Skip to main content
BPN Logo
03 - Jeff Talbott, Writer/Actor

This week’s episode features writer/actor Jeff Talbott. We absolutely loved sitting down with Jeff and picking his brain on his writing routine, how being an actor has helped his role of a writer, and the importance of following the punctuation in his scripts... Read More

From the show: Page To Stage

1 h 4 mins
6/24/19

About

This week’s episode features writer/actor Jeff Talbott. We absolutely loved sitting down with Jeff and picking his brain on his writing routine, how being an actor has helped his role of a writer, and the importance of following the punctuation in his scripts.

Thanks for listening to this episode! We appreciate your support more than you know :)

Check out the books Jeff mentions!

"Song of Spider-Man: The Inside Story of the Most Controversial Musical in Broadway History" by Glen Berger

"Bird by Bird: Some Instruction on Writing and Life" by Anne Lamott

Follow Jeff: Instagram or Website

Follow us:

PAGE TO STAGE: Instagram or Facebook

MARY: Instagram or Twitter

BRIAN: Instagram or Website

#PageToStagePodcast

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:07] Mary Dina: Hey everyone and welcome back to Page to Stage. A conversation with theater makers. We're your hosts. That's Brian. That's Mary. To put it simply, we're both theater nerds. So let's pull back the curtain and get a glimpse at the artist's process while creating their art.

[0:28] Brian Sedita: Hey Jeff.

[0:29] Jeff Talbott: Hi Brian.

[0:30] Brian Sedita: Thanks for joining us.

[0:31] Jeff Talbott: Thanks, Mary.

[0:32] Mary Dina: We're so excited to have you.

[0:33] Jeff Talbott: I'm so excited to be had.

[0:35] Brian Sedita: Yeah. So let's talk about writing.

[0:38] Jeff Talbott: Okay.

[0:39] Brian Sedita: Well, first, yes. We were really interested to know what do you consider yourself as a theater maker.

[0:46] Jeff Talbott: Uh if people ask me now, uh, I generally lead with writer. I've been an actor for over 20 years. I've been an actor for a long time. Um, but I self-identify more as a writer than an actor, although I earn about half my income from each. So it just depends on the year. Last year was a really good year for both. The front half was all writing and the back half was all acting. This year, uh so far, it I've been writing, but it's not anything that's paying me. And in the back half of the year I already have jobs lined up as an actor. So but what I think when I wake up in the morning is what I'm gonna write today, not how am I gonna interact with the world as an actor.

[1:20] Mary Dina: Oh, that's really interesting. Do you write like would you say that you write like first thing in the morning or is it just a thought that you have?

[1:26] Jeff Talbott: I'm a nine to fiver, kind of. Like I treat it like an office job. I get up. I usually uh I usually walk three to five miles to get myself going. I sit down on my desk somewhere probably, but by ten or eleven, then when I sit down, I try to start working, but I'm also looking out the window or looking at the internet or whatever. But I try to turn off the TV and like sit down to work. And uh and by three, four in the afternoon, whatever's happened, I usually am done writing for the day. Usually. If something's really cooking, I'm you know, I might keep going. But there's uh I mean I think this is true for most writers, but there's a there's a period of time where it's all happening and you can't sustain that.

No writer can sustain that with quality beyond I think ninety minutes to three hours, depending on how fast you're cooking, because if you're writing past I was just listening to a podcast the other day of two film writers that I like a lot and they were talking about this exact same thing. And and the and one of them said, It's all writing, like I'm walking, I'm thinking, I'm spend my day. I think I think of it all as writing, but when I but actually hands on keyboard, anything more than three hours for almost any writer Your brain.

[2:36] Mary Dina: Yeah, yeah.

[2:37] Jeff Talbott: You know, it might still be happening for but it's crap, probably.

[2:40] Mary Dina: Do you write on paper or do you think it's not a big thing?

[2:43] Jeff Talbott: I I just wonder I rewrite on paper and I and my first draft is always because I type faster than I can write. I type like a hundred, hundred and ten words a minute, so I can I can actually keep up with my thoughts if I'm if I'm writing longhand, I can't. But that's why I rewrite by hand usually because then it forces me to stop and think.

[3:01] Mary Dina: Yeah. So how do you handle writer's block? Do you because I I took a playwrighting class in grad school and he told us to just keep writing, even if what you were writing was I don't know what to write next, or I don't know what to think.

[3:15] Jeff Talbott: I had like a creative writing class as well, and that's exactly what they told us to write. I do not know what I'm writing over and over.

[3:24] Mary Dina: Yeah, I but I don't consider it wrong.

[3:27] Jeff Talbott: I don't find that to be true for me. I also there are some writers who say writer's block doesn't exist. Like it, that's a, you know, that's a that's a phrase that just and I actually agree with some version of this definition. That's just a phrase that means I'm afraid. You know, like today I'm afraid. I suffer that more. Um there are like three stages if I'm writing a play. Or or something for film or television, but if I'm writing something from scratch, the first third of it is all writer's block. It's all I'm afraid because it isn't anything yet. Like I don't know what it is. Like it's it's it's just torture to sit down because there's nothing there. Like I may have an outline, I may know what I want it to eventually be, but there's nothing.

It's page one. So every day is just like, well, if I can just get like three pages today, or you know, like five lines that I think are usable, that's good because I'm still it's still teaching me what it is, because particularly plays, since you're talking about theater on the podcast, particularly plays.

[4:30] Mary Dina: We're interested in both, so yeah.

[4:32] Jeff Talbott: I mean, but i I mean, it's yeah, the I I approach them all the same. Some screenwriters, because I've written some stuff that that for for s for film and television, but it's all it's all the same process. The first third of it is so unknowable. It's a new language. Like some writers, everything they write is some version of the same thing. You know, like like like David Mamet or some people's voice as a writer, he he's not the best example today, but but he's a very identifiable example because his plays all seem like the same play. I think one of the things that makes me complicated as a writer, particularly for an agent to represent, for somebody to tell other people about my work. Like a brand.

That's right. All of my plays are very different from each other. I know what my voice sounds like on the page, and if you look at my plays, they have a similar look. They there's a way that a cutoff looks in my play. There's a way a lot of my lines end in dashes because my plays uh people don't finish their thoughts a lot because that's how the world sounds to me. But the plays themselves are wildly different. Like uh uh some of my contemporary plays have some similarities in terms, especially if I'm writing about an age group, and if I'm writing about 20 somethings, they may sound similar, but this I just finished a draft this week of something it's said in 1882 in Norway. It on the page to me, it looks like all of my other plays, but I know that it doesn't sound like them, and it's very hard to say, well, Jeff's new play is set in the 19th century in Norway.

It's just like a play he wrote last year that's set in the near future, um, that was produced. A play I had last year was produced that's set in the near future. I think they're very similar, but they're like have a 300-year gap between them, these two plays. So voice for means that I'm trying to answer for me what the story is trying to tell me to do. Other writers, I think, try to put their voice on whatever the story is. So my plays tend to be very different from each other because what I become interested in is a question. Like the thing that always starts me is well, I wonder what what I have a question about this. I don't know what this is in the world. I don't know, I don't know what anything about what that means to me.

And the way I answer that question or approach that question is to write about it, and hopefully by the end, rather than answer it, I've reframed the question for an audience, and their job is to go and talk about it.

[6:54] Mary Dina: Oh, that's interesting. Because I so I just I just finished reading the submission.

[6:58] Jeff Talbott: Oh, yes.

[6:59] Mary Dina: And so I actually felt that.

[7:01] Jeff Talbott: Yeah.

[7:02] Mary Dina: I felt that exactly the way that that you ended it, and I won't I won't give it away for anyone who's listening who wants to read it 'cause it's a journey. I took a whole journey with it.

[7:09] Jeff Talbott: It's a ride.

[7:11] Mary Dina: Yeah. Yeah. It's I was fascinated. But I had a question about So you said you start with a question and that's how you start.

[7:17] Jeff Talbott: Yeah.

[7:18] Mary Dina: Do you do you start with characters in mind or do you start with the story and build the characters to frame your story?

[7:25] Jeff Talbott: Like the submission started because I had some questions. I mean, I think that that there are a couple of major questions that that play is asking that have to do with not many layers. Yeah, but it isn't just I I think one of the plays one of the reasons that play is complicated for people um is because it's a very aggressive play and has a lot of really forceful language and it's kind of an assault. The play is kind of an assault. They end up walking away and thinking that's about that's about the fight between gender, sexual identity, and racial identity. To me, that play, the question I wanted to write about was who gets to tell the story. That's what the play's about to me. But that isn't necessarily what other people take away.

So when I say that I sit down because I have a question about a thing, it may not be the same question other people have when the play is over. But I think the job of a dramatist, at least the kind of drama that I like, is once the once the play is over, once your experience is over, I want to ask questions that you go out into the lobby and talk about. And like, what do you think about this? What did you what what what did you draw from that experience other audience member? And and it's okay with me if people disagree about what that experience was. There are other playwrights I think who want you to walk away with what they and yeah, that's right. What their what their answer to things is, and I often think I failed. Giving you their insight.

[8:48] Mary Dina: Yep. Yeah.

[8:49] Jeff Talbott: Yeah. Cause I think um for my for my money, I've failed if you walk away and know exactly what I think about it. So like the submission is a great example. Like one of and and and again, it was my first play.

[9:02] Mary Dina: I'm now it was your first play.

[9:04] Jeff Talbott: It was my first completed full length play.

[9:06] Mary Dina: Oh wow.

[9:06] Jeff Talbott: I had written a couple of one hours. I had written a play with a friend, but that was the first that was the first completed all by myself play. I'm now eleven plays and four musicals in and I write differently now. So that play, which I'm proud of and has had a really great life I saw a production of it a year ago at NYU and and I try not I don't see that play so much anymore. That play's really uncomfortable for me to watch because I know what it's going to do to an audience. So it's hard because a lot of my plays are very tough on an audience. A lot of my plays have an uncomfortable feeling to them. But because I've seen that one enough I'm like I know what's going to happen to these poor people when this play is over and it's not comfortable for me. I'm proud that it does that but I often think that theater is meant to make people uncomfortable and but also have audience members, creative team, actors walk away with polarizing opinions or thoughts from it.

[10:01] Mary Dina: So I think totally agree.

[10:02] Jeff Talbott: Not all theater, right? Like like some theater is there to help you um let go of your day. You know and and I that is just that is not my interest when I sit down to write for the most part. I all of my plays aren't assaults either. Like a lot of my plays some of my plays they're all kind of about you know sad people I think or people uh challenges I think the the they're the more interesting people to probably write about.

[10:29] Mary Dina: I don't think you say yeah.

[10:30] Jeff Talbott: I mean, that's why I write what I write. Other people write different things. Other people are uh I think much more comforted by the world. I'm pretty uncomfortable with the world, by and large. I mean, I'm a fairly friendly guy, but I'm also like aware of the weight of life on people, and I try to uh honor those people and write about people who are who are in the middle of uh of the thunderstorm of life.

[10:53] Mary Dina: Yeah, would you say that you take what's going on in the world as a lot of your inspiration for when you sit down to write something?

[11:00] Jeff Talbott: I take I take what is happening to me in the world, you know. Um I'm not a I'm not a documentarian, and again, some some some makers really are. I'm not. I really w hope each time that I write something that it is a ride of some sort for an audience. Because the kind of theater that I like best is when it's over, I'm like, whoa, I mean, I feel like so many things happened to me in the last 90 minutes, two hours, two and a half hours. You know, that's just the kind of theater I like. I think writers write what they like, what they like to see.

[11:37] Mary Dina: Yeah.

[11:37] Jeff Talbott: And I think I think the writers who are less authentic, le voices that are less authentic, are writers who don't honor that. You know, and there's some really exciting writers working right now who really are challenging audiences. You know, it's uh a as theater currently is seeking out, you know, much a much wider pool of voices to talk about their experience. Some of those voices have some pretty challenging things to position in front of an audience.

[12:06] Mary Dina: That's right.

[12:06] Jeff Talbott: Yeah.

[12:07] Mary Dina: Or if we have heard, we haven't heard it from the perspective of of those particular writers or people within that story who exist within that who within the community.

[12:15] Jeff Talbott: That's right.

[12:16] Mary Dina: Exist within the community.

[12:17] Jeff Talbott: Um and there have been like this season, there have been some r really in your face plays. Um Slave Play comes to mind. There was a play that just closed at Lincoln Center called Mary Seacole by uh uh by the playwright who won the Pulitzer for her play Fairview. Fairview's a very challenging play. And I don't mean ch challenging in a negative sense at all, you know.

[12:37] Jeff Talbott: But for some people it feels negative. Some people don't have the night of that's not what they want.

[12:42] Mary Dina: That's right.

[12:43] Jeff Talbott: That's right. It's just not what I sit that's not what I write. You know, it's not and and every I've turned over plays to directors or theaters before, and I say, Well, when I started I thought it was gonna be a comedy.

[12:55] Jeff Talbott: But they just never turn out that way for me. I think there are laughs in my plays. Yeah. But when they start, when I usually when I start, I'm like, this one's gonna be a comedy. I'm gonna write a comedy. And by the end, like a baby is like maybe about to die, or like terrible things are about to happen. And it's not because that's what I set out to do, but it's what happens when I sit down to write.

[13:16] Mary Dina: So what did you originally go to undergrad for?

[13:19] Jeff Talbott: I went to undergrad for acting, got a BFA in acting, and I acted for many, many years solely. I acted for nine years in Chicago, and then was accepted into the Yale School of Drama as an actor and went to Yale. And while I was at Yale, I started writing. Yale is a really immersive acting program. I think I did 36 plays in three years as an actor. You're just always acting. It's part of the Yale aesthetic. You're always in multiple things. But there's a completely student-run theater at Yale that has no faculty oversight whatsoever. It's called the Yale Cabaret, it's been there for decades. It produces at night on the weekends after 11 p.m. It rehearses at night after all classes and rehearsals are over after 11 p.m. And I wrote a couple of plays, and everything in there is like 60 to 65 minutes at the cabaret.

And I wrote a couple of things that were produced by the cabaret. I had, I think if I had been brave, I've answered this question to many people the same way. So if anybody is listening that's ever heard me talk, I say this a lot, but it's true. I think if I had been brave from the beginning, I wouldn't have been an actor at all. I would have been a writer. And I've had, continue to have a successful career as an actor. And people who really appreciate what I do as an actor. And sometimes I'm one of them. Like sometimes I think, oh yeah, I was kind of awesome in that. But I was afraid to be a writer. I did in undergrad take one playwriting class, and my memory of it is that that teacher was very unsupportive.

And I just recently, and by recently I mean in the last year, was cleaning out things in my mother's home and found plays like 10 minutes, seven minute, five minute plays I wrote for that class. And he actually was supportive. But he did say to me then, and it's in writing in some of those things, like you don't approach plays, you don't approach your writing the way other writers working today do. I think it will be hard for you. And I took that as disencouragement and was like, Well, you know, I'll just stick with acting because that's also an impossible career, but at least there are more actors in a play than a playwright. I would think that he would have taken it the opposite way and said, We need your voice.

[15:27] Brian Sedita: Okay, there you go.

[15:28] Jeff Talbott: You know, there you go. Yeah, he'd been at it for many, many years, and I think he thought he was doing me a kindness. Yeah, saving you. Yeah, and I was also like a scared person, like a lot of people are, and it was just enough. Look, if I talk to a room full of people as an acting mentor brought in, I'm one of those people who will lay out how difficult the career is because all careers in the arts are difficult and they come laced with pain because it's a difficult lifestyle unless you are miraculously lucky. But it's a hard lifestyle. That's just part and parcel with it. I do think the rewards are great if you really want to do it. But I think it's important to lay out if you scare somebody enough early on, then they probably didn't have the medal to do it anyway because it's hard.

And definitely as a writer, he scared me enough that, and I didn't have the medal for it then, and I kind of put it aside. But it was always going on in the back of my head. I always wanted to do it. And when I got to grad school, I was like, well, here's a playground. I can play a little bit. And a couple of my plays got produced. They went over very, very well there. And still I was pretty afraid of it and got out of acting grad school from the Yale School of Drama, which opened a lot of doors and was super helpful for me, and hit the ground running as an actor, and then just quietly wrote in the background. But then I wrote this play that became the submission. It was actually called something else in early drafts, but I wrote this play that I started sending around and people got interested in it.

And some very lucky things happened that never happened. Like a theater found it in a pile. The guy who was in charge of picking plays found it. His name's Steven Willems. He found it. He believed in it. He called me and he said, I really like this play. I want to show it to my artistic directors. Will you take some notes and rewrite? And I was like, sure. And he gave me some notes and I rewrote. We presented it to his artistic directors. They all believed in it. They submitted it for a brand new award that hadn't existed before then, and I won it. And that award gave me a lot of money, and it gave them even more money to produce the play, and they produced the play off Broadway. And then it won another big award.

So I got, and the money was super helpful. That was really it. I hate awards, but it's nice to win them. But I do, I really deeply dislike setting artists against each other. But when you win them, momentarily it feels really great. But more so for me, what it did was give me a permission slip to do something that I had been afraid of. You know, I got some money, which helped for a little bit, but money goes away. But I got like a little check mark from the universe saying, if you want to do this, you might be okay at it. And I sat down every day from then on and wrote. And from then on, and this is now, that would be 2010, nine years ago, I write every day.

[18:24] Mary Dina: Wow.

[18:24] Jeff Talbott: And it's because I got a little permission slip from the universe. You know, if it was a permission slip I could have given myself, which I think is more important for artists, it would have been great, but it was too scary for me. So I got that as a nod that you might be okay with this. And to go back to your original question about how do you self-identify as an artist? The difference between how I feel as an actor and how I feel as a writer is as an actor, I recognize why people respond to what I do. I'm skilled, I'm good at it. I don't feel personally that I'm special at it. I feel like a journeyman. I feel like what I have to offer is solid. And I know that some people really love it, but I'm always like, well, you know, somebody else would be better at it, but I got lucky and got this job.

I don't feel that way as a writer. When I sit down to write, I think nobody could tell this story as well as me. They could tell it from a different vantage point. They could do it in many, many different ways, but what I have to offer, I personally feel is special, and that hasn't faded. And so it's easy to identify as a writer if that's true.

[19:32] Mary Dina: I love that perspective because I think that all theater makers, I think that can be applied to all theater makers as great advice of just ownership.

[19:41] Jeff Talbott: That's right.

[19:42] Mary Dina: And just knowing that that confidence that you can only present yourself. And it's different than saying what I do is good too. Like I don't know that that's true because good is different to every person viewing or reading. But to me, my viewpoint feels special because it's my viewpoint. I don't feel that way as an actor, oddly. I mean, I do think that one of the reasons my career as an actor has had some highs and lows is I definitely come at things from a different direction when I'm acting than a lot of other actors. I usually go with choice B right away, which some directors like and some directors don't. So some directors like me more than others. Some audiences respond to me more than others, but usually if something comes out of my mouth, it's not the way you would think that line was the first choice.

[20:27] Brian Sedita: I'm wondering how one helps the other for you. So how does writing and acting help acting? And how does acting inform how you approach writing characters and writing arcs?

[20:39] Jeff Talbott: Well, I think that I definitely think that my dialogue is super actable because of my experience as an actor. Like I know how to read a line even internally and know how somebody will say it. They might say it differently than I think in my head, which is the thing I was just saying about coming at it from a different direction. But I have a very natural relationship to dialogue that comes from my relationship to it as an actor.

[21:09] Mary Dina: I think I would agree with that. From the submission that I read, I was telling Brian that I was able to just, it felt very natural that it felt like I could hear the voices. Exactly. And I, but also the flow of it just felt, and I know that you had said earlier with the dashes, and I picked up on that too of how words aren't being finished. But it's, so I, yeah, I'm curious as to how that is for you to write that and to think that in mind because I think one thing that separates me from other writers, I just, a new play of mine is having a small production in Atlanta next month. I'm going down to see it, and I had I Skyped with them last week and I was talking to them because they were asking me about my cutoffs.

A lot of writers today write, they'll write a line of dialogue that has a cutoff, but they'll put a slash in the middle of the line, telling the actor who follows with the next line where they're gonna interrupt. I don't do that. And a lot of directors I've worked with have said, could you please put slashes in so I can help orchestrate this? And I start your vocabulary.

[22:07] Jeff Talbott: It's well, because I don't want to take away the freedom from another, from an actor, and this is my acting tying into how I write.

[22:15] Mary Dina: Right, or to know when to cut off because another actor might hear the incoming line differently than the actor after them, and I want to give them the freedom to cut off where they think it's the right time to cut off. But what I always say to actors or directors working on my stuff, and I try to make sure this is clear in my notes at the beginning, if there's a dash, I inevitably 100% of the time mean two voices at the same time. It's up to you to decide how that happens. But it means that there's always a lot of dovetailing in my dialogue. And if there's a period, I mean you don't cut that person off. Like you might butt up against it, but I try to treat it like you score music, which doesn't separate me from a lot of writers, but I don't want to be too dictatorial about that. And I think that is because I started as an actor.

[23:02] Brian Sedita: But how does if you're working on a play with a director or an actor that may not feel the same way as you with the punctuation? How do you guys deal with and hash out what the final product is going to be on stage?

[23:15] Jeff Talbott: I think one thing I do know that one thing that separates me from a lot of writers is I'm very open to many different interpretations.

[23:56] Jeff Talbott: Five scenes down the road. And if you let them get too used to that emotional response to that scene, you're not gonna be able to unwire it because they're gonna be used to what they're doing. And he was like, Well, I don't generally like to disencourage actors from exploring something. I'm like, they can explore it all they want, but five days from now, I'm once again gonna say, now they can't, you know, now you're hurting the play because they're telling a different story. I forgot what I was answering. I've wandered away.

[24:25] Brian Sedita: If do you how do you move on if you have a disagreement?

[24:31] Jeff Talbott: I just very rarely have a disagreement. Usually what I think when it's different from what I thought is it's awesome.

[24:36] Brian Sedita: Yeah.

[24:37] Jeff Talbott: Usually I'm like, well, I never thought of that. That's so cool. Or like a lot of times, and Brian has worked with me, you know, if an actor will ask me a direct question about a thing, I don't like to answer it. Like I usually say, I can tell you what my opinion is.

[24:55] Brian Sedita: Like history things, like what do you think happened before? Why am I doing this?

[25:00] Jeff Talbott: And I don't think it's my job to answer that because my opinion might be different than yours. I guess I'm just wondering, but so do you not do you not view that your characters have grown from you? And that by an extension that you would know some of those answers?

[25:17] Jeff Talbott: Right, but I might be wrong. Because I'm not living inside of it. Once actors, you know, it's the oldest thing in the book. Writing is an incredibly solitary act. It's very, very lonely and freeing, but very isolating. But each person that gets in, yes, and each person that gets added to the process expands what the thing can be.

[25:40] Jeff Talbott: Then a director joins and starts asking questions, and the play, particularly plays, starts to change because there's another voice in the room. Then designers join and they ask questions. It changes because other people are asking questions, and actors join and everything changes. Actors are always, always 100% of the time, the magic sauce. Always because they immediately know more than you do. And any writer who isn't vulnerable to that is protecting their ego. The actors from the first time they say it out loud know more than you. Now they may ultimately choose a road that isn't, as I was saying, like isn't productive for what you know the play wants, the story, what the play wants to do.

But I often talk when talking about writing in general, and my writing in specific, is your job as a creator of it? It's the old adage of writing is rewriting, but it's true. That's why the first third of writing is always so horrible because you don't know what it is. It's like learning a new language. Writing a play or acting in a play, but particularly writing a play is like learning a completely foreign language and you don't know it when you start. And you're in this new country and you don't know where you are, and all you want to do is go to the bathroom, right? And so you're like finding people and trying to ask, where's the bathroom? Where's the bathroom? And they're like, they don't understand what you're saying because you're not speaking the same language and you really have to go.

But about halfway through the play in the writing process, you've started to be able to speak the language, and you can then like go to the bathroom. And then in the last part, you don't have to ask anybody anything, so if you have to go, you can go. You know, so there's like these three, that's why the first part is so hard because you can get, now my metaphor is gonna get me in trouble. Yeah, yeah. You can be like, you can be totally constipated in the first part because you can't go. But it becomes better and better as it goes along because you can speak the language. That's moving. And I think, yeah, literally. But I think that writers who don't give in to that have a kind of ego about their writing, and I'm kind of egoless about it in a way.

Like again, I think what I have to do, what I have to offer is kind of special, but I often finish it. Most, I know a lot of writers who finish a draft and like, this is awesome. This is the one. And I finish a draft and I'm like, well, that might suck. But at least I think it's the start of the questions that I want to ask.

[28:05] Mary Dina: So you view your writing process as a collaboration.

[28:09] Jeff Talbott: Always.

[28:09] Mary Dina: So who would you say if you're looking at like the creative team folding in actors and such, who is like the go-to person?

[28:18] Jeff Talbott: The director.

[28:18] Mary Dina: The director, as far as receiving feedback.

[28:22] Jeff Talbott: The director. Oh because you have to have somebody who is the focusing agent for that feedback. And there is a danger from, I think, you know there's a danger in a rehearsal room for not knowing who's in charge. Actors as a whole, if it's herding kittens, they get very, very afraid if they don't know who the mama cat is. Hierarchy. That's right. And there are directors who don't establish, and it's not even about authority, but it is about leadership. Well, they're also, sorry, they're also looking at the show from like the beginning to the end. That's right. From all aspects. And they're interpreting the writing. Now actors are usually a little selfish. Well, actors are interpreting the writing too, but they're interpreting the character.

Right. And the director is interpreting the entire story. And especially on new plays, once you start rehearsal, it's still in flux. Yeah, it's not a thing yet. It's all clay and you're making a statue. When you finish a draft of a play, it's the most exciting time because you're like, well, now I can really get to work. Because I've got a hundred and twenty pages that is gonna become something else, but at least now I know what it wants to be. It tells me my job if I'm doing my job right is to listen to it, not to try to tell it what to be, but to listen to it. Because always, again, 100% of the time, the play becomes something that I never thought it would be. When I finish, by the time we get to opening night, but even by the time I finish a draft that I've shown somebody, it is never what I thought it was gonna be when I started. Ever.

[29:58] Mary Dina: Yeah, I totally relate to that. I ended up writing, I think, a one act in grad school and had never written anything like that before. And I so badly had this plan for this end of semester goal, and I was forcing it and forcing it. And I got like, I think to spring break, and I was like, why am I doing this?

[30:18] Jeff Talbott: Yeah. Why? You have to listen to it. I mean, I think your job as a writer is to listen to the thing that's happening and it's killing the character because it doesn't kill your darlings is something that I can tell you. Yeah. It's one of the hard things about writing for an actor or writing for somebody. I have tried to write roles for friends many times, and by the time the play is, if I start a piece of writing, I'm like, okay, I'm gonna, here's a role that I have a very, very, very close friend who is like a genius actor. He's one of the best actors I know. And I have like three times in my life tried to write him a role, and every time by the time the show, by the time I'm done writing, he doesn't fit in the play anymore.

Because the play tells me. The play is like, oh no, no, no, it's not that, it's not that. Oh, okay, but I really want my friend to be in it. And, you know, beyond the fact that I would have no control over that anyway, because I would have no control over that. The play usually tells me something different. It's also why I don't, one of the reasons why I don't do table readings with my friends when a play is over. Because you don't want them to hold on to. Or also because it's just not helpful. It's not helpful for me anymore. Like I, it's gratifying. Once you've written something, it's great to hear it out loud. You feel so special and so great because you're hearing the things you wrote out loud, but it doesn't, it's not particularly helpful for me because I know what my dialogue sounds like.

I know how long a page will take. Like this play that's about to happen in Atlanta, they did the submission. That's how they began a relationship with me years ago. And I remember the director who was the same director who was directing this new play called me right before they went into tech and he said, How long should this play be? And I said it should be somewhere between an hour thirty-seven and an hour forty-one. An hour thirty-six is too short, I found in New York. Then they were running about an hour fifty-five, and I'm afraid I'm gonna have to put an intermission in. And I said, First of all, you can't. Contractually, you can't. Like you know, I, because it happened to me once, somebody put an intermission to that play and I found out.

No, no, no, but I did find out on the back end that a theater company put an intermission to that play and I had to add a clause to the contract. I don't know where you would put one. Exactly. Yeah. Because it was running too long. Because it is, it's not ninety minutes. That play is ninety is a great length because plays usually start eight minutes late. So it's still gonna be an hour forty. They're sitting there for a while. So anything over ninety gets to be tough for audience members who want to get up. Not that there aren't like Circle Mirror Transformation, which is a fantastic play, is about an hour fifty, an hour fifty-five. You know, that's how that play wants to be. Some people don't like that intermissionless form, but that's how that play wants to be.

But if I'm writing without an intermission, I aim for like ninety to ninety-three. Um so anyway, this director called me and he said we're running like an hour fifty-five, and I I'm afraid I'm gonna have to put an intermission, and I said, You can't. And he said, Well, I don't know how to get it shorter. I said, They're not talking fast enough. Yeah, that's what I'm saying. It, I read it so fast. Like I just, the dialogue just was like natural, and sometimes I'd go back and just reread it to make sure I was like catching it all, but he said, he and I remember him saying, Well, they're, it seems like they're talking fast, and I said, I said I think I've misspoken. I don't mean, I said talking fast enough is the wrong thing.

They're not listening fast enough, and they're definitely not cutting each other off. And he said, Oh, he said, Well, they cut off where your dashes are. I said, No, no, no. The dash is an invitation to talk at the same time. They have to talk at the same time. Life sounds chaotic to me. That's how I hear the world. I hear people talking at the same time. That's what I want in my plays. So I try to, I've tried to hone language that makes that clear to somebody who isn't used to working on my work that I want people talking at the same time. I try to be clear about that. And if there's a period, it means they're not talking at the same time. And in my head, I know what that sounds like, and when people hit that, they know.

And I often tell actors who are working on my stuff for the first time, we're used to, we're trained to be polite as actors. We're trained to like listen to the other person and give them their due and then respond in kind. That's not how life works. That's not what people do. What people do is talk and listen at the same time. That's what I want in my plays. And it's difficult. I, it's a high technical act in my work, and I tell actors every time it's going to feel uncomfortable until it's happening. Because usually you don't start to listen as an actor until like long after you've memorized it. You're trying to just do. And I say to everyone, I just said it to this group in Atlanta last week.

You have to get off book quick more quickly than you would in other things, so that you can train yourself to listen and talk at the same time because that's what we do in life. And once you do it, I promise my dialogue is going to feel easier than some other people's. You're gonna feel like you're just talking to people because that's what I want.

[35:24] Mary Dina: You said that you don't have any say in the casting process but do you have a say in the direction process picking your director for whatever you are writing.

[35:33] Jeff Talbott: You have say, it's a collaboration. Yeah. You know, picking a director there are a couple of directors one of whom Brian and I have both worked with he's developed a lot of my work he's one of my favorite favorite people to work on new things with I was wondering you know you probably form a really good relationship with that person they know how you you're working and know not necessarily the world of your plays because you said that you don't have a constant right with all of them but just the way that you write and the way that you and how I develop things I mean I'm a big rewriter I rewrite yeah a lot I like changing colors I change things all the time and the person I'm talking about his name's Wes Grantham he's a fantastic director.

Wes is very used to, very used to well he's very used to working on new work but he's very used to working on my new work because we've developed like six, seven plays together and he knows, he knows to trust he just read a draft of this new thing that seems pretty much on track to be produced by a big theater in like a year and a half before it was even done the theater got interested in it which is super exciting. But he just read this new draft and we had a meeting about it and he was like, Stop writing just stop because I know I know what you're trying to do and we're and we already have a workshop on the calendar for like ten months from now and he said you're in good shape it's very clear what it wants to be wait because we're gonna get in a room with actors and you're gonna do all the stuff that anything I would ask you now you're gonna do with those actors.

The play Brian and I did together wasn't true. Like he read the first draft and he said I see what you're trying to do. I don't really understand it yet but I'm excited by the possibility of it keep going. But that's because we trust each other enough to say that to each other. So that's one of the reasons why I think a lot of writers tend to work with the same directors all the time. Andy Baker works a lot with Sam Gold, Halle Pfeiffer works a lot with Trip Coleman like they tend to try to work with the same people. I work with Wes and I work with a woman named Jen Thompson. It's not that I'm averse to working with other people but I also tend to work with the people that I think are best at their job.

Then it becomes a conversation like when you're trying to select a director for a work if it's being produced in New York the writer has right of refusal, has veto power over everything. You know, you can say no like I don't want to cast that person. I don't want that person to direct my play.

[38:02] Mary Dina: Is that just in New York?

[38:04] Jeff Talbott: It's true for new work. There's a boilerplate kind of contract I think from the Dramatists Guild and the writer always technically has that last say.

[38:19] Jeff Talbott: With great power comes great responsibility. Like you have to use it judiciously or you can get yourself in trouble. So you can't say no to everything. So you have to pick and choose battles.

[38:29] Jeff Talbott: Like you know, if a theater is dead set, if producers are dead set against something, then you're probably never going to win that fight. And you have to know when to pick up your toys and leave, and you also have to know when to stand firm. Like, um, like I lost that battle a couple of times on my first play, and I learned a lot from it, you know. And there are battles I'm willing to lose and battles I'm not. And I know when's I I've started to know when is the right time to really plant my feet and say no, that is not okay with me.

[39:02] Mary Dina: So I have a question about your relationship with theater companies. Um, in New York or regionally, so you apply. You submit your shows basically.

[39:10] Jeff Talbott: I have an agent who does it, but yes.

[39:13] Mary Dina: Yeah.

[39:13] Jeff Talbott: Yeah.

[39:14] Mary Dina: Um, or they can come across it organically, however that is. So when you're in that conversation with the theater company, with the literary agent, whoever that may be, how do you choose what theater is the right theater for you?

[39:19] Jeff Talbott: I try to be, uh, uh, with my f— I've had a couple of agents as a writer, and my first one, which was a complicated relationship that I learned a lot from, but that agent tended to just send everything everywhere. And my current agent is a very thoughtful guy. His name's Ben Izo, he's fantastic. We have very similar aesthetics. We think about theater a lot in the same way, and he doesn't send everything everywhere. Like when I finish a draft, he's like, well, I think it's good for this theater, this theater, and this theater strategically.

[39:43] Mary Dina: That's right.

[39:59] Jeff Talbott: Yeah. Because if you keep—if you send a theater, it's less important each time.

[40:03] Mary Dina: That's right.

[40:03] Jeff Talbott: If they don't start to trust that you at least know what they produce. So if I'm sending plays places, I'll look at their season. Like if I'm submitting to festivals of new plays, which is—that's not on an agent, that's usually me who's doing it. I look at their last couple of seasons and make sure that what they've done kind of lines up with what I do. The play that Brian and I did together at Montclair was called Civics and Humanities for Non-Majors. That my agent isn't really—I mean, he would send that out, but it's too big to be done in most theaters. It was written for twelve.

[40:36] Mary Dina: Yeah, it's a cast of twelve, which is very hard to produce in most theaters because it's just too big.

[40:42] Jeff Talbott: And that was the directive from the beginning. I was commissioned to write it by the theater department who wanted something that was at least eleven actors. I chose twelve because that's the story I wanted to tell. My agent can't really send it out much, so I've taken it upon myself, and I sent it in December. My writing goal that month was to send it to a bunch of universities. But I sent it to a hundred and thirty universities over the course of three or four weeks. But every university that I sent it to, I went to their website and made sure that they produce things that at least look like they live in the world of what I do. If they do only musicals or if they do like only comedies, you know, if they don't do contemporary drama, um, then this isn't the right play to send them.

At that time, a great play to a lot of colleges are doing The Wolves by Sarah DeLapp, which is a fantastic play. A lot of colleges are doing that. That play being on a season at a college was a great indicator that might be a great place to send this particular play because Civics and Humanities has a lot of overlapping dialogue and complicated thematic ideas. Lots of listening.

[41:45] Mary Dina: So what I think is so interesting about other people doing that play is that you wrote it to our strengths.

[41:51] Jeff Talbott: I did. Yeah.

[41:52] Mary Dina: Yeah.

[41:52] Jeff Talbott: But that's put a lot of personal things in there. But that's true of every play. The first production of every play gets built on the actors who are doing it. And every play.

[42:03] Mary Dina: Wow.

[42:06] Jeff Talbott: Yes. I mean, I think some writers are less open to that in the room, but you have to at some point recognize the thing I'm trying to force that actor to do is not organic to them. I'll have to adjust. Now, there's something you have to stand firm on. There are story points that you can't change. You know, like this has to happen for the story to proceed. If that isn't within that actor's wheelhouse, I can write around that to a certain extent, but not always. But Civics and Humanities was built very much on this group of twelve people, and more so than others, I think it got really built to you guys' strengths and personality students.

[42:46] Mary Dina: You were, but also college students. The play was, as you'll recall, in its early drafts, like still very, uh, very what it wanted to attack was formed thought, or those questions were strong, but the way that I wanted to ask those questions was something I was still figuring out. I was still learning to speak the language.

[43:04] Jeff Talbott: Yeah.

[43:06] Mary Dina: Um, other plays, by the time they get to a theater, I at least know what the language is. But it's always built on the backs of those actors. Like the first production of the submission, there are things in that play in its published, produced form now that came from those four actors because they were the first ones to do it. So in my mind, I always picture those four people when I read that play because they're the people I built the town with. That's the—they were the first inhabitants of the town.

[43:34] Mary Dina: What would you say is the biggest challenge of getting your piece from page to stage?

[43:41] Jeff Talbott: The biggest challenge is what every artist has, like getting somebody to notice me. You know, I'm lucky. I've had some advantages, and I think some people know who I am, but it's getting anything noticed, getting noticed as an actor, getting any job is a miracle. Because it's impossible. They're all impossible careers. They just are. Until they're not. But like getting any job is a miracle. So the hardest part is all of it. I had—I’ve been in some early meetings with a producer who's looking at a play of mine for commercial production. Whether that will happen or not is a great question, but you know, these talks are ongoing and it's exciting. And I was asked, like, what's your dream for this play? And do you get interviewed when they're gonna take on a play of yours, a theater company?

[44:32] Jeff Talbott: Uh, well, this is an independent producer.

[44:34] Mary Dina: Okay.

[44:35] Jeff Talbott: So, um, so it was kind of an interview, but yeah, but this producer is already, um, yeah, really loves the play and is really interested in trying to get it to an audience, which is great. But I was asked, like, what's your dream? And my answer was I'm a New York playwright. I'm conditioned to dream for one thing, a reading somewhere. I hope somebody gets to have a reading. Like I'm not like, oh, I hope it goes to Broadway. That's not what I'm conditioned to dream for. And so all I ever dream for is like I just like to keep working on it. Because if that's where I set my goal, then it makes every day, um, uh, achievable. Even if it's being produced, even if it's at, you know, Manhattan Theater Club or Playwrights Horizons or any of the places I would love to have a play produced, if my goal every day is to just keep working on it, then I'm just at work. I'm just doing my thing, and the stakes remain high only insofar as they affect me.

[45:36] Mary Dina: Mm-hmm.

[45:36] Jeff Talbott: And what I want, my job every day is to make the thing that I'm working on the most awesome that I can. That's the whole goal. Because the other things you can't control. Like I cannot control what the marketplace is looking for right now. I can't control that I'm a 54-year-old white dude telling stories about a lot of different kinds of people, but there are different lenses that are being sought out now as they should be, and I can't control that my lens may not be the particular lens that is being sought, being actively sought out. It doesn't mean that people still don't notice what I do. But trying to match that, trying to meet that, just using that as an example, is a mistake because it means that I'm not writing what I want to write.

The only way to be successful in any of the field in any field you choose as an artist is the be true to yourself thing. Like I have to sit down and write what I want to write every day. When I act, when I go into a room to audition, I have to bring into the room what I think it will be. If it's for them, fantastic. If it's not, it doesn't mean I failed. It means what they're doing doesn't match what I would want to do, and I wouldn't want to do it with them anyway.

[46:49] Mary Dina: So as an actor, I try—and this isn't a hundred percent of the time true, but it's true a lot of the time. I feel as much that I'm auditioning them as they're auditioning me. Because if they say things I—if the director says things about that play that I don't agree with, then I have to decide if that's how—if that's do I want to do that. Yeah. Or is this gonna be uncomfortable for all of us and maybe I should not go to the callback if I'm invited to. Um, not that that happens that often, but I try to pay attention to that, or at least if I disagree with them and I get the job, I go in forearmed with the knowledge of, well, you know, we'll find out.

[47:27] Mary Dina: Yeah.

[47:28] Jeff Talbott: That doesn't happen that often, to be honest. Like by the time you get a job, it's probably because you all agree on your approach or the story you're going to be telling. That's—and that's true as a writer too. By the time we get to the rehearsal room, the director and I, whoever it is, agree on the story that we want to tell, and we're all trying to tell the same story. But you can see when you go to the theater, and it's very, very rare, you can see when everybody succeeded in telling the same story, from actor to writer to director, to designers to production. And the ones that are very successful, Hamilton is very successful, not just because it's a terrific piece of writing, but because everybody was telling the same story. Fun Home was another great example of that, I think, Dear Evan Hansen. The things that tend to be super successful are because everybody was doing the same thing.

[48:16] Mary Dina: Yeah.

[48:17] Jeff Talbott: And it's very rare because it's hard to do because people come in as artists with different points of view and sometimes they clash. The Band's Visit was a great example last year of a piece of theater where everybody was doing the same thing. Other things that seem less successful, it isn't because they weren't trying to do the same thing, but it's just because they didn't get there. They didn't get across the finish line telling the same story. Or telling the same story in the same way. And it's rare because it's hard to do because artists all have their own opinions about what to do.

[48:50] Mary Dina: How did writing for music come into play in your life?

[48:54] Jeff Talbott: I knew I always knew that I wanted to, and I reached out to a young composer named Will Van Dyck one day just out of the blue because I liked the stuff he had written, and we got together and had very similar aesthetics and started writing a musical like the next day.

[49:11] Mary Dina: Wow.

[49:11] Jeff Talbott: And we've now written over a hundred songs and we have four musicals, and we write every day together. We talk on the phone every day. We're like, we're very sympatico as artists. We're of two different generations, which I think sometimes lends a really interesting tension to our work.

[49:26] Mary Dina: Um, what's that process like, you know, when you sit, like writing a song?

[49:30] Jeff Talbott: Yeah.

[49:31] Mary Dina: Uh, music first, lyrics first.

[49:33] Jeff Talbott: It depends on the song. Um, the further along we get in our—well, this isn't always true. I was gonna say the further along we get in our relationship, it's often more lyric first. Um, but that isn't always true. Um, we've done a lot of songs where you come up with the melody or does he? I never—nope, the music is all him. The lyrics is both of us, but it tends to be more on my plate than his plate. Um, and we—you know, like if I turn over a song to him, sometimes I'll say if we're writing for a specific thing in a musical, like I'll give him a little scene and say there's a song here I don't quite know what it is. Sometimes I turn over a whole lyric to him that then he messes with, and then we go back and forth with to make—once he's got an idea of what it will be, we change the lyrics to fit that.

Um, but sometimes I just say I know that they are fighting right now. I know that he's mad at her. I know that—I don't think it's a sad song. I know that, um, it's not a ballad. I think it's a mid-tempo. Like we have—you know, like I can lay out what I think it works within the scheme of the show, but whatever he does is always so magical and mysterious to me and is never what I think it's was going to be when it was in my head. And I think that's true, vice versa. Like what I come up with lyrically is never what he thought it was going to be, and we work very well together. We also really like each other personally, which is helpful. I'm very invested in each other's personal success. I think that's helpful. He's a very big fan of my plays. He's written music for several of my plays when they were produced. Um, I find the process very undifferent from writing plays.

[51:12] Mary Dina: Really?

[51:13] Jeff Talbott: The rules are different. Although our musicals, I think it's why we've yet to be produced, and I think one of the reasons we've yet to be produced is our musicals are a little different than other musicals.

[51:23] Jeff Talbott: They're book heavy, um, because they operate like plays with songs, but they might have twenty songs in them. But we tend to really weave in and out of dialogue and music um, uh more than other musicals, which is interesting because our songs are written in a pop vernacular, so people expect the dialogue to stop and somebody to sing a song, but in our musicals those two things tend to happen at the same time and weave in and out of each other. That happens in a lot of musicals, but it's more true than not in our writing, um than I think in some other shows. So I think it makes them a little complicated for people to take in because we're trying to do something slightly different. Just slightly different.

Like we're not trying to reinvent the wheel, but like every writing team, our musicals are ours. I mean, you know, I'm very excited for the potential of a couple of all of them, but you know, musicals much more so than plays. Plays take forever and musicals take an infinity. Like it's just like it's forever to get somebody to notice a musical because they're very expensive to do. We aren't writing, we don't ever, we're not aiming for the commercial marketplace, but ultimately every musical ends up being looked at for the commercial marketplace.

[52:40] Mary Dina: Where would you say that you're aiming?

[52:43] Jeff Talbott: Not for profit. Like I when I'm writing always like, well, this would be great at Playwrights Horizons. Or this would be great at Manhattan Theater Club, or this would be great at the Vineyard. You know, like that's the size of place that we tend to think about when we write. I think a lot of artists in New York do, a lot of writers do. But once those institutions get interested in a musical, they're usually looking at what is the potential for it beyond us. Like what is the potential? Is it potentially a Broadway show?

[53:11] Brian Sedita: Yeah.

[53:11] Jeff Talbott: But Broadway is so, you know, it's just one thing. It is just one thing and not that it's one type of show. It's just one place to do a show.

[53:20] Mary Dina: That's right. Well, I wanted to get your opinion, your thoughts on just the commercial aspect of Broadway and how you view that with off-Broadway and the art that's well there on the stage.

[53:31] Jeff Talbott: There's two kinds of off-Broadway. There's the not for profit and the profit model, and the for profit model doesn't exist for musicals anymore because they're too expensive. I was just talking with a friend about it this week. There's this production of Fiddler on the Roof done entirely in Yiddish that is at a wonderful production. So I've been told I've heard it's phenomenal, but it's being done at an off-Broadway theater and it's big. You know, it's got like a nineteen piece orchestra. I don't know. Big cast. It's impossible for that to turn a profit. Like I'm sure their hope is for it to, and they've tried to finance it so that it does turn a profit, but the marketplace isn't there. Used to be a marketplace for profit musicals off-Broadway. It doesn't exist anymore.

[54:12] Brian Sedita: Yeah, 'cause when you were just naming all those theaters, the first thing I think of is not musical.

[54:17] Jeff Talbott: That's right.

[54:18] Brian Sedita: Uh, theater companies.

[54:19] Jeff Talbott: That's right. Yeah. Um, so off-Broadway, you're usually looking at the Playwrights Horizons, you know, I keep using them as an example, but they're, you know, that's one of the premier places in town and they do do musicals. If you're listening, Playwrights Horizons.

[54:33] Mary Dina: Oh.

[54:34] Jeff Talbott: But they're here.

[54:35] Brian Sedita: Yes.

[54:36] Jeff Talbott: But they often come in with some sort of commercial backing from a producer who is at least interested in helping to finance those shows because they're expensive and everybody hopes that they move on from that venue. As a writer, I just don't think that way. I probably would be more successful if I did, but it cramps my style in a way that isn't helpful for writing. Like I'd rather just say, well I wish this was in front of a hundred and ninety-nine people. And if it was, this is what it would look like and this is what it would sound like. And that's one of the reasons why I think The Band's Visit was very successful artistically. I think it had a ultimately kind of a complicated journey in the commercial market making money, but it didn't seem to me like they were aiming for 999 or 149 seats. They were always writing a very small story and they very successfully mounted it on a Broadway stage.

[55:30] Mary Dina: That's right.

[55:31] Jeff Talbott: And that, and that because I kind of wish I had seen it at the Atlantic. I wish I had because that's what it seems like it wanted to do. So many shows that start in such smaller houses and it's like you wish you were there to witness it with a crowd that intimately. The Broadway commercial theater is largely the space I think in Broadway houses. Some things just don't work.

[55:54] Brian Sedita: Yeah, and it's dominated now by a kind of writing that is largely the jukebox musical or the epic things that the movies.

[55:54] Jeff Talbott: The movies.

[56:05] Brian Sedita: Yeah.

[56:05] Jeff Talbott: The movies being turned into musicals. And that's about name recognition. And then they hire, by and large, writers, especially those movie studios that are turning musicals into movies, they take chances on already established pop writers who don't know, who are learning how to write in the musical theater vernacular. And some of them are more successful at it than others. So Sara Bareilles is fantastic at it. Waitress is a fantastic piece of writing. You know, others are less or more successful based on who they hired to turn that movie into a musical. And I honestly don't know if that's a paradigm to make good art. I think that I think the best art comes when it's driven by a creator who is passionate to tell the story, not by outside sources who hired people to write that story.

Because it comes from a personal place, because that's a story somebody's dying to tell. It doesn't mean that it can't be successful. There are countless stories of producers hiring writers to write things that turn out to be really great musicals. But our current crop of things doesn't, I think, advertise the quality of that paradigm personally, in every case.

[57:32] Mary Dina: Even things that turn out sucking.

[57:33] Jeff Talbott: That's so true. People were trying to make something amazing.

[57:36] Brian Sedita: Yeah.

[57:37] Jeff Talbott: They just were. They weren't trying to like make it bad. There's a really great book. I, there are many things that I, there, well, I mean, there are probably like five things I suggest every maker to read. Like Bird by Bird by Anne Lamott, if you want to write, is the book everybody should read. I think all actors should read it. It's a great book about the creative process. But there's a great book written by, uh, I think his name is Glen Berger, the guy who wrote Song of Spider-Man, the musical. Oh, and he wrote a book called Song of Spider-Man. Oh, yes, yes, yes. That is about that process. I started reading that. And it's a phenomenal book. It's in my Amazon shopping cart.

[58:15] Mary Dina: You should get it tomorrow.

[58:17] Jeff Talbott: Or go to your public library.

[58:18] Mary Dina: Or go to your public library.

[58:20] Jeff Talbott: That's right.

[58:20] Mary Dina: Or get a public library.

[58:21] Jeff Talbott: I know you do. But it's a great book because you want to read it because that show was a very famous flop, right? Because it was too expensive and it didn't work. So you start that book thinking, I'm gonna get the dish. And it's in there, but it's a very sincere piece of writing from the guy who was writing it about how they were trying to make something great. And I found the book really moving because it reminded me that that insane musical, because that musical was insane. I did see it. Was written by people who were trying to make something amazing because they were. And if it didn't work, well, that's just how it goes. I often, if I'm seeing something, would prefer to see something that is a crazy swing and a miss than something that is like just kind of okay. Or immediately everything else is doing.

[59:14] Mary Dina: That's right.

[59:15] Jeff Talbott: Yeah. I would much rather see a failure that isn't boring than something that is just like, yeah, well, that's every other play. That's every other musical. Because at least the people who made the thing that's a crazy failure were trying to do something. But they also did it. Like they did the thing. Even if it didn't, even if the end result wasn't what they had hoped for. They still, they got it up. They got it up on a stage.

[59:34] Brian Sedita: Yep.

[59:34] Jeff Talbott: In front of an audience.

[59:35] Mary Dina: Yeah.

[59:36] Jeff Talbott: So like, you know, and we're trying to seek out other people to appreciate what they did. If it doesn't work, if it doesn't work out, it doesn't work out. But it very rarely completely does. It's very rare that everybody loves something, you know. Not everybody eats at the same restaurant. You know, and if you write, you know, if you write and you're not making food that everybody wants to eat, it doesn't mean that there aren't people who want to eat that food. You just have to find the people that want to eat at your restaurant.

[1:00:03] Mary Dina: We're asking all of our guests as the last question. What was the last?

[1:00:06] Jeff Talbott: And it really ties into what we were just saying.

[1:00:09] Brian Sedita: Yeah.

[1:00:10] Jeff Talbott: What was the last great piece of theater that you saw?

[1:00:13] Jeff Talbott: Oh, oh, well, that's an easy, doesn't have to be the last.

[1:00:15] Jeff Talbott: No, no, that's easy.

[1:00:16] Jeff Talbott: Yeah.

[1:00:16] Jeff Talbott: That's easy because it's the thing I think everybody, I think I have a feeling.

[1:00:19] Mary Dina: What do you think I'm going to say?

[1:00:21] Jeff Talbott: I think you're going to say What the Constitution Means to Me.

[1:00:23] Jeff Talbott: Yep.

[1:00:23] Jeff Talbott: Yeah. Everybody should see it. It should be required viewing for every American, first of all. But it's also an incredibly exciting piece of theater. I saw it first two years ago in a 70-seat theater. That's where it started in New York. She's been working on it for many, many years. But I saw it as a pretty intimate space. It is on Broadway. But it's still Broadway.

[1:00:43] Mary Dina: Still Broadway.

[1:00:44] Jeff Talbott: So we saw it like at two o'clock in the afternoon. It was part of a festival at a theater called Clubbed Thumb. And it was part of their summer short series or whatever. And I remember wandering out onto the street feeling like I had been like taken by the lapels and shaken. And you at that point there were like five performances, and we saw the next to last one. You couldn't get a ticket to it. And I was like, this is the most important piece of theater I've seen in years. That it's very gratifying that it has ended up on Broadway because it isn't typical in any way. Have you both seen it?

[1:01:18] Mary Dina: I haven't seen it yet.

[1:01:19] Brian Sedita: No, I haven't.

[1:01:20] Jeff Talbott: It's on my list.

[1:01:21] Jeff Talbott: You have to see it because it challenges what a play is because it starts as a monologue, but it isn't really a monologue, but it's a few. And it's a one-person play. It isn't, but it feels like it at first.

[1:01:31] Mary Dina: Okay.

[1:01:32] Jeff Talbott: Um, see I'm going in blind.

[1:01:34] Jeff Talbott: Yeah. And you should. And I would say. But it's also an incredibly political piece of theater, but not in the way that you think that it's going to be.

[1:01:41] Mary Dina: Is it more educational?

[1:01:44] Jeff Talbott: No.

[1:01:44] Jeff Talbott: Oh.

[1:01:45] Jeff Talbott: No, it's very personal. Like it starts off, and you think it's going to be educational, and you think you're gonna like I know people who have been dismissive of it, and they are few, but they call it a TED talk. Well, it's just a TED talk. And I love TED Talks. Absolutely. But they don't always make good theater. But this isn't a TED talk. It's a dynamic, personal piece of writing by a female human being in the world trying to understand how, in particular, female human beings interact with the way we've decided to govern ourselves in this country. And she continually ties it back to herself and what she's trying to investigate, and it challenges all the norms of what a play is. It constantly is setting up from a writing standpoint the rules of what it is and then breaking that in front of you.

Like not just the fourth wall, but how the play is being presented changes two or three times within the evening. And it's deeply funny, more so than you think because it sounds serious and stodgy and school-like.

[1:03:00] Mary Dina: The way she wanted to tell it.

[1:03:01] Jeff Talbott: Yeah. So that, that's an easy answer. There are other things that are great in town, but that's the thing.

[1:03:08] Brian Sedita: I feel like you've just sold two tickets.

[1:03:09] Jeff Talbott: Awesome.

[1:03:11] Jeff Talbott: You're welcome, Heidi.

[1:03:12] Mary Dina: Dear Heidi Shrek.

[1:03:13] Jeff Talbott: You're welcome.

[1:03:14] Jeff Talbott: Two percent to me.

[1:03:16] Mary Dina: She definitely is.

[1:03:17] Jeff Talbott: She's definitely listening.

[1:03:18] Mary Dina: I hope.

[1:03:20] Brian Sedita: Maybe we'll have to have her on.

[1:03:21] Jeff Talbott: Yeah, totally.

[1:03:22] Mary Dina: Yeah.

[1:03:23] Jeff Talbott: She's next.

[1:03:23] Mary Dina: Yes.

[1:03:24] Jeff Talbott: Well, thanks so much for coming on here. I loved this conversation.

[1:03:27] Mary Dina: Excellent.

[1:03:28] Jeff Talbott: I also learned so much more. I just, my brain is just like.

[1:03:30] Brian Sedita: Yeah.

[1:03:34] Jeff Talbott: Amazing.

[1:03:35] Jeff Talbott: Thanks.

[1:03:36] Brian Sedita: Thanks, guys.

[1:03:37] Jeff Talbott: Hi.

[1:03:37] Mary Dina: Bye.

[1:03:40] Brian Sedita: Thanks everyone for listening to this episode of Page to Stage.

[1:03:43] Mary Dina: To keep up with us, you can find us on Instagram and Facebook at Page2Stage Podcast.

[1:03:48] Brian Sedita: And if you're enjoying these conversations, we would really appreciate it if you could take a couple minutes to rate and review us wherever you're listening to this podcast.

[1:03:55] Mary Dina: Until next time.

[1:03:56] Brian Sedita: That's Brian.

[1:03:57] Mary Dina: That's Mary.

[1:03:58] Brian Sedita: We'll see you later.

[1:03:59] Mary Dina: Bye.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred