In this Artist Episode Paul Kwak, Laryngologist Chats with MTCA Director Charlie Murphy about. His musical journey to becoming a laryngologist. The importance of vocal technique. How to stay vocally healthy throughout the year... Read More
From the show: Mapping The College Audition: An MTCA Podcast
About
In this Artist Episode Paul Kwak, Laryngologist Chats with MTCA Director Charlie Murphy about
-
His musical journey to becoming a laryngologist
-
The importance of vocal technique
-
How to stay vocally healthy throughout the year
If you have any questions about the college audition process, feel free to reach out at mailbag@mappingthecollegeaudition.com. If you’re interested in working with MTCA for help with your individualized preparation for your College Audition journey, please check us out at mtca.com, or on Instagram or Facebook.
Follow Us!
Instagram: @mappingthecollegeaudition
YouTube: @MTCA (Musical Theater College Auditions)
TikTok: @mtcollegeauditions
Charlie Murphy:@charmur7
About MTCA:
Musical Theater College Auditions (MTCA) is the leader in coaching acting and musical theater students through the college audition process and beyond with superlative results. MTCA has assembled a roster of expert artist-educators who can guide students artistically, organizationally, strategically, and psychologically through the competitive college audition process. MTCA provides the tools, resources, and expertise along with a vast and strong support system. They train the unique individual, empowering the artist to bring their true, authentic self to their work. MTCA believes that by helping students reveal their potential it allows each school to connect with those who are truly right for their programs, which in turn guides each student toward their best college fit.
About Charlie Murphy:
Charlie is a proud graduate of Carnegie Mellon University’s BFA program. As an Actor he has performed with theaters such as: NY Public Theatre’s “Shakespeare in the Park”, The Pearl Theatre Company, Hudson Valley Shakespeare Festival, Chautauqua Theatre Company, Kinetic Theatre Company, and the Shakespeare Theatre of DC.
With MTCA [Musical Theater College Auditions -- mtca.com], he has been helping prospective theatre students through the college process for over 15 years. As a Teacher and Director, he is able to do a few of his favorite things in life: help students to find their authentic selves as artists, and then help them find their best fit for their collegiate journey. Through this podcast, he hopes to continue that work as well as help demystify this intricate process.
This episode was produced by Kelly Prendergast and Socials by Jordan Rice. Episode theme music is created by Will Reynolds with Additional Vocals from Elizabeth Stanley
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:10] Charlie Murphy: Hello, hello, and welcome to Mapping The College Audition. I'm your host, Charlie Murphy, Director of MTCA. That's Musical Theater College Auditions. Check us out at MTCA.com. And today we've got Paul Kwok, Dr. Paul Kwok, that is, on the podcast. For our newer listeners, these artist exploration episodes aim to explore the path to success that artists have forged and are still forging and tease out how their theatrical training has helped them to blaze that trail. This is a really fun one for me. Paul is a Harvard educated doctor and a Juilliard trained musician. Not the most common combination. We're gonna chat about his unique career journey and then we get into a bit of vocal health stuff.
We talk a bit about vocal use, we destigmatize vocal injury, and I can't help myself with a few sports analogies. Um, and this is gonna wrap up our couple episodes that are more health related as we kind of cheer on our seniors who are currently in the middle of their unified auditions. Um, I'm recording this before I jump on a plane to Chicago and then LA. But as you listen, you might be partway through Chicago Unified, or maybe you're about to head out to LA yourself. I hope to see many of you in those green rooms. And any pod fans who want to jump on for your two minutes of fame, don't be shy. We'll get those green room interviews going strong. Uh, I'm sending you all so much love and good vibes as you finish your audition seasons.
Remember, we're here at MTCA for you throughout the whole process. So, you know, as you're synthesizing those Unified, we're there with webinars and also all your school choice related discussions as you begin to narrow it down. We're here for all of it. Um, for our juniors, that's our class of 2027. Please do also make sure you are signed up for our junior intensive. That's February 14th and 15th in New York City and 21st and 22nd of February online. It's really a great way to kind of take your process to the next level for those who've been with us for a bit. So if you did junior kickoff in the fall and then junior college experience in the early winter, um, and it's also a totally fine entry point for those who are just getting started and want to kick things at a year.
It's a great way. Um, we really do try to build our events throughout the year with your timeline in mind and at least an ideal timeline of where you might want to be. So we're trying to have you a good place in February to prepare you for those spring master classes and then our summer masterclass week in the summer, mock auditions that are gonna happen in the fall or winter, and then eventually your actual auditions where all of our seniors are right now. So if you think about in that year journey at least of events, and of course, coaching's a part of this process for you as well. We could get you from here to uh where you want to be a year from now. That's a big part of what we try to do.
Students, at least senior students. If you're listening to this as we release, I want you to get off your phone and go do some walk-ins for our parent listeners. You know, I've already prescribed for you. You at the Palmer House, you have to do a massage. If you're in LA, go find a good massage place. I don't know if they do it at the Western or not, but we remember that that parent massage that is a form of competitiveness for you and your children, for you to be that much more relaxed. That is doctor prescribed. So I hope you're enjoying that massage. Uh, and speaking of doctors, I hope you enjoy this conversation with the wonderful Dr. Paul Kwok.
[3:24] Charlie Murphy: Well, we are so excited to be joined by Dr. Paul Kwok. Uh, Paul is a fascinating multi-hyphenate, uh, our first musician physician. Uh, we've had a lot of different multi-hyphenates, but I think this is our first of that particular combination on the pod. Uh, he has an A.B. from Harvard, where he graduated Magna cum laude. He spent a year abroad at Oxford, where he got a master's degree, an MM from Juilliard in collaborative piano, where he studied vocal accompanying and opera coaching, and then an MD from Case Western Reserve. And I won't read all the medical degrees that happened beyond with residencies and fellowships, but they're all very impressive. He's currently a laryngologist and laryngeal surgeon at the NYU Voice Center, an assistant professor in the Department of Otolaryngology and head and neck surgery of the NYU Grossman School of Medicine, where he specializes in the care of professional voice and some other words I won't try to pronounce.
I did pretty well with the pronunciation there, Paul. Thank you. I really, I didn't even practice that. Um, and I do think the reason we're chatting today is just the confluence of Paul's expertise and knowledge of both the singer and the singing voice, as well as of course having the highest level of medical knowledge that you have in the field of vocal health. We'll chat about all of that. And I will just also say personally, Paul, you are a merging to me of beautiful worlds. I originally met you, of course, through Ellen Lettric, our founder and a friend of the pod. We've all heard Ellen, our wonderful vocal health specialist. But then in a totally separate world, you and my wife were already friends by the time I went.
I know. Really beautiful. One of my favorite human beings. Uh, I agree. She's one of my top five favorite human beings as well. I would hopefully. Uh, Paul, welcome on the pod officially. How are you doing?
[4:58] Paul Kwok: Thanks so much for having me. Listen, I'm really happy and delighted and honored to be here. So I've loved, I've loved this space. I've loved this group since Ellen and I first started. I mean, almost a decade ago, right? It was on webinar form at some point. You talked to MTCA, and then now you're gonna get to talk to the whole. You know, this group, of course, you're gonna listen. These are some MTCA um sort of students who will be listeners, but then also broader listeners who just, you know, young people, some of them looking at college, and some of them will be looking at the sort of early professional landscape as well. Um, so let's dive into it. Before we get into the vocal health specifics, which I'm excited to talk about that, that'll be the latter half.
You can stick ahead if you don't want to hear about Paul's journey. Uh, but let's talk a little bit about your specific journey. Can you give me like the 60-second catch-up of Paul before you started looking into college? So maybe if you're getting get me up to 16, 17 in terms of kind of where you grew up, how you discovered your love of music, your love of academics, etc.
[5:53] Paul Kwok: Yeah, I grew up in Dayton, Ohio. Um, so you know, uh apropos of Elizabeth Stanley, I the best people in the world come from the American Midwest, in my whole opinion. Well, I think Pittsburgh, that's basically the same. Come on. Yeah. Okay. Pittsburgh, Ohio, come on, we're right by each other, no? Um but uh I grew up in a little town called Dayton, Ohio. My parents were Korean immigrants, and I think as most Korean immigrants, uh to make a vast overgeneralization, yeah, they were really interested in their son getting into music. And I just sort of developed this affinity for the piano. My aunt was a piano teacher. Yeah. And so I just started playing piano, and I loved playing the piano. And I um did it all through middle school, high school, and all through college.
And I wouldn't say that I actually knew about voices until I got to like grad school. I just loved playing the piano. I loved playing solo music. I played in church, that's kind of where I learned to sight read. And so, you know, the first, you know, 60 seconds uh of this uh account are that I was a kid in Ohio who loved playing the piano and was good at it and therefore was encouraged to do it. And you know, I know you now as a uh an adult, an avid theater fan. Were you a theater or like did you enjoy performance from a fan perspective? Or did you ever perform yourself as a singer?
[7:14] Paul Kwok: Um, I never, I never performed as a singer. And I would say until I was a sophomore in high school, all of my the music that I thought about and played was classical. Classical music. And as um fortune, fate, uh divine providence would have it, I met Tori Ross who came to my high school and not to continuously circle back to Elizabeth Stanley, but another kind of uh overlap Tori and Elizabeth were in Crybaby together. And Tori was this talent that plopped down into my high school, you know, that was otherwise not super into arts and music. Yeah. But Tori loved musical theater. She was great at it. She had this great belty voice. And we just would sit in the music room and just play through great musical theater songs.
And that's where I came to really add the love of the great American musical theater repertoire. I love it. And we'll definitely talk about some of that collaboration in that degree you guys maybe there'll be a bonus point at the end we'll talk a little bit about sort of your learnings from that end of things. Certainly, you know, both the vocal health and that aspect of it very apropos for this time of year where our students are about to walk into rooms with a accompanist and like music together.
[8:23] Charlie Murphy: For sure. But wait talk to me about so now you're looking at college you know you're gonna study I think you said the history of medic of medicine and medical ethics or what is what the the degree from Harvard is. Was there you know you said you played throughout college was there any consideration of maybe I'm gonna be a professional performer or how did that go as you looked at college?
[8:40] Paul Kwok: Yeah I mean listen I can I feel like um obviously there's it's been like 30 years since I had to make this decision, but some of the emotion of it feels very very fresh in my head about having a real passion for talent for affinity for music. Yeah. And playing piano and frankly having parents who were very professionally minded. They were very practical people. They wanted me to have job security. And obvious obviously like they esteemed medicine as a healing art. And so that they were always very interested in me sort of being on the pre-med track. Yeah. So in college I tried to do both and I tried to play as much piano as possible, but I also did a history major. And I I would say for a decade of my life I didn't know which way it was going to go. Right. And and I was it's going to be a hobby or was it ultimately going to be something you pursue professionally.
[9:33] Paul Kwok: Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. And particularly when I went to graduate school at Juilliard, which was you know a huge honor and thrill, but there you're really in kind of the lines and where you're making music all the time. You play better than you've ever played before because you're just playing all day long. Yep. And you think I could do this. I really could do this. And there was a real moment, you know, in like 2006 when I had to make the decision. Yeah. You know, went to medicine. And early I mean we can talk more about that, but in the early days of medical school, I wasn't sure that it was right. It wasn't so clear that it was gonna work out as brilliantly as it has for me. It took you know another good ten years.
[10:13] Charlie Murphy: So did you see did you see that ultimate bridging? I mean I had a question for later, but did you see like when you went to medical school, oh I see how I could use this skill set I've have 'cause like it seems from the outside like, well, this makes so much sense. You did this amazing job of bridging it together. Did you see that as you went to medical school or were you like I'll just be a doctor?
[10:29] Paul Kwok: I don't know what I I sort of started to see it because my piano teacher Juilliard was a woman named Margot Garrett. And she was very good friends with Steven Zaitels, who's the laryngologist surgeon at Massachusetts General Hospital. Who among other things became very kind of well known for operating on Adele and Sam Smith and many other famous people. And she was she's been one of the great mentors in my life, and when she knew I was sort of having this conflict, she was like, You gotta meet Dr. Zaitels and like have a conversation with him. And that's when it first started to kind of connect. That this was a way in which my interest and love for voices could intersect with the crew in medicine. But you know, when you start medical school, you are at the start of like a ten year trajectory. I didn't read all those damn uh the places you went and all the things you did. But I'm picturing you had to go through like the pit basically or whatever. I don't know.
[11:22] Paul Kwok: Yes, yes. Like it's you're not just doing voice stuff, you're also learning about everything.
[11:26] Charlie Murphy: That's right, yeah. The f I mean the first four years are kind of generalized training, and even the first couple of years of your surgical training are generalized training. So it's really not until like year nine and ten that you get into very voice specific surgical and medical training.
[11:44] Paul Kwok: That's a long, that's a long journey.
[11:45] Charlie Murphy: So it's a long road, and I really um uh I have so much empathy and heart for folks who are like at that moment deciding where to go to college, why, and how to do it and um really tough to make I mean yeah, like I say w our students often are making the decision four years in advance.
[12:03] Paul Kwok: Yeah and it's really hard to know from eighteen to twenty two how you're gonna feel. I can't imagine nine years. I mean now at I'm not gonna say my age, one of my thirties. But to imagine nine years from now, I'm like, I don't know what I'm gonna feel like.
[12:13] Charlie Murphy: I I mean I I could have no idea. We we have trouble doing two years in advance with our child and going, Well, what's it gonna be like to have a six year old? Well, in many ways, you're sort of a literally a different person.
[12:23] Paul Kwok: Of course.
[12:23] Charlie Murphy: Ten years down the line. What's the thing? Every seven years your cells fully yeah, you all brand new cells. So I was like, you're gonna you're completely different person.
[12:30] Paul Kwok: Wait, I want to jump ahead to to some of that and so there's such interesting, you know, all the different people who I've gotten to have a little window in especially through Ellen who are these you know medical people but who have this real interest in the there's some interesting confluence of all those people. But I guess in the decision making of Juilliard specifically, there's obviously a moment after Harvard yeah where you're gonna decide now I I do want additional training. I guess w w was the reason you go to Juilliard because I wanted you wanted more hey I need more specific like technique from a piano playing perspective or was it more about the context you were gonna meet make like I kind of wonder you know a lot of our people they're also looking at theater training thinking I definitely want some more training but a big part of what they look at school is also opportunity and who I'm gonna meet and so how did you sort of view that why Juilliard and why you're gonna spend some years there?
[13:16] Paul Kwok: Well it's a great question and I think some of the elements when I was making that decision were um, you know how seriously did I want to try to do this.
[13:26] Paul Kwak: Because in college it was always on the side. Like I wasn't a music major and so I took piano lessons on the side but I tried to keep my chops up to be as good as they possibly could. But Juilliard for me represented the opportunity to give it the best shot that I can to really do nothing but that all day long in a city and in a venue where real professional possibilities were at your feet kind of all the time. And so it felt honestly sort of daunting and intimidating to move to New York City to rent an apartment by myself and just basically try to be the best at playing the piano that I could be. And that's what I think is so intimidating in that setting is that when you go to medical school, everyone that you're in school with is talented, but likely everyone's gonna get a good job, you know, because everyone needs a doctor.
At Juilliard, like one, two, three, four people out of every given class will really make it in the arts. And so you're it's sort of this constant negotiation of do I keep pushing myself harder and harder and harder, or do I kind of like decide that I'm not going to? But I think the answer to your question is that Juilliard represented the opportunity to give it the best shot that I could. I guess, and I don't know if this is even really answerable for what your perspective of yourself at 22 was. But like, you know, I think with some skill, some harder skills like piano playing feels like it's a harder skill than I'm saying harder as opposed to softer, like acting, where you're like, what is the talent like?
You know, I think some of the people we've had some great MDs on the pod who really have, at least from their perspective, saw themselves as musical phenoms and maybe didn't feel like, hey, I'm here, I need more technique. Honestly, the way some young dancers, you know, had some great dance on the pod who go by 18, not that I couldn't have used more technique or whatever, but I felt like I was really strong and it was about adding more style to myself or adding more whatever versus but I guess I don't know that that was true for you. Did you feel like by 17 you're like I can play anything, or was it like I still need more literal time in the gym pounding on the piano?
[15:34] Paul Kwak: Well, I think I actually needed more time in the gym, just more reps, more just sort of hours. And I think that's one thing. I mean, we can talk about this. I think pianists can practice for hours a day, and often do, and get better because of it. One of the things that I think about a lot with singers is that I don't think that you can practice for eight to ten hours a day and not suffer some sort of consequences from it. But pianistically, there is such advantage kind of neurally and mechanistically more time in the studio, just more time drilling. And that was a real opportunity. Also, Juilliard had these two tracks in their collaborative piano program. So there was an instrumental track and a vocal track.
And that was a huge pivot jumping off point for me because up until that point I had really only played instrumental chamber music. And a friend of mine was like, well, you played a lot of piano music, why don't you try the vocal track? And that made all the difference in my life. It was the first time I discovered voices, I started listening to voices. You know, as an accompanying student, you often will sit in the studios of voice teachers as they're giving a lesson, and then the first half hour they're like doing scales, exercises with the singer, but then you get to the rep. And just watching them warm up the singer, work through technical issues, I just thought was so fascinating. And I wouldn't I can't say that that was part of the plan that I anticipated that when I was jumping in, but in retrospect, that was foundational for the work that I do today and the life that I live today.
[17:16] Charlie Murphy: That's so cool. And I have some more questions, especially in the back half as we talk about some of that training and the perspective you have from all the different aspects of vocal training and then how it leads to vocal health and how it leads to some of the work that you do. I did, I mean, you're talking about the piano players practicing. One of our neighbors, this happens to be one of our neighbors in this building, is a pianist for Lincoln Center Ballet. Oh, yeah and practices four hours a day at minimum. I mean, that's what I hear. I mean, I'm just guessing based on the, I'm like, and she's in her sixties and still like just constant like I mean it's this cool thing of like living in New York being like telling my daughter, I'm like, yep, you're hearing just like absolute professional level classical piano.
But that's hours a day after 30 years or whatever of doing it. It is, you know, and talk actually with singers about that, about how much practice goes into instrumentalists sort of working the music into their bodies kind of literally. And you know, how that is different from what singers get to do. You know, I think again, you can't wear your larynx into the ground for eight hours a day, but there is a certain amount of progression that is just repetition. It's muscular and engagement, right, and exercise.
[18:30] Paul Kwak: Well, so I and I wanna, well we're as we slide into that, we'll take a break here in a second. But can we just give a little overview of like what is the work that you do now with singers? I imagine you meet them in many different ways. I mean, I know Elizabeth will call you and she feels the twingiest of tw anything she'd like to like to Paul. But then like, what is the kind of work that you are can you're doing as you're meeting singers in different forms?
[18:51] Paul Kwak: So yeah, most I mean, I see singers in the office, and so typically when anyone has an issue, I see them here. Rarely do we do much backstage stuff. I mean, you know, I used to sort of hear as a student about like doctors running backstage with steroid shots and you know it happens from time to time, but more commonly now, I think we have enough kind of education and proactivity to understand that the best care is really in the office. So people call me, come in, and if they're having a functional voice issue, they'll see the speech language pathologist and me. And the kind of the bulk of what I do is visualizing the larynx. So we use cameras, people know them as scopes to look at the vocal folds in the larynx.
And the job is to put that information into the totality of what's happening with the singer. And this is a recurring theme that every singer is different, and because every singer is an individual human being. And so that manifests in very real ways. You know, my job would be a lot easier if it were sort of like paint by number and you knew exactly kind of what the solution is based on how the vocal cords look. But that's not at all the case. You know, a lot of what comes into play are everything else about the singer, whether it's allergies, reflux, diet, medications, sleep, work schedule, you know, and all of that comes into play. So I love that. It is what I always say makes my job sort of endlessly fascinating and endlessly difficult.
[20:28] Charlie Murphy: Yep. I'd love to, you know, we make all these wonderful athletic, or I call them wonderful at least athletic comparisons on the pod of like what it is like as a singer, you know, a vocal athlete, but especially, you know, we talk about just the athletic world in general. You know, when you think about the different roles, like if an athlete were to have like a surgeon and then like a physical therapist and a coach, how would you sort of see, you know, like to for all the versions of getting them back on the court, how do you see the different roles of like you, an SLP, a you know, someone who's rehabbing the voice, a voice technique person, you know, sort of vocal technique, you know, coach? How do you see those different roles in terms of you know what the work obviously it all overlaps with each other in some ways of the work you're doing on the voice if you're talking about multiple hours a day, but how do you see those different roles?
[21:14] Paul Kwak: Yeah it's a great question. I think the functional rehab folks are the easier analogy because I think that the voice therapists, the SLPs, are like the PTs. They're the physical therapists who do a lot of rehab functional work with the athletes whether they're physical or vocal or you know sports or vocal athletes. And I think that you know the coaches, the trainers that goes across the aisle too. You know, all those people you see on the sidelines of the football field, they're the voice coaches, the voice teachers. I think the analogy is a little less direct is me and an orthopedic surgeon because generally when athletes when sports athletes need a surgeon they need a surgery. I would say when vocal athletes see me maybe like 20% of the time do they need a surgery.
And so a lot of what I'm doing is trying to figure out what they actually do need. Is it a surgery? Is it voice therapy? Is it medicine? Is it some combination of all those things? Is it some support in the psychoemotional realms of the voice? So all I think that's I feel like I have to think a little bit more comprehensively than an orthopedic surgeon does about care.
[22:28] Charlie Murphy: That's a really helpful I think it's really helpful to hear that both in the analogy of it all and and we'll talk a little bit you know of course we talk about stuff like vocal injury of like injury happens after and there's also training that you try to do to prevent injury but it seems like the idea of like yeah an orthopedic surgeon you're not getting seen like because my knee is twinging as much it's more like I tore my ACL or not. So it's sort of like, and I'm getting seen in a different way. All right but we're getting perilously close to the vocal health of the second half. So let's take a little break.
[22:52] Charlie Murphy: Yeah. Come back, we'll talk to Dr. Paul Kwak a little bit more about vocal health.
[22:56] Charlie Murphy: So we're back to the fabulous.
[22:59] Charlie Murphy: Okay, we're back with the one and only Dr. Paul Kwak. And I just want to touch on some sort of general vocal health knowledge for the singer. Um and you can speak as much as you know or don't know, are comfortable with all those things. You know, I know just from knowing you that you've worked with, you know, young teenage students to the fanciest Broadway and opera singers and celebrities and all of that, right? So um let's just let's give the listeners a little bit of red meat. This is what they really want is like what are the what are the big red flags? What are the things you throw out to young singers in terms of like common vocal health mistakes of people that you maybe do encounter in your office?
[23:35] Paul Kwak: Yeah, well, I think first of all, I you know, I could go for hours. So redirect me if I'm sort of going afield. We can go for hours for sure, yeah. We love because this is all I do. This is all I like think about and talk about all day long. I guess some things that come to mind in response to what you just said are I think when people ask kind of what's the kind of crux of vocal health, I always talk about kind of the appropriate balance between rest and activity. It's a very kind of simple athletic concept, right? Like our bodies can do a lot, our bodies can recover from a lot if you give them the appropriate balance between activity and rest. That sounds too simple to be true, but you would be just sort of shocked how that simple principle eludes so many.
And to be honest, you know, it's not like the Broadway schedule is in any way supportive of that. I happen to think that an eight-show week is physiologically insane. And so we are kind of raising people up into this schedule where more is expected of them than they realistically should be able to deliver.
[24:39] Charlie Murphy: Yeah. So I just want to acknowledge that kind of part of the culture in which we all participate and that it breeds overwork and fatigue.
[24:52] Paul Kwak: Yep. Well and and to not to interrupt you but the to use that athletic analogy it's something you talk at the highest level athletes as well all the time it's they talk about the NBA in an 82 game season and why all these people get hurt. It's like this is an unrealistic load on the body as you get over 30 and so sadly my NBA fantasy team was ruined last night as I mean Butler just tore his ACL. We love you Jimmy I'm sorry. But those things I mean it happens obviously partially these injuries can happen no matter what but some of these the injuries of overuse we talk about it is because of the schedule that is not realistic for people to on people's bodies.
[25:24] Paul Kwak: Totally and and so then the ACL analogy is a great one because it invites the discussion about the way the different ways in which we perceive injury in the vocal community and the sports community. And this is a whole other tangent which we can go on too but just to say in response to your question I think one of the things that I talk to young singers a lot about is the destigmatization of vocal injury. Right. When a football player basketball player tears his ACL no one is like oh he's a bad athlete. He was he was playing too hard he was playing too much I do feel like Jamie was playing a little too hard last night Paul. I was like you didn't have to go for that rebound. I'm kidding but of course right and like no one no one would say to him like you know here these things like oh all of those teachers students get nodules.
You know like no one would say like all of that basketball coaches. So there's a real conversation to be had around how we characterize understand the thing about vocal injury. No one wants a young singer to be injured, but no one like who sees a lot of people like young singers like me is surprised when a singer comes in with vocal injury. So that's that's the other thing. And so basically to to go back to the first question, it seems like you're talking about more issues of overuse. There are issues of overuse as opposed to misuse in terms of what you're you're seeing.
[26:43] Paul Kwak: I think so. I mean what really is the difference right? Like who am I so I really am very careful about using those terms because I'm not a vocal technician.
[26:53] Paul Kwak: I'm a doctor and I'm looking at tissue. And so overuse versus misuse is really for me more a question for teachers and SLPs. I just really have to ground myself in my empathy for what singers are doing with these two tiny little faults of tissue in their throats. You know, I am pretty loath to call something misuse, but overuse is a phenomenon that I can really wrap my mind around and understand. So some level of pacing, some level of understanding that injury can be an inherent part of the trajectory. And then I always talk a little bit, I try to talk with young singers about the value of knowing what your larynx looks like, of the value of engaging heartily with the medical system. Because I think the more knowledge you have early on, the more confident you are as a patient throughout your life.
And that might look like getting a baseline scope and something, a baseline scope just kind of getting to know who the ENT in your area is, getting to know voice therapists early. Many young singers won't need an SLP, but at least knowing where that resource exists is so huge. So I'm a big fan of some baseline information about the larynx. And that's often what I kind of lean into with young singers. And then I just think, you know, like the other thing I say a lot to young singers is that, you know, some people come into my office and they're like 18 years old and they're like, I've been singing my whole life. By which they basically mean they have been, but in terms of the adult larynx. The adult larynx is mostly formed by like puberty, right?
So if you think that your pianist colleagues have been playing for like 15 years, you've been singing for about three, realistically. And so you have to give yourself a little bit of credit and grace for that, and know that there's kind of a long trajectory. I mean, I know that's especially true of the bass baritones like myself, where I'm like, I feel like I got a completely different instrument around 15 years old, like, what? Now I gotta do with this? I was like this rock tenor, and then I'm like, that's gone. Okay, what do I do now? Like totally different things. And the classical voices too take even longer, you know, like bass baritones and vodka, you know, they hit their stride at like age 35, 40. So there's I'm just walking into my prime, Paul. Here comes.
[29:13] Charlie Murphy: Yeah, you and me both.
[29:15] Paul Kwak: Yeah, no, but that's it's a long road, right? And I think the investment early in information and engagement with concepts around health is really valuable. And obviously recognize this your not your exact area of expertise, but is there anything in terms of, you know, so baseline scope, is there anything in terms of like expertise with you know, with vocal use in terms of that the young singers in terms of tr the same way to make that, you know, athletics analogy of like there are ways you can try to train to do your best to prevent injury of going, what can I do to strengthen this part of my body to help hopefully help avoid this compensating those kind of things. Are there things that you recommend when you work with young singers of hey, I want you to get with this kind of person, or I want to get this kind of level of expertise, or I guess how do you think about that job that you is sort of in parallel with yours?
[30:03] Paul Kwak: Yeah, great question. I'm gonna try to answer it in a couple of different ways that I think are important. One I think part of it is just the regularity of it and the routine engagement with the exercise and alongside that I mean that I think I won't say the most successful singers but the most kind of confident patients are the ones who understand what it is they're feeling and what it means which is not obvious obvious to everyone right and so I think the people who pay attention understand what they're feeling how that changes when people make technical modifications that's huge. So just I think a certain curiosity be curiosity about technique and mechanics. And so we're saying that's especially true for the voice maybe more than other parts of your body because it's such a small and sensitive area.
It's you know you kind of might know hey this doesn't feel good on my knee but it's not always obvious to a singer of going does my voice hurt is my throat tight I'm not sure what's right what I'm experiencing. And what's confusing about that is kind of the second point which is that inherent to any sort of exercise development program there is an extent to which you push yourself when you're training right so like you know when athletes we work out and they they work out hard they're sore and that we accept as kind of like a positive because then it stimulates your muscle to gain recruit you know grow your mechanics. Same thing with the voice, right? There is a certain amount of soreness and fatigue after singing that we don't think is pathological.
The trouble is that you know, people are working on this, but there aren't ways to quantify that yet. So, like your roommate might be able to sing an hour more than you and not be fatigued, and you get tired at 30 minutes, and that doesn't mean that one person is better than the other. It just means we all have different exercise capabilities. So I think what's challenging when you're young is knowing when pushing a little bit is good and enough, and when you push too far. And sometimes it just takes some experience, you know, and some attempts to know that.
[32:19] Charlie Murphy: Yeah.
[32:20] Paul Kwak: And then the last thing I think I would say is that, and I think this I comes mostly from my perspective as a musician formerly, is that finding a teacher and a coach is super individual. I think mostly when you go to a doctor or a speech language pathologist, we all kind of practice think sort of in similar ways. Teachers are so different because so much of that is alchemy and chemistry and understanding. And so I am much more agnostic about teachers. And I think finding that's that's super challenging.
[33:00] Charlie Murphy: Yep, and it's certainly something I've experienced of, you know, hiring voice teachers, which I do, but not being a voice teacher expert myself. Just hearing the differences of language, even between purported experts, in terms of the way you talk about it, and to the terms of what is agreed upon, and this is medical knowledge versus this is. Well, I know I mean this, but I say this. I mean, it's really a complicated field.
[33:20] Paul Kwak: Yeah, in that way. What about we even talk much about singing when sick? You know, obviously this is now this time of year. This episode beautifully is gonna release for our senior listeners and our parents are seniors in the middle of their audition season. They'll be like in at Unified's in Chicago when this episode releases. And many of them will be thinking about this question of I have a sickness of some sort, you know, and they'll be thinking, do I cancel my audition? Do I still sing through it? You know, certainly I know I've had the experience of going sometimes I feel congested, but actually it doesn't affect my voice at all. And sometimes I go, I do feel somewhat affected. So how do you sort of think about I am sick? Do I keep singing? Do I push through? Do I take those steroids that you're gonna give me backstage? How do you think about that in terms of sort of singing when sick?
[34:05] Paul Kwak: I mean, in this season of the year, this question is like 95% of my daily existence. Also, how dare they do the audition season in January and February? This is the prime season are we doing?
[34:17] Charlie Murphy: Yeah.
[34:17] Paul Kwak: I know. I mean, so again, I'll try to answer that question in a couple different ways. First to say people will talk a lot about these vocal tests that you can do to figure out if your vocal cords are swollen. And the trouble is that they're not applicable to everyone, right? So I think what's hard, I think seasoned professionals have their tests and they know if they're swollen or not. I think that's harder to know if you are if you're young and starting out. I'll say a couple things. Inevitably when people get sick, they assume they have vocal nodules. And we've all seen what's the what's the movie where they're perfect. That's it. Where she's got the notes. Yeah, yeah, thank you. The nodes, they sit on your windpipe and crush your dreams.
I'm so glad you're ready with that because it would have bothered me if I couldn't come up with it. What I usually tell people is you feel things around your vocal cords and you hear things on your vocal cords. As a general rule. It's not a hundred percent. But so if you're feeling soreness, if you're feeling discomfort, obviously that's not comfortable, it's not great, but your vocal cords might be fine. If you or your teacher or your parent or coaches are starting to hear a fuzz in the sound, that may be a signal that you're more swollen. But that doesn't necessarily make the decision about what you're gonna do. And unfortunately that is very, you know, sort of person dependent. And it kind of depends on like how important is this particular audition to you, how dysfunctional do you feel? How close are you to a voice center where you can see a doctor and maybe get some medicine to help all those things come into play.
[36:04] Charlie Murphy: Um so that how's that for an unhealthy plan?
[36:08] Paul Kwak: It's not unhelpful, but yeah, I definitely understand how individual it is. And you know, again, if you're listening to this right before unified, sometimes it's it's not even a case of one audition. It's sort of like, Whoo, I have ten auditions in the next three days, and what do I do about that?
[36:24] Charlie Murphy: Yeah.
[36:24] Paul Kwak: To divert maybe for a second, I think what I would say actually is that the best treatment is actually prevention. Because once you once you're sick, we're anything that I can do is basically just trying to control symptoms. And even steroids, which we use a fair amount and you know are incredibly effective, you're just trying to get swelling down. And the steroids come with a lot of side effects, right? So I really do encourage people when you're in a kind of an important moment, yeah. I think wearing a mask is a pretty good idea. Washing your hands carefully is is also important. Just prevention, prevention, prevention. And who cares if you look, you know, like I don't who cares what people think about you on the plane? I mean, once you get that cold, you're just trying to play catch up.
[37:12] Charlie Murphy: No, honestly, some some of our students have talked about the the sort of not the benefit in some ways, but of COVID means it's more acceptable to wear a mask on a plane, which some of them were doing before it. Like that's what you should have been doing, probably ten years ago that we should have been doing.
[37:25] Paul Kwak: I think that's completely true.
[37:26] Charlie Murphy: So do you have any strong opinions in terms of, you know, people are always concerned about what they should be eating or drinking, of whether that's you know, the throat coats when my day that was popular or the pontus lozenges or you're drinking honey or I'm drinking coffee as we do this. Like do you feel in terms of what people imbibe, do you have any opinions about that?
[37:44] Paul Kwak: Not specifically. Some big overarching principles. One is just to remember that nothing you eat or drink touches your vocal cords or larynx. I know that seems obvious to a lot of people, but I think it's important to reinforce that everything you eat goes right by your larynx. So things that you eat or drink may be helpful for your gut health or your reflux, but they don't actually do anything for your vocal cords. So keep that in mind. Number one, and the only thing that really does reach your vocal cords is aerosolized water, by which we mean steam or nebulized water. So that can be hydrating to the vocal cords, but things you eat and drink don't really reach them.
[38:25] Charlie Murphy: Yep.
[38:25] Paul Kwak: Reflux is a whole topic that could occupy a couple hours. Here are my bullet points about reflux. One everyone kind of responds to foods and medicines differently. So when you Google reflux, you'll get like a list of things that you're not supposed to eat or drink, and it's basically everything good in life. And at that point, like what's the point? Yeah, it's like those at the ads at the met the whatever the medicine commercials where it's like, you might die. You might whenever you're like, well, this sounds like a good idea. I mean, if I had to eliminate all that from my diet, I would just rather die. But the truth is that, you know, for example, a lot of people can drink a fair amount of coffee and be fine.
A lot of people can eat pasta sauce. So I tell people just to start to d this again, understand your body and have an awareness about your body. If you eat a lot of pasta sauce and the next morning you wake up, you feel more heartburn. All right, maybe that's your trigger and you minimize it. So if you eat late at night, I know for me that was always I'm like, if I eat right before I go to bed, then I will have reflux or whatever.
[39:22] Charlie Murphy: But yeah.
[39:23] Paul Kwak: Well that's the other thing. It's not necessarily about what you're eating, it's kind of about when you're eating it. So that's another kind of important consideration too. Food is medicine, you know? Just the same way medicine is medicine. You mentioned it was on my list of just, you know, the different ways we can get hydration, you know, whether that's the personal steamer, whether humidifier drinking water. I know, you know, for a lot of our students the vocal mists have become all the rage, which yeah, we do have a discount for vocal mist if you want it, it's MDCA ten, though I know they're still crazy expensive. We're not we don't care, we don't you do it much.
[39:49] Paul Kwak: What do you think in terms of personal steamers, humidifiers, drinking water in terms of sort of how they hydrate the vocal cord?
[39:57] Paul Kwak: Yeah, I think that's I think they're great. So first of all, again, everything we eat and drink goes right by the vocal cord. In general, hydration is a good thing for the body. Some people take that to extremes. Like I don't think people all need to be drinking four gallons of water a day.
[40:12] Paul Kwak: You must, and they're bringing the bottle into the audition room and taking three drinks and then be like, oh, yeah. That's just eating constantly, right? So like I think some moderation, plentiful hydration, but moderate in terms of what you drink. Then steaming and nebulizing and vocal mist, I think are excellent. And particularly if you're traveling a lot and you have kind of portable ones, they're a great way when you're in environments that you're concerned about. It may be dusty, it may be kind of very hot and dry.
[40:40] Charlie Murphy: Yeah.
[40:41] Paul Kwak: And you get some really nice surface moisture to the lamps and the vocal cords that way.
[40:45] Charlie Murphy: Yep.
[40:46] Paul Kwak: Do you have any feelings about sort of over-the-counter medicines? And you know, you mentioned steroids. If they're seeing someone, could they be using that? What about if you go, I'm not necessarily at that point, but I do have a cold. I think I feel comfortable singing through it, but you know, in terms of what the kind of stuff they might be taking and anything they should be thinking about.
[41:01] Paul Kwak: Yeah. I think there is an upcoming episode on my podcast if we get around to publishing.
[41:07] Charlie Murphy: Okay, we're here to shill my podcast, Paul. We're not here to chill your podcast.
[41:11] Paul Kwak: No, please tell us all about it.
[41:12] Paul Kwak: Yeah, but the episode doesn't even exist, so it doesn't even matter. But on medicines for the common cold, because that is like a whole hour-long thing.
[41:19] Charlie Murphy: Yeah.
[41:19] Paul Kwak: I think a couple things that I'll say that are commonly asked about, for example, ibuprofen or anti-inflammatory drugs, and whether it's safe to sing on them.
[41:29] Charlie Murphy: You mean because of the autism that it causes?
[41:32] Paul Kwak: Okay. That was just a joke, Paul. It was just a joke for fun.
[41:36] Paul Kwak: It's like too real.
[41:37] Charlie Murphy: It's too real. I can't, it's like I can't, I can't with that right now.
[41:40] Paul Kwak: Yeah. But um, anti-inflammatory medicines like ibuprofen are perfectly safe to sing on. I, uh, there was, there's this mythology that like if you sing on ibuprofen, you will hemorrhage.
[41:50] Charlie Murphy: Uh-huh.
[41:51] Paul Kwak: Just not true. I mean, it has happened, but it doesn't mean that everyone who takes ibuprofen will hemorrhage. So ibuprofen NSAIDs are safe to take. A lot of people ask about mucinex.
[42:02] Paul Kwak: Um, I think mucinex, particularly with cough suppressant is great if you are starting to get a cold and or you have a cold, particularly with a cough.
[42:12] Charlie Murphy: Yeah.
[42:13] Paul Kwak: Because a cold is one thing, whether you can sing, you know, given the vocal fold swelling, but the cough can be really devastating, right? Cause because you're just slamming the vocal cords against each other, the trachea is irritated.
[42:25] Charlie Murphy: So those are some sort of simple tips that you think goal of preventing the cough, preventing the coughing before it happens within.
[42:32] Paul Kwak: Yeah, trying to, because the more it's a kind of thing that can exacerbate itself. The more you cough, the more you cough.
[42:37] Charlie Murphy: Well, and that's really helpful in terms of the time of year of it all. I wonder, you know, you mentioned, I think it was 80% of the people you see who don't actually have nodes or don't need surgery, I think is how you said it. You know, uh, but plenty of our students, and this is true for, have some vocal issue that they may be working through, they may be dealing with, you know, sort of how do you think about if a student is going, hey, I'm going into this process, maybe this is more long term of like maybe it's a junior listener who's going, Hey, I've had vocal issues before, this is something that I'm working through.
[43:06] Paul Kwak: I'm going through this process. Maybe they're listening to this in November or whatever, they're looking forward at their process. Kind of how they can how they navigate that, you know, the whether it's recovery from a vocal injury or I've got something going on, maybe it's not surgical, you know, when you talk about how do I think about going through the if I again make that athlete's analogy of going, maybe I'm resting back to back. So what is my plan in terms of how I'm gonna go through this experience of singing for where I'm gonna have to sing a lot in the course of three months, how do you sort of advise your clients?
[43:36] Paul Kwak: Yeah, I think that's where I come into the picture a little bit more, right? I think that pianists who are training, getting in their reps, doing the hours, going to lessons, going to group classes. I don't know that I ever saw a doctor as a pianist, right? Because I think I actually did one once have a repetitive stress injury, but I saw like the PT, but never a doctor.
[44:01] Paul Kwak: I think the reason I get to know singers often so well is because you can't see your larynx. And having some visual information about what's happening, what's developing there is a really important kind of side piece along with what you're feeling and what your teacher is hearing.
[44:19] Paul Kwak: So I that's why I sort of talk about leaning into the relationship with a voice center and an ENT, because I think it helps integrate all of the kind of information that you were acquiring from teachers, from coaches.
[44:33] Charlie Murphy: Yeah.
[44:34] Paul Kwak: Um, and so I that's why we like singing, seeing young folks and kind of helping along in the journey. I don't know, yeah, our founder Ellen would really put some underlining to that.
[44:43] Paul Kwak: I mean that's a big part of often what she does is going, let's just let's de-stigmatize and let's get you this relationship with the medical professional so that we have knowledge and then we can help sort of make a plan and yes.
[44:53] Charlie Murphy: I really like that.
[44:54] Paul Kwak: Absolutely. And just to add one thing, often people who are starting out in training get swollen. Some people develop little nodules, and with training, with therapy, with additional time, they go away.
[45:07] Charlie Murphy: So it's funny you mentioned Pitts Perfect because we thought we were making good progress with decatastrophizing, as Lucian says, yeah, vocal fold pathology, and then Pitts Perfect came along, and now we're like 10 years behind.
[45:21] Paul Kwak: Yeah.
[45:22] Charlie Murphy: But I'm here to tell you that vocal fold nodules are one of the most common things we see, and people rehabilitate from them completely.
[45:29] Paul Kwak: So it so it's not like, you know, career ender the way that people often think that it is.
[45:35] Charlie Murphy: I love that. I mean, certainly some of our previous podcast guests we had Telly Liang was our first podcast guys. We talked about that. Alex Brightman talked about recovering. These are both people who had did have surgery and recovered from it, but of course, certainly many of our students who've successfully recovered from vocal issues without needing surgery and had success.
[45:50] Paul Kwak: Absolutely. Absolutely.
[45:51] Charlie Murphy: Um I really love that. I mean, you know, we love individualization and every version of MTCA, we talk about this with material selection, all these things, but the idea of sort of getting to know your own body. That's certainly has been my experience as a certainly from a speaking voice perspective of going, yeah. All this knowledge is helpful, but then I also really need to know like how does it work on me? What's actually when do I actually need sleep? How much sleep do I actually need? That's true for me. It's not exactly true for everybody else, but uh you sort of get to know your your own body.
[46:17] Paul Kwak: Exactly right. Everyone's a different athlete.
[46:20] Charlie Murphy: Anything else you wanted to add from a vocal health or vocal athletics perspective before we do a bonus question?
[46:25] Paul Kwak: Um, I think it's a on line with kind of what the some of the themes that have recurred throughout this conversation, but that this is a process, it takes time, it takes effort, it takes work. You're not gonna be perfect from day one, and there will be bumps in the road. There may be bumps on your vocal cords, but there are teams of people to help you through that um and continue on a successful journey.
[46:52] Charlie Murphy: Um I love it. You got some bumps, bumps and bumps.
[46:55] Paul Kwak: I see what you did there. That was very good.
[46:56] Charlie Murphy: Um all right, let's do our bonus question, which we I mentioned that collaboration, you know, talking about collaboration with the pianist. You know, many of our this will come out right basically after New York City Unified's where many of our students are gonna be doing this direct, um, maybe their first time auditioning live within a company.
[47:11] Paul Kwak: Yeah, you know, but certainly that could be true in other live auditions, whether it's in Chicago or on campus, just that experience of what it is to walk in a room and make music with someone or to form that little two-man band of so you know, from your experience, you have obviously the fast experience with this. Are there things you particularly loved with singers when you're making music together? Things in terms of that collaboration, any advice to the singer as they collaborate with the pianist?
[47:36] Paul Kwak: You know, what occurs to me to respond is as a pianist, when you get a score, you better make sure if you have cuts that they're clearly marked, and that you know exactly how much you want me to play in and how much you want to play out.
[47:53] Charlie Murphy: I don't actually know what the format of the unified is in terms of how much you get to sing.
[47:58] Paul Kwak: Um, but just make sure you're like your score is clean.
[48:01] Charlie Murphy: Sure.
[48:01] Paul Kwak: And aside from that, I would say that um sitting on that side of the piano, we are we want you to succeed, right? We want to be thrilled and awed by you. I'm despite what it feels like, no one is out to get you.
[48:21] Charlie Murphy: I like we all want you to do your best.
[48:23] Paul Kwak: And so we're rooting for you. And the more kind of joy and heart that we can see through all of the nerves and the anticipation, I think the more thrilling it is.
[48:35] Paul Kwak: Those are my favorite ones, where the joy and the artistry just kind of shines through.
[48:40] Charlie Murphy: And I'm not sure how much experience you've had specifically with these like audition in that experience, but is there a way that in the way they talk to you that you sort of that you can they get you can help get them on your side or they can help get you on your s your side?
[48:53] Paul Kwak: Like, do you is there a way that if someone is going through a cut or they're going through, okay, here's the markings I've made, and let's say hopefully it is marked correctly. You know, often they're pretty nervous in the stakes of it all.
[49:03] Charlie Murphy: Of course.
[49:04] Paul Kwak: It's like you're their last chance before the daunting people that are behind the table are gonna be hearing them. So so they're often not in that mode of like thinking about how do I get you on my side, they're thinking about oh my god, how do I do this audition?
[49:15] Charlie Murphy: Yeah, yeah.
[49:16] Paul Kwak: I mean, not even so much thinking about getting me on your side, it's just you know, like I'm your partner in that moment, right?
[49:22] Paul Kwak: Like, I think maybe it can feel like the pianist is one of the like jury, but really like we're making a moment together. So even you know, I don't think you need to think about getting the pianists on your side, it's just understanding that we're doing this together.
[49:38] Paul Kwak: I mean you'd be surprised how many people don't even look you in the eye when they come in the room because they're terrified, right? And they're thinking about so many of the things.
[49:45] Charlie Murphy: But if you can just like connect, like just smile at your pianist, say hi, you know, just know that we're there for you.
[49:53] Paul Kwak: I think that can make a real difference.
[49:55] Charlie Murphy: I love it.
[49:56] Paul Kwak: Um, okay, our last question we always ask is just to talk about advice for the parents. We have many parent listeners, you know. Any big thoughts for our parent listeners on just how they can best guide their children through for I guess this daunting field in general, but especially when we talk about, you know, vocal health.
[50:12] Paul Kwak: And you know, I'm sure you've had many parents in your waiting rooms pretty nervous about, oh my gosh, is my child gonna be okay? How can they do this? So just basically for our parent listeners, any any perspective from from their end of things?
[50:22] Paul Kwak: Hmm. Well, um I don't, you know, I think what occurs to me to say is that I really like having you in the room, actually.
[50:36] Paul Kwak: And I think sometimes young young uh students can feel like, uh, mom and dad, like why are you here? But I I really value having that kind of perspective there.
[50:48] Paul Kwak: Um and so know that, you know, that's an important part of of the interaction.
[50:54] Charlie Murphy: Yeah.
[50:57] Paul Kwak: Um, because I think it can be kind of overwhelming as a young person. I certainly don't know that I would have understood vocal fold when I was 15, 16 and 17 years old.
[51:05] Charlie Murphy: So just having another set of years I think is is really helpful.
[51:09] Paul Kwak: Yeah.
[51:09] Paul Kwak: What about from the you know you mentioned with your parents, you know, you sort of pi picture painted this almost stereotype of Korean immigrant parents who go, you know, you're gonna do music and you're gonna become a doctor or whatever.
[51:19] Charlie Murphy: Yeah.
[51:20] Paul Kwak: Right. Um you know what about if they're in that stage where they are wrestling a little bit with like I'm not totally sure if I want to support my kid getting this BFA or if I want to, you know, should they get a BA first and then they can get an MFA or you know for for those I don't know how how much you feel your parents' perspective on that experience now being a little older with it, but sort of h how do you think about them as they just look at this path in general or the educational path.
[51:46] Paul Kwak: So I can say I will say that I just turned 44 and I would say for about 25 years of my life I was fairly angry with my parents for the ways that they had pushed me.
[52:02] Paul Kwak: And it's probably only after I turned I don't know 40 um both my parents have passed on and I think with that comes some perspective about the reasons and the ways that they did what they did and I am truly grateful for it now.
[52:20] Paul Kwak: But I there were many years where it was really tough with my parents.
[52:25] Charlie Murphy: Yeah.
[52:26] Paul Kwak: And I I can only speak to my experience. I I have no I I'm not here to tell anyone how they should raise their child.
[52:32] Paul Kwak: I s I don't have kids. That is not all I'm just trying to offer is just my one person's experience about how um you know it's only deeply in retrospect that I can really be grateful for the ways that they raised me.
[52:49] Paul Kwak: But while I was going through it, it was tough. And so I really have a lot of empathy for people who are I you know, a lot of my friends now are raising kids and kind of going through this.
[52:59] Paul Kwak: Do I push them? Do I let you know?
[53:00] Charlie Murphy: Yeah.
[53:01] Paul Kwak: I don't know. But I feel very lucky that it all worked out into a brilliant career path for me, and I feel my life is fully integrated and every part of that, the music, the college, the grad school, it now all funnels toward my life and my work.
[53:17] Charlie Murphy: Yeah.
[53:18] Paul Kwak: But there were a lot of years when there I had to sort of trust that there was um a light ahead.
[53:25] Paul Kwak: Yeah, it's so beautifully said.
[53:27] Charlie Murphy: And well, I think I've talked about it before in the pod, but it's such an interesting experience for me when you hit the age that your parents were that you have memories of. Like, I remember what it was like when I'm like, and I, in the way you would view your parents, and you're like, but now I'm that age and I'm still a kid.
[53:42] Charlie Murphy: Like I worked I don't know anything, and I don't know. It's very yeah, very interesting. So God bless the parents. Well, yeah, thank you. Thank you for this expertise and for that for your vulnerability, Paul. It was so great getting a chat with you. If people like want to know more about you, if they want to reach out to you, I mean, do you want them following you on social media? Do you want them heading to the uh NYU website? What where's the best place if they wanted to reach out to you?
[54:04] Paul Kwak: A couple of different ways. Um we maintain an NYU voice center um Instagram. It's at NYU Voice, and there's also a Facebook page. Yeah. Um, and uh that's probably the easiest way. And then my Here's your opportunity to show your podcast. That's what I'm trying to give to you, Paul. Go for it.
[54:20] Paul Kwak: It's called Quok Talks. Um, it's a couple years old, but we're we're gonna add some more episodes. But it's you know, it's a resource. And um, yeah, I think that's that's about it.
[54:29] Charlie Murphy: Paul, thanks for the time today. This was so thank you for having me, Charlie. Great to see you.
[54:39] Charlie Murphy: Oh, yes, yes, yes. So fun for me to get a chat with Paul there. Um, I'm gonna be doing uh hopefully a kind of quick takeaway today. We'll see how quick I can do this. Uh, I gotta finish packing and I gotta get on this plane tomorrow. So uh I'm gonna run through a few of the quick underlines and then I'll probably probably try to do like one deeper dive. We'll see how I do with that. Um, so just to highlight, underline the idea we've talked about this before, just that need for skills at a high level. We talked about that kind of piano practice, you know, and I've talked about it before in the context of you know, the just any the practice and the reps you need at any high level of art or athletics, and it can be really daunting, right?
You've gotta love the practice, or you gotta figure out a way to get something out of the rigor of that practice so that you can keep showing up and digging deeper and diving deeper and doing more and more and more again and again and again.
[55:25] Charlie Murphy: Um also just an underline and a bold face to the idea of like destigmatizing a vocal injury or destigmatization, I should say, a vocal injury, and really like destigmatization of all aspects of this crazy career, you know, it's just so funny the way the actors talk to ourselves and talk to each other about our careers. Like we know, we always talk about like if any amazing basketball player like played D1 basketball, but then just didn't happen to ever make it to the NBA. We would like to celebrate that person as an amazing basketball player who had an amazing basketball career who just didn't happen to make it all the way to the NBA, which is really lofty. If they have that second career, we're like, that's so cool.
You play D1 basketball and you do the other those things. But if an amazing Broadway level actor never happens to make it to Broadway, too many people inside and outside the profession are gonna view that as a failure. And it's just not true, right? I don't know if it's because we're all so sensitive or we're also dramatic, whatever it is, but there are just so many ways that we as artists take the ups and downs of this life so much more sensitively than athletes or just people with more regular careers, right? I mean, can you imagine asking a lawyer friend, hey, what would I know you from? And the lawyer being embarrassed if they couldn't be like, yeah, I did Brown the board of education. That's the one you'd know, right?
Like, you know, if their response was like, oh, you know, just some appellate court cases. You've probably never heard of them. It's not that impressive, right? Like, that's how we talk as actors, and we're the only people who do that. Okay, there's my funny actor lawyer joke. I've told that before, but I'm proud of that one. I think that is funny, and we should all be a little bit less sensitive in the way that we talk about ourselves and be proud of our greatness, even if that greatness doesn't happen to lead to something that's a show on Hulu or whatever it is.
[57:03] Charlie Murphy: We also did that idea of knowing your own instrument and individualizing your practice on the last artist episode. So I'm just gonna, yes, thumbs up, check, agree with that. I also really love, you know, Paul corrected my poor phrasing when I was talking about like getting the pianist on your side. Of course, he's completely right. The pianist is on your side. That's not really what you're worrying about doing. I really like the way he talked about the collaboration. That was all really nice. Um, sometimes in professional auditions, we can say, like, you know, get them on your side if they're like tired or lazy, but that's not gonna be the case for you as you're doing this. They are gonna be on your side and they're gonna be excited to help you with your college editions for sure.
[57:36] Charlie Murphy: Um, I will also just add, you know, he mentioned that they won't be a member of the jury or of the auditioning team, he was saying, which I would say is usually true. Usually they would just be an accompanist or someone that from the program or some of the program knows, but they could, it's not always true. They could be a music director of the program, especially if you're doing an on-campus audition. Maybe they're a voice teacher for the program who happens to play. Um, you know, some people just some professors like getting that kind of window into the student experience. You know, that's actually can be true in the professional world too. I know some MDs or even sometimes the composer will actually play their own professional auditions just to have that perspective from behind the piano and really get a sense of the musician from that experience of playing the instrument.
You know, the advice still holds the same, whether they are a member of the team or not, whether they're an outside person or whether they're the composer of the musical, right? You're always gonna treat the pianist like they're your friend, you're gonna look them in the eye, you're gonna help them help you as you make music together and you collaborate, everything that that Paul talked about.
[58:34] Charlie Murphy: So it wouldn't change just because this person might have a vote, but the person might have a vote. Just kind of want to note that that it is possible that they do. And if so, you know, what a great chance to collaborate with one of your would-be professors. You get to like make music together today, just like we will for the next four years when that happens. Um, also just have to say, I just wrote down, you know, near the end of the episode, uh, Paul says, My life is fully integrated. Uh, and I don't know if it's just because I'm in so many different kinds of therapy, but I just am like, that is a goal, isn't it? To have your life feel like you're fully integrated. Me as a father, me as a business owner, me as a teacher, me as an actor.
Can I have all of those things integrated? The goal, you know. I talk about this a bit in an upcoming uh alumni parent episode that we just recorded, which I think you'll all really like. It just feels like such a win from a parent's perspective, too, of like, what do you want for your children? You there's so many things we talk about that you want for your children, but I think that's one of them, right? So much uh of just life is like, can we can we be one person walking in with my romantic partner? And I'll keep going, right? But it's also, you know, I talk about it from an educational perspective. So much of what we're trying to hope for our students to achieve in the room is can they walk into the room as integrated as possible? So yay, yay, yay.
[59:43] Charlie Murphy: Um, all right, let's end with my one slightly longer takeaway. Hopefully it's not too, too long, but is just to talk a little bit about the merging of skills, right? We kind of brushed over in the interview, but how about this idea of a medical doctor, someone who's a Harvard-trained medical doctor who's got all these fancy um medical schools, and also a Juilliard-trained musician with like a deep knowledge of the voice from listening to voice lesson after voice lesson the way Paul described. That's a unique combination. What a beautiful combination of skills that is. And isn't it amazing how that combination instantly elevates Paul to be like the top of his specific field? And that's not taking anything away from him.
Also, I'm sure he's also individually brilliant at both of those things as a musician and as a as a doctor, right? But do I know he's necessarily the best at just like regular old doctoring or the best at music? Actually, I have to know he's really good at music. But the point is, I don't know exactly where you'd rate his skill sets individually compared to people who do only those things, so compared to just other doctors or just other amazing piano players, but that confluence makes him really special, right?
[1:00:48] Charlie Murphy: I mean, there's just something magical about taking two things that are very different and merging them together. I mean, I will take myself as an example. Am I the greatest actor or the greatest teacher you've ever met? Almost certainly not. Though I think even there, there's like a nice combination that not every actor with my knowledge of acting has the teaching skills I have. And I would say even fewer teachers, if you took all the teachers who teach as well as I do, how many, what percentage of those have the level of high-level acting knowledge that I have? That's actually, for how many great actors are and how many great teachers are. I don't know that there's a huge, huge pool of people, but still a plenty huge, uh plenty big pool of people, because I do think those two things go together with some frequency.
[1:01:30] Charlie Murphy: So to me, those are not remarkable to put those two things together. But then if you add in as like a third thing, like my math and business skills. Now, I'm gonna be honest, I am not necessarily the greatest mathematician you've ever met, right? As our regular listeners will know, the last math class I took, and I talk about it all the time, was my AP statistics class in high school. I did get a five on the test, that's fine, right? But I do obnoxiously use that one class because it's the last math that class I took uh all the time on the on the pod, right? So are there people who know a whole lot more about math and have a lot more business savvy because they got an MBA? Of course there are.
But when you combine all those things together, the artistic skills, the educational knowledge that I have, and I think the educational skill set that I have, and then the math business strategy. Now I start feeling more uniquely suited to run an educational acting company. Actually, I don't think there are many people who have as high-level math business strategy I do, if it's a prerequisite to have those other two things at the level that I have, right?
[1:02:29] Charlie Murphy: You know, the sort of pessimistic version of this idea is like in a world of blind men, the one-eyed man is king, right? That's sort of how I feel at different times of like, well, compared to all these artists, I'm pretty smart, right? There's there's something to that idea, right? And the comedy world knows this concept really well. Just this idea of like if you take two divergent concepts and mix them together, you can often come up with something very funny from two concepts that weren't necessarily particularly funny on their own, right? Uh, the example I've heard many times is like there's nothing inherently funny about a caveman and nothing inherently funny about a lawyer, but you put them together, you get a caveman lawyer.
It's pretty funny. It's like an SNL skit for the kids. You can Google it, Google caveman lawyer. Or as I did earlier, you can put the actor and lawyer together and get like a sensitive lawyer who's vain about his court case pilot, which got sent back to the low courts instead of getting picked up. Right.
[1:03:25] Charlie Murphy: And all of a sudden that's funny, right? Those individual concepts are that funny, but you put them together. It's kind of funny in a unique combination, an interesting combination. So if we're gonna take a bit of advice from this, it's just like find your confluence, right? You don't need to know at 18 or even 22 or 28 or 32 or whatever, right? But when students will tell me something like, I just don't think there's anything unique about me, or there's nothing interesting about me, or whatever it is, as we're sort of searching for who they are and how they want to lead in the room. I I will often respond with first, that's likely not true. There likely is something that is singularly interesting about you and something singularly unique about you, but that that's not even necessarily the goal. Sometimes people think it's like, I need to have this incredibly fun, weird fact about me that's singular, right? I think it's often much easier to find uniqueness in those confluences, right?
[1:04:12] Charlie Murphy: Uh, you know, maybe you're not the greatest trumpet player ever or the greatest scuba diver, but are you the greatest underwater trumpet player? That's a terrible one. Don't try that one at all. That's not the analogy I'm going for. But really, whatever it is, in those combinations, I think we find a lot of our unique identity. And it doesn't have to be that interesting of combinations. Like the ones I use was like acting, teaching, and business. Those aren't like some magical things, any of those things, but you put them all together and you go, I actually think with all of those things in combination, in the combination I have them, um, they make me really uniquely skilled to what I am, right?
And again, that goal's not even necessarily unique, it just it makes it makes you special, right? Even if you're not literally the only person who's like that, you go, but okay, there aren't that many people, or this makes me interesting, or this makes gives me a little bit of an edge because I have all of these things all put together, right?
[1:04:58] Charlie Murphy: You know, I think it often I've talked about this before in in terms of the parts that scare you about yourself. It could be in the parts that maybe you take for granted a little bit. That if you take the part of you that's for granted that maybe comes from your family that you go, well, that's that's the part I'm used for, right? I'm used to, I should say. And then you combine it with other growing skill sets, maybe putting those two things together and integrating them can really kind of set you apart, right? And for young people, it's not something you need to rush to, right? Maybe right now, especially 16, 17, 18 years old, you're just kind of cultivating all of those interests and cultivating all of those parts of you that you want to grow, and you're really just focused on growing those skills, and that's a great place to be.
But maybe over the course of the next couple years, as you think about entering the business and entering the world where people are gonna pay you money for things, you can just kind of stay sensitive to like what are all the things that are sprouting and maybe see if there are any ways you might be able to tie some of those those sprouting plants together to in some unique way. I don't know where all of a sudden I went to a plant analogy at the end. But there you go, that's it.
[1:06:00] Charlie Murphy: Another episode of Mapping the College Audition tied beautifully together by the unique confluence of Megan Cordier, Kelly Prennergrass, and Jordan Rice. You can check us out on Insta at Mapping the College Audition. You can like and subscribe to us wherever you watch or listen, comment on whatever platform you want to comment on, and certainly leave us as many ratings and reviews as that platform will allow you to. And you know, you can head over to mdca.com for all of your individual college prep needs and to sign up for our upcoming junior intensive. Two my young artists out there mapping their journeys. Please trust you are enough for the right program, exactly as you are right now. Now keep striving. We'll catch you next week.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
