Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#211 - A Very Potter Musical

"I gotta get back to Hogwarts..." Grab your intellectual property paperwork because this week we're diving into the first StarKid show ever "A Very Potter Musical." We talk about Parody, changes in humor, and how Starkid has changed over the years... Read More

From the show: Musicals with Cheese

1 h 25 mins
9/22/22

About

"I gotta get back to Hogwarts..." Grab your intellectual property paperwork because this week we're diving into the first StarKid show ever "A Very Potter Musical." We talk about Parody, changes in humor, and how Starkid has changed over the years. Check it out


Social Media:

Our WEBSITE

Musicals with Cheese on Twitter

Musicals W/ Cheese on Instagram

Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com

Merch!!

Jess Socials

Jesse McAnally on Twitter

Jess McAnally on Instagram

Andrew Socials

Andrew DeWolf on Instagram

Andrew DeWolf on Twitter

Brianna Socials

Brianna Jones on Twitter

Brianna Jones on Instagram

Use our Affiliate Link

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:06] Jesse McAnally: Hello, I'm Jesse McAnally.

[0:09] Andrew DeWolf: And I am Andrew DeWolf.

[0:10] Brianna Jones: And I'm Brianna Jones.

[0:12] Jesse McAnally: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, a podcast where I try to get Andrew and Bree to like musical theater.

[0:17] Jesse McAnally: And Andrew, how are you doing today?

[0:21] Andrew DeWolf: I'm just out here uh protecting real women, you know.

[0:25] Jesse McAnally: That's that's what we're starting with.

[0:30] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, sorry. I meant magic and stuff. Wizards, they're fun.

[0:37] Jesse McAnally: I guess we do kind of have to start this with talking about the big turfy elephant in the room, don't we?

[0:43] Andrew DeWolf: Like you like we couldn't mention it. We have to do it right now, or else people are gonna be like, why didn't they talk about that?

[0:48] Brianna Jones: Yeah, yeah, yeah, you're right, because they won't last more than three seconds.

[0:51] Andrew DeWolf: Um, we fucking hate JK Rowling.

[0:54] Jesse McAnally: She's a big turf piece of shit and has used her platform to do nothing but harm people that desperately need help, and I hope that the worst things in the world could happen to her.

[1:06] Andrew DeWolf: Dabs.

[1:08] Jesse McAnally: Dab on that. I do not want to endorse any of the products that she creates.

[1:13] Andrew DeWolf: I did not watch that stupid Secrets of Dumbledore movie.

[1:16] Jesse McAnally: I'm not gonna play that stupid Harry Potter video game. I'm not giving her any more money.

[1:20] Andrew DeWolf: However, this fan work that has nothing to do with her, nor does she see a cent from, I am more than happy to talk about.

[1:30] Jesse McAnally: This is the best Harry Potter product to ever exist.

[1:34] Andrew DeWolf: Because JK Rowling gets no money from it.

[1:37] Jesse McAnally: And you know what? You can't beat that. On that note, in case you haven't picked up what we were throwing down today.

[1:43] Andrew DeWolf: This week, we are talking about a Harry Potter musical.

[1:48] Jesse McAnally: Actually, no. This week we are talking about because I'll go into why that is a very specific thing I have to change.

[1:56] Jesse McAnally: Because it was uploaded as a Harry Potter musical, then they had to change it. Um, this is A Very Potter Musical.

[2:00] ♪ Musical number: "Hogwarts" — performed by the cast ♪

[2:00] Jesse McAnally: A Very Potter Musical is a musical written by Nick Lang, Matt Lang, and Brian Holden with music and lyrics by AJ Holmes and Darren Criss. It was performed from April 9th to 11th, 2009 on the University of Michigan campus. Soon after, the group posted the entire musical on YouTube. However, it was later taken down and edited to make it less inappropriate for younger audiences and was posted again, slightly edited under the new title of Harry Potter Musical from Harry Potter the Musical in late June 2009. As of March 2018, the production in its entirety has around 100 million views. Due to the nature of the musical, Team Starkid is allowed by Warner Brothers to host the musical on their channel and owns the rights to the song, script, and all that other stuff, but they do not own the rights to Harry Potter characters and cannot make money off the production, nor can they give the rights of the show to any other production company. The University of Michigan version is the only official production. This has not stopped unauthorized productions from being performed, and blah blah blah blah. Fuck JK Rowling.

[3:31] Jesse McAnally: Okay, the plot of A Very Potter Musical is Harry and his pals are in for adventure when the Dark Lord returns from the dead to take revenge on the boy who lived. So take a ride on Voldemort's Flying Machine and get ready to go back to Hogwarts. Harry and his pals are in for adventure when the Dark Lord returns from the dead to take revenge on the boy who lived. So take a ride on Voldemort's Flying Machine and get ready to go back to Hogwarts.

[4:01] Andrew DeWolf: I think I just said that whole thing twice, if you really...

[4:01] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, I think you might have. I have a question before we get started, though. So how like Bridgerton the musical or whatever they were sued for what? And using the same type of characters, intellectual property, all that type of stuff. Does this fall into the same category?

[4:26] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, but the difference is, and this is a very key difference. Bridgerton charged money for them to go to a live show.

[4:37] Jesse McAnally: Like ranging in the hundreds of dollars, like 170, 150 dollars.

[4:42] Andrew DeWolf: Um, this was a free show that they uploaded for free on YouTube. Now they, the only way they're making money off this is the ads on every YouTube video, not charging people to buy this. So they can sell the original songs, they can sell the original script, they cannot sell the play, they cannot license the play, they cannot charge people to come see the play.

[5:10] Jesse McAnally: Interesting.

[5:11] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, like I elaborate on that well.

[5:14] Jesse McAnally: Like, yes, it makes sense, but also the difference is Is this something that's gonna compete with the IP owned by J.K. Rowling and Warner Brothers?

[5:25] Andrew DeWolf: No, it is not. Would the Bridgerton musical being performed live at the Kennedy Center to a sold-out audience for selling for $150 a ticket when there's also the Bridgerton experience in New York City that they could go to see and they're using the same branding? Yes, that is an issue.

[5:43] Jesse McAnally: So, fun fact about that. Um, they had to pull, as I said earlier, they had to pull down this show for a good couple of weeks because of the Warner Brothers issue. So they retitled it from The Harry Potter Musical to A Very Potter Musical and put it very clearly that this is a parody.

[6:00] Andrew DeWolf: And they removed some of the jokes that might harm the branding at the request of Warner Brothers, and they kind of made the arrangement there.

[6:07] Jesse McAnally: Um, they literally sing a song about how they don't want to be sued. They literally sang a song like, hey, just wait a bit, it'll be up in a few a little bit, but we don't want to get sued.

[6:17] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. I guess that does make more sense now. I didn't realize the Bridgerton experience was Bridgerton branding and like a part of that entity.

[6:27] Jesse McAnally: And they were also selling t-shirts that says the Bridgerton Music. They were hubris, hubris alone is what happened to the Bridgerton girls.

[6:36] Andrew DeWolf: It's because they won that award and they just thought that they could do anything.

[6:40] Jesse McAnally: Honestly, yeah, and you know what? They've disappeared ever since they got sued. They haven't said a fucking thing. Their UK concert was canceled.

[6:48] Andrew DeWolf: I mean they're gonna be fine, obviously, but I'm gonna be curious what their next step is.

[6:54] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. Especially like when you hear that they didn't like they had gotten several notices about being sued and just kind of like, or not being sued, but like asked to stop um right in the line and then they're just like, nah, nah.

[7:09] Andrew DeWolf: The thing that bothers me is they were offered um basically rights like, hey, if you share some of that with us we can give you a license to do this and they were like nah because they thought the court of public opinion would be on their side but we weren't. Now there have been arguments like if they were male um if they were male composers they wouldn't get as much backlash I don't know about that that wasn't the way that the cards fell but I think it was pretty it fell on their hubris a lot to like not even like consider the alternatives they should have just taken the license they still could have made shit tons of money.

[7:09] Jesse McAnally: Exactly but they wanted all of the money.

[7:09] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah like come on it's just selfishness and stupidity so what they should have done to tie this back in is do what Starkid did take the notoriety they're getting from this known property that is bringing people in and then make your own original content from it and make the twisted and make the guy who didn't like musicals and make the Black Fridays that will stand on their own because people came in for the Harry Potter one or the Bridgerton one.

[8:16] Jesse McAnally: But they didn't do that they just latched on to the Bridgerton name and hoped that no one would notice or care.

[8:24] Andrew DeWolf: So anyway A Very Potter Musical yes Andrew this is your first time watching this and we've had a history with Starkid.

[8:32] Jesse McAnally: We covered Twisted, Guy Who Didn't Like Musicals, Holy Musical Batman, and Black Friday on this podcast and now we're going all the way back to their very first show and I actually remember when this got posted I remember the day this hit YouTube.

[8:46] Andrew DeWolf: It was wild. What a wild time. Um But in the year of our lord 2022, you watched this all the way through. What is your thoughts on it? And what is it about? And what's your history with Harry Potter? Just take it away, man.

[9:00] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Um, well, I mean, I guess history with Harry Potter. Uh I think I've seen most of the movies. I read like the first two books when I was a kid. I thought they were fine. I thought the movies were okay. I feel like the movies got bad when it got towards the end. The last I think the last one is the only one I couldn't watch. I literally started it and just decided, nah, I just can't.

[9:30] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[9:30] Andrew DeWolf: And um JK Rowling is a piece of shit. Um, and there's a lot of really garbage shit in this in these books. Anti-Satan. Still can't believe all that. I cannot believe they named a character Cho Chang. Like I can't I cannot believe that's real. That one Jewish character at Hogwarts is named Anthony Goldstein. The uh the black character is named uh King Shackelford or something like that.

[10:01] Jesse McAnally: Kingsley Shacklebolt.

[10:03] Andrew DeWolf: Kingsley Shacklebolt, pardon me. Um wow. That's bad. Also And don't forget that the slaves like being a good thing.

[10:13] Jesse McAnally: Yes, they love being enslaved.

[10:16] Andrew DeWolf: Um Hermione, don't you get it through your own? No adaptation has ever touched that plot line, huh?

[10:24] Jesse McAnally: As far as this goes, it's basically just uh it feels like Tumblr culture.

[10:32] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Am I like wrong there?

[10:36] Jesse McAnally: But that's a check-in on the A question. Because I think this came slightly before Tumblr culture became what it was, and I think it inspired Tumblr culture and what it would become so much that yeah, it is Tumblr culture, but it made the Tumblr culture.

[10:51] Andrew DeWolf: So it's like um proto Tumblr culture.

[10:57] Jesse McAnally: Exactly that.

[10:59] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Uh the I I like some of the stuff. I mean, honestly, there's stuff in here that's better than anything that's in Harry Potter. Like when he's like Voldemort Quirrell relationship is actually fun and good, and I like it. That's probably the best part of this entire show. Harry just being an asshole is kind of funny.

[11:23] Jesse McAnally: More accurate to the book than the movies, sincerely.

[11:27] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, kinda. Um, there's a lot of jokes that are just like not good, though.

[11:35] Jesse McAnally: What joke is aged the worst?

[11:39] Andrew DeWolf: Aged the worst? I mean, there's a lot of like jokes about like Zach Efron that I don't think are remotely relevant now. Uh uh Wizards of Waverly Place is brought up like 15 times. Does anyone even remember that show? Um Selena Gomez was on it, and she's now on Only Murders in the Building. Uh yeah, I don't know. I the jokes I just don't get. Like everything they did with Malfoy, I just don't understand.

[12:13] Jesse McAnally: What do you mean?

[12:13] Andrew DeWolf: Why is Malfoy's joke that he like rolls around the stage? Is that the thing?

[12:19] Jesse McAnally: It's funny, isn't it?

[12:20] Andrew DeWolf: No, it's not. It's just because the actress thought it was funny.

[12:24] Jesse McAnally: So a lot of this show was made up on the fly. They basically wrote it in a couple weeks.

[12:31] Andrew DeWolf: And Darren Criss insists to this day, who plays Harry Potter, that he made up every line that he delivered on the spot.

[12:38] Jesse McAnally: For this, I can believe it, honestly.

[12:41] Andrew DeWolf: I can believe it. Like everybody else knows what's happening, and Harry's just like, what? What's going on?

[12:46] Jesse McAnally: That's bullshit, man.

[12:51] Andrew DeWolf: And it works for that specific character in this. Um, and also, like, I don't know if you recognize, um, do you recognize the gentleman that played Ron?

[13:02] Jesse McAnally: Um, I like recognized people, but I I couldn't place many of them, except for I'm pretty sure Dumbledore is the twisted guy.

[13:11] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, Jumbledore is the twisted guy.

[13:13] Jesse McAnally: That's the only one I can. I'm not gonna lie, Dumbledore is probably my favorite character in all three of these musicals.

[13:19] Andrew DeWolf: I like Dumbledore, yeah.

[13:21] Jesse McAnally: Dumbledore was good. Because they had a very specific take on him.

[13:26] Andrew DeWolf: On the neck is very strange.

[13:30] Jesse McAnally: Um, but Joey Richter, who plays uh Ron Weasley, was on our podcast.

[13:37] Andrew DeWolf: Darry you remember.

[13:40] Jesse McAnally: You're in Town.

[13:41] Andrew DeWolf: You're in Town. He ate uh while on the podcast, and we got a bad review for it.

[13:45] Jesse McAnally: Um not even our fault.

[13:48] Andrew DeWolf: There was nothing we could have done about that.

[13:49] Jesse McAnally: Um, very nice guy. He had a lot of fun on the podcast, ate on the podcast.

[13:53] Andrew DeWolf: We got a now we have a bad Apple iTunes review for it.

[13:57] Andrew DeWolf: Who cares? Um, he's very good in this, but I only bring that up because he also decided he just wanted snacks throughout the show, so he just started bringing snacks on the stage when he came on and became a running joke.

[14:11] Andrew DeWolf: He always had something, and then there was one time he didn't, and somebody handed him like Twizzlers.

[14:17] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[14:19] Andrew DeWolf: And they make that more of a meme. Like, it is gonna be kind of interesting to take like what started as like just peak college kids fucking around and becoming proper character traits later in these musicals.

[14:32] Jesse McAnally: So basically the only thing that I think was genuinely really good in this is Voldemort and Quirrell. Especially the costume where they're like tied together. Like that looks like it'd be actually difficult to perform.

[14:49] Andrew DeWolf: Yes. And I want to give credit to both actors in that situation that were able to make both characters come to life in a genuine way despite being attached to each other's backs. I feel like that was the only part that I was like, wait, this is like good. And then the rest of it was like, oh, this is like memes about Harry Potter.

[15:12] Jesse McAnally: Okay.

[15:13] Andrew DeWolf: Like, I feel like you've got some cringe to bring up. Like, what's cringe about it?

[15:19] Jesse McAnally: I don't know. It's not something that like I can just point to and describe, but it's like the pig farts thing. Like, what's the joke there? Like, it's just not funny. It's just cringy that they keep bringing this up. Um like everyone shitting on Hermione is like, okay, that's a meme because of the books or whatever, but like it just feels mean and doesn't really, it's not funny.

[15:47] Jesse McAnally: Yes, I agree. Like, you know, it's just... And fun fact, this actress that plays Hermione is the only one that doesn't come back for all three.

[15:57] Andrew DeWolf: I wonder why.

[15:59] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. You know, it's just a lot of people. I gotta quite like they get to points where they're close to making a point. Like with the Cho Chang character.

[16:12] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I was gonna bring that up at some point.

[16:14] Jesse McAnally: They point out, I mean, they're so... I'm not sure how to describe it. They're pointing out that what J.K. Rowling did was racist, basically. It feels like, but I'm not sure. But okay, so Devin Little, who played Cho Chang, y'all in this show, um, is a white woman, um, and she plays it with a southern accent. The joke is Cho Chang is not an Asian woman, but a white girl. But I feel like the joke is kind of like, damn, could you pick a more stereotypical, like fake name for an Asian character? My God.

[16:55] Andrew DeWolf: And one character assumes that the Asian character is Cho Chang, and they're like, no, that's Lavender Brown. The white girl's Cho Chang. Um, Devin Little, who plays the role of Cho Chang, most recently came out with like a long video about her time at Starkid, which she's like, yeah, that joke would have worked if they had given like Lavender a character to do, but it does feel weird that I take the one major Asian role for anyone in Harry Potter, and our Asian actress doesn't get to play it, and I'm the white actress that does get to play it. Um, and the Asian actress is basically there as a punchline to the joke, like, aha, you thought that it was an Asian character.

[17:36] Jesse McAnally: Yes.

[17:37] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and she also said that, and I guess we're gonna get to the controversy of this show, too. Um, anytime she addressed concerns to the creators, be it Matt Lang, um, Matt Holden, and all them folks, um, like, hey, I don't like this. They just respond with her, oh Devin, you're so pretty, and just walk away, which is Ann Arbor culture if I've ever heard it.

[18:03] Jesse McAnally: It's a bunch of white dudes from Ann Arbor coming and writing a musical with dude bro humor. It feels like that guy with the glasses kind of vibe in a weird way. U of M is like the massive theater hub outside of New York and Syracuse and CMU. Anyone that you see on Broadway, like the current touring cast of Les Mis, basically all of them are U of M um theater graduates. It is one of the biggest hubs for theater people, but it also like Darren Criss, who plays Harry Potter, he's from LA and wanted to become an actor, so we went to U of M. Like U of M is the biggest thing for like very rich people wanting to get into the acting scene, and a lot of folks that are gonna be very, very successful are going to U of M Ann Arbor. Um, which means it's a lot of people that can afford that tuition, and people that have never had to worry about things going in there and being entitled to shit.

[19:04] Andrew DeWolf: So it's a rich people culture.

[19:06] Jesse McAnally: It's rich pe—rich white people culture. Where they think that they're always right and they have the confidence sky high that they didn't earn.

[19:15] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I mean, the top of the meritocracy.

[19:17] Jesse McAnally: They earned everything that they got.

[19:19] Andrew DeWolf: Of course.

[19:20] Jesse McAnally: How did I end up at U of M? It's no way Daddy's money. I worked hard for this.

[19:24] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[19:25] Jesse McAnally: Um, and it—I hate this because when I watched this as a kid, I was just like, heh heh, goofy funny. I watch this and I'm just like, these fucking entitled white douchebags.

[19:39] Andrew DeWolf: And maybe that's just a me thing, and maybe just me growing up in Michigan has turned me into that.

[19:47] Jesse McAnally: So do you think Starkid has improved then? Or are you trying to say that this is just who Starkid is?

[19:52] Andrew DeWolf: I don't think it's just who they are, but the fact is like they have had controversies even since then. Like Robert Manion, who played um Gaston in Twisted, and uh the professor and guy who didn't like musicals was accused of sexual misconduct with a bunch of people that worked on the shows and had to be kicked off of their most recent show.

[20:20] Jesse McAnally: So the culture seems to still be relatively the same.

[20:24] Andrew DeWolf: I do they did take immediate action as soon as I knew. However, still like that kind of culture felt like it had a right to exist there in the first place.

[20:38] Jesse McAnally: Well, they do make uh essentially uh porn parodies for the stage, so I mean I don't know.

[20:46] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know what else to say, you know.

[20:48] Jesse McAnally: That's like feels expected in a way.

[20:50] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, but uh I still love a lot of their work. I love Twisted. I think Twisted's very good for the first hour and 45 minutes. Um, I think this is pretty good in moments too. The problem is what goes on off stage.

[21:07] Jesse McAnally: And I feel like a lot of like there is a lack of diversity. And I live in Michigan. There's more than three African American people that could perform a role, and there's only three in this show. And I know it's Harry Potter, but even the Cursed Child brought more diversity in. And I know 2009 it's a lot to ask of white men to expect more of themselves, but come on.

[21:32] Andrew DeWolf: Well, yeah.

[21:35] Jesse McAnally: So as far as parody shows go, um, this is pretty good.

[21:43] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I feel like it's um if you are uh a Harry Potter fan, you're gonna like it. But you're not a Harry Potter fan, so I'm very interested in what you didn't like.

[21:57] Jesse McAnally: Like it's hard, it's difficult to hear. I don't want to critique like its technical failings, but it is not the most pleasant thing to watch because every five minutes the audience screams and blows out your eardrums. Um I wish there was more uh and it's just it's just not the type of show it is, but I just I wanted more of a biting edge to it, like uh and and I think that's more of a modern perspective of now everyone hates J.K. Rowling, right? Kind of shit. So I just wanted to see more of a teardown rather than just uh uh it's Harry Potter, but like imagine if they were silly, you know.

[22:42] Andrew DeWolf: I'm pretty sure this came out before the even the last movie came out, so yeah, like it hit it pretty early.

[22:50] Jesse McAnally: They were referencing the books a lot, I think.

[22:52] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[22:53] Jesse McAnally: Um I guess I was happy my favorite character came back. I love Quirrell.

[22:59] Andrew DeWolf: Uh Professor Quirrell is my favorite Harry Potter character.

[23:03] Jesse McAnally: You can even in the books.

[23:06] Andrew DeWolf: Even in the books, I love him.

[23:07] Jesse McAnally: Why?

[23:09] Andrew DeWolf: He just, it's weird. He's just got a weird face on the back of his head. It's kind of fucked up.

[23:15] Jesse McAnally: He's like the mayor from The Nightmare Before Christmas.

[23:19] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[23:21] Jesse McAnally: Do you feel like his character might have been a little bit of a racist thing as well when J.K. Rowling wrote it?

[23:25] Andrew DeWolf: Like, what do you mean?

[23:28] Jesse McAnally: Like the turban.

[23:30] Andrew DeWolf: Guy wears a turban and turns out to be hiding something evil. Only person in the entire school that wears one, and of course it's hiding an evil face that wants to kill everybody.

[23:45] Jesse McAnally: I'm not gonna say you're wrong, but I don't think I know enough about turbans and what they mean to the culture.

[23:53] Andrew DeWolf: Fair enough.

[23:55] Jesse McAnally: Um who do you think is the MVP? Like performer-wise. Is there anyone that got more laughs?

[24:01] Andrew DeWolf: Not even like story and writing, like as a performer.

[24:05] Jesse McAnally: I feel like it's either Voldemort or uh Dumbledore.

[24:09] Andrew DeWolf: How'd you feel about Snape?

[24:12] Jesse McAnally: God, I hate Snape.

[24:13] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[24:16] Jesse McAnally: I didn't think Snape was funny in this, and I don't.

[24:21] Andrew DeWolf: This had the um this had the Snape is the most tumblerized character in all history.

[24:28] Jesse McAnally: Um, I'll probably number one.

[24:32] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, maybe, but I feel like this is the start of it. Where it's like just this weird thing with Snape, where they think that he's like really funny and interesting.

[24:43] Jesse McAnally: And I just don't I just don't think he's funny or interesting.

[24:46] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, I think he's funny, but I don't think like what makes you think that they're tumberizing him?

[24:51] Jesse McAnally: Uh only because only reason why I'm saying this is because they really lean into it in the sequel, so I really want to know why you think it's like this now.

[25:00] Andrew DeWolf: Um, jeez, how do I describe it? This thing's fucking three hours long, and he's barely in it. So it's hard to say, I guess. Just I don't know.

[25:13] Jesse McAnally: It's just a feeling I have.

[25:14] Andrew DeWolf: Maybe it's uh maybe it's uh the culture outside of it affecting my interpretation.

[25:22] Jesse McAnally: Because I'm like, I think the actor is doing something and making fun of like how ridiculous the character is. And also they make fun of like McGuffins and how the structure of the shows and how in the first act they set up basically every McGuffin and they highlight it as like, oh, it doesn't matter, you're gonna find out later. It's weird that they make fun of the fact that Dumbledore is oblivious to Snape betraying him or something.

[25:49] Andrew DeWolf: When isn't that a plot point that he knows?

[25:51] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[25:52] Andrew DeWolf: That he's gonna betray him. So like wouldn't a fan of Harry Potter be like, well, he already knows, why would he—what's the joke here?

[25:59] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, something like they skip over logical consistency for humor here, which I appreciate they didn't do for Twisted and other shows that they care more about.

[26:11] Andrew DeWolf: Um, but I feel like they were very like the joke worked first and the plot worked second.

[26:17] Jesse McAnally: When he—when um when Snape brought out the uh the sandwich with the bomb in it.

[26:23] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[26:24] Jesse McAnally: The—the Neil Sicierega video came to mind, the uh Potter Puppet Pals.

[26:30] Andrew DeWolf: I wonder if this like, does this predate that or is it around the same time?

[26:35] Jesse McAnally: Which I feel like Potter Puppet Pals was also another start of the uh the Snape like fandom.

[26:46] Andrew DeWolf: Ooh, the uh the ticking noise predates this by two years.

[26:50] Jesse McAnally: Uh huh.

[26:52] Andrew DeWolf: So they ripped it off.

[26:57] Jesse McAnally: No.

[26:58] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[26:59] Jesse McAnally: A lot of people can have similar thoughts.

[27:02] Andrew DeWolf: Um they didn't play.

[27:03] Jesse McAnally: Oh my goodness, that sandwich was ticking because it wasn't.

[27:09] Andrew DeWolf: Oh my goodness.

[27:11] Jesse McAnally: Well, what's your favorite thing in this, Jess? What did you like?

[27:14] Andrew DeWolf: Honestly, I just like Dumbledore.

[27:16] Jesse McAnally: I feel like his line deliveries are the best, and Dylan Saunders specifically plays it in a way where the joke could have been that he's gay, but it's more that he's just weird.

[27:28] Andrew DeWolf: And I like that.

[27:29] Jesse McAnally: I like that he wears sandals. I think that that's very funny. I think just his look and his line delivery and how he has open contempt for the students is great.

[27:39] Andrew DeWolf: I almost feel like that that is how he should be in the actual stories.

[27:44] Jesse McAnally: It makes more sense for him to be that way. Because like the way the school is run, like clearly nobody gives a shit about these kids.

[27:53] Andrew DeWolf: What was the line like? I just put all the kids that look like good guys into Gryffindor, and all the kids look like bad guys into Slytherin, and whoever else goes into wherever else.

[28:03] Jesse McAnally: The other two are just like empty houses for whoever.

[28:08] Andrew DeWolf: But we have Cedric Diggory in Hufflepuff.

[28:12] Jesse McAnally: Isn't he the only person in Hufflepuff in the entire story?

[28:15] Andrew DeWolf: And he's a particularly good finder.

[28:22] Jesse McAnally: And I find that you're being a little condescending to um Cedric Diggory.

[28:31] Andrew DeWolf: Like I like I like Cedric Diggory too. I think he's fun. I think it's funny when he dies.

[28:37] Jesse McAnally: You think it's funny when he dies?

[28:40] Andrew DeWolf: Because Harry Potter's the only one that'll drink Squirt.

[28:45] Jesse McAnally: What the fuck is Squirt?

[28:47] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, and that might just be a Midwest thing. It's basically like if Sprite had no flavor.

[28:54] Jesse McAnally: No, isn't Squirt the grapefruit?

[28:57] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[28:58] Jesse McAnally: It's grapefruit soda.

[29:00] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it's not great. So that's a joke, just that was a joke for the locals.

[29:04] Jesse McAnally: It might have been. I didn't realize Squirt was a middle.

[29:07] Andrew DeWolf: Me neither. Like, this is a discovery for us.

[29:10] Jesse McAnally: I thought they just made that up.

[29:12] Andrew DeWolf: No, that's a real thing. I thought it was funny when Harry said that he liked it or whatever. Like they keep people kept bringing it up, and he was like, nice. And everyone else is like not willing to drink it.

[29:25] Jesse McAnally: I mean, it is an acquired taste. Sincerely, my dad used to like it when I was a kid. I remember I was um at he was picking me up from play practice, and he's like, I want you to try this because I used to drink this as a kid, and I'm like, this isn't good, Dad.

[29:41] Andrew DeWolf: Well, I like it. It's really Squirt.

[29:44] Jesse McAnally: I like grapefruit, though. I thought they made it up and specifically tried to make it sound like a weird sex drink.

[29:50] Andrew DeWolf: Oh no, it's a real thing. How about we compare our opinions to those of the crazy folks over on Letterboxd.com.

[29:55] Jesse McAnally: It's tons.

[29:56] Andrew DeWolf: This is on Letterboxd?

[29:58] Jesse McAnally: Yes, it is.

[30:00] Andrew DeWolf: Why? This isn't a movie?

[30:03] Jesse McAnally: I don't know, Andrew. I don't have answers for you.

[30:05] Andrew DeWolf: They have YouTube videos up on Letterboxd now.

[30:09] Jesse McAnally: I don't know, Andrew. Like podcasts.

[30:13] Andrew DeWolf: This probably got better reviews than uh the Fantastic Beasts.

[30:19] Jesse McAnally: Fuck. Um, I don't think you could pay me enough to sit through that second Fantastic Beasts movie. And I really like Mads Mikkelsen. I just could not give a fuck.

[30:30] Andrew DeWolf: Are they still written by by JK Rowling on the floor fucking dying?

[30:36] Jesse McAnally: So the first one was written by her solely. The second one was also written by her solely, but it was gibberish. Um, the third one, they brought in the guy that wrote every single one of the Harry Potter movies to write it, and apparently it's coherent but boring.

[30:53] Andrew DeWolf: Just like every one of the Harry Potter movies.

[30:57] Jesse McAnally: That makes sense. Alright, Bree, you're going up against Andrew. You guys ready?

[31:01] Brianna Jones: Yeah.

[31:03] Jesse McAnally: Alright, Bree, you're up first.

[31:05] Brianna Jones: Okay. Showed this to my dad.

[31:12] Jesse McAnally: Five stars.

[31:14] Brianna Jones: That is correct.

[31:16] Jesse McAnally: Bonnie Mama to dad.

[31:17] Brianna Jones: Five stars.

[31:18] Jesse McAnally: Oh, don't show it to your dad, though. I'm just imagining poor dad having to sit through this, and the kid is like, see, it's funny because uh this Harry Potter is and I like Harry Potter, and the dad's like, what's going on? I don't care. Son of mine. Who is who is this guy? What's a Harry Potter? Is that a guy or a girl?

[31:42] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, keep going, keep going.

[31:46] Brianna Jones: No fucking way this is on Letterboxd.

[31:52] Jesse McAnally: Fuck fucking uh five stars.

[31:56] Brianna Jones: That is correct.

[31:58] Jesse McAnally: Bree, you're ready.

[31:59] Brianna Jones: Yes. Hermione is hot, and there's no pics of her on the internet.

[32:03] Jesse McAnally: One star for no pics.

[32:05] Brianna Jones: Hell yeah. There should be pics of you on the internet. What else um.

[32:10] Jesse McAnally: You said she didn't come back. I wonder why.

[32:12] Brianna Jones: Yeah. Um, yeah, that's pretty weird. They like, okay. Can I this is actually kinda gross what they do? Spoilers for a very Potter senior year, which is the third one.

[32:24] Jesse McAnally: Oh god.

[32:25] Brianna Jones: Remember Sherizad from um Twisted?

[32:30] Jesse McAnally: Yes.

[32:31] Brianna Jones: She takes over for Hermione, and they justify it by someone punching her in the face and then her getting up and they're blowing, wow, you're really hot now.

[32:46] Jesse McAnally: They're out of college for several years at this point. Darren Criss is on Glee at this point.

[32:53] Brianna Jones: Wow, you're hot now. Makes me gross. Like, and I think that the girl is. Obviously, the girl that plays Hermione in the first two or is cute. She's like a good looking girl. What the fuck is wrong with these people?

[33:08] Jesse McAnally: Alright, you ready? Whose turn is it? Andrews?

[33:13] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, yes.

[33:13] Jesse McAnally: Get off the fucking internet.

[33:17] Andrew DeWolf: Jeez, sorry. Uh fucking uh one star?

[33:23] Jesse McAnally: That is a five-star.

[33:24] Brianna Jones: Bree, you're a five star.

[33:26] Jesse McAnally: Okay. Wow, the stuff that is aged badly is aged really badly.

[33:33] Andrew DeWolf: One star.

[33:34] Jesse McAnally: That is a five-star.

[33:35] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[33:37] Andrew DeWolf: A squirrel emoji.

[33:42] Jesse McAnally: Five stars.

[33:43] Brianna Jones: That is correct.

[33:46] Jesse McAnally: Free.

[33:47] Brianna Jones: Because squirrel.

[33:51] Jesse McAnally: I like this before Glee happened.

[33:56] Andrew DeWolf: Five stars.

[33:57] Jesse McAnally: That is a one star.

[34:00] Andrew DeWolf: So after Glee happened, it became bad.

[34:03] Jesse McAnally: I guess.

[34:05] Andrew DeWolf: I liked it before Glee happened, but after, no way.

[34:10] Jesse McAnally: I mean, you've watched Glee. You know how bad it is.

[34:12] Andrew DeWolf: It's true.

[34:15] Jesse McAnally: And let us know if you want us to watch the Glee project on Patreon. It'll be a good time.

[34:21] Andrew DeWolf: Alright.

[34:22] Jesse McAnally: Quality sucks, but damn.

[34:28] Andrew DeWolf: Quality sucks, but damn.

[34:32] Jesse McAnally: Uh five.

[34:33] Andrew DeWolf: That is correct.

[34:34] Jesse McAnally: Bree.

[34:35] Brianna Jones: Yes.

[34:36] Jesse McAnally: I would watch a movie about Quirrell and Voldemort.

[34:41] Andrew DeWolf: Five stars.

[34:43] Jesse McAnally: That is a one-star.

[34:44] Andrew DeWolf: I have no idea what I'm doing anymore.

[34:48] Jesse McAnally: Andrew.

[34:49] Andrew DeWolf: Mm-hmm.

[34:50] Jesse McAnally: I can't go to pig farts. It's on Mars.

[34:55] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, this joke. I do I what is the joke? It's so fucking bizarre. Um.

[35:02] Jesse McAnally: You watched five stars because they're quoting it though.

[35:05] Andrew DeWolf: That's a one star. Because they want to go to pig farts. It doesn't even feel like a Tim and Eric joke, though. It just feels like a. The payoff is that Tim or is that like it exists really, and Rumble Roar is a real headmaster.

[35:20] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[35:22] Andrew DeWolf: I guess that's a payoff.

[35:26] Jesse McAnally: Alright, Bree, you ready?

[35:28] Brianna Jones: Yes.

[35:29] Jesse McAnally: JK Rowling?

[35:31] Brianna Jones: I only know Star Kid.

[35:35] Jesse McAnally: Five stars.

[35:36] Andrew DeWolf: That is correct.

[35:37] Jesse McAnally: Andrew.

[35:39] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. I only wish I had half the confidence as Lauren Lopez maniacally rolling around on the floor.

[35:49] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. The people that like Draco Malfoy are the people that I'm imagining that I would not enjoy talking to.

[35:58] Andrew DeWolf: What's wrong with Draco Malfoy?

[36:00] Jesse McAnally: The Draco Malfoy character is just not funny. Does not do a single funny thing in the entire show.

[36:07] Andrew DeWolf: Um they roll on the floor, Andrew. They roll on the floor and they talk about pig farts.

[36:13] Jesse McAnally: I will say they're rolling on the floor laughing. They have one funny joke. One joke that I I chuckled at more than I expected.

[36:22] Andrew DeWolf: And what's that?

[36:24] Jesse McAnally: Like, they set it up where Draco, you think Draco thinks Hermione's ugly because everyone does.

[36:36] Andrew DeWolf: What?

[36:37] Jesse McAnally: It would be a nine. Or nine and a half on a good day.

[36:43] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. That made me chuckle. But that joke goes on for like an hour, and then they do the same joke like ten times.

[36:50] Jesse McAnally: Doesn't matter. The first shock of it made me chuckle.

[36:55] Andrew DeWolf: I got one.

[36:58] Jesse McAnally: Okay, I forget what the review was. Go again.

[37:01] Andrew DeWolf: I wish I could only be half as confident as Lauren Lopez maniacally rolling around on the floor.

[37:08] Jesse McAnally: Okay, five stars.

[37:09] Andrew DeWolf: That is correct. And Andrew, that makes you the winner of reviews today.

[37:14] Jesse McAnally: I'm just in touch with the Star Kid crowd. What can you s what can I say?

[37:18] Andrew DeWolf: Heck yeah.

[37:19] Jesse McAnally: Alright. By the way, Star Kid comes from this show. We didn't talk about that.

[37:25] Andrew DeWolf: It's from the Pig Farts joke, which is a big disappointment.

[37:25] Jesse McAnally: He calls him Star Kid Potter.

[37:30] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it literally it made me sad when I heard it. I was like, oh. That's where they got it. Fuck.

[37:40] Jesse McAnally: Their full YouTube name used to be Star Kid Potter. Uh, and it was it was it actually made me physically sad. Because I was like sitting through like the least funny scene in the entire fucking show, and then I hear Star Kid Potter, and I was like, No, you took it from that.

[38:02] Andrew DeWolf: I thought it was funny. On that note, let's go into a mid-show and then talk about some songs.

[38:16] Jesse McAnally: Hey guys, sorry to interrupt you in the middle of the show, but we've got a shill at you. Today's show is brought to you by the extremely kind donations by our donors over at Patreon. Patreon is this wonderful place where you get tons of flippin' cool content, including patron only podcasts, where me and Liz talk about the Tangled with Tangled TV show, as well as me and Andrew talking uh over movies. I think we recently did both Camp Rock movies. We did a Goofy Movie where Ethan from Sideways joined us. That was actually a really good commentary. We also did all three High School Musical films, the 2004 Phantom of the Opera, the David Hasselhoff, Jekyll, and Hyde. There are actually a lot of commentaries on there, and you should check them all out because they're a good time, a rip roaring good time.

Also, once a month, you can hang out with us on a Patreon um Discord chat, and that's a good time. And our Discord is just a fun place where they send memes to each other. Andrew never pops in there, but I do, and you can ask us.

[39:11] Andrew DeWolf: I've done it like once or twice.

[39:12] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, on your birthday, and never else.

[39:16] Andrew DeWolf: Once or twice.

[39:18] Jesse McAnally: Um, but Bree hops in there, never, but you know what?

[39:23] Andrew DeWolf: Sorry.

[39:24] Jesse McAnally: I've done it more than Bree.

[39:26] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, true.

[39:28] Jesse McAnally: Um, but Andrew, who is currently supporting us over at Patreon?

[39:33] Andrew DeWolf: Oh boy. Our current patrons are Melissa Goldman, Danielle Rennox, Justice Stampede, Ewan Cassidy, Monica Thoreau, Mina Mineary, Brent Black, with Annual Stacey Coon, Joseph Evans Green, Mary Lou Choquette, John Vanales, Russ Walker, Musical Hell, Emily Gracy, Kyle Summers, Janay C, Scootin' the Technical Dream Club, Liz Lim, Alison Staller, Nothing is Certain Except Beth and Taxis Thesbian, Ren Cullen, Raphael Martinez Salaz, Jessica T, Mitchell Young, Chai Teacup, Katie McDonough, Timothy Keyes, Chris Marcote, Mimu, KG, Marie Anastasio, Leela, RJ Nariga, Charlie B. Patrick Deering, Avery Brinson, Bjorn Hermans, Erica S. Toriana Frazier, Sammy the Most Lopez, Leana Morton, Angela, Kylie Bla Kaylee Blazier, Birdman69, Cinemageddon Reviews, Sophina Ali, The Omega Geek, Katrin Evans, Paige Pearson, Matty Wargle, Eliza Erdman, Anna Loskova, Jessica Viray, Sarah Den Blaker, Jess Gray, Jim, Jamila M. Brown, Evan Ball, Wayne Cruz, Zachary Torres, and Spencer Hellyer.

They give us a little extra financial support that helps us keep the lights on here, musical. So geez. If you'd like to join them in supporting us and get tons of fun perks, as well as discounts on all of our merch, come join them over at Patreon. Also, you get video versions of the episode where you're definitely gonna get extended pieces that you won't get on the recording. At least for this session. So come join us. It'll be a good time. Also, buy our merch. Our merch is really cool. We all own a piece of merch. Do you want to be as cool as us one day? You do. Alright, let's get on to the show.

[41:33] Andrew DeWolf: Sick of summer and this waiting around. Man, it's September, so I'm skipping this town. Hey, it's no Mr. V. There's nothing here for me now. I gotta get back to Hogwarts. I gotta get it back to school. I gotta get myself to Hogwarts. But everyone thinks I'm cool.

[41:59] Jesse McAnally: What do you think of the opening number going back to Hogwarts?

[42:04] Andrew DeWolf: Um it's it's a pretty good setup. I I was trying to figure out what what year it was supposed to be, like if it was supposed to take place like after all the Harry Potter stuff happened, and he was just gonna go back to Hogwarts, or like what was going on, and I don't think they ever specify, and it almost works better because of that.

[42:25] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I in the end it turns out this is like his junior year.

[42:31] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, except for as far as the books go, this is like every year combined into one.

[42:37] Andrew DeWolf: Not every year, because we got two more sequels.

[42:42] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[42:43] Andrew DeWolf: But they're taking stuff from like every single book and just putting it in this.

[42:47] Jesse McAnally: Yes.

[42:48] Andrew DeWolf: Which I think is fun because at least it makes it a little bit interesting to watch.

[42:52] Jesse McAnally: Yes, I agree. I think that's like one of the smart like if it was a one to one, there's no reason to watch it.

[43:01] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[43:03] Jesse McAnally: I like this song because it does get caught in my head a bit, but you also learn nothing from it. It's just like a catchy earworm.

[43:11] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like people already know about Harry Potter, and they know that people already know about Harry Potter, and you're not watching this if you don't already know about Harry Potter, so there's not really anything to explain.

[43:23] Jesse McAnally: Except, you know, a catchy earworm.

[43:26] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, basically. Back to witches and wizards and magical beast.

[43:31] Jesse McAnally: I guess.

[43:33] Andrew DeWolf: But the They should have said Fantastic Beasts.

[43:36] Jesse McAnally: No, they shouldn't have.

[43:40] Andrew DeWolf: The movie about Fantastic Beasts shouldn't have even mentioned Fantastic Beasts.

[43:46] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, maybe. I mean, okay, I kinda dig this opening number. I get that it's pointless, though.

[43:54] Andrew DeWolf: I think it's catchy, and I feel like that's all it needed to be. And they played in the end credits too.

[43:59] Jesse McAnally: How did you feel about the audio mixing?

[44:03] Andrew DeWolf: Um they're singing and there's like score. I feel like I didn't. I think I've adjusted to the crap factor of a lot of bootlegs.

[44:15] Jesse McAnally: That's fair. Um so it didn't feel exceptionally bad to me, but I could probably tell like if I listen side by side with something actually shot well.

[44:29] Andrew DeWolf: I think this will be an interesting experiment because they exponentially get better production value with each sequel.

[44:37] Jesse McAnally: I thought that you said that the third one was like a live reading.

[44:41] Andrew DeWolf: It is. It's an interesting thing because Darren Chris, who plays Harry, he's the only one with a bad mic. Everyone else has like good audio, but just him sounds like shit.

[44:53] Jesse McAnally: Okay, well that's fine. It's just it would almost be better if they all sounded like shit in a weird way.

[45:01] Andrew DeWolf: Just like, why does the main character sound like garbage?

[45:04] Jesse McAnally: I mean you say main character, but we talked about basically everyone except for Harry Potter in our main discussion.

[45:11] Andrew DeWolf: That's because Harry Potter isn't a character in that sense. He's just uh He's just serious for a good amount of books.

[45:20] Jesse McAnally: When you read the books, you're you are supposed to be Harry, essentially. Harry doesn't actually have a personality, which is why it's very funny to see him being an asshole.

[45:32] Andrew DeWolf: Because that kind of is how he treats everybody, because he doesn't really do anything ever. It's funny.

[45:41] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, I think like if you have a blank slate and making them an asshole is a very funny trait. But the fact that they make him an egotistical asshole that just revels in his fame.

[45:53] Andrew DeWolf: It's really good. It's a very funny choice, and Darren Chris just kind of looks the way you would imagine Harry Potter should look.

[46:02] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. Um I think that they knock it out of the park.

[46:07] Andrew DeWolf: Go ahead. What are you gonna say?

[46:09] Jesse McAnally: Well, speaking of knocking it out of the park, let's go on to different as can be between Voldemort and Quirrell, which is their duet about having to be in the same body.

[46:17] Andrew DeWolf: You like plotting a garden, and I like plotting to kill.

[46:23] Jesse McAnally: You think that you should rule the world. I think books are a thrill. Sipping tea on the fire swell. Pushing people in is fun as well. I like folding all my ties. And you have no friends. Hey, that's a surprise. I guess it's plain to see when you look at you and me. We're different. Different as can be.

[46:49] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, this is like the funniest thing in the whole thing. Uh the whole show, I feel like. And the only thing that was never covered even a tiny bit by the books or movies.

[46:59] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. This is like actually a completely original scene that doesn't exist at all. And it's the best thing in here.

[47:07] Andrew DeWolf: Which is why I think Starkid went on to make actually good stuff. Um, where they just didn't adapt things anymore and just made good stuff.

[47:19] Jesse McAnally: Well, you like Twisted, but I mean, uh, we'll go into that later. We're gonna do a ranking at the end of this where we're gonna rank all the Starkid shows.

[47:27] Andrew DeWolf: Oh boy, I'm gonna have trouble probably remembering some of them. Uh but Voldemort and Quirrell is excellent. The different as can be song is uh like a silly number that I like a lot. And they bring up things, logistical things from the story that you wouldn't think about.

[47:43] Jesse McAnally: Like the fact that Voldemort has to watch Quirrell wipe his own butt every day.

[47:50] Andrew DeWolf: It's good. Um Yeah, and then they become like best friends, which is just great.

[47:56] Jesse McAnally: And you become lovers. They are the romantic pairing of this story.

[48:02] Andrew DeWolf: And it it's actually sad and like a little bit tragic what happens in the act in act two. And you're like, damn, Voldemort, don't do that. Like, no.

[48:14] Jesse McAnally: They found a way to make Voldemort compelling in a way outside of Harry Potter. Like, aside from just angry, like, I wanna kill all the They made Voldemort into a character instead of uh just every bad trait JK Rowling could think of shoved into one thing.

[48:31] Andrew DeWolf: He's a racist that hates specific groups. By the way, I hate trans people.

[48:39] Jesse McAnally: Man, fuck JK.

[48:41] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, okay. I I'm sorry, but JK Rowling is like one of the most baffling human beings that for most of my life was held up as a paragon of what we should all strive to be, and then I got common sense and she was called off, called out on like one thing, and now she is an entire hate group in and of herself.

[49:00] Jesse McAnally: I feel like we could go on and on and on, but just um just go on YouTube and watch the Sean video on Harry Potter. Like that's really all you need to do.

[49:07] Andrew DeWolf: Didn't H Bomberguy do a video on JK Rowling or am I thinking?

[49:13] Jesse McAnally: Oh no, no, no, no. Didn't um ContraPoints do a video on her?

[49:18] Andrew DeWolf: Probably also that.

[49:19] Jesse McAnally: Okay. Watch both of those. They're probably both very good. And they'll probably say more than we ever could.

[49:24] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, but JK Rowling's a piece of shit. And donate to the trans rights.

[49:30] Jesse McAnally: J.K. Rowling is um sad. But honestly, the thing is, I feel like we should have seen it coming just based on what's in the text of Harry Potter.

[49:41] Andrew DeWolf: The thing is, for most of our lives, if anyone called out Harry Potter for anything, she got really defensive and would come up with a really shitty excuse.

[49:52] Jesse McAnally: Well, yeah, because the joke used to be that she was so um performatively progressive that she would like just create uh diversity in her books where it didn't exist, basically.

[50:06] Andrew DeWolf: Out of thin air. She's Doubledor's gay now.

[50:09] Jesse McAnally: There's a Doubledor's gay now. Haha. I didn't was never mentioned in the text ever. I never felt the need to say anything about it. But uh, and it's definitely there, 100%. And like stuff like that. And then now she's basically like a far-right reactionary.

[50:23] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know how she switched so fucking far so quickly.

[50:27] Jesse McAnally: She just really hates trans people. That's really all there is to it.

[50:31] Andrew DeWolf: I don't understand like why does anyone hate trans people? And you know where I stand on this very specifically, Andrew, because you saw a debate I was in earlier this week. Um but I don't get it.

[50:46] Jesse McAnally: Why the fuck do people have such vitriol to such a group that has nothing? And it's such a small group, too. It's like the way people talk about it, you think there's like um they're like around every corner. It's like so like I don't know. There's nothing to be mad about.

[51:08] Andrew DeWolf: There's literally nothing to be mad about. What Kool-Aid are they fucking drinking? Or what right wing bullshit podcast are they listening to that's telling them that this is such a big thing to worry about.

[51:21] Jesse McAnally: Joe Rogan.

[51:23] Andrew DeWolf: It's is he like an anti-transhap?

[51:26] Jesse McAnally: Well, that doesn't exist anymore. Hail hail the witch is dead.

[51:31] Andrew DeWolf: I honestly I think it's it is just a disgust thing. They just think it's uh, icky, I don't like it.

[51:40] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. It's a bunch of white men who are uh imagining themselves being emasculated by the trans agenda who it turns them into a woman and they get super angry about it because the only thing that makes them a man is that they own a gun uh or something like that.

[52:00] Andrew DeWolf: But I'd agree with you, but it's JK Rowling, one of the richest women in the world, where it literally would not hurt her at all if she just didn't say a fucking thing about this.

[52:12] Jesse McAnally: But she wants to anyway. I think JK Rowling is honestly on the opposite end. There's like a subset of people who hate men so much and they view trans women as men, so they hate trans women.

[52:26] Andrew DeWolf: Does that make sense?

[52:27] Jesse McAnally: Disgust me. It makes sense though, right? Like I mean, it makes sense in a way that it doesn't make sense to me.

[52:33] Andrew DeWolf: Because I know trans people. They I don't know. It just makes me feel sick to my stomach to think about this shit.

[52:44] Jesse McAnally: And I know this. I don't know. And I know this isn't J.K. Rowling's creation in any way, really.

[52:51] Andrew DeWolf: Oh no, of course not. But you can't not think about her.

[52:54] Jesse McAnally: Although this is uh this is the first Harry Potter property to actually have a gay character in it.

[52:58] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, you're right.

[53:01] Jesse McAnally: But they fuck with it in the next one a little bit.

[53:05] Andrew DeWolf: Well, this is canon to me.

[53:09] Jesse McAnally: Um, this version of Dumbledore is canon to me. But there is a weird thing that happens in the next one that I will want to discuss a lot.

[53:20] Andrew DeWolf: It's not with Quirrell, is it?

[53:22] Jesse McAnally: No.

[53:23] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[53:25] Jesse McAnally: I'll let you watch it and you will 100% understand what I'm talking about when you get there.

[53:31] Andrew DeWolf: Does Quirrell come back?

[53:33] Jesse McAnally: Don't get too hopes up on that.

[53:37] Andrew DeWolf: Uh he doesn't.

[53:38] Jesse McAnally: That sucks.

[53:40] Andrew DeWolf: Like briefly, but not even in the second one.

[53:45] Jesse McAnally: The second one does something actually pretty clever that I like, but we'll talk about that when we get there.

[53:51] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, I forget what we were talking about that JK Rowling came up.

[53:55] Jesse McAnally: Fuck it, who cares? Um, we are.

[53:59] Andrew DeWolf: We are talking about Harry Potter. Um, what did you think about the Ginny song that Harry wrote?

[54:05] Jesse McAnally: I actually think this is kind of a clever gag.

[54:08] Andrew DeWolf: I'm fun and skinny.

[54:12] Jesse McAnally: Uh Ginny. I'm the Mickey to your mini. You the ticket to my winny. Jenny. You hotter than Lovelinny. Wanna take you out to Dinny. Jinny. You're cuter than a guinea piggy. Wanna take you up to Winnipeg.

[54:31] Andrew DeWolf: That's in Canada, you know.

[54:33] Jesse McAnally: Tinny Jinny Jinny. You know, this app it doesn't work, absolutely not. It doesn't work with your name at all. It sounds horrible with your name. It sounds dumb.

[54:41] Andrew DeWolf: This one has a clever gag. I think this one is funny. I don't think this gag has been done before, so I really liked it.

[54:47] Jesse McAnally: He writes the entire song and tells Jinny that her name won't really fit into it, but Jinny's name rhymes with everything in the character that he actually wrote the song for.

[54:58] Andrew DeWolf: It doesn't rhyme with anything at all.

[55:00] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. You're Tom pretty skinny. Really, really skinny. Jinny. And then he changes it. You're probably really skinny. Cho Chang.

[55:11] Andrew DeWolf: It's like this just doesn't work.

[55:13] Jesse McAnally: It doesn't, it doesn't fit here. It's such a good gag.

[55:17] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it's it is pretty funny. They even he's uses guinea pig. I'm gonna take you down a Winnie Pig. That's in Canada.

[55:28] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. It's a funny song. It's a good gag. It's very short, though. I don't I don't think it even counts as a song.

[55:34] Andrew DeWolf: It doesn't, but I think that's one of the few ones that Darren Chris wrote himself.

[55:40] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, probably on the fly.

[55:42] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, he like, especially in the second one, he brings up like, hey, I wrote this like really cool pop song that someone came in and sang with a really stupid voice in this musical.

[55:55] Jesse McAnally: Alright, what else do you think?

[55:57] Andrew DeWolf: They're jokes, Darren.

[56:00] Jesse McAnally: It's a joke. Alright, what do you think about the Ron and Draco discovering they're in love with Hermione called Granger Danger?

[56:08] Andrew DeWolf: Only bringing it up because people would get angry if we didn't. This could mean falling in love, falling in love, falling in love.

[56:39] Andrew DeWolf: With her mind.

[56:57] Brianna Jones: Harry Potter fans.

[56:59] Andrew DeWolf: Um.

[56:59] Brianna Jones: Yes.

[57:01] Brianna Jones: Granger Danger is um a mistake.

[57:08] Andrew DeWolf: Because Draco Malfoy is in it.

[57:11] Brianna Jones: Um.

[57:12] Brianna Jones: And also, honestly, I found Ron to be very annoying in this as well.

[57:16] Brianna Jones: I did not like the Ron character.

[57:18] Andrew DeWolf: Alright.

[57:18] Brianna Jones: Um, you're insulting our former guests like this.

[57:22] Andrew DeWolf: I'm that's not the actor thing.

[57:24] Brianna Jones: I think I just think uh they decided to make Ron an asshole.

[57:30] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[57:30] Brianna Jones: They made every character an asshole too.

[57:32] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, the character's kind of an asshole.

[57:33] Brianna Jones: Except strangely, Dumbledore.

[57:36] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like Ron like smacking his sister early on is what made me like not like him, though.

[57:42] Brianna Jones: Fair.

[57:43] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, you have a little sister. How'd you how'd you get along with her?

[57:47] Brianna Jones: She tried to stab me with a pen.

[57:49] Andrew DeWolf: Did you have it coming?

[57:51] Brianna Jones: Yes.

[57:52] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, then what are you bitching about?

[57:54] Brianna Jones: Nothing. I you didn't hear me complaining.

[57:58] Andrew DeWolf: What'd you do to deserve getting stabbed?

[58:02] Brianna Jones: Exist.

[58:03] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, yeah, that I've done that before too. My brother swung a barbell in my head because of that, too.

[58:10] Brianna Jones: I don't know. The Granger Danger song. It's a little weird, and it's like what, because Hermione's now now looks hot, so now you're like, okay, having a panic attack.

[58:22] Andrew DeWolf: Now, is that a parody of themselves, or is that because that's also what happens in the books?

[58:27] Brianna Jones: Because that is what happens in the books. Suddenly Hermione gets all dressed up and Ron decides he he fine. Dick gets big because of her.

[58:35] Andrew DeWolf: The Draco thing is new ish. Like musical only.

[58:45] Brianna Jones: Trying to tell you.

[58:47] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[58:54] Brianna Jones: What other songs are you have to talk about the Voldemort to dance again where he has his feet, his little feet.

[59:00] Andrew DeWolf: I do like I do like the Voldemort to dance again song.

[59:04] Brianna Jones: Let's chat.

[59:06] Andrew DeWolf: I take my foot.

[59:12] Brianna Jones: My little foot.

[59:17] Andrew DeWolf: And with that foot.

[59:22] Brianna Jones: Oh, how I'd start to shake.

[59:25] Andrew DeWolf: I take two feet.

[59:28] Brianna Jones: Two tiny feet.

[59:31] Andrew DeWolf: Hey, look! That's neat!

[59:35] Brianna Jones: It's coming true. I finally get to dance again.

[59:42] Andrew DeWolf: I like when Quirrell and Voldemort do the little dance line.

[59:45] Brianna Jones: I think that's funny. I love the part where they use the Cruciatus curse to control Harry, which I the fucking um Aladdin musical rips off about five years later than this.

[59:59] Andrew DeWolf: I think it's a funny gag where they force him to dance. It's funny. It's a good one.

[1:00:06] Brianna Jones: Um I feel like there's no good songs after this, though. You got like Voldemort is going down, which kinda is catchy, but not like you're not gonna turn that on to make yourself feel good at the gym.

[1:00:22] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like they it's it's a very top loaded musical, and it's we didn't talk about this, but it's way too fucking long.

[1:00:28] Brianna Jones: Yeah, it's like three hours. And I know Harry Potter movies are long and books are long, but I feel like they got a lot of the self-indulgent, like fuck out of the way. Guys, it's a parody show, two hours max.

[1:00:42] Andrew DeWolf: I respect the fuck out of Brent, who is currently working on his own parody musical, premiering off Broadway in March 2023. Um, he's like trying to get it to a very tight show.

[1:00:49] Brianna Jones: Um, he's cutting it, he has cut it ever since. He's like asking me what feels long. I do appreciate that from him, and my god, you feel the length so much in this.

[1:01:16] Andrew DeWolf: I scroll down and look at how many segments are left, and I'm at like 11 out of 28, and I was like, I was like, oh my god, am I watching all three of them? Is that what's going on?

[1:01:30] Brianna Jones: No, that was just the first one, bro.

[1:01:34] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it's too long. So what they did was they had one performance at around 8 p.m. And then they did their second performance at midnight, and that would go until 3 a.m. And by the end of that, then the recording is uh amalgam of both.

[1:01:54] Brianna Jones: Wow.

[1:01:55] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[1:01:56] Brianna Jones: That's uh that's a long shift for uh for the actors.

[1:02:00] Andrew DeWolf: Performers, yes. Imagine doing and this was just for fun on top of their other class. This isn't for a class, this was just for fun.

[1:02:12] Brianna Jones: You know, it's good that they got it got popular, though. I'm glad I'm happy for them.

[1:02:17] Andrew DeWolf: Well, it basically sprungboarded an entire career. Darren Criss, like, I'm sure Bree even knows who Darren Criss is. Like, he's not a nobody.

[1:02:26] Brianna Jones: I uh everyone in Michigan has their Darren Criss story, especially people that went to U of M, where they're like, Oh, I knew him.

[1:02:33] Andrew DeWolf: Yes. I had the same vocal coach as Darren Criss in college, and he's like, Oh, yeah, he was just a sponge of information, and I'm like, that's nice.

[1:02:42] Brianna Jones: So, did anyone else get a career out of this?

[1:02:45] Andrew DeWolf: Well, Joey Richter went on to be um an actor on Dan Schneider's Henry Danger as well. He would guest on a very popular podcast called Musicals with Cheese in its very early days, which I think is on his resume, one of his biggest claims to fame, if you think about it.

[1:03:02] Brianna Jones: Probably probably, yeah.

[1:03:05] Andrew DeWolf: Um AJ Holmes, who wrote the music, would go on to play um Elder Price in the National Tour of uh Book of Mormon.

[1:03:14] Brianna Jones: And who is StarKid?

[1:03:18] Andrew DeWolf: I'd say Darren Criss is StarKid. But like who's writing the new StarKid stuff?

[1:03:26] Brianna Jones: Well, we'll get to that a bit further, but a lot of them stuck around. Like Lauren Lopez, who plays um Draco has been around still, like, and as well as Dylan Saunders, who played Dumbledore, obviously would play Jafar and would be in Black Friday and Holy Musical Batman.

[1:03:48] Andrew DeWolf: Um then they'd bring on some newbies like Jeff Blim, who would go on to play um Aladdin in The Twisted, and write and compose all of Black Friday and the Guy Who Didn't Like Musicals.

[1:04:04] Brianna Jones: And Mariah Rose Faith, um, who would come on to the guy who didn't like musicals, would perform in the national tour of Mean Girls the musical.

[1:04:16] Andrew DeWolf: So StarKid has started a couple careers at least.

[1:04:19] Brianna Jones: Yes, it has launched a few big careers.

[1:04:23] Andrew DeWolf: Bigger than us, at least, because what do we do? We just shit talk on the internet.

[1:04:25] Brianna Jones: They actually have talent.

[1:04:27] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I mean, shit talking is a talent, but we're not even good at it.

[1:04:33] Brianna Jones: I do want to say I respect a lot of these folks. Like, I'm pretty sure the gentleman that plays Snape is currently going back to school at the University of Michigan to learn copyright law and become a lawyer, which I respect the fuck out of, because we need more people actually studying copyright law.

[1:04:50] Andrew DeWolf: Depends what side he's gonna be on.

[1:04:54] Brianna Jones: That's a good plan.

[1:04:56] Andrew DeWolf: Is he working for the corporations or is he working for the little guy?

[1:04:59] Brianna Jones: I feel like you work wherever the money goes.

[1:05:04] Andrew DeWolf: Don't do that.

[1:05:08] Brianna Jones: We need more Jimmmies.

[1:05:09] Andrew DeWolf: Jimmy Seville or Jimmy McGill.

[1:05:12] Brianna Jones: Jimmy Seville.

[1:05:14] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[1:05:17] Brianna Jones: On that note, what is your actually, Brie? Before we wrap this on up.

[1:05:22] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, what Hogwarts house do you think we all belong to?

[1:05:26] Brianna Jones: Oh gosh. I hope I get the racist one. Please, please, please.

[1:05:33] Brianna Jones: I told everyone for years that I was a Hufflepuff, and then I took like that fucking stupid Pottermore test, and they kept putting me in Gryffindor. They're like, oh no, you're heroic. You belong here. And I'm like, no, you fucking idiots. I'm an idiot.

[1:05:46] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like instead of me saying which one do you guys are that we should just take a quiz.

[1:05:51] Brianna Jones: A group buzzfeed quiz?

[1:05:53] Andrew DeWolf: Are you?

[1:05:54] Brianna Jones: Yeah. But we then we'd all get placed in the same house. We can't do that.

[1:05:57] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like we all belong in the same house.

[1:05:59] Brianna Jones: We're in the house of cheese.

[1:06:01] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, here I'm gonna share my screen. I already found one.

[1:06:04] Brianna Jones: I don't think we do belong in the same house.

[1:06:06] Andrew DeWolf: I I actually I feel like you are a Gryffindor like big time.

[1:06:11] Brianna Jones: What the fuck is that?

[1:06:12] Andrew DeWolf: And I would be Ravenclaw. Andrew, you look like a fucking lion. You belong in Gryffindor.

[1:06:17] Brianna Jones: No, you're right. I'd be in Slytherin.

[1:06:20] Andrew DeWolf: I'm in the racist one.

[1:06:22] Brianna Jones: Yeah, I forgot you are the racist.

[1:06:25] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, here we go.

[1:06:27] Brianna Jones: You don't you love race cards. You are a racist.

[1:06:29] Andrew DeWolf: Wait, wait, wait. How long is this?

[1:06:31] Brianna Jones: Not very long.

[1:06:32] Andrew DeWolf: It's a buzzfeed.

[1:06:33] Brianna Jones: Okay.

[1:06:34] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, thank goodness. You've made it to Hogwarts, which means you've already bought a wand from Olivander's. What's material is at its core?

[1:06:44] Brianna Jones: Unicorn hair.

[1:06:46] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. No, it's a Phoenix feather for sure.

[1:06:48] Brianna Jones: Alright, Brave tiebreaker.

[1:06:51] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, I feel like Phoenix Feather is what I would choose.

[1:06:54] Brianna Jones: Okay.

[1:06:56] Andrew DeWolf: During the end of your exams, you notice that one of your classmates was using an enchanted quill. You've come you come top of class anyway, but they are second. What do you do?

[1:07:08] Brianna Jones: Then I'm tell them to see something, say nothing.

[1:07:08] Andrew DeWolf: See something, say nothing. Why would I nothing?

[1:07:16] Brianna Jones: Wait, wait, I know not that one.

[1:07:18] Andrew DeWolf: No, no, no. I give them a high five.

[1:07:21] Brianna Jones: Yeah.

[1:07:22] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, I thought you said nothing. I mean, I wouldn't tell you, but this one and this one implies if I didn't get top of the class, I would have told.

[1:07:29] Brianna Jones: I'm just never telling.

[1:07:30] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. It doesn't matter.

[1:07:32] Brianna Jones: Yeah.

[1:07:32] Andrew DeWolf: So the answer we chose was give them a high five for managing to sneak the quill into the exam. Honestly, I cheated so much through college.

[1:07:41] Brianna Jones: So um, something say nothing.

[1:07:44] Andrew DeWolf: See something say nothing.

[1:07:46] Brianna Jones: I will cut off.

[1:07:47] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. You would be most hurt if a person called you weak, ignorant, unkind, boring.

[1:07:54] Brianna Jones: Unkind, honestly.

[1:07:56] Andrew DeWolf: I would probably choose unkind as well. What about you, Andrew?

[1:08:01] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like unkind or ignorant, one of the two.

[1:08:05] Brianna Jones: Okay. We'll go with unkind. You're locked in a duel with a skilled opponent. They fire an unknown spell at you. You shout one of these. Which ones are you guys shooting?

[1:08:17] Andrew DeWolf: I don't fucking know. I think he's spelling our numerous. That's the one that they always scream in Harry Potter, so I'm going with that one.

[1:08:25] Brianna Jones: I know Crucius is like the the like the torture curse.

[1:08:31] Andrew DeWolf: Don't I thought they usually scream stupefy.

[1:08:35] Brianna Jones: I'll go with the first one. Whatever. I don't know what these mean.

[1:08:40] Andrew DeWolf: Me either. Gibberish words. It's your fifth year at Hogwarts. It's your fifth year at Hogwarts, and you've just received a fifth year of pig farts.

[1:08:52] Brianna Jones: What the fuck is ha what's a howler?

[1:08:54] Andrew DeWolf: It's an angry letter.

[1:08:56] Brianna Jones: Okay. So you received a howler from your parents. What for? Sneaking into the forbidden forest at night on a dare, getting caught cheating.

[1:09:08] Andrew DeWolf: Um in the divin d divinate I can't say it.

[1:09:12] Brianna Jones: Divination.

[1:09:13] Andrew DeWolf: O W L Owl. Uh being put in detention after I was caught in the library after hours.

[1:09:24] Brianna Jones: Nothing. I did never do anything to warrant a howler.

[1:09:31] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, honestly, my parents, I don't think would have done anything.

[1:09:34] Brianna Jones: Well, we'll go with nothing. My parents didn't love me.

[1:09:39] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, this is kinda long. Okay, speed round.

[1:09:40] Brianna Jones: Let's go.

[1:09:43] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. Which of these double door quotations speaks to you?

[1:09:48] Brianna Jones: Pretty the living. And above all, those who love live without love. Words are, in my not so humble opinion, a most inexhaustible source of magic. It matters not what someone is born, but what they grow to be. It is not do do do well on the dreams and forget to live.

[1:10:06] Brianna Jones: Um born and not what it grow to be, because you babies can't be racist.

[1:10:13] Andrew DeWolf: I guess. I feel like I picked the bottom one, the the dream forget to live thing.

[1:10:18] Brianna Jones: You know what? That's better.

[1:10:20] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. Which of these most accurately describe your relationship with your closest friends? Um I love surrounding myself with people. The more friends I have, the better. I have a few very close friends that I would trust with my life.

[1:10:34] Andrew DeWolf: I tend to be uh worry around worry worrying around people, new people, so don't make new friends often.

[1:10:40] Jesse McAnally: I find myself becoming friends with people who can help me succeed.

[1:10:44] Andrew DeWolf: I'd say very friends.

[1:10:47] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[1:10:48] Andrew DeWolf: Which of your skills are you most proud of?

[1:10:51] Jesse McAnally: My ability to absorb new information, my ability to make new friends, my ability to get what I want, my ability to keep secrets.

[1:10:58] Andrew DeWolf: The top one.

[1:10:59] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, new information.

[1:11:00] Andrew DeWolf: New information.

[1:11:03] Jesse McAnally: The first Quidditch match of the season is approaching.

[1:11:07] Andrew DeWolf: You can't wait to get involved.

[1:11:09] Jesse McAnally: What role are you playing?

[1:11:11] Andrew DeWolf: I'm in the crowd.

[1:11:12] Jesse McAnally: Fuck that.

[1:11:12] Andrew DeWolf: I ain't gonna play in that game.

[1:11:14] Jesse McAnally: I'll die.

[1:11:15] Andrew DeWolf: I want to be a beater.

[1:11:19] Jesse McAnally: I want to overrule Jess on this one too, because the crowd isn't even part of the game.

[1:11:23] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it's a bullshit answer.

[1:11:26] Jesse McAnally: I want to play.

[1:11:27] Andrew DeWolf: Are any of us fucking like athletes here?

[1:11:30] Jesse McAnally: Me.

[1:11:31] Andrew DeWolf: I like to beat the shit out of people.

[1:11:33] Jesse McAnally: I played volleyball for like six or seven years.

[1:11:37] Andrew DeWolf: And every other sport.

[1:11:38] Jesse McAnally: Toad.

[1:11:39] Andrew DeWolf: We're taking a toad.

[1:11:40] Jesse McAnally: Okay, you're allowed a pet at Hogwarts, we're taking a toad.

[1:11:40] Andrew DeWolf: It's a toad.

[1:11:40] Jesse McAnally: We're taking a toad.

[1:11:44] Andrew DeWolf: The frog.

[1:11:45] Jesse McAnally: It's Saturday.

[1:11:46] Andrew DeWolf: You finish your homework and you have some free time.

[1:11:48] Jesse McAnally: You decide to spend some time away from your common room.

[1:11:51] Andrew DeWolf: Where do you go?

[1:11:52] Jesse McAnally: The least of the thing.

[1:11:54] Andrew DeWolf: What the fuck is the room of requirement?

[1:11:56] Jesse McAnally: What is that?

[1:11:57] Andrew DeWolf: That's a room where you go that doesn't really exist, and anything you want is there.

[1:12:02] Jesse McAnally: Oh, I'm going there.

[1:12:03] Andrew DeWolf: Me too.

[1:12:04] Jesse McAnally: Fuck yeah.

[1:12:05] Andrew DeWolf: Like, what are you talking about?

[1:12:09] Jesse McAnally: Uh, what would you see in the mirror of Erized?

[1:12:13] Andrew DeWolf: Erised.

[1:12:14] Jesse McAnally: Er said.

[1:12:15] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know.

[1:12:16] Jesse McAnally: It's desired desire backwards, guys.

[1:12:20] Andrew DeWolf: Tells you what you most desire.

[1:12:22] Jesse McAnally: Damn.

[1:12:23] Andrew DeWolf: How did they do it?

[1:12:24] Jesse McAnally: Where did she come up with these ideas?

[1:12:26] Andrew DeWolf: In her turkey little brain.

[1:12:29] Jesse McAnally: Okay, so what do we see?

[1:12:31] Andrew DeWolf: Rich is riches or knowledge.

[1:12:33] Jesse McAnally: One of the two.

[1:12:34] Andrew DeWolf: Knowledge.

[1:12:36] Jesse McAnally: Rich's knowledge.

[1:12:37] Andrew DeWolf: My loving family and friends, a marvelous adventure.

[1:12:40] Jesse McAnally: Okay, we can go with knowledge.

[1:12:43] Andrew DeWolf: Which of these magical events would you most like to experience?

[1:12:47] Jesse McAnally: Christmas.

[1:12:49] Andrew DeWolf: Christmas at Hogwarts.

[1:12:51] Jesse McAnally: You're having trouble mastering a new spell and you've decided to ask for help.

[1:12:56] Andrew DeWolf: Who do you go to?

[1:12:58] Jesse McAnally: My professor, of course.

[1:12:59] Andrew DeWolf: My house ghost, my smartest friend, the library.

[1:13:01] Jesse McAnally: I'll figure it out myself.

[1:13:02] Andrew DeWolf: The library, I'll figure it out myself.

[1:13:04] Jesse McAnally: Figure out myself too fucking proud on.

[1:13:06] Andrew DeWolf: I ain't trusting nobody with that shit.

[1:13:09] Jesse McAnally: Alright, choose a deathly how any of them do except for the.

[1:13:28] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, we can go into the ladies' dormitory.

[1:13:31] Jesse McAnally: Alright, I'm picking the wand.

[1:13:33] Andrew DeWolf: Picking the wand.

[1:13:34] Jesse McAnally: You guys are.

[1:13:36] Andrew DeWolf: You can't override us.

[1:13:39] Jesse McAnally: I did.

[1:13:40] Andrew DeWolf: Uh which path do you intend to follow after leaving Hogwarts?

[1:13:45] Jesse McAnally: Join the police, travel, settle down and fuck a child into my wife and work hard in order to achieve his must success problem.

[1:13:53] Andrew DeWolf: Why is it not that one?

[1:13:54] Jesse McAnally: A suit deep.

[1:13:55] Andrew DeWolf: These ones all suck.

[1:13:57] Jesse McAnally: These ones all suck.

[1:13:58] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, and finally, we is this the only one that matters?

[1:14:03] Jesse McAnally: Are we gonna pick one here?

[1:14:04] Andrew DeWolf: This is the only one that matters.

[1:14:07] Jesse McAnally: Fucking hate this quiz.

[1:14:08] Andrew DeWolf: So which Hogwarts house do you feel you identify with most closely?

[1:14:15] Jesse McAnally: This buzzfeed.

[1:14:17] Andrew DeWolf: They're not real.

[1:14:19] Jesse McAnally: Awful puff it is.

[1:14:22] Andrew DeWolf: What we did one, I'm gonna fucking what a fucking joke.

[1:14:30] Brianna Jones: Bree, read this.

[1:14:31] Andrew DeWolf: Read what we're looking at right now.

[1:14:34] Brianna Jones: You are all the things.

[1:14:37] Andrew DeWolf: So you're 27% Ravenclaw, 26% Hufflepuff, 26% Slutherin, and 21% Gryffindor.

[1:14:46] Jesse McAnally: You seem to be an almost perfect combination of all four houses, which is incredibly rare.

[1:14:53] Andrew DeWolf: You're equal in your intelligence, bravery, loyalty, and ambition.

[1:14:58] Jesse McAnally: And we know though.

[1:15:02] Andrew DeWolf: Guys, we're 25% racist.

[1:15:05] Jesse McAnally: How does that make you feel?

[1:15:06] Andrew DeWolf: Congratulations.

[1:15:10] Jesse McAnally: It's sad that we're more racist than heroic.

[1:15:14] Andrew DeWolf: Well, that was a cheese.

[1:15:16] Jesse McAnally: You gotta have your priorities somewhere.

[1:15:20] Andrew DeWolf: On that note, what is your overall thoughts on a very potter musical and your cheese rating?

[1:15:26] Jesse McAnally: Andrew.

[1:15:26] Andrew DeWolf: Musicals with cheese, more racist than heroic.

[1:15:37] Jesse McAnally: Alright, Andrew, what's your cheese rating?

[1:15:42] Andrew DeWolf: Uh yeah, um.

[1:15:47] Jesse McAnally: So I think it's fine.

[1:15:50] Andrew DeWolf: There's a lot of like dated and kind of cringy stuff, but there's also some good stuff.

[1:15:57] Jesse McAnally: I wish that it was like an hour shorter at least, but I think if you like Star Kid, or if you like Harry Potter, you'll probably like it.

[1:16:09] Andrew DeWolf: Uh for cheese rating.

[1:16:12] Jesse McAnally: I I wanted to find like a cool Harry Potter cheese thing, but all I was able to find was cheese-based potions, which is kind of it just sounds kind of silly.

[1:16:26] Andrew DeWolf: Uh Severus Snape taught his sixth-year potion students how to brew cheese-based potions in class.

[1:16:33] Jesse McAnally: What the fuck?

[1:16:34] Andrew DeWolf: Why would you do this?

[1:16:36] Jesse McAnally: What do they do?

[1:16:40] Andrew DeWolf: But there you go.

[1:16:44] Jesse McAnally: All right, Bria, what'd you think of our discussion in your cheese rating of that?

[1:16:48] Brianna Jones: Uh it was a good discussion. I feel like I actually learned a lot of uh stuff listening to you two talk um that you know um theater is really big in Ann Arbor, um, and some other things.

[1:17:04] Andrew DeWolf: It's in here.

[1:17:05] Brianna Jones: The other things.

[1:17:07] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, the other things.

[1:17:08] Brianna Jones: So don't forget about more racist than we are heroic.

[1:17:14] Andrew DeWolf: Apparently.

[1:17:16] Brianna Jones: That's my favorite quote right now.

[1:17:17] Jesse McAnally: That's good.

[1:17:19] Brianna Jones: But um you said it was three hours long.

[1:17:23] Andrew DeWolf: I'm a busy gal.

[1:17:24] Brianna Jones: I probably won't ever watch this, but don't worry.

[1:17:27] Andrew DeWolf: We got two more fucking musicals to cover on this show.

[1:17:31] Brianna Jones: Um got them.

[1:17:33] Andrew DeWolf: But I, you know, appreciate Harry Potter.

[1:17:37] Brianna Jones: Um, I just don't like JK Rowling.

[1:17:42] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, so I'm gonna give this uh Hufflepuffs, which are just uh cheese puffs on a plate with a sign in front of it that says Hufflepuffs.

[1:17:51] Jesse McAnally: You know what? That's fair.

[1:17:52] Andrew DeWolf: Um I I don't think this show is aged well, honestly.

[1:17:59] Jesse McAnally: I did not enjoy my watching of this.

[1:18:02] Andrew DeWolf: Um I posted a poll on Twitter where I was like, hey kids who love Star Kid for some reason still.

[1:18:08] Jesse McAnally: Um what do you think of like their first Harry Potter musicals?

[1:18:11] Andrew DeWolf: And they're like, they're mostly just kind of cringy and kids having fun, and they got a little charm to them.

[1:18:18] Jesse McAnally: So even the fans don't really love this anymore.

[1:18:22] Andrew DeWolf: That being said, when I watch it, I don't think about the show itself.

[1:18:26] Jesse McAnally: I think about my nostalgia of watching it for the first time more than that.

[1:18:29] Andrew DeWolf: Is that a weird thing to say?

[1:18:32] Jesse McAnally: I finally understand what the nostalgia critic was trying to tap into, which was that nostalgia for bad things that you once enjoyed, and now you have to understand that they aren't actually all that good.

[1:18:46] Andrew DeWolf: And yeah, there's a spark of something good in them, but a spark ain't a fire.

[1:18:53] Jesse McAnally: And on that note, my cheese rating is goat cheese mini brie from the Zingerman's Creamery in Ann Arbor, Michigan, where this was originally performed, and many a douchebag went to school.

[1:19:12] Andrew DeWolf: Good stuff.

[1:19:13] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, I don't think I could have taught that.

[1:19:15] Andrew DeWolf: Are you excited for two more Harry Potter musicals?

[1:19:20] Jesse McAnally: No.

[1:19:22] Andrew DeWolf: Well that's too damn bad, Andrew.

[1:19:25] Jesse McAnally: I'm really I'm just I'm not a Harry Potter fan at all.

[1:19:29] Andrew DeWolf: I'm really not either.

[1:19:31] Jesse McAnally: We should watch uh we should watch the Lord of the Rings musical sometime.

[1:19:35] Andrew DeWolf: Are you a Lord of the Rings fan?

[1:19:37] Jesse McAnally: Because I am even less of a Lord of the Rings fan.

[1:19:40] Andrew DeWolf: I am.

[1:19:41] Jesse McAnally: You like Lord of the Rings.

[1:19:42] Andrew DeWolf: That's so fucked up to me.

[1:19:46] Jesse McAnally: I'm one of the dwarves, baby.

[1:19:48] Andrew DeWolf: So fun fact um, before they did this Harry Potter musical, they did do a Lord of the Rings parody musical that they didn't film, which is where they first put Devin where they put the girl that played Cho Chang Devin Little.

[1:20:01] Jesse McAnally: She was supposed to be um, I think heroine.

[1:20:05] Andrew DeWolf: Um, just because she was the only pretty girl among them.

[1:20:09] Jesse McAnally: And they literally only brought her into the group because she was pretty.

[1:20:13] Andrew DeWolf: According to her, at least.

[1:20:15] Jesse McAnally: Classic.

[1:20:17] Andrew DeWolf: White entitled men.

[1:20:19] Jesse McAnally: Am I right?

[1:20:20] Andrew DeWolf: They'll always stay the same.

[1:20:23] Jesse McAnally: Am I right?

[1:20:25] Andrew DeWolf: Ann Arbor culture.

[1:20:26] Jesse McAnally: That's me.

[1:20:27] Andrew DeWolf: Full of douchebags.

[1:20:30] Jesse McAnally: You know, Jess, you're one of them.

[1:20:32] Jesse McAnally: I'm not.

[1:20:32] Andrew DeWolf: You went to school there.

[1:20:33] Jesse McAnally: No, I didn't.

[1:20:35] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, you did.

[1:20:36] Jesse McAnally: I went to Detroit, Michigan.

[1:20:39] Andrew DeWolf: Not Ann Arbor.

[1:20:41] Jesse McAnally: 60 miles in the other direction, motherfucker.

[1:20:45] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, but spiritually, you went to Ann Arbor.

[1:20:49] Jesse McAnally: I did not!

[1:20:49] Andrew DeWolf: Don't you fucking dare say that?

[1:20:52] Jesse McAnally: That is worse than saying I don't know.

[1:20:55] Andrew DeWolf: That is a very big insult.

[1:20:56] Jesse McAnally: I take that very offensively.

[1:20:57] Andrew DeWolf: Don't say I went to U of M.

[1:21:01] Jesse McAnally: I was not giving enough opportunity to go to U of M.

[1:21:05] Andrew DeWolf: How dare you accuse me of that.

[1:21:08] Jesse McAnally: But you know who definitely was giving you an opportunity to go to U of M.

[1:21:14] Andrew DeWolf: Hmm.

[1:21:15] Jesse McAnally: Our wonderful patrons.

[1:21:17] Andrew DeWolf: Thank you guys for listening.

[1:21:18] Jesse McAnally: Please follow us on iTunes, Spotify, Stitcher and Music Schools with Cheese.

[1:21:21] Andrew DeWolf: We're on Twitter at Cheesey Musicals.

[1:21:23] Jesse McAnally: We're on Patreon Musicals with Cheese, Instagram musicals with Cheese.

[1:21:25] Andrew DeWolf: We have a YouTube page musicals with Cheese.

[1:21:27] Jesse McAnally: We have a Patreon only podcast called Patreon with Cheese and a bunch of commentaries over there.

[1:21:31] Andrew DeWolf: Come check us out.

[1:21:32] Jesse McAnally: Shoot us an email at musical theater lives at gmail.com.

[1:21:34] Andrew DeWolf: We'll read your email on the fucking podcast.

[1:21:38] Jesse McAnally: Get excited and send us those emails.

[1:21:41] Andrew DeWolf: Our keeper of the cheeses, the amazing, the wonderful Julieta Antonio.

[1:21:44] Jesse McAnally: We're so lucky to have you.

[1:21:45] Andrew DeWolf: Thank you for keeping track of that.

[1:21:47] Jesse McAnally: Our show is produced by the incredible one of my favorite human beings on the planet and definitely did not go to school in Ann Arbor because she's actually a good person.

[1:21:55] Brianna Jones: It's Brianna Jones.

[1:21:59] Andrew DeWolf: I love I Brie.

[1:22:01] Jesse McAnally: Our theme songs were created by the amazing Robin Nash of IOU Music UK.

[1:22:06] Andrew DeWolf: Thank you to the Broadway Podcast Network for having us on the platform and for not kicking us off because of all the Ann Arbor slander we're throwing around on here.

[1:22:14] Jesse McAnally: Alright, guys, anything else we gotta say before we wrap this up.

[1:22:20] Andrew DeWolf: Just linked all these uh this Facebook page.

[1:22:24] Jesse McAnally: And now I'm in uh now I'm trapped in like old Facebook where they're just reposting Tumblr posts.

[1:22:30] Andrew DeWolf: Please tell me what's on there, please, please.

[1:22:34] Jesse McAnally: Well, I found a very potter senior year page.

[1:22:38] Andrew DeWolf: Uh and the top the top is a picture that says, Thank you, JK Rawling for my childhood.

[1:22:47] Jesse McAnally: And then if you scroll down, the last post was in 2013, and it's uh I think it's a uh Sherlock meme from Tumblr.

[1:22:58] Andrew DeWolf: What's the meme say?

[1:23:01] Jesse McAnally: Just read just read Harry Potter, worst series ever.

[1:23:04] Andrew DeWolf: I can't believe they wrote seven terrible books after such good movies, and I think the author got lazy because there are eight movies, only seven books, and then I guess somebody thought that this was real and posted a Sherlock meme that says, Anderson, don't talk out loud.

[1:23:22] Jesse McAnally: You lower the IQ of the entire street.

[1:23:25] Andrew DeWolf: And then there's another comment that says, and the award for the best use of that gith in human history goes to whoever made this.

[1:23:34] Jesse McAnally: And you said that was from 2014.

[1:23:37] Andrew DeWolf: 2013.

[1:23:38] Jesse McAnally: Oof, what a horrible time to be alive.

[1:23:41] Andrew DeWolf: But you know what?

[1:23:41] Jesse McAnally: It's pretty.

[1:23:42] Andrew DeWolf: I just realized that this is it's a Facebook comment of with a gif under it, and then that's posted on to Tumblr.

[1:23:55] Jesse McAnally: And then the Tumblr is screenshot and posted back onto Facebook.

[1:24:02] Andrew DeWolf: Well, we live in a we live in a time.

[1:24:02] Jesse McAnally: We live in a society.

[1:24:06] Andrew DeWolf: We'll see you next time.

[1:24:14] Andrew DeWolf: I gotta get back to Hogwarts!

[1:24:17] Jesse McAnally: I gotta get back to school!

[1:24:20] Andrew DeWolf: I gotta get back to Hogwarts!

[1:24:23] Jesse McAnally: Wherever one thinks I'm cool!

[1:24:25] Andrew DeWolf: Back to witches and wizards and magical beasts, to goblins and ghosts, and to magical feasts.

[1:24:32] Jesse McAnally: It's all that I love and all that I need at Hogwarts.

[1:24:36] Andrew DeWolf: Hogwarts, I think I'm going back.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred