"Wake me up when September ends..." Grab your eyeliner and rebellious t-shirts because this week we're joined by Garret Snook aka Ilneige to talk about the rock musical American idiot. Hosts: Jesse McAnally & Andrew DeWolf. Podcast Edited By: Andrew DeWolf... Read More
From the show: Musicals with Cheese
About
"Wake me up when September ends..." Grab your eyeliner and rebellious t-shirts because this week we're joined by Garret Snook aka Ilneige to talk about the rock musical American idiot.
Credits:
Hosts: Jesse McAnally & Andrew DeWolf
Podcast Edited By: Andrew DeWolf
Theme Songs: Robyn Nash of IOU Music UK
Keeper of the Cheese: Juliet Antonio
This show is a part of the Broadway Podcast Network
Social Media:
Musicals with Cheese on Twitter
Musicals W/ Cheese on Instagram
Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com
Jess Socials
Andrew Socials
Use our Affiliate Link
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:06] Jesse McAnally: Hello, I'm Jesse McAnally.
[0:08] Andrew DeWolf: And I am Andrew DeWolf.
[0:10] Jesse McAnally: And welcome to Musicals with Cheese, the podcast where I try to get Andrew to like musical theater.
[0:15] Jesse McAnally: And you guys, we have an extra special returning guest, and it's been way too long since they've been on.
[0:20] Jesse McAnally: Truly, it is one of the few crimes I've committed, but you gotta find out the rest.
[0:24] Jesse McAnally: Please join me in welcoming comedian, songwriter, brilliant mind, and number one Green Day fan Garrett Snook, or Ilneige from the Twitters and the YouTube's.
[0:34] Garrett Snook: How are you doing, Garrett?
[0:36] Garrett Snook: I am so excited that I get to try to convince Andrew to be a Green Day fan now.
[0:42] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, it's not gonna work. I'm sorry.
[0:45] Garrett Snook: Just give in. You will have the time of your life.
[0:50] Jesse McAnally: He's too lost in the boulevard of Broken Dreams, sadly.
[0:53] Garrett Snook: Oh my god. Why are you referencing the ballads?
[0:56] Garrett Snook: Those are the ones I like the least.
[0:59] Jesse McAnally: What, you don't like 21 Guns and the random Full House tribute in the middle?
[1:07] Garrett Snook: Weird.
[1:08] Garrett Snook: Oh, it's right in there. Apparently that was in there because I guess while they were making the album, they just passed some time watching a bunch of Full House reruns.
[1:17] Jesse McAnally: And that's way in.
[1:19] Garrett Snook: Billy Joe Armstrong with his knees to his chin just watching Uncle Jesse decide to get a haircut.
[1:24] Garrett Snook: Oh really be invested. He's like, this is it. This is going in the next song. Don't do it, Uncle Jesse!
[1:32] Garrett Snook: Don't let the record label ruin your cover of that one Beach Boys song.
[1:37] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, it's the only song he knows, but he's good at that song.
[1:45] Andrew DeWolf: Um so Green Day.
[1:48] Andrew DeWolf: Uh Green Day.
[1:50] Andrew DeWolf: Um, yeah, I don't know how to lead into this, but I know I got a lot of things to do.
[1:55] Andrew DeWolf: This week, in case you haven't picked up what we're throwing down, we're talking about the Green Day Jukebox musical American Idiot.
[2:03] Jesse McAnally: Cue the music.
[2:04] ♪ Musical number: "American Idiot" — performed by Green Day ♪
[2:14] ♪ Musical number: "American Idiot" — performed by Green Day ♪
[2:25] Andrew DeWolf: Welcome to a new kind of tension.
[2:27] Andrew DeWolf: All across the ADM while everything is in MV.
[2:32] Jesse McAnally: Okay.
[2:35] Jesse McAnally: Television dreams of tomorrow.
[2:37] Jesse McAnally: We're not the ones with the follow for nothing for you.
[2:45] Jesse McAnally: So American Idiot is a musical.
[2:49] Jesse McAnally: I want to try that again. American Idiot is a musical.
[2:54] Jesse McAnally: I was two weeks ago. I directed by Gen.
[3:00] Jesse McAnally: We're doing it again. We tricked you.
[3:06] Jesse McAnally: One plus one, Garrett.
[3:11] Garrett Snook: Um so American Idiot is a musical written by Billy Joe Armstrong and Michael Mayer, with music and lyrics by Green Day and Billy Joe Armstrong, based on American Idiot by Green Day.
[3:21] Garrett Snook: The musical opened at the St. James Theater on Broadway.
[3:25] Garrett Snook: I have my St. James Theater uh little uh pendant right here, so I thought that was relevant.
[3:30] Garrett Snook: Um, with previews beginning March 24th, 2010.
[3:33] Garrett Snook: It officially opened on April 20th, 2010, 420 Blaze It.
[3:37] Garrett Snook: The story, expanded from that of the album, centers on three disaffected young men.
[3:42] Garrett Snook: Johnny, Will, and Tunny.
[3:44] Garrett Snook: Johnny and Tunny flee a stifling suburban lifestyle with parental restrictions while Will stays at home to work out his relationship with his pregnant girlfriend, Heather.
[3:54] Garrett Snook: The former pair look for meaning in life and try out the freedom and excitement of the city.
[4:00] Garrett Snook: Tunny quickly gives up on life and the city and joins the military and is shipped off to war.
[4:05] Garrett Snook: Johnny turns to drugs and finds part of himself that he grows to dislike.
[4:05] Garrett Snook: He has a relationship and experiences lost love.
[4:14] Garrett Snook: And all this done in less than 90 minutes. You can do it, Broadway if you believe it.
[4:20] Garrett Snook: No intermission, also. Love it. Love it.
[4:23] Jesse McAnally: Perfect. It's like it's like Jesus Christ Superstar.
[4:26] Jesse McAnally: It's like the Who's Tommy.
[4:27] Jesse McAnally: It is all the things that you want in like those album to stage experiences.
[4:33] Andrew DeWolf: Unlike Jagged Little Pill, which is the worst version of one of those.
[4:36] Garrett Snook: Oh goodness. Don't don't don't d I hate Jagged Little Pill.
[4:40] Jesse McAnally: Um Garrett, this has been your white whale on this show since we started.
[4:45] Garrett Snook: Pretty much. Like you after we did Pokemon Live, um Oh no, I think the first time we talked, you said like any musicals you're interested in, like I could uh I can be done for American Idiot, or this is a long shot Pokemon Live, and you're like, oh, we're doing Pokemon Live.
[4:59] Garrett Snook: But uh, I'm glad we're always a chaotic option.
[5:02] Garrett Snook: But I'm glad we're we're we're uh we're making the rounds back again to uh get to um I don't even know if this is one of my favorite musicals or anything, but this is one of my it's based on one of like my all-time favorite albums of life.
[5:16] Jesse McAnally: Uh that makes sense. Um, I know, Garrett, you're gonna have a good long explanation, but for comedy purposes, I'm gonna start with Andrew.
[5:24] Andrew DeWolf: Andrew, do you have any history with Green Day whatsoever?
[5:28] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, I mean, I was uh Oh man, we were talking, we were talking before the the episode started here, and and uh yes, I was alive during 2004.
[5:37] Andrew DeWolf: So I know all the fucking Green Day songs.
[5:40] Andrew DeWolf: And we don't know anything about Jennifer Lopez.
[5:42] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know anything about Jennifer Lopez other than the goddamn South Park episode.
[5:49] Andrew DeWolf: And I have even less knowledge of Green Day.
[5:51] Andrew DeWolf: Do you Garrett, you're gonna really, really hate me.
[5:56] Andrew DeWolf: My first and really big exposure to Green Day was the commercial for Kids Bop 9.
[6:05] Garrett Snook: Oh, with that amazing cover of "Boulevard of Broken Dreams."
[6:09] Andrew DeWolf: No, "Wake Me Up When September Ends."
[6:12] Garrett Snook: Oh my god.
[6:14] Andrew DeWolf: Summer has come and passed. The innocent can never last. Wake me up when September ends.
[6:33] Andrew DeWolf: Like the time has come to pass. Seven years has gone so fast. Wake me up when September's and I just remember it playing like every fifth commercial, and you got these kids like, wake me up!
[6:57] Andrew DeWolf: When September's have all of their fathers come to pass? Like is this the orphan choir?
[7:05] Andrew DeWolf: I think they might have changed the lyrics to like, you know, being sad that school's back. Live and being hopeful. Summer break has come to pass.
[7:15] Andrew DeWolf: Goodness. Um Jesus fucking Christ.
[7:18] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, so that that's my limited experience before tackling this show.
[7:22] Garrett Snook: Let's talk about Green Day and your relationship to them.
[7:27] Garrett Snook: Um my relationship with Green Day began in earnest. Um in like 2003.
[7:33] Garrett Snook: I picked up their CD Nimrod only because it had two song titles I recognized. That was the one that had "Nice Guys Finish Last" and "Time of Your Life."
[7:44] Garrett Snook: And from there I just ravenously devoured everything.
[7:48] Garrett Snook: So I think by the time American Idiot had come out, I had all of their previous albums.
[7:52] Garrett Snook: Um I was learning guitar this time, and most of my songwriting approach and knowledge and everything just came from one man from Oakland, California banging out the same three chords over and over again.
[8:06] Garrett Snook: And um yeah, and I've just uh I've been a true Blue Green Day fan since I haven't seen them live as many times as like the more hardcore people have, but I've seen the American Idiot tour, seen their Revolution Radio Tour, and I just uh lot of eyeliner.
[8:28] Andrew DeWolf: Did you put eyeliner on today?
[8:30] Garrett Snook: I did not. I could not find it.
[8:32] Garrett Snook: Um I meant I was gonna do like the I were my hair shorter, I would have spiked it up in black and everything, but I can't pull that look off quite as much anymore.
[8:41] Andrew DeWolf: Okay. And did you see American Idiot when it was originally on stage or in its many tours?
[8:47] Garrett Snook: Uh I saw a uh I forget which it was the Amundsen Theater, or it was a different one in California, but I saw it with my mother and a whole lot of seasoned pass holders who did not know what they were signing up for.
[9:00] Jesse McAnally: I love it.
[9:02] Garrett Snook: Yeah, um, my mom actually got more out of the musical than I think I did.
[9:05] Garrett Snook: Um well, um, she's she's a boomer, and you know, so she lived through Vietnam and her first husband was actually a veteran, so what the show whether the show handles it well or not, a lot of how it dives into substance abuse and everything, she actually resonated a lot with that.
[9:22] Garrett Snook: Um but again, I'll never get over standing up, my mom turning to this very, very old woman sitting next to her, saying, Did you love it? And this old woman just saying, not really.
[9:36] Jesse McAnally: I don't think she enjoyed the uh the the more graphic segment of "Give Me Novocaine."
[9:43] Garrett Snook: Um That's when the thrusting happens.
[9:46] Jesse McAnally: Yes.
[9:48] Garrett Snook: Um I love seasoned pass holders. That's the reason why you go to a tour show. That's the joy of it.
[9:54] Andrew DeWolf: Um I I've I struggle with this show. I've struggled with the show for a long time.
[10:01] Andrew DeWolf: Um the same way I struggle with a lot of shows of this ilk where it just feels incomplete as a piece of theater where it feels like a little square peg round hole to me, where it feels, especially with this one, it feels I I didn't feel this until this recent rewatch of the bootleg.
[10:21] Andrew DeWolf: It feels very much in 2009 stage Broadway theater stylings, um, specifically with Michael Mayer, who just came off of Spring Awakening, uh, to do this, and I just see a lot of that stylings, which I think sadly dates a lot of what is really impressive stuff, and I think that they were so focused on not your dad's Broadway that they kind of get lost in the set design a bit.
[10:50] Garrett Snook: Does that make sense?
[10:52] Garrett Snook: Yeah, the very nice scaffolding that gets turned around a whole bunch to be different things.
[10:58] Andrew DeWolf: Broadway loves scaffolding.
[11:01] Andrew DeWolf: It's their favorite fucking thing in the whole world.
[11:03] Garrett Snook: The only thing they love more than that is staircases.
[11:08] Garrett Snook: Like this guy, Michael Mayer, who is like the second collaborator on this, the second biggest person outside of Billy Joe Armstrong, would go on to do some interesting things, but I I I've he didn't really improve it, he just duplicated it.
[11:23] Garrett Snook: Specifically for things like Hedwig and the Angry Inch with Neil Patrick Harris, where it feels very similar and very much like let's let's be transgressive for the sake of being transgressive, and I feel I feel like this would almost work better as a movie.
[11:40] Garrett Snook: Like, I wish this had gotten like the Who's Tommy treatment, where we had like a weird kind of film, uh, which was something that was going to happen for a period with Billy Joe Armstrong reprising St. Jimmy um in the in the film, but that fell apart uh sadly over many many years.
[12:00] Garrett Snook: Um But as a piece, like I I I think I would have just preferred the album because theater people don't sing rock very good.
[12:11] Andrew DeWolf: This is it's especially noticeable here because they're not doing the pop punk voice.
[12:16] Andrew DeWolf: There there's a very particular pop-punk voice that maybe is invented by the Green Day guy, but everybody else imitated it too.
[12:22] Andrew DeWolf: Uh in the fake British accent. All the small things, true care, truth things.
[12:31] Andrew DeWolf: Do you have the time to listen to me one? About nothing and everything allowance.
[12:41] Garrett Snook: That was um when I first got the soundtrack. That was the most jarring thing to keep revisiting is how everybody had such perfect enunciation.
[12:59] Garrett Snook: It's just especially with John Gallagher Jr. as the lead, it just screams Spring Awakening in my ears, where it just feels like you know these CMU graduates being like, I'm gonna be really edgy. I I I I love to rock!
[13:15] Garrett Snook: Rock! Don't want to be an American idiot!
[13:21] Andrew DeWolf: This woman leaves behind a suffering child.
[13:25] Garrett Snook: And it's almost tolerable during the songs, but in the in between, when he's like delivering the monologues to the audience, like that's when it's like, I I don't know, I don't know what voice we're doing here.
[13:37] Garrett Snook: But when you see Billy Joe Armstrong come in and the few clips we have of him as St. Jimmy.
[13:43] Garrett Snook: Oh my god. It's that it's a different show.
[13:47] Garrett Snook: Such a different energy, too, because at least um on the original cast recording and the performance I saw, I think they typically try to cast St. Jimmy as more of um like a high metal Axl Rose kind of type.
[13:57] Garrett Snook: But then, and that's partially the differentiate because you have all these songs written to be sung by one man, now having to be shared among you know three male leads who all have very similar vocal qualities just by virtue of like the range they need to have.
[14:10] Garrett Snook: So let's bring in this guy to do a bunch of like kick-ass Getty Lee squeals, but then you know, for the time that Billy Joe had to fill in, it's like back to like, oh no, there's this very like you know, raw vocal quality, the fake British accent.
[14:21] Garrett Snook: I I think it works. I think it's better. I like Tony Vincent. He's a very talented uh vocalist, and he was the original St. Jimmy.
[14:28] Garrett Snook: Doesn't do it for me. Doesn't scratch that part of my brain. Um same for a lot of the other uh cast members.
[14:36] Jesse McAnally: They all just so let me get off my Broadway soapbox and we'll talk about this show proper.
[14:42] Garrett Snook: Um all Broadway singers are kind of taught in the same way because there's only three big Broadway schools that they really go to, so everyone kind of sounds the same now.
[14:53] Garrett Snook: Everyone they they call it the Carnegie Mellon sound. So that's why we don't have distinctive voices anymore, and why if you get a Lynn Manuel Miranda on stage, technically he's in tune, technically he's singing well, but because it doesn't just sound exactly like Aaron Tveit, um, you're you're immediately like that's bad.
[15:12] Garrett Snook: And the problem is if they try to do anything like jukeboxy, which Broadway is want to do lately, it sounds completely incorrect.
[15:23] Garrett Snook: And passionless. Passionless is the big one. Um I would like to know this is like a free-flowing plot, but I would like to hear the plot described. Um, whoever wants to take the ball there.
[15:35] Andrew DeWolf: I cannot take the ball here. I'm sorry. I cannot- you you could hold a gun to my head, I could not tell you what happened in this.
[15:41] Garrett Snook: Uh, I'll give it not with a query. Uh uh, I'll take this one. I I can give you the album and then the how it that's adapted. Um I would love that, actually.
[15:53] Garrett Snook: Yeah, for sure. Well, the album is a lot more straightforward. Um, it's because it only has one protagonist who he's just ambiguously disaffected by the modern political landscape. Why wouldn't you be it was the Bush administration and uh believe uh uh he's not given I don't think he's given a name in the liner notes of anything.
[16:11] Garrett Snook: He's just the Jesus of Suburbia, but you know, late teens, early 20s, he's like, okay, well, screw this town. I'm gonna go to where something's happening, which I believe is like it's the East Bay.
[16:22] Garrett Snook: Oh no, I don't I don't know why I'm saying that, like it's not clear. They referenced the East Bay multiple times. So they're in Northern California. He falls into drug culture, falls into like, you know, what he thinks is a revolutionary mindset.
[16:33] Garrett Snook: By the end of it, though, it turns out, oh, I'm not standing for anything. I'm just getting high and being an asshole, and that's that that's the persona Saint Jimmy that comes out.
[16:43] Garrett Snook: Which I think is kind of a reference to Quadrophenia by The Who, because that that has a song called Dr. Jimmy, where it's a very similar premise of having this like altered persona who's just a drunk piece of shit.
[16:55] Garrett Snook: Um and so by the end of the rock opera, he's learned like, okay, well, this didn't work out. I've alienated the love of my life. I'm gonna go back home and be very sad about her, if nothing else.
[17:08] Jesse McAnally: I was just gonna lead you into talking about the musical and the differences there.
[17:12] Garrett Snook: For sure. Well, the musical, like, you know, Johnny hi is is like the Jesus of Suburbia. Same arc, same plot trajectory for him, but they add on, you know, the two additional friends, Tunny and Will, and I think that's more like out of necessity of not having a core cast consisting of two people because no th well, three people, technically.
[17:33] Garrett Snook: The album just has Jesus of Suburbia, Saint Jimmy, and what's her name. That's not much to build a show around, so I see, I disagree. It just wouldn't be a show that would be a big Broadway hit with the ensemble voices and all that.
[17:48] Andrew DeWolf: But you could do a Last Five Years style musical, and I think that would be compelling, grungier, and on a smaller stage. Like just thinking of that in my mind, I'm like, yeah, but then you wouldn't have all these TVs and all these people flying in the air.
[18:02] Garrett Snook: The projections. The spectacle is what brings people in, especially with a jukebox show like this. With like a military but also Bush analog, but also the actors like black, and they're doing like I don't know who this guy's supposed to be in the Favorite Son number.
[18:19] Garrett Snook: Well, the thing is they don't want to piss off the conservatives because they're the same as anyone else. So they can put whatever face. Um being black, you know, it is 2009. They could say Obama. Oh, dang. Take that libs.
[18:33] Andrew DeWolf: Um I mean that is kind of how moderate Broadway people think.
[18:38] Garrett Snook: That is true. Um still an observation, but that's how you get the first prominent rap musical by being about the whitest thing ever.
[18:46] Andrew DeWolf: With Hamilton.
[18:47] Garrett Snook: With the most late Obama politics I've ever heard that makes it almost impossible to revisit anymore.
[18:55] Andrew DeWolf: Oh yeah, you can't. Oh, we're so optimistic about our political future. Nothing good. We did it, we ended everything. Everything's great now. We fixed it. We didn't throw away our shot.
[19:07] Garrett Snook: Um anyway, uh, so the musical plot. Um it still has that same core plot for the Jesus of Suburbia or Johnny, but then they add on Will, who he's just uh you touched on this in the summary, Jess, but he's just stuck at home, not doing much of anything, you know, which in his couch, on his couch, big mood, but in the same way of the character.
[19:27] Andrew DeWolf: Yep.
[19:28] Garrett Snook: And then you have Tunny who goes off and joins the military, has his own thing. Um, and that's where the character of What's Her Name kind of gets split off into two characters because the original album has the songs uh She's a Rebel and Extraordinary Girl Back to Back.
[19:42] Garrett Snook: They're the same song with different styles because they're about the same person. The extraordinary girl becomes her own character that Tunny meets when he's on his tour. Um also fun fact, the name Tunny came from the liner notes of the album because one of the lyric sheets, it's for the segment um rock and roll girlfriend.
[19:58] Garrett Snook: It just says like it's written as a postcard, like check it out, man. Rock and roll house, rock and roll car, blah, blah, blah. And it's just signed Tunny. So just this throwaway line at the bottom of a postcard is where they get this name for um a major character in the show.
[20:13] Garrett Snook: I I love I love things like that that are placating to the are not pandering, but like uh trying to address the fans, because people read those liner notes, people will go in and be accepted of that.
[20:26] Jesse McAnally: Um I I know we're not quite done with the plot, but I do wonder how much crossover is there with the classic musical theater people and Green Day fans.
[20:39] Garrett Snook: I can't imagine a ton. Um, it is a rock opera, but it's a heavier emphasis on, you know, the rock, because even the album's very short. Like it's a standard, it's not very short, but it's standard album length. It's it doesn't get super long in the tooth like Tommy or uh Quadrophenia would.
[20:55] Garrett Snook: It's closer to like at Jesus Christ Superstar.
[20:58] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[20:58] Garrett Snook: Which Billy Joe Armstrong has a tattoo of on his, I believe, his right arm, just of that logo. And he's like, I never even saw the show, but I just thought the local look. Damn, dude, that's so punk, bro.
[21:12] Andrew DeWolf: I can't even disagree. I'm like, fuck you. That's cool.
[21:15] Garrett Snook: All the Broadway fans who would go up and try to punk gatekeep to him. Like favorite song from the from the record go, huh? Who's your favorite who's your favorite who hit who hit the high note on the why best? Fuck you, that's who, man.
[21:30] Andrew DeWolf: I don't know, Jesus.
[21:32] Garrett Snook: Oh, he just says uh Lynn. Everyone's favorite Broadway actor, Lynn Manuel Miranda.
[21:43] Andrew DeWolf: Um Disney actor. He's not overexposed at all.
[21:48] Garrett Snook: I think he's been. I think he's taken a step back. Good for him. Like, like, you know, until you know Lion King Mufasa returns, then we get him on the press.
[22:00] Andrew DeWolf: Is it called Mufasa Returns?
[22:02] Garrett Snook: No, it's it should be.
[22:03] Andrew DeWolf: It should be.
[22:04] Garrett Snook: It's Short Bufasa arrives, because it's actually a prequel. The line is Fasa King of Thieves.
[22:10] Andrew DeWolf: I love okay. I I just not to go on a stupid Lion King tangent, but I love that Elton John was so pissed. Like, they didn't even ask me to come back for the Mufasa movie.
[22:21] Garrett Snook: They're like, wait, he's still alive. How many farewell concerts do you need to give, Elton? It's like Red Favre retiring.
[22:32] Andrew DeWolf: But back to American Idiot, like, I I don't know if you saw the documentary Broadway Idiot, um, about the making of this and Billy Joe Armstrong writing a Broadway show and adapting to the theater world.
[22:45] Garrett Snook: It's a very interesting documentary from the point of view of rock and roll or punk really, um, entering the Broadway scene and having to adjust to that. And Billy Joe Armstrong basically being like, okay, uh warming up to the idea of playing the role and how much work it's gonna be in performing and acting and all that, which is neat.
[23:04] Garrett Snook: But on the other hand, I just look at these shows of milk toast white people not giving the energy that they should toward the music.
[23:14] Andrew DeWolf: Oh goodness. I mean uh uh I forget who did it, but there was like it was perfectly encapsulated. There was some might have been a TikTok, might have been pre-Tik Talk, but it's just, you know, American Idiot in a nutshell, George W. Bush, we say no no no no on holiday!
[23:30] Garrett Snook: Like that it's not even inaccurate. But I think the Bush era criticism follows through to today a lot better than a a lot of early 2000s work.
[23:43] Andrew DeWolf: Oh yeah, 2016, um my uh my go-to treadmill soundtrack was just throwing on American Idiot. Guts me so mad but also amped up.
[23:54] Garrett Snook: And as it should, um I d and now my next question is does Green Day still produce music? Are they still a big relevant band that still releases new stuff?
[24:05] Andrew DeWolf: You uh did you miss the New Year's Eve non-troversy where uh a bunch of Republican punks were shocked to find out that Green Day had left leaning views.
[24:14] Garrett Snook: I I mean doesn't happen like every day. There's some fucking people that are like, wait, Rage Against the Machine is left leaning? What?
[24:23] Andrew DeWolf: But I um it's not Dick Clark's Rock and New Year's Eve. Whoever is it Carson Daly who d not what who am I saying? They still say Dick Clark, but it's like, you know, Anderson Cooper and all those other people.
[24:36] Garrett Snook: Or uh freaking Seacrest. I think Seacrest hosts it now, but yeah. They changed the line redneck agenda to I'm not a part of a MAGA agenda, and everyone's like, good good lord. Like if they had monocles to be to be pops.
[24:48] Andrew DeWolf: I didn't know that's what they meant by that.
[24:51] Garrett Snook: But yeah, uh I thought Red I thought they didn't want to be farmers. But yeah, since American Idiot, Green Day has produced, I think, uh, is it six albums? Because after that they had 21st Century Breakdown, several songs of which were reincorporated into this to um give to add a few more songs, or had like segments of those songs worked into the American Idiot numbers just to you know give it a bit more length and a bit more to chew on.
[25:16] Garrett Snook: In 2013, they released the Uno Dos Trey Trilogy, uh, which was three albums in the same year, none of which I would call essential listening for even Green Day. There is no single album that like justifies its own existence. You could have paired them down to a single decent thing, but they were going through some stuff.
[25:35] Garrett Snook: This is the same year that Billy Joe had his meltdown at the iHeartRadio Festival. Uh the the five minutes, fuck you, five minutes. I'm not just in fucking Bieber, that was uh that was that night.
[25:46] Andrew DeWolf: Um great.
[25:47] Garrett Snook: Then in 2015, I believe, that was the release of Revolution Radio, which I think is their third best album. Uh 2019 was I think it was 2019. Um somebody's gonna be checking me on these dates, but was uh Father of All Motherfuckers. And uh just earlier this was it, yeah, earlier this year they put out Saviors, so they they're still keeping up.
[26:10] Garrett Snook: I don't know if they're like they're they're still legacied into rock radio station rotations, but I don't know if I don't think Green Day is necessarily still like the driving a driving force in rock like they were in 2004.
[26:21] Andrew DeWolf: We brought this up in our last episode when we're talking about Jennifer Lopez, and uh forgive me if we're gonna be showing our age. Um we're gonna talk about Green Day and J-Lo.
[26:31] Garrett Snook: Um definitely not as far as early 2000s uh work. Um so when we were kids, like all of us, we would have our parents listening to their music from when they were young, and we would think, oh, that's old classic music.
[26:48] Andrew DeWolf: And now that we're uh like 30s, like approaching 30.
[26:53] Garrett Snook: I I don't know how old you are, Garrett, but I'm assuming you're 30 or around there.
[26:57] Garrett Snook: Um 34.
[26:59] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. So it is it now that Green Day, the oldies to these kids today, and we are the old fuddy duddies that look I mean, Green Day, some of their early stuff is the 90s. So 94 was their first big breakthrough.
[27:14] Garrett Snook: 30 years ago.
[27:15] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. So we really we are around the age that Billy and the boys were when they put out American Idiot. It's a a weird time to be alive. Um which means like, is it a cultural zeitgeist? Well, do you think Green Day will have another resurgence where suddenly they will hit again big?
[27:32] Garrett Snook: I don't know if it'll be with a new album necessarily. They've been kind of uh because ever since American Idiot, it's been a little bit like, what do we do now? Because book 21st Century Breakdown was very much what if American Idiot was longer and had a less coherent plot um than the the trilogy album was very was like power pop, but also garage, but also whatever the hell they wanted.
[27:58] Garrett Snook: Um this uh their 2019 album was very garage rock, and it's also the shortest album they've ever put out, and may or may not have just been so they could get out of their contract.
[28:08] Garrett Snook: That said, um, every time I go on TikTok and see little baby pop punkers, you know, getting into the fashion and everything, they're still playing Basket Case and uh Boulevard of Broken Dreams. So those of those at least are gonna remain standards as far as we I can tell.
[28:23] Jesse McAnally: And now to redirect back to the musical, do you think the musical is a represent a good representation of the story? Like, I know there's no way of saying you prefer the musical. Do you like what it does with the work? And do you think it is transformative enough to be its own thing?
[28:39] Garrett Snook: I do enjoy some of the arrangements they came up with, even with the weird diction, the overanunciation, and even I I was gonna fish out my physical copy to confirm this, uh, but there are several points in the album where people misheard certain lyrics in the exact same way. And those um meloprophrisms, uh is that the word? I don't know, but those actually get incorporated into those get incorporated into the show lyrics. During Letterbomb, the original lyric, I believe, is um I'll tow them back, but everybody thinks that he was saying, Well, don't look back.
[29:06] ⚠ About 5 minutes of audio could not be automatically transcribed.
[33:46] Jesse McAnally: We're guessing out of context quotes if these are uh positive or negative reviews, right?
[33:50] Andrew DeWolf: Yep.
[33:51] Jesse McAnally: Real reviews on letterbox.com.
[33:53] Andrew DeWolf: I'm not doctoring them in any way.
[33:55] Jesse McAnally: You just don't know whether they're a one-star or five-star.
[33:57] Jesse McAnally: Um Andrew, you're up first.
[34:00] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.
[34:01] Andrew DeWolf: Watched on freebie.
[34:06] Jesse McAnally: What the fuck, dude?
[34:07] Jesse McAnally: Come on.
[34:08] Andrew DeWolf: You can't do that.
[34:10] Andrew DeWolf: I just did.
[34:11] Andrew DeWolf: Watched on watched on freebie.
[34:13] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, and for context, this is for the Broadway Idiot documentary.
[34:16] Andrew DeWolf: Um, which I think is uh good.
[34:18] Andrew DeWolf: But it related to it, so okay.
[34:21] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, watched on freebie.
[34:23] Jesse McAnally: Um, you know, who who the fuck goes on freebie?
[34:26] Jesse McAnally: You must have you must have sought it out, right?
[34:28] Jesse McAnally: So we're gonna we're gonna say five on that one.
[34:31] Andrew DeWolf: That is correct!
[34:32] Garrett Snook: Shout out to my 15-year-old self who was who got given tickets to see this musical on her birthday and was so excited she vomited.
[34:42] Garrett Snook: Am I guessing um positive negative or like how many stars out of five?
[34:46] Garrett Snook: One star or five star.
[34:47] Garrett Snook: It's uh binary.
[34:48] Garrett Snook: It's either or.
[34:49] Garrett Snook: Okay.
[34:50] Garrett Snook: Uh shout out to my 15-year-old self.
[34:52] Garrett Snook: I guess that's a f that's a f that's a five-star.
[34:54] Jesse McAnally: Garrett, I'm so sorry the vomited made it a one-star.
[34:58] Garrett Snook: Oh no.
[34:59] Garrett Snook: They threw up so bad they didn't want to see the show anymore.
[35:03] Andrew DeWolf: Oh.
[35:06] Andrew DeWolf: Um, Andrew.
[35:08] Andrew DeWolf: Yep.
[35:09] Andrew DeWolf: LMAO, at sign.
[35:11] Andrew DeWolf: Donald Trump attending opening night.
[35:14] Garrett Snook: Wait, for fucking real he was there.
[35:16] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, he was in New York.
[35:18] Andrew DeWolf: So that was Whoopi Goldberg.
[35:19] Andrew DeWolf: A lot of people were there opening night.
[35:21] Andrew DeWolf: The Garfield meme with the the circle with the cross and it's a little bit more than a little bit.
[35:24] Garrett Snook: I wonder who that is.
[35:27] Andrew DeWolf: I love Billy Joe Armstrong.
[35:29] Andrew DeWolf: He has a lot of good points.
[35:30] Andrew DeWolf: His music gets me up and makes me feel good.
[35:33] Andrew DeWolf: I don't agree with everything, but terrific makeup.
[35:36] Andrew DeWolf: The changing hair color.
[35:38] Andrew DeWolf: Joe Biden is an American idiot, not like me.
[35:42] Andrew DeWolf: I would not.
[35:45] Andrew DeWolf: Um we're gonna give that a f a five stars.
[35:45] Andrew DeWolf: Five stars.
[35:52] Jesse McAnally: That is correct.
[35:54] Andrew DeWolf: That was a pure guess.
[35:55] Andrew DeWolf: Hard to believe a punk rock band made a rock opera and accidentally fell in love with theater.
[36:02] Andrew DeWolf: I feel like you're try you're trying to psych me out, but I I'm gonna guess that's a five-star.
[36:06] Andrew DeWolf: That's a one.
[36:08] Garrett Snook: What?
[36:10] Jesse McAnally: Jess, what the fuck? Why are you doing this to him? Why are they writing these this way?
[36:19] Garrett Snook: I don't blame Jess. I blame whoever doesn't understand how the star system works.
[36:25] Andrew DeWolf: I I'm so sorry. Um, it's still better than did I just watch Butler put Girachi in a milking machine.
[36:33] Garrett Snook: That's one you gave me for Pokemon Live. I remember.
[36:36] Andrew DeWolf: Um, Garrett, did we ever tell you that when we did our live show at BroadwayCon, someone brought us the Pokemon cards for the Pokemon you compared us to?
[36:44] Garrett Snook: I still have. I saw the tweets.
[36:47] Andrew DeWolf: I saw the tweets. Um, that was surreal. Um, mine's hanging up on a cork board in my house.
[36:53] Jesse McAnally: Alright. Love it. Andrew, you've won this, so I'm not reading you another one. I'm reading Garrett another one to see if we can get him on the board.
[37:00] Andrew DeWolf: Okay.
[37:01] Garrett Snook: You're two.
[37:02] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, there's no way.
[37:04] Jesse McAnally: And this is the last one. Enjoyed. I feel this is an ad for the show, because we don't see a ton of it.
[37:10] Andrew DeWolf: Oh, I keep forgetting these are for Broadway Idiot. Um, not the actual musical.
[37:15] Garrett Snook: One?
[37:16] Andrew DeWolf: That is a five, Garrett.
[37:18] Garrett Snook: Oh for three!
[37:20] Andrew DeWolf: Oh my fucking god, that sucks.
[37:23] Garrett Snook: I'm on a hot streak. Let's keep it going.
[37:27] Andrew DeWolf: Stop now. Let him rock.
[37:30] Jesse McAnally: Speaking of hot streaks, how about we go into a mid-show and then we talk about some of these songs?
[37:41] Jesse McAnally: Hey guys, sorry to interrupt you in the middle of the show, but we've got a show at you. Today's show is brought to you by the extremely kind donations by our donors over at Patreon. Patreon's this lovely place where you can give us money and we can get a little bit more money to exist and feed ourselves. You know.
[37:56] Andrew DeWolf: Um, our hundred dollar patron, um, Catherine Shockross, uh, gave you a little thing to read. How about you read it for us?
[38:06] Garrett Snook: Oh boy. I've done this like four times, but I'll do it again. Um, sappening, lad. That's boss that I'll have a chicken teriyaki in a can of coke. Apparently it's a rapture. I wish I knew what that meant.
[38:18] Andrew DeWolf: I wish I knew what it meant.
[38:22] Garrett Snook: Polly Shore. I like the idea that Polly Shore just says this to himself if that's the case.
[38:29] Andrew DeWolf: Um, Andrew, who's currently supporting us on Patreon?
[38:32] Andrew DeWolf: Alright. Um, our current patrons are. And uh, I'll try to go quick, but there's a lot. My god. Uh, Danielle Rennox, Jessica Stampede, Iwan Cassidy, Monica Thoreau, Brent Black, Lathanel Stacy Coombe, Joseph Evans Green.
[38:47] Garrett Snook: No, he's gone. He's gone. Scratch that, reverse it.
[38:50] Andrew DeWolf: Uh, Mary Lou Choquette, John Vanales, Russ Walker, Musical Hell, Emily Gracie, Kyle Summers, Janae C, Scoot and Technicolor Dreamcoat.
[38:57] Andrew DeWolf: Nothing is certain except Beth and Texas, John Vanelles, Thesbian, Mitchell Young, Chai Teacup, Chris Marcote, Kiji Marie Anastasio, Trevi Joseph, RJ Noriga, Julia McLannan, Joe, Bjorn Herman's, Toriana Frazier, Sammy the Adequate Amount Jacobson, Hayley Blazier, Villainous Smith, Sophina Ellie, the Omega Geek Page Pearson, Maddie Wargle, Eliza Erdman, Anna Loscatova, Sarah Den Blaker, Evan Balls, Avery Torres, Rora Morasso, Mara, Lisa L.
[39:23] Andrew DeWolf: Possess Washing Machine, Nick Roten, Puffy Boy, Sidney Hicks, Annabelle, Billy Clifton, Gold Platey Kikimora, Arya Artie, Emma, Carabalda, JRL Studios, Katherine Shawcross, Z Botello, Alec Alexandra Dom, and Gwen Bowman.
[39:45] Jesse McAnally: They give us money. You should give us money too. And if you give us money, you can see Garrett's wonderful costume right now.
[39:52] Andrew DeWolf: Um, this is not a good one. This is not actually a lie. We usually lie, but there is actually a costume.
[39:57] Jesse McAnally: Yeah, he put work into this. Uh, he dressed up for you guys. Um, and I'm sure there's gonna be about five, six minutes cut out of this, because there's always a couple minutes cut out of every episode, and you will see the extended versions over on Patreon.com.
[40:11] Jesse McAnally: Um, alright, are we ready to get back to the show?
[40:20] Garrett Snook: American Idiot almost sounds like it's made to be an opening number.
[40:30] Garrett Snook: Everything isn't meant to be okay.
[40:57] Jesse McAnally: As an idea, that alone sells this pitch to me of this being a show. I mean, it kind of is. It's the opening of a concept album, right?
[41:07] Garrett Snook: Yep. No overture, just bam bah bam, bah bam, bam.
[41:12] Jesse McAnally: And it's great, like, it reminds me a lot, and I mean this as a rare compliment, of Rent, and like how that uses rock and punk music to kind of tell a Broadway style story, except this does it a million times better.
[41:29] Garrett Snook: Um, and it does a lot to show how misguided and dumb our leads are very early on, and it makes it without even a remotest fact. Like my favorite scene, uh, my favorite series of lines is when our lead character is like, yeah, I stole money from my mom's purse. My mom let me borrow it. I fucking hate my mom. Like that kind of series of lines where I'm like, oh, I get you, and I know that you're kind of an idiot. Awesome.
[41:57] Garrett Snook: Like, it's such clear, concise theatrical storytelling throughout this show, and I feel like I didn't highlight that enough in our first discussion. But then it kind of meanders.
[42:09] Andrew DeWolf: A little bit. I mean, again, you've got just alright, they're all in these three locations, and uh they'll be there for a while. Um, what did you think of it?
[42:17] Garrett Snook: Uh, I mean, it's obviously, but visually, do you think it lived up to what you imagined when you listened to the album, Garrett?
[42:24] Garrett Snook: Um, I don't know if I really uh what what I necessarily imagined, like listening to it, but I felt that a lot of like just like a lot of the imagery they go for, just like, you know, it's a lot of TV static and the projections. I'm like, yeah, this all feels like your patched up vest that you covered in stickers that you bought at Hot Topic and whatnot.
[42:44] Garrett Snook: Um, I did I did enjoy, like, you know, we joked about the scaffolding earlier, but again, just having just a bunch of people climbing on exposed pipes. I'm like, yeah, it's this punk. And then you flip it over, and now it's forward, and now we're doing this other thing on it. I don't know why I'm turning into a producer right now.
[43:03] Garrett Snook: Pitching me on the show. I believe it. I think I can see this show. It could make it as money in some Broadway.
[43:10] Garrett Snook: So I've always had a question about the song American Idiot. Like, are the criticisms of American culture like genuine? Like, what like what are they trying to say? Are they the American idiots? Like what what is the deal?
[43:27] Garrett Snook: I as I've come to understand it at least, um, it is the phrase American idiot is kind of just it's it's just calling out, you know, jingoism, mindless patriotism, you know, again, it's the redneck agenda.
[43:43] Garrett Snook: It's trying to proudly proclaim whatever your alt identity is in the midst of, you know, you know, you know, we'll put a boot up your ass, American.
[43:53] Andrew DeWolf: Uh who sang that song?
[43:54] Garrett Snook: I don't know. Um but but but it is also sort of self-aware, because again, the entire arc that's already kind of baked into the album and then further explored in the show, is you know, are you in your rebellion, are you standing for something meaningful, or are you just being a jackass?
[44:11] Garrett Snook: And that's something that Billy Joe has talked about in interviews when they all hit their 30s and kind of self-consciously had to change up their sound and their approach a bit, because to paraphrase I I think this might be the quote I'm maybe maybe I'm just paraphrasing, but it's it's sexy to be a bitter to be an angry young man, but not a bitter old bastard.
[44:28] Garrett Snook: It's a it's a critique that you could have of a lot of punk music, I think, where punk is often like high-minded in its political ideologies, but then you look at what punks actually do, and it's mostly just drink and yell, yeah, and like nothing else.
[44:44] Andrew DeWolf: Abusive to people and their spouses usually.
[44:47] Garrett Snook: It's um like, you know, or like as some of them as they age, like you have the guy from the Misfits complaining about, you know, ah, the trans kids these days. I'm like a lot of specifically the more pop punk style bands, a lot of them ended up being like industry plants that turned into conservatives in the end.
[45:05] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[45:06] Garrett Snook: Or the Misfits or uh what's who's the other guy's Sex Pistols, I think.
[45:11] Andrew DeWolf: Um yeah.
[45:13] Garrett Snook: Because uh, and that that's kind of the the dichotomy there that I think the show is kind of trying to I I don't think it's like digging hard into it, but that is sort of um what it's asking is like, are you are you a Joe Strummer? Are you like too politically engaged? Are you trying to be the righteous soul for something, or are you just trying to piss off the people who inconvenience you daily?
[45:31] Garrett Snook: And as soon as you like join the in group, then suddenly, like, oh no, like uh I'm I I I got mine.
[45:39] Andrew DeWolf: Well, you see a lot of in in uh political spheres, conservatives love being punks or or rebels. We're rebellious because we say stuff that gets people mad, but the stuff that gets people mad is just I'm an asshole.
[45:52] Garrett Snook: Or I'm racist, or that's kind of what like I think Billy Joe Armstrong and Green Day in and of itself has ideals, things it actually wants to say, and is self-aware enough to know how to express them in a way that both appeases people that enjoy punk music and actually says what they have to say carefully and clearly.
[47:15] Andrew DeWolf: Sometimes I wish someone out there will find me.
[47:25] Garrett Snook: Um but then you've got Boulevard of Broken Dreams. Let's move on to another song.
[47:31] Andrew DeWolf: Great I Want song in a musical theater structure way.
[47:34] Garrett Snook: Hmm.
[47:35] Andrew DeWolf: Like, I I as far as that goes, that is as perfect a structurally placement there. Like it is almost like in the if I were a rich man place of Fiddler on the Roof.
[47:45] Garrett Snook: And also it's it's a pretty um the opening three tracks, they're all pretty high energy. Also on the after the 10-minute rock suite.
[47:54] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[47:54] Garrett Snook: It's like, okay, we we had that, we had holiday, so slow down, chill, put the cool tremolo effect on the guitar. And then we uh it's a beautiful actually, like this is where the voices actually do well are the ballads. Like this and waking up when September ends. I think that these classically trained Broadway voices suit them fairly well, and it feels a little less disingenuous here.
[48:22] Garrett Snook: When um the when what's her name's Harmony comes in at the end, um this whole soundtrack has hijacked how I listen to it, like the actual album half the time. I I if I hear just the original version of Boulevard in my head, I'll still have I walk this empty street on the bull. I just I hear her harmony in my head as I'm listening to it every time.
[48:42] Garrett Snook: It does change that a bit, and I I have that with my own with my own like weird muse. Like, I I hear the versions from Across the Universe when I hear the Beatles songs, which is also love. Um, the the Sir Disole show does the same thing to me. When I listen to the Beatles.
[48:58] Andrew DeWolf: I yeah, so The Beatles is another one that's like I hear the Rockafire Explosion version.
[49:06] Garrett Snook: We are all very, very smart men who enjoy our music.
[49:10] Andrew DeWolf: I like Showbiz Pizza. I like when the gorilla played the drums.
[49:15] Garrett Snook: Oh, it was a dog, but yeah.
[49:19] Andrew DeWolf: The fact that you um actually that shit pisses me off.
[49:22] Garrett Snook: The gorilla plays piano.
[49:24] Andrew DeWolf: Oh.
[49:25] Garrett Snook: Shit.
[49:27] Andrew DeWolf: And you called yourself a music enthusiast here.
[49:33] Garrett Snook: You called yourself an enjoyer of a thing. Name one song by the Rockafire Explosion.
[49:41] Andrew DeWolf: Hips, don't lie.
[49:46] Garrett Snook: Oh Garrett, you found the one kind of hyperfixation, Andrew won't let go. The Rockafire Explosion. Animatronic bears.
[49:55] Andrew DeWolf: It's they're very fascinating. I I wanted a whole thing. We did it, we did like a short episode on it. Apparently, the guy that invented email also made the Rockafire Explosion.
[50:04] Garrett Snook: The guy who claims he invented email.
[50:07] Andrew DeWolf: Let's be let's be fair here. Everyone knows email was invented by Hatsune Miku and Thomas Dolby.
[50:14] Garrett Snook: It was the guy who invented whack-a-mole though.
[50:17] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, I can see that.
[50:20] Garrett Snook: Saint Jimmy!
[50:28] Andrew DeWolf: My name is Jimmy and I am in a rare house.
[50:54] Garrett Snook: How do we feel about Saint Jimmy as a representation that character like it it it as soon as he comes on stage? I I kind of picked up on the twist that they were going for with him and what they were kind of going. Um but how do we feel about that representation on the stage as a physical being?
[51:12] Garrett Snook: Um kind of have to, I think. Um I it it I I would argue I I'm not sure if it's even intended as a twist because you know he and Johnny sing it's Saint Jimmy and that's my name together. Um I don't know, Broadway does weird things like that sometimes. I mean because I also like from the original album, I I've I've never like really registered it as a twist there either, necessarily.
[51:33] Garrett Snook: It took me a while before I understood, like, wait, so so this guy killed himself now and he's like unalive. Sorry. What I'm going off on the wrong tangent. Um, I do still really appreciate how, again, to differentiate this one voice from the three other male leads, they go like, okay, well, let's get a really squealy Axl Rose type in here.
[51:54] Garrett Snook: And I think that's they kind of turn him into the the Joker almost. Like some of the choking baby. He's the he's the drug pushing joker with some of his on stage antics, which are also kind of perfect if you want to like this guy's supposed to represent the uh I just want to piss people off and get high thing. Like, okay, the Joker. It's just it's not it's not righteous rebellion at that point, it's just nihilism.
[52:17] Andrew DeWolf: Hear that, Matt Reeves? How the Joker smoke a blunt in the Batman 2.
[52:24] Garrett Snook: That's the only way it'll be a success. And fuck Barry Kyogan. Get get Billy Joe Armstrong to play the Joker, because why not? What is so serious? Batman that's my Billy Joe, apparently.
[52:34] Andrew DeWolf: Gosh. I mean, it sounds like him when he's like, I'm not fucking Justin Bieber.
[52:41] Garrett Snook: That's what I'm riffing on. Um what about you, Garrett? What other songs and moments you want to talk about in this show?
[52:49] Garrett Snook: Um I remember 21st Century Breakdown when it came out. I did not like that album very much. Felt it was too long, and there were a lot of little melody moments in that album that I thought, wait, you used this already. But then as soon as Know Your Enemy comes up in the show, they cut back, like where it would go, the insurgency will rise. They cut back to Wail Back Home, and there's nothing wrong with me. I'm like, oh! Somebody noticed!
[53:22] Garrett Snook: They also thought that those were extremely similar, and they worked it into the thing. They did it on purpose. They did it for the Broadway show.
[53:30] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[53:33] Garrett Snook: But the C, you know what they should have done? Um, they should have had um them watching Full House, and then they can say everywhere. And connected it all together.
[54:16] Andrew DeWolf: But yeah, some of the um in terms of just like, you know, I talked about this earlier. I jumped the gun a bit, apologies. But um in terms of adding more songs to the show, some of the picks I don't necessarily agree with. I don't think you necessarily need Last Night on Earth in there. That's one I always skip when I boot up 21st Century Breakdown.
[54:36] Garrett Snook: It's weird having 21 Guns on there with Boulevard of Broken Dreams, because when that album came out, 21 Guns was criticized for sounding too much like Boulevard of Broken Dreams. And uh And unlike Boulevard, they don't arrange it in a way that everybody is kind of able to be in their range appropriately. So you have this song suddenly having five different key changes, it feels like okay.
[55:00] Andrew DeWolf: I didn't even notice that.
[55:02] Garrett Snook: Oh yeah, because um they're putting it in places that like the the the female leads can sing. Um so what's her name starts off singing it, and she's in a different key from where the song was originally written. Full band kicks in, suddenly they're in the original key again, and they handle the transitions very nicely, but it's also it makes it feel a little bit like okay, and now we're transposing again.
[55:26] Andrew DeWolf: One 21 guns, lay down your arms, give up the fun one 21 guns, throw up your arms into the sky.
[55:48] Garrett Snook: You and I when you're at the end of the road.
[56:01] Andrew DeWolf: Okay, now I'm pulling it up. You're you're a hundred percent right. It does sound weird to have females singing it in that. I guess I was just too like blinded by Full House in the moment to like pay attention.
[56:14] Garrett Snook: And again, like your first exposure was the kids bop version of Wake Me Up When September in, so these weren't baked into your brain when you saw the show.
[56:21] Andrew DeWolf: And my second exposure? The Simpsons movie.
[56:36] Garrett Snook: That'll do it.
[56:37] Andrew DeWolf: Oh shit, they were in there too. They did they played the theme song, right?
[56:41] Garrett Snook: That's one of the first songs I put on my iPod.
[56:47] Andrew DeWolf: They got paid.
[56:49] Garrett Snook: That is like probably the thing that dates that movie the most, sadly. Like, oh, that's so 2007.
[56:55] Andrew DeWolf: Well, it's just it's a period piece now.
[56:57] Garrett Snook: Yeah.
[56:59] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah. I mean, it's as much as any other episode of The Simpsons, because now, like, Homer's a millennial.
[57:05] Garrett Snook: But um It's actually true. Like, they've aged them up so much.
[57:09] Andrew DeWolf: One other um show exclusive arrangement I actually really like. It's how they handle she's a rebel, because again, somebody in production agreed with me that Last of the American Girls of 21st Century Breakdown is just she's a rebel again. So they turn it into a lead-in to She's a Rebel, and then they add in that kick-ass key change at the end, and St. Jimmy comes in and starts reprising the St. Jimmy song and the in the background of it. I just thought, in terms of making a pretty straightforward power pop song more theatrically minded, I'm like, oh shit, you can do that.
[57:42] Garrett Snook: I I mean something I I Oh, go ahead.
[57:46] Andrew DeWolf: I just something I liked about a lot of the arrangements is that they would just go from one song to the next song like boom boom without even a break or anything, which uh was it was really nice. And it makes for a more smooth listening experience, as like that's part of the reason why I think Jesus Christ Superstar works for me. They don't it is the album on stage. Like this even has like one or two lines, and but they don't tend to they don't have like proper book scenes the way the musicals do and would frustrate me if I was an audience member here.
[58:19] Andrew DeWolf: I was disappointed that you know at no point did what's her name stop and ask Johnny, well, what Pokemon are you planning to take into battle?
[58:28] Garrett Snook: Because we need three lines of dialogue to lead into this next number all about Pikachu.
[58:33] Andrew DeWolf: What kind of Pokemon are you?
[58:36] Andrew DeWolf: Well, that leads me to my next question, Garrett.
[58:39] Andrew DeWolf: Um, if you had to assign me, Andrew, and yourself, um, a Green Day song that we're most like uh this could be.
[58:48] Andrew DeWolf: One that would play as our wrestling theme if we walked in.
[58:51] Andrew DeWolf: Let's just make that a little easier.
[58:53] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, uh Andrew, you're definitely Saint Jimmy, because like, you know, you'd come out to, and that's my name, and don't you fucking wear it out.
[59:02] Garrett Snook: Beautiful.
[59:02] Garrett Snook: I can see that.
[59:03] Garrett Snook: You've also got like, you know, because like you you've got the the really long hair at this at right now, so you've got like all the attitude that comes with it.
[59:10] Garrett Snook: You know, my my favorite Green Day song is is Basket Case, obviously.
[59:14] Andrew DeWolf: That one's great.
[59:15] Andrew DeWolf: And I I it doesn't it doesn't work for me though, like as a theme song.
[59:18] Andrew DeWolf: I I feel well, because anybody claiming that Basket Case is their theme song is 14 on MySpace.
[59:24] Garrett Snook: Yeah.
[59:25] Garrett Snook: You see, kids, MySpace was this thing.
[59:28] Garrett Snook: Um it's like Facebook if it didn't suck.
[59:32] Garrett Snook: And no matter what, you have one friend, his name's Tom, he sold it for a lot of money, and now he's probably just being a nice guy.
[59:38] Garrett Snook: Just looking over his shoulder at everybody.
[59:42] Andrew DeWolf: Let's see.
[59:43] Andrew DeWolf: Jess, I'm going, I'm going over the whole the whole ass catalog because like there's just so um gosh dang it.
[59:49] Andrew DeWolf: Um are you I don't I don't know if you're early stage Green Day.
[59:52] Andrew DeWolf: I don't you said off warning, gosh dang.
[59:55] Andrew DeWolf: What's the one from the album you didn't like?
[59:57] Andrew DeWolf: Like one of the Uno Dose traits.
[59:59] Andrew DeWolf: Um that is 36 songs for me to parse through.
[1:00:05] Andrew DeWolf: Um gosh dang it.
[1:00:07] Andrew DeWolf: What's the worst Green Day song?
[1:00:09] Garrett Snook: Uh fuck time.
[1:00:11] Garrett Snook: It's full time.
[1:00:16] Garrett Snook: Oh baby, baby, it's full of time.
[1:00:20] Garrett Snook: I'm fucked time.
[1:00:22] Garrett Snook: That was off.
[1:00:23] Garrett Snook: That was off that was off of dose.
[1:00:26] Garrett Snook: Jess Mac and I Zero.
[1:00:30] Andrew DeWolf: Hey, hey, hey, hey!
[1:00:33] Garrett Snook: Don't you quantal lasagna cat at me because I won't notice.
[1:00:39] Garrett Snook: I don't you put that devil on me.
[1:00:41] Garrett Snook: I'm not gonna live that John Barker carbuckle to baby.
[1:00:48] Garrett Snook: It's just because I I and I know that we are all like multifaceted individuals, but Jess, like, you know, part of my core conception of you is being a you you've got a little bit of cinnamon bun in you, so you might be actually you might be early Green Day.
[1:01:00] Garrett Snook: You're like going to Pasal Aqua.
[1:01:02] Garrett Snook: Billy Billy wrote all these really sappy love songs in their early days, but they had a little bit of an edge to them.
[1:01:07] Garrett Snook: So I think you're going to uh you are the song going to Passalaca, I would say.
[1:01:36] Andrew DeWolf: Garrett, what about yourself?
[1:01:38] Garrett Snook: Oh god, I'm all of them and none of them.
[1:01:40] Garrett Snook: Um shoot.
[1:01:42] Garrett Snook: Uh I the one I wanna say is really like depressing, but in an empowering way.
[1:01:47] Garrett Snook: It's called Still Breathing.
[1:01:50] Garrett Snook: But you're still breathing.
[1:01:52] Andrew DeWolf: I mean that is accurate.
[1:01:53] Garrett Snook: Yeah, uh that is true.
[1:01:54] Garrett Snook: No, that that's the one he wrote that's basically reflecting on yeah, I was having a bad time in 2013, hence iHeart Radio, but I'm still here.
[1:02:29] Andrew DeWolf: Um that note, what is our overall thoughts on American Idiot the musical and our cheese ratings?
[1:02:36] Andrew DeWolf: Um, Andrew, why don't you go first?
[1:02:39] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[1:02:39] Andrew DeWolf: Um this show is uh it's what you think it is.
[1:02:46] Andrew DeWolf: I mean, I feel like when you hear American Idiot and it's a Broadway show, you imagine that it's a uh it's a bunch of Broadway people doing Green Day songs, and that's what it is.
[1:03:00] Andrew DeWolf: Uh I feel like the narrative to me felt like a bit of a mess.
[1:03:04] Andrew DeWolf: Like it was difficult for me to follow.
[1:03:06] Andrew DeWolf: I think there was maybe too many characters for me.
[1:03:09] Andrew DeWolf: I I think that should have maybe stuck with the one protagonist instead of three.
[1:03:13] Andrew DeWolf: I I feel like that was uh a bit much.
[1:03:16] Andrew DeWolf: We didn't need it.
[1:03:17] Andrew DeWolf: But I mean, realistically, I think that they did a good job with the material and did what they set out to do, which is make American Idiot the musical.
[1:03:27] Andrew DeWolf: And uh I can't really fault them for that.
[1:03:29] Andrew DeWolf: I'm not a huge Green Day fan, so it's really not for me, and I'm not gonna be super judged.
[1:03:34] Garrett Snook: You did think they were from Canada before we started this.
[1:03:37] Andrew DeWolf: I'm pretty sure they are.
[1:03:38] Andrew DeWolf: I'm I'm still pretty sure about that.
[1:03:41] Andrew DeWolf: Isn't it like Toronto?
[1:03:45] Andrew DeWolf: Um I'm stalling as I'm trying to think of a good cheese.
[1:03:48] Garrett Snook: I know, I'm trying to riff with you, and you're not helping.
[1:03:51] Andrew DeWolf: Um I got mine locked, I got mine locked and loaded, so you better not steal it.
[1:03:55] Garrett Snook: Yeah, Andrew.
[1:03:56] Garrett Snook: If it's American cheese, I mean I feel like that's too obvious, but like, is it too obvious though?
[1:04:03] Garrett Snook: Like the real American idiot over here.
[1:04:06] Garrett Snook: It's it's punk music though.
[1:04:07] Garrett Snook: I mean, I feel like pounding you in the face with the message is kind of the point.
[1:04:11] Garrett Snook: So maybe we just go with American cheese.
[1:04:13] Garrett Snook: I mean, fuck it.
[1:04:14] Garrett Snook: It's a musical that melts without splitting.
[1:04:16] Andrew DeWolf: Hey, eh, eh.
[1:04:18] Andrew DeWolf: Look at that.
[1:04:19] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, Garrett.
[1:04:21] Andrew DeWolf: You're up.
[1:04:22] Garrett Snook: Um, similar to Andrew, you hear American Idiot as a musical, you kind of know what you're gonna get.
[1:04:27] Garrett Snook: I appreciate a lot of very cra they got more creative with a lot of arrangements than they had to.
[1:04:32] Garrett Snook: Um I don't think every you know, soundtrack choice is a hit, but there's more hits than misses.
[1:04:38] Garrett Snook: And even if it's, you know, uncanny as hell, I don't even necessarily mind the weird diction half the time.
[1:04:45] Garrett Snook: But this this was, though, a lot more intense than a lot of the people I saw the show with in the same theater.
[1:04:52] Garrett Snook: So I'm gonna give this extra sharp cheddar, cause, because you know, you know what to expect from cheddar cheese, but not everybody can handle it when it's extra sharp.
[1:05:02] Garrett Snook: I always get extra sharp.
[1:05:05] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I guess it's mine turn.
[1:05:07] Andrew DeWolf: Um I like this.
[1:05:09] Andrew DeWolf: I had a good time, but Green Day is some I appreciate Billy O Joe Armstrong as a human being, as a figure, as an activist, as someone that speaks his mind.
[1:05:20] Andrew DeWolf: His music outside of like the the hits that played on Kids Bop.
[1:05:25] Andrew DeWolf: Um I really didn't find don't find that that much attraction to me, but also I'm not a big fan of any pop music or any kind of populist music.
[1:05:35] Andrew DeWolf: I'm a theater guy, I don't have good taste.
[1:05:37] Andrew DeWolf: You should know this by now.
[1:05:38] Andrew DeWolf: It's been 300 episodes.
[1:05:39] Garrett Snook: Um you haven't heard their cover of Street Where You Live.
[1:05:43] Andrew DeWolf: I have often walked down the street before.
[1:05:48] Garrett Snook: Fuck you, Higgins.
[1:05:51] Andrew DeWolf: Just you wait, Henry Higgins, just you wait, dude.
[1:05:55] Garrett Snook: Sorry, but it's gonna be too late.
[1:05:59] Andrew DeWolf: That that would actually fuck now.
[1:06:00] Andrew DeWolf: That I'm actually imagining that.
[1:06:02] Andrew DeWolf: You kinda have an idea there, actually.
[1:06:03] Andrew DeWolf: I'm gonna I'm gonna grab a g give me a couple hours, and I'll get back to you.
[1:06:07] Garrett Snook: Oh, I'm I I wait okay.
[1:06:10] Andrew DeWolf: I I wish I could commission this.
[1:06:12] Andrew DeWolf: Well little bit of luck would actually you could just turn a little bit of luck into St. Jimmy and like I think that would work pretty well, actually.
[1:06:23] Garrett Snook: I did it with Shoeless Joe from Hannibal Moe.
[1:06:25] Garrett Snook: I can do it with a little bit of luck.
[1:06:27] Andrew DeWolf: Oh I'm skipping to my cheese rating.
[1:06:32] Andrew DeWolf: I am giving this bit classic Billy Joe's cheeseburger from Billy Joe's Cheeseburger Emporium at WIBWorks.
[1:06:40] Garrett Snook: Is this a place?
[1:06:41] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah.
[1:06:41] Andrew DeWolf: This is a real, I guess.
[1:06:43] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, it's a real place.
[1:06:44] Andrew DeWolf: Um in Newburgh, New York.
[1:06:46] Garrett Snook: Is this the home?
[1:06:46] Garrett Snook: It sounds like a redneck agenda.
[1:06:48] Andrew DeWolf: I'm sorry.
[1:06:49] Andrew DeWolf: More like the MAGA agenda.
[1:06:51] Garrett Snook: My red jacket.
[1:06:53] Andrew DeWolf: Did I trigger you?
[1:06:55] Garrett Snook: Repubs.
[1:06:58] Garrett Snook: Got him.
[1:06:59] Andrew DeWolf: Um speaking of repubs, Garrett.
[1:07:02] Andrew DeWolf: Thank you for joining us today.
[1:07:04] Andrew DeWolf: Um speaking of repubs.
[1:07:06] Andrew DeWolf: That was fucking that was a mean transition.
[1:07:08] Andrew DeWolf: What the fuck, dude?
[1:07:10] Andrew DeWolf: Repubsly thinking he's a good guy.
[1:07:13] Garrett Snook: I mean, I did grow up in Orange County, so I I just missed it.
[1:07:18] Garrett Snook: They almost had me.
[1:07:20] Andrew DeWolf: You are an incredible talent, a kind person, and you deserve all great things in the world.
[1:07:25] Andrew DeWolf: Um, I've been a fan of you for a very long time, so being able to chat with you and being able to call you a friend is a true joy to me, and I I am very grateful for the opportunity to be able to chat with you.
[1:07:35] Andrew DeWolf: Please promote your wonderful content for the world to see.
[1:07:38] Garrett Snook: What the heck is this?
[1:07:39] Garrett Snook: What are you doing to me?
[1:07:40] Garrett Snook: You're being so nice.
[1:07:41] Garrett Snook: You being so nice.
[1:07:43] Garrett Snook: Fuck you!
[1:07:44] Garrett Snook: Stop being nice to me, asshole!
[1:07:46] Garrett Snook: What's this on?
[1:07:47] Garrett Snook: I'm not even just in fucking Bebig, you motherfuckers.
[1:07:52] Garrett Snook: Um, you can find me performing under the name Il Neige.
[1:07:55] Garrett Snook: It's French.
[1:07:56] Garrett Snook: I should have picked something different, but I didn't.
[1:07:58] Garrett Snook: Um on YouTube, I write parody songs.
[1:08:01] Garrett Snook: I am also songwriting my way through the Pokedex.
[1:08:04] Garrett Snook: It is slow but not so steady progress.
[1:08:07] Garrett Snook: Um my latest one was about Quaxley in the style of the DuckTales theme.
[1:08:12] Garrett Snook: Woo woo.
[1:08:13] Garrett Snook: Yeah.
[1:08:13] Garrett Snook: Uh you can also find uh my songs on uh Spotify and iTunes and Apple Music, all that nobody uses iTunes anymore, except me because I'm a Luddite.
[1:08:23] Andrew DeWolf: I do too.
[1:08:24] Garrett Snook: Yeah, yeah.
[1:08:25] Garrett Snook: Stand strong, brother.
[1:08:28] Garrett Snook: And is that it?
[1:08:29] Garrett Snook: I think that's it.
[1:08:30] Garrett Snook: I'm also on uh Instagram and TikTok under uh Ilnez Y T for YouTube, not for white.
[1:08:36] Garrett Snook: Uh I L N E I G E.
[1:08:39] Andrew DeWolf: But you are also white.
[1:08:41] Garrett Snook: I am extremely white.
[1:08:43] Garrett Snook: Case you were thinking he was an Eskimo.
[1:08:44] Garrett Snook: No, the patrons can see uh what my ring light is doing to my complexion right now.
[1:08:51] Andrew DeWolf: Um I know you're probably gonna cringe and be like, don't do this.
[1:08:57] Andrew DeWolf: I really love your Pokemon reviews, your Pokemon reviews.
[1:09:00] Garrett Snook: I know they're probably a thousand years old at this point.
[1:09:03] Andrew DeWolf: Um that's fun.
[1:09:04] Garrett Snook: Thank you.
[1:09:04] Garrett Snook: I appreciate that.
[1:09:05] Garrett Snook: I I think they're great, and I try to recommend some lesser known ones.
[1:09:09] Andrew DeWolf: And I know this will definitely make you cringe that those ones didn't.
[1:09:12] Andrew DeWolf: Your what we had to watch uh series from a thousand years ago.
[1:09:16] Andrew DeWolf: Your Yu-Gi-Oh! the movie one specifically triggers a very specific feeling of nostalgia.
[1:09:23] Andrew DeWolf: Cause I I was not a Yu-Gi-Oh! person, my brother was, which meant he forced me and my mother to go see the Yu-Gi-Oh movie, and I had no fucking eye.
[1:09:31] Andrew DeWolf: I was like, they're just flipping fucking cards.
[1:09:33] Andrew DeWolf: What?
[1:09:34] Andrew DeWolf: $10.
[1:09:36] Garrett Snook: I'm well that one that that that's not one that's tinged with regret for me, so I'm glad you like that one.
[1:09:41] Andrew DeWolf: Yeah, that that one's great because it's just like, oh yeah, that that is a very specific childhood memory.
[1:09:47] Andrew DeWolf: He had to go see that movie because he needed that fucking stupid card.
[1:09:51] Andrew DeWolf: Thank you guys for listening.
[1:09:52] Andrew DeWolf: Please follow us on iTunes and Spotify, musicals with cheese.
[1:09:55] Andrew DeWolf: We're on Twitter at Cheesy Musicals, Patreon Musical Cheese, Instagram Musicals Cheese, YouTube page musicals and cheese, Patreon only podcast, Patreon with Cheese, where you can hear that camp rock 2 commentary.
[1:10:03] Andrew DeWolf: Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com to tell us how we're wrong about Billy Joel Armstrong and Billy Joel.
[1:10:09] Garrett Snook: Fuck it.
[1:10:10] Garrett Snook: Fuck him too.
[1:10:11] Andrew DeWolf: Our keeper of the cheese is Juliet Antonio.
[1:10:14] Andrew DeWolf: Now, Garrett.
[1:10:15] Andrew DeWolf: Juliet does a little bit in the ASMR community, so every time we have a guest, I try to have them do a little bit of ASMR for our friend Juliet.
[1:10:23] Andrew DeWolf: Would you mind lending us some?
[1:10:26] Garrett Snook: One minute.
[1:10:27] Garrett Snook: You're gonna tell me I have one fucking minute.
[1:10:30] Garrett Snook: Let me tell you something.
[1:10:31] Garrett Snook: Let me fucking tell you something.
[1:10:34] Garrett Snook: I've been around since 19 fucking eighty-eight.
[1:10:37] Garrett Snook: And you're gonna tell me I have one minute.
[1:10:40] Garrett Snook: I'm not just in fucking paper, you motherfuckers.
[1:10:42] Andrew DeWolf: Bravo.
[1:10:44] Andrew DeWolf: Bravo.
[1:10:45] Andrew DeWolf: I used to keep my stuff PG.
[1:10:48] Garrett Snook: Nah, fuck that.
[1:10:50] Andrew DeWolf: Um this show is edited by Andrew DeWolf.
[1:10:54] Andrew DeWolf: Our theme songs were created by Robin Nash Value Music UK.
[1:10:57] Andrew DeWolf: Thank you to the Brotherbite Podcast Network for having us on the platform and for not kicking us off for you know putting a big old middle finger to to the worst president, President Bush.
[1:11:05] Garrett Snook: Um, it'll never get worse.
[1:11:07] Garrett Snook: Hot take.
[1:11:08] Andrew DeWolf: That's true.
[1:11:09] Andrew DeWolf: So uh damn HW, the worst president.
[1:11:16] Garrett Snook: Lyndon be sucking.
[1:11:17] Garrett Snook: Am I right?
[1:11:22] Andrew DeWolf: Um, hey, hey, LBJ, how many kids did you kill today?
[1:11:25] Garrett Snook: Uh, I'm edgy.
[1:11:29] Garrett Snook: Damn, those are the things.
[1:11:30] Andrew DeWolf: Hoover, I hardly know her.
[1:11:32] Garrett Snook: William G. Harding, more like William Jean Softing.
[1:11:40] Andrew DeWolf: I had five ideas of where you were going with that.
[1:11:42] Andrew DeWolf: You did none of them.
[1:11:43] Garrett Snook: It's a way to keep me on my toes.
[1:11:46] Garrett Snook: Cause you're soft on the middle classes, am I right?
[1:11:52] Andrew DeWolf: Well, you're Henry Harrison, what's with all the H's?
[1:11:57] Garrett Snook: Hey Garfield, way to get shot on a Monday.
[1:12:02] Andrew DeWolf: Alright, we'll see you next time.
[1:12:06] Andrew DeWolf: You know what?
[1:12:07] Andrew DeWolf: I think people should learn things when they listen to a podcast.
[1:12:09] Andrew DeWolf: Sure, they could listen to Pod Save American, but they chose this, so I'm giving them whatever fun facts I've got.
[1:12:15] Andrew DeWolf: Give them the knowledge, you know.
[1:12:17] Andrew DeWolf: Knowledge.
[1:12:30] Garrett Snook: One twenty one guns everywhere you look, everywhere there's a heart somebody who needs you.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
