"The party goes with you..." Grab your film developing liquid and dark fables because this week we're talking about Ryan Scott Oliver's 35mm A Musical Exhibition. Hosts: Jesse McAnally & Andrew DeWolf. Podcast Edited By: Andrew DeWolf... Read More
From the show: Musicals with Cheese
About
"The party goes with you..." Grab your film developing liquid and dark fables because this week we're talking about Ryan Scott Oliver's 35mm A Musical Exhibition.
Credits:
Hosts: Jesse McAnally & Andrew DeWolf
Podcast Edited By: Andrew DeWolf
Show Produced by: Elizabeth Esten
Theme Songs: Robyn Nash of IOU Music UK
Keeper of the Cheese: Juliet Antonio
This show is a part of the Broadway Podcast Network
Social Media:
Musicals with Cheese on Twitter
Musicals W/ Cheese on Instagram
Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com
Jess Socials
Andrew Socials
Use our Affiliate Link
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:05] Jesse McAnally: Hello, I'm Jesse McAnally.
[0:07] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm Andrew DeWolf.
[0:09] Liz Esten: And I'm Liz Esten.
[0:10] Jesse McAnally: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, a podcast where I try to get Andrew and Liz to like musical theater.
[0:17] Jesse McAnally: And welcome to this photography exhibition that we are currently at.
[0:22] Jesse McAnally: We are recording this live from a photo exhibition in the fanciest part of New York.
[0:28] Jesse McAnally: Um, Andrew, Liz, how would you describe the environment we're in?
[0:32] Andrew DeWolf: It's like a lot of pictures.
[0:34] Andrew DeWolf: Uh some uh snobby guy took pictures and fucking pretentious I I don't know.
[0:42] Andrew DeWolf: This fucking guy with the glasses on, he looks like uh It's a Doug Walker.
[0:48] Andrew DeWolf: He looks like Mark from fucking Rent.
[0:51] Andrew DeWolf: Mark from Rent took all these photos of homeless people and his husband wrote songs about it.
[0:56] Jesse McAnally: I I was gonna try to do like this whole bit where we're pretending we're in a photo exhibition, and for each one we're doing a mini podcast of each song that is also a photo, but you know what? That's too much work.
[1:05] Jesse McAnally: This week we are covering 35mm.
[1:10] Jesse McAnally: Um fuck, it has a proper title.
[1:12] Jesse McAnally: A Musical Exhibition.
[1:14] Jesse McAnally: Hue the music.
[1:20] Jesse McAnally: Stop time, captured lights, gathered imaging on photo sides.
[1:31] Jesse McAnally: A sensor, small like a tube, records and stages, pixel pages of truth focus.
[1:44] Jesse McAnally: Oh alies, stopped in pose that never goes.
[1:44] Jesse McAnally: So 35mm A Musical Exhibition is a song cycle written by Ryan Scott Oliver's based on photographs by Matthew Murphy, his husband.
[2:08] Jesse McAnally: A full developmental production was presented at the Urban Stages in December of 2010, directed by Daisy Prince.
[2:14] Jesse McAnally: Um 35mm made its off-Broadway world premiere at the Galapagos Art Space in New York City on March 7, 2012, and the album was recorded at the Sears Sound in New York City in February of 2012.
[2:26] Jesse McAnally: The quote unquote plot, or just basically press release of 35mm is a picture's worth a thousand words.
[2:35] Jesse McAnally: What about a song?
[2:36] Jesse McAnally: Can a picture inspire a song?
[2:38] Jesse McAnally: Or 15?
[2:39] Jesse McAnally: In 35mm, a photo creates a unique song, moments frozen in time, a glimmer of a life unfolding, a glimpse of something happening, a stunning new multimedia musical, which explores a groundbreaking new concept in musical theater.
[2:56] Jesse McAnally: This intricately woven collection of stories told through songs reimagines what the modern American musical can be.
[3:03] Jesse McAnally: So that's a plot of the show.
[3:05] Jesse McAnally: So I gotta ask, okay.
[3:07] Jesse McAnally: Like right before we even start here.
[3:09] Jesse McAnally: Is there a show to this?
[3:11] Jesse McAnally: Or is it like there's just a bunch of pictures that go with the songs?
[3:15] Jesse McAnally: Like, is there a show element?
[3:16] Andrew DeWolf: Because we didn't watch a show element.
[3:18] Jesse McAnally: No.
[3:18] Andrew DeWolf: Well, you didn't send me one.
[3:19] Jesse McAnally: No.
[3:20] Jesse McAnally: There is often it's kind of minimalist, like they will do more or less a stripped-down stage production and portray the image that they're representing on a projector behind.
[3:31] Andrew DeWolf: So it's basically like there's just a big picture, and then people come up and say yes.
[3:35] Andrew DeWolf: A lot of other people have done different interpretations.
[3:37] Andrew DeWolf: Like when this is picked up for licensing, they have done interpretations like that.
[3:42] Andrew DeWolf: But in the original form, it is more or less a concert with photos to go along.
[3:46] Jesse McAnally: Okay.
[3:47] Jesse McAnally: I was just wondering.
[3:48] Jesse McAnally: This show has had a life of its own in animatic form, which I think is sincerely one of the best ways to engage with some musical theater is fans making animatics of what they think the plot is.
[4:02] Jesse McAnally: Truly the best art form of musical theater.
[4:05] Jesse McAnally: I love it so much.
[4:07] Jesse McAnally: I think before we can't cover this show like we do all the other times.
[4:11] Jesse McAnally: We can't do our Ben Brantley reviews.
[4:13] Jesse McAnally: We can't do our mid-shows.
[4:15] Jesse McAnally: So we we kind of have to talk about each song at face value because they are not connected really by a theme aside from you know the photos that uh Ryan Scott Oliver's's husband Matthew Murphy took.
[4:26] Jesse McAnally: And yeah, um, do either of you know anything about Ryan Scott Oliver's before we dive in?
[4:31] Liz Esten: Absolutely not.
[4:32] Liz Esten: I've never heard of this man.
[4:34] Andrew DeWolf: Um he is a renowned composer.
[4:36] Andrew DeWolf: He just released a new album recently.
[4:38] Andrew DeWolf: I think he's great.
[4:39] Andrew DeWolf: I think his music skills are incredible.
[4:42] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and our former guest and I can say good friend, Emily Clark, childhood best friends with Ryan Scott Oliver's.
[4:49] Andrew DeWolf: So she is a song recommendation.
[4:50] Andrew DeWolf: I'll play it in here.
[4:52] Jesse McAnally: Um What do you got?
[4:53] Andrew DeWolf: Hmm.
[4:54] Andrew DeWolf: Honestly, they're all from this.
[4:55] Andrew DeWolf: Like so, I don't really want to kind of give it away.
[4:58] Jesse McAnally: Okay, never mind.
[4:59] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, cut that out.
[5:00] Andrew DeWolf: I was expecting something from outside of it.
[5:03] Andrew DeWolf: Like, he has a brand new album.
[5:04] Andrew DeWolf: I just started listening to it the other day.
[5:06] Andrew DeWolf: I'm still unpacking it.
[5:07] Jesse McAnally: Okay.
[5:09] Jesse McAnally: Um he also did Jasper in Deadland, which is interesting.
[5:12] Andrew DeWolf: I it's not quite my style, but I do like it.
[5:15] Andrew DeWolf: I think he's a brilliant musician, and I think what he does is very interesting.
[5:19] Andrew DeWolf: However, there are two kind of warring albums with relatively the same cast members at this time.
[5:27] Andrew DeWolf: Um, you have this album, 35mm, and you have Drew Gasparini's album, which has Lindsay Mendez and Alex Brightman and a lot of other people that are in this album as well.
[5:39] Andrew DeWolf: And I kind of prefer Drew Gasparini's album.
[5:42] Andrew DeWolf: And a lot of those songs that I thought were from 35mm are actually in Drew Gasparini's album.
[5:47] Jesse McAnally: So wait, what's the difference between the two albums?
[5:50] Andrew DeWolf: Um, there's the different composers.
[5:53] Andrew DeWolf: His album is called I Could Use a Drink.
[5:56] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and has like, let's take a look at this.
[5:59] Andrew DeWolf: It has Alex Brightman as well.
[6:01] Andrew DeWolf: It also has Lindsay Mendez, and it has a good mix of comedy numbers and dark, dark numbers, basically back to back.
[6:09] Andrew DeWolf: Ben Crawford as well.
[6:11] Andrew DeWolf: So they're a similar uh format though.
[6:13] Andrew DeWolf: They're a similar format, unrelated songs, a lot of the same musicians, a lot of the same vocalists.
[6:20] Andrew DeWolf: And Lindsay Mendez has a very dark moody song in both of them that kind of steal the show that everyone talks about.
[6:27] Andrew DeWolf: And everyone in the world in the general consensus really loves 35mm.
[6:34] Andrew DeWolf: They are really obsessed with that.
[6:35] Andrew DeWolf: And then I'm in my own little corner, like, I really like Drew Gasparini's, I Could Use a Drink.
[6:40] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I really like um this song where Lindsay Mendez sings about probably being Harley Quinn.
[6:45] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know.
[6:46] Andrew DeWolf: Um, so it's kind of me diving into this for the first time properly engaging with it, aside from like one or two songs that I knew and really loved.
[6:56] Andrew DeWolf: So I'm kind of going into this as raw as you guys, aside from maybe one or two numbers.
[7:02] Jesse McAnally: So let's go to the first song that introduces the concept, and that is Stop Time.
[7:25] Andrew DeWolf: So is this the one where they're talking about the uh camera and like how it takes a picture and stop and like literally freezes?
[7:33] Jesse McAnally: Exactly that.
[7:33] Jesse McAnally: It's basically setting up like the concept for the relationship.
[7:38] Jesse McAnally: It's it's literally the and I didn't understand what I was going into, but I I understood immediately that this was just setting up the framework and why it's called 35mm and blah blah blah.
[7:51] Jesse McAnally: Um so it really just feels like an introduction.
[7:55] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it is.
[7:55] Andrew DeWolf: But what do you think of the initial premise?
[7:57] Andrew DeWolf: Because I don't think we're really gonna talk about it outside of this, so I kind of want to dive into this.
[8:01] Andrew DeWolf: Like the idea of taking images and turning them into songs on its own.
[8:06] Andrew DeWolf: I think it's it's like a piece that a lot of composers could use as a um a way to test their storytelling ability, but it almost feels like a training exercise, and we're just seeing it now.
[8:19] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know, like you you take a picture and you're like, how do I turn that into a song?
[8:23] Andrew DeWolf: Um, or it's kind of like a bunch of mini, it's like instead of concept albums as concept songs, but you give every single one of them a uh album cover.
[8:32] Jesse McAnally: That is actually kind of fun.
[8:33] Jesse McAnally: Like these are little mini concept songs with an album cover to go alongside of it.
[8:38] Jesse McAnally: What about you, Liz?
[8:39] Liz Esten: I I don't hate the idea, like, especially if your collab your photographer is literally your husband, like it's like uh you're working with where you're one of the people you're closest with, and like it's really interesting idea, and I it's not done been done a ton, but if the photographs don't have like a similar theme throughout, it feels like a bunch of EPs, like at one after another that are kind of related, but not really, and they're not bad.
[9:04] Liz Esten: They're just not related.
[9:06] Liz Esten: There are thematic ties between the songs.
[9:08] Liz Esten: And I did take notes of like repeated courses, repeated like things turned on its head.
[9:13] Liz Esten: So I think needed a story outside of it.
[9:17] Liz Esten: Like um like like the goosebumps, you know, where you where it's like somebody has a camera and he's taking pictures of a bunch of people, and that's where the pictures come from.
[9:27] Andrew DeWolf: You want a framing device?
[9:28] Liz Esten: I want a framing device.
[9:29] Liz Esten: The framing device is we're at an exhibition.
[9:31] Liz Esten: We are at a photo exhibition, and these are a musical representation of those songs.
[9:36] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[9:37] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[9:38] Liz Esten: That's not a that's not much of a framing device.
[9:40] Andrew DeWolf: You are the framing device.
[9:42] Liz Esten: I already went to communication school and did that a bunch of times.
[9:45] Liz Esten: I don't need to do it again.
[9:47] Liz Esten: Like, I'm good.
[9:48] Liz Esten: I'm the audience, I'm not a framing device.
[9:51] Jesse McAnally: Um, all right.
[9:52] Jesse McAnally: Let's move on to Crazy Town.
[9:55] Andrew DeWolf: Ha oh, ding dung.
[9:58] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, ding dung.
[10:06] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, ding dung.
[10:40] Andrew DeWolf: There's a hole inside my brain.
[10:51] Andrew DeWolf: Take a stroll down the drain to crazy.
[11:00] Andrew DeWolf: You fall in line.
[11:06] Andrew DeWolf: It's an end of the morning.
[11:13] Jesse McAnally: Um, so this is the first time we have an image to go as alongside of it.
[11:17] Jesse McAnally: D Andrew, do you remember the image for this one?
[11:19] Andrew DeWolf: A red gradient background.
[11:21] Andrew DeWolf: I'm guessing a painted wall with a light on it.
[11:24] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and then there is a a what looks like a framed picture of a person a person's lower head screaming and then like blended with the person not screaming facing the other direction.
[11:40] Andrew DeWolf: Um it's like double exposure, but with actual photographs, like if you try to double expose off two physical photograph objects.
[11:47] Andrew DeWolf: It's interesting.
[11:48] Andrew DeWolf: Um, as photo photographically, I find it interesting and as um something engaging.
[11:54] Andrew DeWolf: Now it'd be a good album cover.
[11:56] Jesse McAnally: It would be.
[11:57] Andrew DeWolf: Now, in relation to the song.
[11:58] Andrew DeWolf: Nine inch nails.
[12:00] Andrew DeWolf: Um, what what I have the actual like genius description of it, but what do you think the song was about, Andrew?
[12:06] Andrew DeWolf: Uh this one I I couldn't really parse.
[12:10] Andrew DeWolf: Uh there's a few that I was able to parse a lot better on just one listen, but this one.
[12:15] Andrew DeWolf: This one is just about reality, and they make a lot of comparisons to Wonderland and Narnia and things like that.
[12:23] Andrew DeWolf: Um, and imagery, um, that is I don't even know.
[12:28] Andrew DeWolf: Like, it it's a manifestation of a boy's illusions, more or less.
[12:33] Andrew DeWolf: Um and you could either decide whether he's gone to heaven or hell.
[12:38] Jesse McAnally: Um, it's like, hey, welcome to the world we're gonna live in. And it is probably the most musically complex song on this album. It is the most sound timey, kind of mixy weird, um, and it sets up the world of the show. Um, as Ryan Scott Oliver's said in his commentary, um, he wrote a lot of songs that were meant for an audience, and a lot of them that he just wrote from his soul, and this one he didn't care if an audience got, he kind of just wrote from his soul, and everyone tried to pressure him to not make this the opening number. They were like, make "On Monday" the opening number, because it's like a charming little love song, and it'll kind of ease people in. He's like, No, I want to put this insane song up front so that they will kind of know the varied tones that we're gonna have for the rest of this album.
It's an interesting take to put this at the beginning. I think, um, it was a mistake, and he should have listened to the people that said not to. If you're doing a show, you kind of want people to uh be engaged right away, and you probably shouldn't try to uh confuse them with the most surreal and odd number as your opener. I mean, the song is about a little boy going to Crazy Town, being torn apart, and then having to start it again, so it is like a never-ending hell cycle. I don't know if either of you watch Preacher, where basically the premise of their hell is you have to relive the worst moment of your life over and over again for all eternity. Um, which it sounds like this is taking a lot of influence from, and basing it on a lot of dreams and nightmares that college students have.
Um, I don't know why. Um, so the transitions. We're not really gonna go into the transitions, but apparently they were just put there to kind of ease the audience and for no other reason. Like, give a nice little kind of ease between the songs. But let's move on to "On Monday."
[14:39] ♪ Musical number: "On Monday" — performed by Betsy Wolfe ♪
[15:01] Andrew DeWolf: Which, Jesse, tell us if you could parse that one.
[15:05] Jesse McAnally: Okay. "On Monday" was about, uh, people falling in love. Kind of. For the most part. This is a lot of it. It's about, oh god. Like, okay, I love Betsy Wolfe. This song annoys me a little bit. This is not my kind of song at all. Um, it's about a girl that fell in love with a guy who thinks that she's a little too clingy and you have to stay away from me to make the love more powerful. And honestly, in my opinion, he's, it's kind of abusive. If you love it, let it go or something like that. No, it's if you love it, avoid it for a while, and that'll mean more when you get back to it at the end of the day. So it's about, um, negging?
[15:45] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, this is a song about negging, and their specific meetup date is Mondays and Mondays alone.
[15:51] Jesse McAnally: And he just keeps calling her Garfield.
[15:53] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.
[15:56] Jesse McAnally: Exactly. Um, but she comes to, like, they have different vibes of romantic, different romantic attachments, and he keeps calling her juvenile, but the song keeps saying you're too juvenile.
[16:10] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, I remember that.
[16:11] Jesse McAnally: That I don't know what it is. That kind of I don't like it. And this is just, there is no quality basis. I just kind of didn't like the way it sounded. Look, you said this week I got to be John.
[16:29] Andrew DeWolf: Jesse, you're being too juvenile.
[16:35] Jesse McAnally: I mean, is that an effective thing in a relationship to like avoid them?
[16:40] Andrew DeWolf: No.
[16:40] Jesse McAnally: No. We should maybe actually, we should talk about the picture.
[16:44] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, we should. What is the image that goes alongside this one?
[16:47] Jesse McAnally: Uh, it looks as though, um, a person is putting their hand in their pocket and there's a person beside them, uh, reaching out their hand as if to offer it to hold.
[17:00] Andrew DeWolf: It's about withholding your love.
[17:02] Jesse McAnally: And how that makes you a better lover.
[17:04] Andrew DeWolf: Now it's not being a douchebag.
[17:06] Jesse McAnally: Uh, yeah. People love in different ways, alright. That's just, it's how it is. There are like, there is bullshit about like different attachment things. And like I've had conversations with people I really respect about attachment styles, but in my opinion, I think it's all bullshit. I think it's all about like egos and people's fear of intimacy at the end of the day. It's like zodiac signs where it's like, oh my god, uh, Mercury is in retrograde. That means I could be a bitch to anyone I want. Am I wrong? Am I wrong? I feel like I'm gonna piss off the Zodiac girlies right now. Let's move on to the next song.
[17:38] Jesse McAnally: "Carol Lee."
[17:40] Andrew DeWolf: "Carol Lee" is a terror.
[17:47] Jesse McAnally: But "Carol Lee."
[17:49] Andrew DeWolf: "Carolie, don't suck on that."
[17:50] Jesse McAnally: Pays the bills.
[17:52] Andrew DeWolf: Drop it.
[17:53] Jesse McAnally: Drop it.
[17:54] Andrew DeWolf: Drop it.
[17:54] Jesse McAnally: "Life has her manny beats alive on my fanny still."
[17:58] Andrew DeWolf: "Carol Lee."
[18:03] Jesse McAnally: She kills.
[18:04] Andrew DeWolf: Spit.
[18:05] Jesse McAnally: Spit.
[18:06] Andrew DeWolf: Spit me.
[18:08] Jesse McAnally: Thank you. Okay, I actually know what this one's about, I think.
[18:11] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, Jesse. All yours. Go off.
[18:14] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, it's like, uh, there's like a person who's trying to, like, I thought it was about a person babysitting somebody, but now that I see the picture again, it's like a doll, so I'm not sure. Maybe the doll is Carol Lee and not, not like a girl. But I thought it was a person babysitting somebody and they fucking hated it.
[18:33] Jesse McAnally: Well, describe what the image looks like really quick for the audience.
[18:36] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, the image is an American Girl doll and then another American Girl doll below it. But the other American Girl doll has her hair torn out and I'm missing, it's messed up. Also, it's a wish American Girl doll.
[18:49] Jesse McAnally: That is not a real American doll.
[18:51] Andrew DeWolf: It's not real, no, but it's, I didn't know how else to describe it.
[18:54] Jesse McAnally: Um, you are correct, Andrew. It is about, uh, a nanny, a manny, a male nanny, who is babysitting this child and slowly goes insane from doing so to the point where he literally gives it to a homeless person on the street and runs away. At the end he gets out of it.
[19:11] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.
[19:14] Jesse McAnally: Um, but there is also the alternative reading that it is literally Satan. Like, people have read the literal reading that Carol Lee is Satan and he is trying to escape their clutches. I do not agree with that reading. I just, I think it's about how children are fucking awful. I feel like all of us are gonna be childless 48-year-olds one day. God.
[19:34] Andrew DeWolf: If we're lucky.
[19:36] Jesse McAnally: 50-50. I'm still working that out in my head. Um, "Carol Lee" is Satan. Um, it's an interesting kind of song, a little more funnier than we're used to, especially with the last couple. Um, yeah, I think this, what I mean. I guess we're not really talking about the quality of whether or not we like it, except for me, but do we like this song?
[19:57] Andrew DeWolf: I thought it was good. I like it better than "On Monday." I like this one.
[20:02] Jesse McAnally: Okay, okay. Uh, we're gonna have to do a ranking list at the end of this arc. This one has start depending on the game.
[20:06] Andrew DeWolf: There's no fucking way I can rank all of them. I can't have a big thing.
[20:10] Jesse McAnally: We'll do a collective ranking, you know?
[20:12] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.
[20:12] Jesse McAnally: Um, the next is "The Party Goes With You."
[20:12] ♪ Musical number: "The Party Goes With You" — performed by Lindsay Mendez ♪
[21:12] Andrew DeWolf: This one, it took me a couple listens to figure out, and also I had to look at the genius lyrics. But describe the image.
[21:19] Jesse McAnally: Uh, the image is a man carrying, uh, a bunch of balloons. Um, and you can't see the man, and he's in New York City.
[21:26] Andrew DeWolf: Fair enough.
[21:26] Jesse McAnally: The balloons are, the balloons are covering him. You can almost smell the urine from the image.
[21:30] Andrew DeWolf: It's true.
[21:31] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, you can. Um, this song I struggled with a little bit. Um, just trying to figure out what it was it about. Did you have any idea just based on your general first watch, Andrew?
[21:41] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, honestly, I just, I just thought it was about like, uh, a woman who is with somebody who is the life of the party while she is not.
[21:50] Jesse McAnally: Kind of.
[21:51] Andrew DeWolf: Like that is more or less what it is. Um, it's about a wife, allegedly, that is only there for show. Basically, someone that he only pulls out at parties but is distant from any other time he is not in public.
[22:04] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.
[22:05] Andrew DeWolf: Which is an interesting emotional idea to play with. I've met people like that where I don't think I've ever seen them interact with their wife that wasn't, um, like an event. And it's kind of sad, and you can see the sadness in their eyes, and that's a complex issue to play with.
[22:19] Jesse McAnally: Bill Clinton.
[22:22] Andrew DeWolf: You know what? You're not wrong. Um, sadly, I don't think Hillary sees that as much of a problem.
[22:28] Jesse McAnally: No.
[22:29] Andrew DeWolf: No, I don't think they live together. I think Hillary's living her best life.
[22:32] Jesse McAnally: I mean, it's like Meryl Streep and her husband, allegedly.
[22:35] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Will Smith and his wife.
[22:37] Jesse McAnally: I honestly, I think that most, like, rich couples who care about their image, that's kind of how it is. Um, "The Party Goes With You." Good song, bad song. What do we think?
[22:46] Andrew DeWolf: Eh.
[22:46] Jesse McAnally: It was.
[22:47] Andrew DeWolf: That was fine.
[22:48] Jesse McAnally: I love it. I love Lindsay Mendez too, but continue.
[22:52] Andrew DeWolf: Like, I don't know, it just didn't hit me. Maybe we're too young.
[22:56] Jesse McAnally: That might be it too. Uh, it took me a couple listens to even get what was going on. Which is a part of probably part of my problem. But I don't know. I kinda understood it. I just, the song wasn't, it didn't hit vibe. It didn't vibe with me super well.
[23:09] Andrew DeWolf: That's fair.
[23:09] Jesse McAnally: Um, and I feel similar ways, but I appreciated it in that Sondheim-y way where it's like, I haven't heard that before. I haven't heard this take before. Where a lot of the Sondheim songs for elder women, um, I don't resonate with, but I like appreciate the fact they exist. Um, let's move on to "Good Lady."
[23:29] ♪ Musical number: "Good Lady" — performed by Jesse McAnally ♪
[24:29] Andrew DeWolf: I don't even think this picture relates to like the song we get. This is a picture from the set of Joker 2.
[24:37] Jesse McAnally: This is Joaquin Phoenix. I am so excited for Joker 2, and I'm so excited to make us cover it on the podcast. Um, either way, describe what the image we have is, Andrew.
[24:47] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, it's a guy screaming while he holds his hands out and leans forward. He is in a water fountain. The water looks like fire behind him. He kind of looks like an X-Man.
[24:57] Jesse McAnally: Which answer?
[24:58] Andrew DeWolf: He looks as though he is posing for a, like he's the villain in a superhero movie, and he's doing the pose. What do you think the song was about, Andrew?
[25:07] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, the song is about a guy thinks that his wife is gone, and realizes that she left him on purpose.
[25:17] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.
[25:18] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, I knew a guy that this happened to. I'm not kidding.
[25:22] Jesse McAnally: Oh my god.
[25:24] Andrew DeWolf: Oh my god. Can we please elaborate on that?
[25:28] Jesse McAnally: Without names.
[25:29] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, I don't want to give any names.
[25:30] Jesse McAnally: No, don't give any names.
[25:33] Andrew DeWolf: But this guy moved to my state, and he was a bit of a drunk, and he thought he thought that his wife...
[25:44] Jesse McAnally: It wasn't his wife, it was his girlfriend.
[25:45] Andrew DeWolf: He thought his girlfriend like died or something like that. But then he went back to his home state and it realized that his girlfriend was just dating uh a dude that was in a much better metal band than he was.
[26:01] Jesse McAnally: How did you come up with the best punchline ever to the end of that story?
[26:06] Andrew DeWolf: I know it's based on reality, but holy shit, that like was set up like a joke. Uh the saddest part is he moved back to his state, and I haven't talked to him since, so I don't know what's going on with him. I hope he's alive.
[26:20] Jesse McAnally: You know what you should do? You should just send him this song. Just no context. Just send him the song "Good Lady" and see what happens.
[26:29] Andrew DeWolf: But wow. Moving on from that. What do we think of the song itself? Because it has like the like Latin intro and outro kind of things.
[26:37] Jesse McAnally: I think it's kind of neat. Um, I think it's neat. I feel like as far as it strays the furthest away from the premise that we've gotten so far. Whereas I'm not sure it has anything to do with this picture that was taken in.
[26:48] Andrew DeWolf: This guy's nothing.
[26:50] Jesse McAnally: I don't know, he's not, Jess.
[26:53] Andrew DeWolf: No, he's not. Like this guy just looks really angry.
[26:56] Jesse McAnally: You've never done an angry nut.
[26:58] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. Whatever. I just it does see scream. It's not an angry nut.
[27:04] Jesse McAnally: Um, that's the name of my band, "Hedwig and the Angry Nut."
[27:07] Andrew DeWolf: Bruh.
[27:08] Jesse McAnally: Britt. I think the song is fine. It's fine. For a character that is known as like the knight, and it is about like a knight and a good lady and all that. It doesn't feel very I don't know, medieval, aside from the Latin at the beginning and the end.
[27:22] Andrew DeWolf: I think that that was more of a setup, and really it was about a guy in New York doing the same thing because that's what most musicals are about. Ryan's got all over imagines straight people do, like in their everyday lives, periodically.
[27:35] Jesse McAnally: Let's talk about "Make Me Happy."
[27:51] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, you make me happy all the time. And you know I'm a total dick. But you make me happy all the time. Oh baby, you just like when you know I need my alone time, and you keep out of my goddamn way. Which makes me happy, happ a hapa happy, baby never goes.
[28:17] Jesse McAnally: Make me happy, oh you make me happy. Make me happy. Make me happy, happy oh.
[28:30] Andrew DeWolf: What's this image, Andrew?
[28:32] Jesse McAnally: This image is um it's a still from the trailer for that fucking video game that was like a big thing. Remember, remember that?
[28:39] Andrew DeWolf: No.
[28:39] Jesse McAnally: Where they took happy pills.
[28:41] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, "We Happy." Yeah, people in the audience remember this.
[28:45] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. Um, yeah, it's it's a still from the trailer for that.
[28:49] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, I'll take your word for it. Or from a depression pills ad. You're feeling sad, take Viagra, and then you'll turn happy.
[28:56] Jesse McAnally: In all actuality, though, it's it's two people walking with happy face balloons from Walmart in front of their face.
[29:02] Andrew DeWolf: Forced gum, maybe.
[29:07] Jesse McAnally: I like the shadows, kind of make them look like aliens.
[29:09] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[29:10] Jesse McAnally: A little bit, yeah. It's like South Park aliens.
[29:12] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Um, I I don't under know if I understand this song. I mean, the first line of this song is so stupid that I crack up every time.
[29:21] Jesse McAnally: Why don't you remind us what the opening lines of the song are?
[29:24] Andrew DeWolf: Is it you make me happy all the time, even though I'm a fucking dick?
[29:27] Jesse McAnally: Yep.
[29:28] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, yep. That's what I thought. And then her line is something similar too, like something equally as cringe, which is like, oh god, I'm trying to remember. It's like equally as vulgar.
[29:39] Jesse McAnally: Um, you make me happy all the time, and that is really fucking rough. Still, you make me happy all the time. Oh, baby, I can't get enough.
[29:46] Andrew DeWolf: Um, this is from a time in musical theater where just throwing a fuck word in every now and then was was gold. It's the "Spring Awakening" time.
[29:54] Jesse McAnally: The comedy. Um this is the funny song because they swear. I wouldn't even say that this is really that funny. It's just kind of two aggressive people that think that they make each other happy, I guess.
[30:05] Andrew DeWolf: The genius lyrics say that's described as a couple using each other as a happy drug. The other person in the relationship makes them feel happy and not truly joyful. They say that they need each other to be some kind of happy with their own faults and issues, so basically it's people using other people to cope.
[30:18] Jesse McAnally: But there is one lyric I want to talk about, which is like right before the song ends. It is, and I know I don't deserve you, but please have faith in me. I'm working to be worthy, and soon you're gonna see, you'll see.
[30:28] Andrew DeWolf: Which is an exact lyric from the next song.
[30:31] Jesse McAnally: And I know if I didn't bring that up, other people would point out that I didn't bring it up. And the next song is "The Seraph."
[30:37] Andrew DeWolf: Seraph.
[30:38] Jesse McAnally: Seraph? Seraph? The Seraph? I think the Seraph.
[30:41] Andrew DeWolf: This is Michigan education going for you right now.
[30:46] Jesse McAnally: My journey toward a goodness that he exemplifies wise and cool and clear and human in disguise.
[31:09] Andrew DeWolf: The angel leads me on work, he watches as I sleep.
[31:17] Jesse McAnally: The angel thinks I've got some kind of soul to keep.
[31:31] Andrew DeWolf: Don't know why it should be bought by the angel.
[31:39] Jesse McAnally: I am blessed.
[31:51] Andrew DeWolf: Um, Andrew, what is this image right here?
[31:53] Jesse McAnally: Uh, it looks like a guy on a catwalk and there's a bright light. He's facing towards this bright light.
[32:00] Andrew DeWolf: So, this is about faith. I think that's pretty obvious. It's about an angel and a sinner, and the angel helping the sinner who is gonna maybe sell their soul to the devil. Um in the literal sense, it is someone that is about to sell their soul, an angel saving someone that sold their silver to the devil.
[32:11] Jesse McAnally: Um, in the metaphorical sense, it's just a regular person trying to help a person become better, um, which he doesn't think he deserves. And in his relationship to God, they repeat the verse. No, I don't dis I know I don't deserve you, but please have faith in me. I'm working to be worthy. You'll make me happy all the time.
[32:35] Andrew DeWolf: Which is the same lyric from the previous one, which I guess implies that maybe using God as a crutch to make you happy is equally as unhealthy as using a human being as a crutch to make you happy. Or maybe it's just to tie the two together.
[32:46] Jesse McAnally: Maybe, maybe. Maybe I'm reaching here, but um, I actually think this one ties into the image pretty well, all things considered.
[32:55] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. I think so, and I think reusing um reusing lyrics is interesting. Um, usually you see like you'll reuse like melodies or something like that, but reusing lyrics is uh an interesting way to tie two songs together. Uh yeah, and I don't see many lyrics reused in the show, and I don't see many melodies reused either.
[33:13] Jesse McAnally: Um let's do one more song, then go into a mid-show.
[33:25] Andrew DeWolf: The whore goes like our bosses. Done with her dirty work. Heel breaks. She slinks down to fix. Splits the scheme of her skin. In this waverly gutter, she's giving up tricks. While a shotger is a flutter of clay. Cause she looks just like Jesus in the liquor spot with a tear and a tear in her side. And so I capture the moment I caught giving frame changing shame to cry.
[34:21] Jesse McAnally: So what's the next image?
[34:22] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, the next image, and this one is weird to describe, I guess. It's it's like a it looks like a street curb or maybe a rooftop. I can't really tell. And it's reflecting what looks like a graffiti, and it's like a top hat, upside down top hat and an eye. It's it's a very strange image.
[34:42] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. Um, what do you think the song is about and how does it tie to the image?
[34:47] Andrew DeWolf: Uh what? Ah god. Yeah, genuinely I don't know. This one I could not. I could not parse.
[34:55] Jesse McAnally: I could not parse it either. I don't particularly love this song, to be honest, and maybe that's just kind of my um feeling. Um, but apparently the song talks about the exploitation of painful circumstances, captioning art, in this case photography, for the sake of profit or something like that. Um, it's a pun on Catholic belief of Immaculate Conception, which is that the Virgin Mary's conception without original sin.
[35:20] Andrew DeWolf: The notable thing here is that the prefix switched from the conception to deception, suggesting that art can deceive the perceiver through the way it's framed and presented. It keeps in line with the main theme of the relationships that the musical has as a through line. This one being the relationship between the photographer and the subject.
[35:37] Jesse McAnally: So maybe this is supposed to be like a pool of blood. Like um, I think it's just the the image in there looks a little like freaky, and there's I I do think it's just a puddle. I don't know. Am I am I reaching here too much? Because there is like a little bit of red in the puddle.
[35:54] Andrew DeWolf: It is a black and white image with like red highlights.
[35:57] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, but like if you turn your head to the side, it looks like the Babaduke's cousin that no one.
[36:02] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, that I was gonna bring that up too.
[36:04] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, it did kind of look like the Babylon. I like that. Also, Catholics made up that immaculate conceptive thing to show that Mary wasn't cheating. I don't believe that.
[36:10] Andrew DeWolf: She fucked God.
[36:13] Jesse McAnally: I know this.
[36:14] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, she had sex with God. God doesn't actually have to follow the rules that say you can't cheat.
[36:19] Jesse McAnally: So exactly. God can just have sex in the world. Do you know how many people God has killed?
[36:23] Andrew DeWolf: At least three.
[36:24] Jesse McAnally: At least three.
[36:25] Andrew DeWolf: At least. But you know who else has definitely killed at least three people? Our wonderful patrons. How about we go into a show?
[36:33] Jesse McAnally: And talk about them.
[36:42] Andrew DeWolf: Hey guys, sorry to interrupt you, middle of the show, but we've got a shill at you. Today's show is brought to you by the extremely kind donations by our donors over at Patreon.
[36:49] Jesse McAnally: Andrew, what is Patreon? What's going on over there?
[36:51] Andrew DeWolf: Oh man, you can go to Patreon if you want to get uh access to our unedited live shows.
[36:58] Jesse McAnally: Oh, we got video with this episode in particular, I think is important because we're showing off the images uh that go with each song.
[37:05] Andrew DeWolf: Um I'm sure that Andrew's gonna cut out a lot of this. And there's just a lot of extra content in general.
[37:12] Jesse McAnally: We have like commentary tracks and and just other things that we wouldn't put on our normal feed.
[37:17] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, and Andrew and I are gonna do a lot more of those. Liz and I have some cool things planned. I love our Patreon so much, and hopefully sometime we can get back to doing those meetups.
[37:28] Jesse McAnally: Yes.
[37:29] Andrew DeWolf: I miss them.
[37:30] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. Yeah, we miss you guys. Um, our current patrons are Melissa Goldman, Danielle Renics, De The Peasant Chick.
[37:37] Andrew DeWolf: Wow, changing names on me. You're not allowed to do that.
[37:40] Jesse McAnally: Just the Stampede, Elon Cassidy, Monica Thoreau, Brent Black, Lithanius Stacey Coomb, Joseph Evans Green, Mary Lou Choquet, Sean Van Alz, Ross Walker, Musical Hell, Emily Gracie, Kyle Summers, Janae C Scoot in the Technical or Dreamcoat, Liz Lim, nothing is certain except Beth and Taxis, Desbian, Roger Benjamin, Jessica T, Mitchell Young, Chai Teacup, Chris Marcote, KG Marie Anastasio, Trevi Joseph, Layla, RJ Narrijas, Julia McClennon, Bjorn Hermann, Toriana Fraser, Sammy, the Adequate Amount Jacobson, Liana Morton, Angela, Kaylee Blazier, Cinemageton Reviews, Villainous Miss, Sofiana Lee, the Omega Geek, Paige Pearson, Matty Worgle, Lisa Erdman, Anna Loscatova, Zara Den Bleckier, Evan Ball, Zachary Torres, Rora Morasso, Mara Farloin, Lisa L Possessed Washing Machine, Nick Roton, Puffy Boy, Julia Hardy, Sidney Hicks, and Beale, Billy Clifton, Andrew Wright, the Red Caboose, Gold Plated Kikimora, and literally, as we were recording, we got a brand new patron.
[38:38] Jesse McAnally: So I added them real quick. And this is Julia Baldur's Dottier.
[38:44] Andrew DeWolf: That's a cool name.
[38:45] Jesse McAnally: Destroyed that name. But they give us a little extra financial support that helps us keep the lights on here at Musical Suchie. If you would like to join them in supporting us and get tons of fun perks, come join us over at Patreon.
[38:54] Jesse McAnally: And Andrew, would you believe it? We got more iTunes reviews since the last time we chatted.
[39:00] Andrew DeWolf: That's crazy.
[39:01] Jesse McAnally: Also, I just want to point out that would be Baldur's daughter.
[39:03] Andrew DeWolf: But that's the last name.
[39:04] Jesse McAnally: Baldur's DoTyr.
[39:06] Andrew DeWolf: Baldur's I sounded like the Swedish chef.
[39:11] Jesse McAnally: I went full Swedish chef on that one. It is Boulder's Duterte. Um, are you ready for the first review we have?
[39:20] Andrew DeWolf: Sure.
[39:21] Jesse McAnally: This is from OOV. Um, and their title is Well That Happened.
[39:28] Andrew DeWolf: Oh my god, they're stepping into our world from a Marvel movie.
[39:34] Jesse McAnally: Um, the review says, I did not think the previous awful review would be read on the podcast. Honestly, I am impressed. No things change. The show is still great. Look forward to seeing what comes next.
[39:45] Jesse McAnally: So we read their previous review, which apparently was just nonsense and they didn't think would be read, but then we read it. So they changed their review. It's still a five-star review. Um, excellent.
[39:57] Jesse McAnally: Here is uh uh uh uh uh not so much fun review. And this one has the title Dear Evan Hansen.
[40:06] Andrew DeWolf: Of course.
[40:07] Jesse McAnally: Oh god. I assume this is regarding our original Dear Evan Hansen episode from I want to say 2018, five, six years ago.
[40:15] Andrew DeWolf: That's fine.
[40:16] Jesse McAnally: You were right about everything. Um, they said the Dear Evan Hansen episode was offensive. If you're not autistic, maybe don't criticize those on the spectrum for identifying with a character in a musical. You don't get to tell autistic kids or depressed kids that they're stupid for liking a show just because you didn't get it.
[40:32] Andrew DeWolf: Not everything's about you.
[40:34] Jesse McAnally: Well, I don't think we said that in the episode.
[40:37] Andrew DeWolf: So everything is about us.
[40:40] Jesse McAnally: Not to be that guy, but you can make your own podcast too. Like, there is no law stopping you from it. In fact, if you told me you made a podcast, I would share it.
[40:50] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, an episode that early, we maybe we did say that they were stupid.
[40:55] Jesse McAnally: It was our seventeen. I did go back and re-listen. Um, I did say that a lot of people did think that Evan Hansen as a character was autistic, but I did also go into the fact that Ben Platt himself debunked that and said that was not the case.
[41:10] Andrew DeWolf: We don't think you're stupid. We just think that maybe you should think a little more critically about the show if you actually identify with Evan Hansen.
[41:18] Jesse McAnally: No, and it's also just fine if you identify with Evan Hansen or identify with a show. You're allowed to disagree with us. That is a blind thing to do. But I do think you should think more critically about the show if you actually identify with Evan Hansen.
[41:30] Andrew DeWolf: I think I feel like even the writers don't identify with Evan Hansen. Evan Hansen, even in the context of the show, is a cautionary tale.
[41:38] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. It's like agreeing with fucking um Travis Bickle from Taxi Driver. You're not supposed to, guys.
[41:44] Andrew DeWolf: That's fine. I mean, not everyone's gonna like our show. That's fine.
[41:47] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. But I think our show would be worse if everyone liked it. Don't judge us on an episode that early.
[41:53] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, we did a second episode on it, even. Listen to at least the second episode where we had our thoughts a little more coherent.
[42:00] Jesse McAnally: Or our third, like Patreon commentary. In fact, me and Andrew just recorded a commentary of the Dear Evan Hansen movie over on Patreon.
[42:08] Andrew DeWolf: And you should go join Patreon. Um, yeah, it'd be great. How about we get back to the show and less.
[42:21] Jesse McAnally: Um, leave Luann.
[42:43] ♪ Musical number: "Leave Luann" — performed by Jesse McAnally ♪
[43:34] Jesse McAnally: It is lovely, zero faults, truly a perfect piece of musical theater. Um, sincerely, I have in my own personal life tried to get rights to this song to do a short film version of it. Like that is how much I love this. I think it would be a great little movie.
[43:50] Jesse McAnally: It isn't one to one-to-one. But I was thinking thematically and narratively, there's a lot of similarities between this song and the short from I believe it's Creep Show.
[44:05] Andrew DeWolf: Um, where uh is it is it Ted Danson?
[44:09] Jesse McAnally: Ted Danson. The drowning one in the sand?
[44:12] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, the drowning one in the sand.
[44:13] Jesse McAnally: I think you're reaching it. That is a bit of a stretch, but I love that short.
[44:17] Andrew DeWolf: I love that short too, but I think it's.
[44:22] Jesse McAnally: She doesn't drown herself.
[44:23] Andrew DeWolf: No, no, no. The husband dunks her head in.
[44:25] Jesse McAnally: That makes it even more similar.
[44:29] Andrew DeWolf: No, he doesn't dunk her head in.
[44:29] Jesse McAnally: No, it's Ted Danson who drowns her in the ocean.
[44:35] Andrew DeWolf: It's Leslie Nielsen who buries both of them in the sand.
[44:38] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, he buries him in the sand.
[44:42] Andrew DeWolf: And then they come back to haunt him.
[44:44] Jesse McAnally: Yes, I see. I see the veil connection.
[44:48] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know. There's not that much to both of these stories, and I feel like those are a lot of similarities.
[44:54] Jesse McAnally: If you take anything from this, watch version of Greece.
[45:06] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, describe the image and let's describe the plot of this song.
[45:10] Jesse McAnally: The image is a man wearing a deer head that is on a or holding a deer head in front of him that's on a the oh my god, what do they call those? Like a trophy plate or something.
[45:23] Andrew DeWolf: Uh yeah.
[45:24] Jesse McAnally: Um and honestly, it's terrifying considering my history with uh deers chasing me.
[45:28] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, that's true.
[45:29] Jesse McAnally: Um but also it kind of like uh Evil Dead 2 vibes.
[45:34] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.
[45:34] Jesse McAnally: Um I do not see quite how this ties into the narrative aside from like maybe the husband hunts.
[45:41] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, there's like a Louisiana thing as well.
[45:43] Jesse McAnally: Well, I think hunting isn't like a specific thing in Louisiana or like the South, like even in Michigan, there's a hunting culture.
[45:51] Andrew DeWolf: If you live in New York City and you think of the South, you're thinking of some shack where somebody has one of these hanging over their phone.
[45:57] Jesse McAnally: I guess. That's a good point.
[46:00] Andrew DeWolf: Um, but the visual imagery, like we already I have an image of what Luann, her husband, the dog, the house, the bog, everything looks like.
[46:09] Jesse McAnally: It is like perfect musical theater storytelling. This is as perfect as a musical theater song can get.
[46:16] Andrew DeWolf: It's really good, and you could I got the entire story just from one listen, which is great.
[46:21] Jesse McAnally: That's good storytelling. And literally, it makes you want more of it.
[46:26] Andrew DeWolf: And it's a ghost story. It is like a battered kind of wife kind of revenge story. It is truly incredible.
[46:34] Jesse McAnally: This is uh I can't say enough good things. What do you think of it, Liz?
[46:38] Liz Esten: I love this song so goddamn much. I love it so much. Um deal obviously, but I've been through a like semi like abusive relationship in my early my like early twenties.
[46:51] Liz Esten: Like I connect with these a lot and the storytelling's so goddamn impeccable in this thing. It's so beautiful. Also, I watch like six animatics of this. The animatics are perfect of this.
[47:01] Liz Esten: They're so good for Lethulan, like just look up Liebland Animatic on YouTube and you'll be living. Um I love the song so much. It's so impeccably done. I've listened to it like four times since then, I think.
[47:12] Liz Esten: And my favorite part of this song, and we're not gonna spend nearly as long on the rest of these songs as we are on this one, just because this one's so good, is the little fiddle melody where after Luann escapes, they just go silent and then you get this little fiddle slow like it is so good.
[47:31] Jesse McAnally: Everything about this, uh zero fault. Um I love the song. Listen to it. If you listen to anything, listen to this.
[47:38] Andrew DeWolf: Now let's move on to Mama Let Me In.
[47:40] Liz Esten: Mama Let Me.
[47:47] ♪ Musical number ♪
[48:38] Andrew DeWolf: This time the Christ imagery is locked behind bars.
[48:42] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. Uh is that is that Virgin Mary or something?
[48:46] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Virgin Mary, and then it's it's photographed from behind a like a barred window or something.
[48:52] Jesse McAnally: And there's also like a lot of random. I do have a question, and this is a legitimate question.
[48:56] Andrew DeWolf: Um is it still photography if you do immense amount of photo editing afterwards?
[49:01] Jesse McAnally: I think it's a I would say it is. I think that's fine, but if you have a different view of things as an actual photographer, I would see why.
[49:08] Andrew DeWolf: Why?
[49:08] Jesse McAnally: I just am curious. Like, um, I think mixed media is perfectly fine. I just think it kind of moves away from the photo idea.
[49:18] Andrew DeWolf: But I'm often wrong and ask a real photographer instead of me.
[49:22] Jesse McAnally: Um I think that it's fine, but yeah. I mean, I think maybe it strays from the premise of like we just took pictures and then wrote songs about it.
[49:30] Andrew DeWolf: When well, we took a picture and then edited it, edited it heavily and then wrote a song about that.
[49:36] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, yeah. You know. Um But I don't I'm not opposed to it. I don't really care.
[49:40] Andrew DeWolf: I get what what is the song about, Andrew?
[49:42] Andrew DeWolf: Uh it's about a child wondering why their mother is shutting them out. And with the image, it's like, why is God shutting me out? There's a lot of questioning about faith in this show, I'm getting.
[49:52] Jesse McAnally: Apparently. Didn't love this song. Kinda kind of uh a real downer after Lee Fu Ann kind of gets you pepped up again. Uh but let's move on to the next one.
[50:00] Andrew DeWolf: Lee Wan was just Levil Wan just felt so fun and like uh I mean fun for like a story as dark as that, but yes.
[50:08] Jesse McAnally: Alright, why must we tell them why? Alex Brightman decides he's gonna turn on a school of rock for a song.
[50:13] Andrew DeWolf: Why must we tell them why? Some require an explanation for why we make the things we make.
[50:26] Jesse McAnally: Why rules must break and for who say why must we tell them why?
[50:39] Andrew DeWolf: Why excuse each deviation?
[50:42] Jesse McAnally: Why must we serve them re feature art or prove each part art?
[50:53] Andrew DeWolf: Look, all we're saying is, look, all we're saying is, all we're saying is look.
[51:20] Jesse McAnally: Yes.
[51:20] Andrew DeWolf: He tastes like you might sweep.
[51:22] Jesse McAnally: Way more like energetic than any of the previous ones as far as like electric guitar and shit.
[51:28] Andrew DeWolf: Am I thinking of the right song?
[51:29] Jesse McAnally: Yes.
[51:29] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.
[51:30] Jesse McAnally: It's the only rocky one.
[51:32] Andrew DeWolf: The picture is I I don't I don't really know what the fuck's happening.
[51:36] Jesse McAnally: A man is trying to snap his own neck, and then there's like a silhouette of him like jumping.
[51:42] Andrew DeWolf: It's like three photographs spliced together.
[51:45] Jesse McAnally: There's a bar like in front of the camera, and then there's a guy like trying to snap his own neck in different poses.
[51:52] Andrew DeWolf: Why are you trying to make sense of it?
[51:54] Jesse McAnally: Why must we explain why?
[51:55] Andrew DeWolf: Why must we tell them why?
[51:57] Jesse McAnally: It's all about conformity, man, and why you have to justify your art and why do you have to explain everything you do, man?
[52:03] Andrew DeWolf: So it's like stick it to the man from School of Rock, but different.
[52:07] Jesse McAnally: How is it different though?
[52:08] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know.
[52:09] Jesse McAnally: I'm just trying to use a descriptor because I don't remember this song very well.
[52:12] Andrew DeWolf: They even have the same like vocalist.
[52:15] Jesse McAnally: Thanks to Lord.
[52:16] Andrew DeWolf: This is Twisted Teeth, a vampire story.
[52:37] Jesse McAnally: I'm at my mister Side Night.
[52:39] Andrew DeWolf: What the Part.
[52:41] Jesse McAnally: So sorry to see him so alone in the talk.
[52:45] Andrew DeWolf: He was crying because no love would dare to come read.
[52:49] Jesse McAnally: And so I crept at the strike and whispered this in his ear.
[52:59] Andrew DeWolf: But I had your channel.
[53:11] Jesse McAnally: We made love and sky and now I'll never escape.
[53:18] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like the picture for this one is the best picture.
[53:20] Jesse McAnally: I like this picture a lot too.
[53:21] Andrew DeWolf: Uh describe what we're seeing.
[53:23] Jesse McAnally: Uh I can't.
[53:24] Andrew DeWolf: I can't figure out what the fuck it is.
[53:26] Jesse McAnally: But I think it looks cool.
[53:27] Andrew DeWolf: There's like it's like black and red, and like there's a lot of lens flare and something that looks like a like a spider.
[53:35] Jesse McAnally: It looks like a Worshack test with like human beings.
[53:37] Andrew DeWolf: Cause I see like the human being kind of aspect and it's like reflecting each other.
[53:42] Jesse McAnally: It looks like a horror poster.
[53:45] Andrew DeWolf: But like repeated four times.
[53:47] Jesse McAnally: It's cool.
[53:48] Andrew DeWolf: It looks like the Science of the Lambs poster a little bit.
[53:50] Jesse McAnally: Like that's what it reminds me the most of if it was like tinted red.
[53:53] Andrew DeWolf: It's cool.
[53:53] Jesse McAnally: Yes.
[53:54] Andrew DeWolf: Uh it's the best, it's the best picture, I think.
[53:56] Jesse McAnally: I like it the best.
[53:57] Andrew DeWolf: It's a love song about a woman who happens to be falling for a man who is crying in the dark and discovers he's a vampire, he bites her, makes her a vampire, and then from then on it's ambiguous whether their relationship is one of genuine love or just because you know they're both love vampires, so they have to be with each other.
[54:13] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.
[54:13] Andrew DeWolf: Not gonna lie, this song kind of washed over me.
[54:15] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, I think it's a good thing.
[54:16] Andrew DeWolf: Song is like whatever.
[54:17] Jesse McAnally: The song is like whatever.
[54:18] Andrew DeWolf: I got the vampire thing on first listen, but I didn't really it was like whatever.
[54:23] Jesse McAnally: This is fine.
[54:24] Andrew DeWolf: The picture was cool though.
[54:25] Jesse McAnally: I saw the picture and I was like, that's cool.
[54:27] Andrew DeWolf: The picture is really cool.
[54:27] Liz Esten: What'd you think of it, Liz?
[54:28] Jesse McAnally: You're you're a uh uh true blood fan, right?
[54:32] Liz Esten: I have never seen True Blood.
[54:33] Andrew DeWolf: Uh I've only seen the first Twilight in full.
[54:37] Liz Esten: Um, a sham on me.
[54:39] Andrew DeWolf: Um I don't honestly I don't mind vampires.
[54:43] Liz Esten: Like, they're fine.
[54:45] Andrew DeWolf: I'm not a fan of vampires.
[54:46] Liz Esten: I've seen like the first half of the vampire diaries season one.
[54:50] Andrew DeWolf: That was cool.
[54:51] Liz Esten: I saw Vampire Academy in theaters because my girlfriend really wanted to see it.
[54:54] Andrew DeWolf: It was like she read the books.
[54:56] Liz Esten: She did.
[54:57] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, that makes sense then.
[54:57] Liz Esten: That makes a lot more sense.
[54:58] Andrew DeWolf: It was our first album.
[55:01] Jesse McAnally: What's up, Andrew?
[55:01] Andrew DeWolf: Can I talk for one sec about vampires?
[55:03] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, sure.
[55:04] Andrew DeWolf: I don't like the direction that vampires have gone.
[55:06] Jesse McAnally: I don't understand why they're all romance now and whatever.
[55:10] Andrew DeWolf: Vampires are like the perfect criticism of capitalism.
[55:15] Jesse McAnally: Um and we never use it.
[55:16] Andrew DeWolf: I don't understand why.
[55:18] Jesse McAnally: I love you so fucking much, Andrew.
[55:20] Andrew DeWolf: I don't say that enough to you.
[55:23] Jesse McAnally: Would you?
[55:23] Andrew DeWolf: Like i i i i it's literally like it's a guy who lives forever and feeds off the blood of poor people.
[55:30] Jesse McAnally: It's some versions.
[55:31] Andrew DeWolf: And they live in a fucking castle.
[55:33] Jesse McAnally: They are like the aristocracy.
[55:35] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[55:36] Jesse McAnally: My favorite version of Dracula is the Udo Kier one, who whenever he drinks non-vamp virgin blood, he just like gargles for 20 minutes straight and like nearly dies.
[55:46] Andrew DeWolf: My favorite version of Frankenstein is Udo Kier too.
[55:48] Jesse McAnally: Yes.
[55:49] Andrew DeWolf: We we've moved so far away from like the vampires being about being monsters that drink blood and move towards like, well, they're romantic.
[55:57] Jesse McAnally: And like I feel like the romantic part was the part of vampires that was the least interesting.
[56:01] Andrew DeWolf: Like I don't think Dracula seduces women, whatever.
[56:05] Jesse McAnally: No, Twilight is not the full thing.
[56:07] Andrew DeWolf: I blame um Francis Ford Coppola's Dracula um adaptation for a lot of what would become of this.
[56:15] Jesse McAnally: And we can't avoid Anne Rice as much as I do think she is a quality writer.
[56:19] Andrew DeWolf: She did a lot of work to try to make vampires sexy and cute.
[56:24] Jesse McAnally: Just I I want another like make the vampire not sexy and make them a fucking monster.
[56:29] Andrew DeWolf: Have you seen the descent?
[56:32] Jesse McAnally: The descent.
[56:33] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[56:34] Jesse McAnally: That has some scary fucking vampires.
[56:36] Andrew DeWolf: Are there vampires?
[56:37] Jesse McAnally: Those are very movie.
[56:40] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, the cave, the cave.
[56:42] Jesse McAnally: Oh, I love the descent.
[56:43] Andrew DeWolf: That fucking movie's great.
[56:43] Jesse McAnally: Those are vampires.
[56:44] Andrew DeWolf: That's not vampires.
[56:45] Jesse McAnally: Are you shitting me?
[56:46] Andrew DeWolf: I thought it was like goblin monsters.
[56:49] Jesse McAnally: I swear to god, those are vampires.
[56:51] Andrew DeWolf: Those are not vampires.
[56:54] Jesse McAnally: Anyway, I like vampires.
[56:56] Andrew DeWolf: This song is fun.
[56:57] Jesse McAnally: Oh, oh, okay.
[56:58] Andrew DeWolf: Vampiric Reapers from Blade 2 were the inspiration for them.
[57:02] Jesse McAnally: Well, they weren't vampires.
[57:03] Andrew DeWolf: They were still weren't vampires.
[57:05] Jesse McAnally: They didn't suck anyone's necks.
[57:06] Andrew DeWolf: They just broke people's legs.
[57:07] Jesse McAnally: The blade movies are fucking awesome though.
[57:09] Andrew DeWolf: Some motherfuckers try to ice skate uphill.
[57:12] Jesse McAnally: Always trying to suck up hill.
[57:14] Andrew DeWolf: I will use that sound clip any chance I get.
[57:18] Jesse McAnally: Is this from Blade 1 or 2?
[57:19] Andrew DeWolf: That's from Blade 1.
[57:20] Jesse McAnally: Okay, I haven't seen either any of the blade movies.
[57:22] Andrew DeWolf: That's why I'm asking.
[57:23] Jesse McAnally: Some motherfuckers are always trying to ice skate up evil.
[57:27] Andrew DeWolf: Oh god.
[57:28] Jesse McAnally: Um let's talk about Heming and Hawing.
[57:28] Andrew DeWolf: She wouldn't pull away like you did today, though you know how I like PDA.
[57:51] Jesse McAnally: Cause I'm proud to be with you.
[57:54] Andrew DeWolf: Well, I was.
[57:56] Jesse McAnally: She wouldn't pitch a fit, wouldn't bitch a bit when I leave her alone with my friends.
[58:03] Andrew DeWolf: Cause she'd like them and they'd like her.
[58:06] Jesse McAnally: They like each other.
[58:08] Andrew DeWolf: And oh you're so not perfect.
[58:14] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, oh.
[58:27] Andrew DeWolf: I'm gonna leave you.
[58:30] Jesse McAnally: I'm gonna leave you one of these days.
[58:37] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, that that's about what I expected this image to look like for this one.
[58:45] Jesse McAnally: Uh this image is it's like a it's like yellow, and it's a guy standing facing the camera.
[58:51] Andrew DeWolf: There's a swing set, and there's a girl sitting on the swing facing away from the camera.
[58:55] Jesse McAnally: Is there something romantic about swing sets?
[58:58] Andrew DeWolf: Legitimate question, because they are often used as shorthand in romantic movies.
[59:02] Jesse McAnally: So when you're kids and you swing on the swing set and you swing together, it means you're married.
[59:06] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, it's child marriage.
[59:11] Andrew DeWolf: I was married to a few people in elementary school then.
[59:14] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.
[59:14] Jesse McAnally: See, I was the the weird autistic kid that would try to race between um all the swingers and try not to get hit by them.
[59:27] Andrew DeWolf: I did that as well.
[59:28] Jesse McAnally: That was very funny.
[59:29] Andrew DeWolf: That what does that mean?
[59:31] Jesse McAnally: I got kicked in the head a couple times.
[59:32] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, yeah, I got knocked my ass to the ground for the one kid that was like aiming for people.
[59:37] Jesse McAnally: Why did you do that?
[59:38] Andrew DeWolf: Because you register you had to see how athletic you were.
[59:42] Jesse McAnally: You had to be better than the other guys.
[59:44] Andrew DeWolf: For the people who are just listening, my hand is pure firmly in my face.
[59:48] Jesse McAnally: Um you didn't do that.
[59:54] Andrew DeWolf: Um the one I used to love going on the swing.
[59:56] Jesse McAnally: I broke my wrist on the swing um when I was a kid.
[59:59] Andrew DeWolf: Um I caught That's pathetic.
[1:00:01] Jesse McAnally: I know it is.
[1:00:01] Andrew DeWolf: Um, it was because we were I was we were playing that game and one person knocked me backwards and I just my wrist back.
[1:00:08] Jesse McAnally: I I broke my arm uh playing dodgeball or kickball because a table fell on me.
[1:00:14] Andrew DeWolf: Wait, what the f why was there a table?
[1:00:16] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, we just had we had these tables.
[1:00:18] Andrew DeWolf: The lunch tables were in the gym and they would fold up into the wall.
[1:00:22] Jesse McAnally: Oh and somebody didn't latch it very well, so the ball hit it and it fell and hit me and landed on me.
[1:00:27] Andrew DeWolf: That sounds like you could have sold the sick You could have died.
[1:00:32] Jesse McAnally: I definitely could have died if it hit my head instead of my arm.
[1:00:36] Andrew DeWolf: Well, I'm glad you're here so we can talk about uh hemming and hawing.
[1:00:41] Jesse McAnally: Um The school refused to pay for the medical.
[1:00:43] Andrew DeWolf: Are you shitting my dick?
[1:00:45] Jesse McAnally: Fuck that.
[1:00:46] Andrew DeWolf: Wherever you lived at the time.
[1:00:48] Jesse McAnally: I'm taking it that no one gave a shit about this Heming and Hawley.
[1:00:51] Andrew DeWolf: It's a song about a No no no.
[1:00:53] Jesse McAnally: Let's let's talk briefly about it.
[1:00:55] Andrew DeWolf: Um Hemming and Holling is perfectly adequate.
[1:00:58] Jesse McAnally: Anyway, moving on.
[1:00:59] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.
[1:01:00] Jesse McAnally: What's this image look like, Andrew?
[1:01:01] Andrew DeWolf: This is for cut you a piece.
[1:01:31] Jesse McAnally: Jules, he was fucked up, and Jesse, she was peerless.
[1:01:36] Andrew DeWolf: So of course they fell in love.
[1:01:40] Jesse McAnally: Jesse let Jules know what was wrong with him.
[1:01:44] Andrew DeWolf: And Jules stopped using and binging and pissing his whole life away.
[1:01:54] Jesse McAnally: Jules told Jesse he'd die for her.
[1:01:58] Andrew DeWolf: Which looking back was the right thing to say.
[1:02:16] Jesse McAnally: But the picture's upside down.
[1:02:17] Andrew DeWolf: Or it's the guy, or it's the same guy.
[1:02:19] Jesse McAnally: I can't tell.
[1:02:19] Andrew DeWolf: It's a girl.
[1:02:20] Jesse McAnally: No, it's a girl.
[1:02:21] Andrew DeWolf: And the other guy, the guy kind of is like Jonathan Groff.
[1:02:24] Jesse McAnally: A little bit.
[1:02:25] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[1:02:25] Jesse McAnally: I wouldn't be surprised if a lot of these are secretly Broadway performers, because the photographer is also one of the most prolific Broadway headshot photographers out there doing things.
[1:02:35] Andrew DeWolf: I kind of feel like these two pictures should have been like merged, like the first image was.
[1:02:39] Jesse McAnally: Like the the very first one, the Wonderland one.
[1:02:42] Andrew DeWolf: I guess, but I think the the separation is the big thing because um they fall in love, and after their wedding, the deadly car crash, um, Jesse is killed and Jules is left to live on.
[1:02:54] Jesse McAnally: Um, truly, it's hard to talk about this one because it is just an emotionally affecting number.
[1:02:59] Jesse McAnally: Um, and truly kind of sets up the world. And I like here's the thing I really hate about sad songs is they are always from the point of view of the sad person. I like that this one's kind of omniscient. It is just describing a story and the sadness within it. Cause I don't know. I find whining in songs a little annoying. But if you are describing a situation, it feels more apparent. It's the reason why Mr. Tanner is a song is so effective to me. It's not Mr. Tanner whining about navigating his opportunity. It's about just the story and you take it away. So I like that part of that about this. And that's why I think it's more emotionally affecting than say the last song about um two people that just couldn't make their marriage work out. I was gonna squeeze that in a hemming and hawing. Um yeah, what about you, Liz?
[1:03:45] Liz Esten: Yeah. Oh, about this one? Oh, uh, I liked it a lot. I think the it really does capture the emotion of like losing your partner and then wanting to move on, but always having them in the back of your head. And it really does like capture that loss very well in a way that feels real in an effective way. Um, 10 out of 10 song, probably my second favorite after Leave Luann. Now we gotta talk about the one that everyone talks about. It's a favorite song, it's everyone's fucking favorite song. It's the ballad of Sarah Barry, everyone's in a cover, everyone's done an animatic. Let's talk about it.
[1:04:11] ♪ Musical number: "The Ballad of Sarah Berry" — performed by Liz Esten ♪
[1:05:46] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, Andrew, what's the image?
[1:05:46] Jesse McAnally: Uh there's eight girls, and then there's a ninth girl, and her head is circled with red with a red marker. Alright. Now let's talk about the song then. Um high school song. Feels very Heathers. Heathers, Carrie, something like that. Yeah. Uh girl murders other girls to be prom queen. It's like the opposite of Carrie. It's how Carrie should have ended. While this is probably my second favorite song of the entire album, I think it's a little overrated.
[1:06:15] Andrew DeWolf: I thought the other song was your second favorite song.
[1:06:17] Jesse McAnally: Um, that was only the second favorite up to this point. Oh. If that makes sense. Sorry if I stated incorrectly. So, I mean, overrated is uh not really a judgment of quality. Not at all. No. No. No. It's a great song. I like it a lot. It's a different feel than everything else. It's somehow a little. It's a lot, probably the closest to Leave Luann to any of the other songs. It's like a dark kind of horror. I wish there was just a lot of dark horror songs, truly. I feel like this would be a much more it would have connected a lot more with this specific group of three people on this podcast. Um You think it should have been like a horror anthology?
[1:06:55] Liz Esten: Like a certain movie.
[1:06:56] Jesse McAnally: Yes. If it were like trick or treats. You think if it was if they made a creep show musical, it would be pretty good. Have you even watched the Creep Show Shudder series?
[1:07:09] Andrew DeWolf: I've watched the first episode. I hear it's good.
[1:07:12] Jesse McAnally: It's it's pretty good actually. Greg and Cara does a lot of directing. Uh the first is it. So it wouldn't be creep show if uh Stephen King wasn't Meteor shit. That was some of his best acting work. We are literally recording this a day before Halloween. So we're kind of in that spoopy mood.
[1:07:30] Liz Esten: Yeah. I I honestly the other thing with this one is that a lot of the better the better songs were like dark themes. So I don't know. And I think that's kind of Ryan Scott Oliver's's bread and butter. Um, and I mean there's several attempts at what I would consider horror songs in this. Um so I don't know. When they're done well, they are better than most musical theater songs. And that's truly it. And I feel like as much as we are kind of like, well, that's not really a song we have interest in. The ones that work really fucking work.
[1:08:03] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. Also, Sarah Berry, I know has like 15,000 animatics on it. 100%. They're all really good, just to be clear. I feel like this album was made to be turned into animatics.
[1:08:15] Liz Esten: Yeah. So there is a the problem with this show now that we're basically at the end because the f the finale's just a report. It's just all of the songs together. Yeah, there's no more creatures. That was the last one. So there's a problem with this show that I think is that as a show, it just doesn't I don't think it makes sense to like sit down and listen through all of this. I think you should just pick the ones that you like and listen to those because every song is like its own its own thing. You don't really need to listen to all of them. There's no there's no you're not gonna miss anything if you you know skip straight to leave Luann and don't listen to anything else. You're not gonna miss anything.
[1:08:54] Andrew DeWolf: Well, that being said, Andrew. Quickly, let's let's do a list of all the best songs in order.
[1:09:02] Jesse McAnally: Alright. Oh man. You'll type, but I'm gonna ask Matt. Okay. Where's where should I type?
[1:09:09] Andrew DeWolf: Uh just at the bottom of the screen.
[1:09:10] Jesse McAnally: Oh man, am I if I have to pick all the songs? Three of us are doing it, but I'm just gonna cross map and Liz is gonna write it. Okay, no, so we'll start from the top to the bottom and make my life easier. Uh the best one is Leave Luan. Hard agree with everyone, no one's gonna disagree.
[1:09:22] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I don't think there's uh no one's gonna argue, I don't think here.
[1:09:25] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, and then second is uh Sarah Barry.
[1:09:27] Andrew DeWolf: I like to cut you a piece better.
[1:09:29] Jesse McAnally: Oh, we okay. Okay, we're gonna have to have a I like Sarah Barry better. Are you alright? I guess that's two to one. I think Sarah Barry is better than then cut you a piece is a very close third.
[1:09:38] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. Um, and then here's where it gets I like character I would probably probably next, yep.
[1:09:44] Jesse McAnally: I agree.
[1:09:45] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[1:09:46] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, agree.
[1:09:47] Andrew DeWolf: I agree.
[1:09:48] Jesse McAnally: Um, and then probably um on oh no, um the serif serif? Probably next.
[1:09:54] Andrew DeWolf: I was gonna say the serif, yeah.
[1:09:58] Jesse McAnally: Alright, and then oof. Gosh. Now, now this is where it's this is where it gets hard. This is where it gets hard, not because we love them all. Here, I here I would probably put either. I think the party goes with you.
[1:10:11] Andrew DeWolf: Party goes with you or twisted teeth.
[1:10:13] Jesse McAnally: I'm gonna go to the party goes with you, then twisted teeth. Because I agree they're next to each other, but I think party goes with you is a little bit more interesting because we're sick of vampires. Fair. Then I'm gonna argue good lady and then on Monday. Actually, no, Crazy Town deserves to be above both of those. Crazy Town just for being weird. And then Okay, what was the wait good lady?
[1:10:35] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, Crazy Town, good lady, then on Monday.
[1:10:38] Jesse McAnally: Okay. I want to put the rock one here after that. Yep, and um do where Oh, the Follow Boy one?
[1:10:45] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, why must we tell them why? Also, I kind of want to say, I think stop time probably should have been before a lot of these.
[1:10:51] Jesse McAnally: Oh yeah, stop time exists. I think stop time should have been above all the time.
[1:10:55] Andrew DeWolf: Well, let's put that one above I'd put it above Crazy Town, at least.
[1:11:00] Jesse McAnally: I'd put it right above Twisted Teeth, honestly. Right above Twisted Teeth, and then make me happy right after everything else we said. Then mama let me in because that song bores the fuck out of me. And then is Hemming and Hawing really the worst song in the show?
[1:11:16] Andrew DeWolf: No, you forgot Immaculate Deception.
[1:11:18] Jesse McAnally: Okay, Heming and Hawing and then Immaculate Deception. Is that all of them?
[1:11:21] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it's all of them aside from the transitions. That's all of them. Uh you could probably just put the finale next to the finale's kind of its own world.
[1:11:30] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. I feel like it's just stop time again, but they mix a little bit of the other songs in there. So, our official our official uh 35mm ranking is Luance, Tara Barry, cut you a piece, Kara Lee, Seraph, Party, um, stop time, twisted teeth, crazy town, good lady on Monday. Why must we tell them why? Make me happy, mama hemming and hawing and immaculate deception slash the finale.
[1:11:54] Andrew DeWolf: And you know what? What is our overall thoughts and our overall and our cheese ratings? Andrew, you're first.
[1:12:00] Andrew DeWolf: Oh man. Overall thoughts. Uh this is it's like a big mix of it's a big mix of good and bad. Um honestly, I think for the most part it's good. Um we made like a ranking, but I would say, you know, probably all the way down to like number twelve, I still think that they're mostly good. Like m none of these are really like bad songs or anything like that. It's just some of them are peak, and then it there's just a big mix. So I guess as far as the cheese rating, you have to give it like a cheese platter, I guess. And the cheese platter of a shit ton of cheeses, and some of them are really good and some of them are not.
[1:12:39] Jesse McAnally: You know what? That is as healthy an answer as you are ever gonna get. Um Liz, what about you?
[1:12:44] Liz Esten: This it's one of those things that has like extreme highs but lows that are like, why is this here? Like it's gonna be really good, but it's either middling or just like okay. It's overall, I don't hate that experience this. It was really good. It was a really good vibe in general. I just thought some of the songs are kinda meh. Um, so I I did enjoy Leland and Sarah Barry and cut you a piece. Always great. I like most of them in general. It's just a lot of them are kinda like, would I listen to them again? No. Did I hate that I heard it? No. Maybe. So I'm gonna give this a French bread pizza from your middle school, because sometimes it's really good and sometimes it's just kinda mediocre.
[1:13:28] Jesse McAnally: Hell yeah. Um, I like the show. It's fine. I still kind of like Drew Gasparini's album a little better. It does a lot of the same things in a format that I kind of prefer and has more songs that I remember and enjoy, and it is an album I return to a lot more with a lot of the same cast members. Um so maybe that's just a me thing. But if you really like these songs, go watch the animatic. Support the local Broadway fans that are turning this into a different kind of art and interpreting them because they are doing it better than your brain can. Um, and I'm being so sincere when I say that. Um, so my cheese rating is gonna be paneer. Um, I don't know if you guys know this, but I love Indian food.
And paneer is used in Indian food, but if you use it incorrectly, it tastes horrendous. But if you use it well, it is the most delicious thing you'll ever eat. So I think that's a good kind of description for this. If it's done well, you will love it. If it is done poorly, it probably won't hit you in the right way when you're on the toilet.
[1:14:29] Andrew DeWolf: Alright. On that note, thank you guys for listening. Please follow us on iTunes, Spotify, and wherever the fuck else at Musicals with Cheese. We're on Twitter at Cheesy Musicals. We're not changing it into X, it'll always be Twitter. We're on Patreon Musical She's Instagram Musicals, cheese, YouTube page music schools cheese, Patreon Podcast, Patreon with Cheese. Email us at Musical TheatreLives at gmail.com. Our keeper of the cheese is Juliet Antonio. Here is something for you, Juliet, as an ASMR fan yourself. Leave Lewin. This show is edited by the one and the only Andrew DeWolf, and he's doing a fantabulous job. Our themes are created by Andrew DeWolf and Robyn Nash. Thank you to the Broadway Podcast Network for having us on the platform. Alright, guys, is there anything else we have left to say?
[1:15:13] Jesse McAnally: Nah, I just have Make Me Happy stuck in my head because that's stupid first line.
[1:15:17] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, we'll see you next time on Musicals with Cheese.
[1:15:28] ♪ Musical number: "Leave Luann" — performed by Jesse McAnally ♪
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
