"First a boom Then a shout Then a crash Then a squeak" Grab you magnifying glass and coat because this week we're talking about the digital mystery musical "A Killer Party" -- we talk about the time the show was released during, how things have changed, and the effectiveness of digital theatre... Read More
From the show: Musicals with Cheese
About
"First a boom Then a shout Then a crash Then a squeak" Grab you magnifying glass and coat because this week we're talking about the digital mystery musical "A Killer Party" -- we talk about the time the show was released during, how things have changed, and the effectiveness of digital theatre.
Donate to Black Lives Matter here
Social Media:
Musicals with Cheese on Twitter
Musicals W/ Cheese on Instagram
Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com
Jess Socials
Andrew Socials
Brianna Socials
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:10] Jess McInley: Hello, I'm Jess McInley.
[0:12] Andrew DeWolf: And I am Andrew DeWolf.
[0:14] Jess McInley: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, the podcast where I try to get Andrew to like musical theater.
[0:19] Jess McInley: How are you doing today, Andrew?
[0:21] Andrew DeWolf: Oh boy, I got invited to this party.
[0:23] Jess McInley: It's a bunch of theater people.
[0:25] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, they're the worst, aren't they?
[0:27] Jess McInley: Oh man.
[0:28] Andrew DeWolf: All they will do all they did was the whole time.
[0:31] Andrew DeWolf: Over and over and over again, they just kept talking about how terrible they all are and how I should hate them.
[0:36] Andrew DeWolf: And I just kept thinking to myself, man, somebody just got murdered and you're talking about this?
[0:42] Jess McInley: Man, you're right. Um, in case you haven't picked up on that subtle throwdown, this week we're talking about the musical A Killer Party.
[0:52] Jess McInley: Cue the music, Bree!
[0:53] Jess McInley: So what's exciting is I've been writing a piece of theater never seen before. It's Pete and Dazzle meets Razzle Dazzle with someone lying dead upon the diamond door. Sir Patel Case is the greatest play in my theater's history. I've written a great murder.
[1:19] Jess McInley: A Killer Party is a musical with music by Jason Howland and lyrics by Nathan Tyson and a book by Rachel Axler and Kate Kerrigan. It premiered on Vimeo August 5th, 2020, in nine parts, so it was like separated into like little episodes.
[1:36] Jess McInley: Which I think it's probably easier to digest than a full film. Um, the plot of this show is A Killer Party is a collaboration between more than 50 Broadway professionals all working together remotely, shot from home and delivered directly to your home. It tells the story of a detective Justine Case trying to solve the strange murder of a theater director of an eccentric theater troupe.
[1:59] Andrew DeWolf: Alright.
[2:00] Jess McInley: So it it's weird that this almost feels like a product of its time, and that time was literally last summer.
[2:07] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[2:07] Jess McInley: This is like we're we're still in the pandemic.
[2:10] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[2:10] Jess McInley: Like a lot of people are pretending we're not, but we kind of still are.
[2:14] Jess McInley: But this still feels like, man, that was from the pandemic, wasn't it?
[2:19] Andrew DeWolf: It's weird to say that, because we are in the pandemic.
[2:22] Jess McInley: But this feels like the heat of the pandemic. Like the start when everyone's like, oh God, what are we gonna do? And there's like eight hundred gags about how they're quarantining themselves.
[2:33] Andrew DeWolf: Um, not directly in reference to the pandemic, though, but definitely directly in reference to the pandemic.
[2:40] Jess McInley: Yes, yes, yes. Um, and being a product of its time does not automatically make something bad. Let's just say that.
[2:46] Andrew DeWolf: Um, like Ratatouille, the TikTok musical. That was effective as a thing, but it also is a pandemic musical that had to be done that specific way for because pandemic.
[2:59] Jess McInley: Yes. Um, I will say being a product of your time can make it so it's easier for you to age poorly, though.
[3:07] Andrew DeWolf: You're not wrong there.
[3:08] Jess McInley: Um, it's weird to see. And there have like I remember when this show premiered, um, and they were already talking about online productions with Detroit casts. Like, this is already on Musical Theatre International. People can register to do this as like get your theater troupe together or get your group of kids in your drama club together to do this online, which I think is great, and especially during that thing, that to have an option for that is wonderful.
[3:35] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[3:35] Jess McInley: Well, of course. I mean, you have to have some sort of option, and obviously, since we're still in the pandemic, yeah, that's probably an option people are still looking into.
[3:43] Andrew DeWolf: Mm-hmm.
[3:44] Jess McInley: And as for a musical that is um a quarantine musical about pandemic like about being quarantined and like can be done with those conditions. This is wonderful. I I'm gonna say that.
[3:56] Jess McInley: And also I have to say, because I keep forgetting to do this, this is a Patreon request from one of our favorite patrons, uh, Mina Maniri, so thank you, Mina. Um, you always pick the interesting ones, Mina.
[4:09] Andrew DeWolf: It's always the ones we least suspect, but we're probably gonna have a good amount to say.
[4:13] Jess McInley: Yeah, and like with almost everything that Mina recommends, I feel like I have to come down a little more negative than you here.
[4:20] Andrew DeWolf: I w The thing is I really wanted to like this a lot more than I did. Um, and I have reasons why I feel like watching it is not the best experience. Um, but this is almost a musical for theater people and nobody else.
[4:37] Jess McInley: That's kind of Which is my least favorite type of musical.
[4:41] Andrew DeWolf: I know. Um, but sometimes you can do that and have it work for the everyday crowd, like The Prom, which is a musical about musicals that is also its own thing.
[4:51] Jess McInley: Yeah, um, but other times it's just a bunch of jokes that are references to other shows, references to particular actors, references to the fact that all theater people think that theater people are insufferable.
[5:04] Jess McInley: Um, so Andrew, describe the plot of A Killer Party to me.
[5:11] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. Um, there's like a framing device. Do we care to It's only worthwhile because it is like I'd say the most pedigree Broadway actor in there. Like the I don't want to say elder because she's not really that old, but the l I'm sticking with it. The elder Broadway statesman of it, Carol Lee Carmelo plays the older version of our main character, and it's told from a framing device of her writing about her exploits as a detective in the future.
[5:38] Andrew DeWolf: Which is neat-ish.
[5:40] Jess McInley: Yeah, they do like a I hesitate to call it a joke, but it's a I guess it's a joke where she doesn't want to write her memoir and does anything else other than that, and then does write the memoir. It does do some things that are theatrically interesting later on where she has a duet with her present self and her past self. I like that. Like if you're gonna do it, you do it for that reason, and it works.
[6:05] Andrew DeWolf: Um, either way, continue.
[6:07] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. So you have the framing device, and then they start writing about the first case that they did, and that's where we move to the killer party. Um, now this is uh I feel like you have to just accept it, but it doesn't make any sense to me. They have a party that is simultaneously like a dinner party just for these people, but also like a show that people are gonna be watching.
[6:34] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I was trying to figure out what the heck they were trying to—cause someone's playing the lead in the dinner party. Um, and I understand that these murder mystery dinner parties can have like people play different characters and stuff, but is it usually fully scripted and like there's a lead actor and like side actors?
[6:53] Jess McInley: You see, maybe I just interpret it wrong, but I interpreted that this was a theater troupe preparing for a new show, and it was like their get together dinner before it.
[7:02] Andrew DeWolf: But maybe I'm just wrong.
[7:04] Andrew DeWolf: I thought it was like a murder mystery party where like, you know, you'll give people like, oh, you're gonna be this character and you're gonna be this character, but you're not performing for an audience, like you're performing for each other. You know, like it could have been a rehearsal, maybe like a rehearsal dinner that's a thing.
[7:21] Jess McInley: Yeah.
[7:22] Andrew DeWolf: Either way, um, because why would you need a stage manager for a—That's what I was trying to figure out. I was like what is like what is this? I thought they were just meeting up as like let's meet the cast and crew and creatives and get to know one another and then murder—oh no, but they got to know each other in costume?
[7:40] Jess McInley: Maybe it's more fun that way.
[7:45] Andrew DeWolf: Sure. So they all meet up um and there's this like eccentric Broadway person who's running it essentially um and they end up getting murdered and they're the host obviously uh which isn't this just Clue? I mean it's a pastiche on murder mysteries uh it's fine yeah but I'm just like you're just taking the tropes.
[7:46] Jess McInley: Yeah, it's it's all of those tropes basically the detective comes in it's it's her first ever case um has to interview all these wacky characters who are playing other characters um and figure out who did the murder it's uh and you know I I guess this should I spoil it here I feel like was not even necessary the thing is I called it as soon as it was the it was dropped in a line of dialogue and we never saw the character I knew what the twist was it's not the most in-depth murder mystery in the world no nor is it really trying to be really it doesn't even like matter make sense like the the murderer isn't even one of the characters.
[8:47] Andrew DeWolf: It's just like someone else, you know, which whatever. You know, it's fine. But it's just more of a it's more of a goof than than an actual murder mystery.
[8:56] Jess McInley: And yeah, it's like were you paying attention when someone said a throwaway line of dialogue, which you should always be doing if you're watching a mystery.
[9:04] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, of course.
[9:05] Andrew DeWolf: Um, but if you're expecting like they're gonna figure out which one of the characters it was, they're not.
[9:11] Jess McInley: No.
[9:11] Andrew DeWolf: No, that's not that.
[9:13] Andrew DeWolf: Um, there is a lot of people that attempted murdering and thought they murdered, but n Yeah.
[9:19] Andrew DeWolf: They did like a like a Knives Out thing where like someone thought they did a murder. Someone thought they did the murder, but they didn't do the murder because someone else cancelled out the murder with it's like uh poison and I don't think this would actually work, like a poison but then other person anti po—like wouldn't they still die of like drug overd—I don't know.
[9:44] Jess McInley: Whatever.
[9:45] Andrew DeWolf: It's a fun plot contrivance. I get it, I don't love it. Um, however, uh we brought this up in our Ratatouille discussion. Acting with your iPhone and in a scene like that where you don't really have another partner is very, very difficult work.
[10:03] Jess McInley: It's very difficult to go from stage to screen in a acting role without a very in-depth intense director trying to guide you and kinda and your fellow actors kind of matching the intensity.
[10:18] Andrew DeWolf: And that's one of the strange things that I I it's it's one of those things that you don't see outside of student film work.
[10:24] Jess McInley: Um, and it did give me like flashbacks to film school a lot where uh someone's a YouTube video.
[10:30] Andrew DeWolf: Well, yeah, it feels—no, no, no, no, no, no.
[10:34] Jess McInley: Okay.
[10:34] Jess McInley: This is gonna be a weird reference. It feels like early Nostalgia Critic, where it would be like another reviewer coming in.
[10:43] Andrew DeWolf: He's going there.
[10:44] Jess McInley: He's another reviewer would come in and it's like, who are you? And then they've got like a fan blowing in the background, the cats rolling around, and it's who are you person that is appearing in my video but not in my location.
[10:58] Andrew DeWolf: And the thing is, he will deliver it like really like who are you? And he's like, I am the cor critic who reviews the the movie baths. I'm the cat critic. I only review movies with cats in them. How do you hear about the movie with cat? That's that why you're here. We're talking about cats.
[11:20] Jess McInley: But the thing is, like the difference in quality, the difference in audio, and the difference in delivery all at once.
[11:30] Andrew DeWolf: Like, kind of throws you off, and like the there's no performative connection. However, there is tiny things that show that there's effort. Like when people have to hand things to each other, there is the effort to try to make it look like it's being handed through screens. You can like professionals are trying to make this and are trying to make it good, but they have no means to do it.
[11:54] Jess McInley: Yes.
[11:55] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and it's kind of charming in that way. Oh, I think one of the worst best ex best examples of this is like when they're running to sit at the table, and all they do is they just put all of the different like pieces of footage that every one of them has, and they just scramble them around the screen and have footstep sounds. You remember that?
[12:20] Jess McInley: Yes, I do.
[12:23] Andrew DeWolf: And I think a lot of these wonderful stage actors, they knock it out on stage and they feed off the audience energy, they feed off their other actors' energy. Um, that is where they're in their element.
[12:35] Jess McInley: And uh, a lot of these people aren't film actors as much as they might have been in films, but that's not what they're forte.
[12:43] Andrew DeWolf: Let's say that.
[12:44] Andrew DeWolf: However, there is one that really stands out among them all, and uh maybe you'll disagree with me. But Jessica Keenan Wynne, who plays the lead, the detective uh Justine Case, she gets the tone. She's able to kind of match the energy of everyone around her, and she obviously has a lot of film credit under her.
[13:09] Jess McInley: She was like in the Mamma Mia movie. Um, she's done a lot of stuff and she's been on a lot of television. She's very, very good at keeping her presence, and as a lead, you can feel the charisma coming off the screen. Where other charismatic stage actors like Laura Osnes, who plays the clown actress that doesn't want to be a clown.
[13:32] Andrew DeWolf: Former lead?
[13:33] Jess McInley: Yes. I think that she's great in most things, but here she kind of falls flat because she doesn't have the audience feeding her back, her other actors feeding her back. She is the only one with another actor in the room, though, so it is shocking. There's just, it really feels like a YouTube movie, though. Like, the comparison is really there. And I think a lot of pandemic stuff, because the Ratatouille one felt like this too. It's just the amount of like, because I think stage actors are almost made to overact so that they can hit the back of the audience, and that's not a bad thing. But when you're filming and you're like, it's like this, and then you're overacting, it's like, it's just ridiculous, and then everyone is doing it, and it's like, okay, what am I watching here? Is this Kickassia?
[14:22] Andrew DeWolf: Oh man.
[14:23] Jess McInley: And like, I don't want to say that it's not ever fun or it's not none of it is good at all because we've, I mean, there is much, much worse stuff out there, and they're giving it their best here. I just, you know, I don't think it works that well. And I think once the pandemic is over, this is just gonna be a relic that people will look back on and be like, oh, remember that?
[14:47] Andrew DeWolf: Well, that's gonna lead to my follow-up question. Would this work as a straight-up musical? Like, if they just took this script and they turned it into like a quick one act hour and a half musical with like, and put it on stage. Would it work at all?
[15:02] Jess McInley: I mean, I think you said it best when it's a show for theater people, and that's it. So me, I don't think I would like it because, I mean, 90% of the jokes in here barely made me laugh at all. Um, like every single time, and I think they did this joke like four times, where they're just like, theater people are insufferable, and the lead is like, "You're right, you're telling me." It's like, oh my god, just stop. Just stop. I get it. You're all theater people, and you're making the joke. I get it. But then there's some things that almost like, this feels like a TV movie, but not, like, but it's also like digital theater. Um, there's one song that I just, I thought most of this was fine, to be honest.
I know it sounds like I'm kind of ragging on it, but I think it's fine, and I'll go into what I mean by that a little later. There's one song I find completely insufferable and a little self-indulgent into the theater thing. Like, the offhand jokes can be a little cringy, but you kind of expect that from theater people writing about theater people for theater people.
[16:03] Andrew DeWolf: There's an entire song about how awesome Jeremy Jordan is.
[16:08] Jess McInley: Yeah, I don't even know who Jeremy Jordan is.
[16:11] Andrew DeWolf: We've covered a couple things with him, Andrew. He was Jamie.
[16:15] Jess McInley: Dude, I don't remember actors. Like, come on.
[16:18] Andrew DeWolf: He was Jamie in the Last Five Years movie.
[16:21] Jess McInley: Okay.
[16:22] Andrew DeWolf: He was Clyde in Bonnie and Clyde.
[16:24] Jess McInley: Okay. I've definitely seen both of those.
[16:29] Andrew DeWolf: And he was the leading newsie, which you haven't seen, but I'm saving that one for a big event. Maybe number two hundred. Stop tweeting at me about it. We'll get to it.
[16:38] Jess McInley: I'm sorry. Back to normal. If you want it so badly, be a patron and request it like me and Amaneri did. Um, yeah, wait, so that's all he's been in, and there was an entire song about it?
[16:51] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, he like, the thing is, it would be one thing if it was Hugh Jackman or something like that, where he kind of is a meme of himself.
[17:02] Jess McInley: Yeah.
[17:03] Andrew DeWolf: Or James Corden or something goofy.
[17:07] Jess McInley: Yeah, things like that. Where I don't particularly like them, but they are a meme of themselves, so it is kind of funny when they pop up and embrace that. There is a joke to it. Whereas Jeremy Jordan is just a talented vocalist who has had more success than a Broadway actor is used to, but not like hit the ground running like name top of film success.
[17:30] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. I mean, I'm not good with actors, and I didn't know them, and I was just like, you know, this is probably somebody every theater person is laughing hysterically right now, and I'm just here.
[17:41] Jess McInley: He's a great actor. Like, I don't have a problem with him, but you're acting like he's fucking Oprah or something.
[17:48] Andrew DeWolf: Was he, did he actually appear?
[17:51] Jess McInley: It was actually him.
[17:51] Andrew DeWolf: So I'm like, that song exists basically because they got him and they were like, oh, we'll write a song about it.
[18:00] Jess McInley: Maybe. I can't say. But that is the one thing that makes me think, man, this could not work literally in any other way. You kind of shot yourselves in the foot here. Unless you're gonna try to get like a slightly bigger name guy for every production. I can't imagine a bunch of kids putting this on and it's like, uh, is um, who we gonna get? Um, we're gonna get Gym Teacher Bill.
[18:24] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, Jim Teacher Bill, everybody knows him.
[18:26] Jess McInley: He's everyone's favorite gym guy in the school.
[18:30] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. I mean, there's other self-indulgent ones in other ways. Um, one that stuck out to me was "Stuck," which is maybe not self-indulgent, but so entirely stuck in its time period.
[18:42] Jess McInley: Yes, that like, it's basically once we're past the pandemic, it's just gonna be like, yeah, I don't really want to remember this. But then again, I try not to criticize that too much because I remember a year ago and it felt like the entire world stopped because it did.
[19:01] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, but then you also have like the TikTok joke, which is like painful and I don't know. A huge part of my problem with this is a lot of the humor just does not land for me. Um, even beyond the humor that's entirely based around theater stuff. And like, there's this TikTok joke in "Stuck," which was just kind of painful for me, and the joke at the beginning about how they don't want to write their memoir, I just, I don't, I don't really understand. I didn't think it was that funny. Um, and they did it like three times. I don't know. Maybe there's not comedy writers on this, maybe they just weren't bringing their A game. Maybe it's just not up my alley. I think people in, let's say, what was this, August of last year, like almost exactly a year ago, um, were just so craving for theatrical content because what was that?
It had to have been five months since Broadway shut down where they just needed something, and that something kind of manifested. Um, I think it's like when you haven't had sweets for a very long time, and then you get an entire box of donuts, but then you eat the whole thing, and yeah, it's good in the moment when you're shoving it down your mouth, but the next day you're gonna like feel like garbage. I think that's a good way to describe this. It's too much all at once.
[20:21] Jess McInley: I mean, but I understand why it happened. I also don't think it's like horrendously bad, even though I have been kind of like saying that I didn't like it at all. But I feel like that's while that is true that I didn't really like it that much. We have watched a lot worse stuff, and this is like a pandemic thing that helped people through the pandemic.
[20:40] Andrew DeWolf: Exactly.
[20:41] Jess McInley: And got all these actors paid. I don't like, if you liked this last year because there was nothing else happening, whatever. I get it. I don't, I'm not gonna criticize you because you liked it. I don't care.
[20:54] Andrew DeWolf: Can I tell you what I think holds this back um in what it currently is?
[20:59] Jess McInley: Sure.
[21:00] Andrew DeWolf: I think that what holds us back more than even the Ratatouille musical, because the Ratatouille musical kind of put effort in to make sure this was the one thing that worked. I think the audio is a horrendous issue in this, and it really kind of ruins the entire thing that it's trying to do.
[21:17] Jess McInley: I feel like I kind of noticed this, but you explain what you mean, and I'll see if I agree.
[21:23] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I think the difference in audio is just bad. Um, it's just on-camera mics, and yeah, we can't like buy lavs for everyone, but it sucks. But also, I can't understand the words to any of the songs. It's obviously dubbed, but it's not properly mixed at all. It felt rushed to me.
[21:44] Jess McInley: Yeah.
[21:45] Andrew DeWolf: Um, it felt like they had to get it out, which they probably did.
[21:49] Jess McInley: Well, I think it was like a weekly series, which, uh, okay.
[21:54] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. But it seems like they put the effort in the wrong places. Like, there's very nice green screen effects and like doubling and all that stuff, which is cool, but you should have focused on your audio mix and your actually mixing the tracks and all that because after I watched this, I pulled up the cast recording, um, on iTunes, and I really like the songs. I think all the songs are very good. I think these are very talented composer writers. I think they're very catchy, I think they're well executed, they're doing their thing, they're supporting the actors in their best, um, they're playing to their best strength on every actor. It doesn't come across in the video version. This does not come across in the actual version because it's so poorly mixed, it's so poorly integrated, it's overly echoey.
It's, I don't want to say overly produced, 'cause it feels just thrown together to kind of feel nice. But then they do all these really nice green screen effects and it kind of is like, where isn't it important that we hear your lyrics?
[22:59] Jess McInley: Yeah.
[22:59] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, I agree. I do have to agree. They, it feels rushed. Uh, and I mean, it kind of goes with the whole YouTube quality thing. It feels like it was like they had to get it out. Or maybe they just felt like they didn't have time. I don't know. Maybe they couldn't get a good audio engineer because of the pandemic. I don't know.
[23:21] Jess McInley: Maybe.
[23:22] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, I'm gonna give as much credit, but, um, you know, audio is probably one of the easier things to do over Zoom or over, like us. We have decent-ish audio most days.
[23:35] Jess McInley: Except when Andrew's squeaking his chair all live long day, but you know.
[23:35] Andrew DeWolf: Which is every day. Yeah, we can't do much about that 'cause Andrew won't buy a new chair.
[23:43] Jess McInley: Um, I already bought a new chair. They just, it doesn't stop.
[23:48] Andrew DeWolf: Just gotta s... I don't know. Mine isn't giving me that trouble.
[23:54] Jess McInley: Well, I have a mic on my chair, that's why.
[23:56] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, that's fair.
[23:57] Jess McInley: Um, gives you the full experience.
[23:59] Andrew DeWolf: Gives you the full experience. Uh, uh, audio, it shocked me because I feel like audio should be the first thing you should be worried about in a musical.
[24:12] Jess McInley: Well, pandemic musicals were a brand new thing. Uh, they probably were one of the things expected to perfect the formula, and I think this came first, so yes.
[24:22] Andrew DeWolf: Ma, I, I'm not critiquing that much, but that is the reason why I feel like it didn't hit as hard for me. Um, because I listened to the album, and the album's great. I do recommend the album more than the actual watching of the thing. And I think also the other reason why I think, uh, Justin and K. Jessica Keenan Wynn really kind of stands out is she has the most clear diction among everyone. Um, she is very clear in everything that she's saying, where other people are just like, you know, they're performing, and her character kind of leans more to like the clear speaking. The Christine Baranski effect.
[25:04] Jess McInley: I think some people just weren't used to what this was, and they thought they could talk the same way they could if they're mic'd and they're in a big theater environment.
[25:13] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, and they didn't realize that their phone has a bad mic that doesn't really work very well.
[25:19] Jess McInley: My god. I think we're all aware of that now.
[25:22] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. Well, you know, who cares what we think? Yeah. It's time for us to compare our opinions with that of the New York Theatre Critics, which this somehow got reviews from. It's time for Breeviews without Bree, because Bree had a family emergency.
[25:39] Jess McInley: That rhymes.
[25:40] Andrew DeWolf: It's time for Breeviews.
[25:44] Jess McInley: It's time for Previews.
[25:46] Andrew DeWolf: Well, I mean, they didn't really have anything else to review, did they?
[25:51] Jess McInley: Yeah, I mean, Ben Brantley saw Godspell and like said it was better than crying at home, so.
[25:57] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Can we talk about Ben Brantley's website for a second? Where he has little emojis of himself.
[26:05] Andrew DeWolf: Is it his website, or is this uh someone who doesn't like Ben Brantley's website?
[26:09] Jess McInley: No, that's Ben Brantley's website, and he it's all about whether he liked it, but it was supposed to be about whether critics liked it, but it's all about him.
[26:18] Andrew DeWolf: Well, it's literally a picture, like an emoji of him doing either a thumbs up, sitting on a fence, or a thumbs down, and that's like the extent of it.
[26:28] Jess McInley: Yeah.
[26:29] Andrew DeWolf: Ben Brantley, glad you're gone.
[26:31] Jess McInley: Fix that website, guys.
[26:32] Andrew DeWolf: Um, either way, Andrew, let me let me do the first one, you'll do the second one.
[26:37] Jess McInley: Sure.
[26:37] Andrew DeWolf: Alright. So this one is from the New York Times theater critic, Jesse Green, who said, I used to have high standards for new musicals.
[26:46] Jess McInley: Relevance, craft, and reason for being were traits I looked for, but often found lacking.
[26:53] Andrew DeWolf: Now that we're in lockdown, I'm just happy to see talented people working on anything that doesn't actively make me wish they weren't.
[27:01] Jess McInley: That's that's a backhanded compliment if I ever had one.
[27:04] Andrew DeWolf: Um you may not need much during a pandemic either.
[27:07] Jess McInley: And a killer party directed remotely, but with Verve by Mark Bruni winks broadly at its limitations.
[27:14] Andrew DeWolf: The choreography by Sarah O'Gleppy makes fun of the fact that it's is necessarily rudimentary.
[27:20] Jess McInley: So do Bobby Pierce's closet treasure costumes.
[27:24] Andrew DeWolf: And when Detective Case has the six suspects self-isolate for interviews in separate rooms of the Varthers house, they are actually, of course, rooms in each other and each rooms in each actor's.
[27:37] Jess McInley: If you ever want to know what Lore Ozis' bed looks like, or what Gerard Specter wears in the tub, now for just twelve ninety-nine, you can.
[27:49] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, this is a very accurate review, and I think I agree. We I did have to pay money for this, by the way.
[27:55] Jess McInley: I paid twelve like thirteen bucks for this.
[27:57] Andrew DeWolf: I'm happy to do it because I hope it's worth it. I it is because I hope these actors got paid.
[28:02] Jess McInley: Also, if thirteen dollars for a you know, uh a theater. That's not a production. That's not a bad price.
[28:08] Andrew DeWolf: Pretty cheap.
[28:11] Jess McInley: It's not complaining. I just wanted to say I did pay for this.
[28:14] Andrew DeWolf: Well what do you agree with this?
[28:16] Jess McInley: I mean It's fun to look at other their houses, yeah.
[28:19] Andrew DeWolf: Like Jessica Keenan Wynne. Um I like seeing the Heathers uh playbill hung up on her wall and taking me out and reminding me, oh yeah, you were in Heathers.
[28:31] Jess McInley: If only I was watching that.
[28:34] Andrew DeWolf: Why didn't they do that as a pandemic musical? Wouldn't that have been great?
[28:38] Jess McInley: We also have uh Jay Handleman of the Sarasota Herald Tribune.
[28:42] Andrew DeWolf: Hey, this is your neck of the woods.
[28:44] Jess McInley: Well, I live in Saratoga, not Sarasota.
[28:47] Andrew DeWolf: Oh my god.
[28:49] Jess McInley: I thought you lived I I don't even know if this is newer I am or not.
[28:52] Andrew DeWolf: I'm pretty sure Sarasota's in Florida now that I think about it.
[28:55] Jess McInley: Yeah.
[28:56] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, well, at another time, under different circumstances, a killer party might not be as much silly fun as it is now.
[29:03] Jess McInley: Uh this is another way of saying my standards are extremely low right now.
[29:07] Andrew DeWolf: Of course, under different circumstances, if live theaters were open and allowed to produce shows with audiences, killer party probably wouldn't exist.
[29:16] Jess McInley: It is a murder mystery musical created to accommodate the theatrical limitations of the coronavirus pandemic.
[29:22] Andrew DeWolf: It features catchy songs performed by a counted talented cast of Tony Award nominees and other Broadway veterans who bring far more power to the material than is probably actually there.
[29:34] Jess McInley: Um uh what is this? Ozna's inspector?
[29:37] Andrew DeWolf: Yep.
[29:37] Jess McInley: Osna's inspector appear together on screen, and the entire time they shared a scene, I wondered how they had done it and how safe it was.
[29:45] Andrew DeWolf: That made the reality of coronavirus intrude on this lighthearted fantasy.
[29:50] Jess McInley: Really? That's your in your review? Okay.
[29:52] Andrew DeWolf: Did they live for two weeks in an actor's version of an NBA bubble? Were were their spouses or families with them? Were they afraid?
[30:00] Jess McInley: I sadly became more involved with my concern for them and thinking about what it's going to be like when we get to go back to see live performers than the plot.
[30:11] Andrew DeWolf: But as a diversion, it's fun and the music is worth hearing.
[30:15] Jess McInley: That's that that's fair.
[30:21] Andrew DeWolf: I just figured they lived together.
[30:22] Jess McInley: I guess not.
[30:24] Andrew DeWolf: No.
[30:24] Jess McInley: No, they didn't.
[30:25] Andrew DeWolf: I knew they didn't, so I was like, oh, that's weird.
[30:28] Jess McInley: Yeah, I mean, I guess if I if I had known that they didn't live together, that would be something I would think about, but so do we agree with those?
[30:36] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, they basically said in so many words what we said.
[30:40] Jess McInley: I mean, both of them said lower your expectations really far.
[30:44] Andrew DeWolf: Settle for me.
[30:46] Jess McInley: Come on, just settle for me.
[30:48] Andrew DeWolf: It's a good one.
[30:49] Jess McInley: But also it's the best you're gonna see.
[30:54] Andrew DeWolf: The thing is, would anyone really talk about this outside of a pandemic?
[30:58] Jess McInley: If this had come out and the pandemic didn't happen, I think it would have been like one, nobody would even talk about it, and if they did, they would probably be like, Wow, that wasn't very good.
[31:10] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[31:11] Jess McInley: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[31:15] Andrew DeWolf: But we understand context, and we understand why this was made.
[31:21] Jess McInley: So not a bad thing.
[31:24] Andrew DeWolf: Context has to be considered.
[31:26] Jess McInley: Yes, and it it is, and for what that is, it's good.
[31:31] Andrew DeWolf: Is it as good as Ratatouille?
[31:33] Jess McInley: No. But you know what? Ratatouille felt like an event where we were giving kids the right to like exist neck and neck with real theater people.
[31:40] Andrew DeWolf: This is real theater people patting themselves on the back.
[31:44] Jess McInley: Ratatouille was important not because it was a pandemic show, but because it was written by TikTok.
[31:44] Andrew DeWolf: Because it was written by children.
[31:54] Jess McInley: Yeah, whereas this show references TikTok in like a joke way that is just kind of cringe.
[32:03] Andrew DeWolf: Man, tell us what you really think, Andrew.
[32:06] Jess McInley: Oh my they just do a whole song and then there's like one line where they're like, I hear TikTok is fun, and then it just something else.
[32:13] Andrew DeWolf: It's like, didn't you just humor? Wasn't there a murder like five minutes ago?
[32:18] Jess McInley: It's literally the song after the murder happened.
[32:24] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, Andrew, they took away their phones. How will they survive?
[32:28] Jess McInley: Wait, wasn't this before the phones got taken away?
[32:31] Andrew DeWolf: I don't remember.
[32:32] Jess McInley: How are they wait? Dir their phones get taken away and then they were still using TikTok?
[32:37] Andrew DeWolf: Come on. Get your plot straight.
[32:40] Jess McInley: Andrew's getting mad.
[32:42] Andrew DeWolf: You know what? I think Andrew needs some time to s to to steam off, you know, get his diapie changed. How about we go into a mid-show and we talk more about this?
[32:51] Jess McInley: Okay.
[33:02] Andrew DeWolf: Hey guys, sorry to interrupt you in the middle of the show, but we've got a shish shot.
[33:08] Jess McInley: Oh yes. Andrew, tell us about Patreon and who's supporting us.
[33:12] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, Patreon's where you can go if you'd like to get some extra perks. Like uh extra content, like uh, you know, you can get us to to cover a a weird pandemic show if you or like Mina Maneira.
[33:26] Jess McInley: If you pay us enough, you can be just like Mina Maniri and get us to cover whatever the hell you want.
[33:31] Andrew DeWolf: It's true. Um We have no say in the matter. There's just uh there's a decent backlog of content on there as well.
[33:37] Jess McInley: So if you're a new patron, you'll get access to uh a lot of stuff.
[33:41] Andrew DeWolf: Um and of course we put stuff out. We just did a rent commentary on the movie, the movie rent.
[33:47] Jess McInley: I feel like we covered it in a lot more depth than we ever have, and no, it took it had to wait until our third time around talking about rent to really get in depth.
[33:56] Andrew DeWolf: Um, how about I read some of the names of people that are supporting us on Patreon?
[34:00] Jess McInley: I I can do it, Jess. It's uh we got it.
[34:02] Andrew DeWolf: Are you sure? I mean, I don't want to put too much pressure on you and put too much work on you. I know you're a busy boy.
[34:06] Jess McInley: I'm gonna do it.
[34:10] Andrew DeWolf: Our current patrons are Melissa Goldman, Terry Needleman, John Donna, Lighton Ackles, Danielle Rennes, Jess the Stampede, Ewan Cassidy, Tess Gear, Fire of September, Monica Thoreau, Mina Maniri, Brent Black, Haley Murray, Lysaniel, Lathaniel Stacey Coomb, Joseph Evans Green, Carrie Ahern, Mary Lou Choquette, John Vanels, Heck You I Go by Elijah now, Russ Walker, Musical Hell, Emily Gracie, Andrew Van Barsen, Tablam, Kyle Summers, Janae C, Scoot in the Technicolor Dreamcoat, Felice R.
[34:41] Jess McInley: Liz Lim, Allison Stoller, nothing is certain except Beth and Taxes, John Vanals, Desbian, Ren Cohen, Wait in the Wings, Spe uh Spectacle Machine, Jacob Stroop, Raphael Martinez Celas, uh, Robert Benjamin, Rochelle T, Jessica T, Genevieve Hartnett, Cass, Mitchell Young, Chai Teacup, Katie McDonough, Timothy Keys, Jeffrey Machado, Jacuse, Toon Vanesson, R.
[35:03] Andrew DeWolf: Elliott, uh, Chris Marcot, uh, Katie Turberg, Mimu, uh, Kishi, Marie, Anastasio.
[35:10] Jess McInley: Uh, how is this one pronounced, Jess?
[35:12] Andrew DeWolf: I I I'm actually at a loss here.
[35:14] Jess McInley: Layla.
[35:14] Andrew DeWolf: Is it's just Layla?
[35:16] Jess McInley: Okay. Layla.
[35:16] Andrew DeWolf: I got that one confirmed.
[35:18] Jess McInley: Okay, Layla.
[35:19] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, RJ Norriga, uh, Sebastian Canino.
[35:23] Jess McInley: Um, also known as uh Cinemageddon Reviews.
[35:26] Andrew DeWolf: Was he the one that did the collab with the nostalgia critic in the opening?
[35:30] Jess McInley: Yeah, he What are you doing here? Cinemageddon reviews!
[35:34] Andrew DeWolf: I'm here because you're covering uh Armageddon movie, and only I'm allowed to do that.
[35:44] Jess McInley: And Avan Reagan.
[35:46] Andrew DeWolf: Avan Reagan is the last one. That's a great name, by the way.
[35:49] Jess McInley: Even Reagan. That sounds like a villain name and like a power's episode.
[35:54] Andrew DeWolf: Or Vegan.
[35:55] Jess McInley: I feel like it's Regan.
[35:56] Andrew DeWolf: What if it's even Reaven? E Avine Re Regine.
[36:01] Jess McInley: There's so many so many ways to mispronounce it.
[36:04] Andrew DeWolf: We I mean, the new new patrons, we have to mispronounce their names at least once, so.
[36:09] Jess McInley: Yeah.
[36:10] Andrew DeWolf: We've covered all of our bases now.
[36:13] Jess McInley: But they give us a little financial support that helps us keep the lights on here, musicals with cheese. If you would like to join them in supporting us, get to all those fun perks, commentaries.
[36:21] Andrew DeWolf: You get to see our video versions of us where we have a lot of extra content. Brie cuts a lot out of what eventually goes on to the episode.
[36:29] Jess McInley: Yeah, for good reason.
[36:30] Andrew DeWolf: But you will get the full versions on Patreon with our video faces, too.
[36:36] Jess McInley: Um so if you want that, come join us over at Patreon.
[36:39] Andrew DeWolf: Um also you get the episodes a day early, which is pretty great.
[36:42] Jess McInley: So you get the video episodes a day early.
[36:44] Andrew DeWolf: And you get those by donating anything on Patreon. You don't have to like there's not a tier rating. If you are on a paybreak, you get that.
[36:53] Jess McInley: Um, so how about we get back to the episode, Andrew?
[36:56] Andrew DeWolf: Let's do it.
[37:08] Jess McInley: Killer Party.
[37:13] Andrew DeWolf: Killer Party.
[37:22] Jess McInley: It's my killer party.
[37:25] Andrew DeWolf: I give a stop supply.
[37:31] Jess McInley: Alright. So the music was done by composers I think are very, very good. Um Jason Howland, who is most known for the 2004 musical version of Little Women, um, which I think is very good.
[37:44] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and then Nathan Tyson, um, who we've covered before. Um, we he did the music for Amelie, which we uh, which I think is also very good.
[37:56] Jess McInley: Um he also did uh Tuck Everlasting, which I did on another podcast because it it wouldn't really suit our show very well.
[38:04] Andrew DeWolf: So I covered it on what was the show called? Uh oh god. Jeffrey Jeffrey's podcast. I'm trying to remember it. Uh a musical theater podcast with Jeffrey Scott Parsons.
[38:17] Jess McInley: Well, I think if anything is strong in this, it's the music, even if in the recording it's a little bit mixed poorly.
[38:25] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.
[38:26] Jess McInley: Like the first song, um, a killer party, like after the prologue. I think this song's pretty good setting up all the characters, their goals, their relationships.
[38:36] Andrew DeWolf: It does what an opening number should do very well.
[38:38] Jess McInley: And it's fun.
[38:39] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it's bouncy.
[38:41] Jess McInley: I like it. It's got a it's got a really like on the nose joke, which is actually fine. I think this is one of the jokes that that lands.
[38:50] Andrew DeWolf: It's it's the host continuously saying, I feel so alive, and in every chorus, and it's like, yeah, he's he's gonna die, right?
[38:58] Jess McInley: For a murder mystery, that's a fun gag. That's not the worst joke in the world.
[39:03] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it's like that's fine. That's that's a funny-ish gag.
[39:07] Andrew DeWolf: Um and the song itself is fun to listen to. It's bouncy enough, so no faults in that. I also just love how the harmonies mixed. Listen to the cast album. The harmonies are really, really good in the cast album. They do not live too up to it in the video version. Um another song that I think is really good, is Justine's song Today's Detective. Someone just came this mechanism. The only ticket I'll be riding is my own ticket at a key. I think for an I want number, that's great. It kind of shows you how kind of down on her luck she is. Um, and I like the fact that she's kind of a detective that wasn't really a detective, which is a fun twist on it. Um, an underdog kind of style detective. Um it kind of makes it hard to root for her sometimes. As weird as that is. Is it because she doesn't know what she's doing, and you feel like, man, why didn't they send a real detective? Or a little bit.
[40:18] Jess McInley: Yeah. I mean, it'd be one thing if she was just kind of like an underling or like working in the agency, but not but she was a meter mate. Look, they had just seen Zootopia, and they're like, it worked, it worked in Zootopia, we're doing it.
[40:31] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, you're right. That was literally what happened in Zootopia. Shit. Huh. Man. Sorry, I gotta let that sink in for a second. Um I think that she sings this song beautifully. I think the song is really fun and kind of sets a tone for this character who isn't set up in the opening number. I think she's the only one not set up in the opening number.
[40:56] Jess McInley: Well, she is technically set up in the prologue.
[40:59] Andrew DeWolf: Prologue, but not in like the opening opening, the killer party one. And in this one, the detective is actually like the lead too, which some murder mysteries don't go that route.
[41:09] Jess McInley: Well, I've been writing a couple I do murder writing on the side. Andrew's done a couple readings of them. And the point of the detective is they're not really a character. They're not the one with the arc, they're the point of view of the audience. And as they learn something, we learn something. So it's really hard to try to give them depth when they are literally just our eyes and ears. Um but here, because it's a joke musical where the mystery doesn't really exist.
[41:40] Andrew DeWolf: Um the detective actually has an arc. An arc, and she's fun. She is a fun person to watch. She is the most engaging actor in the entire piece.
[41:50] Jess McInley: And she should be.
[41:51] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Um let's talk about stuck, because I know you hate this song.
[41:57] Jess McInley: It is the most pandemic related. Will I be awaiting here long? I swear to God, my hands are clean. I swear I've done nothing wrong, so why am I in quarantine? I'm all alone here. I'm all alone here. I'm all alone here. I'm all alone here. They say this a killer that's outside the door. The only thing I know for sure.
[42:34] Andrew DeWolf: It's just this is like the first song where they're just like, actually, we don't care about the murder mystery thing at all. We're just gonna do jokes. And on some level, I understand, although I kind of wish they would let the murder mystery thing build up a little bit, and then do the jokes, but instead they undermine it immediately.
[42:55] Jess McInley: And they do it with jokes about the real world rather than jokes about the world.
[43:00] Andrew DeWolf: The world around them is around them, so it's it's kind of like a gigantic swing and a miss, but also like they accidentally hit their own kneecaps or something. Like I I don't maybe it's not bad just because you don't like it, Andrew.
[43:16] Jess McInley: Okay, that's fine, but it is bad because I don't like it.
[43:21] Andrew DeWolf: I I get what you mean. And also just the song isn't that engaging.
[43:25] Jess McInley: Yeah, and then it ends with the TikTok joke, which I've already gone over three times, so this is the last time.
[43:30] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, you gotta pay it off. Rule of threes, my dude.
[43:32] Jess McInley: Rule of three. Uh the TikTok joke's bad. The end.
[43:35] Andrew DeWolf: That's the what this wasn't a joke. Man, Andrew just wants to drink the haterade. Doesn't wanna say nothing positive about nothing.
[43:46] Jess McInley: You know that's true, and that's why they're here.
[43:49] Andrew DeWolf: Well, what song is worth talking about next here?
[43:52] Jess McInley: Um There's so many songs.
[43:54] Andrew DeWolf: There are a lot of songs in this. Um, but I feel like there is a huge amount of them that are just not important.
[44:00] Jess McInley: Yeah, they're very, very well, the way that the show is formatted is a lot like another very famous musical by the name of Cats, where they introduce a character and they give them a song. The way they set up the miss quote unquote mystery as well is that basically every character that the detective goes to is set up to be a red herring.
[44:21] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. It's like this character, oh, they have a motive and they have a means that they could have done it. Oh, but they didn't. They say this person did it. Oh, but this person has a motive and a means that they could have done it. Oh, but they said they didn't and this person. And like, I think the next like four songs are just that.
[44:40] Jess McInley: Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah.
[44:45] Andrew DeWolf: I think I think one I'd want to talk about is uh the never miss my mark, which is when we finally break that cycle and someone is confessing to the murder. Remember when you wrote a fake prescription for the drugsuitamadex? Once in your blood, it sweeps the heart until you have an attack. And no one grabbed him, and then I stabbed him right in his neck just as the room went black. My show is a hit right out of the park with cool spectacle and compelling character arc. Plus the score is full of songs. Because I never miss my mark.
[45:38] Jess McInley: Yeah, and I think it's interesting that the way that they are framing like this is probably the most interesting and probably the first idea that like you I talk about this a lot. A song that is the spark and the reason that the musical exists. And this is a funny premise for a song where you have two narcissistic people that are so narcissistic that they want to take credit for a murder just because they would make them the center of attention.
[46:03] Andrew DeWolf: Like that's a funny idea.
[46:04] Jess McInley: No, it's it's funny, and you know the reveal in itself is a little wacky, but I I get it. Because these guys technically attempted murder, but they aren't the real murderer. Um but it's funny, like, oh, they're both singing about how great their murder attempt was. Um, but it turns out that they both thwarted each other and they accidentally stopped the murder from happening.
[46:29] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[46:30] Jess McInley: So it's goofy, and the song is is good. And this is the only one where the two actors are in the same room.
[46:36] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[46:36] Jess McInley: Like actually the same room. So that's why that duet kind of works.
[46:40] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. And their comic timing in the song is very, very good.
[46:45] Jess McInley: Um, speaking of things that are bad though, let's talk about Big Cat, the song about Jeremy Jordan.
[46:54] Andrew DeWolf: Be a cheek. Leaping through the forest. Be a leak. I know that you can. You can be a leading man. There's a leopard in here. No leopards are too hot. Oh, awesome lots. Not a lot left for options. There's a lion on sketchbox! I already said that. What is left? Maybe you're a bum cat. There's no way we can adopt that. In the tall grass looking for dinner. With a cross in the heart of the winter. Jungle cats are natural wonder. Always the hunter. We're a back killer in together. Now the crap from Android Weapon. It's a preload of kill when I'm out of the round. And you're gonna hear me the rim. Surprise.
[48:09] Jess McInley: So tell us about the Baker character, Andrew.
[48:12] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I mean, what is there to say? There's a it's a character that really likes Jeremy Jordan, and that's I mean, that's about it. He's nervous, and he's like, he can't even act innocent despite being innocent. Like that was what I thought he was set up. But then he just turns into it. And then he's like eating stuff, and Jeremy Jordan, like actual Jeremy and Jordan, starts showing up in the food. And I don't understand. I think honestly, this song exists because they got Jeremy Jordan in their like. Let's put him in. What do we got? Nothing.
[48:53] Jess McInley: Andrew, Jeremy Jordan was almost in the greatest showman.
[48:57] Andrew DeWolf: But not really.
[49:05] Jess McInley: Oh well.
[49:06] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I hate the song. This song really, really rubbed me the wrong way. And it is the most self-indulgent part of the entire show.
[49:13] Jess McInley: Well, it's literally like one, if you don't know who Jeremy Jordan is, the joke doesn't exist. Like there just isn't a joke.
[49:19] Andrew DeWolf: It's just not there. I guess the joke is that this person is showing up in his food, and you can try to interpret, like try to infer who this person is. It's I I don't know.
[49:33] Jess McInley: Yeah, I I mean I agree. It's a bad song. I found it confusing and bad.
[49:39] Andrew DeWolf: So there you go.
[49:40] Jess McInley: I think that's a question to bring up now. Cause with the premise of this show, um, that this is a show where I try to get you to like musical theater, um, and we've been doing this for well over a hundred and fifty episodes. Um, I think this is 153 right now. Um Is a show good if it's only made for theater people? Can a show be good if it's only made for theater people? Because I feel like this has no outreach stretch outside of theater people.
[50:07] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, I think on some level, any show can be good.
[50:11] Jess McInley: That's a lie.
[50:12] Andrew DeWolf: Any show could be good if you like it. I mean, I will argue that my opinion is correct, but I somebody in English class once told me that you should always speak objectively whenever you make an argument.
[50:22] Jess McInley: And I kind of took it to heart.
[50:23] Andrew DeWolf: So why? I don't know. I I just feel like it it it's a very angry way to speak, but it gets people engaged. It feels like Ben Shapiro talk, objectively speaking.
[50:35] Jess McInley: Um The Last Jedi is the worst Star Wars.
[50:37] Andrew DeWolf: Saying things like in my opinion and stuff like that, you're undermining your own argument. You're basically saying, well, you're allowed to disagree. But if you say if you just say like this was bad, then you're not leaving room for that. They have to argue why they don't think it's bad. And I think that's the premise of this show.
[50:53] Jess McInley: Yeah, but um, to your point, if it's only made for that audience, and that audience likes it, then it's successful, right?
[51:01] Andrew DeWolf: I guess it's a matter of what what do the creators want it to be and what does the audience think it is.
[51:07] Jess McInley: But I'm a part of that audience, and I found it a little pandering.
[51:12] Andrew DeWolf: But then again, I didn't watch it in the midst of the pandemic like most people did.
[51:16] Jess McInley: Yeah, I mean, I don't know.
[51:19] Andrew DeWolf: Like I got all the references, but I didn't find them funny, I think is more the thing.
[51:23] Jess McInley: Yeah, I mean, in with every fandom, there's always a group of like hyper fans who know everything. And like, sure, you guys can exclude me from your group or whatever, but I've watched 153 musicals at this point. Like, you can't say that I don't like music's musicals or that I don't understand what they are just because I don't know every actor and actress's name and like what year things came out.
[51:49] Andrew DeWolf: Like, I'm a fan, I'm not a hyper fan.
[51:52] Jess McInley: You know, it's like two different things, right? And this was made for people who are obsessed.
[51:57] Andrew DeWolf: And that's fine.
[51:59] Jess McInley: If that's what you are, and you like the Jeremy Jordan song because you're obsessed with Jeremy Jordan, whatever. But I don't know who he is.
[52:06] Andrew DeWolf: And I've seen two things with him in it, but I don't remember actors.
[52:10] Andrew DeWolf: I don't care.
[52:13] Jess McInley: And I respect you for that.
[52:15] Andrew DeWolf: That also makes it really easy to bring people on the show because you never get starstruck because you don't know who anyone is.
[52:21] Jess McInley: Dude, you could bring Jeremy Jordan on the show, and until the name popped up, I literally wouldn't know.
[52:28] Andrew DeWolf: There has been offers of Jeremy Jordan to be on the show. Um, and it just didn't feel right. I'm not gonna lie. So, uh, yeah, you know, it's fine. It's whatever.
[52:39] Andrew DeWolf: Here's the time where I'm gonna say nice things about someone not on the show who I'm 100% sure won't even listen to this episode, but, uh, it's I wanna say it. So Brent, you know he's been working on a Star Trek musical, uh, Star Trek parody musical for a couple years. I have seen a couple iterations of it. I have read a few iterations of it, I have given notes on many versions of it. I'm not a Star Trek fan. I get that musical. The jokes work. I laugh at it. I don't have to be a Star Trek Uber fan to enjoy what he did there.
[53:13] Andrew DeWolf: Um, same for a lot of the Star Kids stuff. Like, I don't have to know every Disney film to get twisted. It helps, but I don't have to. I don't even need to have seen Aladdin to get twisted. It's, I don't know, it's like a, it, and I feel like music theater is one of the biggest, like, uh, groups that does this. Uh-huh. But there's like this vortex of niche knowledge, and you just get sucked down this rabbit hole, and then you're making content for people that only understand stuff that are also down at the bottom of this vortex, right? And everybody else is like out here and they're like looking in, and it's like a black hole. They're like, I don't, what are you talking about?
[53:56] Jess McInley: Which is why I think our show works very well. You never let me get into that black hole because it is fairly easy to get into it like when you know a lot. Like if it was just me and Emily and Brent, it would go into that black hole within five minutes.
[54:09] Andrew DeWolf: Well, yeah, and then people who probably watch our show and like music theater and are like into it, but they, you know, they've seen a couple shows and they're not like obsessed, but they listen to us and they're like, Oh, we like it. But if they watched this, they probably wouldn't get the jokes.
[54:24] Jess McInley: Like they wouldn't understand what's happening.
[54:27] Andrew DeWolf: And he, I think they probably would get the jokes, they just wouldn't find them funny.
[54:31] Jess McInley: That's true. They might be like you, where they get the jokes, but they'd be like, Oh boy, they're really down there, huh? They're really in the black hole.
[54:39] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Cause I don't know. There is a lot of gatekeeping in the musical theater community, which I am not a fan of.
[54:46] Jess McInley: Well, and that's a lot of communities. And like you said, with the Star Trek example, there is a gatekeepy side of the Star Trek fandom.
[54:52] Andrew DeWolf: There absolutely is. And it is commendable that Brent is making it acceptable, uh, uh, accessible for people who aren't in the bottom of the Star Trek vortex because he could easily probably make jokes about, you know, season two, episode one, moment five, and like, and everyone's like, Oh, I know that, and everyone who doesn't know that is like, wait, what is, what's happening?
[55:16] Jess McInley: Okay, I hope Brent doesn't mind me going into this, but I think this is a great example for how he does parody, and I think it's funny without knowing the context, and he gives you enough to kind of make it there yourself. So you know Wrath of Khan, the Khan is the bad guy in Star Trek 2.
[55:34] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, he goes, he goes, Khan the in against him, yeah, you know.
[55:39] Jess McInley: Yeah, that, but the thing about Khan when he shows up in the TV show is that he is from the 1990s.
[55:48] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and then sent to the future.
[55:52] Jess McInley: Or whatever. Okay. Um, so Brent puts a line in there in Khan's first song, I'm from the 1990s, look it up, kids. Um, and then from that point on, he just makes 90s references and like he's surrounded by 90s paraphernalia and like the same generous guy.
[56:08] Andrew DeWolf: Exactly. Like, that is hilarious without knowing Star Trek things, but he gives you enough to get why that would be funny.
[56:16] Jess McInley: Well, it's also, it's not done in a gatekeepy way. Like he doesn't just suddenly Khan has all this 90s kids stuff, and you're just supposed to know, like, oh, he's doing a joke because in the original show, if you watched it, that he, uh, he's from the 90s, and but he tells you, he's just like, look it up. You know, that's funny. Here's the setup. Here's a bunch of payoff for the rest of the show.
[56:38] Andrew DeWolf: And I think a lot of really good parody does that. Like, you know, there's even good, like older parody movies that are like, like airplane. I'm not saying it's like a great movie now, but you could still watch it and you like nobody even knows what it's making fun of anymore.
[56:54] Jess McInley: It's like, what is it? Uh, airport or something, like is the movie.
[56:57] Andrew DeWolf: There is a specific black and white movie that it took every plot element for from. Um, then they took the visuals from Airport 70 for something, and then that was what nobody even knows that movie. That movie is completely irrelevant, but some people can still watch Airplane, and it's funny because the jokes are just funny.
[57:19] Jess McInley: Yes, you know, like, and that's how you do parody. That's what separates the young Frankensteins, the blazing saddles, and let's say, um, uh, the naked guns, apart from the epic movies, the scary movie threes. Those aren't, they aren't necessarily down the black hole of niche knowledge, but the jokes are so specific to certain movies that if you don't remember that movie, you're completely out of the loop.
[57:49] Andrew DeWolf: You're like, what's the joke? Have you ever seen like epic movie?
[57:53] Jess McInley: Uh, I've seen Epic Movie and Superhero Movie, I think were the two worst ones I've seen.
[57:58] Andrew DeWolf: Superhero Movie isn't garbage. I'm gonna defend that one. That one is at least a thing.
[58:06] Jess McInley: With writers and jokes.
[58:08] Andrew DeWolf: Epic Movie is just the Chronicles of Narnia. And it is, it's the jokes there are, and I mean, sorry to compare it to what we're talking about, but the jokes there are are just, Hey, Rec. Remember this actor? That's like pretty much that's the joke.
[58:23] Jess McInley: That's the joke. Like, look, it's Miley Cyrus. That's the joke.
[58:27] Andrew DeWolf: Oh my god, Iron Man!
[58:29] Jess McInley: And then in, yeah. All of this hate was for one song, by the way. It's not even for the whole show. This is just because they did one song.
[58:36] Andrew DeWolf: One song. Cut this song. Cut, cut, what is it? Big Cat is the song.
[58:42] Jess McInley: Yeah. Cut Big Cat.
[58:43] Andrew DeWolf: Get rid of it. Um, so one last song before we wrap this up. Process of elimination is probably my favorite song and scene within the musical.
[58:53] Jess McInley: How did Farzer end up lying face down in his suit? Did he do it to himself?
[59:01] Andrew DeWolf: Well, let's start with the group. Next to him was Lily. Maybe Lily slammed the door.
[59:09] Jess McInley: How could she have done it when George knocked her to the floor?
[59:15] Andrew DeWolf: The process of elimination. Let's call the body X. Solve the wind. That's the process of elimination.
[59:31] Jess McInley: Where she's like describing the entire thing. There's some really intense, really cool looking imagery where they just go full wacky with it. This is the 11 o'clock number. This is Justine's moment, and it's, it sells. It is a lot of fun to watch and a great, great scene.
[59:46] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, and the reveal is, it ends up being fun. It's stupid, but stupid fun. Like it, I wouldn't mind it in a musical that's more consistent.
[59:56] Jess McInley: Yeah.
[59:57] Andrew DeWolf: And really, overall, the whole thing wraps up and you feel fine about it.
[1:00:02] Jess McInley: Yeah.
[1:00:02] Andrew DeWolf: You're not like, you're not like angry or sour. You know, it leaves you with like that was fine.
[1:00:09] Jess McInley: And that's how you should feel about it, I guess.
[1:00:12] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I'm sorry that we don't have a big opinion on this. We had some great discussions in this episode, but I don't think we had an intense like feel about this.
[1:00:22] Jess McInley: Um, but you know who definitely has an intense feel about this? Um, Cheese Rating.
[1:00:30] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like we're jumping here. What is your overall thoughts on A Killer Party and your cheese rating?
[1:00:37] Jess McInley: Um, overall thoughts, I mean there's some worthwhile stuff to listen to, and I guess just as the cast recording is better.
[1:00:45] Andrew DeWolf: It is a significantly better listen, yes. So, I mean, check that out, I suppose. I don't know if I could say this is worth spending, you know, $13 on, especially now that the pandemic is pretty much over-ish. It's not really over, but the lockdown aspect of it is basically over, at least right now, until the anti-vaxxers put us back in.
[1:01:05] Jess McInley: But, you know.
[1:01:06] Andrew DeWolf: Whatever, what are you gonna do? Um, it's fine. Um, for what it is, it's fine. Uh, for cheese rating, I'm gonna give it, uh, I'm gonna give it cream cheese, because apparently during the pandemic, cream cheese sales, uh, went way up, like 40% increase.
[1:01:22] Jess McInley: So, oh, that's actually interesting.
[1:01:25] Andrew DeWolf: Um, so I thought the show was fine. The album is mixed better, and the songs are actually pretty stellar. I know we didn't talk about a bunch of them, but we're kind of on a time constraint this time. Um, but they're so well done, and the video version does not do them justice in any way whatsoever.
[1:01:43] Jess McInley: So if you're gonna give this a watch, give the cast recording a listen to, because you're not getting the full experience of the songs afterwards.
[1:01:50] Andrew DeWolf: So, honestly, the only cheese rating I can give this is Garfield's fifty-ninth book, which is entitled The Big Cheese, because that's also a big cat.
[1:02:02] Jess McInley: Wow, you really did you really did it with that one, Jess.
[1:02:05] Andrew DeWolf: Um, yeah, um, you should really like put a big ol' smiley face next to it, Juliet Antonio, when you get to our thing and put a big ol' frowny face next to Andrew's.
[1:02:16] Jess McInley: Well, I did research for mine.
[1:02:17] Andrew DeWolf: You did do research.
[1:02:18] Jess McInley: You know what? You're right. You should put a smiley face next to ours.
[1:02:22] Andrew DeWolf: Or you should put eight equals D next to Andrew's and eight equals equals equals equals D next to mine, because that's much more accurate.
[1:02:36] Jess McInley: You know who definitely has a big mouth? Our patrons, thank you guys for listening.
[1:02:43] Andrew DeWolf: We're on iTunes, Spotify, Stitcher at Musicals with Cheese. Please leave us a review on iTunes. We need more reviews on iTunes, or also we're gonna explode.
[1:02:50] Jess McInley: Uh, what the fuck am I saying? We're on Twitter at Cheesy Musicals, or shoot us an email at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com. Our title card is created by the amazing Jolene Casco. Go send her some love at Jolene Casco.
[1:03:05] Andrew DeWolf: Our keeper of the cheese is Juliet Antonio. This show is produced and edited by the Incredible, the wonderful, The Sadly Absent Brianna Jones. We do miss her.
[1:03:16] Jess McInley: Um, please, um, if you liked our brand new theme songs, and we're gonna have a bunch of them. Like, uh, we're gonna change them up depending on what we're talking about. And they were all created by Robin Nash of IOU Music UK. Go follow them on their website, or if you want to pay them.
[1:03:33] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, yeah, whatever. They have Instagram and all that. Please give them followers and say that we sent you.
[1:03:38] Jess McInley: Um, thank you to the Broadway Podcast Network for having us on the platform and for not kicking us off for bullying Jeremy Jordan.
[1:03:45] Andrew DeWolf: Um, we're just so hard on the Jeremy Jordan.
[1:03:49] Jess McInley: How will he survive with his dashing good looks like? Jeremy Jordan, the song Big Cat's not good, okay.
[1:03:55] Andrew DeWolf: That's it.
[1:03:56] Jess McInley: How will he survive with those dashing good looks and charm?
[1:04:00] Andrew DeWolf: My god, the man, the man should be destitute by Wednesday, am I right?
[1:04:05] Jess McInley: Yeah, once this drops, it's over.
[1:04:08] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, alrighty guys.
[1:04:11] Jess McInley: I think that's it. Andrew, do you have anything else left to say?
[1:04:14] Andrew DeWolf: Um, no. Have a good one, everybody.
[1:04:16] Jess McInley: Oh no, I've been stabbed!
[1:04:19] Andrew DeWolf: Oh.
[1:04:20] Jess McInley: He's dead.
[1:04:20] Andrew DeWolf: That's, I mean, that's too bad.
[1:04:22] Jess McInley: Haha! I am now stuck in quarantine, though.
[1:04:25] Andrew DeWolf: We should do a TikTok video.
[1:04:27] Jess McInley: I am his brother.
[1:04:28] Andrew DeWolf: I did the murder.
[1:04:31] Jess McInley: Very cool.
[1:04:32] Andrew DeWolf: And that was the musical.
[1:04:34] Jess McInley: That's it.
[1:04:35] Andrew DeWolf: Wait, did we ever spoil it?
[1:04:37] Jess McInley: Was this the first spoiler we did?
[1:04:38] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, that's the first spoiler right at the end. If you made it this far, fuck you.
[1:04:42] Jess McInley: You made it this far. Now you know the ending. Ha ha.
[1:04:46] Andrew DeWolf: See you next time on Musicals with Cheese.
[1:05:02] Jess McInley: There was a boom, then a shout, like I don't know the song, then a push, then a shove, something like that.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
