Skip to main content
BPN Logo
Broadway Star Jay Armstrong Johnson (On the Town, Quantico) Weaves a Spell of Kindness

Broadway star Jay Armstrong Johnson (On the Town, The Phantom of the Opera) joins The Art of Kindness with Robert Peterpaul to discuss acts of kindness on Broadway, his Hocus Pocus-inspired benefit concert I Put A Spell on You and more!.. Read More

From the show: The Art of Kindness: Pop Culture & Positivity with Robert Peterpaul

49 mins
10/20/22

Guests

Featured Shows

About

Broadway star Jay Armstrong Johnson (On the Town, The Phantom of the Opera) joins The Art of Kindness with Robert Peterpaul to discuss acts of kindness on Broadway, his Hocus Pocus-inspired benefit concert I Put A Spell on You and more!

Over the course of his 5 Broadway shows, Jay Armstrong Johnson has cemented himself as a triple threat. From his debut in Hair, which he shares a kind story about during our chat, to his more recent turn as Raoul in Phantom of the Opera’s 30th anniversary year, Jay is always a standout. Following Phantom, Jay originated the role of Banko in Roundabout Theatre Company’s world premiere show Scotland, PA. His performance earned him critical nominations from both the Lucille Lortel and Drama Desk Awards for Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical. He was also the recipient of a 2020 Outer Critics Circle Award Honor for his performance. Jay’s other Broadway credits include the original casts of Catch Me if You Can, Hands on a Hardbody, and the celebrated revival of On the Town. On screen, Jay is also known to audiences worldwide as genius hacker Will Olsen in ABC’s Quantico.

Jay created the annual live show I Put A Spell on You as a tribute to the beloved cult classic movie Hocus Pocus with larger-than-life performances and choreography, over-the-top costumes and makeup and a healthy dose of Broadway magic. In their search to find beauty, youth and immortality, the bewitching and beloved Sanderson Sisters return from the dead and gather their most famous friends to help them lure the children of New York. This year, those famous friends include Broadway stars like Gavin Creel, Krista Rodriguez, Robyn Hurder and more. The show will be ALIVE at Sony Hall in Times Square on October 23 at 8PM. Most importantly, it benefits Broadway Cares/Equity Fights AIDS. Tickets start at $35 for the dance floor and are on sale now at broadwaycares.org/spell.

Got kindness tips or stories? Please email us:

artofkindnesspodcast@gmail.com

Follow Jay

@jay_a_johnson

Follow us

@artofkindnesspod / @robpeterpaul

Support the show!

(https://www.buymeacoffee.com/theaok)

Music:

"Awake" by Ricky Alvarez, "I Put a Spell on You" by Jay Armstrong Johnson & "Sunshine" by Lemon Music Studio

We are supported by the Broadway Podcast Network.

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:06] Robert Peterpaul: Hello, beautiful people. Welcome to the Art of Kindness, where we have compassionate conversations with artists from all areas of the entertainment industry who are using their voice to spread joy and make this big spinning planet in the sky a better place to be.

[0:21] Robert Peterpaul: I'm Robert Peterpaul, and I'm so glad you're here. In just three weeks, I will be marrying the love of my life, Cassie. Woo! Needless to say, things are a little bit cuckoo for Coco Puss over here. I mean, we have so much going on, we've done so much, but we still have so much left to do somehow. It's crunch time. It's crunch time! Of course, this abundance means that there's also so much to be grateful for, and we will not lose sight of that. Mainly because Cassie is the kindest and loveliest person in the world, and she's just such a grateful little human that I don't think we could. It's going to be the most magical day ever, and I can't wait to tell you all about it. Speaking of magical, our guest today is definitely that.

[1:20] Robert Peterpaul: Today's guest is actor, singer, and dancer Jay Armstrong Johnson. Over the course of his five Broadway shows, Jay has cemented himself as a triple threat. From his debut in Hair, which he shares a kind story about during our chat, to his more recent turn as Raoul in Phantom of the Opera's 30th anniversary year, Jay is always a standout. Following Phantom, Jay originated the role of Banko in Roundabout Theatre Company's world premiere show, Scotland, PA. His performance earned him critical nominations from both the Lucille Lortel and Drama Desk Awards for Outstanding Featured Actor in a Musical. He was also the recipient of a 2020 Outer Critics Circle Award honor for his performance.

[2:06] Robert Peterpaul: Jay's other Broadway credits include the original casts of Catch Me If You Can, Hands on a Hardbody, and the celebrated revival of On the Town. We had the privilege of seeing Jay in A Chorus Line at the City Center, and let me just say he was one singular sensation. On screen, Jay is also known to audiences worldwide as genius hacker Will Olsen in ABC's hit series Quantico, which ran for three seasons. Jay also makes his own music from his album Jay Armstrong Johnson Live at Feinstein's/54 Below, which is available on Spotify, iTunes, and BroadwayRecords.com, to the album of his hit Halloween fundraiser, I Put a Spell on You.

[2:35] Robert Peterpaul: I put a spell on you. And now you're mine. You can't stop the things I do. I ain't lying. Then 300 years right down to the day. Now the witch is back. And there's hell to pay. I put a spell on you. And now you're mine. Hello, listeners. My name's Robert. What's yo? Sorry. At first, Jay created the live show I Put a Spell on You as a way to live out his childhood dream of becoming Winifred Sanderson from Hocus Pocus. Then it transformed into something even more spectacular. His annual show is a spoof of and tribute to the beloved cult classic movie, of course, one of my favorite movies of all time, as you know, Hocus Pocus.

[3:56] Robert Peterpaul: With larger-than-life performances and choreography, over-the-top costumes and makeup, and a healthy dose of Broadway magic. In their search to find beauty, youth, and immortality, the bewitching and beloved Sanderson sisters return from the dead and gather their most famous friends to help them lure the children of New York. This year, those famous friends include Broadway stars like Gavin Creel, Krista Rodriguez, Robyn Hurder, and so many more. The show will be alive at Sony Hall in Times Square on October 23rd at 8 p.m. Most importantly, it benefits Broadway Cares/Equity Fights AIDS. Tickets start at $35 for the dance floor and are on sale now at BroadwayCares.org/spell. That's BroadwayCares.org/spell. So grab your broomsticks and get ready! I'll be there, I hope to see you.

[4:50] Robert Peterpaul: Jay and I discuss how he got this show off the ground and into the air, his self-care routine for working on Broadway, and much more. As always, stay tuned after the interview for your kindness tip of the week. You can also stay tuned to our Instagram pages at Art of Kindness Pod and at Robert Peterpaul. I love connecting with you all on there. I should note that Jay was having a little bit of audio technical difficulties in the beginning, but don't worry, it clears up in about a minute or so. So please hang in there. Now, without further ado, please welcome the joyful Jay Armstrong Johnson.

[5:42] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Hello, hello.

[5:43] Robert Peterpaul: Hi, how are you?

[5:45] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I'm good.

[5:45] Robert Peterpaul: How are you, Robert?

[5:46] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I'm good. I'm so excited to talk to you today. You see a sweet poster over your left shoulder.

[5:51] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Thank you very much. You should see the whole apartment. It's pretty glorious, but it's probably reflective of me like not being okay and being a little too obsessed with Hocus Pocus. But I feel like you can understand that.

[6:01] Robert Peterpaul: I overstand that, actually. That's awesome. Well, not only are you insanely talented, but I have seriously heard from so many mutual friends that we have that you are just the kindest person on Broadway. So I think this is a perfect fit. I'm so thrilled to talk to you today, and I just want to thank you before we get started for just being such a great role model.

[6:23] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That means the world to me, and somewhere in Texas, my mother is weeping at that compliment. So someone in Texas better run some Kleenex over. Maybe we'll do an Instacart or something.

[6:34] Robert Peterpaul: So before I just keep complimenting you for hours and hours, I would love to start our conversation today by getting your definition of kindness.

[6:43] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, kindness. Um, my definition of kindness goes along with empathy, I guess. It really is the understanding that you never know what someone's going through. And so what you may be receiving from other humans on this planet has nothing to do with you. All you really have to do, um, it my mom, speaking of mom in Texas, um, she often used the phrase kill them with kindness when I was being bullied in school for being gay. And so that was always a really great lesson from mom. Even if you are being faced with adversity or anger or meanness, um, that it's your job to just be nice, you know. I grew up pretty Christian in the South. And so it's, you know, it's what Jesus teaches.

[7:45] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah, exactly. I love that. It reminds me of this acting coach I have in the city from the Barrel Group. Shout out to Lee. She always says you get more bees with honey. So it's kind of a similar thing of making the positive acting choice, making a positive choice in your life. So I think your mom is right on track. And look at your sweatshirt. I don't think I noticed that before, but I see our ladies, their hair is peeking out.

[8:07] Jay Armstrong Johnson: There they are. Wow. It's so good.

[8:10] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It was a gift from Danny Quadrino. Broadway's Danny Quadrino.

[8:13] Robert Peterpaul: Ah, not Danny from the first film, but you know, she sounds cool too.

[8:17] Jay Armstrong Johnson: She is. Dora Birch, what a legend.

[8:19] Robert Peterpaul: Dora Birch, come on. Well, before we get into everything Hocus Pocus, because we are gonna dive deep into that, of course. You know, speaking of growing up in Texas, I would love to know if you recall like a first act of kindness from when you realized you wanted to get into the arts and something that somebody did that kind of just helped you go on that path.

[8:39] Jay Armstrong Johnson: For sure. Um, I grew up with not so many means. And so, um, I was kind of supported by a community around me um that like lifted me up um both spiritually and financially. And so it really was this um family, um really dear friends of mine that I met at church, um the Lanzas, it was Janet Lanza and Alison Lanza and David Lanza, and um they uh introduced me to um KWC Performing Arts, which is a children's community theater um in my hometown. And so them um seeing talent in me um and saying you should explore this and then introducing me to KWC Performing Arts and then going to KWC Performing Arts and being on a full scholarship there, um that was really the first time uh that like kindness stuck out to me in relation to theater, um because you know it's expensive um to study theater, to study dance, to study voice, to study acting. And uh there was an entire community that surrounded me and lifted me up um in a way that uh I am eternally grateful for and they set me on the path that I am now.

[8:54] Robert Peterpaul: That's so beautiful and it is so true. I mean, that's the gag is like there's the old saying a starving artist which I don't really subscribe to or like but it is a label and it kind of is true because actors just aren't making any money at first at least and yet it costs so much money to try and just get your foot in the door, you know, getting headshots and resumes and then getting somebody that can get you auditions. Now you got to do workshops and all this stuff. So I mean that's wonderful you had that but then as you start auditioning and getting out there, I guess flashing forward a little bit. Auditioning is such a necessary evil in a lot of ways. I mean, I'm trying to look at it more for me personally as just like a fun opportunity to do what we love, but it could be a little rabbit hole for your mental health. So, how are you at auditioning? Have you kind of found a nice balance with not getting in your own way? Or is it still a struggle?

[10:51] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, it's always still a struggle. And it, but uh over you know, and the older I've gotten, the more I've tried to relabel things. Um if I didn't get callbacks in my like teens and twenties, I would consider it a failure. Um, but now I just consider any audition an opportunity. And if and when something doesn't go my way, then it wasn't meant for me. But perhaps I did good work in the room. And so maybe there's a casting director or director or choreographer or producer that enjoyed my work in the room, but I wasn't the right fit for this puzzle. But five years down the road, I'm the right fit for another puzzle, which has happened to me in my career before. So just kind of it's always like making the positive choice.

Like you can the foot one foot in front of the other kind of thing. Because you know, it's it is a wild industry and it's super hard. Um, there are lots of people that want to do this. So it's just, you know, stay in the course and not taking um, not taking anything personally.

[11:56] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Well, I hear nowadays, even just from casting friends, just getting an audition is such a win now because there are so many more people being seen with self-tapes and all this stuff. So just getting an audition is actually a win. It's an opportunity to meet them.

[12:09] Robert Peterpaul: It's like a free workshop that people are paying for, which is a whole other weird topic. But um, I think that's a great, great mindset. So you've had a lot of wins. I mean, I could spend our time together just listing all these amazing things that you've done, you know, from Catch Me If You Can to On the Town to Phantom. Do you have any stories? I mean, we're big on acts of kindness here or mentors just because that's under the kindness umbrella. Do any of those kind of things stand out to you just from your time on Broadway? I mean, not to make Broadway the end all be all, because I think there's wonderful regional theaters. There's so much so many other works, but we are the Broadway podcast network. So sticking with that, I think would be cool.

[12:48] Jay Armstrong Johnson: For sure. Um, it was my Broadway debut in Hair that was um really kind of formative to the way that I approach my entire life and my career. And it was because of Gavin Creel. Um, I was I was brought into Hair to be Gavin's understudy and to be a swing for the tribe. And the way that he led the company, not just on stage with his genius performance, but off stage with his kindness and with his empathy, um, was is it was pivotal in the way that I understood what a leading player does. Um, because in my head up to that point, I was like, the leading player has the most lines and they get the final bow. Um, but witnessing Gavin um rally our tribe and um really kind of push us um to be a community, to be uh to be a tribe, um to really subscribe to that hair mentality uh was awesome.

Um, and uh I still um think about it to this day. And every single person in that original company of Hair were on a text thread that pops off every single day. I mean, sometimes I'll wake up and then I'll have like 37 missed text messages, and all 37 are from tribe members. So that kind of community that we built that was led by Gavin Creel, um, was really kind of a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity, and it happened to be my Broadway debut.

[14:11] Robert Peterpaul: Oh, how special, because that could have gone the other way, you know, you could have gotten somebody who was maybe more of a diva, not in a good way.

[14:17] Jay Armstrong Johnson: For sure.

[14:18] Robert Peterpaul: And tainted your whole view, you know. So I'm I'm glad that happened to you. And I'm glad to hear that because he's supposed to come on here. So if he wasn't kind, I'd have to cancel the zoom. You know what I'm saying?

[14:27] Jay Armstrong Johnson: He's the kindest. I keep hearing that from people, you know?

[14:31] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah.

[14:32] Jay Armstrong Johnson: He really is the best. I just saw him in Into the Woods, and he's playing like this funny, uh, not kind uh I guess to use the word diva again, uh Prince. So, you know, he can act, which is good. I don't need to tell him that.

[14:44] Robert Peterpaul: The Tony winner, honey.

[14:46] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Seriously, come on. Well, speaking of Tony winners, I'm kind of hoping that when Hocus Pocus comes to Broadway, because apparently it's in the works. We just had the creator on here and he said it's happening, which is exciting. So I'm hoping you're a Tony winner when they cast you as Winnifred.

[15:04] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I mean, I need one of them to be in dra. Come on. Would that be like a dream come true or what?

[15:09] Jay Armstrong Johnson: A wild dream come true. And of course, like that might be out of body. I would be um a liar if I didn't say that it's something that I've like meditated on and ruminated on and truly hoped for. So, you know, the business is wild and it could go many ways. And he Bet Midler might want to come back to Broadway. And if so, I give her all the power in the world.

[15:31] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah, seriously. If I could just have any part of that, I don't care if I'm a red carpet correspondent on opening night. Um, it would just be lovely to just be the smallest part of Hocus Pocus the musical on Broadway.

[15:44] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh, yeah, I couldn't agree more. But you're honestly living the dream either way with your amazing show that you put on in your benefit for Broadway Cares and Equity Fights AIDS. I put a spell on you, which is I love how you guys phrased it alive at Sony Hall this year. I mean, I've seen videos and I I got to watch it when you did it virtually, and it's just such a magical, spectacular experience. And I think the fact that it's such a passion project, and you're doing this with your best friends fully shines through because we're just having so much fun watching it. So would you mind just kind of telling me a little bit about how that show got started and then we can take it from there because I think our listeners will be quite intrigued.

[16:21] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, for sure. Um since I was a kid, I always wanted to be Winifred Sanderson for Halloween, but I also knew I didn't want to half ass it, like I I knew I wanted it to be on like a grand scale. Um you know, not growing up with a lot of money. I was like, all right, well, when I make my money, I'm gonna make it happen. So I did. Um, right after my first season of shooting um Quantico on ABC, I found myself with television money in the bank, and I was producing my own solo show at 54 Below that then we recorded a live album for, and that live album was dropping in October of 2016. And so I was like, okay, it's October. What if we made my album release party a Halloween party? So that's kind of how it came to be I hired my costume designer DW to do the costumes, and my friend Katie Beatty from On the Town did our wigs, and I brought in makeup artists and got all my friends together, and we essentially did my entire album dressed as characters from Hocus Pocus, and then added a few um other Halloween tunes in there.

Um, so that was the inception, really. And then it's it's grown from there. Um, since we had the costumes and the wigs, um, I was like, we should do this every year. Um, and it was around that time that I started working with Broadway Cares a lot and doing events like Broadway Bears and Broadway Backwards, and the sense of community that they create and the rehearsal space and just in those productions in general was palpable. I could really feel it. It felt like that same tribe energy that I felt in Hair.

[17:53] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, because it's just like-minded artists coming together to create on a grand scale for a good cause. Um, and so the second year of doing it, um, I had this thought, I want to get Broadway Cares on board for this. And it took us a few years, but they did finally come on board in 2020. In January of 2020, they said, sure, we'll be your benefactor, um, which was amazing. And then the pandemic hit.

[18:18] Robert Peterpaul: I know.

[18:19] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So our first year with Broadway Cares was a virtual event, and I we had to do some convincing with Broadway Cares to actually shoot a film version of our show because it was pre-vaccines, it was the height of COVID, it was so so much red tape to kind of be aware of. Um, but we did our research and we made it happen. And our first virtual event um raised uh like a quarter of a million dollars for Broadway Cares. Um so here we are. We did two virtual events in a row due to the pandemic, and so now we're in our seventh year. Um and we're back live and trying to blow it out of the water.

[18:58] Robert Peterpaul: And you're going to. That's honestly so incredible. And I think it's super cool that you're you're achieving your dream of becoming Winny on this larger scale, and people are watching you with your friends, but then in your head, you were like, I'm not gonna just focus on it being my dream, I'm gonna give back. And I think that's such a beautiful combination. I don't know. I I love that you you thought that way. Was it also your friends Allison and Amanda? Was it like a collective dream that the three of you would be the Sandersons one day, or was it just kind of like, oh, I'm gonna bring my friends up with me and make this really fun?

[19:28] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I mean, I think it's always been my dream. I don't think Allison and Amanda necessarily subscribed to the Hocus Pocus as much as I did, but they're two of my favorite artists in the world. They have two of my favorite voices in the world. We've known each other since we were like 12 doing theater at KWC Performing Arts. So they were my backup singers and my featured vocalists when I did my solo show at 54 Below that we recorded the album. So I always knew I wanted them in my life as artists and musicians. So it just kind of morphed into this Hocus Pocus thing. So it didn't even start out as like a Halloween dream. It just started out as like I want to create with my friends, and then it's become this spooky thing.

[20:11] Robert Peterpaul: Well, I think when things come from the heart, not to sound corny, but like I am a giant piece of corn with the Jews.

[20:18] Jay Armstrong Johnson: No, I I think so.

[20:20] Robert Peterpaul: I mean, I think when it it just grows from there when it starts from such a genuine place. And I am gonna say this, Jay, I'm not just blowing magical Sanderson dust up your butt, but I need the I Put a Spell on You cover you guys did to come back onto Apple because it's gone and I would listen to it so much. The one you guys had, it was on i music. I can't find it anymore.

[20:39] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I think it's on Spotify at least.

[20:42] Jay Armstrong Johnson: All right. It should be. I mean, unless Hocus Pocus 2 gave us a takedown notice and I don't know about it.

[20:47] Robert Peterpaul: No, I mean it was I it was before that. I was not that I was listening to that, I mean I was listening to it a lot, but anyway, I should get back to your show. So I feel like it just it takes a lot of guts no matter what to really believe in yourself and follow through on an idea like that. Like, what's I guess your prescription, for lack of a better word, for not overcoming to self-doubt? Like for not along the way while you're producing your own show, being like, I can't do this. I mean, like how how do you kind of follow it through?

[21:16] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, it kind of goes back to that tribe mentality. Um, I would not be able to pull off this kind of a huge endeavor if it weren't for the people that come on board to pull it off with me. Um, my co-producers and my director and my choreography team and the makeup artists and the wardrobe designers. I mean, it it takes a village, like literally. I think this year, there's probably about 75 to 80 humans working on the show, probably more, um, because we're still onboarding people every single day. Um, but that the fact that I have other humans that are coming in to be like, yes, let's do this. Oh, we're not getting paid short, it's for a great cause. Let's do it anyway. That's what keeps me going.

Um, because it really is super stressful. And my poor partner has to deal with me pacing around my apartment on calls all day long, um, just nervous about pulling it off. Um, but it really is um surrounding myself with um people that just want to do it, that want to create, um, that want to kind of work on this grand scale for no money. Um so it's yeah, it's it's the same thing I experienced as a kid um doing community theater and having having that community around me and supporting me. Um it's it's kind of translating into my adulthood as a little baby producer.

[22:39] Jay Armstrong Johnson: A little baby producer.

[22:47] Robert Peterpaul: I know it's a funny thing because artists obviously deserve to be compensated for their work, but then at the same time, there's something so beautiful about just doing it for the love of it because that's what we did on the playground when we were kids, you know.

[22:59] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And when it comes from that place of fun and make believe, it's a lot more genuine. So I love that. This year you have such an all-star cast. I mean, our friend, we gotta give a shout out to Katie Rosen, who's one of your producers who we love.

[23:11] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I would not, I mean, this thing wouldn't happen without Katie. It really wouldn't. The work that she's doing on this show is like mind-blowing. She spends so much time, so much energy, and has gotten us crazy press. I mean, I got in People Magazine because I saw that.

[23:27] Robert Peterpaul: Isn't that wild?

[23:28] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It was such a great article. And we were we were linked at the bottom with the Hocus Pocus Broadway news. So it was like a it was like we were together before we were together.

[23:37] Robert Peterpaul: That's amazing.

[23:38] Jay Armstrong Johnson: And those pictures were amazing. I mean, your transformation is like next level.

[23:44] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, the brilliant Jenny Anderson came in to took those photos for us, and Kyle Kruger at Alcone has been my makeup artist for the past three years, and of course, DW is my wardrobe supervisor and designer. So, you know, the people that come on board to do this are like they're my ride or dies, you know. And they they create on such a brilliant scale, too. It's uh I'm so so grateful. So, besides raising so much money and getting the word out there and having people come and enjoy this magical evening. I guess what is your ultimate goal with the show? Would it be to have the OG Sandersons pop in and just have Bet Midler up in there?

[24:21] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Okay, and I, you know, we've always reached out to Sarah and to Bet and to Kathy. Um, you know, Broadway Cares has some relationships with them from previous events, and we've not quite snagged them yet. But my overall goal is to be able to go into a venue where we can literally fly the Sanderson sisters into the show. Like I want, I want to, as a 13-year-old, I got to play Peter Pan at KWC Performing Arts. And flying on a stage is I've, I've been chasing that feeling ever since I was 13. Oh yeah. So I won't stop until the Sanderson sisters are flying.

[25:03] Robert Peterpaul: Well, I got to fly in a show at the White Plains Performing Arts Center. I was LeFou and Gaston like lifted me on a finger and then spun me around. And it was honestly like one of the top five moments of my life.

[25:12] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So incredible. I don't blame it. It's truly magical. That's quite a line item on the budget to fly someone with all the inference and rigging. So we're gonna have to get a little bigger before that can happen.

[25:27] Robert Peterpaul: So have you been watching all the behind the scenes video?

[25:29] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Well, okay, first of all, what I'm getting ahead of myself. Most importantly, how many times have you watched Hocus Pocus 2 at this point? Have you seen it?

[25:35] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Just once. Um, I went to holding up two fingers for the record. It's like just once.

[25:40] Robert Peterpaul: Just once.

[25:41] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Just once. There's like five finger, ten fingers in the air. You're like, just one deck. Um, I was pretty busy the day that it came out on Disney Plus, and I was downtown seeing my friend Jason Gote's concert um at the Maneta Lane Theater for Audible. And right after his show got out, my partner and I ran uptown um because my friend Bronson Murphy, who I went to college with and who's currently in Phantom of the Opera on Broadway, he's an even more hope like Hocus Pocus fan than I am. So we had made a date to watch the movie together at his place. So we started the movie, I think around like 11:30 p.m. and just like it to all like almost 2 a.m. Um, and it was magical. It was also fun being next to someone that's such a Hocus Pocus stan like myself.

[26:25] Robert Peterpaul: Oh, yeah.

[26:25] Jay Armstrong Johnson: We were like two little kids in a candy store, just like giggling and gasping.

[26:30] Robert Peterpaul: Giggling and gasping. I know what else. What else do you do during that? Did you love it? What did you think?

[26:35] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I really did love it. I was super nervous, of course. And like, you know, I try not to be a purist, but when it comes to things like Hocus Pocus or Sister Act 2, um, you know, those are like pivotal artistic um moments in my life. Yeah, I think that they killed it. I mean, they paid perfect homage to the original while updating it for today. It was equal parts camp and heart. Um, SJP and Bet and Kathy were like firing on all cylinders. I mean, yeah, the scene at the beginning with like the baby Sanderson sisters, I was blown away by that little girl that played like young Winifred. I mean, give her the Oscar.

[27:18] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah, oh, give her the Oscar.

[27:19] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I know, seriously. She was great. They did such a wonderful job, and it was cool to learn about that. And I think they left room to learn even more if they were potentially to do an, I mean, Kathleen and Jimmy just teased a possible third one, which stars would have to align, but you know, I'm here for it.

[27:37] Robert Peterpaul: And I agree, it was an amazing time. I was lucky to do a little like set visit, and I happened to be there the day they were doing the musical number.

[27:45] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Are you joking?

[27:46] Robert Peterpaul: I know, I know, I know.

[27:48] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I'm still wearing the same clothes because it was the best day of my life um years later. No, it was insane. And what was really cool is that the whole crew were clearly fans of Hocus Pocus and locals were gathered around, and we were like kind of in the background watching it, and they didn't care if you were like just having a good time. They didn't want you to take videos, but sure. It was just such a beautiful vibe on set. And the whole time I'm thinking, I'm like, why is Jay not the drag for? I mean, no, no disrespect, because I think everything ends up the way it should be. But I, I would have been following you, and I was like, I need to get him in Hocus Pocus 3 or something. Come on.

[28:20] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I got really close um to being the drag Winifred. Like we were in talks with casting for like months leading up to the film. And I think they were confused because they thought I was a drag queen, drag queen. I don't think they realized that I am a drag queen once a year, and it's as Winifred Sanderson for a Halloween benefit. So I think that that's where like wires were a bit crossed. So, you know, when they ended up casting three RuPaul's Drag Race, like royalty, I was like, oh, this makes sense, but I didn't get super close to it.

[28:52] Robert Peterpaul: That's really cool that you got close.

[28:54] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah. Because now you're in, you're kind of in the universe still. I think that's amazing.

[28:59] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Well, and what's also cool is during the pandemic when, because Bet does Hula Win every year, her like benefit for New York Restoration Project. Um, so they did their online benefit that first year of the pandemic. And Mark Shaman is a good friend of mine because of Catch Me If You Can and Mark is her like music supervisor. So Mark actually reached out to me to ask if Bet could use our track for I Put a Spell on You because she now sings in the key that I sing in. And so we actually provided Mark with our track that we created for our album, and Mark shook it up a little bit and added some like Disney magic to it. And that's the track that Bet and Sarah and Kathy sang to for their online benefit.

[29:41] Robert Peterpaul: Wow, that's crazy.

[29:43] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I know. Mark forwarded me an email from Bet that was like, "Your friend Jay is hilarious. I love it. I'm sending this to SJP and Kathy and me." So Bet knows who I am.

[29:53] Robert Peterpaul: Wow. Can we get like a little virtual video from them or something to pop into your show now?

[29:58] Jay Armstrong Johnson: No, I know. I'm gonna get him for the 10th, the 10th anniversary. I'm gonna get them. We got three. I have a feeling. All right. Let's put this out there. And I mean, Kathy, especially seems like just such a through line throughout your childhood. I mean, with Sister Act, oh yeah, and Hocus Pocus.

[30:15] Jay Armstrong Johnson: For sure. I love her. I've got to meet Kathy on two occasions. We were both in callbacks for the Into the Woods that happened at the Delacourt in Central Park. Like, when was that? Like six or seven years ago?

[30:27] Robert Peterpaul: Oh, with like Amy Adams.

[30:29] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah. Okay. So she was outside of the rehear, uh, at the audition room when I finished auditioning, and I like literally got down on my knees in front of her and I was just like, I love you. Thank you for everything. And then she also, uh, is a friend, she's friends with my friend Ari Krebs, who starred alongside me and um Darling Grenadine at the Roundabout Theater Company right before the pandemic shut down. So Kathy actually came and saw that show, and I got to hang out with her a little bit after the show and talk, which was cool.

[30:57] Robert Peterpaul: Did you like go up to her and push her mouth to the side, or were you like, no, I'm gonna hold back?

[31:01] Jay Armstrong Johnson: That's I literally I had to like prepare myself. I was like, don't talk about Hocus Pocus, just like live in this moment, have a conversation with this woman as not a witch. And then you walked in and you're like, Mary, I mean, uh Kathy, hey, hey, Joe, hey, it's good.

[31:17] Robert Peterpaul: That's hard. There's just certain people. Like, I find myself, I mean, I'm like, you know, they're all just people, but certain people you see, like I just ran into Whoopi Goldberg in the city, and I literally because she's an icon, I just froze and I was like, Whoopi! And she was like, hi, like, and like ran away.

[31:32] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh my god.

[31:33] Robert Peterpaul: Like, there's sometimes you just can't. I don't know. I think it's with the childhood people, like we're saying. It's just you become a kid when you see them, and it's so hard not to freak out.

[31:42] Jay Armstrong Johnson: It's true. That's true. Well, uh, you know what's also true is that some people probably freak out in front of you because you have a very massive fan base and people love you. And it's recently been announced that people can come see you in City Center's upcoming Gallup production of Parade, directed by Michael Arden, alongside people like Ben Platt and Gaten Matarazzo from Stranger Things. I mean, the list goes on. Are you rehearsing right now? Like, how's that going?

[32:09] Jay Armstrong Johnson: We start rehearsals a week from today. So that's a tight, that's a tight process. And it's also the same week as my Halloween show. So it's gonna be wild. I'll be in Parade rehearsals from 10 to 6, and then I Put a Spell on You rehearsals from six to 10. So it's gonna be a wild week. Send me all the energy. I'll be drinking all of my fluids and taking all of my vitamins, but it's gonna be a wild, wild week.

[32:32] Robert Peterpaul: That is so wild, but I think that's something people don't realize a lot about performers, is that it's always pretty wild.

[32:39] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah. Sometimes you have no notice, you know. And when it rains, it pours, you know.

[32:44] Robert Peterpaul: Totally. Before the pandemic, I was rehearsing A Chorus Line at City Center while performing Phantom of the Opera at night. And then anytime I had any time outside of those two projects I was working on, I Put a Spell on You at Le Passon Route. So I was like triple duty in 2019, which was so I've done it before, I can do it again.

[33:03] Robert Peterpaul: Oh, wait, and Jay, you were fantastic in A Chorus Line. I can't believe I haven't said that yet. That's I think the one show I've seen you in, and you were besides watching Hocus Pocus, or I Put a Spell on You, but yeah, that was such a fantastic production.

[33:15] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, that was lovely. And that was right before we lost my dear sweet Bob Avian. So it's really amazing. Cause I did the first national tour of A Chorus Line when I was 20, 21 years old. So to, and I played Mark, the baby on the line. So then to fast forward almost exactly 10 years later to play Bobby with the same production team, um, same artistic team at least was really kind of an out of body experience. Um such a fun, fun production with so many great friends.

[33:46] Robert Peterpaul: And the audience was lit for that. I mean, at least when we saw it, people were going wild.

[33:51] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, it was a really fantastic cast. I think that Bayork and Bob said this is the best cast of A Chorus Line since the original, which made us all melt, you know.

[34:01] Robert Peterpaul: I mean, I believe it because you guys were incredible.

[34:03] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Thanks. And I know this incredible cast for Parade is just going to blow people's socks off. I don't know if you can say anything, but uh Michael always puts such a unique spin on his work. So is there anything that's gonna be different about this production that you know of?

[34:17] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, I believe that they're kind of going with the production that they did in London on the West End.

[34:24] Robert Peterpaul: Okay.

[34:25] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, so it's a bit more pared down than the original. Um, and I do know that it's being treated more like an ensemble piece. So I don't think any cast member leaves the stage for the entirety of the show, at least that's what I'm being told. Um, but I've gotten to look at some of the gorgeous set renderings, and it's, uh, these voices. I mean, this cast is truly unbelievable. Some of the best voices that I know are gonna be in this cast. So I just, I'm just excited to sing with these humans and create this beautiful sound on this beautiful score by Jason and Robert Brown. I mean, it's really gonna be an embarrassment of riches. Um I couldn't, I mean, when I got the call that I got it, I literally cried. Like I actually cried.

[35:13] Robert Peterpaul: Well, it's well deserved. I mean, you deserve it, and I'm sure it's gonna be incredible. But you know, you're saying you're gonna be on stage the whole time. You just mentioned double duty with I Put a Spell on You and rehearsing for Parade. What are some of your, I guess, self-care hacks? I mean, what do you do to take care of yourself when you're really running around like that?

[35:32] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I'm gonna say this as a reminder to myself to do this. Cool. Back during On the Town on Broadway, um, I started experiencing like stage fright for the first time in my career. Um, I guess I didn't realize what it really meant to lead a Broadway show. My body was so kind of broken from the physicality of that show, and my mind was a bit scrambled because there were pressure about the Tony Awards. And are we selling tickets and are we gonna run? And am I gonna get a nomination? Or, you know, so all of the external things that shouldn't have anything to do with what we're doing on stage kind of infiltrated my mind and my life and my body. Um, and so thanks to Megan Fairchild, um, New York City Ballet Prima Ballerina, who played our Ivy Smith, she introduced me to transcendental meditation. Um, and it really kind of saved my life um that year.

[36:27] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, and I've kind of fallen off the bandwagon, so I need to get back on that bandwagon. So meditation has been something that I turned to a lot um in moments like these. Um, yoga is also another thing that I've found later in life that I wish I found earlier in life because it's a full mind body breath experience. Um, and sleep. Um, it's hard to get sleep these days, uh, especially going into a double duty situation, but just really making sure I get that solid seven to eight hours a night is like super important. Not to mention the vitamins and the hydration. I think uh I'll be drinking a lot of electrolytes um in the coming weeks for sure. It's so much work just to be a person, and then we have to do all this other stuff on top of it.

I'm like, you just pay me to be alive. Come on. Right. It's hard. And but scheduling that time in is important, you know. These 20 minutes are just for me to sit there. I'm going back to the Hocus Pocus 2 photo of Bette Midler as Winifred leaning on the side of a building sleeping. I mean, you gotta squeeze it in where you can.

[37:35] Robert Peterpaul: So true. Yeah. Important. Yeah. Well, I'm glad we mentally reminded you of that. And everybody who needs to hear that, you know, rewind that and listen to it again. Before we let Jay go, we do have a surprise game.

[37:48] Jay Armstrong Johnson: There is a theme song that I will insert here, or maybe I shouldn't because it's pretty terrible. It's me singing everyone's beautiful in their own way. It's the compliment game on me. Yay up yay, it's the compliment. Compliment, yay.

[38:06] Robert Peterpaul: It's called the compliment game. And basically I reached out to someone in your life for a compliment or a loving statement about you. I'm gonna read it to you, and then you just have to guess who said it.

[38:19] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh my gosh. Okay. Okay. Okay. You can ask me yes or no questions. I don't really know anything. I'll try and help you. And then we'll say you get like three guesses, but I think you're gonna be fine. I have a hint just in case. But yeah, but I think it'll hit you. Okay. Okay. All right. Here's your compliment. One of the things I love most about Jay is his desire to connect to everyone on a genuine level, whether in a creative space, a position of leadership, or a friendship. He's not just gregarious, he's open and comforting in a way that develops trust and camaraderie in the workplace and strong relationships outside of it.

[39:06] Robert Peterpaul: Um, oh goodness. Is this Katie Rosen?

[39:11] Jay Armstrong Johnson: No, but I thought about asking Katie. I thought they'd be a little too on the nose.

[39:14] Robert Peterpaul: It would be on the nose. Yeah. But she loves you and has given you many compliments in conversation with me.

[39:25] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Is this human um male identifying?

[39:29] Robert Peterpaul: Nope.

[39:34] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Okay. Do you need a hint?

[39:37] Robert Peterpaul: I do.

[39:38] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Okay. I mean, there's a big hint.

[39:40] Robert Peterpaul: Okay.

[39:41] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I feel like I should tweak it. Well, I'll tell you why. Okay. So the hint is ride or die since the age of 12.

[39:47] Robert Peterpaul: Amanda Williams where.

[39:48] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yep. It's AWW. It's your Mary Sanderson. And I was going to say fly or die since the age of 12 because you guys are witches, but that's dumb.

[39:56] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Oh my god, Amanda. Yeah, she loves you. She sent it back like right away and was so excited.

[40:02] Robert Peterpaul: She's the best. Both she and Alison are like godsons for me in life.

[40:09] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah. Process so much together. That's uh that means a lot. And she's also a genius writer. So I should have known that immediately because I was like, ooh, this statement is so well crafted.

[40:20] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah.

[40:20] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I could have known it was Amanda. Got the word gregarious in there. Camaraderie. I'm like, can I speak? Can I pronounce these words? Can I pronounce this? No, that that's incredible. It's so cool too that you guys love each other and you get to do what you love together. I mean, that's like kind of the dream.

[40:37] Robert Peterpaul: It is a dream. I mean, it's always a pleasure. And it's also hilarious because you know, Amanda and Alison aren't like full-time performers anymore. Amanda's the development director at the theater company group we grew up at, and Alison's a producer for an animation studio. And so to like steal them away from their lives to come and like do the thing that we used to do as kids is always super exciting. And you know, a lot of work too. I'm like, yeah, you're gonna dance in three inch heels for 90 minutes. You're ready. Come on, dance until you die.

[41:10] Robert Peterpaul: That's right. What do you feel like they have taught you about kindness? I guess. Is it just showing up? I mean, it sounds like they really show up for you.

[41:19] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Yeah, they really do. And um, there's something about those humans that I met at age 12. Um, that they've stuck with me in my life. Um more than any other humans. Um, even high school friends, even college friends, even people that I've worked with in in my career. Um, this core group of people that who we all met uh in adolescence, um, creating theater together. Um, those are my rider dies. Um, and so just uh to know that that's that's not an experience that a lot of people have, and we know it's kind of singular. Um, and the way that we know each other, the intimacy with which we understand each other's lives and how we operate in the world. Um, that that's something that I like try to remember and not take for granted um because they are a phone call away always and always know exactly what to say um if I'm going through a hard time and will be there at the drop of a hat.

[42:24] Robert Peterpaul: Wow that's so special that you have that yeah I love him. What is it? How lucky are they to have each other what's funny is like during I put a spell on you I'm playing Winifred and all she does is just like we give her sister shit the whole time you know all we all call them idiots and elbow them in the stomach so it's it's super funny that like my love for them is so different when I'm Winifred because it has to be like almost expensive. But then you know spoiler alert in the sequel we have that moment where she actually appreciates them. I mean cried yeah that was emotional. I was like oh we're going there we're going there I know I loved it there's apparently was a scene showing them at some point in purgatory together and I'm like I need to see that in the third oh we need a director's cut.

[43:16] Jay Armstrong Johnson: I know for sure I've been following the costume designer on Instagram and like I'm Sal yeah oh I'm so obsessed with all of his posts and all of his posts of like his inspiration from the first movie and how it's translated at the second I mean I'm it's it's unbelievable his work is unreal.

[43:33] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah he had a lot of great nuggets of wisdom.

[43:35] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So smart. But speaking of Hocus Pocus 2 I did want to ask you are you incorporating any of those songs into your show or did anything inspire your show and it was kind of last minute it kind of came too late. I mentioned it to my music supervisor Will Van Dyke, and he was like, Jay, we just don't have the capacity to create something new this late in the game.

[43:55] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah.

[43:56] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So while it pains me to not be able to pay homage to the second movie quite yet, um, we're probably gonna throw a couple of those tunes into like our pre-show party and maybe try to put a joke or two in the show. Um you know giving Hocus Pocus 2 a bit of a shout out. But um, as of now, we're kind of sticking to the original because it was so late in the game producing. It's just hard.

[44:19] Robert Peterpaul: That leaves room for something to look forward to too. Although you could there are a lot of drag interactions that you could probably just like slot in there when they perform right before maybe something. I don't know, it's on my show. But you've been so generous with your time. And I would just love if we could end this chat by you sharing sort of a tangible kindness tip that listeners can take with them and incorporate into their day.

[44:43] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Absolutely. It's gonna be another seed of wisdom from my mother.

[44:49] Robert Peterpaul: Perfect, Linda Armstrong Johnson.

[44:52] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Um, and that is if you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at all. And just right along there with kill them with kindness, those those have been two phrases that I try my hardest to live by.

[45:05] Robert Peterpaul: I love that.

[45:07] Jay Armstrong Johnson: No, it it is these like simple things that are so cliche from childhood that are the most true. Like be yourself is what we learn, hopefully, early on. But that's sometimes one of the hardest things to do. Right. So I think that's great advice. Everybody, if you don't have anything nice to say, don't say you have to remind yourself sometimes. Like, you're like, is this actually really necessary? Is this nice? Right. Kind of like make somebody laugh. Because you when you build the relationships on those toxic phrases, those aren't the ones that end up being okay anyway. So I love that. I love what you're doing. I can't wait to see the show. And I just thank you again for being you. Seriously, we need more performers like you in the industry who are promoting kindness and not just really good, but really good people, if that makes sense.

[45:53] Jay Armstrong Johnson: So thanks, Robert. That really means a lot. I mean it. I'm very genuine when I say that. So thank you. It was great to meet you.

[46:00] Robert Peterpaul: Thank you, you two. You're the best.

[46:02] Jay Armstrong Johnson: Ah, you're the best.

[46:07] Robert Peterpaul: And now it's time for your kindness tip of the week.

[46:16] Robert Peterpaul: For me, today's chat brought up something we don't always talk about here on the podcast, which is the kindness of saying no. I was recently asked by a lovely organization, Broadway Method Academy, which provides training for emerging artists by connecting them with Broadway professionals to be a part of a new production they were doing. I loved working with them in the past. I did Newsies with BMA, and it was the best time ever. But this time was a tight turnaround. And with the wedding and some other projects I have going on, I knew I would be overwhelmed. Of course, I still ask Cassie for her opinion because that is my end all be all. It's electric to have times like what Jay was discussing, where we're running around doing a million things at once.

But it's also obviously so important to have times when we're not. Times when we need to shut the light bulb off. And I knew I needed a little bit of peace, which is still doing a million things. But now maybe minus one. So though it was really hard for me, I ended up turning the job down and saying no. I think as artists, especially, we're taught to say yes to everything. You know? Just say yes. You never know what's gonna happen. One project leads to another. But we can't always say yes. That's not sustainable. So today's kindness tip of the week is to say no when you feel it in your gut. Again, though we're taught to say yes to everything, sometimes saying no is actually saying yes to yourself and your own well-being.

You know, maybe a no is dressed up as a yes for Halloween. I don't I don't know what that meant. Anyway, thank you for saying yes to listening to this podcast today. I had such a great time with you. If you enjoyed it, please leave us a five star review. Go tell your friends, spread the word. We are forming a kindness community. Oh, audio hug. Now, until next time, my dear listeners, please remember everything's gonna be a okay.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred