Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#237 - You're A Good Man Charlie Brown (Feat. Big Beak Entertainment)

"You're a Good man Charlie Brown..." Get your football and kite ready because this week we're joined by Big Beak Entertainment to talk about the concept album and subsequent musical of "You're a Good Man Charlie Brown" Hosts: Jesse McAnally & Andrew DeWolf... Read More

From the show: Musicals with Cheese

1 h 1 min
3/23/23

About

"You're a Good man Charlie Brown..." Get your football and kite ready because this week we're joined by Big Beak Entertainment to talk about the concept album and subsequent musical of "You're a Good Man Charlie Brown"


Credits:

Hosts: Jesse McAnally & Andrew DeWolf

Podcast Edited By: Andrew DeWolf

Theme Songs: Robyn Nash of IOU Music UK

Keeper of the Cheese: Juliet Antonio

This show is a part of the Broadway Podcast Network

Social Media:

Our WEBSITE

Musicals with Cheese on Twitter

Musicals W/ Cheese on Instagram

Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com

Merch!!

Jess Socials

Jesse McAnally on Twitter

Jess McAnally on Instagram

Andrew Socials

Andrew DeWolf on Instagram

Andrew DeWolf on Twitter

Use our Affiliate Link

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:05] Jesse McAnally: Hello, I'm Jesse McAnally.

[0:08] Andrew DeWolf: And I am Andrew DeWolf.

[0:09] Jesse McAnally: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, a podcast where I try to get Andrew to like musical theater.

[0:14] Andrew DeWolf: And this week we have an extra special guest.

[0:17] Jesse McAnally: A very special guest.

[0:19] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, yes.

[0:20] Jesse McAnally: Please join me in welcoming the host and creator at Big Beak Entertainment on YouTube. It's Mr. Big Beak himself.

[0:29] Doug Walker: Hey, thank you so much for having me on the show. It's a real honor.

[0:32] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, that's great. Is that your real name? Is that like on your birth certificate and everything?

[0:36] Doug Walker: Uh yeah. Well, you know, I I am, you know, ethnically, I I'm a toucan. I'm just not religious.

[0:42] Jesse McAnally: Um, okay. But it's clear it's a toucan.

[0:47] Doug Walker: I I do have a you know, my you might know me by my real name, uh Doug Walker.

[0:52] Jesse McAnally: Oh!

[0:52] Andrew DeWolf: Oh!

[0:53] Jesse McAnally: Tell me, we finally got him!

[0:56] Andrew DeWolf: We got him, guys!

[0:57] Doug Walker: I I do have a much more successful and uh much better channel. Uh I I think uh thatguywiththeglasses.com. Uh I hope you really enjoyed my movies. Uh the one that go into space? I don't fucking remember.

[1:11] Doug Walker: My favorite is definitely Suburban Nights. Um, but Kickassia is pretty good too.

[1:17] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I still think your best film ever was the one year brawl celebration.

[1:23] Doug Walker: Oh, that one's great.

[1:24] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, yeah.

[1:25] Doug Walker: Um don't don't forget the classic shorts, Melvin Brother of the Joker. That's a pretty good one. Or or let's play Bart's Nightmare.

[1:33] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, let's play Bart Snyder. I you can't forget the classics.

[1:37] Doug Walker: I'm gonna be straight with you guys. I I've literally never watched a single one of my videos.

[1:44] Doug Walker: Nor should you. Um.

[1:47] Jesse McAnally: No, we're so excited to have you with us, Big Beak. Um you, as far as the internet is concerned, are the penultimate fan of this topic we're getting into.

[1:56] Doug Walker: It is it you have slowly outpaced everyone else.

[1:59] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, penultimate, I guess, is the word. I think Toonrific Tariq's got a leg up on me.

[2:03] Doug Walker: Yeah, but he's never gonna finish that.

[2:06] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, no, he's never in a million years gonna finish that. Uh, but I am just really excited to be here.

[2:13] Doug Walker: And I'm I'm so sorry, you guys.

[2:16] Andrew DeWolf: Who's mom?

[2:18] Doug Walker: I I'm doing the podcast.

[2:21] Doug Walker: Uh no, I I can't pause it. It's online.

[2:27] Doug Walker: Practice your trumpet outside, please.

[2:31] Doug Walker: Okay, I'm I'm so sorry about that, you guys. I I swear that almost never happens.

[2:37] Andrew DeWolf: Hey, hey, Big Beak. I I I want you to not take this offense, but is your mom single?

[2:44] Doug Walker: Uh no, she is a soloist, though.

[2:47] Andrew DeWolf: I always knew Doug Walker lived with his mom.

[2:53] Doug Walker: Too many bits!

[2:54] Jesse McAnally: This week! We are talking about You're a Good Man Charlie Brown.

[2:58] Andrew DeWolf: If you haven't picked up on the bits, cue the music.

[3:01] ♪ Musical number: "You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown" — performed by Doug Walker ♪

[5:02] Jesse McAnally: A second Broadway revival came in 1999.

[5:05] Doug Walker: The character of Patty from the original 1967 performance was replaced by Sally Brown. New dialogue was added by Michael Mayer and additional songs and orchestrations by Andrew Lippa.

[5:16] Jesse McAnally: The 1999 Broadway revival was nominated for four Tony Awards, winning two.

[5:21] Doug Walker: Um, it has been adapted for television twice as a Hallmark Hall of Fame episode, which first aired on NBC in 1973, and as an animated television special, which was first shown on CBS uh in 1985.

[5:34] Doug Walker: The character of Patty was replaced by Sally Brown in that original cartoon and the Broadway revival.

[5:39] Doug Walker: So, this show is based on the beloved Charlie Schultz comic, Charlie Brown and the entire Peanuts bunch explore life's great questions as they play baseball, struggle with homework, sing songs, swoon over their crushes, and celebrate the joy of friendship and the hatred of all your friends.

[5:55] Jesse McAnally: Alright, so you're a good man Charlie Brown. Um Big B. Famously, in your Charlie Brown ranking video, this special was I think like the second lowest.

[6:09] Doug Walker: No, it was the third lowest. I'll have you know. I think uh the only ones below this were the fucking birthday one and uh one that I can't remember, so it probably belongs even below the birthday one.

[6:20] Andrew DeWolf: Oh no, the football one.

[6:21] Doug Walker: The roller skate one and the football one, yes.

[6:23] Andrew DeWolf: No, no, no.

[6:24] Doug Walker: Yeah, the roller skating one and you're in the Super Bowl, Charlie Brown, which I think you could only get from like select shell gas stations.

[6:32] Andrew DeWolf: I don't think Charlie Brown would do well in the Super Bowl. He's notably not very good at sports.

[6:36] Doug Walker: Well no, he didn't make it to the Super Bowl. It was some uh rando named Melody Melody.

[6:41] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, Linus almost won, but Melody Melody um stole it for the last minute.

[6:45] Doug Walker: Melody Melody, yeah, that's uh My name is Melody Melody. I've been watching you. Melody Melody.

[6:53] Andrew DeWolf: That's beautiful.

[6:55] Doug Walker: Is it stealing if it's in a contest, though? Like, I don't like I don't go to like, you know, a like poker competition, and it's like, oh well, you know, I almost won, but you know, I was just a million dollars short or something.

[7:10] Andrew DeWolf: It's stolen if you deserved it more.

[7:13] Doug Walker: Yeah.

[7:13] Andrew DeWolf: And they took it from you. It's like an election.

[7:15] Doug Walker: If you tweet about it louder, yeah, it's like it's like an election. You just say that they stole it from you.

[7:20] Jesse McAnally: Okay. Well, in that case, I stole the ranking of your good man Charlie Brown, because that was the one that I got the most complaints about.

[7:27] Doug Walker: Really?

[7:27] Andrew DeWolf: Every single high school drama student came out of the woodwork to leave a comment on that video that said something like, Hey, I think you are really harsh on your good man Charlie Brown. My high school did a performance of this and I was in it. I was playing Sally Brown, and it was so good.

[7:41] Doug Walker: Yeah, exactly. You know, you know who I didn't get that comment from? Do you know the people that didn't comment that on the channel? Were those people's parents?

[7:50] Andrew DeWolf: Fuck Sally Brown, they should have kept Patty.

[7:53] Doug Walker: No, they should have replaced both of them with Charlotte Braun.

[7:53] Andrew DeWolf: Charlotte Braun, yes, the classic character, my favorite.

[8:00] Doug Walker: Well then you can have like a death halfway through the play.

[8:02] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.

[8:04] Doug Walker: That's really what it's missing. Just like every middle school production, it's it's like it's like thoroughly modern Millie, like with a white slavery in my sister's middle school production.

[8:14] Andrew DeWolf: It's like, you know, just have a murder halfway through.

[8:17] Doug Walker: Um so you I I reached out to you because sincerely your Charlie Brown videos. I am not a Charlie Brown fan. I think we brought this up on the podcast strangely more often than we should have. Um, but I just watched them a lot, and I have no interest in watching any of the specials, but I will re-watch your videos very often, and I continue to plan to do so.

[8:39] Doug Walker: And I knew that so many people have requested you're a good man Charlie Brown on the show because they're the same people that bitch at you for putting it so low on your list.

[8:47] Jesse McAnally: Um so I really wanted your opinion on the proper stage show, both the 70s version and the 90s version. Just to get the vibe.

[8:54] Doug Walker: And what are the vibes for you? Is it better than you thought it was, or is it even worse?

[9:03] Doug Walker: Oh, uh, it sucked.

[9:06] Andrew DeWolf: Oh my goodness.

[9:08] Doug Walker: I'm I'm gonna I'm gonna have I'm I'm just gonna be dropping the hot takes all throughout this um.

[9:13] Jesse McAnally: Alright, alright, alright.

[9:15] Doug Walker: Um I don't know how you want to structure this conversation because this is a production with 50 years of like bullshit behind it.

[9:22] Jesse McAnally: So well, I'll start with the original idea of it and then we'll jump in.

[9:26] Doug Walker: So this is technically the first peanuts fan fiction, if you really think about it. Because the composer was just working on this, um, Clark Gesner was just working on this on his own, saying, trying to get the rights and keep getting rejected by everyone he was going to. Uh, but he kept writing, and then one day he just sent it to Charlie Schultz begging like, hey, can I do this? And Charlie Schultz was like, Yeah, yeah, yeah, do it. This is good, I like this. And got the endorsement and eventually went off Broadway where it was a massive success.

[9:55] Doug Walker: Uh thousands of performers. Like, really, really big show. I will say, I I don't think that you should take Charlie Schultz's endorsement as like some like gospel that it's gonna be a good product because Peanuts has been commercialized all the way like to the moon.

[10:09] Doug Walker: Like the original special the Christmas special was a Coca-Cola product placement, wasn't it?

[10:14] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, yeah.

[10:15] Doug Walker: Linus gets uh ran to do a Coke sign.

[10:19] Doug Walker: Uh my my kind of and uh you know, obviously I never met Charlie Schultz. My take on the man just from what I have read about him and the work that I've seen from him is he was a uh mildly cynical, deeply introspective man who lived a lot of his life in his own head.

[10:37] Doug Walker: And uh the most interesting thing he ever did was go to France in World War II, but he like didn't even kill any Nazis.

[10:44] Andrew DeWolf: So I, you know, but when he got validation for something, he was like super jazzed.

[10:52] Doug Walker: Like he was like thrilled out of his mind when Snoopy and Woodstock were made lifetime masters by the American Contract Bridge Association.

[11:00] Andrew DeWolf: Like it was not that hard to like get Schultz on side.

[11:05] Doug Walker: Um his work is also good, so it's also not too hard to adapt, as you will see by the dozens of Peanuts TV specials, handful of movies, and infinite Snoopy plushies that have circulated around.

[11:22] Andrew DeWolf: You mean he would have fully endorsed all like what is the Met Life ads and shit that they've been attached to post-death?

[11:29] Doug Walker: Yes, I think that he would have endorsed this if it was a steaming pile of crap.

[11:33] Doug Walker: But I think the album is actually quite good.

[11:36] Andrew DeWolf: I I really like the original concept album.

[11:38] Doug Walker: See, I don't love the original concept album.

[11:41] Doug Walker: I don't love the Broadway revival. The only time I think the show works is when kids are putting it on in high school.

[11:47] Andrew DeWolf: I think that's where the show is like really effective.

[11:50] Doug Walker: The charming moments are charming for the same reasons that the original specials are charming.

[11:54] Doug Walker: It's a bunch of kids putting on a show and trying their best.

[11:58] Jesse McAnally: Well, we can talk about why it's so prolific in high schools. I have a couple of theories.

[12:02] Doug Walker: The first is that it's a remarkably simple show. You know, you have what six characters, one of them is a dog. You know, you can put it on in like the middle of bumfuck Alabama, you know, with your, you know, homeschool class.

[12:15] Doug Walker: Everybody gets a lot of uh time. Yeah, there's no like stars, it's an ensemble.

[12:19] Jesse McAnally: And the biggest thing is there's a lot of female roles where they get a lot to do, which you don't get in most musicals.

[12:27] Andrew DeWolf: And it's short.

[12:28] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, well, even what you could do, like if you don't have like the right like cast balance, you could just say, like, yeah, Schroeder's out, we're putting in like Marcy instead. Like, you can just switch out the characters, and they very well did with Sally and Patty, because it really doesn't matter.

[12:43] Andrew DeWolf: They don't do a whole lot in the narrative.

[12:45] Jesse McAnally: There really isn't much of a narrative to speak of. And I guess this is something that we can talk about in relation to the original concept album.

[12:52] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[12:53] Jesse McAnally: Because you have these, you know, songs that are very, you know, kind of short, you know, droll, quippy kind of, you know, dry humor, very peanuts-like, you know, Schultz could have written these songs theoretically. And then it's like, okay, well, how do we put that into a musical? Which is, I guess, the conversation that you know Clark Gesner was having with I don't know, Bob Balaban or whoever was working on this with him.

[13:16] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and you know, I don't know if you've ever seen the uh modern American classic Mamma Mia.

[13:23] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[13:24] Andrew DeWolf: Uh but and two. Yeah, both, you know, obviously cinema and uh musicals at the top of their craft, but I think we can learn a little something from them because they take these pre-existing songs and like actually structure a story for them. Uh and then when they did that for your good man Charlie Brown, they just took the pre-existing songs and then said, Okay, I'm done.

[13:52] Jesse McAnally: Um, yes, it's but vignette-y shows aren't the most rare things. And in the 60s, we were having this kind of tribe musical style come out, um, with like Godspell. Like, strangely, I felt a deeper connection to Godspell than I did for any other kind of music. Right here, maybe even Hair, where it's just like, shit happens. There's gonna be a song and a quick scene, and then we're gonna move on. It just feels like they're doing a bunch of comics essentially.

[14:18] Andrew DeWolf: It's like that's all it feels like to me. Like they reference a bunch of stuff that happens in the comics, and they just kind of run with it, and there's no coherent overall narrative or anything like that.

[14:27] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, well, that's something that I think really crops up, especially in the 99 revival. Um, yeah.

[14:33] Andrew DeWolf: Um, let's talk about the 70s TV production really quickly.

[14:50] Jesse McAnally: I really don't think you have anything to worry about, Charlie Brown. Which is probably the closest way we could ever get to watching what the original Broadway cast was like. I know it looks like it was shot on a potato and uh is like literal like garbage to the eyes.

[15:07] Andrew DeWolf: Um, but what you could see, what did you think? Uh every single like face looks like a Fallout 3 character.

[15:14] Jesse McAnally: I I this line comes to mind. Now, Mina, this is what you call a failure fate. It was very much a failure of faces.

[15:23] Andrew DeWolf: Um I I think that like it obviously was broadcast. I don't know if this was like taped or something. It was broadcast um for I think it was like Hallmark, it was like this quick thing, but they tried to hide it really quick as soon as they found out they were doing an animated version.

[15:37] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, the one that you had sent me, it was like it seemed like it didn't even start yet by the end of it. They like edit it and they're like, now time for the Hallmark feature with like Ricardo Monteban as the Fantastics, and I'm like, well, why didn't we watch that?

[15:50] Andrew DeWolf: Part of me wishes we did. Um that's another one that people keep requesting is the Fantastics, but no, I'm like, I'm gonna do the Blues Brothers. We're never doing Fantastics. I've read the plot for that. It seems like it sucks.

[16:01] Jesse McAnally: Um there's uh entire song. It was back in the days when rape meant to steal, but they keep saying rape. Oh time to rape this person. And I'm like, no!

[16:14] Andrew DeWolf: And Jesse, I know that was the first one you watched. What did you think of it?

[16:18] Jesse McAnally: And nightmare feel, nightmare feel, whatever. Uh I mean, honestly, it's hard to push past the fact that it looks like fucking shit.

[16:25] Andrew DeWolf: Um so I I actually didn't watch this one first, though. I watched the animated one first.

[16:29] Jesse McAnally: Okay, okay. So, like, where how do they compare in your opinion? Because Big Beak also watched the animated one first.

[16:37] Andrew DeWolf: Honestly, they feel like the same thing, except for this one's worse. This one just it's like looks like ass. It doesn't have like any of the animation charm that the animated one has.

[16:50] Jesse McAnally: Which I so I'm I like the peanuts a lot, but I I hate the specials, like all of them. Uh, I just think that the comics are the only way to read the peanuts and fuck the specials.

[17:01] Andrew DeWolf: Um But this one feels like it's close to the comics in a way, like everything is a reference to the comics, more so than the specials ever do, to me.

[17:10] Jesse McAnally: Uh I don't know. I I I can't figure out how I feel about this.

[17:15] Andrew DeWolf: I think that's an extremely appropriate reaction because there really isn't much here to latch on to. It's not like there's like, you know, a store, like, oh, I was really gripped by like the story of like Lucy deciding to like become less of a bitch.

[17:27] Jesse McAnally: Uh like you're not like really supposed to identify with like anyone. It's just vibes, the musical.

[17:35] Andrew DeWolf: What are the vibes of Charlie Brown?

[17:38] Jesse McAnally: Bad, I guess?

[17:40] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it's pretty unpleasant. Everyone hates him.

[17:43] Jesse McAnally: Well, yeah, but that's what that's what the comics are about.

[17:46] Andrew DeWolf: Like. Well, look, at least I can look at the fucking comics. That's why I think we really are having a hard time pinning this down, because like how can you tell what the vibes are when I'm like, I can't see what the hell's going on.

[17:59] Jesse McAnally: So, yeah, the blurry TV special is pretty fucking bad.

[18:03] Andrew DeWolf: Uh yeah. Maybe it looks better in the in when it first came out. Maybe we have like a shitty taping of the special that got fucked up with magnets or some shit.

[18:13] Jesse McAnally: I don't fucking know. The VHS wasn't popular in the 70s. They probably had a third generation tape that is now the only one going around forever.

[18:21] Andrew DeWolf: I think this was on like tubes or something. It's like it's like this was like peeled off the inside of like a glass filament or something.

[18:28] Jesse McAnally: We'll we'll never know if this version was good.

[18:31] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, we can like I so I I I'm gonna extrapolate based on like the original um album and the cast recording from the original musical.

[18:40] Jesse McAnally: And I'm gonna say that it was about the same.

[18:43] Andrew DeWolf: I I'm gonna say that there have been no improvements of your good man Charlie Brown in the last 50 years. They they produced a musical in 1969, and then we landed on the moon, and then they said, okay, we're done.

[18:56] Jesse McAnally: That's that's the end of the development for this musical. We're not gonna make it any better.

[18:59] Andrew DeWolf: We're just gonna make it longer.

[19:03] Jesse McAnally: Um, there are moments I like in Andrew Lippa's editions. Um, so we could let's talk about the animated special really quick.

[19:11] Andrew DeWolf: Some days I like to wake up early so that I can see the sunrise.

[19:16] Jesse McAnally: And I think how beautiful it is. And how my life lies before me. And I get a very positive feeling about things.

[19:25] Andrew DeWolf: Oh boy, have I got some fucking things to say about this one?

[19:29] Jesse McAnally: Alright, alright. Let's go, Big Beak. I know you said it in your video, but let what are what what do you hate about this special?

[19:36] Doug Walker: Well, my my primary feeling is. I can't stand it. I just can't stand it.

[19:43] Jesse McAnally: I I think that they cut the best song.

[19:46] Doug Walker: Uh which, you know, uh, I was watching this in a vacuum originally. I was like, what is this about? You know, fucking nothing. And then I'm I'm listening to the original album, and uh the song, what is it, Doctor is in or something, where yes, Charlie Brown is going to his local roadside psychiatry stand, which really speaks to the state of like mental health care in rural America.

[20:08] Jesse McAnally: Uh, that Charlie Brown has to go to like you know, Lucy Van Pelt for his psychiatric evaluations.

[20:13] Doug Walker: I mean, five cents per session ain't that bad. Lucy's pretty good at it, too.

[20:18] Jesse McAnally: Let me let you in on a little secret, Charlie Brown. If you really want to impress girls, you need to show them you're a winner.

[20:26] Doug Walker: Do you think she's submitting claims from I think she's buying gumballs with the I don't believe that she would accept Charlie Brown's insurance even if she did like cover it.

[20:39] Jesse McAnally: She would know that no one else would be able to talk to him, so she can kind of shake him down for whatever she wants.

[20:45] Doug Walker: I always interpreted the stand as Lucy hates Charlie Brown and creates the stand because she wants to make fun of him.

[20:52] Jesse McAnally: That's how I always interpreted it.

[20:53] Doug Walker: I guess I interpreted it as like Charlie Schultz was like, I want to do a lemonade stand, but like what's funnier than that? A psychiatry stand.

[20:59] Jesse McAnally: I mean, that is a funny a funny gag, but it's also funny because Lucy hates Charlie Brown and Charlie Brown's the only one that ever goes to the fucking stand.

[21:08] Doug Walker: And it is the idea that maybe your psychiatrist does hate you.

[21:14] Jesse McAnally: Well, even in the song, she's like, you're a piece of shit, Charlie Brown. And then she's at the like she pulls it up at the end, like a fucking like, you know, Boeing 737 Max nosediving.

[21:24] Doug Walker: She's just like, yeah, by the way, you're you're you, and that's like, you know, acceptable for now.

[21:29] Jesse McAnally: I'm me!

[21:37] Doug Walker: For whatever it's worth, Charlie Brown.

[21:41] Jesse McAnally: You're you!

[21:43] Doug Walker: Gosh, Lucy, you know something? I'm beginning to feel better already.

[21:48] Jesse McAnally: You're a true friend, Lucy.

[21:50] Doug Walker: A true friend. That'll be five cents, please.

[21:56] Jesse McAnally: You know what? Fair. Um, I I do love that scene. Um the like I love moments in this show, but I agree the animation and the kids here, no energy.

[22:10] Doug Walker: No energy at all.

[22:11] Jesse McAnally: Oh, I'm gonna disagree with that for one very specific reason. Can I can I play a bit from Dear Pen Pal?

[22:18] Doug Walker: Of course.

[22:22] Jesse McAnally: I told you.

[22:29] Doug Walker: It's falsettos. Would you play some directions on how I can get where you are?

[22:40] Jesse McAnally: Okay.

[22:41] Doug Walker: So obviously, you know, a castrato or something, but uh I feel like that was a kid literally like had their parents like, how am I supposed to sing this? And it's like, just do it like this.

[22:53] Jesse McAnally: And then they did it like that on the day. Just do it like this. I'm gonna embarrass themselves.

[22:58] Doug Walker: I'm gonna hit you with this hoctate.

[23:00] Jesse McAnally: I think that's the best performance of that song that I've heard.

[23:02] Doug Walker: Oh my god.

[23:03] Jesse McAnally: I mean, I get it. I don't even go pretty high.

[23:07] Doug Walker: I mean, it's impressive.

[23:08] Jesse McAnally: I think I don't even think like technically it's impressive. I like when I hear that, I believe this is a kid like fucking breaking down in a way that I don't believe with um who's it, Anthony Rapp in the 99 production.

[23:21] Doug Walker: Mark from Rent.

[23:23] Jesse McAnally: Put respect on that name.

[23:25] Doug Walker: When he's not taking pictures of homeless people, he's uh he's being Charlie Brown.

[23:31] Jesse McAnally: All I all I know about um Rent is like the joke from Team America World Police.

[23:35] Doug Walker: Hey, do the one where everyone has AIDS.

[23:38] Jesse McAnally: It's not incorrect, but you should watch Rent, develop your own opinion, and maybe make a video of it.

[23:43] Doug Walker: I would watch it.

[23:44] Jesse McAnally: Oh boy. That yeah, um my inbox is full on that one.

[23:48] Doug Walker: I've I keep getting recommendations for more peanuts products. I'm never gonna do Lucy School, by the way. For any of my subscribers listening to me right now.

[23:55] Jesse McAnally: I don't know. Do you do the comics?

[23:58] Doug Walker: Yeah, but like I'm not gonna scan every comic and like oh, I really like the here's the thing about the comics.

[24:04] Jesse McAnally: The comics are just straight up good.

[24:06] Doug Walker: Yeah. There's not a lot to like like riff on in like a YouTube video in the way that there is for the peanut specials.

[24:12] Jesse McAnally: You could really get click baity, and you might want to cut this, Andrew, because this is a good idea. You might get clickbaity and just be like the the the Charlie Brown character that was murdered, and literally just that, and then just relay the Wikipedia page about Charlotte Braun and then rank in the views.

[24:30] Doug Walker: I love Charlotte Braun so much. She's my like like avatar on on a lot of social media stuff.

[24:36] Andrew DeWolf: Do you get like random fail mail wishing for your death?

[24:39] Jesse McAnally: Sadly, no.

[24:40] Andrew DeWolf: That all goes to me. Nobody, nobody has given me the axe yet.

[24:43] Jesse McAnally: Do you think that's the first example of somebody like wanting to like murder a fictional character and like the author actually doing it for them?

[24:51] Andrew DeWolf: I can't think of another case where that's happened.

[24:53] Jesse McAnally: Well, no, I Rose Tico from Star Wars.

[25:02] Andrew DeWolf: Basically what happened. I mean, death without dying is what happened to Rose Tico.

[25:08] Jesse McAnally: I mean, they never killed Charlotte Braun in the comic.

[25:12] Andrew DeWolf: No, she's fucking dead. She died in a home invasion, like she was axe murdered. I don't know what happened, but she is dead.

[25:18] Jesse McAnally: The drawing of her with the axe in her head, though, that doesn't happen in universe.

[25:24] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[25:25] Jesse McAnally: I think well, I I think it's Schultz's headcanon. I don't think that it's like, you know, some.

[25:29] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, I mean, yeah, of course. I mean, I think it's everyone's headcanon. It's just I I think if if you're looking canonically, maybe she moved away.

[25:36] Andrew DeWolf: You know, it's dead.

[25:39] Jesse McAnally: No. I mean, he brought back fucking Peggy Jean for like a one-panel like scene. Like he's gonna bring back Charlotte Bronte if she wasn't dead.

[25:44] Andrew DeWolf: Charlotte Bronte.

[25:49] Jesse McAnally: Sorry. Sorry, I forgot. I forgot this wasn't. I'm not gonna lie, I've I've I have had half a beer. So um Oh my goodness. That's some GC stories.

[26:01] Andrew DeWolf: I need it scratch. I need it to talk about the the TV special.

[26:05] Jesse McAnally: Let's talk about this line. I'm gonna be the biggest queen there ever was.

[26:11] Andrew DeWolf: Let's talk about how Linus immediately shoots her down with some like Republican bullshit, and then not like 15 minutes earlier, everyone was just telling Charlie Brown that he could have been king.

[26:24] Jesse McAnally: Well, the thing about that is women here. All that Lucy would have had to do is kill Princess Diana and marry Prince Charles.

[26:32] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, you're right. Charlie Brown would have had to like end it very well. Charlie Brown would have had to like fund like a monarchist revolution.

[26:39] Jesse McAnally: Wouldn't that be interesting? Man, it would have been like Harry situation all over.

[26:41] Andrew DeWolf: It would have been interesting. Um who's who's the best peanuts character? Just straight up.

[26:49] Jesse McAnally: Oh well, no, Franklin is the best, unironically.

[26:53] Andrew DeWolf: Franklin is very good.

[26:54] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. There's nothing else to say about Franklin except he's just the best character Schultz ever wrote, but he didn't write him like very much.

[27:02] Andrew DeWolf: Uh I think I think Peppermint Patty's pretty good.

[27:04] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. I hate Lucy and and Linus and Sally. I think those three suck.

[27:09] Andrew DeWolf: I I I I'm kind of partial to Marcy because Marcy's good. Like she's kind of an idiot. But the people just assume she's smart because glasses because of the glasses.

[27:21] Jesse McAnally: Sorry, sir. You can kind of I think you might have read more of the.

[27:23] Andrew DeWolf: I've read probably maybe like 50% to 60% of the comics. There's just a lot, but you can correct me if I'm wrong, Andrew.

[27:31] Andrew DeWolf: But she is like not like stupid in the comics. She's just really stressed out about everything.

[27:36] Jesse McAnally: I don't think Marcy's ever portrayed as stupid, no. Uh Marcy is like just weird. Uh she's got a lot of weird tendencies, weird tendencies.

[27:46] Andrew DeWolf: Um also I don't love the reading that she and Peppermint Patty are like together. I don't think that that's true.

[27:53] Jesse McAnally: I don't think that's ever been true. They both want to fuck Charlie Brown too much for that to be true.

[27:59] Andrew DeWolf: No, she's into yeah. They're both into Chuck.

[28:01] Jesse McAnally: Peppermint Patty, maybe less so. They're both into Chuck, and I think that that's very clear. And the reading that they're they're gay somehow, I think is just weird.

[28:09] Andrew DeWolf: Um it's just one of those like memes like that you see on the internet.

[28:12] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, it's like Bird and Ernie. Except for Bert and Ernie actually live together. So I mean, like at least that one makes a little bit more.

[28:18] Andrew DeWolf: And they're grown men. The thing about Bert and Ernie is in their universe they are grown men. These are kids, so I feel weird, like, oh, definitely lesbians and all that. Especially when a lot of the the story with them is that they both like Charlie Brown.

[28:30] Jesse McAnally: So those are the worst comments that I get is like, who do you ship from the peanuts? And I'm like, fucking no one.

[28:34] Andrew DeWolf: Woodstock and Snoopy.

[28:38] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, Woodstock and Snoopy, if anybody. Which also when they started making Snoopy talk, the comic went downhill a little bit. I think that he's funnier as a mime.

[28:47] Andrew DeWolf: And I think that that's what musical struggles with a little bit. Like it's kind of hard to like rectify like I feel every now and then that I gotta fight someone. With something like nobody ever calls me Sugar Lips. Like, you know, you can get those two lines in a row from Snoopy, and it's like, what what the fuck are you talking about?

[29:06] Jesse McAnally: I when Snoopy started talking, I was like, wait, no, they're really doing this? Like in in in this uh specifically. Like, why Snoopy shouldn't sing or talk in your special with That's a Musical. Snoopy is a dog.

[29:21] Andrew DeWolf: Um especially when you have characters that you do fucking nothing with. Like what what the fuck is Sally even here for?

[29:26] Jesse McAnally: I've actually got a line for that. And I I'm wondering, because this is from the nineteen uh eighty-three or whatever version.

[29:33] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[29:33] Jesse McAnally: And I you know, obviously we all spend a lot of time listening to audio and like splicing audio. So we might be able to hear this, uh, but for you at listening at home or in the car, see if you can and tell if they just changed maybe a word in this.

[29:48] Andrew DeWolf: You don't give me that pen. I'll tell Sally what you said about her.

[29:56] Jesse McAnally: That was the last bit of change. So this is from all the audio engineers at home. If you're gonna re-record a word, just do the whole line. But it's very clear that they're not time. It's clear that they wrote this like with Patty and recorded it saying, I'll tell Patty what you said about her. And then they realized, oh, right, Patty is a shit character. Let's bin her. Who do we put in her place? Uh Sally. And that's where that change comes from, is from this cartoon in 1983.

[30:28] Andrew DeWolf: But that being said, I think it's a good change. And Kristen Chennewith, it's worth having her career because of your good man Charlie Brown.

[30:37] Jesse McAnally: Why would it change? Sally sucks. Peppermint Patty is way better.

[30:41] Andrew DeWolf: It's not Pepperman Patty, it's Patty.

[30:44] Jesse McAnally: Oh, it's just Patty.

[30:45] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, yeah, no, it's my mistake. Straight up Patty, who sucks even more. But like they should have changed. It really doesn't make sense why, like, these like four people are just hanging around each other. Like, it's weird to see Lucy with Sally just like shooting the shit about like a dress she wore. Like, it's not something that they would have that conversation about.

[31:06] Jesse McAnally: Sally would say, like, yeah, I don't really care. Where's my money?

[31:10] Andrew DeWolf: That is what Patty would do is shoot the shit with Lucy. That is that is what Patty would do.

[31:14] Jesse McAnally: Well, in the in the 19, you know, in the in the shit vision one, whatever it was called, the 1970-three one, Patty is just portrayed as like the stupidest person who's ever lived.

[31:28] Andrew DeWolf: And they carried that. Patty's thing that she's loud. Am I mistaken?

[31:32] Jesse McAnally: I think Patty's just thing is that she was there first. It was originally Shermy, Patty, and Charlie Brown. Those are the first three characters.

[31:38] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, I hate him.

[31:39] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, exactly. Just that was the first strip. And that's the vibes of the comic. I'm impressed that Schultz managed to turn that into a 50-year-long career.

[31:48] Andrew DeWolf: Um he never changed it either. That's the it's the same joke every time.

[31:53] Jesse McAnally: When Clark Gesner was writing this, he was writing this in 1962, I think, right?

[31:59] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[31:59] Jesse McAnally: So he had the benefit of exactly like three years of Peanuts Comics, whereas we, as mighty spacemen of the future, have the benefit of 50 years of Peanuts Comics to make fun of him. Like, I don't think like that he was writing these characters super out of character. Like, I don't think that he was like, yeah, Patty's an idiot or something, and like that was an incorrect assessment. I just think that we're smarter than people in the 60s.

[32:24] Andrew DeWolf: What? No way.

[32:26] Jesse McAnally: Um, they they they had all their stuff together. Um before we move on to the letterbox game, um, and then some songs. I do want to share one thing that I think actually kind of works. So, about six years ago, um, Michael Unger directed a New York Theater Company production of You're a Good Man Charlie Brown, starring all the Broadway kids.

[32:47] Andrew DeWolf: So every child that was on Broadway at the time, whether they were from Matilda or Fun Home and anything, they got them all together, and they're all like fantastic singers. But one of them is Millie Shapiro. Does that name ring a bell to any of you?

[33:02] Jesse McAnally: She plays Sally in this production.

[33:04] Andrew DeWolf: Is that the daughter of like Millie Bobby Brown and Ben Shapiro?

[33:08] Jesse McAnally: No, but that is a funny joke and 10 comedy points. Um, it is the little girl from Hereditary who gets beheaded.

[33:17] Andrew DeWolf: And so that really spice up the musical.

[33:20] Jesse McAnally: It did, but she is actually very good. Why aren't you telling me my new philosophy?

[33:29] Andrew DeWolf: The teacher Gaby on last week's homework. She said Miss Sally Brown. Your grades are going down.

[33:38] Jesse McAnally: I could have told her new philosophy. New philosophy. See what I mean? Like, I I think when kids perform this and like really good kids, it can't just be like kids doing it for fun. I think this really sings. And I think that 26 cast album 2016 cast album is the best version to listen to. I think children definitely have to be performing this.

[33:59] Andrew DeWolf: We didn't talk at all, but it's weird when Charlie Brown is a grown man.

[34:03] Jesse McAnally: With hair.

[34:04] Andrew DeWolf: With hair.

[34:05] Jesse McAnally: Oh, he always has hair. It's just very light.

[34:07] Andrew DeWolf: He's got one hair.

[34:08] Jesse McAnally: That's the weird thing about the Peanuts movie that I hated is how they animated his hair is just like one like unicorn hair sticking out of his forehead.

[34:15] Andrew DeWolf: No, Charlie Brown has hair canonically. It's just it's like, you know, the blondest friend that you have, whose like hair is like translucent.

[34:23] Jesse McAnally: Nice. But it also it also sep it separates him for the rest of the crew.

[34:32] Andrew DeWolf: Except Yeah, well, it meant that Schultz could use less ink when drawing him.

[34:36] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. Didn't have to do the hair that he did for Shermy. Or the shading that he did for Franklin.

[34:41] Andrew DeWolf: On that note, um, it's time for everyone's favorite point of the game. It's time for a previews. And this is the time when we compare our opinions to those of the real critics out there, those on letterbox.com. And I'm gonna read you both going head to head. A real letterbox review from any of the peanut shorts, and you have to tell me based on the review alone whether it's a one star or a five star.

[35:06] Jesse McAnally: I was about to ask, are there even enough letterboxed reviews to do that for your good man Charlie Brown?

[35:11] Andrew DeWolf: No, they were not, so I went into all of them.

[35:14] Jesse McAnally: Okay, good. That gives me some context. Who wants to go first?

[35:18] Andrew DeWolf: Let our guests go first, I think.

[35:19] Jesse McAnally: Alright, Big Beak, you ready?

[35:21] Doug Walker: Thank you. Yes.

[35:22] Jesse McAnally: Charlie Brown did have host, actually. Can I like ask which one that's from?

[35:26] Doug Walker: I would not be able to answer that for you.

[35:29] Jesse McAnally: Okay. Uh you can ask, and sometimes I will know. That one I do not know.

[35:34] Doug Walker: Okay. I'm I'm gonna guess that's from 2002, which is a piece of shit, so I'm gonna say one star.

[35:40] Jesse McAnally: That was a five star. Charlie Brown's got hose.

[35:43] Andrew DeWolf: Are you ready?

[35:44] Doug Walker: I I I guess so.

[35:46] Jesse McAnally: Cool thumb brown just passing through.

[35:48] Andrew DeWolf: Cool thumb brown just passing through.

[35:51] Jesse McAnally: Okay. Uh five stars.

[35:53] Andrew DeWolf: That is correct. And was also written by our own guest, Big Beak Entertainment.

[35:57] Doug Walker: Oh, really?

[35:58] Jesse McAnally: Yes, I am a letterboxed uh person.

[36:02] Doug Walker: What did you write that for?

[36:03] Jesse McAnally: You like this one?

[36:03] Doug Walker: I wrote that for uh the 2006 He's a Bully Charlie Brown, starring Taylor Taylor Lautner of all people.

[36:09] Jesse McAnally: Oh damn. That's something I think we should make fun of more celebrities for, is like the time they spent with Charlie Brown.

[36:17] Doug Walker: I'm sorry. Like he's just we gotta bring that up more often, but he went to the Charlie Brown Island.

[36:23] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, like I think it's like hilarious that Fergie's first gig was like a Sally. And Elizabeth Moss was somewhere in there.

[36:30] Doug Walker: Well, we can make fun of Elizabeth Moss for other things.

[36:33] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. Um, alright. Are you ready, Big B?

[36:35] Doug Walker: I I thought I was, but alright, let me let me have it, I guess.

[36:39] Jesse McAnally: I think it's really funny that this made it canon that Charlie Brown likes MILFs.

[36:42] Doug Walker: Uh I I'm like, I'm trying to like reverse engineer it. Like if I can guess the special, I'm not gonna guess it. Uh one star?

[36:50] Jesse McAnally: That is a five star. I can't think of any instance of Charlie Brown like being down bad for a MILF.

[36:56] Jesse McAnally: I did not either.

[36:58] Andrew DeWolf: Doesn't it just turn you on though?

[36:59] Doug Walker: Wop womp, blah blah blah blah.

[37:01] Jesse McAnally: Oof.

[37:02] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, is that person single?

[37:07] Jesse McAnally: Um, all right, Andrew. Drunk driver picks up Snoopy's brother and shows him a good time.

[37:15] Andrew DeWolf: Which brother?

[37:18] Jesse McAnally: The only one that they care about.

[37:19] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I know.

[37:20] Jesse McAnally: Oh, the the cactus guy.

[37:22] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Um I gotta say five stars again.

[37:25] Jesse McAnally: That is a one star because that movie looks like an insane trip.

[37:30] Doug Walker: That movie's great, actually. Every single person like listening to this should watch uh it's the girl in the red truck, Charlie Brown.

[37:37] Andrew DeWolf: Great. I'm gonna go change.

[37:40] Jesse McAnally: Bang, I'll be back in a minute. Peppermint Patty and Snoopy murder ten boys.

[37:50] Andrew DeWolf: Uh five stars.

[37:52] Jesse McAnally: That is correct. And you all are tied now.

[37:55] Doug Walker: All right, one more time around, then we're done.

[37:57] Andrew DeWolf: I swear I was behind.

[37:58] Doug Walker: Alright, what tied?

[37:59] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, we're trying to.

[37:59] Doug Walker: He doesn't actually keep track. He just likes to go.

[38:01] Jesse McAnally: No, no, no, no. Andrew never got anything after the first one.

[38:05] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, okay. Alright.

[38:06] Jesse McAnally: Alright, Andrew.

[38:07] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[38:07] Jesse McAnally: Linus hunts cougars.

[38:09] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. Linus actually would be into older women, that's for sure. Um it's either Linus or rerun. One of them is the sex pest.

[38:16] Jesse McAnally: Rerun's a fake character that I won't acknowledge.

[38:19] Doug Walker: You don't like Rerun?

[38:21] Andrew DeWolf: The fuck, man. He's just a kid.

[38:24] Jesse McAnally: Watch out. He's gonna get Charlotte Braun.

[38:27] Doug Walker: He basically did because he disappeared like as soon as Apple bought it. You can like flip a coin on whether or not rerun is alive or not.

[38:36] Jesse McAnally: Linus Hunt's Cougars. That's gonna be a one-star.

[38:39] Andrew DeWolf: That is a five-star. Um all right. Big beak. This is the last one. You could we can win this all here. Even though it's not fair at all because you started this, so um even if I'm wrong, please like lie to me and tell me that it's right.

[38:52] Doug Walker: Snoopy brought a loaded gun into Charlie Brown's home.

[38:56] Jesse McAnally: Five stars.

[38:57] Doug Walker: That's the Thanksgiving one.

[38:59] Jesse McAnally: That is correct. And you have won the letterbox game.

[39:02] Doug Walker: Oh, thank goodness. My entire identity was wrapped up in winning that game, so I'm really glad that I did.

[39:06] Jesse McAnally: Okay, some guests that we've had get really anxious during that game. They get actually really competitive and uncomfortable during it. So I'm glad you took it with stride.

[39:17] Doug Walker: I've just written probably half of those reviews. I think that I was I might have had a bit of a leg up. There was another review of yours that I didn't read, which is Lucy is a flat earther confirmed.

[39:26] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, she is. Actually, no, she would just do that if it was profitable. So she is like the ultimate flat earther. She's a grifter.

[39:38] Andrew DeWolf: Hey guys, sorry to interrupt you, middle of the show, but we've got a shh shell at you. Today's show is brought to you by the extremely kind donations by our donors over at Patreon. And over at Patreon, you can get all this fun shit. We got commentaries, we got full-blown different podcasts. You can watch me and Andrew do commentaries on the Star Wars holiday special, the Rugrats movie, both Camp Rock movies, the Goofy movie, and all three high school musical movies, along with just a lot of other crazy bullshit. Um, but Andrew, why don't you tell actually, actually, our guests, I can see right in the top of their lips that they just want to say support support them on Patreon. I can see that right at the top of their two-can lips that they want to say it.

[40:17] Doug Walker: Yeah, you should support them on Patreon. I don't know why the fuck you're not.

[40:21] Jesse McAnally: I got him to say it! They did it! I got Doug Walker to support us! Doug Walker is now a patron.

[40:29] Doug Walker: Listen, I review it so you don't have to. Let me tell you guys, I took a fucking bullet for you this time.

[40:36] Jesse McAnally: But who is supporting us, Andrew?

[40:39] Andrew DeWolf: Our current patrons are. And here we go. Uh Melissa Goldman, Danielle Rennox, Justice Stampede, Ewan Cassidy, Monica Thoreau, Mina Maniri, Brent Black, Lathaniel Stacy Coombe, Joseph Evans Green, Mary Luce Choquette, John Finals, Ross Walker, Musical Hell, Emily Gracie, Kyle Summers, Janay C, Scoot and the Technical Dreamcoat, Liz Lim, nothing is certain except Beth and Texas, Thesbian, Ren Cullen, Raphael Martinez Salaz, Jessica T, Mitchell Young, Chai Teacup, Katie McDonough, Chris Marcote, KG Marie Anastasio, Trevi Joseph, Leela, RJ Norriga, Char Charlie B.

[41:13] Jesse McAnally: Charlie Brown, Charlie Brown is a patron. Um nobody is the nostalgic critic, and they just are too embarrassed to admit it, so. Um but they give us a little extra financial support that helps us keep the lights on here at Musicals and Cheese. If you would like to join them and get patronly commentaries and tons of other shit. Come join us over at Patreon. Alright, let's get back to the show.

[42:12] ♪ Musical number: "You're a Good Man, Charlie Brown" ♪

[43:04] Andrew DeWolf: I really like I stayed away from this musical for a very long time because I really did not like this opening number. I think that it's not the number that they should open it with. I I don't think it's bad, but it's not the one that they should open with. I think they should open with the kite one.

[43:18] Jesse McAnally: I get yeah, yeah, because we always like to see Charlie Brown in pain. More recently, they start with like the Vince Giraldi, but that then that one. Um then they do. They shouldn't do that. I I don't really feel like this song makes sense as an opener. Just because it seems like it comes out of nowhere. Everyone's just talking about how much they shit on Charlie Brown, and then all of a sudden they're also all singing about how he's great. I don't know. Maybe I'm misinterpreting the lyrics. Maybe it's uh all sarcastic, they actually don't like Charlie Brown.

[43:49] Doug Walker: It feels like they wrote the song before the script.

[43:52] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, exactly. Yeah. Cause uh I don't know. It just it feels a little weird. Honestly, it just feels out of character for everybody, because nobody in this show says they like Charlie Brown. Uh at least not really. And then at the very beginning, they all love him.

[44:05] Andrew DeWolf: I think that Schroeder doesn't say anything negative about him. I think he's just like, you know, Charlie Brown, like kinda like isn't good at stuff. That's not incorrect.

[44:12] Jesse McAnally: Schroeder is always kind of just neutral because he doesn't give a shit about anything except for Beethoven. Um he's got a hyperfixation, he's not moving away from it. I mean, he literally his his posture is crouched over staring at his uh piano. I mean boys have literally boys pick one personality and stick with it for their entire life. Usually it's trains.

[44:32] Doug Walker: I I wish it was trains. It's usually cars.

[44:36] Jesse McAnally: No, I haven't. It's like boys pick one of these as a personality, and it's like a train or like a soldier or like a plane or something or an astronaut.

[44:45] Andrew DeWolf: What an ours?

[44:47] Jesse McAnally: A microphone.

[44:48] Doug Walker: Yeah, the podcasters.

[44:50] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. And somehow we're the cringy caster now. We live our lives in the podcast mines. Churning out content for you, the glorious patron.

[44:58] Andrew DeWolf: I will say, sincerely, the the the pandemic killed podcasting, being an interesting and niche thing, because then everyone got a fucking podcast.

[45:07] Doug Walker: It's like artisanal mining. The barrier to entry is just so low that like how could you not?

[45:11] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, you're not wrong. You're not wrong. But then, like, pandemic, no one had anything to do, so then they got a podcast and then they abandoned it as soon as they like, you know, got back to real.

[45:20] Andrew DeWolf: Except us. We were pathetic enough to stick with it.

[45:23] Jesse McAnally: We were pathetic enough to be podcasters before the pandemic.

[45:28] Doug Walker: Aha. We're w we're worse.

[45:31] Jesse McAnally: The you want to talk about the kite?

[45:33] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, we mentioned it briefly.

[45:34] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, let's talk about the kite song.

[45:36] ♪ Musical number: "The Kite" ♪

[46:13] Andrew DeWolf: I think this is the song you should start with, because this seems to most like the I want song to me.

[46:18] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. I mean, as far as this has a narrative, sure.

[46:20] Doug Walker: Well, like, you could structure a narrative out of this. You could like extract a story from this if you really wanted to. About Charlie Brown, you know, failing to fly a kite, and then he's like, oh, well, maybe my you know, you could do like Pippin, where, you know, you know, like shit. And uh the story is like, you know, oh, I wanted to fly a kite, but maybe that's not my purpose. Uh oh, well, maybe I can be, you know, good at uh I I don't know, tying my shoes or something. Oh, well, I'm you know, I failed at that. And then you end with the pen pal song.

[46:49] Jesse McAnally: Then we have the pen pal, then we have the baseball. There's a l yeah, that's a good one. Yeah, you can structure it. They just didn't. And that speaks to me like you could just get away with anything in the 60s. Like you did really did not have to try very much. You just had to have a recognizable brand.

[47:02] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, have you seen Godspell?

[47:04] Jesse McAnally: I mean, yeah, have you seen Godspell?

[47:06] Doug Walker: No, I haven't.

[47:07] Jesse McAnally: You don't need a plot. You do not need a plot. You just need a familiar brand, you know, like Jesus.

[47:13] Doug Walker: Or Charlie Brown. They are equivalents. In fact, I might say Charlie Brown is bigger than Jesus.

[47:19] Jesse McAnally: Charlie Brown does have a longer book at this point.

[47:22] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. I think it is technically the longest story written by a single man.

[47:26] Doug Walker: I just really love, like, even he's like, Snoopy likes me, and she's like, no, you just feed him and he pretends to like you. Your dog hates you.

[47:32] Jesse McAnally: It's funny because that's unironically true. Like Snoopy doesn't actually like Charlie Brown that much.

[47:38] Andrew DeWolf: I don't think he hates them, though.

[47:39] Jesse McAnally: He doesn't hate him, but I don't know how much love there is between Charlie and Snoopy.

[47:45] Doug Walker: Is there love between Snoopy and Sally though?

[47:47] Jesse McAnally: Do they even know each other exist?

[47:49] Andrew DeWolf: I don't think they're there's a fetch game that they play in this.

[47:52] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, but that was Patty originally.

[47:53] Doug Walker: You're citing this as Canon?

[47:56] Jesse McAnally: Keep in mind, anything with Sally is supposed to be Patty and Canon.

[47:59] Doug Walker: Oh, you're right. You're right. Charles Schultz never approved this being Sally.

[48:03] Jesse McAnally: You're right. I do think that um Snoopy was originally supposed to be Patty's dog.

[48:08] Andrew DeWolf: When did that change?

[48:09] Jesse McAnally: I don't know, like the fourth or fifth strip. Schultz changed stuff all the time. Woodstock's technically like the first trans Peanuts character. Just because Schultz was like, ah, it's a girl. Oh no, wait, it's a boy.

[48:19] Doug Walker: So it's kind of like Tweety Bird, where for years we all just assumed Tweety Bird was a girl, but no, it's a boy.

[48:24] Jesse McAnally: Because it's kind of like Tweety Bird's not a girl.

[48:26] Doug Walker: No, it's a boy.

[48:27] Jesse McAnally: Oh, okay. Well, I learned something today. Um, I think the only female Looney Tune is Lola, and they had to introduce her in the 90s.

[48:35] Doug Walker: Well, there's the cat. There's the cat that gets uh sexually harassed every episode.

[48:41] Jesse McAnally: That's I yeah, yeah.

[48:44] Doug Walker: Pepe Le Pew's like.

[48:46] Jesse McAnally: I don't think that cat ever had a line of dialogue, but um, let's move on to the next song. Um, let's talk about little known facts.

[48:55] Andrew DeWolf: You know, the song about Lucy being a flat earther.

[48:57] Jesse McAnally: Come along, Linus. You see this tree? It is a fur tree. It's called a fur tree because it gives up first four for coats.

[49:12] Jesse McAnally: It also gives up hope in the wintertime.

[49:14] Andrew DeWolf: I never knew that before, Lucy.

[49:16] Doug Walker: That's very interesting.

[49:18] Jesse McAnally: This is an elm tree.

[49:20] Andrew DeWolf: It's very little, but it will grow up into the giant tree.

[49:25] Doug Walker: And oh, you can tell how old it is by counting its leaves.

[49:28] Jesse McAnally: Gosh, Lucy, that's fascinating.

[49:30] Andrew DeWolf: Now wait a minute, Lucy. I don't mean to interfere my ad wiggle. Let's talk about little known facts.

[49:36] Doug Walker: Let's talk about what they don't want you to know. Where do you really think the rain comes from, Charlie Brown?

[49:42] Jesse McAnally: You think that's air you're breathing? Do you see this tree?

[49:44] Andrew DeWolf: It is a fur tree. It's called a fur tree because it gives us fur for coats.

[49:50] Doug Walker: And it gives us wool in the winter time.

[49:53] Jesse McAnally: Okay, I laughed. I don't know. Is d is do we not think this is funny? Is I like this. Am I missing something?

[49:59] Andrew DeWolf: I think it's funny, but I've heard it like seven times at this point, so it just becomes like, yeah, okay, Lucy is, you know, either just setting up Linus for failure or proving that she herself is the stupidest person alive.

[50:13] Doug Walker: And Charlie Brown just like wants to correct her, and she's like, Charlie Brown, no, you're wrong. She gaslights Charlie Brown to his face.

[50:21] Jesse McAnally: I mean, that's just any argument with a flat earther.

[50:24] Andrew DeWolf: It's a Lucy thing to do, though. Like Lucy is a piece of shit.

[50:30] Doug Walker: It comes up out of the ground like grass. It comes up, Charlie Brown. Snow comes up.

[50:34] Jesse McAnally: I do want to talk about how this song suffers from an utter lack of Woodstock in every performance.

[50:41] Andrew DeWolf: Because keep in mind this play was written before Woodstock existed.

[50:45] Doug Walker: Yes.

[50:46] Jesse McAnally: Um, Snoopy's character really does not work without Woodstock in my opinion.

[50:49] Andrew DeWolf: But when Sally points to Woodstock in the cartoon, I'm like, yes, that joke lands. When Sally just does it like on stage, or I'm sorry, not Sally. I keep saying Sally because Lucy is, you know, not somebody who I really think of very often, but when Lucy when Lucy points to nothing on stage, uh, it's like what is I okay.

[51:10] Doug Walker: Uh is it an eagle? Oh, I guess it's just a sparrow. Okay. We're missing something.

[51:14] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, it's visual humor that is not being communicated effectively.

[51:18] Andrew DeWolf: Um, yeah, we should really write a bunch of letters to Andrew Lippa um and say, hey, you fucked up. You fucked up with this musical, and you're a failure.

[51:26] Doug Walker: Really? Yo, real quick, I want to shout out the absolute Chad who recorded this thing like under his jacket or something in the middle of the theater.

[51:37] Jesse McAnally: In 1999. And he was doing the camera zooms, and he was like, Yeah, this is gonna be a real production. And I want to shout this guy out because this is the only footage that I think we could find.

[51:47] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Was this one like bootleg pirated copy.

[51:51] Doug Walker: Bootleggers are like the backbone of Broadway. They're heroes.

[51:58] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, truly. And it looked better than the 1973 special.

[52:02] Andrew DeWolf: Let's talk about Supper Time, which is kind of the 11 o'clock number, weirdly.

[52:08] Doug Walker: Supper Time?

[52:10] Jesse McAnally: Supper Time!

[52:12] Doug Walker: Behold the brimming bowl of meat and meal, which is brought forth to ease our hunger.

[52:22] Andrew DeWolf: Behold! The flowing flag in moist and sweet, which has been sent to slick our thirst.

[52:32] Jesse McAnally: So Supper Time. Uh Snoopy sings about wanting food. And Charlie Brown tells him.

[52:38] Doug Walker: Okay, there's no need for a big production. Hey, and then everyone, everyone claps their hands.

[52:45] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I agree with Charlie Brown. I think that you know Snoopy should just keep it down a little bit. People are trying to sleep in the audience.

[52:52] Doug Walker: I do like Roger Bart playing Snoopy. I do like Roger Bart as Snoopy on stage. I just don't think Snoopy should talk ever.

[53:00] Jesse McAnally: No, I like him too. I think that his manner is I think that he's probably the best performer up there.

[53:06] Andrew DeWolf: I agree. But I also think that he's got a pretty easy job. I don't think that it's like pushing the boundaries of like, you know, acting.

[53:14] Doug Walker: No, but like I like Anthony Rapp as a human being. Him as Charlie Brown. I don't know what he was going for.

[53:23] Jesse McAnally: I don't know what any of them are going for. At least he didn't do like a weird voice.

[53:26] Andrew DeWolf: Um, Roger Bart.

[53:28] Doug Walker: Yeah. Everyone else did. Um except Kristen Chenowith. Her voice is weird enough without doing a weird voice.

[53:33] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. If we want to talk about how only like shrill children should sing this, we can talk about Kristen Chenowith.

[53:39] Andrew DeWolf: I think that she really comes out strong there, and I think she won the Tony for her little role.

[53:45] Doug Walker: Yeah, she did. I s I as part of my trying to find this performance. I saw her Tony performance of um My Philosophy.

[53:53] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. And she's good. She's very good.

[53:54] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. She is a bucket of charm, and I'm grateful she's had the career she has.

[53:58] Doug Walker: It's a shame I hate the song so much.

[54:00] Jesse McAnally: Why do you hate the song?

[54:02] Andrew DeWolf: I hate both of the songs. I hate Beethoven Day more, um, but I also hate My Philosophy. Um it's weird.

[54:08] Doug Walker: What do you have against Beethoven Day first?

[54:09] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, it sucks. Schroeder, I just want you to know I'm on your side. I want to help you publicity-wise with Beethoven's birthday.

[54:17] Doug Walker: Thanks for your support, but I just don't want to see Beethoven's birthday commercialized.

[54:21] Andrew DeWolf: Commercialized! Yes, the next thing you know, they'll be wearing Beethoven sweatshirts.

[54:26] Doug Walker: Beethoven Day. If you want to read now, how do we start?

[54:31] Andrew DeWolf: Just blow the music till you know it behind. We're gonna celebrate. We'll throw on a Beethoven's birthday.

[54:41] Doug Walker: Beetle. And when you say the title.

[54:44] Andrew DeWolf: Beetle Day. You hear a great recital.

[54:47] Doug Walker: Or rhino, very boy and girl to stand up and say, hooray Beethoven's grey.

[54:53] Jesse McAnally: Schroeder's whole thing. I guess it's kind of my joke that Schroeder is the most bass Peanuts character because he will stick up for Charlie Brown and he really doesn't care what anyone else thinks of him.

[55:04] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, as long as he is just kind of doing the thing that he's comfortable with. Um Schroeder in this is like, I've gotta get everybody to sign on to Beethoven Day at any cost.

[55:17] Doug Walker: But we also gotta make sure that we don't commercialize him. But also I wanna put his face on Mount Rushmore.

[55:24] Andrew DeWolf: I will say, if Schroeder's gonna do that about anything, it would be Beethoven. I also just like, you know, I get it. Schroeder likes Beethoven.

[55:33] Doug Walker: Like, you know, introduce him to like nine-inch nails or something. Like, like spice it up.

[55:38] Jesse McAnally: No, this is art. What about my my like what's that speech he gives?

[55:44] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, yeah, playing great music is an art. An art. Do you hear me? An art. Art, art, art, art, art.

[55:49] Doug Walker: Saloon gals. Sing. Little bitty snop nose children. Thing. I YOLO. And yodeling is an art!

[56:00] Jesse McAnally: I don't know who was doing the you know, obviously, rating a stage performance is very different when you're like watching it behind a screen versus when you're in the audience. I imagine the audience was like losing their minds over that.

[56:11] Andrew DeWolf: I thought it was a little over the top. I uh you know, that's just me. Having seen this at the end of a long list of other Peanuts content, including the same musical twice over.

[56:20] Doug Walker: Um it was Stanley Wayne Mathis who played it on Broadway. Um he's well known. He's like a good character actor. Like he was um he was in the he was the main chief in the Book of Mormon.

[56:36] Andrew DeWolf: He was in uh the Lion King original Broadway cast as one of the hyenas. Um, but most famously he was Schroeder in You're a Good Man Charlie Brown.

[56:46] Jesse McAnally: And on that note, what is our overall thoughts on You're a Good Man Charlie Brown and our cheese ratings? Andrew, why don't you go first?

[56:55] Andrew DeWolf: Uh honestly, it's a bit of a mess. It just doesn't have anything to like really pull you in. And even as a fan of the Peanuts, like you gotta do a bit more than just kind of uh short vignettes of these things that aren't even really that funny.

[57:12] Doug Walker: And I don't know. I I wasn't I wasn't really sucked into it at all. Um I I didn't get nothing out of it, because I think that there are a couple jokes and songs that were. Um and it is short, which being short is a big plus.

[57:27] Andrew DeWolf: Um so there is that. Still, I don't think I can recommend it really. Um though I will give it a cheese rating of a uh grilled cheese made in a uh Snoopy and Woodstock grilled cheesemaker, which uh I assume puts a little pattern on it, I hope. Either that or it just has uh it just is a grilled cheesemaker that has Snoopy and Woodstock on it.

[57:49] Doug Walker: Yeah, I I yeah, I don't think that would work at all. Um all right, Big B, how about you?

[57:53] Big Beak Entertainment: Um, I'm not really much of a musical guy. I did look up the reviews for this. Um, there was this one review by this guy named Ben Brantley.

[58:00] Andrew DeWolf: No, don't you dare! We avoided this.

[58:02] Big Beak Entertainment: I think that he was right on the money. Uh, very perceptive individual. He said basically, like, this should really not be on Broadway. They like did not know how to make this a big production.

[58:12] Doug Walker: There's this one scene where Linus is like dancing with his blanket, and it's like the blanket's like on one wire. Uh it's very clear that like this was not like a Jim Henson production. Um, and it just they they really did not know what to do.

[58:27] Andrew DeWolf: I think that that was the biggest problem is like they had this this big albatross around their neck, which is the original album that we have to write around, and then they just didn't.

[58:37] Big Beak Entertainment: Um, so I I really wouldn't even hesitate to call this a musical. I'd probably call it a review first. I I think that you guys might disagree with me on that, but um, I would give this a cheese rating of uh peanut cheese, which is what the well, because it's what the Dutch call peanut butter, so it's a lie.

[58:57] Andrew DeWolf: Exactly like calling this a musical.

[58:59] Big Beak Entertainment: I actually kind of agree with the idea that this isn't really a musical. Um I I feel like I might call it like a song cycle or something like that.

[59:06] Doug Walker: Yeah.

[59:06] Big Beak Entertainment: Uh I don't know enough vocabulary to be as smart about it as you guys. So I'll do it. It doesn't have the musical structure in any real way.

[59:14] Andrew DeWolf: No.

[59:14] Big Beak Entertainment: So it's closer to something like Godspell than it is to something like, I don't know, Book of Mormon. Which a lot of people would just kind of vaguely put that in the category of musical anyways, but if we're talking like more specifically, structure-wise, I I feel like this doesn't really fit.

[59:30] Jesse McAnally: On that note, Big Beak, you do incredible things on the internet. Promote them for the world to see and find.

[59:36] Big Beak Entertainment: Um, oh yeah. Uh you can uh subscribe to my you know YouTube channel, um YouTube.com slash at channel awesome.

[59:46] Andrew DeWolf: Uh no, don't do that.

[59:52] Big Beak Entertainment: Don't do that. Um Joker. Yeah, whatever else I've made, you know, obviously it's all good. That's a classic. Demo reel. That classic.

[1:00:04] Andrew DeWolf: No, but subscribe to you know youtube.com slash at bigbeekentertainment. Um if you want to see basically whatever I feel like uploading, whenever I feel like uploading it.

[1:00:12] Big Beak Entertainment: Uh I don't I don't usually do you know peanut stuff, but I will do another one at some point. Uh, because you guys keep asking me for it, um, but probably not before like Starfield comes out or something.

[1:00:24] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know. I don't know how to preface this entire thing. You'll never get more Charlie Brown shit. Stop asking for it.

[1:00:30] Jesse McAnally: Thank you guys for listening. Please follow us on iTunes, Spotify, Stitcher Musicals for Cheese. Leave us a review on iTunes. Tell us how wrong we are and how this is the best musical ever.

[1:00:39] Andrew DeWolf: Follow us on Twitter at Cheesy Musicals or on Patreon and Musicals with Cheese, Instagram Musical Cheese, YouTube page musicals of cheese.

[1:00:44] Jesse McAnally: Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com with your manifesto about how uh your good man Charlie Brown is actually better than the Phantom of the Opera. And I don't even know if I disagree with that.

[1:00:52] Andrew DeWolf: Our keeper of the cheese is Juliet Antonio. You're fucking great, Julia. Don't you forget that.

[1:00:59] Jesse McAnally: This show is edited by Andrew DeWolf, and he's doing a fucking fantastic job. Thank you to the Broadway Podcast Network for having us on the platform and for not kicking us off for inviting Doug Walker onto our show.

[1:01:16] Doug Walker: And way up there, the little stars and planets, they make the rain that often showers.

[1:01:22] Andrew DeWolf: And when it's cold and winter is upon us, the snow comes up, just like the flowers.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred