In this College Deep Dive, Charlie and David discuss: What is style and why it’s important. Taking caution with Chat Boards. The willingness to be “wrong” when given an adjustment. Audition Advice for Parents!.. Read More
From the show: Mapping The College Audition: An MTCA Podcast
About
In this College Deep Dive, Charlie and David discuss:
- What is style and why it’s important
- Taking caution with Chat Boards
- The willingness to be “wrong” when given an adjustment
- Audition Advice for Parents!
If you would like to hear more from David be sure to check out the following places:
- @umiamitheatre on Instagram
- Website
- dwilliams@miami.edu
Takeaway Glossary:
- Texas State Acting with Neil Patrick Stewart timestamp: 45:04
- University of Arizona with Danny Gurwin timestamp: 33:08
- Indiana University with Richard Roland DJ Gray timestamp 59:00
- Syracuse University with Thom Miller timestamp: 50:58
Join us for Alumni Waitlist Q&A Webinar and Spring Faculty Masterclass!
If you have any questions about the college audition process, feel free to reach out at mailbag@mappingthecollegeaudition.com. If you’re interested in working with MTCA for help with your individualized preparation for your College Audition journey, please check us out at mtcollegeauditions.com, or on Instagram or Facebook.
Follow Us!
Instagram: @mappingthecollegeaudition
YouTube: @MTCA (Musical Theater College Auditions)
TikTok: @mtcollegeauditions
Charlie Murphy:@charmur7
Meghan Cordier:@meghanmarie2014
About MTCA:
Musical Theater College Auditions (MTCA) is the leader in coaching acting and musical theater students through the college audition process and beyond with superlative results. MTCA has assembled a roster of expert artist-educators who can guide students artistically, organizationally, strategically, and psychologically through the competitive college audition process. MTCA provides the tools, resources, and expertise along with a vast and strong support system. They train the unique individual, empowering the artist to bring their true, authentic self to their work. MTCA believes that by helping students reveal their potential it allows each school to connect with those who are truly right for their programs, which in turn guides each student toward their best college fit.
About Charlie Murphy:
Charlie is a proud graduate of Carnegie Mellon University’s BFA program. As an Actor he has performed with theaters such as: NY Public Theatre’s “Shakespeare in the Park”, The Pearl Theatre Company, Hudson Valley Shakespeare Festival, Chautauqua Theatre Company, Kinetic Theatre Company, and the Shakespeare Theatre of DC.
With MTCA [Musical Theater College Auditions -- mtca.nyc], he has been helping prospective theatre students through the college process for over 15 years. As a Teacher and Director, he is able to do a few of his favorite things in life: help students to find their authentic selves as artists, and then help them find their best fit for their collegiate journey. Through this podcast, he hopes to continue that work as well as help demystify this intricate process.
This episode was produced by Meghan Cordier and Charlie Murphy. Episode theme music is created by Will Reynolds.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:10] Charlie Murphy: Hello and welcome to Mapping the College Audition, a podcast where we explore the landscape of the college theater world and try to demystify this daunting audition process.
[0:20] Charlie Murphy: I'm your host, Charlie Murphy, Director of MTCA. That's Musical Theatre College Auditions. And today we've got a bright and sunny show lined up for you.
[0:29] Charlie Murphy: My daughter is obsessed with the word sunny right now and bunny, anything honey, she's into it. David Williams is on the show today from the University of Miami, and I think it is a really great episode.
[0:42] Charlie Murphy: David is someone I've been hoping to get on for a while, and it was well worth the wait. So I'm gonna give you a podcast first in a pre-interview takeaway, which is really just to say we chat a bit about communication while on a wait list and really communication in general in this kind of post-acceptance period while people are making their final decisions and the value of how important communication is, which leads me to remind you, any of you who have not signed up for our waiting on a wait list Q&A we're having this week, I highly encourage it.
[1:18] Charlie Murphy: That will be with Leo, our other director and last week's podcast guest, chatting with some of our alumni who have navigated wait lists successfully in the recent past. This is something that is such a big topic each year, that this year we decided we didn't want to just squeeze it in to other webinars, but to give it a whole other separate conversation in and of itself.
[1:39] Charlie Murphy: That is 9 p.m. Eastern on this Friday, April 14th, for those who listen in the first 48 hours of release, as you all should. So please register for that. We're also starting our spring faculty masterclass series this week with Catherine Moore of Carnegie Mellon, a previous podcast guest.
[1:56] Charlie Murphy: So for anyone interested in those classes, they're almost all completely sold out, but there are very few spots available in Pace's class as well as in the dance classes. But those will sell out. So if you want to grab one of those spots, please do it soon.
[2:09] Charlie Murphy: The other pre-takeaway I want to do, because David talked about it again, like so many of our teachers do, is just a huge, huge congratulations to the class of 2023. I know we're not at May 1st yet when we'll do our big official celebration.
[2:24] Charlie Murphy: But if you're an MTCA student sitting there stressed with multiple good options, trying desperately to make a final decision, please just remember that stressed out junior that you were when you began this process, hoping that just one school would actually accept you. Well, here you are. You've earned the right for this amazing, stressful decision, and a huge congrats to you on that.
[2:46] Charlie Murphy: David did specifically say how awesome this class was. And it's also just like thrilling to hear about an awesome class that has nothing to do with COVID. The past few years, all of our classes have been amazing, but you kind of couldn't describe them without words like resilient or they're amazing fighters.
[3:03] Charlie Murphy: Oh God, they had to navigate the crazy ups and downs of all of this. And well, that is true of all classes in this process. Resiliency is so important as an actor, but especially in the college process. This class of 2023 feels like they got to shine on their own merits as performers, and that is just thrilling to me.
[3:20] Charlie Murphy: Using my same metric of think back to when you were juniors wanting just one school, I have to do that a bit myself and just like think back to 2021. It was hard to see the possibility of 2023 being this virus-free in its thinking. So yay, spring has sprung, and a huge congrats to the class of 2023, most of whom likely will have made up their final decisions before you hear from me again in a college episode at the very end of this month.
[3:45] Charlie Murphy: So we'll celebrate you for real with all of your finals to come. But just to say now, irrespective of what decisions you make and irrespective of your amazing results that we've seen come in so far, congrats on an awesome process, class of 2023, students and parents. And with that, let's get to David Williams from the University of Miami.
[4:09] Charlie Murphy: Well, we are so honored to be joined by David Williams of the University of Miami. David has a BM from that same university and 99% of an MM, he says. Performed in tons of ballet companies, has many theatrical credits, and is now a senior lecturer at the University of Miami, which is located in Coral Gables, Florida.
[4:37] Charlie Murphy: They have class sizes of about 14 to 16 and offer many degrees, BFAs and MT, BAs in theater arts, etc. David, welcome on the pod. How are you doing today?
[4:46] David Williams: Thank you. How are you doing?
[4:48] Charlie Murphy: I'm doing okay. So I gave that super brief overview of a bio. But I'd love to hear a little bit of like just your journey, and maybe you can hear about the 99% and the 1%.
[4:58] David Williams: Um, but your journey to Miami. I've always done theater ever since I was like four or five. And as a pianist, I was always really in demand to play the piano. You know, they abuse is the wrong word, but they abuse your talents in the theater.
[5:14] David Williams: Um, and so I've always been around it, but I've always been around classical music also. And for years and years and years, I was a working pianist, and just by sheer wonderful luck, a colleague here at UM asked me if I would do them the honor of coming and playing for what they called barriers at the time.
[5:37] David Williams: Which I said, sure, I'll do that. And as it turned out, the entire BFA program at the before I joined here had to do barriers, which was basically a jury, where every single one of them sang for the acting faculty two songs. So at the end of 400 hours, they said, hey, you're good at this. Would you like a job?
[5:55] David Williams: And thinking it would be, I don't know, a couple of months at best, has now turned into way over 20 years. Wow. And I find it the most wonderful thing in my life is to make the transition from pure music into music with words and theater. It's just what I live. I've always lived it, and this fell into my lap, and now I get to share it with BFA students, and nothing's better.
[6:26] Charlie Murphy: Um, so tell me a little bit about so in your experience of your 20 some years at Miami. What do you feel like makes a University of Miami student? What are the sort of unique qualities that you see in a lot of University of Miami students?
[6:39] David Williams: Well, I think the definition of unique is what I see, and it bears out every single time. We don't look for a type, we look for a diverse population in every definition of that. And I need to make sure that the person that I pick for our department is someone that I can live with, someone they can live with, that being me.
[7:01] David Williams: Um, and I'm very, very careful. It needs to be an example of humanity and someone who loves the idea of talking about theater. Someone who I know immediately wants to be challenged. And I don't care what that looks like, what that sounds like, the talent is obviously there, or we wouldn't be having this conversation.
[7:25] David Williams: But it really comes down to what I know is the right type of humanity isn't the right word, but what type of personality, what type of wonder of the world will fit us. One of the things that we also have to be very, very careful with in our BFA program is because we're located in a really academically challenging university.
[7:50] David Williams: And they look at those applications the same way they look at physicists and pre-med students. They don't separate out artists, which is great because I wind up with very, very smart students. And I don't think there's anything known as an overeducated actor. But there seems to be some difficulty in some very good art schools around the country, high schools, with making sure that that academic portion of their education is at the high level that we need.
[8:22] David Williams: And then they have to meet the talent requirements. And so there's a very small diagram of the perfect student for us. But if it's someone that comes in and displays, oh, I don't know, overtly diva behavior, it's not gonna work for us.
[8:40] Charlie Murphy: Um, I love that. And you will talk a little bit more in the second half about the audition process and the admissions process. Um, but I will say you mentioned that you take a lot of time with your students. And that I'll say that is one of the reasons I went, oh my gosh, I have to have David on.
[8:52] Charlie Murphy: I've been thinking of that for years because the number of times I'll be at Unifieds and people will come and go, I just had the greatest experience. This audition was so they took so much time with me, and I was like, uh-huh I've written that down for 10 years. You literally just made my day.
[9:05] David Williams: Um, I think it's something that I am proud of. I like doing this, it's important. And also I don't know why I wouldn't want to spend time with people who've spent so many years getting ready for this.
[9:16] David Williams: Um, I feel like I'm cheating them if I say thank you next. Yeah, there are schools that do it, and I respect them that go do it and with very little conversation pick a class and they feel comfortable with it. I cannot imagine spending four years with someone and not spending 10 minutes talking about it.
[9:29] David Williams: I can't afford to make a mistake with the small numbers. Uh-huh. That's right. I think some schools know they can take 150 kids and graduate X. But if you're getting 14 kids, it's, you know, I don't want to. UM is expensive. I don't want anybody to make a mistake.
[9:43] David Williams: And again, our theater world is difficult. Working in the theater, it takes a lot of stuff out of people. So I think we really should be the kindest people in the world and demonstrate that.
[9:55] Charlie Murphy: Let's get into a little bit of the curriculum. So, um, you know, if I'm spending four years at the University of Miami, how am I gonna come out changed? Let's say I come in, I'm an interesting person, I've got all the humanity, we have a great audition. What am I gonna work on over the series of four years, especially let's say it's a musical theater major, that's gonna sort of add skills to my repertoire?
[10:12] David Williams: I need to define something and then answer that question. Please. So we used to have two distinct tracks. We used to have an acting track and a musical theater track. What we found was that people who went through the musical theater track were taking the same acting classes as the acting students.
[10:34] David Williams: And the acting students weren't getting the music training. And the kids that were immediately graduated from us, it was the musical theater kids that were getting all the jobs, including the non-musical theater jobs. So we said, hmm, there's something wrong here.
[10:49] David Williams: And so now we call ourselves a comprehensive program. If you slit a couple of veins and did some DNA testing of all our kids, they are definitely musical theater. Their DNA reads musical theater. But we want kids that really want to study everything and are not afraid of it.
[11:08] David Williams: When I was a kid, the word triple threat was like something magical. Now it's just, you know, it's like the Olympics. A triple Salchow is nothing. And so now we want kids that come in with talent and want to study everything. In order, A, to understand more of the theater that we're doing, but also quite frankly, and I hate to put it in a financial way, but are more employable, period.
[11:36] David Williams: We talk about all the time. More of the money is in the musical theater world. Exactly. But if you look at the world right now and you watch some of the television franchises, my favorite, the Law and Order ones, they're all musical theater kids that are the stars of these shows.
[11:51] David Williams: Um, there's something going on in the world right now that people are understanding that musical theater is not some sort of cheap stepchild of the acting world. Um, we actually know a lot of style, and I think that's what we do. We teach style.
[12:06] David Williams: That said, we don't want kids that are coming in that are perfect at everything. Well, I would love that, but there's no reason to go to school. There's no reason to go to school. Um, we find that if kids come in as a strong actor and a little shy of their singing voice, they tend to work harder.
[12:26] David Williams: And the truth is, I'm looking at my current junior class. There are a couple of people in there that came not thinking they could sing, and quite frankly, are out singing everybody. That pressure, if that's the right word, I think that that might be a little dismissive, really serves these kids and they work harder.
[12:46] Charlie Murphy: Um, the same thing goes for dance or movement. Take me through a little bit if you want to get a little granular in terms of the freshman through sophomore, sophomore in the junior, senior year. What is the trajectory of what I'm learning as through the four-year?
[13:01] David Williams: So much. Um, we are in a major university, but if you look at just the curricula for the university, you're gonna say for our department within the university, how are we operating?
[13:13] David Williams: Um, I have friends that run programs everywhere, and I look at the curricula and I chuckle a little bit because their lives are so much easier than the lives here. We have been doing this for so long, we don't actually, how do I put this? Uh, I'll just say it.
[13:27] David Williams: We don't exactly tell the truth on our credit value. So our classes within the BFA look like a pure conservatory, but of course, as we start going into the sophomore year, we start adding the required university courses, and we can get more into that later.
[13:43] David Williams: Yes, we do. So, my freshmen, fresh folks, let's let's degender that word once and for all, are taking somewhere between 12 and 14 classes, which if you were looking at a regular university, of course, is impossible because they would have to be three, two, three credits a piece, and they would overload.
[13:59] David Williams: Most of our classes on paper read one credit, even though that's not actually the content, the contact hours.
[14:08] David Williams: So, uh, we take everything in the freshman year. We take movement, singing, um, dance, voice and speech, private voice lessons, um, acting, um, stagecraft, uh, you know, and X, Y, and Z as well, whereas some other universities that the credit values read accurately can only take four or five classes max.
[14:31] Charlie Murphy: Uh-huh.
[14:32] David Williams: So we basically grab you as a fresh folk and start you off, I think around nine o'clock in the morning. Um, and then depending on what your crew assignments are, we would finish around 6:30 and pick up again at seven for those six weeks that you're in crew or technical support for the shows. Then come the second year, you're guaranteed casting, and so your evenings are taken for 12 weeks per semester. And then the percentage of theater classes as opposed to university classes starts to switch. Not by much, but by the junior and the senior year, you're taking all the academics that are required, which are not just general academics. We have a different way of doing it. We have something called cognates, where you make basically little mini minors, which is the definition of a liberal education, and that's another thing that I spoke about earlier. The requirements of the university are vast, and so are the requirements of the BFA. So that also talks particularly to a unique type of student.
[15:41] Charlie Murphy: Yeah.
[15:42] David Williams: Let's stand on that. I'd love to hear a little bit about what are those potential minors that, you know, maybe are minors that people commonly get, or what are my possibilities if I want to get a minor, or even, God forbid, a double major. Is that possible within Miami?
[15:54] David Williams: Well, possibilities are vast, but also the BFA schedule is rather tyrannical. So there are ways of obtaining what you want. We have the discussions with our students. Um, do you need the minor or do you need the classwork? What do you want? Or particularly since we have very academically gifted students coming into our program, what are you coming with? What are your APs? What did you take summer classes? Did you take early university classes? The more you can open that up, the more possible it is to get a minor. And in some cases, depending on what you choose, communications is, uh, we have a great communications school in the university and also become a major. We've had kids have psych majors.
Um, those are rare, but again, it depends on the student. A lot of students come in with a great idea to minor and double major, and by the time the theater bug is completely taken over their lives, that importance falls off. It's very important to some parents, and I get that, but I can't promise anything without being able to look very carefully at the transcript of a student coming in. Um, I think it's important, but also the work of the theater is so vast and so time-consuming that I will say to some parents, well, your child really needs to sleep and eat sometime.
[17:28] Charlie Murphy: Right.
[17:28] David Williams: They're already triple majoring in musical theater.
[17:31] Charlie Murphy: Yeah, you really are, if not quadrupling.
[17:33] David Williams: However, you know, I love academics myself, and I would do that to myself as well. But we need to be kinder and gentler to ourselves and the world right now. And so, um, it's all possible. Um, communications, lots of design elements are possible in minors and majors. Um, what else is out there that people do? Oh, an announcing, you know, television announcing, sports announcing. Um, a few kids have looked into education. The university is massive. Uh, you name it, it's here, but I can't promise that because obviously our BFA requirement is non-negotiable, right? And the time that we teach our non-negotiable classes are the prime time for the university. But it still happens. Um, it's not an easy thing, but the kids that are successful at that are very successful at that and are usually graduating on the top of the university at the same time as doing the musical theater.
[18:41] Charlie Murphy: You mentioned it being comprehensive, which is, I think that's a great word. Is there a discipline of the three that you spend either more credit hours or where you feel like there's more focus? Or maybe another way to ask it is if do people think of a University of Miami student as being particularly strong in one of the three disciplines?
[18:55] David Williams: Yeah, I do, and I believe it strongly because I think it overrides everything. And I suspect most places think this. It's an acting program, first, second, third, fourth, one hundredth. Um, again, the DNA is musical theater, but our students are actors. Um, and you can spot them a million miles away. And maybe a better word for than actor, I think, although I don't know any better word than actor. Um, a person who understands style and is able to move through style. So a stylist, someone who can move from Shakespeare into Sondheim into, I don't know, a tap number. It's style, it's all acting, it's all storytelling, but it's understanding the rules that we have learned throughout the years, and then deciding what to do with those rules. But we're firm believers, learn the rules and then break them, but don't break them before you know them.
[19:50] Charlie Murphy: You started a little bit of there, but if you wouldn't mind, just give me a little bit more of a definition of imagine if I'm a parent listener and I hear style and I'm thinking like fashion or whatever. You know, what do we mean when we say style in the theater?
[20:01] David Williams: For me at least, style is the set of rules or the set of conventions that make a certain type of performance, either being a song, um, a dance or a play, what are the rules that we all can understand that is the operating force for that? So we could say Sondheim, here are the rules, and if we obey those, we're actually performing stylistically correct. But when we know those, we also know what rules don't apply to other things. And I think that's the big thing. We all say we really like X, Y, and Z, but we need to actually go much deeper and go, why don't we like it? Oh, maybe we don't understand why we don't like it. Oh, I didn't understand what those rules were. What’s the umbrella under which that's operating?
And we see it all the time, and we accept it for everything in our lives. You know, we understand what a commercial on television is that operates under a certain style. We understand what Deadpool is, and if we expect a Deadpool to be Schindler's List, we would all be very disappointed in both movies. And so that's style. Once you get what's going on, you understand it. And I don't know. I think style gets a bad rap, that word right now. And so maybe that's why I like the idea of it's just the rules that govern it. And with those, they're mutable. We can go left or right, but we need to know what they are and then decide what to do with it. And I am on my soapbox on this, so forgive me.
[21:44] Charlie Murphy: No, we want to. That was so well said. I think it's really helpful. It's helpful for, I think, our listeners to hear, um, philosophically, also that's how you talk about this kind of stuff. Um, I’d love to talk about dance a little bit. So if I come in as a dancer, maybe I'm really advanced, or if I come in and I'm really not advanced, how does that work in terms of do I work within my freshman sophomore cohort, or am I leveled in terms of across the classes? How does that work?
[22:07] David Williams: Um, we used to level, but as we added more acting and more movement and other classes, we found that that was causing us problems with our scheduling. And it just made it impossible. We didn't, there's just not, there's a very finite amount of space. But then we thought about it very carefully and realized we don't level anything else. Um, and no one is coming in at the same level in any aspect of their training. And we happen to have a really great dance teacher that can teach, just like really great acting teachers. Um, you know, we don't change classes because someone is a better Shakespearean than someone else. So philosophically, I haven't found it necessary. I suppose if we went above 20, I think we would have a different conversation. But at 20, I trust my dance teachers implicitly.
[23:07] David Williams: Um, absolutely to be able to totally make sense. You know, and it's a different construction of a program to your point when you have 14 students versus when you have 80, you know, it's just a different absolutely at 80, you not only do you need to level, you need to cut those numbers. Many people don't start, but at 14 we're in the safe zone.
[23:28] Charlie Murphy: Um, I'd love to talk a little bit about maybe that senior year, or it certainly could start earlier in terms of how you prepare your students for the launch into the business from the idea of a showcase or meeting agents, how you um learn about that part of the world. I love to see you, like, how am I gonna be prepared to launch?
[23:44] David Williams: So, yes, we do showcase. In fact, just a few days ago, I came back from New York and we had a really extraordinarily successful showcase that I am incredibly proud of our seniors. And they were seen by a lot of people. And so that's not generally the rule anymore, but we figured out a way to make that happen. Um, but how we prepare kids for the industry, I think is from day one in class. The expectations are we're gonna learn the protocols, the, again, here we go, the style, the rules of the theater. And the expectations are in classes will be in from minute go enforcing that. We will be talking about this is the reason we're learning this. This is the reason you're going to say this, this is the reason I'm gonna slate, because it's gonna show up in four years.
And quite frankly, if we're not practicing professionalism for four years, it puts an undue burden on that senior class to figure things out. We're doing it from the minute go, and you know, we're actors, we perform what we rehearse. So if we're rehearsing it for four years, we're so far ahead. It's not a challenge. Like, how do I talk to people? Um, that said, we have everything in the curricula that leads up to it. Showcases in the last semester. Um, the book building for that showcase is in the first semester of the senior year, and auditioning is in their junior year. Uh, but before that happens, they were already building their books. And there is not a class that I start without saying, has anybody thought of any material for the showcase?
And I'm talking about first semester kids. Um, and I like that because I love how it changes over the years. Things that they sure that they came in as first-year students that they thought that was the greatest piece of theater and they're gonna do for the showcase, all of a sudden becomes just something that they would never dream of ever putting on stage again. Um, and that's one of the joys watching the growth over the four years and seeing, but seeing what seeing where they're going, and I can see it, and that's for me at least one of the joys of the job. I know the difference between a first, second, third, and fourth-year student. It's so obvious to me, and um, and it's obvious to the students as well. Everybody looks at the seniors with awe.
[26:12] Charlie Murphy: Uh-huh.
[26:12] David Williams: And then, you know, and then we'll never be able to make that. And every single class, it happens. Um, you know, that's one of my lucky positions. I’m teaching all of the classes, I mean, not all classes, but I teach all classes, and um I can see that. And it's wonderful to see the kids acknowledge that, and they all do, they all do.
[26:39] Charlie Murphy: Um, I'd love to talk a little bit about where the kind of breakdown of where your students come from, like all over the country and in the world, and then also kind of where do they end up. So you mentioned there are actors first, so, um, we're not all actors first, but that's the structure of the program. So how many end up in New York, LA, around the country, how many stay in Florida? Um, I'd love to hear both where they come from and then where do they end up?
[27:00] David Williams: Yeah, they come from around the country and around the world, mostly, mostly I would say from the northeast part of our country. We used to have a huge contingent of people from the west side of our land. Um, again, it depends on what these auditions look like, uh, you know, and what the give and take. So they're coming from everywhere. Um, not as much necessarily from our home state. Um, and I think that has to do with, uh, people have wanderlust and they should go maybe someplace that they don't live already. That doesn't mean I don't have a lot of Florida students or Miami students, but the majority of our students are not. Um, where they go again depends on that class makeup. And I'd like to say as a positive, uh, every class that I've ever had that we've ever had doesn't look like, sound like, sing like, act like any class above or below it.
It is, there's just not a type that that's filled. And so whatever that class zeitgeist is, whatever's in the water when they come as their first semester students, um, they tend to move in that miasma and they tend to go in the same place.
[28:16] David Williams: So a couple years ago, almost all of them wound up in LA, uh, polling the seniors that are graduating any day now. Well, while we were in New York, every last hand went up that said they were moving to New York. And so it's like, okay, this is interesting. I'd like to figure out how that happens. But I but more importantly, what I think it says is that the students that matriculate here feel that they have in fact done what the program says, comprehensively taught them, and they can go anywhere. Um a few kids stay in Miami. The tech kids tend to stay in Miami because they're hireable immediately. Um I'll go ahead and say what everybody in the country knows. Um, our tech students are so valuable.
Um and and and hireable at a rate that surpasses actors. I hate saying that for actors, but it's just happens to be the truth. So our kids in turn are our tech kids intern in Miami and tend to wind up in some of the really great theater positions here. I I know there's also a thriving you know scene in in Miami, especially if you're in the independent film world. You know, one of some of my schoolmates from Carnegie Mellon ended up in Miami, and and my best friend who's a Juilliard grad, he was from Miami, ended up back in Miami working in Miami. Like that there's really there is a world there in the in terms of uh the art scene that that's real.
[29:37] David Williams: Yeah, it is, and it's getting bigger by the second. As a shameless plug, um, I'm directing a musical right now by my newest, newest, newest best friend in the world, Polly Penn, who's written a lot of very small, marvelous chamber um pieces, and we're going to be performing it at the end of this month at the Paris Art Museum, which is maybe one of the most beautiful modern art buildings that is built in the last 20 years. And the noise that this is making in this city, uh, because it's just an extraordinary opportunity for everybody involved, and they've never done theater in this building. Um it it and everybody's interested. It it it's actually flabbergasting to me, the number of emails that I'm getting.
Oh wow, it it's not insular the community. Everybody's like, what are you doing? What are you doing? What are you doing? What are you doing? Um, which is really it it it's it's it's heartwarming. I I think it Miami is turning into something that it has not been for a while.
[30:38] David Williams: Um, I want to do a little section on um people choosing your school. So now let's imagine for our seniors who are listeners, I've senior parents listening as well, some of whom may have been accepted and they're trying to make final decisions and all that. Uh I know one of the big determining factors, you mentioned cost, that it's a very expensive university. Um we looked up, it's like something like the tuition's around 58,000, I think is the cloud where we were last quoted. It's going up, up, up. Um what what are we talking about in terms of like stuff like scholarship? So, you know, so many of our students, they are very strong academic students, so how it works with academic scholarships, and then also stuff like talent scholarship. How does that work if we're trying to bring that cost down?
[31:15] David Williams: It's a combo platter. So there is a uh we supply our scholarship recommendations based on what we saw in the auditions at the same time that the financial aid package goes to the university and the and the admissions office. Uh it's a complicated uh process, I'll tell you that. Um, looks at the academic portions of it, and then that each one of those are rated, and somehow they they come up with some sort of calculus that uh and I I think thankfully I'm not privy to. What the university does is meet percentages of need, and they've been doing it exceedingly well for our students in the last, I don't know, 10 years. But I do know when I look at renewal of scholarships that the university itself is meeting it.
They're meeting it in a variety of ways. Some of it is direct financial aid, some of it is based on high scholastic achievement and also high artistic achievement. So when you put those three things together, depending on what the what the financial papers look like, the university will figure out what to do with that from there. In short, not a single financial aid package looks like the same for any person. It is each uniquely drawn. So if you hear that um student A got X, it's really impossible to compare to student B. Um no one, no one really can know anybody else's true financial situation. I hate saying that, but I think it makes everything safer and quite frankly more democratic. Um that said, again, the university is doing a very, very good job of meeting needs. Um I'll just go ahead and say it for the millionth time in my life. The talent and the academic excellence that students come in with pays off.
[32:18] Charlie Murphy: Yep. Totally.
[33:19] David Williams: Well, and and so I know the cost office is a big uh area in terms of why choose people choose or don't choose a school. I'd love to hear about like what are, you know, when you're making your decision, you're you know, you're hearing your final decisions. I guess that's really now speaking toward last year since you haven't heard most of your final decisions for this year. But what makes a student say, you know what? This is what made me, this is what's cinched me. This is what clinched my decision. And then what also maybe if they say, hey, I'm actually going a different direction, do you hear feedback saying, actually, I don't, this is why I didn't choose my hand.
[33:46] David Williams: Yeah, I I I have the answers to that. Um not I'm really not patting myself on the back, but it's just something I think we do really, really well at the audition. I I think we are very we're very good at that and we we speak the truth, and and that's the number one portion of it. The second is when they come to this campus and they see other students. Our students are very warm, um genial human beings that are very much vested in what the classes under them are gonna look like. In our New York auditions and the unified auditions, we have so many um New York actors that have graduated from us that really, quite frankly, I think the right word is insist on coming to the audition so they can talk to possible um students.
It's it's an embarrassment of riches, quite frankly. That also, like they they hear kids that have, you know, graduated 10, 15 years out just going, you need to come here. And then when they come to school, they see the current crop of students and they speak to them, and then they sit on the classes and they go, Oh yeah. And then um, I'll spare everybody, but outside my window, it is really the singularly the most beautiful place on earth. Yeah, um, our campus is gorgeous. And as a side note, we we were de-homed last year. Our our old building came down, and just as we're speaking, I don't know why there's quiet right now, but the foundations are being laid for our new complex, which I'm very much looking forward to.
Um so we're gonna have spanking brand new um facilities on basically what looks like a brand new campus. Um it it's it's hard to say no to it. Um everything points to that. And you know, I and I think when kids say no, it it tends to be financial. It does. We just can't meet their needs. Right. Um and and it hurts me. It it truly does. Um I have no say on what the financial aid office says when you know someone who has three kids in school is being looked at X, Y, and Z the same way. Um, and I I'll do everything, I'll write all sorts of uh of notes, but it it comes down to the legality of the financial aid papers.
[36:12] Charlie Murphy: Do you experience, I mean, this is a a brand new um issue if it were to come up for you, but do you experience any in like our current political climate, any families saying, like, hey, I'm I'm nervous about sending my kid to Florida, maybe if they're from New York or from California or you know, I haven't heard from parents, but I have fielded this question. And I'll just be honest, I'm worried about in this state. However, we are a private institution in a very liberal city. Um and we are the theater department. And so we have been dealing with these issues since since the dark ages. Um I believe that everyone is safe on this campus.
[36:54] David Williams: We're gonna take a short break, and on the back end, we're gonna talk a little bit about the audition and admissions process a bit more.
[37:00] Charlie Murphy: So we're back in a flash. We are back with David Williams, and we're gonna talk a little bit about that magical audition process that he loves so much. Um we're gonna talk a little bit about what you think makes a great audition for you. So what do you want to see in those 10 minutes, 15 minutes, however long you're spending with the student?
[37:19] David Williams: I don't want to be boring, but I I want to everybody says they want to see the person. I I really do. I I don't want to see something that's so highly polished it just looks like a rehearsal or or or memorization. Uh I I don't care if it's perfect or not. I I want to be able to at the end of it ask questions about it. How did you choose that? Why did you choose that? I want to be able to say, how about try this? And it's probably wrong, but let me see you be wrong. Um so the rehearsal, the the audition really lets me know. Are you really gonna do what we need you to do in the theater? Are you going to be able to right away accept that you're just wrong? And and and and learn from it. High school students are just so programmed.
They gotta give perfect tests, they gotta do perfect monologues. It's so it it it it's so they're so tightly wound. I just I want someone who's relaxed and go, hey, give this a whirl and assume that it's wrong, but assume that you can do it. And someone who can actually sit back and when I when I ask them how did you do? Have some sort of answer, some sort of honest to God answer. Not like, well, you know, when I'm performing, I I don't know anything. I get that. I I, you know, I'm a performer as well. But I also I know what the experience for me was. That that question, I'll say that question is one that uh I for so many years I've heard, and people always think it's a trick question. Like, what did he want me to say?
What was I supposed to say? I was like, I think you should answer honestly. They're like, No, what I was what was this a good answer? Was that a good answer? Any answer is good. No answer is not good. There's fine secret.
[39:04] David Williams: Um, it's also the sense of play. Someone who could smile and come in the room and and okay, I'm gonna get on my soapbox again. Uh, material that's appropriate to age. I I may be old, but uh not that old. Uh, and also uh, you know, these these people who are auditioning are are still very, very young. Acknowledge that. Don't don't give material that just I'm gonna have that is gonna make me uncomfortable to work with you on it. Um and there's so much material out there. Second soapbox. Ask your coaches. Does everybody do this? Now I'll hear the same monologue over and over again. But boy am I interested when someone has found something that maybe nobody else has done. And there's so many plays, there's there's there's so many things to look at.
That tells me there's a sense of wonder about our art form that they've that a student has looked and searched and read a thousand books. That's a student, not someone who would say, Here's two monologues, figure out which one you want. Anybody could do that.
[40:16] Charlie Murphy: Can you think of an example?
[40:18] David Williams: I know it's putting you on the spot here, but can you think of an example of a student who, you know, in in that revealing of yourself, where you went, they seemed, you mentioned you really want them to seem easy and seem willing to try some things that are wrong. Can you think of example of an audition that was particularly that way? Um, and what made it really work for you?
[40:34] David Williams: I think a student that when when a question is asked of why, why do you want to go to university, why did you do that monologue, and just something that that there's an instant trust that the answer that would not have been an answer for anybody else in the room. Uh-huh. I I I felt safe to do it. I felt that I or I need to get away from where I am right now to feel safe to be able to be who I am, so I can feel safe to be able to portray things on stage. And I hear that a lot. Um, I, you know, students that come from some places in this country that it's hard for them to be themselves for a variety of reasons. So desperately won out. And you can feel that desperation in the material that they've they've chosen and how they need a they need a home to be able to say it, which is what theater is a home to be able to speak.
And when they express that, and then we try the monologue again right after that expression of of honesty, they go, Oh wow, I can channel all of this. It happens all the time. Or you just get a just an answer so out of left field about why they chose something or how they chose to portray it. It's just like, wow, this is someone who's thinking deeply, way beyond this is what I was told, this is the right way to do it. It it it's it's just so fascinating to me. You you hear, aha, artist in the making. This is this is someone worthy of of doing this. This is someone I'd love to teach because it surprises me.
[42:14] Charlie Murphy: If you had to guess, because you mentioned, uh, at the beginning, uh, we were talking about this, that the talent has to be there, right? If you had to guess how much in terms of the decision artistically for you to come to a yes or a no, how much of that is based on the talent you're seeing in the songs and the monologues versus some of those intangibles of how they take adjustments, how they do answer interview questions? How much is more about the musical and acting talent that you're seeing, and how much is more about what kind of student they are?
[42:42] David Williams: It's interesting because I couldn't give you a percentage or a ratio. I think, uh, what forces me into the in-depth portion of the interview is the obvious talent. If I see something that triggers something in me, that I guess that word is not usable in a positive way anymore, but it's something that sets off my brain wanting to know something about the person in front of me. The talent has just been checked off. And I think people get worried that sometimes maybe I'll hear two songs or two monologues.
[43:10] Charlie Murphy: Right.
[43:19] David Williams: And sometimes I'll hear five seconds and all I want to do is talk. Uh-huh. It's if I really want to upset myself or if I'm feeling particularly in need of depression, I will open up and read any like the college boards or the, you know, the chat boards to find out what I want. It's invariably wrong. Well, actually. I want that. I didn't know I wanted that. It's always wrong. I just, you know, why can't we interview someone just because of the person in front of us? I can't follow a script for this. I follow a script for a play, not for an interview. I need to know things that you're gonna tell me that someone else is not. So I'll hear an audition and I will determine the course of my questioning from that.
Uh-huh. And it could be like the scholarships, every person is going to get a different question, different adjustments based on what you're saying. It's going to be individual. But right, isn't that what we do? I mean, it maybe it's not everybody. I think it should be, but I think the practicality of larger programs make this difficult.
[44:25] Charlie Murphy: I think the other thing that makes our program really very good at what it does is I don't have to teach the same thing over and over and over and over and over again. If you come in and sing a song, I'm only teaching you. Uh-huh. And it will not be the same lesson for that song, even though someone else sings it the same way. And the same thing for the material that we choose to cover. We look at our classes and go, we have 13 of these people. What do these 13 people need? And it goes also into what's most difficult for us picking our season selection because it's not picked on what we as a faculty just I'd love to direct. It's well, let's look at what everybody's done, put it down on a massive flow chart and say, okay, David has only been in a Shakespeare and a small musical.
David needs to be in a large musical. Sally has never been in an ensemble in a musical. Sally's going there. Bert has never been in a play. And so we figure that out, and we figure it out because we truly consider casting as part of the curricula, and it's required, or you can't graduate. And so I think this is very important. And so the choice of material in class as well as the choice of material that we cover in production is solely based on the student in front of us.
[45:52] Charlie Murphy: Yep. Well, another advantage of a smaller program.
[45:54] David Williams: Yes. You can do that. I mean, you cannot do that if you have 200 students. It's not possible to consider on that level.
[45:59] Charlie Murphy: You can't possibly.
[46:01] David Williams: You can't. Um, well in terms of the admission. So let's say the artistically you say, yes, I love the student. Uh, audition was good with the songs and monologues. They answer great interview questions. I really like them artistically or holistically from the audition. Now, as we look at the, um, uh, university, how does that work then with admission? With you mentioned they have to have really strong academics, um, SATs, essays. How do those things factor in if artistically you like the student?
[46:26] David Williams: Completely different beast, the admissions department. So we will, in a perfect world, it all happens as a unit. However, that perfect world is hard to define anymore. So I will do my auditions and the university gets the applications. I will have my list ready, they will have their list ready. We'll look at the Venn diagram and then we'll go, okay, da-da-da-da-da-da-da-da-da. What about this kid? What about that kid? And so there will be a conversation on the kids that are not inside the academic bubble. So you're gonna say, oh, they're a little below, I really love them. Can I get them out? Whether or not that happens, because, uh, I think fortunately for me, maybe unfortunately, I'm not sure.
I'm not supposed to know their academic history when I audition them. Uh-huh. If I did, I think it would taint how I do the auditions. I would get preconceived notions. So then it comes, and then we go, okay, but this kid is this. Oh dear, uh, they can't write. Um, let's see what the veracity of that is. Um, and there's some trading back and forth. Um, and then we figure out how to make the class. And we don't operate as a conservatory. I can't say, okay, I'm offering you a place. It has to be a general university offer. But so you will look at the academics yourself, but only after the audition. So before the audition, you won't have read the essays or any of that kind of stuff, but you might do that afterwards.
What I have asked for in our supplemental application, but it will not be granular, and it'll also probably be self-reported. And so it's not anything that the university is going to look for. Now they look very seriously at our recommendations. There's no question about that. And I think this actually may be one of the most important things I'll say today. Um, the university's application pool each year goes up. The university as a whole, uh-huh, geometrically. Um, there are tens and tens and tens of thousands more applicants each year. And so they look at it in a they look at it more and more stringently. Um, they're very good with us. Um, we're a small little school in a massive university, and I take up an inordinate amount of their time, probably to their chagrin, but hey, I'm not shy.
Um, but it gets done. And every year I look at an incoming class and go, wow, how did that happen? It seems like magic, quite frankly. Um, and knock some sort of wood. Um, they're remarkable classes. I have some of the best classes I've seen in years. And you mentioned that in general, as the academic department is looking at the grades, SATs, etc., that they are judging them as if they're applying for physics. That really there's not a, they're not getting a little bit of a lower standard academically because it's the theater department. They're looking at them the exact same.
[49:44] David Williams: I don't know. The rules for admission is always in flux, and COVID, you know, that thing that happened, um, put everything in a strange way. Like many universities, the SAT/ACT scores were you could submit them. This year, I think maybe the last one where it was is optional. Uh-huh. Um, GPA is important. What school? And just for our listeners, sorry, this year meaning last year, by the way, with SAT/ACT. You're saying that for last year's C that these juniors will have to take that.
[50:14] Charlie Murphy: I literally, as we're speaking, hit submit on my final, my final list for this year.
[50:20] David Williams: Yeah.
[50:21] Charlie Murphy: All right. We're gonna read them all out loud on the pod, tell us who they are.
[50:27] David Williams: I, uh, will be fired faster than the speed of light. Um, and I wouldn't do that because it kills me. I’m gonna just go out. It kills me. We've seen so I, I so thank everybody who's prepared kids around the country. This year's crop of applicants has been extraordinarily high. I, I, it's, I've seen so many kids. Um, and I would take if I could, I would take a class of 60, and I could easily do it. I can't, and it kills me to make a decision between one extraordinary student and the next. It's my least favorite thing.
[51:05] Charlie Murphy: Well, you're leading me perfectly into my next question. Like, because we hear that all the time. You know, I've heard this from, uh, you know, from our professors at Carnegie Mellon. They used to say, we could take a class of 80 or 100, who, you know, some number, but then they end up taking, you know, 12 musical theater, 12 actors or whatever.
[51:19] David Williams: Yeah.
[51:19] Charlie Murphy: And so how do you, how do you, when you're real, you have 60 students who have earned their place, 60 students who are good enough to get in in your mind? How do you get from 60 to 14 or 15 or whatever you're gonna try to yield exactly?
[51:31] David Williams: Well, I do it as if I were, and I, and it's only at this point that I do this. Uh, their headshots go down or on the floor or up on a board, and we go, okay, what do we need to serve our department? What plays have we not been able to do? What are we missing? What, what, how will this class not be a replica of any other class? That's a little vague, but I guess if I were going to winnow it down to a couple of words, I think we're casting. Uh-huh. And then how does it work in the process? Obviously, no, you're not going to yield 100% of who you admit then. How does that work with you in the waitlist process then of going those 60 students probably got in some other schools too? And you're trying to have them say yes to your school. And then how does it work as you adjust the casting? You know, um, as people say no, and as people come off other wait lists, et cetera.
[52:33] David Williams: That I don't want to open up a floodgate of this, but I think students who have been very good at writing and letting us know where their desires are, and being honest, I got into Carnegie Mellon, and I didn't get into UMish or something like that. But you, you, you Miami is my number one choice right now. That information, if it reads honestly, um, is really helpful in putting things into order. Now, I’m hesitant to say that because then all of a sudden every kid will be writing, and then we can't figure that out. But I think that the secret to getting into schools is being completely honest with your needs, financial, academic, um, emotional, figuring out what type of school actually serves you the best.
There is a remarkable difference between the styles that schools use to teach, but all great BFA programs, the truth is you're going to graduate with a great degree and the ability to do something. It's how you get there. And so reading these letters from students or applicants lets me know right away. I think this is the right, this student is expressing the right kind of, um, of, um, words that feel right for a student here. I mean, I've been doing this a long time, and I can often tell within one or two schools where someone's gonna wind up. And my ultimate thought on that is it, we cannot, we're doing all these applicants a disservice if we let anybody wrap their dream school into one bundle and the truth.
They, there's self-roll to be gone. The numbers are against people. It’s, I hate saying that. There are just so many kids wanting to do this, but everybody will wind up in the school if they do their due diligence. They will wind up in the right place. It is not a career where you can ever have that kind of control. No, it's out. But if you get accepted, I, it terrifies me and it doesn't happen often, but it's like, oh, I didn't know you were coming to school. I've never seen you since your audition. Uh-huh. If you can afford it, go to the schools you've been accepted at. I know my school's not right for everybody. I know who it is right for. And you know kids that need to get lost in a big city and be away from everything, they need to be in New York or Chicago. But kids that need other things will know what they get here.
[55:11] Charlie Murphy: Keep looking out of your beautiful window as you're saying this. I can see that you're taking in this gorgeous campus and it's making me jealous. I want to wrap up a little bit. Um, you mentioned, um, some of the changes of like maybe so now the SATs are going to be required and some of the things that as we emerge from the kind of into this post-pandemic world as I've been saying it that the pandemic is not completely over. But as we emerge from it, right? Um, what is carrying forward for you? Is there anything in terms of virtual auditions, um, that's keeping forward any of the sort of, um, progress that Miami may have made in terms of, um, racial equity or in terms of some of the conversations that have been happening for the past two, three years? What are we taking forward out of the pandemic moment?
[55:55] David Williams: I'm taking so much out of it. I think we cannot, we cannot and will not get rid of the possibility of virtual auditions. I think it's important. I think the industry is doing it. However, however, there is something that is intangible about being one-on-one with someone that I find really important.
[56:19] David Williams: Now, granted, there are people around the country and around the world that just can't do it. And to the part of the diversity, yes, and that plays into it there. I would like people from the rest of the world to have the opportunity to be able to do this, and the only way, maybe, is to do the virtual. And also the fiscal, it costs a lot of money to go do all these auditions. And so I'm not the fiscal portion of it is irrelevant to me. It's making sure, and quite frankly, you and I have been speaking for a couple of days right now, and we definitely understand each other, and there's something valuable here. But there's something a little bit different. There's a power imbalance between auditor and auditioner that I think is more easily broken down when we're one-on-one and they can realize yes, we're relaxed.
Let us be honest. That's not to say that Zoom and its friends are not a great tool, but I don't think it's the best way to audition. But our industry is using it and to an extent, right? So I'm not willing to throw it out. The diversity thing, I don't know how to fix it, other than to start way back at a very early age in early education. But it is vital. If we as theater people cannot put on stories that look like the world, I don't know what we're doing. And our university is doing a lot to make that happen. And I have great hopes that we are making great strides there. It's so vital. It is just the number one thing that's on my mind. How do we tell stories that are worthy of being heard and worthy of being told and the ones that are necessary to be told and heard?
[58:29] David Williams: And maybe I'd love to give us some advice specifically to our parent listeners. You know, maybe if I'm a parent of a junior, especially, I'm beginning my research, and I'm trying to put together my college list, and how am I gonna, you know, I really want to help my child as they're moving forward into the pre-screen season and auditions, etc. So what advice would we have to those parents who are just embarking on this process? So much, quite frankly. None of what I'm gonna say is tongue-in-cheek, although I think it may come off humorously. Relax. Find people that you can trust to instruct your children to get them ready, to truly trust them, and not wrap your parental self-worth up in this.
I often see in the unified parents who are just making things much too stressful for their students and quite frankly for other kids in the hallways. I'm saying this most sincerely, it doesn't help. I would prefer that parents stay on their own floor. I'm being serious here, and let their children be children who are auditioning for the theater. They don't need to be professional auditors. That holds for me at least. I'm sure I would love to see a perfect audition, but it is not what I'm looking for. I would like as much relaxation to come in so honesty can come out when people are so stressed in an already stressed situation. My heart breaks for these kids, and that's my number one suggestion.
Let the kids be honest to what they're capable of doing, and that will happen. Any type of—I came from a mother who was, "You are gonna practice," and that was fine, but not when I was auditioning or in school. It dawned on me that I needed to do that on my own. And it may have been the smartest thing I ever did as a young human being, and I'm a firm believer in that. And you know, there are some great parents out there that I adore, and they're very important, but I'm really only interested in the audition and the human that's auditioning. The other stuff, and I gotta say that resume, I love having it, but I love it mostly for the headshot so I can keep track. It's important to some schools; it's important maybe for the academic portion, but for me, I find everything in the audition. I don't need to be told that somebody's daughter or son or other just won an X, Y, and Z award. I don't need that. I'll just see it in the room.
[1:01:35] David Williams: Exactly. And I think that's really also something. You don't need to sell. I don't need to be sold anything. I think the kid is going to audition, and that's it. I love the phrase parental self-worth. That's a new—that's a, you know, I've asked us now of whatever, have 40 some schools. That's a new phrase that I think is so smart. Well, David, I thank you so much for the time. If people want to check out more stuff about Miami, where's the best place for them to go?
[1:01:59] David Williams: To the University of Miami Department of Theatre Arts website. Or you can send us an email and get in touch with me. It would be my pleasure. We take this—this may be the most important job I have.
[1:02:11] Charlie Murphy: Yeah, we love it. That contact info will be in the show notes. We'll have links to check out everything that people need to know. Well, David, thank you so much for the time today. This was really such a pleasure. I enjoyed this immensely. I truly did. I could talk about my program forever apparently.
[1:02:19] Charlie Murphy: Oh hey, now I hope you enjoyed that interview with David. He is so warm and easy to chat with, and you can really tell he's been doing this for many years. Not only his intimate knowledge of the process, but some of those specific insights in terms of pitfalls people have fallen into in the past really speak toward his many years of experience. There are about 12 takeaways I want to do from this episode, but I do have to leave some meat on the bone for future podcasts. And I am blessedly realizing how many of these things we have at least somewhat touched on in previous episodes. By next year, I think this takeaway section might just be like a full glossary pointing you to different previous episodes where I'm just adding footnotes or little additional comments.
For those who are newer to the pod, please listen to the end of our Texas State acting pod with Neil Patrick Stewart or University of Arizona with Danny Gurwin to hear a bit more about the confusion between the way different schools will use the word conservatory in liberal arts. I thought David navigated that really well and very interestingly, Miami being a school we would call a BFA liberal arts school, but it's definitely confusing with different language for different schools and how they think about categorizing themselves.
[1:03:38] Charlie Murphy: I've also talked before about chat boards. I thought it was really funny him talking about how chat boards identified him. So check out our Indiana University episode where we talk about that. I appreciated David's take on them. Similarly, I love the way he phrased the willingness to be wrong when given an adjustment. Or maybe if we translate that into MTCA language, it would be not holding the piece so tightly in needing to be right, which leaves room for the magical slash transcendent work to be a possibility. We outlined that a bit in our Syracuse episode with Thom Miller, so feel free to listen back to that if you want to hear all about adjustments. I also feel like we've talked in a number of ways about his parental advice of not letting too much of your own self-worth be wrapped up in your child.
I think that's great advice and very eloquently phrased, and I underline that as a note to my future parental self. So please listen back to those episodes if you want more on those topics, as I think all of them, which we heard today, are worthy of a deeper dive.
[1:04:37] Charlie Murphy: But today I just want to do two small takeaways aimed specifically at any class of 2023 listeners who are checking this out right as they're potentially making their final decision. We had a nice long takeaway from our SCAT episode two weeks ago about the budgeting of hours that schools use. And I just want to clarify an addendum to that based on what David said here. When you're evaluating curriculum, for those out there finishing and rechecking their scorecards, as Leo assigns you to do, make sure you are translating credits into hours in the week. That should be something you should find from the school themselves, or of course could get from an alumni student. What does a specific week look like with the hours of the day, as opposed to just a credit list that you might more easily find on a website?
And this is because, as David says, especially with theater programs, a credit is not a credit, is not a credit. This may also be true of non-theater college credits. I'm less familiar with them from school to school, but I can say for sure, with theater and musical theater programs, they're often doing exactly what David mentioned and really shrinking the class of a credit hour to meet the needs of their program because what they do might not easily translate into the university system at large.
[1:05:45] Charlie Murphy: So if you compare two credits of acting at one school versus four at another school, that does not actually mean necessarily that you're taking double the acting at the second school. It should mean that, but in order to make the schedules work, many schools will manipulate the math of what a credit hour is to the point of unrecognizability. This is at least partially because musical theater classes, despite having significant outside work from class, do not have the same homework load that a physics class might. So where another major might take 15 credits, meaning 15 hours of class time in a week, knowing they have a ton of work outside of class they'll have to complete, a musical theater major might be in class for more than 30 hours a week before you even start counting stuff like rehearsal and crew hours, which can be really significant.
But if they gave out the 60 credits for the hours you're actually working, you'd be graduated from school in like one year, and that wouldn't work out too well for the university. Which is not to say that you all need to do a lot of this math or translation of what a credit hour is and what kind of, you know, multiplication table do I need to make this all match up. I would just make sure you have a detailed sample schedule in days and hours so that you really understand what your week will be like. This is the kind of thing also that you do not necessarily need to go incredibly deep on in your beginning research. So any younger listeners out there, if your class is 2024, 2025, as I say this, if you're a junior or sophomore as you're doing this, this might not be the thing that you go deep on with the 50 schools you're looking at at the very beginning.
But you definitely do want to be incredibly specific on all of this kind of stuff before you make your final decision. And exactly when you do this level of specificity really varies family by family. Some it'll be a little earlier in the process, some a little bit later. You're gonna do what you can do to have this information. But certainly before you choose to go to school to a place like this, you want to make sure you know what is the schedule actually going to be.
[1:07:33] Charlie Murphy: The other takeaway I want to hit on is not too specific to David but does go back to our class of 2023 and making your final decision where we all are in this place right now. You may have noticed I ask each school that has a musical theater program or an emphasis like that, which of the three disciplines of musical theater they emphasize the most. For a while there, I kept saying like legs of the stool. I'm not sure why that was the thing that was sticking in my craw, but it was like how much leg of the stool are you? Is it one of the legs longer than the other? I don't know, but you're gonna get that for like last year I was doing that a lot. Just to let you behind the curtain a little bit, this is not because I think it's important you go through and actually categorize each school specifically and label it an acting-based school or this is a music-heavy program, etc. As I think you'll make some of those decisions based on the above credit hours deep dive, and you'll get some of that reputationally from how others will discuss the school.
But I do want you to pay attention to the different ways they talk about that question. I think it's really interesting to get a sense of the philosophy of a school in the way they talk about their equality of all three disciplines. Or do they emphasize one of the disciplines specifically there? Or even more importantly, how they talk about what's most important to train a young artist. I mean, I love David's comments about style in this question. I thought that was very interesting, right? And I also love that he said first, second, third, and a hundredth that they're an acting program. Even for other schools that say acting is primary, they may not want to put all top hundred spots on acting and only have 101 be singer, 102 be dancer, whatever.
And again, that's not to say to read too much into a quick answer about a school's philosophy and then say, okay, that means their song and dance training is somehow lesser because of it. But you can get a sense of the vibe and how it lines up philosophically with what you're looking for.
[1:09:12] Charlie Murphy: That's it. The 100th episode in the books. After this one, it will be a while before the number is exciting again, so I'll probably just stop saying it. But I won't stop saying how great it is to have Meghan Cordier producing these episodes, and I certainly won't stop encouraging you to rate and review us wherever you listen to your favorite podcast. And let's be honest, if you made it this far in the episode, we're one of your favorite podcasts. I think we just need to admit that to ourselves. Don't forget to follow our socials at Mapping the College Audition on Instagram and MTCA on all our various social media platforms in the show notes, as well as popping over to mtcollegeauditions.com on the old internet browser if you want some of the best individual college coaching you can find on this planet.
And if you want to see photos of me covered in stickers for my daughter, you can follow me at Charmur7 as well on all my social medias. To my young artists out there mapping their journeys, is the plural of takeaway takeaways or takes away? There are multiple takes that are being brought away, but somehow that feels wrong. See you next week.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
