Skip to main content
BPN Logo
271 - The Book Thief (feat. LadyKnightTheBrave)

"Hello Stars, how brave of you to rise..." This week we're talking about the new London adaptation of "The Book Thief" with our friend LadyKnighttheBrave. It is a great discussion about a very interesting and new musical. Hosts: Jesse McAnally & Andrew DeWolf... Read More

From the show: Musicals with Cheese

1 h 4 mins
11/16/23

About

"Hello Stars, how brave of you to rise..." This week we're talking about the new London adaptation of "The Book Thief" with our friend LadyKnighttheBrave. It is a great discussion about a very interesting and new musical.

Credits:

Hosts: Jesse McAnally & Andrew DeWolf

Podcast Edited By: Andrew DeWolf

Theme Songs: Robyn Nash of IOU Music UK

Keeper of the Cheese: Juliet Antonio

This show is a part of the Broadway Podcast Network

Check out this Etsy Shop

Social Media:

Our WEBSITE

Musicals with Cheese on Twitter

Musicals W/ Cheese on Instagram

Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com

Merch!!

Jess Socials

Jesse McAnally on Twitter

Jess McAnally on Instagram

Andrew Socials

Andrew DeWolf on Instagram

Andrew DeWolf on Twitter

Use our Affiliate Link

Transcript

This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.

[0:06] Jesse McAnally: Hello, I'm Jesse McAnally.

[0:08] Andrew DeWolf: And I'm Andrew DeWolf.

[0:10] Jesse McAnally: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, the podcast where I try to get Andrew to appreciate musical theater.

[0:14] Andrew DeWolf: And today, on this very exciting episode, we have a special returning guest.

[0:19] Jesse McAnally: Woo!

[0:20] Andrew DeWolf: Ooh, a returning guest.

[0:21] Jesse McAnally: Yes, those are the best guests because we're asking them to come back.

[0:24] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.

[0:24] Jesse McAnally: Um, and they didn't say no, which is the important thing.

[0:27] Andrew DeWolf: Please.

[0:29] Jesse McAnally: Yes.

[0:29] Andrew DeWolf: We've had that before.

[0:30] Jesse McAnally: It's been a bummer.

[0:32] Andrew DeWolf: Um, please join me in welcoming video creator with brilliant mind and excellent interior design skills. It's LadyKnightTheBrave!

[0:42] LadyKnightTheBrave: Woo! How are you doing today?

[0:44] Jesse McAnally: We let's pretend we didn't just talk for 45 minutes before this recording.

[0:48] LadyKnightTheBrave: I'm a little bit sweaty.

[0:50] Andrew DeWolf: Jeez, I keep you waiting that long.

[0:52] LadyKnightTheBrave: Uh, I mean, I guess, but also.

[0:55] Andrew DeWolf: I'd be pretty sweaty if I was stealing books, too.

[0:59] LadyKnightTheBrave: Oh my god.

[1:01] Jesse McAnally: You gotta get there.

[1:02] Andrew DeWolf: You gotta get to that.

[1:03] Jesse McAnally: You gotta get to that title somehow.

[1:05] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, it's classic.

[1:08] Jesse McAnally: I mean, yeah, there's no way we're gonna get there.

[1:10] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[1:11] Jesse McAnally: There was no story, there was no buildup. You just boom.

[1:13] Andrew DeWolf: It's not like we're talking about a great comic.

[1:16] Jesse McAnally: We're not talking about forum here.

[1:18] Andrew DeWolf: We kinda gotta get to this, we gotta get to the serious stuff pretty quick.

[1:21] Jesse McAnally: LadyKnightTheBrave and I both have The Book Thief book. We're just gonna hold it up constantly to show how smart we are.

[1:28] LadyKnightTheBrave: I literally cannot look at how loved my copy is.

[1:32] Jesse McAnally: This is an audio medium.

[1:34] LadyKnightTheBrave: Like, put it right up to your mic so we can hear the love.

[1:37] Jesse McAnally: Don't your patrons get a video or something?

[1:40] LadyKnightTheBrave: Oh, they do. But we wanna hear it. Put it up to the microphone, just flip through the pages so we can hear.

[1:45] Jesse McAnally: Beautiful. That's good. That's the ASMR stuff we need.

[1:48] Andrew DeWolf: We're talking about The Book Thief the Musical.

[1:57] LadyKnightTheBrave: Hello, stars.

[2:02] LadyKnightTheBrave: How brave of you to rise.

[2:08] LadyKnightTheBrave: A small but nice surprise.

[2:14] LadyKnightTheBrave: Like a friend just stopping by.

[2:23] LadyKnightTheBrave: Hello, stars.

[2:27] LadyKnightTheBrave: You see us come and go.

[2:31] LadyKnightTheBrave: When loss is all you know.

[2:36] LadyKnightTheBrave: How do you like the sky?

[2:42] LadyKnightTheBrave: Please tell me how you carry home.

[2:46] LadyKnightTheBrave: When all the ones you have are gone.

[2:51] LadyKnightTheBrave: I'll try to be like you.

[3:00] LadyKnightTheBrave: Hello, stars.

[3:04] LadyKnightTheBrave: You are my only friends.

[3:09] LadyKnightTheBrave: And when the night time ends, we'll have to say goodbye.

[3:20] Jesse McAnally: Um, so The Book Thief is a musical written by Jodi Picoult and Timothy Alan McDonald with music and lyrics by Alyssa Sampson and Kate Anderson, and premiered at the Octagon Theatre in Bolton, Greater Manchester, England, on September 17th, 2022.

[3:35] Jesse McAnally: The plot of The Book Thief is, while subjected to the horrors of World War II Germany, young Liesel finds solace by stealing books and sharing them with others. Under the stairs in her home, a Jewish refugee is being sheltered by her adoptive parents.

[3:48] Andrew DeWolf: And that is a D minus summary if I've ever seen one.

[3:51] LadyKnightTheBrave: Um, I wrote that.

[3:54] Jesse McAnally: Yes, that is a base summary. Um, LadyKnightTheBrave, you did an incredible video essay a few years ago comparing the book The Book Thief to the film Jojo Rabbit and a lot of the similar themes there. In that, I don't think there was even like a glimmer of this musical in the culture.

[4:15] LadyKnightTheBrave: Oh no, there was actually.

[4:16] Jesse McAnally: Oh.

[4:17] LadyKnightTheBrave: Um, I think because, yeah, I made it during lockdown, and I remember seeing a video of like a small child singing some version of probably the star song, or maybe a song with Rudy. And literally, when lockdown happened, I was like, oh good, the evil has been defeated.

[4:35] LadyKnightTheBrave: Um, Holocaust stories should be musicals.

[4:42] LadyKnightTheBrave: It feels really, really icky. I don't want to see a line of Jews in stripes going, I can't wait to die. Um, it just feels really gross. Cabaret is I think the closest it's come, but also there's a lot of distance in Cabaret, and this still has some distance. Don't listeners, Broadway, do not make a musical in the death camps. I'm just saying it because they already made this and I don't trust them.

[5:06] LadyKnightTheBrave: Uh, I think The Book Thief should have been a play if they're going to adapt it for the stage. But um, yeah, no, there was some glimmerings of this before lockdown happened, and I went, oh god. And then they kept going.

[5:23] LadyKnightTheBrave: Um, they did not stop. And yes, it is something we all have seen now. We have all watched The Book Thief musical. For better and for worse.

[5:32] Jesse McAnally: Um, I I'm very curious because I haven't talked to any of you about the like general taste, except for LadyKnightTheBrave. LadyKnightTheBrave, you and I had a little conversation before this, so I'm gonna put a bit in that because I know you've got things. Andrew and Liz, what are your first general thoughts on The Book Thief before they get tainted by our opinions?

[5:49] Andrew DeWolf: Andrew Hugo. Who's going to be a good one? Andrew for you.

[5:50] Andrew DeWolf: Andrew, name starts with an A.

[5:53] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, okay. Um, well, geez, is it bad that I liked it?

[5:57] LadyKnightTheBrave: Um, I've known several Gentiles did.

[6:02] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.

[6:03] LadyKnightTheBrave: Also, maybe some Jewish people, maybe some Jewish people like it. I don't know. I'm very judgy.

[6:08] Andrew DeWolf: But also, did you watch the film? Uh, Andrew. I feel like I have seen the film.

[6:11] Andrew DeWolf: That's the only thing I've seen.

[6:14] Jesse McAnally: Did you like this film?

[6:15] Andrew DeWolf: It's a long time ago. I don't remember. I was very young.

[6:19] Jesse McAnally: Um, did that come out?

[6:21] Andrew DeWolf: That came out in like 2014.

[6:22] Jesse McAnally: It came out last year, sir.

[6:24] Andrew DeWolf: It came out like 2013.

[6:25] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, I feel like I don't think I'm that much older than you. You would have been like eight.

[6:30] Andrew DeWolf: Which I consider young.

[6:32] LadyKnightTheBrave: That's a baby.

[6:33] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I was very dumb when I was 18. I think you liked it fine because we're kind of covering a lot of lesser things as of late. And this is just like, oh, minimal effort, well shot enough bootleg, um, actors giving a shit.

[6:48] LadyKnightTheBrave: Hell yeah.

[6:49] Jesse McAnally: Liz, how about you?

[6:53] Liz: I the only word I can describe this as is mid.

[6:56] Liz: It's fine.

[6:58] Liz: It's perfectly fine. I the story's fine. The actors are fine. The bootleg is fine. The songs are fine. I don't remember anything that has happened in detail.

[7:09] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know about the bootleg being fine.

[7:10] Liz: Yeah, towards the end, it got really bad because the guy recording kept zooming and scratching, and it was the worst.

[7:16] Andrew DeWolf: Well, no, there was one guy in the audience. You can't really blame them.

[7:19] Liz: Yeah, and then there's the guy in the audience where the phone was actually ringing as well.

[7:21] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, there's a phone ringing on the bootleg.

[7:21] Liz: Um, it's perfectly fine. But you can't really blame them for the bootlegging.

[7:26] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I don't blame them for the bootleg. I blame them for the rest of it.

[7:29] Liz: It's fine.

[7:30] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[7:31] Liz: I have no feelings towards this that are any strong in any way.

[7:34] Liz: Liesel was good.

[7:35] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, the child actors are fine.

[7:37] Liz: I think Rudy was a little rough, but um child actors, you know, you do your best.

[7:41] Andrew DeWolf: Death did his best.

[7:43] Liz: He was doing his like best pre-Hades Town Patrick Page impression the entire time.

[7:47] Andrew DeWolf: Wait, the narrator?

[7:49] Liz: Yeah, the narrator.

[7:50] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[7:51] Liz: Yeah.

[7:51] Andrew DeWolf: Well, last thing before LadyKnightTheBrave. Did you guys pick up that it was death before the end, or was it a twist to you guys?

[7:57] Andrew DeWolf: You told me.

[7:58] Liz: Okay.

[7:58] Andrew DeWolf: Oh.

[7:59] Liz: I knew the book was narrated by death from the minute I started it.

[8:03] Andrew DeWolf: I talked to some people who said that the twist that the narrator is death is like a twist and that people in the theater were shocked.

[8:10] Liz: So I think it's supposed to be a twist.

[8:12] Andrew DeWolf: It seems really obvious if you go in knowing, but uh he doesn't like say it outright until towards the end, I guess.

[8:20] Liz: If it's actually meant to be a twist, I'm like okay, whatever.

[8:25] Andrew DeWolf: But uh, it seems obvious if you know.

[8:29] Jesse McAnally: Um, but LadyKnightTheBrave, what did you think of this musical that you have such deep connections with from the book and your overall feelings?

[8:40] LadyKnightTheBrave: Uh, just not particularly positive.

[8:44] LadyKnightTheBrave: It's better than the movie.

[8:46] LadyKnightTheBrave: The movie's quite bad.

[8:48] LadyKnightTheBrave: Um, the movie I uh literally I feel like was made with the idea of like how can we make a Holocaust story for five-year-olds?

[8:56] LadyKnightTheBrave: Um, it's they just really like there's so much defanging of the complexity that's in the book that happens in the film, and there's some in the musical.

[9:06] LadyKnightTheBrave: I would say it's a D, you know, the movie's an F.

[9:11] LadyKnightTheBrave: It's still a lot of times it's kind of nails on chalkboard for me because there's just some stuff in it that I'm like there's a lot happening that I was not a fan of, but uh there are some things that are better than the movie, and for that I I say D plus.

[9:30] Jesse McAnally: Uh, fair enough. Um, let's just start from the basics.

[9:34] Jesse McAnally: Like, we could fucking Doug Walker this shit a little bit. Like the set design.

[9:37] LadyKnightTheBrave: Let's just start there.

[9:41] Jesse McAnally: Um, it's got a lot of things I don't particularly love where it's like we're gonna rely strictly on a minimalist stage with lighting and projections and not much else.

[9:51] LadyKnightTheBrave: And that's all modern theater though.

[9:53] Jesse McAnally: I feel like that's not a vision.

[9:55] LadyKnightTheBrave: I didn't I didn't mind the set.

[9:56] LadyKnightTheBrave: Like the set was not a thing I was thinking about.

[9:58] Jesse McAnally: At least it's it was evocative enough for me that I was like, I get what we're doing.

[10:04] LadyKnightTheBrave: And I think that they just mainly did a lot of stuff with like the temperature of the lighting, like the the basement is very like warm yellow light, and like the streets are very blue light, whatever.

[10:13] LadyKnightTheBrave: And like I followed. It was fine.

[10:15] Jesse McAnally: I do think that there are better projections that they could have used than the ones that they did, but well, let's not get there yet.

[10:22] LadyKnightTheBrave: What, you don't love the Hitler puppet?

[10:26] Jesse McAnally: I really don't like the Hitler puppet.

[10:28] LadyKnightTheBrave: I really, really, really I saw a picture of it. They were like, it's he boxes like a big paper Hitler puppet, and that's better than it sounds.

[10:38] LadyKnightTheBrave: And they sent a picture, and I was like, Hoo boy.

[10:43] Jesse McAnally: I thought it was kind of silly.

[10:45] LadyKnightTheBrave: Yeah.

[10:45] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[10:46] LadyKnightTheBrave: It's not meant to be in the book, is the problem.

[10:49] Jesse McAnally: Um, I thought he was telling like a fun story to a little kid.

[10:52] LadyKnightTheBrave: Yeah, that's what they made it in the musical, and I didn't like it.

[10:57] Jesse McAnally: So what was it originally in the book?

[10:59] LadyKnightTheBrave: Like in the book, it's just like he uh the book talks about he has these dreams at night about boxing Hitler and losing, and it's just like of an expression of his trauma of like there is a person who is at fault for like the death of your entire people and your family and everything, and it's not something that was like made cute and digestible for his little child friend.

[11:21] LadyKnightTheBrave: He kept some things to himself because there was some shit that was hard to tell his little child friend.

[11:26] LadyKnightTheBrave: And the musical really went out of their way to go like no, no, no, this is about her now.

[11:32] LadyKnightTheBrave: He's not a character on his own anymore.

[11:34] LadyKnightTheBrave: Like he is a little bit, a little bit more than the movie, again, slightly better, but like not a lot.

[11:41] Jesse McAnally: So in the I I mean, I feel like a lot of this musical and the movie from what I gather really tends to focus on the Gentile characters and making them at the forefront of the story at the expense of basically the one Jewish character with a main lead.

[11:58] LadyKnightTheBrave: Yeah, no, so like for those who haven't seen the video, you can go watch it later if you want, but like this is both and the book too. This is the genre is righteous gentile story.

[12:07] LadyKnightTheBrave: It is a popular genre, it makes Gentiles feel good. Um, I think there is a way to do it right.

[12:14] LadyKnightTheBrave: You don't see it very often, but like one of the main things is like you need to like treat the Jews as people and not as like tragic little props that the Gentiles are saving.

[12:24] LadyKnightTheBrave: And they do a little bit in the musical, um, but like there's so much that the book did that was so vivid and interesting that is lost in the translation.

[12:35] LadyKnightTheBrave: So like it becomes so much more when he leaves Himmel Street, that becomes about Liesel now. It wasn't before, that was just like when Hans gave a Jewish person bread, which again another moment that's really awkward in the staging because he has to go here, have some bread loudly enough that the soldier can hear him.

[12:55] LadyKnightTheBrave: And I'm like, you wouldn't do that. That's stupid. But that happened, and they were like, oh no, the Nazis are gonna come banging down our door and find a Jew in our basement. And so he just left and he left them a note that said, you've done enough. And that's all it was. It wasn't about Liesel, and they made it all about her. Her being like, how dare he leave me? Everybody leaves me. And I'm like, shut up. I will not call a child that, but man, I wanted to.

[13:23] LadyKnightTheBrave: Yeah, no, there's just a lot of choices like that made throughout this adaptation that are just like, how can you make this Jewish character less interesting and highlight the Gentiles more? I yeah, yeah. I feel all these things, and once again, there is a way to do this in interesting ways with a similar narrative. Um, I think you highlighted Jojo Rabbit being something that high does this where the Jewish person, the Jewish character is still very much a character, very much integral, very much an emotional part of that story.

[13:56] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, no, like I got other issues with that film, but I think Jojo Rabbit probably best. Like, I think Book Thief is a good version of this story for like pre-2016 era, like when we were still young and had hope. Um, and you know, after that, you need something that's a little bit more blatant, being like, this is stupid, this sucks. Let me look at the camera and tell you this is stupid. He sucks.

[14:21] LadyKnightTheBrave: Um, this is a the Book Thief is a lot more gentle in its handling of something. Like, it makes its opinions clear, but it's a lot more tame in its handling, and like that was good for me pre-2016. And I'm like, now I think I need something a little bit more pointed, but I still love it. I still think it's good. Um, and I mean, it makes me think of other like Holocaust films and stories from the time that I think a little pandering, like The Boy in the Striped Pajamas, which speak to me of the cursed work.

[14:54] LadyKnightTheBrave: Fucking hate that movie. Obviously, but that is kind of what these adaptations seem to be trying to push it toward.

[15:02] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[15:03] LadyKnightTheBrave: Much more towards like. Very much so. Um, and that you bring that up, we should talk about the book writer, who is not a playwright, they are very much a novelist. Um famously wrote My Sister's Keeper and many other kind of books your mom would read and make her feel real.

[15:24] Andrew DeWolf: Books that I read in high school.

[15:26] LadyKnightTheBrave: Um, well, My Sister's Keeper is more interesting than its movie adaptation. I'll give it that.

[15:33] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I think she wrote her movie adaptation though.

[15:39] LadyKnightTheBrave: Ripped. She killed the wrong sister in the movie. It's really stupid. The wrong sister dies in the movie. I can't, I'll never recover. Um, people were crying in the theater, and I was going, no, wait, no.

[15:53] Andrew DeWolf: Like the last like 15 minutes of the movie.

[15:56] LadyKnightTheBrave: She didn't write the screenplay for the movie. It was Jeremy Levin and Nick Cassavetis.

[16:02] Andrew DeWolf: The notebook guy.

[16:04] LadyKnightTheBrave: Yeah, the notebook guy. So that's what the wrong sister did. Because notebook guy.

[16:08] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[16:08] LadyKnightTheBrave: Like basically, she is Jewish. Um, so this is the rare case where I'm actually standing up for a Gentile's work about the Holocaust over a Jewish person. This does not happen. But like, this is the rare one. I don't know.

[16:23] LadyKnightTheBrave: Um, she tends to be kind of heavy-handed um as a writer. And I just I think that her take on this is very like again, making it very digestible, sanding off a lot of the edges, the whole love over hate thing. The problem is a lot of people like to tell Holocaust stories and overly sort of mythologize it into it's about hate, it's about all bigotry. And it's like, no, it's actually about some very specific bigotry that came from some very specific places.

[16:53] LadyKnightTheBrave: And by oversimplifying and making it about all bigotry, you actually remove a lot of the nuance of this particular genocide. And apparently that's her take. And I'm like, that's unfortunate, my dude. I wonder, and this is a sincere feeling. If this were developed anywhere outside of the UK, maybe it would have had a much more pointed reaction.

[17:14] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know about that.

[17:15] LadyKnightTheBrave: Um, I'm not so sure about that, but I know the UK as far as like this specific political issue and their musicals representing anything other than feel good, sing ABBA, and go home.

[17:28] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, that's true.

[17:29] LadyKnightTheBrave: Yeah, I don't, I don't know. Um, things that are I literally have a list. Things that are good. I think the suitcases as a visual motif are good. He talks about how he picks up souls and he carries them in his arms and stuff like that. Him carrying around a suitcase as like the place he's carrying souls is a cool visual motif. I like it.

[17:49] Andrew DeWolf: Um, the opening line is correct. The show should always open with death saying you are going to die.

[17:54] LadyKnightTheBrave: Everything after that is bad because I'm pretty sure they were trying to keep the reveal of him being death a secret, so they changed the rest of that speech to something less good. Um, the opening line is correct.

[18:09] LadyKnightTheBrave: The opening song is I think the closest the show gets to being an effective musical. Uh, like an effective adaptation of the book. Um, I think that it should have been a play.

[18:24] LadyKnightTheBrave: Um, and uh I thought the choreography was nice. Um, yeah, I have a lot of notes about things I would change about this show if I were to try to fix it as being a musical. Like, all right, we're stuck with it as a musical. What can we fix? I have a lot of notes.

[18:39] Andrew DeWolf: Would you bring on as the writer?

[18:41] LadyKnightTheBrave: Like, oh that I don't know. Like, I don't know who would fix this. I mean, like, I think Dunkin' Sheik might be a better uh like or um Dave Malloy, somebody who has like interesting discordant sort of musical touches because like that's my thing is this sounds too fucking friendly. I'm like, I don't want this to sound this cozy.

[19:04] LadyKnightTheBrave: I want something uncomfortable and discordant, like especially for death. I didn't like how fucking friendly he sounds. I like death should be a creepy Greek chorus, death should be played by multiple actors. Like, I the dude was fine. I thought he was fine. He did fine with what he was given.

[19:22] LadyKnightTheBrave: But um, like I before we move on too far away from the songs, I do want to talk about the composers really quick.

[19:30] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.

[19:30] LadyKnightTheBrave: Um, do you know Alyssa Samson and Kate Anderson?

[19:34] Andrew DeWolf: Nope.

[19:35] LadyKnightTheBrave: Um, I didn't either, but I did well look up them while watching this. They just did an off-Broadway show that a lot of people claim is good. I am not a fan of it. I don't like it called Between the Lines. It's about diving into books or something.

[19:49] Andrew DeWolf: Um it was weird.

[19:51] LadyKnightTheBrave: Did they just go, you wrote a show about books? Here you go. I think they got their start. I think they were proteges of Kristen Anderson Lopez and Bobby Lopez, because their big first break is the um frozen 30-minute film before Coco, uh Frozen Fever.

[20:11] Andrew DeWolf: No, Frozen Ever After.

[20:13] LadyKnightTheBrave: Yeah, they wrote like frozen.

[20:15] Andrew DeWolf: I'm pretty sure it's Frozen Fever because there's Tangled Ever After and there's Frozen Fever.

[20:19] LadyKnightTheBrave: I think that I know this. It's a good thing.

[20:20] Andrew DeWolf: Olaf's Frozen Adventure.

[20:22] LadyKnightTheBrave: That garbage. Um, the TV special, 30 minutes long. They hold you hostage so you can see Coco for 30 minutes.

[20:31] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[20:31] LadyKnightTheBrave: And they wrote all the songs about it. That's bad. And then you can watch Coco.

[20:35] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[20:36] LadyKnightTheBrave: And it just came to life. They were writing this fairy tale Disney wannabe bullshit.

[20:41] Andrew DeWolf: Wait, they're writing Wish.

[20:43] LadyKnightTheBrave: Oh, they just okay.

[20:45] Andrew DeWolf: I get you.

[20:45] LadyKnightTheBrave: They I don't think they wrote Wish, did they?

[20:48] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know.

[20:48] LadyKnightTheBrave: Like, you were talking, I'm like, what else is there? Because that one seems very like Disney brand Disney.

[20:54] Andrew DeWolf: No, I it just for the Book Thief, it felt like Disney brand Disney into a subject matter that did not need that vibe in any way whatsoever.

[21:03] LadyKnightTheBrave: There's so many little things that they cut from. I'm just every version cuts the bit, and it's one of the strongest bits in the book, where when Liesel says, I hate Hitler, Hans slaps her across the face because he's like, that's dangerous. You can't say that.

[21:19] Andrew DeWolf: Um, every version is like, no, no, no, we can't have good friendly papa do that. He's gotta do something else.

[21:26] LadyKnightTheBrave: I just every time I'm like, all right, fine. Sorry. I do have a question about Rory.

[21:34] Andrew DeWolf: That is that the character's name.

[21:36] LadyKnightTheBrave: Rudy, I'm so sorry.

[21:38] Andrew DeWolf: Um, was he that obsessed with Jesse Owens in the book?

[21:41] LadyKnightTheBrave: Kind of, or is that um, I don't know that that should have been a musical number. That's one of the many moments in the show where I was like, I don't think this should have been a musical number.

[21:49] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, there are several of them.

[21:54] LadyKnightTheBrave: Well, no, I'm just like act two opener should be, I don't know, Liesel writing in the basement, or honestly, the act two opener should have been death going, like the sky is the color of Jews, and Nazis are dying in Russia.

[22:09] LadyKnightTheBrave: Like, he does that in the book. He often will just step back and be like, here's what's happening in the rest of the world right now. And frankly, that would have been a lot more interesting than a number about Rudy's thing with Jesse Owens.

[22:20] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, he does like Jesse Owens, and it's a chance for the book to comment on just like the way that this bigotry functions, where like he's a child, he doesn't understand that Jesse Owens is a black man, and so like uh his father tells him, like, you have good, safe blue eyes, you should be happy with that.

[22:40] LadyKnightTheBrave: Um, he literally covers himself in charcoal and runs down a street. Uh yeah, again, it's I think it makes sense in context. It's good they cut that, but like so they just have this number where he sings about Jesse Owens, and I'm like, okay, all right, alright. But of all the things they cut, I'm like, I don't, I don't know why you kept that.

[23:03] Andrew DeWolf: Um, yeah, I it felt weirdly discordant from everything else, and made a character which I think we're supposed to be like ruefully empathetic with.

[23:13] LadyKnightTheBrave: I I hated every I was really like dreading any time he came on stage for the show.

[23:17] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, no, Rudy and the music.

[23:20] LadyKnightTheBrave: It's hard to translate this. I do think movie Rudy might have handled this a little bit better because um again, part of the translation to stage just makes some characters broader, and I don't think that works for Rudy either, because it's very cute.

[23:33] LadyKnightTheBrave: It's just him going, like, how about a kiss sound? Like, just it's it's and it and it just he comes off very grating and pushy, and it's like, yeah, he's being a little pushy. They're like 10.

[23:44] Andrew DeWolf: Um, but in uh it comes off worse in the show every time he shows up to badger Liesel. I'm like, oh god.

[23:52] LadyKnightTheBrave: Um, yeah, no, you are supposed to like him a lot. He's like her one friend.

[23:58] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, um, not a fan, like it's obviously not a good thing when you dread a character coming on stage or anything like that.

[24:07] LadyKnightTheBrave: Um, so as an overall experience, a time at the theater, I think it also just fails. I think as far as that goes, like removing all the social context, anything that you'd want in a musical is also just kind of not there.

[24:21] Andrew DeWolf: The choreography's nice.

[24:23] LadyKnightTheBrave: That's like my one thing. It's like I think the choreography is nice. I don't hate the whole like them like making books fly around and some of the puppetry, some of it, not Hitler.

[24:34] Andrew DeWolf: But some of the other puppets that are like clearly made out of book pages, I was like, that's charming. I don't hate it.

[24:41] LadyKnightTheBrave: Um, you know, there's there's some stuff here that I'm just like, if this were a play, you know, in the vein of a monster calls or ocean at the end of the lane, where it's like, yeah, we're gonna get weird and artistic and we're gonna have funky visuals to represent some things.

[24:58] LadyKnightTheBrave: We're just not gonna sing. I'm like, and this is I love musicals. I am not going to frequently advocate for people to stop singing, but this is the time.

[25:07] Andrew DeWolf: Um, that one, the Nazi number in the bar, the upsettingly cheerful, you're late, you're late to the party.

[25:15] LadyKnightTheBrave: That's the joke. They sing you're late to the party. And I was like, this really wishes it was tomorrow belongs to me, and it's not, and I hate it here.

[25:26] LadyKnightTheBrave: I hated that song just because the audience was laughing at it, like the actual audience was laughing at the time. I love them too. I'm like, I don't want comedy Nazis here. The tone isn't right. This doesn't work. This would work if there wasn't no dramatic musical. It doesn't make them look dumb enough for it to really show that they're making fun of it.

[25:49] LadyKnightTheBrave: Yeah, there's so many bits that I was just like, I don't like this tonally. I don't like what this is doing. Oh no. I don't like when death, because death cheekily says to the audience, like, I don't get a lot of applause in my line of work, uh, so I'm gonna play characters in the show, which like that feels right. That feels like a thing that death in the book would say. I thought that was cute. Um, but like when he shows up dressed as a nun doing man in dress, transphobic humor, I was like, oh, this is unnecessary. He could be anybody other than a nun. Wee. And the audience loved it. Well, that's British. Um British theater. Um, um Andrew, I felt like you had something to say.

[26:39] Andrew DeWolf: No? I mean, I don't know. I feel like I don't fully agree with the negativity, I guess. Like, bring it on. I thought that I thought that there were good themes in this. I really like the themes of um like loss and like I thought it was pretty emotional personally. I guess I don't know. I don't know. I get where you're coming from, because you're seeing a watered down version of something else. A watered down version of something very good. Even a watered-down version of this very good story still has some bits that hit because the story it's working from is quite good. So like I'm just like, the book is a lot better, is what I would say. But like, yeah, no, I'm not gonna fault you for like feeling some feelings during parts of the show.

There are parts of the show that have feelings in them. Uh I still have a lot of feelings about Max, even though I think that this version, while still pretty good. Um, I do think Ben Schnitzer in the film was actually a bit better. Um again, just this bringing it to the stage, Max is a lot bigger and broader and louder, and he's a very withdrawn character, and like there might have been a way to do that on stage. This is not it. Um I like that the show remembers he's a boxer. The movie didn't. Um, and the bit where he uh does a Shabbos prayer with his mother from afar was nice. You know, he wore a yarmulk at Liesel's wedding. That was nice. Um, but I think Andrew, what things really affected you? And I get that all these things are also just point of view things. Do you also agree that maybe this is a subject matter that shouldn't be a musical?

[28:18] Andrew DeWolf: I agree that we shouldn't have like uh, you know, kick lines in the death camps. That's uh that's not good, obviously. But I don't think that I don't think that this show did that. Listen, I just hear Broadway uh not having any restraint. Uh that's just a large. I just don't I don't think that this show did that necessarily. I don't know. It bothers me a lot when they all just have like these very thick cockney accents too, where it all feels very Oliver Twist and less. I it's not a little bit.

[28:46] LadyKnightTheBrave: Well, I think that that's because that this was made in England. Yeah. Honestly, what it reminded me of is like if there were to be a comedy number, and this is a very different tonal show, but I saw the transparent musical. That's not a thing. I don't know if it'll ever get to Broadway, but it was here in LA, and they wanted to bring it to Broadway. And there is a comedy number at the beginning of Act 2, that is a very good comedy number where they sing, it's a great time to be gay and Jewish in Germany in 1940 or whatever. And it's like the comedy is pointing in the correct direction where you're like, oh, oh my god, like it's funny, but it's also really dark. And like that's the kind of humor that I think the show should have.

Like, I don't hate the idea of a comedy number. I don't like the execution of it. Um I just I think the Nazis being the ones to do it is fine because the Nazis are properly portrayed as fucking horrible in the entire rest of the show. And in reality, Nazis are kind of like stupid and funny as a concept, but obviously when they're real, they're horrifying and awful because you know what they do. But like if you listen to one talk, they sound like stupid.

[30:03] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I mean, it's just it's one of those things where, like, and again, I'm coming at this as somebody who is a huge fan of the book. So, like, I'm considering how they're using their real estate, because there's a lot they cut from the book. And some of it I understand. Some of it I'm like, I get that we had to cut some stuff. But like, Max is in a huge part of the book, and he's in like some of act one, and then shows up as like a little aside a couple of times in act two. And I'm just like, how the real estate is being used in the show several times. I'm like, this is what we're gonna spend it on. And you're late to the party as a comedy number. I'm like, I don't know. The I think Rudy had a song or should have had a song about like, do you want to kiss me so much?

If that wasn't actually a song, that's the correct place for it. Again, execution rough, and I think the child actor was a little rough for Rudy. But like, that's the kind of point where I'm like, okay, yes.

[31:01] LadyKnightTheBrave: Um, Andrew, you did bring up a point that I wanted to make sure that you were able to talk up. Um, you one of the things that I think you found most powerful about this is its display of fascism and how as a political standard at all, it affects everyone negatively, no matter who you are.

[31:17] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I think that JoJo Rabbit does this better, but um I do think that I think it's interesting to show how even the people that fascism is supposed to help, it doesn't help them at all, you know?

[31:31] LadyKnightTheBrave: Yeah, no, which is something that the book takes a lot farther. Like, this is a little thing, and this is just book purist. I was like, I know this is me being in my feelings right now, but this annoyed me. Um, so Frau Hapslaffel is the neighbor that Rosa and her like spit at each other, and they have like a thing. That is in the book. Yeah. In act two, they bring it back, and I'm like, because in act two, by that point in the story, Frau Hapslofel's son had committed suicide, and her other had died in the war, and she was like terminately depressed. Liesel would read to her, and I'm like, no, we shouldn't be joking anymore. And like Rosa having a comedy song about how annoying her husband is when she was like actually just like crying over his accordion every night when she thought Liesel was asleep. Um stuff like that. Like, just the book takes that idea much farther in execution.

[32:24] Andrew DeWolf: I actually thought that that song was effective. The trauma sort of thing. It was when it turned at the end and got sad. I was like, okay, but again, I some of this. I thought that that was a good execution, though, because it's like it's a funny number, and you're like, dang, she's really callous. And then you're like, oh wait, she's masking it all. Some of this is helping me.

[32:42] LadyKnightTheBrave: Yeah, but I think Rosa is another character who suffers because she doesn't get a lot of real estate. So like you don't really get a lot of her complexity until I think that moment. Um, whereas like in the book, we have there's a whole sequence they cut. I kind of get it, and I kind of am annoyed. I don't know, I'm not sure again, real estate. Max gets sick, and there is a point where they're like, Hans and Rosa have an earnest discussion about what do we do if we have a Jewish dead body in our basement? Um, like just things like that. When Max shows up like falling over, starving, Rosa's like, here, let me get you food. And he's like puking it up, and because he hasn't eaten in a really long time.

And she's like, Alright, here you go. Here's another bowl. Like, just she is a very harsh character. And I don't think that the musical gives her a lot of moments to show that off until literally that one song. Um so again, just a lot, some of these are nitpicks. I'm going to freely admit I am I am absolutely nitpicky.

[33:43] Andrew DeWolf: One of my things that I think that the music I mean, I can agree that a lot of the characters did feel underdeveloped, yeah. They focused probably too much time onto honestly. I think that little boy got too much time.

[33:55] LadyKnightTheBrave: Yeah, I mean, like one straight up. Like there was just not very much interesting about that, the little boy. He's better in the book. I would say I'd say that actually, in terms of just text adaptation, he's probably one of the more accurate handlings. I just think that kid wasn't great. Um, unfortunately, I kid actors are a toss-up. You just that's that's the roll of the dice, and I think that child was doing his best.

[34:21] Andrew DeWolf: Um the concept of like the the kid in Nazi Germany that loves uh Jesse Owens is fun and like interesting, but there's only so much you can do with that. No, and again, this is one of those things where just because a lot of stuff gets cut, so you get you miss a lot of the times like when his father gets taken away to also be in the war, and like Liesel's running through the Jews, being marched to Dachau, getting beaten by a Nazi soldier, and Rudy's the one pulling her away, like we gotta go. Um, just moments that really illustrate like the value of their friendship, uh are lost in the shuffle. One of the things that I think would have been really good is so in the book, he Max writes stories for Liesel.

Every adaptation does this thing where he paints over the pages of Mein Kampf, and every adaptation has gone, and then he gives it as a journal to Liesel so she can write her magical words. And what it actually is is his sketchbook that he writes and draws in, and he writes stories for Liesel in it. I think eventually he gives it to her and she writes in it, but like his stories are a major part of it. And the word shaker is one of his stories, which is sort of in the musical, but Liesel writes it now. He sort of says a couple lines from it in the paper Hitler boxing sequence, but mainly it's a story that Liesel writes now. And one of the bits of projections that I thought would have been better is if they included like some of the illustrations from the book projected and animated those and put them up on the screen instead of whatever they were doing instead, because the illustrations of the book are extremely evocative.

And um, yeah, no, like I just that was one of the things that I was like on the edge of my seat. Are they gonna include one? And then they did, and then it was written by Liesel, and I'm like, again, just taking away from the Jewish character and aspects that made him interesting, uh, to just like further make it about Liesel.

[36:20] LadyKnightTheBrave: I did find it odd that he gave uh a blank guy. Um like where'd you even get that? No, it's Mein Kampf. You just had a he they say How did he get every single page to be blank? He painted over it. He literally painted over all of them. Yes, literally that's all he did. Um Hans, I think they might have cut this in the show. They didn't do a very good job of it. No, um, so like literally in the book, if you look closely at some of these illustrations, you can see like words leading through a little bit in some of them. Like uh it's uh Hans, I don't think the show mentions this. Hans actually works as a painter, like painting buildings and walls and shit. So like it's literally just his white paint lying around that Max uses to paint over the water.

They do mention it in the in the in the show. Okay, I couldn't remember if they mentioned that bit. Um but yeah, so that's that's what it is. He paints over the words of Mein Kampf, which is very like, yes, thematically yes. Um, but then it just becomes about her.

[37:21] Andrew DeWolf: Sounds like a lot of the issue is that they focus too much on on the weasel.

[37:26] LadyKnightTheBrave: Yeah, and I think just like the love over hate, like ending on this very it's very much oversimplifying. I again, as a book purist, am very annoyed that I think the last line of the show is probably just them singing love over hate or something like that, when it should actually be Death saying, I am haunted by humans. That's the last line of the book, and it's incredibly evocative, and I'm mad that they cut it.

[37:51] Andrew DeWolf: Speaking of haunted by humans, how about we talk about our favorite section? It's the previews letterbox game, where we compare our opinions to those of the real critics that haunt me that over on letterbox.com.

[38:07] LadyKnightTheBrave: You were haunted by your patrons.

[38:12] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, that's also late night. Good news. Uh Transfer Musical is going to Broadway according to a July 10th article. So somebody said that it was like, ah, they just released those articles and then it means nothing. I don't know if something's going to be common, but I did find an article by variety. So we'll see.

[38:28] LadyKnightTheBrave: Yeah, just like the Variety Marvel article. So this is um, Lady Knight, do you remember how this game goes?

[38:34] Jesse McAnally: We have to guess one star or five star.

[38:37] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, okay.

[38:38] Jesse McAnally: Um, you know what? And this is I'm guessing release of the film. I'm reading them as we speak, Jeff, so I cannot participate in this game.

[38:46] LadyKnightTheBrave: Um no, I was gonna say, Late night, do you want to go up against me or Andrew?

[38:50] Andrew DeWolf: Well, Andrew's usually the one who does it, right?

[38:53] LadyKnightTheBrave: That's usually how it comes to the biggest thing. I'm trying to jazz things up.

[38:57] Jesse McAnally: Jess, didn't you find or are you feel alive? What if all three of us do it?

[39:02] Andrew DeWolf: Nah, I'll just put you up against Andrew.

[39:05] LadyKnightTheBrave: Alright!

[39:09] Andrew DeWolf: I don't want to lose against Andrew.

[39:11] Jesse McAnally: That's true. Also, uh you can get them from Jess or me. Uh, you take you make your choice.

[39:16] LadyKnightTheBrave: The L team.

[39:17] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, you guys are gonna take the L's.

[39:19] Jesse McAnally: Okay. We must. You need to participate. I'm so sorry. Liz, why don't you go first?

[39:26] LadyKnightTheBrave: Pick one, Liz.

[39:27] Jesse McAnally: Okay, I'm ready. Go.

[39:30] LadyKnightTheBrave: You're tearing me apart, Liesel.

[39:35] Jesse McAnally: That's a good one. That is a good one. That's where we're starting. We're starting at a nine here, kids.

[39:39] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, we're starting. Who's who who's guessing first? Me or Andrew?

[39:42] LadyKnightTheBrave: Oh, no, you're guessing. That's you.

[39:44] Andrew DeWolf: I when I say you guess.

[39:46] LadyKnightTheBrave: Okay. Um, I'm gonna guess five stars.

[39:49] Jesse McAnally: That's a one.

[39:50] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. What? You come up with a great line like that and then you give it a one star?

[39:55] LadyKnightTheBrave: That was a good one.

[39:56] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, Andrew. Why the effort?

[39:58] Jesse McAnally: Not if it is by the movie. Does it count if I watch the musical?

[40:03] LadyKnightTheBrave: Apparently not. Uh we're gonna give it a one.

[40:07] Jesse McAnally: That is a five.

[40:08] Andrew DeWolf: We're zero for zero!

[40:10] LadyKnightTheBrave: Zero zero.

[40:11] Jesse McAnally: Okay, yeah, fair enough. Max is a smash.

[40:15] Andrew DeWolf: I'm sorry, just I'm they're not wrong. Um, he's a beautiful man.

[40:23] LadyKnightTheBrave: Ben Schnitzer is beautiful, so's the guy in the musical.

[40:26] Andrew DeWolf: They're both beautiful men. Beautiful men.

[40:28] Jesse McAnally: Um I'm going to say one star.

[40:32] LadyKnightTheBrave: Five.

[40:33] Andrew DeWolf: Damn it! I'm always trying to do opposite because I'm like, it's so often opposite day.

[40:39] Jesse McAnally: It's only opposite 40% of the time.

[40:42] LadyKnightTheBrave: Depends on who's gathering them. Andrew, are you ready?

[40:45] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, yeah. My 10th grade English teacher made this boring.

[40:48] LadyKnightTheBrave: Made this boring?

[40:50] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, made it boring.

[40:52] Jesse McAnally: Okay. Weren't they weren't engaged because of their tenth grade teacher.

[40:56] Andrew DeWolf: Now, is that regarding the book or is it regarding the film? Or the musical.

[41:00] LadyKnightTheBrave: It's probably both. They probably read the book and then watched the film.

[41:04] Andrew DeWolf: That's 10th grade English for you.

[41:06] Jesse McAnally: Yep. Great great Gatsby in 10th grade English. American education, right?

[41:13] LadyKnightTheBrave: I mean one star, right? They were bored.

[41:15] Andrew DeWolf: Yep. That is the first point on the board, Andrew.

[41:19] LadyKnightTheBrave: Watch this in class and fell asleep.

[41:23] Andrew DeWolf: One star.

[41:24] LadyKnightTheBrave: Correct. Okay. Alright, Andrew.

[41:27] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. I like Liesel's voice.

[41:31] LadyKnightTheBrave: Okay. Um. Is that enough to be a five-star?

[41:34] Andrew DeWolf: I think it is. We're gonna go five.

[41:36] LadyKnightTheBrave: We're gonna go five. That's correct.

[41:39] Andrew DeWolf: I'm trying to look up what popular show she's on now.

[41:41] LadyKnightTheBrave: Yellow jacket.

[41:42] Andrew DeWolf: I was gonna say, I'm gonna say the Liesel actress is on Yellowjackets.

[41:45] LadyKnightTheBrave: Now that now we've said it. You can't yell at us.

[41:47] Jesse McAnally: Is that a spinoff of Yellowstone?

[41:50] LadyKnightTheBrave: No, it's a very popular show.

[41:52] Andrew DeWolf: It's about Yellowstone has a thousand spinoffs.

[41:56] LadyKnightTheBrave: No, no, no. It's a girl's plane accident on an island.

[42:00] Andrew DeWolf: I think there's cannibalism in like witchcraft.

[42:02] LadyKnightTheBrave: Yeah, there's cannibalism, witchcraft. Yeah, it's fun time.

[42:04] Andrew DeWolf: And they're adults too, and they deal with their own shit there. It's a lot.

[42:07] LadyKnightTheBrave: I like cannibalism in witchcraft. That's it's very popular on Twitter, so it's important that we mention that, or else we will be crucified by the English.

[42:14] Jesse McAnally: But is it popular on Tumblr? They are the true tastemakers of the internet.

[42:18] LadyKnightTheBrave: So we must mention how many ships.

[42:20] Andrew DeWolf: She plays I have to block the tag because some stuff from it is gross.

[42:24] LadyKnightTheBrave: So I don't want to see random gift sets of like mutilated dead bodies.

[42:29] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, they start eating each other. So it's like the Hannibal fandom.

[42:32] LadyKnightTheBrave: Yes. Yeah. Yeah.

[42:33] Andrew DeWolf: That's contempt.

[42:34] LadyKnightTheBrave: Yeah, for lesbians.

[42:35] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, it's lesbian Hannibal. That's probably the best way to describe the Yellowjackets fan.

[42:40] LadyKnightTheBrave: Well, signalism is sexy. Um, is it my turn?

[42:43] Andrew DeWolf: Is it interesting?

[42:46] LadyKnightTheBrave: Oh, no, I you didn't believe it just.

[42:48] Andrew DeWolf: Nah, it's my turn.

[42:49] LadyKnightTheBrave: Okay. Yeah.

[42:50] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. Yeah. High school sophomores really love this one.

[42:55] LadyKnightTheBrave: Aw, five stars.

[42:56] Andrew DeWolf: Correct. Alright, Andrew. It's your time to either win it or look like a huge clown.

[43:01] LadyKnightTheBrave: Are you ready? Because your time.

[43:03] Andrew DeWolf: I'm always looking like a huge clown. So I it's fine either way.

[43:07] Jesse McAnally: Great. I feel empty now.

[43:09] Andrew DeWolf: Damn. Was the movie that bad?

[43:10] LadyKnightTheBrave: I literally it is that bad. I watched like one scene of it and I got it.

[43:13] Andrew DeWolf: I watched it in theater. I watched it at a midnight screening. I was so excited.

[43:17] LadyKnightTheBrave: I considered driving 90 minutes to a nearby larger city where it was showing first because it was limited release.

[43:24] Andrew DeWolf: I cannot stress I was so hyped for this movie, and it was extremely bad.

[43:27] LadyKnightTheBrave: It's like me and I remember the there was the guy that played the accordion.

[43:31] Andrew DeWolf: Yep. And there was like a house that they kept going to that had books in it.

[43:35] LadyKnightTheBrave: Yep. Those are the two things I remember. Did she steal from the house?

[43:38] Andrew DeWolf: Yes.

[43:39] LadyKnightTheBrave: What's that? Did she steal from the house?

[43:40] Andrew DeWolf: She stole from the house.

[43:41] LadyKnightTheBrave: Okay, good. Want to make sure they did miss the literal point.

[43:44] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. Well, no, she steals from the books that are burned first.

[43:47] LadyKnightTheBrave: Like it's was there even an analog to that house in the musical?

[43:51] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like there was. She talks to the lady who owns that house several times.

[43:55] LadyKnightTheBrave: I don't think they ever I don't I I think the scene where they're dancing around with books is meant to be the library scene.

[44:01] Andrew DeWolf: Because like I I feel like the whole movie was them at that house. Like that was like that's the only thing I remember.

[44:04] LadyKnightTheBrave: No, it's not that much.

[44:09] Andrew DeWolf: Well, I think back to that movie, I'm like, there was, yeah, there was the guy with the accordion, he died. And then they were at that house.

[44:09] LadyKnightTheBrave: The guy with the accordion is Jeffrey Rush, by the way, of Pirates of the Caribbean Fame.

[44:20] Andrew DeWolf: Also, did she learn how to play the accordion at the end?

[44:23] LadyKnightTheBrave: No. Um, so I'm imagining that because I have like a vague. I mean, if that happened in the movie, I erased it um from my mind.

[44:31] Andrew DeWolf: But like, no, I think she like might mess around with it once or twice because it's his and she misses him, but like I don't think she learned to play it.

[44:39] LadyKnightTheBrave: Okay. Andrew, I feel like the musical was like I I felt like the uh the the musical was directly calling the movie out when the death was like, oh, you carried that accordion and never learned how to play it? And I was like, oh, because she learned how to play it in the movies.

[44:54] Andrew DeWolf: No, that was just a random shade for no reason.

[44:58] LadyKnightTheBrave: Shade.

[45:00] Jesse McAnally: Okay, okay. Did you ever guess the answer to this?

[45:03] Andrew DeWolf: No. I just went on a rant.

[45:07] LadyKnightTheBrave: I swear to God, Andrew, you review movies like I do when I was five. Like someone asked me, Hey, did you watch The Princess Bride? And I said, Yeah, it was boring. It's about four people climbing up a mountain for three hours.

[45:17] Andrew DeWolf: That is what my interpretation of the Princess Bride at five.

[45:20] LadyKnightTheBrave: Dan, that is what happened, isn't it?

[45:21] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like what's wrong with you?

[45:25] LadyKnightTheBrave: I feel until no, no, no. Great. I feel unfortunate. One star then.

[45:28] Andrew DeWolf: We're gonna say one star.

[45:29] LadyKnightTheBrave: That is a five-star, and y'all time! And that is the game. Um, so let's go into a mid-show talk about our patrons, then.

[45:39] Jesse McAnally: I guess talk about one or two of the songs.

[45:48] Andrew DeWolf: Hey guys, sorry to interrupt me in the middle of the show, but we've got a shell at you. Today's show is brought to you by the extremely kind donations by our donors over at the Patreon, Lady Pates and whatnot.

[46:01] Jesse McAnally: Andrew, what's Patreon?

[46:03] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, Patreon's a website that like takes money and gives it to other people.

[46:08] Jesse McAnally: Um, namely us. You can use it to give to us.

[46:11] Andrew DeWolf: Only us.

[46:12] Jesse McAnally: Only us. Only us.

[46:13] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, well, we we have like a bunch of perks and stuff that you can get. We have a lot of extra content on there.

[46:16] Jesse McAnally: A full commentary of the dear of enhanced movie.

[46:20] Andrew DeWolf: That's true. We did put that up there. And we'll probably have something new soon. Maybe even when this drops. We can only hope.

[46:26] Jesse McAnally: Yeah. Um plus if you uh, you know, pay enough, you can come on the show.

[46:32] Andrew DeWolf: Yes. Um, that is one of the things. Um Lady Knight did not pay us to come on the show.

[46:36] Jesse McAnally: But also, even if you give us as little as $1, you will get the unedited full versions of this show where you can see our faces. You can see Lady Knight's face. They are not just a stick figure, they have a face and a personality.

[46:49] Andrew DeWolf: And a beautiful beautiful room. Um, I gotta cut a lot of stuff from these episodes.

[46:54] Jesse McAnally: So, you know, you might get a lot of extra content. Take a look at our School of Rock episode where Andrew cut 90 minutes out.

[47:01] Andrew DeWolf: It's amazing. She should listen to it.

[47:04] Jesse McAnally: It was hilarious.

[47:08] Andrew DeWolf: It was too funny.

[47:10] Jesse McAnally: 911.

[47:10] Andrew DeWolf: 911.

[47:12] Jesse McAnally: We we called all of it. I'm like, this cannot possibly go with the episode.

[47:17] Andrew DeWolf: We called the Miranda Singh's apology uh 9 11 for your ukulele's, and then we did an entire bit about what that would look like.

[47:25] Jesse McAnally: I don't know what we can't bring back up because we thought it was funny.

[47:30] Andrew DeWolf: So I had to cut every single time. And you know, that is.

[47:33] Jesse McAnally: Yes. Yes, you did. And you made the right call.

[47:36] Andrew DeWolf: Um our current patrons are Melissa Goldman, Danielle, Renick, Peasant Tick, Chick, Just the Stampede, Ewan Castie, Monica Thoreau, Brent Black, Latano, Stacey Coomb, Joseph Evans Green, Mary Lou Choquette, John Finales, Russ Walker, Musical Hell, Emily Gracie, Kyle Summers, Jen AC, Scoot the Technicolor, Dreamco, Liz Lim, nothing is certain except Beth and Texas, Desbian, Roger Benjamin, Jessica T, Mitchell Young, Chai Teacup, Chris Mark Cote, Kiji Marie Anastasio, Trevi Joseph, Layla, RJ Norija, Julia McQuennon, Bjorn Hermann, Toriana Frazier, Sammy.

[48:05] Jesse McAnally: The adequate amount. Jacobson, Angela, Kayleigh Blazier, Cinemaget and Reviews, Villainous Miss, Sofiana Ali, the Omega Geek, Paige Pearson, Maddie Worgle, Elisa Erdman, Anna Loscatova, Sarah Den Bleckier, Evan Ball, Zachary Torres, Rora Morasso, Mara Four Loin, Lisa L, Psest Washing Machine, Nick Roe Ten, Puffy Boy, Julia Hardy, Sydney Hicks, Ann Bellg, Billy Clifton, Andrew Wright, the Red Caboose with a kaboom, Gold Plate and Kim Kim Kiki Mora, and Julia Baldur Dutier.

[48:38] Andrew DeWolf: They give us a little money that helps us keep us paid, I guess. Um, and they get tons of fun perks, and they get to hang out with us.

[48:45] Jesse McAnally: Um I feel like we don't hype up our Discord server enough, but that that is actually pretty active, and you can literally ask me and Andrew anything at any point, and we'll probably respond to you.

[48:54] Andrew DeWolf: And they're they're just good people over there, which is the best part. It's a good time.

[48:58] Jesse McAnally: How about we get back to this?

[49:06] Andrew DeWolf: Um Yeah. So here's the thing. There's no album for the show.

[49:11] Jesse McAnally: Yeah.

[49:12] Andrew DeWolf: So we're kind of limited to what we can technically are legally allowed to play on the Broadway Podcast Network.

[49:20] Jesse McAnally: Oh which is is it these two songs that you have listed?

[49:24] Andrew DeWolf: No. We can only do the fucking star song.

[49:28] Jesse McAnally: Really?

[49:29] Andrew DeWolf: No, I hate that song. That's the only song we can do.

[49:32] Jesse McAnally: Is that the?

[49:32] Andrew DeWolf: It's the only song they've officially released.

[49:34] Jesse McAnally: Really?

[49:35] Andrew DeWolf: That song has a reprise as well that Max sings, which I like.

[49:42] Jesse McAnally: Sure in a song section on record. Jesus Christ.

[49:46] Andrew DeWolf: It's really rough, but they got Hello Stars. It came out officially as a song a month ago.

[49:52] Jesse McAnally: And they play it 500 times.

[49:54] Andrew DeWolf: So we are talking about half the score when we talk about this one song. Hello Stars.

[50:07] LadyKnightTheBrave: And when the night time ends, we'll have to say goodbye.

[50:18] Andrew DeWolf: So even when you're out.

[50:58] Jesse McAnally: The thing is, and I don't remember Liesel, I think has like one scene where they talk about her looking up at the stars, but there's a really great scene where Max, after being in a basement for months, like goes outside during the bombing of Himmel Street and like gets to look at the sky for the first time in a really long time. And uh I think there's a line about like he looked at the stars, they burned his eyes or something. Like it's a great scene.

[51:22] LadyKnightTheBrave: So when Max sings Hello Stars, I was like, yes.

[51:25] Andrew DeWolf: And when Liesel sang it, I was like, no. But whatever. I see why you would have that be a reprise, another thing connecting them musically. Like I get the idea behind it. I'm just being a nitpick. Um, I will say the opening number, which you can't play a clip of, but they where they sing like the colors, the colors. Um, I kind of like that song. It's actually a pretty good take on because like the opening of the book has literally the first lines are first the colors, then the humans. That's usually how I see things, or at least how I try. And then he says, I'm so sorry. Um, I didn't mean to interrupt, but I do want to make sure that Angela knows this. You can play the opening number because it is in the first 45 seconds of the Book Thief trailer on the Belgrade Theater YouTube page.

[52:09] LadyKnightTheBrave: That's true. There's a story I've studied. Just one of a few. It begins with a go. But this girl, she steals. Watch. I mean, who does that? And why? But a book thief was born, and I was intrigued. The year is 1939. The place is Nazi Germany. Here's a moment in history where hate bottom won. The result? Devastation. I suppose I take pity on those tournipes. So I urge you. Have a heart. Have a heart. Have a heart.

[52:58] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, no, the opening number is good. Because they're the the colors, the colors. And then he runs through the three times he saw Liesel Memminger, which was, and because he says that he focuses on the color of the sky rather than on his work, which he doesn't enjoy. Death doesn't like his job, it bums him out. He wants a vacation. Can I have a standard? That's understandable. Yeah, no, again, this book is very good. And um, he describes the colors, uh, the white of the snow when uh Liesel's brother died. Um, and then there's black, I think, and then red when uh Mulking gets bombed. Black, I don't know what they do in the show because they cut it, but in the in the book, there's a whole sequence where there was a crashed American pilot who basically died in his plane, and like Liesel and Rudy find him in the forest, and he's got like a minute or two, and then he dies, and Rudy gives him a teddy bear that he was carrying around.

It's a really sweet scene. They cut it, probably because they couldn't handle a plane. Um, I don't remember what they did for the middle one in the in the musical. But um, yeah, and then red for when like the sky when Mulking gets bombed. Um and yeah, just that whole number, uh, the refrain is have a heart, which feels like a thing Death would say, because he's constantly like trying to be like, This sucks. You should be sad. I'm sad. But it also feels a little dystified. Like I love like anything that isn't leading back to the have a heart, because have a heart feels like something like Snow White would sing.

[54:31] LadyKnightTheBrave: Yeah, I mean, again, it's it's less on the nose than love over hate, which is the refrain for a lot of the show that I thought was really trite. Um I stole that from Michelle Obama. I'm just like, if I had to, if I had to pick a refrain that I could live with from this show, Have a Heart Feels Right, uh, or at least more right. Um, but yeah, no, just that song I think was the right level of like a little bit spooky, a little bit unsettling, but also like it was kind of a good song. I didn't I didn't hate it as a song.

[55:07] Andrew DeWolf: But on that note, what is our overall thoughts on the Book Thief Musical and our cheese ratings? Which um probably my worst transition of the entire night. Um Liz, why don't you go first?

[55:18] Liz: I'm gonna throw you under the bus. I know I had to go first. No, I've been really quiet. Because they were actively looking up and I wasn't gonna do it.

[55:27] LadyKnightTheBrave: Oh yeah, I was acting I actually Google cheeses sometimes during the song session.

[55:30] Liz: Oh, I know you did. Fun fact, yes, I am I am prepared. Uh yeah, this is fine. It's very mid, as I said before. I have no I don't remember much from it besides like it's like okay. Like nothing, nothing stands out. Liesel's fine. I wish she wasn't this main character 100% of the time. The songs are fine, everything's fine. I wish it wasn't funny half the time. I don't know. It didn't really affect me in any way at the end of it. It was like, okay, cool. And then I like moved on with my day. Like, okay, it's fine. Also, these these composers also worked on Apple TV Central Park.

[56:04] Andrew DeWolf: Yes, starring Kristen Bell playing a black child.

[56:08] Liz: Oh, what?

[56:09] Andrew DeWolf: So there's a show called Central Park. They had a biracial, like half-black, half-white character played by Kristen Bell.

[56:16] Liz: They got called out for it, and Kristen Bell was like, Well, I am a half white, so I am white, and so I am half this character, so I have equally as right. And then people were like, no, that ain't cool. And then she stepped down from the role after season one.

[56:30] Andrew DeWolf: Yup. That's not a good idea. Why'd they think they could do that?

[56:34] Liz: Um because Hollywood is really dumb.

[56:36] Andrew DeWolf: Uh speaking of Hollywood being dumb, you saw that they just canned an entirely finished wild e-coyote movie today.

[56:44] Liz: Well, I mean, that's uh Warner Brothers. They're a mess.

[56:46] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it's a mess. Warner Brothers realized that you can make more money by not making movies than by making them.

[56:52] Liz: So they just started calling everything.

[56:54] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, they make a lot of money via TLC shows now. It's very funny.

[56:57] Liz: Ugh. Okay, somebody else needs to be a good idea.

[57:01] Andrew DeWolf: Anyway, uh cheese.

[57:01] Liz: Cheese.

[57:02] Andrew DeWolf: I need to give cheese. Uh I'm gonna give this Parser Cheese, which is a sour milk cheese from low fat curd cheese, and only contains 1% fat. So that's my German cheese of choice for this recording. I think I've done like six German cheeses in my musical cheese musical cheese career.

[57:18] Liz: So I like that it's a career.

[57:22] Andrew DeWolf: Um, Andrew, what about you?

[57:23] Andrew DeWolf: Um I I definitely think there's flaws in this, but I guess maybe me not having read the actual source material, I had very different expectations going into this.

[57:33] Liz: Yeah.

[57:33] Andrew DeWolf: Because honestly, I thought it handled a lot of what it did very well. Um I definitely would have liked to see some of the other characters explored more.

[57:41] Liz: Um and maybe less of uh just that kid that likes to run a lot.

[57:45] Andrew DeWolf: Um just read the book after this. It'll be better. Like you'll like the musical, you'll like the book even more. But I I actually thought that the the themes of of death and loss were handled very well.

[57:56] Liz: Um I don't think the themes of like racism or anything like that were handled well at all.

[58:02] Andrew DeWolf: Um they didn't really focus on it enough for it to be handled well. Uh so oh well. Uh I'm gonna give it uh Death Cheese, which is not a real cheese, but I guess it's from a video game.

[58:15] Liz: Um seems good to me.

[58:17] Andrew DeWolf: What video game?

[58:18] Liz: Uh Forgotten Realms.

[58:20] Andrew DeWolf: Somebody will be excited that you mentioned it.

[58:22] Liz: What might not be a video game, might be a uh might be a tabletop.

[58:26] Andrew DeWolf: Uh forgotten. Somebody knows what it is and is very hyped that you just referenced cheese.

[58:33] Liz: Um it's a campaign setting for D&D.

[58:36] Andrew DeWolf: Alright.

[58:36] Liz: Okay, yeah, so it's a table, it's a tabletop.

[58:39] Andrew DeWolf: Overall thoughts, um, maybe with a lot of work and not being a musical and maybe not making it at all, but maybe there's a good show in there.

[58:47] Liz: Um so my cheese rating is um like one piece of like slightly moldy parmesan cheese at the back of your fridge. Like if you cut off enough of the mold, there's like a good parmesan cheese is nice. If you cut off all the gross bits, there might be a nice cheese in there.

[59:07] Andrew DeWolf: That's fair enough.

[59:09] Liz: Um I struggled with this show. I always I found myself uh apathetic toward it at best, and the things I liked were not like things I loved, which was a bummer because I kinda I kinda had relatively high uh hopes for this, and it really it was not doing it for me um in a lot of ways.

[59:28] Andrew DeWolf: So the cheese rating I am giving this is the one book I ever stole on accident by um it just happened to be in my backpack on the last day of school, and I'm like, oh oh I guess this is mine now and that is the book that I think we all know and love The Stinky Cheese Man and other fairly stupid tales.

[59:52] Liz: Yes what grade did you still miss in the street?

[59:56] Andrew DeWolf: That should have actually you actually stole that?

[59:59] Liz: That was like in first grade.

[1:00:00] Andrew DeWolf: First grade, okay.

[1:00:01] Liz: I was gonna say this is high school, I'd be a little bit more it wasn't like an intentional thing. It was like in my desk, and I just kind of loaded my desk into my backpack, like the one armed it in.

[1:00:13] Andrew DeWolf: It is a wonderful book.

[1:00:14] Jesse McAnally: Lady Knight, you are wonderful, and I am so grateful that you joined us today and you brought so many wonderful insights. I'm sure there's nobody out there that doesn't already know your wonderful content, but in case there's just one person, please tell us where we can all find you, because it's not on X.

[1:00:29] LadyKnightTheBrave: No, it ain't.

[1:00:30] Jesse McAnally: No, it ain't.

[1:00:31] LadyKnightTheBrave: I jumped that ship like a year ago. Um, I am Lady Knight the Brave, all one word, K and I G H T. Uh, and you can find me on Tumblr, Instagram. I make video essays on YouTube. I made one about the Book Thief novel and Judger Rabbit. I'd recommend it. It's one of one of my better ones. Um, and yeah, I think that's everything.

[1:00:56] Jesse McAnally: Um, and also you've done some incredible content recently. Um, you are literally the only reason why I have a nebula membership.

[1:01:03] LadyKnightTheBrave: Oh thank you.

[1:01:06] Jesse McAnally: Because you actually post consistent like Nebula only stuff that I want to watch.

[1:01:11] LadyKnightTheBrave: You know, those are actually they're they're Patreon exclusive, and I post them on Nebula.

[1:01:15] Jesse McAnally: So um Well, now I gotta get a Patreon too.

[1:01:17] LadyKnightTheBrave: Yeah, it's it's one or the other. You know, it's literally with the exception of the drawing videos of like how I draw the thumbnails, those are the only things that are just on Nebula, but the monthly movies are on my Patreon as well.

[1:01:29] Jesse McAnally: So unless you really like listening to me word vomit to try and explain the tragic thing that's uh I'm uh let's call it a process of how I uh paint the thumbnails.

[1:01:40] LadyKnightTheBrave: Um that's the only Nebula exclusive exclusive.

[1:01:43] Jesse McAnally: Fair enough. I mean, I love your content. I've been a fan of you before I became uh a colleague of yours, and that is so lovely, and I'm grateful that you joined us today. Speaking of people we're grateful for, thank you guys for listening to this episode.

[1:01:57] Jesse McAnally: Please follow us on iTunes Spotify Stitcher at not Stitcher. Stitcher doesn't exist at Musicals with Cheese.

[1:02:06] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, Google Podcasts uh should it's not even on there.

[1:02:09] Jesse McAnally: I don't read that. I just word vomit because I know how this show goes.

[1:02:13] Andrew DeWolf: Follow us on Twitter at Cheesy Musicals, Patreon Musical the Cheese, Instagram Musicals the Cheese, YouTube page Musicals of Cheese. Liz is working on two new videos for our YouTube page, which I am very excited for people to see.

[1:02:25] Jesse McAnally: Um we have a Patreon only podcast, Patreon with Cheese, where you can hear me and Andrew do a full-length dear of enhancing commentary where God damn.

[1:02:38] Andrew DeWolf: I did not do that.

[1:02:40] Jesse McAnally: That was totally incredible.

[1:02:43] Andrew DeWolf: Um school theater lives at gmail.com to tell us how wrong we were about the Book Thief.

[1:02:48] Jesse McAnally: Send all the hate mail to that email.

[1:02:50] Andrew DeWolf: Um, at hotmail.com.

[1:02:54] Jesse McAnally: That email's public.

[1:02:55] Andrew DeWolf: I'm not literally.

[1:02:57] Jesse McAnally: Oh yes, yes.

[1:02:59] Andrew DeWolf: They have a hotmail.

[1:03:00] Jesse McAnally: Oh, a hotel.

[1:03:00] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I'm sorry, one time ago.

[1:03:04] Jesse McAnally: Our keeper of the cheese is Juliet Antonio. And Lady Knight, do you want to give some ASMR to our good friend Juliet really quick? Because they write ASMR and we do this every week.

[1:03:16] LadyKnightTheBrave: You just did it.

[1:03:18] Jesse McAnally: You whispered in your mic, you got it.

[1:03:19] LadyKnightTheBrave: You just did it.

[1:03:20] Jesse McAnally: Ten out of ten.

[1:03:22] Jesse McAnally: This show is edited by Andrew DeWolf, and I think he's doing a fantabulous job. Our theme songs were created by Robyn Nash of IOU Music UK. Thank you to the Broadway Podcast Network for having us on the platform and for not kicking us off for I don't know.

[1:03:37] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, anything else we have left to say before we wrap this on up?

[1:03:40] Liz: Read the book.

[1:03:42] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.

[1:03:42] Liz: Read the book.

[1:03:43] Andrew DeWolf: I have it, but read it.

[1:03:45] Liz: I own it and I have never read it.

[1:03:47] Andrew DeWolf: Liz, you should read it now.

[1:03:49] Jesse McAnally: Alright. We'll see you next time on Musicals with Cheese.

[1:04:00] Andrew DeWolf: Hello, stalls.

[1:04:02] Liz: Hello, school.

[1:04:04] Andrew DeWolf: Hello, Lloyd.

[1:04:06] Liz: No.

[1:04:06] Andrew DeWolf: This is my.

[1:04:07] Liz: That's how she's saying it.

[1:04:08] Andrew DeWolf: That's exactly how she said it.

[1:04:10] Liz: The colors.

[1:04:13] Andrew DeWolf: Thank you.

[1:04:13] Liz: Thank you.

[1:04:14] Andrew DeWolf: Have a hot!

© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved

An error occurred