Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#48 Jay Armstrong Johnson Is The Prom King

From the Broadway Revival of Parade, to starring as Raoul in the 30th Anniversary Broadway cast of The Phantom of the Opera, Jay Armstrong Johnson is the prom king of Broadway. U Guys, we're talking Golden Globes nominations in this week's BroadwayWorld Recap, brought to you by BroadwayWorld.com... Read More

From the show: Oh My Pod U Guys

59 mins
12/18/23

Guests

Featured Shows

About

From the Broadway Revival of Parade, to starring as Raoul in the 30th Anniversary Broadway cast of The Phantom of the Opera, Jay Armstrong Johnson is the prom king of Broadway.

U Guys, we're talking Golden Globes nominations in this week's BroadwayWorld Recap, brought to you by BroadwayWorld.com. Then I am joined by Broadway star, Jay Armstrong Johnson, to talk all things Bway! Jay is a true triple threat, from singing incredible scores like Phantom, to dancing Michael Bennett's original choreography in A Chorus Line, to acting the role of Will Olsen on ABC's Quantico. A Texas native, Jay shares his experience as a young artist in the South, and his journey to New York City and working consistently on Broadway. His Broadway credits range from Hair, to On The Town, to Catch Me If You Can. While consistently working on the stage and screen, Jay also flexes his creative muscles in ways that benefit incredible organizations like the Ali Forney Center for LGBTQ youth, and Broadway Cares Equity Fights AIDS. You can see Jay's Hocus Pocus inspired Halloween show, I Put A Spell On You, annually, and he has starred multiple times in Jerry Mitchell's, Broadway Bares. Jay is such a love, U don't wanna miss his episode!

Follow Jay on Instagram: @Jay_A_Johnson

Follow the pod on Instagram: @ohmypoduguys

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:00] Jayke Workman: You guys, you guys, we have to come together. We have to band together. Our time is now. Our fight is here. We cannot let Timothy Chalamet bring Wonka to Broadway. Oh my god, did you hear? Did you hear? Did you hear my god guys?

[0:32] Jayke Workman: What's up, everybody? My name is Jayke Workman, and this is Oh My Pod, you guys, a musical theater and pop culture podcast. Y'all, I am wasting no time today because there is an imminent threat to our society. And that is Timothy Chalamet threatening to reprise his role of Willy Wonka on Broadway. No. Just no. We cannot stand for this. I'm making chocolate, of course. No. No. We're not doing that.

[1:00] Jayke Workman: Like, you guys, have you seen the video of Hugh Grant introducing himself in like a French press junket where they're like, can you tell us who you play? And he goes, lead so sad. Like, he is not happy to be there. We cannot allow this movie to infiltrate the sanctity of Broadway. It will not happen. We already had a Willy Wonka musical. We don't need that again. I have had it.

[1:29] Jayke Workman: But anywho, this week I had the absolute pleasure of seeing my friend Emma Pittman, friend of the pod, in her Broadway show, Back to the Future. And you guys, I was absolutely floored. I had heard so many different things about this show. You know, it's very campy. It's like we're not doing Chekhov when we are doing Back to the Future. But this show is truly one of the most amazing spectacles I have ever seen in a theater. It was unbelievable. I couldn't believe my eyes at what I was seeing.

[2:03] Jayke Workman: Casey Likes and Roger Bart as Marty McFly and Doc Brown, respectively, are truly unmatched. Their comedic timing, their deliveries, their vocals, they were serving. But this ensemble, you guys, everyone is whacking their face. Everyone is singing their faces off, running around. The women are doing quick changes, sometimes two or three quick changes inside of a dance number. Like, it's crazy. And the DeLorean, y'all, I hate to be this person, but like it's the reason to see the show. It will blow your mind. I cannot recommend it enough.

[2:40] Jayke Workman: It's playing right now at the Winter Garden, but it's also about to go on a national tour, and I cannot wait to share some very exciting news about some very special people in my life who get to be a part of that show. So you guys run to see Back to the Future as soon as you can. And without further ado, let's dive right into this week's Broadway World recap, brought to you by my wonderful partners at Broadwayworld.com.

[3:03] Jayke Workman: First, you guys, we got the very exciting announcement that the 2023 Broadway revival of Parade is hitting the road in 2025. I know that I have spoken at length about this show on the podcast, but you guys, I'm just so, so excited that the entire country will get to see this show. Anyone who wasn't able to get to New York and, you know, pay these like crazy ticket prices in New York City and everything to get to see the show will get to see it across the country. I mean, it's amazing.

[3:30] Jayke Workman: It won the Tony Award for Best Revival of a Musical this year, and it is going to start in January of 2025 at Proctor's Theater in Schenectady, followed by its official tour premiere at Hennepin Theatre Trust's historic Orpheum Theater in Minneapolis, my home theater baby, where I literally would go and see Wicked and Phantom in all of these touring shows as a teenager. So I'm so excited about this. The only thing that I'm bummed by is the fact that we have to wait a full year. Come on! We need this story, we need this show out on the road sooner. But hey, worth the wait, you guys. It's incredible.

[4:11] Jayke Workman: And speaking of shows helmed by the incredible director Michael Arden, you guys, we just got the announcement that a new musical adaptation of The Lost Boys is in development. I am so excited about this. I can't believe this hasn't been thought of before. I have loved this movie for so long. I think I was first introduced to it when I was like 11 or 12, and it's described as a teenage vampire movie that was tawdry, pulpy, and sexually charged. And it was a critical and commercial success and has since achieved cult classic status by transcending the genre with its unique blend of horror and comedy, which is like my tea. I live for it.

[4:53] Jayke Workman: It's so, so campy, but also so sexy and scary and dark, and I think it is truly perfect source material for a musical. I'm so excited about this. Hell, I want to be in this musical. The show is gonna feature a book by David Hornsby, and the music is going to be written by The Rescues. No official word yet on when and where this show is going to be developed, but stay tuned because I will, of course, keep you updated as soon as I know anything.

[5:23] Jayke Workman: Next, you guys, there were some amazing nominations for Golden Globes this year that are super exciting for us theater nerds. First, Fantasia Barino was nominated for Best Actor in a Motion Picture for Comedy or Musical for her performance in The Color Purple, which I am thrilled to see. I cannot wait to see this movie. And her co-star, Danielle Brooks, was nominated for Best Performance by a Female Actor in a Supporting Role for any motion picture for her performance in The Color Purple. So I'm so excited for these beautiful, amazing women. I cannot wait to see this movie.

[6:03] Jayke Workman: And also, Maestro was nominated for Best Director for Bradley Cooper, Best Performance by a Female Actor in a Motion Picture Drama for Carrie Mulligan, and Best Performance by a Male Actor in a Motion Picture Drama for Bradley Cooper. And it's nominated for Best Motion Picture Drama. You guys, I am so excited to see this story about Leonard Bernstein come to life. I'm thrilled. It comes out so soon, um, I believe on Netflix, and it looks absolutely beautiful. So congratulations to all of these amazing nominations, all of the nominees. The Golden Globes are taking place on January 7th, 2024 on CBS.

[6:44] Jayke Workman: And lastly, you guys, Broadway favorite Renee Rapp and the icon herself, Miss Megan Thee Stallion, have released a new song for the Mean Girls soundtrack, and it is so good, you guys. It's called Not My Fault, which is a fun play on the line from the original Mean Girls movie where Lindsay Lohan is like, It's not my fault, you're like in love with me or something. It's so good. The Megan's rap verses are incredible. Obviously, Renee is singing down, and it just made me so much more excited to see this movie. Renee is reprising her role of Regina George after doing it on Broadway, and the movie comes out on January 12th. I am so excited.

[7:24] Jayke Workman: And you guys, this has been the BroadwayWorld Recap. Oh, my pod, you guys. I am so excited to welcome my next guest to the show. He is truly one of Broadway's true triple threats. I can confidently say, even though we have just met. Please welcome Mr. Jay Armstrong Johnson.

[7:45] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Thanks, Jay. Welcome to the pod.

[7:48] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, thank you. What a fierce intro. I'm bluffing. You can't tell because this is an oral medium, but I'm watching over here.

[8:00] Jayke Workman: Um, well, could you please tell the listeners where you're calling from? Because I think it's absolutely hilarious and I in true artist form.

[8:08] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I am posted up in office number one on the third floor of Pearl Studios. Come on, Pearl. 500 Eighth Avenue, honey.

[8:17] Jayke Workman: Oh my god, we all know her way too fucking well.

[8:20] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yes, we do. Well, Jay, thank you so much for coming on the pod. I have been such a fan of your work for so long, and I really do mean it when I say that you are someone who I believe is a true triple threat star of the stage and the screen. And I cannot wait to hear about all of your incredible endeavors.

[8:39] Jay Armstrong Johnson: But I first just have to say that I was so thrilled to be able to see your performance in Parade. It was absolutely stunning. That show was unreal, and I just can't wait to hear all of your thoughts. I had Harry and Sean on the podcast, I had Douglas Lyons on the pod. Like I made my rounds through the Parade cast, like I'm so excited to hear your thoughts on it because you had such an incredible role, and you did it first at City Center and then in the Broadway revival. So tell me, like, what was your road to that show?

[9:15] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, well, I wasn't like a lot of my theater friends who like grew up on the Parade soundtrack. Like it's actually my best friend's favorite musical. She is obsessed with it and has been since we were kids. So, but it wasn't one of those that I really studied as a kid. I didn't really know about it until like college when kids would sing it for like, you know, song rep class. Um, but I've been friends with Michael Arden's husband Andy Mientus since we were like 19 because we were in final callbacks for Spring Awakening together back in the day.

[9:49] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So I've known Michael and Andy for a while, so I've known them as friends before I've known Michael as a collaborator. So I just remember hanging out with Michael. We were doing a concert in Tokyo a couple of years ago, and I guess he was working on Parade, and he just kind of mentioned like I'm thinking about you for a role in Parade. Is that something that you would want to do? And I was like, working with you, Michael, yeah, literally anything.

[10:16] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, that was just like a mention, and then like an audition came through, and you know, I put myself on tape, and you know, Michael was like, You're my first choice for this, but just so you know, like the powers that be, like I'm not the only one making this thing happen. JRB's got to sign off on you. So the process, you know, the process was a little easier than I anticipated because you know, Jason knew me through Hal Prince, you know, I was one of Hal Prince's, like, you know, he took me under his wing when we did Candide, and so I became kind of a part of like the Prince family for a while there.

[10:52] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So I got to meet Jason through Hal. And so I was easily co-signed by Jason just because of that connection through Hal. And you know, Parade is a Hal Prince, you know, produced and directed musical from the 90s, and so there's just so much synergy and connection there that I was just really grateful to like be in the right place at the right time with the right thing, you know.

[11:15] Jayke Workman: That's so, so cool. And you guys, I mean, I've like I mentioned, I've spoken to a few people who did the show, but I think it's such an interesting avenue in because it's not like this was, you know, originally set up to be what it became. It was the City Center production where you guys basically had what, like two weeks of rehearsal or something, ten days and you know, that's not normal for something of this caliber and you know, this scale. So then to move to Broadway. Did you know going in how special of a show you guys had created?

[11:56] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I mean, I kind of knew it was going to be special before we even started rehearsals for City Center because just the cast list came in, and I was like, well, this is an embarrassment of riches. And then you know, Michael was so aware of like the time constraints of what it meant to put this thing up on its feet in less than two weeks in front of a New York audience. And so he sent this really lovely comprehensive email about like his vision for the show and his hope for the show and his like rallying of the troops around this piece at this time and acknowledged the uphill battle that we had to get it up on its feet and just kind of asked us to like really be prepared.

[12:38] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And you know, the City Center like on course E contract allows for you to have your book on stage with you, and he really kind of encouraged us to be off book so that the piece packed more of a punch. The rise in anti-Semitism was so wild these days, and he really thought that the piece could really say something on a really deeper level if we actually did that hard work going into it. So I kind of felt that it was going to be special before we even began it, if that makes sense.

[13:14] Jayke Workman: Totally, yeah. Wow, that's incredible. Well, and I also think I mean Parade is based on an actual, you know, series of events and trial and real people, and that's really cool, and it's also not the only show that you have done that you know you are playing characters that are based on real people because you have gotten to do A Chorus Line, which you know, just a little different than Parade, but I'd so love to hear about your experience doing that show because that's one you obviously did it at City Center, but the tour as well, and that is one of the like, you know, sort of iconic Broadway staple shows, and it's an insanely dance-heavy show. You guys are a dawn sing. What was your road to A Chorus Line?

[14:11] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I mean, were you always a dancer? I mean, I was a dance major at my performing arts high school, um, at the Fort Worth Academy of Fine Arts. So most of my training, proper training as a kid was in dance, right? Like I was in choirs, but I never really took voice lessons. Like I did plays and musicals, but I never like took acting classes. But like dance class was something that I was doing an upwards of five hours a day, five days a week from the time I was like 15 to the time I was eighteen, right?

[14:45] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So though that was like the crux of like my education, and I was like a major, that was my major. I chose to be a dance major um in high school um because I loved it so much. So to w when I when I got into NYU, I decided to be a vocal major because I wanted to play more roles and like I didn't want to be kind of pigeon-holed as like a dancer ensemble chorus person. So I really like studied voice and um but the dance auditions were where I felt most comfortable because that was kind of where I had most of my training. So I was skipping a lot of classes on NYU to like go to like Broadway auditions and national tour auditions and open calls. So A Chorus Line, the revival, which was what 2007, 2008 was on Broadway, like my freshman sophomore year of college.

So I was going to those Broadway replacement open calls like all of the time and continuing to get called back for like a year and a half. I was like went on multiple auditions for it until the national tour came around my junior year and I got Mark um on the national tour, and I dropped out of school and never looked back. Period.

[15:59] Jayke Workman: Wow, incredible. And then how long how long were you on the road with that show?

[16:03] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um I signed a six-month contract, and I kind of only wanted to do six months, and I had signed with an agency at the time that was like kind of interested in getting me back to the city as soon as possible. So after six months, I came back to the city um and then kind of did a couple of concerts um at NYU. Uh, but my replacement, Dave Hall, uh actually sprained his ankle the day before he was supposed to replace me. So they asked me to so they asked me to come back out on tour to replace my replacement while he healed his sprained ankle. Um so that's when I got to like hang out with Robin Herter, which is when I first got to meet Robin because she replaced Nikki Snelson after those first six months. So I got to do another like month and some change with like the new cast turnover. So I ended up doing a little over seven months on the road with A Chorus Line.

[16:54] Jayke Workman: Wow, that's amazing. I mean, I have such love and respect for that show. I have never done it, and I don't know if I could first of all just do it eight times a week, but then travel the country and do it. I mean, w so obviously you you mentioned Robin Herter. You went on to do it at City Center, which was insanity. That cast was insane. The was the experience doing it on the road different than bringing it back to New York and doing it at City Center?

[17:26] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Absolutely, Charlie. On the road, I was 20 years old. I wasn't even like legal to drink on the road. Like at City Center, it was a decade later, and I was playing Bobby and not Mark, right? So like I like changed roles to an old. I mean, I was all of a sudden, instead of being the youngest one on the line, I was one of the oldest ones on the line, and my body felt it, and my spirit felt it. And like we only had to do it for that one week at City Center. I don't know. I mean, I actually don't know if if my um sweet, lovely body can sustain like a major dance show like that eight times a week ever again, to be completely sure. Those days might be over.

[18:06] Jayke Workman: Well, and that one, I feel like the City Center one truly like it just sort of like leveled up the show in a way that we didn't even really know it could go. I mean, like every moment it's just like the the standard, the baseline was like, okay, triples and legs up here, and we're gonna do this, and we're gonna do that. I mean, it was like and did Bayork set it? Was it by the way?

[18:31] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, it was both Bayork and Bob Avian. So, you know, they and they set my tour as well. So it was like it was this really cool, like full circle moment where like the people that gave me my first big job that allowed me to drop out of college all of a sudden gave me another big job ten years later, and it was almost as if no time had passed, except all of a sudden I had this like resume, so I was just more by these people that I've respected for my entire career. And you know, Bob passed away not too not long ago, so to be able to work with him one last time before he passed was really kind of beautiful and bittersweet.

[19:10] Jayke Workman: Yeah, and and on the show that they uh created. I mean, I feel uh a similar bond with Chicago just because I have gotten to work um like anytime I'm I'm working on Chicago, it's with the people who created it. And so it's like that's it's a such a special um connection that you feel to like a piece and and like you said, like at different points in your career and everything. And so to get to revisit it, I'm sure was just fascinating.

[19:38] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, and I've been so lucky, like I was able to do Phantom of the Opera and touch a lot of the original people that created that, like Hal Prince, you know, David Caddock. And we gotta talk about Phantom of the Opera Beach because you okay, you go, I yeah, I was just like a dancer, didn't really take voice lessons, whatever. And then he's singing Raoul Viconditioni Beach on Broadway. We gotta talk about it. 30th anniversary cast on Broadway of I would say the most iconic Broadway show ever. My first Broadway show I ever saw.

[20:11] Jayke Workman: Really? What did you did?

[20:19] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Have you always been like, oh yeah, I'll do Raoul? I had never seen Phantom of the Opera until like one of my very good friends, Mary Michael Patterson was playing Christine Daye on Broadway, and I was like, Well, you know, my one of my best girls is leading a Broadway show. I better go see her in it. So that's when I first saw it, right? Um, and looking on that stage when I was watching that show, I was like, well, this is not a show for me, but I'm glad to experience this, right? So it was it was never on my radar, it was not a musical that I studied. It was, you know, I I never thought that I would be like the tall strapping, you know, owner of the, you know, opera, you know, but because of my connection to Hal Prince and Candeed, um, that's how it kind of happened.

You know, I was I did Candeed, and then I was doing a television show around that same time, and my television show got cancelled. So I was feeling pretty good about myself, and I had a one bedroom apartment and living by myself for the first time ever, and then all of a sudden my TV show goes away and I don't have means to pay rent. And so Hal was the first person I called just to be like, dude, I'm I'm kind of nervous. I think I'm gonna have to move out of my place. I'm unemployed. I thought my TV show was gonna last longer than this. I'm just you know, call on the top of the food chain to see if you have any advice for me. And he was like, Well, we're looking for a new Raoul replacement on Broadway.

So let me I'm gonna make a couple of phone calls. And then all of a sudden I had an audition for Raoul like the next week, and then I went in three times, you know. I had the callback process was pretty extensive. Um and and the final the final callback, they had a camera in there to film it to then send the film to Andrew Lloyd Webber and to Cameron Mackintosh for them to sign off on me. Um so that's that's how Phantom came about, and it was to literally save me from having to move out of my apartment.

[22:06] Jayke Workman: Wow, and then you went on to be I mean, I feel like you are the type of person who when you go into a show that has been running that long or or you know, is such a machine, you are the type of person who can bring new life to it and and sort of like inject new um I don't know, light and and excitement in it because you know sometimes it gets stale, even from an outside perspective, like like people going to see the show who have seen it ten times are still seeing the same thing over and over. And so to to bring someone in who is well known, like you, and who has you know the the um the fresh eyes and like the fresh experience, I think is really important, and I think it's so cool that you you got to do it.

I'd love to to know more about just like being in a show that is that huge because it's it's a different beast than doing Parade where it's like you guys are all on stage there's there's like not there's nothing to hide behind in a show like that but Phantom has like the darkness and the the music the scale like what is that like?

[22:53] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It was the first show that I've done on Broadway where I wasn't an original cast member right this this is my first time I ever replaced and so that was new for me. So um to go into a show where someone had been working there for 18 years was just a totally different vibe in the building right it's like it's a very wild family type atmosphere where people have you know put their children through college on one show which is just like unheard of the the gift that Hal was able to give to me in doing this was I've always heard horror stories about replacement replacing in a machine like that and how you know how regimented it is and how the rules are this and you have to hit this mark and you have to say a line like this and you you know um A Chorus Line often often felt like that even though we were like a new company um because of the history of it but Hal really told the team at Phantom to like let let my instincts shine through he was like Raoul is always gonna stick on the mud and I trust Joe's instincts and I wanna so let Joe do what he wants. So he kind of gave me carte blanche to like really put my own spin on Raoul and um do my own thing with it that maybe hadn't been done in 30 years.

[24:34] Jayke Workman: Yeah.

[24:35] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So that that was lovely. I mean there was some it it took some getting used to, especially for the creative team to like uh have someone be given that kind of uh right I don't know ability to like not listen to to like the 30 years of history. Um but I really appreciated Hal trusting me to kind of put my own like flavors into it.

[24:59] Jayke Workman: Yeah that's so cool. Did you feel like it this is the height of glamour. You're in these like crazy costumes and running all around and there's smoke and fire.

[25:09] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh yeah I mean it's so it's such a heightened reality and like that was one thing that Hal always told us in rehearsals is like just remember that you're in a hit and that it's melodrama. You know like and I was yeah girl I had a three piece suit that was gorgeously tailored to my body and like because I'm a little on the shorter end of things they gave me like a little two inch lift and my heat like I had like a little heel, you know. So I did I felt bougie and expensive and you know I'm I'm usually the character actor that's a little like yucky yucky and so this is the first time I got to like step into a power and like hold my chest high and like own this opera company and be like the you know romantic leader leading lady.

[25:54] Jayke Workman: Your bare chest in the lair. Who was your first um like Christine and and Phantom who were who were playing those roles when you went in?

[25:57] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It was Allie Ewold um and Ben Crawford who were both like friends of mine. You know I I'd met Allie doing like concerts and going to events and Ben and I of course had known each other from thirty-five millimeter. Um Right. So yeah, uh it was and they were s God, we had so much fun. We actually got in trouble a lot backstage because of our social media presence. We were not quite on brand with what Phantom was hoping to put out into the world. So like we got like our hands like smacked every now and again for being sure wild backstage on our social media channels.

[26:39] Jayke Workman: But the fans loved it.

[26:42] Jay Armstrong Johnson: The PHANs loved your shenanigans backstage.

[26:48] Jay Armstrong Johnson: They sure did, honey. That's what we live for. Are you kidding? Yeah, we were bringing a new audience to this old ass dusty show and you know, London didn't like it. So whatever London, we get it. The Brits.

[27:00] Jayke Workman: And now it's closed, so well, I have been a fan of yours for quite some time, but I I am so excited to get to actually like put a face to you know a real face to to you and and your work because I've I've never gotten to meet you and I'm so I'm just inspired by you. I I have to say, I've you your work is crazy. It's everywhere. You've done so many things. You've done TV and and you know, you continue to to make your mark on the world of New York theater, and I am just so excited that you continue to um seek out those opportunities because I feel like there are people who who fall in love with theater or or you know, start here and then make their way to TV film and then that's it because that that's where the money is, honey, and it's a real enticing thing.

Um so it's amazing and um just refreshing to see you continue to I mean, you've done so many fucking shows, like On the Town, Hands on a Hard Body, like what is there is there one thing that you look for in a piece that um you're really drawn to in terms of like taking on a new show or is it just kind of you're you audition and you you know work with people who are excellent collaborators and then the piece is the piece?

[27:58] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I mean uh that's a really great question I try uh this business is so good at putting artists in boxes and being like this is what you do and it's been kind of my goal to confuse the industry with every new job that I have to be like wait A Chorus Line wait a rock show Hair wait a country show wait a dance show Bernstein wait an operetta Candeed, you know I want to keep everyone guessing because I want to do so many things like a I love uh growing I love learning I love being able to kind of fit into new molds that I would normally hadn't fit into so you know Whoopi Goldberg said in uh in Sister Act 2 that she likes eclectic music and like that's that's kind of how I want to like live my life and career is like through like an eclectic I don't know gaze.

[29:30] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um yeah I don't know keep them guessing don't let them put you in a box period well you continue to do that because uh your your annual Halloween concert that has now become this like very sought after event is is one that um not only is it a a beautiful fundraiser that benefits an incredible organization, Ali Forney, and you know, um advocating for LGBTQ rights and and youth, but um you I love that you don't take yourself too seriously to quite literally put on the wig and the heels and be Miss Winifred Sanderson.

[30:09] Jayke Workman: What what inspired you to do that in the first place?

[30:13] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I mean first of all, I've always wanted to be Winifred Sanderson for Halloween, I've just not had the money to pull it off.

[30:19] Jayke Workman: Oh, right.

[30:20] Jay Armstrong Johnson: What homosexual does not want to be Bet Midler and Hocus.

[30:23] Jayke Workman: That's right.

[30:23] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And I couldn't like admit that in Texas, or else, you know, I might have found myself even more bullied than I was. Um it's uh always been this thing. I just knew that I didn't want to do it half-ass. Like when I played when when I did Winifred Sanderson for Halloween, I would want it to be like done well. I would want to like have the money to be able to like nail it, right?

[30:43] Jayke Workman: Yeah.

[30:44] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So my first television show kind of gave me that opportunity. And so with the money from my first season of shooting Quantico, I was able to produce my own solo concert at 54 Below and do like a live album of that concert and release that album over like October of that year. And so I just decided to do like a Halloween album release party where uh we got dressed up as characters from Hocus Pocus and did songs from my album and then added some spooky tunes just to make it a Halloween event. So that's the that was the like that was the like what what started out. So it was just like a fun, stupid Halloween release party, but we had so much fun and like I lived my best dreams that we had the costumes, we had the wigs, we just decided to continue doing it every year.

[31:29] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And for the first few years it was just fun. It was just me and like some of my closest friends getting together to like throw a Halloween party and everyone got paid a little bit. And you know, we didn't really make any money off of it. It was just like a way to have fun and collaborate. Um, and then when I started working more closely with Broadway Cares and doing Broadway Bares and Broadway Backwards and these fundraising events, I kind of realized that I could turn my Halloween show into that kind of event and so raise money for a good cause. So we worked two or three years with Broadway Cares. Last year they introduced us to the Ali Forney Center, and so it's just grown ever since then.

So, you know, I I have a site visit to we're looking to expand to a bigger venue next year because we kind of have outgrown Sony Hall. Um which is wild. So, you know, I I already have meetings on the books for our ninth anniversary of I Put A Spell On You, and it's it's wild to see how far it's come and to see how many artists say yes and to see them execute on such a high level every year. I mean, it really is kind of a humbling and like wildly exciting experience to be able to collaborate with people that are doing so well in like the theatrical realm, and then to say yes to my project and I don't know it um to raise money. I mean, uh, I'm just I'm beside myself with happiness and uh with with how it's all kind of um growing, um, and how much it's become this thing that I didn't quite realize it could become.

[33:02] Jayke Workman: That's so cool. And and how amazing too that like not only was it just like a fun passion project for you, but it uh raises awareness and raises money for incredible organizations, and you know, you touched on it a little bit, but um, I just had the pleasure of going to the Red Bucket Follies, which was the celebration for um Broadway Cares, and you know, obviously came to Broadway Bares, which we must talk about because Bears is something that like for a long time I I've been like kind of afraid, like I really want to do it. I think it'd be so fun, but I'm also just like, I don't know. I don't know, but I went and saw it for the first time, and it was the most beautiful celebration of queer people, queer people of color, people of any gender expression, any body type, like it was so one thing in my head.

And then getting to see it live for the first time, I was like, oh my god, this is just this is just a celebration of everyone. And and it's you know, to raise money for this incredible organization, Broadway Cares Equity Fights AIDS. So tell me about you know how you first got connected with that incredible show, and is it scary to be shaking your little booty out on a stage in front of 2,000 people?

[34:19] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Uh yes, of course it's scary. And you know, I had a similar like idea of what Broadway Bears was when I was younger, and I was like, that's not for me. Like it's for like a jacked, like body oddity adi, like dancer dancer dancer, like it's this is not my space, right? Until yeah, Jay Armstrong Johnson is known for not having a body or being a dancer, clearly. But this was like years ago when like I was like, you know, a bit more prudish and not leaning into sexuality and saying so you know what I mean. Um like I met Jerry Mitchell's through doing Catch Me If You Can on Broadway, right? So like that was my first intro to like Jerry. Um, and I had seen a Broadway Bears back during that time. Um, and uh and really enjoyed myself, right?

But it it wasn't until I was able to do it at Hammerstein Ballroom in 2016 because they asked me to be a part of it because I had done Quantico, right? So as a Broadway boy, I'd had a little bit of a resume on Broadway, and then I had a TV show, so all of a sudden I was just like, Oh, look, he now he's got a verify check on Instagram. So let's, you know. So that's right, how I got involved uh as like a performer in Bears. And I was nervous, of course I was nervous, but I had friends that were doing it, and I trusted um the director, um, Nick Kenkel, who was also the um dance captain associate choreographer on uh Catch Me If You Can. So these were friends of mine that I'd worked with before that um were kind of ushering me through this thing, and I just remember one being totally terrified, right?

Being ass out in front of 2,000 people is wild, but it was also I've never felt so much energy coming at me from an audience. Like I truly felt like I was in a stadium concert tour and I was the fucking star, right? It was like I had never felt that kind of energy. Right.

[36:16] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So that was fun and exciting and totally overwhelming. And then by the end of the show, when they were announcing how much money that we had raised, like, and there's Judith Light like giving this gorgeous speech. I just found myself like weeping, like tears of happiness and gratitude, and seeing this community that Jerry began 30 years ago grow into what it has become. Like, um, that's where I was like, oh, now I get it. This isn't just about shaking your ass and feeling like sexy. Yes, it is that, but it's way more than that. It's it's more about a community coming together to like raise money for incredible causes, you know, and that's totally. I was a scholarship kid growing up. I never paid a dime for any of my theatrical training, so.

So knowing that there are organizations out there that provided me the opportunity to do what I love as a young queer kid. I know that like so much of what I want to be and do in this world as an artist to give back to those kinds of organizations that like gave so much to me, if that makes sense.

[37:17] Jayke Workman: Totally. Absolutely. Well, I I mean, switching gears a little bit, but um off of that vein, I would love to hear about your experience as as a young queer person growing up in Texas. Did you have an upbringing that was particularly um like theatrical or musical? I mean, I think I think I read somewhere that you uh did Peter Pan as a kid. But what like what set you up to to want to do this?

[37:46] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I mean music has always been in my family. Like my dad's a drummer and a singer, and always kind of has been. My mom and my aunt would always like sing in like cute two-part harmony, like you're on holidays. So like music has always been in my blood and in my family. Um, I just remember like going to Disney on ice for the first time at age four and being like, This is the most magical thing I've ever been to, or going to the circus and being obsessed with clowns for six years of my life and only being a clown for Halloween for like six years in a row. Like, I was so I was so attached to this idea of entertainment to this idea of performance, uh, but didn't realize that I could quite access it as me, right?

So it was when I I guess fifth grade is where it really began because Mr. Ingram's fifth grade English class always put on a much abridged version of Romeo and Juliet, and my sister played Juliet the year before me because she's a year older than me, and like I wanted to play Romeo so badly, but I was the only person in public school system of Texas that wanted to put on white tights and recite Shakespeare in front of a school body at age what 10? 11 right? So I you know I got to play Romeo, so that was the first time I was like, I want to be an actor. So like at age 15, I was like, I want to be in not age 15, at what how old are you in the fifth grade? I think you were right, I think like 10 or 11.

[39:12] Jayke Workman: 10, yeah.

[39:12] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I wanna I knew I wanted to be an actor then. Um Wow. And then I joined the church choir, um, because I love to sing, and so as a sixth grader, I was a boy soprano in my church choir, and I would have like little angel solos, you know, around Christmas time, and I had a couple of friends that went to my church that were a part of this theater company called KWC Performing Arts. Um, and they said I should come audition for a musical, and I did, and I got one of the leads, and it really got that theater bug and was like, okay, so by age 12, I knew exactly what I wanted to do, and I was like, this is what I'm gonna do. And then by age 13, I was playing Peter Pan and Peter Pan at that same theater company, and I was like, great, I'm gonna move to New York after high school.

I'm gonna go to NYU. I literally like made a plan at age 13, go to NYU beyond Broadway by the time I'm like 18, you know, it took me till I was 21, but you know. But that's kind of how it all started for me.

[40:16] Jayke Workman: Wild. And and did you feel like theater offered you something that um you weren't getting other places in terms of your like queerness, or did did you understand that you were queer at a young age?

[40:31] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I I didn't quite understand I was queer because I was told that to be gay was an abomination, um, that it was against God, and I was a straight A student that went to church every Sunday, like I was a good, good boy, like there's no way I could be gay, there's no possible way. I'm hearing everything correct. Yeah, I'm I'm so correct, right? And so I didn't think I was I didn't know I was gay until I was like 15 or 16 when I was meeting gay people for the first time when I was actually being cast in professional productions, right? So and then I was like, oh wait, now they're bringing in all of these New York artists and we're doing Beauty and the Beast together in my hometown at my regional theater, and now I'm seeing all of these lovely humans that are smart and talented and sweet and kind and Christian even and gay, like love themselves, and love themselves, and uh so that so you know it takes you gotta you gotta meet people to like understand the world and to know that you know they're not just hellbound.

So yeah, it I it did change my life and my world, and when I found out that there was a you know, a a performing arts high school in my hometown, I was like a get me out of this public school system. I'm the oh like I'm being absolutely yeah, so I went from being like bottom of the food chain, made fun of, like tortured on a daily basis for being gay, even though I didn't even know I was gay, I guess I could smell it on me, to like being literal prom king at my performing arts high school, right? Like that's like so like it was such a a wild change, you know. Uh J A J is the prom king that I live. Title of episode, bitch.

[42:12] Jayke Workman: So then have you have you gone on to um to feel any type of um being boxed in in terms of being a queer performer? I mean I I assume and I, you know, I guess I shouldn't assume, but um you are a cisgender man, and you also I would imagine come or or have gained um privilege just in being perceived as a man and you know a and you are also a fantastic actor so you if you are playing a person who is in love with a woman, you can do that. But um how have you been met with any um sort of like limitations or or um boxes being put around you in terms of your queerness?

[43:00] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah I mean in my early 20s like right around hair time, you know, there was a manager that like sought me out and I remember this particular woman um encouraging me to not be seen in public with my boyfriend encouraging me to chemically straighten my hair because boys with curly hair don't play leading roles encouraging like it was this like you know I was I was early 20s I was just breaking into the industry I was you know understudying Gavin Greel and a Broadway show like wanting so badly to like get my next foot in the next door and I was kind of brainwashed by this woman into like dimming my queer light in 2008, nine, you know, when like marriage equality was being passed. And so there's this like really wild.

This wild like cognitive dissonance about like being in hair and celebrating queerness and marching on Washington for gay rights, and then having a manager that was like dim that queer light, don't be seen in public. Yeah, hide it. Um gross. So, you know, I've I finally kicked that manager to the curb, and the second that I did that, like doors opened and things happened.

[44:14] Jay Armstrong Johnson: But you know, I do still feel as though that there are like a group of like straight white theater boys that get all of the straight roles. Not often, not always. I mean, I got a straight role in On the Town, but that's because all of this group of straight white theater boys can't dance, right? I can, and so I'm like, um, but like I yeah, it's uh I still feel the conversation around what it means to be queer as an actor, or should straight people play queer roles, should queer people play straight roles. It's it's such a nuanced and hard conversation to have. Um, but if I'm being completely honest, I would say the last decade of my career, I would say 75% of the auditions that I've received are for queer roles, right?

There, I don't I don't often get seen for straight roles, and when I do, I don't often book them unless it's how friends telling me to go be in Phantom of the Opera because, right, unless he's my dad, the most iconic director and creator being like you should be the leading man in the most iconic Broadway show ever. For sure. And most of I mean most of the roles I've played over the course of my career have been straight, right? I've only played like a couple of queer roles in my life. I don't know. Wow. It's just so strange. I feel like there's like this weird, uh you said it correctly. It's such it's like this cognitive dissonance of like, okay, I can do this, I can be anyone. I'm so versatile.

And so I have to be like everyone else. Right. Because that'll that'll get me the job. It's like, wait, first of all, what stories are we even telling? Why do I want to tell that story anyway? When I'm still in the process of kind of weeding away this like heteronormative way of going through life, especially as an actor and trying to like, you know, make the business look at me in a certain way. Like, I'm so over that now. Right. I'm trying to like, uh I'm trying to um what am I trying to say? I'm trying to remember the eight-year-old kid that would spur lunk through his grandmother's closet and try on her heels and her sequin moo moos, and like traips around her house living his best dreams.

Like that's who I've always been in my heart, and I've really dimmed that part of me to try to fit into this mold of wanting to be a leading man, and I'm saying all of that now, right? Like screw that um, yeah. I am going to the ladies section at the department stores first to see what tickles my fancy. Like I'm going and getting manicures and pedicures, honey. Like I'm like leaning into this thing that always excited me as a kid that I've like tried to stay away from because of this, that whatever. But it's it's fun and it's it's so it's so uh God, it's like I don't know, it's freeing. It's uh totally. And you know, thank God for the Billy Porters of the world and um that have kind of paved this way for a new way of like living and thinking and dressing and yeah, yeah.

I mean, I think it's hilarious that you literally did hair penis out and then went on to do Broadway Bares, and you're like, I'm a little scared. I just have to say that. Come on. Well, it's it's one thing to like be holding your tribe members' hands and screaming the word freedom at the top of your lungs, dick out. And then be like, but then be like ass out on the sexy, you know, it's like a sexy vibe is different than like a protest vibe, if you know what I mean. I think you're wrong. I think they are one and the same. I protest very sexually. I love that. Well, before I let you go, God, you are just an absolute treat. Before I let you go, I have a series of rapid fire musical theater questions that I ask all of my guests.

Oh god, not trivia. These are these are specific to you. Okay, great. You ready? Ready. Sondheim or Andrew Lloyd Webber? Sondheim. Sweatpants or jeans? Jeans. Do you have a favorite musical? My Side Story. Do you have a least favorite musical? Spill it on the podcast, Jay Armstrong Johnson. Uh, If Then. Sorry, Jackie Burns. We're done. Um, would you ever like to do a Broadway play? Absolutely. Love. Are you a morning person or a night owl? I'd have to say night owl. Same. What is the craziest thing a director has ever asked you to do? You have a very extensive career, so I'll I'll give you as much time as you need with this one. Um, the craziest thing a director has ever asked me to do either in a rehearsal room or an audition.

I guess. I guess it felt crazy at the time. This doesn't necessarily feel like it's a crazy thing to be asked to do because it was literally my job. But it felt crazy to me in the moment, and it was when they like gave Aaron Tveit the morning off of tech of Catch Me If You Can. And so they asked me to step into his place. So it was like I was on stage doing the like one of the big production numbers, and so I like got to ride the elevator up, and it was you know, it was like the big like fly away song in Catch Me. I don't even remember the name of the song. Um, but I remember Aaron coming in the back of the theater and like standing at the back and like watching me do his role on stage while I was standing in for him while they gave him the morning off, and I remember just being like, this is wild.

You're like hi. And then I never went on. He never let me go on. Thanks, Aaron. Son of a bitch. Uh, golden age or contemporary? Contemporary. Do you have a favorite role you've ever played? I would probably have to say Banko in Scotland, PA. Um, yeah, I just I just had too much fun. Like that was the one based on Bank Woe, right? Yeah, yeah, yeah. So it's yes. It's essentially the Scottish play that was turned into a movie in like the 70s or 80s, and then that movie was then turned into a musical called Scotland, PA. Um, and I auditioned for um the lead, like I wanted to like play the lead, I wanted to play Mac, I wanted to be Macbeth, right? Um, and it didn't quite fit, and so Lonnie Price, the director, asked me to like at my audition asked me to like learn the Banko sides.

Um, and I was like, okay, fine, whatever. And I didn't really care, and so I just like made a stupid choice um because I didn't really want to play the supporting role. But I guess me not caring um and making a stupid choice was absolutely what they were looking for because like I had the entire room in stitches. Um, and then I and then it became my favorite thing that I've ever done because it was just a way for me to access comedy uh in a way that I had never been able to before. Um, so yeah, that's probably my favorite. That's so fun. Um, are you a coffee or tea girly? Coffee. Same. What is the hardest show that you've ever done? Oh, shout out Starbucks. We're drinking on the pod. The hardest show I've ever done is probably On the Town.

Uh, yeah, it was a year of my life, and it was the way I had to warm up for that show, uh, the kind of physical therapy that I had to go through, the kind of mental health uh issues that I was having around the time, leading my very first Broadway show amongst uh amidst a Tony Awards season was like a new thing for me. Uh, the cooldown, yeah. So it was mentally and physically uh exhausting, and also one of the best years of my life, right? Um, but it was the first time I was like, because I've always like I wanna be a lead on Broadway, and then finally I was a lead on Broadway and realized that it was the hardest job, maybe ever, mentally and physically. Um, so yeah, that was that was a hard one.

That was a tough one. Would you cool down between shows? Like on two show days? Um, no, not necessarily. I don't I wouldn't do my like true cooldown until the end of the day. Um, I I wouldn't cool down between shows. I would just kind of rewarm back up before the second show. My god, that's insane. I wish I could have seen that show. I've watched every bootleg possible. Um, could you name all of the Broadway theaters that you have performed in? Okay, Parade was the Jacobs. Parade was the Jacobs, the Bernard B. Jacobs Theater. Um, Phantom of the Opera was the Majestic Theater, which I hope they rename The Prince soon. Um, fabulous. On the Town was the Lyric Theater, formerly known as Ford's Theater.

Um, Hands on a Hard Body was they just renamed it, but at the time it was It was the uh Oh I'm gonna forget. Okay, wait. I know the hair was at the Al Hirschfeld Theater, formerly the Alvin. Um, and then Catch Me If You Can was the Neil Simon. But Hands on a Hard Body is now called something different. It's where Six is right now, and it's called like it's like some ladies. It's the Lena Horne now, yes. Yeah. But back then it was some lady's name, I'm fucking dead. Oh, this is gonna drive me nuts. It This is so embarrassing. I ask you as if I know everything. The Brooks Atkinson. The Brooks Atkinson! That's what it was called. Damn it. Um, do you have a favorite costume that you've ever worn?

Um, I mean, my favorite costume to wear is probably Winifred Sanderson. Just because the second that I s the second that I step into that dress and that wig, I truly transform into her. And have been she's there, and I've been doing it for eight years, and the way I can access that character is kind of scary to me. Um, but if I had to pick a costume that's like outside of the thing that I produce, I would probably have to say when I did Hair, um, when I would go on for a tribe member, like the Michael McDonald, the costume designer, like made us each our own very specific tribe costumes, and they were based upon like the tribe character that we built um with the rest of the cast. And so my tribe character was from Texas and grew up outside of Austin, and you know, uh his name was Mac.

Um, so I remember Michael made me this like very Texas, like red, white, and blue with with the like fringe. It was very it was very me. Yeah, so it's it so I really uh that costume is like near and dear to my heart because it was created with this character. Yeah, yeah, for sure. Have you ever missed an entrance? Absolutely. For sure. Specifically in college, I remember, and my director like just essentially read me the riot act when I missed it, and I was like, what? Like I was on stage for five seconds for a spotlight to hit me and then go out. Shut up, John. But no, I did, I've definitely missed entrances. Well, my last question for you, which I ask every single guest is what is one thing that you would tell baby Jay?

Uh-huh. You're not running out of time. Slow down, uh, live in the moment, uh, breathe. Um, I've always felt like I'm behind. I've always felt like um, yeah, I've I've always felt like uh I've needed to play catch up my whole life and career. Uh, and I think that kind of energy has not allowed me to like kind of live in the moment, and so uh that's that's what I would tell baby Jay. It's live more in that moment, Queen. Love, I love it. Well, Jay, thank you so so much for coming on the podcast. Will you tell the listeners where they can find you on the socials and keep up with all of your shenanigans? Absolutely. Um, you can find me on Instagram at J underscore A underscore Johnson, because I want to make your life a living hell.

Um, you can also check out my website, jarmstrongjohnson.org. Um, and I'm also on Twitter or X, and I rarely post, so um maybe don't check that out. Yeah, that's great. Yay. Well, thank you, thank you. You are such a delight. I'm so glad that I got to have you. Me too. Thanks for having me, Jayke. I really appreciate it. You guys, that's it for another episode of Oh My Pod, you guys. Please, please, please rate, review, and subscribe anywhere you listen to the pod. You can follow the show on Instagram at ohmypoduguys. Thank you so much for listening. Talk soon. Bye.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred