Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#182 - Daddy Long Legs (feat. Sammi Lopez)

"I've discovered The secret of happiness is Learning how to glide..." Grab your pens and envelopes because this week we're joined by High Tier Patron Sammi Lopez to talk about the Musical "Daddy Long Legs" We talk about the show, its adaptation, its impact, and whether its creepy... Read More

From the show: Musicals with Cheese

1 h 9 mins
3/3/22

About

"I've discovered The secret of happiness is Learning how to glide..." Grab your pens and envelopes because this week we're joined by High Tier Patron Sammi Lopez to talk about the Musical "Daddy Long Legs" We talk about the show, its adaptation, its impact, and whether its creepy.

Donate to Black Lives Matter here

Social Media:

Our WEBSITE

Musicals with Cheese on Twitter

Musicals W/ Cheese on Instagram

Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com

Merch!!

Jess Socials

Jess on Twitter

Jess on Instagram

Andrew Socials

Andrew on Instagram

Andrew on Twitter

Brianna Socials

Brianna on Twitter

Brianna on Instagram

Use our Affiliate Link

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:07] Jess McEnally: Hello, I'm Jess McEnally.

[0:09] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm Andrew DeWolf.

[0:10] Brianna Jones: And I'm Brianna Jones.

[0:12] Jess McEnally: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, a podcast where I try to get Andrew and Brianna to like musical theater.

[0:16] Jess McEnally: And you guys, we have an extra super special guest.

[0:19] Jess McEnally: You know why? Because it's one of the superest guests because they paid to be here.

[0:23] Jess McEnally: Please paid to be here.

[0:24] Jess McEnally: They paid to be here.

[0:25] Jess McEnally: They were like the sound of that. One of our highest tier patrons for two months, which means they get to come on the show for an episode. Join me in welcoming musical teacher, fan, and all-around cool person, and Daddy Long Legs super fan, Sammi Lopez!

[0:44] Sammi Lopez: Thank you, thank you. How are you doing, Sammi?

[0:47] Sammi Lopez: Oh, I'm pretty great. I'm pretty great. How are you all doing?

[0:50] Jess McEnally: I'm feeling good. Are you feeling buyer's remorse at the moment yet?

[0:54] Sammi Lopez: Oh, this is everything you paid for. I think this is gonna be like the highlight of my entire life right here.

[1:00] Jess McEnally: Oh, don't say that. That's a lot of pressure to put on us early on.

[1:05] Sammi Lopez: Oh boy. But I do want to talk about something a little serious, and I actually need some advice. Um, so some impartial people right here. So I've been sponsoring this orphan to go to school, and I think I'm falling in love with them over their letters.

[1:20] Sammi Lopez: I haven't spoken to them. They just keep writing me letters, and I'm just kind of, you know, building it up in my head, and I think I might start grooming them. What do you guys think?

[1:28] Jess McEnally: Sammi, I have a suggestion. Have you tried meeting with them in person, but not saying that it's you?

[1:33] Sammi Lopez: Oh, I'm gonna write that down. Write that down.

[1:36] Jess McEnally: Do it for a couple years as well, and then you can reveal later on, and they'll love that.

[1:42] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, yeah, yeah. And also the best part is I have control over their life and all their funds and anything. So if they want to do something, I can just veto it.

[1:51] Sammi Lopez: That's a good position to be in, honestly.

[1:53] Andrew DeWolf: Really? It helps with the process.

[1:57] Jess McEnally: It's a very Patrick Bateman situation. But as per request from Sammi Lopez, this week we're covering Daddy Long Legs. Cue the music, Brie.

[2:07] ♪ Musical number ♪

[2:30] Jess McEnally: I guess I'll never know him.

[2:35] Jess McEnally: Daddy Long Legs, it's a musical with a book by John Caird and music and lyrics by Paul Gordon. The musical opened off-Broadway at the Davenport Theater on September 28th, 2015, at an open-ended run. On November 29th, it was announced that the production would be streamed live online December 10th, 2015, becoming the first Broadway or off-Broadway production to do so in the history of the form.

[2:57] Jess McEnally: So this is like a groundbreaking musical in the idea. First live stream musical ever. According to provided statistics, the live stream was watched by 150,000 people from over 135 countries. The Off-Broadway production celebrated its 200th performance on March 22nd, 2016. The production played its final performance June 6, 2016. So this is like Paul Gordon's first big hit since ever. This is like one of his biggest hits he's ever done.

[3:24] Jess McEnally: The plot of Daddy Long Legs tells the tale of Jerusha Abbott, the oldest orphan of the John Greer home. One day, a rich anonymous benefactor decides to send her to college, but she must write him a letter once a month. Unaware of his identity, she invents a nickname for him, Daddy Long Legs. Through her letters, Jerusha shares her experiences of college while discovering her own identity and reveling in the wonders of literature, adventure, and love. But one key fact eludes her. Who is Daddy Long Legs?

[3:56] Jess McEnally: So, Sammi, this was your big Patreon request. Like, you could have picked any musical in the world, we'd have to do it. Why this one?

[4:01] Sammi Lopez: Um, well, I was actually kind of trying to decide between like a couple different ones. Um, there was one, like I thought it might be different to talk about, you know, I was flip-flopping between like there's a musical that I don't like, and maybe I can just come on and rant about how I don't like it for, you know, a couple hours with you guys.

[4:22] Sammi Lopez: Uh, always fun. I've been in one of them, it's pretty fun.

[4:27] Jess McEnally: Yeah, yeah.

[4:29] Sammi Lopez: I was like, you know what? I'll do one that I love. I, you know. Um, so I mean it was hard to pick, especially since I tend to be an indecisive person in general. Uh, so I just had to lock it down. And every time I watch Daddy Long Legs, I just get this huge smile on my face.

[4:49] Andrew DeWolf: I understand that. When I talked to Paul Gordon a few years ago, um, in a very what became a very awkward situation, um, I told him it's like ice cream the musical, because it just does feel like very sweet and consistently good. Um, but Andrew, as always, this is your first time watching Daddy Long Legs. Any initial thoughts?

[5:11] Andrew DeWolf: Um, it was not what I was expecting, but actually I quite liked it. Um, I mean there's only two characters, which is already just a massive plus. I could follow it all the way. I mean, the last time there was, you couldn't follow it. It was The Last Five Years.

[5:26] Jess McEnally: No, no, no, The Last Five Years has time travel, so we're not gonna go there.

[5:31] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, this had no time travel. Um, it was just straightforward two characters. I really like the storytelling device of everything is told as a letter, at least until the end. Um, that was really cool. Uh, yeah, it's just it is very sweet. Um, and the emotional beats really hit. So good stuff.

[5:54] Jess McEnally: Yes, yes. And of course the live stream, the record-breaking live stream, the first live stream ever. Um, and then She Loves Me with Soup in a few months later and do their live stream, being like, oh, we'll be the first Broadway ones. We're better.

[6:08] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, I won't say anything like that.

[6:11] Jess McEnally: But I have really, really liked the show for a while and its effectiveness. But hearing about it, I doubt anyone's read the book. Like, right, the actual proper books that they say.

[6:22] Sammi Lopez: I read it after seeing the musical.

[6:25] Jess McEnally: Isn't it weird that we don't know Jervis is who he is until the end, where it kind of becomes like a mystery. Who is Daddy?

[6:33] Sammi Lopez: Yeah, um, yeah, that is interesting. Well, I guess because of the fact that the book is all completely told from Jerusha's perspective.

[6:45] Sammi Lopez: Um, and so you don't get any of Daddy Long Legs' or Jervis's input in the book itself. So, um, because the way the musical is, you know, with it being a two-person musical, they put some of his stuff in there at some point.

[7:01] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[7:02] Sammi Lopez: Well, that's the only full creation of this musical. Like they stay fairly accurate to what Jerusha learns, how her life develops. The daddy, uh, Jervis Pendleton, um, everything that he says and experiences is written by John Caird and Paul Gordon for this musical.

[7:19] Sammi Lopez: And I think that's also very effective. It's just as good as Jerusha's stuff. And I wonder if I like Jerusha as much of a character if she wasn't played by Meghan McGuinness.

[7:30] Jess McEnally: A lot of what I love about that character is her performance.

[7:34] Sammi Lopez: Oh, absolutely. I totally agree. She nailed it.

[7:36] Sammi Lopez: She is the only person to perform that role. Um, I think I was looking on the Wikipedia or something and I think in all the English language productions, yeah, she was. From inception to that final off-Broadway performance.

[7:51] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[7:52] Sammi Lopez: Yeah, she developed that role with the composers, and it shows. She is so flippin' good. So everything that could have been like really two-dimensional, she really makes kind of work. She could have played it a little too doe-eyed, a little too like, oh, I don't know what's going on. But she has this wisdom to her, even when she was a little bit more ignorant at the start.

[8:14] Sammi Lopez: And it becomes a sad ignorance instead of like a point your finger and laugh ignorance. Um, I do want to say we're gonna have to talk about our good friend Paul Alexander Nolan.

[8:29] Jess McEnally: Um, I don't know if you remember Andrew, but we've brought him up quite a bit, and every time it's really sad.

[8:36] Andrew DeWolf: It's really sad what he's involved in.

[8:39] Sammi Lopez: So, Paul Alexander Nolan. Um, I first heard of him when he did the Jesus Christ Superstar revival in 2012. Um, that was not a very well-reviewed revival, um, unfairly, because Josh Young is incredible in it.

[8:51] Sammi Lopez: Um, and then he did Bright Star, which we also covered.

[8:55] Andrew DeWolf: He was the lead in Bright Star.

[8:56] Sammi Lopez: Bright Star.

[8:57] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, yes.

[8:58] Sammi Lopez: Oh, that's right. And Escape from Margaritaville. Some really good classics here, really hitting all the marks.

[9:06] Sammi Lopez: Um, but he was Jervis in this until he left to go do Bright Star. And then Meghan McGuinness' husband steps into the role, and that is what was there for the recording, the video recording.

[9:19] Andrew DeWolf: And their chemistry, despite not really having a scene together until the end, really, really works. You can feel that there's like a love between them, and that kind of removes a lot of what could feel predatory about this behavior.

[9:31] Jess McEnally: I don't know, like Paul Alexander Nolan kind of has a sinister face. Like he'd play a great villain.

[9:38] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, this is a story you could very easily twist into like something really dark and creepy.

[9:45] Jess McEnally: And I'm glad it never did that. Um, but yeah, it definitely takes some tact to not make the Jervis Pendleton character not feel a little bit like groomy.

[9:59] Sammi Lopez: Yes.

[10:00] Jess McEnally: Um, Sammi, have you seen the Fred Astaire movie that was adapted from the same book?

[10:04] Sammi Lopez: I have not.

[10:06] Jess McEnally: Um, because I was gonna ask about that because I haven't, but um, it takes place entirely from Jervis's point of view, and it gives a lot of excuses for um him to do tap dance numbers and to be a pedophile.

[10:20] Sammi Lopez: He is basically an outright pedophile.

[10:22] Jess McEnally: Because when you see her grow up, it registers in your head a bit more than the theatrical having a full-grown adult play a younger person.

[10:33] Sammi Lopez: So a lot of those theatrical tricks fool your brain, like, this isn't as bad as I thought it was.

[10:38] Jess McEnally: So they took a book that was written entirely from the woman's perspective, yes, and made a movie that was entirely from the man's perspective.

[10:48] Sammi Lopez: Wow.

[10:50] Jess McEnally: That is bold.

[10:51] Sammi Lopez: They really went for it.

[10:53] Jess McEnally: That's a word for it, for sure. There are some choices.

[11:04] Sammi Lopez: And Paul Gordon, who writes women very well. What is your relationship to Paul Gordon's other musicals, Sammi?

[11:10] Sammi Lopez: Um, I actually have not gotten the chance to see any of the others.

[11:14] Sammi Lopez: Um, I know he's the one with the streaming musicals website, right?

[11:18] Jess McEnally: Yes, he's been I've been meaning to check that out, and I just haven't really sat down and done it yet.

[11:25] Sammi Lopez: Um, but I would really like to see what he has up there.

[11:29] Sammi Lopez: I think that Paul Gordon is genuinely a good empathetic dude, which is so rare on Broadway.

[11:35] Jess McEnally: I've talked to plenty of Broadway composers in my time doing musicals, which he's none of them have been as genuine and open as Paul Gordon.

[11:42] Sammi Lopez: Um, he has this very kind, empathetic.

[11:47] Andrew DeWolf: Caddy and press, you might say.

[11:49] Sammi Lopez: Um, how do they sidestep the very possible grooming aspect of this?

[11:57] Jess McEnally: How do you think, Andrew?

[11:59] Andrew DeWolf: Um, well, one, not having her be an actual child, like underage at the very beginning. She's obviously still kind of young and it's still a little bit weird, but uh, I suppose starting her at 18 is better than starting her at like 14.

[12:15] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, that would be very bad. Um, that's one major thing, but I think the way the characters are portrayed really um, I don't know.

[12:28] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know. Because I feel like deep down I want it to be creepy in some way. Because like it is creepy.

[12:37] Andrew DeWolf: It is creepy, though. It is kind of like if this happened in real life, it would be very, very questionable.

[12:44] Jess McEnally: So I'm struggling to find out like why it doesn't come across that way.

[12:48] Andrew DeWolf: I think we have Jervis's intentions from the start, which I think the book falters in not having his intentions in there, and he could very much just come off as like very predatory and because we don't see his side.

[13:00] Andrew DeWolf: And you have to write that very intentionally. You have to write it where at first he's like legitimately going into this like, I just think that she deserves a chance, and I'm gonna let her go do her thing, and then he gets invested in her the person.

[13:15] Andrew DeWolf: Whereas we, he is an audience surrogate where we fall in love with Jerusha the same way he does.

[13:23] Sammi Lopez: Yeah.

[13:23] Andrew DeWolf: No, no, that makes perfect sense. I think that is really what works. Because we know from the start that that wasn't his intent.

[13:30] Andrew DeWolf: Like he did not go into this, like, I want to have this girl as like my wife, and I'm gonna sneakily do it this way.

[13:39] Andrew DeWolf: Like, he's very clear that like he didn't even want to talk to this person. You know, like so you kind of understand, like, okay, he messed up and it was kind of weird what he did, but also he didn't intend to do it this way.

[13:54] Andrew DeWolf: So it's a strange line to walk where it could be like the anxiety-inducing lies that you see in like Dear Evan Hansen or spoilers for next week or last week, depending on the order. Mrs. Doubtfire. Um, where it does become a web of lies that you get trapped in. Where he does tell a lot of lies, but he's doing it for the right reason. There's not like a malicious intent behind it. I could still see if somebody had the interpretation of this where they were like, what he did was wrong and I can't forgive him. But I can. Let's think about Dear Evan Hansen, where you and I fundamentally made a list of the things he did wrong. What are the things that Pendleton did wrong?

[14:38] Jess McEnally: Well, he probably should have just told her right away. But he would break the thing, like he just was trying to help this person. The first thing he did wrong was send her flowers when she asked him for like some kind of response, and he gave that. And that was the first thing he did wrong. And then he wanted her right, and he's like, maybe I should meet her in person, and then one thing leads to another. Like, I think the fact that we get into his head, he's a very clear thinking. I'm gonna speak my thoughts aloud, individual. Yeah. And it's also they don't make excuses for him. Like when he messes up and is like being very controlling, it's very like he even has like a number about how he like completely screwed up, and like that wasn't right at all to do that. So, you know, they don't forgive him in any way.

[15:30] Jess McEnally: Alright, Sammi, what did you think of the staging? Like, because it's very specific, very intentional, but what do you think?

[15:37] Sammi Lopez: Um, I really loved the um I guess you wouldn't necessarily call it simple. Um, but it was still kind of simplistic, and um I loved the uh the letters compiling over his like uh over in his desk area just over the course of the musical. Um the the clever way that they had like Jerusha's outfit changes hidden in the the boxes on the stage and it was just it was so seamless.

[16:15] Jess McEnally: Do you consider yourself a Jerusha? A girl that just wants to be like other girls?

[16:20] Sammi Lopez: Uh not necessarily well I don't know. I think we all have a Jerusha inside of us. I want to be like other girls. I want to win the Nobel Prize like other girls. You know, I'm gonna be honest, I was never as ambitious as Jerusha was. Like she starts like a communist revolution, doesn't she? Or pretty Am I wrong? Like she's talking about socialism and like she's the Bernie Sanders of her time. Championing for women's rights to vote.

[16:56] Jess McEnally: Mm-hmm.

[16:58] Sammi Lopez: When does this take place?

[16:58] Jess McEnally: I think Well, she graduated the year of 1912.

[17:01] Sammi Lopez: Yeah, I think it was contemporary to when the book was written. The book was written around 1911.

[17:07] Jess McEnally: Yeah.

[17:09] Sammi Lopez: Very progressive.

[17:09] Jess McEnally: Yeah, she wants to she uh where do you think their future goes after the musical? Do you think they stay together?

[17:16] Sammi Lopez: I don't even think I have a thought about that. I feel like it ends when they kiss, and that's where I find one. They stop existing. They stop they cease existing.

[17:28] Jess McEnally: Part of me thinks like, yeah, it's probably not gonna work out, but I think that he's a bit I I think that Jerusha is strong-willed enough where he loves the idea of her, where we love the person herself in a weird way. Like we the audience know more about Jerusha than he could ever know. And because of that, I don't think Jerusha would put up with any of his shit. I don't think she's a weak willed in any way the way that he is. He is a coward, by all means.

[18:03] Sammi Lopez: No, he's a coward and he has shown himself to be very controlling when he doesn't get what he wants.

[18:08] Jess McEnally: Yeah, but he immediately like falls back and is like, oh my bad.

[18:14] Sammi Lopez: Yeah, but he doesn't really apologize to her. He gets upset that he he messed up and she might not like him anymore. If you were in the position with Jerusha where she finally gets the letter from from Daddy, I if I say daddy this many times, I I have to go to Horny Jail. Um, she gets the letter from Daddy. Um and then you find out, oh my god, it's my friend's uncle. What? And he's kinda he's kinda daddy, you know? Daddy long legs indeed. Like, how would you react? Like just this guy you kind of know?

[18:52] Jess McEnally: I feel like that's weird.

[18:54] Sammi Lopez: Her reaction was pretty was pretty natural. Those were private letters. Yeah, I mean, you can't send you can't send letters to somebody and then this person that you're writing about is actually reading them, and you don't even know that.

[19:10] Jess McEnally: Like why does this reveal like I know that they're in my head and they're connected. But She Loves Me has a very similar conceit where George does not tell Amalia until the end, and then when she finds out, she's like, Oh yeah, that's great. Hell yeah, let's you were the guy? Great. Um, it's the same vibe where she's immediately like, What? Okay, let's do it. You're right. This is this works. You got the money.

[19:36] Sammi Lopez: It's just a happy ending, Jess. Everyone loves a happy ending.

[19:39] Jess McEnally: I don't know. I feel like there needs like an a a little bit more. I feel like I need a little following action.

[19:46] Sammi Lopez: Well, to be fair, she did yell at him.

[19:49] Jess McEnally: Yeah.

[19:50] Sammi Lopez: Oh yeah.

[19:51] Jess McEnally: Yeah, yeah. That's more than even Evan Hansen got.

[19:54] Sammi Lopez: It it wasn't just like, oh, you're him? Great. It was how dare you. And then great.

[20:03] Jess McEnally: I mean, would you have forgiven him right away? How like would your reaction be the same as Jerusha's, or would you here's part of the reason I decided to come on this show is the reason why you paid us money to come on the show. The super patron that I am.

[20:18] Sammi Lopez: Hell yeah. I feel like the show can lean a little too cynical at times. And I'm like, I need to come and champion the cause of escapism and storytelling. And I mean, that's what I mean. That's what I just said. People love the happy ending. And as a hopeless romantic, happily ever after for me. You know. I think. Yeah, like, because she even wrote in her letter that she was in love with Jervis.

[20:56] Jess McEnally: You're right. You're right. Look.

[20:58] Sammi Lopez: But he's also lying and her her daddy. So does that change how that love is if he's her daddy, then I mean we gotta go to Horny Jail.

[21:16] Andrew DeWolf: I'll I I want to talk about the staging a bit.

[21:18] Jess McEnally: Okay.

[21:19] Andrew DeWolf: Because I really like the staging a lot. Um I think there's two aspects that I really liked. Um mostly having to do with the start of the show, where she starts the show like on the floor, basically, and he starts it up in darkness, up above her. Like there's actually like steps up above, and he starts it up above her, but then at the end of the show, he's standing on the floor and she's up on the platform above him. She grew beyond her standing.

[21:51] Jess McEnally: That's a very good point.

[21:53] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Power dynamics being visually shown. Also, the letters being pinned to the wall as he becomes more and more obsessive about her, and then by the end of it, they're in that room and the letters are everywhere. Um, just all over the place. Imagine if you're walking in there and you just see a room full of your letters just be the uh there's strings tied between each farm! Don't like farm! Jerusha just spelled out in red paint. It was me the whole time. I love you. I'm your daddy.

[22:32] Jess McEnally: What was that you were saying about us being too cynical?

[22:37] Brianna Jones: On that note of cynicism, it's time for everyone's favorite section of musical cheese. It's time for previews. It's Tom Falls! It's Tom Fall Previews! Alexis Solowski in their 2015 review for the New York Times wrote that Will no one pity the Postman. Two centuries of novels and plays would have a run aground without these couriers delivering menace, promise, and revelation with the morning letters.

[23:14] Jess McEnally: Alright, let's pause there. This is not a Ben Brantley, so I am under able to understand every word of that sentence. However, this isn't like She Loves Me. Like this isn't letters are a factor, but it's not really about letters or mail.

[23:28] Andrew DeWolf: I mean it kinda is.

[23:31] Jess McEnally: I wouldn't say that. Like I'd even say Dracula is more about letters and mail than this one.

[23:37] Andrew DeWolf: Look, they wanted to open with something that sounds fun and you and made you want to read the rest of the review.

[23:43] Jess McEnally: I I guess, and I I am just imagining poor Alexis coming home, like, oh shit, I gotta write this in three hours. God is a long goo Webster's dictionary to find mail.

[23:58] Andrew DeWolf: No, that's a Ben Bradley thing to write.

[24:01] Jess McEnally: That is a Ben Bradley, absolutely. Alright, Bree, what's next?

[24:05] Brianna Jones: Okay. That mailbag is unusually full in Daddy Long Legs, a sweet, beautifully sung, and only occasionally unsettling musical adapted uh adaptation of uh uh Jean Webster's 1912 novel predicated on the lengthy correspondence between a pert orphan and the anonymous benefactor who sends her to college.

[24:32] Jess McEnally: That's about right.

[24:33] Andrew DeWolf: Good good on you, Alexis Solowski.

[24:36] Brianna Jones: Most of the cast and creative team uh you is used to working on a much larger on much larger stages. The Tony winning writer and director John Caird previously collaborated with the composer Paul Gordon on the Broadway production of Jane Eyre. A story that has thematic resonance. Miss McGuinness and Mr. Nolan have each played Broadway leads. Here, Mr. Gordon's music and lyrics have a charm and ease, though the songs can blur into one another in ways that are sometimes purposeful and sometimes not. Mr. Caird's book is appealing and his direction more or less nimble. Miss McGuinness has a bright spirit, a mass of curly hair.

[25:24] Jess McEnally: Okay. That's one way. Is this her Tinder profile?

[25:30] Brianna Jones: Um I've got a kind spirit and a mass of curly hair. And a dulcet soprano. To watch Jerusha awaken to love and literature is a great treat. Mr. Nolan is softly Debonair, and he has a tender tenor that nicely encircles Miss McGuinness's voice in their duets.

[25:57] Jess McEnally: Who are these written for? What is Debonair mean?

[26:00] Andrew DeWolf: Debonair? Debonair, Du Bonair.

[26:02] Jess McEnally: What does that mean?

[26:03] Andrew DeWolf: Um sexy without saying sexy.

[26:06] Jess McEnally: Hey Siri, what does Debonair mean?

[26:10] Andrew DeWolf: Of immense confidence.

[26:12] Jess McEnally: Okay. Like, isn't this review supposed to be for people that are interested in seeing the show? Do I have to do that's a good one? Well, you're gonna know you're gonna get some some some twirly hair and sopranos.

[26:18] Andrew DeWolf: Do I have to have a dictionary?

[26:27] Jess McEnally: Massive curly hair and a dulcet soprano and a debonair man. I don't disagree with anything being said here so far. This is all very good.

[26:35] Brianna Jones: Seen through modern eyes, the story does have its creepy undertones. Here we go. Mr. Caird's direction avoids the merest hint of sexual suggestion, which does a lot to de-sleeze the relationship.

[26:50] Andrew DeWolf: I love the word de-sleeze.

[26:52] Jess McEnally: Can't have too much sleeves in this.

[26:55] Andrew DeWolf: We turn the sleaze meter down to 20% from 40%.

[26:59] Brianna Jones: A wrong intonation would have would give a lyric like, Daddy, I'm no good at being bad, some very naughty implications.

[27:08] Jess McEnally: Someone's gonna turn that doesn't have naughty implications.

[27:11] Brianna Jones: I'm about to say, Bree, someone's gonna turn that like audio snip of you saying that and like use it on the back.

[27:15] Andrew DeWolf: Daddy, I'm no good at being bad.

[27:24] Brianna Jones: I'm gonna have to make an OnlyFans. Just do voice snippets.

[27:29] Jess McEnally: Isn't that ASMR though?

[27:30] Brianna Jones: Oh, true. Good at being bad.

[27:34] Jess McEnally: Maybe you should do it.

[27:35] Andrew DeWolf: I'm not gonna say it.

[27:37] Jess McEnally: Say it, Andrew.

[27:38] Andrew DeWolf: Say it, Andrew.

[27:43] Andrew DeWolf: But it's still unethical that Jervis woos Jerisha without disclosing his identity, and at least a little disconcerting that his folk preminist tale ends with its plucky heroine rewarded with marriage to the man who has manipulated her for the past five years.

[28:06] Sammi Lopez: Um maybe she should write a letter of complaint.

[28:10] Jess McEnally: Ah, bring it right back around. Good job, Alexa Solowski. Do we agree with that review?

[28:16] Sammi Lopez: Uh I mean, I understand. We talk enough about stuff being weird and unethical in stories that I can't fault people for saying it here. I just feel like I can forgive this one more than some of the others.

[28:31] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know. I feel like this doesn't take place in anything that sh like even close to real reality in a weird way. It feels like a fantasy like fiction novel. It all feels so everything feels like symbolic in this in ways. Like it doesn't feel like Dear Evan Hansen's like, we're real world. This is what real kids deal with. Um so you gotta lie to people's parents to be about their best friend, you know?

[28:54] Sammi Lopez: Yeah. I mean, it might be that it's a period piece, and we can't see how it would be like in 1911 or whatever, but the thing is, Jervis Pendleton has more consequences for his actions and his lies in 1912 than Evan Hansen is allegedly supposed to have in 2015. That is the big difference.

[29:18] Jess McEnally: Yeah. I think it's alright. I can see if people would be a little upset about it. But I mean, I think that even this reviewer is uh this critic is is generally pretty positive on the show, even with that. So most people I agree with this review.

[29:34] Sammi Lopez: I don't know. I'm trying to imagine one person being like, you know what, Daddy Long Legs? Worst show I ever saw. Like, I feel like most people are positive to neutral on this show. Like, if you feel anything violently about the show, it's violent positivity. It's not like, oh god, that's show.

[29:49] Andrew DeWolf: Does anyone here feel violent positivity?

[29:52] Sammi Lopez: I feel violent positivity for this show.

[29:54] Jess McEnally: Would anyone here before? I love it so much, I just want to go see it. I just love Jerusha so much. I will fucking fight a dragon for her.

[30:04] Andrew DeWolf: Well, Jervis would do that for you.

[30:07] Sammi Lopez: Can't pay for the thing.

[30:12] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, yeah, what was that guy's name?

[30:13] Sammi Lopez: Jimmy McBride.

[30:15] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Jimmy McBride, I'd beat the crap out of that guy. You know what? He's not good enough. He can't pay for your college, Jerusha.

[30:27] Jess McEnally: On that note, let's play a game of letterbox reviews. One star, five star, Sammi. You've listened to this many times. I feel like you have the right amount of training. You've at least listened to one episode of the show, which is more to say for most of us, our guests, to be honest.

[30:43] Sammi Lopez: At least one, yeah.

[30:45] Andrew DeWolf: At least one. Maybe two.

[30:48] Sammi Lopez: Definitely all of them.

[30:50] Jess McEnally: Really? Listen to all of them?

[30:52] Sammi Lopez: I when I first found this podcast, I decided to just start from the beginning and I you had to suffer for a little while then.

[31:01] Jess McEnally: So it's letterbox review, one star, five stars. Sammi, are you ready? Whose team do you want to be on, Sammi? You want to be on Bree's team or my Yeah, we're gonna do that. You you pay us money. You paid us money to be here. You can't be on my team. I have to beat you.

[31:13] Sammi Lopez: Alright, alright. Um Bree.

[31:18] Jess McEnally: I'm gonna go. I'm gonna go Bree. Girl Power.

[31:21] Sammi Lopez: Hell yeah.

[31:21] Jess McEnally: Yes, girl power. Andrew, we're in this together. Um Brie, you go first.

[31:27] Brianna Jones: Okay. Oh, and for clarification, this is letterbox reviews for the Fred Astaire film and the 2015 recording.

[31:33] Sammi Lopez: Okay, okay.

[31:34] Brianna Jones: Oh, they have both.

[31:35] Sammi Lopez: Okay.

[31:36] Brianna Jones: This one says.

[31:39] Sammi Lopez: Bitch, he's my daddy.

[31:46] Brianna Jones: Oh.

[31:47] Sammi Lopez: That sounds like a five star.

[31:49] Brianna Jones: That's a five star.

[31:50] Jess McEnally: Yeah. Good job, good job, good job. Starting easy. Starting them easy.

[31:54] Sammi Lopez: Yeah, yeah.

[31:57] Brianna Jones: Literally every other character. Fred Astaire, please stop doing that. It's very rapey and inappropriate.

[31:59] Sammi Lopez: Fred Astaire.

[32:03] Brianna Jones: I don't remember asking you a goddamn.

[32:08] Sammi Lopez: Sounds like a 50s movie.

[32:10] Brianna Jones: Um. Oh Lord. I kind of wish we had watched this uh movie to do this episode. I feel like we don't need to give it more power.

[32:20] Jess McEnally: Alright. We'll do it as a bonus thing. We'll do a remote. Why don't we do a commentary on it since we're gonna have a lot more time for those?

[32:27] Brianna Jones: Yeah. Okay. Um I'm gonna say this is a this is a one-star.

[32:33] Sammi Lopez: This doesn't sound like a correct Bree, what we got.

[32:39] Brianna Jones: Okay. Uh Daddy, Daddy, why your legs so long?

[32:46] Sammi Lopez: What?

[32:48] Brianna Jones: Daddy with those long legs. That also is in all caps, so it's more like Daddy Daddy, why your legs so long.

[32:59] Sammi Lopez: Oh gosh, that that gives like nothing away. Um I feel like take a shot in the genetics?

[33:09] Brianna Jones: Uh I'm gonna say five stars.

[33:15] Sammi Lopez: That is a one star.

[33:17] Brianna Jones: But I don't know why. I can't be my own. I would have guessed five as long. Like I said, I it was it was a shot in the dark, that one. I always thought leg like long legs were were good, but here maybe not.

[33:29] Jess McEnally: Alright, alright. Andrew, you ready?

[33:31] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, yeah. A plus effort from the show for trying to make calling someone daddy anything other than sexual.

[33:40] Sammi Lopez: Yeah. I'll be real, I still got a little bit of those vibes sometimes.

[33:45] Andrew DeWolf: It's hard to not. Daddy, I'm sorry for being bad. I'm no good at being bad.

[33:53] Sammi Lopez: Say it, Andrew.

[33:54] Andrew DeWolf: Um Why did she call him father?

[33:57] Sammi Lopez: Father.

[33:57] Andrew DeWolf: Because that's on a you can't say father long legs.

[33:57] Sammi Lopez: Father long legs.

[34:01] Andrew DeWolf: That's worse.

[34:04] Sammi Lopez: Papa long legs.

[34:06] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, father. I'm no good at the end. Looking like uh daddy long legs. The musical really does try so hard to make it not creepy. Where they're like, okay. He looks like a daddy long legs. You should be called daddy long legs because you look like a daddy long legs. Not for any other reason. But you can you have long legs. You're my daddy, not because you're my daddy.

[34:25] Sammi Lopez: My daddy. I'm a little bit more.

[34:30] Andrew DeWolf: Wait. Wait. Sugar daddy long legs.

[34:33] Sammi Lopez: Okay. Uh five stars.

[34:37] Brianna Jones: Bria, what was it?

[34:38] Brianna Jones: Um, that was uh five stars, yeah.

[34:41] Sammi Lopez: It was five stars. Sorry, I'm quick to cross them out.

[34:44] Andrew DeWolf: You were, I lose them. Um, alright. You guys are up next.

[34:49] Sammi Lopez: Yes.

[34:50] Brianna Jones: Um Okay. I have so many questions. Laughing emoji, broken heart emoji.

[34:57] Sammi Lopez: Oh gosh. So many questions.

[35:01] Brianna Jones: So many. Uh um. One star.

[35:05] Sammi Lopez: One star is correct.

[35:07] Brianna Jones: Broken heart emoji. Does something happen in the other movie or something?

[35:10] Sammi Lopez: Maybe.

[35:10] Brianna Jones: I think it's just creepy.

[35:12] Sammi Lopez: It's just creepier.

[35:15] Brianna Jones: To be with daddy. It's like one star because he didn't end up with me.

[35:27] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I'm ready. Let's go. I love this, but I'm not sure I could ever forgive Jervey for being a coward.

[35:34] Sammi Lopez: Jervy Coward is in all caps.

[35:38] Brianna Jones: Okay. You open it with I love this, which I in I have to give it five stars for that.

[35:44] Sammi Lopez: That was a one star.

[35:47] Brianna Jones: I guess him him being a coward, it's just like it takes it from five stars all the way to to zero.

[35:53] Sammi Lopez: Yeah, yeah. Yep, yep. All the stars are gone. Letterbox makes no sense. I keep saying this every week. Stop trying to look for logic in these.

[36:02] Jess McEnally: Alright, Brie.

[36:04] Brianna Jones: Okay. This one says Okay, musical. Too much age difference between Um, I'm not sure that's ever actually established, but uh that sounds like That's a one star.

[36:22] Sammi Lopez: That's probably about the the movie, right?

[36:24] Brianna Jones: Oh, it said musical, but uh It's a musical for Fred Astaire.

[36:28] Sammi Lopez: It's just him dancing to a bunch of songs.

[36:30] Brianna Jones: I guess that's fair. That's fair. Alright. Alright, Andrew, you ready?

[36:35] Andrew DeWolf: I am as ready as I'll ever be. Don't be under the impression this film this is a film musical. Someone has pointed a camera at a stage whilst a man and a woman go through a lot of songs to live an audience to a live audience. Odd why the blurb on the main IMDB page is not clear on this.

[36:54] Sammi Lopez: That is the one IMDB review of Daddy Long Legs, I want to say that.

[37:00] Andrew DeWolf: So they're very, very upset that this filmed version of a musical is a filmed version of a musical.

[37:06] Sammi Lopez: Yeah.

[37:07] Andrew DeWolf: But an IMDB lied to them and tricked them, apparently.

[37:09] Sammi Lopez: Yeah, tricked them into thinking that this is a very good idea.

[37:11] Andrew DeWolf: Part of me wants to see the IMDB page now.

[37:15] Sammi Lopez: Wait, so okay. I mean, I guess one star, they seem very upset.

[37:22] Brianna Jones: That is correct.

[37:24] Andrew DeWolf: That is probably my favorite review here. And it was very obvious. I just think it's so don't be tricked. Don't be tricked that this is a filmed musical. Like I was stage. I mean, it's it's a very well shot, like three-camera thing, like, but there's he framed it like it's like one camera, no cuts, watch the show. It's like, well, yeah, I mean, that's a musical, though. Like, that's what that's what you are getting, right?

[37:52] Brianna Jones: Alright, Brie, what we got.

[37:55] Brianna Jones: This is one of the many problematic stories I found immensely romantic when I was 15.

[38:01] Sammi Lopez: Ooh.

[38:04] Brianna Jones: I mean. Is it bad that I find it romantic now? And I'm in my 30s.

[38:15] Sammi Lopez: No one would believe that.

[38:16] Brianna Jones: You look 19. Come on.

[38:17] Sammi Lopez: I I definitely look that.

[38:19] Brianna Jones: I know. Uh, that sounds like a one star.

[38:22] Sammi Lopez: That was a five star.

[38:23] Brianna Jones: That was a five star.

[38:26] Sammi Lopez: Hmm. Alright. You can't trust these people.

[38:28] Andrew DeWolf: No.

[38:28] Brianna Jones: And you're ready.

[38:31] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I'm not sure. It's problematic, but I loved it when I was a kid. Five stars.

[38:34] Sammi Lopez: Yeah.

[38:35] Brianna Jones: That's a phantom of the opera for most people.

[38:38] Andrew DeWolf: Phantom, too. Phantom's alright. But I'm not saying it's uh like the greatest love story.

[38:44] Sammi Lopez: Yeah, no, that's Daddy Long Legs. Um the tragedy of it all. Which phantom's better?

[38:50] Andrew DeWolf: The the the Arthur Kopit and Yesin and Copa one.

[38:54] Sammi Lopez: Come on.

[38:56] Andrew DeWolf: No, it's the it's the Freddie Krueger version.

[39:00] Sammi Lopez: You know what, Andrew? You're right.

[39:03] Jess McEnally: Hey, we did a commentary on that. That's the most romantic.

[39:06] Sammi Lopez: I need to watch that commentary.

[39:07] Jess McEnally: That is the one we have at like I loved doing that commentary with Andrew because he's so baffled every five minutes.

[39:14] Andrew DeWolf: I do actually like the song that they have in it though.

[39:16] Sammi Lopez: Oh, the song, the Don Juan song is incredible in that Freddy Krueger version.

[39:21] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. Like we're not even calling it Robert England. We're just saying Freddie Krueger, the man. He still has the makeup on, so let's say it is. Um yes, Adam Haplin is easy on the eyes, but I believe in Paul Alexander Nolan's supremacy.

[39:37] Sammi Lopez: That's a Bright Star fan right there, I guess.

[39:40] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, Bright Star. That's the one fan of Bright Star right there. Steve Martin wrote that review.

[39:47] Sammi Lopez: Um I mean, I feel like it's a one star, but it almost feels too obvious. I wanna I want to say five stars because I think they liked the show still.

[40:00] Andrew DeWolf: It's one star.

[40:03] Sammi Lopez: Sammy's kicking your ass, Andrew.

[40:05] Andrew DeWolf: I tried, I tried.

[40:08] Brianna Jones: Bree, how about you got one more?

[40:10] Brianna Jones: I got one more, and then we wrap this up. It's a bit hard to ignore the creep factor.

[40:12] Sammi Lopez: A bit hard.

[40:19] Brianna Jones: A bit a little bit hard to ignore. Uh that sounds like it should be a middling review. But I know it's one star.

[40:32] Sammi Lopez: Why am I trying to logic this out?

[40:34] Andrew DeWolf: Um Andrew does it every week.

[40:37] Sammi Lopez: It's hard not to. It's hard not to. Like you you like start thinking about it, and then you then you realize that these people that write these don't have brains, so it's like why are you why am I using mine?

[40:48] Brianna Jones: I'm gonna say five stars.

[40:50] Sammi Lopez: It was a one star.

[40:53] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, Andrew. Here it is. You can tie it up right here.

[40:59] Brianna Jones: Four laughing crying emojis.

[41:07] Sammi Lopez: What?

[41:08] Andrew DeWolf: Yep. That's the full review.

[41:11] Sammi Lopez: How am I like? They could be laughing because it's so bad. They could be laughing because it's so good.

[41:18] Andrew DeWolf: Five stars.

[41:21] Sammi Lopez: That was a one star.

[41:24] Andrew DeWolf: One star.

[41:29] Jess McEnally: Yay! Great job, Sammy. I hope you're proud. You won letterboard.

[41:35] Andrew DeWolf: It was four to three. Okay. Yeah, sorry, Andrew. You lost.

[41:40] Jess McEnally: You can't just go and storm the Capitol and say you won.

[41:46] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, I feel like there should be a recount. I feel like there should be a recount here.

[41:51] Jess McEnally: Alright, Brie, count them again.

[41:54] Brianna Jones: Oh god, okay. Well, I have three to three.

[41:57] Jess McEnally: Oh, I thought you said four, because Sammy just got the last one.

[42:00] Brianna Jones: Stop the count.

[42:02] Jess McEnally: No, no, I know. No, they were tied at three to three, then Sammy got the last one right, and Andrew got the last one wrong.

[42:08] Brianna Jones: No, she got the last one wrong too.

[42:10] Sammi Lopez: Yeah, I got the last one wrong.

[42:12] Jess McEnally: Didn't you?

[42:13] Sammi Lopez: Oh, okay, then we're tied.

[42:15] Jess McEnally: I thought I thought that Sammy got that one right. I apologize. That's on me.

[42:21] Andrew DeWolf: Jeez. Trying to steal my points away from me. Man.

[42:25] Sammi Lopez: How about we go look at a lot of things? I get paid based on how many of these I win, so he's right.

[42:32] Andrew DeWolf: He's right. So what happens in a tie then?

[42:34] Jess McEnally: You get like he doesn't get paid. I get half the money.

[42:38] Andrew DeWolf: I tell him it's half, but it's really like a coin.

[42:41] Sammi Lopez: Does that mean I get the other half?

[42:42] Jess McEnally: No, you gave the other half. Jess just pockets it. The house always wins.

[42:51] Jess McEnally: And on that note, let's go into a Metro announcement. And listen to these ads.

[43:03] Jess McEnally: Hey guys, sorry to interrupt you in the middle of the show, but we've got a shell at you. Today's show is brought to you by the extremely kind donations by our donors at Patreon. Sammy, tell them a little bit about a Patreon as a patron yourself. What do you get out of it?

[43:16] Sammi Lopez: Um, well, you get access to uh lots of extra stuff. There are there's an extra podcast, there's uh extra commentaries, there's even video versions of this podcast. You can see Sammy's lovely face right now. Oh, she's doing a little dance. Oh, look at that.

[43:42] Jess McEnally: What else, Sammy?

[43:44] Sammi Lopez: Um, there's access to a great Discord community. Um if you donate certain amounts, you get to request shows. Or even be on it. You can even be on it. Guest on an episode like I am currently doing.

[44:04] Jess McEnally: Hell yeah. Um, thank you, Sammy. Um and also, here are the list of people that are supporting us on Patreon. They are Melissa Goldman, John Donna, Danielle Renics, Jess the Stampede, Iwan Taskity, um, Teskear, Monica Thoreau, Mina Meneary, Brent Black, Lathaniel, Stacy Comb, Joseph Evans Green, Carrie Hearn, Mary Lou Showcat, John Van Ouse, Rust Walker, Musical Hell, Emily Gracie, Kyle Summers, Janay C, Scoot, and the Technicolor Dream Code, Liz Lim, Alison Stullard, nothing is certain except Beth and Taxes, Desbian, Ren Cullen, Raphael, Martinez Salaz, Robert Benjamin, Jessica T, Mitchell Young, Chai Teacup, Katie McDonough, Timothy Keyes, Chris Marcote, Mimu, Kiji Marie Anastasio, Layla, RJ Narigo, Sebastian Canino, Evan Regan, Charlie B, Patrick Tearing, Joe, Avery Brinson, Marilyn Brown, Mel Cormack, LaFemme Fictionnelle, Bjorn Herman's, Mac the Knife, Erica S. Toriana Frazier, Sammy the Most Lopez, Lyanna Morton, Angela, Kaylee Blizz Blazier, Birdman69, great name.

And Danielle Smith. They all give us a little extra financial support that helps us keep the lights on here at Musicals for Cheese. If you'd like to join them and Sammy, um, just come on over to Patreon. You get so much fun stuff. Sammy, as someone that has listened to at least a couple episodes of our show, do you ever listen to the mid-shows?

[45:32] Sammi Lopez: All the time.

[45:33] Jess McEnally: Really?

[45:34] Sammi Lopez: Ever well, I listen to it in my car on my drive to and from work. So I just I just keep it playing.

[45:41] Jess McEnally: That's fair, that's fair. Does that actually bring you joy?

[45:47] Sammi Lopez: It does. Everyone loves hearing their own name.

[45:51] Jess McEnally: Yes, yes. How about we get back to the show and talk about some songs?

[45:54] Andrew DeWolf: Sounds like a good idea.

[46:33] ♪ Musical number: "The Oldest Orphan in the John Greer Home" ♪

[46:37] Jess McEnally: So I really like the opening number, uh, the oldest orphan at the John Greer Home. It has like a really kind of like l lintly gentle feeling to it. Like that piano riff throughout it really, really is effective. What do you think of it, Andrew?

[46:53] Andrew DeWolf: Um, well, I think it's a a pretty effective song, and I think you have to like it because it comes back so often that if you don't like it by the end of the show, I mean, then you probably just didn't like the show.

[47:05] Jess McEnally: Did it really come back that often? Maybe I'm just not remembering it.

[47:08] Andrew DeWolf: The little melody line I feel like comes back all the time.

[47:10] Jess McEnally: It came back twice.

[47:12] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I remember it twice, where it's like formerly uh the John Greer home and some other part of the John Greer home.

[47:18] Jess McEnally: No longer associated with the John Greer home.

[47:20] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, well, those two, but there were also like perfectly awful day sections.

[47:25] Jess McEnally: Okay.

[47:27] Andrew DeWolf: It comes back a lot.

[47:28] Jess McEnally: Does it really I don't know? It doesn't feel like it comes back. I feel like it's a very effective, I wouldn't even call it an I Want song. Because it's just like life kinda sucks, sets up the world, sets up her predicament, and the big change that will happen through Jervis. If only she wasn't singing the song and just paid attention to who walked into the building.

[47:47] Andrew DeWolf: I think that I mean, I think that's part of the fun. And really the conceit of the musical. Man, wouldn't it have been great if Indiana Jones just had the arc in his basement?

[48:02] Jess McEnally: That would have been an interesting twist, actually. It's like, oh, it's in my basement. How'd it get there? Let's open Ah.

[48:15] Jess McEnally: Um, I do love this song. I think it's very effective. Um, there's not many proper songs in this show. Like, it's hard to like talk about like who is this man and stuff like that, because it really does just feel like spoken sung dialogue, so to say. Um, however, one very eerie, very different song that I really like in act one is I'm a beast.

[48:40] ♪ Musical number: "I'm a Beast" ♪

[49:04] Jess McEnally: Where it's like this very eerie sounding like very minimal song where she just talks about like her self-regrets and all of that stuff as a reaction to him sending her flowers. It feels very real, where it's like, I'm sick of being who I am, and I'm gonna be better than I ever was. And it's a strange. It gives you the emotional feeling in musical form of guilt in every facet of everything. It is it sounds the way I think guilt feels.

[49:34] Andrew DeWolf: I think what's also very interesting is that it's sung by both characters at different points in the show.

[49:39] Jess McEnally: Yes.

[49:40] Andrew DeWolf: It's their apology numbers.

[49:42] Jess McEnally: Yeah.

[49:43] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. So kind of goes back to what I was saying about the staging where they switch places by the end of the show.

[49:49] Jess McEnally: Yeah, yeah, you you picked up on something there, but I really picked up on something there. I'll give you a gold star after the show's over.

[49:55] Andrew DeWolf: Give me three gold stars. I want three.

[49:57] Jess McEnally: You get one and a half.

[49:59] Andrew DeWolf: I love these negotiations at the moment.

[50:03] Jess McEnally: I mean, uh that's how we handle the show afterwards. That's what he gets paid in. Gets paid in. I mean, you lost the preview, so you you can't get two. I'm sorry.

[50:13] Jess McEnally: What do you think of this song, Sammy?

[50:16] Sammi Lopez: Uh, I'm a beast. I I think you really really nailed it. Like, the the tone of it is just so different from all the rest of the songs in the show. And it really just kind of hits you. Uh, emotionally.

[50:36] Andrew DeWolf: Oh no.

[50:38] Jess McEnally: I had a discovery while looking at these songs. They could all be like titles of like a sexy romance novel.

[50:47] Andrew DeWolf: Freshman year studies. Uh college. Uh things I didn't know. What does she mean by love? I'm a beast. When shall we meet? The color of your eyes. The secret of happiness. Sophomore year studies. The man I'll never humble pie. Charity.

[51:08] Jess McEnally: I mean, I mean, they do kind of feel like a little bit like that. I'm not stretching too much there. I didn't even have to use the word daddy once.

[51:21] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. There's a song in this that has like the twisted version of the uh Bohemian Rhapsody Play.

[51:27] Jess McEnally: Okay, talk about that. Which one is that?

[51:29] Andrew DeWolf: I can't remember what song that was.

[51:31] Jess McEnally: I think that's I'm a Beast.

[51:32] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[51:32] Jess McEnally: Is it I'm a Beast?

[51:33] Andrew DeWolf: It is I'm a Beast.

[51:34] Jess McEnally: Okay.

[51:35] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I was I I felt like it was, but I wasn't entirely sure, and I didn't want to bring it up and be wrong. Uh oh yeah, I I thought that this was really interesting, but I couldn't unhear that. Like the boom boom boom boom beep bee.

[51:51] Jess McEnally: It sounds just different enough though.

[51:53] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[51:54] Jess McEnally: Because I kinda hear it. It's like wicked little town in dancing through life, kind of having the same melody.

[51:59] Andrew DeWolf: Well, it almost makes the song feel like more like off, because it's like you're almost listening for something else and it's not playing it. It makes you feel sick to your stomach, like in a weird way. I I've never had a song give me that reaction. I know we joked about Institute Institute earlier where that was supposed to make us feel like we were eating grilled cheese or something. That didn't do that, but this made me feel gross and guilty somehow, just through being.

[52:23] Jess McEnally: I don't remember that. That was the only interesting thing about There was a song that made you feel like eating grilled cheese.

[52:30] Andrew DeWolf: I can't remember that.

[52:31] Jess McEnally: That's the only reason why we did it. We need to revisit some of these like weird shows that we've done.

[52:37] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know how we could do that.

[52:40] Jess McEnally: I don't think they want it. We're interested the first time, to be honest. I wanna feel like I'm eating a grilled cheese.

[52:47] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. No, I'm a beast. Yeah, no, this was actually this was probably my favorite number then if this was if that's the one I was thinking of, so.

[52:54] Jess McEnally: Yeah. Um, let's talk about the secret of happiness, which is kind of the torch song of this show. Like the big like, here's what our show's about. Um, and it's probably the most like poppy number aside from maybe my Manhattan, which is an act two.

[52:54] ♪ Musical number: "The Secret of Happiness" ♪

[53:39] Jess McEnally: What do you think of this song, Sammy?

[53:41] Sammi Lopez: Um, it's definitely one of my favorites. Um, I really identify with the message of it. Um about you know, living in the now, not really being focused on the too much on the future or the past. And just kind of uh Yeah, enjoying what's around you at the moment.

[54:08] Jess McEnally: Like it's like the weird kind of like things that your mom will post on Facebook, but genuine.

[54:15] Sammi Lopez: Yeah, yeah, exactly. Well, and I have I mean, I've had kind of first hand experience of uh having that moment where it's like, man, I gotta take a look at you know what's around me, all the good stuff that's there, and just enjoy it while it's happening.

[54:36] Jess McEnally: I completely agree. As Brian Andrew will know, like sometimes I have those moments and I just have to remind them how happy they make me and the joy they bring in my life. So that's why you get 2 a.m. texts from me.

[54:47] Andrew DeWolf: That seems like an insane person.

[54:49] Jess McEnally: I just I just thought it was because you have a little bit too much wine that night.

[54:54] Jess McEnally: But it happens though, where you're like, you know what? The secret of happiness is uh magic hour pre-peach moscato. Um, but one of the lines I really like is you can still win the race by coming in last, which really does kind of make sense where everyone says like slow and steady wins the race, which is a horseshit thing. I like this one because it's a much more vague, much more easy to digest.

[55:19] Jess McEnally: Paul Gordon is very good at coming up with these very good truisms.

[55:22] Jess McEnally: He's also very good at translating adaptations from like books to stage.

[55:28] Jess McEnally: I really really like Paul Gordon as a composer.

[55:30] Jess McEnally: Give him more stuff.

[55:32] Jess McEnally: Give him a Disney movie.

[55:34] Jess McEnally: You can pick someone that isn't Alan Menken and Lynn Manuel Miranda every now and then, Disney.

[55:39] Sammi Lopez: No, they can't.

[55:40] Jess McEnally: I was gonna say, can they?

[55:43] Sammi Lopez: I wish they would.

[55:45] Jess McEnally: Um, you know, Alan Mencken's not even allowed to win Oscars anymore.

[55:50] Sammi Lopez: They made a rule because of him.

[55:52] Jess McEnally: He's got too many.

[55:54] Sammi Lopez: Why do you keep having him do things?

[55:57] Jess McEnally: They don't care if they win an award.

[55:59] Jess McEnally: They just want money.

[56:00] Sammi Lopez: I thought you said Alan Mencken isn't alive to win anywhere.

[56:03] Jess McEnally: Oh no, no, he's alive.

[56:05] Jess McEnally: He's just not allowed to win.

[56:06] Sammi Lopez: I was like, I'm pretty sure he's still living.

[56:10] Jess McEnally: Is he ghost writing?

[56:13] Sammi Lopez: Yeah, he's ghostwriting the new songs for The Little Mermaid with Lin-Manuel Miranda.

[56:19] Jess McEnally: No, that's Howard Ashman.

[56:21] Sammi Lopez: Um, Secret of Happiness.

[56:23] Jess McEnally: Great, great number.

[56:25] Jess McEnally: Um, you want to talk about Sammy that we haven't?

[56:29] Sammi Lopez: Um, just in act one or just in general?

[56:33] Sammi Lopez: Um, I wanted to mention the reprise of the Secret of Happiness.

[56:38] Jess McEnally: Let's go!

[56:40] Sammi Lopez: I've discovered the secret of happiness is not to be afraid.

[56:48] Sammi Lopez: I've discovered the secret of happiness is fine.

[56:57] Sammi Lopez: Don't fear the future, you'll just be delayed.

[57:01] Sammi Lopez: 'Cause the secret, the secret of happiness is maybe in the now.

[57:10] Sammi Lopez: Just because, again, as a hopeless romantic, there are just like a few lines in this song, and when you know Adam Halpin turns and looks at her when he sings those lines, I'm just like, oh my heart.

[57:23] Sammi Lopez: Like, you know, he said, like, I imagine the secret of happiness was the art of compromise.

[57:30] Sammi Lopez: But I've discovered the secret of happiness was looking in her eyes.

[57:35] Sammi Lopez: And I was just like, and then you know, I've discovered the secret of happiness was something more divine that her happiness is more precious than mine.

[57:48] Sammi Lopez: And it's just like, I just like melt.

[57:52] Sammi Lopez: I melt.

[57:53] Andrew DeWolf: I have a very similar experience, but with the song Charity, where he like discovers like he thought he was helping her through college, and then he realizes how much of an emotional outlet and sponge she was for his stuff.

[58:06] Sammi Lopez: Yeah.

[58:07] Andrew DeWolf: Um, that song really gives me that same feeling where I just look at the lyrics where it's like charity, who is helping who.

[58:14] Andrew DeWolf: It's you could do for me what no one else could do.

[58:17] Sammi Lopez: Like it's so good.

[58:18] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I get the vibes from that song too.

[58:20] Andrew DeWolf: That's also one of my favorites.

[58:23] Sammi Lopez: But I really don't like the Paul Alexander Nolan version.

[58:27] Sammi Lopez: I like it when a man is singing this about his real-life wife, the mother of his child on stage.

[58:32] Sammi Lopez: It's beautiful.

[58:33] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, absolutely.

[58:35] Sammi Lopez: But I think I don't know if like it would make a difference being able to watch Paul Alexander Nolan performing it, because I've only ever listened, but I absolutely love the way Adam Halpin just brings out the emotion in every bit of his part.

[58:54] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know.

[58:55] Andrew DeWolf: Paul Alexander Nolan might be the kindest guy in the world.

[58:59] Andrew DeWolf: Gives me Patrick Bateman vibes.

[59:02] Sammi Lopez: He is the brightest star.

[59:06] Jess McEnally: On that note, Sammy, this was great, but what is everyone's overall thoughts and cheese ratings?

[59:11] Jess McEnally: We've reached that part of the podcast.

[59:14] Jess McEnally: Andrew, you want to go first?

[59:16] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I'll go first.

[59:19] Andrew DeWolf: Um, this was a very good show, actually.

[59:22] Andrew DeWolf: I really enjoyed it.

[59:23] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, the emotional beats hit pretty well.

[59:25] Andrew DeWolf: The music was pretty good all the way through.

[59:28] Andrew DeWolf: Um, check it out.

[59:30] Andrew DeWolf: Apparently there's a great film version of it you can watch, so no, don't, don't, don't say this, Andrew.

[59:38] Andrew DeWolf: So, you know, yo-ho, um, go check it out.

[59:41] Andrew DeWolf: Um, legally subscribe to Broadway HD and watch.

[59:43] Sammi Lopez: Oh, which you should do.

[59:41] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, you should do that.

[59:41] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, yeah, yeah.

[59:41] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I'm gonna give it the cheese, um, uh, Milbenkase, which is sometimes called uh, Spinnencase or spider cheese, um, which is apparently a cheese that is made by making the cheese and then leaving it for three months with cheese mites that digest the cheese and then make it ripe, um, and they're like little spiders.

[59:41] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and that makes my skin crawl. I don't like that.

[59:41] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, yeah, you know, it's like something that sounds kind of gross and like if you explain it to somebody, the story might sound a little gross, but also when you watch it, it's really good and when you eat the cheese, it's gonna be really good.

[59:41] Jess McEnally: Okay, um, I'm so spider daddy long legs, you know.

[59:41] Jess McEnally: I thought about this, Andrew.

[59:41] Jess McEnally: I actually really like the cheese reading for it.

[59:41] Jess McEnally: Absolutely, I really like that cheese rating also.

[59:41] Jess McEnally: Or Juliet, when you make the list, put a little vomiting emoji next to that.

[59:41] Sammi Lopez: Um, what about you? What's your overall thoughts on cheese?

[59:41] Sammi Lopez: Uh, well, if you haven't figured it out, this is probably one of my favorites.

[59:41] Sammi Lopez: I just, I just love it.

[59:41] Sammi Lopez: It's a beautiful sweet story.

[59:41] Sammi Lopez: Um, and again, like it could have been problematic, but when I watch it, I don't see any of that.

[1:01:19] Sammi Lopez: I just see a couple of people growing into themselves and figuring out what they actually want.

[1:01:26] Sammi Lopez: And, uh, it's got a nice happily ever after at the end.

[1:01:31] Sammi Lopez: Um, so I think I just might have to give it one of my favorite cheeses, which is mozzarella.

[1:01:39] Sammi Lopez: It's like very soft, and, uh, I, you know, I can't get enough of it.

[1:01:44] Sammi Lopez: I could eat mozzarella at any time.

[1:01:47] Sammi Lopez: I could just watch this musical anytime and just be super happy.

[1:01:51] Jess McEnally: So are you telling me that the secret to happiness is Daddy Long Legs, the musical?

[1:01:51] Sammi Lopez: Yes.

[1:01:51] Sammi Lopez: Absolutely.

[1:01:57] Sammi Lopez: And mozzarella cheese.

[1:01:58] Sammi Lopez: And mozzarella cheese.

[1:01:59] Sammi Lopez: Yep, eat mozzarella cheese while watching Daddy Long Legs.

[1:02:02] Sammi Lopez: Oh, that is pure happiness.

[1:02:02] Jess McEnally: Yep.

[1:02:02] Jess McEnally: Joy.

[1:02:07] Brianna Jones: Bree, what'd you think of our discussion and your cheese rating of that?

[1:02:11] Brianna Jones: A fantastic discussion.

[1:02:12] Brianna Jones: This felt so natural having you on the show, Sammy.

[1:02:16] Brianna Jones: Um, it was a great time.

[1:02:19] Brianna Jones: I want to go watch Daddy Long Legs now.

[1:02:22] Brianna Jones: Um, so I probably will go do that.

[1:02:24] Sammi Lopez: Do it.

[1:02:24] Brianna Jones: Um, but I am going to give this like my go-to cheese, um, which is Colby Jack.

[1:02:31] Brianna Jones: I buy it every time I go to the grocery store.

[1:02:33] Brianna Jones: I use it on my eggs, I use it in my grilled cheeses.

[1:02:37] Brianna Jones: It's my go-to cheese.

[1:02:37] Brianna Jones: I love Daddy Long Legs.

[1:02:40] Brianna Jones: It's a great show.

[1:02:41] Brianna Jones: Um, very few complaints.

[1:02:43] Brianna Jones: The recording they have on Broadway HD is very well done.

[1:02:47] Brianna Jones: The first live stream musical of all time.

[1:02:50] Brianna Jones: That's pretty flippin' incredible.

[1:02:52] Brianna Jones: Um, Paul Gordon, I think his musicals are good.

[1:02:55] Brianna Jones: Um, we're about to dive into that a little bit soon.

[1:02:59] Brianna Jones: Um, don't worry, we're still talking about it.

[1:03:02] Brianna Jones: This episode's not quite over yet.

[1:03:03] Brianna Jones: Um, therefore, the only cheese rating I can give this is Ho Mac and Cheese made with Ho's Your Hill Farm Big Daddy mac and cheese mix.

[1:03:16] Brianna Jones: I didn't make that up.

[1:03:18] Brianna Jones: I don't think I go to Morning Jail.

[1:03:20] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, Horny Joe, here I come.

[1:03:23] Brianna Jones: Daddy, mac and cheese.

[1:03:27] Andrew DeWolf: Just seeing Andrew's face after that was priceless.

[1:03:31] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm, you missed out.

[1:03:33] Andrew DeWolf: You know what?

[1:03:34] Andrew DeWolf: If you were on our Patreon recordings with us, you might have been able to look at that.

[1:03:40] Brianna Jones: Thankfully, Sammy paid us a buttload of money to be here with us.

[1:03:44] Brianna Jones: Um, but I think we've done enough Paul Gordon musicals where Andrew can actually rank them.

[1:03:44] Jess McEnally: Yay!

[1:03:50] Jess McEnally: Oh Lord.

[1:03:51] Jess McEnally: You're ready to make a tier list, buddy!

[1:03:53] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, you're gonna have to remind me which ones he even did.

[1:03:55] Jess McEnally: Okay, okay, let's just start with Daddy Long Legs.

[1:03:57] Jess McEnally: Where do you put that?

[1:03:58] Jess McEnally: And remind people of how your lists go.

[1:04:00] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, so tier list, uh, I just do A, B, C, D.

[1:04:04] Andrew DeWolf: In order A is the best, D is the worst.

[1:04:06] Andrew DeWolf: I don't do any F tier or S tier or whatever for people familiar with tier lists.

[1:04:12] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I'm just doing it very simple.

[1:04:14] Andrew DeWolf: So, uh, also these are in relation to the other shows on the list.

[1:04:19] Andrew DeWolf: This is not in relation to all shows ever.

[1:04:23] Jess McEnally: Um, so, yes.

[1:04:25] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, Daddy Long Legs is going in A.

[1:04:27] Sammi Lopez: Hell yeah, that's a good one.

[1:04:29] Andrew DeWolf: Next up, we're just gonna go backwards.

[1:04:31] Andrew DeWolf: If it went anywhere else, I'd have to fight you.

[1:04:34] Andrew DeWolf: I'm so violently positive about it.

[1:04:39] Jess McEnally: Next up, we have Jane Eyre.

[1:04:42] Andrew DeWolf: Oh boy.

[1:04:43] Andrew DeWolf: Ah, see, Jane Eyre, I don't even remember that well.

[1:04:46] Andrew DeWolf: I'll be fully honest.

[1:04:47] Andrew DeWolf: We just did this.

[1:04:48] Jess McEnally: I know we just did it.

[1:04:50] Andrew DeWolf: That's why I'm like, geez, I don't remember this that well.

[1:04:53] Andrew DeWolf: Like, I, this can't, it couldn't have been that good.

[1:04:56] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I honestly, everything I remember about it, I think I'm actually remembering Rebecca.

[1:05:04] Jess McEnally: He did not do Rebecca.

[1:05:06] Andrew DeWolf: I can tell you that one.

[1:05:07] Jess McEnally: I know he didn't do Rebecca, but I know that the two shows are very similar in tone and story.

[1:05:14] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I'm struggling.

[1:05:15] Andrew DeWolf: I'm gonna put it in C tier and maybe reconsider a second.

[1:05:19] Jess McEnally: Okay, okay, okay.

[1:05:20] Andrew DeWolf: Um, next up we have Pride and Prejudice.

[1:05:23] Andrew DeWolf: I remember thinking this one was okay, if I'm thinking of the right one.

[1:05:27] Sammi Lopez: You probably are.

[1:05:29] Andrew DeWolf: So I'm gonna put that in B.

[1:05:29] Jess McEnally: Cool.

[1:05:32] Andrew DeWolf: And then we have No One Called a Head.

[1:05:35] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, No One Call It Head is going in C, to be honest.

[1:05:39] Sammi Lopez: Ooh, ooh, and that's your list.

[1:05:42] Jess McEnally: That's your list.

[1:05:42] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[1:05:44] Andrew DeWolf: Hey, he hasn't made a bad musical.

[1:05:46] Jess McEnally: You even put some Andrew Lloyd Webber musicals into D.

[1:05:49] Jess McEnally: You even put some Sondheim musicals into D.

[1:05:49] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[1:05:53] Andrew DeWolf: No, I don't think anything deserves a D.

[1:05:53] Andrew DeWolf: No.

[1:05:56] Andrew DeWolf: He still has a lot of musicals.

[1:05:57] Jess McEnally: We need to review his Emma.

[1:05:59] Andrew DeWolf: He did a Estella Scrooge, a Christmas Carol musical.

[1:06:03] Jess McEnally: We could do another Christmas Carol musical, Andrew!

[1:06:05] Andrew DeWolf: I'm totally down.

[1:06:06] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, you know I love a Christmas Carol.

[1:06:08] Andrew DeWolf: Every single adaptation, all 800 billion of them.

[1:06:11] Jess McEnally: Uh, they're all fantastic.

[1:06:13] Jess McEnally: But we all know the best one is the one you and I did randomly in 2018.

[1:06:17] Andrew DeWolf: That was the best one ever.

[1:06:20] Jess McEnally: Yeah, we still have to do another one, but yeah, maybe we'll do an Easter one.

[1:06:24] Jess McEnally: We'll reenact, uh, no, that would probably be bad.

[1:06:29] Andrew DeWolf: I was gonna say, reenact um, the Passover story, the Moses and Pharaoh one, but probably not a good idea.

[1:06:36] Sammi Lopez: Rugrats did it already.

[1:06:37] Andrew DeWolf: We can't rip them off.

[1:06:38] Jess McEnally: Yeah, I don't know if we can do better than the Rugrats.

[1:06:43] Jess McEnally: You know who can definitely do better than the Rugrats though?

[1:06:46] Jess McEnally: Our patrons.

[1:06:47] Jess McEnally: Our wonderful patrons.

[1:06:48] Jess McEnally: Thank you guys for listening.

[1:06:50] Jess McEnally: Um, please follow us on iTunes, Spotify, Stitcher, Musicals with Cheese.

[1:06:53] Jess McEnally: We're on Twitter at Cheesy Musicals, Patreon Musicals with Cheese, Instagram, I said Patreon twice.

[1:06:59] Jess McEnally: YouTube page Musicals for Cheese.

[1:07:01] Jess McEnally: We have a patron-only podcast called Patreon with Cheese.

[1:07:04] Sammi Lopez: How do you like Patreon with Cheese?

[1:07:06] Jess McEnally: How do you like what we do there?

[1:07:07] Sammi Lopez: Um, I think it's great that you make so much extra content for people.

[1:07:11] Sammi Lopez: I haven't really had the chance to peruse a whole lot of it yet, because I'm just, real life is just way too busy for me.

[67:11] Jess McEnally: What?

[1:07:20] Jess McEnally: Having a second podcast entirely on Patreon that you pay money for?

[1:07:24] Sammi Lopez: I'm glad that it's there for me to access at any time that I want.

[1:07:29] Jess McEnally: Over 50 holy new Musicals with Cheese episodes only for the patrons?

[1:07:34] Sammi Lopez: Doesn't that sound good?

[1:07:36] Sammi Lopez: Sounds fantastic.

[1:07:39] Jess McEnally: Um, email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com.

[1:07:42] Jess McEnally: Our title card was created by the amazing Jolene Casco.

[1:07:45] Jess McEnally: Go send them love on Instagram at Jolene Casco.

[1:07:48] Jess McEnally: Our keeper of the cheese is Juliet Antonio.

[1:07:50] Jess McEnally: Thank you for keeping up with that, Juliet, because you are awesome.

[1:07:53] Jess McEnally: This show is produced by the wonderful, the incredible, my best friend in the entire world, Brianna Jones.

[1:07:59] Jess McEnally: Thanks for making the show possible, Bree.

[1:08:02] Brianna Jones: Our theme songs were created by Robin Nash of IOU Music UK.

[1:08:06] Jess McEnally: Thank you to the Broadway Podcast Network for having us on the platform and for not kicking us off for talking about Big Daddy mac and cheese.

[68:06] Jess McEnally: Alright.

[1:08:15] Jess McEnally: Sammy, is there anything you want to promote before we wrap this up?

[1:08:18] Sammi Lopez: Uh, not really.

[1:08:19] Sammi Lopez: I'm more of a lurker than a poster on any social media, so you know, I'll just follow you guys.

[1:08:26] Jess McEnally: Fair enough.

[1:08:27] Jess McEnally: You know what?

[1:08:27] Jess McEnally: Everyone, just be followed by Sammy.

[1:08:30] Jess McEnally: Give me like, just, you know, list your social media out there.

[1:08:35] Jess McEnally: Yeah, just reply to this.

[1:08:35] Jess McEnally: Alright.

[1:08:39] Jess McEnally: We'll see you next time on Musicals with Cheese.

[1:08:50] Sammi Lopez: I'm a beast.

[1:08:52] Sammi Lopez: I'm a burden, Daddy, but I'm not good at being bad.

[1:08:52] Sammi Lopez: Mama.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred