Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Episode 5: NYC Rental Housing Types Demystified

You are moving to New York City, and you have questions about NYC rental housing. Or, you have lived in New York City all your life, and you still have questions about NYC Housing! Rent Stabilization, Rent Control, the Good Cause Eviction Law, Affordable Housing, Co-ops, Condos, Co-living... Read More

From the show: Learn to Live Better: A Housing Law Podcast

25 mins
Jan 12

About

You are moving to New York City, and you have questions about NYC rental housing. Or, you have lived in New York City all your life, and you still have questions about NYC Housing!

Rent Stabilization, Rent Control, the Good Cause Eviction Law, Affordable Housing, Co-ops, Condos, Co-living. Welcome to the most confusing rental housing landscape in the country.

Not to worry. In this episode, we explain everything!

Links:

Tenant Law Podcast Website

New York City Rent Guidelines Board

New York State Division of Housing and Community Renewal

Suggest future topics at questions@tenantlearningplatform.com

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Michelle Itkowitz: You're moving to New York City and you need to learn about New York City housing.

[0:04] Michelle Itkowitz: Or you've lived in New York City for years, you've lived here all your life, and you still need to learn about New York City housing.

[0:11] Michelle Itkowitz: Rent stabilization, rent control, the good cause eviction law, affordable housing, co-ops, condos, co-living.

[0:19] Michelle Itkowitz: Welcome to the most confusing crowded housing landscape in the country.

[0:24] Michelle Itkowitz: Fortunately, this episode is entitled New York City Housing Types Demystified.

[0:31] Michelle Itkowitz: New York City tenants have more rights than tenants anywhere else in America.

[0:36] Michelle Itkowitz: But New York City tenants are also shockingly uneducated about what those rights are.

[0:40] Michelle Itkowitz: A right you don't know you have is the same as no right at all.

[0:44] Michelle Itkowitz: And there are so many bits of incomplete information out there.

[0:48] Michelle Itkowitz: This podcast will change all that.

[0:50] Michelle Itkowitz: In each episode, we look at current legal cases and statutes and the real life apartment stories they give rise to here in the greatest city on earth.

[1:01] Michelle Itkowitz: And every episode ends with a tenant takeaway so you have actionable information to help you make better choices.

[1:09] Michelle Itkowitz: The law belongs to you, New York City, but your ownership of the law is only as great as your understanding of the law.

[1:16] Michelle Itkowitz: So let's learn to live better.

[1:19] Michelle Itkowitz: I am Michelle Itkowitz, and this is Learn to Live Better, a Housing Law Podcast.

[1:29] Michelle Itkowitz: Okay, so there are 2.6 million units of rental housing in New York City.

[1:34] Michelle Itkowitz: 2.6 million apartments.

[1:38] Michelle Itkowitz: By the way, I'm getting my data today mostly from the New York City Rent Guidelines Board.

[1:45] Michelle Itkowitz: And I made you a chart.

[1:46] Michelle Itkowitz: Don't worry if you're not watching.

[1:48] Michelle Itkowitz: I'll never do a podcast that you have to have a visual.

[1:52] Michelle Itkowitz: But if you are watching, I made you a pie chart.

[1:55] Michelle Itkowitz: That 2.6 can be broken down broadly into two large categories.

[2:00] Michelle Itkowitz: This is what people really need to know.

[2:03] Michelle Itkowitz: 700,000 of those units of housing are free market.

[2:08] Michelle Itkowitz: And 1.9 million of those units of housing are what I call, this is a term I made up, forever rental homes.

[2:18] Michelle Itkowitz: Forever homes, but they're rental apartments.

[2:20] Michelle Itkowitz: What do I mean by that?

[2:22] Michelle Itkowitz: A forever home is an apartment that you can only be evicted from if you fail to pay the rent or if you break the rules of the tenancy.

[2:31] Michelle Itkowitz: And generally, with forever homes, there is some kind of government suppression of the rent level so that the rent isn't just at the market level.

[2:42] Michelle Itkowitz: A forever home is more affordable and you can only be evicted for certain causes.

[2:47] Michelle Itkowitz: It could be a home that you stay in forever.

[2:50] Michelle Itkowitz: All right, so let's start by talking about the free market apartments because that's what people are going to be most familiar with.

[2:58] Michelle Itkowitz: All right, in a free market apartment, upon renewal, the landlord's able to raise the rent as much as it wants to.

[3:05] Michelle Itkowitz: And if the tenant doesn't agree to the proposed rent increase, then the landlord can freely evict the tenant.

[3:13] Michelle Itkowitz: Now I just want to be a little careful here.

[3:16] Michelle Itkowitz: That doesn't mean that there are not lots of protections in place for all New York City tenants.

[3:22] Michelle Itkowitz: For example, a tenant could never be evicted for a discriminatory reason because they're in a certain category.

[3:31] Michelle Itkowitz: Also, there are certain notice requirements in place if a landlord wants to terminate a tenancy or raise the rent more than 5%.

[3:40] Michelle Itkowitz: Also, a landlord cannot attempt to evict a tenant who has paid the rent just because the tenant has made a complaint about repairs.

[3:49] Michelle Itkowitz: There are certain checks and notices in place that will pump the brakes on an eviction.

[3:55] Michelle Itkowitz: But none of that converts a free market apartment into a forever rental home.

[4:01] Michelle Itkowitz: So let's start talking about forever rental homes.

[4:05] Michelle Itkowitz: So I'm going to start with two categories that are smaller.

[4:08] Michelle Itkowitz: Together they make up half a million apartments.

[4:11] Michelle Itkowitz: We're going to start with co-ops.

[4:14] Michelle Itkowitz: All right, the first thing I want to do is distinguish between co-ops and condos.

[4:20] Michelle Itkowitz: These are two terms that people conflate all the time.

[4:24] Michelle Itkowitz: A condominium apartment is just like a house.

[4:27] Michelle Itkowitz: It's a piece of real property that you would buy.

[4:31] Michelle Itkowitz: You would get a deed for a condo.

[4:33] Michelle Itkowitz: That's not something we're ever going to be concerned with here because we're concerned with rental housing.

[4:38] Michelle Itkowitz: Co-ops, however, are rental housing.

[4:40] Michelle Itkowitz: And this is where people get confused.

[4:42] Michelle Itkowitz: They sometimes say, wait a minute, I didn't think co-ops were rental housing.

[4:45] Michelle Itkowitz: I thought you bought a co-op.

[4:47] Michelle Itkowitz: Yes and no.

[4:48] Michelle Itkowitz: When you buy a co-op, what you're really doing is you're buying shares in a corporation that owns the building.

[4:55] Michelle Itkowitz: And the building then issues you a long-term lease, a 99-year lease.

[5:01] Michelle Itkowitz: That's why this is a form of forever rental housing.

[5:06] Michelle Itkowitz: Now you can take a bank loan to buy the shares, and sometimes people get confused and think that's a mortgage.

[5:14] Michelle Itkowitz: It's not really a mortgage, it's a security interest.

[5:18] Michelle Itkowitz: And you have to be generally approved by the co-op board before you can buy a co-op.

[5:26] Michelle Itkowitz: And there are 310,000 co-ops in New York City.

[5:31] Michelle Itkowitz: The thing with co-ops, though, is there's no government suppression of the rent level.

[5:36] Michelle Itkowitz: And a co-op, your rent is really determined because you're paying a share of your building's operating costs.

[5:43] Michelle Itkowitz: But again, I just want co-ops to be on people's radar because you might be subletting from a co-op shareholder.

[5:49] Michelle Itkowitz: And there, the thing I really want you to walk away with is knowing that usually for co-op sublets, the subtenant needs board approval.

[6:00] Michelle Itkowitz: And I see this happen a lot.

[6:01] Michelle Itkowitz: A lot of times people don't seek that out before they put their subtenant in.

[6:06] Michelle Itkowitz: And then that can be troublesome for you in the future as a subtenant of a co-op shareholder.

[6:12] Michelle Itkowitz: So if you're gonna sublet a co-op, always ask the shareholder if they need board approval or if you can obtain board approval.

[6:23] Michelle Itkowitz: Another type of housing that's a forever home is needs-based housing.

[6:28] Michelle Itkowitz: Needs-based housing are apartments that one must qualify for based on one's income and assets being below a certain threshold.

[6:38] Michelle Itkowitz: And once a tenant is admitted to this type of housing, the laws generally require that the tenant be perpetually renewed as long as the tenant pays the rent, doesn't violate the terms of the tenancy, and income recertifies.

[6:51] Michelle Itkowitz: The rent is always kept very low by certain formulas because the whole point of needs-based housing is to provide affordable housing for people to make their homes in.

[7:03] Michelle Itkowitz: What you should know about this is there are very long waiting lists for this type of housing, and there is a lot of paperwork to fill out to get into it.

[7:12] Michelle Itkowitz: So you could just Google this, you can start on a New York City website portal, and it will take you through that.

[7:20] Michelle Itkowitz: But neither of these housing modalities are things you can slip right into.

[7:25] Michelle Itkowitz: It takes a minute to buy a co-op and it takes a minute to get admitted to needs-based housing.

[7:32] Michelle Itkowitz: Let's move on to the big categories of forever homes that are much more accessible to most people.

[7:38] Michelle Itkowitz: Rent stabilization is our big player at somewhere between 900,000 and a million units.

[7:45] Michelle Itkowitz: Okay, rent stabilization.

[7:47] Michelle Itkowitz: It started in the 1970s.

[7:49] Michelle Itkowitz: Once a tenant's admitted to a rent stabilized apartment, the law requires that such tenancy be renewed by the landlord as long as the tenant pays the rent and follows the rules of the tenancy.

[7:59] Michelle Itkowitz: Now you notice I didn't say here, and as long as the tenant income recertifies, as I did with needs-based housing, and that's because rent stabilization is not needs-based.

[8:11] Michelle Itkowitz: You could be a billionaire and live in a rent-stabilized apartment, and I've actually seen that.

[8:16] Michelle Itkowitz: Not needs-based.

[8:17] Michelle Itkowitz: Anybody can live in a rent-stabilized apartment.

[8:19] Michelle Itkowitz: Now, if you're rent stabilized, it means that your rent can only go up by small annual percentage increases that are decided by the New York City Rent Guidelines Board.

[8:32] Michelle Itkowitz: Different people get appointed to this board, and they come up with these increments every year.

[8:45] Michelle Itkowitz: In regular market rate apartments.

[8:47] Michelle Itkowitz: And the longer you're there, the more the gulf grows between what you're paying and what the market would be paying because it's perpetually lower percentages that rent increases are going up by.

[9:01] Michelle Itkowitz: So the current renewal rates authorized by the New York City Rent Guidelines Board, effective from October 1st, 2025, going through September 30th, 2026, are 3% for a one-year lease and 4.5% for a two-year lease.

[9:16] Michelle Itkowitz: And that's the other thing.

[9:17] Michelle Itkowitz: You, as the tenant, get to choose if you're going to renew for one year or for two years.

[9:22] Michelle Itkowitz: The landlord doesn't decide that you get to pick which one you want.

[9:25] Michelle Itkowitz: A big unique feature of rent stabilization that's not talked about enough is that rent stabilized tenants have a whole extra way for enforcing their housing rights.

[9:36] Michelle Itkowitz: In the free market, if you don't like what your landlord did, you could sue your landlord, which costs a lot of money and takes a lot of time, or you could stop paying your rent and then your landlord would sue you, and you end up in housing court and you can fight out your dispute with the landlord there.

[9:51] Michelle Itkowitz: But I've never liked that as an option for tenants because if you're the aggrieved party, but you stop paying it and get sued, now it looks like you're someone who doesn't pay your rent, which could have implications for you and other parts of your life.

[10:05] Michelle Itkowitz: And rent stabilization, tenants have an agency, a New York State agency called the New York State Division of Housing and Community Renewal, the DHCR.

[10:15] Michelle Itkowitz: And rent stabilized tenants are allowed to bring certain types of cases and this quasi-judicial arm of DHCR.

[10:24] Michelle Itkowitz: So if you have a grievance against your landlord, you can bring it there, certain types of cases.

[10:29] Michelle Itkowitz: And you don't have to go there, it's all done through the mails.

[10:33] Michelle Itkowitz: And it you don't have to pay a fee for these cases.

[10:36] Michelle Itkowitz: And DHCR has a great deal of expertise about rent stabilization.

[10:40] Michelle Itkowitz: It's not perfect, it takes a long time, but it's a good option.

[10:47] Michelle Itkowitz: Also a big unique feature of rent stabilization, and you'll also see this in needs-based housing typically, is that a family member who has resided with you for a certain amount of time, or someone who's in a family-like relationship with you who resides with you for a certain amount of time before you vacate the apartment, might be able to do what we call succeed to the apartment.

[11:10] Michelle Itkowitz: It's a fancy word for inherit the apartment.

[11:13] Michelle Itkowitz: Your family can literally inherit your rent stabilized tenancy under certain circumstances.

[11:18] Michelle Itkowitz: I have a case right now where I'm trying to save a rent stabilized apartment for a couple in their 50s, and one of them was born in the apartment.

[11:31] Michelle Itkowitz: That person's father moved into the apartment in 1969.

[11:36] Michelle Itkowitz: I'm born in 1967, and I just think it's wild that I am litigating at 58 years old about an apartment that the family moved into when I was two.

[11:48] Michelle Itkowitz: I mean, that's rent stabilization.

[11:50] Michelle Itkowitz: And they have a teenage child.

[11:51] Michelle Itkowitz: So if I can save this apartment, this is a tenancy that now spans 56 years and three generations.

[11:59] Michelle Itkowitz: That's the power of rent stabilization.

[12:01] Michelle Itkowitz: By the way, before we go off of rent stabilization, there is another rent regulatory system called rent control.

[12:08] Michelle Itkowitz: This is another thing that people always conflate, like condo co-op.

[12:12] Michelle Itkowitz: So a lot of people mix up rent control, rent stabilization.

[12:15] Michelle Itkowitz: Rent control was another housing system that ended, I believe, in the late 60s.

[12:21] Michelle Itkowitz: And as rent control tenants leave their apartments, rent control goes away with them.

[12:27] Michelle Itkowitz: Those apartments either go into the free market or rent stabilization, depending on a bunch of factors. But rent control's just been going away over the years. And at this point, I think there's like 24,000 rent control apartments, and you're not going to rent one because I mean, I suppose if you move in with your grandmother, maybe you could succeed to it. But other than that, rent control is not really on the radar anymore. All right, so now here's the thing. The biggest change in housing since we got rent stabilization in 1974. The easiest way maybe to think about this is this. Rent stabilization and good cause eviction, they end up largely in the same places. Your tenancy has to be renewed unless you're not paying the rent or breaking the rules. Neither are needs-based, and both have artificial caps on the rent. The rent can only go up so much in both systems. The thing is, however, they approach getting to that place from completely different angles.

[14:04] Michelle Itkowitz: I found an April 17th, 2024 City Limits article that had some methodology for estimating how many that sounded good to me. They're estimating that 400,000 apartments are covered by the good cause eviction law. One good thing about good cause eviction that is better than rent stabilization, and this is really the only thing you're gonna hear me say about good cause that's better than rent stabilization, is that the landlord is required to give you a notice on every lease renewal or every court document, letting you know your status as yes or no a good cause eviction apartment. And if the answer is no, they're required to explain why. That's a very good aspect of good cause eviction that does not exist in rent stabilization, which is a story for another day.

[14:55] Michelle Itkowitz: So the rent increases on good cause eviction. They are limited, and they are limited by a formula that has to do with a change in the consumer price index plus five percent. Don't don't check out on me on that one. I can't stand this either. I have never had to think about the consumer price index, and I could care if I ever had to think about the consumer price index. Fortunately, you don't really have to think about the consumer price index because the thing is the calculation is done for you and it's published. It's published by the agency I mentioned earlier, the DHCR. So you could just Google it and you can always find what the good cause eviction rent percentage increase threshold is. Right now, as I record this, I think it's 8.79%.

Now, no, think about that. It's almost nine percent. What did I just say the rent stabilization increases were? For a one-year lease, three percent. And for a two-year lease, 4.5%. That's very different than nine percent. But actually, there's more because under good cause eviction, there's also a very big loophole written into the statute whereby the landlord can attempt to raise the rent beyond that threshold based on certain costs that are enumerated in the statute. We're just going to need more case law on this to see how this is working. But your rent is not going to stay as stable in good cause eviction as it does in rent stabilization, at least not at this point.

[16:34] Michelle Itkowitz: Also, the good cause eviction law lacks a provision giving good cause eviction law tenants access to an agency like DHCR to litigate in an easy forum for disputes with their landlord. So right now it looks like with good cause eviction, if there's a fight between a landlord and tenant, it has to take place in the court system, and that's unfortunate. Also, good cause eviction does not have a succession option. It's not like families can inherit good cause eviction law apartments from each other. That's just not what the statute is. All right. So now we're gonna backtrack just for a second back to free market, and we're gonna talk about something called co-living. Co-living is a subset of free market housing, but it's growing fast and it's very innovative and it's important, and we have to talk about it.

[17:29] Michelle Itkowitz: Co-living is an arrangement by which a landlord rents an apartment to a group of tenants for at least 30 days. This is not short-term renting, where the tenants occupy and share the apartment. It's all about roommates in co-living. And this is an arrangement that the landlord participates in and facilitates. The tenants have flexible terms in co-living. And this really differentiates it from regular free market housing. In general, landlords don't like it when you make a lease and break it. But in co-living, it's set up so you can break your lease. That is allowed. You can give a certain notice and break your lease early. Flexibility is a big advantage for tenants in co-living. And if a roommate does do that, if a roommate breaks the lease, then you as tenants don't have to go out and find a replacement.

The landlord agrees in the lease that it will help you find a roommate. This makes a lot of sense to me because landlords are in a much better position to aggregate roommates than tenants are. You only have your own personal network. And but a landlord is in the housing business. They have brokers, they had advertisements. The landlord will go out and try to find you a new roomie. While the landlord is looking for the roommate in co-living, the landlord will also offer the tenants, it's built right into the lease, rent relief so that they don't have to make up the share that that roommate was paying.

[19:13] Michelle Itkowitz: And co-living, the apartments are typically furnished, and that's another nice thing. And there's also other amenities. Sometimes there's cleaning. There's a lot of emphasis on community and co-living. They'll have maybe thematic programming, a potluck dinner, speakers, the barbecue in the yard. The advantages of co-living for tenants are affordability, flexibility, convenience, limited liability for bad roommates, and community. And the advantage of co-living for the landlord is they're getting a higher price per square foot for all of this. So the actual roommates are paying less, but as an aggregate, the landlord's getting more for the apartment than they would in a regular free market setting.

It's controversial because there are bad co-living operators out there that are not doing co-living at all. They're just people renting rooms in regular apartments, which is highly illegal. You cannot rent an individual room in a New York City apartment. That is a no-no. It's illegal and it's also extremely dangerous. It could be a fire hazard. Someone could get hurt. If you're out looking at co-living, try to go with the more reputable companies that have a track record. And also just make sure you're renting an apartment. You're not renting a room. And also use common sense. Always look around, make sure is this apartment too crowded. Do I have egress and ingress? Can I get in and out in a fire? God forbid. Those are some things to keep in mind in co-living.

[20:42] Michelle Itkowitz: All right, so let's sum this up with another pie chart that you don't need to look at. Free market apartments, 700,000. Rent stabilization, 984,000. Good cause eviction coming in at 400,000. Needs base, 220,000. Co-ops, 310,000. And co-living, I have no idea. I estimated on my chart 20,000 apartments. I could be wrong by a factor of 10. Co-living is really growing. And it's important because it addresses the affordability crisis in New York. All right, we are going to do some tenant takeaways, but before we do that, this is not legal advice. I am not your lawyer, but because I am a lawyer, this might be considered legal advertising. If it's legal advertising, it's just terrible because I'm asking you not to contact me.

This podcast is not a commercial for me or my law firm. This is just the podcast that I always wanted to make. What I would like to hear from you on is what topics do you want to hear more about? I have the email on the show notes. It is time for the tenant takeaway.

[21:49] Michelle Itkowitz: Tenant takeaway time. If you're new to New York, and even if you're not new to New York, co-ops and needs-based housing are forms of housing that are forever homes. They're forever homes, but they both take a lot of time to get into. You don't just slide into owning a co-op. You don't just slide into an affordable housing situation. There's application procedures. Again, co-ops, I really want to have on your radar because you might come in sublet one. And in that case, really your crucial question is did the board approve this sublet? Do they have to approve the sublet? Because you don't want the board to start coming down on the shareholder who all of a sudden tells you that you have to get out.

The takeaway, I think, is rent stabilization beats the good cause eviction law right now, anyway. I have a case I'm involved in right now, and the tenants are good cause eviction law tenants, no doubt, good cause eviction all the way. But the tenants nevertheless are suing the landlord fighting, saying that the landlord wrongly deregulated the apartment, and it really should be a rent stabilized apartment. They're fighting for rent stabilization, even though they have good cause eviction, because rent stabilization beats good cause eviction. However, good cause eviction beats the free market. Because we're in the worst housing crisis we've been in since 1968. There's a 1.4% vacancy rate. And I mean, you don't really need numbers.

You can feel it. The rents are high, the availability is low. That's why something like co-living being on your radar, I think is important. And we should really look at all of these different housing modalities. This episode was a little different because it wasn't about a new case or a new law. But I thought we had to cover this because these are the questions that people have for me all the time. And it also makes it easier for me to cover topics that have to do with any of these different types of housing. Rent stabilization, good cause eviction law, co-ops, co-living, whatever it is. I can refer back to this episode if people want an overview of how that particular type of housing fits into the overall picture of the New York City housing landscape.

[24:11] Michelle Itkowitz: Remember, New York City, the law belongs to you, but your ownership of the law is only as great as your understanding of the law. So let's learn to live better. I am Michelle Itkowitz, and this is Learn to Live Better, a housing law podcast, and the

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred