"I didn't wanna be a half-blood!" Whip out your teen angst and magic lightning bolts because this week we're to talking about the Young Adult Fantasy Musical "The Lightning Thief." If you've ever had teen angst, you'll have a blast. Donate to Black Lives Matter here... Read More
From the show: Musicals with Cheese
About
"I didn't wanna be a half-blood!" Whip out your teen angst and magic lightning bolts because this week we're to talking about the Young Adult Fantasy Musical "The Lightning Thief." If you've ever had teen angst, you'll have a blast.
Donate to Black Lives Matter here
Social Media:
Musicals with Cheese on Twitter
Musicals W/ Cheese on Instagram
Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com
Jess Socials
Andrew Socials
Brianna Socials
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:06] Jesse McInally: Hello, I'm Jesse McInally.
[0:08] Andrew DeWolf: And I am Andrew DeWolf.
[0:09] Brianna Jones: And I'm Brianna Jones.
[0:11] Jesse McInally: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, a podcast where I try to get Andrew and Brianna to like musical theater. How are we doing today, guys?
[0:16] Andrew DeWolf: Man, life is really hard for me right now.
[0:22] Brianna Jones: Oh, why?
[0:23] Andrew DeWolf: Oh no, no, no. I just found out that I am half god. And uh that obviously has made my life worse somehow.
[0:32] Brianna Jones: Oh my god, which god?
[0:33] Andrew DeWolf: Oh my or oh you because oh my you because you're half god.
[0:38] Andrew DeWolf: No, I'm only a half-blood. I'm a mere mortal god. I'm not a true god. My father is Thor.
[0:44] Brianna Jones: Your father is Thor?
[0:46] Andrew DeWolf: The god of thunder.
[0:47] Brianna Jones: Your your father is sore? Like, I can get him some ibuprofen if you'd like, but I don't know if it would help him much. He's always fighting Yotans.
[0:57] Jesse McInally: This week we're talking about the musical The Lightning Thief.
[1:01] Jesse McInally: Q the music breeze!
[1:04] ♪ Musical number: "All Things Couldn't Be Worse" — performed by the cast ♪
[1:29] Jesse McInally: Oh no! When your dad's a god, life can be tough. I met the guy once, and once was enough.
[1:40] Andrew DeWolf: No, I hear that. The Lightning Thief is a musical with music by Rob Rokicki and lyrics by Rob Rokicki. Book by Joe Tracz, and based on the Lightning Thief books by Rick Riordan.
[1:51] Jesse McInally: Um, it premiered off Broadway on July 21st, 2014, at the Lucille Lortel Theater in New York City. And then it went on a couple of national tours and finally premiered on Broadway on October 16th, 2020, at the Longacre Theater. It closed on January 5th, 2020, and you know what? It was nominated for no Tonys, despite being the only musical with an original score that came out that year.
[2:15] Andrew DeWolf: They literally nominated the music from plays, so I couldn't nominate The Lightning Thief for best original score and music.
[2:22] Jesse McInally: What the— in a year when there was no theater, that was what they did.
[2:28] Andrew DeWolf: They didn't want to even justify the existence of this.
[2:32] Jesse McInally: Yeah.
[2:34] Andrew DeWolf: That baffles the fuck out of me. I'm still mad about that. Like, this isn't the best show ever, but that pisses me off.
[2:39] Jesse McInally: But the players are not going to be able to do the show.
[2:43] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, but I don't even care if it wins at this point. Like when it was like nomination time is coming around, I didn't even care if it won. I just wanted to get nominated because hey, it probably wouldn't have been any other season, but hey, since the COVID shutdowns kind of avoided a lot of shows opening, that could be a good thing for The Lightning Thief.
[3:01] Jesse McInally: Now here we are, and shit, shit sucked. Um, the plot of The Lightning Thief. Percy Jackson has newly discovered powers he can't control. Monsters on his trail, and he is on a quest to find Zeus's lightning bolt and prevent a war between the Greek gods. Normal is a myth when you're a demigod.
[3:19] So Andrew, what did you think of The Lightning Thief the musical?
[3:22] Andrew DeWolf: Honestly, I didn't know what to expect going into it, and I was uh honestly, I feel like I was disappointed anyways. Like I expected nothing, and I'm still disappointed.
[3:33] Jesse McInally: Yeah, like I feel like that's actually where I'm at. Like the only thing I knew about this is that it was apparently so bad that they didn't nominate it for a Tony, even though it was the only show that existed that year. Um, so I was like, okay, um, well maybe that's just big ol' mean critics.
[3:52] Andrew DeWolf: And then I watched it and I was like, oh no, it wasn't. Okay, that's just bad.
[3:55] Jesse McInally: I disagree with you. I think the show's great. I think this show's a ton of fun.
[3:59] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, can we just briefly— did you watch the movies?
[4:04] Jesse McInally: I watched the first movie when I and I've read the first book. So I read and saw all the adaptations of this before seeing the musical.
[4:12] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. Is the book just bad?
[4:15] Jesse McInally: Is the book just bad? Like I hear the movie is bad, and I don't like the musical, and I know that they're gonna adapt it into a TV show or something soon as well.
[4:26] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, Disney Plus show.
[4:28] Jesse McInally: And like I just I just feel like it's just bad.
[4:33] Andrew DeWolf: Like I don't know.
[4:35] Jesse McInally: Alright. It was kind of coming off in the Harry Potter area of like young adult fantasy based on like some kind of mythological connection.
[4:45] Andrew DeWolf: So it is very similar in tone to that, where it takes place in contemporary reality. Um, a kid is sent off to a school for a bunch of magic folk where they have to learn and do things. But things go awry, and he and his two friends, um, his nerdier, weirder friend that has goat legs, um, and his attractive lady friend, all go off on an adventure to try to stop bad things from happening because Zeus thinks he stole like his lightning bolt.
[5:12] Jesse McInally: Um, it's a darker piece than the musical is. The book is very much in kin with like Harry Potter, but like the midpoint Harry Potter, where it gets like a touch darker, but not so dark that it's not for kids anymore.
[5:25] Andrew DeWolf: So not like the little kid ones, but like the teenagers one almost?
[5:30] Jesse McInally: Yeah. Um, while they are like twelve years old in the book, the tone is closer to like Prisoner of Azkaban than it is to Sorcerer's Stone.
[5:38] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.
[5:38] Jesse McInally: Um, and this just kinda leans into the like camp um and humor side, which I kind of appreciate because I like that and that's fun, and if you take this story about like half gods or gods that go down and fuck women and impregnate like babies into them and just abandon them on Earth for them to figure it out for themselves. That's a wacky, fuckety idea. And if you don't play it for laughs, it's gonna kind of feel icky. So I think they kind of feel the right choice.
[6:10] Andrew DeWolf: Like the Greek gods are— I don't know. I wish the Greek gods were— and I know it's really common to do these modern stylizations of Greek gods like uh what is it, what is that show?
[6:24] Jesse McInally: Like American Gods or something?
[6:26] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, I don't know. But they do like modern stylizations of these god characters. I just feel like it always sucks.
[6:34] Jesse McInally: Have you read the book American Gods?
[6:36] Andrew DeWolf: I have not.
[6:37] Jesse McInally: It's pretty good. Um, but it's what you're saying except it takes itself much more seriously.
[6:41] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, well taking it more seriously would be nice. Um, they really did my boy Dionysus dirty in this, and I was really unhappy to see that portrayal but Andrew's gonna love the frogs.
[6:52] Jesse McInally: I feel like I've come around and now I'm just fairly certain that Andrew's just gonna love every second of the frogs.
[6:58] Andrew DeWolf: Like Dionysus is like the god of like partying essentially and like what do they do to him?
[7:04] Jesse McInally: He's like an old man, like a grumpy like Danny DeVito type, like come on.
[7:10] Andrew DeWolf: I mean alright, what's the difference between something like this and Hercules? Which I know you like— there's not that much of a difference, just Hercules is animated and has a lot more fun with it.
[7:21] Jesse McInally: This has a ton of fun. They have like leaf blowers with toilet paper rolls on the end so they spray you with toilet paper.
[7:27] Andrew DeWolf: It's great! I didn't get sprayed with any toilet paper watching this is all I can say.
[7:32] Jesse McInally: I did. I was in the third row seeing this live and I had a blast. There was an old couple in front of me that walked out midway through and I got a better view of the show that way.
[7:42] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. Chiron, they couldn't even be bothered to make him an actual centaur. Like come on, how hard is it to just do a bottom of a horse costume? Come on.
[7:50] Jesse McInally: But I like that. I like the kind of ramshackle paper mache look of this show where they kind of lean into it being like a little cheesier so you don't take it as seriously. I think the tone does a lot of favors.
[8:04] Especially like seeing this as what it was originally gonna be, it was like a one act 60-minute show just for fun that eventually grew into a much longer thing and now it is like perfect for like high school theaters. This is gonna be like do gangbusters in community theater and high school theater and it's great for that.
[8:15] Andrew DeWolf: Imagine kids doing it. It's wonderful. I'm sure they'll have a great time with it.
[8:25] Jesse McInally: I didn't enjoy it at all though.
[8:27] Andrew DeWolf: Why?
[8:28] Jesse McInally: I just did not like it. It just felt like a young adult— like I don't know, I don't like that young adult feel, you know, where it's like kids saving the world from threats that are like not really that threatening.
[8:30] Andrew DeWolf: Like I don't know, I mean that's a problem you have with the young adult genre, not the show itself. You kinda have to like detach yourself a little bit and see this as an adaptation.
[8:54] Jesse McInally: And as an adaptation, I appreciate the choices it made, as opposed to the choices made in the film version, which is to age them up, make them all strong boys and make everything like either super goofy or super stupid or super serious.
[9:09] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, why do they call it Camp Half-Blood when there's already a word for it? It's called being a demigod. Shouldn't it be Camp Demigod?
[9:16] Jesse McInally: I mean, half-blood is just like a cutesier version of that.
[9:19] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like that's exactly— that's like why do we have to do that? Can't we just use the word demigod?
[9:28] Jesse McInally: You want my honest opinion? Um, my cynical opinion.
[9:32] Andrew DeWolf: Sure.
[9:32] Jesse McInally: As 'cause you can't sell demigod. You can't really trademark demigod, but you can trade half god or half-blood.
[9:40] Andrew DeWolf: It just reminds me of like a trademark muggle.
[9:43] Jesse McInally: Yeah, it reminds me of like the mudblood thing from Harry Potter. It's just like they're trying to do that.
[9:48] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it is. And it does it well.
[9:51] Jesse McInally: No, it does it just does it worse.
[9:53] Andrew DeWolf: It 'cause the writer isn't a transphobe, it's better.
[9:57] Jesse McInally: Okay.
[9:57] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, I don't care about the author. We don't have to drag that in.
[10:00] Jesse McInally: Death of the author, come on. Get with the title.
[10:02] Andrew DeWolf: Well, the author's still alive and profiting off of the merch, you know.
[10:07] Jesse McInally: Okay. Andrew, you're just angry at like tonal things, which I respect it. You can't be mad at a tone because it wasn't what you expected. You gotta respect it for what it is.
[10:14] Andrew DeWolf: Oh no, it's not because it wasn't what I expected.
[10:18] Jesse McInally: Okay, it's because it's not what I like.
[10:22] Andrew DeWolf: We've covered other teenage-driven musicals. We've covered Be More Chill, we've covered Dear Evan Hansen, we've covered um—
[10:24] Jesse McInally: Yeah, but Be More Chill is like a simple story where there's not like a fake threat that's not really threatening.
[10:39] Andrew DeWolf: Like I never actually felt like any of these characters were in any actual danger through the entire show here.
[10:47] Jesse McInally: Even though they are characters with goals and aspirations and issues.
[10:52] Andrew DeWolf: Like, yeah, but no. Like, what is Percy’s like goal other than just to get his mom back, I guess?
[11:00] Jesse McInally: Well, his mom is dead. Um, his goal is to find himself and figure out like where he fits into this new world that he was thrown into that he didn't realize he was a part of, and he doesn't know who his dad is. It's like a usual story of a kid that doesn't know who his dad is, and his mom's gone and thrown into this world he doesn't know.
[11:20] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[11:21] Jesse McInally: I don't know. I don't know. I really just don't enjoy it.
[11:24] Andrew DeWolf: I guess I have trouble explaining why. I just I don't like it.
[11:30] Jesse McInally: I mean, was anything done incompetently? Because I feel like the I Want song explains what people want, they explain their issues, the characters are very distinct from one another.
[11:39] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I think if anything was done incompetently, it's not very funny.
[11:45] Jesse McInally: Like most of the jokes do not land for me at all.
[11:48] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I'm even trying to remember any of the jokes, and I can't quite— I remember they did the Dead on Arrival like records is like that's where uh Hades is.
[11:59] Jesse McInally: Like, I think that song's a lot of fun, by the way.
[12:02] Andrew DeWolf: It's just I just don't think it's that funny.
[12:05] Jesse McInally: I don't— I mean, a lot of it is more like kind of nudgy goofy, like I'm imagining like for kids, this is their first like step into like the Greek god territory where it gives you just enough of their like what they are and how they stand for and like the fun side of it.
[12:22] Andrew DeWolf: It's mostly for fun at this point.
[12:24] Jesse McInally: I don't even think it's like for comedy.
[12:26] Andrew DeWolf: I guess.
[12:27] Jesse McInally: Um, if I liked anything—
[12:30] Andrew DeWolf: No, I don't think I liked anything.
[12:33] Jesse McInally: You didn't like the set design? You didn't like the stylistic choices that are obviously made of stylistic choices?
[12:39] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, no, I don't like the tone. I don't like the characters. I think Percy is just unlikable in a way.
[12:48] Jesse McInally: Um, he doesn't have any like real character traits other than just not knowing of the world.
[12:58] Andrew DeWolf: It's just like he's just an audience insert character in a like majorly.
[13:03] Jesse McInally: Well, he is that, but he also has like traits, like he has ADHD. I think in the book it was dyslexia, um, where he just has a very hard time missing. They try to use that to say that because he had those mental disorders, he was definitely a demigod, which is kind of like in the book it was more like they were a side effect of being a demigod.
[13:26] Andrew DeWolf: I guess. That was a bit of an awkward choice, uh, in my opinion. Um, but even then you don't even really see those things happen. Uh, like you never actually see him like try to read something in the and he has dyslexia or something like that. Doesn't actually happen in the show, they just say that it does. Uh, and I I mean, I don't remember the girl's character's name, but Annabet Annabeth, Annabelle, Annabeth.
[13:53] Brianna Jones: Annabeth.
[13:55] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, she just really wants to please her mom is like her whole thing. Uh, and I don't know, they they try to go with this thing where they have the uh the oracle tell uh Percy. So Percy finds out, well, I gotta go through the plot real quick. Percy finds out that he is a demigod, a half-blood. Um, and he gets uh attacked by a Minotaur and his mom dies to it. I think it was a men it was a Minotaur, right?
[14:25] Brianna Jones: It was some creature, yeah.
[14:26] Andrew DeWolf: I think Manotaur. And then he goes to Camp Half-Blood, and all of the kids are sorted into different cliques that are just based on who their parent is. His parents like Ares, Athena, uh did they even Merc Mercury? Uh, not Mercury. I forget I forget the name in uh I forget the name that they use. My goodness. I I I get confused with Roman and Greek names. Uh, but okay. Yeah, they do all that, and then uh he gets framed for stealing Zeus's lightning, so he goes on a quest to go to Hades in the underworld and get the lightning.
[15:08] Brianna Jones: Yeah, get the lightning back.
[15:09] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, an oracle tells him before the quest that he's going to fail, and one of his friends will betray him, which I think is paid off in the laziest way they possibly could pay that off. Um, in my opinion, but maybe Jess will disagree.
[15:25] Brianna Jones: Uh, I I I will agree. I do not like how that kind of comes up in the end, but that was in the book.
[15:30] Andrew DeWolf: Um, but I I just don't think it's done well there either. Just incredibly lazy. It's just like, oh yeah, you'll get framed by a you'll get uh betrayed by a friend, and you'll fail, and like he doesn't fail, and the friend he gets betrayed by was somebody who was not on the quest with him.
[15:48] Brianna Jones: So like over.
[15:49] Andrew DeWolf: It was just some other guy, you know. Um. And then he goes to the underworld, Hades doesn't actually have the lightning. He turns out Percy did have the lightning, but Ares actually was framing him with it because Ares like helped them and they trusted him for some reason, even though he's like the god of like horrific violence. But I guess we'll trust Ares, yeah.
[16:11] Brianna Jones: That's cool.
[16:12] Andrew DeWolf: Um, he gives them the lightning, and then Poseidon comes and saves the day, who is Percy's dad. And then his mom comes back to life for some reason. I love the design of Poseidon. I think Poseidon is hilarious.
[16:22] Brianna Jones: Poseidon, yeah.
[16:26] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, he it's funny. I like the Hawaiian shirt. Poseidon's always portrayed as like really chill, even though he definitely is not like really really chill. He's just as weird and hyper sexual as the other two brothers are, but he's like the stoner sexual, like horny bro.
[16:47] Brianna Jones: It's actually weird because Hades is always portrayed as the bad guy, and they even make the joke in this that he is. And but like in the actual Greek mythology, he's actually like the most chill. Uh, and he's like very uh into Persephone, and that's about it.
[17:06] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, yeah, it's all these things. It's a simplistic story for kids. And it was made to be an hour-long kid's show that got expanded into a two-act musical, which is still fairly short. It's like a little over two hours.
[17:18] Brianna Jones: It's not even like approaching.
[17:20] Andrew DeWolf: Actually, you know what? Positive things. It's short. It is very short, it moves very fast. Um, the plot is told very succinctly, like the opening scene where he like gets kicked out of school, and like we learn about him being a half-blood and like all that stuff. Done very, very quickly in the opening, very well.
[17:38] Brianna Jones: And very fun, and like with all these puppets.
[17:40] Andrew DeWolf: This has so much puppet usage, and you don't like it.
[17:44] Brianna Jones: I just I don't think the puppets are that good.
[17:47] Andrew DeWolf: I think they're really cool. I think the Mannitar was pretty cool. I wish they used him more than once.
[17:53] Brianna Jones: They didn't, though.
[17:55] Andrew DeWolf: Uh yeah, I don't know. I'm not saying this is a faultless show. I'm not. I'm not. I'm not saying like this is the most perfect show in the world. For children and teenagers wanting a kind of young adult experience at the theater that they could probably put on in a way that they can relate to, where you could teach this in your class and then you can also perform it in your school.
[18:17] Brianna Jones: I think this is the best of all worlds.
[18:19] Andrew DeWolf: In community theater, this is like a perfect community theater show.
[18:22] Brianna Jones: That I can maybe agree with that, but how the heck did this get to Broadway?
[18:27] Andrew DeWolf: Um, popularity, fan base. It got a really devoted young fan base. Um, run through a very vocal, very well done Twitter account, um, that really brought people together. Um, it was an underdog show that would just tour, and when it toured, a lot of people would go to see it because brand recognition, like this is it's like if they did a Harry Potter musical, um, and it was just small and intimate.
[18:50] Brianna Jones: I appreciated how small it was.
[18:52] Andrew DeWolf: It is a very seven cast members. That's pretty pretty incredible. I think that's good for what they pull off with such a small cast.
[18:59] Brianna Jones: Um and it's just different.
[19:02] Andrew DeWolf: It is not the same, it is not heavy like Dear Evan Hansen. It is all the things I like about Spongebob in a more you know, smaller container.
[19:12] Brianna Jones: I think what it doesn't have that Spongebob does have though is Spongebob is funny.
[19:17] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, this isn't really trying to be like a laugh riot. This has a lot of plot it has to tell, and it's worried more about character development than it is chuckles.
[19:27] Brianna Jones: Uh yeah, I just don't think they develop the characters very well.
[19:30] Andrew DeWolf: They develop Grover okay, I think. If if anyone got developed well, it was uh him.
[19:37] Brianna Jones: And I will say he was the one that got shafted the most in the live action film directed by Chris Columbus, where he is comic relief buffoon in those movies.
[19:48] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, I mean, I I definitely could see that coming. Like, if anyone is gonna get turned into that, it's it's that guy. Whereas in the book, he's like the guy that kind of explains it all. He's not really a funny guy. He's like just a guy that happens to be a goat on the bottom.
[20:05] Brianna Jones: I like the traumatic backstory element that they did with him.
[20:09] Andrew DeWolf: I kind of wish there was something like that for like Percy.
[20:15] Brianna Jones: I mean, we see it happen, his mom gets murdered.
[20:19] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[20:21] Brianna Jones: I don't know. It doesn't even feel like he really responds that well uh that much to it.
[20:27] Andrew DeWolf: Well, the movie I the the show just moves that fast where it just not a lot of those moments get to sink in too much. And also because it's not really a depressing Dear Evan Hansen-esque show either.
[20:41] Brianna Jones: Yeah.
[20:42] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know. I guess I just um it just You just wanted to drink the Hater Aid and be like, fuck them kids. Just like Michael Jordan.
[20:52] Brianna Jones: I I don't even usually mind kid shows though.
[20:56] Andrew DeWolf: Honestly, I think I think I like children's media more than I like young adult media. I think young adult is just like this genre of bland, like just really bland stories about teenagers fighting in Harry Potter knockoffs.
[21:15] Brianna Jones: Well, there's th there is an actual Harry Potter show on Broadway that I think is much worse than this, actually.
[21:22] Andrew DeWolf: Like, I think this is a much better show than the actual Harry Potter stage show on Broadway at the moment.
[21:28] Brianna Jones: I have not seen that.
[21:30] Andrew DeWolf: I don't want to. I'm not a huge fan of Harry Potter either.
[21:33] Brianna Jones: I think Harry Potter's really mediocre.
[21:37] Andrew DeWolf: It's pretty mediocre.
[21:39] Brianna Jones: I think these books are actually better written than Harry Potter. They're very clear, cut, easy reads.
[21:46] Andrew DeWolf: I just I wish there was more depth to the young adult genre.
[21:50] Brianna Jones: Like I wish they would talk about anything like thematically that was anywhere close to an amount of depth.
[22:01] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like you get more depth from some Disney movies than you get from some of these young adult things.
[22:05] Brianna Jones: I mean, they they're there. Like young adult books that have depth are there, just that they get memed to death.
[22:11] Andrew DeWolf: Like the Fault in Our Stars is very depthful, but it got memed to death because of that god-awful movie, and that's just become its own stupid group of memes for little girls now.
[22:22] Brianna Jones: I as bad as this sounds, I think there's more depth in shit like Twilight than there is in Harry Potter.
[22:29] Andrew DeWolf: Like there's Harry Potter has going on there.
[22:32] Brianna Jones: Harry Potter has like no depth.
[22:34] Andrew DeWolf: Like at all.
[22:34] Brianna Jones: Well, Harry Potter is a repetitive structure for eight books.
[22:39] Andrew DeWolf: Like literally, they have the same basic things.
[22:41] Brianna Jones: And you can call it, oh, it's just warm and familiar, or like I I know the structure, I know what it is.
[22:46] Andrew DeWolf: No, it's all the same book.
[22:48] Brianna Jones: Every every book is the same, guys.
[22:50] Andrew DeWolf: Harry Potter is like a deeply flawed universe that is getting attacked by an evil person, and Harry Potter's just like, yeah, I defeated the evil person. Let's never look inward though.
[22:59] Brianna Jones: Ever.
[23:01] Andrew DeWolf: Harry Potter is just the ultimate, like protagonist.
[23:07] Brianna Jones: You might as well just call him protagonist.
[23:10] Andrew DeWolf: Whereas Percy, he has issues. He has like he has a stepdad he doesn't like.
[23:16] Brianna Jones: He has these mental facilities that he is struggling with.
[23:20] Andrew DeWolf: He has like this constant ability to like find himself in trouble and no one believes him when he says, like, no, no, it's not me. Like, there are things here that I think kids and teens should and could relate to while it's still being a young adult fantasy novel.
[23:35] Brianna Jones: There are those real life things that I find much more interesting than like, you know, it sucks being the coolest guy in the world and Harry Potter.
[23:42] Andrew DeWolf: You know what could have made this show way better.
[23:45] Brianna Jones: What?
[23:46] Andrew DeWolf: If they did it like Wizard of Oz. You know? Like, let's say before he finds out about he's actually a demigod, we see the stepdad, and then we see like a mean teacher that he has or something, or just people he doesn't like, and then he finds out that he is a demigod and he meets Medusa and it's the same actress that played the mean teacher, and then he meets Ares, and it's it's oh, it's the mean stepdad, it's the same actor.
[24:16] Brianna Jones: Like I just I kind of feel like that could work better.
[24:19] Andrew DeWolf: Whereas like he's agree.
[24:20] Brianna Jones: It just feels like he it's just set piece after set piece that has no connection to any like they run into Medusa.
[24:27] Andrew DeWolf: They just run into Medusa, just 'cause I mean, why were they why did they meet Medusa?
[24:32] Brianna Jones: Andrew, we've had covered vignette musicals before, and we haven't had this complaint.
[24:38] Andrew DeWolf: It's just a series of vignettes from scene to scene. They have a goal, they're going to the goal, and vignettes happen on their way to the goal.
[24:45] Brianna Jones: It is no different than any other structure like that.
[24:48] Andrew DeWolf: Hero's journey.
[24:50] Brianna Jones: No, because usually there's like thematic relevance to things.
[24:54] Andrew DeWolf: Like, what does Medusa represent for Percy, other than just a mean lady that he doesn't like?
[25:01] Brianna Jones: I mean, uh nothing.
[25:05] Andrew DeWolf: There's nothing.
[25:06] Brianna Jones: There's nothing.
[25:07] Andrew DeWolf: What does a wicked witch represent to fucking Dorothy aside from a mean lady she doesn't like?
[25:12] Brianna Jones: It's an actual mean lady that she doesn't like in her real life.
[25:15] Andrew DeWolf: What does the jitterbug represent to Dorothy when she a cut scene that doesn't exist in the movie?
[25:22] Brianna Jones: When she no, he he's a guy who told her about a fine affair.
[25:26] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, that's not a real movie that doesn't exist.
[25:29] Brianna Jones: What do Tom and Jerry represent, uh Dorothy when she goes to the show?
[25:33] Andrew DeWolf: See, this is you're explaining this. This is why the Tom and Jerry one is not as good, and this is why Percy Jackson is not as good.
[25:40] Brianna Jones: I think you just wanna hate this.
[25:42] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like you had a bad taste in your mouth for the stylistic choices that you wanted to find reasons to dislike it.
[25:47] Brianna Jones: And I don't usually claim that to you.
[25:50] Andrew DeWolf: Sure.
[25:51] Brianna Jones: I just don't think it was good.
[25:54] Andrew DeWolf: Well, it doesn't really matter what we think, because it's time to compare our opinions to those of the New York theater critics.
[26:01] Brianna Jones: And one of our favorite segments of all time, it's time for BREV.
[26:07] Andrew DeWolf: It's time for previews.
[26:11] Brianna Jones: It's time for previews.
[26:14] Andrew DeWolf: New York Times critic Jesse Green said of the limited 2019 Broadway production. Here's an idea for a Broadway musical. An awkward boy with an absent father and an overwhelmed mother gets involved with friends in a dubious scheme that spins out of control and almost undoes him.
[26:30] Brianna Jones: Is it Dear Evan Hansive?
[26:31] Andrew DeWolf: Hansen?
[26:33] Brianna Jones: Is it Dear Evan Hansen?
[26:35] Andrew DeWolf: If only.
[26:48] Andrew DeWolf: Alas, The Lightning Thief, the Percy Jackson musical, is a pale patch of the earlier show in a failed attempt to board the teen teenage fantasy angst train. See also Be More Chill and more successfully, Harry Potter and the Cursed Child. Uh, based on the popular 2005 novel by Rick Riordan, it is both overblown and underproduced, filled with sentiments it can't support and effects it can't pull off. Shows of this ilk, not just Lightning Thief, but also Be More Chill, School of Rock, and despite its terrific score, 13, normalize the idea that actually quite privileged youngsters are victims of social or parental neglect. They bellow their rebellion and catchy songs, they go on childish quests to claim their maturity.
The Lightning Thief doubles down on that agenda. Its final, an anthem called Bring on the Monsters, would be laughably banal if it were so aggressively false. The battle's just begun. The characters instruct the audience. What battle? The one with the parents who ponied up the big bucks to bring you to a show featuring flashlights and sock puppets? Better to count your blessings and find another fantasy.
[28:11] Brianna Jones: That's such a shitty diminishing review. Like, that is such a reason. I don't know, man. I gotta say, I agree with everything after that Dear Evan Hansen line.
[28:20] Andrew DeWolf: I disagree so much. I disagree about the specific framing of teenagers, because I don't think that's the message this is trying to say at all. I think even more so, I think he should have included Dear Evan Hansen in the genre that he was describing there. Because I think Dear Evan Hansen fits it perfectly. The idea that privileged young people are actually the victims. Like all of these shows are about people who discover that they're literally magic and like have more power than anyone else. But actually, you guys are really the victims who are like being oppressed by society if you think about it. You're a fucking demigod. Your dad is goddamn fucking Poseidon, the ruler of the world.
[29:03] Jesse McInally: Daddy wasn't there!
[29:04] Andrew DeWolf: Daddy's not there. I'm magic, but my daddy's not there. Oh my god, grow a pair.
[29:12] Brianna Jones: Jeez, I'm gonna do that. Oh my god, was that the amazing atheist that just showed up on this podcast with me?
[29:17] Andrew DeWolf: Hell yes.
[29:22] Jesse McInally: Jesus Christ. No, no, I think you're just trying to find reasons to agree with the Euro. My name's Harry Potter, and my stepparents are so mean, but also I'm able to do magic and I'm the chosen one, and everyone worships me at school, and I'm literally going to defeat an evil person and like probably become like a king or something in this world.
[29:43] Brianna Jones: Well, there's the kind of fine line these have to walk for young adult novels. Because you kind of want it to be a fantasy fulfillment where it's like, wouldn't it be cool if, but you also want to give these characters nuance and problems that you can at least understand? So that is the fine line that they walk.
[29:58] Andrew DeWolf: I think Harry Potter does it badly. I think this does it better. You know what does it really good? Spider-Man.
[30:08] Brianna Jones: Think about it. Spider-Man, Spider-Man does it a hundred times better than any of these ever have. And you know what? That didn't work as a musical either.
[30:17] Andrew DeWolf: It works better than this. I had more fun.
[30:19] Brianna Jones: Oh, you take that shit back.
[30:21] Andrew DeWolf: I had more fun. It was more fun to watch.
[30:23] Jesse McInally: You are a monster, Andrew DeWolf.
[30:26] Andrew DeWolf: No. I'm not taking it back. Spider-Man into the Into the Darkness was more fun.
[30:32] Brianna Jones: Jesus Christ. My god. Alright, we gotta move on to the next review. Bree, what we got to do?
[30:36] Brianna Jones: Dude, straight up, I did not have a good time watching this.
[30:39] Andrew DeWolf: You are a monster.
[30:42] Brianna Jones: I straight up was not having a fun time, bro. This is like ringing true of like early days of musical cheese where we like disagreed every week. Did you not enjoy your teenage years, Andrew?
[30:54] Andrew DeWolf: No, I actually didn't. No, I actually did not, not at all.
[30:58] Brianna Jones: Andrew, we shared our teenage years, and neither of us enjoyed it.
[31:02] Andrew DeWolf: No. All the media for teenagers is trash.
[31:07] Brianna Jones: At least now they've got Marvel.
[31:10] Andrew DeWolf: Which is like popcorn, but I enjoy popcorn. At least it's mildly better. I mean, they're still being trained to worship billionaires, but you know, it's whatever.
[31:19] Brianna Jones: I mean, Percy Jackson was middle class. He's not like a gazillionaire.
[31:21] Andrew DeWolf: Middle class in money, upper class in demigod status.
[31:28] Brianna Jones: Oh my god, that's like fucking god Zack Snyder behavior there. Mike.
[31:32] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, I mean, is being a demigod not great man theory? I mean, come on.
[31:37] Brianna Jones: Read this review before I strangle him through the computer, Brady.
[31:42] Jesse McInally: You got it, boss. Alright. Time's out. Raven Times Out, Raven Snook said of the 2017 off-Broadway run. The musical is best enjoyed by families with school-aged kids, especially those who devoured the book like my eleven-year-old. The seven cast members, though too mature to totally convince as angsty adolescents, are charismatic and energetic and handle the required quick character changes smoothly.
[32:14] Brianna Jones: Still, the action rarely flags thanks to Steven Baracetti's direction, Rob Rokicky's spirited songs, Trax Lucid's book, which is easy to follow even if you don't know the novel, and the smart avoidance of special effects in favor of lo-fi stagecraft, leaf blowers spew toilet paper to show Percy's ability to control water, Medusa's novelty glasses with illuminated eyes.
[32:47] Andrew DeWolf: What? What is going on here?
[32:54] Brianna Jones: What is going on on the stage? Um for tweet audiences, this Lightning Thief is liable to steal their parts.
[33:07] Andrew DeWolf: Every word every word. Yeah, they use leaf blowers and they shoot toilet paper into the audience and it like looks like water. Just just likes getting covered with toilet paper while being surrounded by 11-year-olds.
[33:25] Brianna Jones: Maybe I'm biased. Maybe I'm biased because I did see this live. I was kind of like in the zone. I really had a lot of fun watching this. Um and maybe if I just saw a bootleg like Andrew, I would feel a little less good about it. But I very much enjoyed it. I felt the cast knocked it out of the park. I feel like the stagecraft was fun and goofy in the right ways.
[33:47] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, yeah, it probably is more fun to see live. You probably don't nitpick it as much as I was when I was just watching it as a bootleg.
[33:57] Brianna Jones: I don't know. I'm not an 11-year-old, though. I'm not sure it's made for me.
[34:03] Andrew DeWolf: We just talked about Tangled last week, and you had more nice things to say about the hour-long Disney cruise line magic cruise line production.
[34:12] Brianna Jones: That was a better show. What do you want me to say?
[34:18] Andrew DeWolf: Tangled is better. It's more like fun to watch. Media for children is fantastic. Media for teenagers is garbage.
[34:27] Brianna Jones: Is there any media for teenagers that you think is actually good?
[34:35] Andrew DeWolf: That's a really tough question because I think the answer is no.
[34:39] Brianna Jones: Riverdale.
[34:40] Andrew DeWolf: I'm just kidding.
[34:41] Brianna Jones: Oh no! I mean no, no, no, no. Well, I mean, actually, though, like, what is what is made for teenagers? Like Harry Potter, this, Hunger Games, uh, Twilight, uh Riverdale. Like, all of these are things that I definitely do not enjoy in any way. Like, teenage media is just bad.
[35:05] Brianna Jones: Yeah, I might have to agree with you, Andrew. Because it's all very cringy. Because it's like they're at a weird age. They're trying to push like love and things like that. I don't know. But like love in like a very specifically non-sexual way as well. Or if it is sexual, it's like awkward sexual.
[35:26] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. It's like I don't know. It's just it's not good.
[35:31] Brianna Jones: Can I offer an alternative for like teen novels that I think worked?
[35:37] Andrew DeWolf: Sure.
[35:38] Brianna Jones: I think the Series of Unfortunate Events books worked really well.
[35:43] Andrew DeWolf: They are very different style style. I've not read those, but the movie was more fun to watch than most teenage driven movies.
[35:52] Brianna Jones: I don't know if that's accurate to the books, though. Would you consider it like for tweens and teens though?
[35:58] Andrew DeWolf: I always thought of that as like for kids though, to be honest.
[36:01] Brianna Jones: As did I. Like I read those books when I was a kid.
[36:04] Andrew DeWolf: What do you think these are made for? Like I imagine like pre-teens and teens.
[36:09] Brianna Jones: See, I would have still considered a kid. I don't know, like eight, nine, ten is when I probably read those.
[36:16] Andrew DeWolf: It's still kind of fun. I think Bree's right on this one.
[36:20] Brianna Jones: What I mean, what's the difference between a kid's book and a pre and a teen book? Teenagers are kind of weird and horny. Kids aren't. And what's the difference? Kids, you can just send characters on an adventure.
[36:34] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.
[36:34] Brianna Jones: Teenagers, you have to send them on an adventure with a love interest, and like most of it has to be about like finding yourself, like and stuff. And it's just like, you know, maybe we could just do an adventure. Like maybe they could just go on an adventure. You know, like that'd be fun. Like maybe we don't have to have like three scenes of the person talking about why did my mom never send me on a quest? Oh why have my mom not loved me? Why did my dad never be a part of my life? Like just go on an adventure. Like, okay, you're going to the underworld. Like, can we not just have fun with it? Like, come on.
[37:12] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know. Maybe they do that so like teens and tweens will reflect. I don't know. I'm trying to play devil's advocate here.
[37:18] Brianna Jones: I don't think you need to play devil's advocate. We have the devil in chat here.
[37:26] Andrew DeWolf: I do have to agree though, but the content is weird and it's not appealing. I mean, I think that a lot of adult content is just as cringe as T.
[37:39] Brianna Jones: Oh, absolutely. Absolutely. Adult content is also pretty consistently.
[37:49] Andrew DeWolf: But I think what Andrew is saying is that kids' content is typically good because it's just an adventure. Like you start one place and you end somewhere else, and it's not awkward or weird or sexual in any way. It's just fun. I think most of the really good adult content is also like just they go on an adventure, it's just more violent.
[38:12] Brianna Jones: Yeah. And then you have this teenage area where they're no longer allowed to just go on an adventure. They have to do all sorts of ridiculous self-loathing nonsense like all the time. You know what? Let's go into a mid-show announcement. And then we can talk about the songs.
[38:35] Andrew DeWolf: Hey guys, sorry to interrupt me in the middle of the show, but we've got a shill at you. Andrew, take it away.
[38:41] Andrew DeWolf: Oh man. Uh, you can donate to us on Patreon if you'd really like to, because we got extra content and stuff there too. I mean, you're gonna get something out of it. We're gonna get something out of it. It's a win-win.
[38:52] Brianna Jones: Is it really? Like, we can keep making the show. You're listening to the show, you probably like it.
[38:58] Andrew DeWolf: I'm liking it. I'm feeling good being mean again. It's been a while.
[39:01] Brianna Jones: It's been a while.
[39:02] Andrew DeWolf: It's been a while since Andrew's been openly antagonistic. It's been a long time.
[39:05] Brianna Jones: It's been probably about 50, 60 episodes, honestly.
[39:10] Andrew DeWolf: We're bringing it back. This is classic. This is honestly a classic musical cheese. And I'm hopping on the train to gang up on Jesse.
[39:18] Brianna Jones: Yeah. Yeah. This is what it used to be. I used to just berate Jess, and then the audience would be like, Jess was actually right the whole time. But it was really funny listening to you.
[39:29] Andrew DeWolf: Sorry, Jesse. That was our first 10 episodes. Like, yeah, Andrew was wrong, but I laughed my ass.
[39:38] Brianna Jones: So you know what? I'm anticipating everyone being like, You are making fun of this poor show. But you know what? It was fun. It was a blast. Our current patrons are Melissa Goldman, Terry Needleman, John Donna, Lighton Accles, Danielle Rennox, Jess the Stampede, Ewan Cassidy, Taskier, Fire September, Monica Thoreau, Mina Maneri, Brent Black, Haley Murray, B Way Flicks, Lithanial Stacey Coombe, Joseph Evans Green, Carrie Ahern, Christine Malmadel, more uh Mary Lou Choquette, John Vanels, Heck You, I go by Elijah now, Russ Walker, Musical Hell, Emily Gracie, Andrew Van Barsen, Tablam, Kyle Summers, Janae C, Christina Francis, Scoot and the Technicolor Dream Code, Liz Limb, Corey Wilmarth, Allison Stoller, nothing is certain except Beth and Taxes, John Van Ales, Thesbian, Ren Cohen, Wait in the Wings, Lady Malvolia, Spectacle Machine, Jacob Stroop, Raphael Martinez Sales, Robert Benjamin, Rachelle T, Jessica T, Genevieve Hartnett, Cass, Just Cass, uh Mitchell Young, Chai Teacup, Hayden Wilder, Katie McDono, uh Katie McDonough.
[40:45] Andrew DeWolf: Why do I keep doing why do I do that?
[40:47] Brianna Jones: Genkey Guys, Stacas, Timothy Keys, Jeffrey Machado, uh, Jacass, uh, Ten van Asen, uh, Jesse Taylor, and R. Elliot.
[40:58] Andrew DeWolf: My goodness. If you want to hear more times of Andrew pronouncing Jakus at Jacast, come join us over at Patreon.
[41:04] Brianna Jones: We got a lot of money.
[41:07] Andrew DeWolf: I'm sorry. If you want to hear Andrew mispronounce your name every week, it'll be fun to have you on Patreon, right?
[41:14] Brianna Jones: I pronounce the easy one wrongs when they're new. Like, my goodness.
[41:19] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, me and he was like, John Smith or something, and I'll mess it up, you know.
[41:27] Brianna Jones: Is this a Jean Smythe that we have here? Joan Smith?
[41:32] Andrew DeWolf: I think it's a French name. Uh also we have merch by our merch because you know that just helps the world go around.
[41:41] Brianna Jones: You got that stimulus check, spend it all on musicals with cheese merch.
[41:45] Andrew DeWolf: Absolutely. Alright, let's uh let's get back into the show.
[41:55] Brianna Jones: So if you think you are a half guy, better get headed to the exits now. This folks will think you lie in bed or running those are crying plus your monster chow. Stick around and maybe you'll learn from me. This ain't no JC, it's his Odyssey.
[42:14] Andrew DeWolf: So hear me out. It's yourself. But if nobody this is me, they never miss it. Nobody listens to me, they never listen, no hell.
[42:32] Brianna Jones: I don't have to be a hellfire. It's wrong.
[42:41] Andrew DeWolf: Let's talk about the first song, The Day I Got Expelled, which I think is a really good and effective way to get a lot of information across.
[42:48] Brianna Jones: Yeah. Um I think the beginning of this show is the best part. I think this like opening like story, like the storytelling and like kind of the framing is brilliant.
[43:01] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. I like that they um they have uh like the teacher there and they have uh Grover there already, you know. They got all that stuff, and then they kind of ease you in, but those characters stick around, you know.
[43:18] Brianna Jones: That's fun.
[43:20] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, and also the puppets, the puppets are great. It kind of shows you the stylistic choices, which is gonna be minimalist lo-fi puppetry and kind of like stage tricks rather than like grandiose, realistic looking uh Harry Potter the Cursed Child style animatronics and shit.
[43:36] Brianna Jones: Don't forget that they open it in in that way as well with that very cheap background that they rip apart at the very end.
[43:44] Andrew DeWolf: I love it. I love it, it's kind of grungy, Nickelodeon style, it's fun.
[43:48] Brianna Jones: Yeah, it almost made me think I might like it, and then I want you all to go and attack him on Twitter.
[43:59] Andrew DeWolf: I don't have my Twitter anymore for reasons I don't want to go into. But please just attack him and tell him how wrong he is.
[44:06] Brianna Jones: I think this opening reminds me of um uh that Andrew Jackson show that we did.
[44:12] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, Bloody Bloody Andrew Jackson.
[44:14] Brianna Jones: Yeah. And I I'm wondering if it's just because that there's a like a teacher in a wheelchair.
[44:21] Andrew DeWolf: Wasn't that an ancient wasn't that in Bloody Bloody Andrew Jackson?
[44:24] Brianna Jones: Yeah, there's just this random lady in a wheelchair that would come out randomly to like, ah history.
[44:28] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. I feel like that's the only reason it reminds me of that, but I guess the music style's not that different either.
[44:35] Brianna Jones: No, I feel like it's of the same ilk of kind of like edgy ish, but really the content here doesn't match the edge.
[44:43] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Well, they want it to.
[44:46] Brianna Jones: I like this opening. I think like the idea of like them setting up both like it sucks to be the son of a god, as well as Percy being like, I didn't ask for this, but here's how my day went.
[44:56] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Um I think this up to the Menotaur is the best part of the show. So I think his I Want song of strong is also very effective with him and his mom. I think that scene is like really emotionally like r valuable in a way that it doesn't really get that sincere again for the rest of the show.
[45:16] Brianna Jones: Nor should it, because it kind of is like an emotional through line and to show that connection and doesn't really need to pop up in any substantial way for the rest of it. It doesn't need that.
[45:25] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. I thought it was a bit strange that they had the mom and him sing that song and then immediately after kill the mother character, though. Um, it seemed a bit quick.
[45:36] Brianna Jones: It's pretty quick in the book as well.
[45:38] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. I feel like it would have a bit more impact if she stuck around for like a little bit.
[45:45] Brianna Jones: Yeah. Um, but then again, she'd be able to answer too many questions. We gotta kinda throw them out. Get rid of all the people that can answer specifics.
[45:52] Andrew DeWolf: I guess. She could just tell him who her f his father was, and that would be too easy. It's kind of weird that she doesn't just tell him to be honest.
[46:04] Brianna Jones: I want to talk about my favorite song in this show, which is probably where the lyrics and like the song is the most clever, and I think the jokes land the best, and that's the campfire song. Where they all the kids talk about who their parents are and how it affects them and why it it changed them and why it's it's like their angst like venting session.
[46:25] Andrew DeWolf: So my dad is some guide. That's great, I guess. Did he not want me and not want the stress? Too bad he's the worst, and my life is a mess.
[46:42] Brianna Jones: Oh no.
[46:43] Andrew DeWolf: Oh yeah, I hope he shows even a trace. Cause I've got some choice words to throw in his face.
[46:56] Brianna Jones: All things couldn't be worse when your parents run the universe.
[47:03] Andrew DeWolf: All things couldn't be worse. But I don't care where our parents may be, as long as you are here with me.
[47:14] Brianna Jones: We don't care where our parents may be, as long as you are here with me. As long as you are here with me!
[47:26] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like this was where I started really not liking it, actually.
[47:30] Brianna Jones: Really?
[47:31] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Um, I just really thought the whole concept of like them just singing about their parent and like why that they're upset about it and why it stinks for them. It's just so like so much pit like self-pity in a song, and I I just take it.
[47:51] Brianna Jones: But teenagers are that way. They'll find reasons to self-pity themselves. And what do they all have in common? They got a dad that abandoned them or a mom that abandoned them.
[48:01] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Self-pity's lame though, and like this is an entire song of it. And then it's kind of odd that they have Percy singiverse, even though they know that he doesn't even know who his parent is. It's like awkward for him.
[48:13] Brianna Jones: Well, it's kind of to show, like, as bad as they got it, he has it worse because at least they know who their parents are.
[48:20] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. And he is kind of like the least self-pitying out of all of them, because he's like, Oh, my dad was some guy and I don't know him, and I guess I never will. Whatever.
[48:22] Brianna Jones: I don't know.
[48:34] Andrew DeWolf: It's a character moment, Andrew. It's a moment. It's it's something. They they introduced a bunch of characters and they all sing.
[48:42] Brianna Jones: Uh yeah.
[48:45] Andrew DeWolf: That's what's a view of every musical ever. They introduced a bunch of characters. And they all sing.
[48:51] Brianna Jones: Well, I gotta go see it.
[48:56] Andrew DeWolf: That actually is what happens in this song, though, because they introduce a bunch of characters and most of them never show up again. Like they I like who's Isn't there like a daughter of Ares or something? And then there's like a I don't know, that the guy that's like the actual friend that betrays him who he like knows for like a day.
[49:17] Brianna Jones: Uh or something. I don't know.
[49:21] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. I think you just want to drink the hater aid.
[49:25] Brianna Jones: The hater aid is is fully devoured. I was drinking it all the way through the show.
[49:30] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. Let's talk about the angstiest song in the show, and probably like the worst balladie one.
[49:36] Brianna Jones: Sure. That's good kid, where Percy just like, I wanna be a good kid, um bad kid. That one.
[49:42] Andrew DeWolf: The same old story. The same old song. Don't act up, don't act out, be strong. I keep my head down, I keep my chin up, but it ends up all the same. With back your badge, you're always to play.
[50:04] Brianna Jones: I never try to do anything. I never mean to hurt anyone I try to try to be a good kid, a good kid, a good son. But no one ever will take my side. All I ever do is gave off. I swear I swear that I'm a good kid. Guess I'm good for nothing at all.
[50:31] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, no, this was where I'll relent to your point. Yes. Too angry. This one's pretty bad.
[50:38] Brianna Jones: Um, yeah, they should have just cut this song and just done killer quest instead.
[50:43] Andrew DeWolf: And just but I feel like you do need that dive into Percy's mind and how he thinks and how he functions. We don't really have that moment until now.
[50:51] Brianna Jones: Yeah, but do we wanna find this out? Do we wanna find out that this is what our main character is thinking?
[50:58] Andrew DeWolf: I think it's important to figure out what he's thinking.
[51:00] Brianna Jones: And I agree, maybe it's not this. But I have seen a lot of kids like really connect with this song.
[51:07] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Um, this is a bad one. I didn't like it.
[51:12] Brianna Jones: Oh my god, Andrew. You didn't like it either. Get out of here.
[51:19] Andrew DeWolf: I didn't hate it though. Killer Quest was probably the best song since the opening.
[51:26] Brianna Jones: I like Killer Quest a lot. It's a great act one closer.
[51:29] Andrew DeWolf: Oh bon boy, I shouldn't bear me well. You're gonna fight each foe, each person spell. We're gonna march straight down to the gates of hell. Underworld closing up. I'm finally gonna pass a test. We're going on a killer quest.
[51:47] Brianna Jones: Oh, don't forget this official camp half blood questing backpack. It comes pre-packed with everything you need. Gold dragmas, ambrosia squares, deodorant.
[51:57] Andrew DeWolf: This is like when they decided, like, oh wait, they're going on like a quest. It's supposed to be like fun.
[52:04] Brianna Jones: Right. Great, great summation there.
[52:07] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I just think it's like a real blast, and it kind of sets you up for like a lot of fun for act two in a way that I think a good act one closer should. It set ups the stakes, it set up the goal, and leaves you like, how we gonna succeed at this and when we come back.
[52:22] Brianna Jones: And then I also think the act one or act two opener is really good where they're lost in New York, like they're trying to get to LA. It's not safe to stay out here in the open when monsters are hoping to eat us alive. How do they know where we are when we don't even know? How are we gonna survive?
[52:39] Andrew DeWolf: It's your smell.
[52:39] Brianna Jones: I don't smell.
[52:40] Andrew DeWolf: Dude, like listen, please have bloods to monsters. Smell like Mickey D smell. Like tacos or take out Vietnamese. Hopefully they just ate Fantastic King.
[52:50] Brianna Jones: Well, I don't want to die in the garden state. Lost in the woods, somewhere in New Jersey, and we're never gonna make it to LA.
[52:57] Andrew DeWolf: We're lost in a start, and I think that's something, and I think it's coming this way.
[53:02] Brianna Jones: Yeah, how did they get to New York?
[53:06] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know where they start. Were they in Canada?
[53:08] Brianna Jones: Uh you know what? Actually, I don't know where they started. Like maybe they were in Canada.
[53:11] Andrew DeWolf: I'm about to say that like logically that makes sense, right? That tracks.
[53:15] Brianna Jones: Not really. I mean, New York is basically the furthest away you could possibly be from LA.
[53:24] Andrew DeWolf: It's weird that they don't just magic themselves there somehow.
[53:28] Brianna Jones: I like this because I like a good travel song.
[53:30] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, they do magic themselves there though, because Ares just kind of shows up and takes them there.
[53:35] Brianna Jones: Yeah.
[53:37] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I do like that little song moment. It's not like brilliant or anything, but I have a lot of fun watching it and them going through their different variations of oh that didn't work, and oh no, now that falling apart, and like their misfortune in trying just to get a ride to LA.
[53:53] Brianna Jones: I think it's a funny idea for Act Two opener.
[53:56] Andrew DeWolf: It is a little bit repetitive though.
[53:57] Brianna Jones: And uh if I remember it goes on quite a bit.
[53:59] Andrew DeWolf: It goes quite a bit, I will.
[54:01] Brianna Jones: But I enjoy it. I have fun.
[54:03] Andrew DeWolf: Sure. It's about the slapsticks and the chuckles, and especially if you're waiting for people to come sit down after taking their two poops.
[54:10] Brianna Jones: It's a good song if you like some goofs and gaffes and some laughs.
[54:15] Andrew DeWolf: You know? And which is what you like?
[54:18] Brianna Jones: Don't frame that like a bad thing, you motherfucker.
[54:22] Andrew DeWolf: Um, it's too long. It's repetitive, it's garbage.
[54:25] Brianna Jones: Uh your girlfriend's review of your sex, too.
[54:28] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, let's move on to Dead on Arrival, DOA.
[54:31] Brianna Jones: If only the souls of the newly deceived.
[54:36] Andrew DeWolf: I gotta swing.
[54:38] Brianna Jones: It was newly loose in the dead complain that just turn up the scary old way.
[54:49] Andrew DeWolf: We get our kings cross the reality!
[54:53] Brianna Jones: It's a permanent trip.
[54:54] Andrew DeWolf: So the final trips.
[54:57] Brianna Jones: Gentlemen, it's Hades who runs the show.
[55:02] Andrew DeWolf: Oh look! It's the Vienna Boys Choir.
[55:03] Brianna Jones: They crashed their bus on the way to sing for the Vatican.
[55:07] Andrew DeWolf: They're kids. They're lucky. Their voices will never change now.
[55:25] Brianna Jones: I love this song. This song is fun. I think uh what they do with this song is a lot more interesting than what they did with any of the other like villain set piece songs.
[55:37] Andrew DeWolf: I agree with you there. I think this is the best villain set piece moment in the entire thing. I feel like a lot of the times when they introduce folks like that, it kind of falls flat.
[55:46] Brianna Jones: Yeah.
[55:46] Andrew DeWolf: Um I was expecting them to do a bit more with like Hades and stuff, but they just he's only here for one scene. Um, and I feel like uh Karen kind of just straight up outshines him in like every way.
[56:01] Brianna Jones: So you know, I think the song is this is a good moment though. It's it's good.
[56:07] Andrew DeWolf: I think that this is just like the most fun moment, and it kind of like gets your adrenaline going, because even I was kind of losing steam halfway through act two, and this just kind of got me up to the end.
[56:17] Brianna Jones: Yeah.
[56:18] Andrew DeWolf: Um I don't have much negative or positive to say for any of the rest of the song.
[56:22] Brianna Jones: Bring on the monsters.
[56:24] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it's a little cringe, but fuck it. It's an end song. I I I I enjoyed it. They're gonna shoot water like toilet paper at me. It's a lot of fun. Come on.
[56:31] Brianna Jones: Justice loves being covered with wet toilet paper.
[56:34] Andrew DeWolf: It's not wet, it's strong.
[56:38] Brianna Jones: Just water toilet paper is literally what you said though.
[56:48] Andrew DeWolf: It's meant to represent water.
[56:52] Brianna Jones: Okay.
[56:53] Andrew DeWolf: I'm dumb being mean.
[56:54] Brianna Jones: Okay.
[56:54] Andrew DeWolf: The meanness is done.
[56:56] Brianna Jones: Fair enough. I we finished the classic uh musical cheese episode.
[57:01] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, that was uh that was a revival of the original tone of Musicals with Cheese.
[57:05] Brianna Jones: Yeah, can we um can you can you give me like the uh nostalgia critic The Wall ending here? So you just ask me how I thought of it so I can just say, oh, it was fine. A lot of creativity.
[57:15] Andrew DeWolf: But what did you really think of it?
[57:17] Brianna Jones: Oh, it was fine, you know. Uh a little folded itself, but there was a lot of creativity.
[57:22] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, yeah, that's fair.
[57:25] Brianna Jones: So Andrew, what was your overall thoughts on Percy Jackson, the lightning thief, the musical, and your cheese rating.
[57:32] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, okay. Um, did I make myself clear?
[57:36] Brianna Jones: Uh no, I feel like you didn't really express yourself this episode, honestly. I feel like you could have like been more honest.
[57:42] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, okay. Let me be a little more honest. Um, I didn't enjoy it. I I don't I don't like what they did. I didn't think it was good. Um I don't know how else to say that.
[57:59] Brianna Jones: This is why negative media criticism sucks, because this like the whole episode, I'm just like, what else do I say? I just I didn't like it.
[58:06] Andrew DeWolf: Wait to look like Vegas!
[58:10] Brianna Jones: Uh Toilet paper has water!
[58:13] Andrew DeWolf: What?
[58:16] Brianna Jones: Yeah, I don't know. It was That's not how the Greek gods actually were tiny gods be happy Okay What are you bitching about so much teen?
[58:32] Andrew DeWolf: You know what Jess has nailed my review. Um yeah no I'm Andrew DeWolf.
[58:40] Brianna Jones: I remember it because it's a lightning thief.
[58:43] Andrew DeWolf: I remember it because I watched it yesterday. Have you ever watched something I was so full of teen angst that you just didn't want to know it?
[58:53] Brianna Jones: You do like a really good impression of Doug Walker, it's like incredible.
[59:00] Andrew DeWolf: Are you sure you're not from Chicago?
[59:05] Brianna Jones: What's your cheese rate?
[59:08] Andrew DeWolf: Um Oh my goodness. Uh does this deserve like a good cheese? Um I don't want to get too creative with this one because I feel like they didn't do very much, so I'm gonna give it feta cheese because that was the first cheese that comes up if you look up Greek cheese.
[59:27] Brianna Jones: So there you go.
[59:28] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, that's fine. Um Bree, what'd you think of our discussion and your cheese rating on that?
[59:33] Brianna Jones: I'm tired. I have never been on an episode where you guys were at the opposite ends of the spectrum here.
[59:40] Andrew DeWolf: And really?
[59:41] Brianna Jones: Yeah, like you guys have never I mean I've missed a couple episodes since I started, but um I don't think we've disagreed very hard on anything lately.
[59:51] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, no, you haven't. So I'm a little tired and worn out from that. Um I don't know how to feel about this.
[59:57] Brianna Jones: Uh Andrew hated it.
[59:59] Andrew DeWolf: And Jesse, you loved it.
[1:00:02] Brianna Jones: I didn't say I loved it, I just liked it.
[1:00:03] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, well you liked it. That's but Andrew really hated it.
[1:00:09] Brianna Jones: So um I don't know how to feel. So I'm just gonna give it a piece of um little Caesar's Pizza, because that makes sense.
[1:00:29] Andrew DeWolf: Oh my god. Percy Jackson has stolen Jupiter's lightning. It's over.
[1:00:41] Brianna Jones: Um that's a great, great choice break.
[1:00:48] Jesse McInally: Um I am going I like the show. It was a lot of fun to watch. I enjoyed it while it was happening. It's not gonna change the world, but I saw that it has affected a lot of teenagers and I've seen them connect with it, and I understand why.
[1:00:59] Andrew DeWolf: I don't really want to yuck their yum because I don't have any strong emotions. I could just rip this apart if I was like, you know, a cynical asshole, but I don't really want to be that guy.
[1:01:03] Brianna Jones: Cynical asshole.
[1:01:10] Andrew DeWolf: Sometimes you have to be a cynical asshole, you know?
[1:01:13] Brianna Jones: No, you don't. You know, you don't always have to do that. All of the teenagers that enjoy this right now, they're gonna grow up and become cynical assholes.
[1:01:21] Andrew DeWolf: So I'm allowed to hate their media too.
[1:01:27] Brianna Jones: You know what? That's fair, Andrew. And I say, Andrew, you should open up your DMs and let everyone just let you know exactly the reason how they feel about it.
[1:01:37] Andrew DeWolf: Are my DMs not open?
[1:01:39] Brianna Jones: They should be, honestly. I feel like I I feel like I just never get into it. I feel like most people just don't know your Twitter exists.
[1:01:45] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[1:01:45] Brianna Jones: Same with Bree. They don't know your Twitters exist.
[1:01:48] Andrew DeWolf: That's because they don't tweet.
[1:01:49] Brianna Jones: Because you're probably a healthier human being than I.
[1:01:52] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I don't check social media a lot. Except if unless it's TikTok. Then I spend lots of hours there.
[1:01:58] Brianna Jones: Yeah, that's the new one. Um, but my cheese rating is apparently Medusa's favorite type of cheese.
[1:02:04] Jesse McInally: Gorgonzola.
[1:02:05] Brianna Jones: Because I get it.
[1:02:07] Andrew DeWolf: You get it?
[1:02:08] Brianna Jones: Do I have to explain it?
[1:02:09] Andrew DeWolf: No, you don't have to explain it.
[1:02:10] Brianna Jones: Medusa is a Gorgon.
[1:02:12] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, okay. I get it. Um I don't think they ever used I don't think they ever used that term in uh The Lightning Thief, though.
[1:02:20] Brianna Jones: They didn't. Because um, because the show barely gives a shit about Greek mythology and hardly uses anything from it.
[1:02:33] Andrew DeWolf: You know, why even make it about the she's making her own characters?
[1:02:36] Brianna Jones: You know what? All I have to say is uh if they didn't do my boy Dionysus so dirty, I would have loved this show.
[1:02:43] Andrew DeWolf: This was literally episode. This was a spite episode.
[1:02:47] Brianna Jones: That's right.
[1:02:48] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, no one could tell just from your tone up throughout that you had a lot of spite in your heart during this.
[1:02:57] Jesse McInally: Oh, right.
[1:02:57] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. Well, you know who definitely isn't full of spite? Not me. Our wonderful patrons.
[1:03:04] Brianna Jones: She said it!
[1:03:05] Andrew DeWolf: Alright. Thank you guys for listening. We're on iTunes, Spotify, Stitcher at Musicals with Cheese. We're on Twitter at Cheesy Musicals, Patreon Musical Cheese, Instagram Musicals with Cheese, YouTube page musicals with cheese.
[1:03:13] Brianna Jones: We have a Patreon only podcast, Gallivants with Cheese. Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com to tell us how wrong Andrew is, because of course he is.
[1:03:20] Jesse McInally: Title card created by Jolene Casco. Go send her some love on Instagram at Jolene Casco. Our keeper of the cheese is Juliet Antonio. Thank you for keeping up with all our cheese ratings. We love you to death, Juliet.
[1:03:30] Andrew DeWolf: Our show is produced by the incredible, the wonderful, the girl that's always got my back is Mariana Jones.
[1:03:38] Jesse McInally: I love you so much, Bree. You're the best. Thank you to the Broadway Podcast Network for having us on your platform and for not kicking us off yet, but now we will because Andrew's talking shit about the Lightning Thief.
[1:03:49] Andrew DeWolf: America's favorite musical.
[1:03:51] Brianna Jones: America's only musical.
[1:03:53] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[1:03:55] Jesse McInally: 2020's only musical, but still not good enough to get the Tony nomination.
[1:04:00] Andrew DeWolf: It deserved the nomination. I feel like even you have to admit it deserved the nomination as the only musical that came out.
[1:04:07] Jesse McInally: Yeah, I mean, I I'll admit that. They should have at least nominated it.
[1:04:10] Andrew DeWolf: I don't think they should have won.
[1:04:14] Brianna Jones: Andrew didn't think.
[1:04:21] Andrew DeWolf: Then they just didn't pick it.
[1:04:23] Jesse McInally: Yep.
[1:04:24] Andrew DeWolf: I somehow feel like that's what I'm talking about.
[1:04:26] Brianna Jones: I mean what actually won.
[1:04:28] Andrew DeWolf: What actually won?
[1:04:29] Brianna Jones: It has the Tonies haven't happened yet, Andrew.
[1:04:32] Andrew DeWolf: Somehow the 2020 Tonies still haven't happened yet.
[1:04:35] Brianna Jones: Oh, okay. Well, maybe it will win then.
[1:04:37] Andrew DeWolf: It's on the nominations are up, but the rewards still haven't happened.
[1:04:44] Brianna Jones: They can't pick.
[1:04:45] Andrew DeWolf: They said it was supposed to happen in October.
[1:04:48] Brianna Jones: October was a long time ago, guys.
[1:04:51] Andrew DeWolf: To be fair, I would rather not get nominated for something instead of get nominated for something and be the only thing that got nominated for something and not win.
[1:05:02] Brianna Jones: I mean, Aaron Tveit is the only one nominated for best actor in a musical.
[1:05:08] Andrew DeWolf: And maybe that'll be him. He gets nominated and still doesn't get it.
[1:05:12] Brianna Jones: Actually, technically, that's still it, because the Tony Award still hasn't happened.
[1:05:16] Andrew DeWolf: No, he's they're not even gonna give him the satisfaction of losing. They're just not gonna do it.
[1:05:22] Brianna Jones: We're just gonna skip over the 2020 Tonies. If you got nominated, good for you. You'll always be a Tony nominee.
[1:05:26] Andrew DeWolf: You'll always be a nominee.
[1:05:27] Brianna Jones: You're not gonna be a winner, though.
[1:05:29] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[1:05:32] Brianna Jones: Alright, you guys. Anything else you want to say?
[1:05:39] Andrew DeWolf: Love you guys.
[1:05:45] Brianna Jones: Jesse does not want to hear that right now.
[1:05:47] Andrew DeWolf: He does not feel loved by you, Andrew.
[1:05:50] Jesse McInally: I really don't.
[1:05:52] Andrew DeWolf: It was fine. A lot of creativity.
[1:05:54] Brianna Jones: What a fool of itself. Very intuitive.
[1:05:58] Andrew DeWolf: Like that.
[1:06:02] Jesse McInally: I like how you're putting this on the same level as The Wall.
[1:06:05] Andrew DeWolf: I agree with you that this is your artistic equal of Pink Floyd's The Wall.
[1:06:09] Jesse McInally: No, no, this is the artistic equal of Doug Walker's The Wall.
[1:06:18] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, we'll see you next time on Musicals with Cheese.
[1:06:28] Brianna Jones: I didn't want to be a half-blood!
[1:06:31] Andrew DeWolf: I didn't ask to be a hero seeking place.
[1:06:33] Brianna Jones: I didn't have a half-blood s that's the song, right?
[1:06:37] Andrew DeWolf: I think that's that's Yeah.
[1:06:39] Brianna Jones: That was so good, dude.
[1:06:42] Andrew DeWolf: I could be like a teen angsty rock star.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
