Bestselling Author Emma Straub's new book American Fantasy has pulled into port! The acclaimed writer joins The Art of Kindness with Robert Peterpaul to discuss her joyful writing process, the kindness and power of nostalgia, being kind to yourself as a creator and more... Read More
From the show: The Art of Kindness: Pop Culture & Positivity with Robert Peterpaul
About
Bestselling Author Emma Straub's new book American Fantasy has pulled into port! The acclaimed writer joins The Art of Kindness with Robert Peterpaul to discuss her joyful writing process, the kindness and power of nostalgia, being kind to yourself as a creator and more.
This episode features:
- Why Emma Straub's book American Fantasy meets the current moment, thanks to a healthy dose of nostalgia
- Embracing the "uncool-ness" of being a passionate fan
- Creating community with her bookstore Books Are Magic in Brooklyn
- How vulnerability can unlock kindness, creativity and more
Emma Straub is the New York Times-bestselling author of six books for adults: the novels This Time Tomorrow, All Adults Here, The Vacationers, Modern Lovers, Laura Lamont’s Life in Pictures, and the short story collection Other People We Married. She is also the author of a picture book, Very Good Hats. Her books have been published in more than twenty languages.
She and her husband are also the beloved owners of Books Are Magic, an iconic independent bookstore in Brooklyn, New York.
Got kindness tips or stories? Please email us:
artofkindnesspodcast@gmail.com
Follow Emma
Follow us
@artofkindnesspod / @robpeterpaul
(https://www.buymeacoffee.com/theaok)
Music:
"Awake" by Ricky Alvarez & "Sunshine" by Lemon Music Studio.
We are supported by the Broadway Podcast Network.
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Emma Straub: This is Emma Straub, and you are listening to The Art of Kindness.
[0:04] Robert Peterpaul: Okay, narration voice.
[0:06] Robert Peterpaul: That was good.
[0:12] Robert Peterpaul: Hello, beautiful people. Welcome to the Art of Kindness, where we have compassionate conversations with artists from all areas of the entertainment industry who are using their voice to spread joy and make this big spinning planet in the universe a better place to be.
[0:28] Robert Peterpaul: I'm Robert Peterpaul, and I'm so glad you're here.
[0:43] Robert Peterpaul: Hello, friends. Today we're chartering a kindness vessel and sailing into the magical sea of books. On the wave of her new book release, I feel very fortunate to have gotten to spend some time with New York Times bestselling author, Emma Straub.
[1:04] Robert Peterpaul: Emma Straub is the acclaimed author of six novels. You've likely seen their colorful covers winking to you from the window of bookstores. This Time Tomorrow, All Adults Here, The Vacationers, Modern Lovers, Laura Lamont’s Life in Pictures, and the short story collection, Other People We Married.
[1:27] Robert Peterpaul: Emma and I came together to discuss her new book, American Fantasy, which is a true joy, from bow to stern if you catch my drift. It centers on a newly divorced 50-year-old woman, Annie, who goes on a themed cruise with a 90s boy band that she loved growing up, rediscovering herself through nostalgia, and an unexpected connection with, well, possibly one of the band members.
[1:57] Robert Peterpaul: And guess what? It hits bookshelves tomorrow, April 7th. This is not an April Fool's, because it's the 7th, mainly. Emma is also the author of a picture book, Very Good Hats. She even sells hats, you'll get that later, with her husband at their beloved indie bookshop, Books Are Magic, which you can visit in Brooklyn, New York.
[2:22] Robert Peterpaul: I cannot wait to go with Cassie. Everything we look for in a great A-OK guest. And I hope you enjoy it too. If you do, I'd love for you to share the episode with a friend, my friend. Or leave us a little review wherever you listen, if it's no trouble, of course. It truly means so much as we work our way toward 200 episodes. Can you believe it? We're so close, which is wild.
[2:54] Robert Peterpaul: Anyway, now without further ado, final call for boarding of the American Fantasy with Emma Straub. Emma, how are you doing, my friend?
[3:17] Emma Straub: I'm good. I'm good. You know, it's interesting. Like I always forget about this part of writing a book, you know, like when you actually talk to people about it. I'm like, oh my god. Oh my god, I have to talk about that. But it's really fun. You know, I almost wish they put you on a cruise and they just had all your readers come onto that cruise, and then we could just ask you questions and also sort of see you walk in the hallway.
[3:44] Emma Straub: I mean, that would be wild. How wild would that be?
[3:47] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah, I mean, I'm ready. I'm ready. Although I will say that, you know, I have a bookstore, and so people can catch me walking whenever they want. They just have to come to Brooklyn.
[4:00] Emma Straub: I love that. Well, again, congratulations on American Fantasy. I set sail with this book, and three days later, I was in port. Yes, I did think about saying this beforehand. I flew through the book. It's such a conduit for escape, which I feel like we just desperately need in these times. So I want to start off with gratitude and just thank you for writing it.
[4:22] Emma Straub: Thank you.
[4:23] Robert Peterpaul: You're welcome, and thank you. I mean, I, you know, I really, you know, it's funny. I think different books come out of different needs, and every book sort of follows the one before it, you know, for a reason. And I, I mean, I that's what I needed too. Like, I wanted escape. I wanted fun and joy and like kooky, kookiness. Like, that's what I needed to sexy sunrises.
[4:51] Emma Straub: A sexy sunrise. I needed 12 sexy sunrises.
[4:56] Robert Peterpaul: Well, I wonder, you know, whether you're getting a sexy sunrise at a bar, whether you're at your bookstore in a situation like this. How do you feel like you are at accepting compliments?
[5:07] Emma Straub: Um, uh, not great. Not great.
[5:10] Robert Peterpaul: You did a great job, but I'm just curious how you feel about that.
[5:14] Emma Straub: I mean, my, you know, uh, it's something that I'm working on. I mean, I'm very good at giving compliments, for sure. And I'm trying to be better about like receiving compliments, but it is definitely still true that like if, you know, if I'm in a room with a hundred people, and 98 of them are cheering for me and rooting for me, and two of them are sending me death stares, I am focusing all of my energy on those two people who hate me.
[5:53] Robert Peterpaul: I know. I get that as a performer. It's like you perform to the one person that's texting or that looks like they're checked out. And the joke is sometimes you meet them after, and actually they were the most engaged and loved you. And it's like you just don't they have a resting whatever face.
[6:06] Emma Straub: Yeah.
[6:06] Emma Straub: So I totally get that. I think it's a human condition and it's sort of wrapped up in kindness, which we're also here to talk about today. And so to start, I'd love to know, Emma, what would you say is your definition of kindness and how do you think it's evolved over the years from growing up in New York City to now still being on the outskirts of New York City, but you know what I'm trying to say.
[6:27] Emma Straub: Yeah. Um I guess when I think about kindness now, I think about generosity and um not quite forgiveness, like forgiveness is maybe pushing it like a little bit farther than I mean, but I think of kindness as allowing room for other people to make mistakes and to sort of accept, you know, someone else's imperfections. That's what I think of as kindness.
[7:06] Robert Peterpaul: Wow, I love that. I feel like you do that as a writer too, for your characters. You've been just looking at American Fantasy, which is the first time I read your work. I'm so sorry.
[7:14] Emma Straub: Welcome.
[7:18] Emma Straub: Welcome aboard.
[7:19] Robert Peterpaul: Well now I'm aboard. Toot suit, beep beep. Do you feel like Emma, there's an act of kindness that changed your trajectory as you kind of look back?
[7:28] Emma Straub: Oh my god. I mean, there have been so many. There have been so many. Like, you know, I think that I think that I think that it's true for all of us, you know, that that like if we actually—
[7:31] Emma Straub: My cat is so interested in joining this conversation.
[7:48] Robert Peterpaul: Please, I should have asked, what is your cat's name? May we meet the cat?
[7:50] Emma Straub: This one is honey butter. She's coming around. She's like sniffing around.
[7:56] Robert Peterpaul: Honey butter.
[7:57] Emma Straub: Yeah, hold on. Honey, where are you? Okay, wait. Where are they? Hi. Hi, baby girl. How are you? Let's get you a mic up.
[8:07] Emma Straub: I know. She'll come around. So there's honey butter and there's dip dip.
[8:12] Robert Peterpaul: Okay, I was waiting for you to say Winnie because we have honey and Winnie.
[8:15] Emma Straub: Oh.
[8:16] Emma Straub: Yeah, it's semi close. An accidental Winnie the Pooh reference, you know.
[8:20] Emma Straub: Dip dip.
[8:21] Robert Peterpaul: That's fun.
[8:22] Robert Peterpaul: Dip dip. Was that a given name? Was is that an homage?
[8:24] Emma Straub: My we got these cats when my children were like four and seven, and my older son, who was like seven at the time, we literally like we surprised them. It was 2020. So like we all needed a good surprise. But we surprised them, and River, my 12-year-old, was just like honey butter and dip dip. Like he just said it and we were like, Well, okay.
[8:56] Emma Straub: Okay. Excellent. You know what? You might have to bring some character breakdowns Rivers Way and say what are the names in this book. Some of it's hard to warp up names. But I will say, you know, as we dip dip into the toes of American Fantasy. Sorry, those are really bad. I would love if we could just get warmed up by doing a little bit of a flash round. Because I feel like growing up in New York City is an experience that a lot of people probably fantasize about. And you had that, of course. Your book centers really on nostalgia and fantasy and reconnecting with your younger self, which I loved. So I just thought we could do if it hasn't been cheesy yet, just you wait, Emma. I thought we could do a fun flash round to get to know the sort of many versions of you called Emma Rickin Fantasy.
[9:41] Emma Straub: I am so ready. I feel prepared for this game.
[9:46] Robert Peterpaul: Yes. Okay, I'm gonna say a phrase and you just finish it with whatever pops into your head.
[9:52] Emma Straub: Okay.
[9:52] Robert Peterpaul: Okay. Here we go. And now I hear my cats. They're like, I'm gonna play too.
[9:56] Emma Straub: Not today.
[9:57] Robert Peterpaul: The first book I remember being obsessed with was um maybe like uh Nancy Drew, Nancy Drew or Lois Duncan or Christopher Pike, like, you know, those early mysteries I was obsessed with, and I would read like a stack of them every day. Those were my jam.
[10:22] Emma Straub: It's so funny. I'm going off on a tangent already, but I my grandfather got us the Hardy Boys, and it's like you're supposed to read that. But the Nancy Drew books were so good and they just they sucked you in.
[10:30] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah.
[10:31] Robert Peterpaul: I'm gonna get a flashlight now and I'm gonna move over to your weekends as a teenager. So as a teenager, my weekends were spent.
[10:39] Emma Straub: I mean, uh, my children know this about me, so I suppose it doesn't matter if you do, but like um chain smoking and binge drinking. Like I was I was I did hear you say that in an interview.
[10:50] Emma Straub: Yeah, so I mean I set you up.
[10:52] Emma Straub: Yeah, I mean, I was it's so funny because now I'm so boring. And like if I have like two glasses of wine, I'm like, whoa, look out, world. But yeah, no, I was kind of a wild, I was kind of a wild teen. You know, going to like trying to get into clubs to like dance with Leonardo DiCaprio. Like that's what I was doing.
[11:20] Robert Peterpaul: Well, some of that comes out in American Fantasy. There's a lot of dancing with celebrities. And this is perfect for my next one, which is my teenage idol was.
[11:29] Emma Straub: Oh God. Well, hmm.
[11:30] Emma Straub: That's okay, that's tricky because like I mean, like, I loved the new kids on the block, but that was that was pre-teen. That was pre-teen.
[11:39] Emma Straub: River Phoenix.
[11:41] Robert Peterpaul: I have that in all caps right here.
[11:44] Emma Straub: I mean, yeah, like my 12-year-old is named River because River Phoenix was the first love of my life. Like that was he was perfect and beautiful and too pure for this world. Like, I mean, honestly, R.I.P. Sweet River. I wish that he had I wish that we could have seen him as a grown up.
[12:07] Robert Peterpaul: I know.
[12:08] Robert Peterpaul: And you know, a lot of that does come through in the book too, which we'll get into, but my next one, sort of similar, my go-to comfort movie was.
[12:08] Emma Straub: Oh my god. Um as a as a kid.
[12:20] Emma Straub: Yeah, unless it's still the same. I don't know.
[12:21] Emma Straub: Well, okay, so I would say, like, okay, so like if I was having like a sleepover with my best friend, we would be watching um Pretty in Pink, The Breakfast Club, Dirty Dancing, The Sound of Music, Grease, like at least at least two of those, I would say.
[12:42] Robert Peterpaul: It's really funny you say that we are in the Broadway podcast network, and I forgot actually, I thought this while I was reading the book. I actually think this would make such a great musical.
[12:50] Emma Straub: So do I.
[12:51] Emma Straub: So do I.
[12:52] Robert Peterpaul: Okay, okay. We're let's manifest that.
[12:54] Emma Straub: I like felt that while a musical movie or just on Broadway.
[12:57] Emma Straub: I mean, it would be so much fun.
[12:58] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah, it really would be.
[13:00] Robert Peterpaul: I agree.
[13:01] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah, okay. Let's we're putting that out there.
[13:03] Robert Peterpaul: Well, speaking of music, a song that transports me back to my teenage bedroom is.
[13:03] Emma Straub: Oh man. Okay, so okay, so by the time I was a teenager, smoking the sigs. I mean, okay, so there were I there were different sides, you know, different different parts of my heart. So it would be like, you know, Mariah Carey, like a Mariah Carey ballad. Like, for sure.
[13:33] Emma Straub: That's one side.
[13:36] Emma Straub: Yeah. Or um, or I started listening to like sad, sad, like Elliot Smith. Like I loved Elliot Smith, like that kind of thing, or like the cure, like, you know, so I so it because I went from like I went from like pop music, pop music, like New Kids on the Block, Madonna, Janet Jackson, to like R.B. I transitioned like through R.B. to like sad, sad music.
[14:10] Robert Peterpaul: Well, it teaches us how to get in touch with our emotions. My little brother used to play the ASPCA, is that it commercial with Sarah McLaughlin in the arms of an angel. He used to play that and cry.
[14:18] Emma Straub: Yeah.
[14:20] Robert Peterpaul: And he'd be like, we're not playing it for you anymore. He's like, let's play. We're like, okay. New kids on the block. Was that an inspiration? Because they do a famous cruise, right? Don't they?
[14:28] Emma Straub: They sure do. They sure do. And I and I went, I did it. I went.
[14:33] Robert Peterpaul: Was it research or was it inspiration?
[14:36] Emma Straub: I mean, it was research. It was research, but I went, I mean, yes. I went because I had an idea for this novel, like a boy band cruise novel.
[14:50] Emma Straub: And I was like, well, like that's my boy band. Like, so that's perfect. Like, I can go and I can like understand what the scene is like, and then I can obviously like make up the the boy band that I need, you know, like that. Like, I wasn't interested in writing a book about any actual boy band. I just, but I but I did go on their cruise. And like it was research, and I was taking notes the whole time and taking pictures and like really like juicing it for that. But I would be lying if I said to you that I wasn't also like there as a as a as a person, you know, like as like a a person who had loved them at a at a tender moment in my life. And who was like really ready to scream with everybody else, you know? Which is so special. It's such a cathartic experience to just be with your people and let loose that way. And I mean, nuke it's on the block. I'm just gonna say maybe they're the composers of this musical that we've been doing throughout our time together.
[16:05] Robert Peterpaul: But I wonder, Emma, you know, I have this question later on, and I mean, I guess this flash round isn't so much flash anymore. It's more just around and round and round. I'm wondering, are you like Annie in these situations? How are you when you step into these situations maybe by yourself? I don't know if you had a friend with you, but what would you say you're like in those?
[16:20] Emma Straub: Well, I I went alone. I went alone because I wanted to I wanted to be there alone. Like I I didn't want anyone to I didn't want to have to like take care of anyone, you know, like I didn't want to have to like make sure someone else was having a good time or like you know, like I didn't want to have to do that. But I also really didn't want anyone I knew looking at me, you know, like I wanted to I wanted to experience it as like as purely as I could and to process it on my own without having to do that, you know, that normal thing that you would do with any friend if you were like, you know, went to a show or a movie or whatever where you're like, oh God, blah blah blah. You know, like you know, you don't I didn't want to do that.
I wanted to really like think about it and and just experience it. Um but yeah, I mean it it is it is a beautiful thing to to be in community in that way. Like it really is like being in the audience in a theater or or or at a concert or like I mean it was I felt that I was even though I saw myself as like different than the crowd in a lot of ways I also was like, oh like the things that I am seeing as different are so surface level and really we are all the same. Like these are my people. These are my people. Like I might be to pretend to be some sophisticated New York City, whatever. But like, but that doesn't matter. Like it's we are we are all the same here. Like we're all here for the same reason, which is that this music was really meaningful to us, and it still is. Otherwise you wouldn't you wouldn't go, you know?
[18:36] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah. I love that you say that because these unifying forces are so important in today's world. And so, you know, you might spend that weekend not knowing what someone's politics are, what not knowing X, Y, and Z about them, and then at least for the to the weekend have a friend or just have a good time and it gives me hope. And I, you know, looking at that environment, just to wrap up this flash round, I had a writing environment I fantasize about. Uh uh one where uh someone brings me meals.
[19:08] Emma Straub: Oh what kind of what kind of meals are we talking?
[19:12] Robert Peterpaul: I don't know, just like any like a basket. I don't know. Many, many friends of mine have have gone to like, you know, these like famous writer retreats, you know, where whatever, where they literally bring you lunch in a little basket. And I think desperate housewives situation. I don't know what it is. I don't know what's in there. I but I've never had that, and I want a basket. You know, I feel like one of the big problems of adulthood is that you're in charge of figuring out what you have to eat so many times a day.
[19:36] Emma Straub: So many times a day, and that you have to then procure it and then cook it.
[19:51] Robert Peterpaul: Like thank you. Terrible. Terrible. I was just working on this family musical and I added a line that was like, Why are happy meals for kids? Like the adults are the ones that need happiness more. So throw French fries in a basket and it's just a lot happier. But we'll say you won the splash round, you win a sexy sunrise. And let's just let's dive into American fantasy and just more about you. Obviously, I I'll say for listeners, this story centers on Annie, a newly divorced woman who rediscovers herself on a themed cruise, as we've mentioned with 90s boy band energy. She loved them as a teen, exploring themes of nostalgia and second chances and aging and really all the things from all different perspectives.
I've heard you speak before about how you feel like you can only write books that feel like you could write them. I'm phrasing this very poorly. But yeah. What was it about? I guess we've touched on it al already, but what do you think the core of this story was?
[20:44] Emma Straub: Yeah. I mean, because I think that like if you know, there are people love to say that like there are a limited number of plots in the world or whatever. And I don't I but that might be true, but I really don't think it matters because I think that any time you read a book, the thing that's gonna get you or push you away is gonna be the way the story is told. Like the way the writer uses sentences and language and humor. Like that is what is gonna either bring you in or push you out. Um and so I think it's true for all of us that like we we all are writing books that only we could write. Like that's the goal. That's the goal. But for this one, like I mean, yeah, I mean I, you know, I like to write books with that have humor.
Like not all my books are hilarious. Yes they are. They're all hilarious. But like, you know, they're that's not always like the number one thing. But like this one I knew I wanted it to have both like humor and transcendence. Like I wanted it to be both. I wanted there to be room for both. Um and that's yeah and I and I and I think I did it. I think I didn't I think I did it too.
[22:06] Robert Peterpaul: I'm glad you think you did it because that's it's important. I mean I think someone of your stature too a lot of young writers obviously look up to and I don't know the self-confidence thing is tricky as as any human will know but I love that you just talk about because of your iconic father and growing up in this it's like it is a job. So it's sort of like you know there's people that work at an office and know they're really good at X, Y, and Z. So I don't know the self confidence thing in the arts, don't you find it's like a little bit more complicated.
[22:36] Emma Straub: Yeah it is well because I think that we are you know if you if you work in an office and you're you know your your only feedback is gonna be from I maybe your your your direct boss at your annual review or whatever, you know? And that's gonna be well, Robert, you know, you were really great at this this year, but this uh, you know, you could maybe improve on the XYZ, but oh you know, like that's the feedback. But when you're an artist of whatever kind and putting things out into the world, you hear back from everybody. I mean, whether it's like, you know, professional critics, you know, who who have really put like time and thought and their own art into your into engaging with your art, which I I usually find like flattering even if it's not totally positive.
[23:33] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah.
[23:34] Emma Straub: But you also have places like Goodreads or like Amazon, where people can write you like a one star review and then you look at it. This was this was my favorite one. From my book, from my book, All Adults Here, there was a one star review that said, This book has cursing and gay marriage. And I was like, Yep. Yes, it does. Yes, it does.
[24:01] Robert Peterpaul: I hope you framed that.
[24:03] Emma Straub: Yeah, frame that and put it up. I thought you were gonna say like cursing like like a witch magic kind of virus.
[24:09] Robert Peterpaul: I would also words.
[24:10] Emma Straub: Yeah, that would also be fine. But so you just I mean, that's what I mean. You just hear from everybody and and and some things like that comment, like are easy to be like, okay, well, I wish you luck with this world person. But but but more often it's like, you know, so I mean, sometimes it's harder to ignore that that kind of feedback. Um, but yeah, I mean, what I try to remember is that like it's my job to write the book, you know, like it's my job to write the book and to talk to people about it and to, you know, go on book tour and you know, read from it or talk about it with readers, whatever, but like it's not my job to um to worry about how it is received. Like I've I've I've done my part and I worked so hard on it and I am so proud of it, and it was so meaningful to me to write it, you know? So so whatever happens after that is sort of none of my business.
[25:19] Robert Peterpaul: I love that perspective. It's like you put the meal in the basket, you left it at the door, and whatever happens behind the door, you're making another basket already, you know, so just enjoy it.
[25:27] Emma Straub: Yeah. I I wonder, I I'm not sure at your your level. I know it's certainly true for um, you know, writers starting out, but we mentioned good reads. Do you still write your sort of log lines? And I this is a technical question, but I wonder what okay, I was gonna ask you what makes a good log line in your opinion.
[25:43] Emma Straub: No, no, I don't do any of that. I don't do any of that, and I don't go there at all. And it was funny, I was I was at like a a bookseller conference a couple of last week and I was talking to this other woman novelist, and she says she's publishing her maybe third or fourth book, and she told me that she still goes and looks and reads those reviews. And I was like, girl, no, no, don't do that. Don't do that. Um, but I guess some people do. Some people do. Oh my god. It's not for us. It's not for us. That's the way I see it.
[26:21] Robert Peterpaul: But what about like the sort of I mean log I guess that might be a screenwriter term, the log line in the s in like the one sentence of your book and then even the synopsis? That feels like the bane of people's existence.
[26:30] Emma Straub: Yes. No, no. My editor, I I do, I do I have some friends who do write those for themselves, but I I don't. I don't. My editor does it and she sends it to me to read. And sometimes I give her, you know, feedback or whatever, ask for changes. But mostly I'm just like, please take this off my plate. You do it. You're a professional.
[26:53] Robert Peterpaul: Like Yeah, I think that's that's smart. You know, it's it those things can be a little a little too much. And you know, just even looking at the cover, it's hitting me now. We don't get a lot of really fun, happy big boat stories. We got Titanic, we got Jaws. I mean, we got what's it what's the the one that woman in Cap and 10. I mean, this I thought this was such a brilliant setting. And it also just features a lot of acts of kindness, in my opinion. You know, from the new friend that Annie meets to Sarah, who's so hilarious, the cruise coordinator. It kind of starts out as niceties, almost politeness, and then by the end, genuine kindness. And I just wonder it's kind of something you think about when when you're writing.
[27:35] Emma Straub: Yeah. I mean, it well, it's something I think that it's something that I think about as a as a person, you know, like it's something that I think about in my in my actual life. And therefore, because uh it's something that I think about, it ends up in my fiction. You know, like I don't like I I guess I knew I wanted in the book, I knew I wanted this moment between Annie and Keith, where she offers him where she offers him something more genuine than he's used to receiving in this in this setting. So I guess that I mean I was thinking about kindness in that in that moment where like I wanted her, you know, it's it i in this setting like these men, these poor men are are really are treated like zoo animals.
You know, they are treated like beloved zoo animals. Like, you know, who's the who's the monkey right now that everybody came into my mind too and I can't remember the name. I could see the monkey. You know, they're they're they're treated well, but they're treated like um, you know, like yeah, exactly, very much like not human, like not the same. And I wanted Annie to like s actually see him and and and check in with him just the way she would have with anyone, you know, and and that and that moment in the book ended up being like a a big shift for the their characters.
[29:18] Robert Peterpaul: On the flip side, Emma, how kind would you say you are to yourself during the writing process? Especially on the tough days where, you know, I think some people think it's glamorous and inspiration is always striking, but I I sometimes it is, but I know sometimes it's also not.
[29:32] Emma Straub: Yeah, I mean, I think that like I've written, you know, I've written enough books now that I'm familiar with my own dramatic ups and downs. And you know, I've been with my husband for a really, really, really long time. And so he also, if I'm like, oh my god, this is going so badly, I'm never gonna do this, he will say to me, like, uh-huh, okay, yep. You say this every time at exactly this point, and here's what's gonna happen. And he's always right. Like he's always right. Like, I'm always so stressed about finishing like a draft or whatever. And he's like, Okay, you're gonna be done in two days. I've seen this before. But it yeah, so I think in terms of being kind to myself, like I pretty much have, you know, like I know that I can do it now.
Writing a novel is hard, but it's hardest the first time because that's when you don't know whether or not you're capable of it. Like I imagine it's like any sustained, like running a marathon, you know, like until you actually run a marathon, you're like, well, I don't know. I like running, but can I? That seems hard. But then if you do it again, you know that you might have easier and tougher marathons, but you know that you can run a marathon, and that's what writing a novel feels like.
[31:13] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah, the information, the awareness, having the person to drag you back down and anchor you in reality, which I love. I think your relationship seems like just such a, I know it's real, but fantasy too. I was showing my wife the bookstore you guys have together. I'm like, oh my gosh, such a dream. Which I want to get into your bookstore too. But yeah, American Fantasy. Okay, we've talked about how it's set on the cruise. There's boy talk, which is chef's kiss. I mean, you nailed the name so good. Fandom, I guess, is it something that's always interested you? And then on the flip side, now you have your own fan. So how does it feel to now be on the other side?
[31:49] Emma Straub: Okay. Well, first of all, I have to give my husband credit because he came up with the name Boy Talk. It was him. It was him all the way, hundred percent. So he gets a Did you have one that you initially had in there that changed over? They were so much worse that I can't even remember what they were. But he came up with Boy Talk. Um, 97 Degrees? Yeah, that's too much. But yeah, I mean, I just I am a fan. I'm a fan. And I've always been a fan. And like, you know, I'm a fan of, you know, bands and, you know, film directors and, you know, songwriters and whatever, you know, like I'm a fan in a lot of different directions. But like there is something about the uncoolness of being an ardent open-hearted fan of something that I just think is really beautiful and pure.
And I wanted to tap into that. That the uncoolness of that felt connected to me to the uncoolness of being in middle age. Because like I'm 45, you know, and like I don't know, like my children nag me all the time and are like, You're so old. And I'm like, well, no, I'm not, but also I am the youngest that I'm ever gonna be. So like I look great. I look great, I feel great. I like I am, you know, I'm doing great. So like I but also like last week we were on vacation, and it just so happened that one of my sons, my younger son's favorite basketball players, was in our hotel, and he was down the hall and we could see him, and I was like, Jalen! Like I just called out his name, you know, and my son is like hiding behind me, terrified. But I was like, I have nothing to be embarrassed by. Like, you cannot shame me. You know what I mean? Like, I am totally uncool, and that's great. Like, it is freeing. It is freeing.
[34:20] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah, it's so true. And it's also a fuel because if you didn't have the fans, you couldn't write books. If that, you know, he wasn't on the court, you know. Like if no one came up to you and said they loved your book, how sad would that be? So it's sort of like, I mean, I know there's a time and a place. You don't want to go up to someone when they're eating dinner or whatever. There's some things to navigate there on a human level, but it is so needed. And can I just say that this book literal book jacket? I was like really nailed what a fan looks like. I mean, with the we got the pin, the talker pin. I mean so Chef's kiss beautiful there. I wonder for you, is there anyone you're a big fan of that you would love to see in a movie version of this or like a Broadway version? Have you thought that far ahead?
[35:06] Emma Straub: Or no, I don't know. I mean, you know, in terms of like adaptation stuff, like my books have, I think, except for my first novel, my books have all been like optioned and like so many times, like so over and over again. And things, you know, like right now, there's one of my books that seems like it has a little chance. But who knows? You know, like I so I try not to think about it too much. But what I will say is that I mean, number one, I do think that American Fantasy would be an incredible musical. I really do. But also I think that if it was a film adaptation, like what I love is that the characters are middle-aged, but they are like deep in reinvention. You know, like they're finding new corners of themselves, and they want more. They want more, they want something new. And I just would love to see that's what I want to see in the movies anyway, you know, is like I want to see a middle-aged lady discovering her rediscovering herself. Like, yes, please.
[36:36] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah, like we want to feel seen, we want to see what we haven't seen. Well, I keep saying seen, and we want to see Meryl Streep in a scene. I mean, Meryl Streep, we just want to see everything, I guess. That's just Land this plane. But you know, what I loved about this too is that you paint so many quirky characters that I'm sure you maybe saw when you were actually on the cruise and maybe amped up a little bit and hopefully you didn't see some of the things or count of some of the things. But one of the things I admire about you most is that I feel like you are a community creator, obviously with your readership, but also in person with your bookstore. And I just would love your thoughts on what you think cultivating a community means because we need more community in this world.
[37:17] Emma Straub: I mean that it's so crucial. It's so crucial, especially like not only in the horrific political climate that we're in right now, and not only in the post-COVID pandemic world, but we just need it. We need spaces where we can go where we feel safe. I mean, just base level where we feel safe and welcome and where we feel like we can explore things and learn things and experience things. Like we have events at our bookstore like not quite every day, but like we had almost 300 events last year.
[38:05] Robert Peterpaul: Wow.
[38:05] Emma Straub: And that's across everything. That's like, you know, big famous novelists and poets no one has ever heard of, and you know, picture book artists and like everyone in between. Because it is I mean, it's the same as the cruise, you know, like it feels good to sit there and learn about something new about a book, hear from a book, have an experience, and then you know, get to meet them after. Like it's really amazing. And that's just like, you know, the public events, you know, the public events, but like the really important thing, like the most important thing for me is just the everyday, like being a part of someone's routine, you know, being a part of like especially with like little kids, like just being a part of their routine and their lives, the dogs in the neighborhood, like who come in and know where the treats are, you know what I mean?
Like that kind of stuff is just and like being a good work environment too, you know, being a place where people are happy to come to work and feel like safe and listened to and supported, like, you know, it's so much for so many people. And I just feel really lucky that we were crazy enough to do it, and that we've really lucky that we have learned as much as we have about how to do it well over the last like almost nine years, you know, because we didn't know what we were doing at the beginning, but now we really do.
[39:58] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah, you took a dip in and then you learned how to swim. You know, I mean it's so novel not to have another pun here, but it sounds like such a novel idea just to have a kind space, you know, and it's sad that it's not something that's down across the board, but yeah, I just appreciate you for doing that. And I can't even imagine how special it is to know that sometimes you're giving someone the first book that they'll ever read.
[40:21] Emma Straub: Yeah.
[40:22] Robert Peterpaul: That must be crazy.
[40:23] Emma Straub: I think about that in the theater. It's like someone's first show. They always say it's someone's first show and last show, which is like, but it applies to books too, you know? It's magic.
[40:32] Robert Peterpaul: Which is do you love the word magic? Because I see you use it a lot, and I see honestly.
[40:38] Emma Straub: I do, I do. I mean, and like, you know, before we opened, my husband and I met with this guy who wanted to invest, or who's like a potential investor. And I mean, we didn't like him anyway, but we really didn't like him. Shark Tank music is playing in my head. It's like he said to us, no one serious will ever walk into a store called Books Are Magic. And I just like I kind of want to just be like, P.S. Do you know how many t-shirts we have sold? Like how many thousands of t-shirts and hats and pens and stickers. Like, forget the hundreds of thousands of books we have sold. Like, do you know how many things we have sold that say Books Are Magic? Because people are like, oh my god.
[41:28] Robert Peterpaul: I mean, I think the greatest thing you could do is have him come and give him one.
[41:33] Emma Straub: I mean, like give him a t-shirt.
[41:34] Robert Peterpaul: There's yeah, there's a I've heard so many stories that are similar with like Adam Sandler, his teacher telling him he can't act, and then later he gets him a drink at a bar, and he's like, Well, I'm pretty famous now. But um, that's hilarious to me. Well, congratulations on that. Obviously, this book, I think we've talked about this a bit, but a major through line is just vulnerability and sort of the characters can't really get to the climax or the end or have these genuine moments unless they embrace that. And Annie certainly is learning still to embrace that. And I wonder what role do you think vulnerability kind of plays in not only the book, but just in kindness and sort of if you have advice for all of us out there that are afraid to be vulnerable.
[42:13] Emma Straub: Yeah, I mean, I think that it really helps. And like this is certainly true. Like just to go back to what I was saying about the bookstore, like I have certainly learned that like, you know, if I pretend that I have all the answers and know exactly how everything should be, people are gonna be like, mm, this is sort of off putting. But if you're like, gosh, I really don't know. What do you think? You know, like if you are open to admitting what you don't know, people will step into that space so happily and be more open with you and be kind to you. And like so certainly I think vulnerability is a direct invitation to kindness.
[43:09] Robert Peterpaul: I love that.
[43:11] Emma Straub: And I talk about t-shirts and hats. Vulnerability is a direct invitation. Let's go. But you know, I think that it's true. I mean, I hope it's true in my work also that like I mean I definitely feel like American Fantasy and This Time Tomorrow, which was my most recent book, like those two books are by far my most vulnerable are by far my most personal and I think they're my best. I think because of that, you know, because I'm like, well, here is my heart. Here, here, here is me. Here is what I am on the inside. Take it or leave it. You know. Like it's it means more to me, you know. And I think that that comes across on the page.
[44:15] Emma Straub: And even just looking at misconnections, I mean, I have 87 cheesy metaphors that I won't say as far as like a plug and an outlet and having a computer, having Wi-Fi. I mean, it really takes two. And in this, I think I especially notice it in the brothers dynamic. You know, it's like they're not able to genuinely connect because none of them are really being vulnerable with each other.
[44:34] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah.
[44:34] Emma Straub: And I even just appreciated seeing sort of male identifying folks attached to themes that maybe we don't traditionally get to see in media as far as like aging and all that. I mean, you really hit so many different levels. So I'd love to know how you sort of approached writing them specifically and finding the balance.
[44:52] Emma Straub: Yeah. Well, I mean, I loved them. I loved the men. They're so fun. The men of boy talk, the boys of boy talk. I loved them because in my previous novels, I'd spent a lot of time on family dynamics, you know, whether it's like marriage and children or siblings or whatever. But they were their own little kind of family for me to understand.
[45:22] Emma Straub: And it is fascinating to me to think about. I mean, so number one, just like a group of middle-aged men and how they relate to each other. Number two, like a group of middle-aged men who have been like physically objectified for their entire lives. That was really interesting to me because like, you know, I think that we these men, like what they get pelted with is in many ways a lot more like what most women get pelted with, which is like a dissection of their bodies and their hair and their faces and like, you know, their aging is scrutinized. And that I mean, I think that's true for maybe anyone in the public eye, but like, you know, if you were like a heartthrob, whatever that meant in the eighties or nineties, what do you look like now? You know? And like that, I was really interested in that. I just, I just loved them. I just loved them.
[46:34] Emma Straub: And I love that their experiences were all different. You know, it's not like they were all like being famous is awesome. Or being famous is terrible. Like, you know, like they really have a wide range of experiences. You know, some of them are good with money, some of them are bad with money, some of them are happy in their lives, and some of them are not, you know, like, um, yeah, I loved, I loved boy talk. My sweet, my sweet boys. I love them so much too. And I loved their dynamic with Sarah. I mean, obviously the Keith and Sarah dynamic.
[47:06] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah.
[47:08] Emma Straub: I mean, I would honestly read a whole series of Sarah just on different cruises with these different people. I mean, I thought she was such a fun character. And it was cool because I don't even know if this is true, but it sort of opens with Sarah on the reality and then it ends in a fantasy, or at least could be a fantasy, could be real. We don't really know.
[47:26] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah.
[47:27] Emma Straub: That was just such an interesting parallel too that I'm remembering right now that I feel the need to say to you.
[47:32] Robert Peterpaul: No, you're right.
[47:33] Emma Straub: You're right. Well, and that, you know, like I really I wanted to play, you know, one of the reasons that I had these three points of view is because I wanted the reader to feel like they really got the truth of it. You know, like that they got okay, so you can see it from Keith's perspective, which you know is sort of skewed in these ways, and you see it from Annie's perspective, which you know is sort of skewed in these ways, but with Sarah, you're looking at it pretty straight on.
[48:09] Emma Straub: Um, you know, but then as the book goes on, you know, things get a little loose, things get a little looser, you know, things get a little kooky.
[48:21] Robert Peterpaul: Oh, yeah.
[48:22] Emma Straub: There's a it's a wave that you must ride. I'm going to like a Jennifer Anderson voice. I don't know why. I also loved the structuring and the framing of actually having the itinerary because it really does feel like you're on the cruise. Was that always there?
[48:35] Emma Straub: Yeah. I mean, I just, you know, I wanted it to be like, because it is, you know, it the cruise is purposefully repetitive, you know, like it has to be because you can't go anywhere. You cannot leave. And so you're gonna be in the same spaces over and over again. And so I wanted to give the reader as much sort of help as possible, being like, okay, here's what's coming next. This is, you know, sort of timetable.
[49:02] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah.
[49:03] Emma Straub: Which could have felt repetitive and almost made you check out when you're reading it, but like you nailed it in such a way that even if it's in the same room, it's just it's so exciting. Like you feel like you're getting dressed and getting ready to go to the event. I mean, it's so good. And I think one moment that I remember that to me really spoke to kindness, and I was very lucky to have an early copy of the book. So I don't know if this is still in the book, and if it's not, I'll cut this out. But it's a moment where Annie really reflects not just on aging, but also the current state of the world. And we actually talk about it on this podcast a lot of seeing someone on the other side of the sidewalk and then walking towards each other. And then I think you wrote there used to be dances.
[49:41] Emma Straub: Yeah.
[49:41] Robert Peterpaul: And she says there used to be that, like you would actually look at each other.
[49:45] Emma Straub: Yeah.
[49:45] Robert Peterpaul: And in the world today, it's such a like an astute observation to me because that's so lacking. Everyone's just on their phones. And don't you find looking up is just such an act of kindness?
[49:55] Emma Straub: Yeah.
[49:56] Emma Straub: Yes. Engaging, engaging with the humanity of the people around you. A hundred percent.
[50:02] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah.
[50:02] Emma Straub: And I thought that, and then I mean, not just to keep reading you to you, but there was another line you wrote, I think that was just okay. This is actually one of this is a question I have for you before I get to that line. Don't worry, everybody.
[50:12] Emma Straub: Yeah.
[50:14] Emma Straub: I have an issue where I will not write in books or highlight, and I'm having more authors on here now, and I just like can't mark up a book, Emma. What is my deal? Is that something you do? I gotta get over this.
[50:27] Emma Straub: I think I think your books belong to you, you know. And you can you can write in them, you can fold down the pages. Like, I mean, do I have some regrets about um like folding down the pages in some like first edition books that I stole from my parents when I was a teenager? Yes, I do, but you know what? You know what? Those like Frank O'Hara poems really meant the world to me. And I can still pull that book off the shelf and see what pages I folded down in 1995. So like I think it's fine. I think it's fine. Do whatever you want. Do whatever you need to do.
[51:10] Robert Peterpaul: There's so like there's two types of people in this world. My wife's the opposite. And I'll I'll give her one of my books and then she'll sit in bed and she'll go like this. And like crack it back, and I hear the spine break, and I'm like, ow!
[51:23] Emma Straub: But I I love that. I think that's so true. And in my chicken scratch notes, I wrote, I think you had a very simple sentence, which is just joy was important.
[51:32] Emma Straub: Yeah.
[51:32] Robert Peterpaul: And I feel like that must be just an important part of your process in writing. Like having the joy.
[51:41] Emma Straub: Yes, yes, yes. Yes. I mean, I think joy is important in general in life. Um in our I mean, in your day, you know, I think that there should be things that bring you joy every single day, whether it's like a matcha, you know, or a yoga class, or a song in your headphones, or a moment that you sit on a sunny park bench, or whatever, you know, or whatever. Like there should be things that bring you joy every single day.
[52:24] Emma Straub: And I think that writing this book was like just I mean, it was a gift that I gave to myself of knowing that I was like taking taking my own joy seriously for the time that it took to write a book, you know, which is a long time. Like it's a it's a years long process, you know. Like I went on the Nukies on the Block cruise in 2023. Now it's 2026. You know, like that's three years of dedication. And like w how amazing to be able to do that for yourself.
[53:13] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah.
[53:13] Emma Straub: And it does, like you said earlier, allow you to just see people in a different light and experience people in a different light than if you were to, you know, meet them as an investor for a venture versus seeing them as a fan screaming. You know, it's it's so cool to me. And I wonder, we once had uh Morgan Harper Nichols on here, and she described inspiration as an inhale. And I just wonder what are the things you inhale, like what inspires you maybe on the days where you're not feeling motivated.
[53:39] Emma Straub: Yeah. I mean, I would say that the thing this feels extreme, having just written a book that takes place on a cruise. And I so I don't I don't always mean it this literally, but travel, travel really inspires me always. Like travel, there's I think it's because like, you know, I have a husband and two children and two bookstores, and like my my circuit, my daily circuit is really small. Like I basically walk in a circle all day long, you know, between these points, these fixed points. And so I think my brain, you know, is sometimes like like a car on a track at Disney World, like where, you know, like I I don't have to think too much in order to get where I'm going. But whenever I'm in another space, and I mean, I could be going out to dinner in Manhattan, you know what I mean? Like it it doesn't have to be the other side of the world. Like anytime I'm pushed outside of my little triangle of life, like I feel like that is inspiring.
[54:55] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah, my little triangle of life. I love that.
[54:57] Emma Straub: I mean, it's certainly true in the cruise, too, right? I mean, they don't have to think where they're going and then well, they do go off at one point, which is that little oh the catty group that uh women I mean I could get I could I gotta stop. Okay. I enjoyed this book so much. I I am a lifelong fan. Now I'm gonna read all your other stuff, download it into my brain. And I would just love if we could end our time together by you sharing a tangible kindness tip. So what is something you would like everybody out there listening to do on their own corner of the world to try and make the world a little brighter?
[55:30] Emma Straub: Um I would say write thank you notes. Now that doesn't mean just like you know, someone sends you a birthday present, you know, your grandmother sends you a fifty dollar check for your birthday, you write her a thank you note. Like you better, you better send her a thank you note for sure. But what I mean is like someone does something kind for you, you know, like whatever it is, whether it's like a coworker who like brings you a coffee when they're getting a coffee, or you know, or a friend who just reaches out to say hello because they're thinking of you or whatever, you know, just like some thing that where you're like, oh, that person was thoughtful, like to just reach back out to them and say thank you. It could be a text, it could be an email, it could be a letter in the mail, you know, like it could be anything. But just to say thank you.
[56:35] Emma Straub: Like I love writing thank you notes more than anything in the world. It's so and it's like it's so satisfying. And like yesterday I got a thank you note from a writer whose book I chose for my first edition club at the store. And it was so nice. And it was months ago. Like it was months ago. But it but it was It does take time sometimes to write a nice thank you note, you know, it takes a couple months, yeah.
[57:07] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah, and but it was so genuine. And so then I'm I immediately wrote her a thank you note for her thank you note. You know what I mean?
[57:13] Emma Straub: Okay.
[57:15] Emma Straub: I this is this is a spiral you can get down as a kind person because then you're like, why do the thank you notes stop?
[57:20] Robert Peterpaul: No, that's it.
[57:21] Emma Straub: Like I think that's the end. That's the end of the thing. You know, 'cause like I feel like especially when when you send someone a letter in the mail, like I I want acknowledgement that it showed up. You know what I mean?
[57:33] Robert Peterpaul: Yes.
[57:35] Emma Straub: So I sent her an email. Like I didn't write her back a another letter, but I sent her an email and I was like, I got your letter and it's blah blah blah. You know?
[57:43] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah.
[57:44] Emma Straub: It's the start of another story, you've got mail. It's like then it turns into a whole thing. I I really truly love that. And there is a lot of science behind the fact that one of the things psychologically as humans that I hate to use the word matter because it's gonna be again, that matters the most to us is feeling like we matter.
[58:00] Emma Straub: Yeah, and so thanking someone is a way to do that.
[58:03] Robert Peterpaul: Yeah, yes.
[58:05] Emma Straub: And we still do that in books. We have the whole acknowledgment section for a reason. I know my acknowledgments are not in the uh in that version, but my acknowledgments are they're really good. They're really good this time.
[58:18] Robert Peterpaul: Well, everyone, please go pick up a copy of American Fantasy. You're in for a real great trip, I'll say. And Emma, I just appreciate you being here and you being you. I think you're a great role model for people to have in the writing community. And I I gotta come to your to your shop. I will be there.
[58:33] Emma Straub: Please, please, and let me know so I can come be there and give you a hug.
[58:38] Robert Peterpaul: Oh, that would be so fun.
[58:40] Emma Straub: Yeah.
[58:41] Robert Peterpaul: Until next time, remember everything is gonna be a okay.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
