Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Happy Hour #85: The Podcast on the Wall - 'The Mystery of Edwin Drood'

Happy Hour #85: The Podcast on the Wall - 'The Mystery of Edwin Drood' Will this be the podcast episode that never ends?! The jury’s out as we deep dive into Rupert Holmes’ “The Mystery of Edwin Drood” - please insert your own gavel... Read More

From the show: Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour

1 h 22 mins
8/16/20

About

Happy Hour #85: The Podcast on the Wall - 'The Mystery of Edwin Drood'

Will this be the podcast episode that never ends?! The jury’s out as we deep dive into Rupert Holmes’ “The Mystery of Edwin Drood” - please insert your own gavel. With two incredible, classic productions there is plenty to talk about with this Tony Award winning musical. We get into the general brilliance of Mr Holmes, the race issues related to the recent productions and how they could be easily remedied and Chita Rivera’s octogenarian athleticism.

Support the Show ➤

The Mystery of Edwin Drood (New Broadway Cast Recording)

Amazon / iTunes / Spotify

SHOW NOTES

Are you ready for our next new podcast - Stephanie J. Talk?

Besides being a musical theatre writing extraordinaire, Rupert Holmes is an incredible pop writer working with the likes of Barbra Streisand! Check out one of his songs here!

Believe it or not, there is a symphonic heavy metal version of The Mystery of Edwin Drood. Do you think it works?

Here’s a great article to give some perspective on the racism in the productions of Drood.

If you’ve never come across the incredible comedy Father Ted, then you’ve missed Drood star Jim Norton giving a career-defining performance!

Could this be Jimi’s all time favourite Side By Side By Susan Blackwell? It’s truly too soon to tell. But it’s up there! Here’s Stephanie J. Block and her li’l pupper (who also starred in the show!) Macaco!

Actually before I go, here’s just more SJB being great.

Remember you can come chat to us about the episode on Twitter and Instagram @jimandtomic! Or if you wanna pop OFF then jump into our email inbox at jimandtomic@gmail.com!

A Rapping Quiz QuestionChance the Rapper recently saw inspiration from perhaps one of the most unlikely of places – one of the songs in this Golden Age musical. What musical?

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Tommy: I've got the Lurge.

[0:01] Jimmy: Do you indeterminate Lurgy?

[0:04] Tommy: Save more British things.

[0:06] Jimmy: That's wild.

[0:06] Tommy: Indeterminate Lurgy?

[0:08] Jimmy: Lurgy, yeah.

[0:09] Tommy: Do you have Lurgy?

[0:10] Jimmy: Like lethargy?

[0:13] Tommy: No Lurge.

[0:14] Jimmy: It's like you're oh I've got Large.

[0:16] Tommy: Just like it's you're full of stuff.

[0:18] Jimmy: Lurgate.

[0:18] Tommy: That's you can put that one right up there with the big light.

[0:21] Jimmy: These are ones that are so far out of Americanisms.

[0:28] Tommy: Well somebody get us another drink!

[0:30] Jimmy: Welcome to Jim and Tomic's musical theater happy hour.

[0:34] Tommy: I'm Tommy.

[0:36] Jimmy: And I'm Jimmy, and this is the only musical theater podcast with Bud Lights.

[0:41] Tommy: And opening nights.

[0:42] Jimmy: Here we take about your favorite shows, muddle them together with a shot of buffoonery, and pour you a refreshing glass of musical theater conversation.

[0:50] Tommy: Jimmy, what you drinking today?

[0:53] Jimmy: Lemsip.

[0:57] Tommy: Not a bit of port.

[0:59] Jimmy: No.

[1:00] Tommy: Do you uh do you have Lemsip in the States?

[1:02] Jimmy: No, but we I could guess it we have emergency.

[1:05] Tommy: Do you have that?

[1:06] Jimmy: I think it's like airborne.

[1:08] Tommy: Yeah, yeah, same sort of dissolvable, yeah.

[1:11] Jimmy: Vitamin C shit.

[1:14] Tommy: Yeah, with and it's got paracetamol in it.

[1:16] Jimmy: Yeah.

[1:16] Tommy: So it's British, therefore it counts.

[1:19] Jimmy: Yours is medicated.

[1:20] Tommy: Yeah, ours is not medicated.

[1:21] Jimmy: 420.

[1:24] Tommy: This is gonna be a wild episode.

[1:29] Jimmy: Oh dear.

[1:31] Tommy: I'm sorry.

[1:32] Jimmy: Uh read the quiz question.

[1:34] Tommy: Okay.

[1:34] Jimmy: Ooh.

[1:36] Tommy: The author of this musical that we are talking about today, allegedly, uh likes Pinicolades in getting caught in the rain, uh, a fact which I think has haunted him his entire career.

[1:46] Jimmy: Um Tommy, what show did this author create?

[1:50] Tommy: Do we hold I gotta find a gavel.

[1:52] Jimmy: The mystery of Edwin!

[1:55] Tommy: Drew!

[2:03] Jimmy: What's a king without a crown take away his throne and gun?

[2:07] Tommy: He could be the rubble all the Russians are.

[2:09] Jimmy: Judge each creature of our race by each feature in his face.

[2:12] Tommy: Just look at him.

[2:13] Jimmy: I rest my tasteful.

[2:14] Tommy: There you are.

[2:15] Jimmy: There you are!

[2:16] Tommy: And it's not just not to me what part of town you come from.

[2:19] Jimmy: We must cheer you've made it here at all.

[2:21] Tommy: Take it now!

[2:22] Jimmy: Here within this game's parish call.

[2:28] Tommy: There you are!

[2:29] Jimmy: I'm very glad we are that there you are.

[2:32] Tommy: It isn't who you are, but where you are!

[2:35] Jimmy: And there you are!

[2:43] Tommy: There you are!

[2:45] Jimmy: And you're me there!

[2:46] Tommy: Are you out there?

[2:47] Jimmy: Oh Bill!

[2:48] Tommy: Here I am!

[2:50] Jimmy: Surprisingly enough.

[2:53] Tommy: That yeah, that doesn't get annoying.

[2:57] Jimmy: Well, I've seen this done amateurly.

[2:59] Tommy: Yeah.

[3:00] Jimmy: And I actually think some people who were in that listen to this.

[3:05] Tommy: But hey, hey, um that that got annoying.

[3:08] Jimmy: I could I could see, I think I was I was telling my boyfriend this.

[3:12] Tommy: I I think this is a show that is fun to watch and much more fun to be in than it is to watch.

[3:18] Jimmy: Um I would love to be in the show.

[3:21] Tommy: I would I would man, I'd be a great chairman.

[3:24] Jimmy: Um yeah, actually, you would.

[3:27] Tommy: The but I do think like I could see I once saw a terrible production of a terrible high school production of Noises Off.

[3:34] Jimmy: Um god.

[3:36] Tommy: Which I found e so much funnier than a good production.

[3:40] Jimmy: Oh man, and only 'cause I knew the show really well, but like watching the things not go wrong that are supposed to go wrong.

[3:51] Tommy: It's it's a really really special kind of comedy.

[3:54] Jimmy: Um that's quite unique to Noises Off, I guess.

[3:58] Tommy: Yeah.

[3:59] Jimmy: Um I could see being trapped in a a you know, not or an overindulgent well, I don't know.

[4:06] Tommy: Could this show be too indulgent?

[4:08] Jimmy: Um no, because it's it's it's very um is self-effacing the right word.

[4:12] Tommy: Is that the one where you like make fun of yourself?

[4:14] Jimmy: Sure.

[4:14] Tommy: That means make fun of yourself.

[4:16] Jimmy: Sure.

[4:16] Tommy: Let's go with that.

[4:17] Jimmy: Um but it does that all the way through.

[4:19] Tommy: So I don't think it's it it can be Yeah, self it'd be very I don't know, it'd be very weird if that was the result.

[4:27] Jimmy: Um but it can also just be a lot.

[4:30] Tommy: Yeah, it can be a lot to do.

[4:31] Jimmy: I mean if if it's very you know, if if everyone is being melodramatic.

[4:35] Tommy: Absolutely.

[4:36] Jimmy: That's a lot.

[4:37] Tommy: Yeah.

[4:37] Jimmy: Um, you know.

[4:39] Tommy: Yeah, I do wonder if the show would swing in Denver because it does take a lot of like theatrical understanding, you know.

[4:50] Jimmy: Um I see what you mean.

[4:52] Tommy: Right.

[4:52] Jimmy: And just because I find that Denver isn't quite as much of a theater going city as say Chicago is or New York or London or something like that.

[4:59] Tommy: Um and like it might you know, some of the comedy might not just land.

[5:03] Jimmy: I don't know.

[5:04] Tommy: I think yeah, some maybe some of like the stage jokes, but I think the general we've not even talked about what the hell it is yet, Tommy.

[5:10] Jimmy: Um the general access I would say it's very accessible.

[5:13] Tommy: That's true.

[5:14] Jimmy: Because it's silly.

[5:15] Tommy: Yeah, it's the same way that I think anyone could see Noises Off and not think it's the funniest thing that's ever existed.

[5:20] Jimmy: That's true.

[5:20] Tommy: It'll a lot of I forget that so much of it is just s you know, firmly sat in low humor, falling downstairs, slapsticky sort of body stuff, which is always funny.

[5:32] Jimmy: Anyway, hey, what is it? Mystery of Edwin Drude, uh music, lyric books, and orchestration by Rupert Holmes.

[5:40] Tommy: A more than a hat trick.

[5:42] Jimmy: I wonder, like, 'cause we say this a lot, right?

[5:45] Tommy: Like, I don't think this is ever happened for nine thousand people tell is the the very long list of people that do that.

[5:50] Jimmy: Yeah.

[5:51] Tommy: But like I found a write-up somewhere that said it often Rupert Holmes is quoted as being the at least the first, if not the only, to do all four.

[6:00] Jimmy: Um and the this particular write-up said, as far as anyone can really tell in modern musical theater, that seems pretty true.

[6:09] Tommy: But if you do look back to perhaps some of these music hall style things or early vaudeville stuff, that sort of thing was very common.

[6:17] Jimmy: Um in the same way that like Shakespeare wrote and started in his play.

[6:20] Tommy: Like we we pre-diversificating theater jobs.

[6:24] Jimmy: But for nineteen eighty-five this huge deal.

[6:30] Tommy: Right.

[6:31] Jimmy: A huge undertaking.

[6:33] Tommy: Absolutely.

[6:34] Jimmy: Um who did comets orchestrations.

[6:38] Tommy: Oh, he d he did.

[6:39] Jimmy: He did.

[6:40] Tommy: Yeah.

[6:40] Jimmy: I do think there's more contemporary examples.

[6:42] Tommy: I think we're seeing, you know, post in in like n in new modern musical theater post two thousand and ten, maybe.

[6:49] Jimmy: Yeah.

[6:49] Tommy: Um we see m more of like single author vision.

[6:54] Jimmy: Um but it is, you know, it is interesting to we we talk so much about like there is this uh in the the romanticized musical theater ideal, there's supposed to be this authorial tension and you want collaborators.

[7:08] Tommy: Son you know, Sandy talks about this, like you want people to pull you in the different directions and to tell you your ideas are stupid.

[7:14] Jimmy: Um and so I do, you know, to be able to do it successfully, I think both takes it takes a deep understanding of your own hubris and a willingness to like talk yourself out of stuff.

[7:27] Tommy: Yeah, I think so.

[7:28] Jimmy: But it's interesting because like a lot of people who've done all three or four.

[7:36] Tommy: Yeah, yeah.

[7:37] Jimmy: I think I mean but maybe that's just uh they're very good because this person is very good at it.

[7:43] Tommy: Right.

[7:43] Jimmy: Do you know what I mean?

[7:44] Tommy: Like I can't think of an example of a bad one.

[7:46] Jimmy: Well, I think so.

[7:48] Tommy: I do also wonder, like a lot of the triple threats, they'll it's only one show.

[7:53] Jimmy: Even like Meredith Wilson, um who uh h arguably has other shows, but like one successful show.

[7:59] Tommy: And I often wonder if it has more to do with the success of the idea and less to do with the like you have a good idea that you know arrives in your head almost fully formed, and all you have to do is translate it onto paper and flesh it out.

[8:15] Jimmy: Um whereas like you see people who are serial writers, you know, bounce between collaborators or have tried and true collaborators because that becomes their process, and then you know, they find different successes that way.

[8:26] Tommy: It is it's an interesting, you know, because our art form's so collaborative.

[8:32] Jimmy: Exactly.

[8:34] Tommy: Put it in the back of your mind, playwrights, maybe.

[8:37] Jimmy: Yeah, exactly.

[8:38] Tommy: Try it.

[8:39] Jimmy: Yeah.

[8:40] Tommy: Um hey, this was performed in 1985.

[8:44] Jimmy: Yeah, it got its premiere at uh Shakespeare in the Park in Central Park and transferred to Broadway in eighty five, won a ton of Tony Awards.

[8:50] Tommy: Uh nominated Tony?

[8:52] Jimmy: I mean he won a ton of Tony Awards.

[8:53] Tommy: Yeah.

[8:54] Jimmy: He just he was just told you were you're very good.

[8:56] Tommy: You're very good.

[8:57] Jimmy: You're very good.

[8:59] Tommy: Then made it to the West End 87, a tour in 88, directed by Rob Marshall, surprisingly.

[9:05] Jimmy: Yeah.

[9:05] Tommy: Um two West End revivals 07 and 12, and then the 2012 West End Revival transferred to Broadway, basically.

[9:13] Jimmy: Yes.

[9:14] Tommy: Um and I saw it.

[9:17] Jimmy: Yeah?

[9:17] Tommy: Did you like it?

[9:18] Jimmy: Yeah.

[9:19] Tommy: Was that my first project?

[9:20] Jimmy: No, it was my second probably show.

[9:22] Tommy: Um, you saw it, you saw it here.

[9:24] Jimmy: You saw it in New York.

[9:25] Tommy: I saw it in New York.

[9:27] Jimmy: New York.

[9:28] Tommy: My first probably show was Peter and Starcatcher.

[9:30] Jimmy: Okay.

[9:31] Tommy: Uh, and then I saw this.

[9:32] Jimmy: This is my first probably musical.

[9:34] Tommy: Give it that.

[9:35] Jimmy: What a great what a great first show for you on Broadway.

[9:39] Tommy: Yeah, I I cause it as well at the time I didn't really know it beyond listening to it for the Tony's.

[9:45] Jimmy: You know what I mean?

[9:46] Tommy: Yeah.

[9:47] Jimmy: Um, so yeah, I barely barely knew it, and it was uh a great time.

[9:52] Tommy: And I will talk all about my experience later.

[9:55] Jimmy: Excellent.

[9:56] Tommy: We get into Stephanie J.

[9:57] Jimmy: Block.

[9:58] Tommy: Um, which would be a full segment of this.

[10:01] Jimmy: Yeah, we're actually starting a spin-off podcast.

[10:04] Tommy: The the block cast.

[10:05] Jimmy: Stephanie J Talk.

[10:06] Tommy: Ooh.

[10:08] Jimmy: That works.

[10:09] Tommy: TM TM TM.

[10:10] Jimmy: Copyright, copyright.

[10:11] Tommy: It's ours.

[10:12] Jimmy: It's ours.

[10:13] Tommy: Sorry, sorry, Steph.

[10:15] Jimmy: I mean, with the amount of podcasts that exist nowadays, I wouldn't be surprised.

[10:20] Tommy: Um, hey, well, we've already talked quite a lot about it.

[10:24] Jimmy: Um, but should we start doing it properly?

[10:26] Tommy: Sure.

[10:26] Jimmy: Here we go.

[10:35] Tommy: Right.

[11:47] Jimmy: So yeah, I think like I I do just want to like give him a little bit of an applause because it's I I'm just very impressed because uh I personally think it's real solid.

[12:00] Tommy: Oh yes.

[12:01] Jimmy: Like it's really, really solid in terms of a really entertaining night out at the theater.

[12:08] Tommy: Even even just technically, like I think um the you know you dive into the lyrics of some of these songs and it takes as many listens as you know, perhaps something like Hamilton does, just because it's so dense in some of its wordplay and you know, creativity and metaphor.

[12:28] Jimmy: Um Rupert Holmes knows what's up when it comes to songwriting, I think.

[12:33] Tommy: He really does.

[12:34] Jimmy: I mean obviously that's that's how he started off.

[12:36] Tommy: Um and a lot of his the pop songs that he wrote um are are quite narrative, which was obviously quite a trait um in the 70s.

[12:47] Jimmy: You know, I mean these songs did get quite expansive and uh sort of ballady in terms of the traditional t uh, you know, idea of a ballad.

[12:55] Tommy: Right.

[12:55] Jimmy: Um and so y you could tell he had the skills now uh apparently, um according to many interviews, uh he had always kind of wanted to do music theater, but never really thought of it as an an option.

[13:09] Tommy: Sure.

[13:09] Jimmy: Yeah.

[13:10] Tommy: Um and uh it was this show in particular that he had in his head is like this would make a good musical just because you know the main character is very musical.

[13:20] Jimmy: The c the people sing songs in the in the book, and that is always a good sign of something that yeah can translate quite naturally um onto onto a stage.

[13:31] Tommy: Well and that even he you know t kind of I mean stumbled into is the wrong word because it's very intentional, but found this like very apt, productive framing device around the whole thing.

[13:42] Tommy: Um, I'm so curious. It's hard to tell if this is lore or truth, but the narrative goes that Rupert Holmes pitched this show to the producers of Shakespeare in the Park solo, like in a living room somewhere, and like performed the whole thing just for them holding a script.

[14:02] Jimmy: Right.

[14:02] Tommy: Which, like, of course that's how this sort of thing gets pitched, but even just imagining that experience, you know, of it's not a staged reading, it's not rehearsed, like you're just gonna describe your show and perform this very complicated, you know, even without some of the audience voting aspects, show just in like even just performing the inner show, the actual Edwin Drood stuff, would be is already wildly complicated.

[14:35] Jimmy: Yeah.

[14:35] Tommy: Like it kind of works.

[14:37] Jimmy: Yeah, like in its own right.

[14:38] Tommy: Yeah.

[14:39] Tommy: Like it could be, you know, save for not having an ending, a mildly interesting Dickensian piece, right?

[14:46] Jimmy: Yeah.

[14:47] Tommy: Um to add on the other layer, you know, the additional layer of the music hall, then layer of the voting, and on and on and on.

[14:54] Jimmy: Mm-hmm.

[14:54] Tommy: And just to have that from inception, you know, it sounds like it was pitched, and then only a couple weeks later it was in production.

[15:03] Jimmy: Absolutely.

[15:04] Tommy: And I guess like if you don't really know Drood, or if you don't really know why it's very unique in the music theater sphere, basically, the Charles Dickens who wrote the book died whilst writing it.

[15:16] Jimmy: Yeah.

[15:16] Tommy: Um and there were no notes or you know anything as to what the ending may look like.

[15:23] Jimmy: Right.

[15:24] Tommy: Um, so it was just kind of left as an unfinished piece. And it's one of the most delightful pieces to be left that way because it is a mystery, a murder mystery.

[15:32] Jimmy: Right, exactly.

[15:34] Tommy: And so literally there is no ending, and then the show itself frames like tells you this. The chairman comes out at the beginning and describes this whole thing to you and then says, ladies and gentlemen, by the end of the night, you will decide who did and who did indeed murder Edwin Drood, and the audience votes on that and several other things, and depending upon how they vote, that changes the ending of the show.

[15:57] Jimmy: Exactly.

[15:58] Tommy: Every night, many different I can't remember the exact number of different combinations, but the votes are you get to vote for who is the secret detective all along and who was obviously the murderer, and then who are the lovers.

[16:14] Jimmy: Yep.

[16:14] Tommy: So like within that, something like 86 or something different combinations that you could possibly get.

[16:19] Jimmy: Yeah.

[16:19] Tommy: Um all with different songs, different, you know, verses, different reactions, and like the doing their very best to justify why this person you voted for did the thing you voted for them to do.

[16:32] Jimmy: Exactly, exactly.

[16:33] Tommy: And it all yeah, so it's not just like this is the murder song. Each person who could have murdered has their own confession.

[16:40] Jimmy: Yeah, whether it makes sense or not, that is interwoven into the story, and it's just it's really, really smart.

[16:49] Tommy: Yeah, and that it, you know, came out of one man's head. I mean one man's head. Certainly in his forward in one of the published versions of the script, he does talk about having, you know, plenty of inspiration and help.

[17:01] Jimmy: Um but it was his idea, for sure.

[17:04] Tommy: Absolutely. And it's something that really hasn't been replicated.

[17:11] Jimmy: Certainly not in the music.

[17:13] Tommy: Um I guess like we'll talk a bit more about that specific side of it in a bit. Uh but yeah, do you want to talk about a bit a bit more about the different changes between the original and the revival?

[17:29] Jimmy: It's been really interesting to like try and unpack the history of this show. Usually, you know, Tommy and I will like it's really easy to be like, oh, look, what are the new songs added in the contemporary revival? Because they need to give David Hyde Pierce a new song to sing because he's famous and he's gonna come out at the beginning of Act Two and sing "Penny in My Pocket" and be like, okay, David.

[17:47] Tommy: Um because Drood is such a puzzle piece kind of show, there's you know, the original show was three and a half hours long and had 30-something songs, like the original drafts of it, and that have kind of flowed in and out of it, and because it is such a meta-theatrical piece, you can kind of just throw it around.

[18:08] Jimmy: Like, it has such a complicated revision journey, it puts it in the same caliber as "Meet Me in St. Louis," I would say.

[18:15] Tommy: But where "Meet Me in St. Louis" they were trying to fix the thing. This one is kind of just like, yeah, whatever. Like, even in the current licensable script, there's a ton of optional songs, and like, yeah, you could do this one or not, or put it here, even beyond the as written, you know, choose your own adventure style ones, but just elsewhere throughout the show.

[18:38] Jimmy: And so, you know, it's really even just looking at the two very publicly available cast recordings, the '85 one and then the revival 2012-2013 version, there's already tons of differences, and then even on top of that, like I found myself, you know, reading like, wait a minute, there's that song, and like Googling and trying to find some amateur high school production, be like, oh my god, it's a whole nother song that I didn't even know you could include in this show.

[19:06] Tommy: Like because the only time I can really think of that happening, certainly in terms of things that I've done was with "Into the Woods."

[19:14] Jimmy: Yeah, licensed about "Into the Woods" has different directions and things like that.

[19:18] Tommy: But again, not to the point where it like kind of allows you to change the story that you're telling.

[19:23] Jimmy: Yeah, it does strike, like I think this is one of Holmes's most canny understandings of theatre is that and clearly it's reflected in the fabric of the show, but that every night it is different.

[19:39] Tommy: Um, and to just dive into that, you know, with your entire body. Um, like there is this, you know, you read any licensing agreement for a production, and it's like you will change no words in the script and you'll adhere to authorial intent and blah blah blah blah blah.

[19:57] Jimmy: Rupert Holmes wrote like seven pages of notes at the end of Drood. It's like you could do this or you could do that, or maybe it's kinda like this. I don't know, it's yours. Good luck.

[20:06] Tommy: Um, and it's such a I find that such a wholesome understanding of how musical theatre is. Um absolutely that like you can you have permission to make this one your own, which you don't have if you do even "Into the Woods" or "Shrek" or "Mary Poppins," or like those the authors have decided this is the way it must be, and if you go against that, we have people who will sue you.

[20:34] Jimmy: Yeah, exactly, exactly.

[20:36] Tommy: Um yeah, I mean, so far to say that there is a heavy metal version of Edwin Drood out there that was part I think it was performed in DC.

[20:46] Jimmy: Oh my god.

[20:46] Tommy: Um and there's a video of obviously put it in the show notes, of some of the new arrangements that they did.

[20:56] Jimmy: Um, does it work?

[20:58] Tommy: It could work.

[20:59] Jimmy: Yeah.

[20:59] Tommy: It could there's some things that I personally so for example, like um I think it's the Rosebud.

[21:06] Jimmy: Uh huh.

[21:07] Tommy: Uh still sings in the kind of lyrical operatic style.

[21:12] Jimmy: Yeah.

[21:13] Tommy: Um but so but like Moon uh Moonfall sounds like a big 80s like Bonnie Tyler style ballad.

[21:23] Jimmy: Yeah.

[21:24] Tommy: Right? And I was like, oh it'd be so good actually if you just I mean to find someone that can like belt IFs and just do it like that. Like that's tricky, but that would be really cool.

[21:33] Jimmy: Yeah.

[21:33] Tommy: Um if you made it s have that kind of vibe, like that that would be epic. Um but again, just as pure creativity, that's amazing.

[21:42] Jimmy: And there was a really cool interview with Rupert Holmes from like just local press and he went to go see the show and did a Q&A with them and is like, yeah, I love it. Like this is I really like the fact that people go out there and get creative.

[21:58] Tommy: And it kind of was like, I wish people would do it more.

[22:01] Jimmy: Like I love.

[22:03] Tommy: I think that's so like there's there's not really any writers who have that level of infinitely respect, isn't it? It's respect for the other theatre creators out there.

[22:12] Jimmy: And so many so many writers in fact go so you know, so hard in the opposite direction.

[22:18] Tommy: I mean, how many times has Samuel Beckett's estate like gone out and sued a college production for doing like a female version of "Waiting for Godot" and changing nothing else?

[22:29] Jimmy: Like, and how like how up your own ass do you have to be to think that you did it perfectly right and no one could possibly have anything at all to possibly add to improve your writing or make commentary on it?

[22:46] Tommy: Like, of course not. Like, it's so antithetical to what live performance in theatre is.

[22:52] Jimmy: I always find it mind-boggling when you know the contract is so explicitly written, like, you will do it like this or else.

[23:01] Tommy: Like, what, you know, that's not the point. That's not why we make theater. It's different every night.

[23:06] Jimmy: I mean, it just goes to show, like, obviously, we're so many like Broadway revivals and stuff that have changes in them, and yeah, you know, it's like, oh, we want to tell this.

[23:14] Tommy: We look at the Ivan van Hove with a story, right?

[23:16] Jimmy: Right? That's West Side Story.

[23:17] Tommy: That is right. You know, Jerome Robbins won't let you put a step out of line, right?

[23:22] Jimmy: Obviously, that is different now, but um that was held in such high state, and he gets to go in and tear apart.

[23:29] Tommy: No high school or college would ever be given that permission, especially with a show that is, you know, contemporarily problematic, like West Side Story.

[23:39] Jimmy: Yeah, you know what I mean?

[23:40] Tommy: Like, if somebody went in to do like with the revival, yeah, we're like, oh, we really would love to write some Spanish lyrics right for this show, they would have been shot up on that.

[23:51] Jimmy: If my high school went and did that, we would get written up, you know.

[23:53] Tommy: Like, and it does beg the question, why, you know, why are we doing this then anyway?

[24:01] Jimmy: Like, I do understand as an educator, like, there is certainly something to be gained about like we're trying to imitate what the real life is, and so we're gonna, you know, do Hairspray and we're gonna, you know, do our best to make it just like the original thing.

[24:17] Tommy: And like, as a tech director, as a set designer, I get this all the time. Like, I want it to look like it did on Broadway, right?

[24:23] Jimmy: I want you to build me that.

[24:25] Tommy: Um, which has a whole other slew of, you know, copyright problems and intellectual property problems. But like, why? Why not do some new art?

[24:38] Jimmy: Why not build upon the thing?

[24:40] Tommy: Why not, you know, cultivate and create a neighbor, an environment, a world where that's the standard not the illegal thing exactly it yeah it is really bad because like this is it's literally a huge creative avenue in an educational environment for the most part right and you're not allowing people to be creative and learn like it's it's it's weird right it's it's really really weird and like I even try to like think through okay like what what would a well meaning playwright be worried about right maybe your work is used to promote something that you disagree with or whatever um sure valid but like I've seen plenty of amateur productions of things I don't think you know whatever middle school doing legally blonde is like doing a super accurate job of recreating the themes and motifs that you very much intended in your Broadway production right yeah like so who cares exactly well one of the reasons why sorry to bring this up one of the reasons why so many people hate Cats is because they've seen an awful lamb dram production of right exactly you know I mean and so they're just like this is trash and well actually if you went to see it in the show theater you might not have thought that because it's a huge spectacle like it's it's really it's not trash.

[26:05] Jimmy: Right.

[26:06] Tommy: Um but yeah I am like trying to get high school to do that level of choreography that level of production value right because that's obviously what they want it to look like.

[26:15] Jimmy: Right, exactly.

[26:15] Tommy: They're never gonna achieve that.

[26:16] Jimmy: No, instead, like what if you did a like let's just you know a staged reading of Cats, right?

[26:23] Tommy: In t-shirts.

[26:25] Jimmy: Right.

[26:27] Tommy: Be an interesting discussion.

[26:28] Jimmy: And it would be and the specter of Lloyd Webber would show up and start throwing tomatoes at you, like he absolutely would.

[26:36] Tommy: But yeah.

[26:37] Jimmy: So yeah, I say well done, Rupert Holmes.

[26:39] Tommy: Yeah.

[26:40] Jimmy: You know big fan.

[26:41] Tommy: More authors should allow should like be cognizant of that it's that is fucking theater.

[26:50] Jimmy: Theater.

[26:52] Tommy: It's theater. It's such a stupid thing to say, but you know, having experienced it, a lot of I'm you'll be surprised, Jimmy, but I think a lot of theater makers do have their heads up their own asses.

[27:03] Jimmy: I'm stunned.

[27:05] Tommy: I'm full, full, fill, fill stunned. Um yeah, no, well done, Mr. Holmes. Good guy.

[27:12] Tommy: Shall we talk about what a great job he did with the framing and you know, get into the actual structure of this giant puzzle bound to the puzzle pages?

[27:21] Jimmy: I love puzzles, yeah.

[27:23] Tommy: Let's do a puzzle.

[27:24] Jimmy: All right, so you struck the lucky thing, never break through any lucky chain on the pain.

[27:42] Tommy: That's easy to give you a sea target.

[28:20] Jimmy: We're just the beginning.

[28:22] Tommy: Yeah.

[28:22] Jimmy: Because it's crazy.

[28:24] Tommy: The whole I mean if Jimmy and I have been trading back and forth trying to find different published versions of this script.

[28:31] Jimmy: Um because you know, how on earth from text to stage do you make this thing happen, right?

[28:38] Tommy: Exactly.

[28:39] Jimmy: It's such a mess.

[28:41] Tommy: Yeah.

[28:42] Jimmy: Cause that like that's the thing is like if you're a script write script writer, particularly for theatre, um, oftentimes you're so much more prescriptive with your language and and how you're writing your text.

[28:54] Tommy: Yeah.

[28:54] Jimmy: Um whether you go full um Arthur Miller and describe the the smell of the wind.

[29:00] Tommy: Yeah, the the holy candles on the altar of Laura's face were snuffed out.

[29:04] Jimmy: Right, exactly.

[29:05] Tommy: Yeah.

[29:06] Jimmy: Um or you can be a bit more free, I guess.

[29:09] Tommy: Right.

[29:10] Jimmy: But with something like this, which is so technically challenging, yeah.

[29:14] Tommy: Like just very, very challenging, and as well, like if you are an amateur company who isn't maybe not necessarily used to improv, right? You need that handholding, you need that guiding.

[29:27] Jimmy: Yeah.

[29:27] Tommy: Um and for the most part, certainly the the new one, is there.

[29:33] Jimmy: Yeah, it does a pretty good job of walking you through here are the options, here's where you go, here's how to get from this to this, here's what to do when this happens.

[29:41] Tommy: Um and it does, you know, one of the delightful things about I think the success of framing it in a music hall is like, oh, whatever, you know.

[29:50] Jimmy: Like, um if, you know, if the if whoever was like, and the murderer tonight is so and so, and that was wrong, like they said the wrong word, they'd be like, oh no, no, sorry, not you.

[30:01] Tommy: You right? That's totally in world, totally keeps going, could be a joke, like Abs absolutely, like it like that wouldn't be out of place within the whole card of the show.

[30:12] Jimmy: And I think that's again, like, that's one of the things that why I think it's so intelligently written.

[30:17] Tommy: Yeah.

[30:18] Jimmy: Because I don't doubt that that was an intentional framing device.

[30:22] Tommy: You know, he didn't have to set it with actors putting on a musical, right? He didn't have to do that.

[30:27] Jimmy: Um that was very much choice, and it's it's just served him in so many ways.

[30:33] Tommy: Yeah.

[30:33] Jimmy: But at the same time, throws up a lot more obstacles because you then need to get your audience on side from the get-go.

[30:41] Tommy: Right.

[30:42] Jimmy: Yeah, you gotta, you know, let them know what's happening, build it up.

[30:45] Tommy: And of course they do, like the the construction that like, you know, you applaud for characters when they arrive on stage, when they're introduced, when they finish their song.

[30:54] Jimmy: Um, it is I do find it interesting because there are inconsistencies in the world building, and it's interesting when you run into those, like there is so for example, the big one, I think um uh Alice Nutting, the actress who plays Drood, and then um uh what's his face?

[31:15] Tommy: Uh Dick Datchery for the beginning of Act Two uh quits in a huff after she's voted to you know not be alive anymore, basically.

[31:26] Jimmy: Um, but as an actress and like storms off, it's very funny and definitely plays into Holmes' idea of like enjoying when things go wrong, and this is a scripted moment of when something goes wrong.

[31:37] Tommy: But then also scripted in the show, spoiler alert, is that Edwin Drood is alive, and so this actress who you very visibly watched quit earlier and walks out of you, you know, back through the audience, arrives back on stage to reprise her role at the very end.

[31:53] Jimmy: Um or even uh during um uh both sides of the coin, um the fact that the chairman is subbing in for whatever uh the mayor or whatever character he's supposed to be playing, um, and uh is singing this duet with John Jasper, both about how they have this kind John Jasper in the show has this split personality thing, whereas the chairman uh like out of the show has this split personality thing.

[32:20] Tommy: And not a lot of the other songs are framed as like, let's just sing this song, say for um uh Bazard's song.

[32:29] Jimmy: Is that his name?

[32:30] Tommy: Yeah.

[32:30] Jimmy: Yes, uh-huh.

[32:31] Tommy: Um but like so you start with the chairman doing this accidental substitute in, but then having what has to be a very well-rehearsed song, the super high-paced Patter song, you know.

[32:45] Jimmy: It is interesting that like I ri I very much enjoy that we ha the world has these bounds and we can play with them, and it doesn't have to be a big deal.

[32:55] Tommy: No one's like, no one's standing up in the back and being like, wait a minute, Drude can't be back.

[33:00] Jimmy: You know, who cares?

[33:01] Tommy: It's all who cares?

[33:02] Jimmy: Exactly.

[33:02] Tommy: And thank God this comes back because it's definitely boss.

[33:06] Jimmy: Yeah.

[33:06] Tommy: Um but yeah, I'm like, I think it's and it's just quite fun as well, the way that they dance and play in that world.

[33:14] Jimmy: Like, um, I remember it like literally splitting up with laughter when um the cue off to the races, just because it's like it's the song that we always sing in every show that we do.

[33:26] Tommy: Gotta sing it.

[33:27] Jimmy: Like, we must, I guess we better go off to the races.

[33:31] Tommy: Might as well.

[33:33] Jimmy: And like it is really funny. That that kind of just self-referential.

[33:37] Tommy: Oh, it's so funny.

[33:38] Jimmy: Or like even and I w I want to talk more about uh don't quit while you're ahead, maybe in a minute, but like the fact that during the encore of don't quit while you're ahead is where like the strings fall off the violin, everyone comes to the grinding a grinding halt, the chairman takes his hat off and says, ladies and gentlemen, it is at this moment where Charles Dickens laid down his pen for the final time.

[33:58] Tommy: Like, no, it isn't.

[34:00] Jimmy: Exactly, exactly.

[34:01] Tommy: He didn't lay down his pen and he was like, and then during the encore in the kick line, pen trails off the page, right?

[34:09] Jimmy: But it's still just so it's so great, and you're so along for the ride.

[34:12] Tommy: And I think like that is why the um the voting works, like, is because they set up all of these this silliness and this like we're we're here for you, like, because that's what I I think there you are is such an incredible opening number.

[34:30] Jimmy: It's so good.

[34:31] Tommy: It just and not even necessarily in terms of content, I think it's uh it is really good.

[34:34] Jimmy: Yeah, but just in terms of what it is, yeah, um, and the framing of it.

[34:39] Tommy: And he he talks about this quite a lot, but just how a lot of opening numbers in shows are like you are here, right?

[34:48] Jimmy: Like, welcome to my world.

[34:50] Tommy: Yeah.

[34:50] Jimmy: Whereas this is very much like it's like, oh hello.

[34:53] Tommy: Yeah.

[34:53] Jimmy: Like, thank you for coming.

[34:55] Tommy: Like, this is such a nice thing.

[34:57] Jimmy: Yeah, and it's all opening basically.

[34:59] Tommy: It's all framed, it's delightful reading the stage directions about it, where it's like, yeah, you know, the house lights don't blink, there's no chime, people just you know, the actors start walking in in.

[35:07] Jimmy: In um in one of the uh introductions, the the whole first stage direction is even written in first person, um which I very much enjoy.

[35:17] Tommy: Hold on, let me see if I can find it.

[35:19] Jimmy: Um just as we have made some progress with our playbill and even more successfully progressed through our second glass of hawk, we are distracted by a rather beery voice next to us in the aisle.

[35:29] Tommy: It's Nick Cricker himself.

[35:30] Jimmy: Odd that he would venture out into the audience before the show.

[35:33] Tommy: He greets us with a few jests that have long lain in public domain and is now saying something about a determining the outcome of this evening's performance.

[35:40] Jimmy: Man must be drunk.

[35:41] Tommy: Voting, he's going on about.

[35:43] Jimmy: And as we try to decipher his words, another voice commences to hawk salutations like a monger of jellied eels.

[35:49] Tommy: It's Moncrief, thought the man had more dignity than that.

[35:52] Jimmy: He's addressing another section of the audience, apparently about the same matter that Cricker's going on about.

[35:57] Tommy: Suddenly a loud cry of Drood emanates from the residents of the cheaper seats.

[36:01] Jimmy: Sounds like Grinstead and his new the new fellow leading the hazat.

[36:05] Tommy: Like, no one writes stage directions like this.

[36:08] Jimmy: Absolutely.

[36:08] Tommy: That's beautiful.

[36:09] Jimmy: It's it's absolutely again.

[36:11] Tommy: It really helps because there's nothing worse.

[36:14] Jimmy: We've all been in that position where it's like, okay, so you're gonna start in the audience and just like mingle, just like make talk to people, like, you know, have fun.

[36:21] Tommy: It's the biggest nightmare, particularly if you are not an improviser.

[36:26] Jimmy: Oh yeah.

[36:26] Tommy: Like that is just the worst thing.

[36:29] Jimmy: Um and to kind of give you that slight handhold there of just like this is the fun that you can have with the stuff.

[36:34] Tommy: And this is what it should feel like.

[36:36] Jimmy: This is what you and like it speaks to Holmes' understanding that like the show starts the moment you start thinking about the show.

[36:42] Tommy: Um, and even like I think the other thing, and this is what I love about Don't Quit While You're Ahead, and There You Are, and is I can't find the best descriptor for it.

[36:51] Jimmy: I've been trying to talk around this.

[36:53] Tommy: Uh at the I made my boyfriend watch some of the clips.

[36:56] Jimmy: Um, and I'm trying to describe this thing I like about it, and I don't have the right words.

[37:00] Tommy: Maybe you can help me.

[37:01] Jimmy: One of the things I love about There You Are is it is you know, it's a double entendre, not in a sexual way.

[37:07] Tommy: It's you know, Bob's your uncle, there you are, right?

[37:10] Jimmy: It's you know, this thing happens, that thing happens, and there you are, right?

[37:14] Tommy: It's just an idiom and a saying of like, and that's what happens.

[37:17] Jimmy: But it is also, as you said, hey, look, you're here in this theater.

[37:22] Tommy: There you are over there, and there you are over there.

[37:25] Jimmy: And like, that's really it's funny to me, not haha funny, but like I find it very ticklish.

[37:31] Tommy: Um tittery.

[37:33] Jimmy: And then the other one that I love, and I wish, you know, I want don't quit while you're ahead to do it just a little more.

[37:40] Tommy: They play into it with the encore, but like it starts just with puffer on stage, and like already already the joke is funny because the idiom isn't don't quit while you're ahead.

[37:51] Jimmy: The idiom is quit while you're ahead.

[37:53] Tommy: Right.

[37:53] Jimmy: And like it's already framed as like, be an idiot, spend your money, you might win more.

[37:59] Tommy: Um, but the whole structure, like from the music to the conceit of the song is like Puffer sings a verse, and then the music goes, bum bum bum bum, and then two more people walk on stage.

[38:12] Jimmy: And then they sing a verse, and then they go bum bum bum bum, and two more people walk on stage.

[38:17] Tommy: And like, I wish I don't know, I wish the music just took a little more pause there.

[38:22] Jimmy: Like it might be done, it might be done.

[38:24] Tommy: Here's another one, still more to do.

[38:26] Jimmy: Right, yeah, yeah, yeah.

[38:27] Tommy: Um and they do do that with the encore because of course this song needs an encore.

[38:31] Jimmy: This song needs like six encores, you know, don't quit while you're ahead.

[38:35] Tommy: One more time.

[38:37] Jimmy: Absolutely, and like it's so funny to me.

[38:40] Tommy: Yeah, again, it just it feeds into that like silly self-referential nonsense.

[38:46] Jimmy: Um, and I think like it just it it creates like a cool kind of magical chemistry um for that show that is then utilized really really well in the voting because yeah, it like it yeah, it's because I remember so obviously from um when I saw it, we had what I think must be the most common outcome.

[39:12] Tommy: Who who won?

[39:13] Jimmy: Um so uh datchery was Bazard.

[39:18] Tommy: Okay.

[39:18] Jimmy: Um because everyone feels sorry for it.

[39:21] Tommy: Right, and you want to give him another song.

[39:23] Jimmy: Exactly, exactly.

[39:24] Tommy: Um the murderer was Rosa because it's kind of the most changing character, do you know what I mean?

[39:34] Jimmy: Um and then the lovers were the dandlesses.

[39:37] Tommy: Okay.

[39:38] Jimmy: Because incest.

[39:39] Tommy: Right, of course.

[39:40] Jimmy: Funny.

[39:40] Tommy: That does mean you missed out.

[39:42] Jimmy: I don't know which version it's in, but uh Bazard has a line if he's not datery when he's like pitching himself as a voter.

[39:52] Tommy: Um I forget exactly what it is.

[39:54] Jimmy: Cause it's all like how it's why would it be him? He doesn't he's such a tiny goddamn character who cares.

[40:00] Tommy: Exactly.

[40:00] Jimmy: He doesn't even do anything.

[40:02] Tommy: Um, but he has he like goes a little crazy.

[40:04] Jimmy: I says, and who knows? I just might sing again.

[40:11] Tommy: It's great.

[40:12] Jimmy: It's so stupid and so funny.

[40:14] Tommy: Yeah.

[40:15] Jimmy: Um, but what I I don't know, I just I'm addicted to the fact that like the actors, like and the fact that it can change, so like the actors are kind of like selling themselves.

[40:28] Tommy: Yeah, I mean like it's like because you know that way in a show, like if you if you see it say three nights in a row, just depending on the different subtle choices that actor makes can completely change the way the audience thinks that is the number one thing my mom loves about high school theatre.

[40:46] Tommy: Um and like any uh you know, when I was in stuff, she'd be like, I'm gonna come Wednesday, Thursday, Friday, Saturday, Saturday, and the topic of discussion when I got him be like, Oh my gosh, did you see so and so almost tripped in that it was why I what a delightful you know the thing she loved was the where's Waldo of it all to like find the subtle difference.

[41:08] Tommy: But I just I just love the fact though, like, and I don't know if this did happen because I've not heard any of them ever say this, but like I love the idea that say Bazar's having an off night, right? Or he's like, I can't really be bothered, or like I'm a bit tired or I want to get out earlier.

[41:22] Jimmy: Yeah, like he then just like holds back a little bit. Right, doesn't sell himself as much. You know what I mean?

[41:29] Tommy: Exactly then but you know, uh it's been a while since uh Jesse Mueller's had her shot. So we're gonna go for her, yeah.

[41:37] Jimmy: Exactly. Or just like depending on who's in that night, because I remember um uh Will Chase uh talked about this in an interview where his kids were in.

[41:46] Tommy: Uh huh.

[41:47] Jimmy: And so they've seen it I think like thirteen or so times um and have seen lots of different things, but one of the things they they never saw, they'd never seen the reverend uh do his uh um confession.

[42:00] Tommy: Uh huh.

[42:01] Jimmy: Uh and so they basically were just like, cause they got to help Will Chase do the bottom um and so they were just like campaigning with things like that.

[42:12] Tommy: Number four, number four.

[42:13] Jimmy: He went on and did it, which is is so good. Because like I don't think I imagine, you know, if that's I would love to see the stats.

[42:20] Tommy: Like I want a bar chart.

[42:22] Jimmy: But I don't doubt that Chris Barker would be really down the bottom just because he's like secondary character that isn't necessarily the funniest.

[42:30] Tommy: Right.

[42:31] Jimmy: It's not such a funny choice. It's also not a really like convincing choice either.

[42:36] Tommy: Yeah, exactly. Exactly.

[42:37] Jimmy: So um I imagine he wouldn't get to do it. So I just love that these kids made that happen and then he got to do it. You know what I mean? It's just there's so much there's so much to it, and there's so many ways that it can be pulled, and yeah, just as an actor, as a director, uh it's just so funny.

[42:56] Tommy: Yeah.

[42:56] Jimmy: Well, and I do love, and I think maybe the thing we're underselling about this show too, is like for all of its meta-theatricality and how much it can like step outside itself and you know really mess around and play around with it, it also turns into a serious play every once in a while.

[43:15] Tommy: Like you know, in there uh no good from can come from bad is tense and like you know Drood's gonna get murdered, and so you're like what it's the parlor dinner scene, you're watching what's happening and who's doing what, or like even how you know beautiful Moonfall is, or even like perfect strangers.

[43:34] Jimmy: Like all of these like in-world play songs, or the whole like opium ballet, um is just you're you're sucked into it, and the fact that the show can like, you know, yank you back and forth between these two worlds without you getting too much whiplash is d is just delightful.

[43:34] Tommy: It is.

[43:34] Jimmy: And the fact that it wasn't written by an experienced book writer. It's just delightful. I just think it's incredible.

[44:06] Tommy: I mean I wonder if that's part of it too. And you know, this is always the problem of making overarching assumptions of our admittedly very tiny art form.

[44:14] Jimmy: But like being, you know, as Holmes is somewhat of an outsider, you're not stuck in concepts of what musical theater is, right?

[44:27] Tommy: Mm-hmm.

[44:27] Jimmy: And so I don't know, it's such I I then go back on that because the whole thing is a love letter to a musical.

[44:34] Tommy: It's a musical, yeah.

[44:35] Jimmy: Right. But then it's it's not and uh I think he does know his stuff.

[44:40] Tommy: Yeah.

[44:42] Jimmy: Maybe he's just cre but 'cause he's not come from a a theater background, you know. I mean, that wasn't how he started. He didn't see into the world wanting to be yeah a musical theater composer.

[44:52] Tommy: Right.

[44:52] Jimmy: And maybe just having that way in allows you to be to tackle it a bit differently.

[44:57] Tommy: Yeah.

[44:57] Jimmy: In a similar way that um I I guess like contemporary example, like a similar way that Sarah Bareilles came out the score with waitress, like it does have a very fresh yeah sound for the most part.

[45:09] Tommy: Yeah um and that's because she isn't directly embedded in the musical theater composing scene.

[45:18] Jimmy: Do you know I mean it doesn't have that yeah, you know, contemporary Broadway sounds.

[45:22] Tommy: It it is there I was because there's nothing to do these days, and I was watching a whole bunch of um, you know, YouTube documentary think pieces, um as I do.

[45:33] Jimmy: And there's a statement in one of 'em that I loved about animation. Um it was some interview with someone who I didn't recognize, so my apologies.

[45:42] Tommy: Uh the whole thing was about Ratatouille.

[45:44] Jimmy: Um but the it was very cool. The the framing quote was I'm sick of people calling animation a genre.

[45:51] Tommy: Animation is an art form but not necessarily a genre.

[45:56] Jimmy: And animation can contain any kind of genre. You can make a Western animation, you can make a soap opera animation, you can make a mystery animation.

[46:04] Tommy: And I do think, and I think we fall into this trap too, that musical theater is an art form and not a genre.

[46:10] Jimmy: Um or may like straddles it in an interesting way.

[46:14] Tommy: But it does I think it is, yeah, completely.

[46:17] Jimmy: It does speak to that. Through the only reason I hedged that a bit is because this show portrays an English music hall as a genre, not as an art form, you know?

[46:27] Tommy: Um, and there are parodies of musical theater that do successfully paint it as a genre, not as an art form.

[46:35] Jimmy: Between, you know, well you you pull out the spangles and the kick lines and the top hats, and it becomes a genre again, not an art form.

[46:42] Tommy: So it there's an interesting relationship there that this show and a lot of other shows, but this show especially plays with and like takes advantage of how it goes back and forth between genre and art form.

[46:54] Jimmy: Yeah.

[46:56] Tommy: That is quite interesting. I guess like that almost plays on the like when it gets to the genre factor, like is that genre created out of stereotype?

[47:07] Jimmy: Right.

[47:07] Tommy: Isn't it? I mean, is that the the source of that or is that literally the the kind of um what do you call that thing that spends centrifuged pellet of musical theater?

[47:21] Jimmy: Exactly.

[47:21] Tommy: Well and it is in Kick Claims.

[47:23] Jimmy: Exactly. It's the it's the same thing uh uh we were kind of talking about in maybe it was a s a strange loop, it was either last time or Joseph.

[47:30] Tommy: Um but that this kind of like manufactured nostalgia, um you know, like this fake nostalgia, and it's all over this show.

[47:38] Jimmy: Like this is like no one knows what a music hall is these days.

[47:43] Tommy: Right.

[47:44] Jimmy: You know, no one's been to one. You might have touchstones for it, you might accept it as something is truth, but you don't know that this is what it was like, but the show convinces you that you remember what it was like.

[47:55] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.

[47:56] Jimmy: Well, I the thing that kind of obviously baffles me, obviously being British is so much of it as like steeped in like pantomime as well, and just the fact of having like your um primary boy like being a pants rolling a female, yeah.

[48:13] Tommy: Um like that isn't at the core of US theater.

[48:19] Jimmy: Genuine that isn't how US theater began, that's very much how UK theater began.

[48:23] Tommy: Yeah.

[48:23] Jimmy: But a US audience looks at that and gets it.

[48:26] Tommy: Yeah.

[48:26] Jimmy: And I th and I do think it is because it does it because it feels separate, and that does, you know, that's the part that that takes you by surprise and kind of opens up that doorway for you to go on that journey tonight.

[48:39] Tommy: Like, if the show started with, you know, house lights down, drum roll, spotlight up on stage on chairman, I think it would be less successful.

[48:49] Jimmy: Um they're not they're not using the entire theater as the setting for the piece.

[48:56] Tommy: They're using they're falling into our uh accepted contrivance of the stage and the proscenium and the fourth wall being gone.

[49:05] Jimmy: Um but because you know, I'm uh sitting in the lap of a most engaging chap somewhere in the aisle, now everyone's in on the show.

[49:16] Tommy: Exactly.

[49:16] Jimmy: And is it a show or is it just a game, right? Like that's the the delightful question of the evening.

[49:24] Tommy: How much of this is planned? Does my vote count?

[49:27] Jimmy: You know?

[49:27] Tommy: Yes.

[49:28] Jimmy: Yeah exactly. The answer is yes.

[49:30] Tommy: Yeah.

[49:30] Jimmy: And i is that's also quite an interesting one because you like I could have told you who was going to win that night.

[49:38] Tommy: Yeah.

[49:39] Jimmy: Just based on literally the volume of appla of a pause and like who's getting the most laughs.

[49:45] Tommy: Who is you know I mean who is it that night that is kind of winning.

[49:48] Jimmy: Yeah.

[49:48] Tommy: Um and I think that is is so cool that it is like like i it is created by an atmosphere.

[49:55] Jimmy: Yeah.

[49:55] Tommy: Um I think that's just so fun.

[49:58] Jimmy: It's so fun. This must be such a fun show to be a part of.

[50:02] Tommy: I do think so if in kind of a different tone, but we talk about you know those God spells, those Pippins, the shows where companies become something greater than themselves.

[50:12] Jimmy: Yeah yeah.

[50:13] Tommy: And I do think kind of with a different flavor but the same idea, this is one of those shows as well I would imagine I would I wouldn't be surprised either just because like you know that way like is especially with anything improved the trust that you need trust is so so strong.

[50:30] Jimmy: So that just that kind of internal bond that you have to have with with every player um yeah I can see that a hundred percent being being the case um with this one which is nice isn't it?

[50:42] Tommy: Yeah it's nice when you can when you find those shows.

[50:44] Jimmy: And it is, you know, I think perhaps as we talked at the very very beginning. What is delightful about this one is it is so self-indulgent that the question is where is the upper limit to the self-indulgence?

[50:56] Tommy: And there might not be one, maybe, but it's way up there.

[51:02] Jimmy: You know, on a on a show that capitalizes on mugging for the audience.

[51:07] Tommy: How exactly as long as it's funny, you could keep on mugging.

[51:11] Jimmy: That's it. Keep on mugging.

[51:15] Tommy: That's a song.

[51:16] Jimmy: Is it really?

[51:17] Tommy: Well, keep on keep on running, keep on trucking.

[51:20] Jimmy: It's not keep on mugging.

[51:22] Tommy: It's not a recruiting song for um miscreants.

[51:26] Jimmy: Uh no, it's not.

[51:28] Tommy: But keep on mugging. I don't know. I feel that could be a good parody.

[51:31] Jimmy: Isn't that a song cut from Oliver?

[51:33] Tommy: Keep on mugging.

[51:34] Jimmy: I guess they're they're pickpockets, not muggers.

[51:37] Tommy: Yeah.

[51:40] Jimmy: Cool.

[51:43] Tommy: Glance is cut like plate to bone like daggers drawn.

[51:48] Jimmy: Dare presume to stare it.

[51:49] Tommy: Who might make my weapon share my lap and see you date with boss we're so wet?

[51:54] Jimmy: It tweets near.

[51:55] Tommy: I feel it, I fear it.

[51:57] Jimmy: We are friends, and yet, we'll not soon forget.

[52:01] Tommy: Hearing there's let every athlete.

[52:05] Jimmy: In younger days, I hungered for another.

[52:08] Tommy: Rosa's mother.

[52:11] Jimmy: After Rose's birth, she left this earth.

[52:13] Tommy: Now dust is all I'm worth.

[52:15] Jimmy: Too long a time they thought that I'm addressed in doll quite naive.

[52:20] Tommy: But I perceive these boys, this noise harm brain than they might conceive.

[52:35] Jimmy: With these new indications, they may be revealed.

[52:38] Tommy: Murderous indication.

[52:56] Jimmy: So, hey.

[52:58] Tommy: It's not perfect.

[53:00] Jimmy: No.

[53:00] Tommy: It's a shape.

[53:01] Jimmy: It's tricky.

[53:02] Tommy: It's so it's such a it's such a fucking shame.

[53:06] Jimmy: Yeah, it's disappointing.

[53:07] Tommy: But then also like not without hope.

[53:11] Jimmy: Sure.

[53:12] Tommy: Yeah. Right?

[53:13] Jimmy: Yeah.

[53:14] Tommy: So, um hope remains while the company is true.

[53:17] Jimmy: Yeah.

[53:18] Tommy: Lord of the Rings. Get out of here.

[53:20] Jimmy: Um, two characters in the show.

[53:22] Tommy: Uh the the characters in the interplay, Helena Landis and Neville Landis, siblings.

[53:29] Jimmy: Yeah.

[53:30] Tommy: Um are f from uh what's it called? Ceylon.

[53:34] Jimmy: Yeah, which is Sri Lanka which is colonized Sri Lanka.

[53:38] Tommy: Um, you know, South Indian.

[53:42] Jimmy: Um as you would imagine uh productions don't have the best track record of dealing with this role.

[53:57] Tommy: Um the 2012-2013 revival put who was it? Um Jesse Miller and Andy Carl.

[54:02] Jimmy: Jesse Mueller and Andy Carl in Brownface.

[54:04] Tommy: Um to the point where even recently when I because like, you know, I'm just I hadn't been thinking about these things the first time I listened through to the show.

[54:16] Jimmy: Um, and I'm bad with actor names.

[54:18] Tommy: Um, and I had this thought doing research for this one, it's like, Andy Carl's in this? Who does he play?

[54:24] Tommy: Right?

[54:24] Jimmy: Exactly.

[54:25] Tommy: Um, which is a bad sign.

[54:27] Jimmy: It's a bad sign.

[54:29] Tommy: Yeah.

[54:30] Jimmy: Um, and there is a lot of we'll put some links in the show notes. Like uh uh Roundabout Theater Roundabout, yeah, um, was called out for this in its own time.

[54:39] Tommy: Um I think in a way that would have been bigger news in 2020 than perhaps it was in 2013, which of course speaks to the ongoing uh uh uh blindness and racism problems of Broadway and the theater community at large, for sure.

[54:56] Jimmy: Absolutely, absolutely.

[54:57] Tommy: And I think like I I've seen people make really, really good points that you know where these uh African American or Afro-Caribbean are just black characters, they would there would be no question that that would ever be performed in blackface.

[55:16] Jimmy: Right, yeah.

[55:17] Tommy: So why is it yeah for it to be done in brown face?

[55:21] Jimmy: Yeah, and it is like it's not it's not wrinkly, but the counter argument is that this is not a you know, because of the meta theatrical nature of this piece, these are performers in a late 1800s music hall performing these roles, and uh and it's it's frustrating because Holmes writes in there's a whole uh uh page of notes about it in the current script about how this is how it would be performed, right?

[55:55] Tommy: And it's frustrating because he's he's not wrong in his historical assessment of this piece.

[56:04] Jimmy: But musical theater, like we're not aiming for historical accuracy here.

[56:11] Tommy: No, not at all.

[56:11] Jimmy: No, it's and it the whole thing is a a parody, the whole thing is a melodramatic prestige.

[56:17] Tommy: Exactly.

[56:18] Jimmy: Musical.

[56:18] Tommy: Yeah.

[56:19] Jimmy: That isn't, you know, people aren't in it for the, you know, historical accuracy.

[56:25] Tommy: Exactly.

[56:26] Jimmy: No.

[56:26] Tommy: And in in the same way that like I think nowadays, to your comparison, you'd have to push pretty hard to argue for a contemporary portrayal of blackface on stage, right?

[56:38] Jimmy: I mean, it just would never be allowed.

[56:40] Tommy: It would never be allowed.

[56:41] Jimmy: Even if we're talking about something that is absolutely historically accurate.

[56:45] Tommy: Yeah.

[56:46] Jimmy: And like people are so much quicker to be like, oh yeah, no, no, no. So again, you know, you get the the model minority yellowface brown face problem of Asian portrayal on Broadway, which we've seen and a bunch of stuff. And I think, you know, you you wrote this in, but it's especially disappointing because of the potential power that these roles have in the context of the play.

[57:13] Tommy: Absolutely.

[57:14] Jimmy: Like yeah, that's the thing is um out of nowhere, so the song um a British subject like it's that's the thing is like it that's why it's so disappointing with the revival because you can tell it's playing on their mind.

[57:24] Tommy: Right.

[57:25] Jimmy: You can tell they're thinking because they added so in the in the original they had a a song called I Say It Wrong, what Celon?

[57:31] Tommy: Ceylon.

[57:31] Jimmy: Ceylon.

[57:33] Tommy: Just that song.

[57:33] Jimmy: And then they re-added in the song A British Subject for the Revival, which was originally part but was not in did not make the original production.

[57:41] Tommy: The original Broadway, yeah.

[57:42] Jimmy: And Ceylon was just more kind of more extended and just kind of filled with let's name places from South Asia.

[57:48] Tommy: Right.

[57:48] Jimmy: Oh, how how exotic, how different, blah blah blah.

[57:51] Tommy: Right, right, exactly.

[57:52] Jimmy: Whereas what's despite with a British subject is it's like a commentary on c colonialism in you know the 19th century.

[58:01] Tommy: Yeah.

[58:02] Jimmy: Like it's uh which also then has like weird, interesting connotations with emigration nowadays.

[58:08] Tommy: Yeah.

[58:08] Jimmy: You know what I mean? Like there's these really quite nuanced notes in it.

[58:13] Tommy: Yeah.

[58:13] Jimmy: But it's kind of all thrown to shit when the characters performing it are white.

[58:19] Tommy: Right.

[58:19] Jimmy: Yeah.

[58:20] Tommy: Like you totally shit on your, you know, it's the same problem we kind of get with um uh Millie nowadays. Is like Millie is so close to being this interesting commentary on racism of the time.

[58:35] Tommy: Yes.

[58:36] Jimmy: But it doesn't make it.

[58:38] Tommy: And not at all.

[58:39] Jimmy: Because of the performative nature of this and the way some of this stuff is framed, instead it becomes somehow worse.

[58:46] Tommy: Yeah.

[58:47] Jimmy: Like I mean better off not drinking.

[58:49] Tommy: Yeah, you're going so close.

[58:51] Jimmy: So you're away, that's that thing.

[58:52] Tommy: It's like you have the awareness, you know there's this isn't right.

[58:55] Jimmy: Right.

[58:55] Tommy: So therefore, um yeah, it's it's interesting because like I've read a few things now, um, and again, like we'll link a couple of articles and things of of people um who are South Asian and big music theater fans, sometimes big fans of Druid itself.

[59:09] Jimmy: Yeah.

[59:10] Tommy: Um just talking about the fact like it you don't need to do it.

[59:14] Jimmy: Right.

[59:14] Tommy: There's nothing there's nothing in the show, and and in fact, even in the script, um in the recent um producible version of it, um, they've taken out like the one line that Neville Landless says about the colour of his skin.

[59:28] Jimmy: Right.

[59:28] Tommy: Um to allow you to have white actors being white.

[59:34] Jimmy: Which circumstances of your own.

[59:35] Tommy: Absolutely, and and if we're talking about like maintaining historical accuracy, also is an entirely plausible explanation of these two characters in the time that Dickens is writing, right? Like you're you're, you know, it's so entrenched in this idea that they can't see the forest for the trees.

[59:59] Jimmy: Right, exactly.

[1:00:00] Tommy: And it's so uh yeah, like nothing nothing would be detracted for sure if it was just you know another two white characters on stage.

[1:00:08] Jimmy: Right.

[1:00:09] Tommy: But also it would be in a way quite good if they gave the opportunity for South Asian actors to play South Asian people.

[1:00:18] Jimmy: What a w what a crazy idea.

[1:00:19] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:00:20] Jimmy: Right, exactly.

[1:00:20] Tommy: But also just in a very interesting time when it was to be South Asian because of colonialism.

[1:00:27] Jimmy: You know what I mean?

[1:00:27] Tommy: Absolutely.

[1:00:28] Jimmy: There's no musicals about that.

[1:00:31] Tommy: And it is the as uh uh a British subject, you know, lays out, like they're grappling with this stuff in in the show.

[1:00:40] Jimmy: Like it's it's in context for sure to then blow straight past it when you know Holmes is on record saying, like, yeah, it's not Dickens, it's this, whatever, right?

[1:00:53] Tommy: Why is this the thing?

[1:00:55] Jimmy: Exact exactly, exactly.

[1:00:56] Tommy: There's there's no excuse for it.

[1:00:58] Jimmy: There just really isn't.

[1:00:59] Tommy: And I think like it's uh the fact is 2020, like it's it's crazy that that but then I guess the the thing that always baffles me is that like, well, we just had Aladdin.

[1:01:10] Jimmy: I mean, yeah, show me all the South Asian uh actors there.

[1:01:13] Tommy: Exactly, and like Aladdin, especially Disney Aladdin, which is always this like weird kind of mm Middle Eastern Americanized pastiche of this fantasy bullshit, like you know, it's already problematic from its inception.

[1:01:28] Jimmy: Yeah, you know.

[1:01:29] Tommy: It's just it's frustrating.

[1:01:31] Jimmy: It and it's especially frustrating given uh how m you know how much we praise Rupert Holmes at the beginning of this and like him being okay with the adaptability and the flexibility of some of this, like but then this is the one that stuck around, like Yeah, I think that I find it quite interesting.

[1:01:48] Tommy: Like I obviously we don't know the conversations that happen behind closed doors at you know he didn't cast it.

[1:01:55] Jimmy: Right.

[1:01:56] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:01:57] Jimmy: And he didn't direct it.

[1:01:58] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:01:59] Jimmy: Um was it the the fact that you know the director was like, No, this is how I want this to be done because X, or was it like you know, we need big names, Jesse Mueller very up and coming, Andy Carl very, very up and coming.

[1:02:14] Tommy: Yeah, you know, like let's get these guys in as our supporting roles, right?

[1:02:19] Jimmy: That would be fantastic.

[1:02:20] Tommy: Like it sure, because I don't think there's a South Asian equivalent.

[1:02:26] Jimmy: Right.

[1:02:26] Tommy: Right.

[1:02:27] Jimmy: Not at the other story.

[1:02:29] Tommy: Not in a casting director's mind at the time, certainly.

[1:02:32] Jimmy: Exactly, exactly.

[1:02:33] Tommy: Um so I can see that being the thing, but it's a shame that I've never seen him talk about it as a problem.

[1:02:41] Jimmy: Yeah.

[1:02:41] Tommy: That's that's the frustrating thing.

[1:02:42] Jimmy: And I do think, you know, in this uh uh as as we enter a a post George Floyd era, um the theater community does seem very much to be moving towards a if you see something say something model which is much better than it's been.

[1:03:03] Tommy: Um because certainly, you know, interproducer cast casting politics, like there's a world where there might have been plenty of people who saw problems with this who didn't speak up for fear of their careers or whatever, and you know, we're now and landing on a place where like that's not an acceptable place to be in anymore.

[1:03:21] Jimmy: Um which is a great sign of the times.

[1:03:24] Tommy: It is frustrating to see, you know what, this was seven years ago, not that long ago.

[1:03:28] Jimmy: Right, exactly.

[1:03:29] Tommy: And Aladdin was even closer than that.

[1:03:32] Jimmy: So um yeah, so uh you know, the next production of Druid that comes on.

[1:03:38] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:03:39] Jimmy: You know, if you're doing it in your high school, like I think I don't know, I guess I wonder what yours what your opinion on this is, and it's because it's such so mired in a history, like I have changed my opinion on all white schools producing umce on this island in the past couple months.

[1:03:56] Tommy: Um I don't think they should anymore.

[1:03:59] Jimmy: Right, yeah, yeah, yeah.

[1:04:00] Tommy: Which I've I would have argued the exact opposite and very well may have, um in the past.

[1:04:06] Jimmy: This one is I don't know, I'd I'm more curious about it too, because it's a popular high school show, for sure.

[1:04:13] Tommy: Um and high school theater departments, you know, for worse, absolutely run white, um, which is a huge problem in this country.

[1:04:20] Jimmy: Uh that's interesting.

[1:04:21] Tommy: Uh, because I was quite fortunate um in my high school that it was uh very diverse, very multicultural, and even within our theater department as well.

[1:04:30] Jimmy: Um which is great.

[1:04:32] Tommy: Uh so like uh I don't think that our director would have ever put white people in brown face.

[1:04:42] Jimmy: Right.

[1:04:43] Tommy: Because we have plenty of actors of Asian descent.

[1:04:48] Jimmy: You've got a casting pool, yeah.

[1:04:50] Tommy: Right, exactly.

[1:04:51] Jimmy: Um that it would be ridiculous.

[1:04:55] Tommy: Like that would be ridiculous, that would be flat out offensive because you've got, you know, I mean, it's that thing.

[1:05:01] Jimmy: Yeah.

[1:05:03] Tommy: It's like, well, you've got people there.

[1:05:03] Jimmy: Yeah.

[1:05:03] Tommy: Why aren't you putting them in the spotlight?

[1:05:06] Jimmy: Um I I I think that the scenario I want to present, because this is a show where you you could conceivably have have both options, right?

[1:05:15] Tommy: Mm-hmm.

[1:05:16] Jimmy: You cast white characters in this role, and with the the appropriate sensitivity, probably be just fine.

[1:05:24] Tommy: I because of the landscape of you know, high school and amateur theater and casting pools and things like that, you know.

[1:05:31] Jimmy: Picture this.

[1:05:32] Tommy: You want to do Edwin Drude.

[1:05:34] Jimmy: Um you've got two appropriately castable South Asian actors who are auditioning, right?

[1:05:41] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:05:43] Jimmy: Can are you pre-casting them in these roles?

[1:05:47] Tommy: Or could you make one of them Jasper, right?

[1:05:50] Jimmy: And like I the the obvious right correct answer is yes.

[1:05:56] Tommy: Absolutely.

[1:05:57] Jimmy: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

[1:05:58] Tommy: But I see so many I yeah, I see this all the time in, you know, my peers who I know work in high school is my experience with high school theater across the country.

[1:06:07] Jimmy: Like, you I s I saw high school doomie because they knew they had two vaguely Asian characters who could play the two Asian characters.

[1:06:15] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:06:16] Jimmy: Um like it's it's tokenizing, it is, you know, somewhat dehumanizing, it perpetuates the continual problem with these things, you know.

[1:06:25] Tommy: And I don't doubt that it's so frustrating for the kids.

[1:06:28] Jimmy: Yeah.

[1:06:29] Tommy: Like I'm gonna play the Asian character.

[1:06:31] Jimmy: God damn it, right?

[1:06:32] Tommy: You know, why can't I play the other role?

[1:06:35] Jimmy: Um, you know, like I I don't see, and maybe I'm not looking in the right places, but like I don't know where else to look.

[1:06:45] Tommy: Every every high school that's not happening right now is doing some diversity and inclusion Zoom workshop right now.

[1:06:51] Jimmy: And these aren't conversations that are happening which is frustrating because it's the national discourse right now.

[1:06:56] Tommy: Absolutely.

[1:06:57] Jimmy: And like we gotta look at it. It's it's it's again it's such a gift that amateur um groups have um and that they don't need to work with casting directors who are thinking about clout.

[1:07:08] Tommy: Right.

[1:07:08] Jimmy: Um I think Lynn Manuel goes on record a lot saying like where in the world could like a young skinny Latin American boy play Tevier.

[1:07:18] Tommy: Right.

[1:07:18] Jimmy: You know what I mean?

[1:07:19] Tommy: Like that's the joy of of having these opportunities when you're in yeah high school or amateur dramatics companies.

[1:07:26] Jimmy: But w flipped flipped on its head we still find problems.

[1:07:28] Tommy: I mean the the contemporary hairspray drama of the the script previously having uh provisions in it for non black actors to portray the black characters and just got removed 'cause that's usually problematic.

[1:07:42] Jimmy: I of course it is.

[1:07:44] Tommy: You know, this is the it's a minefield.

[1:07:46] Jimmy: Um and I'm I'm happy that I I think everyone's reckoning with it now.

[1:07:54] Tommy: Um I'm I'm sad that it you know I remember feeling uncomfortable when I student taught and they cast the two Asian kids in Millie.

[1:08:04] Tommy: Um but I'm not gonna speak up to my cooperating teacher, right?

[1:08:09] Jimmy: Exactly, yeah you have to be complicit in these things.

[1:08:11] Tommy: And you know the same way that um I I don't doubt there were people in that cast who did not feel comfortable.

[1:08:17] Jimmy: Right.

[1:08:18] Tommy: You know what I mean? I d I I again you they wouldn't see well they might say I don't know um against it but how comfortable would oh yeah Jesse Mueller feel putting on a really thick indeterminate South Asian accent.

[1:08:34] Jimmy: I think and and like at what point should Jesse Mueller say no.

[1:08:40] Tommy: I precisely because she wasn't Jesse Mueller at that point.

[1:08:43] Jimmy: Right, exactly she evil hadn't happened.

[1:08:46] Tommy: Yep.

[1:08:46] Jimmy: Yeah.

[1:08:47] Tommy: And I'm not saying I'm not saying like so you know Jesse's like therefore she's a demon then she sold out like absolutely not but i i it just I I mean I guess it just shows you like I can't see her standing by that happening now.

[1:08:59] Jimmy: Right.

[1:09:00] Tommy: And it's it's how much of a reckoning it's how deep this shit goes, right?

[1:09:05] Jimmy: Yeah.

[1:09:05] Tommy: And how ingrained it all is all the way back to Charles Dickens, right?

[1:09:11] Jimmy: And the show shows that.

[1:09:13] Tommy: Um i and why it you know it is a huge unpacking and like as much as we do couch these things in like well there's systems in place that are holding people down then like maybe but these days that's a bullshit excuse.

[1:09:29] Jimmy: If you see something say something right and you know I don't think like I did I haven't done a granular uh search of Jesse or Andy's Twitter yet, but it's the sort of thing where yeah maybe you should say something nowadays.

[1:09:46] Tommy: Like we're uh we are all atoning for our sins.

[1:09:49] Jimmy: Exactly.

[1:09:49] Tommy: And it's and it's signs of growth and you know every everyone should really I honestly believe that for sure.

[1:09:58] Jimmy: Um what I will say though, that revival cast was sensational.

[1:10:03] Tommy: I know.

[1:10:04] Jimmy: It's it's the frustrating thing about it is they did a really good job.

[1:10:07] Tommy: Getting to see getting to see Tisa Rivera performing on the stage.

[1:10:11] Jimmy: I'm sure is like a box ticked.

[1:10:14] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:10:14] Jimmy: Also, so yeah, she was 80, and she was doing higher kicks than anyone else on the stage.

[1:10:20] Tommy: Of course, like you're the best person.

[1:10:22] Jimmy: Because also, I have to commend her British accent.

[1:10:27] Tommy: It's very good.

[1:10:28] Jimmy: Yeah.

[1:10:29] Tommy: That is good Cockney.

[1:10:30] Jimmy: Like it wasn't overplayed.

[1:10:32] Tommy: I wondered what you thought about as as you know, a a Brit watching Americans do British, how overall because we've talked about this before, how sometimes it's really shitty.

[1:10:44] Jimmy: Yes, Billy Elliott.

[1:10:45] Tommy: Um yeah, some a a lot of time it's really, really bad.

[1:10:50] Jimmy: Yeah.

[1:10:51] Tommy: Just get you Rivera to do it, mate.

[1:10:54] Jimmy: I was really impressed.

[1:10:55] Tommy: I was honestly really, really impressed.

[1:10:57] Jimmy: Um, they all they all did. I mean, the thing is like I feel like the RP English is a lot easier to do than Cockney, just because Cockney's filled with so much nuance.

[1:11:05] Tommy: Sure.

[1:11:06] Jimmy: Um, so that's why I was just so impressed with her specifically.

[1:11:13] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:11:13] Jimmy: It was great.

[1:11:14] Tommy: Great performance.

[1:11:15] Jimmy: So good.

[1:11:16] Tommy: So many good performances.

[1:11:17] Jimmy: Stephanie J. Block.

[1:11:18] Tommy: Oh.

[1:11:19] Jimmy: So delightful.

[1:11:20] Tommy: Yeah, let's do some Stephanie J talk.

[1:11:22] Jimmy: Um Yeah, exactly.

[1:11:23] Tommy: We'll get a stain.

[1:11:25] Jimmy: I mean, I do think the thing that is just delightful about this show is because it is so bawdy, because it is so indulgent, you could get these great performers in it, and they could do a uh more than halfway decent job at baseline.

[1:11:40] Tommy: And the the 2012 production is delightful.

[1:11:44] Jimmy: Like, no one is at their baseline.

[1:11:47] Tommy: The it is filled to the brim with subtlety and nuance, and that just creates I'm sure I imagine for a rip roaring night.

[1:11:59] Jimmy: Oh, it was so fun.

[1:12:01] Tommy: Like it Yeah, just had the best the best time.

[1:12:06] Jimmy: Like it was yeah kind of surprisingly so because I remember going in and obviously having only listened to it once.

[1:12:13] Tommy: Sure.

[1:12:14] Jimmy: But I think if you just if you just listen through it, not really understanding the voting side and how that all works.

[1:12:19] Tommy: Yeah, it's not the most impressive.

[1:12:21] Jimmy: You're not like wow, this music's even yeah, we haven't even gone into the plot of actual Edwin Drude, which is so complicated, it's like barely worth talking about.

[1:12:30] Tommy: Right, exactly, exactly.

[1:12:31] Jimmy: And a lot of the times, like, although the songs are driving the plot, they're not like plot filled, if that makes sense.

[1:12:36] Tommy: Right.

[1:12:37] Jimmy: Like a lot of it is contained just in the book itself.

[1:12:39] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:12:39] Jimmy: Um and yeah, it's I think it exists so much in that night.

[1:12:46] Tommy: Like, I don't know, it was just such a such a great time.

[1:12:49] Tommy: Out of interest, do you know um Jim Norton, who he plays the um the mayor?

[1:12:55] Jimmy: Oh not offhand, no.

[1:12:57] Tommy: Who is he?

[1:12:58] Jimmy: So he is like it was so funny because I remember watching it and just being like, I know exactly who you are, who are you?

[1:13:05] Tommy: You know, right.

[1:13:06] Jimmy: Watch, watch, watch it.

[1:13:07] Tommy: So he um for the Brits listening um played uh Bishop Brennan in uh come over here called Father Ted.

[1:13:17] Jimmy: Oh, I know Father Ted, okay.

[1:13:19] Tommy: Oh, do you?

[1:13:20] Jimmy: Yeah, j uh just as uh a cultural touchstone, not very much.

[1:13:24] Tommy: Okay.

[1:13:25] Jimmy: I mean, definitely get a watch because it's seminal comedy, like absolutely.

[1:13:30] Tommy: Um particularly with a Catholic upbringing, so you have many things to think about.

[1:13:35] Jimmy: Um but yeah, so he plays this this cat and I was like, oh my gosh, and he's a very, very good actor.

[1:13:42] Tommy: Like and it has done quite a lot of other uh stuff in the certainly British theatre, British TV.

[1:13:46] Jimmy: Um but yeah, just even down to that, I was like, that is crazy that you're there, and then so is Will Chase and so is definitely you know I mean like it's just uh medley.

[1:13:56] Tommy: Just a uh an all-star medley um of joy.

[1:14:01] Jimmy: Yeah, and I feel very uh lucky that I got to see it.

[1:14:05] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:14:05] Jimmy: It does sound delightful.

[1:14:06] Tommy: Well, and it is even you know, re-listening it to it a bunch recently.

[1:14:11] Jimmy: This thing we've described as being like very fluffy and very inconsequential in its conceit.

[1:14:17] Tommy: But I was it was just I I was making my way through it maybe for the last time last night.

[1:14:22] Jimmy: Um so much of this show is witty wordplay and not much more.

[1:14:28] Tommy: But listening to writing on the wall for the last time, um, like there's a beautiful part and Stephanie J. Block delivers it wonderfully.

[1:14:39] Jimmy: Like if you hear my voice, then you're alive. What a bloody marvel we survive. What do you think of every risk we face in our mad human race?

[1:14:47] Tommy: Is like one I'm finding more of these lyrics in the things I enjoy that like two years ago would be like, huh, what a what a uh fluffy uh idiom uh about the how happy life is.

[1:15:00] Jimmy: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

[1:15:01] Tommy: And nowadays I'm like, yeah, wow, it is wild that like we haven't we're still alive.

[1:15:08] Jimmy: Exactly.

[1:15:08] Tommy: And especially with Stephanie J Blocks and Bel De Brogue behind it.

[1:15:12] Jimmy: Oh yeah.

[1:15:12] Tommy: You know, what are the kids what do the kids say like it hits different now?

[1:15:16] Jimmy: Um Yeah, yeah, yeah.

[1:15:18] Tommy: Um I mean honestly that like I think the writing on the wall, the finale version is is a really good like shorten.

[1:15:25] Jimmy: Yeah.

[1:15:25] Tommy: It's really, really good.

[1:15:26] Jimmy: And it's even like when the chorus creep in with the ooze and the build up.

[1:15:29] Tommy: Yeah.

[1:15:30] Jimmy: Right to that final that final.

[1:15:33] Tommy: Um just it's so good.

[1:15:36] Jimmy: In a show that could have just sung off to the races again, and it would have been hilarious and appropriate and done, right?

[1:15:44] Tommy: Which they do after bows, but like they could have just end with like, we figured it out!

[1:15:48] Jimmy: Oh one, two, three, off to the river.

[1:15:50] Tommy: They could have.

[1:15:51] Jimmy: But instead, we get this, you know, wonderful anthem of a march about like how delightful it is to be alive.

[1:15:59] Tommy: And we've left Dickens so far behind.

[1:16:02] Jimmy: Yeah.

[1:16:03] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.

[1:16:04] Jimmy: So that song ain't going anywhere.

[1:16:06] Tommy: Hopefully, the racism does in any future productions.

[1:16:10] Jimmy: Yeah.

[1:16:11] Tommy: I'd write to hey, right to Concord Theatricals or whoever is your your uh local Amdram and say they need to revise their script.

[1:16:19] Jimmy: You know, get exactly just say don't do it.

[1:16:22] Tommy: Yeah, get get Holmes back on the phone again and be like, Hey, oh okay.

[1:16:25] Jimmy: Well I think that we're st we did it, we did the wrong time to do the right now.

[1:16:29] Tommy: Exactly.

[1:16:29] Jimmy: Let's fix it.

[1:16:30] Tommy: Exactly.

[1:16:31] Jimmy: Um because it's a good show and it's a show that should be performed.

[1:16:35] Tommy: Yeah, I think it is I do find as as we enter our reproblematizing of everything that's ever been written, you know, what are we cancelling and what are we not cancelling?

[1:16:45] Jimmy: Right, right, right, right.

[1:16:46] Tommy: Like I do think it is worth it to look in things and be like, what is uh, you know, don't frame it as what are we cancelling, but like what's salvageable? What can we, you know, what can exact go past this moment um alongside all the new stuff we should be making.

[1:17:01] Jimmy: For sure.

[1:17:01] Tommy: Exactly.

[1:17:02] Jimmy: I would I would argue that we should be elevating.

[1:17:04] Tommy: Right, exactly.

[1:17:05] Jimmy: I would argue that Drude can let's let's keep it going.

[1:17:08] Tommy: Let's find a way to to fix this and still honor what it is.

[1:17:13] Tommy: Is it clear?

[1:17:15] Jimmy: If you hear my voice, then you're alive.

[1:17:20] Tommy: What a bloody marvel.

[1:17:23] Jimmy: We survive.

[1:17:25] Tommy: When you think of every risk we face in our mash human race.

[1:17:34] Jimmy: I have a rate for I to not fall.

[1:17:38] Tommy: Try to live forever and give up ever the fight.

[1:17:43] Jimmy: You need the well before.

[1:17:46] Tommy: Can't you hear me?

[1:17:50] Jimmy: As I play to read the right.

[1:18:19] Tommy: The mystery of Edwin Drood.

[1:18:24] Jimmy: Why do they gavel?

[1:18:26] Tommy: I never understood.

[1:18:27] Jimmy: And they don't do it on the recording.

[1:18:30] Tommy: I mean, is that a musical thing?

[1:18:33] Jimmy: Yeah.

[1:18:34] Tommy: Actually, it probably is.

[1:18:35] Jimmy: Yeah.

[1:18:36] Tommy: That's not something you just do.

[1:18:39] Jimmy: But it could be.

[1:18:40] Tommy: That's the that's the thing.

[1:18:41] Jimmy: That's the thing about this musical.

[1:18:42] Tommy: I totally believe it.

[1:18:44] Jimmy: You know, like the um the philistry in Midsummer Night's Dream.

[1:18:47] Tommy: I feel like that's something he would do.

[1:18:49] Jimmy: Yeah.

[1:18:50] Tommy: Right.

[1:18:50] Jimmy: Perhaps.

[1:18:51] Tommy: That's a reference.

[1:18:54] Jimmy: Hey, Philistrates aside.

[1:18:57] Tommy: Wanna know what's next.

[1:18:59] Jimmy: I'm so excited to hear your quiz question.

[1:19:00] Tommy: But first, let me take a philostrates aside as I talk.

[1:19:03] Jimmy: No.

[1:19:04] Tommy: Um, I see what you were doing.

[1:19:07] Jimmy: Yeah, I shouldn't have pursued that joke.

[1:19:08] Tommy: It wasn't it was a bad bit.

[1:19:10] Jimmy: That was a Shakespeare quote uh joke.

[1:19:12] Tommy: Shakespeare joke that you were doing there.

[1:19:14] Jimmy: Thank you, thank you.

[1:19:15] Tommy: As we dissect this frog.

[1:19:17] Jimmy: Um I'll I'll carry all the quiz questions there, shall I?

[1:19:21] Tommy: Um okay, so hey, Chance the Rapper recently sought inspiration uh from perhaps one of the most unlikely of places.

[1:19:34] Jimmy: Uh and that was one of the songs in this golden age musical.

[1:19:40] Tommy: What's musical is that?

[1:19:43] Jimmy: Chance the Rapper's from Chicago, and for a while there was a uh crocodile or an alligator. I always get them confused in one of the uh manufactured uh lakes in one of the parks of Chicago, and informally the alligator was named Chance the Snapper.

[1:19:58] Tommy: Um that's cute.

[1:20:00] Jimmy: If you want to get in touch with the show, our Twitter and Instagram is at Jim and Tomic, J I M A N D T O M, I see.

[1:20:08] Tommy: Or you can drop us an email uh at Jim and Tomic at gmail.com or on our website, Jim and Tomic.com.

[1:20:14] Jimmy: And hey, while you're over there, you can uh have a gander at our Patreon.

[1:20:18] Tommy: Uh if you would like to financially support the show, um, all of our current patrons, we love you.

[1:20:23] Jimmy: We've had a few more come through the doors recently, and uh we love you deeply and dearly.

[1:20:30] Tommy: Um, but hey, if you want to just support us in any way, reviews over on Apple Podcasts or wherever you listen are super duper or tellful.

[1:20:38] Jimmy: Absolutely tell your friends.

[1:20:39] Tommy: Uh Jimmy, I actually got a uh Facebook message from uh an old college acquaintance who's like, Oh, stumbling through podcasts, found your podcast.

[1:20:46] Jimmy: Very sweet.

[1:20:47] Tommy: Hi Matt, thanks for listening.

[1:20:49] Jimmy: I love that.

[1:20:50] Tommy: Isn't that delightful?

[1:20:51] Jimmy: I love that a lot.

[1:20:52] Tommy: That could be you, ladies and gentlemen.

[1:20:54] Jimmy: That could be you.

[1:20:55] Tommy: Well, not you, because you're listening already.

[1:20:56] Jimmy: Unless you're listening because someone told you.

[1:20:59] Tommy: How does this time is it an illusion?

[1:21:01] Jimmy: In which case that is you.

[1:21:03] Tommy: That's true.

[1:21:03] Jimmy: Hey, you, thanks for listening.

[1:21:06] Tommy: Yes, specifically you.

[1:21:08] Jimmy: Thank you for listening.

[1:21:09] Tommy: And hey Tommy, specifically you.

[1:21:11] Jimmy: Cheers.

[1:21:12] Tommy: Cheers, Jimmy.

[1:21:26] Jimmy: So you're sick with big lightitis, is what you're saying?

[1:21:29] Tommy: Big biglititis, yeah.

[1:21:30] Jimmy: Biglitis sounds like it couldn't be too bad.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred