"I'm on my way!" Grab your M&M's and your Card Deck because this week we're joined by the incredible Pearl Rhein to talk about Violet! We talk about Jeanine Tesori's incredible instrumentation, the specific stage choices, and how to represent "sad dads." You're going to love this!.. Read More
From the show: Musicals with Cheese
Guests
About
"I'm on my way!" Grab your M&M's and your Card Deck because this week we're joined by the incredible Pearl Rhein to talk about Violet! We talk about Jeanine Tesori's incredible instrumentation, the specific stage choices, and how to represent "sad dads." You're going to love this!
Donate to Black Lives Matter here
Social Media:
Musicals with Cheese on Twitter
Musicals W/ Cheese on Instagram
Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com
Jess Socials
Andrew Socials
Brianna Socials
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:06] Jess McEnally: Hello, I'm Jess McEnaly.
[0:08] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm Andrew DeWolf.
[0:10] Brianna Jones: And I'm Brianna Jones.
[0:11] Jess McEnally: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, a podcast where I try to get Andrew and Brianna to like musical theater. And today we have an extra special guest.
[0:15] Andrew DeWolf: I am so flipping excited!
[0:17] Brianna Jones: Specialist guest!
[0:19] Jess McEnally: I'm always, it's always a special guest, but today it's a super special guest.
[0:24] Andrew DeWolf: I'm prompt!
[0:25] Jess McEnally: It's true.
[0:26] Andrew DeWolf: You win, you win.
[0:28] Jess McEnally: Specialist! Um, this week we are lucky enough to be joined by composer, lyricist, um, actress, multi-instrumentalist, Pearl Rhein.
[0:39] Pearl Rhein: Let's go!
[0:43] Jess McEnally: And the applause! Streamers, explosions, fireworks. Let's go! Thank you. Pearl, thank you for joining us.
[0:48] Pearl Rhein: Thank you so much. I need to add like five more "ist" words to my credit, I think, just to make it as much.
[0:59] Jess McEnally: How many can we add on to it?
[1:03] Pearl Rhein: Socialist!
[1:04] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.
[1:05] Brianna Jones: Ooh.
[1:06] Jess McEnally: Oh, that's the bicist.
[1:07] Pearl Rhein: Oh yeah.
[1:09] Jess McEnally: Um, so glad to have you here today. And you're actually the one that decided what we're talking about today. So what are we talking about today, Pearl?
[1:16] Pearl Rhein: We're talking about one of my favorite musicals, Violet.
[1:21] Jess McEnally: Ah, cue the music, Brie!
[1:25] Pearl Rhein: Before another sunrise wakes me, before another night is gone, I'll find on my other highway takes me, let my troubles all behind me. Back there when I climbed on the wall, Jordan Rivers where you'll find me.
[1:51] Pearl Rhein: Violet is a musical with music by Jeanine Tesori's and lyrics and book by Brian Crawley, based on The Ugliest Pilgrim by Doris Betts. It premiered at the Eugene O'Neill Theater at the National Music Theater Conference in 1994. It premiered off-Broadway at Playwright's Horizons on March 11, 1997, and closed April 6th, 1997. It opened on Broadway for its revival at the American Airlines Theater in a Roundabout Theater Company production on March 28, 2014, in previews, and officially opened on April 20th, 2014, with Sutton Foster starring as Violet.
[2:33] Pearl Rhein: And the plot of the story is Violet tells the story of a young woman's quest for beauty amidst the image-obsessed landscape of the 1960s. Facially disfigured as a child in an accident, Violet dreams of a miraculous transformation through the power of faith. Convinced that a televangelist in Oklahoma can heal her, she hops on a Greyhound bus and starts the journey of a lifetime.
[2:53] Jess McEnally: Alright, all that's out of the way.
[2:57] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, that's it.
[2:59] Jess McEnally: Y'all get the gist. Um, we got it.
[3:01] Brianna Jones: We got it, Jess.
[3:02] Jess McEnally: You got it. You understand what Violet is about? You know who was behind it. And now we never have to bring it up again, is the best part. Like, podcast over.
[3:09] Andrew DeWolf: That was fun.
[3:11] Jess McEnally: Yeah, yeah. Great episode, everybody. See you next week.
[3:22] Jess McEnally: Um, Pearl, when did you first like get into Violet?
[3:26] Pearl Rhein: Okay, so I went to college in Muncie, Indiana. I went to Ball State, and I was an acting student, not in musical theater. Um, but I play a bunch of instruments and piano is one of them. And so when I was either a freshman or a sophomore, I was young in college. One of the cool seniors was going to do a senior directed project, and it was Violet, and he asked if I would music direct. And I don't, I do not music direct. I've done like, I think in my, I've done four shows. I've music directed four shows, two productions of Children of Eden, um, a new brand and Violet. Those are my, I could not think of three more different shows.
[4:07] Andrew DeWolf: Right.
[4:08] Pearl Rhein: Uh, and I so, but I just, I didn't have anything else to do. And I had never heard of it because I went to college in the early 2000s, so like you theater was still like you gotta go and buy the cast album at Barnes and Noble. You gotta hope somebody has the vocal selections. Um, that was my introduction to the show, and I learned it and had a real blast teaching it and playing. Um, I played piano for the whole show, except for there was one. I was listening to it today and trying to remember there was one number where, um, it might have been like the fight, like there's a fight on stage, and I switched to fiddle and played fiddle for that one number. But when you have like three people in your band, the pianist pretty much has to always be playing the keys.
So it just, we just randomly had fiddle for one song. And that was so I, I just, that became one of my absolute favorite musicals, um, especially cast recordings, and so like I know the cast recording of the off-Broadway production really intimately. Uh, and then I saw it on Broadway when Sutton Foster did it, and that was, I guess, the first time I got to see it staged. I just think it's great.
[5:28] Jess McEnally: What'd you think of the revival compared to like the original cast album as well as your moments in the pit?
[5:28] Pearl Rhein: I thought it was really good. I think the show lends itself to a stripped down staging so well to this kind of like bare bones, same costume the whole time, not a lot of bells and whistles performance. Um, Sutton is such a strong actor, and like really what you need for that role. And I know that she was, I think there was a little bit of like Sutton Foster doing Violet, and she inhabited that role so beautifully, it was so moving. And um, Josh Henry singing "Let It Sing" is still like one of the most time-stopping performances that I've ever gotten to see in a show. I can't, I was, I went with my husband and a friend, and uh, who was my husband at the time, and the, and Josh Henry finished singing "Let It Sing," and the audience applauded and it was one of those like two full minutes of applause, and you could tell you could watch the actors being like, this always happens, we have to wait for a long time. And we just looked at each other like it was just such an incredible performance.
[6:45] Jess McEnally: I mean, of course, um, that's incredible. Um, I've only dove into Violet recently, um, within the last two years, um, and mostly only have the revival as my framework for what it is. From what I gather from the two albums, there's like subtle differences, but not much there. They didn't really restructure the show.
[7:05] Pearl Rhein: It's not like, uh, really intense.
[7:07] Jess McEnally: Yeah, I don't think so. There's one, I think there's one song swap out. Um, that the character Montgomery, they replaced, I'm still so much more familiar with the off-Broadway recording, but they replaced one of his songs in the second act, I believe. But other than that, I, I, it felt pretty close to what I remembered from doing the show, uh, structure-wise. Oh, and another, uh, another connection with that original recording, uh, was I did Memphis, uh, the musical when it was at, uh, the La Jolla Playhouse. I was in grad school at UCSD, and I was in, uh, that's like two legs before it hit Broadway. I did not go to Broadway with Memphis, but um, at the table read, it was like my first big professional musical.
Um, Cass Morgan, uh, like a Broadway musical theater stalwart, she's an incredible lady. She opened her mouth and I heard, you know how you like those line readings from cast albums get like ingrained in your DNA? And I heard her voice and I, and I was like, oh my god, because I could hear her saying, "I'm rat tired of children" from the off-Broadway cast recording because she was in the original off-Broadway cast of Violet. Um, and she became a friend and still is, and that was a very exciting experience.
[8:40] Jess McEnally: That's beautiful. That's such, that's such a great journey to go on with both that show and like how it all connects together. It's incredible, incredible. And that just shows how small this, this industry and this world altogether really is.
[8:53] Pearl Rhein: Oh, yeah. Everybody seems to know everybody.
[8:56] Jess McEnally: Yes, and they all seem very, very nice, which is the best part of all.
[9:00] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.
[9:02] Jess McEnally: But Andrew, I forced you to watch this literally yesterday. He dove into the album and sadly enough watched away because Broadway doesn't exist at the moment.
[9:11] Andrew DeWolf: I have no shame. That's my favorite thing to watch while I lift weights.
[9:16] Jess McEnally: Yo, I'm curious as I didn't really get to talk with him about what he thinks of this show yet. So what on first watch, Andrew, what'd you think?
[9:28] Andrew DeWolf: I had no idea what to think of it going in, but honestly, I thought it was pretty strong, and I'm surprised I haven't heard of it at all. Because this seems like a relatively recent show, and it just, I've never heard of this show. Um, what it reminded me of a bit was, uh, that Steve Martin show we did, Musical Star, but like better than that, but like much better. So I'm surprised I haven't heard of it, because I think it deserves a bit more recognition. Uh, unless I'm out of the loop, of course.
[9:58] Jess McEnally: I mean, let's talk about the composer Jeanine Tesori's, because we've covered a lot of her work and recently too. Um, we've covered her other collaboration with Sutton Foster, which was Thoroughly Modern Millie. We had opinions on that and how that has and has not aged well in many different ways. Um, we covered Caroline, or Change. Um, we covered Fun Home, and all of them are, are strangely so big of shows in their own specific and of course Shrek the Musical. We can't forget that one. Um, such big shows, like big intense shows that both changed the landscape or like started something rolling that is still feeling to this day that sadly enough, Violet kind of gets lost in the shadow of the greats, and you kind of forget how great Violet is.
[10:43] Pearl Rhein: Yeah.
[10:43] Andrew DeWolf: And it was her first, right?
[10:45] Pearl Rhein: I believe it was her.
[10:47] Andrew DeWolf: Her first, like big one, yeah.
[10:48] Pearl Rhein: Yeah. And if for someone's first show to like really like strike, this is, this is really good. And I think it might even be like my second or third favorite of her work so far.
[10:58] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. I think it's like there's not a lot going on plot-wise, but it feels like they make up for that with some very good character songs and like just a small number of characters, but they are all interesting. So you care about what's going on. Um, you know, and it's a little bit sad watching the whole thing, because I mean it's basically about a woman getting scammed by a preacher. But you know, it's, she still learns something from it, and you feel like it's a happy ending.
[11:29] Jess McEnally: I don't know. And it uses theatrical convention in a way that many smaller musicals feel and smaller plays altogether feel they don't need to do because of how small they are. Like this has like the magical mysticism and the idea of traveling back and forth and talking to past versions of yourself, interacting with past versions of yourself, and all these things you can only do on stage that a lot of like other smaller slice of life musicals are like, well, we want it to be real, so we don't need that. Just put them on the rules.
[12:05] Pearl Rhein: And I appreciate that in all of Tesori's other like kind of slice of life musicals as well.
[12:11] Jess McEnally: Um, you did bring up something that I want to talk to Pearl about, um, specifically about the deformity and how it's portrayed on stage and whether, how it's not portrayed on stage.
[12:23] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I found it a bit interesting. They kept talking about how she has this deformity and scar, and I'm like looking at the screen, like, uh, does she? Um, so I don't, it doesn't seem like they used any makeup, or at least not in the version I've watched.
[12:38] Pearl Rhein: Um, yeah, I think that's, that's the tradition. I, the, I know that's how the off-Broadway and the Broadway production were done, and yes. When I MD'd it, that's how it was done. And yes, I don't, I don't know that I've ever heard of a production using makeup or prosthetics. Um, I would, I've never heard a person with facial difference speak to what it's like to watch that, so I don't, I feel like it could be possible that that would be no fun if you had facial difference and you, what you're watching an entire show about somebody's experience of that who doesn't have that. But I, uh, mostly I think it's a smart theatrical choice because then you leave it up to the imagination, and it's probably easier to perform as well.
[13:23] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[13:24] Pearl Rhein: And I feel like what, as soon as you start doing prosthetics, then it's about prosthetics, and it's about like, well, what is the extent of the deformity? And uh, yeah, I feel, I feel like not doing it kind of fits with the theatricality of the rest of the show. And I can see an argument. Um, I just envision like the Gerard Butler Phantom of the Opera deformity where people are like, well, that ain't that bad, or it's like, that's too bad. Like you start making comparisons and it's all about how she looks as opposed to the form. She doesn't really look that bad. This whole show is ridiculous. It's like, well, that's not really what it's about.
[14:01] Andrew DeWolf: Right.
[14:03] Pearl Rhein: Um, yeah, I can see that. It also changes the ending, how you would see the ending. Because you technically you don't know if she, uh, like just feels like she got better or if she actually did, because she goes to the preacher and thinks that he healed the scar.
[14:18] Andrew DeWolf: Right.
[14:19] Pearl Rhein: You know? So without actual prosthetic there, the audience can kind of interpret that either way until another character shows up at least.
[14:26] Andrew DeWolf: That's a really good point, yeah.
[14:29] Pearl Rhein: So I can I can I feel like I remember audience response to like the first time that she but Violet says to another character, says something that indicates that she thinks maybe it has changed, but the character responds that it hasn't, like I think there's a there's a line about a mirror and a woman and woman's like, you could use some powder or something.
[14:50] Pearl Rhein: And I I can remember the audience being like I do want to take a moment to talk about Violet as a character, um, because she is an oxymoron in so many ways.
[15:04] Pearl Rhein: Like there's so many contradictory things about her. Like she does kind of have this self-pity, but she is also very stubborn and strong. Um, she like is like a very like reflective about how she looks, but is very quick to insult other people about how they look. Like she's a very like crass and defensive organism, it seems, but yeah. She's very defensive, but then again, she's also super naive and she's falling right into this televangelist's hands. So like every single thing about her just like contradicts herself, which makes it feel even more real. Is this like totally one of my life?
[15:44] Jess McEnally: Yeah.
[15:45] Pearl Rhein: One of my favorite things about her as a character is her sexual agency and the fact that sex isn't a huge deal to her. And I that feels really special in a musical, too, because musical theater can exist in this like really puritanical world where either sex doesn't exist at all or like it's a really big deal and it like has huge emotional ramifications, and I just love that it's like a thing she does in her life and it is not the end all be all, and when she has sex with somebody, it's not the it's not like a first time, and then that doesn't end up being the guy she's with, and that everybody's okay with that. That feels extremely radical in musical theater, unfortunately.
[16:29] Pearl Rhein: And the most radical thing about it, too, for me is this person that thinks herself so ugly and like all this. It's not she doesn't get any like physical gratification from sex, like that is not gratifier, like oh, I guess I am pretty 'cause someone wants me. No, it's herself that finds herself like unattractive. And she like gets out in front of rejection and because that's that is such a way that people handle the fear of rejection of like I'm gonna I'm just gonna be in control of everything, and I'm gonna always do the rejecting.
[16:59] Jess McEnally: Yeah.
[17:00] Pearl Rhein: It's a great, great show. And I want to talk about the relationship with her father and the flashbacks to her as a child, which I think this is my favorite part of the show. It's the best part, especially um, I believe her name is Emerson Steele, who plays the young girl on the 2014 revival. My god, that is a star.
[17:23] Jess McEnally: Yeah, whatever. I'm a big fan of sad dads, so you know, this is a great show for me.
[17:29] Pearl Rhein: Um Alexander Gipnani. Um he deserves the career um growth that Alex Brightman is currently having. I think like he should just take off right now. Anything he is just he's incredible.
[17:43] Jess McEnally: Yeah, the I feel like it's such good use of flashback and of that bifurcated character where you see them at different ages. Because that can feel really academic in musical theater. That can just feel like you had an idea. Well, we're here again. And this just feels it feels so dramatically important and so revealing. And then when you realize you're kind of building up to actually seeing the incident, it though there's like such a sense of dread, and it's gonna be and it's gonna be so hard and scary for everybody.
[18:22] Pearl Rhein: I'm with you with sad things. We've gotta spoil, we gotta spoil some stuff really quick.
[18:26] Jess McEnally: Oh, yes.
[18:27] Pearl Rhein: Um spoilers. Um if you haven't seen Violet, um, as soon as the theaters reopen, go see Violet. I I feel like we've been very positive up to this point. You know we love this show. Somebody do Violet. But yes, I'm available. We've gotta do, we gotta do spoilers real quick.
[18:42] Pearl Rhein: Um, so Violet was not born with like a facial defect or anything like that. She has a physical scar because her father was like chopping wood or something like that, and she walked in and the axe somehow hit her face, or the axe head came off, is how I explained. Yeah, there's like there's a thing that holds the axe head onto the handle. What's his line? He's uh I didn't I didn't drop the axe. The something wasn't I don't check it every time. And then she's like, I bet you check it now. But yeah, like a pin came loose, and so the axe head flew off the handle. And that wasn't just the be all end all of her deformity. It's the fact that he ran her to a doctor, and the doctor was like the local city doctor who's also a drunk that did not do it well.
[19:26] Jess McEnally: Oh, I forgot about that.
[19:28] Pearl Rhein: Yes. Um it's like one thing on top of another on top of another, and then it takes five years of it being healed incorrectly and before she can even go see a real professional about it. It it's like one thing atop the other, and she just blames her dad for this, who up to this point we see being a rough and tumble farm dad, but not a bad father.
[19:50] Jess McEnally: Yeah, and I I think I don't think he is a bad father necessarily. Um I don't think that's the point. I think really the the emphasis of the show is that a she has to forgive him because he's dead at this point. And you know, the the climax is she confronts him spiritually and forgives him essentially. Um at least that's how I interpret it.
[20:11] Pearl Rhein: So just like contact.
[20:12] Jess McEnally: Yeah.
[20:13] Pearl Rhein: She closes all of her baggage, which then l as um oh, I forget. Yeah, it makes her feel healed, and even Flick is like, something's different about you where you can finally move on and live your life.
[20:28] Jess McEnally: Yeah.
[20:29] Pearl Rhein: With me because I'm Josh Henry and I'm beautiful.
[20:37] Jess McEnally: Yeah, that's a it's a perfectly fine interpretation, I think. I mean, that's that is how it ends. And it is nice, it's nice to give her such a happy ending. And like I I d I do think it glosses over a little bit like beauty isn't everything, beauty's on the inside, yes. But the world is really shitty if you're different. And and I and I I feel like it's it's a little bit too aspirational in like all you have to do is feel different because she's still a woman with facial difference in the South in the 60s, and that's probably He's still a black man in the South in the 60s, which is they're both in a very bad situation. They just still have it end with that kind of asshole type guy, though, that wants to use her essentially, uh, like still trying to, and she turns him down. So it's not as though they completely throw that out the window that the world is still shit.
[21:37] Pearl Rhein: I think I love it on Monty, please.
[21:39] Jess McEnally: Oh yeah.
[21:41] Pearl Rhein: Um my god, that character. Do you guys swear in this?
[21:45] Jess McEnally: Oh, yeah, absolutely.
[21:47] Pearl Rhein: Monty is like the the OG musical theater fuck boy.
[21:52] Jess McEnally: I don't know about the OG. I mean, we've we've seen Billy Bigelow.
[21:56] Pearl Rhein: Oh my god. Speaking of speaking of Josh Henry performances, no, you're totally right. You're totally right. He he takes all of the cakes. I don't think there's uh a bigger definition of fuck boy than Billy Bigelow. I'm gonna come back from the dead just to hit my daughter.
[22:16] Jess McEnally: I just I had to, but it's okay to go to heaven anyways. She said it felt like a kiss, so it was all okay.
[22:25] Pearl Rhein: Oh my god. If you love someone, beat them.
[22:31] Jess McEnally: No, there's not really that's a joke.
[22:37] Pearl Rhein: And I took them. We went to see Caro on Broadway, and my Lutheran mom walked out of the theater and was like, those gender roles were kind of outdated.
[22:49] Jess McEnally: Um so I mean, yeah, I I don't disagree with that.
[22:54] Pearl Rhein: Yeah. That's on my long list, and this is an unpopular opinion, but that's on my long list of musicals that just shouldn't be done unless the book gets rewritten. Because I'm gonna write to it in our episode, but I'm gonna write you a pitch. It should be turned into a sh there's yes, there is one way, one way. You end it at after if I loved you, and that's the end of the show. It's a nice short musical.
[23:22] Jess McEnally: This is alternate pitch, Billy Bigelow can just go to hell.
[23:27] Pearl Rhein: Yes! A lot of options. And uh Julie and uh what's her friend's name? I forget. Julie and her friend, they run away from uh Mr. Snow with all of the kids, and they raise the children together in a lesbian commune island off the coast of Maine. And then instead of if I loved you, now I love you, we get a nice reprise, and everyone's happy. Like, yeah, I'm down for this. I don't care if it makes the musical five hours long. We've gotta do this.
[24:04] Jess McEnally: Um we gotta get back to Monty, the the OG fuck one. Monty at first I was like, this guy doesn't seem that bad, and then I was like, wait, never mind. This guy seems that bad. It's great, it really sneaks up on you, and then you think like, oh no, she's gonna be shattered, and then she's like, I'm already shattered. It's it it's so uh it's so satisfying and liberating that she doesn't get like in a in a way her like self-defensiveness works because she's seen that kind of thing coming before.
[24:41] Pearl Rhein: Yeah, I don't know about you, but uh anytime I just see a white man in like you know military fatigue, I'm like I'm on the fence, like, what are you gonna do wrong?
[24:52] Jess McEnally: Yes. Let's go. I mean, when you got dogfight, you've got Ms. Gone. In musical theater, they're never really the best people in the world, is all I'm saying. So it's like sometimes the school knows that and sometimes it doesn't, but there's still probably bad news. I mean, even when they're kind of on the good guy, they're bad news. Like, if they don't enter the female leads life, their life would probably be better.
[25:16] Pearl Rhein: Yes.
[25:20] Jess McEnally: So, Vietnam men, very bad. Unless you're Josh Henry.
[25:24] Pearl Rhein: Yeah. Then you're fine.
[25:26] Jess McEnally: You're fine. Um, but it doesn't matter what we think. It's time for us to go into our n favorite segment uh where we compare our opinions to those of the New York theater critics when this show came out. It's time for previews.
[25:39] Pearl Rhein: It's Tomful Previews.
[25:46] Jess McEnally: It's Tom Fall Previews.
[25:49] Pearl Rhein: Okay, so New York Times, Ben Brantley said of the original 1997 production, Violet, which has a score by Jeanine Tesori's with a book and lyrics by Brian Crawley, is adapted from The Ugliest Pilgrim, a short story by Doris Betts that has been widely anthologized.
[26:08] Jess McEnally: That's right.
[26:09] Pearl Rhein: Um, that's right. The popularity of the story, which follows the Odyssey of a young woman who leaves her rural home to seek out a television faith healer, is understandable. What the show fails to do is to provide any compelling sense of character. Miss Ward's Violet, whose scar is left to the audience imagination, is an appealing, supple voiced presence, and the actress works hard at whipping up some emotional ardor. But from the beginning, Violet seems like a shrewd, scrappy, and sure-footed creature. A little like Sissy Spacek and Coral Minor's daughter. And you're never convinced, as you have to be, of the desperate spiritual path which she lives. The truth is never so pat, says Violet. Try and wrap your mind around that. This show unfortunately lets you wrap your mind around its message nearly from its inception. That's not a good thing when the musical is for the most part the message.
[27:12] Jess McEnally: I don't understand what he's trying to say here.
[27:14] Pearl Rhein: This is another one of those Ben Brantley reviews where I think he just wanted to say a bunch of pretty words and mean nothing.
[27:20] Jess McEnally: Yeah.
[27:21] Pearl Rhein: I I can't I have no idea if he's criticizing the character writing or the direction. Like he's sounds like I didn't really relate to this character, but I have not thought about why that might be.
[27:54] Jess McEnally: Which is not good. But it's like, okay. Like, it's like it's hard to wrap your mind about the message, despite it being a very simple method message. But the show is the message, and I'm like, mother f what the fuck are you trying to say, my dude? I don't know. I guess I didn't watch the version of the show he watched, so maybe.
[28:10] Pearl Rhein: It was a 97 production, which isn't insanely different. Um, it's just I don't know. I I think he just went in with a bad taste in his mouth, to be honest.
[28:19] Jess McEnally: It was another one of those classic Ben Brantley. I'm gonna go into this because it's an off Broadway show and I'm gonna shit on it for 10 pages.
[28:27] Pearl Rhein: Yeah.
[28:28] Jess McEnally: You know, the Ben Brantley classic.
[28:32] Pearl Rhein: Oh no for me, dog. My favorite is one of his last reviews he ever did, which was of a Godspell production just like somewhere in the world where he's just like, yeah, Godspell sucks, but I was so glad to be in a theater.
[28:46] Jess McEnally: That was his review.
[28:48] Pearl Rhein: Might as well have just been reviewing COVID-19 or whatever. Like, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. The worst wine still tastes like the best wine if you haven't had it in a while. What a guy.
[28:59] Jess McEnally: What a guy, Ben Brantley. Do we agree with that review? I feel like there's no way we can because we don't understand what he's trying to say.
[29:05] Pearl Rhein: I I mean, I understand what he's saying, what he's trying to say with not being compelling as far as character goes, but I can't agree with that.
[29:13] Jess McEnally: So no.
[29:14] Pearl Rhein: Yeah, it feels like it that feels like um I wanted the character arc more spelled out, or I did not like how self-defensive this character was. But that uh that's like a quibble with the personality of the character. Like he won like, I guess he wanted her to be more passive and like nothing. I mean, so sure. Probably. But I don't I don't think that would have improved anything. In fact, it probably would have been a less interesting show. Because how many times have we seen a show about uh a woman who is passive and damaged or whatever? I mean, I feel like he wanted the glass menagerie or like light in the piazza or something, and then he got something that is more realistic and more true.
[29:59] Pearl Rhein: Oh, yeah.
[30:00] Jess McEnally: This does not fit my idea of a person with a disability or a deformity.
[30:06] Pearl Rhein: Exactly.
[30:07] Jess McEnally: Yep.
[30:08] Pearl Rhein: Exactly.
[30:08] Jess McEnally: And he, and I think like he almost is blaming it on the fact that we don't see the scar.
[30:13] Pearl Rhein: Like the fact that he addresses that makes me think I can't feel sympathy for them because I can't imagine how bad they look.
[30:19] Jess McEnally: Yeah.
[30:20] Pearl Rhein: They didn't even bother.
[30:24] Jess McEnally: Um, yeah, so fuck Ben Brantley. Let's go on to, let's travel through time to 2014 and see what happens next.
[30:31] Pearl Rhein: Okay, so is this, this is the New York Times once again.
[30:36] Jess McEnally: They upgraded to Charles Isherwood.
[30:40] Pearl Rhein: Um, so he said of the 2014 revival, when Sutton Foster appears on Broadway, she's usually boasting a sunbeam smile, flapping away in tap shoes, clowning around amiably, and generally behaving like a girl determined to nail the talent competition in a beauty pageant, and maybe even take home Miss Congeniality award too.
[31:02] Jess McEnally: But pep allergic people will not need to steal themselves to see the terrific, heart-stirring revival of Violet.
[31:10] Pearl Rhein: The musical by Jeanine Tesori's and Brian Crowley that opened at the American Airlines Theater on Sunday nights, starring Miss Foster in a career redefining performance.
[31:38] Jess McEnally: Although her belief that a preacher can heal her would seem to suggest a deeper naivete?
[31:44] Pearl Rhein: Is that right?
[31:46] Jess McEnally: Naivete.
[31:50] Pearl Rhein: Miss Foster makes us feel from the inside how Violet's survival of her painful teenage years was linked to the belief that her disfigurement would only be temporary.
[32:02] Jess McEnally: Hope dies hard in young hearts.
[32:05] Pearl Rhein: It's not exactly a spoiler alert to reveal that Violet's wish doesn't come true.
[32:10] Jess McEnally: That the preacher she put her hope in is a charlatan.
[32:17] Pearl Rhein: Uh, that all the years of prayers cannot erase the damage done.
[32:22] Jess McEnally: But the musical concludes on a satisfying but not too sugary note of uplift by shedding her illusions at how painful a cost.
[32:31] Pearl Rhein: Violet has also found a new kind of faith, a belief that her life's promise does not depend on divine intervention but the homelier comforts of human attachment.
[32:41] Jess McEnally: Now this guy gets it.
[32:43] Pearl Rhein: I'd say so.
[32:44] Jess McEnally: He always does.
[32:46] Pearl Rhein: Yeah, Charles Isherwood has a much better track record of understanding the assignment than Ben Brantley.
[32:55] Jess McEnally: Well he actually talks about what the show is about rather than just saying that what the show was about was way too simple, and I understood it, but I didn't like it.
[33:05] Pearl Rhein: I I've got it, but I'm too cool to tell you what it meant.
[33:10] Jess McEnally: I'm impressed too, because I feel like Violet has the smallness of a show that sometimes Broadway critics are like, it's Broadway, but there's not 40 people tap dancing, so it's boring.
[33:25] Pearl Rhein: You know what? That's a fair point.
[33:26] Jess McEnally: They'd rather just sit and watch like Thoroughly Modern Millie, which has like a bunch of rap choreography.
[33:34] Pearl Rhein: There was some great choreography. Remember when everybody leaned back in their chair at the same time?
[33:38] Jess McEnally: It was amazing.
[33:40] Pearl Rhein: And they ripped that off for Comfort Away.
[33:42] Jess McEnally: They all leaned back in their chair then too.
[33:44] Pearl Rhein: True.
[33:50] Jess McEnally: As a singer who moves, I am a huge fan of Lean Back in the Chair choreography.
[33:58] Pearl Rhein: Oh yes.
[34:07] Jess McEnally: I never got to do that.
[34:11] Pearl Rhein: On your feet.
[34:12] Jess McEnally: Not two and a half hours.
[34:13] Pearl Rhein: Not there.
[34:14] Jess McEnally: Yeah.
[34:15] Pearl Rhein: You're playing a viola, you still have to kick.
[34:27] Jess McEnally: There.
[34:28] Pearl Rhein: Yeah.
[34:29] Jess McEnally: I probably had a lot more than the, uh, well.
[34:32] Pearl Rhein: I think it's a good time for a mid-show.
[34:35] Jess McEnally: I think so too.
[34:37] Pearl Rhein: Heck yeah, we can.
[34:39] Jess McEnally: Alright. Let's go into a mid-show.
[34:47] Pearl Rhein: Hey guys, sorry to interrupt you in the middle of the show, but we've got a sh shoo at you!
[34:52] Jess McEnally: Oh boy.
[34:54] Pearl Rhein: Today's show is brought to you by the extremely kind donations by our donors over at Patreon.
[34:58] Andrew DeWolf: Andrew, who's donating to us on Patreon?
[35:01] Pearl Rhein: Oh boy. Uh, we have a lot of patrons, so I think I'll just get right into it.
[35:05] Andrew DeWolf: Our cover patrons are uh Melissa Goldman, Terry Needleman, John Donna, Layton Accles, Danielle Rennox, Jess the Stampede, Ewan Cassidy, Tess Gear, Fire of September, Monica Thoreau, Mina Maniri, Brent Black, Haley Murray, B-Way Flicks, Lathaniel Stacey Coombe, Joseph Evans Green, Carrie Ahern, Christine Malmadale, Mary Lou Choquette, John Vanels, Heck U, I go by Elijah now.
[35:27] Pearl Rhein: Russ Walker, Musical Hell, Emily Gracie, Andrew Van Barrison, DeBlam, Kyle Summers, Janae C, Christina Francis, Scoot and the Technicolor Dreamcoat, Liz Lim, Corey Wilmart, Alison Stoller, nothing is certain except Beth and Taxes, John Vanels, Fesbian, Ren Cullen, Wait in the Wings, Spectacle Machine, Jacob Stroop, Ref uh Raphael, Martinez, Silas, I think that's right.
[35:51] Andrew DeWolf: Robert Benjamin, uh, Rachel T, Jessica T, Genevieve Hartnett, Cass, uh, Mitchell Young, Chai Teacup, Hayden Wilder, Katie McDonough, um, Genke Geist, Stacas, Timothy Keys, Jeffrey Machado, um, oh boy.
[36:07] Pearl Rhein: Shakuz.
[36:08] Andrew DeWolf: Jacuse.
[36:08] Pearl Rhein: Jacuse.
[36:09] Andrew DeWolf: I knew that one, but I couldn't remember it.
[36:11] Pearl Rhein: Jacuse.
[36:12] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, Toon Van Essen, uh, Jesse Taylor, R. Elliott, Chris uh Mark Marcote.
[36:19] Pearl Rhein: Marco?
[36:20] Andrew DeWolf: Is that French or is that Marcot?
[36:23] Pearl Rhein: Marcot.
[36:24] Andrew DeWolf: Chris Marcat. I'm sorry. I I'm terrible with these new names.
[36:27] Pearl Rhein: Uh, Alexandria uh Seng and Katie Terberg.
[36:32] Andrew DeWolf: I swear next week I'll probably get them right, but you won't.
[36:35] Pearl Rhein: Um, but the best part is there are new names.
[36:37] Andrew DeWolf: Um, we love having new folks on here.
[36:40] Pearl Rhein: There's so much great things, and they give us a little extra financial support that helps us keep the lights on here at Musicals with Cheese, lets us keep Brie employed.
[36:47] Andrew DeWolf: And you know what? If you're the lights on, it is hot lights are on.
[36:51] Pearl Rhein: I am sweating my ass off. Let's go.
[36:52] Andrew DeWolf: Um, but you know what you get if you support us?
[36:57] Pearl Rhein: You get tons of fun shit.
[36:59] Andrew DeWolf: You've got like me, Brie watching The Little Mermaid, the most demented episode of the TV show ever made.
[37:04] Pearl Rhein: Um, you get to watch me, Andrew, and Brie talk about trailers and like the upcoming movie musicals.
[37:11] Andrew DeWolf: Um, don't forget the Tom and Jerry Wizard of Oz special.
[37:14] Pearl Rhein: Yeah, we did a full-on commentary of that.
[37:17] Andrew DeWolf: And also, if you were to download or donate literally any money to us on Patreon right now, you can see Pearl's face right now, and she's got this big smile on, she's dancing right now.
[37:28] Pearl Rhein: Oh, you're missing out. You're not on Patreon on her chair.
[37:31] Andrew DeWolf: This is incredible.
[37:33] Pearl Rhein: You know what? She's gonna lean back, she's leaning back.
[37:36] Andrew DeWolf: Oh my god, she's leaning back!
[37:37] Pearl Rhein: Oh my god, those dance moves!
[37:40] Andrew DeWolf: Award-winning Broadway dancer.
[37:43] Pearl Rhein: Incredible Bravo!
[37:46] Andrew DeWolf: My goodness!
[37:48] Pearl Rhein: And you know what? I just see it on the top of her lip.
[37:52] Andrew DeWolf: She just wants you to join Patreon.
[37:54] Pearl Rhein: I can just see her wanting to say it.
[37:56] Andrew DeWolf: I do, please.
[37:57] Pearl Rhein: Please try to.
[37:58] Andrew DeWolf: I got her to say it!
[37:59] Pearl Rhein: I gotta do it!
[38:00] Andrew DeWolf: How do you keep getting the guests to embrace us for free?
[38:04] Pearl Rhein: This is honestly, this is extortion.
[38:10] Andrew DeWolf: You know what? It's Pearl approved.
[38:13] Pearl Rhein: Let's just join us.
[38:15] Andrew DeWolf: Give us money, is what we're saying.
[38:17] Pearl Rhein: We need your money, or else Brie, Brie will have to live in a box, and we don't want that.
[38:21] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, alright. We've gone long enough.
[38:23] Pearl Rhein: It's time to get back to the show.
[38:24] Andrew DeWolf: Let's talk some songs.
[38:34] Pearl Rhein: A battered nose, a pimple chin.
[38:39] Andrew DeWolf: Uneven eyes to take it in.
[38:45] Pearl Rhein: Mama wise a man have hands.
[38:48] Andrew DeWolf: I tell you go detail.
[38:58] Pearl Rhein: Let's talk about that opening number, which I don't know about you, but Jeanine Tesori's always knocks her opening number out of the park.
[39:05] Andrew DeWolf: Absolutely.
[39:07] Pearl Rhein: Oh yeah.
[39:08] Andrew DeWolf: The recurring like theme of mama was a man got us and like it starts as like this really charming thing, and then by the time it comes back much later, it's like, oh my god, I'm about to, I need a tissue, I cannot breathe on my gut.
[39:22] Pearl Rhein: So chilling.
[39:25] Andrew DeWolf: Um, but it just sets up every single theme as well as like the specific devices used in the show as well.
[39:34] Pearl Rhein: The traveling back and forth in time and all that.
[39:37] Andrew DeWolf: Um, what do you guys think?
[39:40] Pearl Rhein: I so agree.
[39:42] Andrew DeWolf: And uh one thing I love about the score too, as a, uh, I play and sing a lot of country and folk music, and that's like sort of like the genre that I live in the most next to musical theater.
[39:54] Pearl Rhein: The country and folk influences feel really genuine and actually known, and not like, like sometimes musical theater goes like, oh, and now it's a country song, and it like, and it feels very like it was written by a bunch of wasps in a room in New York.
[40:13] Andrew DeWolf: And the, and this feels a lot more authentic.
[40:16] Pearl Rhein: Um, and that comes in the instrumentation too, and like the fiddle parts, the pedal steel guitar, like there's so few musicals that have pedal steel.
[40:29] Andrew DeWolf: Um, then the revival uses banjo.
[40:32] Pearl Rhein: Um, that just like all of that music feels like it already lives right in your chest, and they're just pulling it out.
[40:39] Andrew DeWolf: It feels like, uh, and I said it earlier, it feels like Bright Star.
[40:43] Pearl Rhein: And I remember when we did the episode on Bright Star, I was like, I like this music style. I don't think this show is very good, but I'd like to see more shows try this.
[40:52] Andrew DeWolf: And then here this is.
[40:53] Pearl Rhein: It's right here.
[40:55] Andrew DeWolf: Um, so everything I said about the music in Bright Star goes double for this because this is better.
[41:04] Pearl Rhein: In my opinion, I'm sure some people really like Bright Star.
[41:07] Andrew DeWolf: Probably about to say, like, I am the biggest Bright Star fan.
[41:10] Pearl Rhein: Throw that baby off the train.
[41:13] Andrew DeWolf: If you like throwing babies off trains, I mean I can't fault you for that.
[41:16] Pearl Rhein: It's fun.
[41:17] Andrew DeWolf: But in slow motion.
[41:21] Pearl Rhein: So you are the biggest Bright Star fan in the world.
[41:26] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, I'm mostly with you. Like some gorgeous banjo, some beautiful melodies, some beautiful chords, slow motion baby.
[41:38] Pearl Rhein: Off the train.
[41:39] Andrew DeWolf: Off the train, off the train.
[41:41] Pearl Rhein: A man's gotta do.
[41:42] Andrew DeWolf: Ben's gotta do what a man's gotta do.
[41:46] Pearl Rhein: Specifically, this is a can of worms, but it's specified only white performers, and like that doesn't feel good to me.
[41:55] Andrew DeWolf: And I, that kind of like, uh, like I can't hear that musical without remembering the fact that the fact of that.
[42:05] Pearl Rhein: Uh, I did not know about another reason to hate Bright Star.
[42:10] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, that is very specific.
[42:13] Pearl Rhein: It's very like no story reason at all.
[42:18] Andrew DeWolf: No.
[42:19] Pearl Rhein: And like I don't know if our conclusion concern is historical accuracy then why?
[42:25] Andrew DeWolf: It's not a, it's not a story for history.
[42:28] Pearl Rhein: And why is it like what's historically accurate about everyone being white?
[42:32] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, yeah, yeah, I have, I have strong feelings about that.
[42:37] Pearl Rhein: But beautiful bitch to my stomach now and I'm just like remembering that was the Hamilton year where Broadway's patting itself on the back for being so woke.
[42:45] Andrew DeWolf: Oh yeah, they're real good at that I hear. I hear seen Thoroughly Modern Millie.
[42:53] Pearl Rhein: You don't get to talk about being woke Broadway.
[43:01] Andrew DeWolf: You can't talk about being woke on Broadway.
[43:01] Pearl Rhein: Oh no, oh wait, yeah, yeah, that, that I hope that joke didn't hit too close to home.
[43:11] Andrew DeWolf: God, we hate Cast Boy here.
[43:12] Pearl Rhein: Wait, what's what word are you saying?
[43:14] Andrew DeWolf: I don't think I know this word.
[43:16] Pearl Rhein: Um, dear Cast Boy.
[43:18] Andrew DeWolf: Cast Boy, he's talking about um Evan Hansen.
[43:22] Pearl Rhein: Oh, I have to, I have to admit that I am biased because I was in Great Comet which was the same year of the Tonies and so like I have to preface it with like obviously I'm gonna have feelings.
[43:22] Andrew DeWolf: Um, well that's fine we're biased, we're biased too.
[43:22] Pearl Rhein: Yeah, we love Great Comet, hate Dear Evan Hansen.
[43:47] Andrew DeWolf: That's our bias.
[43:49] Pearl Rhein: Yeah, it's just, it's real wrong on a lot of things like mental illness and suicide, and uh when it's okay to kiss a teenage girl and a lot of things.
[44:06] Andrew DeWolf: It's just real wrong.
[44:07] Pearl Rhein: Is it okay if you're pretending to be her dead brother's friend?
[44:11] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, and you haven't gotten consent.
[44:16] Pearl Rhein: Is that okay?
[44:18] Andrew DeWolf: There's a lot of consent issues in Dear Evan Hansen.
[44:22] Pearl Rhein: And anytime I talk to people about it, they're like, it's all about social media.
[44:25] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm like, it's not all about social media, and don't you dare try to say that to me.
[44:30] Pearl Rhein: What is it trying to say about social media? I'd love to know.
[44:33] Andrew DeWolf: Like, it's all of those things exist on social media too.
[44:37] Pearl Rhein: And they are also worse for the girls and for the people with suicidal ideation.
[44:44] Andrew DeWolf: And like, it's still worse for all the other characters.
[44:47] Pearl Rhein: Yeah.
[44:47] Andrew DeWolf: The sad part is every female character in Dear Evan Hansen is a hundred percent more interesting than any male character in Dear Evan Hansen.
[44:55] Pearl Rhein: Yeah.
[44:55] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and I think that's our rant on um Dear 40-year-old man in high school.
[45:01] Jess McEnally: Um, let's go on to the I Want song of Violet on my way.
[45:11] ♪ Musical number: "On My Way" — performed by Pearl Rhein ♪
[46:10] Jess McEnally: Oh, I was just thinking before we signed on. One of the things that I really like about the songs is they press up against the mold a little bit in like that your musical theater structure songs.
[46:24] Pearl Rhein: Yes.
[46:24] Jess McEnally: And but they still fit them, but you can't immediately go, oh, I want song, charm song, patter song. Like they feel a little bit more idiosyncratic. And On My Way is such a good I want song because it has so much motion. There like there's so much like literal travel happening in it that it doesn't suffer from the like I'm like it's it's I want and am getting, not just this is what I want. I hope someone gives it to me.
[46:54] Pearl Rhein: Also, Tesori.
[46:55] Jess McEnally: Yeah.
[46:55] Pearl Rhein: And her key changes. Just she knows when to modulate in a way that is like so thrilling and so and it like character and story-driven, it is just stupid.
[47:09] Jess McEnally: I completely agree. And also I can't disagree. Like for an I want song, it kind of sneaks up on you like because it kind of fades right into the conversation so beautifully. Um and as well, you don't really know what the story is. I mean, you get a gist, but you don't quite know where it's unfolding to. We have really not even introduced like the soldier characters yet. We just know Violet, we know like her basic goal and all that, and structurally, I agree with you. It does kind of bounce up against it where this is like a perfect I want song, and then after that it kind of falls apart. A lot of that has to do, at least in my opinion. I don't remember if the original production was like this, but it's a one act.
Um, so you don't have like that act break where it's like, all right, we'll be back in a bit. I think originally two acts, and then they took it down to one when they did it at um Encores, and then kept that structure for Broadway, and I think that works really well.
[48:04] Pearl Rhein: Well, it's nice, it's not it doesn't overstay its welcome, you know.
[48:08] Jess McEnally: It like you said, like in a way, not a ton happens. And so that allows it to be about the characters and the relationships, and doesn't doesn't put too much emphasis on like where's the bus stopping now? Because that's like not the exciting part.
[48:27] Pearl Rhein: Doesn't really doesn't really matter.
[48:29] Jess McEnally: Yeah, and yeah, and like the moments to breathe are so important, but they're also like my least favorite moments in the show. Like all the M&Ms and moments where I'm like, uh I'm glad they're short. Let's just say that. They're some song and a great musical eventually has to be the worst one.
[48:47] Pearl Rhein: Yes, it does do really well with those patterns and charm songs, which uh it can so easily go boring and be like the one you skip on the recording. Um like for instance, um, what's the poker learning song called?
[49:02] Jess McEnally: Luck of the Draw.
[49:03] Pearl Rhein: Luck of the Draw is such a good uh like musically, it's such a good quartet, and then it's also such a good informative scene, and like so much happens and you learn about the pause relationship with her when she was young and using it to teach math, and you learn about you you start you really start to see that Violet has always been like really prickly, and then you get to see her introducing herself to the soldiers, uh, and then you learn a little bit about poker, and the harmonies are so killer.
[49:34] Jess McEnally: And then they lean back in the chairs and I wanna say like Luck of the Draw. Like, this is a super emotionally charged musical. Luck of the Draw is probably the one that gets me the most choked up just on how great a song and scene and like how it works. I'm like, fuck, you can do that.
[49:51] Pearl Rhein: Yes, yeah.
[49:52] Jess McEnally: It's really good. Like, shocked as like, okay, I know exactly her relationship with her dad. I know the kind of guy that her dad is, who is not a saint by any means, but doing his best in the way that he knows how, which also perfectly illustrates why she is the way she is and how she acts and all that. You see her being like the cut of his jib because that was really like who she was raised by, um, no through no fault of his or no fault of hers.
[50:19] Pearl Rhein: Yeah.
[50:20] Jess McEnally: Um, and as well, introducing like how she can kind of play these two dudes under the table and why. It's great.
[50:27] Pearl Rhein: Yep.
[50:27] Jess McEnally: And the lines that get echoed when both of the girls go royal flush.
[50:32] Pearl Rhein: All right, let's talk about Flick's first like big solo.
[50:36] Jess McEnally: Um, Let It Sing.
[50:38] ♪ Musical number: "Let It Sing" — performed by Pearl Rhein ♪
[51:25] Jess McEnally: I like Flick a lot in this. I kind of I wish that he got more, but yes. I guess it wasn't really about him, so it's I mean, it bothers me a ton that we focus so much on Monty as like this.
[51:35] Pearl Rhein: I rat.
[51:37] Pearl Rhein: He's the villain.
[51:35] Jess McEnally: I'd rather just have this like really nice.
[51:38] Jess McEnally: I know, but he's got like so much more playtime than say like Flick, who is just this well-intentioned.
[51:45] Pearl Rhein: Monty's just not an interesting character.
[51:48] Jess McEnally: Monty's just like, yeah, we know this guy. Okay.
[51:51] Pearl Rhein: Yeah, it does.
[51:56] Jess McEnally: It feels like the kind of thing that was maybe a little progressive in the 90s, and now feels like Flick is not allowed to be complicated because he's like the only black character with a character.
[52:09] Pearl Rhein: Yes.
[52:09] Jess McEnally: Um, and then and of course, the show does suffer from that musical theater thing of we're gonna bring in a black woman to sing gospel, who also doesn't have a character.
[52:21] Pearl Rhein: Like it's gonna be one of the best things in the show, but she doesn't get to talk.
[52:26] Jess McEnally: Yeah, that's one of my like the big things I have an issue with in this show is that specifically. Like it's a cool moment, but it means nothing.
[52:33] Pearl Rhein: Um full of sound and fury signifying nothing, all that.
[52:38] Jess McEnally: And uh I'm I it bothered me a lot.
[52:42] Pearl Rhein: I d I yeah, I didn't really enjoy the gospel part. It just kind of the song is fine and like, but it just goes on so long, and then there's none of the characters are in it except for the preacher, I guess, but he's not even really a character.
[52:54] Jess McEnally: I don't know.
[52:55] Pearl Rhein: Yeah.
[52:55] Jess McEnally: And it's like it's it's rough to spend a lot of time like just listening to the music of this institution that we already know is hollow and is not going to be the answer that Violet's looking for.
[53:13] Pearl Rhein: Well, yeah, it's like immediately when she says tell evangelist at the beginning, you're like, oh boy.
[53:18] Jess McEnally: Yeah.
[53:19] Pearl Rhein: Yeah.
[53:20] Jess McEnally: So it's like, you know, unless like there is some real twist where she the preacher.
[53:29] Pearl Rhein: Yeah.
[53:29] Jess McEnally: Funny. I do work for free.
[53:33] Pearl Rhein: Well, Lord does work in mysterious ways.
[53:36] Jess McEnally: Yeah.
[53:38] Pearl Rhein: But they do they do give a song to the preacher and his posse for like seven solid minutes with nobody else on the stage.
[53:48] Jess McEnally: It's like, okay. I mean, the song's good and they're singing really well, but it feels so much like that was like an era where every musical had a gospel song.
[53:58] Pearl Rhein: Yeah.
[53:59] Jess McEnally: Like even all the way up to Hairspray, where Hairspray has its go-to gospel song and all that.
[54:06] Pearl Rhein: Yeah.
[54:06] Jess McEnally: It just it kind of feels like a thing that's there because it's in musicals, not because it's like somewhere. If it was like three minutes, and maybe if it had more like double meaning for the preacher or something, I don't know.
[54:18] Pearl Rhein: It'd be more interesting.
[54:20] Jess McEnally: If it was if it was short and quick enough for us to feel like, oh, yay, I'm excited, church, and then it's over and you don't have time to think about it, then I feel like that would that would show a little bit more how you could get caught up in the like the Sound and Fury.
[54:34] Pearl Rhein: Yeah.
[54:34] Jess McEnally: I'm looking at the the cast recording, and it looks as though this song was uh six minutes and forty seconds, and it's the longest one in the entire entire cast act.
[54:44] Pearl Rhein: That's a long song, guys.
[54:46] Jess McEnally: Yeah, and it's also the only one with none of the characters in it, you know?
[54:51] Pearl Rhein: Yeah, let's think about it. Sudden Foster and all of them, they need time offstage to like breathe and get water.
[54:56] Jess McEnally: Especially when you cut intermission.
[54:59] Pearl Rhein: Yeah, there's no intermission.
[55:01] Jess McEnally: Was that the song that came like the first song after intermission?
[55:05] Pearl Rhein: Yes.
[55:06] Jess McEnally: I'm I'm gonna go.
[55:08] Pearl Rhein: That explains it.
[55:09] Jess McEnally: That explains it.
[55:10] Pearl Rhein: That's the everyone sit down, everyone, you don't have to worry about plot, everyone find their goddamn seats.
[55:15] Jess McEnally: Yes.
[55:16] Pearl Rhein: You're coming back from the bathroom. It's okay, you got six minutes of this gospel number.
[55:19] Jess McEnally: You don't have to care about.
[55:21] Pearl Rhein: Yeah.
[55:21] Jess McEnally: Except for it's a it's a one act, and it's like something major just happened, and you're like, where's where's the lead?
[55:30] Pearl Rhein: I was about to see like, you know, like yeah, Flick give this like intense song, like hard to say goodbye and promise me Violet. Like both of those are like really intense numbers, and it feels like, oh, you're gonna want to see what comes back in an act two, and then when you it's like me up.
[55:48] Jess McEnally: I know, and it's not even B plot.
[55:50] Pearl Rhein: It's like not plot.
[55:51] Jess McEnally: It's I mean it's a good s I don't want to like crap on it too hard. It's a good song.
[55:55] Pearl Rhein: Uh just it's a good song, I think it's not a good it's not a good song in stories.
[56:02] Jess McEnally: In this musical, I'd say even.
[56:04] Pearl Rhein: Um it's not nowhere near as bad as uh Act Two opener as like this was a real nice clam bake or something, but man.
[56:14] Jess McEnally: We're just hating on Carousel today.
[56:16] Pearl Rhein: My god, I'm I'm here for it.
[56:22] Jess McEnally: Um is there any other big songs you want to talk about in this show?
[56:25] Pearl Rhein: There's tons of them, but it's like I think the that's what I could do, the father's number is pretty good in that moment.
[56:35] Jess McEnally: Forgive me.
[56:39] Pearl Rhein: You're my own song.
[56:45] Jess McEnally: Look how bright.
[56:48] Pearl Rhein: Look how strong.
[56:51] Jess McEnally: Look how beautiful you are.
[56:59] Pearl Rhein: I've raised you stronger child than me.
[57:04] Jess McEnally: Which you'll always be.
[57:07] Pearl Rhein: That's what I could do.
[57:12] Jess McEnally: I raised you strong enough to start seeing with your heart.
[57:20] Pearl Rhein: That's what I could do.
[57:23] Jess McEnally: That's all I knew to do.
[57:30] Pearl Rhein: Rips your soul right out of you.
[57:32] Jess McEnally: The mo and the transition is so smooth. Um, whereas like in Fun Home, it's just kind of like, hey, I'm talking to you now, adult Alison. And here it's like such a smooth transition, you don't even know when it stops being the daughter or the younger version and starts being the adult version.
[57:48] Pearl Rhein: Yeah.
[57:48] Jess McEnally: Yeah.
[57:49] Pearl Rhein: Very, very good moment.
[57:51] Jess McEnally: And I got sad.
[57:52] Pearl Rhein: Sad dads are too much.
[57:54] Jess McEnally: It's too much.
[57:54] Pearl Rhein: That's my kryptonite, too.
[57:56] Jess McEnally: That's tough.
[57:58] Pearl Rhein: Let's talk about sad dads and w what makes them work.
[58:03] Jess McEnally: Um because the next week, me and Andrew, spoiler alert, we're talking about The Lion King, and that's a sad dad moment that I think doesn't work because he is too good.
[58:15] Pearl Rhein: He is too perfect in every way that it's like, oh, you were designed to be a sad dad with a sad death.
[58:22] Jess McEnally: Um this he's like an imperfect, like trying really hard but failing and like doing his best.
[58:32] Pearl Rhein: Yes, that's what makes it worse.
[58:33] Jess McEnally: Yeah.
[58:34] Pearl Rhein: And not having a perfect relationship represented makes it even sadder because it's what could have been all those types of questions instead of like, you know what? My dad was perfect and his memory lives on.
[58:42] Jess McEnally: Yeah.
[58:44] Pearl Rhein: My dad was a perfect king, and it's sad that he's dead because now the kingdom is going to fail.
[58:51] Jess McEnally: Yeah.
[58:52] Pearl Rhein: There's reasons why people are really at.
[58:58] Jess McEnally: There's a reason why people are very attached to like the uh he might have been your dad or your father, but he won your daddy moment from Guardians of the Galaxy Volume 2 in a way that's That's a sad dad moment.
[59:09] Pearl Rhein: In a way that they don't for like any of the other like Odin's death from Thor Ragnarok.
[59:15] Jess McEnally: Oh, nobody gives a shit.
[59:16] Pearl Rhein: Do you even remember when that happens?
[59:18] Jess McEnally: I mean, come on.
[59:20] Pearl Rhein: I'm Odin.
[59:24] Jess McEnally: And Michael Rooker versus Anthony Hopkins, who pulled off the saddest dad death?
[59:31] Pearl Rhein: Well, Michael has to be a good thing.
[59:32] Jess McEnally: The answer might surprise you.
[59:33] Pearl Rhein: He seems more complicated.
[59:35] Jess McEnally: I just, I think so many of us have, especially the older you are it, the older your dad is, and the more that your dad was fathering you with like the patriarchy that he was raised with.
[59:46] Pearl Rhein: And so they made a lot of mistakes, and like a lot of dads had a hard time being emotionally present and had a hard time relating with kids, you know, to make like big blanket statements.
[59:59] Pearl Rhein: But so a lot of us have a relationship where either what we want from our dads is like I fucked up a little, wish I did better. Or maybe we did get that, and then it kind of echoes that moment. I think what does it is when the dad finally opens up emotionally, and you're like, Yes. He just says what he wanted to say, but he was too manly to say the whole time. Because let's think how old is Violet in this. Um let's say she's in her mid-20s, and that would put him like her born in like the mid-30s, or because it takes place in 64, so 20 years before that, she would have been born in like the late 30s, early 40s, let's say. So he's even more patriarchal than like even we are. Let's say he's probably pretty progressive, all things considered, than most dads at the time.
He's teaching his daughter how to play poker in 54 or 55, so that she can be better at math. And he wants his daughter to be good at math. That's like Yeah. Possibly. He's a sad dad. Okay. Yeah. He's not the same. And he I the thing that surprised me, he wasn't even like, you can't be playing with those boys. He's like, not yet. Like that was a very mature response for like a dad of that time.
[1:01:30] Jess McEnally: On that note, what is our overall thoughts on Violet and our cheese rating? Um, Pearl, are you aware of our cheese rating? Do you know how that works?
[1:01:38] Pearl Rhein: Will you refresh me, please?
[1:01:39] Jess McEnally: I will. I'll make Andrew do it first. Andrew, what is your overall thoughts and your cheese rating?
[1:01:45] Andrew DeWolf: Alright. I uh I really enjoyed this. I mean, there's some aspects that I didn't love, namely the uh elongated uh gospel section that doesn't have much to do with anything. But I mean, overall it's pretty strong, and even that isn't like a a major negative, so I'm not gonna detract too much from it. Um the performances are good. I like the chair leaning a lot, you know, and I want more of that. More like they three I'm telling you, four people are leaning back in their chair at the same exact time on stage. Like it's impressive. Uh as far as the cheese rating, uh I I just looked this up. This is uh I'm looking at the Cheshire Cheese Company has a Parma Violets and it's violet cover colored cheese, which is just the strangest looking thing, and it does not look appetizing. But for this episode, because it's violet, we're giving it Parma Violet.
[1:02:39] Jess McEnally: That's a great, great. I'm sure it tastes good. It just I I don't I don't know how I feel about purple cheese.
[1:02:46] Andrew DeWolf: I I don't blame you. Um great answer. You actually put effort into that. I see you looked up cheese and violet, which is more than you usually do. I'm proud of you, Andrew.
[1:02:58] Pearl Rhein: Um alright, Pearl, what about you?
[1:03:01] Pearl Rhein: Um well, I I'm always gonna love this musical. I l I think both cast albums are really up there as great albums to listen to. They have incredible performances. The orchestrations especially are really important to me as a musician and and with country music. Um I I don't I don't know like if it needs to get done a lot more, like it ki it kind of feels like we've we've evolved a little bit and and bec because of because of the racial elements in the story, it kind of does lock down that casting, which makes it a really white cast, and that's a little bit of a bummer.
[1:03:40] Jess McEnally: Yeah.
[1:03:41] Pearl Rhein: Um yeah, but we're still putting on like carousel and whatever, so I know. Well let's I'll I'll s my rating is always do violet instead of carousel. Cheese. Where can I buy that?
[1:03:54] Andrew DeWolf: Where can I buy that cheese?
[1:03:55] Pearl Rhein: It's our creamers or something like that. Carousel, isn't carousel cheese an actual thing?
[1:04:01] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know. I probably there's probably some shit. You'll never cheese alone.
[1:04:10] Pearl Rhein: You know what? When I think about that cheese, I just think what's the use of wondering if it's good or if it's bad? I I don't plan to watch it again.
[1:04:18] Brianna Jones: Um Bree, what'd you think of our discussion on your cheese rating of that?
[1:04:23] Brianna Jones: Oh my god, your discussion was fantastic. Uh this uh Andrew, what we what's with your eyes?
[1:04:30] Andrew DeWolf: They were all big.
[1:04:32] Brianna Jones: I'm sweating, okay? It was like shocked that I said it was fantastic.
[1:04:38] Andrew DeWolf: Um can't be popping Molly's before we record. That'll make you sweat.
[1:04:43] Brianna Jones: This musical sounds sounds like it has everything you could ever want. A girl with a scar, a sad dad moment, um, a lying priest. Um so I mean they all beat her in a nutshell right there. Uh so I'm gonna give this, because I I looked, I looked it up and it said Violet started in North Carolina. So I'm gonna give it North Carolina Cheese biscuits as my cheese rating.
[1:05:13] Andrew DeWolf: Dang, it started in North Carolina. That's the same place the Wright brothers were.
[1:05:18] Brianna Jones: Or maybe South Carolina. I can't.
[1:05:20] Andrew DeWolf: Hey Pearl, hey Pearl, you want to get in get in on this? We're we we want to write a Wright brothers musical. You want to help us?
[1:05:27] Pearl Rhein: Ooh.
[1:05:28] Andrew DeWolf: That's not true. Because it's all about the right it's all about the right sister that never flight brother. Never got credit for doing like most of the work.
[1:05:36] Pearl Rhein: Yeah, she did most of the work and never got credit. So I'm like, there's a musical there.
[1:05:41] Andrew DeWolf: There really is. And I'm like, and I'm like, alright, us three, we could do this.
[1:05:46] Pearl Rhein: And you got some interesting characters. I mean, you got the two Wright brothers who are all both interesting, and then the right brother. But they were also in competition with like the the what's he called? The Smithsonians. Like they were in competition of who could patent it first. Like there is plot there. And in the end, um, the two siblings don't talk to each other like after one of the brothers die, the sister and brother just stop talking to each other. It doesn't one and the brother like try to take way more credit than he actually deserves. Because since everyone died and he decided, well, I'm the last one right left and I get to write what happened. He wrote what happened to make himself look greater, and then some historian much later came out, like, hold on, don't listen to his autobiography. That ain't how that happened. It kind of like turns out that he actually did like almost nothing.
[1:06:30] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it kind of is. It's a ridiculous story. There's a musical there. I don't know if we could do it, but I know there's a musical there. Stage it site specific on an airplane.
[1:06:39] Jess McEnally: Yes.
[1:06:43] Andrew DeWolf: I think I had a cheese reading song to give.
[1:06:46] Jess McEnally: My God. Go for it, Jess.
[1:06:49] Jess McEnally: Go! I love Violet. Violet was so much fun. I I the score is gorgeous. Jeanine Tesori's's like music is wonderful. I agree with every fault that it has, but my god, it's I think 2014 was the last possible time they could have revived it, and I'm glad they did. Um if they do kind of play with it more, um, I I'd say go for it. Make some changes. I mean, it's a relatively new enough musical where you can like really dive in and no one's gonna like, what? You're ruining my favorite show. How we how dang you! You're pissing on the graves. Um I think it can only benefit from being uh played again. I think I think people would like it. But my only cheese rating I can give it is a no big MM cheese ball dessert. Um, because it's sweet and it just it's not like the most it's a little garish to look at, but my god, it's a sweet little treat, and there's a song called MMs.
[1:07:47] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. I like that. This is like when we gave uh we gave that one show cheese nips as a rating. How can we not?
[1:07:54] Brianna Jones: I mean, I I got that.
[1:07:57] Jess McEnally: Um all right, we did it, guys. Pearl, you were a fantastic guest. Like what one of our best guests. Um anytime you want to come back on, if there's another musical, you're like, I gotta talk about this. Like, our doors are always open to you anytime.
[1:08:13] Pearl Rhein: Oh my god. I'll go back to the list that I wrote when you asked me originally, and I was like, it could be this or this.
[1:08:19] Pearl Rhein: Oh, they've already done that one.
[1:08:22] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, the list is getting long.
[1:08:23] Brianna Jones: We're getting to a point where we're like, we're gonna have to redo some of these.
[1:08:26] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, or you're you're gonna start doing more of the things. Some of the older ones need to be redone.
[1:08:31] Pearl Rhein: I love doing it. Like Gelseys, like Institute Institute.
[1:08:34] Brianna Jones: Institute Institute.
[1:08:39] Pearl Rhein: What an interesting thing is.
[1:08:40] Brianna Jones: Oh, I adore that woman.
[1:08:44] Pearl Rhein: That's um, that's the best person to go to for something obscure.
[1:08:48] Jess McEnally: She was a great guest, and we talked about like I love that show. Like that entire Institute Institute album I revisit a lot because it is just insane pants. I don't get it, but I love it.
[1:08:57] Andrew DeWolf: We should do another episode and like fig we should each come up with like an actual theory on what it is about.
[1:09:04] Brianna Jones: That would be good.
[1:09:05] Jess McEnally: We should have Gelsey back on, and we just like it, or and the composer Brian McCorkle, um, who wrote Institute Institute, and then he can say, uh no, you're wrong.
[1:09:15] Pearl Rhein: Ooh, I don't want to be told I'm wrong.
[1:09:17] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, then why do you have a podcast on the internet, Andrew?
[1:09:20] Andrew DeWolf: So I can tell other people they're wrong.
[1:09:25] Pearl Rhein: You like David Hanson? You're wrong.
[1:09:27] Andrew DeWolf: That's easy.
[1:09:28] Pearl Rhein: Oh man, you are wrong.
[1:09:32] Jess McEnally: Um, Pearl, Pearl, you've got so much wonderful things on the internet. Um, tell the world where they can find you and promote shill it out for the world.
[1:09:40] Pearl Rhein: Oh absolutely, yes. You can find my website is PearlRine.com. It's R-H-E-I-N. It's just like the river in Germany. Um I'm on Twitter at Pearl Rhein, I'm on Instagram at PearlRine. Um uh the I think the day that this drops, I recently took a composing and songwriting class from William Finn.
[1:10:06] Pearl Rhein: And it who is like one of my musical theater idols. Um, and it was an incredible experience, and he is a tough teacher. Um, but he's uh hosting and New York Theater Barn is co-hosting a concert of songs that the students wrote in that class. And so that is that's going to stream on their YouTube page on the 27th and then remain there after that. So when this drops, that will already have happened, but then it will also just exist on the New York Theater Barn YouTube page.
[1:10:39] Pearl Rhein: And then you can you can find I'm gonna be tweeting about that a lot, and it'll be on my webpage. So if you find any of my socials, that will direct you to that concert because I have um I have a couple of songs in that concert and I'm really excited about them. Um and I think there was something else I wanted to say. Oh, and on June 7th, um I am premiering a new song with a one of my favorite groups called Necromancers of the Public Domain. Um it's usually a live performance group, and they're doing a streamed one uh because of obvious reasons. Um and it's all original songs and pieces inspired by um a book in the public domain. And in this in this case, the book is about cicadas. It's this book from 1907 written about cicadas.
So a bunch of songwriters of different genres and disciplines just all write songs based on these weird obscure books. Um, and that will also be on all of my socials and whatnot. Um and yeah, find me. I I like to I like to tweet a lot. I like to Instagram sometimes.
[1:11:44] Jess McEnally: Yeah, hell yeah. That's amazing. Um, you'll be tagged in all of these things. And also, if you're not already, um, which you should be, please, please subscribe to our YouTube page. It has some of like my favorite musical theater content ever. I I find myself revisiting it a lot. If you ever wanted to hear what Sonia Alone sounded like as a country song, come on, guys.
[1:12:06] Pearl Rhein: You are too kind. Thank you.
[1:12:09] Jess McEnally: As uh well like a bunch of original compositions. Um I do listen to a ton of them on my own. Um, if I'm gonna recommend a couple, um the the ballad of the blue foot footed booby, like uh so much fun. Um and if you want something a little bit darker, the mask, which is another wonderful like trio. Beautiful.
[1:12:29] Pearl Rhein: Thank you so much. I cannot recommend it enough.
[1:12:31] Jess McEnally: Cannot recommend it enough. And please, please, please um go follow her and tell her how much you loved her being on our show. I had such a great time, you guys. This is really fun. Thank you.
[1:12:43] Brianna Jones: Hell yeah. You know who else coming on?
[1:12:46] Andrew DeWolf: Definitely had a great time. Our wonderful patrons! Thank you guys for listening. Please follow us on iTunes, Spotify, Stitcher at Musicals with Cheese, or on Twitter at Cheesy Musicals, Patreon Musicals Cheese, Instagram Musicals with Cheese, YouTube page musicals with cheese, or on Patreon, and you know that already. Or please email us at musical theater lives at gmail.com. Our title card was created by the amazing Jolene Casco. Go send her some love at Jolene Casco. Our keeper of the cheese is Juliet Antonio. Um our breviews theme song is created by Robin Nash of IOU UK Music. Go send her some love. This show is produced by the incredible, the wonderful, the gorgeous Brianna Jones. We love you so much, Brianna. Thank you to the Broadway Podcast Network for having us on the platform and for not kicking us off or bullying Dear Evan Hansen.
[1:13:33] Andrew DeWolf: Or meatloaf.
[1:13:35] Brianna Jones: Or Meatloaf.
[1:13:35] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, yeah.
[1:13:37] Brianna Jones: Or Ben Brantley.
[1:13:39] Andrew DeWolf: Or Ben Brantley.
[1:13:40] Brianna Jones: Yeah, we both maybe we are the bullies.
[1:13:42] Andrew DeWolf: Now that I think about it.
[1:13:44] Brianna Jones: We are.
[1:13:45] Andrew DeWolf: We aim high with our bully subjects, though, like Meatloaf, Ben Platt, Benchley, Ben Shapiro.
[1:13:51] Brianna Jones: All white men, it's fine.
[1:13:59] Jess McEnally: Alright. Um Pearl, is there anything else you want to say before we wrap this up?
[1:14:07] Pearl Rhein: No, put a uh always put a banjo in your musical.
[1:14:11] Jess McEnally: Hell yeah. That's a that's great advice.
[1:14:14] Andrew DeWolf: Um write that down.
[1:14:16] Jess McEnally: Write that down!
[1:14:17] Andrew DeWolf: Right from this banjo's musical.
[1:14:20] Brianna Jones: Seven banjos.
[1:14:21] Andrew DeWolf: We need banjos!
[1:14:23] Brianna Jones: How many banjos can we get?
[1:14:24] Andrew DeWolf: Oh god.
[1:14:25] Brianna Jones: We've gone too far.
[1:14:27] Andrew DeWolf: Too many banjos.
[1:14:29] Brianna Jones: We've gone too far in a few places.
[1:14:32] Pearl Rhein: It's stylistically designed to be that banjoy, but we can we can't undo it, but we can mitigate the effects.
[1:14:42] Jess McEnally: Alright, guys. We'll see you next time on Musicals with Cheese.
[1:14:53] Andrew DeWolf: I'm on my way to watch Violet.
[1:14:57] Brianna Jones: Go watch it.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
