Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#214 - Over the Garden Wall

"Oh, potatoes and molasses If you want some, oh, just ask us..." Grab your pumpkins and frog because this week Jesse McAnally and Andrew DeWolf are talking about the Spooky Cartoon Network tv show "Over the Garden Wall!" Our WEBSITE. Musicals with Cheese on Twitter... Read More

From the show: Musicals with Cheese

1 h 9 mins
10/13/22

About

"Oh, potatoes and molasses If you want some, oh, just ask us..." Grab your pumpkins and frog because this week Jesse McAnally and Andrew DeWolf are talking about the Spooky Cartoon Network tv show "Over the Garden Wall!"

Social Media:

Our WEBSITE

Musicals with Cheese on Twitter

Musicals W/ Cheese on Instagram

Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com

Merch!!

Jess Socials

Jesse McAnally on Twitter

Jess McAnally on Instagram

Andrew Socials

Andrew DeWolf on Instagram

Andrew DeWolf on Twitter

Brianna Socials

Brianna Jones on Twitter

Brianna Jones on Instagram

Use our Affiliate Link

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:17] Jesse McAnally: Hi, I'm Jesse McAnally. I'm the host of Musicals with Cheese, but I'm not just that, I'm also a filmmaker, and today I am launching a Kickstarter to help fund my first feature film entitled The Daughters of the Domino. The plot follows Detective Nina Rose, a claim for arresting her own serial killer father, the Domino, but destroying her relationship with her sister Laura. Years later, the Domino is dead. But Laura's daughter Jules goes missing, so the sisters must reunite and work together to find Jules before it's too late. Sounds like a pretty good film, right? Something you'd like to see? Well, that's why you should check out our Kickstarter or go to Daughters of the Domino.com for more information. I repeat, Daughters of the Domino.com. So what are you waiting for? We gotta get this movie made, and we can't do it without you. Go check us out.

[1:00] Jesse McAnally: Hello, I'm Jesse McAnally.

[1:02] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm Andrew DeWolf.

[1:04] Liz Eston: And I'm Liz Eston.

[1:05] Jesse McAnally: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, a podcast where I try to get spooky Andrew and Spooky Liz to like Ooky Spooky Musical Theater. Ha ha ha ha! How are you doing today, Andrew?

[1:16] Andrew DeWolf: Oh boy, I'm spooked. I'm absolutely spooked beyond belief.

[1:23] Jesse McAnally: I feel like there's no sincerity coming out of that statement whatsoever.

[1:28] Andrew DeWolf: I'm scared. Um, and I am frightened and I'm spooked.

[1:32] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, me too. Me too. How have you been though, aside from all that?

[1:36] Andrew DeWolf: Well, you know, it's been a little weird, but that's what happens when you get lost in the woods for ten episodes.

[1:46] Jesse McAnally: Um, fair enough. Um, I feel like have you noticed that there's something following us? And the highwayman warned us about the beast.

[1:54] Andrew DeWolf: It was is the woodsman, actually, the highwayman just sang a little song. We got warned about the beast basically by everyone we bumped into in this scenario.

[2:02] Jesse McAnally: Am I Greg and your Wart or am I Wart and your Greg?

[2:05] Andrew DeWolf: I don't think I want to be either of them. Can I be the bird?

[2:08] Jesse McAnally: Okay. Liz, you're Wart.

[2:10] Liz Eston: No, I don't be Greg.

[2:11] Andrew DeWolf: Nope. This week nobody wants to be Wart. Nobody likes Wart.

[2:15] Jesse McAnally: This week, in case you haven't picked up what we're throwing down, by popular demand, we are covering Over the Garden Wall. Q the music Brie.

[2:18] ♪ Musical number: "Over the Garden Wall Theme" — performed by The Blasting Company ♪

[2:56] Jesse McAnally: Over the Garden Wall is a TV show made for Cartoon Network created by Patrick McHale. Um, with music and lyrics by an American Novel Nouveau folk band called The Blasting Company. Um, it made its premiere on Cartoon Network on November 3rd, 2014, and ran for over five consecutive nights. The series centers on two half-brothers who travel across a mysterious forest to find their way home, encountering a variety of strange and fantastical things on their journey. Andrew, have you heard about the show before we covered it today?

[3:26] Andrew DeWolf: I think the only thing I've seen of it is that there's a bunch of frogs in it.

[3:29] Jesse McAnally: And there is a bunch of frogs in it.

[3:30] Andrew DeWolf: There is. Yeah. It's a debate of what there is more of frogs or turtles.

[3:34] Jesse McAnally: Well, I mean, I think literally speaking, there's more turtles because there's that one episode with the basket of turtles, but there's turtles in basically every episode.

[3:41] Andrew DeWolf: I didn't even notice that. Um, and also like this show, there's nothing like this show. It's like I wouldn't even call it a kid's show, weirdly enough. Feels like closer to Courage the Cowardly Dog than any other show, and I wouldn't even call I wouldn't show that one to my kid.

[3:55] Jesse McAnally: We shouldn't have been watching that as children.

[3:57] Andrew DeWolf: I had nightmares from Courage.

[3:58] Jesse McAnally: I didn't watch that.

[3:59] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, that shit was funny. The slap episode.

[4:01] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. The weird CGI mix, unpleasant.

[4:05] Andrew DeWolf: It's not good to look at. It's just ugly and scary.

[4:09] Jesse McAnally: And on our four by three CRT TVs where the quality is even worse.

[4:13] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. It felt like he was coming out. He was gonna guess.

[4:16] Jesse McAnally: He was coming out of the TV.

[4:18] Andrew DeWolf: But there's things of the same ilk in this show as well. There's like very spooky things, very unpleasant. Like the beast alone is terrifying, which is the antagonist of the story.

[4:28] Jesse McAnally: The beast is pretty scary looking. They don't show the actual design except for like a frame for more than like um like yeah, I think I went through it was like three frames because I wanted to see what he looked like. And he looks like Freddy Kruger except made of wood. And that's scarier than if we saw him the whole time.

[4:44] Andrew DeWolf: Um and then his the rest of the show he's like a dark silhouette with antlers. It reminds me of that one movie that's on like Netflix or something, but I can't even remember what it was called, like the ritual or something like that.

[4:54] Jesse McAnally: I never heard of it. But the antagonist is like a human torso with antlers. Um, the design was similar. Um, what would you describe the plot of this show is? Because uh it's not I feel more like a narrative movie with like vignetted segments because the entire thing's about two albums. We gotta get out of the woods. Into the woods and out of the woods and a home before dark.

[5:16] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, I think that is generally just the plot. They have to get out of the woods.

[5:19] Jesse McAnally: I mean, there is that, but you also have like all these characters that build upon it, especially like Beatrice, who I think is important to bring up.

[5:27] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. There's other stuff going on, but the one through line narratively is just they're trying to get out of the woods.

[5:33] Jesse McAnally: I mean other stuff happens. And our main characters, Wert and Greg. Um, what do you think of them?

[5:39] Andrew DeWolf: Greg feels like he's from a different Cartoon Network show. Like it feels like he's the comedy character. He's the one that's like, well, this is a Cartoon Network show. There has to be a kid to make the kids laugh. And then Wert is just annoying.

[5:52] Jesse McAnally: Um, you think he's just annoying.

[5:54] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. I feel like he gets better though. He has like an actual character arc. I don't know. I didn't like him much at the beginning.

[6:01] Jesse McAnally: That's fair. He is kind of pretentious in a way. I think you the whole show is a vibe-based show. You know what I'm saying? And I think that's where the music comes in. Because even though there isn't like songs in every episode, there's always like ambient music that's like it's just it's a vibe.

[6:18] Andrew DeWolf: I completely this is this is what they put in the New York Times, probably.

[6:23] Jesse McAnally: I mean, yeah, this is what Ben Brantley would write. Um, and he'd write a narrative about his entire vibe.

[6:29] Andrew DeWolf: Bro, it's like a vibe-based thing, bro.

[6:32] Jesse McAnally: You're not wrong. There's like if you if you type in Over the Garden Wall onto YouTube, there's like 50 compilations of just music played on piano with like the imagery going on. Um, this is just something you can put on at a Halloween party and just the visuals alone will give you like the proper feeling.

[6:50] Andrew DeWolf: Um, so do you feel like I mean this is obviously an original idea. Um, and we're gonna get metaphysical here. Did you know what it's based on? And did you figure it out halfway in?

[6:57] Jesse McAnally: Based on.

[7:01] Andrew DeWolf: It's based on a popular story or the truth if you're some parts of America. Uh I guess I didn't, I don't.

[7:08] Jesse McAnally: It's based on Dante's Inferno, where you have the character who's a poet named Dante, um, who's trying to get the.

[7:18] Andrew DeWolf: Yes. Where he's trying to get through all these levels of the Inferno to get to his love Beatrice.

[7:26] Jesse McAnally: Um, and if you break down each of the nine episodes, and they are nine um circles of the inferno, they match up pretty well with what happens in the episode. Like you have limbo, lust, gluttony, greed, wrath, heresy, violence, fraud, and treachery. And in each episode, there's something that lines up with that.

[7:46] Andrew DeWolf: And if you look at what Dante looked like, um and compare it to the way that Wert is dressed, they are very, very similar images.

[7:53] Jesse McAnally: I guess I can sort of see that. Honestly, usually I am looking for that type of stuff, and I didn't pick up on that.

[7:59] Andrew DeWolf: Um I like Dante's Inferno, but I did not pick up on that at all. And that's kind of the reason why the show works for me. Like it's not heavy-handed in anything it does, and there and not to say that it's grimdark, but it takes itself seriously. There are comedic moments, specifically with Fred the Horse, who I think is probably one of my favorite characters in this. I think it is a perfect entry in the genre of children's horror.

[8:24] Jesse McAnally: Okay, which is a genre that I think is too uh too often neglected.

[8:28] Andrew DeWolf: What else would you put into children's horror? Like, I know it's been a very bleak genre for the last like 10 years. You have like Goosebumps and stuff like that, you know.

[8:36] Jesse McAnally: Wait till later this month, kids.

[8:38] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Oh, yeah, yeah. That's gonna be good actually.

[8:41] Jesse McAnally: Umps is a good example. Uh, you know, there's other TV shows like um This is what Dante looks like. The one where they Are You Afraid of the Dark?

[8:53] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, that one. Are you afraid of the dark? Um honestly, it's hard to name entries because there's so few of them. Like, would you I'd count like Gremlins and Krampus in there too?

[9:02] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, Gremlins for sure. Krampus might be too edgy, but I really Krampus is too edgy.

[9:08] Andrew DeWolf: What? I think I would put it there, but there's a lot of people that I think would be a good thing.

[9:14] Jesse McAnally: They wouldn't show it to kids though.

[9:16] Andrew DeWolf: No, no, no. No. I saw it in theaters. It was like people over 13. Like no children were there.

[9:21] Jesse McAnally: But yeah, I mean, I think this is a really good entry though. Um, because it's the thing that with that some children's horror doesn't have, and I feel like Goosebumps sometimes does this, is it's just not actually scary at all.

[9:34] Andrew DeWolf: Like it's not even like a little scary.

[9:36] Jesse McAnally: Right. Um, and it's like, well, it's not actually horror if it's not scary, even a little bit. Like, it has to be kind of scary. They're afraid to put actual stakes, and they always undercut the threat. Here, while there is comedy, the threat is never undercut.

[9:51] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I mean, one of the main characters almost fucking dies. As far as we know, they might have died. Maybe.

[9:58] Jesse McAnally: Um, I do have a question about narrative linearity here. So we have basically a complete narrative. We start the show and they're just wandering around the wood. Like when you started, what time period did you think this took place in?

[10:11] Andrew DeWolf: Honestly, I thought they were just going for like an ambiguous, like, you know, 18 to 19x.

[10:18] Jesse McAnally: Yes. And then episode nine happens.

[10:22] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, episode nine happens and it's like, oh, okay, so it's like modern.

[10:25] Jesse McAnally: Well, they're modern, but so it's actually at first you don't know because it's like, is this just they live in this weird world and they actually are just trying to like get to their house or something? Or are they from a different world and are like trapped somewhere? And it turns out it's that. And I think that's like one of those brilliant reveals. And in the commentaries, that was originally the first episode, episode nine. That was how they planned to start.

[10:45] Andrew DeWolf: But then they thought I think that would have been a much crappier opening.

[10:50] Jesse McAnally: I mean it would have read more like a chowder kind of show or more like uh adventure time kind of show because of it. It would have been too obvious that like there'd be too much of a juxtaposition immediately, where it's like, oh well, they're trying to go back to the real world, you know. And you just feel the Wizard of Oz side of it where you as soon as you see them go down, you think, oh, it's a dream.

[11:11] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[11:12] Jesse McAnally: Whereas with this, you're like, oh shit, just weird shit happens. Like, I don't even know. And I think I like imagine just a small change could have made this much worse.

[11:22] Andrew DeWolf: Well, I mean, I think that's the case with a lot of stuff, you know. Sometimes something is put together so well that any change would just drastically alter its quality.

[11:33] Jesse McAnally: Now they go to a lot of places in the show. Um, because this is a vignette style show. What do you think the best place they went to is like what is your favorite episode?

[11:41] Andrew DeWolf: My favorite. I think I mean my favorite is the final episode. But if we have the vignette stuff.

[11:50] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. Probably the tavern or the pumpkin patch place.

[11:55] Andrew DeWolf: Ooh, I love the pumpkin patch place because just the anti-climax of it. A lot of these are kind of based on anti-climaxes where they set up what should be a threat and then they reveal there's more to the story, which I really like. That's the narrative device I like.

[12:08] Jesse McAnally: Well, I think it's fun and it but they never undercut it too much because even if the threat isn't the threat, the overarching threat is always present and is actually bad.

[12:09] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, like, let's take um Mr. Underco Windicot Indicat, um, the old man played by John Cleese, where he thinks he has a ghost.

[12:28] Jesse McAnally: Yes, which I think he's the ghost, you know.

[12:30] Andrew DeWolf: Quincy Endicott. Yes. I don't understand why people don't like Greg, because that's great. I love Greg.

[12:39] Jesse McAnally: Um, I do have a story about Greg a little bit later, um, but the fact is the ghost he sees is just his neighbor who he immediately falls in love with, which is weird.

[12:50] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, and then he's never seen again, but the neighbor is. It's weird because John Cleese is seen again, and he plays Adelaide, which is a strange range.

[12:59] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. Um, which is a strange choice by the creators. But another time that's done is Auntie Whispers. Um, if you remember her as played by Tim Curry, who oh my god, a poor man. I thought that there was gonna be something with the turtles in that where she was eating the turtles, because she looked kind of like the dog from the first episode.

[13:18] Andrew DeWolf: Well, that's the thing. Well, they both are there's theories that the turtles are a result of the trees. Um they come from the trees that the beasts created and grew, so that the whatever they get involved gets caught up in the beast, which is what happened to the daughter allegedly, is the beast got in her.

[13:36] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, and maybe from the turtles.

[13:38] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, and Auntie Whispers, you think is the threat, but it's really the daughter who is the threat, and she's just trying to keep her at bay.

[13:45] Jesse McAnally: Like things like that that are like basic storytelling for us, but for kids would probably be really like against the grain.

[13:52] Andrew DeWolf: Am I the only one that thought Auntie Whispers was still the bad guy, even after that, though?

[13:56] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, I did a little.

[13:57] Andrew DeWolf: Like what it was so it was so easy to ring the bell and just get rid of the spirit.

[14:01] Jesse McAnally: Like Wert did it the first try.

[14:03] Andrew DeWolf: Auntie Whispers didn't do that.

[14:05] Jesse McAnally: I feel like she just wanted a slave.

[14:06] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, there's that too.

[14:08] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[14:09] Andrew DeWolf: There's something even when she was nice, I got a bad vibe from her.

[14:12] Jesse McAnally: I don't know. It's like, so you could have just expelled the demon by telling the demon to leave.

[14:17] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know. I mean, we also gotta remember that Adelaide is Auntie Whispers' sister.

[14:22] Jesse McAnally: They both grew up in the same household.

[14:24] Andrew DeWolf: And Adelaide, like both evil-ish, probably.

[14:28] Jesse McAnally: One of them wanted child labor.

[14:30] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[14:31] Jesse McAnally: They both kind of wanted child labor.

[14:33] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, they did both want child labor.

[14:36] Jesse McAnally: Hang on a second.

[14:38] Andrew DeWolf: Except one of them is Greg.

[14:41] Jesse McAnally: Oh, poor Greg.

[14:43] Andrew DeWolf: Poor Greg.

[14:44] Jesse McAnally: Um, your theory is Greg is dead.

[14:46] Andrew DeWolf: My theory is that they're in purgatory.

[14:48] Jesse McAnally: Um, like they are half dead, and you can interpret the ending whether it's Greg's dream of the better case scenario.

[14:56] Andrew DeWolf: No, I mean I think that they're I think that they did get out.

[14:59] Jesse McAnally: I was honestly, I was thinking that your theory was something with maybe we don't see Greg after the fact, but I'm pretty sure.

[15:05] Andrew DeWolf: I know we do.

[15:06] Jesse McAnally: No, no, we do because we yeah.

[15:07] Andrew DeWolf: Um, out of all of Greg's names for his frog, which was your favorite, both of you.

[15:13] Jesse McAnally: Uh, like Dr. Cucumber or something.

[15:14] Andrew DeWolf: Dr. Cucumber.

[15:15] Jesse McAnally: I think it was that.

[15:17] Andrew DeWolf: I love George Washington where he just keeps calling him the president.

[15:20] Jesse McAnally: I think I actually think Kitty was the best one.

[15:23] Andrew DeWolf: I think that's kind of a funny name for a frog.

[15:25] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, kitty name a frog named Kitty.

[15:27] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I think that's kind of funny.

[15:28] Jesse McAnally: I'm gonna go with Mr. President, only because it's just vague and stupid.

[15:34] Andrew DeWolf: I love it so much, especially because that was the episode where he gets a record deal.

[15:38] Jesse McAnally: I actually think the name that they end up with is the worst one, but um Jason Thunderberger, yeah, yeah, yeah.

[15:45] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I like that Greg is always Greg, even in dark situations. Like there's that time where he's like about to die covered in trees, and he's coughing up leaves, and she's like, Oh no, he's got leaves on the inside of him.

[15:56] Jesse McAnally: He's like, No, I was just eating leaves. Like that that's the right kind of joke that doesn't undercut the moment and feels right for the character.

[16:03] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, so the beast turns children into trees.

[16:07] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, well yes, and that's what the um lumberjack is cutting down to fill the lantern.

[16:13] Andrew DeWolf: The woodsman is the best character as well.

[16:16] Jesse McAnally: That's yeah.

[16:18] Andrew DeWolf: Like elaborate.

[16:20] Jesse McAnally: Also, keep going.

[16:21] Andrew DeWolf: I like when Christopher Lloyd is in stuff.

[16:24] Jesse McAnally: And I also like weird old men that are getting manipulated by bad stuff.

[16:30] Andrew DeWolf: I think that that's a cool narrative thing.

[16:32] Jesse McAnally: I guess um I honestly did not like that his daughter was still alive.

[16:38] Andrew DeWolf: I didn't like that was weird.

[16:39] Jesse McAnally: I don't like that she just came back at the end. I feel like he should have just dealt with that sacrifice.

[16:43] Andrew DeWolf: No, because I thought the whole point I think his whole character arc is that he is driven by a denial to properly process grief.

[16:53] Jesse McAnally: Mm-hmm.

[16:53] Andrew DeWolf: And he is keeping this monster alive in his quest to do so.

[16:58] Jesse McAnally: And then the ending is him deciding to actually correctly process his grief and helping other people by also doing that.

[17:06] Andrew DeWolf: But it's very heavily undercut because the daughter just kind of shows up and is like, Hey, what's up?

[17:12] Jesse McAnally: I absolutely hate that the daughter shows up again. That is like if I have anything that's negative about that, that's a big one.

[17:18] Andrew DeWolf: Um although it this also has like one of my favorite narrative things that has ever happened in like a medium ever. And that's when the beast offers Wert the opportunity to become the new woodsman.

[17:29] Jesse McAnally: He's like, You hold the lantern and keep him alive, and he's like, No, that's stupid.

[17:33] Andrew DeWolf: Like in any other thing, they'd be like, I will do it, yes, yes. And now he's like, No, that's stupid. That makes no sense. I'm not just gonna self-sacrifice for something that makes no goddamn sense.

[17:45] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, but I mean, I think that that's a great way to juxtapose what Wert has learned versus who the woodsman has become, you know?

[17:55] Andrew DeWolf: And the woodsman is also one of the few like things that are there from episode one to the end, same with Beatrice.

[18:00] Jesse McAnally: Um, did you notice? You know that first house that Wert and Greg kind of destroy?

[18:05] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[18:05] Jesse McAnally: Did you notice that that was Beatrice's house? It has like bluebird designs all over the walls, and in the final scene, that's where Beatrice and her family are living.

[18:13] Andrew DeWolf: I did notice that.

[18:14] Jesse McAnally: I don't understand the significance, but I did notice it.

[18:17] Andrew DeWolf: I just think that's cool. Um, because he says, I just found this house abandoned and started making additions to it.

[18:24] Jesse McAnally: Um, do you think it's weird that the woodsman do you do you think he's lying?

[18:27] Andrew DeWolf: Like he doesn't know that the trees were like lost souls or something like I think he was lying to himself, you know.

[18:35] Jesse McAnally: Like he did know, but like he kept going like, well, I don't have any proof, I don't have any proof.

[18:40] Andrew DeWolf: He probably had an inkling that it was used for something nefarious, but would rather not know because his daughter was worth it.

[18:49] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. Um, what do you think of Beatrice and her storyline?

[18:52] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, I think it's okay.

[18:53] Jesse McAnally: What is it?

[18:54] Andrew DeWolf: I don't understand how did she turn into a bird?

[18:56] Jesse McAnally: I don't understand what happened.

[18:58] Andrew DeWolf: She threw a rock at a bluebird, and that bluebird cursed her and her family to be bluebirds forever.

[19:03] Jesse McAnally: So cartoon logic.

[19:04] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, why would you like a bluebird? That's so mean.

[19:07] Jesse McAnally: I mean, if he got nothing better than just a, you know, wander the woods forever.

[19:12] Andrew DeWolf: I wish that we got to see them chopping off their wings with scissors to make them human again.

[19:17] Jesse McAnally: That was that's such a weird fantasy thing. That's like an Into the Woods dark thing.

[19:22] Andrew DeWolf: I just wanted to see that.

[19:23] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. Liz, what do you think is your favorite like narrat like little vignette?

[19:28] Liz Eston: Uh, I'm not I liked I really like the tavern. Um, I have to say the pumpkin town because striking individuals.

[19:37] Jesse McAnally: Visually it's really interesting. And also just like pumpkins. Like I just like pumpkins a lot around Halloween.

[19:42] Liz Eston: Uh, but the tavern is also really cool. I like the school a lot too because it was very like scary-ish but it wasn't actually in the end it was just a massive misunderstanding involving a gorilla costume.

[19:55] Jesse McAnally: I like that one because it does a bunch of reversals of people that should be evil not being evil.

[20:01] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[20:02] Liz Eston: Um, like school for animals one that's just a funny idea where you have like little bulldog and little later hose and learning about how to read and I can't talk performing the benefit concert for it's just a schoolhouse in the middle of nowhere who is going to the concert and giving them money the dog parents I don't know it's people who is he paying to open a school in the middle of the woods well where else are they property taxes?

[20:29] Jesse McAnally: Is there a government?

[20:30] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know is there a government in the world where there's pumpkin people that take over the skeletons?

[20:30] Liz Eston: Yes well I mean yes there is the there is a judicial system they had a punishment yeah just a few hours of manual labor.

[20:47] Andrew DeWolf: They all end up there eventually allegedly that is like one of the most fucked ideas that's so beautiful as you die then you become like this happy pumpkin town.

[20:55] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. What what level of hell is that supposed to be the first level?

[20:58] Andrew DeWolf: Is that the first that's be the first level of hell, right?

[21:01] Jesse McAnally: Um, I think it's l no, because the first one I think is I you gotta you're gonna have to line this up for me, Jess.

[21:07] Andrew DeWolf: I'm not getting the Dante's Inferno vibes.

[21:09] Jesse McAnally: I did a lot of Googling on this thing, and Dante's Inferno has not appeared in any of my results.

[21:14] Andrew DeWolf: What is the first level of let's break down the episodes?

[21:21] Jesse McAnally: Okay.

[21:22] Liz Eston: Should I just read your off the titles?

[21:24] Liz Eston: Uh Liz, do you have an episode list for me? Can you get that?

[21:24] Jesse McAnally: Just the first episode.

[21:25] Liz Eston: First one is the one in the woods, right?

[21:27] Jesse McAnally: Like into the unknown.

[21:29] Liz Eston: They go to the woodsman's easy.

[21:31] Jesse McAnally: Yes. That's an awesome song I forgot about.

[21:35] Liz Eston: Um and that one is limbo, where you're just kind of getting your footing and figuring things out.

[21:40] Jesse McAnally: Yes, limbo is actually not a circle of hell.

[21:42] Liz Eston: No.

[21:43] Jesse McAnally: Um, that is a misunderstanding.

[21:44] Liz Eston: I'm just telling they call it the first circle of hell.

[21:48] Jesse McAnally: They are wrong, but okay.

[21:49] Liz Eston: That's where virtuous non-Christians find themselves.

[21:52] Jesse McAnally: Yes.

[21:52] Liz Eston: So that's where all of them are.

[21:53] Jesse McAnally: That is where I will be, because I am virtuous and non-Christian.

[21:59] Andrew DeWolf: I'll just well, I'm I'm a reformed Catholic, so I'll just be hanging out in hell.

[22:04] Jesse McAnally: So it's fine.

[22:06] Liz Eston: Um the second one.

[22:09] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, that's true.

[22:10] Liz Eston: The second one is lust.

[22:12] Andrew DeWolf: Someone is pumpkin town.

[22:13] Liz Eston: Yes, so.

[22:18] Andrew DeWolf: Well, they are like they are skeletons.

[22:20] Liz Eston: But in here for me.

[22:24] Andrew DeWolf: No rest.

[22:25] Liz Eston: They have no eternal rest because they become pumpkins.

[22:28] Jesse McAnally: Okay. Alright. I'll buy it this one time.

[22:31] Andrew DeWolf: We're gonna have to keep going on.

[22:32] Liz Eston: Next up is school.

[22:33] Andrew DeWolf: Gluttony.

[22:33] Liz Eston: All right, I can actually get the school one because this one is the one with the songs about potatoes and molasses.

[22:38] Andrew DeWolf: And that sounds kind of delicious.

[22:40] Liz Eston: Okay, what's the next one?

[22:41] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, we never.

[22:42] Liz Eston: Next up is it's the one with the tavern where Beatrice can't go in and they want directions.

[22:47] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, that one's greed.

[22:48] Liz Eston: Um, isn't the next one Greed?

[22:50] Andrew DeWolf: 'Cause that's the one with the rich guy.

[22:51] Liz Eston: Maybe I have oh, I might have this beyond and like okay.

[22:55] Andrew DeWolf: So let's move all of them up real quick.

[22:57] Liz Eston: Episode five is the one with Quincy and the cotton that one's greed.

[23:01] Andrew DeWolf: That one has to be greed.

[23:02] Liz Eston: Yes.

[23:02] Andrew DeWolf: So let's just say that the first episode is kind of like just getting your bearings.

[23:06] Liz Eston: The second one would be Pumpkin Town, which is limbo, which is kind of like actually.

[23:12] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, but now now we have to make the school one into lust.

[23:15] Liz Eston: So um there's the song the teacher sings.

[23:18] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, where she's in love.

[23:19] Liz Eston: It's the only one with like a proper romance in it, aside from maybe Endicots.

[23:23] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. That's true.

[23:24] Liz Eston: So the tavern is gluttony.

[23:26] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[23:26] Liz Eston: And the next one is greed.

[23:28] Andrew DeWolf: Yep.

[23:28] Liz Eston: Okay.

[23:28] Andrew DeWolf: Then the one after that is uh the one on the boat with the frogs.

[23:33] Liz Eston: Wrath.

[23:34] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, I guess the frogs get mad at them.

[23:36] Liz Eston: Yeah.

[23:36] Andrew DeWolf: Frogs do get angry.

[23:38] Liz Eston: And then the next one is Lorna.

[23:40] Andrew DeWolf: Lorna.

[23:40] Liz Eston: And that's the one where Beatrice gets found out, right?

[23:43] Andrew DeWolf: Uh no, that's the one before that.

[23:44] Liz Eston: Okay, yeah, that that's the reason why that one's wrath is because of uh Adelaide.

[23:48] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[23:48] Liz Eston: So then the next is the Greg and uh weren't are on their own because they ran away from the Beatrice and now they're wet the uh um Auntie Whispers.

[23:57] Andrew DeWolf: Heresy.

[23:58] Liz Eston: Yeah.

[23:58] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[24:01] Liz Eston: Heretics are trapped in flaming tombs.

[24:01] Andrew DeWolf: What would you call being trapped in a body that you can't control?

[24:05] Andrew DeWolf: We're stretching here.

[24:06] Liz Eston: Okay.

[24:07] Liz Eston: Next one is when Greg does a lot of weird dreaming.

[24:10] Andrew DeWolf: Um this one is violence.

[24:12] Liz Eston: Yeah.

[24:12] Andrew DeWolf: Um honestly I'd probably call that one fraud.

[24:15] Liz Eston: I thought that one would be fraud.

[24:16] Andrew DeWolf: It's not though.

[24:17] Liz Eston: And then the origin story, which treachery.

[24:20] Andrew DeWolf: No, that one's fraud.

[24:21] Liz Eston: Oh, that one's fraud.

[24:23] Andrew DeWolf: I think wait, there's ten episodes, right?

[24:25] Liz Eston: Yeah.

[24:25] Andrew DeWolf: Cut out the origin story, because there's only nine circles.

[24:27] Liz Eston: Okay, and the last one is the beast is gone, the final chapter begins.

[24:30] Andrew DeWolf: So that'd be fraud.

[24:33] Liz Eston: Well then where's treachery?

[24:34] Andrew DeWolf: Um, ninth circle.

[24:36] Liz Eston: Oh no, that's treachery.

[24:37] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[24:37] Liz Eston: So I'm gonna call fraud as the one where he goes to animation world because that's all basically a ploy by the beast to get Greg to join him.

[24:45] Andrew DeWolf: Then what one of the things treachery would be I mean I could see treachery being what the beast did to the woodsman.

[24:53] Liz Eston: Yeah, I feel like a lot of these are um I'm feeling some stretching going on with this is not my theory.

[25:00] Andrew DeWolf: I've read it a couple places, and also just Dante and Wert look alike, and Dante is looking for Beatrice in the story.

[25:10] Liz Eston: I feel like there's enough comparisons there where it's like there's a little bit of something to something there.

[25:15] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[25:17] Liz Eston: It's okay.

[25:17] Andrew DeWolf: It's okay.

[25:19] Liz Eston: According to this CB comic book resources article, episode seven is here heresy.

[25:25] Andrew DeWolf: Heresy.

[25:26] Liz Eston: Yeah, I don't know how to read.

[25:27] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know how to read.

[25:28] Liz Eston: Um episode eight is violence.

[25:30] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[25:30] Liz Eston: Episode nine is fraud.

[25:32] Andrew DeWolf: What's the fraud?

[25:33] Liz Eston: Let's think.

[25:34] Andrew DeWolf: The fraud is apparently the origin story.

[25:36] Liz Eston: Yeah, but let's try to I want to think of why.

[25:39] Andrew DeWolf: Is it because he's lying to Sarah?

[25:42] Liz Eston: That's what this article says.

[25:43] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, what's the next?

[25:44] Liz Eston: And then episode 10 is treachery.

[25:48] Andrew DeWolf: And fraud is still the cartoon episode, right?

[25:50] Liz Eston: Fraud is the origin story.

[25:51] Andrew DeWolf: The cartoon episode is now violence.

[25:53] Liz Eston: I guess that's pretty violent.

[25:54] Andrew DeWolf: Cartoons in the 40s were pretty violent.

[25:56] Liz Eston: And the frog episode is now anger.

[25:58] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. I mean I get anger because Wart leaves her in anger, and he literally says he was angry, so he took the scissors with him.

[26:06] Liz Eston: So violence is the one with the ghost possession going on, or am I that's the one where Greg has weird drug child dreams?

[26:16] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[26:16] Liz Eston: And has to fight the evil wind.

[26:18] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[26:19] Liz Eston: That appears in his dream and then goes to join the beast.

[26:22] Andrew DeWolf: According to this comic book resources article.

[26:24] Liz Eston: Okay, I feel like we're stretching pretty hard on some of these.

[26:27] Andrew DeWolf: I can see other ones though.

[26:29] Liz Eston: I think that there's like a loose connection.

[26:31] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I don't think it's like a direct one to one, but this has been pitched.

[26:35] Liz Eston: Um there's a weird thing that happens with this show every year for me. Um anyone that knew me, like any old family friends or like people I went to elementary school with, will just periodically, even before I watch the show, will just text me and be like, Have you watched Over the Garden Wall?

[26:51] Andrew DeWolf: Greg reminds me of you when you were a child.

[26:53] Liz Eston: And I'm like, and this has happened at least four times from different people from different sides.

[26:58] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm like, Oh.

[26:59] Liz Eston: What were you like as a child?

[27:01] Andrew DeWolf: I was a lot like Greg.

[27:03] Liz Eston: So you admit it.

[27:04] Andrew DeWolf: Good answer. Good answer.

[27:05] Liz Eston: Yeah. I was Greg. I was very optimistic, goofy, and a little chubby.

[27:10] Andrew DeWolf: Did you have a pet? Did you have a pet you constantly change the name of every 10 seconds?

[27:14] Liz Eston: No, but I did like giving fun facts.

[27:17] Andrew DeWolf: And that's a fact.

[27:19] Liz Eston: You had a rock fact without a rock.

[27:21] Andrew DeWolf: Are the rock facts false, though? Isn't that wasn't that the point?

[27:23] Liz Eston: Every rock fact is false.

[27:25] Andrew DeWolf: They're like, except for the last one.

[27:26] Jesse McAnally: Except for the last one where he said that he stole the rock.

[27:30] Andrew DeWolf: He's a stealer, and that's a rock fact.

[27:31] Jesse McAnally: But what if he—what if that was actually incorrect?

[27:33] Andrew DeWolf: He actually really didn't steal it.

[27:35] Jesse McAnally: Ooh, why would that be your last word?

[27:36] Andrew DeWolf: It's Greg.

[27:37] Jesse McAnally: Uh, I don't know.

[27:39] Andrew DeWolf: It's a weird, weird thing.

[27:41] Jesse McAnally: My favorite is just like, did you know that dinosaurs had really big years, but nobody knew because they don't leave bones?

[27:47] Andrew DeWolf: That's not true.

[27:49] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, it's not true.

[27:50] Andrew DeWolf: Rock fact.

[27:51] Jesse McAnally: That's a rock fact.

[27:52] Andrew DeWolf: Speaking of rock facts, let's compare our opinions to those of the folks over at letterbox.com.

[27:58] Jesse McAnally: It's time for previews.

[28:00] Andrew DeWolf: It's Tom Falls.

[28:05] Jesse McAnally: It's Tomful Previews.

[28:07] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, you guys ready?

[28:09] Jesse McAnally: I'm ready.

[28:09] Andrew DeWolf: I'm ready.

[28:10] Jesse McAnally: Alright, Liz, you're first.

[28:11] Liz Eston: Oh god damn it.

[28:12] Jesse McAnally: Whispers with the two asterisks.

[28:14] Liz Eston: I want to clap cheeks with Miss Langtree.

[28:17] Andrew DeWolf: Why are people so horny?

[28:19] Jesse McAnally: Oh god.

[28:20] Liz Eston: Um, five.

[28:21] Jesse McAnally: That is a five. Good job, Liz.

[28:22] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.

[28:24] Jesse McAnally: You so horny for animated people.

[28:26] Andrew DeWolf: Who's trying to be the wort to my Sarah?

[28:29] Jesse McAnally: Um, I mean, you gotta get deep into the show for this, so I'm gonna give it a—I'm gonna give it a five.

[28:34] Liz Eston: That's a one.

[28:35] Andrew DeWolf: That's a one?

[28:36] Jesse McAnally: You watched the whole fucking show and you gave it a one?

[28:39] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know. I was very confused by this review.

[28:41] Liz Eston: I was very confused by this review.

[28:44] Andrew DeWolf: Sincerely.

[28:45] Jesse McAnally: Um, alright, Liz, you ready?

[28:46] Liz Eston: I'm ready.

[28:47] Jesse McAnally: Over the midden wall.

[28:48] Liz Eston: I don't even know what that means.

[28:50] Jesse McAnally: Um, it means that it's mid, and that is incorrect.

[28:53] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[28:53] Jesse McAnally: Rock fact.

[28:54] Andrew DeWolf: And that's a rock fact.

[28:55] Jesse McAnally: Andrew, are you ready?

[28:56] Andrew DeWolf: I'm ready.

[28:57] Jesse McAnally: I resonate a lot with Adelaide of the pasture.

[28:59] Andrew DeWolf: Need to go to therapy.

[29:00] Jesse McAnally: To Adelaide, to Adelaide.

[29:03] Andrew DeWolf: So once slave labor.

[29:05] Jesse McAnally: Um, we're gonna say five stars.

[29:08] Andrew DeWolf: That is correct. You are now tied.

[29:10] Liz Eston: Ready.

[29:11] Jesse McAnally: Fantastic.

[29:12] Liz Eston: Unfortunately, low amount of horse content, however.

[29:15] Andrew DeWolf: There is some though.

[29:16] Jesse McAnally: There's a talking horse in this.

[29:19] Andrew DeWolf: I get sad when Fred leaves.

[29:20] Jesse McAnally: I always think he's more in the show, and he's probably like one of the best parts.

[29:24] Andrew DeWolf: A horse that just wants to steal. Come on.

[29:27] Jesse McAnally: Uh, one?

[29:28] Andrew DeWolf: That is correct.

[29:29] Jesse McAnally: Andrew.

[29:29] Jesse McAnally: Watched while trapped overnight in Amsterdam.

[29:30] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[29:32] Andrew DeWolf: So they were.

[29:33] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, so the show is good, but this sounds like a bad experience.

[29:37] Andrew DeWolf: But I'm still gonna go five stars.

[29:39] Jesse McAnally: That was a one star.

[29:40] Liz Eston: Damn.

[29:41] Jesse McAnally: Jason Thunderburger ASMR.

[29:43] Andrew DeWolf: That one's for you, Juliet.

[29:45] Liz Eston: Okay.

[29:46] Jesse McAnally: I love you, Juliet, by the way, but I don't think anyone wants Jason Thunderburger ASMR.

[29:50] Andrew DeWolf: I near Sarah.

[29:53] Jesse McAnally: God, God.

[29:54] Andrew DeWolf: I'd rather date him than work, though.

[29:55] Jesse McAnally: Anyway.

[29:56] Andrew DeWolf: I would—I love the bait and switch with Jason Thunderburger, where you make—they try to make you think it's the big chalk, but that's just another guy.

[30:03] Jesse McAnally: He's just about the level of work.

[30:06] Andrew DeWolf: But I want to date where he's a whiny—he's a whiny little swine.

[30:09] Jesse McAnally: I date Sarah though. She seems great, and she loves non-alcoholic beverages, teen-appropriate beverages.

[30:14] Andrew DeWolf: She really likes beverages that are completely legal to show people consuming on television.

[30:19] Jesse McAnally: I love that.

[30:20] Andrew DeWolf: That just felt like a studio note that they turned into a joke.

[30:24] Jesse McAnally: Uh, I'm gonna give that a one, because that sounds like a painful experience.

[30:28] Andrew DeWolf: That is a five.

[30:29] Jesse McAnally: Andrew!

[30:30] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.

[30:31] Jesse McAnally: Okay, hear me out.

[30:32] Andrew DeWolf: Over the garden wall.

[30:33] Jesse McAnally: But horror.

[30:34] Andrew DeWolf: Hey?

[30:34] Jesse McAnally: Hey!

[30:36] Andrew DeWolf: Brother, it already is.

[30:36] Jesse McAnally: Um, five.

[30:37] Andrew DeWolf: That is a one.

[30:38] Jesse McAnally: Liz.

[30:39] Andrew DeWolf: God fucking damn it.

[30:40] Jesse McAnally: Oh god.

[30:40] Andrew DeWolf: QT.

[30:42] Jesse McAnally: Q T?

[30:43] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, the letter Q, the letter T, and a period.

[30:45] Jesse McAnally: I think it was cute.

[30:47] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, I'll give that a one.

[30:49] Jesse McAnally: That is correct.

[30:50] Andrew DeWolf: The loveliest lie of all.

[30:53] Jesse McAnally: Which is one of the darkest final lines of a TV show ever.

[30:57] Andrew DeWolf: Five?

[30:57] Jesse McAnally: That is a one.

[30:58] Andrew DeWolf: But what do you think?

[30:59] Jesse McAnally: Who's hating on this show so much?

[31:00] Andrew DeWolf: My God.

[31:02] Jesse McAnally: I will say when I went through it, there's a lot of people like overrated, boring.

[31:05] Andrew DeWolf: Couldn't you even get past the second episode?

[31:07] Jesse McAnally: There's a lot of them.

[31:08] Andrew DeWolf: Why is it so high rated on letterboxed?

[31:10] Jesse McAnally: Probably because it's good.

[31:11] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, probably.

[31:12] Jesse McAnally: Not letterbox's fault that you have shit taste.

[31:15] Andrew DeWolf: The final line is part of the reason why I think that part—I think the ending of the show was a lie.

[31:21] Jesse McAnally: Which might lend credence to why the Woodsman's wife or wide man's daughter comes back, why Beatrice is happy at home, why Greg is alive.

[31:30] Andrew DeWolf: Like I think it's kind of tipping your head that it might not be true.

[31:33] Jesse McAnally: Maybe.

[31:34] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, I will say I did look this up and I found a Reddit thread, and people said there's a comic book extension to this show, which disproves the purgatory theory entirely.

[31:43] Jesse McAnally: That's lame as fuck.

[31:44] Andrew DeWolf: Why do you have to explain things?

[31:46] Jesse McAnally: Stuff isn't canon if I don't want it to be, so yeah.

[31:49] Andrew DeWolf: So according to Reddit, it's not canon, but yeah, but according to Reddit, uh, I was doing their mom last night, so I saw them do it!

[31:58] Jesse McAnally: That's in my canon.

[32:00] Andrew DeWolf: This is why my reddit username is gender neutral as hell.

[32:04] Jesse McAnally: Um, I forget whose turn it is.

[32:06] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, I think Andrew just felt right?

[32:08] Jesse McAnally: I think we already lost, right?

[32:09] Andrew DeWolf: I—we got one more, so okay, we got one more.

[32:12] Jesse McAnally: I'll go.

[32:12] Andrew DeWolf: I'll go.

[32:13] Jesse McAnally: Fuck it.

[32:13] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, Andrew can't win this no matter what.

[32:16] Jesse McAnally: Um, god.

[32:17] Andrew DeWolf: When in purgatory.

[32:18] Jesse McAnally: Uh, do as the Skellingtons do.

[32:20] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, five.

[32:23] Jesse McAnally: Someone likes this show, right?

[32:24] Andrew DeWolf: Five-one!

[32:25] Jesse McAnally: And Liz, you have to waterbox game.

[32:29] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like a lot of these people like forgot to put a rating.

[32:33] Jesse McAnally: They were just like, I wrote my review, and then it's just—it like automatically sets it to one, and then they hit enter.

[32:39] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, alright, guys.

[32:40] Jesse McAnally: Let's go into a mid-show and then we'll talk about some singing songs.

[33:01] Andrew DeWolf: Hey guys, sorry to interrupt you, mail the show, but we've got a shill at you.

[33:06] Jesse McAnally: Today's show is brought to you by the extremely kind donations by our donors over at Patreon.

[33:10] Andrew DeWolf: Patreon is this wonderful place where you get the video episodes of this show.

[33:14] Jesse McAnally: Extended versions.

[33:15] Andrew DeWolf: Like, literally, there's gonna be parts of this show that you will only get to see the full version on Patreon.

[33:21] Jesse McAnally: Also, you will get a bunch of fun stuff that me and Liz got cooked up as well.

[33:25] Andrew DeWolf: Me and Andrew are doing commentaries a little bit more frequently, a little less now, but we're gonna keep going at them.

[33:30] Jesse McAnally: Um, and also just general updates.

[33:33] Andrew DeWolf: On October 21st, join us for a Patreon meetup where Andrew and Liz will both be there.

[33:38] Jesse McAnally: It'll be a really good time, kids.

[33:41] Andrew DeWolf: Um, that what Liz.

[33:43] Jesse McAnally: Sorry, I don't—I don't have my sketch right now.

[33:45] Andrew DeWolf: It'll probably be there.

[33:46] Jesse McAnally: Hell yeah.

[33:47] Andrew DeWolf: And also, if you're listening to this right now, there is a Kickstarter for my first feature film.

[33:52] Jesse McAnally: And if you've got money or a hole in your pocket, could you please donate to that?

[33:56] Andrew DeWolf: Both Liz and Andrew are going to be parts of it, so don't worry.

[34:00] Jesse McAnally: It's a whole Musicals with Cheese family thing.

[34:03] Andrew DeWolf: It's not just me.

[34:04] Jesse McAnally: Um, currently, as I'm recording this, we are like—I want to say around 30% funded or something like that.

[34:04] Andrew DeWolf: Something like that.

[34:12] Jesse McAnally: Um, so help us get there.

[34:14] Andrew DeWolf: Um, but those of us currently helping us on Patreon include Liz, give me a beat.

[34:20] Jesse McAnally: No.

[34:21] Andrew DeWolf: No, no beat this time.

[34:22] Jesse McAnally: We're not doing that.

[34:22] Andrew DeWolf: No beat buck.

[34:23] Jesse McAnally: I wasn't here when you did it, but I know.

[34:25] Andrew DeWolf: Read it faster.

[34:26] Jesse McAnally: Just read this, wrap it, my god.

[34:28] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, just do a freestyle. You don't need a beat.

[34:29] Jesse McAnally: Melissa Goldman and Daniel, Red X went to the bottom.

[34:32] Andrew DeWolf: Don't wrap it slow.

[34:33] Jesse McAnally: Don't wrap it slow, don't fit.

[34:34] Andrew DeWolf: You and Kathy and Monica the Throw went to the store as Monica Marie.

[34:38] Jesse McAnally: Can we take the beat for the 30, 40?

[34:41] Andrew DeWolf: Here's the beat.

[34:44] Jesse McAnally: Mary Lucia Ken John, Russ Walker, Musical Hill.

[34:49] Andrew DeWolf: Emily, Gracie, Giles, Hummer, see, could the Technicolor Dream Code.

[34:53] Jesse McAnally: Liz Lim, Alice and Stellar.

[34:54] Andrew DeWolf: Nothing is certain to set back to Tassis.

[34:57] Jesse McAnally: We and Red Call, Rafael, Martina Silas, Jessica T, Mitchell Young, Chai D Cop, Katie, McDonald, Kelly, Timothy Keys, Christopher Code, Mimu, Kichi Marina, Saskio Layla, Arjuna Reacher, Charlie B.

[35:06] Andrew DeWolf: Avery, Prince and Mion Herman's Heracast.

[35:08] Jesse McAnally: Doriana Fraser, Sammy the Most Love, has Lyanna Morton, Angela, Kaylee Blazier, Blairman69 said, said Megan Review, Sophia Lee, Millie Omega Gee, Paige Pearson, Maddie Wargle, Elizabeth Man, Anna Lostova, Jessica Varet, Sherrod Dan Blacker, Jess Gray, Jamila M.

[35:23] Andrew DeWolf: Brown, Evan Ball, Zachary Torres, Spencer Hellier, and Gather Partner Gathering Party before venturing forth.

[35:30] Jesse McAnally: They give us a little financial support that helps us keep the lights on here, Musicals with Cheese.

[35:33] Andrew DeWolf: If you'd like to join them in supporting us and get tons of per fun parks, such a page on the commentaries are episodes today earlier or even earlier.

[35:39] Jesse McAnally: Come join us over at Patreon.

[35:40] Andrew DeWolf: And in doing that, I just hit all three of my workout goals for the day.

[35:45] Jesse McAnally: Fun fact.

[35:46] Andrew DeWolf: Well, let's get back to the show.

[36:05] Jesse McAnally: Led through the mist by the milklight of moon.

[36:12] Andrew DeWolf: All that was lost is revealed.

[36:17] Jesse McAnally: Our long bygone burdens.

[36:24] Andrew DeWolf: But where have we come?

[36:28] Jesse McAnally: And where shall we end?

[36:31] Andrew DeWolf: If dreams can't come true, then why not pretend?

[36:40] Jesse McAnally: So what do you think of that intro number?

[36:42] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, I thought the intro was really good, and I was kind of hoping that there would be more.

[36:47] Jesse McAnally: I was a little sad that they didn't have like one of those for every episode.

[36:51] Andrew DeWolf: I thought that that would be kind of fun.

[36:52] Jesse McAnally: I mean, it's kinda there.

[36:53] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, but I wanted the frog to come in and introduce every little episode, you know?

[36:59] Jesse McAnally: I guess.

[36:59] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, I love that Into the Unknown song.

[37:03] Jesse McAnally: I love the vibe.

[37:04] Andrew DeWolf: And how it sets up literally every character perfectly.

[37:07] Jesse McAnally: Everything that will be important later is set up there.

[37:09] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it's—and that's—it's also how they end it.

[37:13] Jesse McAnally: They just—they bring back the little frog, sings a different song at the end.

[37:16] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[37:17] Jesse McAnally: Um, what vibes did you get from it at first?

[37:19] Andrew DeWolf: Like Android gave this to you without any context.

[37:21] Jesse McAnally: What do you think it would be just from this opening number?

[37:23] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like I picked up on what it was trying to do pretty quickly.

[37:26] Jesse McAnally: I feel like I had the whole thing not figured out, but like I understood what it was going for right from the first episode, right from the get-go.

[37:35] Andrew DeWolf: You say that like it's a bad thing though.

[37:37] Jesse McAnally: No, it's not.

[37:38] Andrew DeWolf: I like when I know what I'm getting into, you know?

[37:41] Jesse McAnally: I don't—I don't like to be surprised.

[37:43] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, so you don't like your expectation subverted?

[37:46] Jesse McAnally: You hate The Last Jedi?

[37:47] Andrew DeWolf: Are you alright?

[37:48] Jesse McAnally: I hate all Star Wars movies, yes.

[37:51] Andrew DeWolf: I've said this before.

[37:52] Jesse McAnally: I've said this many times.

[37:53] Andrew DeWolf: All Star Wars movies are bad.

[37:55] Jesse McAnally: Um, yeah, but some are better.

[37:56] Andrew DeWolf: You haven't seen The Last Jedi, so you can't say that one's bad.

[37:59] Jesse McAnally: No, but I can guarantee it's bad.

[38:01] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[38:01] Jesse McAnally: Because all Star Wars movies are bad.

[38:03] Andrew DeWolf: Except for like the first one and maybe the second one.

[38:06] Jesse McAnally: No, the second one and maybe the first one.

[38:09] Andrew DeWolf: I'd say the second one, The Last Jedi are the only ones I really like.

[38:12] Jesse McAnally: I think the only one I actually enjoyed watching was the second, like the Empire.

[38:16] Andrew DeWolf: Well, aren't you excited that we're doing the holiday special this Christmas?

[38:20] Jesse McAnally: Stir whipster whip whip whip stir.

[38:23] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, if we're gonna be completely honest about things, I've probably watched the holiday special more times than I've watched any actual Star Wars movie.

[38:31] Jesse McAnally: I've watched that movie so many times.

[38:34] Andrew DeWolf: Start with—the only clip I've seen is Carrie Fisher really high trying to sing, and that weird thing the grandpa looks at in the VR that's basically kid porn.

[38:44] Jesse McAnally: Um, kid porn?

[38:45] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.

[38:45] Jesse McAnally: No, it's not kid porn, it's normal porn.

[38:48] Andrew DeWolf: It's normal porn, not kitty porn.

[38:50] Jesse McAnally: That would be fucking weird.

[38:52] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.

[38:52] Jesse McAnally: Okay, normal porn is totally fine.

[38:55] Andrew DeWolf: I just—it's Diane Carroll.

[38:58] Jesse McAnally: She's an of-age woman with a bunch of Dr. Seuss splooch all over her head.

[39:01] Andrew DeWolf: And showing normal porn to children in your Star Wars thing is normal and fine to do.

[39:08] Jesse McAnally: In 1970 something.

[39:10] Andrew DeWolf: 1978, November 1978.

[39:13] Jesse McAnally: It aired one time, and Diane Carroll, Jefferson Airplane, but Jefferson Starship in that point.

[39:20] Andrew DeWolf: Um, Harvey Corman, so many good people in that.

[39:23] Jesse McAnally: Written by Bruce Land.

[39:25] Andrew DeWolf: I love that.

[39:26] Jesse McAnally: Did you just—Harvey Corman is one of the good things in that?

[39:29] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, have you seen it?

[39:30] Jesse McAnally: No.

[39:30] Andrew DeWolf: I've seen the Arthur.

[39:31] Jesse McAnally: I've also seen the B.

[39:32] Andrew DeWolf: Arthur scene.

[39:33] Jesse McAnally: He's in that.

[39:34] Andrew DeWolf: Stir whip, stir, whip, whip, whip, stir.

[39:36] Jesse McAnally: And that.

[39:36] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.

[39:37] Jesse McAnally: I think that's like the only thing I actually remember from it.

[39:39] Andrew DeWolf: That and it's like life day or life day.

[39:39] Jesse McAnally: Life day.

[39:39] Andrew DeWolf: Life day.

[39:43] Jesse McAnally: Life day, okay.

[39:44] Andrew DeWolf: Um, someone did threaten to request that on Patreon, but I still—I uh, it kind of made me sold on doing it this Christmas now.

[39:53] Jesse McAnally: Now everyone knows that we're gonna do it too, so now they're gonna hold us to it.

[39:57] Andrew DeWolf: We can't cancel it.

[39:58] Jesse McAnally: Celebrate a day of peace, a day of happiness.

[40:04] Andrew DeWolf: I'd love that.

[40:05] Jesse McAnally: My partner will periodically text me that one gif of lumpy that's available on the keyboard just for fun.

[40:10] Andrew DeWolf: Like I'll just owe my phone and be like, oh, my partner texts me and it's just lumpy.

[40:15] Jesse McAnally: I think the only things I know about that is from the red letter media thing, which I have watched both of their episodes.

[40:21] Andrew DeWolf: The one where they itch targeted.

[40:24] Jesse McAnally: They bait you the entire time that they're gonna talk about it and they don't.

[40:28] Andrew DeWolf: And then also the one where they actually talk about it.

[40:30] Jesse McAnally: I've watched both of those like multiple times.

[40:32] Andrew DeWolf: Me too, but I think I've watched the holiday special more times than either of them.

[40:36] Jesse McAnally: Oh my god, you've actually seen the real thing.

[40:38] Andrew DeWolf: I've seen the real thing multiple times.

[40:40] Jesse McAnally: There's a bar I go to in Detroit.

[40:42] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and every Christmas they just play it at the bar and they have a drinking game, and it's so much fun.

[40:47] Jesse McAnally: Everybody must get fucking toasted on the room.

[40:51] Andrew DeWolf: It's so much fun though.

[40:53] Jesse McAnally: Come on.

[40:54] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, it does seem like a funny bad movie though.

[40:56] Jesse McAnally: It doesn't seem like a boring movie.

[40:58] Andrew DeWolf: It has like actually good parts.

[41:00] Jesse McAnally: Like I really like the animated segment.

[41:02] Andrew DeWolf: I think that's properly good.

[41:03] Jesse McAnally: Isn't that what everybody says is like the animated segment is the one good thing in the whole thing?

[41:08] Jesse McAnally: I mean, that's not the one.

[41:09] Andrew DeWolf: And it's also where Boba Fett came from.

[41:11] Jesse McAnally: Like that's what I'm saying.

[41:15] Andrew DeWolf: So fun fact. Did you know that Boba Fett came from the holiday special, actually?

[41:19] Jesse McAnally: Um, can you tell me?

[41:21] Andrew DeWolf: He debuted in the holiday special.

[41:23] Jesse McAnally: Well, the um so fun fact, um, do you know who Kree Summer is?

[41:28] Andrew DeWolf: No.

[41:29] Jesse McAnally: Yes.

[41:29] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[41:31] Jesse McAnally: Yes.

[41:31] Andrew DeWolf: That is her father playing Boba Fett in that special.

[41:33] Jesse McAnally: Amazing.

[41:34] Andrew DeWolf: The original Boba Fett.

[41:35] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, the original Boba Fett is the father of Kree Summer, who is like I think she's like the voice of oh, what's her name? Susie Carmichael and the girl from the kids next door and all that.

[41:46] Andrew DeWolf: She's that kind of voice actress.

[41:48] Jesse McAnally: So I just think that's a fun fact because I know too much about the Star Wars holiday special.

[41:52] Andrew DeWolf: And when we come back, speaking of Cartoon Network shows.

[41:55] Jesse McAnally: There we go. Back to Over the Garden Wall.

[41:58] Andrew DeWolf: Let's move on to the next song, which I think is "Patient is the Night," which is the song that plays over them doing chores.

[42:08] Jesse McAnally: Among the feels called stall.

[42:17] Andrew DeWolf: Damn the generous dream.

[42:23] Jesse McAnally: Vision is the night.

[42:37] Andrew DeWolf: This the vibe of this song is just so relaxing.

[42:40] Jesse McAnally: Well, yeah, it's the uh you're supposed to be like, oh, oh jeez, nothing's actually gonna happen.

[42:46] Andrew DeWolf: And then you see them digging their own graves, and you're like, oh wait.

[42:49] Jesse McAnally: I agree, but like a lot of people get these pastiche kind of songs so fucking wrong.

[42:56] Andrew DeWolf: Like, especially in musical theater.

[42:58] Jesse McAnally: If there's one thing the musical theater is doing very badly lately, it's pastiche of like a bygone time, because they just sound like pretend.

[43:05] Andrew DeWolf: Example, give me an example.

[43:07] Jesse McAnally: Um like Tootsie.

[43:09] Andrew DeWolf: Like all those are trying to be pastiches of like 90s music, or even like Six to a certain extent, um, where they're trying to think I've heard much girl pop music from the 90s, and it just kind of it feels like imitation.

[43:22] Jesse McAnally: Even Hamilton feels like imitation of rap music rather than a pastiche, and it feels too theatery, too pretty.

[43:29] Andrew DeWolf: Where this just feels rough.

[43:31] Jesse McAnally: Um, and it just found it doesn't have to do with anything, it's just pretty.

[43:35] Andrew DeWolf: Like the lyrics have no real meaning.

[43:37] Jesse McAnally: Well, this is all done by some folk band, right?

[43:39] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, what you said at the beginning here.

[43:41] Jesse McAnally: I'm about to look them up.

[43:42] Andrew DeWolf: I like this kind of like uh neo folk music.

[43:44] Jesse McAnally: Um, and I don't think I've heard like an American style of it, so no, um, I do I really liked a lot of the like ambient music that just plays throughout this as well.

[43:52] Andrew DeWolf: I do want to give you the claimed meaning of this song, which is actually much darker than I thought, which is that the narrator is awaiting death.

[44:01] Jesse McAnally: This is evidenced by the fact that despite proclaimed to be clocked in till the work day's over, he says that he is anxiously waiting instead of working.

[44:08] Andrew DeWolf: In that this case, the night would mean death alongside the woman who is described.

[44:12] Jesse McAnally: This could be signifying Wort as he expresses an inclination to remain in Pottsfield and after his ultimate decision to keep traveling, essentially confronting and overcoming death.

[44:21] Andrew DeWolf: He ceases to recite his morose poetry, only picking it back up after he is betrayed by Beatrice.

[44:26] Jesse McAnally: I guess staying in Pottsfield is literally saying you are dead.

[44:30] Andrew DeWolf: So Chris Isaac sings this song.

[44:33] Jesse McAnally: He is the voice in it.

[44:34] Andrew DeWolf: I really like that there's like a meaning to the lyric that actually ties in.

[44:38] Jesse McAnally: I feel like that's something that you only would see in a show where they actually give a shit.

[44:43] Andrew DeWolf: You know?

[44:44] Jesse McAnally: I feel like the show is so short and it's so easy to give a shit.

[44:47] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, but that's I feel like that's a good thing.

[44:49] Jesse McAnally: I think more TV shows should be like a one-season full story, like complete thing where they have an ending in mind.

[44:57] Andrew DeWolf: I hate TV shows where they just keep going and they just don't end.

[45:00] Jesse McAnally: And it's just like Stranger Things, we're looking at you.

[45:03] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[45:03] Jesse McAnally: And it's just like, you know, and I have a show like I got really like The Boys right now, but I kind of am getting the vibe where it's like it just keeps going and nothing major happens.

[45:12] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm just like, do they have an ending?

[45:14] Jesse McAnally: Or is this gonna go until Amazon decides we're done and then they'll just shoehorn like slap an ending on there at the end of it?

[45:20] Andrew DeWolf: One of the things I'm really appreciating about what like Liz, I know you're a big fan of Ted Lasso, same as me, is that they're like, We only had three seasons planned, I think we're done after three seasons.

[45:30] Jesse McAnally: And I'm like, I respect that.

[45:32] Andrew DeWolf: Give me a satisfying ending.

[45:33] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[45:33] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I remember uh Rachel Bloom is like, yeah, we're done after four.

[45:37] Jesse McAnally: Um, that's it.

[45:38] Andrew DeWolf: And I respected that like deeply for Craig's girlfriend.

[45:41] Jesse McAnally: I don't know if there even is people out there that just want shows to go forever, unless it's like a sitcom where it's it doesn't matter, like it's just haha, funny same thing happens over and over again.

[45:50] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, if they end on a cliffhanger, then I'm like, yeah, wrap that up, please.

[45:54] Jesse McAnally: That's a little different.

[45:55] Andrew DeWolf: I'd say like Grey's Anatomy fans probably wanted to keep going.

[45:58] Jesse McAnally: That show's been going on for like 300 decades with maybe Simpsons fans.

[46:02] Andrew DeWolf: No.

[46:02] Jesse McAnally: No, there are no Simpsons fans that exist that don't want it to end.

[46:07] Andrew DeWolf: So people are saying it's getting good again.

[46:09] Jesse McAnally: I don't believe that.

[46:10] Andrew DeWolf: People are watching it for the first time and like are in they're blind.

[46:15] Jesse McAnally: They don't know what it used to be like.

[46:17] Andrew DeWolf: I think we got a bunch of like zoomers who are like, I just saw The Simpsons on TV, and like it's actually pretty good.

[46:22] Jesse McAnally: But they've never seen the older episodes.

[46:24] Andrew DeWolf: Like they don't know how good it used to be.

[46:26] Jesse McAnally: I mean, the thing is, everyone's ripped off The Simpsons.

[46:29] Andrew DeWolf: It's hard to even give it a proper context anymore.

[46:31] Jesse McAnally: It's true.

[46:32] Andrew DeWolf: Like, how do you watch The Simpsons after Family Guy has been on for almost as long as they have?

[46:36] Jesse McAnally: Family Guy, American Dad, um even South Park Simpson.

[46:41] Andrew DeWolf: Uh Seth McFarland.

[46:43] Jesse McAnally: Even South Park to some degree.

[46:45] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[46:45] Jesse McAnally: Um, yes, let's move on to the case.

[46:48] Andrew DeWolf: The next one has two songs that I think Do you want to talk about Mr. Langtree's Lament?

[46:50] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, this one's pretty funny.

[46:54] Andrew DeWolf: A is for the apple that he gave to me, but I found one in the side.

[47:00] Jesse McAnally: B is for the lover that I called to him before he left my side.

[47:07] Andrew DeWolf: And C, see what he did.

[47:10] Jesse McAnally: That's D.

[47:12] Andrew DeWolf: And did it to Paul me?

[47:15] Jesse McAnally: How could I be such an emotional foo?

[47:22] Andrew DeWolf: She's doing the ABCs, right?

[47:23] Jesse McAnally: But she's also doing like a like a I'm heartbroken because gorilla suit, you know?

[47:28] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, because my husband abandoned me.

[47:31] Jesse McAnally: My husband abandoned me, and there's also a gorilla.

[47:33] Andrew DeWolf: Well, she doesn't know that yet.

[47:34] Jesse McAnally: And it's Jimmy Brown.

[47:36] Andrew DeWolf: Um she doesn't know that the husband is the gorilla, but she does sing about the gorilla in the lament.

[47:42] Jesse McAnally: You're right.

[47:42] Andrew DeWolf: I think it's funny lyrics, like, and they don't focus enough on the lyrics, so you kind of have to listen to the soundtrack to really get how good the thing is.

[47:49] Jesse McAnally: They cut away from the song a couple times and they come back like at random points.

[47:53] Andrew DeWolf: Like G is for the gentleman I thought he was when he first said hi.

[47:57] Jesse McAnally: H-I, Jay's for the joke of that Jimmy B the man who made me cry.

[48:02] Andrew DeWolf: That's C.

[48:04] Jesse McAnally: Like I think that's really funny.

[48:06] Andrew DeWolf: Like a teacher that can't deal with her emotional trauma and just trauma dumping on kids.

[48:10] Jesse McAnally: We've all had that teacher before.

[48:12] Andrew DeWolf: Oh man.

[48:13] Jesse McAnally: It's really And then we also got in the same episode we have "Potatoes and Molasses," which is another good one.

[48:18] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, this song is so cute.

[48:20] Jesse McAnally: It makes my heart so happy.

[48:22] Andrew DeWolf: Would you put molasses on potatoes?

[48:24] Jesse McAnally: Oh, it would taste so terrible.

[48:26] Andrew DeWolf: It would I don't know.

[48:28] Jesse McAnally: I guess syrup is good on a lot of stuff that even you wouldn't think.

[48:31] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[48:32] Jesse McAnally: Like I put I'd put maple syrup on my sausages.

[48:35] Andrew DeWolf: No.

[48:36] Jesse McAnally: No, I don't know.

[48:37] Andrew DeWolf: We're not doing Elf.

[48:39] Jesse McAnally: Um but I actually put them on sausages for like breakfast.

[48:43] Andrew DeWolf: And then I'll have a hash brown and I'll put the hash brown in the sun.

[48:46] Jesse McAnally: Oh, you're gonna make sure you throw the bigger.

[48:48] Andrew DeWolf: That is that is potatoes in syrup.

[48:51] Jesse McAnally: That kind of sounds like it is good.

[48:53] Andrew DeWolf: Don't even know.

[48:54] Jesse McAnally: That sounds delicious.

[48:55] Andrew DeWolf: I would I might tell him to try that next time I have a diner.

[48:57] Jesse McAnally: Just make up some sausages and make up a hash brown, and then you put the syrup on the sausage and then you dip the hash brown into the syrup.

[49:06] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, potato Andrew breakfast.

[49:08] Jesse McAnally: Yes.

[49:09] Andrew DeWolf: It's potatoes and syrup, but syrup isn't molasses.

[49:13] Jesse McAnally: They're not actually the same thing.

[49:14] Andrew DeWolf: No, no, no.

[49:15] Jesse McAnally: They are very different.

[49:15] Andrew DeWolf: You could argue that the potatoes are deeply under seasoned, it might help a little, but other than that.

[49:21] Jesse McAnally: At first, I didn't think they were eating potatoes.

[49:22] Andrew DeWolf: I thought it was supposed to be like a nebulous, like overly bland food.

[49:26] Jesse McAnally: It was just like a white.

[49:28] Andrew DeWolf: I thought it was like a demonic presence that was gonna take over their bodies or something and like cause issues, but it was just potatoes.

[49:35] Jesse McAnally: Um I like that Greg is so vehemently against school until there's like a Sasquatch coming to get him, and then he's like, I'm gonna go in and eat and do a school for a bit.

[49:45] Andrew DeWolf: And he's like, Miss Langtree plays something like this, and he plays gibberish on the piano.

[49:49] Jesse McAnally: Things like that really endear me to Greg.

[49:51] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[49:52] Jesse McAnally: All right. What's the next like good song?

[49:54] Andrew DeWolf: I want to talk about "The Highwayman," like specifically.

[49:57] Jesse McAnally: This one's so short, but okay.

[49:59] Andrew DeWolf: I'm the highwayman.

[50:01] Jesse McAnally: I make it me.

[50:04] Andrew DeWolf: Just like any man.

[50:06] Jesse McAnally: I work with my hands.

[50:08] Andrew DeWolf: You cause my pain.

[50:12] Jesse McAnally: I'll knock you out.

[50:16] Andrew DeWolf: Do your shoes remove your feet.

[50:28] Jesse McAnally: In our years of doing this show, we have covered so many Cab Callaway ripoffs or wannabe Cab Callaways, whether it be Oogie Boogie or the one song uh a fine affair from the Tom and Jerry movie.

[50:43] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, yes.

[50:44] Jesse McAnally: Which that one was directly Cab Callaway.

[50:46] Andrew DeWolf: And all of them failed except for this one.

[50:49] Jesse McAnally: They got the animation right.

[50:51] Andrew DeWolf: They got the style of singing.

[50:52] Jesse McAnally: Perfect.

[50:53] Andrew DeWolf: It's like they put the it's like they animated him normally and then put it through like a fish eye lens when they they probably didn't film it, but like if if you were in the old animation days, that's how I feel like I mean have you seen the Minnie the Moocher animation, Andrew?

[51:07] Andrew DeWolf: I have not.

[51:07] Jesse McAnally: Okay, we're gonna show you that real quick.

[51:09] Andrew DeWolf: Um honestly one day I'm thinking we might just cover Minnie the Moocher because this is like one of my favorite animated things ever.

[51:17] Jesse McAnally: Okay.

[51:17] Andrew DeWolf: Um all right so you're gonna get to it.

[51:19] Jesse McAnally: So this is how the how they'd move in that oh it's a Betty Boop thing?

[51:23] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[51:24] Jesse McAnally: So that's Cab Callaway performing as this weird seal creature.

[51:28] Andrew DeWolf: And that's exactly how the highwayman moves.

[51:31] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, you're right.

[51:31] Andrew DeWolf: It's got a kind of like a weird rotoscope vibe.

[51:34] Jesse McAnally: Weird vibe to it yeah.

[51:36] Andrew DeWolf: And they get that right for the highwayman.

[51:38] Jesse McAnally: Um and then of course the singing I mean this highway waste man song isn't quite as screamy as Cab Callaway's Minnie the Moocher but it is just as it it gets the vibe.

[51:49] Andrew DeWolf: Now a highwayman that's just someone who steals from people on the road right?

[51:49] Jesse McAnally: Yes um and in the comics they're he's a it's a land pirate.

[51:57] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.

[51:58] Jesse McAnally: I want to be a highwayman.

[51:58] Andrew DeWolf: Um so you know why Fred likes to steal is because the highwayman found Fred and made him his stealing horse.

[52:05] Jesse McAnally: That was we found that out in uh in a comic so it's all clear so that's not we've already established that the comic's not can't I know I just thought you'd like to know that we we have some context for why that might it be it.

[52:18] Andrew DeWolf: I also want to bring up so you know when Greg's dying um this is calling back they have a Latin version of "Potatoes and Molasses" playing in the background there like a really sad version of it saying it sung entire in Latin and I think that's very funny.

[52:32] Jesse McAnally: Of course.

[52:33] Andrew DeWolf: All right.

[52:33] Jesse McAnally: I don't I think the main ones I want to talk about now are just the the fucking beast songs.

[52:38] Andrew DeWolf: Um yes, let's go to that.

[52:40] Jesse McAnally: What's the what's the last what do you want to talk about?

[52:42] Andrew DeWolf: The just the beast is out there or what?

[52:44] Jesse McAnally: Um what are the two s he sings like two songs, but I feel like they're pretty similar.

[52:47] Andrew DeWolf: It's "Come Wayward Souls," and I don't even know if the other one has a name, but it's just like he's singing about cutting down trees.

[52:54] Jesse McAnally: Yes, um, getting them all out.

[52:56] Andrew DeWolf: Um so "Come Wayward Souls" is like the very unpleasant sounding song in a weird way.

[53:32] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, he's like he's doing like some like opera style vibrato, but it's like it's it's like it's almost like he's going out of key while he's doing it, which makes it sound like really weird.

[53:44] Andrew DeWolf: Um he sounds scary.

[53:47] Jesse McAnally: Um yes, and it's like strangely to the tune of "Oh Holy Night."

[53:52] Andrew DeWolf: Like I can't not hear "Oh Holy Night" when he's singing it.

[53:55] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, and then they have like the little kids that come in.

[53:58] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, it's in this one.

[53:59] Jesse McAnally: Properly spooky.

[54:01] Andrew DeWolf: And also, if you just listen to the lyrics, it's like really dark.

[54:03] Jesse McAnally: It's like come wayward souls that wander through the darkness.

[54:07] Andrew DeWolf: There is a light for the lost and the meek.

[54:09] Jesse McAnally: Sorrow and fear are easily forgotten when you submit to the soil of the earth.

[54:13] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, and then the I believe the kids sing about like becoming a tree.

[54:16] Jesse McAnally: Yes.

[54:17] Andrew DeWolf: Um yeah, I guess when when the beast had the lantern, which is implied that he used to, that'd probably be pretty scary.

[54:24] Jesse McAnally: That would have been a good that would have been a good image.

[54:26] Andrew DeWolf: Like like uh a kid gets lost in the woods and sees like a light and wanders towards it and it's just him.

[54:32] Jesse McAnally: There's so much is just so spooky about this just in the thought of it rather than just the actual execution in the story.

[54:38] Andrew DeWolf: I think the only thing I don't like about the execution is it seems um trivially easy to not become a tree.

[54:44] Jesse McAnally: The thing is I think it sneaks up on you.

[54:46] Andrew DeWolf: Like Wort is almost turned into a tree when he's just sleeping and the only reason why he doesn't become a tree is because Greg says I'll become a tree.

[54:53] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, but then the beast, I think the one I'm mainly thinking of is the beast gets Greg to become a tree and then is like, I'll put his soul in the thing if you, and he's just like, oh no, I'm just gonna take him out, and then he just removes him from the tree and walks out, and it's like, wait, what? I think the beast just had the woodsman to deal with, which is the reason why he let him go so early, so easily is because the woodsman now suddenly realizes the ploy.

[55:19] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, yeah, yeah, I mean there is a little bit of a continuity error because the light does go out in the first episode for a second.

[55:26] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I mean, I'm not gonna be fucking CinemaSins over here, but it did happen.

[55:30] Jesse McAnally: Doesn't it also fall on the ground in one of the episodes and like light a tree on fire?

[55:34] Andrew DeWolf: Yep, does it not go out then? Maybe it doesn't, I don't know. I just remember going out and I'm like, oh, that's supposed to be the soul of the wood or the beast. Maybe he had a different lantern at that time.

[55:44] Jesse McAnally: Maybe. Speaking of that, I do want to talk very briefly before we wrap this up, what'd you think of the cartoon anime animated pastiche episode? Because I don't like that episode.

[55:55] Andrew DeWolf: I did not like that one at all.

[55:56] Jesse McAnally: Oh, like the one where he goes into the dream?

[55:58] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I don't like it.

[56:00] Jesse McAnally: I'm not a fan.

[56:01] Andrew DeWolf: I think it's episode eight.

[56:02] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, I don't like the dream stuff. I feel like it's like, it's too silly. It doesn't fit the tone of the rest of the show very well.

[56:08] Andrew DeWolf: And I don't even think that's how Greg sees the world, which is what I think they're trying to imply.

[56:12] Jesse McAnally: I think Greg is just optimistic, not, you know, deluded.

[56:16] Andrew DeWolf: He might be a little deluded.

[56:18] Jesse McAnally: Not in that way.

[56:19] Andrew DeWolf: Not in the way that they're showing there, where he thinks a blue fairy's gonna save the day.

[56:23] Jesse McAnally: I mean, the blue fairy does save the day, maybe.

[56:26] Andrew DeWolf: But is it the beast?

[56:28] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. I mean, you can say anything for Greg, though. It's that he's completely fucking fearless. I mean, he just sees the beast and walks towards him.

[56:35] Andrew DeWolf: Greg is fearless in a way that kids are, where they just see the best in every situation, whether it's a beast or a child monster.

[56:42] Jesse McAnally: It's like, hey friend, break out the...

[56:56] Andrew DeWolf: Sure.

[56:57] Jesse McAnally: Um, I thought it was really good pretty much all the way through. And, uh, as I said earlier, it's a vibe, it's a vibe-based thing, you know.

[57:07] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, but no, but like I actually, I actually recommend it if you haven't seen it. But probably everyone listening to this has seen it.

[57:14] Jesse McAnally: I feel like this is one of those things where I was like one of the last people who hasn't seen this, and like everyone else on the internet has seen it and loves it.

[57:20] Andrew DeWolf: You're completely correct, Andrew. We're on a very late time stream. In fact, two years ago, I was thinking about doing it in Nassau. Does this count as a musical? And they're like, no, but if it means you cover it on the show, do it.

[57:30] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. So you've seen it, you know it's good. And, uh, yeah.

[57:36] Andrew DeWolf: Um, uh, as far as a cheese rating, um, I'm trying to think of like a good rating that this would work with this, and I'm almost not even sure what I would give it. But maybe I'll give it cheese with molasses.

[57:52] Jesse McAnally: That's a good choice. Um, alright, Liz, how about you?

[57:55] Liz Eston: Uh, I enjoyed this. I remember I thought I was watching this, I remember when I had mono last year.

[58:00] Jesse McAnally: You told me to watch this.

[58:02] Liz Eston: I did. And you did.

[58:03] Jesse McAnally: Make me feel better.

[58:04] Liz Eston: And then I did it.

[58:05] Jesse McAnally: Do you wish you had?

[58:06] Liz Eston: I kind of wish I had now.

[58:08] Jesse McAnally: Do you understand why I recommended it though?

[58:10] Liz Eston: Yeah, honestly. This on Sick Brain would probably be a trip.

[58:13] Jesse McAnally: It's a perfect kind of like, you know, sickly day kind of vibe.

[58:18] Liz Eston: Yeah. No, honestly, if I was on Sick Brain, I'd probably love this like deeply. If you're taking an LSD trip, man, maybe this is the one to turn on.

[58:26] Jesse McAnally: You got mono, watch Over the Garden Wall. Um, your brain will love it. I told you, I think we brought up when we had Kate Sloan on. When she took LSD, she turned on the producer's movie.

[58:35] Liz Eston: So hey, whatever your comfort movie is, turn that on while you're on LSD.

[58:39] Jesse McAnally: Indeed. Uh, but I really enjoy this. It's very cute. Um, it's only like two hours, so it's a lot of fun. You can just do it in a night on a spooky evening. I'm like Andrew, I'm assuming everyone who's listening to this has already watched it.

[58:51] Liz Eston: So written their OC insert character porn or whatever the fuck already. They probably made a fan theory on YouTube I haven't found in my search yet when I'm fancy.

[59:00] Andrew DeWolf: It's definitely one of those shows where you know the fan base is, um, Greg is really Wort's dad. This is the type of show where I will love it, but I won't tell anyone in public that I love it because then I have to walk on eggshells.

[59:16] Liz Eston: Like, are you part of the fan base though?

[59:18] Andrew DeWolf: You know?

[59:19] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait, wait. What other things are like that? Curious.

[59:23] Andrew DeWolf: Rick and Morty.

[59:25] Jesse McAnally: Yes.

[59:25] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, Rick and Morty's a good one. There's a lot of stuff like that, I feel like Star Wars is, oh man. If you like Star Wars and you tell someone you like Star Wars and they really like Star Wars, I agree.

[59:38] Jesse McAnally: You're in for like a three-hour conversation.

[59:41] Andrew DeWolf: I made that mistake once in a party with a drunk guy.

[59:43] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, there's also just like basic filmmaking. Like if you say you like any Tarantino film to the wrong guy, like they'll talk your ear off the rest of the night.

[59:54] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. It's these niche things where people get way too passionate about it.

[1:00:02] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, yeah, that's the thing is it's like mainstream stuff that people think are like normal people think are niche. It's like Quentin Tarantino movies are like world-renowned, everyone has seen them.

[1:00:12] Andrew DeWolf: You're not like what?

[1:00:14] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. It's like, wow, have you seen this Kill Bill thing I've heard so much about? Like a lot of people have.

[1:00:22] Andrew DeWolf: Oh my god, I saw the weirdest movie. I swear to god, it's so mental. It's called A Million Ways to Die in the West.

[1:00:27] Jesse McAnally: Which funnily enough, Doc uh CRISPR Lade made in the same year as Over the Garden Wall. I checked.

[1:00:32] Andrew DeWolf: What a, what a wow.

[1:00:34] Jesse McAnally: Oh, right. There's the Back to the Future stuff.

[1:00:36] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, he, Seth McFarlane is so unfunny that he literally is just like, what if I just do Back to the Future part three in my movie?

[1:00:44] Jesse McAnally: Fun thing about going on IMDB on Prince Verloyd's page is if you scroll, most of it is just Doc Brown. It's like Doc Brown, Doc Brown, Doc Brown, Doc Brown.

[1:00:54] Andrew DeWolf: Maybe that character from the Oogie Loves, Doc Brown.

[1:00:56] Jesse McAnally: So fun fact, um, people have almost Patreon requested Oogie Loves many times. Um, and it's come this close to before.

[1:01:01] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[1:01:06] Jesse McAnally: And I haven't tried talking them out of it, but just fucking do it, you cowards.

[1:01:12] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. You want to hear me talk about Oogie Loves, and you know you do.

[1:01:15] Jesse McAnally: In the big balloon adventure.

[1:01:17] Andrew DeWolf: The big balloon adventure, I will have so much to say. You know this.

[1:01:21] Jesse McAnally: The funniest part about the fucking Oogie Loves is they brought it out as if it was something that's existed for years. Like, oh, finally, the Oogie Loves movie.

[1:01:27] Andrew DeWolf: The Oogie Loves movie. We've been waiting.

[1:01:35] Jesse McAnally: Do you know the story of why the Oogie Loves movie exists, Andrew?

[1:01:38] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, they couldn't get the rights to the fucking some other shit.

[1:01:42] Jesse McAnally: No. The director went to a Tyler Perry movie and saw that the audience was participating and said, I wanna do that, but for kids.

[1:01:50] Andrew DeWolf: That's every kid's thing ever. Just do the Dora the Explorer movie.

[1:01:54] Jesse McAnally: You know the Blues Clues movie.

[1:01:59] Andrew DeWolf: I actually saw that one in theaters. Um, fun fact.

[1:02:02] Jesse McAnally: I always liked Thomas and the Magic Railroad. I thought that that was great. I was a big fan of Elmo and Grouch Land.

[1:02:09] Andrew DeWolf: Mandy Patinkin's only available on VHS.

[1:02:12] Jesse McAnally: Mandy Patinkin.

[1:02:13] Andrew DeWolf: Oh.

[1:02:13] Jesse McAnally: Elmo and Grouch Land.

[1:02:14] Andrew DeWolf: I did not know who he was at the age of like four, so I watched the everything.

[1:02:19] Jesse McAnally: I'm gonna stand at high Mandy Patinkin. I didn't know he was in it till I was an adult, and I was like, oh, Mandy Patinkin was a big figure in my childhood.

[1:02:27] Andrew DeWolf: Speak wow, okay. So there's a lot of Santa alums in these movies because in the Barney movie, you know who the grandfather is, right?

[1:02:35] Jesse McAnally: That's George Hearn, the one of the original Sweeney Todds in the recording.

[1:02:39] Andrew DeWolf: I didn't know who George Hearn was until you just told me.

[1:02:41] Jesse McAnally: So yeah, and there has to be someone in Thomas and the Magic Railroad, Alec Baldwin, known renowned murderer.

[1:02:48] Andrew DeWolf: That's true. That's true.

[1:02:49] Jesse McAnally: Well, manslaughterer.

[1:02:51] Andrew DeWolf: Allegedly.

[1:02:52] Jesse McAnally: Allegedly. No, no one sue us.

[1:02:54] Andrew DeWolf: I like to see Alec Baldwin fry, to be honest.

[1:02:58] Jesse McAnally: Alec Baldwin, come at me, bro.

[1:03:00] Andrew DeWolf: But not with a gun.

[1:03:01] Jesse McAnally: I wanna.

[1:03:04] Andrew DeWolf: Trying to.

[1:03:05] Jesse McAnally: Protect us legally.

[1:03:08] Andrew DeWolf: Look, no, if he wants to sue us, he's gonna have to prove that he didn't shoot somebody.

[1:03:16] Jesse McAnally: He doesn't even deny that he shot somebody.

[1:03:20] Andrew DeWolf: It's not allegedly.

[1:03:22] Jesse McAnally: He, that's manslaughter.

[1:03:23] Andrew DeWolf: Since maybe he didn't get legally in trouble for it.

[1:03:25] Jesse McAnally: No, since if I'm gonna break this down, he shouldn't be the one getting in legal.

[1:03:30] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, let me break this down even more. If he weren't also the producer of that movie, he should not be getting in legal trouble.

[1:03:36] Jesse McAnally: But since, like if he was just an actor given a hot gun and being told it was a cold gun, that's one thing.

[1:03:42] Andrew DeWolf: But he's also the producer that hired people and all that. Therefore, he is still liable, but not because he was the one that fired the gun.

[1:03:50] Jesse McAnally: Yes, but because he was the one who fired the gun, but also the one who gave himself the gun that fired the gun.

[1:03:57] Andrew DeWolf: Logistically.

[1:03:57] Jesse McAnally: I mean, this is not quite a John Landis situation with the Twilight Zone incident. Do you know about that, Andrew?

[1:04:03] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, the one where they killed a, uh, like a bunch of people with a helicopter, that one.

[1:04:08] Jesse McAnally: Three people, two children, one old man.

[1:04:11] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.

[1:04:11] Jesse McAnally: Oh yes. Where the, yeah, this is like one of the worst things to ever happen in filmmaking history, if I recall.

[1:04:17] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.

[1:04:18] Jesse McAnally: And the only thing that come close to it ever since is one event in Michigan where a gentleman did not get the rights to film on a train track.

[1:04:26] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and it's like one of those bridge train tracks.

[1:04:29] Jesse McAnally: Um, a gentleman, Jess.

[1:04:31] Andrew DeWolf: It was not me.

[1:04:32] Jesse McAnally: I can say this.

[1:04:34] Andrew DeWolf: It was not me.

[1:04:35] Jesse McAnally: Yes, it was not me. Allegedly.

[1:04:39] Andrew DeWolf: No, no, no. I swear to God, this wasn't me because I would get permits. He didn't get permits, but it's like one of those train tracks on a bridge where there's no sides to it and just the fall to the death.

[1:04:48] Jesse McAnally: Um, and they didn't get approval to get there, so they didn't reroute the trains. So a train starts coming, they start running. PA was ran over, lost thousands of dollars. Um, that was bad, and the director, I think this might be the first in its case, is legally prohibited from ever making another film.

[1:05:06] Andrew DeWolf: Oh lord.

[1:05:06] Jesse McAnally: That is the reason why I know this.

[1:05:11] Andrew DeWolf: He is not allowed to make another movie.

[1:05:13] Jesse McAnally: That's pretty funny.

[1:05:14] Andrew DeWolf: It's not because someone died in a very horrendous way.

[1:05:17] Jesse McAnally: No, it's tragic.

[1:05:18] Andrew DeWolf: Because of the incompetence of their director of not putting safety first.

[1:05:22] Jesse McAnally: It's funny that that's the legal penalty they gave him.

[1:05:25] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, he also went to prison.

[1:05:26] Jesse McAnally: Like, you can't make another movie.

[1:05:28] Andrew DeWolf: Like he went to prison for a couple years, but when he came out, they're like, You're never allowed to make a movie again.

[1:05:33] Jesse McAnally: He's like, If you're on a film set, someone will be informed and kick you out.

[1:05:37] Andrew DeWolf: Literally, I think he was kicked out of the DGA.

[1:05:39] Jesse McAnally: I mean, obviously kicked out of the DGA.

[1:05:41] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[1:05:41] Jesse McAnally: Um, on that note, my cheese rating.

[1:05:44] Andrew DeWolf: I didn't give a cheese.

[1:05:46] Jesse McAnally: Go ahead.

[1:05:46] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, it's just cheese rating. It's fine.

[1:05:47] Jesse McAnally: It's fine.

[1:05:48] Andrew DeWolf: We usually go off topic during my cheese ratings.

[1:05:50] Jesse McAnally: It's fine.

[1:05:50] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, you were so interesting.

[1:05:52] Liz Eston: Cheese balls.

[1:05:53] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, do you have pictures of what those look like?

[1:05:55] Liz Eston: I do. I can share them.

[1:05:57] Jesse McAnally: I Googled spooky cheeses and this popped up.

[1:06:02] Liz Eston: He's all my horrible taps.

[1:06:03] Jesse McAnally: Well, let's read all your tabs real quick.

[1:06:05] Andrew DeWolf: Oh my god, those are cute.

[1:06:07] Liz Eston: Yeah.

[1:06:07] Jesse McAnally: Alright, that's a good choice. Um, so you like the show.

[1:06:10] Liz Eston: Yeah, I like the show.

[1:06:11] Jesse McAnally: And just how about you?

[1:06:12] Jesse McAnally: Um, I like the show. It's good. Um, hard to complain about something that's so good. I am giving this Emporium Selection, Scary Pumpkin Spice, Wensleydale cheese, as sold on Instacart. It is Wensleydale cheese mixed with cinnamon, ginger, and nutmeg.

[1:06:27] Andrew DeWolf: It sounds disgusting, but it has a like it has a little like, um, it has a little pumpkin thing that it comes in.

[1:06:33] Jesse McAnally: I thought it was cute. Look at that.

[1:06:35] Liz Eston: Oh, it's cute.

[1:06:36] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, like I could not do that, right?

[1:06:40] Andrew DeWolf: It's from Aldi, which is a little bit questionable, but what's questionable about good deals, Liz?

[1:06:45] Liz Eston: I once drank Aldi fruit punch and I thought I was gonna die.

[1:06:48] Andrew DeWolf: Maybe it's just your body's not prepared for the good deals that you get from Aldi.

[1:06:52] Jesse McAnally: Or I could just go to Wegman's instead, which is what I did.

[1:06:55] Liz Eston: You know who definitely should go to Wegman's though?

[1:06:57] Jesse McAnally: Me.

[1:06:58] Liz Eston: Our wonderful patrons. Thank you guys for listening. Please follow us on iTunes, Spotify, Stitcher, Musicals for Cheese. Leave us a review. We need more reviews. It's the holiday season coming up, and that would be a great Christmas present.

[1:07:08] Jesse McAnally: Follow us on Twitter at Cheesy Musicals. We're on Patreon Musical Cheese, Instagram musicals for cheese, YouTube page musicals for cheese. We have a patron-only podcast called Patreon Cheese. Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com. Our keeper of the cheese is Juliet Antonio. You're the fucking best, Juliet!

[1:07:22] Andrew DeWolf: And here's a motherfucker for your dad.

[1:07:24] Jesse McAnally: Um, this show is produced by the wonderful, the incredible Brianna Jones, who sadly is not here because today is Yom Kippur and Lizabeth Eston stepped in so gracefully today. You did a wonderful job.

[1:07:34] Liz Eston: Happy to be here.

[1:07:36] Jesse McAnally: Um, our theme songs were created by Robin Nash of IOU Music UK. Thank you to the Broadway Podcast Network for having us on the platform. Alright, folks, is there anything else we have left to say?

[1:07:46] Andrew DeWolf: Potatoes with molasses.

[1:07:47] Jesse McAnally: Um, if you don't understand, you should wear your glasses.

[1:07:49] Andrew DeWolf: Potatoes with molasses.

[1:07:51] Jesse McAnally: Alright. I love Greg.

[1:07:52] Andrew DeWolf: I love Greg too.

[1:07:53] Jesse McAnally: Um, we'll see you next time on Musicals with Cheese.

[1:08:13] ♪ Musical number: "The Highwayman" — performed by Unknown performer ♪

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred