Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Colleen Kessler (MTCA Alumni Parent and Host of Raising Lifelong Learners) on Empowering Your Student Through The College Audition Process

In this Artist Exploration, Class of 2025 MTCA Alumni Parent Colleen Kessler and Director of MTCA Charlie Murphy discuss; 🔴A fresh perspective on the Musical Theater College Auditions Experience. 🔴How to enjoy this time with your student... Read More

From the show: Mapping The College Audition: An MTCA Podcast

2 h 2 mins
6/4/25

About

In this Artist Exploration, Class of 2025 MTCA Alumni Parent Colleen Kessler and Director of MTCA Charlie Murphy discuss;

🔴A fresh perspective on the Musical Theater College Auditions Experience

🔴How to enjoy this time with your student

🔴Raising Gifted children

🔴How homeschooling impacts the college audition process

You can learn more about Colleen and Raising Lifelong Learners HERE!

If you have any questions about the college audition process, feel free to reach out at mailbag@mappingthecollegeaudition.com. If you’re interested in working with MTCA for help with your individualized preparation for your College Audition journey, please check us out at

mtca.com, or on Instagram or Facebook.

Follow Us!

Instagram: @mappingthecollegeaudition

YouTube: @MTCA (Musical Theater College Auditions)

TikTok: @mtcollegeauditions

Charlie Murphy:@charmur7

About MTCA:

Musical Theater College Auditions (MTCA) is the leader in coaching acting and musical theater students through the college audition process and beyond with superlative results. MTCA has assembled a roster of expert artist-educators who can guide students artistically, organizationally, strategically, and psychologically through the competitive college audition process. MTCA provides the tools, resources, and expertise along with a vast and strong support system. They train the unique individual, empowering the artist to bring their true, authentic self to their work. MTCA believes that by helping students reveal their potential it allows each school to connect with those who are truly right for their programs, which in turn guides each student toward their best college fit.

About Charlie Murphy:

Charlie is a proud graduate of Carnegie Mellon University’s BFA program. As an Actor he has performed with theaters such as: NY Public Theatre’s “Shakespeare in the Park”, The Pearl Theatre Company, Hudson Valley Shakespeare Festival, Chautauqua Theatre Company, Kinetic Theatre Company, and the Shakespeare Theatre of DC.

With MTCA [Musical Theater College Auditions -- mtca.nyc], he has been helping prospective theatre students through the college process for over 15 years. As a Teacher and Director, he is able to do a few of his favorite things in life: help students to find their authentic selves as artists, and then help them find their best fit for their collegiate journey. Through this podcast, he hopes to continue that work as well as help demystify this intricate process.

This episode was produced by Kelly Prendergast and Socials by Jordan Rice. Episode theme music is created by Will Reynolds with Additional Vocals from Elizabeth Stanley

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:09] Charlie Murphy: Hello, hello, and welcome to Mapping the Colleen Audition. I'm your host, Charlie Murphy, director of MTCA. That's Musical Theater Colleen Auditions. Check us out at MTCA.com. And today we've got Colleen Kessler on the show. Uh Colleen is an MTCA alumni parent, having just gone through this process with her daughter Molly, and also an author, podcaster, specializing in neurodiversity and gifted learners and homeschooling. So, apart from her experience as a been there done that parent in this process, we dive deep into all those individual topics, and we do manage to break the record for the length on this podcast for those who haven't already looked at their podcast feeds and seen that ticker.

An exciting achievement for us for sure. Um, these alumni parent episodes have become some of our most requested favorites. So I'm trying to listen to you all and keep them coming. Though, of course, also making sure I'm giving you a balance of our usual artist episodes and our rotation of college deep dives as well. As always, if you want to participate in leaving us feedback in general about the types of episodes you love, or just help the podcast out as we reach more families and try to increase our reach across the globe. You know you can leave us a rating and review wherever you listen to podcasts. If you leave one on Apple Podcasts, we may just read it on the show. Like these two reviews from CJ Reeves 12.

[1:31] CJ Reeves 12: You need to listen. If your kid is interested in a career in the performing arts, you need to listen every episode. Charlie, ask the questions. I want answers too. So informative and a terrific resource as we embark on this journey.

[1:43] Charlie Murphy: CJ, that's so kind of you, and I appreciate all of your exclamation marks. I'll say I'm personally, I'm definitely like a write an exclamation mark after every sentence kind of email person, and then I have to go back and delete half of them. So I appreciate that review, all the exclamations and the voice that I think you did there. You know, it's just what it is. Or uh there's this from M Bennett 99.

[2:05] M Bennett 99: Uh, this is one of the most helpful podcasts I've ever listened to. Uh so grateful to Charlie, MTCA, all of the uh college representatives and MD professionals who come on and give us so much insight and advice. It is truly a gift.

[2:20] Charlie Murphy: Uh thank you. Uh thank you, and then it is truly a pleasure on our end as well. Uh, you can tell I do a lot of children's books, so I'm just always picking random voices out of the hat for any quoted text. And as you all know, of course, this podcast is a free resource, and of course you get what you pay for, but it's a free resource that we share with all of you, uh, whether you're an MTCA student or not. And Colleen gives us a nice rave at the end of the interview, it's very sweet about how helpful she found our green rooms that we do in all of the unified cities, um, which we also offer for free, another one of our complimentary bonuses. So that has me in a good mood and tempted to spare you all any kind of advertisement toward any of our MTCA paid services for this one episode.

So you may go forth unadvertised to, uh, aside from the BPN ads that you do have to skip through, but we can bloop bloop through those, and we're gonna keep everything on our end complimentary in honor of those very complimentary reviews. Um, I will just add, I think I mentioned this uh at the top of this interview, but it is quite long and I think really jam-packed with a lot of great stuff that's gonna be relevant to a lot of folks, but not necessarily every section is gonna be relevant to every single person. That first section is really focused on the universal process that'll apply to almost everyone. It's about the first half of the interview. So whether you're a parent or a student who's going through this process or a young artist in general, I think that section will be really helpful to you.

The next session focuses a little bit more on neurodivergence. And then the third diving into homeschooling and how the process is different for homeschoolers or those who may be considering it. So if not all of the sections are relevant or interesting to you, feel free to skip around or just, you know, jump off the episode and dive right into that rating and review that you're so excited to leave us so that you can figure out what voice I will do for you. Okay, without further ado, here is the wonderful Colleen Kessler.

[4:18] Charlie Murphy: Well, we are so excited to be joined by Colleen Kessler. Uh Colleen has a BS in elementary education from Cleveland State University and an MA in gifted education from Kent State University. She's the author of dozens of books for children, teachers, and parents, and has the podcast Raising Lifelong Learners, where she speaks on homeschooling, raising gifted children, and neurodiversity. Also, most importantly for this podcast, she's the mother of Molly Kessler, who was a class of 2025 alumni headed off to Otterbine to study musical theater this fall. Colleen, how are you feeling? Welcome on the pod.

[4:52] Colleen Kessler: Oh, I'm excited to be here. I'm feeling a little, you know, it's the summer, two and a half months till I have to say goodbye to my baby after spending like the whole year with her. So it's gonna be interesting. All the feels right now. I'm sure you hear that from everybody.

[5:05] Charlie Murphy: Deeply so. And it's one of the there's three reasons I'm so excited to have you on the podcast. But one of the reasons I'm so excited to have you on, aside from I will think in general, just like our alumni parent episodes, they have gotten the best feedback in terms of the kind of episode that people say, give me more of these. I love them so much. I hear that so much from our other parents how full to different parents, but especially the fact that you are such fresh meat. You have just gone through this, and that is that's unique, right? We've had some parents who did it last year, but you did it like a month ago. You finished like it's you've just finished that process. So I think your perspective will be really helpful for that.

Aside from the fact that you also uh are a podcaster yourself, which we love, um, and I think have some real expertise on these like two additional topics that I think we're gonna talk about. We'll talk about homeschooling, we'll talk about neurodiversity, raising gifted children. The other thing, and I wonder this is why I I thought I might start us off as we get into sort of your alumni experience. I sort of saw you might be this a little bit of a Goldilocks sweet spot of what I've been looking for in the like it seemed to me like you were an involved parent, but not an overly involved parent, right? In terms of going, it seemed like like we talked about like sort of Molly's independence and how much she brought to the process, how much you brought to the process.

So it's it's often difficult for me to get someone on the podcast if they're not a super involved parent because they don't make their way to my inbox. You did not email me a thousand times during the the process. I I I don't you were not like a super present. Not that there's anything wrong with those parents, but I think helpful to have that represented on the pod, the the parent who's who's involved, but who's also uh, you know, that they're sharing their relationship that way. So first off, I guess is that fair that third categorization of you as involved but not overly involved? How would you sort of talk about your involvement?

[6:35] Colleen Kessler: Yeah, I think that I was involved in a lot of the details with regards to like college applications and things. Uh-huh. Um, so like I feel almost like I was more of a secretary or an administrative assistant to her, um, because and a lot of this was because, you know, as you said before, I podcast about homeschooling. It's because I'm home I homeschool, and uh we've been homeschooling now sixteen and a half years, and so Molly's and my oldest went to school for a little while, but Molly only homeschooled. And so I feel as part of my job as a homeschooler as the administrator of our homeschool was I needed to take a little bit more point on that because the homeschooling piece is really different when you're applying to schools in general, and then even a little bit more fraught when you're applying to these types of programs.

And so I was all in on that administrative part, and then was like, you tell me what you need with regards to coaching or with regards to who you need to talk to. I proofread most of her emails uh because she wanted to make sure she was coming across both as professional, but still as herself, and um, but let her take the point of all of that. And she's she tends to be a more reserved person, and she's I actually think that um for those of you parents out there listening who have a kiddo who always feels like she shouldn't bother people, that's something to help them break through this year. I'd have to encourage her sometimes to reach out to people to ask questions because I wasn't the expert and I didn't want to do it for her because she's leaving next year and has to know how to approach professors.

So she was most comfortable with her coach Lisi. And so she was she would email Lisi first for information. And um, and then you know, there's there's that piece too a lot of times where it it's better coming from other people. You and I had that experience in the Chicago green room, and we could talk about that later, but um, needing to hear from other people and be that person who got the the answers back. So, no, I didn't email anybody for the most part. We had one kind of meltdown issue in there that I emailed coaches about, and um, and then they facilitated from there. But yeah, no.

[8:43] Charlie Murphy: No, that uh, you're describing to me what I yeah, that involved, but not over. That's a that's the that's the blending. I think that's that's right. Um, and for those who you you may recognize, the keen listener may recognize Molly's name. Molly was did one of our unified green room interviews. So for those who listen to that episode, you'll hear Molly talk for about five minutes. She gives this great um little snippet about skill-based improvement goals and how she would go back and do things differently if she could sort of about her interests versus her level of what she needed. And so we invite you to do all that. But okay, great. So so let that let's get into it. You know, I I wanna really start off.

We're gonna do kind of three parts, and I want to talk, we'll talk about homeschooling, we'll talk about sort of neurodiversity and gifted kids, and I want to talk make sure we hit all those different things. Um, but let's start off just from your perspective of Molly's process. Having just gone through this, um, I'd love to kind of hear, you know, the same question we asked all of our artists' guests when we start them off, you know, thinking about like, hey, what was your mission statement or what were your goals as you looked at the process? Do you kind of remember from both from a guest your perspective of Molly, but also from your own goals of like when you were thinking about this process, I think we met you at Pittsburgh Unified's Molly's junior year, was we when you first so you know when you're around then and you're looking at schools, what were you thinking about? This is what I'm looking for in a school, this is what I hope it has for my child. And then if Molly had she her own version of that.

[9:58] Colleen Kessler: Yeah, good question. Um, so it was it's very as everybody who's listening to this this podcast knows, it's an overwhelming process. And at the time, we had a voice teacher who I love the voice school, but this particular voice teacher, I think was kind of on her way out, and she was almost discouraging us from starting the process too early.

[10:20] Charlie Murphy: Uh-huh.

[10:21] Colleen Kessler: And I felt in my gut that that was wrong information.

[10:24] Charlie Murphy: What was her do you do you remember what her reticence was to start early?

[10:27] Colleen Kessler: Yeah, she I think she felt that people overcomplicate the process. And that if you start too early, you'll burn out, and you won't actually have a more uh well, it won't make you as well-rounded as you think it's going to be. She even actually we ran into her not that long ago, and this was very telling of her her opinion of the process itself. She's also been out of the process for a little too long to know what's currently going on in the process, and she's more classically trained, not musical theater. And so she doesn't know what she doesn't know. I'm giving her grace and the benefit of the doubt. But she introduced Molly to a student she currently has when we ran into her recently, um, as someone who applied to an obscene amount of schools, and you don't need to do that to yourself.

[11:11] Charlie Murphy: Um this was uh were these the schools swearing?

[11:15] Colleen Kessler: I mean, these are like filthy how big of a number is it with that it was so it was not. I mean, I think when all was said and done, the actual applications were like 32, and that included like walk-ins and stuff, which is a lot, but it's not a number you need to bleep out of your screen, though.

[11:28] Charlie Murphy: I wouldn't call it.

[11:30] Colleen Kessler: No, and so um so she was just she was prejudiced towards the process, and I felt like Molly wasn't getting started enough. So we heard about Pittsburgh Unifieds and went for the junior experience. Ultimately, we didn't go to that this year as a senior because it is so early, and Molly made the conscious decision to take more time and training to have the best polished pre-screens and not rush that initial process.

[11:56] Charlie Murphy: Um, but I will say to any parent, like in their in their sophomore junior years, um, if you're thinking about is my kid actually competitive, is this something that they're gonna be able to handle? Do they really want to do this? A junior experience like that from anywhere, like some of the MTCA stuff, um, the Pittsburgh process, there's other people and places that do junior things. It was probably the initial most beneficial thing we did and the best money spent.

[12:25] Colleen Kessler: She came out of that and going into all the master classes and things, feeling like, yeah, yeah, I am definitely competitive. I'm not the best in this room, but I am not the worst by far. I have a place, there's a place for me. And then we met you, we met Leo.

[12:41] Charlie Murphy: Um, and I mean, we have to be honest, right?

[12:44] Colleen Kessler: Leo shines in those scenarios.

[12:46] Charlie Murphy: Like he is definitely a worker of the room and um made her feel very welcome.

[12:51] Colleen Kessler: In fact, I will say this um because I'm on with you. She loves Leo, she loves Lisi, she loves Adriana, she loved Aaron and Kate, all of her coaches.

[12:59] Charlie Murphy: Um, but what she has said at the end was I really wish I'd spent more time getting to know Charlie because she really enjoyed your conversations in the green room, both in New York and Chicago, and hadn't had the opportunity to really talk to you because we were a la carte members of the family.

[13:16] Colleen Kessler: And so she we couldn't get to New York as often as we would have loved to. And she really got so much out of those conversations, which just speaks to all of the different aspects that you guys bring.

[13:29] Charlie Murphy: So um, so that's how our process started. You can let her know she missed out on nothing.

[13:33] Colleen Kessler: She must just be safe. I'm really good in small doses. So, like she got the perfect amount of I will let her know that. Of Charlie. Um, no, I that makes so much sense, and I think really smart to sort of speak toward, you know, what something like a Pittsburgh Unified, and this is true of other um organizations like this too. It's a mix of an audition experience, but also like a college fair. It's not exactly that, but like it seemed like you got an experience of like understanding what the audition experience was, an introduction to all these schools, and then you go, all right. Now I can make the choice of how do I want to lean forward in my senior year, having started that early.

[14:04] Charlie Murphy: Yeah, absolutely. It's really interesting, also. Also, like, I mean, I I think I the obscene is a little bit much, but I I can understand there's I mean, I think it's all off in a kernel of truth, and even people who I disagree with their opinion. I'm like, there's there's definitely is a danger of we certainly wouldn't want someone to feel overcoached or be like drilling their material for two straight years, you know. There's certainly but I think the often in people correctly identifying this has been said about politicians who'm like, oh, they identify the the problem correctly, but they don't always have the right solution. Then I'm like, I don't think not starting is the way to avoid being overcoached.

It's don't overcoach is the issue. Like, don't don't don't shellac your process. Like, don't if you don't want to do 50 schools, don't do 50 schools. You're not, it's not you don't have to do 50 schools just because you do Pittsburgh Unified or those kind of things.

[14:47] Colleen Kessler: Right, absolutely. Well, and Molly did a few walk-ins and didn't ultimately apply to those schools, even though they were really successful walk-ins, the uh the experience, there's a value in the experience. And then with regards to the starting early, I would say you're absolutely right. You don't want to overwork your material because you're gonna get tired of it, but you need to have a feel for what builds a well-rounded package, right? And you can't start that process in September.

[15:13] Charlie Murphy: That's right, and all the opportunity costs of like so it yes, sure. If you pick material that works perfect for you for you and you work it consistently for X amount of total time, that can work great. And not starting too early ensures you won't overwork it. But it also means that if you wanted to change the piece, if you want to now you don't you lose that opportunity, but if you have some skill based improvements you want to make, now you would lose those opportunities if you start start later.

[15:34] Colleen Kessler: Yeah. Uh and that I love that that Unified example is such a good the walk in at Unified's is such a good example where I'll hear families say that of like, well, I don't want to apply to another school, so I shouldn't do it. You don't have to that so if you don't want to apply to another, don't apply to another school. Doesn't mean you should have the experience still. Um, but we were getting a little bit sidetracked from I I wanted to talk about the the sort of mission statement in the list side of things. Because you know, again, a lot of our parents, I think that's where if they're listeners, they may feel if what whether they're in the more um administrative assistant mode or I'm more of the COO helper, whatever version of involved they are, I think they often feel like they are helping with stuff like school list research and forming that list.

[16:10] Charlie Murphy: I'm looking at the list that you came in to our initial consult with, which is like 50 schools long, meaning that you were someone who actually cut it down to get to ultimately 32. So just I guess can you talk about like what was the research that went into the list that you came in with and that you ended up with, right?

[16:27] Colleen Kessler: Um how how did that process go for you as you're call adding schools to get to that list and then calling schools to get to the ultimate ones you'll apply to?

[16:34] Colleen Kessler: Yeah, um, so I did a lot of that initial research because it was overwhelming for Molly. Um, and really she just I think like a lot of kids get stuck on the ones that they hear about over and over again. And so those were the only ones she was coming back at me with. There were a couple that she really knew she didn't want that are great programs, but she knows a lot of people that go there and she just want because they're local. We're really fortunate and it's strange that we're fortunate in Ohio to have so many options. Um but Ohio has a ton of great options, and some of those options, even though they're great, would feel like an extension of high school to somebody who lives in Ohio.

[17:12] Charlie Murphy: And so um we had some on her list that actually were put on by coaches initially that we knew she didn't want to apply to because she didn't want to end up there because she would feel like she wasn't, you know, starting over. Not starting over, that's the wrong term, but going somewhere with herself. From us, Penn State was that way for it. Penn State's a fantastic school, but you went to school in Pittsburgh, it was just like so many kids are at Penn State, even though actually was their experience at that big school. Who knows? But people felt that way. It was like it was like, oh god, that's so many people. Kent State was that for Molly, because it's a great program, but it's very local. I went there for my ma my masters.

[17:48] Colleen Kessler: Yeah, yes. And and she knows like five people in the current freshman class. So and she's done shows with them. So she wouldn't be pushing herself to, you know, um, and so in any case, we came in with a lot with the idea that we would need to pare it down. And so a lot of those were reach schools. We knew that. Um, and I actually think the majority of ours were nice middle ground. Um, and we didn't come in uh there's one or two on that initial list that were that are just BAs. Um, and just BAs isn't the right, but like just BAs where there was no audition for for the you know the safety that you want to have.

[18:27] Charlie Murphy: Yeah, um most of these are audition-based programs, and yes, and ultimately a lot of those audition-based programs also have BA programs. So one of our initial kind of calling experiences was when we submitted the academic applications and she was initially academically accepted to some of those schools that also had BAs. We took off the other any of the other BAs because we had a safety already, like she was admitted academically to Slippery Rock and um Ohio Northern and uh Ohio Northern, I think only has a BFA. Anyway, she was accepted to a couple places that had both BFAs and BAs, so we knew she could go somewhere for musical theater.

[19:08] Colleen Kessler: Yeah, so that was our initial calling, and then after talking it through with both Leo and Lisi, there were a couple others like we put on like Montclair after talking to Adriana who went there and then took off a couple others because after she did a little bit more looking at their campuses, she wasn't really interested. So I I love it.

[19:28] Charlie Murphy: Yeah, I mean, was there and of the 32 it ended up being, how many of those ended were in the first round pre-screen applications, and how many were added in after walk-ins, after other sort of audition experiences?

[19:39] Colleen Kessler: Yeah, I think um most of them were in our initial like pre-screen application process. There were, I don't know, maybe four or five, I think, after walk-ins. Um, and then a couple that were like, and this is full disclosure, mom panic. Here we are. Like, I'm not sure we have enough. Yeah. Because and let's throw this one in and throw this one in. Because Molly has a very distinct color to her voice. We've been told this by multiple different people. She's routinely cast in community theater and high school theater and youth theater. Um, but she's also a girl of average height with blondish brown hair and brown eyes, and looked like dozens of other people around and sounded similar. And so there's that panic when you're in such a competit plus.

We then learned, you know, this current class was one of the largest classes ever. And so there were a couple panic ads, which was ridiculous because ultimately she had like 19 acceptances to be at that program. You made it obscene.

[20:45] Charlie Murphy: You turned it obscene. No, I have the list here. I have the list here. I see eight. Well, I see 18 results. That's some acceptance is a wait list. I'm not sure how accurate the up-to-date data wait list. Maybe you'll give it to me live on the pod. But uh, but yeah, so so that's where, and it's also some of it, you know, as an informed person who started early, and again, that's where some of the I think the intention of your voice teacher saying, Hey, don't you don't have to panic, it is gonna be okay. Some some of that is this process gets so drawn out, right? You you do the pre-screens and then there's the waiting, and then there's the auditions, and then there's the waiting. And so that's like in those moments to go, should we do more?

Do we have enough? Even though it's like you could already have five acceptances and not even know it yet. Like they're already there waiting for you, but you don't know that until you know that. So a little bit of that panic sets and the waiting was more excruciating than I thought it was gonna be for both of us. It it felt like you were in this weird limbo.

[21:31] Colleen Kessler: Yep. Well, and it's that has gotten worse, not only the sometimes the length of time that you're waiting, but now more and more schools which do the kind of pool of consideration. It's not a yes or it used to be like pretty quickly you get a yes or a no or a wait list, and now you get these results that are like, what are you telling me? Like I'm I'm kind of interested in the third date. Let's talk about this. And you're like, is it yes, it's a no, where are we? Um, but wait, before I get too much into the minutiae, and I want to I want to do more minutiae. Just is there anything from just the broad perspective of just having just gone through this a month ago? Whew, you finished the waiting, the deposit is down. You know, is there some some wisdom that you feel like you've gained of like, hey, here's what I would tell parents. This is what this is what the experience was to me, and here's what I learned from it.

[22:12] Colleen Kessler: Yeah, I think that if I were to go back, and I've heard this from other parents too, and I'm gonna tell any parent that's listening who is about to go through this process, this is easier said than done. I would enjoy the process more and I would take it less seriously. Um, because even I got caught up in that. I would encourage my daughter to do that. I would make more, I would like pad our time with auditions to have a little bit more downtime at any of the locations so we could do things. There were a couple places that just because of the way the auditions like fell, we had this downtime and we went to like some thrift stores and bought those like blind bags of random stuff and sat in the hotel room with takeout pizza, going through these random halls of jewelry and filming videos.

Like that's that is the stuff that we're gonna remember 20 years from now. And I don't think we did enough of that. I wish that we had done more of that, but it's really really easy to get caught up in the intensity of it because when you're in the when you're in like the the weeds of it, whether it's a unified or an on-campus audition, uh, it's it's very easy to get caught up in like this is life and death, even for our kids who are easygoing.

[23:21] Charlie Murphy: And I probably would, and here's a practical thing I would say to people um if there is a school that you're really your your child really is interested or even marginally interested in, um, I would uh schedule those later in the process. We did that to an extent. The couple that we did first were not ones that she was really excited about and would have been okay with nose, um, which was great because she she was a different auditioner in March than she was in January, even. But her first on campus audition, I didn't think that went through enough. I wish we had done an on-campus audition for a school she didn't care that much about because she froze a little and had all sorts of great feedback. And I think if that particular audition had been at a unified, the energy would have been a different and it would have been a different outcome.

[24:15] Colleen Kessler: And so I would say any that are really important. I also thought to myself, any that are really important would be important to do on campus, and I don't think that's the case. I actually think she had more success at Unified's because of the energy that was in the room. So I would do more unifieds and less on campus auditions. And I think that's not necessarily universal advice. There are people who do better on campus. I think unifies and on campus are both equally successful opportunities in terms of but that, but people do, many do sort of biased toward on campus because the schools tell you, oh, come on campus, that's your best chance. But the schools mean that's their best chance. They know they'll get you if you visited and you've seen a show and all those things, but they're not admitting you at a higher rate because you go on campus.

And some people love the experience of a whole weekend focusing on audition. But to your point, especially for people who do struggle with nerves, it is a whole different kind of audition. It's like an away game versus a home game. Like it is a different experience when you're on a campus and you spend all day waiting for one audition versus when you have four auditions. It's just there's more pressure. Even if it's even if the stakes of the schools are the same, it's a different kind of pressure when you're like, I've been waiting since you know 10 a.m. for this 4 p.m. audition on this one campus.

[25:26] Charlie Murphy: Yeah, it's a whole whole different thing. And there really is no difference. I I don't think people believe that. I know I didn't fully believe it. There is no difference between the virtual and the unified and the on-campus. Yeah. We we had acceptances at all three. And some of those acceptances didn't feel like they were her best work. She felt crummy afterwards. And they were still well received. So there when people tell you that there is no difference, you need to schedule what's convenient for you, they actually mean it.

[25:54] Colleen Kessler: Yeah. I I love that. And I love the, you know, the advice about ease, which I think you know, that's a kind of general parenting advice. I think people say, offer your second kid, it's easy. You just don't take every everything as as direct drastically. Ah, they'll they'll be fine. They're probably not that sick, like all the stuff that you panic over with your first kid. I I do think in watching the process too, finding the balance of ease also does make you more competitive in the process. It it is, it's not just that, oh, you will enjoy it more. It's like if you can find the level of joy of like, here I am, I'm having fun auditioning, that is better for you too. I mean, you can't just be laissez-faire, like, have fun and not have done any work.

But if you did the work, which most of our students come in having done work being ready, then the more of that ease is that it's not just oh, so you enjoy it more, it is also for your competitors. You audition better when you're joyful and loose and all things.

[26:38] Charlie Murphy: Um, what about do you agree with Molly's assessment that she made in the this was in the the unified screen green room video of more vocal tech earlier in the process? That was her sort of self-assessment of what I would have done differently. You mentioned the ease. Would you also, you know, say, hey, that was that was advice that I think that uh I would co-sponsor?

[26:55] Colleen Kessler: Yeah, I think she stressed more about the dance pre-screen video and the dance um calls because that's her weakest area. And so she naturally wanted more of our in-person one-on-one coaching, and then the coaching, you know, virtually with Adriana, and they were very beneficial to her.

[27:13] Colleen Kessler: Yeah, but um, she had a vocal injury two years ago and had been working with um a vocal uh voice therapist at the Cleveland Clinic's voice center, um, off and on for well, like very consistently for a year and then off and on for the last the last year, and there were a couple pieces of her voice that just weren't like she couldn't get them back exactly. And we never really looked into the vocal tech stuff through MTCA, and Lisi and her were working through something, and Lisi's like, I really think you should talk to McKenzie. Okay, McKenzie shout out, like phenomenal, phenomenal. Molly already has plans to keep working with McKenzie, you know, throughout college and beyond. Um, even if it's just like a once-a-month or every six-week check-in.

But in her first like session with him, she felt like it was more valuable than six months of work with her vocal therapist because it was a different because vocal tech is different than vocal therapy, and it's different than song coaching, and it's different than voice work, it it gave her a deeper understanding of her voice. And she she took a lot of that actually into her senior production, um, where she played Dragon and Shrek, which is a very vocally complex song and long. I mean, it's a five and a half minute song, and ultimately won a supporting actor. Um, let's go, let's go. Like, and she really credits it, like her her critiques, her adjudication specifically spoke to the control in her voice, the um the choices that she made technically, and that was all based on the tech work she did.

And so in retrospect, she's thinking like if I had started tech when it was first brought up in my first consult with Leo, how much further would I have been? Sure. So yeah, there's there's definitely definite truth to that, but you can't always know where the work like what's gonna because her work with Lisi was equally you know, transformative. Her work with Kate before Kate booked was equally transformative. Her work with Aaron after Kate booked was equally transformative. So I think that just figuring, like definitely continue working on your strengths and lean into your weaknesses, but don't forget about your strengths. Like continue. It it's too often we lean we lean more heavily into our weaknesses in this process, but you need to set yourself apart in the room. So you need to like really be strong in your strength and then be good in your weakness.

[29:42] Charlie Murphy: Yeah, it's a it's a both and I mean that that's that is the first. I'll just say for those if you're a little bit of a younger listener and you're like, wait, did she say vocal tech is different than vocal therapy, which is different than songwork? Isn't that all singing? It's like, yes, that this is an advanced level of understanding, but it it is um, they are different things. So the idea of vocal therapy, vocal health versus vocal tech working on your techniques, singing versus what the work you're doing when you're acting while singing is all related to each other, but they're four different uh ideas. So I just want to make sure I said that. But but I totally agree with the strength and weaknesses we talk about on the pod a lot.

It's like we want you to lean into your to not lean away from your weaknesses out of fear, but that doesn't mean you don't need to accentuate your strengths, which often are the things that get you into the room too. So, you know, and in Molly's case, I mean, and as she she had mentioned in the interview that I think I said a bit of this in that green room thing, she was like, but I'm just loving the work of my acting uh class, I'm just loving it. And to me, I'm like, well, there's nothing wrong with pursuing the thing that you love. Maybe that's gonna evolve that some of these schools are actually acting schools with musical theater minors or whatever. But then she said, But I do want musical theater as the degree.

Well, okay, then you do have to work on those musical theater things as much. That's it, but it's it's it's hard to give blanket advice because some students who start out musical theater find they love acting and they go, Well, I'm gonna be a singer, but I'm gonna study acting because that's the thing I love them. And so it's like I don't want to s I don't want to tell parents, oh, always make them stop acting and go dance if that's their the thing they love. If you know everyone's got different goals, it's sort of like what what is that goal and and does the actual dream evolve too may happen as well.

[31:07] Colleen Kessler: Yeah, well, actually, and that's a good point and a good segue because the the idea of the dream evolving and the goal, your kids really do need a goal, and we need to honor their goals. That was um one of the things. So if you if you're looking at her acceptances, yeah, ultimately they were split. Like she initially did not want to audition for any acting only programs because she really does want the training because she knows she is a natural and intuitive actor. Yes. Now, coming like midway through the process, she did say to me at one point, I wish I had decided to audition for Juilliard and Carnegie Mellon, where she took those off of her lists initially because they're they're expensive for us.

And she knew if she went for one of those two programs, she was going to go for acting. And she really ultimately wanted to spend her four years training in all four, even if she ends up doing more acting in her career. She really is a gifted actress. That that is her gifting, which is why she had redirects, which is why she had like one of the programs actually accepted her on the spot for acting and waitlisted her for musical theater. And so then she's going back and forth and having a like a mid-audition season identity crisis. Like maybe I'm actually not cut out for musical theater and I should just lean heavily into acting and go for acting. And her final two choices came down between two very different programs, Ithaca Acting and Otterbahn Musical Theater.

And so, based on her initial goal of graduating college, after four years of intense training in all three areas, Otterbine's the clear winner because they treat all three equally, they really intensely train you. But in the idea of maybe I need to rethink my career goals and lean really into my acting strength, Ithaca makes more sense. Yes. And though you're not, you're comparing apples and oranges at that point. And so the soul searching that had to happen at that point in the conversations with coaches, including Leo and Lisi, and then people around us who have gone to both programs or knew both programs to get down to okay, what do you really want to get out of your training? And after doing a lot of deep searching, it was like, I really want to get in my undergrad all three and then potentially go back and get a master's in acting.

[33:28] Charlie Murphy: Yep. And so that and and I love the idea that they need a goal. They need that because the goal needs rigor to it, that you you you have to be able to stick to, like, hey, is this a moment of doubt that I need to push through? But it's also like, but also holding on to it loosely enough that if if it does, it seems like you did do that that down to the end, we could consider it an actual acting school that, you know, of course, she'd gotten musical training and it's like, of course. But it wouldn't have been the same as what she's gonna get out of.

[33:52] Colleen Kessler: Right. Um before we jump to the so the f I love that we already know the final two. We saw the 18 that we're into. Can you talk about the process of how did you because 18, I imagine you did not visit 18 schools, um, right? So how how did you arrive at the process of narrowing down to was it a final five before we got to a final two? How did that work for you?

[34:09] Colleen Kessler: Yeah, there were a couple that like kind of went off right away. They were like acceptances on the spots at um walk for as a walk-in, or ones that she put on the list because she felt she had to. Like one of them was a state school in the city. Your panic school went back out. They put the panic in, the panic came out. Exactly. Like one was a state school in our in our state that she knew she really didn't want to, you know, go to, but she felt she had to apply because it's it's by far the most affordable. And when we went down to it, a couple of the other options were close, would have been a little bit more money, but having the discussion. I'm actually glad we did that for for parents because um I can show it's not just about the money.

Yeah. Yeah, it'd be great to go to the cheapest school for you, but when there's just only a couple thousand in there, let's talk about what you're gonna get out of it. And so we took on we took off ones that were just way too expensive, didn't come down enough, ones that she just really applied to because she got accepted in a walk-in, one she applied to as a safety, and then we pulled it down to um four initially, and then she got off a wait list of one. So we put that on there too, and then we created a chart. I actually might not have it really close. I know it's like behind me, I think, because I don't think I threw it away. Do you want me to grab it? Yeah, go check it out.

[35:25] Charlie Murphy: Oh yeah, hold on. So, like we created this like chart of the final, you know, whatever, five schools. And there were we the it's like the scorecard that you'll hear about Leo talks about. Um, I'm sure you talk about it too, Charlie. And I gotta put my old lady glasses on to read my old lady glasses. She looks for those not watching the video, gorgeous, but now more like an old lady. Totally, more like an old lady. So we had the cost after financial aid and then the curriculum and the campus. So um we didn't visit all of them. We had visited four of these because they're they were either close or we um audition. In fact, the only two that we we um ended up visiting after acceptance, um, that weren't, you know, because we went there for the the audition were Ithaca and Auttervine, the final two in the final weekend that we needed to be making that decision, and we did it back to back. I think that that's a good thing to do because the comparisons were fresh and authentic.

[36:24] Colleen Kessler: Yep. Um, but it it was like I wanted to show the the cost because you really have to have that discussion. And not just here's something, and Lisi said this to Molly, not me. Um, and it kind of transformed the way Molly thought about the cost was don't just think about the cost because as smart as our kids are, and Molly's smart. She got accepted in the honors programs at all these schools. Um it's hard for a 17, 16, 18-year-old to comprehend what the payment looks like after graduation. The cost of attending is very different than the practical payment that they're gonna have, the money that they're gonna have as an income, and the expenses of living if they don't want to come back and live in your basement or their old room.

And so we talked about all of those things. We talked about there is a comparison of what do the stages look like, what does the training look like? What if it is an acting program because three of these five or two of these five were acting programs? What's the crossover? How easy is it to get into a dance class or a voice teacher? Um, and so we we did that and we had lots of hard discussions, and I will say I relied heavily on Leo and Lisi for these conversations because parents ultimately they have to make the decision. Yes, you're paying. Like there were a couple schools I was like, I can't pay that. Yeah, you can apply and you need to know you're taking out loans, we're co-signing, and as soon as we can, we're transferring them in your name because I have two other kids to get through college.

[38:01] Charlie Murphy: Um, but while you're paying initially or signing them up or co-signing for loans, ultimately it's their life and they need to be able to make that decision.

[38:11] Colleen Kessler: Well, and I think everything you said is so true, and adding in the factor, especially if you're you want to do theater primarily, of like early on, the jobs that you might take, even when you're working, it's not just about when you're not working, when you're working, the jobs you might take are not are are not gonna pay at a level where you're gonna be able to easily pay off loans as well. So that it also in some ways limits the flexibility you might need in the first couple years of your career to go take regional theater jobs that don't pay a ton of money, and what's that look like? And you know, there are definitely times when you're like you're making more as a bartender than you are when you switch back to being an actor for a second, and so to be able to go, like, oh, my loans are the reason I can't go do this job that doesn't pay much but is super exciting artistically. Yeah, that's there's definitely a burden to that for for sure.

[38:52] Colleen Kessler: Um you mentioned could we just talk while we're talking to scholarships. Did you guys do some negotiating? Did you talk through in those five? How did that work with you negotiating with different schools?

[39:00] Colleen Kessler: So it worked really well for a couple and not so great for a couple. Um and uh ultimately I think that that was the final um decision making between Otterbein and Ithaca. Ithaca was was much more expensive than Otterbine for us. And um they they they wouldn't go, they they gave us their best offer. And Otterbein's best offer was significantly better and then weighing the ultimate cost at the end. But then a couple other schools negotiated with us too. So there were a couple that came close at the end there to eking out one of the final two, but um ultimately she knew that one of those two places was where she belonged. It was that was my hardest thing, because that really does come from the parents.

Like, you know, um, you they know you're going to be talking about finances. And some of that they want it from the kid, but I'll be completely honest and transparent here. I wrote as Molly. I went into her email box, I wrote as her, I negotiated as her if they wanted to talk to the kid, because my 17-year-old is not equipped mentally and emotionally to handle that kind of negotiation. I had to do it. Yeah, right. I I'm I'm 50 and I'm not emotionally responsible enough to do that sometimes. But um, I had no problem when the conversation was difficult. Um, saying to Molly, and I always ask her permission, do you want me to go in your email and write as you? And she would be like, nope, I can do this one, or yeah, could you please do that? Um, parents, I think that as society, like you get one of like two very diametrically opposed opinions on this.

[40:38] Colleen Kessler: Like you can't do anything because they have to be a pin, they have to be independent, or I'm gonna do whatever my kid needs. Um, you have to meet somewhere in the middle. Yes, they have to be independent, they absolutely do, but they're kids. They're they're they're literal kids and they don't know how to have these conversations. And so you do have to be them for them sometimes. And there's no shame in that. There's no shame if your kid is someone who emotionally or because they have anxiety or another neurodivergency, um, you need to step in more. It is totally okay. And if the school can't recognize you for theirs their reasons, just be your child in their inbox.

[41:16] Colleen Kessler: I love that you reminded me of the I've heard so many famous stories of celebrities who don't have assistance but pretend like they have assistance, where at their right side, I'm sorry, this is George's assistant over here. He's not available in two claims. We tell the kids too, you can always blame, oh, my main mom is saying this. She's saying I won't pay a dime more than whatever, even though it's you pretending to be yourself as your child. Now we're getting deep into the meta. Um, but I want to talk a little bit about we'll we'll talk uh in a second on the the break here we're gonna talk about neurodiversity and some different aspects in terms of your other children. Just what was your experience?

You're so you're homeschooling your kids, you have other kids. How how are you juggling the other balls in your life while you're also navigating? You know, people talk about this like a full-time job, which it can be. How do you what about all the other full-time jobs you have? And how how did you survive the last year?

[42:06] Colleen Kessler: Yeah, you want the truth?

[42:07] Charlie Murphy: Yes, I do.

[42:08] Colleen Kessler: That's where you're I dropped a lot of those balls.

[42:10] Charlie Murphy: There you go.

[42:11] Colleen Kessler: Yeah, okay. Which balls got dropped? Are these kids the kids are gonna be mad at you? Your jobs are gonna be mad. What's what's the most dropped ball?

[42:17] Colleen Kessler: So um for me, I work from home. I have my own business. I'm a podcaster, I write books, I have a membership community for families who homeschool neurodivergent kids. And that ball got dropped a lot in that I was not super present on social media, which drives business. I um I didn't create new things or the new things that I had were not getting promoted. Um, I did the things that were already that needed to be done. Like I had podcasts going up because I have a sponsor for my podcast. So I honored that contract. I had the content in my membership community going up because I have paid community members who expected that. And then beyond that, nothing else got done.

[42:58] Colleen Kessler: So I'm digging out of this huge, like ridiculously overwhelming pile of work that should have been done over the last six months that hasn't been. Um, and my other kids, now thankfully, my kid, my younger two are 15 and 12, and they've only homeschooled. So we we stripped things down to what in my homeschooling we call our must do's like they did math, they did a little bit of writing and a little bit of reading and some handwriting every single day, and then everything else, like is all the extras because you can always catch up science and history and things like that. So they watched documentaries and they read books, but they didn't do anything that I needed to facilitate or check beyond the the three hours, right?

[43:46] Colleen Kessler: Um, and then their activities, their outside activities. So we stripped everything way down, and um, we're gonna do some more over the summer because we can always catch up and it's just part of our life. So there was no way, no way we could do everything. Um, and so everything else had to be kind of like stripped down to the bare necessities. Like we had a lot of you know, easy meals to prepare. We ate a lot of convenience foods instead of me cooking from scratch. We got backed up on our laundry, everybody ended up taking over their own laundry. Uh it it really is a full-time job. And if you homeschool, and I know there are other homeschool parents whose kids are going through this, yeah, it feels extremely overwhelming because as a homeschool parent, you're the administrator and you're the counselor and you're the record keeper, and the schools need information that the counselors at the high schools typically present or or produce to them or you know, give them.

[44:43] Colleen Kessler: And you have to come up with this. Um, I bought templates online uh for creating my um my transcripts and counselor letters and recommendations and things, so I didn't have to reinvent the wheel and then just tweaked those. Um, I over shared the stuff that my kids had done in their homeschool and our philosophies so that the academic acceptance was the easy part.

[45:05] Charlie Murphy: Yep.

[45:06] Colleen Kessler: Yep.

[45:06] Colleen Kessler: Um so they had more information than they needed, and any homeschool parent that wants to know what we did, like you can email me.

[45:13] Charlie Murphy: Yeah, well, and we're gonna we have a bunch more to talk about. I got a whole section on homeschooling I want to do, but I do think just holding on to the the balance sides of things too, just like recognizing some something has to go.

[45:24] Colleen Kessler: Yeah, you can't balance anything. I mean, balance is a myth anyway, right?

[45:28] Charlie Murphy: You're always gonna be dropping balls.

[45:29] Colleen Kessler: You need to make sure that the balls you drop aren't the ones that break and are irrevocable, yeah, exactly.

[45:34] Colleen Kessler: Like it has to be the stuff that can bounce and you can go back to. Like my younger kids and I have had a lot of Starbuck dates and random ice cream dates, yeah.

[45:42] Colleen Kessler: Um, so we can connect. The connection is the thing I can't drop. We can always come back to science. We can always come back to history.

[45:49] Charlie Murphy: So that's I mean, I talk about my wife all the time when she we will decide can we do this job? Can we do it? You know, can we do this Steven Spielberg movie for a week? Yes, but uh much if it was the two months, I don't think no. I could do every single bit of parenting and my job. Like there's certain things you could like, what can we handle? What can we not handle?

[46:04] Colleen Kessler: And and but almost always the answer is something can physically be done, but something will give.

[46:10] Charlie Murphy: I mean, there will be the balls that are dropped and things that are not accomplished, and you know, all those things.

[46:14] Colleen Kessler: Um, wait, let's take the break and I want two whole other sections of the podcast I want to get to. So let's throw this to a break and we're back in a flash with Colleen Kessler.

[46:21] Charlie Murphy: Okay, we're back with Colleen Kessler, MTCA mom and podcast host of Raising Lifelong Learners. So let's talk about these factors. I've been hinting, we're gonna talk about homeschooling, we're gonna talk about neurodiversity a little bit. Um, and I imagine they may weave together, so we'll all we don't have to keep it totally separate. But uh, you know, we've had a few conversations touching on neurodiversity and diversity of ability in different ways. Um, I thought maybe it'd be helpful just for anyone who that's newer to, and I'm sure many people it's not, but for anyone who it is, can we do a little definition of terms when we're speaking about like neurodiverse children? What does that mean definitionally? And like what are some examples of neurodiversity in terms of how it might manifest?

[46:57] Colleen Kessler: Yeah, so I'll go by like how I define it. Um so my master's, like Charlie mentioned in the very beginning, is in gifted education and with a special focus on social and emotional needs of kids who are gifted and twice exceptional. Twice exceptional is just any other kind of neurodivergency that and giftedness. So neurodivergency is when it's divert divergent from what the brain is average, like normal, normal is not the right word, but like neurotypical.

[47:27] Colleen Kessler: So the majority of people hit developmental milestones around the same time. They think about things in a pretty typical way, which is why there's a bell curve, right? Um you have the average on the bell curve for a reason because the majority of people hit that, whether it's in academics, whether it's in social and emotional development, whether it's in like physical development. And then you have those who diverge from that wherever that is. And neurodivergence is when they diverge neurologically.

[47:57] Colleen Kessler: So they could diverge neurologically, meaning they are their IQ is significantly higher or significantly lower than average. It could be an anxiety thing. Their brains are in a constant state of like fight, flight freeze. Um, they could be on the autism spectrum and have just a different kind of qualitative experience of life. Um they could be very sensitive, um, like sensory processing type issues where uh their emotional regulation, their physical regulation, um, their uh emotional regulation is difficult for them to maintain. They could have ADHD, any kind of difference that is um uh quantitatively different than the typical child is what I'm talking about when I talk about neurodiversity.

[48:45] Charlie Murphy: And what level, I mean, uh you mentioned the bell curve, like is there a a percentage of away from the mean or something? Because it feels like I, you know, I was just talking about one of my friends. It's like it feels like almost everybody is like, well, I'm not neurotypical, like I'm there's something about me that's you know, even if it's I have some ADHD tendencies, or it's like it feels like it's kind of sometimes tough in this world as we understand it better and better to to define you are this or you have this versus you're somewhere toward this, or you know, I guess what what are we talking about in terms of you know what percentage of people would be neurodiverse by the way we would define it.

[49:16] Colleen Kessler: Yeah, I so I can't speak specifically to the percentage, but I can say that like when we're talking about giftedness, it's two standard deviations above the average IQ. Um if we're talking about that bell curve.

[49:27] Colleen Kessler: So two standard deviations, two like sections. Same thing with developmentally delayed, cognitively delayed, two standard deviations below. Um when we're talking about kids who are anxious or have ADHD or um sensory processing, it's to a degree that it affects all aspects of their life. So maybe you're a little ADHD or you use that colloquial colloquially because you tend to squirrel if you're working on a task you're not super interested in. But you if you can focus in every other aspect of your life, you probably don't have ADHD. You just don't want to focus in something that you don't want to focus in.

[50:01] Charlie Murphy: And that's normal.

[50:03] Colleen Kessler: But yeah, it is like you could feel very off when you're you know in that situation, or you might be somebody who has who has stage fright and is really, really stressed out or worried before an audition, but you don't have that anxiety with any other part of your life.

[50:18] Charlie Murphy: So I wouldn't say that you then have anxiety, you're just uh nervous when it really matters to you.

[50:26] Colleen Kessler: Right. So so when we're talking about kids or adults even, but kids in our for our purposes who are neurodivergent, these are people who have, these are kids who have some kind of challenge, cognitive, physical, um, academic, that gets in the way of everything they do to some degree. They have better coping mechanisms in some areas than others, but it's going to affect them no matter what, and could, especially in the case of autism or anxiety, rear its head at any time and you just don't know when that's going to happen.

[51:01] Charlie Murphy: Yep.

[51:01] Colleen Kessler: And can we talk about some, you know, especially in the college application process. How how does it rear its head or what are some of the obstacles and challenges of going through this? I I know many of our students go through it as neurodiverse students and have these struggles and and I think it's something that we as a company are trying to be like, how do we help them more? How do we, you know, more specifically address those needs. You know, because I think it's something we you know 20 years ago we just did not have that much level of awareness.

[51:24] Colleen Kessler: We didn't certainly I think the cultural didn't but I know as a company we didn't. But I said love to hear like what what are those obstacles and what are those challenges?

[51:32] Colleen Kessler: Yeah. So like from personal experience and you know um I can share this the the perfectionism piece that comes along with anxiety or high IQ can make it so it's really hard to get essays written because we can't just write an essay. It's got to be the best essay I've ever written in my entire life or I will have no chance at all of ever getting accepted to any school. And then you're like, you know, now you're down to the the 20 minute wire of the deadlines approaching and you've got to submit it to multiple schools. So when you've got a a kiddo who is very anxious or perfectionistic or you know that kind of thing um you need to make sure that you give yourself extra time or you have somebody that is different than you that can say no this is good this is actually good enough.

[52:23] Colleen Kessler: You can submit this or so it's going to it's going to show itself in those areas. It's going to show them show it in like I don't think I did really well when everybody else around them thinks that they did well and we can't recover from it. Um, or or like a hyperventilation situation, like an overwhelm, and um you you need to like taking a deep breath is not going to make it go away. Like you have to understand what's going on in the body.

[52:47] Colleen Kessler: I try to teach my kids in particular, I've got two that do have anxiety and anxiety disorder, um, that that statistically, um, a panic attack when it gets to that point is has a half-life of about seven minutes, meaning an average anxiety attack's not gonna last longer than 14 minutes. So if you meet the seven-minute mark, you're already coming down on the other end of it. Anyone can do anything for 14 minutes. So when we can talk through it intellectually or understand the chemistry of the brain or what the brain is doing, a kiddo who's very smart and has a challenge can latch on to that intellect to kind of intellectualize themselves through, which is why to use a very specific example, when we were having a struggle point in Chicago, and you asked me how things were going, and I said it's not going really great, and you asked me what was going on.

I said, actually, why don't you go ask her? Uh-huh. Because me describing it would have been overheard and would have taken away any authority that or coaching, like mentorship that you had, and she like it could not be heard from the parent at that point.

[53:54] Colleen Kessler: And many parents of any kind of anxious or neurodivergent kiddo is gonna say that like they don't, I'm their safe spot, so they're just gonna like melt down with me. And then somebody else that can come at it from a more um just outside perspective might be able to talk them through in a way that we couldn't if we're in the emotion with them.

[54:15] Colleen Kessler: Yeah, that's why we'll said and and I think you mentioned the essays, but I obviously I think what a lot of our students struggle with also with perfectionism is the pre-screens, too. That's you know, we've had students who've literally said, I need you to take like they're like, I need to work with Matt Simpkins because I need to not have the choice to refill. But it's like I just have to because have it be good enough and move on because I will never let myself stop otherwise we ultimately did that too. We hired Lisi to be on the computer and said at the end of this hour we have to have a take of the two songs because we've taken too many tries and we did. And she's like that one's submittable don't go any further.

Yep. That's I feel like it's half my job now as a as a you know coach slash husband or whatever when we're doing 10 p.m self types of being it's good enough. It's it's probably 80% but let's just we gotta sleep so we're finishing with that one. I don't know that it's gonna be well and that's a good what you just said that 80% um for our really talented individuals. And I mean let's face it anybody that is going through this process um is already in the higher percentage because the people who kind of want to do it aren't gonna put the time and the money into it that it's gonna take because it does take both time and money and so anybody at this level could be successful. And so anybody at this level their 80% is better than the majority of the population's 110% Molly and I just had this conversation because we were talking through we keep trying to I keep trying to have different conversations about you know prepping for when I'm not there you know which is in college and I said you know one of the things I think you've you're gonna have to remember is turning papers and things in when they're 80% because your 80% is actually probably more like a 95 or 100% and you have to let yourself 80% is 95% like done is better than perfect.

We have to get that mantra. And so the 80% or the done is better than perfect is something our kids need to start hearing as just a regular part of our daily conversation. So when we get to the audition process, it doesn't feel like you're just saying that because everybody tells you to say that.

[56:16] Charlie Murphy: It's so well said.

[56:17] Colleen Kessler: So well said. Um from a kind of broader neurodiversity perspective, I think one of the most hotly debated questions we get, and I've gotten it for years in many different forms. Um we talked about it a little bit on the podcast, but I'm kind of interested in your perspective of like what to just disclose, when to disclose, how to disclose. You know, I gave a version of my answer already, which is that like in general, I think I'm in favor of more transparency than less. But I do feel like, you know, there is there is a weight of opinions on the other side of things that I'm not totally sure exactly where it comes from. I think I must be countering some advice that comes from a neurodiverse community of like of non-disclosure of not wanting of wanting to not disclose.

I think I'm especially thinking of like our students with autism and on this um this world, though, I think it could apply to some other things too. But you know, like our our autistic students maybe are a little bit worried of being judged if they disclose it. Oh, they're gonna think this means X about me, and I actually think I can pass, and so I'm gonna pretend not to, you know, not disclose it or some way. So I guess I'll throw it to you generally and then maybe we'll get some specifics. But how do you feel about that idea of like how you should disclose if you should disclose when you should disclose, et cetera.

[57:20] Colleen Kessler: Yeah, I think that that's one of those things, and this is it feels like a non-answer, but it really is the answer that it depends. Um, it totally depends on the situation, the person, and what they're auditioning for. If we're talking about college auditions, I think by and large, non-disclosure up front is where you go because you don't ever want to go into an audition with an excuse. For sure. You would never walk and go, hi, I'm Charlie, by the way, I'm autistic. Right. Oh, okay, right. But there are kids who are who are it's very especially like you said, when you're talking about autism, it's very evident when you're talking to somebody that there's something with the way like their eyes meet or they don't meet or whatever.

And so if I think a really good way to disclose that in a way that's not like hello, I'm autistic or hello, I have anxiety, is in the special skills, you know, um being uh a leader in this community or whatever, like so saying, you know, um uh I don't know, I'm a leader in the autism club or whatever it, whatever if if that's true, right? But maybe that's something you cultivate leadership in a role that is tied to uh whatever your challenge is or whatever you are. Um now, when it comes to like anxiety or ADHD, again the situation depends. I wouldn't say that in um in an audition. I would disclose that once we get, you know, to the point where we're talking about accommodations and stuff. Um how would you the school help me if you're right?

We'd need to, we'd need to do that. Like I wouldn't send any of my kids off to somewhere without the disclosure. My oldest um is very like you said earlier, like very ADHD, but actually isn't ADHD. Um he has a profoundly gifted IQ, which was the reason we started homeschooling in the first place. And profound giftedness is a just a different animal. And um everything is is different, the way that your brain takes in information and interacts with it. And so when he would go places like he went to a summer camp one time, we actually just said he had ADHD because a lot of his behaviors mimic that, and they were more able to accommodate a kiddo with ADHD than someone who is gifted because they'd be like, Oh, you're just bragging now.

If I just watched it, hey, I'm Charlie, I'm profoundly gifted. Exactly, right? And it doesn't mean anything to a population who's like, okay, fine, I get that you're smart, you know. So figuring out what's going to work in a given situation that's going to get you the best support that you need. So if we're if we're taking that from an I need support in this situation, um, then that's when you disclose. Like maybe there's um you're at a an audition and there's a gajillion people in the room waiting, and you need to be waiting outside. That could be something where you talk to the the proctor or whoever's checking you in and say, I have sensory processing disorder, I struggle in large groups.

Is there any way I can wait down the hall where it's a little quieter and you know, you just let me know, or I can come back and check in periodically, but I just want you to know I'm here. I think that's a totally appropriate way to disclose.

[1:00:29] Colleen Kessler: So it's gonna depend on the situation, what you're doing, what it's about, um, and then how you when it might come up in a way that's evident. Like, you know, I uh with this smaller example, but I know like when I have a dyslexic friends, it's like you don't walk in the room and say, Hi, I'm dyslexic. Right. But like if you're given a cold read, there's nothing wrong with saying, Hey, do you mind actually if I skip a person and I need a little more time with this because I'm dying. Nobody looks down on that go, of course. Yes, I'm not gonna ask you to cold read something if that's something that's and I think that's a really good example. In fact, my my younger daughter is dyslexic and did that once in like it was a read through and she was fumbling over words and she's like, I'm sorry, I'm dyslexic, just give me another second.

Um, when we can teach our kids that that's that's totally valid and to say with no judgment even on yourself, like I have dyslexia, this just takes me a minute, can I just have another minute to reread? Um, is empowering. And then you're when you say it in that way, you're inviting the person behind the table to come in with you and join you on that journey.

[1:01:32] Charlie Murphy: I love what you said.

[1:01:33] Colleen Kessler: You don't walk in the room and apologize. That that's that's right. There's a way of, I think there's a way of talking about those conversations where it's not an apology, it's it's a self-awareness that then yeah, invites them to say, and and also if it's two-way relationship, does invite them to go, uh, what, huh? If they were to have a negative reaction to that, I'm like, then that's probably not the school for you, right? Do you want to fool yourself into a school where you're auditioning for a program head who's like, oh, autism, I don't know, I don't know what to do with that. And you'd be like, Well, that's it's gonna be my reality for the next four years. Like, I feel like that would be a yeah, it wouldn't be a situation where I feel like it would be helpful to not have that information out there.

I I just watched uh for any of your baby survivor fans, we just watched uh uh one of the final three in this last version of Survivor was autistic. Like day one, she just came in and was like, I need to find an ally, I have to tell them I can't lie, I'm not gonna pick up on people lying, and I may have an episode in the middle of a challenge. Like she did, and then like he was able to comfort her. It was this very kind of a little bit overly cloying moment where Jeff Propes ends up crying on Survivor, but it ends up being this like kind of beautiful thing of like, hey, this is someone who was aware, and I think it was a young person who was confident to be able to say, I know what how I can succeed in this game, and I need to have those things happen. She ended up coming off so confident, and it ended up being an asset to her as opposed to a negative.

[1:02:43] Charlie Murphy: Yeah.

[1:02:45] Colleen Kessler: Um, I guess we talked about accommodations a little bit. Uh you know, as you're looking at programs, what does that look like? What are you looking for when you're having this conversation about like what additional resources or investigations of sort of faculty and which faculty might be able to work or not work with uh children who are neurodiverse? What could families be looking for? What should what questions should they ask and what should they be looking for in terms of which programs may be more supportive or less supportive of their neurodiverse kids?

[1:03:07] Charlie Murphy: Yeah, I think that more and more um the majority of the programs have accommodations and you'll find ways to work. I think that when you have a kiddo who is neurodivergent in any way, shape or form, uh, that's when it's super important to build in the extra time at the end of this process to be able to visit the final choices. So you and visit the final choices in a way that allows you time to take a tour and talk to some students. Um that was really beneficial for us at the end there. Um, the feeling on campus versus so many people say that and it feels so out there and like woo-woo, but there really is something about stepping on campus and talking to the people on campus that I remember on one of the campuses, Molly turned to me and she's like, I I didn't believe people when they said like you know when you're you're there, and I feel like I could live for four years here.

Um, I like the the conversations that we've had and whatever. Um, I think that that's hard though, because you just really I mean, you don't when it comes to neurodivergency and clicking with people, there's still the element of you're you've got people like you don't know everybody that's in your cohort. So there could be it very well could be you get in there your first year, and this is not a good fit for you because of the people who make up your cohort. Most cohorts are small and so and you live with them and breathe with them and do all your classes with them. So holding that loosely, I think is is important too. Um, asking the questions, like once you're accepted, asking the questions about what kind of accommodations are there for you know, this, that, and the other.

Molly got really good about asking what mental health accommodations there are, what kinds of resources they have for students who might be struggling with any kind of anxiety or challenges in that way. She asked about tutoring, though she's very, very smart. She gets in her head about stuff and learned through going through some dual credit stuff that like the free tutoring on campus is actually a good thing. Um, and so uh she asked those questions in appointments and meetings. Um, and so empowering your kids or encouraging your kids to feel empowered enough to ask those questions, especially. So I don't remember if it was you or Leo who said this in one of our um our parent things, but like the tables have turned once you're accepted um academically or once you're accepted artistically, even if you're just accepted academically and you're still waiting on the artistic.

Um, when you're meeting with like the admissions people or the financial people or whatever, those artistic people aren't hearing about all the questions that you're asking. They're too busy. So they're trying to get you another dotted line. They want to. Yeah. So even if you haven't, like if we had visited somewhere and we didn't know that we were artistically accepted, but we knew we were um academically accepted. Asking about tutoring, asking about mental health facilities, asking about all of that when you're not sitting with the program director is not going to damage anything. No, there's no bias against that because the registration people or the you know, whatever records people, they're not gonna call and say, Hey, did you know that the person who you're thinking about offering a BFA to uh has anxiety and wants to see a mental health professional?

Like they're not gonna do that. So you the tables really have turned at that point. You ask the questions academically and accommodation wise of the departments that are separate from artistic while you're waiting on the artistic stuff, because it's not crossing over. There's no crossover at that point. And then once you're accepted to both, you really do have all the power to ask any question. You're not gonna have your aunt your offer rescinded because you have autism or because you have anxiety or you have ADHD or whatever. They're actually going to feel better about you when you go into it because they're now for they have information that they might need or want. And I think less stigma in general.

So even if they were to that, even if that information were to somehow cross the membrane, which it wouldn't, but if it did, it's like I I do think even 15 years ago there might there may have been a little more stigma, but like now the number of schools who talk about we're looking for diversity of ability, something we're actively seeking out, and certainly have an understanding of, oh, this doesn't make you something less. This doesn't make you feel like there's just there is a that there's less stigma than there would have been.

[1:07:22] Colleen Kessler: Absolutely. And then to your point before, if there is stigma, you don't want to be there anyway. You're right. And I shouldn't say there are no programs or no people who certainly have biases, there still are, but you know, yeah, I think the world has evolved, the theater world. Oh, so much. So much. I I wonder sort of in general, like how do you feel? I'm thinking about this a little bit as a parent. Like, how do you feel in terms of like the language?

[1:07:42] Colleen Kessler: I even caught myself saying autistic students, and I think now we more likely would say, you know, students with autism or, you know, struggling with autism or other people use different phrasing. How do you feel about even this? So first, that kind of language in general, and then even the idea of like labeling, like there was a, I think about this as a parent. There was a Times article recently that was sort of saying, like, hey, I the way I now think of neurodiversity is more episodic, the way that we might view other forms of mental health. So, like someone who struggles with depression isn't necessarily depressed all the time, but there's somebody who that even in their own life they'll experience various levels of depression.

And that might be true for things like ADHD too that you experience it at different levels. I guess I've the more that's I'm interested in that scientifically, but I'm also kind of as a parent, like, do you ever have any fear of like in labeling somebody as you're an anxious kid? Is there danger in then that I think of myself differently and in more of a victimhood mindset or in terms of just like the experience of does that change me being called anxious as opposed to someone who's experiencing anxiety or that kind of thing?

[1:08:44] Charlie Murphy: Yeah.

[1:08:44] Colleen Kessler: So this is I'm not probably the most, um, I don't even know, like politically correct with my verbiage. Um, you have, yeah, I'm sure most of our listeners are the most, but yeah.

[1:08:58] Charlie Murphy: Right.

[1:08:58] Colleen Kessler: So the thing is like as a parent, so I have this unique perspective of having the background in education and the career working with families who have kids who are differently wired in some way, shape, or form, and parent for kids who have very different neurodivergencies, even from each other. Right. And I will say, first as a professional, I don't always say it right. Because here's the thing I've now been doing this, I've been working online since like the dinosaur age. Um, I had a blog when blogs were the popular thing, like built on blogger. And um at that time, you said it one way, and over the course of like the 13 years or whatever, that I mean, I started blogging before Instagram was created. Like, this is a long time, and through that period of over a decade, the language has switched multiple times.

[1:09:58] Yeah, and you can have people arguing with you online because you said he's autistic or he is a person with autism, both ways. And you can have people that say you need to use person first language or you know, um, whatever first diagnosis first language. Um, and then you have people who say you need to use the words that that autistic people use. Well, I've got friends who are autistic who like to be told who like to be called autistic, and I've got other friends who are autistic who want to be talked about as a person with autism. So even that doesn't work. So I think that the pro that you need to just you need to say whatever's most comfortable for you and your child and whomever has the diagnosis in your world and change it if you're talking to somebody else and say, I'm sorry, this is just how I've always talked about it, and my child prefers to be referred to.

And then remember that as a society, there is a danger of throwing the baby out with the bathwater. If we're too focused on the language, we're not helping children, they are children, even our 17 and 18-year-olds, they are children. Be able to become the best versions of themselves. And when we are so focused on the language and not the person behind the language, we're not helping them, we're just using them as a platform to debate. And so I don't think language matters as much as the person and getting the person the support, accommodations, and help that they need to be like I said, the best version of themselves because it is who they are, it is part of them. And so, um, so when it comes to language, I think you use what comes naturally to you, and if someone corrects you, you say, Okay, well, uh when I'm talking to you, I'll use that language and let it go with that.

[1:11:48] Colleen Kessler: And then the other part of that conversation with regards to labels, when we're talking about kids, um, we need to give them all the tools that we can give them as parents because our kids are gonna label themselves if we don't. So if you're not letting them know that they're struggling with anxiety or perfectionism, they're labeling themselves as stupid, as dumb, as bad, as broken. And we're not giving them the tools. We don't want them to use it as an excuse, like you said, for bad behavior because we live in a society with other people. And my rights stop when somebody else's start. I can't push you down because you're in my way, but I can say, I really need to walk over there and you're in my way.

Could you please move? Like we need to give them the language to be able to accommodate everybody's needs while still honoring their impulsiveness. Like I can't say I have ADHD and my impulses are hard to control, so I pushed you and I'm okay for that. No, you still can't push a person. So we need to help them understand that ADHD makes controlling your impulses a little bit more challenging for you than it is for me to control my impulses, but it doesn't make it less right. You still need to correct your, you still need to control your impulses. You just might need to talk to yourself a little bit before you act, and you might need to apologize more for behaviors that you do impulsively. And so giving them the language to understand that their brains are wired in a way that you know manifests as anxiety or autism or ADHD or sensory processing or whatever, gives them the tools to understand what their brain is doing, but we want to encourage them not to use it as an excuse for bad behavior because behavior is always a choice, even if it's a hard choice.

[1:13:31] Charlie Murphy: Oh, that's so well said.

[1:13:32] Colleen Kessler: Yeah. I just feel like that's the root of because I I find myself, I mean, I have an almost four-year old now. I find myself resistant to what is almost certainly true of a label of my child as a highly sensitive child. That's the fashion of the day, the word of the day. But the it does feel like it's yeah, it's that accountability side of it, or it's like the person. I mean, of course she's four, so I don't want her to have too much accountability. But it's like, you know, you you want her to be able to develop of like, I don't want to think, oh, I'm incapable of doing these other things, even if you're aware of like, hey, it may be that you are somebody who this is harder for it. Clear that this is harder for you than for some than other kids, but I still want you to be able to do it.

I want you to be as successful as you can in life and all those things that you I f I feel my personal resistance, even though I think intellectually I'm like, of course that's true, and I don't want to not say that's true, and I don't want her to think it's because there's something wrong with it that she can't do it.

[1:14:16] Colleen Kessler: Right.

[1:14:17] Charlie Murphy: Yeah.

[1:14:17] Colleen Kessler: Well, and that's that that's a great conversation. Like, my gosh, your brain is wired in a way that makes you so sensitive to understand what other people's are fe other people are feeling. You're so empathetic, you've got these big feelings. That's such a gift. We just need to be sure that we're not hugging people if they don't want to be hugged. We're not like yelling with excitement if we're in a place where we need to be quiet. And that's gonna be really hard for you, but I'll help you because your empathy is amazing. Like so having that language is important and exciting without then like demonizing it, right? Because you don't want that to be a problem that you they need to fix. You want it to be an understanding of who they are and what they need to work on to accommodate the others around them.

[1:14:55] Charlie Murphy: Yep.

[1:14:55] Colleen Kessler: And I definitely now have more empathy for, you know, it's just like, but she's so vice. Like she's this person, she's she's this unique, it's a good one. She's adorable and she's so exuberant. I adored her. But but I do really, I mean, I see with our parents have seen it for years, where they go, oh, but let me tell you, my child is. I'm like, I find myself doing, okay, but she is really special. I don't know. I understand it well. Um, I I don't know how expert you feel here in terms of like a conversation about like neurodiversity in commercial theater. Like, I guess how have you is that something that you're that you are paying attention to in terms of like we've seen much more evident um diversity of ability.

That's something that's you know, certainly on Broadway that's both more in inclusive. I think we've seen that uh in some ways, but also externally more um sort of representative shows like how to dance in Ohio, et cetera. Uh, how do you feel in terms of as you're seeing the you know, the commercial theater world and how they're representing neurodiversity and and or being inclusive, or are there areas where you say, hey, there still is more lacking, or the places where I really I see this as a big miss.

[1:15:54] Colleen Kessler: Yeah.

[1:15:55] Charlie Murphy: Um, I think that I'm learning more and more as we go because of the venues, you know, Molly's been more of a part of and the shows that we've seen and things like that, and the people that we've met, I I'll say like the the world of professional theater is smaller than you think. And um, and it's it's really exciting to have met so many people throughout this process because we're seeing all of that. So I feel like I'm getting more insight into that than I once had. Um, and then, you know, just being on top of like the news of our of the the Broadway world and and um regional world. So I think that it is becoming more accepting and inclusive. I think that the um, and this is completely personal with you know a little bit of my professional bias in there.

I think the danger is always uh flipping the pendulum too much to forget about like we want true representation, um, but we also want to honor the the acting piece because acting is a craft and skill. And there are people who are very gifted in that craft and can portray people that they aren't in a way that people maybe who are in that particular neurodivergence may not be able to convey the emotional. It's a different thing being with a person who has any kind of neurodivergency. We can say autism, we can say ADHD, any of those things, and an actor portraying it because an actor's job is to help you feel that character's struggle, that character's internal debate through all of the things they portray.

Whereas while you can see a person who's who has that neurodiversity portraying it, you might not be able to feel it as an audience member who doesn't experience it in a way that an actor can convey. So I think we have to be careful in professional theater of honoring both. There are definitely actors who are on the autism spectrum who are phenomenal actors and can help you feel the true struggles of autism. But I've also seen actors in um the um the show that I don't think it's around anymore, atypical that Netflix had for a while, who give a really amazing portrayal of of the internal uh workings of autism, and they're not autistic. So I I still think that we need to cast the best person for the role because acting is a craft, but we need to be more open to like we need to get more actors who have these um these actual uh diagnoses in there um to either portray it or to support the portrayal of it.

So we're being extremely, extremely authentic. And I think there are some theaters and some productions who do that really, really well. And then there are some that it almost feels like they're not they're doing it for the well, we hired these actors, like and there's always been that, right? Like with any kind of movement. Um it's impossible to draw the line, especially when we talk about lived experiences that are not evident, that are not always like, oh, I can tell this person is this. You talk about sexuality, you talk about the it goes, it's really hard to know exactly where to draw the line of who can portray different non-evident lived experiences. You know, I always use the analogy of like just you're playing a murderer, you don't actually have to be a murderer.

With certain things, well, that's obviously true. But then there's where exactly that line is drawn. I mean, I've I've had multiple gay friends argue about whether all the people in inheritance have to be gay or not. And smart people who argue both ways on both sides, you know, who say, no, you cannot understand it if you're not. I I don't know that that's I've I'm I I'm set out of the debate and go, it's interesting.

[1:19:55] Colleen Kessler: Right.

[1:19:55] Charlie Murphy: That's I think that that's where I stand too. Like it is a really interesting debate, and I can see both sides of it. I can see a value to having a person with that lived experience, like you said, a person who is autistic, portraying an autistic character, and I can see the value of having someone who is a really talented craft-based actor portraying it to evoke the emotions in the audience. There's pluses and minuses to both sides of that. Um, and so I I ultimately think that the accessibility of theater is what the real the accessibility of the auditions, yeah, the and the accessibility of people coming into the theater to watch is the bigger, you know, place we want to open things up.

[1:20:40] Colleen Kessler: That's well said and I know it's defin definitely has been and is now uh quite actively a goal of MTCA to keep making sure that we can be supportive to our our neurodiverse students and it's something our coaches I mean it's one of the most requested things for our coaches when we ask okay where could we support you more that they've all keep saying how can you help me more with it I want to be able to help my neurodiverse students more and into this world and so something that sort of I'm uh we'll put our flag in to keep keep continuing to try to grow and and learn in that area ourselves. But we boy we're going deep in philosophical and we're running long which I knew we would I knew this would be break records for our longest podcast break date so we're gonna do a little quick break and then we're gonna come back and talk about homeschooling.

[1:21:17] Charlie Murphy: So back in a flash, all right, we're back with Colleen Kessler, and we're gonna try to make this not another 30-minute section. We'll see how we can do. Um, but I want to talk about, you mentioned already that your decision to homeschool. Yeah, I want to talk about that. Uh, first, let's talk about homeschooling just in general in terms of like why you want to homeschool, what the experience is and was of homeschooling. You talked about some of the specifics of what adjusted and balls that were dropped, etc. But talk to me about what made you decide, hey, I do want to homeschool my kids, and what is that experience?

[1:21:43] Colleen Kessler: Okay, so again, full transparency, I came into homeschooling kicking and screaming. Um, so I taught for a decade. I taught first, third grade, and then I taught gifted and twice-exceptional kids, along with their emotional needs, for second and third grade for a long, long time. I left teaching not to homeschool; I left teaching to write full-time and to be home to take my kids off the bus and give them cookies and ply them with sweets and experiences. It would have been great. It didn't work out that way. My oldest, like I said earlier, is profoundly gifted. He, um, we had him tested for all manner of things in first grade because we were trying to keep him in school. We were trying to figure out what was wrong with this kid.

Um, and just like the shoemaker's kids going shoeless, the gifted specialist kids totally got that missed diagnosis because he was like all the kids I've ever worked with. He just talked at a higher level, understood at a higher level, and it was just what I was used to with kids. And so I missed the giftedness and then all of the things that went along with it. And it was clear as we went further into the diagnoses that the school system that we were in at the time was not going to be able to accommodate him in a way that wasn't going to continue killing his love of learning, which was already happening. And then our only other options were two different schools. One was a gifted magnet school that we could drive him to, and it was a 45-minute drive one way.

And I had Molly was three at the time, and I had a nursing baby. So you just drive one way. Yeah, there's no way I could drive an hour and a half twice a day with a nursing baby and a preschooler and in Ohio in the winter. So that school was out. It would have been his best option of the options at the time. And then the private schools, we just couldn't afford. I had just left teaching. I was freelance writing, taking assignments in between nursing sessions, and it just wasn't gonna work. So under duress, we pulled him out in February of his first-grade year and decided at the time we'd take it kid by kid, year by year. Molly was in a preschool at the time, and um, she did not go back to preschool.

It was hard to juggle the different schedules of a preschooler and a toddler and then a homeschooler and be able to offer the homeschooler all of the different things because there's an age gap between my first and my second, so there's a five-and-a-half-year age gap. So it was really difficult to be able to give him the experiences and the time with co-ops and outside classes and different things, and still be at preschool pickup and, you know, deal with the toddler who was, you know, in the car seat. So we decided homeschool, um, pulled them out, uh, kept her home, and my second one, Molly, just thrived. Like she at the time was like, she loved her workbooks, she loved sitting down at a little desk.

And so I was, you know, pulling the ADHD kid and gifted kid through things like kicking and screaming, and then she was like, "Can I have more? Can I have more?" And so we just kept going kid by kid, year by year. As the kids got older, we'd offer to put them back in if they wanted to, and they didn't because the opportunities that they had just kept growing. Um, I credit homeschooling really to Molly's growth in theater because we were able to pick shows. Northeast Ohio has a tremendous theater scene with so many opportunities because of Playhouse Square and because of the Beck Center, and because of Cleveland Playhouse, and because of Baldwin Wallace University and their partnerships and all the community and regional theaters around us.

And we were able, because she homeschooled, to pick and choose community theater all over within an hour, hour and a half drive because she could sleep in, do her schoolwork in the middle of the day, and had that flexibility. So she was doing um community theater as the only kid in the cast, like Mary Lennox in professional community theater, but not based theater.

[1:25:38] Charlie Murphy: Yeah.

[1:25:38] Colleen Kessler: Yeah, no kidding, like she stopped doing the youth theater where you pay, you know, and they get a role and whatever, uh, way early on because she was just able to. So she did youth theater. She did community theater. She did some regional theater, and then she wanted the high school experience, so she did high school theater through an all-boys' school that recruited girls from the community.

[1:25:57] Charlie Murphy: I was just gonna ask you, how does that work?

[1:25:58] Colleen Kessler: So you, how do you apply for that? How do you audition?

[1:26:01] Colleen Kessler: They recruited you. You just audition. So they sent out um there's a list serve here in Ohio. It's like a seriously old-fashioned list serve with like email notifications. And I came across the opening um to audition for, I don't even remember which the first one was, and we went there, she auditioned and got a part. She got, it was Something Rotten, and she got Beat and just fell in love with that community of theater and the people, but it was an all-boys Catholic prep school, and so it was um it was a completely different type of experience, but it was still high school theater, and so it, you know, got her um into it, gave her some of those experiences, and she is my kid who really likes the regular milestones, but also loves the flexibility of homeschooling and being able to pick and choose what she wants to do or doesn't want to do that year and drive her own education.

So she was able to do all the homecomings and prom and, you know, awards ceremonies and things like that, um, but still she did prom through the Catholic school. That one she did, she, her best friend goes to a school, and her best friend took because her boyfriend's a year behind her, and so they only do a senior prom. So her best friend took her boyfriend, and her best friend's boyfriend took her for prom.

[1:27:18] Charlie Murphy: Cute.

[1:27:18] Colleen Kessler: I love. But so I guess that's a part of what, and in truly this is more out of my ignorance. I'm, I'm, I wonder if there are other families who were thinking about it going, how does that work socially? And how do you, how do you maintain those social connections?

[1:27:29] Colleen Kessler: Yeah, you just, you just become more active in finding them. And here's the thing. When I started homeschooling 16 and a half years ago, almost 17 years ago, we didn't have the internet the way it is now. Uh, the prevailing thought as to how to find other homeschoolers was go to the public library during school hours, and if there were school-age children, they were likely homeschooled. Uh-huh. And so that's how we found our first groups. And um now you can, if you put into Facebook your community or your county and the word homeschool, you'll find groups, and then you could, so you can, if you want to be with other homeschoolers, you can find other homeschoolers. And then you can go to community theater, just look for audition things like there's in our, in Facebook.

Um, I'm on three different Northeast Ohio auditions groups and things like that. So there's, they're constantly posting because they want people to come audition, and you just try to audition for the different places that are looking for kids to audition, or just do youth theater and stick with one theater. I will say, in retrospect, that was one of Molly's complaints early on, was that we went for roles she really wanted to try or shows she really wanted to do instead of making one theater her home. And she's, she knows people who um, who are also gonna be going through this process who has a home theater and is always cast as one of the supporting or the leads, whereas she's constantly, you know, learning new people in new groups.

But on the flip side of that, I think as an adult, she'll realize how beneficial that is because she's worked with at least 30 different directors. She, what she experienced is much more typical of what actual actors go through with like random different new casts. Whereas it's so weird sometimes, you're like, I've been in the same youth theater, I get all the leads. I'm like, good luck out in the world.

[1:29:16] Charlie Murphy: Exactly.

[1:29:20] Colleen Kessler: Um, I love that. Well, uh, I the maybe just a little bit, and it can be a short window into it, but like what is the experience of you? You obviously as an educator was a little easier for you, but how much expertise do you have to have as a person to do free kids?

[1:29:32] Colleen Kessler: I mean, okay, so be as good as you? That's a huge misconception because I think actually my education degree hindered me more than it helped me. So when you're taught to be a teacher, you're taught to manage a group of kids. You're taught to hit certain standards by a certain time, and the kids that aren't meeting those standards are getting specialized help from resource interventionists and things like that. Gifted kids are being pulled out to work with the gifted specialist, and you're trying to manage like the middle. And when you're homeschooling, you're one-on-one, you're meeting the kid where they are, you're moving them forward, and you're parent. Um, so there's a different relationship.

And almost every time we've had problems in our homeschooling in retrospect, it's when I've tried to revert back to my education background. Like, no, this is this, this is what we need to learn now. And so I think it hurt me more than it helped me. That said, it did give me an understanding of what most kids are learning at a given time. Um, so when I could get out of my own way and remember that all kids develop differently, um, I was okay with this kid being two years behind in math, but this kid being two years ahead in math, but the kid that's two years behind in math is like three years ahead in language arts, and the one that's two years ahead in math is on grade level in language arts.

So I think that the best thing anybody homeschooling can do is not compare themselves with other homeschoolers in their area because kids really do develop at a different rate, um, and they develop at a different rate across the board. So they're not gonna be, it's really difficult for any individual to be the same level across the board, which is why there's always kids who are struggling in some areas in school. Um, and then the other thing for homeschoolers to remember is everyone in the world graduates with gaps. There's nobody that graduates high school knowing every single thing about every single textbook that they've ever been presented with. They don't remember things, and one individual is gonna remember some stuff and another is gonna remember other stuff from the same classroom.

And schools teach things differently and different, you know, courses of study and sequences. And so you don't have to teach your kids everything. You have to teach them how to find the information that they want to learn and be able to, frankly, I think this is the gift that homeschoolers have over traditionally schooled kids is um, if you can teach your kids to know that it's okay not to know and to ask questions, they're going to be more confident and the professors are actually gonna like them more.

[1:32:04] Charlie Murphy: Yep.

[1:32:05] Colleen Kessler: Um, because most kids are taught that there's a right answer and a wrong answer and that they need to know it and they're afraid to speak up and ask for help. And Molly's biggest successes in her couple of dual enrollment classes have been when she's gone to the professor and said, "I am just not getting this. Can you recommend a tutor or can you sit with me for extra time during your office hours?" And now she's gonna go into college knowing that admitting to a professor she doesn't know something is actually a sign of strength and intelligence, and the professor's gonna respect her more than if she just tries to coast or dial it in. And so, um, if you're homeschooling and you're listening, you don't have to teach them everything.

You just have to teach them that they don't need to know everything, but they can find the answers to anything. It's a, and it's a real adjustment, I know, for most kids coming from a more rigid high school environment to see the laxity. I mean, it's not completely lax, but it's the difference in terms of the way the college professors will interact with you versus your high school professors is significant. I mean, I just remember being like, oh my gosh, I can just ask for that. I need more time. And the professor's like, of course, yeah, give it stuff.

[1:33:06] Charlie Murphy: Yeah, turn it in on Monday.

[1:33:07] Colleen Kessler: I'm like, that's an option. I didn't know that was ever, but um, I'd love to talk a little bit. This is one of the questions that um, I've gotten a lot in recent years, and I was like, I have to profess my ignorance. Like, got an rarely do I get a Q&A kind of question uh in a parent meeting where I'm like, I don't know the answer. But uh someone asked recently, uh, like as a homeschooler, um, how might I be viewed differently in this process by um, by the colleges, especially like when you taught, you mentioned I've overprepared them when you look at like office of admissions and stuff like that. So, how do you feel like from the sense that you got how was Molly viewed or how are homeschoolers viewed differently from uh academic transcript perspective in this process?

[1:33:47] Colleen Kessler: Um, okay, so five, seven years ago is a different scenario than now. Now you have nothing to worry about. Um, there are so many more homeschoolers than there were, and so many admissions counselors are expressing that. They're seeing exactly what you just said. The um, the kids who are coming in from a non-rigid homeschool experience are actually more easily adapting to the college environment, and so they're able to make growth quicker than kids who have never had that flexibility. So, um, not that they're viewing them over, they're just viewing them differently, and they're viewing them as equally um enticing. Molly was not, and this is she doesn't understand, and I don't think any of our kids understand how hard it is to get into colleges just to get into colleges because they're focused on the artistic piece of it.

[1:34:47] Colleen Kessler: Molly applied academically to 35 schools and was accepted with honors to 35 schools. And her transcript is impressive, but it's not like she doesn't have her roommate that she's hooked up with for Otterbine has 11 APs. Molly has zero APs. She has two dual enrollment classes. One is ASL and one is intro to entrepreneurship. Like they're not rigorous classes. But her essay was innovative. It was about like Barbie's impact on society's view of women. And she wrote it 15,000 times it sounds like yes totally. And she is articulate when she talks to you and she's consistent with her grades and she works hard. And then her audition was strong. So but to be academically accepted with honors and merit scholarships to every single school you apply to when you're applying to that many and some are really competitive.

She was accepted to Emerson College which is a competitive academic school with significant merit money and does not quite understand the accomplishment that that is I think homeschoolers have to worry less than they do. I do think you need to keep good records um they don't have to be overkill but you do need to be able to ex have some kind of like at least general description of what the transcripted course is even if it's something you taught, there's a lot of courses on her schedule that I taught that we decided we were going to do or that I framed around stuff that we did consistently that I'm like the hours you spent on this is definitely a class on this, and so creating good descriptions, creating a good philosophy of your education, being able to articulate that and explain that.

I had a school description and a school philosophy section that included the reason why we started homeschooling in the first place. And so if you have the documents in place and you've um you've kind of done that work, I wish I had it in front of me because I tell you the different sections that I included. But again, I'm totally open if anybody like reaches out to you and wants to know that I can send you an outline or they can reach out to me. Um, but just be prepared. Do your work early because you're going to be caught up in their work too. So you need to, I underestimated that. I underestimated the the time it would take me to pull together the transcript and the course descriptions and write a letter, a counselor letter because you are the counselor, and then upload my own stuff to the common app so that she could, you know, pull it.

Um, so do that. You also need to make sure that they've got at least one other outside teacher that can write a letter of recommendation. Um, because like we had the issue that we had a different structure to our homeschool before the pandemic because we were part of a co-op that had teachers we hired to be in there, and that shut down and didn't resurrect after the pandemic. So after the pandemic, we pieced together a lot more of our stuff or did online things that she was doing asynchronously, so she didn't have the same connection with the teacher that she did prior to the pandemic, and so we had to actively cultivate relationships with like a college professor for dual enrollment and things like that.

So I would say it's not super hard. It's not hard at all to get into the schools. She got top merit at every school she went into. And here's a little side note this might change next year, but she went into every school test optional. She is a really good academic student, and she's not a great test taker because of her anxiety. And we made the conscious decision that she did not have to test, and that any school that required a test, she just wouldn't apply to. And it really only affected two of the schools that she wanted to go into. Um nationally, your diploma is recognized because homeschooling is legal in all 50 states. Every school, every state has a different requirement. And there were some states that were like, well, she needs a GED because like New York State says this in our language, and Ohio says this in our language.

But then if you go back and you say, Yeah, but this is our legal language, and we followed our law to the letter, then the New York school would be like, okay, actually, you're right. So submit what you have. So you just might have to stand strong and say, no, this is a legal diploma, and this is why, and I can give you more information about the classes if you want to. But it is recognized in every state, and there is none of the schools turned her down because she was a homeschooler.

[1:39:30] Charlie Murphy: Yep. No, that that certainly is really that's really gratifying. I think that's the part of the answer that I did know that I know people have done it. I think it's just the how to do it. And it sounds like we're here what I'm hearing is that it does require a certain level of organization on your end. Somebody at home has to be pretty organized, yeah, who's doing the homeschool, even if not an expert educator, someone's got to be able to go. I'm at least the really good, you know, um organizer of things of an event manager or whatever the thing is, they're going, I'm able to sort of process this and keep records and all that.

[1:39:56] Colleen Kessler: Yeah, or you have to have templates, like that. That was uh that's one thing I'm thinking about transferring mine into templates that somebody can download because I'll be AI. Can't they just say, hey, write me a homeschool letter from blah blah blah? You absolutely can. AI is great, and then you go back and you make it more yours. I am a huge proponent of AI because it's not going anywhere, you just have to use it the right way.

[1:40:16] Charlie Murphy: Truth. Um, what about uh this kind of tying together both homeschooling and the neurodiversity question? How do you feel like the preparation for college is different? You kind of mentioned well when I'm for when I'm not there, you know, the experience, it sounds like Molly's already had some college experiences from from homeschooling. But you know, what what are the differences in terms of how you might be preparing her or your other children for college that may be a little different than uh people who went to high school?

[1:40:39] Colleen Kessler: That's actually one of the main reasons that I had her take two dual enrollment classes. It was it was twofold. One to show a college admissions representative that she can get an A from someone other than me and um at a collegiate level. Um, and which is why I didn't care what classes she took. I mean, ASL is a rigorous class and she needs a foreign language, so that one worked out. But intro to entrepreneurship, like it was an easy class, frankly. Um, but that was one piece, so she could know that the lessons that we learned and that she learned in that, um, like you can your professors have office hours for a reason. The tutoring center is free for a reason. There are student services because they actually want you to be successful and they don't look down on people who utilize those services.

Um, so that was a choice we made specifically, and Ohio has um a partially funded program, so we applied for it and got some credits. Even if your state doesn't, I would say it's well worth the money to even take one class at a at a community college just so even if it's just online, just so your kiddos know kind of the like the like blackboard was a different, like submitting assignments virtually like that. Um, and then the other point, the other part is giving them more and more opportunities to do things that they're gonna need to do, budget, um, you know, buy their own food, think through like what foods they need and why, like the meal plan. There, you know, make meals on their own. Uh we've been we've been practicing with like rice cooker meals.

Um, you know, figuring out ways, uh, ways to say no too. Like you can blow through your money pretty quickly if you're going out with friends every day and every night. Um, so figuring out ways like, okay, I can go out, but um, I'm only gonna get a salad today. I’m gonna eat before I go, so I'm not really hungry when I go out because I've got this food in my room. Um, so I can still enjoy being with my friends, but I'm not gonna like blow my budget in a week. Um that, but then really knowing how to advocate for yourself when it comes to any accommodations that you need. Um, Molly has asthma and um she's going to a place where dorms don't have central air. And when it's very humid or the allergens and pollen are really up, she really needs that cold controlled air to be able to maintain her levels.

And I said, you have to appeal to the accommodations department because we also had heard that that's an that's a regular accommodation that they make. You could just you have to bring your own air window unit, but you have to have a physician sign it. So she made her appointment with her asthma doctor, and we went in and got a full checkup and got a new nebulizer. So she has her own nebulizer in case of emergency. She's gonna teach her roommate how to use it, and she got the accommodation form for an airy air conditioning unit. So she's bringing that. So like knowing what happens if you have an anxiety attack and mom's not downstairs. Like, what are we gonna do? Are you gonna feel comfortable going to campus services?

And you know, how are you gonna tell your roommate to help you through things? And so um just talking through things. A psychologist calls those social stories, and it's really just putting yourself in the social situation that you're gonna potentially be in and talking through scenarios like role playing and having those, just normalizing those conversations. Like, hey, how are you feeling today? You're feeling good? Great. I'm feeling blah, blah, blah. The more you do it as a parent, you know, I'm feeling overwhelmed today, I'm stressed, I haven't had a chance to work on my business this whole week and I feel like I'm failing. Can you just can you make dinner for me tonight while I go and get an hour of work in showing your kids through your actions that everybody needs accommodations sometimes? Um, so I've started normalizing doing that with all of my kids, but really intentionally with Molly this year.

[1:44:39] Charlie Murphy: I love it. All right, we've done it. We've broken the podcast record for the longest podcast yet. No, it's fantastic. Um, I just thought we let's wrap with, you know, we often ask about like general parenting advice, advice for parents. I feel like we've given so much of that. If there's any additional parent advice I would I would take it, but I'd love to do just is there any um anything that you feel like from the student perspective for our student listeners who've made it this far, any perspective of like what Molly did well in in navigating her relationship with you, or anything that you sort of feel like, hey, if you could give Molly notes or give the kids like, hey, here's a way that you can have your parent most effectively help you. Anything from that end where you would go, hey, this this is what worked or what could have worked a little bit better from the student to parent relationship perspective.

[1:45:19] Colleen Kessler: Yeah. Um I think we did a pretty good job overall, uh, because we really listened to a lot of what you guys said up front, and you know, Leo's example of his water bottle that he shares with everybody, like that hit home in the mock auditions. And so we went into it really intentionally trying to be aware of our, you know, open communication. Um that said, emotions are high, and there are times when um I would try to help too much to de-escalate, and she just really needed to live in her emotions for a little bit longer. Um pretty early in we found, and it's gonna be different for everybody. Um, you know, you have the post-audition treats and all of that, but um Molly enjoyed checking out all the hotel gyms and just walking on the treadmill, just to like kind of dissociate, and she did not want me to be a part of that.

And so I would listen to my audiobook in the room, or I'd you know, go down to the lobby and she'd go in the gym. Now, sometimes she was there much longer than I was comfortable with because you never know who's walking halls and seeing a cute girl in workout gear. And um, so I would text. I'm like, my only my only requirement is you check in, or if I text you, you just say I'm still okay. And so we did that, and I gave her the space she needed. I gave her the space to FaceTime her boyfriend every night without me in the same room, so she could so know your kid. Um I I tell the people that I work with this um be a student of your child, um, really know who they are and what they need and honor that.

Sometimes, as a parent, like you you don't need the same things that they need, and you want to give them what you need. Um, but if you're really intentional about knowing your kid and what they need and honoring that, everything else will fall into space or into place. It's just like when we were in that that situation, we had a really rough audition, and she just wanted to stay in the room and continue her meltdown. And I said, Green rooms open for 20 more minutes. We should just go. And she's like, I don't want to go in the green room, I don't want to be upset in the green room. I'm like, you're not gonna be the first one to be upset or cry in the green room. But if you just go go get a bottle, we could walk in, you can grab a bottle of water, and we can walk out if you're not feeling it.

But I just don't think it's a the right choice to stay here. And she's like, and I just let that percolate, and she came back out, had sweats thrown on, and she's like, Okay, let's go. We went up there, we walked in, I talked to you, she went straight to the water bottles. Um, Lisi was in a conversation with somebody else, and then you went over to her, and I just went to the other side of the room, and on the way back, she said, I'm so glad you made me go to the room. So sometimes you need to push, but you need to know when to push, and you need to push less than you think you should.

[1:48:17] Colleen Kessler: But then when you really feel in your gut that they're making the wrong decision, that's the time to push and enlist the help of the coaches. I'm telling you, we couldn't afford to do as much coaching as I wanted to do. The coaching that we did was all valuable, but there is nothing that can replace the green rooms at Unified's. That was I would have paid a significant amount more for that because just free. That's part it was free. I know because we that but there's so much value like honestly, Charlie. I want to say that's one of the things that sold us on MTCA was having that as a perk, no matter how many sessions we were able to afford. And I think because of it, we managed, we did more sessions than we initially had budgeted for because there was so much value in everything that you know you want you keep wanting to give back and you keep wanting to do more.

So there's so much value in that. But parents, you really do need to listen to your kids. And kids, you need to know that your parents are there because they love you, and anything they're saying is out of love. And so get frustrated, but then go back and say, I know you were just trying to help. I'm sorry that I lashed out. Um, and parents do the same thing. Apologies both ways just work to repair relationships forever.

[1:49:38] Charlie Murphy: Yeah. I will let you end it on a compliment for our green room.

[1:49:41] Colleen Kessler: That's very sweet. Isn't it true the idea of like we try to give our kids what we wanted? I mean, I'm certain that as I do my therapy with my parent parents. I'm like, oh, I see. This is what you needed from you. This is why you gave me this. And I'm sure I'm passing that same same foible along. We're trying not to, but we'll see. Um Colleen, thank you so much for all the time today. We know we can check out Raising Lifelong Learners on Instagram. It's at Colleen Kessler. Um, we so deeply appreciate you. And we'll send some people your way if they have specific questions about either of these topics for sure.

[1:50:12] Colleen Kessler: Yeah, no problem. And then you guys feel free to pick my brain too anytime you have somebody who comes to you needing anything. So appreciate it.

[1:50:19] Charlie Murphy: Thanks, Collie. This is fun. I'll talk to you soon.

[1:50:26] Charlie Murphy: Wow, wow, wow. I hope you enjoyed that record-breaking interview episode for us. Uh, I warned Colleen when I prepped this pod that I was like, I have three full episodes for you. So it turned out to be almost exactly true. There's almost the length of three full episodes of what we got into. Um, just because we're already at that record time-wise, I'm gonna try to keep these takeaways a little bit on the shorter side. You know, on both of these broader topics, when we talk about neurodiversity or homeschooling, you know, these are ones where I'd call myself more of an interested learner than someone who has any kind of real expertise on them. You know, as far as the homeschooling, uh I have no personal connection there, but I do tend to think that the representation Colleen made, that squares pretty well with my general understanding of it from previous students that we've had who've done homeschooling.

Um, the basic idea that anybody can do it when you talk about like from an educational background perspective, meaning you don't have to already be a teacher necessarily to um potentially uh do homeschooling, but that it is a big lift and it's gonna take at least one very organized person in the household. Hopefully, you got the sense from the interview of like you gotta be pretty organized to pull this off. So just knowing yourself and what you're in for before you take that on, I think is really smart.

[1:51:34] Charlie Murphy: As far as potential advantages or any disadvantage uh of it, I know some people really swear by it, but I don't really have any expertise in terms of academically. If there's a devil's advocate position to take, you know, Colleen had this very successful experience she told you about. If there's a devil advocate position to take, I would be the one to take it. Um, from an artistic perspective, I can definitely say it's not gonna hurt you and it's not gonna help you in terms of how they view you in the room. And from that educational development perspective, which might be relevant to a lot of you, I would just leave that to more to people who know what they're talking about, because I don't really know in terms of what is better.

It was interesting to me as someone who almost certainly is gonna have a gifted learner. My years peaked up, perked up. I was told my wife was like, we should think about maybe thinking about it. But uh, but yeah, but I don't really have any expertise to share there.

[1:52:18] Charlie Murphy: With neurodiversity, I think I am really learning more and more about it. Something that I think is um impacting my life more and more in terms of the presence of my family. Um, my younger brother now identifies as someone who's on the spectrum, though he didn't identify as that growing up. So it's a bit of an adjustment for all of us as a family and understanding him, understanding ourselves a little bit better, um, where we might fall on that spectrum. But I can't say I have anything really helpful to add to that general conversation. You know, I do feel relatively strongly. I'm kind of going to restate the opinion that I I said on an earlier podcast, I think as part of an intro. You know, I've I've previously shared that idea of like why you might want to be comfortable disclosing potential neurodiversity in the room.

But I have to say also, I do really agree almost 100% with Colleen's answer that she gave in the show about how it would vary based on different situations and be totally different for each specific person, each specific diagnosis, but also each specific person with that diagnosis. You know, even that example I gave, any time I gave a cavalier example, I'm always like, I don't know, not 100% true. I gave that example of like you'd never walk in and be like, hi, I'm Charlie, and this is what's going on for me, right? That's not 100% true, depending on what was going on for you physically, or if there was some neurodiversity in some kind of evident form, I could actually see exactly that happening.

If I came in on crutches because I just had a skiing accident, I could absolutely come out with a joke to just address the elephant in the room of my crutches, right? That might be a really disarming way to sort of uh lighten up the room or explain what's going on, you know, especially if it fit in with who I was as a person. Wouldn't mean I necessarily have to make a joke if that's not who I am, but that that would potentially be an avenue. So, really, you know, there are no hard and fast rules with any of this stuff.

[1:53:54] Charlie Murphy: My strong opinion that I shared, it's not about what you have to do in the room, but it's more just kind of triggered by seeing families and students who might have might think or might have expressed that it's something they need to actively hide, as if there's some reason to be ashamed of neurodiversity or really of difference in ability, physical, neurological across the board, right? And that especially for this process, I just think like all of the things that make you uniquely you are there to be proudly showcased rather than covered up. And in the case of something like autism, which is where we often get this question, I just don't think it's a helpful mindset for it to be viewed as a weakness to be hidden from auditors instead of a unique strength that makes you who you are, right?

You know, I made that comment about the recent Survivor player. You know, she kept making jokes about how she was gonna like unleash her autism on people. And she really figured out how to turn her autism into a strength for her that she could own and was a significant part of her game and her success in the game. It's Eva Erickson, if you want to look up with that person as Eva Erickson is the person who just on this most recent version of Survivor, a very impressive young woman. And I do think it's not that it's important that you necessarily explicitly lead with every version of neurodivergence, including necessarily autism, right? There's so many different ways that that could show up. And again, you know, all the situations could be different where it's like some examples we've given, like dyslexia or dyscalculia, right?

They're not likely gonna be relevant in most audition rooms, unless again maybe you're asked to read sides in the case of the dyslexia. But I do think in general, it's important that students find a way to just comfortably and confidently own who they are in all aspects of what that means. So I just tend to be in favor of whatever makes a student confidently step into owning who they are, that that's a win, right?

[1:55:46] Charlie Murphy: Um, have you all seen or heard The Greatest Showman? If not, you have a little bit of homework to go look up on YouTube or Spotify or whatever. There's this great song called This Is Me from The Greatest Showman, which probably almost all of you know, right? I just feel like it sums up the college audition process so perfectly. You could turn almost any of the lyrics of that song into a mantra for yourself right before you walk into an audition room. Like they have the line uh, I am brave, I am bruised, I am who I'm meant to be, this is me. I'm not scared to be seen, I make no apologies, this is me, right? You could do that almost any of the lines. They're just like they're there. But so I think we we have to find that version of I'm not scared to be seen, I make no apologies.

That doesn't necessarily mean disclosure. Of course, you could be someone who makes the choice not to do that, right? But you still have to be not scared to be seen, and you still have to make no apologies for who you are as you walk into the room just as an auditioner in general.

[1:56:39] Charlie Murphy: Um, okay, but I don't have time to do a deep Greatest Showman deep dive. I'm not like a huge fan of the movie. I just think that song is very great for this college audition process. Um, the last little takeaway I had was just a little note on the idea of the perfect being the enemy of the good. Um, I really appreciated Colleen's general perspective on it, especially as a parent of a perfectionist, which I think so many of our students struggle with, some element of that idea of perfectionism. I'm sure the internet and social media has made that worse. I just wanted to add in that caveat that like that 80% number that I threw out there, that is probably a bit more appropriate when we're talking about like a late night self-tape for a random guest star on a TV show, but I wouldn't necessarily use that 80% number as a barometer for a pre-screen, right?

In the case of Colleen's kid, she was saying, well, maybe 80% is actually like 95%. I'm like, okay, well, that that might be close enough, right? You know, those pre-screens, though, we've talked about it many times, they are important. They are really a big cut, as we talked about on a lot of the college episodes. A lot of the most competitive schools will pass only 25% of those videos. Some schools more, but some as few as 25% of the people are gonna pass from the pre-screen. And then we also talked about others where they'll come back and view them at the end as a final tiebreaker. So they may see them, see your audition, and then watch them as the last thing as they're putting together that yes pile.

So I certainly wouldn't just be like, oh, as long as they're 80% as good as you can do, and focus on the 80% in terms of number, that's not uh at all what I mean. But that said, the idea there of like the goal is not perfection, is absolutely true, right? It's not that they need or that they want to be shellacked or polished or perfect, right? And in fact, we talked about this before on the pod too, like the goal of striving for true perfection, if perfection means like a version that's error-free, it actually can take some of the human experience and freedom out of it, right? If it feels like you've drilled it 15 times that day, it might not be the take that has your uh all of your humanity and artistry and messiness, all of which is good.

Then again, we don't want to be singing wrong notes in your song. So there's a little bit of a balance with that, right? This is where I think if you can take the part of Colleen's advice where she talks about using a professional opinion like MTCA, who does have expertise on what is representative of your child's best work. It's a word I like to use as is it representative of your child's best work? Doesn't have to be perfect, doesn't have to be amazing, doesn't have to be the greatest thing that's ever been sung or the greatest thing that's been ever been acted, but it's got to be a representation of your child's best work. I think using that outside eye, that's money well spent.

[1:59:12] Charlie Murphy: You know, we mentioned a bit of this at the very top of the interview. Um, some of the point I was making in that Colleen was not like an overly involved MTCA parent, meaning she was not someone who's like present at every MTCA event and oh, you know, doing a hundred hours of coaching with us, where some families would do a lot of coaching. Colleen did they they used their time really wisely and judiciously in how they engage with MTCA because I think they were on a budget, right? You talked about some of that budget and from a scholarship perspective and what that would mean. And part of what they did, which I think was really smart, is they engage in what we call our red light, green light system.

This is how we help you with pre-screens and are we ready to film? Are we ready to send them in? So we you'll first get a hey, your coaches think you're in a good place to go ahead and film, and then we think you're in a good place to actually send those videos in once we've seen those videos, right? It is just a place where I think families benefit a lot from having that outside expert eye, especially for those perfectionists who, by their own standards, might always see what's wrong. It's nice for them to be able to have someone look at their pre-screen videos and say, Let me look focus on what's right here. There's a lot right here, and this is absolutely representative of your best work.

Or if something isn't ready, to let them know that, right? Once you've heard someone say, I think you can do better, this is not representative of your best work, then it can really put your mind at ease when someone says, Okay, now that one that is absolutely representative of your best work. That can make you go, okay. This person was honest with me, and now they're saying a yes, and now I feel good about um having that yes as well. You know, ultimately it's always gonna be your decision as a student and as a family. But to have that outside eye to help you if you're if you're not sure, I think it'd be really helpful for people.

[1:59:50] Charlie Murphy: All right, that is a good place to leave it for another episode of Mapping the Colleen Audition, produced by Megan Cordier and Kelly Prennergrass with social media work by Jordan Rice. You know, you can check us out at Mapping the Colleen Audition on Instagram, as well as like, subscribe, rate, and review us wherever you listen or watch your podcast. And as always, check us out at mtca.com for help with your individual college prep journey and a bit of that outside eye expertise that we can offer you. To my young artists out there mapping their journeys, please trust that you are enough exactly as you are right now, all diversities of ability included. And now keep striving. We'll catch you next week.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred