Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Midwestern State University with Dr. Grace Edgar

In this College Deep Dive, Dr. Grace Edgar from Midwestern State University chats with MTCA Director Charlie Murphy about: Non-audition BFA program. Small individualized program. What am I looking for now and where do I want to be in five years?.. Read More

From the show: Mapping The College Audition: An MTCA Podcast

58 mins
12/18/24

About

In this College Deep Dive, Dr. Grace Edgar from Midwestern State University chats with MTCA Director Charlie Murphy about:

  • Non-audition BFA program
  • Small individualized program
  • What am I looking for now and where do I want to be in five years?
  • Tailoring their interest to production aspects of theater

If you have any questions about the college audition process, feel free to reach out at mailbag@mappingthecollegeaudition.com. If you’re interested in working with MTCA for help with your individualized preparation for your College Audition journey, please check us out at mtcollegeauditions.com, or on Instagram or Facebook.

Follow Us!

Instagram: @mappingthecollegeaudition

YouTube: @MTCA (Musical Theater College Auditions)

TikTok: @mtcollegeauditions

Charlie Murphy:@charmur7

About MTCA:

Musical Theater College Auditions (MTCA) is the leader in coaching acting and musical theater students through the college audition process and beyond with superlative results. MTCA has assembled a roster of expert artist-educators who can guide students artistically, organizationally, strategically, and psychologically through the competitive college audition process. MTCA provides the tools, resources, and expertise along with a vast and strong support system. They train the unique individual, empowering the artist to bring their true, authentic self to their work. MTCA believes that by helping students reveal their potential it allows each school to connect with those who are truly right for their programs, which in turn guides each student toward their best college fit.

About Charlie Murphy:

Charlie is a proud graduate of Carnegie Mellon University’s BFA program. As an Actor he has performed with theaters such as: NY Public Theatre’s “Shakespeare in the Park”, The Pearl Theatre Company, Hudson Valley Shakespeare Festival, Chautauqua Theatre Company, Kinetic Theatre Company, and the Shakespeare Theatre of DC.

With MTCA [Musical Theater College Auditions -- mtca.nyc], he has been helping prospective theatre students through the college process for over 15 years. As a Teacher and Director, he is able to do a few of his favorite things in life: help students to find their authentic selves as artists, and then help them find their best fit for their collegiate journey. Through this podcast, he hopes to continue that work as well as help demystify this intricate process.

This episode was produced by Meghan Cordier and Kelly Prendergast. Episode theme music is created by Will Reynolds with Additional Vocals from Elizabeth Stanley.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:09] Charlie Murphy: Hello, hello, and welcome to Mapping the College Audition.

[0:12] Charlie Murphy: I am your host, Charlie Murphy, Director of MTCA.

[0:14] Charlie Murphy: That's Musical Theater College Auditions.

[0:17] Charlie Murphy: Check us out at MTCA.com.

[0:19] Charlie Murphy: And today we've got Dr. Grace Edgar from Midwestern State University in Texas on the show.

[0:26] Charlie Murphy: For our newer listeners, it's another one of our college deep dive episodes where we explore the landscape of the college theater world and try to demystify this daunting audition process.

[0:35] Charlie Murphy: And I'll give that same caveat that I've given before any of these programs that are not necessarily on everyone's radar in a sort of standard audition-based BFA path, which is that this episode may not be for you.

[0:46] Charlie Murphy: It will not be for everybody.

[0:48] Charlie Murphy: If your focus is only on the most competitive program that you can get into, or if you just can't see yourself going to school in the middle of Texas, then this might be one where I say, thank you for your download.

[0:57] Charlie Murphy: Don't forget to like and subscribe us and give us a rating review and all those beautiful things.

[1:01] Charlie Murphy: But for some of our listeners, I think this will be really a gem.

[1:05] Charlie Murphy: Not only is Dr. Grace, I think, a really engaging interviewee, I think the program she's describing is really specific and right for a certain kind of student in a way that not a lot of programs out there are.

[1:14] Charlie Murphy: And as we say, so much of this process is about finding your fit as you explore these programs.

[1:18] Charlie Murphy: And for some students, this will be an excellent addition to their list in that very search.

[1:30] Charlie Murphy: This used to be a lot more common when we started doing this 20 years ago, but more and more of these non-audition BFAs started adding in at least some kind of audition element for admission into the BFA.

[1:40] Charlie Murphy: Um maybe they'd still offer a BA that was non-audition, but then some beared entry that involved some kind of artistic review with the BFA.

[1:46] Charlie Murphy: But this audition process might strike you actually as more similar to some BAs, like Muhlenberg describes a similar process, where the audition experience is for scholarship and to explore mutual fit with the program in a personalized way.

[1:57] Charlie Murphy: So I thought cool to have them represented on the podcast for sure.

[2:01] Charlie Murphy: As well as another rare thing, which is that this was a program I had not heard of until they reached out to be represented on the podcast.

[2:07] Charlie Murphy: I believe that brings that particular total up to three schools out there out of about a hundred that we've had on that I didn't know anything about coming in.

[2:15] Charlie Murphy: But you get to now listen to me ask questions with genuine curiosity, a sort of fully open, curious mind about how things work, unlike many cases where I'm asking questions, but I have a good idea of the answers.

[2:25] Charlie Murphy: Of course, that's not to say that I don't learn something from every episode of the show, because of course I do, but normally I go in with a bit more of an impression or information from previous student experiences and my own research.

[2:34] Charlie Murphy: Not the case here.

[2:35] Charlie Murphy: Um so I like you getting to experience that with me since you know that's what so many of these programs are to most of you.

[2:41] Charlie Murphy: You know, you might come in with a list of three or four schools that you've heard uh a lot about, and then a bunch of schools that are total mysteries to you.

[2:47] Charlie Murphy: So you're fumbling blindly in the dark, just like I was in this interview.

[2:51] Charlie Murphy: Um, in terms of time of year, this is our last episode that we're releasing before the holiday break.

[2:56] Charlie Murphy: Um, we've got you covered with episodes going through the holiday break.

[3:00] Charlie Murphy: God, pat on the back to us.

[3:01] Charlie Murphy: Um, we're gonna do a bit of a clip show and a mailbag next week.

[3:05] Charlie Murphy: So please make sure you get your questions if you want them answered in our Christmas episode.

[3:09] Charlie Murphy: I'm gonna try to limit myself to not doing too many questions since I don't want to do a 90 minute episode like I did for Thanksgiving.

[3:15] Charlie Murphy: Boy, that was a lot of me talking.

[3:17] Charlie Murphy: Uh, but we'll see how good and tempting those questions are, because we know I tend to be for both.

[3:22] Charlie Murphy: So we'll see.

[3:23] Charlie Murphy: Um, but to get those questions in, you know, as well as any kind of feedback in general, you can always reach out to us at mailbag at mapping the college edition.com.

[3:30] Charlie Murphy: That's mailbag at mapping the college edition.com for any questions.

[3:33] Charlie Murphy: Get them in this week, like before Friday the 19th, or it may be too late for the mailbag.

[3:38] Charlie Murphy: Um, I hope you all have wonderful holiday breaks.

[3:42] Charlie Murphy: Many of our students just completed a successful private audition weekend with six schools and are riding high into their break.

[3:48] Charlie Murphy: Uh, I know all of you listeners, at least uh our MTCA students have signed up for a mock already.

[3:54] Charlie Murphy: So I don't need to tell you that there are only two spots left in the January mock.

[3:58] Charlie Murphy: But in case you are the exception to that rule, please grab one of those last two spots.

[4:02] Charlie Murphy: Please, everybody needs a mock audition experience.

[4:05] Charlie Murphy: Don't miss out.

[4:06] Charlie Murphy: Uh, and then I'll see so many of you in the new year, whether at that mock um or at our upcoming uh private auditions or upcoming in-person unified experiences in New York, Chicago, and LA.

[4:16] Charlie Murphy: I cannot believe it's that time of year again.

[4:18] Charlie Murphy: Here we go, 2025.

[4:20] Charlie Murphy: But here we are.

[4:21] Charlie Murphy: Um, until then, happy holidays, and may you all please take some time for yourself to rest and recharge and hit this prime audition season with all of your best self, Rare and to go.

[4:32] Charlie Murphy: Uh, okay, and to that end, I hope you all sit back, grab a mug of cocoa, and enjoy this episode with Dr. Grace Edgar from Midwestern State University, Texas.

[4:47] Charlie Murphy: Well, we are so excited to be joined by Dr. Grace Edgar.

[4:50] Charlie Murphy: Uh, Dr. Grace has a Bachelor of Music from Centenary College of Louisiana, a Masters of Arts in Theater from Midwestern State University, a graduate performance diploma in opera from Long East School of Music, and a PhD from the University of Houston with a minor in directing.

[5:06] Charlie Murphy: Uh, she has sang, acted, directed, and music directed all over the place, and is now the assistant professor of theater and head of musical theater at Midwestern State University MSU, which is in Wichita Falls, Texas.

[5:19] Charlie Murphy: I said Wichita weirdly there, but you'll forgive me.

[5:22] Charlie Murphy: Uh, they take classes of about seven to eight students per class, only twenty-five to thirty over the whole um school, and we'll talk about that.

[5:28] Charlie Murphy: They offer a degree at BFA in theater, a theater minor, and an MT minor.

[5:33] Charlie Murphy: Dr. Grace, welcome on the pod.

[5:35] Grace Edgar: How are you feeling today?

[5:36] Grace Edgar: I'm great. Thank you so much for having me.

[5:39] Charlie Murphy: I gave that little kind of overview bio of you.

[5:41] Charlie Murphy: Anything, you know, in terms of your journey to MSU that you want to sort of zero in on, or in terms of just what your experience was journeying to the academic world?

[5:50] Grace Edgar: Absolutely.

[5:52] Grace Edgar: So I come to the academic world after being a professional performer.

[5:57] Grace Edgar: Most of my performance experience was as an opera singer, and I have some experience as an actor as well.

[6:03] Grace Edgar: So before coming back to my doctorate, I was a resident artist with Arizona Opera.

[6:08] Grace Edgar: I performed with Opera New Jersey, Shreveport Opera, Key West Pop Symphony, Growing Stage, Traveling Lantern, Theater Company.

[6:17] Grace Edgar: And then after, when I was about 32, I thought I wanted to go back and be a college professor.

[6:25] Grace Edgar: And I always knew that I wanted to be a college professor, but I also wanted to perform in order to be an even better college professor.

[6:33] Grace Edgar: So when I was about 32, I went back to the University of Houston and studied vocal performance and directing.

[6:40] Grace Edgar: And after that, I had some kids.

[6:44] Grace Edgar: And then I got back into academia.

[6:46] Grace Edgar: And it's been wonderful.

[6:48] Grace Edgar: It's my dream job.

[6:49] Grace Edgar: I'm so excited to be doing it.

[6:52] Grace Edgar: I am continuing to learn new things.

[6:55] Grace Edgar: I am now an intimacy choreographer with a diploma from theatrical intimacy education.

[7:03] Grace Edgar: So it's great.

[7:04] Grace Edgar: It's good.

[7:04] Grace Edgar: I'm happy to be here.

[7:06] Charlie Murphy: Super cool.

[7:07] Charlie Murphy: That feels like a theme of this podcast.

[7:08] Charlie Murphy: If you want to be a professor, just have some kids.

[7:10] Charlie Murphy: Somehow having kids turns you into professor.

[7:13] Charlie Murphy: I'm dooming myself having just had a child.

[7:15] Charlie Murphy: I have to say, you know, when you're performing and you're on the road, that is so exciting.

[7:20] Grace Edgar: Yep.

[7:21] Charlie Murphy: And also when you teach and your students' performance succeed, that is deeply satisfying and gratifying in a lasting way.

[7:29] Grace Edgar: Yep.

[7:30] Charlie Murphy: I want to get into MSU a little bit.

[7:31] Charlie Murphy: So first I want to talk about sort of MSU students, but first, what attracted you to MSU?

[7:35] Charlie Murphy: What was your journey?

[7:37] Grace Edgar: Absolutely.

[7:38] Grace Edgar: I had worked at a previous institution that had a really strong and continues to have a really strong reputation in musical theater.

[7:45] Grace Edgar: And then I was looking to move to another university and got um actually several offers, several interviews, several on-campus interviews, and several offers.

[7:56] Grace Edgar: And I chose MSU for several reasons.

[7:59] Grace Edgar: One of the reasons is the BFA degree.

[8:02] Grace Edgar: So that we do have those pre-professional degrees in design tech, performance, musical theater, and we also have a teacher certificate.

[8:12] Grace Edgar: And this is important to me that we are providing a BFA in performance and musical theater, and simultaneously we are educating high school and middle school theater teachers.

[8:24] Grace Edgar: And I think to have the dichotomy of both training programs together, feels really good for me as a teacher.

[8:33] Charlie Murphy: Yep, totally makes sense.

[8:34] Charlie Murphy: And and we'll talk a little bit about the degree in the as we get into the second half.

[8:37] Charlie Murphy: We'll talk about the sort of audition and admission process.

[8:40] Charlie Murphy: Um, very cool and kind of unique or or rare to be a BFA that is non-audition for admit, so we'll we'll get into that a little bit.

[8:47] Charlie Murphy: But I'd love to talk about just the kind of student that you attract.

[8:50] Charlie Murphy: So, in the same way that you were attracted to the school, what does it tend to be?

[8:53] Charlie Murphy: What does an MSU student tend to be?

[8:56] Grace Edgar: You know, as as you can tell, that is distinguishable from other kinds of students, what sort of makes them unique or or makes them the specific MSU brand or whatever?

[9:04] Grace Edgar: That's such an excellent question.

[9:06] Grace Edgar: Um, um, a lot of our students come with open minds and open hearts, and that is what I am looking for.

[9:06] Grace Edgar: I am looking for a student who is willing to be silly, willing to take risks, willing to explore, willing to try things and uh be playful.

[9:26] Grace Edgar: So those are very important things.

[9:28] Grace Edgar: When we have a student come and audition and interview for us, the audition and the interview is important, but what happens after the audition and the interview with the student maybe taking a little bit of direction?

[9:41] Grace Edgar: Like, can you try that monologue as a period piece?

[9:45] Grace Edgar: Or can you try that monologue with singing head voice instead of belting right there?

[9:52] Grace Edgar: Or how are you?

[9:56] Grace Edgar: Oh, in their song, they'll present a song and a monologue.

[9:59] Grace Edgar: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

[10:00] Grace Edgar: But you know, maybe can you pick a different vocal registration?

[10:03] Grace Edgar: And so I think a willingness to play and explore is important.

[10:07] Grace Edgar: We also ask our performers to have a secondary area of design architecture.

[10:14] Grace Edgar: So we want to are we want our actors and our designers and our technicians to work.

[10:19] Grace Edgar: So if somebody comes in and they are the next Sutton Foster, that is great.

[10:25] Grace Edgar: We're gonna put them on stage, and we're also gonna say, would you like to learn about the lights or the sound or the costume design or the box office?

[10:32] Grace Edgar: Is there another area of theater that interests you?

[10:36] Grace Edgar: So that while you get gigs performing, if you have a period of time where you're not engaged, what else can you do in the theater to pay your rent?

[10:48] Charlie Murphy: Yep, expanding those other hyphens we talk about so much on the on the show.

[10:51] Charlie Murphy: I love that.

[10:52] Charlie Murphy: I mean, that was exactly my next question.

[10:53] Charlie Murphy: You know, it's again, it's a specific the BFA in theater is kind of an interesting dichotomy because the BFA tends to mean very specialized and professional, in exactly what you said.

[11:04] Charlie Murphy: But then it's basically what level of specialization should our students have in performance if they're looking at MSU.

[11:12] Charlie Murphy: Are they 80% performers and 20% interested in stage managing or lighting or something like that?

[11:16] Charlie Murphy: It's like, well, and you don't have to have exact numbers, but how does it feel in terms of like how specialized?

[11:22] Charlie Murphy: I obviously know I want to be in the theater if I'm getting a BFA in theater, at least that's my my interest.

[11:27] Charlie Murphy: But how specialized am I at this point if I'm looking at going, is it two or three, four options?

[11:32] Charlie Murphy: Is it just having exactly two?

[11:33] Charlie Murphy: So how do you look at your students in terms of their their broadness or their narrowness within the theater world?

[11:40] Grace Edgar: When they come in as freshmen freshmen, it's very broad.

[11:43] Grace Edgar: So usually the folks, our prospective students will come to us with one area of interest.

[11:49] Grace Edgar: That could be I want to be a musical theater performer or I want to be a costume designer.

[11:54] Grace Edgar: And then once we get the freshmen on campus, we start to ask them where their interests are.

[12:00] Grace Edgar: And so, and then when we plan out the assignments, the production assignments for the year, we try to tailor that to the student's interest.

[12:12] Grace Edgar: So if a student comes in as a freshman, we just did uh interviews with our freshmen about how their first semester went.

[12:19] Grace Edgar: And in that interview, we said, what are production aspects that you're curious about or that interest you?

[12:26] Grace Edgar: So the student can say, I'd like to learn how the soundboard works, or I'd like to run the spot, or I'd like to work in the costume shop and get a work study there.

[12:36] Grace Edgar: And so that's how we'll start.

[12:39] Grace Edgar: We will say, like, okay, for the third show of the season, let's have you be our light board op.

[12:45] Grace Edgar: And for the six or eight weeks that we're in production for that show, you're gonna work with a faculty member to learn about the board, and then you'll run the board during the show.

[12:55] Grace Edgar: And at the end of that semester, we'll say, How did you like running the board?

[12:59] Grace Edgar: Would you like to continue to learn more about that area of design or would you like to explore something else?

[13:06] Grace Edgar: So generally by the junior year, the students have an idea about their interest and their strengths, and we can really start to give them bigger opportunities.

[13:17] Grace Edgar: For example, we did Mr. Burns as our first play with music at the beginning of the year.

[13:24] Grace Edgar: And the actor that played Mr. Burns and sang in that is gonna be my lighting designer for Godspell.

[13:31] Grace Edgar: So it's that actor who is, you know, getting role after role after role with us that also wants to explore lighting design.

[13:40] Grace Edgar: And so we've created opportunities for this actor to do both of those things to be a star in the musical and then to lighting design later in the season.

[13:49] Charlie Murphy: It's so cool.

[13:50] Charlie Murphy: And we've talked a lot on the pod about sort of the advantages and disadvantages of the size of a program, right?

[13:55] Charlie Murphy: But you're really speaking to some of the advantages of being a small program.

[13:58] Charlie Murphy: Some bigger programs could not possibly have that level of specific detail per student per four years.

[14:03] Charlie Murphy: It just wouldn't be possible if you have, you know, 200 students over the course of your um your school itself.

[14:08] Charlie Murphy: So um I I love hearing about some of the wonderful flexibility and how it can be different from you know, student to student over the 30 students over the the four years.

[14:17] Charlie Murphy: Is there something in terms of if you could take us through the curriculum, what is said?

[14:20] Charlie Murphy: I know there's some rules in terms of what a BFA has to be.

[14:22] Charlie Murphy: What is said about the curriculum in terms of what is rigid and what can change uh depending on students' interests?

[14:28] Grace Edgar: Absolutely.

[14:29] Grace Edgar: Um, so all of the students are going to take a sort of introduction to stagecraft, lights, sounds that's gonna be in the curriculum.

[14:40] Grace Edgar: All of the students, regardless of what their focus is, are gonna take voice and diction, and that is learning IPA and projecting. I teach that class, so it's IPA and I do link later in that course. Um, students are gonna take what we call dramatic analysis, which is script analysis, and script analysis is gonna be the beginning of the directing track, and every student's gonna have exposure to directing. So after script analysis, they will take directing and then they will move into play production. In play production, each student who wants to direct a one act will get a fully supported and produced one act play at the end of their junior year. I also teach singing for the actor. So everyone who is a musical theater performance major is gonna get four semesters of singing for the actor with me, which is gonna be private voice lessons and also scene work.

We have an acting series that I believe is three required acting courses and additional optional acting courses. Each theater student is gonna take three theater histories with the option of also taking musical theater history. Of course, everyone takes makeup design, costume design. So it's we get a lot of the basis covered in theater, and then each BFA from there really specializes, and the students are able to personalize that track. We had a student who graduated a year ago, and during her time with us, she directed two shows on mainstage, did beautiful costumes for some Chekhov that I directed, and starred in many, many shows. Another thing that's unique and special about MSU is I teach the directing courses, and every year one of our four main stage productions is directed by a student, which I think is amazing. So we do one of our main stage productions each year is directed by a student. We just had a student direct the Thanksgiving play, which was very exciting for us.

[16:48] Charlie Murphy: And how many of these classes? I'm just imagining with the smaller class, um, uh the freshman sophomore class sizes, how many of these classes that are performance-based are open to the broader university? So am I taking with non-majors? Am I taking with minors? How does that work in terms of um the different classes? Which ones are are or not open to the broader university?

[17:06] Grace Edgar: That's an excellent question. So a lot, I would all of the classes that are lecture classes and classroom classes are open to any student at MSU. Also, all productions are open to any student at MSU. Once we get into the higher level performance classes, including all of the singing for the actor courses, that is going to require instructor permission. So we have a, for example, we have a course at MSU taught by theater faculty called Acting for Non-Majors. Yeah. And we have another course called Acting One. So usually anyone can take acting for non-majors. A theater major can absolutely take all the acting courses, but a non-theater major would need to ask permission to be in that class.

[17:58] Charlie Murphy: Totally makes sense. Yeah. And I guess I'm wondering, you know, of the 30, uh, we sort of talking about like per making everything math-based, percentages of non-performing interests and how that would work and how broad, and it's maybe a difficult question, but I guess maybe uh let me flip that around. How many of them are interested in performing? Are all of them at least somewhat interested in performing, or the majority of them? Are some people coming and saying, I'm really mostly interested in lighting design, but I'll try my hand at performing.

[18:26] Grace Edgar: That is such a great question. Most of our design tech students try performing at some point, um, and a lot of them do it multiple times, but there are some students that don't. Students that are on scholarship are required to audition for shows unless they are a design tech person that is not comfortable with that. So they would get an assignment and not be required to be in a main stage production. Our tech design students are required to take voice and diction, and also we try to make that really accessible for them.

[19:07] Charlie Murphy: Yep. Well, and we talk about sometimes with uh I tell this the parents who goes, Well, what are the chances my child is gonna be an actor professionally? I'm like, there are some great transferable skills in those classes too. I'm sure from the design tech world, even just having an understanding of the performance element, and it's not a world that I've gone deep into the design tech world, but I can't imagine a voice and diction class wouldn't be helpful in terms of like your life skills and some of those things moving forward.

[19:28] Grace Edgar: Yeah, and also when a parent comes to me and says that I like to talk about our teacher certificate. Yes. So I would say my undergraduate degree is in sacred music, and I was able to use that degree to work in churches, in schools, teaching kids how to play piano and sing. And I feel like because I was able to support myself through the journey doing my craft. Yep, it informed my performances, made me a better teacher. It really enabled me to have theater and music be my entire world. So I think it's actually very smart to get that teacher certificate, knowing that the students have all the opportunities to audition, direct, perform, because there's always grad school, right? So if the parents are really worried about that, sometimes I'll say this could also be an option.

[20:29] Charlie Murphy: Totally agree. Um, let's talk a little bit about just as you look at the those 22-year-olds who are who are leaving. Sort of what are you doing to prepare them for their launch into the business? And what does that look like in terms of, you know, are they getting sort of showcase material to go into uh other cities? Do many of them go to New York, Chicago, LA, do many of them stay in Texas? How does that what does the launch look like for most of your students?

[20:51] Grace Edgar: Yeah, that's a great question. We are very plugged in to the Southeastern Theater Conference. I am the chair of women in theater for SETC. Um, so we're taking students to audition at SETC. We are also using our professional connections. So a couple of summers ago, a bunch of students and I went up to Big Fork Summer Playhouse. Actually, I had had a lot of students go to Big Fork for summer stock in the past. And when I met the producers of Big Fork, I said, Hi, I'm so and so and so and so's voice teacher. And they said, Oh, come work for us. And I said, I will. And I said, and you should hear these folks sing. So there is that sort of situation where I can, I can't always guarantee a job, but I can usually get an audition.

[21:39] Charlie Murphy: Yep.

[21:39] Grace Edgar: So, you know, work in those professional contacts. A couple of summers ago, I directed at Red River Lyric Opera. And that company was very generous about using our students. And that was an opportunity for our students to do a brand new opera with the composer in residence. Yes. And I also directed at Seattle Public Theater last summer. So we're bringing our students to do auditions and we're trying to work connections to get the students' auditions. When they graduate, a lot of them moved to Dallas Fort Worth area, which is uh growing a lot. They are building some big sound stages down there for film and television, and we're excited about those possibilities. Yep. Some of them are moving to New York and Chicago and working and doing those sorts of things as well.

[22:31] Charlie Murphy: Cool. Um and I often ask that question with the in the conjunction with where your students come from. How many of your students are from the Texas area? I know we'll talk about cost in a second and some of that uh in-state tuition discount. But um, how many of them come from Texas versus how many come from the broader country and the world?

[22:47] Grace Edgar: Almost all of them come from Texas. Yep. So almost all of them come from, I would say about a six hour radius around us. Yes, which is only a part of Texas, unbelievably. For those of who don't live in Texas, six hour ready is like that's three states, right? Nope, not for Texas.

[23:02] Charlie Murphy: Um let's talk a little bit about costs. So we very affordable, we found, and even without the in-state tuition, right? What I the quick crack research team says around 10K, that's with the in-state and about 12K out of state for does that sound right?

[23:15] Grace Edgar: Those numbers sound right to you?

[23:17] Grace Edgar: Correct, yes. Let's talk about how those work. I don't know. In on the second half, we'll talk about the scholarship audition, but let's just talk about scholarships in general. Um, how many of your students, let's say it sounds like most are in state, so they're paying the 10K. How many of them are paying the full 10K versus what are my scholarship options from an academic or a uh a talent-based or need-based, et cetera?

[23:37] Grace Edgar: Absolutely. We have a lot of scholarships. So we have the theater scholarship that I mentioned before. That scholarship is up to $1,500 per semester. Freshmen usually start a little bit under that, and we like to raise the scholarship every year and max you out in the senior year. We also have choir scholarships. So some of our theater majors also want to sing in the choir and they'll get a music scholarship, or they can play in the orchestra or the band and get a scholarship that way. We have academic scholarships, we have first generation scholarships. That's a big push for us. Yep. Um, so there are lots of other we have personal donors who have a scholarship in their name that we're nominating students for all the time. So very few, if any, of our students pay full tuition.

[24:30] Charlie Murphy: Yep. And it's worth not to keep just doing nothing but math on this podcast, but worth just helping anyone because sometimes people hear $1,500 per semester. It doesn't sound so much when you're talking about some of these other schools, but you're talking about that would be $3,000 per year off of 10,000. So that's 30% of your tuition right there. It was just in that one scholarship.

[24:46] Grace Edgar: Yes. And we're usually the cream on the top. Like students come to us usually loaded with scholarships anyway. And we are just able to seal the deal and sweeten the pot at the end, usually. It's also a very affordable place to live. It's an ex Wichita Falls is extremely affordable. Um, and most of our students live on campus all four years if they're with us, which is really nice.

[25:10] Charlie Murphy: Really cool. Yeah, and so let's talk about that. That we'll wrap this section with just talk to me about the university itself outside of the theater program, both in terms of what does a campus look like, but then also stuff like academic opportunities, you know, how how do students take advantage of specific academic opportunities? But then you also mentioned that like choir, other, you know, sort of things that the college does. So tell me about the broader university.

[25:30] Grace Edgar: Absolutely. Um, MSU was voted the most beautiful campus in Texas, so we're very, very proud of that. We've got this very beautiful brick that is around our campus. We are about a big city block, so it's very walkable. Which tall falls is very much a university town, which is really nice. Everybody here is really plugged into MSU and has a lot of school spirit, and we get a lot of support from the community. We also have two community theaters in town, so it's very much like a Texas theater town, which is great. We have students who go, we collaborate with the community theaters. One is very family focused. I'm out also music directing for them right now. They're doing the sound of music. So we have a couple of students who are gonna go out and do that show, and then we have another uh theater in town that students can work with as well, and we're all uh very supportive of each other.

Other opportunities on campus, one of the things that I am involved in is student research, because I also research and write. We have a Eureka project where there is scholarship money and budgets provided for students to do research, and that is in every discipline. And sometimes we collaborate with other disciplines. So that's really exciting. We collaborate a lot with other departments. We did a collaboration with art in the spring. We did the musical Now Hear This, and we collaborated with the art department and they made some video projections for us. And we used a live caption suit in the present moment in the musical. So we saw the actor in the suit and saw what the art students had projected up on the scene on the screen simultaneously. So a lot of opportunity for collaboration across campus as well.

[27:35] Charlie Murphy: And what about what about sort of in the non-theater world? I mean, are are we going to sports on Friday nights or are there frats? I mean, what's what's sort of the college experience, you know, sort of if I want to go? I want to rest my theater self for a day or two. What does that look like at MSU compared to other schools?

[27:50] Grace Edgar: Absolutely. We have football, which is a big deal, sports are a big deal, soccer, basketball, all the things, and we have the fraternities and all of that. We also have a very active chapter of APO, Alpha Psi Omega. So a lot of it's it's delightful to me that when we're not in rehearsal for a main stage production, it seems like APO is putting on their own show. The APO produced She Kills Monsters, and then last year they did a 24 hour play festival. So this is completely student produced. But again, outside of the theater things.

[28:26] Charlie Murphy: Yeah.

[28:26] Grace Edgar: Things that you can do. Um, yes, like going to the art shows, we do a lot of that. Our students just collaborated with the nursing department on a nursing disaster scenario. We do this every year.

[28:45] Charlie Murphy: Yeah. Fun.

[28:46] Grace Edgar: Yeah. And that we haven't really talked much about that in terms of academically. Um, both we can talk about specific opportunities, but just even talking a little bit about the schedule, you know, within the BFA. How many of your students are able to get external minors, meaning kind of non-theater minors and or double majors? Like, how does that work in terms of if I was interested in, let's say, acting and lighting design, it sounds like for the BFA theater, but also interested in psychology or something like that.

[29:11] Grace Edgar: How would that work in terms of my schedule and what's possible for me? Well, it's completely possible. It's just a matter of how long you want to be on campus. So, you know, double majoring is absolutely a possibility. It is probably gonna take you five years. So I think it's just about going in. And then when we have the BFA in musical theater, that degree is very specific and concentrated to prepare our students to be performers. So that BFA is gonna be more demanding than like a bachelor's of arts. Yep. So to come and get a BFA and then maybe get a BA in psychology or something else, I think it's just a matter of being honest about the time commitment and being willing to stay the extra year.

[29:57] Charlie Murphy: Totally makes sense. All right. Well, let's take a short break and on the back end, we're gonna chat a little bit about the audition and admission process. So we're back in a flash.

[30:04] Charlie Murphy: All right. All right, we are back with Dr. Grace, and we're gonna chat a little bit about the audition and admission process. And you know, so I already kind of mentioned it seems like an interesting, uh, not unique as in um singular, but but certainly a rare BFA where you're admitted first from the university and then the audition is more about scholarship. Can you talk to me about what are the criterion for first that academically? So, what are we being looked at in terms of whether I'm gonna get in from the university level and then what that audition looks like?

[30:35] Grace Edgar: Yeah, so we want to see a 3.0 if possible for students in our program in the theater program specifically. The uh grade point average that MSU is going to look at for general admits is gonna be like a 2.5 or a little bit lower. We just it's a big time commitment to do shows with us on top of your coursework. So we like to see freshmen coming in having a 3.0 or higher because we believe they'll be successful at that point.

[31:06] Charlie Murphy: Totally makes sense. And do you know, like, do you interact with any part of that academic application? Are you seeing the grades and the essays or anything else that they have to do from an academic perspective?

[31:15] Grace Edgar: I'm not. I'm when they come to audition for scholarship, that is one of our questions. We have a point system when we give scholarships. One of the questions is what is your GPA? And that has a corresponding point value. And another question is uh, where what is your class standing? Like, are you in the top 25% of your class? And that is another point value. And that is again just about wanting the students to be successful when they're here at MSU.

[31:47] Charlie Murphy: Yep. Um, all right. So and I want to talk about those auditions themselves. Um, first off, how how do those happen? So they're mostly happening on campus, people are showing up on campus for an audition. Do we have anything virtual? How does that work in terms of um how I would come to get that scholarship audition?

[32:01] Grace Edgar: It can be on campus or virtual. We like it to be on campus. We like for our student to come to campus and spend a day or half of a day with us. So ideally you would sit in on a couple of classes and get to meet two different professors and then go to lunch with the student without a faculty member. So you feel like you can really get the scoop and ask anything you want to ask. Yep. And then we'll do a campus tour, which goes through admissions. We'll do a tour of the theater building, and then usually we do the audition in the afternoon. The audition requirements for musical theater are going to be a song or a cut of a song. We ask for 60 to 90 seconds and a 60 to 90 second monologue for someone majoring in performance.

That's not um musical theater performance. We ask for two contrasting monologues between 60 and 90 seconds. After the student performs the material, we have a conversation where we just say, What are you interested in? What questions do you have? We might give some feedback on the audition if they ask for that. Yep. And then if we can, we like the student to stay for a performance or a rehearsal.

[33:22] Charlie Murphy: Sounds like an awesome day. Um, I you may mentioned some of those uh top-of-the-sheet scores we're getting from the academics. I'd love to talk through sort of as you're walking watching the artistic audition. What are the other things that you're kind of sniffing for? And how do I get a good score on myself? You know, artistic. So what are you looking for that would get a five or a ten or whatever the goal that you're using?

[33:43] Grace Edgar: Good. I'm so excited to talk about this. So uh as a voice teacher and music director, the first thing that I'm looking for in the song is that the student can sing a legato line in tune. So that's what I need to know. I need to know that in the middle of your voice, you can sing a musical phrase smoothly in tune, uh, and that the voice is healthy. Because I can do anything. If we start there, I can teach you how to belt, I can teach you how to mix belt, I can teach you how to do the high notes. I need to know the instrument is healthy. So that's like that's a major thing. The other thing that we want to see in the acting, both in the song and in the monologue, is we want to see big choices. There's no such thing as a wrong choice or a bad choice.

We want to see a committed choice. It's nice when we can see contrast. So if the song is in a minor key and has a lot of angst or conflict, it's nice to see a comedic monologue so that we can kind of see the range of what a student can do. We like to see all of the things, facial expression, gesture, blocking when that's appropriate for the audition. You know, that you feel comfortable in your own skin on stage. And again, if we give a note, sometimes in an audition, we might ask for something that seems ironic just to see if the student can take direction. So a willingness to make a bold choice and try something new is very attractive for an actor.

[35:27] Charlie Murphy: Yes. Totally makes sense. And how would you specifically play with the voice? So I totally understand the idea of the adjustment of hey, you've tried you've tried these two, everything's working. I'm gonna give you a wacky adjustment. Let's see how this goes. What what would that look like if let's say a student student is not demonstrating they can sing a legato line in tune? What would you do vocalizing them to sort of investigate their voice?

[35:48] Grace Edgar: I would probably say, can we go in my studio and can I vocalize you? Uh-huh. So then, like, and then when we're in the studio, I could give very specific instructions. Like, let's try that on a closed ooh vowel, knowing that ooh brings in a lot of head voice. So if I um need more information, going to the piano with the student and doing some simple vocal exercises and giving some simple coaching can answer that question for me about because sometimes it's like, oh, it's just tongue tension and I can fix that. Uh-huh. Right. Or it's, or it could be like, oh my gosh, that sounds like it could be vocal notes, and then a conversation about like, do you sleep with a humidifier? You know, like, do you have a cough?

You know, things like that. So we could start to, once they're on campus, I'm invested. If any student comes to campus and auditions for us, I will give you a 20, 30 minute voice lesson. Because I want you to come here because you want to work with us and you want what we have to offer. So I, at the point the student is showing up on campus, or even at the point that the student is emailing me, I feel like my job is to help them find the right place.

[37:07] Charlie Murphy: Yep. I love it. We often use that kind of dating analogy on the show that it should be dating in both both people. You're you're deciding who to take, but they're also saying, does this feel right for me? Um I'd love to talk about sort of you mentioned the conversation you have. So if there's sort of the adjustment portion where you may throw things at them in the conversation, you know, what are you investigating in terms of the kind of questions you would ask a student and then what you might be looking for in terms of their responses?

[37:30] Grace Edgar: Yeah. So the first thing I'm looking for is to make sure that they can phonate on every pitch throughout their range, so that I actually know that the vocal cords and the larynx are performing properly and healthy. And that is the case 99% of the time. Even if there is something like lip tension, tongue tension, you know, the voice is nasal, all of those things we can absolutely fix as long as the voice is healthy. So a simple exercise like, can you do a siren? Can you go? That tells me that the voice is healthy. So it could be. But a lot of times I come um from a silly, a place of silly. Let's be silly. Like we're not singing, we're just making noise. And then later on we can turn that into something.

Like, let's say I have a student who comes in and they're belting, and the belt is amazing. And they're belting, you know, um, maybe this time, right? So it's it's really low. And then we get into the studio, and I'm like, I'd like to hear your head voice. And the student says, uh, I don't sing in my head voice, I'm an alto, I'm a belter. And I say, okay, can you whimper like a puppy dog? Can we not singing? Let's just see, let's just play around and make some noise. Can you do this with me? Can you mimic me? Can we do this together? And then if we can, can we turn that into? You know, like what's the next building block? Where can we go next? Baby steps in a playful way.

[39:16] Charlie Murphy: Yep, totally makes sense. I let's talk a little bit about the other side of that conversation. So, in terms of like your pitch to students, imagining we're gonna have a decent number of listeners, especially ones in the Texas area, but even some maybe who aren't who are gonna say, This program sounds interesting. I'm I want to check this out, but I'm also looking at a bunch of other programs too, you know, as a program, which I I admit it to you in the break, I was saying that's not a program that I knew well at all, you know, it was not on my radar, and I think that's gonna be true for a lot of families. Do you have like a pitch of like how you are choosing to distinguish yourself? Like, do you have a like, hey, we're sort of like this program, but we're cheaper, you know, or or or we're like nothing you've never seen before because of the way we put it together.

Like, how do you, you know, if a student is going, if they were to ask you audaciously, why should I choose MSU over three or four other options? What sort of feels like your pitch of going, here's why, here's why I'm I'm getting students to sign on the dialine.

[40:08] Grace Edgar: Absolutely. Um, a couple of super important things. We are big on creating a culture of consent, so we want everyone in the room to feel like they have a voice and their voice is valid, and that's something that's very important to me. That means we're using intimacy choreographers and fight choreographers and cultural consultants, we're talking about lived experience. Yes, all of those things. The second thing I would say is opportunity to have a student who can, and this is a student that we had last year who was in our student-directed play at the beginning of the semester as one of the leads, then was my costume designer for the checkoff, the second production, then directed the third production.

I don't know of another program that offers that kind of opportunity. And that was particularly interesting for that was a reason I wanted to work here. Is we are small enough that once you are in our community, you are gonna get big opportunities to do all the things that you want to do as long as you are on time and you show up and you're nice, right?

[41:21] Charlie Murphy: Yep, I love that. That's that's a great pitch. It's really, and I do agree. I think this that is not a specific what you just outlined is not a specific pitch. We've heard on 190 episodes of this podcast. We haven't heard that exact uh pitch yet. Um, I'd let's talk a little bit about sort of if you have any kind of goals for growth in terms of the program itself. You know, obviously you're you're coming on a podcast like this where you're gonna have thousands of listeners and maybe more uh people um potentially auditioning and and looking at admittance to your program. You know, do you have ways in which you're hoping to grow or or not? I mean, some you know, some pro some newer programs will come on the pod and say, give me 10 years, I'm gonna be Juilliard.

I'm gonna be Michigan, you know, it'll feel that kind of energy. Whether they say that exactly, it kind of could feel like that's the goal. Is is the goal to go, hey, I really want us to be a known name on the Broadway stages. Is it, hey, I want us to keep growing organically in this way? Like, do you have a sense of sort of what you want the program to be 10 years from now?

[42:17] Grace Edgar: I do. So the BFA and musical theater at MSU is new. It is in its third year, and this degree created my position. So I'm in a new position coming in to teach musical theater at MSU. My goals are not about increasing the size of our student population or having more majors. It is absolutely about increasing the quality of their experience and their marketability as performers. Some of the things that we've done since I got here last spring, we did the Pirates of Penzance with full orchestra. So that's a big deal for us. So we had singers unmiced singing with full orchestra, and I was very, very proud of that. Um we are about to do Godspell with the rock band. So very proud of that. So my growth ideas are about providing better instruction, more support, and more opportunities for our students so that they do get out there on Broadway.

I am fortunate that I have a couple of students from my previous institution. I have one in Back to the Future right now. So I've had several students graduate and go on and be very successful working as performers. MSU needed a voice teacher in the theater department. So as we continue to specialize in musical theater and grow that program, I anticipate that our quality will get stronger as our students learn more and get stronger in their craft.

[43:54] Charlie Murphy: Yep. Very well said. All right, all right. Well, let's wrap with. I know we already given a little bit of parental advice, and we talked about sort of transferable skills, but I love to talk to our parent listeners. You know, a good chunk of our listeners are parents who listen sort of for their children as they're investigating. Have you been in this program? And um, what sort of uh advice would you give to parents who are trying to guide their children through this process? You know, I've now noticed I started off sort of giving that advice of like if they're juniors and seniors going through the process. We now have parent listeners who if the kids are in eighth grade or whatever, you know. So just looking at guiding a student who is um interested in theater, interested in pursuing theater. Um, what advice would you have to that parent?

[44:30] Grace Edgar: Yeah, I think I'll start with a story from this morning. So, you know, we have good boundaries about like the students can text me on my cell phone when we're in production and they're my own. Those are good boundaries? Those sound like no boundaries. We have some boundaries. So this, but genuinely we communicate over email and things like that. This morning I gave a theater history three final at 8 a.m., which is tough because we had callbacks for Godsville last night. Cruel, it's cruel, not tough, it's cruel, it's mean. Well, I know I didn't make the schedule, right? So at 820, I noticed one of my students wasn't here, and I thought, okay, I've never called the student before, but I'm gonna call her.

And so that's the kind of attention our students get that if your student is supposed to be taking their theater history exam at eight o'clock on a Monday morning and they're not there at 820, the professor will call them on their cell phone. And I think that's what I want parents to know is that we are small enough that we see our students nearly every day. If something is up with them, we know it immediately and we care about them and we reach out and we say, Hey, what's going on? We are also friends as colleagues. So I just texted this morning with my friend who's in the music department, the voice teacher in the music department, with myself being the voice teacher in the theater department.

I was like, your kids were awesome, and callbacks last night. And she said, Oh, I haven't seen this one in a couple of weeks. And so, you know, it's just like checking in and checking up and supporting. And MSU does a good job of helping young people transition from high school and living with their parents through four years of college and into the real world in a way that can be a stepping stone where faculty and staff are gonna be plugged in and aware of what's going on with the students.

[46:32] Charlie Murphy: Yep, so well said. Um, if people want to check out more information on MSU, um, where's the best place? Do you like social media? Right to the website. Should they be reaching out to you directly on your cell phone at 8 a.m.? What's sort of the what's the way that you want people to be checking out more stuff on MSU?

[46:46] Grace Edgar: Yeah, I am happy to answer emails. So my email is grace.edgar at MSU Texas.edu. I get lots of emails from prospective students, and I really enjoy helping them get acquainted with our programs and begin the application process. And I walk with them all the way through the audition and even after the audition, talking about hey, I know you're coming in as a freshman. We have auditions for the fall shows on the second day of classes. So just making sure we're small enough that we really can keep tabs on everyone.

[47:22] Charlie Murphy: I love it. Um, well, Dr. Grace, thanks so much for the time today. It was such a pleasure.

[47:26] Grace Edgar: Thank you.

[47:31] Charlie Murphy: Yes, yes, yes. Okay, I hope you enjoyed that chat with Dr. Grace. Uh, it really is amazing how good all of these professors are, no? I mean, from the most competitive schools across the board, you just tend to have amazing quality of educators. You know, I always talk about that when we're talking about differentiating between programs, that you're gonna find very different student bodies, all kinds of different factors, but you'll tend to find great teachers almost everywhere. Um, but let's get into these takeaways and some of those ways that you do distinguish between schools, because that's what the point of this podcast is. Uh, one of those factors I just want to make sure we hit, we talked about in the episode, but just the size of a program.

We've talked about it in many kinds of different contexts, but here we're really talking about as small a program as can exist and be a program. You know, we've talked about the difference between the size of school, meaning the larger university and the size of the program. But here is an example of that real extreme edge in a very small class and real individualized attention. You know, as I record this, I just had NYU Tisch back on the show today to talk about their unique beast of a program that's going to come out in January for all of you. And to me, a program like this is just like the opposite side of the coin from an NYU. You know, where you could potentially have some fear, and we talked about some fear in the NYU episode of being lost among 400 other freshmen spread out over seven other studios, and how that may be difficult to navigate your individual path.

Here you have an example of school where your professor is gonna call you because you're late for an exam, since they're intimately following your education journey and they were at that same audition with you last night, right? You know, that's really not to say that one is necessarily better than the other, but worth an honest conversation with yourself about what your needs are. Are you ready for that big city feel, both in terms of environment and a toughness that you might need to navigate a competitive landscape among a lot of different peers? Or would a bit more attention and space away from the excitement of the business actually be helpful for you? And of course, there are lots of different schools in between on the scatter plot of program size and school size and all the kinds of campuses that you can attend.

There's a lot of schools between an MSU Texas and an NYU. You know, I think for a lot of students, this actually would feel too small in all of those areas. But for some, it would feel just right. I feel like this is the baby bear in the Goldilocks analogy. Is that right? Was baby bear the one that was too small for some? I'm not looking that one up, but uh the second one, whatever the second one is. Um, but this is just, you know, it's an extreme level of personalization and care that you can get in a way that is just not realistic at some of these bigger programs that we've had on the pod.

[49:53] Charlie Murphy: Okay, and that leads me right into this conversation about competitiveness, which I think is worth having in an honest as way as possible. While it's of course difficult to do so when I'm speaking in the abstract to a group of strangers coming at this from many different places, and I think at times we in this business like to avoid this conversation I'm about to have just because it can be a bit icky. We're gonna try to do it in as non-icky way as possible. Um, you know, you've heard us say many times that this process should not necessarily be solely focused on having the most competitive school that will have you, right? In the same way that dating should not necessarily be focused on finding the most attractive partner that will have you.

You know, again, we use that word attractive in multiple ways. But I'm gonna be honest, this is how a lot of students do approach the process, and where that plenty of people do approach the dating process. And there's a gravitational pull that tends to happen in both of these analogies toward that. Right? I will say it is rare that we find a student gets into a bunch of the most statistically competitive programs and then chooses to attend a much, much less competitive program. And every time I say that, of course, the counterexamples pop up, whether because they choose to attend a more academic, non-audition program, like maybe they do a non-audition BA. You know, we've had students get into Michigan and then Harvard and choose to go to Harvard, but I wouldn't really call that a counterexample here because Harvard, of course, is very competitive in other ways, though non-audition, right?

And certainly not at all uncommon. Make sure we hear this. It's not at all uncommon for our students to not go to the very most competitive school that they get to on their list. This happens all the time, where the fit you know they tend to find at one school fits them better than another school. Even if that first school is significantly less competitive that they get into, they could totally end up going to the less competitive school. But in those cases, it tends not to be orders of magnitude less competitive. You know, you've maybe heard this before. We tend to group schools into the three categories of most competitive, competitive, and emerging. And even in those three categories, there could be multiple different mini categories within it, right?

It's not like there's a perfect three way of breaking them down. And where it would not be unlikely at all that a student would choose a competitive school, that second category, over a most competitive school, especially if those two are pretty close to each other on the spectrum. It is rare that we'd have a student choose an emerging school that's really not very well known over one of the most competitive schools that are out there. You know, and that's a frank conversation that I think is potentially helpful to have here, which is just some version of the difference between these schools and the schools that and the students that attend schools like this will not be insignificant, right?

I think that's where it can be confusing to people and where we'll be tempted to lead with some version of kindness and obfuscation is the idea that of course it is absolutely possible for someone to attend any of these programs and go on to have an incredibly successful career, or of course vice versa, to attend the most competitive school out there and to not have particular success. Nothing is guaranteed in this business, and in this career is not one where one plus one equals two. However, it is worth just noting that there will be a significant and qualitative difference in the experience of these schools when you're talking about the most competitive schools and the real emerging schools, right? And potentially the opportunities that can follow, at least on a statistical basis, the likelihood of those opportunities.

[52:50] Charlie Murphy: I haven't done a sports analogy in a while, so I think we're due for one. I think this is where that conversation of growth and where you are in that growth is helpful. You know, if you are capable of playing basketball at a D1 basketball school, your chance of playing the NBA goes up significantly. And very few D1 athletes would choose to play at a D3 school. Again, not none, but for the most part, that wouldn't be sort of a blanket advice that we would give. And of course, you do see late bloomers come from D3 schools and go on to have fabulous careers, but they're more the exception than the rule. But part of the reason I use this analogy is that for those students, for the students who are attending the D3 schools, the experience of attending a D3 was actually the perfect path for them in their development.

They were able to star in their roles at this school in a way that they may have been riding the bench and never playing if they tried to push themselves or force themselves to be a walk-on at a D1 school and they were just barely successful getting on the team, but then never got to play at all, right? You'll see this with quarterbacks and football sometimes. You know, they might choose to play at the highest level where they can actually be a starter as opposed to being a third string at a most competitive school. And now I do think personally that's where the analogy falls apart a bit, since I don't think artistically I would ever make that as a conscious strategic choice to go to a less competitive school only to get more playing time on the field and therefore more kind of scouting attention.

Of course, acting in sports are not identical here. But I do think what holds in this idea is that you want to be playing opposite folks who are at a comparable level that you are. Maybe I'll bring in my partner Leo's favorite sport of tennis, right? Tennis is always most fun when you're playing with someone who's at your same level. Or in my dream world, someone who's slightly better than me, since it keeps pushing me to get better. But it's not fun to like mop the floor with someone again and again again on the tennis court or to get trounced yourself. Nobody has fun, nobody gets better. In the same way, though it's not identical, if you dropped a greener acting student into a Yale MFA classroom, it wouldn't be good for the class or for the student, right?

It would not be the best thing. Not that nobody could learn, of course they could, but it wouldn't necessarily be the best thing. And if you drop Meryl Streep into an acting one class at an emerging program, the same would likely be true. You know, it might be interesting for her classmates, and I don't know, maybe Meryl will just find a way to get a ton out of it. But in general, it wouldn't be the most helpful thing for her. Um, but that's the other end of the conversation I often have about you're not trying to fool yourself into the most competitive school, you're trying to find your fit. I'm often talking about that in a version of authenticity to lead with authentic authenticity, you will do better.

But the other side of that is if you did successfully fool yourself into a program that actually wasn't the right fit for where you are in a competitive world, it wouldn't be a happy thing for you or the program. And as we talked about many times, this is where acting, it just isn't as numerical as academic pursuits, and it's not as definable or numerical as sports, but it also doesn't mean that it's random either. Having those frank discussions with yourselves and with trusted educators around you about where you think your abilities are right now can be a really helpful exercise to help determine what your college list might end up looking like and what your goals for growth are. The process itself, when you look at a broad list, will do a version of that for you.

So if you come in with a really broad list, it will kind of do a little bit of that assessment for you. But if you come in with an informed head on your shoulders, it might help you determine whether a school like MSU Texas will be on your list or not.

[56:06] Charlie Murphy: Because here's where I would push a little bit back on what Dr. Gray said. Uh, and I know she may have been speaking a little bit just in hyperbole here, but she said, uh, you know, we can train the next Sutton Foster, or we can train and listed a number of these other things. But I would say if you really are the next Sutton Foster now, I'm not sure MSU Texas is the right place for you. In the same way that if you're the next LeBron James now, you wouldn't necessarily be looking at D3 schools when you already have NBA offers, right? Sutton couldn't even make it one year at Carnegie Mellon before the allure of the business drew her away. For those who don't know, Sutton Foster went to Carnegie Mellon for one year and then left and then ended up getting some, I think, uh degrees afterwards, some some honorary degrees afterwards from other plays.

You know, and the way that, you know, phenom athletes often play one year at school back in the day, Kobe and LeBron, they didn't play any years of school, they just went pro, right? That's not to say that someone who graduates from MSU, Texas might not ultimately have a more successful career than Sutton Foster. We all know, of course, that they can, and we can think of examples like that have happened, but it is not the statistical likelihood. And based on a frank assessment of where she was now in the process for Sutton Foster, MSU Texas might not be the perfect fit. And those are hard conversations, but I think important ones to have with yourself. You know, what am I looking for right now and where I want to be in the next four years?

Because that's what college is. You know, it can be a foundation, it can be a launching point, it's a very important part of your process, but it doesn't necessarily determine all that you can be in this life. It is really about where are you from 18 to 22.

[57:34] Charlie Murphy: Okay, that'll do it for another episode of Mapping the College Audition, produced by Meghan Cordier and Kelly Prennergrass. Please like and subscribe wherever you listen to podcasts. Give us a rating review as a nice little holiday bonus for your favorite podcast host, and check us out on all the socials media. And as always, head over to mtca.com for information on how we can help you with your own college prep journey. Two of my young artists out there mapping their journeys. Some of my basketball teammates still call me Big Tex because of my supposed resemblance to the giant statue with the same name. You can Google it. Do you think I should find this offensive? We'll catch you next week for our special holiday episode.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred