In this College Deep Dive, Carl Menninger from American University and MTCA Director Charlie Murphy discuss: The differences in a BA Program. The possibilities for blending Arts and Social Justice. The difference between enjoying acting and doing it for a career... Read More
From the show: Mapping The College Audition: An MTCA Podcast
About
In this College Deep Dive, Carl Menninger from American University and MTCA Director Charlie Murphy discuss:
- The differences in a BA Program
- The possibilities for blending Arts and Social Justice
- The difference between enjoying acting and doing it for a career
- The shifting tide of more multi-hyphenate artists
- The different timing options for American’s auditions
If you have any questions about the college audition process, feel free to reach out at mailbag@mappingthecollegeaudition.com. If you’re interested in working with MTCA for help with your individualized preparation for your College Audition journey, please check us out at mtcollegeauditions.com, or on Instagram or Facebook.
Follow Us!
Instagram: @mappingthecollegeaudition
YouTube: @MTCA (Musical Theater College Auditions)
TikTok: @mtcollegeauditions
Charlie Murphy:@charmur7
Meghan Cordier:@meghanmarie2014
About MTCA:
Musical Theater College Auditions (MTCA) is the leader in coaching acting and musical theater students through the college audition process and beyond with superlative results. MTCA has assembled a roster of expert artist-educators who can guide students artistically, organizationally, strategically, and psychologically through the competitive college audition process. MTCA provides the tools, resources, and expertise along with a vast and strong support system. They train the unique individual, empowering the artist to bring their true, authentic self to their work. MTCA believes that by helping students reveal their potential it allows each school to connect with those who are truly right for their programs, which in turn guides each student toward their best college fit.
About Charlie Murphy:
Charlie is a proud graduate of Carnegie Mellon University’s BFA program. As an Actor he has performed with theaters such as: NY Public Theatre’s “Shakespeare in the Park”, The Pearl Theatre Company, Hudson Valley Shakespeare Festival, Chautauqua Theatre Company, Kinetic Theatre Company, and the Shakespeare Theatre of DC.
With MTCA [Musical Theater College Auditions -- mtca.nyc], he has been helping prospective theatre students through the college process for over 15 years. As a Teacher and Director, he is able to do a few of his favorite things in life: help students to find their authentic selves as artists, and then help them find their best fit for their collegiate journey. Through this podcast, he hopes to continue that work as well as help demystify this intricate process.
This episode was produced by Meghan Cordier and Charlie Murphy. Episode theme music is created by Will Reynolds.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:10] Charlie Murphy: Hello, hello, and welcome to Mapping the College Audition, a podcast where we explore the landscape of the college theater world and try to demystify this daunting audition process.
[0:20] Charlie Murphy: I'm your host, Charlie Murphy, director of MTCA. That's Musical Theater College Audition. And today we've got Carl Menninger from American University on the show.
[0:30] Charlie Murphy: American is one of those handful of audition-based BA programs that we want to have on the show. Of course, we know more of our students tend to be looking at the BFA or BM path in their audition-based pursuits.
[0:42] Charlie Murphy: And there really truly are innumerable BA options if we open it up to all the non-audition BAs with no artistic requirement at all. I mean, almost every college has a theater department and the ability to major in theater in some way.
[0:53] Charlie Murphy: But for a nice chunk of our students who are looking at seriously pursuing theater with that audition-based component, but also want a significant amount of academics, maybe even more so than what you can get in a liberal arts BFA, those audition-based BAs can be a sweet spot for them, and we're gonna have one of them on the show today.
[1:11] Charlie Murphy: Um and we get into the unique timing options with American's audition into the theater programs, which can be a little um different, that can vary a bit more with BAs compared to most BFAs, or most BFAs you're auditioning um as a senior or potentially as a gap year student, but before you're um admitted to the university, where that can be a little bit different with BAs.
[1:28] Charlie Murphy: Okay. If you're hearing my voice and listening to our podcasts right as they drop at midnight on Wednesday morning, you have about 20 hours left to sign up for our upcoming junior workshop. If it's past the drop date, you're too late, you've missed it, you're gonna have to catch the next one.
[1:44] Charlie Murphy: But if you catch us in time, run to our website at mtca.nyc. I guess type to our website actually. You can't run to a virtual site, but click on the banner at the top to sign up for this free workshop. It's a nice chance to meet us, learn about the process a bit more in depth, and see how we might be able to help you with your individual college process.
[2:03] Charlie Murphy: Other than that, all is well on my end. Um, we just had a really wonderful November mock audition with some of our awesome MTCA students and parents. It was great to see all of you. I know some of you are listeners. Hello.
[2:15] Charlie Murphy: Um, and I see a lot of you listened to my strong dad vibes from the last intro and registered for a mock audition. Thank you for that. Those are filling up fast, and there's only a few more options. I mentioned December 3rd in New York City and January 6th in New York City, as well as December 10th in San Diego.
[2:33] Charlie Murphy: That last January mock, um, January 6th coincides nicely with our Baldwin Wallace private audition days that weekend. And for those of you who already registered for mock, like I heard your advice last time, I already registered. I'm eager for more. Stay tuned to your inboxes for more masterclass announcements as well. Some exciting new college faculty announcements coming down the pike.
[2:53] Charlie Murphy: Okay, that's it. Let's get to this interview with Carl Menninger from American University. Well, we are so excited to invite Carl Menninger on the show from American University.
[3:09] Charlie Murphy: Uh, Carl has a BS from Northwestern University, an MA from Emerson College. He's a writer, director, and playwright. He's been the associate artistic director at Windy City Playhouse in Chicago.
[3:20] Charlie Murphy: Also worked at Ford's Theater, Studio Theater, and Adventure Theater, and is an assistant professor in the Department of Performing Arts at American University, which is located in Washington, DC. They offer a BA in theater and a BA in musical theater, as well as some other degrees.
[3:35] Charlie Murphy: Um, and they have a class of about 20 students. Uh, Carl, welcome on the pod. Um, we're so excited to have you. Is there anything in that bio that I missed in terms of stuff that you'd want us to know about you before we get to the program itself? Any fun facts, tidbits?
[3:51] Carl Menninger: Um, that was great. Thanks for having me. Um, that was a very uh comprehensive resume that you did there. Thank you.
[4:01] Charlie Murphy: All right, so let's dive in and let's do just like top line assessment of American University. If people are gonna kind of shut off this podcast after question one, what are the things they need to know about? Kind of what differentiates American from maybe some of the other theater musical theater schools that people could be looking at?
[4:17] Carl Menninger: Sure. Um, American is a BA program, which I think uh many students looking to go into theater go into a BFA program. So we're very different in that sense.
[4:30] Carl Menninger: Uh, we also are located in our nation's capital, which is a thriving, which has a thriving theater community. Uh-huh. And so many of our students uh uh have internships or find that right when they graduate, they work in some of these theaters.
[4:47] Carl Menninger: So uh it's a pretty remarkable city when it comes to that. Um and uh because we are not a huge program, we have relationships with our students in uh in ways that a program with 500 students, uh a student wouldn't have that kind of opportunity to really get to know their professors well.
[5:10] Carl Menninger: Uh those are the top lines.
[5:13] Charlie Murphy: You've you've also mean you've mentioned probably the most pivotal uh thing already about being a BA versus a BFA. And you know, you are now the second BA program we've had in terms of audition-based BAs. You know, not the only ones that are out there, but certainly more of our students, as they're looking at a higher percentage of their list will be a BFA.
[5:29] Charlie Murphy: But American is definitely one of those schools that people will have on their list, even if they're also looking at a significant number of maybe those BFA liberal arts programs. I would just love to hear in terms of the you say it makes it very different. Of course, we maybe understand from listening to this podcast. Yes, a BA will probably mean more opportunity for academics and some other things, but how how could you distinguish, you know, let's say maybe not just from a conservatory, but from let's uh a BFA liberal arts program like uh an NYU, where you could maybe get a double major, maybe, right?
[5:57] Carl Menninger: Um, in some of those BFA liberal arts kind of programs. How is a BA different or why what's the advantage, maybe specifically of a BA as opposed to uh a BFA with a more liberal arts program?
[6:07] Carl Menninger: Sure. Um I think one of the things, and you and you brought it up with uh this idea of double majoring. I think our students are very curious about the world, and uh they are curious about things beyond the theater.
[6:22] Carl Menninger: And I think that is one of the things that distinguishes our students. They come to American with a kind of hunger for other things besides um the desire to explore and study the theater.
[6:37] Charlie Murphy: And does it change the tenor of the acting classes or of the musical theater classes? Is it changed by the fact that maybe you have more academic students? Is the approach, I guess, if you were to take a conservatory style school with an acting class and uh an American University acting class, do you feel like the classes are are changed or have a different tone because of that?
[6:56] Carl Menninger: No, I don't think so. I think um the acting classes uh in particular, are rigorous. The uh we train students with the idea that they are interested in pursuing something that is generally in an acting class, we assume that a student is interested in performing and uh and using the skills that they learn in an acting class on a stage somewhere or in behind a camera or in front of a camera.
[7:27] Charlie Murphy: Yeah, and and maybe tag me through the some of that curriculum if if you can, as granularly as you know it. Like going through the four years, um maybe let's especially focus a lot of our students or musical theater students. So if I'm want to be a BA musical theater um applicant at American University, what is my kind of progression through the four years going to look like?
[7:52] Carl Menninger: Yeah. Um you're gonna take musicianship for a year, you're gonna take dance classes for four, um, you're gonna take acting classes for four, you're gonna take history classes.
[8:02] Carl Menninger: Uh what's interesting, if at least from my perspective, is that the musical theater students and the theater students study many of their courses together. Um, because basic, a basic acting class is a basic acting class, and learning those tools and having those skills is uh something you need if you're a musical theater major or uh theater performance major.
[8:27] Carl Menninger: And so they work alongside our musical theater students work alongside theater performance students, which I think is a good thing.
[8:35] Carl Menninger: Uh, when it comes to auditioning for plays, our musical theater students can be in musicals or plays, and the same thing with our theater performance students, they can do either.
[8:45] Charlie Murphy: So um there's not that kind of separation between the two majors as there would be in other programs.
[8:51] Carl Menninger: Yep.
[8:52] Charlie Murphy: I love it. For the musical theater, is there a kind of discipline of those three that it feels like you focus more on? I mean, are they really a lot of singing, a lot of acting, a lot of dances, or one of the three that sort of feels like it lifts above the others?
[9:04] Carl Menninger: Wow. Um I never thought of that. Um I would say that our this idea of acting through song and acting on stage is really important for us.
[9:17] Carl Menninger: And so um while we do want to train singers who sing um well safely uh who take care of their voices we also want to train singers who know how to interpret a lyric and uh who understand that the basics of acting are part of what it is you do when you are singing a song uh on stage in a musical totally and you know you you already mentioned sort of from the BA perspective some of those double majors uh what what are what would those look like if you know you don't have to of course know every student who's there currently but you know am I more likely to have an arts related double major am I I mean are people having computer science in musical theater?
[9:17] Carl Menninger: I mean what what does it look like in terms of what some of the double majors that you're currently seeing?
[9:17] Carl Menninger: Um sure we get a lot of students who m um double major in communication studies um uh journalism um PR um the university offers a um business and entertainment major and so we have students who double in that recently we've had a a chunk of students who are in uh double majors in psychology which that's that's been a recent thing we have student uh washington DC is uh as you can imagine a very political international city so we have students who study international service we have student students who study uh political science and that's a pretty common thing.
[9:17] Charlie Murphy: Yeah I wonder do you do you tend to at uh attract a lot of students who are sort of interested in arts activism? I mean and those becoming a lot of our students will often talk about hey I want to I want to use my art to affect change or whatever and I wonder if being a DC based school do you get more of those kind of students who go, I want to be in the Mecca.
[11:12] Carl Menninger: Yes uh one of the things we've just instituted is a um theater for social change and social justice um uh certificate and uh that has really been in response to exactly what you're talking about students who are interested in uh in using their art to affect change using their art to see the world in a much larger global uh through a much larger global lens.
[11:12] Charlie Murphy: Um I just love to talk about and I know you might not know the exact breakdown but do you have a sense of kind of where your students come from in the world so you know how many are coming from across the country across the world in terms of how many are in the sort of DC area already and then how many of them end up in in different places.
[11:54] Carl Menninger: A lot of our students come from the East Coast. And when they graduate, it is uh often they stay here for here in DC for a year or two.
[12:30] Carl Menninger: Um they get their footing, they feel they discover what it feels like to audition professionally, to um really go out and do the thing that they studied and want to do.
[12:43] Carl Menninger: And then from there, students will move to New York, to Los Angeles. Some move to Chicago, not as many. Uh LA and New York are the two big spots where people go.
[12:55] Charlie Murphy: Uh listeners of this podcast may know, but I spent my first year out of school in DC. I interned at the Shakespeare Theater or the apprentice at the Shakespeare Theater of DC.
[13:02] Charlie Murphy: Um great theater town. Love to love being there for a year. Um, let's talk a little bit. How many of your students do you feel like end up, if they want to pursue acting at a higher level, how many end up getting an MFA?
[13:13] Carl Menninger: Like, um, do many of your students end up applying either right out of college or a couple of years later saying, Hey, I got the BA. I think I want a little bit more intensive conservatory style training.
[13:22] Carl Menninger: Um I would say it's less common that they go directly from the BA program to an MFA program. Personally, I try to discourage that. I think it's important to understand what this lifestyle is, and is that a lifestyle you want to live? And is this a is there's a difference between being in school and being a performer in school versus being a performer out in the world. And um, and so I think school gives you a very different take on that. So go into the world, see if this is what you want, and then decide to go get an MFA, have some experience under your belt, and then pursue it.
[14:12] Charlie Murphy: I love that answer. And boy, is it true that the loving the process of working on a play and loving a rehearsal is not necessarily the same as loving show business and auditioning and what that life is. I mean, it's a very different life. Of course, there's core elements of it that are similar, but they're very different.
[14:28] Carl Menninger: Well, in that segue, it's beautifully into how do you prepare your students for sort of the launch into the business? So, you know, I've taken my four years of class, hopefully I'm as educated as I can be in the theater world and the musical theater world. But then how are those seniors kind of prepared to, you know, meet agents and managers and casting directors and sort of figure out how the sort of business of the business stuff works?
[14:49] Carl Menninger: Sure. I actually several years ago now, I realized that we were not preparing them as well as we could. And so I wrote a book, and then I devised a course called The Business of Acting. It's a great way to sell some books.
[15:08] Charlie Murphy: I love it.
[15:06] Carl Menninger: It's a great way to sell it. Basically, that's what we do. We look at headshots and write cover letters or talk about what an agent is versus a manager versus a casting director and understanding how you pursue that. And I bring in guests to talk about their experience on the business side of things. We talk about the fact that you are the CEO of your own company when you are an actor and you are running a small business. And um, and that is just as important as all the art and all the brilliant acting chops that you have, if not more important, because the kind of discipline it takes to really roll up your sleeves and dive into that world is significant.
[16:06] Carl Menninger: And um interestingly enough, when I teach the course, the students kind of freak out a little bit. My god, I have to know all this. And um, and I don't know it yet. Well, that's what this semester is about is figuring out what it is you need to think about as you graduate and move on.
[16:27] Charlie Murphy: Yep.
[16:28] Carl Menninger: Well, it and it's one of the things, especially, you know, I talk to a lot of actors and the other half of the podcast, I talk to, you know, artists and talk about their paths and their careers, and it's the number one thing when you ask them, like, what do you wish you learned more of in school? And they're always saying, I wish I knew what this business was. You know, you can't know it all at 22 until you experience some of it, but it's always important to have a sense of.
[16:47] Charlie Murphy: Um, can we talk a little bit about cost? So we've looked up, it seems like the full-time tuition, at least listed is 278. So about 28,000 would be full-time tuition or up to 29,000 if you take a couple more credits. So somewhere in that range is what the full listed tuition is.
[17:03] Carl Menninger: Um that's per semester.
[17:05] Charlie Murphy: Per semester, thank you. So it means it's actually six or almost sixty thousand dollars.
[17:10] Carl Menninger: 57, I think is where we're at.
[17:12] Charlie Murphy: Well, so can we talk a little bit about the scholarship end of things in terms of so what am I likely, you know, if I'm a student, I'm an American university student, what am I likely paying? You know, am I likely paying the full sticker price? Am I paying something in between? And how does that work in terms of, you know, am I getting academic scholarships, talent scholarships? How does that work if I want to go here?
[17:34] Carl Menninger: Yeah, the easiest way to answer your question is this. Um 80% of the student body receives financial a million dollars in scholarship money every year. So how that divides out, I don't know, but many students are on financial aid at American because it is so expensive to go to a private institution.
[18:08] Charlie Murphy: Yep, sure is.
[18:09] Carl Menninger: And but you don't you mean in terms of divide out, do you mean versus need versus academic versus talent? You know, do you have the opportunity from on your end in terms of do you have the opportunity to say, hey, this person is really talented, let's give them a little bit more money, or is that more dealt with from the admissions perspective?
[18:26] Carl Menninger: We do have the ability to say this is this person's talented, let's give them a little bit more money. We don't give out huge scholarships from the performing arts. We give out some, but I wouldn't say that you're gonna get a free ride on a theater scholar.
[18:45] Charlie Murphy: On talent, right?
[18:46] Carl Menninger: It would be that would be more from an academic perspective or potentially need.
[18:48] Charlie Murphy: Um, love it. Um, okay. I'd love to just talk about talk a little bit about the timing of the audition in terms of so how does it work in terms of I think often with BA programs, especially if there's an audition element, sometimes that happens all before, sometimes it happens all after you already admitted to the school, and sometimes it's in freshman sophomore year. So, how does the timing of the audition work for American?
[19:11] Carl Menninger: Well, it's both. You can audition beforehand. We usually audition students who are applying early decision in November, and then we audition the bulk of our students in February. It's usually president's weekend because that's a weekend that students are able to they have a day off and so they're able to travel. We also have students audition who are current students. Sometimes this is somebody who's come in and decided that they want to be a theater major or a musical theater major and they came in as an English major or something like that. And so they've made they've changed their mind about what their major is. So that happens sometimes. Or it's students who just waited till they got here before they decided to audition.
[20:04] Charlie Murphy: Totally makes sense.
[20:05] Carl Menninger: So if I'm doing on a kind of audition tour of other theater musical theater programs, I'm auditioning as a senior in high school to get into the program and also applying to the school. We'll talk about that a little bit in the second half of sort of how the admission works. But also then some of my fellow classmates might have been undeclared American university majors who were accepted and then joined the class that fall semester. Am I getting that timing right?
[20:29] Carl Menninger: Absolutely. Yeah, it's really interesting. You know, and that really is something that varies more with the BA programs than the BFAs, where more of them you're auditioning and coming in at the beginning, but some BA programs you're auditioning freshman sophomore year even, but to enter. So that's really interesting.
[20:42] Charlie Murphy: Um anything else we want to hit in terms of the school in terms of like a best kept secret or something that you wish people knew about the school before they applied? Um is there anything else that you know people should know about American before we get into the admission part of things?
[20:55] Carl Menninger: Um I think I may have touched on this, and maybe this is more about the program than about the university. I think that because of the nature of the work and the nature of the size that we have a very different kind of community feel to the program. One of the things we say often is that we value community and that we are a community of artist scholars and um and so for me that's one of the things I value the most about it and we also place a lot of emphasis on collaboration and and uh and what that means and how we go about doing it and collaborating what does collaboration mean to you meaning within disciplines so you know playwrights and actors or and directors and actors or how do you mean in terms of collaboration?
[21:21] Carl Menninger: Um I think first between um theater artists and I'll include any theater artist in that equation of collaboration and then what happens also at the university is we collaborate with people outside our discipline so um it may be that well an easy one is that our classes in acting for the camera also pair with our classes in directing for the camera which is a different school. So or sometimes someone's working on a project that they know would pair well with an English lit course and so they'll they'll work with a professor in another discipline. But originally what I meant was this idea of how we as theater artists work together.
[22:54] Charlie Murphy: Yep.
[22:55] Carl Menninger: I love that. Well, and what's one something I didn't get to ask, but I had jotted down in advance, just to chat a little bit about like what percentage do you feel like your class are students who know or or think, I guess you can't know, but think I want to be only a performer, you know? Because I think sometimes that's also what attracts people to a BA is going, I think I might be more of the multi-hyphenate. I know I want to act and sing, but I'm not totally sure if I also maybe want a director or maybe one. What percentage of your theater and musical theater BAs are people who are, you know, in that place of going, maybe I'm 50-50 between being an actor and a playwright or an actor and a director, or that kind of thing.
[23:32] Carl Menninger: Well, it's interesting you bring that up because more and more students are being attracted to this idea of being a multi-hyphenate. Um it and I think it's because we've given them permission, not just American, but the industry. The world, totally. Yep. Uh has have given people permission to explore uh to spread their wings to demonstrate a set of skills that are that go beyond just I um I want to be an actor or I want to, you know, be a performer. Um, and so I find more and more that that's a common thing for that students talk about, uh in particular in my business of acting class, where we we talk about it's great if you're a multi-hyphenate. You know, you you can do more than write plays or act or act and write plays, you know.
And and but in terms of percentage, I don't know that I could give you an exact percentage in terms of of a tide shift. Then that's definitely the case. Impossible to give a percentage because some of those students might be, well, I'm 90% this and I'm 10%. I mean, they don't know all their own exactly how they're feeling too.
[24:44] Charlie Murphy: Yeah. Right. Um, all right. Well, let's do a short break. And on the back end, we'll chat a little bit more. We started talking a little admission stuff, but we'll chat a little bit more about admission and the audition process.
[24:53] Carl Menninger: Great.
[24:56] Charlie Murphy: All right. We are back with Carl Menninger, and we're chatting a little bit about the audition and the admission process for American. Um, and I just want to start off with kind of in short, what do you think makes a great audition for you? What are you looking for when you see a student auditioning that makes you say, this is an American university student?
[25:14] Carl Menninger: You know, uh my guess is that my answer is probably gonna be something that's that lots of people have said in the past on this podcast. Um, that we're really looking for someone who can come in and be themselves. We're looking for somebody who is comfortable just being themselves and uh and really uh being okay with that and sh allowing themselves to shine through. I think often uh people try to to um try to figure out what it is we're looking for, and we're looking for you is the is the answer. Um and the more authentic someone can be, the more engaging they are. And um so I don't know that there's a I you know there's a a level of skill that we're looking for. Um but there are so many we see so many talented students there. There are so many students out there. That it's that other thing, it's that other piece, that authenticity that really makes someone stand out.
[26:27] Charlie Murphy: And is there anything that you're sniffing for in terms of, you know, you sort of mentioned, hey, it seems like we're the kind of university that attracts these kind of students, maybe what ones you're more interested in in the world and and a little bit more uh intellectual, and you know, you're mentioning some of the stuff about what might attract a student to a BA. Is there anything you're sort of sniffing for in terms of going, would this student feel like they're a fit here based on now, maybe this interview questions that you're asking or engaging that you're doing with them in the audition?
[26:52] Charlie Murphy: How does that work for you in terms of the broader university?
[26:56] Carl Menninger: Yeah, uh I think uh there's a question answer period. We say, you know, do you have questions for us? And we ask them questions. And I think it goes back to this idea of somebody whose interests are broad, someone who really gets what it is about being in a BA program. Um there are students who walk in that I just think you're not gonna come here. This isn't the school for you. You know, it doesn't feel like the right fit. Um they're wonderful, they're talented and polished and terrific. It's just I think you I can feel when a student wants a BFA program. You can almost feel it.
[27:54] Charlie Murphy: Well, now talk to me about, so you mentioned the unique platform that you guys have of you could already be admitted and auditioning for American. But now when we're talking about the auditioning students, so the high school seniors or gap year students, whatever this incoming class, how does the audition process work in terms of the different platforms I'm able to audition on? Or, you know, how do students actually come in and audition for you in the various ways?
[28:19] Carl Menninger: Um we have done in-person auditions, video submissions, and Zoom auditions. Uh so we've kind of covered our bases in that sense. We've done all of those. Obviously, we prefer an in-person audition over a Zoom audition over a video. Um it often is hard to tell what a person's like from just a video.
[28:46] Charlie Murphy: Yep.
[28:47] Carl Menninger: Um you can do better on a Zoom audition and ultimately in person is where you really can get someone's vibe. And if there is a video audition, is there any kind of Zoom callback? Or how would it work if you go, I like this student from a video audition, but I want to see a little bit more?
[29:01] Carl Menninger: No, we don't do a callback. We um, for instance, there's no pre-screen for us. Um if someone submits a video, you go, that's what you're basing it on. Based on whatever you've put into that video, it's gonna be a yes or a no from this.
[29:15] Charlie Murphy: Absolutely.
[29:16] Carl Menninger: Yeah, that's how we do it. And if I want to do in-person with you, must I come to campus? Are there any like regional opportunities where you pop around to various whether it's a unified or whether it's a um whatever they're calling themselves, but non-on-campus auditions?
[29:30] Carl Menninger: No, just on campus. We just do auditions on campus. Um, I just if you know this, and again, I'm not to nail you down to a number or whatever, but do you have a sense of if you like a student artistically, what sort of percentage of the admitting power you have versus the academics, right? So, what percentage, you know, if they go, is you know, is it two different grades that they get and they're weighted in certain ways? Is it 50-50? Do you have a sense of going, I really like them artistically, maybe they're a little below our academic standards? How does that work in terms of the two parts of the admission process?
[30:02] Carl Menninger: Uh what we do is we share a list with admissions of these are our strongest candidates. Um and I think what winds up happening is if admissions is maybe on the bubble about someone, and we have expressed a real interest in having that student, then that may tip the balance in our favor. Um but generally not generally speaking, absolutely speaking, you have to be accepted to the university first.
[30:38] Carl Menninger: And um, American has become quite a competitive institution.
[30:41] Charlie Murphy: For sure institutional school.
[30:44] Carl Menninger: And does it ever work in the reverse? I mean, does it ever if someone goes you go, they were kind of on the edge for me, but they go, look, that is a 1600, 4.5, we love this student. We’d love for you to admit them into the theater program, or is it more that it's going the other direction?
[30:57] Carl Menninger: No, I think uh it absolutely works in the direction of a student is so outstanding, and we think, okay, you know, this student has some potential, great, but we don't communicate on that level with admissions.
[31:15] Charlie Murphy: Right. Well, what do you look at about the application other than let's say it's a video submission? So you're seeing the video, which the artistic, they got some analog, some songs that they're doing, musical theater. Right. How are you looking at essays? Are you looking at letters of recommendation? Do you look at other parts of that, or is that all done by the admissions department?
[31:32] Carl Menninger: That's mostly done by admissions. Uh students are given the option to submit a letter of recommendation along. We do slide room.
[31:40] Charlie Murphy: Mm-hmm.
[31:41] Carl Menninger: And uh slide room like for those or no, let's get accepted or one of those platforms.
[31:45] Charlie Murphy: It's a video platform or an online platform that where you can submit things.
[31:48] Carl Menninger: Yeah. Yes, exactly. Thanks. So they can submit a headshot, a resume and letters of recommendation. And some students choose to do that, and then we can see the letters. But mostly those letters go to the institution to American and to the admissions office.
[32:08] Charlie Murphy: And what else do you think about as you're admitting students? You know, so you, of course, you're looking for talent, you're looking for a personality fit. You know, of course, they've got to academically get into the university. Are you conscious of things like the gender balance of your class or thinking about height or racial diversity or size balance? Are there different things that you're thinking about of going of our cohort that we're putting together? I want them to have a certain kind of makeup, or is it just about I'm accepting these people and whoever shows up here shows up here?
[32:34] Carl Menninger: Um we strive to um to have racial diversity. It is not an easy uh thing based on um the profile of students that we get at the university, but it's something that is important to us and um is is something that we as a university as an institution really value our uh creating a more racially diverse campus.
[33:07] Charlie Murphy: Um I love it. Anything else that we need to talk about in terms of the audition process? Anything that we haven't covered in terms of sort of how the audition works, and then diving in a little bit too, like what are you hoping to see in those two contrasting songs and monologue? We sort of talked about, of course, their authentic personality, but as you think about like, you know, the material they select, and as you think about okay, this is what contrast means to me. Like what, you know, from a perspective of going, that student is talented? I like what they presented on that the material. What are you kind of looking for there?
[33:35] Carl Menninger: Um well, when it comes to the song, I'll go back to what we said, uh, to what I said earlier. Um can a student act a song? Um, is a student using their voice over their uh acting ability? You know, there are students who can sing their faces off, and um, and you know, they come in and they blow the doors off the place, and that's great, but uh have you thought about the thought process that goes into this song? And who is who are you singing to and why are you singing to them? And um, what is it that is the nature of this relationship between you and the person you're singing to? And uh to dig deeper into the music itself and um and to the and dig deeper into the lyrics themselves.
[34:29] Carl Menninger: And um, and so for me personally, that's one of the big things that I look for is can you act a song? Um what about in a monologue? What what are you sort of, you know, if they're showing one monologue, what are you hoping to see uh in that piece that says this person is a good actor, or or I see potential in this person as an actor?
[34:49] Carl Menninger: Um does a well, similar to what I was just saying about the um uh about the song, is there an objective in this monologue? Is there uh what's the nature of my relationship? What's the to the listener? What's the listener doing while I say this? You know, in what way is this listener, is this listener an obstacle? Um, and you know, this is I sort of separate, but uh invariably students um come in with very heavy monologues.
[35:26] Carl Menninger: And um and I think about the fact that you know, if you're coming in as Biff Lohman, and you are um and we are looking at the very end of that play. You know, if we had seen the show, we would have had two hours of us invested in that story, invested in you, and now all of a sudden you're gonna give us this heightened moment. Um, I think that takes so much, and um invariably um I see a lot of students just being angry up there, uh-huh.
[36:06] Carl Menninger: Um and a lot of gnashing of teeth and beating of chest kind of thing. And um, and for me, one of the most refreshing things is when someone comes in with a comic monologue.
[36:21] Charlie Murphy: Um I don't know if that's I don't know if that goes against what it is you uh—
[36:21] Carl Menninger: No, totally. I mean, you know, especially if you're talking about doing three pieces, if they're all dark, heavy, deep, you know, sometimes you're like, I would love to see what you're just like on a Tuesday sometimes too. Like, what's it's a truthful, real, you know, because especially it's not something that you've experienced as much as a human being, you know, it's great to stretch yourself. We want to see what you can do. But um, I do think, you know, I think sometimes students come in thinking, I need to show every bit of my range, every here's let me show you, plumb the depths. Because you know, we'll say things like can you let's go deeper in that work? And you want to go deeper, and you want to show you're a serious actor, but but yes, certainly the audition experience of going, oh my god, dramatic piece after dramatic piece after dramatic piece.
[37:06] Carl Menninger: Yeah, um, can be tough.
[37:07] Charlie Murphy: It can. I'd love to talk a little bit from the parents' perspective. You know, I think a lot of parent listeners right now might be going, I love the idea of American university for my academic student. Maybe the student is going, I'm really thinking about maybe I'm BFAs, I'm not sure, or you know, I really want the you know, the this musical theater training or this specific thing. How do you sort of suggest parents to guide their students, you know, or to guide their children um going through this process? Let me imagine maybe a parent who's starting off, they're maybe a parent of a junior, they're really just starting to look into these schools now. What advice would you have to those parents going through this process?
[37:43] Carl Menninger: Boy, um I taught high school for 15 years before coming to American. And so, and I taught in very um high-powered high schools where 97% of students went to college, and um parents were very concerned about their students getting into a top university, and um, and I and I think the first thing I would say is um it all works out. You know what I mean? Like your child will find a place where they feel that they belong. And um, and I think that that is just knowing that I think takes a lot of pressure off the process.
[38:41] Carl Menninger: Um I believe that following your passion is a really awesome way to have an education. Schools are there to teach people to think and to communicate and to work in groups and um and to think critically, not just to think, but to think critically and to write. And um and so I think that allowing a student, a child to um pursue that passion, all those other things will come into play. We have students who go off to law school and um and uh go off and do other things. We have students who um are criminal justice majors and the passion they find with the theater really uh excites them, but it excites them alongside this idea of being a criminal justice person.
[39:48] Charlie Murphy: I totally no, we talked about a lot before on the pod the idea that like especially in twenty twenty three or these students can be graduating in twenty twenty-seven, twenty twenty-eight now, you know, that in that world of you know, we think what are the secure jobs, of course computer science or things we know there's gonna be AI and whatever, but the number of people who are employable with communication skills, creativity, I mean so many jobs out there where people want that kind of passion and ability to connect with people and communicate and and you know, we see our students who most of whom have a degree in theater and musical theater who are doing all kinds of amazing different things that aren't just about being on Broadway or just being in TV and film.
[40:31] Carl Menninger: If people want to hear more about American University, uh, where would we find that out?
[40:35] Charlie Murphy: So if people wanted to check out a little bit more, do you suggest the website? Do you see socials? Are there places where you would really want people to um look for more information?
[40:44] Carl Menninger: Um, one of the things that I think would be well, on our website, you can email us. And of course, now I'm blanking on what the email address is. But and you can request to connect with a student, you can request to connect with a faculty member, um, and ask questions. And um one of the things that we do when we have uh our auditions are we have student volunteers come and hang out with the prospective students because it nothing like it coming from the horse's mouth kind of thing. And um and from for these prospective students to really hear from current students, I think is is important. Um, you know, you can go on the website and you can uh you can Google us and all of those things, but I think uh the more personal you can make that connection, the better idea you're gonna have about what it is that we offer and how it is that people feel about it.
[41:49] Charlie Murphy: And do we like DPA at American University or American.edu?
[41:53] Carl Menninger: DPA?
[41:54] Charlie Murphy: I think that's it. Did you just look it up?
[41:55] Carl Menninger: That's I Google it. So hope that's correct. We'll put that in the show notes for you as well.
[41:59] Carl Menninger: But DPA at American.edu is what it says on the contact us part of the website.
[42:04] Charlie Murphy: Awesome. Well, Carl, thank you so much for the time. It was so fun getting to chat with you.
[42:08] Carl Menninger: You as well. Thank you, Charlie.
[42:14] Charlie Murphy: Oh, yeah. I hope you enjoyed that interview with Carl. For today's takeaway, I want to do a slight sidestep to our usual interview takeaways. Lots of great stuff we could have talked about from today. I could dive deeper on a lot of these different issues, though I do feel like we've hit on a number of them and you kind of know my thoughts on some of the places where I might have uh chosen to go. But I did think I would take this opportunity, this kind of neutral opportunity, to talk about locations of schools geographically.
[42:43] Charlie Murphy: I'm going to use the fact that we talked about Washington, DC as being a political city to kind of shoehorn this in a bit, as I do record this on election day. And maybe because it's our nation's capital, I also can talk about locations a little bit more freely. But I mostly want to talk about geography and politics, because this is a question we get a lot. Our MTCA is often ask this of us, and we've gotten a few different mailbag questions on this subject or somewhere in the range of the subject. It's always a little bit delicate to bring up in the context of a certain school, as I don't want to make any specific school feel like their location is particularly more unpalatable than another, be it for whatever reason, whether it's politics or not.
[43:22] Charlie Murphy: So I've kind of skipped this takeaway a few times when it's almost come up. I almost went in this direction. Then I was like, oh, I don't want to sort of make that school feel like they are particularly politically unpalatable. But to be clear, this of course is not directly related to American University, unless for whatever reason you particularly dislike the idea of going to school in Washington, DC, for whatever reason.
[43:40] Charlie Murphy: But we get asked this question a lot from people as they're beginning to form their lists, which is essentially how do I deal with incorporating schools that may be artistically exciting to me or to my child if it's a parent asking, but are in states with policies that either I strongly disagree with politically, or maybe more relevantly to me as a parent that I feel may endanger my child, or if it's me who's asking the question, may endanger me, right? This could be because the state's law with something like abortion rights, or um it could be they've taken a strong, maybe it's a more performative stance, or maybe it's an actual stance that feels kind of anti-gay or anti-trans or anti-Semitic, whatever the case may be.
[44:17] Charlie Murphy: And the parent often asks, how will my tender city kid, you know, who's one of those things I just mentioned, survive in the deep south or in a very rural setting, or whatever the case is. Sometimes it goes the opposite way too. How would they survive in a big city if they're more of a rural kid? So here's my big feeling on the subject.
[44:34] Charlie Murphy: And I'm gonna be a little bit vague in general, but first off, I really understand the idea of being conflicted here. And of course, ultimately, this is a decision each individual student and family has to make. Will I feel comfortable and safe attending university in this location, whatever that location may be? Even if I were to present to you great statistics and data that kind of conclusively says this idea is a little bit overblown in this area for whatever it is.
[45:01] Charlie Murphy: I mean, I've often done this with New York City when I say New York City is actually one of the safest per capita cities like in the world, um, and certainly in the United States. But if the feeling of safety is not there, then this likely will not be a fit for you or your child to attend, right? If you don't feel like you can be safe there, whether that's physically safe or emotionally safe, then it's obviously not going to be a great school for you.
[45:22] Charlie Murphy: That said, I will say in general, most college campuses tend to be very liberal and inclusive, and to some of you, liberal may not be a good thing, but most people, I think, uh listening to this podcast tend to be a little bit more on hoping for campus to be a bit more liberal. And I'll say, even more so, the theater programs will tend to be warm and welcoming to students of all identities.
[45:44] Charlie Murphy: I would say this also extends a great deal, though not necessarily in every case, but it sends a great deal to college towns and certainly to cities where most of these schools are. So even if you're a city in a more conservative region, that city will tend to be a little bit more liberal and likely inclusive than the surrounding area.
[46:02] Charlie Murphy: I have often used the example of Texas State, where I subbed a few years back, that San Marcos felt a whole lot more like Brooklyn to me than some random city in Texas. And Austin, which is only a 30-minute drive away, is not what most Northeasterners picture when they think of Texas. I mean, I personally counted more vegan restaurants than I see walking in the streets of Harlem.
[46:20] Charlie Murphy: But again, that's not a universal statement, and nothing is going to replace the idea of getting to visit the campus, sit in on classes within that department, and then of course what we're talking about, explore the surrounding area. Which is why a huge percentage of this question to me comes down to budget. You've heard us recommend before doing a high percentage of your visits after admission so that you're getting more bang for your buck with schools that you know want you.
[46:43] Charlie Murphy: You've also heard me say, I don't like closing off too many possibilities for yourself before you've had that organic artistic experience of the audition, right? To close out a huge swath of the country and a lot of great programs, you know, feels a bit to me like setting your dating range on your profile at like a two year range, right? You might think you only want to date someone who's 32 to 34 years old, but what about that amazing 35 year old or that amazing 30 year old that you just haven't met yet?
[47:09] Charlie Murphy: I'm always a bigger fan of getting into more schools, having more options, and then you could decide that that geographic tiebreaker is a big enough reason to go to this other great option or to not even end up visiting the school because you have so many great options that you don't feel like you need to visit them all. Of course, we love that, right? But then you haven't eliminated that possibility of some of those great schools, especially I'm gonna say some of those great state schools, which can have very affordable tuition options from even entering the mix for you.
[47:35] Charlie Murphy: But if resources are more limited, I think it makes a lot of sense to focus more of your list on schools that you feel like you have a higher chance of wanting to attend if you if they like you back, right? If you start there and determine that even if a very successful visit happens and you have a great experience, it's still very unlikely, like maybe it's a you go, I don't know, I still think it's under 5% that I'd want to go to school in Oklahoma or Missouri or name whatever state, then I totally understand not featuring those states on your list, even though you know both of those states have a number of great programs that you could potentially want to attend.
[48:09] Charlie Murphy: There are enough other great schools out there that you should never feel like you have to have any specific program on your list. If you feel like this is not what I want for myself, or even I'm 90% sure, I'm 95% sure, well, just in terms of the numbers of it all, there will probably be some better options that can populate your list.
[48:25] Charlie Murphy: But for those who are on the more on the fence, I do think I tend to lean more toward keep your options open, and then you can decide after you know your results, especially with some of those schools where the finances can be so different, can be where you can really have a great, really affordable option in some of those state schools.
[48:41] Charlie Murphy: I will also say personally, this just on a personal note about Charlie, I tend to follow politics very closely. I listen to many political podcasts. That's one of the reasons I love um podcasting and wanted to get into it. I have very strong political opinions myself. But I have found with age, with great age that has come on me, that the actions of politicians and maybe especially sort of heads of state kind of politicians, in most instances, do not end up directly affecting you as much as you think they likely will.
[49:10] Charlie Murphy: Even with policies that seem aimed specifically at a subset of the population, they can have downstream effects that end up being almost the opposite of their intention, sometimes to comedic effect, right? One of the things I think people were surprised by, after Roe uh was struck down, there were more abortions in this country than beforehand, right? I think that was not the intention of the people who were striking down Roe.
[49:30] Charlie Murphy: I mean, I'll also give the example, Donald Trump was not, I'm gonna admit here publicly, he was not my ideal candidate for president. I did not vote for him. That is not who I wanted to be president at any point. And I think when he was elected, even at my ripe old age at the time, I think I felt like many did, that his presidency was gonna truly and deeply affect my life in a negative way.
[49:50] Charlie Murphy: And I have to say, to be totally honest, those four years were some of the happiest of my life personally. Of course, when I met my future wife, so many amazing things happened in my life that just happened to occur in those four years. And I certainly would argue that was not because of his great leadership, but I don't know how much of it was even directly in spite of it, versus just kind of more ancillary to it.
[50:10] Charlie Murphy: So I'm gonna say, whether it's a governor that you particularly object to, or a senator, or whatever it is from a specific state that you feel like I just could never go to school in that state. I would just offer that if you speak to people living in that region, they may not be as affected directly as you think, or maybe especially as you it seems like they might be on the news, or sort of what you you read or you what you picture life in that state might be like. It might not be the reality for them.
[50:34] Charlie Murphy: And it may be too. That's why it's worth talking to them. Again, this is really just a case-by-case situation. I don't want to say that politics definitely won't affect your life. Of course it can, of course they do, right? But just a bit of perspective from old age that it may not be as black or white as you think in terms of um, I will like people from this state, I will not like people from that state, right? Unless you've actually experienced the region, it might not be exactly what you're picturing it's gonna be.
[50:56] Charlie Murphy: I will also say, just some blanket advice I give to anyone who's concerned about the issue of safety for their specific student, whether it's some of the stuff we've been talking about, you know, whether it's gender identity, religion, sexuality, stuff like disability, etc., these are great things to directly ask the schools themselves. Not only can they potentially give you answers, which you can then investigate for yourself in a visit, and of course, talk to students to help verify that those answers are actually true, um, or at least that you know you you feel that they are satisfactory to you.
[51:24] Charlie Murphy: But in actually asking those questions of the schools, you can kind of hold their feet to the fire a bit to address any of these potential issues, right? If they hear that a state's potential abortion policy or their anti-trans policy or some anti-trans law that just passed, or whatever it is, if that's a reason that students are considering not attending their school, it is leverage for them to help address what they can, at least on a campus-wide level, in a public and transparent way, as well as with enough instances, it's potential help to put pressure on their region to improve that policy or to find a workaround or whatever they can do to sort of address that policy if it knows it's actually losing them students and therefore them money and hurting their university and and hurting their region.
[52:04] Charlie Murphy: Well, there we go. About as political as we'll ever get on map in the college edition, and maybe worth saying, I just do want to say I don't assume any of our listeners' politics or backgrounds, they're gonna be like my own, hence some of the vagary in that language above. Um, one thing I do kind of assume, or I'm gonna say I know if you're listening to this podcast, is that you are generally looking out for the welfare of yourself if you're a student, your peers, or if you're a parent, your child, and other people's children, which I do think describes the vast majority of non-political people in this country.
[52:33] Charlie Murphy: We are full of love here on this podcast, as is Meghan Cordier, our intrepid producer, who, if you hated how this episode sounded, you cannot blame, as this was produced entirely by myself. You can follow us on our social media platforms at Mapping College Edition on Instagram and check us out at MTCA.nyc if you want to hear more about MTCA and check out that junior workshop, which is tonight.
[52:56] Charlie Murphy: Again, if you're listening later, you missed it. To my young artists out there mapping their journeys. How many hyphens can you have before it becomes too many hyphens? We'll see you next week.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
