Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#241 - Catch Me If You Can

"Yes I'm live in living color Life ain't lived in black and white..." Get your money and fake checks together because we're breaking the law and talking about "Catch me if You Can" the Musical! Hosts: Jesse McAnally & Andrew DeWolf. Podcast Edited By: Andrew DeWolf... Read More

From the show: Musicals with Cheese

47 mins
4/20/23

About

"Yes I'm live in living color Life ain't lived in black and white..." Get your money and fake checks together because we're breaking the law and talking about "Catch me if You Can" the Musical!


Credits:

Hosts: Jesse McAnally & Andrew DeWolf

Podcast Edited By: Andrew DeWolf

Theme Songs: Robyn Nash of IOU Music UK

Keeper of the Cheese: Juliet Antonio

This show is a part of the Broadway Podcast Network

Social Media:

Our WEBSITE

Musicals with Cheese on Twitter

Musicals W/ Cheese on Instagram

Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com

Merch!!

Jess Socials

Jesse McAnally on Twitter

Jess McAnally on Instagram

Andrew Socials

Andrew DeWolf on Instagram

Andrew DeWolf on Twitter

Use our Affiliate Link

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:05] Jesse McAnally: Hello, I'm Jesse McAnally.

[0:07] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm Andrew DeWolf.

[0:09] Liz Eston: And I'm Liz Eston.

[0:11] Liz Eston: Hey!

[0:12] Jesse McAnally: Hey, she's back!

[0:13] Jesse McAnally: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, the podcast where I try to get Andrew to like musical theater.

[0:17] Jesse McAnally: And today we have Liz Eston joining back, Triumph and Return.

[0:21] Liz Eston: Oh thank you.

[0:23] Liz Eston: Thank you.

[0:24] Liz Eston: I'm back.

[0:25] Andrew DeWolf: You're back in guest terms.

[0:27] Jesse McAnally: You literally, much like Robbie Rosel, who did not know he was gonna be in an episode until like 12 hours before we did an episode.

[0:35] Jesse McAnally: Liz did not know she was gonna be in an episode until she got the link for the episode and just showed up.

[0:41] Andrew DeWolf: The moral of the story is Jess is an asshole and don't click any links he sends you.

[0:45] Andrew DeWolf: Jess sends you a stream yard, anticipate being in a podcast, not having an impromptu meeting about something else.

[0:53] Jesse McAnally: And speaking of that, this is a Patreon request by a brand new patron that I don't know the name of yet, so I'm gonna go check the Discord messages real quick.

[1:03] Andrew DeWolf: Puffy boy.

[1:04] Andrew DeWolf: Come on, Puppy Boy.

[1:05] Jesse McAnally: It is Teapot.

[1:07] Jesse McAnally: Um, whoever that is in our Patreon.

[1:09] Jesse McAnally: With uh your Discord username Teapot.

[1:12] Jesse McAnally: Oh no, it is what did Boris say is their Patreon name.

[1:15] Andrew DeWolf: Which one is it?

[1:16] Jesse McAnally: What did Boris say?

[1:19] Andrew DeWolf: What did Boris say is their patron name?

[1:22] Jesse McAnally: Okay.

[1:23] Jesse McAnally: But that being said, Andrew, I've had a real rough time and I need some advice.

[1:28] Andrew DeWolf: Really?

[1:28] Andrew DeWolf: What what's going wrong?

[1:29] Jesse McAnally: Um, I have bounced so many checks, and I think the government might.

[1:35] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, I've just bounced them, and you know what? I've also lied to so many people.

[1:40] Jesse McAnally: I lied about being a pilot, and they just let me be a pilot.

[1:44] Jesse McAnally: I lied about, you know, being a doctor, a lawyer, all of these things.

[1:49] Jesse McAnally: I lied about being an FBI agent, and I think eventually all these crimes that I'm committing might catch up with me.

[1:57] Andrew DeWolf: I doubt that.

[1:58] Andrew DeWolf: I doubt that, yeah.

[2:00] Andrew DeWolf: It's not gonna catch up with you because like you're not gonna like fall in love or something like that.

[2:06] Jesse McAnally: I would never do that.

[2:07] Jesse McAnally: Never.

[2:08] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[2:08] Jesse McAnally: Oh no, I've fallen in love.

[2:10] Andrew DeWolf: What do I you literally just said you weren't gonna do that?

[2:13] Jesse McAnally: That's the thing that's gonna get it in my life.

[2:17] Jesse McAnally: That's the one thing that I'll get your car.

[2:19] Jesse McAnally: Andrew, I gotta meet your parents and tell them who I am.

[2:23] Jesse McAnally: Cause I'm in love.

[2:24] Andrew DeWolf: Well, I'm sorry, you're going to jail.

[2:26] Jesse McAnally: But I'm not.

[2:29] Andrew DeWolf: Cause you're gonna work for the FBI.

[2:32] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[2:33] Andrew DeWolf: Twist ending.

[2:34] Jesse McAnally: I lied about everything I did, and none of it's true.

[2:37] ⚠ About 4 minutes of audio could not be automatically transcribed.

[6:11] Andrew DeWolf: The Mario's and the Luigi's.

[6:13] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, so you separate the Mario's and the Luigi's.

[6:16] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, the Mario's and Luigi's.

[6:17] Jesse McAnally: So the Mamas and the Mias.

[6:21] Andrew DeWolf: So I was in an assembly and everyone else was watching um Invictus, and then the other group was in an assembly, and we watched October Sky.

[6:29] Jesse McAnally: Uh, they did not even bother to justify either of these, but the two the two genders.

[6:33] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, the two genders are October Sky and Invictus.

[6:37] Jesse McAnally: Yes.

[6:37] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.

[6:38] Jesse McAnally: I identify as Invictus.

[6:40] Andrew DeWolf: I identify as October Sky because young Jake Gyllenhaal only.

[6:45] Jesse McAnally: But yeah. When did you watch this then?

[6:46] Andrew DeWolf: I in some class. I don't know. Uh I had some teachers who made weird decisions. Uh, we once watched the Father Aldrinon movie for no reason, and we never discussed it again.

[6:56] Jesse McAnally: But what'd you think of the movie?

[6:58] Andrew DeWolf: Uh anyway, yeah, back on track. I like the movie.

[7:00] Jesse McAnally: I don't I'm not really a Spielberg gal.

[7:03] Andrew DeWolf: Um, mostly because I'm not a film bro, and I don't understand the appeal of Spielberg's.

[7:08] Jesse McAnally: You don't you didn't like the Fablemans?

[7:10] Andrew DeWolf: I didn't see the Fablemans.

[7:12] Jesse McAnally: You didn't like West Side Story 2021?

[7:15] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, of course I did. It has Aaron Tveit in it.

[7:18] Jesse McAnally: Okay, West Side Story 2021 was actually pretty good. That is a fantastic movie.

[7:22] Andrew DeWolf: Uh some of his other stuff, I don't know, maybe I find it.

[7:24] Jesse McAnally: You didn't like the BFG or Bridge of Spies or The Post or AI or Minority Report?

[7:30] Andrew DeWolf: I loved the Big Friendly Giant. That was my favorite fucking movie.

[7:35] Jesse McAnally: It stars Steven Seagal.

[7:37] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and it costs three dollars. I'd watch that. I'd watch Big Friendly Giant starring Steven Seagal.

[7:44] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, I liked it uh only because it felt more like a movie that felt super accessible. It's not like a I'm a filmmaker and I'm passionate about what I do or whatever, or a World War II movie, which I just skip. Bridge of Spies looked really boring to me.

[7:57] Andrew DeWolf: So he's gonna be able to do it.

[7:59] Jesse McAnally: Bridge of Spies is a good movie.

[8:01] Andrew DeWolf: I skipped it. Like until West Side Story, I was calling it Steven Spielberg's last good movie.

[8:06] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. Amazing.

[8:07] Andrew DeWolf: And then the Fablemans.

[8:08] Jesse McAnally: And then the Fablemans.

[8:09] Andrew DeWolf: Fablemans is good.

[8:12] Jesse McAnally: I was disappointed by it.

[8:14] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[8:14] Jesse McAnally: Oh.

[8:15] Andrew DeWolf: But I will not.

[8:18] Jesse McAnally: It's a weird movie.

[8:19] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, I I tweeted about this. Uh it's when do I ever get to talk about Spielberg in a way? We don't have much to say about this musical. Sorry. I'm gonna talk about Spielberg for a second.

[8:29] Jesse McAnally: The Fablemans is the plot of the first half is about the plot of his divorce. The second half is him in high school, and he has this bully, and his emotional catharsis is that he is so good at filmmaking, he makes his bully look so good on film, and the bully like, why'd you make me look so good and so hot on film? He's like, I just thought you'd look good from that angle. And we're supposed to think, oh no, he has this romance with filmmaking. And I'm just like, did you want to fuck your bully? You know, Sigmund Freud once said.

[9:00] Andrew DeWolf: Fucking the bully, the bully was an anti-Semite. He's a real piece of shit. There's a lot of other stuff going on. But it reads real weird when you see him film this, and you got this naked guy in the beach being shot as in races and volleyball games, and I'm like, did you did you want to fuck that bully?

[9:18] Jesse McAnally: Well, so that's the Fablemans, but but Catch Me If You Can is a very effective dad movie.

[9:25] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.

[9:26] Jesse McAnally: I think it is the perfect description of a dad movie. You got Tom Hanks as the person chasing Leo DiCaprio.

[9:33] Andrew DeWolf: You said Tom Hanks.

[9:34] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[9:34] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[9:35] Jesse McAnally: Um it is very well made. The father is played by Christopher Walken, who famously got an Oscar nomination and a Razzie nomination this year.

[9:46] Andrew DeWolf: Oscar nomination for Catch Me If You Can, and he is very good in this movie.

[9:50] Jesse McAnally: He is very charming. He says some of his most iconic Christopher Walkenisms in it.

[9:55] Andrew DeWolf: Two little mice fell in a bucket of cream.

[9:59] Jesse McAnally: The first mouse quickly gave up and drowned.

[10:04] Andrew DeWolf: The second mouse wouldn't quit. He struggled so hard that eventually he turned that cream into butter and crawled out.

[10:15] Jesse McAnally: Gentlemen, as of this moment, I am that second mouse.

[10:21] Andrew DeWolf: But he was also in The Country Bears.

[10:24] Jesse McAnally: Oh, I love The Country Bears.

[10:27] Andrew DeWolf: Um, where he But Country Bears is one of the movies that's funny to just bring it up. It's just like, hey, remember The Country Bears.

[10:31] Jesse McAnally: Have you watched it though? Have you properly sat down and watched it?

[10:35] Andrew DeWolf: Maybe that's a commentary idea.

[10:38] Jesse McAnally: Of course. I've seen it like three times, I think. It is horrendously unwatchable.

[10:44] Andrew DeWolf: And it feels like it'll never end. It is one of those films that just keeps going, and you think you're getting to an ending, and you're not.

[10:51] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, then you get to the fast feud musical number, and you're like, oh god, why is this happening now? I'm only in it for the honey.

[11:11] Andrew DeWolf: Please! Why why would you make a movie about The Country Bear Jamboree, which is an attraction at Disneyland and Disney World that has nothing, like nothing's going on. You just sit down and you watch the bears and they sing.

[11:25] Jesse McAnally: The fucking Goofy Movie made fun of The Country Bears.

[11:29] Andrew DeWolf: Like, for real.

[11:30] Jesse McAnally: You are completely correct. And I says it says a lot about um post-Catzenberg Eisner solely run Disney, where it's just like anything that might get the boomers to see a movie.

[11:42] Jesse McAnally: Okay, catch me if you can.

[11:44] Jesse McAnally: Yes. As we were told by Robbie Rosell, when it was originally developed in its workshops with Annaleigh Ashford, Nathan Lane, and Matthew Morrison, it was supposed to be like a big pastiche on variety shows.

[11:57] Jesse McAnally: Which at least that's a clever idea because it takes place in the time of variety shows. And using that kind of background to get through crimes, at least then it wouldn't be a one-to-one recreation of the movie, the way that the final version is.

[12:11] Jesse McAnally: Where you still see like everything is told through pastiches of reality shows, but they're doing a there's no connective tissue between that and the narrative. It just is the style they're doing, and I don't get it.

[12:22] Jesse McAnally: I don't get what they're doing with this musical. I don't think it's incompetent. I know the songs are catchy, I know Mark Shaman is one of the most talented composers out there.

[12:32] Jesse McAnally: I hear some like it hot, it is good. I don't know, I haven't dove into that one yet. But this didn't work for me in any way because if I wanted to watch the movie told by literally one of the best directors of our time, I would.

[12:45] Jesse McAnally: And you brought this up to me off the mic, Andrew, where this entire story is plot driven. There is not very much emotionally driven by this character except his relationship with his dad, which they surprisingly don't lean into very much.

[12:59] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, so this is um, and I haven't seen the movie, so I can't speak to what the movie is, but it reminded me when I was watching it of what we talked about with um with Sister Act, um, and why Sister Act worked a little bit better than Back to the Future.

[13:15] Andrew DeWolf: And I think I said something like Back to the Future is too plot-driven. There's not enough emotional moments um where a song will naturally kind of flow out, but this kind of feels like the same thing where it's like there's not a ton of emotional moments.

[13:32] Andrew DeWolf: There are some in this, but there's not like a lot, and most of those moments don't drive the plot forward in any way. So it doesn't really work for a musical in that way.

[13:44] Jesse McAnally: No. There are parts that I think I like. I like Hanratty's song about like, don't do the crime, crime is bad. Like, I like that song.

[13:54] Jesse McAnally: The Hanratty character is I think more of the story should have followed that character, honestly, because they seemed like they're fun, more interesting.

[14:02] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, they were more fun. So I grew up 2011. I was on the YouTubes, I was involved in the musical theater internet community more often than not at all.

[14:12] Andrew DeWolf: And I heard a lot of people talk favorably about that. And I have this weird connection with Newsies that people keep bothering me, because it's never you, it's always me, about why we haven't covered Newsies.

[14:23] Andrew DeWolf: And that's because I don't like Newsies. And I feel like this is a similar situation where people confuse liking a show with finding the lead very hot.

[14:33] Jesse McAnally: Now, this show starred Aaron Tveit, who is Liz is doing a comedic reaction here, who is very good looking.

[14:43] Andrew DeWolf: Very good looking. Almost comically attractive. He feels like a cartoon character of a man.

[14:49] Jesse McAnally: He's too attractive. Someone is hot in the show, and then people are like, I love the show. That's what you're saying.

[14:56] Andrew DeWolf: And I think that's the same thing that happened with Newsies, where I don't see what everyone sees in Newsies. I don't get that show.

[15:04] Andrew DeWolf: I don't get the appeal of Newsies, to be honest. I thought Newsies was just like a fun like 1930s kind of thing where it's like everyone talks like they're from the 30s.

[15:16] Jesse McAnally: 1910s, but yeah.

[15:17] Andrew DeWolf: 1910s, whatever. I thought that was part of the charm of it. But no, they're about these underage kids selling newspapers, but they're all very hot, attractive 20-year-olds doing funny, funny goofy dances for 45 minutes, and I'm looking at my watch every 10.

[15:34] Jesse McAnally: We have to cover Newsies.

[15:36] Andrew DeWolf: We do, but I don't want to be just like you're wrong. So I want to get someone who actually really, really likes Newsies so we can properly talk about it.

[15:43] Andrew DeWolf: I don't like the movie Newsies, I don't like the stage show Newsies. And I think a lot of the only reason why the Newsies became what it became is because people thirsted over the actors in it, Jeremy Jordan and the entire cast.

[15:56] Jesse McAnally: So you think that the reason Catch Me If You Can did but didn't it do poorly though?

[16:01] Andrew DeWolf: It did poorly, but I think it garnered a cult following on the internet because of the Aaron Tveit of it all.

[16:06] Jesse McAnally: Oh.

[16:07] Andrew DeWolf: So this is popular in some sort of niche crowd.

[16:11] Andrew DeWolf: It's in the niche crowds, this is like, oh, this is such an underrated classic, da-da-da. And then I'm just like, I think y'all are just thirsty.

[16:17] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, I'm not sure I see this as a classic in any way.

[16:22] Andrew DeWolf: No. This doesn't have it doesn't have any staying power, I don't think.

[16:27] Jesse McAnally: No, and this came out the same year as Book of Mormon, which kind of it stole that Tony year.

[16:33] Andrew DeWolf: Now, Book of Mormon has an age great, but it did have staying power. It was a juggernaut and still runs to this day.

[16:41] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, so Catch Me If You Can the movie. I want to ask about I want to ask about it a little bit since I haven't seen it.

[16:48] Andrew DeWolf: I have watched it recently, in fact.

[16:50] Jesse McAnally: Is there more like focus on the scamming element?

[16:55] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. There's a lot of montages specifically about the scamming and how he did it.

[16:59] Andrew DeWolf: I felt like there was a severe lack of scamming going on in this the show. The brilliance of the movie, because you know Spielberg, he's a very methodical filmmaker, and he shoots every scam like it's an action scene.

[17:13] Andrew DeWolf: It is a reveal where you he gets told a piece of information, and then you see how he implements that into his next scam. He's like, oh, this needs a seal.

[17:23] Andrew DeWolf: So he buys a bunch of toy airplanes and like puts them in a bathtub, then peels off the seal to put onto his checks to make them look official.

[17:30] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, see, that's the that's the kind of thing that that the stage show feels like it's missing. It feels like this is a it's like a show about scammers, about a scammer.

[17:39] Jesse McAnally: But all we we just hear about like, oh well, he bounced a bunch of checks, or like he has a bunch of fake checks and he uses that to make a bunch of money somehow. And I feel like we don't see it.

[17:50] Andrew DeWolf: I want to see it, you know?

[17:52] Jesse McAnally: It is a very like here's the method way of storytelling. The only thing that like it has an interesting take.

[18:01] Jesse McAnally: The opening scene where he asked permission of Hanratty to put on a performance for the audience explaining how he got there. That's interesting at the very least.

[18:11] Jesse McAnally: Like, I'm like, that is something I don't think I've seen like this and didn't expect from this, but then they kind of never really do anything that kind of cool again, and they just follow the beats of the movie almost so much that I'm surprised Terrence McNally got writing credit because it just feels like Mr. Nathan's script from the movie.

[18:27] Andrew DeWolf: They should have had more times where like he would come back out and narrate again.

[18:35] Jesse McAnally: Well, he's narrating throughout the entire thing.

[18:37] Andrew DeWolf: He does it a lot. It's just it's just to get us to the next plot point.

[18:41] Jesse McAnally: I guess maybe it needed to be like him and Hanratty should have come out and like commented on what was actually happening.

[18:47] Andrew DeWolf: Maybe and we should have had some back and forth, like maybe something where it's like that's not how it happened, or or like I don't even know.

[18:54] Jesse McAnally: Well, we do get that the movie is very good about giving you what you want because they cut back and forth from his kidnapping, like well, not kidnapping, his arrest, to him being brought back to America, and we get them getting back and forth and questions that he asks takes us back in time to learn about Leo DiCaprio's story.

[19:12] Jesse McAnally: So we get their back and forth throughout the movie. It's not something that they ask you to wait for the way that the musical kind of does.

[19:19] Andrew DeWolf: There's a lot of stuff that I feel like is missed opportunities in this. And I mean I wanted to love this show.

[19:26] Jesse McAnally: Like straight up.

[19:28] Andrew DeWolf: Because I love scammers.

[19:28] Jesse McAnally: Because I fucking love scam artists.

[19:31] Andrew DeWolf: I think that they're so cool.

[19:33] Jesse McAnally: Um, but what?

[19:38] Andrew DeWolf: That you love scammers.

[19:40] Jesse McAnally: No, I think that scamming people is actually really sick.

[19:43] Andrew DeWolf: Um I wanted more focus on the scam artist element.

[19:51] Jesse McAnally: And I feel like the movie probably has what I'm looking for.

[19:53] Andrew DeWolf: Really?

[19:54] Jesse McAnally: The show doesn't.

[19:55] Andrew DeWolf: The show just doesn't.

[19:57] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, the fake check writing montages in the movie are like impeccable.

[20:01] Andrew DeWolf: It's the most Spielberg-Spielberg shit.

[20:03] Jesse McAnally: Like the stage show, all you're getting is like songs about uh the how sexy all the ladies are.

[20:11] Andrew DeWolf: And there's kick lines of nurses and kick lines of stewardesses.

[20:15] Jesse McAnally: They literally do both.

[20:16] Andrew DeWolf: They have to do both because they're both somebody's fetish.

[20:19] Jesse McAnally: Well, nurses and stewardesses are a lot of people's fetish, let's be real.

[20:23] Andrew DeWolf: But we should talk about how within the last couple of weeks, Frank Abagnale Jr. has been revealed that most of the crimes he committed were actually lies.

[20:33] Jesse McAnally: Most of most of his scams turned out to be false.

[20:37] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, I have an opinion on this, and I think I told you, but I think that this makes it better.

[20:42] Jesse McAnally: Okay.

[20:43] Andrew DeWolf: This improves the whole thing. Because now he tricked so okay.

[20:47] Andrew DeWolf: Let's just quickly. The story is he's he signs a bunch of fake checks or something, he gets followed by the FBI, he fakes being a pilot, he fakes being a lawyer, he fakes being a doctor, and then he gets caught, and then he works for the FBI because he was so good at being a scam artist.

[21:04] Jesse McAnally: No one else could compare to him.

[21:06] Andrew DeWolf: He's the only one that can tell if checks were that's the story.

[21:08] Andrew DeWolf: Like, that's the story, that's what happens. He has a love interest, but like okay, but in real life, he basically just he just did the checks in the pilot thing, and that's it.

[21:17] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[21:18] Andrew DeWolf: That's it. Every everything else is fake, including the big thing at the end where he works for the FBI.

[21:24] Jesse McAnally: All of it.

[21:24] Andrew DeWolf: All that is fake.

[21:25] Jesse McAnally: My take is we all got scammed.

[21:27] Andrew DeWolf: He's he scammed everybody.

[21:29] Jesse McAnally: He pulled it off.

[21:30] Andrew DeWolf: He tricked all of us.

[21:32] Jesse McAnally: He tricked Steven Spielberg into writing a legend.

[21:35] Andrew DeWolf: He literally yes.

[21:39] Jesse McAnally: He was the ultimate tale of Liberty Valence.

[21:41] Andrew DeWolf: He's like, if the story is better the legend's better than the truth, then print the legend.

[21:45] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[21:46] Andrew DeWolf: So honestly, I it is all fake and reality does matter, but also what a fucking legend.

[21:53] Jesse McAnally: What a dude.

[21:56] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it's fascinating that I mean there's both a musical and a movie. Like recently, Frank Abagnale showed up to a high school that was putting on a performance of Catch Me If You Can the musical, and he's like, I did all this when I was like 16 to 20.

[22:09] Jesse McAnally: I shouldn't be branded for life, which is kind of wild.

[22:12] Andrew DeWolf: It was like five years of his early youth when he was just doing this shit.

[22:16] Jesse McAnally: Also, though, you shouldn't be branded for life.

[22:19] Andrew DeWolf: Like scamming people out of millions, I'm surprised he got off so easily.

[22:24] Jesse McAnally: I do want to say the movie has like one of the most stacked casts ever of people before they were famous.

[22:30] Andrew DeWolf: You got Amy Adams, like you got Christopher Walken, Tom Hanks, Martin Sheen.

[22:35] Jesse McAnally: Um, but then in like small, small worlds, you've got like you've got Ellen Pompeo, Elizabeth Banks, Jennifer Garner, like in these tiny blink and you'll miss it cameos.

[22:47] Andrew DeWolf: That movie is so wild to watch.

[22:49] Jesse McAnally: I mean, they were in a Spielberg movie.

[22:52] Andrew DeWolf: You you get famous from that.

[22:53] Jesse McAnally: You know who definitely had opinions on this?

[22:56] Andrew DeWolf: Ben Brantley.

[22:57] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, let's what does Ben Brantley have to say?

[22:59] Andrew DeWolf: So Ben Brantley reviewed this when it first came out, and remember, context, Book of Mormon is taking the scene.

[23:06] Jesse McAnally: It is a weird time for Broadway.

[23:08] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and this is Mark Shaman and Scott Whitman's follow-up to Hairspray, one of the most beloved musicals ever put on Broadway, and still to this day.

[23:16] Jesse McAnally: It's got issues, hasn't aged perfectly, but it's still like it is illegal in Tennessee now, but yeah, it is.

[23:17] ⚠ About 7 minutes of audio could not be automatically transcribed.

[29:53] Andrew DeWolf: A couple people have done that, like Mina Maniri, Sammy the Mos Lopez, Joseph Evans Green. You could do that as well. You could hang out with us and you know play video games with us. We do that every month, month or so. Um I'm making a movie right now, so it's gonna be a little less consistent. But after June, it'll be pretty consistent. Who's currently supporting us, Andrew?

[30:10] Jesse McAnally: Our current patrons are. I'll make a beat. Okay. Melissa Goldman, Daniel Renx, just Stampede, Io Cassie, Monica Roa, Brent Blag, Joseph's Green, Marilou Choquette, John Vanels, Russ Walker, Musical Hell, Emily Gracie, Kyle Summers, Janay C, Screw the Technical Dreamcoat, Liz Lim, nothing is served except Better Tesses, Thespian, Ren Cullen, Rafael Martina Celeste, Jessica T, Michelle Young, JT Cup, Katie McDonough, Chris Marcote, Kiji Berea, Nastasio Lila, RJ Noriga, Charlie B, Bjorn Hermans, Toriana Fraser, Sammy the Most Lopez, Leana Morton, Kylie Blazier, Cinnamageddon Reviews, Villainous Myth, Sophina L.

[30:49] Andrew DeWolf: The Omega Geek, Paige Pearson, Maddie Wargle, Eliza Erdman, Anna Luscatova, Shesk, Jessica Varay, oh my goodness. Messing up some of these names. Sarah Den Blaker, Evan Ball, Zachary Therese, Gathering Party before venturing forth, Rora Morasso, Mara Forloin, Captain Rod Tastic, Lisa L, Sarah Walsh, Nobody. What did Boris say?

[31:12] Jesse McAnally: Puffy Boy and Summer. Come join them at our Patreon! You can help us keep Andrew getting paid and make some more videos. Like we want to make more videos coming up. Um with Liz. Liz is so good at making the video. Let's get back to the show.

[31:33] Andrew DeWolf: Live in Living Color, which is I guess trying to set up like the hey TV. They try to set up the hey TV a lot. Living color. And it's brought to you by me. Yes, I'm not living colorful TV. What's so lame? Justin Window dressing. Everybody knows that it's the clothes that make the noise. Hey the game. Just keep them guessing. Try to catch me if you can.

[32:15] Andrew DeWolf: They get a new TV, and he's like, whoa, I love watching TV. They really do try to kind of tie it in, but not enough. It's I it I think, and again, we couldn't find any real info on this, but I'm pretty sure this is just a remnant from when this was gonna be a variety show. Um that being said, the song is fine. Like it's the song is fine. It's just it's weird that it doesn't tie in to the like actual themes of the show. It's tying into a premise that isn't there anymore.

[32:48] Jesse McAnally: It's obvious that they just tried to back ass backwards their way into a th a thematic idea that isn't there anymore.

[32:56] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. I don't this musical is confused. Like, I wonder if I'd actually like the variety show version of this. I don't know if I would. Like we will never know because it's probably never going to exist. That's a bad thing about musicals. Like movies eventually leak. Like those eventually do happen. If a stage musical has an alternate version, we'll never know about it. No, unless you were there.

[33:19] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. Um, I like the song. It's cute.

[33:22] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. I like Living in Living Color. Aaron Tivate's hot.

[33:26] Jesse McAnally: At least you admit it. I like that. Yes, let's let's talk about a song I know you like, okay?

[33:30] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, let's go. Don't break the rules. This is the game main world for women if you'll break it out the rules. Oh, else we're living in the wild, wild west. Don't bring the rules. That's keeping scar. You don't want to fail that test. Don't break the rules. You thumb your nose right up the iPhone, which I strive. But those rules keep us alive.

[33:55] Jesse McAnally: I love this song because you rarely see a guy that moves that way on Broadway. Where it's like, it's not a graceful dance at all. It's like this jig. This unpleasant jig that everyone's doing, and I love it. Like this. It works. This moment really works. When I saw it at the Tony's, I'm like, I want to see that show. Like, no one moves the way this guy moves. It is so wild looking. Like, it's not like your average kind of dance break number. I appreciate that about it. It is engaging, strange, and novel.

[34:29] Andrew DeWolf: It fits the character too.

[34:31] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. It is the one part about this that doesn't feel by numbers.

[34:35] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, because this character is supposed to be. So so again, we're a podcast for context. He dances like someone who doesn't know how to dance.

[34:43] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[34:44] Andrew DeWolf: He dances the way I imagine Tom Hanks would at your wedding.

[34:47] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, like he dances like your dad.

[34:50] Andrew DeWolf: Yes. Um, who doesn't know how to dance? Um, and it's it's interesting because you don't generally see that in a character on Broadway.

[34:59] Jesse McAnally: It's also it's the thing is it's he dances like someone who doesn't know how to dance, but they're actually dancing.

[35:07] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[35:07] Jesse McAnally: So they're like, they turn these like not dance moves into actual dance moves, and it's it's interesting.

[35:14] Andrew DeWolf: It's the one time the show comes alive.

[35:17] Jesse McAnally: Like sincerely.

[35:18] Andrew DeWolf: Like, where it doesn't feel like it's trying to get you to like you, and you just actually like what's happening.

[35:24] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[35:25] Andrew DeWolf: And honestly, I feel that way about this character. I think that this character brings the show together. Like, and it's the only reason that I don't think this show is terrible, is this character is fun to watch. And I think that since this character was also like a fictional amalgamation character and as well in the movie, I think they have a lot more freedom to do whatever they want with it, because they don't need to get input from anyone else. They don't have to like. Is this how the actual person acted? Like who cares? Because it's not really. And that's what I that's why I feel like this this guy works. Um everything about him works. In a way that when you cut to Tom Hanks in the movie, I'm kind of bored because it's not it's not the scamming fun stuff that we're doing.

It's the you know, the boring dad stuff about like, oh, the scars uh got the MCR codes cut off, and he knows what we're doing wrong. And go fuck yourself. This character's very fun. That is the one moment in this show I really like.

[36:23] Jesse McAnally: Um I do like m my favorite time of year. That is a fun little ending to act one.

[36:28] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, don't you love the yellow time fun.

[36:32] Jesse McAnally: There's joy and cheer for everyone.

[36:36] Andrew DeWolf: I wait for Santa with a gun.

[36:41] Jesse McAnally: Yes, Christmas is my favorite time of yeah.

[36:50] Andrew DeWolf: Some sugar plums I haven't kissed.

[36:54] Jesse McAnally: But mistletoe, I must resist.

[36:58] Andrew DeWolf: Cause I'm on Saint Carl's most wanted list.

[37:03] Jesse McAnally: Yes, Christmas is my favorite time of me.

[37:11] Andrew DeWolf: Where like they they finally meet, quote unquote. It is a narratively, it suits to be a cliffhanger. But aside from that, the show don't offer me much. Literally, I felt nothing.

[37:22] Jesse McAnally: Anything, anything that you connected to.

[37:27] Andrew DeWolf: I kind of thought that the payoff to like the love story was okay.

[37:34] Jesse McAnally: So fly fly away, I fly away song, I think.

[37:38] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, you gotta give your female lead a song.

[37:41] Jesse McAnally: No need to tell me why my baby.

[37:44] Andrew DeWolf: Maybe it's because you'll fly back home to me one day.

[37:55] Jesse McAnally: We give a look out.

[38:28] Andrew DeWolf: You'll need to tell me why my baby. Maybe it's because you'll fly back home to me one day.

[38:38] Jesse McAnally: And I think she actually did a really good job with it. I think that this it's not like a super interesting song, but I I didn't hate it, and I I I feel like it was a decent payoff to this plot line.

[38:50] Andrew DeWolf: I want to make sure I'm the character Brenda in the musical is also in the movie. She's played by Amy Adams, and she is at no point conspiratorial with uh Frank. She it's and she um almost immediately rats him out. Like there is so consideration. She's like, as soon as she found out shit's up, she rats him out immediately.

[39:16] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, I feel like it's more interesting the way they did it here, but maybe in the movie it's probably fine because there's just other stuff going on. Whereas here, you kind of need this because there's nothing else happening. That is the closest thing to an emotional beat, and it's the one that they made up for the movie or for the stage show. They made up a lot for the movie, but Yeah I mean, they probably made up a I mean he did the movie make it up, or did he make it up? There's the question.

[39:44] Andrew DeWolf: Eh, I don't know anymore.

[39:46] Jesse McAnally: I don't know. He said in like 2001, like I've never spoken to Steven Spielberg and I've never read this script. I don't want to. Fine. But he does like the musical. He does strangely show up to productions of the musical. He showed up to opening night. The musical is puts him in a very flattering light, I think.

[40:02] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[40:03] Jesse McAnally: But doesn't the movie does too, though, right?

[40:06] Andrew DeWolf: I wouldn't say the movie puts him in a flattering light. I mean, he is played by Leo DiCaprio, but he's still kind of a stupid guy.

[40:12] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, in in this, we don't see him doing the scams so much. Um, and on top of that, he actually has like an emotional core with this love story plot. There is no emotional core to any of his love stories. He just fucks a lot.

[40:26] Andrew DeWolf: He fucks a lot in the movie.

[40:27] Jesse McAnally: He does. That's about it. So he's Leonardo DiCaprio in real life.

[40:31] Andrew DeWolf: Maybe, maybe he just likes that this puts him in a better light. Um, apparently he said the movie wasn't as accurate as it could be. Apparently, his mother never remarried and had a baby. It's one of the grapes he has with it.

[40:44] Jesse McAnally: Well, apparently the movie could have been a lot more accurate because he lied about the whole fucking thing.

[40:48] Andrew DeWolf: Exactly.

[40:49] Jesse McAnally: This is a quote from 2017. So this is before he admitted to anything. So he's very much like, this is true, but this little things are false. And then later he's like, Yeah, I made it up. My source is that I made it the fuck up.

[41:02] Andrew DeWolf: No, he never admitted to making it up. It's just other people are like, yeah, that doesn't track.

[41:06] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. I think Frank Abignale probably has a small dick and no one that loves him.

[41:10] Andrew DeWolf: Alright. Please don't sue us Frank Abignail if you aren't listening to this for some reason. What is our overall thoughts on Catch Me If You Can and Your Cheese ratings? Andrew, why don't you start?

[41:21] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, uh catch me if you can. It's fine. I I I'm not gonna seek this out to watch it ever again, and I I would be kind of surprised if this ever gets revived on Broadway or anything like that. It's made for regional theaters.

[41:34] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, like that's fine. Um it's not bad. If there's like a community theater production of it, I wouldn't be like, oh, don't see that. It's gonna that's gonna be garbage. Uh it's fine, but it's not great, you know.

[41:48] Andrew DeWolf: I I feel very similar about this as I do to like sister acts, where it's just it's just fine. It's it's just fine. Um, I'm gonna give it a cheese rating of a uh fruit and cheese platter that you would get as airline food, because that's probably a similar quality cheese to the quality of this show.

[42:10] Jesse McAnally: Can't disagree with any of that. What about you, Liz? What are your thoughts on our discussion and all that jazz?

[42:15] Liz Eston: Uh I learned that you have not much to say about this show.

[42:19] Andrew DeWolf: What are you talking about?

[42:19] Liz Eston: We talked, we were on track the entire time. We didn't talk about it ever got derailed.

[42:25] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, we never mentioned Ishtar.

[42:27] Liz Eston: Three, two, three, four, four, four. Four, two, two, three, four.

[42:35] Andrew DeWolf: It's fraudulent as my chicks.

[42:38] Liz Eston: Oh.

[42:40] Jesse McAnally: Jess will be arrested at the end of this recording.

[42:43] Liz Eston: The police are bagging down his door.

[42:46] Liz Eston: Uh no, I I learned that this show is pretty fine. Um, I re I saw a middle school version of Elf the musical back in like December-ish, and it was pretty good. It was fun. Like, so I get kind of that vibe from it. Like, I'd see it, but it would go like out of my way to see it if I wanted to. And Andrew legit stole my cheese rating. So uh I'm going to give it an airplane made of cheese, which is probably looks cool, but probably.

[43:16] Andrew DeWolf: It's probably but probably tastes very good because it's probably made of like really bad craft.

[43:21] Liz Eston: Okay, okay. Yeah. You know what? Both of those are good opinions. Um, I this show left a really rotten taste in my mouth. Like, I felt unsatisfied, and honestly, I just got shit all over my fingers, and I didn't I the overall experience was not pleasant, so I'm giving this flavin' hot cheetos.

[43:42] Andrew DeWolf: You really think it's that spicy?

[43:44] Jesse McAnally: I I think it's more regular. If anything, I would give this normal Cheetos.

[43:48] Andrew DeWolf: Like regular broadband.

[43:50] Jesse McAnally: I'm giving this stale, because you know, you put it in the bottom of the bag and it popped open, but it's not enough where the Cheetos fell out, it's just enough where they get stale, and then you get to the bottom of the flaming hot Cheetos thinking you're gonna get a spicy, like oh little hot take here. Then nah, nah. It's just it's it all fell out of the bag. It tastes like you're eating packaging peanuts.

[44:11] Andrew DeWolf: So those fake Cheetos from 30 Rock that Liz Lemon got obsessed with.

[44:15] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. These are these are the hardest musicals to talk about because there's never anything to fucking say. It's always just like, yeah, it was kind of lame. Now back to Ishtar.

[44:22] Andrew DeWolf: Now back to Ishtar.

[44:24] Liz Eston: Two, three, four.

[44:29] Jesse McAnally: Ishtar is a musical, isn't it?

[44:31] Andrew DeWolf: They they sing a lot of songs in it.

[44:33] Liz Eston: It looks kind of racist.

[44:36] Andrew DeWolf: It does.

[44:37] Jesse McAnally: Looks just a looks like a little bit racist.

[44:39] Andrew DeWolf: I don't think Ishtar is the worst film ever made. Let's be fairly clear here.

[44:43] Liz Eston: We'll learn that Jess actually didn't like the Fable Mans controversial.

[44:48] Jesse McAnally: I didn't hate it either. Like so there are moments in it that's about the Fablemans again. There are moments that really worked for me.

[44:56] Andrew DeWolf: Stop, just stop.

[44:57] Jesse McAnally: We're stopping right there. We're not going into the Fablements again. Give us the outro. Let's go. I'm hungry.

[45:06] Andrew DeWolf: We're not talking about the fucking Fable Mins again. You know who definitely didn't like the Fablemans? Probably not our patrons. I'm sure they have good taste in movies, unlike Jess. Sit them again reviews, did. But I'm talking about our patrons. Thank you guys for listening. We're on iTunes Spotify, Stitcher Musical Cheese, Twitter musicals are cheesy musicals, whatever the fuck you know. We've been here long enough. We're on Twitter. We got on Patreon. We're gonna talk about Shemigakago or whatever it's called now. Liz and I are gonna be hanging out there. Instagram, musicals or cheese, YouTube page music. Talk about that. Email us at musical theater lives at gmail.com. Tell us how wrong we are about newsies.

Um, our keeper of the cheese is Juliet Antonio. Here's something for you, gift gifty gift for you. This show is edited by Andrew DeWolf. Our theme songs were created by Robyn Nash of IOU Music UK. Thank you to the Broadway Podcast Network for having us on the platform.

[45:58] Jesse McAnally: Alright, kids. We ready to call it a night. We'll see you next time on musicals with cheese.

[46:10] ♪ Musical number: "Catch Me If You Can" — performed by Jesse McAnally & Andrew DeWolf ♪

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred