During the interval, Jimi and Tommy gossip and gab about Tony noms, Hamil-hype, and more. Plus some (inadvertent) hints about the next podcast's show. Enjoy!.. Read More
From the show: Jim and Tomic's Musical Theatre Happy Hour
Featured Shows
About
During the interval, Jimi and Tommy gossip and gab about Tony noms, Hamil-hype, and more. Plus some (inadvertent) hints about the next podcast's show. Enjoy!
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Jimi: You know, I'm I'm I won't put this little part in, but I may pull all this Tony part out and make it a bye episode.
[0:00] Tommy: When I was over getting my charger, I was like, that might be a good idea.
[0:09] Jimi: Because it's good stuff, but it's too long.
[0:16] Tommy: Somebody get us another drink. Let's talk let's talk Tony Award nominations.
[0:20] Jimi: Okay.
[0:20] Tommy: Okay, this is what we would chat about in the bar.
[0:22] Jimi: I don't know if there's a bar.
[0:23] Tommy: This is there isn't this.
[0:25] Jimi: Yeah, the whole thing is a bar.
[0:26] Tommy: Of course there's a bar.
[0:26] Jimi: I'm sure your server comes to your table and takes another drink order.
[0:30] Tommy: Exactly.
[0:30] Jimi: Um Thank you, sir. That's how they make their money with this.
[0:34] Tommy: I mean that's the key. You know, they're making their ticket money back by charging people.
[0:40] Jimi: Um I mean a lot of Tony Noms are pretty obvious.
[0:46] Tommy: What a beautiful way to open that.
[0:48] Jimi: Like, uh I did uh did you see did you see my Twitter poll?
[0:51] Tommy: I did, I did.
[0:51] Jimi: And it was do you know what it was heated? Uh if people missed out on my Twitter poll, I I asked who was gonna win the Tony Awards and Choice A was Hamilton and so word choice is B and C.
[1:00] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:01] Jimi: It was really close.
[1:02] Tommy: It was really close.
[1:04] Jimi: Um but I think the right one won in the end.
[1:06] Tommy: Right.
[1:06] Jimi: Yeah.
[1:07] Tommy: Yeah.
[1:07] Jimi: I mean, I I just think they're gonna sweep.
[1:09] Tommy: I think they're gonna sweep.
[1:11] Jimi: I hope they don't. Who do you think which one through you think in my Dave Malloy pilgrimage?
[1:17] Tommy: Right.
[1:17] Jimi: I've like I I've not hit like a backlash against Hamilton because you know uh i it's still perfect. Um but it's now it's getting to the stage where I mean I don't think the um the board will kind of acknowledge this, but people the world and literally the world, like the amount of people that I know that I didn't even realise knew about musical theatre, like, yeah, Hamilton, that that's great.
[1:47] Tommy: Um, okay. Um everyone kind of obsesses about it and it's like, yeah, Hamilton has to win everything.
[1:54] Jimi: Yes, it does. I'm like, yes, but have you actually looked at anyone else in the category or listened to any of the other cast recordings?
[2:02] Tommy: Right.
[2:03] Jimi: And a lot of the time the answer's no. And I I just feel like because it's Hamilton, you know, a lot of people are just ignoring it.
[2:13] Tommy: Obviously, you know, the awards committee won't ignore ignore everything else.
[2:18] Jimi: Right, because you you can only vote if you've seen the shows. Like there's there's restrictions put in place.
[2:23] Tommy: I can I don't know, I can imagine But are but I are you just are you this this happens, this happens in pop culture, and you know it happens where once something gets too cool.
[2:32] Jimi: Oh what like the hipster, yeah, yeah, yeah.
[2:34] Tommy: Once it gets too cool, then it's too cool, then you gotta you know, jump ship a little bit.
[2:39] Jimi: I mean, not at all, but I think I don't know, I think as well, like we were we were there, well, not at the start, but you know, early on when it when it became on Broadway, uh podcast number one.
[2:48] Tommy: Damn right.
[2:48] Jimi: This is the gen, it was the thing that we were like, we need to talk about Hamilton, let's just podcast about it.
[2:54] Tommy: Right, exactly. So I feel like we've we've been enjoying it for a very long time.
[2:57] Jimi: And that's the thing is I don't I don't want everyone to turn around and be like, you hate Hamilton, kill them, burn the wind.
[3:04] Tommy: Not at all. I don't think anyone hates Hamilton, right? And you'd be stupid if you did, because it's amazing.
[3:10] Jimi: But I just feel there are certain nominees there that I'm like, I don't know if you're gonna wear that.
[3:16] Tommy: Yeah, um, there are certain nominees that I'm like, thank god you got that. Please win it.
[3:20] Jimi: Basically, Christopher Jackson.
[3:23] Tommy: Yeah, yeah.
[3:24] Jimi: S surprised and no.
[3:28] Tommy: I mean, he's up against three of his own two of his own cast members.
[3:32] Jimi: Right.
[3:33] Tommy: Um, who I'm like, yep, perfect.
[3:35] Jimi: Yeah, I I called David Diggs from the podcast.
[3:37] Tommy: Uh yeah, that's true, you did.
[3:39] Jimi: Um, I don't I don't know if he'll win it because Leslie is a force to be reckoned with.
[3:45] Tommy: Different categories.
[3:46] Jimi: Oh yeah.
[3:47] Tommy: David is up for featured roles.
[3:49] Jimi: Oh, it's Jonathan again.
[3:50] Tommy: He's a list, isn't it?
[3:51] Jimi: No, nope. So David, Jonathan, and Chris are featured actors.
[3:56] Tommy: Also up against uh Brandon Victor Dixon from Shuffle Along and Christopher Fitzgerald from Waitress.
[4:01] Jimi: Right.
[4:02] Tommy: And then leading actor is Lynn Leslie, and then Zachary Vye from She Loves Me, Danny Bernstein from Fiddler, and uh uh the guy from uh School of Rock plays Jack Black.
[4:14] Jimi: Yes, yes, yes.
[4:15] Tommy: Alright, okay. Well then he's got a better chance.
[4:19] Jimi: Right. But it's so one, it's interesting that three actors from the same musical are nominated for the same category.
[4:26] Tommy: Right.
[4:26] Jimi: Nuts.
[4:27] Tommy: Um nuts, yeah. Absolutely nuts.
[4:29] Jimi: And uh I don't know, Jonathan Graff. I don't think Jonathan Groff will win.
[4:34] Tommy: No, oh god, no. Um like he was great, but it's a it's a tiny bit part.
[4:38] Jimi: And yeah, and it's just so it's like right. What what justifies best performance by an actor in a you know in a future only musical?
[4:47] Tommy: I mean, I guess you know, he makes the most of his feature.
[4:50] Jimi: Yeah, but that's just the role. I mean, like exactly like there's not anything, there's nothing to it.
[4:55] Tommy: The only reason his replacements aren't nominated is because they were replacements. Like it's just that that's the role.
[5:02] Jimi: Yeah, there's nothing to it. There's not uh you put on a funny British accent and you dance about the stage, I guess.
[5:08] Tommy: Would you know, you you m move your eyebrows a little bit.
[5:12] Jimi: Yeah.
[5:12] Tommy: Um Chris Jackson, I I don't know, I just like I've never really been the biggest Chris Jackson fan.
[5:21] Jimi: Mm-hmm.
[5:22] Tommy: I feel like I'm like, this is huge.
[5:24] Jimi: So sorry, sorry, Chris Jackson, if you're listening. You're great.
[5:27] Tommy: You are a lovely person. You're a really lovely person.
[5:30] Jimi: This is important stuff. We're talking about it's a competition, and only one person gets a Tony unless you're a Billy Elliott.
[5:36] Tommy: Right.
[5:37] Jimi: Like he he's very strong. But as an act, I mean, I I don't know. I've not seen Hamilton.
[5:46] Tommy: I don't know, you know what I mean. This is the eternal thing with Tonies, right?
[5:49] Jimi: Right. But uh knowing Chris Jackson, having seen as much as I've possibly seen of Hamilton and Chris Jackson in the role, he's you know, I mean it could be Benny with a bit more poise.
[5:59] Tommy: Like I mean, I I think featured actor is is the most up in the air category as far as my world is.
[6:07] Jimi: In in terms of this year?
[6:08] Tommy: In terms of this year.
[6:09] Jimi: I think I think so. I think I bet you my um I would still put my money on on Mr. Diggs.
[6:15] Tommy: David, yeah.
[6:16] Jimi: But just barely. And again, I I I feel David uh kind of sh I love the idea of David winning it because he's not a a Broadway guy.
[6:26] Tommy: I mean it would mean a lot if he won it.
[6:29] Jimi: Right. Because the thing is it's not like oh let's cast this celebrity. You know, he was cast for his uh rapping ability.
[6:36] Tommy: Right, his technical skill and his his kind of pure heart to it.
[6:39] Jimi: Yeah. But he's come in and he's played two massively contrasting roles with a plom. You know, he sings, he raps in a French accent. Like he's become this kind of he's become really iconic.
[6:53] Tommy: And I feel that is deserving of a Tony.
[6:57] Jimi: I could see that too. So tell me what you think about uh leading actor.
[7:01] Tommy: I want Danny to win it so much.
[7:05] Jimi: Yeah, yeah, I really too. I just think people aren't gonna vote for Fiddler.
[7:09] Tommy: But why not?
[7:10] Jimi: I think people I think people are still gonna have their founding father without a father glasses on.
[7:16] Tommy: And but then they're gonna be like, well, we can't give Lin another one because he can only hold so many, and they're gonna give it to Leslie.
[7:23] Jimi: I I I'm sorry, right? This is where I'm actually gonna get quite passionate.
[7:26] Tommy: Yeah.
[7:27] Jimi: I get Lynn Manuel. Uh he is one of the greatest writers ever. I would never take that away from him.
[7:34] Tommy: He's not one of the greatest actors ever.
[7:36] Jimi: Nope. He's not by any stretch one of the greatest singers ever.
[7:40] Tommy: So when this is one of my favorite artist stories. Do you know how Lady Gaga happened?
[7:43] Jimi: Uh no.
[7:46] Tommy: Well, I don't know, maybe.
[7:47] Jimi: No, I don't know.
[7:48] Tommy: Right? How Lady Gaga went like became Lady Gaga. She from like high school to fr like found that persona, decided this was the world she wanted to live in.
[7:58] Jimi: The story goes, at least, and I'm sure I'm butchering it a little bit.
[8:00] Tommy: Right.
[8:01] Jimi: She was playing piano at some cabaret bar or you know, just some venue where people were drinking, and you know, like she was the entertainment, but just on the side, and no one was paying attention to her, and no one was listening to her, as as happens at places like that.
[8:15] Tommy: And it was it was kind of getting to her because like this was her art. This was the thing she cared about.
[8:20] Jimi: And so one day she decided she was she stopped in the middle of the song, took all of her clothes off, and then sat down at the piano and continued to play.
[8:30] Tommy: And then people paid attention.
[8:31] Jimi: Right because she was naked. And that is 100% Lady Gaga's MO.
[8:39] Tommy: Right. Uh huh, yeah.
[8:40] Jimi: She, you know, every every every show she does, every crazy thing she's doing is so that you'll listen to her music. It's not particularly about the weird, crazy persona she's building.
[8:52] Tommy: It's that's a distractor for getting into the music that she's doing.
[8:59] Jimi: Yeah, that's a beautiful button. And yeah, because the talent that she has transcends the Lynn Manual Miranda very openly says he was faced with a similar problem.
[9:08] Tommy: He loved musical theater in like in no small way the same way we do.
[9:13] Jimi: Yep. Growing up on cast albums, scrounging to see whatever show he can, just like absolutely living and adoring in this world.
[9:19] Tommy: But there weren't shows where he could be the leading role.
[9:24] Jimi: Yep.
[9:24] Tommy: Outside of college, outside of high school, where you know that sort of stuff happens more often.
[9:29] Jimi: And so he took it into his own hands and wrote them.
[9:33] Tommy: And I think I think now he has reached the success where he doesn't need to cast himself in that role and can start casting, like start giving those roles away.
[9:42] Jimi: But I think it says something really, really important that he followed that dream through.
[9:47] Tommy: That on Broadway, there doesn't exist shows for people like me.
[9:52] Jimi: So I am going to create them, and then to prove it, I'm going to be in them. And that is Hamilton to a T.
[10:00] Tommy: What about well, what about heights?
[10:02] Jimi: I think Heights starts it. You know, Heights is an autobiographical story.
[10:06] Tommy: It's the first, it's the first story that any aspiring artist ever writes.
[10:11] Jimi: And Lin Manuel Miranda just happens to be a great artist. Where Hamilton is a new piece of musical theater that is so much more that because like Lin Manuel Miranda is playing Lynn Manuel Miranda in In the Heights.
[10:14] Tommy: Yeah, yeah, exactly.
[10:14] Jimi: Lin Manuel Miranda is not playing L, you know, a kid who grew up in Washington Heights in Hamilton. And like he's he is redefining the narrative like that.
[10:34] Tommy: Like, that's why I think it's important. You don't you don't like the art that's out there, go make some new art.
[10:40] Jimi: Is and I can I completely agree with that.
[10:40] Tommy: I completely agree with that.
[10:46] Jimi: Um but I I don't know. I I wouldn't feel comfortable writing a show that I was like, I'm writing this this role was really cool. I want it.
[11:00] Tommy: Yeah.
[11:02] Jimi: I'm gonna cast myself in it.
[11:05] Tommy: I I don't feel I don't feel comfortable doing that.
[11:08] Jimi: Maybe that is just purely down to my own personal preference.
[11:11] Tommy: I could see that. I would want to know. I won't, you know, I hope someday, and it's too soon for him to have this conversation, but I want to hear the interview someday with LaMemo Miranda about how he feels being in shows that he's written, you know.
[11:24] Jimi: Do you think he'll do another do you think he'll do it again?
[11:26] Tommy: I I mean I think good artists can't help but create.
[11:32] Jimi: But no, that's that's uh that is a I think there's a difference between creating and and acting.
[11:36] Tommy: Yeah, do you know what I mean?
[11:37] Jimi: And he I don't think there's a difference for him.
[11:41] Tommy: I don't uh yeah, may uh maybe that's it. I guess I don't know if he'll write another show with him as the lead, you know, in the same way that he decided he couldn't end Hamilton with in Washington Heights.
[11:52] Jimi: Yeah, yeah, yeah. He he gets he doesn't Elvis Presley was asked to audition to be Conrad Birdie in the movie of Bye Bye Birdie and was gonna take it, and his agents said you can't do that the moment you're a parody of yourself, your career's over, yeah.
[12:07] Tommy: Lim and memoranda isn't yet, but I think if he did another show or two or whatever, he would get very close to becoming a parody of himself.
[12:16] Jimi: Yeah, and he's savvy, he's smart, he gets it.
[12:20] Tommy: I don't think like I think he would know well enough to do that.
[12:24] Jimi: Um also he doesn't need to anymore, right? If the goal was create a broadway that everyone has a role in, he's started that trend.
[12:34] Tommy: Like he that's what Hamilton's praised for.
[12:37] Jimi: Like he we reached it. You know, and then now we can write the shows for other Broadway people.
[12:43] Tommy: Yeah.
[12:44] Jimi: Uh yeah. I d uh yeah, yeah. I just don't think it's very good.
[12:50] Tommy: I still don't think he's gonna win the Tony for Best Actor.
[12:53] Jimi: No, and but I don't want it to be I don't want it to be political. I want it to be artistic.
[12:57] Tommy: Yeah.
[12:57] Jimi: Danny Bresteon's performance in Fiddler in the roof is fantastic. Leslie Odam Jr.'s performance in Hamilton is fantastic.
[13:04] Tommy: To be honest, Alex Brightman's also amazing.
[13:08] Jimi: I really like him in terms of you know, in inhabiting that character.
[13:12] Tommy: Sorry, Zachary, I've not really watched much of you yet.
[13:15] Jimi: It's I mean, I also I don't think Alex is gonna win, you know, for the same reason I don't like those kind of musicals.
[13:15] Tommy: The same reason I go on and on about Spongebob the music is the politics of it all.
[13:25] Jimi: Yeah.
[13:26] Tommy: That's not the, you know, they're that's it if you if yeah, yeah.
[13:29] Jimi: It's it's that it's that type of thing. Like if you take away the pol if you just look at like you are an actor, are you you know, right?
[13:36] Tommy: Exactly. But it's it's the it's the Tony it's the Tony Wards committee's way of like taking their little spray bottle of water and being like, no, we want.
[13:43] Jimi: No, that's why they get rid of the the sound design Tony.
[13:49] Tommy: Um for the record, Dave Malloy bills himself as a musical theater composer, pianist, and sound designer.
[13:57] Jimi: Right.
[13:58] Tommy: And the show would not exist if sound design was not an art, Tony Committee.
[14:04] Jimi: Exactly, Tony Committee. How many times can everyone tell you that it's a good idea?
[14:08] Tommy: Natasha Pierre and the Great Comet of 1812 would not be as amazing and specific as it was if it wasn't written by a sound designer.
[14:20] Jimi: I'm sorry, Hamilton, the amount of sampling that is used in Hamilton, it would not be nearly as good.
[14:25] Tommy: Right.
[14:26] Jimi: If Limanuel didn't have a great knowledge of sound design.
[14:30] Tommy: Oh man. Doesn't that sound like an art?
[14:34] Jimi: I know. So right anyway.
[14:53] Jimi: The Colour Purple, Jesse Mueller from Waitress, and Philippa Soo from Hamilton.
[15:01] Tommy: Hamilton's gonna win.
[15:02] Jimi: She's amazing.
[15:04] Tommy: She's just amazing.
[15:05] Jimi: I'm gonna disagree with you. My pick is Cynthia.
[15:10] Tommy: Yeah.
[15:11] Jimi: Yep. She is just unstoppable.
[15:17] Tommy: Because I started over here, I've seen a lot more of that than a lot of the other shows. And hopefully, when I go across the pond in like three weeks, holy moly. Colour Purple's at the top of my list because it isn't, it's not for Jennifer Hudson.
[15:30] Jimi: Poor Jennifer Hudson.
[15:37] Tommy: I know. It's not for Tasty.
[15:40] Jimi: I don't think that poor. Well, I'll see. I'll let you know. Because yeah, she is just sensational. And Philippa is very, very good, but Cynthia Erivo has, I don't know, she's just got the vulnerability edge. It's also a better role.
[16:01] Tommy: Yeah, I think that's definitely true. It's a much, much better role for her too. There's a lot more depth. Not that Mrs. Hamilton, whose first name I can't remember right now, Eliza Hamilton, does not have a lot of depth, but not as much.
[16:24] Jimi: That's my thoughts on that one. We'll see who wins. Then what? We'll ignore the plays. We're ignoring plays, but you know, we're a musical theater podcast.
[16:33] Tommy: Exactly.
[16:34] Jimi: Featured actress.
[16:35] Tommy: Featured actress. I mean, I'm just like Renee.
[16:38] Jimi: Yeah.
[16:39] Tommy: But again, I said it in the first podcast. I'll forever be obsessed. I think she's gonna win.
[16:44] Jimi: I absolutely think she is. She's gonna win.
[16:46] Tommy: I so hope she does. I just love her. She's just fantastic. And I see that's the thing is I'm, I've told you this before, like I'm an Angelica. Like I'm her. She is my hero in that whole show.
[16:59] Jimi: Um, and she and David are just my favorite. They're just fantastic. And yeah, it's beyond the problem. It just, her is such a complex character, satisfied as devastating and awesome, and just give her a Tony. That's all right.
[17:14] Tommy: She deserves it very much so.
[17:18] Jimi: Yeah, I'm not even gonna acknowledge anyone else in the category.
[17:23] Tommy: So we skip totally past the big categories.
[17:27] Jimi: Well, I thought we should leave the best to the end.
[17:30] Tommy: Okay, okay, okay. Just because that's the big one. Those are the, I mean, I always have my thoughts about the technical categories, but I also think those are more crapshoots.
[17:38] Jimi: Mostly, not because I think, I think partially because a lot of contemporary lighting design and a lot of contemporary costume design is just all exemplary. Like it's all very good and it's difficult to do something revolutionary with lighting design for a musical where people are like, whoa, the lighting.
[18:01] Tommy: Exactly.
[18:02] Jimi: I think that's half of it. I think the other half of it is that Tony voters for the most part aren't tech theater people.
[18:09] Tommy: Yeah, exactly.
[18:10] Jimi: That stuff blows right past them. They're not thinking about it. It was interesting with the Oliviers. The musical that won was Gypsy.
[18:16] Tommy: Okay.
[18:16] Jimi: Well, the show that won that is to play or musical at the old Oliviers because who cares? And I think the lighting design for that was absolutely stunning. So I don't know whether maybe the Olivier committee are really clued up on these things, but basically they don't do anything exceptional, absolutely not, but they create natural light on the stage.
[18:37] Tommy: And you know, like that's fantastic. It's the most difficult thing to do.
[18:41] Jimi: Exactly. They just, they did it perfectly. I was, the times I was blown away because it, and also it was seamless with the set design. Like it was an amazing design altogether.
[18:53] Tommy: So yes, well done. So I think that's also like the technical categories are just kind of tied to the production as a whole.
[18:59] Jimi: Yeah, yeah, very true. Except for it does make it seem a bit like a slight when your musical is only nominated for technical awards.
[19:08] Tommy: Say like poor American Psycho, which I believe is up for lighting design and set design.
[19:14] Jimi: Yeah.
[19:14] Tommy: And that's it.
[19:15] Jimi: Well, let's talk about American Psycho.
[19:18] Tommy: It looks not so great.
[19:19] Jimi: Right. Have you listened to it yet?
[19:21] Tommy: I've listened to it. I got maybe three songs in.
[19:24] Jimi: Uh-huh.
[19:25] Tommy: I watched, they were on the Colbert show or something. I watched whatever.
[19:29] Jimi: Is this with a money gun?
[19:31] Tommy: No.
[19:33] Jimi: Oh, you must have seen it.
[19:34] Tommy: I'm sure it's that performance.
[19:36] Jimi: It's not the game where they're doing like the opening number.
[19:39] Tommy: Yeah, I must have missed the money gun.
[19:41] Jimi: No, you can't have missed the money gun.
[19:45] Tommy: Yes, the Colbert, it's the Colbert Report. How have you not?
[19:47] Jimi: Maybe I gave up on this one too.
[19:51] Tommy: Oh, there it is. Oh, this is so stupid.
[19:55] Jimi: This is so stupid.
[19:57] Tommy: Right. What production meeting were they in where they were like, and then he pulls out a money gun and shoots dollar bills at the audience?
[20:05] Jimi: For one second.
[20:06] Tommy: Literally just like, ha ha ha.
[20:08] Jimi: Yeah.
[20:08] Tommy: No, this is, did you see the Matt Smith production?
[20:13] Jimi: I didn't know, but apparently it's pretty much identical.
[20:15] Tommy: Did it do well?
[20:16] Jimi: No. But what it did is it was like, hey, do you know what? There's lots of potential here. Go work on it and make it better, and you could have something really interesting on your hands.
[20:30] Tommy: Yeah.
[20:31] Jimi: So what they did was do nothing and put it on Broadway. So it just seemed like the whole, none of the tone of any of the pieces match. The tone of the music doesn't match the source material. Like a Dunkin' Shake electropop extravaganza doesn't really fit with like the calm, cool and secret world of Patrick Bateman.
[21:01] Tommy: Like he's not the kind of character who sings his feelings.
[21:06] Jimi: Yeah. That's, it's come, but the thing is, it's like, so there's some moments of genius in it where I think it gets really close. Because I love American Psycho, just to preface the film amazing, the book, terrifying, love it. I feel the opening monologue makes sense because it's, I mean, it's pretty much pervasive from the source material.
[21:27] Tommy: But just in a sense, in even the way that thingy delivers it, I feel Matt Smith actually is better at delivering it. He's not as good a singer, but better at the acting side, but that's fine. It's Matt's bad. And that idea is just really good and just very matter of fact.
[21:43] Jimi: But the second he goes introspective, I'm like, well that actually physically can't be done because you never get, you never see inside Patrick Bateman's mind.
[21:51] Tommy: Yeah.
[21:51] Jimi: And heaven forbid if you do, because oh my god, he can't sing about his feelings because he doesn't understand his feelings.
[21:57] Tommy: Right.
[21:57] Jimi: Like he's, I don't know, I don't know the correct term, psychopath or sociopath.
[22:01] Tommy: Yeah.
[22:03] Jimi: But it just is completely at odds. So why not, I mean, make a show where he doesn't sing his feelings. Make it not musical.
[22:11] Tommy: It just doesn't seem to fit.
[22:13] Jimi: Well, no, but that's the thing, is I actually, I don't mind it as a musical because again, there are some moments where I'm like, yeah, I do kind of get it. Because it's got, well, some of the songs have that really good eighties vibe. Again, I'm a massive fan of the eighties and new wave and high energy and the kind of gay disco scenes, you know what I mean?
[22:37] Tommy: Like that's what I'm obsessed with, amongst everything else.
[22:41] Jimi: But there are some great moments of that. Like Hard Body has got, you can imagine that being in a gay club, you know, I mean, in London, and things like you are what you wear, mm-hmm. You know, I mean, it sounds a bit like early Madonna, yeah, Cindy Lauperish.
[23:00] Tommy: So there's these like little allusions, yeah, but then you've just got some random ass crap in there.
[23:07] Jimi: It's just pure crap, like and apparently my friend McDowell's saying that a lot of the songs are just Dunkin' Shake songs that he's written when he was in his band that he's just shot into the musical.
[23:21] Tommy: I pardon my friend, hate all that. Like it is everything I hate about musical theater. A popular commodity blindly adapted into a poorly conceived piece of theater using popular names to try and draw people in.
[23:37] Jimi: Yeah.
[23:38] Tommy: It just grinds my gears.
[23:40] Jimi: And so, you know, sorry, not sorry, American Psycho. I'm so disappointed in Dunkin' Shake because I'm like, I thought you were better than this man.
[23:47] Tommy: Let's, I mean, never forget, Lin-Manuel Miranda helped bring Bring It On: The Musical, so we all have our skeletons.
[23:55] Jimi: The middle ones are always a bit shady.
[23:59] Tommy: I'm just so disappointed. So disappointed. Sorry, that was a massive segue.
[24:05] Jimi: Nothing of that is gonna make it into the podcast because it's already five hours long.
[24:08] Tommy: Yeah, so do you want to talk like direction? Because I think that's an interesting category.
[24:16] Jimi: What's always interesting to me about these categories is that they're the categories where the revivals and the new stuff go head to head.
[24:24] Tommy: Exactly.
[24:25] Jimi: For direction, up is Spring Awakening with Michael Arden, John Doyle for The Colour Purple, Scott Ellis for She Loves Me, Tommy Kail for Hamilton, and then George C. Wolfe for Shuffle Along or the Making of the Musical Sensation of 1921 and all that followed.
[24:43] Tommy: Do you remember?
[24:44] Jimi: I don't remember how many years ago. You know the movie Precious?
[24:48] Tommy: Oh, right, uh-huh.
[24:49] Jimi: Yeah, yeah, yeah. The full title is Precious, based on the novel Push by Sapphire. That is the full official title.
[24:56] Tommy: So the year when Precious won a whole bunch of Oscars, every time they had to say the name, they said Precious, based on the novel Push by Sapphire.
[25:05] Jimi: Yeah.
[25:05] Tommy: And up for is this short movie name, this short movie name, and Precious based on the novel Push by Sapphire. And I think it was George Clooney who was like announcing the best picture stuff and was like Precious, based on the novel Push by Sapphire. And I don't remember what the next movie was, but he was like Finding Nemo, based on the novel Push by Sapphire.
[25:27] Jimi: And it's become this joke that like this based on the novel Push by Sapphire.
[25:32] Tommy: That's completely gone over my head.
[25:34] Jimi: I am sure at the Tony Awards, it is going to become very trying if they're like Shuffle Along or the Making of the Musical Sensation of 1921 and all that followed.
[25:45] Tommy: That is a too long title.
[25:46] Jimi: That title is too long. You don't need that.
[25:49] Tommy: I think they're gonna have to do it.
[25:51] Jimi: Yeah, it's gonna be really true.
[26:02] Tommy: Yeah. And we're gonna get bored. Thank, and it's up for quite a lot. Hamilton, She Loves Me, Shuffle Along, Colour Purple, Spring Awakening.
[26:12] Jimi: I think Spring Awakening might win.
[26:14] Tommy: Yeah. I mean, it in many ways it does really deserve to.
[26:22] Jimi: The concept of that whole show is excellent. And the only category to award that concept in is directing.
[26:32] Tommy: Like it seems like an inappropriate award for the thing you're trying to honor, you know.
[26:37] Jimi: Uh-huh.
[26:38] Tommy: But at the end of the day, it's like, I don't know the history of Spring Awakening, but I don't think unless Deaf West came to Michael Arden and were like, hey Michael Arden, we love Spring Awakening. Do you want to direct this? Like he had to have this idea somewhere in his head where he's like, do you know what? I want to make this more open.
[26:55] Jimi: Yeah.
[26:55] Tommy: I want to open this up. And he's a good guy. Like I don't doubt that that was his thinking, and he executed it. And the thing is, it's like it wasn't perfect. We've discussed this.
[27:07] Jimi: Perfect, but it was brilliant. Like it was fascinating. It was interesting and new in ways that the direction for Hamilton isn't.
[27:11] Tommy: The direction for Hamilton is still great.
[27:19] Jimi: But it's very linear. Like it's very, like I don't know. I feel being a director, without sounding as wanky as that sounded. But being like, I think about how would I do this with everything that I listen to.
[27:37] Tommy: Yeah.
[27:38] Jimi: And with Hamilton, the first thing before I saw any press, any staging image was I was like, oh my god, I bet you they will be in like a mashup of like period dress and hip hop because how good would that be? And the whole thing would be like half in half.
[27:58] Tommy: Yep.
[27:58] Jimi: And I'd be like, that feels so cool, so fresh. And I see it, and I'm like, oh no, it's all just in period. And it's quite actually quite boring.
[28:07] Tommy: It's quite boring.
[28:08] Jimi: Yeah, the pure direction of Hamilton is appropriate, and not that the direction for Spring Awakening sticks out or seems inappropriate, but it is more worthy of honor than Hamilton.
[28:21] Tommy: Yeah, completely.
[28:22] Jimi: Nothing, I mean, I love you, Tommy.
[28:24] Tommy: Oh, completely, and well done for Grease.
[28:26] Jimi: Hamilton and you know the rest of everything else you do. But you know, just a little bit more imagination.
[28:34] Tommy: Like I can't wait to your next one.
[28:36] Jimi: Yeah, exactly.
[28:37] Tommy: Meanwhile, choreography, so is Hamilton, Shuffle Along, Fiddler, Dames at Sea, and On Your Feet, the story of Emilio and Gloria Estefan, based on the novel Push by Sapphire.
[28:51] Jimi: What we've got here is me, and this happens quite a lot in Tony's where my brain has to get split in two.
[28:58] Tommy: Yeah.
[28:58] Jimi: Like, you know, in The Lion King when Rafiki opens that like juicy fruit.
[29:03] Tommy: Yeah, juicy fruit with the gum and then he just hands it out.
[29:11] Jimi: Imagine that happening to my brain because I have loved Savion Glover for so effing long. Like he was one of the first tap dancers that I was ever introduced to. And I just, I was like, I want to do that, you know, I want to do what you do. And because it was when we did Anything Goes, and it was my first experience of tap dancing. We had some amazing choreographer, and she, because I was just into it, I was like, oh, who else do you like?
[29:43] Jimi: Um, and she just kind of sent me all these things. And she sent me this video of Savion Glover, and I was like, "What? You’re incredible." Absolutely incredible, and I've watched quite a lot of the choreography that he's done, and it's really tough. Like, it's some challenging, challenging stuff. I don't know what the execution's like, but the actual choreographic design is great.
[30:05] Tommy: Yeah.
[30:05] Jimi: And then on the other hand, uh-huh, we have Hofesh Shechter, who I think needs to win it for many reasons. A, because he's stopped the curse of Jerry Robbins. Thank God. Right?
[30:17] Tommy: Exactly.
[30:17] Jimi: Nothing against Jerry Robbins, but you know, it's company decades later. Exactly. The world has changed. And not only has he re-choreographed it, he's drawn from the source material in a way that Jerry Robbins didn't quite do.
[30:35] Tommy: Yeah.
[30:35] Jimi: Um, and he's created something very innovative for Broadway. And that's why I think Hofesh Shechter should win it. But I'm a massive Savion Glover fan.
[30:45] Tommy: You don't think this is just gonna be another category that Hamilton's gonna sweep?
[30:49] Jimi: Absolutely not. Absolutely not. No. I'm very passionate about this. No. The choreography in Hamilton is very, very, very similar to the choreography in In the Heights.
[31:00] Tommy: That's true.
[31:02] Jimi: And I don't think that should be awarded. The choreography for In the Heights was sensational. The choreography for Hamilton is a watered-down version of the choreography for In the Heights. My two cents. If Andy wins it, I will be disappointed. Thoroughly.
[31:17] Tommy: I'm excited to follow your Twitter.
[31:19] Jimi: Damn right. Is that @asinhendrix on Twitter? Is that what that is?
[31:22] Tommy: It is indeed. What's yours?
[31:24] Jimi: T, uh, @musicalmash.
[31:27] Tommy: Mine's a little easier. The pseudonym.
[31:30] Jimi: Um, Tommy's @musicalmash.
[31:33] Tommy: Hey.
[31:34] Jimi: Uh, yeah. Um, do you think Andy's got a chance?
[31:38] Tommy: Uh, I think everyone's got their $10 bill goggles on.
[31:43] Jimi: I'll be so annoyed. I think, I mean, a lot of times with theater, it's easy to fall into this trap of like embracing—embracing is the wrong word. New stuff sticks out. Like new stuff, you think about Fiddler on the Roof, and you're like, "Oh yes, the choreography," because that was the interesting thing about the show, you know? You think about American Psycho and you're like, "Oh yes, the lighting," because that was the interesting thing about the show. You think of Hamilton and you don't think of the choreography because it was appropriate.
[32:16] Tommy: Um, again, I just like, I disagree.
[32:19] Jimi: Yeah.
[32:20] Tommy: I actually disagree because I—no, I think it was lazy.
[32:25] Jimi: I think that's valid. The choreography that they use in Hamilton was vaguely hip hop. It was closer to being contemporary, to be honest, and it wasn't illustrative, it wasn't hugely dynamic. It didn't really serve in terms of what choreography should be, do you know what I mean?
[32:42] Jimi: Yeah, yeah, it didn't serve that purpose. I do feel that Fiddler, you know, it had—it was referencing a culture, um, it was modernizing it, it was seamlessly tracked through, and at the end of the day, it was beautiful.
[32:59] Tommy: No, I think that's valid. I, you know, this is also much more your wheelhouse than it is mine, to be honest.
[33:06] Jimi: Yeah, that's the—is it's some, uh, it's something I'm hugely passionate about. Um, because I think a lot of times I think the choreography Tony has been given away incorrectly because of, well, I don't know, I guess it's like you say, the voters don't necessarily quite get what goes into it.
[33:25] Tommy: Yeah.
[33:26] Jimi: I would wager one of the most underappreciated and most important Tony Awards, best orchestrations.
[33:32] Tommy: Exactly.
[33:33] Jimi: And this one, give it, give it to last year.
[33:37] Tommy: This is a Hamilton show in.
[33:39] Jimi: 100%.
[33:40] Tommy: Yeah.
[33:41] Jimi: A hundred and fifty. Mostly even because what he's up against. Like Bright Star, She Loves Me, and Shuffle Along.
[33:50] Tommy: Um, boring, boring, boring orchestration-wise.
[33:54] Jimi: And do you know, I was surprised but happy that American Psycho didn't appear on this list because it was incorrect. Um, yeah, so very happy for you, Alex, because you're going to win this.
[34:08] Tommy: Yeah.
[34:08] Jimi: Well, and it's also, you know, you watch all of the digital media that exists of Lin-Manuel Miranda working on Hamilton, and Alex is right next to him the entire time. If he's not accompanying him on the piano, he is like there, also ready to talk about the thing like this is a collaboration to a T.
[34:28] Tommy: Completely.
[34:29] Jimi: It's, yeah. Excellent. Bravo. So then we get to the big ones. Um, I think we should talk about non-revival first because I think that's the easier one.
[34:40] Tommy: Right.
[34:41] Jimi: I mean, does anyone think Hamilton's not gonna win?
[34:44] Tommy: Exactly.
[34:45] Jimi: If it doesn't, and again, if it doesn't, I'll be so—I mean, I don't even know why I'm saying if it doesn't because it will.
[34:50] Tommy: Right.
[34:51] Jimi: But like, it's worth it to think about the others. Bright Star, School of Rock, uh-huh, and Waitress.
[34:59] Tommy: Right, okay. Let's say Hamilton wasn't this season.
[35:04] Jimi: Uh-huh. Who would win?
[35:06] Tommy: I would want it to go to Shuffle Along.
[35:10] Jimi: Yeah.
[35:11] Tommy: Because I find it hugely groundbreaking. Um, in a lot of the same way that Hamilton is, it's usually groundbreaking. And obviously, it's an updating.
[35:22] Jimi: Right.
[35:23] Tommy: Which is controversial. Obviously, they had to change so much of the criteria to get it in.
[35:29] Jimi: Um, I'm very glad they did because it's a different world. Do you know what I mean?
[35:33] Tommy: I'm sorry. That was the twenties and Broadway is all the same.
[35:37] Jimi: Yeah. Do you know what I mean?
[35:39] Tommy: Yeah.
[35:39] Jimi: Um, so I would—that's what I would want. Because I think best musical isn't just about what's best. This is the only one that I'll allow politics to interfere with. Because I think it, you know, I mean, the best musical is that it has a social status as well as a creative and artistic one. And I feel if Hamilton wasn't around, people would be looking to Shuffle Along.
[36:01] Tommy: Yes.
[36:02] Jimi: Absolutely.
[36:03] Tommy: Uh, paragraph. Do you agree?
[36:04] Jimi: I do agree.
[36:05] Tommy: Um, I think I do.
[36:08] Jimi: Uh, you want to talk best revival? Because I think this is one of the more difficult ones to call it.
[36:13] Tommy: I can't call it.
[36:15] Jimi: Yeah, I can't do it. So it's The Color Purple, Fiddler on the Roof, She Loves Me, and Spring Awakening. I think right away we can cross out She Loves Me.
[36:23] Tommy: Which is a fine show, and it's just a kind of generic revival.
[36:27] Jimi: Yeah, and uh, it's a shame that this is the season that's a good thing.
[36:29] Tommy: It is a shame because it's a great show and it's, uh, what's her face? From 30 Rock, she's fabulous.
[36:34] Jimi: Jane Krakowski.
[36:38] Tommy: Jane Krakowski is in it, and she's great, and Zachary Levi. Did I get that right?
[36:44] Jimi: They're great. It's a cute musical, it has some of my favorite songs from like old, old musicals.
[36:49] Tommy: Exactly, yeah, exactly.
[36:51] Jimi: And, uh, I just feel it's a shame for it because as an old musical, it's actually really good.
[36:51] Tommy: Really good.
[36:56] Jimi: Yeah. But it's, who's gonna even look at it?
[36:58] Tommy: Who's gonna look at it?
[36:59] Jimi: There's nothing, and like compared to the things it's up against, there's nothing new in it. It's like a generic, whitewashed version of ye oldy Broadway.
[37:10] Tommy: And it's, sorry, but we gotta start accepting it.
[37:13] Jimi: The golden age is over.
[37:15] Tommy: And that's, we're like, we are in a new realm. If you're not doing something new.
[37:19] Jimi: I feel like kind of five years ago, sort of Promises, Promises time.
[37:23] Tommy: Yeah.
[37:23] Jimi: It could have been a contender.
[37:25] Tommy: Yeah.
[37:26] Jimi: Or even like, you know, when Dan Radcliffe was in How to Succeed, like there was a time where revivals with people you recognize in them did well, but I think people have gotten—a younger generation has gotten more creative than that on Broadway and are demanding a lot more from their productions.
[37:45] Tommy: So then we're stuck with Spring Awakening, Fiddler, and The Color Purple.
[37:50] Jimi: Yeah.
[37:51] Tommy: So three extremely—well, no, actually. I think The Color Purple and Fiddler on the Roof are doing similar things.
[37:57] Jimi: They're really good updates of—
[37:57] Tommy: Yeah, and they're super modern.
[38:01] Jimi: Yeah, they're super modern in just kind of like all across the board.
[38:06] Tommy: Where Spring Awakening is more out of left field.
[38:09] Jimi: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Because it's barely a revival. We, you know, we did a whole podcast.
[38:14] Tommy: Um, like it was on—it was on five minutes ago.
[38:17] Jimi: Right.
[38:18] Tommy: Like, hello again, but then it's not, you know, it's not like, "Oh, Les Mis has showed up for its sixth revival." It's like, "Oh, this is a different production of Spring Awakening," which is really interesting.
[38:29] Jimi: Yeah, the—I can't think of a revival that's not something stupid or popular, like Les Mis or Cats, um, that has starred some of the same cast members as the original production.
[38:42] Tommy: I know, you know?
[38:43] Jimi: Like so close to each other that you can just, you know, come on back, we're doing it again.
[38:47] Tommy: But it's different.
[38:48] Jimi: Yeah, completely.
[38:48] Tommy: Yeah, and that's it.
[38:49] Jimi: It's so different. If you're gonna revive something that's happened really recently, do it like this.
[38:54] Tommy: Yeah.
[38:55] Jimi: I think for those reasons, they might give it to Spring Awakening.
[39:02] Tommy: I would be really surprised.
[39:03] Jimi: Yeah.
[39:03] Tommy: I mean, because critically it didn't do that well.
[39:08] Jimi: Yeah.
[39:08] Tommy: But this is where then you're getting into discussion as to whether it's a critical choice or a political choice.
[39:13] Jimi: I think the political choice is Spring Awakening.
[39:15] Tommy: Do you think we want more like this?
[39:17] Jimi: But the thing is, so this is—I don't know.
[39:20] Tommy: Yeah, I do agree, like, do more like this, but what they did was still—and I know it'll sound like I'm going back on myself, but I'm not. Basically, like what they did was innovative, but there were still inaccuracies and there were still things that were wrong, inappropriate.
[39:39] Jimi: Do you know what I mean?
[39:40] Tommy: Yeah.
[39:41] Jimi: That isn't for Michael Arden to be penalized because it's his conception, and that is a—his concept is fantastic. But then you have to look at it as a unit and a whole thing for it to get best revival, and I don't know.
[39:57] Tommy: Yeah, because it's—I don't know.
[39:59] Jimi: It's not up for much else, really.
[40:01] Tommy: It's not.
[40:02] Jimi: Which is interesting. I think remember what—well, actually when we did the podcast, we said, "Gosh, it's gonna be really tough at Tony Time to think 'cause who do you give the actor awards to?"
[40:12] Tommy: Yeah, and none of them are nominated.
[40:14] Jimi: And none of them are nominated.
[40:16] Tommy: Is that them just trying to get out of a whole concept?
[40:19] Jimi: Or is it such an ensemble show?
[40:23] Tommy: That's a bullshit excuse.
[40:24] Jimi: But completely, but you know, for the record, it's up for three. Best revival, lighting design, and direction.
[40:31] Tommy: I bet you if it wins direction, it won't win revival.
[40:34] Jimi: I bet you if it doesn't win direction, it will win revival because that's how people vote.
[40:38] Tommy: Yeah, very true.
[40:40] Jimi: Um, yeah, I can see that happening. I don't know. I honestly don't have an opinion. I'd be happy with any of the three of them won.
[40:47] Tommy: Uh, yeah, absolutely.
[40:49] Jimi: You know, it's also like politically wise. A Tony win is great for a show that's running. Spring Awakening is the only one that's not running.
[40:58] Tommy: Spring Awakening closed before its time.
[41:00] Jimi: Yeah, absolutely. I wanted to see that. I had planned to see that.
[41:04] Tommy: Yeah.
[41:04] Jimi: And then it went away, and I was annoyed.
[41:07] Tommy: That's really unfortunate.
[41:08] Jimi: That's the Tony Awards.
[41:09] Tommy: Oh, we didn't talk about Best Book.
[41:11] Jimi: Oh, we didn't talk about Best Book.
[41:12] Tommy: Or Best Score.
[41:14] Jimi: Yeah.
[41:14] Tommy: I mean, well, we know Best Score is gonna be Hamilton.
[41:17] Jimi: Yeah.
[41:17] Tommy: You think so?
[41:18] Jimi: Are you serious?
[41:20] Tommy: Well, it's the best bit about Hamilton is the score.
[41:25] Jimi: Just checking.
[41:28] Tommy: I feel like you just opened a gateway into a different dimension by insinuating that Hamilton might not win.
[41:34] Jimi: Yeah.
[41:37] Tommy: I feel like that's more secure than it winning best musical.
[41:39] Jimi: I'm just making sure that you're still the real Jimi and you haven't been replaced by like a sports-playing imposter or something.
[41:47] Tommy: By the person from the other dimension that you just opened.
[41:50] Jimi: Yeah.
[41:54] Tommy: Um, Best Book, it's gotta go to Hamilton.
[41:57] Jimi: It's not gonna be the—
[41:59] Tommy: Yeah.
[42:01] Jimi: This is why we didn't talk about them because they're easy.
[42:01] Tommy: Yeah, that's true.
[42:03] Jimi: I do think, to go back a little bit, in Best Actor World, both of those winning book and score is a reason—is a more plausible reason that some voters will not vote for Miranda for best actor.
[42:23] Tommy: Yeah.
[42:24] Jimi: Because they'll be like, "Well, he's already got these. He doesn't need to matter. Let me vote for someone else."
[42:30] Tommy: Uh-huh.
[42:30] Jimi: Not because they've assessed it accurately or inaccurately. You know, no comment about better or worse actor-wise, but I think people will like, you know, if every answer is B on the multiple-choice quiz, you want to choose some other answers.
[42:46] Tommy: Yeah, exactly. Beautiful analogy.
[42:48] Jimi: And also he—he doesn't serve it.
[42:50] Tommy: Oh, sorry.
[42:51] Jimi: Um, watch the Tony Awards.
[42:56] Tommy: Did you know?
[42:56] Jimi: Jimmy, I learned this fact.
[42:58] Tommy: Um, tell me.
[42:59] Jimi: Commercials, a minute's worth of commercials on all of the American award shows. So the Oscars, the Grammys, the Tonys, and the Emmys.
[43:09] Tommy: Yeah.
[43:09] Jimi: A commercial is the most expensive on the Tonys.
[43:12] Tommy: I'm slightly surprised.
[43:14] Jimi: Not because the Tonys—the Tonys pale in comparison as far as audience is concerned. The Oscars get like 11 million and the Tonys get like two million.
[43:22] Tommy: But Tony Award viewers, legitimate advertising research fact, are smarter.
[43:29] Jimi: It's not even like a hoity-toity thing. Like there is research, and generally Tony Award viewers are smarter and therefore more affluent.
[43:37] Tommy: Um, which is just what the advertising says, and so people want to advertise their more expensive products during the Tony Awards.
[43:45] Jimi: So as you sit through that next commercial on the Tony Awards, you know, think back on that one.
[43:50] Tommy: I am going to. I'm gonna be analyzing.
[43:52] Jimi: Isn't that interesting?
[43:54] Tommy: Very much so.
[43:55] Jimi: Granted, I only read one article on the internet, so you know.
[43:58] Tommy: Asterisk.
[43:59] Jimi: It has to be true.
[44:03] Tommy: Very interesting.
[44:04] Jimi: I'm musing on that already. And that's Tony Awards.
[44:07] Tommy: Thanks for listening to our bonus episode.
[44:09] Jimi: Okay, anyway, we—
[44:09] Tommy: Yeah, yeah, oh my gosh, yeah, because we need to get back into the theater. So, uh, hurry up and go take your seat and get back into that.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
