Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#148 - In the Heights

"Lights up on Washington Heights, up at the break of day" Grab your Piragua and hairspray because this week we're talking about the musical "In the Heights" and the recent film adaptation... Read More

From the show: Musicals with Cheese

1 h 21 mins
7/1/21

Featured Shows

About

"Lights up on Washington Heights, up at the break of day" Grab your Piragua and hairspray because this week we're talking about the musical "In the Heights" and the recent film adaptation. We have some intense opinions on the recent controversy, the adaptation from stage to screen, and the future of musical movies!

Donate to Black Lives Matter here

Social Media:

Our WEBSITE

Musicals with Cheese on Twitter

Musicals W/ Cheese on Instagram

Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com

Merch!!

Jess Socials

Jess on Twitter

Jess on Instagram

Andrew Socials

Andrew on Instagram

Andrew on Twitter

Brianna Socials

Brianna on Twitter

Brianna on Instagram

Use our Affiliate Link

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:06] Jess McInally: Hello, I'm Jess McInally.

[0:08] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm Andrew DeWolf.

[0:10] Jess McInally: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, a podcast where I try to get Andrew to like musical theater.

[0:14] Jess McInally: How are you doing today, Andrew?

[0:16] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, I am doing just fantastic.

[0:19] Jess McInally: Holy shit.

[0:21] Andrew DeWolf: I did not expect that reaction.

[0:23] Jess McInally: I'm not gonna lie, it shocked me.

[0:25] Andrew DeWolf: It shocked you?

[0:26] Jess McInally: Yeah, a little bit.

[0:28] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. Well. What makes you so good? Why are you doing so good?

[0:32] Andrew DeWolf: Well, I just got fired from my job because the owner of the business sold it so they could get their daughter to go to college again. And you know, I'm just I'm feeling really good about it. I'm feeling fantastic.

[0:44] Jess McInally: I mean, are you having sex with his daughter though?

[0:47] Andrew DeWolf: Well, yes, of course.

[0:48] Jess McInally: Oh, okay. That explains everything.

[0:52] Jess McInally: Um, you're not gonna believe what's happening in my week.

[0:55] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, really? What's going on with you?

[0:57] Jess McInally: Um, remember how I was planning to go back to my home of the Dominican Republic, right?

[1:01] Andrew DeWolf: Wait, you never told me you're from the Dominican Republic.

[1:04] Jess McInally: Oh, yeah, I totally am from the Dominican Republic. And me and you know, the blocks Abuela. Um, yeah, we and our f my cousin Sonny, we were all gonna go back. But Abuela died, and you know what? Some dude just painted her on my wall, so I guess I'm stuck here. I decided not to go.

[1:23] Andrew DeWolf: No, that's great.

[1:26] Jess McInally: In the Heights!

[1:27] Andrew DeWolf: To the music, Bree!

[1:29] Jess McInally: In the Heights, I find my coffee and I go I find my coffee and set my sights, only what I need to know.

[1:39] Jess McInally: I need to go in the nights go down, I'm highway.

[1:50] Jess McInally: So In the Heights is a musical with music, lyrics by Lin-Manuel Miranda, and a book by Quiara Alegría Hudes. Based on, you know, like In the Heights, which was an original 1999 show that Lin-Manuel Miranda wrote. It opened on March 9th, 2008 at the Richard Rodgers Theater, the same theater currently playing Hamilton. Fun fact. It closed on January 9th, 2011, after 29 previews and 1,184 regular performances. It was nominated for 13 Tony Awards and won four, including Best Musical. The plot of this musical is in Washington Heights, a neighborhood of Manhattan, a young store owner watches the joys and heartbreaks of his tight-knit community as they pass through his bodega.

[2:36] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like that's just the plot of the opening song.

[2:38] Jess McInally: Yeah, yeah.

[2:40] Andrew DeWolf: Hey, a playbill can only give you so much info, Andrew.

[2:44] Jess McInally: Okay, fair enough. Um, so we did things differently than we usually do this week.

[2:51] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, we did.

[2:52] Jess McInally: Um, so I don't know if you guys have noticed, but a film adaptation of In the Heights came out this past week. Well, currently, I guess with this, this is coming out in July, so it will have been out for a little while when this comes out. You've probably already seen it.

[3:06] Andrew DeWolf: Like a couple times, probably.

[3:09] Jess McInally: It's on HBO Max. You could have watched it in a theater, watched it at home. Um, so Andrew watched the movie first, which is something that I usually tell him not to do, but who cares? He had friends around that he wanted to watch it with, so the schedules didn't quite align. And I saw In the Heights back a long, long time ago, back in like 2010, a bootleg of all that. Barely any of it had retained in my head, but I know I saw it and remembered like the broad strokes of it. Um, and then I was invited to an advanced screening of the movie, which was great, and I saw it in theaters, and it was a good movie. So the movie was more in my head, and I had forgotten most of the musical. So I rewatched the musical, and I've got some it's basically like we saw the movie before the musical, despite kind of not. I mean personally, I think the movie is better.

[4:01] Andrew DeWolf: Ooh, that's a big thought.

[4:02] Jess McInally: That is a big statement, my friend.

[4:05] Jess McInally: I'm gonna say it's just better. I think it handles it better. I like the new stuff that it adds, and I love the reframing of certain aspects of the show.

[4:17] Andrew DeWolf: I think I'm torn 50-50. There's about 50% of the musical that is not in the movie that I love and wish were in it, and there's 50% of the movie that is original to that that I love, and there's 50% that I don't like that I feel like they leaving out affects the story negatively.

[4:34] Jess McInally: Can we also just say the movie is probably the best movie musical in a long time?

[4:41] Andrew DeWolf: Can we think of another one?

[4:44] Jess McInally: Can we think of another good one?

[4:46] Andrew DeWolf: Um, fuck. Hello Again, maybe?

[4:50] Jess McInally: That was the last one I liked as much as this. And that's still not like a great.

[4:54] Andrew DeWolf: This is better.

[4:54] Jess McInally: This is better though. Even with that. And even that is like it's better than like Cats or like the movie musicals where they actively ruin it.

[5:06] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know, Andrew. This is gonna be the year of movie musicals. This could be topped a couple times over. We've got Tick, Tick... Boom coming out, we got West Side.

[5:13] Jess McInally: I'm not saying it might.

[5:16] Andrew DeWolf: You never know.

[5:17] Jess McInally: I'm not saying it can't be topped. I'm just saying that it has topped everything before it.

[5:22] Andrew DeWolf: I since we've started this podcast, every new movie musical, I think this is better than.

[5:26] Jess McInally: I think that's a fair statement to make. I also think it's just good. Like overall, and you should have your friends watch it. I don't know.

[5:33] Andrew DeWolf: Yes. This is like it's such a it's such an easy watch. And I don't know. I don't I think it's fun.

[5:39] Jess McInally: So I had a friend of mine who's like a huge cynic about things and really doesn't like like things because he's a bit of an asshole. I don't know why I'm friends with him. Um, and it's not you, which is the weird thing. I think I'm a bit cynical. I don't know about full cynic, though.

[5:51] Andrew DeWolf: But they were like, I feel dubious about all these good reviews coming in for In the Heights, and I had already seen it at this point, and he's like, it just feels like white guilt and people are like talking about it. I'm like, no, it's just Is that cynical or is that just racist?

[6:08] Andrew DeWolf: It's probably racist. Um, but you we all have that one friend that won't stop talking to you.

[6:14] Jess McInally: Okay. And like, is he watching right now?

[6:17] Andrew DeWolf: He might be, I don't know.

[6:18] Jess McInally: Is he in the room with us?

[6:19] Andrew DeWolf: I highly doubt it.

[6:20] Jess McInally: I highly doubt it.

[6:22] Jess McInally: But the thing is, this movie is so like of quality that I can't imagine anyone having an intense negative reaction to it.

[6:31] Andrew DeWolf: Well, racists. But people call it. There is some controversy about the movie that we will address later. Um, briefly, but we will address it. I have thoughts, but not too many. Um, but Andrew, let's start with the Broadway musical.

[6:46] Jess McInally: As backwards as that feels. What is the plot of the Broadway musical in your best summation?

[6:52] Andrew DeWolf: Sure. Um. So you have Usnavi.

[6:59] Jess McInally: Usnavi.

[7:00] Andrew DeWolf: How do you say it?

[7:02] Jess McInally: Okay, if I have one complaint, I hate that name. I wish they didn't use it.

[7:05] Andrew DeWolf: Um, it's very cringe how it's derived. And apparently it's a fairly common thing. Like a lot it's a common name because of that reason.

[7:17] Jess McInally: Okay. I mean, I don't know. I just I don't like it.

[7:20] Andrew DeWolf: But that's fine. If it's a racist, I knew you'd be a racist.

[7:24] Jess McInally: It's true. I mean I'm racist against the Navy.

[7:27] Andrew DeWolf: That's fine. I have a friend in the Navy.

[7:32] Andrew DeWolf: So Usnavi, um he runs a bodega shop in Washington Heights, um, and you get introduced to all the characters at the beginning, which is Abuela, who is like the mother of the neighborhood, essentially. Like everyone knows her. And everyone calls her Abuela despite not being nobody's grandmother. Yeah, but everyone respects her, everyone knows her. Uh she's relatively important. Um you have Vanessa, who is his uh Usnavi's crush.

[8:01] Andrew DeWolf: Um, in the musical, that's all she is. She has nothing aside from that.

[8:06] Jess McInally: Yeah, they actually don't have she does she literally well, she works she works at the hair salon.

[8:11] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, she has a job. And she wants to be a little bit more. She has a job.

[8:16] Jess McInally: Yes, and she dreams about moving.

[8:19] Andrew DeWolf: Um, just leaving. I mean, I think the only real aspect of the dream is that she's not gonna be there anymore.

[8:25] Jess McInally: Yeah. It is and strangely enough, she has more personality despite having less character traits, if that makes sense. Like she's a bit more of an edgy girl, the bad girl kind of type. Like a lot of folks kind of treat her as a bit trashy, like especially like Nina's daddy, um like calls her trash at one point, and she just kind of steals wine after that.

[8:49] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, yeah, and of course we have to get into that. Nina, who is uh everyone believes that she's gonna be like the one who makes it out.

[8:57] Andrew DeWolf: Yep. She's going to Stanford, or she was going to Stanford.

[9:01] Jess McInally: Stanford is in California.

[9:02] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.

[9:03] Jess McInally: Um her dad and mom. Um, parents uh who run a taxi service.

[9:12] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, a taxi dispatch service.

[9:15] Jess McInally: Yeah. Um, and uh who am I missing?

[9:18] Andrew DeWolf: Benny.

[9:19] Jess McInally: Benny who has a crush on uh Nina and works for the dad, the taxi service.

[9:25] Andrew DeWolf: I wouldn't see it's a crush, it's like a love affair that continues like they had it before she left and it continues when she gets back.

[9:34] Jess McInally: Yeah, they're they're actually just dating.

[9:36] Andrew DeWolf: They're just dating.

[9:37] Jess McInally: But it's behind Kevin's back.

[9:39] Andrew DeWolf: Is Kevin's the dad name?

[9:41] Jess McInally: I honestly I don't know.

[9:42] Andrew DeWolf: Kevin O'Shaping Bosario or something like that.

[9:44] Jess McInally: Yeah. And then as the plot goes, I mean, Nina it reveals to the parents that she dropped out of Stanford and they get upset and decide they're gonna sell the business to try to get the water.

[9:55] Andrew DeWolf: Well the dad decides.

[9:56] Jess McInally: The dad decides he's gonna sell the business, the mother isn't for it at first at the very least.

[10:00] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and neither is Nina. She's like, oh well, you you shouldn't sell your business or whatever. We should mention that her dad is basically an abusive dude.

[10:09] Jess McInally: Not not a good dude. He's not a great guy. He does seem to be like trying, but he's obviously not very good at it.

[10:16] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I don't know. Benny is also not in favor of them selling the business since he works for obviously.

[10:22] Jess McInally: Um, but he wants to open his own business uh and he sees it as practice. Usnavi uh doesn't really have motivations other than going out with Vanessa.

[10:34] Andrew DeWolf: I also just realized I skipped over Sonny.

[10:36] Jess McInally: Yes, he does he barely exists in the in the stage.

[10:39] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, he he just is a character, a goofy side character that makes jokes.

[10:44] Jess McInally: And has this slight social justice bent to him.

[10:48] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[10:48] Jess McInally: And by slight you mean he has one monologue in one song.

[10:52] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[10:53] Jess McInally: Um so Sonny's not even really worth mentioning. But we'll pretend he's there because he's important.

[11:01] Andrew DeWolf: He's important in the movie, and that's one of the good things about the movie we'll talk about.

[11:05] Jess McInally: Yeah. Usnavi doesn't really have motivations outside he wants to go out with Vanessa.

[11:11] Andrew DeWolf: Um, but he's afraid to ask her out, and then Sonny helps him ask her out.

[11:16] Jess McInally: Um then they start going out, and there's a lottery ticket. Uh he uh Usnavi's bodega sold a winning lottery ticket, and they don't know who it was.

[11:27] Andrew DeWolf: Um, but then it's revealed that it was uh the ticket that he gave to Abuela.

[11:32] Jess McInally: Um and Abuela approaches him and is like, we should move back to uh the Dominican Republic, like we'd have a lot of fun, you know, it'd be great. The beaches are cool, and Usnavi is like, yeah, let's do that. Then blackout.

[11:44] Andrew DeWolf: We he gets a date with Vanessa, but he kind of gets try-hard dude, and then a blackout happens, the entire block shut down.

[11:53] Jess McInally: Entire block shuts down. Um, I believe this is where Abuela dies.

[11:57] Andrew DeWolf: It takes a bit.

[11:59] Jess McInally: Um, but is there anything else important that happens between there?

[12:03] Andrew DeWolf: Carnaval del Barrio.

[12:06] Jess McInally: No.

[12:07] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, yeah, yeah. The characters that I haven't mentioned yet who run the beauty salon.

[12:11] Jess McInally: Yeah, uh, they are leaving.

[12:13] Andrew DeWolf: They leave.

[12:13] Jess McInally: Yeah.

[12:14] Andrew DeWolf: Um also Nina and Benny have sex.

[12:18] Jess McInally: Yeah.

[12:19] Andrew DeWolf: And then Abuela dies.

[12:21] Jess McInally: Abuela does. Everyone's sad.

[12:22] Andrew DeWolf: Everyone is sad.

[12:24] Jess McInally: I think it's sadder in the movie, but whatever.

[12:28] Andrew DeWolf: Well, talk, because people disagree with you.

[12:30] Jess McInally: People highly disagree with you.

[12:32] Andrew DeWolf: Schaefer Ellis disagrees with you.

[12:33] Jess McInally: Well, Schaefer Ellis has been wrong in the past.

[12:36] Andrew DeWolf: His hatred of the Shrek musical is very contentious, in my opinion.

[12:43] Jess McInally: Damn.

[12:46] Andrew DeWolf: Just saying.

[12:47] Jess McInally: I don't think there's nothing wrong with the Shrek musical.

[12:49] Andrew DeWolf: Usnavi decides he's still gonna go to the Dominican Republic alone.

[12:54] Jess McInally: Despite all that, he's got the $96,000 lottery ticket, splits it between him and Sonny.

[13:01] Andrew DeWolf: Yep.

[13:02] Jess McInally: He helps Vanessa move into an apartment where she isn't in Washington Heights anymore.

[13:07] Andrew DeWolf: But then Vanessa is like, hey, you should stay because Sonny needs you. He needs a daddy, despite being 25.

[13:14] Jess McInally: He looks like in mid-20s, mid to late 20s.

[13:17] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, but you know, and I guess that's really all it takes to convince him.

[13:21] Jess McInally: And then Nina decides she's gonna take the money to go back to Stanford, um, and the mother decides that she's okay with selling the business, and Benny doesn't get a say because he just works there.

[13:33] Andrew DeWolf: He's just an employee, it's not like they matter.

[13:36] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[13:36] Jess McInally: Um, and then uh it kind of just ends.

[13:41] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, yeah.

[13:42] Jess McInally: Um I feel like the lack of Usnavi having any real motivation or arc. He just kind of changes his mind at the end. It just kind of hurts the show, and he didn't even he didn't even like the movie makes a very big change right from the start where he is the one who wants to move back to the Dominican Republic.

[14:01] Andrew DeWolf: And Abuela needs convincing to even consider going.

[14:04] Jess McInally: Because she loves her boy. In this one, it's her idea, and he's just kind of like, whatever. I mean, I guess that sounds fine. Yeah, sure. It's it's almost like a character with no motivation, you know.

[14:17] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, alright, alright. This is gonna be different from even our like ones where we also cover the movie. This is basically gonna be a comparison episode where we're throughout this entire like episode. We're gonna be talking about the movie and the musical comparison.

[14:30] Jess McInally: Like Andrew texted me earlier today. He's like, Do I really need to watch the musical to like fare this? I'm like, Yes, we do. Yes, you do.

[14:40] Andrew DeWolf: The movie is very different.

[14:42] Jess McInally: Like it I don't know. I kinda still stand by that. I think it's better. I think it flows a lot better. I think that I know you get our upset that there's certain characters that get tossed aside a little bit, but I think that it focuses on the characters that probably should have been focused on more from the beginning.

[14:58] Andrew DeWolf: Um, because I think that they're just better. Let's just do let's do a quick transition into the movie.

[15:04] Jess McInally: Um so in Sure. The movie has been in development since basically the show hit Broadway in 2008.

[15:10] Andrew DeWolf: Um it was originally supposed to be Universal, but then they're like, who the fuck's gonna go see this movie? So they sold the rights back to Lynn Manuel Miranda and Alexandria.

[15:20] Jess McInally: Or yeah, back to uh uh Lynn Manuel Miranda. And then they sold the rights to the Weinstein Company in I think October 2017.

[15:30] Andrew DeWolf: Um no in May of 2016. But then, you know, um Weinstein was outed as being the horrible monster he was, and then they bought back the rights and they sold it to WB.

[15:41] Jess McInally: Um then John M. Chu was brought on.

[15:43] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and the film was originally supposed to come out last year, June of twenty twenty.

[15:49] Jess McInally: Um and then a great time. Then COVID happened and fucked that all up.

[15:55] Andrew DeWolf: And then it came out um just last weekend, July eleventh, or June June 11th.

[16:00] Jess McInally: And it it's done okay, but not the gangbuster hit they were hoping for, which kind of disappoints me because I really I want more musicals like this, moot musical films like this.

[16:12] Andrew DeWolf: Um And here's where I have the offhand remark about the casting, um the situation Lynn Manuel Miranda and the rest of the creative team is facing, and I'm only bringing this up because I have one point to make that kind of bothers me.

[16:26] Jess McInally: Mm-hmm. So the film has been criticized for its casting choices, which seemingly exclude Afro Latino actors with darker skin colors and misrepresented the demographic of Washington Heights.

[16:36] Andrew DeWolf: And then I mean that's a fair argument to make. Um but then Lynn Manuel Miranda issued an apology for it, and people are are attacking Lynn Manuel Miranda.

[16:47] Jess McInally: I've got a slight problem with this. Um yes, Lynn Manuel Miranda is a powerful man. He is listed as a producer of this film, but he's not the only person making these choices though.

[16:57] Andrew DeWolf: He's not even apologizing. Let me say this. Um when we talk about Cast 2019 and the casting choices of James Corden or Le Miz 2012, and we talk about Russell Crowe and Hugh Jackman.

[17:13] Jess McInally: We don't point the fingers at Alain Bobu and Claude Michel Schoenberg. We talk about cats in the animation. We don't point fingers at Andrew Lloyd Weber, and on all of them, those people are listed as producers in the same way that Lynn Manuel Miranda is.

[17:26] Andrew DeWolf: Why aren't we pointing the finger at John M. Chu, who is the one who has final say directorial choices? Is it just because Lynn Manuel Miranda is an easier target?

[17:36] Jess McInally: Who knows? I mean, there's some theory that if somebody apologizes for something, it's very easy to attack them because you're gonna get something out of them.

[17:45] Andrew DeWolf: You know what should have been I I mean, PR wise, and I am not a PR genius, and I don't have much to say about the controversy. The controversy is valid. I I agree with it.

[17:55] Jess McInally: Um now I'm just talking PR nonsense. It shouldn't have just been Lynn Manuel Miranda apologizing. He wasn't the one that made the choices.

[18:02] Andrew DeWolf: Um it should be him, John M Choo, um Miss Hughes, uh, Kiara Alegria Hughes. All of them should have come together, signed an apology together, and they post on the In the Heights movie page, like we fucked up collectively as a team.

[18:16] Jess McInally: Instead it's Lynn Manuel and Miranda coming out and say, I fucked up as a man who did not direct this movie. And that bothers me.

[18:23] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[18:24] Jess McInally: I mean yeah.

[18:25] Andrew DeWolf: Yep.

[18:26] Jess McInally: It's it's a tough situation to be in. I I don't want to contribute to it too much though because I know internet mobs can be it's just a thing to think about.

[18:36] Andrew DeWolf: Um a thing that bothered me like he didn't direct this movie. He didn't make the casting choices.

[18:39] Jess McInally: Yeah.

[18:42] Andrew DeWolf: But do we want to harass the director because he did direct the movie?

[18:45] Jess McInally: I mean I don't think maybe if we go to the studio you could go to the studio because WB I mean they probably have a lot of say on that I don't know.

[18:53] Andrew DeWolf: And let me s w now it's time to talk about the movie a bit.

[18:57] Jess McInally: You like the movie. You think it's better than the musical?

[19:00] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.

[19:01] Jess McInally: Um I think there are elements that are better than the musical in here.

[19:05] Andrew DeWolf: Um there's a lot of stuff I like a lot. I think just the cinematic techniques are impressive as all hell.

[19:11] Jess McInally: Um 96000 is one of the most amazing filmed musical theater sequences I've ever seen.

[19:17] Andrew DeWolf: That entire song is great. Piancia Faye, which is basically Patience and Faith.

[19:23] Jess McInally: That is one of the best musical theater scenes of all time, like in any musical ever.

[19:29] Andrew DeWolf: That is so incredible. However, Nina and Benny are just thrown off the sidelines.

[19:36] Jess McInally: Um Benny and his conflict with um Nina's dad. Basically non-existent, which is an important part and an important commentary on race relations between like Latin people and black communities.

[19:50] Andrew DeWolf: Sure.

[19:50] Jess McInally: Um though I would say that it's also kind of toss of the side in the stage show as well. I don't think that that gets nearly enough time.

[19:57] Andrew DeWolf: It does, but it means more when he gets together during the blackout um with Betty and they both get on the dispatch.

[20:04] Jess McInally: It means throwing away their differences. And just the fact that Nina's dad just sees him as beneath his daughter it's an interesting dynamic and it makes um Nina's dad a much more interesting character.

[20:17] Andrew DeWolf: Um especially his song number where he's worried about being useless, that is also super important and reflects like how people immigrants can come in here wanting to get bigger and bigger and just that can be pressure on your children.

[20:32] Jess McInally: And that was interesting. We lose a lot of those elements.

[20:35] Andrew DeWolf: I think that there's a um there's a strong message in the movie about both the dream acts and dreamers and uh gentrification that is not nearly as strong in the stage show.

[20:48] Jess McInally: Um I agree appreciate. Um the whole aspect of him selling the business becomes a lot stronger when you realize that he's selling it to someone who's ripping off everyone in the town.

[20:59] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[21:01] Jess McInally: You know, like somebody who is literally gentrifying the neighborhood, and yet that's who he's being forced to sell to.

[21:08] Andrew DeWolf: Um also the idea that his business is failing um and it isn't doing well.

[21:14] Jess McInally: I mean, I don't know.

[21:15] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, and the fact that we already started off with like the pressure being applied with he already sold half his business to Patrick Page.

[21:22] Jess McInally: Yeah.

[21:22] Andrew DeWolf: That's a good addition to like have that looming there, that ticking clock.

[21:26] Jess McInally: I think the uh whole concept of I've already said Usnavi actually having a motivation to leave, um, which also ties into Vanessa having a motivation to leave, um, and them both having that same motivation to leave and both convincing each other not to leave.

[21:43] Andrew DeWolf: Um that's really good. Only in the movie.

[21:46] Jess McInally: Um I think moving the song, uh I'm just gonna say patience and faith because I'm not good at pronouncing Spanish. I'm sorry.

[21:53] Andrew DeWolf: Is it even Spanish?

[21:55] Jess McInally: I'm I I think it is, but that song number has a lot more power when it's her like you know, death number.

[22:04] Andrew DeWolf: The last lines where she's like, and now should I stay or go means more when it's about should I die or stick around versus should I just leave.

[22:15] Jess McInally: Yeah.

[22:16] Andrew DeWolf: Um it doesn't feel like a conflict for her in the musical, in the stage musical.

[22:21] Jess McInally: It feels like, yeah, I'm gonna get the fuck out of here. Whereas here it's like, oh, I I love my block and my people.

[22:28] Andrew DeWolf: Like, have I have I finished my work here, basically.

[22:32] Jess McInally: Right. But also it cuts her out of a lot of the second act.

[22:37] Andrew DeWolf: Let me tell you why I think the movie is objectively perfect as a movie.

[22:43] Jess McInally: Like I I know it sounds like I'm on the detriment side of the movie because we're having a talk about it, and I I think there are good things about the musical too.

[22:51] Andrew DeWolf: It is a perfect adaptation from stage to screen.

[22:55] Jess McInally: Perfect as it can be. Because it does it isn't constrained by the act break, the same way like something like Into the Woods is.

[23:04] Andrew DeWolf: That's a great example of why that doesn't work, where they try to turn that into a three-act story.

[23:09] Jess McInally: What they do is p firmly plant Usnavi as the main character and give him a hero's journey arc.

[23:16] Andrew DeWolf: Um that basically he has a Luke Skywalker arc, if you think about it. He has a goal.

[23:22] Jess McInally: He's like, I'm gonna go out and do this thing. I am gonna put all these things in place to do these things.

[23:27] Andrew DeWolf: I'm gonna meet with um Sonny's dad to try to get him to go with it. I'm gonna convince um grandma to do it.

[23:30] Jess McInally: But in order for Abuela to want to go with it, um I need to convince Sonny to want to go with it.

[23:37] Andrew DeWolf: Sonny doesn't want to go with it. It's going out, the call to adventure and trying to get the call.

[23:43] Jess McInally: Um, and then what happens in the m like right at the middle of the film?

[23:47] Andrew DeWolf: He loses his Obi-Wan character, his guiding force, his light.

[23:52] Jess McInally: They have to die, and then he has to figure out what he needs as opposed to what he wants for the rest of it without that guiding light.

[23:59] Andrew DeWolf: It is a narrative, it is a story with an O.

[24:01] Jess McInally: And then he decides that he's gonna leave, even though Sonny's not gonna come with him and he just has to go.

[24:06] Andrew DeWolf: He just he's just gonna go.

[24:08] Jess McInally: But then at the very end, he's like, No, I shouldn't do that. You know?

[24:12] Andrew DeWolf: It's it's I don't know. It's really good.

[24:14] Jess McInally: Mm-hmm.

[24:15] Andrew DeWolf: And they trick you with the bait switch um um framing device where they make you think that he's in the Dominican Republic talking to kids, and then they're like, Nope, nope, it's just his bodega, except he made it all Dominican.

[24:27] Jess McInally: Which is uh it's fun.

[24:29] Andrew DeWolf: It's fun to play with the audience expectations like that.

[24:31] Jess McInally: Cause I I was like, Oh, so he does he just eventually gets there, and we're just gonna watch it. Because I didn't know, you know.

[24:37] Andrew DeWolf: So it's like it well, I mean, he's there now, so he must get there eventually.

[24:42] Jess McInally: I like Vanessa having a fashion like that's what she wants to do.

[24:47] Andrew DeWolf: I like that being integrated into the final scene, and it isn't just like a spray painting of Abuela, it is like her like showing her talents and being a part of it.

[24:57] Jess McInally: Because she just kind of disappears after champagne in the musical.

[25:01] Andrew DeWolf: Um I don't quite know if I love Flashing to the Future and them being married.

[25:06] Jess McInally: I don't know if they're a couple meant to be married.

[25:09] Andrew DeWolf: That kind of aspect of it feels like a like movie ending, like, oh they gotta be happy with kids, because that's what everyone has to be.

[25:20] Jess McInally: Nuclear heterosexual families.

[25:23] Andrew DeWolf: Which you can criticize as much as you want, but I mean that's fine, it's a movie ending.

[25:27] Jess McInally: It just makes me sad to know that like 10 15 years down the road, they're in the same fucking place.

[25:33] Andrew DeWolf: She does not become a fashion designer, he does not go back or do anything.

[25:37] Jess McInally: That depresses me.

[25:38] Andrew DeWolf: They just live a life, have a shitty kid.

[25:41] Jess McInally: I mean the point of the story though is that they were being forced to leave.

[25:46] Andrew DeWolf: You know, Patrick Page is gonna buy the whole place.

[25:49] Jess McInally: So the fact that they're still there is good.

[25:53] Andrew DeWolf: Right?

[25:55] Jess McInally: You're right.

[25:56] Andrew DeWolf: You're right.

[25:56] Jess McInally: You make a good point.

[25:58] Andrew DeWolf: The uh gentrifiers didn't win, and Sonny is still there, even though he is a uh illegal immigrant.

[26:08] Jess McInally: Undocumented immigrant.

[26:10] Andrew DeWolf: I love the fact that you're if I'm using wrong terms.

[26:12] Jess McInally: Undocumented.

[26:14] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I love the fact that Yusnavi's goals is not predicated on having a bunch of money.

[26:21] Jess McInally: He was gonna do this anyway. The money helped, and it could have been his answer to like solving all of his problems, but instead he has to do the selfless thing and give it to Sonny for him to have a future.

[26:32] Andrew DeWolf: That is so much better than just like, hey, I've got money now.

[26:35] Jess McInally: The lottery ticket thing, it feels better.

[26:37] Andrew DeWolf: I I don't know fully how I feel about him just kinda throwing it to Sonny to like do that, but it is certainly better than what they did in the stage show, which is just like wouldn't it be cool if he just won a bunch of money and then he did.

[26:51] Jess McInally: I agree.

[26:52] Andrew DeWolf: I don't like it.

[26:53] Jess McInally: Um the musical though does the Benny and Nina scenes are incredible in the musical.

[26:59] Andrew DeWolf: It's some of my favorite pieces in this entire story.

[27:02] Jess McInally: Like Sunrise is probably my favorite scene in the entire musical, and they just cut it in the movie because of how they changed up the structure and how they wanted Pay Pashense Faye um to be during the blackout.

[27:16] Andrew DeWolf: So it'd be really weird if we cut from like Pashansei Fey and Alabanza to just meet Nina and Benny fucking.

[27:25] Jess McInally: I kind of don't care though. I don't know. Having seen the stage show, I don't find Nina and Benny that interesting, to be honest.

[27:35] Andrew DeWolf: It's such a cool scene where it's like a post-coital like Spanish lesson where he's trying to learn her culture.

[27:41] Jess McInally: That's the important part. The attempt to learn their culture and from the outsider.

[27:45] Andrew DeWolf: He could have been the outsider looking in and the like the one person that isn't a part of the Latin community. I don't think it's necessary for what the story in the movie is trying to tell, though.

[27:56] Jess McInally: And it might even muddle it. Well, the movie just firmly puts Usnavi as the main character.

[28:02] Andrew DeWolf: I agree. I just also think that's uh it's a given too much.

[28:06] Jess McInally: I understand. I'm not saying that there's nothing done better in the stage show. I just think if I was gonna recommend this to anybody, I'd just say watch the movie.

[28:13] Andrew DeWolf: I mean the movie's great. The movie is a great movie.

[28:17] Jess McInally: What do you think the stage show did better, if anything?

[28:20] Andrew DeWolf: I mean it did flesh out Nina and her family and Benny more.

[28:25] Jess McInally: I mean that is true. I mean they remove they completely remove the mother character from the movie.

[28:31] Andrew DeWolf: Made her a Disney princess killed off a parent.

[28:33] Jess McInally: Yep they're just like okay bye you're not needed because I mean realistically they simplified that whole story arc so they didn't need her.

[28:41] Andrew DeWolf: So and he the dad is just much nicer which I don't know if I like.

[28:45] Jess McInally: Well I think he's nicer because he is now both the dad and the mom at the same time.

[28:50] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[28:52] Jess McInally: And they I will say the movie does give Nina a reason to want to go back to school as opposed to just like, you know my dad told me to which is I want to help people like Sonny.

[29:02] Andrew DeWolf: Actually I wanna say I think even in the even the Nina story you could argue is better in the movie because of that.

[29:08] Jess McInally: Um I was a little I was honestly a little bit confused when she in the stage show was just like I guess I have to go back to Stanford you're right It's like wait but you just said you're not gonna accept the money you're not gonna do it because you you don't want him to sell the business but then she just goes and she's like no no we should do it you're right and then the mom's like okay I guess I'm okay with the business being sold.

[29:32] Andrew DeWolf: Agency they give Nina agency. They give Vanessa agency.

[29:36] Jess McInally: I don't know. I think the movie just feels like it's more of a story. It feels like it had something shit happening. It feels like it had something really to say.

[29:47] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know. I personally I think the movie was better.

[29:52] Jess McInally: Alright, alright, alright. I get what you're saying. I really, really do, but also there's like there's arguments to be made.

[30:02] Andrew DeWolf: And I don't even think I disagree with you, is the problem.

[30:04] Jess McInally: Oh come on. And those fantasy dance sequences. I mean, you can't do that.

[30:07] Andrew DeWolf: Holy shit. You can't do that on stage.

[30:10] Jess McInally: It's so good. And you know what? I'm gonna make an argument here. I think every movie musical should be better than the stage adaptation.

[30:18] Andrew DeWolf: Because movies can do more than the stage can.

[30:21] Jess McInally: So I think the fact that they are not is a huge disservice to the medium.

[30:26] Andrew DeWolf: I agree. I think realistically, every single time a movie version of a musical gets made, you should expect it to be better than the stage adaptation.

[30:35] Jess McInally: I mean, in some cases, just some things don't adapt well.

[30:39] Andrew DeWolf: I will say that.

[30:41] Jess McInally: Well, then they shouldn't be getting adapted.

[30:44] Andrew DeWolf: Like, I wouldn't know the right way to adapt Lay Miz.

[30:48] Jess McInally: I mean, not how they've done it.

[30:51] Andrew DeWolf: No, definitely not how they did it, but I don't know if there's a better way I would have thought of.

[30:56] Jess McInally: I mean, honestly, if they did it how they did it, but they actually got singers to play the actors, it probably would have been really good.

[31:04] Andrew DeWolf: But you know what? Lay Miz made a lot more money than this did.

[31:07] Jess McInally: Well, this has only been out for like a week when we're talking about it right now.

[31:11] Andrew DeWolf: Even opening weekend, I made a lot more money.

[31:14] Jess McInally: Well, people don't like feeling there is a lameiz scene in this movie, and did you could you tell what it was?

[31:22] Andrew DeWolf: I don't think I noticed. What was it?

[31:24] Jess McInally: The champagne scene.

[31:26] Andrew DeWolf: That is a literal Tom Hooper scene. It is one take done entirely live.

[31:31] Jess McInally: Hmm.

[31:32] Andrew DeWolf: You bet you didn't even notice.

[31:33] Jess McInally: I did not. Because it's so effectively done.

[31:35] Andrew DeWolf: And I noticed because I'm like, man, we we aren't cutting, are we? This is like pretty claustrophobic.

[31:41] Jess McInally: I also really like the um actual like record scratch that they were able to do in the movie, um, which I think was cool.

[31:47] Andrew DeWolf: They didn't have like a musical.

[31:49] Jess McInally: Yeah, but they didn't have a singer like literally repeating it. They had like an actual record player. You know?

[31:55] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, so they set it up a little bit.

[31:57] Jess McInally: Yeah. Also, another thing we should bring up, I love the fact that they made Carla and Daniela lesbians um in a relationship. It that is a great touch.

[32:06] Andrew DeWolf: Um the age gap bothers me a little bit.

[32:09] Jess McInally: Yeah, what are you gonna do?

[32:13] Andrew DeWolf: And if I'm gonna critique this movie a bit, it does look a little grey. Like the block doesn't look very colorful. It looks like just strange overcast day with gray, like you could have painted it to be a little bit more bright.

[32:26] Jess McInally: That's that's nitpicky shit though.

[32:28] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. I think overall though, it was it was very good and and it makes me a little bit hopeful for some of these upcoming musical movies.

[32:37] Jess McInally: Let's talk about the future here. This director has been confirmed to be directing the wicked movie, and I was dubious when that was first announced, and then I saw this and I saw the patient CFA um scene, and I was like, oh no, I want I I'm this is good. This will be fine.

[32:52] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, if if they are able to pull off this movie in this way, which I don't even think this musical is like one of the best or even close to it, but this movie just makes it so good.

[33:06] Jess McInally: I don't know. It takes the content and elevates it. Um and it's not even a fantastical kind of musical. It's a place of life kind of. It's honestly extremely grounded.

[33:18] Andrew DeWolf: Um, but they turn it into this fantastical thing by creating these gigantic dance scenes and like I don't I don't know how big the budget was, but it felt like a big budget thing because of how many people they had dancing and the locations that they used and the effects that they did.

[33:35] Jess McInally: I don't know. It felt great.

[33:38] Andrew DeWolf: How does this compare to something like the Rent movie, which is also very high budget, very um fantastical in moments, slice of life, because this in Lynn Manuel Miranda's own words is his rent, his version of rent.

[33:56] Jess McInally: Um, which is and I can see that, obviously. It like in the not nearly as progressive. Say that. Um it had different things to say, but um this is his version of Rent, his slice of life kind of movie.

[34:11] Andrew DeWolf: And Rent also, when adapted into a film, embraced the more fantastical elements, like the tangoine type segments.

[34:19] Jess McInally: I'm gonna be I'm gonna be fully honest. I cannot remember the Rent movie.

[34:25] Andrew DeWolf: Nothing.

[34:27] Jess McInally: Nothing.

[34:28] Andrew DeWolf: Oh Mike. I guess Patreon, we got a new commentary we've got to do.

[34:33] Jess McInally: It's been a very long time.

[34:34] Andrew DeWolf: I did watch it. I do not remember.

[34:35] Jess McInally: I know you did. We have we have an episode to show for it.

[34:39] Andrew DeWolf: I don't remember it. I really don't.

[34:43] Jess McInally: I think it's time to compare our opinions to those of the New York theater critics when this first came out. It's time for a breeze.

[34:48] Andrew DeWolf: But sadly, Bree isn't here. So Andrew, time to whip out um Ben Shapiro Brantley.

[34:57] Jess McInally: It's Tom for it. It's time for previews.

[35:04] Andrew DeWolf: Oh good God. I'm losing my touch with this Ben Shapiro Brantley.

[35:08] Jess McInally: Alright. New York Times, Ben Brantley said of the original 1999.

[35:12] Andrew DeWolf: 2009.

[35:13] Jess McInally: 2009 production.

[35:15] Andrew DeWolf: Where is this 1997 number coming from?

[35:17] Jess McInally: Um that's from something else we did. I don't know.

[35:24] Andrew DeWolf: 2009.

[35:26] Jess McInally: Eight?

[35:26] Andrew DeWolf: Eight?

[35:27] Jess McInally: Yeah, 2008.

[35:28] Andrew DeWolf: 2008 production.

[35:30] Jess McInally: In addition to the aforementioned characters, there is Usnavi's cocky 16-year-old cousin Sonny, the impliciously funny Robin DeJesus.

[35:39] Andrew DeWolf: Uh is that Jesus.

[35:41] Jess McInally: Jesus, pardon me. Um, eager to give Usnavi tips on how to woo the girl he's got a secret crush on.

[35:48] Andrew DeWolf: She is the ambitious Vanessa, uh, Karen Olivio, all all legs and voice in parentheses here, whose ardent wish is to move out of the barrio.

[35:58] Jess McInally: Unfortunately, she's got a mother draining her resources and a serious credit problem.

[36:04] Andrew DeWolf: The vivacious Daniela and Andrea Burns. Uh choice choicely tart. I don't even know what he means by that.

[36:13] Jess McInally: Nope.

[36:15] Andrew DeWolf: Who owns the beauty salon where Vanessa works is on the move whether she likes it or not. Priced out of the hood, she's packing up her straighteners and moving to the Bronx.

[36:26] Jess McInally: Um, I I want to stop there. I I picked that segment specifically because of the parentheses that just show kind of how sexist Ben Brantley is.

[36:34] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, we're all legs and no I I even got he didn't say all legs and no voice, he said all legs and voice. Um meaning there's no personality, which I don't know if I disagree with.

[36:46] Jess McInally: Well, is he saying that about the character or is he saying that about the actress?

[36:51] Andrew DeWolf: That's a fair point. Because if he's if he's saying that about the actress, that's rude.

[36:56] Jess McInally: Yeah.

[36:57] Andrew DeWolf: Choicely Tart is another one I just don't like as a description of a human being.

[37:01] Jess McInally: Yeah.

[37:02] Andrew DeWolf: Alright. Uh. I mean, he's so far not inaccurate in the non-parentheses stuff.

[37:11] Jess McInally: You could easily be cynical about the show's heartfelt belief in the possibility of a little love and a big lottery win, making all things right. But then Mr. Miranda bounces on stage, throwing down rhymes and you know throwing his arms open wide, as if to embrace the whole mezzanine.

[37:27] Andrew DeWolf: He seems to embody music's ability to take the trite. To make the trite seem true again. And after all, this scrappy little musical about chasing your dreams and finding your true home is Mr. Miranda's own dream come true.

[37:42] Jess McInally: He couldn't look more at home.

[37:44] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Can we talk about Lynn Manuel Miranda's performance in the Broadway show?

[37:49] Jess McInally: It's fine.

[37:51] Andrew DeWolf: Anthony Ramos knocks him out of the park, though.

[37:54] Jess McInally: Anthony Ramos brings so much to that movie version of the character that wasn't in the script.

[37:59] Andrew DeWolf: And Lynn Manuel Miranda gives off the vibe of like your dad jokes friend, the guy that tells all the dad jokes.

[38:07] Jess McInally: Lynn Manuel Miranda needs to um start writing more and stop acting as much.

[38:14] Andrew DeWolf: You see, I don't think he's a bad actor when he's not doing his own shows.

[38:18] Jess McInally: That's kind of the thing.

[38:19] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. I can't remember. I think he was fine in that Mary Poppins thing.

[38:25] Jess McInally: Yeah, he wasn't the problem.

[38:26] Andrew DeWolf: He's very good as Charlie and Merrill we roll along. He was very good when he played uh Jonathan and Tic Tick Boom.

[38:33] Jess McInally: He nails it when he's not doing his own material.

[38:37] Andrew DeWolf: Um, but when he's in his own material, he's just playing a self-insert.

[38:40] Jess McInally: Um, I know what you're like, Lynn.

[38:43] Andrew DeWolf: Um, even in Hamilton, it's just like, what if I was Hamilton, but it's just me, you know?

[38:48] Jess McInally: It's just me. I'm just doing it.

[38:49] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like he was actually pretty decent in the movie as like uh that jokey side character.

[38:54] Jess McInally: Uh Piragua.

[38:55] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. I feel like he was probably better there than he was when he was actually playing the lead.

[39:00] Jess McInally: I agree. He's a lot of fun character actor that you like to see as a little jokey fun thing.

[39:06] Andrew DeWolf: Um that's how I felt about him and Mary Poppins. He was not the problem in Mary Poppins Returns.

[39:10] Jess McInally: No.

[39:11] Andrew DeWolf: That movie had issues, but it wasn't him.

[39:14] Jess McInally: Yeah.

[39:15] Andrew DeWolf: Um I like Lynn Man Wall Miranda. His voice works. I don't think he has a bad singing voice. I'm sick of people being like, oh, you just can't say No, he he can sing fine. He's good.

[39:24] Jess McInally: He's he's he would be great in Sontime stuff. He is great in Sondime stuff.

[39:29] Andrew DeWolf: Um he'd be a great MC in cabaret, like fuck it. Just when he does his own work, he gets a little lost and he can't really analyze the text since he wrote the text.

[39:39] Jess McInally: Yeah, he might have a different idea of what he intended to write versus what's actually written.

[39:45] Andrew DeWolf: So maybe that's maybe an issue. Like he doesn't see the character the same way everyone else does because he has all this like extra stuff about the character that isn't there.

[39:54] Jess McInally: I mean, Vanessa is literally his wife's name. It's a self-insert kind of story. You it's impossible to be objective and to play that objectively, and that's not his fault.

[40:04] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[40:04] Jess McInally: Um but when he's given a character to play, he's great.

[40:07] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Stop picking on him, kids.

[40:09] Jess McInally: Including myself, I guess, because I am kind of picking on him right now.

[40:12] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. So what do you think of this review?

[40:15] Jess McInally: Which just seems to be vaguely positive.

[40:17] Andrew DeWolf: Vaguely positive. You know, it's fine.

[40:19] Jess McInally: Ben Brantley. You you gave a review. Good for you.

[40:22] Andrew DeWolf: I think I agree. I mean, uh, as far as the stage show goes, I'm also vaguely positive about it. You know, for a musical without any arcs that's so sliced of life, I am surprised it did as well as it did and got as many positive reviews as it did. I think what I really like better about the movie is that it just it does make it have character arcs.

[40:44] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know. Character arcs, it ties it all together. If we were women are more better represented. I think if we were just doing a show, like uh if we were doing an episode on the stage show and that's it, I probably would be middling about this show. But the movie added a lot for me. I don't know. You know what a better version of In the Heights is? The the musical?

[41:07] Jess McInally: What?

[41:08] Andrew DeWolf: Aside from the movie? The Band's Visit. That's another slice of life kind of musical that kind of but it has arcs and wraps it up very well. I think it just it really does in the um stage show, it really does feel like nothing happens.

[41:22] Jess McInally: Yeah.

[41:22] Andrew DeWolf: Can't argue you can also dies.

[41:25] Jess McInally: Yeah, other than that.

[41:26] Andrew DeWolf: But in the movie you can also argue that nothing really happens, but you can't argue that the characters didn't learn anything. Um, so you watched the movie with a group. Correct?

[41:36] Jess McInally: Yeah.

[41:37] Andrew DeWolf: What do they all think about it? I'm curious.

[41:41] Jess McInally: Um, honestly, it was pretty positive. I think everybody enjoyed it. I didn't like analyze or ask, like, well, exactly what did you think, but yeah, overall everyone was seeming to have a good time with it.

[41:52] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, because I took my girlfriend to my screening. It was a free screening that I went to. Um and she the best way to describe her is she likes musicals, but only the really good ones.

[42:04] Jess McInally: Okay.

[42:04] Andrew DeWolf: So this is a ma this is a very big maybe.

[42:07] Jess McInally: Yeah.

[42:09] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and she had not seen those stage musicals. She liked Hamilton, though. Like everyone likes fucking Hamilton. But Hamilton is one where you'd probably put that into the really good ones category.

[42:17] Jess McInally: Yeah.

[42:18] Andrew DeWolf: Um so we sit down, and I remember. Um she caught Patrick Page, because of course she knows Hades Town. Um but I remember right when Abuela died, and there's Alabanza, and there's a joke about an intermission, because like this is usually where the intermission hits. Um and he's like, Y'all want to break? And I was like, nutshell, and I was like, intermission joke. She's like, intermission, it's not almost over. And I was like, oh. And we left, she's like, it was fine. About an hour too long. And I'm like, really? I can see it though, because there is not very much going on.

[42:57] Jess McInally: Yeah.

[42:58] Andrew DeWolf: I didn't personally feel like it went too long, but I could see someone having that take.

[43:02] Jess McInally: I didn't feel the length at all, honestly.

[43:04] Andrew DeWolf: Can I just uh throw out there that um lore-wise, uh Abuela's death and Jacob's Ladder tie together.

[43:12] Jess McInally: Do we compare are we comparing everything to Jacob's Ladder again?

[43:15] Andrew DeWolf: I thought we cancelled that after like episode 50.

[43:18] Jess McInally: Not canceling it. We're going back to it.

[43:20] Andrew DeWolf: Uh she dies, and the first thing she does is come out of a subway, um, which is literally the opening to Jacob's Ladder. So just throwing it out there. I'm just saying. Just saying, you know, hypothetically. You know? Um, they even do the thing where you can see her dying, like, in real life, and then also her dying in the fantasy world, which Jacob's Ladder also does simultaneously. Um, it's the same lore, and Abuela is not gonna be having a good time for the next couple weeks um until she goes to heaven with Macaulay Culkin.

[43:55] Jess McInally: Before we go into a mid-show, we've now covered the three Lin-Manuel Miranda musicals. We've we've done it, kids. Um, Andrew, I know it was like very early in our run, but can you rank them in order right now? Between Hamilton, 21 Chump Street, and this.

[44:13] Andrew DeWolf: Am I ranking only the stage show for this, or do I count the movie too?

[44:17] Jess McInally: Stage show alone.

[44:18] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. I think I'm gonna have to do it I think I actually would change the rating based on the movie. I think I would go Hamilton at the top, 21 Chump Street, and then the stage show of this. And then if we ranked the movie, Hamilton on top, the movie, and then 21 Chump Street.

[44:36] Jess McInally: Wow. Well, that's interesting. But we're gonna talk about the songs when we come back.

[44:40] Jess McInally: We interrupt this program to bring you a special report. Hello, this is Jess from the future to interrupt your podcast already in progress. So I meant to bring this up in the initial recording, but forgot, so I'm adding it here now. I was able to interview the screenwriter of In the Heights, and she also wrote the book of the original musical, Chiara Allegra Hudis, who is wonderful, by the way. But in my interview, I was able to sneak in asking her what her cheese rating would be for In the Heights. And I think I should add in here so it could be public record and added onto the official cheese rating list made by Juliet Antonio or Keeper of the Cheese. So take a listen to this clip of when I interviewed the screenwriter of In the Heights.

[45:20] Jess McInally: Alright. I think I could squeeze in one more question here. I'm really appreciative of your time, and don't worry, this is not gonna be a real question. Um what is your favorite cheese? I run a podcast called Musicals with Cheese, and I love getting people's opinions on cheese.

[45:34] Chiara Allegra Hudis: I was like, musicals with cheese? Um I'll tell you what. There it on the best date nights I've ever had. My husband and I have splurged and gone to El Comedor, a very fancy hotel in Old San Juan. And they have a cheese hour. And on their patio, a slice of aged Manchego cheese is just about perfection.

[46:00] Jess McInally: That is as good an answer I think I could ever have asked for. My goodness. Um, that that was great. Um, since I have a little bit of free time, what cheese would you uh equate with In the Heights? Just a rating of cheese, like if you had to compare it to it.

[46:15] Chiara Allegra Hudis: Ooh. Um, you know, probably like an oozy shredded cheese that's just like sprinkled on everything and gets into all the good stuff.

[46:26] Jess McInally: Wow, isn't that neat? Alright, time to get back to the show already in progress. Today's show is brought to you by the extremely kind donations by our donors at Patreon. You can go to Patreon to donate to us and help us keep the lights on and help us put out some good content for you all. We also have additional content on Patreon like commentaries and Patreon with Cheese, which is an occasional show where we cover TV shows and other musical-related things. Um, and we of course have a pretty large backlog on there. We also do uh monthly meetups with our uh with our patrons as well. Our current patrons are Melissa Goldman, Terry Needleman, John Donna, Lighton Accles, Danielle Renics, Jess the Stampede, Ewan Cassidy, Taskeer, Fire of September, Monica Thoreau, Mina Maneri, Brent Black, Haley Murray, B Way Flicks, Lithanial Stacey Coombe, Joseph Evans Green, Carrie Ahern, Mary Lou Choquette, John Van Ales, heck you I go by Elijah now, Russ Walker, Musical Hell, Emily Gracie, Andrew Van Barsen, Tablam, Kyle Summers, Janae C, Christina Francis, Scootin' the Technicolor Dreamcoat, uh Thelice R. Liz Lim, Allison Staller, nothing is certain except Beth and Taxes.

John Vanels, Thespian, Ren Cullen, Wait in the Wings, Spectacle Machine, Jacob Stroop, Raphael Martinez, Salas, uh, Robert Benjamin, Rochelle T, Jessica T, Genevieve Hartnett, Cass, uh Mitchell Young, Chai Teacup, Hayden Wilder, Katie McDonough, uh, Timothy Keyes, Jeffrey Machado, uh, Jacuse, Toon Van Essen, uh, Jesse Taylor, R. Elliott, Chris Marquette, uh, Alexandria Seng, Katie Turberg, Mimu, Kiji Marie Anastasio, Trevor Lopez, and Sierra Moncrief. They all give us all extra financial support, and Andrew described very well what they get when they're joined. Um, how about we go on to the songs, Andrew?

[48:27] Andrew DeWolf: I think we can do that.

[48:35] Jess McInally: That was Abuela. She's not really my abuela, but she practically raised me. This corner is her escuela now. You probably think I'm up sh. I've never been north of 96th Street. Well, you must take the A train even farther than Harlem to Northern Manhattan and maintain. Get off at 181st and take the escalator. I hope you writing this down. I'm gonna test you later.

[48:58] Andrew DeWolf: I'm getting tested. Times are tough on this Bodega. Two months ago, somebody bought Otagers. I maybe started packing up and picking up another system right. When up is gotten mad, expensive, but we live with just enough in the ice.

[49:33] Jess McInally: That opening number though, right? That opening number's fantastic. That opening shot was like really good.

[49:40] Andrew DeWolf: No, no, uh, In the Heights, uh, is probably one of the best, not the best, because I think uh I don't know, if we're just counting songs, it might be the best, like music-wise. It's very catchy.

[49:53] Jess McInally: It is very, very catchy.

[49:54] Andrew DeWolf: And like when I took my girlfriend to see it, that's the only song she can hum at the end, which if you count that for anything, that that's what you get. It's pretty good. And it strangely doesn't pop up very much throughout the rest of it. It's not like a recurring thing. Which it probably should have been. But I guess it doesn't have to be. It's fine.

[50:15] Jess McInally: Mm-hmm. Um, I will say, like, the bouncy kind of more uh Dominican style um hits better than like the ballads, which feel a little generic in this musical.

[50:27] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I think Lin-Manuel Miranda's best stuff is usually the bouncier, like uh Yeah.

[50:34] Jess McInally: You know, I I don't know if you'd call it rap in this, but kind of hip-hop, kind of yeah, hip-hop, hip-hop style.

[50:41] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it feels alive, it feels in a way. Whereas as much as I know people love Breathe a ton. Um Breathe, which is Nina's song about like how she won't live up.

[51:02] Jess McInally: I need a stun with Science Day.

[51:17] Andrew DeWolf: So I knew it's made the great. But maybe I should have to stay. When I was a child, I stayed wide awake, climbed to the highest place on every fire escape, readless time. I got every scholarship saved, every dollar. The first to go to college.

[51:53] Jess McInally: Asking Gina. What'll you be?

[52:02] Andrew DeWolf: I think the song Breathe is like not really delivered on in the movie. The visuals are great. There are fantastic visuals throughout it. Um I just think the actress she gives me Vanessa Hudgens in high school musical vibes.

[52:16] Jess McInally: She smiley.

[52:18] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, almost like the girl from the prom who is smiling throughout every situation.

[52:24] Jess McInally: Yeah.

[52:24] Andrew DeWolf: I don't particularly buy her in most scenes. Um the actress playing Vanessa is fantastic. Are there just directors out there that are like, it's a musical, smile. Come on.

[52:34] Jess McInally: Dad, I I was searched at school.

[52:42] Andrew DeWolf: Oh boy. It's like a and I like a jungle. But I just it just doesn't feel engaging. And the struggles that she's supposed to be going through, I don't quite feel in the movie because of that performance.

[52:53] Jess McInally: Yeah, fair enough. I mean, yeah. I can definitely I wasn't paying too much attention to that. And I didn't have much in the movie, I didn't have any expectation that she would be like the lead, where arguably she is in the stage show. So she gets the I Want song. She gets the second song in the musical.

[53:09] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[53:10] Jess McInally: So yeah. I don't think Breathe is a great number, though, honestly, and I don't blame her for not performing it that well since I don't think it was really that great to begin with.

[53:19] Andrew DeWolf: I love Breathe, um, as an idea. Like as a song on its own. It's great. And I've heard it before. I saw it in context, and I think it is a song along alone with what I imagined it was about. It is better than what it is in context.

[53:36] Jess McInally: Yeah. Let's talk about No Me Diga, which is a fun as fuck number about gossip. Come on.

[53:44] Andrew DeWolf: Gorgeous. Tell me something I don't know.

[53:49] Jess McInally: Yeah. Little bit of news you heard about the body home. Tell me something I don't know. Well, you didn't hear this from me. But some little birdie told me.

[54:19] Andrew DeWolf: This is the new Piccolo Talk a little here. It's pretty good. Um, the is this is the Tell Me Something I Don't Know song.

[54:26] Jess McInally: Yeah.

[54:27] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, this is a very fun one, and I like that they have that serious turn like halfway through. Um, you know, like when they finally do get something they didn't know, and they're like, oh yeah.

[54:36] Jess McInally: Oh shoot.

[54:38] Andrew DeWolf: Oh no, and that's how we the audience learned it.

[54:41] Jess McInally: Yeah, it's good. It's good. It's a very fun number.

[54:44] Andrew DeWolf: How do you think it was done in the movie? Because that that's one of the times where they embrace just fantasy, they make the wig heads dance and stuff like that.

[54:54] Jess McInally: The wig head scared me.

[54:55] Andrew DeWolf: Really?

[54:56] Jess McInally: A little bit. I wasn't expecting it fully, and then it happened, and I was like, oh, whoa.

[55:00] Andrew DeWolf: I do like that they kind of have the uh set also react to the bad news. Um like it's like the the room itself is a character that's like, oh, that's bad news.

[55:13] Jess McInally: I do want to say about the movie, I do like the kind of moving of it won't be long now to after um Tell Me Som or No Me No Me Diga.

[55:24] Andrew DeWolf: Because then we set up Vanessa where she works and all that before we go into her and what she wants.

[55:31] Jess McInally: I feel like that sets her up more strong. Because of course we do introduce her in the in the height song where she's everyone.

[55:38] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[55:39] Jess McInally: We introduce her kind of basic wants, and then we show where she works, and then we show like her goals, which I think all that works so much better in the movie, uh, structurally.

[55:49] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[55:49] Jess McInally: Well, I think there's just a there's a lot of stuff in the movie that they fixed structure wise, so if only they had casted it better.

[55:56] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. What are you gonna do?

[55:58] Jess McInally: Um 96,000.

[56:01] Andrew DeWolf: Real though I would feel going real slown the highway of life with no regrets and no breaking and neck for respect.

[56:11] Jess McInally: Oh paycheck.

[56:12] Andrew DeWolf: Real though.

[56:14] Jess McInally: Take a break from the wheel and wheel through the party, everybody.

[56:20] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, we can we can re tick it easy.

[56:26] Jess McInally: Yo, mom, it's me. Check my ticket!

[56:29] Andrew DeWolf: That's one, two, three. What would you do with 960?

[56:33] Jess McInally: I mean if it's just between you and me.

[56:37] Andrew DeWolf: That is tricky.

[56:38] Jess McInally: I know 96.

[56:42] Andrew DeWolf: I'd start my life with a brand new release.

[56:44] Jess McInally: Atlantic City with a little rooperies.

[56:47] Andrew DeWolf: And a brand weave.

[56:49] Jess McInally: Or maybe just bleach.

[56:51] Andrew DeWolf: The pool dance party.

[56:53] Jess McInally: I mean, it isn't in the musical, but it is in the movie.

[56:56] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I don't know. I feel like it's better as a pool dance party.

[57:02] Jess McInally: But I think that's mostly because there's not that much being said in this number besides just like what each character would do if they won a bunch of money.

[57:09] Andrew DeWolf: And having that backdrop of everybody dancing at the pool makes it a lot better.

[57:14] Jess McInally: There were so many opportunities, like them using like the pool like entranceway as like ballet balance beams.

[57:20] Andrew DeWolf: That's amazing.

[57:20] Jess McInally: The Bubsy Berkeley reference with um Vanessa in the pool.

[57:24] Andrew DeWolf: My god.

[57:25] Jess McInally: And when they go underwater for the tiptoe, and then you know, no, and uh then when they come up, everyone's just up there dancing.

[57:32] Andrew DeWolf: My god. Holy shit.

[57:35] Jess McInally: It's so fucking good.

[57:37] Andrew DeWolf: And they it's taking a song that really just in the state show, there's just not that much going on with it.

[57:42] Jess McInally: Um they're just on stage and they dance.

[57:44] Andrew DeWolf: It sounds incredible.

[57:45] Jess McInally: Like on the stage show, it it sounds great.

[57:48] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, but it's sounds great in the movie, too.

[57:50] Jess McInally: It sounds it's yeah, just sounds good.

[57:52] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I like it, you know.

[57:54] Jess McInally: I don't love the plot device of just a winning lottery ticket.

[57:57] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and I especially don't like how they did it in the stage show where they just kind of like a Blela won it and they use it to give it to his Navi.

[58:06] Jess McInally: I don't I don't know. I don't love that.

[58:08] Andrew DeWolf: I think it's better in the movie where it's like they even have the uh the line where he's like, nobody ever turned it in, we never found out who won it.

[58:14] Jess McInally: You know?

[58:15] Andrew DeWolf: Right. I like that better.

[58:16] Jess McInally: And then I guess spoilers, at the very end, he finds it and a blelo gave it to him.

[58:22] Andrew DeWolf: Um that is a much better thing as a story, as a reveal.

[58:26] Jess McInally: And then he's actually using it for what he wants to use it for rather than a Blelo just being like, we should use it for this.

[58:34] Andrew DeWolf: He thinks about using it for what he wants to, but then he discovers his actual need is to help Sonny and be a father figure to Sonny.

[58:41] Jess McInally: Yep.

[58:42] Andrew DeWolf: That's why it's important.

[58:43] Jess McInally: It's a better story.

[58:44] Andrew DeWolf: I I'm sorry, guys. I know you all are real attached to this musical, but it is told better in the movie.

[58:50] Jess McInally: I I'm just being honest with you.

[58:52] Andrew DeWolf: You know, I'm I'm straightforward here.

[58:53] Jess McInally: I'm not even trying to defend.

[58:56] Andrew DeWolf: The movie's better.

[58:57] Jess McInally: I don't care.

[58:58] Andrew DeWolf: It's not better.

[58:59] Jess McInally: It's different, and it's a better it is a great movie.

[59:03] Andrew DeWolf: As a movie.

[59:04] Jess McInally: It's a better story.

[59:05] Andrew DeWolf: It's told better.

[59:07] Jess McInally: I disagree because then you're missing all the like race stuff with uh Benny and you know, Nina and her father, and you're losing a lot there, so I can't say it's better.

[59:16] Andrew DeWolf: Just because you lose stuff doesn't mean it's not better.

[59:18] Jess McInally: You lose good stuff.

[59:20] Andrew DeWolf: But you gain better stuff.

[59:23] Jess McInally: You gain different stuff.

[59:24] Andrew DeWolf: You gain better stuff.

[59:27] Jess McInally: Paciense fee which is an okay song in the musical, an amazing sequence in the movie.

[59:34] Andrew DeWolf: Sharing double breads, trying to catch a break, struggling with English, listening two friends, finally got a job working as a mah.

[59:45] Jess McInally: So we clean some homes, polishing with pride, scrubbing the whole of the upper east side, the days into weeks, the weeks into years, and here I spit these birds, my hands begin to shake.

[1:00:06] Andrew DeWolf: And as I say these words, my heart's about to break.

[1:00:12] Jess McInally: And I mama, what do you do when your dreams come true?

[1:00:18] Andrew DeWolf: I spend my life inheriting dreams for you.

[1:00:24] Jess McInally: I made it through.

[1:00:26] Andrew DeWolf: I survived.

[1:00:28] Jess McInally: I did it.

[1:00:30] Andrew DeWolf: This is the highest point of the entire show in the movie.

[1:00:34] Jess McInally: And it is so disappointing in the stage show that it's not even close.

[1:00:40] Andrew DeWolf: It's just another I want number for the like another female lead.

[1:00:43] Jess McInally: Think about it just like that.

[1:00:45] Andrew DeWolf: It's no different than it won't be long now or breathe.

[1:00:47] Jess McInally: It's actually really sad in the movie.

[1:00:50] Andrew DeWolf: Like, it's really good.

[1:00:52] Jess McInally: It's like here's this character that we in the movie.

[1:00:55] Andrew DeWolf: You haven't even seen that much of her.

[1:00:57] Jess McInally: You just kind of know that she's like the mother figure.

[1:00:59] Andrew DeWolf: And then her like last moment is that they like walk her over to bed because it's getting hot, and and she's singing to herself about everything she's been through, and looking at uh the younger people in her life and is like, I think I'm done here.

[1:01:16] Jess McInally: Like they can figure themselves out, which is it's more heartbreaking, and honestly, I am much more affected by someone being surrounded by their loved ones, being distracted and smiling, watching them be together, as opposed to someone dying off screen.

[1:01:34] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[1:01:34] Jess McInally: Off stage.

[1:01:36] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it's just the death is just kind of like, oh, I guess she's dead.

[1:01:41] Jess McInally: I mean, I don't know.

[1:01:42] Andrew DeWolf: It's if this wasn't in the movie, I probably wouldn't have such a strong feeling that the movie is better.

[1:01:47] Jess McInally: But because it's really so this scene alone makes it This scene alone is like the most powerful scene in the movie, and it's like in the stage show it's just not there.

[1:01:56] Andrew DeWolf: It just isn't there.

[1:01:58] Jess McInally: Um and I will say I do appreciate the movie bringing back the actress who played her on the Broadway show and her knocking out of the park in the movie just as much.

[1:02:06] Andrew DeWolf: If not more so because of the recontextualization.

[1:02:10] Jess McInally: Hell yeah.

[1:02:10] Andrew DeWolf: I think it's good, and she Abuela leaves more of an impact with less of her aunt in it, as strange as that is.

[1:02:17] Jess McInally: Well, yeah, because otherwise, I mean, what what is her impact in the stage show?

[1:02:21] Andrew DeWolf: She won't She won a lottery.

[1:02:23] Jess McInally: She won the lottery, and she's like convincing Uznavi to do something that even in the show he realizes he doesn't want to do.

[1:02:31] Andrew DeWolf: Like, she's literally a bad influence contextually.

[1:02:35] Jess McInally: Yeah.

[1:02:37] Andrew DeWolf: I love the blackout scene in both.

[1:02:40] Jess McInally: I think it's really well done in the musical.

[1:02:43] Andrew DeWolf: I think it's really well done in the film.

[1:02:44] Jess McInally: It's good in both.

[1:02:45] Andrew DeWolf: It's about the same in both.

[1:02:46] Jess McInally: They gotta do the same thing.

[1:02:48] Andrew DeWolf: It's a knockout scene, but do you remember um who got in the fight in the stage musical?

[1:02:56] Jess McInally: I don't.

[1:02:57] Andrew DeWolf: Who was it?

[1:02:58] Jess McInally: It was between Benny and Nina in the stage musical, and then they just took that fight and made it between Usnavi and Vanessa, so they actually have some tension in their relationship.

[1:03:08] Andrew DeWolf: That's yeah, that's right.

[1:03:09] Jess McInally: Actually, you're you're right.

[1:03:11] Andrew DeWolf: And I didn't realize that until I rewatched it just today.

[1:03:14] Jess McInally: I was like, oh but I kind of feel like it helps a lot though, because otherwise, like Usnavi and Vanessa's relationship is just so boring.

[1:03:24] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, it is.

[1:03:26] Jess McInally: Um although I will admit they did kind of remove a lot of the characteristics of Vanessa in the movie.

[1:03:32] Andrew DeWolf: Like I feel like she had more personality but less desire in the musical.

[1:03:37] Jess McInally: Um, but in the movie they kind of gave her a goal but took away like specific moments that kind of characterized her more.

[1:03:44] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, although I I personally would prefer a goal over particular quirks.

[1:03:49] Jess McInally: Um I I miss the quirks though.

[1:03:52] Andrew DeWolf: I kind of miss the quirks.

[1:03:53] Jess McInally: Sure.

[1:03:54] Andrew DeWolf: I wish we could have had both.

[1:03:55] Jess McInally: I mean, yeah, I'm not saying that we couldn't have had both.

[1:03:57] Andrew DeWolf: I'm just saying if we if we can only have one, I'd rather have the goals.

[1:04:02] Jess McInally: I agree.

[1:04:03] Andrew DeWolf: Um but I also here's another thing about the movie.

[1:04:07] Jess McInally: I disagree about Benny and Nina fighting at all.

[1:04:11] Andrew DeWolf: I really don't think that works.

[1:04:13] Jess McInally: I love in the movie that Benny is kind of always on Nina's side.

[1:04:16] Andrew DeWolf: The the idea that Benny and Nina get into a fight because her dad's gonna sell the business um to pay for her college education.

[1:04:26] Jess McInally: Do you really think that he I like the fact that he's basically listens to Nina and talks to her.

[1:04:31] Andrew DeWolf: There's that argument scene where he backs Nina up.

[1:04:34] Jess McInally: Yeah, why like why would he fight Nina instead of fighting with his employer who is selling the business?

[1:04:40] Andrew DeWolf: Because it's her fault that he's gonna lose his job.

[1:04:42] Jess McInally: It's like, no, it's not, it's your employer's fault for selling the business.

[1:04:45] Andrew DeWolf: Like, it doesn't matter why he's doing it.

[1:04:47] Jess McInally: The fact that he's doing it is what's causing you to lose the job.

[1:04:50] Andrew DeWolf: Uh-huh.

[1:04:51] Jess McInally: And also, it makes more sense for Usnavi and Vanessa to fight since Usnavi's basically acting like a douche canoe.

[1:04:57] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, which is still in the stage show.

[1:04:59] Jess McInally: He still does.

[1:05:00] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, it is.

[1:05:01] Jess McInally: But they don't fight about it.

[1:05:03] Andrew DeWolf: They just kind of stop talking for a bit.

[1:05:06] Jess McInally: Like, do they even have another scene before champagne happens?

[1:05:09] Andrew DeWolf: I don't remember, but I don't think so.

[1:05:11] Jess McInally: That's lame.

[1:05:12] Andrew DeWolf: It makes more sense for them not to talk to each other than a f this movie.

[1:05:16] Jess McInally: This movie made a lot of choices.

[1:05:18] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[1:05:18] Jess McInally: And it's good to not be angry at the movie to be angry at the musical, but makes a little bit less sense.

[1:05:24] Andrew DeWolf: Can we get a stage adaptation of the movie?

[1:05:30] Jess McInally: You make good point.

[1:05:32] Andrew DeWolf: Um, Carnaval de Barrio.

[1:05:35] Jess McInally: Um, this scene is so much fun.

[1:05:37] Andrew DeWolf: I love it.

[1:05:37] Jess McInally: It's great in the movie, it's great in the musical.

[1:05:40] Andrew DeWolf: Carnaval del Barrio.

[1:05:45] Jess McInally: Carnava.

[1:05:47] Andrew DeWolf: Carnaval del Barrio.

[1:05:49] Jess McInally: Barrio.

[1:05:54] Andrew DeWolf: Bario.

[1:05:55] Jess McInally: We don't need electricidad.

[1:05:57] Andrew DeWolf: Get off your butt.

[1:05:58] Jess McInally: Avanisa.

[1:05:59] Andrew DeWolf: Saka la madaka.

[1:06:00] Jess McInally: Bring your tambourine.

[1:06:01] Andrew DeWolf: Come and join the parlanda.

[1:06:03] Jess McInally: Hey.

[1:06:16] Andrew DeWolf: Garnava Del Babio.

[1:06:20] Jess McInally: Me me Danny, I have a question.

[1:06:23] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know what you're cantando.

[1:06:25] Jess McInally: Just make it up as you go.

[1:06:27] Andrew DeWolf: We are in Fabi Sando.

[1:06:29] Jess McInally: La la You can sing anything.

[1:06:34] Andrew DeWolf: Whatever comes into your head.

[1:06:36] Jess McInally: Just so long as you sing.

[1:06:37] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, my name is Dominican Cuban.

[1:06:39] Jess McInally: My dad is from Chile and PR, which means I'm Chile Dominicuri.

[1:06:45] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it's it's fun.

[1:06:46] Jess McInally: Um I feel like it's more uh impactful in the movie.

[1:06:51] Andrew DeWolf: For me, it was anyways.

[1:06:52] Jess McInally: Explain.

[1:06:53] Andrew DeWolf: Because I I was gonna make the opposite argument, so I want to hear your um the movie has much more focus on this gentrification angle and like the businesses being driven out of the Washington Heights area by these overpriced uh like Patrick Pages.

[1:07:11] Jess McInally: Yeah.

[1:07:12] Andrew DeWolf: And I feel like this celebration of the culture right as they're leaving and not coming back has more power there where those themes are more present.

[1:07:22] Jess McInally: I agree.

[1:07:23] Andrew DeWolf: And I like that Newsnave doesn't just show up like I got money, I'm going away.

[1:07:28] Jess McInally: Fuck y'all.

[1:07:29] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[1:07:30] Jess McInally: I'm not saying it's bad in the stage show.

[1:07:32] Andrew DeWolf: I just personally felt like it had more impact on in the movie.

[1:07:36] Jess McInally: And I mean, this whole entire This entire episode has just been me saying that I think the movie improved nearly everything.

[1:07:41] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm trying to fight you a good majority of the time.

[1:07:45] Jess McInally: Um there is one part of this song that's in the movie that I think is bad.

[1:07:49] Andrew DeWolf: Not because of anything the movie does, but what it doesn't do.

[1:07:54] Jess McInally: Sure. What's that? Where they're like, hey, you and you and Nina had sex, Benny, and they're like, What? And I'm like, why have that there if we don't see them having sex? Like, is that a big it wouldn't feel like a big deal if we seen it? It felt a little bit awkward to me, anyways, because it it seemed like everyone knew that they were dating anyways, so it's like, why care? It feels weird in the movie. Like, because we don't have a scene, and it feels like they've kind of been official, like, even before she left. Yeah. So it's like, is this really news? Like Yeah. A couple that are dating have had sex? What I would have just cut that verse a bit. Yeah. Or kind of It was probably like a they didn't think about their own changes in that one instance.

Like they just kind of were like, well, that's the lyrics of the song, so But I disagree because they change all of Usnavi's lyrics because he doesn't have the watery. But they keep that it makes me think maybe they shot Sunrise and then they cut it because it's like, well, grandma died, we just sang Alabanza, and now we're just cutting to them fucking. Yeah. Fair enough. I don't know. It bothers me in the movie. Even when I saw the movie like first, I was like, that feels wrong. That feels like a weird thing to say when we don't even show it. I wonder if it also has more impact because it happens after Alabanza in the movie. I I can imagine that being distracting. I don't know about distracting.

It feels like Um There's more stuff that is happening that's kind of tearing the neighborhood apart. So having this like everybody come together moment is more impactful. Alright, alright. I I know I always do this and I pitch better versions of scenes to you. Sure. So we have grandma Abuela dies. We have Alabanza where everyone's crying and singing and all that and during the blackout. And then we just cut to Benny and Nina hugging each other. We cut to Carla and Daniela hugging each other, and they and Usnavi going to bed alone and all that, and all of them going to bed together. Carla and Daniela as the established older long-term couple that just kind of like hold each other quietly. And Benny and Nina as the like I need you right now, and they kind of get intimate, and we get the implication of that without having the sunrise scene.

And then Usnavi and Vanessa crawling into bed alone. Like Osanavi just broken, Vanessa, heartbroken and all that, and sad about Abuela. That scene could have worked. And then you could have paid it off later with uh an arrow on the hay. Yeah. Sure. I will agree. Yep. Okay. What you don't think that would have been good? You don't see that working. I can see it working. I I don't know if it's necessary. I don't know. Yeah. Eh. Just cut the line and cut. Just cut the line and we're all good. Yeah, a little bit. Um, when the sun goes down, the dancing on the building scene from the movie.

[1:09:25] ♪ Musical number ♪

[1:09:25] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know about the song itself. Because it's just kind of like a love song, it seems like. It's like their third love song in this musical. Because we have um I I feel like part of the reason why I don't care that they cut so much of Nina and Benny is because they don't have any songs that mean anything besides they just love each other. Um When You're Home, I really like. I think they do that very well in both versions. Um the sun goes down, both of those kind of feel like the same song to me. Yeah. I'm glad that they were able to make use of it to make a very cool dancing on the building scene. Because what else could you do? Yeah. But outside of the very cool visuals, this song doesn't bring very much to the table.

It's the 11 o'clock number two. It's the song before the finale, which also baffles me. Yeah. Which kind of says a lot about how little there is going on plot-wise. That this these two characters singing about how they love each other again for like the third time is the 11 o'clock number. Yeah.

[1:13:08] Jess McInally: In the movie, don't they kind of they don't have any songs, but they kind of add a bunch of stuff, like not songs but book stuff, in between that in the finale, though. Because this ha this song happens, and then Uznavi has the whole like Vanessa um, he's about to leave, and Vanessa brings him into the shop and all that kind of stuff happens. Yeah, but we also have the sunny stuff. I think that is what happens before when the sun goes down and the finale. Yeah, the sunny stuff is. But also, also, also, they move when the sun goes down to be before champagne in the movie. Which makes a lot more sense. Yes. Um, I agree. But also it's tomato tomato. Um, champagne is a good song in the movie. Ooh, Snobby!

[1:13:56] ♪ Musical number ♪

[1:14:35] Jess McInally: It's shot live. They do it all in one take, and it works. Uh you didn't even notice it, it didn't throw your eye off, it didn't throw your ear off. They did good with it. Um, just rewatch that scene and know it's shot all in one take and live. Um and think, wow, Tom Hooper could have done something like this with Flay Miz and chose not to. Well, he could have if he hired singers. Yeah, yeah. Imagine that. These are all like singers. Um, it's great. It's great. Um, what did you think of the finale changes between the movie and the musical?

[1:15:10] Andrew DeWolf: Which changes do you mean specifically?

[1:15:12] Jess McInally: Well, the finale in the musical is just like, hey, he drew a painting of a builder and like a new snobby's like, hey, I'm gonna stay here now.

[1:15:20] Andrew DeWolf: So you mean like the reasons why they're staying, and I mean it's much better. The only the only complaint I do have is the same complaint you brought up, which is just like, oh, they had kids and got married, which is like such a cliche, like did we really have to do that? I mean, I don't hate it because it's it's cliche, but it's like, you know, that is a lot of people's happy ending, and that's fine, but it's a little bit tacked on. It's a little bit like, why do we do that? I like them kissing under the fire hydrants. Um I will say the the hydrants are open, cool breeze. That that musical element works better when he's telling the story to the kids and he just sees like his entire block there, like beckoning him.

That's an incredible cinematic moment. I think that works very, very well. Uh better than the musical where it just kind of you hear these distant voices. And I think the um like framing device and that being broken in the finale is uh is a good touch too. It doesn't feel like a lie, honestly. It's one of those times where it just kind of feels like, uh, we didn't want to spoil it for that. They didn't want to spoil it, and it's like in his head, that is what this is, you know. That he is at his doing his father's dream in his in his own way. So it's like you know. Yeah.

[1:16:43] Jess McInally: I agree. Um Andrew, this has been a great talk, but what is your overall thoughts on In the Heights and your cheese rating?

[1:16:52] Andrew DeWolf: Um I mean, I've been really positive to the movie, which makes probably seem like I like really, really, really, really, really loved it. But it was fine. I I I don't dislike it in any real way, but I wish they could do this, like what they did with this show with a better musical. Better musicals. Like, I wish this was done with like Lay Miz or this was done with not cats. I don't care about cats. Honestly, this is better than even if the best version of cats, but I don't know. Um I really like all the structural changes they made, and I I do personally think, and I'm sure I'll get a lot of fan backlash, but I do personally think that the movie is better structure wise and story-wise. Um I really like a lot of the visuals stuff that it does. Um you can watch the movie right now. So on HBO Max. Because you should support good musical movies being made. Um I'm What do you what do you think? How do you think this guy will do with Wicked?

[1:17:55] Jess McInally: I think he's probably gonna do a very good job if he I mean, assuming that everything that made this good was his decisions, um, which I suppose we can assume in some way, then I think he's gonna do a very good job. I think so too. I um your cheese rating.

[1:18:12] Andrew DeWolf: Um let's see. I'm gonna just look up something here and and see if uh see if it's good. Yeah, I don't. Um I'm getting I'm getting some news that there's something called uh Caribbean cheddar, but I'm not sure if that's an appropriate name. Where is the Dominican Republic located? West Indies, I think. I have no idea. I have no idea. Maybe I'm dumb. I have no idea. I'm so I'm s we are boring whites. We are uh the whitest of the whites. I wish I did know where these things were. It is at the Caribbean. Okay. Caribbean cheddar, baby. Yeah, it's it's next to Oh, it's on the same island as Haiti. I should have known that already, because that's like right next to America or the United States of America.

But I'm uh American, so my education system has failed me miserably. Um all right. Um I love In the Heights. I really like the musical. I really enjoy the film. There are things I love about both of them, and things that I dislike about both of them, and there are some good choices made in the film and some choices I don't agree with, and there's some things I miss from the musical, and some things I I I I think are better without. Um they are both very complicated things I think are on par with one another. It is a perfect musical and a perfect st movie version of a musical. I don't think you could make it any better except for the parts I mentioned before. Um so my cheese rating is um a macaroni and cheese bake from a place called Alabanza Catering Company.

I did it! I did it, everybody! I did it, I won! I won! I won the cheese rating. And a bonza! Yeah. Check out the movie and or stage show that doesn't being aired. You know who should check out the movie and or stage show. Our patrons. Uh wonderful patrons. Thank you guys for listening. Please follow us on iTunes, Spotify, Stitcher, and Music Schools with Cheese. We're on Twitter at Cheesy Musicals, we're on Patreon and Musicals with Cheese, Instagram Musicals of Cheese, YouTube page musicals of cheese. We have a patron only podcast called Patreon with cheese. Email us at musical theater lives at gmail.com. Our title card is credited by the amazing Jolene Casco. Go send her some love at Jolene Casco, our keeper of the cheeses, Juliet Antonio.

This show is produced by the incredible, the amazing, the wonderful Brianna Jones. We miss you so much, Bree. Please come back next week. Um thank you to the thank you to the Broadway Podcast Network for having us on the platform and for not kicking us off. Alright, Andrew, is there anything else you want to say before we wrap this up?

[1:20:52] Andrew DeWolf: We love you all and have fun. In the heights!

[1:21:00] Jess McInally: We'll see you next time on Musical Vitale. Washington Heights.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred