Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Episode 1: Breaking Your Lease Early - Seven Best Practices

Yesterday, you signed a lease for an apartment in Brooklyn for $4100 per month. But all those career advice podcasts that you consumed on the Broadway Podcast Network finally paid off, and you got cast in a Broadway show…well…during its Off-Broadway run…in a state not exactly contiguous with New York... Read More

From the show: Learn to Live Better: A Housing Law Podcast

25 mins
11/27/25

About

Yesterday, you signed a lease for an apartment in Brooklyn for $4100 per month.

But all those career advice podcasts that you consumed on the Broadway Podcast Network finally paid off, and you got cast in a Broadway show…well…during its Off-Broadway run…in a state not exactly contiguous with New York. But this is the break you’ve been waiting for!

The problem is you just committed to paying a landlord in Brooklyn $50,000 over the next year, for an apartment you no longer need.

Fortunately, you have found this episode, “Best Practices for Breaking Your New York City Lease Early”. We are going to go over the law and the cases that you need to know, that are very much in tenants’ favor. Then we will wrap up with seven Tenant Takeaways, actionable tips to help you lessen your liability and, hopefully, negotiate your way out of your lease. Then you can put this chapter behind you without fear of the landlord chasing you all the way to Tupelo!

Let us know what housing law topics you would like to hear more about at mmaratto@itkowitz.com.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:02] Michelle Itkowitz: You just signed a lease for an apartment in Brooklyn for $4,100 a month. But today you got the call, the call you've been waiting for. All those Broadway Podcast Network episodes you watched about how to nail the audition, they paid off, my friend, because you have been cast as the lead in a Broadway show. Well, it's an off-Broadway show. Actually, it's an off-off-Broadway show. It's not even in a state that's contiguous with New York. But this is the break you've been waiting for. The problem is you just signed a lease, a binding legal contract that says that you're gonna pay a landlord in Brooklyn $50,000 over the next year for an apartment you no longer need. What should you do? Should you pick a fight with a landlord?

Should you sublet? What are your rights? What are your responsibilities? Fortunately, this episode is entitled Best Practices for Breaking Your New York City Lease Early. This is episode one of Learn to Live Better, a housing law podcast. New York City tenants have more rights than tenants anywhere else in America. But New York City tenants are also shockingly uneducated about what those rights are. A right you don't know you have is the same as no right at all. And there are so many bits of incomplete information out there. This podcast will change all that. In each episode, we look at current legal cases and statutes and the real-life apartment stories they give rise to here in the greatest city on earth.

And every episode ends with a tenant takeaway, so you have actionable information to help you make better choices. The law belongs to you, New York City, but your ownership of the law is only as great as your understanding of the law. So let's learn to live better. I am Michelle Itkowitz, and this is Learn to Live Better, a housing law podcast.

[1:56] Michelle Itkowitz: Okay. As always, we're gonna get started with some context. A lease is a binding legal contract, guys. You can't just decide that you don't want to do it anymore and call up the landlord and say, sorry. What we're going to be looking at is best practices for what you should do from the moment that you decide you're going to break your lease. What steps should you take? What things should you be doing that are going to give you the best chance to win a case if your landlord sues you for the rent? Although our goal isn't exactly to have you win a lawsuit. I mean, if God forbid you get sued, it would be great if you won the lawsuit. But our real goal is to help you make a deal. That's what you want to do in a lease break situation.

As soon as possible, you want to make a deal to put this whole incident in the rearview mirror so you don't have to be worrying about your landlord chasing you for the rent when you're off doing something else, when you've moved on to the next thing in your life. The thing is, your ability to make a deal is dependent on your ability to understand what your rights and responsibilities are. You need to understand what the law says about this, because that's where you're going to find your leverage. That's what you need. You need to understand what your real leverage is, what your strengths are, what your weaknesses are, because that's how you negotiate, and that's how you get to a deal.

[3:29] Michelle Itkowitz: We are going to start with real property law, section 227e. Enter stage right, real property law, section 227e. This is the law that is most implicated in a New York City residential lease break. So that's where we're gonna start. Okay, real property law section 227E. It's a fairly new law, actually. So this is what I'm gonna do. I'm gonna sort of read you the law, sort of paraphrase. Now I know what you're thinking. You're saying this woman is gonna read me a statute. That's boring. That's not a fun podcast. But here's the thing. Just stick with me a minute. The law is words, guys. The law is words. And your landlord and your landlord's lawyer, they're reading the words. So we're gonna read a few words too, not too many.

Here we go. So real property law section 227E tells us that if a tenant vacates a premises in violation of the terms of the lease, if you break the lease early, the landlord shall in good faith, and we're gonna talk about what good faith means, and according to the landlord's resources and abilities, take reasonable and customary actions to rent the apartment at fair market value or at the rent that you were paying, whichever is lower. In other words, the landlord can't just sit there and do nothing and sue you for the rent when you break the lease. The landlord must attempt to find someone else for the apartment. This is what's known as mitigating the damages. The landlord has the obligation to attempt to mitigate its damages, to lessen its damages.

And only when the landlord can't find someone else, then the landlord can go after you. But the landlord must list the apartment for the same rent that you were paying or fair market value, whichever rent is lower. Maybe you're breaking the lease at the six-month mark, and that six months made a difference, and now the value of the apartment's less. The landlord would have to list it for less in order to satisfy this duty to mitigate to lessen their damages, which is what they need to do. That's a requirement before they can go after you and sue you and get a judgment against you for the rent.

[5:46] Michelle Itkowitz: Okay. Now, this is what we're gonna do next. The statute just gives us these words, and that's great. But one thing we just we did on the landlord has to make a good faith effort to do this. What does that mean? How hard does the landlord have to work? What steps does the landlord have to take? Because we need to know that because we need to see if the landlord's doing those things. So that's why we're going to talk next about some cases. That's how the law works. We have a statute, and then we have real-life cases where people have real court battles and they get written up and published. And those cases guide judges and lawyers and future litigants for what choices they should make. So we're going to look at three cases.

[6:45] Michelle Itkowitz: Now, in this case, the tenant left owing five months of rent. The landlord listed the apartment promptly on Street Easy, Zillow, Trulia. But here's the thing the landlord listed the rent at a higher rent than the lease breaking tenant was paying. Now remember our statute, real property law 227e. It just said that's a no-no. The landlord can't list it any higher than what the tenant was paying or fair market rent, whichever is lower. But this is what the landlord said to the court. The landlord said, yes, the listing rent is higher, but if you also notice the listing includes rent concessions, like a free first month's rent or something like that, a number of free months' rent that would actually make the net effective rent that the new tenant would be paying the same or lower than what the lease breaking tenant was paying.

And then the landlord in Toporik also documented that it got 60 inquiries. It showed a whole spreadsheet and it provided where each inquiry came from, proving that it really did list the apartment, and also it documented the steps that the agent took as it tried to re-rent the apartment. The agent did nearly a dozen video walkthroughs and over three dozen live showings. And the landlord also provided comparable listings for other apartments, showing that the price hadn't really, the fair market price hadn't really gone down. And even though the landlord did these activities, the landlord was not able to find anybody for the apartment over those five months, and the court held that the landlord could sue and get a judgment against the tenant for the rent for those five months.

[8:39] Michelle Itkowitz: Let's look at another case comes to us in 2022 from the New York State Supreme Court. Now, fun fact whenever you hear me on this podcast talk about New York State Supreme Court, I'm not talking about the highest court in New York. As you know, on the federal level, the United States Supreme Court, that's the highest court. But in New York, the state Supreme Court is the lowest court, court of original jurisdiction, and that's where Aster comes from. Now, in Aster, it's a very interesting twist because the landlord rented or landlord listed, it listed the apartment immediately when the tenant left, but then it pulled the apartment from the listing. And the tenant said, wait a minute, you didn't leave that listing up.

You took the listing down. So you didn't make a good faith effort to lessen to mitigate your damages, and you can't come after me. But the landlord said no. The reason we pulled it was because after we listed it, we realized that the lease breaking tenant had messed something up in the apartment, something needed to be fixed, so they had to take it off of the market for a period of time to correct that so that they could list it and find another tenant. And the court went with that and said, okay, the landlord has met its duty to mitigate and it can sue the tenant, even though the apartment was briefly pulled from the market for this reason.

[10:08] Michelle Itkowitz: So you see why we're looking at cases. This gives us ideas of what best practices might be in a lease break situation. You're going to hear me mention this case later when we get to the tenant takeaways and the best practices. Another Supreme Court case from 2022. Now, in this case, the tenant signed the lease and never moved in. So that's harsh. The landlord went after the tenant and was probably gonna get 12 months of rent if we didn't have this statute, real property law 227E. The landlord listed the unit right away, but for $50 more than the lease breaking tenant was paying. But this one didn't have any rent concessions or net effective rent. It was just listed for $50 more. And the landlord said, wait a minute, court, I can get $50 more.

The market has gone up, so I want to list it for $50 more. And the court said, well, that's fine, but when you do that, you're not making the good faith effort to mitigate that real property law, Section 227E requires you to make that's going to enable you to be able to sue this tenant. You can't sue the tenant. So finally, the landlord dropped the price back to what the lease breaking tenant had been paying, and then they found somebody. But the court held while the rent was listed at $50 more than was in the lease, that wasn't meeting the real property law section 227E requirement, and therefore the landlord didn't have the right to sue the tenant for that rent.

[11:43] Michelle Itkowitz: So this is the statute in action. Okay. So next we're going to get to the seven best practices for breaking your New York City lease early. But first we're going to do some housekeeping. Who am I? I'm Michelle Itkowitz. If you want to see my bio, I'm not going to get into it here. You can look at my website at itkowitz.com, I T K O W I T Z. But keep in mind, none of this is legal advice. This is not legal advice, and I'm not your lawyer. But because I am a lawyer, I am required to say that this may be considered legal advertising.

[12:19] Michelle Itkowitz: If it's legal advertising, it is terrible because the next thing I'm going to say is please don't contact me. This podcast is not a commercial for me or my law firm. This is really simply the podcast or one of the podcasts that I always wanted to make. What I do want to hear from you on is what topics would you like to hear about. So it's time for the tenant takeaway.

[12:45] Michelle Itkowitz: So tenant takeaway time, we're going to be looking at the seven best practices for breaking your New York City lease early, and we're going to do a sample deal, a deal example. Every situation is going to be different, but we're just going to give you an example of where all this is leading to, so you can make that deal and move on with your life and your creativity. Okay, best practice number one.

[13:13] Michelle Itkowitz: The first thing we're going to do is get your head in order. The best defense is not necessarily a good offense. People call me all the time when they're anticipating breaking their lease, and they always say the same thing. Oh, the handle on the cold water in my second bathroom in my powder room is a little stuck, and the clock on my microwave oven is off by a few minutes, and I can't stand living like this, and I have to break this lease.

[13:44] Michelle Itkowitz: If it's people's instinct to call and start yelling at the landlord and say, saying, This is a bad apartment, you need to let me out. Now, here's the thing this is New York City, and I've been a housing lawyer in New York City for 30 years. And let me tell you, there are occasionally people who are subject to conditions that are so bad that their rental obligation is completely suspended. And that is not something that you would wish on your worst enemy. Those conditions are horrible and dangerous, and it's probably not the conditions that you're in. Hopefully, God forbid.

[14:23] Michelle Itkowitz: So here's the thing. When you call up the landlord and start screaming, the landlord understands that what you're complaining about as conditions are not enough to break the lease. The landlord does housing all day long because that's the landlord's job. So the landlord knows that you're making a losing argument. And how does that help you in a negotiation to start out looking like you don't understand what's going on? Also, remember I said our goal here is to make a deal, and the landlord is who you need to make a deal with. So starting off by beating up the landlord, the person you need to make a deal with, that's probably not the best place to start.

[15:08] Michelle Itkowitz: So best defense is not always a good offense in the lease break negotiation world. On top of that, I'm also going to suggest that you try to be part of the solution. So the landlord's going to want to show the unit as soon as possible. And that might be very inconvenient for you, especially if you're moving, but that's too bad. Cooperate. Cooperate with as many showings as possible because if the landlord finds someone, you're off the hook.

[15:34] Michelle Itkowitz: Also, let's say there is something broken in the apartment, like maybe there's a broken window or something. Let the workman come in and fix whatever it is to get the apartment in tip-top shape to be re-rented. This is a little counterintuitive. You're saying to yourself, Well, I'm leaving. I don't care if the upper pane of a window in a room I never use is broken, but if things would need to be fixed to make it easier for the landlord to rent the unit, then just cooperate. Cooperate as much as you can.

[16:08] Michelle Itkowitz: Next, if you don't have a deal by the time you vacate, make sure you document your exit. Let the landlord know you're gone. The landlord's duty to mitigate is not going to kick in until the landlord knows that you're not in the apartment anymore. If they can't rent an apartment that they think you're still in. So if there's a portal, communicate through the portal and say, on this date, I am surrendering, I'm giving the keys to the super or to the managing agent or I'm dropping them off in your office, whatever it is.

[16:54] Michelle Itkowitz: Also, on top of that, if there's an email address you have, also write a letter, just a one-page letter saying this is the date I'm surrendering. Send the letter by email, send the letter to the managing agent's address, which you will find online on HPD. Send that by overnight mail so you have a record it went. So document when you've left. For that matter, and number four, we have document the condition of the apartment.

[17:21] Michelle Itkowitz: Remember the case we just looked at. So again, it's counterintuitive. You know you're not getting your security back because you're breaking the lease, so maybe you don't carefully document the condition you leave the apartment in because you're not getting your security back anyway. But you should go through with a video and document that the apartment is in good shape because you don't want the landlord to be saying to a court. Well, the reason I didn't list it right away was because I had to do all this work because of the condition the tenant left it in. Document the condition the apartment is in before you leave.

[17:56] Michelle Itkowitz: Okay, as soon as you leave, start. If you don't have a deal, you're gonna start monitoring the landlord's efforts to mitigate. So if you saw the apartment on Street Easy, look on Street Easy and see if the landlord is listing the apartment. Look everywhere where the apartment should be listed. Now it's a little difficult to prove a negative, but if you're looking and you're not seeing it, maybe take some screenshots and just make a note that it's not there.

[18:23] Michelle Itkowitz: If you do see the apartment listed, again, you're checking, is it no higher than what my rent was? And even, even if, listen carefully, even if it is listed at your rent, you still need then to do at number six. We have to do some market research. Because remember, the landlord is only satisfying its duty to mitigate that allows it to sue you. If it's listing that apartment at the rent you were paying or at the fair market rent.

[18:59] Michelle Itkowitz: And again, the market in New York City moves fairly rapidly. So if it's dropped and now the fair market rent for the apartment would be lower, that's how they satisfy their duty to mitigate. So they might be listing the apartment at your rent, but that still might not be satisfying their duty to mitigate and allowing them to come after you. Maybe the market has fallen and the fair market rent is lower. So look at comps, pull comparable rents for apartments on that block, same size, same floor, same condition, that kind of thing. The more you pull, the better. But that can really protect you.

[19:39] Michelle Itkowitz: Okay. Do not sublet. Number seven, our final takeaway is do not sublet. Oh my God, I don't even know where to start with this one. Okay, let's look at it this way. You are at a place where you don't want to be a tenant in Brooklyn anymore, under my opening scenario. So you're going to become a landlord in Brooklyn. How does that make sense? The point is if you're not letting go of the apartment, the landlord's duty to mitigate isn't even kicking in.

[20:09] Michelle Itkowitz: So all of that real property law 2278, that's not even at play anymore. But it's so much worse because now you're a landlord. And what are you gonna do if your tenant, if your subtenant stops paying you? So now you're not only owing the landlord the rent, but now you're hiring a lawyer in New York City to chase the subtenant for rent and try to evict them. That's a terrible position to be in.

[20:41] Michelle Itkowitz: And as bad as that is, it gets worse. It gets worse. Let me let me give you this one. Let's say you don't sublet, and the landlord makes a good faith effort, doesn't find anybody, and you owe every dime of rent to the end of the term. That's an unfortunate situation, but I'll give you one even worse. You sublet it. Your subtenant stops paying, and your subtenant at the end of the term of the lease does not get out. They stay. They're the thing that wouldn't leave. You're still liable, even after the term of the lease, to pay the landlord rent because the lease required you at the end of the term to return vacant possession to the landlord.

[21:24] Michelle Itkowitz: That's what every lease says. And you haven't returned vacant possession to the landlord because your non-paying subtenant is sitting there. So your liability doesn't even cut off at the 12th month if it's a one-year lease. Now you're really stuck. Now this is where you're going to tell me, don't worry, it's my the subtenant is my friend, it's my buddy. The problem with that is everybody's your friend until they lose their job and can't pay the rent.

[21:49] Michelle Itkowitz: Or I'll do you one better, because I've seen this one a number of times as well. Your friend, okay, they're okay, but they enter a relationship while they're living there, and their significant other moves in. And then they have a fight, and your friend moves out and leaves a virtual stranger in the apartment who's now not paying. That's not something that I would recommend.

[22:17] Michelle Itkowitz: Okay, what would I recommend? Let's look at an example of what I would call a good deal. And again, every situation is completely different. I just wanted to leave you with something. How would this look? Where are we going with this? All right, this is just an example. So let's say that you're three months into a 12-month lease when you want to break the lease. When you get your big break and you're off Off-Broadway show, okay.

[22:44] Michelle Itkowitz: You say to the landlord, how about this? Landlord, keep the security, and I will pay three more months' rent all at once before I leave. That gives you seven months of rent. You've got my first three, you've got my security, you've got the three I'm paying now. And you will certainly rent this apartment in the next four months after I leave. So you won't lose anything, you'll actually be ahead. And then just let me go.

[23:12] Michelle Itkowitz: So I don't have to pay those last six months. Will it work? You don't know till you try. But the point is you're armed with the fact that if the landlord says to you, well, you owe me all this rent, you could educate the landlord or let the landlord know that you've been educated and say, you have a duty to mitigate real property law 227E. And you need to get out there and do it, and let's work together. I'll let you show it, whatever it is, and hopefully you will make a deal.

[23:53] Michelle Itkowitz: But your ownership of the law is only as great as your understanding of the law. So let's learn to live better. I'm Michelle Itkowitz, and this is Learn to Live Better, a housing law podcast on the Broadway Podcast Network.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred