"Gimme Gimme!" Cut your hair and prepare to cringe because this week we're joined by the amazing James from Schaffrillas to talk about Thoroughly Modern Millie. You're going to love this episode. Donate to Black Lives Matter here. Our WEBSITE... Read More
From the show: Musicals with Cheese
About
"Gimme Gimme!" Cut your hair and prepare to cringe because this week we're joined by the amazing James from Schaffrillas to talk about Thoroughly Modern Millie. You're going to love this episode.
Donate to Black Lives Matter here
Social Media:
Musicals with Cheese on Twitter
Musicals W/ Cheese on Instagram
Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com
Jess Socials
Andrew Socials
Brianna Socials
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:05] Jess McInalle: Hello, I'm Jess McInalle.
[0:07] Andrew DeWolf: And I am Andrew DeWolf.
[0:09] Brianna Jones: And I'm Brianna Jones.
[0:10] Jess McInalle: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, the podcast where I try to get Andrew and Bree to like musical theater.
[0:14] Jess McInalle: And today we have an extra special returning guest.
[0:18] Andrew DeWolf: Woo!
[0:19] Brianna Jones: Woo!
[0:20] Jess McInalle: You will know him as James from Schaffrillas.
[0:23] James: James!
[0:24] Brianna Jones: Yay!
[0:26] James: Hey everyone! How's it going? It's me. Back again, baby.
[0:31] Jess McInalle: Back again.
[0:33] Andrew DeWolf: Again, and about time too.
[0:36] Brianna Jones: Agreed.
[0:37] Jess McInalle: Exactly. And we're bringing out the DK crew.
[0:39] James: My God.
[0:41] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. The best thing is if you tell like Alexa or Siri to like play that, they will play Brent's version of that song.
[0:48] James: And that is the best thing ever.
[0:50] Jess McInalle: Um my God, that's amazing. But James, you suggested this show.
[0:54] Jess McInalle: Um, and I assume it's because you have survived being in white slavery before.
[1:00] Andrew DeWolf: You are, is there something you have to talk about?
[1:04] James: Be like, no.
[1:05] Andrew DeWolf: Oh no.
[1:06] James: Did you sell yourself to Disney?
[1:08] James: Oh, yes, they are white slavers at Disney.
[1:11] Jess McInalle: Yes. You can immediately see him like, oh, we shouldn't have said that as soon as those words came out of his lips.
[1:17] Brianna Jones: Oh God.
[1:18] Jess McInalle: Um, but James, what are we talking about this week?
[1:21] James: Uh, we're talking about Thoroughly Modern Millie, a show that has not aged well at all.
[1:26] Jess McInalle: Cue the music, Bree!
[1:28] Brianna Jones: Oh boy.
[1:30] James: The fact is everything today is thoroughly modern. Check your personality. Everything today makes yesterday slow. Bandit face reality. It's not insanity, it's vanity fair. In fact, its style is to raise your skirts and buy yours and Thoroughly Modern Millie is a musical with music by Janine Tesori and lyrics by Dick Scanlon. The book was by Richard Morris and Dick Scanlon as well, based on the 1967 film of the same name. It premiered on Broadway on April 18th, 2002.
[2:08] Jess McInalle: Wow, it's coming up on like an anniversary right now. Um, it closed September 4th of 2006 after a bunch of performances. Um, the production subsequently won six 2002 Tony Awards, including Best Musical. Due to the success of the original Broadway production, there was both a United States tour and a West End production in 2003, followed by a United Kingdom tour in 2005. The show has garnered controversy over its perceived racial stereotyping of its Asian characters.
[2:37] James: Perceived quotation. And has been described as a piece that walks the line of being entertaining and highly offensive.
[2:47] Jess McInalle: I'm gonna say it tripped over the line, like right into a highly offensive.
[2:52] James: But the plot of the show is it tells the story of a small town girl, Millie Dilmont, who comes to New York City to marry for money instead of love. A thoroughly modern aim for 1922 when women were just entering the workforce.
[3:07] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, that sounds normal, but here's the twist. Millie soon begins to take delight in the flapper lifestyle, but problems arrive when she checks into a hotel owned by the leader of a white slavery ring in China.
[3:20] Jess McInalle: Barry the lead though!
[3:21] James: Oh no!
[3:24] Jess McInalle: So, James, I'm assuming you had a big reason for wanting this musical. So I'm very curious what's your history with it.
[3:31] James: Yeah, so um Thoroughly Modern Millie is um, unfortunately, it is the first musical I was ever in back in uh middle school. Um, it was like coming up on 10 years, actually. It was April 20, 2011, so like this month is the uh 10-year anniversary of that. So back then I didn't realize how just bad it was in terms of like how offensive it was, and now it's like looking back on it, I get more and more embarrassed that I was ever in it, and it's just like you're like, oh God. I have to tell people that was what I was. It's just rough.
[4:06] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Did you have any Asian actors playing the Asian characters? Is my next question?
[4:11] James: We did not, no, so yikes. Um, I don't know why my school picked it. Um, I mean, I get why it's so big in school productions. I would want to make it's a very rare musical where most of the characters are female, so in like most high schools and colleges mostly females auditioned, so it seems like it lines up one and one. It's not like the going Gary Glenn Ross, where you have all men and all that.
[4:38] Jess McInalle: Um, so that part I understand. The white slavery side, less so.
[4:42] Andrew DeWolf: Who'd you play by the way?
[4:44] James: Uh, I played uh George Gershwin. I had like one line during the scene at uh Muzzy's party, so that was my introduction to theater, was just that one line. So it was like uh my line was it isn't I'm stuck, frozen, blocked. I still remember that because it was because it's one line, so it's easy to remember.
[5:04] Brianna Jones: I'm sure you know. I'm sure you know.
[5:05] Andrew DeWolf: Did you ever flub it? Like that one time it's like I'm stuck line.
[5:11] James: Yeah, fortunately, I got it right all three nights.
[5:14] Andrew DeWolf: So good, good, good. Consistency is really important, so.
[5:18] Jess McInalle: Yes. So, what made you want to revisit it? Like, yeah, it probably is a bit cringe looking back on it, but what there's something to this show, and I feel like you'll agree with me here.
[5:28] James: Yeah, because like I'm conflicted, because like there's stuff that's good. Like, I like a lot of the songs and stuff, and like a couple of the characters, but like there's just this huge problem with it, and like the fact that it keeps getting performed by high schools is just so questionable. So I just kind of wanted to like take a look at it for that reason and be like, why did it have to have a white slavery plotline in it? I just I don't understand. I just feel like there could be a junior version or something where you just cut that plotline entirely and it would still work fine. It's such a cute musical if you don't know the white slavery.
[6:07] Jess McInalle: The racist, racist Asian interpretation. And we do I do want to highlight since there has been a lot of hate crimes against Asian people. We're gonna be talking about a lot of really racist tropes against Asians in this, and if that's not something you're into right now, feel free to walk away and come back when you're ready.
[6:23] Andrew DeWolf: Alright. Tell us what happens in Thoroughly Modern Millie, as you just watched this a few hours ago.
[6:30] James: Yeah. Uh so um Millie moves to uh I believe it's New York City.
[6:35] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.
[6:36] James: Uh and she is looking for uh a marriage with her boss. Um she wants to get a job and then marry her boss, and she's pretty dead set on that. Um she moves into this hotel. Um I can't remember the name of the hotel, but it's not really that important. The hotel is run by um Miss Mears, I believe is the uh name given.
[7:00] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.
[7:01] James: Uh who is um, I mean, I honestly I can't describe this character without just sounding like a racist. It's like a Chinese woman in like traditional face paint and like a gown, and she talks with like the you know the the accent, you know that one? You know the I'm not going to do it, but you know that one.
[7:23] Andrew DeWolf: Uh and I do want to point out, um, unless I'm corrected otherwise, I didn't see any. Um, the original woman who played her on Broadway was a white woman.
[7:32] James: Which makes it worse.
[7:33] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.
[7:34] James: Yeah. I think that's like her character is she's a white woman who pretends to be a Chinese woman in order to like catch people and put them in white slavery, which is just so bad. Like of course, it's made a little worse by the fact that she has two assistants who are also Chinese and help her with this. They're all dressed stereotypically. Uh but if you just ignore this aspect of it, she has like a couple of friends and they go to flapper parties, and she meets this guy named uh Jimmy, and she falls in love with him, but she's not really sure because she's like, Well, I know I was supposed to marry my boss, I don't want to marry for love, I want to marry for money, and eventually she overcomes that um with the help of her friends and this rich person she meets named Muzzy, I think. Um then she marries Jimmy, who turns out to be uh rich anyways, so cool.
[8:31] Andrew DeWolf: Uh also they take down the white slavery ring.
[8:34] James: Great.
[8:34] Andrew DeWolf: They stop white, they end white slavery. Goodbye, Disney Racism is over.
[8:40] Jess McInalle: We still have racism and one fell swoop, kind of.
[8:44] Andrew DeWolf: Um James. Have you seen the original film, the 1967 film?
[8:49] James: Uh no, I haven't.
[8:50] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, it's a it's a ride. Well, let's just say that.
[8:53] James: It's not good. It is like the musical is a better version of this story. The white slavery stuff is still ingrained in there. In fact, Pat Morita was one of the quote credited oriental men. Um, thus given a beefier roll in the musical later. Um it's interesting. It is like a lot of things that they bring over. Like it's still a musical, but none of the songs from that movie make it over to this new musical. Uh but they take elements like tap dancing on the elevator to make it move and stuff like that. Um and it's a bad movie. But Carol Channing's fun. That's it. That that's literally the only thing. The gifts of Carol Channing are great and everything else is garbage.
[9:36] Jess McInalle: Um I guess for context, like, what do we talk about here? Like, do we find it? It's very difficult to discuss this show without like I feel like we just have to get it out of the way, like, straight up, and then we could talk about the rest.
[9:50] James: Uh I think the rest of it's pretty good.
[9:53] Jess McInalle: That's the problem. Like, everything that isn't the Asian racism subplot, I have a lot of fun with.
[10:01] James: Um it's not great. I would say it's boring even at worst.
[10:05] Jess McInalle: Can I bring up the uh Wikipedia for this show really quickly?
[10:10] James: Go for it.
[10:11] Jess McInalle: I'm not gonna stop you.
[10:12] James: I mean, if you want false sources and fake news, my friend, you could go ahead and check Wikipedia.
[10:19] Jess McInalle: Um Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[10:20] James: Uh so I was reading through it because I ever since the uh the last five years I tried to get a uh slight basis for these episodes so I know what the heck is happening.
[10:29] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[10:29] James: Um there is a section called Racial Stereotyping Controversy. Uh, and they talk about, and I'm sure it's sourced somewhere else, but this is where I saw it. Um according to the musical playwright Dick Scanlon, the musical aims to shatter racist stereotypes and allows the audience to experience the chasm between the stereotype and the real thing.
[10:52] Andrew DeWolf: The original actor, uh for Bun Foo, uh Francis Ju, uh probably pronouncing that wrong, I'm sorry, also said, This show can be done racist, but it doesn't have to, and actually it can be anti-racist, and the Chinese guys are the heroes of the story.
[11:09] James: Ah no, they're not. No, no, no, no, they're not. I'm just I'm throwing it out there. That is kind of their response to it, and I don't buy it at all.
[11:21] Jess McInalle: I do want to put this small asterisk out there. I know the creators were in 2020, back before COVID hit, going to do an encore production where they revised the entire script to make it more PC.
[11:34] Andrew DeWolf: And it was supposed to star Ashley Park from Mean Girls, who is an Asian woman, as the lead of Millie.
[11:40] Jess McInalle: So they were gonna revise the score, cast an Asian lead, and really try to fix that up, and then that got cancelled for COVID, and it looks like it's gonna stay that not not gonna ever get performed. And I would have been very curious to see how that would have changed the viewpoint of this, how it would have framed those characters. Would they even keep those characters, or would we just focus on the flapper lifestyle?
[12:00] James: Because there is a full musical there without talking about kidnapping orphans.
[12:04] Jess McInalle: Yeah, I think that would be like the best course of action going forward with this musical because like I it's like the whole white slavery plotline is just completely separate from everything else in the musical. So it's like it's horrible and it's pointless to the overall story. So just like revising the whole musical, just taking that out, like I feel like is the best way to do this going forward. Just like I'm surprised it hasn't happened already, honestly.
[12:33] James: You can just have a different source of drama as a secondary plot, or just not even do that. Just make it a bit shorter and focus on the, uh, the love story thing. Or you could just make it not race related, like lady kidnaps girl and like sells them. Like there is a real thing about trafficking women in the world. It does not have to be a race-based white slavery kind of thing.
[12:57] Jess McInalle: Yeah, it's not a good thing. We don't have to have one of the characters yell white slavery at the top of his lungs during the show. Like that could actually have an interesting commentary on like women, young women who go out into the world on their own, two bucks, three bags, one me, and all that, and the dangers that could be that. That could actually be something interesting where we don't have this buffoon comic evil villain that is in yellow face.
[13:25] James: Yeah. Alright. I think I think we've done enough about that. So why don't we talk about something else? Let's move on. So this is 2002. Sutton Foster, like brand new onto the scene. Um, back when Broadway was kind of a meritocracy, because she was in the chorus for this and then just slowly got bumped up until she was a star winning Tonys and fell into like her success through this.
[13:49] Jess McInalle: And she is very, very good. Um, she is amazing in this show, in fact.
[13:55] James: Yeah, I really like love her performance. I think she has, uh, great chemistry with, uh, Gavin Creel. I just like, every time she's on screen, it's just like especially like her number later on, but we can I guess we'll get to that when we get to the song.
[14:08] Jess McInalle: Yeah, I just like everything about her performance just really like sold me. And it's cool to see her like early in her career as well, like before she became like the Tony winning, like legend we all know her as. Like so yeah, it was neat in that respect, definitely.
[14:23] James: And it's just casting-wise, you would imagine her in like the Mary Tyler Moore role and not the Julie Andrews role, because when you think typecasting, you think of her more like that. And she revised the character to fit kind of her own, uh, personal strength to be a little bit more broad, be a little bit more goofy, and, uh, really make a presence of herself. But I think in doing that, she took all the power away from the friend character that was there with Mary Tyler Moore, where she was like this rich person pretending to be poor, and there's like breadcrumbs, whereas this one you don't get many breadcrumbs, it just feels like they lied to you for the entire musical.
[15:00] Jess McInalle: Yeah.
[15:01] James: Um, can I just say I really hated the friend characters so much? Like I don't remember them. I didn't remember them being this bad, but I just hated their whole like, oh, I can't wait to be poor and live with poor people. It's like poverty's not like a quirk. Like she really got on my nerves.
[15:18] Jess McInalle: Actually, I know we just talked about one really bad theme, but can we talk about the other theme that I don't like that much?
[15:26] James: Of course.
[15:26] Jess McInalle: It's there's so many like rich people disguising as poor people in this. Like, what is that about? Like, uh, Jimmy and Dorothy are both like rich heirs or heiresses and they're disguising as poor people. Muzzy's, uh, story about her, uh, husband, she thought he was poor. And it's just like these rich people are just disguising as poor people and marrying, uh, and they're like doing it for love, and it's like just kind of a weird theme when you think about it.
[16:00] James: Yeah.
[16:01] Jess McInalle: It's like they just Millie just has her cake and eats it too at the end because she like marries for love, but then it's like, oh, never mind. It turns out he was also, he was also really rich anyway.
[16:11] James: But if you marry for love, he'll be rich.
[16:13] Jess McInalle: Yeah. It's just I don't really like that aspect of it either. But imagine if like there's also the weird aspect that is added for the musical, um, where Dorothy does not end up with the rich guy that you think that she was in love with, she ends up with one of the henchmen, um, that she truly fell in love with.
[16:33] James: Where in the movie she just legitimately fell in love with the big chinned guy.
[16:37] Jess McInalle: Um, I think Grayson is the name.
[16:39] James: Yeah, it's like I had Batman.
[16:43] Jess McInalle: A little bit strange though, because it's like she gets kidnapped and then falls in love with one of her kidnappers, and then that's the end.
[16:50] James: Yeah, it's very weird.
[16:53] Jess McInalle: Um, another thing I really didn't like is that like Millie tells her friend like over and over, like, I'm gonna marry my boss, and then like her friend comes to work, she sees the boss, they're like instantly falling in love, and then she's just like, okay, I'm gonna go on a date with him now. Bye. It's like she just completely steals him from Millie, who's like her best friend.
[17:13] James: I will say that is the most accurate pro presentation of a rich person I've ever seen, where it's like, of course I can take it. Come on.
[17:21] Jess McInalle: Yeah. Isn't that also after she, uh, like Millie explains to her that she thinks that, uh, Jimmy is in love with her as well?
[17:30] James: Or something like that?
[17:31] Jess McInalle: Yeah. Like, yeah, like she thinks the two of them are in love, and then all of a sudden, no, she's like in love with, uh, Millie's boss. It's just like, and it's just like she's just stealing all the guys in her, in, uh, in her life.
[17:45] James: Yeah. But then again, we realize that's her brother later, even though there was no context clues to imply that earlier.
[17:51] Jess McInalle: Nothing at all, other than just that they know each other, I guess.
[17:56] James: Yeah.
[17:56] Jess McInalle: Oh god. This musical feels like it should have been made like 40 years before it came out. Like this was from 2002.
[18:07] James: Yes.
[18:08] Jess McInalle: Yeah.
[18:08] James: Like I was like, okay, this must have come out like at least around like Miss Saigon and that kind of stuff.
[18:14] Jess McInalle: Nope.
[18:18] James: Did you learn nothing from Jonathan Price Broadway?
[18:23] Jess McInalle: Like, yeah, didn't Miss Saigon get in a lot of trouble for the whole like yellow face thing?
[18:28] James: Yeah, they just comes out in 2002. It's like, like, what are you doing? And it's not like everyone involved just slowly put their heads into the ground hoping not to be seen. Like Janine Tesori would go on to like win a Tony a few years later and is still doing work. Like everyone involved in this is super big right now, and this is like, eh, maybe we don't look at that no more.
[18:51] Jess McInalle: Yeah.
[18:53] James: Oh good. And I don't mean to like pick on this show. Because it there is quality stuff in there. There's fun dance numbers and tap numbers and all that.
[19:01] Jess McInalle: So so what is good? Like, let's do it. What's good?
[19:04] James: Alright, let's go. James, you're up first. What's good?
[19:07] James: Okay. Um, I personally really liked the chemistry between like the Millie and Jimmy characters. Like I thought it was believable. I thought like Sutton Foster and Gavin Creel, especially, like, did a great job bringing them together.
[19:18] Jess McInalle: Yeah.
[19:19] James: Um, so they were good. I, uh, I liked Trevor Graden. He's just kind of the way he talks is just funny, the super fast. Like that whole like floor wax song. Like, I honestly found that delightful.
[19:31] Jess McInalle: Um, that's actually one of the songs not written for this move or for this musical. It was an old Gilbert and Sullivan song that they just changed lyrics to.
[19:40] James: Oh, okay, nice.
[19:41] Jess McInalle: Yeah, I didn't know that. So yeah, that was good. And I like the character Muzzy as well. Like I just thought like the performance is great, and just I liked her like story about her husband. Like, I thought that was like one of the few times I got like really emotionally invested in the story.
[19:54] James: It was kind of cute when it happened to her, but then when it also happens to Millie afterwards, you kind of feel like it's weird.
[20:01] Jess McInalle: But yeah, it's just that's bizarre.
[20:04] James: I don't know.
[20:05] Jess McInalle: Yeah, maybe just hearing her talk about the story was like nice, but then seeing it actually unfold, it's like actually this is weird when I'm like seeing it unfold.
[20:13] James: It's less that it's not like if it happened the one time, it'd be like, oh, okay. Well that's kind of funny. That's like a lesson, I guess. But then it's like, oh, it actually happens like three times in the same thing.
[20:24] Jess McInalle: It just happens all the time.
[20:26] James: Apparently.
[20:28] Jess McInalle: I do I do like Jimmy. Uh, I think he's pretty funny. I like, uh, how like eccentric he is.
[20:35] James: Um, like the, uh, him hanging out the window is like really weird, but kind of iconic, I guess.
[20:42] Jess McInalle: Yes.
[20:43] James: Uh, and Millie's fun. I, I don't know. I, the characters work is the thing. Like the characters really work. The story almost works, like if you ignore a certain piece. The choreography, like, is so much fun.
[20:57] Jess McInalle: It's like how to succeed in business.
[20:59] James: Like, and I'm not usually a big fan of like dance breaks, but these dance breaks were like a welcome addition to like, oh yeah, let's see Sutton Foster move like her legs, which are most of her body.
[21:10] Jess McInalle: Let's go.
[21:11] James: Yeah, I just love the tap dancing. Like, it's just it's so nice. What I love about tap dancing is that it's not only looks really cool, but it's like so like audibly like pleasing to just hear these like shoes like clack on the floor.
[21:25] Jess McInalle: It's just like so yeah, this is like one of those shows where I like look forward to the dance breaks because it's just the tap dancing is like really good, I think.
[21:32] James: I mean, there's a lot of good stuff in here, and I feel like they could make it work, but there's just you gotta get rid of, you gotta get rid of the garbage, you know?
[21:41] Jess McInalle: Yeah.
[21:42] James: A couple rewrites, you guys.
[21:44] Jess McInalle: Um, I think my thing that I'm difficult with most of all with this, as ridiculous as it says. This is a lopsided show. Like it cuts from one moment to the other, you cut from one subplot to another, and you just don't care about one, and you're fully enraptured into the other.
[22:02] James: So it's a frustrating watch despite the good, is the biggest problem.
[22:06] Jess McInalle: Yeah, like I think, especially in act two when she sings her like big, uh, number gimme gimme, like that's so, that's so good, and then we have to put that plot on hold to deal with the white slavery plot line.
[22:17] James: And it's just so annoying how that happens.
[22:20] Jess McInalle: Really? And then they resolve it, and then Jimmy's like, now where were we?
[22:24] James: Oh yeah, were you marry me?
[22:25] Jess McInalle: And it's like now we're suddenly supposed to be back to that plot line.
[22:28] James: It's just my godly handled.
[22:31] Jess McInalle: It's made even worse by the fact that every time they do the white slavery plot line, you're like, oh, get me out of here.
[22:36] James: Oh my god, get me out of here.
[22:38] Jess McInalle: Yeah. But the funniest scene is when she's like trying to seduce Mr. Graydon, like, and just like he's not into it. That is such great situational comedy work.
[22:49] James: Um, and I wanted more of that. Like, imagine if this was just a musical about Millie trying to seduce men into marrying her and then just failing in different ways, and like or we just go full dark where she gets married and then the rest of the show is about trying to kill them for the inheritance.
[23:05] Jess McInalle: That's my kind of musical. Let's do that.
[23:07] James: Come on.
[23:09] Jess McInalle: That would be really fun.
[23:10] James: Yeah. It's like, yeah, there's pieces of like a really fun story and like the main plot line here. But then, uh, not only do you have the awful plot line, but it's just like they never put the pieces into anything like super fun or engaging.
[23:24] Jess McInalle: It just kind of feels like every like rom com ever, where it's like, oh, she wants to marry this one guy, but then there's this other guy, and I don't know, who's she choose?
[23:32] James: It's a classic, uh, musical where they're just rom coms with songs.
[23:37] Jess McInalle: Yeah, basically, it really feels like it was written in the 60s, like down to terrible stereotypes and all that stuff.
[23:45] James: It's just it's like, man, why why is this being played now?
[23:50] Jess McInalle: Yeah, honestly. I think I'm just very baffled, only because I had heard I, I have not watched this. This is like a big blind spot in my musical theater world. So when James suggested it, I'm like, alright, I'm gonna go in blind with the best intentions here.
[24:06] James: Um then I as soon as like I see that character walk on stage, I'm like, okay.
[24:14] Jess McInalle: Uh, I was I'm gonna try. But let's talk about that Tony year for a second.
[24:19] James: Um, James, do you know anything about the Tonys that year?
[24:22] James: Um, I know, uh, You're in Town was also up for a lot of Tonys, and I know people really love that show. I haven't seen it personally, but I know that Millie, uh, beat it, uh, for the Tony and a lot of people were upset about it.
[24:35] Jess McInalle: Uh, that's all I really know about that year.
[24:36] James: Let's let's just look at that for a second.
[24:39] Jess McInalle: Um, so yes, it was up against, um, You're in Town, which is kind of like the off choice. Like there were two other choices that seem like, uh, the populous choice, I think is the one, the ones you would expect.
[24:51] James: Um, you got Thoroughly Modern Millie, which was relatively successful and also well liked by critics, strangely enough.
[24:57] Jess McInalle: And then you've got Mamma Mia.
[24:59] James: This was the year of Mamma Mia.
[25:05] Andrew DeWolf: And I still think Urin Town beats out the other two.
[25:08] James: Um, and I don't even like Urin Town that much. You're in town is like this town weird. It's not a normal like Broadway show. It's like this weird black box theater kind of feeling where they're just gonna throw random shit at the walls, kind of show.
[25:23] Andrew DeWolf: I wish it was funnier with You're in Town. That's all I know.
[25:25] James: Yes, I think this is actually a funnier, more successfully funny show than You're in Town.
[25:30] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Or Your In Town is just the uh unhumor in it, but Yeah.
[25:34] James: Well, U in Town is more of a satire than it is like a comedy. And I know people are like, oh, it's hilarious, but I'm like, mm-hmm.
[25:41] Andrew DeWolf: It's I guess in the way that like what is that? Like a David O. Russell film is hilarious, I guess.
[25:49] James: Yeah.
[25:49] Andrew DeWolf: So you're saying you're in town was robbed.
[25:51] James: Uh I'm not saying you're in town is robbed or anything like that. I'm just saying maybe just give it to Mamma Mia. You know what? Whatever. Give it to Mamma Mia.
[25:59] Andrew DeWolf: You know what? Here we go again.
[26:01] James: Here we go again.
[26:04] Andrew DeWolf: There you go. Mamma Mia is not as bad as everyone likes to try to claim it is.
[26:09] James: It's not good.
[26:10] Andrew DeWolf: My mom loves it.
[26:12] James: Oh, my mom does too.
[26:13] Andrew DeWolf: Everyone's mom loves it. What's wrong with mom's enjoying things? Come on. Just let the moms have it. They can win this one.
[26:20] James: Yes.
[26:21] Andrew DeWolf: Have you seen the Mamma Mia sequel, James?
[26:24] James: Uh no, I haven't. Um, I was not a big fan of the original, which is something that a statement that'll get me like crucified online because I know it has a huge fan base, but um yeah, and this is just the movie. I haven't seen the Mamma Mia musical. Let me just say this. Yeah, not a huge fan.
[26:39] Andrew DeWolf: I used to be like you, a big hater of Mama Mia. Then the sequel came out, and I'm like, there's something here. Then I rewatched the original. I'm like, you know what? Fuck it. It's fun. God damn it.
[26:50] James: The sequel is actually a legitimately well-made film, is the thing. And if that like it is a lot of work and effort to make that a really effective movie. Whereas the first one is just everyone's got drunk on an island and started singing songs.
[27:05] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like we get to Mamma Mia all the time, and we just need to do Mamma Mia episodes.
[27:10] James: We will, but that is like a thing to dedicate to, you know. I feel like that's a July thing. Like episode one. We have to do, we have to do like with what we did with uh Mary Poppins and do them both in a row.
[27:21] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, yeah. I think we should do it as one episode, like one really long episode. Sorry, James. We're like planning for the future now.
[27:27] James: So good.
[27:28] Andrew DeWolf: I would like to add into this planning. Okay, if we're doing Mamma Mia, can we please all get drunk and talk about Mamma?
[27:34] James: Oh, fuck yes. I am, I guess a mother at heart because I love Mamma Mia. I don't know, maybe it's because I love ABBA.
[27:42] Andrew DeWolf: Abba's great.
[27:44] James: Yeah. I love Abba.
[27:45] Andrew DeWolf: Everyone loves Abba. I mean, let's just have an Abba.
[27:50] James: Especially moms.
[27:51] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. That's all my mom listened to when I was growing up. But yeah, we'll plan for it. I'll make it happen.
[27:56] James: No, what we should do. Sorry, James. Bree, feel free to cut this. This is so good. No spoilers for future episodes.
[28:03] Andrew DeWolf: This isn't even it. Alright, Brie, you, me, and Andrew, we have a live stream where we force people to watch along with us and we play a drinking game, and we just slowly get drunk as we progressively wash through all the two Mamma Mia movies.
[28:16] James: All the two on them.
[28:18] Andrew DeWolf: They're making a third one now. They've announced it. The trilogy will finally be complete.
[28:24] James: Yes, the mom. The first musical theater trilogy.
[28:26] Andrew DeWolf: My god.
[28:28] James: Oh wow, yeah. I can't think of another. Maybe I'm wrong.
[28:32] Andrew DeWolf: I guess we'll have to see where Schaeferless is gonna make the You know, Mom Mia wasn't that bad.
[28:38] James: Yeah, maybe. I feel like I need to have my like character development when it comes to Mamma Mia, where I come around to it and realize it was actually good the whole time.
[28:47] Andrew DeWolf: No, it's not. It'll never be actually good.
[28:49] James: It'll just be fun.
[28:50] Andrew DeWolf: Damn.
[28:52] James: Fun. Eventually I'll have fun with the difference.
[28:55] Andrew DeWolf: The first one is fun. The second one is good. The third one will be Return of the Jedi or Rise of Skywalker, probably.
[29:01] James: Oh no.
[29:03] Andrew DeWolf: Oh man. Alright. You know what? It's time for everyone's favorite segment of our show. It is time where we compare our opinions to those of the New York theater critics when this show came out. It's time for breviews.
[29:13] James: It's Tom Full Preview.
[29:20] Andrew DeWolf: It's Tomful Previews. Barbara and Scott Siegel of Theatre Mania said, if the show's book and the score are less than stellar, Rob Ashford's choreography is exuberant and playful. A typing and tapping number is a standout, as is a speakeasy routine. David Gallo's elaborate sets and Martin Pakledina's excessively colorful costumes are eye candy. The production's ringmaster, director Michael Mayer, does an exceptional job of keeping the audience's mind off the show's limitation and stressing its strengths.
[29:57] James: Color, pacing, laughs. Thoroughly modern Millie. Thoroughly modern Millie doesn't have Urin Town's originality or wit, nor does it have the ambition of sweet smell of success. To say that is it's better than Mamma Mia. Only points points up what a pitiful season this has been for Broadway musicals.
[30:19] Andrew DeWolf: That was like the most backhanded review ever. Like, yeah, it sounds good. Smell of success. I guess it's better than Mamma Mia, but I guess that's where we are in Broadway right now. Shit.
[30:33] James: Do we agree with that, guys?
[30:35] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know.
[30:36] James: I don't know.
[30:37] Andrew DeWolf: I'm I mean, I guess they are praising a lot of the technical stuff and like the dancing, which yeah, I agree. It's probably like some of the best parts of the show.
[30:45] James: Maybe I'm crazy, but this didn't feel like a cheap show to me. Like it uh like it doesn't look cheap to me. Uh it doesn't feel limited when I watch clips and all that.
[30:56] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know.
[30:57] James: Yeah. It feels like the way it was meant to be. And I feel like judging limitations like that is not cool for a show like that's mostly based on character work and dancing. And you know what they didn't mention? I feel like we all know what they didn't mention.
[31:08] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[31:13] James: They said it's it stresses its strengths and color, right?
[31:19] Andrew DeWolf: Oh god.
[31:20] James: What the fuck? Bree, go on to the next review.
[31:23] Andrew DeWolf: We got one more. I was gonna ask if the um costumes were anything special.
[31:29] James: They're pretty. I mean, like they're cute.
[31:31] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, they're nice.
[31:32] James: Depends on the costume.
[31:36] Andrew DeWolf: Now we're really gonna get kicked off the Broadway podcast network, danger.
[31:39] James: Jesus. Well, I was well, I was just looking at looking at them on Google, and I was like, this isn't I don't know. They're cute.
[31:46] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[31:50] James: Okay. It's not even like accurate 1920s representation. It's 1920s through the viewpoint of 2002, viewing it through 1960s. So there's like four areas of removal where it's the sixties trying to be the twenties, and it's two thousand two trying to be the sixties trying to be in the twenties. It's also the twenties how they wanted to be seen as well, being seen by the sixties. Gilded age. And this is right before the depression. So like despite the fact that she gets her rich husband, I just know that they're gonna lose it all. So it makes me feel happy in the end.
[32:22] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know if that's true. I feel like the rich did fine during the Great Depression. It was just the poor got really poor.
[32:28] James: Isn't that how it always goes?
[32:29] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it's America. If anything, the Rich probably made money during the depression. Just like the rich made money during COVID.
[32:36] James: Yep. Yep. This is a political episode, guys. We're bringing bringing money during 2008 as well.
[32:44] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, okay, so we'll move on to our next one, which is from our favorite Ben Brandt. Um so New York Times theater critic Ben Brantley said Hard Sal doesn't begin to describe thoroughly modern Millie, adapted from the 1967 movie musical of the same title. Watching this aggressively eager show is like being stampeded by circus ponies. It is all whining and clomping and brightly decorated bouncing heads, and it is never letting up for a second. You'll leave either grinning like an idiot or with a migraine the size of Alaska.
[33:22] James: Uh it is possible that some theatergoers may object to perceived racism and the portrayal of Miss Mir's Chinese assistants, Ching Ho, Ken Liung, and Bon Fu, Francis Ju, uh, who's assist her in selling orphans from her boarding house into bondage as prostitutes. But Mr. Morris and Mr. Scanlon have made them virtuous, after all, who have a worthy place in the New York melting pot, and the evening's biggest laughs are garnered by the use of supertitles.
[33:57] Andrew DeWolf: Ostensibly. Ostensibly to tr I had to make it bigger. To translate Chinese into English English and vice versa. So I I the framing of actual racist depictions as like, you know, it's just great that we have representations. It's a pretty presentation. Like that's what he decided to do right there, right? I didn't misinterpret that they're literally selling people into slavery, and so what that the leader is like an actual like racist stereotype. You know, it's representation.
[34:30] James: Yeah. At least the subtitles were funny.
[34:34] Andrew DeWolf: The subtitles were funny.
[34:36] James: It's funny because uh Chinese, I guess.
[34:40] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[34:40] James: Oh god. Uh remember when she cleans the rug and says that she's using soy sauce, and that's like an actual plot point.
[34:47] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, and then no show. Why? Oh. Cringe! So much cringe.
[34:54] James: Oh no.
[34:56] Andrew DeWolf: Perceived racism.
[34:58] James: Perceived, of course.
[35:00] Andrew DeWolf: Oh yeah. Some of us have blinders on, and I wasn't perceiving it, so it was written in 2002 was when it was released on Broadway. Uh we should have known better at this point.
[35:12] James: I mean. Yeah.
[35:13] Andrew DeWolf: But then again, it's not the next year we have the racist stereotype in Avenue Q. It's not like it's stopped here.
[35:20] James: Yeah, everybody's a little bit racist.
[35:22] Andrew DeWolf: And it's the same racist stereotype.
[35:24] James: It is. They couldn't even change it.
[35:26] Andrew DeWolf: Oh my goodness. What was up with us in the early odds that we thought that Asians were fair game to just make fun of at free will. Especially with like it would get worse in like things like the hangover, which are just like horrible, horrible depictions.
[35:40] James: Remember uh South Park did theirs as well? Uh I forget what his name was, but the City Walk guy.
[35:46] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[35:47] James: Oh my god. Yeah. It's just also awful.
[35:50] Andrew DeWolf: Oh my god. And I and maybe it's just us being like Uber woke, hashtag liberal cucks or whatever the fuck, but I don't know. I don't think it's that woke to think that this is a racist stereotype. It just kind of is.
[36:06] James: I'd be very interested to see how they were going to do it for the Encourse production with Ashley Park as the lead. I would have been very curious to see how they would have fixed this. But it bothers me the fact that they were so quick to defend it and literally no one was pointing it out at the time, aside from Asian people that felt offended by it.
[36:22] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Perceived racism.
[36:26] James: Oh yeah, just how about we go into a mid show and talk about these these these rockin' tunes?
[36:32] Andrew DeWolf: Sure.
[36:38] James: Hey guys, sorry to interrupt you in the show, but we've got a shill at you. Today's show is brought to you by the extremely kind donations by our donors over at Patreon. Andrew, tell us about Patreon so I can read these names.
[36:50] Andrew DeWolf: You want to talk about a hard sell. Uh shale, shall we? Shake is the key word. Shill, shill, shill. Uh, Patreon is where you can go if you want to give us money and we give you extra content. Like uh, we have the Patreon podcast where we cover things like Gallivant and Glee and we talk and Jerry, Fossi Verden. We we talk about Tom and Jerry going to the Wizard of Oz or whatever. I I I don't know. We got a lot of stuff. Also, you can see James's beautiful face right now on Patreon. You wouldn't be able to do that right now.
[37:17] James: Yeah, he's telling you right now that you should join our Patreon. He's doing it. He's holding a sign.
[37:22] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. And you won't be definitely you won't be able to know this unless you join the Patreon and see for yourself.
[37:27] James: You can't you can't put words at our guests.
[37:28] Andrew DeWolf: No, James, put your shirt back on.
[37:32] James: I will never put it back on.
[37:34] Andrew DeWolf: And live on the edge.
[37:37] Jess McInalle: Andrew, who's reading the list?
[37:39] Andrew DeWolf: Is it me?
[37:41] Jess McInalle: You're reading the list.
[37:42] Andrew DeWolf: I'll read the list.
[37:43] Andrew DeWolf: Our current patrons are Melissa Goldman, Terry Needleman, John Donna, Layton Accles, Danielle Rennex, Terren the Duck, Justin Stampede, Ellen Cassidy, Taskeer, Fire September, Monica Thoreau, Mina Meneer, Brent Black, Haley Murray, B Way Flix, Nathaniel Stacy Coomb, Joseph Evans Green, Carrie Ahern, Christine Malmadell, Mary Lou Choquette, John Vanalith, Heck you, I go by Elijah now, Russ Walker, Miesko Hell, Emily, Gracie, Andrew and Barr, Sinka Tablam, Kyle Summers, Jen A C, Christina Francis, Scoot, and the Technicolor Dreamcoat.
[38:08] Andrew DeWolf: Liz Lyn, Cory Wilmarth, Ellison Stellar, nothing is certain except Beth and Taxes, John Finales again, Thesbian, Ren Cullen, Wait in the Wings, Lady Malvolia, Spectacle Machine, Jacob Stroop, Rafael Martinez Salaz, Robert Benjamin, Rachel T, Jessica T, Genevieve Hartnett, Cass, Mitchell Young, Chai Tea Cup, Hayden Wilder, Katie McDonough, Gunky Geist, Stachis, Timothy Keyes, Jeffrey Machado, Jacqueline Spring, Toon Van Essen, and Jesse Taylor.
[38:34] Andrew DeWolf: They all give us a little extra financial support that helps us keep the lights on here at Musicals with Cheese.
[38:38] Jess McInalle: If you would like to join them in supporting us and get tons of fun perks, come join them over on the Patreon.
[38:43] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, you guys. You got anything else we want to say before we go into the show?
[38:46] Jess McInalle: We have merch.
[38:47] Andrew DeWolf: Oh yeah, buy our merch.
[38:49] Jess McInalle: Um, we have a two.
[38:50] Andrew DeWolf: We have cool merch.
[38:51] Jess McInalle: We do. You want a shirt that says the stinkeroo of Oz?
[38:54] Andrew DeWolf: Come join us there.
[39:06] ♪ Musical number: "Not for the Life of Me" — performed by Jess McInalle ♪
[40:01] Jess McInalle: And it kind of just sets up both the world we live in and Millie as a human being. But the problem is, it's just not as charming as the follow-up number. Like, you tend to forget it exists, but this is the I Want song.
[40:15] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, the whole time I was just waiting for the big number with like the whole ensemble to start. Like, I just, yeah.
[40:21] Jess McInalle: And it's kind of weird head hours. And as far as I know, this is like the only ballad-ish thing. They like cock tease you with ballads throughout all of Act One, but they don't give you one except for here where they're like, here is her sitting on the bench telling what you want.
[40:34] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, we're done with that. We're a dance show. We're done with that. No more emotion. I want the dancing.
[40:40] Jess McInalle: Look, they should have just started it with the dancing. Like that's what I wanted. That's what everybody wanted.
[40:45] Andrew DeWolf: But we need this structurally. Andrew, we've gone over this. If we don't have one, we don't really understand what she's after.
[40:50] Jess McInalle: And it's such a weirdly specific thing that she's after, which is to bag herself a rich man and marry him into submission.
[40:59] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Definitely. Is that I don't think that's what she actually expressed in the song though, so it's not really connected to her actual motivation in the story, so it's like I don't know.
[41:11] Jess McInalle: It is kind of a weird I Want song. It is kind of like she does not want to be back where she was. It doesn't say like the know-how, but we know that she does not want to be poor.
[41:23] Andrew DeWolf: Um, idolizes want to be poor. I mean, some people do. Look at the people in Rent, Jimmy. They have a statement for that as that.
[41:31] Jess McInalle: Um, but it's interesting just because like it's someone that's like, I wanna be more, and then we don't quite understand what that means for them or the means of going about it. It's like if Ariel's like, I want legs, and then she goes up on the human world and chops off a human's legs to put 'em on her. Like that's like the kind of thing. Like we have part of their world, and that is her solution to the problem, is kind of where I'm why I find it so fascinating.
[41:55] Andrew DeWolf: I think it's funny. Uh, the marrying the boss thing is played off as like a joke, so I think it's funny.
[42:01] Jess McInalle: Yeah. Um, I'm glad that that's not what actually happens. If that was what actually happened, it would be a different show.
[42:06] Andrew DeWolf: It should have been what actually happened. It should have been that different. I want that different show. Let's just say that.
[42:11] Jess McInalle: I want to be fun, yeah. It's a dedicate to her just being a gold digger, like being kind of like this anti-hero.
[42:18] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[42:18] Jess McInalle: Um, the other thing with "Not for the Life of Me" is that they like do it like three different times.
[42:23] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, and it's like the first three numbers, like it's so weird. Like it's her singing it, and then it's just these random girls at the hotel that we don't know, and then it's the Chinese henchmen, which is like, why are they singing it?
[42:36] Jess McInalle: Because they don't want to be poor either.
[42:38] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Perceived racism.
[42:41] Jess McInalle: Of course.
[42:42] Andrew DeWolf: Of course, perceived. Yeah, it's just like at that point, I was like, if I was an audience member seeing it for the first time, I would be like, do they have any other songs, or are they just gonna sing this for the entire show?
[42:54] Jess McInalle: It's like it's so weird how we just get it like three times in a row at the very beginning.
[42:58] Andrew DeWolf: It's to tie everybody together into the same, like they all want the same thing.
[43:03] Jess McInalle: Yeah.
[43:04] Andrew DeWolf: To marry their boss.
[43:06] Jess McInalle: Yes. Everyone strives for that, indeed.
[43:09] Andrew DeWolf: And then it just so clearly fades into like the actual like big number, which is "Thoroughly Modern Millie."
[43:15] ♪ Musical number: "Thoroughly Modern Millie" — performed by Jess McInalle ♪
[44:01] Jess McInalle: Like, I think the rhyme adorable with Sodom and Gamorable.
[44:05] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[44:06] Jess McInalle: What?
[44:07] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[44:07] Jess McInalle: Even back in like seventh grade when I was in the show, I just knew that was a terrible rhyme. Like, oh god.
[44:13] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, it technically rhymes. You can't say it doesn't.
[44:16] Jess McInalle: Yeah, you could just add anything to the end of a real word and make it rhyme.
[44:20] Andrew DeWolf: There you go. Baboom.
[44:24] Jess McInalle: But this is like the first song, I think, is to set up Millie and her goals and her ideals, or so to say, her what she wants to do. Whereas this song sets up location and time period, where this is like 1922, like the movies, I'm gonna bob my hair and wear a skirt, like aesthetic choices that set up the 1922 world.
[44:45] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[44:46] Jess McInalle: Also fun stances. And the best opening numbers can do both, but it's like we reversed it.
[44:53] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, alright. Here's my pitch of why I think this kind of reads to me weird. In traditional musical theater structure, we have our big opening number where we like the tradition. And like all that. And then we follow that up with either "Matchmaker" if you're if I were a rich man, whichever one you want to claim is your I Want song for that one. Whereas this one, we start with the I Want song and then we follow it up with the big opening number setting up the world. And I don't know why that just rings wrong to me.
[45:20] Jess McInalle: Yeah, no, I know what you mean. It is kind of weird the way they do it. And it's like she has a moment like after she gets like mugged where she just starts to do a little reprise of like "Not for the Life of Me." And it's like that's where the actual song could be.
[45:33] Andrew DeWolf: Yes. They could have just opened with the "Thoroughly Modern Millie."
[45:36] Jess McInalle: Yes! You've solved the problem with the opening of this musical. You've done it, my man!
[45:40] Andrew DeWolf: I did it. They had to fill time.
[45:42] Jess McInalle: They had to fill time, okay?
[45:44] Andrew DeWolf: It's barely two hours.
[45:46] Jess McInalle: No, that's fine! We don't need every vehicle to be nearly three hours.
[45:51] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, honestly.
[45:54] Jess McInalle: But yeah, it would have made for a more exciting opening just right from the start, just "Thoroughly Modern Millie." Just introduce the setting and everything, and then we get to know this character. Like, yeah, I don't know why it is the way it is. Outside of stalling for time.
[46:07] Andrew DeWolf: I don't want to be that kind of guy, because I know Janine Tesori is smarter than that. She's a very smart lady that makes really good musicals. I don't want to be like stalling for time is the only reason why it's like that. But maybe the reason is like we wanna set up our character before we have an entire song about her name.
[46:25] Jess McInalle: Maybe that's it. It might be that it could also be like the build-up aspect where you do the soft song and then you build into the big dance number. I don't know. It could just be like a music thing, and not less of a lyric thing.
[46:41] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it could just be like you want to kind of get them ready for the big drop of the musical number as opposed to like just dropping them into the—
[46:41] Jess McInalle: There is a defense for all that, and I'm sure they went through previews and it was probably switched all around, and they're like, "Oh, I guess this is the best way." But hey, David Scanlon, write us an email. Tell us the reason why you did that that way, because it feels weird to me.
[47:02] Andrew DeWolf: Um, let's talk next about the speed test.
[47:06] Jess McInalle: Dear Mr. Hudson! My eyes are fully open to my awful situation, so I'm writing you a letter to demand an explanation when the floor box that we bought from you arrived here Monday morning. We discovered upon your side that I should have a warning. The only possibility is that your wax is brand so I request a full refund of all the bottom. Like, sweet ransom. That shouldn't convince me. You can prove the low box matter. We will take our business elsewhere. Oh, I hope you solve this matter. So I hope he's on the status. So I hope he's on the Saturday. Going on!
[47:35] Andrew DeWolf: Enclosure for small container rubber stuff to talk about Sherry Moon. Sure, you wouldn't want me to load the papers with the news where all this was affected by your papers, which might choose to wreck you.
[47:47] Jess McInalle: Which is um a Gilbert and Sullivan tune. Um, spit from like that was originally called "My Eyes Are Fully Open," but I recognized it as the little piece that played after Paradox in the film adaptation of Pirates of Penzance. Or it just kind of sounds like modern Major General, but kind of faster and a little bit off key.
[48:06] Andrew DeWolf: Um, this song is very funny.
[48:08] Jess McInalle: This song is actually brilliant. This is maybe the best one in the show.
[48:12] Andrew DeWolf: Like, which is weird.
[48:14] Jess McInalle: Yeah, it's up there for me. Like, I've always loved this one. Like, I don't know. Just Trevor Green is just a fun character, and I just love just hearing him go as fast as he can. And this and it's just like by the end, it's like it's kind of unintelligible, but at the same time, it's like the fact that it's semi-understandable is just super impressive to me.
[48:33] Andrew DeWolf: Also, like the call and response aspect where he's having her like read it back to him, and I don't know.
[48:38] Jess McInalle: Yeah. And I think the lyrics stand out here very well too. Like, especially if we're gonna hear it over and over again. I think this is like the best lyrical work in the show.
[48:47] Andrew DeWolf: Um, yeah, it's just very like verbose, just like the words that he uses, and just like hearing Millie repeat all of that back. It just really sells that she's like really good at her job as a stenographer too.
[48:58] Jess McInalle: So it's like, yeah, I think it works in a lot of respects, like as a character thing and as just a good song. And the one laugh that I got, like really big, like hearty laugh, um, is the stenographer payoff when we are in the horrible white slaver plot line, and she wrote down every word that came out, and she just pops up and just sings the song. It's fucking great, and I laughed my ass off when that happened.
[49:23] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, that's like the only part of the white slaver plot line that I thought was like good. Like just that that payoff was.
[49:29] Jess McInalle: Which is it's just a callback to a good song, and like maybe that's it. I just like the song, and I was like, "Oh, it's there again."
[49:37] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, yeah, they did it again. Like, you don't even have to do the white slaver plot line to have that reincorporated in some way.
[49:44] Jess McInalle: Yeah, honestly. Just any other way of reincorporating it when you're not expecting it would have been good.
[49:51] Andrew DeWolf: But like, yeah.
[49:53] Jess McInalle: Yeah. But still, it's a nice callback.
[49:55] Andrew DeWolf: Mm-hmm. See, we can say nice things about this show, can't we? We're not all negative Nellies focusing on the perceived racism.
[50:00] Jess McInalle: Perceived racism.
[50:07] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[50:08] Jess McInalle: What do you think of "What Do I Need with Love?" Jimmy's big number, his prison number.
[50:13] James: Although I hardly know you.
[50:20] ♪ Musical number: "What Do I Need with Love?" — performed by Jimmy ♪
[50:50] Andrew DeWolf: I really like that one.
[50:52] Jess McInalle: Yeah, I think this was a good one too. When I think of songs that tease about love, this is the one that really comes to mind where it's like he starts off with like this, like, "Oh, the places I'll show you," and then he's like, "Nope, nope, nope."
[51:04] James: Fun pattern dance number, let's go. Not dealing with that.
[51:08] Brianna Jones: I think that does fit his character though, because he really wants to avoid that sort of overt love and just the sort of lovey-dovey ballad that would go with the street.
[51:16] Jess McInalle: Trying to not be a romantic, but then yeah, falling into it.
[51:20] James: Yeah, I think it just fits really well for him, and it's just very funny as well.
[51:24] Andrew DeWolf: I think that we don't have a proper love number between our two leads now that I'm thinking about it, our two romantic pairings. Like they don't have like the "If I Loved You" unconditional love song somewhere in Act One.
[51:38] Jess McInalle: They kind of both have their own song for that.
[51:41] James: Yeah.
[51:42] Brianna Jones: True.
[51:43] Jess McInalle: They split it up into two different songs.
[51:48] James: True, yeah.
[51:49] Brianna Jones: It's like they do get "I Turned the Corner" in Act Two.
[51:51] Jess McInalle: Yeah.
[51:52] James: I like that song as well. But like, yeah.
[51:54] Jess McInalle: I don't know. It might be because they're like both like they don't want to fall in love with each other because they both have like plans to like Millie wants to marry her boss, Jimmy wants to like stay free and like date a bunch of women. So it's like maybe that's why like at first they don't like have a love ballad, and then finally in Act Two, they like realize that they can't fight their feelings anymore, and they just want to come together. And so then that's why the love ballad's there. So that might be it.
[52:19] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Can I bring something up that has nothing to do with anything? But I guess.com, there isn't there's usually like fun facts where you click the highlighted parts, but here's just very obviously a teacher or someone making notes to their students. Like where it says, "I got a good," it just says, "Don't let the note fall off, sustain it." And I'm like, that's not a genius annotation.
[52:54] Jess McInalle: Well, if you ever perform this, you mean Yeah, there you go.
[52:57] Brianna Jones: It's good advice, I guess.
[53:00] Jess McInalle: I guess we gotta talk about the Jimmy back-to-back number. So let's talk about the Act One closer. Very interesting cliffhanger to end us on with Jimmy.
[53:10] ♪ Musical number: "Jimmy" — performed by Millie ♪
[53:54] Andrew DeWolf: I love this. I love the idea of I might be in love with someone, and then a reason why I shouldn't be in love with them, like back to back, and then find out what happens in Act Two. Like, if this were a simpler musical, that would have been enough.
[54:07] James: Yeah, I just love how she switches back between like this ballad where she's worried about Jimmy, and she's like, "Everything today is thoroughly." She just keeps going back to that song because it's like how it represents her, like, you know, her plan to marry her boss and all that and be modern and stuff. So it's like it's really well done, and it just I find the ballad part of it is really good as well. Just like her coming to love Jimmy, like yeah, pretty good stuff.
[54:31] Jess McInalle: There's just there's a whole show here where you just cut out the white slavery and just do this, you know.
[54:37] Brianna Jones: Yeah.
[54:37] Andrew DeWolf: It's just it's like an hour and a half instead of two hours, and then you know a good one-act black box musical with a lot of dancing. Come on. Who doesn't want that?
[54:47] James: Honestly, yeah.
[54:49] Jess McInalle: With Jeanine's story, some music and like some really fun, catchy lyrics, and oh god. What could have been with this show?
[54:57] Andrew DeWolf: It still can be. Like, literally, there's no nothing stopping you from putting this on. Like, it could just be like a really like remember the really racist part of Cats that they just cut out in more recent versions? It could be like that.
[55:08] James: Wait, what part of Cats?
[55:10] Jess McInalle: In like the very first productions, there was like some really funky Chinese stereotypes. I think it was in Gus's song.
[55:20] Brianna Jones: Aristocats type of thing or kind of.
[55:23] Jess McInalle: It was a joke about like Siamese cats and all that. And they've cut it out in more recent productions for obvious reasons. And no one no one has complained about like they're received. They're ruining my Cats musicals.
[55:39] Andrew DeWolf: This ain't the Cats I grew up with. Where's all the racism?
[55:47] James: Oh wonderful far right really got that upset about editing Cats.
[55:52] Jess McInalle: I wanna see Oh god. This is cancel culture. Cat musicals culture.
[55:58] Brianna Jones: Musicals are masculine.
[56:01] Andrew DeWolf: Release the racist.
[56:02] Jess McInalle: Release the racist cuts.
[56:06] James: Oh god. I love that is basically every far-right protest on everything. Like for release the racist cut.
[56:19] Andrew DeWolf: Oh fuck me. Alright. Forget about the boy. Great Act One opener.
[56:24] Jess McInalle: Yeah.
[56:25] Brianna Jones: I love this one.
[56:27] James: Act Two. Oh, sorry. You're right. You're right. Act Two opener.
[57:06] Andrew DeWolf: Especially like this is the one they performed at the Tonys, which out of context is pretty wacky, but it's just like the stenographer like ballet dance taps number. It's great.
[57:23] Jess McInalle: Yeah.
[57:24] James: Yeah, it's just so catchy. I actually listen to it like a lot. Like it's just so catchy and so fun. I love the tap dancing part. Just everything about this number is just so good.
[57:32] Brianna Jones: Yeah, and the best part is if you're not seeing it, you're only getting half of it. And that is such a rare thing with musical theater. Especially nowadays. Like you can listen to Dear Evan Hansen, and you're like, I got what most of those songs are about. There is like no choreography to some newer shows. Like this one has a lot.
[57:50] Jess McInalle: This one does, and they use it to their fullest potential. There is not a single moment of dance that is not fully realized.
[57:58] James: Yep.
[57:59] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Alrighty. Final thing I want to talk about. Final song I want to talk about is "Gimme Gimme." The final like payoff, the 11 o'clock number.
[58:10] Jess McInalle: Gimme a man after mid.
[58:12] Andrew DeWolf: No, not nine until we have our drunken live stream. Come on!
[58:17] ♪ Musical number: "Gimme Gimme" — performed by Millie ♪
[59:10] Jess McInalle: This song is so much fun, and I've heard this song before watching this musical a thousand times. Because I've seen it at cabarets, I've heard it on like recordings, and it works great outside of it, but my god, seeing it in context and seeing it as a payoff to like Millie's like anti-modern, like her finally deciding I'm not gonna be a modern now, and I'm gonna do the love and fall in love, I guess.
[59:33] James: Yeah.
[59:35] Brianna Jones: Yeah, it's just so gratifying to like get this at the end of the show after like she keeps insisting over and over that she wants to be like this modern woman and marry her boss and all that, and it's just like for her to finally just in one just amazing number to just like reject it all and be like, no, I do love this guy. It's just yeah, it's from a story standpoint just really really strong.
[59:56] Jess McInalle: It's very catchy as well.
[59:58] Andrew DeWolf: Great payoff that they undercut by having it like slap between white slavery plot lines.
[1:00:05] James: Yeah.
[1:00:06] Jess McInalle: It's just like this this could just be the big number. Like we don't have to do the rest. This could be the climax of the whole show, but no, I guess we gotta have this.
[1:00:21] Brianna Jones: Oh no.
[1:00:22] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, sorry, that was because I my teeth were kind of gritted when I was like talking about the um the whole white slaver plot line.
[1:00:28] Jess McInalle: Alright.
[1:00:29] James: Oh yeah.
[1:00:30] Brianna Jones: Oh god. Um, all right, can we talk about one last number? We talked mostly positive for the song numbers, which was actually a really nice change of pace for like what we're talking about here.
[1:00:40] Jess McInalle: Most of the songs are pretty good, is the thing.
[1:00:43] Andrew DeWolf: There is one song we probably gotta talk about. Um goodness. It's "They Don't Know," the villain song.
[1:00:51] ♪ Musical number: "They Don't Know" — performed by Mrs. Meers ♪
[1:01:27] James: Yeah, this got a lot of laughs too in the in the one I saw.
[1:01:31] Brianna Jones: Yeah.
[1:01:32] Jess McInalle: Same. It's just it made me uncomfortable. Like every time the audience laughed, I was like, oh god. Like everyone, everyone in 2002 was like on board with this. Like, oh god. It's just.
[1:01:43] Andrew DeWolf: I just remember like, even the guy holding the camera for the bootleg is like, huh? Alright. It's like.
[1:01:52] James: Ha! Right. Perceived race perceived racism.
[1:01:57] Brianna Jones: Of course. I like perceiving it.
[1:02:01] Jess McInalle: Yeah. The idea of this song I kind of love, though. Like an old former actress that wants to act again and still thinks she can do it and resents all these very young people. Like it's a fun motivation if it weren't a racial stereotype, you know?
[1:02:18] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[1:02:19] James: It would. Like they there, like you said earlier, there is a way to do this plotline without having these racial elements in it. And it's like, yeah, this song just kind of shows there's like there's potential here with like this character and like the song as well, but like they just had to have it be this horrible racial thing.
[1:02:40] Andrew DeWolf: It's just uh Well, I'm I mean I'm glad that Ben Brantley got a good laugh out of the uh subtitles.
[1:02:48] James: Oh god.
[1:02:49] Andrew DeWolf: Good old Ben Brantley.
[1:02:56] Jess McInalle: I guess on that note, folks, what is our overall thoughts on Thoroughly Modern Millie and our cheese rating? James, do you want to go first?
[1:03:02] James: Um maybe not, because I kind of need to look up a certain Andrew. Why don't you go first?
[1:03:07] Andrew DeWolf: Sure thing. Uh let's see. Thoroughly Modern Millie is kind of okay, but I don't think I can recommend it to anyone. It's uh one of those shows. I just I don't think people will feel comfortable watching this. Um unless you're a racist. Um, in which case I hope you're not listening to my show.
[1:03:29] James: Yeah, if you're racist, get the fuck out of here.
[1:03:32] Andrew DeWolf: If you're like still slapping your knees to how hilarious like Miss Mears is as a character, maybe maybe maybe musicals with cheese is something you should give a miss.
[1:03:42] James: Yeah.
[1:03:43] Andrew DeWolf: Um, but there is something good in here, and like if you can ignore all of that, which I don't think you should be able to ignore it because honestly it's pretty blatant. Um there's good stuff. I don't know. I I wish they could just redo this and just get rid of that, because I it doesn't even seem like it's necessary. It's not like ingrained and necessary to the show's plot. You could just get rid of it. It doesn't have to be there. Um it would make it a lot better. Um, but as of right now, maybe listen to some of the good songs that we recommended and leave the rest of the show out, I guess. Although that kind of stinks too, because the choreography is good. I don't know. It's a really difficult show to talk about. Um I'm gonna give it a uh a slice of New York uh cheese pizza. Just just cause it takes place in New York, that's all I've got.
[1:04:33] James: You know, that's fair. And I do want to put the asterisk of I kinda get why they implemented it. It was from the original 1967 film, which was a product of its time, racist product of its time. But you know, with adaptations, you you can make changes. You don't have to you don't have to stick to what you got there.
[1:04:50] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, and I get the like they're trying to say that it's like, oh well, the stereotype is the bad guy, and the good guys are the real Chinese people, and it's like uh I just it's it's not there. Like it's not there. Like I don't know if that's if that's what they were trying to do, that's better than how it comes across. But how it comes across is just racist.
[1:05:13] James: Yes, I can see the argument of like uh the white man who wrote this, where it's like, I made a white character racist, and then we have the actual representation also in this show. I'm like, you know what, just fucking like put your representation as Millie. How about that? Or like one of the girls, and just make these guys some fuckers. How about you don't like uh force diversity into this in a very offensive racist way and just make a diverse show?
[1:05:43] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, like and also the diversity is also bad guys who are working for a white slaver. So it's like it doesn't even really work in that way because you know they're on the lower world too. Like they are not portrayed as high and mighty characters, they are not portrayed as fun characters, really, even. Or good characters, and until the very end when one of them falls in love with the uh other side character, but like you had to go through the entire show to get there, so it wasn't worth it when you got there.
[1:06:14] Jess McInalle: Alright, James, yeah, your overall thoughts.
[1:06:17] James: Okay, um, yeah, it's like nowadays I look back on it being my first musical and I'm like, oh geez, I couldn't have had like a non-racist show be the first one I was in. Like, oh god. Um, but yeah, I don't know. There's there's a lot of uh good elements still, but yeah, it's kind of like what Andrew said. Like, like I don't I can't recommend it in good conscience as it is now. Like, I'm really hoping they update the show and like remove these elements because they're very easy to remove, I feel like. And you can then the main plot, which is pretty good, is like still intact. And um, yeah, like like you said, just maybe just watch the uh maybe maybe like watch the Tony performance of like Forget About the Boy.
Uh that then you can really see like the impressive dancing and everything, and like listen to some of the songs as well. But yeah, in its current state, maybe don't watch the the show as is. So for my cheese rating, I'm just gonna give it a uh a cheese that's just covered in mold entirely. Just like clear you need to remake this cheese with without the molds that grew on it because it's just like it doesn't have to be there. Like the cheese would be better if there wasn't the mold. It's like it's like you took a bladder and added the mold on top of it. It's not like the mold grew onto the cheese. It is gr put on there, sprinkle gently on there yourself. Just like, why'd you do that? Honestly. You didn't have to do that.
[1:07:40] Andrew DeWolf: So just yeah, just take the recipe, just make the cheese again. This time don't shove the mold on it. You know, some people like this cheese, but other people have complaints about perceived mold that I put on the ultimate payoff.
[1:07:59] Andrew DeWolf: We did it, Andrew!
[1:08:00] Jess McInalle: Alright. Bree, what did you think of our discussion and your cheese rating on that?
[1:08:06] Brianna Jones: I think you guys did a great job touching on, you know, the fact that there are some racist elements in this, and then you guys addressed it, I think, very well. Um, but it does sound like there were some good elements. Um I wouldn't personally watch it. You said it was racist, so I'm cut it off right there. Um but I stumbled upon um an article called Cheese in the Time of dot dot dot El Capone. And I figured okay, the Roaring Twenties, this seems fitting. And so I'm gonna give my cheese writing is a cheese ball because this is what um this article talks about. But it says, hidden inside the creamy ball of cheese is a party animal past that helped to make criminals out of many Americans. Okay. I just that's the last line of the article, and I really just wanted to share that. So next time you go to a party and you see a cheese ball, don't touch it, because you may become a criminal.
[1:09:10] Andrew DeWolf: There's white slavery in there. You gotta be careful.
[1:09:14] Brianna Jones: Of course. I guess it's all down to me now. And there's things I like about this, but like you can't just close your eyes and plug your ears at all the shit shit garbage in here. Um and it's just weird because I try to do a little bit of like research to see what like the musical theater lexicon thinks of this. I was listening to like podcasts about this, and I'm not gonna name any. And it seems like they talk about everything that isn't the oriental representation in this, which is like just fucked up. Like two white people talking about how great the show is and the dancing and all that, and they don't say a damn word about it. Like any of the like the horrible, horror. I don't know how you could talk about this show without mentioning it.
Oh, just focus on how great Sutton Foster is and like how amazing it all looks and Gavin Creel and all that, and you just don't talk about the stuff that doesn't look like I don't like that. No, we gotta focus on the shit that sucks, like politically, too. We can't just close our eyes because we want to like something. And uh I I that bothers me a lot. Um, and that has nothing to do with the show itself, it's just how we see it. And Ben Brandley, it is not perceived racism, it is active racism. It harms these communities, and it pisses me the fuck off when you try to bash it down. I know this is like almost 20 years ago. It's hard to like be objective about like the time differences and how things were at the time, but I'm mad now, so fuck you.
Um so my cheese rating is a cheese culture. So I'm gonna say like a cheddar with a cheese culture made by Mad Millie's cheese culture. Okay. And it's a Millie thing. And it sounds thoroughly modern to me.
[1:10:55] Jess McInalle: Um, James, I know you've got tons of things to promote. You got great content. Promote away.
[1:11:01] James: Alright, so um you can find me on YouTube at uh Schaeferless Productions. It's a little hard to spell, but if you just type in like uh Shark Tale review, you'll probably find me. Um I don't know why that's the first thing that came to mind. Oh no. I am not Doug Walker, I will say that just as a disclaimer. Um, but yeah, you can find me on uh YouTube and then Twitter as well at Schaefer Ellis. Um I have my own podcast with my friends called Shiny Cast, so you can look that up as well. We talk about like a lot of different things like video game announcements and um stuff like that. And uh yeah, uh that's about it. So check out my videos and yeah.
[1:11:43] Jess McInalle: That that's great. Yeah. Um I also, for folks who are fans of us, you will really love his wonderful Spongebob the musical video that he just released a couple of weeks ago. Um highly recommend it if you want to try to dive in there from musical theater perspective. He also did great videos on Hades Town and the Hunchback of Notre Dame, the stage musical version. So if you're looking for stage musical jump on points that will kind of lead you through it, that those are my recommendations. And also, while I've got you here to talk about Hunchback, have you looked into the Berlin production at all?
[1:12:15] James: The original Berlin?
[1:12:17] Jess McInalle: Uh no, I haven't.
[1:12:18] James: Holy shit. That is like an insanely gorgeous production.
[1:12:22] Jess McInalle: And we talked about this in our Hunchback episode, and I don't mean to throw an addendum onto this. But I'd be so curious as to your opinion on that production in comparison to the more recent one. Because it has like all the dark stuff, but they remove a lot of the related. It's a little it is the midpoint between the movie and that new stage version where it just looks gorgeous and has like these beautiful giant stained glass pieces, but removes like the new Frollo relationship side of things. Um very curious to see what your thoughts would be on that. But that's not what we're here.
[1:12:55] James: I'll have to check that out though.
[1:12:57] Jess McInalle: Yeah, that sounds awesome. But you know what? Who how the fuck do I usually do this? Our patrons!
[1:13:04] Andrew DeWolf: Yes!
[1:13:06] Jess McInalle: Our wonderful patrons! Thank you guys for listening. Please follow us on iTunes, Spotify, Stitcher at Musicals for Cheese. We're on Twitter at Cheesy Musicals, Patreon Musicals for Cheese, Instagram Musicals for Cheese, YouTube Page Musicals for Cheese. We have the patron only podcast, Patreon with cheese. Check us out there. We're currently covering Galavant. We also have some commentaries coming up. Bree and I have some cool stuff we're gonna get done soon. Um I'm also gonna start live streaming some stuff soon. That's gonna be that's gonna be a lot of fun. Um, shoot us an email, musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com. Our title card is created by the amazing Jolene Casco. Go send her some love at Jolene Casco on Instagram.
Our keeper of the cheese is Julietta Antonio. Thank you for keeping track of that. Um, the composer of Brie Views is Robin Ash of IOU UK Music. So go check her out. She does great work. This show is produced by the absolutely incredible, the wonderful Brianna Jones. We love you so much, Brie. We're so glad you're back. We missed you last two weeks. Um thank you to the Broadway Podcast Network for having us on the platform and for not taking us out behind the shed to be shot like old yeller.
[1:14:05] Andrew DeWolf: It's it's gonna happen.
[1:14:06] Jess McInalle: We just don't know when. James, is there anything else you want to say before we wrap this up?
[1:14:12] James: Um, I actually just remembered I do have one more uh musical theater video coming out uh probably in May, and it's about a certain Star Kid musical that I love uh very much. So uh look forward to that, everyone.
[1:14:24] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, is it twisted? Is it guided in like musicals? Is it gonna be uh Oh no spoils, don't spoil it here.
[1:14:30] James: No, no. I I I won't spoil it. I'll tell you afterwards, but yeah. For uh everyone listening at home. It's a mystery on my channel.
[1:14:40] Jess McInalle: So yeah. You're gonna love it. No matter what, you guys are gonna love it, because Shaferless is a great YouTube channel, some great content. Highly recommended, man.
[1:14:46] James: So it's so great.
[1:14:49] Jess McInalle: Thank you. I don't even know what accent you're trying to do. It started as Trump, but then I got tired of it.
[1:14:54] James: But so I changed it to whatever she actually. Um all right. We'll see you next time on Musicals with Cheese.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
