If I were a Podcast Daidle deedle daidle Daidle daidle deedle daidle dumb! Today Jess and Andrew talk about Fiddler on the Roof, in the episode they talk about Tradition and what exactly it means, they unpack the metaphor of a Fiddler on the Roof, mourn for the life of Lasar Wolf and the true love that could have been, and queried about which of Teveye's daughters would we watch to be matched up with!.. Read More
From the show: Musicals with Cheese
About
If I were a Podcast Daidle deedle daidle Daidle daidle deedle daidle dumb! Today Jess and Andrew talk about Fiddler on the Roof, in the episode they talk about Tradition and what exactly it means, they unpack the metaphor of a Fiddler on the Roof, mourn for the life of Lasar Wolf and the true love that could have been, and queried about which of Teveye's daughters would we watch to be matched up with! It'll be fun so give it a listen!
Links:
Listen to "Fiddler on the Roof" Now!
Social Media:
Musicals with Cheese on Twitter
Musicals Theatre Lives on Instagram
Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:00] Jess: Hi guys, Jess here.
[0:01] Jess: Before we get you started, I just wanted to let you guys know there is a little bit of language in this show, so if you're driving around the car and you got kids in the backseat, maybe throw on some headphones.
[0:09] Jess: Alright, thanks for listening.
[0:14] Jess: Hello, I'm Jess.
[0:16] Andrew: And I'm Andrew.
[0:17] Jess: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, a podcast where I tried to get Andrew to like musical theater more.
[0:23] Jess: Mazaltav, Mazl Tov.
[0:25] Jess: Lechaim.
[0:28] Jess: Gazuntight.
[0:29] Jess: So, with an intro like that, what could we possibly be covering this week, Andrew?
[0:35] Andrew: Uh, we're covering the most Jewish thing I've ever seen in my life.
[0:41] Jess: What is it, Andrew?
[0:43] Andrew: Uh, Fiddler on the Roof.
[0:46] Andrew: Someone gotta get him off.
[0:48] Andrew: Someone should knock him down, push him over.
[0:53] Jess: And how do we keep our balance?
[0:56] Andrew: That I can tell you.
[0:58] Andrew: In one word.
[1:00] Andrew: Tradition.
[1:14] Andrew: I wanna throw out there that, uh, with my, uh, I remember we talked about this a little bit in the episode where I tried to guess what these are about.
[1:23] Jess: Yeah.
[1:24] Andrew: Um, the fiddler character is kind of, uh, a magical being in this, I'd say.
[1:30] Jess: So I think I was partially right.
[1:31] Andrew: I'd say he's more of a metaphor than anything else, but sure.
[1:36] Jess: If you take him literally, then I was right.
[1:40] Andrew: Alright, um, so Fiddler on the Roof.
[1:44] Jess: Yes.
[1:45] Jess: Fiddler on the Roof is a musical with music by Jerry Bach and lyrics by Sheldon Harnick, and a book by Joseph Stein.
[1:52] Jess: Set in Imperial Russia in 1905.
[1:54] Jess: It is based on Tevya and his daughters, or Tevye the Dairyman, another of the Sholom Aleichem tales.
[2:03] Jess: Um, other tales by Sholom Aleichem.
[2:09] Jess: Uh, Shalom Aleichem.
[2:11] Jess: This is that whole episode.
[2:13] Jess: The whole episode's gonna be this.
[2:15] Jess: I'll be mispronouncing things that are probably being culturally uneducated, basically.
[2:21] Andrew: Look, can we can we just, uh, say right now that everything we're gonna say that's pronounced Jewish is gonna be terrible.
[2:28] Andrew: Except for Lasar Wolf.
[2:30] Jess: Alright, so the story of Fiddler on the Roof centers on Tevya, the father of five daughters, and his attempts to maintain his Jewish religious and cultural traditions as outside influences encroach on his family's lives.
[2:42] Jess: He must cope both with the strong-willed actions of his three oldest daughters who wish to marry for love.
[2:47] Jess: Each one's choice of a husband moves further from the Jewish customs that he's so used to, and with the edict of the czar that evicts the Jews from their village, spoilers alert.
[2:58] Andrew: Wow, you just ruined the whole thing in like the first five minutes.
[3:01] Jess: Even if you know the ending of Fiddler on the Roof, it's not like it's gonna ruin the entire experience for you.
[3:07] Andrew: It's true.
[3:07] Andrew: It's not very story-driven, I wouldn't say.
[3:10] Andrew: It's character-driven and it feels more like a sitcom, basically.
[3:13] Jess: It feels like a few episodes of a sitcom that happens to take place in Imperial Russia.
[3:20] Andrew: You say that about everything we watch.
[3:21] Andrew: It feels like an episode of something.
[3:23] Andrew: You said that about Falsettos, too.
[3:25] Jess: I did say that about Falsettos.
[3:27] Jess: The original Broadway production of Fiddler on the Roof, which opened in 1964, had the first musical theater run in history to surpass 3,000 performances.
[3:35] Jess: Fiddler held the record for the longest-running Broadway musical forever for almost 10 years until Grease surpassed its run.
[3:41] Jess: It remains the sixteenth longest-running Broadway show in history.
[3:45] Jess: The production was extraordinarily profitable and highly acclaimed.
[3:48] Jess: It won nine Tony Awards, including Best Musical, Score, Book, Direction, and Choreography.
[3:53] Jess: It spawned five Broadway revivals and a highly successful 1971 film adaptation that won Best Picture and was nominated for a bunch of other Oscars.
[4:04] Jess: So this is a very well-known, well-respected, and well-loved musical, and do you think it's deservingly so?
[4:12] Andrew: Absolutely not.
[4:14] Andrew: I'm just gonna throw out there I thought this was awful.
[4:17] Jess: Hashtag that's a problematic opinion.
[4:22] Andrew: Hashtag I'm being, uh, I'm lying.
[4:24] Andrew: Uh, this just, that's the trailer for the episode, though.
[4:27] Jess: Cut there.
[4:28] Andrew: Uh, no, I thought the whole thing was great, I loved it.
[4:31] Andrew: We're gonna get T-shirt by our merch with that on there.
[4:38] Jess: Not really, though.
[4:39] Andrew: It was, it was really good.
[4:40] Andrew: Uh, it definitely earned its reputation.
[4:44] Andrew: It is one of those very rare, absolutely perfect Broadway shows where I literally could not change anything to make it better.
[4:51] Andrew: It's three hours long, but it doesn't feel it.
[4:54] Jess: So, Andrew, when I first told you about Fiddler on the Roof and you started watching, your response was this is the most Jewish show I've ever seen.
[5:02] Jess: And that was just from the opening number.
[5:05] Jess: And yet, despite the fact that this is very drenched in Jewish tradition, and you and I are very much Gentiles, um, we're able to relate and understand the basic morals and quandaries within this show.
[5:18] Jess: Why do you think that is?
[5:22] Andrew: Well, they don't really go into, uh, how it's how it's Jewish, really.
[5:27] Andrew: It's just more of a, it's just about tradition and, uh, that's it.
[5:33] Andrew: They just use Judaism as a, uh, way to tell that story, basically.
[5:37] Jess: I think.
[5:38] Jess: So it's still relatable.
[5:39] Andrew: I mean, what makes it so universal?
[5:41] Andrew: I mean, even when it first came out on Broadway, the way they promoted it was you don't have to be Jewish to love Fiddler on the Roof.
[5:47] Andrew: And it does have very, very specific Jewish things.
[5:50] Andrew: Like, I don't understand the exact tradition of the Sabbath and how exactly it works, or the exact marriage explanation of how it works, the father's mission and all that.
[6:02] Andrew: I had none of that coming in.
[6:04] Andrew: And yet without like outright explaining this is how it works, this is what you need, um, it conveys it very acutely and very specifically, like so subtly that we don't even know that we were taught it.
[6:16] Jess: I think it's tough to explain.
[6:18] Jess: I think it's just because you get into the characters' heads, uh, so much that you don't even notice that it's like these bizarre things that you don't know anything about.
[6:29] Andrew: I w I wouldn't call it bizarre, but just not our, um, traditional values.
[6:35] Jess: That's what bizarre means.
[6:37] Andrew: Okay, maybe not.
[6:40] Andrew: I feel like this is relatable, especially in nowadays, like the idea of one wanting to marry who they want, that's specifically relates to like the last ten years with the gay marriage and like interracial marriage and all that, and that's still going on today, where I worry if my father will accept us or give us the blessing despite this or that or that.
[7:00] Jess: Yeah, I think it's, it's just, um, it's something that is always going to be present because there's never going to be a point where there's not someone who's going to break some sort of social norm.
[7:13] Andrew: Um, there'll always be the sticklers that are like really hard to change on that.
[7:20] Jess: Well, and I think that what is really interesting with this musical is that they don't, um, they don't look down fully on the people that aren't willing to change.
[7:33] Jess: They try to show you why they're not willing to change.
[7:38] Andrew: And that sometimes they are willing to change.
[7:40] Jess: Well, the thing is, Tevya, let's let's just go through the story.
[7:44] Jess: Um, Tevya, um, is our lead character, or at least our focal character, because I'm gonna make arguments that he may not in fact be the lead.
[7:52] Andrew: Ooh.
[7:54] Andrew: I think you're just straight wrong.
[7:55] Jess: I mean, he's obviously the leader.
[7:56] Jess: I mean in musical theater structure-wise.
[7:59] Andrew: Okay.
[8:00] Andrew: Okay, fair enough.
[8:01] Andrew: Whatever you want.
[8:02] Jess: Um, he is the focal character, and we see him have to deal with the fact that his first daughter, um, wants to choose her husband.
[8:10] Jess: Her second daughter isn't asking permission, but is asking a blessing, which he's no longer has input or control over his daughter, and he finally breaks down and disowns his third daughter when she decides she wants to convert to Christianity and marry a Christian boy.
[8:26] Jess: And we see him, and he is compared to the rest of the city he lives in, one of the more liberal forward-thinking idealists in the city.
[8:37] Jess: And even then, he's still very much in love with his faith.
[8:41] Jess: He's able to bend the rules and use the traditional things as a weapon sometimes.
[8:47] Jess: But he's also, um, he's still very stern, and he's not always willing to change.
[8:55] Andrew: So it is interesting.
[8:57] Andrew: I find Tevya one of the best characters in musical theater history because of that specific duality of him, like he wants to, he loves more than he doesn't, and he wants to adapt and grow and become better, but it's where he draws the line that shows the true measure of his belief system and traditional value.
[9:19] Jess: It's a very, very nuanced, uh, story, really.
[9:23] Andrew: Mm-hmm.
[9:24] Andrew: Which I think is more interesting than something like, uh, like say Rent, where they just take all these, uh, same sort of ideas and they just basically put it like if you don't accept all this, you're just an asshole.
[9:39] Andrew: Uh, and that's it.
[9:40] Andrew: You know.
[9:41] Andrew: Uh, it's just, it's more nuanced than that.
[9:44] Andrew: Like, even when Tevya disowns his, like, third eldest daughter, um, you're, um, you're still kind of with him, like.
[9:51] Andrew: You understand, because we've had the preceding hours setting up his belief system where you're like, okay, I understand why that's where you're drawing the line.
[10:01] Jess: It's a shitty thing to do, especially in our modern context of just disowning your daughter, but you understand it.
[10:07] Andrew: Yeah, and, and almost to a point you can almost agree with him that you know what, that is from where what he's coming from, it would be impossible for him to accept that.
[10:18] Jess: Mm-hmm.
[10:19] Jess: And it's strange that while we see his wife Golda as the more strict one, or the one that's always on his ass about following this and following that, is the one willing to like bridge that gap.
[10:33] Andrew: And I find that equally interesting.
[10:36] Andrew: I almost saw it as her not bridging the gap and just her putting her emotions beyond her, uh, uh, what would, uh, what would you call it?
[10:46] Jess: Principles or faith, basically.
[10:48] Andrew: Yeah.
[10:48] Andrew: Like she was willing to go to the church, the Christian church, to figure out what happened to her daughter.
[10:54] Andrew: She cares more about her family than she does about her faith.
[10:57] Jess: Where Tevya cares about his faith and then his family.
[11:01] Jess: To an extent.
[11:02] Andrew: To an extent.
[11:03] Andrew: But if it came between him, his relationship with God and his relationship with his daughters, that is an interesting thing that I'm gonna talk about when we come to If I Were a Rich Man.
[11:14] Jess: I think this story is amazing, universal, and very clear, concise, despite being three hours long and not feeling it.
[11:23] Jess: Like, you have everything sets up very well.
[11:27] Jess: You set up the Russian Christians in the town, and even they're very nuanced.
[11:33] Andrew: Like in the two life sequence when they're he and Lasar Wolf are dancing at the bar and the Christians see them.
[11:40] Jess: They could have very easily have just started a program right there, and the like started being mean to the Jewish people on their happy day, but no, they join in and celebrate with them, revealing that they aren't just mustache-twirling meanies.
[11:56] Andrew: Yeah, which I think most, uh, most, uh, stories would have went that way where they're just like, oh, these are the bad guys.
[12:04] Andrew: Uh, now it's time to do their bad thing.
[12:07] Jess: Yeah, I mean, most of the Christian characters with speaking lines are fairly kind.
[12:13] Andrew: Fairly kind and understanding and nuanced.
[12:17] Jess: Yep.
[12:18] Andrew: Like Fietka is basically, uh, uh, a prop, but he is nice.
[12:27] Andrew: Day and night must scramble for a living children.
[12:48] Jess: Alright, let's talk about tradition for a second.
[12:50] Jess: Because I think tradition is a brilliant song.
[12:55] Jess: Alright?
[12:56] Jess: And one of the best opening numbers to any musical ever.
[12:59] Jess: Much like traditions themselves, they exist coinciding with one another as a society, weaving into one another like a woven basket, basically.
[13:10] Andrew: And so the song acts as that as well. When we get the first verse, which is um uh the papas of the papas, um, and all they have their very specific verse, and then the mamas, which is like Who must know the way to make a proper home? A quiet home, a coach home, who must raise a family and rock no home, the pop must be to be the holy book. And they're very, very different lyrical pieces. And then at the end of the song, they all come together and they fit so well, despite being very, very different melodically. And that is a description of the traditions of Anatefka altogether. Um, yeah, it's very well written. Uh, and it just keeps coming back too. It's it's uh repeats all the time throughout the whole show.
And it's perfect, and it sums up the entire village with their belief system, and every single one of the characters and where they fit in so perfectly. You are ready for this beast of a show after that song's done. I'm also a huge fan of Tevya talking to me. In the show, he's like talking to you directly, but in the film adaptation, he's talking just beyond the camera. He's talking to a tennis ball right above the camera. He's he's looking at me. You know, he knows I'm there. I wish you would address us later on, too. Like No, I was kept I kept waiting for him to come back and talk to me again. But he's just like, no, I gotta talk I gotta talk to God. And I'm like, I'm God, you know, I'm close enough.
And in that first number, we get the description of a fiddler on the roof, which is basically a representation of why we need our traditions. I feel like it's a really uh stretched metaphor, honestly, but you know, they got the name for it from it, so I think it's a effective metaphor, at least in its use, especially when how it like follows Tevy Around, and in the end, like once again Tevya's on his own pulling the cart, and he the one thing that he's able to bring with him on his back is the traditions of the fiddler on the roof, and that's what he represents. That's the one thing he has left. Was Fiddler on a roof like a saying already, or did they just make this up for this? Because it just seems like such a bizarre metaphor to just kind of pull out. I think they made it up for this based on like a Jewish painting. Ah, okay. I could see that. Mm-hmm. If I remember correctly. Now let's talk about musical theater structure for a quick second.
[16:14] Jess: Alright, so in a given musical, the first song is the introduction number. It introduces you to the world and the leads. The second number is more often than not, the I want song. Sung by the main character about what they want and their goal for the entire show. And then the third song is the conditional love song, which is we have a complicated thing, but we're gonna end up together in the end. So that is the basics of an opening of a musical. So we have tradition, which is the great opening number that sets up everyone. And then instead of having If I were a rich man as a second song, the second song is Matchmaker. Sung by Tevy's three daughters about what they want. Um, yeah. I don't think that makes the daughters the main characters, though.
Well the thing is, they get what they want in the end. Tevya doesn't. He does not become a rich man. So matchmaker is the I Want song, and we focus on these three characters as a collective, as them going in seeking out their goal. They are the only ones with an active goal in this. We want to be with someone that isn't terrible. We want to be able to choose who we get to be with. Yeah. Whereas Tevya doesn't really have a goal aside from make it through another day. Um that's a pretty important goal, though. I'd say he also has the goal that he wants to hold on to his traditions. So Matchmaker Matchmaker is the setup, and then if I were a rich man is about the one true relationship that is the love story in this.
It is the um Billy and Julie of this show. It is Tevya's relationship with God. Yes. Mm-hmm. That is the love story of Fiddler on a Roof. And uh does he end up with God in the end, I he does. The fiddler comes with him. It's true. That's true. So Tevya has lost everything. He's lost his home. The I the icon of his entire homeland and all that, he's lost his daughters. One of them's going one direction, another one's going another direction, the other one's in Siberia. So he's lost them. Um, and he all he has left now is the tradition and his relationship with God, which will never leave his side and comes with him to America where he goes after he's kicked out of his home. Yeah, so I guess he does end up with God.
Although he was already with God also, so. Yeah, but i i it gets complicated, especially after Zidol's wedding. Yes. Yes, it does get complicated. He gets he has a rocky relationship with the with the big man. Which is like any romantic comedy. They they're together, they have the second act breakup, and then they get back together. Despite all the shit thrown at both parties.
[19:16] Andrew: So so are you saying that you think that the three daughters are the main characters just because they have the song in that spot? They have the I Want song and they get what they want. So I'm saying that they collectively are the main characters. Wouldn't it be just easier to say that this particular straw song breaks the structure than it would be to say that these three characters that do not actually have that much time on the screen are the main characters? I don't know, because collectively they have a good amount of time. They have a bunch of songs collectively. Do they? I mean, we have Um Zidal um and model song Miracle of Miracles. They have the Far from the Home I Love. We got Havala, we got um Sunrise Sunset, which is basically a connection.
Havila is is Tefya. Yes, but it's about her. It's him singing about her, but it's not her song. I mean, they have collectively a good amount of moments. Tevia has way more. Tevya is the focal character, but I'm not sure he is the lead, so to say. I I feel like those two are synonymous. They aren't quite. They're close, but not always. Because I consider the one with a clear goal with an arc and all that as the lead central characters. And it's just fun to speculate. And it's just fun to speculate too. But Tefia also has a clear goal, and he definitely has an arc. Does he though? And he Yeah, he does. I mean, yes, he has things that put him in a place there and he he doesn't begin, but he's basically the same person.
He's not changed. He definitely has changed. He's changed his mind on quite a few things. Yes, but when it comes to the big thing that we are set up to, he is there. He is still steadfast. Even the last words he says to his daughter is kind of a backhand compliment. I'm trying to remember what she what he said. Um Zidal is trying to call out to Hava, and they're and Tevy's like sarcastically whispering to the Zeital to say, God be with you. It's like, yeah, you've given up our god, so let him be with you still. I guess. I mean, there's a lot of different implications of that line. I it depends on how it's said. I don't think that means that he's not the lead just because of that.
[21:51] Jess: May the Lord protect and protect. May the Lord preserve you from May of Smain Sabbath. I love the Sabbath prayer sequence. Like, I think that's a fun scene that's like so emotionally gripping and so solemn. And it's just it's based on an actual prayer. What did you think of that song? Um, I mean, it was uh There was a lot going on uh around that song, so it was definitely an interesting uh because they had the uh like basically the um Jeez Oh my goodness, I can't talk right now. Okay. Uh they had uh the two men that both wanted the same daughter, and that was all no, they want different daughters. What? They wanted different daughters. They they did? Yeah, they w um model wanted Zeitl, and um Perchik wanted um Hodel.
No, no. Model and laser wolf both wanted the same daughter. Gotcha, gotcha. My bad. And that was happening around the Sabbath prayer song. Yep, I thought you meant because Perchick and Model were both there. I thought you misinterpreted as them both wanting Zeitle. No. Perchick didn't want anybody. He just wanted to preach communism. Fair. His true love. Uh yep, yeah, yeah. I don't see him going to jail over fucking Hodle. He didn't. In fact, he uh he he left her alone because he doesn't care about her. He just loves uh he just loves communism. Um and after the Sabbath prayer, we get probably one of the more fun songs in the entire show. To life to life, the hai.
[24:13] Andrew: Yes, to my bride to be. Bring the hai to life to life, the hai. Life has a way of confusing us, blessing and bruising us. Bring the high to life! Uh I remember when things used to be fun. No, Two Life is a is a really fun one. Although it it's kind of it's kind of not fun, though, because you know that it's not gonna work out. But you can see the growth of Tevya and Laser, which leads to one of the best lines in the entire show, which is I've always wanted a son, but I hope that he would be a little younger than myself. Which just shows the strangeness of the traditions that they live in. It's true, but it also breaks my heart that poor poor laser still just ends up alone. Yeah, poor laser. He went through the matchmaker and everything.
He's just gonna have to go make a lot of money killing animals all day. I mean, that's good for him, but you feel bad. You're like, this guy's he seems like he seemed like a nice guy. He really did. He did. He seemed like well-intentioned, you didn't feel like he was gonna be a bad husband desidal. But she just loved that like awkward dweeby kid, and what are you gonna do? So she begs her father to let her marry Model Come Zoyle, which is the awkward dweeby kid, and he eventually relents and says, fine, you you you enjoy your poor miserable life, you dumb dumb winch. And then he has to figure out, oh no, how am I gonna convince my wife that this was the right idea? Oh no. I mean, he he comes up with it pretty easily, I think. He doesn't think about it too long.
[26:15] Andrew: Have you no consideration for a woman's feelings? Handing over my belongings to a total stranger. How can you allow it? How? How can you let your daughter take my place? Pearls. Um this is the first time you actually see Tevya use the traditions against uh as a weapon, basically. He weaponizes tradition. Is there tradition though? Is there a tradition that he's using as a weapon to listen to your dreams or something? Like listen to the matriarch, basically. It's listening to your parental figures and your ancestors. Ancestry line, basically. But are you also supposed to listen to the dream version of them? I mean, at a certain point, do you believe that that connection to it? Like if someone's coming to you from beyond the grave as ghosts, you listen to it.
Either way, though, is a pretty funny idea. It's a funny idea, but it I don't know. I'm not a huge fan of the song. It's super goofy. I mean, I know you love cheese. Uh I just feel like it goes a little long. Is the only thing. It does it does go a little long. Uh, but I do I do like that it's like they have this like funny sequence. Uh it almost feels like uh like they ripped it out of like evil dead or something. I mean it's got some great kooky characters in there. I love the grandmother and the grandfather. And Fruma Sarah's slapping parts of it too. There's like like the the ghost is like slapping him around. Like Yeah, I don't know, it's funny. It works, but I still feel like it goes a little long in the show. The show is really long to begin with.
[28:05] Jess: You're yeah, you're not wrong about that. They definitely could have trimmed that a little bit. But you know what? Every time I pull it up and I pull up that scene, I'm never bored. Like I enjoy watching that scene full in a vacuum, but I'm not sure it works as a whole.
[28:19] Andrew: Yeah, keep it. We'll keep it. I'm fine with it. So, um the Russian Christians come in and they start bl destroying the entirety of Zidl's wedding. And Tevy's left at the end of Act One thinking, God, why are you so so mean against your most devout followers? Why do you do this to us? Is it bad that when he did he was just like kinda like doing this shocked like shrug? I was just thinking of that um that meme with uh John Travolta where he's like got his sweater and he's like looking around. That's Tevya throughout the entire show. He's just like what yeah.
[29:13] Jess: So then ha um Hodl asks Tavia if she can marry her communist boyfriend, and he's like, No, no, and she's like, I'm not really asking permission. I'd like your blessing, but we're gonna do it anyways. And he's like, What? What? What And then he just approves them anyways, because you know. Come on, Tavia, you gotta put your foot down for that kind of thing. Nope, nope. And then he gets arrested. Uh But Oh my goodness. Hoddle's profession of love makes ki Tevy curious about his own love life with his own wife. And probably my favorite song in the entire show. But do you love me? Do I love him? Well. For twenty-five years I've lived with him, fought with him, stopped with him. Twive years, my bed is his.
[30:32] Andrew: Uh do you love me? Do you love me? I think that's a really cute song.
[30:37] Jess: No, I think it's fun. It doesn't uh doesn't really have much story impact. It has a thematic impact. It's true. Where it's interesting where you have all these people talking about love, and Tevya hasn't even considered the idea that he might love his wife. He's not sure because he was trapped in that arranged marriage type traditional setting. But they do love each other, so it proves that traditions really are worth it. And I think that's like one of the more cute and honest moments. And I think especially in the film, Total plays that song really well. I think I like it. I like that part. Mm-hmm. It's really cute, and we kinda needed like an honest romance where we've seen these pe these this couple at their throats the entire show.
And then they finally come to like uh what is love, and do I actually feel it for you? I don't know. I I'm glad they didn't come to uh realize that they don't love each other, because I feel like that would have been uh it would have steered the message a little bit like wrong.
[31:33] Andrew: It would have steered it way too far in one direction.
[31:47] Jess: Yeah. But then Hadel decides she wants to go to Siberia with her communist boyfriend who is in prison. Mistake.
[32:01] Andrew: It's actually her husband, though, isn't it?
[32:03] Jess: Oh no, not yet. Not yet, no. They get married in Siberia.
[32:05] Andrew: Yeah, they get married in Siberia. So she demands that her dad take her to the train station so she can go meet with her husband. And he's like, Why are you doing this? Like, it makes no sense to me that he's demanding that you go up there. She's like, he didn't demand anything. I wanna go. And she sings probably one of the more heartbreaking songs, aside from the following one, Far from the Home I Love, where she describes, like, yeah, I love home. I love my family and all them, but I very much love this man too. And for some reason, I am feeling drawn to go with him. Oh, what a melancholy choice this is. Wanting home. Wanting him. Closing my heart to every home button. Leave a home line. How how long do you think that marriage lasts, and then how long do you think she was stuck in Siberia with no one?
[33:06] Andrew: Uh depends on how long it took for them to freeze to death. Because I'm gonna say that that marriage would have lasted like two years. At the most.
[33:16] Jess: When you don't believe in true love.
[33:19] Andrew: Um not with a revolutionary like that.
[33:22] Jess: So you believe in true love with Zidol and a model, but not with them?
[33:26] Andrew: I think that yeah, I think that they they actually model that works. I think Perchuk is uh he's a revolutionary, so he's he's a little too impulsive. It's just not gonna work out. He he thinks women and men should dance together. Fuck. He was a little crazy. Don't we we all know that men should dance together, not women.
[33:45] Jess: Yeah, I danced I danced with several men all the time down down at skins.
[33:49] Andrew: Oh yes.
[33:51] Jess: Oh yes.
[33:52] Andrew: Oh yes. But you think marrying a communist revolutionary in Siberia is whack. Wait till you hear what Hava did. Oops. Ah, she snuck out and converted to Christianity and married a Christian boy. Daddy, Jesus came in my heart.
[34:10] Andrew: Gross.
[34:14] Jess: Gross. When I said aim for the chest, that's not what I meant. I'm gonna be I'm gonna say I'm with Tevya on this. Just saw my original my initial reaction to this happening. It was just a bunch of no's a variation of no's and caps lock. You know what? Come on. Like come come on. Like, you gotta be kidding me. You're gonna you're gonna go out and marry both this guy and Jesus at the same time. Like You can't do like come come on.
[34:56] Andrew: No. No, no, no, no, no.
[34:57] Jess: And Tevya takes no time in banishing her from the family altogether. I mean, she was always the odd duckling too. She's like a ginger. Like, come on. Teving, you know that wasn't your kid.
[35:13] Andrew: He he's he's known all along. And now it's like obvious. Finally has the excuse. Little bird. Little Havel. You are always such a pretty little thing. Everybody's favorite child. Gentle and kind and affectionate. What a sweet little bird you were.
[35:42] Jess: But it leaves Tevya to sing the song Little Bird aka Havla, which I adore this song, which he sings it like he's singing it at her funeral. It literally could be a funeral song about this daughter that he that died. That's how he sees it though. That it is she's dead to me. I mean she betrayed him in a way that she must have known would be just too much. She even brought it up to him and he was very relatively understanding about it. He's like I understand that this is how you feel but a frog and a bird could very much care for each other, but where would they build a home?
[36:26] Andrew: I mean you gotta think of it too. At this time all the Christians that he knows are destroying his town uh are kicking him out of his country like do you think before Zaidal's wedding he would have been more open to it maybe.
[36:46] Jess: Probably not. But maybe. A little more open.
[36:49] Andrew: That's interesting. I find it interesting to think if these Christians had been kinder to this community, like what could have grown out of it.
[37:01] Jess: Yeah, but I mean, she betrays his faith, she betrays his trust. Uh you know, she goes behind his back with it. Like, come come on. You know, she's she's dead to me, too.
[37:21] Andrew: Papa, I beg you to accept us. Accept them.
[37:26] Jess: How can I accept them? Can I deny everything I believe in? On the other hand, can I deny my own child? On the other hand, how can I turn my back on my faith? My people. If I try to bend that far, I will break.
[37:33] Andrew: On the other hand.
[37:56] Jess: There is no other hand.
[38:05] Andrew: No.
[38:07] Jess: No!
[38:09] Andrew: Well, good thing you just lost a dark, because we gotta do some traveling. They get this notice that they have to be sent away from Anatefka, their home, because Yep, they got they gotta take they're taking over this land. Fuck y'all, get out. You know, it just feels like uh you have this this opening song where he talks about how important tradition is to him, and just throughout the entire musical, it's just slowly traditions get ripped away from him over and over and over until finally he just loses the whole fucking town and the whole everything he knows is gone.
[38:45] Jess: The fiddler falls off the roof.
[38:48] Andrew: This guy. I mean he at the end he's not on the roof anymore, is he?
[38:51] Jess: Yes. This poor guy. I feel so bad for poor Tevya. Tevy is one of the most like empathetic characters in musical history. Like, he just goes through the the shit, and even the musical has tamed down what happens to him. Like, this is the best better version of what his life ends as.
[39:21] Andrew: In the books, like, um, his entire family dies and he's left alone.
[39:27] Jess: Oh my god.
[39:37] Andrew: No. And then they sing a really like mournful song about Anatefka about their life and all that.
[39:45] Andrew: And Tevya and Lasar Wolf, despite all the disagreements, share a hug before they all go in their separate ways.
[39:56] Andrew: He was he was disappointed and he was upset and he felt betrayed.
[40:01] Jess: But I don't think he was ever. I love how he has to go to that wedding, because it would be way more weird if he didn't go because the community's so small.
[40:11] Andrew: Well, yeah, and I mean, I feel like he wanted to go because I think he really did love that girl, so he was he just wants her to be happy.
[40:19] Andrew: Like I think he cared about Zidal's happiness, but he thought that she valued funds more than she did love.
[40:27] Jess: Yeah. Which it makes sense in a lot of ways in a economically like trampled world that they live in.
[40:37] Andrew: Well, I mean, yeah, the guy with the money, like, who wouldn't want to be with him?
[40:40] Jess: I'd I'd marry him.
[40:43] Andrew: And then the show ends with Tevya and his traditions going off to America to figure out what their life leads for them next.
[40:51] Jess: I think he becomes a taxi driver.
[40:53] Andrew: I think he'd be a good taxi driver is the thing.
[40:56] Jess: He'd be a great taxi driver.
[40:58] Andrew: Until his car goes lame.
[40:59] Jess: He'd probably still end up being a milkman.
[41:03] Andrew: Ugh, bringing the milk.
[41:07] Jess: I don't think there's any milkmen in New York.
[41:13] Jess: Hey guys, sorry to interrupt you in the middle of the podcast, but we're here to shill at you.
[41:17] Andrew: Yay.
[41:19] Jess: That's my favorite thing to do.
[41:20] Jess: That's that's my uh that's my game.
[41:22] Andrew: Alright.
[41:23] Jess: Please subscribe to us on iTunes and leave us a review. It's our way of getting viewed and getting up there on the new and noteworthy list.
[41:29] Andrew: We really want that.
[41:30] Jess: Also find us on Spotify, Stitcher, and all the other podcast websites.
[41:35] Jess: Uh check us out on Twitter at Cheesy Musicals.
[41:38] Jess: On Instagram at Musical Theater Lives.
[41:41] Jess: YouTube, Musical Theatre Lives.
[41:44] Jess: And please, if you have any questions, recommendations, thoughts, or just anything that you want to say at us, email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com.
[41:53] Jess: We always read 'em and we will respond.
[41:54] Jess: We'll probably respond to them on the show.
[41:57] Jess: Also, a reminder that we are currently having a raffle for anyone that is gonna leave us a review on iTunes.
[42:04] Jess: If you leave a review, you'll be automatically put into a raffle for a $20 Amazon gift card.
[42:09] Andrew: So if you leave a review, you have a chance to win.
[42:13] Andrew: And you're very likely to win, because there's barely any reviews.
[42:16] Jess: Just letting you know.
[42:18] Andrew: Exactly.
[42:20] Jess: So thank you for listening, and let's get you back to it.
[42:23] Andrew: I belong on Tavka.
[42:28] Jess: Tumble down work a day on the Andrew.
[42:39] Andrew: I've got a I got a question for you.
[42:41] Jess: Alright?
[42:42] Andrew: What do you got?
[42:43] Jess: Yeah.
[42:44] Andrew: Alright, so we got the three brides. We got uh Zidl, Hoddle, and Hava. Which bride would you ask Tavia permission to marry?
[42:52] Jess: Uh Zidal.
[42:54] Andrew: Really? Why Zidal?
[42:56] Jess: Yeah, she seems the most down-to-earth and reasonable.
[42:59] Andrew: Would you convert to Judaism for her?
[43:02] Jess: I would chop off the tip of my penis for her any day of the week.
[43:07] Andrew: I think I'm a Hodl fan. I like the fact that she's kinda into revolutionaries.
[43:12] Jess: Jess considers himself a resolute revolutionary.
[43:14] Andrew: I'm a resolution.
[43:17] Jess: Did you vote for Bernie Sanders, Jess?
[43:19] Andrew: Oh man. I'll pat you on the back.
[43:21] Jess: Hang on. I voted for Shea Guevara and both of the 2016 elections.
[43:29] Andrew: They're all just the revolutionary.
[43:32] Jess: Ah, vive Lafrance.
[43:39] Andrew: But no, I I just kind of liked Hodl. She felt like one of the more um willing to stray away from the belief.
[43:47] Jess: Like, not so far as Hava.
[43:51] Andrew: Not as far as Hava, but willing to like.
[43:53] Jess: Okay, okay. Was Pershik was he a Jew?
[43:57] Andrew: Yeah, he was.
[43:59] Jess: Really?
[44:00] Andrew: Yeah, he was.
[44:02] Jess: He didn't wear the little uh the little thing, so I I didn't know if he was or not.
[44:06] Andrew: He had the hat on and a beard.
[44:08] Jess: Did he have the hat?
[44:09] Andrew: Yeah, he had the hat.
[44:10] Jess: I don't remember that.
[44:11] Andrew: No, he did. Like he thought he he was very much.
[44:14] Jess: I thought he wore more of the I thought he wore more than the normal hat, like that the uh Christians were wearing.
[44:21] Andrew: No, he wore the Tevya like kind of like newsboy hat.
[44:25] Jess: Yeah, that's what I thought he wore.
[44:28] Andrew: Yeah, and that was the same hat Tevya wore.
[44:31] Jess: That's the same hat some of the uh Christians were wearing, though.
[44:34] Andrew: Yeah, he was 100% Jewish. He was just revolutionary Jewish.
[44:41] Jess: He didn't wear the little uh the little uh undergarments.
[44:46] Andrew: The the prayer shawl?
[44:48] Jess: Yeah. One of the characters I think is really nuanced that doesn't get a much attention is his majesty, as Tevi calls him.
[44:57] Andrew: I don't quite know his real name, but the one with the mustache in the movie.
[45:01] Jess: The one the Christian the one that looks like uh Stalin?
[45:04] Andrew: Yeah, basically Yosef Stalin and Tevy's buddy Yosef Stalin.
[45:08] Jess: He he's the closest we had to like an actual villain, I would say.
[45:12] Andrew: And he's still pretty nice.
[45:14] Jess: He's nice, but doesn't it get to a point where when you're following orders that force you to be so cruel that you would you know stop following those orders and quit your job, you know?
[45:26] Andrew: True.
[45:27] Jess: What'd you think uh what you think of the um the rabbi?
[45:30] Andrew: What did you think of him?
[45:31] Andrew: The rabbi has probably one of my more favorite scenes in the entire film version of it that's like not in the stage show.
[45:41] Jess: Is that him dancing or him?
[45:43] Andrew: Him and his temple, um gathering his Torah together and leaving sobbing, like leaving the play his place of worship. Like that is so depressing and quiet.
[45:52] Jess: Yeah.
[45:59] Andrew: Feel bad for him.
[46:00] Jess: Mm-hmm. And he just looks huggable. Like, you you could hug that rabbi.
[46:04] Andrew: He wouldn't want you to touch him, though. You're a dirty Christian.
[46:12] Jess: So let's talk about the film to wrap things up. Traditions, traditions.
[46:19] Andrew: Without a tradition.
[46:22] Jess: Our lives would be as shaky as.
[46:27] Andrew: As a fiddler on the roof.
[46:32] Jess: The stage show was adapted into a film in 1972, and it was directed by Norman Jewison and starred Haim Topel as Tevya, which was a controversial decision since Zero Mostel, who is a very big name, was in the original Broadway cast as Tevya.
[46:49] Jess: And he feels like he was kind of snubbed in bringing it from stage to screen.
[46:54] Andrew: If I were a rich man, okay long time.
[47:04] Jess: If I were a wealthy man, I wouldn't have to work.
[47:13] Andrew: If I were a rich He's just too big and bombastic, whereas Topol is very real and grounded.
[47:22] Jess: I feel like he would have been like way too out there with it, flamboyant and fabulous.
[47:28] Andrew: Yeah, and I I don't know, I can't see anyone other than uh the person playing him as the that character.
[47:35] Jess: And I agree with you more or less because even when I saw it live on stage when it came touring, I saw Topol in it.
[47:43] Andrew: Who else could do it that well?
[47:45] Jess: I don't think anyone else could.
[47:48] Andrew: It's very few films like characters from stage that I just see as that character.
[47:55] Jess: Um, except for Toppel as um Tevya. That is that character in my mind.
[48:02] Jess: And I've seen a lot of great actors like Danny Bernstein and Alan uh Alfred and Melena play Tevia, and all of them d just don't feel as right for the role as Toppel does.
[48:15] Andrew: And while here I'm gonna go into some problematic territory trigger warning sexual assault, Toppel might even be a terrible person.
[48:25] Jess: So I've uh to the surprise of literally no one, I have read Patty Lapone's autobiography.
[48:34] Andrew: I don't know who that is, but okay.
[48:37] Jess: Um, you will. You will soon, Andrew. Uh just you wait.
[48:43] Andrew: I I sure.
[48:44] Jess: And she was in a production of The Baker's Wife with Toppel.
[48:49] Jess: And they were developing the show together. And apparently Topple would go up to women, grab their breasts to see how much meat was on their bones, um, had sex with m in its blurry whether or not it was consensual with a bunch of chorus girls just coming out of his room like half naked and flustered and all that.
[49:08] Jess: And as well, um, he had a vendetta almost against the creatives and would just go out on stage and sing gibberish because he didn't like the lyrics he was given.
[49:18] Andrew: To paying audiences.
[49:20] Jess: Oh man. Which is unprofessional.
[49:22] Andrew: Um salt and just kind of shitty.
[49:26] Jess: And while this is all Patty Lapone's account, I don't see many people tr jumping up to defend whether or not it was true.
[49:33] Jess: I think that, yeah, in in situations you gotta just separate the artist from the other.
[49:39] Andrew: That's hard.
[49:39] Jess: It really is. A lot of times.
[49:41] Andrew: It really is.
[49:42] Jess: And even if this is true, it wasn't true at the time of the film, and it shouldn't affect the creatives behind the film and the development of that.
[49:51] Jess: The directors, the caterers, and all that. It shouldn't their work shouldn't be unappreciated because someone happened to be an asshole after the film was done.
[50:20] Jess: So Andrew, Fiddler on the Roof. What are your overall thoughts and your cheese rating?
[50:26] Andrew: Okay, I'm gonna say that uh I really enjoyed it. Uh it was quite long, but I think that it's it was still a very enjoyable watch.
[50:36] Andrew: And uh if you haven't seen it, I do recommend it.
[50:39] Jess: Absolutely. Um for a cheese rating, uh, I'm gonna give it some uh kosher cheese. Uh I don't know what kinds of cheese are kosher, uh, but something uh something like that, you know?
[50:54] Jess: Alright, and I think s quite similar thoughts. I think Fiddler on the Roof is one of the very few perfect musicals that if they ever try to remake the film I might get a little more than violent.
[51:06] Jess: Um I think it is altogether amazing and hard to complain about.
[51:11] Andrew: So yeah. So thank you guys for listening to our show.
[51:17] Jess: We got some great stuff coming up. Thank you for sticking around.
[51:20] Jess: Um please, if you could subscribe to us on iTunes, we're also on Spotify, Stitcher, and all other podcast platforms.
[51:26] Jess: We're on Twitter at Cheesy Musicals, Instagram at Musical Theater Lives, our YouTube page is Musical Theater Lives.
[51:33] Jess: Shoot us an email at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com.
[51:36] Jess: Our title card is created by Jolene Casco. Please follow her on Instagram at Jolene Casco, she's amazing.
[51:43] Jess: Um also we're still running that the contest for reviews on iTunes, so if you can get your reviews in, we're gonna choose randomly by episode 15, and we're gonna pick one of you guys to win a twenty-five dollar Amazon gift card.
[51:57] Andrew: So that'll be fun.
[51:59] Jess: It's gonna be a blast, Jess.
[52:00] Andrew: It's really gonna be great.
[52:01] Jess: I can't wait to see what they spend uh twenty-five dollars.
[52:04] Andrew: You have to send it to us. Let us know.
[52:07] Jess: Alright, Andrew. Thank you guys for listening, and we'll see you next time.
[52:12] Jess: I'm Jess.
[52:13] Andrew: And I'm Andrew.
[52:14] Jess: And this was Musicals with Cheese.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
