I love is just what explodes out of that.

[52:03] Jimi: Oh yeah.

[52:04] Tommy: That I mean is a bunch of questions like well, and also like the whole um what what's the song?

[52:11] Jimi: Is it Tyler Perry writes real life where I'm Harry motherfucking Tubman and I've got a problem with you?

[52:17] Tommy: Exactly.

[52:18] Jimi: Oh man, what a great line, and like all that follows.

[52:21] Tommy: Um and then 12 years a slave here, which is not a person, like it's all it's so well the fact that Whitney Houston would have a problem with him, you know, I mean writing it's so a show, like it's so wild.

[52:33] Jimi: Um but like the I I can comprehend that, you know.

[52:39] Tommy: Like I see that.

[52:40] Jimi: Have you ever seen a Tyler Perry movie?

[52:43] Tommy: No, I don't think I have.

[52:45] Jimi: I had a look through um but no, I didn't I didn't actually even really recognize any titles, so I don't know if it's something that's necessarily made its way.

[52:54] Tommy: I I wouldn't be surprised if it's not terribly UK centric for a ton of reasons.

[52:59] Jimi: Um the I had a uh uh uh boyfriend in college who loved them.

[53:05] Tommy: I feel the need to specify this, but I don't know why.

[53:07] Jimi: A white boyfriend.

[53:08] Tommy: Um the and I don't know, you know, maybe I'm exploring something there that's weird and I need to specify.

[53:14] Jimi: And he really liked Tyler Perry movies unabashedly, you know, just because he found them entertaining for no particular reason.

[53:20] Tommy: So we went and saw a couple.

[53:21] Jimi: Um, and certainly much more popular with a black audience, and there's a lot of discourse around this that I am I am, you know, only able to scratch the surface about both the the the problems and the goodness of Tyler Perry.

[53:38] Tommy: Um you know, which I do think there is, if I can put my own analogy on it, that there is this sense of people in an out group becoming famous and then running into problems that way, you know.

[53:53] Jimi: I see that a lot nowadays with Howard cancelling Ellen DeGeneres.

[53:57] Tommy: Um certainly a pioneer in gay rights and gay representation in media, but now kind of really out of touch with a lot of stuff.

[54:05] Jimi: Um I I would imagine there's a uh that's an analogy for uh, you know, some Tyler Perry sort of stuff.

[54:15] Tommy: Yeah, I I I again it's because it's it's not a story that I have any, you know, because it's not anything I've grown up with at all, so I d I I don't really know.

[54:28] Jimi: It's it's is the answer I don't really know the the uh what's that word the conflict.

[54:37] Tommy: Sure, yeah.

[54:38] Jimi: I g I can't I can't get a handle on it.

[54:41] Tommy: Um there's nothing that I I feel like I could directly compare it to, like thinking like what would be the show that my mum would want me to write compared to what I would want to write.

[54:52] Jimi: I can't see a huge yeah yeah just see you know discrepancy there.

[54:56] Tommy: And I and I think that's the sort of thing why I'm even really reticent to make the Ellen comparison because that's not it's it's its own, yeah.

[55:03] Jimi: It's its own thing, and the show is trying of all the places, you know, where I say like it is breezing past some references, it makes you understand Usher's distaste for Tyler Perry, what a Tyler Perry show is, a flavor of why it's problematic, absolutely and why he's struggling with it.

[55:21] Tommy: It's definitely something you could recognise as well.

[55:23] Jimi: Like I remember um I had a conversation with a few of my friends recently about it weirdly in the context of drag race.

[55:30] Tommy: Fascinating.

[55:31] Jimi: Um like how drag race is contributing to this conversation.

[55:39] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?

[55:40] Jimi: About contemporary black culture, um and actually well what like obviously drag race does have quite a strong uh black representation on its show, but what facet of black culture is it representing and is it giving you a good broad spectrum or is it giving you quite a narrow like a some kind of stereotypical or problematic?

[56:03] Tommy: Right, exactly.

[56:04] Jimi: Yeah.

[56:05] Tommy: Exactly.

[56:06] Jimi: Um but it's that thing of like is it better than nothing?

[56:11] Jimi: Yeah, you know, if the it's still like I say it still comes from a place of honesty, it still comes from RuPaul's childhood.

[56:19] Tommy: Right.

[56:19] Jimi: Do you know what I mean?

[56:20] Tommy: Yeah.

[56:20] Jimi: Um and therefore it's still authentic.

[56:25] Tommy: Right.

[56:25] Jimi: But there is this like fetishization of authenticity that becomes problematic.

[56:33] Tommy: Right.

[56:33] Jimi: Um it it's it's just a I think it's just a really interesting discussion to have.

[56:40] Tommy: Because now as we are as as more black stories are being told, it is that idea of like what is kind of what is the story of of now, like what is what's happening now.

[56:54] Jimi: Yeah.

[56:54] Tommy: Well um and there is, you know, I think this happens in any kind of group, but there's also a ton of infighting about what that story should be.

[57:04] Jimi: Um, you know, there was a uh I will remember this wrong, but there there's lots of uh when Obama was president, there was plenty of discussion about like what a a fine upstanding black man is and what a fine upstanding black man isn't, and what the differences between those things are and how those are connotated in, you know, poverty and uh you know urban upbringing and some of this stuff.

[57:29] Tommy: Um and you know, the the ever present uh uh uh uh cloud of uh civil rights problem and slavery in the United States and how that problematizes a ton of this conversation and like saying, you know, and I'd I think they mention it somewhere, or maybe I read it in as a line in a review, but like how Usher's mom talk mentions Obama, like name drops Obama at some point.

[57:55] Jimi: Like that's who you should be like.

[57:57] Tommy: Um and that becomes, you know, a problem when you're trying to tell the story of a people, there is a responsibility there.

[58:06] Jimi: It's all it's it's multifaceted.

[58:09] Tommy: I think it'll be an eternal struggle forever.

[58:11] Jimi: And you know, to to be a conscientious media absorber as we all should be, like it it will always be the the viewers' responsibility to try and be aware of how they're being pulled in their perception of these things.

[58:26] Tommy: Exactly, exactly.

[58:28] Jimi: Well, it's that is the um it comes into that double consciousness idea that again I've only come across as a term for listening to and really researching the show.

[58:37] Tommy: Um but yeah, that that idea as a concept that as a as a black person, particularly in America, um you you have these two different perceptions of yourself.

[58:49] Jimi: You've got yourself as you, yeah, and then yourself as viewed by this white lens um and how you position yourself.

[58:58] Tommy: Right, and how you navigate that and between both of those, exactly.

[59:02] Jimi: Yeah.

[59:02] Tommy: It's fascinating.

[59:04] Jimi: It is fascinating.

[59:04] Tommy: And it's really fascinating.

[59:06] Jimi: And it is like I think that is part of the appeal of this show is and and I say this gingerly, is there's something that'll that is easy to identify with that challenge because it is so plainly represented in the plight of a black person, we do have these moments of self-definition versus group expectation, right?

[59:30] Tommy: That is, you know, like that those are the parts that get to me.

[59:35] Jimi: And it it, you know, you see Usher also struggle with it with his queerness, which is perhaps where I'm more acutely sympathize with it.

[59:41] Tommy: Right.

[59:42] Jimi: Um, but there is, you know, it's terrible that blackness is kind of a vehicle for this discussion, and I don't want to minimize it by saying like I feel that too, but I feel that too.

[59:42] Tommy: You know?

[59:54] Jimi: Like that, and that's what I mean by presenting it gingerly is I have no idea what it's like to be a black person in America.

[1:00:01] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:00:02] Jimi: I do sometimes feel like the out group in an in-group and trying to navigate straight spaces or spaces with older people, or you know, all gay spaces.

[1:00:14] Tommy: Or gay spaces, yeah, for sure.

[1:00:16] Jimi: Um and that I think that that's the thing is uh that that going back to that quote earlier um about it, you know, the musical isn't trying to bring this sense of oneness, and you're not it's not like try and find yourself in this show.

[1:00:31] Tommy: Exactly.

[1:00:32] Jimi: It's portraying the thing.

[1:00:33] Tommy: But I did, I must say, like, I really appreciated all of the songs discussing what it's like to be a gay male, yes, a gay black male, but also the step up from that of being just a flat out gay male that doesn't fit the mold.

[1:00:54] Jimi: Yep.

[1:00:55] Tommy: Um and obviously it goes into a whole other realm when you're a black gay male.

[1:01:01] Jimi: Oh yes.

[1:01:02] Tommy: And you don't even fit you know, the white mold.

[1:01:05] Jimi: Right.

[1:01:06] Tommy: Um as well.

[1:01:07] Jimi: So it yeah, I it's I deeply appreciated those songs.

[1:01:12] Tommy: I really, really appreciated them.

[1:01:14] Jimi: My my first listen through Exile in Gayville was was the turn for me.

[1:01:20] Tommy: Was was the point where my brain was like, Oh, this is okay, okay.

[1:01:25] Jimi: Okay.

[1:01:26] Tommy: Um we're gonna talk about a lot of stuff here, aren't we?

[1:01:29] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:01:30] Tommy: You know, and it and unabashedly so.

[1:01:33] Jimi: Absolutely.

[1:01:34] Tommy: But I'm so grateful.

[1:01:36] Jimi: Oh yeah.

[1:01:37] Tommy: I'm so so grateful.

[1:01:40] Jimi: It's just it it doesn't get talked about.

[1:01:43] Tommy: No.

[1:01:43] Jimi: Enough.

[1:01:44] Tommy: Like I don't I don't think like that.

[1:01:46] Jimi: I still think even now that there's such a an idea that because as gay people we're a minority, therefore think within our world.

[1:02:00] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:02:01] Jimi: The there's like an inner minority there.

[1:02:03] Tommy: There's a great it came up uh during this year's cancelled pride month because it was RAMP Month.

[1:02:08] Jimi: Um, but there was a great uh like one one panel comic of a bunch of you know shirtless, twinky, attractive, speedo wearing white men standing on top of an iceberg, and then every other subcategory of queer like crawling underwater trying to get up out to like reach the top of this iceberg.

[1:02:31] Tommy: Um it was a very visceral, you know, the uh uh illustration of this problem, right?

[1:02:37] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:02:37] Tommy: That there is this, you know, uh uh cis white, you know, gay male homogeny that is assumed of uh queerness in America, in the world, who knows?

[1:02:54] Jimi: Um that becomes a big problem if you don't fit that mold.

[1:02:58] Tommy: Because it's still a you know, a fighting minority, like certainly the certainly white gay men are oppressed, and certainly much less more than tons of other letters in the alphabet, right?

[1:03:12] Jimi: And subsets of queer existence.

[1:03:15] Tommy: Exactly.

[1:03:17] Jimi: Um so yeah, I was just I was just very like say grateful that it it was there as a conversation because like at the moment, certainly in London, um there's a lot of white writers, white gay writers writing their story, yeah, and whether it's grind the musical or whether it's the the fifth chemsex play in three months, yeah.

[1:03:42] Tommy: That's all about extremely attractive men having sex with each other, and it's you know, they're trying to warn you against chemsex, like no, it's just you're just this is just porn, yeah.

[1:03:52] Jimi: Um nothing against porn.

[1:03:55] Tommy: Love it dearly, but uh like it's not you're not telling the story you're trying to tell.

[1:04:01] Jimi: Um I find this so refreshing because I was like, this is the reality of grinder, yeah.

[1:04:07] Tommy: Like this, this is this is what grinders is.

[1:04:10] Jimi: This is what any of our hookup apps are.

[1:04:13] Tommy: Oh yeah.

[1:04:14] Jimi: No, and it's like I love how much uh uh Exile in Gayville like names names and calls it what it is, and like you know, it it doesn't paint it as this like utopic queer as folk style right, everything's gonna be difficult but okay.

[1:04:34] Tommy: That like no, there are also shitty gay people in the world.

[1:04:38] Jimi: Or that it's just like memeworthy, or just like camp like camp gay fun.

[1:04:43] Tommy: Like, I don't know, like I just thought it was really slick and again that raw honesty.

[1:04:50] Jimi: And so clever, and I didn't catch this um until like I was listening earlier today.

[1:04:56] Tommy: That the last stanza of that song, um, which is presented uh uh without accompaniment, like it sounds open and vulnerable.

[1:05:04] Jimi: My dick too small, my dick too small, too fat and black to live it all.

[1:05:08] Tommy: So why don't you just ravage me with your white gay Dan Savagery?

[1:05:13] Jimi: Yep.

[1:05:14] Tommy: And I had to hear damn.

[1:05:16] Jimi: I heard damn until I got there.

[1:05:18] Tommy: And like Dan and when I heard Dan Savagery, I was like, oh, exactly.

[1:05:23] Jimi: Oh man oh man.

[1:05:24] Tommy: And you know, to unpack one simple reference, but like the fact that like Dan Savage as you know, who started the It Gets Better project.

[1:05:33] Jimi: Absolutely.

[1:05:34] Tommy: Dan Savage's done a lot of wonderful things for a ton of wonderful stuff, but has also positioned himself as this kind of like it, you know, gay sex advice icon, but absolutely comes at it from a privileged white cis gay perspective that d doesn't take into account a ton of other stuff.

[1:05:55] Jimi: Right.

[1:05:56] Tommy: Uh uh including otherness.

[1:05:58] Jimi: Right, yeah, exactly.

[1:06:00] Tommy: A crucial part.

[1:06:01] Jimi: Um yeah, like I I just think uh I again it's it's not just what I love about it is it's not just there as like uh here's the grinder song, right?

[1:06:13] Tommy: Yeah, the fact that it comes back again in the number of daddy, oh boy, which uh potentially one of the most challenging musical theater songs ever written.

[1:06:24] Jimi: Oh yeah.

[1:06:24] Tommy: Um after that, boundaries, which is probably my favorite song in the show, um because like it i i if we're talking honesty and vulnerability, that number and everything it discusses is sensational.

[1:06:48] Jimi: That so basically the way again if you've not listened to it yet, um he has uh I mean he has this hookup uh with a sort of meth adult racist, basically, who's just shetogising him for his blackness, um and uh treats him so abhorrently, yeah, it's it's fail.

[1:07:13] Tommy: Um but I I don't doubt that it's a huge reality.

[1:07:18] Jimi: And he participates in it, which is a lot of what the discussion of boundaries is about.

[1:07:23] Tommy: Uh huh, and so that's it.

[1:07:25] Jimi: So boundaries is this kind of like morning after um sort of walk of inverticoma shame, um, where he's going over why did I let myself do that, what part of me allowed that to happen when I know fine well that's not something I want to do.

[1:07:42] Tommy: Yeah, but yeah, I hate myself so much that that's all I felt I could do, that that's all I felt I was worthy of.

[1:07:49] Jimi: Like I was just like that that is you know as a piece of theatre full stop, let alone musical theatre.

[1:07:57] Tommy: I just think that honesty and vulnerability is sensational, and I was really like really disarmed by that song.

[1:08:07] Jimi: Like I thought it was incredible.

[1:08:09] Tommy: Oh yeah, the whole the whole the whole run of the you know back half of this show is debilitating.

[1:08:16] Jimi: Yeah, exactly.

[1:08:17] Tommy: Because it is, it's like it's i i it goes back to the idea of like, does it have a full stop?

[1:08:22] Jimi: It doesn't, it's just like it's realisations, but not necessarily problem solving, yeah.

[1:08:28] Tommy: Yeah, I mean it's it's acknowledging.

[1:08:30] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:08:31] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:08:32] Jimi: And that's obviously so destroying because you're like.

[1:08:38] Tommy: Wow.

[1:08:39] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:08:40] Tommy: Wow, they're living with all of this all times.

[1:08:42] Jimi: And it's it's situated in a world, you know, where where Usher's talking about himself and you're not, you know, you're not supposed to read yourself in.

[1:08:51] Tommy: And you're also running through your head, like, yeah, you know, where are my boundaries?

[1:08:57] Jimi: And, you know, I do think there are a ton of, you know, gay man, gay sex is I think like a lot of perceptions of sex in general has a there's the reality and the the uh what people think the reality is, and there's a huge disconnect between those things, which causes people to have all sorts of inner turmoil about these things.

[1:09:19] Tommy: And 100%.

[1:09:21] Jimi: You're you know, you might not be reading yourself into the the character in that moment, but you are similarly having a self-reflective, you know, analysis of your own eye, of your own ego, and where it sits in relationship to some of these things.

[1:09:37] Tommy: Yeah, like I don't know, I just feel like I could I don't know where I would begin having a conversation with my straight cis friends about my difficulties with sex.

[1:09:50] Jimi: Oh I mean, and let alone it if I was a black man, having to also layer in how race factors into that and race fetishization, like Oh god.

[1:10:03] Tommy: It's wild.

[1:10:05] Jimi: It's wet and get he's done that.

[1:10:07] Tommy: Like I don't I just can't get over the first bit.

[1:10:10] Jimi: In a way that like and I meant it, like these are conversations, you know, that would be impossible to have with my mother.

[1:10:17] Jimi: But if I took her to this show, she'd get it, right?

[1:10:22] Tommy: When I think she well, I don't know if she'd come to as much of a lot of people.

[1:10:27] Jimi: Right.

[1:10:28] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:10:30] Jimi: But you know the other side of things.

[1:10:31] Tommy: But yeah, exactly.

[1:10:32] Jimi: Exactly.

[1:10:32] Tommy: Um so just uh yeah, I don't know, stand up and applaud. Like it's I'm just so it's so well, and even you know, like uh uh Precious Little Dream, Ages God God's Punishment.

[1:10:46] Jimi: Like well my first time through, I I had to like hit pause and take a breath. It I it took me a minute. It and and I don't know if a musical's ever made me do that. Maybe um uh bear. I had some moments where I just needed to like take a break from the art to process my own self.

[1:11:07] Tommy: Well that that was something I wanted to speak to you about was obviously it weird we spoke about this in the last episode.

[1:11:13] Jimi: Yeah, religion and yeah.

[1:11:14] Tommy: Obviously, we've got very different perspectives on this. I didn't I didn't grow up religious at all, so I don't have I mean I've still got the sense of Catholic guilt you get living in any sort of but not I imagine to any near the degree that you would, you know uh it's you know it is f like and this show talks a lot about you know gayness and relationship to religion.

[1:11:36] Jimi: Um Usher's mother is is poised both of them mom and dad, like they are unkind in how they talk about gay people.

[1:11:44] Tommy: Um but also the heartbreaking fact that they're also so in love with him. That they still love him, which is which like what a what a piece that is not explored in media, right?

[1:11:56] Jimi: Ever.

[1:11:57] Tommy: Like that like it's so they're not the tropes we paint.

[1:12:02] Jimi: Not so much.

[1:12:04] Tommy: Like you you end up with three, right? You either end up with, oh, you know, you're a fucking fag, I'm gonna kick you out of the house. Good luck with your life.

[1:12:13] Jimi: Or I'm gonna be a pi P flag mom. Of course we always knew you were gay. Ha ha ha ha ha, I'm gonna wear rainbow.

[1:12:19] Tommy: Or the like I've struggled with this and I've recovered and I've now learned to accept and change my ways.

[1:12:26] Jimi: You don't end up with the like talk about it.

[1:12:28] Tommy: Right.

[1:12:28] Jimi: You don't end up with like the we love you and we don't like that you do this, and you're gonna go to hell if you do. And we're gonna tell you that and remind you about it a lot.

[1:12:36] Tommy: Exactly.

[1:12:37] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:12:38] Tommy: Like and again, it's so freaking odd. Like it's so it's so raw.

[1:12:44] Jimi: It's so real.

[1:12:46] Tommy: Like I don't know.

[1:12:47] Jimi: Well, and even like I would say my I don't know if we've ever talked about this on on pod, and I'm gonna be a little vulnerable for a bit. But like I think like you know, I uh I knew I was gay in fifth or sixth grade.

[1:13:03] Tommy: Um and I have some of my earliest memories of coping with my own homosexuality in Catholic school.

[1:13:09] Jimi: Um in our uh big church, there was a like a lot of Catholic churches, a giant naked dead Jesus on the cross and like a loincloth.

[1:13:20] Tommy: Um and the white version of Jesus, so we had a six-pack and a chiseled jaw, and like I have hipster beard.

[1:13:28] Jimi: Yeah, exactly.

[1:13:29] Tommy: And I have distinct memories of being sixth grade me in the pew at church, thinking Jesus is sexy.

[1:13:37] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:13:38] Tommy: And you're doing it in church, the place where God can read your mind and like having the terrible thought about like it's really, you know, it's a terrible trap to put someone in.

[1:13:50] Jimi: Um absolutely affected, you know, why I am I'm sure as outspokenly anti religious nowadays, because what a terrible thing to do to, you know, a 12 year old.

[1:14:00] Tommy: Um but I think even beyond just some of the religious stuff, like I think our generation well, I don't know. I'm gonna make some assumptions here, but our generation in particular happening after the AIDS epidemic, um creates for an interesting entry into the the world of being gay.

[1:14:23] Jimi: Um like I remember when coming out to my parents, you know, they were accepting and great, and the one thing they said and they said it vaguely, but they was like, you know, they were like, We're protected, we don't want you to get sick.

[1:14:35] Tommy: Um, and like that was their big worry, right?

[1:14:39] Jimi: Yeah, uh by the way, snap.

[1:14:42] Tommy: But I think my my mom said specific I I don't want to call it my mom, but specifically AIDS is a is a big problem.

[1:14:50] Jimi: Yeah, I mean, like that was that was the the conversation that we had.

[1:14:54] Tommy: Yeah, and there I mean they were sex, right?

[1:14:57] Jimi: I know, right? Like that was the other like mom, you have a much greater opinion of plenty of time for that, don't you?

[1:15:03] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.

[1:15:03] Jimi: But like that was their understanding of what it meant to be gay, right?

[1:15:09] Tommy: Exactly.

[1:15:10] Jimi: That was the identity.

[1:15:11] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:15:12] Jimi: Um, and you know, it it is walking through that, living in that, navigating that, while in reality, like AIDS is God's punishment as this kind of opus that Usher is writing to fulfill his parents' wishes of writing a gospel play, informed by what their opinions of gayness is, compared to Exile in Gayville, probably a more accurate description of what gayness is right now, which would absolutely terrify Usher's parents, right?

[1:15:48] Tommy: Mine too, to know kind of how prom promiscuous a lot of gay world can be or is assumed to be or is expected to be, right?

[1:15:59] Jimi: It's just seeing those paired with each other, it's another little thought moment of like not my story, and it's stirring a lot inside of me.

[1:16:08] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:16:09] Jimi: I I think uh one of the things as well with um with AIDS is got punishment, Aids got punishment, AIDS is God's punishment, um is uh his like mum's relationship with that song and kind of how that fits into the structure of it being in his head, slash also you know, potentially a reality like this could have happened, this could happen, this could be happening.

[1:16:43] Tommy: Right, but obviously his mum, you know, towards the end of the song telling him to to stop and to stop saying it, and he ends it with you wanted a gospel play, this is the only way I know how to do it.

[1:16:55] Jimi: Um like I just think that uh again like a really interesting and quite a challenging thought of like yeah um this is this is what this is what I would present to you, this is what you've taught me, right?

[1:17:09] Tommy: Do you know what I mean?

[1:17:10] Jimi: Yeah, this is what you wanted.

[1:17:11] Tommy: I think like the right after that is one of the most moving parts I find is you know the Usher's mom is like why would you write this why do you you know tell people you hate us so much and Usher's like I don't hate you I you know I love you I write this because I love you and it is such a it's a challenging thought and you know just to to wrap your mind around like isn't this what you taught me mom and not not in a you know go suck it right not in a like you made me this way this look what you made me do to get right yeah but in a like this is what isn't this what you think it's it's hard it's hard to listen to it's hard to talk about yeah and that's good yeah it's what makes it a great show I love and then man the the last bit of this show then to like ease us into memory song which is you know starts about like the struggle of being a a young gay kid in a locker room and like man yep feel that one also that's the first song he ever wrote really yeah uh of course not crazy and not just like the first song of the musical that's the first song he ever wrote oh my gosh that crazy time yeah it it's it's very good it's very good it is I mean I think it's one of the most vulnerable songs in the show right for sure.

[1:18:46] Tommy: You know, I I you you see Michael R. Jackson singing it, like it's yeah.

[1:18:55] Jimi: There's it's so on point.

[1:18:57] Tommy: I struggle to even put commentary on it.

[1:19:02] Jimi: Right, exactly, because it it kind of it really speaks for itself.

[1:19:05] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:19:06] Jimi: It's like it's like being asked to like annotate someone's personal diary.

[1:19:10] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:19:12] Jimi: Um that's just so honest.

[1:19:14] Tommy: Absolutely.

[1:19:15] Jimi: And i if there's something about as well, there's something about memory song that um it reminds me of the denemo of uh Life of Pi.

[1:19:26] Tommy: Have you read Life of Pi?

[1:19:28] Jimi: I've not read Life of Pi.

[1:19:29] Tommy: Tell me about it.

[1:19:30] Jimi: Oh, it's a big ol' spoiler alert.

[1:19:33] Tommy: Okay.

[1:19:33] Jimi: But I will probably never read it.

[1:19:35] Tommy: I forgot how to read after eighth grade, so well for anyone listen because I really think this needs to be read rather than listening to someone discuss it.

[1:19:44] Jimi: Um so for anyone listening, uh if you've not read Life of Pi and it's been on your bookshelf or it's been on your things to read, and really everyone should read it.

[1:19:53] Tommy: It's a sensational book.

[1:19:55] Jimi: Um skip ahead five minutes or whatever.

[1:19:59] Tommy: Um anyway, uh the denoma on this book basically the whole of the book charts this boy's journey after he's shipwrecked um with uh four animals.

[1:20:09] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:20:10] Tommy: Uh and he kind of goes on this crazy survival adventure in the open sea, taming this tiger, uh learning a lot about how to how to survive it.

[1:20:21] Jimi: So he goes onto this very strange island, um that's inhabited solely by mere cats and this kind of like flesh-eating plant, like it's very fantastical.

[1:20:31] Tommy: Um and uh yeah, so like I say at the denumo, um a journalist comes in speaks to him.

[1:20:38] Jimi: Uh once he's he's been discovered and back in the hospital, yeah.

[1:20:42] Tommy: Yeah, a journalist comes to speak to him and is like, I don't believe your story, like it's too fantastical that couldn't have happened.

[1:20:50] Jimi: Um he says, Well, I could tell you the story that uh it wasn't for animals, it was me, my mum, my dad, uh a cook who was going crazy um from the thing, and actually instead of the animals eating each other, it was this cook who was going crazy and amidst the survival and the being shipwrecked that he killed his parents and he witnessed that and he survived all of this.

[1:21:21] Tommy: He said I could tell you that, or I could tell you this other story of you know, these animals and this fantastical thing, and it's it's however you take it.

[1:21:32] Jimi: I'm bastardizing this is why I didn't want to take it.

[1:21:35] Tommy: But anyway, um there's something about that kind of like taking a step back and kind of exiting your own story, yeah.

[1:21:45] Jimi: Um that I feel memory song does for me.

[1:21:48] Tommy: Like I don't feel like it it it sits in the story, not and I'm not saying this in a bad way, I'm not saying like it doesn't fit, like it doesn't work, it absolutely works, and it absolutely is in the correct place.

[1:22:00] Jimi: Um, and again, wish I had the book because I would be fascinated to see how it's embedded in the story.

[1:22:06] Tommy: Um but I don't know for me, there's something that it's it's just it's a different level of honesty compared to everything else.

[1:22:14] Jimi: Yeah, it's really it it feels like you say, this feels like Michael R. Jackson, you know, stepping out in front of the stage and singing his own song before going back and letting the show finish.

[1:22:25] Tommy: Like it has that vibe, and it's so I think that's one of the things that makes it so powerful is it just it rests somewhere else.

[1:22:32] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:22:33] Tommy: But it in the show in the same way it also like codifies the show, right?

[1:22:39] Jimi: Right, exactly.

[1:22:40] Tommy: Because it's it's not it's not a new idea, it's everything that the show's been talking about.

[1:22:44] Jimi: Yeah, in a new very Yeah.

[1:22:48] Tommy: It's it's like non-metaphorical way.

[1:22:51] Jimi: It's a way back to then from title of show. It's you know, I I I I feel tinges of there's this commentary of like Yeah, memory and storytelling and you're right, stepping outside of the story for a second, you know, way to reinforce the story.

[1:23:12] Tommy: Exactly, 'cause that's the thing is like if if we're living in his head, yeah, surely we're encountering a lot of his memories, and he hears him saying, Well, these are my memories.

[1:23:21] Jimi: Right.

[1:23:21] Tommy: And they they actually a lot of the times fly in the face of things that he's been talking about.

[1:23:26] Jimi: You know, I mean, you you get this idea that he's had maybe quite an awful childhood because he's had these homophobic parents and um this resonation in his head of AIDS is God's punishment.

[1:23:41] Tommy: Like he has that there.

[1:23:42] Jimi: But actually what he talks about is a very it's it's a lot more simple, not to take power out of it, but yeah, uh you know what I mean by that, it's not we're not dealing with big dark ideas, there's no yeah, um it's not the mother from Coraline, like it's right, it's it's very simple life.

[1:24:05] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:24:06] Jimi: And within that, this is the kind of birth of all of these other thoughts.

[1:24:10] Tommy: Right.

[1:24:11] Jimi: And like some some big big problems.

[1:24:13] Tommy: I do think, you know, one at one of the things that makes me sad at night is the plight of gay children, which is a lot of what memory song is about. Um is like, you know, to I think gay kids have to grow up, queer kids have to grow up so quickly that they lose out on their childhood and end up with like a reversed childhood. Um and there's something so sour sorrowful about that, um, that I really feel in memory song. Um it makes me sad. Um yeah.

[1:24:56] Jimi: Yeah, and I think I i I get again because uh there's no answers in this show, right? Which is great. Um I think I think there's a part of me that's sad that uh he's lost his religion.

[1:25:10] Tommy: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Do you know what I mean? And it it it's interesting because there's a there's a framing within this song, obviously towards the end, um, where he says, like, all those black gay boys I knew who chose to go on back to the Lord, um, and for himself he says, I'm one of those black gay boys I knew who chose to turn his back on the Lord. Um there's it's it's a shame that it has to be one or the other.

[1:25:37] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:25:38] Tommy: It's such a it's such a tragedy. I uh the Yeah, I think about this a lot. I thought about it a lot when I was, you know, coping with my own homosexuality. And I think I was very early on to like be like, ah, well, I'm gay, fuck religion. Like that that transition didn't take too much out of, you know, my own mental health. But I do see, you know, and the the framing around religion being enforced by his mom and some of this stuff is what to me makes it even more tragic. Not that my mom did similar things, but like you put yourself in that position of like religion is a great comfort to those who have it, right?

[1:26:25] Jimi: Absolutely.

[1:26:26] Tommy: You know, you there's this place you're gonna go when you die, and everything's for the best, and Jesus is watching out for you, and like all this stuff, right? And I'm sure like once you start to study it, you know, sociologically and psychologically, it makes a lot of sense. Like, of course, humans are going to invent this big man in the sky who's gonna solve all your problems because that's what we crave, right? To the point of you know, delusion, honestly. Uh or y if you're in my perspective. Um and to lose all of that is also such a huge tragedy. Or to have all of that and know that, or you know, believe that your your son will lose it all is a fantastically huge tragedy.

[1:27:17] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:27:17] Tommy: Um my grandma, um, who's 92, um, used to live near near Chicago, like down the street from where I grew up, um, you know, like we she introduced me to singing in the rain when I was in like fourth grade. Like, she's the reason I love musical theater of bar none. Um, moved to Oregon when I was in eighth grade, um, and used to secretly tell me that I was her favorite grandson, and I much suspect she told everyone that. Um But I you know, moved to Portland when I was in eighth grade. We went out and visited two years later, um, and she told me in confidence, Tommy, I moved out here to die and I haven't died yet. Um that was when I was a sophomore in high school. She's still alive, she's still there.

[1:28:07] Jimi: Wow, yeah, coping with herself.

[1:28:09] Tommy: Um, starting to lose her facilities a bit. Um, you know, and I I adore my upbringing with her, but I went out to visit maybe two years ago. Um, and like she's racist, she's probably mildly homophobic, you know. It comes down to her upbringing and all sorts of stuff, certainly. And I, you know, I don't apologize for it, but it's what the reality I live with. Um and it was interesting visiting with her again, because you know, I adore her and love her, and we've never talked about me being gay, but she did on one point she mentioned like you have a you have a special friend, don't you? Which was just a fantastically comedic way to deal with it.

[1:28:47] Jimi: Um and then we would talk about other stuff, and she's losing her facilities a bit, so it's all rambly. Um but then she started to talk about when she was very young, uh her parents got divorced and she was raised by her grandma.

[1:29:02] Tommy: Um, and in a time when getting divorced was probably as poorly looked down upon as being gay is looked down upon now. Um, and like she point blank asked me, Tommy, do you think I'm going to hell? Because she has this like deep-seated difficulty with her parents getting divorced. And like it's one of the bigger I don't know, it's one of the bigger struggles in my brain I've had. Like my honest answer is like, no, Graham, I don't think you're going to hell. I think when we die we die and that's it. Which might be a comfort instead of going to hell, right? But what a fascinating, you know, to experience it on both fronts.

[1:29:46] Jimi: Both on like an academic separated from it, you know, sociological clinical perspective.

[1:29:54] Tommy: It's a difficult thought to cope with, right? But then also to cope with it relationshiply, you know, with someone you know and love and care about in spite of all of their significant problems. Right. You know, that there's it's such a human thing. And all of it all, you know, couched in the context of this show, it you know, Usher's story is not my story. Michael R. Jackson's story is not my story, but it does bring these thoughts to my head.

[1:30:25] Jimi: Yeah, exactly.

[1:30:26] Tommy: Which is some of the the beauty of it. And why it is such a like I like this show, it's not gonna be on repeat for me, you know.

[1:30:37] Jimi: Right?

[1:30:37] Tommy: This isn't a go to show. And like I'll listen to Sweeney Todd recreationally.

[1:30:42] Jimi: Um but a strange loop is hard to listen to.

[1:30:48] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:30:50] Jimi: It Yeah, exactly.

[1:30:52] Tommy: It's it's and it's even that is uh an interesting thing in its own right, isn't it?

[1:30:58] Jimi: Mm hmm.

[1:30:59] Tommy: Because obviously, nowadays what we know for shows to be successful.

[1:31:07] Jimi: Right.

[1:31:08] Tommy: They get on TikTok.

[1:31:09] Jimi: Yeah, exactly.

[1:31:10] Tommy: Right?

[1:31:10] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:31:11] Tommy: Like who's gonna be I mean, don't even tell you what we're talking about. Like that but that's the thing. So and I I agree with you, I I would probably be the same. It's not something that I would just put on flippantly because I don't I have a weirder reverence for and not irreverence, reverence for material like this that I think is powerful and significant, and that I don't just dip into it because I worry that it will lose its significance.

[1:31:38] Jimi: Right.

[1:31:38] Tommy: And its importance.

[1:31:39] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:31:39] Tommy: Um in the same way I've only read The Life of Pi three times when I've needed to. Do you know what I mean? Because it's like because you don't want it to become so rote that it loses its power.

[1:31:50] Jimi: Exactly, exactly.

[1:31:52] Tommy: Um and I feel the same I actually feel the same way about this show. Um but if it's not getting the lessons.

[1:31:58] Jimi: Right.

[1:31:59] Tommy: It's such the curse of the art form.

[1:32:01] Jimi: Right.

[1:32:02] Tommy: Not that I think a single thing should ever change it though. I don't think I think the art is much better than any sort of commerciability that could be applied.

[1:32:12] Jimi: Yeah, but this is the you know, we talk the business all the time, and it is the big curiosity I have going back to your very first question, you know, what's the future of this show?

[1:32:22] Tommy: And like in a world of white producers who want marketability and where you know wokeness is just another kind of marketability.

[1:32:32] Jimi: Yep.

[1:32:33] Tommy: I don't know if this fits in the cookie cutter they're looking for. Um, like it it does it will be a big question of how wholesale the paradigm shift actually will be in the theatrical community when stuff opens up again, when you know we are sitting with the whiteness we've been perpetuating and the racism we've been perpetuating will and like the personal struggle I have with that it's sad to me to think about a Broadway production of a strange loop as an apology because I could see it kind of coming from that motivation and it you know it deserves so much better right it deserves to stand on its own merit but we don't you know we live in this world of tokenization and you know my college used to do what they called one multicultural play a season right I know isn't that terrible so basically you mean one non white right yeah is fucked up um and I didn't like I was complicit I was excited right yeah we're gonna of course look at how inclusive we are right yeah yeah exactly right it's so you know it's it's in the same bucket as colorblind casting like good on the surface terrible past its sugary exterior um so it'll be fascinating to see how you know what the life of this show is what you know how Broadway is when we get back.

[1:34:16] Jimi: Absolutely I really just I I hope it has some sort of life yeah more people deserve to experience it more fully I you know we deserve those extra 40 minutes.

[1:34:28] Tommy: Exactly I know I know um yeah, I'm I'm really fascinated to see to see where it goes.

[1:34:36] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:34:36] Tommy: And it does in a very different way that I was fascinated about B More Shell.

[1:34:40] Jimi: Right, exactly.

[1:34:41] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:34:42] Jimi: Well yeah.

[1:34:43] Tommy: And eve and even like, you know, I can absolutely see a well meaning producer.

[1:34:50] Jimi: Like this moves to Broadway, there are gonna be conversations about how racy it is, right?

[1:34:56] Tommy: And do you keep it all? Do you remove it? It's so it's so it's so frustrating.

[1:35:03] Jimi: Right?

[1:35:04] Tommy: But 100%.

[1:35:05] Jimi: That we no, it's so frustrating that we like musicals.

[1:35:08] Tommy: Because also if this is a play, yeah.

[1:35:12] Jimi: No questions asked.

[1:35:13] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:35:14] Jimi: Because plays aren't a part of pop culture.

[1:35:16] Tommy: I mean, look at slave play.

[1:35:17] Jimi: Um exactly.

[1:35:19] Tommy: It's usually well received, very di very challenging, more challenging than this.

[1:35:22] Jimi: Very very challenging.

[1:35:23] Tommy: Well, I mean, you know, I guess it depends on your view.

[1:35:26] Jimi: This this kind of really hits.

[1:35:28] Tommy: Yeah, no, for us, I mean it's because we like musicals, but yeah.

[1:35:31] Jimi: Um but I uh yeah, I don't know, like that it that frustrates me because uh musical theater, this frustrating thing that we have to live with every time you have that conversation of yeah, when I see musical theater, you hear Joseph.

[1:35:49] Tommy: Right you hear Mamma Mia.

[1:35:51] Jimi: Oh yeah.

[1:35:51] Tommy: Um you don't hear a strange loop.

[1:35:55] Jimi: Right, exactly.

[1:35:56] Tommy: Well and it is how do you have that conversation with someone?

[1:35:59] Jimi: It is a growing uh like it's a frustration I'm sure we've had for years, but is ringing louder in my head about like the the white ivory tower that is Broadway.

[1:36:10] Tommy: Uh you know, and that it becomes this we've talked about how it becomes uh navel gazy.

[1:36:17] Jimi: It's n New York theater for New York people.

[1:36:20] Tommy: And how much that excludes and like even deeper, you know, New York theater for the people who can afford New York theater.

[1:36:29] Jimi: Exactly.

[1:36:30] Tommy: And that's such a tiny, tiny, tiny subsection of humanity, much less America, much less musical theater enjoyers.

[1:36:39] Jimi: Um and it's it's frustrating that this paradigm has been created and seems, you know, I like to think we're finding ways of unpacking it.

[1:36:50] Tommy: Um I I think we're certainly entering a brave new world in a thousand different ways.

[1:36:56] Jimi: It seems like every every week.

[1:36:58] Tommy: Um but like does a strange loop have a life as a really popular or influential piece in a bunch of regional theaters?

[1:37:10] Jimi: And is that is that a better life for it too?

[1:37:14] Tommy: It's one of those things I would argue, yes, but how does it get in there?

[1:37:17] Jimi: Right.

[1:37:17] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:37:18] Jimi: It's the we talked about it last time.

[1:37:20] Tommy: It's the um what's it called? Now I can't remember the name of the play.

[1:37:24] Jimi: Um almost almost main problem.

[1:37:27] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:37:27] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:37:27] Tommy: Where like you just gotta push to get that one week on Broadway, and then Sam French is excited to have you.

[1:37:33] Jimi: I will say I don't think this will do well in skills.

[1:37:35] Tommy: That's fair.

[1:37:36] Jimi: That's fair.

[1:37:36] Tommy: I think this will do great in colleges, appropriate ones.

[1:37:39] Jimi: Yes.

[1:37:40] Tommy: Um but high schools maybe.

[1:37:44] Jimi: But what a wild consideration, and w I know we talk about that all the time.

[1:37:47] Tommy: I've you know, fuck, I've made a whole YouTube videos about shit like that.

[1:37:50] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:37:51] Tommy: But like, what a wild consideration that like if you want a musical to be to have longevity and be successful, it must be appropriate enough for an 18-year-old to perform in.

[1:38:03] Jimi: Right, exactly.

[1:38:04] Tommy: Right?

[1:38:04] Jimi: What a wild thing.

[1:38:05] Tommy: And it's such a loaded thing.

[1:38:14] Tommy: On that note, it's another I'm sorry to like bring up a new point just because we are like tailing off. But um, yeah, that's something I want to talk about is like shock value in musical theatre, where this show sits compared to things like Avenue Q with the Mormon.

[1:38:34] Jimi: I don't think tell me, describe to me what you mean by shock value.

[1:38:40] Tommy: Uh what I mean by shock value is the thing that will make you go, okay. Right? What you do after that, yeah, is the issue.

[1:38:49] Jimi: Sure.

[1:38:50] Tommy: Whether you go or whether you go, yeah.

[1:38:55] Jimi: I think I have a connotation with shock value that also associates it with authorial intent, which might not be well But that but that's that's what that's what I mean about the after.

[1:39:05] Tommy: Sure.

[1:39:05] Jimi: I think Avenue Q intends all of its shock value.

[1:39:10] Tommy: Uh-huh.

[1:39:11] Jimi: I would I think a strange loop embraces it but doesn't intend it. Is that nuanced enough to make a difference?

[1:39:18] Tommy: I don't know. I think it intends that I think it's I think he's literally saying like hello, this is the reality.

[1:39:25] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:39:25] Tommy: Sorry. Like there's no, you know, I mean, there's that's what I mean about it coming from this place of like deep honesty. But the thing that frustrates me is that Book of Mormon is still running.

[1:39:37] Jimi: I don't is it still running in Broadway?

[1:39:38] Tommy: I don't know.

[1:39:39] Jimi: I don't think it's running in London.

[1:39:40] Tommy: Um uh fuck Book of Mormon. Um Right, but but that's the thing, is like here's a show that is like renowned success, yeah, like in our lovely prepackaged happy clappy Broadway world, right? Because it is that but you'll get a laugh out of it, so it's fine.

[1:39:54] Jimi: Right.

[1:39:58] Tommy: Whereas this is like oh my god, you have a realization, you'll learn something about yourself, it's an important shock, like it's not shock with a s a dig at somebody else.

[1:40:08] Jimi: I I think the difference is the kind of the flavor of shock, because very clearly Avenue Q, when Kate Monster drops that first fuck, um and they like they talk about how it's so important that that happened so early on, like it's not a rhyming thing, it like happens in the clear, like these puppets are gonna swear at you.

[1:40:30] Tommy: Yeah, and that tells you the tone of the show.

[1:40:33] Jimi: The uh corollary to that in this show is when they don't say the N-word, um, you know, uh uh it's the naval gazy line. Um if you can't please the Caucasians, you'll never get the dough. Because critics clinically deny us, it's such a great run. Because critics clinically deny us, then deny implicit bias with their vanity supported by a system that's distorted, watch them write you off as lazy, not to mention naval gazy, lacking both in craft and rigor, because you're just a fucking uh yes, and they don't even say it.

[1:41:04] Tommy: Um which they don't shy away from later, right? And like that's the moment when you know this is a show that might drop the N bomb, right?

[1:41:17] Jimi: It it lands hugely differently, I would wager.

[1:41:23] Tommy: It it does, but uh what I find frustrating is that that stops the strange look from getting on bro.

[1:41:30] Jimi: Right, exactly. But I think and it's you know, because and it is the huge problem with Avenue Q, even there's a great article which we should link about like the outdated uh hand wavy racistness of uh everyone's a little bit racist in Avenue Q. Um, and this kind of, you know, like uh, you know, second wave wokeness, maybe that uh we're approaching right now in 2020.

[1:41:58] Tommy: Um where like after Kate Monster says fuck, you know you're supposed to laugh as an audience and like look at the person next to you and be like, oh, she just say that? Wow, that's wild, right? When a strange loop doesn't drop the N bomb and barrels right into the next line, it might get a laugh from the audience, but it's a like, am I allowed to laugh at this kind of laugh, right?

[1:42:25] Jimi: Which is a different flavor of shock value. And I do agree that it is a shame because both are both this and Avenue Q and uh uh Book of Mormon are capitalizing on that same like offensiveness juxtaposition with the bouncy musical theater sound, like literally the next line is a big black and queer ass American Broadway and a big old catchy, brassy run, right? Toe toe tapping, everyone's doing jazz hands, walking across the stage, right? It's the same thing.

[1:42:56] Tommy: Yep, but because of the particular positioning of this one and the way it's commentating on something, yeah, Avenue Q is safer. Book of Mormon is safer for white audiences. They know they're still in a safe space and are gonna be taken care of. Whereas like a strange loop is gonna make you sit with some stuff.

[1:43:17] Jimi: Right, exactly. Um, so see, just to finish, can I give uh a quote from um Michael R. Jackson?

[1:43:24] Tommy: Absolutely.

[1:43:25] Jimi: Weirdly about that, but kind of also sums up literally everything else we're talking about. Um, so the interviewer asked the question Um, one recurring theme of self-policing pertains to the N-word. Um, in intermission song, one of the thoughts is going to rhyme what we've just talked about. Um and uh later in the Guardians of Musical Theatre scene, so a scene that we don't know, um, one of the thoughts says, uh, you can't say N, uh, there are white people watching, there are black people watching. Um, and the interviewer goes on to say it's interesting because I remember after a performance of Bella, I was standing with Kirsten, these are all playwrights horizon people, um, in the audience, and a very distinguished-looking black gentleman came up to her and very respectfully asked, Um, I just need to ask you uh why did you feel the need to have that word in your play? Um, I should preface as well, Kristen is a black writer. Um and the interview says I hadn't really appreciated until that moment that there's a real controversy around the subject.

[1:44:21] Tommy: And so Michael R. Jackson goes on to say, um, this argument has been going on since the word was created by white people. Whether you can say it or can't say it, or who should say it, or why I should say, um, and my thing about it is that I respect people who say I won't say it or I don't like it, but I won't be policed by them because to me, I feel like I will say it until there's no need to say it. It's a very powerful word, and it's a word that draws a line in the sand. I feel like I mostly hear arguments against using it from black people who think if we just stop saying it, then we'll show white people who's boss or prove that we respect ourselves or whatever. But I'm like, no, that actually isn't true.

Uh as Tony Morrison says of racist white people, there will always be one more thing. There's a wrinkle when you're talking about musicals. The thing that inevitably happens with musicals is the songs get inside you, and then you start bursting into song walking down the hall, including the songs with taboo lyrics. I'm not sure if the hair soundtrack were released today, if I would feel okay to sing along to Colored Spade. But isn't the thing about our favorite musicals is that we always memorize the whole score and sing along with it? What is inhabiting us? Is it the composer, the character, the story? I think art is about making the intangible tangible and about creating a common language between disparate experiences.

It is none of my business what lyrics people sing along with at home. I believe strongly that everyone has to take responsibility for their own choices, including whether to clap along to AIDS is God Punishment or not. That song was written specifically because I had gone to see the 2013 Tyler Perry film, Temptation Confessions of a Marriage Counselor. In the film, two black women are essentially cursed with AIDS for exercising free sexuality. In the movie theater, there were audience members who nodded along and said, Yep, that's what she gets. And I was struck by the dissonance of that, and how that kind of thinking was completely consonant with the homophobia I had been raised with slash under.

I wanted to create an infectious song moment that gave listeners a punishment and a reward, not necessarily in that order. I think our favorite musicals give us a framework for thinking about real life, which is why I love the forum so much.

[1:46:43] Tommy: Jimmy, I think we have to stop doing our podcast because Michael R. Jackson's gonna start a pod podcast, and there's no way we're ever gonna compete.

[1:46:51] Jimi: I know.

[1:46:52] Tommy: I just thought like because that's something like that. That is something I've I've been that person singing along to hair. Do you know what I mean?

[1:46:59] Jimi: And be like, oh even I live alone in my flat, and I'm like I mean, uh who's sung along to hairspray, and once a month we have our what day, right?

[1:47:08] Tommy: Exactly.

[1:47:09] Jimi: Yeah.

[1:47:10] Tommy: Um I'm not saying it's like so now we all have permission to say whatever. But it's just I just found it really interesting uh this take on it. Um that how much authorial intent he thought about it, yeah.

[1:47:27] Jimi: It's no accident, which is delightful. It's always wonderful to hear that the authors meant it.

[1:47:33] Tommy: Because so many, you know.

[1:47:34] Jimi: I think it's why I bitch so much about Andrew Lloyd Webber, because I don't think he means it.

[1:47:40] Tommy: But Michael R. Jackson does.

[1:47:42] Jimi: He really, really does. And yeah, very grateful that he's written this. And I'm telling you, the moment his musical theater analysis podcast starts, we are sunk.

[1:47:53] Tommy: We'll be guests.

[1:47:55] Jimi: That's fine.

[1:47:57] Tommy: Should I give up on hoping?

[1:48:00] Jimi: My point of view will shift.

[1:48:04] Tommy: And let this agony just be my greatest gift.

[1:48:11] Jimi: What if that is the secret?

[1:48:14] Tommy: That makes like zero sense.

[1:48:17] Jimi: I'll never change forever.

[1:48:21] Tommy: If I stay on the fence with dogs, I like to find me.

[1:48:28] Jimi: And the last I keep avoiding and rage that I repress.

[1:48:38] Tommy: I should stop overthinking and do the thing that's tough.

[1:48:45] Jimi: Unleash my hungry lion.

[1:48:48] Tommy: Cause old he's had enough of toxic Tyler Perry and white gay male tyranny and my secret inner white girl, though she is dear to me.

[1:49:05] Jimi: But would that be sufficient?

[1:49:09] Tommy: Or would that be a shaw?

[1:49:12] Jimi: Cause even with those actions, I'm stuck with who I am someone whose self-perception is based upon a lie.

[1:49:26] Tommy: Someone whose only problem is with the pronoun Ibe I don't need changing.

[1:49:36] Jimi: Maybe I should reprove.

[1:49:40] Tommy: Cause change is just an illusion.

[1:49:43] Jimi: And I is just an illusion.

[1:49:47] Tommy: If thoughts are just an illusion, it's an illusion, just an illusion.

[1:49:53] Jimi: Then what a strange strange.

[1:50:15] Tommy: Loop. And welcome to Jim and Tomic's musical theater hat.

[1:50:19] Jimi: Right, that's how we should.

[1:50:20] Tommy: Oh, that's funny. Because look.

[1:50:21] Jimi: Right, got it. See?

[1:50:23] Tommy: The jokes.

[1:50:24] Jimi: Yep.

[1:50:24] Tommy: Uh but that's not how we end the episode.

[1:50:24] Jimi: We end the episode with a quiz question.

[1:50:29] Tommy: Ha ha we do. What is it?

[1:50:33] Jimi: You ready?

[1:50:35] Tommy: Uh yeah.

[1:50:36] Jimi: The author of this musical allegedly likes Pina Coladas and getting caught in the rain. What show?

[1:50:43] Tommy: Fascinating. Um, if you would like to get in touch with us, you absolutely can. Uh our show, Twitter, and Instagram is at Jim and Tomic. That is J-I-M-A-N-D-T-O-M-I-C.

[1:50:58] Tommy: Um or uh you can drop us an email over on our website, Jim and Tomic.com. We've got a few emails.

[1:51:04] Jimi: Yes.

[1:51:04] Tommy: And I will get around to reply to them very, very soon. But keep them coming. I love them. It's so fun to hear from people. It's the best kind of email to get.

[1:51:12] Jimi: Um and while you're at the website, you can also check out our Patreon if you want to financially support the show. Thank you as always to our current Patreons and reviews on Apple Podcasts and other podcast uh uh media places locations are always super helpful to the success of our show.

[1:51:30] Tommy: Indeed. Um, but the best way uh to help us grow is if you just speak to your friends and let them know all about the darn thing. Um is there an old episode that you love that you want them to listen to? Is there one that they want?

[1:51:41] Jimi: I don't know.

[1:51:43] Tommy: I don't know where I was going at that point. Um either way, tell your friends.

[1:51:47] Jimi: Tell your friends.

[1:51:48] Tommy: And that's all we got. Thanks for listening.

[1:51:49] Jimi: Cheers, Jimmy.

[1:51:52] Tommy: Cheers, Tommy.

[1:52:07] Jimi: I'm excited to find out what songs you picked to play in the segues to find one.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred