Skip to main content
BPN Logo
#254 - Trouble in Tahiti

"Mornin' sun kisses the windows, kisses the walls Of the little white house..." Grab your marital strife and movie tickets because this week we're talking about the Bernstein opera "Trouble in Tahiti" Hosts: Jesse McAnally & Andrew DeWolf... Read More

From the show: Musicals with Cheese

1 h 1 min
7/20/23

Featured Shows

About

"Mornin' sun kisses the windows, kisses the walls Of the little white house..." Grab your marital strife and movie tickets because this week we're talking about the Bernstein opera "Trouble in Tahiti"

Credits:

Hosts: Jesse McAnally & Andrew DeWolf

Podcast Edited By: Andrew DeWolf

Theme Songs: Robyn Nash of IOU Music UK

Keeper of the Cheese: Juliet Antonio

This show is a part of the Broadway Podcast Network

Social Media:

Our WEBSITE

Musicals with Cheese on Twitter

Musicals W/ Cheese on Instagram

Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com

Merch!!

Jess Socials

Jesse McAnally on Twitter

Jess McAnally on Instagram

Andrew Socials

Andrew DeWolf on Instagram

Andrew DeWolf on Twitter

Use our Affiliate Link

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:05] Jesse McAnally: Hello, I'm Jesse McAnally.

[0:08] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm Andrew DeWolf.

[0:11] Jesse McAnally: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese.

[0:15] Jesse McAnally: A podcast where I try to get Andrew to like musical theater.

[0:21] Andrew DeWolf: And opera, apparently.

[0:23] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, we're doing opera today.

[0:25] Andrew DeWolf: It's been a minute.

[0:26] Jesse McAnally: Dude, everyone likes opera with cheese. They like it when we cover opera.

[0:30] Andrew DeWolf: Those do tend to be surprisingly popular episodes.

[0:33] Jesse McAnally: Um, I think I just underestimate the amount of people that love opera out here in the podcast sphere.

[0:39] Andrew DeWolf: You know what I think? I think nobody else covers opera.

[0:42] Jesse McAnally: Um, I don't disagree with you, but I also feel like when they do, they do it poorly.

[0:47] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm not saying we do it great, but we don't.

[0:50] Jesse McAnally: No.

[0:51] Andrew DeWolf: That is a full sentence. I'm not saying we do it great.

[0:55] Jesse McAnally: Um, but this is actually an opera musical theater piece that is very dear to my heart and has stuck with me for a while, so let's dive into it. Today we are talking about Leonard Bernstein's Trouble in Tahiti.

[1:09] Andrew DeWolf: Cue the music day.

[1:50] ♪ Musical number: "Trouble in Tahiti" — performed by Leonard Bernstein ♪

[2:03] Jesse McAnally: So Trouble in Tahiti is an opera written by Leonard Bernstein and with music and lyrics by Leonard Bernstein, the only piece of theater that he is both the writer, composer, and lyricist for. Um, even the sequel that he would later make, um, he commissioned out the script and book to be written by someone else. Um, the musical is based loosely, uh blah blah blah. The musical is not really based on anything, but fun fact, uh Leonard Bernstein did write it on his honeymoon.

[2:31] Andrew DeWolf: That's ironic.

[2:33] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, um, it's based on the relationship between Bernstein's own parents, uh, Sam and Jenny, but the wife's name was changed to be more singable, Dinah. I just find it fascinating that this is his The Fabelmans. Like his little Leonard Bernstein's The Fabelmans is much less impactful. It's just about them both missing a school play. The work is dedicated to Mark Blitzstein, and Blitzstein and Bernstein were good friends and both alumni of Curtis Institute in Philadelphia. Yeah, that's basically it. The problem is, this show has never been on Broadway or anything like that, and its first performance on June 12th, 1952, was at Bernstein's Festival of Creative Arts on the campus of Brandeis University at Waltham, uh Massachusetts, to an audience of nearly 3,000 people.

He wrote it to be basically at the end of the night to like just kind of wrap it all up, but everything went long, so this went up at around 11 p.m. and no one really wanted to be there at that point. So it was kind of a depressing thing. He would later revise it and make it better, and it was recorded for NBC's opera theater subsequently, and was aired on television in November of 1952. Basically a TV special. That was a trajectory back then. Um, the plot of Trouble in Tahiti is in 1950s suburbia, Sam and Dinah appear to have the perfect life in their white little house, but their growing detachment exposes a mutual feeling that they are trapped in a life that has turned into a lie.

[3:57] Jesse McAnally: So I threw this at you. This has been a back pocket kind of thing for me, where I know Andrew's gonna have a rough week, so here's something short that we can cover really quickly. What did you think of Trouble in Tahiti?

[4:05] Andrew DeWolf: Um honestly, I was I was impressed. I I kind of like it. I I actually thought it was more modern. I I mean I I go into these completely blind, I just watched it, you know. I thought it was maybe a more modern piece that was like criticizing fifties culture.

[4:23] Jesse McAnally: Um, but it turns out it was actually made in the fifties.

[4:27] Andrew DeWolf: Like if we made a culture about the 2020s right now. It's really interesting because a lot of the critiques that we have about the fifties are kind of present here.

[4:37] Jesse McAnally: Um like what specifically?

[4:39] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, we're in the Mad Men post like view of the fifties, so what are you thinking of?

[4:45] Jesse McAnally: I I would be thinking of the fact that like housewives were basically all like secretly depressed and horrible, uh lived horrible lives, I mean, um, and even though advertising and all that would portray it as oh, it's perfect living in suburbia and blah blah blah. It's like everyone was just depressed and drugged up and hated their lives. You know?

[5:08] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and it's it's interesting that something written in nineteen fifty-two kind of portrays exactly that in that way.

[5:16] Jesse McAnally: That is interesting. Um maybe if we're taking like the context into line that Leonard Bernstein wrote this about his own parents, maybe it's a critique on 1920s culture, and we're just stuck in an endless repeating like pattern of us. Like nothing has changed at all, and things just keep getting worse and worse, and all of the same problems persist because nothing ever changes.

[5:39] Andrew DeWolf: Are you are you saying something? Are you saying something here, Tucker Carlson?

[5:42] Jesse McAnally: I'm just I'm just saying that that might be the world we live in.

[5:46] Andrew DeWolf: Um I'm not saying anything. I'm just asking questions.

[5:49] Jesse McAnally: There we are. Um it is a fascinating critique, but I feel like it's more a critique on loveless marriages and absentee parents.

[5:59] Andrew DeWolf: Sure. They do open with a song about how perfect it is living in suburbia, though.

[6:03] Jesse McAnally: So it's hard to not see that as a critique in a way.

[6:06] Andrew DeWolf: I guess. Maybe it's just him trying to work in jazz. Some jazzy upbeat tunes.

[6:11] Jesse McAnally: I I don't know. It's like uh it's it's funny cutting from the like jazzy upbeat, uh what I perceive as like an advertising tune. Like this is an advertisement, and then we flash to the real world where they just are immediately bickering and miserable.

[6:28] Andrew DeWolf: I love this show so much because the intensity is always out of 10. Like, it's like a boy like that from West Side Story. Honestly, I think it's it's a type of show that I I've talked about that I don't really like very much, which is like the only thing that goes on is that the it's just a loveless marriage and they hate each other, and that's the whole show. But it being 50 minutes kind of like dang, they like you know, you get the idea and it's over. No show has wasted least less of my time than this, except maybe Dr. Horrible.

[7:02] Jesse McAnally: So when I say Leonard Bernstein, what does that name mean to you?

[7:05] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I feel like I I would mostly recognize him because I'm pretty sure he did the music to West Side Story, and he's not known for like writing libretto or even writing his own lyrics, and that's what sets this apart from most of his other work. I think it's both obviously his most personal work and the one that is most wholly his.

[7:25] Jesse McAnally: Well, I mean, it has to be in a way. I mean, he wrote everything. Uh what what do you think of the lyrics, actually?

[7:32] Andrew DeWolf: That's a that's an interesting question. Cause I found that there was some stuff that I was like, Jess is probably gonna be like this is weird.

[7:39] Jesse McAnally: It is very weird.

[7:41] Andrew DeWolf: But he had a very I part of me was thinking it was intentional. Um, because it's very common everyday language heightened to operatic standards of singing, which is I think the juxtaposition he was trying to go for, which is opera standard to petty bullshit.

[8:00] Jesse McAnally: Oh, yeah, because opera, like when you when you hear opera, like I mean, one people generally don't even imagine it in English, which isn't necessarily true. There's a lot of opera that is in English, but we don't think of that. You always think of like, oh, they're singing like Italian era, blah blah they're singing Italian and they're singing about like uh Greek gods or something.

[8:23] Andrew DeWolf: Um but here here it is where they're just singing literally singing advertising songs or talking about the plot of a movie. You know? Or like wondering, wait, did I have a thing for my secretary? Nah, let me check with her. Oh, I did? Oh no.

[8:42] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, like it's it's it's so interesting. Um I I wish how would you pitch this? Like, if you were to like walk up to someone on the street, like, should hey, I got tickets to Trouble in Tahiti, like performing. Uh, can you tell me what it's about? What should I expect?

[8:59] Andrew DeWolf: Um I mean, I think the the simplest thing is that they uh it's it's a couple that hate each other and it's set in the 50s, and really there's not a ton else to it. I mean, obviously there's a very simple plot line, which is just like the the wife uh thinks that the guy is cheating, the guy kind of is cheating, um, but the guy is not even sure if he's cheating.

[9:23] Jesse McAnally: It's weird.

[9:24] Andrew DeWolf: I'm not sure about that part. I'm not sure like how we're supposed to take that. Is this is it like he's covering his ass by pretending that he wasn't cheating, or isn't it that he was like getting accused of like having sexual overtones and he's like, No, that's just the way everyone is. I'm gonna call her to make sure. She's like, Yeah, you kinda have been. He's like, Wait, what?

[9:41] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, okay, okay. So so he he was sexually harassing somebody and is a man in the 50s, so he didn't realize it.

[9:49] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I didn't realize that was a not so kosher thing to do.

[9:52] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, we just he was just like, no, that's just how you act. You call everyone Toots and slap their butts.

[9:58] Andrew DeWolf: That's uh that's only okay on the football field. Um they have a son named Sam, though, that I feel like every like even they forget exist by the end of the show. He just kind of reappears at the end.

[10:10] Jesse McAnally: Uh but I mean that's a major plot point, is that they forget he exists, right? Because neither of them go to his play.

[10:19] Andrew DeWolf: Um yeah, I mean, they both go to a movie instead.

[10:25] Jesse McAnally: Um, which I think says more about Leonard Bernstein and where he felt that their opinion his parents' focus was. Um I I think it's uh very interesting that there's an entire like the name of the show is Trouble in Tahiti. Which is just I mean, it sounds like, oh, this is gonna be like uh Mary Kate and Ashley, like there's trouble on an uh paradise, right? Aloha little man. Problem in paradise.

[10:52] Andrew DeWolf: But uh I'm sorry. That is not the case.

[10:57] Jesse McAnally: Uh this is that is the name of a movie that is inside of this that they go and see, and uh I I don't know if these characters have names. They're Sam.

[11:08] Andrew DeWolf: Right.

[11:08] Jesse McAnally: Dinah goes to see this movie and just hates it, but she describes the entire plot in like a jazzy upbeat number. Uh so it's really fucking weird.

[11:19] Andrew DeWolf: Um can I tell a story of where the first time I encountered Trouble in Tahiti? Um and it's related back to this song, so it's not just me like I'm gonna go on a tangent in the middle of your sentence. Um, so I was hired along with three other videographers to record an entire um opera showcase um in Michigan.

[11:37] Jesse McAnally: And I don't know what's coming.

[11:39] Andrew DeWolf: Um so but we have to do set up all of our cameras and do sound checks during rehearsals, and it's just the mother character out here doing the song, and I'm just like, What the fuck is this? This is weird. I'm excited, and I it got me pumped, and then seeing it in context was even funnier. Because I'm like, how are we gonna lead to a lady doing a racist vocalization? It's so nonsense.

[12:05] Jesse McAnally: Um which yeah, there's that weird racist vocalization, but it's almost like it's like she's doing a thing from a movie within the show, so you don't even know how to feel about it.

[12:14] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, she is um more recent productions, they all have like title headers like Act One, blah blah blah blah. This one uh in a production I saw was scene seven, Mom sees a racist film. Which I mean, yes, yes. That is that is what happens. Uh we'll not deny that. Um something is so charming, and sincerely, I think this song, the I as it's a scene, but uh what a movie is its unofficial title, is one of the catchiest pieces of music I've ever heard. What since I first heard it, I can hum basically the entire melody from the start. It's so fucking bizarre. Because it's like literally the intro to the song is just her saying that she hates that she hates this movie, and then the entire rest of the song is her describing everything that happened in the movie in a really upbeat and like energetic way, and then it ends with her saying she hated the movie.

Like it's so specific. Like, um, there's a legend, if a princess marry white man and rainfall that day, then the white man shall be sacrificed without delay. Like okay, I've watched this show maybe three times in my life. I can hum that part perfectly. Um it is such a convincing, but it is very much describing a very white savior situation of a movie and criticizing it.

[13:35] Andrew DeWolf: It is a wildly racist premise for a movie. Like I the fact that the fact that they made it so that she is describing a movie and not just doing this, uh saved this show from being just horrendous. I I think it's aged better because honestly, yeah, because it's like now it's like, oh shit, they're they're critiquing this, even though honestly when they wrote it, I'm not even sure if they were. Uh maybe, maybe. I don't know. I I'm pretty sure he was. Like, considering he would go on to write West Side Story, I feel like he'd have to do that.

[14:06] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, a little bit, that's true. Right. Yeah, so he probably was critiquing it. Yeah, it's not like this guy is just like uh a some schlub doing weird mommy issues on stage.

[14:15] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, so but but it does feel even more relevant now because it's like we're looking back at a lot of these movies now and we're like, holy shit, like all of these movies are fucking racist as fuck. But this feels like such a modern take. Like this opera feels so modern to me, and seeing a production today just feels as relevant as it is back then because it's just simply about like a dissolution of a marriage and critiquing racism and it feels like a critique of the 50s despite being written contemporaneously to that time.

[14:48] Jesse McAnally: Well, again, again, just going back to what I was saying earlier, like if you had asked me, like without without like me knowing anything else, if you had asked me when this was written, I would have been like two years ago. Um let's talk about the idea of short musicals, like short music theater. We've always been big proponents of it. I think this is like one of the only big times that we can really bring it in. Like nothing else like this exists. I mean, this is under an hour. Like, we talk about shows that are like, oh, like an hour and a half, or like an hour is like very short. This is 50 minutes. Perfect. Maybe 45, depending on the performance.

[15:29] Andrew DeWolf: Like I sincerely think this entire show is as perfect as musical theater can be. They and I'm not saying there's no longer shows that I would rather watch or any other.

[15:39] Jesse McAnally: Oh, yeah, no, no, this is not like a top-tier show anyway.

[15:42] Andrew DeWolf: No, no, but this is but as far as like should we have more shows like this that are just this like kind of bite-sized, like perfect, like contained story, very simple, very pointed. Like it's it's a very clear satire, and you get the message from 50 minutes. You don't need to to waffle on about it for for two hours, you know? Like, it's it nails it, you know? And I I would love to see more stuff like this.

[16:10] Jesse McAnally: I would too, but I guess we do eventually um have to talk about the longer version of this.

[16:18] Andrew DeWolf: There's a longer version of this?

[16:19] Jesse McAnally: Yes, so Leonard Bernstein um ripped off John Krasinski and made a sequel called A Quiet Place.

[16:29] Andrew DeWolf: Did he rip him off in the past?

[16:31] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, he ripped him off in the past. They have to be very, very quiet. Um, and this one is everything that are the original one they were afraid it was gonna be, or it sounds like it would be, and critics lauded it as pretentious and terrible.

[16:47] Andrew DeWolf: Um so here's the premise of that.

[16:51] Jesse McAnally: And in more recent days, they will take the first half of a quiet place, then put the elongated flashback that is the entirety of trouble tahiti, then come back to a quiet place and form a three-act opera.

[17:03] Andrew DeWolf: That sounds like you're taking one of the best aspects of this show and removing it for no reason.

[17:12] Jesse McAnally: Um, yeah, so basically, it's about Dinah's funeral and you know, the father and son coming to blows at the mom's funeral, and it's a real bummer.

[17:23] Andrew DeWolf: That is a real bummer, and honestly, why would you of all the characters to kill off, why would you kill off Dinah?

[17:29] Jesse McAnally: Like, she was wasn't she kind of the most interesting character in Um I think it's just because he was instead of trying to make art, he was trying to go to therapy.

[17:40] Andrew DeWolf: Oh.

[17:40] Jesse McAnally: And she died in an alcohol-induced car crash.

[17:44] Andrew DeWolf: Drinking and driving, very nice.

[17:46] Jesse McAnally: Yes. Um it's just a a real mourning, like, oh my mom's dead kind of story.

[17:53] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I mean I'm not gonna say that trouble in Tahiti is like upbeat or anything. It's clearly not.

[17:58] Jesse McAnally: I mean, it's it is about a pretty uh depressing situation overall, and it doesn't exactly have a happy ending.

[18:06] Andrew DeWolf: But this is a like it's about the dad trying to reconcile with his adult children. It's big fish, it's uh everything we've seen, at least this is kind of a little bit more subtle with its abandonment of the child.

[18:17] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, and I I feel like we what do you gain by having it be about death and like that sort of thing?

[18:24] Andrew DeWolf: Um grieving and whatever. I mean, I'm not saying it's bad, I haven't seen it, because I I don't want to judge it beforehand, but it doesn't sound like the extension to this show that I would want to see.

[18:36] Jesse McAnally: The characters aren't in depthful enough where I really want to see an extension of their life. It feels like it feels more like this show is just a satire, like just a direct satire, to the point where I I feel like they did name the characters, but they don't even necessarily they didn't even need to really do that.

[18:52] Andrew DeWolf: Like it could have just been man, woman, like like 1950s man, 1950s woman, because it really just feels like a satire.

[19:00] Jesse McAnally: Yeah it doesn't feel like a story but which it's therapy for the artist.

[19:06] Andrew DeWolf: Which True, true. You know, but there's a there's a difference between what the artist wrote it for and how it is interpreted by everyone watching it.

[19:15] Jesse McAnally: And like, sure. He wrote it about his parents in the twenties, but uh me watching it, all I'm seeing is a satire of the nineteen fifties.

[19:25] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, it's like the Fablemans where Spielberg writes a scene at the end of Have you seen the Fablemans?

[19:31] Jesse McAnally: I haven't, but you can spoil it.

[19:33] Andrew DeWolf: I don't care.

[19:33] Jesse McAnally: Okay, okay. I just want I need to know that I'm not the only one that feels this way.

[19:40] Andrew DeWolf: So the film ends with him like the Spielberg goes and brings his camera to Senior Skip Day and films everyone, and then he screams it at Prom for some reason, and he apparently followed his bully around shirtless at the beach and made it look like an action hero, and he's shirtless at the beach.

[19:59] Jesse McAnally: So I think the film wants to be like, oh, he uses cinema so effectively he made the bully look like a hero because of the magic of cinema.

[20:06] Andrew DeWolf: But I'm reading as you're in love with your bully.

[20:09] Jesse McAnally: And yeah, there's a lot of other things like the bully is anti-Semitic, and there's a lot more complex issues going on there.

[20:15] Andrew DeWolf: But you just show me a video of him following him around shirtless at the beach and just

[20:15] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, and then the bully crying in the hallway at him saying, Why'd you make me look so good?

[20:26] Andrew DeWolf: He's like, I don't know.

[20:26] Jesse McAnally: I I honestly I've seen that scene, and I I couldn't I couldn't figure out what the hell they were trying to do with it.

[20:33] Andrew DeWolf: Um and I was like, maybe if I see the whole movie it will make sense, but you just kind of explained explained it and I feel like it doesn't really.

[20:40] Jesse McAnally: It's a it's a weird movie.

[20:41] Andrew DeWolf: Um I have problems, big problems with the Fablemans, but I don't have those problems with trouble and Tahiti because it is less self-grandizing.

[20:49] Jesse McAnally: I I'm so glad that the child character is not a character in this.

[20:53] Andrew DeWolf: And I think the problem with a quiet place, even of Quiet Place Part 2, is that the children are at the forefront of that story.

[21:02] Jesse McAnally: God damn.

[21:04] Andrew DeWolf: What the quiet place part two.

[21:09] Jesse McAnally: You know, pro a quiet place part two, trouble D.

[21:13] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, okay.

[21:15] Jesse McAnally: Um.

[21:16] Andrew DeWolf: So, um, one of my favorite pet aspects of this is the Greek chorus, like singing chorus. I think they are like the glue that holds this together and makes this a full piece rather than just a a solo of Arya's bunch varia.

[21:32] Jesse McAnally: I I really like their implementation. And again, this is my personal interpretation, but every time I see them, I'm like, there this is like the characters seeing listening to the radio or something.

[21:45] Andrew DeWolf: Like this is because what like one of their main songs is that they're literally advertising the suburbs that the house is in, or whatever.

[21:54] Jesse McAnally: Like they're singing about how nice this house is in the suburbs. Uh, and then of course, when we go inside the house, the first thing we see is that they hate each other and everyone is miserable.

[22:03] Andrew DeWolf: Um, so it really does it it feels like the um Greek chorus is supposed to be like a uh juxtaposition in a way with the actual uh main characters.

[22:17] Jesse McAnally: I don't I don't quite see it that way.

[22:19] Andrew DeWolf: I think they're just the society reflecting the main characters.

[22:23] Jesse McAnally: You think they keep keep setting them up as the perfect family, the perfect well like they are society setting them up as what they world sees them as, and we're seeing what they really are.

[22:34] Andrew DeWolf: Maybe that's more what I was trying to say on because I do agree with that.

[22:37] Jesse McAnally: Um because I think what's the frustrating about Bernstein in this is that he is seen by the outside as having this perfect life, and then he sees the strife on the inside and the intricacies and the what what sucks.

[22:50] Andrew DeWolf: Um so you brought up lyrics.

[22:53] Jesse McAnally: They're rough.

[22:54] Andrew DeWolf: They can be, yeah.

[22:56] Jesse McAnally: Um there was a portion of the opening number that I was pretty sure they were just speaking gibberish.

[23:01] Andrew DeWolf: La da dot dot.

[23:03] Jesse McAnally: Is that is that am I right about that? Or was it right? Was I having a stroke at the time?

[23:09] Andrew DeWolf: And I know you like scatting.

[23:11] Jesse McAnally: I thought it was interesting, but I was like, what are they doing?

[23:14] Andrew DeWolf: Like it I was half expecting it to be like an experimental piece.

[23:17] Jesse McAnally: Like this is an opera where they're like, it's like a a play on music theater, like, but imagine if there was no lyrics and it just you just got the vibes.

[23:28] Andrew DeWolf: Like it was just like we did a sim ish.

[23:32] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, like like literally, that's what I was like. I was like, are they doing that for like and then it uh they just go back to English, of course.

[23:38] Andrew DeWolf: But it be motivated, skiddly data abominate.

[23:51] Jesse McAnally: But I was like, what the hell's happening?

[23:54] Andrew DeWolf: So if we were to try to what would it be like if we were trying to make our own trouble in Tahiti about the 2020s?

[24:02] Jesse McAnally: Replace the like 1950s advertising style uh songs with uh TikTok uh type songs.

[24:11] Andrew DeWolf: Ukulele apologies, you ukulele apology uh songs.

[24:15] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like the 1950s, like, uh, you know, atomic family nuclear family.

[24:15] Jesse McAnally: Nuclear family.

[24:23] Andrew DeWolf: Um, the 1950s nuclear family, that has been sort of replaced for us with this like hustle hustle culture kind of thing. You know what I'm saying? I love the way your brain works, Andrew. Because we like we no longer have this idea of like the American dream is we're gonna start a family in the suburbs with a white picket fence and a lot of yeah because now we like gay people do that and now it's ruined it for white people so now the American dream is you work uh you know twenty five hours a day every day of your life and eventually you're Elon Musk.

[24:36] Jesse McAnally: Oh my god yours is so much worse than mine I'd much rather be dead than Elon Musk.

[24:36] Andrew DeWolf: Well the thing is people that buy into hustle culture do want to be Elon Musk like so I think but I don't know I feel like that's just capitalism grinding us to the bone and demanding nuclear family was though like the nuclear family was an invention by uh by advertising agencies to put on billboards you know like that that wasn't a real thing uh and and I think that this this show is kind of saying that so it would be about a couple one of them overworks himself at Wall Street while what would the the spouse or friend character be sadly I think if you did a 21st century or a 20 uh yeah 21st century century yeah if you did a 21st century version of this there wouldn't be a couple because they would both be working but there'd somehow be a kid we're still procreating somehow that's the other thing are we should we should we is a is a great question.

[26:06] Jesse McAnally: Let's talk about the ethics of having children when there's a global climate crisis that is about to destroy fucking everything.

[26:14] Andrew DeWolf: Oh buckle your seatbelts, bitches.

[26:16] Jesse McAnally: Andrew's got opinions.

[26:20] Andrew DeWolf: You thought we were just talking musical theater?

[26:22] Jesse McAnally: Hell no, we're taking a dive into politics town. Look, we're talking about trouble in Tahiti, okay? This show has things to say.

[26:27] Andrew DeWolf: And it does nothing to do with what I just said.

[26:33] Jesse McAnally: I mean, I think Leonard Bernstein would agree with you. Um, that maybe we shouldn't procreate if we are gonna be shitty people. That is kind of what this show is about. And all Sam wanted, it meant the world to him that they saw his play, and neither of them saw the play. Neither of them fucking went. That is the subtext. The authorial intent is mommy and daddy didn't see my play.

[26:57] Andrew DeWolf: Daddy wasn't there.

[26:59] Jesse McAnally: It's worse than that, isn't it? Not only did the mother not go to see the play, she went to see a horrible movie that she hated.

[27:06] Andrew DeWolf: Twice.

[27:07] Jesse McAnally: She would rather go see a movie that she hates two times than go see.

[27:13] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, the modern one.

[27:15] Jesse McAnally: The modern one. She had to see the flash.

[27:20] Andrew DeWolf: And there's a Batman, and he helps them save the day, but then there's suddenly uh another Batman from a different universe that comes.

[27:29] Jesse McAnally: So the Flash has to run and a run, and he's running.

[27:35] Andrew DeWolf: Trouble in the multiverse.

[27:42] Jesse McAnally: I just okay. Well, now we gotta make trouble in the multiverse. Um, we have to do the modern trouble D. I mean, I feel like we have some good ideas already here. I think I mean we we've come up with some stuff here. If you want to know a film that is like the antithesis to everything of art and a representation of hustle culture before uh thinking, it's the Flash movie.

[28:06] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I have not paid to see it, but I did um Yo ho um some some most of the film. And yikes. That film is literal gibberish uh I saw the trailers and that was enough for me um I was like I've seen enough I don't want to see any more you made the right call it might be the worst film I've ever seen since joker 2019 I've gotta say I like I know that there's like one or two exceptions but dc really just pumps out trash doesn't it I mean the exceptions are the ones that are taking over like I really like the suicide squad the second one though not the first one because the first one was was garbage yes that that was incomprehensible it was barely a movie it might as well be a tick tock you realize that not only will DC continue to pump out garbage but it's going to get worse because now there are no writers and no actors let's talk about the strike for a minute I know I know that it's trouble and Tahiti time but the the day we're recording this the screen actors guild just announced that they are going on strike alongside the writers guild what a fucking nightmare this isn't I I retweeted this but just a context that I know Andrew is gonna love so much.

[29:33] Jesse McAnally: Do you know the last time this happened?

[29:35] Andrew DeWolf: Oh god I think I saw something but I just go ahead I I don't remember um the last time both the SAG and WGA were on strike um not only was Eisenhower still president, but the actors union was led by noted organizer and socialist Ronald Reagan.

[29:57] Jesse McAnally: Ronald Reagan went on strike?

[29:59] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, he was like known for his socialist beliefs and led the union into the strike.

[30:04] Jesse McAnally: He was doing the Fran Dresher thing.

[30:06] Andrew DeWolf: Damn, he really did get brain damage somewhere along the way.

[30:09] Jesse McAnally: Um yeah, whatever happened to that guy.

[30:11] Andrew DeWolf: What happened?

[30:13] Jesse McAnally: I think the red scare happened, and then he turned in a lot of friends. And on that note, how about we go into a mid-show?

[30:30] Andrew DeWolf: Um, sorry to interrupt you, but we've got a shill at you. Today's show is brought to you by the extremely kind donations by our donors over at Patreon. Patreon's this beautiful place where you can get um a lot of cool stuff, including Patreon meetups. Hopefully we're gonna be doing one uh a little bit this week, um, this month. Um, as well as a lot of other cool stuff. Our current patrons are Melissa Goldman, Danielle Rennex, Jessica Stampede, Ewan Cassidy, Monica Thoreau, Brent Black, Fanial Stacey Coomb, Joseph Evans Green, Mary Lou Choquet, John Van Alz, Russ Walker, Musical Hell, Emily Gracie, Kyle Summers, Janae C, Scoot the Technicolor Dream Code, Liz Lim, nothing is certain except Beth and Taxes, Vesbian, Jessica T, Mitchell Young, Chai Teacup, Katie McDonough, Chris Marcote, KG Marie Anastasio, Layla, RJ Norija, Bjorn Herman, Toriana Fraser, Sammy The Adequate Amount Jacobson, Lyanna Morton, Hayley Blazier, Cinemagin Reviews, Villainous Mist, Sor Sofiana Ali, The Omega Geek, Paige Pearson, Matty Worgle, Alisa Erdman, Analoscatova, Sarah Den Bleckier, Evan Ball, Zachary Torres, Rora Morasso, Mara Fourloyne, Captain Rodastic, Lisa L, Possessed Washing Machine, Renee Thomas, Nick Roden, Puffy Boy, Summer, Julia Hardy, Jay Cusia, Caitlin Bridgman, uh, Sidney Hicks, and Beale and Billy Clifton. They all give us a little extra finance support that helps us keep the lights on your musicals or cheese. Come join them. Be cool like them. I'll love you slightly more.

[31:56] Jesse McAnally: Alright. Anything.

[31:57] Andrew DeWolf: Oh yeah, Monica Thoreau, our hundred dollar patron. Um wants to remind you to please get your eyes checked and don't go to sleep with your contacts in. That is uh what she wants us to say every week. Andrew, uh any opinions on that?

[32:10] Andrew DeWolf: Do you do you ever wear eyeglasses?

[32:12] Jesse McAnally: No, I don't. But I hear that you do, and you often fall asleep with your contacts in.

[32:16] Andrew DeWolf: I've never fallen asleep with my contacts in.

[32:18] Jesse McAnally: You you told me that you can't get them out sometimes.

[32:21] Andrew DeWolf: That is different. Um they get stuck in the inside of my eye, and then I have to like wash it out with like an actual like water hose in my shower. It eventually comes out. Um, contacts are a son of a bitch.

[32:35] Jesse McAnally: Okay. Let's get back to the show.

[32:43] Andrew DeWolf: I really, really enjoy the the we already brought up the jazzy prelude, but every time they come in, it both feels like a classic musical theater as opposed to opera. Lovely day, lovely life, the middle, sweet little son, friend, living picture, second. It's a wonderful light.

[33:14] Jesse McAnally: There's a couple songs that do feel very much more music theater than opera.

[33:19] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[33:20] Jesse McAnally: But the s the stuff that connects them is what makes it really the whole show feels like an opera.

[33:26] Andrew DeWolf: More so, though.

[33:27] Jesse McAnally: Mm-hmm. And I I just like I feel like he's still working within his musical theater tricks. And I know music like musical theater was barely a genre at this point. Um it is Yeah, 1950, like what what's out at this point? Like let's take a look.

[33:43] Andrew DeWolf: 1952 Tony Awards. Was that even a thing?

[33:46] Jesse McAnally: I don't know. See, this period, um, it is the sixth Tony Awards that year.

[33:52] Andrew DeWolf: Sixth.

[33:53] Jesse McAnally: Oh my goodness. Um, let's see. What was it? The King and I was the big musical that year.

[33:59] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[34:00] Jesse McAnally: So it existed. Like, yeah, musicals were still pretty pretty new, but doing alright.

[34:05] Andrew DeWolf: Wow.

[34:06] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, the King and I was the big one that year. Um, yeah, this didn't get no love. Um, and uh I am a camera. The sh the play that Cabaret would be based on um was being nominated for uh Tony's that year.

[34:20] Andrew DeWolf: Look at that.

[34:21] Jesse McAnally: Um little peek into the future.

[34:23] Andrew DeWolf: A little peek into the future. Um but yeah, so musical theater was a brand new genre, and he's using those tricks through opera. Um, where the operatic piece is is the most mundane shit in the world. Like, are you going to Sammy's play? I'll try. Wait, no, I can't, I have to go to the gym, you and that gym. Things it's almost like things are flipped in a way.

[34:41] Jesse McAnally: Like the uh like the mundane stuff that probably should have been more music theater y is like opera, and then the the stuff that's more like um bigger, like more uh epic in a way.

[34:53] Andrew DeWolf: More stylized even.

[34:55] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, like cause because like uh I would say the song where she describes the plot of the movie is kind of music theater y.

[35:01] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[35:01] Jesse McAnally: Um, and that one is, you know, about this like grand adventure, which is something that you usually hear as an opera, like, cause those are usually about like gods and and myths and things. So But then when we get into just like, oh my secretary.

[35:17] Andrew DeWolf: It's like it's imagine the intensity of a boy like that from West Side Story with the stakes of just the opening scenes of West Side Story where it's just the brother and sister talking.

[35:30] Jesse McAnally: Oh, Mr. Partridge.

[35:34] Andrew DeWolf: I'm perfectly fine, thank you.

[35:38] Jesse McAnally: She's well.

[35:41] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, exactly what I want to speak to you about.

[35:45] Jesse McAnally: With things as they are, I cannot see how you could ask me again.

[35:49] Andrew DeWolf: Ah, Mr. Partridge.

[35:53] Jesse McAnally: Yes, I know all that.

[35:57] Andrew DeWolf: You've already said that.

[36:00] Jesse McAnally: Oh, but that's just why I have to refuse you.

[36:03] Andrew DeWolf: No.

[36:05] Jesse McAnally: No.

[36:07] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, I was sure you would finally see it my way.

[36:15] Jesse McAnally: No trouble at all. I mean, the stake is the stakes are literally just.

[36:21] Andrew DeWolf: Did I do something creepy?

[36:23] Jesse McAnally: Uh, it's like a meeting with HR.

[36:29] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and your wife saw a movie. Those are the stakes.

[36:33] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[36:35] Andrew DeWolf: Um, so and here's the thing: all the songs kind of blur together for me.

[36:40] Jesse McAnally: Like, aside from the movie one, which feels like a very distinct scene, all the rest of them kind of flow into each other.

[36:47] Andrew DeWolf: Well, it's kind of like an opera in that way where it is just kind of sung through and everything kind of flows together except for there are these moments of real song.

[37:00] Jesse McAnally: But the interesting thing about it though is that the moments of song are, most of them, except for "What a Movie," I would say are done by the chorus, you know?

[37:00] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Um, did you feel any pathos or emotional connection to these two? Like when they're singing their hearts out, it's not about like what they want or their regrets really, it's just about... I mean, I felt that they both hated each other and that was about all I got from them.

[37:30] Jesse McAnally: Like I didn't feel sad for either of them really or anything like that. It was more just like, goddamn, they hate each other. But along with a lot of musicals that are about broken families, "Next to Normal," "Fun Home," um, to a certain extent, "Kimberly Akimbo," this feels entertaining. Like I know it's like cra... but this feels very much trying to entertain us and never loses that.

[37:58] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I think a big part of it is the fact that they have these upbeat music theater numbers that come back in that are not really about the same stuff, you know?

[37:58] Jesse McAnally: Um, I got a question for you.

[37:58] Andrew DeWolf: What's that?

[37:58] Jesse McAnally: If you had to cast this musical with internet celebrities, who would you put in the two roles?

[37:58] Andrew DeWolf: Um, Doug Walker as the man and, uh, Colleen... what's her name?

[37:58] Jesse McAnally: That's not a real answer, but I'm still gonna go with it.

[38:38] Andrew DeWolf: No, we're sticking with that.

[38:39] Jesse McAnally: Um, we're gonna turn "What a Movie" into a ukulele song.

[38:45] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, and they both have to apologize by the end.

[39:10] Jesse McAnally: Isn't it time that we had a talk?

[39:15] Andrew DeWolf: A talk about art.

[39:20] Jesse McAnally: Whatever you say.

[39:23] Andrew DeWolf: Where to begin?

[39:31] Jesse McAnally: Uh, and this is me interpolating Larry Bernstein. Had a weird past and a weird relationship with both men and women.

[39:39] Andrew DeWolf: Um, he is in musical theater, he is very much a theatrical guy, but he's also a bit often hard to work with.

[39:48] Jesse McAnally: Um, and I feel like everything that he represents, his father as going to the gym, having a real normal nine to five, schmoozing with ladies, that that was not him.

[39:58] Andrew DeWolf: So it's more like in critiquing his own father, he is critiquing manhood in general.

[40:04] Jesse McAnally: And I think that's a lot of it. I'm thinking of it as a personal connection to the writer to this one thing, which also says something about society's representations of this one thing as a whole.

[40:15] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, a lot of this in it, a lot of what we've been saying, I think, is that this is almost just an accidental perfect satire.

[40:25] Jesse McAnally: Like, you know?

[40:26] Andrew DeWolf: Like he didn't mean it to be, and he didn't write it to be one, but it kind of just is.

[40:33] Jesse McAnally: Or maybe just all good work is also commenting on the society around it, whether it's intended to or not.

[40:39] Andrew DeWolf: This isn't just commenting, though. This is like direct critique of like very particular elements.

[40:46] Jesse McAnally: You know?

[40:47] Andrew DeWolf: Like, from the start, you're directly critiquing the nuclear family life in suburbia.

[40:53] Jesse McAnally: Um, saying like, oh, it's perfect, it's perfect, like all of our billboards and our advertisements say, and then immediate like undercutting of that, no, it's not, they hate each other.

[41:02] Andrew DeWolf: And then you have like songs about very particular parts of it, like being a housewife sucks ass, being a man has all of these rules that we have to follow.

[41:13] Jesse McAnally: Um, racist movies exist.

[41:17] Andrew DeWolf: And that's our escape.

[41:18] Jesse McAnally: Our escape from this is into these racist movies, because that's all we've got.

[41:23] Andrew DeWolf: She sees him handsome, uh, I must say he's pretty hot, man.

[41:29] Jesse McAnally: Six feet tall, and it's more just incredible.

[41:32] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, the man in love, but the struggle, there's a letter.

[41:50] Jesse McAnally: Idle wave surrounds.

[41:52] Andrew DeWolf: That's horrible.

[42:05] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, so it feels like less... it feels like less of just, well, all art comments on society and more like direct satire of very particular things with examples, you know?

[42:18] Andrew DeWolf: Like, uh, I don't know.

[42:20] Jesse McAnally: That's it. It really feels like he accidentally made like a very sharp satire to me.

[42:25] Andrew DeWolf: You know the closest that, as far as I'm concerned, of dealing with an actual one-to-one of parents to individual, "A Strange Loop."

[42:34] Jesse McAnally: This feels very much akin to "A Strange Loop" in how him critiquing his own familial relationships critiques the society around it as a whole.

[42:43] Andrew DeWolf: It's true, which... and he also comments on like the media that they consume with Tyler Perry, like representing very...

[42:52] Jesse McAnally: You're actually kind of dead on.

[42:54] Andrew DeWolf: This actually, you're kind of dead on.

[42:57] Jesse McAnally: Is this like the template for "A Strange Loop"?

[43:01] Andrew DeWolf: Like "A Strange Loop" is incredible, and I think it's probably better than this and more relevant today.

[43:07] Jesse McAnally: But is this like the 1950s "A Strange Loop" somehow?

[43:12] Andrew DeWolf: I think that is the way we should sell this if we're like hired to produce a new production of "Trouble in Tahiti."

[43:18] Jesse McAnally: We promote it as the original "Strange Loop."

[43:22] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like it's sort of offensive to do that.

[43:24] Jesse McAnally: No, it's a hundred percent offensive to do that.

[43:27] Andrew DeWolf: But I think like genre-wise, now that I'm thinking about it, like they are kind of like in the same place in a way.

[43:34] Jesse McAnally: The only thing that "A Strange Loop" tackles that this doesn't really tackle, mostly because I feel like he would be afraid to just for the cultural standards, is the sexuality and all that that I know Leonard Bernstein was going through and dealing with at the time.

[43:48] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I think that the time period like just prevents him from doing that entirely, though.

[43:53] Jesse McAnally: I don't think this one could get aired on like television, which it did, if he had done that, obviously.

[44:00] Andrew DeWolf: But is there some sexual subtext in this?

[44:03] Jesse McAnally: Like I would almost argue that the complete lack of sexual subtext is sexual subtext in the sense of a satire of the 1950s, like where is the sex?

[44:16] Andrew DeWolf: We don't talk about it.

[44:18] Jesse McAnally: Well, it depends on which 1950s media we're embracing, because like "Mad Men," it's everyone's fucking.

[44:18] Andrew DeWolf: James Bond, like one of the most iconic mid-20th century pieces of media is all about sex.

[44:32] Jesse McAnally: True, true.

[44:33] Andrew DeWolf: But when we talk about like what it means to be like the American dream, like family, it... there it's all like completely and literally whitewashed, you know?

[44:47] Jesse McAnally: It's interesting.

[44:48] Andrew DeWolf: That is to say, though, this does not have any like sexual subtext outside of just the HR meeting that he goes to.

[44:56] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[44:56] Andrew DeWolf: That he sets up for himself.

[45:01] Jesse McAnally: Imagine you getting a, like, I need to go see HR, just puts on a different hat.

[45:06] Andrew DeWolf: You can't be doing that.

[45:08] Jesse McAnally: Okay.

[45:09] Andrew DeWolf: Did I do something fucked up?

[45:11] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, you did.

[45:12] Andrew DeWolf: I, uh, no, no way.

[45:14] Jesse McAnally: No, no, I did.

[45:17] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, shucks.

[45:20] Jesse McAnally: I'm fired.

[45:23] Andrew DeWolf: Ah, you're rehired, we forgive you.

[45:27] Jesse McAnally: Oh my goodness.

[45:28] Andrew DeWolf: Um, so actual question.

[45:31] Jesse McAnally: I asked you a joke question the first time.

[45:33] Andrew DeWolf: Unlimited money. Who would you cast in these roles if you were given like a chance to do this production with the assumption they can sing it?

[45:41] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, I mean, them being able to sing it is huge because like not many people are gonna be able to sing those high parts.

[45:49] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, or really the low parts either.

[45:52] Jesse McAnally: Um, you know, I'm terrible with actors.

[45:55] Andrew DeWolf: I really don't know who I would cast.

[45:57] Jesse McAnally: This is more of a you question, really.

[45:59] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[46:00] Jesse McAnally: Um, I mean, do you have like a casting ready?

[46:03] Andrew DeWolf: I would probably, like, the easy answer would be Josh Groban, because you know...

[46:07] Jesse McAnally: Josh Groban, I think would do a fine job.

[46:10] Andrew DeWolf: I don't think it's really something he would do though.

[46:12] Jesse McAnally: No.

[46:12] Andrew DeWolf: Although then again, he's in "Sweeney Todd" right now, so maybe he's wanting to break out of that mold a little bit.

[46:17] Jesse McAnally: You know what? I'd do Norm Lewis, maybe.

[46:20] Andrew DeWolf: I think he'd be a good choice, a little different, and I'd probably try to update it.

[46:24] Jesse McAnally: So what would be the modern family?

[46:27] Andrew DeWolf: Because I know we got the setting of 1952, but what would be the modern version of this?

[46:32] Jesse McAnally: Um, so maybe, maybe Roger McDonald, just because I like hearing her sing, and I feel like those two look good together.

[46:39] Andrew DeWolf: Um, yeah, that'd be interesting.

[46:41] Jesse McAnally: Just vocally, I want this now.

[46:43] Andrew DeWolf: I think that there's a lot of potential in this.

[46:45] Jesse McAnally: I do hope it's still being performed.

[46:47] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I feel like the version you sent to me was a bit of a newer one, so...

[46:47] Jesse McAnally: Yes, that was. That was, I believe, the National Theater production.

[46:55] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[46:56] Jesse McAnally: I don't have issues with more modern productions, but I feel like when they're trying to make it too modern, like I feel like this doesn't need a set.

[47:04] Andrew DeWolf: I, I'm not like opposed to having like small amounts of sets, but it really doesn't need much.

[47:10] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, I feel like this is a good pairing with like a 90-minute musical just to kind of give a little bit of an extra bit of fun at the end.

[47:18] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like this is a good like appetizer or dessert for an evening.

[47:23] Jesse McAnally: I don't think it's a full evening in and of itself.

[47:25] Andrew DeWolf: Wait, the way I saw it, it was like paired with a Gershwin concert as well.

[47:29] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, I think that that would be great and would be well worth the money.

[47:33] Andrew DeWolf: Because obviously the part of the reason these type of shows don't get put on is because no one's gonna pay a hundred and fifty dollars to go see fifty minutes of a show when you could pay the same amount to go see two hours.

[47:47] Jesse McAnally: But it's impressive.

[47:49] Andrew DeWolf: Like most of this is more vocally impressive than a lot of the shows on Broadway.

[47:53] Jesse McAnally: Of course, but that's a lot of opera, isn't it?

[47:55] Andrew DeWolf: Like opera is more about showing off the vocalists.

[47:58] Jesse McAnally: And you know the orchestrations, like this is, you kind of need a big band to be able to pull this off.

[48:03] Andrew DeWolf: But this is such an interesting opera and so different from what you would usually see in that space.

[48:10] Jesse McAnally: Like what other operas we've covered with like "Pirates of Penzance" and "The Magic Flute."

[48:14] Andrew DeWolf: It's not really the same category.

[48:16] Jesse McAnally: It really isn't. Like "Pirates of Penzance" is probably the closest, but that's just because that's almost like a proto musical, whereas this is actually more of like a true opera that just has like a couple musical theater numbers thrown into it in a way.

[48:33] Andrew DeWolf: What is your overall thoughts on Trouble in Tahiti and your cheese rating? I mean I was very positive here and I did really enjoy it. Of course it was it was uh on the short side so you know I I like that type of thing. It's a satisfying chode yeah it's short but fat and dense. There you yeah what what he said. Uh no I it's it's very good. I'm not saying it's it's perfect or anything, but like for what it is, it's good. And and honestly, the fact that it was made in the 50s is impressive to me. It's like it's so uh prescient, I suppose, uh is the word. Like they knew like he somehow maybe he didn't know, but he somehow perfectly uh encapsulated a lot of the ideas that we still hold about that era now. Um back in this is early 50s, this was before it even the whole thing had happened, you know. This is 52.

[49:31] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, this is it might as well be the 40s. Yeah, like in he he pretty much perfectly uh encapsulates everything that we think about that now in in this show. So very good. Uh I I really enjoyed it. Um as far as a cheese rating, you gotta give it like a because you because you said short and fat, uh, I have to give it something like that, right? So give it a cheese wheel.

[50:01] Jesse McAnally: Oh yeah, cheese wheel would be good.

[50:03] Andrew DeWolf: Those are short and they're fat.

[50:05] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, yeah.

[50:06] Andrew DeWolf: We'll give it a cheese wheel. I don't know what type of cheese. I'm gonna go with uh I'm gonna go with mozzarella just because it's a classic. I don't know if they even make cheese wheels for mozzarella, but we're gonna pretend they do, and if they don't, fuck it, I give it it anyways.

[50:20] Jesse McAnally: Um, you know what? That's fair enough. I also really really love um this show. This show I have a very big soft spot for. Um I I can't even describe why I do. Um it's just very specific, and I think the score, we didn't really harp on this, is gorgeous. Like, it is one of the more beautiful, more epic sounding, more big scores out there for such a short number of.

[50:44] Andrew DeWolf: Of course, it has a full orchestra behind it, so it's kind of yeah.

[50:48] Jesse McAnally: It's like it's cheating in a way, but like imagine just a ukulele and a couple like instruments, it would not work as well at all. Um, but I'm gonna give this Dinah's cheese from Kurtwood Farms in Seattle.

[51:03] Andrew DeWolf: Um, because Dinah is the name of the mother, and she dies in A Quiet Place Part Two.

[51:12] Jesse McAnally: Trouble in Tahiti Part 2, A Quiet Place Part Two, starring Killian Murphy.

[51:17] Andrew DeWolf: Jesus Christ. I can't believe he called it A Quiet Place.

[51:22] Jesse McAnally: About his mom's death and having to reconnect with his dad, Sam, who might have been fucking the secretary.

[51:28] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[51:29] Jesse McAnally: Um maybe we'll talk about that in full some at some point.

[51:33] Andrew DeWolf: Maybe, but I just don't have particular interest.

[51:35] Jesse McAnally: I don't really want to ruin this perfect thing to me.

[51:38] Andrew DeWolf: It's true.

[51:39] Jesse McAnally: It's true.

[51:39] Andrew DeWolf: Like, this is such a good, like, and I feel like especially if we watched it where it's sandwiched, like that would totally ruin it.

[51:46] Jesse McAnally: Like a worse musical at the start and then an even worse musical at the end.

[51:50] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, and it's just like, here's the thing you liked sandwiched between two pieces of crap.

[51:56] Jesse McAnally: Is there any other movie that's like that?

[51:58] Andrew DeWolf: Uh Silent Night, Deadly Night 2.

[52:02] Jesse McAnally: Garbage Day No!

[52:06] Andrew DeWolf: You're right.

[52:07] Jesse McAnally: You're right.

[52:08] Andrew DeWolf: That is such a good fucking poll.

[52:11] Jesse McAnally: My brain was telling me things like Hook, where I think the beginning is fantastic and the end is fantastic, but it's got so much dog shit in the middle.

[52:19] Andrew DeWolf: No, I mine is perfect.

[52:21] Jesse McAnally: I nailed it.

[52:22] Andrew DeWolf: You're you nailed it.

[52:23] Jesse McAnally: That exam my god.

[52:25] Andrew DeWolf: Um Deadly Night is a really unsettling film, too.

[52:29] Jesse McAnally: It's actually pretty decent.

[52:31] Andrew DeWolf: Like it really, it really isn't a bad movie.

[52:33] Jesse McAnally: But then it got memed to death because of Garbage Day.

[52:36] Andrew DeWolf: Well, that's the second one, though.

[52:37] Jesse McAnally: But that's the thing.

[52:38] Andrew DeWolf: The second one ruined it.

[52:39] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[52:39] Andrew DeWolf: It legitimately it's it's a good one.

[52:41] Jesse McAnally: It was the Quiet Place of horror movies.

[52:44] Andrew DeWolf: It literally sandwiched like a pretty o like it's not like amazing. It's like a pretty okay movie between two pieces of shit.

[52:53] Jesse McAnally: Um is there any sequels to horror films that you think are really as good as the original?

[52:59] Andrew DeWolf: Well, I mean, yeah. If you're counting slasher movies, I would definitely say yeah. Because I mean a lot of those, like Friday the 13th is pretty shitty, right?

[53:09] Jesse McAnally: Like it doesn't really even get good until like the fourth one.

[53:12] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, I think the twist of the first one is enough to make that film good for me. I d I like the first one a lot, but it is it's rough.

[53:22] Jesse McAnally: Uh but Kevin Bacon.

[53:24] Andrew DeWolf: Kevin Bacon does make it though.

[53:26] Jesse McAnally: I'm actually a fan of the second one too, because uh they kill that little dog muffin.

[53:30] Andrew DeWolf: Um I I remember a thousand years ago, this is a true story. Andrew made the mask from the second Friday the 13th movie, and he sent me videos of him dancing to Just Dance in the Fresh.

[53:42] Jesse McAnally: I wish I could find the Jason. Do you still have those?

[53:46] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know, but I know that you sent that to me.

[53:49] Jesse McAnally: I I thought those were fucking funny as hell, and I wish I still had them.

[53:53] Andrew DeWolf: I just think about that. Whenever I think about young Andrew, I think of him dressed as Jason from the second Friday or Friday the 13th.

[54:04] Jesse McAnally: Which is honestly still my favorite Jason.

[54:06] Andrew DeWolf: That's that's how he should be.

[54:08] Jesse McAnally: You don't like Jason X while he when he's in space?

[54:10] Andrew DeWolf: Dude, that one sucks ass.

[54:15] Jesse McAnally: You don't like the one where it's not really Jason, but like some mortician guy?

[54:20] Andrew DeWolf: I haven't seen that one, but I cut part of me thinks that I would like it just because it's so fucking like dumb.

[54:25] Jesse McAnally: Tarantino thinks that's like secretly the best one, and people would love it if it weren't for the fact that it wasn't Jason.

[54:32] Andrew DeWolf: I I mean I wouldn't be surprised if that is true because a lot of horror fans they don't really care about the right stuff, really.

[54:39] Jesse McAnally: They're just like it wasn't Jason, that's so dumb.

[54:43] Andrew DeWolf: Michael Myers isn't in Halloween 3.

[54:45] Jesse McAnally: I'm gonna go cry on the internet.

[54:47] Andrew DeWolf: Even though Halloween 3 is like probably better than half of the fucking franchise.

[54:52] Jesse McAnally: It is better than most of the fucking franchise.

[54:55] Andrew DeWolf: Have you seen Halloween Ends?

[54:57] Jesse McAnally: No, I haven't.

[54:57] Andrew DeWolf: I think it might be like the second best Halloween movie.

[55:01] Jesse McAnally: Really?

[55:02] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I fucking.

[55:03] Jesse McAnally: What was the one wasn't the one before that like complete shit?

[55:06] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, it was. It absolutely was.

[55:08] Jesse McAnally: I thought the one before that one was pretty okay as well, though.

[55:11] Andrew DeWolf: That one was okay.

[55:12] Jesse McAnally: Okay, can I uh keep all this in.

[55:19] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[55:20] Jesse McAnally: Halloween Ends. Spoilers for this movie, because it is the most fun I've ever had watching a movie in a very long time.

[55:27] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[55:28] Jesse McAnally: Um Miranda and I watched it the night it came out. It opens with on the night that Michael is out killing people, and you think, oh no, Michael Myers is gonna stop this boy babysitter and babysitting this kid.

[55:40] Andrew DeWolf: No, the boy babysitter accidentally kills the kid.

[55:43] Jesse McAnally: Um That's actually great.

[55:47] Andrew DeWolf: That's a great twist.

[55:48] Jesse McAnally: They accidentally too, not even on purpose.

[55:50] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, he like opens a door and the kid falls down a set of stairs and just snaps his neck.

[55:55] Jesse McAnally: Um but then it's like is it like uh is it like hereditary? Do they do it like that?

[55:58] Andrew DeWolf: It's a little bit broader because it makes a comedy neck breaking noise when the kid falls.

[56:05] Jesse McAnally: Okay, okay.

[56:06] Andrew DeWolf: Um but he's like seen as basically as it cuts to Michael Myers and they play the the trombones.

[56:12] Jesse McAnally: Whoa, whoa.

[56:17] Andrew DeWolf: But he is seen as just as bad as Michael Myers in this town, and he basically becomes a recluse and he's like all of his college prospects.

[56:25] Jesse McAnally: Because he did it on purpose.

[56:27] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, and they think that he is just another Michael Myers. And eventually, self-fulfilling prophecy, he and Michael Myers just start killing people together.

[56:36] Jesse McAnally: They team up.

[56:37] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[56:37] Jesse McAnally: And until eventually that kid starts taking over for Michael Myers wearing the mask as him.

[56:43] Andrew DeWolf: Because Michael Myers is an old fucking man, so this kid can actually complete kills and make them actually threatening.

[56:49] Jesse McAnally: Um and it's just a really good like passing the baton, except you have a character you actually kind of care about, and he is in this killing mode, and you get why he's murdering people and he's murdering bullies and all this.

[57:01] Andrew DeWolf: Um it's like Christine mixed with Halloween, and it's just such a bonkers, its own film kind of thing.

[57:08] Jesse McAnally: Now it makes perfect sense why people fucking hated it too.

[57:12] Andrew DeWolf: Because it's a good movie and an idea.

[57:13] Jesse McAnally: I remember people saying that it was bad, and like I just said, horror fans care about the wrong shit.

[57:19] Andrew DeWolf: They're just like, it wasn't really Michael Myers.

[57:22] Jesse McAnally: This is so lame.

[57:25] Andrew DeWolf: And he just wants to start this kid, and he's giving a fucking good performance, this guy who's playing I I am baffled that no one else liked this movie because it is and it's got a John Carpenter score.

[57:38] Jesse McAnally: Like he and his son composed it.

[57:40] Andrew DeWolf: It is one of the better horror films I've seen in a very long time.

[57:44] Jesse McAnally: I'm watching that soon.

[57:46] Andrew DeWolf: That's that's on the list.

[57:47] Jesse McAnally: Anyways.

[57:48] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, thank you guys for listening. Please follow us on iTunes, Stitcher, and Spotify.

[57:54] Jesse McAnally: Spotify doesn't exist.

[57:55] Andrew DeWolf: Or sorry, Stitcher doesn't exist anymore.

[57:57] Jesse McAnally: Spotify's still kicking somehow.

[57:59] Andrew DeWolf: Um, follow us on threads.

[58:02] Jesse McAnally: We we do have a threads.

[58:04] Andrew DeWolf: Musicals with cheese does have a thread, so follow us there.

[58:07] Jesse McAnally: Oh, you promote it.

[58:08] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, like, yeah, we're on threads.

[58:10] Jesse McAnally: Twitter will be gone in a couple months.

[58:13] Andrew DeWolf: We'll see.

[58:13] Jesse McAnally: Sincerely, I like threads better because it lets me keep musicals with cheese as my username, and Twitter did not let me do that.

[58:19] Andrew DeWolf: So fuck Twitter.

[58:21] Jesse McAnally: My only problem with threads right now is I just can't find the content that I want, like the people that I want to follow yet, because I think a lot of them haven't moved over from Twitter yet.

[58:30] Andrew DeWolf: Um I liked it because Instagram just automatically gave you your followers from Instagram and let you follow the people you were following on Instagram.

[58:40] Jesse McAnally: I followed you.

[58:41] Andrew DeWolf: I don't use Instagram, so uh that's fair.

[58:46] Jesse McAnally: Um, but yeah, we're on Patreon Musicals, cheese, Instagram musicals cheese, threads musicals with cheese, YouTube page musicals with cheese, uh, patron only podcast, Patreon Cheese.

[58:54] Andrew DeWolf: Email us to tell us stop talking about horror films.

[58:56] Jesse McAnally: You're a musical theater podcast.

[58:59] Andrew DeWolf: Fuck you.

[58:59] Jesse McAnally: Uh at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com. Our keeper of the cheese is Juliet Antonio.

[59:04] Andrew DeWolf: Here's some ASMR for you, Juliet.

[59:07] Jesse McAnally: Halloween Ends is pretty good, and y'all are just mean.

[59:11] Andrew DeWolf: This show is edited by Andrew DeWolf, and if that didn't make sense, burn him.

[59:16] Jesse McAnally: He cut a whole lot of gold out.

[59:17] Andrew DeWolf: Um I'm not cutting the Halloween stuff.

[59:19] Jesse McAnally: That that's gold.

[59:21] Andrew DeWolf: Because that that flows naturally from the uh incredible Silent Night, Deadly Night conversation.

[59:27] Jesse McAnally: You're right, you're right, you're right.

[59:28] Andrew DeWolf: Um God, I wish I sincerely wish it was earlier in the night so I could just watch Halloween Ends with you right now.

[59:36] Jesse McAnally: Um thank you to the Broadway Podcast Network for having us on the platform and for not kicking us off for spending about a third of this episode talking about horror movies.

[59:45] Andrew DeWolf: Um all right, Andrew, anything else left to say.

[59:48] Jesse McAnally: This episode is 20 minutes longer than Trouble in Tahiti, so if you had time to listen to this, you should have listened to Trouble in Tahiti.

[59:56] Andrew DeWolf: He makes good points.

[1:00:00] Jesse McAnally: Um, we'll see you next time on Musicals with Cheese.

[1:00:18] Andrew DeWolf: Sure enough, on the night of their wedding day, there's a storm like nothing on earth. Tidal waves and sickeres and hurricane, and top it all off a volcano erupts, and the natives sing!

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred