This week we talk about the group of individuals who thought that all their problems would be solved through shooting the President of the United States. In this conversation about Musical Theater we discuss why Garfield hates Mondays, James Barbour's sad continued existence on Broadway, and of course Stephen Sondheim... Read More
From the show: Musicals with Cheese
Featured Shows
About
This week we talk about the group of individuals who thought that all their problems would be solved through shooting the President of the United States. In this conversation about Musical Theater we discuss why Garfield hates Mondays, James Barbour's sad continued existence on Broadway, and of course Stephen Sondheim.
Links:
Social Media:
Musicals with Cheese on Twitter
Musicals Theatre Lives on Instagram
Email us at musicaltheatrelives@gmail.com
Transcript
This transcript was automatically generated and might contain errors.
[0:03] Jess: Hello and welcome to Musicals with Cheese.
[0:06] Andrew: It is I, Jess, joined as always by Andrew.
[0:09] Jess: That's me. And the premise of this show is that someone who knows musical theater pretty well, myself, um, and someone that doesn't know it as well, tackle a musical every now and then and talk about their different points of view on it.
[0:24] Andrew: Yes.
[0:26] Jess: And what is this month, week, whatever's musical, Andrew?
[0:30] Andrew: Oh, we're talking about Assassins.
[0:36] Jess: Get it? I made a joke.
[0:36] Andrew: Haha, it's pretty nuts.
[0:39] Jess: It's not funny. Just cut that.
[0:41] Andrew: Everybody's got the right to thumbs on the shine.
[0:46] Jess: Everybody got the sun but baby one of its me.
[1:00] Andrew: Everybody just got the right.
[1:42] Jess: The music varies to reflect the popular music of the eras depicted. The musical opened in off Broadway in 1990 and on Broadway in 2004, where it won five Tony Awards.
[1:54] Andrew: Just as literally reads these.
[2:04] Jess: Now, this is actually the first time we're doing a thing where I hadn't properly watched the musical beforehand. Um, I'd listened to the songs, but I'd never like sat down to fully bring in all of Assassins. So this is a first-time experience for me as well. Um, I thought it was good. Um, it has moments of being sometimes best, but it overall it feels it feels like a complete piece, but also kind of feels like one of his weaker ones.
[2:34] Andrew: I liked it a lot. First question for you is was it better than Rent?
[2:40] Jess: Do we really even need to ask this?
[2:42] Andrew: Come on.
[2:43] Jess: Yes, it was better than Rent.
[2:46] Andrew: What?
[2:47] Jess: Yeah, it was better than Rent.
[2:49] Andrew: It was better than the best musical of all time.
[2:51] Jess: I'm s I'm sorry. Um, yes, it is very much better than Rent. Let's never talk about Rent again, you guys.
[3:00] Andrew: So, um, w how would you describe Assassins, Andrew?
[3:06] Andrew: The bit of a like a dark comedy kind of uh clip show almost.
[3:12] Jess: Yeah, they they don't make any attempt to have it organized in any real way. But that doesn't mean it feels disjointed, so to say. Like it works in favor of the s the tr the mood they're trying to give.
[3:27] Andrew: Well, I think the fact that it is disjointed is the tone they were trying to set. Because it's har you don't want the truth because that's not a very engaging or fun evening at a show. You want to have the fun moments so you can see these people as humans as opposed to just mustache twirlers who want to kill people.
[3:48] Jess: Um, one of the most interesting things that both Stephen Sondheim and um John Weidman bring up um is that these would every nation has its would-be assassins, but these people do disturbing and horrible things, not because they want to influence national politics, but they feel they're wrapped in a malignant sense of entitlement. They feel like they were owed an American dream and they get angry at America but when they don't get their in their dream.
[4:20] Andrew: Um where's my prize it's it's true. Uh there none of them really at least as far as uh what is described in the musical none of them were really out for political change. They were just kind of looking for attention for themselves.
[4:40] Jess: I'd say the only one that John Wilkes Booth is probably the only one that just gonna say John Wilkes Booth uh his whole song is him arguing that he was out for political change.
[4:52] Andrew: I mean he kinda started that way, but then he moved into the more seedy reasons well, that was still political change though. It just wasn't politics that anyone nowadays agrees with really but let's not dive in too deep.
[5:07] Jess: Let's find some structure to this and just probably go character by character, because this is a character piece and let's just describe each character and the songs and elements that go around them in the non-chronological way that this show goes in.
[5:23] Andrew: Alright, so the show starts with a proprietor. Um he's a gun salesman who pretty much gives the weapons to everyone in the show. He's the one that gives people the guns.
[5:33] Jess: And he starts with the everyone has the right song that is the opening and closing numbers that sets up basically the thesis statement of every character in the show.
[5:45] Andrew: I like this character.
[5:53] Jess: It's like who is this supposed to represent is really what I was trying to figure out. And I never I never really figured it out. Maybe he's like representation of insanity or just like the gun itself, maybe.
[6:08] Andrew: Maybe, or maybe he just doesn't represent anything, and he's just a fun concept. Um, but moving on to the balladier who represents the every American, the general America's point of view and how they will eventually view these people.
[6:23] Jess: He's a voice of the audience.
[6:26] Andrew: Almost.
[6:27] Jess: He's the eyes of the audience and the reaction of the audience. Until eventually there's a twist at the end where you realize any audience member can become one of these assassins.
[6:39] Andrew: Um I think it's a great concept that could have been executed well if they had originally intended it, but since they just kind of shoehorned it in later down the line, it feels forced.
[6:49] Jess: Yeah, very much so.
[6:51] Andrew: They picked the wrong assassin to do the twist with, to be honest.
[6:55] Jess: Who would you have picked?
[6:57] Andrew: Uh, definitely not Oswald.
[7:01] Jess: I don't know. I I think that's the good part.
[7:03] Andrew: Um, he's the kind of most iconic assassin. Like, um, if you think assassination of a president, the first thing in your head is Lee Harvey Oswald.
[7:12] Jess: Um, some might think Booth, but like the most ubiquitous face and name is Lee Harvey Oswald, especially because we know so very little about him.
[7:23] Andrew: Yeah, I guess.
[7:25] Jess: Alright, and then moving on to John Wilkes Booth, the assassin of Abraham Lincoln.
[7:31] Andrew: Um, he has the first real big number, um, the ballad of Booth, where he describes the political and um possibly racially charged reasons why he committed his act.
[7:44] Jess: Uh because uh he didn't get good reviews or something like that.
[7:49] Andrew: That was like the whole thing.
[7:52] Jess: And his brother made him jealous.
[7:55] Andrew: Yeah, I mean, who wouldn't be jealous of that guy, though? Time to kill the president.
[8:02] Jess: Booth is such an important character in this too. Because he's like the the head assassin, kind of.
[8:09] Andrew: I at least that's how they that's how they that's how they portray him.
[8:13] Jess: He's like the HR manager.
[8:15] Andrew: Obviously.
[8:17] Jess: Charles Guiteau.
[8:20] Andrew: He was the assassin of President James Garfield, who loved him some Liz.
[8:27] Jess: This is my favorite.
[8:28] Andrew: But he hated Mondays, I believe.
[8:30] Jess: This is the the Lordy guy, isn't it?
[8:34] Andrew: Yes. Do you want to explain his entire backstory?
[8:37] Jess: He wants his history. Like he wanted the pos a an ambassador position as a ambassador to France.
[8:44] Andrew: And the Garfield was like, not this Monday.
[8:49] Jess: And so he shot him.
[8:54] Andrew: He shot him and he he died.
[8:57] Jess: And then he went to the Lordy.
[9:01] Andrew: Maybe that's why Garfield didn't like Mondays.
[9:03] Jess: Oh boy, let's see what I'm saying. Was James Garfield murdered on a Monday?
[9:08] Andrew: Oh boy. This this episode's gonna require a lot of uh research.
[9:13] Jess: September 19, 1881.
[9:16] Andrew: Like I know what day that is.
[9:19] Jess: The day of the week was Monday!
[9:25] Andrew: Fucking yes.
[9:28] Jess: We finally figured out why Garfield hates Mondays.
[9:31] Andrew: We did it.
[9:32] Jess: We solved the mystery.
[9:34] Andrew: Let's stay on Guiteau for a second.
[9:36] Jess: Um let's talk about fun.
[9:39] Andrew: Sorry, I didn't want to move on, but uh I wanna talk about how his song is the one time Stephen Sondheim has ever used lyrics that weren't his own.
[9:49] Jess: Oh, okay. You wanna talk about that?
[9:51] Andrew: Yes, um this song has my favorite lyrics because of that.
[9:56] Jess: Um the Lordy song.
[10:00] Andrew: The Lordy poem. Here, let's do a little bit more research.
[10:04] Jess: I am going to the Lordy, I am so glad.
[10:07] Andrew: I'm going to the Lordy, I am so glad.
[10:11] Jess: I am going to the Lordy.
[10:13] Andrew: Glory hallelujah, glory, hallelujah.
[10:17] Jess: This is the most horribly cringy and funny thing ever.
[10:24] Andrew: Almost sounds like it's from Rent.
[10:27] Jess: Almost.
[10:27] Andrew: Except it I mean, except for he's dead now.
[10:30] Jess: Well, actually, you know what?
[10:32] Andrew: Hmm.
[10:39] Jess: Okay, so this guy wrote this horrible poem, and he performed it at his execution.
[10:46] Andrew: And he wanted to have a an orchestra behind it.
[10:50] Jess: And the the whole poem is just horrible in in every way.
[10:56] Andrew: And it's hilarious.
[10:57] Jess: And then they put the lyrics, they use those lyrics in the in the song.
[11:05] Andrew: Basically, yeah. Um, it is the most upbeat um execution scene since um The Green Mile. Moving on to uh Leon Schulgosh. Um, he was the steel worker that assassinated William McKinley. He's the most boring character in the musical. He's the one that likes gun doesn't like guns. Does like guns. He he makes guns and he's the one that's like it takes many men to make a gun. That song's hundreds. I like the the idea of that song. Um, I think that's sometimes prettiest song, really. It is really nice to listen to. I kinda like his character a little bit. I mean, he's boring, but I feel like he's supposed to he should have been the everyman guy. Whatever. Moving on to Giuseppe Zengara, um, a man who attempted to assassinate um Franklin D. Roosevelt.
Um, he had a bad stomach ache, so he thought killing the president would fix it. It did. He no longer has that stomach ache. Yes, but the most interesting thing about his story segment was the people's reaction and how they tried to steal the fame by claiming they saved Roosevelt. Also another very funny song. Agreed, and it rings very true to this day. I mean, in any tragic situation, you do get those people that are like trying to grab a bit of it, like I was there, I was involved, the TMZ generation. So that's as true today as it was back in FDR's day. Alright, let's move on.
[12:41] Jess: Alright. Moving on. Um to Sam Bick, who attempted to assassinate Richard Nixon by driving a plane into the White House. Which, by the way, uh is a very good plan. I mean, it worked in other occasions. Okay. He dressed up as Santa Claus. He dressed up as Santa Claus and made a lot of recordings into um a little recording device and sent them off to many people. And I find it ironic because at one point he's singing Tonight from West Side Story, which Stephen Sondheim did the lyrics for. So is this the first time Santheimes has reused his own lyrics in another one of his plays? Interesting. You can't say he didn't write the lyrics, though. It's I think it's interesting that this character doesn't really have a song. He has a lot of great monologues, like that's mostly his thing.
[13:43] Andrew: Yeah, but he can't really do a s yeah, he doesn't really sing though. Some people just don't need their own song. It's like Sarah Jane Moore. She doesn't have her own song, but she just kinda hops in into the gun song. Then we're moving on to John Hinckley, Attempted Assassination Attempt on President Ronald Reagan. And he's got one of the best songs in in the thing, Unworthy of Your Love, which is a duet with another character that we haven't talked about yet. Where he sings about how much he he is in love with um uh Jodie Foster, I think, and he uh and he wants to know how he can win her over. Ma maybe he could help her make the beaver. Maybe he could kill the president. Those are two very good options and equally as horrible.
I wonder how John Hinckley felt as soon as he found out that Jody Foster was a lesbian. I'm sure he was one of the type of guys that thought he could still win her over or or you know what I'm saying. I mean with his charming good looks. No, with the president being dead. You know John Hinckley is out of prison right now. Um hey John, if you're listening, call us up. Let us know how it felt when Jody Foster told you she'd rather munch on Salmon.
[15:04] Jess: Ooh. Or a uh beaver puppet. With Mel Gibson. Then we're moving on to Lynette Squeaky From, uh tempted assassin of President Gerald Ford, along with Sarah Jane Moore, who also attempted to assassinate Gerald Ford. Well, she also has What do you think of these two characters? They're both in good songs, but every scene that other than that is uh awful and I hated it. Okay, what I didn't like is I I didn't think these guys the the two ladies in this fit the tone at all. I actually think they broke the tone because you went from this kind of a dark comedic to basically slapstick. I specifically didn't much care for the scene with like them dealing with her kid, which is an interesting premise and could work on its own as like, oh, I brought my kid to the assassination attempt.
Yeah. Ha ha ha ha ha. It's too stupid. It's it's I think it everything with them was too stupid. Like there was other like really goofy stuff like with uh with Bick had some goofy monologues. But with that it's played more like he's actually insane. With these two, it was like, wow, they're dumb. You know, I And I don't I don't think they're dumb as much as they're indoctrinated in real life.
[16:20] Andrew: Yeah, which would have been more interesting. I would have liked to see that more. They they kinda played to that during their songs. But when they were just on sc on uh the stage talking to each other was just goofy annoyances. And not to shit on John Wideman at all, but I think that Stephen Sondheim just had a better understanding for what was more interesting about these characters than John Wideman did. Because how they did this show is Sondheim went off on his own, wrote the songs in a vacuum, John Wideman wrote the scenes in a vacuum, then they put it together. Yeah, and the songs with these characters are better than the scenes with these characters. And then we get an actually really amazing scene at the very end.
Where all the assassins come together from the past, future and all that, and try to convince John Wilkes Booth or Lee Harvey Oswald to murder JFK. The only aspect I don't like about that scene is the aspect that it's the balladier, because I just don't think that fits. I think it could fit, but it needs some toying around, but I don't that's not a deal killer for me.
[17:31] Jess: What I think is wrong with it is I don't think that anyone could be Oswald. I I think it takes a very special case to make an Oswald, and it's not just anybody could do it. You know. I I don't think any average Joe off the street could just suddenly be in Lee Harvey Oswald's shoes. So obviously the assassins are able to convince Lee Harvey Oswald to kill JFK, and after that we have a song called Something Just Broke, which only existed um in the newer productions, was not in the original production, and I think it's so imperative that this exists. And I think nowadays it's even more effective. Right. And then by the end when they're singing Everybody's Got the Right once again, um right at the audience, it's so chilling and you hate every one of them. And then the show ends. Andrew, what are your overall feelings on Assassins?
[18:52] Andrew: Um You know, it was there's some really good music and it overall it's not it's not bad, but I'm not sure I'd like recommend it too much. It it's good. It's it's um Yeah, that's fair. Um I think like if you catch it like at a community theater nearby, give it a watch, or just listen to the soundtrack or the cast recording album, forgive me. Yeah, listen to that. Uh I'm not sure it's worth seeking out in terms of watching it though. A lot of the scenes aren't nearly as good as the songs. Um sadly. Yeah, I don't mean to be a party pooper. I know a lot of people love this musical and I thought I was expecting to adore this, but just didn't hit me the way I was hoping it would. I I would much rather listen to the album than I would listen uh watch the musical again.
Just over But I do think the performances from the Broadway production are astounding from um Neil Patrick Harris, Michael Cerberus, um all them chaps uh child molester dude James Barbour's. Hey if you're listening James Barbour's, uh maybe maybe you shouldn't be on Broadway no more. Maybe we need to retire. I don't know if I want him around kids no more.
[20:16] Jess: Um alright Andrew, what is the cheese rating you would give Assassins?
[20:21] Andrew: I I can't uh Swiss because it has a lot of holes in it.
[20:28] Jess: Ah you stole my answer you fuck. I don't know. Alright so next week you guys we're gonna have a super special Halloween special and we're not gonna reveal that. But for November we are gonna reveal that for you. In November we're gonna have our next musical is gonna be a Star Kid musical. I'm not gonna tell you which one it is but it rhymes with Quisted but next time in on October 31st expect a super special surprise from us. It's not Annie.
[21:04] Andrew: It's not Annie.
[21:05] Jess: No, no. Alright, we'll see you then. Andrew, do you have anything left to say?
[21:10] Andrew: Um, it will not be next week because we're always off schedule.
[21:14] Jess: Okay.
[21:14] Andrew: We stop using the weak terminology.
[21:18] Jess: That's all I have to say.
[21:20] Andrew: This one might actually be next week, though.
[21:22] Jess: This one might be next week, but but you know what? We gotta stop saying next week because it's never gonna happen.
[21:27] Andrew: Uh bye, fellas.
[21:30] Jess: See you later.
[21:31] Andrew: Wait, wait, wait no, we gotta do a skit.
[21:33] Jess: Hey you, I'm gonna shoot you with this gun.
[21:36] Andrew: Bang.
[21:38] Jess: Sing a song now.
[21:40] Andrew: I shot you with the gun, I'm going to the Lord E.
[21:40] Jess: I'm going to the Lord E.
[21:50] Andrew: And yeah, that's it. See you guys next time.
[21:54] Jess: That was the longest outro of all time.
© Broadway Podcast Network, All Rights Reserved
