Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#179 - By Jeeves

"Banjo boy, banjo boy, you're the musical sun..." Grab your pig mask and banjo because this week we're talking about the terrible Andrew Lloyd Webber musical "By Jeeves," We chat about the stage show, how bad it is, and eventually we get bored and do Buzzfeed quizzes... Read More

From the show: Musicals with Cheese

1 h 1 min
2/10/22

About

"Banjo boy, banjo boy, you're the musical sun..." Grab your pig mask and banjo because this week we're talking about the terrible Andrew Lloyd Webber musical "By Jeeves," We chat about the stage show, how bad it is, and eventually we get bored and do Buzzfeed quizzes. it's a ton of fun.

Donate to Black Lives Matter here

Social Media:

Our WEBSITE

Musicals with Cheese on Twitter

Musicals W/ Cheese on Instagram

Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com

Merch!!

Jess Socials

Jess on Twitter

Jess on Instagram

Andrew Socials

Andrew on Instagram

Andrew on Twitter

Brianna Socials

Brianna on Twitter

Brianna on Instagram

Use our Affiliate Link

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:06] Jesse McInally: Hello, I'm Jesse McInally.

[0:08] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm Andrew DeWolf.

[0:10] Brianna Jones: And I'm Brianna Jones.

[0:11] Jesse McInally: And welcome to Musicals of Cheese, a podcast where I try to get Andrew and Bree to like musical theater. How are you guys doing today?

[0:16] Andrew DeWolf: Well, actually, my podcasting voice got stolen, so um, we're actually gonna have to do a narrative this episode.

[0:25] Brianna Jones: We can't do musicals with cheese.

[0:27] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[0:28] Jesse McInally: Oh, do you remember that one time that you and I tried to do a podcast about the show By Jeeves, Andrew?

[0:36] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, yes, that was an interesting story.

[0:40] Jesse McInally: Um could you start?

[0:43] Andrew DeWolf: Um, yes, yes, yes.

[0:45] Jesse McInally: We were sitting down at our podcasting table, you know, just kind of like this, and we're all gonna sit down. And Brianna was there, but you know what? Let's have an actress portray Brianna. Bring in Uma Thurman.

[0:56] Brianna Jones: Yes, yes, excellent.

[0:59] Jesse McInally: Good choice. Hello, Uma Thurman. How are you doing? Bri, I mean, I'm sorry. Hello, Brianna. How are you doing?

[1:05] Brianna Jones: Hello. I'm doing well.

[1:07] Jesse McInally: My god, Uma Thurman is a fantastic actress. Remember, I remember it started. I introduced myself as Jess.

[1:12] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, yeah, this is Jess, by the way.

[1:16] Jesse McInally: This is Jess. Uma Thurman Bree. And I my name is Andrew DeWolf.

[1:21] Brianna Jones: Ah.

[1:22] Andrew DeWolf: Actually, uh, hang on. You're actually Bree.

[1:25] Brianna Jones: Oh, I'm Bree now.

[1:26] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, okay. Yes, yes, yes, I'm Bree. And oh no, Jake has walked in the room, and who uh he's asking who we are, and it turns out uh I'm Andrew again.

[1:37] Jesse McInally: Um, but we don't want someone else to find out.

[1:43] Andrew DeWolf: I hate this show. This show is garbage.

[1:45] Jesse McInally: This week we're talking about By Jeeves, a Patreon request from Joseph Evans Green, in case you haven't figured it out. Cue the fucking music, Bree.

[2:04] Jesse McInally: By George by Jove, by Jeeves. If the intro wasn't funny, don't blame us.

[2:16] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, try watching the musical.

[2:18] Jesse McInally: Don't want to.

[2:19] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, better best.

[2:20] Jesse McInally: You're making better choices than we are. So By Jeeves is a musical with a book by Alan Ayckbourn and music and lyrics by Andrew Lloyd Webber and Alan Ayckbourn. Um, based on Jeeves stories by P.G. Wodehouse. Um, so I'm gonna take a dive back in history. How about this? Um this was Andrew Lloyd Webber's original follow-up to Jesus Christ Superstar, if you think about it.

[2:45] Andrew DeWolf: Um, so originally Tim Rice, who he did Superstar, Evita with and Joseph with, conceived the idea of turning the Jeeves stories into a musical. Um he was to work with Andrew Lloyd Webber on creating it, but Tim Rice backed out of the project.

[2:59] Jesse McInally: Eventually, the Wade Weber teamed up with famed British playwright Alan Ayckbourn, and the two of them began work with the personal blessing of Wodehouse. Um the director was Eric Thompson, who's actually the father of Emma Thompson.

[3:13] Andrew DeWolf: He was fired right before the opening, so Ayckbourn took over himself and just directed the show right before it opens.

[3:20] Jesse McInally: It received horrible reviews and closed after a little over a month at after 38 performances. Several critics noted that the authors failed to develop the title character Jeeves, not even having a solo song.

[3:32] Andrew DeWolf: It was so bad, like so terrible, that when he was trying to figure out where The Phantom of the Opera was going, he did not want to play at the Her Majesty's Theater because he thought it was cursed.

[3:43] Jesse McInally: Okay. So the original cast album um was recorded and released, but is it extremely hard to find because Lloyd Webber, reportedly, acting on the advice of American theater director Harold Prince, withdrew the recording in order to be able to reuse some of the musical material in subsequent shows because it had so little of value.

[4:03] Andrew DeWolf: So that was the first time Andrew Lloyd Webber tried to make a Jeeves musical, alright? That is not the show we watched, Andrew. Has anyone found that original cast album?

[4:13] Jesse McInally: I'm sure it's somewhere. The internet's a magical place. So in 1996, Lloyd Webber and Ayckbourn decided to try it again, you know, jettisoning basically the entirety of the score and the entire book, and retitled By Jeeves to avoid association with the previous flop version.

[4:28] Andrew DeWolf: It reopened on the first of May 1996 at the Stephen Joseph Theatre in the Round in Scarborough.

[4:35] Jesse McInally: Um audience reaction was generally enthusiastic, so the show moved to July 2nd, 1996, to London for a 12-week season at the fairly intimate Duke's York Theatre.

[4:45] Andrew DeWolf: The show turned out to be even more popular than first thought, and the run was extended to February 1997, where the show moved to the Lyric Theatre in Shaftesbury Avenue.

[4:53] Jesse McInally: It had a short run on Broadway at the Helen Hayes Theater from October 28th, 2001 to the 30th of December 2001, for 73 performances.

[5:03] Andrew DeWolf: So the show was never really the it was not a phantom, it was not a smash hit. I wouldn't really even call it the Woman in White or School of Rock levels. Do you want to know what the plot is, Andrew?

[5:15] Jesse McInally: Or would how about you describe the plot for us?

[5:17] Andrew DeWolf: What do you what is the plot By Jeeves?

[5:19] Jesse McInally: I know the plot to By Jeeves.

[5:21] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, tell me the plot of By Jeeves.

[5:23] Jesse McInally: Alright. Hmm. Okay. So there's this guy who is a banjo playing star, apparently, and everyone in the audience is there to see a banjo concert, right? Like that's that's the start of the show.

[5:36] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[5:40] Jesse McInally: Um but actually we're not because there is no banjo. The banjo's been stolen. So then his faithful servant, Jeeves, comes out and is like, oh, actually, you should um do a narrative instead.

[5:55] Andrew DeWolf: So then they do this narrative where oh lord. Tell tell us what the narrative, Andrew is. Please, please, please.

[6:01] Andrew DeWolf: Oh Lord. I d I've been trying to avoid this part. Okay, um.

[6:06] Jesse McInally: So he is his the main guy Wooster guy number one, Wooster.

[6:12] Andrew DeWolf: I can't you can't use their names to keep track of them though.

[6:15] Jesse McInally: So guy number one, Wooster, whose actual name is Wooster, claims to a judge to be guy number two, who is what what is his name?

[6:26] Andrew DeWolf: Like, uh oh my goodness. Uh Finster or something like that.

[6:31] Jesse McInally: Chucky Finster.

[6:32] Andrew DeWolf: Chucky Finster. He he he says to a judge that he's Chucky Finster, but Chucky Finster is in love with the judge's daughter.

[6:41] Jesse McInally: Stinker Pinker.

[6:42] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. Gotta put in the stink in the pink. Like he he really messed up. Damn.

[6:47] Jesse McInally: Okay, so Stinker is in love with the judge's daughter, so Stinker tells her tell well she knows that he's actually Stinker. But the father, he told that he's Wooster, because he why he would use the name of the other, I don't know.

[7:05] Andrew DeWolf: So are you the judge.

[7:07] Jesse McInally: The judge thinks that Wooster is Finster?

[7:12] Andrew DeWolf: Wooster's the main character that wants his banjo.

[7:14] Jesse McInally: Wooster's the main character.

[7:16] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[7:16] Jesse McInally: The judge thinks that Wooster is actually Stinker, but Stinker... but the show...

[7:22] Andrew DeWolf: What do you think Stinker is Wooster?

[7:24] Jesse McInally: This judge's daughter is a prop.

[7:26] Andrew DeWolf: The judge's daughter is a prop that they're fighting over. No wonder why she's not on the cat original.

[7:31] Jesse McInally: So then the judge comes over and he's like, he comes over to Wooster's house, but Stinker tells the judge that it's his house.

[7:40] Andrew DeWolf: So the judge comes over and Wooster is hiding in a coat rack, and the judge is like, oh dang. We're not even 20 minutes into this musical leaver.

[7:49] Jesse McInally: That coat rack is talking.

[7:51] Andrew DeWolf: And then Wooster comes out and he's like, oh, I'm actually I'm Stinker. Uh bye.

[7:59] Jesse McInally: And then he leaves.

[8:01] Andrew DeWolf: So then do you think it'd be easier if I just read what Playbill describes the show as?

[8:06] Jesse McInally: If you want to.

[8:07] Andrew DeWolf: I'm trying to explain the plot here, though, but I mean, sure.

[8:10] Jesse McInally: I mean, uh I I feel like we're all lost in the plot right now.

[8:16] Brianna Jones: Like, so Wooster.

[8:19] Jesse McInally: Alright, so I'm just gonna read and then maybe Bree, can you try to surmise what Andrew just said?

[8:25] Brianna Jones: Um, yeah, okay.

[8:28] Jesse McInally: I didn't even get more than like 10 minutes in. Wooster, the main character.

[8:33] Brianna Jones: Yes, you're good so far.

[8:34] Jesse McInally: You got it so far. Wooster the main character. Um and we got Stinker Pinker or World.

[8:40] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, you're already lost.

[8:43] Jesse McInally: See, Wooster needs his banjo because he's supposed to be putting on a banjo performance. But then Jeeves comes out and he's like, Hey, your banjo isn't here yet. It'll take about two and a half hours. How about we put on a little show for these people?

[8:55] Andrew DeWolf: And he tells recounts a story about when he faked identities. And then comes Harold Pinker. He's like, I need to pretend to be you, Wooster.

[9:01] Jesse McInally: And then Wooster's like, uh, I don't know about okay, okay, I guess.

[9:05] Andrew DeWolf: And then the judge comes in and he's like, You're you're the you're a coat rack, Wooster, and he's like, No, I'm not Wooster, I'm Pinker.

[9:11] Jesse McInally: And then Pinker's like, I'm Wooster. So mistaken identities, all that. You kind of follow where that is.

[9:15] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, Andrew, continue.

[9:18] Jesse McInally: Oh, okay. I'm keep going.

[9:19] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, go. Because I feel like we just had to sum up where we are at this point.

[9:23] Jesse McInally: Yeah, there's a lot going on for a second. We're good.

[9:26] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Um, so then he goes into his car and he's going, he's going to the judge's house, and I don't I don't quite understand why he's doing this.

[9:35] Jesse McInally: Who is doing this?

[9:36] Andrew DeWolf: Jess Wooster is Wooster.

[9:38] Jesse McInally: Real Wooster, not fake Wooster. Why is Wooster going to the judge's house?

[9:41] Andrew DeWolf: I don't think I caught that.

[9:43] Jesse McInally: Um, so they can make a joke about making the the motor noises with his mouth.

[9:49] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, so he's just there's no reason for him to go there.

[9:52] Jesse McInally: Okay, because every character is going to the judge's house. I don't understand it.

[9:56] Andrew DeWolf: Um, is there a party going on? I feel like that that makes sense, right?

[9:59] Jesse McInally: Yeah, there must be.

[10:00] Andrew DeWolf: I don't, but they're all sleeping there too. But every character's going to the judge's house.

[10:05] Jesse McInally: So if I mention a character, assume that they're going to the judge's house.

[10:09] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[10:09] Jesse McInally: So then Wooster is driving his car, and he accidentally hits somebody who is his friend, and this guy's name is Stuart Little.

[10:16] Andrew DeWolf: Um, this is he's a mouse.

[10:18] Jesse McInally: Um I think his name actually is Little though.

[10:24] Andrew DeWolf: Bingo Little.

[10:25] Jesse McInally: Bingo Little. Um, so he is doing a walk for hedgehogs.

[10:32] Andrew DeWolf: Uh it's a charity walk for hedgehogs.

[10:34] Jesse McInally: And his girlfriend is also doing a charity walk for hedgehogs, but he needs to catch up.

[10:40] Andrew DeWolf: So Wooster agrees to give him a lift, but then he also somehow ends up also giving the girlfriend a lift, but the guy is hiding in the back, so the girlfriend doesn't know.

[10:49] Jesse McInally: But the girlfriend also used to be Wooster's girlfriend.

[10:52] Andrew DeWolf: So the girlfriend is hitting on Wooster the whole time, so then Little gets angry at him because angry at Wooster.

[11:00] Jesse McInally: I know why Wooster's going to the judge's house. Because it says that he's engaged to Stiffy, whoever that the girl, that's his friend, but he did not his girlfriend, and he wants to be like, hey, what's going on here?

[11:11] Andrew DeWolf: So he wants to talk to her about it. That's why he's going to the house.

[11:14] Jesse McInally: Okay. Why is she at the judge's house?

[11:17] Andrew DeWolf: I think that's where she lives.

[11:19] Jesse McInally: Why does everyone live at the judge's house?

[11:21] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know, Andrew. Whatever. British people are fucking weird and they love this for some reason.

[11:26] Jesse McInally: So then everybody gets out of the car. Um, but everyone's mad at Wooster now.

[11:30] Andrew DeWolf: Everyone's mad at Wooster.

[11:32] Jesse McInally: So then he goes to the judge's house, and he meets this American man who is the best character in the street.

[11:37] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, the best character, the most interesting character.

[11:39] Jesse McInally: By far.

[11:40] Andrew DeWolf: By far the best character, has all of the best stuff.

[11:42] Jesse McInally: Has a mustache.

[11:44] Andrew DeWolf: Has the mustache, has the best song, has all the all the best stuff, but he's also kind of a little creepy, so he's not really the best character.

[11:51] Jesse McInally: But okay, well, you know, we'll it's fine.

[11:53] Andrew DeWolf: It's fine.

[11:53] Jesse McInally: He's fun in a Gaston sort of way.

[11:56] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[11:56] Jesse McInally: He's the villain, you know.

[11:58] Andrew DeWolf: So um, he meets this American guy, and the American guy is like, Oh, I'm in love with this girl, and it's the judge's daughter who, you know, and and he's like, And he doesn't want to it's the judge's daughter, but the announcement just said in the paper that he is in g Wooster was engaged to the judge's daughter, which is his real name, so he gives a different name so he won't get his ass kicked by this American.

[12:17] Andrew DeWolf: So he gives Little's name.

[12:19] Jesse McInally: You have it wrong.

[12:20] Andrew DeWolf: You have it uh you have it wrong.

[12:21] Jesse McInally: Do I?

[12:22] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[12:23] Jesse McInally: This is uh He gives Little's name later.

[12:27] Andrew DeWolf: He gives his he gives his real name at first.

[12:29] Jesse McInally: You're right, you're right, you're right.

[12:31] Andrew DeWolf: So he gives his real name at first, and for some reason, the guy, even though I assume he would have talked to the judge, but I guess he got it directly from the daughter, and the daughter actually told him that she was dating Stinker.

[12:45] Jesse McInally: Um he's like, Man, I want to beat the crap out of this stinker guy if I ever meet him.

[12:51] Andrew DeWolf: Um, you know, and okay.

[12:53] Jesse McInally: So they're all lying to each other.

[12:55] Andrew DeWolf: It's yeah, you're following that we're just lying about it.

[12:58] Jesse McInally: It's really great.

[12:59] Andrew DeWolf: I want everyone to remember though that they're also these are all characters that are introduced at the start of the show as different characters, too.

[13:06] Jesse McInally: So these characters all have like three names.

[13:10] Andrew DeWolf: Um just let's what's the fast version?

[13:13] Jesse McInally: We we're getting to the end of act one eventually, right?

[13:15] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, we're we're here, we're here, we're here.

[13:17] Jesse McInally: So now now it's just like, oh, the judge comes out and they all change names.

[13:20] Andrew DeWolf: Eventually, everybody is everybody else's name.

[13:23] Jesse McInally: The Wooster is Little and all this, and then somebody approaches him, approaches Wooster, and is like, Man, you gotta Rob pretend to rob the house.

[13:32] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[13:32] Jesse McInally: It just out of nowhere.

[13:33] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, that felt weird.

[13:35] Jesse McInally: You gotta pretend to rob the house, and then he's like, Oh man, I guess I have to pretend to rob the house.

[13:39] Andrew DeWolf: And he wears a pig mask.

[13:40] Jesse McInally: Yeah, and then they're all chasing the pig around the house, and it's not funny and it's horrible.

[13:45] Andrew DeWolf: And then he goes outside and Jeeves breaks the fourth wall and is just like, oh, actually, um, the American guy gets framed for this.

[13:55] Jesse McInally: Ha ha.

[13:56] Andrew DeWolf: Um, you get off scot-free.

[13:58] Jesse McInally: Um, cool.

[13:59] Andrew DeWolf: And then they're like, oh, the banjo's here, and they give him the banjo, and he doesn't play the banjo, and I I literally want to die.

[14:06] Jesse McInally: It's like the worst ending in my of the whole in everything.

[14:10] Andrew DeWolf: They don't even play the banjo.

[14:11] Jesse McInally: I waited two hours to hear the banjo song.

[14:14] Andrew DeWolf: They don't even play the fucking banjo.

[14:16] Jesse McInally: Like, why would you do this to me?

[14:18] Andrew DeWolf: It's the longest no lube hand job you've ever gotten, and right when you're about to go, they like just let go.

[14:25] Jesse McInally: It's like, are you kidding me?

[14:27] Andrew DeWolf: You literally you start it by telling me there's gonna be a banjo, and then immediately, rug pulled, I don't get a banjo.

[14:35] Jesse McInally: End of it, I see the banjo, and I'm like, oh, I can't wait to hear the banjo song.

[14:39] Andrew DeWolf: Actually, at least that'll be funny.

[14:41] Jesse McInally: Actually, I'm changing my analogy.

[14:43] Andrew DeWolf: It's a no lube hand job, and right when you're about to to finish, they stop you.

[14:51] Jesse McInally: It's very accurate.

[14:53] Andrew DeWolf: This is extremely accurate.

[14:54] Jesse McInally: So I just I hate it.

[14:58] Andrew DeWolf: I just I I didn't like it.

[15:00] Jesse McInally: I couldn't follow it well because they didn't want me to follow it.

[15:04] Andrew DeWolf: And the only time I laughed was when the American guy was shaking hands with everybody because that was kind of funny.

[15:09] Jesse McInally: I laughed once.

[15:10] Andrew DeWolf: A grand total of once when when uh Jeeves is like setting up the time, he's like, it is 9 30, and it's like bright sunny PM, and then they change it tonight.

[15:20] Jesse McInally: That was the one joke I laughed at.

[15:23] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, I laughed when I laughed when they said the American guy was sticky because he's covered in jam.

[15:29] Jesse McInally: I thought that was kind of funny.

[15:30] Andrew DeWolf: And I thought it was sort of funny when they convinced the American guy that British people just reintroduce themselves every single day.

[15:38] Jesse McInally: Because that just feels like something British people actually would do.

[15:42] Andrew DeWolf: So Bree, what do you think of that story?

[15:45] Brianna Jones: Could you could you follow it?

[15:47] Andrew DeWolf: I understand it.

[15:49] Brianna Jones: I I understand big picture.

[15:52] Andrew DeWolf: Everybody is confused.

[15:54] Brianna Jones: No, no one's confused.

[15:55] Everybody's switching names.

[15:56] Andrew DeWolf: And there's no dance.

[15:58] Brianna Jones: The audience is confused.

[16:00] Andrew DeWolf: And did you notice something in that story?

[16:07] Brianna Jones: Could it be Jeeves?

[16:09] Andrew DeWolf: Where the fuck is Jeeves?

[16:14] Brianna Jones: So Jeeves just exists as like a narrator character, and the only joke is like the only joke the entire time is the Wooster guy will be like, wait, what's happening?

[16:24] Andrew DeWolf: And then Jeeves will be like, This is happening, sir.

[16:27] Brianna Jones: And then that's like the only joke.

[16:29] Andrew DeWolf: They just do that like 50,000 times during the entire thing.

[16:32] Brianna Jones: It's horrible.

[16:33] Andrew DeWolf: It sounds horrible.

[16:34] Brianna Jones: It was a rough watch, and I wanted it to end.

[16:37] Andrew DeWolf: I had to watch this in like 20 minute increments because I had to walk away and do something that actually made me feel good, made me feel like a human being for a little bit.

[16:49] Brianna Jones: You know, it it just I know like there are some people out there that are like, man, I have to do like manual labor for a job, or oh this.

[16:58] Andrew DeWolf: I had to watch by Jeeves, so honestly kiss my ass.

[17:02] Brianna Jones: You know what? You know what though? I don't think this is the worst Weber thing we've covered.

[17:07] Andrew DeWolf: Well, we're gonna make you do a tier list.

[17:09] Brianna Jones: Oh yeah, this is an Andrew Lloyd Webber musical, which is this is the least Lloyd Webery Lloyd Weber musical.

[17:15] Andrew DeWolf: Like the songs you feel so separate from what's going on.

[17:19] Brianna Jones: I wouldn't have known if I didn't get told, to be honest.

[17:23] Andrew DeWolf: It it feels so wrong.

[17:25] Brianna Jones: I I hate it.

[17:29] Andrew DeWolf: End of statement.

[17:31] Brianna Jones: It's just it's all like I've made complaints before. It's like, man, this show had too many characters, I couldn't follow it.

[17:37] Andrew DeWolf: And then this show comes and is like, oh, hold my beer.

[17:41] Brianna Jones: You're not gonna follow this shit.

[17:44] Andrew DeWolf: Even me reading the Wikipedia page right now, I'm like, fuck, what's I'm lost?

[17:51] Brianna Jones: It's like you could have written like a time travel plot and it would have made more sense.

[17:59] Andrew DeWolf: I understood Donnie Darko more than I understood by Jeeves.

[18:02] Brianna Jones: Oh man, I can follow Donnie Darko.

[18:04] Andrew DeWolf: I get what's going on there.

[18:06] Brianna Jones: Big talking bunny.

[18:08] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[18:09] Brianna Jones: Alright.

[18:09] Andrew DeWolf: Um what else is there to say?

[18:12] Brianna Jones: It's time for a previews.

[18:14] Andrew DeWolf: Previews!

[18:15] Brianna Jones: It's Tom for the preview.

[18:20] Andrew DeWolf: It's Tom for previews.

[18:23] Brianna Jones: Um, how about we hear what Ben Brantley had to say about by Jeeves?

[18:26] Andrew DeWolf: See if we agree with him.

[18:28] Brianna Jones: Yeah.

[18:29] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[18:31] Brianna Jones: What did Ben Brantley have to say?

[18:32] Andrew DeWolf: Let's see if he agrees with us.

[18:33] Brianna Jones: Okay, Ben Brantley in his 1996 review for the New York Times wrote that there's not a hydraulic lift in evidence at the pocket-sized Norma Terrace Theater of the Goodspeed Opera House.

[18:48] Andrew DeWolf: The unlikely setting for the latest import from Andrew Lloyd Webber.

[18:54] Brianna Jones: The king of the monster musical.

[18:57] Andrew DeWolf: There's not even a painted backdrop to conceal the bare brick walls.

[19:02] Brianna Jones: Which would appear to confirm Mr. Lloyd Weber's belief in his recent um assertion that the party's over for the spectacle driven musical.

[19:12] Andrew DeWolf: Here's what I look like without makeup.

[19:14] Brianna Jones: The show seems to be saying, take me as I am.

[19:17] Andrew DeWolf: It poses a burning historical question.

[19:20] Brianna Jones: Can a Lloyd Weber show fly if the scenery doesn't?

[19:24] Andrew DeWolf: No.

[19:24] Brianna Jones: Man, he is overthinking this like a lot.

[19:28] Andrew DeWolf: He put more thought into this than we did.

[19:32] Brianna Jones: So there's no backdrop or anything in the musical?

[19:35] Andrew DeWolf: Not really.

[19:36] Brianna Jones: It's just the well, it it is there like a set at all?

[19:40] Andrew DeWolf: The idea of it is that there isn't a set because they're doing the show on the fly.

[19:45] Brianna Jones: Because it was supposed to be a banjo concert.

[19:49] Andrew DeWolf: That's the stupidest sentence we've ever said on the show.

[19:53] Brianna Jones: That's what it is, though.

[19:55] Andrew DeWolf: I know, but we we we it's sorry, we it's you not every day you know you've said the stupidest thing you've ever said, but you just said it, Andrew.

[20:04] Brianna Jones: It's done on the list because there was supposed to be a banjo concert.

[20:08] Andrew DeWolf: When are they getting to the banjo concert?

[20:12] Brianna Jones: The best twist setting would have been Steve Martin coming out, and then it's just Bright Star.

[20:17] Andrew DeWolf: They just played Bright Star.

[20:20] Brianna Jones: Continue, Brie.

[20:22] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[20:23] Brianna Jones: Uh, for the moment, the answer is at best, a qualified yes.

[20:28] Andrew DeWolf: A reworking of Mr. Lloyd Weber's and Mr. Ackborn Jeeves, a well-dressed flop in London in 1975.

[20:37] Brianna Jones: The musical turns Woodhouse artfully spun narratives of aristocrat dim-wittedness into vaud villain slapstick.

[20:45] Andrew DeWolf: And like the amateur theatrics, it parodies, it often strains to entertain.

[20:53] Brianna Jones: Yeah, yeah, you're getting there.

[20:55] Andrew DeWolf: You got there, Brad Brantley.

[20:57] Brianna Jones: Strains is a is an understatement.

[20:59] Andrew DeWolf: Much of what makes the Jeeves story so comforting is that they are are tales told by an idiot, the rich, slothful Bertie Wooster, who is utterly dependent on his peerless man-servant Jeeves.

[21:16] Brianna Jones: Even when the action is frenzied, Bertie's voice isn't.

[21:20] Andrew DeWolf: It's endearingly fuzzy, suggesting a cushion of langor, money and good old stupidity between him and the world.

[21:29] Brianna Jones: Take away that voice, and what's left is more primitive comedy of the Benny Hill variety.

[21:36] Andrew DeWolf: The cast members are appealingly game as they scramble through a frank frantic plot of mistaken identities, but they can also be unappealingly shrill.

[21:47] Brianna Jones: Yes, I agree.

[21:48] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, the show sucks.

[21:50] Brianna Jones: Fuck you, Ben Brantley for being as slightly positive as you were.

[21:53] Andrew DeWolf: He was slightly positive, wasn't he?

[21:56] Brianna Jones: He was trying.

[21:57] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[21:57] Brianna Jones: I think I think he might have felt like he had to be nice because it was uh Lloyd Weber.

[22:01] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know.

[22:02] Brianna Jones: Probably.

[22:02] Andrew DeWolf: Well, he he he was like Lloyd Weber's trying something new, and I don't want to talk him out of doing something new.

[22:08] Brianna Jones: Yeah.

[22:11] Andrew DeWolf: He didn't have to get talked out of it though, to be honest.

[22:15] Brianna Jones: I mean, Jeeves, this was a passion project.

[22:18] Andrew DeWolf: He's been wanting to do this since the seventies.

[22:20] Brianna Jones: Think about this.

[22:20] Andrew DeWolf: This was a passion project.

[22:22] Brianna Jones: This was a what goes on in that man's mind?

[22:26] Andrew DeWolf: Not much.

[22:27] Brianna Jones: Other people's music.

[22:29] Andrew DeWolf: Oh man, we didn't even we didn't even bring up the the Wizard of Oz stuff at the end.

[22:33] Brianna Jones: No God.

[22:34] Andrew DeWolf: Um let's let's hold on that for a minute.

[22:37] Brianna Jones: Um let's keep on Brie Views for a second.

[22:39] Andrew DeWolf: It's time for a letterboxed game of one star or five stars.

[22:43] Brianna Jones: Brie, Andrew, you're going head to head again.

[22:45] Andrew DeWolf: Back to the old classics.

[22:47] Brianna Jones: So would you believe by Jeeves does have a letterbox account?

[22:50] Andrew DeWolf: There ain't many reviews, but there's a couple.

[22:53] Brianna Jones: I don't believe it, but sure.

[22:56] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, it's time.

[22:57] Brianna Jones: Alright, Brie, you're on first.

[22:59] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[23:01] Brianna Jones: Go on.

[23:01] Andrew DeWolf: Pretend this is actually any good.

[23:05] Brianna Jones: One star.

[23:06] Andrew DeWolf: That is correct.

[23:08] Brianna Jones: Andrew.

[23:09] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[23:13] Brianna Jones: How do you do?

[23:14] Andrew DeWolf: How do you do?

[23:15] Brianna Jones: How do you do?

[23:15] Andrew DeWolf: How do you do?

[23:17] Brianna Jones: They're actually quoting the show.

[23:19] Andrew DeWolf: Oh boy.

[23:20] Brianna Jones: Five stars?

[23:21] Andrew DeWolf: That is correct.

[23:22] Brianna Jones: Nice.

[23:23] Andrew DeWolf: Someone gave it five stars.

[23:24] Brianna Jones: Is that Ben Bradley?

[23:25] Andrew DeWolf: Who knows?

[23:26] Brianna Jones: I I felt like I was taking a big risk with that, because somebody giving it five stars is like, woof.

[23:35] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, Bree, you ready?

[23:37] Brianna Jones: Yes.

[23:38] Andrew DeWolf: Jeeves wouldn't do this.

[23:40] Brianna Jones: Oh.

[23:43] Andrew DeWolf: One star.

[23:44] Brianna Jones: That is correct.

[23:47] Andrew DeWolf: Andrew, you ready?

[23:48] Brianna Jones: Yeah.

[23:49] Andrew DeWolf: This is the hard one.

[23:51] Brianna Jones: Part of the show must go on.

[23:53] Andrew DeWolf: Which was Andrew Lloyd Webber's pandemic thing where he would air all of his musicals live onto YouTube.

[23:59] Brianna Jones: So he aired all of his musicals live on YouTube.

[24:02] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, he did cats.

[24:02] Brianna Jones: He did like everything that had a recorded production.

[24:04] Andrew DeWolf: And this this is the only comment is that it was part of it.

[24:08] Brianna Jones: Yes.

[24:09] Andrew DeWolf: My gut says one star.

[24:10] Brianna Jones: Your gut was correct.

[24:14] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, Bree, you ready?

[24:15] Brianna Jones: Yes.

[24:17] Andrew DeWolf: By Jeeves walks, so the play that goes wrong could work could run.

[24:35] Jesse McInally: Oh no, another quote from the show.

[24:38] Andrew DeWolf: Oh.

[24:40] Jesse McInally: Five stars.

[24:41] Andrew DeWolf: That's a one star.

[24:42] Brianna Jones: Bree!

[24:45] Jesse McInally: Um, we got two reviews left, so this is literally us at the bottom of the barrel. Here it is.

[24:51] Andrew DeWolf: I had no idea what was going on and gave up. It's no one's fault but mine because I had expectations. Sorry, Angeloid Weber. I think as well, it should it was a story I'm not familiar with them. One star.

[25:06] Brianna Jones: That was a five-star.

[25:08] Andrew DeWolf: What?

[25:09] Jesse McInally: They blame themselves for not understanding the story.

[25:13] Andrew DeWolf: That probably obvious.

[25:15] Jesse McInally: That poor person needs to go to therapy.

[25:18] Andrew DeWolf: The story was obviously perfect. The problem was me.

[25:23] Jesse McInally: That is the You're right, you're right. Andrew, the last one.

[25:28] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. This is a weird show. It's not that I didn't like it, but rather that it feels like it was made for 50 plus theater people drunk on wine. One star.

[25:39] Brianna Jones: That is correct. You have tied the game.

[25:42] Jesse McInally: Yay! What a fun game. That was actually much more difficult than I expected it to be. And a lot more material than I expected it to be from for reviews letterbox game.

[25:55] Andrew DeWolf: I'm surprised that this had anything, but I guess they did film it, so.

[25:59] Jesse McInally: And they did like air it like last year during the Pangea.

[26:02] Andrew DeWolf: Ah, boy. Honestly, I would rather get COVID-19 than watch By Jeeves.

[26:10] Jesse McInally: I'm kidding.

[26:11] Andrew DeWolf: No, I wouldn't. I wish there was a vaccine for the show.

[26:16] Jesse McInally: Yes, I wish there was a vaccine for my By Jeeves. Speaking of wishing there was a vaccine, how about we go into a mid-show?

[26:23] Andrew DeWolf: Sure.

[26:24] Jesse McInally: Awesome. Hey guys, sorry to interrupt me a little show, but we've got a shell at you. Today's show is brought to you by the extremely kind donations by our donors over at Patreon. At Patreon, you can give us some money to help us keep the lights on, keep becoming a better bigger and better show for you guys. Um if you join us, you get a lot of fun perks, such as a weekly podcast with me and Liz Eston, where we're talking about TV shows. We're just finishing up Encore over there. We're gonna start something new. Um, and you could probably vote on what we do if you join over at Patreon at the $5 level. Also, if you give us any money, you can get the video episodes of this podcast where you get a lot of extra bits.

Like, there have been times where Brie has cut lots out of episodes, and the people on Patreon are getting half hours to 45 minutes of extra material. And you're missing out on that, as well as our beautiful faces if you're not over at Patreon. Also, once a month we have a weekly or a monthly meetup where we have guests and we come and hang out on our Discord page and we play games. And it's a lot of fun. Even these two will show up and have a blast with us, and you're missing out if you're not there. Um, but worst of all, if you are on our $20 level, or you know what? I lied. If you're at our a hundred dollar level, you get to be a guest with us eventually, and you have to force us to read a paragraph once every episode. And you know what? Joseph and Green both suggested this episode and wrote this paragraph. And Brianna Jones, it's your turn to read this paragraph. Are you ready?

[27:56] Brianna Jones: I am.

[27:57] Jesse McInally: Alright, it is on your screen whenever you're ready. And remember, he paid for us to say this. There's a star man, he plays in blue and white. His name's Yuri Tielemans, and he is Dynamite. Wilfred Nandidi, he'll take the ball off of you. And finally, ooh, Jamie Vardy. Ooh, Jamie Vardy.

[28:18] Andrew DeWolf: Alright. Great, great job. Rheon. Thank you, Joseph Evans Green for your money. I hope that was worth it. Andrew, who's supporting us over at Patreon?

[28:27] Andrew DeWolf: Our current patrons are Melissa Goldman, Terry Needleman, John Donna, Layton Ackles, Daniel Rennox, Justin Stampede, Ewan Cassidy, Tess Gear, Monica Thoreau, Mina Maniri, Brent Black, Lathaniel Stacy Coombe, Joseph Evans Green, Carrie Ahern, Mary Lou Choquette, John Van Ales, Russ Walker, Musical Hell, Emily Gracie, Kyle Summers, Janae C, Scoot in the Technical or Dreamcoat, Liz Lim, Alison Stoller, nothing is certain except Beth and Taxes, Thesbian, Ren Cullen, Ratha, Raphael Martinez Celeste, uh Robert Benjamin, Jessica T, Mitch Mitchell Young, Chai Teacup, Katie McDonough, Timothy Keyes, Chris Marquette, uh Timimu Robinson, Kiji Maria Anastasio, uh Leela, RJ Nariga, Sebastian Canino, Avan Reagan, Charlie B. Patrick Deering, Joe, Avery Brinson, Marilyn Brown, Mel Cormac, LaFemme Fictionnelle, Bjorn Hermans, August Gorman, Mac the Knife, Erica S. Tori Yana Vestel, Sammy the Most Lopez, Liana Morton, and Angela.

They give us a little extra financial support that helps us keep the lights on here at Musicals with Cheese. If you like to join them, and many others and get all those fun perks, come come join us over at the Patreon. Alright, let's get back to the show.

[29:45] Jesse McInally: Fuck, is there any songs worth talking about? Is there any song with the band job?

[29:50] Andrew DeWolf: No!

[29:51] Jesse McInally: No. The entire show's disappointing.

[29:56] Andrew DeWolf: Ugh. Well I'm looking at these song lists. I think the hello song is pretty okay.

[30:03] Jesse McInally: Hello again. Hello's it all. Good day to you. You keeping fit. So great to meet you. It's mean and age. A tiny well. How do you? How do you? How do you how do you? How do you do?

[30:17] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, that's it. The hello song. It's fine. Um It's funny that they all have to reintroduce ourselves and it keeps popping up, and every time it pops up, it kinda gives me a little bit of a dopamine rush.

[30:28] Jesse McInally: Yeah, it's like probably the best song in it.

[30:31] Andrew DeWolf: The let's see. Um, like surprisingly so. Like this is the one they named the show after, and it's like, wow, that's it. Hook by crook, by way by palm, by see by hell, by rope, by ground, by seven dwarves, by font to thieves, by George, by Joe, by Jeeves, by Shammer called Cock.

[30:58] Jesse McInally: 20 years on this Angel Lloyd Webber. What was it like? By Joe, by George, by something, by Jeeves, by Jeeves. It's like it's not good. They're trying to do the it was red and yellow and blue and orange thing from Joseph, but much worse.

[31:13] Andrew DeWolf: Well, yeah, I mean Joseph is already a perfect show, so I'm not really sure how you're trying to improve on that.

[31:18] Jesse McInally: Well, you know what? Joseph Evans Green has already you know what his next Patreon request is?

[31:23] Andrew DeWolf: What's that?

[31:24] Jesse McInally: Joseph, and he has to join us for the episode.

[31:26] Andrew DeWolf: Well, I can't wait. I remember when we watched it, it was just like uh it was a very long period of time of me just laughing.

[31:32] Jesse McInally: Yeah, it was. It was a joy. Um, man, I w I wish we could go back to just enjoying Angeloid Weber musicals.

[31:39] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it feels like we did all the good ones, and now it's just like oof.

[31:43] Jesse McInally: You mean all two of them?

[31:45] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Cause what do we got left? School of Rock the musical. Maybe that one's okay. I bet it'll be like Cinderella tier.

[31:52] Jesse McInally: Speaking of tears, Andrew, why don't we just go into your tier list of Andrew Lloyd Webber musicals and see if anything's changed.

[32:01] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, you don't want to talk about it's a pig or banjo boy?

[32:05] Jesse McInally: Well, you do want to talk about the ending really quick, don't you?

[32:08] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, the wizard rainbow banjo mix.

[32:12] Jesse McInally: The golden king and fashion can't destroy it. Stop it.

[32:29] Andrew DeWolf: Banjoo!

[32:38] Jesse McInally: Yeah, go ahead, Andrew. It's all yours. Balls in your court, bitch.

[32:42] Andrew DeWolf: Oh man, it it's just it's such a good ending. They get the banjo, and hit listen to this hilarious joke, okay? It's so funny. He plays the banjo and it doesn't make any sound. And Jeeves goes, Oh, that's because it's new string technology that only allows people far away from the banjo to hear it. And then he goes, Oh, that's crazy. Like, I totally a hundred percent believe that because I'm actually like the dumbest person alive. Like what And then the Wizard of Oz people come out. And then the Wizard of Oz people come out, and he's like, Oh, we just had these costumes, and they're just the Wizard of Oz people, and it's not really explained. They just are, and it's like, wow, that's not even a joke. There isn't a joke here. You're not, that's just a reference. Then the show is this. Am I watching the nostalgia critic? Like, what am I Oh look, you guys are in costumes, and I'm playing a banjo. Let's sing SpongeBob with Slipknot.

[33:45] Jesse McInally: Yeah, it's like, oh, I just did this whole episode on the wall. I guess let's end it with SpongeBob SquarePants. I want to dust Andrew Lloyd Webber, like nostalgia critic is doing better than you at this point.

[33:59] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, at least at least most of the songs in that were related to Sadwell giving Doug Walker more credit than Andrew Lloyd Webber.

[34:08] Jesse McInally: Yeah, and I feel like at the end though they also just kind of did some of the other songs, like again.

[34:14] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it's a mega mix, a banjo make a mix.

[34:17] Jesse McInally: Yeah, and it's just like why? Like, I I feel like I got the point, like, you know, when you did it. Not gonna lie, after the Wizard of Oz people came out, I kind of intentionally fell asleep and missed the Mega Mix.

[34:30] Andrew DeWolf: Do you have a pot podcast to record today? I'm done paying attention.

[34:33] Jesse McInally: Damn, I watched more of it than you did.

[34:38] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, probably. Do you have a least favorite song?

[34:42] Jesse McInally: Yeah, probably it's a pig.

[34:43] Andrew DeWolf: Listen, Beaver! Don't you try it? Try it to kiss me! I didn't die it! Oh, you swing your multiplicity! Praise your hands around! Stop shooting! The badly bruised libido and woos that change rabbito!

[34:56] Jesse McInally: It's not funny. Like, that's at all what the worst part of these are. Like, the songs aren't the worst thing I've ever heard. It's not like ear pain or anything like that.

[35:05] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, yeah, it's more that they're not funny. And it's like supposed to be funny, and it's not. And it's just so bland. Like, everything, at least as soon as it happens, it's like, okay, that was a nice distraction, and then you forget it. It's out of your head. Like, to be honest, I was actually like, you know, maybe maybe they'll get the banjo and we'll get to hear a song where they where he plays the banjo, and that'd be kind of fun. And then they just don't, and I'm like, and your excuse for not doing it is that the joke where he's so dumb that he can't figure out that Jeeves replaced the strings with something they can't make sound.

[35:44] Jesse McInally: Andrew, I can't wait until someone literally like only listens to this episode, decides, hey, that's my opinion. I formed my opinion on this entire nearly 200 episode podcast, and then writes a review saying, you guys just don't understand By Jeeves, and honestly, I find your opinion snobbish and terrible.

[36:03] Andrew DeWolf: Fair enough.

[36:04] Jesse McInally: Okay. I mean, if you love this show, um, go away.

[36:12] Andrew DeWolf: I I I is this anyone's favorite musical. I really sincerely hope not.

[36:18] Jesse McInally: Because I did a poll on Twitter a few days ago. Um, just because I was curious of like even with Cinderella, some people really do like Andrew Lloyd Webber's Cinderella. Right? I I mean, I guess. And I can understand at least why they might. It's not the worst thing ever. Though I may have said in the episode that it was. Okay, let me tell you some of the responses I got when I was like, hey, what's what do you feel about By Jeeves? Which I tend to do just to get like what a general folks feel about a musical we're talking about, so I'm not like shitting on someone's favorite show without listening.

[36:54] Jesse McInally: Um, someone said it came on during lockdown when Andrew Lloyd Webber started broadcasting his shows on YouTube, and it was the first one that none of my family could sit through.

[37:03] Andrew DeWolf: I swear we got about 20 minutes in and gave up out of utter boredom.

[37:08] Jesse McInally: Yeah. I mean, if I can give it any credit, and I'm not gonna give it very much, it is cheesy, just not in a good way.

[37:16] Andrew DeWolf: I think that the joke of like a very slapped together amateurish play could be funny, but I don't think it's done well here.

[37:25] Jesse McInally: Okay, here's one more note from someone who responded to it, and this is from @CrunchingNoise. They said, "When my dad saw that on Broadway, a stranger came up to him at intermission and said, 'I hope the second act's better than the first.'"

[37:41] Andrew DeWolf: And that it's not.

[37:43] Jesse McInally: No.

[37:44] Andrew DeWolf: That's the worst part. It's not.

[37:47] Jesse McInally: Like, and then there's just so much better versions of it, like Gentleman's Guide to Love and Murder. Like, that is like a show similar in vibe and tone to this, that just does it so much better.

[37:58] Andrew DeWolf: Well, yeah, I think the issue isn't in tone or anything like that. And honestly, even the music is mostly passable.

[38:06] Jesse McInally: Yeah. Like the tone is good. I like the tone, like it's like very doesn't take itself seriously, goofy, like fun. But then the just all the jokes just fall completely flat.

[38:16] Andrew DeWolf: It's just like somehow it manages to not ever be funny. You know?

[38:22] Jesse McInally: I can't wait for people to use this against us and be like, "That's how I feel listening to your podcast. You just shit on my favorite musical, and somehow you guys are never funny or just mean."

[38:30] Andrew DeWolf: Then why are you listening to us? Just go away.

[38:32] Jesse McInally: If you feel about our show the way that I feel about By Jeeves, then yeah, you should not turn it off.

[38:37] Andrew DeWolf: Turn it off.

[38:40] Jesse McInally: No one should feel that way about anything they engage in. I would never willingly watch By Jeeves again.

[38:44] Andrew DeWolf: No. There's other Andrew Lloyd Webber musicals I really don't like that I would watch before I'd ever watch By Jeeves again.

[38:53] Jesse McInally: I'd watch Love Never Dies before watching By Jeeves again.

[38:56] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like Love Never Dies has like some unintentionally funny moments.

[39:01] Jesse McInally: Yeah, whereas this is the worst thing you can be is a bad comedy because there's just nothing. You can't even like make fun of how inept the comedy is.

[39:15] Jesse McInally: So let's look at your Andrew Lloyd Webber tier list. It is at the bottom of the document, Andrew, and why don't you just read out where everything fell from the last time we did Andrew Lloyd Webber, which I believe was Cinderella a few months ago.

[39:26] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, yeah. So in A tier, which this is um, it's on a curve. It's on a, it's on a curve, I guess, but A tier is the top. So there is no, like some tier lists do S tier. There's no S, there's no nothing above A.

[39:39] Jesse McInally: A is the top. And you've also said that this is on a curve because your Andrew or your Sondheim A list would have been like S list for this one. Like everything would be dropped down if you were on the same level.

[39:50] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, because I don't think any of Webber's are quite as good as the best of Sondheim.

[39:56] Jesse McInally: Nope. But okay, so this is A tier. We have Evita, uh, Joseph, and uh, Jesus Christ Superstar, which I still stand by. I think all three of those.

[40:05] Andrew DeWolf: These are not ordered, by the way. This is just, this is the top.

[40:08] Jesse McInally: Yeah. Um, B is uh, Sunset Boulevard and Phantom. Uh, C is Cats and Cinderella, and D is uh, Starlight Express and Love Never Dies.

[40:20] Andrew DeWolf: So where does By Jeeves fit in this ranking list, Andrew?

[40:25] Andrew DeWolf: I gotta be honest, I think it has to go in C tier.

[40:28] Jesse McInally: Oh really? That is the most shocking. I am shooketh.

[40:33] Andrew DeWolf: There's like passable music, and like I laughed like twice. And like Love Never Dies is like offensive to me.

[40:44] Jesse McInally: And Starlight Express is just the worst thing ever.

[40:49] Andrew DeWolf: Another Joseph Evans Green uh request, dare I remind you. Yeah, Starlight Express is just like so abysmally awful that I can't like, I can't even express it.

[41:00] Jesse McInally: Um, I feel like this, if I was to compare this to anything else, it probably would be something like Cinderella. Um, but I do, I'm torn because I do want to put it in D tier because it has the crime of making me extremely confused at who is who, which I absolutely hate when that happens.

[41:18] Andrew DeWolf: And it's also not funny. Like, even Cinderella got a cute few chuckles out of you.

[41:23] Jesse McInally: Yeah, I think I think really what it is is the hello song and the American character that's obsessed with jelly is kind of keeping it out of D tier for me.

[41:33] Andrew DeWolf: I think that those two, I don't know. Um, I would make a new tier for D Plus, but I'm not going to.

[41:39] Jesse McInally: That's Disney Plus, so you can't do that.

[41:48] Andrew DeWolf: By Jeeves is going into um, oh my goodness, what am I typing? By Jeeves is going into C tier.

[41:51] Jesse McInally: Alright. That's uh, that's the saddest information. Because honestly, this is probably one of the worst things we've covered on the show, for me at least.

[41:59] Andrew DeWolf: I don't blame you, but I honestly, I don't know. Starlight Express? Do you remember sitting through that?

[42:06] Jesse McInally: I do. I sat through it multiple times, Andrew.

[42:09] Andrew DeWolf: I don't remember sitting through that. I remember By Jeeves.

[42:12] Jesse McInally: I think I'll be able to remember By Jeeves in like a month. We can't even talk about what the plot is in a cohesive way. Starlight Express, it's like, oh yeah, there's trains racing.

[42:20] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like that's the worst part, though. Like, do you remember Starlight Express? They just did the train race like five times?

[42:26] Jesse McInally: Yes.

[42:26] Andrew DeWolf: Like, that's so bad. At least they had a stage gimmick. This has nothing.

[42:31] Jesse McInally: This has a stage gimmick.

[42:34] Andrew DeWolf: Don't say the banjo.

[42:36] Jesse McInally: It's the whole, like, everyone is pretending like everyone is supposed to be part of this banjo concert, but now they're part of, that's the gimmick.

[42:44] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know. If there's any one positive thing I can say about this show, and literally there is just one positive thing, it's that Donna Lynn Champlin is in it, and I love her. And she is very, very good.

[42:57] Jesse McInally: She is an American that does a great British accent. I love her and everything. She's great in Crazy Ex-Girlfriend.

[43:03] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, hang on. Let me express my thoughts a little better, I think.

[43:07] Jesse McInally: Okay.

[43:08] Andrew DeWolf: Starlight Express made me feel like depressed and like dead inside. And Love Never Dies makes me feel exactly the same way. By Jeeves, I think the tone alone allows it to be higher for me.

[43:22] Jesse McInally: I understand that at least. That makes, that's a good defense where with those ones, the tone alone saved that for me because at least it's a weird thing where if it's a comedy and it's not funny, it makes me more angry, but if they're drama that isn't funny but is boring at worst, I am more tolerable of it.

[43:41] Andrew DeWolf: See, no, but this, this is cheesy. Like the only thing this has going for it is it's cheesy. Whereas Starlight Express is like, it should be cheesy, but it's like completely lacking in the cheese department. Like it's just, there is no cheese.

[43:55] Brianna Jones: Bree, whose side do you think you love everything be on?

[43:59] Brianna Jones: Um, you know, I was, we're arguing whether or not this should be in the bottom tier or in the trash tier.

[44:05] Jesse McInally: So, well, so it's funny that you guys say that because I was looking at Andrew Lloyd Webber's, all his musicals ranked. Um, and so this list I was looking at, um, one to eighteen, By Jeeves was ranked number seven.

[44:22] Andrew DeWolf: Right in the middle.

[44:23] Brianna Jones: What's the right in the middle?

[44:26] Andrew DeWolf: So that, I mean, that's about a C.

[44:29] Brianna Jones: What is the lowest one though?

[44:31] Andrew DeWolf: Woman in White?

[44:32] Brianna Jones: Uh, Starlight Express.

[44:35] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. See, I agree with that. Like a hundred percent. I think Starlight Express is probably the worst thing that I've watched that it wasn't, we will rock you.

[44:44] Brianna Jones: Yeah, um, what did you say though? The, uh, the Woman in White was number ten?

[44:51] Andrew DeWolf: Jeez, that I haven't seen it, so Jess always talks about it like it's the worst thing he's done, but it's number two. It's just a ridiculous failure.

[45:00] Brianna Jones: Where's Aspects of Love on it?

[45:04] Andrew DeWolf: Number eight.

[45:05] Brianna Jones: And School of Rock is nine.

[45:08] Andrew DeWolf: Oh no.

[45:13] Brianna Jones: No, no, no, no, no. That's so bad.

[45:17] Andrew DeWolf: You know what? I think it's time for us to do something else. We're a little short of an episode here. Um, I don't quite want to end it yet, so how about we play a Buzzfeed quiz?

[45:28] Jesse McInally: Um, just so we can say we've done something with our lives today.

[45:31] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. So we're gonna take a BuzzFeed quiz just to end this episode. And the quiz is what Andrew Lloyd Webber musical are you? And this is gonna be answered collectively. We're not each gonna take one, so we're all gonna vote on an answer.

[45:43] Brianna Jones: Okay.

[45:44] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like we should always alternate.

[45:46] Jesse McInally: Okay.

[45:47] Andrew DeWolf: Are we like alternating the answers or that would be fun?

[45:49] Jesse McInally: Alright, I'll go first. So um, cheers to the freaking weekend. We can find you. A, throwing the most epic party yet, studying for that big presentation, or memorizing lines. It's hard to say. Your plans tend to change.

[46:05] Andrew DeWolf: Well, I think I'd probably be studying for that big presentation and memorizing lines.

[46:10] Jesse McInally: Alright, what's the next one?

[46:11] Brianna Jones: Alright, Bree, what's this next one?

[46:15] Brianna Jones: Right now, you would say your greatest goal is living with passion, achieving your dream job, never letting others determine who you are, finding your one true soulmate, making a difference in the world.

[46:29] Andrew DeWolf: Well, what do you got?

[46:32] Brianna Jones: Um, right now I'm living with passion.

[46:36] Andrew DeWolf: Hell yeah.

[46:37] Brianna Jones: Alright, Andrew, what's the next one?

[46:40] Andrew DeWolf: Alright. Choose your dream home. It's a, there's four images of houses. There's like an old castle one, there's like a rustic little tiny village one, minimalist, Tony Stark's house, and then a fucking shitty apartment. I'm gonna say the little cottage, I think. I would choose that one. The other two are too extravagant, and honestly, I don't think I want to live in an apartment building, so yeah.

[47:08] Brianna Jones: Alright.

[47:09] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, my question is you resonate most with these lyrics. I remember the time I knew what happiness was. Let the memory live again. Keep on rocking. Each note, grab it by the throat. Keep the rhythm afloat. Don't forget to emote. We are still waiting, still hesitating. Any dream will do. Couldn't stay all my life down at heel, looking out of the window, staying out of the sun. All I want is freedom. A world with no more night. And you always beside me.

[47:33] Jesse McInally: Okay, this is actually rough. Which one do you think I should do? That's my two closest confidants.

[47:40] Brianna Jones: I would pick the bottom one, personally.

[47:44] Andrew DeWolf: Honestly, I think I'm the Evita quote, to be honest.

[47:47] Jesse McInally: Yeah, that's it. I don't want to be trapped inside forever.

[47:51] Brianna Jones: Um, alright. Bree, are you a leader or a follower?

[47:55] Brianna Jones: Um, so I'm either a faithful follower, a leader through and through, you're more of a lone wolf.

[48:02] Brianna Jones: I am a leader through and through.

[48:04] Andrew DeWolf: Hell yeah. A beta, an alpha, or a sigma.

[48:09] Andrew DeWolf: What's next?

[48:11] Andrew DeWolf: Your reaction when someone wrongs you. Let's see. I can talk it out with a group of friends. Uh, express my anger through art or music. Move past it. You have better things to do than be mad. Forgive the person almost immediately. Hold a long-term grudge.

[48:30] Brianna Jones: Um, honestly, probably the third one. Move past it.

[48:33] Andrew DeWolf: Alright.

[48:34] Brianna Jones: That's the fourth one. Not forgive immediately.

[48:38] Andrew DeWolf: I don't forgive immediately. But alright.

[48:41] Brianna Jones: Choose a style of music. Rock opera, traditionally Broadway tune style, hymns, music specific to a culture, calypso country, etc.

[48:50] Andrew DeWolf: Rock and roll. Shit. Probably rock opera.

[48:55] Brianna Jones: Alright, Bree.

[48:57] Brianna Jones: Money is low, and you find cash on the street. What do you do?

[49:00] Brianna Jones: Hell, I keep it, but what are the, what is my option? It depends on your mood. Take it without a thought.

[49:07] Andrew DeWolf: You have to do what's best for you. Look for its owner. They must be nearby. You take it, but then you put it back in case the owner comes back.

[49:15] Jesse McInally: No, I'm taking it. If no one is around, but if someone's around, I'm gonna look for them. But if no one's around.

[49:22] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I'm gonna look for them and make sure they don't see me today.

[49:25] Jesse McInally: Exactly, Andrew. Times are tough out here.

[49:29] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, Andrew. You can spend one day in a different decade. Which do you choose?

[49:34] Jesse McInally: Okay. Damn, that's uh not many choices. 1980s or 1970s. Or right now.

[49:42] Andrew DeWolf: Um, well, I mean, I guess I'd rather live right now, because race everyone's a little better. Everyone I know lives right now, too. I feel like I'd be kind of lonely in the 70s or 80s.

[49:55] Jesse McInally: Yeah. On a scale of one to ten, how dramatic am I?

[49:59] Andrew DeWolf: Um I like how they don't even give me like a four. I have an eight will do, a solid three, five, ten all the way. Fuck, what do you guys think?

[50:08] Brianna Jones: You?

[50:09] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[50:10] Brianna Jones: I'd give you a few. I'd say you're five. You're a five or an eight.

[50:12] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, that's kind of where I'm sitting. Oh, I think that's the last question then.

[50:16] Jesse McInally: We're a Vita.

[50:17] Brianna Jones: Oh, good. I get to be a fascist.

[50:20] Jesse McInally: Yeah, we're fascist, guys. We did it. We did it. Avita was number one on that list.

[50:27] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, Avita is Andrew Lloyd Webber's best musical, so I guess that makes sense why I was number one on that list.

[50:33] Jesse McInally: Yeah, it's a good show.

[50:35] Andrew DeWolf: It's a good show. Um I recently found a clip of Patty Lapone talking about it where she's like, Madonna cannot act her way out of a paper bag. She is shit. She cannot sing. I hated it.

[50:49] Brianna Jones: And I thought Madonna was fine. Um, but guys, what is our overall thoughts on Buy Jeeves and our cheese rating? Um Andrew, do you want to start us off?

[50:59] Andrew DeWolf: Um yeah, sure. Um I guess uh I'm gonna say I I didn't like it, mostly because it wasn't funny and uh it failed to supply any banjo, which I mean those are two of the greatest crimes that a musical can commit, to be honest. Um the music was like fine, I guess. I don't don't watch it. It's just not good. It's just it's not worth your time. It really just isn't. Um as far as cheese. I mean, if I can give this thing any compliments, it is it is that it's cheesy. Um it just fails to actually supply any entertainment. Um so I'm gonna give it uh I'm gonna give it um, let's see, stilton cheese, which is uh a British cheese, and it sounds stilted like the comedy in this show.

[51:47] Jesse McInally: Yeah.

[51:48] Brianna Jones: Alright, Bree, what do you think?

[51:51] Brianna Jones: I don't want to watch Buy Jeeves. Um I was already confused when you guys were trying to explain it to me, so I don't think uh I would have Imagine what?

[51:59] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, yeah.

[52:00] Brianna Jones: I don't think I could probably watch it. Um but this this episode was fun. We had fun. I had fun playing the BuzzFeed quiz. I had fun looking at that um tier list and Andrew's tier list. Um, but since I never want to watch Buy Jeeves, I'm gonna give it a moldy goat cheese. Because I already don't like goat cheese, and so I think if you make it moldy, you know, it's just really like no.

[52:26] Andrew DeWolf: That's fair. Um hold on, guys. I I I know with my cheese ratings, I tend to give you whack as fuck facts about it too. Um so my my my my my cheese rating is pig's milk cheese, which is a thing done by um the blue Pig Company. Um so I don't know if you know this, but pigs are notoriously difficult to milk. Um let me read you some of this. Um They're a nightmare to milk with the female sows not liking human contact and having eight to fourteen small teats to milk, which in turn only gives them a little amount of milk for fifteen seconds at a time. Um however, they do create a cheese that is higher in fat than cow's milk and provides interesting flavors, which is perfect to make cheese.

[53:14] Brianna Jones: Um so if you So basically you're saying that your your cheese rating is that they had to torture a pig to get this show.

[53:21] Andrew DeWolf: Yep. Yep. And because he dresses as a pig and everyone sings about a pig and I want to fucking die.

[53:29] Jesse McInally: They all think that he's really a pig, it seems like it doesn't make sense.

[53:33] Brianna Jones: Well, this the costume was really, really effective. I mean It was so yeah, real.

[53:38] Andrew DeWolf: Fuck by cheese. Um, you know who definitely doesn't like Buy Jeeves, our patrons. Thank you guys for listening. Please follow us on iTunes Spotify Stitcher and Musicals with Cheese. We're on Patreon at Musicals with Cheese. So if you want to recommend us some better shows, or at least something that we'll have some fun things to say, uh come join us over at Patreon, please. Recommend better shows. Recommend more interesting shows, please.

[54:04] Brianna Jones: Um We're on Instagram, YouTube, and all that at Musicals with Cheese. We have a patron only podcast called Patreon with Cheese where we're covering TV shows. Or we're talking about Encore on there. It's a lot of fun. Um, me and Andrew also do commentaries on there. It's that's great too. Email us at musical theater lives at gmail.com. Our title card is created by the amazing Jolene Casco. Go follow them on Instagram at Jolene Casco. Our keeper of the cheese is Juliet Antonio. Thank you, Juliet. Um, this show is produced by the wonderful, the incredible, one of my favorite people on the entire planet, Brianna Jones. Our theme songs were created by Robin Nash of IOU Music UK. Thank you to the Broadway Podcast Network for having us on the platform and for not kicking us off for talking about by Jeeves, because god damn it, there are so many better musicals we could be talking about.

[54:52] Andrew DeWolf: Like I'm just imagining like our download numbers like crashing into the ground, and they're like, oh, by Jeeves? Really? You did the producers last week, and that was so much fun. And by Jeeves, really?

[55:03] Jesse McInally: Um Indeed, sir. It's number nine or whatever, eight on the seven as the best Android Weber shows.

[55:12] Andrew DeWolf: That I feel like that's very strange, like strangely high on the list.

[55:17] Jesse McInally: I clapped because it was different.

[55:19] Andrew DeWolf: Very cool.

[55:20] Jesse McInally: Very cool. Alright, anything else we have left to say?

[55:25] Brianna Jones: Um, what if this was Joseph Evans Green's um favorite musical and you guys just shit on it?

[55:31] Andrew DeWolf: Well, good for them. We have your money either way. Come on, it's definitely not. There is no way. This is no one's favorite show. I'm sorry.

[55:39] Jesse McInally: It might even be like, oh, I kinda like it. You're like, oh, it's just kind of my thing. No one's favorite show. Nobody is like out here like, yeah, that's the one. By Jeeves Revival.

[55:48] Brianna Jones: Yeah, when's the by Jeeves revival? This time they actually use the banjo. Steve Martin plays G or by plays Wooster.

[56:00] Andrew DeWolf: It's sad that Steve Martin could have made this show better. Have you guys uh watched the Beautiful Game?

[56:02] Brianna Jones: What?

[56:02] Andrew DeWolf: The Beautiful Game?

[56:07] Brianna Jones: That's number sixteen on this list.

[56:09] Andrew DeWolf: I yeah, I've never even heard of that. Someone will probably request it on Patreon. I'll be like, God damn it. Andrew Lloyd Webber has two good shows and he's just famous for it, isn't he?

[56:19] Jesse McInally: Yeah. Yeah, he has two sh two and a half. I'll give Phantom the half.

[56:26] Andrew DeWolf: Phantom is the half. Okay. What would be the other half? Do you have another one?

[56:29] Jesse McInally: Sunset, maybe?

[56:31] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, I think if we're being like stretching the term good a bit, we could say like Sunset, Phantom, Evita, Super Jesus Christ, Superstar, and maybe Joseph is in there as like a as like a meme.

[56:46] Brianna Jones: I really can't wait for you to rewatch Joseph on your own this time and be like, man, just didn't do it for Oh, I still listen to the soundtrack.

[56:54] Andrew DeWolf: You really do?

[56:55] Brianna Jones: Yeah, it's hilarious.

[56:57] Andrew DeWolf: It's so funny. There's one more Angel in heaven. One more T. The go-go song. The go-go song gets me.

[57:05] Brianna Jones: Every time.

[57:07] Andrew DeWolf: Every time. Love it. I can't understand it. And that song follows him like being like, yo, Mr. Baker, you're you're gonna your execution date's set. Go, go, go, Joseph! It's it's so It's so bad that I I just I I can't not love it.

[57:26] Brianna Jones: It's just Bree. We might have to do a Patreon episode of just you and me talking about Joseph.

[57:31] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. Where's Joseph on that list?

[57:37] Brianna Jones: How are these people ranking?

[57:38] Andrew DeWolf: So is by G's Joseph is number four on both of these lists.

[57:42] Brianna Jones: You're kidding, right?

[57:44] Andrew DeWolf: So is there is there like a bunch of like absolute trash tier like Lloyd Weber shows that we didn't don't even know about?

[57:51] Jesse McInally: Yeah. Maybe. Okay, so um bottom up, Bree. Let's do it from the bottom.

[57:55] Brianna Jones: One says disqualified on this list, so Cricket.

[58:00] Andrew DeWolf: Why is it disqualified?

[58:01] Brianna Jones: Um was never recorded. And most of its songs were used later. Like Andrew Lloyd Weber wants to do. Um The Wizard of Oz was disqualified.

[58:15] Andrew DeWolf: Because he only wrote like three songs for it, and then called it Andrew Lloyd Webber's Wizard of Oz, and just had all the original movie songs, and then two songs he wrote.

[58:24] Brianna Jones: Okay, so number 17 on this list is Love Never Dies.

[58:28] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. Okay. Technicality, I get it, but fuck you.

[58:32] Brianna Jones: Um The Woman in White.

[58:35] Andrew DeWolf: Hey, at least that one gets like the reputation I think it deserves.

[58:39] Brianna Jones: Uh number 15 is um Steven Ward. That was like a big passion project for him for a while.

[58:44] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, what else?

[58:47] Brianna Jones: 14 is Aspects of Love. That one was a big flop.

[58:51] Andrew DeWolf: Starlight Express getting up there, huh?

[58:54] Brianna Jones: Number 13 um is uh The likes of us.

[58:59] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, that one's bad.

[59:00] Brianna Jones: Number 12 is Whistle Down the Wind.

[59:04] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, I forgot that one existed. Starlight Express still not on the street.

[59:08] Brianna Jones: Number 11 is Starlight Express.

[59:11] Andrew DeWolf: Oh my god, number 11. By jeez hasn't even come up yet.

[59:15] Brianna Jones: Alright, what's number 10?

[59:17] Andrew DeWolf: The beautiful game.

[59:19] Brianna Jones: Never heard of it.

[59:20] Andrew DeWolf: Rewritten as The Boys in the Photograph.

[59:24] Brianna Jones: Still don't know it.

[59:25] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. Didn't help at all. Um number nine is Tell Me on a Sunday.

[59:32] Brianna Jones: Yeah, no that one.

[59:33] Andrew DeWolf: Number eight is School of Rock.

[59:35] Brianna Jones: Number seven by Jeeves.

[59:37] Andrew DeWolf: Number seven is Cats.

[59:39] Brianna Jones: Cats is worse than by Jeeves.

[59:41] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like I'd still rather watch cats.

[59:43] Brianna Jones: Yeah, I think I would as well. The dancing is at least interesting.

[59:46] Andrew DeWolf: Number six is by Jeeves. Uh number five is Sunset Boulevard. Number four is Joseph. Umber three is Phantom of the Opera. And then Jesus Christ Superstar, and number one, Aveda.

[1:00:00] Brianna Jones: I get it. That's a fair list when you get to like the halfway point.

[1:00:07] Andrew DeWolf: Uh you know what? We'll see you next time. We're gonna have to cover all of those someday. Get on Patreon. Force us to do it at gunpoint.

[1:00:19] Brianna Jones: That was an old list, too. They didn't even have Cinderella, did they?

[1:00:22] Andrew DeWolf: No, Cinderella wasn't on there.

[1:00:23] Brianna Jones: No, the Cinderella wasn't on either of them.

[1:00:25] Andrew DeWolf: So one the one I just was just did was from 2015, and the one from before was from 2020. I feel like Cinderella would probably be around like school of rock.

[1:00:37] Brianna Jones: I think it would be above by Jeeves.

[1:00:39] Andrew DeWolf: I think so. Maybe. I think it would be. I people Cinderella got really good reviews. I think that's something we often forget, but it got really good reviews. Well, we're done here. We'll see you next time on musical.

[1:00:53] Jesse McInally: So it's Jeeves.

[1:00:59] Brianna Jones: Bye-bye.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred