In this Artist Exploration, Joel and Charlie discuss revisiting a show after the pandemic, navigating imposter syndrome, and learning to advocate for yourself. We revisit Joel’s victory on $100,000 Pyramid by recreating his Winner’s Circle Round... Read More
From the show: Mapping The College Audition: An MTCA Podcast
Featured Shows
About
In this Artist Exploration, Joel and Charlie discuss revisiting a show after the pandemic, navigating imposter syndrome, and learning to advocate for yourself.
We revisit Joel’s victory on $100,000 Pyramid by recreating his Winner’s Circle Round
If you would like to hear more from Joel, you can follow him here:
If you have any questions about the college audition process, feel free to reach out at mailbag@mappingthecollegeaudition.com. If you’re interested in working with MTCA for help with your individualized preparation for your College Audition journey, please check us out at mtcollegeauditions.com, or on Instagram or Facebook.
About MTCA:
Musical Theater College Auditions (MTCA) is the leader in coaching acting and musical theater students through the college audition process and beyond with superlative results. MTCA has assembled a roster of expert artist-educators who can guide students artistically, organizationally, strategically, and psychologically through the competitive college audition process. MTCA provides the tools, resources, and expertise along with a vast and strong support system. They train the unique individual, empowering the artist to bring their true, authentic self to their work. MTCA believes that by helping students reveal their potential it allows each school to connect with those who are truly right for their programs, which in turn guides each student toward their best college fit.
About Charlie Murphy:
Charlie is a proud graduate of Carnegie Mellon University’s BFA program. As an Actor he has performed with theaters such as: NY Public Theatre’s “Shakespeare in the Park”, The Pearl Theatre Company, Hudson Valley Shakespeare Festival, Chautauqua Theatre Company, Kinetic Theatre Company, and the Shakespeare Theatre of DC.
With MTCA [Musical Theater College Auditions -- mtca.nyc], he has been helping prospective theatre students through the college process for over 15 years. As a Teacher and Director, he is able to do a few of his favorite things in life: help students to find their authentic selves as artists, and then help them find their best fit for their collegiate journey. Through this podcast, he hopes to continue that work as well as help demystify this intricate process.
This episode was produced by Meghan Cordier and Charlie Murphy. Episode theme music is created by Will Reynolds.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:10] Charlie Murphy: Hello, hello, and welcome to Mapping the College Audition, a podcast where we explore the landscape of the college theater world and try to demystify this daunting audition process.
[0:20] Charlie Murphy: I'm your host, Charlie Murphy, director of MTCA, Musical Theater College Auditions. And today we have a silly and fun show lined up for you.
[0:30] Charlie Murphy: Joel Waggoner is a dear friend of mine from when I first moved to New York City and a longtime amazing MTCA vocal tech coach who used to work with us before he moved on to teaching at Pace. Um, and who from whom I used to take some voice lessons. Uh Joel and I did like an exchange of like, I would give him like dialect and acting classes, and he would give me voice lessons. I think I still owe him like a dialect class, but we'll see if he collects.
[0:56] Charlie Murphy: Guys are bartering. Oh, you got to. Bartering for goods. Move into the city, you gotta barter a little bit for sure. You gotta make it happen.
[1:02] Charlie Murphy: Um, today on the show with Joel, we get into what it is to come back to a show after COVID, two years after, to sort of come right back into the same costumes. We talk about the game show aspect of NYU grad school and how he really thrived, getting to use all of his skills there. We talk about Joel not viewing himself as an actor and kind of working through imposter syndrome. Um, we talk about what it is to be a yes person and really now trying to kind of not just say yes to the next project, but actually manifest the different multi-hyphens that Joel has that he really wants to put out into the world. We talk about Joel's journey to winning $100,000 Pyramid, which happened a couple years ago, and we talk a bit about the traps of social media.
[1:42] Charlie Murphy: But Megan, before we get into the episode with Joel, spring has sprung. We've just announced our faculty masterclass teachers.
[1:51] Charlie Murphy: It's an exciting time to be an MTCA student.
[1:54] Charlie Murphy: It is an exciting time. I did it once upon a time, and I greatly enjoyed the experience.
[2:00] Charlie Murphy: Many moons ago.
[2:02] Charlie Murphy: Many, many moons ago.
[2:03] Charlie Murphy: Not so many moons.
[2:04] Charlie Murphy: Not so many.
[2:05] Charlie Murphy: But many moons. Um, but it was a great experience, and it has developed and evolved throughout the years.
[2:11] Charlie Murphy: And this year we have a spring masterclass too. Do you want to talk a little bit about like what's what's the benefits of doing spring versus summer?
[2:18] Meghan Cordier: It's so true, Megan. They're really two different experiences that are reaching toward the same thing.
[2:22] Charlie Murphy: I'll start with our in-person experience, which is 12 teachers. That's at the top of August, the second through seventh, with lots of also additional fun activities. Like we're all gonna go see a Broadway’s show. We have some Q&As with some amazing guests, including a former friend of the pod who I happen to live with.
[2:39] Charlie Murphy: I've heard a rumor that she may be doing a Q&A with us. Um, but so like a really fun week during the summer.
[2:44] Charlie Murphy: And spring is exactly half of that. It's the same program, but it's six teachers and all online. Where the in-person, the summer is all in person, the spring is all online.
[2:53] Charlie Murphy: We're really trying to stay conscious of having training available online for people who aren't able to make it in person, whether it's an East Coast activity or a West Coast activity that we have in person.
[3:02] Charlie Murphy: We've really learned about the benefit of what works with online training the past two years. And while it may not be as fun, and let's face it, it's often not as fun as in person acting and singing and dancing, it can be a really effective way to meet six faculty members from incredible training programs.
[3:18] Charlie Murphy: And it is gonna be part of, as we talk about on all these episodes, it's gonna be part of your auditioning process, whether it's in college or just moving on in the world as an auditioning professional actor. So it's worth figuring out how to learn online as well.
[3:30] Charlie Murphy: So, two amazing programs, all different teachers across the programs that you've seen, all 18 of those teachers just got announced. And of course, you've all heard about our junior weekend experience, which is happening this weekend, helping prep for all of this.
[3:44] Charlie Murphy: So, students could do both. You can get the online, you can get the live experience. There's multiple benefits of going to both, and your auditions probably will be both. Hopefully the world will be better, but you know, you never know in this changing landscape.
[3:59] Charlie Murphy: We want you so prepared that you could be doing simultaneous auditions, auditioning for one school on the computer, one school in person, all at the same time, answering questions, multitasking. That's what we train you to do here at MTCA.
[4:09] Charlie Murphy: It'd just be like a multiple cam audition rather than like a TV show.
[4:14] Charlie Murphy: It would just be an audition. But speaking of multi-cam, why don't we get to our multi-hyphenate artist, Joel Waggoner, and this fun interview.
[4:27] Charlie Murphy: Well, we are so honored to have Joel Waggoner on the pod.
[4:32] Charlie Murphy: I like that Joel laughed as soon as I said honored about it. Um Joel is another one of our true multi-hyphenate, multi-hat wearing artists.
[4:41] Charlie Murphy: He's an actor, writer, composer, music director, musician, and game show winner. Uh he has a BA from the University of Northern Iowa, an MFA in musical theater writing from NYU.
[4:52] Charlie Murphy: He's been on Broadway’s in shows like School of Rock with our fearless director, Leo Ash Evans, uh Be More Chill. He's also a founding member of the Musical Theater Factory, alongside Friend of the Pod, Shakina Nayfak, uh, a music director and vocal arrangement ranger, including shows like Broadway’s Bounty Hunter and many productions at Pace University, where you served as director of music.
[5:14] Charlie Murphy: He's also the winner of season three's premiere of ABC's 100,000 Pyramid, which will come up later in the show. Gotta do that. Joel, what's up, man? How are you doing?
[5:22] Joel Waggoner: Oh my gosh. I'm so glad to see you. I gotta tell you, I don't remember last time I saw you because of like the two years of the pandemic.
[5:30] Joel Waggoner: Because the two years of the pandemic. I think it would have been Leo's birthday party.
[5:33] Joel Waggoner: Um, and you were charming the pants off of Elizabeth at the time. She was like, who it Joel is so funny. He's so great. I was like, I know, I know.
[5:39] Charlie Murphy: Oh my goodness. Well, I remember her pants staying on, which is good.
[5:42] Joel Waggoner: Um I don't remember it that way, Joel.
[5:44] Charlie Murphy: I do not remember that. That's why you have a baby.
[5:46] Joel Waggoner: That's why you're gonna be able to do that. I don't. But you're in a nursery, that's great, unless that's your bedroom.
[5:50] Joel Waggoner: But I love it. Look how beautiful that is. What a life.
[5:53] Joel Waggoner: I'm in a little hotel.
[5:54] Charlie Murphy: Yes, you're right now at Oslo Rep, right? This is where you're calling in from.
[5:56] Joel Waggoner: Yes, I'm at Oslo Rep in Sarasota.
[6:01] Joel Waggoner: We two years ago, um, we were putting up a world premiere of this new show called Knoxville by amazing writers Steven Flaherty and Lynn Ahrens, and um uh we got cut off right in the middle of it, and they decided to put it up two years later, and I gotta tell you it is surreal and um totally healing because I was really hoping it would be healing because I, you know, I like anybody else in the industry have like really struggled the last two years finding purpose in it, finding a point in it, because like the essentiality of theater was questioned largely and and everyone was pivoting, and I just didn't know like not only did I feel purposeless, I was also like, well, what's the point of theater? What are we even doing it for?
[6:43] Joel Waggoner: But being back in rehearsal and having a schedule and having people around me and and um, you know, telling the story and just convincing yourself that that matters, it eventually gets back in your bones.
[6:58] Joel Waggoner: And I'm just so profoundly grateful for that. But it is weird because you know, they bring us back, and there are our costumes with our names in them, and there are props just have been they've just been sitting there, you know, just sitting there in the same spot.
[7:11] Joel Waggoner: Thank God my costumes still fit. Otherwise, whatever. But you know what I mean? Um that's a Herculean effort itself, just the costume fitting after two years.
[7:17] Charlie Murphy: Oh, don't even get me started.
[7:19] Joel Waggoner: I do think it's really interesting. We talk about this a lot with the pandemic of like going back to something from before, because I think we all had that desire for the snapback of the business.
[7:27] Charlie Murphy: Oh my god, it's all back, it's everything we wanted that we didn't lose anything from it, but we're all like different people emerging from it.
[7:34] Joel Waggoner: So to step back into costumes and parts that you played two years ago, now as a new person, it's gotta be so weird.
[7:40] Joel Waggoner: It's so weird. One thing that we did on the first day, which was amazing, was Oslo has this um, this woman named Dwanda, and she's an affinity space holder.
[7:51] Joel Waggoner: So basically what she did is just we had a big Zoom meeting the first day because we had the COVID test, and everybody in the cast and creative team had a moment to say where they've been, what they've been doing, what they want to get out of the process, where they are as a person.
[8:06] Joel Waggoner: And everyone was brave enough to be really vulnerable. And some of us were like, I don't really know if I I don't really know if I like theater anymore, or I don't even know if this is for me, it's been a real struggle.
[8:19] Joel Waggoner: Or some people were like, I lost someone really recently, and this is really hard, or I'm or some people were like, I'm actually really, really ready. I've been missing this, and blah blah blah.
[8:28] Joel Waggoner: So everybody was able to come at it with total honesty, which I thought was like so great, which also opened the doors for us to have side conversations as people and cut the small talk.
[8:38] Joel Waggoner: We just went straight to like, you know, here was what I dealt with in my mental health journey, and um, here's where I went, and um, you know, I got a house and I didn't do this, and blah blah blah.
[8:49] Joel Waggoner: So it was like it's just been really profound, and we're all able to come at it just as we are. Like as our ambivalent sort of like, I'm not sure who I am, or if I know how to act anymore. So let's just try it.
[9:02] Joel Waggoner: So that's been actually really, really, really special. But we were just informed yesterday that they're gonna produce a original cast album.
[9:11] Joel Waggoner: Hell yeah.
[9:12] Joel Waggoner: Which is like out of control, insane for me to imagine like I first of all, that it's happening after a regional theater world premiere. That's like who does that anymore?
[9:24] Joel Waggoner: But also at the same time, I'm like, you know what? If Flaherty and Ahrens are making that happen, and they're and there are people who support them, if that's the new precedent, like what if that were a new thing?
[9:26] Joel Waggoner: What if that were a thing? You could actually premiere a new musical out of town and then get a cast album out of it. Like, so Broadway’s isn't the sort of nucleus of it anymore. I love it.
[9:45] Charlie Murphy: Um, but before we get too deep into the career, because I I love what we're where we're going and we'll spend a lot of the second half talking about the career. I'd love to hear a little bit about your journey to this wonderful success that you have had, um, especially in terms of kind of your educational journey.
[9:58] Charlie Murphy: And if I can take you back to like 16, 17 year old Joel, maybe first starting to look at colleges. I'd love to even hear like what were you looking for in a school? What were your goals as you began to approach the process, maybe not knowing quite as much as you know now about it, like what were you thinking about it in terms of what you were hoping to get out of school?
[10:18] Joel Waggoner: It's so weird and interesting for me to look back at myself in high school, um, for many reasons. But as far as the college search goes, because I grew up in um medium town Iowa.
[10:38] Joel Waggoner: Um, and that's not a real town, right?
[10:41] Charlie Murphy: You're just saying medium size.
[10:43] Joel Waggoner: Yes, I'm saying instead of saying small town, I said medium town.
[10:47] Joel Waggoner: In the middle of the country, sometimes medium town would be believable as a town.
[10:49] Charlie Murphy: I wouldn't have to be able to do that.
[10:50] Joel Waggoner: Exactly. Welcome to Medium Town Normalville, starring little things.
[10:54] Charlie Murphy: Yes.
[10:55] Joel Waggoner: So the town was called Waterloo, Cedar Falls. There's two cities, and one of them had a university.
[11:00] Joel Waggoner: But when I was looking to sc for for colleges to go to, my first my first criteria um was anywhere but Iowa.
[11:12] Joel Waggoner: I was like, nope, I'm and I'm definitely not going to UNI because my dad worked there and I was and I grew up there.
[11:18] Joel Waggoner: I grew up like taking dance lessons and and violin and like, you know, just you just drive by it because you grow up there.
[11:26] Joel Waggoner: Um I was like, absolutely not. I meant for bigger things, right. But what happened was no one in my town knew a thing about how to prepare someone for musical theater auditions.
[11:37] Joel Waggoner: It was a really opera heavy school, and the community theater people just did community theater. And I didn't know anybody who left town to do what I did.
[11:45] Joel Waggoner: Um so I was like, okay, I'm gonna find some applications to like the classic musical theater schools at the time, which were like Michigan, UCLA, uh Carnegie Mellon, um Cincinnati Conservatory, Boco, and I just literally printed them off.
[12:02] Joel Waggoner: Um, and then I also just for fun printed off University of Northern Colorado. Because I was like, well, I heard they had a program.
[12:10] Joel Waggoner: And I was like, just get me out of Iowa.
[12:12] Joel Waggoner: Um so what happened was I printed them off, and then I started looking through the uh audition process and where I had to go to audition, and my parents and I were completely lost.
[12:27] Joel Waggoner: Like I had no power, I had no knowledge of what to do. I was like, where do we go? Are we supposed to drive to Boston? Am I supposed to learn a song?
[12:34] Joel Waggoner: Like, do we just show up at the door and say, Hi, I'm gay, let me in, like, like I do with every other thing I do in the world, which is works. I'm just joking.
[12:44] Joel Waggoner: So I had a real quiet moment with myself, and I was like, what is the one constant for me that I would be unwilling to be um not the not the best at, but what's the one skill set that matters the most to me?
[12:45] Joel Waggoner: And I was like, that's music. I was like, I've always had music at the forefront.
[13:08] Joel Waggoner: I've always been composing, I've always been playing piano, violin, guitar, singing. I've always done that, always written, and I'm like, that is the thing that if I don't know the most about, I'll be disappointed.
[13:20] Joel Waggoner: Acting for me, I was like, I'm not passionate about acting. Singing, I can learn, but I was like, I I gotta know music, music, music.
[13:28] Joel Waggoner: And ironically, the best music school I knew of was University of Northern Iowa, which was where I grew up.
[13:36] Joel Waggoner: They had an incredible jazz program, an awesome vocal department, great theater department, incredible orchestra with this amazing conductor, and the Waterloo Cedar Falls Symphony was out of there.
[13:46] Joel Waggoner: Um, and it was a big 13,000 state school. So, like 13,000 uh the the number of students was about 13,000.
[13:55] Joel Waggoner: And you know, I I grew up going there, but I'd never been to college there.
[13:58] Joel Waggoner: Um, and I think I decided I was like, I'm just gonna do a semester while I figure out how to audition for these other musical theater programs.
[13:58] Joel Waggoner: I was like, I'm just gonna go, and that way, like, you know, I can just ease out of my parents or whatever.
[14:13] Joel Waggoner: I stayed at University of Northern Iowa, which was where I grew up.
[14:18] Joel Waggoner: Um, I stayed there for five years.
[14:22] Joel Waggoner: I did a victory lap because I loved it so much.
[14:26] Joel Waggoner: I was able to not only do everything I wanted to do and more, but I was also able to spend the last years of my grandparents' life near them.
[14:26] Joel Waggoner: I was also able to have my parents support when I needed it.
[14:40] Joel Waggoner: Um, and I lived away from home the whole time. And in that five years, I saw my dad on campus maybe twice. And once was on purpose because he had to help me move a cheap love seat up four flights of stairs. And I made the best friends of my life at that program. So, and I uh so it's really weird for me to look back at that time because I was so hungry to get out, but it was a life-changing experience. I do think that if I have one regret, it was that because it was in my hometown, I had a reputation of being sort of like a vunderkint a little bit in my hometown. So when I went to college, I didn't really allow myself to fully fail. Like I didn't allow myself to be anonymous and just fall back and do nothing and or not do nothing, but fall back and be willing to let my voice crack and willing to like be bad at stuff.
I had a little bit of a chip on my shoulder, I had to keep it up. So I was a little resistant to some education and some learning that would have made me um be bad, which kept me from getting better. So I had some student, I had some colleagues and friends of mine who came in, you know, being like Say to my you know, and I would come and be like, sit. Well, I I'd be singing my you know, my version, but slowly and surely because they knew very little because they were coming from zero and learning what they were taught, before you knew it, all of a sudden I was like, Wait, how are they hitting that note? How are they getting that? How are they hitting that? How come they won that thing and I didn't? Like, I was suddenly like, wait a second, maybe I need to start over and erase my erase what I know.
So I really think that if I were to go back, I would have found a place where I could have s really been vulnerable, started over, had the support and the confidence from others and and and teachers and professors that I would be okay. Because I do know now, even as an adult, I struggle with man, I wish I had learned to do this earlier because instead I was really trying to I was trying to be the star kid. Um and all I needed was like a year of just being bad.
[16:59] Charlie Murphy: Yeah, it comes up a lot the idea of like uh you know it's a marathon, not a sprint, right? So that that like the more that you if you're ahead, you're way ahead in this one area, it's like it's great, but people will catch up if you're not continuing to work, continue to move in that place. If you're like, I'm just gonna rest on my laurels there. It's like people will catch you up in this business and certainly in the education. You studied vocal performance and violin, right?
[17:20] Joel Waggoner: Well, yeah. So here's the deal, right? I I'm chewing something, by the way. I this is how casual I am. 2022, I'm like, I'm eating on a podcast. ASMR for all you friends out there, yummy, yummy. There's a little agave nectar in it if you want to have like smell of vision. Okay, so the uh the major, the reason I'm saying this, um, or the reason I'm stopping to talk about this, is I did every possible uh thing that I could do in college, including every extracurricular moment. So I was concertmaster of the orchestra, I was section leader of uh a chamber uh singing group and a jazz choir group, and uh I was in a concert corral. I played piano for vocal um studios and recitals. I took piano lessons.
I was Sweeney Todd in a gigantic production uh that was done in partnership with the School of Music and Theater production. I was Johnny Skeeky in an opera. I was in a chorus line, I played Al DeLuca. I mean, this happened. Um and then I was also a conductor, so I would conduct things and um I wrote things, I wrote a fanfare for the orchestra, and like it just so I just went nonstop all the time. Um but the problem with that at a liberal arts school is that you have to take liberal arts. So I was shoving so many things into my schedule that I couldn't get my liberal arts core in enough time. And so here I was, 23 years old, or 23 years old, um, my fifth year of college in a math for decision making class with 18-year-olds.
Um, you know, desperately trying to copy off the girl next to me and you know, exchange somehow. I don't know what I tried to barter with her, just like association with a senior. I don't know. It was awful. But I had to push through that.
[19:17] Charlie Murphy: Um, and having seen your payloads, Joel. I know for sure you did not pass that math class.
[19:22] Joel Waggoner: I'm just no, you did not. Oh my god. Payloads back in oh the last time I gave you a payload was maybe 10 years ago, I feel like. Oh Lord. It's been a while. You've got a different thing now, right? Something knack or I don't know.
[19:31] Charlie Murphy: Um, but yes, thanks, thanks for the your photo confidence. I'm much better at music math. Uh-huh. But what happened was I I ran up to a point where I'm like, I can't stay in college anymore because A, I'm going to graduate school because I decided to apply. And B, it's time to leave the nest. Um so what I basically did is I just looked at all my Halloween candy that was laid out on the can't on the on the counter, and I was like, what can I piece together? It was honestly like chopped. It was just like chopped. It was like open a basket. It's like you get a rabbit liver, a jello salad, you know, the the head of a um beetle, and you have to like make a meal out of it. And I was like, okay, well, I have enough here to maybe piece together a vocal performance or a vocal degree, a vocal major and a violin major, but I I have to do a recital for both.
So I just like threw together basically a recital in and voice and violin, and that allowed me to have a BA in both those things. But ultimately, when I describe my college experience, I say that I should have just gotten a degree of participation. Just get a participation trophy.
[20:41] Charlie Murphy: What do you imagine? Like, I know of course you had such a different education than those ones you first envisioned, but how do you imagine it would have been different if you gotten that BFA from a CCM or a vocal or you know that that kind of more traditional musical theater training, given that you have many different hats, but at least one of them now is a Broadway’s actor.
[21:00] Joel Waggoner: Yeah. You know, I think that's r it's really interesting. I haven't really thought about how my life would have been different. I think that I would have been. I think that I I think I would have met more people like me sooner. I think I would have met just more gay men sooner, but I also would have met more people like me sooner. And I um and by that I mean people who have the same interest as me and the people who like to sing like I do unapologetically and not be ashamed of it because there's a lot of shame in musical theater singing in an opera program. So that I think would have really done wonders for me to feel seen and feel like, oh my god, like not only am I not alone, but it's so cool to be here.
Like I would have loved to have gone back and felt like I found my people earlier and that I wasn't this stick out standout who is this person guy. I had a lot of friends, totally, but I was not like anybody else. Like, I just wasn't. It took me till New York to sort of meet people that were like me.
[22:08] Charlie Murphy: I feel like Yeah, I I remember that and and especially when we first met. Of course you had a great friend group and you're a community, but it felt there was still a a a a searching and a putting your tentacles into the community in a way that I think you didn't graduate with twelve other people who moved to the city with you in the same way. That there was that different like, oh I'm I'm still rooting myself in.
[22:27] Joel Waggoner: Right. And I'm in a way different place now than I was when I moved to the city. Um you know in a way I the person I am now is the person I've been trying to build since high school because I had delays and fear and shame in the way, but I also had logistics and just not knowing. And so I've had to give myself a lot of compassion. I've had to show myself a lot of compassion and patience. Um just to just to let myself just just because I feel sometimes like it's taking me, it's taken me too long to get to this place. Um, but that's just me comparing myself to other people's journeys. And my journey has its own sort of spectacular arc.
[23:20] Charlie Murphy: So um yeah, it does. Yeah, I mean, we all have. We had Dakon Matthews on the pod who made it Broadway’s debut in his 60s. So, you know, come on. You cracked it.
[23:27] Joel Waggoner: Right, right, right. Well, that's something I didn't even after a while, it's something I didn't even expect. Um or didn't even think about anymore. Um, because I was so entrenched in a different life. So if I had a BFA in musical theater or went to musical theater school, I imagine I would have a very different trajectory um because I'd be more hungry for the stage or or hungry for writing musical theater. Um and I wouldn't have taken the music directing and teaching uh route that I took and the vocal coaching route that I took for, you know, almost eight years. Um but it was also a a part of me. I really loved teaching and I and I loved music directing because I was good at it, but I also um I liked I felt purposeful and I felt like I could make it fun and I could be creative with it.
Uh it just so recent it just so happens that recently I've I've been deciding to pull away from it a little bit more because it isn't as creative for me as it used to be. It used to be really fun for me to put things together and teach and and now I'm a little bit more like uh I want to spend any time that I have, I want to spend either working on my own work um and realizing that or just picking things that are are are let me be my fullest self and less of a facilitator of other people's works if that makes sort of sense and we'll get a lot into the hats in our second half of the interview but before m I move on I just want to talk a bit about NYU the MFA so how did that timing work in terms of um when you you lashed on for for that part of things so I started my fifth year of my fifth year of college my victory lap which was basically also a like oh my god I need to I need a year to figure out what I'm gonna do next because I didn't think this through just like I did in high school I was like I didn't think this through so I had two professors that I loved one was my director for Sweeney Todd and the other was the orchestra conductor and we are both dear friends still I just produced a demo of their new musical but they said there's this program at NYU it's for musical theater writing and we think you should apply and I was like oh okay and then I recall my mom showing me that program in high school and I was like oh man I wish I could do this right away but I can't because I have to go to college first.
[25:51] Joel Waggoner: So I literally forgot about it for five years. And they were like we think you should apply and I was like I think you're right and I was terrified but I was like I have to do this because I think that that is the thing. And it was so niche but so up my alley because I was like I I know I've been wanting to write I wrote my first musical when I was in third grade like I've just always been like I got I've got to do this. So I worked up the courage to make do the application and I wrote music for it and I I literally put everything I'd ever written into this envelope. Like and stuff I'd written specifically for it. In fact, one of the songs I still play at concerts was a piece I wrote for the application.
And I sent it in. I had some of my friends record the stuff. I put it on a CD. I remember like going to CopyWorks and getting a spiral bound. It was like it was the hardest I'd ever worked on an application. It truly was. There's a lot more than just like, hello, I'm gay, let me in.
[26:52] Charlie Murphy: Exactly.
[26:52] Joel Waggoner: It's a way more than that. Because gay is a given when you're applying for musical theater writing to school. Um so I uh I put that it was a really hard application to put together, but I put it together somehow. And it took a long time, but I sent it in and I was like, here literally goes nothing. I mean, like these are songs that no one had ever heard. Um, you know, I don't think I picked my parents heard them. Like it was wild. I just sent them all in. And I somehow got um picked for the applicant weekend, which was in March of 2008. And so my parents flew me out there, or did they they flew? We flew out, and I wore off like a full suit to my interview. But when I showed up, I was so shocked that like people were just like not wearing suits.
They were just like straight up like just wearing hoodies and regular ass people's shit. But they were right wearing just regular things. I was like, oh, I'm way too dressed up for this, but at the same time, I'm like, well, I'm dressed for how much it matters to me. And I think that's an important thing to take with you.
[27:52] Charlie Murphy: Um let's just be clear, Joel is right now dressed in pajamas, so I'm just taking the notes.
[27:56] Joel Waggoner: I am not in pajamas, I'm wearing a vest.
[27:57] Charlie Murphy: I'm wearing a vest.
[27:59] Joel Waggoner: What's on the bottom?
[28:01] Charlie Murphy: What's on the bottom?
[28:01] Joel Waggoner: The bottom are amazing gauze pants from this store called Oh My Gause in Leto Beach, Sarasota. And they are flowy, cool women's pants, and they are extra extraordinary. And they look a little bit like Aladdin pants.
[28:16] Charlie Murphy: Well, then I take it. Then you think we're extraordinary.
[28:18] Joel Waggoner: Yes. You dress for the for how much you care.
[28:21] Charlie Murphy: Yes, absolutely. And for rehearsal. Um but uh so I did the program. Uh I I I I did the applicant weekend. It was very intense. Um, it was like three days. They they pair you up with a random person from another part of the country. I had this girl from London, and we had to write a scene in a song over the weekend somehow in New York City, finding a piano. And then we came back and I performed it, and then they just sent us off. And we found out, I think, oh gosh, maybe like a month or so later. I found out that I got in, and my parents and I were just like, well, here goes nothing. And I I got in touch with some of the people from the applicant weekend who also got in, and we found an apartment together, and my parents drove me out in a van for two days, and um the rest is sort of history.
The the program was two years long, and the first year was a lot of tutorials, labs, meaning like you go in and you do like you you practice writing one song, a lot of assignments, just like learning the craft of it.
[29:22] Joel Waggoner: And the whole second year, you're paired with a person. If you're a composer, you're paired with a lyricist book writer, and you write a full-length 90-minute musical over the span of the entire year. We had great professors. We had Bill Finn, Michael John LaCusa, we had a lot of guests, like Winnie Holzman, Elton John came and talked to us. We had a lot of incredible people there, and I made a lot of great connections. My most important one was probably Bill Finn. He had a really intense master class in lyric writing, and it was honestly a reality show. He was just like, "This sucks," or he was like, "This is good." Basically, everyone sat around a table and they presented their lyric that they had written based on the assignment that he'd given.
We all read it aloud, and if he liked it, he'd go, "Who wants to set it?" Us composers would be sitting in the dugout around the table, and one of us would just raise our hand, and he would hand us the lyric, and we would run downstairs to the basement and set it to music, and then by the end of class, come up and perform it for the group. If he liked it, he put it on one of his concerts. So it was this really wild game show-like thing. It really was. And I learned to be a confident songwriter because of how little time I had to get my own way. I would have to go downstairs, write it out, and then I loved to perform. So I came up and I was like, I just would end class with just performing what I just written, and I was like this really weird rush of unbelievable creativity and adrenaline, and it was just wild.
But so I wrote enough stuff in that class that he didn't hate, and we built a relationship over time, which led me to my relationship with Barrington Stage Company and some of the musicals I did there. But that's a whole other thing. The graduate program was profound for me; it was very expensive, and some other people didn't get much out of it, and a lot of people haven't followed the career because it's very difficult. It's a very difficult, as you know. Some people are like, "Oh, I don't know why I even went there." So many people at BMI didn't or just go for free, and now their work's getting produced. But for me, it is the thing that got me to New York. It is the thing that got me noticed as a composer to people who could move me forward, and it taught me that I was a composer because when I went there, I had like five songs to my name, and now I have hundreds and hundreds and two full-length musicals and all this stuff because I just learned so it was really a magical thing for me.
And also while I was there, these other composers that were working on things would have me sing their stuff, so I'd be performing and playing violin and playing piano, and so I was just a real perfect use of all the music skills that I had built up. So it was like perfect synthesis. And then one of the composers who had been in the program a couple years prior was working on a new musical called Southern Comfort, and she heard that I sang and played violin. She's like, "Hey, I'm doing a reading of this late night this Thursday. Can you just come insight read and play a little violin?" And that was in 2009, my second year of grad school. And then two years later, 2011, there was a full production at Cap 21, and she asked me to be in it, and I was like, "Oh my god, sure."
Then in 2013, that same production of Southern Comfort was done at Barrington Stage Company, and then 2016 it was done at the Public Theater, and I was in every one of those things. So that's like that's another one of those things where you just stay with it for long enough, and it's crazy. And that's sort of what's happened with Knoxville, why I'm here right now. I was a Dramatists Guild fellow in 2012 because of my experience at NYU. And in 2012, it was Stephen Flaherty and Lynn Ahrens' last year running the Dramatists Guild fellowship program. They heard me play all the things and sing all the things, and then somehow in 2018 they heard that I was in School of Rock, and Stephen Flaherty sends me an email.
He goes, "Hey, we're working on a new show and we think you'd be right for it. Will you send in a tape?" So over an agent's head. It's just it's so weird how life works out that way. Like I'm really having to remember that, especially after two years of darkness.
[33:51] Charlie Murphy: Tell me a little bit about that before we jump to the Steven Flaherty. Just the acting of it all. Certainly when I first met you, you didn't talk about yourself like an actor, right? You talked about yourself like, "I have all these skills and I teach voice and I'm a great vocalist." We knew you could sing always, and you were gonna go composer and writer, but you didn't lead with, "I'm a performer." But then, you know, only a couple years later, there you are on Broadway’s. So how does that happen in terms of the transition for you?
[34:17] Joel Waggoner: I still oddly don't call myself an actor. I don't consider myself an actor even though I know I am, and I'm waiting for the moment for someone who I trust to be like, "You're an actor." The reason I say that I'm not an actor is I feel a little I feel imposter syndrome or fraud syndrome. I feel like I haven't put the work in like most other people have. I haven't gotten the degree. I haven't studied all the classics. I haven't done Shakespeare. I haven't been in a play except for like a kid play. And I like to entertain. I love to just be myself. Clearly, I've been talking this entire time with no problem. Oopsie daisy, sorry if you're bored, scoop over it. But I enjoy that. And I enjoy comedic acting, which is also acting, I guess.
So I enjoy sort of big stuff like that. It's the dramatic acting that I think I struggle to tap into as a performer because I would rather sing it 'cause I can really feel safe to release it there. So I guess I am an actor. I will say that I am an actor, but I have hesitancy around dramatic acting. Even though I do it, I still feel fraudulent about it a little bit.
[35:29] Charlie Murphy: But if I can say, someone who's seen you perform, you're a fantastic actor. And of course, yeah, if you're comfortable acting while singing, but it's like that's like how I would feel. I'm like, I'm comfortable with Shakespeare, but like you put a sheet of music in my hand, I'd be like, "Um, okay, we'll see what happens here." Great. Yeah, I guess you're not saying you're a flawless actor, but you're very good at acting. That's interesting.
[35:47] Joel Waggoner: Yeah, I mean, yeah, if you put a Shakespeare monologue in front of me, I would feel so naked. But if you put sheet music in front of me, I would be like, "All right, move over, you know." Full on gauze pants, you're ready to go.
[35:59] Charlie Murphy: Gaus.
[36:01] Joel Waggoner: Oh my gosh. Yes. So I'm actually working through some of that imposter syndrome right now in this production, and I was very open with Frank, especially after two years. I was like Frank Galati, the director, who's a wizard and a legend. I was like, "Listen, I'm not quite sure how to do this. I'm not quite sure how to synthesize everything." Because I think what happens for me is it's easy for me to be honest. It's easy for me to be myself. What's hard for me to do is funnel my honesty through a character description. So for instance, the particular character I'm playing in the show is a functional alcoholic who's sort of emotionally abusive to his wife in 1915 Tennessee, and he's the lesser loved son of his brother Jay.
And so there's a lot of things that I have to that are put on me that I necessarily don't have to play, and that's what I've been trying to figure out how to synthesize. It's like, "Okay, I'm not gonna play drunk because I'm functional," which means I am already operating, so I don't have to stumble or anything.
[37:19] Charlie Murphy: Exactly.
[37:19] Joel Waggoner: But you know what I mean? Like there's things like that that sometimes I feel like I'm carrying all of these assignments. "Okay, it's 1915, so you can't like pop your hip, and it's da-da-da, so you can't do this, and it's southern, so keep the accent going, but also you're abusive, so don't use your arms too much because you're hurt." And sometimes I have a hard time just sort of wearing the clothes, just like dropping it all and wearing the clothes and just letting the stillness of my body tell the story. So that's what I'm really working on is trying to stop intellectualizing everything so much.
[37:51] Charlie Murphy: I love that. That's something we talk about a lot. It's like trust your homework, right? It's like that you've done all the homework, but now don't show me the homework. If you're showing me, "I did this and I did this, and here's all the stuff from Chop that I've put together, and here's what the ingredients I'm making," whereas opposed to it's like just do the thing, right? That if you've done the work, hopefully it'll be there.
[38:07] Joel Waggoner: Right. And sometimes I doubt that I've done the work, or I doubt that I knew how to do the work, and I think that is where I come into am I an actor or not. And you feel the sheen of performance has to come on because you go, "I don't know if I trust the work enough that it'll show through." But I know my tricks; I'll go back to the channel. And I know my tricks, and I know I'm an entertainer, so I know I can make people laugh, I know I can entertain, I know, and I know I can make choices. I know you can make an actor appropriate choices, I think, but deep down, I'm sort of like, "I don't think I'm doing this right. I don't think I did the homework. I didn't read the book," you know what I mean? So I'm working on that a little bit, and Frank is the most amazing person to help with that.
[38:44] Charlie Murphy: Not to diagnose you with even more diseases, but I do think that that is a specific phobia that I sometimes see in people who did not go to acting school, that they feel like there must be some secret that I don't know. When I want to be like, "No, acting is acting is acting." Like if you're doing the acting, if you're doing the work, whether you've been in class or however you figured out how to figure this thing out, it counts. But somehow people feel like it doesn't count if I don't have that degree with the titles on it. If I don't see BFA, or if I don't see I studied this four years of acting under this certain teacher, then people go, "Well, I don't know if it's real. I don't know if I can trust it in the same way," even though it's sometimes just as good work as somebody else who has that degree.
[39:20] Joel Waggoner: Yeah, or somebody who just got like a film and TV career from just being a truck driver that someone liked, you know. Or and just had a decent personality and just like had an affinity for it.
[39:33] Charlie Murphy: Yeah, it's interesting. And what's funny too is like, especially for the listeners, this message that I'm receiving from my inner self about acting, and they just don't go away unless you work at them and be kind to yourself. And this is after two Broadway’s shows that came as a surprise, right? And you know, and a show I'm literally originating a role in right now, and I still have those feelings. And so do all the other people involved. So it's a constant journey for me, I think, figuring out that balance of wanting to continue to be curious and also feel worthy, you know?
[40:19] Charlie Murphy: So true. What a cue to a break here in a second, but you promised me a full circle moment. Something happened at UNI that you were gonna then full circle, it's come back this year. Give me that tying of the bow.
[40:32] Joel Waggoner: Oh really great. So remember those musical theater speech context, those sort of twofold musical theater speech context, little pieces that I made? Well, this the second year that I wrote, they were supposed to be 10 minutes long, and you can have five people, five chairs and a table, and you have to make a backing track, so I arranged the backing track. The first year we did Fame and we won. The second year we did Ragtime, and the third year we did The Wiz. Now the second year we did Ragtime, and here I am however many years later in the room with Flaherty and Ahrens and Frank Galati, the creative team of Ragtime, in an original musical about to do an original cast album. So my mind is completely blown, and Stephen Flaherty's music is much with all of us a part of not only our DNA but like America's DNA.
So much of that musical theater canon is just unstoppable. But the other thing I was gonna say about it was this year, February, like as in last month, the Iowa High School Speech Association had me return as an Allstate critic. So I got to actually go and critique all of the musical theater categories or all of the musical theater category of the high school entries for the Allstate Festival and award the banner to a school, which is that's the full circle thing. And it was absolutely life-changing for me because not only was I able to really, after two years of not performing at all, lift these kids up, make them feel like they were amazing, because they were, and inspire them to move forward, but also brought the life back into me.
And then to stand at the very podium on the same stage, and it hasn't been that long, it's been like 20 some years, but so there are still teachers there who are the same, and the guy, the same guy runs it. But to stand on the podium and to feel the air stop, and I got a huge, massive standing ovation from these kids because they're just incredible. Iowa, I tell you, Iowa kids don't listen to Iowa politicians. Iowa kids are incredible, and Iowa theater kids are incredible, and they're brave and they are ferocious in the best way and they care. Anyway, I got to give the award to a school that did an amazing version of Come From Away. But to stand at the podium and know there I was, 37 years old, with a pierced ear and a swish in my hip, my fully gay, proud adult self who had been in two Broadway’s shows and was on his way to something else, who had just suffered a real mental health crisis because of all of this, standing there in my fullness, looking out at the audience, knowing that I was out there closeted, looking for somebody to tell me that I could do it, looking for somebody to tell me that I had a shot, and that's what it was for me. When I got the banners, I thought, "Somebody thinks I can do this, I can be a composer, or I can be a performer, I can do this."
[43:58] Joel Waggoner: So the full circle moment in that was like pretty life changing. And honestly, life doesn't give you many of those. And so I'm really, uh, I hold that one dear to my heart, close to my heart. I love it. We will take a short break and on the back end, we're gonna talk a little bit more about these many hats that Joel wears. We'll get a little bit of his career and we will play a game for sure.
[44:29] Charlie Murphy: Okay, we are back with Joel Waggoner. And we're in the middle of the break talking about some of the things that I had to shush him so that we could get into some of these for real on the episode. Um, we're gonna talk about some social media, we're gonna talk about some of the many hats that Joel wears. Um, I'd love to start off with just a little rapid fire wise, like with all these different hats, and maybe you can go through some of them. I hit some of them kind of jokingly in the intro there, but many different things that you play, you write in all kinds of different forums. So both like you're a composer, but then also I can tell you comedic writer as well. There's a lot of different things in that world, certainly as an actor.
Is this something that you put like a conscious effort into? Like, do you have to juggle keeping up all these skills of like, how's my violin? How's my piano? I haven't done that in a while. Like, how's my vocal technique teaching? Like, you've so many of those hats. How do you keep all of them in the clock?
[45:22] Joel Waggoner: The only way I keep them in the air is by having projects. I don't pick my violin up if I don't have a reason to. I don't sing if I don't have a reason to. I sing at home, I'll write songs and stuff, but projects only. I wish that I were the kind of person who just had a studio and just made stuff and threw it out, like had my own little musical bakery, but unfortunately, if I don't have anything on the schedule, then there is nothing on the schedule. Like I can't even put down, like, Joel, go grocery shopping. I'll find a way not to. But if someone's like, meet so-and-so at the grocery store for a special meeting, I'll go to the grocery store. So that's something I've been learning to figure out.
So this show right now, I haven't picked my violin up in a while. So I'm gonna have to really, really practice while I'm here. But it ultimately comes back, you know what I mean? It's not, it doesn't go so far away that I have to like relearn, but um, I do definitely need to brush it up while I'm in the process of something new.
[46:24] Charlie Murphy: And it usually the rehearsal process helps clear out some of that, the cobwebs. What about like just as an artist, as you look at kind of seasons of your life, are you consciously planning out this feels like it's gonna be a moment of writing and music directing, or this feels like it's gonna be more of an actor moment for me? Or is it all just whatever the universe gives you? If no one tells you to meet you at the grocery store, it's not gonna happen, or is there some conscientious saying for these six months I really want to manifest some of these hats that I'm wearing?
[46:51] Joel Waggoner: So right now in my life, I'm starting to explore this idea of manifesting what I want. Up until now, it has been truly research and whatever fate has thrown at me. I think I've always been a yes person for a long time, and those are the, and I would take experiences and opportunities that were given to me as signs that that's where I should go and move to. Um, I never really had a conscientious or a conscious, excuse me, effort toward any particular thing. I think that I felt a shift from music directing into performing because that was very clear that all of a sudden, uh, I was Mary Sugarman wrote me an email and was like do you even she was like do you want to audition for this and um for for a ensemble part in a school of rock and I was like uh yeah sure but like I hadn't really been trying or auditioning as an actor at all.
I w at the time was working at I think I was working at Pace University. Well I just finished three years there. But I knew I loved to perform I just didn't know how to get through or how to break through into the business at all.
[48:07] Joel Waggoner: So um, for but for most of my time I was going where the wind blows. So if someone said hey you want to write this hey you want to play piano hey you play violin for this and then after a while I was like you know what? I don't want to be called just to play violin. So then I was like you know if you're gonna have me play violin on your concert I also need a song or hey if you want me to music direct this I also need to be sing on it. Or so I started to do that kind of stuff because I didn't want to be pigeonholed too much because I definitely felt what that was. So I learned that I didn't want to be pigeonholed as a music director or a violinist or a pianist. I wanted to be pigeonholed if anything as a singer, actor, composer that kind of stuff.
Where the world will be consciously pigeonholing you not as a performer because there's fewer amazing violin slash music directors than there are amazing actors. So they're gonna go, oh let's put you in that box if they have the option yes yes because it's very rare in the theater you know it's very rare that you find a violinist that's like I'm gonna move to New York to play for cabarets for other people, you know, it's not the journey.
[49:01] Joel Waggoner: So um, but that it's been great for me to do all those things because what I love about my New York career is that I stuck around long enough for enough people to know the things that I do and just know that I'm a comedian and also know that I'm a singer and and a pianist and um a writer and a violinist, and to do all those things, and uh and I'm legitimate at them and not just toying around. Sometimes I get really annoyed by people being like, I'm a multi hyphenate because I am a coffee maker and an actor, and I also am a producer of my own um laundry. Like I just am a little bit like, okay, Queens, like, are you really? Are you really like those are all the same? And I don't care if you're a little bit more than a lot of things.
This is a true multi-hyphen. I mean, you're not just bragging. This is really you have some, you could be almost uh multiple of these things as an entire career. Well, that you could just be a music director and do amazing stuff. You could just be composer, just be writer.
[49:59] Joel Waggoner: And it's weird to like just I'm I'm not a I'm a very humble person. So for me to be able to be like, yes, Charlie, you're right. I'm behind door number one is Joel version of this. And it's true, I could do all those things. I'm not happy doing all of uh doing one at a time. I think I just I need to scoot and skedaddle from each from one to the next. But um, yes, I I do I do take pride in my ability to do that I've worked hard to be. And I do always wonder, like, do do you are you almost like fearful of success in the in the way of like it's our light, not our darkness that scares us? In in sort of one of those hats.
[50:33] Charlie Murphy: Like the example I would give is like that Carolinder that you and Julia do is so effing good. Like that could be your career. Like you must have got sense that like after the season one, you're like, oh, if if I just did this all day, like I could be a professional skit writing, you know. It's like you could be the Lonely Island boys or whatever. That like there feels like there's something there that you know works, but you seem like you've consciously been like, but that's only for one season, and then I'm doing other things too. I'm not just gonna do that. Is that true?
[51:02] Joel Waggoner: Yeah, I think fear of success is a huge thing. I think also I lack the chutzpah and the the real knowledge of how to advocate for myself in a in a larger way. I think I am waiting for that perfect representation or that agent who knows what I do and loves what I do so much that they can feel things through me and I can be like, okay, not that project, this project, not that one, this one. Because it's really hard for me to be like, hey world, um, don't you love me? Otherwise, if that were the case, I would be posting way more things on Instagram of just myself. But it was easier for me to do that with Julia because she's brilliant and I respect her so much and love her so much. It's so much easier for me to put out things into the world when I'm not the only one being looked at.
[51:56] Charlie Murphy: You're lifting each other up, yeah.
[51:57] Joel Waggoner: Right. And we're trying to make something happen with that uh uh uh uh behind the scenes, but you know, that it's really hard to do unless you have a ton of money. And I think people think that we got paid to do that. We didn't. We produced that ourselves just to make a big Christmas card for everybody, and we had a blast doing it, and it's been great for both of our careers um in the long run.
[52:19] Charlie Murphy: But that's not laundry production, that's real production, you're saying.
[52:22] Joel Waggoner: Yes, exactly. Um, but I yeah, I I've thought about that a little bit too, because then I think to myself, well, I also don't want to be known as just the funny guy. You know, I still have a side of myself that's like I want to be, you know, I want to be Sarah Bareilles at the piano, I want to be, yeah, you know, I want to have that sort of reverence to my performance as well. But so I think I a part of me is a little afraid of being pigeonholed again for something, which is why I hold myself back. And I'm also a I'm also afraid of appearing arrogant, and sometimes I think I judge people who really put themselves out there too much because I I think I'm envious um of it, and so I've got a little resistance to that.
[53:02] Joel Waggoner: It's much easier if someone's like, Hello, everyone meet Joel. Isn't he great? Because then I didn't do it, they did. But if I come out and I'm like, hey, everybody, meet me, then I just like sort of want to throw up into my lap.
[53:16] Charlie Murphy: It does feel like there's a real inefficiency of those kind of people who like because you're someone who everybody knows you goes, Joel is so damn talented, he's gonna be a star where he's just amazing. Well, I don't know what to do with him, but he's gonna be a star, he's gonna be amazing. Like, there's a lot of those people who go, You're super talented, you've been discovered, people know who you are. But then whatever that next step of like, what is that what does that look like? How does that iterate to be like now he's a star on YouTube, he's a star, like we don't kind of know what that means, but you're waiting for someone to swoop swoop in and make some money off of you given your talent.
[53:50] Joel Waggoner: Well, that's really kind of you to say, actually, and it helps sort of synthesize some ideas. I it means a lot to me to hear you say that. Especially after two years of literally being alone and having a really really difficult time. I mean, the kind of time where I was a I was erased not only from the world but from myself, and I lost all joy and hope in in things, and I I lost the pleasure in doing what I thought I loved to do.
[54:16] Charlie Murphy: So not only hearing that, but also being able to hear that from a place of recovery and healing is like just really really powerful. So thanks um for saying that.
[54:26] Joel Waggoner: I'll just say that's not me saying that. That's like everybody says that. Like, like if you haven't heard that uh really heard that, it's like that is like the person who walks by and goes, he's so handsome. It's like it's not that one person thinks that, like everybody thinks that he's so talented.
[54:37] Charlie Murphy: And I am handsome too.
[54:38] Joel Waggoner: I am handsome too. Yeah, there's no doubt.
[54:39] Charlie Murphy: For those not watching a video, he's sort of like um, he's kind of a uh Dustin Hoffman mixed with uh well yeah, right now I'm giving you like a sheriff like kill bill vibe. I don't know what I'm giving you.
[54:49] Joel Waggoner: But you know, and that's really interesting. I also had a lot of grappling with to do in therapy about that because I the word talented has been used a lot around me in my life. Um and I I I'm not saying like oh way, way, whah, but it has made me um it has been a little bit difficult for me to ex to to exist without that being available to so who are you without your talents being evident all the time?
[55:23] Joel Waggoner: Yes, like am I still lovable if I just have lungs and that's it? If I am I still worthy of love and belonging and friendship and acceptance, and uh if I couldn't sing a note, if I couldn't play a thing, if I were boring, if I were not funny, if I were you know what I mean, like whatever the iguana on the rock version of myself is, just the like reptilian cellular life force, is that person worthy? And so I've actually got to have a lot of work to do around that because I feel like so many of the things I do are appreciated. But then I go, Well, am I appreciated? Would you be friends with me if I didn't do these things that you maybe you want to associate and stuff with?
[56:02] Joel Waggoner: So that's been a whole journey too. But as far as the like the thing, yeah, I have a lot of shame too. I'm like 37, like oh my god, I'm 37 and I don't have this many credits, or I haven't done this thing, or I haven't been on TV yet, except for the game show. Like I I have all these messages. I'm like, I can't be, I can't suddenly decide to be like a musical artist at 40. Like who's gonna take me seriously? I should have done that in my twenties. Like if I'm not Billy Eilish, I'm nobody. And I think that the pandemic has has hopefully freed a lot of people from those from those shackles. I'm really hoping it uh I can I can really incorporate some of the freedom into my own life because I really do want to write and perform and uh and be on stage and be myself and not worry that maybe I got here when I did, and maybe I I never thought I'd have a bald spot touring my one man show, but here we are, you know.
[56:56] Joel Waggoner: Um I I so desperately want to step into that way of thinking. Um but yeah, as far as the I I don't know, I just I guess I'm waiting for somebody honestly, I'm waiting for somebody to take charge, and I'm waiting for someone to believe in me, and I honestly unfortunately think that person is me.
[57:14] Charlie Murphy: Well, if you're out there with a fancy talent agent, get in there, give all the good inside. Um I want to talk a little bit about you mentioned comedy a couple times, and it's it's something I wrote down. We just our last week's guest was Annalie Ashford, who's also a great comedian. We were talking a little about like what made her what makes her so funny, and she kind of gave a little treatise on what she thinks comedy is. So I thought I would give you the same question, because I I think to me, you are someone who both seems like effortlessly funny in like who you are and your comedic instincts and your big choices and those things, but also like so whip smart in terms of funny as a writer and an improviser.
[57:49] Joel Waggoner: And those two things don't necessarily seem like they naturally like many people have both of those two things. So I'd love to kind of hear about how do you how did you cultivate that skill and and moving forward, how do you use sort of the fun actor self of yours and the fun writer self of yours to kind of make comedy gold?
[58:05] Joel Waggoner: Oh, that's really uh that's really thoughtful.
[58:07] Joel Waggoner: Um that's a great question.
[58:09] Joel Waggoner: Uh definitely humor started as a defense mechanism being bullied in school.
[58:14] Joel Waggoner: Like I definitely know how to make the straight guys laugh because I would just say really gross stuff um and really like gross, just like body stuff, and I would take it way further than they would, so I would get their respect.
[58:28] Joel Waggoner: So I would sort of like started in it with that kind of humor.
[58:31] Joel Waggoner: But also, I started to just my antennas were always up, my antennae were out.
[58:36] Joel Waggoner: Yeah, plurally. Always checking to see the temperature of the room and the emotions of the room. Who's feeling what, who's here, who likes me, who's looking at me, who's laughing, who's not. Because I was just hypersensitive to that. Because I think when you grow up gay, there's also like just a lot of other superpowers that you just have. You know that you're other, so you just sort of you just are on high alert. On top of that, you know, my brain works pretty fast, and I love metaphors. I love coming up with metaphors all the time. Um, and so my brain is always like an old-fashioned switchboard, like telephone, like yeah, holding a cop, please. You know, it's like the it's like one of those ladies, and she's always putting things together in my mind.
So I think that my um my wit comes from that kind of thing. Like, I'll hear a word and my brain will be like, this word rhymes with this word, and you have three seconds to make this joke in the room, or it will pass. And that's what's really fun for me in rehearsal right now, actually, because I told I lost my sense of humor last year. I really did, and I was praying for it to return. Then rehearsal, I it's a very serious show that we're doing, and I will find myself in little moments like popping in jokes that just release the tension in the room. And so it's a little bit of a performance, but it's also like I think it's really appreciated. But I will have this sort of like experience where I will there'll be a moment, someone will say something, I will have an immediate thought that's a connection that's like, this is like this thing, this is like this thing.
You have three jokes to say, you have two seconds to do it. Which one are you gonna pick? I blurt it out, the room laughs, we move on. So it's it's a little bit uh I have some some of those decisions that just come up. And sometimes I go, not worth it, not funny enough. And sometimes I'll say the joke to like two people, and it won't land. I'll be like, that was good, that was a good try. But yeah, exactly. But I do find myself all of a sudden, like getting a lot of calls. I feel sort of like a medium where I'm like, oh my god, there's so many ghosts here. Like all of a sudden I'm getting a lot of jokes that just fly out. It's just my I just it's the way I see the world a little bit. Um I love um, I just love weird connections and taking things too far, and but I I love the 17th choice down the list, not the first or second.
Um yeah, and my you know, my mom's uh my mom's a creative writer, and I think I always loved making my dad laugh, so that's something that I really enjoyed doing, and my sister is really funny too. Um, and I think it was like a little bit of shocking. I like to shock people and surprise people, but yeah, I don't know where it comes from. Sometimes I think it just is maybe it's the ADHD thing that I think I have, where we're just my brain is like just throwing stuff together and uh and I have a choice in that moment, sort of just like, here's a joke, you want one? It's like it's like I'm in a writer's room and I just go from there. Improvising I found has really been really really fun, especially with Julia.
[1:01:31] Charlie Murphy: You have a prodigious intelligence, too. I feel like that also like comes out quickly, and like in even just in the your pace and the fact that you're like, I can do the 17th joke because I've actually thought that through and I've already played out the scenario and I'm jumping right to that place. Um, is really impressive. And what you were doing in class as you were sort of testing out and feeling is this working? How am I reading this room? How's it reacting? That is acting. When you wonder about like what is what is what is that skill set of that goes in terms of you as a dramatic actor? That's what it is, right? It's listening and responding. So even though you may have used it to comedic effect as a kid, you were also training as a dramatic actor.
[1:02:05] Joel Waggoner: You're right. That's interesting, which makes me feel like I've been acting my whole life. But um it's all it is. But what am I when I become the iguana and I stop acting? And oddly, what I'm most happy, I am performing a version of myself, which is myself. So that's what I'm most happy. It's like I have created this person, and it is me. Yes, it is not a false me. Now, there is a sleepy version of me that just sits on the couch and watches Housewives and doesn't want to doesn't does not want you to FaceTime. I only want to text you. Um, there's that person, and then there's the person who's a little bit snippy and da-da-da-da. But the person that I am on stage is generous, is open, is cool hearted, is funny, is lively, and that that is a core version of myself. So I think that like I've crafted that person for sure. But not it's not false, it's just a centered version of myself.
[1:02:54] Charlie Murphy: Absolutely. So I like that I want to spend more time in that place. Yeah, absolutely. Um I got a couple more questions, but we have to make sure we get to this game show winning because that's when we're gonna play a little game show ourselves. So tell me about this crazy experience. So, have you always wanted to go on this pyramid? Has you always want to go on that show? Do you just love game shows in general? How did that happen? How did that come about for you?
[1:03:14] Joel Waggoner: A friend of mine was on it and she won. And then she uh she won a trip. She won a trip to Turks and Caicos and she invited some of her friends, and I was one of those friends. And we spent a week at a villa in Turks and Caicos with a private pool and private beach. And it was the I will never be on a vacation. No, that's when I'm on a vacation like that again, I will be paying for it with my royalties. Um, it was amazing. And she was like, You should try out for the show. And so I basically just sent in um uh I sent in an application and a tape, and then Sasha put in a good word for me for um uh with casting, and I went through a ton of uh video audition. Again, this is more than just like I'm gay, put me on pyramid.
That's not what you did. I know, you're right. You're right. I have not had it easy in my life, Charlie. Um, but I uh I I got on the phone with the I got on like a FaceTime with the casting agent, and she was like, Okay, let's play around to the game. And I'd never heard of the game, I'd never seen the game. And I played a terrible round, I didn't even know what I was doing. She was like, She was like, I can tell you're fun, but I need you to hang up, Google a bunch of episodes, learn how to play it, and then call me back in an hour. And so over the span of two months, I just played the game over and over and over again with them, over again. And because they really want to vet you, they want you to actually be good at it.
Which you were so they vet, you vet, you vet you. And then um finally, I think in like May, they were like, We're gonna book you on the show, and it the book, the show is uh, oh gosh, I don't know if it was in June, or maybe it was June. Uh, and I was in School of Rock at the time, so I had to get a day off to do it. Um, and I had been really practicing at that point, so I was ready. I was really practicing, I was ready. And um, then I went there the day of, and I had uh no idea who I was gonna be paired with, what celebrities. Um, and they just threw us all in a room and we waited, and um I I got they chose my outfit for me out of things I brought, and then all of a sudden, we're just sitting there.
I I had some makeup in here, we're just sitting there waiting. They go, Okay, Joel and Giovanni, you are first. And this was like at noon, and we got there at nine. And some of them were there until like 10, which I was like glad I didn't have to do. I was first. I was like, oh crap. So they go back and they put me, they're putting me in a mic, and I was like, well, well, wait, where are we going? And they're like, Well, we're gonna put you in micro and we're gonna do the show. And I was like, Well, who were my people? And they go, Oh, you did no one told you? And I was like, no. And they're like, you have Leslie Jones and Julie Bowen. So good. From Modern Family. And I was like, oh my God. I was like, and then they just shove you out into a freezing game show floor, right? Um, freezing, freezing, freezing, uh, because comedy is cold. Um, and uh we just got started, and it just happened so so fast. And the funny thing is, is I was calm. I was cool as a cue.
[1:06:16] Charlie Murphy: Yes, I've watched this episode now in preparation for this. I watched you. You looked like you were like meditating. I was like, is he on something? Like you're going through it like next question. Go next guy.
[1:06:27] Joel Waggoner: You would find yourself in the same situation, I think. Because what's so interesting is it is it is it is this eye of a hurricane, right? Uh-huh. You know, there's a crowd there, there's cameras on you, there's a celebrity you have not met. Yep. There is Michael Strahan. There's a gaping there's music uh your your body just sort of knows like make it happen and I was really calm I was having fun until you won and then when you won the release is like oh my gosh like you're chasing and running around but also Charlie also Charlie remember when you win you have an obligation to show the audience and everybody an exciting win yes because I've seen the show where they were like really oh so I knew that two three things happened I said the the I said the thing she said pits it went ding I go oh my god I did it and then I immediately thought perform for that gotta please them gotta give to show them how great it is so I was like do it yeah well yeah because I was also really excited but I also like show the world and so I like you know did that kind of thing and picked her up so funny it was wild it was wild and all that money's gone oh I was I assume so it went away to taxes mostly I won fifty yes I won fifty thousand dollars which turned into 25 and then after you know things it just went away but it was glorious I did not get a trip but I did get the money what we're gonna try to do now Joel is recreate some of that true excitement and then I'm gonna bring you back this is a specially made game for you we're replaying your winner's circle clues okay we're gonna re-take you back to what you how you won this $50,000 which is now gone and this is the same categories that made up your winning pyramid but I'm gonna give you terrible clues to see if I can get you there.
[1:08:14] Joel Waggoner: Oh my gosh I I think I forgot them. Okay, okay, okay, okay. Joel, are you ready to play this game? I'm gonna give you, of course, you know that how it works. I'm gonna give you potentially three items in a list, all of which are gonna name the pyramid that you created in your winner's circle to win $50,000. These will not be easy.
[1:08:28] Charlie Murphy: These will be very difficult clues to get you there. I was scared.
[1:08:32] Joel Waggoner: Okay, okay, okay. Are you ready to play?
[1:08:35] Charlie Murphy: Is there a timer?
[1:08:37] Joel Waggoner: Three minutes on the clock, maybe.
[1:08:39] Charlie Murphy: Three minutes. We love three minutes.
[1:08:41] Joel Waggoner: Thank you, three. Sixties are tough with this.
[1:08:43] Charlie Murphy: All right. Are we ready?
[1:08:44] Joel Waggoner: Here we go. Okay, listeners. This is me talking to you from the future. These are going to be incredibly hard questions, even if you know the categories. So we thought we'd let you know what the categories are that Joel got right in 2018 when he won the hundred thousand dollar pyramid. These are the six categories that you're gonna guess as you play along. They are what a cockroach might say, things you sharpen, types of greetings, things that tell time, things that have pits, and islands.
[1:09:17] Charlie Murphy: So those are the six categories I'm gonna describe to Joel so that you can play along, see if you can with that information um get some of these answers right yourself. Enjoy.
[1:09:26] Joel Waggoner: The first category cook.
[1:09:30] Charlie Murphy: Uh kitchen.
[1:09:33] Joel Waggoner: Um, uh, things you uh things that are cook, things that are hot.
[1:09:41] Charlie Murphy: Kitchen.
[1:09:43] Joel Waggoner: Tends you stand in. Things you move in. I can't remember what she said.
[1:09:48] Charlie Murphy: Ah temptation.
[1:09:49] Joel Waggoner: Things you feel, things you uh things you buy wedding gifts for.
[1:09:55] Charlie Murphy: Sharp, sharp sharp objects.
[1:09:57] Joel Waggoner: This is so bad.
[1:09:58] Charlie Murphy: Okay, that was islands.
[1:09:59] Joel Waggoner: We were going for islands.
[1:10:04] Charlie Murphy: Islands. Season 13 of Survivor. It's fine. This is very difficult.
[1:10:06] Joel Waggoner: Uh huh. I'm gonna really make this up.
[1:10:08] Charlie Murphy: Okay, you ready? You're right. Category number two.
[1:10:10] Joel Waggoner: Oh gosh.
[1:10:11] Charlie Murphy: Temptation island.
[1:10:12] Joel Waggoner: I hate you for that.
[1:10:13] Charlie Murphy: You're going.
[1:10:14] Joel Waggoner: And orchestra.
[1:10:17] Charlie Murphy: Things that have strings.
[1:10:19] Joel Waggoner: Sarlac.
[1:10:21] Charlie Murphy: Sarlac? What's Sarlac?
[1:10:22] Joel Waggoner: Things you eat.
[1:10:24] Charlie Murphy: Brad and Angelina.
[1:10:27] Joel Waggoner: Things that break. Things that break up. Things that have too many children. Things that are confused. Things with too much plastic surgery.
[1:10:33] Joel Waggoner: Sarla. Large groups of people. Things with big families. And Angelina.
[1:10:36] Charlie Murphy: Uh things with lots of people.
[1:10:42] Joel Waggoner: The answer was things that have pits.
[1:10:44] Charlie Murphy: Oh, things that have pits. Orchestras, of course.
[1:10:47] Joel Waggoner: Well, I you went out of order. That's not the order of the street.
[1:10:48] Charlie Murphy: Of course, I can't repeat the order for you. That's too easy.
[1:10:51] Joel Waggoner: Okay, here we go. Category three.
[1:10:53] Charlie Murphy: Now I know. Because now I would have guessed Pitts had a known Okay, good cook going.
[1:10:59] Joel Waggoner: I'm going to live forever.
[1:11:01] Charlie Murphy: Lyrics.
[1:11:02] Joel Waggoner: Fame.
[1:11:02] Charlie Murphy: Things about fame.
[1:11:03] Joel Waggoner: I hate light.
[1:11:06] Charlie Murphy: I hate light.
[1:11:07] Joel Waggoner: Dark things.
[1:11:08] Charlie Murphy: Things in the dark.
[1:11:08] Joel Waggoner: So tread on me, bro.
[1:11:10] Charlie Murphy: Tread on me, bro.
[1:11:12] Joel Waggoner: Things said by men.
[1:11:14] Charlie Murphy: I mean male workers.
[1:11:16] Joel Waggoner: Forever.
[1:11:18] Charlie Murphy: Um I hate the light.
[1:11:19] Joel Waggoner: Why do I just think I hate the why am I thinking of fame? Like, don't tread on me.
[1:11:25] Charlie Murphy: Things things men say.
[1:11:27] Joel Waggoner: Things boys.
[1:11:28] Charlie Murphy: I made this way too hard. I was sure you were going to remember all six of the categories, so that I thought this was a good thing.
[1:11:33] Joel Waggoner: I don't remember. This is what a cockroach might say.
[1:11:35] Charlie Murphy: What a cockroach might say.
[1:11:37] Joel Waggoner: Oh, a cockroach would say, Don't tread on me, bro.
[1:11:40] Charlie Murphy: I mean, I don't know.
[1:11:40] Joel Waggoner: Don't step on me.
[1:11:43] Charlie Murphy: That's good. No, this is actually funny. I forgot about cockroach. But the second you say it, I remember it. We might go over six now. But now you know how bad I would. Here we go.
[1:11:51] Joel Waggoner: Okay. Number four.
[1:11:52] Charlie Murphy: I think you can believe this.
[1:11:53] Joel Waggoner: Okay.
[1:11:54] Charlie Murphy: Rings.
[1:11:57] Joel Waggoner: Things that are round and circle yet.
[1:11:59] Charlie Murphy: Annoyed managers.
[1:12:01] Joel Waggoner: Things that are pointy and wrinkles.
[1:12:05] Charlie Murphy: Oh, things, uh, things that uh managers on a tree.
[1:12:13] Joel Waggoner: Things that are old. Things that tell age. Things that are agey.
[1:12:17] Charlie Murphy: I'll give it the other thing.
[1:12:18] Joel Waggoner: Things that tell time.
[1:12:19] Charlie Murphy: Things that tell time was that clue.
[1:12:20] Joel Waggoner: Oh, you're right. Things that are age. What was the manager?
[1:12:23] Charlie Murphy: Annoyed managers. These actually are excellent clues, and they're they're also terrible.
[1:12:29] Joel Waggoner: Well, if you knew what you remembered your damn categories, I'd do better.
[1:12:31] Charlie Murphy: Okay, you've two left. Here we go, Joe. It's been four years. I watched it this afternoon, so for me, it's not that hard.
[1:12:37] Joel Waggoner: Okay, here we go. You have two left. I believe you can get one exactly. We've gotten one now, but that was uh I gave you a little bit. I think I can too.
[1:12:43] Charlie Murphy: Okay. Your mind.
[1:12:46] Joel Waggoner: Things you sharpen.
[1:12:47] Charlie Murphy: Oh my god, you were ready to go.
[1:12:48] Joel Waggoner: I was, because I that was one I do remember. Give me other clues. Give me the other clues.
[1:12:53] Charlie Murphy: Your mind, your vision, and up.
[1:12:58] Joel Waggoner: Sharpen up.
[1:12:58] Charlie Murphy: Yeah.
[1:12:59] Joel Waggoner: Oh. Okay, one left.
[1:13:01] Charlie Murphy: One left to go 50-50 and get some money at least.
[1:13:05] Joel Waggoner: Seasons.
[1:13:08] Charlie Murphy: Things that change. Take me to your leader.
[1:13:20] Joel Waggoner: Things.
[1:13:21] Charlie Murphy: Oh, interesting.
[1:13:22] Joel Waggoner: Seasons.
[1:13:24] Charlie Murphy: Things you experienced.
[1:13:25] Joel Waggoner: Take me to your leader.
[1:13:27] Charlie Murphy: Waza.
[1:13:29] Joel Waggoner: That's what an alien says.
[1:13:31] Charlie Murphy: Um, things that uh, oh shoot.
[1:13:34] Joel Waggoner: Seasons.
[1:13:35] Charlie Murphy: Things that um four season.
[1:13:37] Joel Waggoner: Things that um the the way so like um was uh what is that?
[1:13:41] Charlie Murphy: Things that someone says, things that someone says, wait, um things that the person says, um, no, it's not.
[1:13:47] Joel Waggoner: It's the things that a think thing says, it's things that a think thing says types of greetings.
[1:13:51] Charlie Murphy: It was types of greetings.
[1:13:53] Joel Waggoner: Oh, it was the first seasons.
[1:13:58] Charlie Murphy: Oh, of course.
[1:13:59] Joel Waggoner: Actually, these are you did a really good job.
[1:14:02] Charlie Murphy: Here's the thing.
[1:14:03] Joel Waggoner: You did a really good job.
[1:14:04] Charlie Murphy: And like an afternoon of coming up with some terrible but excellent clues.
[1:14:08] Joel Waggoner: Thank you, Joel.
[1:14:09] Charlie Murphy: I was really proud of them, and I I really thought this was gonna go well.
[1:14:12] Joel Waggoner: I just was sure it was imprinted on your mind.
[1:14:14] Charlie Murphy: Because if it were me, I would have watched myself on TV so many times that I'd have it memorized.
[1:14:19] Joel Waggoner: I did two years ago.
[1:14:21] Charlie Murphy: But no, here's the thing.
[1:14:22] Joel Waggoner: The second you say the category, I go, of course, I remember that.
[1:14:26] Charlie Murphy: Come on, Brad and Angelina, things that have pits.
[1:14:28] Joel Waggoner: I thought that was so good.
[1:14:29] Charlie Murphy: Well, I was waiting for pits to be last.
[1:14:30] Joel Waggoner: I thought you were gonna do an order, but now it makes sense you didn't do an order.
[1:14:33] Charlie Murphy: So well, anyway, I was very good at the game at one point, and I could probably do it again, you know.
[1:14:38] Joel Waggoner: Uh, but go watch, it's on Hulu now if you want.
[1:14:40] Charlie Murphy: Anyone who has Hulu, season three, episode one, you'll watch Joel just be fantastic on the show.
[1:14:47] Joel Waggoner: Um you tease me with social media, and that's really becoming a theme.
[1:14:51] Charlie Murphy: I'm asking more and more of our guests because I'm just fascinated by it in 2022 as I kind of dipped my toes into it ten years after the rest of the world began their relationship with it.
[1:14:59] Joel Waggoner: What is your current relationship with it?
[1:15:01] Charlie Murphy: You know, obviously you've produced content for it, you know, uh, with the Carolindor, and I know you are someone who's on it.
[1:15:06] Joel Waggoner: How do you use it kind of in your personal and professional life?
[1:15:09] Charlie Murphy: So um the uh it's tricky.
[1:15:14] Joel Waggoner: I was using it a lot um back in two thousand seventeen when I was in school of rock, uh, when I first got that show.
[1:15:21] Charlie Murphy: I also created an extra account where I was making these a cappella videos I made called Joel Capella's, and I was creating that content.
[1:15:27] Joel Waggoner: But then what happened was I started finding that people were like expecting more and more and then it was less fun because I was like oh shoot I have to produce it and I have to think about it.
[1:15:34] Charlie Murphy: So I just sort of flopped off.
[1:15:35] Joel Waggoner: I just sort of stopped doing that.
[1:15:37] Charlie Murphy: And then when Julia and I wanted to do something for Christmas we were actually just gonna film it in our in her living room and then at the last minute she was like, well I have a friend with a really fancy studio we could go there and I was like Julia we haven't really created anything.
[1:15:51] Joel Waggoner: We'd be improvising and she's like yeah that'd be fun.
[1:15:53] Charlie Murphy: I was like improvising with like professional equipment like what if it but she knew what she was doing.
[1:15:57] Joel Waggoner: So we got there and and that's why it looked so good.
[1:16:01] Charlie Murphy: Beyond Carolindor, which is sort of like a general like almost TV series for free for anybody who wants it for every day of December.
[1:16:09] Joel Waggoner: I've been finding advent Caralendar on Instagram.
[1:16:12] Charlie Murphy: Yes.
[1:16:12] Joel Waggoner: I've been finding my involvement in Instagram has significantly decreased since the beginning of the pandemic.
[1:16:18] Charlie Murphy: Um mostly because I find it a little bit of a of a tricky place to be.
[1:16:21] Joel Waggoner: I feel like it leaves you susceptible to um to negativity um with whatever you're contributing.
[1:16:28] Charlie Murphy: It g it leaves you susceptible to negativity coming at you from other s um sources.
[1:16:34] Joel Waggoner: I I've tried to curate mine so it's a lot of like self help and quotes and and things that bring me joy and and you know it's a real difficult space um for actors because it's it's a very competitive place where everybody puts their their good goings on.
[1:16:49] Charlie Murphy: Here's me in a movie premiere here's a sli here's a photo dump of me in movie premiere or here's here's my first day of the city.
[1:16:57] Joel Waggoner: So excited for my first day of school national tour of blank or and these are all things we should be celebrating for each other, but it's really not a good healthy place for someone who's either not working or struggling to work.
[1:17:07] Charlie Murphy: And um and it doesn't feel like responsible of me to put that stuff out there because I know how people would feel seeing that.
[1:17:14] Joel Waggoner: So I've drawn way back.
[1:17:16] Charlie Murphy: Like I haven't posted on my I post something on my main feed like maybe like I think like once every five months.
[1:17:21] Joel Waggoner: But I'm on there watching stories and stuff, and listen, I know that the way to get famous quick is to just put all your money into TikTok and Instagram and just like put stuff out there.
[1:17:33] Charlie Murphy: If you if you're good, people will watch it eventually.
[1:17:36] Joel Waggoner: It's just not the kind of career I want.
[1:17:37] Charlie Murphy: And I I know that that is probably maybe foolish in some ways, but also uh for other people, but I don't want to be a content house.
[1:17:46] Joel Waggoner: I like to make something and then share it.
[1:17:49] Charlie Murphy: I don't want to make little things every single day or money multiple things every time of a day.
[1:17:54] Joel Waggoner: Um and I want to be off my phone more and more because the more I get into it, the more I see and find ways to believe that everyone is doing better than me.
[1:18:03] Charlie Murphy: And it's just uh not a good thing for me.
[1:18:06] Joel Waggoner: In fact, I'm actually hearing younger people pulling away from it too, like early 20s, like saying, I grew up with this and I'm just like not into it.
[1:18:13] Charlie Murphy: I so I I'm really curious to see what happens.
[1:18:16] Joel Waggoner: Yeah, I'm hearing I'm yeah, they've they've been able to see like, yeah, it's not all it's cracked up to be um except to listen to podcasts.
[1:18:23] Charlie Murphy: Do continue listening to podcasts, young people.
[1:18:25] Joel Waggoner: Come on.
[1:18:25] Charlie Murphy: Oh, well, podcasts are very different.
[1:18:26] Joel Waggoner: Podcast is not social media to me.
[1:18:28] Charlie Murphy: For sure.
[1:18:29] Joel Waggoner: I totally think podcasts is music.
[1:18:31] Charlie Murphy: Yeah, it's on the phone.
[1:18:32] Joel Waggoner: Phone is different.
[1:18:32] Charlie Murphy: Do it while you look out.
[1:18:34] Joel Waggoner: When you listen to a podcast, you're learning and you're deepening your knowledge of yourself and of the world around you.
[1:18:38] Charlie Murphy: When you are on Instagram, you are you are engaging in uh just a a compare and despair game.
[1:18:46] Joel Waggoner: Unless you curate your content to be podcast like in your in your sort of like education of self, you know, which I'm trying to do.
[1:18:53] Charlie Murphy: Alright, my actual last question for you, Joel, and then I will let you go.
[1:18:57] Joel Waggoner: It's just if you could give a piece of advice to young Joel, he's coming up today in the into the industry, what would it be?
[1:19:05] Charlie Murphy: Oh that's really hard.
[1:19:10] Joel Waggoner: That's what you'd say to young Joel.
[1:19:14] Charlie Murphy: Um, oh gosh.
[1:19:16] Joel Waggoner: What I would say to young Joel is um I would say it is okay, not only okay, but imperative that you feel things deeply and allow people to see you feeling them, and that you trust people um, even if your heart breaks that you trust again and again, because if you keep uh you you have to be seen.
[1:19:49] Charlie Murphy: You cannot keep performing Dance Monkey Dance.
[1:19:54] Joel Waggoner: Like I think it's so important that you find people that you can you can feel helpless around, helpless and hopeless around, because that's what I discovered in this pandemic.
[1:20:08] Charlie Murphy: I was leaning on my friends in a way that I had never in my life, and they saved me.
[1:20:12] Joel Waggoner: And if I could tell myself earlier, it's okay, you're safe, you're loved, you're accepted, go ahead and relax.
[1:20:18] Charlie Murphy: Just relax.
[1:20:19] Joel Waggoner: Be it dare to be unremarkable, dare to be beige, just exist and be loved for who you are, and don't feel like you need to impress anybody and practice that.
[1:20:33] Charlie Murphy: Don't just say it to yourself.
[1:20:34] Joel Waggoner: Practice it.
[1:20:35] Charlie Murphy: Step into un step into discomfort, step into awkwardness, step into the kindness and compassion, all the Brene Brown stuff.
[1:20:41] Joel Waggoner: But just um create self-love from that place and not from the place of your skills are what validates you.
[1:20:52] Charlie Murphy: I think that's one piece of advice.
[1:20:54] Joel Waggoner: And then also just like to really care for your mental health and not to and not have shame in caring for your mental health.
[1:20:59] Charlie Murphy: Because um perfect pitch for subsection B on our next podcast.
[1:21:05] Joel Waggoner: Um for now, you can check out Joel.
[1:21:07] Charlie Murphy: He posts once every five months at Joel Waggoner.
[1:21:09] Joel Waggoner: Um I would follow at Advent Carolinder.
[1:21:12] Charlie Murphy: It's a fantastic follow.
[1:21:13] Joel Waggoner: We'll see if he keeps and continues to do that.
[1:21:15] Charlie Murphy: But even if you just go back and watch the old ones, it's amazing.
[1:21:17] Joel Waggoner: And at Joel Capella.
[1:21:18] Charlie Murphy: Joel, thank you so much for your time today.
[1:21:20] Joel Waggoner: It was such a pleasure getting to chat with you.
[1:21:22] Charlie Murphy: You are an extraordinary person.
[1:21:24] Joel Waggoner: You always have been, and thank you for holding space for me today and reaching out to me.
[1:21:29] Charlie Murphy: And it's really good to see your face.
[1:21:30] Joel Waggoner: I'm so happy for you, and I hope that you're feeling like just as good as we all, you know, know you to well, I I hope you're feeling the love because you're definitely getting it.
[1:21:45] Charlie Murphy: I love you, man.
[1:21:46] Joel Waggoner: That's really I love you.
[1:21:48] Charlie Murphy: Alright.
[1:21:54] Joel Waggoner: Oh man, I hope you enjoyed hearing Joel as much as I enjoyed talking to him.
[1:22:00] Charlie Murphy: Uh he's always so amazing to chat with.
[1:22:02] Joel Waggoner: He's such a combination of warmth and wisdom, of humor, and intelligence and vulnerability and depth.
[1:22:07] Charlie Murphy: And Megan is making fun of me for all these adjectives, but it's how I feel.
[1:22:10] Joel Waggoner: Megan, how I feel.
[1:22:12] Charlie Murphy: Um, we did a pretty long deep dive into a few different things here.
[1:22:16] Joel Waggoner: Um, so I really just want to pick up and and kind of examine a little gem that Joel dropped, which we didn't touch on much, which is that idea of being your own advocate in the business.
[1:22:27] Charlie Murphy: I actually did touch a bit on this in one of our uh college episodes and kind of in how it relates to getting into college, specifically auditions, like having that quiet confidence to believe it can be you, what it is to walk into a room and say, yes, me, as opposed to saying, I don't know, if maybe if you want to, right?
[1:22:43] Joel Waggoner: But this is kind of that same gem, all grown up as we talk about it in the business, as you know, sort of people are pursuing a career.
[1:22:51] Charlie Murphy: Joel was joking about how he's kind of waiting for someone to tell him he's an actor, or in a different context, he was saying, I'm I'm kind of waiting for someone to see all the extraordinary things that he can do and decide what to do with them or how to sell them, right?
[1:23:04] Joel Waggoner: And you heard him quietly say, if you caught it in the episode, he says, but I know it actually has to be me.
[1:23:09] Charlie Murphy: He like kind of whispered it under his breath.
[1:23:11] Joel Waggoner: And I just want to co-sign that little angel on Joel's shoulder.
[1:23:15] Charlie Murphy: Yes, it does have to be you, because it is so true in most cases, right?
[1:23:20] Joel Waggoner: There are always are those exception cases where there's like this incredible talent manager or agent who sees you in some back end of a bar and goes, You're such an extraordinary talent doing that karaoke.
[1:23:31] Charlie Murphy: I'm gonna turn you into a whatever, right?
[1:23:33] Joel Waggoner: That's like how it happens in the movies.
[1:23:34] Charlie Murphy: And of course, could it happen in real life?
[1:23:36] Joel Waggoner: Yes, it could, right?
[1:23:38] Charlie Murphy: But most people are not getting that kind of step-by-step, let me help and sell you, and you just get to be the artist's path to success.
[1:23:47] Joel Waggoner: Much more often, what people will say is that after they're super successful, after they're already well known and people are breaking down their door to help them come up with these brilliant ideas on how to sell themselves or how to brand themselves or to take their career to the next level.
[1:24:01] Charlie Murphy: And people are always like, Well, where was this when I couldn't get a damn audition?
[1:24:04] Joel Waggoner: Yeah, these are great ideas.
[1:24:05] Charlie Murphy: I wish someone was helping me do this when I couldn't get in for that role, or I couldn't even, you know, be seen by that casting director.
[1:24:10] Joel Waggoner: But first, most actors have to go through that process of deep self-discovery in terms of what they bring to the world.
[1:24:18] Charlie Murphy: What is that unique thing that I'm offering that nobody else, or maybe few others are.
[1:24:22] Joel Waggoner: What can I do better than anyone else?
[1:24:24] Charlie Murphy: What do I know about deeply and truly that I can put out into the world?
[1:24:28] Joel Waggoner: And then once you've done that artistic introspection, which Joel clearly has done and has a real firm grasp on his own unique and incredible artistry, there's often that next step of what is being that true advocate for yourself.
[1:24:41] Charlie Murphy: That's what Joel was sort of saying he's waiting on, right?
[1:24:43] Joel Waggoner: You may have heard the idea that actors have to be the CEO of their own company, which is true.
[1:24:48] Charlie Murphy: And for those who are business heads, the CEO is responsible for all that artistic vision or all the kind of strategy of what the company's gonna do.
[1:24:55] Joel Waggoner: But also sometimes, especially in 2022, an actor might have to be the CMO and the COOs and all the other O's that a company might need, right?
[1:25:05] Charlie Murphy: There might be that element of self-production, as we saw Joel do beautifully with his Carolinder, you know, before that thing gets picked up by Apple TV Plus or whoever ends up doing it.
[1:25:13] Joel Waggoner: I'm telling you it's gonna happen.
[1:25:14] Charlie Murphy: But until that happens, you might have to do some self-producing.
[1:25:18] Joel Waggoner: Or that element of kind of marketing that is kind of the pounding the pavement equivalent and maybe makes us feel a little gross as actors.
[1:25:26] Charlie Murphy: I think a lot of actors feel really uncomfortable with self-promotion.
[1:25:30] Joel Waggoner: And that's not to say that we all have to be incredible networkers or whatever, that gross image we get of people who kind of use other people around them to climb the ladder in a blatant, obvious way.
[1:25:40] Charlie Murphy: But I do love that Joel said he was both grossed out and jealous of that skill and the kind of shamelessness that takes.
[1:25:48] Joel Waggoner: And I think a lot of people, especially a lot of artists, feel that way, myself included, I'll include myself in that category.
[1:25:54] Charlie Murphy: So we might have to find that deep part of ourselves that says, yeah, I'm saying it's me.
[1:26:00] Joel Waggoner: I'm the show you should produce out of the thousand other great shows.
[1:26:04] Charlie Murphy: I'm that actor that you really have to meet, that you should cast over these hundred of other amazing actors.
[1:26:09] Joel Waggoner: I'm the director who's right to help me your next show.
[1:26:11] Charlie Murphy: There's a real vulnerability to that.
[1:26:13] Joel Waggoner: And I think we don't always see it as vulnerability.
[1:26:16] Charlie Murphy: I think we sometimes think of that as a cockiness or oh God, that person just loves to put themselves out there.
[1:26:24] Joel Waggoner: But it is, it is a vulnerability.
[1:26:25] Charlie Murphy: And often that I think it is fear that holds us back from doing that.
[1:26:29] Joel Waggoner: But if we can make that scary leap, I think we have that much more chance to actually, you know, make whatever that dream is come true that we have.
[1:26:37] Charlie Murphy: Which of course leads me to my scary leap of saying, I am the podcast that you should listen to first thing in the morning.
[1:26:43] Joel Waggoner: Give it a download, you know.
[1:26:44] Charlie Murphy: Uh, and if you want to be sure not to miss any episodes, we'll give us a little tap on that subscribe button.
[1:26:48] Joel Waggoner: You can rate and review us with five stars if you think I make the games too hard, and an ironic five stars if you think I should make them harder.
[1:26:57] Charlie Murphy: You can also reach out to us with questions for the pod at mailbag at mappingthecollegeedition.com, or reach out to me and Megan directly and give us a follow.
[1:27:04] Joel Waggoner: I'm at Charmers 7, very close to a big round number on those Instagram followers.
[1:27:08] Charlie Murphy: So give me like six more followers.
[1:27:10] Joel Waggoner: We can do it.
[1:27:10] Charlie Murphy: Or you also could follow at Megan Marie2014.
[1:27:13] Joel Waggoner: If you're interested in working with MTCA for help with your individual prep for your college edition journey, please check us out at mtcollege editions.com.
[1:27:20] Charlie Murphy: You can also check check us out at Musical Theatre College Editions at Tweet MTCA.
[1:27:24] Joel Waggoner: We're also on YouTube, we're on TikTok, the whole darn thing.
[1:27:28] Charlie Murphy: To my young artists out there mapping their journeys.
[1:27:31] Joel Waggoner: Any path to a successful college degree can work, whether it's a BFA, a BA, a BM, or a participation trophy.
[1:27:39] Charlie Murphy: We'll see you next week.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
