Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#242 - Phantom of the Paradise

"All my dreams are lost and I can't sleep..." Grab your bird imagery and plunger because this week Jess and Andrew are talking about Brian DePalma's incredible film "The Phantom of the Paradise" Hosts: Jesse McAnally & Andrew DeWolf. Podcast Edited By: Andrew DeWolf... Read More

From the show: Musicals with Cheese

52 mins
4/27/23

About

"All my dreams are lost and I can't sleep..." Grab your bird imagery and plunger because this week Jess and Andrew are talking about Brian DePalma's incredible film "The Phantom of the Paradise"


Credits:

Hosts: Jesse McAnally & Andrew DeWolf

Podcast Edited By: Andrew DeWolf

Theme Songs: Robyn Nash of IOU Music UK

Keeper of the Cheese: Juliet Antonio

This show is a part of the Broadway Podcast Network

Social Media:

Our WEBSITE

Musicals with Cheese on Twitter

Musicals W/ Cheese on Instagram

Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com

Merch!!

Jess Socials

Jesse McAnally on Twitter

Jess McAnally on Instagram

Andrew Socials

Andrew DeWolf on Instagram

Andrew DeWolf on Twitter

Use our Affiliate Link

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:06] Jesse McAnally: Hello, I'm Jesse McAnally.

[0:08] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm Andrew DeWolf.

[0:10] Jesse McAnally: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, the podcast where I try to get Andrew to like musical theater.

[0:15] Andrew DeWolf: And for the entire month of May and part of April, we are doing something to celebrate the closure of Cameron Mackintosh and Hal Prince's and one other guy's Phantom of the Opera on Broadway.

[0:28] Jesse McAnally: Um, and by we're doing so by covering other phantom adaptations that were not on Broadway, in fact have almost nothing to do with the Phantom of the Opera, the stage musical, except for the fact that they share a source material.

[0:43] Jesse McAnally: And to start this off, we are talking about one of the few musical versions of Phantom of the Opera that actually predates the Andrew Lloyd Webber musical, and that is Paul Williams' The Phantom of the Paradise.

[1:55] Jesse McAnally: It is a musical with songs by Paul Williams, directed by Brian De Palma and also written by Brian De Palma, based on Gaston Leroux's Phantom of the Opera.

[2:05] Jesse McAnally: It premiered October 31st, 1974, and it was a box office failure and received negative reviews while earning praise for its music, receiving an Academy Award and Golden Globe nominations.

[2:17] Jesse McAnally: However, over the years the film has received much more positive reviews and it's become a cult favorite.

[2:22] Jesse McAnally: The plot of The Phantom of the Paradise is in this rock opera hybrid of the Phantom of the Opera and Faust, fledgling singer-songwriter Winslow Leech finds himself double-crossed by the nefarious music producer Swan, who steals both his music and the lead girl, Leech wants to sing it.

[2:39] Jesse McAnally: Phoenix for the grand opening of his rock palace, the Paradise.

[2:43] Jesse McAnally: After Swan sends Leech to prison for trespassing, Leech endures a freak accident, which leaves him both disfigured and plans his revenge on both Swan and the Paradise, becoming the Phantom of the Paradise.

[2:55] Jesse McAnally: So, Andrew, I kind of threw this at you kind of raw, and what did you think?

[3:00] Andrew DeWolf: This is a fucking weird one, and I don't mean that in a bad way.

[3:04] Andrew DeWolf: It's weird in a good way.

[3:06] Andrew DeWolf: I didn't really know what to expect going into it.

[3:09] Andrew DeWolf: The only thing I think I knew about it was I had seen stills of the phantom's goofy mask where he has like a bird mask.

[3:17] Jesse McAnally: It is brilliant. There's a lot of bird imagery.

[3:21] Andrew DeWolf: What other bird imagery are you thinking of?

[3:23] Jesse McAnally: What's the first? What is Swan?

[3:23] Andrew DeWolf: Swan Phoenix?

[3:27] Jesse McAnally: That's true. We have Swan Phoenix.

[3:29] Andrew DeWolf: What is Winslow's last name?

[3:30] Jesse McAnally: Is that a leeching?

[3:32] Andrew DeWolf: Winslow Leech.

[3:33] Jesse McAnally: Okay, yeah. Yeah, there is a lot of bird imagery, isn't there?

[3:36] Andrew DeWolf: And it's like imagery, like naming schemes.

[3:39] Andrew DeWolf: Well, then the first thing we see is the dead animal or the dead bird-like image.

[3:45] Jesse McAnally: And the dead bird is the swan.

[3:48] Andrew DeWolf: It's yeah.

[3:49] Jesse McAnally: So there's a lot of bird stuff going on here.

[3:52] Andrew DeWolf: This is this is a movie where and this is like one of the best kinds of movies.

[3:57] Andrew DeWolf: It's so campy and over the top, but like you can tell that the people making it had something that they really wanted to like say and get out there.

[4:07] Andrew DeWolf: They had an idea, and it's a wild idea, and they just go with it, and you could tell there's no self-doubt in the movie, you know?

[4:18] Andrew DeWolf: Never once does anyone stop and go, this is ridiculous, this isn't good, whatever.

[4:24] Andrew DeWolf: They're just like, no, no, no, no. Just just do it.

[4:26] Andrew DeWolf: We're just gonna do it.

[4:27] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, he's gonna get his teeth taken out in prison, and he's gonna have weird metal teeth.

[4:32] Andrew DeWolf: Like, that's just gonna be a thing.

[4:33] Jesse McAnally: That's just gonna be the thing that happens.

[4:37] Andrew DeWolf: I agree.

[4:38] Andrew DeWolf: Um, what is your history with Brian De Palma?

[4:42] Jesse McAnally: Honestly, I don't know.

[4:43] Andrew DeWolf: What what else is what else has he made?

[4:45] Jesse McAnally: Like, I know he's done the original Carrie, which you're a big fan of.

[4:48] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I do like.

[4:49] Andrew DeWolf: I do like that.

[4:50] Andrew DeWolf: I'm not like a big fan, but I do I did enjoy that.

[4:53] Jesse McAnally: He did the first Mission Impossible movie.

[4:55] Andrew DeWolf: He's one of the most stylistic directors out there.

[4:59] Andrew DeWolf: I've actually never seen Mission Impossible.

[5:01] Jesse McAnally: It's good. You should watch it.

[5:03] Andrew DeWolf: But my favorite film by him is definitely Dress to Kill.

[5:06] Andrew DeWolf: It's a little transphobic, but I think it is like one of the most beautifully made mystery films I've ever seen.

[5:13] Jesse McAnally: Okay, so it's got a good catalog of stuff to hear.

[5:17] Andrew DeWolf: And this is kind of his only movie like this.

[5:19] Andrew DeWolf: Like you still see his trademarks.

[5:21] Andrew DeWolf: Like he's known for his split screens, and he's known for like weird transitions, but um, he doesn't really do camp like this very often.

[5:28] Jesse McAnally: This was kind of the or musical.

[5:31] Andrew DeWolf: I wonder if this turned him off of it.

[5:33] Jesse McAnally: I wouldn't be surprised, but it's developed a very heavy cult following in the same vein as Rocky Horror Picture Show.

[5:40] Andrew DeWolf: It's very comparable to Rocky Horror Picture Show.

[5:43] Andrew DeWolf: And honestly, I feel like this deserves a lot more credit than it gets.

[5:48] Jesse McAnally: I agree.

[5:48] Jesse McAnally: In those communities.

[5:50] Andrew DeWolf: We you have you have Rocky and you have Beef.

[5:54] Andrew DeWolf: Gentlemen, I give you the future.

[5:58] Andrew DeWolf: Beef.

[5:59] Andrew DeWolf: Beef has a Lisa character that Rocky does not.

[6:02] Jesse McAnally: Exactly.

[6:03] Andrew DeWolf: Like Beef is more interesting.

[6:05] Andrew DeWolf: I swear, the the whole like beginning of this, like probably the first half of this, everything where he's becoming like this phantom man, all of that is so just off the rails fucking crazy.

[6:18] Jesse McAnally: It's so good.

[6:21] Andrew DeWolf: Um and it doesn't really like slow down after that.

[6:25] Andrew DeWolf: It's just it like switches gears, you know?

[6:28] Andrew DeWolf: Like halfway through it switches gears into this different type of movie where it's like now he's like a slasher villain going after people.

[6:36] Andrew DeWolf: He doesn't he doesn't actually kill anybody, I don't think that I remember.

[6:39] Jesse McAnally: He tries to kill Swan.

[6:40] Andrew DeWolf: Um I guess he kinda does.

[6:42] Jesse McAnally: That's true.

[6:43] Andrew DeWolf: He kills Beef.

[6:44] Jesse McAnally: Oh, that's right, he does kill Beef.

[6:46] Andrew DeWolf: I remember the scene where he's in the shower and he doesn't kill Beef in that, but no, he like electric beef.

[6:51] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[6:51] Andrew DeWolf: And I feel like Beef does not deserve to die.

[6:54] Andrew DeWolf: Beef was just doing their best.

[6:57] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, but I mean that's a that's a Phantom of the Opera thing, isn't it?

[7:00] Andrew DeWolf: Like is that that uh woman always what's the fuck is her name?

[7:03] Jesse McAnally: Carlotta.

[7:04] Andrew DeWolf: Carlotta, yeah.

[7:05] Andrew DeWolf: She she gets she usually gets it, doesn't she?

[7:07] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[7:08] Andrew DeWolf: But this um this takes a lot less inspiration from the Gaston Leroux film and a lot more from the 1943 film with Claude Rains.

[7:19] Jesse McAnally: Christine.

[7:20] Andrew DeWolf: You're going to be a great and famous singer.

[7:23] Jesse McAnally: I'll help you.

[7:28] Andrew DeWolf: Specifically, like the in the book, the Phantom is born disfigured, whereas in the Claude Rains film, he is disfigured by acid by a rival, and he's aiming to get revenge because of that, and all that sorts of things.

[7:41] Jesse McAnally: And it is much more like father-daughter, teach I want her to sing my music, all that kind of stuff.

[7:47] Andrew DeWolf: I can see the influences.

[7:48] Andrew DeWolf: As far as comparative to Phantom of the Opera, I think there's a lot of things that run parallel, like Beef is Carlotta, we talked about.

[7:56] Jesse McAnally: The one thing that and Phoenix is of course Christine.

[8:00] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.

[8:01] Andrew DeWolf: The one thing we don't really have, we don't have a chandelier crash, and we don't um Paul Williams' character Swan does there's not really an equivalent for him in any other version of Phantom of the Opera.

[8:12] Jesse McAnally: That's because the Swan character comes from the Faust influence, I feel like the Swan is the devil, sort of.

[8:22] Andrew DeWolf: No, he made a deal with the devil, kind of.

[8:25] Andrew DeWolf: In in the Faust parallel, he is the devil character.

[8:30] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[8:31] Jesse McAnally: Um he also made a separate deal with the devil to not be.

[8:36] Andrew DeWolf: Exactly.

[8:36] Andrew DeWolf: He's not literally the devil.

[8:38] Andrew DeWolf: It's just in what they took from the story, he's the devil.

[8:42] Andrew DeWolf: Because the Phantom, who is Winslow Leech, um, makes a deal with him to get more famous and get more popular, and of course it all backfires because it always does immediately.

[8:57] Jesse McAnally: Winslow wants to just get revenge on Swan the whole time.

[8:59] Andrew DeWolf: But Swan also in this part is a little weird and just kind of almost out of nowhere, but I guess it's it's so weird that it almost works.

[9:08] Andrew DeWolf: Swan also made a deal with the devil to like live forever as a young man or something.

[9:14] Jesse McAnally: It's very interesting.

[9:16] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, but he can't be shown on TV, or else you will see the real side of him, which is the um Dorian Gray part of the narrative.

[9:25] Jesse McAnally: Yes.

[9:26] Jesse McAnally: Um just an absolutely wild movie.

[9:30] Andrew DeWolf: But the thing is, we've made comparisons Rocky Horror Picture Show.

[9:33] Andrew DeWolf: Um I think this is closer to Little Shop of Horrors because unlike uh Rocky Horror Picture Show, but like Little Shop of Horrors, this has very incredible filmmaking, like the single shot like time bomb scene is absolutely impressive.

[9:47] Jesse McAnally: Um the filmmaking is stylistic, intentional, and very confident.

[9:54] Andrew DeWolf: And I really I'm a big fan of work like this.

[9:57] Andrew DeWolf: It's weird that this failed so hard, I guess, initially, but I'm I am glad that it's getting a cult resurgence, and I almost wish it had more of a cult resurgence.

[10:09] Jesse McAnally: Uh, because I I people do talk about this in certain like communities, but I feel like it doesn't get nearly the attention that like Rocky Horror has gotten.

[10:18] Andrew DeWolf: No.

[10:18] Andrew DeWolf: Where like there's no like uh remake of this on Fox, you know, like that's it.

[10:23] Jesse McAnally: They have been trying to remake this for a couple years.

[10:27] Andrew DeWolf: Um this has been something they've been trying for many years.

[10:30] Jesse McAnally: The other thing is I don't know if you could remake it, because I think a lot of the um a lot of the charm with this is that it's so 70s.

[10:38] Andrew DeWolf: Well, it's so 70s, and also the filmmaking is so deliberate in the you don't see this type of filmmaking that often.

[10:45] Jesse McAnally: Um I don't think just some remake is gonna do it justice at all.

[10:50] Andrew DeWolf: I think the minute you lose Paul Williams and Brian De Palma, you have nothing.

[10:50] Jesse McAnally: And Brian De Palma is a visionary, but Paul Williams, do I I know you know his work.

[10:59] Andrew DeWolf: Um he did most of the Muppets soundtrack.

[11:02] Jesse McAnally: Oh, the yeah, I definitely know his work.

[11:04] Andrew DeWolf: He did all the songs in this?

[11:06] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, he did every song any place swamp.

[11:08] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, really?

[11:09] Jesse McAnally: Okay.

[11:09] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, he uh And most of the time when like the uh Leech is singing, it is him.

[11:16] Andrew DeWolf: So he did the songs for The Muppet Christmas Carol, um, The Muppet Movie, Bugsy Malone, which we should cover one of these days.

[11:24] Jesse McAnally: Um Emmett Otter's Christmas.

[11:26] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, he's uh really he's really good at this.

[11:30] Jesse McAnally: Emmett Otter's Christmas underrated.

[11:32] Andrew DeWolf: Actually, some some fun jug band stuff in that.

[11:35] Jesse McAnally: But this was like his big thing.

[11:37] Andrew DeWolf: And I know it's inspired filmmakers like Edgar Wright.

[11:40] Jesse McAnally: Um, so much that uh Paul Williams gets a cameo in Baby Driver because Edgar Wright is such a big fan of this film.

[11:47] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like we have to describe more of what actually happens.

[11:51] Jesse McAnally: Tell us the plot, Andrew.

[11:52] Andrew DeWolf: So a lot of the plot is kind of fuzzy and surreal, a surrealist in a way, but the Paradise I think is a physical location.

[12:02] Andrew DeWolf: It's a it's a music venue that the Swan is trying to open.

[12:06] Andrew DeWolf: We open in some other club, I'm pretty sure.

[12:10] Andrew DeWolf: With the Juicy Fruits.

[12:13] Andrew DeWolf: With the Juicy Fruits, and the Juicy Fruits is like a 50s rock band, kind of like Beach Boys.

[12:21] Andrew DeWolf: We'll remember you forever.

[12:27] Andrew DeWolf: Through the sacrifice you made, we can't believe the price you paid for love.

[12:40] Andrew DeWolf: So they have like different their name changes as the movie goes on.

[12:44] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, don't they become like the Beach Bums or some shit?

[12:47] Andrew DeWolf: Something like that.

[12:47] Andrew DeWolf: I love it.

[12:48] Andrew DeWolf: And they go on, and then uh Winslow Leech goes on and plays like a piano ballad that's like uh you could tell it's supposed to be a lot more uh like heartfelt than what the Juicy Fruits were playing.

[13:01] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, it's a it's a song called Faust, and I love the song.

[13:15] Andrew DeWolf: And sleep alone could ease my mind.

[13:23] Jesse McAnally: The swan and we don't see the swan, but the swan and this other person are are at uh this claim.

[13:30] Andrew DeWolf: Like a glass bar like a glass bubble above it.

[13:34] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, because everything in this movie is fucking weird.

[13:37] Andrew DeWolf: I love it.

[13:38] Jesse McAnally: I love it.

[13:39] Andrew DeWolf: It's like if the apple were good.

[13:42] Jesse McAnally: I yeah, exactly.

[13:43] Andrew DeWolf: And you're taking that word from me, I think.

[13:46] Jesse McAnally: Uh because I I had said that.

[13:49] Andrew DeWolf: Life is nothing but your business in 1994.

[13:53] Jesse McAnally: We fight on this fortnight with him for a call.

[13:58] Andrew DeWolf: We talked about the apple, and the apple is so weird and wacky, but it's just cause it kind of just doesn't work.

[14:05] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[14:05] Andrew DeWolf: Whereas this does everything that the apple did, but like it works.

[14:10] Jesse McAnally: So well, I think the thing about this is it takes a breath and knows when to just be a moment and when to be wild and erratic.

[14:19] Andrew DeWolf: So Winslow meets this guy that the Swan was talking to, and the guy is like, we want to make a deal with you to like play your music.

[14:28] Jesse McAnally: And Winslow has like uh he calls it a a cantata, I think, or a sonata, I forget which one he calls it.

[14:35] Andrew DeWolf: Um called Faust.

[14:37] Jesse McAnally: He's playing rock music, so it's a little weird that but I I get it.

[14:41] Andrew DeWolf: He's supposed to be like this uh musician, out there musician guy.

[14:45] Jesse McAnally: And he has like a stack of papers as big as a freaking encyclopedia that is his his cantata sonata uh Faust.

[14:53] Andrew DeWolf: But the thing is only he can sing Faust.

[14:55] Jesse McAnally: Uh he doesn't want anyone else to sing Faust.

[14:57] Andrew DeWolf: Until he meets Phoenix.

[14:59] Jesse McAnally: Until he meets Phoenix, but that's later.

[15:01] Andrew DeWolf: Um he goes.

[15:02] Jesse McAnally: So he gives he gives them his music and never hears back.

[15:07] Andrew DeWolf: So he goes to like the Swan's house.

[15:10] Jesse McAnally: I love how you're calling him the Swan, like it isn't his name.

[15:12] Andrew DeWolf: Is his name just Swan?

[15:14] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[15:15] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[15:15] Jesse McAnally: He goes to Swan's house and there's tryouts being held for for women to sing Faust, his song, and he's like, I he must have forgotten to invite me or something, because he's just uh dense, I guess.

[15:30] Andrew DeWolf: Uh he's not the brightest bulb.

[15:33] Jesse McAnally: So he sneaks in and meets Swan, and Swan kicks him out and beats him up and imprisons him.

[15:39] Andrew DeWolf: Uh well, the police imprison him.

[15:41] Jesse McAnally: Right.

[15:42] Andrew DeWolf: He goes to federal prison for some sh some shit.

[15:46] Jesse McAnally: Trespassing.

[15:47] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know.

[15:47] Jesse McAnally: They take his teeth out.

[15:48] Andrew DeWolf: What the Yeah, they knock his fucking teeth out.

[15:51] Jesse McAnally: The prison prisoners don't aren't allowed to have teeth, I guess, in in uh in this prison system.

[15:58] Andrew DeWolf: But it's okay.

[15:58] Jesse McAnally: He escapes by putting himself into a box.

[16:01] Andrew DeWolf: It's great.

[16:03] Jesse McAnally: So he hears that the the juicy fruits are going to play Faust at the opening of the Paradise on the radio.

[16:11] Andrew DeWolf: And this upsets him so much that he jumps out a window into a box or some shit.

[16:18] Jesse McAnally: Jumps into like a conveyor belt and packages him away in a box.

[16:23] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, and this gets him out of prison.

[16:26] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, it works.

[16:27] Andrew DeWolf: It's very much uh the way that Annie got out of the orphanage is how uh Winslow gets out of prison.

[16:32] Jesse McAnally: So it it just works.

[16:35] Andrew DeWolf: He gets out of prison and he he runs to uh does he is it Swan's house again, or is it is it like a different it's somewhere where they're printing records.

[16:45] Jesse McAnally: It's a r I think it's just the Paradise record printer.

[16:47] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[16:48] Jesse McAnally: Uh and in through the most convoluted ridiculous nonsense ever.

[16:53] Andrew DeWolf: He gets caught and smashes his face into the fucking red record printer.

[16:57] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, he bashes his face into the printer and half his face gets all uh all messed up because Phantom, it has I mean we gotta get to that deformity somehow.

[17:06] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[17:06] Jesse McAnally: And they they only they do the half-face deformity thing, but he wears a mask that covers the top part of his face.

[17:12] Andrew DeWolf: All of it.

[17:13] Jesse McAnally: I I am equally baffled, and it's not even the only version of Phantom of the Opera that does that, and I am always confused every time.

[17:21] Andrew DeWolf: It's like, I mean, I guess half masks are a weird thing to come by, but why even but like why not just have his whole face be deformed though?

[17:28] Jesse McAnally: The other thing that's strange about this adaptation is it also destroys his vocal cords.

[17:33] Andrew DeWolf: So he needs to get a vocoder to be able to talk again, which I think adds a lot to this specific version of Phantom of the Opera.

[17:40] Jesse McAnally: Like gives it a Batman element.

[17:41] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, what I think is really cool about it as well is that it it makes him dependent on Swan to do his singing.

[17:48] Jesse McAnally: Because he goes and he meets with Swan again, trying to destroy the paradise or whatever, but Swan is like, I need more of your music.

[17:55] Andrew DeWolf: Uh let's just let bygones be bygones.

[17:58] Jesse McAnally: Here, sign this contract that has In blood.

[17:58] Andrew DeWolf: In blood.

[18:03] Jesse McAnally: And I'll and I'll help you sing again.

[18:05] Andrew DeWolf: And he and so now he can sing again, but only when he's hooked up to this machine that Swan made.

[18:11] Jesse McAnally: And when he does, it's Paul Williams' voice coming out, not the original actors.

[18:15] Andrew DeWolf: So literally he Swan gives him his voice.

[18:18] Jesse McAnally: Um and this is where we kind of move into the second like half of the story.

[18:26] Andrew DeWolf: We didn't even talk about like the casting couch segment where Winslow breaks in to like.

[18:32] Jesse McAnally: There's so much.

[18:33] Andrew DeWolf: We can't talk about like everything.

[18:34] Jesse McAnally: There's just so fucking much that goes on.

[18:36] Andrew DeWolf: I know, but that one's specifically weird.

[18:38] Jesse McAnally: It's like, what is he watching us do?

[18:40] Andrew DeWolf: Do each other.

[18:42] Jesse McAnally: We're not even at like we're we're still this was all building up to now he is the phantom of the paradise.

[18:49] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, now he is the phantom of the paradise.

[18:51] Jesse McAnally: Because all of this is just backstory to that, essentially.

[18:55] Andrew DeWolf: And it goes quickly.

[18:56] Jesse McAnally: I know it sounds like we took a while.

[18:58] Andrew DeWolf: That's like 20 minutes of the movie.

[19:00] Jesse McAnally: It's ridiculous.

[19:01] Andrew DeWolf: So much happens, and it's like it's just boom, boom, boom, boom, boom.

[19:06] Jesse McAnally: It's it's crazy.

[19:07] Andrew DeWolf: And usually that's a negative, but for this film, like you appreciate the adrenaline.

[19:12] Jesse McAnally: You you like it because it's just it it feels like um it's like Winslow Leech's no good, very bad day, you know.

[19:21] Andrew DeWolf: Then what happens?

[19:22] Jesse McAnally: Um then we introduce Beef, don't we?

[19:24] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, Beef gets introduced.

[19:25] Jesse McAnally: Who is beef beef is part of the Juicy fruits or or something The new headliner, basically.

[19:32] Andrew DeWolf: Like basically what Phoenix was supposed to be, it's now beef.

[19:35] Jesse McAnally: So Swan, as far as I'm aware, Swan is just a fucking asshole.

[19:40] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.

[19:40] Jesse McAnally: Cause he literally is like the Juicy Fruits aren't singing the songs right, which Winslow literally told him the Juicy Fruits wouldn't sing the songs right.

[19:49] Andrew DeWolf: Said that just straight up, and Swan is like, whatever, we're gonna have the Juicy Fruits sing the songs.

[19:54] Jesse McAnally: And then they didn't sing the songs right.

[19:56] Andrew DeWolf: And now Winslow is like, I want this Phoenix person to sing my songs.

[20:01] Jesse McAnally: And Swan is like, yeah, yeah, that's great.

[20:03] Andrew DeWolf: We're gonna have this other person sing the songs who can't do it.

[20:06] Jesse McAnally: We're gonna find the most ridiculous human being on the planet to try to sing these songs.

[20:16] Andrew DeWolf: To piss off Winslow.

[20:17] Jesse McAnally: I think it's um I mean in the narrative, yes, he does, but it's hilarious.

[20:22] Andrew DeWolf: And the way they reveal Beef, they like pull him out of a casket, and then he goes glares into the camera.

[20:29] Jesse McAnally: Beef is incredible.

[20:30] Andrew DeWolf: Beef is just amazing.

[20:34] Jesse McAnally: And the fact that the movie is so good before they even introduce beef is really a testament.

[20:39] Andrew DeWolf: It gives you a new lease on life when beef shows up, and it also is such a bummer when the fucking Winslow murders him.

[20:46] Jesse McAnally: It's still good though.

[20:47] Andrew DeWolf: Like, so Beef is is Carlotta.

[20:49] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[20:49] Andrew DeWolf: Beef is like a uh I almost want to say like a glam rock singer.

[20:55] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, a pretty face with like a intensity mostly in the performance, less than the actual singing.

[21:02] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[21:02] Jesse McAnally: Ki he kind of a drag sort of vibe.

[21:07] Andrew DeWolf: Definitely yeah, that kind of vibe.

[21:09] Jesse McAnally: Um and Beef Beef like gets threatened by Winslow because Winslow is like psycho reference.

[21:16] Andrew DeWolf: Um like with a plunger in his mouth, it's great.

[21:20] Jesse McAnally: But Beef is not like let's be clear.

[21:22] Andrew DeWolf: Beef is not an mean or evil person.

[21:25] Jesse McAnally: Even he's like, I don't like fiddling around with the dead man's music.

[21:28] Andrew DeWolf: It's kinda weird.

[21:29] Jesse McAnally: It gives me the willies.

[21:30] Andrew DeWolf: I don't like this.

[21:31] Jesse McAnally: Beef wants out.

[21:32] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[21:33] Jesse McAnally: The the thing is Swan kinda has everybody by the balls.

[21:36] Andrew DeWolf: Like, if there's anyone not deserving of death, it's Beef, but the Phantom kills him anyway.

[21:40] Jesse McAnally: Well, yeah, because the I mean, it's Phantom of the Opera, the Phantom is never the good guy, really.

[21:46] Andrew DeWolf: No.

[21:47] Jesse McAnally: Sympathetic, but never the good guy.

[21:51] Andrew DeWolf: What has come the closest to him being the good guy?

[21:54] Jesse McAnally: I mean, probably this.

[21:56] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I guess.

[21:57] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[21:57] Andrew DeWolf: And he still killed Beef.

[21:59] Jesse McAnally: He still kills Beef.

[22:00] Andrew DeWolf: But at this point, Winslow's had enough, you know?

[22:03] Jesse McAnally: Like everyone's fucking with him.

[22:06] Andrew DeWolf: And the worst part is he can't even kill himself to be free of it, because he's under contract.

[22:12] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, this movie has a thing with contracts.

[22:14] Andrew DeWolf: Both Winslow and Swan are under contract, and the contracts are like magic, so they're literally not able to die because it would break the contract.

[22:24] Jesse McAnally: So he's like, Yeah, you you gotta play your music to me forever.

[22:28] Andrew DeWolf: And then Winslow tries to kill Swan.

[22:30] Jesse McAnally: He's like, Oh, I'm under contract too.

[22:32] Andrew DeWolf: Don't even worry.

[22:33] Jesse McAnally: I I kinda want you to explain the the very end here.

[22:36] Andrew DeWolf: Well then Swan breaks his contract, like forced like this is where it just gets into big technicalities where Swan broke his contract, was seen on TV, and people saw his real face, and therefore both of them die because they both their stab wounds open up again.

[22:55] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, it's just it a contractual technicality ends the movie.

[22:59] Andrew DeWolf: Yep.

[23:00] Jesse McAnally: Which for a critique on the music industry, I think that's pretty funny.

[23:06] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[23:07] Jesse McAnally: Like this film is just an overall critique of like, man, the music industry sucks, right?

[23:12] Andrew DeWolf: Am I right?

[23:13] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, I mean, it takes everything from you, gives your music to people that sucks.

[23:17] Andrew DeWolf: Uh and people will be dancing on your corpse, not even aware you even existed, which is like the chaos of the ending.

[23:24] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[23:24] Andrew DeWolf: So I feel like that that's Phantom of the Paradise.

[23:27] Jesse McAnally: But really, i it's pretty hard to explain this because it's so

[23:34] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.

[23:35] Jesse McAnally: You need to watch it for yourself.

[23:37] Andrew DeWolf: You have to watch it.

[23:39] Jesse McAnally: Um really you're missing out by not watching it because like you have to see his eyes with the black makeup staring back at you through the fucking mask.

[23:47] Andrew DeWolf: Like it it's it's really something.

[23:50] Jesse McAnally: And it's nothing about this screams laziness.

[23:52] Andrew DeWolf: Nothing about this is lazy, nothing about it is by the book.

[23:56] Jesse McAnally: It is incredible.

[23:57] Andrew DeWolf: And I love Brian DePalma's, and he can do subtle work.

[24:00] Jesse McAnally: Like Dress to Kill is a very subtle film.

[24:04] Andrew DeWolf: Um, but this is over the top camp, and you know what?

[24:07] Jesse McAnally: I love it.

[24:08] Andrew DeWolf: We we don't get enough of shit like this.

[24:11] Jesse McAnally: This is like i it's it's one of those B movies that is really good.

[24:16] Andrew DeWolf: Like it's it's everything good about B movies, you know?

[24:20] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, except Jerry Seinfeld.

[24:22] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, everything good about the B movies.

[24:26] Jesse McAnally: On that note, Andrew, want to compare our opinions to those of the true critics over on Letterboxd.com.

[24:33] Andrew DeWolf: I am excited to hear what they have to say.

[24:35] Jesse McAnally: Because I mean, with a movie like this.

[24:37] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, are you ready?

[24:39] Jesse McAnally: I'm ready.

[24:39] Andrew DeWolf: Number one, Jessica Harper, heart emoji.

[24:43] Jesse McAnally: Is that an actress in the movie that has been?

[24:44] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, she plays Phoenix.

[24:45] Jesse McAnally: This has to be a trick.

[24:46] Andrew DeWolf: Because I mean, this is an obvious five, so I'm gonna go one star just because beef.

[24:55] Jesse McAnally: I know drug reel from real.

[25:00] Andrew DeWolf: That's right.

[25:01] Jesse McAnally: Fucking that's some does.

[25:06] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, they're because like beef is like a drugie or whatever, and and he's trying to leave, like, oh, there's a phantom, and they're like, you're just on drugs.

[25:13] Jesse McAnally: And he's like, I know drug reel from real real.

[25:16] Andrew DeWolf: And you know what?

[25:17] Jesse McAnally: Good for him.

[25:22] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, beef is great.

[25:24] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[25:24] Andrew DeWolf: Um I'm gonna go five for the beef quote.

[25:28] Jesse McAnally: That is correct.

[25:29] Andrew DeWolf: Winslow frowny face.

[25:31] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, yeah.

[25:32] Andrew DeWolf: Uh five stars.

[25:34] Jesse McAnally: That is correct.

[25:35] Andrew DeWolf: I'm just I'm on a roll.

[25:36] Jesse McAnally: I'm gonna roll too much.

[25:37] Andrew DeWolf: You are, you are, you are.

[25:38] Jesse McAnally: Um, next one.

[25:39] Andrew DeWolf: If you watch this, you will grow sideburns and your pants will lengthen.

[25:43] Jesse McAnally: Five.

[25:43] Andrew DeWolf: Five stars.

[25:44] Jesse McAnally: That is a one star.

[25:46] Andrew DeWolf: Fuck.

[25:47] Jesse McAnally: Fuck.

[25:47] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, okay.

[25:48] Jesse McAnally: Still doing that.

[25:49] Andrew DeWolf: Next one, next one.

[25:49] Jesse McAnally: I hate when my favorite artist gets two into coke.

[25:57] Andrew DeWolf: One star. There was too many. I've tried five too many times. That is correct. True deck. And the last one, beef deserved better. True. Five stars. That is a one star. But you got two points. You did alright that game, Andrew.

[26:10] Jesse McAnally: Okay, okay. How about we go into a mid-show and then we talk about some of these songs?

[26:21] Jesse McAnally: Today's show is brought to you by the extremely kind donations by our donors over at Patreon. You can check out our Patreon for some extra content. We got commentary tracks, we got uh whole extra podcast episodes over there, just a lot of content to check out. You can also request episodes, you can come to our uh monthly Patreon meetups, and you get your name on this nice list that I am about to read.

[26:47] Jesse McAnally: Our current patrons are Melissa Goldman, Danielle Rennix, Justus Stampede, Ewan Cassidy, Monica Thoreau, Brent Black, Lathaniel Stacey Coomb, Raphael Martinez Salaz, Jessica T, Mitchell Young, Chai Teacop, Katie McDonough, Chris Marcote, KG Marie Anastasio, Leela, RJ Noriga, Charlie B. Bjorn Hermans, Toriana Frazier, Sammy the Most Lopez, Liana Morton, Haley Blazier, Joseph Evans Green, Marilou Choquette, John Vanales, Russ Walker, Musical Hell, Emily Gracely, Gracie, Heil Summers, Cinemageddon Reviews, Villainous Miss, Sophina Ali, The Omega Geek, Paige Pearson, Maddie Wargle, Eliza Ertman, Anna Loscatova, Jessica Veray, Sarah Den Blaker, Evan Ball, Zachary Torres, Gathering Party Before Venturing Forth, Rora Morasso, Janae C.

[27:40] Jesse McAnally: Scoot in the Technical Dreamcoat, Liz Lim, Nothing is Certain Except Beth and Taxes, Desbian, Mara Ferloin, Captain Rod Task, uh, Lisa L. Nobody, Renee Thomas, What Did Boris Say, Puffy Boy, Summer, and Julia Hardy. They give us a little extra financial support that helps us keep the lights on here, Musicals of Cheese, and keeps us making this podcast that we think you like.

[27:58] Jesse McAnally: We think you like it. Um, so come join them. They got some cool shit over there, and we got more shit coming, so here're just hoping you'll go. Alrighty.

[28:14] Jesse McAnally: Let's get back to the shoo.

[28:22] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, let's just talk about all the Juicy Fruit songs to begin with.

[28:32] Jesse McAnally: Never knew his father. Mother didn't bother to catch his last name as he came, he was off the piet. Times were really and he had his mother-in-law. Soon another mister, soon a baby sister. Mama kept swinging and Eddie kept singing on.

[29:14] Andrew DeWolf: I almost feel like it's just one song. They just it's it's the Beach Boys song, isn't it? They do goodbye, Eddie, goodbye, then they do s uh upholstery. And then I think they do one more. Um, oh, somebody super like you. I are we supposed to like these songs?

[29:31] Jesse McAnally: I don't know. I mean they're catchy. I don't dislike when they're on.

[29:34] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, that's the weird thing. Is like honestly, I thought that when the first when the Juicy Fruits first came on that this was just gonna be like the song style of the of the show, of the not the show of the movie.

[29:45] Jesse McAnally: Right.

[29:46] Andrew DeWolf: But when Winslow actually shows up, he's just playing something almost completely different. I I do like them for the most part, but it is kind of a generic sort of style. You know, like it's it's this 50s surf rock kind of thing, you know.

[30:03] Jesse McAnally: I mean, I don't I like the Beach Boys, like I Yeah, that's that's the thing.

[30:08] Andrew DeWolf: Um, like, do you really not like the nipplice if we were older? Like, I love that sound. Why haven't we done a okay? Real talk. Why haven't there been a Beach Boys uh jukebox musical?

[30:21] Jesse McAnally: I feel like a lot of their songs really suits a narrative, and maybe that's just a me thing. I feel like it would work.

[30:28] Andrew DeWolf: Like, I mean, wasn't Ain't Too Proud like pretty popular?

[30:31] Jesse McAnally: Uh isn't that like the temptation?

[30:33] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, the temptation. Like, I feel like that's not like the same genre, but it's like a similar style.

[30:38] Jesse McAnally: Like you could do something like that with the Beach Boys. I don't know, like God only knows what I do without you feels like a romance ballad to begin with. I'm not like a proponent of jukebox musicals, but they clearly have an audience, so if we're gonna keep doing them, like do a band that I like, please.

[30:54] Andrew DeWolf: You know, I I know you can't do other bands that I like for reasons that I don't like many other bands, but let's talk about Faust.

[31:11] Jesse McAnally: Who will stand by me? Stand back and give my back the gift or after stand by me.

[31:25] Andrew DeWolf: Stand back and after making love we dream of the stack would dream a bunch of friends, dream each of the Smith.

[31:46] Jesse McAnally: Dream it never end.

[31:50] Andrew DeWolf: Let's talk about Faust. I love the song. It does come up a lot in the preceding like story.

[31:57] Jesse McAnally: He has a big stack of papers, right?

[31:59] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[32:00] Jesse McAnally: Big stack of papers.

[32:01] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. You would think that he has a bit more music for this song, but he does just kind of have this one song.

[32:08] Jesse McAnally: The one song. He went to the Andrew Lloyd Weber School of Songwriting.

[32:14] Andrew DeWolf: I wrote one song, and that's a score, right?

[32:18] Jesse McAnally: Why is your one song like this fucking thick?

[32:22] Andrew DeWolf: Well, uh, I did it four or five times. You know, it's a different uh lay motif.

[32:29] Jesse McAnally: That's what we're calling it. A lay motif. The the uh Winslow does get another song later though, doesn't he?

[32:35] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I think so. The Beauty and the Beast uh Phantom song. It's the one that he sings when they're like reconstructing his voice or something, or after they reconstruct his voice.

[32:43] Jesse McAnally: No, he's singing Faust again when he does when they do that.

[32:45] Andrew DeWolf: It's after he reconstructs his voice, then, right?

[32:47] Jesse McAnally: It's he he goes to compose something new and they they do that.

[32:51] Andrew DeWolf: Right. That that makes sense.

[32:52] Jesse McAnally: Yes. Um I I really like Faust. Faust, like every I know we hear it a lot, but every time I hear it, I'm like, ah fuck, here we go again. It's that good feeling when you hear a reprieve is like, ah, get the I get to hear that song I like again.

[33:04] Andrew DeWolf: I gotta say, I think the first time they do it's the best one though.

[33:07] Jesse McAnally: I agree, it's just simple piano, but it gets more experimental and bigger every time, which for a narrative I appreciate.

[33:15] Andrew DeWolf: You know, is it sad that we never actually get a version of of Phoenix performing Faust?

[33:20] Jesse McAnally: It is, but I I like the songs that Phoenix do perform. Like, um, I really like special to me.

[33:27] Andrew DeWolf: Caught up in the old wheel and dealing. You've got no time left for simple feeling.

[33:34] Jesse McAnally: I thought I knew you, but I didn't know you at all.

[33:41] Andrew DeWolf: Trapped inside your world worry.

[33:45] Jesse McAnally: You miss so much when you always hurry.

[33:48] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, slow down, baby. You'll only get hurt if you fall.

[33:55] Jesse McAnally: Well, you told me one time that you'd be somebody that you weren't working just to survive.

[34:02] Andrew DeWolf: But you're working so hard that you don't even know you're alive.

[34:10] Jesse McAnally: Working so hard to be somebody special.

[34:14] Andrew DeWolf: Not working just to survive.

[34:17] Jesse McAnally: Well, you're special to me and baby when I don't see the babe.

[34:21] Andrew DeWolf: It's where you go once you arrive.

[34:24] Jesse McAnally: Where we go once we arrive.

[34:29] Andrew DeWolf: I really like Jessica Harper's voice.

[34:31] Jesse McAnally: Um, maybe this Halloween we'll talk about shock treatment, the Rocky Horror Picture Show sequel that she starred and played Janet in.

[34:39] Andrew DeWolf: Is that good?

[34:40] Jesse McAnally: I hear that that's I've heard I think I've heard that's that that's not good.

[34:44] Andrew DeWolf: The th okay, so here's my opinion.

[34:47] Jesse McAnally: I don't like it.

[34:48] Andrew DeWolf: I sincerely believe you might.

[34:50] Jesse McAnally: Okay.

[34:50] Andrew DeWolf: Is it like camp?

[34:51] Jesse McAnally: Like it's very much camp.

[34:53] Andrew DeWolf: I I am a fan of camp, usually.

[34:55] Jesse McAnally: That being said, there there has been campy movies that I've I've not liked, but I think it's closer to this, strangely, in tone and vibe, than it is to Rocky Horror.

[35:05] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[35:06] Jesse McAnally: I mean, I'd be down to at least check it out.

[35:08] Andrew DeWolf: Like, it's still got the same kind of catchy tunes as Rocky Horror, just more of a a weird unpleasant vibe.

[35:16] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, I it maybe this Halloween, because it's more how would I put it? It's more a critique on television.

[35:23] Andrew DeWolf: So everyone lives in a TV studio.

[35:25] Jesse McAnally: Which it's what uh catch me if you can want it to be.

[35:28] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, yeah, it's creative.

[35:30] Jesse McAnally: It definitely I think it's a lot like this where it's very creative. Um, I like um all Phoenix's song, but special to me is like Jessica Harper's voice is very, very specific and very, very good.

[35:42] Andrew DeWolf: I like that better than old Souls.

[35:46] Jesse McAnally: Our love is an old love behavior is older than all years.

[36:00] Andrew DeWolf: I have seen in strange young eyes.

[36:05] Jesse McAnally: Familiarities.

[36:09] Andrew DeWolf: Um, she has this very low register where you have the right song, it sounds beautiful, but if you have the wrong song, you kinda get bored.

[36:16] Jesse McAnally: And old Souls feels like the wrong song.

[36:19] Andrew DeWolf: I could I can kinda see that.

[36:20] Jesse McAnally: However, live at last.

[36:22] Andrew DeWolf: Life at last! Salutations from the other side.

[36:27] Jesse McAnally: I can see that you're the devil's pride.

[36:30] Andrew DeWolf: Do you realize a whole you don't have some hole?

[36:37] Jesse McAnally: Your network's coming true!

[36:39] Andrew DeWolf: I am your crap!

[36:48] Jesse McAnally: Shouldn't listen while the fun. Hearts are broken and the bad guys win.

[36:54] Andrew DeWolf: Shouldn't you listen while the coming of the July soon squeezy over the week of home?

[37:05] Jesse McAnally: Salutation from the other side.

[37:07] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, this song fucking kicks ass.

[37:09] Jesse McAnally: Yes, it does. I am so happy.

[37:11] Andrew DeWolf: Um, so I have this song rotating through or this album rotating through my iTunes shuffle a lot.

[37:17] Jesse McAnally: Um, and every time this comes in, I get my heart rate gets pumped, and I'm excited.

[37:22] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, this drive's suddenly gonna be a little bit better.

[37:24] Jesse McAnally: It's it's honestly, it's great that he dies too.

[37:28] Andrew DeWolf: He you can't top that.

[37:29] Jesse McAnally: There's nothing he can do after that that can top what's happening.

[37:33] Andrew DeWolf: He does the song and he he dies in the most weird way.

[37:39] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, by like an electric sign.

[37:41] Andrew DeWolf: It's so fucking weird, but you know what? Like, it's great.

[37:43] Jesse McAnally: It works.

[37:44] Andrew DeWolf: It is a punk rock moment in the most blatant description of a punk rock moment.

[37:52] Jesse McAnally: Dying on stage, that's fucking punk rock.

[37:54] Andrew DeWolf: Kind of reminds me of uh Meatloaf song.

[37:56] Jesse McAnally: I mean a Jim Steinman song.

[37:58] Andrew DeWolf: No, like Meatloaf's song in uh Rocky Horror.

[38:02] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[38:03] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Hopatooty. Bless my soul. I'm gonna come in and sing this great song, then get pickaxed to death.

[38:09] Jesse McAnally: Just get killed immediately.

[38:12] Andrew DeWolf: Beef at least left more of an impression on this movie than Meatloaf did on Rocky Horror.

[38:19] Jesse McAnally: That's because Beatloaf and Rocky Horror is literally that song.

[38:22] Andrew DeWolf: That's it.

[38:23] Jesse McAnally: There's nothing else. He on brought our uh in the West End played both Eddie and Dr. Scott, so.

[38:28] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, which they probably should have let him do in the movie, but whatever.

[38:33] Jesse McAnally: I I get why they did.

[38:34] Andrew DeWolf: And you know what? Maybe it's a good thing they didn't, because then, you know, there would be a lot of meatloaf, and I'm not the biggest Meatloaf fan anymore.

[38:43] Jesse McAnally: I've grown out of it a little bit.

[38:44] Andrew DeWolf: Why why why did that happen?

[38:46] Jesse McAnally: I wonder.

[38:47] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know. Just weird interactions with him, I think.

[38:55] Jesse McAnally: I was like, I got a weird Meatloaf story for you.

[38:58] Andrew DeWolf: Why is someone ask about Meatloaf?

[39:00] Jesse McAnally: I think they were just talking about like cause they were I won't say on the older side, but like a different generation than me.

[39:07] Andrew DeWolf: Um more of Meatloaf's generation, and they're like, Oh yeah, I just love all Meatloaf's music.

[39:11] Jesse McAnally: And I was like, I I have a fun Meatloaf story if you want to hear it.

[39:15] Andrew DeWolf: Did they want to hear it?

[39:16] Jesse McAnally: I did, and I told him they're like, that is so wild.

[39:19] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[39:24] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[39:24] Andrew DeWolf: Going into the And it's sad that he's that he's gone, you know?

[39:28] Jesse McAnally: It yeah, it is.

[39:29] Andrew DeWolf: It's sad that him and Jim Steinman are gone.

[39:31] Jesse McAnally: One day we'll cover Bat Out of Hell.

[39:33] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like that's something worthy of covering now.

[39:35] Jesse McAnally: Uh for years I was like, man, it's not really worth it, but now that we kind of have become so entangled with Meatloaf in our lives.

[39:43] Andrew DeWolf: We have the Meatloaf backstory now.

[39:46] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, we have that connection as one of the wildest things that has ever happened to us on a weekend.

[39:52] Andrew DeWolf: And also now that Meatloaf and Jim Steinman are both gone from the world, you know.

[39:58] Jesse McAnally: Neither of them can attack us on Facebook.

[40:00] Andrew DeWolf: I don't think Jim Steinman would ever attack us on Facebook, though.

[40:02] Jesse McAnally: He he seemed like a good guy.

[40:03] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, Jim Steinman is fine, man, from everyone that I know who has worked with him.

[40:07] Jesse McAnally: Including Meatloaf.

[40:13] Andrew DeWolf: Oh man.

[40:14] Jesse McAnally: This is really this is just a wild movie.

[40:16] Andrew DeWolf: I I I the pr it's very difficult to talk about because it's just good.

[40:21] Jesse McAnally: Well, it's I I feel like we've given it like a glowing treatment here, and it's not for everyone.

[40:28] Andrew DeWolf: Let's put that disclaimer on there.

[40:30] Jesse McAnally: Like, I don't think your your dad's gonna like it.

[40:32] Andrew DeWolf: I don't want to know you if it's not for you, though.

[40:35] Jesse McAnally: That's interesting.

[40:37] Andrew DeWolf: I I don't know. It's it's one of those movies where it's like, if it isn't for you, are we we're not gonna be friends, I don't think.

[40:47] Jesse McAnally: What else is in that category for you?

[40:50] Andrew DeWolf: It doesn't even be musicals or cheese related.

[40:52] Jesse McAnally: I I think a lot of like kind of campy uh movies are like that.

[40:57] Andrew DeWolf: Like it I I all of my friends I like to have over and like watch like kind of uh schlocky horror movies and schlocky just movies in general, and it's like I I don't think I would be friends with somebody who doesn't enjoy this type of thing.

[41:12] Jesse McAnally: Do you think you'd show Phantom of the Paradise with your friends like coming over to watch?

[41:16] Andrew DeWolf: This is a t this is a movie that I think they would enjoy watching.

[41:19] Jesse McAnally: Okay.

[41:20] Andrew DeWolf: Uh and like my I think my friend group would like.

[41:24] Jesse McAnally: Cause the thing is this isn't like uh a music theater thing.

[41:28] Andrew DeWolf: This is a rock rock, campy, like midnight screening kind of culture.

[41:34] Jesse McAnally: I think that I think that it's it's unique in that way.

[41:38] Andrew DeWolf: Well, it's in in a small amount of company that like there's only a couple other movies that are really like this.

[41:44] Jesse McAnally: I agree.

[41:45] Andrew DeWolf: And I like it.

[41:45] Jesse McAnally: I will watch this movie anytime.

[41:47] Andrew DeWolf: The soundtrack specifically is wonderful.

[41:49] Jesse McAnally: I I also think that this movie is good enough that it sort of transcends being just a cult movie.

[41:57] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[41:57] Jesse McAnally: I think if you enjoy cult movies, you will really like this.

[42:01] Andrew DeWolf: But I think even if you're not a cult movie fan, if you just like musicals or you like Phantom of the Opera, like there's something to get out of this.

[42:08] Jesse McAnally: But speaking of Phantom of the Opera, I think it's time, because as we do these, we're going to rank them as far as how Andrew feels about the Phantom of the Opera adaptations we've talked about and covered on this show.

[42:21] Andrew DeWolf: So Andrew, do you have your tier list ready?

[42:23] Jesse McAnally: Spoilers. Next week we're covering Phantom of the Mall, and Andrew's gonna like uh rank it here just for.

[42:28] Andrew DeWolf: I'm gonna rank it here.

[42:29] Jesse McAnally: Because why the fuck not?

[42:31] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, yeah.

[42:32] Jesse McAnally: Spoilers, kids.

[42:32] Andrew DeWolf: It's the we're not a real show.

[42:34] Jesse McAnally: We're a fucking pretend.

[42:36] Andrew DeWolf: Um let's start with Andrew Lloyd Weber's fan of the opera musical.

[42:46] Jesse McAnally: Alright, do I meme or do I do I do it serious?

[42:49] Andrew DeWolf: Uh that's up to you, man.

[42:51] Jesse McAnally: If we're doing it serious, it probably has to go in A.

[42:54] Andrew DeWolf: Alright.

[42:55] Jesse McAnally: Like, but if we're memeing, probably C or D, because I just it's like it's like this overhyped kind of thing, you know?

[43:02] Andrew DeWolf: It's like you don't want to give it a good rating, but like comparing it to the other Phantom stuff that I've watched, which is how we do this, it's probably A.

[43:12] Jesse McAnally: Like, there's not that much that's that, like, that amazing.

[43:15] Andrew DeWolf: Alright.

[43:16] Jesse McAnally: You know.

[43:17] Andrew DeWolf: Um I'm gonna put it in B.

[43:19] Jesse McAnally: Alright.

[43:20] Andrew DeWolf: Because I I'm just not the biggest fan of it.

[43:22] Jesse McAnally: Then we have um the film version of the Android Weber thing.

[43:26] Andrew DeWolf: Because we're kid I consider those two very different things, two different people.

[43:35] Jesse McAnally: I barely even remember that, but I feel like I didn't like it that much.

[43:39] Andrew DeWolf: We did do a commentary on it.

[43:40] Jesse McAnally: It is on Patreon.

[43:41] Andrew DeWolf: I'm gonna put it in C.

[43:43] Jesse McAnally: It it maybe deserves D.

[43:45] Andrew DeWolf: I don't remember, but I with without having seen it recently, I I don't think I can fairly rate it like that.

[43:52] Jesse McAnally: Okay, next up we have the American musical version of uh Phantom.

[43:58] Andrew DeWolf: Phantom the American Spectacular.

[44:21] Jesse McAnally: Is this the other composers?

[44:23] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.

[44:24] Jesse McAnally: The one that technically got the rights and were the only ones approved by the with the original approval by the authors.

[44:30] Andrew DeWolf: I think I actually really liked this one.

[44:32] Jesse McAnally: I did too.

[44:32] Andrew DeWolf: I like it better than Android Weber.

[44:34] Jesse McAnally: I'm gonna put this in I'm gonna put this one in A.

[44:36] Andrew DeWolf: Now I'm glad I didn't put Weber's in A, because I think this one is more deserving.

[44:40] Jesse McAnally: Then we have the horror one starring Robert England.

[44:51] Andrew DeWolf: You know, it probably doesn't deserve it, but I'm gonna put it in B tier as well.

[44:55] Jesse McAnally: I love that movie.

[44:56] Andrew DeWolf: I think that movie's great.

[44:57] Jesse McAnally: It's got a great score.

[44:59] Andrew DeWolf: It has a really banger song that I'm probably gonna use as a as a theme, a recurring theme for this month, because I just really like it.

[45:06] Jesse McAnally: And we're not and I'm not gonna have another chance to put it anywhere because uh we're not gonna cover it.

[45:10] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, we covered that one on Patreon as well.

[45:13] Jesse McAnally: Good episode.

[45:13] Andrew DeWolf: Like good.

[45:14] Jesse McAnally: I love that movie.

[45:15] Andrew DeWolf: Then Phantom of the Mall.

[45:26] Jesse McAnally: Uh Phantom of the Mall is in C.

[45:29] Andrew DeWolf: But it's like a good C, whereas whereas Phantom of the Opera, the movie is like a bad C.

[45:34] Jesse McAnally: Then we have Phantom of the Paradise.

[45:46] Andrew DeWolf: Phantom of the Paradise is another A.

[45:49] Jesse McAnally: I actually really enjoyed this.

[45:51] Andrew DeWolf: I I didn't think I would enjoy it as much as I did.

[45:56] Jesse McAnally: It was just a really fun movie to watch.

[45:58] Andrew DeWolf: Of course we gotta include Love Never Dies in there somewhere.

[46:14] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, we we were saving the D tier for something.

[46:16] Andrew DeWolf: Love Never Dies.

[46:17] Jesse McAnally: D tier.

[46:18] Andrew DeWolf: I fuck fuck Love Never Dies.

[46:19] Jesse McAnally: I don't get the apologists.

[46:21] Andrew DeWolf: I am slightly an apologist.

[46:23] Jesse McAnally: I don't hate it.

[46:23] Andrew DeWolf: I I genuinely did not like it at all.

[46:26] Jesse McAnally: Uh oh, oh, oh, oh, another one.

[46:28] Andrew DeWolf: Goosebumps the musical, the Phantom of the Auditorium.

[46:44] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, you know what? I I think that that can that can make it into B tier as well.

[46:48] Andrew DeWolf: Uh people say we don't do enough phantom shit, and look at all the phantom shit we've done.

[46:52] Jesse McAnally: We've covered like a fuck ton of phantom shit.

[46:54] Andrew DeWolf: Like, I don't know what the fuck they're talking about.

[46:56] Jesse McAnally: Everyone's like, oh, you don't do any of these things.

[46:58] Andrew DeWolf: You don't you never cover popular things.

[47:01] Jesse McAnally: You just do these weird obscure shit.

[47:03] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm like, I don't think that's true.

[47:04] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, Phantom of the Auditorium was actually was actually decent.

[47:07] Andrew DeWolf: I I thought that that was fun.

[47:08] Jesse McAnally: I'm maybe rating it a little high, but like with what they were doing and what they were going for, I think it works really well.

[47:17] Andrew DeWolf: It succeeded uh very much.

[47:19] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, like I don't think it puts it in A, but I still think I still think that was a a worthwhile listen.

[47:24] Andrew DeWolf: I agree.

[47:24] Jesse McAnally: And as far as I know, that is all we've done.

[47:27] Andrew DeWolf: So we've got a lot of a phantom month of in May and April to go.

[47:32] Jesse McAnally: Um anyone that you're particularly excited for.

[47:35] Andrew DeWolf: Uh what else do we have coming up?

[47:37] Jesse McAnally: I know we've got Dario Argento's Phantom of the Opera, which is historically like very bad.

[47:44] Andrew DeWolf: Like most people.

[47:45] Jesse McAnally: I'm looking forward to that one.

[47:46] Andrew DeWolf: I I I want to see how bad this could possibly be.

[47:48] Jesse McAnally: Like, have you do you are you aware of Dario Ragento's other work?

[47:51] Andrew DeWolf: Have you seen Susperia?

[47:53] Jesse McAnally: I haven't seen Susperia.

[47:54] Andrew DeWolf: Disperia fucks.

[47:55] Jesse McAnally: This movie's terrible.

[47:57] Andrew DeWolf: Part of me is wondering.

[47:59] Jesse McAnally: So he kind of made two Phantom of the Opera movies.

[48:01] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, really?

[48:02] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, and I was wondering if I should just mix them into one episode, because he made a film called Opera about a masked man in an opera that kills people and is obsessed with a woman.

[48:13] Andrew DeWolf: And then he makes it.

[48:14] Jesse McAnally: That looks familiar.

[48:15] Andrew DeWolf: But then he makes a proper Phantom of the Opera movie, um, like uh seven or eight years later, um, that is called the Phantom of the Opera, where he is a it's there's a character named Christine and a guy that is the Phantom, but he does not wear a mask, he's not disfigured.

[48:33] Jesse McAnally: There, like, and he fucks rats.

[48:35] Andrew DeWolf: Good.

[48:35] Jesse McAnally: I love fucking rats.

[48:37] Andrew DeWolf: Well, it's you you hear me say it.

[48:40] Jesse McAnally: Um, there will be 900 trigger warnings at the start of that episode.

[48:44] Andrew DeWolf: Like, there's several nude scenes with the lead actress and also the lead actress is the director's daughter.

[48:49] Jesse McAnally: Well, you know what, Jess?

[48:50] Andrew DeWolf: There's one more phantom thing that I've watched that we could uh we can put in this.

[48:54] Jesse McAnally: What are you gonna put in?

[48:55] Andrew DeWolf: Uh that old old Phantom of the Opera.

[48:58] Jesse McAnally: Oh, yeah, the 1925 one.

[49:00] Andrew DeWolf: I was actually thinking about covering that on this, but I forgot.

[49:02] Jesse McAnally: We're not covered in on our show, but I have actually seen it, so I think I I can rank it.

[49:06] Andrew DeWolf: I think you and I did watch that together.

[49:09] Jesse McAnally: We did uh what is this?

[49:11] Andrew DeWolf: Phantom of the opera.

[49:12] Jesse McAnally: Who who stars in that?

[49:13] Andrew DeWolf: Is that Lon Cheney?

[49:14] Jesse McAnally: Lon Cheney, yeah.

[49:16] Andrew DeWolf: But yeah, so your ranking is number one Phantom the American Musical, then Phantom of the Paradise, then the Andrew Lloyd Weber, then Robert England, and Phantom of the Auditorium, Phantom of the Opera Lon Cheney, Phantom of the Opera movie, then Phantom of the Mall, then Love Never Dies.

[49:30] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[49:30] Jesse McAnally: I am very curious as to where the others will rank as the month goes on.

[49:36] Andrew DeWolf: On that note, what is your overall thoughts on Phantom of the Paradise and your cheese rating?

[49:36] Jesse McAnally: Phantom of the Paradise slapped. It was sick. I really liked it. You know what, though? I'm gonna not give a shit and not give a fuck. And I'm gonna give it Guda Cheese. Not even because it's a gouda, but just because I actually really like that cheese, and that's what I want to give it.

[49:55] Andrew DeWolf: Fair enough.

[49:56] Jesse McAnally: Um you are allowed to have whatever you want.

[49:59] Andrew DeWolf: I I don't control you.

[50:01] Jesse McAnally: Um I love this movie. Um, and the only cheese ranking I can give it is Miles Cheddar from the specific Robinson Ranch Swan Brothers Dairy Cheese because Swan.

[50:14] Andrew DeWolf: On that note, you know who else definitely likes Swan Brothers cheese?

[50:17] Jesse McAnally: Uh don't even worry about it, because it's our wonderful patrons.

[50:20] Andrew DeWolf: Thank you guys for listening. Please follow us on iTunes, Spotify, Stitch Right Musicals for Cheese. Leave us a review. There's been a minute since we've gotten a new review. Um we'll read it on the podcast if you write it, Swan. Um, we're on Twitter at Cheesy Musicals, Patreon musicals, cheese, Instagram musicals cheese, YouTube page musicals of cheese, patron only podcast, Patreon with cheese, email us at musical theater lives at gmail.com.

[50:39] Jesse McAnally: Our keeper of the cheese is Juliet Antonio.

[50:41] Andrew DeWolf: Jesse, why don't you try to give Juliet some ASMR?

[50:44] Jesse McAnally: Do you just you just talk really quiet? Is that is this ASMR?

[50:48] Andrew DeWolf: Gotta waste burn.

[50:49] Jesse McAnally: I'm not really that good at this point.

[50:50] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, now I'm rock hard.

[50:51] Jesse McAnally: Um, our theme songs were created by Robin Asher IoU Music UK.

[50:55] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, thank you, the Broadway Podcast Network for having us on the platform for not kicking us off for swallow and stealing my music and framed me.

[51:02] Jesse McAnally: Alright, Andrew, anything else you have left to say?

[51:04] Andrew DeWolf: Go watch Phantom of the Paradise. It was sick.

[51:06] Jesse McAnally: It was sick.

[51:07] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and there's not any other movie like it.

[51:10] Jesse McAnally: And I mean that in a goodwell way.

[51:12] Andrew DeWolf: Hey, we'll see you next time, kids.

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred