"Come with me and you'll be In a world of pure imagination..." Grab your chocolate and golden ticket because this week we are joined by the hilarious and gracious Pushing Up Roses to talk about the Movie "Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory" and the stage show "Charlie and the Chocolate Factory." This was an all time great episode, and you don't want to miss out on it!.. Read More
From the show: Musicals with Cheese
Guests
Featured Shows
About
"Come with me and you'll be In a world of pure imagination..." Grab your chocolate and golden ticket because this week we are joined by the hilarious and gracious Pushing Up Roses to talk about the Movie "Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory" and the stage show "Charlie and the Chocolate Factory." This was an all time great episode, and you don't want to miss out on it!
Donate to Black Lives Matter here
Social Media:
Musicals with Cheese on Twitter
Musicals W/ Cheese on Instagram
Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com
Jess Socials
Andrew Socials
Brianna Socials
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:10] Jess McInally: Hello, I'm Jesse McInally.
[0:12] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm Andrew DeWolf.
[0:14] Brianna Jones: And I'm Liz Eston.
[0:15] Jess McInally: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, a podcast where I try to get Andrew and Liz to like musical theater. And you guys, we've got a super special guest.
[0:23] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, the most special guest.
[0:24] Brianna Jones: The most of all.
[0:25] Jess McInally: Yes, please join me in welcoming artist, video maker, and Willy Wonka truther, PushingUpRoses.
[0:34] PushingUpRoses: Oh my gosh. Oh my, thank you. Thank you. No autographs. Thank you so much.
[0:40] Jess McInally: How are you doing today? Thank you for joining us.
[0:42] PushingUpRoses: I am doing amazing. Thank you for asking. I'm so excited to be talking about Willy Wonka. When we decided to get together to do this, I looked at all the episodes. I'm like, what can I do that's relevant to me that I love, that I grew up on? And I noticed you guys hadn't done Willy Wonka. I'm like, it's perfect. And I actually love musicals. I don't talk about it very often, but just as an artsy person, I love musicals. Grew up on Rodgers and Hammerstein. Don't know if that's good or bad, but that's where we are. And Willy Wonka was always like a comfort movie to me as a kid. Watched it over and over again, so very excited to talk about it and the stage play, which I am sort of excited to talk about.
[1:29] Jess McInally: Yeah, yeah, yeah. You got the double-edged sword of it because right around when you messaged us and we were working this out, our patron Daniel Smith requested on Patreon that we do the Charlie and the Chocolate Factory stage musical. So I thought this is a brilliant time to torture you and make him happy.
[1:46] PushingUpRoses: I don't even know about it. Maybe I did a little bit. There are certain scenes I saw that went viral, but I don't think I fully understood what it was or where it was coming from. The tone, the tone. But we don't want to dive into that quite yet. For now, we're gonna break this episode into two parts. And right now we're going into the pleasant candy room of the 70s. And right now we're gonna talk about the original 70s Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory.
[2:18] ♪ Musical number: "Pure Imagination" — performed by Gene Wilder ♪
[2:44] Jess McInally: So Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory is a film written by Roald Dahl, technically, with music and lyrics by Leslie Bricusse and Anthony Newley, based on Charlie and the Chocolate Factory by Roald Dahl. The film was released by Paramount Pictures on June 30th, 1971, with a budget of $3 million and only garnering $4 million at the box office. Not really a big hit. However, in the mid-80s, it gained a cult following where it was all over TV and all over the video stores, because that was not something you could find films at at the time. And the plot of Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory is an eccentric candyman Willy Wonka prompts a worldwide frenzy when he announces his golden tickets are hidden inside of five delicious candy bars. Will the lucky holders enter his top-secret confectionary, but does Wonka have an agenda hidden amid the world of Oompa Loompas and Chocolate Rivers?
[3:34] Andrew DeWolf: Alright.
[3:37] Jess McInally: I mean, I wouldn't have phrased it like that.
[3:41] Brianna Jones: Hey, hey, hey, we're not quite there yet.
[3:44] Jess McInally: The secret ingredient.
[3:46] Andrew DeWolf: Oh.
[3:46] Brianna Jones: Soylent Green?
[3:48] Jess McInally: No, it's Augustus Gloop. He's delicious.
[3:51] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[3:51] Jess McInally: The gloop, the gloop busters. So Roses, you were very deeply connected to this film as a child. Andrew, I'm very curious. What was your connection to Willy Wonka as a child?
[4:02] Andrew DeWolf: I watched it like once or twice.
[4:06] Jess McInally: So pretty deep.
[4:08] Andrew DeWolf: Pretty bonded. There's a scene in Malcolm in the Middle that I've seen a lot where they sing the Candyman song. And that's probably my deepest connection to Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory when I was a kid.
[4:21] Jess McInally: You're a deeply emotional man connected to all the facets. What about you, Liz?
[4:26] Brianna Jones: I grew up watching this movie. I'm pretty sure I have a pretty bad memory, but I remember watching it as a kid and I really liked it. Then I watched the Johnny Depp version later, and I didn't like it. So then I watched the 70s version again. It's like, oh, this is actually really good. I actually own a poster of it in my house somewhere.
[4:44] Jess McInally: Nice.
[4:44] Brianna Jones: So I'm very attached to it now. I've seen it a few times as an adult.
[4:48] Jess McInally: It is a good film that ages, it gets better as you grow up. I feel like it's one of those things that doesn't quite stagnate. Like I feel like a lot of our kids' movies, especially in our generation, don't tend to age that well. Like even the Johnny Depp one, like literally a kid screams the R slur several times.
[5:04] Brianna Jones: Oh my god, I forgot about that.
[5:06] Jess McInally: No.
[5:07] Brianna Jones: Like the timelessness of that movie doesn't exist.
[5:11] Jess McInally: Yeah, right.
[5:12] Andrew DeWolf: But yeah.
[5:13] Brianna Jones: That's real. That's in the movie.
[5:15] Jess McInally: Yeah, he says, like, Mike TV hacked the system, and he's like, "Oh, it's Mike TV. An R slur could do this." And I'm like, ugh. Because I watched all of the versions to prepare for this.
[5:25] PushingUpRoses: And I have never seen that one in mine.
[5:29] Jess McInally: I don't think you don't have to. Don't feel like you need to. Don't feel like you need to watch it.
[5:35] Andrew DeWolf: Production design-wise, great. Everything else.
[5:38] Jess McInally: So this was a deep childhood memory for me as well, much like you, Roses. What was the first time you watched it? Like, was it on TV, were you shown it by your parents, or did you discover it?
[5:48] PushingUpRoses: It was I was at my aunt's house. I was always at my aunt's house. I had a favorite aunt, and she loved musicals, as did my dad. My father has since passed, but they grew up on musicals. And there were like three movies in rotation that would play when I spent the night at her place. You know, my parents would need a night out or whatever. Go to Aunt Carol's house, we're gonna watch some musicals, and that was Willy Wonka, The Sound of Music, and Mary Poppins. Those were on rotation. They were my favorite things in the world. But Willy Wonka was something special to me because it, unlike the other musicals, this seemed more substance. There was a lot of dialogue. It seemed to have more meaning to me.
There was like a serious nature to it, especially with Gene Wilder playing this version of Willy Wonka. So I was a very introspective child grown into a got the introspective adult. And like it, I just really like that poetic nature of Willy Wonka. So I liked it as a kid. I appreciated more as an adult. Because I think as a kid, you connect with the golden ticket winners, because they're children. You connect with Charlie. But then as an adult, I connect with like this melancholic Willy Wonka that Gene Wilder plays, you know.
[6:55] Jess McInally: He is. He's like really wistfully melancholy. I think that's the best way to describe Gene Wilder, and that's a good transition to talk about that performance, which I think if you had gotten that even a tiny hair incorrectly, the film doesn't work at all. And he's just picture perfect. We'll talk a lot about how performance dictates whether or not a Willy Wonka makes.
[7:18] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[7:19] Jess McInally: But Gene Wilder is he's like a raunchier side of comedian, like at the time. It was a different choice. I feel like most people will have kind of thought like a kid's show host, and Gene Wilder was just kind of an offbeat comedian. So it's interesting to think about how that could have gone wrong. And it's different from the book where he's described as like bearded. He kind of looks like Andrew. Andrew is the description of Willy Wonka in the book. Just the top hat, the beard, like a little like calm, like introspective hobbit is the best way to describe him in the book. Where Gene Wilder comes in like goofy, haired all over. He's like, you know what? I'm gonna read some poetry at these people and murder some children, maybe.
But I feel like the thing that ages best about the film is the stuff before the golden ticket. Because I don't know if this happened to you, Roses. A lot of people around my age. My parents called me in as soon as like they were entering the factory. So I never got like the golden ticket side of the story. I just got the Yeah, we're in the factory, let's have some fun.
[8:22] PushingUpRoses: Yeah.
[8:23] Andrew DeWolf: You skip half the movies? Your parents are like this building. We'll protect you.
[8:27] Jess McInally: So I was like four, so I remember it very clearly being very, very small. And my mom was like, All right, come on into this. You'll like this, I promise. And then she sat me down, and of course I liked it.
[8:37] Andrew DeWolf: But this is the part where all the kids die. You'll love this part.
[8:40] Jess McInally: Well, the tunnel scene is like the specific. I mean, let's talk about all five children. Who wins the first one? I think it's Augustus Gloop. Am I right?
[8:52] Andrew DeWolf: Augustus is the first one. Yeah.
[8:54] Jess McInally: What do you think of Augustus?
[8:56] PushingUpRoses: Oh man. What a weird character. And that's part of the thing. That's part of the movie that I thought and book that didn't age very well. Why are we making fun of this like bigger child? It's a little strange, right? It's just a little bit bizarre to me. I like Augustus in theory. I'm not sure I've ever liked Augustus in execution in any version.
[9:18] Andrew DeWolf: In any version. I feel the most bad for him. He just likes chocolate. He's just hungry, man. Like, just give the kids some chocolate. He's a kid. Chocolate tour. Like, I mean, yeah. But by all theories, he should be the one that gets the factory. There's another podcast on this network called The Wrong Cat Died about like how Grizabella shouldn't be the one chosen at the end of Cats. There should be like Augustus should have gotten the factory. He should have won the golden ticket. No one knows more about chocolate and what kids want than him.
[9:48] PushingUpRoses: I don't know about that. No, he probably would have eaten all the product. It would have been bad. Charlie got it because he liked chocolate. I don't know.
[10:02] Andrew DeWolf: We can't deal with that.
[10:02] Jess McInally: Yeah. Augustus. Do they do they die in the order they get it? Is this like final destination rules?
[10:07] Brianna Jones: Oh, that's a good question.
[10:09] Andrew DeWolf: No, no, that's not true. Because Veruca's next.
[10:12] Jess McInally: Mm-hmm. Okay. But I do want to hold on Augustus just a moment longer because it does extend to like the greater Roald Dahl Pantheon, where of how Roald Dahl like thinks of bigger people. Like there's also Bruce in Matilda and Spongebob is described bigger. I don't quite know what he has to say, but he definitely has like these opinions on gluttony that I'm like, eh.
[10:35] PushingUpRoses: Yeah, I think he's definitely conflating it with greed. You're just you're just blindly, you know, for Augustus, just blindly eating whatever you can, and it's not necessarily his body that is the problem, it's the unthoughtful greed, I guess, that goes into it.
[10:51] Andrew DeWolf: He already has a different character for greed, though. So it's like that's true.
[10:54] Jess McInally: Yeah, that's true. I mean, what does he exist? Just the rhyme nincompoop. Greedy, foul, and infantile.
[11:00] PushingUpRoses: Yeah, yeah. Well, I think he also wanted to make fun of Germans.
[11:04] Andrew DeWolf: Sure to seem like it, right?
[11:07] Brianna Jones: I mean, were we coming out of a war?
[11:11] Jess McInally: I mean, I'm just saying.
[11:12] Brianna Jones: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
[11:13] Jess McInally: You know what? We've hit the head. But let's move on to Veruca. What do you think of her?
[11:19] PushingUpRoses: She's my favorite of the sour golden ticket winners. And that might be I might be a little biased there because I think the actress does a fantastic job in her role. She's so talented. Just she's so perfect at playing this dominating child in her parents' life. With the mom being like, oh, whatever, who cares? Just give her. She's gonna be mad if you don't give her a thing, and the dad just being like beleaguered and like I have to give her the thing. And I think at the very least, even I think maybe Augustus wasn't executed well, but I do think the greediness of Veruca was was good because they brought in the parents. They're saying, the parents, you're you're not disciplining your kid. She's getting extremely spoiled. Now she thinks she can rule the world. So I think that kind of greed at least was executed better than the gluttony of Augustus, who just wanted chocolate. That's all he wanted.
[12:11] Andrew DeWolf: He wanted chocolate on a chocolate tour. You're getting a tour of a chocolate factory. And you know, even the problem, really is that you can eat anything. Like these kids are bursting open these balls and looking the inside. Why can't I drink the river? Also, why didn't he why won't Wonka put a fence around the river?
[12:27] Brianna Jones: Yeah, candy little fence. Yeah. Just like, what are you doing?
[12:30] Jess McInally: He wasn't prepared. Let's let's be honest. Was Wonka really prepared to see the channel? I mean, the chocolate was watery. I'll give him that.
[12:36] Andrew DeWolf: I think Wonka was extremely prepared, actually. All of these murders were planned. Empty seats on the boat. I'm just saying.
[12:51] Brianna Jones: Oh no!
[12:53] Andrew DeWolf: He's right!
[12:56] Jess McInally: But I do want to talk about how Veruca is the only one of the kids in the musical outside of Charlie, because he doesn't count that gets their own song.
[13:04] PushingUpRoses: It's true. Yeah, that's true. I'm trying to think. Yeah, she gets her own song. Mike TV doesn't sing. Augustus is barely there. Poor guy.
[13:13] Jess McInally: She is the only one that has more need than Charlie. That's so much that they have to sing.
[13:18] PushingUpRoses: Yeah, wow. You know, I don't think I ever clocked that before. And I do wonder if that's just because her character was just very larger than life. I remember even as a kid, I was slightly bored by Mike TV, slightly bored by Mike T.
[13:31] Andrew DeWolf: Mike TV is lame.
[13:33] PushingUpRoses: Yeah, and but Veruca, like she's dressed in this bright red, you know, this bright red dress. Her voice is louder than larger than life. So I'm just wondering if they're kind of playing to the actress's strengths there. I think that her song is great. I want it now. Brie plays some clips of this.
[14:14] Jess McInally: So that song, like it is the shot in the arm that you kinda need because it follows one of the more like crazy, like I frustrating scenes, which is the busy lifting drink scene, which always just gave me pure anxiety when I was younger.
[14:30] Andrew DeWolf: Well, they're gonna go into that fan.
[14:32] Brianna Jones: Yeah.
[14:33] Jess McInally: Oh, there's all these bubbles. Not to hide the wires or anything, just because there's fun to have bubbles.
[14:41] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.
[14:42] Jess McInally: But so that song always like stuck it with me. It's like, oh thank gosh, we're back to it. We're back, we're back to the fun musical numbers.
[14:50] PushingUpRoses: But finally, someone will actually die. And just like pure destruction in that whole scene. There is a scene that I always that always stands out to me from the actress. It's been Veruka saying she wants all this stuff and she doesn't want to share him, and she has a little moment where she's kind of shaking and going a little a little nuts, and then right back into eloquent, like soft voice. I'm like, that's brilliant. That is talent right there. What a good cast. You know, I will say she's probably the one that has the most to do as an actress among the kids. Like even Charlie, he kinda like has three notes and he hits them fine, where she's like got all these small minute things of how she's supposed to play things, and she exceeds at all of them.
[15:32] Jess McInally: Yeah, agreed. Agreed. Um, yeah, 10 out of 10. What do we think of her come up in? Did she deserve to go into the furnace and be marked a bad egg?
[15:40] PushingUpRoses: Oh, I certainly think she deserves something. I don't know if she deserved to be incinerated. I don't know if anyone deserves to be incinerated.
[15:48] Jess McInally: Good choice. If anyone deserved it, it was her.
[15:51] PushingUpRoses: Oh god. Really? Mike TV was like watching race's stuff and pull he brought a gun to the factory.
[16:00] Jess McInally: Yeah, I mean Mike TV, he gets stepped on later by his mom.
[16:03] PushingUpRoses: What?
[16:05] Jess McInally: It's true, because he shrinks in the TV room and then Mike's mom accidentally steps on him.
[16:10] PushingUpRoses: Really?
[16:11] Jess McInally: Yeah.
[16:12] PushingUpRoses: Did that happen in the movie?
[16:13] Jess McInally: Not in the movie.
[16:14] PushingUpRoses: I think was that a book?
[16:15] Jess McInally: No. This is fanfiction that I wrote.
[16:17] PushingUpRoses: It sounds accurate. I'm guessing. I was very intrigued.
[16:25] Jess McInally: No, no, I don't. I mean, in my head, all of these kids do die.
[16:29] PushingUpRoses: Oh.
[16:30] Jess McInally: Like, I uh honestly, I don't how do you survive any? Like one of them turns into a blueberry.
[16:35] PushingUpRoses: Well, you get juice. You just get the juice pushed out. It's very normal. Um in the incinerator, you know, that's only on Tuesdays and Thursdays.
[16:45] Jess McInally: Every other or whatever. So she's a big thing. But the fall though. Ah, well, you know. Um, I do want to bring up one of the things that the Tim Burton movie goes out of their way to show is that all the kids live. And she's like all bendy now, and that's but even though she's blue and that's I think is a little more horrific. It's like you see how now they're deformed for life. You have to like live with the consequences of what you've done.
[17:11] PushingUpRoses: Yeah. It's like maybe it's maybe it's better. I don't know, but I prefer not seeing it. And in the original movie, Wonka just says they're all restored to their normal, terrible selves.
[17:23] Jess McInally: And in the depth film, yeah, they're just deformed forever. I think we assume Gene Wilder was lying. It's like, yeah, he was lying. He's not gonna tell Charlie. Oh no, they're dead. I merged your cohorts.
[17:38] PushingUpRoses: Wait till we get to the Broadway version, though. I can't wait.
[17:43] Jess McInally: Well, we got two more kids to go through. So next we got Violet Beauregard.
[17:47] PushingUpRoses: Before we get to Vrook, I have just one thing to add. I'm on the Wikipedia page for Charlie and the Chocolate Factory characters, and there's a paragraph dedicated to the Tom and Jerry version only in Veruca's section.
[17:57] Jess McInally: Oh.
[17:58] PushingUpRoses: And no one else is because she has her own song.
[18:01] Jess McInally: Yeah. Um, I have not watched Tom and Jerry was or I have watched that one. We have watched Tom and Jerry Wizards on the YouTube channel. Um, yes, um, I have not watched the Willy Wonka because I love myself.
[18:13] Jess McInally: I love that for you. Is it one of the ones where Tom and Jerry are just like there?
[18:18] PushingUpRoses: Yes. Like the Wizard of Oz one, where they're just like, why is Tom and Jerry here?
[18:22] Jess McInally: Well, fun fact, they give Slugworth a lot more to do in the Tom and Jerry Wizard of Oz special. And I know for a fact he sings I want it now, but to Tom and Jerry.
[18:30] PushingUpRoses: That's weird. Do Tom and Jerry get the golden is or does Charlie get it?
[18:35] Jess McInally: Um there's an Oompa Loompa played by the little annoying one.
[18:39] PushingUpRoses: The what?
[18:40] Jess McInally: You know the annoying one that talks to Tom and Jerry?
[18:44] PushingUpRoses: The little mouse, and they let them in.
[18:46] Jess McInally: Oh, like the white mouse?
[18:49] PushingUpRoses: Yeah, that one.
[18:50] Jess McInally: The smaller one.
[18:51] PushingUpRoses: Yeah, the one that can't shut up. Yeah, I know who you're talking about.
[18:54] Jess McInally: And it's played by Phil and Lil from Rugrats, and they're like, Come on, Tom and Jerry, we gotta go into the factory.
[19:01] PushingUpRoses: What? I love myself. I didn't watch it. I'm giving you as much context as I can.
[19:06] Jess McInally: I can't wait to watch this with you, Jess.
[19:08] PushingUpRoses: Yeah, it'll be on the Patreon eventually.
[19:11] Jess McInally: I'll join you.
[19:12] PushingUpRoses: Yeah, it'll be a blast. Um, so let's move on. Violet Beauregard. Um, I love her father in the movie. Her father is probably my favorite person in the entire movie.
[19:23] Jess McInally: He's a car salesman, right?
[19:25] PushingUpRoses: Dan B, it's a guarantee. I always like as a kid, I always felt confused at Violet. I'm like, I didn't get any any symbolism that may have been there by the author. I'm just like, okay, she likes gum. Cool.
[19:39] Jess McInally: Yeah, that's kind of how I feel.
[19:41] PushingUpRoses: Yeah, just not a lot of substance there, uh, to be honest. Other adaptations are trying to make it oh, she's ambitious and competitive, which is bad, which I think the stage musical tries to lean into, and I know the Tim Burton film really leans into.
[19:55] Jess McInally: Um, which is that bad? I don't know. What's wrong with being competitive?
[19:58] PushingUpRoses: I don't know. It it's pro-capitalism. Are they trying to say she's like a poor sport because she steamrolls? I I'm I've never I've never quite understood. Because they have such an emphasis on the gum. And what does that even symbolize? Like if you're an overcompetitive person, right? What is your comeuppance and how does that relate to the gum scene?
[20:17] Jess McInally: Blueberry.
[20:18] PushingUpRoses: Turn it into a blueberry. It's um that's what needs to happen to Elon Musk. We need to turn him into a blueberry. Then he'll explode when somebody like darts him.
[20:28] Jess McInally: I don't understand where it came from in that regard, but I do think it's a fetish thing.
[20:36] PushingUpRoses: What?
[20:37] Jess McInally: Yeah, no, no, it's pretty sure it's correct. Look up uh Sonic Inflation on DeviantArt. Uh and then watch the Violet Beauregard scene in the world. Liz, you got any similarities. Violet Beauregard rule 34. See if it exists. See if it exists.
[20:53] PushingUpRoses: Are you kidding me? There's like probably hundreds upon hundreds of pages. Do not share a screen. Don't screen share, but I want to know if it exists. Don't look that up. Um she blows up into a big old blueberry and maybe j dies.
[21:08] Jess McInally: Yeah, I don't know. I I think the only thing that kind of showed her true colors prior the gum was just disrespecting the rules and be like, I don't care about your product. I don't care. I'm just gonna do it anyway and kind of disrespect this person. And that's the only thing I saw that she was doing that was like, well, that's that's wrong. He said not to, and you did.
[21:27] PushingUpRoses: Yeah. But I like it when she's just I there's specific relationship stuff here that I love in this movie, like how much she and Varuka hate each other.
[21:36] Jess McInally: Oh from moment one, just the little things that they say to one another is like obviously vitriolic.
[21:42] PushingUpRoses: Yeah, oh yeah. There's so much rule 34 of Violet Beauregard.
[21:46] Jess McInally: Oh my god. So many well, they're really Wonka characters. Take your choice.
[21:51] PushingUpRoses: No Balumpas. Probably. I didn't scroll past any and the first three lines. Well, internet, you're welcome for that. Liz Eston has fallen on that sword for you. You're welcome, internet.
[22:09] Jess McInally: She picks her nose and then critiques spitting.
[22:12] PushingUpRoses: She picks her nose. Charlie breaks the rules too, though. I mean, you're just talking about the screen.
[22:16] Jess McInally: Yeah. Well, that is one of the things added only for the movie. The fizzy lifting drink scene. Now we still got one more kid we gotta talk about, but let's talk about the Charlie of it all now. Um Charlie Charlie didn't deserve the golden ticket in the movie.
[22:30] PushingUpRoses: I I'm I'm uh um not the golden ticket, the the prize at the end. I don't think what he did was good enough.
[22:35] Jess McInally: Yeah, that's it's really interesting. Like it it it's definitely way better than the stage play because in the movie at least they have uh slugworth and um they're constantly kind of tempting him. I do feel like they do constantly tempt him in the beginning of the movie. And maybe that's just good enough, Brawonka. Maybe he just needs to see a pure child who can redeem themselves, even if they did break the rules. He is a kid. You know, he's a kid. He's gonna break some rules probably, but if he shows he's pure of heart, I guess that's good enough.
[23:06] PushingUpRoses: So I I do like Charlie. I don't know if he deserved or is even good. Like I don't know. How is he just gonna handle this entire factory with all of his old grandparents? Like it seems a little strange. But I did like him. He seemed pure enough.
[23:20] Jess McInally: I think he did deserve it. I'm just yeah, I I gotta know where you're coming from, Jess.
[23:26] PushingUpRoses: Just by being the final girl, he deserves a factory. We're not giving Lori Strode a chocolate factory for not getting killed by Michael Myers.
[23:33] Jess McInally: But we're giving her like multiple sequels. I don't know. I think it's I think it's fine. I think Charlie's a good, a good kid who has an imagination, and that's what matters.
[23:42] PushingUpRoses: That's what we learned.
[23:43] Jess McInally: Yeah, I'd agree with that. And I also think is is it even about worth? Or is it about just you you are somebody who's been down on their luck, impoverished, and you come into this and you kind of you you deserve it just for those reasons. You deserve to have something good. Um, so maybe it's kind of more of a Cinderella tale in that way, you know, where you come up in this terrible situation, and whether you deserve it or not, here it is. You know, you got it. It's also probably a dream. I mean, the whole thing. Jacob's ladder style. He died in the fizzy lifting drinks room. Come on, he gets a golden ticket, he gets a golden ticket, he buys a single chocolate bar and he gets the golden ticket. Come on.
[24:19] PushingUpRoses: He knows he's imagining it all.
[24:21] Jess McInally: I thought he finds the golden ticket in like a grate.
[24:24] PushingUpRoses: No, he finds the money for the chocolate in the grate.
[24:27] Jess McInally: Right, right. I'm okay, right. That's correct. And he gets that's his second bar, I think.
[24:31] PushingUpRoses: Right, right. Okay, so it is the interesting thing. Alright. I I pitched this to Andrew earlier, and I need to pitch it to you now, Roses.
[24:37] PushingUpRoses: Okay.
[24:37] Jess McInally: So Charlie is fairly selfless throughout the first half of the movie. The one time he performs a greedy action, he gets rewarded with the golden ticket. What does that say?
[24:51] PushingUpRoses: Selfishness is the greatest virtue.
[24:51] Jess McInally: I mean, that's obviously the moral. Just be selfish.
[24:56] PushingUpRoses: Yeah. Get what you want. Just get it.
[24:58] Jess McInally: Mixed messages coming from the show. Raldal did not have a full message in mind, I don't think.
[25:04] PushingUpRoses: Maybe not. And I I don't know if I watched Willy Wonka thinking there was a full message there. You know, it's just kind of like this nice story about a kid who gets every as Willy Wonka says, gets everything he wants. And whether it was deserved or not, it's it's nice to see somebody who is impoverished get something.
[25:22] Jess McInally: I agree. So I'm not sure if there's a message. I think he tried. Like with the greed and like the gluttony tried, but I don't know if there is a deeper message than just a really sweet kid getting something nice from an eccentric old man. And that's the story. I like that story.
[25:38] PushingUpRoses: Um, if you want me to say anything, the only bad thing about Charlie is his grandfather. His grandfather is the devil and constantly influencing his worst decisions.
[25:47] Jess McInally: That's true.
[25:48] PushingUpRoses: I hard, hard disagree.
[25:50] Jess McInally: Oh my gosh.
[25:52] PushingUpRoses: I don't agree. Grandpa Joe is totally fine. Did nothing wrong. Actually, the best character is.
[25:57] Jess McInally: I am very against the Twitter rhetoric that Grandpa Joe caused all the problems.
[26:00] PushingUpRoses: Grandpa Joe did cause all the problems.
[26:03] Jess McInally: Are we in a war right now with Liz and Andrew versus Jess and Roses? Because I'll fight them to death.
[26:07] PushingUpRoses: Grandpa Joe did nothing wrong.
[26:10] Jess McInally: I don't, he was supportive of Charlie the whole time. He bought him a chocolate bar with his meager funds just to make him happy. Kept it warm under his ass the entire day.
[26:21] PushingUpRoses: He can't get up. What are you gonna do? Melted by my ass folds, Charlie. Open it up.
[26:27] Jess McInally: That bothered me as a kid. He like pulls it from underneath his butt that he's been sitting on all day. And then he's like, I need tobacco. I don't get out of the house or do anything, but I need tobacco.
[26:42] PushingUpRoses: Oh, what are we were we shaming him for being lazy now? Like, what is this? What is this? Augustus Gloop? Is this a good one?
[26:47] Jess McInally: We have another situation. He's 61 if he's limbing and he's been out there. Like, what are we doing? He hasn't been out of bed in 20 years at age 61.
[26:56] PushingUpRoses: What is the wife's out there not doing anything? His wife is in bed.
[26:59] Jess McInally: Yeah, they're all in bed. They're all in bed together.
[27:02] PushingUpRoses: And the gramps learned orange. You're right. They're all laying in bed because they can't get out of bed.
[27:08] Jess McInally: Yeah, they're old. And then he can get out of bed in Charlie's dream as soon as it helps him financially give him a few.
[27:19] PushingUpRoses: I don't like this commentary on old people that can't get out of bed. Like, what is that? They're not that old.
[27:25] Jess McInally: Yeah, they're like 60. And he said he hadn't been able to get up in 20 years.
[27:30] PushingUpRoses: I don't know why that bothers me. We are just gonna like crumple when we turn 40. That's it, man. I feel like he has like polio or something.
[27:41] Jess McInally: There could be something going on here. Like, we don't know the whole story of his grandparents.
[27:46] PushingUpRoses: All four of them.
[27:48] Jess McInally: I got it from Georgina and she got it from George, and uh it all kind of spread. I mean, don't sleep in the same bed with the biggest.
[27:55] PushingUpRoses: What if he used to work in a coal mine or something and he broke his legs? Like, I don't we don't know what's going on there. You know what, Andrew? You're right. It's pretty cruel for you to assume malice. Because an old man lays in bed all day.
[28:10] Jess McInally: Okay, okay. Here's a pitch of a question for you guys. If Charlie's mom had gone with Charlie, do you think they would have still done the fizzy lifting drinks?
[28:18] PushingUpRoses: No.
[28:18] Jess McInally: Nope.
[28:20] PushingUpRoses: There's a lot of people.
[28:20] Jess McInally: Charlie told Charlie. I don't think I think he already had the lesson. My favorite part is Grandpa George Joe being like, We're gonna give that to Slugworth. Come on, Charlie. Let's make some money.
[28:31] PushingUpRoses: That oh, he is the worst.
[28:35] Jess McInally: You're so right. I I will I will say the right decision though. They're poor. Willy Wonka just murdered five children in front of you.
[28:45] PushingUpRoses: And like, what do you have to go to the police? Please shut up for a second, Rose is what we were trying to say. I like I no, I like this narrative. I was just gonna say, I like despite that, um, I still think Grandpa Joe has one of the best songs in the movie. It's very fun. Yeah. I like singing it. I just watched it the other day and was like belting it out. And when he's, you know, learning to walk with Charlie. Golden ticket, I think it's just called I Got a Golden Ticket.
[29:10] PushingUpRoses: Yeah. Um But that being said, he is crotchety. He doesn't like anyone. He enables Charlie to do terrible things. Not the best. Not the best. I'd say we might know something about him and his wife, but she doesn't wasn't allowed to have any lines, so.
[29:24] Jess McInally: Oh, you're right. Even Georgina got a line.
[29:38] Andrew DeWolf: Let the boy work. He stands up for him against Willy Wonka as well. He's like, what the heck? We did all the whole thing. You're not gonna give us the prize, anyways? Like, you know what he should have done? Hey, Mr. Wonka, I told him to do it. That was my bad. Can you please give the kid another? That's what a real great one. It wouldn't have mattered though. Willy Wonka wouldn't have given him the prize, anyways, because that's not the point. The real test was the slug word thing.
[30:02] PushingUpRoses: True. That's true. Yeah, and Charlie's the only one pure-hearted enough in the whole story to see that. Which is why Grandpa Joe has to be against him on that one.
[30:12] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, yeah, yeah. We still have to talk about Mike TV, though.
[30:16] PushingUpRoses: Okay, Mike TV is just awful in every version. In every version. It'd be kind of fine if they just cut him like entirely. I love the TV remote. That's such a fun idea.
[30:25] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, yeah, it is a fun idea. I like as a kid, I'm like, that's interesting. Look at all the specs on the screen. Wow. Like as a kid, I'm just like very fascinated. Never understood how it's supposed to work, though.
[30:37] PushingUpRoses: It's nothing. You can't reach into a television. Hold on, I'm gonna just touch you real quick, Andrew. That's the Broadway version. I love that they couldn't quite figure it out either, so they just had them reach into the side of the TV.
[30:48] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, like brilliant. It's like what? That's what? Yeah, that's like it's clearly not how broadcasting works. Like, we're not put into a million pieces in the atmosphere. Like, that's not at least not like that, not visually. Like, you shouldn't look up and be able to see like little artifacts.
[31:05] PushingUpRoses: That was for the audience. They wouldn't understand the ideas of television. They don't get it. There's little bits of Mike TV, his organs and all that getting re-put together. We gotta rebuild his lungs here, little boy lungs.
[31:19] Andrew DeWolf: Mike TV actually did die, and no matter what version you know. That's like it's like, uh, like when you dissipate like that, you're dead, and then when you come back together, it's like a clone, you know.
[31:29] PushingUpRoses: Oh, it's deep, it's real deep. So, uh, you're saying in every version, he's just a shell, just a clone of his former.
[31:35] Andrew DeWolf: He's like a miniature clone of his former self. Yeah, the real Mike TV is dead.
[31:39] PushingUpRoses: Wow, and you thought that we were gonna stick with like just kind talk here in this Willy Wonka episode. I think Charlie and the Chocolate Factory is fundamentally a horror story of sorts.
[31:52] Andrew DeWolf: It is baby's first slasher movie.
[31:54] PushingUpRoses: Yeah. Yeah, it explains a lot. Um, I kind of like it.
[31:58] Andrew DeWolf: I yeah, I agree. I love it. I think this movie is perfect in a way.
[32:02] PushingUpRoses: Um, production design could be a little better.
[32:05] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it's, I as I watch it as an adult, I'm like worse as well. Like I watched it again just last night, and just seeing like, oh, that's just custard thrown onto like paper mache, and that's just a blown-up balloon. Okay. In some warehouse with like industrial looking tubing and like it looks like an athletic center gym because it just has like those windows.
[32:28] Jess McInally: Jess, do you think you'd be improved if there was no set at all?
[32:32] PushingUpRoses: No, no, I don't. Um, I didn't try to adapt this to Broadway, so I'm not that galaxy-brained. But as that's the one room that I feel like aged badly. The other ones feel okay.
[32:47] Andrew DeWolf: Like I kind of like the inventing room and how kind of shitty 70s that looks. Like that works for me.
[32:51] PushingUpRoses: I always wanted to try like the weird tomato concoction he was making up there.
[32:56] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, yeah, I like that. I like the invention room. I liked the weird like, um, shrinking room. I liked the coat hangers that are just hands as a kid. I'm like, oh, it's so scary.
[33:07] PushingUpRoses: John Cocteau hands reaching out. Um, yeah, that I feel like the candy part itself is a little underwhelming, just because you can tell what is fake. And they're just clearly those are just bouncing balloons with maybe chocolate in them. I'm not sure what they're eating.
[33:24] Andrew DeWolf: Um, but I do like it. I do, I thought they could have done a lot better for the stage. There are a lot of points where there was like just nothing. So at least the movie has a setting. At least it's trying.
[33:35] PushingUpRoses: Yeah. Well, we should talk about the scene that defined a lot of people's experience with this film. The boat scene.
[33:41] Andrew DeWolf: Oh my god. Um, I love the boat scene. I love the boat scene so much. Roses, you watched this young like me. What was your reaction the first time you saw that boat scene?
[33:52] PushingUpRoses: I need you all to understand that as a kid, I was scared of everything. Like the I did a 180 in my teens, like after my dad died, I decided I was the most badass person on the planet, got a bunch of piercings and tattoos, and changed my whole perspective. Prior to that, everything scared me. I couldn't even go to Chuck E. Cheese and ride 75% of the rides. They were terrifying to me. So this boat scene legit gave me insane nightmares.
[34:24] Andrew DeWolf: And not even just for those watching, I hope you know what scene what this entails, but there's a scene with like a chicken getting its head cut off. And that didn't bother me as much as like that snake repeat. Do you know what I'm talking about? Going over the nose.
[34:39] PushingUpRoses: Uh, I could not watch it. I had to fast forward through it as a kid. As an adult, I think it's just the most artistic, amazing, like demented thing I've ever seen, and I adore it. And I adore Gene Wilder being very creepy and just spewing nonsense. I swear to God, next time I'm on an airplane and I know the pilot, I just want to get on there and do the Willy Wonka speech. Just no context, see what happens.
[35:08] Andrew DeWolf: Um, what is your favorite image from it, Andrew? Because I know you love this scene.
[35:12] Andrew DeWolf: I honestly, I just like the whole thing as a whole. I just like the, um, I just like the speech, honestly. That's my favorite part. I just like how obvious it is it's not moving. Like that's just talking there. Stop moving. Stationary, the Oompa Loompas are going, but they're not going anywhere. They're just in front of a screen projecting things.
[35:31] PushingUpRoses: Like my favorite thing are just the cutaways to the adults. Like the secret ingredient to this movie is really Mrs. TV. She is probably like my favorite character. Somebody's touching me!
[35:45] Andrew DeWolf: She's so like cranky and like just frustrated. I love her. I love Mrs. Mike TV. But my favorite moment with her is what's Charlie's reaction to all of it. He's like he's very freaked out. Uh, I'm watching it right now on mute. Um, he's freaked out, but like there's a part where like, uh, Slugworth comes on, and that's what freaks him out the most.
[36:09] PushingUpRoses: He's like, oh my god, there's the guy.
[36:11] Andrew DeWolf: And like less than a minute later, there's a lizard eating something, and he's like, I fly.
[36:15] PushingUpRoses: Yeah.
[36:16] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, that's fine, but slug. Starts pointing it at the wall. So unhinged. I just how it starts with Violet going like, what is this? A freak out? A freak out? What a 70s thing to say. Like late 60s, early 70s thing to say. Freak out.
[36:38] PushingUpRoses: Oh my gosh. Well, let's talk about some of the most famous songs in the world, real quick. Um, Candyman, iconic opening number. No way you could ruin that. Um, but can you?
[36:50] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, yes. We're foreshadowing there. Um, you brought up I've got a golden ticket. I love that song so much as well. Um, there's a few near misses with an upskirt shot of Grandpa that makes that a little anxiety-inducing for me.
[37:05] PushingUpRoses: I wish they had gotten a little closer.
[37:07] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, yeah. I'm like, man, we were missing the good stuff. Show off them legs, they're working again, and he's all about it. The peaks and his legs look they look pretty good for being in bed for 20 years.
[37:17] PushingUpRoses: Yeah, yeah. He got the moves. And then basically, outside of pure imagination of, uh, and I, uh, want it now, it's just reprises of, uh, the Oompa Loompa song. Oh, and Cheer Up Charlie.
[37:27] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, there is an idea going around more recently, Roses, that people just always skipped over that song and the entire scene where he's like, Mom, why why won't I get it? She's like, Cause you're not good enough, Charlie. Did you like that scene as a kid?
[37:42] PushingUpRoses: I did. Because, uh, as I said, I was very introspective. I'm like, oh my god, I'm so dark and poetic, and I can relate to this, even though I could not relate to that. There was just something about the sadness of it that I was like kind of drawn to.
[37:56] Andrew DeWolf: And there are still people in my life today, like I watched it with my roommate, and he's like, I hate this song. Let's fast forward. I'm like, this is an important thing. He's thinking about his life, and we should watch it.
[38:08] PushingUpRoses: Uh, I don't yeah, I never skipped it. I skipped, what would I say? Skip the boat scene.
[38:12] Andrew DeWolf: That's what I skipped as a kid.
[38:14] PushingUpRoses: You can't skip the boat scene.
[38:15] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Um, what did you think about Cheer Up Charlie, Andrew?
[38:18] Andrew DeWolf: Um, yeah, I don't remember it.
[38:20] PushingUpRoses: So you must have skipped it the entire like unmemorable.
[38:24] Andrew DeWolf: I think the scene's really good, but I think it really does a good job of showing off Jeremy cause UK stand or wherever they are in this movie.
[38:32] PushingUpRoses: Because they have American accents, but it's very European wherever they're living.
[38:36] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Is it is this like his mom sings this song?
[38:39] PushingUpRoses: Yeah. His mom, yeah.
[38:40] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. His mom is a character for like the first half and then just disappears and never comes back.
[38:45] PushingUpRoses: Yeah. Which is kind of weird. Well, his dad was a character in the book, but then they just kill him. They he they did put him in the depth version, which is nice. And the West End version of the musical, but then they're like, nah, gotta kill him. Gotta kill him for Broadway.
[39:00] Andrew DeWolf: Gotta make it more tragic.
[39:01] PushingUpRoses: It's more sad if he has one dead parent.
[39:03] Andrew DeWolf: Um, all right. It's time for our favorite part of the show. It's time where we compare our opinions to those of the insane people over on letterbox.com. It's time for breviews.
[39:16] PushingUpRoses: It's Tom for the reason. It's Tom for previews.
[39:23] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, Roses. Are you aware of how this works?
[39:26] PushingUpRoses: No, but I'm very excited right now.
[39:29] Andrew DeWolf: Alrighty. So this is called One Star Five Star, where Liz and I are gonna read reviews to you and Andrew going head to head, and you have to guess whether the full review on Letterboxd.com, and we did not make any of these up, is a one-star review or a five-star review. This game is deceptively difficult.
[39:46] PushingUpRoses: Okay, I'm so excited. I am so ready. There's gotta be a lot of good ones for this one.
[39:51] Andrew DeWolf: There is. Liz, whose team do you want to be on?
[39:53] PushingUpRoses: Uh, I'll be with Roses.
[39:55] Andrew DeWolf: Hell yeah. Alright, you go first, Liz.
[39:58] Brianna Jones: Alrighty then. Let's kick this off. This film is just midsummer with children.
[40:04] PushingUpRoses: Is that the whole thing?
[40:06] Brianna Jones: That's the entire review. It's one sentence.
[40:08] PushingUpRoses: I'm gonna you know what? It's it already sounds unhinged, so I'm gonna go five star.
[40:13] Brianna Jones: That is correct.
[40:14] Andrew DeWolf: Hell yeah. Is that even true? I haven't seen Midsummer yet.
[40:18] PushingUpRoses: It's not untrue. It's Wicker Man with a lady.
[40:22] Andrew DeWolf: I like Wicker Man and the ladies, so it's like perfect.
[40:26] Brianna Jones: Yeah, but Wicker Man is nothing like in the chocolate family. Midsummer, I get where they're coming from. It's culty, but people do get picked off one by one in a similar way. But that's like the only comparison.
[40:38] Andrew DeWolf: Um reviewer. It's very bright. They tried. And Florence Pugh does add a bunch.
[40:44] Brianna Jones: Alright, Andrew, you ready?
[40:46] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[40:47] Brianna Jones: Um, Hello, naughty children. It's murder time. All in caps.
[40:51] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, five stars.
[40:54] Brianna Jones: That is correct.
[40:55] Andrew DeWolf: Well, yeah. I mean, I wrote that one.
[41:00] Brianna Jones: Andrew has like 15 alternate letterbox accounts.
[41:02] Andrew DeWolf: That's how he wins these.
[41:04] Brianna Jones: That's true. I go in before I'm like, ah, time to write my reviews.
[41:09] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, Liz.
[41:11] Brianna Jones: Alright. Augustus is literally is literally the little German boy ever. Did they watch the whole movie?
[41:20] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, um, I'm gonna I'm gonna have to go with one star.
[41:23] Brianna Jones: That is a five. What?
[41:25] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it doesn't make sense to me. You know what? That's not a five-star review, whoever you are, reviewer.
[41:31] PushingUpRoses: I give you one star.
[41:34] Andrew DeWolf: The review reviewer.
[41:38] PushingUpRoses: I'm the review reviewer, and I'm here to stop you from reviewing this.
[41:42] Andrew DeWolf: Like, did I find this review helpful? No. Thumbs down.
[41:47] Brianna Jones: Isn't the reviewer reviewer a thing that happened?
[41:49] Andrew DeWolf: I'm sure it didn't.
[41:51] Brianna Jones: Alright, Andrew, are you ready?
[41:52] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[41:52] Brianna Jones: Okay, here is the full review. I want Uncle Joe's stash to tickle my lower lady lips.
[42:02] Andrew DeWolf: I remember this one specifically because she calls them Uncle Joe.
[42:02] Brianna Jones: Uncle Joe.
[42:08] Andrew DeWolf: Uncle Joe. Are we projecting? What's going on here, reviewer? Come on. What's wrong with Grandpa Joe? He's too old.
[42:15] PushingUpRoses: G filth. Um, five stars?
[42:22] Andrew DeWolf: That is correct.
[42:23] Brianna Jones: Okay, yeah. I mean, there was a very positive tone to that particular.
[42:28] Andrew DeWolf: They want to rewatch it, I'm betting.
[42:32] Brianna Jones: Oh god. Probably watching it in slow-mo kind of freeze frames a couple times, you know.
[42:36] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, especially during, you know, the I Got a Golden Chicken, like almost upscript shots.
[42:41] Brianna Jones: Yeah.
[42:41] Andrew DeWolf: Willy Wonka rule 34, isn't there?
[42:43] Brianna Jones: Wait, did you write this?
[42:45] Andrew DeWolf: I'll never do.
[42:48] Brianna Jones: Maybe I have 15 alternate letterbox accounts. You don't know.
[42:51] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, Liz, what do we got next?
[42:54] Brianna Jones: Okay. Wonka casually plays a flute.
[43:01] Andrew DeWolf: I love that review, actually. Um, there's gotta be a one-star in here somewhere.
[43:07] Brianna Jones: So just based on statistics and like process of elimination, I'm gonna say it's a one-star.
[43:11] Andrew DeWolf: It's a five star.
[43:12] Brianna Jones: What?
[43:13] Andrew DeWolf: There's gotta, there's gotta be a one-star in here.
[43:15] Brianna Jones: There's no one stars.
[43:17] Andrew DeWolf: Gambler's fallacy doesn't work here.
[44:03] Brianna Jones: Alright, Andrew, are you ready?
[44:03] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[44:03] Brianna Jones: Grandpa Joe could have walked anytime he wanted, yet he chose to stay in bed while his family starved.
[44:03] Andrew DeWolf: It's a one-star.
[44:03] Brianna Jones: You wrote it.
[44:03] Andrew DeWolf: That is a five star, and I did not.
[44:03] Brianna Jones: Or did you?
[44:03] Andrew DeWolf: Man, that reviewer's angry. Can hear it. Grandpa Joe did nothing wrong and is a cool grandpa.
[44:03] Brianna Jones: Alright, Liz.
[44:03] Andrew DeWolf: Alright.
[44:03] Brianna Jones: Oh god. There's like 15 different access in Charlie's town and no explanation for why.
[44:03] Andrew DeWolf: I'm gonna go with five stars.
[44:03] Brianna Jones: It's a one.
[44:03] Andrew DeWolf: What?
[44:03] Brianna Jones: She got her one though!
[44:03] Andrew DeWolf: See statistically, I knew there had to be a one in there somewhere.
[44:03] Brianna Jones: Alright, Andrew, are you ready?
[44:04] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[44:05] Brianna Jones: Can't decide if I hate Grandpa Joe or we're let him hit it.
[44:08] Andrew DeWolf: What is happening with these thirsty Grandpa Joe comments?
[44:12] PushingUpRoses: It was over.
[44:14] Andrew DeWolf: What is happening? Grandpa Joe, you're looking mighty fine over there. Mind if I join you in bed? Room for one more.
[44:30] PushingUpRoses: Oh my god. Um five stars for more Grandpa Joe?
[44:34] Jess McInally: Yes.
[44:37] PushingUpRoses: You gotta get it back.
[44:38] Jess McInally: You gotta get it back.
[44:39] PushingUpRoses: I know.
[44:39] Jess McInally: I'm failing.
[44:40] PushingUpRoses: You're failing.
[44:41] Jess McInally: Roses!
[44:42] PushingUpRoses: I know, I'm so sorry.
[44:43] Jess McInally: It's my fault.
[44:44] PushingUpRoses: I'm bad at this.
[44:45] Jess McInally: This game's hard.
[44:46] PushingUpRoses: This game is much deceptive.
[44:48] Jess McInally: It's very hard, actually.
[44:49] PushingUpRoses: Uh I played it before it was I I lost very very easily.
[44:54] Jess McInally: Alright, I'll do a very simple one.
[44:56] PushingUpRoses: Zaddy Zaddy Wonka.
[44:59] Jess McInally: Zattie won't.
[45:00] PushingUpRoses: Well, that's gotta be a five star.
[45:01] Jess McInally: Yes, it's fine.
[45:03] PushingUpRoses: It's too positive.
[45:04] Jess McInally: We're back to be.
[45:05] PushingUpRoses: All right, Andrew, are you ready?
[45:07] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[45:10] PushingUpRoses: I played Augustus Gloop's mom in a school play.
[45:13] Andrew DeWolf: What's in my favorite?
[45:14] PushingUpRoses: It's the most like nothing part.
[45:15] Andrew DeWolf: You might as well say you played a tree.
[45:24] PushingUpRoses: One star?
[45:25] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know.
[45:31] PushingUpRoses: Damn.
[45:32] Andrew DeWolf: Maybe she had a really negative experience in this school play.
[45:37] PushingUpRoses: She was aiming for, you know, like Violet Beauregard, Charlie's mom comments is glued.
[45:42] Andrew DeWolf: This is gloom.
[45:43] PushingUpRoses: She has like two lines, and one of them's just like, My Augustus!
[45:46] Andrew DeWolf: Save some food for later.
[45:51] PushingUpRoses: My son.
[45:53] Andrew DeWolf: My son, he is dead.
[45:54] PushingUpRoses: He got sucked in the chocolate.
[45:56] Andrew DeWolf: I can't do a German act.
[45:58] PushingUpRoses: He's going to become the gloop.
[46:00] Andrew DeWolf: The gloom chocolate.
[46:02] PushingUpRoses: The new gloop chocolate bar.
[46:05] Andrew DeWolf: Well, maybe if he was better, he wouldn't.
[46:07] PushingUpRoses: Limited.
[46:07] Andrew DeWolf: Limited edition.
[46:09] PushingUpRoses: Alright, Liz.
[46:10] Andrew DeWolf: Wasn't that in the movie?
[46:11] PushingUpRoses: He got sorted into like he got saved because he got sorted into bad chocolate.
[46:15] Andrew DeWolf: I can't remember.
[46:16] PushingUpRoses: I don't remember.
[46:16] Andrew DeWolf: But goes to the fudge room.
[46:19] PushingUpRoses: Yeah, that's yeah, that was there.
[46:21] Andrew DeWolf: It went to the fudge room.
[46:22] PushingUpRoses: Yeah.
[46:22] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, okay.
[46:23] PushingUpRoses: Okay.
[46:23] Andrew DeWolf: I'd let him kill me.
[46:25] PushingUpRoses: I don't care.
[46:27] Andrew DeWolf: Who Grandpa Joe or I don't is this letterbox or like live journal?
[46:33] PushingUpRoses: Like these people are very thirsty.
[46:35] Andrew DeWolf: Um, let's do five stars.
[46:37] PushingUpRoses: Yes.
[46:38] Jess McInally: Yes.
[46:38] PushingUpRoses: Hell yeah.
[46:39] Jess McInally: Alright, you're getting back in the game, Roses.
[46:41] Andrew DeWolf: All right, Andrew, you ready?
[46:43] PushingUpRoses: Yeah, yeah.
[46:44] Andrew DeWolf: This movie is like a fart.
[46:45] PushingUpRoses: You think it's gonna be silent, but when you let it rip, you just shit yourself.
[46:49] Andrew DeWolf: The song slap them.
[46:50] PushingUpRoses: What they thought they had something there when they wrote that.
[46:57] Andrew DeWolf: It doesn't make any fucking sense.
[47:01] PushingUpRoses: What do you know?
[47:01] Andrew DeWolf: The movie's like a fart that you think is gonna be silent, but when you let it rip, you just shit yourself.
[47:06] PushingUpRoses: The song slapped them.
[47:09] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[47:10] PushingUpRoses: Yeah.
[47:10] Andrew DeWolf: Slaps them, chi-chi.
[47:12] PushingUpRoses: I mean, okay.
[47:14] Andrew DeWolf: Saying the movie is like shitting yourself, so I'm gonna guess it's a bad.
[47:18] PushingUpRoses: One one star?
[47:19] Andrew DeWolf: That is correct.
[47:22] PushingUpRoses: But the song slapped.
[47:23] Andrew DeWolf: Never forget.
[47:26] PushingUpRoses: The songs don't even get it to two stars, though.
[47:28] Andrew DeWolf: It's still one star.
[47:30] PushingUpRoses: So sad.
[47:31] Andrew DeWolf: Not even one and a half.
[47:33] PushingUpRoses: All right, Liz.
[47:34] Andrew DeWolf: We got two more, I think.
[47:35] PushingUpRoses: Or three more.
[47:36] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, three.
[47:36] PushingUpRoses: Okay.
[47:37] Andrew DeWolf: Where do the grandparents piss and shit if they never get out of bed?
[47:40] PushingUpRoses: Oh my god, I wondered that too as a kid.
[47:43] Andrew DeWolf: I'm like, do they have a chamber pot?
[47:46] PushingUpRoses: Like, how old are they?
[47:47] Andrew DeWolf: I always wondered that.
[47:48] PushingUpRoses: I'm gonna say that that's a five-star.
[47:51] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.
[47:51] PushingUpRoses: Yes.
[47:53] Andrew DeWolf: Because they're thinking about it.
[47:54] PushingUpRoses: So if they're thinking about the minutiae, clearly they like the movie.
[47:58] Andrew DeWolf: That's my that's my justification there.
[48:00] PushingUpRoses: The world building they're considering.
[48:01] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[48:02] PushingUpRoses: All right, Andrew, are you ready?
[48:04] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[48:04] PushingUpRoses: This film used to play in a loop at one of my former jobs, and I can now quote the entire thing.
[48:09] Andrew DeWolf: Ooh, that could go either way.
[48:13] PushingUpRoses: I gotta say, if a movie was playing at work that much that I could quote the whole thing, I don't think I'd like it, but he can quote the whole thing.
[48:20] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know.
[48:21] PushingUpRoses: Yeah, but might I pause it to you that now you have a skill.
[48:24] Andrew DeWolf: This movie has given you a skill of memorization.
[48:27] PushingUpRoses: I'm just saying, I'm just putting that out there for your consideration.
[48:31] Andrew DeWolf: I'm gonna go with one star.
[48:32] PushingUpRoses: I don't think this is a good review.
[48:33] Andrew DeWolf: That is correct.
[48:36] PushingUpRoses: Tried to sway you.
[48:37] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, yeah.
[48:38] PushingUpRoses: Dang, I'm good.
[48:39] Andrew DeWolf: I'm good.
[48:40] PushingUpRoses: Getting them tonight.
[48:43] Andrew DeWolf: My mic is falling down, is what's really happening though.
[48:46] PushingUpRoses: My goodness.
[48:47] Andrew DeWolf: It's Willie Wonka's fault.
[48:49] PushingUpRoses: He's trying to kill you.
[48:51] Andrew DeWolf: For being too confident.
[48:53] PushingUpRoses: What do you do when you're cocky as shit?
[48:59] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.
[49:00] PushingUpRoses: Okay, there's two left.
[49:00] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[49:01] PushingUpRoses: Okay.
[49:02] Andrew DeWolf: Fucking scam artists, creepy ass grandparents.
[49:06] PushingUpRoses: Whoa, whoa.
[49:07] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.
[49:09] PushingUpRoses: Yeah, last reviews are slightly mean, so it was either one.
[49:13] Andrew DeWolf: I'm gonna say that's so negative, it's gotta be a one-star.
[49:16] PushingUpRoses: That's a five-star.
[49:17] Andrew DeWolf: What?
[49:19] PushingUpRoses: I want to win one star too.
[49:21] Andrew DeWolf: That's crazy.
[49:21] PushingUpRoses: Letterboxd be crazy.
[49:23] Andrew DeWolf: Rox is weird.
[49:24] PushingUpRoses: Letterbox has some of the funkiest people on the planet.
[49:28] Andrew DeWolf: And the grandparent hate.
[49:30] PushingUpRoses: My goodness.
[49:31] Andrew DeWolf: It's either thirst or just untapped hatred.
[49:34] PushingUpRoses: Have you guys seen the TikTok of the girl like, yeah, but look at how grandpa licks that Snozzleberry.
[49:41] Andrew DeWolf: No.
[49:43] PushingUpRoses: Um, yeah, he like like goes full time on them.
[49:46] Andrew DeWolf: Like, I want grandpa to look at me the way he looks that Snozzleberry, and she got like a lot of hate.
[49:53] PushingUpRoses: That's a good video though.
[49:54] Andrew DeWolf: I think about it at least once a week.
[49:56] PushingUpRoses: All right, last one, guys.
[49:59] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.
[50:00] PushingUpRoses: Love that this movie is pro-child slavery.
[50:03] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, ooh.
[50:05] PushingUpRoses: Is it pro-child slavery?
[50:06] Andrew DeWolf: Or I mean are you?
[50:09] PushingUpRoses: Well, you know, Charlie basically had to work at age five or whatever age he is.
[50:14] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like, doesn't this is like one of those like ambiguous time period movies, though.
[50:19] PushingUpRoses: So I feel like it probably was like child labor was just cool.
[50:24] Andrew DeWolf: Um I mean that sounds bad.
[50:26] PushingUpRoses: One star?
[50:27] Andrew DeWolf: That's a five-star.
[50:28] PushingUpRoses: You're incorrect, but you still win the day.
[50:30] Andrew DeWolf: Libertarian reviews, my bad.
[50:45] Jess McInally: Hey guys, sorry to interrupt you in the middle of the show, but we've got a shill at you.
[50:49] Andrew DeWolf: Today's show is brought to you by the extremely kind donations by our donors over at Patreon.
[50:53] Jess McInally: Andrew, tell us a little bit about Patreon and what's going on over there.
[50:57] Andrew DeWolf: Oh man, you can go to Patreon if you want to support us and get some extra content.
[51:02] Andrew DeWolf: We uh we got commentary tracks, we got an extra podcast that runs over there.
[51:07] Andrew DeWolf: Um we do monthly meetups.
[51:09] Andrew DeWolf: You can request episodes.
[51:11] Jess McInally: I believe this was a request.
[51:13] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, it was.
[51:14] Andrew DeWolf: Um, so lots of stuff going on over there.
[51:16] Andrew DeWolf: We also get video episodes.
[51:18] Andrew DeWolf: You can see what's going on here, and a lot of extended cut stuff.
[51:22] Andrew DeWolf: Like a lot of stuff that I know doesn't make it into the episodes because it's too risque for the masses.
[51:30] Andrew DeWolf: Um we recently got just bad.
[51:33] Andrew DeWolf: It's just bad.
[51:33] Andrew DeWolf: We recently got a comment from a patron like, how did you cut the first 15 minutes of your first date episode?
[51:39] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm like, I don't even remember what was wrong with it, so that's great.
[51:45] Jess McInally: Um, but I can also just tell, like, looking at Rose's picture right now, they just want to say, support us on Patreon.
[51:52] Andrew DeWolf: It's right on the tip of their lips.
[51:53] PushingUpRoses: Uh oh no.
[51:57] Andrew DeWolf: Roses, I don't know what happened, but your audio just suddenly turns into like a demon monster saying that.
[52:03] PushingUpRoses: Oh, that's gonna be a good idea.
[52:04] Andrew DeWolf: We should just start.
[52:05] PushingUpRoses: We should start reading the names.
[52:06] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, we should be able to do that.
[52:08] Jess McInally: You want to do it this time, Jess?
[52:09] PushingUpRoses: Yeah, please do it.
[52:10] Jess McInally: Our current patrons are Melissa Goldman, Layton Accles, Danielle Rennox, Jess the Stampede, Ewan Cassidy, Monica Thoreau, Brent Black, Mina Maniri, Lathaniel Stacy Coombe, Joseph Evans Green, Carrie Hearn, Mary Lou Choquette, John Van Alves, Russ Walker, Musical Hell, Emily Gracie, Kyle Summer, Scootin' the Technicolor Dreamcoat, Liz Lim, Alison Stellar, nothing is certain except Beth and Taxes, Desbian, Ren Cullen, Rafael Martinez Salaz, Jessica T, Mitchell Young, Chai Teacup, Katie McDonough, Timothy Keys, Chris Marcote, Mimu, Kiji Marie Anastasio, Layla, RJ Narija, Avan Regan, Charlie B, Patrick Deering, Avery Brinson, Bjorn Herman's, Joanna Oakley, Erica S.
[52:48] Andrew DeWolf: Toriana Frazier, Sammy the Most, Lopez, Liana Morton, Angela, Kayleigh Blazier, Birdman69.
[52:55] PushingUpRoses: Nice.
[52:55] Andrew DeWolf: Danielle Smith, who requested this episode.
[52:57] Jess McInally: CinemaGen Reviews, Villainous Miss, Shona Enders, Safina Ali, The Omega Geek, Tori C, Katrin Evans, Paige Pearson, Maddie Wargle, Jonathan and Dragon Eye.
[53:10] Andrew DeWolf: They all give us a little financial support that helps us keep the lights on here at Musicals of Cheese.
[53:14] PushingUpRoses: If you'd like to join them in supporting us and get tons of fun perks, such as Patrick, Patreon only commentaries, a full Patreon podcast, and a lot of other cool shit.
[53:21] Andrew DeWolf: Come join us over at Patreon.
[53:22] Jess McInally: All right, are we ready to get back to the show?
[53:24] Andrew DeWolf: Am I am I back?
[53:25] PushingUpRoses: You're back.
[53:26] Andrew DeWolf: You're not a demon.
[53:27] PushingUpRoses: I'm so sorry you guys all had to see my true form.
[53:31] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, usually I keep that, you know, under uh, but we're good now.
[53:35] PushingUpRoses: Yeah.
[53:35] Andrew DeWolf: Um my air deem comes out sometimes too.
[53:37] PushingUpRoses: I get it.
[53:38] Andrew DeWolf: You need to keep that in there.
[53:40] PushingUpRoses: You need to keep that.
[53:41] Andrew DeWolf: I hope that it showed up in your recording, maybe.
[53:44] PushingUpRoses: I probably did.
[53:45] Andrew DeWolf: Like it was probably more of a mic, a mic issue than a broadcast issue, so it probably is there.
[53:51] PushingUpRoses: Well, if you're sounding good now, I think we're in a good shape.
[53:53] Andrew DeWolf: But that was that was that was you can't buy that kind of timing.
[53:57] PushingUpRoses: That was crazy.
[53:58] Andrew DeWolf: Just had a little little phlegm, had to clear my throat.
[54:00] PushingUpRoses: We're all good now.
[54:02] Andrew DeWolf: All right, let's get back to it.
[54:14] PushingUpRoses: The candy man makes everything he bakes.
[54:19] Andrew DeWolf: Satisfying and delicious.
[54:22] PushingUpRoses: Talk about your childhood wishes.
[54:27] Andrew DeWolf: You can even eat the dishes.
[54:33] PushingUpRoses: Who can take tomorrow?
[54:35] Andrew DeWolf: Who can take tomorrow?
[54:39] PushingUpRoses: Dip it in a dream.
[54:41] Andrew DeWolf: Separate the sorrow and collect up all the cream.
[54:45] PushingUpRoses: The candyman.
[54:47] Andrew DeWolf: The candyman.
[54:48] PushingUpRoses: Oh, the candyman.
[54:50] Jess McInally: So Charlie and the Chocolate Factory is a musical written by David Greig, um, and with music and lyrics by Mark Shaman and Scott Whitman.
[54:58] Jess McInally: Um, based on Charlie and the Chocolate Factory by Roald Dahl.
[55:01] Jess McInally: Um, it was directed by Sam Mendes.
[55:03] Jess McInally: The musical premiered on the West End at the Royal Drury Lane Theatre, which Andrew has said that's where the muffin man lives, in June of 2013, and ran for three years and seven months before closing on January 7th, 2017.
[55:15] Jess McInally: Um, the production broke record for the weekly ticket sales in London while receiving mixed reviews from critics.
[55:20] Jess McInally: The show won two Laurence Olivier Awards in 2014 for best costume design and best lighting design.
[55:26] Jess McInally: A reworked version of the show opened on Broadway in spring of 2017, with changes including new direction by Jack O'Brien, because you know, Sam Mendes was busy making good things.
[55:35] Jess McInally: Um O'Brien wanted the score to pay homage to the Leslie Brucusse and Anthony Newley songs, written for the 1971 film, and would also feature the songs written by Shaman Whitman and a couple new ones.
[55:46] Jess McInally: Um O'Brien confirmed that the Candyman and Pure Imagination would be included in the musical because of course it is.
[55:51] Jess McInally: For this production, the characters of Augustus Gloop, Violet Beauregard, and Veruca Salt, Mike TV, are all played by adult actors, unlike the child actors in the London production.
[55:59] Jess McInally: While the character of Charlie is still filled by a child actor.
[56:02] Jess McInally: The Broadway production received mixed to negative reviews from critics.
[56:05] Jess McInally: Despite the enormous overhaul to both the book and score from the London production, critics noted that the storytelling was still choppy and relied too heavily on humor.
[56:13] Jess McInally: Criticism was also drawn to the decision to cast adults as the golden ticket winners instead of children, as well as the lackluster set redesigns for Broadway.
[56:21] Jess McInally: However, Christian Borle received widespread praise for his performance as Willy Wonka, even amongst negativity towards other aspects of the show.
[56:27] PushingUpRoses: Um yeah, so I'm gonna disagree.
[56:30] PushingUpRoses: Christian Borle's rough in this.
[56:32] Jess McInally: Um but Roses, I am so fascinated on what your thoughts are of this Broadway revamp.
[56:38] PushingUpRoses: Well, um, there's no nice way to put it.
[56:42] PushingUpRoses: I absolutely hated it.
[56:44] PushingUpRoses: Um interestingly, uh a few months ago I just made like a new group of friends who are theater people, and that musical theater is part of that, and so I've been watching a lot of musical theater and theater lately, and I think I've become spoiled on very good musical theater and stage acting, and this was not it.
[57:04] PushingUpRoses: This was this was not it.
[57:06] PushingUpRoses: Um I could not believe the humor.
[57:10] PushingUpRoses: And like as a humorous writer myself, we all do I'll do riff jokes, MST3K style jokes for Murder, She Wrote.
[57:17] PushingUpRoses: I could not believe how unfunny these jokes were, and they start immediately.
[57:21] PushingUpRoses: You know, they start with Wonka coming out, which is bizarre, a weird choice in itself, and he's like, Everyone likes chocolate except for dogs, and the audience is laughing.
[57:31] PushingUpRoses: And I'm like, where's the joke?
[57:33] PushingUpRoses: Where's the where's the joke?
[57:35] Andrew DeWolf: See, dogs can't eat chocolate because they'll die.
[57:35] PushingUpRoses: Because they'll die.
[57:39] Jess McInally: Yeah.
[57:40] PushingUpRoses: And I I just I noted that right away as they're trying for this humor.
[57:43] PushingUpRoses: They're trying to make it ha ha funny instead of Gene Wilder eccentric funny, but like, isn't this goofy?
[57:50] PushingUpRoses: Isn't this silly what we're doing here?
[57:52] PushingUpRoses: And at the end of the show, I'm like, are they trying to satire this?
[57:56] PushingUpRoses: But it's already satirical.
[57:58] PushingUpRoses: What is this?
[57:59] PushingUpRoses: Like, it just the tone was all over the place.
[58:03] PushingUpRoses: I swear I have not seen a more confused show in my entire life.
[58:07] Jess McInally: Yeah.
[58:07] PushingUpRoses: Especially after watching the West End version, which is very much in kind in kind with the Matilda musical that came out a few years before it.
[58:15] PushingUpRoses: They feel very of the same ilk.
[58:17] PushingUpRoses: Not like the humor is there, but very of the Gene Wilder movie where it's a little bit more tongue-in-cheek and less broad.
[58:25] PushingUpRoses: Where when they transferred to Broadway, it's like, let's tell as many jokes and make it as morbid and mean spirited and kind of cynical as we can.
[58:33] Jess McInally: Um, but what'd you think of it, Andrew?
[58:34] Andrew DeWolf: Your first watch.
[58:36] PushingUpRoses: Um, say it.
[58:38] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, say it.
[58:39] PushingUpRoses: It's uh what what do you want me to say?
[58:41] Andrew DeWolf: You want to want me to talk about it?
[58:42] PushingUpRoses: I remember you telling me, like, I actually thought it was really good.
[58:45] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, okay.
[58:46] PushingUpRoses: No, no, I thought I thought that the uh tone was really good because you were talking about you thought the tone was uh I think the tone's a mess, so elaborate on that.
[58:55] Andrew DeWolf: They just murder the children, like they're there's no ifs, ands or buts.
[58:59] PushingUpRoses: The kids are dead.
[59:01] Andrew DeWolf: Um, the parents see the kids die, uh, and we get to watch that, and I think that that is incredible that they would actually go that route.
[59:11] PushingUpRoses: So I I really applaud them for that.
[59:13] PushingUpRoses: That was not in the case of the West End version, I want to say that.
[59:17] PushingUpRoses: Um, but I do think the overall it's pretty bad. There's a lot of not funny jokes, and I think the worst thing possible is the set design is just non-existent.
[59:32] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I clocked that too. There were so many parts where they're like standing in front of what appears to be a blue screen or something, and there's just nothing. And I'm like, where's the set? Like, where's anything? My absolute favorite scene in the whole thing is when they go to an empty room and there's a maze.
[59:52] PushingUpRoses: Yeah.
[59:53] Andrew DeWolf: A maze that they have to navigate, and everyone has to navigate the maze, but Mike TV gets bonked on the head by stuff.
[1:00:02] PushingUpRoses: There's nothing there.
[1:00:04] Andrew DeWolf: There's nothing there. The whole stage is empty. And I think the joke is like a fourth wall break, because at the end of it, they're like, oh, I guess we can't go this way anyway, so let's go back. And they just walk back.
[1:00:18] PushingUpRoses: Yeah.
[1:00:18] Andrew DeWolf: And they don't go through the maze anymore. But like, I don't get it. Is the joke that this sucks? Or is it like the joke is on you for watching this? I don't even know if the play is smart enough to even make this commentary, but are they trying to be like, use your imagination, pure imagination? These are the things that are happening, and these are what the kids are interacting with. But I actually don't think it's smart enough to do that. And it's certainly it wasn't creative enough or visual enough to pull that off.
[1:00:46] PushingUpRoses: But I will say, the actor playing Mike TV, I liked his physical comedy. I liked seeing him flop around the screen around the stage like a fish. It was very funny to see him get clocked like multiple times. Another performer I think is really doing the work here is the Mrs. TV. She, every time she has a line, it really sells really well.
[1:01:10] Andrew DeWolf: Mrs. TV has problems, man. Like she's like, yeah, yeah. Like she doesn't love her kid because she doesn't respect like she's happy to see that he's made small so she can take him home and treat him like a toy.
[1:01:26] PushingUpRoses: Yeah, yeah. Uh Violet, when she explodes into a juice and just is dead.
[1:01:33] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Um, the father seems really distraught, like, she exploded!
[1:01:36] PushingUpRoses: Spotted!
[1:01:37] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Doesn't um Willy Wonka make some sort of comment to her about how like now she'll make good wine or something?
[1:01:44] PushingUpRoses: Yeah.
[1:01:45] Andrew DeWolf: And he's also like, she exploded onto the scene. And like the audience is like cracking up. What do you mean? I'm like, oh god. What was she's just dead? There was another one where Mike TV's like so small and just kind of goes off, and then they were like, oh, is Mike TV ever be back to normal? And Wonka's like, no one's back to normal after they've been on TV.
[1:02:06] PushingUpRoses: Yeah, yeah. These jokes are real mean. And you know, real unpleasant. It's weird because they also tried obviously they modernized this. And I think the reason the movie is so timeless is because there isn't you can't really tell what year we're in. Even as a kid, I didn't know it was an older movie. I didn't really know, except for maybe the set design and maybe the fashion choices. But this play, it's all about memes, and they're saying LOL and I'm gonna tweet about it and put this on the gram, and it's trying to get it.
[1:02:40] Andrew DeWolf: Trump references.
[1:02:41] PushingUpRoses: Yeah. And I'm like, this is not gonna age. He plays like Fortnite or something, he's doing Fortnite dances. And I definitely appreciate a good like, you know, satire or commentary, if you will, on social media. That's fine. But this was just it's just shoehorned in. It's just LOL. It's for the lols, put it on Instagram, check me out. And it was weird. And it was weird seeing it from adults. Even though I understand why they cast adults for the kids, it's still bizarre.
[1:03:11] Andrew DeWolf: So they can murder them.
[1:03:12] PushingUpRoses: So they could murder, yeah. It would be only Stephen King gets to do that, my friend. If you're Stephen King, you can put child murder in your shit. If not, we cast adults. I think it has a really weird quality to it, though, where you get to the end and all of these kids are dead, like actually dead, and Willy Wonka's joking about how they died, but then you get to the end, and it's like Willy Wonka's talking about this imagination and how Charlie and him share something together. And it feels like Charlie is being inducted into a cult.
[1:03:49] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I was actually cracking riffs like, is this Scientology? What's happening? You are the next Willy Wonka, Charlie. Get ready, because you're going to be making blood sacrifices every year.
[1:04:05] PushingUpRoses: I don't disagree. Um, let's try to extend ourselves a little bit. Was there anything we liked about this show?
[1:04:13] Andrew DeWolf: I will say yes. There's a couple things I liked about the show. Um, or at least appreciated. Let's not be silly and just say I liked it. Um, but I did appreciate some of the puppetry. Um, I wrote that I remember I wrote that down. Um, the Oompa-Loompas were weird, but the puppetry with the black outfits that they were wearing, that's not easy. And it read, it translated for me. It reminded me of like Labyrinth when Jim Henson's puppeteers would do similar things like that. I thought it was okay. Um, I'm trying to think of other things. I there were maybe a couple songs that I thought were sweet in nature, but ultimately they were disconnected, and maybe that's why I liked these like sweeter songs, because once they ended, they went back into this odd-toned, almost egocentric version of Willy Wonka. And so it's a disconnect. Even though I liked that puppetry and I liked some of the sweeter songs, it's still so disconnected from the whole thing, you know.
[1:05:16] PushingUpRoses: I like that they made the guy that runs the candy shop like horrible.
[1:05:21] Andrew DeWolf: You mean Willy, he was Willy Wonka. I feel like it's like in the text. I'm pretty sure it is, but I love that he's awful, but he's also it's almost like he knows that Charlie's gonna get the ticket somehow. They keep cueing him up to be like, oh Charlie, take this free candy bar, but he never does. He never does it. He just he's like you think he's gonna give him anything and he doesn't, but then he leaves behind money or something. He doesn't even sell him the candy bar that wins him the golden ticket. The street lady sells that to him. Yeah, so it's like he can't actually know that he's gonna get the ticket, so it's like Willy Wonka is like, I'm gonna be too nice to this Charlie kid, so let me be horrible to him at first or something like that.
[1:06:05] PushingUpRoses: No, he is just kind of playing a like a street, like a tramp on the street, like and it's Willy Wonka, and it's a little less obvious. Like he's basically the one that goes the nobody ever goes in, no one comes out moment. He's that guy, and I'm like, okay, that kind of works. Here, this does not work for me, even a little bit.
[1:06:22] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I don't I agree. I don't think it works at all. It's so weird. There's so many strange choices that I feel like it's uh it was it's an interesting watch just because of it. It's just like I don't know what they were just trying to do.
[1:06:37] PushingUpRoses: No, I really don't. I uh okay. I got one nice thing to say that I kinda like about it. I kinda like Veruca in this.
[1:06:44] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, okay.
[1:06:45] PushingUpRoses: I think she's pretty cool. Veruca was interesting. She's a ballerina. Like I like her song. I'm like when Veruca wants this, and I like that they're Russians. Little things I'm like, alright, I kind of dig that.
[1:06:56] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it was an interesting choice. I didn't think I would like her character at first because it was such a departure. But I'm like, actually, this is well acted. I do like, I do like that she's a Russian ballerina. Um, I did not like her death scene, like, at all. Not even comically. I will I will very seriously say that it disturbed me when I saw it. And I'm like, Why don't you describe the death scene from?
[1:07:19] PushingUpRoses: Sure, surely will. So, um, in the book, instead of the goose that lay the golden eggs that you see in the movie, they're actually squirrels, specially trained squirrels that look for bad nuts. And Veruca wants one of these squirrels. Uh so she goes into the squirrel room. She's determined to be a bad nut by the squirrels, whose eyes now turn red. They're kind of cute squirrels at first, right?
[1:07:42] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[1:07:44] PushingUpRoses: Now they're demon squirrels with like red glowing eyes. They chase her up this um like conveyor belt. She goes off uh off stage for a second. A dumb, they're suddenly holding a dummy. These squirrels are holding a dummy of Ballerina Veruca, and they rip her apart. Um all five squirrels are holding a limb, including her head, by the way, of Veruca. As the lyrics say, as we tear her apart from limb from limb.
[1:08:14] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, yeah. It's very blatant.
[1:08:16] PushingUpRoses: And like I can't believe they didn't know. I can't believe they did that. I just what's the point? I don't see the point. This is on Broadway?
[1:08:26] Andrew DeWolf: This was on Broadway.
[1:08:28] PushingUpRoses: Christian Boris. That's brute. They just kill the kids. The only one who survives is Mike TV. And it's brutal. And like upon second viewing, I was kind of like rolling my eyes. But if you first view it and you see the dummy come out, it's actually disturbing. Like you have that thought of a kid just got ripped alive. That's and also, what is the point? How can we go from you know Wonka's actor singing about pure imagination and ooh, the wonders of childhood to literally ripping a child, including her head? Like it's it's and I'm I'm very much like a dark humor person. I like dark humor, but there's nothing dark humor has to have a redeeming quality, and this does not. It's just straight up ripping her apart, and then they pan over to or they show over to the parents who are just in shock, and that's it.
And I'm like, that's not what you would. I mean, they're just like, what happened? What happened here? Uh what happened? And they try to play it, they play it like the parents are watching the scene in the movie.
[1:09:30] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[1:09:30] PushingUpRoses: Instead of watching what actually happened.
[1:09:32] Andrew DeWolf: Right. I like how someone asks Wonka, like, hey, how will they do it? And he's like, I know Oompa-Loompa, that's great with a glue stick. Like, that's how flippant they are about it.
[1:09:42] PushingUpRoses: Yeah, like the reaction's weird. It's pointless. It's it's just kind of gratuitous for for no reason whatsoever. Um, but the audience, I think the audience was so shocked that they just kind of laughed and like applauded.
[1:09:56] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, applauded just because it was that shocking. It was that absurd, you know. This doesn't feel like a kid's show.
[1:10:04] PushingUpRoses: Not at all. Um, which I think might be the most confusing part about who is this version of Charlie and the Chocolate Factory for?
[1:10:11] Andrew DeWolf: I think it's just for me, Tennessee. I think that's for one person. I think they made this version for me.
[1:10:14] PushingUpRoses: Cause I just I really like that they murder the kids. I think that it's great. I love it.
[1:10:23] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know why. I feel like I've always wanted to just see a version where they're just they just admit it. Where it's like, yeah, we we kill four kids in this show.
[1:10:34] PushingUpRoses: I mean if it's gonna go like off the rails, though, I wish it would have stayed in that vein because uh I'm fine with like some morbid stuff. Um I like the concept of Sweeney Todd being as morbid as it is, but it's it's like it's just so over the top.
[1:10:52] Andrew DeWolf: Um there's no tone.
[1:10:53] PushingUpRoses: It goes from silly, like very goofy jokes, silly jokes, and weird dialogue. Honestly, that was my least favorite part is this dialogue is awful.
[1:11:02] Andrew DeWolf: It is busted.
[1:11:03] PushingUpRoses: Yeah, it's rough. Um so they don't stay with that line of kind of like dark humor. They don't really know what genre.
[1:11:12] Andrew DeWolf: So yeah, who is this for? Like, you know, demographically, who is this for?
[1:11:18] PushingUpRoses: Apparently, no one.
[1:11:19] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, it did poorly and got negative reviews.
[1:11:22] PushingUpRoses: I mean, Liz. That's a good transition.
[1:11:24] Andrew DeWolf: Liz, we got some reviews down here. Why don't you read one of the New York Times reviews?
[1:11:29] PushingUpRoses: I have to do brief.
[1:11:31] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, we're previous part two here. We got actual reviews.
[1:11:35] PushingUpRoses: I am I am diet brief, uh, but I will do my best.
[1:11:38] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.
[1:11:39] PushingUpRoses: What have we got here?
[1:11:40] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, we got first this one's from Ben Brantley. So do you want me to read? Or do you want Ben Brantley? Do you know the bet someone who can do a Ben Brantley voice?
[1:11:49] PushingUpRoses: Nah, you do it.
[1:11:50] Andrew DeWolf: Alright. Alright. Ben Brantley in the New York Times on April 23rd, 2017, says of the says of what Charlie and Chocolate Factory. Don't expect a sugar rush from Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, the new musical that opened at the Lunt Fontan Theater on Sunday. This latest adaptation of Roald Dahl's winning sinister children story from 1964 is, thank heaven, no sweeter than the two film adaptations inspired, starring Gene Wilder from 1971 and Johnny Depp in 2005.
[1:12:20] PushingUpRoses: Okay, so fun fact Ben Brantley gave a negative review to the West End production and gave a middling review to the Broadway production. I don't know why that's just like me for real for real. Because Ben Brantley does not give faint praise to anything.
[1:12:36] Andrew DeWolf: Maybe he was also just shocked by the absurdity of it. Sometimes you just want to watch bratty children die horrifically.
[1:12:45] PushingUpRoses: You know, and you're just like, this is the only show that will give me that.
[1:12:50] Andrew DeWolf: Indeed.
[1:12:50] PushingUpRoses: But then Time Out came out from David Coates saying, strangers with candy should be avoided. Our parents warn. Raoul Dahl urges us to grab sugary goods, but be prepared for the consequences. Families who accept the treats currently proffered at the Lund Fontaine Theater, though, are in for a rough time on Broadway. Joyless, shapeless, and grating. Charlie and the Chocolate Factory is a stale Necco wafer of a musical.
[1:13:13] Andrew DeWolf: Woo!
[1:13:15] PushingUpRoses: David Cohen. That's a good one.
[1:13:17] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, Liz, we got one more. What's that one?
[1:13:20] PushingUpRoses: Alright, we got NBC New York, written by Robert Kahn.
[1:13:23] Andrew DeWolf: Con!
[1:13:24] PushingUpRoses: The best thing about Broadway's new Charlie and the Chocolate Factory is the inventively, savagely, and barbarously ways that all the golden ticket winners, except that is, for Charlie Bucket, die.
[1:13:40] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, someone had to put in the first sentence.
[1:13:44] PushingUpRoses: That is the most interesting. Like, I feel like they were just like, how are we gonna get people to talk about it? Like, we gotta kill the kids, don't we?
[1:13:52] Andrew DeWolf: That does feel like a very like gratuitous choice. Is like this'll get people talking.
[1:13:57] PushingUpRoses: Yeah, we don't have the greatest sets. Yeah, we put the factory in a little box, but but we kill kids.
[1:14:02] ⚠ About 4 minutes of audio could not be automatically transcribed.
[1:17:35] ♪ Musical number: "So Much Time" — performed by Christian Borle ♪
[1:18:58] Jess McInally: I think Christian Borle performs it very poorly. I think Douglas Hodge, who put it in the West End version, really nails that song and gets like the dark vibe of it, where he's just like has a hood up and then he pulls the hood off and he reveals himself and it's like, it's Wonka. Where Christian Borle works better than we hadn't seen Wonka already.
[1:19:16] PushingUpRoses: Yeah, they fixed that problem too.
[1:19:18] Jess McInally: But here the falls to the ground face plants, people gather around, then he just hops up, like it's terrible.
[1:19:24] PushingUpRoses: Well, he's trying to do the thing from the movie.
[1:19:27] Jess McInally: It don't work.
[1:19:28] PushingUpRoses: Right?
[1:19:28] Jess McInally: Yeah.
[1:19:29] PushingUpRoses: In the movie, he gets his cane stuck and he likes doesn't the audience seem to really enjoy it, but I also like I do wonder, it's just having seen stage performance. It is different when you're there.
[1:19:44] Jess McInally: It is different when you're in the theater, kind of connecting with these actors and actresses. But I wonder if that audience watched it, the recording, if they would feel the same way about this performance.
[1:19:57] PushingUpRoses: Cause yeah, I was not on their page, man. I was not on their level.
[1:20:00] Jess McInally: Well, speaking of the audience in that specific moment when Christian Borle stands up and reveals himself, dude, do we clap here? And you can see on Christian Borle's face that he's like, God damn it, and then he keeps going with the song.
[1:20:18] PushingUpRoses: Oh no.
[1:20:20] Jess McInally: Like that moment flops, but other moments, like most of the laugh lines, like Mrs. TV's entire presence on stage really sells to the audience.
[1:20:29] PushingUpRoses: Yeah, yeah, for sure.
[1:20:36] Jess McInally: You don't find out what I mean.
[1:20:40] PushingUpRoses: Beyond this gate is a world I create.
[1:20:45] Jess McInally: But it must be believed to be seen.
[1:20:51] PushingUpRoses: Yeah.
[1:20:52] Jess McInally: Um, so we have now reached the end of our discussion. What is our overall thoughts on Willy Wonka and the Chocolate Factory and Charlie and the Chocolate Factory, the musical? And our cheese ratings. Um, Rose, are you aware of our cheese ratings?
[1:21:06] PushingUpRoses: Uh no, do do explain.
[1:21:13] Andrew DeWolf: Overall thoughts on your cheese rating.
[1:21:15] Jess McInally: Sure. Um, I think the movie is really good, and I'm sure almost everyone listening has probably already seen it. But, you know, if you haven't seen it, it's like a classic. You should definitely watch it. The musical, on the other hand, feels like a satire of the movie in a lot of ways. Um, and is so like all over the place, like insane, that I can't help but have some enjoyment to it.
[1:21:45] Andrew DeWolf: I think it's a true guilty pleasure. I think it's awful, and you should not watch it, but I think I enjoyed it a little too much, honestly. Um, it really feels like if somebody hated if somebody hated the movie and then made it, this is what you would do. Um, it and and yeah, it almost it I think it would almost work better if you like made it like Ronald McDonald or or something in the sh in the hamburger factory, and like this is like a satire, you know, and it's like it's not the same, but that's like played up as if it's an advertisement for I don't know. It's like I can't even describe my feelings for it, but maybe don't watch it.
[1:22:27] Andrew DeWolf: Um I'm gonna go and give it a uh a classic that we've already used, but we have to do it here. Um this gets chocolate cheese.
[1:22:38] PushingUpRoses: Yep, you you could not do it.
[1:22:38] Andrew DeWolf: Um that's fair enough. Um Liz, what is your overall thoughts on our discussion and your cheese rating?
[1:22:46] PushingUpRoses: Uh I enjoyed it. I enjoyed it a lot. Uh I learned a lot about child murder. Um it can help you in your college studies.
[1:22:54] Andrew DeWolf: It really does.
[1:22:55] PushingUpRoses: I'm I've been out of college for a while, but yeah, definitely will help me down the line. No, I I love the movie. Uh I was catching bits of the show while you're talking. It is insane, and I'll probably watch it drunk at some point. So just for fun.
[1:23:09] Andrew DeWolf: Hell yeah.
[1:23:10] PushingUpRoses: So I was gonna I thought of giving chocolate cheese, but I thought Andrew would do it before me, so I came up with a different one. Uh so I'm gonna give it a sweet cheese pie. Which looks like a little ham pie with cream cheese in it. Doesn't look half bad.
[1:23:24] Andrew DeWolf: All right, Roses, how about you?
[1:23:27] PushingUpRoses: Well, I love the movie. Um I think it's earnest and dark, but not so much that children can't enjoy it. I think it's a true comfort, uh comfort movie. I think that Gene Wilder really becomes Willy Wonka.
[1:23:41] PushingUpRoses: If you know Gene Wilder's um other films, he really becomes a different character here. I I don't even see him as Gene Wilder, just Willy Wonka. So highly recommend. The stage play.
[1:23:54] PushingUpRoses: I do not recommend. I I'm hesitant here because I want people to see it so that I can talk to them about it. So I don't know. That's kind of a recommendation. I think I I think it was terrible. Um, I I'm maybe the showrunners had good intentions.
[1:24:11] PushingUpRoses: Maybe they thought they were doing something really creative or really out there and off beat, and maybe they thought that matched, you know, the Willy Wonka vibe, something that offbeat. I just think it went too morbid and clashed with the silly jokes.
[1:24:23] PushingUpRoses: So I I'm gonna give it a personal cheese rating here. I'm gonna give it I'm gonna give it apple pie cheese because some people die by it, but we all know it's disgusting, really.
[1:24:36] Andrew DeWolf: I I agree wholeheartedly that that entire sentiment. Thank you. Um that was wonderful. Um, yeah, I love Willy Wonka. Not a big fan of the stage musical.
[1:24:43] Andrew DeWolf: So I'm giving the original film um drunken goat cheese made by Beauregard of Vineyards. Um, because we gotta gotta try that.
[1:24:51] Andrew DeWolf: And I am giving the stage version Willy Wonka, which is a type of cheese weed. Um you can buy it at Leaffly.com. So those are my two ratings.
[1:25:02] PushingUpRoses: Like, because you know, like you got the nice Beauregard cheese, drunken goat, very good, and then you got like weed.
[1:25:09] Andrew DeWolf: So they call it cheese, but it's not really cheese.
[1:25:13] PushingUpRoses: Got it.
[1:25:13] Andrew DeWolf: Perfect. No notes.
[1:25:15] Andrew DeWolf: Roses, you are an absolute delight to have on this show.
[1:25:18] PushingUpRoses: Well, thank you.
[1:25:19] Andrew DeWolf: You do so many wonderful things out there for the world. Please promote them for the world.
[1:25:23] PushingUpRoses: Uh well, my name is Pushing Up Roses. You can find me on YouTube if you just type in Pushing Up Roses, or you can find me on Twitter if you type in pushing up roses, or on Instagram if you type in pushing up roses.
[1:25:34] PushingUpRoses: I'm everywhere. Just type in my name. Don't go too far down the rabbit hole. You'll find some weird stuff probably. Stay at the top, go to Instagram and Twitter, and that's me.
[1:25:45] Andrew DeWolf: And do you have any art accounts or anything like that?
[1:25:47] PushingUpRoses: The art is all on Instagram. Um and from the Instagram, you can find my Etsy shop where I sell my art.
[1:25:53] PushingUpRoses: And YouTube is dedicated to reviews and riffs and retrospectives on all things murder mystery, horror, and sometimes video games.
[1:26:01] Andrew DeWolf: Sometimes.
[1:26:02] PushingUpRoses: Heck yeah.
[1:26:02] Andrew DeWolf: And I always try to like give my own personal recommendation of your content. I am a big fan for a long, long time.
[1:26:09] Andrew DeWolf: Um I really loved your Muppet Family Christmas special. Like you coverage. Like that was such a sweet video.
[1:26:15] Andrew DeWolf: But of course, your murder she wrote videos are always great. And most recently, your Ferris V Bueller video about something I watched as a young in it.
[1:26:23] Andrew DeWolf: Um that that was that was a pretty intense one.
[1:26:26] PushingUpRoses: Oh, it was a disaster. I I didn't think I could even finish it. I'm just like, I gotta do this review, but I don't want to.
[1:26:34] Andrew DeWolf: Will I wonka the musical or Ferris Bueller the TV show?
[1:26:36] PushingUpRoses: Oh, really wonka. For like hands down, 100%. Hands down.
[1:26:40] Andrew DeWolf: But thank you.
[1:26:41] PushingUpRoses: Muppet Family Christmas got I knew that would get less hits because it's such a I think people think Muppets, they think Buppet Christmas Carol.
[1:26:47] PushingUpRoses: They don't necessarily think Muppet Family Christmas, but I love that special.
[1:26:51] Andrew DeWolf: I love I love the Muppets.
[1:26:53] PushingUpRoses: How can you?
[1:26:54] Andrew DeWolf: We did an episode of it uh a couple years ago.
[1:26:56] PushingUpRoses: Yeah, I love that special.
[1:26:58] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I love it.
[1:26:59] PushingUpRoses: Well, thank you again for coming on, and thank you all for listening.
[1:27:03] Andrew DeWolf: Please follow us on iTunes Spotify Stitcher at Musicals with Cheese. We're on Patreon Musicals with Cheese, we're on Twitter at Cheesy Musicals, Instagram Musicals with Cheese, YouTube Page Music Schools with Cheese.
[1:27:11] Andrew DeWolf: We have a Patreon podcast called Patreon with Cheese, where me and Liz Essen are currently starting Tangled Season 2.
[1:27:16] PushingUpRoses: Yeah.
[1:27:17] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, that's a lot of fun.
[1:27:19] PushingUpRoses: That's a blast.
[1:27:19] Andrew DeWolf: Email us at musical theater lives at gmail.com. Our keeper of the cheese is Juliet Antonio.
[1:27:25] Andrew DeWolf: You are the fucking tits, Juliet.
[1:27:27] Andrew DeWolf: This show is produced by the amazing, the incredible, the sidely apps, and Brianna Jones.
[1:27:31] Andrew DeWolf: Our themes were created by Robin Nash of IOU Music UK. Thank you, Robin, for creating those.
[1:27:37] Andrew DeWolf: Thank you to the Broadway Podcast Network for having us on the platform and for not kicking us off for teaching you how to murder some children.
[1:27:43] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, do we have anything else we gotta say before we wrap this on up?
[1:27:46] PushingUpRoses: Don't murder children.
[1:27:47] Andrew DeWolf: Don't do it.
[1:27:49] PushingUpRoses: You know what?
[1:27:49] PushingUpRoses: Murder children.
[1:27:50] PushingUpRoses: Unless you own a chocolate factory.
[1:27:53] Andrew DeWolf: Just don't.
[1:27:54] PushingUpRoses: Yeah.
[1:27:55] PushingUpRoses: Or the egg room.
[1:27:56] Andrew DeWolf: Either one.
[1:27:58] PushingUpRoses: Definitely go into the TV room.
[1:28:00] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, that's a fan.
[1:28:01] Andrew DeWolf: You gotta go in there.
[1:28:02] Andrew DeWolf: That's just a good time.
[1:28:04] PushingUpRoses: Spring your friend you don't like.
[1:28:05] PushingUpRoses: You can shrink them.
[1:28:06] PushingUpRoses: Like never see them again.
[1:28:08] Andrew DeWolf: That's taking OnlyFans to a new level, is all I'm saying.
[1:28:11] PushingUpRoses: You could eat a French fry and survive the whole day.
[1:28:15] Andrew DeWolf: If you were that big.
[1:28:18] PushingUpRoses: You know what? I was on the fence, and now you've sold me.
[1:28:23] Andrew DeWolf: We'll see you next time on Musicals with Cheese.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
