You have been sued by your landlord, and you just wish the case would go away, because with a bit more time, you would have the money to move, which you were planning on doing anyway. You just need a break... Read More
From the show: Learn to Live Better: A Housing Law Podcast
About
You have been sued by your landlord, and you just wish the case would go away, because with a bit more time, you would have the money to move, which you were planning on doing anyway. You just need a break. Therefore, in this episode, we look at a Housing Court Hack regarding the inadequate apartment description defense in eviction lawsuits. We also cover where tenants often go wrong in their negotiations with their landlords and offer some tips for obtaining better deal outcomes.
Links:
• Case Mentioned: Ahmed v. Reid, 77 Misc.3d 1213(A) [New York City Civil Court, Kings County 2022].
• Today’s Case: Osibodu v. Fehintola, 2025 WL 4062273 [New York City Civil Court, Kings County 2025].
• Suggest future topics at questions@tenantlearningplatform.com.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Michelle Itkowitz: You've been sued by your landlord, and you just wish the case would go away so you had the time and the money to move, which you were planning on doing anyway. You just need a break. This is the desire I hear tenants state all the time. Therefore, in this episode of Learn to Live Better, we look at a housing court hack that might give you the time and the space that you need. New York City tenants have more rights than tenants anywhere else in America, but New York City tenants are also shockingly uneducated about what those rights are. A right you don't know you have is the same as no right at all. And there are so many bits of incomplete information out there. This podcast will change all that.
In each episode, we look at current legal cases and statutes and the real-life apartment stories they give rise to here in the greatest city on earth. And every episode ends with a tenant takeaway so you have actionable information to help you make better choices. The law belongs to you, New York City, but your ownership of the law is only as great as your understanding of the law. So let's learn to live better. I am Michelle Itkowitz, and this is Learn to Live Better, a housing law podcast.
[1:22] Michelle Itkowitz: This is a housing court hack episode of Learn to Live Better. If you look at my back catalog on the Tenant Law podcast feed, I have six other episodes like this, Housing Court Hack. A housing court hack is where I tell you about a technical defense in housing court that a lot of tenants could be using, but that you wouldn't know about if you didn't have a lawyer. A housing court hack is not a way to substantively win your case and make it go away forever. Rather, a housing court hack is a way to possibly get the current case against you dismissed because your landlord's lawyer did something procedurally wrong. This can possibly give you the space and the time you need to negotiate a better deal for yourself. But first, as always, let's start by setting the stage with some context.
[2:16] Michelle Itkowitz: Okay, so first we're going to start by talking about some background, some context you need to understand today's case. When your landlord sues you, they're suing you in the civil court of the city of New York, the housing parts of that court, so we call that housing court. And what's happening is the landlord is prosecuting against you a special type of lawsuit called a summary proceeding for the recovery of real property, otherwise known as an eviction case. Eviction cases are governed by a special law called the real property actions in proceedings law. Real property actions and proceedings law section 7413 says every petition, the petition is the lawsuit papers, every petition shall describe the premises from which removal is sought.
[3:11] Michelle Itkowitz: So case law has expanded this, and our rule is this that the petition, the lawsuit papers, must set forth the address and or the configuration of the premises sought to be recovered, your apartment, with sufficient precision to allow a marshal to execute on the warrant. Even if the description of the premises in the court papers in the petition reflects exactly the wording of how your apartment is described in your lease, even if they're exactly the same, that's still not good enough if what's there in the lease is itself confusing. In other words, the landlord's not getting off the hook if you say, hey, wait a minute, the description of my apartment is confusing. I don't know how anybody could find this apartment if they had to evict.
If the landlord says, but well, I followed exactly how your apartment is described in the lease, that's still not going to be good enough. It's not about matching the lease. No, no, no. It's about making it so if somebody was coming to evict, God forbid, they could find which apartment to evict from.
[4:25] Michelle Itkowitz: Let me start to give you some real-world examples of how this gets confusing. Well, there's a case from 2022 called Ahmed versus Reid. Maybe I'll put a link to that in the show notes. In that case, the housing court dismissed an eviction case where the lease described the subject premises, the apartment, as the first floor. The lease says first floor. But the apartment was actually physically on the second floor of the building. Why? Because the first floor in that particular building was described as the ground floor. The same apartment could potentially be called the first floor or the ground floor. In New York City, those are very interchangeable. Sometimes the first floor is the first floor, and sometimes the first floor is the ground floor.
But that always leads to a little bit of confusion about what's above the ground floor. Is that the first floor or the second floor? But here's the thing. Sometimes if the first floor or ground floor is a little bit below grade, it could also be referred to as the basement. It becomes confusing when you don't just have something simple like an apartment number. When we're talking about first floor, ground floor, lower level, basement, second floor, it gets confusing. And this confusion can be used in your favor. Remember, the standard is that the marshal has to be able to figure out when they get there for the eviction, which apartment is being referred to.
[6:07] Michelle Itkowitz: If you were telling a friend how to get to your apartment and you weren't going to meet them at the front door of your building, would the description that's in the petition in the court papers against you, if they followed that, would they be able to find where you are without calling you up on the cell phone and saying, okay, I'm here now, which door is yours? Is that the upper door? Is it the lower door? Wait, are you around back? Where's your apartment? Now, if you're in 7F and they press the elevator button and they go up to the seventh floor and there's 7A, 7B, 7C, and they find 7F, I mean that they don't need your help with that. But they might need your help with first floor, ground floor, lower level, basement, front, rear, if it's not clear. So the standard is you look in the court papers, and if you were just reading those court papers, could you find the apartment? And if you can't, that is a potential defense.
[7:10] Michelle Itkowitz: Okay, so that lays the groundwork we needed for today's case. So let's get into today's case. Today's case is called Osibodu versus Fayhintola. And that comes to us from the New York City Civil Court Housing Parts, so Housing Court in Kings County in Brooklyn, Brooklyn Housing Court, 2025. I will put a link to this case in the show notes. So let's talk about what happened in today's case. The tenant in today's case had a free legal services lawyer who said that the description of the apartment in the court papers was incorrect. They made a motion to have the case dismissed, but they lost the motion. The judge looked at it and said that she thought the description was adequate. But in the meantime, something very interesting happened. The landlord, maybe the landlord thought they were looking at losing the first case, because the landlord got another lawyer and brought another case in the same court for the same reason against the same tenant.
[8:16] Michelle Itkowitz: And the second lawyer in the second case described the same apartment and those court papers very differently than in the first case. Because look, look how the landlord just proved our point for us. The landlord brought another case, same tenant, same apartment, but described the apartment very, very differently. So let's look at this. Here's how the apartment is described in the first case. One room, number one, front apartment, first floor on the first floor. But then along came the second case. Listen to how they describe the apartment in the second case. Basement, ground floor, room A front. I mean, it is, it's different. Is this apartment on the first floor, like they say in the first case, or is it in the basement, which is what they say in the second case?
Is this apartment number one, like they say in the first case, or is this room A front, like they say in the second case? I don't know. Neither did the judge. So the judge said, you know, I am going to allow you to renew your motion. And based on this new evidence, I am going to dismiss the case because based on this, I can't tell you where the apartment is, and I don't think the marshal will be able to either.
[9:57] Michelle Itkowitz: So that's the case. There's stuff we really need to go over in the tenant takeaways. I've got two or three things for you that you really need to hear. Let's get the housekeeping out of the way first. Okay, this is not legal advice. I am not your lawyer, but because I am a lawyer, this might be considered legal advertising. If it's legal advertising, it is terrible because I'm asking you not to contact me. This podcast is not a commercial for me or my law firm. This is simply one of the podcasts that I always wanted to make. What I would like to hear from you on is what topics you'd like me to cover. My email is in the show notes. Now, this is the sixth time I'm dropping a Learn to Live Better episode in the Tenant Law Podcast feed.
I guess what I've really done in essence is I've changed the name of Tenant Law Podcast to Learn to Live Better, a housing law podcast. This is probably not good branding, all the this switching and putting Learn to Live Better in the Tenant Law Podcast feed, but whatever. My goal is not to be a brand. My goal is to get this important information to as many New York City tenants who need it as possible. So the show could be called Tenant Law Podcast or Learn to Live Better or Tea Time with Michelle. And as long as it helps as many people as possible, I don't really care. I'm never asking you for any money. There's no Patreon, there's no merch. I tell you in every episode, don't call me. This is not a commercial.
[11:31] Michelle Itkowitz: But what you could do for me, however, if you're listening on the Tenant Law Podcast feed, which right now most of you still are, to help me help New York City's middle-class tenants, is to go over to the Broadway Podcast Network and also subscribe to Learn to Live Better over there.
[11:50] Michelle Itkowitz: Don't unsubscribe here from Tenant Law Podcast because I don't want to lose all the work I've done over here, but also subscribe over at Broadway Podcast Network, Learn to Live Better, and get our numbers up over there, which is obviously going to lead to the show being heard by more people.
[12:06] Michelle Itkowitz: It is time for the tenant takeaway.
[12:10] Michelle Itkowitz: Okay, tenant takeaway number one is that a possible way to get an eviction case in housing court dismissed is to question the accuracy of the description of the premises in the petition.
[12:24] Michelle Itkowitz: And now I'm gonna look at two contrasting examples.
[12:28] Michelle Itkowitz: Okay, so example A. Let's say in the petition, in the court papers, the apartment is described as 7F as in Frank.
[12:37] Michelle Itkowitz: And on the door of the apartment, it says prominently, 7F as in Frank.
[12:43] Michelle Itkowitz: And then the description of the premises in the lease says apartment 7F as in Frank.
[12:50] Michelle Itkowitz: And then even on the mailbox for this particular apartment, 7F.
[12:55] Michelle Itkowitz: It's 7F everywhere you look.
[12:57] Michelle Itkowitz: This defense we're discussing today is probably not gonna work for you.
[13:02] Michelle Itkowitz: But let's look at another example.
[13:07] Michelle Itkowitz: Okay, example B. Let's say in your petition in the court papers, your apartment is described as rear apartment on the second floor.
[13:09] Michelle Itkowitz: Rear apartment on the second floor.
[13:23] Michelle Itkowitz: That's the description in the court papers.
[13:26] Michelle Itkowitz: But the description of the apartment in your lease says apartment two R.
[13:33] Michelle Itkowitz: And on your mailbox, it says apartment two.
[13:36] Michelle Itkowitz: And on your apartment door, it says absolutely nothing.
[13:39] Michelle Itkowitz: It's just an apartment door with no marking.
[13:42] Michelle Itkowitz: You might get somewhere with questioning the description.
[13:46] Michelle Itkowitz: I don't know if you're going to win, but you might get somewhere by raising it.
[13:52] Michelle Itkowitz: That's the obvious takeaway.
[13:56] Michelle Itkowitz: Tenant takeaway number two.
[13:57] Michelle Itkowitz: Now there was something else going on in this case that I see a lot.
[14:02] Michelle Itkowitz: Not a lot, but enough.
[14:04] Michelle Itkowitz: And it's another possible defense.
[14:07] Michelle Itkowitz: So remember what happened here.
[14:09] Michelle Itkowitz: I'm just making an assumption that as this motion was being brought by the legal aid attorney, and it was a good motion, and it scared the landlord.
[14:20] Michelle Itkowitz: So the landlord runs out, I guess, and gets another lawyer who files another case with a totally different description.
[14:29] Michelle Itkowitz: Putting aside the description stuff, you can't file two lawsuits for the same thing against the tenant at the same time.
[14:39] Michelle Itkowitz: It's a doctrine called that we're not going to go into today.
[14:42] Michelle Itkowitz: Maybe this is another episode, but I thought it was important to mention here today.
[14:47] Michelle Itkowitz: Prior action pending defense.
[14:49] Michelle Itkowitz: The prior action pending defense.
[14:51] Michelle Itkowitz: You can't sue somebody twice for the same thing because that's like judge shopping.
[15:00] Michelle Itkowitz: Oh, I'll sue the person three times, and whoever the best judge that I like the best, or wherever, whichever case I think is going the best, I'll keep and I'll get rid of the other two.
[15:09] Michelle Itkowitz: That's not how it works.
[15:10] Michelle Itkowitz: You can't do that.
[15:11] Michelle Itkowitz: And it's not fair.
[15:13] Michelle Itkowitz: The tenant shouldn't have to be defending themselves in two places at once.
[15:16] Michelle Itkowitz: That second lawsuit, lawsuit number two, could have been easily dismissed by saying, hey, there's a prior action pending.
[15:23] Michelle Itkowitz: Now I don't know what's going to happen with the second lawsuit.
[15:25] Michelle Itkowitz: I actually looked it up.
[15:26] Michelle Itkowitz: It seems like it's just sitting there.
[15:27] Michelle Itkowitz: Nothing's happened on it yet.
[15:30] Michelle Itkowitz: Maybe, maybe they're negotiating, which is what we're going to get to next.
[15:33] Michelle Itkowitz: But just keep in mind, you can't be sued twice at the same time for the same thing.
[15:39] Michelle Itkowitz: And I see this kind of thing pop up enough.
[15:42] Michelle Itkowitz: Okay, now the big takeaway.
[15:46] Michelle Itkowitz: Tenant takeaway three.
[15:49] Michelle Itkowitz: Negotiation.
[15:51] Michelle Itkowitz: I wanted to use this, our sixth housing court hack, to really drive a point home that I've made with respect to all the other housing court hacks, but I think each time I make it a little better.
[16:03] Michelle Itkowitz: Okay, first you're getting an anecdote.
[16:05] Michelle Itkowitz: So a guy called me for a free 15-minute consultation.
[16:10] Michelle Itkowitz: He wasn't rent stabilized or good cause eviction law protected.
[16:14] Michelle Itkowitz: So it was not a forever home apartment.
[16:17] Michelle Itkowitz: He didn't hire me.
[16:18] Michelle Itkowitz: But whatever I told him in those free 15 minutes, apparently it was useful because when he called me a year later, he said, Oh, thank you.
[16:27] Michelle Itkowitz: Whatever you told me, I was able to get my case dismissed.
[16:30] Michelle Itkowitz: Let me just say this about my free consultations.
[16:33] Michelle Itkowitz: And again, this is not a commercial for me.
[16:35] Michelle Itkowitz: I tell everybody in writing in a paper that I send to them before I will consult with them.
[16:41] Michelle Itkowitz: And I tell them when I'm consulting with them that whatever you're getting out of a free consultation is not actionable legal advice because it's not time enough to completely review your matter.
[16:54] Michelle Itkowitz: So whatever.
[16:56] Michelle Itkowitz: Thank God it worked out for the guy.
[16:58] Michelle Itkowitz: But then here he is a year later, and he wants another consultation because there's another case.
[17:03] Michelle Itkowitz: Now, I looked at it and I didn't see the problem that had been there a year ago.
[17:10] Michelle Itkowitz: Obviously, the landlord wasn't going to make the same mistake twice and corrected it.
[17:14] Michelle Itkowitz: And in this case, it wasn't like the case we looked at today.
[17:17] Michelle Itkowitz: The first case was long gone.
[17:27] Michelle Itkowitz: There was just nothing obvious at that point.
[17:30] Michelle Itkowitz: And the gentleman said to me, he goes, Oh, I really just need this case to go away.
[17:36] Michelle Itkowitz: Because I just need a few more months of free rent and then I can afford to move.
[17:42] Michelle Itkowitz: I was planning on going anyway.
[17:44] Michelle Itkowitz: I really wish I could negotiate, but I don't have anything this time like I had last time.
[17:51] Michelle Itkowitz: Now, there is the problem.
[17:54] Michelle Itkowitz: There's the problem.
[17:56] Michelle Itkowitz: He should have made or tried to make a deal with the landlord when he had defeated the landlord on the first case.
[18:04] Michelle Itkowitz: Now listen carefully because this is the important takeaway.
[18:07] Michelle Itkowitz: The problem with the middle class not having access to lawyers, either because they don't qualify for legal aid because they make too much money or they can't afford a qualified private counsel.
[18:18] Michelle Itkowitz: Either way, part of the problem is people wouldn't know the law.
[18:23] Michelle Itkowitz: Who would know what I just told you today?
[18:25] Michelle Itkowitz: That an improper description could get your case dismissed.
[18:28] Michelle Itkowitz: That's like inside baseball.
[18:29] Michelle Itkowitz: It's important and it happens a lot, and it could probably protect a lot of people.
[18:34] Michelle Itkowitz: Part of this podcast project is to educate you about the law.
[18:38] Michelle Itkowitz: But it's more than that.
[18:39] Michelle Itkowitz: And what you're getting here with me that you're not getting anywhere else is not just what is the information, but how do you utilize it?
[18:47] Michelle Itkowitz: How do you best utilize it?
[18:49] Michelle Itkowitz: So here's the thing.
[18:51] Michelle Itkowitz: When the guy who called me got his first case against him dismissed, at that point he had the maximum leverage he was ever going to have.
[18:51] Michelle Itkowitz: At that point, he should have gone to the landlord and said, Ms. Landlord, I need six more free months of rent and I'll be out of your hair.
[19:10] Michelle Itkowitz: And you need to stop paying lawyers who lose cases in housing court.
[19:14] Michelle Itkowitz: Let's both get what we need here.
[19:16] Michelle Itkowitz: If you waive the rent that I owe and give me another free six months, I'll give you a judgment of possession and a warrant of eviction.
[19:23] Michelle Itkowitz: That and that'll ensure you that I'll get out in six months.
[19:28] Michelle Itkowitz: I don't know if you're gonna get that deal, but trying to get that deal is what a good lawyer would do.
[19:34] Michelle Itkowitz: That's what a good lawyer would put you into.
[19:36] Michelle Itkowitz: Frankly, that's what a good lawyer for the landlord would do as well.
[19:39] Michelle Itkowitz: I notice that people they have a fight with the landlord, they win, they do a victory lap, and then they sit there and wait for the next case.
[19:48] Michelle Itkowitz: So let's look, let's do a little example here on the screen.
[19:51] Michelle Itkowitz: Again, if you're not on the screen, just listen to my words.
[19:54] Michelle Itkowitz: So, what do you want?
[19:55] Michelle Itkowitz: You want more time, you want your arrears waived, you want more free rent, you want a good letter of recommendation so you can go get the next apartment, and you want certainty of what's going to happen versus uncertainty.
[20:08] Michelle Itkowitz: You don't want another case.
[20:09] Michelle Itkowitz: Now, you don't settle the case by just thinking about what you want.
[20:13] Michelle Itkowitz: You settle the case by thinking about what the other guy needs, because that's how you make a deal.
[20:19] Michelle Itkowitz: So, what does the landlord need?
[20:21] Michelle Itkowitz: The landlord needs to stop paying lawyers to lose in housing court.
[20:25] Michelle Itkowitz: The landlord needs to get the apartment back.
[20:27] Michelle Itkowitz: This is the main thing they need, they need the unit back so they can collect rent again so they can pay mortgage and taxes and salary.
[20:35] Michelle Itkowitz: And the landlord also needs certainty versus uncertainty.
[20:38] Michelle Itkowitz: And the holy grail for the landlord is a judgment of possession and a warrant of eviction, because that's the only thing that's going to get you out.
[20:47] Michelle Itkowitz: And if you're willing to swap that for more time, waived arrears, more free rent, a good letter of recommendation, then that could be a deal that benefits both sides.
[20:59] Michelle Itkowitz: So the takeaway is if you use one of the housing court hacks I give you that we discuss here, and you use it to your advantage to get what you need by swapping with the landlord for what the landlord needs, that's where this should ideally go.
[21:18] Michelle Itkowitz: If you had a good lawyer, that's what the good lawyer would be working for.
[21:22] Michelle Itkowitz: Not just to keep you litigating and paying and keep the landlord litigating and paying.
[21:27] Michelle Itkowitz: A good lawyer is going to bring about a mutually beneficial solution.
[21:30] Michelle Itkowitz: Again, you got to think about what the landlord needs, and you have to think about what you need.
[21:35] Michelle Itkowitz: That's key.
[21:37] Michelle Itkowitz: You don't make a deal that is not a good deal for yourself.
[21:41] Michelle Itkowitz: Don't make a deal that you can't keep to.
[21:43] Michelle Itkowitz: So think about what you need, think about what they need, and have those conversations at your moment of maximum leverage after you get a case dismissed on a procedural ground.
[21:54] Michelle Itkowitz: Don't just sit there and wait for the next case.
[21:57] Michelle Itkowitz: Instead, use it, call up and just say, hey, look, what are we both doing?
[22:03] Michelle Itkowitz: Let's stop with these with the court.
[22:06] Michelle Itkowitz: Let's just make a deal that works for us both.
[22:08] Michelle Itkowitz: Now, I don't know if it's going to work, but I'm just telling you that that's what the middle class is missing when they're not represented.
[22:14] Michelle Itkowitz: And let's start to think about the material this way.
[22:18] Michelle Itkowitz: There you have it.
[22:20] Michelle Itkowitz: Remember, New York City, the law belongs to you, but your ownership of the law is only as great as your understanding of the law.
[22:29] Michelle Itkowitz: So let's learn to live better.
[22:31] Michelle Itkowitz: I am Michelle Itkowitz, and this is Learn to Live Better, a housing law podcast.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
